Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- HEARING ON THE 2020 CENSUS [House Hearing, 115 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] HEARING ON THE 2020 CENSUS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ OCTOBER 12, 2017 __________ Serial No. 115-58 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://oversight.house.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 30-245 PDF WASHINGTON : 2018 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Trey Gowdy, South Carolina, Chairman John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Elijah E. Cummings, Maryland, Darrell E. Issa, California Ranking Minority Member Jim Jordan, Ohio Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Justin Amash, Michigan Columbia Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts Blake Farenthold, Texas Jim Cooper, Tennessee Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia Thomas Massie, Kentucky Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Mark Meadows, North Carolina Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Ron DeSantis, Florida Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Dennis A. Ross, Florida Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Mark Walker, North Carolina Val Butler Demings, Florida Rod Blum, Iowa Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois Jody B. Hice, Georgia Jamie Raskin, Maryland Steve Russell, Oklahoma Peter Welch, Vermont Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Matt Cartwright, Pennsylvania Will Hurd, Texas Mark DeSaulnier, California Gary J. Palmer, Alabama Jimmy Gomez, Maryland James Comer, Kentucky Paul Mitchell, Michigan Greg Gianforte, Montana Sheria Clarke, Staff Director Robert Borden, Deputy Staff Director William McKenna, General Counsel Patrick Hartobey, Counsel Kiley Bidelman, Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on October 12, 2017................................. 1 WITNESSES Panel I: The Honorable Wilbur L. Ross, Jr., Secretary, U.S. Department of Commerce Oral Statement............................................... 6 Written Statement............................................ 9 Panel II: Mr. Robert Goldenkoff, Director of Strategic Issues, Census Issues, U.S. Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 41 Joint Written Statement from Mr. Goldenkoff and Mr. Powner... 43 Mr. David A. Powner, Director of Information Technology Management Issues, U.S. Government Accountability Office Oral Statement............................................... 84 Ms. Carol N. Rice, Assistant Inspector General, Office of Economic and Statistical Program Assessment, U.S. Department of Commerce Oral Statement............................................... 85 Written Statement............................................ 87 Ms. Vanita Gupta, President and CEO, The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights Oral Statement............................................... 96 Written Statement............................................ 98 APPENDIX Opening Statement of Mr. Gerald E. Connolly...................... 114 The Leadership Conference reports titled, ``Counting Everyone in the Digital Age,'' and ``Administrative Records in the 2020 U.S.Census: Civil Rights Considerations and Opportunities,'' referenced in Ms. Gupta's written statement.................... 116 Statement for the record of J. David Cox Sr., submitted by the American Federation of Government Employees, AFL-CIO (AFGE).... 117 Letter for the record from the Interreligious Working Group on Domestic Human Needs........................................... 121 Questions for the record for Secretary Ross, submitted by Members of the Committee............................................... 124 HEARING ON THE 2020 CENSUS ---------- Thursday, October 12, 2017 House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The committee met, pursuant to call, at 10:10 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Trey Gowdy [chairman of the committee] presiding. Present: Representatives Gowdy, Duncan, Issa, Jordan, Amash, Farenthold, Massie, Meadows, DeSantis, Ross, Walker, Blum, Hice, Grothman, Hurd, Palmer, Comer, Cummings, Maloney, Clay, Kelly, Watson Coleman, Plaskett, Demings, Raskin, Welch, Cartwright, DeSaulnier, and Gomez. Chairman Gowdy. The committee will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Secretary Ross is with us. He will be joining us momentarily. I will recognize myself for an opening statement and then my friend from Maryland. The census is constitutionally required. It is what ensures that, just as every vote should be counted, every person should be counted. This is a condition precedent for accurate redistricting and accurate reapportionment. The census is not only important for purposes of constituting our government, it is also important for apportioning the resources and services of our government. So the census is vitally important for a number of reasons. It is also eminently predictable. There are a few things that can be foreseen quite like that decennial census. It happens every 10 years whether you are ready or not. So it is incredibly important, beginning with the fundamental truth of counting every one of our fellow citizens. And we know well in advance when it is coming, so we can't complain that we were caught off guard, and we can't complain that we didn't see it. So have a couple more years before we actually count everyone, but now is the time to make sure that we are ready to count everyone with accuracy, with security, and with professionalism. We are all concerned with cost. Our fellow citizens are hearing about cuts in a number of areas, and there is concern about the deficit and the debt, so cost is important, but it is also very important that we get this done right, accurately, professionally, with security and in a fashion worthy of the world's great democracy. What would be even worse than unexpectedly high cost is unexpectedly high cost coupled with less-than-full success, so we want to make sure the census is a success. We don't appropriate money on this committee, but we do help make sure the right questions are asked in a timely fashion. So for Secretary Ross, I appreciate his time, and I appreciate the time frankly that he has given our committee before today, as well as his appearance today. We live in a country that is increasingly skeptical of whether or not we can get things done right, in a timely fashion, and in an incredible responsible way. I think our country as a whole, irrespective of the region in which you may live or your political ideation, would appreciate a good news story, a story of how a government entity was prepared, efficient, and exceeded their expectations. So 2020 may seem like a long way off, but it is coming, and when it comes, we are going to have to have counted 300 million-plus people accurately, so I think time is of the essence even today. Chairman Gowdy. So with that, I would welcome all of our witnesses, especially Secretary Ross, and would yield the remainder of my time to my friend from North Carolina, the chairman of the subcommittee, Mr. Meadows. Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for your leadership on this particular issue. And as we go into this hearing today, I think it is critically important that we all realize that, while 2020 is a good ways off, we have already missed critical dates, critical testing, and critical implementation that should have already been done according to our own schedule that we have had in previous hearings. Of the IT systems that are out there, there are some 43 IT systems that need to be implemented, and yet today, only four have actually been fully implemented, another 31 are only partially done, and 18 have not been delivered in any form or fashion. And yet we continue to have hearings over and over and over again about the critical nature of making sure that we not only get these systems implemented but tested and that we do end-to-end testing on a basis to make sure that cybersecurity, other fumbles do not happen. And yet here we are today on another hearing, and I am concerned that the focus will be on the $3 billion in terms of a budget shortfall and not on the other critical mission steps that have to be addressed. And so let's today focus not on the $3 billion but on the management issues that must be done. And in doing so, we are talking a little whole lot about disaster relief in every other area. Today is a day that we need to start talking about disaster relief for what will be a disaster if we don't get on this today. And so, Mr. Secretary, thank you for coming. For our second panel of witnesses, thank you for coming. I have been informed by some of your staff, Mr. Secretary, that you are on this and that you plan to make sure that this is not just a budgetary component, that it is a component that actually looks at the management procurement and otherwise. And I was pleasantly assured of that this morning, but we look forward to hearing more from you. I thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your leadership. And as we get this right, I look forward for this to be a good story in the months and years to come. I yield back. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from North Carolina yields back. The gentleman from Maryland is recognized. Mr. Cummings. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. If there is one key point we can get across to those watching today's hearing, I believe it is simply this: The Census Bureau is dangerously underfunded and has been for years, and unless we do something about it right now, not yesterday, not today, but right this moment, this massive deficiency could imperil the fairness and accuracy of the census itself. Americans expect us to be able to do things right, and I think the Chairman would agree with me; I think you just said it. We want to be effective and efficient in whatever we do. Mr. Meadows is right. We have got to--it is not just a thing of money. It is a thing of operation and making sure that things are done properly. So this is not a partisan observation. Both progressives and conservatives agree that current budget projections are way, way, way, way, way too low. Eli Lehrer, the president of the R Street Institute, wrote an op-ed just this Tuesday warning that the census is, quote, ``understaffed and underfunded,'' end of quote, and that, quote, ``America is in serious danger of the census going wrong,'' end of quote. Ladies and gentlemen, we cannot afford to allow that to happen. This is the United States of America, the exceptional nation. If we cannot count the 300-plus million people who are in our country, I don't know how exceptional we will be determined to be. Last month, the Conservative American Enterprise Institute joined with the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities in warning Congress the current level of flat or near-flat funding, quote, ``is unprecedented and would significantly undercut efforts to conduct an accurate survey,'' end of quote. They warned that, quote, ``shortchanging the census is penny wise and pound foolish,'' that it, quote, ``jeopardizes the Bureau's ability to implement cost-effective new technologies,'' end of quote, and it, quote, ``could backfire, costing taxpayers more in the long run,'' end of quote. I say that we are better than that. I would like to show a future that illustrate this urgent problem. It won't show up on the screen, but members, it will show up on your screens at your desk. First, as we all know, funding for the Census Bureau historically increases dramatically in years 8 through 10 of each decade to accommodate the ramp-up in activities for the census in year 10. The first chart shows funding for the last four decades in inflation-adjusted dollars. For the 1990 census, the Bureau increased from $596 million to $3 billion over the last four years. For the 2000 census, it increased from $535 million to $6.9 billion over this period. For the 2010 census, it increased from $1.1 billion to $8.4 billion over this period. But what are we doing now? We are basically flatlining. The Trump administration did not request a significant increase for 2018. You can see the same trends when you look at the budget from a percentage basis, which is what this next chart shows. The 1990 census had a massive increase in the last four years of the cycle, as did the 2000 census and the 2010 census, but here is where we are now. The administration is not on track to match past increases for 2020. If we use these historical trends to project forward, total Census Bureau funding would be increasing over the next several years. But that is not what is happening. As this last chart shows, there is a shortfall of about $760 million when you compare what the administration is requesting to pass trends. I say that we are better than that. Now, Congress shares part of the blame, no doubt about it. In 2012, Congress insisted that the Census Bureau spend less on the 2020 census than it spent on the 2010 census. Congress refused to acknowledge or budget for two of the most significant and predictable drivers of cost increases that occurred between each decennial census inflation and population growth. Aggravating this problem even more, Congress appropriated even less then the Census Bureau requested in every single year since 2012. Now, some people will argue that the Census Bureau was supposed to save billions of dollars this time around by using new IT innovations to reduce the number of workers it needs to hire and increase the number of people who submit their forms online. The problem is that when you starve the Census Bureau year after year after year, it cannot make the investments needed to implement these innovations. And this is exactly what happened. And I am sure Secretary Ross will talk about that. As the former director of the Census Bureau, John Thompson, who left his position this summer, explained to the Washington Post just this week, and I quote, ``Had we been funded to do everything we asked for then, we would be much further ahead,'' end of quote. He continued, quote, ``At this point, they are going to have to go back and do some of it your way with paper and pencil,'' end of quote. With paper and pencil. This is the exceptional nation, the one that has done the census over and over and over and over again. Secretary Ross, I want to thank you for being here today and for briefing members of the committee last week. I understand you have limitations on your time, but, Mr. Secretary, we beg you to--we have members--and I am sure the chairman will emphasize this. We have members that are very interested in this subject, and I hope that--I don't know what--unless you are meeting with the President, I hope that you can spare us a few extra moments because we do want to get to have members ask. And as I close--and I know you will get into this during your testimony, but I appreciate that as a result of your own team's review you have also recommended that the administration increase its request for 2018 by $187 million. And thank you for doing that because so often we have Secretaries come in and they don't say exactly what they need because they don't want to get people upset. But this is just too important. I commend you for taking this step, and I know you understand the importance of this issue as a former enumerator yourself. However, I believe that even this request is far too low, too low. Did you hear me, Secretary? Too low, especially given the number of tests that have been canceled and extremely low number of hires at the moment. And so I know you are constrained in your current position. I was amazed to hear that the Office of Management and Budget rejected your request for an additional $50 million for contingencies that are virtually certain to occur. Nevertheless, we have a responsibility under the Constitution of the United States to ensure that the census is funded adequately and that the Census Bureau has the resources it needs to conduct a fair and accurate census. This should matter to each and every one of us because, while we historically discuss minority and immigrant populations being undercounted, low-income and rural communities are also at risk of being missed, particularly in a digital census. For this reason, yesterday, I joined my colleague, Representative Carolyn Maloney, who also chairs the Congressional Census Caucus, in introducing legislation to fund the Bureau at $1.935 billion this year, an amount that reflects budget projections from the Bureau's fiscal year 2017 budget and an extra $135 million for increases in the necessary funds for the CEDCaP program. As I close, we must recognize the gravity of the situation we are facing. And, Mr. Chairman, I thank you. You have taken on this matter very, very seriously. As you said earlier, we had a very informative meeting with the Secretary. I think that helped to lay the foundation for this hearing, and I look forward to the testimony. And thank you very much for your indulgence. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Maryland yields back. We want to welcome you, Mr. Secretary. Pursuant to committee rules, I am going to ask you to please stand and we will administer the oath. If you will raise your right hand. [Witness sworn.] Chairman Gowdy. May the record reflect the witness answered in the affirmative. You may take your seat, Mr. Secretary. Your entire opening statement will be made part of the record. You will have five minutes to summarize that. I want to say, as Mr. Cummings did, we do appreciate the fact that there are other demands on your time, and we want to be good stewards of your time. The census is one of the unusual entities that is squarely within the jurisdiction of this committee, and there are lots of members that have questions, so what I am going to ask of my colleagues on both sides is to exercise the self-restraint of getting your questions done within five minutes. I am notoriously slow on the gavel because it is hard to unlock the mysteries of the world in five minutes, but I am going to ask my colleagues to self-discipline and get it done within five minutes so everyone can have a chance to interact with you and we can also be a good steward of your time. With that, I would invite you to turn on the microphone, and you are recognized for your opening statement. WITNESS STATEMENT PANEL I: STATEMENT OF WILBUR L. ROSS, JR., SECRETARY, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE Secretary Ross. Thank you very much. Chairman Gowdy, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee, thank you for your continuing support and your discerning oversight. Thank you also for allowing the opening statements to be read while I was reviewing some of the newly developed material so I could comment on it myself. An efficient 2020 census that provides a full, fair, and accurate count has been one of my highest priorities since being confirmed in February. I myself was an enumerator as I worked my way through business school, and so I have a strong appreciation for the responsibilities and the unique challenges of counting everyone in the United States once every 10 years. Any operation that must hire and manage half-a-million temporary employees with complex and new technological systems and with rigid completion dates is bound to be a difficult undertaking for even the most experienced managers. And it has been clear to me from the beginning of my tenure that census would be one of the most challenging aspects of the entire Commerce portfolio. I agree with the members of this committee. The census is the bedrock upon which we construct our system of democratic representation. It provides for apportionment, redistricting, and the distribution of hundreds of billions of dollars of Federal funding. Accordingly, some of my first meetings as the newly confirmed Secretary of Commerce were with the Commerce staff. In those meetings I sought to identify and then address the key issues faced by the decennial census. My early concerns were heightened when, only two months into my tenure, the Census Bureau suddenly announced a 40 percent cost overrun in one component, namely, the Census Enterprise Data Collection and Processing, CEDCaP, program, a critical part of the technology infrastructure for the 2020 census. In terms of the broader decennial census, the prior administration's last lifecycle cost estimate in the--October 2015 was $12.5 billion. When testifying before Congress in June, I did not accept that figure. Instead, I vowed to return to Congress after a thorough review with a vetted 2020 census lifecycle cost that I could support. The product of that review is what brings me here today. As promised, we assembled a team of experts to conduct an independent review of the estimate, and they have come back with numbers I can now stand behind as we continue our preparation for 2020. The team was comprised of financial management experts from the Department of Commerce, from the Office of Management and Budget, former census employees, two former technology executives with experience in rolling out complex systems, as well as other experts with extensive private sector experience. In conducting our review, we looked at the many concerns raised by the GAO and Members of Congress, including those on this committee about the Census Bureau's cost estimates. I am aware of the funding statistics presented by Ranking Member Cummings and can assure you that the $760 billion budget shortfall and its impact is encompassed within our new lifecycle projections. You will hear testimony from both the GAO and the Commerce IG discussing their concerns with the prior 2015 lifecycle cost estimate. For example, the GAO estimated that the IT budget would be at least $4.8 billion. Our estimate is $4.96 billion, so $160 million over the floor that the GAO estimated would be the correct number rather than the previously used one. I share their concerns, and their testimony will underline the need and justification for this new lifecycle cost estimate. GAO also points out that there are 43 technology systems involved in the 2018 end-to-end test. Only four of those systems had completed development and integration tests as of August 2017. And of the 39, a portion of the functionality has been deployed in the 2018 end-to-end test, but that is not yet true for the remaining 18. With so much still under development, the need for a contingency to address possible overruns seem self-evident. These are just a few examples. The IG provided another example regarding address canvassing where they found that it would cost at least three times the amount the Census Bureau estimated in 2015. We agree with that, and we have incorporated that into our numbers. On the whole, we found that the prior administration provided Congress and the public with overly optimistic assessments of both the ease of implementing new technologies and the cost savings they would provide. These issues were undoubtedly compounded by initial appropriation constraints. Also, procurement decisions created a series of silos, most of which had a small firm as the general contractor and a number of major firms as subcontractors, a very complex structure. Worse yet, many segments were on a time-and- materials basis, and in my view, that's the most dangerous form of a contract. The prior administration also failed to follow basic management practices like using certified cost estimators and checking estimates against actual costs. We have addressed these failures and corrected the record with this new lifecycle cost estimate. We identified key areas where census programming would likely create costs above the 2015 estimate. Those include declining self-response rates, increased public concerns about privacy and cybersecurity, high levels of mistrust of the Federal Government, tightening in the labor markets since 2010, development and integration of new technologies and the complex array of contractors and subcontractors. This leads us to now project a revised lifecycle cost estimate of $15.6 billion. The increase includes contingency funding of $1.2 billion to address additional potential risks and associated challenges such as national disasters, potentially even lower self-response rates, the difficulty and cost of hiring 500,000 temporary workers in a tight labor market, and the complexity of developing and integrating multiple information technology innovations. Over 80 percent of the projected spending, over 80 percent will occur post-2018, so it's a very back-ended expenditure, as Congressman Cummings pointed out in his charts. And this rapid ramp-up in the future brings its own challenges to implementation and to cost control. Our $1.2 billion reserve, a contingency of 10 percent of the post-2018 budget, on top of the independent cost estimate level, will be managed at the secretarial level and used only if unforeseen developments occur. A 10 percent contingency is commonplace in estimating complex private-sector projects. Government tends not to set up reserves but instead funds overruns in subsequent appropriation requests. Our new $15.6 billion 2020 census lifecycle cost estimate includes a request for a $187 million adjustment for fiscal year 2018. We are working with our House and Senate appropriators on this request. These funds would allow us to make a significant course correction to keep crucial programs on track and provide much-needed financial oversight and better management at the Census Bureau. The Census Bureau and the Department of Commerce will be held accountable to manage the 2020 census efficiently while maintaining the highest quality. The Under Secretary for Economic Affairs Karen Dunn Kelley has been in place since late August and has direct oversight over the 2020 census, the Census Bureau, and the Bureau of Economic Analysis. She brings over three decades of management experience in the financial investment sector with experience managing people, strategy, budgets, operations, public relations, and thought leadership across the globe. Seasoned and experienced senior management is also in place at the Census Bureau itself. Ron Jarmin, performing the nonexclusive duties and functions of the director of the U.S. Census Bureau, and Enrique Lamas, performing the nonexclusive duties and functions of the deputy director and chief operating officer of the U.S. Census Bureau, are jointly leading the census, and each has nearly three decades of experience in census. Commerce now conducts weekly 2020 census oversight reviews and will require metric tracking and program execution status on a real-time basis. Commerce also has monthly meetings with OMB, census program managers, and Commerce's 2020 leadership team, headed by Under Secretary Kelley to review issues related to the program's budget, scope, schedule, and risks. These management meetings include detailed reviews of the evolving budget and lifecycle cost estimate for the 2020 census. The results of these meetings are reported directly to me by Under Secretary Kelley and her staff, and we maintain a free flow of access and information so that I can personally oversee the progress of the decennial. We are now just 30 months away from the 2020 census. There are still many challenges ahead, and these additional resources I have described are urgently needed. But with the changes I have detailed and with the additional resources requested, I am confident we will have a full, fair, and accurate census. I look forward to working with this committee, your staff, and the rest of Congress over the months and years to come, and I thank the committee for the opportunity to come before you today. I look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Secretary Ross follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Gowdy. Thank you, Mr. Secretary. The chair now recognizes the gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Duncan. Mr. Duncan. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. And, Mr. Secretary, thank you for being with us. And I have two questions. I will just asked them both so we get them in. Many of us who were here at the time of the last census received a lot of complaints about this American Community Survey, and some privacy advocates were very critical. And our colleague Ted Poe has led a charge against this. He called that survey, quote, ``an unnecessary and completely unwarranted government intrusion,'' and he has led a charge to make that survey voluntary. And I am wondering if you have looked into that to see if you can make that survey a little less intrusive so that we won't get as many complaints this time as we did the last time. And secondly, the second question I have is many States are going to be trying to do everything they can to make sure that they don't lose a Member of Congress or maybe that they pick up one, and many Federal appropriations are based on population. Can you assure us that steps are being taken or are you satisfied that things are being done so that no States can inflate their populations in those kinds of--with the goal of getting more money or another congressional seat? Secretary Ross. Well, thank you. Those are two questions. I will try to answer them in sequence. The American Community Survey is one of the Department of Commerce's most valuable data products, and it's widely used in the business community to make decisions. A voluntary survey would have a negative effect on the reliability of the data, especially for rural and small communities. At the same time, the Census Bureau continues to look for ways to reduce the burden on respondents such as removing questions by using other data sources, including information that people have already provided to government in a different form. So we're trying to reduce the scope of the burden as a means of making it easier for people. In terms of trying to assure that we really do count everyone, we've made a number of changes. First of all, the communications budget for the 2010 decennial census was $350 million, and that included outreach to non-primary English- speaking communities. We have increased that budget to $500 million this year or for 2020, and that equates to an inflation-adjusted $420 million that would have been in 2010. So we have had a material step up in the communications budget. And in the 2010--2020 census, about half of that will go for our partnerships, the various faith-based and other community organizations that help us get to the more difficult- to-enumerate parts of the population. So we are keenly aware of the need for even greater effort than was used before. And finally, we have added internet response as an additional tool to make it more convenient for that portion of the population that likes to use internet. So we have made a number of very specific modifications, all of which we believe will lead to the end result of a more accurate and more complete census. Mr. Duncan. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from Maryland. Mr. Cummings. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Ross, Secretary Ross, in 2012 Congress directed the Bureau to spend less than the 2000 census, and I quote, ``not adjusting for inflation,'' end of quote. Since that time, Congress has basically starved the Bureau of funds and has appropriated less than the Census Bureau requested in every single fiscal year since 2012. And this must have negatively affected the Bureau's investments in new technologies. Is that right? In other words, did it affect your investment in new technologies, sir? Secretary Ross. Well, the expenditures you're describing, if I understand it correctly, are the ones prior to the present period. And I have seen the chart, and it roughly parallels-- even though the distribution year-by-year isn't the same, the 2020 one roughly parallels the expenditures for the 2010 census. The 2020 census is heavily back-ended, as were the prior ones, but it's even more so because of the nature of the technological changes that we're making. So if you would superimpose on your chart and in the supplemental material that I file after today, I will fill in the blank for you and show you how our projected budget for 2020 would compare both with the fluctuations, the amplitude in the prior ones, and you will see we are coming to a significantly higher absolute level than they had been. Mr. Cummings. Okay. In previous decades this is the year, year eight when there are larger funding increases as the Census Bureau historically ramps up towards census day. However, the Trump administration did not seem to recognize this precedent earlier this year. The President requested only a 1.8 percent increase in funding for the Bureau in fiscal year 2018. Is that right? Secretary Ross. I believe so, and I believe that was based on the information he then had from the prior management of census. Mr. Cummings. Well, you presented our committee with data last week showing that this level of funding is inadequate and could impair our ability to provide for a fair and accurate census. You are now requesting an additional $187 million to make up for what your Department termed a, quote, ``shortfall,'' end of quote, in the budget request for fiscal year 2018. Is that figure correct? Secretary Ross. Yes, sir. I believe we do need $187 billion--million more than was in. Mr. Cummings. And OMB supports that request, is that right? Secretary Ross. I'm sorry? Mr. Cummings. And OMB supports that request? Secretary Ross. That's my understanding. Mr. Cummings. You also informed the committee last week that you at the Commerce Department, as well as the Census Bureau, believe that you need more than that amount to fully be prepared for all eventualities. You asked for an additional $50 million to cover contingencies that almost certainly will occur. Is that correct? Secretary Ross. Yes, sir. Mr. Cummings. But OMB denied this request, isn't that right? Secretary Ross. I don't know ---- Mr. Cummings. For the contingencies. Secretary Ross. I don't know that they have taken a position on the overall lifecycle cost. Our focus, because of the urgency of the budget, had been on getting their support for the immediate request for an additional appropriation. Mr. Cummings. Do you know whether that came to the attention of Mr. Mulvaney? Secretary Ross. Well, it's been brought to Mr. Mulvaney's attention ---- Mr. Cummings. Okay. Secretary Ross.--by me. Mr. Cummings. And I see I am running out of time, but do you know if the President is aware of your request for the additional $50 million? Secretary Ross. I have not personally spoken to the President about it. Mr. Cummings. Last question. So what will happen if problems arise? How will you obtain funding to cover them? Secretary Ross. Well, we believe that the $187 billion will cover us through the fiscal year 2018. We're reasonably comfortable with that. The bigger risk comes after 2018 because that's when 80-plus percent of the money will be spent. Mr. Cummings. Right. Secretary Ross. So 2018 we think is pretty high visibility, pretty well within hand. It's post that period that needs that big contingency. Mr. Cummings. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman yields back. Mr. Comer from Kentucky. Mr. Comer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Bureau's contracts--I'm going to ask a question about the contracts-- are set up as time-and-material contracts, which means there are limited incentives for contractors to control labor hours and costs. To your knowledge, what was the thinking behind this type of contract? Secretary Ross. I have no idea, sir. I have been less worried about re-exploring the past than about trying to make sure we get our arms around the future. Mr. Comer. What do you think the Department can do to manage these contracts more effectively? Secretary Ross. Well, we're interacting quite aggressively with the contractors, and that's about all that we can really do. The--many of the contracts have very severe cancellation provisions and would be very disruptive to cancel at this stage in the game in any event. So I think we have to manage through the process pretty much with the existing group of contracting parties. But the intensity of interaction I can promise you is a lot more than it had been. Mr. Comer. Okay. One more quick question, Mr. Secretary. With respect to IT, are you concerned that certain IT products and systems may not be delivered in their final form and time for testing during the 2018 end-to-end test? Secretary Ross. So far as we can tell, the ones that are incomplete are reasonably unscheduled, but it's always the last 10 percent that's the devil. Just like in any contract, the devil's in the details. Mr. Comer. Okay. Well, thank you, Mr. Secretary. It is an honor to have you here. I am a big fan of yours when you were on CNBC a lot over the years ---- Secretary Ross. Thank you. Mr. Comer.--but I yield back, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman yields back. Mrs. Maloney. Mrs. Maloney. Thank you. First of all, Secretary Ross is from the great State and city of New York ---- Secretary Ross. Yes. Mrs. Maloney.--and I would like to welcome you here today and thank you for your public service. Secretary Ross. Thank you. Mrs. Maloney. In your comments you seem very committed to getting an accurate count, which is mandated in our Constitution, but if you look at the spending levels--granted, you are just new in this job, but for the census for 2020, the spending, the red line is way behind, you know, the prior censuses from 2010, 2000, 1990. And as a businessman ---- Secretary Ross. Could you raise the chart a bit? I can't see the whole thing. Okay. Thank you. Mrs. Maloney. You know what, let's take it down and give him one of these. But anyway, this is a chart that we have on the ratio of the census budget to year one of the decade. But in any event, as a businessman, it is hard to achieve the results without spending, so I certainly support your spending requested $187 million. I think it is a good start, but I don't think it is good enough. You have a lot to catch up on. Several of the dress rehearsals were canceled. The foreign-language rehearsals canceled. This is a major undertaking. It is one of the major undertakings of our country. And if we don't have a good census, you know we don't have good data for government policy or business policy, so I want to know what you are doing to address the immediate problem. And as I understand it, your increase of $187 million is basically for IT work, but in your new lifecycle estimate, you identified seven major cost drivers, and the first two of these are all about public confidence, public response, and public concern. And these cost drivers can be addressed through education and outreach and promotion of the census, and we have seen that before. The 1990 census was called a failure because there was a declining response rate, so in 2000, the 2000 census, the Congress allocated more money and called for a paid advertising campaign and for partnership outreach and all types of efforts to build up participation. And both in 2000 and 2010 we were successful in increasing the public response rate, which is what it is all about, getting people to participate. But by getting the public response rate up, it was critical in keeping the expensive follow-up methods that you have to do if there is an undercount, so that is very important. Now, I read recently in the Washington Post that the ad contract Congress mandated for the 2020 has not been funded yet, and the partnerships have not been fully filled, and the census has to start early to be successful, so these partnerships with communities like the NAACP, like La Raza, like the Hispanics and LGBT community, you have to fill those contracts, and they haven't been filled with people yet as I understand. And nowhere in your testimony or your documents do you propose fully funding the ad contract as originally planned, let alone increasing the contract to start addressing the later start in tracking these cost drivers that you identified in public outreach. So, yesterday--I am supporting your efforts, Mr. Secretary. I introduced the 2020 American Census Investment Act, which would provide more funding for the census and mandate that funds be used on promotion, education, outreach, in addition to the IT that you are addressing. And I just would like to hear your comments on that on whether or not you will be funding. By the way, I want to thank Ranking Member Cummings for supporting the bill and the efforts to increase funding for it. And do you feel that--will you be funding the ad contract? Will you be funding the partnership outreach? Will you be funding education and outreach to get participation up in the census? Secretary Ross. Well, thank you, Congresswoman Maloney. I am not used to being granted more money than I asked for, so that's a totally new experience for me. Mrs. Maloney. We want to make sure we get an accurate account, and as you look at this chart, we are way behind spending in the prior censuses in this decade. Secretary Ross. Well, as I said earlier to Ranking Member Cummings, we believe that that cumulative shortfall of the $176 million and its impact on the overall program is made up for by the funding we've requested in the total lifecycle cost. Mrs. Maloney. Will you be investing in promotion and education and advertising? Secretary Ross. Yes, we are investing in all sorts of things. For one thing, our communications budget will be $500 million as opposed to the $350 million that was spent in 2010. Inflation adjusting the 2010 would bring it to $420 million, so we're running $80 million more than--on an inflation-adjusted basis than the 2020. In addition ---- Mrs. Maloney. My time is almost up. The economic survey, is that on track, the economic survey? Secretary Ross. I think so, so far, but that's not the most urgent part of the problem of the communications. What we're doing is several things. We have more ways that people can respond than ever before. We're doing more language training than before. For example, we've introduced telephone call centers, and they will have the capability of operating in 10 languages, naturally including Spanish, but our population is more diverse than just that. So the call centers will be able to do up to 10 languages. In addition, the census enumerators will be able to provide support through the nature of people we select in multiple languages. We're trying to match the characteristics of the enumerators to the characteristics of the population in the area that they will be surveying. As to the partnerships, we certainly agree that those are a big key, and those will include national organizations, State and local governments, churches, and other faith-based organizations, health clinics, legal aid centers, and other support mechanisms, so we're trying to work with all of those. And the partnership program will consume approximately half of the $500 million budget for communications. It's about $248 million will go for the partnerships. So we believe that we are dealing adequately with the need for those. Chairman Gowdy. The gentlelady ---- Mrs. Maloney. Thank you. Thank you very much. Chairman Gowdy. The gentlelady yields back. The gentleman from Texas, Mr. Farenthold. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am over here in the corner, Secretary Ross, other direction. Secretary Ross. Oh. Oh, sorry. Mr. Farenthold. I have got a couple of questions for you. It seems to me that the Census Bureau has this attitude of we have got to do it ourselves and aren't looking to products that may be already out there or companies that we might be able to contract with to save some money. For instance, it is my understanding that the Census Bureau have received numerous recommendations, including some from the GAO and the Census Scientific Advisory Committee, as well as the private sector how the Census Bureau could better use commercial mapping and GIS--that is geographic information technologies--which would yield a large cost saving and increase productivity. However, to date the Census Bureau doesn't appear to have recognized or implemented any of these recommendations. How come we haven't been looking at some things like that? Secretary Ross. Well, there were very many private organizations contacted in the original process. I can't vouchsafe the process by which they made the final selections they did. That, as you know, basically occurred years before. But we are dealing with the contracts that we do have. We believe that these are qualified people, and we believe that we will be able to get the job done if we get the additional funding that we have requested. Mr. Farenthold. Well, can you maybe provide ---- Secretary Ross. In terms of lessons learned, one of the things we intend to do as we go along is to keep careful track of further improvements that should be made in subsequent censuses. Mr. Farenthold. I ---- Secretary Ross. I think with having only 30 months between now and the 2020 decennial, making radical changes would probably guarantee that we didn't get it right. Mr. Farenthold. I am a little concerned about the path we are on not getting there, too, but if you could get me a list of some of these proposals and recommendations, I sure would like to take a look at them. I mean, just as an old computer guy, we do the census every 10 years, and there are very few computer systems that have an effective life beyond 10 years, so we are going to gear up with this new computer system in 2020. And here we are in 2030, we are going to be sitting here doing the exact same thing when it seems to me you could get with a cloud service that is secure. We have got those that the government uses now, and get an application written for people's phone. This seems a whole lot simpler. And this cloud service that we would use would buy the computers and size them the way they need to be sized so they worked, and then when we are done with needing that massive capacity, they are there for them to use for their other clients. And to me that just makes economic sense. Rather than trying--this government attitude of we have got to do everything ourselves, especially in IT where I think the government really struggles--we are damned by some of our own contracting laws on that--it just seems like this is a great opportunity to look for some cost savings. And, you know, it is something that I brought up to your predecessor several years ago, but apparently it fell on deaf ears. So I ---- Secretary Ross. Well, we do believe that the cost will come in below the inflation-adjusted cost of the 2010 census, notwithstanding that there are the overruns. My predecessors estimated that the inflation-adjusted cost of 2020 using the 2010 methodology would have been $17.5 billion, so we are way more than $1 billion below that with all the problems that have occurred. Second, in terms of using existing databases, we do what we can. For example, we are making a lot of use of administrative records, the postal system records, local--the IRS records, Social Security records to check IDs, things of that sort. But the truth is Americans are a very mobile population. Something like 12 percent relocate each year. Mr. Farenthold. And I do--I am running out of time. I do want to make one more comment. I do think the Postal Service is an unused government resource that could be more help to the census than I think they are currently using. You have got Postal Service employees that visit almost every American residence five, six times a week, so I think there is a great resource there that may be underutilized. My time is expired, but if you would like to comment further, I am sure the chairman would ---- Secretary Ross. We are. We're using the Postal Service and, as I say, the IRS, Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare records, the Indian Health Service, every database that we can imagine because we really are trying to make sure we count everyone and that we count everyone one time. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Texas ---- Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, sir. I yield back. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Texas yields back. The gentleman from Missouri, Mr. Clay, is recognized. Mr. Clay. Thank you, Chairman Gowdy. And also, thank you, Secretary Ross,--on the top--for your testimony today. Secretary Ross. Sorry. I don't know the geography of the committee well enough ---- Mr. Clay. I understand. Secretary Ross.--where everybody is sitting. Mr. Clay. I understand. And really, the census is about three things: money, information, and power. And no community or State wins if we fail to get this right. And our nation will be the ultimate loser. And as you all know, our country is more mobile, as you said, and much more diverse than ever before. And sadly, in some parts of our nation, residents have a high level of distrust for the Federal Government, which makes them less inclined to take part in the census. That is true in urban communities like the one that I represent in St. Louis, which always struggles with a lower self-reporting response. And generally, across the nation, African Americans, Latinos, Asians, new immigrants, and the rural poor are at a much greater risk of not being counted, a costly mistake they will pay for for an entire decade. And that is why underfunding the census 2020 outreach programs to hard-to-count groups is such an enormous bipartisan threat to every state and every district that we represent. And I guess I want to start the line of questioning following up on Ms. Maloney's questioning. Hard-to-count, hard- to-reach audiences and lack of funding for this initiative, Mr. Secretary, which is part of your communications contract, must receive the full attention of your administration. And I say that because the component of the communications contract needs--they need to be made full partners in the communications effort because that is where the challenge will be on how we get to those hard-to-count populations. So if I could just hear your concerns about that ---- Secretary Ross. Surely. Mr. Clay.--and where we are going with it. Secretary Ross. Surely. The entity overall in charge of communications is Young & Rubicam ---- Mr. Clay. Yes. Secretary Ross.--which also was involved in the 2020 decennial. So, first of all, we have the institutional knowledge that they gain by their role 10 years ago. Second, the--they have retained something like 15 individual firms that specialize either in different forms of media or different ethnic groups, so we tried to pinpoint. Further, I may not have made it clear in what I said before, but the $500 million of communications is in addition to the $248 million for the partnerships. So altogether we're spending $748 million on this outreach initiative. And when you consider how many total households there are, that's quite a bit per household. And if you take out of that the ones that are easy responders, you'll find we're spending an enormous amount per household on the ones that are difficult to reach. And that is quite a deliberate thing. We have been conservative in our estimate of those who will give voluntary response. Last census was 63.5 percent. We're assuming that that may drop down to 55 percent. So we've assumed--despite massive communications, we've assumed that a higher percentage of the population will still need the foot soldiers clogging around ringing doorbells. Mr. Clay. Sure. And your partnership program also calls for testing of communications methods, all communications elements. Secretary Ross. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Mr. Clay. And that has been canceled for 2018, so how will these elements be tested adequately? Secretary Ross. Well, it hasn't been canceled; it's just been postponed. Mr. Clay. It has been postponed ---- Secretary Ross. Yes. Mr. Clay.--so sometime in the calendar year of 2018 ---- Secretary Ross. Yes. Mr. Clay.--it will be tested? Secretary Ross. Yes. Mr. Clay. And I thank you for that response, and I yield back. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Hice, is recognized. Mr. Hice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I appreciate you being here, Mr. Secretary. Who is responsible to deliver the IT products on time? Secretary Ross. Who is responsible? Well, the Census Bureau is responsible, and they have a whole series of contracting parties. If you count them all up, there are probably 100 individual entities. Mr. Hice. But at the end of the day somebody has got to be responsible that the product is delivered. Secretary Ross. Well, ultimately me at Commerce and Karen Dunn Kelley has the oversight of census. Mr. Hice. So why are the IT products not delivered on time? What is the holdup? Secretary Ross. Of? Mr. Hice. For the delivery of the modernization IT products. Here we are going to end-to-end and we don't have what we need. Secretary Ross. Well, I think the original estimates as to how long it would take and how much it would cost to get to those products were flawed, so some of it may be contractor not performing as well. I can't judge what went on prior to the present, but I think it's a combination of over-optimism on the part of census and maybe some errors on the part of the contractor. Mr. Hice. So is there any accountability, is there any penalty for not delivering on time what was promised to be delivered? Secretary Ross. Well, each contract is different, but when you are on a time-and-materials contract, the concept of penalty doesn't really work very well. That's why ---- Mr. Hice. So we are just going to have ambitious--we hope to deliver but we won't deliver, and there is no accountability. Secretary Ross. There's not as much accountability as there would have been if there were fixed-price, fixed-time contracts, but that's not the situation that we're faced with. Mr. Hice. So when do we have--when can we possibly even guess under these circumstances that we will receive what we have? Secretary Ross. Well, we have given more than what we think is a guess. We have done lots of work out in the field. We've done lots of analysis of what's been done thus far, lots of analysis of the contracts, and we believe that this budget phased in the way that we have proposed will deliver the product that we need. Mr. Hice. Well, I don't share your optimism. I don't see how in the world you can either with the type of situation we are dealing with. And then you look at cybersecurity. How confident are you that this information gathered with an IT that hasn't even been tested is going to be secure? Secretary Ross. Well, in today's world you can't be sure of anything in terms of cybersecurity, but I can assure you the systems we're putting in are far more robust than anything that has ever been done before in census. Mr. Hice. Well, I know last year the CIO for Bureau made a similar statement, said he had great confidence that the cybersecurity was intact, and yet the system hadn't even been tested. How in the world can you have that kind of confidence on something we know nothing about? Secretary Ross. Well, first of all, I didn't say I have confidence that it's impenetrable. What I said is it's a lot more robust than had been true in 2010. Mr. Hice. How do you know that is my question. Secretary Ross. Because of discussions with the people who are doing the implementation of it. But having said that, I'm not aware that there's any system that's flawless. Mr. Hice. Sir, so you are giving great confidence to us about the cybersecurity based on conversation. Secretary Ross. No ---- Mr. Hice. Conversation is not enough to give us the assurance that this information is protected. Secretary Ross. What I'm telling you, sir, is that the systems themselves will be far more robust than anything census has used before. Mr. Hice. And yet we have not seen those systems? Secretary Ross. Well, no, because they're works in progress. Mr. Hice. So it's all based on conversation, not on tests? This is all part of the problem. We get promises that are never delivered on, and we get--now, we have cybersecurity promises, commitments that are the most robust thing we have ever seen before, but it is simply based on conversation, not on tests. It looks to me like we are going to go back to the same thing that happened in 2010 when we were promised all kinds of modernization, but it was a faulty IT program, so we end up with a paper-based census. I don't see how we can proceed with this any further without going back to paper-based and just be honest with what we are dealing with. Secretary Ross. Well, it's impossible to test something that doesn't yet exist. Eighty percent ---- Mr. Hice. My point precisely. Secretary Ross. Eighty percent of the spending will be post-2018. But let me describe to you what it is that we are doing. All of the data on the census systems are being protected. We're applying some rigorous security protocols to the perimeter of the census' own network. The census has an existing network, so we're applying rigorous protocols to that. We're putting in routers and firewalls. We also have our own detection intrusion and prevention systems in place at census. Census Bureau now has an unprecedented level of engagement with the best resources elsewhere in the Federal Government. We're working closely with cybersecurity experts across the Department, including NIST, which is part of Commerce, the Federal CIOs office, the Department of Homeland Security, and the intelligence and law enforcement communities. We're also putting a new level of cybersecurity Federal management in place for the 2020 census over and above what was done in 2010. Mr. Hice. Mr. Secretary, all due respect, our time is gone. I know we want to respect the time. I appreciate your answers. They just sound like talking points to me with not much beyond that. I yield back. Secretary Ross. You can't test something that isn't in place. Chairman Gowdy. All right. The gentleman yields back. The chair will now recognize the gentlelady from the Virgin Islands, Ms. Plaskett. Ms. Plaskett. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for having this committee hearing. Good morning, sir. How are you? Secretary Ross. Good, ma'am. Ms. Plaskett. Good. I wanted to ask you some questions which of course are something that is on the minds of quite a number of Americans right now is undertaking census in areas that have recently been ravaged by disaster and the mechanisms and processes that are potentially in place to be able to do that. We know that millions of Americans have been displaced by Hurricanes Harvey, Irma, and Maria in the States of Texas, Florida, and in the areas of Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. As the communities work tirelessly to rebuild, large-scale changes are likely to occur that, I would assume, would greatly impact the 2020 census. If we have learned anything from Hurricane Katrina in 2005, it is that recovery from large-scale natural disasters take time and often quite a lot of that time. A 2011 report by the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights illustrated that challenges to enumeration activities still exist in the Gulf region in 2010, almost five years after Katrina took place. And the report highlighted issues such as large numbers of individuals in temporary housing, informal housing arrangements, high rates of vacant units, significant changes in both new housing stock, and population shifts in those affected areas. Mr. Secretary, do you agree that the Bureau is likely to encounter many if not all of these challenges due to the destruction caused by this year's hurricanes and perhaps future hurricanes before the census takes place? Secretary Ross. Well, you're surely right in pointing out issues. Here's what we're doing. During the 2010 census they changed the operations in the areas that were hit by Katrina and Rita. Basically, what it involved was putting more people on the ground to deliver questionnaires directly to housing units and updating the addresses while doing so. We can do something similar in 2020 as needed. If it does turn out that we need that, it will cost more money, but we've tried to allow an amount for these types of contingencies, provided that the natural disasters are not more extreme than we've experienced in the past. In addition, we have a particular problem in the U.S. Virgin Islands and for that matter in Puerto Rico. We conduct the decennial census in those territories by working directly with territorial governments to build and implement the operations that best fit their respective situations. We're currently developing our approach for the 2020 with the government of the Virgin Islands and will ensure that the operations take into account the impact of the recent hurricanes. Ms. Plaskett. Excuse me, sir. When you say particular challenges, what have you seen in the past as being uniqueness of trying to find census data in areas like Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands besides the obvious that I know, which is that we don't have street addresses? Secretary Ross. Right. Well, as you know, the census has confronted those basic problems over and over and over. Ms. Plaskett. Yes. Secretary Ross. So every time that they've gone through it, they've learned something from the process. The difficulty we have now is that the issue with residence has been terribly compounded by the awful destruction that occurred. So the magnitude of the task has become greater than it ever had been. Ms. Plaskett. And will your budget reflect the magnitude of these hurricanes? Secretary Ross. We have tried our best to do so. Ms. Plaskett. And I know in the past that you have done a good job of not just partnering with the local governments but with community organizations as well, that they have been somewhat a boots-on-the-ground for you. Secretary Ross. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. And that's why we have allocated $248 million for partnerships with local community organizations. Ms. Plaskett. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. I yield back. Chairman Gowdy. The gentlelady from the Virgin Islands yields back. The gentleman from Alabama is recognized. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Secretary, for being here today. I understand some of the frustration that my colleagues have expressed, and to give you an example, the GAO and the Office of Inspector General have cited a number of issues with the Census Bureau that honestly you inherited to be totally truthful about it. But the frustration is that these don't appear to have been adequately addressed. For instance, the GAO included the 2020 census on its high-risk list for 2017. In fact, over the last three years, they have issued 30 recommendations, but as of January this year, only six have been implemented. Are you familiar with this list? Secretary Ross. Well, we have been working closely with the GAO. You will be hearing from them a bit later. And we are cooperating with them in their audit of the work that we've been doing. Mr. Palmer. My question, Mr. Secretary, and we only have five minutes and I want to give you an opportunity to answer this as--a yes or no would be sufficient. Are you familiar with this list of 30 recommendations? Secretary Ross. I couldn't hear you, sir. Mr. Palmer. Are you familiar with this list from the GAO, the 30 recommendations that they have made in the last ---- Secretary Ross. Oh, sure. Mr. Palmer.--three years? Secretary Ross. Sure. Mr. Palmer. And you are aware that only six have been implemented--have been followed up on as of January of this year? Secretary Ross. As of January, that was true. I believe there's been some further progress since then and there will be continuing progress. Mr. Palmer. I think it is extremely important that when the GAO or the OIG make recommendations when they have findings of issues that Federal agencies, Federal departments act on them. I mean, it is frustrating to the folks who are doing the work. It is frustrating to us in our oversight capacity. And it is not just with the Census Bureau. This has occurred in other agencies, but there is a mounting frustration that we identify problems and they don't get addressed. So my question to you, sir, is this a top priority, mid- level? I mean, how serious are you taking these? Secretary Ross. Well, it certainly is a top priority, and, you know, I think you'll find the OIG testimony pretty well mirrors the top management challenges report that we put together. What happened prior to January of this year I can't account for. Mr. Palmer. I ---- Secretary Ross. I was confirmed February 28, so ---- Mr. Palmer. I realize that, and I made that clear that you inherited most of these problems, but the thing that we want to know is that under your leadership that this is taken seriously. Secretary Ross. Oh, it is. Mr. Palmer. I mean, the cost estimates, for instance, we have known this--the GAO began questioning that in 2008. Secretary Ross. No, it certainly is, and my testimony today focused on a lot of it. One of their recommendations is the Bureau needs to manage the risks of implementing innovation. Well, you heard my testimony. I totally agree with that, and we are much more heavy-handed in the management than there had been before. Second, the Bureau continues to face challenges in implementing and securing key IT systems, 100 percent true for sure. And the 2018 end-to-end test will probably reveal some more deficiencies that we'll have to deal with. Mr. Palmer. But my colleague from Georgia expressed frustration with the testing process, and I appreciate your response that you can't test a system until the system is in place, but ---- Secretary Ross. Right. Mr. Palmer.--the Bureau has had a number of problems in terms of failing to adequately test systems and products, and when they do test them, they are not using the results to inform their decision-making. Secretary Ross. Well, we will. Mr. Palmer. Well, that is comforting to know, and I am certain under your leadership that that will happen, but that is one of the frustrations again that we have is that you have the GAO, the OIG, this committee making recommendations, and it is not just the Commerce Department or the Census Bureau. This has happened a number of times with other agencies, but we want to make sure--this is such a serious issue, we want to make sure that systems are tested and the results are used in decision-making. Mr. Chairman, I appreciate the opportunity to submit the questions ---- Secretary Ross. Absolutely. Mr. Palmer.--and I yield back. Secretary Ross. And the IT part was a very key one in the GAO recommendations. And as I had mentioned earlier, our budget is more than what they felt was the minimum required. They came in thinking that--as opposed to I think it was $3.6 billion that the former administration had estimated, I think they recommended $4.8 billion or more. We came in at $4.96 billion. So we are not ignoring any of those recommendations, not by a longshot. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Alabama yields back. The gentlelady from Florida is recognized. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. And, Secretary Ross, thank you so much for being with us today. You have already talked about undercounted populations, but this issue has been in the news recently because of a lawsuit filed by the NAACP which it filed in part because of concerns about the undercount of communities of color, young children, home renters, low-income persons, and rural residents. I am concerned that the undercount could be exacerbated in 2020 if minority groups are less inclined to share personal information with the government due to the climate of mistrust created by this administration's immigration policy. Secretary Ross, can you assure immigrant families and other--it is a bad word but--marginalized groups that their data will be kept confidential and not used to pursue any law enforcement or immigration action? Secretary Ross. I believe it would be illegal for those data to be used for other purposes, so unless someone commits a crime, I don't think that's going to happen. But on the NAACP lawsuit, they filed a Freedom of Information Act request with us on the June 29th. Mrs. Demings. Secretary Ross, excuse me just a second. So you are saying if the information was used for law enforcement purposes or for immigration policies, that that would be illegal? Secretary Ross. My understanding is that the information about specific individuals is not to be used for any other purpose but ---- Mrs. Demings. And using it would be illegal is--I am just trying to understand that that is what you are saying. Secretary Ross. I am not a lawyer, so I can't parse that, but as I understand it, it is not to be used for any other purpose. Mrs. Demings. Okay. Well, you know, one way--I know you have also spoken about partnership programs, and certainly I believe that additional programs of that nature may lessen some of the concern. How many partnership specialists have you hired and how many do you anticipate hiring by census day? Secretary Ross. Oh, there are quite a few. Let me see if I can get you the exact number. Mrs. Demings. Okay. And while you are looking for that, I think ---- Secretary Ross. Well ---- Mrs. Demings.--my colleague Mr. Clay talked about testing of new processes ---- Secretary Ross. Okay. Mrs. Demings.--particularly ---- Secretary Ross. The answer is 40, 40 people. Mrs. Demings. Forty? And how many do you anticipate hiring by census day or is that the total number? Secretary Ross. Forty I believe is the total number. Mrs. Demings. Okay. Secretary Ross. To date. Mrs. Demings. To date, okay. Thank you very much. Any anticipated numbers by census day at this point? Secretary Ross. Well ---- Mrs. Demings. We aren't sure? Secretary Ross. We'll see how much comes in. A lot of firms--a lot of community organizations are well aware of the census, have participated in it before, and are signing up themselves. So depending on whether we get a good flow, consistent with improving it over the last time, that'll determine how many people will need it. Mrs. Demings. Okay. Thank you for that. I know you also spoke about testing of new procedures. I would like to talk particularly about in rural island and tribal areas and also tie in those procedures to the budget constraints that we currently face. Secretary Ross, what are you doing to ensure that these new processes will work smoothly in rural island and tribal areas? Secretary Ross. Well, the tribal areas are one of the specific segments that are being tested so that we can get real-world results, seeing how the procedures that we've introduced work. Mrs. Demings. Okay. And for rural and islands? Secretary Ross. Same. Mrs. Demings. Okay, same. Okay. Thank you very much for that. On the census website it says, and I quote, ``We promise that we will use every technology, statistical methodology, and physical security procedure at our disposal to protect your information,'' unquote. Could you talk, Secretary Ross, a little bit about how the adequate or inadequate funding might affect that promise? Secretary Ross. Well, we believe that the funding we have requested will provide us the resources we need for that purpose. Mrs. Demings. And if you do not get the funding that you requested, are you still able to fulfill the promise that is on your website? Secretary Ross. Well, we will do the best we can with the resources we get, but we think that the optimal amount for the proper job is the amount we've requested. Mrs. Demings. Thank you, Secretary Ross. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Thank you. Chairman Gowdy. Yes, ma'am. The gentlelady from Florida yields back. The gentleman from Iowa is recognized. Mr. Blum. Thank you, Chairman Gowdy. Secretary Ross, thank you for being here today. Good to see you again, my friend. Fifteen-point-six billion I guess is the latest estimate. Secretary Ross. Yes. Mr. Blum. In Iowa that is a lot of money. Secretary Ross. It is to me too, sir. Mr. Blum. A hundred and twenty-five million households I think there are, so the math, if I am correct, is about $125 per household ---- Secretary Ross. That's about right. Mr. Blum.--to do what we want to do. Does that strike you as a large number per household? Secretary Ross. It's a large number ---- Mr. Blum. What are your feelings about that? Secretary Ross.--and it's an even larger number when you consider that the vast bulk of that is spent on getting the last few million in because the ones who respond to the initial mailed document or respond over internet, the cost of those is very small. It's the more-difficult-to-enumerate people that are really the most expensive to get to. The last few million people are going to cost infinitely more than the first few million ---- Mr. Blum. I'm ---- Secretary Ross.--and that's why the response rate is so critical. Mr. Blum. You are a private sector guy. I am a private sector businessperson as well. Can you just in 60 seconds let me know how much--are we utilizing the private sector? I am thinking of, for example, Google probably didn't spend $15 billion to map the entire United States visually. Are we utilizing the technology and the resources available in the private sector to the extent possible? Secretary Ross. I believe so. I believe so. Mr. Blum. Can you expand on that just briefly or-- especially the technology piece of this. Secretary Ross. Right. Well, where the Google-type technology is helpful is in locating physical structures. It doesn't really go within the structure to the individual person, so our task is first to identify the physical structures that have residents in them, whatever the nature, whatever the formality or informality of the living arrangements, but then the real test is to get inside them and find out exactly how many people are there. So that's where the self-responses are very helpful. And we're providing for internet self-response. We're providing call centers to make it easy. Everybody's going to be getting mailings. And then finally, as a last resort, we'll use the primitive thing of a guy knocking on the door. Mr. Blum. And speaking of--I am glad you said a guy knocking on the door. Back in my district in Iowa I have delivered the mail with postal carriers. One of them brought an idea to me. They said, ``Why is it when we do the census, why don't they use us more?'' He said, ``For example, I know exactly on my route how many people live in each house. I know their names.'' He said, ``I know a lot about them.'' He said, ``Why don't they utilize us?'' Secretary Ross. We do. Mr. Blum. I thought it was a great question. Secretary Ross. Oh, we do. Mr. Blum. I would like to pose that to you. Secretary Ross. Oh, we do. Our fundamental database is the postal system, no question. But because people move, people die, people--all kinds of things happen. Something like 12 percent of the population relocates during the course of a calendar year. And within the more difficult-to-enumerate portion, there's probably even more mobility than there is, say, in a single-family home in a little town. So it's very, very complicated, but we do begin with the postal system records for sure. Mr. Blum. So you use their database. Can we also utilize the man knocking on the door? Secretary Ross. The man knocking on the door ---- Mr. Blum. Can we utilize the postal carrier for that? Secretary Ross. The man knocking on the door is the last resort, only when all the more efficient mechanisms have already been used. Mr. Blum. I got looking at the $15.6 billion and I thought, Mr. Secretary, if you and I formed a company, I am guessing we could do for $8 billion, save the government $7 billion, and you and I would put a few dollars in our pocket I am guessing. Is there any truth to that? Secretary Ross. Well, I don't know. We are where we are, and we do think under the circumstances we really need the $15.6 billion. Thank you very much. Thanks for being here, Mr. Secretary. I yield back my time, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Iowa yields back. The gentleman from Pennsylvania is recognized. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And, Chairman Gowdy, I want to express my appreciation for this hearing. People don't think about the census that much, but it is such an important thing, not just because it is constitutionally mandated that we need to get it right. We need to get it right so our American Federal Government can work better for everybody. We need an accurate census. We need to know where the people are, we need to know where the jobs are, we need to know where the poverty is, we need to know how the economy is changing, we need to know what the government needs to do and maybe needs to stop doing and where these things need to happen. So, so much of policy depends on an accurate census. We need to get it right. Secretary Ross, it is good to see you again. I saw you in May when you came and testified before the House Appropriations Committee. And I want to touch on some areas that we do have concerns about. I think all of us in this room share the concern we need to get this census right. We want to learn from past mistakes. We don't want to be--we don't want to have rose- colored glasses and really unjustified hopes. We need to be very practical and pragmatic about this, and I think you are that kind of person, Secretary Ross, so I want to touch on a few things. First, warning signs of trouble, I mean, May 3 was when Census Director Thompson appeared before my subcommittee on appropriations, and we asked him hard questions, much like the ones you are getting here today, Secretary Ross. And he resigned the next week. That is a warning sign of trouble to me. And he hasn't been replaced. First question, are there immediate plans to replace the census director? Secretary Ross. Yes. We had actually come up with a nominee and then that fell away during the vetting process, so we're actively trying to recruit. But I have very good confidence in the team that we have assembled right now, namely, the two people who collectively have some 30 years each of experience are there, they're functioning every day. And Karen Dunn Kelley now is providing very direct oversight of them. Plus, I'm being very personally involved, and we have the whole series of oversight meetings, meetings with the contractors. We're all over this thing as best we can be. So it's not to say that we don't want to have a permanent approved census director; we do and we will. It's not an easy task to fill because you need someone who has subject matter command and management experience to deal with an enormously challenging task of hiring a half-million temporary workers, getting them out there, getting them productive, and getting this big technological change introduced. Mr. Cartwright. Well, you have a lot of other things that demand your attention, Secretary Ross, so I urge you to devote the maximum effort into finding that person to be a strong, active, knowledgeable census director, and let's get that done quickly. Secretary Ross. We're trying our very best. Mr. Cartwright. Now, we need to get this census right, and one of the problems, one of the red flags is we know there are underreported communities, and a number of them have been mentioned by my colleagues on both sides of the aisle today, but one of them I notice is the LGBT community. They are historically underreported. We know that they face higher levels of poverty, particularly older LGBT people, that LGBT young people are more likely to be homeless, making it all the more likely that they will be not counted. And, in fact, the Census Bureau itself has recognized that the LGBT community is a hard-to-count population, yet the Bureau has declined to put questions about sexual orientation and gender identity into the census. Secretary, did you determine that there was no Federal need for this information? Secretary Ross. No, there were hearings held about it. There were requests put in, and it was concluded that that particular set of questions did not meet the requirements for being put in. One of the problems with adding questions is it reduces response rates. It may seem counterintuitive, but the more things you ask in those forms, the less likely you are to get them in. Mr. Cartwright. Well, I ---- Secretary Ross. So there's a balancing act between more information and fewer responses. Mr. Cartwright. Secretary Ross, my time is up, but I want to associate myself with the hard questioning you got from my colleague, Congressman Hice of Georgia. I urge you to devote a great deal of attention to the online, the self-reporting, increasing public confidence in the cybersecurity of the system because, as you have said yourself today, that is the cheapest way we get this job done with the self-reporting, with the online work, and I urge you to devote a lot of attention to increasing the public's trust in the online system and giving them good reason to have trust in that system. And with that, I yield back, Mr. Chairman. Secretary Ross. We share your concern. Mr. Cartwright. Thank you. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Pennsylvania yields back. The gentleman from California is recognized. Sorry about that, the gentleman from Texas, I apologize. And I do want to say this in Will's defense. He was up several times ago and he let others go, so, Will, I apologize. You're up, and then the gentleman from California. Mr. Hurd. Thank you, Chairman. And, Secretary Ross, it is great to have you here, and it is great to know that there is C-suite attention to this important issue. You have a very important portfolio, but it is great that you are involved in providing leadership for this. And I know you have inherited I think the technical term is a mess, and I recognize and I appreciate your comments about how to prevent the next census from being in a similar position, so I appreciate that. And when some of your predecessors were here last time, there was a debate about whether the Census Bureau should develop a widget that uses the telecommunications backbone that the enumerator can put data in, and the question was that widget already exists; it is called a smartphone. And I am glad to know that the Census Bureau decided to use I believe smartphones. And my question around that is have we discussed or have plans, have you and the CIO for the Census Bureau had some conversations around the security of whatever device is going to be used by the enumerators? Secretary Ross. Yes, we've had consultation not only within the Department but with Homeland security, with FBI, with the intelligence community, with the overall CIOs in the government and in Commerce. So we're building in the best firewalls and routers that we possibly can. But having said that, there's probably some 13-year-old kid in a garage somewhere trying to figure out how to penetrate it, so in today's world, you do your best, but you can't be 100 percent sure unfortunately. Mr. Hurd. You have to begin with the assumption of breach. I did this for a living. I never not got in, but the fact that there is, again, focus from your office on the security of the systems--and I know that there is 43 systems that have to be delivered for end-to-end testing in 2018 and only four of those have been delivered. I know there has been some conversations on that. And, you know, my concern is the Bureau is going to have to get the authorizations to operate the ATOs for each one of these systems, and I know some of these--a section of these 43 systems already have ATOs, but they're going to need to get new ones because the system is evolving. And I am curious in the strategy that you and your IT team have discussed on ensuring that we have those ATOs in time to protect those personally identifiable information, especially on those 33 systems that do have PII. Secretary Ross. Well, there are actually more than 50 systems that will be involved. And their uses are to update and maintain the address list to enable people to respond via the internet, to identify the households that have not responded in order to send interviewers to them, to manage the work of the interviewers, and to recruit and pay the field workforce. Those are just a few examples of the kinds of systems. Systems also capture, process, and tabulate all of the data collected on the people living in the United States. We're monitoring the progress of all of these systems, and each one is at a different stage of completion as we sit here. Mr. Hurd. And so what is your strategy to ensure that these systems are delivered and they have the ATOs necessary to get this done? Secretary Ross. Well, we're trying to apply enough pressure on the contractors and enough surveillance of them to deal with the glitches that inevitably will come up. There will be unexpected problems in each area, and that's why we have allowed the 10 percent contingency because most of these problems that come up can be solved. It's a question of how many people it takes and at what cost. Mr. Hurd. And, Mr. Secretary, I would like to offer that we would love to talk to those folks, those contractors that may not be delivering on time and have them join you at this table to ensure that this census is done properly. And my last question in my remaining two seconds, why did the head of the census, the former Director Thompson leave the Bureau? Secretary Ross. Well, I think he has issued a public statement about why he left. I did not know him very well, so I can't really judge if--what his motivations were. He has found other employment in the statistical community, and he actually held a press conference at the National Press Club a week or two after he resigned and explained what his motivations were. Mr. Hurd. Good. Copy. Thank you. And, Mr. Chairman, I yield back the time I do not have. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Texas yields back, and I apologize again for not counting the gentleman from Texas, particularly embarrassing at a census hearing. So I apologize for that. The gentleman from California is recognized. Mr. Issa. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I don't mind you calling him the gentleman from California. We have had so many Californians moved to Texas. Chairman Gowdy. I should have specified the other gentleman from California, Mr. Gomez. Mr. Gomez. Thank you. Mr. Secretary, thank you so much for sticking around. I am over here. I am the newest member of the House and of this committee, so you sticking around is very helpful to me because I never get to ask these kind of questions. First, I am a big fan of the census. It is a subject I studied in graduate school at the Kennedy School of Government, took classes on it. It is very important just to the entire country and how we operate. One of the issues is definitely the undercount when it comes to certain communities. African Americans were undercounted by 2.1 percent in 2010 and Hispanics by 1.5 percent. I am fearful that that will go up in this next census because of the immigration policies, especially the interior enforcement policies of this new administration. The acting ICE Director Homan issued a statement last week in response to a bill that was passed in California, S.B. 54, the California Values Act, that they would have no choice but to conduct large-scale raids and enforcement within neighborhoods and workplaces. What kind of--you know, and you mentioned--this also kind of made me think about--you mentioned the response rate would be 55 percent. Has I guess the new interior enforcement policies of the administration been taken into account when determining the response rate, the undercount, and just trying to figure out what kind of impact they will have on these communities. Secretary Ross. Well, the--there are quite a lot of questions in what you've said, but the response rate in 2010 had been 63.5 percent. The original estimate that the census folks had used was 60.5 percent this time. We took that down to 55 percent for the very reasons that you are describing. Is that exactly the right number? Who knows, but it certainly is a lot safer number than 60.5. So our starting point is a much more conservative one, and as a result of that, we've allocated more money to the difficult-to-enumerate part. Second, we have increased the communications budget from the $350 million that was spent in 2010 to $500 million, and even if you look at 2010 on a 2020 inflation-adjusted basis, that would only bring it to $420 million, so it's almost a 20 percent increase over the inflation-adjusted basis. So we're increasing the communication is one thing. Second, were spending $248 million on these partnership arrangements. That's over and above the $500 million that we're spending on communications. So if you add that all up, that's $750 billion essentially devoted to outreach, and most of that, when you really think about it, is in fact devoted to the last few million, the last few percentage points to try to minimize the danger of undercounting because the ones who respond immediately to the mailings, the ones who respond immediately to a phone call, those don't cost too much to get. It's the last few that take up most of the money. We're making use of 10 different languages. We're doing all kinds of things that were not done before by way of training in order to improve the efficiency of the process. Mr. Gomez. Mr. Secretary, thank you. I am glad that is being taken into account, and I guess that is why you have a lower number. That is why also the partnerships are so important. I noticed that you mentioned that only 40 partnerships specialists have been currently budgeted. In 2000 there was 590 if that is correct. What is your goal on the number of partnerships for the 2020 census? Secretary Ross. Well, our goal is--our target is to get to a number on the order of magnitude of 800. Mr. Gomez. Okay. Thank you. The reason why it is so important is that there is a historic undercount in these communities. We need to make sure they are accurately counted. You have a tough, tough job. I appreciate that there has been thought about the political environment and the immigration enforcement. What I have seen in some of my-- even in talking to community hospitals and community clinics, you don't think there is a correlation, but some community clinics have seen increases in the no-show rate up to 19 percent. That is a big jump. So if they are not showing up to get physical and health checkups, you are going to see a lower response rate and lower counts in some of these communities. So thank you so much. I appreciate having the time to ask the questions, and I yield back. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman California yields back. The gentleman from California, Mr. Issa, is recognized. Mr. Issa. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Secretary, you know, around here we always say that all questions have been asked but not by all of us here. Seeing as I appear as though I am the last up to bat, I will try not to repeat any more than necessary. Earlier on, Mr. Duncan apparently asked about the American Community Survey. I just want to plant something. I have the same concerns he has of intrusiveness and so on, but I also have a concern of inaccuracy. It is anecdotal, but I have been living in the same house when I am here for years. The last census and this census, for whatever reason, they threaten my very livelihood if I don't answer questions about a place I don't live. And so the absence of a targeting pursuant to the survey that would reasonably determine whether or not there is a resident. In other words, the place that I reside in when I am here, except for a corporate name on the title, there is no way to trace it back to anybody. It is a house that receives no mail, has no bank accounts, absolutely nothing to it, and yet, for whatever reason, it is the target of the Community Survey for which I ignore to be honest. I don't really ignore it; I take it into my staff and they then send it to the Census Bureau to say this is silly. So the one thing that I would ask is that you, going forward, ask the question of to get accuracy, do you have to be random and without looking, or in this modern age can you use tools to determine the high likelihood of places that should be surveyed? Just a thought. Now, here is the bigger thought. This is going to be my third census, and as I came in as the first census--and the gentleman from California has departed talked about we inherited it from the Clinton administration, and it did have some differences. In 2010 under the Bush era and then Obama, he really inherited it from President Bush, who had done most of the preparatory work. What I will tell you is I saw very little difference in the fact that the Census Bureau always seemed surprised that 10 years had passed. They always seem a little shocked that they didn't make it, and then they start talk about funding for something they had 10 years. So here is a question from yours and my years in business. Decades ago when we were younger businessmen, companies closed for as much as a week to do their annual shutdown and inventories. Everybody except those counting went home. And that once-a-year inventory was the way it was. That was before a great many advances both in statistical accuracy and in the ability to continuously monitor inventories. Today, no sensible company ever has to shut down because they are continuously making sure their inventories are accurate. The Constitution does enumerate a once-every-10-year requirement, but the Constitution could be changed if necessary. If we were to ask the question wouldn't America be better off with continuous accurate counting, a system in which the Census Bureau, in its many activities, including the aforementioned American Community Survey, would be constantly doing its job. It would not be trying to do something once every 10 years, which seems to be Herculean simply because they only do it once every 10 years. So I would ask you to draw on the evolutions that you have seen over decades in how we look at accounting for things and ask the question, on your watch, shouldn't we begin the process, even if it requires congressional action, to go to a continuous-counting system to make it constitutional but to make it much more accurate, which today, with tools both in counting and, to be honest, with the modern computer accuracy of what we know and where we know it, couldn't we do the American people a better service? Secretary Ross. Well, I must confess with trying to get my arms around the existing process, I've not given much thought to changing the whole thing. There are probably pluses and minuses to the idea of the continual survey. At some point I will try to give some thought to it, but as you correctly point out, that would take a constitutional amendment, and I would think that's going to be a big challenge in and of itself to make such a radical change in something so fundamental to the allocation of seats and allocation of monies. Mr. Issa. I would agree with you that if, in, fact the certification once every 10 years that the count was as accurate or more accurate than it would be by the current system would require some action. The question is when the Census Bureau certifies what our population is and where it is in 2020, they will be doing so with the best efforts they can have, most of which will be done based on a once-every-10-year count. What I would say to you, Mr. Secretary, is if we look at what we should do for our progeny in the decades and centuries to come, if we begin now with some sort of an effective study-- and of course, this would be based on the people behind you for the beginning, but then a commission that would in fact check out the feasibility, run the questions, create the question of could we have a higher confidence, and could we have it every day of every month of every year rather than the estimates today, which we rely on the estimates during the interim period. Why are they not as accurate or more accurate than the once every 10 years? So I plant this for you because your real legacy can only be affected slightly in what you do from the time you take over to the time we have our census. You have a short period of time, and most of the time has expired. But for 12 years from now plus, there is a question of whether or not we could improve the system just as any of the portfolio of companies that you are familiar with would never close for a week once a year and think that that is the best way to count inventory. Secretary Ross. No, I certainly agree with your analogy about the private sector. That is 100 percent accurate. I do think that would be a very large undertaking to try to figure out the pluses and minuses of a continual thing, so I really do think that would require additional congressional appropriation. I don't want to divert any of the census people from the task at hand because this is a heavy enough lift the way it is. So to take some of them off that job and think about a possible alternative I really don't think is in the public's interest. So that would have to be a separate appropriation. Mr. Issa. Thank you, Mr. Secretary, and thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gowdy. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Secretary. We have got one more member to go. I am going to go last. Secretary Ross. Oh. Chairman Gowdy. I think one thing you and I both heard today, the census is constitutionally significant. It is incredibly important for purposes of our democratic republic, counting people, apportionment, even the apportionment of goods and services. And what I learned from you last week is this causal link between cost and compliance. The compliance numbers are going down, the cost is going up. I don't remember a lot from my childhood because it was a long time ago. I do remember the seriousness with which my parents took the census. It was almost a form of public service, maybe not to the level of jury service, but it was important. So if you accept the belief that most of our fellow citizens would like to help, particularly in an area that is constitutionally significant and important and kind fundamental to our form of government, what are the impediments to the compliance rate? How do we reverse the trend of our fellow citizens not voluntarily complying? Secretary Ross. Well, I can only speculate, but I will give you a couple of thoughts on it. I think the fabric of the relationship between the public and the government has been deteriorating. I think there is less public confidence in government than there has been for a long time, and I think that is one of the problems. I think a second problem is there is so much input that comes into everyone, whether it is over social media, whether it's through the conventional media, from whatever source. I think everybody is overdosed on information flow, junk mail, the whole thing. So I think information clutter is a separate problem, and it's one of the problems even with the call center. A lot of people don't like to get incoming calls from strangers for whatever reason. And the do-not-call lists have proven quite ineffective. I find even though I have only been in government a short while I got these robocalls on my official government cell phone. I think if we got--if we want to get response rates improved, we have to get rid of a lot of the intrusions that people find in the normal course. I was astonished to get--I would say I probably get two or three junk calls a day on my official government cell phone. Chairman Gowdy. Well, we might ought to switch that number, and I am happy to help you there if you want to get a different number. Maybe it won't help. I think you put your finger on something, the disconnect between the citizenry and the government and the lack of trust, which leads to the next two areas. I don't think people mind answering questions where they see the relevance. How many folks live in your household, that is directly relevant to apportionment and therefore redistricting and the provision of goods and services. I made a note you said in response to one of my colleagues that the more questions you ask, the lower the compliance rate is, and you ---- Secretary Ross. Absolutely. Chairman Gowdy.--used the word counterintuitive, and in fact I think it is not counterintuitive. It makes perfect sense. The longer something takes me, the less likely I am to do it. The more intrusive I view it, the less likely I am to do. Secretary Ross. Right. Chairman Gowdy. So I would--there are two things. I don't want to dwell on the Community Survey because it has been touched upon by a number of my colleagues. It is not lost on me that American citizens can reject a jury trial, they can reject a lawyer, they can refuse to talk to the government, they can refuse to talk to law enforcement, they can refuse to vote. It is surprising to me to see that little line at the bottom of the Community Survey that you can be punished for failing to tell the government how many bathrooms you have and what kind of fixtures you have. So given that you and I agree that the disconnect between the citizenry and the government is one of the reasons we have a low compliance rate, I would encourage you to be very judicious and thoughtful about what questions government does ask. And the other thing I would--two other points and then we are done. Cost matters. It matters, period, new paragraph. I think in lots of facets of life we are willing to pay for quality. We do it with automobiles, we do it with sporting events. I think if you were somehow able to convince our fellow citizens that they are going to get an A-plus product--you are not happy about the extra costs, but if they can swallow that, they will get an A-plus product. I think it is when you get the higher cost and a substandard product that also actually feeds the disconnect. So I don't know you well. You were kind enough to come over last week. I know nothing about your background, don't even know anything about your politics. I will tell you this. You come across as an authentic person. You come across as someone that our fellow citizens would believe on an issue like this. I would encourage you to pair up with someone who has a different political ideology. Whatever yours is, find somebody on the other side, and communicate to our fellow citizens, look, we get the disconnect. We are not trying to change that. It would be really helpful to all of us as Americans, not Republicans, not Democrats, not Southerners. It would be helpful as Americans if we got that compliance number up. It is going to save money. It is also more accurate. So I am not talking about an ad campaign where you are on an ad at the Super Bowl, although I am sure you would be great. Just use the bully pulpit of being a Cabinet-level official to kind of reassure our fellow citizens that you want to do it the right way, and you want it to be accurate, and you could use their help. Secretary Ross. Well, I think that is very good advice, and I will try very hard to use whatever bully pulpit comes with Commerce to try to achieve that. Chairman Gowdy. Well, on behalf of everyone, I want to thank you not just for today but also the briefing you gave us yesterday. We have another panel. I know that you have other things to do, so we are going to recess and then allow the second panel to come forward. And with that, thanks on behalf of all of us for your time this morning. Secretary Ross. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Gowdy. Yes, sir. [Recess.] Chairman Gowdy. I want to welcome our second panel. I want to thank you for your patience. It was a little longer morning, but we made it, so thank you. I will introduce you, recognize you for your five-minute openings. And Mr. Cummings is coming, and he graciously told me to go ahead and start. From my left to right, Mr. Robert Goldenkoff, director of strategic issues, census issues at the Government Accountability Office; Mr. David Powner, director of information technology management issues at the Government Accountability Office; Ms. Carol Rice, assistant inspector general for economic and statistical program assessment at the Department of Commerce Office of Inspector General; and Ms. Vanita Gupta, president and CEO of the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights. I think all of you have testified before. You know what the little coloring system means. Green means go, yellow means run through the light as quick--yellow is speed up, get through it as quick as you can, and red, you are going to get stopped. I won't stop you right at five minutes because it is really important, but your opening statement is part of the record. So with that, Mr. Goldenkoff. WITNESS STATEMENTS PANEL II: STATEMENT OF ROBERT GOLDENKOFF Mr. Goldenkoff. Chairman Gowdy, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee, GAO is pleased to be here today to discuss the Census Bureau's readiness for the 2020 headcount. As you know, in recent years we have identified a number of operational, management, and other challenges that raise serious concerns about the Bureau's ability to conduct a cost-effective enumeration, and in February 2017, we added the 2020 census to our list of high-risk government programs. My remarks today will focus on two such challenges: implementing design innovations aimed at controlling costs, and developing reliable cost estimates that better account for risks and inform annual budget requests. My colleague David Powner will then discuss the challenges the Bureau faces in implementing and securing critical IT systems. The bottom line is that, while the Bureau has made considerable progress in redesigning the census, significant risks and uncertainties remain. Moreover, as Secretary Ross mentioned, the decennial is now projected to cost $15.6 billion, more than $3 billion above the Bureau's original estimate. Going forward, continued management, attention, and congressional oversight will be needed in the short time remaining until census day to ensure that key components and IT systems are fully tested and will function as required, that preparations stay on schedule, that cost estimates follow leading practices, and any further cost growth is capped. To help control costs while maintaining accuracy, the Bureau will use new procedures and technology for 2020, including greater use of automated data collection methods, administrative records in place of--collected by enumerators, verifying addresses using aerial imagery and other in-office procedures, and allowing households the option of responding to the census via the internet. While these new methods may control costs, they also introduce new risks in part because they have not been used to a great extent and prior decennials, if at all. To help ensure that key systems and procedures will function as planned, the Bureau has held a series of tests since 2012 at various sites across the country. The Bureau is currently conducting the 2018 end-to-end test in Pierce County, Washington; Providence County, Rhode Island; and the Bluefield- Beckley-Oak Hill areas of West Virginia. The test began in August 2017 and is scheduled to run through April of 2019. Essentially, a dress rehearsal for the actual enumeration, the 2018 test is the Bureau's final opportunity to demonstrate that essential census-taking activities will perform under operational conditions. However, in May 2017, because of budgetary constraints, the Bureau de-scoped the test and only plans to conduct a complete test in Rhode Island. The Washington and West Virginia sites will only assess address canvassing. This is not the first time the Bureau has curtailed its testing. Citing funding uncertainties, the Bureau canceled field components of a 2017 test. Importantly, without sufficient testing across a range of geographic locations, housing types, and demographic groups, operational problems can go undiscovered, and the opportunity to refine procedures and systems will be lost. Another risk factor is the quality of the Bureau's estimate of the cost of the 2020 census, which does not conform to best practices. Quality cost estimates can help an agency manage large complex activities like the decennial, as well as help Congress make funding decisions and provide sufficient oversight. However, the Bureau's 2015 cost estimate only partially met the characteristics of two best practices, that of comprehensiveness and accuracy, and minimally met the other two best practices well-documented and credible. Additionally, the Bureau has not yet publicly released an update to its 2015 cost estimate, yes several events since then, including changes in system requirements and procedures, indicate that the decennial lifecycle cost will be substantially higher than the original estimate of $12.5 billion. The Bureau's preparations for 2020 have been further complicated by ongoing vacancies in the positions of census director and deputy director. Although acting leadership has since been named, turnover in the Bureau's top ranks makes it difficult to ensure accountability and continuity, as well as to mitigate risks and control costs over the long term. This concludes my prepared remarks. I will now turn it over to my colleague Dave Powner, who will discuss the risks facing the Census Bureau's IT efforts. [Prepared statement of Mr. Goldenkoff follows:] [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.008 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.009 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.010 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.011 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.012 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.013 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.014 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.015 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.016 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.017 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.018 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.019 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.020 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.021 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.022 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.023 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.024 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.025 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.026 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.027 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.028 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.029 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.030 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.031 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.032 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.033 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.034 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.035 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.036 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.037 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.038 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.039 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.040 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.041 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.042 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.043 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.044 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.045 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.046 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.047 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] T0245.048 STATEMENT OF DAVID A. POWNER Mr. Powner. Chairman Gowdy, thank you for inviting us to testify on the Bureau's plans to deliver and secure key technologies for the 2020 census. These technologies, if appropriately deployed, can improve our nation's response rates and secure citizens' data. This technology has not been effectively plans or managed, and much work remains to deliver it. Three areas require congressional attention associated with the technologies. They are schedule, security, and cost growth. I will expand on each of these starting with schedule. The Bureau needs to deliver 43 systems for the 2020 decennial. Some are new systems and infrastructure, while others are changes to existing systems. Clearly, the internet response capability, mobile devices, and the centralized operations component are critical systems. These systems need to be ready for the end-to-end test that started in August to ensure that they are integrated appropriately. The Bureau has missed many milestones and currently only four of the 43 have completed development and testing. Of the remaining 39, 21 have delivered some functionality while nothing has been delivered for the remaining 18 for this test. Many of these systems have key delivery dates in early 2018 so that they can be included in the end-to-end test. These systems include the internet response, the mobile device enumeration application, and the fraud detection system. The mobile device application has been running behind schedule for some time, and we have serious concerns about the timely delivery of the fraud detection system. I'm not sure I agree with the Secretary's comment this morning that the systems are on schedule. The appendix in our written statement lays out each of these 43 systems' delivery dates, and we'll be tracking each of these closely for this committee. We are especially concerned that schedule pressure and late deliveries will result in compressed and inadequate testing. Turning to security, the Bureau needs to continue its diligence in this area since it has been the target of recent cyber attacks. The Bureau needs to minimize the threat of phishing, secure about 400,000 mobile devices, ensure security of cloud services, and properly configure all systems. To ensure that all systems are as secure as possible, the Bureau needs to assess security controls, fix known deficiencies, and have the proper signoff by both the chief information officer and the head of the decennial office to ensure that each system is authorized to operate. This process is critical since 33 of the 43 systems contain personally identifiable information. The Bureau has such a process, but we have concerns about whether there will be ample time to complete all the security work given the late delivery dates of the system and whether shortcuts will be taken due to pressure to authorize prematurely. Right now, all 43 systems need to be authorized-- reauthorized or authorized. This is a point that I think it is fair to say Congressman Hurd hammered home quite well. Finally, we have concerns about cost growth associated with these technologies and have had these concerns for some time. The CEDCaP program, as mentioned by Secretary Ross in his testimony, has overrun about $400 million and is now costing about $1 billion. Baseline IT costs seem to be changing constantly. The latest from the Bureau is that IT costs were about $3.4 billion, but this total did not include about $1.4 billion, bringing the total cost closer to $5 billion, not $3.5 billion. As mentioned by Secretary Ross, the new lifecycle estimate includes this additional $1.5 billion that was previously unaccounted for. We will be tracking these costs closely because, given the remaining work and past mismanagement, we remain concerned about cost growth in this area even with built-in contingencies. In conclusion, schedule security and cost growth are major concerns that we will continue to monitor for the Congress. Mr. Chairman, thank you for holding this hearing and your oversight of the 2020 decennial. Chairman Gowdy. Ms. Rice? STATEMENT OF CAROL N. RICE Ms. Rice. Good afternoon, Chairman Gowdy, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee. I appreciate the opportunity to testify about the Bureau's 2020 census lifecycle cost estimate. We all support the Bureau's ultimate goal: to produce a high-quality census while minimizing cost. But over the last several years, we've produced a number of reports that have found weaknesses in how the Bureau allocates costs, collects cost data, and estimates costs for the 2020 census. My testimony today provides additional details about these limitations. First, we found that the Bureau's 2020 census lifecycle cost estimate cannot be validated. Second, much of our work throughout this decade reveals cost overruns, unaccounted for costs, and decreased cost avoidance. To the first point, the Bureau's cost estimate is not auditable. It takes into account more than 100 inputs, but when we tried to verify their accuracy during the 2014 census test, there was no supporting documentation. Additionally, we evaluated the interactive review portion of the in-office address canvassing operation and found that the estimate was derived from undocumented verbal conversations. This lack of documentation prevented us from auditing the estimated cost avoidance the Bureau reported to stakeholders. Similarly, we identified three instances where the Bureau's census tests failed to capture cost data that could validate and update the cost estimate. Both the 2014 census test and the 2015 address validation test intended to collect cost data in the field, but it didn't. Finally, during the 2015 census test, we found that the Bureau could not differentiate between the cost performing enumeration versus administrative activities. Therefore, it could not determine whether the new enumeration methods were more effective and more efficient than was achieved by just reducing administrative burdens. We also reported weaknesses with how the Bureau accounts for cost. In auditing its process for implementing the fiscal year 2014 budget cuts, we found that the Bureau recorded employee costs based on predetermined budget allocations instead of the actual hours worked. In addition, we found multiple instances where contractor costs were not charged to the correct activities. All of these accounting and estimation weaknesses prevent the Bureau from making informed decisions. Second, we are concerned about cost overruns, unaccounted for costs, and decreased cost avoidance. For example, the Bureau initially projected spending $656 million for the CEDCaP program and now it's estimated at $965 million. And I think based on what the Secretary just said, it will be even higher. One audit of the--our audit of the Bureau's address canvassing test also found substantial overruns. The Bureau estimated that spending for in-office address canvassing would be $44 million between fiscal year 2016 through 2019, but our review found it would cost nearly three times that amount at $125 million. Finally, our evaluation of the 2016 census test identified unaccounted-for cost with the redesigned NRFU operations. We found that the operational control system allowed enumerators to make more NRFU contact attempts than the cost estimate accounted for, so the expectation was they would go up to six times, and we found them going many, many more times. We are also concerned about the increased unresolved rates, as observed in the test, the potential need to expend additional resources that are not currently accounted for in the Bureau's cost estimate. In conclusion, we applaud the Census Bureau for undertaking several major initiatives to modernize its decennial operations. We recognize that not all the innovations will perform as expected, and that some of the 2020 cost savings may not materialize. However, for stakeholders to have confidence in the cost estimate, the Bureau must strengthen its cost accounting processes by documenting inputs and capturing and tracking all project costs correctly. I'm encouraged by the recent efforts to improve the lifecycle cost estimate. The Bureau has started linking documentation to the variables in its estimate, and as we've just heard, the Secretary's task force worked closely with the Bureau to improve that estimate. We are looking forward to reviewing that final product. So thank you very much for inviting me, and I'm pleased to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Ms. Rice follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Gowdy. Thank you, Ms. Rice. Ms. Gupta? STATEMENT OF VANITA GUPTA Ms. Gupta. Chairman Gowdy, Ranking Member Cummings, and members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to be here today. The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights is a coalition of more than 200 national organizations that--and has been deeply engaged in the last several cycles of the decennial census. The Leadership Conference shares this committee's concerns and interest in a modern, secure, and cost-effective 2020 census. Technology can facilitate easy and less costly participation in the census. However, to uphold its constitutional duty and ensure an accurate and fully inclusive count, Congress must allocate sufficient resources to count historically undercounted communities, as well as easier-to- count communities. It must also provide funding for comprehensive risk management and preparations for real-time backup methods and operations, and we're pleased to submit for the record two reports from the Leadership Conference in addressing both opportunities and the risks posed by the use of technology and of administrative records in the 2020 census. Per the Constitution, the primary and overarching goal of the census is a fair and accurate enumeration of all people living in the United States on census day. And the goal of a census that is equally successful in all communities is really nonnegotiable. These aren't, as the chairman said, Republican goals or Democratic goals. They are shared American goals, and achieving them is going to be very key to our representative system of government. But insufficient, uncertain, and frequently late annual funding has delayed and derailed important census testing and preparations, as you've heard already. Most at risk are operations that are specifically designed to enumerate historically hard-to-count communities. The Census Bureau needs a steady ramp-up and funding to support a critical dress rehearsal, deployment of the IT architecture and field structure, and development of a massive communications campaign that is going to encourage people to participate and therefore at the backend help keep census costs in check. We support the proposal in Congresswoman Maloney's new bill. I won't go through the details of that because you have that already before you. But the census has political consequences, of course. In fact, the Constitution says as much by basing congressional apportionment and equal representation on the population count. But the conduct of the census must be strictly nonpartisan and must strive to achieve an equally accurate account in all communities. Unfortunately, even with careful planning, we may be looking at an environment that could yield significant undercounts in poor communities, rural areas, communities that are recovering from natural disasters, communities of color, as well as undercounts of young children, immigrants, and others who have a palpable mistrust of government, who have deep concerns about cybersecurity and the security of their information, as well as in rural communities where the digital divide is particularly pronounced. There are hard-to-count communities in every State and hard-to-count populations in communities of all sizes from large urban areas to smaller cities to rural and remote communities, including American Indian tribal lands and reservations. And just two points to note for both members here, nearly 10 percent of census tracts in South Carolina are hard to count per Census Bureau research, and 27 percent of Baltimore's population live in hard-to-count census tracts. Regrettably, we fear that the strict budget constraints Congress has imposed on the 2020 census add to these formidable barriers. The Census Bureau is going to attempt to minimize undercounting but is going to be hampered by a smaller footprint in the field. And as you know, when your constituents are not counted in the census, they remain invisible for the next 10 years. There aren't any do-overs, and there's no question that the Census Bureau must get it right for the first time because all of us, Members of Congress, county officials, and mayors, school principals, veterans, advocates, businesses large and small, and indeed all of us in the United States have to live with the results of it for the next 10 years. So the Leadership Conference and our member organizations look forward to working with all of you to ensure a cost- effective, secure, and above all an accurate and inclusive census in every single one of our nation's communities. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Ms. Gupta follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Gowdy. I want to thank all four of you for your opening statements. I also want to thank you for doing it in less than five minutes, which is something that Members of Congress cannot do, so I hope you consider running some time. Mr. Cummings, my friend from Maryland. Mr. Cummings. Certain population groups have historically been undercounted in the decennial census, specifically minorities such as African Americans, Hispanics, and American Indians on reservations are counted at rates much lower than others. Ms. Gupta, what are some of the reasons these groups are undercounted? Ms. Gupta. Well, I think that one significant reason--and it's particularly of concern right now--is the mistrust of the Federal Government and whether communities will be--whether their information when filling out the census will be safe and not used for enforcement purposes or-- and the like is particularly I would say right now among--in immigrant communities, but there's also a real concern around the digital divide and what that might do with--and I would say it's even more acute in rural communities, as well as, you know, real concerns around cybersecurity and whether their information is going to be breached and the like. But a lot of hard-to-count--a lot of these harder-to-count communities, with communities of color, there is a lot of mobility in these communities. They need to be--have trusted partners in the field from the census, whether it's through organizations like the ones that make up the Leadership Conference or through trusted partnerships with the Census Bureau to have trusted messengers that are explaining the purpose of the census, why it's important to be counted, and that's why the partnership program and the communications aspects of the census need to be adequately funded because without that, there's no chance of getting an accurate count, and that will ultimately fail the entire census and the country. Mr. Cummings. One thing that Secretary Ross said to the chairman and I the other day is that the cost of labor he thinks has to go up because you have got to get a certain kind of person, the type that you just talked about, and to get--and I was just trying--as you were talking, I was trying to figure out how do you penetrate that? I mean, how do you get past that problem because if people are not trusting of government, if they are worried about immigration issues maybe not for themselves but for family members, and then there are some people that just--they don't even know what the census is. All they know is that the government is knocking on their door. And any time the government is knocking on their door, they assume that it is something bad. I know because I lived in a neighborhood like that. So how do you get past that? Ms. Gupta. Well, I really think it's critical that the census have--the Bureau have the infrastructure around the communications machinery and the partnership program. And we were encouraged--I was encouraged today when I heard the Secretary talk about a projected communications budget of $500 million, but I think it's really important to ensure that there is enough money to actually promote census participation in our many diverse communities and to address some of the unprecedented challenges that the 2020 census is going to be facing around, as I said, the mistrust of government, cybersecurity fears, fear of Federal Government agencies. And I think it's deeply important that the Commerce Department and the Census Bureau consult closely with stakeholders who know these communities well, who are in these communities, who can be trusted messengers and know best how to convey the information and the value of what it means to be counted. And that's the only way I think that we're going to be able to ensure that there's a fair and accurate count. And of course there's already deep concerns about the canceled testing and the like that could have other implications for the accuracy of the census in the next--in 2020. Mr. Cummings. Talking about the canceled testing, I understand that one test the Bureau canceled in 2017 due to insufficient funds was to be conducted on tribal land, including on the Standing Rock Reservation. Is that what you are referring to? Considering that Native Americans were the most undercounted group of the 2010 census, this is a very significant. Ms. Gupta, what are the implications of canceling this and other critical tests, particularly for rural areas and American Indian reservations? Ms. Gupta. Well, you know, it's the--there's a statistic that we have that 87 percent of the hardest-to-count counties in the 2010 census were rural counties, and given that this is the first high-tech census, I think there's a lot of questions that you have heard a lot of concerns both about cybersecurity, about whether there's going--the technology is going to work. While obviously we all want a modernized census, you have to be able to test it, and testing it in rural communities as well as in hard-to-count communities is going to be really important to be able to actually get it done in 2020. And the fact that they canceled because of insufficient funding three out of four of the census test runs, end-to-end test runs is really of great concern, and it will hamper--this lack of preparation, you know, could very well hamper the accuracy and fairness of the census count in 2020. Mr. Cummings. With the chair's indulgence, I just have one question, one last question. The alleged cost savings of such cancellations are, as they say, penny wise but pound foolish. Mr. Goldenkoff? Mr. Goldenkoff. Yes. Mr. Cummings. GAO has reported that higher response rates save money. Can you try to explain that to us? Mr. Goldenkoff. Sure. The most cost-effective way to count people is when they fill out the questionnaire that's either mailed to them or when they self-respond via the internet. Every time--and if they don't self-respond through either of those methods, then the Census Bureau has to send out enumerators to knock on their doors and--as many as six times. And so you can see how costs add up very quickly. It's both in terms of the time that the enumerators are paid for, the wages that they earn, as well as for the mileage that they're reimbursed. So the most cost-effective way of conducting the census is to get up to increase that initial count. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman yields back. Mr. Powner, I was sitting here trying to figure out whether anything could be more inherently predictable than the decennial census. I really am struggling to think of something that you see that far in advance that is coming. So not to ask this in too sophisticated of a way, but how the hell did we get here if we know it is coming every 10 years? How do you get on a critical watchlist? Mr. Powner. Well, the thing that's a bit frustrating is the same thing happen in 2010, and we actually were involved in that in 2010. So that's when we canceled the handheld project. This committee held multiple hearings on the overruns there and the eventual cancellation. The interesting comment that Secretary Ross talked about, 80 percent of the monies going from--beyond 2018, from an IT perspective, that should not be the case. We should start early, plan more appropriately, get the right contracts in place, and deliver. What happens with the decennial historically and it's going to happen again, can we get this done late and secure it late? Yes. But you know what it's going to be? It's going to be at higher cost. You pay a premium for doing everything late. I would have major concerns about the 15.6 and still hitting that even with the 10 percent when you look at the IT management of this. The thing that's good is having the Commerce Department's governance and oversight I think will greatly help, but we still haven't changed the basic management of how we're doing things at the Census Bureau, so we would still have concerns about additional cost overruns going forward. But it is--it's not acceptable that we repeat the same sins of the past that we do every 10 years with the decennial. Chairman Gowdy. It is really hard to explain to the same people that you are trying to convince to voluntarily comply, which leads to my next question. What are the impediments? Mr. Goldenkoff, what are the impediments to what I call voluntary compliance, although I am sure that is not the right technical term? Mr. Goldenkoff. Sure. There are a number of barriers. One that was already mentioned was just declining civic engagement. People are increasingly disconnected from the government, you know, so that requires trust, building trust between the Census Bureau and the public. There's also a cultural divide. You know, when--and it was already mentioned, too, when the government comes knocking on your door, you know, the census is sometimes seen as not something that's done for you or on your behalf. It's sometimes seen as something that's done to you. It's not always seen in a positive light. Then there's structural barriers, people living in makeshift housing, nonconventional housing, people doubling up, people living in basements and converted attics, so they're just physically hard to find. There are language barriers out there, so just reaching those folks is difficult as well. And this is why all this upfront work is so important and why the Census Bureau is at the point that it is right now. It's very difficult to make up for either funding that was not provided or time that's already elapsed. You can get behind the curve very quickly. Chairman Gowdy. Well, accepting the fact that we can't do all of the preplanning for 2020 that needed to be done in 2012, 2013, so the best we can do is the 2030 census there. With specific reference to the 2020 that is coming up, if I heard the testimony right, there is an opening in the census director's office? So I'm going to start with Ms. Gupta. If you were the census director and you got to do one thing and you have got to do it today, upon the chance that Mr. Ross or his folks may be listening, what is the single most important thing you would do today for the 2020 census? Ms. Gupta. It's hard to say a single thing. I think two--a couple things need to happen all at once. The IT infrastructure needs to be tested clearly for all of the reasons that have been previously stated. And I think that the partnership and communications campaigns need to be out there starting in the next couple of months. They've got to ramp up this whole infrastructure in order to really educate folks about why it's important to be counted and to overcome some of the real concerns around mistrusting government and cybersecurity. And so--and, you know, I want to add that when the Secretary was testifying, he said that he anticipated 800 partnership specialists, which is well below the 2010 number of 3,800, and so those plans are still inadequate, and I just think that right now there is a lot of concern that the hardest-to-count communities are not going to be adequately counted, and that will result in a failed census even with the $1.6 billion if allocated. And so we have to--there has to be an immediate investment in that infrastructure and kind of real planning around it, just as there is with the IT. Chairman Gowdy. Ms. Rice, what is the single most or two if you want--what needs to be done today, given the fact that we can't change the lack of preplanning? Ms. Rice. I really think the IT infrastructure has to be in place. We don't want to be in a position where we were in 2010 where--and they had to revert to a paper-based operation at the last minute. And they didn't have the--they had some infrastructure there, and they had to build on it, and it was a problem. There were backlogs, and they--you know, the office sizes weren't compatible for a paper operation. I mean, there were--it was just a trickle down, all the problems. They got it done, but it wasn't pretty. So getting that IT infrastructure in place, it's ---- Chairman Gowdy. Mr. Powner, you can't use the word infrastructure. What would you do? Mr. Powner. So with the IT, and that's my world, Mr. Chairman, I would say those 43 systems need to be delivered and secured. And, you know, we have this data in our testimony that looks all neat and every--it's very difficult to get a handle on where all the systems are from a delivery point of view, integration and security. That needs to be managed weekly. Someone needs to dog that weekly in terms of what we got done, what remains next week, and are we going to hit those dates. There's key dates in early 2018 that are going to be key to getting this stuff delivered to be included in the end-to-end test, so you have to dog the 43 systems from a security perspective, Chairman. Representative Hurd's comments about the ATO process, it's fine to bring in people, but you know what, you need to actually do the assessments and you need to fix the vulnerabilities and you need to sign off on the ATOs. That needs to be managed weekly to ensure that that gets done and we don't have a major breach. Chairman Gowdy. Mr. Goldenkoff, last question, the diminution of public trust, it didn't happen overnight. It is not going to be remedied overnight. What is something that perhaps Members of Congress haven't thought about or what is something you would do to try to restore some modicum of public trust so we can raise the voluntary compliance rate in 2020? Mr. Goldenkoff. Sure. It's--I don't--you know, off the top of my head I don't think there's anything new, and I would certainly be leery of trying anything that has not been used before at this point just because it will be one more risk for the Bureau to have to manage. What I think needs to be done is focus on the tried-and-true methods, things that are known to work, and I would point to the partnership specialists and the whole communication and outreach campaign. The partnership specialists are so critical for engaging the different people that they represent, their different stakeholder groups, and they're the ones who create the trust. They are the trusted voices. If, you know, Secretary Ross or any of us goes up on TV or, you know, makes--encourages people to respond to the census, it's not going to have the same level of response as people who know the community, your local minister, your school principal. It was mentioned before that the Census Bureau hopes to hire as many as 800 partnership specialists. That sounds like a large number, but if you just look at the workload, if you think if there are over 3,000 counties in this country, that's a huge workload for them. It's a three-dimensional issue. They have to cover both physical geography, the different channels of communication, plus the deep dive into all the different communities. And so I think a focus then on the partnership campaign and making sure that that's adequately funded and gets the resources they need will be critical for increasing the count in hard-to-count communities. Chairman Gowdy. Mr. Palmer. Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Rice, can you provide your initial thoughts and observations of the 2018 end-to-end testing? Ms. Rice. Sure. So we did visit all three locations and found--just to remind everybody about 2010, they actually did use a device in 2010. The field data collection automation worked for address canvassing. They abandoned it for NRFU or nonresponse follow-up. So using a device in the field for address canvassing they did last decennial, so it actually went, all things considered, okay. I didn't see any major ---- Mr. Palmer. Was there any aspect of the testing stand out to you as raising any potential issue for future address canvassing? Ms. Rice. We did think that in the rural areas that there's something called an optimizer that sends the lister to a location, that it wasn't as efficient as maybe it could have been. We're trying to look into that as--to find out why. But there were people--some folks traveling a couple of hours to get to locations, which seems fairly inefficient. Mr. Palmer. Well, your office raised some issues. You actually published a report questioning the Bureau's in-office address canvassing cost estimates, as well as warning that an increase in the infield canvassing could increase cost. Will the percentage of addresses sent for infield work during the testing be a factor in your review as you consider that issue? Ms. Rice. Yes. So the in-office address canvassing basically determines whether something--a block looks like it grew or changed. So if indeed the test--the results don't show that that process worked very well, there will be more infield address canvassing, and that will raise costs. The Bureau is in the process of putting out a study to show the effectiveness of in-office address canvassing. We, too, plan on trying to look at that to see how well it worked because that is a concern. If in-office address canvassing isn't predicting the infield workload, that can be a problem, and it can ---- Mr. Palmer. Is that part of the increase in the cost estimate? Is that already taken into account or is that going to be in addition to what they are saying we are needing now? Ms. Rice. Yes, my understanding is because the in-office address canvassing consisted of two pieces, the interactive review, which was satellite imagery, and then the second part was an active block resolution where they take the results from the imagery and try to find the households. They canceled the active block review, and those housing units will now go into infield address canvassing. So that will create an increase. Mr. Palmer. Mr. Goldenkoff, in panel one with Secretary Ross it got a little intense in some of the questions that were asked, and part of the issue is that the Census Bureau has I think pretty evident a poor track record in addressing flaws and problems that have been identified by the OIG office and GAO. Would you like to enlighten us a little bit on this relationship between your office and the Census Bureau and their willingness to follow up on the things that you have suggested ---- Mr. Goldenkoff. Sure. Mr. Palmer.--which your office has suggested? Mr. Goldenkoff. In that respect, you know, we're encouraged by willingness to work with us and other stakeholder groups. Just some examples of the way that we engaged the Census Bureau, on a monthly basis we meet with the acting director and deputy director and before that with the director of the Census Bureau. We share information about ongoing problems. We do have regular discussions about the progress that they're making on implementing our recommendations. They're much more transparent than they used to be. I've been involved with census issues since 1997, and there really has been a sea change in terms of the culture at the Census Bureau and their willingness to work with outside groups, us. And going into the 2000 census, it was very standoffish, tried to keep GAO at bay and other organizations. Now, they embrace our recommendations, and that goes all the way up to the Department of Commerce level as well. We've had some meetings with Commerce Secretary, and they been very effective and very willing to work with us. Mr. Palmer. And you said currently I think--I'm not sure exactly the way you used it, but one of the questions that I raised to Secretary Ross is the fact that the GAO had a high- risk list. You issued 30 recommendations over three years but only six of them were fully implemented by January. Mr. Goldenkoff. Right. Mr. Palmer. And obviously under Secretary Ross he inherited that problem. I think what we on the committee would like to determine is how much willingness is there to work with the GAO or Mr. Powner with the OIG's office to resolve these issues and do it in a timely manner? Is that what you are finding now, that there is this willingness, a ---- Mr. Goldenkoff. Oh, absolutely. They really embrace our recommendations now, and that was not the case a decade or more ago. Mr. Palmer. Well, I think both your offices had expressed some concerns that the Bureau is failing to adequately test systems and products, and that was one of the issues raised by my colleague from Georgia. I appreciated Secretary Ross' answer that you can't test a system until the system is in place, but one of the things, again, that we emphasized to the Secretary is that we want him to test the systems and we want the test results to be used in the decision-making process. Are you finding them to be working in an agreeable manner on that? Mr. Powner. So, first of all, they had delivered the systems, so once we get all the systems delivered, there is a plan to test it in an integrated fashion. I will give the Bureau credit that they did higher an integration contractor to help with that. We think that's a good thing. The issue ends up being can they get all that delivered, integrated, and secured in the time that remains? It's highly likely not everything will be in 2018 end-to-end test, and--so what does that mean? That means they're going to have to test it post end-to-end test. And again, it's not that it can't be done, but there is-- you know, you're compressing testing schedules. There's higher risk. There's more cost and that type of thing. But that something that we will monitor closely to ensure all those integration tests are done appropriately. Mr. Palmer. When was that contract awarded to that contractor? Mr. Powner. Pardon me? Mr. Palmer. When did they award this contract to the contractor? Mr. Powner. That would have been in the summer of '16. Mr. Palmer. Is there a particular reason why they can't get the work done so that it could be tested pre-census? Mr. Powner. Well, they're trying to get it done so--pre- census. I mean, they're working hard to get that done. That integration contractor is relying on other contracts-- contractors to deliver their systems. And again, you know, we missed milestones. We had some late starts, and they kind of inherited a bad problem, so they're kind of coming in to mop up. Mr. Palmer. Well, I appreciate your willingness to come before the committee today and answer our questions. With that, Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Gowdy. The gentleman from Alabama yields back. On behalf of all the members of the committee, I want to thank you for your time today, for your expertise, and your commitment to an accurate census in 2020. The hearing record will remain open for two weeks for any member to submit a written opening statement or questions for the record. If there is no further business, thank you again for your testimony today, and we are adjourned. [Whereupon, at 1:02 p.m., the committee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]