Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- FORCED LABOR, MASS INTERNMENT, AND SOCIAL CONTROL IN XINJIANG [Joint House and Senate Hearing, 116 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] FORCED LABOR, MASS INTERNMENT, AND SOCIAL CONTROL IN XINJIANG ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ OCTOBER 17, 2019 __________ Printed for the use of the Congressional-Executive Commission on China [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available at www.cecc.gov or www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 56-600 PDF WASHINGTON : 2024 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA LEGISLATIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS House Senate JAMES P. McGOVERN, Massachusetts, MARCO RUBIO, Florida, Co-chair Chair JAMES LANKFORD, Oklahoma MARCY KAPTUR, Ohio TOM COTTON, Arkansas THOMAS SUOZZI, New York STEVE DAINES, Montana TOM MALINOWSKI, New Jersey TODD YOUNG, Indiana BEN McADAMS, Utah DIANNE FEINSTEIN, California CHRIS SMITH, New Jersey JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon BRIAN MAST, Florida GARY PETERS, Michigan VICKY HARTZLER, Missouri ANGUS KING, Maine EXECUTIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS Not yet appointed Jonathan Stivers, Staff Director Peter Mattis, Deputy Staff Director (ii) C O N T E N T S ---------- Statements Page Opening Statement of Hon. James P. McGovern, a U.S. Representative from Massachusetts; Chair, Congressional- Executive Commission on China.................................. 1 Statement of Hon. Marco Rubio, a U.S. Senator from Florida; Co- chair, Congressional-Executive Commission on China............. 3 Statement of Hon. Chris Smith, a U.S. Representative from New Jersey......................................................... 5 Statement of Hon. Todd Young, a U.S. Senator from Indiana........ 5 Zenz, Adrian, Non-resident Senior Fellow in China Studies at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation, and author of ``Beyond the Camps: Beijing's Grand Scheme of Forced Labor, Poverty Alleviation and Social Control in Xinjiang''........... 7 Turkel, Nury, Washington-based attorney and Chair of the Board and co-founder, Uyghur Human Rights Project.................... 8 Posner, Michael, Jerome Kohlberg Professor of Ethics and Finance and Director of the Center for Business and Human Rights at NYU's Stern School............................................. 11 Lehr, Amy K., Director of the Human Rights Initiative at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and former legal adviser to the U.N. Special Representative on Business and Human Rights................................................... 12 Appendix Prepared Statements Turkel, Nury..................................................... 43 Posner, Michael.................................................. 48 Lehr, Amy........................................................ 54 McGovern, Hon. James P........................................... 56 Rubio, Hon. Marco................................................ 57 Submissions for the Record Zenz, Adrian, ``Beyond the Camps: Beijing's Grand Scheme of Coercive Labor, Poverty Alleviation and Social Control in Xinjiang''..................................................... 59 Zenz, Adrian, supplemental material.............................. 84 The Citizen Power Institute of Citizens Power Initiatives for China, ``Cotton: The Fabric Full of Lies'' (A Report on Forced and Prison Labor in Xinjiang, China, and the Nexus to Global Supply Chains), submitted by Nury Turkel....................... 87 Lehr, Amy K. and Mariefaye Bechrakis, ``Connecting the Dots in Xinjiang--Forced Labor, Forced Assimilation, and Western Supply Chains,'' a report of the CSIS Human Rights Initiative......... 163 Uyghur Human Rights Project, ``Repression Across Borders: The CCP's Illegal Harassment and Coercion of Uyghur Americans,'' submitted by Nury Turkel....................................... 207 CECC Truth in Testimony form..................................... 254 Witness Biographies.............................................. 255 FORCED LABOR, MASS INTERNMENT, AND SOCIAL CONTROL IN XINJIANG ---------- TUESDAY, OCTOBER 17, 2019 Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Washington, DC. The hearing was convened, pursuant to notice, at 10:00 a.m., in room 419, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Representative James P. McGovern, Chair, presiding. Also present: Senators Rubio, Daines, Young, Merkley, and Peters, and Representatives Suozzi, Smith, Kaptur, and Hartzler. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JAMES P. McGOVERN, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM MASSACHUSETTS AND CHAIR, CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA Good morning, and welcome to today's Congressional- Executive Commission on China hearing, ``Forced Labor, Mass Internment, and Social Control in Xinjiang.'' In the last year Chinese authorities have expanded their network of mass internment camps where 1 million or more Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims have been detained and subjected to torture, extended solitary confinement, and political indoctrination, and deprived of food. Children of detainees are reportedly often placed in orphanages, welfare centers, and boarding schools. Some scholars and human rights groups argue that these practices may amount to crimes against humanity. Outside the camps, the Chinese government has become more efficient in the use of technology to control and suppress. Some observers have described the surveillance system as an open-air prison. Recent reports indicate that Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims are increasingly sentenced to lengthy prison sentences on vague charges. One case is that of Uyghur scholar Ilham Tohti, who is serving a life sentence in spite of his dedication to nonviolence and reconciliation. He is a ``Defending Freedoms Project'' prisoner of conscience and his congressional advocate is Representative Jim Langevin of Rhode Island. Meanwhile, the practice of Islam has also been criminalized. Mosques have been destroyed, Islamic dress has been forbidden, and fasting for Ramadan has been disallowed. It is in this context that new information has come to light detailing the widespread use of a government-subsidized and large-scale system of forced labor in both mass internment camps and in factories throughout Xinjiang. Satellite imagery, personal testimony, and official documents indicate that detainees in camps, and some who have been released, are forced to work in food, textile, and other manufacturing jobs. Products reportedly produced with forced labor include textiles, such as yarn, clothing, gloves, bedding, and carpet; electronics, including cell phones and computers; food products; shoes; tea; and handicrafts. In January 2019, the U.S. company Badger Sportswear stopped importing clothing following reports that it was made with forced labor by internment camp detainees. In May 2019, the Wall Street Journal linked the supply chains of Adidas, Campbell Soup, H&M, Kraft-Heinz, Coca-Cola, and Gap Inc. to forced labor. On October 1st, U.S. Customs and Border Protection issued a withhold release order on garments produced with prison or forced labor by Hetian Taida Apparel, which has exported products to Costco. Current U.S. law prohibits the import of any product made with forced labor. Any U.S. or international company that produces or has a supply chain in Xinjiang may be complicit in forced labor and human rights violations. In 2002 China ratified the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The ICESCR affirms the right of all people to self-determination and non- discrimination, to freely choose and accept work, to enjoy just and favorable conditions of work, including the right to remuneration, and to take part in cultural life. All of these policies and practices I have just described violate the ICESCR as well as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. China is failing to comply with international human rights obligations it freely assumed. There is no question that the U.S. should be doing more to help the Uyghur people. In April, Senator Rubio and I, and over 40 Members called for Global Magnitsky sanctions against Chen Quanguo, the Xinjiang Communist Party Secretary, as well as Chinese officials and companies complicit in gross violations of human rights. And last week, we expressed support when the Administration added 28 Chinese companies to the Entity List and applied visa restrictions on some Chinese officials. Right now, there are important bills in Congress that should pass including the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act, sponsored by Senator Rubio, Representative Suozzi, and Representative Chris Smith, and the Uighur Intervention and Global Humanitarian Unified Response Act, sponsored by Chairman Brad Sherman. I look forward to hearing any and all recommendations about what more can and should be done, including whether it is feasible for companies to conduct reliable inspections and audits of supply chains in the region. Congress stands in solidarity with the Uyghur people, and we want to do all we can to support the full exercise of their human rights. Finally, before I begin, I would like to recognize Nury Teyip, who is here with us today. His brother, Tashpolat Teyip, was the president of Xinjiang University and is a renowned scholar. Tashpolat Teyip was disappeared in March 2017 and was sentenced to death with a two-year reprieve. Last month, we learned from Amnesty International that he may have been executed. I condemn his detention in the strongest possible terms and call on the Chinese government to release him immediately. Having said that, I'm now happy to yield to the Co-chair of the Commission, Senator Rubio, for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARCO RUBIO, A U.S. SENATOR FROM FLORIDA AND CO-CHAIR, CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is an important hearing. Thank you for convening it. It is also timely. I want to thank all of our witnesses. Your research and your advocacy have done a lot to inform us and the world about what's happening--the atrocities being committed in the Xinjiang region by the Chinese Communist Party. Through the decades, the crimes of the Chinese Communist Party have been as consistent as they have been egregious. Yet somehow, these tyrants maintain the ability to shock the world even further with their cruelty and their callousness. The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region in the last two years has experienced the classic forms of Communist totalitarianism combined with the application now of new and advanced technologies. The difference between the Chinese Communist Party's crimes of the past and those of the present is the motivation. The past was about power alone. The present is now about power, but also about profit. Chairman Xi Jinping and his henchman, Chen Quanguo--who, by the way, used to oversee Chinese brutality and repression inside Tibet, so he's a specialist at this--revived collectivization to force Uyghurs into the harness of the Chinese Communist party-state. Just as collectivization created famines that harmed millions in China, this new effort is blazing a trail of human suffering. The problem goes much deeper than simply one million or more Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities detained and forced to work in what can only be called concentration camps. For those able to escape the camps, they face the full power of the Chinese party-state mobilized against them and their families inside and outside of China. Hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Uyghur men and women have been forced to go through a regimen of military discipline and political reeducation in preparation to take jobs in satellite factories. The Chinese Communist government offers incentives for Chinese companies to exploit this labor as the cost of doing business in coastal provinces rises. And what of the families, the children, and the elderly? They're removed from their family's care so the adults can work in the factories. Instead of the warm embrace of their families, the young and the elderly are forced into the stifling custody of the Chinese Communist Party. For the children, this means the loss of their language, their culture, their faith, their heritage. For the elderly, this means loneliness and isolation in their final years. Their children and grandchildren will never hear the stories of lives well lived, of hardships conquered, or the importance of faith and values in a brutal communist-governed world. Today's hearing, however, is not about this alone. It is about understanding how the Party integrates labor and social control, and the national security and moral risks for individuals and companies that deal with China. The network of detention facilities and factories has turned Xinjiang into a forced labor camp roughly the size of the states of California, Montana, Texas, and Florida combined. Millions of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim ethnic minorities labor in textile and light manufacturing and are prohibited from practicing their faith. Simply put, this is slavery--the slavery of socialism with Chinese characteristics. Earlier this month the Trump Administration announced sanctions, as the Chairman said, targeting Chinese officials as well as governmental and commercial entities for these severe human rights abuses, and I believe that these also constitute crimes against humanity. We all welcome these steps. We also believe more can and should be done to resolve one of the world's greatest ongoing tragedies and to hold its perpetrators accountable. I hope the House will soon pass S. 178, the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act that the Senate passed last month. The bill would require the Administration to gather information about the situation in Xinjiang and China's efforts to suppress international awareness of it. China's efforts to silence Uyghurs and turn the world's attention away from the ongoing atrocities in Xinjiang have included the coercion and the intimidation of American citizens and residents here and abroad. This is an outrage that must be addressed. The U.S. Government needs to do its part to ensure that Americans and the world are aware of what the Chinese government is doing in Xinjiang and have the freedom to express their views. Despite the efforts of our witnesses today, Americans--and American companies in particular--are all too unaware of what is taking place. For example, the National Basketball Association maintains a residential training camp in Xinjiang, seemingly oblivious to the contradiction between speaking out about societal issues here at home, which they have the full freedom to do, yet staying silent about China's oppression. Only after the U.S. Commerce Department added the Chinese artificial intelligence company SenseTime to the Entity List last week for its role in facilitating all of these crimes did MIT begin to review its relationship with the firm. So it's long overdue for Americans and important institutions in academia and the private sector to wake up and fully realize the real risks of doing business with China. So I thank all of you again for being here today. I thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I look forward to the discussion. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. I yield briefly to any of my colleagues who want to make an opening statement. Mr. Smith. STATEMENT OF HON. CHRIS SMITH, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM NEW JERSEY Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, for the past two years the Commission has shined a bright light on the massive, outrageous human rights abuses occurring in the Xinjiang region of China. To that end, I, joined by my good friend Tom Suozzi, introduced the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act of 2019, H.R. 649, with 110 cosponsors, and the companion bill, as Senator Rubio has pointed out, has already passed the Senate. So I hope we take that up immediately. We have used our congressional platform to advocate for action on this Commission and to hold Chinese businesses and officials accountable for crimes against humanity. I commend the Administration for speaking out about dire human rights abuses over the past year, particularly Secretary Pompeo and Vice President Pence. I also applaud the action taken just last week to restrict visas for certain Chinese officials and to place 28 Chinese governmental bodies and businesses on the Commerce Department's Entity List. Of course more needs to be done. We should also be looking really aggressively at using Magnitsky sanctions against individuals because this is absolutely outrageous. As a matter of fact, we talk about crimes against humanity--this is genocide. They are trying to destroy the Muslim Uyghurs--they being the Chinese dictatorship--and the world needs to do far more than we have done to date. The world cannot remain silent when the Chinese government conducts a high-tech police state whose goal is the destruction of the entire ethnic minority population. And they are using every means at their disposal to do so. I would point out--we talk about how they are using gulags and forced labor--that has been a staple, as we all know, of the Chinese dictatorship's exploitation for decades. I actually, after Tiananmen Square, joined Frank Wolf. We went and visited Beijing Prison No. 1 where the activists--40 of them that were there that we knew of--they were in Tiananmen Square asking for democracy. They were making jelly shoes and socks in Beijing Prison No. 1 for export. So this is just part of their apparatus that has now gone into hyperdrive, extended to the people of Xinjiang. So we need to speak out. I believe that more countries, especially those with Muslim leaders, need to speak out more aggressively than they have. The OIC has done some, but it needs to do more. And the world and the U.N., all of us need to coalesce around--this has to stop. This is genocide. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. Senator Young. STATEMENT OF HON. TODD YOUNG, A U.S. SENATOR FROM INDIANA Well, I thank you for holding this hearing. It is important to be here today. This strikes me as modern-day slavery consistent with China's disregard for all manner of human rights; the basic dignity and freedom of all these individuals has been undermined and it appears they are being persecuted, in part, for their faith. It strikes me that the United States is standing up for the Muslim world during this time, which is really important, as we stand up for the freedom of religion of all people. And I think it's a really important time to hold this hearing. So thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will have some more questions later. Chair McGovern. Okay. Thank you very much. Mr. Suozzi. Representative Suozzi. I'll wait. Chair McGovern. All right, well, thank you. And I am now pleased to introduce our esteemed panel of expert witnesses this morning. Adrian Zenz is a nonresident senior fellow in China Studies at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation. Dr. Zenz has done pioneering work documenting the scope of mass internment camps by analyzing Chinese government procurement documents, construction bids, and domestic security budgets. He's also helped document the mass institutionalization of children whose parents have been detained in mass internment camps and the incentives offered to Chinese manufacturers to employ forced labor. Nury Turkel is an attorney and serves as Chair of the Board for the Uyghur Human Rights Project, a research and advocacy organization that he cofounded in 2004. He has published commentaries on policy and legal matters in publications such as the Wall Street Journal and Foreign Policy. Born and raised in Kashgar, Mr. Turkel received his law degree from American University. He is the first U.S.-educated Uyghur lawyer and is a fluent speaker of Uyghur, Chinese, and Turkish. Michael Posner serves as the Jerome Kohlberg Professor of Ethics and Finance at NYU Stern School of Business. He is the director of the Center for Business and Human Rights at the school, the first-ever human rights center at a business school. Prior to joining NYU Stern, Mr. Posner served in the Obama Administration as Assistant Secretary of State for the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor. As a member of the White House Apparel Industry Partnership Taskforce in the mid-90s, he helped found the Fair Labor Association, an organization that brings together corporations, local leaders, universities, and NGOs to promote corporate accountability for working conditions in the apparel industry. Amy Lehr is the director of the Human Rights Initiative at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. Ms. Lehr leads the initiatives work on human rights around the world, with a particular focus on how technology affects human rights and labor rights, and the importance of a values-based foreign policy. Ms. Lehr's core expertise is in the area of business and human rights. She spent a decade in private practice advising companies and international institutions on how they can respect human rights in their global operations. Previously, she served as legal adviser to John Ruggie, U.N. Special Representative for Business and Human Rights, and in that role helped develop the U.N. Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Thank you all for being here. Dr. Zenz, we will begin with you. STATEMENT OF ADRIAN ZENZ, NON-RESIDENT SENIOR FELLOW IN CHINA STUDIES AT THE VICTIMS OF COMMUNISM MEMORIAL FOUNDATION AND AUTHOR OF ``BEYOND THE CAMPS: BEIJING'S GRAND SCHEME OF FORCED LABOR, POVERTY ALLEVIATION AND SOCIAL CONTROL IN XINJIANG'' Salaam, and thank you for having me today. In 2017, China's Xinjiang region embarked on probably the largest incarceration of an ethno-religious minority since the Holocaust. Despite international criticism, Beijing has persisted in this campaign. The reason for this is now clear. All along there was a long-term strategy behind it. What I am presenting today is in a number of ways more shocking than the reeducation campaign itself. It is more long- term, more all-encompassing, more intrusive, and more devious. Within this grand scheme, the camps only represent one piece of an entire puzzle. Beijing's long-term strategy in Xinjiang is predicated upon a perverse combination of coercive training and labor, intergenerational separation, and complete control over family units. Much of this is being implemented under the heading and guise of poverty alleviation. In my research I've identified three schemes by which the state seeks to place the vast majority of minority adults into different forms of coercive, or at least involuntary, labor. Flow one pertains to persons in vocational training internment camps. Camp detainees can end up in factories on internment camp compounds, in industrial parks, which can be located near camps or the camps in them, or village satellite factories. The employing companies receive an 1800 Chinese yuan state subsidy for each internment camp laborer they train, 5000 yuan for each they employ, and a shipping cost subsidy of 4 percent of their sales volume. In 2018, Huafu Corporation, which operates the world's largest dyed yarn production in Xinjiang, received half a billion Chinese yuan, or US$71 million in subsidies from the Xinjiang government. This means that Beijing is now turning its internment campaign into a business of oppression where participating companies benefit not only from huge government subsidies but also from cheap minority labor. As a result, they will be able to undercut global prices and turn Made in Xinjiang into a multi-billion-dollar business model. In one document, a company was promised the free use of factories. The government paid for two-thirds of the upfront investment cost and provided 500 internment camp laborers with accompanying police guards. The factories came with security equipment pre-installed and are being run in a semi-military style management fashion. In 2018, several Uyghur counties established large factory compounds explicitly designed to employ internment camp labor. One county alone commissioned a factory park with 335,000 square feet of floor space to be constructed directly on an internment camp compound, providing forced labor for 1,560 camp detainees. Flow two in this scheme pertains to a vast government scheme that puts hundreds of thousands of so-called rural surplus laborers into centralized training lasting between one and three months, involving one month of military drill in order to produce standardized behavior, one month of political thought indoctrination, and one month of vocational skills training. Workers are then sent off to their new work destination in large groups and live in factory dormitories, often far from home. This process might not be as coercive as internment camp labor, but it shares many similar features indicating a high degree of coercion. Flow three places rural Uyghur women into village factories equipped with nurseries for infants as young as a few months old. Uyghur women are traditionally resistant to full-time work because they care for the elderly and children. Government village work teams have been working overtime to ``convince'' these women and their parents of the benefits of full-time factory labor. Government documents note that factory work transforms women away from traditional customs and backward thinking and propels them into modernity. One propaganda text on Uyghur women in a textile factory states that the process of de-extremification causes minority workers to become ``born again.'' The Chinese term used here for ``born again'' is the same as in a Chinese Bible where Jesus says you must be born again. Forced labor is equated with salvation. A particular concern is that all of these labor flows are mixing beyond recognition. Graduates from internment camps now work alongside workers from flows two and three. Products made by any combination of these workers are then either directly exported or shipped to eastern China, but then may form components of products, or be repackaged, relabeled, and then exported. As a result, many or most products made in China that rely at least in part on low-skilled labor-intensive manufacturing can contain elements of involuntary ethnic minority labor from Xinjiang. My findings call for a global investigation of supply chains involving any Chinese products or product components. The burden of proof should be shifted onto the Chinese companies. By declaring any low-skilled labor-intensive item manufactured in Xinjiang as potentially tainted with some form of coercive minority labor, Chinese companies that seek to export such products to the United States should conclusively prove that these products have no connection to Xinjiang. If they do, then relevant research teams must be permitted to conduct full and randomized authentic due-diligence audits in Xinjiang's factories, villages, and internment camps. Thank you. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. Mr. Turkel. STATEMENT OF NURY TURKEL, WASHINGTON-BASED ATTORNEY AND CO- FOUNDER AND CHAIR OF THE BOARD, UYGHUR HUMAN RIGHTS PROJECT Thank you, Chairman McGovern. Thank you, Co-chair Rubio, and thanks to the other members of the Commission for directing the attention of Congress to the abominable crimes committed against Uyghur people in East Turkestan that China calls Xinjiang. Even as we speak, these crimes are tainting American consumer products. I'm here to urge Congress to strong action to end the unwitting complicity of the American public and to create a legislative mandate for a much stronger U.S. Government response to the ongoing Uyghur crisis by passing the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act without further delay. Forced labor is a deeply embedded tool of repression, punishment, and control in China. Over a decade ago in 2008, the Uyghur Human Rights Project reported on the systematic program of coercive labor transfer that targeted young Uyghur women to be sent to factories in coastal Chinese provinces. The authorities used a combination of deception, pressure, and threats to round up thousands of young Uyghurs against their will. These programs had the dual effect of separating families and placing Uyghurs in involuntary factory settings far from home. Today we are seeing a convergence of the Strike Hard campaign of mass internment with the pre-existing state plan to relocate the textile industry to the Uyghur region. As documented in the recently published report by Citizen Power for China, new subsidies encourage companies to shift factories to the region. Government documents outline a plan to have at least a million textile industry jobs in the region by 2023. The manager of a factory known to use detained-labor camps stated in a TV interview: ``With the support of the government we have already recruited more than 600 people. We plan to reach 1,000 workers by the end of this year. We plan to provide jobs to 1,500 people by the end of 2019.'' One of those workers reported that she got paid less than half of the minimum wage. She was also not allowed to leave and continued to endure forced indoctrination and was threatened with being sent back to the camp if she refused to sign a contract. We want to thank CBP for its October 7th withhold release order on goods produced by Hetian Taida in a factory in the Hetian Taida vocational education training center. But it's extremely disturbing that U.S. companies were still sourcing from the company until then. Two weeks ago, baby clothes produced by Hetian Taida were on the shelves at Costco. The company has now pulled these products, but it is hard to understand how the goods got to the store shelves in the first place given how long this information has been public. But it is not just Hetian Taida. U.S. enforcement must step up the pressure so that all goods sourced from the companies in the Uyghur region receive scrutiny commensurate with the extremely high risk of forced labor in the supply chain. Asphyxiating social control facilitates forced and involuntary labor. The techno-totalitarian system of surveillance and intimidation put in place by Xinjiang authorities means that any attempt to resist orders puts one and one's family at great risk. As in the case of the 2008 labor transfer program to the eastern factories, many Uyghurs are currently being forced to work in factories under the so- called poverty alleviation program. Uyghurs don't have a choice. Refusing to participate in these programs could result in being sent to the camps. This is the same dynamic as in the state program encouraging marriage between ethnic Han Chinese men and Uyghur women, which is promoted and celebrated in the state media outlet. Uyghur women consenting to these marriages must be assumed in the vast majority of cases to have consented under extreme duress. If a young Uyghur woman were to decline a marriage proposal from a Han Chinese man, she and her family could be labeled as extremists and sent to the camps. Uyghurs cannot say no. As a Uyghur individual living overseas recently described to the BBC, there is an atmosphere of horror: ``Everyone feels like they are being watched all the time. There is a huge sense of fear. People tell me they sleep in their clothes because no one knows whether at night they might be taken away.'' Uyghurs outside of China are also subject to extraterritorial surveillance and coercion. Our latest report on this issue documents these ongoing and flagrant violations of federal law on U.S. soil. As one Uyghur American said about being contacted by Chinese state secret agents, ``They are telling us, `We are watching you. Wherever you go, you are still Chinese.' Even though you are outside of China, it does not mean that they can't do something to you, because they have your friends, children, parents and relatives.'' Agents of foreign powers are surveilling and terrorizing our own fellow American citizens with threats to send their remaining family members to the camps if they speak out about what is happening in their homeland. Given this system of intimidation and terror both inside and outside of China, corporate supply chain due diligence is impossible. The complete secrecy surrounding the camps and horrific means of total control that is hanging over those who are not in the camps means that the free flow of information has been cut off to an extent rarely seen in modern times. No independent auditor or supply chain certification process can collect reliable information from workers, factory management, and local government. No interviews can be treated as uncoerced. Because due diligence is impossible, no company can provide assurance that products sourced in the Uyghur region qualify for legal import into the United States or any country that bans the import of forced labor products. If existing legal authorities are insufficient for Customs and Border Protection to issue withhold release orders commensurate with the risk of allowing illegal goods into the United States, Congress must act to shift the burden of proof to the companies that wish to import products sourced in Xinjiang or that were produced with Xinjiang-sourced cotton. I have some additional recommendations that I would like to share with you when time permits. Thank you very much. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. [The prepared statement of Mr. Turkel appears in the Appendix.] Chair McGovern. Mr. Posner. STATEMENT OF MICHAEL POSNER, JEROME KOHLBERG PROFESSOR OF ETHICS AND FINANCE AND DIRECTOR OF THE CENTER FOR BUSINESS AND HUMAN RIGHTS AT NYU'S STERN SCHOOL OF BUSINESS Thank you, Chairman McGovern, Chairman Rubio. I want to first thank you, especially, and Congressman Smith, for the leadership you've displayed on human rights over the years. When I was in the government, I was called quite frequently to come to various places in Congress to defend things that we were doing. We needed prodding then and it was really, to me, a welcome opportunity to come up here, but not everybody in the State Department or the Government views congressional appearances as their favorite pastime. This is a particularly important moment for you to be continuing to lead, and especially on this issue. All of you in your opening statements laid out the various things that you have done--you, Senator Rubio, and the Senate passing the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act, and Congressman McGovern and Smith, what you've done, what you are doing now in getting the House to pass a comparable or different bill that deals with some restrictions, especially on technology. It's really important that you keep doing that. And I think the recent actions by the Administration, adding the 28 organizations to the Entity List, the October Customs and Border withhold release orders, and the identification-- although without names--of individuals for visa restrictions. None of that would have happened if Congress hadn't been on the ball. And there's more that the Administration can do. You have mentioned the Magnitsky Act as one example. We need to name names. We need to not only pass laws, but we need to implement them and implement those regulations so that companies that are doing business, and entities, leaders in that area really feel the bite. So I just urge you to continue what you are doing. I want to say just a couple of words about what the Administration's done. I am often critical of the Administration, and this is an area where I think Secretary Pompeo and Deputy Sullivan have spoken out forcefully and said the right things consistently, including at the U.N. General Assembly last month. Their words are clear. They are clearly concerned about what's happening in Xinjiang. But their words are undermined by the ambivalence of the Administration, and frankly, it starts at the top. The President himself has been unable or unwilling to speak out forcefully about human rights in China. And it's part of a broader pattern. At the Group of Seven meeting last month, Trump referred to Egyptian President el-Sisi as ``my favorite dictator.'' In a bilateral meeting, he called him a real leader who's done some things that are absolutely amazing. He called the Saudi Crown Prince bin Salman a friend, saying he's done a spectacular job. He has pledged complete support for Brazilian President Bolsonaro, saying he's done a great job for the people of Brazil in all respects. He has praised Vladimir Putin as a terrific person. The list goes on and on. And it's not surprising then, that in August, when he was asked about what was happening in Hong Kong, he said the people of Hong Kong and China are going to have to deal with that themselves; they don't need any advice. With due respect, they do need advice. They need support. They need help. People who are suffering human rights violations in China need our leadership and that leadership has not been forthcoming. I will give you one quick example. At the UN Human Rights Council, which we withdrew from, 22 mostly Western European governments together called on the Council to condemn what's happening with the Uyghurs in Xinjiang. We weren't there. We did not participate. U.S. leadership is lacking in the world now on these issues at a time when it's more needed than ever. I want to just take my last minute to say a couple of things about the business community. I'm at a business school. Senator Rubio talked briefly about the NBA. What was striking to me last week as the NBA caught itself up in an unnecessary set of confused statements--they were debating whether or not a general manager of a team even had the right to tweet something. They didn't talk about the underlying issue--are human rights and democracy being respected in Hong Kong? We all need--whether on the commercial side, in government, or the private sector or private individuals, we need to recognize that what's happening in Hong Kong, what's happening with the Uyghurs, is of interest and concern to all of us. We need to be straightforward and we need to be stronger. In my written testimony, I talk a lot about surveillance technology, the so-called integrated joint operations platform in Xinjiang, which is probably the most pervasive surveillance program anywhere in the world. A number of American companies have been involved in that as investors--there are some examples in my testimony. I think it is critical now--and this goes back to something Senator Rubio said--it's critical now for the investment community, for the technology community, for universities, to double their efforts to think about what due diligence really means and not involve themselves at all in supporting this Chinese program of surveillance technology that's being misused against this population. Thank you very much. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. [The prepared statement of Mr. Posner appears in the Appendix.] Chair McGovern. Ms. Lehr. STATEMENT OF AMY LEHR, DIRECTOR OF HUMAN RIGHTS INITIATIVE AT THE CENTER FOR STRATEGIC AND INTERNATIONAL STUDIES AND FORMER LEGAL ADVISER TO THE U.N. SPECIAL REPRESENTATIVE ON BUSINESS AND HUMAN RIGHTS Chairman McGovern, Chairman Rubio, and distinguished members of the Commission, thank you for holding a hearing on this important topic and for the opportunity to speak. I've worked in the field of business and human rights for over a decade, which will inform what I say. My program has been focusing on both technology and forced labor in Xinjiang and we issued a report today on forced labor in that region. Can I submit this report for the hearing record? Chair McGovern. Without objection. [The report appears in the Appendix.] Ms. Lehr. Thank you. Forced labor in Xinjiang is unique and it requires novel responses. Normal forced labor involves migrant workers who end up indebted to recruiters and have their passports confiscated, leaving them trapped in a foreign country. In contrast, in Xinjiang, the Chinese state itself is organizing the forced labor. Moreover, it is part of a broader effort to cut minorities off from their culture and religion and increase loyalty to the CCP through detention, reeducation, and work. Forced labor in Xinjiang may indeed rise to the level of a crime against humanity, which I'm happy to expand upon later. At CSIS our research confirmed and expanded on the work of others who have spoken today. Our interviews with ex-detainees confirmed, for example, that in some cases both ex-detainees and the rural poor are being threatened with more detention if they don't accept work assignments. Both groups are also being paid far below the minimum wage in some instances, and the populations of the rural poor and ex-detainees are being mixed in factories. We don't know the exact scale of forced labor in Xinjiang, but there are some indicators. So for example, the government of Kashgar, a region in Xinjiang, stated that it would send 100,000 reeducated individuals to work in factories. That is 20 percent of the entire Uyghur population of Kashgar. Even if the Chinese government does not hit all of its targets, the numbers are likely to be very significant. Because some of the companies potentially involved in forced labor in Xinjiang are linked to global supply chains, action in this area can be part of the solution, although it certainly won't be sufficient. So what are these links? Xinjiang produces 84 percent of China's cotton. A number of large Chinese yarn, textile, and apparel companies operate in Xinjiang, along with many smaller ones. This sector is on the rise because, as others have mentioned, it is being subsidized heavily, including for taking in reeducated workers. In many instances, the companies operating in Xinjiang sell to other enterprises in China that further process textiles or other goods. The U.S. imports over 30 percent of its apparel from China. So it's quite clear that some of Xinjiang's tainted goods are indeed entering our stream of commerce. But when we reviewed import records, less than 1 percent of Chinese shipments arrive directly from Xinjiang to the U.S. So it's a bit complex, the supply chains are. Identifying Chinese suppliers using forced labor in Xinjiang will require new approaches. For example, companies cannot conduct their normal human rights due diligence such as labor audits because it's such a suppressed place. And our labor auditors actually don't have access to the region in many cases now. Very few ex-detainees are willing to speak about their experience because they're being terrorized, even abroad. There are some red flags or indicators of forced labor that can be identified through online research. These include--I'll just give a few examples--hiring through government recruiters, language that mentions employing ethnic minority graduates, or companies that are getting certain kinds of subsidies, for example, for training supplements for factories in Xinjiang, aid to Xinjiang, and so forth. So where does that take us in terms of recommendations? As a starting place, U.S. foreign policy really should embody our values, and we need to respond with an urgency that matches the severity of these abuses. As others have mentioned, the Administration should apply the Magnitsky sanctions and that could be to individuals that are hiding some of these companies, for example. We do know that some of the companies involved in forced labor in Xinjiang have a U.S. presence. And generally, I think the more we can pursue companies directly involved in abuses in Xinjiang, the better. And that wouldn't just be forced labor, but also related to technology and even companies that are building these factories and detention facilities. A federal agency, perhaps the Department of Labor or Department of State, should actually be funded to create a public watchlist of companies in Xinjiang that trigger the red flags we identified that indicate a risk of forced labor. That would help CBP do its job, it would assist with Global Magnitsky designations, and it would also put U.S. companies on formal notice of the risks in their supply chain. CBP's approach will need to reflect--in terms of using the Tariff Act to seize goods that are produced with forced labor abroad--their approach needs to reflect the fact that Xinjiang is a police state. And so they probably are going to need to make some assumptions based on certain of the red flags we identified to enable seizures. Companies have a stand-alone responsibility to respect human rights. So they should be carrying out human rights due diligence on their extended supply chains that come from China. And again, that means not business as usual, but actually much enhanced due diligence that will require new efforts and learning on their part. They could consider a ban on knowingly sourcing Xinjiang cotton as well. That's obviously challenging given the relationship between our economy and the Chinese economy and certain sectors, but it is an option. The U.S. Government itself should adopt our report's recommendations on using red flags and due diligence in their own procurement practices. Our procurement as a government is enormous. And last, I do think it's going to be really critical to work with allies so they adopt similar measures on global supply chains because there's a risk that what we shut out here will simply go, let's say, into Europe. Thank you very much for your time. I welcome your questions. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. [The prepared statement of Ms. Lehr appears in the Appendix.] Chair McGovern. I'm going to yield to Mr. Suozzi first. He is chairing another hearing at the same time as this. So we'll go to him first for any questions. Representative Suozzi. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for your leadership. Thank you, Senator Rubio, for holding this hearing as well. I want to thank my colleague Chris Smith for his longstanding work on human rights issues, and especially for working together with me on the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act of 2019. I want to thank the witnesses for being here today. You see the President on television with the leader of China and it looks kind of like it's just another normal relationship, but there is really something extreme going on that you're educating the public about. And the American people do not realize--despite the reports in major periodicals and reports that you've done and people that pay attention like the people on this Committee--most Americans do not realize what's happening. I sound like a broken record, but most Americans have believed ever since Nixon went to China that the more that China was exposed to the United States of America and the West, that they'd become more like us, that they would adopt our way of life as far as capitalism. They would adopt our way of life as far as democracy and human rights. And obviously that just hasn't happened. And this is one of the most blatant examples of the way that the Chinese Communist Party and government treat the people. It started with the Tibetans, and we see it unfolding in the newspapers and on television in Hong Kong. But this is really one of the grossest examples of human repression that's taking place in the world today. China, as it makes its efforts to become more and more of a global power economically, technologically, militarily, wants to export its way of life to other people. And this is their way of life. This is the way they want to treat their own people. So I want to go to you, Mr. Zenz, where you talked about this as being an economic model. When most of us have looked at this, certainly when I've looked at this, we've thought about it as being a way to promote conformity, to repress people, religious persecution, but you're saying that this is also an economic model. And if you look at the industries that this forced labor is being used for, it's usually low-skilled, standardized mass production. It's not the future of high technology and things like that. This is a way to get cheap labor for standardized mass production. How much of what's going on with the Uyghurs, especially, and the forced labor that's taking place, do you see as being a way to get conformity and repression of a religious minority, and how much of it do you see as being an economic model? I know this is not a precise thing, but is it a 50/50 thing, or is it 80 percent repression and conformity and 20 percent economic model? How do you view that? Mr. Zenz. The primary goal of Beijing in Xinjiang is to secure the long-term power and survival and rule of the Communist Party. For a communist regime, securing power and ideological supremacy through labor is ideologically consistent. It goes hand in hand. I argue that the ideological goals are primary, and the economic goals are secondary. But even so, the economic goals are very important because, as we have seen, economic success is now the main driver of the CCP's power in the world, the reason why China is powerful. And I believe they are extending their business model in Xinjiang; they're killing a whole bunch of birds with one single stone. Representative Suozzi. So when they are using this economic model, I think it's important for us to publicize the fact that--and I was not even aware of the extent of this until I prepared for this hearing--how many American companies are using the products that are being produced from this forced labor in Xinjiang. So we see that there was a Wall Street Journal report back in May of 2019, that supply chains of Adidas, Campbell Soup, Kraft-Heinz company, Coca-Cola, and The Gap, and I see also-- and I don't know where this came from, but it is in some of my materials that I prepared for this--that yarn reportedly entered the supply chain for H&M and Esprit, that there's also supplied clothing for Calvin Klein, Tommy Hilfiger, Nike, Patagonia. Is it even more extensive than the companies that I have mentioned that are using these products that are being produced with forced labor in these internment camps--reeducation camps? Is it even more extensive than the companies that I have mentioned here? Mr. Zenz. Three points on this. The first point is that this is subject to further research because it likely is much more expansive than we all realize. Secondly, Xinjiang produces 84 percent of China's cotton. And China produces more than a quarter of the world's cotton, supplying cotton to Bangladesh, almost half of Bangladesh cotton, etc. Now, we need to establish the exact dynamics of what all is made with forced labor, what is made with involuntary labor. I will give you one example. Hetian Taida--who was just subject to a Customs and Border Protection detention order--days before this detention order came into effect, Hetian Taida shipped 1.2 million items of baby pajamas and baby sleeper blankets with the destination Costco. Costco was going to sell them and put them up on a website until they decided to pull it. I personally went to a Costco in Minnesota and asked about these baby clothes. And they said, yeah, we had them; for some reason we just got an order from management to pull them off the shelves for now. Representative Suozzi. So it's important that we remind people that this is internment. People are being imprisoned. People are being tortured. People are being forced to do things against their religion, and they're trying to benefit from it economically as well. And the work that we are doing is to try and highlight this and have them pay for this economically. Part of their goal is economic. We want to really hurt them in their wallets. There are other things we need to do as well, but the sanctions efforts that we are trying to do to stop these products from coming to the United States of America are also essential. I just want to point out also that China is exporting these practices to other parts of the world, including U.S. soil. And there was a report in March of this year that a jury in Brooklyn convicted the head of a Chinese construction firm for engaging in a conspiracy to provide forced labor of Chinese workers working here in the United States of America where people were working 14-hour days, 7 days a week for several years without receiving any pay, in the United States of America, in Brooklyn. We also have--the U.S. Department of Labor announced that a Chinese construction company owed over $13.9 million to 2,400 workers on the island of Saipan, part of the U.S. Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. The Chinese construction firms hired to build the Imperial Pacific Casino Resort project engaged in reprehensible labor practices. They employed workers who entered Saipan on tourist visas and forced workers to labor for over 12 hours a day with no days off, ignoring federal minimum wage and overtime rules. And there is further ongoing litigation regarding worker safety and forced labor. China's goal is to become the dominant world power. They have a plan to do it. We need to look at what it is they are trying to accomplish. We know how they treat their people already. We know how they treat the Uyghurs. We know how they treated the Tibetans and are treating the Tibetans. We know what's going on in Hong Kong. And they want to export this throughout the world. So I want to thank all of our witnesses today for their excellent work that they've done leading up to this point, the research they've done in helping to highlight this to the American people. And I ask my colleagues here to work with us to try and get our Foreign Affairs Committee to finally put our bill forward on the Uyghurs to get this moving so we can join with the Senate to try and get something passed to help make this happen. Thank you very much to everyone, and Mr. Chairman, thank you so much for allowing me to go. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. Senator Rubio. Co-chair Rubio. Thank you very much. I appreciate it. Mr. Turkel, let me ask you this. It's clear from your testimony that the horrific situation that Uyghurs are facing, they're facing it no matter where they live, as their relatives at home in the Uyghur region are either swept into the camps or live in an atmosphere of constant and pervasive fear. As a Uyghur American yourself, if you feel comfortable speaking about this, can you tell us a little bit about how all of this has affected your family personally? Mr. Turkel. Thank you. Before I answer your question, I would like to ask the Chairman for permission to enter these two reports into the record. One is by my organization profiling China's harassment activities, coercive activities. And the second one is about labor, issued by a Chinese sister organization. Chair McGovern. Without objection. [The reports appear in the Appendix.] Mr. Turkel. Thank you very much. First of all, Senator Rubio, I would like to thank you for writing a letter early on to our ambassador, Ambassador Max Baucus, to ask for his help to help assist my parents. Two things that I thought I was over with--especially after I arrived in the United States and became a U.S. citizen. One, I would never talk about my past history being born in a reeducation camp. Forty-odd years later, we're talking about similar circumstances. And then, two, I thought after becoming a U.S. citizen and licensed to practice in the United States, I should be able to speak my mind. That is not happening to the full extent. The last time I saw my mother was when she was here in 2004 for my law school graduation. With all the efforts, including Mr. Posner here, we have not made any progress. My father is 80 years old. Mom is 68. I do not think that I will ever see them again unless the Chinese government allows them to spend the rest of their lives here with their three American grandchildren. It's been difficult. It would be disingenuous for me to say that I have a normal life. I don't. I would love to go back to my life two years ago, even though it was sort of a weird, strange, difficult life, but at least I was able to check up with my family members, to say hello, you know, congratulate them on significant dates. Because of this software that the Chinese government forced Uyghurs to install on their phones, the Uyghurs have been disconnected. Even testifying at this hearing may cost the lives of my parents. But, you know, it's the right thing to do. I have to speak out. This helps me to overcome the sense of anxiety, sense of guilt, sense of desperation and despair, because speaking as the voice of the people is very empowering. Co-chair Rubio. And I think anyone who hears your testimony should be troubled. You're a United States citizen. Your children are United States citizens and your family is being directly impacted by the policy decisions, the coercion, the repression of a foreign entity, and it's being applied even here in the United States. When people ask about this issue--first, this is not just about something that's happening in China. It is terrible what has happened over there. It is impacting people that live here, on a regular and daily basis. And it's not just limited, by the way, to people with your background from that region who have a family there or were born there. As we saw last week, the NBA has learned that you really cannot ignore politics in China if you are doing business with or in China because your business partner is the Chinese Communist Party. In the case of the NBA, their partner is the Ministry of Education. And in the case of these corporations-- and I think this is for the whole panel--the entity in China in charge of joint ventures and foreign companies doing business is the exact same entity that's in charge of standing up these factories in these different operations in this region. If all of you could elaborate, if somebody is listening now, the corporate CEO, members of the board, even prominent shareholders who think that they could somehow make money in China, do business with China, but somehow avoid the political implications and/or witting or unwitting complicity in what's happening--I want to give the panel the opportunity to explain to them why that cannot be the case and why that will get harder and harder both from a realistic perspective--I think, Mr. Turkel, in your testimony you talked about how due diligence is impossible in this region--but even broader that there is no way to escape this. If you're sourcing from there, if you're doing business from there, particularly in the Xinjiang region, you are engaged in not just witting or unwitting complicity in these crimes, but you're engaged in politics whether you like it or not and you're now forced to make this decision between billions of dollars in revenue or speaking out and losing it. Mr. Zenz. I would say something right away. I would like to support your point, Mr. Rubio, with one further important aspect that you will find in my written testimony. The links between Xinjiang and eastern China are growing stronger by the day. So even if a company is doing business with an eastern Chinese corporation in China or outside of China, because of the mutual pairing assistance scheme by which 19 cities and provinces including Beijing, Shanghai, Guangdong, and others, the biggest ones, the biggest business players, are mutually linked with mostly Uyghur minority regions in Xinjiang, especially southern Xinjiang. And by design and default, they're investing billions in the development of Xinjiang's minority regions. Now, this development, especially in the past years, has been predominantly to support the very business models that I've testified about, the three flows of labor. I have hard evidence that mutual pairing assistance monies have directly funded internment camp labor by constructing factories on the grounds of internment camps or right next to them, expressly designated by government documents to employ internment camp workers. And these links mean that China's entire domestic supply chain is becoming tainted. The implications of that heavily underscore the very point that you have made, that doing business with China is not only a problem because the CCP and Beijing dictate what you can say publicly or not say about anything that they care about, but also because doing business even in eastern China is now increasingly impossible without in some way participating or supporting the repression in Xinjiang. Co-chair Rubio. If I can paraphrase, what you're basically saying is there is not a single American today that has not either worn clothes or used a tech device that is either funded or has been directly created by forced labor in China. Mr. Zenz. This is the trend because as we speak, it's Beijing's policy to turn Xinjiang into the cheap manufacturing hub of the Belt and Road. Xinjiang is already the center of the Belt and Road. And this pertains to textiles, also to electronics assembly. It pertains to food products, all kinds of products. This is a long-term strategy, and this is increasing Xinjiang's share in the manufacturing of cheap goods, as we have heard, because of rising labor costs in the east. It is only going to increase its long-term government policy. Mr. Posner. Senator Rubio, just to add one other dimension which I mentioned briefly in my testimony, there are a number of companies now that have been put on this Entity List--28 companies and government institutions. A number of them are private companies that have gotten U.S. investment dollars. And it seems to me one place to start would be to look at--there is a company called Megvii, another called SenseTime. We know that not only are private investment firms, let's say in California, venture firms, investing, but also our public pension funds. In fact, the majority of dollars are coming from public pension, from state university funds. I think one of the ways we can start to look at this is to ask not only who's doing business, who's manufacturing, but who's investing. Here we are talking about firms that are involved in surveillance technology, facial recognition in Xinjiang. They are being supported financially by U.S.-based investors who say, I am not focused on that. We need to focus-- every American business that is connected to that needs to be put on notice that this is now their responsibility as well. Co-chair Rubio. I just have one final question in regard to all this, and I am not claiming this is what is going to happen. I think I know the answer you're going to give me, but I think it's important to have it on the record. How disastrous would it be if we wake up one day six months from now to news that there's some sort of trade deal and as part of this broader economic arrangement we have agreed, in exchange for them buying more stuff from us, to stop doing anything about this, to stop talking about this, to remove companies from the Entity List--in essence, I get asked this all the time--should this be related to the trade talks? My answer has always been you don't want it related to the trade talks because you don't want this to be something that can be bargained away in exchange for more agricultural product purchases or what have you. But how disastrous, how demoralizing would it be on the global stage, not to mention to the character of our nation, if somehow this became one of the items to be negotiated. And I'm not claiming that it is, but certainly trying to be ahead of the curve on this. Mr. Posner. Well, I very much agree with your answer. Ultimately, this is a very important relationship, the U.S. and China. We've got security concerns. We have got economic concerns. We have to make sure that the human rights concerns are not subsumed by those other interests. We have to be principled; we have to stand for our values. And these issues have got to be dealt with on their own terms, and we can't compromise them for other interests. Ms. Lehr. Just to quickly add to that, I also think U.S. leadership is so important because if we back off, especially on the technology side--we know that these technologies are being exported to other countries. And so when you just think about the world we want to live in and the role of democracy, it is just incredibly important. So maintaining a focus on human rights regardless of what happens with trade is vital. Co-chair Rubio. Just a final point that I would make, as my time is up. Although the clock keeps jumping around here somehow. I don't know, it's magical. [Laughter.] Co-chair Rubio. But it is a home field advantage, I think. Chair McGovern. We are very liberal. Co-chair Rubio. The point I want to make, and just in the broader sense of it, the morality of this is clear. I think our national security and national interest in being outspoken and active on this is clear. I would just add, just if you purely analyze this from a trade and economic perspective, how can you fairly compete? You are talking about outsourcing. How could you fairly compete with a nation who produces basically free labor, compelled free labor competing with your workers and your industries? So it's wrong morally. It's outrageous, but it is also, I think, the ultimate violation of any sort of trade agreement you could possibly have that would be fair and balanced between two countries. So anyway, the more you learn about this, the more outrageous it is. It really is. But thank you all for being here. Chair McGovern. Thank you. Before I yield to Representative Smith for his questions, I just have a quick question. It was reported this morning that Cotton On and Target Australia have stopped sourcing cotton from Xinjiang due to the concerns about forced labor and human rights abuses. And so I am just sitting here listening, as we all are, to the expert testimony here today on the widespread use of forced labor in Xinjiang and the difficulties in determining whether or not a particular factory is using forced labor. I've met with American businesses. We've had these conversations and they tell me they have complied with all the rules and regulations that we have required of them and they check all the boxes. But yet I don't really feel reassured that they know for certain that they're not sourcing from places that use forced labor. I just want to ask; do you believe that the U.S. should ban all imports from Xinjiang? Ms. Lehr. I think that's a hard question. In terms of potentially CBP having a WRO that bans all products or all cotton from Xinjiang, it would obviously have significant, immediate economic repercussions. And I think the challenge may be--I think there's a problem with companies; Costco, for example, is quite powerful--where they really should have known. There are situations where things will be many layers away in the supply chain and companies may incidentally and unknowingly still source. So it's never going to be a perfect system. And I think the question is, just what's the fastest way to get us somewhere that puts pressure on the Chinese government? So bans are one approach. Another approach would be to start putting major, some of the larger Chinese companies, on some kind of watchlist. It is going to cause them specifically to feel pain. So a lot of the companies in the pairing program that Adrian talked about would probably make it onto that watchlist. And if anyone's going to--to the extent you can put any leverage on the government, it would be them. They are big enough to do it. So I think there are different potential approaches. Chair McGovern. And I ask the question because based on some of the conversations I have had with U.S. businesses, again, they can check a box, but I don't really feel that they are trying hard enough to determine whether or not forced labor is part of what they are producing. I just throw that out there based on the news this morning. Mr. Posner, do you------ Ms. Lehr. Could I just say very quickly--sorry, Mike. Yeah, I think they need to really step up what they are doing. The normal way that companies try to figure out if they have forced labor in their supply chain doesn't work in Xinjiang. They have got to change how they are doing it to be taken seriously. Chair McGovern. I guess my point is that we can lecture, and we can urge, and we can tell them to do this, I just don't really feel that they are. Mr. Posner. Mr. Posner. Yes, I was just going to add--I think one of the advantages, one of the benefits of the Senate bill, the passed bill, the Human Rights Policy Act, is that it requires the U.S. Government to report more fulsomely on what's going on. And one of the things that they should and can be looking at much more ambitiously is the use of forced and slave labor. And to the extent that they make that link to companies in the United States, that's the place to start. And my sense is we need to shift the burden of proof. We need to say, if you know that things are being produced with forced labor in Xinjiang, then companies need to be absolutely sure that their products are not being produced there. We need to make it easier to connect those dots so that companies feel the obligation--American companies and others-- not to do business. Chair McGovern. Mr. Turkel. Mr. Turkel. Yes. I would say in one word, yes. That is necessary. We should also encourage other countries, our trade partners, to take a similar measure. This has to be a global effort. I applaud the Australian government for taking this step yesterday with those companies. They are even looking at others, such as H&M and other importers to implement similar policies. Chair McGovern. Mr. Zenz. Mr. Zenz. Yes, I think at a minimum the burden of proof should be shifted to the companies. That's a step that should be done. So there should be much more restrictive practice. But I actually do believe that a general ban on low- skilled, high-labor-intensive manufacturing items from Xinjiang is actually not unfeasible. It can be done because we have such policy evidence, and we can continue to work on it, but we have such evidence that this is a systematic policy. In relation to the mutual pairing assistance, we have evidence of the funding being put into it. We have evidence on enough levels. I think this would send a much stronger message to Beijing than anything else, including visa bans on Chen Quanguo, or policy acts, travel bans, etc. I think this would be the thing to look into and I think it can be done if done properly. Mr. Turkel. Can I add one more quick point? We have been looking at very different ways to address the humanitarian crisis and to force the Chinese government to change its behavior. This is one of the ways that they may possibly change, because the Chinese government has not incurred any cost for their policies. Unless it becomes a very costly operation, I don't think that they will change their behavior. And also by banning everything, we may be able to help manufacturers to start their tooling technician life all over again. Chair McGovern. Yes, I am just curious. Target Australia-- why isn't Target America doing it? It just--in any event, thank you. Mr. Smith. Representative Smith. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you all for your tremendous testimony and your leadership. Secretary Posner, great to see you again. In the 1990s, I held a series of hearings and worked very hard on the whole issue of gulag labor. And George Bush--Herbert Walker that is--and then Bill Clinton--had this weak and inadequate policy of an MOU where they said, Oh, if we suspect something is in violation of the Smoot-Hawley Act and is coming here, prison-made goods, we will then tell the Chinese to investigate. And within a certain time period, they'll give us their answer, and end of story. I went and visited two of the Customs people in Beijing who are in charge of implementing that, and they were like the Maytag repairman. They had no work. They said, Well, we never get anything. We have enabled, perhaps unwittingly over these decades through very feckless and weak policies, the Chinese to exploit. And why would they expect that there would be any real penalty now when the world looks away, including in many cases, the United States. So the gulag labor issue has been with us a long time. It is now being implemented with great, horrific consequences against the Muslim Uyghurs. I say that as some background. But we do have some tools that ought to be more aggressively--hopefully the new bill will, as Secretary Posner said, really increase that scrutiny and require a great deal of application of our laws. The Trafficking Victims Protection Act makes absolutely clear that this is in violation of U.S. law. That ought to be used. Yes, China is already a Tier 3 country, but there's a sanctions regime that has not been imposed. It was not imposed under Obama. It was not imposed because--they were Tier 3 for one year under Obama, and it has not been imposed upon a whole lot of countries. That needs to be brushed off and those sanctions used there. We also need, obviously, to use other tools that are at our disposal. So I say we've got to just end mere words, and rhetoric, and concern, and now use tools, laws that are at our disposal. If any of you could give us best estimates as to how many people are in the Uyghur laogai or gulags? For years, some of you know this. I know, Secretary Posner, that you know this. Since my second term in 1983, I have pushed very hard on the issue of forced abortion and coercive population control in China, which is often implemented in a way--in terms of discovery of pregnancies that were not agreed to by the government, children that were not agreed to by the government--at the factory level. I remember John Avedon wrote a horrific piece about the rape of Tibet and talked about how it was an act of genocide, what they were doing there. When Rebiya Kadeer contacted me about a mother carrying a child, who had been rounded up by three dozen police in Xinjiang, I went to our ambassador. I went to the Chinese ambassadors and said--are you kidding? All those people to destroy one little baby and to exploit that woman? That baby got a reprieve and was born, but the mother was in the hospital being coerced to have an abortion. What happens in the labor camps when a woman is pregnant? Is she forcibly aborted? Does anybody know? Have we been asking those questions as well? So I guess--I have a lot of other questions, but I don't have enough time. If you could speak to some of those issues, if you would? Mr. Zenz. The number of estimated detainees is, of course, of interest and relevant in terms of coercive internment labor. The problem with that is that the internment network is very multi-pronged and much of it is heavy-handed on reeducation. We have indication that one section of detainees is now sentenced to prison terms. Another part is being kept in intensive reeducation because they apparently have not been broken yet, and apparently the ones on their best behavior are being put in vocational training which is largely reeducation. But then eventually--if they are on top behavior, they can graduate. I am actually looking into some of this, so it is a bit premature to give more details. But we are looking at multiple streams and the ones that most comply with the government are being sent into the factories for labor. It's very important to look at all three flows of labor that I've outlined in my research paper because the involuntary or coercive labor issue goes far beyond the reeducation camps. The training of rural surplus laborers, the official policy to set up satellite factories in every other village, in every second village in Xinjiang's minority regions, the co-optation of nearly all adults, including women, into labor, means that we are looking at a scheme--depending on how we define forced labor--if we define forced labor as at least highly involuntary at a minimum, we are talking millions, millions of minority Uyghur and Kazakh adults. If we do it more narrowly as internment camp labor taking place in or near internment camps, we are getting smaller numbers. But the problem is these people are being sent, firstly, apparently, to forced labor right on the camp compounds or nearby in industrial parks, often with police accompaniment. But then after some time if they have behaved well, they can then move on to satellite factories in their own villages or industrial parks. So it is a successive scheme. We cannot only pin this on internment camps or even prison labor, which is also happening. The prison labor is a whole separate thing in itself. We need to track the entire development and related policies, and on a scale of coercion of labor, we are talking about a grand scheme that's encompassing basically almost the entire minority population to an extent, with the exception of the more highly educated; some of them are allowed to just remain in government jobs and whatnot. Mr. Turkel. There're different numbers being put out. The most recent one was by Randall Schriver, the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Indo-Pacific Security Affairs. He stated up to 3 million. Even if it is 1 million or 3 million, that is a significant number. Let's say it's 3 million. That is four times the size of the District of Columbia population. So this city has been four times emptied out. That's the equivalent of that figure put out by the Pentagon. And those people have names, aspirations, and families. So it's easy for us to say 1 million, 3 million, but the entire generation has been wiped out. They have a specific targeted age group, the people born in the 1980s and 90s. And as you may have known, they have been collecting individual information based on travel history, past teaching, like Mr. Teyip's brother, and also a social context. So the artificial intelligence gathered up these people. So when you look at the survivors, when you look at the survivors' testimony or talk to them, some villages are completely emptied out. So the Uyghurs actually think this 3 million figure is a very conservative figure. Ms. Lehr. I wanted to just pick up a little bit on the medical-related issues. We don't have anything very clear, specifically, on forced abortion. We have not heard very much, but we did interview a number of former detainees. And one thing we heard repeatedly that we weren't even looking for was people being subjected to repeated blood tests, repeated medical testing, often quite extensive; women being given shots that they did not really know what they were for, not consensual, which is a violation of international law, medical testing without consent. So I think that's a whole other piece that needs attention, and we just don't have enough yet to know exactly what's going on. Representative Smith. Are there any indications that organs may be--the way they---- Ms. Lehr. You know, there are people who suspect it, but I don't think we have heard anything that we could confirm that with. Nury, do you have anything on that? Mr. Turkel. No. Mr. Posner. Okay. If I understand the slightly broader point, and it goes back to something Senator Rubio said when he asked the question about linking trade. All of the good will and good intentions in this room, both on the part of all of you, and witnesses here, pales in comparison to the direct relationship between our President and Xi Jinping. The Chinese Communist Party is a top-down, centrally controlled apparatus. Xi is both the president of China and the head of the Chinese Communist Party. And so on one level the thing that is the most important is that there be a clear, unequivocal message coming from the top of our own government. That's what would make the greatest difference and it's why I dwelled on it a little bit in my testimony, but there is such an obvious disconnect between what people in the State Department and these other agencies are saying and doing, and what the President is saying. And so again, I know none of you has the ability to control the President's words or actions, but I think we need to keep our eye on that part of the relationship. It's a critical piece. And what happens at the top of the Chinese Communist Party filters down throughout the system. That's where the problem starts and we're not going to really solve this until we have a more clear and unambiguous policy coming from the top. Representative Smith. Thank you. Chair McGovern. Congresswoman Kaptur. Representative Kaptur. Yes, I want to thank our co-chairs this morning for just an excellent hearing and all of those who have come to place on the record your very important information. The word ``communism'' is a very disturbing word to me. I come from a family where two great-uncles--one died in one of Stalin's gulags, and the other was sent to two of them and survived. He got out in 1952 after Stalin's death. So the whole philosophy, Dr. Zenz, that you referenced, work sets you free--whether one looks at the Nazi Party or the Communist Party, this whole idea that somehow forced labor equals salvation, I would be very grateful for any additional information you have from a philosophical standpoint about where this sick idea comes from. That's not really my question this morning, but I think that the Victims of Communism Foundation . . . you are on to something extraordinarily important that I think the new generation needs to learn. In terms of the impact of U.S. business relations with China, I'm wondering if in terms of China's balance of payments with any country in the world, if any of you could state with which nation China has the largest trade surplus. In other words, more purchases from that particular country come from China than China purchases from that country. Could someone state which country purchases more of their goods than any other? Mr. Posner. I don't know the exact numbers, but U.S. imports from China are number one. Representative Kaptur. That is correct, the United States. So if one looks at half a trillion dollars or more of trade deficit annually, we are integrally woven into their practices. I'm wondering, if you look at the purchase of U.S. debt, do any of you know which country purchases the greatest share of U.S. debt? Mr. Turkel. China. I believe it's China. Representative Kaptur. Yes. It's over a trillion dollars, $1.13 trillion. So what China does is integrally woven into the functioning of our society. Mr. Turkel, I will do anything I can to help your family. I am sure every Member up here would. Just know that we stand ready to help families like yours. I welcome you to my district to tell your story. If you're ever flying over Ohio, we would welcome you. Mr. Turkel. Thank you. Representative Kaptur. We have a series we call ``At Freedom's Edge.'' Your family is a living example of it, globally. God bless you and God bless your parents. Mr. Turkel. Thank you. Representative Kaptur. I want to ask our witnesses, in terms of the gulags that you referenced, is there a gender difference? Are there more women working in these zones than men, or is it equal? Does anyone wish to comment on that? Mr. Zenz. Yes, the government has a quota for gender in minority textile manufacturing. And it's supposed to be either 3:7 or 4:7, a ratio in favor of women. You also see that almost all the propaganda accounts in Uyghur textile manufacturing, especially connected to internment camps, show women. Representative Kaptur. Are you saying it is four men to seven women? Is that what you're saying? Mr. Zenz. Yes. Yes, for textiles and manufacturing. Representative Kaptur. Why is that? Mr. Zenz. It is, of course, for traditional reasons because traditionally Uyghur women, minority women, have engaged in traditional forms of cloth making, dress, etc. Representative Kaptur. All right. I am reminded of the Triangle Shirtwaist fire in New York City which spawned the development of what was called the International Ladies Garment Workers Union in our own country, and the struggle that women have had globally, to try to earn a decent living for the work that they do, many in very unsafe conditions and exploitative conditions. I want to ask any of you, what are the average wages? If you were to talk to an average American and just say look, this is what American workers earn, what do Chinese workers earn working in these zones? Ms. Lehr. I can just give you a little anecdotal information about what the minimum wage is and what we are hearing people are actually being paid. The minimum wage in Xinjiang is between 1400 and 1800 yuan per month. But in fact, what we're hearing is that some of both ex-detainees and the rural poor who are part of these poverty alleviation programs are being paid sometimes not at all, sometimes being paid maybe 300 yuan per year. Representative Kaptur. Okay, what does that translate to in U.S. dollars? Ms. Lehr. A couple hundred dollars. The minimum wage should be, I believe--Nury, you will get this more correct than me-- but a couple hundred dollars a month is the minimum wage. Mr. Turkel. That is correct. Ms. Lehr. But what they are actually being paid is just a fraction of that. So people are being paid in a year what they should be paid in a month. Representative Kaptur. We don't even know that? We don't even know what workers work for there? It's that hidden? Ms. Lehr. We know what the official minimum wage is, but there is an official government policy right now with regard to minority labor--that they do not have to be paid it. Representative Kaptur. None of you placed that in your testimony, I don't believe. If you could provide any refinement of that so that the American people could understand what's really going on here, I think that would be quite helpful. I also wanted to ask a question about fentanyl. In my district this past weekend, 26 pounds of fentanyl were collected by the DEA and several individuals were arrested. We know that that comes from China. Have you ever come across this issue in your work, and where that's manufactured and how it gets here? [The witnesses indicated ``no''.] Representative Kaptur No? All right. Thank you very much. That ends my questions, Mr. Chairman. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. Senator Merkley. Senator Merkley. Thank you all for your testimony and to my colleagues from the House and Senate who are paying attention to this issue. Mr. Posner, you mentioned that it would be so important, central, to have a message from the top. And I am concerned that we haven't succeeded in getting President Trump to speak to significant human rights abuses around the world--the ethnic cleansing that occurred in Burma, driving 700,000 Rohingya into the neighboring country of Bangladesh, 300 villages burned down, massive systematic rape, assaults. And in this case--also again a vacuum--and I think that all of us--Democrats, Republicans, House, Senate, need to try to find a way to have President Trump stand up on the international stage on both of these issues. As I was pondering the situation in the province, I was reminded of the movie ``Gattaca'' from 1997. And in that movie, there is a character named Vincent Freeman who because of his DNA is assigned and categorized to be in a class that can only do menial jobs. But he is determined to travel in space. So he goes to extraordinary lengths to, basically, overcome the government's systematic testing of urine and DNA. And this is really before we had the ability to monitor DNA the way that we can now--in 1997, twenty years ago. And now we have this province that has an additional tool that was not even dreamed of in the late 90s, of facial recognition, and Vincent Freeman would have had a very hard time overcoming that additional factor. I am concerned that this model of a government exercising extensive massive surveillance in combination with artificial intelligence, with the data storage capabilities that exist at this moment--let alone what is to come--is a tool that is very difficult for governments to perhaps resist. We have a case of our own government just saying that they want to take a DNA record of every immigrant to the United States of America. And so you can see that we're not immune from the collection of massive amounts of personally identifying data that could be used in all kinds of ways. As we're listening to you, I'm sensing that we don't have one clear path to be able to exercise more leverage. One of the issues that has come up is how difficult it is for U.S. companies to track where the products are originating, and getting more difficult all the time, it sounds like. How can we take that on? And if all of you can follow up with all of us, we can think about what we can do legislatively. Senator Rubio led a bill, the Uyghur Human Rights Act, that passed on September 11th. It has a series of reports and strategies in it. It has an amendment that I submitted that called for--unless international monitors are allowed access, it would trigger the Global Magnitsky Act. I don't know where this stands in the House and if the House is prepared to take it up. Chair McGovern. We're working on it. Senator Merkley. Great. That is terrific to hear because at least that would be one tool to draw attention to this situation. And I think as a result of the Senate examining this, the U.S. Government, the executive branch, has now taken action on October 7th and October 8th. On October 7th, they set a series of export restrictions on certain products to a host of provinces in China that could be used in surveillance and so forth. On October 8th, they put in visa restrictions on officials who are complicit in the internment camps, the slave labor, and so forth. I want to ask all of you, do you think there will be any significant impact from the actions taken on October 7th, October 8th? How would you like to see the Uyghur Human Rights Act strengthened in the House, or should we just get the Senate version passed quickly to try to get it to the floor, to get it to the Oval Office and then seek another bill as we understand more and have more defined strategies for applying leverage? Mr. Posner. We had a little bit of discussion of this earlier. I think both the Senate and the House bill have elements that are quite useful. The Senate bill as I understand it is more a reporting requirement for the State Department, which I think is always helpful. But I think the House bill also relates to sourcing restrictions and export controls, especially relating to technology. So elements of both of those, I think, are useful and you ought to be pursuing it. The other thing I said in the opening is that all of those restrictions, while they're very much in the right direction, need to be enforced and that you need to have congressional oversight. The companies that are doing the surveillance you talked about in Xinjiang, in particular, are Chinese companies. Those were put on the list in early October, but they're also getting investment support from American investors. And I think that's a place where there needs to be much more attention. This integrated joint operations platform that the Chinese are operating in Xinjiang is probably the most intrusive surveillance program in the world. And what you mentioned, facial recognition technology, is part of that. It's really important that we pay attention not only to who's doing it, but who's supporting it. One positive thing I would say, we've talked a lot about what companies should be doing. One company that really has taken the issue of facial recognition on in an affirmative way is Microsoft. They even took down a public facial recognition technology they had up, when they realized that it was being misused in China. So there are ways to deal with this, but most companies are not doing what they need to be doing. Mr. Turkel. The Entity List, I think it's very significant. I never thought in my lifetime that I would see a government that would sanction the entire police department in the Uyghur region, which is very significant. And also, it's related to me. That's the police department that has been harassing and intimidating my parents, and that same police department forcibly took my parents' DNA samples in 2015. So on a personal level, it is very gratifying. In substance, as well, it is a very useful step. The visa ban is also a significant step, even though we don't know who the individuals are. As for the bill, I think we should pass a bill for now, and then talk about the other issues, make an amendment or introduce another bill with more teeth. The Uyghur people have been waiting for this body to do something legislatively to force our executive branch to take a coherent policy step. So it is imperative that the pending bill, H.R. 649, be finalized as soon as possible. Mr. Zenz. I would recommend making forced labor a separate issue and bill because it is a really, really big issue even though it's related. I think it's good to pass what you have now, so that that's passed. I really suggest that a separate forced labor bill be introduced because the implications are also, as Mr. Rubio pointed out--there are some very real business implications of making money off of oppression, undercutting prices. I would really suggest that that would really have some teeth to scare the business community, the American business community, the Western business community, to really put sanctions on companies that have dealings with forced labor, and to make that a really strong separate package. That would be my recommendation. Senator Merkley. This makes me think there's a premium on us getting the Senate and House Members together to get a strategy because so often we end up with a bill passed in one chamber and not the other, and nothing makes it to the Oval Office. Certainly I'll make myself available for any discussions of that nature. It was mentioned earlier that China is a Tier 3 country in terms of labor practices, forced labor, and slave labor. That puts it in a small group of very abusive countries, but the real impact of that is related to foreign aid. And we don't send foreign aid to China. So how could we strengthen the Tier 3 consequences in a real substantive way so that it would have an impact on the types of practices we are seeing applied to the Uyghur community? Mr. Posner. Well, again, to me, the biggest issue is enforcement. We had some discussion earlier about Customs and Border Protection issuing withhold release orders on a few companies that were using prison and forced labor in the apparel sector. The enforcement of what comes into the United States has historically been extremely weak. We don't have the resources to get at that. And there's no doubt that there are many, many products coming into the United States that are products of forced labor. So I think part of this is really trying to figure out how we bolster that and make sure that things coming into this country are not the product of the practices that my colleagues have been describing here today. Senator Merkley. Well, we've also heard from all of you on how difficult it is to sort out the sourcing. And we have in Senator Rubio's bill a provision that is trying to open the door to international inspectors. But it makes sense to me that a piece of what we have to do is to greatly increase transparency of the transactions taking place so that we can track the products and apply pressure in appropriate fashion. I want to encourage U.S. companies to do everything they can on their own to understand their sourcing, but if they are buying bulk cotton--it sounds like it's very difficult to determine exactly all the roots of that supply chain. Mr. Turkel. I would like to share a story. Recently an Albanian journalist took a trip as part of the government- sponsored Potemkin village visits. In one of his interviews he asked one of the happy-faced Uyghur minority individuals if she was Muslim. She hesitatingly said that she was not Muslim. With that kind of lack of freedom core circumstance, it is inconceivable that any worker would tell the true side of the story, the real story. So it is impossible. I think that if anyone claims, if any company claims that there is due diligence being done, that is dubious at best. It is impossible to accomplish that goal. Senator Merkley. So even with inspectors or international observers gaining access, that doesn't mean that they can really tell what's going on in terms of testimony from people they are interviewing. Mr. Zenz. The Chinese regime, what we can see from these organized tours to Xinjiang, has now had two years, or a year and a half, to refine their shows--as I would call them-- putting on a show. And these detainees know if they don't play along in the show, they're going to end up in a much worse place than they are. I think it's extremely problematic to conduct any meaningful or reliable due diligence. I would still press for inspections because intelligent people can read between the lines. If you look at the BBC video on the camps, they did a fantastic job and made surprise visits later on and were able to record things spoken about 20, 30 feet away when the minders were chiding the head of the reeducation camp about not having the right answer at the right time. But even so, I think it's much more necessary to look at this from what the government has said on paper. The Xinjiang government has made some very clear statements on paper. These ought to be taken seriously. I am documenting them in my research, and I think it's much more effective to come to the conclusion of declaring Xinjiang an involuntary or coercive labor zone by policy, or similarly, go on that level rather than picking apart production supply chains, try to do investigations. One can do both at the same time. But I would really recommend doing the latter as well, and not just the former. Mr. Turkel. Senator, the issue is much bigger than just the forced labor issue. I think we need to look at a broader industry standard. If you stop this practice in a manufacturing sector--we have--the universities are vulnerable because we already know that one famous U.S. scientist, Professor Kenneth Kidd, assisted the Chinese Public Ministry with DNA sequence sampling technologies. And also, we have the winter Olympics coming up. So this has to be a multifaceted approach. We have to also address the CCP's insecurity. Early on, there was a question about the CCP. To the Chinese Communist Party, the Uyghur identity, the Uyghurs' religious background, in and of itself, is a threat. So they need to get rid of it. So this has to be looked at on multiple fronts. The Australian example, I think, has a lot to do with this Entity List. So whatever happens in Washington on this particular issue has global implications. Senator Merkley. Thank you all. Amy, do you want to comment? Ms. Lehr. I was going to say something on a slightly different topic, which was maybe another point of leverage that I think needs more exploration. The extent to which, maybe less than the forced labor realm, but with technology--maybe some of the large state-owned enterprises that are building some of these detention facilities and factories--are they listed or are their subsidiaries listed in the U.S.? And if they are involved in crimes against humanity, should they be able to be? I just think that's another avenue we might be able to pursue some of this from. Senator Merkley. Thank you. I look forward to having my team work with all of you on strategies that could be effective in increasing our leverage. Thank you. Chair McGovern. Thank you. Congresswoman Hartzler. Representative Hartzler. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thank you to my colleagues for holding this very important hearing. And thank you to each of you for your very, very important work. I share Representative Kaptur's comments, Mr. Turkel, that we stand ready to help you, your family, in any way that we can. I wanted to focus a little bit on Hikvision and Dahua. As you know, these Chinese companies have profited greatly from the surge in Chinese security spending, winning government contracts for large-scale surveillance projects, and they've provided much of the surveillance equipment used by officials to monitor the ethnic minorities in Xinjiang. On October 7th, 2019, the U.S. Department of Commerce, as we've talked about, added 28 organizations located in China to the Entity List which restricts American exports to such organizations. And these companies, including Hikvision and Dahua, were added due to their human rights violations and abuses in China's campaign targeting ethnic minorities. Additionally in last year's National Defense Authorization Act, I included language prohibiting the Federal Government, our Federal Government, and companies that contract with our government, from purchasing Hikvision and Dahua video surveillance equipment. I have an inquiry pending with the GSA now to get a status update on the implementation of this provision. Ms. Lehr, what additional actions should the U.S. Government and American investment firms take to ensure that they do not purchase or sell to, or invest in, companies such as Hikvision and Dahua? Ms. Lehr. Well, I think Mike has touched indirectly on this a number of times. I think there's a lot of work to do--maybe not just in terms of purchasing, but actually who's funding. A lot of these companies are developing this technology, and the role of both venture capital and institutional investors in the U.S.--our pension funds--that are funding their work. And so I haven't thought of exactly the right mechanism to get at that yet, but first of all, just more attention to it. I think what surprised a lot of Americans is how their money is being used. How you get at it legislatively . . . maybe Mike has some ideas. Mr. Posner. Well, actually, in my written testimony I mention an investment firm called AMX which specializes in high-performance computing for deep learning applications, and they've partnered with Hikvision. One of the things I think we have to really look at is who the investment firms are, including the public pension funds, and the university endowments that have a stake in companies like Hikvision and the others that are on this Entity List that just was added to in early October. I think that's really a place we haven't put enough attention. And we also ought to look at university partnerships because some of this technology's being developed in conjunction with U.S. technical experts who are working hand- in-glove with Chinese companies to build surveillance technology, facial recognition, and DNA testing. So there's a lot of work to be done. There's a company called Thermo Fisher, out of Massachusetts, which actually sold DNA sequencers directly to government authorities in Xinjiang for genetic mapping until it was publicly called out earlier this year. They stopped doing it. But how did that happen? What were they thinking? It seems to me we've got a lot of work to do just to map the field of where the investment dollars are going and how they connect to the kinds of surveillance and bad use of technology we have been talking about. Mr. Turkel. Divestment is one of the things that we need to look at. Hikvision makes one-third of the world's security cameras. There have been reports that the American Teachers' Union has invested in some of the technology companies in question. I always emphasize the global effort because the Chinese government already tested out these surveillance technologies by using Uyghur lives in their homeland. And now they're exporting it. The New York Times reported that there are about 18 countries already in the process of adopting Chinese surveillance technology. The question is very simple: What kind of world do we want for the next generation? Are we going to be dealing with this kind of surveillance technology monitoring citizens' activities even if it is the mildest of political opposition? Countries like Venezuela, countries like Sudan, Iran and others have already adopted these technologies. So I think it's a threat to the world that needs to be looked at in a much broader perspective. Representative Hartzler. Are you aware of any efforts at the U.N. to look at this or discuss this? Mr. Posner. Not meaningfully, no. Representative Hartzler. Okay. Anything else you want to say on the pensions investing, other than just that we need to look at it? Do you have a way to go after that? I think that's a very important point from this hearing. It's not just to target and hold companies accountable, but to hold the pension funds and the investors accountable as well, and as you bring up, the universities are complicit in this. Mr. Posner. One of the challenges we have in all of this-- this is what I call the dark side of the moon. We're dealing with a place that has been essentially sealed off from public visibility--independent journalists, diplomats, the U.N. haven't got access. So the first thing is we have got to find ways to get greater insight into what's actually happening there and who's involved. But then when we know, for example, on the issue of surveillance technology or forced labor, I think we need to be educating people in public pension funds, people in university endowment investment offices, and private investment firms. We need to set a new standard that says it's not okay just to say this is one of many things we invest in and we have no idea what they're doing. If it's a company involved in high technology that's being used for surveillance or police enforcement, security enforcement, the presumption ought to be--you've got to be assuming that it's going to be misused in a place like Xinjiang against the Uyghurs. Ms. Lehr. I just want to add one thing. I agree with Mike that this is the dark side of the moon. It is very hard to get firsthand information. But you can get some information. And so I think--one thing in our report is the idea of having someone, maybe more than one person, fluent in written Mandarin who's doing research in the U.S. Government and who can start actually mapping out this world. It takes a lot of work, and resources really need to be devoted to it. And then even without the access to the ground, we can still start to map this world. Representative Hartzler. Okay. I wanted to close--my last question, following up on something that Mr. Smith said too, because I am also deeply concerned about reports of forced abortions, forced use of contraception and sexual violence, targeting the female ethnic minorities in the Xinjiang detention camps. And there was a recent Washington Post article highlighting the story of a woman who had her unborn baby cut out of her body without the use of anesthesia. And there are reports of women being raped by Chinese guards, impregnated, and then forced to undergo an abortion while in prison. This is nothing more than systemic torture. And as a nation that values dignity and human life, we must shed light on and work to stop these egregious acts. You indicated earlier that none of you really have much knowledge about what is happening with these reports of forced abortion, sexual violence. Is there any more light you can shed on this, and could the forced abortion policy and birth control be part of China's plan to keep the ethnic Muslim population down? Is there any documentation that this is part of their official state policy, and what can we do, if anything, additionally, as an international community, to stop China's gross human rights violations? Mr. Turkel. We're speaking about millions of people being taken away, but we only have been able to speak to about five individuals who have been in those camps. At least three of those survivors have been telling us very consistent stories about sexual violence, mysterious pills that they've been given. Last month I was one of the panelists at an event organized by the State Department, and one of my co-panelists who is a camp survivor told us that she no longer can conceive a baby because of what she was given in the prison--and also the Washington Post story that you reported also described very gruesome sexual violence. But historically Uyghur women have been sexual objects for the society. And now forced marriage and other things on top of taking away Uyghur children; every day when you turn on social media you see a Uyghur woman forced to marry a Chinese individual. As you know, there's a large number of Chinese bachelors who are looking for wives, and the Chinese government is providing incentives: housing, cars, and employment, as part of the effort to lure Chinese bachelors to go to the Uyghur region to marry a Uyghur woman. So it sounds like a typical--it fits the definition of cultural genocide. If a regime of government is focusing on your children and your women, I don't think--I am sitting with two lawyers here--it is pretty obvious there's cultural genocide/ethnic cleansing taking place. That, I am pretty comfortable stating. Mr. Zenz. Yes. I would like to add to that. Obviously, this is a very difficult topic to investigate, and official documentation on this is basically nonexistent. However, the evidence coming out of Xinjiang, thankfully, is increasing. Just this morning, I read a new article of testimony by Mrs. Sauytbay, who was a reeducation camp educator--forced to be. She is now in asylum in Stockholm. She has testified before, but I am just reading more detailed testimony of hers that specifically gives more detail on sexual abuse and details a particularly disturbing incident where several hundred reeducation camp detainees were let into the courtyard by the security guards and then one woman was forced to undress and was raped by multiple policemen in front of all of the detainees. And, of course, Mrs. Sauytbay, being the teacher, witnessed this personally. The purpose of this rape was to watch the responses on the faces of the reeducation camp detainees, and those who showed dismay, shock, or looked away were then taken away for further punishment. Those detainees who did not express, or who were expressionless and continued watching this horrific rape were apparently considered as having made progress in their reeducation conversion and were not punished. Representative Hartzler. Unbelievable. Well, we have much work to do. Thank you very much. Chair McGovern. Thank you very much. Senator Daines. Senator Daines. Mr. Chairman, thank you. Some of you might know I spent over half a decade working in China and Guangzhou back in the 90s. Today I am very concerned with the ongoing erosion of human rights across the region--everywhere from Hong Kong to Urumqi. I appreciate the work of this Commission. I believe it's critical that we address these issues going on in Xinjiang and bring more awareness to these forced labor camps, mass internment, and other atrocities going on in the region. The U.S. has been the global leader in human rights, and we must continue to lead. The Trump Administration recently demonstrated leadership with the blacklisting of companies associated with human rights violations in Xinjiang and elsewhere across China. I'm glad we're here today so that Congress can continue to work to stop these ongoing atrocities. Ms. Lehr, the Administration recently took steps to blacklist eight video surveillance and artificial intelligence Chinese companies, including SenseTime and Hikvision, due to their support of human rights violations in Xinjiang. Could you provide additional information about the role that technology plays in human rights suppression in China? Ms. Lehr. That's, obviously, a significant discussion. In Xinjiang, specifically, a lot of the technology is being perfected, so it's almost like a place to experiment and fine- tune technology that's being used for social control. And then I think what we are seeing is how that's going to seep into the rest of China and also be sold to other countries. So the social credit system in the rest of China is sort of nascent still, but it is a way of really tracking people's lives in detail and either providing them with state benefits or denying them. Your ability to travel to another city, for example, could be influenced by who your friends are and whether they're considered problematic, whether you jaywalk. It's a level of potential social control that honestly is hard to get your mind wrapped around, but very significant. And we know, for example, in Xinjiang that people are being tracked for how much gas they're using and whether gas usage changes because that's seen as a signal of something, whether they go in and out of their back door or their front door. It's pervasive in a way that is hard to really fully comprehend. Senator Daines. The Trump Administration has taken steps to blacklist eight of these video surveillance artificial intelligence companies. Are you aware of any other Chinese companies or perhaps key technologies that were not included in this blacklisting that play a critical role in human rights suppression in the region? Maybe said another way, are there any others you would add to that list of eight? Ms. Lehr. Off the top of my head, I don't have those names for you, but there are people who are researching that in a lot of detail who probably could add some names. I imagine that was not all the companies that have been involved in developing this kind of surveillance technology in China. Mike, I know you have been specifically focused on this. Senator Daines. Yes, are there a couple others that the Administration ought to consider? Mr. Posner. Mr. Posner. I don't have a list of others. I would just add to what Amy said, that I think we ought to view what they're doing in Xinjiang under what they call the integrated joint operations platform as a kind of predictor of the future of the social credit index. The government is trying to gather as much personal information--blood type, physical characteristics, and movement as they can. They have made it basically a suspicious activity to use WhatsApp or Viper, which are encrypted. They've said that if you don't carry your phone with you, that in itself is a basis for suspicion and can lead to arrest. So what we're really seeing is a kind of laboratory experiment using the Uyghur population as the test case, or the guinea pigs, to see how much information you can gather as a means of social control. I think this is an area where we ought to be looking and I think, as Amy said, others are trying to figure out who else is involved. But we also ought to figure out which American companies are investing in this vast apparatus. I will say one other thing. It's in my written testimony. There are several places where I think Apple, which is a big American technology company, has done things that I have concerns about. I think they need to adopt a broader human rights policy. One is--through a partnership with a Guizhou cloud/big data company, that company has agreed to store data on servers operated by state-run China Telecom. And I think a company like Apple, a big strong company, needs to be highly careful about who it's partnering with and what their activities are. Senator Daines. I spent 12 years in the cloud computing business. In fact, I ran Asia-Pacific for our company for 5 years. I'd be very concerned about privacy in terms of any data that is stored on servers in China. The words ``due process'' do not always work over there. Mr. Posner. Right. Senator Daines. I want to ask you, Mr. Posner, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has provided some of the strongest support to the Uyghurs at the recent U.N. Council meeting, stating that, ``This is China's attempt to erase its own citizens'' and requesting that countries resist China's demands to repatriate the Uyghurs. How is the rest of the world responding to the U.S. lead in this area and Secretary Pompeo's request for support? Mr. Posner. Senator, in my opening remarks, I gave praise to Secretary Pompeo and also John Sullivan, the deputy, both of whom have been quite outspoken. Sullivan also at the U.N. General Assembly held a session on religious freedom where he went out of his way to talk about Chinese violations. I think consistently the Secretary of State and the deputy have been very strong on this. My concern is--and I expressed it earlier--their words are compromised by the inability or failure of the President to echo a similar line. The notion that, for example, the Chinese and the people in Hong Kong can figure out what to do about Hong Kong. They don't need outside advice. Or the suggestion, which was reported by CNN and others, that he had a conversation with Xi Jinping where he said, while we are negotiating a trade deal, I am not going to talk about Hong Kong. The world looks at the totality, and the President is the primary spokesperson for the United States. And if he's not echoing or even leading in the same direction as Secretary Pompeo, it sends at best a mixed message and it allows somebody like Xi Jinping to say, I'll listen to the guy I am talking to, the President, and I can ignore the rest. So I commend Secretary Pompeo. The challenge now is to get a whole-of-government approach, and it needs to start at the top. Senator Daines. All right. Thank you very much. I am out of time here but thank you. Mr. Chairman, thank you. Chair McGovern. Well, thank you. I appreciate everybody here. I just have one final question. Senator Rubio referenced the whole NBA controversy in the beginning. And as you all know, back in 2016 the NBA worked with a Chinese state- controlled entity to open up the NBA Academy in Xinjiang. To your knowledge has the NBA voiced any concern to their partners over the detention of Uyghur athletes? The reason why I ask is because we know that Chinese authorities detained a 19-year-old Uyghur, a rising soccer star, for 11 months for ``visiting foreign countries after he trained and competed abroad.'' I am not sure what that is all about. They have detained a 24-year-old aspiring professional soccer player. He was detained for being in contact with his cousin who had fled to Turkey. I have been watching this controversy unfold in the news, and I guess the benefit of this controversy coming to the news is that we are now focused on what's happening to the Uyghurs. It shouldn't take that to be able to focus our attention, but nevertheless, do you think the NBA should even be operating a training camp there? If they were here, I'd say, What the hell are you thinking? Are you that tone deaf, or are you so interested in potential markets and making money that you're willing to ignore the mounting evidence, much of which has been made public, about the human rights atrocities going on there? As I mentioned in my opening statement, some have described what is happening there as crimes against humanity. If anybody wants to comment--I just figured I needed to raise it because it's been bugging me. So if anyone wants to comment. Mr. Turkel. Yes. Lebron James said that the Rockets' manager needs education. Actually, he himself needs to be educated about what's happening. Not only the NBA, the other U.S. companies. Mackenzie was holding a summer retreat in my ancestral hometown, Kashgar, last summer. All the media is covering the mass atrocities. So this needs to be looked at in a much broader sense. The NBA is losing its credibility. They have actual leverage. I don't want to get into the history of the NBA, but the NBA is such an important aspect of the Chinese people's daily lives in China. So if they can use that to the benefit of their own presence here in the United States or their image internationally, this can be a very effective tool. Mr. Posner. Just to add really quickly--press reports say 10 percent of the NBA's income is now generated in China. There are 500 million NBA fans in China. They are estimating or projecting that their income will be 20 percent in the next five or ten years. I think for a big company or big entity like the NBA, it's critical not to--we're seeing a new normal where the Chinese government has said, Not only is what we are doing in Xinjiang or with Hong Kong right, but you're not allowed to talk about it. Chair McGovern. Right. Mr. Posner. And the idea that somehow we are debating whether or not a general manager of a team is allowed to issue a seven-word tweet, leaving aside the merits of what he's talking about, means that the goalpost is moving. And I think this bipartisan hearing is so important because we reaffirm the fact that these issues are very serious. They deserve attention and we are, in fact, allowed to debate and discuss them. It's critical for American companies--if they're going to continue to do business in China, they've got to be able to recognize that what their commercial interests are is one thing, but you cannot prevent people from having a discussion about values, about interests, and that's really what the human rights issue is about. Chair McGovern. And we should point out for the record that the controversy was over a tweet about Hong Kong, not even about what was happening in the place where they have their training camp. I don't know if anyone else has anything they want to add to that. Look, I've always felt that while our businesses certainly want to be able to take advantage of the Chinese market, there's benefit to the Chinese government as well to be able to do business with us. And I've always been frustrated by the fact--and this is the latest case--that they felt the need to apologize for a tweet from a general manager about what has been in the international news on a daily basis about what's happening in Hong Kong. And I'll tell you if we can't--Speaker Pelosi always likes to use this line--if we're not willing to speak out about human rights in Xinjiang or in Hong Kong because we're worried about the bottom line or about money, then we really lose the moral authority to speak about human rights anywhere. And I think one of the powerful things about what you heard today is that there is virtual unanimity--Democrats and Republicans, liberals and conservatives and moderates all together--all are horrified by what is happening to the Uyghurs. And there's a determination to do something more than just issue a press release, more than just hold a hearing. You've all come up with the legislation that is now pending in the House--and the House has an obligation to try to move this legislation that the Senate has already passed, that Senator Rubio has championed, as quickly as possible, and other things as well. I thank you all for being here. This has been a very important hearing. With that, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:07 p.m. the hearing was concluded.] ? ======================================================================= A P P E N D I X ======================================================================= Prepared Statements ---------- Prepared Statement of Nury Turkel The human rights and humanitarian crisis taking place in the Uyghur homeland of East Turkistan (designated by the government as the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region) has entered a new phase since CECC's groundbreaking hearing on the crisis in July 2018. It is now clear that Uyghurs and members of other Turkic ethnic groups are not only being detained and tormented with cruel and unusual mistreatment and abuse. They are also being swept into a vast system of forced labor. The extra-legal internment camps are only one piece of this emerging system, which involves prisons and village-based manufacturing as well. It is becoming increasingly hard to ignore the fact that goods manufactured in East Turkistan have a high likelihood of being produced with forced labor. forced labor as a deeply embedded tool of repression, punishment, and control Forced labor is a deeply embedded tool of control in China. A regime of forced labor has become the fulcrum of the CCP's campaign of forced assimilation in East Turkistan. Transforming the population from one largely made up of independent farmers and traders into industrial workers, subject to regimes of surveillance and control in factories far from their hometowns, is a major part of the government's program of ``stability maintenance.'' The link between forced labor and ``re-education'' goes back decades. Despite the fact the government claimed to have abolished the re-education-through-labor or ``laojiao'' system in 2013, extrajudicial detention has continued under different names. East Turkistan has been a particular locus of forced labor since the establishment of the PRC. The Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps (XPCC) is powered by forced labor, serving a function similar to the Soviet Union's gulags. In addition to the XPCC prisons, there is a decades-long history of forced labor in the XUAR prison system, including in textile factories such as the Qixin Garment Company inside the Xinjiang Women's Prison in Urumchi.\1\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Han, Lianchao, August 2019, ``Cotton: the Fabric Full of Lies,'' Citizen Power Initiatives for China. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the Uyghur Autonomous Region, a system of forced agricultural and infrastructure construction labor known as ``Hashar'' was supposedly abolished in 2017, although similar forms of forced labor persist, according to the State Department's 2019 Trafficking in Persons report.\2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ U.S. State Department, June 20, 2019, ``Trafficking in Persons Report June 2019,'' Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons, https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/2019- Trafficking-in-Persons-Report.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Over a decade ago, in 2008, UHRP reported on the systematic program of coercive labor transfer that particularly targeted young women to be sent to factories in coastal Chinese provinces.\3\ Government cadres used a combination of deception, pressure, and threats to round up thousands of young Uyghurs against their will. Then, as now, the program had a dual effect of separating families and placing Uyghurs in involuntary factory settings far from home. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ Uyghur Human Rights Project, February 8, 2008, ``Deception, Pressure, and Threats: The Transfer of Young Uyghur Women to Eastern China,'' http://docs.uyghuramerican.org/ Transfer_Uyghur_woman.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- a long-term state plan to relocate the textile industry in the uyghur region Today, we are seeing a confluence of the ``Strike Hard'' campaign of mass internment with a pre-existing state plan to relocate the textile industry in the Uyghur Region. East Turkistan is the source of over 80% of the total cotton produced in China, and the crop is heavily subsidized.\4\ As documented in the new report on forced labor in the cotton industry, published by Citizen Power for China, since the mid- 2010s, the Chinese government has developed plans to transfer the textile processing on a large scale to the region, including the production of cloth and finished garments. This addresses rising costs in coastal areas for land, electricity, and above all labor, but in addition, new subsidies encourage companies to shift factories to the region. Government documents outline a plan to have at least a million textile industry jobs in the region by 2023.\5\ A disturbing picture is thus emerging of the government pushing companies to use cheap or entirely unpaid Uyghur labor. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ USDA, September 6, 2018, ``China: Cotton and Products Update,'' USDA Foreign Agricultural Service GAIN Report, https:// apps.fas.usda.gov/newgainapi/api/report/downloadreport byfilename?filenameCotton%20and%20Products%20Update_Beijing_China%20%20P eoples%20 Republic%20of_8-30-2018.pdf. \5\ Darren Byler, October 11, 2019, ``How Companies Profit From Forced Labor In Xinjiang,'' Living Otherwise, https:// livingotherwise.com/2019/10/11/how-companies-profit-from-forced-labor- in-xinjiang/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The general manager of a factory known to use detainee labor, speaking in a state TV interview released in December 2018, stated, ``With the support of the government, we have already `recruited' more than 600 people.'' He said that since the founding of the new factory in 2017, ``We have generated more than $6 million in sales. We plan to reach 1,000 workers by the end of this year. We plan to provide jobs to 1,500 people by the end of 2019.'' \6\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ Darren Byler, October 11, 2019 ``How Companies Profit From Forced Labor In Xinjiang,'' Living Otherwise, https:// livingotherwise.com/2019/10/11/how-companies-profit-from-forced-labor- in-xinjiang/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- from camps to factories It is clear that some individuals are being moved from the extra- legal prison camps where the ``de-extremification'' program focused on indoctrination classes, Chinese language, and indefinite detention, to factories. While some factories are inside camp compounds, others are in industrial parks, where individuals are forced to stay in on-site dormitories and allowed to leave for onlyshort periods, if at all. One woman, Dilnur Idris, told her sister in Australia via WeChat that she had been sent from the camps to a factory and forced to work.\7\ Another woman reported being paid less than half the minimum wage, though she received far less due to expenses incurred during her stay. She was not allowed to leave, continued to endure forced indoctrination, and was threatened with being sent back to the camp if she refused to sign a contract.\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ McNeill, Sophie, McGregor, Jeanavive, Griffiths, Meredith, Walsh, Michael, Hui, Echo, Xiao, Bang, July 16, 2019, ``Cotton On and Target investigate suppliers after forced labour of Uyghurs exposed in China's Xinjiang,'' ABC Four Corners, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019- 07-15/uyghur-forced-labour-xinjiang-china/11298750. \8\ Byler, Darren, September 4, 2019, ``How Companies Profit from Forced Labor in Xinjiang,'' SupChina, https://supchina.com/2019/09/04/ how-companies-profit-from-forced-labor-in-xinjiang/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- While some detainees are being ``released'' into another form of captivity in factories, others are being sentenced under absurd charges in secret trials. As of 2017, the region accounted for 21% of arrests despite making up only 1.5% of the population of China.\9\ The already massive prison system is being rapidly expanded, and disturbing reports of large numbers of people being transferred from the camps to prisons are emerging,\10\ including reports of people being sentenced in ``open court sessions'' for infractions inside the camps, such as failure to study well.\11\ The prisons, too, have long been sites of forced labor and given unfair trials, the sentences cannot be considered legitimate. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\ Chinese Human Rights Defenders, 7/25/2018, ``Criminal Arrests in Xinjiang Account for 21% of China's Total in 2017,'' https:// www.nchrd.org/2018/07/criminal-arrests-in-xinjiang-account-for-21-of- chinas-total-in-2017/. \10\ Xinjiang Victims Database, ``List: From prolonged detention to prison, excluding victims from pre-Chen Quanguo period,'' accessed October 9, 2019, https://www.shahit.biz/export.php?list=15. \11\ Bunin, Gene, October 5, 2019, ``From camps to prisons: Xinjiang's next great human rights catastrophe,'' Art of Life in Chinese Central Asia, https://livingotherwise.com/2019/10/05/from- camps-to-prisons-xinjiangs-next-great-human-rights-catastrophe-by-gene- a-bunin/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In December 2018, the Associated Press broke the story that clothing had been exported to the U.S. by a Chinese manufacturer (Hetian Taida), in a factory in the Hotan Vocational Education and Training Center, one of the many detention camps that have been established across East Turkistan.\12\ This clothing was being sold to U.S. supplier Badger Sportswear. Several weeks later, Badger Sportswear announced that it had ceased sourcing from the company and all companies with operations in Xinjiang, but continued to maintain that it was skeptical that the goods had been produced by forced labor. This was despite the fact that the factory and the re-education camp share an address, the fact that satellite imagery confirms that they are in the same compound, and the fact that the man of the company acknowledged that the factory was employing ``trainees'' and was located in the same compound.\13\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\ Kang, Dake, Mendoza, Martha, and Wang, Yanan, December 19, 2018, ``US sportswear traced to factory in China's internment camps,'' Associated Press, https://www.apnews.com/ 99016849cddb4b99a048b863b52c28cb. \13\ Worker's Rights Consortium, June 24, 2019, ``Worker's Rights Consortium Factory Assessment Hetian Taida Apparel Co. Ltd. (China): Findings, Recommendations, and Status,'' https://www.workersrights.org/ wp-content/uploads/2019/06/WRC-Report-on-Hetian-Taida-China-June- 2019.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We wish to thank the CBP for issuing a withhold release order on goods produced by Hetian Taida. However, it is extremely disturbing that U.S. companies are still sourcing from the company despite clear evidence of forced labor. Baby clothes produced by the company recently went on sale at Costco; while Costco has now pulled the goods from their shelves, they should never have gotten that far in the first place, given how long this information has been public. U.S. enforcement must be stepped up to ensure that all goods sourced from companies in the Uyghur Region receive scrutiny commensurate with the extremely high risk of forced labor in the supply chain. asphyxiating social control facilitates forced and involuntary labor Asphyxiating social control facilitates forced and involuntary labor. The techno-totalitarian system of surveillance and intimidation put in place by Xinjiang authorities means that any attempt to resist orders puts oneself and one's family at great risk. Those ``recruited'' directly from their villages into factories cannot be assumed to be working of their own free will. Communist cadres have been sent to Uyghur villages by the tens of thousands. They enter Uyghur households, politically assess them, and push them towards work in the factories in the so-called ``homestay'' program. As in the case of the 2008 labor- transfer program to Eastern factories, Uyghurs do not have a choice. Refusing to participate in the state's ``poverty alleviation'' programs can get one labeled extremist and therefore sent to the camps. The threat is often implicit, but according to some testimonies, it is explicit. \14\ This is the same dynamic as in the state program encouraging marriage between Han men and Uyghur women, celebrated in Party media outlets. Uyghur women's consent to these marriages must be assumed in the vast majority of cases to be given under extreme duress. If a young woman were to decline a marriage proposal from a Han man, she and her family could be labeled ``extremists'' and sent to the camps. Uyghurs cannot say no. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \14\ Sophie McNeill, Jeanavive McGregor, Meredith Griffiths, Michael Walsh, Echo Hui, Bang Xiao, July 16, 2019 ``Cotton On and Target investigate suppliers after forced labour of Uyghurs exposed in China's Xinjiang'' ABC Four Corners https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019- 07-15/uyghur-forced-labour-xinjiang-china/11298750. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- As one Uyghur living overseas described it to the BBC, there is an atmosphere of horror where ``everyone feels like they're being watched all the time . . . There is a huge sense of fear_people tell me they sleep in their clothes because no one knows whether at night they might be taken away.'' \15\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \15\ Andreas Illmer, October 11, 2019, ``Tashpolat Tiyip: The Uighur leading geographer who vanished in China'' BBC News, https:// www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-49956088. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Nor is asphyxiating social control confined to PRC borders. Uyghurs outside China are also subject to extraterritorial surveillance and coercion. UHRP's latest report, Repression Across Borders: the CCP's Illegal Harassment and Coercion of Uyghur Americans, \16\ documents the ongoing and flagrant violations of federal law on U.S. soil. As one Uyghur American said about being contacted by Chinese state security agents: --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \16\ Uyghur Human Rights Project, August 2019 ``Repression Across Borders: The CCP's Illegal Harassment and Coercion of Uyghur Americans'' https://uhrp.org/press-release/new-uyghur-human-rights- project-uhrp-report-details-how-chinese-government-engaged. They are just telling us, ``We are watching you. Wherever you go, still you are a Chinese.'' Even though abroad, it doesn't mean they can't do something to you. Because they have your --------------------------------------------------------------------------- friends, your relatives. Agents of a foreign power are surveilling and terrorizing our own fellow American citizens, with threats to send their remaining family members to the camps if they speak out about what is happening in East Turkistan. due diligence is impossible in the uyghur region Given this system of intimidation and terror, extended not only throughout the Uyghur region and but also abroad, corporate supply- chain due diligence is impossible. The complete secrecy surrounding the camps, and the horrific means of total control hanging over those who are not in the camps, means that the free flow of information has been cut off to an extent rarely seen in modern times. Simply put, it is impossible to conduct normal due diligence to determine whether a particular facility is producing goods with forced labor. No independent auditor or supply-chain certification process can collect reliable information from workers, factory management, or local government. No interviews can be treated as uncoerced. Recall that any Uyghur who departs from the government-dictated script faces a high risk of detention, torture, and possibly death in custody. Because due diligence is impossible, companies cannot carry out their claims to manage their supply chains in accordance with ethical principles. By definition, no company can provide credible assurance that products sourced in Xinjiang qualify for legal import into the United States, or any country that bans the import of forced-labor products. The evidence is now clear that all manufacturing in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region is taking place under inhuman and degrading conditions--under a nightmare totalitarian police state preventing free choice and the free flow of information. If existing authorities are insufficient for Customs and Border Protection to issue Withhold Release Orders (WROs) commensurate with the risk of allowing illegal goods into the U.S., Congress must act to shift the burden of proof to companies that wish to import products sourced in Xinjiang or produced with Xinjiang-sourced cotton. recommendations Recommendations for the U.S. Government: 1. Congress should act urgently to pass the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act, putting in place a legislative mandate for vigorous U.S. Government action to respond to the Uyghur crisis. 2. Congress should ban the importation of cotton, textiles, and garments originating from Xinjiang, until the policies of mass internment and coerced labor recruitment are ended, and the conditions necessary for due diligence have been established, including a free press and unimpeded access for international observers and diplomats. 3. Congress should pass legislation to mandate clearer transparency about suppliers and should publicly disclose to the Securities and Exchange Commission and elsewhere the risk of forced labor in their supply chain, and whether they have taken measures to identify and address forced labor from Xinjiang and China in specifically. 4. The Administration must vigorously enforce international trade standards to address China's unequal subsidies to Xinjiang industries that help fuel the use of forced labor in that region. 5. Congress should increase funding for the Uyghur Service of Radio Free Asia in the FY2020 Foreign Operations Appropriations bill, commensurate with the scale of the crisis, to enable it to carry out adequate investigative journalism and to continue to uncover critical evidence regarding the situation on the ground. 6. The State Department and Department of Education should conduct a thorough review of all educational and cultural exchanges with the People's Republic of China. There should be no government funding of any programs involving the Chinese Ministry of Education as long as the mass internment and unfair trials of intellectuals continue, and should not resume until all educators and students are released and receive reparations. At least 77 Uyghur and Kazakh university instructors and hundreds of students are known to have been disappeared, sentenced, or arbitrarily detained, figures which are just the tip of the iceberg. \17\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \17\ Uyghur Human Rights Project, Oct 22, 2018, ``The Persecution of the Intellectuals in the Uyghur Region: Disappeared Forever?'' https://uhrp.org/press-release/persecution-intellectuals-uyghur-region- disappeared-forever.html and Uyghur Human Rights Project, May 21, 2019, ``UHRP UPDATE: 435 Intellectuals Detained and Disappeared in the Uyghur Homeland'' https://uhrp.org/press-release/uhrp-update-435- intellectuals-detained-and-disappeared-uyghur- homeland.html. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7. USAID's program to support international religious freedom, including the new $25 million fund to protect religious sites, announced by President Trump in September, should include--support for cultural preservation, and research and documentation regarding Uyghur mosques, shrines, and religious libraries. 8. Governments must jointly press for a UN-mandated independent investigation. Most such investigations involve travel to the region where mass atrocities are taking place. This will likely be impossible in the case of the Uyghur Region. In that case, there should be an official investigation even in the absence of access to Xinjiang, and the U.S. should contribute funding to this effort. 9. Governments should continue to make joint statements of condemnation. 10. Governments should jointly impose coordinated sanctions. Sanctions should include visa denials, freezing of assets, a modification of the EU-U.S. Tiananmen sanctions to add additional restrictions, suspension of government funding of educational and research exchanges, and export restrictions on textiles and on high- tech tools for surveillance and racial profiling. 11. The U.S. and like-minded countries should back United Nations action similar to the action on apartheid, including the 1960 Security Council Resolution 134 deploring the policies and actions of the South African government and calling on the government to abandon its policies of apartheid and racial discrimination; the 1963 Resolution 181 calling upon all states to cease the sale and shipment of arms, ammunition and military vehicles to South Africa; and the General Assembly resolution of 1968 requesting that all states and organizations ``suspend cultural, educational, sporting and other exchanges with the racist regime and with organizations or institutions in South Africa which practice apartheid.'' 12. The Red Cross should be mandated to seek access to the camps. There is an urgent need to collect information now so that families can be re-united, before it is too late. 13. The silence of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation must come to an end. To mobilize support for those members of the OIC that are concerned about the Uyghur crisis, the U.S. can conduct bilateral diplomacy and make funding available to NGOs who can translate materials into relevant languages in these countries, bring witnesses, and other focused programming to educate local civil society, religious leaders, parliamentarians, lawyers, andothers. 14. In countries where the government or CCP influence operations have succeeded in suppressing accurate reporting on the Uyghur crisis, the U.S. Government should provide funding to human-rights advocacy organizations to translate the available documentation,including explanation of the satellite evidence, witness testimony, and of the Chinese government's own announced policies, designed to eliminate Islamic practices, force Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims to renounce their faith and denounce Islam, and demolish and desecrate mosques, shrines and cemeteries. 15. Conclusive evidence is rapidly emerging regarding China's continued sourcing of transplant organs from prisoners, including both Uyghur and Falun Gong practitioners, despite the government's continued denials. The China Tribunal, a panel of jurists and medical professionals, led by Sir Geoffrey Nice, Queen's Counsel, issued a major report on June 17,2019. It concluded ``beyond a reasonable doubt'' that China's lucrative organ-transplant system is heavily reliant on prisoners' organs. The voluntary-donor system is insufficient to provide a huge number of human organs needed for transplantation surgeries, and China's organ-procurement program does not meet minimal ethics standards. All cooperation withthe transplantation field in China should be suspended, including a ban on transplantation professionals from China participating in international conferences, and from publishing in international scientific and medical journals. 16. Congress should prohibit U.S. universities and companies from using federal funds for joint research or other forms of cooperation with China-based companies and governmentagencies building and maintaining China's suffocating total-control police state--openly based on racial profiling and designed to commit mass atrocities against Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims. 17. Congress should request an update regarding U.S. Government protection of Uyghur Americans and action to investigate and deter illegal acts of coercion, threats, and reprisals by Chinese government agents, aiming to intimidate Uyghurs and prevent them from providing testimony about what is happening to their relatives in East Turkistan. Recommendations for businesses, universities, and other private actors: 1. Companies must recognize that due diligence in the supply chain is impossible, given the conditions of total control, mass internment, widespread government-subsided forced-labor recruitment, and large- scale government-sponsored prison/camp labor. Companies must suspend all sourcing of cotton, textiles, and garments from Xinjiang. 2. Private companies must immediately end collaboration with surveillance and racial profiling of Uyghurs, enabling arbitrary secret detention and an Orwellian system of control-by-terror. 3. Pension funds, both private-sector and government, must divest from these companies facilitating crimes against humanity, whether U.S. or foreign, including those listed on the Shanghai, Shenzhen, Hong Kong, and New York stock exchanges. 4. Researchers must end joint projects with China-based institutions building the system of surveillance and racial profiling, including in artificial intelligence, big-data programs, and bio- engineering. 5. Scholars and universities should institute an academic boycott in response to ``the crime ofthe century'' taking place in East Turkistan. In 1965, U.S. and U.K. universities began an academic boycott of South African universities in order to ensure that they were not complicit in the system of apartheid. Scholarly collaboration, publication of research, and participation in international conferences were denied to those representing the apartheid institutions of South Africa. UHRP urges a similar approach to the cultural genocide of the Uyghurs. ______ Prepared Statement of Michael Posner Senator Rubio, Congressman Smith, thank you for inviting me to appear at today's hearing, which draws much-needed attention to the plight of the embattled Uyghur community in China. At a time when core human rights principles are being tested in many places around the globe, I deeply appreciate the steadfast commitment the two of you have demonstrated, along with others on this Commission, to shining a spotlight on serious violations of human rights. When I served in the State Department during the first Obama term, I often was summoned to appear before various committees of Congress to discuss problematic countries where we needed to step up our game. While Congressional scrutiny is not a favorite pastime of State Department officials, I valued the constructive prodding during those encounters. You pushed us to do better, and you continue to play this important role. I am now based at the New York University Stern School of Business, where I direct the Center for Business and Human Rights. I appear here this morning to offer thoughts and recommendations to the Executive Branch, to Congress, and to the business community, on the challenging questions they face in their ongoing engagements with China. I do so hoping to offer a constructive critique of current efforts to engage constructively and in a principled way with China, and to make suggestions for going forward. First I want to offer a little context. I teach business students about human rights, and in my first class every semester, I discuss the reduction of global poverty as an important metric of human rights. According to the World Bank, in 1981, 88% of the people in China were living in extreme poverty, surviving on less than $1.25 a day. Today, that number has dropped below 5%. \1\ This dramatic progress is largely attributable to China's impressive economic growth, about which the Chinese people are understandably proud. An important factor fueling this growth has been the government's embrace of a market-based system and its move away from the economic orthodoxy of its past. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ http://bit.ly/32ph7R3 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Unfortunately, the Chinese government has refused to show a concomitant willingness to reform its political system. The gross abuses of human rights we see today against the Uyghurs in Xinjiang and the efforts to crush democratic freedoms in Hong Kong are two striking examples of this resistance. Since Xi Jinping came to power, the human rights situation in China has grown worse, and in some ways dramatically so. \2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2019/country-chapters/china- and-tibet --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Others on this panel will describe the desperate situation of the Uyghur population in Xinxiang in greater detail. They have faced systematic discrimination and persecution by the Chinese government for many years. \3\ Recently, the scope and scale of these violations have escalated dramatically. \4\ The imprisonment of more than a million Uyghurs today \5\ makes it the most egregious example of arbitrary detention anywhere in the world. Thousands more endure forced labor, \6\ and virtually everyone in that community is subject to pervasive surveillance and isolation from the outside world. \7\ The response of the international community has not been commensurate with the extent of these gross human rights violations, which is why this hearing is so important. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-26414014 \4\ https://nyti.ms/2LihrcV \5\ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-rights-un/u-n-says-it- has-credible-reports-that-china-holds-million-uighurs-in-secret-camps- idUSKBN1KV1SU \6\ https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/16/world/asia/xinjiang-china- forced-labor-camps-uighurs.html \7\ https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/09/09/eradicating-ideological- viruses/chinas-campaign- repression-against-xinjiangs --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the last few weeks, some progress may have been made on U.S.- China trade. If a preliminary agreement is consummated, and this is still far from certain, the pact would obligate China to purchase $40 to $50 billion worth of American agricultural products annually. It also would strengthen Chinese protections for American intellectual property and give U.S. financial services companies greater access to Chinese markets. In exchange, the U.S. government would forgo imposing additional tariffs on $250 billion of Chinese products being imported to the United States. On a different track, in the last several weeks, various U.S. government agencies have imposed new sanctions on China and companies doing business there related to the government's mistreatment of the Uyghurs. On October 1st, the U.S. Commerce Department added 28 Chinese organizations to the so-called Entity List, preventing U.S. companies from selling their products without U.S. government approval. \8\ These entities were found to have been ``implicated in human rights violations and abuses in China's campaign targeting Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim ethnic minorities'' in Xinjiang, and more specifically, in ``China's campaign of repression, mass arbitrary detention, and high-technology surveillance.'' \9\ The list includes both government entities and private companies that provide surveillance and artificial intelligence technology. \10\ According to Professor Julian Ku of Hofstra University, this may be the first time the Entity List has been used as a penalty for human rights violations. \11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/07/us/politics/us-to-blacklist- 28-chinese-entities-over-abuses-in-xinjiang.html \9\ https://www.commerce.gov/news/press-releases/2019/10/us- department-commerce-adds-28- chinese-organizations-its-entity-list \10\ https://fortune.com/2019/10/08/china-ai-us-entity-list/ ;https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/07/us/politics/us-to-blacklist-28- chinese-entities-over-abuses-in-xinjiang.html \11\ https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/08/business/china-human- rights-technology-xinjiang.html --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Separately, the US Customs and Border Protection agency issued five Withhold Release Orders banning products that were produced using forced labor. One company on the list was the Hetian Taida Apparel Company in Xinjiang, which U.S. officials determined was making apparel products using prison or forced labor. \12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\ https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/national-media-release/cbp- issues-detention-orders-against-companies-suspected-using-forced --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Reflecting similar human rights concerns, the State Department on October 8th announced visa restrictions on unnamed Chinese government and Community Party officials ``implicated in the detention or abuse of Uyghurs, Kazakhs, or other members of Muslim minority groups in Xinjiang.'' \13\ The State Department cited the Chinese government's ``highly repressive campaign'' against Uyghurs and other Muslim minority residents of Xinjiang, and made specific reference to the ``mass detentions in internment camps; pervasive, high-tech surveillance; draconian controls on expressions of cultural and religious identities; and coercion of individuals to return from abroad to an often perilous fate in China.'' \14\ By imposing these three categories of sanctions, the U.S. government is signaling strong condemnation of the ongoing repression of the Uyghurs. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\ https://www.state.gov/u-s-department-of-state-imposes-visa- restrictions-on-chinese-officials-for-repression-in-xinjiang/ \14\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Adding rhetorical force to the administration's various actions, individual officials have spoken out about mistreatment of the Uyghurs. Secretary of State Pompeo in particular has condemned the persecution of the Uyghurs, most recently at last month's UN General Assembly. Secretary Pompeo told reporters: ``I want to make clear that China's repressive campaign in Xinjiang is not about terrorism. It's about China's attempt to erase its own citizens. We call on all countries to resist China's demands to repatriate the Uyghurs.'' \15\ At a UN side event, Deputy Secretary of State John Sullivan condemned the Chinese government's systematic campaign ``to stop its own citizens from exercising their unalienable right to religious freedom.'' \16\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \15\ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-china-un/pompeo-urges- world-to-resist-chinas- demands-to-repatriate-ethnic-uighurs-idUSKBN1W70KX \16\ https://www.state.gov/deputy-secretary-john-j-sullivan- remarks-at-the-human-rights-crisis-in-xinjiang-event/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- But sanctions and strong public admonitions have been undermined by the administration's broader failure to prioritize human rights as a consistent element of US foreign policy. The administration's continued unwillingness to acknowledge the role of Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince in the Khashoggi murder last year is one glaring example among many. \17\ Without a consistent commitment to promoting human rights norms, the administration is far less persuasive in its efforts to promote compliance with these international standards in China and elsewhere. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \17\ https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-47182567 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- This reluctance starts at the top. Time and again, the President has resisted talking about human rights in general, and about Chinese government violations in particular. In September, CNN reported that the President had assured President Xi that he would not raise human rights issues relating to Hong Kong while trade talks are ongoing. \18\ The effects of this promise rippled through the administration: Kurt Tong, the then-US Consul General to Hong Kong and Macau, was directed by the State Department to cancel two speeches he planned to give in Washington discussing the human rights situation in Hong Kong. \19\ On August 1st, when he was asked by reporters to comment on the situation in Hong Kong, the President demurred saying only that the people of China and Hong Kong will ``have to deal with that themselves. They don't need advice.'' \20\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \18\ https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/04/politics/trump-xi-hong-kong- protests/index.html \19\ Id. \20\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The President's cavalier and dismissive comments about human rights in China and other places are now all too familiar. At the Group of Seven summit last month, he referred to Egyptian President Sisi as ``my favorite dictator,'' \21\ and before their bilateral meeting in New York praised him as ``a real leader'' who has ``done some things that are absolutely amazing.'' \22\ He recently characterized Saudi Crown Prince Salman as a ``friend,'' saying he's done ``a spectacular job.'' \23\ He has pledged ``complete support'' to Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, saying he is ``doing a great job for the people of Brazil . . . in all respects.'' \24\ He still refuses to condemn the Russian occupation of Crimea and Russia's continued interference in Ukraine's democratic system and its support of armed insurgent forces in Eastern Ukraine. He has praised Vladimir Putin as a ``terrific person.'' \25\ And despite their tumultuous relationship, the President has referred to Kim Jong Un as being ``very talented.'' \26\ The list goes on and on. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \21\ https://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-awaiting-egyptian- counterpart-at-summit-called-out-for-my-favorite-dictator-11568403645 \22\ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks- president-trump-president-el-sisi-egypt-bilateral-meeting-new-york-ny/ \23\ https://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-praises-saudi-crown-prince- for-doing-a-spectacular-job-11561778810 \24\ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-environment-usa/ trump-pledges-complete-support-for-brazils-bolsonaro-idUSKCN1VH1OV \25\ https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/g20-june-2019-intl-hnk/ h_0ac0caf83fde21799a2600d58fedea54 \26\ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/dictator-envy-trumps- praise-of-kim-jong-un-marks-embrace-of-totalitarian-leaders/2018/06/15/ b9a8bbc8-70af-11e8-afd5-778aca903bbe_story.html --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The administration also continues to turn its back on, and even undermine, multilateral approaches to human rights. The Uyghur crisis provides a salient case in point. In February, ambassadors from 22 countries signed a letter to the president of the UN Human Rights Council, calling on China to end its mass detention and surveillance of the Uyghurs in Xinjiang. \27\ Australia, Canada, Japan, Britain, France, Germany, and Switzerland were among the signatories, but the United States was not. \28\ As a result of the American withdrawal from the Human Rights Council, we are unable to lead multilateral efforts under the auspices of that body. Instead, no government was the principal sponsor of this effort, a fact that no doubt weakened the effect of the statement itself. This was a missed opportunity to apply global pressure to the Chinese government, a casualty of the administration's go-it-alone approach to diplomacy. The U.S. government can and must do better, and Congress needs to pressure the administration to take more decisive action. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \27\ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-xinjiang-rights- exclusive/exclusive-west-japan- rebuke-china-at-un-for-detention-of-uighurs-idUSKCN1U51E1 \28\ https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/11/asia/xinjiang-uyghur-un-letter- intl-hnk/index.html --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Congressional oversight, such as what you're doing today, can have a real effect. On May 9th of last year, Senator Rubio and Representative Smith sent a letter to the U.S. Commerce Secretary demanding answers about the sale by U.S. companies of surveillance technology used by Chinese security forces. \29\ On August 28th of 2018, the chairs sent a bipartisan letter, signed by 17 legislators, urging swift action by the executive branch in response to the systematic discrimination and arbitrary detention of Turkic Muslim minorities. \30\ Both letters were no doubt instrumental in achieving the recent sanctions and exemplify one of the ways Congress can hold the administration accountable. More recently, the Senate passed the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act of 2019, calling on bodies within the U.S. government to prepare reports on China's treatment of the Uyghurs. \31\ The Uighur Intervention and Global Humanitarian Unified Response Act has also been introduced in the House, relating to sourcing restrictions and export controls. \32\ The adoption of some form of this legislation will be an important step in bringing attention to the atrocities occurring in Xinjiang and will help to ensure a thoughtful and cohesive response by the U.S. Government. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \29\ https://www.cecc.gov/media-center/press-releases/chairs-ask- commerce-secretary-ross-about-sale-of-surveillance-technology \30\ https://www.cecc.gov/media-center/press-releases/chairs-lead- bipartisan-letter-urging- administration-to-sanction-chinese \31\ https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/178 \32\ https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/ 1025?q=%7B%22search%22%3A%5B%22uyghur%22%5D%7D&s=1&r=5 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- U.S. companies doing business in China also have a very important role to play with respect to human rights, but to date, their record has been uneven. The allure of doing business in and with China is obvious. According to the World Bank, the Chinese consumer market is now the third-biggest in the world after the U.S. and the EU. \33\ China also continues to be the largest global manufacturer of electronics, apparel, toys, and many other products. \34\ Given these economic realities, global companies will continue to look for opportunities to do business in China. All too often, U.S. companies have opted to pursue their economic interests, while paying insufficient attention to how their words and actions affect the broader human rights debate. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \33\ https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ NE.CON.PRVT.CD?most_recent_value_desc= true&year_high_desc=true \34\ https://www.brookings.edu/research/global-manufacturing- scorecard-how-the-us-compares-to-18-other-nations/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Last week's confrontation between the National Basketball Association and the Chinese government is the latest example. After Daryl Morey, general manager of the Houston Rockets, tweeted his support for human rights and democracy activists in Hong Kong, \35\ the NBA released starkly conflicting statements. The English-language version expressed support for Moray's freedom of speech while recognizing that his tweet had offended friends and fans in China; a second statement in Mandarin, posted on the NBA's Chinese social media account, said the league was ``extremely disappointed in the inappropriate comment.'' \36\ NBA Commissioner Adam Silver subsequently reiterated the league's commitment to free speech. \37\ As he did so, a Chinese e-commerce platform, a sporting goods brand, and a sports news website all suspended access to goods and coverage related to the Rockets, and Chinese Television announced it would not broadcast NBA exhibition games scheduled to be played in China. \38\ Lost in the debate was the underlying question of how human rights in Hong Kong are being seriously undermined by the Chinese government. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \35\ https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/10/07/nba-china- tweet-daryl-morey/ \36\ https://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-how-the-nbas-apology- was-different-in-china-and-the-us-2019-10-07?link=MW_latest_news \37\ https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/10/07/nba-china- tweet-daryl-morey/ \38\ https://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-how-the-nbas-apology- was-different-in-china-and-the-us-2019-10-07?link=MW_latest_news --------------------------------------------------------------------------- There are special responsibilities for U.S. technology companies operating China. The Chinese government continues to use advanced technology to stifle dissent and to intrude on the privacy of its people. Chinese authorities have attempted to justify this mass surveillance as a tool to fight terrorism, \39\ but most of what the system tracks has no relationship to threats of terrorism or extremism. A recent Human Rights Watch report about the Chinese government's ``Strike Hard Campaign'' in Xinjiang highlights the risks. In that region, the government has used what it calls the Integrated Joint Operations Platform (IJOP) to perform sweeping surveillance of the Uyghurs and other members of the Turkic Muslim minority. \40\ This app collects huge amounts of personal information, including blood type and other physical characteristics, education level, and religious and political affiliations. The IJOP also reports on activities the government deems suspicious, such as the use of encrypted communication tools like WhatsApp and Viber. \41\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \39\ https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/08/china-terrorism- xinjiang-repression-islam.html \40\ https://www.hrw.org/report/2019/05/01/chinas-algorithms- repression/reverse-engineering-xinjiang-police-mass-surveillance \41\ https://www.hrw.org/video-photos/interactive/2019/05/02/china- how-mass-surveillance-works-xinjiang --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The IJOP surveils and collects data on every person in Xinjiang, tracking their movements by monitoring the location of their phones, ID cards, and vehicles. Information collected through the IJOP system is used as a basis for house arrest or more formal detention. Failure to carry a smart phone can itself be a basis for detention. In some reported cases, U.S. companies and investors have played a role in this system. Until it was publicly reported in February, Massachusetts-based Thermo Fisher sold DNA sequencers directly to authorities in Xinjiang for genetic mapping. \42\ California-based Amax, which specializes in high-performance computing for deep-learning applications, partnered with Hikvision--now on the Entity List, as well. Hikvision is one of the world's largest producers of facial recognition and surveillance equipment, \43\ and the company has won several security-related contracts from the Chinese government in Xinjiang, totaling $260 million. \44\ One contract was for a ``social prevention and control system'' feature on tens of thousands of cameras. \45\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \42\ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/03/19/962492-orwell-china- socialcredit-surveillance/ \43\ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/03/19/962492-orwell-china- socialcredit-surveillance/ \44\ https://www.afp.com/en/news/15/chinas-blacklisted-ai-firms- what-you-should-know-doc-1lb4wb1 \45\ https://www.afp.com/en/news/15/chinas-blacklisted-ai-firms- what-you-should-know-doc-1lb4wb1 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Some U.S. technology companies have weighed the risks of doing business in China and declined to pursue aspects of their business there. Google, for example, did the right thing in 2010 when it withdrew from China in the face of extensive government interference with free expression. \46\ To date, the major internet platforms, Google, \47\ Facebook \48\ and Twitter have limited their businesses in China given the government's poor record on free speech and privacy. \49\ Microsoft has been an industry leader in crafting safeguards relating to facial recognition. \50\ The company even took down its public facial recognition database when reports surfaced that Chinese companies, including Megvii and SenseTime, both newly added to the Entity List, were using the database to train their facial recognition systems. \51\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \46\ https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2010/jan/12/google- china-ends-censorship \47\ https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/location/ \48\ https://www.facebook.com/notes/mark-zuckerberg/a-privacy- focused-vision-for-social- networking/10156700570096634/ \49\ https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/7/20902947/nba-rockets-daryl- morey-hong-kong-protests-tweet-internet-speech-censorship-china \50\ http://bit.ly/35vEzxW \51\ https://www.ft.com/content/7d3e0d6a-87a0-11e9-a028- 86cea8523dc2 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- But it was disappointing to see Apple remove pro-democracy songs from its Chinese music store, \52\ and Taiwan's flag from its iOS emoji library for users in Hong Kong and Macau. \53\ Apple's Chinese iCloud partner, Guizhou-Cloud Big Data, recently made a deal to move user data to servers operated by state-run China Telecom. \54\ Apple also removed the HKMap.Live app, thereby depriving Hong Kong citizens of the capacity to track online the sites of demonstrations and police actions. \55\ All of these actions seem guided by the company's desire to preserve its status with the Chinese government. Apple maintains that they are simply following local law. \56\ This alone is not a tenable path. Instead, Apple and other technology companies need to develop company-endorsed human rights policies that address privacy, free expression and other rights issues, using international norms as a baseline. Such policies will help businesses make these challenging decisions in a more consistent and principled manner. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \52\ https://www.fastcompany.com/90332656/apple-removed-this-pro- democracy-music-in-china \53\ https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-10-08/apple- pulls-taiwanese-flag-emoji-from-iphones-in-hong-kong \54\ https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/18/17587304/apple-icloud- china-user-data-state-run-telecom-privacy-security \55\ https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/09/technology/apple-hong-kong- app.html \56\ https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/10/tim-cook- apple-hong-kong-mapping-app-removal --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Investors must also face these questions head on. A range of U.S. investors have been providing capital to Megvii and SenseTime. According to one report, among U.S.-based institutions with stakes in these two Chinese firms, ``public pension funds are the largest committers of capital.'' \57\ Megvii representatives told Buzzfeed News that the company does not ``have any access to the IJOP platform or the [Chinese] national ID database.'' \58\ And while the company also assured Buzzfeed that it requires clients not to use its technology for the infringement of human rights, it did not provide details of how it enforces this commitment. \59\ U.S. investors need to adopt more stringent safeguards to avoid contributing capital to Chinese companies that are involved in surveillance and related data-gathering, especially in Xinjiang. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \57\ https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/us-money-funding- facial-recognition-sensetime-megvii \58\ Id. \59\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- China and the U.S. compete fiercely for economic and political influence in Asia, Africa, and elsewhere. But the two countries-- including their companies and investors--must find ways to interact that allow for peaceful, fruitful competition and perhaps, on occasion, cooperation. As I learned in government, saying this is easy; doing it is very hard. But the U.S. government and American businesses must find ways to navigate this terrain, allowing economic and political cooperation when it is mutually beneficial, while always standing firm in support of universal human rights principles. Prepared Statement of Amy K. Lehr Chairman McGovern, Chairman Rubio, and distinguished Members of the Commission, thank you for holding a hearing on this important topic and offering me an opportunity to speak. I am the Director of the Human Rights Initiative at CSIS. My program issued a report today on forced labor in Xinjiang, with a series of recommendations to address these abuses. I have worked in the field of business and human rights for over a decade, and the recommendations reflect my practical experience. Over one million Muslim minorities in Xinjiang are believed to be held in extrajudicial detention facilities, where they are brainwashed to abandon their religion and declare loyalty to the Communist Party. The entire region of Xinjiang is covered by an unparalleled surveillance system infiltrating every aspect of inhabitants' lives. And now there are credible allegations that minorities, including those who were detained, are being subjected to forced labor, particularly in the textile industry. Today, I will focus on the issue of forced labor in Xinjiang and why it is unique and requires novel responses. Forced labor is always abhorrent, but the situation in Xinjiang is uniquely abusive. The forced labor in Xinjiang goes beyond more typical forced labor, which usually involves migrant workers who pay fees to a recruiter and end up indebted, with their passports confiscated and their movement restricted. Forced labor is not typically a centralized, masterminded effort, where the state acts as the organizer as part of a broader effort to cut minorities off from their culture and religion at any cost. In Xinjiang's case, the Chinese state is playing this role. The Chinese authorities believe that through re-education and work, they can break the minority population's ties to religion, increase their loyalty to the state, and stabilize the region. \1\ Forced labor is part of a set of government policies seeking to accomplish this. Other key elements include mass detention and what the government considers to be ``poverty alleviation'' for minorities, and these are all interlinked. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Emily Rauhala, ``China Now Says Almost 100 Were Killed in Xinjiang Violence,'' Time, August 4, 2014, https://time.com/3078381/ china-xinjiang-violence-shache-yarkand/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Forced labor in Xinjiang may rise to the level of a crime against humanity. Why do I say this? International jurisprudence defines several key elements of crimes against humanity: the act must be part of a widespread or systematic attack; the attack must be against the civilian population; and the attack must be launched on discriminatory grounds, including ethnic or religious grounds. \2\ Such attacks in many instances are violent, but are not always. \3\ Enslavement-- including forced labor--is enumerated as a potential crime against humanity when carried out as part of such an attack. Indeed, the Nuremberg trials after World War II found certain German industrialists guilty of crimes against humanity, including the use of forced labor associated with concentration camps. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ Akayesu, (Trial Chamber), September 2, 1998, para. 595 \3\ ``An attack may also be nonviolent in nature, like imposing a system of apartheid . . . or exerting pressure on the population to act in a particular manner.'' Akayesu, (Trial Chamber), September 2, 1998, para. 581. See also Rutaganda (Trial Chamber), December 6, 1999. Para 70, and Musema, (Trial Chamber), January 27, 2000, para 205 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Xinjiang appears to fit this pattern. Muslim minorities are being forced to work at a significant scale in Xinjiang based on their religion and ethnicity. It is part of a broader attack on them, including widespread detention. As a result, the Chinese companies playing a direct role in Xinjiang's state-sponsored forced labor are at risk of complicity in international crimes. Our response needs to match the gravity of the abuses. At CSIS, our research confirmed and expanded on the work of others speaking today. Forced labor in Xinjiang takes three primary forms. First, there is traditional prison labor, which has long played a key role in cotton and textile production in Xinjiang. It is believed that increasingly large numbers of minorities are entering the formal prison system in Xinjiang, where they may be forced to work. \4\ Second, detainees and ex-detainees are being funneled into factories. Chinese government planning documents and statements from detainees suggest that this could be occurring at a significant scale. One credible source told an Associated Press journalist that 10,000 ex-detainees, or 10 or 20 percent of the population in his county, were being forced to work. \5\ The government of Kashgar, a region of Xinjiang, stated that it would send 100,000 ``re-educated'' individuals to work in factories. \6\ That is 20 percent of the entire Uyghur population of Kashgar. Even if the Chinese government did not hit its targets, the numbers are likely to be very significant. Third, there are indications that Chinese authorities are coercing rural, poor minorities to enter the formal workforce as part of the government's poverty alleviation program, which is based on the idea that factory work will break their ties with their culture and religion. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ Cotton: The Fabric Full of Lies: A report on forced labor and prison labor in Xinjiang, China, and the nexus to global supply chains (Washington, D.C.: CPIFC) \5\ Dake Kang, Martha Mendoza, and Yanan Wang, ``US Sportswear traced to factory in China's internment camps,'' Associated Press, December 19, 2018, https://www.apnews.com/ 99016849cddb4b99a048b863b52c28cb \6\ Chris Buckley and Austin Ramzy, ``China's Detention Camps for Muslims Turn to Forced Labor,'' New York Times, December 16, 2018 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Chinese government's efforts to move minorities into the workplace, willingly or not, center particularly on yarn, textiles, and apparel. Indeed, the government is offering significant subsidies to textile companies and allows factories to pay these workers much less than the minimum wage. \7\ Our interviews of ex-detainees indicate that some are paid less in a year than the legal minimum wage for a month in Xinjiang. This extraordinarily cheap labor creates significant competitive advantages for these Chinese companies. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Wusu City: The First Apparel Manufacturing Company Starting Operations in September,'' The Government of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region of China, https://web.archive.org/web/20180126102601/http:// www.xinjiang.gov.cn/2017/08/30/143690.html --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Chinese government helps funnel these workers to the factories. The ex-detainees we interviewed were explicitly told that if they refused to work, they'd be sent back into detention. At least some of the rural poor moving into the workforce as part of the government's poverty alleviation program were also reportedly threatened with being sent to detention if they did not agree to the job placement. Like the ex-detainees, they were also paid a pittance. Forced labor in Xinjiang is one part of a much larger set of human rights violations. The situation requires policy action on a number of fronts, including diplomatic pressure. However, because some of the companies potentially involved in forced labor in Xinjiang are linked to global supply chains, action in this area can be part of the solution. To think about what leverage is available, we can consider how Xinjiang connects to brands and consumers here in the U.S. China is one of the world's largest cotton producers, with around 20% of the world's production. \8\ But a more apt characterization is that Xinjiang itself is one of the world's largest cotton producers, since it alone is responsible for 84% of all of China's cotton production. \9\ Some of that cotton is transformed into yarn and textiles in Xinjiang--indeed, the world's self-proclaimed largest producer of colored yarn \10\-- Huafu Fashion--has a factory in Xinjiang and is accused of using ``re- educated'' labor. \11\ Our research indicates that several other large Chinese textile companies that sell to Western brands--directly and indirectly--also have factories in Xinjiang that raise red flags. Much of Xinjiang's cotton, yarn, and textiles then are sent into the rest of China for further processing. Over 30% of U.S. apparel imports come from China, \12\ and much of this is likely to be affected by Xinjiang's forced labor several steps back in the supply chain. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ China: Cotton and Products Annual,'' USDA Foreign Agricultural Service, April 16, 2019, https://www.fas.usda.gov/data/china-cotton- and-products-annual-3 \9\ Ibid. \10\ ``World's largest textile mill for coloured yarns in Xinjiang,'' Xinhua, August 25, 2018, http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/ 2018-08/25/c_137418336.htm or https://perma.cc/SV96-V2B4 \11\ Ibid. \12\ Sheng Lu, ``China's Changing Role in the World Textile and Apparel Supply Chain,'' FASH455, November 2, 2018, https:// shenglufashion.com/2018/11/02/chinas-changing-role-in-the-world- textile-and-apparel-supply-chain/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Recommendations Our foreign policy should reflect our values. We must respond with an urgency that reflects the severity and scale of these abuses. The Administration should apply Global Magnitsky sanctions on companies and their officers directly involved in forced labor, responsible for building detention facilities, or knowingly providing key technology for Xinjiang's pervasive surveillance. This is an obvious and urgent step. A federal agency--either the Department of Labor or Department of State--should be funded to create a public watch list of companies in Xinjiang that trigger red flags indicating a risk that they use forced labor. We identify examples of those red flags in our report. This watch list would help Customs and Border Protection assist with Global Magnitsky designations, and also put companies on notice of risks in their own sourcing practices. Customs and Border Protection should develop unique approaches to enable seizures of Xinjiang goods tainted by forced labor that reflect the fact that Xinjiang is a police state. For this authoritarian environment, Customs and Border Protection should assume that some of the red flags we identified in our report are a sufficient basis for a seizure. The aforementioned company watch list would put Western companies on notice that certain suppliers could face seizures. Customs and Border Protection should first conduct seizures on shipments coming directly from Xinjiang to the United States, because receiving companies should be on notice of the risks of their sourcing. This would provide time for companies indirectly sourcing from Xinjiang to identify red flags and adjust their sourcing practices. The apparel industry should consider instituting a ban on knowingly sourcing Xinjiang cotton, as they did for Uzbek cotton. This would acknowledge the severity of the problem, although given the dependence of the U.S. apparel sector on China, it will be challenging. In the meantime, individual companies should carry out the due diligence and reporting we identify in our report and shift their supply chains as appropriate. Notably, traditional factory audits are impossible to conduct credibly in Xinjiang, so companies should instead use a combination of traceability and a red flags approach. If companies do identify likely forced labor, they will not be able to directly mitigate it in the Xinjiang context and will need to change their sourcing. The U.S. government itself should adopt the report's red flags approach in its own procurement practices. Given the dollar value of U.S. government procurement practices, this could be impactful. Congress and the Administration must think more broadly regarding what can be done about companies directly involved in the centrally planned, gross human rights abuses in Xinjiang. Some of the technology companies knowingly contributing to the surveillance state in Xinjiang have a U.S. presence. It is suspected that large state- owned enterprises helping to build the detention facilities there also have a U.S. presence. They should be the U.S.'s primary targets whenever we can reach them. The U.S. should work toward building a broad coalition of international allies who are committed to removing these abuses from global supply chains. Each recommendation above, while vital, will not effect change on its own. Our allies, who also have commitments to protecting human rights, must hear from the United States that we want to work together to cut off export markets for Xinjiang's tainted goods. Strong U.S. diplomatic efforts will be essential. This work is one aspect of ensuring that the goods we keep out do not simply slip into other, lucrative supply chains. Finally, simply indirectly pressuring Chinese companies involved in abuses in Xinjiang will not by itself address the underlying state-led abuses. These recommendations need to be combined with a robust diplomatic effort and the use of other points of leverage. Thank you very much, and I look forward to answering your questions. ______ Prepared Statement of Hon. James P. McGovern Good morning and welcome to today's Congressional-Executive Commission on China hearing on ``Forced Labor, Mass Internment, and Social Control in Xinjiang.'' In the last year, Chinese authorities have expanded their network of mass internment camps, where one million or more Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims have been detained and subjected to torture, extended solitary confinement and political indoctrination, and deprived of food. Children of detainees are reportedly often placed in orphanages, welfare centers, and boarding schools. Some scholars and human rights groups argue that these practices may amount to ``crimes against humanity.'' Outside the camps, the Chinese government has become more efficient in the use of technology to control and suppress. Some observers have described this surveillance system as an ``open air prison.'' Recent reports indicate that Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims are increasingly sentenced to lengthy prison sentences on vague charges. One case is that of Uyghur scholar Ilham Tohti who is serving a life sentence in spite of his dedication to nonviolence and reconciliation. He is a ``Defending Freedoms Project'' prisoner of conscience and his congressional advocate is Representative Jim Langevin of Rhode Island. Meanwhile, the practice of Islam has also been criminalized. Mosques have been destroyed, Islamic dress has been forbidden, and fasting for Ramadan has been disallowed. It is in this context that new information has come to light detailing the widespread use of a government-subsidized and large-scale system of forced labor in both mass internment camps and in factories throughout the Xinjiang region. Satellite imagery, personal testimonies, and official documents indicate that detainees in camps and some who have been released are forced to work in food, textile, and other manufacturing jobs. Products reportedly produced with forced labor include: Textiles, such as yarn, clothing, gloves, bedding, and carpet. Electronics, including cell phones and computers. Food products, shoes, tea, and handicrafts. In January 2019, the U.S. company Badger Sportswear stopped importing clothing following reports that such clothing was made with forced labor by internment camp detainees. In May 2019, the Wall Street Journal linked the supply chains of Adidas, Campbell Soup, H&M, Kraft Heinz, Coca-Cola, and Gap Inc. to forced labor. On October 1st, U.S. Customs and Border Protection issued a ``Withhold Release Order'' on garments produced with prison or forced labor by Hetian Taida Apparel, which has exported products to Costco. Current U.S. law prohibits the import of any product made with forced labor. Any U.S. or international company that produces or has a supply chain in Xinjiang may be complicit in forced labor and human rights violations. In 2002 China ratified the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). The ICESCR affirms the rights of all peoples to self-determination and non-discrimination, to freely choose and accept work, to enjoy just and favorable conditions of work, including the right to remuneration, and to take part in cultural life. All of the policies and practices I have just described violate the ICESCR as well as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. China is failing to comply with international human rights obligations it freely assumed. There is no question that the U.S. should be doing more to help the Uyghur people. In April, Senator Rubio and I, and over 40 Members called for Global Magnitsky sanctions against Chen Quanguo, the Xinjiang Communist Party Secretary, as well as Chinese officials and companies complicit in gross violations of human rights. And last week, we expressed support when the Administration added 28 Chinese companies to the ``entity list'' and applied visa restrictions on some Chinese officials. Right now, there are important bills that Congress should pass, including: The Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act by Sen. Rubio and Rep. Suozzi and Rep. Chris Smith; and The Uighur Intervention and Global Humanitarian Unified Response Act by Chairman Brad Sherman. I look forward to hearing any and all recommendations about what more can and should be done--including whether it is feasible for companies to conduct reliable inspections and audits of supply chains in the region. Congress stands in solidarity with the Uyghur people, and we want to do all we can to support the full exercise of their human rights. Finally, before we begin, I would like to recognize Nury Teyip, who is here with us today. His brother, Tashpolat Teyip, was the president of Xinjiang University and is a renowned scholar. Tashpolat Teyip was disappeared in March 2017 and was sentenced to death with a two-year reprieve. Last month, we learned from Amnesty International that he may be executed. I condemn his detention in the strongest possible terms and call on the Chinese government to release him immediately. ______ Prepared Statement of Hon. Marco Rubio Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is an important hearing, so thank you for convening it. It's also timely. I also want to thank all of our witnesses. Your research and your advocacy has done a lot to inform us and the world about what's happening--the atrocities being committed in the Xinjiang region by the Chinese Communist Party. Through the decades, the crimes of the Chinese Communist Party have been as consistent as they have been egregious. Yet somehow, these tyrants maintain the ability to shock the world even further with their cruelty and their callousness. The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region in the last two years has experienced classic forms of Communist totalitarianism now combined with the application of advanced technology. The difference between the Chinese Communist Party's crimes of the past and those of the present is the motivation. The past was about power alone. The present is about power, but also profit. Chairman Xi Jinping and his henchman, Chen Quanguo--who by the way used to oversee Chinese brutality and repression inside Tibet, so he's a specialist at this--revived collectivization to force Uyghurs into the harness of the Chinese Communist Party's state. Just as collectivization created famines that harmed millions in China, this new effort is blazing a trail of human suffering. The problem goes much deeper than simply one million Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities detained and forced to work in what can only be called concentration camps. For those able to escape the camps, the full power of the Chinese state is mobilized against them and their families inside and outside China. Hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Uyghur men and women have been forced, after military discipline and political reeducation, to take jobs in satellite factories. The Chinese Communist government offers incentives for Chinese companies to exploit this labor, as the cost of doing business in coastal provinces rises. And what of the families, the children, and the elderly? The children are removed from their parents' care so the adults can work in the factories. Instead of the warm embrace of their families, the young and the elderly are forced into the stifling custody of the Chinese Communist Party. For the children this means the loss of their language, their culture, their faith, their heritage. For the elderly this means loneliness and isolation in their final years. Their children and grandchildren will never hear the stories of lives well lived, of hardships conquered, or the importance of faith and values in a brutal, communist-governed world. Today's hearing, however, is not about this alone. It is about understanding how the Party integrates labor and social control, and the national security and moral risks for individuals and companies that deal with China. The network of detention facilities and factories has turned Xinjiang into a forced labor camp roughly the size of the states of California, Montana, Texas, and Florida combined. Millions of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim ethnic minorities labor in textile and light manufacturing and are prohibited from practicing their faith. Simply put, this is slavery--the slavery of socialism with Chinese characteristics. Earlier this month the Trump administration announced sanctions, as the Chairman said, targeting Chinese officials as well as governmental and commercial entities for these severe human rights abuses, and I believe that these also constitute crimes against humanity. We all welcome these steps and we also believe more can and should be done to resolve one of the world's greatest ongoing tragedies and to hold its perpetrators accountable. I hope the House will soon pass Senate bill 178, the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act, that the Senate passed last month. The bill would require the Administration to gather information about the situation in Xinjiang and China's efforts to suppress international awareness of it. China's efforts to silence the Uyghurs and turn the world's attention away from the ongoing atrocities in Xinjiang have included the coercion and intimidation of American citizens and residents here and abroad. This is an outrage that must be addressed. The U.S. Government needs to do its part to ensure that Americans and the world are aware of what the Chinese government is doing in Xinjiang and have the freedom to express their views. Despite the efforts of our witnesses today, Americans--and American companies in particular--are unaware of what is taking place. For example, the National Basketball Association maintains a residential training camp in Xinjiang, seemingly oblivious to the contradiction between speaking out about societal issues here at home, which they have the full freedom to do, and staying silent about China's oppression. Only after the U.S. Commerce Department added the Chinese artificial intelligence company SenseTime to the Entity List last week for its role in facilitating the Chinese Communist Party's crimes in Xinjiang did MIT begin to review its relationship with the firm. It's long overdue for Americans and the private sector to wake up and fully realize the real risks of doing business with China. [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Witness Biographies Adrian Zenz, Non-resident Senior Fellow in China Studies at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation and author of ``Beyond the Camps: Beijing's Grand Scheme of Forced Labor, Poverty Alleviation and Social Control in Xinjiang'' Adrian Zenz is a non-resident senior fellow in China Studies at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation (Washington, DC). Dr. Zenz has done pioneering work documenting the scope of mass internment camps in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region (XUAR), including through his analysis of Chinese government procurement documents, construction bids, and domestic security budgets. Recently, he has published and contributed to groundbreaking research documenting the mass institutionalization of children whose parents have been detained in mass internment camps and the incentives offered to Chinese manufacturers to employ forced labor in the XUAR. Nury Turkel, Washington-based attorney and Chair of the Board, Uyghur Human Rights Project Nury Turkel is an attorney in private practice in Washington, DC, specializing in regulatory compliance, with a focus on anti-bribery investigation and enforcement, data privacy, and aviation. In addition to his law practice, Mr. Turkel serves as Chair of the Board for the Uyghur Human Rights Project, a research and advocacy organization that he co-founded in 2004. He served as Executive Director until 2006. He has published commentaries on policy and legal matters in publications such as The Wall Street Journal and Foreign Policy and has appeared on radio and television programs on CNN, BBC, Fox News, Al Jazeera, France 24, NPR, and ABC Australia, among others. Born and raised in Kashgar, Mr. Turkel received a bachelor's degree from Northwest A&F University in Xi'an, China. Mr. Turkel has a master's degree in International Relations and a J.D. from American University. He is the first U.S. educated Uyghur lawyer, and is a fluent speaker of Uyghur, Chinese, and Turkish. Michael Posner, Jerome Kohlberg Professor of Ethics and Finance and Director of the Center for Business and Human Rights at NYU's Stern School of Business, and former Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor Michael Posner is the Jerome Kohlberg Professor of Ethics and Finance at NYU's Stern School of Business. He is the director of the Center for Business and Human Rights at the school, the first-ever human rights center at a business school. Prior to joining NYU Stern, Posner served in the Obama Administration from 2009 to 2013 as Assistant Secretary of State for the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor. As a member of the White House Apparel Industry Partnership Task Force in the mid-'90s, he helped found the Fair Labor Association, an organization that brings together corporations, local leaders, universities, and NGOs to promote corporate accountability for working conditions in the apparel industry. From 1978 to 2009, he led Human Rights First, a New York-based human rights advocacy organization. Amy K. Lehr, Director of the Human Rights Initiative at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and former legal adviser to the U.N. Special Representative on business and human rights Amy K. Lehr is the director of the Human Rights Initiative at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. She leads the Initiative's work on human rights around the world, with a particular focus on how technology affects human rights and labor rights, and the importance of a values-based foreign policy. Her core expertise is in the area of business and human rights. She spent a decade in private practice advising companies and international institutions on how they can respect human rights in their global operations. Previously, Lehr served as legal adviser to the UN special representative on business and human rights, John Ruggie, and in that role helped develop the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. [all]