Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- WOMEN AND RETIREMENT: UNIQUE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES TO PAVE A BRIGHTER FUTURE [Senate Hearing 116-528] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 116-528 WOMEN AND RETIREMENT: UNIQUE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES TO PAVE A BRIGHTER FUTURE ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ SEPTEMBER 24, 2020 __________ Serial No. 116-22 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 46-841PDF WASHINGTON : 2022 SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine, Chairman TIM SCOTT, South Carolina ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania RICHARD BURR, North Carolina KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York MARTHA McSALLY, Arizona RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut MARCO RUBIO, Florida ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri DOUG JONES, Alabama MIKE BRAUN, Indiana KYRSTEN SINEMA, Arizona RICK SCOTT, Florida JACKY ROSEN, Nevada ---------- Elizabeth McDonnell, Majority Staff Director Kathryn Mevis, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman.......... 1 Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member 3 PANEL OF WITNESSES Hon. Gene L. Dodaro, Comptroller General of the United States, Government Accountability Office, (Accompanied by Tranchau (Kris), T. Nguyen and Tamara Cross), Washington, D.C........... 5 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Statement of Hon. Gene L. Dodaro, Comptroller General of the United States, Government Accountability Office, Washington, D.C............................................................ 29 Additional Statements for the Record American Retirement Association Statement for the Record......... 47 WOMEN AND RETIREMENT: UNIQUE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES TO PAVE A BRIGHTER FUTURE ---------- THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2020 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:32 a.m., in room SD-562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, and by videoconference, Hon. Susan M. Collins, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Collins, Tim Scott, Hawley, Braun, Rick Scott, Casey, Gillibrand, Blumenthal, Sinema, and Rosen. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SUSAN M. COLLINS, CHAIRMAN The Chairman. Good morning. The Committee will come to order. Over the years this Committee has focused on improving retirement security for older Americans today and for generations to come. Many of the financial paths to retirement today are not as they were in the past, and for some Americans these paths appear to lead to a financially insecure future. Prior to COVID-19, the nonpartisan Center for Retirement Research at Boston College estimated that Americans face a cumulative $7 trillion gap between what they are projected to have saved for retirement and what they are likely to need. The COVID-19 public health emergency and economic recession are expected to further increase this staggering gap. For some women, the situation is particularly acute, and that is the focus of our hearing today. It seems appropriate that as we mourn the passing of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg we focus today on the unique challenges women face in preparing for and maintaining a secure retirement. In general, women are more likely than men to take time away from the workforce to raise children or even grandchildren. They are more likely to care for an ill spouse or parent. Time out of the workforce often results in lower social security benefits, smaller pensions, and less in defined contribution plan savings. Women also have a higher life expectancy than men do. A woman born in 2020 who reaches age 65 can expect to live 2 years longer than a man born in that same year. Higher average life expectancy can also translate into higher expected lifetime health care costs and a greater risk of outliving one's savings. Today we will feature a report from the Government Accountability Office that this Committee requested on the challenges that women face in retirement. The report includes the voices of women across the country sharing their stories with us. These women tell us about their struggles, including navigating the rising costs of prescription drugs, housing, and other necessities, and how limited opportunities for financial education contributed to these challenges. To lower the cost of prescription drugs I have spearheaded bills that have been signed into law. As a result of this Committee's landmark bipartisan investigation into prescription drug price spikes, I developed legislation with then Ranking Member Claire McCaskill to incentivize lower-cost but equally effective generic medicines. That law created an expedited new pathway at the FDA that has resulted in 44 new generic drugs. We can and must do more to bring down the cost of prescription drugs. That is why I support the Prescription Drug Pricing Reduction Act of 2020, which is projected to save seniors and individuals with disabilities $72 billion in out- of-pocket costs in Medicare Part D and reduce premiums by $1 billion. This is the legislation led by Senator Grassley and Senator Wyden. As Chairman of the Housing Appropriations Subcommittee, I am also keenly aware of the housing needs and challenges faced by our Nation's seniors. Of the 31 million senior households in the country, nearly one-third, or 10 million households are paying more than 30 percent of their income on housing costs. That is why I have also championed to increase funding to provide low-income seniors with safe places to live independently, whether this is through HUD-assisted housing or through home modifications to enable low-income seniors to remain in their own homes. Just last week I wrote a letter to Treasury Secretary Mnuchin, urging the administration to provide rental assistance in the next COVID relief package. I am committed to working on all fronts to ensure that housing is safe and affordable for all seniors. Social security has also emerged in the report as a persistent concern for many women who are planning to rely on this financial resource for retirement. Yet, in some states, including my State of Maine, public employees such as teachers continue to have their earned social security benefits unfairly reduced by two social security provisions, the government pension offset and the windfall elimination provision. Both of these provisions have a disproportionate impact on women. I have heard from women throughout Maine, particularly retired schoolteachers, who are affected by these laws, such as a 65-year-old woman in Jay, Maine, who changed careers after 30 years of teaching to pursue a career where she will earn social security coverage. However, she is not able to receive any of her deceased husband's social security benefits due to the government pension offset, and her very own social security will also be reduced because of the windfall elimination provision. That is why I have consistently sponsored the Bipartisan Social Security Fairness Act, which would fully repeal both of these unfair offsets. I am committed to developing solutions, from lowering the cost of prescription drugs and housing to strengthening social security. We must also address caregiving duties and financial education. Thanks to the RAISE Family Caregivers Act, a law that I authored with Senator Baldwin, a national security is in the works to support family caregivers and improve their financial security. In the 2020 Older Americans Act reauthorization that I led with our Ranking Member, Senator Casey, we worked to ensure the continuation of the National Resource Center for Retirement and Women, which is a hub for financial education. Today I look forward to hearing about the GAO report in more detail to determine and guide our work on what we can do to improve the retirement security for all women. Thank you. I am now pleased to turn to our Ranking Member, Senator Bob Casey, who is joining us remotely this morning. Senator Casey. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., RANKING MEMBER Senator Casey. Chairman Collins, thank you very much for having this hearing on the topic of women's retirement security. I also want to thank Gene Dodaro and the Government Accountability Office for producing a report that is informing our conversation today. As I always mention when the Comptroller General is here, he is a Pennsylvania native from Monongahela, which is in Washington County, which is in the southwestern corner of our State, just south of Pittsburgh, we are always grateful that a Pennsylvanian has done so well in the work he has done for the GAO. We know, as Chairman Collins just highlighted, we know that last Friday, when we lost a pioneer for gender equality in Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, we were also reminded that she challenged all of us to advance the causes of justice and equality. She also reminded us, and would remind us, that these advances will not simply happen on their own. They must be fought for. I believe our discussion today about gender inequality in retirement is another critical facet of this work. Achieving financial security in retirement is a goal that every American, women or men, should be able to achieve. The unfortunate truth is that while our retirement system works for some it continues to allow millions of Americans to fall through the cracks. This is especially true when it comes to women, who continue to have lower average retirement incomes and are more likely--more likely to fall into poverty in old age. As the GAO report that we are focused on today makes clear, we know that there are many factors that are responsible for these disparities: 1) we know that differences in life expectancy means women have to put away more money to save for additional years of retirement and medical expenses; 2) we know that the pay gap means that women earn less over their careers than men do, on average, undermining their ability to save; 3) we know that family caregiving responsibilities disproportionately fall on women, and they spend more unpaid time out of the workforce; and 4) we know that these factors and others result in women receiving lower average social security benefits and relying on less income in old age. We have documented all of these problems. What we need to do now is to take action and address them. To ensure that all women are able to enjoy retirement on their own terms and be financially secure, we must do at least the following: 1) strengthen social security and increase benefits for those most likely to fall into poverty; 2) take action to secure multi- employer pensions and to protect the benefits millions of workers are relying on; 3) close the pay gap and ensure that women are paid equally for equal work so they can save for retirement; and 4) create permanent paid sick and paid family and medical leave so workers do not have to take as much unpaid time out of the workforce to care for loved ones. Legislation that would address all of these needs has already been introduced, and we should pass that legislation, or several pieces of legislation, without further delay. It is more important now than ever that we take action, because as we speak, millions of families are continuing to struggle through the pandemic and the economic and jobs crisis that was created by the COVID-19 pandemic. This crisis is not only harming families' finances now but also threatens their ability to achieve financial security in retirement. The Senate had all summer to act and we did not, but has still not passed additional legislation to get the families the support they need and mitigate the long-term economic damage. We should pass a relief bill now, while we are here in Washington, and pass legislation that addresses these long- lasting inequities that have prevented women from being able to maintain their quality of life in retirement. We must make sure that all Americans--all Americans--are able to achieve the financial security that they have earned. Chairman Collins, thank you again for the hearing. We look forward to our witness's testimony. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Casey. Let me explain that we have Senators here in person and we also have Senators who are joining us remotely. I am going to go in order of seniority, and we will proceed, but first I am going to turn to our witness. I am very pleased to welcome the Comptroller General of the United States, Gene Dodaro, to testify today. His career at the GAO has spanned more than 45 years, and he will mark his 10th year as Comptroller General in December. I am pleased to say that I chaired the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee when we considered his nomination. He has played a key role in guiding the agency's efforts to bring to light emerging issues that deserve our attention and action. Today the Comptroller General will discuss the findings from a recent GAO report exploring older women's perspectives on their financial security. Comptroller General, we welcome you here today and look forward to hearing your testimony. I am particularly pleased to note that you did focus groups of women to guide your work, and I understand that we will hear from some of them today. Thank you. Please proceed. STATEMENT OF HON. GENE L. DODARO, COMPTROLLER GENERAL THE UNITED STATES, GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY OFFICE, WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. Dodaro. Thank you very much, Chairman Collins. I appreciate greatly the opportunity to be here. Senator Casey, Senator Blumenthal, I very much appreciate your presence and your comments. I have long been concerned about retirement security for older Americans and have issued special reports and publications and testified before this Committee before. All our research predated the COVID-19 pandemic, and that certainly, as you point out, Senator Collins, has complicated this situation and the landscape considerably, both from a health care perspective of either directly or potentially indirectly affecting the health of our senior citizens as well as economically. We noted that during the last Great Recession we had that when seniors in the workforce lost their jobs it took them much longer to come back into the workforce than other people. This can have a dramatic effect on their retirement savings, cause them to potentially pull some of their retirement savings out to help them meet necessary expenses, so it is very important. Now women in particular, as has been pointed out this morning, have unique challenges. They have longer lifespans, as you pointed out, lower lifetime earnings, and they are more likely to be primary caregivers. Our analysis of the Survey of Consumer Finances showed, in terms of the confidence, that households where older women were present had a mixed view. Only 42 percent had high confidence in their retirement security, 33 percent medium, and 25 percent low confidence in their retirement security, moving forward. Now while that is an overall statistic it varied greatly by race, by retirement plan that they were in participation, by home ownership, by marital status, by education, and whether they were in a rural area or in an urban area. To learn more about this we had the focus groups that you mentioned, Senator Collins. We had 14 focus groups in 9 different areas across the United States, 190 women in total, and they were very rich discussions. What came out of that discussion was, you know, some of the things that were supported by our analysis, in that women who had higher liquidity--in other words, more checking and savings and investments, stocks and bonds--had a much higher degree of security, retirement security, than those that did not, and that the amount of wealth that people had was a higher predictor of their confidence level in retirement, more so than race, marital status, and all these other factors. We also found, in all the focus groups, the most talked- about issue was social security and Medicare. Women were concerned that they were going to lose their benefits in this area. They were confused about some of the implications of and the provisions in these programs, for example, when to apply for social security and the age at which you apply matters and affects your annuity forever, and also early application of Medicare, for example, and what that might foretell if you did not sign up within the timeframes for Part D and the prescription drug coverage, and that if you joined later there was a higher cost associated with it. Social Security and Medicare dominated the discussions and are really key factors. In fact, the future benefits, expected benefits, for social security are going to be the highest asset for 40 percent of the women 70 years or older. It is essential and it becomes more important as they age, because they spend all their other investment money and others earlier so they are left in their later stages of life, in the 80's in particular, with social security being the predominant amount. We heard a lot about the fact that these women would have wanted more financial education earlier in their lifespans, and that they would have done many things differently and had advice for other women to make sure they save, they invest, they manage their debt properly and they understand these programs and get more education. Health care was another dominant topic, particularly prescription drugs and the fact that of the 161 women who answered our question about their confidence in health care, Medicare, only 28 percent were confident that Medicare covers their costs right now. They were concerned about not having adequate coverage in that area, and then also housing, as you pointed out, Chairman Collins, is a big issue. A lot of people own homes, the women that we talked with, but they were concerned not just with the mortgage but property taxes, maintenance costs, and other factors that they felt that were straining their ability to do it, so because of all these factors, a lot of these women felt very insecure about the future and uncertain about it. I am sure that that has been exacerbated by the pandemic that we are experiencing right now as well. We have a short video where you can hear directly from some of these women about their experiences, and then I would be happy to answer questions. The Chairman. Thank you very much. [Video plays.] [Video may be viewed on the Senate Aging website.] The Chairman. Thank you very much for that video. I really appreciated the fact that you made such an attempt to go out across the country and get information from women first-hand. There were several important themes that came out in the presentations that we just had. We had thought of having a panel of women, and this gave us the panel that we needed in this COVID environment, so thank you for that as well. Just as a reminder, I will be recognizing members to ask questions in order of seniority, and we will alternate between the majority and the minority. If a Senator is not present or logged in to WebEx when it is his or her turn to ask questions they will be placed at the end of the queue, and Senators will be given 5 minutes each on this first round. After I do my questions we will go to Bob Casey and then Tim Scott, who is logged in online is going to be the next person, and then Richard Blumenthal. I just want to give members some idea here of how we will be proceeding. I was very interested to hear several of the women talk about the need for more financial education. One of them said that if she had better understood the matching part for 401(k) plans that she would have contributed more money. How often did you find the lack of financial education to be an issue as you talked to these 190 women? Mr. Dodaro. [Inaudible, off microphone]. The Chairman. [Ms. Nguyen introducing herself] [microphone was off] Thank you, and if you would introduce yourself again and make sure that your mic is on. Thank you. Ms. Nguyen. Good morning, Chairwoman Collins. In response to your question we found that in all 14 focus groups, women in the 14 focus groups--we found that women in all 14 focus groups raised concern about financial--lack of financial education. Specifically, they raised concerns that knowing to ask the right questions can be very difficult, as well as finding the right trustworthy financial advisor was also a challenge. The other issue that is associated with financial literacy, that they raised, is also cognitive decline, challenges such as Alzheimer or Dementia, and these conditions can make it difficult for older workers, older Americans, to be more vulnerable to financial exploitation. The Chairman. Thank you. I will share a very poor financial decision that I made early on, and that is after working on Capitol Hill for more than 10 years, so I clearly would have been vested, I took all of my money out of the account in order to buy a car. I would have been so much better off just taking a car loan rather than withdrawing all that money, which would have applied toward my retirement security. I keep thinking that if just one person had said to me, ``You know, that is not a smart decision, and it is one that will affect the amount of your ultimate pension,'' I would have made a different choice. We are now encouraging automatic enrollment in 401(k) plans. Mr. Comptroller General, do you think that that will help women, and men for that matter, be more secure than if they are just presented with a package of information about the 401(k) plan that their employer offers? Mr. Dodaro. Yes, I do. I believe auto-enrollment is a very important component of getting people started into the process, and our research supports that and I highly recommend it. The Chairman. Another issue that you referred to briefly in your opening statement had to do with the age at which a senior decides to claim social security benefits. We held a hearing on this, and it makes a huge difference in your amount of benefit if you are able to wait until a later time, age 70, to claim the benefit. Could you elaborate on that? Obviously, some people that is not a practical option for, but if you are able to wait to claim your benefit at age 70, what kind of impact does it have on your benefit level? Mr. Dodaro. One of my colleagues has the number. I do not know off the top of my head but it is a big difference between taking it, you know, at 65 or even earlier, and to waiting to 70. I mean, it is a significant increase. I will provide that for the record. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Casey. Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I wanted to start with a question about unpaid time out of the workforce, and I would start by noting that we know that the pandemic has made it more clear than ever, probably, that workers need to have paid sick leave as well as paid family and medical leave. They should not have to choose between caring and paying, caring for themselves or loved ones and paying their bills, and so many are forced into that terrible choice. The burden of caregiving, as I mentioned earlier, falls disproportionately on women, and that reality, I think, is probably more apparent in the midst of this pandemic than otherwise. We know that Congress acted, to a certain extent, in this area when Congress, earlier this year passed legislation that included emergency COVID-19 paid leave. Too many workers were not able to take advantage of it and it will expire at the end of the year. I have joined my colleagues, including colleagues like Senator Gillibrand, in pushing to expand that emergency leave and create permanent paid leave by passing legislation like the bill entitled Providing Americans Insured Days of Paid Leave Act, by the acronym PAID Leave Act. I would ask Comptroller Dodaro, in light of this if you could provide more detail on how unpaid time out of the workforce can reduce women's income and retirement and why this issue is so relevant to women in particular. Mr. Dodaro. It is a very important issue, especially to women, who are more likely to be a caregiver. You know, of the 190 people we spoke to, 38 of them had been caregivers for a median time of about 10 years. When you are out of the workforce you are then, you know, not only affecting your wages that then provide the basis for your social security benefits but you are also not able to contribute to a retirement plan, you are not able to, you know, basically, you know, continue to have your benefits while you are in the workforce for health care and other matters, it has a tremendous effect, plus what we found for caregivers was that they also had out-of-pocket costs that they had to put out in order to help provide that care. It has a tremendous effect, and since women are more likely to be caregivers than men, any time out of the workforce is a problem for them in saving for retirement. Senator Casey. Thank you. I wanted to move to a second question on social security and the importance of it. We know that it is the bedrock of our retirement system, and as I said earlier, we should strengthen social security benefits. I have got a bill that goes by yet another acronym, the SWIFT Act, and this bill, in particular, would enable widows and widows with disabilities to receive higher social security benefits. The bill would also ensure that recently widowed individuals receive better information on the benefits available to them and how their claiming decisions, which can be very perilous, these claiming decisions can permanently affect their retirement income, as we have talked about. I would ask Comptroller Dodaro, what does research say about the importance of social security benefits to widows, and did you find, in the interviews that GAO conducted, that these women who were interviewed had concerns about how best to claim social security benefits? Mr. Dodaro. Yes. Social security is essential for women, particularly those that are widowed, especially in the later part of their lifespan. Now we looked at, you know, women when they were 65, and basically I think about 58 percent were unmarried at that time. By the time they were in their 80's that jumped to over 70 percent of them were unmarried at that time. The research also shows that currently, for women 70 or older in households, that the amount of social security future benefits, the present value of those future benefits accounts for the most significant part of wealth for over 40 percent of households with women 70 or older, so it is essential. Also what we found through the research is that women will spend down their savings and their investments first, their homes second, and then they will be left, later in life, with their social security benefits as the primary source. The longer they live the more important social security is. For many women it is important right now, or as soon as they retire, but the longer they live the more important it becomes. Senator Casey. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman Collins. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Casey. Senator Scott had to leave for another meeting so we will next turn to Senator Braun. Thank you for being with us today. Senator Braun. Thank you, Madam Chair. I always like it when you are here to testify because you have got the best command of facts and figures I think of anybody I have met in the U.S. Government. We have so many places where we need to call upon that. I remember when we were discussing the number of improper payments, and I will never forget that statistic that it was close to, I think, 3 percent of all checks that we write here either are to the wrong payee or for the wrong amount. I kind of knew that before I got here. I have been here nearly 2 years now, and that is the kind of stuff I think the American public needs to hear more of. When it comes to planning for retirement, I think I have got a strong kind of feeling on the fact that the institution, social security in general, which drives so much of our structural budget deficit, because no longer is that trust fund being built. In fact, we are depleting it. I think, you know, here, in a little over a decade, what we are going to do to it what we have done to the Medicare trust fund. Medicare trust fund is now due to be completely exhausted in a little over 5 years. I think that is another thing that the American public needs to realize, because so many people count on both of them, and they just assume that they will be there. When it comes to the topic here, I think that the only way that you hedge your bets when it comes to anyone's retirement is that you have got to increasingly look to maybe not rely on something that looks to me like we will get up to the cliff. We will come to a crisis before we do anything about it. I think, in general, as it relates to women's retirement, anyone, because we are all in this together, in terms of how it might impact us, what do you think is the first issue that is going to come to the forefront? Do you think it will be the Medicare trust fund becoming the issue or the Social Security trust fund? Then what, in your opinion, are our options once we are there at the crisis and looking over the cliff? Mr. Dodaro. The first issue that will face the Congress will be the multiemployer pension system. That is expected to be insolvent by 2026. Now what that will happen--and I will get to Medicare and Social Security in just a second, but I do not want to miss the multiemployer portion--what that means is because the multiemployer plans do not take the assets over, that they would only be able to pay someone an annuity if their company goes bankrupt, and during this economic turmoil right now they will only be able to pay people $2,000 a year, on average, which is hardly adequate for a month pension, let alone a yearly pension, so the multiemployer part of the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation is urgent. That is closely followed by the Medicare Hospital Trust Fund. Before the pandemic it was estimated by the trustees that by 2026, as you mentioned, Senator Braun, right around the corner, that that fund would only have 89 cents on the dollar to pay, so they would not be able to fully pay benefits. CBO more recently made estimates that because of the economic downturn, payroll taxes are not going into those funds, either Medicare or social security, at the same rate they were anticipated, so that date will be advanced. How much? CBO is estimating now around 2024, so that would move up at least 2 years. Those dates are going to move up faster because of our economic downturn. The longer we are in the downturn and the lower economic growth, the lower the payroll taxes will be to these funds, so they will come closer, not go further away. Social Security, before the pandemic, was estimated by 2034 they would only have enough funds to pay for 77 percent of benefits, so that would be like a 23 percent cut. You have heard me talk about how important that is for women in particular, but for a lot of retirees. I know, you know, Congress will not let these things happen because of the catastrophic effect it would have on elderly people, but it is going to require either increased revenues or changes in benefits. The sooner we do these things, the better. It will allow people to adjust over time, because people under the situation now for retirement have more of a burden themselves to be able to save money. They assume certain things are going to be there but there are big decisions awaiting the Congress to deal with these fundamental pillars of retirement security in America. Senator Braun. Thank you. It is also interesting to me that this has not snuck up on us. Actuarially, we have known this for a long time, way before COVID came along and has accentuated it. Maybe Senator Collins and I can galvanize the political will we need around this place to do something about it. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator. You always add a lot to our hearings. Comptroller General, I want to switch topics to another issue that this Committee has devoted a great deal of attention to that can hurt the retirement security of women as well as men, and that is senior scams and fraud. Over the past 7 years this Committee has held 25 different hearings examining scams that are targeting our Nation's seniors, and these scams not only exact an emotional toll on the victims and their families but they also threaten their retirement security. We have heard from seniors in Maine and across the country who have lost their hard-earned savings to a scam. We have a toll-free fraud hotline that people can call and we will try to assist them. We issue a fraud book every year to try to alert seniors to the most frequent kinds of frauds and scams. What we have found is these con artists, these outright criminals are infinitely creative in the kinds of scams that they come up with. An example is Philip Hatch from Portland, Maine, who testified before this Committee about losing $8,000 of his retirement savings to a scammer who was impersonating an IRS agent. The most frequent scam that we are hearing about now involves social security, and that has been the No. 1 scam that we are seeing right now, where a senior will be tricked into giving out his or her social security number, and, of course, that is often the keys to the kingdom. Comptroller General, does GAO have any recommendations for additional steps that the Federal Government can take to prevent seniors from losing their hard-earned retirement savings to these ruthless criminals? Mr. Dodaro. Yes. There is some legislation that is working its way through the Congress that I think would be very helpful, the Stopping Senior Scams Act. I think it was co- sponsored by Senator Casey. It has passed the Senate unanimously. Hopefully there is a bill being introduced in the House, a companion bill. I think that legislation would be very helpful. It would set up an advisory committee made up of the key Federal entities that are involved in this effort. It would ensure better coordination across the Federal Government, which I think is essential. We find that typically that is one of--the most pressing problems now across government and the most complex involve multiple agencies to work together to deal with this, and we are--the government is not all that great all the time at having that kind of cooperation and coordination. This would help in that area. There is also a piece of legislation that has been introduced about preventing emergency scams involving seniors during the pandemic, which I think would be good. What I have seen over my career, which is quite lengthy, as you mentioned, is that when there is a natural disaster, when there is an emergency, that during the pandemic people have high anxiety. They are concerned. They are very vulnerable. This is when these people ramp up their activities to try to take advantage of this. You know, before I took my job as Comptroller General, I had a much higher opinion of human nature than I do now. They seem to be ever-creative, ever, you know, evolving their sceems to prey, and the elderly are among the most vulnerable people in this area. We have also had some recommendations to the Justice Department. They have a number of activities underway to improve their efforts, to set better goals that could be measured, to assess how well they are doing in helping states, where they provide grants to areas as well. I think that those type of things are essential. We are also doing work, at your request now, looking at HHS and their collection, whether they are collecting enough information about what is going on to be able to better target the Federal Government's efforts, and the full extent of elder exploitation, financial exploitation. I do not want to take--miss this opportunity to also commend the Committee for your efforts in this area. I think the hotline, the fraud book that you put out is essential and very, very thoughtfully approached and helpful. The Chairman. Thank you. I want to followup by highlighting two new scams that are directly related to the COVID-19 pandemic, because as you have just pointed out, these criminals will take advantage of any tragedy, any new development, any chaos that occurs, any problems that are facing our country. One being, is seniors are being called and told that they have to pay up front for a COVID test, when, in fact, those tests the cost of which we have appropriated billions of dollars, are in the vast majority of cases completely free. Second, they have been told that they have to pay now for a vaccine that is not even on the market yet, but in order to ensure that they will get the vaccine. Third, there are criminals who are exploiting the sympathies that seniors have for families that are struck by COVID-19 and are economically struggling, and trying to get them to contribute to a fund that will help a family, when, in fact, it is never going to that family. It is just lining the pockets of these criminals. I am very glad you mentioned the Justice Department efforts. I will take credit for causing them to name an elder abuse attorney in every U.S. Attorney's Office in the United States. When my former colleague, Jeff Sessions, was named Attorney General this was an issue that I talked to him about and urged him to pursue, and he did indeed do just that. Now we have a focal point in the U.S. Attorney's Office so that no longer are what, in the eyes of law enforcement, maybe viewed as small-dollar frauds but are devastating to the senior who is ripped off, ignored. They now are being pursued in U.S. Attorney's Offices all across the country, and I think that is big progress. I am going to ask one more question before yielding to-- well, I see that we have been joined by Senator Rosen, so let me yield to her. Senator Rosen. Senator Rosen. Thank you, Madam Chair, and of course the Ranking Member as well for bringing this important hearing here today. I would just like to thank you for the report and everything that you have been doing. I would like to focus a little bit on women in STEM. Prior GAO reports found that women are overrepresented in low-wage professions. They make less money than their male counterparts throughout their careers. They are more likely to leave the workforce to care for family members. Taken together these trends really have significant effects on women's financial security and retirement. According to the U.S. Department of Commerce, Economics, and Statistics Administration, workers in STEM fields--of course, science, technology, engineering, and math--earn more than their non-STEM counterparts, and the gender pay gap actually shrinks for women in these careers. Unfortunately, as a former computer programmer, I can attest that despite making up half the U.S. workforce, women still only hold a quarter of these jobs. That is one of the reasons why I introduced a bipartisan bill called the STEM RESTART Act, which would provide funding for small and medium- sized businesses to help women and others who left the workforce or to transition to the STEM workforce. This is also great not just for women, for people of color, those individuals in rural communities to restart their career for more lucrative fields. How else do you think we could diversify the economy to include more women to STEM careers, and that have a positive effect going forward on women's ability to save for retirement? Mr. Dodaro. I think one of the things that could be done is to better focus on the effectiveness of the Federal Government's efforts to expand STEM education and training and job opportunities. We have identified well over 100 Federal programs and activities, and the last time we reviewed this two-thirds of them had never been reviewed to determine whether they are effective or not. I think the Federal Government is making a lot of investments in this area but we are not sure we are getting a proper return on our investment, and that some of these programs are even too small to measure. We could have a better strategy. I think having a better strategy, having a better targeting of the Federal Government's activities, but also having important measurement of whether they are successfully achieving their objectives or not is essential to make sure they are producing the right outcomes. As you mentioned, Senator Rosen, I mean, the outcome is we want more women to be in the STEM fields. We are spending a lot of money and have a lot of programs in order to achieve that objective in various aspects of the economy, but we do not know whether that investment is paying dividends that we would like it to have. More evaluation of these programs and activities. Then you can better target, you can have better strategies that will produce better outcomes, so that would be my main message here in this particular area. It is not for lack of trying, that the fedeal governement has but I'm not sure it is as effective. Senator Rosen. I think we need to size our programs a little better--but we will try to do that in the future Mr. Dodaro. Yes. Senator Rosen [continuing]. Moving on I also want to talk about the cost of caregiving, because I did leave my career at one point to take care of my parents and my in-laws, as they got older and sicker. I took them to doctor appointments, coordinated care, all those things that caregivers do. My mother-in-law had Alzheimer's toward the end of her life, spent time in the memory care unit, and every day I hear similar stories, not just from Nevadans but people across the country. People saved for their retirement but then they have to--when they were working they had to leave work in order to care for family members, and that was nearly devastating to them. They dipped into their retirement funds. We know that women oftentimes are those caregivers for their immediate family and oftentimes their extended families. Do you have an opinion about what we should do to reflect the value of caregiving perhaps in social security or retirement savings plans that might help those of us who were caregivers who stepped away from our jobs and are not paying in to social security during that particular time? Mr. Dodaro. Yes. Yes. I think, you know, one suggestion with that is that there be allowed to be better catch-up opportunities for when caregivers come back into the workforce, enhancing their abilities to be able to make greater contributions to tax-deferred accounts. This occurs in the Federal Government, Thrift Savings Plan for people over 55, you can contribute, you know, more money. I think that would be helpful. As it relates to social security, you could increase the minimum social security benefit which would help over time. You could also give social security credits for caregiving during the period of time. There is also some opportunities for out- of-pocket costs that caregivers have, to give some tax credits and some tax relief in those areas as well. Those are among the suggestions that we have in that area, but it is definitely something that could be rectified by taking some of these actions that I suggest. Senator Rosen. Thank you very much. I appreciate your time and your suggestions. I yield back. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Rosen. Senator Hawley, welcome? Senator Hawley. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for hosting this important hearing today, for scheduling it, and thanks also to the Ranking Member. It is undeniably true that older Americans, and older women in particular, were facing significant retirement challenges prior to COVID-19, and those trends have only been made worse by the pandemic. I have to say, as someone who comes from a State that is largely rural, or at least has many large rural areas, rural areas have been particularly hard-hit by the ongoing financial insecurity driven by lack of jobs, rising health care costs, of course the pandemic, and you have alluded to this, Mr. Dodaro, in your written testimony, so I look forward to asking you about some of that today. You put all those things together and you really do the significant uncertainty, and it is no wonder that Americans, many older Americans, are worried about the future, which makes this hearing all the more important, so thank you again, Madam Chair, for hosting it, for holding it. Mr. Dodaro, let me just ask you about some of the challenges facing rural communities in particular. You mentioned in your written testimony the significant disparities in asset ownership for rural female households versus urban female households, and you also mentioned--I thought this was interesting--in the focus groups that you did and the data that you collected in the report that rural women tended to bring up the cost of health care more often than their non-rural or urban counterparts. Let me just give you a chance to comment on some of that. Can you just tell us a little bit more about some of those findings and these disparities between the concerns of urban female households and rural female households? Mr. Dodaro. Very good, Senator. I will address the financial equity issue and then I will ask one of my colleagues to talk about that, that participated in some of the focus groups, to talk about the health care objectives. First, as it relates to financial disparities, what we found through our analysis is that in rural households women 70 or older households, their asset base only had about 14 percent financial assets, and these are liquid assets. Liquidity was a big factor driving retirement confidence. In urban households, it was 36 percent, so it is a big difference, well over twice as high in those areas. This is Tamara Cross, who is in charge of this work and research and led the efforts on the focus groups, Senator. Ms. Cross. The research showed that, as the Comptroller General said, that there were significant differences between rural and urban, in that in rural households women 70 or older had relatively low liquidity, which is very important because if you have low liquidity you can end up being cash poor. We also found that incomes were lower in rural areas compared to urban. For example, in rural areas the median household income was about $38,000. In the urban areas it was $55,000. Wealth was also lower. The median household wealth was $87,000 in rural areas. In urban areas it was $99,000. The median household wealth increased in rural areas by about 25 percent, and surprisingly it only increased 13 percent in the urban areas. That was one area where the rural areas were doing better than the urban areas. The median household wealth increased only 3 percent in rural areas and 27 percent in urban areas. Then their incomes, the median household income increased about 2 percent in rural areas and about 10 percent in urban areas. You can see that the rural areas, you know, are greatly affected by the differences between rural and urban households. Senator Hawley. Yes, that is very striking. Thank you for that. I mean, just to recap, lower incomes in rural areas, lower wealth in rural areas, leading to lower liquidity and less cash in rural areas. Pretty significant disparities here that you are talking--14 percent, you said, of female households in rural areas have liquid assets compared to 36 percent in urban areas. That is very significant. That is double. Mr. Dodaro. I think the health care issue that you mentioned is driven by a number of factors. We have done a lot of work at GAO, too, about the closures of hospitals in rural areas, and I think that that may be a factor. Now people did not say that specifically but I am putting two and two together, and I think that is an issue. Then a lot of women in the rural areas are also uncertain about their family structure kind of issues and changes that might occur there if they were left in, you know, an unmarried status, for example, or if they had to take care of a child or whatever. That came up more in the focus groups, from what I understand, as well. Senator Hawley. Very good. Well, I see that my time has expired but thank you for your testimony today. Ms. Cross, thank you for being here. Thank you for your work. I will give you some more questions for the record. I would like to learn more about what you have found here. I think these are very, very important findings, so thank you for your work. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Dodaro. I would be happy to respond, Senator. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator. Senator Casey. Senator Casey. Madam Chair, thanks. I wanted to raise another issue which we have all referred to in one way or another and that is a basic issue that jumps out at us every day, but it does not receive enough attention, frankly--pay inequality. We know that that gap in pay undermines the ability of women to save for retirement. We also know--and I do not think any of us have mentioned this number yet--but women working full-time, year-round, receive only 82 percent of what men make. The gap between what women of color receive and what white men receive is, of course, even larger. One of the proposals to close the gap is a piece of legislation that is Senate Bill 270, the Paycheck Fairness Act, to ensure that women receive equal pay for equal work. That is one step we can all take to promote basic fairness and to reduce that gap. I was noting in your written testimony and in the report itself, Mr. Comptroller General, you include an example of how differences in men's and women's earnings can result in women being paid less to save for retirement. If you could speak further about the gap between the earnings and how that gap can compound over a full career and thereby undermine a woman's ability to prepare for retirement, or to save for retirement. Mr. Dodaro. Yes, I would be happy to. Based on our analysis of the current population survey information, the average pay for women in 2019 was $45,000 a year. Men was $55,000 a year. You have a fundamental difference. A large part of this is reflected in the fact that women are more represented in lower- paying occupations than men, but then there is the issue of equity, the equal pay for equal work issue that you brought up, which is also a factor. Now what we did was we simulated, over a career, if you took man and woman who were both working full-time over a 44- year career, assuming each put in 6 percent of their earnings into a savings retirement plan and earned 5 percent interest on that over the life of their careers, that at the end of the day the man would have $476,000 and the woman would have $395,000, so it affects long-term over that period of time. For people that were not working full-time, if you just looked at men and women over their careers, we did the same simulation, and that would show that the man would earn $343,000 and the woman $216,000. It has tremendous effects, just like compound interest has effect over time. If women do not have enough to put in, they do not have the benefit of compound interest to help them accumulate lifetime savings, so it makes a big difference, not only in the current situation, contemporary, but also longer term as it affects accumulating retirement savings. Senator Casey. In that first example, give me the numbers again. Mr. Dodaro. In the first example, if you had a man and a woman that had a 44-year career---- Senator Casey. Right. Mr. Dodaro [continuing]. they each put in 6 percent of their wages in a retirement plan and earned 5 percent, the man, at the end of that time, would have $476,000, and the woman would have $395,000. Senator Casey. Yep. Mr. Dodaro. There is a big gap in there, and that all starts--emanates from the pay disparity issue. It has compounding effect over time. Senator Casey. Thanks very much. Thanks, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Casey, and thank you, Comptroller General. I just want to touch briefly on two more issues. We have talked a lot this morning about the fact that women are much more likely to take time out from their careers to either raise children, take care of an elderly parent or a sick spouse, and Senator Rosen mentioned her own experience in that regard. There is another group of people who often lose out on retirement benefits and that is military spouses, because they move so frequently they often never are able to invest in an employer's retirement plan. This summer I introduced a bipartisan bill that would encourage small employers to provide the spouses of active duty servicemembers with accelerated eligibility for retirement plans and ownership of employer contributions to those plans. That aims to address the reality that military spouses often have to move every year or two, and they are never able to fully vest in their employer-sponsored retirement plans, so they lose the money that has been put aside. We would incentivize, through tax credits, small employers to accelerate the eligibility for military spouses. Based on GAO's recent report on women's retirement security, how does having a retirement plan to supplement social security affect retirement security? How big a factor is it? I know in my State the average social security recipient is receiving only $16,000 a year. Mr. Dodaro. It has a huge effect. What we have found, of the women who have low confidence in their ability to have retirement security, 46 percent had no retirement plan at all. For those people who had a defined benefit and defined contributions or an IRA, some women had all three, through the course of their career. Of those women who had retirement plans, 61 percent had high confidence. Without a plan, 46 percent low confidence; high confidence, 61 percent, or with a plan 61 percent high confidence. It makes a huge difference. It is a stark difference, Senator, and I applaud you for taking on the issue of military spouses. Our military makes a lot of sacrifices, and their families, and I think recognizing that with some effort. We have also pointed out for people who change their jobs frequently sometimes they leave their contributions in the retirement savings and do not roll them over into their new retirement plan. We have made some recommendations on that area as well. That is part of financial literacy and education as well, but a lot of people left. We found, I think it was several--about 16 million accounts, that was $8.5 billion that people left in their retirement savings, that could have been rolled over to their new accounts. Helping the military in that fashion, I think, is a noble goal. The Chairman. Thank you. Well, that 61 percent versus 46 percent is an extraordinary figure to guide our work as well. I am glad that you ended on the issue of financial literacy, because that is a theme that I noticed was repeated in your report, and also the importance of starting financial education at an early age. It really is not very helpful if we learn, when we are in our 50's or 60's, what we should have done back then. The Maine Credit Union League has created Financial Fitness Fairs to help students learn about budgeting, saving, and other aspects of financial literacy. Since the program's inception in 2004, more than 65,000 Maine students have participated, and I think they will make far better choices and decisions than I did when I was leaving the congressional staff and unwisely withdrew my retirement savings. Past GAO reports have noted the importance of partnerships among Federal, State, local, nonprofit, and private organization providing financial literacy. Based on your previous work and the findings from the latest report, does GAO have any recommendations on how we can better coordinate Federal and private efforts, or State efforts, or high school efforts even, to expand financial education and target individuals when they are younger and can avoid making those mistakes, such as not rolling over their retirement savings? Mr. Dodaro. Yes. I think it is very important to have these partnership efforts. There is a bill that Senator Jones has introduced to deal with youth that would give grants to people to do things. Part of the complication here is the Federal Government does not have a strong role in curriculum-setting at the State and local level, which is their purview and their prerogative. The Federal Government can give grants and other means to try to stimulate having greater education efforts at that local level, and that proposed legislation would help in that vein. The other thing that could be done is that the Federal agencies could work with the private sector and the states through employers to provide employer-based education. A few years ago I had a forum where I invited experts in financial literacy to talk about this issue, and they said the powerful impact of employers could have, and, of course, people start working at young ages to, that it could have this effect. Based on that I started a program at GAO in 2012 to provide financial education for our people. Now we have--75 percent or more of our people have advanced degrees, but they still, you know, face challenges in navigating some of life's biggest decisions, on purchasing a home, saving for college education, dealing with life insurance, health insurance issues, how to take advantage of your retirement systems and approach that you have. I think that is a very important issue. Also, we have recommendations in the women's area, and this could be worked at the Federal and State level as well, on the Qualified Domestic Relations Orders. This is where there is a divorce and there is a division of assets. What our research found, Senator, is that very few people were aware of these Qualified Domestic Relations Orders, do not use them, which provides a court judgment order or degree that better protects the spouses in that particular time. Usually it is the woman who would be, you know, protected in this particular case. We recommended that the Department of Labor provide more information out there, and this could be done, you know, earlier in people's lifespans as well, because people marry early and things, but I think getting education in the school system is important, but the Federal Government could be a catalyst that can't, you know, provide any dictas to the State and local level. I know the State and local level, based on some of the conversations I had, there are efforts underway, through some of their organizations, to have curriculum to increase financial literacy. Many years ago, when I joined GAO, and I was not sure whether I wanted to stay long term, I had an idea on developing a financial literacy course that I would teach as a teacher in high school. My father is a teacher, my mother and sister are teachers, so I was following on that path. That was, you know, 48 years ago, and it is still a really important issue. In fact, it has become more complicated because people have to make more of their own decisions, for retirement and the financial implications of the situation. The Federal Government can do a lot as leveraging their reach and their ability to do it. There is also the Financial Literacy and Education Commission that we have done work on. This is led by Treasury and vice-chaired by the Consumer Financial Product organization. We have made recommendations there for better coordination, and they could become a catalyst in also working with the State and local levels and nonprofits and others to get more information. Finally I would mention there is the Women's Retirement Security Act that has been introduced. That would give grants to nonprofits that would have outreach to women to provide financial literacy education, counseling, advice and counsel to a wide range of women. That way, I think that is intended mostly to deal with adult, or women who are older in their career. I think, you know, we all learn from our grandparents and our parents, and if they can also impart on their own children the importance of education, so the more we can educate everybody, no matter where they are in their lifespan, the better off we are going to be, but educating the older women would have great advice. They have great sway over their grandchildren and children, and imparting to them the importance of getting it to. You get it from the schools but getting it from your own parents and your family unit I think would be helpful as well. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Sinema. Senator Sinema. Thank you. Thank you to our Chair and our Ranking Member for this important hearing on the challenges facing women in retirement, and thank you to our Comptroller Dodaro for testifying today on the 2020 GAO report on retirement security, which included the perspective of everyday women across the country. Women, in particular, face unique challenges in preparing for retirement, including lower career earnings due to unequal pay and the expectation that they will shoulder most of the responsibilities in raising a family and caregiving. We have seen this throughout the pandemic, where many women in Arizona are balancing working from home, helping their children with distance learning, and for older women, supporting their grandchildren as well. The economic effects of the pandemic will also have long- term impacts on retirement security, in particular, how to recover from the impact of lost earnings, unemployment, and reduced savings. In Arizona we have also seen an increase in coronavirus- related scams targeting seniors. Criminal fraudsters are seeking to take advantage of the public health emergency by peddling dangerous, unproven cures, or even trying to steal people's unemployment benefits or stimulus checks. My question for you is that the GAO report notes that when seeking professional financial advice women in 10 focus groups had negative experiences, which they said include receiving poor advice, paying high fees, or becoming a victim of fraud. That is why we introduced the Senior Security Act, which builds a task force at the SEC to protect seniors from financial investment scams. We also promoted the National Senior Fraud Awareness Day to help educate seniors on coronavirus scams and protect their savings and investments. Can you talk about how having financial assets, including investments, contributes to retirement confidence? Mr. Dodaro. Well, the financial investments is a key driver in confidence level for women. In fact, it was the most important driver that we saw. This was particularly true for liquid assets. Liquidity is a big issue, and by liquidity we mean checking accounts, savings accounts, stocks, bonds, and other investments that they had. Women with higher liquidity had a much, much higher confidence in their ability to provide a secure retirement for themselves, so it was a huge factor, Senator Sinema. Senator Sinema. Well, thank you. I very much appreciate that and I appreciate the work you have done on this report. Chairman Collins and Ranking Member Casey, before I yield back my time I want to address something that occurred late last night. My team received information last night that the Committee had changed its requirements for verifying Senators' attendance in our Committee, and I was concerned about this because it appears to allege that Senators lack integrity or lacked fairness or the willingness to be honest about their participation in the Committee. My question is, has there been an instance in which Senators have lied about their attendance in this Committee or was this change made as a prospective concern with the expectation that some Senators would lie about their attendance or participation in this Committee? The Chairman. Senator Sinema, I apologize if you were given that impression. We are adapting to a new era where we have some Senators showing up physically in the hearing room, as we did today, others joining us remotely. What we are trying to ensure is that as attendance is kept at these hearings, and as you know I always go out of my way to acknowledge every single Senator who participates, and I am grateful for their participation, this becomes more difficult to do when I look at the television screen and the initials do not match the Senators' initials. If that Senator does not come on either verbally, as you have today, or as most Senators do both with audio and video, I cannot tell whether that is a staffer just tuning in to monitor the hearing or whether a Senator is waiting to make comments. I would be happy to talk with you further about that, and I certainly apologize if you took, as you obviously did, offense at it, because I have a great deal of respect for you and for each and every member of this Committee. It was simply an attempt to make sure that we know, particularly when someone such as you did today, chooses not to turn on their video, and we see initials that may not match the Senators, we do not have any idea whether it is a Senator who is participating. Let me give you a great example. Doug Jones--and I was going to acknowledge him--was on earlier, but it was his staff's initials that were showing, so we knew that he planned to speak today. He then got called away, so I was able--I am able to acknowledge that he was present. If the Senator is neither speaking nor showing us any video, and the initials do not match that of the Senators, I have no way of knowing whether or not the Senator is present, either remotely--when they are joining us remotely. I would be happy to work with you, if you have got a better suggestion for how to do that. I go out of my way to try to be fair to both sides and to acknowledge the presence of everyone who is here. For example, Senator Blumenthal was here earlier and had to leave. He was here in person. Tim Scott was online, because he wanted to hear the Comptroller General's statement, but then had to leave. I am going out of my way to acknowledge everyone, so I am very surprised at your reaction and harsh criticism, suggesting that somehow I am trying to not acknowledge Senators. In fact, the opposite is the case. Senator Sinema. I appreciate that explanation, Chairman. My concern is the idea that there would not be an acknowledgement when a Senator says, ``I am here. I am participating in this Committee,'' and to not be believed about that, which is a concern. The Chairman. That is not at all what was conveyed to you, and I would certainly go out of my way to acknowledge everyone. In fact, I was just about to say that I saw briefly that Kirsten Gillibrand, our Senator from New York State, did join us briefly. She was not able to stay. I want everyone to know that she did turn in for a time. I realize people have different schedules and busy schedules, and we are trying to accommodate everyone in this new world. Obviously, in the old world we lived in, this was very easy because everyone would be here, physically present. Some, such as yourself, have chosen not to be, but I realize that does not mean that you are not interested. It does not mean that you are not participating, and that is why I just called upon you. Senator Sinema. I appreciate that, Chairman. I would be willing and interested to followup with your staff to find a way where we can solve this issue, as many other Committees have, in a way that acknowledges the participation of everyone who is joining. There are some Senators---- The Chairman. With all due respect, I acknowledged your participation. I called on you. You have just had an exchange. Despite the fact that your video is not on, you are clearly paying attention and asked great questions, as you always do, and gave a statement that gave you additional time, so I really don't think there is an issue here. Senator Sinema. Well, we can followup. The Chairman. I am happy to talk with you further. Senator Sinema. Thank you. The Chairman. I am now going to, seeing no other Senators seeking to be recognized, I now am going to do my closing statement and then turn to Senator Casey for his closing statement. First, let me thank the Comptroller General for joining us and for the report, and most of all for getting out there and doing focus groups with 190 women across the country. Women face unique challenges in preparing for and maintaining a financially secure retirement, particularly in this era, where private sector defined benefit plans are increasingly rare, so more of the responsibility is falling on the individuals. There are many steps that we have discussed today that can make a positive difference. First, to help increase retirement security we need to do more to tackle the skyrocketing costs of prescription drugs, and that is an area where our Committee has really led the way. Second, we need to protect and strengthen social security, including finally fixing the unfair government pension offset and windfall elimination provisions. Third, we need to look to increase retirement savings and access to employer-based retirement savings plans. We made some progress last year with the enactment of the SECURE Act, but more needs to be done, including passage of my bill to make it easier for military spouses to access employer-sponsored retirement plans. Fourth, we need to continue to look for ways to support our family caregivers. This has been a priority of mine in the Senate, and I look forward to the release of the national strategy to support family caregivers. Fifth, we have heard today repeatedly about the importance of financial education and making sure that people are planning at young ages for their retirement. There are other important actions we can take, including continuing this Committee's work to combat scams that target our Nation's seniors and increasing funding to provide low-income seniors with safe places to live independently. I want to thank our Ranking Member, Senator Casey, and all the Committee members on both side of the aisle for their participation today. Senator Casey. Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins, for holding this hearing. Probably could not have a more important topic at this time in our Nation's history. I want to thank, as well, Comptroller Dodaro, for the testimony today and for his continuing exemplary public service. As we heard from him today, by virtue of the report and the good work of his team, women face significant challenges in preparing for retirement, and these challenges leave them more vulnerable to falling into poverty and old age. As we know that the ongoing pandemic will exacerbate many of the issues we discussed today, I hope GAO will consider conducting a similar line of work through a COVID-19 lens in the near future. We must work together to comprehensively address the shortcomings of our retirement system and ensure that all women are able to achieve financial security in retirement. In the short term, we should pass a comprehensive relief bill that helps working families and prevents additional permanent damage to their economic health. In the meantime, and over time, I should say, this will take a while, but we should outline some broad goals. First, we should, as I indicated earlier and as I now many agree, strengthen and safeguard social security. Second, protect workers' hard-earned pensions. A point that Mr. Dodaro made about the multiemployer pension system is an important one. Third, we have to close the pay gap, and fourth, create permanent paid sick and paid family and medical leave. I look forward, as I know many members do, to continuing to work with our colleagues in the Senate on these critical issues. Thank you, Chairman Collins. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Casey. Committee members have until Friday, October 2nd, to submit any additional questions for the record. I again want to thank our witness, Ranking Member Casey, and all the Committee members who participated in today's hearing, whether they were here physically in the Committee room or joining us remotely. Finally, let me thank our Committee staff on both sides of the aisle for their hard work, and also the GAO staff. I know that the Comptroller General would want me to acknowledge their hard work as well. As I said, I particularly appreciate the focus groups that they conducted throughout the country, involving some 190 women, so we could have the benefit of their perspective. This concludes our hearing today. Thank you. [Whereupon, at 11:08 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Additional Statements for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]