Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- REAUTHORIZATION OF SBA'S SMALL BUSINESS INVESTMENT COMPANY PROGRAM [Senate Hearing 116-554] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 116-554 REAUTHORIZATION OF SBA'S SMALL BUSINESS INVESTMENT COMPANY PROGRAM ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP of the UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ JUNE 26, 2019 __________ Printed for the Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 39-486 PDF WASHINGTON : 2022 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS ---------- MARCO RUBIO, Florida, Chairman BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, Maryland, Ranking Member JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho MARIA CANTWELL, Washington RAND PAUL, Kentucky JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire TIM SCOTT, South Carolina EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts JONI ERNST, Iowa CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey JAMES M. INHOFE, Oklahoma CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware TODD YOUNG, Indiana MAZIE HIRONO, Hawaii JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois MITT ROMNEY, Utah JACKY ROSEN, Nevada JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri Michael A. Needham, Republican Staff Director Sean Moore, Democratic Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Opening Statements Page Rubio, Hon. Marco, Chairman, a U.S. Senator from Florida......... 1 Cardin, Hon. Benjamin L., a U.S. Senator from Maryland........... 3 Witnesses Panel 1 Shepard, Mr. Joseph, Associate Administrator, Office of Investment and Innovation, U.S. Small Business Administration, Washington, DC................................................. 4 Panel 2 Palmer, Mr. Brett, President, Small Business Investor Alliance, Washington, DC................................................. 27 Muro, Mr. Mark, Senior Fellow and Policy Director, Metropolitan Policy Program, Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.......... 99 Ozkazanc-Pan, Prof. Banu, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Management, UMass Boston, Visiting Associate Professor of Sociology, Brown University, Boston, MA........................ 113 Alphabetical Listing and Appendix Material Submitted Brookings Institution report ``America's Advanced Industries: What They Are, Where They Are, And Why They Matter'' 136 Brookings article ``Reshoring: Why It's Not Easy''............... 224 Brookings article ``Is America's Seed Fund Investing in Women- and Minority-Owned Businesses?'' 227 Cardin, Hon. Benjamin L. Opening statement............................................ 3 Muro, Mr. Mark Testimony.................................................... 99 Prepared statement........................................... 101 Ozkazanc-Pan, Prof. Banu Testimony.................................................... 113 Prepared statement........................................... 115 Responses to questions submitted by Senator Hirono........... 245 Palmer, Mr. Brett Testimony.................................................... 27 Prepared statement........................................... 30 Rubio, Hon. Marco Opening statement............................................ 1 Shepard, Mr. Joseph Testimony.................................................... 4 Prepared statement........................................... 7 Responses to questions submitted by Chairman Rubio and Senators Booker, Hawley, Hirono, and Rosen................. 233 REAUTHORIZATION OF SBA'S SMALL BUSINESS INVESTMENT COMPANY PROGRAM ---------- WEDNESDAY, JUNE 26, 2019 United States Senate, Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 3:17 p.m., in Room 428A, Russell Senate Office Building, Hon. Marco Rubio, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Rubio, Ernst, Young, Kennedy, Romney, Hawley, Cardin, Cantwell, Shaheen, Coons, and Duckworth. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARCO RUBIO, CHAIRMAN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM FLORIDA Chairman Rubio. Today's hearing of the Senate Committee on Business and Entrepreneurship will come to order. I apologize. We are in the grips of a terrible plot against the Senate Small Business Committee. They keep scheduling like 18 votes at the same time as our meeting. I think we are going to change our name. But anyway, so the members will be coming in and out. I do not know what the--no one can tell us exactly what the future holds, but they will keep us up-to-date here on it. And Senator Cardin will be in in a minute. I am going to abbreviate my opening statement in the interest of time so we can get through this and not delay it any further. Today we are going to be having a pretty good conversation about the SBIC program, which is one of the earliest SBA programs. The impetus was a Federal Reserve Report that showed significant gaps in the business credit and equity markets, with the most prominent gap being found in the small business sector. And the report recommended the SBA to create a program to provide equity financing to small businesses. This resulted in the SBIC program that, in turn, popularized the venture capital model of investment in the 1960s and 1970s. And since then, the program has continued to provide venture capital financing to fill the gap in investment in small business by the private sector. The impact of the program is immense. In 2017, the Library of Congress prepared a report that measured the role of the program in small business job creation. It only covered the timeframe between October 1995 and December 2014, but found that the program created almost 3 million jobs during this period, which is one new job created for every $14,000 in SBIC investment. It also looked at administrative costs, and found the average administrative cost was approximately $35 per job created. So it is a clear example of the type of public-private partnership that fills a gap in the private marketplace and creates quantifiable results. It is a proven program that has historically met investment needs not being met by the private sector, and so it is prudent to reassess the state of investment in the United States, identify gaps in financing, and evaluate the opportunities that exist for this program to fill those gaps under current example. For example, there are meaningful market failures in the current configuration of the American innovation and advanced manufacturing ecosystem. The United States is beginning now the difficult work of confronting Chinese industrial policy, which has a clear goal of dominating the most important industries of the century, through government support, credits, access to guaranteed market share in their own large, domestic market. And so it is prudent for us to consider how we align public policy to address these market failures in the light of this direct national competition. The access to capital challenge that is facing innovative American firms with high-growth potential is damaging our country's competitiveness, and the financing gap is not being filled by private investment. Today, venture capital funding in the U.S. is highly concentrated by geography, primarily in areas like San Francisco, New York, and Boston, and by industry, largely to information and communication technology companies. The relatively short window for expected returns, combined with the prioritization of highly scalable, capital-light businesses for investment, skews funding toward digital technology and skews it away from capital-intensive manufacturing sectors with longer profit horizons. So creating an environment in which U.S. firms can compete globally, while creating jobs in the United States, is in our vital interest, because if the policy fails to address it, the United States will continue to lose to other nations, both in our capacity to produce now and our capacity to innovate in the future. These small advanced manufacturing firms, in particular, face a debilitating lack of access to critical finance in the U.S. Innovative firms engaged in complex, advanced manufacturing production require larger amounts of capital and they also require more time than non-production firms. While these kinds of firms can often find financing for the earlier stages of their development, they face difficulty accessing financing when they reach the larger-scale production and commercialization stage. Since innovation and production are so closely interwoven in advanced manufacturing, losing the ability to engage in advanced manufacturing production is prohibitive to the ability to innovate and conduct high-level research and development. So the SBIC program is uniquely positioned to play a role in filling this gap in financing and to leverage private domestic investment. After all, one of its tenets is to support industries that will undergird our national competitiveness. Our discussion today will explore the role of the SBIC program, the role it can play in this national discussion, as well as further expand upon its history, stability, and success. I look forward to discussing this with everyone. Are you ready? Senator Cardin. I am ready. Chairman Rubio. All right. I will turn it over to the Ranking Member. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM MARYLAND Senator Cardin. First, let me apologize for the lateness of starting this. As I am sure the Chairman has explained, we have been in a series of votes on the floor of the Senate, and there has been some discussion as to how we are going to proceed later today. I was involved in some of those discussions so I apologize for being a little bit late. I want to welcome all of our witnesses. This is our seventh hearing in regard to the reauthorization of the programs under the Small Business Administration. I think we all understand that the building block needed to start and grow business is capital, so today's hearing is particularly important. It was in 1958 that the Small Business Investment Act was passed by Congress, which recognized the realities that for small business it is very difficult to find investment dollars. Since then, the SBIC program has invested more than $97 billion in 10,000 small businesses, including many well-known companies like Intel, Apple, and FedEx. Last year alone, SBIC facilitated more than $5.5 billion in investment to more than 1,100 high-growth companies across the country, at zero cost to the American taxpayers. This funding is vital because traditional venture capital is overwhelmingly concentrated in urban centers in New York, Massachusetts, and California, with less than 1 percent of all venture capital going to businesses in rural communities. The lack of diversity is not just geographical. Around 2 percent of venture capital goes to women-owned businesses, and only 1 percent goes to black- and Hispanic-owned businesses. That is not acceptable. There are businesses in every community throughout America that could achieve growth if only they had the capital, and that is why we need the SBIC program. Consider, for example, Zentech Manufacturing, a Baltimore company that designs and builds high-tech circuit boards, cables, and other parts for companies in the defense and medical technology industries. When Zentech needed capital to prevent a takeover that would have shut down the company in Maryland and shipped dozens of jobs overseas, an SBIC fund was the only entity that could provide the type of capital Zentech needed. Since then, the company has increased its workforce by more than 60 percent and has successfully competed against overseas companies for contracts, reassuring manufacturing jobs here in the United States. These are well-paid jobs that are lifting families into the middle class. The simple truth is that traditional venture capital industry is doing an inadequate job of directing capital to communities most in need, and companies like Zentech are missing out on the opportunities for growth and job creation as a result. The SBIC program fills a very wide gap in traditional venture capital markets. But more importantly, SBIC is a good investment for the taxpayers. According to the 2017 Library of Congress report, SBIC creates one job for every $35 spent administering the program, and SBIC investments support minority- and women-owned businesses more than twice as often as traditional venture capital. That is not enough, but at least it is better. While SBIC does is a better job of reaching underserved communities, we still have to do a lot more. Our focus today must be on how we can take the SBIC program from a good program to a great program, a more inclusive program that reaches underserved communities frozen out of the traditional venture capital markets. We can begin by exploring how to build a pipeline of diverse investors into the SBIC program, because we know that racially and gender-diverse SBIC funds investment more frequently in minority- and women-owned businesses. We also need common-sense reforms to make the SBIC program more attractive to investors and more efficient for those who run SBIC funds, especially expediting the licensing process. These are some steps that will significantly improve the SBIC program as well as create jobs and value in communities nationwide. So I am looking forward to the discussion we have today, how we can improve the SBIC program, and the role that this Committee can play in facilitating those changes. Chairman Rubio. Thank you. Our first panel is one witness. Joseph Shepard is the Associate Administrator of the Office of Investment and Innovation at the Small Business Administration. He held the same position in the Administration of former President George W. Bush. Mr. Shepard, thank you for being here. We will begin with your testimony, and again, our apologies. STATEMENT OF JOSEPH SHEPARD, ASSOCIATE ADMINISTRATOR, OFFICE OF INVESTMENT AND INNOVATION, U.S. SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION, WASHINGTON, DC Mr. Shepard. Good. Good. Thank you, both, Chairman Rubio, thank you, and Ranking Member Cardin, thank you as well, and members of the Committee who will join us later, I am sure. I appreciate the opportunity to be here before you and discuss the reauthorization of SBA's Small Business Investment Company, or SBIC, program. I have spent a great deal of my private equity career in and around the SBIC program. In addition to having worked for an SBIC, several of my mentors were trained in SBICs, and from them I learned much of my on-the-job training and due diligence, financial analysis, investment structure, and transaction processing. Prior to assuming my current position at SBA on March 22, 2017, the SBIC program's capital-at-risk increased 1.8 times from $7.9 billion as of September 30, 2010, to $14.2 billion as of December 31, 2016. During this time, the SBA did not keep pace with this growth in areas such as technology, examinations, risk, SBIC program costs, and personnel. During my time at SBA, I have worked with the SBA team to identify challenges faced by the SBIC program, and together we have been endeavoring to modernize the program and make improvements. During this time, I have enjoyed the support and leadership of former administrator Linda McMahon, and I greatly appreciate the hard work of the SBIC program team and all my colleagues at the SBA. Following is a brief summary of the select improvements that we have made within the SBIC program. There have been no major technology improvements to the SBIC program since 1994. Since my arrival at SBA, it has been a priority of mine to modernize the SBIC program's information technology infrastructure. During the past two years, we have transitioned the legacy SBIC Web data collection system to SBA's Office of the Chief Information Officer, conducted an extensive review of the SBIC program's existing technology, procured a new software platform, and this year began the configuration of the new software. The implementation of this new software platform will allow the SBA to improve the information associated with the SBIC program and dramatically improve the SBA's data security, risk management and oversight capabilities. Prior to my arrival, challenges associated with the SBIC examinations were present, as a result of issues and practices prior to fiscal year 2017. A 2013 SBA Inspector General report had also identified deficiencies in the management of the SBIC examination process. Statute requires that SBICs be examined at least every two years. SBA began fiscal year 2017 with an estimated 56.9 percent of SBICs in statutory compliance. In fiscal year 2017, I recommended and then implemented an examination surge. Today, statutory compliance has improved dramatically and is now at 100 percent. Additionally, to better mitigate current and future credit risk in the SBIC program, the SBA enhanced its credit standard to require that all SBICs with SBA guaranteed leverage be examined within an 18-month time period. In fiscal year 2018, I initiated the creation of a new econometric subsidy model to replace the SBA's 27-year-old model. The result is an improved subsidy model that is reflective of the inherent risks associated with present-day private equity investing, and we believe will more accurately project future losses and long-term costs of the current SBIC program to taxpayers. The SBIC program also has a total operating cost each year that is not covered by subsidy. SBA's total cost to operate the SBIC program during fiscal year 2018 was $27.3 million. Since my arrival we have focused on ways to reduce taxpayer costs associated with SBIC program expenses. In 2017, SBA increased licensing fees paid by SBIC applicants and examination fees paid by operating SBICs. Both fees had not been increased since 1996. Finally, the SBIC program's workforce needs to evolve. Approximately 31 percent of the program's current position descriptions are 15 years or older, and 41 percent are 7 to 13- years-old. The oldest position description is 22 years old and was last revised in 1997. A contractor has been engaged to assist us in revising all outdated position descriptions. SBA will continue to hire additional staff and fill current future vacancies. New positions are also being created and filled, including an IT project manager, IT data scientist, senior examiner, senior risk and investment policy officer, and an investment accounting and analytics officer. I am committed to hiring for an organization that can support the program of the future. In conclusion, actions taken over the last two years have improved the SBIC program. Many of these changes and improvements are generational in nature with no previous such improvements occurring since the 1990s or for the past 20 years. As a result, the SBIC program is in a better position today to face the challenges of the future. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Shepard follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Rubio. Thank you. Mr. Shepard, I want to begin my questions by--I want to read you the statement of policy of the Small Business Investment Act. It is the law that created this. In creating this program, this is what Congress stated as its intent. Here is a quote: ``Stimulate and supplement the flow of private equity capital and long-term loan funds which small business concerns need for the sound financing of their business operations and for their growth, expansion, and modernization, and which are not available in adequate supply.'' End quote. That is the stated intent. It seems to me that Congress made clear when they passed it, and it is reiterated in many reforms to the law, that the intent of the SBIC program is to provide patient capital to small businesses that private financial markets do not otherwise provide. So let me ask, do you agree with Congress' enacted law and stated intent---- Mr. Shepard. Oh, absolutely. Chairman Rubio [continuing]. The goal of the--well, do you agree that the intent--let me just ask it this way. Do you agree that the law and the stated intent is to supplement the private market by increasing the flow of long-term funds to small businesses? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Chairman Rubio. Okay. Because in your testimony you implied that risk has increased in recent years, or at least has been undervalued, making necessary and update of the subsidy model SBA uses for the SBIC program. So, for example, you say that from fiscal year 2010 to 2018, the program experienced charge- offs where SBA expenditures on loans have defaulted, of $281 million for the debenture program. As you are aware, charge-off costs are not the only payment factor in the program. The SBA can recover assets on loans that have defaulted. They can charge fees on operating loans to cover costs. Is it not it true that during the same period the SBIC debenture program operated on a zero-subsidy basis? Mr. Shepard. That is correct, yes. Chairman Rubio. And is it also true that during this period the fees the SBA charges on the debenture SBIC program has been lower than the historical average? Mr. Shepard. Yes, absolutely. That is correct. Chairman Rubio. So you say in your testimony that upon your initiative, the SBA will begin to use a new econometric model to calculate its costs, that the model will include new assumptions like macroeconomic factors, private equity elements, private equity fund characteristics. You answered the first question agreeing, right, that the purpose of this is to provide funding that private market was not meeting. One of the purposes of the SBIC program is to fix that market failure, to increase the long-term patient capital that goes into small businesses, which would not be made available without the program. It is true, I think you would agree, that part of achieving this purpose is investing in small businesses that are themselves investing in innovations and new products which are, by definition, more uncertain investments than what the private market writ large has to offer. Mr. Shepard. Right. Chairman Rubio. So will the assumptions you have added to the historical model SBA has used, will it increase or decrease the time horizon of capital financing for these small businesses? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Thank you for--good question, Chairman. I thank you for the question. The intent of the subsidy model, that will not impact the disbursement of capital. The intent there, and with a lot of the things that I mentioned in the opening comment, were generational, things that have not been fixed, getting the program ready for the future, getting it ready for whatever may come. We looked at the subsidy model and we looked at how the portfolio was constructed, currently about $15 billion, and its move into more equity-oriented investments. When the model was built it was more debt-oriented, so I wanted to make sure--and we, as a team, wanted to make sure that we were accounting for future losses, and let's have a better model in place so as to stewards the taxpayer dollars we do not experience loss in the future. That was the intent. Chairman Rubio. You agree the metrics, the private financial markets are used, are more short-term, or sorry. I guess, let me ask you, are the metrics the private market uses more short-term or long-term in their views than the current SBA model? Mr. Shepard. I think they are similar. I think a lot of the investing activity that takes place in the SBIC model, the majority of it is subordinated debt of mezzanine, and it has got, you know, a maybe 3-, 5-, 7-year time horizon, very similar to the private sector. So I do not feel like there is a disconnect there, by any means. Chairman Rubio. Well, and which private equity elements will be used in assessing the default risk of--say there is a company that is developing a new cancer drug or a telecommunications equipment that can compete with Huawei. And would private equity elements investment in small business taking on these challenges without an SBIC program? Mr. Shepard. Well, to the subsidy model, we will be working with OMB. The implementation will occur in 2021. We are reviewing those right now, in terms of what those will be. They will be more macroeconomic in terms of trying to anticipate macroeconomic factors in our economy. And so it will be less oriented toward specific industries and more oriented toward the economy as a whole. Chairman Rubio. Well, I guess my last question--and I am going to turn it over to the Ranking Member--in developing the model, have you considered the shortfalls of equity valuation methods like the capital asset pricing model or others that are commonly used in the private markets, and undervaluing the development of long-term innovative product? As an example, which investment would capital asset pricing model more highly value, buying a share in an index fund in the S&P 500 or taking an equity stake in a company that, for example, is making new agricultural machinery to pick crops like strawberries in Florida that have been done manually? So do you take into account, in the model, the well-established shortfalls of this valuation method? Mr. Shepard. Yes. We are going to need to do that, without question. Chairman Rubio. Thank you. Ranking Member. Senator Cardin. Mr. Chairman, thank you very much for being here and for your service. You heard in my opening statement the concern I raised about opportunities in the traditional venture capital markets for women-owned businesses and minority businesses. And then I cited the SBIC numbers, which are twice as strong but still, I hope we all would agree, unacceptable. So what are your recommendations for how we can have a more diverse use of the SBIC funds and use it to help particularly women- and minority-owned businesses? Mr. Shepard. Right. Well, you know, I publicly stated before that, as the Chairman read, looking for areas in the intent and the mission of the SBIC program, to look for areas where there is not an adequate supply of capital, and certainly women, veterans, minorities, rural areas hit all of those areas. And I would say, as you look at our numbers, and as we have talked in the past, they are anemic in the impact that the program has had in a lot of those areas. Much room for improvement. And so I could not agree more that there is more that we should do and need to do. I will note that SBA invests and backs the capital that goes to the SBIC, and the SBIC investment managers are the ones who make those investments. Senator Cardin. I understand that completely. So how do we get--and that is why I said I think the key is to get more SBIC investors that are diverse, that represent diverse communities, including rural communities. How do we go about doing that? Mr. Shepard. I think what we have got to do is we have got to back up and look at the licensing phase, and make determinations about what kind of SBICs are going to be licensed and what plan are they going to put before the SBA, in terms of where their focus is going to be. Are you going to focus in women and minority areas? Are you going to focus in rural areas? And we have got to make the determinations there and then keep them on plan once they get into the marketplace, if they successfully get an SBA license. And I would look forward to working with your team to talk about--and the Committee--to talk about how can we do that? How can we do that inside the SBA to make that happen? Senator Cardin. So for entrepreneur development we have special programs to try to help our veterans, to help women. Do we need a similar program for the SBIC? Mr. Shepard. I think we could certainly do it within the current framework, but again, it begins in how do we license and who are we licensing to? Senator Cardin. So let me get to the licensing issue here, because I know that Chairman Risch, when he was Chairman of the Committee, held a hearing that dealt with the concerns about the length of time on the licensures, the complications. We have been told a lot of potential licensees decide not to go through the process because they think it just takes too long, and that, at least the information that we have, it is getting worse rather than better, as far as the process itself for licensure. The numbers of SBIC licenses that have been granted has gone down. So how do you streamline the license process to encourage more investors but also do it in a way that recruits in underserved communities? Mr. Shepard. Right. Well, the technology improvements that I have talked about are certainly going to help. We are hopeful, by the end of the summer--by the end of the fiscal year we will have implemented what we are calling the licensing tracker. So that should help us streamline and make our process more efficient. So that is one way, from a technology standpoint. When we have more startup, first-time small business investment companies, and we have seen an uptick in those, it does take a little longer to vet those. In the private sector it take anywhere from a year to two years. We are nowhere near that timeframe. We do a much better job. But there is always room for improvement. And so do we add more people? I am taking care of the technology standpoint. So that speaks to process and improving the process and having a better process in place. In terms of how do we get participants that are going to invest in some of these areas you have mentioned, we are going to have to do that by encouraging those people to come in, and again, are there ways to do that? Do we do that through regulation? Do we do that through statute? I think those are conversations that we need to have about the best way to impact the few, if you will, to impact those applicants that are coming in to invest in those types of small businesses. So let me ask you one last question dealing with early stage investments, because that would also target more to underserved communities if we had early stage investment. The program we did start was terminated, I believe for the reason that it was claimed not to be cost-effective. Does this need still exist, and how do we make it cost-effective? Mr. Shepard. Well, that was one of the reasons. There also was not a high degree of interest. A lot of it was the way the current program is built, is the majority of the funds that come in are subordinated debt or mezzanine. They are investing in operating companies that have existing cash flows that can service that debt that they are borrowing through the SBA guarantee. And so they are not early stage or seed companies. And so that is what you are seeing in the portfolio right now, if you will. That is what you are seeing in the SBIC. Senator Cardin. But would not early stage investment have a tendency to reach more of the underserved areas that are more women, more minorities, more rural? Mr. Shepard. Certainly startups and certainly early stage, and one other thing is we do have unleveraged small business investment companies. The majority of those do invest in early stage. They are welcome to come into the program at any time, because it is not a credit risk to the government. It is not a credit risk to the SBA. So they do come in to get the license, and many of them do invest in that area. Senator Cardin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Rubio. Senator Romney. Senator Romney. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Ranking Member. I appreciate the focus on this Committee on building our economy and providing opportunities for all our citizens. I am interested in understanding just where it is in the entire spectrum of investment that this investment activity that you carry out is playing a meaningful role. I do recognize that there is an underrepresentation in the private equity and venture capital world in businesses that are led by or founded by minorities and women. Having worked in that industry for some time, I would note that in my own experience very few of the people that came to us with proposals were minorities or women, although we did invest in a number. Meg Whitman at FTD, Judy George at Domain, and Linda Mason at Bright Horizons. And like most, some were successful and some were not. I do know that in the industry there is more money chasing deals than there are good deals, and my experience is that, well, at least from firms I knew, we would have invested in a Martian if we thought we could make money at it. So it was not that we were afraid of investing with a particular type of American. We just wanted the best deal we could possibly find that made a bunch of money for our investors, and, ultimately, for ourselves. Given the fact that there is so much money in private equity today, billions upon billions, and so much money in venture capital, with SoftBank and others that are just flooding the market, where are the gaps where the private market is not reaching, that this investment activity on the part of the SBA is reaching? Why do you exist, if you will, in this investment activity as opposed to just turning to the private market? Where are the gaps? Where are the places that you feel you need to play a role? Is it with regards to minority opportunities? Is it with regards to investing in things that have social values that may not have the high enough return to justify a standard venture capital investors? Is it a certain region of the country? Are you playing a redundant role that can be filled by the private sector, or are there really areas that you are filling that would not be filled otherwise? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Romney, thank you for your question. I will say that the small business investment companies are certainly internal-rate-of-return driven. They are trying to return to their limited partners a certain retain that has been promised to them, and then return the capital back to the SBA, that has been borrowed from the SBA. So their incentive is often return-based as opposed to based on investing in certain types of businesses. It maybe women-, minority-, veteran-owned, or geographic as well, in terms of rural investing. We would need to make some modifications to the program to incentivize that investment activity, otherwise, than its current state. In terms of gaps, we need more information, and I am working on getting a study together, hopefully beginning early in 2020, that will specifically address that issue, because we have a concern about it as well, and where in the marketplace is the need? I will tell you that in 1999, the program size was about $3 billion. It is now close to $15 billion. But there is a component of that portfolio that are business development companies, for example. They are now at about $3 billion. It is a pretty large concentration of the portfolio. It is between 20 and 25 percent. And the majority of those publicly traded companies do provide unitranche debt, which is also senior debt. And so there are certainly places where you can look at the portfolio and you can look at the activity and you can see competition with the free enterprise system. And the intent, of course, is to provide capital in those areas where there is not an adequate supply and not be competitive. And so not a great answer, because there are some unknowns, and we need to have some more information to define that better. Senator Romney. I would just note that I would think, in traditional venture capital and private equity, that there really is not a need for the government to participate and to, if you will, juice or leverage the returns that are available to private investors and private funds, that the reason for this activity potentially being supported by Congress and by our government and taxpayers is if it is focused on addressing a particular area where the need is not being met, where the private market is not reaching. And if the private market is effectively reaching every area then there is no particular reason for the taxpayer to subsidize returns to private equity and venture capital funds. And even then, even if there are gaps, one would have to ask, are we better trying to find ways to get the people that live in those gaps, or the individuals that are affected by those gap areas, to have better access to the private markets, or should government step in? So these are, I think, real questions that I hope we will be able to answer. Mr. Shepard. Right. And one other thing I will add, we are certainly, as you have mentioned, at an all-time high, in terms of private equity, close to $3 trillion, and maybe have surpassed that, private equity-based in the United States. And we have seen a decline in licensing activity because there is such an opportunity to raise capital in the private markets with LPs there, and I think that is part of the reason we have seen a steady decline of fewer SBICs, because they have been able to access that capital a different way. Senator Romney. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Rubio. Senator Cantwell. Senator Cantwell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you again for introducing legislation that is topical today to fix this problem as it relates to women-owned businesses being penalized if they actually have equity investment from being able to participate in the SBA program. So I am assuming that you agree that that is a good solution to fixing that problem. Mr. Shepard. I am not sure what. Senator Cantwell. So currently if you are a woman-owned business and you receive equity investment, they are saying that that counts against your minority ownership. Look, we have a major problem in America that women are underrepresented in our economy, and there are lots of reasons for that, but we need to work a lot harder on this Committee to make sure that access to capital, technical and skilled training, barriers that are inhibitors to that, we change the law to allow women- owned businesses to be sole-source, contract-approved at the Federal level. For the first time, Federal Government made their threshold numbers. So capital importance of opportunity, the Women's Centers, all these things are important to bringing up that number, which is a very low number. Frankly, my colleague, Senator Shaheen, and I, we like women as women-owned businesses because chances are they create products that we like and they are more geared toward the things that we are interested in. But the bottom line is we need half of our economy to be more entrepreneurial, and to do that they have to have access to capital and changing this law so they are not penalized. That was my question. Do you believe that we should continue to help women-owned businesses not be penalized under the Federal law? Mr. Shepard. Absolutely. That should not be a barrier to entry in our economy, by any means. Senator Cantwell. And you support the Women Business Centers? Mr. Shepard. Absolutely. They are a great product and one of the good things we have at SBA. Senator Cantwell. And do you agree that they are key tools, because again, part of some of the other programs that we have, again, have been oriented more toward a lot of retired CEOs, and that is great, but again, women come in to pitch them on an idea that they have, and they do not have familiarity with what the women are talking about--the market, the product, the solution. And so the Women Business Centers of the SBA helps fund a really key tool for somebody to just show up in a community and go, ``Where do I get started?'' Mr. Shepard. I agree. My mother was an entrepreneur when I was young, and she could have really used those. And so there are a lot of women today benefiting from that Small Business Administration resource, and it is a wonderful thing we have. Senator Cantwell. And the other thing we have figured out is they do not want to borrow as much as the guys want to borrow. They are just a little more--they did not want to borrow, you know, $500,000. They wanted to borrow smaller loan amounts, so also achieving that. But I want to, again, thank Chairman Rubio for co- sponsoring this legislation. I am hoping our colleagues will help support this so that that private sector investment will not penalize women ownership from getting access to these Federal programs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Rubio. Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you--what do I call you, Commissioner Shepard? Mr. Shepard. Associate Administrator. Senator Kennedy. Administrator. Mr. Shepard. Associate Administrator Shepard. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Thanks for being here today. Mr. Shepard. Thank you, Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. Why don't you like SBICs? Mr. Shepard. I actually do. Senator Kennedy. Well, you know, one of the things that I have learned since I have been up here--I have not been up here for a while--but you have to watch what people do, not what they say. Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy. So you have been Associate Director I think two terms. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Kennedy. And you are--while you are in office, the average number of SBICs approved is 11. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Senator Kennedy. When you are out of office, the average is double that. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Senator Kennedy. That tells me you do not like them. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Why is that? Mr. Shepard. Yes. I do. I think in the Bush administration I was in that position for a little over a year---- Senator Kennedy. Yes, and you averaged 11. Mr. Shepard [continuing]. And we had the Great Recession, and we had a lot of funds that---- Senator Kennedy. And you are averaging 11 now. Mr. Shepard. And--and---- Senator Kennedy. And the normal is 20. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Senator Kennedy. I mean, if I am a small business woman or man, and let's say I have got an $8 million company---- Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. But I have got promising new software, and I go to SoftBank or Sequoia Capital and ask for money, they are not going to even see me, are they? Mr. Shepard. Right. Right. Probably not. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Okay? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Yes. Senator Kennedy. That is the purpose of an SBIC. Correct? Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. In many instances, yes. Senator Kennedy. So let me ask you again, why don't you like them? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Yes. Well, I do. I absolutely do. Senator Kennedy. Well, then why don't you approve them? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Well, we have been approving them. Senator Kennedy. Not very quickly. Mr. Shepard. We are doing--we are doing as good a job as we can. We can always do better. Senator Kennedy. Do you need more people, or do you---- Mr. Shepard. We may need--we may need more people. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. Or do your people just--I mean, it is not only that you are not approving them--and I am not suggesting that your analysis should not be rigorous---- Mr. Shepard. Yes, sure. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. But when you are not in office---- Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. It seems to go much more quickly. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Senator Kennedy. And it is not just the denial, it is the delay. Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy. That is what most people hate about government. It is the stall and restall. Mr. Shepard. Sure. Senator Kennedy. I mean, if you continue going at the pace you are going, the average age of your applicants for an SBIC license---- Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. Is going to be deceased. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yes. Senator Kennedy. So what is the problem? Mr. Shepard. Yes. Yes. Well, I think, you know, last year we licensed 25, and we had a period of time where we actually licensed faster than we had ever done before, in 5.1 months. We had a lot of subsequent funds, so we licensed faster. We are seeing more startup funds or new funds. Those take a little longer to process, and so that extends our licensing time from five months to, say, seven months. Senator Kennedy. Well, but, isn't there a--I am sorry for interrupting you but I have only got 5 minutes. Mr. Shepard. Sure. Sure. I understand. Senator Kennedy. Rubio is tough. Mr. Shepard. Yes, sir. Senator Kennedy. He is tough. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Kennedy. But if you have got a brand-new license application, but you have a lot of folks who have had one SBIC---- Mr. Shepard. Correct. Yes. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. And they are applying for a second one---- Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. It would seem to me that the second one should go more quickly. Mr. Shepard. We can move them faster. Senator Kennedy. No, you do not. No, you do not. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Kennedy. It takes just as long, and in some cases, longer, and I do not get it. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Kennedy. I mean, to me there is a--yes, there is a lot of venture capital out there. There is venture capital all over hell and half of Georgia. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Sure. Senator Kennedy. But unless you are a big girl or a big boy, you are not going to have access to any of it. Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy. That is what the SBIC is for. Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy. That is your job. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Not once I do get an answer out of you guys, you just say, ``Denied,'' and I say, ``Why?'' Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Kennedy. And you say, ``If I told you, I would have to kill you.'' Mr. Shepard. Yes. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Why don't you tell people why you are lying to them? Mr. Shepard. Well, we do. Senator Kennedy. No, you do not. Mr. Shepard. We have---- Senator Kennedy. Why isn't there an appeals process? Mr. Shepard [continuing]. We--we--we have not had any denials at the agency committee level. Senator Kennedy. Yes. It is because you do not give them an answer. Mr. Shepard. Well, we---- Senator Kennedy. It is because you stall them and restall them. Mr. Shepard. Well, we--we--we answer them as quickly as possible at that level, and we have approved several at that level, and we have not had a lot of denials there. I think one of the things to keep in mind is we cannot force capital formation. They have to decide to apply---- Senator Kennedy. Okay. Mr. Shepard [continuing]. And---- Senator Kennedy. I am about to run out of time and I want to land this plane on time. Mr. Shepard. Understood. Senator Kennedy. Mr. Shepard, I do not know you. I know you are a fine person. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Senator Kennedy. I do not think you like SBICs. Either that or you have got folks who just are not competent. Mr. Shepard. Okay. Senator Kennedy. I think applicants deserve an answer when they are denied. I think you should tell them why. I think that if you really do not support SBICs you are in the wrong job. Mr. Shepard. Right. Understood. Yes. Senator Kennedy. And it does not look to me like, based on your behavior, you support them. Mr. Shepard. OK. Senator Kennedy. Now I am not telling you, do not be rigorous in your analysis. Mr. Shepard. Understood. Yes. Senator Kennedy. This is taxpayer money. Mr. Shepard. Right. Senator Kennedy. But I am telling you, I am suggesting to you, if you have a bias against SBICs, you ought to go run for the Senate or something. Mr. Shepard. Right. Right. Senator Kennedy. But you should not be doing what you are doing. Mr. Shepard. Right. Well, I do like the program and would look forward to visiting more with your staff about some of these instances, and making sure that we clarify some things. Senator Kennedy. Thank you for your service. Mr. Shepard. Thank you very much. Chairman Rubio. Before I turn it over to Senator Shaheen I want to just take on that, because I do not want to forget to bring it up. When we talked about the new models that you are going to be using to calculate the costs, it is going to include assumptions--I read them out already--macroeconomic factors, private equity elements, private equity fund characteristics. And you initiated this new model. Are these assumptions that you are coming up with, are those required by the Federal Credit Reform Act or the Office of Management and Budget? Mr. Shepard. The Federal Credit Reform Act does speak to the fact that you should have a model, that underlying model that mimics the type of investment activity. And so that is what we are trying to do with this Federal Credit Program. Chairman Rubio. Right. But the FCRA and the OMB only require the use of Treasury discount rates. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Chairman Rubio. That is the only ones they require. So these are ones you chose. Mr. Shepard. We are working on selecting them. They have not been selected yet. Chairman Rubio. But those are the ones you are leaning toward choosing or using, correct? Mr. Shepard. Yes, sir. Correct. And we will vet that with OMB and make sure that it is done right. There is no question about that. Chairman Rubio. Yes, and I guess, building on what Senator Kennedy's question was, how is this evaluation of the program not you substituting your own priorities for those that Congress has laid out? Mr. Shepard. Oh, and it is not intended to be a substitution, by any means, Chairman. It is intended to do a better job of making sure that we secure taxpayer dollars and that we do not have losses. So it is trying to improve the program to make it better from a loss standpoint. Chairman Rubio. Senator Shaheen. Senator Shaheen. Well, just--my time needs to go back up to five minutes. Chairman Rubio. I do not even look at it so you can go ahead. I do--only for Kennedy do I look at the time. Everybody else---- Senator Kennedy. You better watch Rubio. Senator Shaheen. I know. Really. Just to be clear, so that I understand what your response was to Senator Rubio, I understood you to say that the criteria that you have laid out are not criteria that are required by the law. Is that correct? Mr. Shepard. I--we have--I am not sure about that. We have actually---- Senator Shaheen. Well, can you get an answer for this Committee? Mr. Shepard. I absolutely can. Yes. Yes, ma'am. Senator Shaheen. Mr. Chairman, if you could share that answer as soon as we get it, I would appreciate it. Chairman Rubio. Sure. I think we know the answer but we are more than happy to hear what---- Senator Shaheen. I agree. Mr. Shepard. Thank you. Senator Shaheen. So I guess I have to say, Mr. Shepard, I found your responses to Senator Kennedy totally unacceptable, because the SBA's statistics show that the average licensing timeline for SBICs rose to 8.2 months in 2017, from 5.1 months in 2016, and that the program has led new license requests to decline from 29 in 2017, to just 17 in 2018. So again, I do not know what has caused this, but I know that you are in charge, and that the program is going in the wrong direction. Mr. Shepard. Mm-hmm. Senator Shaheen. So I think it is incumbent on you to find out what is causing the decline in license requests and the increasing timeline, so that we can fix that. Mr. Shepard. Correct. Yes. Senator Shaheen. Because I agree with Senator Cantwell. As I have traveled around and looked at what is happening in the economy right now, one of the things that we know is that women-owned businesses are increasing much more dramatically than other businesses, women- and minority-owned businesses, and that they are employing people at a greater rate. And we also know that women-owned businesses have a much harder time getting access to capital. And so I guess what I want to know is what is SBA doing to make clear to women and minorities that the SBIC program is available to help reduce barriers to new entrants. So what are you doing to reach out to women and minorities to ensure that they understand that SBIC is something that they can participate in as well? Mr. Shepard. Right. Well, there are two answers. The Small Business Investment Companies who actually make the investments are the ones that would be having the majority of the dialog with those women-owned businesses and making investment decisions about whether they are going to invest in them or not. On our side, in terms of licensing, it would be making sure that the female fund investors can invest, using SBIC as a vehicle for an investment fund. And we have a few, but as I mentioned, Senator Cardin, we need more, and we do not have an issue with that at all. We just do not have very many female prospective fund managers that come in seeking an SBA license to operate an SBIC. Senator Shaheen. And so are there things that you think SBA might do to encourage more women and minorities to be able to do that? Mr. Shepard. I think we could certainly improve in that area. Yes, ma'am. Senator Shaheen. And what kinds of things do you think might be possible for SBA to do? Mr. Shepard. I think we could maybe use some of our other partners within the SBA to communicate that message better, and also use our education team that we have in-house within the SBIC program to have better outreach to those groups and those entities. Senator Shaheen. Well, I would certainly encourage you to do that---- Mr. Shepard. I appreciate that. Senator Shaheen [continuing]. Because as we look at where job creation is happening, there are tremendous opportunities there. And so I hope SBA will encourage the SBIC program to be more inclusive. Mr. Shepard. Yes, ma'am. Senator Shaheen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Rubio. Seven minutes left. You did not need the reset. Senator Hawley. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Shepard, I have got to be honest with you. My office has heard a lot of complaints from SBICs about your process, and to be frank with you about your leadership. And so like other members of this Committee I think I am trying to get to the bottom of this. But when I say ``a lot,'' I mean a lot. So was the SBIC approval process inadequate before you came to office? I mean, is that the issue here, that you have had to clean up? Is your position that we are approving way too many of these, and the whole thing needed to be overhauled? Mr. Shepard. Not at all. I mean, there are certainly improvements that need to be made, and I have put those in the written testimony, and before you got here talked a little bit about some of those enhancements and improvements. But the intent is to make the program better and to streamline. Senator Hawley. So that explains why there has been a 50 percent reduction in the approvals, in the way that Senator Kennedy was asking? Mr. Shepard. Just the processes alone should not account for that. I think---- Senator Hawley. So do you know--how many staff are in your office? Mr. Shepard. Total? We have got 82 is our count. Senator Hawley. So how many staff vacancies are in the office? Mr. Shepard. We have got 11. Eight are in the process of recruitment and three are about ready to be recruited. Senator Hawley. What about senior management positions? Do you have any of those that are unfilled? Mr. Shepard. We have a deputy position that needs to be filled. That is the only senior management. Senator Hawley. You know, a major complaint from the SBIC is the time it is taking to process applications, schedule interviews, classes, even doing something as simple as actually sending a license to the applicant once they have been approved. What accounts for that? Are you not adequately staffed? Is your staff not good at their job? I mean, what is the--what are we to believe? What are we to conclude? Mr. Shepard. Our staff is fantastic at their job, and they are wonderful people. And I think more of it, we could certainly look at our personnel and look at our size. Senator Hawley. I mean, if your staff is really good at their job, but the program does not seem to be functioning, and the processes are fine, I mean, what are we left to--I mean, who is the weak link then? I mean, where does that leave us? Mr. Shepard. Yes. The program has doubled in size, and so we have got a lot more work to do. And so we are certainly--we certainly could look at personnel and driving up those numbers. Senator Hawley. Why don't you give applicants who deny the opportunity, or who are denied approval, the opportunity to amend their application, to account for whatever would have caused the denial? Mr. Shepard. I think unless--unless it is an issue of-- unless it is some kind of a legal issue, I do not know why we would not do that, and that is something I will look into with our team, because they certainly should have an opportunity to adjudicate or to come back around and have a fuller discussion. Senator Hawley. It just seems strange that after applicants spend who knows how many hours--tens, hundreds of thousands of dollars, raising millions of dollars in private capital, seeking a license, that you do not give them either the courtesy of an explanation, to Senator Kennedy's point, or the opportunity to fix their application. I mean, that seems strange to me. Don't you think so? Mr. Shepard. I would agree, and I need to look into more of why that may be happening and some of those areas where that is happening. Senator Hawley. Let me ask you something else. In December 2018, Chairman Rubio's Spurring Business in Communities Act became law. I was not here then but that is an important bill to me, because it gives first priority to SBIC applicants who are located in under-licensed states like mine, like the State of Missouri, and it removes certain capital requirements to make it easier for applicants from underserved states like mine to participate in the program. So that was over six months ago. Where are we on implementation? Mr. Shepard. We are close and we are going to have it done by the end of the fiscal year, so in this next quarter. Senator Hawley. So when can I expect to see results in Missouri small business investment as a result of your implementation? Mr. Shepard. Yes. I think at the beginning of the next fiscal year, starting in that first quarter, we will start promoting that and talking about that program. Senator Hawley. So you have taken steps toward implementation? Mr. Shepard. Oh, absolutely. Senator Hawley. Yes. For example? Mr. Shepard. Well, we have taken steps toward finalizing the legislation, and we are starting to plan outreach to talk about and announce it. Senator Hawley. Wait. Okay, wait. So you are starting to plan outreach. So you have not actually done any implementation? Mr. Shepard. We have an event in Oklahoma planned in August, to talk about--to talk about the underserved and the under-licensed. Senator Hawley. Okay. So that will be your first event. Mr. Shepard. Yes, sir. Senator Hawley. So so far you have not done anything. Mr. Shepard. So far what, sir? Senator Hawley. So far you have not done anything. You said in August. This is June. Mr. Shepard. Oh, this is outreach, outreach about the program. We are close to implementation and should have that done in about---- Senator Hawley. So you have not done any implementation yet? Mr. Shepard. No implementation yet. No, sir. Senator Hawley. Okay. Mr. Shepard. Yes. Senator Hawley. You know, are you aware that Committee staff invited several SBIC fund managers to testify here today but none agreed to do so, for fear of reprisal from you? Mr. Shepard. I did not know that, and that---- Senator Hawley. Don't you think that is alarming? Mr. Shepard. It is unfortunate. Senator Hawley. What accounts for that? Mr. Shepard. I do not know. I do not know. That should not be the case, but I do not know. Senator Hawley. No, it should not be the case. What should we do about that, do you think? Mr. Shepard. Yes. I do not know. They should be here. I would like them to be here. I would like us to have a good conversation with those SBIC fund managers. Senator Hawley. Hm. Have you ever delayed or denied the processing of an applicant as a form of punishment or reprisal? Mr. Shepard. Absolutely not. Senator Hawley. You are sure about that? Mr. Shepard. I am pretty sure. Yes, sir. I do not know why anyone would ever---- Senator Hawley. You are pretty sure or you are 100 percent sure? Mr. Shepard. I am 100 percent sure I---- Senator Hawley. And you are--you are---- Mr. Shepard [continuing]. Would not do that. Senator Hawley. Okay. You are on the record and you are under oath. Mr. Shepard. Understood. Yes, sir. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Rubio. I guess, I know it has been a tough hearing. You can hear some of the pushback and I would just comment, you know, we read through some of this and you sort of see some of the language--we see the performance, and we see sort of in your testimony and this discussion about providing sort of private equity-type structures and metrics to the program moving forward as a way to justify sort of why the program is not delivering the same numbers as it did in the past or historically has done, and sort of couched in the sense that we want accountability for taxpayer dollars. But I think one of the reasons why this program exists is the acknowledgment or the belief by members of Congress that private equity--I think this problem has gotten worse-- fundamentally undervalues innovation. And so you see these buzz words like private equity to justify the reduced activity and I get concerned, I personally do, you know. And I think one of the trends we have seen is the finalization of our companies, particularly the management of companies, has come into being. You have seen less investment in things that have a longer life, for example physical assets like equipment or machines or plants or even research and development. Industrial innovation has paid a price, in my view anyways, as we financialize corporate governance and corporate decisionmaking. At some point, the financial markets concluded that it was just too risky to invest in these sorts of things anymore. And so it would be ironic if the very program that was designed to help small business overcome financialization of these decisions was financialized itself. And so when we add what we have heard from you today, these new metrics that are being designed, with the numbers that we have seen and some of the other things that have been brought up, I think you understand that this Committee is pretty--for lack of a scientific term--fired up about not just the direction this program is going but our view as to the direction it is being taken. And I hope that came across today. It certainly did for me. Mr. Shepard. Yes, sir. Chairman Rubio. I do not know if the ranking member has anything to add. Senator Cardin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Shepard, I think there is a general consensus here on a couple of things. First, we like the SBIC program. Democrats, Republicans, small businesses, we like the SBIC program. Secondly, we are not satisfied with the time it takes for an application to be received and the numbers that are being approved and the outreach to underserved communities not having investors. I would point out, you indicated that the program has grown. Our information shows that actually there was a reduction in the total funds in the SBIC from fiscal year 2017 to fiscal year 2018. It actually went down. So that is unacceptable. When you look at the total volume today, it is about what it was four years ago. So it is not the type of growth that we would have expected in the SBIC program. So this is a hearing on reauthorization. There is something not working. If it is the law, let us know how we need to change the law so Congress can give you the tools you need through statute. If it is the way that your agency is organized and the resources that you are getting, let us know that so that we can deal with it. If it is a matter of capacity in your agency, we need to know that also. That is our responsibility on oversight. But the bottom line is this is a very important program. It is not meeting the expectations that we have set for it in total availability and it is not fairly distributed among all of the communities that need small business financing. So this is an opportunity for you to present to us ways that we can improve the law and give you the tools you need because you have bipartisan support for this program. So I would just urge you to take advantage of that and get that information to this committee. Mr. Shepard. We will do so and appreciate that, Senator. Thank you. Chairman Rubio. Senator Hawley, anything else? Senator Hawley. No. Chairman Rubio. Thank you. Thanks for being here today. We are going to transition to the second panel. Again, our apologies for the late start. I will introduce the second panel as they come up. It will buy us some time here. Brett Palmer is the President of the Small Business Investor Alliance. In his role at the SBIA, he represents small business investment companies and the institutional investors in these funds. Mark Muro is the Senior Fellow and Policy Director of the Metropolitan Policy Program at the Brookings Institution. He focuses his work on regional technology, ecosystems and economic development. He has published extensively on digital trends, automation, advance industries, and regional development issues. Dr. Banu Ozkazanc-Pan--did I say that right? Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan. Pretty good. Chairman Rubio. I like getting names right. Ozkazanc-Pan---- Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan. Ozkazanc-Pan. Chairman Rubio. Ozkazanc, I have to say it faster, perfect. Dr. Ozkazanc-Pan, is an Associate Professor at the University of Massachusetts and a Visiting Associate Professor of Sociology at Brown University. Obviously, you do not have a non-compete there. That is great, you are in two places. Her work examines diversity and inclusion in organizations and entrepreneurship. Her latest research focuses on the effects the venture capitalists have on the flow of resources in entrepreneurial ecosystems. So I will just begin from my left to my right. Mr. Palmer, thank you, and the floor is yours. STATEMENT OF BRETT PALMER, PRESIDENT, SMALL BUSINESS INVESTOR ALLIANCE, WASHINGTON, DC Mr. Palmer. Thank you, Chairman Rubio. My name is Brett Palmer. I am President of the Small Business Investor Alliance. I would like to thank the Chairman, the Ranking Member, and the other Senators participating today for taking part in this hearing, for reviewing the Small Business Investment Company program, discussing small business investment generally, and answering any questions you may have about it. The SBIA is the trade association of small business investors that includes the SBIC industry. The goal of the SBIA is to promote a healthy ecosystem for small business investing, one that benefits both small businesses and their investors, and thereby promoting economic growth and job creation. Small business investment companies have been around since 1958. And what was true in the 1950s will always be true. Small businesses need external capital to grow and to thrive and to reach the next level. And it is really hard to access that type of capital. Debenture and non-levered SBICs have increased the amount of small business investment capital, with over $28 billion invested domestically over the last five years. All SBIC investments must be used exclusively for domestic small businesses with at least 25 of those investments going to smaller enterprises, which is a smaller standard than the small business standard. SBICs cannot be used for an investment for short-term projects and cannot be used for moving jobs offshore. By law, SBICs are focused on America. SBICs provide an important national benefit because SBICs are often the first institutional capital into small businesses. SBICs help with not only capital but also expert advice on how to scale up and professionalize as a company grows. SBICs invest across a broad range of industries and across a broad range of geographies. It is common to see investment in manufacturing and other not so flashy industries and in low and moderate income areas, as well as parts of the country generally overlooked or flown over. In contrast, venture investment is extremely concentrated and a lot of private equity investment is also concentrated. SBICs invest in a far, far more broader footprint. This is one of the reasons why we need more SBICs and we need them in more places. The SBIC program has a very strong taxpayer protection system built into the system. It is maintained at zero subsidy now, the SBIC debenture program, for about 22 years since Congress reformed in the late 1990s. The SBIC program continues to have some of the healthiest and strongest payback period in its 60-year history. The annual charge that Chairman Rubio mentioned is a fee that covers potential losses to the program. It is at its lowest rate in 60 years. The SBIC leverage has continued to operate that zero subsidy and we expect that to continue. There is a strong private sector interest in investing in small businesses, and particularly via Small Business Investment Companies, which is critical because the private sector is the leading component to make the program work. This is not a subsidy program. It is not a grant program. It is not a prop up failing businesses program. It is a market driven program where market forces are aligned with a clear public benefit of more jobs, more innovation, and more geographic dispersion of opportunity. A 2017 Library of Congress study, which you all have mentioned, highlighted that the SBIC program has backed businesses that created 3 million jobs and support an additional 6.5 million jobs over the 20 year period, an incredibly efficient rate to the taxpayer. This study was performed by researchers from Duke and Pepperdine's Business School. Your average debenture-backed SBIC business added 125 new jobs. Non-levered and equity oriented SBICs created over 530 new jobs per small business. That is an average, that is not universal for each one. But to put that into perspective, over the 20-year period of the study, that represents about 7 percent of the net new jobs in the United States from SBIC- backed businesses. That is an extraordinary number for a little known program, but that is what it is supposed to do. Most of these companies will never even consider going public. They will never be written about in the Wall Street Journal. But they almost all grow, changing lives and supporting communities. All of these quiet little business successes add up to something big, which is the reason the SBIC program has broad bipartisan support. The SBIC program is good, but it is not perfect and there are limits to any government program. Every government program can benefit from congressional oversight, regular reforms and updates, and we thank you for having this hearing. We welcome the oversight and we want to work with Congress to make improvements. There are still significant market gaps that are leaving too many small businesses unable to grow due to a lack of capital. My written testimony, which is far more robust than you see from normal congressional testimony--it is almost a phone book that you see before you--is broken into three categories because it is an unusual program. It is a plain English of how the program works, is the first section. The second section is ideas for improving the operation of the program and for using the program to shrink what is commonly called the ``valley of death'' because there are still a lot of businesses that are good businesses that are not able to access the capital they need to access that next level. And third, and regrettably, is a sampling of the profoundly frustrating dumbfounding mismanagement that is creating unnecessary risks and cutting off of capital to small businesses. I would like to thank Senator Rubio, Coons and others here for their efforts to be thoughtful and deliberate about manufacturing in particular, and we would like to see an international policy as we compete globally against the Chinese and others to really create that long-term investing. I would be happy to answer any of your questions. I would also mention, with the few seconds I have left, that I would like, if the chance presents itself, to respond to some of the questions directed to the first witness that I think, frankly, need significantly more fleshing out to give a full picture of the truth. But with that, I would hand it over to Mr. Muro. [The prepared statement of Mr. Palmer follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Rubio. Mr. Muro. STATEMENT OF MARK MURO, SENIOR FELLOW AND POLICY DIRECTOR, METROPOLITAN POLICY PROGRAM, BROOKINGS INSTITUTION, WASHINGTON, DC Mr. Muro. Thank you, Chairman Rubio, Ranking Member Cardin, members of the Committee who I assume will see this material otherwise. Thank you for inviting me today. My expertise revolves around what my group at Brookings Institution calls America's advanced industry sector. More on that in just a sec. But I want to suggest how the SBIC could be better positioned to support those industries that our particular industry claims we need to talk about. Specifically, I want to urge that the committee explicitly prioritize advanced manufacturing enterprises when it revisits the SBIC's activities in the coming months. Not all industries matter equally. Indeed, these high- productivity, high-pay innovation industries anchor American competitiveness, and matter inordinately. We need to think about them and nudge the SBA's and the SBIC's services and resources toward support of those. What are advanced industries? Why do they matter? Brookings defines these industries as those in which the R&D spending per worker reaches the top 20 percent of all industries and the share of workers with significant STEM knowledge exceeds the national average. We count three energy, 12 service industries, and 35 manufacturing industries. This super sector is dominated by strong advanced manufacturing. Among these 35 manufacturing industries is automaking, aerospace, pharma, medical devices, computers, semiconductors, chemicals and their huge supply chains. Why do they matter so much? The advance industries sector encompasses much of the nation's most crucial economic activity. It anchors the traded sector, generates above average productivity, and supports long supply chains. It spreads innovation because its inordinate R&D spending drives product and process innovation, both within enterprises and then through spillovers throughout the economy. And then this group of industries I am talking about train and employ the nation's STEM workforce. They find them, they locate them, they hire them, they train them both engineering talent but also non-BA technical workers, what we call blue collar STEM. We can go over a few of the statistics here. They are delivering value, these industries. Advanced industries perform 90 percent of the private sector R&D in our country. Advanced industries, including advanced manufacturing, are extraordinarily productive. Each worker generated approximately $250,000 worth of output last year, twice the amount of the other sectors. And advanced industries punch way above their weight in generating our GDP, $3.7 trillion worth of output, 18 percent significant. Advanced manufacturing, about 40 percent of that. The bottom line is this, without a competitive advanced sector, it is going to be simply not possible for the U.S. to maintain global preeminence, sustained prosperity, and renew national unity. So I want to bring that national imperative into this discussion. But here is the problem, as we have been hearing, there is now abundant evidence that the primacy of America's advanced industries, and especially its advanced manufacturing sectors being contested and eroding. Slipping U.S. R&D investments, low STEM graduating production, thinning of manufacturing ecosystems is our problem. So we are going to need to intervene here. But the challenge of finance is a very real additional challenge. Inherent biases of VC and capital resources skew the existing small firm financing system away from these capital intensive manufacturing enterprises. There is a role to intervene here. Policy should address this. The SBIC is clearly a useful tool for some of this work and should be further enabled to assist advanced manufacturing concerns in the coming years. The lack of sectoral specificity in the program and in loan making means that public funds are not always maybe channeled to the highest and best use in this national purpose. And then we have heard about the repayment structure which begins immediately and is comprised of an SBA annual charge plus interest due, just simply is not conducive to the nature of the long-term product development timelines that advanced manufacturing firms require. So I endorse several of the ideas that I think are being discussed. Explicit prioritization of advanced manufacturing growth makes a ton of sense and the Committee could provide for more robust and patient capital in SBIC funding. The SBA should adopt an ethos of investing in the national interest here. It is not just a technical matter. The national interest needs to enter this discussion and I think this Committee has been strong on that. America's medium- and long-term competitiveness will be heavily influenced by its success in expanding these advanced industries. Success or failure will be determined, meanwhile, by our choices--something I think you have written about--and what we choose to do and not to do in a world of great competition. So I think working to improve the availability of patient capital for smaller advanced manufacturing firms would be a good choice. So thank you again for having me. [The prepared statement of Mr. Muro follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Rubio. Dr. Pan. STATEMENT OF BANU OZKAZANC-PAN, PhD., ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF MANAGEMENT, UMASS BOSTON AND VISITING ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF SOCIOLOGY, BROWN UNIVERSITY, BOSTON, MA Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan. Thank you. Chairman Rubio, Ranking Member Cardin, and Members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify here today. In addition to my very long title, I am the founding director of the Venture Capital Inclusion Lab at Brown University and happy to speak further about some of the work that we are doing. Today, I will provide a broad overview of the VC industry and then go on to discuss the specifics as they relate to women and minorities. The VC industry last year saw record growth in investments. Last year, the industry invested around $130.9 billion across 8,948 deals and raised $55.5 billion across 256 funds, representing record amounts compared to the dot com boom era. During this time, around 62 percent of total invested capital was due to deals sized $50 million or larger. VC mega- funds, or those raising $500 million or more, accounted for 57 percent of all capital raised. These large funds were partially supported by the involvement of private equity and corporate VC investments. During this time, we saw that both deal size and valuations grow, particularly in early stages. Right now, $25 million deals or larger now represent almost 62 percent of all early stage deals by value. However, whether the pace of such investment activity is sustainable continues and needs to be seen. There is some concern about the amount of available capital and whether it is being deployed efficiently. In addition, the majority of VC investments go to pharma, biotech, and software industries with software representing the largest single sector for VC money. Despite the growth of VC investments, the situation for women and minorities is quite different. On the investor side, a 2017 report by TechCrunch found that women represented 8 percent of all partners in top 100 VC firms. Only 1 percent of survey's 713 VC firms had Black decisionmakers, coming out with a whopping 7 individuals, while Hispanic decisionmakers were represented at 1.5 percent and Asians at 24 percent. Overall, 85 percent of decisionmakers in the U.S. VC industry are male and 73 percent are white. On the entrepreneur side, less than 1 percent of Black women receive VC funding and startups with a female CEO have received only 2.7 percent of all VC money. We see that all male teams represent 82 percent of all VC- backed startups. Blacks represent 1 percent, Latinos around 2 percent, and Asians around 18 percent. In general, Whites represent about 77 percent of all VC-backed companies. Despite these challenging facts, 40 percent of all current businesses in the U.S. are women-owned. These businesses have been growing at impressive rates. Between 2007 and 2018, women- owned businesses grew at 58 percent compared to 12 percent growth across all businesses. Women of color-owned businesses grew an impressive 163 percent during the same time. Despite this growth, revenues generated by women of color- owned businesses have dropped between 2007 and 2018 by 21 percent, whereas non-minority-owned business revenue grew by 17. Research shows that if revenues generated by minority women-owned businesses matched those currently generated by all women-owned businesses, they would add 4 million additional jobs and $1.4 trillion in revenues to the U.S. economy. Similarly, if minority-owned businesses were at entrepreneurial parity, the U.S. would gain 1.9 million firms, 13.2 million more employees, and an additional $2.9 trillion in gross receipts. The challenges are taking place at a historic moment. The U.S. is changing in terms of demography and this will mean new consumers, markets, and opportunities will emerge. At the same time, increased global competition requires investments to make the U.S. economy strong and competitive. SBICs can provide these investments and can be even stronger in terms of employment and job creation. New programs, such as on-ramps for women and minority fund managers and investors can boost the already better than industry numbers for gender and racial diversity in SBICs. They can allow expanded deal flow options and networks and move away from some of the group think and pattern matching that allowed the VC industries to fund companies like Theranos. They can take advantage of new customer segments and consumer needs that can be served through diverse firms. By investing in industries beyond those associated with traditional VC funding, we can build a sufficiently diversified economy. And by continuing to fill the gaps in capital resulting from mega-deals in the VC community, we can expand opportunity across geography, gender, and race. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Rubio. Thank you. Let me start here. Mr. Palmer, you have been the president of the association that represents the SBIC companies for many years now, right? Mr. Palmer. Eleven years, yes. Chairman Rubio. So before this hearing, we tried to get fund managers to come testify. We could not get a single person to come and tell us about their experience. Why will not-- Senator Hawley touched on it pretty extensively. Why are they not here today? Why will they not come? Mr. Palmer. Well, there are some that had legitimate business conflicts, but there is legitimate fear. The Associate Administrator is well known to the industry. His style is one that certainly leaves significant open questions. The fund managers believe they have a fiduciary duty to their investors and they are afraid of retaliation where there are so many steps in the process that are judgment calls that if they go against you, you have got a big problem. And they feel that they cannot, in good faith to their investors, speak publicly lest they put their investors at risk. Chairman Rubio. The bottom line is that there are members of your organization, these investment companies, who feel that if they come testify before the elected representatives of the U.S. Senate about the status of the program and how it is working, that they are going to get hurt, that there will be decisions made on the margins that is going to harm them and ultimately put in danger their obligation to their investors. They are afraid to come---- Mr. Palmer. Yes. Chairman Rubio [continuing]. Because they are afraid they are going to be retaliated against. Mr. Palmer. Yes, and though it is difficult to quantify those judgment decisions, there have been events that have happened in the past that they look at, and on the face of it, say that to me looks like retaliation for not hiring him or speaking out against him previously and we just do not feel that we have--they will do it privately. And it is a challenge because there is--being in the sunshine is important. But they have an obligation and they are legitimately scared. I tried to talk to them. Chairman Rubio. And I raise this without him being here and able to respond because he was asked the question directly earlier. Mr. Palmer. Right. Chairman Rubio. So we have now on the record his response to that question and we have your statement here, so that Senator Hawley's comments do not just stand on their own but we now have a representative of the association. Dr. Pan, there is, as you know, the requirement--the SBA essentially requires that an SBIC applicant have two fund managers. They have to both have previous experience and expertise with the program. I have drafted a proposal that would allow applicants to have a single fund manager with the experience and provide SBA training to applicants whose management team has no previous experience with the program. My question is do you believe this provision could help expand the pool of potential fund managers? And would this kind of proposal help to increase diversity in the venture capital and private equity communities? Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan. Thank you for your question, Mr. Rubio. I do believe these are good first steps to ensure that there is opportunities available for women and minority fund managers, and sometimes experience and exposure could be one way in which they feel left out. So I think a program like this, with additional elements, could be very beneficial to diversifying SBIC fund managers. Mr. Palmer. I can give you a case of that that is exactly true. The past chairwoman of my board, Carolyn Galiette with Ironwood Capital, she will tell you point blank that she would never have gotten licensed today--even though she is on her third or fourth license--if they had the standards now in place for licensure that she had back then. And her fund invests, by design, more than half of her investments are in women, minorities and low-income areas as a top tier firm. Chairman Rubio. Mr. Muro, I wanted to sort of lead into the question with the following statement. There is two orthodoxies that have been in place for some time which frankly, I have dealt with and confronted and, in some cases, at some point potentially even supported in some of the decisions. The two orthodoxies are these: the first is that there is a very limited role for government to play writ large across everything. And I am a person who believes in limited government. But that the bottom line is the private market will determine what is a good idea or not a good idea, particularly in the role of investment. And the second orthodoxy is that we are headed into an era that is good for us, in which we would innovate here but then make things somewhere else. And then we would be on the high end and let someone else make it. We will innovate the software, we will innovate the ideas, and then someone else will build it and that is better for the U.S. consumer. These are the two orthodoxies. The problem with the first one, that first one, is that investment today, it is my view but I think it is supported and the report we put out earlier this highlights this, the financialization of so much of our corporate and business activity in this country has driven investment decisions toward how can I get the highest return for the lowest risk in the shortest amount of time? That is what is being rewarded and that is what is driving investment decisions. So that is the first problem with simply saying the private market will take care of it, is that when you do that, when your focus is on how can I get the highest return in the shortest amount of time with the lowest amount of risk, you are not going to invest in research and development. You are not going to invest in innovation. It may be the greatest idea in history or it may be a total flop. And that is problematic because of the second point. And that is this notion that we are going to invent things here but they are going to be made somewhere else will not last forever. So there is a lot of noise out there about Huawei. What people are missing about Huawei and telecommunications is an important piece but it is just one piece of a much broader strategy in which China, as an example, has used the government support of its national champion companies to establish dominance in a series of critical fields to the 21st century. So how it works is you are one of these companies. You have government-backed credit. You have a guaranteed protection in the domestic marketplace. So here is a billion people that only you can sell to. Plus, we are going to give you money. So what do these companies do? They can now go abroad in rail cars. They can flood the market with batteries or robotics. And no one can compete with them until none of their competitors exist and they have created a dominance in that industry. And so I wanted you to address--the first point, I think, is well established and you can talk about it. But it is the second one that I want people to understand, that what is flowing away from us in the 21st century will eventually be the innovation, as well. But there is a value, an inherent value, in the jobs that are created as a national priority in those industries that we are going to have to have a response to. We are going to have to have a collective national response--that does not have to be partisan, by the way--on China's industrial policy. Because we are not competing with businesses like ours. We are competing with national champions backed by the government of the soon to be largest economy, not per capita but gross largest economy in the world with extraordinary market resources that are going to, in essence, leave us in a world where their companies will dominate all of these fields at the same time as the financialization of our corporate and investment decisions is leading us further and further away from the kinds of things we need to do to compete against them. So I told you it was a long question. Mr. Muro. Yes, I think you are pointing to some of the most critical issue we are facing. We know there are market failures on market irregularities and how resources flow at home. What has happened, I think, is that we are realizing that by allowing, by failing to support some of these sectors, they are flowing offshore on their production end and it is no longer simply a choice between innovation and production. More and more, we are learning that innovation requires specific inputs and detailed iterative knowhow. And even the accumulation of knowledge in specific regions that become warehouses of knowledge. So we have to manage and protect those because you can lose--there are many examples, solar PV cells, electric motors, rare earth elements, LEDs, many others, where we thought we were just off-shoring the production and pretty soon it turned out that we were losing control and leadership in the creativity. And it is because innovation is not a high-flown purely intellectual activity. It is about small, embedded iterative product iterations and process improvements. We have to be able to manufacture so that we can innovate. And I think that logic has gotten somewhat skewed. I think the innovation has gotten associated simply with digital innovation and we have lost track of how things actually are created in plants. Chairman Rubio. And I will turn it over to the Ranking Member, other than to say that even in the digital space that is true. So the platform known as the internet and all of the transactions that take place in it has spawned a bunch of innovation. One of them is mobile payment, right? Today, China has--you could argue that we innovated the platform upon which it is occurring. But the innovation and the application of it, when it comes to mobile payment, they lead the world both in adopting it but also in all of the technologies that are related to it. So at some point in the future, when all of these other companies around the world want to go on a mobile payment system because that is what everyone is doing, they will control--even in the digital space--that industry and the technologies that drive it. The 5G is another example. The Ranking Member. Senator Cardin. Let me thank all of our witnesses. This has been certainly an interesting hearing, a little bit livelier than most of our hearings. But the focus is on the reauthorization of Congress of the SBIC programs. As I said in the beginning, this is our seventh hearing on reauthorization of parts of the SBA. So I just really would like to get your views, I hope we could get some short answers. But the SBIC program, you all believe is an important tool available for small businesses? Mr. Palmer. Yes. Senator Cardin. And it appears, from the way that you have presented your testimony in response to the Chairman's question, that it is not doing everything it should be doing today. Is that a fair enough statement? Mr. Palmer. Not as much as it could be doing. I mean, people are trying. It is just a question of there are barriers to being as successful as it could be. Senator Cardin. Are those barriers statutory or is it the way it is being administered? Mr. Palmer. There are several. There is clearly a mismanagement problem and a hostility in the functioning of the program. I do not say that lightly and I do not say that without evidence. I have got a book in front of me where you can document that. But I think there is also, for the risk aversion of the program, as far as the ability to make sure that it has zero subsidy, also really minimizes risk. And so as you minimize risk, it takes it away from some of the earlier stage side. And I think it is time to really look more aggressively, what can we be doing to make that valley of death smaller, to allow for more equity, more patient capital, more manufacturing, some earlier stage businesses that are not quite as good. There are a number of things we need to be looking at to figure out some new tools to make sure we can do that. Senator Cardin. So was the early stage capital sabotaged to not work? Because it seems to me early stage capital would deal with some of the issues that we have all been talking about, and it was started and stopped. Mr. Palmer. Well, there is several different versions of early stage that they have done. There was an Early Stage program that was done around 2012 or thereabouts that actually worked. They only licensed five funds. The biggest problem they had with it is that you could only get licensed once a year. So you were in, and if they had a question you were out. And so you had to go back and forth a little bit. You have to wait another year. And private sector will not wait a year to raise a fund. So that could be popped up tomorrow with the regulations reactivated and all they have to do is go to a rolling licensure. That would work and that operates at zero taxpayer subsidy. The participating securities program was a program that ran from 1994 to 2004, that was extraordinarily good at creating early stage capital investment, it was $21 billion. But it also lost about $1 billion or $1.5 billion because of the cockamamie payback structure. The SBA has internal models of what they could have done to fix that and that really could have been fixed and reformed with some very modest changes. That could work again, but you would have to make those changes because if you do not protect the taxpayer you have a problem. But that was why that changed. Senator Cardin. And it could have been changed---- Mr. Palmer. It absolutely could have. Senator Cardin [continuing]. By the SBA? Mr. Palmer. That could have been changed--this is going back to the mid-2000s, before my time so I was there post. But I believe some of that could have been done by the administration, which I was in, full disclosure. But some of it would have required some congressional changes, if I recall. Senator Cardin. So it appears like, what I have heard from today's hearing, it is not so much the fundamental law that has been passed by Congress, but the way the law is being implemented? Mr. Palmer. Yes. Senator Cardin. It is not reaching its full potential. It is working but it is not working as well as it could work. Mr. Palmer. Right. And I think one of the things--you heard a lot about risk from the first witness. What you never heard was reward. Reward is a critical element to risk. We have to take risk. We are trying to facilitate risk. We are trying to facilitate the private sector to take risks that they might not otherwise have taken that are not irrational risks but that are properly incentivized without subsidy. And we have to be not paralyzed by risk but actually figure out how to do that. Senator Cardin. No question, small businesses always present a risk. We know that. Mr. Palmer. Right. Senator Cardin. So we recognize if you do not take risks, you are not going to make progress. The Chairman mentioned, I thought, a very good point on minority participation--professor, I want to get you engaged in this--about the fund managers and the experience of the fund managers, and that can be used to as a way to prevent outreach in underserved communities if you set up such high standards that communities do not have representation in the funds themselves, in the investors themselves. Are there other recommendations that you would make so that we can get more participation from women, from minorities in underserved communities? Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan. Absolutely. And I would be happy to work with respective staffs for solutions, given some of my research and some of the findings around best practices. One of the things we have seen work are fellowships or apprenticeships that are funded. Sometimes they are matched, sometimes they are fully funded. But this allows women and minorities who may not have the financial background to enter into the fund manager position, to gain that experience and exposure. There is a venture fellows program at a new venture capital firm that has placed their first fellow into another VC firm. So there are examples across the board of firms doing things right. And lastly, just as a followup, at the VC Inclusion Lab, we are actually following up with each of the 40-plus firms that signed the National Venture Capital Association diversity pledge in 2014, to see what they have done and what changes they have seen. So I would be able to give you more concrete information hopefully in a few months when we have contacted and gotten information from each of those firms. Senator Cardin. As I encouraged from the last witness, please give us your suggestions because you see there is a lot of frustration here and we really do want this program to be at its full--meet its full potential. And it is not doing that today. So one of the areas is what you are talking about on participation from groups that we just do not have the numbers. These numbers are pathetic. They are not even in the ballpark of where they need to be. So we have taken looks at other areas of SBA programs that have not reached, we think, full potential and we have taken steps to correct that. So your recommendations there, I think, can help us in trying to meet those goals. Mr. Palmer. And one thing I would add to that is, you know, it is a particular risk to step out and try to raise a private equity fund. You have no salary, you take a year to two years. And it is a particularly risk for women and minorities to take that risk. It is a bigger leap. And so if you are trying to get more diverse fund managers in the SBIC program--which we certainly want to do, and I actually have some ideas in my testimony that I do think help move the needle there--just look at the new funds. You heard from the first witness that we have so many new funds coming in. Total new pipeline is down 45 percent year over year. It is not new funds coming in. They are being actively scared off. And if you cannot keep the funds that you have because they think they are being mistreated and paralyzed, then how are you supposed to get people to take that entrepreneurial risk to form a new fund that is a woman or a minority? It is really hard. Senator Cardin. It is just hard to understand why we have not done better in creating new funds in minority and women communities. It is a logical step for the SBIC program to have achieved and it does require an attitude of SBA to do this. Mr. Palmer. I have had 10 chairs of the board over my terms. Four have been women. So that is not 50 percent, but that is good. We actually have a lot of women in leadership. Actually, our northeast president next year is going to be a woman from your state. We have a lot--we have tried a lot of women and we are making progress there. It does take time. And I do think, part of the problem to get an SBIC fund is you have to come from private equity. So you are recycling from the same pool. We are far more diverse than the rest of the private equity and venture industry but you are not going to really have a breakout until you can broaden that pool out a little bit. And so actually, I have some proposals in here about how to do that that I think work and could happen very quickly, that we could see the next generation of minority and women fund managers in a way that is constructive and without subsidy. So there is a lot we can do there but the program really is being--has major management problems right now. They do not have staff in senior positions. You are missing more than one senior staffer. You are missing the top career staffer, the Deputy Associate Administrator. You are missing the Director of Licensing and Program Development. They have three what are called area chiefs, that are in charge of managing the teams that manage the funds day-to-day. There are three of those. Two of them are vacant. You have a lot of--and some of these are positions that have been open for over two years. And the Program Development Office, whose job it is to recruit new funds and to help license funds in underserved states and underserved communities, consistent with Senator Rubio's bill, has gone from four FTEs to one. There is only a director left with zero employees, and I do not think he has got a budget since last December. So I am not sure the private sector is seeing the program being managed in the same way that the person running the program is seeing it. We see it from a very different lens that is very concerning. And I think the numbers and data back this up. The private sector is not saying okay, we do not want to do SBICs or small business investment because there is an opportunity. But we are looking at that and going oh my gosh, are you kidding me? Am I going to walk into that buzz saw? Am I going to put my investors and my professional career on that line? And that is a problem. Senator Cardin. Look, I think Senator Kennedy's point about we look at action rather than words, it was disappointing that we did not have an acknowledgment as to numbers being unacceptable. I thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Rubio. Before turning to Senator Duckworth, just one observation on your point. It is hard to attract new people when one of the requirements is that you cannot be new. Mr. Palmer. Mm-hmm. Chairman Rubio. In essence, what we are saying, you have to have two fund managers with previous experience in order to be an applicant, you are basically saying the only people that can apply are the people that have done it before. Well that, by definition, knocks out everybody who is new and wants to come in. Mr. Palmer. That is right. You have to basically have been recruited somewhere else in the private equity industry and then you can spin out to form an SBIC. And that is why one of my proposals is you can form bank-owned non-levered SBIC funds. That is a big mouthful. But banks can do that and they have done that. They exist across the country. And banks have something that SBICs do not have, which is scale. Some SBICs are as few as two people. Banks have really good recruiting programs. They have gotten good at that in the past couple of years. And so if they form bank-owned non- levered--one, they can help fill the equity gap, that is long- term patient capital. Two, they can broaden the footprint. And three, they can seed the next generation of private equity fund managers. That would be helpful. That is not the only solution. This has got to be a multi- step process. But there are a number of things that we can do. Chairman Rubio. That may be a great idea, but it is not going to work unless you find a shorter term, a shorter word to describe it. [Laughter.] Mr. Palmer. Yes, sorry, wonking out. Chairman Rubio. We have got to come up with something fancy. Senator Duckworth. Senator Duckworth. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Actually, Mr. Palmer, I am glad you brought up banks because I think another component of the challenges that we are facing with SBIC, especially for providing long-term loans to growing small businesses is that smaller banks find it very difficult to invest in SBICs. Mr. Palmer. Mm-hmm. Senator Duckworth. And when you talk about women and minority communities, you know, that is the realm of the smaller banks, right? Mr. Palmer. Mm-hmm. Senator Duckworth. They are the ones that tend to be, you know, you have black-owned banks, women-owned banks. Those tend to be smaller. And I think that they are at a disadvantage to larger banks who have greater access to this program. This week Senator Young and I introduced the Investing in Main Street Act that would allow financial institutions to invest a greater portion of their surplus and capital into SBICs. Could you describe how this legislation or this idea might help small businesses better access capital without jeopardizing the safety and soundness of these financial institutions? Mr. Palmer. Sure, absolutely. I think it is a great idea. This is a provision that has already passed the House unanimously. It has broad bipartisan support and I appreciate your taking it up. Basically, there is a timing issue, when banking law was written at a different time than the Small Business Investment Act. And so banks are allowed to invest more in small businesses via SBICs but the SBICs are not allowed to accept the money from the banks to invest in small businesses from the banks. It is an accident of history. And this bill would fix that. And what that would do is get more capital flowing into SBICs. And one of the things that banks do, is banks have this big footprint, to your point. And they have more interactions. And a lot of times a small business will go to a bank and say I need a loan. Well, that is not the type of stuff we do. You need equity. You need unitranche. You need some complicated structure, subordinated debt. You are not cash-flowing enough, whatever it may be. But they can turn around and hand that and say hey look, SBIC, here is a great opportunity. We know this client. They are in an underserved area. That is important to us from a bank, from a CRA perspective. Can you take a look and see if this works. And often they do. There are between 500 and 600 banks that are currently invested in Small Business Investment Companies. They get very good returns. But they also get community reinvestment assessment saying hey, is this serving these underserved communities? Because many times they are. So yes, I think it would be very helpful. I think it does not reduce any bank protections. It would still require the approval of the bank regulators to rise above that. But it would increase small business access to capital and broaden the footprint of small businesses that are exposed to it. Senator Duckworth. Thank you so much. Professor Ozkazanc-Pan, you mentioned in your testimony women and minority-led VC firms have increased over time but a lot of work remains to be done. In 2016, SBA joined several organizations to launch the ONBOARD Initiative, designed to give SBICs more options to hire diverse talent and assume board leadership positions. Unfortunately, it appears that SBA has done little to promote the initiative since its creation, I think missing a real opportunity to help SBICs hire qualified, diverse candidates for their management teams. Can you discuss why initiatives like this are so important to the investment community and what Congress and the SBA can do to improve diversity on VC management firms? Ms. Ozkazanc-Pan. Yes, absolutely. I think these kinds of initiatives are profoundly important because they signal one, interest and opportunity for women and minorities that they may not otherwise see themselves in taking on these roles. But they also communicate information and opportunities both in terms of signaling to people that these are things available to them that is not generally something that they see them for themselves. I would say that if we continue with the program that is not discontinued, that would be a step in the right direction. In terms of VC firms, the reason we are seeing the emergence of women or minority or minority women-only focused firms is because the VC, as a whole, is not moving fast enough. So these are actually smaller firms that are trying to fill in the gaps. And I believe that there could be potentially dedicated funds that might also work in a similar fashion at the SBIC or the SBA level. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Did you want to add something, Mr. Muro? Mr. Muro. My overarching point is simply that all of these are much more the technical questions. They really are about overall American well-being and competitiveness, you know. So to make sure that we are unveiling every great entrepreneurial opportunity, you know we are missing Einsteins and missing entrepreneurs. So it is important that the systems works if we are going to push back against the challenge from China and elsewhere. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Mr. Palmer. And licensing more women fund managers and keeping the fund managers you have that are women. There are a number of women that run funds right now that are pulling their hair out and deciding whether or not they want to do this. And so keeping them in, and getting more women fund managers, I think is very helpful. The Library of Congress studied this and they found basically that like is more likely to invest in like. Women are more likely to invest in other women and women-owned businesses. And the same thing is true for minority. When you have minorities on your private equity team, you tend to invest more in minority-run businesses. And so we just need to add more people into the program. Senator Duckworth. You spoke, Mr. Palmer, about these empty positions. The other thing that I am concerned about is the fact that there is no timeframe on application status updates and approvals or disapprovals as people are moving applications through the approval process. Senator Risch and I, along with several members of this Committee, introduced the Small Business Investment Improvement Act of 2019 that would actually set the timeframes in which SBA must give status updates to SBIC applicants and set deadlines. Can you speak a little bit about the importance of that portion of it, in terms of the need for timeframes and deadlines? Mr. Palmer. Sure. The way the SBICs work, they have to raise private capital. If you cannot pass a private filter, you have no business going and getting a license. So you have to be responsive to those private investors. You have to be able to manage their expectations. I think I can get a license in X period of time. And this is a multi-step process with lots of stages. And every step of every licensing process, since the new management of the Office of Investment has taken over, has become gummed up and unpredictable. It is regulatory roulette. And so we just do not know whether it is going to take--it used to take two weeks. Now it takes 13 months, in some cases, to get a green light letter for a repeat fund with a clean examinations. That is nuts. Meanwhile, your investors, who are waiting on this money, the pensions, the universities, the endowments who want to deploy this capital to small business, they need to get a return. They cannot be sitting on millions of dollars doing nothing while you wait around for the SBA to get to license you. Managing expectations is critical. So having a process where it is clear, it is consistent, it is fair--if it is no, give me a quick no. But be fair about it. And dragging these things out where it is step after step after step, it makes no sense. You heard the first witness talk about examinations, he has done such a good job. SBIC funds have zero control over the examinations. The SBA does those. The SBA controls the time. They control the results. It takes months to get them scheduled. It takes a month for them to do it. And it might take 6 months or longer to get the results back. And during that time period, you cannot advance the licensing period. You cannot reserve leverage. You cannot do a lot of your basic stuff you need to do unless your window happens to come up at the same time their exam clock is going, of which you have no control. So bragging about having a tightened credit standard for examinations, where now 69 percent of the SBIC funds meet my credit standard, they are compliant. Well, that means that the SBA is failing 30-plus percent of the SBICs being able to operate fully. And that does not work for licensing, it does not work for any of it. And so having timelines and holding the accountable, I think, is critical because this is the type of mundane stuff, administrative stuff, that is paralyzing and is completely unnecessary. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Mr. Palmer. It is baffling. So it would be very helpful and we welcome it. Thank you. Senator Duckworth. And it is a bipartisan bill. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Rubio. Thank you. I want to thank you all for being here. We were delayed with the votes and so forth, but just to kind of sum it up, if you look at the need for innovation, innovation, by definition, is risky because it has never been done before. That is why it is innovative. And to do that takes money, right. And so people with money or entities with money are doing less of it than ever before. The banks do not want to lend. They are kind of frozen in some way. They are just not in the business of doing that anymore. And private equity has moved further and further away from that. They want to do less risky. They want a higher yield at a shorter or mid-term period of time and there is no taste for that. So that is why programs like this exist in the small business space. In the big space, you are a multi-billionaire, you want to invest in a rocket company, you can do that and they have done it. But if you are a small business person with a great idea, you need access to capital. The banks will not give it to you. The venture capital community does not like ideas like that. It is too risky. And so that is where this program comes into play. So it is concerning when we see the numbers flatline and begin to decline at a time of great need. And I do not think we have run out of ideas in this country, or people with them. And it is most concerning when you start to hear that we are going to be applying new criteria to the program and the buzz words I am hearing are by the way, it is the same criteria of the funds and the banks that are not lending money now. So in essence, we are going to turn the SBIC program into a similar criteria to the ones that created the need for it in the first place. And all of it happening, by the way, at a time which our Nation desperately needs innovation. We need to come up with a response to Chinese industrial policy that threatens to displace us in industry after industry after industry around the world. Very aggressive and we have not had an answer for it. And clearly, the current market conditions are not meeting that demand. So other than that, I think it is going well. [Laughter.] Chairman Rubio. No, it was a very insightful hearing and that is why I am so glad we are doing reauthorization because we are not just having people come in and talk to us. We are going through the lines and the details at a granular level of the entire agency and the programs that it has and trying to align them to national priorities in a way that I hope can actually avoid some of the partisan fights that are going on. This is stuff that should be unifying and I think can and has a chance to be. So we are grateful to all of you for your patience and the time you have given us today. The hearing record for this hearing is going to remain open for two weeks. If there is any statements or questions for the record, they should be submitted by Wednesday, July 10th, at 5 p.m. And with that, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 5:04 p.m., the Committee was adjourned.] APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]