Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- EXAMINING IRS CUSTOMER SERVICE CHALLENGES [House Hearing, 115 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] EXAMINING IRS CUSTOMER SERVICE CHALLENGES ======================================================================= JOINT HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS AND THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON HEALTH CARE, BENEFITS, AND ADMINISTRATIVE RULES OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ MARCH 8, 2017 __________ Serial No. 115-2 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 25-233 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Jason Chaffetz, Utah, Chairman John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Elijah E. Cummings, Maryland, Darrell E. Issa, California Ranking Minority Member Jim Jordan, Ohio Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Justin Amash, Michigan Columbia Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts Trey Gowdy, South Carolina Jim Cooper, Tennessee Blake Farenthold, Texas Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Thomas Massie, Kentucky Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Mark Meadows, North Carolina Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Ron DeSantis, Florida Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Dennis A. Ross, Florida Val Butler Demings, Florida Mark Walker, North Carolina Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois Rod Blum, Iowa Jamie Raskin, Maryland Jody B. Hice, Georgia Peter Welch, Vermont Steve Russell, Oklahoma Matt Cartwright, Pennsylvania Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Mark DeSaulnier, California Will Hurd, Texas John Sarbanes, Maryland Gary J. Palmer, Alabama James Comer, Kentucky Paul Mitchell, Michigan ------ Jonathan Skladany, Majority Staff Director Rebecca Edgar, Deputy Staff Director William McKenna, General Counsel Jack Thorlin, Counsel Kevin Eichinger, Professional Staff Member Kiley Bidelman, Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director Subcommittee on Government Operations Mark Meadows, North Carolina, Chairman Jody B Hice, Georgia, Vice Chair Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia, Jim Jordan, Ohio Ranking Minority Member Mark Sanford, South Carolina Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Thomas Massie, Kentucky Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Ron DeSantis, Florida Columbia Dennis Ross, Florida Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Rod Blum, Iowa Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey ------ Subcommittee on Health Care, Benefits, and Administrative Rules Jim Jordan, Ohio, Chairman Mark Walker, North Carolina, Vice Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois, Chair Ranking Minority Member Darrell E. Issa, California Jim Cooper, Tennessee Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Columbia Mark Meadows, North Carolina Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Paul Mitchell, Michigan Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on March 8, 2017.................................... 1 WITNESSES Mr. John Dalrymple, Deputy Commissioner for Services and Enforcement, Internal Revenue Service Oral Statement............................................... 3 Written Statement............................................ 5 Mr. Russell Martin, Assistant Inspector General, Returns Processing and Account Services, Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration Oral Statement............................................... 16 Written Statement............................................ 18 Ms. Jessica Lucas-Judy, Acting Director, Strategic Issues, U.S. Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 31 Written Statement............................................ 33 APPENDIX Statement for the Record of Nina Olson, National Taxpayer Advocate, submitted by Chairman Meadows........................ 62 Get Backs from The Hon. John Dalrymple, Deputy Commissioner for Services and Enforcement, Internal Revenue Service............. 77 EXAMINING IRS CUSTOMER SERVICE CHALLENGES ---------- Wednesday, March 8, 2017 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Government Operations, joint with the Subcommittee on Health Care, Benefits, and Administrative Rules, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittees met, pursuant to call, at 2:10 p.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Mark Meadows [chairman of the Subcommittee on Government Operations] presiding. Present from the Subcommittee on Government Operations: Representatives Meadows, Hice, Jordan, DeSantis, Blum, and Connolly. Present from the Subcommittee on Health Care, Benefits, and Administrative Rules: Representatives Jordan, Meadows, Grothman, Mitchell, Krishnamoorthi, and Plaskett. Mr. Meadows. The Subcommittee on Government Operations and the Subcommittee on Health Care, Benefits, and Administrative Rules will come to order. And without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. The IRS is the Federal agency that the average American probably interacts with more frequently than most other agencies in the Federal Government. And as we look at customer service at the IRS and how most Americans experience the Federal Government, we owe it to them to make sure that their experience is clear and helpful. And if the taxpayers can get help from the IRS to understand some of the often more complicated tax obligations, the IRS then does not have to spend as much time looking or providing resources for audits or enforcement. Unfortunately, the 2015 tax season had one of the worst customer service records in IRS history with only 38 percent of the taxpayers who called the IRS assistance line actually getting a representative. And thereafter, the average wait time was well over 30 minutes. And so as we look at this, as the IRS calls for more resources, Congress indeed did grant them $298 million in for the 2016 tax season with $176 million specifically marked for taxpayer services. As a result, the 2016 filing season was better but still not as good as it was a decade earlier. So as we look at today's hearing, I am going to keep my opening remarks very brief because we are expecting votes here in just a few minutes. And we will certainly yield to a number of the other members as they have questions. And I will include some of that in my questioning. And the entire written statement will be made part--or opening statement will be made part of the record. Mr. Meadows. So with that, I will now recognize the ranking member for his opening statement. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Thank you, Chairmen Meadows and Jordan, for holding this important hearing on a topic that is so familiar to so many Americans: IRS customer service. Many of the individuals I represent encounter challenges when dealing with the IRS. The individuals are hardworking, honest Americans who are doing everything they can in order to comply with their tax obligations. I have seen some of these individuals go to great lengths to fulfill their responsibilities: contacting the IRS and others for help, providing what seems like an endless stream of documentation to their agency and their employers in order to get on an installment plan, and in some cases even digging into their hard-earned retirement savings to pay their outstanding tax debts. So while IRS says that it is working hard to improve customer service, it can be difficult for many of my constituents to believe in some cases. As our nation's tax code becomes increasingly complex, the burden placed on those trying to maintain tax compliances also increases. It is absolutely critical that the IRS have the appropriate channels to assist these well-meaning taxpayers and processes in place to rectify situations in which these channels fail. For that reason, and as a former small businessman, I hope we can shed some light on the processes currently in existence at the IRS for assisting customers before, during, and after the filing season. All customers deserve to have their questions answered in a timely, effective, and respectful manner. What does it take to make that happen? As the Oversight Committee, we have a responsibility to ensure that government works effectively and efficiently and is responsive to the citizens it serves. We should encourage agencies to take a hard look at themselves and identify areas that are working, as well as those that need improvement. We should encourage agencies to adopt best practices from other areas of government and the private sector, and we should certainly encourage agencies to listen to feedback from those on the other side of the table. Only after doing that can we have a meaningful discussion of what needs to be done and what resources need to be devoted in order to make our system succeed. I hope that these are discussions we can have today, and I look forward to the testimony of our witnesses. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Ohio, Mr. Jordan, for his opening statement. Mr. Jordan. I want to just thank the chairman for helping us put this important hearing together. As we are heading into tax season or into tax season, I think this is going to be some hopefully valuable information for the folks we get the privilege of serving and representing. So with that, I would yield back and look forward to the witness' testimony. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. We will hold the record open for five legislative days for any member who would like to submit a written statement. I will now recognize our panel of witnesses. I am pleased to welcome the Honorable John Dalrymple, deputy commissioner for Services and Enforcement at the Internal Revenue Service. Welcome. Mr. Russell Martin, deputy inspector general with the Treasury, inspector general for the Tax Administration, welcome. And Ms. Jessica Lucas-Judy, acting director of Strategic Issues at the U.S. Government Accountability Office, welcome. And pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify, so if you would please rise and raise your right hand. [Witnesses sworn.] Mr. Meadows. Thank you. Please be seated. And let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for discussion, we would ask that you please limit your oral testimony to five minutes, but your entire written testimony and statement will be made part of the record. And so, Mr. Dalrymple, we will recognize you for five minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF JOHN DALRYMPLE Mr. Dalrymple. Thank you. Chairmen Meadows and Jordan, Ranking Member ---- Mr. Meadows. Maybe just pull the--yes, a little bit closer to you there. Yes. Mr. Dalrymple. I thought I was loud enough. Sorry. Chairmen Meadows, Jordan, and Ranking Member Krishnamoorthi, and members of the subcommittees, thank you for the opportunity to testify on IRS's taxpayer service efforts. The IRS spends a significant amount of time and resources on this part of our mission because every taxpayer contact is important to us. The most visible taxpayer service the IRS provides is the delivery of a smooth, problem-free tax filing season so people can file their returns and receive their refunds as quickly and easily as possible. I am pleased to report that, so far, the 2017 filing season has gone smoothly in terms of tax processing and the operation of our information technology systems. As of February 24, the IRS received more than 53.2 million individual returns on the way to a total of about 152 million. We've issued more than 41.3 million refunds for more than $127 billion. The average refund so far is more than $3,000. During the filing season and throughout the year, the IRS provides assistance to taxpayers to help them meet their tax obligations. With over 150 million individual taxpayers, we realized there is no one-size-fits-all in terms of delivering service to them. We offer a mix of service channels and are always looking for ways to improve service delivery. Over many years, we've been working to expand our online service offerings because our research tells us that taxpayers increasingly prefer to interact with us through digital channels. Last year, taxpayers visited our website, IRS.gov, more than 500 million times. They used IRS.gov to find helpful tax information, check on the status of their refund, and perform transactions such as paying their tax bill. We've also been working to develop an online account at the IRS where taxpayers or their representatives can log in securely, get information about their account, and interact with the IRS as needed. We recognize that there will always be taxpayers who prefer not to interact with the IRS online. For that reason, we will continue providing and improving service on our other channels. One of these is phone service. The IRS receives more than 63 million taxpayer calls a year on our toll-free lines. A very challenging year in fiscal year 2015 the level of service provided on the phones improved significantly in 2016 as a result of additional funding from Congress. I'm pleased to report that during the 2017 filing season we are again seeing an even improved phone service. The IRS also provides in-person help to millions of taxpayers who visit our Tax Assistance Centers, or TACs, as we call them. Each of these contacts is also important to the IRS, and to cut down on long lines at our TACs, the IRS in 2015 began testing the idea of letting people make appointments in advance. We extended the appointment process to call--I'm sorry, to all TACs as of this year. Doing so has dramatically cut wait times, and we've had no reports of any lines outside TACs so far this filing season. Another way the IRS provides in-person help is by supporting nearly 12,000 volunteer income tax assistance and tax counseling for the elderly sites around the country. Volunteers at these sites provide free tax preparation help to eligible individuals. Along with the service we provide on these channels, the IRS also processes nearly 8 million pieces of correspondence from taxpayers each year, and these taxpayers are also important to us. The IRS remains dedicated to improving taxpayer service across all of our channels. Chairmen Meadows and Jordan, Ranking Member Krishnamoorthi, this concludes my statement, and I'd be happy to take questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Dalrymple follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you so much for your testimony. As Murphy's law would have it, they called votes just about the time that you started speaking. And so what we are going to do is go into recess. And for planning purposes, it will actually be subject to the call of the chair, but for those of you that may want to get a cup of coffee, if you will plan on being back here no later than 10 till 3:00. It may be later than that but certainly--the subcommittees stand in recess subject to the call of the chair. [Recess.] Mr. Meadows. The subcommittees will come to order. Thank you all for your patience and willingness to stay with us throughout this. Mr. Dalrymple, I want to congratulate you on your upcoming retirement. A little birdie told me that you were retiring in a couple of weeks, so we will try to make this as painless as possible. How about that? Mr. Dalrymple. You can't imagine how I appreciate that. Mr. Meadows. And before I recognize you, Mr. Martin, I want to recognize Mr. Sapp who is here from Drake Software, a good friend and constituent from back in North Carolina, who actually deals with these kinds of issues. And so it is good to have you here as well. So, Mr. Martin, you are recognized for five minutes. STATEMENT OF RUSSELL MARTIN Mr. Martin. Thank you. Chairmen, Ranking Members, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify on IRS's efforts to provide customer service to taxpayers, including those who are victims of identity theft. For the 2017 filing season, taxpayers have multiple options to choose from when they need assistance from the IRS. Examples include the toll-free telephone lines, face-to-face assistance, the mail, self-assistance through IRS.gov, and social media channels such as Twitter and Facebook. Despite other available options, taxpayers continue to use the telephone as the primary method to seek assistance from the IRS. The IRS is projecting a 75 percent level of service for the 2017 filing season, an increase from 72 percent reported for the 2016 filing season. The level of service represents the relative success rate of taxpayers who call the IRS for assistance. As of February 11, 2017, the IRS reports it answered approximately 2.5 million calls and provided an 82 percent level of service. Each year, millions of taxpayers also seek assistance from one of the IRS's 376 walk-in offices known as Taxpayer Assistance Centers or TACs. Although the IRS reports there are 376 TACs for the 2017 filing season, 24 are not open because they have not been staffed. The IRS estimates that the number of taxpayers it will assist at its TACs will continue to decrease. The IRS plans to assist more than 3.4 million taxpayers at its TACs in fiscal year 2017, a 22 percent decrease from fiscal year 2016. Taxpayers also interact with the IRS through the mail. The IRS's ability to timely process taxpayer correspondence remains a challenge. IRS management stated that the reduction in available staff is the most significant factor in not timely responding to taxpayer correspondence. In response to increased demand for online self-assistant options, the IRS continues to increase the services they provide online. However, as we have reported, the risk of unauthorized access to tax accounts increases as the IRS expands its focus on delivering online tools. Therefore, it is critical that the methods the IRS uses to authenticate individuals' identities provide a high level of confidence that tax information and services are provided only to individuals who are entitled to receive them. Much of the IRS's ability to serve taxpayers require staffing. Beginning in fiscal year 2015, the IRS made some resource decisions, which significantly affected the level of service provided to taxpayers. This included shifting a significant portion of the user fees it collects to operation support to implement other obligations required by law. In fiscal year 2016, the IRS received $178 million in additional funding by Congress. As a result, it has increased its level of service substantially from its low of 38 percent in fiscal year 2015. The IRS also continues to devote significant resources to assist victims of identity theft. In July 2015 the IRS created a centralized unit to combine the skills of employees working identity theft cases in multiple functions into one directorate. This has resulted in improvements in case closure time frames and a reduction in case closing errors. To help protect identity theft victims and improve authentication, the IRS began issuing unique identification numbers to eligible taxpayers in fiscal year 2011. The issuance of these numbers to confirmed victims of identity theft reduces IRS's resources needed to resolve identity theft cases. Specifically, this number helps the IRS verify a victim's identity at the time their tax return is filed and, as a result, not delay the processing of the taxpayer's return or issuance of their refund. However, TIGTA has identified that confirmed victims of identity theft tax accounts were not always consistently updated to ensure that these identification numbers were generated as required. This results in the need to unnecessarily use additional resources to review future tax return filings. TIGTA has reported that the trend of lower budgets and reduced staffing has affected the IRS's ability to deliver its priority program areas, including customer service and enforcement activities. The allocation of limited resources requires difficult decisions to balance customer service with enforcement activities. This ends my statement, and I look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Martin follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Martin. Ms. Lucas-Judy? STATEMENT OF JESSICA LUCAS-JUDY Ms. Lucas-Judy. Chairmen Meadows and Jordan, Ranking Members Connolly and Krishnamoorthi, members of the subcommittees, thank you for this opportunity to discuss GAO's recommendation for improving IRS customer service. My statement today focuses on two areas: IRS's performance in 2016 compared to prior years and its efforts to improve service for victims of identity theft. During the filing season, millions of taxpayers contact IRS. The service also processes most of the approximately 150 million tax returns it receives during this time and issues more than 100 million refunds. The scale of these operations, as well as IRS's declining resources, have raised concerns about its ability to provide service to taxpayers. Maintaining quality customer service is important because it helps taxpayers comply with the tax code. Regarding the first area, performance, IRS provided better telephone service to callers during the 2016 filing season compared to 2015. More people who wanted to speak to an assister were able to get through. In fact, it was the highest level of service for a filing season since 2011. However, IRS performance during the full fiscal year remained low. In addition, wait times were much shorter than in 2015, 11 minutes rather than 23 minutes on average. Total calls where taxpayers abandoned the call, were disconnected, or received a busy signal declined about 10 percent. These improvements were because IRS devoted additional resources and staff to answering calls, as well as offered overtime to staff after receiving additional funding and allocating user fees. However, IRS does not make customer service information, including average wait time, easily available such as through an online dashboard. Without this information, taxpayers are not well informed on what to expect when they're requesting services from IRS. Accordingly, we recommended that IRS display customer service standards and performance online, and the agency agreed. The second area is customer service for victims of identity theft refund fraud. IRS estimates it paid at least $2 billion identity theft refunds in 2015. Such fraud also burdens honest taxpayers because authenticating their identities can delay processing their returns and their refunds. We found IRS has overall improved aspects of service for victims of this fraud. For example, IRS reduced its backlog of cases and began consolidating inventory and better managing its case flow. However, we did find three things that IRS could further improve. First, IRS's file retrieval and scanning processes contributed to delays and unnecessary document requests. We reviewed a sample of 16 identity theft cases, and in two of those cases it had taken six weeks or more for IRS to retrieve and scan the requested documents, during which time the assisters closed the cases without receiving the documents. This leads to the question whether or not they were even needed. We recommended IRS review its retrieval and scanning procedures for improvements, which IRS agreed to do. Second, we found potential weaknesses in IRS's internal control processes could lead to IRS paying refunds to fraudsters. In discussion groups, IRS assisters and managers told us some assisters may release refunds even if indicators on the account show the tax return was under review for identity theft. We recommended IRS improve its data or collect new data to monitor how and why assisters might be releasing refunds before closing these types of cases. IRS disagreed, stating that the problem was not widespread and current processes are sufficient. However, we maintain the data IRS was using had weaknesses and were not sufficient to make that determination. In response to our draft report, IRS sent us an analysis that they said showed this type of error does occur but may not be as widespread as the discussion group participants suggested. We'll continue to work with IRS on this important issue. Finally, we found IRS does not notify taxpayers when a dependent's identity appears on a fraudulent return. By not doing so, IRS is limiting taxpayers' ability to take action to protect its dependents' identity. We recommended IRS revise notices to victims to include information such as whether dependents were claimed on the fraudulent return, and IRS agreed with this. In summary, as taxpayers file their returns for 2016, it's important that IRS ensures timely, quality service. IRS can increase transparency and accountability by implementing our recommendations to provide performance information, improve file retrieval and scanning, determine how assisters might release refunds, and notify taxpayers when dependents' identities have been used fraudulently. This concludes my prepared remarks, and I'll be happy to answer any questions that you may have. [Prepared statement of Ms. Lucas-Judy follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you all. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Ohio, Mr. Jordan, for five minutes. Mr. Jordan. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Dalrymple, why has taxpayer service at the IRS been terrible? Mr. Dalrymple. Taxpayer service at the IRS has been improving, in fact, I think this year is a perfect example of where taxpayer service could be going forward given the resources necessary ---- Mr. Jordan. Taxpayer advocates said that taxpayer service is the number one most serious problem at the Internal Revenue Service. The current Commissioner, someone who, frankly, I am not a big fan of, said it was ``abysmal.'' Mr. Meadows, the chairman, indicated in his opening comments that 38 percent of the callers asking for assistance, only 38 percent actually got to a representative. Mr. Dalrymple. That was in 2015. In ---- Mr. Jordan. That is why I said why has taxpayer service at the IRS been terrible? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, it's--it was clearly a resource issue, Congress. Mr. Jordan. Resource issue? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Mr. Jordan. Could it be your priorities were misplaced? Could that be a problem? Mr. Dalrymple. I don't think so. I think the real issue here is how the budget actually works. You know, the IRS receives its budget in three specific categories: taxpayer service, enforcement, and operation support. And in order to move money from--between those appropriations, it has to ask for permission from Congress to do so. And in 2015 actually we moved $30 million from enforcement into our taxpayer service operation. So I don't think that's -- -- Mr. Jordan. And you asked Congress for that ---- Mr. Dalrymple. And we asked Congress to do that, and they allowed us to do that. Mr. Jordan. Why didn't you ask for more? Why didn't you ask for it more often ---- Mr. Dalrymple. We had ---- Mr. Jordan.--to offset this terrible performance ---- Mr. Dalrymple. We--if ---- Mr. Jordan.--with 30-minute wait times, only 38 percent actually talk to a representative. Mr. Dalrymple. The ---- Mr. Jordan. Your own Commissioner said it was abysmal. Mr. Dalrymple. It was abysmal. There's not enough money to go around for anything. The audit rates at the IRS have also dropped ---- Mr. Jordan. Well, let's talk about ---- Mr. Dalrymple.--dramatically. It's ---- Mr. Jordan. Let me just give you one example of what I would argue is mismanagement of taxpayer resources at the Internal Revenue Service. You know a gentleman named Terry Milholland? Mr. Dalrymple. I--he was the former CIO. Mr. Jordan. He was former what? Mr. Dalrymple. The former CIO. Mr. Jordan. Chief information officer? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Mr. Jordan. Okay. And was he chief information officer when the IRS targeted conservative groups? Was he functioning in that role at that time? Mr. Dalrymple. I'm not certain when he became CIO. Mr. Jordan. Yes, between 2008 and 2016 he definitely was. Was he chief information officer when Lois Lerner's hard drive crashed? Mr. Dalrymple. I think he probably was. Mr. Jordan. He was. And was he chief information order-- officer, excuse me, when 422 backup tapes were destroyed at the IRS, tapes under subpoena? Mr. Dalrymple. I think he would have been the CIO at that point. Mr. Jordan. Yes. And was he the gentleman who issued the preservation order to not destroy those 422 backup tapes? Mr. Dalrymple. He could have been. Mr. Jordan. He definitely was. I have seen it. And did Mr. Milholland live in Washington, D.C.? Mr. Dalrymple. I'm not sure where Mr. Milholland lived. Mr. Jordan. Yes. He lived in Texas. In fact, in 2015 alone, $55,000 was spent by Mr. Milholland, taxpayer money, for him to commute to Texas, come up here to Washington, and 30 weeks of commuting back and forth, the guy who is in charge of maintaining--keeping the records, the guy who gave the preservation order that wasn't followed, backup tapes destroyed, $55,000, $18,000 for lodging, $7,000 for meals and incidentals, $2,500 for airport parking, 14--$1,100, excuse me, for mileage and toll reimbursement, $1,500 he charged for taxi service. He probably took taxis instead of Uber. Mr. Dalrymple. I'm not sure when Uber even began, Congressman. Mr. Jordan. Well, it was certainly in 2016, 2015. So maybe it is that the IRS doesn't have the priorities in the right place. Do you know what is streamlined critical pay authority, Mr. Dalrymple? Mr. Dalrymple. Streamlined critical pay authority allows the IRS to be able to direct hire skilled individuals that we need to, particularly generally in our IT functions to be able to ---- Mr. Jordan. Allows you to pay them more than they would otherwise get, right, more than the top salary allowed under the pay schedule for Federal work? Mr. Dalrymple. For SES, that's correct. Mr. Jordan. Yes. Was Mr. ---- Mr. Dalrymple. And--but also in addition to that, it allows us to directly hire them quickly because these people ---- Mr. Jordan. Okay, quickly. Mr. Dalrymple.--have skills that don't ---- Mr. Jordan. You hired this guy quickly, but he couldn't move here in eight years. He still lived in Texas charging in one year alone $55,000, couldn't take Uber, took a taxi instead. Was Mr. Milholland getting critical pay? Mr. Dalrymple. I believe he was. Mr. Jordan. I know he was, right? So he was getting paid more than any other Federal worker, couldn't live here, $55,000 in one year, hanging out at the Hyatt, taking taxis, reimburse him for everything you can imagine it looks like here. And while he is the chief technology officer, the guy who is critically important, we have got to pay more than we pay anyone else in the Federal Government under his watch, the chief technology officer, Lerner's hard drive crashes, 422 backup tapes are destroyed even though he personally gave the preservation order to preserve all communication. And here is the kicker: He purchased some $12 million email archiving system that these guys at GAO said he never even implemented, $12 million just thrown down the drain. And you are telling me that it is improving and it wasn't pathetic and it wasn't terrible? Mr. Dalrymple. You asked me about the taxpayer service activities, not about the IT organization. And by the way, they don't work for me. Mr. Jordan. Was this taxpayer dollars that were used for Mr. Milholland? Mr. Dalrymple. I assume that they would have been, of course ---- Mr. Jordan. Of course, right? Mr. Dalrymple.--appropriated dollars. Mr. Jordan. And you just told me you can ask to have money transferred and that we have already given the authority to do that in situations to actually better serve the taxpayers. All I am saying is it could be priorities are a little out of place at the IRS, and that is contributing to the pathetic taxpayer treatment, customer service, or lack of customer service that the hardworking taxpayers of this country have been receiving. I went over time, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate the indulgence. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Connolly, for five minutes. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair, and I would ask ---- Mr. Meadows. A generous five minutes. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair. I ask that my opening statement be entered into the record without objection. Mr. Meadows. Without objection. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair. Welcome to the panel. Well, in listening to my friend Mr. Jordan--and I will say this underscores for me why it makes sense to have the seat of government here in Washington and limit some of this remote location for some of our key hires. Why was Mr. Milholland traveling back and forth from Texas, Ms. Lucas-Judy? Mr. Dalrymple. I really don't know what Mr. Milholland's arrangement was with the IRS. Mr. Connolly. Do you know, Ms. Lucas-Judy? Ms. Lucas-Judy. No, I don't. Mr. Connolly. Okay. Mr. Martin? Mr. Martin. No, I do not. Mr. Connolly. Okay. I guess I want to shift the subject a little bit to the--well, the budget and the IT budget in particular, which you brought up, Mr. Dalrymple. Ms. Lucas- Judy, how much has IRS budget been cut in the last six or seven years, about $1 billion or more? Ms. Lucas-Judy. It's been about--a decline of about $900 million. Mr. Connolly. I am sorry? Ms. Lucas-Judy. About $900 million since 2011 I believe. Mr. Connolly. Okay. And how many--in terms of numbers of personnel, what has been the reduction or increase net? Ms. Lucas-Judy. I don't have the precise figures. I'd be happy to get those to you. But I know it's--the number of full- time equivalents has gone down across ---- Mr. Connolly. Rather significantly, has it not? Ms. Lucas-Judy. Yes. Mr. Connolly. Do you know, Mr. Martin? Mr. Martin. I would agree it's gone down rather ---- Mr. Connolly. No, I am not asking ---- Mr. Martin.--but I don't have the--I don't have a specific number. Mr. Connolly. Mr. Dalrymple, do you know? I can't hear you, sir. Mr. Dalrymple. Seventeen thousand employees over that span. Mr. Connolly. Fewer? Mr. Dalrymple. Fewer. Mr. Connolly. Net? Mr. Dalrymple. Net. Mr. Connolly. Seventeen thousand. Well, that is a number worth GAO's attention, Ms. Lucas-Judy. I mean, it is has not just gone down a bit. Seventeen thousand by any account is a lot. Ms. Lucas-Judy. Yes, and that is something that GAO has noted in a number of our reports, and we are looking at ---- Mr. Connolly. But, I mean--but isn't that ---- Ms. Lucas-Judy.--capital management ---- Mr. Connolly. Isn't that about 20 percent of the workforce? Ms. Lucas-Judy. Yes. Mr. Connolly. Well, that is a lot of people. And your budget has gone down almost by $1 billion. I mean, even if everyone whistled while they work, I would think those kinds of reductions might have some effect on productivity and on the ability to provide high-quality customer service. Fair statement, Ms. Lucas-Judy? Ms. Lucas-Judy. Yes, sir. Mr. Connolly. From a management point of view. Now, sometimes we do more with less. Sometimes we make ourselves more efficient. But when I look at IRS, given the, you know, unceasing war on the IRS and the constant drumbeat about Lois Lerner and the so-called attack on certain political orientation of various organizations, it has all seemingly been a justification for gutting the IRS, an agency we don't like because it is big and it is the vehicle that finances the enterprise, which we also apparently don't like. Would you say, Mr. Dalrymple, that these cuts have had an appreciable effect on the ability of the IRS to fully perform its mission? Mr. Dalrymple. Absolutely. Taxpayer service has been in some instances abysmal. I mean, the Commissioner was right about that. We haven't been able to answer the telephones when we should. We haven't been able to answer correspondence as--at the speed we should. We haven't been able to develop online services at the rate we should for taxpayers. Our audit rates are down dramatically. Our collection--our collections are down over time. There ---- Mr. Connolly. Just speaking of collection so people understand, how much money is left on the table do we estimate every year really owed to the government but not collected because of lack of resources? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, the tax gap is estimated at about $450 billion, and that's just ---- Mr. Connolly. A year? Mr. Dalrymple. A year. Mr. Connolly. Wow. That is a lot of money. Okay. One thinks about what one could do with that amount of money if you had it. And on the IT side, last time we looked at this I want to say the average age of computers at the IRS was about seven years. I assume it is now older. Is that about right, Mr. Dalrymple? Mr. Dalrymple. I can't comment on that. I'm not a--I'm not familiar enough ---- Mr. Connolly. Ms. Lucas-Judy, do you know? Ms. Lucas-Judy. I do know that we have recommended that IRS needs to modernize a lot of it systems ---- Mr. Connolly. Right. Ms. Lucas-Judy.--that that will go a long way towards helping the organization. Mr. Connolly. But, I mean, if you are replacing computers every seven or eight years, that is not the industry standard. The industry standard is more like two to three years, is that right? Ms. Lucas-Judy. Right. And they are relying a lot on legacy systems. Mr. Connolly. Correct. And so--that is right, on top of that. So part of the problem, what could go wrong with that? Well, a lot of hard drive crashes like that which occurred in the IRS that was certainly the focus of hearings in this committee, is that not correct? Ms. Lucas-Judy. I'm not--I have not looked at that specific instance. Mr. Connolly. Well, I am not asking about that specific instance. I am generally saying when computers are that old and ---- Ms. Lucas-Judy. They do become unreliable. Mr. Connolly. Right. And we have problems. And the guidance in some parts of the IRS anyhow--correct me if I am wrong--was in order to archive material, the instructions were print and save. Ever hear of that, Mr. Dalrymple? Mr. Dalrymple. I have, and that's ---- Mr. Connolly. That is astounding. And we have, what, 81,000 employees, something like that? Mr. Dalrymple. Something in that neighborhood ---- Mr. Connolly. Yes. Mr. Dalrymple.--including all of the full-time folks plus temporaries and seasonal ---- Mr. Connolly. Right. Mr. Dalrymple.--et cetera. Mr. Connolly. And we have got data on every single tax filer, which is several hundred million, right? Mr. Dalrymple. That's correct. Mr. Connolly. So what could go wrong with that? So at the very least, hopefully, we here in Congress, if we are concerned about customer service, if we are concerned about the very issues that have been cited, maybe we could make a smart investment in IT to make the IRS more efficient, doing more with less, and we can close that gap of the amount of money owed but not collected, my shorthand, I think obviously could make an appreciable difference in financing other investments, including the new President's defense initiative, which is $54 billion, a small part of the $450 billion you referred to. So with that I yield back. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Jordan. [Presiding] Mr. Martin, just real quick, my good friend from Virginia said the so-called targeting. When TIGTA did its report, did it use the term so-called or did it say targeting took place at the IRS? Mr. Martin. We said inappropriate criteria was used. Mr. Jordan. Okay. I appreciate that. I appreciate that. The gentleman from Georgia is recognized. Mr. Hice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Dalrymple, let me just go with you here. I am shocked-- actually, not shocked. Probably all of us have experienced these kind of statistics with the IRS, but in 2015, less than 10 percent of the callers whose returns were flagged as suspicious for possible identity theft, less than 10 percent were able to get through an IRS helpline. What is that number now? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, our levels of service right now on our helplines is right around 80 percent. We're scheduling about 75 percent for this filing season and about 70 percent overall. Mr. Hice. More than 60 percent could not get through the National Taxpayer Advocate phoneline that is the safety net. What is that figure now? Mr. Dalrymple. I have no idea what the--what it is. Mr. Hice. In 2015 the IRS received more calls than ever. Is that true? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. And the reason for that--that's true is because people call back over and over if they can't get through so ---- Mr. Hice. Okay. Well, it doesn't matter to me what the reason is but they received more calls than ever and answered fewer calls ---- Mr. Dalrymple. That's correct. Mr. Hice.--than ever. Do you know what official time is? Mr. Dalrymple. I do know what official time is. Mr. Hice. Do you have any idea how many people with the IRS are on official time? Mr. Dalrymple. I couldn't tell you that number. I have no idea. Mr. Hice. Could you get that number and provide it for me? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes, we can. Mr. Hice. All right. I would like a divided in those that are 100 percent ---- Mr. Dalrymple. Sure. Mr. Hice.--versus those that are part-time. Mr. Dalrymple. Absolutely. Mr. Hice. Thank you for that. Mr. Hice. In 2012, our reports show that the IRS approved 62 people to be 100 percent on official time as contact service representatives. These are people answering phones, that type of thing, approved 62. I am assuming that is 62 more than what perhaps were on official time before. Now, official time means that they are hired to do IRS work but they end up doing union work. In 2012 you had 62 of them that you approved who were customer service reps that went to 100 percent. In addition to that, there were another 70 that were approved for other IRS jobs. Any idea how many phone calls those 62 people could have answered? Mr. Dalrymple. I couldn't tell you that. I ---- Mr. Hice. Our calculations show that those 62 people could have answered approximately 11,000 phone calls a week. That is over half-a-million phone calls a year, and yet you were not able to answer phone calls. People were waiting in line. And I am quite confident that there are more people on official time now at the IRS then there were five years ago. Is that a fair assessment? Mr. Dalrymple. I have no idea how many people were on official time. Mr. Hice. Okay. But we are going to find out that, and like I said, I'm confident. Was there any discussion during 2015 on those who were on official time 100 percent of their time--was there any discussion saying that a crisis was underway of getting people who are on official time to come off and go back to work? Mr. Dalrymple. No. That's governed by our union contract. So no, there was no discussion ---- Mr. Hice. So who allows these people to go on official time to begin with? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, if they're in a position--a specific position with the union that allows for them to be on 100 percent official time, that's governed by our union contract. Mr. Hice. So you have no say-so--no one at the IRS has any say-so whatsoever as to how many people are on official time? Mr. Dalrymple. We have--they have to justify their official time based on the amount of time that they're expected ---- Mr. Hice. And you are not able to justify your reason for them not to be on official time because you have a crisis with people not being able to get in to the IRS? Mr. Dalrymple. I have to say I'm not familiar enough with the union contract to be able to say that we couldn't move them to work status ---- Mr. Hice. So so far as you know there is no mechanism in place for the IRS to retrieve people who are on official time to come back to work? Mr. Dalrymple. I'm not aware--it's possible that the union contract allows for that but I'm not certain. Mr. Hice. Don't you think that might be something to be certain of if there is such a catastrophe where people are not able to get answers? Mr. Dalrymple. I think that it's probably something I should know but I don't. Mr. Hice. I think it probably is, too. I have just got a couple of seconds left. You know, we hear of these kind of issues over and over, and the IRS has come before this Congress, this committee over and over, and always the answer is we need more resources. I am absolutely convinced the IRS does not need--you don't have a resource problem; you have a waste problem. You have got people right there who were hired to do the job who are going off doing union work rather than the job for which they were paid to do. That seems awfully wasteful to me on the backs of taxpayers and on the backs of people who need answers to their tax returns. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Thank you. Mr. Jordan. I thank the gentleman. I now recognize the gentleman from Illinois for his five minutes of questions. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Dalrymple, after your experience here, are you still planning to retire in two weeks? Mr. Dalrymple. If not earlier. [Laughter.] Mr. Dalrymple. Just kidding. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Well, in any case, thank you all for coming today. I know this is not a--I think it is always useful to have a feedback loop and obviously this hearing is part of that process. Look, as a former small business owner, I too have struggled to consistently obtain quality, timely customer service from the agency. I don't think this is just merely one or two data points. I think that there are a lot of people who have struggled at times. But I hope and believe that you want to do your best to improve the level of service there. One question I have is, you know, does the IRS survey taxpayers to better understand, you know, their concerns? And if so, how does that process work? Mr. Dalrymple. We do survey taxpayers and on a fairly regular basis. We've surveyed taxpayers individually, we survey practitioners. So we do a fair amount of survey work and have for quite some time, in fact, that is how we have focused our whole view of what the future of the IRS should look like in the work that we're doing so we know what taxpayers want and need and how they want to get that information, et cetera. We have that information available to us. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. But do you do the survey or do you have third parties do these surveys? Mr. Dalrymple. We get them through surveys we do ourselves. We get them through surveys that are done for us. So we have multiple ways of getting that information and data. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. And these percentages that you folks quote, the 70, 80 percent, and so forth, who actually completes--how is that percentage computed? Mr. Dalrymple. It's a model that we've--we have that we've agreed with our auditors on in terms of how it is calculated. It goes back, you know, almost 20 years. And so, yes, it's a model that we use. We know exactly how--what our demand is, how many people try to get in, how many people weren't able to get in, how many people got cut off, et cetera. All that goes into the level of service number that I've mentioned. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Right. Let me just suggest that perhaps you folks may want to take another look at this model of how you survey taxpayers to determine what is really underlying their concerns, you know, what is working, what is not working, and with regard to what is working, learning from those best practices. What is not working, we have to kind of deal with it. And I know from personal experience as a former small business owner, as well as people I have worked with, you know, there is just a kind of a--how do I say it--kind of a frustration that they are not being heard sometimes. And so I think I respectfully submit that perhaps you should go back and take a look at these customer survey methodologies, as well as those percentages that you compute, because I am not sure that they are consistent with how people perceive the IRS. And I think that if you did that, it might be, you know, a salutary benefit for all of us really. Ms. Lucas-Judy, I have a question. Do you folks kind of try to get a sense of what are the best practices of the IRS and, you know, how to learn from them? Ms. Lucas-Judy. One of the things you're talking about, the customer service in looking at surveys and models, one of the things that we have recommended for a long time that IRS do is compare its phone service with best in the business ---- Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Right. Right. Ms. Lucas-Judy.--you know, try to do some sort of benchmarking. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Right. Ms. Lucas-Judy. Initially, when we made the recommendation, IRS did not agree with it. They thought that, okay, they're the only ones who provide that kind of service ---- Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Right. Ms. Lucas-Judy.--and there's nobody really comparable out there to look at. But I'm pleased to say that in working with IRS over the last couple of years on this, they've come around and decided that it actually would be worthwhile to do a benchmarking study. And, in fact, they completed the study and we're reviewing it now to try to see-- because you can never get to 100 percent. You would love to be able to answer 100 percent of the calls, never have anybody get a busy signal, but that's not realistic. And so we were hoping that they can look at what other industries do to figure out what is a good level of service, what is a good target to strive for. Mr. Krishnamoorthi. Yes, I think it is really important to borrow from what we learn in the private sector about benchmarking against the best practices out there for customer service and just generally, you know, how do you handle such a large volume of calls and make sure that people are treated fairly, with respect, with dignity and responsiveness? And so if you leave with anything today, I would just respectfully submit that there has to be a bigger emphasis on that going forward because at this time, I mean, given how people perceive government and the IRS, we can't afford for them to--their trust to further erode. And so I would respectfully, you know, request you folks to really take a hard look at this and do some soul-searching on this. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Jordan. The gentleman from Michigan is recognized. Mr. Mitchell. Thank you. And, Mr. Dalrymple, first let me wish you well in your retirement. I hope it goes well for you, sir. Let me ask you, in 2016, Commissioner Koskinen testified that as he computed, the return investment for enforcement operations is roughly $4 for every $1 spent on enforcement. Can you enlighten the committee as to how that calculation was made? Because I understand that the number was thrown out there but there is no description of how that calculation was--that return investment was calculated. Mr. Dalrymple. Actually, I'd be happy to get the calculation and submit it back to the record. I can't describe it specifically, but basically let me give some general ---- Mr. Mitchell. Well, rather than take up a lot of time, if you would submit that to the committee, that would be appreciated. I have questions, and rather than tie them up ---- Mr. Dalrymple. Sure. Certainly. Mr. Mitchell. I would like to see that. That would be--I am a business guy like my colleague from Illinois and would like to know how--I believe return investment matters. Mr. Dalrymple. Just a small point on that, it's a compendium, so some things we have $15 or $20 to $1 return, some we have $3 or $4 to $1 return, et cetera. So it's a compendium and we can get you that information. Mr. Mitchell. Have you done a similar analysis in terms of return investment for customer service spending? And what is that number? Mr. Dalrymple. We've had a very difficult time finding any way to measure that. We've tried over the years, but to be honest, we've never come up with a legitimate measure of return on investment for service activities. Mr. Mitchell. Okay. Enforcement comprises about 43 percent of your budget as of this year, $11.2 billion, which is roughly $5 billion just doing quick a government math. You spoke of moving $30 million from enforcement to customer service. Mr. Dalrymple. Right. Mr. Mitchell. With all due respect, I mean, of a budget of $5 billion for enforcement, moving $30 million is like the light bill for the week. I mean do we really seriously think that is going to make an impact on it--from business, $30 million of $5 billion isn't much. Mr. Dalrymple. Well, it's $30 million against a $2 billion budget for taxpayer service, so it's a bigger percentage for them. Having said that, though, it's not a huge amount. It's what was necessary to reach certain levels of either inventory or levels of service on the phone, et cetera. So we had the additional $290 million that Congress gave us, which $178 million of it was dedicated to taxpayer service. We had some monies from user fees that we put into taxpayer services, and then in addition to that we still had a shortfall in terms of where we wanted to be in terms of levels of service, and we were able to move another $30 million out of enforcement into taxpayer service. Now ---- Mr. Mitchell. And even after moving the money, you still end up with significant shortfalls of reasonable customer service response. Mr. Dalrymple. Well, for this year, as I said, we're very close to--we're between 75 and 80 percent on our telephone level of service. Our inventories and correspondence are the lowest they've been in four years. Generally speaking, taxpayer services here is the best it's been in the last five or six years. And I can't really speak prior to that. Mr. Mitchell. Well, let me suggest that--I mean, part of the frustration that my colleagues noted about the reputation of the IRS is the difficulty people have, as you have already heard, getting someone to answer the phone. Now, for the world of the private sector, we actually had standards of that. Mr. Dalrymple. Right. Mr. Mitchell. Calls were answered in three to four rings. In fact, we actually had secret shoppers that went around and shopped it to see if calls were answered, and when they were answered, did they get their questions responded to. Mr. Dalrymple. Right. Mr. Mitchell. It seems to me that you haven't set the same kinds of standards that we would expect in the private business world. Mr. Dalrymple. We actually do some of that. We have quality reviewers that shop the lines, listen for responses, whether they're correct or not. You know, we are not in business for a profit so we don't really want to answer the telephone in--on the first or second ring because what that means is you are actually waiting for the next call to come in. Mr. Mitchell. Well, what is your standard for answering the phone? Mr. Dalrymple. We would love to be at about an 85 to 86 percent level of service, which would mean basically that people were waiting less than a minute or two to get the next assister on the line. Mr. Mitchell. Now, I am new here ---- Mr. Dalrymple. And we've been there before. We have achieved that in the past. Mr. Mitchell. When were you there last? Mr. Dalrymple. In the--you know, I--just a little history here. I left the--I retired from the service before in 2006. Mr. Mitchell. And you came back? Mr. Dalrymple. And I came back. I was asked to come back. I was also--at one point in time the Commissioner Wage and Investment Division, which handles all of our telephone services. When I was Commissioner of the Wage and Investment Division, our telephone service was in the high 80s, and at that point in time we started to drift into the high 90s. We actually found out that we had employees waiting for the next call, which is not an efficient way for a government to run their telephone systems. So about 85 to 87 percent we found out was really the right place to be if we could get our telephone service to that level. Mr. Mitchell. Well, my time is expired. I thank the chair. And let me wish you well again in your retirement, sir. Mr. Dalrymple. Thank you. Mr. Mitchell. Thank you. Mr. Dalrymple. I appreciate that. Mr. Mitchell. I yield back. Mr. Jordan. The gentleman from Florida is recognized. Mr. DeSantis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Dalrymple, the news just broke this afternoon that two years after the fact the IRS has located almost 7,000 documents that are related to the targeting of conservative groups. Are you familiar with those documents? Mr. Dalrymple. I am not. Mr. DeSantis. Are you familiar with the news report? Mr. Dalrymple. I am not. Mr. DeSantis. We would like to know on our committee if you can get us an answer ---- Mr. Dalrymple. Sure. Mr. DeSantis.--whether those are documents that have previously been provided to this committee or to other committees in the Congress ---- Mr. Dalrymple. I'll find that out. Mr. DeSantis.--because we went through this for years and years and there were a lot of emails that were destroyed, there were backup tapes, and it was really, really frustrating to do that experience. Mr. DeSantis. We have asked, a number of us on the committee, for the President to make a change at the IRS to really bring in some new blood so we can start reforming the agency. And the targeting was one of the issues and how the agency responded to that, but there is also issues that we see about really a contempt for the taxpayer. I mean, the agency will go and they will, you know, try to get taxpayers dead to rights on producing their taxes and all this other stuff, but then you have employees--you had a single IRS employee that spent, according to a Senate Committee on Finance report, spent $43,000 staying at the Ritz-Carlton in Pentagon City. How is that acceptable? Mr. Dalrymple. I'm not familiar with a report that says that we had an IRS employee that spent $43,000 staying at the Ritz-Carlton. Mr. DeSantis. It was over the course of a year. It was a lot of stays obviously, but that is the ---- Mr. Dalrymple. Well, I have to assume that the Ritz-Carlton was offering government rate per diem at that location is all I can assume, but I don't know the particulars around that. Mr. DeSantis. Well, it would be the type of thing that I think it would be tough for that to have been the most appropriate thing. You also had--again, this is the same report, the Senate Finance Committee, IRS employee rented a $1 million townhome in Arlington for almost $5,000 a month with tax dollars. I mean, how is that acceptable? Mr. Dalrymple. Again, I'm not really familiar with that. Mr. DeSantis. Okay. Well, this is I think frustrating for us. And I know there are a lot of taxpayers that they don't feel that they always get the benefit of the doubt from the IRS. In fact, when Congress reduced the budget for the IRS in response to the targeting, there was a major drop-off in customer service. It was very difficult for the people, the taxpayers to get through. So the bureaucracy was really not affected. It was all put on the taxpayer. And you had people that really couldn't get their questions answered, and that obviously has a lot of effects for our economy and for their well-being. Ms. Lucas-Judy, let me ask you this. What are the metrics that the IRS uses to assess customer service, to measure it? Ms. Lucas-Judy. The primary one is the one we've been talking about, the telephone level of service, but they also for correspondence--for paper correspondence they track the percentage of--the backlog. They track the percentage that are what they call over-age, so those that are 45 days or older. They track the traffic to the different services that they provide online, as well as ---- Mr. DeSantis. Does it track whether people are satisfied with their level of service? Ms. Lucas-Judy. That I think would be a question that I would defer to Mr. Dalrymple. Mr. Dalrymple. Actually, we do--we survey every taxpayer that we have contact with on a satisfaction survey, so the answer is yes, we do. Mr. DeSantis. Okay. And so you keep--do you know what percentage of callers are satisfied? Mr. Dalrymple. Actually, the number's quite high so--but I don't know what it is off the top of my head, but I could get that for you. Mr. DeSantis. Okay. Mr. DeSantis. Now, did we satisfactorily answer your question? Is that kind of the way you go about it in terms of customer service? Mr. Dalrymple. It's a series of questions that try to get at how satisfied the taxpayer was with the interaction that they had. Mr. DeSantis. Ms. Lucas-Judy, what are the GAO recommendations, if any, about--are there other metrics that can be used so that the IRS can better understand the issue with customer service? Ms. Lucas-Judy. Well, we've made a number of recommendations, including that they have a comprehensive customer service strategy to help them determine overall among telephones, correspondence, walk-in, online, what they're looking for ideally and what's the most efficient, most effective way to get to that. We've also made recommendations that they have other metrics for correspondence, that they include performance targets for their correspondence. And in addition, we've got some recommendations--we've made some suggestions to Congress that would help IRS as well in terms of having authority to adjust or correct math errors that they see. Mr. DeSantis. Great. My time is up. Mr. Chairman, these emails, we need the answers on those emails ---- Mr. Jordan. Sure do. Mr. DeSantis.--and see, were they responsive to us then not provided? And they may have been provided because this is in the context of a FOIA suit with Judicial Watch, but even within the context of that FOIA suit, this is two years late where they said they didn't have them and now all of a sudden they are producing them. And so ---- Mr. Jordan. No, we will ---- Mr. DeSantis.--that obviously is troubling. I yield back. Mr. Jordan. Well, sir, I thank the gentleman for raising that issue and the others. Do you need congressional authority to move user fee dollars around, Mr. Dalrymple? Mr. Dalrymple. No, that authority was granted to us back in the '90s to be able to use that ---- Mr. Jordan. You can use it wherever you want? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Mr. Jordan. You can use it on customer service? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Mr. Jordan. Did you focus in on customer service or were some of those user fees moved over to implement the Affordable Care Act? Mr. Dalrymple. We used--we did have to use user fees for the Affordable Care Act, FATCA, the FAST Act, the PATH Act, the HTCs, the human--HCTC. We've had a number of ---- Mr. Jordan. But of those acts, which one would you have used more--which one was probably the bigger hurdle or the one that required most of the user fee dollars? Would it be the Affordable Care Act? Mr. Dalrymple. It would be a guess for me to answer that. I can find out for certain ---- Mr. Jordan. Well, give me your best guess. You have worked there a few years. Mr. Dalrymple. I would guess--I would have guessed it would have been the ACA. Mr. Jordan. Yes, so would I. So would I. So that could have contributed to the terrible customer service that taxpayers were receiving. You mentioned earlier that ---- Mr. Dalrymple. But that's a legislative mandate. Mr. Jordan. No, I understand. Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Mr. Jordan. I understand. Mr. Dalrymple. Okay. Mr. Jordan. Yes. The ability to use the user fees or the ACA or both? Mr. Dalrymple. Both. Mr. Jordan. Right. I understand that. But the ACA is one I didn't vote for. Mr. Dalrymple. I can't ---- Mr. Jordan. I didn't vote for the user fee, the ability to move the user fees because I wasn't here. Mr. Dalrymple. I appreciate that. Okay. Mr. Jordan. You mentioned earlier that the budget has been reduced at the IRS and that, as a result of that, there is 17,000 less people working at the IRS. Is that accurate? Mr. Dalrymple. That's accurate, yes. Mr. Jordan. Okay. I mean, that is reflecting your testimony in an accurate way, I think. What time frame are you talking about, that 17,000? Mr. Dalrymple. I believe that's between 2010 and 2016. Mr. Jordan. And that 17,000 were because you received fewer dollars in your budget. Were those people let go? Were they fired? Were they said, dismissed? Mr. Dalrymple. Most of them were either--have retired and not hired behind or we didn't bring as many temporary or seasonal employees on because that's ---- Mr. Jordan. So no one was actually told to hit the road? Mr. Dalrymple. We did--there was no riff if that's what you're asking. Mr. Jordan. That is exactly what I am asking. Mr. Dalrymple. No, not to my knowledge. Mr. Jordan. Okay. Mr. Dalrymple. Again, I didn't report back to the IRS until 2013, but I don't believe there was a riff. Mr. Jordan. So people retired, you just didn't rehire? Mr. Dalrymple. That's right. Mr. Jordan. Okay. Mr. Dalrymple. Or hire people that would have come back from a seasonal job, so that is a bit different. If you're a seasonal employee with us, we don't have to offer your season back to you, and in instances like that ---- Mr. Jordan. No, I understand. You probably hire a few more people at tax season than other times of the year I can guess. Mr. Dalrymple. A lot more, yes. Mr. Jordan. Right. I get that. Okay. If he is ready, we will get Mr. Grothman. We will just be at ease for a second while we wait for the gentleman from Wisconsin to come back. Is Glenn coming? The gentleman from Wisconsin is recognized. Mr. Grothman. I know, you know, you certainly keep track of the quality of your folks and I hope you do. Years ago, I used to do taxes. And at the time not just me, other people felt compared to the Wisconsin Department of Revenue, because obviously we dealt with them both, that if you talk to your guys on the phone, they weren't always the sharpest. They didn't know their own laws. You know, you would call them three times and you would get three different answers. Well, you call them twice, you get two different answers anyway. Do you monitor the quality of your folks? I haven't done taxes for 20 years, but do you have an opinion as to whether your folks know what the law is? Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Actually, we do monitor their--every call is--can be monitored. We have a quality review system that statistically selects calls at random for quality assurance, and during that process, we determine whether--one of the main things we're looking for is did the taxpayer get the correct answer. And actually, we do quite well there. So if you get through to us, you're going to get pretty high quality. Mr. Grothman. Has it improved over time? Mr. Dalrymple. It's really been pretty stable over time, in the high 90 percent rage. Mr. Grothman. How long have you been monitoring it? Mr. Dalrymple. At least 20 years. And 20 years ago it was actually quite low. Probably for the last 10 or 15 years it's been quite high. Mr. Grothman. Better than 20 years ago, you have improved. Some of the stuff they want to know here is the amount that can be spent traveling by employees and, you know, it says here Federal employees can spend over $7,000 per month on lodging. Do you keep track of that or what is your travel policy for your people when they get around? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, first--well, travel policy isn't set by the IRS; it's set by--you know, government-wide by ---- Mr. Grothman. Right, right, I understand. Mr. Dalrymple.--the GSA. So we do monitor, and we actually monitor how many people are traveling at any time and how long they're traveling. And we don't generally have very many people traveling for extended periods unless they're on some project. But that's typically what we monitor. Mr. Grothman. And how does it work? If somebody goes out there for a week or whatever, I mean, how much are they allowed to spend? Who determines where they stay, that sort of thing? Mr. Dalrymple. It's based on the per diem rate, so if they find a place to stay within the per diem rates, then, you know, they're--we don't ask them, you know, where they're staying or prohibit them from staying in places that are within those ---- Mr. Grothman. Okay. Mr. Dalrymple.--rates. Mr. Grothman. I am going to give you a more open-ended question, and any one of you can answer it. And in part I think of the earned income tax credit, but in any event, people are always--you know, have ideas how to use the tax code for more and more things. Hopefully, this time around we use it for less and less, but historically, Congress always liked to use it for more and more. And I sometimes think when Congressmen propose things, they don't think how it is going to look to the Internal Revenue Service who has to deal with it, like somebody once came up with the earned income tax credit and they apparently didn't think of the fact that if you fill out a form and get a $5,000 check, fill out an easy form, a lot of people will take a crack at it, which is why the fraud is so high. But do you have any comments on the earned income tax credit? Or are there any other parts of the tax forms that you feel invites cheating or I guess I would say would require you to spend a lot more on compliance than you would want to? Mr. Dalrymple. Anything that is a refundable credit has always been a challenge for the Internal Revenue Service so whether it's the earned income tax credit or the advanced child tax credit, anything that actually is refundable back to the taxpayer. And by the way, there are corporate refundable credits, too. They're not just to individuals. Mr. Grothman. Right. Mr. Dalrymple. They cause us difficulty from a compliance standpoint. Mr. Grothman. Okay. So when you retire and run for Congress, you are going to take a swing at these things? Mr. Dalrymple. I am not running for Congress. Mr. Grothman. Oh. But you would take a swing at these things? Mr. Dalrymple. I don't know that I'd take a swing at them because, you know, there are reasons for them I understand. But from a tax standpoint they are challenging. Mr. Grothman. From a compliance standpoint they require a lot of your resources, and the reason they require a lot of your resources is they invite fraud, right? Mr. Dalrymple. They invite confusion and fraud both. Ms. Lucas-Judy. The GAO has reported that EITC does have a very high improper payment rate, and part of the reason for that is the complexity of the credit itself. And it's also self-reported. Mr. Grothman. Right. It would be easy if one wanted to cheat to try to cheat, right? Mr. Dalrymple. Right. Ms. Lucas-Judy. That's one of the reasons I think that IRS does audit--a lot of audits of EITC returns. Mr. Grothman. What happens when you find somebody has gotten a few thousand dollars they shouldn't get? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, what we try to do is actually find out that before they get the money back, so we do--most of those audits that were referred to are pre-refund audits. We do over 300,000 of those every year, so we're stopping the refund from going out on the front end. It's very, very unlikely to get an EITC refund back if it's given to a taxpayer. Mr. Grothman. Once it is out, it is gone, huh? Mr. Dalrymple. It is very difficult to get it back at that point. Mr. Grothman. Do you ever try to do anything with those people? Mr. Dalrymple. I'm sorry? Mr. Grothman. Do you ever try to do anything with those people? I mean ---- Mr. Dalrymple. Yes ---- Mr. Grothman.--if somebody--if it is very apparent that somebody is claiming a credit they shouldn't get, does anything happen to the people who do that? Mr. Dalrymple. Well, actually, we bar them from getting the credit then afterwards. The other thing that would be incredibly helpful would be to have correctible error authority around earned income tax credit in terms--because we have to do examinations on all of these. If we had correctible error authority, the process would be much easier to stop the refunds when we saw them. Mr. Grothman. What does that mean, correctible error authority? Mr. Dalrymple. It means that when it's an obvious error on the return, we can actually reverse the credit that's being asked for as opposed to having to do a full examination to be able to stop the credit. Mr. Grothman. Okay. I know my chairman is indulging me, but you know I love this committee. Mr. Jordan. That is good. Mr. Grothman. I will give you one more--can I have one more question? Mr. Jordan. You sure can. Mr. Grothman. If there is one business, refundable business tax credit or one corporate tax credit, refundable credit that you feel is prone to be given erroneously, what would it be, if something comes to mind? You mentioned it is not just earned income tax credit; there are business credits, too. Mr. Dalrymple. I can't think of one off the top of my head, but I'd be happy to come back to you with ---- Mr. Grothman. Yes, think of some so we can--yes. And how many of the EITCs percentagewise did you guys review do you think are fraudulent or erroneous? I should put it that way. Mr. Dalrymple. Yes. Because--the point that my colleague from the GAO made is this is an incredibly complex law for a very unsophisticated group of taxpayers. And so a lot of the mistakes made are not necessarily fraudulent. They are honest mistakes. And then the other thing that you've got here are not normal nuclear families, so determining who has the ability to claim the dependent, et cetera, all those things are incredibly difficult in this environment. Mr. Grothman. You are a nice man, Mr. Dalrymple, but I think you are naive. I think they do it on purpose. But ---- Mr. Dalrymple. Yes, I don't know that many people would call me that, but I appreciate that actually. Mr. Grothman. You are a nice guy, as we say. Okay. Thank you much. Mr. Jordan. Let the record show the gentleman kept us waiting and still got eight minutes of questioning. [Laughter.] Mr. Jordan. Let me thank our witnesses. And, Mr. Dalrymple, we want to wish you the best in your retirement. Mr. Dalrymple. Thank you. Mr. Jordan. Thank you for being here on this important subject and for the important work that you do in uncovering what has been happening at the IRS. I would ask unanimous consent that members have five legislative days to submit questions for the record. Without objection, so ordered. The subcommittees stand adjourned. Mr. Dalrymple. Thank you. [Whereupon, at 4:33 p.m., the subcommittees were adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]