Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- ENSURING TRUST: STRENGTHENING STATE EFFORTS TO OVERHAUL THE GUARDIANSHIP PROCESS AND PROTECT OLDER AMERICANS [Senate Hearing 115-745] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 115-745 ENSURING TRUST: STRENGTHENING STATE EFFORTS TO OVERHAUL THE GUARDIANSHIP PROCESS AND PROTECT OLDER AMERICANS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ NOVEMBER 28, 2018 __________ Serial No. 115-22 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 37-591 PDF WASHINGTON : 2020 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine, Chairman ORRIN G. HATCH, Utah ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania JEFF FLAKE, Arizona BILL NELSON, Florida TIM SCOTT, South Carolina KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut BOB CORKER, Tennessee JOE DONNELLY, Indiana RICHARD BURR, North Carolina ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts MARCO RUBIO, Florida CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO, Nevada DEB FISCHER, Nebraska DOUG JONES, Alabama ---------- Kevin Kelley, Majority Staff Director Kate Mevis, Minority Staff Director CONTENTS ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman.......... 1 Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member........ 3 PANEL OF WITNESSES Cathy (Cate) G. Boyko, MPA, Senior Court Research Associate, National Center for State Courts, Williamsburg, Virginia....... 5 Bethany Hamm, Acting Commissioner, Maine Department of Health and Human Services, Augusta, Maine................................. 7 Karen C. Buck, Esq., Executive Director, SeniorLAW Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania..................................... 8 Barbara E. Buckley, Esq., Executive Director, Legal Aid Center for Southern Nevada, Las Vegas, Nevada......................... 10 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Cathy (Cate) G. Boyko, MPA, Senior Court Research Associate, National Center for State Courts, Williamsburg, Virginia....... 28 Bethany Hamm, Acting Commissioner, Maine Department of Health and Human Services, Augusta, Maine................................. 41 Karen C. Buck, Esq., Executive Director, SeniorLAW Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania..................................... 45 Barbara E. Buckley, Esq., Executive Director, Legal Aid Center for Southern Nevada, Las Vegas, Nevada......................... 50 Additional Statements for the Record Closing Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman.......... 60 Closing Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member 60 ENSURING TRUST: STRENGTHENING STATE. EFFORTS TO OVERHAUL THE GUARDIANSHIP PROCESS AND PROTECT OLDER AMERICANS ---------- WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 28, 2018 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:32 p.m., in room SD-562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Susan M. Collins (Chairman of the Committee) presiding. Present: Senators Collins, Fischer, Casey, Gillibrand, Blumenthal, Donnelly, Cortez Masto, and Jones. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SUSAN M. COLLINS, CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The Committee will come to order. Good afternoon. Earlier this month, a former state legislator in Maine was convicted of carrying out one of the worst cases of elder financial abuse in our state's history. The man, who is also a securities agent, was found guilty of stealing more than $3 million from two elderly widows. While these women viewed the man as the protector of their accounts, in reality he actually preyed on their trust and vulnerability after their husbands died. Rather than protecting them, this individual slowly drained their bank accounts over a period of 7 years, according to the court. Maine's Office of Securities found that the man used his position as a trusted financial professional and a close family friend to groom his victims in order to commit his crimes. He ingratiated himself with these families, assuming power of attorney, and becoming the trustee of their accounts. He used the funds under his control as his personal piggy bank, covering everything from travel and fine dining in the United States and Europe, to purchasing and renovating an expensive home in California's wine country. Maine plans to seek full financial restitution. The harm that this individual has caused to these women and to their families is, however, irreparable. This abuse, by a trusted advisor, is a crime that no individual or family should ever have to face. While appalling stories such as these remind us of the fraud that can be perpetuated against vulnerable individuals, there are also many stories of guardians and conservators who have protected seniors against such abuse, preserving both their dignity and their assets. When a pastor in Maine befriended an elderly woman under false pretenses at an assisted living facility earlier this year, it was her conservator who stepped in and protected her from precisely this type of exploitation. Before the pastor could steal her money and assets, the conservator notified the police and put a stop to the abuse. It is not difficult to imagine the harm that could have come without the intervention of this trusted guardian. We must do more to make success stories like this one the norm. Today our Committee is releasing a bipartisan report to help change the tide, implement reforms, and restore trust in guardianship. Titled ``Ensuring Trust: Strengthening State Efforts to Overhaul the Guardianship Process and Protect Older Americans,'' the report is the culmination of this Committee's year-long work investigating the guardianship systems. An estimated 1.3 million adults are under the care of guardians--family members or professionals--who control approximately $50 billion of their assets. Guardianship is a legal relationship created by a court that is designed to protect those with diminished or lost capacity. We have found, however, that in too many cases the system lacks basic protections, leaving the most vulnerable Americans at risk of exploitation and fraud. Throughout the course of the year, we have heard harrowing tales from families around the country who are struggling with abusive guardians. We also spoke with families who had heartening stories to share--of dedicated and faithful guardians stepping up to protect the assets of seniors with dementia and other conditions affecting their capacity. A good guardian can provide years of support for a protected individual--sometimes it is a disabled child--ensuring a full life directed, wherever possible, by the person's own choices and preferences. Once a guardianship is imposed, however, the individual's rights are removed, and oversight to protect the individual from abuse, neglect, and exploitation becomes critical. We have gathered during the past year much information, analysis, and recommendations from states, courts, and organizations representing older Americans and those with disabilities around the country. We have received more than 100 comments identifying gaps in the system and, more important, offering solutions. We have found a pattern of barriers to proper oversight, and we have identified a need for greater use of alternatives to guardianship. We have found persistent and widespread challenges that require a nationwide focus in order to ensure the guardianship system works on behalf of the individuals it is intended to protect. The Committee's report outlines policy recommendations at local, state, and federal levels that would improve outcomes for Americans subject to guardianship. Many of these recommendations are reflected in legislation that the Ranking Member, Senator Casey, and I have authored, called the ``Guardianship Accountability Act.'' This bill would promote information sharing among courts and local organizations as well as state and federal entities, encourage the use of background checks and less restrictive alternatives to guardianships, and expand the availability of federal grants targeted at improvements in the guardianship system. I would invite all of our colleagues to join us in supporting this legislation. Today we will hear from states that are making progress at better protecting those placed in guardianship arrangements. The number of Americans aged 65 and older is projected to more than double from 46 million today to more than 98 million by the year 2060; therefore, the issue of ensuring strong guardianship oversight will only become more urgent in coming years. And as Commissioner Hamm well knows, Maine is particularly affected by this demographic change as the oldest state in the Nation by median age. Protecting older Americans from financial fraud and exploitation has long been one of my top priorities as Chairman of this Committee. From our toll-free fraud hotline to new laws such as SeniorSafe that encourage financial institutions to flag suspicious activity, our efforts to combat fraud and crack down on criminals who are always seeking new ways to steal the hard-earned savings of our Nation's seniors have produced results. On guardianship, the Committee's report uncovers significant challenges that remain. In our hearing today, we will examine the practical steps that can be taken to improve a system that is intended to help safeguard those who need it most. I am now pleased to turn to our Ranking Member for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., RANKING MEMBER Senator Casey. Chairman Collins, thank you very much. Thanks for holding this hearing and for your work on these issues for many years. I am pleased that the Committee's 2018 annual report addresses this important subject matter. This report is the culmination of a year's worth of research and analysis and includes input from, as the Chairman said, over 100 stakeholders, advocates, representatives of the courts, and state officials. It is abundantly clear that something has to be done--as the title of the report suggests-- to ``ensure trust'' in our guardianship system. While most guardians act in the best interest of the individual they care for, far too often we have heard horror stories--and that is probably an understatement--of guardians who have abused, neglected, or exploited a person subject to guardianship. As our report notes, there are persistent and widespread problems with guardianship around the country. For instance, we found deficiencies in the oversight and monitoring of guardians. We have also found that courts sometimes remove more rights than necessary by failing to consider less restrictive alternatives to guardianship. And, importantly, it is universally agreed upon that there is also a lack of reliable, detailed data to inform policymakers. This is simply unacceptable. We have a sacred responsibility to ensure that no one--no one--loses a house or life savings or is needlessly deprived of their rights because a guardian abused their power. Today I look forward to hearing about steps that states have taken to reform guardianship as well as the steps that must be taken to further improve the guardianship system. As Chairman Collins mentioned, we are releasing bipartisan legislation which will help states improve guardianship oversight and data collection. We look forward to receiving feedback on the bill so we can work together next Congress to pass legislation to improve guardianship all across our country. Guardianship is supposed to be protective. Too often, it has not been protective. We must do everything in our power to make sure we get it right all the time. Again, thank you, Chairman Collins, for holding the hearing, and thanks to our witnesses for lending your time, your expertise, and your knowledge at this critical time. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Casey. We will now turn to our witnesses. First, we will hear from Cate Boyko, who is the senior court research associate at the National Center for State Courts in Williamsburg, Virginia. She testified before this Committee at its 2016 hearing on guardianship when we first started getting into this issue. In her new role at the National Center for State Courts, Ms. Boyko has become a national resource on guardianship issues and opportunity for improved court oversight. Next I am delighted that we will hear from Bethany Hamm, the Acting Commissioner for the Main Department of Health and Human Services. Commissioner Hamm has served in the department for more than 30 years. Currently the Maine Department of Health and Human Services has legal guardianship and conservatorship relationships with approximately 1,300 adults. I look forward to your testimony this morning. I now will turn to our Ranking Member to introduce our next witness from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I am pleased to introduce Karen Buck. Karen is from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, as one of our witnesses today, but more importantly for purposes of today's subject matter, Karen is the executive director of the SeniorLAW Center, which is located in Philly. It provides legal services to older Pennsylvanians. It provides as well direct representation, referral services, advice, and many other services to help ensure that seniors have access to justice. In addition to her role at SeniorLAW Center, Karen serves in many leadership positions promoting access to justice itself, including her role as a member of Pennsylvania's Supreme Court Advisory Council on Elder Justice. We thank Karen for being here today. We look forward to her testimony. Thanks. The Chairman. Thank you. Next I would like to turn to Senator Cortez Masto to introduce another witness, and I want to also recognize the work that the Senator has done on this issue and that the State of Nevada has done, because your state has been a real leader. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman Collins and Ranking Member Casey. And I so appreciate you holding this hearing on an issue that, as you well know, is very important to me, to Nevada, and to all of us. And I appreciate all of the work that you have done and this Committee has done on this report. Thank you. We are fortunate enough today to hear and have Barbara Buckley, who is not only a friend of mine but was one of the chief architects of these reforms on guardianship in the State of Nevada, and she helped create one of the most advanced systems in the entire Nation for protecting seniors from abuse. Barbara served as the Speaker of the Nevada Assembly from 2007 through 2010, becoming the first woman in the state's history to hold this position. We are a state of firsts. She is currently executive director of the Legal Aid Center of Southern Nevada, which provides free legal assistance and representation to those who cannot afford an attorney. Barbara helped create the Legal Aid Center's Guardianship Advocacy Program which provides that representation to seniors and adults with disabilities under guardianship to ensure that adults' legal rights are protected. The right to counsel is a vital part of Nevada's new guardianship system and crucial to protecting those who are the most vulnerable. So welcome, Barbara, and thank you for being here. And, again, thank you for this important hearing, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you very much. I also want to acknowledge the three other Senators who are here and may be returning: Senator Fischer, Senator Jones, and Senator Donnelly. And a special word to Senator Donnelly. He has been a terrific member of this Committee, and I just wanted to say that we will very much miss your service here. I know how deeply you care about issues affecting our older Americans, and I just wanted to personally thank you for your service on the Committee. Ms. Boyko, we are going to start with your testimony. STATEMENT OF CATHY (CATE) G. BOYKO, MPA, SENIOR COURT RESEARCH ASSOCIATE, NATIONAL CENTER FOR STATE COURTS, WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA Ms. Boyko. Chair Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of the Senate Special Committee on Aging, thank you for inviting me here to discuss the efforts to overhaul the guardianship process and protect older Americans. My name is Cate Boyko, and I am a senior court research associate at the National Center for State Courts. The National Center is a nonprofit organization with headquarters in Williamsburg, Virginia, whose mission it is to promote the rule of law and to improve the administration of justice in state courts and courts around the world. My areas of expertise include elder abuse and exploitation, and guardianship and conservatorship. Because terminology varies from state to state, we used generalized terms. Guardianship refers to those cases in which the court has appointed an individual to handle the medical and well-being issues of another person, while conservatorship refers to those cases in which an individual has been appointed by the court to manage the finances of another person. As Chair Collins stated, in the U.S. there are approximately 1.3 million active adult guardianship or conservatorship cases. Nationally courts oversee at least $50 billion of assets under adult conservatorships. My written testimony addresses issues that can dramatically improve efficiencies and oversight of guardianships and conservatorships, including improved data collection, modernization of processes and professional auditing, the use of differentiated case management strategies to prevent and address exploitation, the development of interactive online training programs to provide basic education for nonprofessional guardians and conservators, and expanding collaborative efforts such as Working Interdisciplinary Network of Guardianship Stakeholders groups, or WINGS groups. For this hearing, I will focus on the first two items: improved data collection and modernization. The National Center's Court Statistics Project annually collects state court data on a variety of case types, including adult guardianships and conservatorships. However, as noted in a number of publications, the quality of national data is highly problematic. In 2016, to determine if the quality of data had improved and to explore challenges in documenting adult conservatorship exploitation, the National Center undertook a survey of courts for guardianship and conservatorship data. Five data elements were requested: new cases filed, total active cases, total dollar value of conservatorship cases, and cases in which a conservator was removed for cause or criminally charged. Fifty-one states and territories responded, but only 39 states were able to provide some level of data. No state was able to provide data on all five elements. The three primary themes why courts could not provide data were: the authority and practices are highly localized, a lack of standards for data reporting, and outdated technology and case management systems. So why is data a concern? Many courts may not be aware of which cases are open and should be monitored and which cases are closed or no longer need their attention. There are states that have taken on reviewing each case, updating records and accompanying data. Texas, Nevada, and New Mexico are reviewing case files to determine if each case should remain open, what filings or accountings are missing and needed follow-up. Texas, Indiana, and Pennsylvania have all established statewide guardianship/conservatorship registry systems to help them track and monitor cases. Determining the open or closed status of a case, although very basic, is an essential step for court reform in guardianship and conservatorship case management and oversight. The Texas process could be adopted as a model for court case review. Courts lack resources and skills to monitor and oversee these cases. The National Center will soon launch a project that could transform the conservatorship system in courts. With funding from the Office for Victims of Crime, the National Center will work with two courts to pilot the concept where conservators would be required to sign up with a financial monitoring company that will identify suspicious transactions based on personal financial profiles created through machine learning. The company will send alerts to the court's Rapid Response team. The team will respond to each instance and resolve the issues through education, removal of exploitative conservators, repayment of assets, and referral to investigative agencies in a very quick timeframe. I thank you for this opportunity, and I welcome your questions. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Commissioner Hamm. STATEMENT OF BETHANY HAMM, ACTING COMMISSIONER, MAINE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, AUGUSTA, MAINE Ms. Hamm. Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of the Committee, I am Bethany Hamm, Acting Commissioner of the Maine Department of Health and Human Services. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My testimony provides background information on Maine's Adult Protective Services and public guardianship program. I will also outline recent changes to Maine's probate code that relate to guardianship of adults and how we anticipate the recently enacted probate code changes will serve to protect adults under guardianship and conservatorship in Maine. Maine DHHS is required by state law to carry out the mandates of the Adult Protective Services Act, or the APS Act. In accordance with the APS Act, Maine's program within DHHS' Office of Aging and Disability Services is specifically responsible for protecting incapacitated adults from abuse, neglect, and exploitation through thorough, investigative, protective, and supportive efforts. When APS determines that an incapacitated adult needs a guardian or is subject to abuse, neglect, or exploitation, we will conduct a search for a suitable private guardian. If none are available, APS will petition for public guardianship. Public guardianship or conservatorship is only considered as a last resort. If DHHS is appointed public guardian, the department files a detailed guardianship plan annually, and more frequently as necessary. Licensed social workers who serve as guardianship representatives are assigned to maintain contact with each adult under guardianship and coordinate with service providers, medical professionals, and family and friends to ensure the health and safety of each adult under guardianship. Guardianship representatives may also seek to terminate or modify a guardianship relationship if necessary. Currently, Maine DHHS has legal guardianship and conservatorship relationships with approximately 1,300 adults. Approximately 15 percent are limited guardianship relationships. During the most recent state legislative session, Maine enacted the Maine Uniform Probate Code, or UPC, to recodify and revise the state's probate code. While the Maine UPC maintains the same requirements for public guardianship, a number of mandates relative to private guardianship of adults in the UPC are scheduled to go into effect July 1, 2019. The Maine UPC establishes, for the first time in the state, the private guardian's duty to report annually on the condition of the adult and account for money and other property in the guardian's possession or subject to the guardian's control. Additionally, the Maine UPC effectuates a requirement for the courts to establish a system for monitoring and reviewing each report at least annually. The court will use the guardian's report to determine if additional actions or modifications, including termination, are appropriate. The Maine UPC also highlights the importance of exploring all options to limit or preclude the need for guardianship at the outset, including the use of technological assistance and employing supported decision-making. Similarly, the UPC language underscores the viewpoint that autonomy should be preserved as much as possible, and an adult who has a guardian or conservator must still have a seat at the table when decisions are being made. The department anticipates that the Maine UPC's statutory requirements will substantially improve data collection on guardianship. Similarly, requiring annual reporting of all guardians will allow the courts to more effectively provide oversight and bring concerns to the attention of appropriate entities, such as APS and law enforcement. The emphasis on reviewing all less restrictive alternatives to guardianship in statute, alongside the requirement for annual review, will help to ensure that guardianship is not imposed unnecessarily and is removed if no longer needed. Overall, the Maine Department of Health and Human Services is strongly committed to protecting the health and safety of incapacitated adults through its investigative and public guardianship functions. We believe that the UPC's revised focus on what is in the best interest of the incapacitated adult is a significant step forward to guardianship reform in Maine. Thank you for inviting me to speak and for taking the time to focus on this significant topic. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Commissioner. Ms. Buck. STATEMENT OF KAREN C. BUCK, ESQ., EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, SENIORLAW CENTER, PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA Ms. Buck. Thank you, Senator Collins, Senator Casey, and members of this Committee. It is a real pleasure to be here on this panel with these esteemed colleagues. As a proud public interest attorney and nonprofit leader who has advocated for older Americans for the past 21 years, I am so pleased to be able to testify today about the challenges of the guardianship system and some ideas on solutions and best practices for improvement. SeniorLAW Center fights for justice for older Pennsylvanians. We are a nonprofit legal services organization of attorneys and advocates, celebrating our 40th year of representing older people, focusing on those in the greatest economic and social need. We envision a world that values older people, that hears their voices and guarantees their rights. This vision, I think, really captures the essence of why we are here today. Few legal proceedings have more impact on an individual's fundamental rights and liberties than guardianship. Putting life decisions of one into the hands of another is daunting. At SeniorLAW Center, we do much to prevent the need for guardianship. Guardianship has overwhelming impact on an individual's health, safety, economic security, shelter, family, happiness, quality of life, and, yes, even, longevity. And it is ripe for abuse, neglect, and exploitation in the wrong hands. It has created situations of enormous family anguish and pain. It is at the same time an important tool to provide for the care of our most vulnerable citizens. It is often misunderstood. I will now highlight the major points detailed in my full statement, my full written statement. The first is about data collection, and it is so great to hear from my colleagues here about what they are doing in other states and at the State Center. We know there is a paucity of guardianship data, much less reliable data, in Pennsylvania and elsewhere around the country. Data is essential, as we heard, to addressing the size and scope of the problem, what is working and what is not, tracking the caseload, the guardians and individuals, wards, or alleged incapacitated persons who are involved, and, most importantly, their health and safety. In this area, Pennsylvania is making great strides. I am proud, as the Senator mentioned, to be an appointed member of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Elder Law Task Force and its Advisory Council on Elder Justice in the Courts, which have both spent enormous time and effort in examining guardianship and its challenges and best practices, elder abuse and neglect, and access to justice. The task force released its report with 130 recommendations in November 2014, and I cannot wait to take this new report back to the Supreme Court in Pennsylvania. I do have to add, though, that in presenting this testimony, I do so on behalf of SeniorLAW Center and myself and not on behalf of the court or its council. We are so proud of the groundbreaking work of the court's task force and council, and of the Administrative Office of the Pennsylvania Courts, who together have created and in 2018 released a new Guardianship Tracking System, GTS, which will transform guardianship data in Pennsylvania, and we believe set a gold standard for the country. It will streamline and modernize the filing, reporting, and monitoring functions of the court in a sophisticated data base and enable courts to share information about guardians and counsel to identify red flags when abuse or exploitation may be involved, track caseloads, and both financial and personal care information, and much more. Providing accurate information to courts who are making these profound determinations about individuals will have an extraordinary impact on individual lives and freedom. Data collection is great, but we also need other responses to abuse and exploitation of those under guardianship, and so many of the recommendations are in my written testimony, but just to point out a few. Certainly training is an enormous issue of judges, court staff, families, the aging network, and others about the process and what rights we have under guardianship. A Bill of Rights for both Incapacitated and Alleged Incapacitated Persons, and I know my colleague Ms. Buckley will speak about that in Nevada. Volunteer pro bono systems who do guardianship monitoring or professional monitors, training and certification of professional guardians, and reasonable investigation into their backgrounds. And supporting advocates and legal services to represent and advocate for individuals who are being abused and exploited or who allege such abuse or exploitation. Legal services are an essential tool in the fight against guardianship and abuse, as are statewide senior legal helplines, which are now available in 26 states and provide free, accessible, effective, and cost- efficient legal advice, information, and representation to seniors in critical civil areas of law. I have a number of comments on least restrictive alternatives, but in the spirit of my time, I will just end with the right to counsel and access to justice, which is the essence of the work that we do at SeniorLAW Center and has really been my professional passion. We are especially concerned about the right to counsel and representation of alleged incapacitated persons in guardianship proceedings and ensuring fair, unbiased, and zealous advocacy. In many jurisdictions across the country, including Pennsylvania, counsel is frequently not appointed, and I would submit that the scales of justice are, therefore, imbalanced. We believe individuals should participate in their hearings, be present when at all possible, and start with the presumption that they can be. I will end by thanking you for this opportunity to participate in this important discussion. We are delighted to see the report that has been issued today, and we look forward to being involved in your next efforts to pursue justice for older Americans. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Ms. Buckley. STATEMENT OF BARBARA E. BUCKLEY, ESQ., EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, LEGAL AID CENTER OF SOUTHERN NEVADA, LAS VEGAS, NEVADA Ms. Buckley. Thank you, Chair Collins, Ranking Member Casey, members of the Committee. For the record, my name is Barbara Buckley, and I am the executive director of Legal Aid Center of Southern Nevada. I am honored to be here today to discuss a critical issue facing our country: exploitation of the elderly and adults with disabilities in the guardianship arena. Guardianship abuse hit many in Nevada. It destroyed the lives of countless individuals, depriving them of their liberty, their right to see their family, and their assets. Guardians were being appointed without notice, often when there was no real need for a guardian. The court bypassed family members to appoint professional guardians or others who proceeded to loot the estate and then isolate the individual from their loved ones. All of the fees incurred by the guardian and the guardian's attorney robbed the protected person sometimes of their entire life savings, with little or no oversight. The elderly adult or adult with disability at the center of the case was often the only party without an attorney or the ability to object in court. They were left stranded without being able to express their wishes and had no one to enforce their rights. It became clear that reforms were needed after families and protected persons, with their voices magnified by the press and others who believed in them, began coming forward about their victimization. In 2015, Nevada Supreme Court Chief Justice James Hardesty enacted a Guardianship Reform Commission which suggested numerous reforms, all adopted by the Nevada Legislature and approved by our Governor. My testimony today focuses on the three most significant reforms enacted. The first, right to counsel. The right to counsel for individuals facing or in guardianship is one of the most important recommendations emanating from Nevada. Since individuals face significant deprivation of rights and liberties, it was determined that individuals should have the same right to counsel as set forth in the landmark case of Gideon v. Wainwright. The goal of counsel is to ensure that the least restrictive alternative to guardianship is the first thing examined so as to maximize the independence and legal rights of those who are facing guardianship, to provide a voice in court proceedings, for those who want to contest a guardianship either because it is unnecessary or because the guardian is abusing their power, and to protect the due process rights of those waylaid into the system. The commission recommended and the legislature agreed that counsel would follow a client-directed model, and that model requires the attorney to zealously advocate for the wishes of their client and not to substitute their own judgment for what they think should happen in the case. Nevada also decided that legal aid attorneys should provide this representation. We have now become experts in the field of elder law and guardianship and share best practices amongst ourselves in Nevada. Since the advent of this program, there is a completely different landscape in guardianship proceedings. As soon as a petition is filed, a legal aid attorney is appointed, we go visit the client where they are to learn what they want. We get their input from the very beginning. The client makes the decision whether to support or oppose the guardianship or who is being proposed to be the guardian. We have had unscrupulous guardians removed, unnecessary actions dismissed, and our clients' assets recovered. We ended a structural imbalance that was just spoken about where the most important person in the case previously had no voice. The second important reform, creation of a Bill of Rights for a protected person. In Nevada, like many other places, there seems to be almost a callous indifference about the rights of the individual under guardianship where their opinion did not really matter. To combat this sometimes callous treatment, we scoped all of the Bill of Rights throughout the country--Texas--we looked at different areas, rights given to individuals with mental illness and the like, and we compiled a Nevada-centric version. A person has the right to be treated with dignity, respect, be in the least restrictive environment, be represented by counsel, to not have their visitors restricted. It is a comprehensive end to the previously lack of consideration for those under guardianship. Last, I would like to talk about our Nevada Guardianship Compliance Office. This is the third plank of the Nevada reforms. This office opened in January 2018 and provides auditing and investigative services to the district courts. They may locate a protected person who is not where they are supposed to be. They may report on the appropriateness of the guardian and the care and treatment. They have opened 121 cases involving appropriateness of guardians and 50 audit cases just in that short time. It is hard to describe the heartache and suffering that was going on in Nevada prior to these reforms. We are proud of the strides we have made. I would be remiss if I did not thank our then-Chief Justice, now-Justice James Hardesty, our courts, our legal aid team, our lawmakers, and our victims' families for bringing these issues to the forefront and for their solutions. There is still a lot of work left to do in Nevada, so I want to thank you for this hearing, for your report, and all of the work that you have done on this issue. I would also like to thank our Senator Cortez Masto for her work as AG in regulating private professional guardians, bringing that issue up for the first time and all she does for our state. I would urge this panel to continue to engage with jurists, lawmakers, and to continue your quest for reform. Our seniors and adults with disabilities deserve no less. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Commissioner Hamm, I am going to start with you. I was interested to learn of the reforms that the State of Maine has made in its probate code to better protect those who need guardians, and part of the reforms that you mentioned were regular reports, I believe, being filed annually. Could you give us some sense of what kind of information is required to be reported to the court? And what is involved in the court's review of guardianship reports? Ms. Hamm. Certainly. Thank you, Chairman, and I just want to start off by saying Maine is extremely lucky to have you as a champion, particularly on these issues, and not just a champion in Maine but a champion across the country. The Chairman. Thank you. Ms. Hamm. So thank you very much for your work, and I do want to just go back to one statement that you made in your opening remarks about Maine being the oldest state in the Nation, which right now about 20 percent of our folks in Maine are 65 and older, so we have an interest in making sure that they are protected. So Maine did adopt the Uniform Probate Code which goes into effect July 2019, so the report has generally adopted everything that was in the reporting requirements, the 13 requirements that were laid out. So those were adopted and will be followed. They will review the reports annually, as I described, and just looking here to see a little bit about what the reports will determine. So the reports provide sufficient information to establish the guardian has complied with the guardian's duty, whether the guardianship should continue, and also whether the guardian's fees, if any, should be approved. So that is just a few examples of those. The Chairman. Thank you. Ms. Buckley, you talked about the reforms which were really major reforms that Nevada implemented. Were these reforms in response to specific cases that occurred? I recall from a previous hearing a particularly egregious case of one individual who had ripped off so many people who were under his care. Ms. Buckley. Thank you, Senator. Yes, the reform commission started after reports became known through the voices of victims and their families and the press, and there were just so many of them. One particular private professional guardian was particularly egregious. She was the one featured in that New Yorker article that you discussed at your last hearing. She is still in the Clark County detention center and has agreed to a plea bargain, you know, but she destroyed hundreds of lives. But it was not just her. It was other private professional guardians. It was other guardians including family members that just suffered from a lack of kind of rights and a structural imbalance. The Chairman. And nobody overseeing them really once they are appointed, too. Ms. Buckley. None whatsoever. I mean, I recall one case where our attorney went to visit someone, and they had had a stroke, and Elder Protective Services asked us to go visit the home. And when we talked with the gentleman and asked him, ``Are you happy where you are?'' he just looked at us and signaled, you know, ``No.'' We said, you know, ``Would you like a change in guardian?'' He had been, you know, pretty hurt by a stroke. And he squeezed our attorney's hand so tightly, and when she said, ``I will represent you. I will tell the court that you need another guardian,'' he moved his finger to give her a thumbs up, and a tear went down his face. He had been held prisoner in this home without the ability to address the court, without the ability to escape. That is what the right to counsel began to end in Nevada. The Chairman. It is a heart-wrenching story indeed. Ms. Boyko, you described in your testimony the proposal for a rapid response pilot project that proposes to transform the guardianship system in the courts, and I was intrigued that part of it was that the guardian or conservator would be required to sign up with a financial monitoring company so that suspicious transactions could be identified quickly and alerts sent to the court's rapid response team. Can you tell us the current status of that pilot project? Ms. Boyko. Yes. Thank you, Chair Collins. That project is just about to go underway. We hope to start it at the beginning of the year. We have received funding from the Office of Victims of Crime, and although it is minimal funding to get it started in two pilot courts, we have a court in Michigan and a court in South Carolina that are going to pilot it. And we are hoping that the proof of concept will be determined to be viable and it will be able to be replicated on a national level. The Chairman. And would the funding that is included in the Guardianship Accountability Act that Senator Casey and I have introduced be useful in expanding pilot projects like that? Ms. Boyko. It certainly would. The Chairman. I knew you would answer that way. [Laughter.] The Chairman. But I just wanted to get it on the record so that we---- Ms. Boyko. Yes, yes, yes. It certainly would. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. That was remarkable choreography. [Laughter.] Senator Casey. And we need it. Karen, I will start with you and also maybe Ms. Boyko on this round of questions. But I wanted to start with this question of data and, more importantly, reliable data. We found in this process that even what we consider, I think most would consider basic information on guardianship is lacking. We do not know often, for example, how many people are subject to guardianship, who their guardians are. Has a guardian been thoroughly vetted? How many people are possibly being abused or exploited by a guardian? Questions to which we often do not know the answer. Karen, I wanted to start with you on this and ask you, in light of the really limited information sometimes, we know that Pennsylvania has created the Guardianship Tracking System, a data base for guardianships that will be up and running in all 67 counties in Pennsylvania by the end of December. I guess, first, could you explain how the system would address this gap in data? Ms. Buck. Yes, I would be happy to, Senator. Thank you. And, again, thank you for your leadership on behalf of older Americans. We are really thrilled to have you on this Committee and as our voice in Washington. So the Guardianship Tracking System, as I mentioned, came out of the work of the Supreme Court's Elder Justice Council and Task Force, and it was a recommendation of that initial report that was released in 2014. Similar to Nevada, our courts really took leadership in this role. And as we were working as a leadership entity through the problems of access to justice, guardianship, elder abuse and neglect, we surveyed courts. We did some recon to find out what was the status of data on guardianships in Pennsylvania, and what we found was very disheartening. As you know, Senator, we have 67 counties in Pennsylvania. Many of our judicial and Orphans' Court branches are quite small. For example, we have one county in Pennsylvania which has one judge. He does it all. He is the president judge and the only judge. So the challenge is we recognize that there are challenges, and keeping up with the data was one of them, and having enough resources to review reports, make sure they were filed, follow up with guardians and track the data. So the Supreme Court had recommended through its council that we develop this tracking system, and it has been a year and a half in the making. This is our profile, GTS, and if you go on the Supreme Court Council Web site, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court Web site, there is actually a video about our new tracking system. I just wanted to mention a couple things about how it was created. This was a project of the Office of Pennsylvania Courts, and they put a whole team of IT experts on this project--five analysts, five developers, four data base administrators, and a separate migration team. It really was transformative. They are currently migrating all active guardianship caseloads into the system and working with courts and with guardians to ensure that information is as accurate as possible as it is migrated into the new system. As you mentioned, it is new and will not be fully implemented until the end of this year. But it will really make various information that was never available before on a statewide basis available, including the frequency of contact of guardians, the caseloads, the relationship to incapacitated persons. Ms. Buckley talked about we would like family members to be guardians of their loved ones if it is at all possible. Criminal background checks, of course, is an issue, and next year it will become a requirement in Pennsylvania. Bond information, whether the individual is leaving the community and moving into a nursing home, and that is a big problem with guardians, as Ms. Buckley mentioned, and others--selling the house, moving that individual under their care, not where they want to be, but what might be more effective for the guardian. Sometimes it is the right decision, but we want to have that information, and, also, significant transfers of funds, so that also flashes the financial information. There is a page in our manual--several pages which are all the flags that judges and their staff can input into the GTS, concern of loss and neglect flags. So a series of over 34 flags that judges and their court staff can input into the system to say this guardian or this case is problematic or potentially problematic, and then that information will be available to all judges who are looking at guardianships in Pennsylvania. And then, finally, I would just say I heard the federal funding question, and this transformation of data for our courts is going to require a lot more effort to review the information, to have eyes and ears on it. So any type of additional funding for the courts and the court staff to do that important work would be much welcome in Pennsylvania. Senator Casey. Well, thank you very much. I know that I am over time. Let me just ask one more for Ms. Boyko, the same general question about reliable data. But I guess from more of a national perspective, what improvements to the collection of data are needed to ensure we can have consistent, reliable data from across the country on guardianships? Ms. Boyko. Thank you, Senator Casey, and I reiterate I do not think the issues in Pennsylvania that Ms. Buck identified are unique to Pennsylvania. I think they are reflective nationwide as far as the data picture goes. I think the No. 1 thing that is needed is a national identification of what data elements would be beneficial for courts to collect, and then an avenue to assist courts in finding ways to collect that data. And as Ms. Buck identified in Pennsylvania, the resources needed to get to that level are essential and extensive, and any assistance to courts--because courts are very localized, it is a very individual court issue as far as the collection of data. So assisting courts at the very local level in establishing a mechanism to gather this data would be essential. Senator Casey. Thank you very much. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Blumenthal? Senator Blumenthal. Thank you very much, Madam Chairwoman. This topic is immensely important. Many of us in this room will encounter this situation. In Connecticut, guardianship or conservatorship decisions are made by a local probate court judge who is elected and need not be a lawyer. I do not know how often that occurs elsewhere in the country, but these judges are essentially beyond any oversight. And very often they have their own fiefdoms, literally their own private kingdoms. They make a ton of money. [Applause.] Senator Blumenthal. So I gather from the applause that many of you are familiar with these situations. Maybe you have been in a sense involved in them. I hear from my constituents all the time. We are carrying on this conversation at a very high level of abstraction, but the impact on lives, real-world situations, is enormous. And I say that as a lawyer in Connecticut who has never handled a guardianship or conservatorship case, but I think we need to figure out a way to assure greater accountability in this system. [Applause.] Senator Blumenthal. And I think we need more information. But I do not need more information to have seen some of the ways that the probate courts or the other parts of the system operate. And you can all speak for your own states. Maybe Connecticut is an outlier; maybe the rest of the system is perfect, and Connecticut is the one place in the universe where there have been these issues. But I wonder if you could comment on the quality of judging--I assume it is mostly judges who appoint these guardianships. I have always assumed it in other states as well, judges who are elected. Are they appointed? Do we know? What kind of oversight is there? I realize these are all big questions, but maybe you can give us some feedback on it. And, most importantly, what is the quality of this decision-making? Ms. Buckley. I will answer that. So, Senator, I am from Nevada, and when we started our reform journey, there were 8,000 open adult guardianship cases. After the cases were scrubbed, it was found that there was only 3,000 actually where the person had not died. There was no oversight of the financial issues or the care of the guardian. The cases were basically rubber-stamped. If a lawyer said this person needs guardianship, it was granted without even a hearing. And so the protected person did not have a voice. We had a very sad case where a neighbor came to protest that she was looking after the neighbor in her cul-de-sac, but the hearing was canceled. The private professional guardian was appointed. She moved the person out of the home, sold her lovely home, liquidated all her assets, overcharged her, and every time the neighbor looks at her former neighbor's house, it breaks her heart. That is what happens when there is no oversight. Ms. Buck. I might just add a comment as well, Senator. Karen Buck from Pennsylvania. I know we have a lot of family members here who have experienced a lot of anguish and pain as a result of guardianship and maybe some bad decisions. We have worked with a lot of Orphans' Court judges who are doing excellent work, and I would not make any blanket statements about any judges, and I probably would not be here complaining about judges either. We know that our judges are also elected in Pennsylvania, so there is a real challenge there. I would say, however, that having a right to counsel, having an attorney representing the alleged incapacitated person, as well as incapacitated persons already determined to be under guardianship who may not need to any longer be under guardianship, having access to counsel to fight abuse, exploitation, and neglect to challenge what is going on in the courtroom is really an essential first step. We have been talking about the access to legal services, which I would agree with Ms. Buckley, as an independent, usually nonprofit organization, profit is not the goal of our work in legal services. So, to me, that would be one of the great recommendations that we have unbiased, independent, nonprofit attorneys helping to represent these individuals. Ms. Boyko. If I could just address that question, Senator Blumenthal, I am Kate Boyko from the National Center for State Courts, and the Conference of Chief Justices and the Conference of State Court Administrators are very interested in reform in the courts in the area of guardianship and conservatorship. A document referred to in my written testimony on the guardianship improvement process has been supported and resoundingly approved by the Conference of Chief Justices and the Conference of State Court Administrators, and I think that that is a step in the right direction to provide an increase in oversight and to start reform in this--or continue the reform in some areas, but in some instances start reform in this area. Ms. Hamm. Senator, thank you for the question. In Maine, our probate judges are elected as well. Generally, I would say that they are thoughtful in their oversight or thoughtful in their decision-making. There is little oversight, as my colleague said. They are locally represented, and one thing I would say is there is a general need for more education around the guardianship issues amongst the probate judges. And I would also echo the need for more requirements around the noticing and rights to attorneys, et cetera. Senator Blumenthal. Well, I want to thank all of you. I apologize that I have gone over my time, Madam Chairwoman. And I do not mean to impugn every probate judge in Connecticut or elsewhere. There are some very fine and dedicated individuals doing this hard work. But it is an area which is largely invisible. Every other judge in our system has an appeals court, whatever it is called, above him or her, and then another appeals court, and then the United States Supreme Court eventually, theoretically. But probate court decisions are unto themselves, and I understand that the right to counsel is a protection, but if you said to the ordinary litigant, ``Well, you have no right to appeal this decision, but you do get a lawyer,'' they would say, ``That is not really good enough.'' And I do not know what the solution is for us because we are up here on the dais and up here symbolically as Senators and we cannot really dictate to states how to run their justice systems. But I really appreciate all your hard work, and I appreciate the Chairwoman and Ranking Member focusing on this issue. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Gillibrand, you have been very patient. Senator Gillibrand. Oh, I very much enjoy my colleagues' work and your insightfulness, so I am very grateful to be here. Thank you all for your work. Obviously, you are all public servants and helping people who desperately need your help. Many advocates argue that there are far too many individuals in guardianship arrangements and that states need to provide better guidance to courts to use when determining when it is appropriate to subject an individual to such arrangements. Ms. Hamm, in your written testimony, you touch on the importance of exploring all options to limit or prevent the need for a guardianship arrangement when appropriate, including the use of technological assistance and employing supportive decision-making? Can you describe in more detail some of the alternative arrangements to full guardianship? What steps can Congress take to support greater adoption of these alternatives? And for Ms. Buck, in your testimony, you discuss the importance of education about guardianship alternatives for courts, families, and communities. How can Congress improve access to education in this area so that families facing undergoing complex guardianship proceedings are aware of all of their options before such a life-changing event? Ms. Hamm. Thank you, Senator. Well, I think that the UPC code and the enactment in Maine is moving in the right direction around less restrictive alternatives, by way of supported decision-making approaches, identifying a team or an individual that can help somebody make those important life decisions rather than move toward full guardianship. Single- issue orders, examples of that might be medical or financial, and then limited guardianships, examples of that might be residential placement or medical or financial. So I think that we are making progress, but my esteemed colleagues certainly represent those on the ground in the forefront and probably have some more thoughtful ideas around that. Ms. Buck. Yes, Senator, thank you so much for the question. The alternatives to guardianship are an enormous issue in this realm. There have been proposals from the American Bar Association that guardians--that states should require consideration of alternatives to guardianship in their guardianship statutes, to add that requirement, which I think is an important one. And you also questioned about education and training. In Pennsylvania, we are doing a lot to really energetically start that training of all judges so that they understand the full panoply of issues affecting older people, whether it is elder abuse and neglect or capacity or the aging brain, family dynamics, domestic and family violence, et cetera, and, of course, guardianship, because the issues of elder abuse and neglect are not aligned only with the guardianship field, as we know, and they do affect all aspects of the judicial system, whether it is the family court, the housing court, the orphans' court or others, landlord-tenant court, et cetera. So in Pennsylvania, we have created bench books that we are about to release in 2019 that every judge who handles guardianship will have so that they are clearly familiar with their duties, the roles and responsibilities of guardians, the rights of individuals, and, of course, the additional alternative means to guardianship. We would very much like to see less guardianships and more alternatives to guardianship, whether it is supported decision-making, whether it is making sure people have done all of their advance and life planning issues, done power of attorney duly executed while they have capacity, and having judges recognize the legitimacy of those documents and referring to those first. So we are also doing lay guardianship and training programs. We are training district attorneys and others. But I think there is a lot of misunderstanding not only about guardian but the full panoply of alternatives. If I could just go back quickly to Senator Blumenthal's question, I did want to point out that in Pennsylvania many of the judges are part and parcel of crafting the solutions. So I think they do understand in many instances that there are serious challenges in our judicial system. Senator Gillibrand. Ms. Buckley or Ms. Boyko, do you have any comments you want to add? Ms. Boyko. One comment that I would add to promote the alternatives to guardianship, the National Center for State Courts is currently working with the American Bar Association, with funding from the Elder Justice Initiative, to provide some online training for lay persons that will speak to alternatives to guardianship in hopefully promoting people before they come to the court that they know that there are other alternatives out there. Senator Gillibrand. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. Thank you, Mr. Ranking Member. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Senator Cortez Masto? Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you, Madam Chair. And thank you all for being here. I apologize. I have other committee hearings going on at the same time. That seems to be a thing here. So if this question was asked, excuse me. I want to jump back to the idea of these proposed rules and duties for attorneys as they represent those in guardianship, and maybe, Ms. Buckley, let me start with you. Describe the difference. What we are talking about here is the duties for attorneys. It is not the duties that we typically have as attorneys in our roles that we are trained in law school and the rules and responsibility and what we carry out and the oath that we take specifically. These are duties that are unique to guardianship, the special interest model for attorneys that are engaging in this. Do you see a distinction? In other words, is there training that is necessary for an attorney that is taking on one of these roles that would be different than what they normally carry out in their day-to-day functions and other representation? Ms. Buckley. Thank you, Senator, for the question. The short answer is yes and no. The longer answer is we want an attorney for someone in a guardianship arena to follow the traditional attorney-client model. The person facing guardianship has the right to have their opinion matter and direct the course of the attorney. It is not a guardian ad litem role where the attorney says kind of what I think, ``Oh, I think this person is better than this person,'' because sometimes attorneys are not very good at that, right? They are trained in law. They are trained in how to be a lawyer. They are trained in what to do when there is a client in need. So our attorneys zealously advocate for our clients. If they are unable to communicate with us, let us say they are in a coma, we will then represent their legal and constitutional rights; if they have done estate planning, to make sure that is honored; if they are not in the least restrictive alternative, right? That is how we operate as attorneys for protected persons. Senator Cortez Masto. And how do you ensure--so this is best practice. So better jurisdictions are going to favor best practices. How would you help them to understand, yeah, that is something that--how does that export to part of best practices? Ms. Buckley. So what we have done is we have learned from our brethren throughout the country who study these issues, there are national trainings, and for attorneys in Nevada, we have put together a manual on how to represent a protected person. We are going to be offering a pro bono program, which is what we usually do, where we represent individuals directly, and then we ask attorneys in the community to come forward so they get to see unmet legal needs, so they can add their voices to Supreme Court commissions. And so in my written testimony I have provided a link to it and would encourage all throughout the country to look at it and to add their thoughts to it, and a major shout-out to our attorney, Jim Berchtold. It is really a masterpiece and really could be a model throughout the Nation. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. And I know, Ms. Buck, this is an area that you have advocated as well. Is that something similar to what you have seen as well? Ms. Buck. Yes, absolutely. But I think Ms. Buckley makes a very important point that we want attorneys to be zealous advocates for incapacitated or allegedly incapacitated persons, not to serve as a guardian ad litem. These are not children. They are adults. I started my legal career representing abused and neglected children, and part of the education of courts and others is we need to treat seniors as adults who have rich histories and experiences and not to be infantilizing them, to really check our paternalism and ageism at the door. And I think that is a big part of what we all do who advocate for older people. Senator Cortez Masto. Right, both for seniors and people with disabilities that require the guardianships. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Ms. Buck, I am impressed by the work that the SeniorLAW Center Project Stop Abuse and Financial Exploitation, the SAFE program that you have, and the free legal representation that is provided to and abusive situations. What are the barriers that you have found to the successful prosecution of financial crimes? Ms. Buck. That is an excellent question, Senator. Thank you. Project SAFE, Stop Abuse and Financial Exploitation, is one of our most successful projects and one that is really growing and expanding enormously because of the extraordinary need of older victims who are facing so many forms of abuse, domestic violence, family violence, and the financial exploitation issues that you are all so familiar with. We have a real challenge just keeping up with the need, but I am happy to say--it is a two-part answer, some happy, some not happy. I am happy to say that we have had really successful civil and criminal justice partnerships with our district attorneys in Philadelphia and district attorneys around our Commonwealth. That being said, we need more resources and more attention by prosecutors to these issues of financial exploitation and other forms of elder abuse, and sometimes they do not get the attention that they need. And it is often a resources question. In Philadelphia, we have the largest percentage of seniors of the ten largest cities in the country and one of the poorest, and we are still working with a new district attorney to develop an elder justice unit in the district attorney's office. Another positive note is that, as you probably know, the U.S. Attorneys, the Department of Justice, have now Elder Justice Coordinations in almost every one of---- The Chairman. We pushed very hard for that. Ms. Buck. Yes, and we thank you. In Pennsylvania, and particularly in the Eastern District, near Philadelphia, that is going to be transformative for us, and we are working very closely with them to try to pursue additional prosecutions. The Chairman. Thank you. Commissioner Hamm, obviously it is important that we prosecute those who have ripped off our seniors and betrayed their trust. I have a feeling that at times when it is a family member involved, that there is a reluctance on the part of the victim to proceed with the case. But my question for you is: What more can we do in the area of prevention, of making sure that these abuses do not occur in the first place, whether the guardian is a family member, a close fried, or a professional guardian who is unconnected to the family? Ms. Hamm. Thank you, Senator. That is an excellent question and one that I asked my team before I came here today to talk with everyone. So it is a difficult thing to tackle, for sure, and I think you can recall a situation in the State of Maine up in the Lincoln area where a family member did just what you described and was eventually prosecuted, so that was a good thing. But we are deploying things like SeniorSafe, which I know you are intimately familiar with. We partner with the Maine Council for Elder Abuse and Prevention and do regulate APS outreach in the community. We work very closely with our Legal Services for the Elderly folks. We contract with them to investigate or represent individuals who do not have representation. So those are some of the things that we are doing and will continue to do moving forward. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. Thank you very much. Karen Buck, I will go back to you about the issue of background checks. I know we have talked about the right to counsel, but several of the individuals and organizations that have provided feedback to the Committee recommended that courts adopt a process for investigating backgrounds. I think that is fundamental. While this surely will not prevent all instances of abuse or exploitation, or both, it could weed out some really bad actors. The General Assembly in Pennsylvania is considering a bill to require these background checks of prospective guardians before being appointed, and the question I have for you is: If these checks are implemented with the proper safeguards, do you believe they could play an important role in providing additional information to the court as it considers whether to appoint a person as a guardian? Ms. Buck. Thank you, Senator. Yeah, the issue of criminal background checks is an important one. I am familiar with the legislation that you are referring to by Senator Haywood and others. One great stride we have been making as a result of some very egregious guardians in Philadelphia and surrounding counties who had very significant criminal convictions in other states that were not revealed by the guardianship process and were not known to the courts. As a result of that, Philadelphia has changed its rules and now currently requires criminal background checks to be part of the guardianship petition in all cases. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has changed its rules, and as of next June, July, criminal background checks will be required in the filing of all guardianship petitions in Pennsylvania as well. As legal services attorneys, we think that as much information as possible is the way to go. I think the real question is: How is that information used? The judge should have all possible information at his or her disposal when they are making those decisions, and to Senator Cortez Masto's question, that is one of the areas and ways that we can prevent the appointment of bad or exploitive guardians. We do not condone blanket applications or exclusions of individuals with criminal backgrounds. It really should be a case-by-case basis on what was the criminal conviction. Is it relevant? And will it make the guardian less able to do their job? Of course, there are many that immediately should raise red flags, and that information will go into our Guardianship Tracking System as well. Senator Casey. The bill in the General Assembly, is it bipartisan? Ms. Buck. I believe so, yes. Senator Casey. OK. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Casey. A vote has just started. Senator Cortez Masto, I want to give you a chance for one more question before we close out the hearing. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. For Ms. Boyko, thank you for your testimony and all of the work that you are doing. Data is key. I think it is key to everything that we do. It informs us. It helps us develop best practices, identify trends, things that we need to improve upon. Let me ask you this: Is there anything that the Federal Government can do to assist in distributing and encouraging some of these best practices that you have identified? Or what more can we do to help states address the issue of a lack of data or standardizing some of this data across the country so we can compare it? Ms. Boyko. Thank you for that question. I think one of the key things is encouraging collaboration. There are a lot of good ideas out there. There are a lot of states and local courts that are doing fabulous things to reform this area and improvements in data such as Pennsylvania that we have heard of today, and I think providing some type of national resource center for the clearinghouse of that information, to get that information to a variety of local courts and local states, accompanied by resources--there is a lack of resources, but sharing information. We do not need to reinvent everything. We can use the best practices that are in place some places and just share those with other places so that courts can implement them. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. That was a good segue into the final recommendation, because the recommendation, one of them in there, is a national resource center, which is fantastic. So thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you very much. I want to thank all of our witnesses for being here today and for your enormous contributions to this debate. I have a fairly lengthy closing statement, but in the interest of our all making the vote, I am going to just put it into the record. I do want to take this opportunity to thank the two staffers who worked the hardest on this report, Amber Talley on my staff and Kevin Barstow on the Ranking Member's staff, who were the chief authors of the report. Many other staff members also played a role, and I want to thank them as well. I also want to indicate that Committee members have until Friday, December 7th, to submit questions for the record, so you may be receiving some additional communications from our Committee. But, again, my thank you to the witnesses today. You have really helped enhance our understanding. My hope is that states will take a hard look at the recommendations in our report and that the legislative reforms that we have proposed will be enacted as well. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. I will submit a statement for the record as well. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. The Chairman. Thank you. This hearing is now adjourned. [Whereupon, at 4 o'clock p.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Additional Statements for the Record ======================================================================= Closing Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman I want to thank our witnesses for your contribution to this important discussion about what States are doing to better protect those placed under guardianship arrangements. Guardianship, conservatorship, and other protective arrangements are designed to protect those with diminished or lost capacity. In most situations the appointment of a guardian is necessary, and many of the individuals charged with caring for others through such arrangements provide compassionate and faithful services, enabling better outcomes for seniors, their families, and their communities. At the same time, in this Committee's investigation over the past year, we have uncovered opportunities for improving oversight of guardianship arrangements, for the increased use of alternatives to guardianship and the restoration of rights in appropriate situations, and for the collection of more reliable and consistent data. Several States are, however, making significant progress in reforming their guardianship procedures. As we have heard today, Maine, Pennsylvania, and Nevada are real leaders in this effort, and we applaud their efforts and successes. The report the Committee is releasing today discusses these issues and highlights some of the reforms that have been implemented, and includes recommendations for continued improvements. The Guardianship Accountability Act that Senator Casey and I introduced this morning would further support guardianship reform, providing support for many of those recommendations. This Committee remains committed to addressing the financial exploitation of older Americans by guardians, and we seek your feedback on this legislation as we look toward the 116th Congress. Working together, we can identify the best ways to protect seniors from exploitation and stop the egregious abuses of power by guardians like those in the stories we heard today. Before I close, I'd like to thank those Members who will be leaving our Committee at the end of the 115th Congress . . . Senators: Hatch, Corker, Flake, Donnelly, and Nelson. Thank you for your service on this Committee, and you will be missed. __________ Closing Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member Thank you, Chairman Collins, for holding this important hearing. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today and providing valuable insight. As we have heard today, and exposed throughout the Committee's examination of the issue, there are many concerns about how the guardianship system is currently working. Instead of serving as an option of last resort, guardianship is far too often the first course of action. Older Americans and individuals with disabilities are faced with a complete loss of rights that often lasts their entire lives. For too long, we have heard horrific stories of how guardians have exploited people in their care. Once under guardianship, older Americans and individuals with disabilities are provided with little to no resources to lessen or remove a guardianship. I was encouraged to hear about efforts that are taking place in States across the country to improve their guardianship systems. While great work has been done, it will take a sustained effort to reform the guardianship system. We must work together to ensure individuals subject to guardianship are protected and that their well-being is considered first and foremost. I would like to thank Kevin Barstow, Rashage Green and Josh Dubensky on my staff, as well as former fellow in my office, Liz Weintraub, who helped kick off this work. I would also like to thank the staff of Senator Collins's office, for their work over the past year to bring this report together. I am thankful to Senator Collins for working with me on legislation that would improve the oversight of guardians and the collection of data. I am committed to working with her and my colleagues in the next Congress to pass this legislation. I look forward to our continued work on the issue. [all]