Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- IMPROVING THE VISITOR EXPERIENCE AT NATIONAL PARKS [House Hearing, 115 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] IMPROVING THE VISITOR EXPERIENCE AT NATIONAL PARKS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE INTERIOR, ENERGY, AND ENVIRONMENT OF THE COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ APRIL 5, 2017 __________ Serial No. 115-7 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.fdsys.gov http://www.house.gov/reform ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 25-748 PDF WASHINGTON : 2017 ----------------------------------------------------------------------- For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512-1800; DC area (202) 512-1800 Fax: (202) 512-2104 Mail: Stop IDCC, Washington, DC 20402-0001 Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Jason Chaffetz, Utah, Chairman John J. Duncan, Jr., Tennessee Elijah E. Cummings, Maryland, Darrell E. Issa, California Ranking Minority Member Jim Jordan, Ohio Carolyn B. Maloney, New York Mark Sanford, South Carolina Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of Justin Amash, Michigan Columbia Paul A. Gosar, Arizona Wm. Lacy Clay, Missouri Scott DesJarlais, Tennessee Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts Trey Gowdy, South Carolina Jim Cooper, Tennessee Blake Farenthold, Texas Gerald E. Connolly, Virginia Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Robin L. Kelly, Illinois Thomas Massie, Kentucky Brenda L. Lawrence, Michigan Mark Meadows, North Carolina Bonnie Watson Coleman, New Jersey Ron DeSantis, Florida Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Dennis A. Ross, Florida Val Butler Demings, Florida Mark Walker, North Carolina Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois Rod Blum, Iowa Jamie Raskin, Maryland Jody B. Hice, Georgia Peter Welch, Vermont Steve Russell, Oklahoma Matt Cartwright, Pennsylvania Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Mark DeSaulnier, California Will Hurd, Texas John Sarbanes, Maryland Gary J. Palmer, Alabama James Comer, Kentucky Paul Mitchell, Michigan Jonathan Skladany, Staff Director Rebecca Edgar, Deputy Staff Director William McKenna, General Counsel Chris Esparza, Counsel Kiley Bidelman, Clerk David Rapallo, Minority Staff Director ------ Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy and Environment Blake Farenthold, Texas, Chairman Paul A. Gosar, Arizona, Vice Chair Stacey E. Plaskett, Virgin Islands Dennis Ross, Florida Jamie Raskin, Maryland Gary J. Palmer, Alabama (Vacancy) James Comer, Kentucky (Vacancy) C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on April 5, 2017.................................... 1 WITNESSES Mr. Glenn Casamassa, Associate Deputy Chief, National Forest System, U.S. Forest Service, US. Department of Agriculture Oral Statement............................................... 4 Written Statement............................................ 7 Ms. Linda Lanterman, Director of the Division of State Parks, State of Kansas Oral Statement............................................... 12 Written Statement............................................ 14 Mr. Chris Edmonston, Vice President of Government Affairs, BoatU.S. Oral Statement............................................... 17 Written Statement............................................ 19 Mr. Rick Cables, Vice President of Natural Resources and Conservation, Vail Resorts Oral Statement............................................... 23 Written Statement............................................ 25 APPENDIX Opening Statement of Subcommittee Chairman Blake Farenthold...... 42 IMPROVING THE VISITOR EXPERIENCE AT NATIONAL PARKS ---------- Wednesday, April 5, 2017 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy and Environment Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 2:18 p.m., in Room 2247, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Blake Farenthold [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Farenthold, Ross, Palmer, Plaskett, and Raskin. Mr. Farenthold. The Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy, and the Environment will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. Good afternoon. Today, the Subcommittee on the Interior, Energy, and Environment will be examining the Concessions Program at the National Park Service, or NPS. Last year, the country celebrated the 100th anniversary of the NPS. Now that the festivities of that milestone are over, it's time to get back to work improving the Park Service. The NPS is the custodian of some of our greatest national treasures. To that end, we must make sure that it's performing well and living up to this responsibility. In July of 2015, shortly before the centennial celebrations, this subcommittee held a hearing that began the Oversight and Government Reform Committee's involvement in these issues. In her opening statement, my predecessor as chair, Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming, quoted Stephen Mather, the first director of the National Park Service. I believe the quotation is worthy of repeating today. He said: ``Scenery is a hollow enjoyment to the tourist who sets out in the morning after an indigestible breakfast and a fitful night's sleep on an impossible bed.'' This is a particularly astute observation. To be able to enjoy our Nation's stunningly beautiful parks, beaches, monuments, wildlife, and other features, the people need food, lodging, and other appropriate amenities. To this end, since the first national parks were created in the late 19th century, there has been a history of private companies working on these parks to provide services to visitors. Unfortunately, the amenities at many parks have aged poorly and many have not been maintained properly. The National Park Service must modernize. It has failed to meet the challenge or the changing demands of its visitors. Millennials and modern families want tech services, like WiFi and internet access. Cell service is not only an amenity, it's an important safety consideration. When NPS does not keep up, our parks lose visitors to other tourism opportunities, such as privately run theme parks and other attractions. Certainly, we don't need to turn our parks into Disneyland, but we do need to keep up with what 21st century Americans want when vacationing. I want to see my friends' vacation pictures at our parks on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, and I want to know I can get help in the event of an emergency by dialing 911. By providing up-to-date technology, contemporary food and beverage service, and a choice between rustic, comfortable, and modern places to stay and unique visitor experiences, our parks become more attractive. This is where the role of concessionaires is critical. They help provide these services while providing much-needed funding to the Park Service. In our last hearing on the subject, we heard of several instances of bureaucratic red tape getting in the way. For instance, one park had a 1,629-page-long bid request outline that cost one concessionaire 2,500 company management hours and more than $90,000 to fill out. As another example, we heard about parks with campgrounds that sell out, but are only open for part of the year due to bureaucratic requirements. Fortunately, we have sources of ideas for ways to update the NPS. For instance, in partnering with ski areas, the Forest Service has found a way for people to use the land it leases year round. Furthermore, good ideas have come from various State park systems, such as Kansas' matching of park fees with demand. I hope to hear more about these ideas and more from our panel today. I very much look forward to hearing suggestions on a way forward from here and hopeful the committee can help update our National Park System. I would now like to recognize our ranking member, Ms. Plaskett, for her opening statement. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. And thank you all for being here this afternoon to talk about such an important part of the American experience, our national parks. I appreciate the National Park Service's protection and care of our Nation's cherished natural and cultural resources and for the important educational and recreational opportunities they provide for all Americans. The National Park Service plays an important economic and recreational role in my district, the U.S. Virgin Islands. We have national parks on all three of our major islands. Well, technically, St. Croix, Hassel Island, which is off of St. Thomas, and, of course, St. John. On the island of St. John, the Virgin Islands National Park covers approximately 60 percent of the island and includes the Cinnamon Bay Resort and Campground located inside of the National Park Service, as well as Caneel Bay, one of the most wonderful resorts as well. Under a new concession agreement reached last fall between the National Park Service and Redwood Company, the campgrounds are currently undergoing extensive renovations that include eliminating bare sites and installing Eco-Tents. The original plan called for 64 Eco-Tents, but after public opposition, that was reduced to 55. My office has received several complaints regarding the relocation of bare site camping and the high cost and quality of the new Eco-Tents. This is an example of how improvements of park sites can lessen and not improve on the visitor experience at the national parks. After the Park Service held its centennial celebration in 2017, we must ensure that the very best services are provided for the 280 million visitors that our national parks attract each year, as well as the local employment that it can provide through the vendors and through those individuals who work at those park sites and the relationship they have with the communities that are located adjacent or sometimes even within the parks themselves. Vendors play a key role in providing visitor services. They offer a wide range of recreational and retail services, while helping to generate more than $1.2 billion annually in revenue for the Federal Government, as well as the revenues that our local economies are able to receive by visitors and individuals who come to the parks and pass through the areas in which the parks are located. Vendors also employ more than 25,000 workers and drive economic growth in the communities surrounding the parks. I understand that the public is demanding more recreational and cultural opportunities during their visits to the national parks. I also understand that vendors are ready, willing, and able to provide these additional visitor services, but they've encountered some barriers. We want to understand what these are and how we here in Congress can be supportive of the vendors as well as the parks. Today, we will examine some of the challenges faced by the National Park Service and vendors in providing the best visitor experiences to our parks. Those challenges include a rigid contracting process, contracts which create negative cash flow for vendors, and the Park Service's failure to meet public demand for more services. Although the Park Service has made great improvements in its contracting process in recent years, more work can and should be done. We can always work to improve the contracting process with great cooperation between government and industry. I look forward to hearing from the witnesses as we explore possible solutions that can drive progress in these issues. Thank you. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. I will hold the record open for 5 legislative days for any members who would like to submit a written statement. We will now recognize our panel of witnesses. I am pleased to welcome Mr. Glenn Casamassa. You're associate deputy chief of the National Forest System for the United States Forest Service and the United States Department of Agriculture. We have Ms. Linda Lanterman, director of the Division of State Parks for the State of Kansas. Welcome. Mr. Chris Edmonston, the vice president of government affairs for BoatU.S. And Mr. Rick Cables, the vice president of natural resources and conservation at Vail Resorts. Welcome to you all. Pursuant to committee rules, all witnesses will be sworn before they testify. Would you please rise and raise your right hand? Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God? Thank you. Please be seated. And you can let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. In order to allow time for questions and discussions, we'd appreciate it if you'd limit your testimony to 5 minutes. Your entire written statements will be made part of the record. There ought to be a timer in front of you. The green light will be on for the first 4 minutes. The yellow light, much like a traffic light, means speed up--I'm just kidding there--and the red light means your time is up. So we'll start first with Mr. Casamassa. WITNESS STATEMENTS STATEMENT OF GLENN CASAMASSA Mr. Casamassa. Good afternoon, Chairman Farenthold, Ranking Member Plaskett, and members of the subcommittee. I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today regarding the Forest Service recreation program. We are proud of the work we accomplish with our private industry partners to provide the best possible breadth of choice and the highest quality outdoor recreation opportunities for the American people. Today, our national forests hosts 149 million visits. Since 2009, estimates of our recreation visitation has been rising by an average of about 1 million visits per year. Through their direct and ripple spending, recreationists who visit the national forests contribute billions to the U.S. economy and support thousands of jobs, the vast majority of which are in gateway and rural communities. Outdoor recreation supports significant employment opportunities and offers a tremendous economic stimulus for local municipalities. In addition to the continued popularity of traditional activities, like recreational sport shooting, hunting and fishing, we are seeing growth in ziplining and snowboarding, off-highway vehicle use, rafting trips, or guided backcountry trips. The combination of public demand and tremendous economic contributions makes outdoor recreation one of the more challenging programs in public land management, pushing the Forest Service to seek innovative approaches in balancing the growing demand for recreation and economic interest for further development with landscape conservation for generations to come. We administer recreation special uses that enable thousands of private sector professionals to lead a range of activities on national forests and grasslands. For many Americans, these activities represent their first introduction to their national forests and grasslands, and the outfitters and guides they use are small businesses, providing jobs and income. For example, approximately 4 million people visit the Coconino National Forest in Arizona, which surrounds the city of Sedona. Several outfitter and guide permits are issued to locally owned and operated businesses. One specific example of an outstanding working relationship we have with an outfitter is the Pink Jeep Tours. This small business provides about 100 percent of the maintenance to the Broken Arrow Road, one of the most popular 4x4 routes in the area. The national forests also host more than 120 alpine ski areas. These facilities are privately owned and constructed by our permittee partners, who provide recreation opportunities for proposing and developing sites in response to industry trends and public needs. We are working with the ski areas to go beyond snow season by enhancing year-round recreation, providing more choices for visitors, and creating additional jobs around resort communities. This is a win-win situation. More people will be able to find jobs in communities around ski areas, and more Americans will have access to year-round opportunities in these beautiful and convenient settings. Recognizing the critical role that private enterprise plays in outdoor recreation on our national forests and grasslands, we're also working to expand how we service businesses and the public by improving the permitting process. Special uses remains one of the primary economic drivers of the agency, in terms of both receipts to the government and national and local economic activity. Modernizing the special use program creates a more predictable business environment and a more efficient workforce. The Forest Service is working to eliminate redundant process, simplify forms, improve internal and external communication, improve financial accountability through simplification of fees, and streamlining the environmental analysis process for use of a continuing nature. Presently, our line officers have discretion to waive the special use authorization requirements for proposed uses on a case-by-case basis. Forest Service guidance stresses that officers shall allow activities that will have little impact on the land to move forward without undue process. Also, the Forest Service has implemented an agreement with GSA's 18F for development of an ePermitting System. We will soon offer a more convenient way for the public to apply for special use authorizations via an online application process. A national Campground and Day-Use Concession Review was conducted in early fiscal year 2017. The goal of the review was to enhance public-private ventures and agency business practices that promote true partnerships and identify shortfalls in agency policy and procedures. The Forest Service remains committed to serving the American public through commonsense cooperation with businesses, who drive the enormous diversity of recreation opportunities on American national forests. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. I'd be happy to answer any questions you may have. [Prepared statement of Mr. Casamassa follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Your timing is phenomenal. I assume you practiced that. Thank you. Ms. Lanterman, you are up for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF LINDA LANTERMAN Ms. Lanterman. Thank you, Chairman Farenthold, Ranking Member Plaskett, and members of the subcommittee. I am here representing the Kansas Department of Wildlife and Parks, the Division of State Parks. We manage 26 State parks, with an annual budget of $12 million. I am also the vice president of the National Association of State Park Directors. It's an organization dedicated to helping State park systems effectively manage and administer their State park systems. I am here, though, today to discuss Kansas State parks, as well as the national State park landscape and how State park systems work to improve outdoor recreational opportunities for their constituents and conserve natural resources, through partnerships, innovations, and reducing barriers. Nationwide, there are over 10,000 State park areas. They are comprised of over 18 million acres, and we receive more than 790 million visits annually. Those State parklands may be owned outright by States or consist of lands leased from Federal agencies. As a result, Federal partnerships are crucial to the success of State park systems, as well as to the success of Federal agencies which make their lands available for public use. Of special importance to State park systems are Federal programs, such as the Land and Water Conservation Fund, the National Recreational Trails Grant, and the AmeriCorps program. State parks around the country collectively serve the public with more than 37,000 miles of trails, over 241,000 campsites, over 9,400 cabins and cottages, and 161 lodges. Operating expenditures account for $2.5 billion, with less than half of those expenditures coming from the general funds of the States. Nineteen thousand full-time and 29,000 part-time or seasonal staffs work tirelessly to provide topnotch memorable visitor experiences. Nationally, it's been estimated there may be as much as $95 billion in unfunded capital improvements and maintenance needed just to sustain the State park systems. In Kansas, our capital improvement and maintenance needs are over $25 million. The Kansas State Parks Division and the Department do not receive any State general funds. Instead, our State parks are funded primarily from revenues we receive from our State park vehicle permits, camping permits, and cabin rentals. In addition, we also receive a portion of the Department's allocation of the Economic Development Incentive Fund, which is funded by proceeds from the Kansas Lottery. However, there are many State park systems that benefit from dedicated funding sources. The Land and Water Conservation Fund, the Recreational Trails Grant program, and the AmeriCorps program have always been an important and efficient matching fund for Kansas State parks. We rely heavily on our partnerships with our friends groups, our volunteers, and other park supporters that provide financial, labor, and advocacy support. With the support of Governor Brownback, we have implemented several measures to meet challenges of operating a primarily fee-based parks program. For example, we aggressively market our State park systems within Kansas, nationally and internationally. We hold staff positions open at times to save staffing costs. We've been successful in matching permit fees with demand. Additionally, we have special events to attract and encourage our customers' ongoing loyalty. Some of those events include outdoor music concerts, live bands, guided nature hikes, Halloween events, Black Friday with the hashtag #OPTOUTSIDE, the Governor's Campouts and, of course, our First Day Hike. To be competitive in today's leisure market, it's important that we address the changing needs and expectations of our customers. Some of the land use policies of the Federal agencies need to be modernized so our parks can compete for our Nation's young family free time. Among the immediate changes we recommend concerning our Federal landlord partners are more flexible lease agreements, more streamlined processing of concessionaire contracts, an ability for our Department to retain all net proceeds arising from hosting of special events designed to attract our customers. Some of the Corps properties, we have both State park and Corps parks. Efficiencies could be improved if these two levels of government were not duplicating their services, such as camping. Kansas State parks and those in other States attract a diverse clientele who enjoy traveling in their home State and visiting parks in other States. Staying at a State park is truly a form of recreation that's important on a national level. From my testimony today, I hope you really see the important role Federal partnerships are and how the Federal funding in our State parks and how important the partnership with State parks are nationally to an efficient public land strategy. I too will accept any questions. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Ms. Lanterman follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. Mr. Edmonston, you are up for 5. STATEMENT OF CHRIS EDMONSTON Mr. Edmonston. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Plaskett, and members of the committee, I am pleased to be here representing the 550,000 members of the Boat Owners Association of the United States, BoatU.S. We appreciate the chance to share how access, public-private partnerships, and technology can improve the visitor experience in national parks and other public lands. Reflecting on the visitor experience in national parks provides an opportunity to consider how important access to the water really is. Boaters need facilities to launch and retrieve, dock, moor, and anchor their boats. Providing such access is vital to keeping boating available to the American public. The thoughtful oversight of this committee and Congress should focus the National Park Service and other Federal agencies on providing such access to our public lands and waters. In our experience, how well a particular national park unit or other Federal entity provides access is highly variable. In some cases, they welcome boats, which might be the only way to reach some of the more remote areas. Other park units do not always welcome all boats and often make management decisions that diminish public access. The controversies at Key Biscayne National Park surrounding fishing closures, adequate moorings, bans on certain types of boats, and expansive nonmotorized zones is of grave concern to us. In our view, a shift in management philosophy to one that welcomes all users, not just the young and fit, is long overdue. Our current system of waterway access provides a good example of the wide range of partnerships that can benefit all of us. For example, many boating access programs are funded by the Sportfish Restoration Boating Trust Fund. This user pay- everyone benefits fund is supported primarily through taxes on boaters and anglers. The system is widely supported by the boating and angling communities. Boaters are not looking for a free ride and are quite willing to pay reasonable fees, provided they can count on the facilities being available and well-managed. We recognize there is a reconsideration of Federal budget priorities currently underway. We respectfully suggest that investment in facilities that provide access to public lands and waters should remain a priority for this Congress. Each year, over 80 million Americans go boating, with a large portion doing so on federally managed waters. We ask the help of this Congress to be sure that recreational boaters, as well as other outdoor recreation participants, aren't ignored as tough budget decisions are made. During another time of budget crunches several decades ago, the Coast Guard shifted its mission focus and ended its longtime policy of aiding recreational boaters stranded on public waters. While they do continue to come to the aid of those in life-threatening conditions, other situations, such as a malfunctioning engine or running out of fuel, are no longer a time where the Coast Guard will provide assistance. In response to this policy change, BoatU.S. created a nationwide towing dispatch service, which today has more than 600 towboats across the country and is available at a very reasonable cost. The program is effective, it's popular, and it allows the Coast Guard to focus on emergency missions. In fact, there is a large industry of on-water service providers which works closely with State and Federal agencies to ensure that recreational boaters receive prompt and professional assistance on the water, assistance which over the past few decades has saved the Coast Guard untold millions of dollars. Another area where we see opportunity for Federal agencies to provide better service involves the application of new technology. Information on boating and other outdoor opportunities are often difficult to discover on many government or individual park websites. Such resources should be welcoming to visitors and provide ways to discover all the activities available. This requires a new outlook on the part of Federal managers, one with a view to enhance the visitor experience as part of their core mission. We also see technology as a way to enhance access while protecting resources. Providing greater connectivity will open up management options, such as allowing faster updates to resource information, better reporting of available activities, such as fishing or camping, and the purchase of passes and permits needed for recreating. BoatU.S. supports the appropriate use of technology to improve visitor experiences on all public lands and waters. In closing, recreational boaters and anglers have an abiding interest in the protection of our waterways, as do other recreational users of public lands. We wish to see these special places protected. We also need to be able to reach these special places in many different ways. Providing appropriate access is crucial to the long-term political and financial support for national parks and other public lands. We appreciate the opportunity to bring the voice of boaters before the subcommittee. Thank you. [Prepared statement of Mr. Edmonston follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Thank you, Mr. Edmonston. Mr. Cables, you are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF RICK CABLES Mr. Cables. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Plaskett, and members of the committee, thank you for the invitation today. Vail Resorts operates 13 premier resorts worldwide. We have resorts in Canada, in British Columbia, and Australia. The others are all in the United States. We have some of the most iconic and beautiful landscapes that we operate on in the Nation, and we've learned a thing or two about managing people and providing a guest experience that I want to share today. Six of our largest resorts are on the national forest, and we have a 40-year permit with the United States Forest Service that lays out exactly how we can operate. It's a classic example of a public-private partnership, where the Federal Government provides the land and our business provides the business acumen, the capital, and the operational capability to deliver wonderful experiences for the American public and our guests. We provide a fee to the Treasury for leasing the land, which is substantial. It wasn't long ago that ski areas were just thought of as for the winter recreation. You do it on snow. And so for the bulk of the winter, that's when ski areas operated. In the summer, they didn't. In the fall, they didn't. The private land ski areas started changing that by offering summertime activities on the ski resorts and including things like hiking trails, mountain biking trails and mountain coasters, ziplines, and those sorts of activities. And so about a decade ago, we approached our partner, the United States Forest Service, with the idea: Can we do that on our public land resorts? Can we actually open it up for four seasons? The response was: Yes, and it's probably better if you get some enabling legislation that helps do that. So we approached Congress, and in 2011 the Ski Area Recreation Opportunity Enhancement Act was passed unanimously in both Houses. And I think that's a testament that it just made common sense that you would use this land for four seasons. We have the infrastructure in place, parking lots, restaurants. They were sitting idle half of the year. It helps us round out the resort communities' economies, because we provide jobs all year round now, and for our own employees. So the benefits, both from a guest experience and from an economic benefit, are significant. Our company proposed the first projects under the new law in 2014, after the regulations were promulgated. We started at Vail in Colorado and Heavenly at Lake Tahoe. We proposed ziplines, coasters, canopy tours, mountain biking trails, and a whole host of fun things to do. Our concept is learn through play. So we want people to learn a little bit about the natural environment and also have fun on these mountains. The results are spectacular. If any of you ever want to come out and enjoy a zipline at 11,000 feet, you should do it. The public loves it. The economic benefits are coming. Our guests are up in the summer versus what we had before, clearly. And we've got a partnership with the Nature Conservancy to take a percentage of our revenue and put it into conservation projects. We've worked with the Forest Service because we want uniformed rangers on the mountain. The public loves it when they're on the mountain and there's a ranger there that can talk to them about the environment, the wildlife, the forest, water, whatever questions they may have. So we're really excited about that. It's working. The challenges we have are with funding and the way the Forest Service budget's fire suppression has eaten into the other programs, like recreation. So the Forest Service is having a hard time keeping up with us. We have a proposal to solve that. If we could get legislation that allows us to keep the fees we pay local, then we can help fund the Forest Service and they can be a better partner and a healthier partner. Senators Gardner and Wyden on the Senate side are proposing this legislation and working with us on it, and we'd like to work with Members of Congress here. And also, obviously, there's process streamlining that would help. We think there's ways to streamline some of the National Environmental Policy Act analysis associated with really common projects that we do. So, again, I'll close by saying, if you can imagine a family, maybe a single parent from Denver, that gets up to Vail that's really never spent time in the mountain, getting on a chair lift in the fall with the Aspen turning, getting up on the mountain and doing a mountain bike trip or riding a mountain coaster, and just hooking those people on the outdoors and recreation, that's what we're trying to do, have fun and get people out and do it in a way that we haven't done in the past. So our partners with the Forest Service have been fabulous to work with. I can't say enough about that relationship. Thank you, and look forward to your questions. [Prepared statement of Mr. Cables follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And we'll start with Mr. Ross for 5 minutes of questioning. Mr. Ross. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I'm particularly grateful to our witnesses today who've testified. I feel like I've been to most of the locations that you all have discussed today. To give you an example, I grew up traveling to national parks with my grandfather in a 1960 Airstream, which I have now restored and own. We went to the '62 World's Fair staying at national parks--that shows you how old I am--'64 World's Fair, '67 World's Fair. But what we did is we stayed at the national parks because they were not only convenient, but they had full facilities and the commercial market didn't. And today, the RV industry is growing phenomenally. In fact, I own three RVs, one of which is an antique, one of which I let my boys use, and one of which my wife and I use when we travel around the country. By the time my boys were 12, they had been to all continental 48 States and predominantly staying in national parks throughout this country. And what we've seen, though, unfortunately, is that the national park campgrounds have declined from nearly 4.5 million overnights in the 1980s to less than 2 million overnight stays in 2013. There's an opportunity being missed there, not only by the national parks but by the citizens of the United States because they don't have a chance to enjoy those phenomenal resources, those natural resources that are out there. So my questions are, first of all, Ms. Lanterman, I love what you guys are doing with public-private partnerships and I think that you've hit on something there, but it's the capital requirements that are necessary. And if Kansas is like Florida and like any other State, those resources, those dollar resources are so limited. Are there opportunities for bond issues to be funded by revenues from concessionaires or things of that nature? Is Kansas looking into creative ways to finance these capital improvements? Ms. Lanterman. We actually do. That's a great question. We look at bond issues. And we've also looked at our foundation for support on putting in our cabin program. Actually, our foundation helped do that. And then our Governor, through the Economic Development Fund, paid those off. And so now we are reaping the benefits of those revenues. And today, as I sit here, we are still looking at a bond issue for another development in one of our bigger parks. So you have to look at all sources. You can't look at the State anymore just to fund. Mr. Ross. You can't. And, in fact, these RVs today have become so--I mean, really, you know, they're your home once you take the wheels off. But they're large and the facilities in our national parks just can't accommodate them, so we have to put in the infrastructure necessary to allow this. And then I guess my question is, Mr. Cables, you've talked about the four seasons in Vail and how you've been able to make use of a resource. What other ways can we utilize our national parks and creative financial resources to bring them up to speed so that they can accommodate today's recreational vehicles? Mr. Cables. Thank you, Congressman Ross. All I will say is that we found a way with our partner, our Federal partner, the United States Forest Service, to look at creative ways to expand recreational opportunities, and where there's a will, there's a way. The Forest Service came to us when we started working on these opportunities, and we proposed some things that they didn't believe were natural resource-based or went a little bit over the line, and we talked it through and worked it through and came up with an agreement on the things that really did make sense that we thought our guests would love and that the Forest Service---- Mr. Ross. And it's been a good relationship. Mr. Cables. Yes. It's the relationship, it's the quality of the land managers that we deal with locally, that we've been able to work this through. So I think that's really the secret. Mr. Ross. And, Mr. Casamassa, if I might, how has your relationship been with the National Park Service, I mean, in terms of wanting to be able to expand the infrastructure in these national parks? Mr. Casamassa. I think at times, in my experience, working with park superintendents around different parts of the country, we've looked at ways to provide opportunities for one thing on the park, like, for example, a large parking lot. And then, in addition to that, we would then do something as it relates to camping on the National Forest System. So it was providing a full suite of amenities. I think we have the opportunity to expand that, to find a full suite of opportunities for people, but it doesn't necessarily have to be on one land administration or another. It could be done together. Mr. Ross. And just to bring in an aside here since I've got limited time here, working with the RV industry, working with the Outdoor Recreation Industry Roundtable, is that something that you're taking the initiative to do? I think that would be very fundamental to getting it done in a very all-encompassing way. Mr. Casamassa. I think right now to ensure that we can make our facilities contemporary and connect people to their public lands is paramount. Mr. Ross. I agree. Mr. Casamassa. And that any way that we can to set up roundtable discussions to understand fully what the needs are and try---- Mr. Ross. And with the industry. Mr. Casamassa. With industry. And try to marry up the public lands with those kinds of needs is something that we'd be certainly interested in. Mr. Ross. Thank you. And I see my time is expired. I yield back. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much, Mr. Ross. Ms. Plaskett, I'll recognize you for 5 minutes. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you very much. The National Park Service is entering its second century, and I want to explore ways that the agency can better utilize the vendors that operate with them. Mr. Edmonston and Mr. Cables, I understand from your testimony here today that the path to improving visitor experiences in our national parks starts with an effective public-private partnership. Would you say that that is correct? Mr. Edmonston. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. One of the things I noticed, and I happened to look at the Park Service websites for your Virgin Islands, and I noticed several things related to vendors. First off, there is a 35-page guide to becoming a vendor in the Park Service, and I noticed that it hadn't been updated since 2001. When I read it, it seemed more of a way for the Park Service to limit liability for the parks rather than a way to encourage entrepreneurs to come into the park system. I also looked at ways people could utilize parks, their visit to the parks, like, let's say, they wanted to get married and they wanted a nice scenic overlook or a pavilion to get married in. The only way to do that would be to print out a form, mail it in with a nonrefundable deposit, and hope that the date and the facility you wanted were available. There was no way to look to see online even what facilities were available for renting. So if you didn't have local knowledge, you couldn't do it. There are many ways, simple ways, better use of technology, that could help visitor experience and also could make it easier for vendors to come in and use the parks. Ms. Plaskett. So just to go forward with that before I get to Mr. Cables, when you talked about, you know, in your testimony you talked about technology, and prior to the passage of the Centennial Act, the business community had raised several concerns with it. And within that, I know that there was some discussion about technology. You talked about the manual that is probably a PDF---- Mr. Edmonston. Yes. Ms. Plaskett. --that is not interactive, not easy to utilize. What are some of the other new technology that we might--we know what's wrong, but what could the parks be using that would facilitate---- Mr. Edmonston. Oh, goodness, I will defer to Mr. Cables on that since he uses that on a daily basis in his business. Mr. Cables. Thank you, Ranking Member Plaskett. First, real quick on the public-private partnership. Yeah, that has to start, be where it starts. The government, at least in my experience in the government, isn't the best at entrepreneurial, some entrepreneurial thinking, marketing, some of those kind of things. I think the private sector does that better. The private sector is an expert on the land management, the forest and wildlife and water science and the considerations associated with that. So if we're both playing to our strengths in a partnership, then it can really work, and I think that's been our experience. I would say on the technology, again, my expertise is more in natural resources, but we do have a program that we initiated a couple years ago called EpicMix where there's an app and people can track their vertical fee in a given day, and you can actually find out which lift lines are shorter than others. And it gives young people particularly but a lot of people the opportunity to use their phones and to use it in a way that's kind of fun and figure out where to meet and to do things along those lines. So we find that tying that kind of technology in with an outdoor experience can actually work and not diminish the outdoor experience, but actually enhance it. So, yes, we have some really talented people in our company that focus on technology and how it makes the guest experience better. Ms. Plaskett. Okay. Thank you. I think what I'm really trying to understand is, if we want to have these relationships and we want to work together, I don't want us to just be beating up on the park, but really offering them some constructive support, because we know that they have their budgetary constraints. They are a government agency. And so it's not their orientation to think this way. And how do we in Congress facilitate a way that you as vendors and you as entrepreneurs and being in this recreation and resort business can facilitate more people coming to the park. Because, listen, in the Virgin Islands, on St. John, we want to maintain the park. And we realize how important it is to our local economy, because when you get to St. John, you've got to come over on the ferry. That's a ferry fee for us. You're going to eat in a local restaurant. You're going to do other things. And that supports our economy. So how do we make that experience such that people are going to keep coming back? So if you all have any other thoughts, I'd just leave it up to--I see you, Ms. Lanterman, shaking your head. If you have any other thoughts or, otherwise, I'll yield back after that. Ms. Lanterman. What I would say is we are government, those of us that are in government, and we can change. And there are companies out there that can help us change, with iPhone apps and with a reservation system. And we are moving towards that. And sometimes it's a little bit slower, but I've found the best way for you learning those changes is when you go out and use it yourself. And so when we travel and when I travel on my own, I use those systems and I come back and I think: Oh, my gosh, we've got to do this. And so that's how you learn. And it's a process, but I believe it can be done. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. And I want to follow up on a little bit of the testimony in my 5 minutes here. Mr. Casamassa, you talked about getting special use permits and the like. Can you give me an example of what some of the special uses that people use in the forest or parks? Mr. Casamassa. Sure. There's, say, recreational events. In some respects we have, say, a bike race that crosses over five different national forests in an entire State over a week's period of time. Lots of activity associated with an event of that scale. And that's one of the kinds of permits that we issue for those type of recreational events. We have outfitter and guide permits for whitewater rafting, hunting, fishing, mountain bike tours, OHVs, and the like. So there's a full suite of things that we look at when it comes to providing recreational opportunities to meet the demands and needs of people. Mr. Farenthold. So how do you balance the mission of preserving the wilderness with making it available to the public? This has got to be one of the biggest challenges. I've sensed in some--Park Service more so than Forest Service--but this is a great national park but for the damn tourists. I mean, how do you reconcile that? Mr. Casamassa. And that's a very delicate balance. And one of the ways that--I think about looking at opportunities, a full suite of opportunities. And maybe people only understand or are provided the information about one place that provides that opportunity. If you would then provide them a full suite of, well, are you looking for a hike? Are you looking for a lake? Are you looking for that kind of setting? You know, this is a very crowded place here, maybe we can direct you to another location. So I think it is a lot about information. It's a lot about balancing the maintenance and enhancement of that landscape for generations to come with the use. And I think there's an interest from the Forest Service about understanding a bit more about the carrying capacity, and perhaps we should be thinking through this and maybe looking at letting the users provide that carrying capacity for an area if we feel like that the area could be maintained, that there isn't any damage to the environment around it. So it's just about looking at it maybe in a different way that expands, I think, our opportunities. Mr. Farenthold. Ms. Lanterman, you work in the State parks, and I've found that States are a little bit more responsive to the public than we are here in Washington, D.C. Did you want to kind of weigh in on that balance as well? Ms. Lanterman. You know, we have to be. We are in the business of making sure that our customers have a place to go and that it's maintained. And we do our best, truly, to make sure that we have the loyalty of our constituent groups. And, frankly, they'll tell us if we do not. And so, along with what my colleague here said, it's an education process. We have to educate our users. You don't love and protect what you don't know about. And so that's what our process is, is try to educate our users when they come in so that we can keep it for the preservation for years to come. Mr. Farenthold. Mr. Cables, you look like you wanted to weigh in as well. Mr. Cables. Yes. I would say there are other mechanisms to do that. For example, for operating our ski mountains in the summer on national forests, we've zoned the mountain. So at the top of, like, the gondola, in an area that's already developed, there's hard infrastructure, the environment's been altered, that's where we'll put certain things like climbing walls, ropes courses, and some of the heavier infrastructure. And then as you get further from that location, you'll get into what we call zones two, three, four, and five, where there may just be the only appropriate use is a hiking trail. So it's a spectrum of concentrated recreation, which some people like. They don't want to get too far off, away from sight of a building. But yet others may want to do a mountain bike trip or a hiking trip and get really back away from everything. And there's a master development plan that we have to submit to the Forest Service that actually creates a zoning, and that's how we deal with that. Mr. Farenthold. Great. I've got some more questions, but I've only got about 10 seconds left. So I'll save them to the second round of questioning and let Mr. Raskin go for 5 minutes. Mr. Raskin. Thank you for your courtesy, Mr. Chairman. Let's see. Mr. Casamassa, I was interested in something that you said just a moment ago where you were saying that people might have a cluster of different interests. They might want to do a hike. They might want to do camping near a Civil War battlefield. Is it possible on your website for me to put in all of my different requests and then for you to send me back what your advice is for where I might go? Mr. Casamassa. Well, I think there are opportunities to do that. We continue to enhance. Rec.gov, I think, is a multi- agency website that provides, I think, a relatively large suite of opportunities for people to be informed, to maybe do some trip planning, to get some kind of reservations. Certainly that is unto itself a good start. Tailoring some of the more I'd say specific trips is something that we continue to work on. One thing that I'd like to add to that is that we recognize that providing information and education in more of a digital platform, really, what I call it is I think it adds capacity without adding any people. Mr. Raskin. Got you. Let me just follow up with you for 1 second. I think you're the right person to direct this to, but others can comment if they need to. To what extent are you dealing with the effects of climate change and severe weather events, and to what extent is that having an effect on the visitor experience in national parks, in terms of floods, forest fires, hurricanes, severe events? Mr. Casamassa. And a good question. I think one of the things that I've experienced prior to coming to the headquarters here in our Nation's Capital is I've had to manage lands that had a significant number of forest fires, catastrophic events, that really impacted the landscape as a whole. In addition to that, I've seen some pretty significant flooding across a wide landscape that actually really wiped out all the roads and access, bridges, and some of our developed sites. Mr. Raskin. Where is that? Mr. Casamassa. In Colorado. And so that, you know, I've seen some significant weather events that we've had to adjust our thinking around how best to site areas and be able to adjust and mitigate to the best of our ability some weather events. Mr. Raskin. Thank you. I'm interested also in the question of accessibility. One of the things I've always loved about the national parks is, at least the ones I go to, people just go and they're not even paying. There might be some, I think, where people pay, but it's kept at a modest level. And I was moved by what Mr. Cables said about doing public-private partnerships that allow for different things to go on. But to what extent is that done with an eye towards accessibility for the whole population that would otherwise be able to come and hike there? Does it suddenly become off limits to large numbers of people because it's so expensive? Just curious what you might have to say about that. Mr. Cables. Thank you for the question. The resorts that operate on National Forest System lands, they're public lands. So uses can occur on those lands as long as they don't materially interfere with our permitted use. So, for example, people come up all the time in the summer and hike that don't pay a fee, don't get a ticket, don't engage in our own facilities or activities. Mr. Raskin. You're not displacing them. Mr. Cables. No, no, we're not, no. Mr. Raskin. But how much does it cost to do your kinds of things? Mr. Cables. Again, we've got one summer under our belt and we've got a suite of products for summer. The high end to do everything is like $80- to $90-dollar range. Mr. Raskin. For the day? Mr. Cables. Yes, for a day. And then we have a package, I think we call it the Little Explorer, which is around $50 for kids. And you can also do things a la carte, where you don't get the whole package, but you can go to a specific ride or do something along those lines separately. And we're still experimenting. Like I said, we've got one season under our belt. Mr. Raskin. That's great. Okay. And my final question is about education. Is there some formal effort underway to make connections with schools in local areas with the national parks? Mr. Casamassa. I would say that we, ``we'' the Forest Service, we invest heavily in student conservation service, resource assistant programs, and programs that connect youth to the outdoors. There are several applications that we use for children to be able to explore specific locations. So I think what we're trying to do is invest in youth to grow the next, I'd say, generation of conservationists in the country. Mr. Raskin. Thank you very much. I yield back, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you very much. And I guess I'm back up for my second round of questions rather quickly. So I want to talk, Mr. Cables, a little bit about something that I've heard from various national parks and some forest concessionaires, and that's end of contract time. You've entered into I'm assuming a relatively long-term contract with the amount of capital investments that you have put in. But as you near the end of that term, say you've had a--I'm picking a number out of the air--say you've had a 30- or 40-year lease, in the last 5 to 7 years there's not a lot of incentive for you to put a lot of money in maintenance and upgrades because most likely your whole deal will go out for bids again. Is there any middle ground or way that we can structure this to where we don't end up having a huge capital expenditure, putting in nice facilities up front, with no incentives other than contractual requirements to upgrade or improve the facilities? Twenty or 30 years down the road, we're not going to think of the amenities that people are going to want and are going to be necessary to keep your facility competitive, and you have no real financial incentive to do those upgrades as you're in the waning years of your contract. Mr. Cables. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would say that it sounds like you're describing an assumption or a set of assumptions based on the park's concession program versus ours. We have a 40-year term special use permit, which is a huge factor because it allows us to invest and amortize that investment over a long period of time, A. B, we own the facilities, so they're our facilities, and the equipment, the lifts, whatever, they're our facilities. And thirdly, at the end of the term of that permit, we're able to get a reissued permit, without competition, as long as we're managing and meeting the requirements of the permit. So we don't go through a competitive bidding process. Mr. Farenthold. Does anybody want to address that issue? Do you face that in Kansas? Ms. Lanterman. We actually do. And what we've done is we've enacted a list of what our concessionaires do. Are they in compliance? Have they always been in compliance? And then we allow them to renew. Our problem is, though, if we are on Corps or Bureau property, we cannot extend it beyond our lease. And that is if we have only a 25-year lease with them, we can't extend it longer than that. Mr. Farenthold. Okay, great. All right, so you talked about some of the funding issues and such. Is there ever a point where we can be closer to self- sustaining? I mean, a lot of this, especially on the Federal level, is financed through appropriations. Obviously a ski resort has a much better chance of being self-sufficient than some wilderness park somewhere. How close to self-sufficient can we get? Ms. Lanterman. Well, I guess what I would say is the challenges we have is we have to--or at least we feel like we need to make sure our customers, all customers can come, so all clientele. Can they afford it? Can that single mom come? And we try to make our fees that way. Additionally, you have that weather issue. Most State park systems receive most of their revenue May through September. And so if you have weather issues in there, then you have a challenge of your finances and your cash flow coming in. And so I always believe that may be something that plays a part in this. Mr. Farenthold. Anybody else want to weigh in there? Mr. Edmonston. Yes, sir, I would like to. I mentioned in my testimony the Sportfish Restoration and Boating Trust Fund, and that is a system that collects fees based on the sales of boats, motors, fishing equipment. It collects some revenues from the gasoline tax. And it really goes a long way towards paying for a lot of the infrastructure that boaters and people who recreate on water use. It pays for fish stocking in most of the rivers and lakes around the country. It is a great partnership. And I would say that there is an appetite for more access, better access, better services. And if vendors were allowed to come in and provide those, maybe not at every park, maybe not at every piece of Federal land, but you would see an increase in revenue and you would be able to better manage your properties. And getting back to the leases, we have seen on particularly Corps of Engineers facilities, issues with marina managers losing their lease. We saw that up in New York after Hurricane Isabel, I believe, a few years ago, where a marina was taken out by the storm, and they were not allowed to rebuild, and we had to really have an act of Congress to get them to get their lease back. So that is an ongoing issue, yes. Mr. Farenthold. All right. Thank you very much. Ms. Plaskett, do you have some more questions? Ms. Plaskett. Yes, I did want to ask just a question to Mr. Casamassa, just along the lines of discussion about the growing public demand for outdoor recreation, discussing some of the best practices and initiatives you have identified in your testimony towards improving the visitor experience. How many partnerships are there between the Forest Service and small businesses utilizing recreational special use permits, if you are aware? Mr. Casamassa. Today, I want to say close to 25,000 permits, recreational permits. I think that that is the number that we have for recreational opportunities. But it is in the thousands, and it is partnerships that we have for a full suite of activities. Ms. Plaskett. And how long does it take to apply and then receive the permit on average or typically? Mr. Casamassa. It depends on, I would say, what the proposal would be and how significant it would be, what the scope and scale of it. I would say for individual rec events it should not take but several weeks to get from a proposal into the actual issuance of a permit on something that is that relatively routine and minor, some of the activities now that we are saying that you don't really need a permit. Other activities that have some infrastructure considerations and some longer terms for the permit will take longer than that. Ms. Plaskett. What is the longest that you have seen permits take? Mr. Casamassa. That is a good question. From my own personal experience, I'd say over a year. Ms. Plaskett. Okay. And how much do the permits cost? Mr. Casamassa. It depends on what actually is being authorized. Ms. Plaskett. Okay. And then could you tell us a little bit about the rollout of ePermit system? Mr. Casamassa. Sure. One of the things that we've done, just to back up a bit, is that we have what we called a recreational diagnostic. It was both a public- and a private- facing assessment of how well we were doing. We had five different things that came out of our diagnostic, and one of them was is that we wanted to connect youth to--we thought it would be advantageous to connect youth to the outdoors. We wanted to celebrate our iconic places. We wanted to ensure that there was appropriate access, both roads and trails. We wanted to increase our reach when it came to the digital strategy as another one. And we wanted to streamline our special use permitting process because we recognized that that was a bottleneck. And so in conjunction with the streamlining, we recognized that some of the activities could be done online. So we are making considerable investments right now not only in the back of the house with our data systems that connect to the front of the house, which would be our ePermitting issue. And we are looking at--right now we have a platform that we are working with AT&F on that could be--it could be used for a wide array of permits. Right now our launches are around rec special uses in specific areas, as well as Christmas tree permits. And so those are the things we are starting, but, again, that's one of the--for me, I am advocating that we invest in the technology to add capacity without increasing the number of people that we have. Ms. Plaskett. Thank you. I really appreciate the work that you all are doing, and I am particularly grateful that you talk about the youth program and working with young people. I think that that is really important. On the island of St. Croix we have had a really outstanding summer youth program with the National Park Service, which has been really instrumental in a lot of kids, high school students and others, really getting comfortable and having a great community awareness for the Park Service that is there in their communities. Personally, one of my sons ended up going to this program in the summer, being really involved in the restoration that was happening with our fort, went on to college to get his degree in architecture, and is in the outdoors doing this kind of work. So it has really been important to us. And I am also grateful to the regional director of the National Park Service who has committed to the Virgin Islands to reinvigorate the program on the Island of St. John, where that relationship is even more important because the proximity that the park and the community and the young people really be closely involved. So thank you so much, Mr. Chairman, for this opportunity to ask these questions. Mr. Farenthold. Thank you. And they've just called votes, which means we've got about 5 minutes before we need to walk over to make it. So I just have one quick question for you guys. And if you all had some advice to give to the Park Service and/or concessionaires about what we need to do, what would it would be? And we will just go down the line with Mr. Casamassa. Mr. Casamassa. I would say, and I think that the--I don't know everything that the Park Service is doing, but I know that they are on a trajectory to look at or assess their concession program, and I think that that is something that we did. There are some good findings out of that. And to me, I would like to think that we would continue on with looking at ways to lever public-private partnerships through that assessment. Mr. Farenthold. Great. Ms. Lanterman. Ms. Lanterman. And I would suggest that the National Park Service, as they have in the past, just continue to work with America's State parks to help solve some of these issues too that we face too with them. Mr. Farenthold. Great. Mr. Edmonston. Mr. Edmonston. I would say it is maybe a slight change of focus in having the focus placed on how to enhance the visitor experience and how to work better with industry and other outside partners. Mr. Farenthold. Make it better for those doggone tourists. Mr. Cables. Mr. Cables. Talk and listen to your constituencies and have an open mind. Mr. Farenthold. All right. Well, listen, I want to thank our witness panel for being here. I think we got some great input. We do have votes coming up, so we will wrap this up if you guys are good with that. And I will ask unanimous consent that all members have 5 legislative days to submit questions for the record. And without objection, that's so ordered. Did you have anything else, Mr. Raskin? All right. Well, then, with no further business, without objection, the subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 3:23 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- Material Submitted for the Hearing Record [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]