Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE HOME: HOME HEALTH CARE IN RURAL AMERICA [Senate Hearing 116-536] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 116-536 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE HOME: HOME HEALTH CARE IN RURAL AMERICA ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ FEBRUARY 12, 2020 __________ Serial No. 116-18 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 47-056 PDF WASHINGTON : 2022 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine, Chairman TIM SCOTT, South Carolina ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania RICHARD BURR, North Carolina KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York MARTHA McSALLY, Arizona RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut MARCO RUBIO, Florida ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri DOUG JONES, Alabama MIKE BRAUN, Indiana KYRSTEN SINEMA, Arizona RICK SCOTT, Florida JACKY ROSEN, Nevada ---------- Sarah Khasawinah, Majority Acting Staff Director Kathryn Mevis, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman.......... 1 Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member 6 PANEL OF WITNESSES Leigh Ann Howard, RN, DNP, CHFN-K, Director, Home Health and Speciality Programs, Northern Light Home Care & Hospice, Waterboro, Maine............................................... 4 William Dombi, President, National Association for Home Care & Hospice, Washington, D.C....................................... 7 Warren Herbert, DNP, RN, CAE, FAAN, Assistant Professor, Loyola University, and CEO, Home Health Care Association of Louisiana, Lafayette, Louisiana........................................... 9 Francis Adams, Home Care Worker, Washington, Pennsylvania........ 11 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Leigh Ann Howard, RN, DNP, CHFN-K, Director, Home Health and Speciality Programs, Northern Light Home Care & Hospice, Waterboro, Maine............................................... 33 William Dombi, President, National Association for Home Care & Hospice, Washington, D.C....................................... 39 Warren Herbert, DNP, RN, CAE, FAAN, Assistant Professor, Loyola University, and CEO, Home Health Care Association of Louisiana, Lafayette, Louisiana........................................... 50 Francis Adams, Home Care Worker, Washington, Pennsylvania........ 55 Questions for the Record Francis Adams, Home Care Worker, Washington, Pennsylvania........ 63 William Dombi, President, National Association for Home Care & Hospice, Washington, D.C....................................... 64 Leigh Ann Howard, RN, DNP, CHFN-K, Director, Home Health and Speciality Programs, Northern Light Home Care & Hospice, Waterboro, Maine............................................... 65 Additional Statements for the Record Senator Tim Scott's Statement for the Record..................... 69 National Community Pharmacists Association....................... 70 American Assoication of Nurse Practitioners...................... 74 American Academy of PAs.......................................... 81 Submitted Public Comment of Christopher E. Laxton................ 83 The American Occupational Therapy Association, Inc............... 85 America's Health Insurance Plans................................. 88 Leading Age Submission of Statement for the Record............... 96 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE HOME: HOME HEALTH CARE IN RURAL AMERICA ---------- WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 12, 2020 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:02 a.m., in Room SD-366, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Susan M. Collins, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Collins, Hawley, Braun, Rick Scott, Casey, Gillibrand, Blumenthal, Jones, Sinema, and Rosen. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SUSAN M. COLLINS, CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The Committee will come to order. Good morning. Let me explain to everyone the early start for this hearing. The Senate has scheduled a series of votes to begin at 10:30. We did not expect that and we had witnesses on the way, so we did not want to postpone the hearing, so I am going to start with my opening statement. I expect the Ranking Member, Senator Casey, will be here shortly, and when he is able to get here I will interrupt the hearing and allow him to deliver his opening statement but I want to thank all of our witnesses and those who are here today for your flexibility. Unfortunately, I do not control the floor schedule, and usually our votes are in the afternoon, not the morning, but today is different. First, let me bid you all a good morning. Year after year, when seniors are asked how they want to spend their golden years, they overwhelmingly answer ``at home.'' Today's hearing will focus on how we can better help our seniors achieve that goal. I saw first-hand the importance of home care in my very first home visit during my second year of Senate service. In my hometown in Aroostook County I saw how home health care allowed an older couple in their 80's to spend the rest of their lives together in the comfort, security, and privacy of their own home. They were worried that otherwise they would be separated and one of them living in a nursing home. I remembered them telling me that all they wanted was to spend the rest of their lives together in their own home. Highly skilled and caring visiting nurses make such a difference in the lives of patients and families like this couple. In Maine, home health workers often go to extraordinary lengths for their rural patients, sometimes relying on lobster boats and mail planes to reach them. Home health care not only helps seniors live in the comfort of their own homes but it also saves money. According to research from the University of Rochester, older adults who receive one to two hours of in-home physical therapy, for example, are up to 82 percent less likely to face hospital readmissions 60 days after discharge. Studies from post-acute care discharge patterns have shown that clinically appropriate deployment of home health care can yield potential savings of more than $32 billion over 10 years. In the face of workforce shortages and payment cuts, today's hearing will highlight challenges that are facing the home health community. For those in rural areas where more than one in five older adults live, home health can be a lifeline, and we must do more to meet growing needs. As we look to the future, the demand for home health services will only continue to grow as our population ages. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the need for home- based aides is projected to grow by 97 percent over the next 10 years, making it the third-fastest-growing occupation. Yet while we recognize the value that home health can provide, many home health agencies are struggling in the current reimbursement and regulatory environment, precisely at the moment when we need their services more than ever. I am concerned about the implementation of the new patient- driven groupings model and the ability of rural agencies to absorb preemptive rate cuts of more than 4 percent based off assumptions that somehow agencies will try to maximize reimbursement. Agencies have weathered several years of reimbursement reductions through both regulatory changes as well as sequestration, and we cannot assume that they can continue to provide the same level of home health services at reduced rates. That is why I have introduced the Home Health Payment Innovation Act, which has been co-sponsored by 31 Senators, including committee members Tim Scott, Jones, Sinema, Burr, Rosen, and Rubio. My legislation would prevent further inequitable payment rate cuts. It would provide flexibility on waiving the homebound requirement for services. According to a survey of home health administrators by the Walsh Center for Rural Health, more than two-thirds reported that there were rural patients who could benefit from home health services but simply did not meet the criteria for being homebound. Furthermore, one-third reported that it could be inconvenient or even dangerous for some senior patients to be driving. However, because they did not drive, they did not qualify for services--because they did drive, they did not qualify for services. As home health agencies are adjusting to the new payment system, I believe that Congress should revisit the rural add-on payment. A well-targeted rural add-on payment is especially needed now, and it is needed to compensate home health agencies that are operating in vast rural areas, such as northern Maine, where they have to drive long distances between patients. I have also introduced the Home Health Care Planning Improvement Act, which has 41 co-sponsors, including Senators Casey, Sinema, and Gillibrand. This bill would improve the access Medicare beneficiaries have to home health care by allowing physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and clinical nurse specialists to order home health care services. That would be particularly helpful in rural and underserved areas of our Nation. In many instances in rural areas, a patient's primary health provider may not be a physician. Yet today only physicians are allowed to certify home health care for Medicare patients, even though they may not be the most familiar with the patient's case. In fact, they may not be familiar at all with the patient or his or her condition. These requirements create obstacles, delays, and administrative burdens to receiving home health care services. Last summer, Health Affairs featured an article that put a human face on the unintended consequences of its policy. A rural patient waited several days before a physician was available to sign an order for home health care. By that time, an open wound on his hip had doubled in size and deepened. Instead of taking two to 3 weeks to heal it took nearly 3 months, so this policy has real consequences for the health of our patients. By helping patients to avoid more costly hospital visits and nursing homes, home health saves Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurers millions of dollars each year and allows seniors to age in the comfort and security of their own homes. I have never understood why administration after administration targets home health care for reimbursement cuts. If there are bad apples in the industry, go after those agencies. Do not penalize everyone. That makes no sense whatsoever when home health care reflects the choice that the patient wants and is the most appropriate care, and saves money. I am looking forward to hearing from each of our witnesses today, and I am going to introduce our witnesses, and as I said, when Senator Casey arrives we will interrupt and have him deliver his opening statement. First I am very pleased to welcome Leigh Ann Howard from the great State of Maine. Leigh Ann is the Director of Home Health and Specialty Programs at Northern Light Home Care & Hospice. In this capacity, she is responsible for directing the development of new and innovative telemedicine and health programs. I am really interested in telemedicine and what that could do to help solve some of the distance problems that we have. Leigh Ann has been on the forefront of bringing telemedicine and home health to Mainers, and I am delighted that she is able to be with us today. Next we will hear from William Dombi. I know Bill very well and have worked with him for many years. He is the President of the National Association for Home Care & Hospice. This association represents more than 33,000 home care and hospice providers, as well as more than 2 million nurses, therapists, and aides that they employ nationwide. He is also the Director of the Center for Health Care Law and Executive Director of the Home Care & Hospice Financial Managers Association. He is a longstanding champion in the field of home care. Next we will hear from Dr. Warren Hebert. I told Dr. Hebert that because I am from northern Maine I know how to pronounce his last name, since Louisiana and Northern Maine both have a lot of Acadian influence. He is an Assistant Professor as well as being the CEO of the Home Health Care Association of Louisiana. He has worked in home care since 1985, and has offered his expertise to panels and reports for many institutions, including the Institute for Medicine and CMS. Our final witness is from Pennsylvania. Mr. Francis Adams is a home care worker from Washington, Pennsylvania. I know that Senator Casey has a fuller introduction of you that he will want to give, so I will hold up but express my gratitude for your being here today as well. Ms. Howard, we are going to start with you. STATEMENT OF LEIGH ANN HOWARD, RN, DNP, CHFN-K, DIRECTOR, HOME HEALTH AND SPECIALTY PROGRAMS, NORTHERN LIGHT HOME CARE & HOSPICE, WATERBORO, MAINE Ms. Howard. Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and members of the U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging, good morning. My name is Leigh Ann Howard and I want to thank you for this opportunity to speak to you today to share our experiences as a provider of home health care in rural America. I currently serve as the Director of Home Health and Specialty Programs at Northern Light Home Care and Hospice, which a Medicare-certified home care and hospice agency. As a member of Northern Light Health, a Maine-based integrated health care system, our home health and hospice programs provide care throughout the entire State of Maine. Maine citizens are among the oldest in the country living in a large rural geography. Over the last year, Northern Light Home Care and Hospice clinicians drove over three million miles to provide care, making close to 200,000 home care and hospice visits. At times the transportation to get to these patients' homes is just as unique as the geography of the State of Maine. For example, to serve many of our island communities off the coast of Maine, our clinicians need to travel by lobster boat or mail boat as this is the only way to access the island. This time of year, our staff may have to shovel their way down a long snowy driveway to reach the front door. Traveling the winding back roads in unpredictable weather conditions of western Maine also brings another layer of challenge, and many times the travel time between each patient can be an hour or more. As Maine's rural population continues to decline, so do the number of qualified health care professionals. Health care workforce shortages have reached critical levels in our State. Not only do we experience a significant nursing workforce shortage but also in primary care physicians. Nurse practitioners many times are the only primary care clinicians in our rural areas. Unfortunately, Federal law prohibits those nurse practitioners and physician assistants from ordering home health services. Recently we received a referral for a patient who had just been discharged from the hospital. He needed home health and physical therapy services. We worked for over 2 weeks with the patient's nurse practitioner to try to find a physician who would sign for the home health care that he needed. Some patients are even readmitted to the hospital before we can even find a physician who will sign for the plan of care. Rural residents already face many challenges to accessing the care they need and it is important that we remove those barriers to be able to allow them to access health care, regardless of where they live. Recent changes in Medicare, brought by PDGM have driven home the importance to us of collaboration between our home care staff, patients, physicians, and our patients' families. We are focused on how technology helps us to achieve the best collaboration with all of them. To focus on this, we have realized a significant success with our home telemonitoring program. This services places technology in the patient's home where they check their weight, their blood pressure, and their heart rate. That information is then transmitted to a web-based portal, either by cell signal or by the patient's home Wi-Fi. This information is then reviewed daily by the nurse. The telemonitoring nurse can then act on those readings, whether it is calling the patient to investigate the symptoms further, calling a physician, and collaborating with a physician to make medication adjustments, all while the patient is still remaining in the home. Our telemonitoring program has realized a rehospitalization rate of between 2 to 4 percent, which when compared to the national average or 24 percent rehospitalization rate for heart failure patients is a significant improvement. One patient we have been seeing for a number of years, before coming on to a telemonitoring program, had over 20 ER and hospitalizations over a matter of 6 months. While working with our health care clinicians, our telemonitoring program, and our physicians, we were able to significantly decrease her rehospitalization rate, and most importantly, we have kept her in her home for over 5 years. Telemonitoring services are not reimbursed by Medicare but it is allowable in the episodic payments for home health. However, we need to always continue to move to a discharge with those patients, and with that we need to remove that equipment that is in the home, which then brings that patient to be at a significant risk of being readmitted to the hospital. We are removing a device or a product that is helping us to be able to identify symptoms early, treat them in the home or in the physician's office, and out of the ER or the hospital. Connectivity is also a challenge in our State. There are significant areas with little to no cell coverage, poor or no broadband access, and sometimes the cost of those services is just more than a patient can afford, and this also prevents us from continuing to move forward with video-based home visits. Other services that we think would help to keep our patients in their home longer are home-based pharmacists visits, as many of our patients experience polypharmacy, taking more than 25 medications. Again, I am so honored to be here today to be able to share our work with you, and I just thank you for this awesome opportunity. The Chairman. Thank you very much for your testimony. I am now going to turn to our Ranking Member for his opening statement and to complete the introduction of Mr. Adams, who I introduced just briefly in anticipation of your arrival. Thank you. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., RANKING MEMBER Senator Casey. Chairman Collins, thanks very much. I apologize for being late. We had a scheduling change and I am sorry for that delay. I am pleased that the Committee today has convened to discuss the important issue of access to health care, particularly home health care and rural communities. From Washington County, which is in southwestern Pennsylvania, where our witness, Mr. Adams, is from, from that county to Wayne County, way up in northeastern Pennsylvania, near where I live, there is about 350 miles of road through rural Pennsylvania. We know from research that people who live along that stretch of road and along rural roads across the country are more likely to be older, to be sicker, and to be less well off than their peers, and as a result they require more health care services. I visited with seniors and people with disabilities in at least 33 of our 67 counties in the last couple of years. One of the constants I hear is that they prefer to age and receive services and supports in their homes and in their communities. Due to transportation constraints and travel distances, accessing those services can be challenging, and that is an understatement. That is especially true for seniors and people with disabilities living in rural areas of our State and our country. They tell me that they skip medical appointments because there is no affordable or easy way to make the trip. This can lead to even greater disparities and even worse health outcomes. In an effort to meet people where they are and keep them healthier longer, we must make investments to expand access to rural health services at both the macro level and micro level. We must ensure that individuals and families have affordable health care. It is why I have been fighting to protect the Affordable Care Act and Medicaid from cuts by the Administration and sabotage. We must protect Medicare from the half a trillion dollars in budget cuts that have been recently proposed by the Administration. We must support rural hospitals. That is why I introduced the Rural Hospital Sustainability Act, which provides stable funding for rural hospitals, allowing hospitals to redesign their care and remain open in rural communities, and we must invest in home health care. I am introducing the Home and Community-Based Services Infrastructure Improvement Act. This bill will provide Medicaid grants to all states to support existing service providers, and encourage the creation of new delivery systems to meet the needs of older adults and people with disabilities. The bill provides states with funds to support more accessible transportation and housing. It will also incentivize states to increase wages and benefits for direct care workers, people like Mr. Adams, who is with us today, and others who do that difficult work in rural communities. In our State of Pennsylvania, over 13,000 older adults and people with disabilities are waiting--waiting for home and community-based services. Across the country, that number is more than 700,000 people waiting. My bill aims to change that to make home-based care and services a reality for all those who need it. An investment in home care is an investment in the future of rural America. It is also an investment in our care, our workforce, and our economy. Madam Chair, thank you, and I will do the introduction now? The Chairman. That would be great. Senator Casey. Thank you so much. I am here to introduce, as Chairman Collins noted, and as she began to introduce, and I am grateful for that part of the introduction, Mr. Francis Adams of Washington, Pennsylvania, as I said, in the southwestern corner, just south of Pittsburgh. He is a home care worker with over 20 years of experience working in rural Pennsylvania, of which I just spoke. He began his home care work taking care of his grandfather who suffered from black lung disease from the coal mines, and too many families and retired coal miners in states like mine suffer from black lung. Mr. Adams is also a third-generation union member, a proud member of the United Home Care Workers of Pennsylvania, a joint program of SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania, and the AFSCME union. Mr. Adams' father was a steelworker and his mother was a teacher, and as I said, his grandfather was a coal miner. They are all proud union members. He will share with us the difficulties facing home care workers in rural communities and the steps we can take to better serve rural seniors and people with disabilities in rural America and rural Pennsylvania. Mr. Adams, thanks for being with us today. We look forward to your testimony. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Mr. Dombi. STATEMENT OF WILLIAM DOMBI, PRESIDENT, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR HOME CARE & HOSPICE, WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. Dombi. Thank you, Chairman Collins and Ranking Member Casey, and the remainder of the Senate Aging Committee for the opportunity to be with you today to testify at this very important hearing. Since the beginning of Medicaid, the home health care benefit has had a special place in that program. Most notably, it is the only benefit that is available under both Medicare Part A and Part B. Medicaid itself also has led the charge in rebalancing long-term services supports into the home care setting. Still, there is room to modernize the Medicaid home health benefit and to expand home care options in Medicaid. To start with, the Home Health Care Planning and Improvement Act, which is co-sponsored by Chairman Collins and Mr. Casey as well, Ranking Member Casey, is one of the crucial modernizations that is needed. We thank you for your longstanding sponsorship in support of that bill, which began in 2007. It is certainly time to revise Medicare to permit the over 200,000 non-physician practitioners in primary care practice to certify Medicare benefit eligibility instead of limiting such to physicians. S. 296 would improve program integrity as it is compromised when the patient is handed off to a physician for the sole purpose of meeting Medicare certification requirements. The bill would also enhance quality of care as it would no longer be necessary to insert a physician who has not cared for the patient into the patient care process. Finally, there would be cost savings, since Medicare reimbursement rates for non-physician practitioners are less than payment rates for physicians, but more importantly, costs would be reduced as it avoids duplicative paperwork. Today the legislation is supported by numerous patient advocacy groups, health care professionals, and physician groups as well. There is an obvious reason why there has been such widespread support. Our nation depends on non-physician practitioners every day. It is now time to pass S. 296 and bring the long-overdue modernization of the home health benefit requirements into reality. In 2007, when such legislation was originally introduced, the reform may have been considered innovative. In 2020, it is a necessity. Number two, we suggest reinstating the Medicare home health rural add-on. The longstanding rural add-on for home health services will be phased out completely in 2022, threatening the provision of home health benefit in rural areas. Since the 1990's, the home health service payment system has recognized the special needs of rural areas as there are higher travel times, travel costs themselves, and often the need for an extended duration of the service visit. The absence of physicians in rural areas, along with hospital closures, compound the problems of care delivery. The latest data available shows that home health agencies located in rural areas receive an average of 6.2 percent less than their cost of care. Most notable is that nearly 40 percent of these providers have Medicare margins below zero. Targeting an add-on may be considered as the current legislation does, but the current approach does not work, with 38 to 69 percent of agencies affected by that in the respective target categories being paid less than their cost of care. We recommend that Congress reinstate the 3 percent rural add-on for 3 years and require an expanded study to determine whether targeting is warranted. Number three, the new home health payment model, the PDGM as we call it, took effect January 1 of this year. It includes a preemptive first-year reduction in base payment rates of over $750 million, derived solely from assumptions as to how home health providers might behave in their provision of care and documentation practices. We strongly supported the Home Health Payment Innovation Act, S. 433, as introduced by Senator Collins last year. While that proposal may need now some refinements given the issuance of the 2020 rule, Congress should call on Medicare to improve transparency and restrict the use of bald assumptions in setting payment rates. It would also be very helpful if Congress committed to closely monitoring access to care and changes in service utilization. There are clearly anecdotal reports of access problems for patients in categories with reduced reimbursement levels to home health agencies already, in just a little over a month of this new program. To finish with just two other items, innovation telehealth. Ms. Howard gave all the information necessary to justify that. We wholly support moving forward with any steps to provide for remote monitoring the patients and other telehealth services in rural areas and in the rest of the country. Among the steps to be taken would be to increase the availability of broadband for the ability of those technologies to actually work, and finally, workforce. You know, I look forward to listening to the discussions regarding the workforce. There is no delivery of home health services without the workforce and we have a shortage of nurses, which continues to expand, and even a greater shortage of personal care attendants to deliver the services to individuals who need support with activities of daily living. We need a national solution to this and we need it soon, because the aging of our population as well as the growing number of persons with disabilities cannot make it in the home without that support. Thank you for the opportunity to come here today. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Mr. Dombi. Mr. Hebert, and I am going to ask you to turn on your mic. Thank you. STATEMENT OF WARREN HEBERT, DNP, RN, CAE, FAAN, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, LOYOLA UNIVERSITY, AND CEO, ASSOCIATION OF HOME HEALTH CARE, LAFAYETTE, LOUISIANA Mr. Hebert. Thank you. ``My histories and physicals are incomplete until I have had a chance to have a meal at the table with their family and the patient.'' Those words were made famous by Dr. Patch Adams. Patch Adams, a West Virginia physician, was made famous by Robin Williams in the movie named Patch Adams. Dr. Adams understood rural home health care. He knew that he did not have a complete picture of the patient and their situation until he saw them in their home. This is one of the advantages that rural home care agencies have and those that are providing rural home and community-based services, and a lot of those folks that are doing that are nurse practitioners, because physicians cannot be in those rural areas. The access to the home is extremely important and social determinants of health, that we have talked a lot about over the past few years, are certainly very important in our rural areas. There is much to be joyful and thankful about in our rural areas. The peaceful drive through the countryside of the mountains of Maine, down in south Louisiana the swamplands and the marshes, and you just had the Washington, D.C., Mardi Gras, so you probably know that this is crawfish season in Louisiana, and we are seeing crawfish ponds as we drive along. Our patients in rural areas live there, in those places. A trained eye visiting those places can do what is called a windshield survey. As we are driving into the area we can see a lot of the public health issues that exist. We can understand the socioeconomic challenges that are in that area. When I knock on a patient's door and cross that sacred threshold into their home, health care is very different than it is with our friends in the acute care settings. It is their place. It is their territory. As I walk in the house I know a little bit about how the patient and their family are going to engage me. That tells me a lot, related to my assessment. I can look at the pictures on the walls and find out what sort of support they have within their family unit, and I will speak to family caregivers a bit in a few minutes, and if that first visit goes well I might be offered a cup of coffee. That happens a lot in rural homes and if I am really good at building a relationship they will invite me to have a look into their refrigerator and their pantry. Madam Chair, Ranking Member Casey, Senators and hard- working staff, you know, as my colleagues are I am honored to be here with you and dive into some of the challenges around rural health care. Depending on the resource one cites, as many as 45 million family caregivers are taking on challenges alone across the country with very little support. In rural areas, families are very fortunate if they are able to have home and community- based services or they are able to have home health care assisting them. On occasion, we have nurse practitioners making visits to patients in their home. That is a real gift and we are very fortunate that we have nurse practitioners who are willing to do that critical work. AARP reports that daily between 7 and 8 million people are providing care as family caregivers, and again, most of the time they are unsupported, so it is critical for us to understand the work that your Committee is doing, Madam Chair, and the need to support that. Within my own family, my wife and I are very fortunate to have a 29-year-old daughter who has Down syndrome, so besides being on the provider side we are also consumers in that she receives home and community-based services. My dad had dementia for 7 years. We were fortunate that Mom and Dad prepared for their senior years. I am the oldest of 10 children, and in south Louisiana people do not wander too far from home, so the 10 of us all lived within 20 minutes of Mom and Dad. Over his 7 years with dementia, Dad did not spend one night in a hospital or a nursing home, because we were able to help my extraordinary mother with Dad's work. These are the sort of challenges that rural families are dealing with, but the rural families are not experiencing the same ability to connect as they did in the past. We are having challenges that as conglomerates are taking over a lot of rural farms, those farm families are needing to move and find jobs in suburban and urban areas, so as a result, the tax base is drying up in those communities. As the tax base dries up, schools, hospitals, physicians, pharmacists, et cetera, are all having to close. In closing, I would like to quote Dr. Joseph Coughlin, of MIT's AgeLab. About a year ago he tweeted that when it comes to aging, independence is overrated. It is interdependence that we should be seeking. I hope that in this hearing we can be more vibrant and have a lively conversation about interdependence. That is a critical conversation for people who need home care in rural communities. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Doctor. Mr. Adams, welcome. STATEMENT OF FRANCIS ADAMS, HOME CARE WORKER, WASHINGTON, PENNSYLVANIA Mr. Adams. Good morning. My name is Francis Adams. I am a home care provider from Washington, Pennsylvania. I am also a proud member of the United Home Care Workers of Pennsylvania, a joint program with SEIU Care, and AFSCME. I have been helping seniors and people with disabilities who live at home for over 20 years. I left my job as a steelworker to care for my grandfather when he fell ill from black lung. I later cared for my aunt. I wanted to be there for my family. That is when somebody told me that home care can be a career. I really liked the work and people needed it. Every day, more than 10,000 people turn 65 in America. We need to attract 1 million more workers to this industry by 2026 to meet the demand. However, our current long-term care system does not support home care workers or our clients. Presently I care for my brother, who is blind. I am also a on-call home care worker, stepping in at all times when a client's regular caregiver is unavailable. Many of my clients do not have anyone else. A lot of my job duties are physical-- bathing, cooking, cleaning, driving to appointments--but it is the emotional connection that really makes the impact. I never want to leave a client alone. Depression can kill you as quickly as lung cancer and because I work on call, oftentimes I do not know what equipment someone has in their home. That is why training is so important. Washington, Pennsylvania, is not like D.C. It is a rural area. We cannot cross the street to get to the grocery store or hop on a subway to get across town. Neighbors are separated by several miles. It takes much longer for fire trucks and ambulances to get those in need. Distance and mobility issues sometimes leave my clients running out of vital supplies. I make sure they have them. Home care work was a lifeline for me, after working at the mills. My pension was only a small fraction of what had been promised to me, so I need this job. I make $10.70 an hour and I work 10 to 40 hours any given week. In addition to being a home care worker, at age 70 I have a second job in retail to make ends meet. If home care paid more, I would not have to take on other work. It is not that we do not have enough people to do home care that creates a shortage. It is that our country undervalues this work. We have to fix this. That is why I am joining Pennsylvania home care workers fighting for higher wages and a union. With a union we have the strength in numbers to negotiate wages, basic benefits, and training. We have worked together to strengthen Pennsylvania's Medicaid program, and importantly, my union has given me a sense of community. My grandfather, my father, my mother were union members. I saw what the unions do to improve our lives. Unions advocate for racial and social justice. My family marched with Dr. King and I held that passion as I grew older. As a child I saw firsthand the shameful legacy of Jim Crow that held hardworking people in my community back. The legacy continues in home care, a job that has historically been mislabeled as unskilled. We must move past this institutional racism so that in 20 years home care is a well-respected, sought-after, family sustaining job. Home care is the country's future. Home care jobs must be good jobs, union jobs, and workers must make at least $15 an hour and have affordable health care. When we invest in our home care workforce we can improve our long-term care system for all. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Mr. Adams. Ms. Howard I want to start with you. Home health agencies in Maine and across the Nation have had to weather a series of Medicare reimbursement reductions from the reimbursement payment cuts that were contained in the Affordable Care Act to the latest negative 4-plus percent behavioral adjustment cut. I would like you to describe what the impact is on home health agencies in Maine. I know I read that a very large agency recently closed, that was serving nearly 600 patients, so what is the impact of inadequate reimbursements, whether it is under the Medicaid program or the Medicare program? Ms. Howard. Sure. A number of things are happening, so as you know, there are closures. There are also a number of mergers and acquisitions, so home care agencies that once functioned independently of each other are now merging in order to be able to still provide for residents in their area. There is also the challenge of workforce, so our more rural sites are also where we are most challenged to find staff and so because of that we need to pay for high-cost travel staff, as we are being reimbursed less and less but our costs to provide care are going, you know, higher and higher. Also, we are honestly having to make difficult decisions. We have a patient that might take 2 hours to get to. We have to send a staff out to see a patient that is 2 hours away. Can we even do that when we have three other patients who are in a more tight geography? Do we go and serve that one patient or do we stay closer and serve those three? We are having to make those difficult decisions as well. Also, with those changes, with the decrease in reimbursement, getting more creative about our workforce, so being innovative about developing our own internal workforce, so personal care assistants train to be CNAs, train to be LPNs, and so on. All of that comes at a high cost, and as we are continuing to have decreases to our reimbursement, those things were getting squeezed tighter and tighter and it is harder to do those things. The Chairman. Thank you. I think your example of the patient who is 2 hours away is a really important one, because that is why the rural add-on is so important to compensate for that extra time on the road, rather than just not being able to serve those patients who are further away from the agency. Mr. Hebert, Dr. Hebert, I was struck in listening to you about your comments on interdependence and also the reaction that home health workers get when they come into a person's home, because that was the experience that I have always seen when I have gone on home health visits. In fact, I saw the senior's face literally light up when the home health nurse arrived. Sadly, oftentimes that might be the only person who is seeing that patient, and thus can take stock of everything. Is there enough food? Are other needs being met? We held a hearing in which we learned the effect of prolonged isolation and loneliness is equivalent to smoking 15 cigarettes a day. That is how important this is. What do you see as the biggest challenges that you are facing in trying to ensure that home health services are delivered? Mr. Hebert. Madam Chair, you pointed out the isolation. The research that has been done related to social isolation and loneliness make it very clear. As you said, it has a worse impact on morbidity and mortality than smoking 15 cigarettes a day, or drinking a half a dozen adult beverages. This issue of isolation is not only an issue for us here in the United States, it is an issue for aging folks across the world. We have, in the room today, guests from Europe who are here to learn from the Senate Aging Committee and some of the proactive work that you have done here. The challenge for the rural patient in that isolation is that they do not have, in most cases, the family that my mom had, to be able to say, ``Hey, look, I need some help. Come.'' As a result, that is often, as you indicate, the only person they may see. As I indicated, that happens a lot here in the United States. One nurse talked about over a period of a few weeks she saw a calendar with the numbers 1 through 7 struck out. She finally had the courage to ask the patient what that was, and she said, ``Well, that is my calendar.'' She said, ``Well, tell me about it. You have only got the numbers 1 through 7.'' She said, ``Sweetheart, when you leave today I am going to write 1 through 7 again, and I am going to mark each day off because I know that is when you are coming back.'' The exact same experience I had was when I led a group of home care and hospice workers to Dharamsala, India, and spent 2 weeks in Tibetan Buddhist communities. Those people waited for their home health nurse because it might be the only visit they get in a week, so when you ask the challenges that the patient and the family has, essentially that engagement from the rural home health nurse or the home and community-based worker, those are critical for them to be able to do well. Thank you for asking. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Casey. Senator Casey. Thank you, Madam Chair. I am going to thank our witnesses for their testimony today. I will start with Mr. Adams. Your story is a powerful story about the work that you had to do to transition from the work you had done as a steelworker. I think not only your own personal story but the reality of home care itself but also home care in the rural context is a disturbing story for the country. We are not anywhere close to meeting the obligation we have to rural seniors and their families if we do not make some changes. As you highlighted, we have a very rural State. A lot of people do not realize that. We have got 67 counties. Some people think of my State as Philadelphia and Pittsburgh and just some towns in between. Of the 67 counties, 48 are rural, 48. Three and a half million people live there, a bigger population than the whole State of a lot of states. I think we have, if not the top rural population in the country, it is one of the top two or three, so millions of people who have challenges that frankly exceed, often, the challenges in urban communities. One of the points you made, Mr. Adams, is the stagnant wages, the long hours, the distance, and the difficulty of providing care in rural settings. We have got to have more resources. You also pointed, in your written testimony, to just some numbers on turnover. When you talk about turnover in this industry, national workforce turnover rates as high as 60 percent, so if we are not recruiting more people to do this work we are not going to meet the need, and as I said, we are failing as a country. You cannot ask people to do difficult work and drive long hours if you do not pay them enough. What I am trying to do with this legislation is to focus on that basic problem, a lack of appropriate pay and a lack of investment in training. Mr. Adams, can you just speak to that question, the question of resources that are needed to better support workers who are doing the work you are doing in rural communities? Mr. Adams. Well, without the resources what it means to me is that America has failed to help the people that need them most and the people that care for them. Like the man that cuts his lights off at 7 in the evening to keep his electric bill affordable, or the lady that struggles to sit up in her bed when we feed her because she does not have a hospital bed. or the woman that waits hours for someone to drive out to her home to take her to the grocery store, because she cannot afford transportation, or the man that falls in the middle of the night because there is no home care worker there, because he does not have the funds to keep one through the night, so he lays on the floor, afraid to push his call button, because he lives outside the city, and an ambulance would cost him an exorbitant amount of money. When the home care worker comes in there in the morning they struggle to pick him up, because he is a 200-pound man, and they do not have the equipment, like a lift, to help him get back in the chair, and that is a shame. It is important because we have 10,000 people turning 65, and these people live in their homes. Lots of times they have built those homes with their own hands. They have worked hard to pay for these homes. It means that we have failed these people, and that is a crying shame. Senator Casey. Thanks very much. I wanted to turn, as well, to Mr. Dombi, and I appreciate the perspective you gave us in highlighting legislation that has been on the agenda of Congress for far too long and not passed. I mentioned the infrastructure improvements that we are trying to bring about and using target investments through Medicaid. Do you agree that these kinds of investments are necessary to expand care to home and community-based services in rural communities? Mr. Dombi. Senator Casey, I had the opportunity to review your bill last week for the first time and I am very impressed with it, and you can have our organization's support throughout on that. Medicaid has proven itself to be the best place for finding home care options available to people but it is far from perfect. The turnover rates, the compensation to the workers, there still is a need for rebalancing of care. If I find myself in need of home care there are certain states I will go to and certain states I will not go to because the distribution of support is that varied. Oregon actually is the best State among them in terms of support. Pennsylvania is doing okay, you know, and Maine is doing pretty darn good as well, but it is time that we support seniors as well as persons with disabilities with an even approach toward access to home and community-based care, and you know, it is not just about wages for the workers. It is wages, it is also career opportunities, and frankly, having been fired as a home care aide by my sister, it is about respect too. You know, these workers do the hardest job in the country. Somehow U.S. News and World Report picked personal care attendant and home care aide as the number 1 job areas to go to for people without a college education. It is a great, rewarding job, but you still have to put bread on the table. Senator Casey. Thanks very much, Chairman Collins. The Chairman. Senator Hawley. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Ranking Member. Thank you for holding this important hearing today about the obstacles to expanding health in rural America, and thank you to all of our witnesses. Thank you for the work that you do. Thank you for taking the time to be with us and share your perspective. My home State of Missouri is home to a very large number of rural communities. I grew up in a rural community. I know when I talk to my constituents back at home and in these regions, one of their top concerns, if not their number 1 concern, is access to quality, affordable health care. That is all the more urgent because Missouri's population is rapidly aging. We have got a lot of seniors in the State of Missouri and a lot of them live in rural areas, so the topic of today's hearing is very, very important for my State. Mr. Dombi, let me just start with you if I could. In your testimony, your written testimony, you discussed the innovative uses of telehealth and telehomecare, in particular, as a way to bring home health care to patient populations in communities like the one where I grew up. I am aware of the infrastructure barriers to telehealth expansion, including inadequate access to quality broadband. That, of course, places a huge restriction on health care providers in rural regions. Despite these barriers, Congress, I know, has taken some incremental steps to expand telehealth and telemonitoring capabilities, but I think that we can probably do more. I just want to ask you, what lessons have we learned so far, in your judgment, in demonstrating the cost-effectiveness of services like telehealth, telehomecare, and what are the most promising areas, would you say, where we can utilize those services more strategically? Mr. Dombi. The number one gain we have seen in the use of telehealth, or we call it telehomecare, a term which someday might be adopted, but in terms of telehealth it is remote monitoring by non-physicians as a way of keeping people from going back into the hospital, to avoid readmissions of the individual. It is important to have boots on the ground, people to see face to face the patients, but that 24/7 monitoring of a number of patients categories has proven a high reduction in readmissions. One readmission avoided to a hospital saves tens of thousands of dollars, with very little cost attendant to it. We have actually been working on a proposal to advance to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid innovations to create a risk-based telehealth program, where the provider of the telehealth services would put tremendous skin in the game so that they would only be paid, or they would only be paid fully, if they demonstrated cost savings to the Medicare program, so we think that opportunity exists today out there, and it does not always need physicians, as I mentioned. These are non- physician-based remote monitoring services. Senator Hawley. That is very helpful. Thank you. Do you have any recommendations for home health agencies that are looking to set up new programs? Mr. Dombi. Well, you know, come in with some capital, because the reimbursement systems are not yet up to date where it needs to be. That is why our proposal would have a risk- based approach to it, because, frankly, you know, when we have been working on some of these issues for over 10 years, you know, we figure we have to change the dynamic, and that is what a risk-based proposal would be about. Senator Hawley. Very good. Thank you. Ms. Howard, let me ask you, on this topic of access to telehealth services, I wonder if you could speak to your experience serving on the ground with rural communities. Older adults, we know, experience the highest rates of adverse drug events, resulting in emergency visits, and are several times more likely than younger persons to have an adverse drug event that requires emergency hospital admissions. They are also more susceptible to chronic pain, we know, and many of them are prescribed opioids to control and manage the pain. Have you been able to leverage your program's telemonitoring technologies to identify changes in patients using opioids? Ms. Howard. That is not an area that we have currently been working on, but, however, you know, having the telemonitoring in the home, of course, you know, many of our patients are on 25 or more medications and many of them, you know, are on opioids, so having that nurse checking in every day would help to be able to identify certain challenges are things that we need to followup on. The other thing, too, that I will add about the telemonitoring is it really allows us to make those home visits on a demonstrated need, meaning we see changes in the patient's blood pressure or based on different questions that they answer, so when we talk about workforce shortages, this allows us to make those, as it is knowing when they need that visit instead of anticipating when they may need a home visit. Senator Hawley. That is very helpful. Let me ask you this, my last question. Beyond expanding access to broadband, which is critically important, I think, for so many reasons, and telehealth is at the top of that list, and providing more reimbursement coverage for telehealth services, do you have any insights from your experience for us about what Congress might do to make home health care programs better, more available to more Americans? Ms. Howard. One of those challenges that we have, our patients that we see are in their acute State of their disease, so maybe they have had a heart failure, readmission to the hospital, they are discharged home with our service. We are using our telemonitoring equipment during that fragile time to clue us in as to any changes that might happen that would send them back to the hospital, so we are able to take action based on those. Currently we can only see that patient for a short period of time. Eventually we need to work to discharge, so that patient returns to that chronic health State of their heart failure, for example, and we need to remove our telemonitoring equipment, we remove the nurse, we remove the therapist or the home health aide, and that patient is now on their own, and so what usually happens is after a period of time eventually that patient may run into trouble again, and in order to access our care again they end up going to the ER, going to the hospital, and then the referral back up to home care again, and here we go out to do what we do best, to keep them out, only again for a short period of time, and we just are in that cycle. We have been able to work with some of our Medicare Advantage plans, where we do telemonitor patients after they are discharged from their skilled home care benefit, so we telemonitor those patients for an extended period of time, sometimes make a home visit, but what we are able to do is identify those changes in the health status. For a heart failure patient, it could be an increase in a weight or their reporting through their telemonitoring system that they are short of breath. Our nurse goes out and assesses the situation, is in contact with the physician, and many times we are able to make medication changes at that point in the home, readmit them to home care service, and then care for them again under that acute state, so we have bypassed that ER and that hospitalization visit, which would have normally brought them back to us, so we have had great success with that. Senator Hawley. Very good. Thank you. Thank you for all that you do. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Rosen, welcome. Senator Rosen. Thank you, Madam Chair and Ranking Member, and I want to thank each and every one of you for being here, for everyone else who is here as well. I know from my personal family experience as a caregiver how critically important each one of these areas are and that there are angels that walk among us, and they are the ones who help us take care of our loved ones when we can't always be there, and I am personally grateful to the angels who helped my loved ones through much of their care. I want to talk a little bit about palliative care, Mr. Dombi. You know, based on my experience as a caregiver, I launched a bipartisan Senate Comprehensive Care Caucus. It is serving to raise the public's awareness, promote the availability, and the benefits of palliative care, and trying to find those bipartisan solutions to expand access to palliative care services, improve coordinated care, and really address issues impacting caregivers. I am also proud to have introduced the Provider Training in Palliative Care Act with my colleague, Lisa Murkowski, Senator Murkowski, which is going to have the National Health Service Corps focus on these areas, so we know that the important work of hospice home care that providers do in their home, how can we take this hospice model, and knowing that also there are people who maybe do not need to be on hospice but they have chronic, long-term disease--cardiac disease, pulmonary disease, diabetes, Parkinson's, whatever. How can we take these palliative care, hospice care models and use them, expand them across the home health spectrum? Mr. Dombi. Well, thank you for that question. We are on a new frontier with palliative care. There had been a struggle at one time for people to even recognize it as a necessary service for individuals. My sister was fighting stage IV breast cancer, and her oncologist was hell-bent on killing her cancer. At the same time she was having a miserable life and so we brought in a palliative care physician to support her. The oncologist, then, and the palliative care physician were butting heads for a number of weeks until they realized they needed to be in partnership. My sister did not make it through her breast cancer, but palliative care is not just end-of-life services. It is an important component to end-of-life but palliative care truly is something that should be part of all health care services, at all times. I think, you know, when I say we are at a new frontier, we are at the new frontier of awareness. I do not know if all the solutions are out there yet. Probably not, but when we look at the solutions we start with the recognition that, while I mentioned the physician in palliative care, much of palliative care is provided by non-physicians--nurse practitioners, nurses, personal care aides. It involves much more than even clinical health care kinds of services. One of the recommendations that we have been making is that you can take existing benefit structure, in Medicare, for example, like the home health benefit, and make it a palliative care component to it without honestly having to go through Congress to do so. It is skilled care. It is care for people who are, you know, in their homes. It can be done by the professionals with the home health agencies, if they have some specialized training, and we do not see it as really increasing spending much in any way, if at all. At the same time, in a pre-hospice kind of mode, there are some efforts to try to experiment with what we would call pre- hospice palliative care. We are seeing it in the managed care context, but more than half of the country is not in a Medicare managed care program. I hate to admit but I am a Medicare enrollee, and I am not in Medicare Advantage at this point. I do not know if I ever will be, but we need to experiment also within the fee-for-service kind of program. An example of where to go might be Medicaid, where they have used dollars in a very flexible kind of a person. Ranking Member Casey, you have support for money follows the person within your bill. Similar concepts relative to using the dollars that would otherwise go into higher cost settings, into palliative care, I think is a good option for us to consider, in both Medicare and Medicaid. Senator Rosen. Now I have to agree with you, especially as we talk about the mental health, the depression. All those things really--you're going, what is in the refrigerator?--all these things matter to the care and consideration and overall health of a person, and contribute to them going up or going down. If you would like to say a few words, please. Mr. Hebert. Senator Rosen, I really appreciate that question. One of the things that a lot of public health folks chuckle about today is the change in names and how people are excited that we have this new issue of social determinates of health, when public health folks know that these are issues they have been addressing for decades. Palliative care is care that has been provided by home health workers for decades, and it is now beginning to be recognized that we have got people like the ones you just questioned, who have multiple comorbidities, multiple chronic illnesses, and to be able to manage those well, palliative care benefits could significantly change things. You talked about the Training Act. One of the things that is critical to this conversation is workforce, so not only training for workforce but our medical schools, nursing schools, social work, therapy, et cetera, have been educating people for many, many decades, based on an acute care model that is very hospital-centric, and I would add physician- centric, so one of the challenges that we have is to change curricula across all of those schools, to include rural components of care at home and certainly palliative care. Thank you for that very important question. Senator Rosen. Thank you for being here today. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator. Senator Braun, welcome. Senator Braun. Thank you, Madam Chair. I just got here a moment ago, but everyone, I think, knows here, since I have been here about a year, that health care is the thing that I think is most urgent, and that in my own business many years ago I really worked hard to make it consumer driven and transparent. I know the particular arena you are in. Indiana, I think, would be in the category of where we have not done well with home care. I would like to know, whoever might be able to give me an answer, where it has a foothold, what is the financial difference between home care when it is working at its best versus traditional, which we have mostly in the State of Indiana, which would be through a nursing home? Mr. Dombi. I can try that question. I think it is working really well in place like Oregon and Washington State. New York State, a long time ago, had a policy of directing people to kind of a home care first approach, keeping people out of long stays in hospitals because no nursing home beds were even available for those individuals. There have also been several studies, including from New York, indicating that the woodwork effect does not happen, the woodwork effect meaning that if you make it available, people who are currently not costing anything to the system will go to that service, and, in fact, that has not been the case. Where it is working best as well is where there is support, as Dr. Hebert referenced, with the informal caregivers, because the bulk of home care services is provided by family and friends. I think AARP recently estimated it to exceed $570 billion a year, whereas total home care spending in the business of home care is about $125-$130 billion a year. The VA has done pretty well in connecting caregivers in the informal sense with paid caregivers for respite services and otherwise, so when we were looking to where it is working best, we are looking to those kinds of states in the upper Northwest, we are looking to New York, and we are looking to some of the other government programs. The VA has the most robust home care program of any program on paper. I had the privilege, I hope, this afternoon I am testifying at the House Veterans' Affairs Committee about home care services. It is great on paper. It needs a little bit of improvement in practice, though, but it still provides a lot of guidance. Senator Braun. What were the catalysts that worked for Washington, Oregon, New York, or even the VA, to kind of push home health care, and how much entrepreneurial energy has there been? My main beef with the health care industry in total is that it has lacked transparency, it is inherently uncompetitive, it has barriers to entry, and the consumer is not engaged, to boot. When you take two of those four, you generally do not have a well-functioning supply and demand, you know, market that drives, generally, prices low in other markets, and then you differentiate by your intangibles, so when it comes to, what was the original catalyst--let's just take Oregon or Washington or the VA--that got it to where it has pushed something that seems to be a better value, you know, for the customer? Mr. Dombi. It was looking for value. It was looking to control spending, in Medicaid as well as in the VA. Secondarily to that, but very much equally important, is the humanity aspect of giving people the opportunity to stay at home but the driver was the bottom line. With the growing population of need for long-term services and supports, the population being served, whether it was in the VA or in the Medicaid program, which is a primary funding source for long-term care, the recognition was they had to find a better way than the high cost of caring for individuals in nursing homes, combined with the concern that nobody wanted to go to a nursing home and that is what really drove it. There is tremendous competition in home care in a number of the sectors that are out there. It is an unusual economic dynamic, marketplace dynamic. You have mom-and-pop operations working at farmhouse in Appalachia and you have public companies that operate in 40, 50 states nationwide. Senator Braun. That is refreshing, because it is normally not the case through any other parts of health care, and then do you run into, within certain states, where the nursing home industry--in other words, the status quo that has been around a long time, that is there--not giving you that good deal, that has weighed in to kind of suppress what looks to be some grassroots competition? Is that something that occurs? Mr. Dombi. Yes. I am going to give you a delicate answer there. Senator Braun. I figured it would be. Mr. Dombi. We tried to work with the nursing home world as well, but you can go to every State legislature and they all know their nursing home operators. You know, it is harder to get to know the home care operators, and it is very hard to get to know the home care workers because, you know, they gather at the person's home rather than at a facility somewhere. Senator Braun. Well put, and I think that is our goal as Senators, to provide, where it normally occurs, when you have transparency, when you do not have a strong lobby that tries to suppress that stuff. It works so well in other places. It is good to see that in home health care that it is actually succeeding in a system that is basically dysfunctional and broken. Mr. Adams. If I may add, the states that he mentioned all have good unions, good wages for home care workers, and that is part of the reason why those states function well. Their wages are reasonable, the union is strong, and as he stated, the states are doing well. Senator Braun. That is good to know as well, and that makes sense. It is good to see that it also engendering higher wages for that function. Did you have---- Mr. Hebert. Senator, I would add that value-based purchasing has had an impact. Even though it is slow and moving along, we are moving away from the old sick-care model where everything is fee-for-service and reimbursement is based on volume, so the move toward value is critical in the home care space as well, and I think that is why you have seen that sort of progressive activity in the states that you mentioned. Senator Braun. Thank you for setting a good example. I hope the rest of the industry is paying attention. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you very much. Senator Sinema. Senator Sinema. Well, thank you, Chairman Collins, Thank you, Ranking Member Casey, and thank you to all of our witnesses for being here today. As seniors live longer they should be able to access home and community-based services wherever they live. I believe we must do more to help seniors live safely at home before they need to receive specialized medical care at home or in a residential facility. A part of this effort includes increasing access to home care and assistance with daily activities, such as bathing, eating, dressing, or even ensuring medication adherence. This week I was proud to team up with Senator Cory Gardner of Colorado to introduce the Home Care For Seniors Act. Our common-sense, bipartisan bill allows seniors to use their tax- advantaged health savings accounts to pay for home care. This will help seniors remain safely at home and provide needed relief for family caregivers. We think it is a first good step but we must do more. As I have heard from Arizona's local Area Agencies on Aging, home health care remains an acute challenge for rural communities and seniors, so this leads to my first question for Mr. Dombi, although I welcome everyone's thoughts. Arizona's Medicaid program is pursuing exciting collaborations to build a long-term care workforce, especially in our rural communities. Working with technical high schools, community colleges, and nursing programs, this initiative will develop training courses that help students quickly earn a license or certification and enter the home care workforce. There are also options for students to continue on to a licensed practical nursing program or other advanced jobs in the health care industry. The goal is to help increase career mobility in rural areas while managing the training and hiring costs that can be prohibitive for our rural providers, particularly those who need entry-level direct care workers now, so do you believe that such a strategic plan could be implemented on a larger or national scale to help address the short-term need we all face for a qualified workforce? Mr. Dombi. We need a multidimensional strategy to improve the availability of the workforce within home care, and your proposal has many of the elements that are absolutely worth employing in that. When we look at the kind of strategies that have been employed, they have had a little bit of impact so far, but when we look at particularly the personal care services supports for activities of daily living and the workforce that provides those services, it implicates a broad array of elements within our health care delivery system. Compensation is absolutely one of them. Figuratively, I think the State Medicaid programs combined make up the largest employer, figurative employer, of the low- wage workers across the country. You cannot pay somebody a living wage if you are paying $12 an hour for the services to the employer. You could not give $12 an hour to the worker because you are paying things like your taxes and, you know, your rent, and paying for the billing and such. It goes beyond compensation. It goes into other elements, like a career ladder opportunity for the individuals who wish to be there. Flexibility may be necessary, even in some of the Federal wage and hour law to deal with the issue of scheduling of these workers, that the workers do not necessarily schedule their time based on their interests. They schedule based on upon the clients' interests, and they work well to do so but it doesn't necessarily fit with the existing wage and hour law when calculating such issues as overtime compensation. Immigration fits into the issue as well, you know. We know that is a very sensitive issue in this country today, but when you are looking at the workforce that is out there, a quarter of the current workforce providing for personal care supports are recent immigrants. If we look back perhaps on our own family history, my grandparents came from Hungary, Lithuania, and Poland in the late 1800's, and they took, as most immigrants do, the hardest, lowest-paying jobs that are out there. They worked with trying to advance their families along the way. We do have to take a look at our immigration policies to see, can we bring that kind of workforce to bear? The demographics of our country, in many ways, will require us to bring in new people. I had four people--children in my parents' family that could help care for them as they aged. I have two children. Not only am I not liked by them, but they cut my resources in half, so somewhere I am going to have to find outside caregivers when that need might arise, but I appreciate, really, the work that you are doing to explore these various things. There is no one silver bullet solution. Senator Sinema. Yes. Thank you so much. Mr. Hebert. If I could add---- Senator Sinema. Yes. Mr. Hebert [continuing]. Senator, it is a very important question. I think that one of the things that we need to find a way to do--and, Madam Chair, I am going to borrow a term from a couple of your PhD public health folks in Maine---it is important for us to find incentives to keep our free-range, pass-the-raise children at home. If we can keep those rural people in there and give them incentives, they already know the culture, they know the climate, they know the people, so part of our challenge is to find those folks at home and provide incentives. Thanks for your good work. Senator Sinema. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. My time has expired. The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. Dombi, as you know, we have worked together for years to allow nurse practitioners, physician assistants, other advanced practice nurses to prescribe home health care, and oftentimes, as I pointed out earlier, they are the primary care provider for the person needing home health care. One nurse practitioner expressed to me her frustration that she could prescribe, she could order x-rays, can do all sorts of tests, and yet she cannot prescribe home health care for her patient, her very own patient who is being discharged from the hospital, for example. I just do not understand the resistance to allowing more health care providers to authorize home health care. What is the chief criticism of expanding those who can prescribe home health care, and what is your response to that criticism? Mr. Dombi. The roadblock is not at the State level. States have authorized these practitioners to order home health services, to manage patients in the home care setting, to varying degrees, either, you know, completely independent or in some collaborative relationship. The barrier is an antiquated Medicare program, and I think the barrier is still there simply because there is, at one time, concern on program integrity and concern on quality of care, which was not well founded in the first place. Instead, as my written testimony points out, we think program integrity is compromised and quality of care likewise compromised with this antiquated rule, when you have to hand off to a physician. There is one other factor that has come into the mix over the years, as we have tried to get this legislation passed, and that is the Congressional Budget Office. We still do not have a score, a formal score, from CBO on this. CBO at one point gave us an informal score, gave the House--I say us--gave all of the stakeholders an informal score of what they called budget dust, under $100 million, something close to my annual salary, you know, budget dust, and then, suddenly, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services stepped in and advised the CBO that they had concerns on program integrity as well as quality of care. My information is now that CMS no longer holds those views, but we still need a CBO score in order for this to move forward. We think this really should be scored as a saver rather than as a coster there. I do not think there is anybody who is, you know, categorically opposing it. More and more physician groups, who one time might have been considered competitors, are now coming on board because they are partnering in so many different ways, business wise as well as caring for patients, with nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and the like. Mr. Hebert. Madam Chair? The Chairman. Yes, Dr. Hebert. Mr. Hebert. Madam Chair, I would offer this is even more critical in rural areas---- The Chairman. Yes. Mr. Hebert [continuing]. where the primary care practitioner is a nurse practitioner or a PA, so this is a vital issue for rural communities. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. Hebert. Thank you for your long-term support of this issue. The Chairman. I completely agree with your comments, and it is one reason that I have felt so frustrated that we cannot get this common-sense change made, that is going to improve the lives of patients and prevent rehospitalizations or worsening of their condition because of the delays that are often inherent in finding a physician to authorize the care. It just makes no sense and I am going to work on trying to get the CBO to give us a score and see if we can enlist the Financial Committee leaders to help us in that regard. I personally believe that it is going to save money, for a whole host of reasons, and we could use that. Mr. Adams, I saw that you were nodding when Mr. Dombi was talking about the VA doing a good job. Did you have anything you wanted to add on that topic? If I could ask you to turn on your mic. Thank you. Mr. Adams. The thing that I was nodding my head about is the fact that he mentioned Washington State and New York. These are places that have strong unions, and the unions are the people that advocated for the safe working conditions, that advocated for the higher pay. When you advocate and you have higher pay and better training, it attracts people to the jobs. That is why those states are successful, and that is what we are trying to do in western Pennsylvania. The Chairman. Thank you. Finally, Ms. Howard, I want to commend you for being such a leader in telemedicine, telemonitoring, because that can be so helpful, especially if you are servicing someone who lives on an island off Maine, where it is very difficult to get to them. That was an example that you had used. I have noticed that when I am talking to veterans who have come back, who have post-traumatic stress, that they actually really like the telemedicine, the younger veterans in particular. They prefer it to having to go to the office of a psychiatrist or a therapist or a mental health counselor, so there are two questions I have and that is, are your older patients receptive to telemedicine, first of all, and second, what roadblocks do you see to expanding telemedicine? Ms. Howard. Thank you for those questions and thank you for your recognition of our program. I appreciate that, so some of the roadblocks to expanding, of course, are broadband and cell connectivity. A patient does not need to have Wi-Fi or internet at home. If we can get a cell signal at that patient's home we can still transmit the data, and that helps us tremendously to be able to get the information that we need. You do not have to stray too far off I-95 to start to run into complications, especially with a cell signal, and of course the coastal areas is also a challenge. Our seniors, they enjoy using the equipment. It is very simple. It is a tablet-based system, and it walks them through it. They enjoy it, which is a surprise to some people. They would think they would not be accepting to the technology in their home, but we have learned not to assume, because many of them are probably more tech savvy than some of us, which is great, so, you know, and the other thing is, you know, as we look to expand, the challenge is that, you know, yes, it is under our episodic payment, but our providing this benefit, we have to afford that financially through grants, through cutting in other areas because as we have had more and more cuts, you know, in looking for where can you cut back, and, you know, as you cut more and more in our operations budget and then that means we are not as able to utilize as much equipment with as many patients as we would like to, because we cannot afford to purchase more equipment. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Casey. Senator Casey. Thanks very much. I will pick up on the last answer by Ms. Howard, referencing broadband. One of the many problems that still burden rural America, for lots of reason-- health care, broadband is a problem for health care, it is a problem for business. It is another way that we shortchange rural America. Health care itself, when we have got proposals in this town all the time to cut Medicaid, for example, it disproportionately falls on rural America when that happens. We know that more kids, as a percentage, in rural America, depend on Medicaid and CHIP than even in urban areas, because in urban areas you have low-income folks. We have higher-income folks that do not depend upon--who live in cities but do not depend on CHIP and Medicaid, so Medicaid is a program that is so critical to rural America. We have a proposal now by the Administration to allow states to cap Medicaid spending for certain populations. I am reading here from an Associated Press story, February 6th. The first sentence of the article is very simple. It says, ``Governors of both major political parties are warning that a little-noticed regulation proposed by the President's administration could lead to big cuts in Medicaid, reducing access to health care for low-income Americans.'' That is Governors of both parties saying that about the adverse impact on low-income folks through this just one proposal on Medicaid. When you combined that with the proposed cuts in the budget announced this week, once again we are talking about rural America paying the freight, dealing with the impact of Medicaid cuts. There are some people who walk around this town morning, noon, and night, talking about how much they care about rural America, and then they propose these cuts to Medicaid, so we know what the Governors of both political parties say about it. We know what health care experts say about it. Mr. Adams, I am just going to ask you. You are in the trenches. You deliver home health care to rural communities. Tell us what you think the impact would be on your work and the people you take care of in rural Pennsylvania, with these cuts. Mr. Adams. These cuts, as I stated earlier, would be devastating to the community, people that have no transportation, and as I stated they would have no ambulances. It would be harder for those of us who have low wages to afford gas to get to work. They would not have food to eat. Senator Casey. What the Federal Government is asking the states to do is to stretch their Medicaid dollars much further and as our Secretary of Human Services said, ``Permitting states to grow--if this happens it would permit states to grow health inequities experienced by the poorest Americans.'' That is rural America. Chairman Collins, thank you very much. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator. I want to thank all of our witnesses for their contributions to our hearing this morning. It was an excellent panel. I also want to point out that we had a number of Senators who dropped by who were unable to stay due to conflicts in their schedule, but I did want to read their names for the record: Senator Rick Scott, Senator Gillibrand, Senator Jones, with whom I have a bill to expand rural broadband, and Senator Blumenthal were all here. I very much appreciate that and know that they would have liked to have stayed. I also want to recognize Lisa Harvey-McPherson, who is here. I have worked with her for literally probably two decades on home health care issues. She was one of the people who first introduced me to the topic and sparked my great commitment to home health care. Home health care is clearly a compassionate and less- expensive way to care for our seniors, for our disabled citizens, and for others who need assistance. It is far less expensive than hospitalization or going to a long-term care facility. It allows our seniors and disabled citizens to be at home, and that is where they overwhelmingly want to be. Of an estimated 73 million baby boomers in America, roughly 10,000 of them turn 65 years old each day. That combined with the increasing life expectancy rate illustrate the need for us to ensure that we get ahead of this issue and that we ensure that we have the workforce, that we have the technology, that we have the reimbursements across all of the programs that are affected in place for caring for this generation, and that we not wait until we have a crisis, which I think we are approaching when it comes to workforce issues, to deal with these issues. As home health care has become even more skilled over the years its promise has grown, and we must do everything we can to not only keep the doors open for home health agencies but to help them thrive so that they can serve those rural patients. The two home health care bills that I have introduced have received wide bipartisan support, and I look forward to shepherding them across the finish line. Again, I want to thank our witnesses and Committee members for their dedication to the cause, and I also want to thank our staff for their hard work too. I now will turn to Senator Casey if he has any further closing remarks that he wants to make. Senator Casey. Chairman Collins, thank you for the hearing. I want to thank our witnesses for providing great insight into these issues. I will just be really brief and say we have to provide much more help for the people doing this work, and we have to prioritize the health care needs of rural Americans. We are not doing that nearly well enough. One of the best places to validate that we care deeply about the people who live in those communities is to make sure we do not cut existing services that are provided through programs, especially those like Medicaid. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Committee members will have until Friday, February 21st, to submit questions for the record. If we get additional questions we will be sending them your way. Again thank you, and our timing is exquisite because the vote has just begun. This concludes our hearing. [Whereupon, at 10:37 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Questions for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Additional Statements for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]