Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- PATIENT-FOCUSED CARE: A PRESCRIPTION TO REDUCE HEALTH CARE COSTS [Senate Hearing 115-687] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 115-687 PATIENT-FOCUSED CARE: A PRESCRIPTION TO REDUCE HEALTH CARE COSTS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ OCTOBER 3, 2018 __________ Serial No. 115-21 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov ___________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 35-285 PDF WASHINGTON : 2019 SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine, Chairman ORRIN G. HATCH, Utah ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania JEFF FLAKE, Arizona BILL NELSON, Florida TIM SCOTT, South Carolina KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut BOB CORKER, Tennessee JOE DONNELLY, Indiana RICHARD BURR, North Carolina ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts MARCO RUBIO, Florida CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO, Nevada DEB FISCHER, Nebraska DOUG JONES, Alabama CONTENTS ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman.......... 1 Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member........ 3 PANEL OF WITNESSES David Howes, M.D., President and Chief Executive Officer, Martin's Point Health Care, Portland, Maine.................... 5 Jeff Micklos, Executive Director, Health Care Transformation Task Force, Washington, DC.......................................... 7 Sean Cavanaugh, Chief Administrative and Performance Officer, Aledade, Bethesda, Maryland.................................... 9 Reverend Sally Jo Snyder, Director of Advocacy and Consumer Engagement, Consumer Health Coalition, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 11 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements David Howes, M.D., President and Chief Executive Officer, Martin's Point Health Care, Portland, Maine.................... 34 Jeff Micklos, Executive Director, Health Care Transformation Task Force, Washington, DC.......................................... 64 Sean Cavanaugh, Chief Administrative and Performance Officer, Aledade, Bethesda, Maryland.................................... 68 Reverend Sally Jo Snyder, Director of Advocacy and Consumer Engagement, Consumer Health Coalition, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 78 Additional Statements for the Record Justice in Aging (formerly the National Senior Citizens Law Center)........................................................ 92 LeadingAge, an association of nonprofit aging services providers. 93 PATIENT-FOCUSED CARE: A PRESCRIPTION TO REDUCE HEALTH CARE COSTS ---------- WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 3, 2018 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:30 a.m., in room SD-562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Susan M. Collins (Chairman of the Committee) presiding. Present: Senators Collins, Fischer, Casey, Nelson, Gillibrand, Donnelly, Cortez Masto, and Jones. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SUSAN M. COLLINS, CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The Committee will come to order. Good morning. First, let me apologize to our witnesses that we have a bit of a media ``circus,'' I guess is the right word for it, outside of the hearing room today. But that does not detract from the important work that we are doing inside this hearing room today. And I very much appreciate your patience with getting through the hoards of reporters and protesters and others because the issue that we are focusing on today, like so many issues that are confronting the Senate right now, are extremely important. According to a recent poll, for more than a year now, Americans have listed health care as the most important issue facing our country. This should come as no surprise. Health care is deeply personal. It is a complex issue that affects each and every one of us. It comprises one-sixth of the American economy. In 2016, we spent $3.3 trillion on health care. If we want to improve the affordability and accessibility of health care, we simply must get a handle on the cost while also focusing on improving the quality and patient outcomes. This Committee has already addressed health care costs from several different angles. We have focused on how market failures and a lack of transparency affect the pricing of prescription drugs. For example, we have examined the rising cost of insulin and rheumatoid arthritis drugs, as well as the tangled nature of the relationships among pharmaceutical companies, pharmacy benefit managers, and various other components of the supply chain. We have also highlighted the need for more investment in medical research in the areas of diabetes, Alzheimer's disease, and other devastating illnesses, which have significant financial costs for our country. Today we examine a different aspect of health care costs: How can we better leverage spending on innovations and quality initiatives that help keep patients well? And, critically, what specific actions would help us to succeed in that mission and to help moderate the rising cost of health care? Health care providers often refer to the ``Triple Aim'': improving the patient experience of care, including quality and satisfaction; improving the health of populations; and reducing the per capita cost of health care. Without a doubt, tremendous opportunities exist for improvement. As Dr. Atul Gawande correctly observes, ``The one thing the medical profession is not rewarded for is providing better, higher-value care. . . . In a fee-for-service payment system--a system of paying doctors and hospitals by pill and procedure--we are actually penalized for making the effort to organize and deliver care with the best service, quality, and efficiency we can.'' Part of the solution to bringing down health costs is to emphasize prevention as well as other cost-effective health interventions. According to the Centers for Disease Control, chronic diseases that are avoidable through preventive care services account for 75 percent of the Nation's health care spending, yet all too often, the incentives are wrong. For example, colorectal cancer is one of the leading causes of cancer deaths, yet it is also one of the few cancers that can be prevented with proper screening. A recent study finds more than 14,000 colon cancer deaths could be prevented every year if health care providers matched the screening and mortality rates of America's highest-performing health systems. We need to learn more from these providers and remove barriers that prevent better performance, but we also need to examine Medicare reimbursement policies. Seniors covered by Medicare are eligible for colorectal cancer screenings without out-of-pocket costs; however, if a physician takes a further preventive action--such as removing a polyp--during the screening while the patient is under anesthesia, the patient is billed as if the procedure were a treatment rather than prevention. This makes no sense to me at all, and I have talked to physicians in Bangor, Maine, where I live, who tell me that when their patients learn this, they will actually cancel the colonoscopy because they are so afraid of being saddled with considerable costs. And that is why I have cosponsored the Removing Barriers to Colorectal Cancer Screenings Act, and I am joining several of my colleagues in sending a letter to CMS encouraging the agency to change its reimbursement and solve this problem. That is just one example. The care of individuals with diabetes--I know it is an issue of special interest to Dr. Howes--offers another lesson. Medicare will pay for all the serious complications of uncontrolled diabetes--amputations, blindness, heart disease; it affects every system in the body--but the program often reimburses poorly for innovative programs that can help avoid these devastating consequences. Again, that just makes no sense to me. Recently I joined with my Senate Diabetes Caucus Co- Chairman Jeanne Shaheen to expand Medicare coverage for diabetes self-management training sessions, where diabetes educators help train patients on how to manage their glucose, maintain a healthy weight, eat healthy foods, manage their insulin levels, and improve general care for their diabetes. On the other end of the spectrum from prevention is the problem of inefficient and wasteful health care spending. According to the Institute of Medicine, spending in the United States on health care waste totaled approximately $750 billion, or as much as 30 percent of our Nation's health care spending. Today we will hear from witnesses who bring a variety of very valuable perspectives on how we can successfully achieve better value, lower costs, and higher quality in health care spending. Participating in innovative care models that align payment with quality and value, improving patient engagement and communication efforts, and deploying data to help both clinicians and patients manage chronic conditions are all critical components to improving our health care system and reducing costs. I want to thank our witnesses for joining us today. I know you have a lot of valuable information to share with the Committee, and I look forward to your statements. I now would turn to our Ranking Member, Senator Casey, for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., RANKING MEMBER Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins, for holding this hearing today. Every American will interact with our health care system, and we owe every citizen a system that ensures that they can afford the care that they need, no matter what illness or accident that they will endure. We owe taxpayers a system that guarantees federal dollars are spent wisely and efficiently. We owe health care providers a payment system that allows them to focus on what matters most: patient care. The Affordable Care Act provides individuals, families, taxpayers, and providers all of these benefits. The Affordable Care Act expanded coverage to 20 million Americans. It provides key consumer protections, like protections against being denied coverage or being charged more for coverage due to a pre- existing condition. It invests in proven reforms to our health care delivery system and updated payment models so that providers and patients can work together as partners in shaping their care. These are key improvements to health care in America, enhancing care and reducing costs for patients, providers, and health care systems alike. The Affordable Care Act is not perfect, and we have more work to do to lower costs--just by way of one example. Recently, the administration refused to defend the Affordable Care Act's protections for people with pre-existing conditions in a lawsuit led by 20 Republican-led states. Each of us is one accident or one illness away from joining the millions of Americans with a pre-existing condition. In Pennsylvania, that number is 5.3 million people with a pre- existing condition. Chairman Collins and I agree that we must keep our promise to Americans with pre-existing conditions while working to improve care quality and lower costs. Congress made a commitment to payment innovation in the Affordable Care Act as well. The law expanded an important program called ``Money Follows the Person.'' It makes it possible for seniors and people with disabilities to receive the care they need in the very place they most want to be--at home and among those in their community. Alongside Chairman Collins, I am a proud cosponsor of this legislation to extend this essential program. Congress should act to continue Money Follows the Person before the year's end. Today the Committee will discuss ways to build upon improvements like Money Follows the Person and other programs made possible by the Affordable Care Act. This is an important conversation. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses about how we can preserve everything from coverage protections to the innovative programs included in the ACA, but also what more we can do to make our health care system even stronger. Thank you, and I look forward to today's discussion. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Casey. I also want to acknowledge two of our colleagues who have joined us. Senator Donnelly and Senator Jones, thank you for being here this morning. Dr. Howes, we are going to start with you, but I want to give you a proper introduction first. Our first witness today is Dr. David Howes, the president and CEO of Martin's Point Health Care, a not-for-profit health care organization headquartered in Portland, Maine. I have known Dr. Howes for many years and have always been so impressed with the innovative approach that he brings. He began his career as a family physician in rural Maine. In fact, he actually served on some of Maine's islands for a while. That truly is providing health care to a population that otherwise would have great difficulty in accessing it. He brought this background to Martin's Point, first as a primary care physician and now as the president and CEO. Martin's Point is unique in that it provides direct patient care at seven health centers in Maine and New Hampshire, and also offers highly rated Generations Advantage plans to Medicare beneficiaries in Maine and New Hampshire, as well as the U.S. Family Health Plan's TRICARE Prime to military families in northern New England, New York, and Pennsylvania. We will then hear from Jeff Micklos, the executive director of the Health Care Transformation Task Force. The Health Care Transformation Task Force is an industry consortium of payers, providers, purchasers, and patients who are committed to accelerating the pace of transforming the health care delivery system. They share a common commitment to transforming their respective businesses and clinical models to deliver person- centered, high-quality care at lower cost through innovation. Next we will hear from Sean Cavanaugh, a famous name around here these days. [Laughter.] The Chairman. But it is spelled differently, I would note. He is--and this is sheer coincidence--the chief administrative and performance officer at Aledade. Aledade provides value- based care through physician-led accountable care organizations, ACOs, across the country. Mr. Cavanaugh will discuss his company's successes thus far in reducing spending and improving health care outcomes as well as how accountable care organizations fit into the health innovation landscape. Mr. Cavanaugh previously served as Deputy Director and Administrator of the Centers for Medicare at CMS. I now will turn to our Ranking Member to introduce our witness from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I am pleased to introduce Reverend Sally Jo Snyder, a Pittsburgh resident and long-time consumer and patient advocate. Reverend Snyder and I met I guess last year in McKeesport. I did not have a chance to say hello to her personally today. I will do that after the hearing. But thank you for being here. Reverend Snyder's organization, the Consumer Health Coalition, provides consumer education and health insurance counseling to Pennsylvanians across the state. Among many programs, Reverend Snyder provides trainings to help empower patients to be active participants in their care. These issues are not only at the heart of Reverend Snyder's profession, they are deeply personal. She lost her Mom to what should have been an avoidable hospital-acquired infection. To borrow a phrase from Reverend Snyder, I am confident her testimony will inspire us to ``make good ripples'' as we work together to transform our Nation's health care system. Reverend Snyder, thank you for being here, and we look forward to your testimony. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Dr. Howes. STATEMENT OF DAVID HOWES, M.D., PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, MARTIN'S POINT HEALTH CARE, PORTLAND, MAINE Dr. Howes. Thank you, Senator Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of the Committee on Aging for this opportunity to provide testimony regarding the health care landscape for seniors in Maine. My name is David Howes, and I am the president and CEO of Martin's Point Health Care. We are a not-for-profit integrated health care organization based in Portland, Maine, and we provide care and coverage to about 155,000 people. In my testimony today, I want to share with you a picture of the health care landscape for seniors in our home state--a landscape shared, I am sure, by many states with significant aging populations in rural areas. I will also tell you what relatively small, but we like to think mighty, health care organization is doing to address the significant needs of this population and how our nonprofit status allows us to go the extra mile in serving both patients and members and improving the health of our communities. If you would like to learn more, please refer to my testimony for full details on my credentials and background, as well as a number of innovative outcomes that define the high- quality care we provide at Martin's Point. I would like to start, though, by sharing a personal story from my home State of Maine. This summer my son, Owen, began work in one of the most physically demanding careers in Maine. He is serving as a sternman on a lobster boat under the tutelage of his boss, ``Captain Mike.'' I mention this because, to my delight, after he took the job, I discovered that Captain Mike is a Martin's Point health plan member and a Martin's Point patient. He comes to one of our health care centers before each lobster season, making the journey from his island home in Vinalhaven to our health care center in Brunswick, some 70 miles south. He comes to have his knees treated for his increasing arthritis--he calls it ``getting a grease job''--the result of many years hauling lobster pots. Now at an age when a lot of people are planning retirement, Captain Mike is teaching my son, a member of the new generation, the intricacies of catching lobsters. In the off-season, he returns to the mainland as an art teacher. I think Senator Collins would agree that his career reflects the way many Mainers make a living-- doing what they do best, often combining a variety of occupations to add up to a satisfying and sustaining whole. Mike could choose to have his knees worked on closer to home, but he chooses to travel to Martin's Point because we have earned his trust. By providing both his primary care and his insurance coverage, we are uniquely positioned to consider the full spectrum of his health and support him on land and sea, reliably and affordably. At Martin's Point we believe we have much to offer members like Mike and thousands of other rural seniors in Maine, who seek a trusted health care partner who shares their local roots. It is important to remember, though, that for every energetic lobsterman in Maine, there are many more of our members who are confronting the converging effects of chronic illness, forgetfulness, and limited mobility. Some of the most poignant examples of our provider-patient connections come to me from the nurses who administer our home- based care management programs. They tell me about the little things that they note in their assessments during a home visit, such as the condition of the house, the person's appearance, and the visible signs of declining self-care. During a recent visit to conduct medication reconciliation, our nurse arrived at an older man's home to find that he was storing his medication in various receptacles throughout his home, including spice jars in his kitchen. He had lost track of the number and schedule of his medications. She worked to place all of his pills in one of our organized containers and then reviewed the dosage and frequency with him. The pill box probably cost us less than a dime, but the time spent in conversation and companionship and instruction allowed us to make a full assessment of his circumstances and offer him additional support and monitoring. As we do this with more and more seniors in Maine, the dime containers represent thousands of dollars per patient in avoided incidents, hospitalizations, and readmissions. I regard our care management programs as some of the best innovation work we are doing at Martin's Point, and they continue to illustrate to me that the little things, not always medical, make a huge difference. All in all, we care for a lot of people in Maine, but at the heart of what we do is our ``true north'': We are people caring for people--our patients, our members, each other, and our community. We are very committed to the Triple Aim and score ourselves on the Triple Aim quarterly to see that we are actually making a difference against each of those objectives. Our care extends to our annual quality metrics that we believe are essential to better health outcomes and form a central part of our organization-wide employee incentive plan. A quarter of our employees' annual incentive is based on a set of quality metrics that are uniform for all 800 employees. We have dedicated particular attention to the care of chronic conditions such as diabetes and congestive heart failure. We seek great promise in comprehensive home-based care and are seeing promising early returns on our investment in this care model. We have been recognized for our recent work in opioid mitigation, particularly for elders, and we accomplish all that we do through our lean health care management system. I am pleased to be with you here this morning and would be glad to take your questions on any of the work that we are doing to support our patients and members. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Dr. Howes. Mr. Micklos. STATEMENT OF JEFF MICKLOS, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, HEALTH CARE TRANSFORMATION TASK FORCE, WASHINGTON, DC Mr. Micklos. Good morning, Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of the Senate Special Committee on Aging. Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss innovative approaches to improving value in the health care system for older Americans. My name is Jeff Micklos, and I am the executive director of the Health Care Transformation Task Force. As Chairman Collins said, we are a diverse group of industry stakeholders across providers, health plans, employers, and consumers. We are looking to accelerate the pace of delivery system transformation. Our payer and provider members aspire to have 75 percent of their business in value- based payment arrangements by 2020. While the task force supports many types of value-based payment and care delivery models, my testimony this morning will focus on accountable care organizations. ACOs refer to health care organizations that manage the health of their population by tying payment incentives to quality metrics and the cost of care. Last year the task force conducted a study of the 21 highest-performing Medicare ACOs based on 2015 performance data. The most successful ACOs focused on three key elements: one, achieving a high-value culture; two, developing strong population health management programs; and, three, creating structures that can ensure continuous improvement in performance over time. The highest-performing ACOs first and foremost have a strong commitment to developing a culture that supports innovation and is committed to the mission of improving care delivery. That commitment must be unwavering in the face of multiple obstacles. Changing culture takes time and requires effective leadership at many levels. Most of the successful organizations we profiled had previous experience managing financial risk before implementing an ACO model, including through commercial payment arrangements with payers. They also had the support and commitment of executive leaders who saw the importance of investing in new models, as well as governance structures that are conducive to fostering a high-value culture. Organizations with high-value cultures understood the importance of engaging clinicians and care teams to accomplish shared goals and demonstrated a commitment to practice education, support services, and compensation structures that reward continuous improvement. ACOs succeed with truly engaged multidisciplinary care teams committed to understanding how their practice patterns influence the goals of the ACO and serving as champions to help guide their peers. The crux of any successful payment program is top-notch care delivery. For ACOs, having very strong population health management programs is critical. These programs serve the essential function of identifying at-risk patients with multiple medical conditions and acting swiftly to ensure that these patients receive the best, most personalized care possible to avoid unnecessary hospitalizations. Effective population health management programs truly put the patient first by using tools and resources that facilitate personalized, proactive care. Vanguard health care providers risk-stratify patients using homegrown analytics models, electronic health record modules, and population health software. These high-tech processes are combined with expert recommendations from physicians on how best to provide treatment that is individualized to patient needs. Risk stratification practices are key. For example, Atrius Health, a physician-led ACO based in Boston, has taken on risk for its Medicare fee-for-service members for several years, most recently in the Next Gen ACO program. The organization determined that the second-largest opportunity for savings after post-acute care was hospitalization prevention. Atrius built an analytical model that would allow it to proactively identify patients with high clinical risk and assign a score to those individuals based on their likeliness of hospitalization in the next six months. The score is reviewed by a care team to ensure a comprehensive care plan is in place for each patient. A case management team conducts outreach, and high-risk patients are provided with access to additional services such as same-day appointments. Atrius' approach has resulted in the organization saving Medicare an impressive $10.4 million in 2016 and $6.8 million in 2015, while maintaining a quality score of over 95 percent. The best population health management programs employ interdisciplinary care teams that typically consist of physicians, nurse care managers, pharmacists, social workers, and care guides or navigators. Patient needs inform who from the care team should focus on the patient. For example, a social worker may be best equipped to interact most often with the patients struggling with social factors such as housing or food instability or access to transportation that directly contribute to his or her health status. Strong population health programs also partner with existing community resources and local public health departments to ensure that all facets of a patient's health challenges are addressed. Today addressing social determinants of health is a concept that gets a lot of attention, and rightfully so, and maturing ACOs are increasingly focused on those factors as a way of caring completely for patients. Partnering with community organizations is important to a comprehensive care regimen for individuals. Finally, we have found that successful ACOs must have continuous improvement structures in place to drive value once the low-hanging fruit has been plucked. It is simply not enough for health care providers to change their business model in one go and coast. They must constantly reevaluate their performance and business structures. The most sophisticated organizations have dedicated data, actuarial, and performance improvement resources that are constantly looking for new opportunities to increase value. All organizations should expect to run into challenges on their journeys. That is why participation in shared learning opportunities is critical. The ability to share experiences, compare data with peers, and access to organizations that are more advanced in their value models can be tremendously helpful for budding ACOs. Regional health improvement collaboratives, such as those found in Maine and Pennsylvania, and national consortiums offer outlets for organizations that are interested in learning from peers and cross-industry partners. The task force serves this function for national collaborators. In closing, changing our health care system is not something that can be accomplished in one fell swoop. Rather, we are rebuilding brick by brick the foundation upon which our care is paid for and delivered. Not all innovation will be an immediate success, and it is incumbent upon all to identify what holds promise and stay the course until sustainable change is achieved. Patience and diligence are absolutely essential. Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of this Committee, thank you again for the opportunity to testify, and I look forward to your questions. The Chairman. Thank you very much for your testimony. I also want to welcome Senator Cortez Masto and Senator Fischer, who have joined us this morning. Mr. Cavanaugh. STATEMENT OF SEAN CAVANAUGH, CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE AND PERFORMANCE OFFICER, ALEDADE, BETHESDA, MARYLAND Mr. Cavanaugh. Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of the Committee, thank you for inviting me today to discuss how Aledade is partnering with independent physicians to provide patient-focused care that reduces costs and improves outcomes. My name is Sean Cavanaugh. I am the chief administrative officer at Aledade. Prior to joining Aledade, I served at CMS for six years, including a period as Deputy Director of the Innovation Center and three years as the Deputy Administrator and Director of the Center for Medicare, where I supported the movement toward value-based models. I am proud to continue that work at Aledade. At Aledade, we bring together independent primary care practices who are committed to value-based care. We form them into an ACO and join the Medicare Shared Savings Program. Aledade ensures the success of the ACO by providing data- informed population health tools and transforming how the practices deliver care. We also negotiate value-based contracts with commercial payers, too, so our physicians can transform care for their entire panel of patients. I am pleased to report to the Committee that value-based payment is working in the Medicare Shared Savings Program. Beneficiaries are getting better care, and Medicare is saving money. In 2017, 10.5 million Medicare beneficiaries were aligned with ACOs in the Shared Savings Program. We now have evidence from the CMS Actuary, from MedPAC, and from Harvard researchers, and the findings among all three are consistent: one, ACOs are saving money for Medicare; two, the savings grow over time, the longer an ACO is in the program; and, three, physician-based ACOs are generating the strongest results. So, if you think of the three major ways that a beneficiary can receive care in Medicare--traditional fee-for-service, Medicare Advantage, or ACOs--ACOs are the lowest-cost provider of care in Medicare. And, perhaps most important, these savings are the result of Medicare beneficiaries actually receiving better care. Aledade is proud to be part of the success of the Shared Savings Program. Last year our ACOs saved Medicare over $40 million. Some of that success was from one of our ACOs in Pennsylvania outside of Philadelphia. We did this by helping independent physicians deliver more primary care, which reduced unnecessary hospitalizations, typically by 10 percent on average, and shortened post-acute-care stays by 22 percent on average. And like the rest of the program, our results improve the longer our practices work with us. I will give you a very simple example of one of our strategies. We provide our practices with real-time notifications when their patients are discharged from the hospital. This is information that the typical small independent primary care physician would not receive if they were not participating in an ACO and receiving the help of an organization like ours. These practices proactively reach out to the discharged patient and manage that transition to the home. Our physicians ensure that patients comply with follow-up care protocols and, importantly, make sure they understand their medications, why they are taking them, which ones they should be taking. These are simple strategies, but when applied consistently and reliably, they reduce unnecessary readmissions. Because of our success, Aledade is growing. Next year we will partner with over 2,000 doctors in 350 practices, FQHCs, and rural health centers, organized in 32 ACOs across 24 states. These physicians will be accountable for around 330,000 Medicare beneficiaries and an additional 120,000 commercially insured patients. More than half of our primary care providers are in small practices with fewer than ten clinicians. Congress has done much to support value-based care, but there is always more you can do. One, we need to reduce the complexity and uncertainty in the Shared Savings Program. It is hard for physicians to succeed in a complex environment, and some ACOs have been reluctant to move to two-sided risk in the ACO program because of the complicated benchmarking methodology. A simple solution would be for CMS to move all ACO benchmarking methodology toward the methodology used in Medicare Advantage. Those benchmarks are well understood and more predictable. Two, we can make risk taking less risky, especially for physician-based ACOs. ACOs that do not have access to capital, especially rural ACOs and physician-based ACOs, should not be required to take on potentially crippling levels of risk. The Medicare ACO Track 1+ model took a big step toward creating a two-sided model that is feasible for rural and physician-based ACOs. CMS has proposed to make this a permanent part of the program, and we support that. Finally, the benchmarking methodology has to be fairer for rural ACOs. Currently an ACO's own performance is included in its regional comparison group, so when that ACO drives down costs, it is making its regional target that much tougher. For most ACOs, it is not a big deal because they have a small percentage of beneficiaries in their region. But a rural ACO could have a majority of the beneficiaries in their county, and this is punishing them for their success. Thank you for the opportunity to share Aledade's experiences with you, and I look forward to the rest of the hearing. The Chairman. Thank you very much for your testimony. Reverend Snyder. STATEMENT OF REVEREND SALLY JO SNYDER, DIRECTOR OF ADVOCACY AND CONSUMER ENGAGEMENT, CONSUMER HEALTH COALITION, PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA Reverend Snyder. To Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, members of the Committee, fellow panelists and persons in attendance, thank you for the opportunity to provide testimony. Furthermore, I want to commend you for realizing the importance of including the perspective of the consumer voice in health care. It has been my experience that the most successful and the most effective policies and programs are initiated with having sought, heard from, listened, and responded to the voice of the consumer. My name is Reverend Sally Jo Snyder, and I am the director of Advocacy and Consumer Engagement at the Consumer Health Coalition. Our organization educates and activates consumers to be engaged and to take charge of their own health care. We educate our shared community about pertinent health policy issues, and we also enroll eligible Pennsylvanians in public health insurance programs. I travel across western Pennsylvania performing patient activation trainings. Recently, I conducted a focus group of 125 seniors in southwestern Pennsylvania. The questions asked were: ``Who helps you live well?'' and, ``Who is on your health care team?'' With intention, I met with both persons living in high economic areas and with individuals living in poverty and asked the same questions to both groups. Those with resources and financial health answered the questions very succinctly by responding, ``My doctor, my specialist, my therapist.'' When pressed, the answer remained the same. When persons living below or near the poverty line answered the questions, they talked to me for 25 minutes, and they mentioned the bus driver, members of their congregation, their pastor, the social worker, the clerk at the local 7/11, the pharmacist at the CVS, their friends and their family. There is a quote, ``We do not heal in isolation, we heal in community.'' The more we can broaden a person's base of connections and increase one's trust points, we can create better outcomes in physical health, mental health, and overall wellness. As clergy and advocacy director, I have earned my status as a trust point for the persons our agency serves and journeys. I am trusted because I know their names, I listen, I remember, I pay attention, I am present, and I follow through on what is shared. Providers and care staff must do those same things and become trust points as well. Being a trust point in the community, I know firsthand how important it is that people of Pennsylvania retain access to affordable health care coverage. The passage of the Affordable Care Act was a watershed moment in our communities, expanding the availability of private insurance coverage as well as Medicaid. Continued threats to these programs undermine community trust and risk the basic health and well-being of Pennsylvanians. This is particularly acute for people with pre- existing conditions, who now worry that the courts will take away the guarantee of health care coverage provided to them by consumer protections in the Affordable Care Act. In fact, it is the threat of persons with pre-existing conditions losing health care coverage that is the most pressing issue of those with whom I educate and advocate. We provide ``Activated Patient Trainings'' for seniors. These sessions walk persons through every step of the health care encounter from: finding a provider; communicating with a provider; what to bring to every appointment; questions to ask to understand your diagnosis, including my all-time favorite question in the guide, ``Can you explain this to me in a way that I can explain it to the members of my health care team?''; medications; one's care plan; and that most important question of why. Because these trainings are done in a group setting, persons from these learning communities offer their insights and provide support for their fellow students. In these sessions, additional trust points are formed. As health care advances, the experience and insight of the patient must be intentional, heard, listened to, and implemented. To fail to involve this perspective from the foundation to the completion is to have a health care system that functions only at half capacity. A person who fears being able to afford any health care because they lack insurance is not someone who can meaningfully participate in their care and focus on being the most valuable player of their health care team. Patients, providers, and payers are the central players in an effective health care system. All have roles to play, all have responsibilities to fulfill, and all have reasons to work together as a team to build and to bear a health care system that works for all of us. Thank you, and I welcome your questions. The Chairman. Thank you very much. As I was listening to you on the importance of those connections, I was reminded of a previous hearing we held on the impact of prolonged isolation and loneliness on health, and I was astonished to learn that-- among seniors, and I was astonished to learn that prolonged isolation and loneliness has the same kind of detrimental impact on health as smoking 15 cigarettes a day. I mean, that is just astonishing. So those connections you talked about are really important, and I think Dr. Howes, in talking about the success of his home health visits, is helping to make those connections as well. Dr. Howes, I want to turn to another area that you did not have time to get into in your oral statement, and that is the very impressive work that Martin's Point has done in the area of diabetes. Could you tell us what the results have been in terms of reducing emergency department visits, inpatient admissions, and cost reductions, and what you did to achieve those results? Dr. Howes. Thank you, Senator Collins. Let me start by just saying that we have had dramatic reductions in both admissions and in total cost of care. As you know, diabetic patients in our system on an annual basis cost about 75 percent more than the general population. And most of them, in fact, two-thirds of them have a second chronic illness. Very seldom does diabetes travel alone as an illness. So you have a second chronic illness, which is very important, and we have very significantly reduced admissions and emergency room visits for this population. The tool set that we have used is, first of all, to learn about this best, we decided to initiate a special needs plan, a Medicare special needs plan. So we have a diabetes special needs plan. It starts with an analytic infrastructure so that we are able to identify who has diabetes and how do we reach out to them. And we reach out to them initially with relatively simple means, such as mailings and the like, but then call them and urge them to come in. Sometimes we will do that using our own staff. This summer and last summer, we had the pleasure of having interns from local colleges do that, which was really a thrill for them. They were making a real difference for these people and really a positive for the member that was called. We really focus on meeting these people where they are because not everyone is ready to deal with their diabetes, and we start with a social work conversation or a nurse conversation, which is a motivational interview. What makes it worth you changing the way you are living and improving your diabetes, that when we give you medicine, you will take it; when we ask you to change your diet, you will do it? We have a multidisciplinary team that lives under that, that works with them and manages medications, diet, and activities. That consists of a physician, a nurse, pharmacist, social worker, dietician. So all of that stuff comes together. We do meticulous tracking and followup of these people, and where they drop out, we get them back in so that we see them multiple times in the course of a year. And we measure our performance quite carefully and actually feed that performance back to the team. We reward the team, and the team is rewarded financially, but what I am really struck by is that is much less important to the team that is caring for them than the pride they get in seeing real improvement in these patients. And in the medical field, to an amazing degree, what motivates people is the sense they have done a good job and made a difference in someone's life. And so as this data comes back and they see improvement, it is very self-reinforcing. So that is really the model that we use for the care of these people. We have many people who are not in our diabetic special needs program, but we extend as much of the same techniques to the community members and non-special needs plan members as we can. The Chairman. When you consider that the care of people with diabetes consumes one out of three Medicare dollars, what you are doing is really important in terms of helping to sustain the Medicare program as well as obviously making such an improvement in the lives of these individuals. Dr. Howes. The great pleasure for our people, I will tell you, is improving the lives of the people they serve. The Chairman. Exactly. Mr. Cavanaugh, I referred earlier to an Institute of Medicine report that said that the spending in our country on health care, the large percentage, as much as 30 percent, is not useful. And this report found that $55 billion of the total resulted from missed prevention opportunities or opportunities for preventive care that could have avoided more expensive services in the future. In your testimony, your written testimony, you specifically mentioned that ACOs are unable to waive co-pays for high-value primary care services and that ACOs are unable to include Medicare beneficiaries in any financial benefit from the cost savings. Could you elaborate on that and give us some recommendations in that area? Mr. Cavanaugh. Sure. A couple things. One, you are absolutely right and the IOM, of course, is right about prevention, and the core of the Aledade model starts with the annual wellness visit. Our primary care physicians reach out to high-risk patients and get them into the office so they can identify those preventive services that they have not received and do that consistently. Two, you specifically asked what more could we do to motivate patients on the benefit side. There are some proposals and possibilities to help waive co-payments or encourage certain services. There is much more that could be done. For example, one of the big strategies all of us use is chronic care management, which I think has benefited our patients tremendously. But this is not a service that the beneficiaries see their physician providing, and then they are surprised when they get billed for the co-payment. Transitional care management is the same thing. It is an essential form of care that our physicians provide, and then oftentimes the beneficiary is surprised with a co-payment. You mentioned the problem around colonoscopies. These are services that are of high value in which the notion of creating a disincentive through co-payment or deductible does not make any sense. I would suggest one way to get out of this bind--all these co-payments and payment rules were created in a fee-for-service environment where we were worried more about overutilization than underutilization. As ACOs move to two-sided risk where they are truly accountable for the total budget, you do not need to worry about those things as much. If we can encourage policies that move the ACO program to two-sided risk, both CMS and Congress can start looking at these issues and relaxing some of these rules and giving us more flexibility. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. Thanks very much, Madam Chair, and I was thinking earlier, my staff knows that I have become a little obsessive about these numbers of people that got health care by county in my state. But Senator Nelson was here earlier, and I think when people think of states like Florida and Pennsylvania and Maine, too, people focus on the high percentage of seniors. In our state, depending on the number you look at or the year, the number of people over age 65 approaches 2 million people. And those numbers are big, and the number of people that got health care in our state through the ACA was about 1.1 million people. Just imagine that. More than 60 percent got their health care only because we had Medicaid expansion. But the number that I think a lot of Americans have not thought about until recently is the number of people with pre-existing conditions. Nationally, it is about 130 million. In Pennsylvania, the latest estimate is 5.3 million people. In a state that has a little less than 13 million people, 5.3 million. So I will start with that number. Reverend Snyder, you have seen not just a big number; you have seen individuals, human beings that have health care and have those protections now and will not have it if the administration's point of view prevails in this litigation. And all the administration has to do is withdraw the argument, just say we are going to make every effort, no matter what, to give people those protections. So it is pretty clear that we have to make a choice as to whether or not we are going to protect--or I should say maintain the protections for pre-existing conditions. So I ask you about that in the context of, from your experience dealing with real people, not dealing with numbers in Washington debates, but with those real people, what was their life like before, meaning those with pre-existing conditions, and what is their life like now after having the protections? Reverend Snyder. Thank you. I think the deal was in our experience with them, it was kind of a course, and before getting health care coverage, they were afraid. But prior to getting the Affordable Care Act coverage, they would not go to the health care provider because they were afraid. They were afraid to go. They were not feeling well. They were afraid, and I think kind of having a sense of what they had and knowing I am going to go, they are going to diagnose me, this is going to be a label that is going to be attached with me, and then am I going to be able to get health care coverage, and the health care coverage I currently have, if I have it, am I even going to be able to afford it. So there was a lot of fear. Then the Affordable Care Act comes, and they can get coverage, and it was a big exhale. It was literally like a weight off their shoulders. They definitely exhaled. It was a relief, and they were then going to get care, going to the physician, getting the care they needed, getting on a course of treatment plan, and all going along quite well. And now here they are and there is once again fear. If this is taken away, now what? And that fear is mixed very understandably with anger, and I get that. It is kind of the double ouch: ``I did not have it. Now I got it. I was on a course of treatment plan, and now you are going to take that away from me? Seriously.'' And there is understandable anger and fear, and that is kind of a nasty combination, but it is a very real combination. It is something that the folks now that we are talking with and meeting with, this is issue No. 1, that this needs to be continued and needs to be maintained. Senator Casey. As you were talking about that, referencing that weight lifted off the shoulder, at the other end of the state, in southeastern Pennsylvania, we had a meeting a couple weeks ago now where a young woman was speaking about her pre- existing conditions. That is exactly what she said, the language that you just used. She said, after she had all kinds of bouts with cancer at a very young age and all kinds of surgery and ups and down, she literally said exactly what you just said: ``A weight lifted off my shoulder.'' That is what this means. I know we are running low on time. I will just try to get one more question in. The Money Follows the Person program helps folks who might be a senior or have a disability stay in their community. As of 2016, the program has transitioned over 75,000 people with disabilities and chronic conditions out of institutions. By the end of 2018, this will include 3,500 Pennsylvanians. Can you share why Money Follows the Person is important to older adults and people with disabilities in your experience? Reverend Snyder. Sure, absolutely, and starting--you had referenced in your introduction my Mom, and talking from that perspective, my mother was one--and it is kind of the norm in southwestern Pennsylvania. She literally was born in the house where she lived all of her 84 years, literally born, married my Dad, raised her five kids in that house, and rocked numerous grandchildren and neighbors' kids and cousins in her mother's rocking chair. And I share that very personal point of this because home matters. People want to stay in their homes. I could walk down 2nd Street or Avenue or whatever it is in Washington, DC, and ask the first ten people I pass, ``Do you want to live in your home or an institution?'' And we know what the answer is. ``I want to live in my home.'' Why? It is familiar. It is where they are comfortable. I firmly believe and have evidence that people live longer and recover stronger when they are at their homes. This is absolutely critical for folks to be able to remain in their homes surrounded by family, what they know, what is familiar, surrounded by their own trust points that are very intimate. People know where they live. Meals on Wheels knows this is who I deliver the food to, right? Congregations and support networks know this is where I find this person is absolutely critical for seniors as well as for persons with disabilities. Senator Casey. Thank you, Reverend. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator. Senator Cortez Masto? Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Thank you all for being here today. You know, I am from Nevada. In Reno, Nevada, we have Renown Health ACO, and it has been in existence since 2014, serving over 18,000 beneficiaries, and there is no doubt it has progressively improved the quality scores and work flows by integrating care that we have all talked about, that you have talked about today. And, in fact, in 2017, Renown also generated $2.6 million in savings. However, talking with them--and I do on a regular basis-- one of the things that they share with me--and I am curious. I am going to open it up to the panel for what you think. What they said to me is some of the difficulties they have are data sharing at the point of care, and it has been a challenge for them. In Renown, the network includes both rural and urban facilities as well as providers that practice across state lines. And I understand that standardizing the electronic health records within the ACO can be challenging. But I hear from Renown that the full data integration would allow accurate and timely data at the point of care and empower the physicians to make the most informed decisions and eliminate duplicate or unnecessary orders. So I guess my question for you is: What can the Federal Government do to help data integration or interoperability for ACOs? Is that something that you see as well or an issue or difficulty or challenge that you are dealing with as well? And maybe, Dr. Howes, I can start with you. Dr. Howes. Yes, first of all, the lack of data interoperability and data flow between care entities is a real issue, and we are blessed in Maine that we have a health information exchange, which I am not sure is the optimal solution, but it does allow us to get good data on all patient encounters over a period of time. But the need to get data interoperability--and I think this is an opportunity for Congress to push data interoperability between electronic health records and to build really good data warehouses, so that we can understand all of the care that is being delivered in all the locations in which it is being delivered, and intervene in an intelligent way in order to improve the health and avert costs for our patients and members. Very important issue as the health care system evolves forward from really what was an analog system to a digital system and something that has not been sorted out well. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Mr. Cavanaugh, do you have something to add? Mr. Cavanaugh. First of all, you have identified a really complex but important issue, and we fully agree. The better interchange of clinical data would be critical. We spend a lot of money--because all of our physicians have very different EHRs, we spend a lot of Aledade's money just integrating with very different EHRs. But I will tell you one simple issue that Congress could help with. As I mentioned in my testimony, one of our basic interventions is to tell our physicians when their patient has been discharged from the hospital. The way we do that is we tap into the health information exchange that Dr. Howes referred to. Some states do not have those exchanges. When that happens, we go around to the local hospitals, and we say--you know, at our expense we tap into their systems and just say, ``We just want to know when our doctors' patients are discharged.'' And most hospitals are fine with that. They realize it is good for the patient. We do run into instances where the hospital says, ``No, we will not share that data for competitive reasons.'' Either we are starting our own ACO and we want your doctor to come to our ACO, or whatever reason. And they are very up front that it is for competitive reasons. But, you know, if you think of it from the beneficiary perspective, they do not care what corporate entity is benefiting from their data. They want their primary care doctor to know that they have been discharged. And often when our doctor calls the patient, they are startled: ``How did you know?'' But pleasantly startled. They are glad to hear from their primary care. So I think Congress and CMS should not allow hospitals to block this. You know, at our expense we are willing to go tap in and just ask, ``Tell us when the patient is discharged.'' And some hospitals are resistant to that. Not all. Some are more than happy to share the data. But that is something policymakers could help us with. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Mr. Micklos? Mr. Micklos. Yes, thank you, Senator, and I would echo what both panelists have already responded. I will add, too, that there continues to just be positive movement in the ability for patients to be able to kind of capture their own information and share it directly, too. And there is a lot of work in the technology arena there that supports that activity. And so that is not going to be a foolproof solution, but to the extent there have been barriers between proprietary medical--EHR products, the ability to have the beneficiary be the quarterback, as it were, of their information, being able to share that is one solution. In addition to the clinical data sharing, I think, though, that the opportunities that are out there for ACOs both in the public sphere but also in the commercial sphere is the ability--the greater sharing of claims data and better understanding from an actuarial standpoint where you can manage it. So a provider-led ACO, you see quite a lot of investment now in new experience and expertise with regard to actuarial analysis, and sometimes the data that comes from Medicare is not as complete or as timely as you would like to see. And to Mr. Cavanaugh's point, you know, you often see in commercial arrangements where there are competitive reasons, and I think we are seeing increasing--and the task force is actually involved in activities where we are trying to further the dialog so that parties who sit across the table from each other can understand better about how they want to use each other's information to move it forward. So the data sharing is both clinical and also claims data. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. And I know my time is running out. I do not know, Reverend, if you had anything to add. Reverend Snyder. Sure, I did. And I appreciate that. I think letting the primary care physician know when someone is being discharged from the hospital is absolutely from the consumer perspective coin of the realm movement, right. It really is, because as you have been in this strange land and you have discharged, now it is trying to get everything in order, and, again, what a moment to have the primary care know and contact you. It is incredible that they know, and then you can help them to get on to this next course of treatment, right? And with the digital records, with our folks, again and with all of this I would be remiss, representing a consumer voice here, if I did not say from the very get-go involve the voice of the consumer. Tell us what it is. Explain it. Listen to their feedback. Implement that feedback to build this much better system. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. The Chairman. Senator Gillibrand. Senator Gillibrand. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. Thank you, Mr. Ranking Member. A common theme that we have heard today from your testimony is the importance of preventive care. Studies have repeatedly shown that people who are uninsured are less likely than those with insurance to receive preventive care for major health conditions and chronic disease. Given that on average an American with multiple chronic conditions will end up spending up to 14 times more on health care services than someone without chronic conditions, it is imperative that these Americans continue to have access to quality, affordable care. In New York, I am particularly concerned about the more than 1.9 million older adults between the ages of 55 and 64 who have a chronic or pre-existing condition and rely on existing protections in order to access basic health care. Reverend Snyder, in your testimony you mentioned the uncertainty and worry around the corner of the Texas v. United States case that could potentially overturn protections for people with pre-existing conditions and how many of the individuals you work with will have one of these health concerns and fear that they will be unable to access basic quality care. Can you speak to some of the health and financial challenges that these individuals could face if protections for pre-existing conditions or chronic conditions are lost? Reverend Snyder. Sure. Thank you, Senator. First of all, if this is taken away and all the buzz around it, they are automatically going to stop, and they are not going to go. They are not going to get treatment for diabetes. They are not going to get treatment for a chronic health condition. Even worse than that, if it is a cancer diagnosis or they are a cancer survivor, they are not going back because they are scared. And that is problematic, and it impacts not only them but their base and their family on that whole line. Some of them definitely--and I do not think--well, I will probably say in Pittsburgh, blue-collar Pittsburgh, right? And these are very proud folks, right? And they are not going to be ones who are going to go to a hospital, even knowing they do not have insurance, and, quote-unquote, put that burden on a hospital system. They are not going to do that. They are simply not going to go. And it is horrific. It really is. And, again, I have to emphasize the fact that they had it and were on the-- it was an exhale. Kind of they literally got that burden off their shoulders. They kind of stood a little taller and lived a little fuller, which we all should be expected to, and they are simply now dealing with, ``I had it and now you are taking it away,'' and there is anger and shock with that, and it is the emotional toll of that as well as the physical toll of that. Yes, it is a significant burden that could happen. Senator Gillibrand. Dr. Howes, in your testimony you mentioned that Martin's Point Health Care's quality care practices include improving health outcomes through managing chronic conditions, preventive care, and early detection of common cancers. How has access to quality and affordable health care for these patients helped control health care costs? Dr. Howes. Both on the acute side and on the chronic side, having good access to primary care is absolutely critical. Small conditions which can become severe quickly are dealt with early, and on the chronic disease side, there are the opportunities to carefully manage people's medications and all of the other services that they need in order to do what we call advance preventive care, that is, when people have chronic illness, they are at risk, getting in to see the clinician, getting in to see the nurse practitioner who is managing their chronic illness makes an enormous difference in the total cost of care and, consequently, in their access. Senator Gillibrand. Right. Dr. Howes. And so I would tell you, that had I written the high-deductible health plan law, I would have made primary care something that could be purchased out of the health savings account because I think we need to lower those barriers. I think it has long-term benefits. I think the same should probably be true in the ACA exchange plans. And I know that we have a couple of plans in your state--Independent Health, led by Dr. Mike Cropp and CDPHP led by Dr. John Bennett--have really worked to reduce barriers to primary care and improve chronic disease care in that way. And it is a win for everybody. Senator Gillibrand. We talked a lot about innovation, and so for Mr. Cavanaugh and Mr. Micklos, given your work with providers and experiences at HHS, could you share with us the importance of patient involvement and consumer education to the success of innovative health care models? Mr. Cavanaugh. Certainly. When I was at CMS and we were initially kicking off the whole ACO program, there was a lot of speculation: Well, would ACOs want sick patients or would they want well patients? You know, which way would they select? Now that I am in the ACO business, what I learned is what ACOs want are engaged patients. They do not care if you are sick--the doctor does not care if you are sick or healthy, but if you are engaged, it makes the physician's job so much easier. So we are constantly looking for ways to engage the patient, working with community organizations, religious organizations, anything that motivates the patient, trying to address issues beyond the medical issues that are really important to the patient, because if they see that their physician practice cares about their life more broadly, they are more likely to be engaged. Mr. Micklos. I agree with that. I would just add to that that as you build a value-based care model, if you cannot engage the patient, it is not worth the investment, right? So in our organization, we do talk about patient activation and how best to reach patients. I think Dr. Howes said earlier in his testimony it is critical that you meet patients where they are and then you engage with them appropriately and move them forward. I think some of the earlier conversations also talked about in the Medicare population, in particular some of the barriers that still continue to exist from a fee-for-service architecture, where maybe there are not certain services that can be provided in the home, but that patient really needs to be in their home, would benefit from being in their home. So looking at breaking down some of those barriers I think still remains to be an option. And then to the extent that we can continue to incentivize proper support of preventive medicine, it is very important. And there is increasing flexibility, so we are encouraged there. But more is necessary. We have had members who have contracted with ride-sharing services now that have been able to get people to their appointments, and there is a lot of investment now in public housing and in addressing food deserts. There have been fraud and abuse laws that have stood in the way of that in the past, and there are still some concerns there, but at least it is going in the right direction. We should encourage this care to be kind of coordinated and integrated across systems and not have some of those last boundaries still stand in the way. Senator Gillibrand. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Jones? Senator Jones. Thank you, Chairman Collins, and thank you all for being here on this really interesting and important topic, especially for states like Alabama that are poor and rural and unhealthy, to be honest with you. I want to focus on a couple of things. One, we have talked about technology, and I think from my perspective telehealth is going to be--we are going to have an increasing role in the coming years. The State of Alabama is trying to put a telehealth clinic in every county health department. The University of Alabama in Birmingham, one of the really world- class medical facilities, has got a program that they are working on. I would like to just hear from maybe each of you what experience you have had with that, and are there specific models that our states and our communities need to be looking at for telehealth? We will just start down the row, I guess, if anybody wants to chime in on that. I think it is important. Dr. Howes. Martin's Point does not have any telehealth capabilities now, but has been looking at it carefully. And there is an enormous benefit in a rural state like Maine where over 50 percent of our population is rural in telehealth. Actually, in parentheses, I started practicing on the island of Deer Isle in 1979, and there had been a telehealth capability out there at that point, which was shut down when we opened our practice. But it really is incredibly valuable for a lot of different populations. On the mental health side, it can be accomplished relatively easy and at low cost. Other specialties like dermatology, et cetera, are very easy to build telehealth capabilities, and it increases access, it can reduce cost, and it can really benefit the population that we serve. Our larger issues with putting it in place have been how do we fit it into the larger spectrum of other services that are offered both locally and regionally in a way that optimally benefits the patient and does it at high quality. Senator Jones. All right. Thank you. Yes, sir? Mr. Micklos. It is a great question, Senator. I think that there are so many opportunities in this space. I think we have historically thought about it as telehealth. I think there is really just now this broader umbrella of virtual care, and whether it is--it helps with access, that is obviously a critical point, but also for reaching patients where they are. We are talking about from the elderly all the way down to, you know, millennials who want to kind of engage in a different way. I think there is some really interesting work that the military has done. I heard a presentation just last week about, you know, what the military has done in light of the fact that they have been in theater for 17 years, and there are advancements in how they use it. It also is a significant way to address the physician shortages, especially in neurology and other areas where there really are some great opportunities to make sure that the consults are ready. And it is a timeliness issue as well. If someone needs that consultation immediately, that is really the way many patients will be able to obtain it. Senator Jones. Thank you. Mr. Cavanaugh? Mr. Cavanaugh. A lot of our ACOs serve rural areas and are located in rural areas. We are starting an ACO in your state next year, interestingly. Senator Jones. Good. Mr. Cavanaugh. Not many of them participate actively in telehealth, and when you talk to them to find out why, it is because of all the restrictions around the current way it is structured in the Medicare benefit, that it just does not fit the way they practice and it does not fit the way their beneficiaries live. But as Mr. Micklos said, the technology is evolving and our physicians are very excited about it. Going back to my answer to an earlier question, I think as we move ACOs to being more and more accountable for the total cost of care, all these Medicare regulations that were built around preventing overutilization of services hopefully will fall by the wayside, and we can get more--I think it would work well for many of the beneficiaries that our ACOs treat. I think our doctors would love it. It is just that the way it is currently constructed, it is problematic. Senator Jones. Yes, sir. Thank you. Reverend Snyder? Reverend Snyder. Thank you for the question, Senator, and I think with this as well is from the get-go, right out of the gate, involve the consumer, the patient, seek their perspective, how it works, because I think the piece of this is going to be that they understand it, No. 1, how it works, and are going to be concerned about the personal aspect of this. Is that going to be part of it? All the more reason when that occurs to make sure the trust point, the person, you know, with them when they are having that interaction with their provider and setting that up is someone that they absolutely trust. And, again, involve them from the beginning. Share with them, get their feedback in this. Senator Jones. My time is just about up, but could you, Reverend Snyder--following up on Senator Gillibrand's question, what can we do as Members of Congress to try to help with what I call ``health literacy,'' getting patients to be engaged as you all talked about and understanding? What is it that we might do from the Congress that might help with that program? Reverend Snyder. I think the point of that is realizing that we are all involved in this. You can look at it from the economics, and I get that perspective, but as well, I mean, we are all going to be health care consumers and interact with that. And I think becoming available and really listening to these stories of these folks, involving them in this, yes, it is economic, but ultimately it is a person, and it is who they are, and to provide--to gather those stories and listen to them around that piece and be very accessible to hearing those stories and involving them in this piece. As far as health literacy, again, it really is that, and programs to provide even in your offices, right? And interact with your local community organizations that do that. Honestly, to get people into programs in health literacy as respected trust points and the connection people have with the offices, more than maybe going to get a fishing license or a hunting license, which that is important, too, but as well to have that being a connect point with that office into the broader community I think would be a really good piece as well. Senator Jones. Great. Well, thank you. Thank you all very much. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator. We are going to do a very brief second round of questions. There are so many issues that have been raised that deserve a little more attention. Mr. Cavanaugh, I noticed in your testimony that you said you had been able to achieve a 22 percent average decrease in skilled nursing facility stays. That is astonishing for two reasons: one, the difference in cost between home health care and a skilled nursing facility; but, second, as Reverend Snyder said, all of us or virtually all of us would so much rather be able to stay in our own homes. So how did you do it? Mr. Cavanaugh. Thank you for the question. I should preface my answer by saying we think we can do a lot more. What we have done so far has been fairly basic. One is having our physicians in our ACOs go out and talk to the local skilled nursing facilities and explain we are now in an ACO, we are now watching, we now care that the right patients come to you, that they stay for the right duration, that they get the right therapies while they are there. There is value in just having that conversation and letting the skilled nursing facility know that someone now is watching and cares, which has not been true in the past. In some of our markets, we have created post-acute liaisons, so there is someone in the ACO designated to check in and say, ``I see Ms. Smith is still there. What is the plan? When is she getting home? Can we help you plan the discharge so that when she goes home, the services she needs to go home are ready?'' So it is almost like augmenting the discharge process for the skilled nursing facility. There are a series of these things that are really--they are sort of resource-intensive, and that is why--but I think we have just scratched the surface of this. When I was at CMS and we looked at the variation in spending in Medicare across the country, almost all of it is explained by post-acute-care utilization, how expensive the site of care is. There are just different cultures in different regions, so trying to break out of that and stay focused on the actual needs of the beneficiary. We have done some basic things and had really remarkable results, but we think there is a lot more potential there. The Chairman. That is very encouraging. Dr. Howes? Dr. Howes. We have made some really substantial reductions as well, and one of the very interesting facts that we have learned is that, for example, post-joint replacement, our orthopedists in Maine feel that people do better when they go home than when they go to a skilled nursing facility if they have an adequate rehabilitation plan and they follow it. Their perspective is that their recovery is quicker and more complete. And so that has served as a nice motivator for our teams to get people home as quickly as possible, as much of the time as possible. The Chairman. That is absolutely fascinating. I just think this is very exciting. The final question I want to ask involves the treatment of and the identification of depression and other mental illnesses. And, Dr. Howes, you and I started to have a brief conversation about that. I bring it up because this is the 10- year anniversary of the passage of the Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity Act that was intended to make sure that insurance treated the limits on mental illnesses the same as physical illnesses. And there is a 2016 study that found that a depressed mood, which included symptoms such as anxiety and fatigue, was as strong a predictor of heart disease as well-known risk factors like high cholesterol and obesity. So, Dr. Howes, what are you doing at Martin's Point to better integrate screening for mental health and substance abuse disorders? Dr. Howes. Well, in our population we do the same thing that Mr. Cavanaugh's people do, which is an annual wellness visit, which includes a mental health screen. The other piece of work that we are doing, which is our home care program adapted from Health Quality Partners in Doylestown, Pennsylvania, is that when our nurses take on a sick, chronically ill patient, they screen very thoroughly for depressive illness and substance abuse, which is both associated with and exacerbates mental illness. And we are finding a fair amount of treatment need there. I would also tell you that we find opioid addiction in the elder community is higher than we would like it to be. We are dealing with that, and we actually have now got a zero co-pay for people in our health plans to access opioid treatment for the very reason that it all ties together. Mental illness, substance abuse, and depressive illness are really connected. The Chairman. Thank you. That is very helpful. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. Madam Chair, thank you for the second round. I will get to two questions. Mr. Cavanaugh, I will start with you. You get extra credit because you went to Penn, but that is not why I am asking you the question. [Laughter.] Senator Casey. I want to take you far away from a big city like Philadelphia into rural communities. As you know from your work, you have got a proven track record working in those parts of states like mine. I represent a state that has 48 out of 67 counties are considered rural. That means we have a larger rural population than any other state except maybe three or four, over 3 million people living there. So access to health care in rural areas is a big issue in our state. People who worry about getting food on the table or figuring out a way to get to their doctors' appointments is a bigger deal when you have great distances to travel, as you know. We know that in our state and in a lot of states the Area Agencies on Aging are critically important. So I guess in light of your experience with these rural communities and access to care, can you explain the importance of community partners in addressing the social needs of a rural patient? Mr. Cavanaugh. Those community partners are absolutely essential, and even more so for a model like ours. Our model is based on the physician practice, and in a rural area, the physician practice is bare bones. It is maybe one or two physicians, maybe one or two staff. So the notion that they are going to personally address the non-medical needs of their patients is just not viable. They need to tap into community resources in a big way. And they do not have the resources of a health plan. So a lot of what we do is try to help them with backup resources, but also help them map out what are the community resources in your community. And the AAA agencies are often the starting point. I would say one of the hard lessons we have learned both in rural and non-rural communities is a Meals on Wheels program in one community might be the best provider of food services, and then you go one community over, and it is a weaker agency. So part of it is learning not just what the resources are, but which ones are really worth working with that are really going to deliver, are going to be customer friendly. And, unfortunately, you have to relearn that in every community you work in. We try to stay close with our doctors. They often know this. But often if it is their first time in an ACO, they are doing these sort of functions for the first time, so they are learning. So I could not agree with you more that tapping into community resources is essential. The aging agencies often are one of the best--not always but often one of the best. So it is a big part of our model. Senator Casey. Thank you. Reverend Snyder, I will go back to you as well for another kind of real-life issue, which is the work that navigators do. It seems like if you had a Ph.D. in health care, you would still need a navigator on some days. But we are grateful for the work that gets done. The navigator grants are critically important. But, unfortunately, the administration has chosen to reduce funding for navigators from $62.9 million in 2016 to only $10 million in 2018. So over the course of two years, cutting it by roughly $53 million. I do not know who the hell thought of that idea. I do not know how the United States of America is better off by taking $53 million from navigators. But some bright star, I guess, in the administration thought that was a good idea. It is a dumb idea, a really stupid idea. But I wanted to ask you, what is the value of those navigators and the in-person assistance that they bring? Reverend Snyder. Thank you, and I would resonate with not the greatest idea, what they are planning to do. When open enrollment started back in 2013, on October 1, we literally had folks show up at our office asking this question: ``OK. I am here for my free health care.'' And you are, like, ``Well, time out.'' And part of that is on us about educating what the Affordable Care Act was. And as that caught its stride, I mean, we have folks coming here and we are a trust point, right? It is confusing. They are intimidated. They are not sure, and to have someone that is with them person to person helping them to navigate it, answering their questions, giving them that comfort, and then the all important followup is absolutely golden. That has been one of the pieces of the Affordable Care Act along with, as we have discussed already, you know, the covering of pre-existing conditions, having the navigators has been absolutely beneficial because folks come in, they are confused, they are intimidated. And we had folks walking in having no idea what a deductible was. So it is meeting them, that person-to-person, that trust point, and helping them to navigate through the system, it was valuable and I think made the Affordable Care Act be the success it has been in a lot of ways. Senator Casey. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Cortez Masto? Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. And I want to follow up on the Chair's latest conversation with all of you on mental illness, but let us turn it to Alzheimer's and dementia. We have spent a number of hearings, thank you very much, trying to address and understand how those patients and their families dealing with Alzheimer's and dementia navigate the health care system. Could you talk to us about how you address and work with patients and their families who are navigating your health care system through an ACO that are dealing with either Alzheimer's or dementia? Maybe, I do not know, Dr. Cavanaugh, do you mind starting--or, excuse me, Mr. Cavanaugh, do you mind starting? Mr. Cavanaugh. You just made my Mom very happy. [Laughter.] Mr. Cavanaugh. Sure, it is one of the great challenges. I hate to keep harping on it, but it starts with the annual wellness visit and making sure you know that the patient has dementia and, you know, screening and just the awareness of the primary care practice and wrapping their arms around the patient. But typically then the practice needs to know who the caregiver is, so it is not just working with the patient, but understanding the patient's support system. And this is, frankly, where traditional American practices have not been well oriented to. But now that you have an ACO model where they see that, it is the type of medicine they want to practice, like this is something physicians want to get involved in, they just have never felt they had the time or that the business case warranted it. You see physicians recognizing the challenge and stepping up to it and saying, ``This is how I want to practice. I want to know what this patient is going home to.'' So a big part of this also is the care manager. Most of our practices, we have embedded care managers if the practice is big enough. It would be not just the physician dealing with the medical side but the care manager dealing with the family side and, again, linking into community resources. But we do not have any magical clinical programs that solve this problem, but getting the basics right at the outset like that is the important first step. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Reverend? Reverend Snyder. And I really want to play off of the whole idea of the caregiver in this piece, right? And a lot of times, I mean, the person living with Alzheimer's and dementia, they are scared. They are scared about what they have already lost and what they are going to lose. And the most important thing I think they are scared of is the loss of independence, right? So one of the things we encourage with the caregiver is a lot of times they will walk in, and a good provider is going to talk directly to the patient, as they should. It is always defend the person's dignity. And they might ask, ``How is it going?'' And the person might say, ``Oh, I am fine. It is well. Everything is good,'' when the caregiver knows that there have been instances and issues, and maybe there has been falls and what have you. And one of the neat things we recommend is for the caregiver then, before the visit, to either email or call and talk to the provider and share with them, ``Hey, look, this has been happening. You might want to address this in the visit,'' so you are not embarrassing the person who has dementia or Alzheimer's in the visit, saying, ``No, that is not true. Things have not been well.'' It is just another way of defending dignity and involving, again, the caregiver and that whole team--I cannot stress that enough as well--in this whole journey through Alzheimer's and dementia. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Yes, Mr. Micklos? Mr. Micklos. I will just add to that that I think the increasing focus on the ability to provide home care services is also very important in that realm. It is really important to be able to meet that patient where they are, and as we talked about, even in a demented state, it is still a better outcome for them to be at home and receiving home care. And so I think we need a greater opportunity to really kind of focus on that. I think in the Medicare Advantage space and watching the policies around supplemental benefits will also be interesting to watch. There will be opportunities beyond the caregivers, but also potentially for companionship and other opportunities that I know at least from a social work perspective are really important for that patient population. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Dr. Howes? Dr. Howes. We really are beginning now to scan our claims data base to us who is showing various signs of dementia to try to begin to provide for them services like referrals to dementia daycare, to provide respite for families. In our area we have a wonderful organization called the Southern Maine Area Agency on Aging which has put together a great daycare facility. But, in addition, we are beginning to figure out what are the social supports that these individuals and their families need. The clinical interventions, while they are making some difference, are not really very effective at this point, and this is really about supporting the patient and supporting the family through this terrible illness and loss. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Thank you so much. I appreciate the hearing today. Thank you all for being here. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you. I want to thank all of our witnesses for your compelling testimony today. It is extremely helpful to our Committee as we contribute ideas for moderating health care costs while actually improving the quality of patient satisfaction and outcomes, and the two are not incompatible goals at all, as your experiences clearly demonstrate. In fact, oftentimes the lower-cost interventions, the emphasis on prevention, can prevent more serious illnesses from developing or worsening and increase patient satisfaction and outcomes. I appreciate your sharing your very specific ideas with us. That is very helpful as well. I also want to thank our staff on both sides of the aisle for working hard on this hearing, which, as I said, I think contributes to the general debate. We have had a lot of focus on the cost of health insurance, which clearly is vital, but we need to focus more on health care costs, which obviously has a direct impact on the cost of health insurance. And I am also concerned about the sustainability of our entitlement programs, and this debate is very important for that as well. Senator Casey, do you have any closing comment? Senator Casey. Just briefly, Madam Chair. Thank you for having this hearing on such an important set of issues. I also want to thank our witnesses for their testimony, particularly Reverend Snyder, not only because she is from Pennsylvania but that helped, and I am grateful. And I am really grateful for all of our witnesses who are here today. Congress, when we passed the Affordable Care Act, took strides to expand coverage and to help make coverage more affordable and transform the health care delivery system. I and I know others will continue to work to keep the promise that our Government made to 130 million Americans and 5.3 million Pennsylvanians with pre-existing conditions. I will also continue to work with Democrats and Republicans to improve the patient and provider experience. We have got a lot of work to do, but I look forward to working with my colleagues in both parties to improve our health care system. Chairman Collins, thank you very much. The Chairman. Thank you. Committee members will have until Friday, October 12th, to submit questions for the record. If we do receive some, we will be passing them along to you. Again, my thanks to our outstanding witnesses today, to Ranking Member Casey, and to all the Committee members who participated in today's hearing. Given all else that is going on, I was really delighted that so many members were able to come by for parts of the hearing, and I think that shows their interest in this topic. This concludes the hearing. My thanks. [Whereupon, at 11:02 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Additional Statements for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]