Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- UNION TIME ON THE PEOPLE'S DIME: A CLOSER LOOK AT OFFICIAL TIME [House Hearing, 115 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] UNION TIME ON THE PEOPLE'S DIME: A CLOSER LOOK AT OFFICIAL TIME ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ MAY 24, 2018 __________ Serial No. 115-86 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://oversight.house.gov ________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 31-272 PDF WASHINGTON: 2018 Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Trey Gowdy, South Carolina, Chairman John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Elijah E. Cummings, Maryland, Darrell E. Issa, California Ranking Minority Member Jim Jordan, Ohio Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Justin Amash, Michigan Columbia Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Jim Cooper, Tennessee Thomas Massie, Kentucky Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia Mark Meadows, North Carolina Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Ron DeSantis, Florida Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Dennis A. Ross, Florida Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Mark Walker, North Carolina Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois Rod Blum, Iowa Jamie Raskin, Maryland Jody B. Hice, Georgia Jimmy Gomez, Maryland Steve Russell, Oklahoma Peter Welch, Vermont Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Matt Cartwright, Pennsylvania Will Hurd, Texas Mark DeSaulnier, California Gary J. Palmer, Alabama Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands James Comer, Kentucky John P. Sarbanes, Maryland Paul Mitchell, Michigan Greg Gianforte, Montana Sheria Clarke, Staff Director Robert Borden, Deputy Staff Director William McKenna, General Counsel Kevin Ortiz, Professional Staff Member Kiley Bidelman, Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director ------ Subcommittee on Government Operations Mark Meadows, North Carolina, Chairman Jody B. Hice, Georgia, Vice Chair Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia, Jim Jordan, Ohio Ranking Minority Member Mark Sanford, South Carolina Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Thomas Massie, Kentucky Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Ron DeSantis, Florida Columbia Dennis A. Ross, Florida Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Rod Blum, Iowa Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on May 24, 2018..................................... 1 WITNESSES Mr. Trey Kovacs, Policy Analyst, Competitive Enterprise Institute Oral Statement............................................... 5 Written Statement............................................ 7 Mr. Bob Gilson, Senior Labor and Employee Relations Consultant and Author Oral Statement............................................... 15 Written Statement............................................ 17 Mr. Darrell M. West, Vice President and Director of Governance Studies, Brookings Institution Oral Statement............................................... 33 Written Statement............................................ 35 APPENDIX Committee Staff Report on Official Time Data, Submitted by Chairman Meadows............................................... 52 The Official Time Usage Report for FY 2016, submitted by Chairman Meadows........................................................ 59 Letter for the Record from the Department of Education, submitted by Chairman Meadows............................................ 86 Democratic Rebuttal to the Republican Staff Memo, submitted by Ranking Member Connolly........................................ 88 Statement for the Record of the National Treasury Employees Union, submitted by Ranking Member Connolly.................... 91 Statement for the Record of the American Federation of Government Employees, submitted by Ranking Member Connolly................ 94 Statement for the Record of the International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers, submitted by Ranking Member Connolly................................................ 97 Unfair Labor Charge filed by the AFGE against the Department of Education, submitted by Ranking Member Connolly................ 99 Editorial from The Ledger, submitted by Mr. Ross................. 101 Questions for the Record for Mr. Robert Gilson, submitted by Ranking Member Connolly........................................ 110 UNION TIME ON THE PEOPLE'S DIME: A CLOSER LOOK AT OFFICIAL TIME ---------- Thursday, May 24, 2018 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Government Operations, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 10:44 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Mark Meadows [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Meadows, Hice, Jordan, DeSantis, Ross, Blum, Connolly, Maloney, and Norton. Mr. Meadows. The Subcommittee on Government Operations will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Official time is a term for Federal employees performing union representational activities during normal working hours while getting paid for their regular salaries. A number of employees using official time and the amount of hours spent on it are governed by collective bargaining agreements at agencies. Some collective bargaining agreements even allow for certain employees to spend 100 percent of their time on official time, meaning that they never do the job that they were hired to do. On January 9, I, along with some of my colleagues of this committee and the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, sent a letter to 24 agencies requesting information on official time usage in the Federal Government. The results were quite interesting and likely surprising to the average taxpayer. Some 12,508 employees at 23 agencies in fiscal year 2017 used official time in some capacity. Of those, nearly 1,000 spent half or all of their workday on official time. And another 221 employees in this category were paid over $100,000 by the Federal Government. In total, the Federal Government spends $1 billion on salaries of employees who took at least some of their work time as official time. Every hour spent on official time is an hour spent away from some of the critical tasks the Federal Government really has before it. In the case of the Veterans Affairs Department, there are 472 employees who spent 50 percent or more of their time on official time, meaning that they were not caring for the veterans. And in the case of the Internal Revenue Service, 185 employees spent 100 percent of their time performing representational work on behalf of the union, which means that they are not serving the American taxpayer. I ask that the committee staff report be inserted into the record. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Meadows. Now, while not performing the work an employee was hired to do is bad enough, there are other aspects of official time that can impact the mission. Official time allows unions to follow grievances and appeals to the administrative agencies and bring the work of the government to a halt. By way of example, we have heard from a Federal employee who told us that after repeated requests that an employee come to work on time, this employee complained that the official was harassing the employee and filed a grievance. The union representative got involved, and after weeks of back and forth, the employee's agency allowed the employee to push back her start time by 15 minutes. Now, to me, as a private business guy, this sounds absurd. The grievances filed while on--filled while on official time can also implicate national security. Luke Air Force Base in Arizona ended off-base access to email system with only a password after it experienced multiple security breaches. The union filed a grievance arguing that this was a change in the working conditions that the Air Force base first needed to do negotiate. Now, this committee is not alone in examining official time. A recent Office of Personnel Management report found that official time usage is on the rise governmentwide. The Federal Government saw a 4.76 percent increase in hours spent on official time from fiscal year 2014 to fiscal year 2016. OPM also estimated that the total cost of official time in fiscal year 2016 to be $177.2 million. OPM said that this number does not reflect the true total cost, because OPM does not--the OPM report does not take into account government costs relating to the free use of government property and supplies by union officials. So I'd ask that the official time usage report for fiscal year 2016 of the Federal Government be submitted into the record. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Meadows. This administration is taking steps to reverse this troubling trend. Recently, the Department of Education narrowed considerably the amount of official time employees may use, but it did not eliminate it. I would like to enter into the record from the Department a letter explaining the recent changes made to the collective bargaining agreement. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Meadows. And in a hearing last week, the new director of OPM testified official time is a problem at agencies and that the administration is committed to reexamining its use. I would like to thank the witnesses today for their testimony and look forward to hearing their insightful comments. And with that, I recognize the ranking member, the gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Connolly, for his opening remarks. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair. And I would ask at this point before I begin, Mr. Chairman, unanimous consent that the Democratic rebuttal to the Republican staff memo, which was not cleared on our side, be entered into the record. Mr. Meadows. Without objection. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair. When Congress enacted the Civil Service Reform Act, Congress found that, and I quote, ``labor organizations and collective bargaining in the civil service are in the public interest.'' Because the reality is that unions contribute to the effective conduct of public business and facilitate settlements of employee disputes. Federal unions are required to represent all employees within a bargaining unit, including those who do not pay dues and may not seek fees from nonmembers. In exchange for those representational duties, the Civil Service Reform Act authorized the use of official time. The legal authorization for designated Federal employees to protect whistleblowers, represent colleagues in grievances against abuse, and negotiate collective bargaining agreements. Sometimes they're troubleshooters who can diffuse a situation before it gets to the litigation stage. The truth is that official time is authorized by law, negotiated by agency management with the union, and is intended to promote the peaceable resolution of disputes and the efficient operation of government. Unions and agencies must agree on the amount of time for representational activities, which must be, and I quote, ``reasonable, necessary, and in the public interest.'' Congress carefully crafted a collective bargaining system for the Federal Government that balanced the interests of the agencies involved, Federal employees, and the American public we all serve. The cost of all of these benefits: just 40 seconds per day. That's the amount of time per Federal employee official time costs the Federal Government, according to the Office of Personnel Management. That is less than the time it takes to get a cup of coffee, like this one like I got right here. Do my Republican friends want to prohibit Federal employees from getting their morning coffee because it's a drain on the Federal Government? This hearing isn't about protecting the taxpayer dollar. As the Republican staff memo makes all too clear, it's about attacking Federal employees, a central theme of this Congress, unfortunately, and the Trump administration. Last week, the Oversight Committee held a hearing to discuss the recently issued President's management agenda and the President's plan to take $143 billion from middle class Federal workers in wage and retirement cuts and to use their money to partially offset the cost of a $1.5 trillion tax giveaway to the wealthy. During this administration, Federal employees have had to deal with efforts to gut the missions of Federal agencies, attacks on the Federal workforce, and their retirement benefits, as well as the repression of and retaliation against Federal whistleblowers. We might even add censorship to scientists trying to do their work. Federal employees need more support and avenues for redress, not fewer. Whether it's through congressional oversight, inspector general investigations, or through union representatives, we should be giving Federal employees the tools they need to sound the alarm against the activities that make it harder for the Federal Government to work for the American people. If our committee wants to quibble over the 40 seconds spent on official time, it should also look into how some of the Trump administration political appointees spend their time. According to numerous press reports, Millan Hupp, the director of scheduling and advance for the EPA Administrator, Scott Pruitt, spearheaded Administrator Pruitt's search for new housing after he moved out of a sweetheart deal at a condo he rented for $50 a night from the wife of a lobbyist who had business before the Agency. Part of Ms. Hupp's search, including contacting real estate companies and viewing apartment options for Administrator Pruitt, clearly took place on official hours. Or this committee could look into the White House Presidential Personnel Office. In March, The Washington Post reported that that office, which has struggled to fill vacancies throughout the Federal Government, has become, quote, ``a social hub where young staffers throughout the administration stop by to hang out on couches and smoke electronic cigarettes.'' PPO leaders regularly host happy hours in their offices that include beer, wine, and snacks, but not only PPO employees, but also White House liaison who work for other Federal agencies. And in January, they played a drinking game in the office called ``icing'' for one employee's birthday. I've been informed that icing involves hiding a bottle of Smirnoff Ice and demanding that the person who discovers it drink it as quickly as possible. Now, these individuals may be able to guzzle a 12-ounce bottle of flavored malt liquor in 40 seconds, but it's still an infinitely less productive use of company time than official time. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses today on their perspectives regarding the impact of official time on the efficiency and effectiveness of Federal Government, and for that matter, the use of any time by any Federal employee on government time. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Meadows. I thank the gentleman for his statements. And I agree that some of the behavior that was talked about is certainly something that we do need to look at, and I'd be glad to do that in a bipartisan way. I'd like to thank the witnesses for coming today. I'll introduce Mr. Trey Kovacs, policy analyst at the Competitive Enterprise Institute; Mr. Bob Gilson, senior labor and employee relations consultant and author. Welcome. And Mr. Darrell West, vice president and director of government studies at Brookings Institute. Welcome. Welcome to you all. And pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify. If you would please rise and raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God? All right. Thank you. You may be seated. Please, the record should reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for enough questions and answers, I would ask that you limit your oral testimony to 5 minutes, but your entire written testimony will be made part of the record. There is a clock there in front of you, and so if you will just please press the red button when you go to speak and speak into the microphone. Mr. Kovacs, we recognize you for 5 minutes. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF TREY KOVACS Mr. Kovacs. Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Connolly, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for holding this hearing and providing me the opportunity to discuss official time in the Federal workforce. My name is Trey Kovacs, and I am a labor policy analyst at the Competitive Enterprise Institute. CEI is a nonprofit, nonpartisan public policy organization that focuses on regulatory issues from a free market and limited government perspective. Official time grants Federal employees paid time off from their government duties to perform union business. This taxpayer-funded subsidy to Federal employee unions enables them to file grievances, bargain, and even lobby Congress, among other activities. Unfortunately, the reality is that no one really knows how much time and money is spent by the Federal Government on official time. In addition, the lack of transparency surrounding the practice makes it impossible to know what specific activities are performed by Federal employees on official time. However, the Office of Personnel Management does occasionally produce a report that estimates the cost of official time. According to the latest data available from the OPM, in fiscal year 2016, official time cost approximately $175 million, and employees spent 3.6 million hours conducting union activities instead of their assigned public duties. Problems with official time, other than poor recordkeeping, have been recognized by administrations from both political parties. During the Clinton administration, the OPM explained when Federal employees are on official time they are not available to perform the duties associated with their regular positions. This can hamper the agency in accomplishing its mission, as certain assignments must be either be delayed, covered by other employees, or accomplished through the use of overtime. The use of significant amounts of official time may adversely affect an employee's ability to keep his or her technical skills current. Given these problems associated with official time, it is past time to consider legislative reforms. Congress should enact legislation to eliminate the practice of official time. One potential reform could eliminate official time and nullify a frequent union argument in favor of the union subsidy. Unions contend that official time is necessary because Federal employee unions are required by law to represent nonmembers who do not pay dues. This problem can easily be solved by lifting the legal requirement for Federal employee unions to represent nonmembers. Congress should consider implementing what is known as Workers Choice, a members-only union policy that relieves unions of the obligation to represent nonmembers, and as a result, eliminates the need for official time. Membership in and representation by a union should be voluntary. Nonmembers should not be forced to work under a union-negotiated agreement they do not want, and unions should not be forced to represent employees who do not pay dues. A policy of Workers Choice addresses union concerns, eliminates the need for official time, and protects workers' freedom of association. Short of eliminating official time, Federal agencies must track and record official time in greater detail and with more precision. Under the current accounting regime, the cost of official time is severely underestimated. Further, the true cost of the union subsidy is difficult to determine because of poor tracking and recording of when employees use official time. Across the Federal Government, what activities Federal employees engage in while on official time is relatively unknown. The enactment of H.R. 1293, sponsored by Representative Dennis Ross, would increase transparency regarding official time. Specifically, it requires OPM to furnish a report on the cost of official time throughout the Federal Government on an annual basis, which includes information presented in the current OPM report, details the specific activities for which official time was granted, details official time's impact on agency operations, and determine the amount of office space granted to unions to conduct official time activities. Taxpayers have a right to know how much tax dollars are used to finance official time and what activities Federal employees undertake instead of the job they are hired to do. I applaud the subcommittee's inquiry into the use of official time, and I would welcome any questions. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Mr. Kovacs follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you so much. Mr. Gilson, you're recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF BOB GILSON Mr. Gilson. Mr. Chairman, members, thank you for the opportunity---- Mr. Meadows. If you'll hit the red button there. Mr. Gilson. Thank you for the opportunity to address the subcommittee. I'm a retired Federal employee. I've worked in this area for over 40 years. As an agency representative, adviser, advocator, and negotiator, I regularly write for FedSmith, a website devoted to Federal issues, and have done so for over 10 years. I currently train, advise, and bargain on behalf of Federal agencies as a contractor. The Civil Service Reform Act was passed in 1978, and I was at the Civil Service Commission at that time as a labor relations person. Its labor relations provisions were touted by its sponsors as an encoding of President Nixon and President Ford's executive orders. It was to establish basic employee rights under a law continuing as it did before. The law has turned into a Pandora's box of unintended consequences. One result, and why we're here today, is the evolution of a concept of official time no one 40 years ago either intended or would believe. The law's creation of a Federal Labor Relations Authority and general counsel to administer government labor relations has had far-reaching consequences on Federal Government. The case law expanding the statute's official time and the creation of other broad and costly union subsidies is only one such sequence. Recently, OPM issued a report on official time for fiscal year 2016. OPM admits the report relies on agencies' submissions and that some agencies didn't even submit reports. This report, frankly, should not be relied upon. No one knows what official time costs. No one. As an example, the report says the Justice Department unions use the same official time as the Department of Defense. Justice has about 120,000 employees. Defense has 750,000. I believe DOD is more organized than Justice is in terms of labor relations. It also reports that VA, the Department of Veterans Affairs, is almost three times as much as DOD or DOJ, but yet VA has less than half the number of employees of the Department of Defense. VA's numbers are probably closer to the truth, but are also unreliable. Based on my 44 years representing agencies and interacting with program managers, I bet OPM's gross total is low by a factor of 5 or 10, and that's not a percentage figure. No one knows. By the way, labor relations official time is not the only official time representatives get. In 2009, President Obama issued Executive Order 13522 requiring agencies to engage in predecisional involvement on agency decisions and other activities. The unions complained that agencies would hold them to official time in labor agreements. They were advised by OPM that since they were complying with a Presidential order, duty time, not official time, would be appropriate for union involvement in order activities. Many thousands of hours were used under this order. No one knows what it cost. The Equal Employment Opportunity regulations creates what it also calls official time. A Federal employee representing an EEO complainant in any stage of the process is on EEOC's official time. EEOC also specifies the activities warranting its official time. There are literally hundreds of thousands of EEO allegations a year. No one knows what this costs. Also true of the Merit Systems Protection Board and Workers' Compensation. I did not include EEOC, MSPB, or OWCP time in my estimates. In agencies you might ask why don't they hold people accountable for this? Well, if you're a supervisor and you have a union steward, are you going to risk the ULPs and grievances if you try to hold their feet to the fire? In addition, if somebody is representing someone in an EEO complaint and management holds their feet to the fire on reporting time, what they'll get is a reprisal complaint. That's a fact. Official time, however defined, and other free services have never been accurately reported. All of the costs--office space, furniture, computers, internet space--all of these costs are covered by labor agreements in the government. Nobody knows what they cost. Federal unions pay nothing inside an agency to represent employees, not a single penny. When they walk in the door, their official time, their offices, their space, in many cases their travel, their training of the representatives is all paid for by the taxpayer. In closing, no one in 1978, not even the unions themselves, would have believed that the cost of Federal employee union representation would be entirely borne by the taxpayer and that virtually all union dues would be available to those unions as discretionary funds. The taxpayer has paid many billions of dollars over the last 40 years for Federal labor union activity and growth. I for one don't have a clue what they got for their money, because nobody knows what this actually costs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [Prepared statement of Mr. Gilson follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Gilson. Mr. West, you're recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF DARRELL M. WEST, PH.D. Mr. West. Thank you. Chairman Meadows, Ranking Member Connolly, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify. I am vice president of governance studies at the Brookings Institution and the author of several books. My newest book is The Future of Work: Robots, AI, and Automation, and it looks at the impact of new technologies on the workplace, education, and public policy. What I want to do today is to summarize my testimony on official time, and I'm going to talk about three points: How much it costs the Federal Government, the benefits of official time, and how proposed changes would affect Federal employees. In its April report, the Office of Personnel Management estimated that official time in fiscal year 2016 totaled 3.6 million hours and cost around $174.8 million. That comes to 2.95 hours per employee each year, and that compares to 2.88 hours in fiscal year 2014. Based on that, the report concluded that the overall 2016 hourly total represents an increase in official time over that of fiscal year 2014. But based on my reading on the report, I don't believe that conclusion is warranted by the data. The difference between 2.95 hours and 2.88 hours in 2014 is seven-hundredths of an hour or 4 minutes per employee for the year. A GAO analysis indicated concern about the OPM methodology and notes that the OPM estimate could be higher or lower. Given those data limitations, it's impossible to know if official time costs are rising, staying the same, or actually decreasing. There are a number of benefits of official time. Among the activities that take place through that mechanism include things such as the discussion of grievances, dispute resolutions, labor relations training, and new department initiatives, among other things. These activities are important for labor management relationships and they promote a public purpose. They establish vehicles for communications. They provide opportunities for employees to air grievances, and they offer a mechanism to resolve conflict. As such, they are vital for agency operations. There have been several efforts to alter current rules on official time. For example, the U.S. Department of Education has eliminated official time as part of its new labor contract. In addition, the Official Time Reform Act of 2017 proposes major changes in the existing law. For example, it says that an employee may not be granted official time for purposes of engaging in any political activity, including lobbying activity. In my view, adoption of this provision would weaken labor management relations in the Federal Government, would reduce the ability of government employees to air their concerns with management, and undermine agency performance. Like every other American, it is important that Federal employees have the right to express their viewpoints and petition government for a redress of grievances. I think curtailing those rights would deny Federal workers important privileges that are guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution. Thank you, and I'd be happy to answer any questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Mr. West follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Hice. [presiding.] Thank you very much. Mr. Connolly. Mr. Chair? Mr. Hice. Yes, sir. Mr. Connolly. I'm sorry. Just a unanimous consent request. I have four documents I would ask to enter into the record: a statement of the National Treasury Employees Union, the statement of the American Federation of Government Employees, the statement of the International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers, and a copy of an unfair labor charge filed by the American Federation of Government Employees against the Department of Education. Mr. Hice. Without objection. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair. Mr. Hice. You're welcome. I will now recognize myself for 5 minutes. I thank each of the witnesses for being here. We've got--do I have a graph? Is it available? If not, I'll go over some of the basics of it. There's been an increase in official time since 2010 through 2016 of over 17 percent. 3.6 million hours were used on official time in 2016. Mr. Kovacs, Mr. Gilson, do those figures sound somewhat accurate to you from, what you've tracked? Mr. Kovacs. Yes. I mean, that does sound accurate, but as I said in my testimony, as well as Mr. Gilson, you know---- Mr. Hice. Severely unreliable. Mr. Kovacs. Yes. Mr. Hice. Underestimated. Mr. Gilson, does that sound ballparkish to you? Mr. Gilson. No. The OPM admits that its report is inaccurate. Mr. Hice. All right. So more or less? Mr. Gilson. I'd say it's--as I said in my testimony, it's low by a factor of 5 or 10. Mr. Hice. Okay. All right. So we've got, based on what OPM has given us, we've got somewhere--if you take an average 8- hour day, we have almost half a million days a year that the taxpayers are paying. Mr. Gilson. Easy. Mr. Hice. And as your testimony is what you're saying today, Mr. Kovacs, that is severely underestimated. This is quite disturbing to many of us because it's all riding on the backs of the taxpayers. Now, just for an example, the Department of Veterans Affairs has nearly 2,000 employees who are involved in official time in one capacity or another, hundreds of them 100 percent of their time doing official time. So they were hired to do a specific job and they're doing none of that job, instead doing 100 percent union work but getting paid for the job they were hired to do. Of these 100 percent people on official time, who is doing the work that they were hired to do, Mr. Kovacs? Mr. Kovacs. Well, it's unknown. Potentially, new hires would have to be made to do their work, overtime assignments would have to be given to employees who are not on official time. But due to the lack of reporting, it's unclear. Potentially, their jobs were not met, and potentially, the work was not done. Mr. Hice. Mr. Gilson, would you agree with that? Mr. Gilson. There's an early FLRA case, Federal Labor Relations Authority case, which said that whatever time was negotiated, the agency--or used, the agency was obviously obliged to get its work done. Mr. Hice. Okay. So with the VA, just for example, of those who were involved in 100 percent official time, we have nurses, addiction therapists, pharmacists, physicians, we have people who are very important to the care of veterans not doing the job they were hired, 100 percent of their time going to unions. This is very disturbing to me. Mr. Gilson, something you said in your testimony I want to come back to that caught my attention. You said, quote: ``Federal unions pay almost nothing toward the cost of their day-to-day operations within the agency. This creates large surpluses that may support lobbying, organizing, and other internal union business since the taxpayer is paying operational costs.'' That is quite a powerful statement. Are you saying that these Federal employee unions can't afford to divert resources to other activities besides union operations because the taxpayer is subsidizing the union in essence? Mr. Gilson. AFGE currently has a $54 million set of assets that is able to build--and by the way, that is the national headquarters. That doesn't count their councils and locals. I would say it's probably $150 million in assets. Mr. Hice. All right. And those are coming from the taxpayers. Mr. Gilson. Coming from the dues paid because they don't pay any---- Mr. Hice. Dues and taxpayers, okay. Mr. Gilson. Yes. Mr. Hice. So is it fair to say that taxpayers are subsidizing them? Mr. Gilson. One hundred percent. Mr. Hice. All right. So you mentioned AFGE. How involved are they politically? Mr. Gilson. That's a question I don't know the answer to, Congressman. I do know that they send--they don't send Federal employees out, but they do send their employees out to work either on behalf of or against people running for office. Mr. Hice. Well, I can answer that question. They spent nearly $2 million last cycle giving to employees--or giving to candidates, 92 percent were Democrats. The National Treasury employee, the IRS union, right at 96 percent of their donations went to Democrats. I think when all of this is riding on the backs of taxpayers, it seems greatly alarming that the taxpayers are paying, number one, for people to do union work rather than the job they were hired to do, but then the union turns around and is involved in lobbying and political activity. Is that something that the unions are supposed to be involved with? Mr. Kovacs? Mr. Kovacs. Well, certainly labor unions have every right to engage in political activities. I would just say that, you know, the taxpayer shouldn't have to subsidize their representational activities. Mr. Hice. All right. That's the point I'm getting at. I realize my time has expired. I will now recognize the ranking member for 5 minutes. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair. Of course, what's good for the goose is good for the gander. If we're going to talk about political support, I wonder what kind of tax payoff Sheldon Adelson got and the Koch brothers got in the recent tax cut bill, and who do they support? Almost exclusively Republicans. So if we're going to talk about, you know, quid pro quos or the implication of quid pro quos, we can certainly have that discussion. I'd be glad to have that discussion. I assume labor unions support people who support them. They act in their own self-interests, like any other donor. Mr. West, might you agree with that? Mr. West. I would certainly agree with that. And all of the activities that we're talking about, the establishment of official time, the activities that are taking place, were authorized by the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978. And I would just like to remind members of the subcommittee that Act passed the Senate on an 87-to-1 vote, and the House agreed to the conference report on a 365-to-8 vote. So it was passed on a purely bipartisan basis. Almost nobody in Congress opposed it. Mr. Connolly. Okay. But Mr. Gilson makes a point. He says, yes, that's true, but in 1978, nobody foresaw the expansion of the use of official time. No one had that in mind, when they passed that bill, that it's evolved into something that would not be recognizable to those people. Would you comment on that? Have I got that accurate, Mr. Gilson? Mr. Gilson. Yes, sir. Mr. Connolly. Yes. Mr. West, what about that? Mr. West. I mean, what the legislation allowed was for representatives to assist their colleagues when their colleagues had grievances. If there was some disagreement in the workplace, if there is a sexual harassment charge, if there is a grievance that needed to get fired. So these individuals who are being supported through official time are helping their fellow employees. I see nothing wrong with that. Mr. Connolly. Okay. I want to explore that a little bit, because you talked in your testimony about the benefits of official time. Now, to listen to the narrative so far in this hearing, with the exception of you and me, one would assume that official time is a, you know, just a sinkhole. No good comes out of it. It's all on the taxpayer dime. It's a rip-off. It's, you know, unions exploiting the taxpayer and, once again, not really putting in a full day. In some cases not putting in a day at all. Now, are there specific benefits that come from official time? For example, does official time cover whistleblowers, Mr. West? Mr. West. The legislation did actually set up the whistleblower process, and it enabled those working on official time to assist others who were helping to protect the Federal Government in terms of the waste of taxpayers' money, fraudulent activities that might be taking place, or any type of misconduct. Mr. Connolly. So it's not just a cost, there's a benefit. We recover costs. Now, I take Mr. Gilson's point and actually certainly am prepared to work with my Republican friends in trying to have more accurate data so that we know what we're dealing with. I think that's a totally fair point. But it has to work both ways. It can't just be about the cost of the official time itself and how we calculate it; it's also got to be some estimate of the benefits. What is the dollar value of the benefits? Now, in 2017, long after 1978, the GAO did a report about whistleblowers at the Department of Veterans Affairs, and it said it actually--it actually praised official time that facilitated the whistleblower process at the VA. What did that whistleblower process entail? Well, it uncovered the overprescribing of opioids, which is a huge problem across the country and certainly with some of our veteran populations, and long wait times for veterans, which also then led to the uncovering of fraudulent form filling so that the VA looked better than, in fact, it was. Does that ring a bell with you, Mr. West, what I just said? Mr. West. Absolutely. Mr. Connolly. And is there a value to that? Mr. West. There is great value in that. Activities that take place under official time save the Federal Government money, so all the efforts to increase transparency and collect better data do need to identify not just the cost side but the benefit side. Mr. Connolly. Helping our veterans and maybe to the tune of millions of dollars. Mr. West. We all remember the problems of the veterans hospitals several years ago, and some of those were uncovered because Federal employees spoke up about those. Mr. Connolly. And that's not just our opinion, that's the GAO finding in 2017. My time is up. I thank the chair. Mr. Hice. I thank the gentleman. I now recognize Mr. Ross for 5 minutes. Mr. Ross. I thank the chairman, and I thank the panel for being here. A year ago today, the House passed on suspension my bill, which Mr. Kovacs referred to, H.R. 1293, which is a very fundamental accountability transparency bill that would require OPM to submit a report each year, including the total amount of official time granted to employees. It doesn't pass judgment on what that time was used for, what it should be used for, nothing. All it does is create the transparent process of accounting for all official time. And in furtherance of that, I would like to submit for the record an editorial from The Ledger, a newspaper in my district, discussing the benefits of that particular legislation. Mr. Hice. Without objection. Mr. Ross. And so my first question is, is there any reason not to have a transparent accountability process, such as set forth in H.R. 1293, for the purpose of reporting official time? Mr. Kovacs? Mr. Kovacs. I think it's an excellent idea. Taxpayers certainly should know what Federal employees are doing while paid by the public. Mr. Ross. Mr. Gilson? Mr. Gilson. I honestly don't think that you'd get an accurate report even under a statute. Mr. Ross. But it is better than what we have today. Mr. Gilson. Absolutely, Congressman. Mr. Ross. So you would have no objection to that? Mr. Gilson. Absolutely. Mr. Ross. Mr. West? Mr. West. I certainly support efforts of greater transparency in getting a better handle on the costs, but we also need to identify the benefits and how much money has been saved through this activity. Mr. Ross. And, in fact, Mr. West, I think you helped me prove my case. In your testimony you say: ``Given the data limitations, it is impossible to know whether official time costs are rising, staying the same, or decreasing.'' So in that sense, it would be good to at least have that baseline accountability. Now, we have that accountability in sick time, in vacation time, health benefits, TSP submissions. So this is mainly just another accounting procedure to account for what time is being used on union time as opposed to being used in taxpayer business. And my next question, you know, we're 435 Members of a board of trustees of a large organization that has the public trust as our foremost interest. And that public trust is exactly what we do with the taxpayer dollars it appropriated to us. Mr. Kovacs, can you say what benefit the taxpayers gain by the use of official time? Mr. Kovacs. I cannot. Mr. Ross. Mr. Gilson? Mr. Gilson. Yes, sir. Mr. Ross. And, please. Mr. Gilson. Mr. West is correct in one regard, and that is that there is a benefit in some circumstances for labor and management to sit down and solve problems, and to negotiate and to work on employee grievances. Official time has gone so far beyond that, that that's not just what it covers. For example, since the law passed, there have been over a quarter of a million unfair labor practice cases filed with the Federal Labor Relations Authority. The agencies have no say on them. And also, the use of official time in those cases is mandated by the Federal Labor Relations Authority for every witness, for everybody assisting one of their attorneys, for any employee that's engaged in that gets official time. Mr. Ross. Including whistleblowers. Whistleblowers don't need official time, do they? They're protected by statute. Mr. Gilson. Right. Whistleblower time is not the official time we're here to talk about. It's a separate matter under the law. If we're here to talk about the labor relations official time, that's all I'm talking about in terms of union abuse. And there is a great deal of union abuse of official time, at least in my experience. Mr. Ross. Is there any such similar process in the private sector in dealing with unions with regard to collective bargaining and the use of official time that anyone is aware of? Mr. Gilson. Some companies, some companies allow union stewards on the shop floor time to work a grievance. Mr. Ross. And would you say, if you know, that there is an accountability of that time that's being used in the furtherance of that private concern? Mr. Gilson. I think the company is going to exact a cost for that across the table if it's hurting productivity. Mr. Ross. Precisely. And so when we have a collective bargaining opportunity, how does it begin? What evidence is used by the unions to say this is how much we need in official time? Can you say, Mr. Gilson? Or how that process works. Mr. Gilson. I'm sitting at the bargaining table right now with a couple of agencies as their chief negotiator, and I've done this my whole career. What the unions--what the unions put on the table is a proposal, and what happens eventually is trade-offs are made. I hesitate to say this, but I believe it's true. I have yet to see a Federal sector union take a--anything less than a union institutional benefit over an employee benefit in negotiations. So what happens is, if an agency wants to accomplish something, it often trades the union benefit to get something done. Mr. Ross. Got you. Mr. Gilson. I've seen this happen over and over again. And that's how unions have managed to leverage the amount of official time and other costs that the agencies pay, is the agencies want to accomplish things--by the way, in this city, to get a space move done within the beltway, I've known agencies to take 6, 7, 8 years in negotiations because the unions don't want the change to happen. So they delay, they file complaints, they file unfair labor practices. Eventually, the agency has to play let's make a deal if they want the move to occur at all. All of that costs official time. Mr. Ross. Thank you, Mr. Gilson. My time has expired. Mr. Hice. I thank the gentleman. We will take some time for a few more questions if any members have any further. Let me ask you this: There are hundreds of employees making over $100,000 a year, and they're involved with official time. The Department of Veterans Affairs, for example, 472 employees, 100 percent official time. What does this do for an agency when you have this many people not doing the job they were hired to do? Mr. Kovacs. Well, I would assume that it makes it more difficult to achieve the agency mission when you don't have-- when you have that many employees who, you know, don't perform any agency activity. And I think this is one of the things where official time is supposed to be given if it's reasonable and necessary and in the public interest. And I'm not sure how an employee who never does their regularly assigned duties can achieve the public interest. Mr. Hice. Mr. Gilson? Mr. Gilson. What I've seen in my career is agency leadership sometimes says to the line supervisor don't mess with the union official. We don't want to hear the noise. Keep the noise down, number one. Number two is that supervisors and managers would rather have someone who wants to cause them problems away from the job. So what do they do? Other employees cover. If they can hire somebody, they try. There's an expression in the business that I'm in, he's not heavy, he's my colleague, which a lot of people apply to in situations of 100 percent official time, especially in places where the union is less than 20 percent of the people pay dues, which is very common in the Federal service, less than one in five employees pays dues. Mr. Hice. Just out of curiosity, I mentioned the Department of Veterans Affairs, and we've got a host of other agencies, but the VA seems to have a large number, 100 percent on official time. Do any of you have any information regarding other agencies where there seems to be an unusually high number of individuals on 100 percent? Mr. Gilson. I think that there's quite a number in HHS, Social Security, and the other HHS agencies. I think in the Bureau of Prisons, there's a number--wherever the union activity is great. In Department of Agriculture's Food Safety and Inspection Service. In places where you see a lot of grievances, a lot of unfair labor practices filed, you see people with 100 percent. In addition, Mr. Congressman, the most highly paid Federal employees are in FDIC, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation; the Securities and Exchange Commission; National Credit Union Administration; and the Comptroller of the Currency. Those folks, when you say $100,000, some of those people in those agencies are make $200,000 a year. Mr. Hice. Right. Mr. Gilson. The other thing that you may not know is that those agencies bargain pay without a specific authorization from the Congress to do so. Mr. Hice. Okay. Several months ago, in fact, in January, I joined with Chairman Gowdy and Chairman Meadows and others writing a letter trying to request information from various agencies on official time. It took months and months and months, over 5 months, and then when we finally got a response, it was so difficult to compile. Staff worked countless hours trying to get all that information in such a way that it could even be remotely understandable. And we're still going through it. Do any agencies really keep track of official time usage, to your knowledge? Mr. Gilson. Some agencies have, as part of the time and attendance system, the employees go into their computer and put their hours in. If you're a union steward or official, one of the blocks is official time. Mr. Hice. And do we know, for those that use official time, what they are using it for? And I'm not talking about collective bargaining, all that kind of stuff that we know they're supposed to be using. What other activities are utilized during that time? Mr. Gilson. The Federal Labor Relations Authority has, generally, over its case law years made it an unfair labor practice in many cases for an agency to inquire what the union is using the official time for. Mr. Hice. So the agency doesn't even know? Mr. Gilson. Oh, no clue, in many cases. Mr. Hice. Okay. All right. I thank the gentleman. The gentleman recognizes Mr. Connolly for 5 minutes. Mr. Connolly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Gilson, you talked about representing agencies on one side of the table and the unions are on the other side. Is that correct? Mr. Gilson. Yes, sir. Mr. Connolly. Is that what you do for a living? Mr. Gilson. Yes, sir. Well, not for a living. I'm retired. I do it part time. Mr. Connolly. All right. But have you ever been hired by a union to represent them? Mr. Gilson. No, sir. Mr. Connolly. Ah, okay. Mr. Gilson. However, I was a high school teacher union representative for 6 years before I became a Federal employee. Mr. Connolly. Good for you. Some of my best friends are union members. So we have a hearing here with a very partisan memo that was not cleared on our side that's filled with factual errors and misrepresentations. We have Mr. Kovacs who has an idealogical point of view about unions and what they ought to be doing, which is apparently very little. Even saying, just now, well, people are doing work they weren't hired to do, meaning official time. And yet when I check the law, official time is actually--I mean, it is actually protected by the law. Not like they're doing something wrong. Mr. Gilson makes a point I do concede and I think is valuable, that it has to be captured accurately. There has to be transparency. We've got to know how much time. But that's not really what this hearing is about. This hearing is about attacking unions, and we heard it from our chairman, whom I respect. He don't like the fact that they give money to the Democrats. And he doesn't like the fact that they're active. And we're going to have a hearing where we don't acknowledge any possible benefit from official time. And that disturbs me because that's not an intellectually honest enterprise. That's something else. That's union bashing, and we're apparently willing to distort facts and make assertions irrespective of the fact of the law Mr. West cited, which passed overwhelmingly. Mr. West, am I correct that contrary to sort of the image we're kind of allowing here in this hearing, that we got out of control union members who are running around doing things they shouldn't be doing and calling it official time? In every agency is there not an agreement that circumscribes official time? Mr. West. There are agreements. Supervisors have to approve the use of official time, so presumably, if these individuals were engaging in abhorrent acts, the supervisor would not be approving it. There are a number of good uses of the union time. We've recently seen a big increase in sexual harassment claims. That's something that employees are subject to and often need assistance in drafting those types of grievances. Unions often are the first line of defense for those individuals. Mr. Connolly. Is there also sort of informal troubleshooting that those people engage in so that it doesn't even get to the official grievance stage? Mr. West. There certainly are preliminary efforts to resolve disputes that take place in the workplace. Mr. Connolly. And might that be something management might actually welcome? Mr. West. Management should welcome that because that would improve the operations of the agency. Mr. Connolly. And make the manager's life a little easier? Mr. West. Exactly. And, of course, there are lots of efforts to reorganize, to introduce new administrative processes, there are new technologies coming to the workplace, all of which I applaud. Sometimes management needs help from union officials to get those things adopted. Mr. Connolly. And, you know, Mr. Gilson talks about management just throwing in the towel sometimes saying just appease them because it's easier than fighting. And I can see that. By the way, that happens in the private sector too with workforce. But what about that, Mr. West, is that something that we ought to be concerned about that management just--my words, not Mr. Gilson's, you know, allowing unions to run amuck and kind of run the agency instead of the other way around? Mr. West. Well, there should be cooperation between labor and management, and if that doesn't happen, we need to look at why that is not happening. But in a time period where I think all of us want the Federal Government to do a better job, we all want agencies to function much better, we need ways for employees to be able to communicate to management what is taking place. Mr. Connolly. And so another way of putting that might be labor management relations are kind of an important part of managing an agency toward its mission and its effectiveness. Sometimes it's done well, sometimes it's not in the public and the private sector. But the idea that there's a labor management dynamic that has to be addressed is not a new concept, is it? Mr. West. It is not a new concept. Mr. Connolly. I thank you, Mr. West. And thank you, Mr. Chairman, for a second round. Mr. Hice. I thank the gentleman. And we'll now recognize Chairman Meadows, and we'll be lenient on time since you missed the first round. If you have some extra questions, you're welcome to. Mr. Meadows. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. West, let me come directly to you because in your opening testimony, I was listening very closely, you would agree that we have no idea whether official time has increased or decreased. Is that correct? Mr. West. That's correct. Mr. Meadows. All right. And so--but you think official time is a good thing? Mr. West. Yes. Mr. Meadows. And so if official time is a good thing and we don't know whether we have more or less of it, do you not see that that's a problem? Because if it's a good thing, shouldn't we have more of it? Mr. West. I'd like to see better data that actually captures both costs and benefits. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Because you have someone here who actually had the head of a union working with me in a previous career, and I can tell you that the relationship was extremely good because official time--I recognize the law and the contractual reason for official time. Here's where I have a problem. When you have so many people on 100 percent official time, your statement you just made to the ranking member from Virginia about, well, they're supposed to check in with their supervisor, if they're on 100 percent official time, they don't have to check in. Would you agree with that? Mr. West. No. The statute says that official time has to be approved by the supervisor. Mr. Meadows. Okay. So let me ask it a different way. Listen, I know the answer to the question, so I'll ask it a different way. Those people, individuals that are on 100 percent official time, do you believe that they have the same accountability that someone who may be on 25 percent official time to their supervisors? Mr. West. If their supervisor has approved it, the answer would be yes. Mr. Meadows. They have the same accountability? Mr. West. Yes. Mr. Meadows. And what quantifiable data do you have to back up that claim, Mr. West? Do you have anything from Brookings that would prove that? Because I would venture to say you do not. So what do you have? I'll look at the numbers. What do you have to back that up? Mr. West. I mean, my sense is if someone is working 100 percent---- Mr. Meadows. I'm not asking for your sense. I'm asking for real data to back up your claim. Mr. West. We've done a lot of research through our public management center. I spent 40 years kind of looking at governance questions. We do a lot of work on Federal agencies and how to improve their performance, and if supervisors are approving this---- Mr. Meadows. Good, so you spent 40 years. Do you have any quantifiable data to suggest that someone who's on 100 percent official time has the same accountability to their management as someone that is on partial official time? Mr. West. If they're helping their colleagues file grievances, resolve disputes, communicate with management, there's accountability there. Mr. Meadows. You answered a great question I didn't ask. I asked, do you have any quantifiable data to support that hypothesis, Mr. West? After 40 years, do you have any data to support it? Mr. West. I'm just giving you the benefits of my research and case studies that we have undertaken---- Mr. Meadows. So yes or no, do you have quantifiable data? Mr. West. Based on our research, we think the answer to that is that there is evidence in support of that. Mr. Meadows. All right. So the quantifiable data, we'll give you 30 days to get to this committee if you've got it. Is that enough time? Mr. West. Yes. Mr. Meadows. All right. And so you're going to commit to get quantifiable data on that question. Mr. West. I will give you the benefit of my impressions, yes. Mr. Meadows. That's not what I'm asking for. We already have your impression. You're an expert witness. You're here. What I'm looking for is data. Here's my problem. I'm willing to go with the ranking member on acknowledging that we have to have official time. Even there are some who probably ought to have 100 percent official time if indeed they're the head of this and they're doing--but at the same time, we have to have some kind of matrix to figure out who is being accountable and who is not, because according to your testimony, it's a good thing, and we need to understand when it's a good thing and when it's not. Wouldn't you agree? Mr. West. Yes, I would agree with that. Mr. Meadows. Okay. So if we have to make that determination, I have a real concern that we have people that they don't have to check in with their management. I'm on 100 percent official time. In fact, as a supervisor, I wouldn't expect them to be around if they were on 100 percent. I wouldn't ask them to do any work on behalf of the taxpayer if they're 100 percent. Do you see how that accountability may not be the same as someone who was only there part time? Mr. West. All I know is the statute still requires supervisor approval even if somebody is working 100 percent on official time. Mr. Meadows. All right. Do you--in your 40 years of experience, have you ever seen anybody who did not get supervisor approval? Mr. West. I don't know the answer to that question. Mr. Meadows. So you've not seen anybody ever--and you've studied this, and you've never seen anybody not get supervisory approval in 40 years. That's your sworn testimony here today? Mr. West. I don't know the answer to that question. Mr. Meadows. Well, either you know or you don't. I mean--so you've not seen anybody? Mr. West. I can't answer that question. Mr. Meadows. Mr. Gilson, have you seen anybody, ever? Mr. Gilson. Over and over and over again. Mr. Meadows. Okay. Mr. Kovacs, in your experience, have you seen that the accountability at some times is less than robust? Mr. Kovacs. Yeah. I mean, 2009 National Labor Relations Board Inspector General report showed that consistently supervisors did not approve of official time. Mr. Meadows. Okay. But you weren't aware of that report, Mr. West. Is that correct? Mr. West. Which report? Mr. Kovacs. The 2009 inspector general report from the National Labor Relations Board. Mr. West. I've not seen that report. Mr. Meadows. But you study it and you're an expert. You weren't aware of that? Mr. West. I've not seen that report, no. Mr. Meadows. I didn't ask you if you've seen it. Were you aware of it? That's a different question. Mr. West. I'm aware the inspector general does lots of reports. Mr. Meadows. All right. Mr. Chairman, I can see that this line of questioning is not producing any real results for me or Mr. West, so I'll yield back. Mr. Hice. I thank the gentleman. Are there any other questions? Mr. Connolly. Mr. Chairman, I would just say, in the spirit of what's good for the goose is good for the gander, if we're going to insist that Mr. West provide data in support of official time, I'd certainly like to see data to corroborate Mr. Gilson's anecdotal observation that over and over and over again he has witnessed---- Mr. Meadows. Yeah. I have no objection to that. Mr. Connolly. I thank my friend. Mr. Meadows. And am I the goose or the gander? No. I'm kidding. Mr. Hice. We may want to end there. I want to thank the witnesses for joining us today. We appreciate you taking time. And the members who remained as well, thank you very much. The hearing record will remain open for 2 weeks for any member to submit a written opening statement or questions for the record. If there's no further business, without objection, the subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:48 a.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]