Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- UNFUNDED MANDATES: EXAMINING FEDERALLY IMPOSED BURDENS ON STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT [House Hearing, 115 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] UNFUNDED MANDATES: EXAMINING FEDERALLY IMPOSED BURDENS ON STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ APRIL 26, 2017 __________ Serial No. 115-24 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://oversight.house.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 26-556 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office, http://bookstore.gpo.gov. For more information, contact the GPO Customer Contact Center, U.S. Government Publishing Office. Phone 202-512-1800, or 866-512-1800 (toll-free). E-mail, [email protected]. Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Jason Chaffetz, Utah, Chairman John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Elijah E. Cummings, Maryland, Darrell E. Issa, California Ranking Minority Member Jim Jordan, Ohio Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Justin Amash, Michigan Columbia Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts Trey Gowdy, South Carolina Jim Cooper, Tennessee Blake Farenthold, Texas Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Thomas Massie, Kentucky Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Mark Meadows, North Carolina Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Ron DeSantis, Florida Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Dennis A. Ross, Florida Val Butler Demings, Florida Mark Walker, North Carolina Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois Rod Blum, Iowa Jamie Raskin, Maryland Jody B. Hice, Georgia Peter Welch, Vermont Steve Russell, Oklahoma Matthew Cartwright, Pennsylvania Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Mark DeSaulnier, California Will Hurd, Texas John Sarbanes, Maryland Gary J. Palmer, Alabama James Comer, Kentucky Paul Mitchell, Michigan Jonathan Skladany, Staff Director Rebecca Edgar, Deputy Staff Director Katy Rother, Senior Counsel William McKenna General Counsel Kiley Bidelman, Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director ------ Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs Gary Palmer, Alabama Chairman Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin, Vice Val Butler Demings, Florida, Chair Ranking Minority Member John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Mark DeSaulnier, California Trey Gowdy, South Carolina (Vacancy) Virginia Foxx, North Carolina (Vacancy) Thomas Massie, Kentucky Mark Walker, North Carolina C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on April 26, 2017................................... 1 WITNESSES The Hon. Wayne Niederhauser, President, Utah State Senate Oral Statement............................................... 6 Written Statement............................................ 9 The Hon. Jim Davis, Senator, North Carolina State Senate Oral Statement............................................... 13 Written Statement............................................ 15 The Hon. Gary Moore, Judge/Executive, Boone County, Kentucky Oral Statement............................................... 18 Full Statement of the Hon. Gary Moore can be found at: http:// docs.house.gov/meetings/GO/GO04/20170426/105942/hhrg-115-GO04- Wstate-MooreG-20170426.pdf The Hon. Jermaine Reed, Councilman, City of Kansas City, Missouri Oral Statement............................................... 19 Written Statement............................................ 21 The Hon. Jeff McKay, Supervisor, Fairfax County Board of Supervisors, Alexandria, Virginia Oral Statement............................................... 29 Written Statement............................................ 31 APPENDIX Opening Statement of Subcommittee Chairman Gary Palmer........... 52 UNFUNDED MANDATES: EXAMINING FEDERALLY IMPOSED BURDENS ON STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT ---------- Wednesday, April 26, 2017 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 10:06 a.m., in Room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Gary J. Palmer [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Palmer, Grothman, Foxx, Walker, Demings, and DeSaulnier. Also Present: Representatives Meadows, Comer, and Connolly. Mr. Palmer. The Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Affairs of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Today, we are examining Federal unfunded mandates and their impact on State and local governments. The issue of unfunded mandates is central to this subcommittee, which is charged with oversight of the relationship between the Federal Government and State and local government partners. In December, the chairman sent a letter to Governors, State legislators, and county and local government officials soliciting feedback on the most burdensome or impactful Federal unfunded mandates. Respondents cited over 645 individual Federal laws and regulations that have taken away the ability of local governments to decide how best to serve their constituencies. Almost a quarter of those laws represented Federal environmental requirements. Governor Eddie Calvo of Guam reported that the compliance costs for the EPA's enforcement of the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, and Safe Drinking Water Act alone equates to almost $10,000 per man, woman, and child, and makes the basic cost of utilities for the median household unsustainable. Unfunded mandates reported to the committee covered a variety of topics, from labor to housing to transportation to prison administration. This issue does not discriminate. Of the most cited laws, Medicaid was routinely reported to be one of the most burdensome, imposing billions of dollars on communities annually for care that is often not reimbursed. Higher education institutions in the State of Virginia report spending millions annually on compliance with Federal education laws. The University of Virginia, for example, spends an estimated $20 million a year just to comply with unfunded mandates. Respondents cited mandates imposing significant administrative costs with no identifiable benefits, mandates requiring standards inconsistent with the needs of the State, and mandates that are simply impossible to achieve. In certain cases, such as implementation of the new National Ambient Air Quality Standards, unfunded mandates reportedly resulted in direct loss of jobs. The corresponding costs of these mandates are directly borne by the taxpayer. Merely looking at cost, however, is not sufficient. The time and resources that States and local governments take to comply with these mandates demonstrate that current law does not adequately capture the extent of the burden of unfunded mandates. As an example, Speaker Mac McCutcheon from my home State of Alabama shared an unworkable Department of Transportation mandate that requires the State to outline a financial plan for certain projects for up to 30 years without knowing the source of funding that far into the future, making the annual exercise just that, an exercise. What we heard from nearly all the respondents is that the attempt to provide a one-size-fits-all solution effectively strips officials of the flexibility necessary to govern at the State and local level. Every dollar a State or local government uses to comply with Federal law is a dollar they can't direct to specific needs at their own levels of government. The committee learned that a Federal Aviation Administration policy change resulted in the use of State and local infrastructure funds to pay for flight inspections in Oklahoma. A small rural county in Nevada had to consider closing its sole library, which was its residents' key source of internet access, after the Department of Labor implemented its overtime rule. These tradeoffs are made every day by State and local officials. I would like to thank each of the witnesses today for taking valuable time out of their schedules to appear here today to testify. You are uniquely situated to provide insight into this issue and where we should go from here. I now recognize the gentlelady from Virginia, Congresswoman Virginia Foxx, for the remainder of my time. Ms. Foxx. I thank the chairman for yielding. Like some of you, I served as an elected official in State and local government, and can testify to the difficulty of balancing a State budget when there are dozens of complicated unfunded Federal mandates that must be taken into account. In 1995, in a model of bipartisanship, Congress passed and President Clinton signed the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act, or UMRA. UMRA was designed to force the Federal Government to estimate and report how much its mandates would cost local and State governments, which was previously not the case. UMRA was not intended to prevent the government from regulating or legislating, but, rather, to ensure that decisionmakers have the best information possible when crafting new policies. I have always admired the purpose and spirit of UMRA, but weaknesses in the law have been exploited in the intervening decades, and they need to be addressed. For instance, most independent agencies, like the FCC and the SEC, are not subject to UMRA's requirements for their proposed regulations. Costly changes in conditions of grant aid don't fall within the definition of a mandate, and agencies can skip UMRA cost analyses if they begin rulemaking with a mechanism other than a formal notice of proposed rulemaking. Finally, UMRA measures only direct costs of compliance with mandates, and the law contains no enforcement or accountability mechanisms which allow State and local governments recourse if the process is not followed. It is my hope that this hearing will be a first step toward an improved and more transparent regulatory process that eases the burdens passed onto State and local governments. To that end, since 2007, I have worked on a bill known as the Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency Act, or UMITA, which seeks to address some of UMRA's shortcomings and will help the law meet its unfulfilled potential. UMITA will ensure public and bureaucratic awareness about the cost that Federal regulations impose on the economy and local governments. It will also make our regulatory apparatus more efficient, effective, and transparent. UMITA has bipartisan DNA, and its purpose is purely about good government, that of openness and honesty about the cost of regulations. These principles do not belong to either party. That is why my Democratic colleague Henry Cuellar joined me in introducing the bill, and it is why it has passed the House in previous Congresses with overwhelming support from both parties. Republicans and Democrats can agree that every unfunded mandate the Federal Government imposes should be both deliberative and economically defensible. Thank you for your time, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, for yielding. Mr. Palmer. The chair notes the presence of our colleagues Congressman Meadows of North Carolina, Congressman Connolly of Virginia, and Congressman Comer of Kentucky. We appreciate your interest in this topic and welcome your participation today. And the chair recognizes the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Meadows. Mr. Meadows. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to thank my colleague Ms. Foxx for her leadership on this particular issue, for your leadership in bringing forward this hearing. But I am here today to thank the fine senator from North Carolina, Senator Jim Davis, who is probably the best qualified person to speak on this topic, because when I didn't know what unfunded mandates were, Senator, you as a county commissioner were telling me what it was. You knew all too well those Federal mandates that came down, and we required you to have to pay for it at the county level. You have been an advocate on this, not only as a county commissioner, but now as my State senator and someone I enjoy calling my friend. Thank you for making the special effort. Thank you for your expert testimony. And, Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentleman. The chair now recognizes the gentlewoman from Florida, the ranking member, Mrs. Demings. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. Good morning, everyone. Let me start by saying I am very pleased, Mr. Chairman, to join you as ranking member of this subcommittee. We have had one joint subcommittee hearing, but this is our first hearing of just the Intergovernmental Subcommittee. I look forward to working with you in a bipartisan manner to conduct rigorous, yet effective, oversight. I am glad we are having this hearing to examine the impact of unfunded mandates on State and local governments by the Federal Government. As a former chief of police for the city of Orlando, Florida, I am keenly aware of the challenges State and local governments face in managing their local budget and implementing Federal mandates. Right now, I believe the single biggest threat to State and local funding is President Trump's proposed budget. It slashes hundreds of billions of dollars from programs that American families rely on. And if these Draconian cuts go through, the burden will fall on cities, counties, and States. Here is a brief list of the programs set for elimination. The administration's budget would eliminate funding for the Community Development Block Grant. It would eliminate funding for the HOME Investments Partnership Program. It would eliminate Community Services Block Grants. And it would even eliminate the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program. The president of the National League of Cities said President Trump's proposed budget, and I quote, ``threatens the safety and prosperity of cities around the country.'' I could not agree more. What does it all mean? Well, it means low-income American families may go without heat in the winter and air conditioning in the summer. It means that the elderly, children, and people with disabilities will not receive funding that is critical to these vulnerable populations. It means funding for afterschool programs will disappear. And it means that counties and cities will have to divert funds as they are forced to do more with less. It will negatively impact public health and safety across the country, and it will negatively impact budgets nationwide. Regardless of whether you live in rural areas or urban cities, you will be hurt by this budget. When these cuts to vital programs are proposed, they are packaged as cost-saving efforts. This isn't true. This is cost shifting to someone else, and the, quote, ``someone else'' is the most vulnerable families in our communities and States and local governments. I look forward to hearing about unfunded mandates facing local governments, but as part of this conversation, we must reject the President's massive budget cuts and the burden they impose on local and State governments. I understand as well as anyone how Federal mandates can pass costs down to State and local governments that impact the outlook for their budgets. We must distinguish between mandates that assure basic rights and protections and mandates that impose burdens. For example, there are mandates that ensure clean water. All we have to do is look at the crisis in Flint, Michigan, to understand what would happen if these protections were eliminated. As this committee found, the problem in Flint was not Federal overreach. It was that the Federal Government did not step in sooner to protect the citizens of Flint. And now an entire generation of children will be paying the price as they deal with the consequences of lead poisoning. The solution there is not just to eliminate the mandate; it's to provide adequate funding to comply with it. Then there are examples of mandates that burden State governments. It's no secret President Trump wants local governments to help with immigration enforcement. At the same time, however, his proposed budget looks to eliminate the State Criminal Alien Assistance Program, which provides reimbursements to State and local governments for incarcerating undocumented immigrants. This is a prime example of States being asked to do the Federal Government's job at their own expense. We cannot lose sight of why we are concerned about the burdens of State and local governments in the first place. It's about doing what is best for Americans everywhere. The funds at this level and the services provided are crucial to Americans across this country. We cannot tolerate irresponsible cuts to these needed programs. Again, thank you so much. And, Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentlewoman. And I also look forward to working with you. And I think we have a lot of opportunities, a lot of good work to do on this committee. The committee will hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. We will now recognize our panel of witnesses. First of all, the Honorable Wayne Niederhauser, president of the Utah State Senate, who represents the ninth State senate district in the great State of Utah. The Honorable Gary Moore, judge and executive of Boone County, Kentucky. Mr. Moore chairs the National Association of Counties' Committee on Environment, Energy & Land Use, and is the former chairman of the Opioid Epidemic Task Force. I got out of order, Mr. Davis. I would also like to recognize Senator Jim Davis of North Carolina's 50th district. Welcome today. The Honorable Jermaine Reed, councilman of the city of Kansas City, Missouri. And I am now pleased to recognize Congressman Connolly from the great State of Virginia to recognize our last witness. Mr. Connolly. I thank my friend, and I thank the chair and the ranking member for holding this very important hearing. In fact, when I was chairman of Fairfax County, from which Mr. McKay comes, I actually testified before this committee, when Tom Davis was chairman and Henry Waxman was ranking member, on unfunded mandates. Unfunded mandates particularly affect local government. In fact, local governments are on the receiving end not only from the Federal Government but from State governments. I notice we have two State senators, one of whom at least was in local government. But it is all too often the practice at the State level to, frankly, slough off burdens onto localities. I know that goes on in my home State of Virginia, and I know Mr. McKay is on the receiving end of that as a supervisor from Lee district in Fairfax County. Mr. McKay is a long-time friend of mine for over two decades. We worked together in a myriad of enterprises in transportation, in human services, on the Legislative Affairs Committee, which he now chairs, which I also used to chair. And I know he understands intimately the impact on the budget because he now chairs the Budget Committee for the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors, a county bigger than eight States. So, you know, he is dealing with really large issues, and it's a full enterprise government. So it's everything from human services to a bus fleet. And they know the impact of unfunded mandates, Mr. Chairman. And I have always said, as a local government official and now up here, if Congress thinks an idea is really worth doing, we should pay for it. It should never be a burden put on somebody else. No Child Left Behind is a great example. You know, maybe good intentions, but it was an unfunded mandate. And that was always my problem. So I welcome Mr. McKay being here representing a wonderful place, Fairfax County, and I thank him for being willing to spend his time and bring his expertise to this committee. Mr. Palmer. Welcome to you all. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn in before they testify. Please rise and raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth so help you God? Thank you. Please be seated. Let the record reflect that the witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for discussion, please limit your testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written statement will be made part of the record. The chair now recognizes Mr. Niederhauser for his testimony. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE WAYNE NIEDERHAUSER Mr. Niederhauser. Thank you, Chairman Palmer, Ranking Member Demings, and committee members for this opportunity to speak to you today. I am Wayne Niederhauser, senate president of Utah. I represent Sandy, Utah, gateway to Snowbird and Alta ski resorts. It was snowing when I left home yesterday morning. I also have the privilege of working closely with the Council of State Governments, CSG, and I am here in that capacity today. On behalf of CSG and our leaders throughout the country, I want to thank you for convening this important hearing and for your leadership in exploring ways to improve relationships between the States and the Federal Government. Founded in 1993--1933, excuse me, the Council of State Governments is the Nation's only organization serving all three branches of government. CSG is a region-based, nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that fosters an exchange of ideas that helps States shape public policy. Our new administration, the Vice President and President, have both voiced their strong support for strengthening relationships with State and local governments. The administration has issued several executive actions. While these executive orders are important steps towards keeping faith with the established principles of federalism, CSG believes Congress should follow suit and consider legislative action to codify processes that ensure adequate State input. We applaud Congresswoman Virginia Foxx for introducing H.R. 50, the Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency Act, which addresses UMRA's narrow coverage, exemptions, and loopholes. The committee understands the constitutional and foundational role the States play in our Federal system as outlined in the 10th Amendment, which laid the foundation for States to develop innovative ideas and policies to fulfill their roles as laboratories of democracy. The Utah legislature in this last session passed a resolution outlining several dozen areas of State responsibility that have been assumed by the Federal Government. That resolution will be attached to my testimony. State-based innovation is being stifled by a growing web of Federal policies and regulations, which come in the form of unfunded mandates. Unfunded mandates limit State and local flexibility to address more pressing local problems like crime and education. States are often forced to find money to pay these bills. In addition, these mandates may come in a one- size-fits-all box that can shut down innovative efforts to address problems that involve unique local considerations. Among the most costly mandates are those involved in environmental compliance. The EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers' infamous rule to establish an expansive definition of the Waters of the United States is a prime example of which this committee is well aware. A smaller example is the groundwater rule that requires us to manage a new violation, including site inspections, which forces us to hire new employees that cost us $240,000 a year. The Perkins Program from the Department of Education is my final illustration. Utah receives a grant of approximately $12 million to support State and administrative costs, professional development. In return for this $12 million, we are locked into a maintenance of effort agreement that now costs the State $241 million. It is not a complete loss of money. Some of those things we would have done regardless. But the lack of flexibility comes at a cost. I am attaching a summary of our Perkins analysis. Goals behind Federal mandates are often admirable, but local governments have admirable goals also, more important to citizens, more likely to be effective, and less expensive. Along with the cost of financing these new mandates, the majority of Federal regulations have been enacted with limited or no input or consultation from local governments. This is what led CSG to start a multiyear initiative focused on improving the role of States in the Federal system. I have included the full list of principles in my testimony. One size does not fit all. Local governments should be encouraged to provide unique local solutions. Stronger coordination and communication will help reduce conflicts, which far too often end up in court and come with enormous economic and opportunity costs. Cooperative federalism requires the Federal Government to work in good faith with the States as equal partners. The broken system demands Congress to implement changes to the process. Navigating this relationship between the Federal Government and the States and local government--I believe, with your leadership--will improve. Again, I thank you for this opportunity to appear before you today and look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Niederhauser follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentleman for his testimony. The chair recognizes Senator Davis from North Carolina. STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE JIM DAVIS Mr. Davis. Good morning. Thank you, Chairman Palmer and Ranking Member Demings and members of the subcommittee. I am delighted to be here today. And I appreciate the opportunity to share the impact of unfunded mandates, or what I call federally imposed burdens, on North Carolina's State and local governments. I am here to provide examples of compliance challenges and their associated costs from such mandates. I serve North Carolina's district 50, which covers the seven westernmost counties in the State. Collectively, these counties contain almost 900,000 acres of Federal land, large tracts removed from development opportunities and the property tax base. As a result, these counties face significant challenges in their ability to provide critical services to their citizens. The added costs of compliance with unfunded mandates exponentially stress these already struggling local governments. On the opposite side of my State, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers dredges Federal channels and disposes of dredged materials in Federal waters offshore. Coastal counties seeking resources to renourish beaches and to repair from coastal storms often have need of dredged sand. But before any restoration can begin, managers of renourishment and repair projects must navigate the federally imposed bureaucracies of two separate agencies. First, they must secure Federal lease from the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management. Then they must work through the National Environmental Protection Act sediment sampling process for approval to extract sand from Federal waters and place it back on the beach. Delays in these processes are the norm and force local governments to create funding by increasing sales and property taxes on our citizens. Our North Carolina workforce, and in particular our citizens with disabilities, along with our North Carolina Division of Vocational Rehabilitation and its contracted providers, are being directly and deleteriously impacted by numerous Federal unfunded mandates associated with rules and regulations promulgated in section 4 of the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act. These mandates include extension of service obligations. DVR programs are now responsible for services to youth with the most significant disabilities starting at age 14 for up to 4 years, with no additional funding and no previous responsibility. Funding must come from either North Carolina taxpayers or reduction or elimination of services for other citizens. New mandated allocation of States' DVR Federal grant. Fifteen percent of the total DVR Federal grant money is now mandated for a new responsibility to provide preemployment transitional services to youth starting at age 14. The 15- percent requirement was not graduated for infrastructure ramp up, causing States to forfeit Federal funds. With forfeiture of funds, no additional funding, and no previous responsibility, the money must come from North Carolina taxpayers or a reduction or elimination of services. While the legislative intent of the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act was intended to benefit our workforce and citizens with disabilities, it was in effect a regulatory overreach, an attempt to legislate through rulemaking, which resulted in noble intentions becoming unfunded mandates, ungrounded in reality. The North Carolina Department of Transportation is rife with examples of the burdens of unfunded Federal mandates. NCDOT is responsible for all modes of transportation in my State. The NCDOT also oversees and helps expand economic opportunities through the North Carolina ports and North Carolina Global TransPark. Federal unfunded mandates impact States that support passenger train services delivered by providers other than Amtrak. There is no Federal funding to support the additional costs associated with this designation. And the total financial impact to North Carolina is over a million and a half dollars per year. Due to a change in the Federal definition of ``passenger ferry,'' base appropriations for North Carolina's ferry system went from 22 million in 2007 to over 31 million in 2008. And I could list many other Federal mandates that caused our State to either increase taxes or reduce services. But I would like to conclude my testimony with this compelling example from a business owner in my district. His experience is at best a sobering commentary on compliance challenges and associated costs from unfunded Federal mandates. He was told by a compliance officer charged with enforcing EPA guidelines that his boiler system was compliant with current emissions of arsenic; however, he would be required to reduce the emissions from 12 parts per million to 4 parts per million. After spending over $200,000 on consultants, lawyers, and other experts, this business owner learned two things. One, the technology didn't exist to reduce it to 4, and secondly, arsenic occurs naturally in our air at 12 parts per million. Rather than invest $200,000 on needed equipment, employee raises, or profit, the business owner spent his money on efforts to comply with the impossible. Where I come from, $200,000 is real money. I commend my testimony to you and welcome your questions. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Mr. Davis follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Palmer. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Kentucky, Mr. Moore, for his testimony. STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE GARY MOORE Judge Moore. Chairman Palmer, Ranking Member Demings, and distinguished members of the committee and subcommittee, thank you for holding today's hearings on unfunded mandates. I would also like to say hello to Kentucky Representative Comer and, if he is able to join us later, my Congressman Massie, Thomas Massie. My name is Gary Moore, and I am the elected county judge executive in Boone County, Kentucky, and I am honored to provide testimony today on behalf of the National Association of Counties to share how we can strengthen the intergovernmental consultation process. This issue is so important to counties nationwide as we work to balance our budgets and provide critical services to our constituents, including public safety, health services, fire and rescue, infrastructure development, and much more. As this committee examines the impacts of unfunded mandates, I would briefly like to share a few points for your consideration. First, the regulatory consultation process between Federal agencies and State and local governments needs to be strengthened. In 1995, Unfunded Mandates Reform Act, UMRA, was instrumental in reducing unfunded mandates in Federal legislation for State and local governments. In fact, CBO periodically and proactively brings together NACo and other State and local organizations to discuss proposed legislation that could result in unfunded mandates. However, the framework it established for the regulatory consultation process has been less effective. It tasked each agency with developing their own internal process, which we found to be inconsistent across and within agencies. We often find that the agencies just want to check a box instead of having meaningful discussion with us as intergovernmental partners before and throughout the rulemaking cycle. We are encouraged that Congress has been working on legislation to strengthen this process and hopefully curb the number of unfunded mandates. For example, H.R. 50, UMITA, would increase transparency about the cost of unfunded Federal mandates to State and local governments. Similarly, H.R. 1009, the OIRA Insight, Reform, and Accountability Act, would increase levels of consultation and collaboration between agencies and State and local governments. Time and time again, we see major Federal regulations like Waters of the U.S., the ozone rule, and the Department of Labor's overtime rule finalized with little or no consultation with State and local governments, even though these regulations have major practical and financial implications for counties. Second, counties face mounting fiscal stress from unfunded mandates. Counties must operate balanced budgets. We often do not have the flexibility in our budgets to pay for new Federal requirements. In fact, 45 States already impose limitation on counties' ability to raise additional revenue. In my home State of Kentucky, the burden of an ever-growing list of Federal and State mandates has resulted in reduced funding for county jails, inmate health care, infrastructure maintenance, while other funding limitations are affecting our county-run 911 system. Federal policies and programs developed with only the impact on the Federal Treasury in mind put the ability of local governments to fulfill our responsibilities at risk. Finally, our system of federalism requires a strong Federal, State, and local partnership to achieve our shared goals. Unfortunately, our intergovernmental partnership is often out of balance as Federal agencies impose one-size-fits- all approaches, taking away local decisionmaking. When the Federal agencies do engage in meaningful consultation, they are better able to develop practical rules that accomplish our shared goals. Mr. Chairman, thank you again for the opportunity to discuss these issues and the major impact of federally imposed burdens on State and local governments. In short, we hope Congress will implement a consultation process across the Federal Government that includes working with State and local partners early and often. I am happy to answer your questions. Thank you. Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentleman for his testimony. The chair recognizes Mr. Reed for his testimony. STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE JERMAINE REED Mr. Reed. Thank you. And good morning to you, Mr. Chairman, and the ranking members and the members of this committee. I am Jermaine Reed, a member of the city council from Kansas City, Missouri. And it's an honor to be able to join you on behalf of National League of Cities, the oldest and largest organization representing American cities and towns. City leaders, as you have indicated, are on the front lines of almost every issue. From education, health care, environment, cities and towns are making major strides in these areas because we are in the business of finding solutions to the challenges that face our communities. But one of the biggest barriers to our progress is the burden of unfunded mandates. All city leaders face tough budget choices in what services we are able to provide, but often the added burden of unfunded mandates is the last straw for straining local budgets. We at the National League of Cities are opposed to unfunded mandates. As has been indicated, with the release of the President's budget proposal, the concerns on whether the Federal Government can reduce or can be eliminated without shifting the costs to local governments has never been greater: the across-the-board proposed cuts to critical funding for programs and services in cities, the new unfunded mandates it would create. And we urge Congress to reject these cuts. Our constituents depend on the success of our Federal-local partnership to ensure that government services are affordable, reliable, and also high quality. To achieve that, I urge the committee to work to eliminate unfunded mandates and other regulatory burdens, support local flexibility and control to avoid taking a one-size-fits-all regulatory approach. The partnership between local, State, and Federal Government works best when our unique powers and responsibilities are clearly defined and respected. Local governments' biggest duty is to provide services, solve day-to-day problems, and respond directly to the needs of our citizens. As our research at the National League of Cities shows, city budgets are still recovering from the Great Recession. The country's municipal workforce is still at 58,000 jobs below the peak in the mid-2000s, and we are still meeting the needs of our citizens, but there certainly is a very little to--margin of error. In my hometown of Kansas City, we treat every budget approval process as an opportunity to reexamine with our constituents what their needs are to provide. When we are faced with unfunded mandates, my colleagues and I are forced to disregard the will of our voters and divert local tax dollars to meet the standards imposed by Congress. As explained in my written testimony, the unfunded mandates that we are facing include regulations from the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, and the Americans with Disabilities Act. And right now, I would like to focus on the Clean Water Act and what it takes for cities our size to comply with unfunded mandates it's proposed. In 2009, in order to meet the requirements under the Clean Water Act, Kansas City developed a 25-year plan called the Smart Sewers Program. The program includes 101 separate projects and comes at a cost of nearly $5 billion, financed entirely by wastewater fees. In order to fund these improvements, the city was forced to impose double-digit increases on our residents each year for the past 7 years. The average monthly bill has more than doubled, from $48 in 2009 to nearly $101 today, with major burdens on our elderly and low- income citizens. In addition to the Smart Sewers Program, the city has been mandated to invest in over $800 million in wastewater systems upgrades to meet the population discharge and regulation by the year of 2035. Now let me be clear that these programs are important and include many benefits to our community. But without the adequate funding and no input from local elected officials, they leave our city helpless to meet the Federal needs and to balance our local budgets. Cities need to have a seat at the table during the rulemaking process to ensure that local consideration and consequences are taken into account. As I stated in my written testimony, I would like to commend EPA for the significant improved consultation process with State and local governments. And I urge all Federal agencies to learn from their progress. More importantly, on behalf of the National League of Cities, I urge this committee to improve the Federal-local consultation process in a way that local government input and consideration in rulemaking is made. This can be achieved through the consistent consultation guidelines across Federal agencies and the low consultation thresholds, as the EPA example has shown. With more opportunities for local officials to participate in the rulemaking process, we can eliminate unfunded mandates at an early stage and give local governments the flexibility to balance their budget, provide high-quality services, and respond to our constituents' needs. On behalf of the National League of Cities and the City of Kansas City, Missouri, thank you for the opportunity to submit this testimony on this critical issue, and I look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Reed follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Palmer. Thank you for your testimony. The chair now recognizes Mr. McKay for his testimony. STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE JEFF MCKAY Mr. McKay. Good morning. Thank you, Chairman Palmer, Ranking Member Demings, Representative Connolly, members of this subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Jeff McKay, and I serve as chairman of both the Budget and Legislative Committees on the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors. I also serve on the Board of Directors of the Virginia Association of Counties. Many of you are probably familiar with Fairfax County, from Tysons Corner mall to the Springfield Town Center to Wolf Trap to Mount Vernon, we have transformed from a rural farming community into the largest jurisdiction in the Washington, D.C., area and the largest jurisdiction in the Commonwealth of Virginia with a highly diverse population of over 1.1 million people. We hold a coveted AAA bond rating and among the most highly educated populations in the Nation. We have a strong partnership with the Federal Government, with 54.7 billion in total defense spending in fiscal year 2014. Nearly 30,000 defense personnel are located in Fairfax County, Virginia, in addition to many other Federal employees. We value the close relationship we have with the Federal Government and are even seeking to expand it with the potential relocation of the FBI headquarters in Springfield, Virginia. We very much are your partners, and we are proud of that relationship. Though Fairfax is often described as a wealthy community, we have many individuals and families who are struggling, including approximately 70,000 people living in poverty. Nearly 51,000 students in our public school system qualify for free and reduced-price lunch. Only five school divisions in Virginia have more total students than we have on just free and reduced- price lunch in Fairfax County. As has often been said, local government is the level of government that is closest to the people. We are where the rubber hits the road. Unfortunately, we are also the level of government with the fewest revenue options, making it even more difficult to address an increasing list of Federal and State mandates. In Fairfax County, we estimate the county spent approximately $1.4 billion on Federal and State mandates in fiscal year 2016, with a net fiscal impact of $834 million. Of course, we often support the policy goals the mandates seek to achieve, but mandates often prescribe not only we must do, but how we must do it, though they rarely include sufficient funding to carry out those requirements. In Virginia, localities are even more limited than in many other States, as Virginia has a strict adherence to something called Dillon rule, a doctrine of limited authority for local governments. As a result, we have very limited revenue authority, leading to an overreliance on property taxes. Virginia also provides less funding to localities than many States, ranking 38th nationally in State per-pupil funding for K-through-12 education. The challenges we face would be exacerbated if the recent budget proposal by the Trump administration were enacted. Dramatic reductions in Federal operations could lead to dramatic consequences for us. A recent study by George Mason University illustrates them. A decrease of 20,000 to 24,600 Federal jobs in the D.C. region, removing 2.3 billion to 2.7 billion in Federal salaries from our economy. A decrease in 800 million to 1.2 billion in Federal procurement spending in our region. The Trump budget proposal also raises concerns about critical programs and services we provide with Federal funding, eliminating the Community Development Block Grant and HOME Program, funding restoration for the Chesapeake Bay, and funding for Impact Aid in our schools, which partially offsets the costs of federally connected children in our school system. That program is already significantly underfunded in Virginia. Consideration of such massive cuts is alarming. As we point to many successes where Federal contributions were integral, our transportation proposed to be reduced by 13 percent, some excellent projects that have happened in Fairfax County could not happen under this budget proposal. As I mentioned earlier, most mandates come with insufficient funding, but they are also overly prescriptive. If such mandates were eliminated, we in Fairfax County might address the same issues but in a totally, completely different way. We would still need appropriate contributions from our Federal and State partners. We also need to be empowered with the tools to diversify our revenues and strike the appropriate balance for our communities. Conversely, some requirements must be maintained, and it is correctly the Federal Government's role to set priorities for overarching issues of national importance. Localities are struggling to meet increasing needs with decreasing revenues. In Fairfax County, we continue to try to find creative solutions to problems, to leverage the funds that we have, but demands are beginning to outstrip our means. We already do more than is required in areas the State does not provide essential funding and services. We cannot also step into the Federal Government's shoes and backfill the substantial loss of Federal funds. Keep in mind that, unlike the Federal Government, we are required by Virginia law to annually balance our budget, a task made more difficult by Federal underfunding and unfunded mandates from both the State and Federal level. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify on behalf of Fairfax County, Virginia, today, and I look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. McKay follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentleman for his testimony. I will now recognize myself for 5 minutes for questions. Senator Niederhauser, I think it has been consistent in what we have heard is the lack of coordination between the Federal Government and State and local government in regard to these unfunded mandates. What kind of assurances do the States and local governments need that the Federal Government will seriously consider their input? Mr. Niederhauser. I think that improving the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act would be a great place to--I think that's one area that could be worked on. The idea that there is noncompliance with that in the administration I think is a problem. Reaching out to organizations like the Council of State Governments, National Council of State Legislatures. There's other organizations like ALEC. These are all legislative organizations that will give some really good input and State view on issues. And then I think that there ought to be a question asked before you go down the road on any mandate whether that is something the Federal Government ought to be addressing or the State Government. Let me just give you an example. It was probably about 2008-2009; I was chair of the Health System Reform Task Force in Utah. And we were going down the path of health reform. We were one of the first States to create an exchange. Utah, a red State, we created an exchange, a health exchange. We were already on this path, and then we felt like we were preempted by the ACA, the Affordable Care Act. And then we were playing defensive, trying to figure out what that meant for us. And so I think there ought to be that question asked before you even begin the discussion of some laws and especially regulations, because I think what happens is these-- the regulators kind of lose--take laws beyond what they were ever intended to address. And Congress, I believe, needs to be more involved in making those decisions rather than an administration so that we have some more consistency and we have the voice of the people involved. Mr. Palmer. I want to come back to that. But just, in general--and each one of you can answer yes or no, or you can elaborate a little bit if you would like--but based on your experiences, do you believe the unfunded mandate regulatory act's requirement for consultation between State and local governments is effective in its current form? I think you have already answered that, that it needs to be reformed. Mr. Davis? Mr. Davis. I agree that it does need to be reformed. But I think a lot of it has to do with the cost associated with it and rather than the product. I think it is very important that, when we look at these mandates from the Federal Government, that we are looking for a goal, and we are not just concentrating on how much it costs us to get this goal. Mr. Palmer. Mr. Moore? Judge Moore. Mr. Chairman, I believe that UMRA has worked well on the legislative side. Where it has not worked well is on the regulatory side. We, as local and State officials, elected officials, if we are involved in the process on the regulatory side, we can improve the process. We can often I believe avoid some of the pitfalls we see with some of the bureaucracy that we see from the Federal Government. So I would suggest that the successes from the legislative side be more strictly applied to the regulatory side. Mr. Palmer. Mr. Reed? Mr. Reed. Mr. Chairman, I echo the comments of my fellow witnesses. You know, we are asking that, if you have a seat at the table in the beginning, then it will really help eliminate some of the costs that we are finding with our citizens, who are bearing the burden of a lot of the mandates that we have to pay. As I indicated in my testimony, you know, from 2009 and the water bills that continue to be increased, you know, if there was a way that we could actually figure out ways to pay for these items before we actually have to increase the budget, it would help eliminate a lot of the burden that many of our citizens are experiencing. Mr. Palmer. Mr. McKay? Mr. McKay. Thank you. I associate myself with the comments of Mr. Moore as well. I think local government's seat at the table is critical. We are closest to the people. And in terms of interaction with the Feds and State, you know, it's very easy for the States to take Federal unfunded mandates and just push them right down to the county level. And so that's certainly the process that takes place in Virginia. And, you know, there doesn't seem to be the consultation at all with local governments in terms of what impact that has; just a simple legislative act by the States to push down to the lowest level. Mr. Palmer. There is something that is consistent in all of your testimony and I think evident in your answers to that question. That is, is that the process would work much better if we left the implementation of the regulations in the hands of State and local government, even to the degree of perhaps sending the funding down with the regulations. For instance, the EPA mandates. They are writing the regulations, but they're--I think in Mr. Niederhauser's testimony--I think it was your testimony. You said 96.5 percent of the environmental regulations are implemented or administrated at the State level. So it seems to me it would make more sense not only to have this collaborative process where they are getting input from you, but if you are going to do--if the mandates, the regulations need to be implemented, that they allow you the flexibility to implement them. Does that make more sense to you? Nodding is appropriate, but for the record, that indicates an affirmative to the question. I want to come back to some of this and some other areas as well. But at this point, the chair recognizes the ranking member from Florida, Mrs. Demings, for 5 minutes. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. And, again, to our witnesses, thank you so much for being with us today as we discuss this very important topic. Mr. McKay, Fairfax County, like many other counties across the country, relies on Federal funding for its residents. In your testimony, you did express concern, though, about President Trump's budget. How would his proposed cuts impact Fairfax County? If you could just elaborate a little more on how you would be directly impacted. Mr. McKay. Sure. I appreciate the question. First, there's impacts to actual programs that I mentioned in my testimony, significant impacts. As I mentioned, there are 70,000 people in Fairfax County living in poverty. So obviously reductions in the HOME Investment Partnerships, CDBG funding are significant. In terms of our school budget, the reductions in Impact Aid, which is already grossly underperforming what is actually needed to educate our students in Virginia, would be a huge hit for us. And funding for the restoration of the Chesapeake Bay is in jeopardy. I think, though, fundamental to your question, what concerns us the most is what's happening with our Federal workforce. So there are a lot of Federal programs that would affect Fairfax if they are not funded, but as I mentioned, we are home to a significant Federal employee population. And some of the things that are happening under the Trump administration with regard to Federal employee freezes and things of that nature have a significant economic effect on the residents of Fairfax County, Virginia. So we are one of the jurisdictions that has to watch this from multiple levels, not just the cuts to programmatic things and things that our residents rely on, but also cuts to, you know, the Federal workforce and the economic impacts of those. We also are very concerned about some of the impacts to transportation. We are sitting here in the Nation's Capital, many of your staffs rely on Metro to get to and from work. And without Federal support of Metro, we remain very concerned about the funding that's going to be necessary to sustain the Metro system. So we're watching this from many different angles, not just programmatic, but also in terms of the impact to the finances of the very people that live in our county. Mrs. Demings. If the budget cuts did move forward, how do you believe State and local governments would be able to make up the difference? Mr. McKay. I don't believe that we could, to tell you the truth. We in Fairfax long have a history, unfortunately, of having to make up where the State and Federal Governments do not adequately fund programs. But we cannot sustain that. As I mentioned in my testimony, we do not have the revenue sources at the county level to be able to expand. We are left with property taxes, which is a very regressive tax on people in a very high-income but high-cost-of-living area. And so I don't believe that we can sustain the type of Federal cuts that are in this budget, and I don't think that local governments will be able to make that amount up. Mrs. Demings. Thank you. Judge Moore, your organization, the National Association of Counties, supports the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program. Is that correct? Judge Moore. The association, I believe, does, yes. Mrs. Demings. President Trump's proposed budget calls for the elimination of that program. Is that correct? Judge Moore. I am not familiar with that component. Mrs. Demings. So you believe the association does, but you do not have any direct knowledge that the association that you are a part of supports that program? Judge Moore. The association supports the program. I am not familiar with the budget cut. Mrs. Demings. Okay. Judge Moore. What I am here to talk about really is the unfunded mandate process. Mrs. Demings. What I am here to talk about, since we are talking about unfunded mandates, are the proposed cuts by the Trump administration also is taking money away from local and State and county governments. Are you familiar with the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program? Judge Moore. I am. Mrs. Demings. Okay. So let's say that that program was eliminated. Your association, I believe you said your particular county has seen tremendous growth. Is that correct? Tripled over the last 30 years. How do you feel a cut to that program will directly impact members that you represent as a part of the association? Judge Moore. If I answered this as my county and the people that I am elected to represent, I believe that, in that particular case, we would be called upon as local government to either find a way to fund the program or the program would go away. What we do object to is a mandate that says we have to continue the program without funding. Ms. Demings. What would be some alternatives for you to find a way to fund that particular program? Judge Moore. As my colleagues have testified today, local governments are very limited in how we can raise revenue. So it would be very difficult. Mrs. Demings. Thank you. I am out of time. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Palmer. The chair now recognizes the gentleman from Kentucky, Mr. Comer, for 5 minutes. Mr. Comer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I want to recognize Judge Moore. It is good to see you here, Judge. He represents and has been the leader in Boone County for a long time. And there are 120 counties in Kentucky, and Boone County consistently is one of the fastest growing counties in the State. And you have done a great job there overseeing tremendous growth. And Boone County, as I have said many times, is a real economic development success story in Kentucky. Judge Moore, you discussed in your testimony the importance of early consultation with local governments in the Federal rulemaking process and note that in fact the EPA outright refused to consult counties prior to the proposed Waters of the U.S. rule's publication despite repeated requests to do so. My first question, did the EPA and Army Corps provide a reason as to why they did not consult with counties on this rule? Judge Moore. No, they did not give us any reasons. Mr. Comer. Would this rule have imposed a significant cost on counties and local stakeholders? Judge Moore. Absolutely. Probably the best example of that is that we also are under a consent decree, as some others have testified, with combined sewer overflows, sanitary sewer overflows. And we are continuing to raise our sanitary sewer and storm water fees substantially to be able to meet those requirements. We are nearing the affordability threshold of the amount of increase that we can put upon our ratepayers. So, if we were at the table consulting with the Corps and with Federal agencies during this process, we would have some potential solutions on how to deal with that in a more efficient way. Mr. Comer. Good. You mentioned the new administration has started a State and local consultation process on this rule. Have you been able to provide feedback to the EPA and Corps through this process? Judge Moore. I did meet with our State secretary of the environment and energy cabinet who has a regular dialogue with the Federal agencies. And we have talked about some potential solutions. One example would be that we have a payment-in-lieu program when we are developing new property if we impact a wetland or a stream. Those funds are not used efficiently. And environmentalists as well as others would agree that there is a better use for those funds to use those to help eliminate combined sewer overflows and sanitary sewer overflows rather than the projects that are being done now. We are hopeful that our State secretary of environment, working with the Federal agencies, will be able to help us in that situation. Mr. Comer. All right. Have the agencies indicated what they intend do with the feedback that they are supposed to be getting? Judge Moore. Not that I am aware of. Mr. Comer. All right. Next question, Judge Moore, you also shared that the Department of Labor did not adequately consult with State and local governments to assess the impact of its recent overtime rule. Did the agency provide any justification for its failure to cooperatively consult with counties on this rulemaking? Judge Moore. No, not that I am aware of. Mr. Comer. Do you believe it's a good use of your time as an official of local government to have to make repeated requests for meaningful consultation every time the Federal Government decides to act? Judge Moore. I have a lot of other things I would prefer to do. And it would be refreshing to see elected officials involved in that process rather than non-elected. Mr. Comer. Right. Well, hopefully, help is on the way. I believe this new administration has a more commonsense approach to doing business, and hopefully, we can address the unfunded mandate issue that you are always faced with and the Federal Government. And I know that there are a lot of issues that each of you that testified have, and hopefully, we can work together to try to bring some relief for the great jobs you are doing in each of your States. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Palmer. The chair now recognizes the gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Connolly. Mr. Connolly. I thank the chair, and I thank your courtesy. Just for another point of view, I don't know that, at least where I come from, we think help is on the way coming from this new administration. Maybe that's a welcome message in Kentucky. It's not a welcome message in Virginia. Because we are looking at the Trump budget, as Mrs. Demings pointed out, and it looks to me like it is a road map for a whole bunch of additional unfunded mandates. So, for example, Mr. McKay, if we completely defund the Chesapeake Bay Commission, do the requirements to clean up the bay go away? Mr. McKay. They do not. Mr. Connolly. And isn't it true that already the overwhelming financial burden on the cleanup is on the local and State governments? Mr. McKay. It is. Mr. Connolly. So the little piece the Feds provide financially is that commission. So, if it goes away, we lose that guidance; we lose that assistance. But the burden remains on all of the States in the Chesapeake Bay estuary. Is that correct? Mr. McKay. Absolutely correct. Mr. Connolly. That's a pretty expensive mandate to try to clean up the Chesapeake Bay. And, of course, we face the same thing on the Great Lakes and Puget Sound. Their respective commissions are also zeroed out in this budget--that apparently is--help is on the way. I don't know what help that would be in that regard. But CDBG, Community Development Block Grants, to local governments. Mr. Reed, are they helpful at all, CDBG? Mr. Reed. They are extremely helpful. And I will tell you that a number of our community organizations depend on them. If you are thinking about Meals on Wheels or you are thinking about senior citizen homes or what have you, they are dependent on CDBG. And we have seen significant decreases in CDBG in the past several years. And it is one of those Federal funds that many of those organizations who continue to come to us every year as we are looking for appropriations for that, asking for more, and they are doing more with less. Mr. Connolly. So, again, you have got both State and Federal mandates in terms of the provision of mental health, disabilities, senior citizen needs and the like. They don't go away---- Mr. Reed. No. Mr. Connolly. --even if the Federal funding does. Is that correct? Mr. Reed. Correct. Mr. Connolly. Mr. McKay, I noticed Kentucky, of course, did expand Medicaid pursuant to the Affordable Care Act. Virginia did not. And so we have got sort of a healthcare mandate offering funding, but the State chose not to accept the funding. So it is in some ways the State of Virginia choosing politically to undertake an unfunded mandate, isn't it? Mr. McKay. That is correct. And Fairfax County has strongly supported the expansion of Medicaid for the very fundamental financial reasons that you mentioned. It would be a significant influx of funding to the Commonwealth of Virginia to provide health care for people who need it but also to relieve the burdens that local governments face to provide some of that same health care without any reimbursement today. Mr. Connolly. Transportation. So the Federal Government, as you pointed out, has a big stake in the future of Metro since a third of the Federal workforce uses Metro to get to work every day. And I guess 40 percent of the total ridership every day is Federal employees. And if Metro shuts down, so does the Federal Government. There are four members to the compact, three of which provide operating subsidies. Is that correct? Mr. McKay. That is correct. Mr. Connolly. So the fourth one, who is that that does not provide any operating subsidies? Mr. McKay. The Federal Government. Mr. Connolly. And does the Federal Government nonetheless provide oversight and mandates to Metro in terms of how it operates, safety, things like that? Mr. McKay. They do all of the above. And they even have seats on the Metro Board of Directors. Mr. Connolly. And, in fact, recently, this administration, help-on-the-way administration, actually withheld Department of Transportation funding for lots of other unrelated transit projects throughout the Commonwealth of Virginia because of an unrelated issue having to do with Metro and the oversight, safety oversight trilateral commission. Is that correct? Mr. McKay. That is correct. Mr. Connolly. That's interesting. So, at the end of the day--one final thing, a lot of us talk loosely up here about State and local like they are the same. And, of course, we know they are quite different. And a lot of us talk loosely, especially those of us who have no experience in local government, about ``let's just block-grant everything, send it to the State, and their tender mercies will see to it that localities do well.'' What's the problem with that thinking from your perspective vis--vis Richmond? Mr. McKay. There are significant problems with that, some of which I mentioned in my testimony. As the Dillon rule states, the hands of the counties are tied in terms of how they can generate revenue to pay for some of these things. Richmond has a very different political philosophy than Northern Virginia in terms of our Federal partners and how these programs trickle down at the local level. Richmond is very good at just transferring the authority and the requirement to do certain things to local governments but not sending the funding attached to it. More importantly, these things are very prescriptive. And so, in many cases, they are laudable goals; there are things we would certainly do at the county level, and we would do them a whole different way than the prescriptive way. The way we are told how to do these things is particularly concerning. But our relationship with the State in Virginia is unique. As a Dillon rule State, our hands are tied in terms of raising additional revenue. And the State politically and philosophically disagrees with us in many cases. And the one you gave with Medicaid expansion is probably the most egregious one. We are losing, as a county, millions of dollars in Federal support because of the State's inability to support the expansion of Medicaid. So they essentially have our counties in financial shackles. Mr. Connolly. Thank you. And, Mr. Chairman, thank you for your courtesy. Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentleman. It's interesting the direction that the hearing has gone. We've gone into federalism. We've gone into the budget, and now we've gotten into State constitutions and home rule and the Dillon rule. So certainly an interesting conversation. The chairman will now recognize the vice chairman of the subcommittee, Mr. Grothman of Wisconsin, for 5 minutes. Mr. Grothman. Thank you. We anticipate a big infusion in infrastructure later this year, and I assume a lot of that will be sent to the States and local units of government. It's been my experience that frequently highways or other infrastructure projects become much more expensive once Federal money is involved. I'm not going to ask you to deal with Davis-Bacon, because we've all heard about Davis-Bacon. But could any of you comment on perhaps anecdotal evidence or other examples in which you feel you've had to spend more for roads or other projects once Federal money is involved? Judge Moore. Mr. Vice Chair, I could address a portion of that. In Kentucky, recently, prevailing wage was repealed. I know that the Federal level did not--has not---- Mr. Grothman. Just don't deal with Davis-Bacon. Judge Moore. Okay. I won't deal with that. Where we could see improvement is in the NEPA process. Time is money. And in a growing community like ours, getting a project to completion is very important. We have to wait, usually, a season in the fall for the leaves to leave the trees so that we can do an assessment for the Indiana bat, for instance. That delays us a full season in many cases. I do believe there are items within the NEPA process where, if local governments were involved with the regulatory process, as we're speaking today, through UMRA and other acts, it would improve the process. It could bring projects to completion sooner and less costly. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Any of the others. Do you have a comment on that, Mr. Reed? Mr. Reed. Thank you. I will mention, as I indicated in my written testimony to the committee, is that, recently, in Kansas City, Missouri, we had an $800 million general obligation bond, which we put forward to our voters, that would deal with three items: one would be transportation; two being flood control; and three being the ADA and also public facilities. The reason why we had that is because of the very question that you were asking in terms of how can we backfill many of the items that we have to get done. And so we asked our voters to be able to help us with that to help fill those backfills that we have. And it was passed overwhelmingly. But I can tell you it's something that will be a real burden to our citizens over a period of 20 years as we have it. Mr. Grothman. Thank you. Another question I have for you--and I don't need to call this a mandate, but I can think of examples in Wisconsin where maintenance of effort resulted in people doing things they wouldn't do at all otherwise or were stuck--I'll let you go with that, though. Any of the four of you have any comments on maintenance of effort in which you maybe feel you are forced to do things you wouldn't do otherwise or think is outright a complete waste of money? Mr. Niederhauser. I mentioned the Perkins Program, the Perkins grant with education. And I think that's a perfect example: $12 million mandating $241 million of State funding. While we would do some of that already, the flexibility and efficiencies of crafting those things on our own--we're there on the ground. We're where the rubber meets the road, maybe not quite as much as the local governments. But I know that we can get the outcomes, because I think that's what we're missing here, is focusing on what the outcomes are. And let's not have regulation that's making us do something that is not getting the outcomes. I can--we have a list of those things--and focus on clean air, clean water, getting our children educated. But we waste and we burn money with regulation that really doesn't have an impact on the bottom line. Mr. Grothman. I think of TANF funds. For both of the guys on the State level, do you ever feel that you're getting money that you don't need? Mr. Niederhauser. Yes. We have unspent TANF money in Utah. Mr. Grothman. Right. So you're in a position--maybe you can give us an example--in which you maybe have to make up something to do just to sop up the Federal money. Mr. Niederhauser. I think that that happens. No question. Mr. Grothman. Can you give an example of what you do in Utah when you have a bunch of money sitting around that you really don't want to use, but the Federal Government says you got to use it. Mr. Niederhauser. I think that's obvious. You start to create programs and spend it where it's really not necessary. Mr. Grothman. I don't want to embarrass any programs, but do you find the same thing in North Carolina, Mr. Davis. Mr. Davis. Yes, sir, we do. And I'm--this session, I'm the new chair of Transportation Policy and Appropriations. And I've--2 weeks ago, I spent my spring vacation visiting the Outer Banks and looking at the issues that they have to deal with out there. And I haven't seen any money in transportation that we couldn't use yet, but I sure have seen a lot of unfunded mandates. And particularly what we're working with is environmental assessments when we have a transportation project to deal with these environmental regulations that delay the completion of these projects and add exponentially to the cost. Mr. Grothman. Okay. Can I just still get one comment from Mr. Niederhauser? I would like if you could get something together because we have an Appropriations Committee that I hope I can trust--but we don't know yet--who might be under the impression we have to keep TANF at the current level. If you could give us something in writing that we could forward to these guys so they can realize--I know Wisconsin also does things that we--just throwing away money because we have a maintenance of effort on this stuff. But thank you. Mr. Niederhauser. Thank you. Mr. Palmer. I thank the gentlemen. The chair recognizes the ranking member, Mrs. Demings, for additional questions. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Councilman Reed, the administration's proposed budget would cut 482 million from the EPA's categorical grant programs that aid State and local governments in protecting human health and the environment. Your testimony indicates that cutting categorical grant programs that serve State and local governments is a step in the wrong direction. Is that correct? And why do you feel that way? Mr. Reed. Well, we feel it's a cut--as I believe I even mentioned earlier--is that these would be, unfortunately, ways that we would have to try to figure out, where do we get funding from? And so we feel that it would be a step in the wrong direction. Mrs. Demings. According to the National League of Cities, another quote is, ``Measures requiring cities to use local law enforcement resources to enforce Federal immigration laws are unfunded mandates that impose additional disproportionate responsibilities on local law enforcement, increase financial liability on local governments, and ultimately move us further from our fundamental principles of federalism,'' which Mr. Niederhauser spoke so eloquently about in his opening statement. Mr. McKay, do you share the concerns of the National League of Cities that measures requiring local law enforcement to enforce Federal immigration laws are unfunded mandates? Mr. McKay. I do. I think they're the mother of all unfunded mandates. Not only would they cost us money, but they would permanently damage the relationship that law enforcement in Fairfax County has with our community and further endanger our citizens. Bottom line is our police prevent crime and solve crimes. And without a robust conversation with a community that feels comfortable talking to law enforcement, we think it would have a significant impact on our ability to solve crimes, protect victims, and seek proper prosecution. We do cooperate with ICE when we have an opportunity to. But asking local governments to take on a massive Federal responsibility, such as immigration enforcement, we think is damaging not only as a mandate but also damaging to the fabric of our community. Mrs. Demings. At the same time, the administration's budget proposal cuts the State Criminal Alien Assistance Program, a grant program to reimburse States and local governments for incarcerating undocumented immigrants, which would appear that counties would then--or local governments would then incur millions of dollars in unreimbursed expenses each year in housing undocumented individuals that violate State and local laws. Do you believe that cutting programs such as this leaves local government then holding the bag? Mr. McKay. It absolutely would leave us holding the bag. Mrs. Demings. Thank you so much. Mr. Chair, I yield back. Mr. Palmer. Thank you. I have a few additional questions. Senator Niederhauser, you mentioned in your testimony that State-based innovation is being stifled because of Federal mandates. I've been involved in this area for a number of years, going all the way back to the passage of the Unfunded Mandates Relief Act. The thing that I've seen is that, particularly with the EPA and other Federal agencies, they've gotten outside of what the original intent was. Originally, it was designed to operate within a framework of what we called cooperative federalism where the--let's just use the EPA as an example. They would write the regulations. Congress would pass the law. The EPA would write the regulations. But it would be up to the States--they were given broad latitude and flexibility to implement the regulations as long as they met the objectives. In your experience in the State of Utah, is that intent still being complied with? Mr. Niederhauser. Well, we want clean water, and we want clean air. Those are good outcomes. But we feel like we're tripping over a bunch of regulation that's costing us a lot of money, creating inefficiencies and burning State tax. Mr. Palmer. Let me ask it this way. Does the State of Utah have the ability to effectively partner with the Federal Government, whether it is the EPA or another Federal agency, to implement Federal regulations. Mr. Niederhauser. No. It's a top-down approach to government. Mr. Palmer. But do you think you have the ability within the State of Utah to implement these guidelines if given the flexibility and the latitude to do so. Mr. Niederhauser. Yes. Absolutely. Utah has shown through a number of different policies that we can innovate, that we can do things and have outcomes and save tax dollars. Mr. Palmer. Do you believe that you can do it in a more cost-effective manner and accomplish the same objectives than within the current framework that you're having to operate under. Mr. Niederhauser. Absolutely. No question. Mr. Palmer. Senator Davis. Mr. Davis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'd love to speak to this issue. I think that the presumption that all wisdom and knowledge emanates from our Nation's Capital or our State's capital is an erroneous one. Some of the most creative and innovative ideas that I've ever seen are from local government. As a matter of fact, I use them as a resource. Unfortunately, many of them tell me that ``nobody from the State has ever asked me how to accomplish this.'' And for that reason, I strongly support block-granting a lot of things to the State and to the local government. Hold them accountable. Tell them what the goal is and what the end product that you want. But get rid of a lot of needless regulations. Those people on the ground, they know what they are. Just release them. Mr. Palmer. To your point, I'd like to point out that if you look at the data--and it's government data--improvements in air quality, water quality, and land use, that sort of thing, most--and, obviously, it was the low-hanging fruit--but most of the improvements, the biggest improvements, occurred when we operated under the concept of cooperative federalism. Judge Moore, does Boone County have the ability to carry out these mandates without it being a top-down, inflexible approach? Judge Moore. No. We need to be at the table during the process. Mr. Palmer. You don't think you can, or do you agree that you could carry this out if you're a partner in this? Judge Moore. If we're a partner and we have a voice in the process, many times, I think we can. There may be some situations we cannot. An example, with the Clean Water Act and with the payment- in-lieu fees for impacts to streams and wetlands, I mentioned we have combined sewer overflows and sanitary sewer overflows. We're not allowed to use these mitigation fees to clean up our streams in the same watershed. Instead, those revenues are pulled to another watershed, usually in another county, and we never see the revenue again. We do agree with the environmentalists in our area, a better use of those funds would be to use them in the same watershed to eliminate SSOs and CSOs. That would be a perfect example of not spending more money at the Federal level but receiving a better outcome if we're part of the process. Mr. Palmer. Mr. Reed--and I realize that there's certain programs, particularly at the local level, that would be outside your expertise. But you mentioned health care and the burdens of Medicaid that are being imposed on you. If given the ability to have more flexibility in the administration of these programs, do you think you could do that effectively and efficiently. Mr. Reed. Well, I didn't in my testimony mention--I believe it was one of my other partners here on the dais who mentioned the health care. But I think I share, of course, the same example, is that if we have to carry these out, we, of course, as a community, will. But the relief that we need is, of course, having the opportunity to address these items in the beginning, and having a seat at the table to talk about ways that we can actually pay for it is most important to us. Mr. Palmer. Mr. McKay, you've been nodding your head. Mr. McKay. Yeah. I agree entirely with what's been said. The flexibility in so many of these things is important at the local level. One size does not fit all. And many times, Federal regulations don't recognize the local environments under which they're being applied. And the only way to realize that is to have local officials at the table and a good, cooperative relationship. So, while I agree with many of the Federal requirements, certainly of the EPA, and want clean air and clean water, we would like to see more flexibility in how those are applied; a recognition, particularly, of local governments' ability to pay and absorb these regulations; and, frankly, more flexible timelines, less punitive actions and more cooperation, especially with the jurisdictions who are making attempts to do the right thing. There doesn't ever seem to be a recognition of that when the Federal Government is looking at these. And so one size does not fit all in the ground-level application of these regulations. We need that flexibility. Mr. Palmer. Well, I ask these questions in the spirit of--I believe it was another Virginian who had this observation that the government that governs best governs closest to the people. And I think you have more transparency. You have more accountability. But you also have the ability to innovate. One size does not fit all. That's particularly important, I think, in the area, for instance, of Medicaid and giving the States the flexibility to innovate, and I think it eliminates a lot of the problems we have with improper payments of Medicaid. We sent out $36.3 billion last year in improper payments on Medicaid. Same thing is true of going back to the original intent of the EPA and cooperating with State and local government and allowing State and local government to implement Federal regulations with broad latitude as long as you meet the standard, because the objective, as Senator Niederhauser has mentioned several times, is we want clean air, clean water. We want wise land use. We want to preserve the environment for the future. But those are not inconsistent with allowing the States more latitude in carrying out these regulations. And I think the situation that we find ourselves in right now with these unfunded mandates makes that extremely difficult for you and extremely costly and diverts resources away from other programs that really need the money and makes it--and particularly at the local level because you've got so little ability to generate revenues to meet some of these mandates. I now recognize the vice chairman, Mr. Grothman of Wisconsin, for 5 minutes. Mr. Grothman. I just want to give you guys one more chance, because I can think of so many ways that--constantly, constantly ran into situations where States are doing something that is sometimes a complete waste of money and sometimes even counterproductive to meet Federal mandates. Particularly for the State guys, Mr. Niederhauser and Mr. Davis, do you have any experience on problems with education because of Federal mandates, things where your schools are maybe doing something they wouldn't have to do otherwise? Mr. Niederhauser. Well, there's a lot of examples. One was just--it's been several years ago--how school lunches changed, mandated by--well, that was an administration issue. They were working fine in Utah, but the new requirements--actually, my wife works at the elementary school across the street. She found that children were eating less. Even though some of those were intended to--some of those mandates were intended to help nutrition, the outcomes were not there. In fact, it was the opposite. So that's just one. There's---- Mr. Grothman. Could you give us some others? Mr. Niederhauser. Yeah. For example, I mentioned the Perkins Program in my testimony. But just the thing that really we struggle with in Utah is--education is a big deal. Mr. Grothman. Uh-huh. Mr. Niederhauser. And 91 percent of the money comes from State assessments, taxes. But yet 9 percent of the money coming from here in Washington is driving the ship. And the outcomes that we could accomplish without those regulatory burdens and the desire we have for every dollar that--those are all precious dollars. So we don't want to give up any of them, and, consequently, we allow Washington to dictate a lot of what we do. Mr. Grothman. Right. Okay. Mr. Reed, it looks like you've had problems--we've had problems too. Nobody argues with the idea that we should help people with disabilities. But sometimes when you hear about the Federal mandates, they require things that you wonder who they're really helping, other than the construction companies. You had some problems with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Do you care on elaborating about that? Mr. Reed. Thank you. I appreciate the opportunity to elaborate a little further. You know, I think one of the things is the time constraints for our resources in directing how much work has to be done and when it has to be done. We want to make sure that we're meeting the terms and the agreements as part of our settlement. But a longer timeframe and also additional flexibility for priority of the projects also benefit our city and our citizens, allowing a more efficient plan of how we think the resources should be used. As I mentioned earlier, too, about our general obligation bond, which we passed, I mean, we want to make sure we're compliant. We want to make sure we're providing places where many of our citizens are able to get in and out of facilities and have the access that they need and deserve. But we also need to do it within a good timeframe that allows for us to do it in a way that the resources are actually there. Mr. Grothman. Do you ever find you're being asked to do things that cost more money that you look at and you wonder, who are you even benefiting. Mr. Reed. Sure. I mean--yeah. Mr. Grothman. It's horribly designed. The Federal Government ought not be involved in this stuff or should be much less involved. I'll put it that way. The Clean Air Act, I guess, is a problem for Kansas City, right? The Ozone Standard? Mr. Reed. Correct. Yes. Mr. Grothman. And this is something, I take it, the Federal Government may make it much more expensive to operate manufacturing facilities in Kansas City. Is that right. Mr. Reed. Yeah, it is. You know, it's one of the things that I mentioned even in my testimony earlier and also in my written testimony, that it is a problem. I mean, it's 70 parts per billion that we continue to see. And our State, local government, and also our Mid-America Regional Council has been working to kind of find ways to--forward. And we've got to figure out how to fix it. Mr. Grothman. You lived in Kansas City a long time. Mr. Reed. Born and raised. Mr. Grothman. Wow. Did you feel unhealthy living in Kansas City 30 years ago. Mr. Reed. Say that again. Mr. Grothman. Did you feel unhealthy living in Kansas City 30 years ago. Mr. Reed. Well, I wouldn't recall 30 years ago. Mr. Grothman. Okay. We have an ozone problem in the Wisconsin area. I felt quite healthy growing up, and now they've got a lot stricter things. But as we fight for jobs for our cities, there are--and I know there are people who--you know, I don't know how they expect big cities to thrive without manufacturing jobs, but apparently people do. But you do feel that you're putting manufacturers in Kansas City at a competitive disadvantage with other areas around the country as well as other countries? Do you feel that way? Mr. Reed. Yeah, we do. And it's how do we provide that relief is what's most important as well. Mr. Grothman. Well, I hope you let everybody in Kansas City know it's the Federal Government who is making it more difficult to get these manufacturing jobs, and we'll see what we can do about making that part of Mr. Trump's Drain the Swamp initiative. Thank you very much. Mr. Palmer. I would like to thank the witnesses for taking the time to appear before us today. Mr. Niederhauser, I think there was a request for additional information on your TANF program in Utah, which if you provide that, appreciate if you provide it to the subcommittee, and we will provide that to Vice Chairman Grothman. Mr. Palmer. If there are no objections, with that, the subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:37 a.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]