Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] FROM TOOL TO WEAPON: THE FACE ACT AND THE DANGERS OF FEDERALIZING CRIMINAL LAW ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CONSTITUTION AND LIMITED GOVERNMENT OF THE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ TUESDAY, APRIL 28, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-65 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via: http://judiciary.house.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 63-601 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY JIM JORDAN, Ohio, Chair DARRELL ISSA, California JAMIE RASKIN, Maryland, Ranking ANDY BIGGS, Arizona Member TOM McCLINTOCK, California JERROLD NADLER, New York THOMAS P. TIFFANY, Wisconsin ZOE LOFGREN, California THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky STEVE COHEN, Tennessee CHIP ROY, Texas HENRY C. ``HANK'' JOHNSON, Jr., SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin Georgia BEN CLINE, Virginia TED LIEU, California LANCE GOODEN, Texas PRAMILA JAYAPAL, Washington JEFFERSON VAN DREW, New Jersey J. LUIS CORREA, California TROY E. NEHLS, Texas MARY GAY SCANLON, Pennsylvania BARRY MOORE, Alabama JOE NEGUSE, Colorado HARRIET M. HAGEMAN, Wyoming LUCY McBATH, Georgia LAUREL M. LEE, Florida DEBORAH K. ROSS, North Carolina WESLEY HUNT, Texas BECCA BALINT, Vermont RUSSELL FRY, South Carolina JESUS G. ``CHUY'' GARCIA, Illinois KEVIN KILEY, California SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JARED MOSKOWITZ, Florida BRAD KNOTT, North Carolina DANIEL S. GOLDMAN, New York MARK HARRIS, North Carolina JASMINE CROCKETT, Texas ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri Vacancy DEREK SCHMIDT, Kansas BRANDON GILL, Texas MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CONSTITUTION AND LIMITED GOVERNMENT CHIP ROY, Texas, Chair TOM McCLINTOCK, California MARY GAY SCANLON, Pennsylvania, THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky Ranking Member HARRIET HAGEMAN, Wyoming STEVE COHEN, Tennessee WESLEY HUNT, Texas PRAMILA JAYAPAL, Washington GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JOE NEGUSE, Colorado MARK HARRIS, North Carolina BECCA BALINT, Vermont ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California BRANDON GILL, Texas DANIEL S. GOLDMAN, New York CHRISTOPHER HIXON, Majority Staff Director ARTHUR EWENCZYK, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- TUESDAY, APRIL 28, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Page The Honorable Chip Roy, Chair of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Texas.... 1 The Honorable Mary Gay Scanlon, Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Pennsylvania...................................... 4 The Honorable Jim Jordan, Chair of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of Ohio......................................... 6 The Honorable Jamie Raskin, Ranking Member of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of Maryland....................... 7 WITNESSES Eva Edl, Yugoslavian communist concentration camp survivor, Pro- life Advocate Oral Testimony................................................. 10 Prepared Testimony............................................. 12 Christopher A. Ferrara, Senior Counsel,Thomas More Society Oral Testimony................................................. 14 Prepared Testimony............................................. 16 Roger T. Severino, Vice President, Economic and Domestic Policy, Joseph C. and Elizabeth A. Anderlik Fellow, The Heritage Foundation Oral Testimony................................................. 27 Prepared Testimony............................................. 29 Jessica L. Waters, Senior Scholar in Residence, Justice, Law & Criminology, American University Oral Testimony................................................. 71 Prepared Testimony............................................. 73 LETTERS, STATEMENTS, ETC. SUBMITTED FOR THE HEARING All materials submitted by the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government, for the record......................... 107 A statement from Sterling Heights clinic, submitted by the Honorable the Honorable Jamie Raskin, Ranking Member of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of Maryland, for the record Materials submitted by the Honorable Mary Gay Scanlon, Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Pennsylvania, for the record An article entitled, ``DOJ's First `Weaponization' Report Is a Bust,'' Apr. 20, 2026, The Atlantic A press release entitled, ``Ohio Woman Pleads Guilty to Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act Violation for Damaging Pregnancy Center,'' Dec. 8, 2023, Office of Public Affairs, U.S. Department of Justice A press release entitled, ``Wisconsin Man Sentenced to Prison for 2022 Firebombing of Madison Building,'' Apr. 10, 2024, Office of Public Affairs, U.S. Department of Justice A press release entitled, ``Florida Woman Convicted of Civil Rights Conspiracy Targeting Pregnancy Resource Centers,'' Dec. 20, 2024, Office of Public Affairs, U.S. Department of Justice A press release entitled, ``FBI Offering $25,000 Rewards for Information in Series of Attacks Against Reproductive Health Service Facilities,'' Jan. 19, 2023, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) An article entitled, ``Separating Fact from Fiction in FACE Act Enforcement,'' Apr. 14, 2026, Just Security A press release entitled, ``Seven Defendants Convicted of Federal Civil Rights Conspiracy and Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act Offenses for Obstructing Access to Reproductive Health Services in Michigan,'' Aug. 20, 2024, Office of Public Affairs, U.S. Department of Justice A statement from Reproductive Freedom For All, Apr. 28, 2026 A statement from The American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists, Apr. 28, 2026 A statement from the National Abortion Federation (NAF), Apr. 28, 2026 A statement the Center for Reproductive Rights, Apr. 28, 2026 A statement from David Gunn, Jr. and Wendy Gunn, Apr. 28, 2026 Pages from the 2025 Presidential Transition Project, pp. 557- 558, Apr. 28, 2026 A statement from Judith C. Appelbaum, Apr. 28, 2026 An article entitled, ``I testified before Congress on the FACE Act--and became a target,'' May 8, 2026, MS Now An article entitled, ``Arrests in Memphis as Antiabortion Training Camp Sparks New Era of Clinic Blockades,'' Nov. 26, 2025, Ms. Magazine, submitted by the Honorable Steve Cohen, Member of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Tennessee, for the record Materials submitted by the Honorable Chip Roy, Chair of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Texas, for the record A report entitled,``Fact Sheet: Planned Parenthood's 2024-25 Annual Report,'' Apr. 7, 2026, Lozier Institute The Executive Summary report entitled, ``The Biden Administration's Weaponization of the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act,'' Apr. 14, 2026, Office of Legal Policy, U.S. Department of Justice Materials submitted by the Honorable Sydney Kamlager-Dove, a Member of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of California, for the record A statement for the record from Renee Chelian, Founder, CEO, Northland Family Planning, Apr. 28, 2026 An article entitled, ``Trump pardons abortion clinic protesters ahead of March for Life,'' Jan. 23, 2025, Politico An article entitled, ``Fertility clinic bombing suspect was `nihilistic' 25-year-old, FBI says,'' May 18, 2025, The Washington Post A press release entitled, ``More Men Using Family Planning Services,'' Jun. 16, 2016, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services A letter to the Honorable Chip Roy, Chair of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Texas, and the Honorable Mary Gay Scanlon, Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government from the State of Pennsylvania, from Amnesty International, Apr. 28, 2026 FROM TOOL TO WEAPON: THE FACE ACT AND THE DANGERS OF FEDERALIZING CRIMINAL LAW ---------- Tuesday, April 28, 2026 House of Representatives Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government Committee on the Judiciary Washington, DC The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10 a.m., in Room 2141, Rayburn House Office Building, the Hon. Chip Roy [Chair of the Subcommittee] presiding. Members present: Representatives Roy, Jordan, Hageman, Grothman, Harris, Onder, Gill, Scanlon, Raskin, Cohen, Jayapal, Balint, and Kamlager-Dove. Mr. Roy. [Presiding.] The Committee will come to order. Without objection, the Chair is authorized to declare a recess at any time. We welcome everybody to today's hearing on the FACE Act and the dangers of Federalizing criminal law. Before I start, I just want to say thanks for everybody's patience. I think there were some security line issues. Thanks to the witnesses for navigating through those, and thanks to my colleagues on the other side of the aisle. I apologize for starting a little bit late, but we were trying to deal with that issue. I will now recognize myself for an opening statement. Today, this Subcommittee confronts a fundamental question about the proper role of the Federal Government in our constitutional system, because the issue before us is not just one statute; it is about a broader and more dangerous trend-- the steady expansion of Federal criminal law into areas the Constitution traditionally reserves to the States. When Washington creates these authorities and hands them to unelected bureaucrats, these tools will inevitably be weaponized. The FACE Act is a case study into exactly that problem. It was sold as a narrow, even-handed tool designed to equally protect access to abortion clinics, pregnancy resource centers, and places of worship by prohibiting threats of force, obstruction, and property damage. Like so many Federal laws before it, it has become a vehicle for selective enforcement, a mechanism for political targeting, and ultimately, a weapon used against conservatives and prolife Americans. We don't need to speculate. We now have clear evidence from the Department of Justice's own report that this law was weaponized by the Biden Administration. That report shows how, under the Biden Administration, enforcement of the FACE Act was shaped, if not driven, by outside advocacy groups. The Biden Department of Justice worked in close coordination with extremist NGOs, particularly large, well- funded pro-abortion groups, like the National Abortion Federation, Planned Parenthood, and the Feminist Majority Foundation. These groups weren't merely reporting crimes. They were operating as de facto intelligence-gathering arms, collecting and compiling detailed dossiers on the speech and activities of American citizens for Federal authorities mapping their movements, logging protests, and gathering deeply personal information, including participation in religious activity, home addresses, license data, even photos of their families and minor children all of it fed into the prosecution pipeline, even as DOJ officials themselves recognized much of the underlying activity was protected under the First Amendment. The DOJ didn't just receive this information. It gave these groups privileged access. On May 15, 2023, the National Abortion Federation requested a full internal list of every active FACE Act prosecution in the country. They got it in full within one hour. When this Subcommittee and I personally, as a Member of Congress, asked for the exact same information, the DOJ didn't just delay. They stonewalled for over three years from 2022- 2024. In October 2022, a formal request was ignored. December 2023, asked again under oath: No answer. February 2024, followup in writing: Nothing. May 2024, response finally comes 16 months later. It wasn't just Congress; defense counsel and active FACE prosecutors were denied the data outright. In one case, a DOJ official explicitly wrote that providing the information would, quote, ``open gates we will struggle to close,'' implicitly acknowledging that the records would reveal unequal enforcement targeting only prolifers. They refused and claiming the records didn't exist, even though the same information had been handed to the National Abortion Federation on demand. Why does an outside abortion advocacy group get immediate access to internal Department of Justice enforcement data, while Congress, prolife defendants, and the American people are forced to wait years or are denied altogether? That is not equal justice under the law. That is a two-tiered system where political allies are treated as partners and dissenters as targets. It didn't stop there. The bias we are seeing didn't just shape who was investigated. It shaped how these cases were prosecuted in court. In FACE Act trials, we have evidence that DOJ attorneys probed prospective jurors on their religious beliefs and prolife views, treating constitutionally protected convictions as potential disqualifications for service. In one instance, a DOJ prosecutor even complained when a judge took care to protect the defendant's First Amendment's rights. This is what happens when Washington takes power it was never meant to have, using it to target, instead of to serve, while treating constitutional protections as obstacles rather than guarantees. We don't have to imagine what that looks like. We see it sitting here before us today. Ms. Eva Edl is not a violent criminal. She is a 91-year-old survivor of a communist labor camp, someone who has lived through the horrors of unchecked government power. Yet, in Biden's America, she was not met with freedom, but with the full force of Federal prosecution for a nonviolent protest. Having survived the abuses of a 20th century regime built on centralized power, she now faces the consequences of that same dangerous principle right here on American soil decades later. Her case is not an outlier. It is a warning about what happens when the Federal Government takes jurisdiction over local conduct, and then, applies that power selectively guided not by equal justice, but by political priorities. This should concern every American, regardless of their views on the underlying issue. Because the real problem isn't just how this law has been used. It is the permanent expansion of Federal power it represents. When Congress Federalizes criminal law, we are not just addressing a single issue in a single moment. We are creating authorities that do not disappear when political control changes hands, authorities that will be used again and again by whoever sits in the White House, controls the DOJ, or directs Federal law enforcement. That is why this hearing isn't just about the FACE Act. It is about what happens when Washington takes power it was never meant to have. We are seeing the same impulse in proposals to Federalize other areas of criminal law. New Federal penalties layered on top of existing State crimes and efforts to nationalize deeply contested social issues through criminal statutes. Because the real question isn't whether this power delivers you the outcome you want today. It is whether you are willing to hand that same power to your political opponents tomorrow. The answer should be obvious. It isn't to fight over who controls these powers. The answer is to stop creating them in the first place. Criminal law enforcement, particularly for conduct that is local in nature, has historically and constitutionally belonged to the States. That division of authority was not accidental. It was designed as a safeguard against centralized power. When we ignore that structure, we don't just make a policy mistake; we create a system ripe for abuse, a playground for bureaucrats, a lever for political agendas, and a direct threat to the liberties we are sworn to protect. That is why I have called for the repeal of the FACE Act, not only because of who it has been used against, but because of what is represented, an expansion of Federal power and a breakdown of constitutional limited. The Federal Government should not be in the business of policing local conduct through expansive criminal statutes. If we are serious about protecting liberty, then we must be serious about limiting power. Because once Washington takes it, it doesn't give it back. One final point, a point of personal privilege, is I have tried to be consistent on this point to the extent of opposing or raising questions about legislation that is supported by people that are, shall I say, politically aligned typically, or issues that I care passionately about issues such as transgender surgeries or issues involving law enforcement who are being targeted locally or cops who are killed, that are not getting justice in one jurisdiction or another. I believe that we need to have this debate and this conversation about how much authority should be vested in the Federal Government in the form of criminal laws. Because I assure you that my colleagues who have concerns about this administration and those of us who had concerns about the last, the point that the Founders were making was that we should leave those authorities and those powers to the people and to the governments in the States closest to them, and not centralize that power in such a way that it can, in fact, be used against the people. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses. I now yield to the Ranking Member for her opening statement. Ms. Scanlon. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, today is the third time in as many years that this Subcommittee, under Republican leadership, is holding a hearing to undermine the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, or the FACE Act, fourth, if you count the markup of the Chair's FACE Act Repeal Act last year. Eliminating the FACE Act is a Right-wing policy priority drawn directly from the extremist Project 2025 manifesto, page 558, to be precise. No matter how many times the enemies of reproductive rights try to rewrite history or drum up new conspiracies about the FACE Act, the facts stay the same. We continue to see criminal obstruction of and threats, intimidation, and violence against abortion providers and women seeking those services. The FACE Act is needed now as much as it has ever been. In 1994, Congress passed the FACE Act with bipartisan support to address rising violence against abortion and reproductive healthcare providers. Over the years, that violence has included arsons, bombings, chemical attacks, blockades, murders, and attempted murders of abortion providers and bystanders. Specifically, the FACE Act protects the people who work in or seek care at facilities providing access to abortion and other reproductive healthcare services, as well as places of religious worship. It protects them from the use of force, threats, intimidation, or physical obstruction. For decades, the same coordinated extreme anti-choice forces whose violent conduct created the need for the FACE Act in the first place have tried to undermine the law as part of their unpopular mission to gut access to reproductive healthcare and, effectively, ban abortion in the United States. Since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, anti-abortion extremists have been emboldened, fueling a resurgence of violence and harassment against abortion providers. A report from the National Abortion Federation documented 777 instances of obstruction of clinics in 2024. In the last two years, there have been 296 incidents of death threats and other threats of violence aimed at abortion providers and their patients. For years, our Republican colleagues have tried to warp reality, and today's hearing is more of the same. They are claiming that people were arrested under the FACE Act for praying. That's just not true. Praying is not unlawful conduct, but you can't mask unlawful conduct, including violent threats or blockading entrances to clinics, with performative prayer. Those threats and physical harassment are crimes, and they jeopardize people's access to potentially lifesaving care. Take, for example, one woman's story from Michigan. After struggling with infertility, she finally got pregnant, but at 12 weeks she and her husband got devastating news. Their baby had an extremely rare abnormality and he wouldn't survive birth. If she continued the pregnancy, her ability to have children in the future would be at risk and her life would be at risk as well. She and her husband made the decision to terminate the pregnancy. On the morning of her appointment at a local reproductive healthcare clinic, she arrived to find people blocking the entrance. A group approached them, trying to force her to take graphic pamphlets and telling her she could stop a murder from happening. The harassment continued even after the couple moved their car. She and her husband had to leave out of fear for their safety, even though she needed immediate medical attention. They were only able to return after police arrived, arrested the disruptors, and removed them. In another instance, five anti-abortion extremists forced their way into a clinic in Virginia and attempted to grab a patient. The patient's friend had to step in and help the clinic staff usher the invaders out. We are talking about women and their loved ones facing terror, threats of injury, and having to physical fight people off, just to receive legal healthcare for serious medical needs. It shouldn't be that way. That is why we have the FACE Act. Republicans have seized on a false narrative that the Biden Justice Department selectively enforced the law. That's not true. This month, as Chair Roy has related, Trump's Department of Justice issued a report claiming that the former administration used the FACE Act to go after allegedly peaceful prolife protestors. I should note that this report has been variously described across multiple outlets as cherry-picked, shoddy, misleading, hypocritical, inaccurate, incomplete, and a distortion of the truth that disregards multiple court rulings and jury verdicts. It parrots longstanding anti-abortion conspiracies, particularly those championed in the extremist Project 2025 manifesto. There is no credible evidence that prior administrations selectively enforced the FACE Act against anti-abortion protestors. To the extent that there is any disparity in FACE Act prosecutions of attacks on abortion clinics versus prolife facilities, it is simply a reflection of the facts. Abortion providers and their patients face significantly higher threats and levels of violence than other entities covered by the statute. The actions of the Trump Administration and its Right-wing allies, including our Republican colleagues, to undermine the FACE Act have invited anti-abortion extremists to carry out even more dangerous and hostile acts against women seeking healthcare and their medical providers. The President's firing of lawyers who prosecuted FACE Act violations, along with pardons for people who were convicted by juries of harassing and attacking abortion providers and their patients, only further emboldens people to commit these crimes. In fact, we have already seen pardoned anti-abortion activists go back to commit similar acts. Last July, six people, two of whom received Trump pardons for FACE Act violations, were arrested after invading a clinic in my District in Delaware County, Pennsylvania. They have gone on to be arrested again after their plea bargains were affirmed. They lied to get into the Delaware County facility, and then harassed patients and staff until the police removed them. If my Republican colleagues want to examine the real dangers of an out-of-control executive using the government to attack its political enemies, they should be holding hearings to examine what the Trump Administration is doing right now. How about deploying American troops and armed and masked Federal agents to our city streets to shutdown opposition and threatening assaulting and even killing people who would hold them accountable? How about using warrantless searches to arrest American citizens in their own homes? Or labeling people who disagree with the President's policies as domestic terrorists under NSPM-7? Putting their names on secret government lists and demanding that tech companies' hand over the identities of Americans who organize or share their dissenting opinions online? If we are talking about Federal intrusion into areas reserved to the States, how about this administration's attempts to Federalize our elections and seize State voter rolls? Why aren't we holding hearings about that? In politicizing a law meant to keep all Americans safe, anti-abortion extremists are openly attempting to lay the groundwork for a national abortion ban. Their goal is to scare, threaten, and physically obstruct women from accessing reproductive healthcare. The Majority of Americans agree, all women deserve the freedom to work with their doctors and their families to decide on the healthcare that is right for them without the meddling of radical politicians or religious extremists. No one should be denied medical care because of someone else's religious or political beliefs. I yield back. Mr. Roy. I now recognize the Chair of the Full Committee, Mr. Jordan, for his opening statement. Chair Jordan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I can't think of a better time to have this hearing. Last week, we learned that the Southern Poverty Law Center was running a scam. The Southern Poverty Law Center who said, quote, ``The prolife movement is fundamentally antidemocratic,' '' was running a scam, paying $3 million to, quote, ``informants'' to go foment the hate they told the world they were actually supposed to be fighting. This is exactly the right time to have this hearing, for goodness' sake. The Southern Poverty Law Center that the Biden Justice Department used to train lawyers to go deal with the FACE Act? You've got to be kidding me. The Southern Poverty Law Center, which was cited in the now famous memorandum--we have the Thomas More Society here; they remember this--where they said prolife Catholics were extremists, guess who they cited in that memo? The Southern Poverty Law Center. I remember when Rahm Emanuel said, ``Never let crisis go to waste.'' Well, the SPLC took it further. They said: We're going to create the crisis, so we can go after prolife groups using the FACE Act, and whatever else. The Ranking Member can talk about, oh, we have had three hearings on this. Well, this one couldn't be better timed. This is exactly what we need to be talking about, in light of the fact they have been indicted for running a $3 million scam against the people who were supporting them, and going out and going after prolife people, like Eva Edl, the 90-year-old. The Chair talked about her history and what she is doing, praying at a clinic. I'm glad you are all here and I look forward to hearing your testimony. I thank the Chair for putting this hearing together. With that, I yield back. Mr. Roy. I thank the Chair. I will now recognize the Ranking Member of the Full Committee, Mr. Raskin, for his opening statement. Mr. Raskin. Mr. Chair, thank you very much. I want to thank all our witnesses for joining us today. We are in a weird time warp groove with our friends across the aisle. Most of their energy is now focused on pardoning people who attacked the Capitol on January 6th, wounding and injuring 150 of our police officers, disfiguring and disabling some of them for life. Their time is spent vacating the criminal convictions of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers, who engaged in seditious conspiracy against the U.S. Government, which means conspiring to overthrow and put down the government. Now, the Department of Justice wants to vacate those convictions that were handed down by unanimous juries. They want to give millions of dollars to convicted criminals like Michael Flynn, for example, President Trump's disgraced former National Security Advisor. They gave him $1.5 million for a lawsuit he brought against the government and already lost. He lost it in court, and nonetheless, they wrote him a check for $1.5 million. They wrote a check for another $1.5 million, or $1.25 million, to Carter Page, who unsuccessfully sued the government for damages and losing four different lawsuits. Nonetheless, they just wrote him a check of the taxpayers' money, $1.25 million. Now, they are all lining up at the trough. A lot of the January 6th insurrectionists wanted their $1.25 million payout. Donald Trump has sued the IRS for 10, no, forgive me, not $10 million--$10 billion. He wants 80 percent of the IRS budget that he is suing the government for. He is also suing for the search warrants handed down by an independent, neutral magistrate, where they executed a search on Mar-a-Lago and found lots of classified documents and confidential and secret documents he shouldn't have had. He is suing there for several hundred million dollars as well. It is a big piggy bank for them. Now, we are having our third hearing about the claim, I'm not sure I fully understand it, but I think the claim is that the activists who forcibly blocked health clinic entrances and prevented women from accessing lawful reproductive health services were somehow unjustly prosecuted under the FACE Act, which they intimate is unconstitutional, but eight different Federal Circuit Courts have upheld its constitutionality as a perfectly lawful exercise of Congress' powers under the Commerce Clause and not in any way in violation of the First Amendment. OK? They continue to want to pander to people who think that they should never have been prosecuted for their criminal conduct. This hearing is an after-the-fact justification for President Trump's antichoice pander pardons which took place last year. As one of his first acts in office, he pardoned nearly two dozen people convicted, again, by unanimous juries, of FACE Act-related crimes, including one of the witnesses here today, Ms. Edl. As with the January 6th rioters and insurrectionists that he pardoned, Trump and his MAGA allies are attempting to rewrite history to portray convicted criminal conduct as peaceful protests and to cast the dedicated public servants who sought to protect patient safety as the villains. Let's discuss some of the facts of Ms. Edl's case. She was pardoned by President Trump and invited as an example of the so-called ``peaceful protestors.'' A jury convicted her, along with six coconspirators of Federal civil rights offenses, including a FACE Act violation arising out of their blockade of a reproductive healthcare clinic in Sterling Heights, Michigan, in August 2020. A jury of her peers, not deep-State prosecutors, a jury of her peers drawn from her community convicted her by unanimous vote after a trial by an impartial Federal judge. She was one of two defendants convicted of another FACE Act violation arising out of their actions in yet another clinic blockade in Saginaw, Michigan. Now, I have no problems with the fact that Ms. Edl and others like her have strong moral convictions about this, as did Martin Luther King and John Lewis. They had strong moral convictions about Jim Crow apartheid and segregation in America, and they participated in civil disobedience. They violated various trespass laws in different cases, and they were arrested for it, and they were willing to accept their punishment as the price for trying to get a law they considered or actions by the government reversed and to dismantle racial segregation. What these protestors have a problem with is other people accessing their own healthcare. The civil rights protestors weren't trying to stop people from getting healthcare, and they were willing to, nonetheless, accept the consequences of having a sit-in, or whatever. Here, they don't seem to want to accept the fact that they violated the law. In fact, they violated the law precisely to prevent other people from exercising their constitutionally protected rights to healthcare. That is exactly what they were doing. I'm afraid there is a huge difference between them and other people who have participated in civil disobedience in the past. We got a statement from the founder and operator of the Sterling Heights clinic, who was present that day, which I'm going to enter into the record in full, that described what happened. Mr. Raskin. She writes this: Perhaps the most dangerous and appalling episode of clinic violence I've ever experienced since the FACE Act became law took place in August 2020. Our Sterling Heights clinic was blockaded by extremists who prevented me and other staff from entering the clinic. Patients were stuck in their cars, including three women who were coming in for medical abortions following the detection of fatal fetal anomalies. One woman was actively losing amniotic fluid and was scheduled for the second day of a two-day procedure. She needed immediate medical attention. She huddled with her mother and her husband trapped in the parking lot while extremists plastered signs of fake fetuses on her car windows and shouted, ``God loves you. God loves your baby.'' The woman cried back, ``I know God loves me. I know God loves my baby, but my baby is dying.'' Her baby was missing most of its brain and had no kidneys. This woman later shared her powerful testimony at trial. As eight different Circuit Courts have found, Congress has the power under the Commerce Clause to protect people against being harassed and interfered with as they go to get medical attention. The FACE Act is a legitimate exercise of Congressional power, and they people were properly arrested and prosecuted for perhaps their very morally, sincerely held views, but they violated the law. These politically motivated pardons of FACE Act violators, as well as January 6ers and dozens of white-collar criminals and fraudsters, are all part of a political strategy that has got nothing to do with justice. Now, this is the equivalent of the government giving people a green light to go out and break the law. Indeed, there are numerous reports that President Trump has been pardoning promises, has been promising pardons rather, to everyone who works for him. As President Trump continues to endanger public safety with pardons like this, they are making threats against the Southern Poverty Law Center, which is the main not-for-profit organizational antagonist to the Ku Klux Klan and the neo-Nazi and the White extremist groups. They are being investigated and prosecuted for having sent people undercover to research what is going on in those groups, to get the information to government for prosecution. Now, the administration, which has pardoned 1,600 extremists who attacked the U.S. Capitol, who violently assaulted our police officers, and tried to overthrow a Presidential election, which Joe Biden won by more than seven million votes, 306-232 in the Electoral College, well, now, after having pardoned all of those people, they want to attack the Southern Poverty Law Center. That is an amazing attack on the First Amendment for real. I yield back to you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Roy. Without objection, all other opening statements will be included in the record. Mr. Roy. We will now introduce today's witnesses. Ms. Eva Edl. Ms. Edl is a prolife advocate who came to the United States after surviving a communist concentration camp after the end of World War II. In 2023, she was prosecuted by the Biden Administration under the FACE Act for protesting at an abortion clinic. She was pardoned by President Trump in January 2025. Mr. Christopher Ferrara. Mr. Ferrara is a Senior Counsel at the Thomas More Society, a public interest law firm. Mr. Ferrara's practice focuses on cases involving the sanctity of life, religious liberty, and parental rights. He founded the American Catholic Lawyers Association in 1990. Mr. Roger Severino. Mr. Severino is the Vice President of Economic and Domestic Policy and the Joseph C. and Elizabeth A. Anderlik Fellow at the Heritage Foundation. He previously served as the Director of the Office of Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services. Professor Jessica Waters. Ms. Waters is a Senior Scholar in residence for Justice, Law, and Criminology at the American University Washington College of Law. She previously served as the American University Dean of Undergraduate Education and Vice Provost for Academic Student Services. We thank our witnesses for appearing today. We will begin by swearing you in. Would you please rise and raise your right hand? Do you swear or affirm under penalty of perjury that the testimony you are about to give is true and correct to the best of your knowledge, information, and belief, so help you God? Let the record reflect that the witnesses have answered in the affirmative. Thank you, and you may be seated. Please know that your written testimony will be entered in the record in its entirety. Accordingly, we ask that you summarize your testimony in five minutes. Ms. Edl, you may begin. I will just remind you to have your microphone turned on, I believe it is, and to speak clearly into the microphone. STATEMENT OF EVA EDL Ms. Edl. I'll try. Mr. Roy. You might want to pull that microphone a little closer, if that's possible. There we go. Thank you, Ms. Edl. You may begin. Ms. Edl. Chair Roy, Ranking Member Scanlon, and the Members of the Subcommittee, my name, as I have said, is Eva Edl. Thank you for inviting me to speak to you today. As I say in my biography, as a young child, I was taken to a communist death camp and survived only by the grace of God. When I came to this country, I was so grateful to see that the respect-that this country respected life. To my horror, even this country lost its moral compass when abortion was legalized in 1973. I knew from basic biology that human life begins when an ovum and sperm unite. I knew I could not remain silent, and I knew I had to speak in defense of the preborn babies. In 1988, I became aware of the existence of abortion clinics, which I view as our American death camps. On TV, I watched women take their babies inside to be killed, and it reminded me of my ride in the cattle car that took me as a young girl to the death camp. While being locked up in that car, I wished that some people would have put their bodies on those tracks to bring that train to a stop and set us free. I thought of the word of the Lord Jesus in Matthew 7, ``that I should do unto others as I would have them do unto me.'' I knew I had to place my body between those victims and the abortionists, no matter what the cost. For the prolife movement, this is what we call ``rescue.'' We call it an interposing, putting ourselves in danger to save someone else. In 1988, I also learned of a rescue plan for October in Atlanta. I decided to join them. People were peacefully sitting in front of the door of the abortion clinic and not moving; consequently, shutting the business down at least until everyone was arrested. When we are at clinics like that, it's like sitting in front of the train tracks. While we are being arrested, our sidewalk counselors have the opportunity to offer help to young women, and hopefully, persuade them to give their life to their children. Then, in 1994, when I heard that Senator Ted Kennedy introduced the FACE Act, I knew that things would change. I knew that we rescuers would be targeted. Prolifers who continue to put their bodies between the abortionists and innocent victims today will continue to be targeted by this unjust law until it is repealed. Yet, despite knowing this, when the Lord asks you to do something, you just simply do it, no matter the cost. After all, he gave his life to save us. There are many others who have answered this sacrificial call. In my case, I was only charged with a first offense misdemeanor in Tennessee, but in Michigan, I was convicted of two separate violations of FACE and one violation of conspiracy against rights and faced up to 13 years in prison and up to $300,000 in fines. I am before you today. I plead with our government to repeal the FACE Act because it is targeting people who want to do right. After all, we have enough laws that, if somebody does something wrong, we have the means to punish them. I plead with our government to stop the killing and go back to the foundational principle that our forefathers built this country on: That all human life has equal value before God. If we do not have an awakening of our national conscious, then we will exterminate our posterity. Indeed, our next victims will be the elderly and the sick through the so-called ``assisted death.'' We are aborting those who would be our country's future, who will take care of us when we are old. When we do not respect human life, it becomes very disposable. Yet, where there is life, there is hope. It is this hope that has carried me over 90 years through World War II, a genocide, and Tito's horrific camps, all the way to today. While I may not see the end of abortion in my own lifetime, I have the unshakeable hope that the truth will prevail and that our Nation will soon recognize the value of all human life. Let us act by beginning to repeal the FACE Act. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Edl follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Roy. Thank you, Ms. Edl. Mr. Ferrara, you may begin. STATEMENT OF CHRISTOPHER A. FERRARA Mr. Ferrara. I thank the Committee for this opportunity to argue in favor of repeal of the FACE Act. The FACE Act was supposedly a viewpoint-neutral protection of abortion clinic access. It contained a disclaimer that it would not prohibit First Amendment protected conduct or create new remedies for interference with that conduct. We members of the prolife bar were not fooled. The FACE Act targeted a particular social justice movement, the prolife activist movement. It created a new category of Federal offenses, civil and criminal, based on what were purely matters of local law involving citizens and other minor offenses committed in the context of nonviolent civil disobedience no different from what Dr. Martin Luther King defended in his Letter from a Birmingham Jail. As for the acts of violence in the course of the movement, there were acts of violence, and they were prosecuted appropriately under local law. Consider Paul Hill, who was executed under State law in Florida in 2003. No need of FACE to bring him to justice. I've had 25 years of experience defending FACE claims, almost entirely in opposition to attorneys general, and I have seen how, with dreary predictability, the terms ``force,'' ``threat of force,'' and ``physical obstruction'' in FACE have become so elastic as to reach even de minimis conduct that would not even warrant a desk appearance ticket under local law. Even the most fleeting physical contact has been found to constitute force. The most minimal impediments of clinic workers or clients on the sidewalk have been found to constitute physical obstruction. Mere references to God's judgment on death have been found to constitute threats of force. The FACE Act has been used to impose ridiculous injunctions; totally unheard of in any other context. Speech- free buffer zones, bubble zones, and even floating bubble zones around clinics have created for prolife advocates, and them only, exactly what Justice Scalia described in McCullen v. Coakley., quote: ``An entirely separate abridged edition of the First Amendment applicable to speech against abortion.'' Consider, also, FACE's mode of requirement. If you stand in front of an abortion clinic worker outside a clinic to demand money that you are owed, delaying that person, no law is violated. Stand in front of the same person to offer prolife literature and discuss alternatives to abortion, and you've just violated FACE. Even worse, FACE is being combined with 18 U.S.C. 241, prohibiting conspiracies against rights, which elevates misdemeanor FACE violations into Federal felonies. The result has been preposterous prison sentences. Consider the clinic sit-in at a D.C. abortion clinic in 2020 called a ``blockade'' by the government. Because a clinic staffer allegedly suffered from a sprained ankle, all the participants were found guilty of a crime of violence, as coconspirators, and were sent immediately to prison after the verdict. Joan Bell, 27 months in Federal prison for a 77-year-old grandmother. Jean Marshall, 24 months in Federal prison for a 77-year- old retired nurse. Heather Idoni, 24 months in Federal prison for a 61-year- old grandmother. Consider the case of Beverlyn-Bevelyn Beatty, 41 months in Federal prison for the mother of a two-year-old girl, based on uttering political hyperbole and allegedly causing a minor hand injury. Well, thank God Trump pardoned all these victims of FACE and many more political prisoners that he rescued from the Biden Administration's Gulag. Now, we have the massive DOJ report on weaponization of FACE by the Biden Justice Department. That report reveals a comment by an Assistant U.S. Attorney in the case of U.S. v. Jastrow, which says it all concerning the Biden Administration's weaponization of FACE against religiously motivated prolife activists. I quote, Unfortunately, we ended up with a very Catholic magistrate on duty this week and he was very particular about bond conditions and not infringing on First Amendment rights. At the end, we ended up with overly lawyered bond conditions that would be difficult to enforce. Well, there we have it anti-Catholic bigotry on full display in a public record pertaining to the Biden Administration's vindictive FACE Act prosecutions. We have never seen anything like this pernicious law in American history. For the sake of freedom and justice in America, the FACE Act must be repealed. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Ferrara follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Roy. Thank you, Mr. Ferrara. Mr. Severino, you may begin. STATEMENT OF ROGER T. SEVERINO Mr. Severino. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to build off comments from your opening statement and to consider a few different scenarios, and what could actually be the common thread. Scenario 1. You want to build a pool in your house, and the people doing the construction move the dirt from the hole into some soggy area of your land. Scenario 2. You're cleaning a gutter from your house, and you get up on top and you notice that there is a bird nest there that you push off to the side to the ground. Scenario 3. You go with your son to a National Park, and you discover an Indian arrowhead that you keep as a souvenir. Scenario 4. You're walking down the street, and you see a protest going on. It could be in front of an abortion clinic. It could be in front of a pregnancy resource center. You get into a heated debate and there's an altercation that ensues. The common thread among those four scenarios is that they may be Federal crimes. The thing is, you're not really sure if they are or they aren't. It really depends on the prosecution and what their theory of the case is, and what facts they cherry-pick, and worst of all, whether or not the identity of the alleged perpetrator is perhaps of the same political party or not of the prosecutor. All these things are a result of overcriminalization. The FACE Act is a poster child of overcriminalization. Now, whatever you think about the underlying issue to be addressed in any of those cases, are the wrongs to be addressed at the Federal level? Is everything meant to be, literally, a Federal case? Under our constitutional system, it was designed such that the Federal Government is one of enumerated powers. It only has the power that was given to it by the people specifically in the Constitution. It cannot act unless Congress is authorized by a specific provision in the Constitution. Now, the problem is, Congress has used the Commerce Clause as its catchall to cover every single aspect of American life, such that we have 5,200 different crimes. My former colleague at the Heritage Foundation, Giancarlo Canaparo, catalogued these crimes, but his chilling finding was he couldn't be sure, either. Nobody knows how many Federal crimes there are. The Department of Justice was tasked to actually try to figure this out and they gave up. They did not know how many Federal crimes there are. When you add to this the fact that there are 300,000 regulatory crimes, let me repeat that, 300,000 regulatory crimes, where some bureaucrat decided to amend a regulation that then becomes a crime, well, are we really a Nation of laws or not? We have delegated far too much authority to Federal bureaucrats, and that discretion has given unchecked power that has been abused with the FACE Act and other cases. Let me give you a few examples. There was a person who was importing undersized lobsters from Honduras, and unfortunately, didn't know the Honduran regulations and packed them in plastic bags instead of boxes. What Federal crime was violated? Well, it was done--no Federal crime actually. A Honduran crime perhaps was committed, but because he violated a Honduran crime, that became a Federal crime under the Lacey Act. Who knew that, if you don't follow Honduras' laws for packing lobsters in plastic versus boxes, you might be committing a Federal crime? Now, sticking with Fish and Game, in Florida, a fisherman was capturing some grouper, and they were, again, undersized. A Fish and Game Warden came by and said, ``Wow, they look undersized.'' When the warden left, the fisherman threw some of the fish away to try to kind of hide the evidence. Now, he was charged with a Federal crime under Sarbanes- Oxley, an Enron-related bill that was designed to go after people and accountants that were shredding evidence in an investigation. All of a sudden, the Federal agent said, ``You know what? A fish is a whole lot like a document.'' The Supreme Court said, ``no, it's not; a fish is a fish; it's not a document.'' On with one more example. I was the Nation's HIPAA regulator, and I had the power to issue regulations which also had the force and effect of law. The case of Eithan Haim, a whistleblower doctor in Texas who discovered that Texas Children's Hospital, despite what they were saying, was still giving cross-sex sterilizing treatments to minors possibly in violation of law. He blew the whistle, and the Biden DOJ went after him, not the hospital, for an alleged HIPAA violation 10 years potential prison time for looking into files, not disclosing any protected health information, but verified that, in fact, the hospital was lying. This shows that our laws have been weaponized, such that we are no longer a Nation of laws, but a Nation of men with unchecked authority to go after political enemies whenever they like. [The prepared statement of Mr. Severino follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Roy. Mr. Severino, thank you for your statement. Professor Waters, you may begin. STATEMENT OF JESSICA L. WATERS Ms. Waters. Chair Roy, Ranking Member Scanlon, and the Members of the Committee, and the Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for inviting me back to testify today. I appreciated our conversation related to FACE during the December 2024 hearing before this Committee, and I look forward to additional constructive dialog today. The specific provisions of FACE are outlined in my written testimony, but in brief, FACE created criminal penalties and civil remedies against specific types of intentional violent, threatening, or obstructive conduct directed at people providing or obtaining reproductive health services or seeking to exercise First Amendment religious rights at houses of worship. A few concepts are key there: (1) FACE prohibits specific conduct, not speech. (2) FACE requires that the conduct be intentional; that is, directed at preventing the seeking or provision of reproductive health- care or the exercise of religious rights at houses of worship. (3) FACE expressly excludes nonthreatening, nonobstructive speech from its purview, as it must, as the First Amendment demands that protection. We have heard other witnesses opine today that FACE should be repealed and that it is somehow unconstitutional. Let us be clear: That is simply not what the law says. Every Federal court to consider such arguments has unequivocally held that FACE was a constitutional exercise of Congress' authority. This is not an area where circuits are split or where the laws are unclear. Whether the challenge has been on Commerce Clause grounds, First Amendment speech grounds, First Amendment free exercise grounds, or Tenth Amendment grounds, the courts have said the same thing: FACE is constitutionally sound and based on extensive legislative findings about the need for a Federal remedy to combat a nationwide campaign of violence. Lest there be any confusion, this unanimity is true both pre- and post-Dobbs. A few post-Dobbs cases illustrate this point. For example, in 2025, the Sixth Circuit confronted the question squarely of whether FACE's long-affirmed constitutionally constitutionality was impacted by the Dobbs decision. The Sixth Circuit held that Dobbs had no effect on FACE's constitutionality, finding that, quote, The Supreme Court's decision in Dobbs provides no basis to reconsider prior holdings that FACE is a constitutional exercise of Congress' power under the Commerce Clause. The Sixth Circuit also directly affirmed its prior decisions holding that FACE did not run afoul of the First Amendment speech or free exercise protections. Notably, in the case in which Ms. Edl was a codefendant, United States v. Gallagher, the Tennessee District Court confronted this same question and flatly rejected any argument that Dobbs undermined FACE--FACE's constitutionality or protections. As the Court wrote, and I quote, What did the holding and essential reasoning of Dobbs change about the interstate nature of the reproductive health field? Nothing. Those issues were not even remotely raised by the case which involved a State statute. Other courts to reach this question have found the exact same thing. This includes a New York Court, the D.C. District Court, and a Pennsylvania District Court. Where I think Dobbs does matter in this equation is in two areas that actually underscore the need for FACE. First, Dobbs returned the abortion question to the States, leaving us now in a patchwork of laws across the country. By the end of 2025, 13 States had total abortion bans and six more have 6-12-weeks abortion bans. As has been well-documented, the number of abortions did not decline nationwide after these bans went into effect. Instead, what happened is people who lived in States with bans traveled to other States that protected access to reproductive healthcare. A hundred and seventy thousand patients traveled in 2023; 150,000 in 2024, and 140,000 in 2025. That is, patients and clinics engaged in interstate commerce, the very basis on which FACE left rests. Finally, following Dobbs, there was an almost immediate spike in major incidents targeting reproductive healthcare providers, including arsons, burglaries, and death threats. In 2023 and 2024, the National Abortion Federation documented three arsons, 13 invasions, 169 incidents of vandalism, 621 incidents of trespass, 296 death threats, 38 assaults and battery, 777 counts of obstruction, and 12 bomb threats. Though I wish it wasn't the case, the continued campaign of nationwide intimidation and violence against reproductive healthcare providers highlight the continued need for FACE. As I said in 2024, the bottom line is this: People should be able to seek medical care, and medical professionals should be able to provide it, without fear of violence or intimidation. This is an issue that warrants a Federal remedy. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Waters follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Roy. I thank the witness for her testimony. I will now recognize the gentleman from North Carolina for five minutes. Mr. Harris. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thanks to all the witnesses for being a part of this today. Mr. Ferrara, as a pastor, and now, a Congressman, I have unequivocally stood firm on the importance of protecting the sanctity of life. It is undeniable that every life is a precious gift from God, created with inherent dignity and purpose. This truth has encouraged prolifers across the country to push back on the pro-abortion rhetoric by serving outside of abortion clinic to pray, to counsel women who feel they have run out of options, and to reaffirm the sacred truth that the unborn have value. The way in which the Biden Administration weaponized the FACE Act against prolifers was indefensible and it makes me fear that these actions have discouraged others from getting involved in the fight for the unborn. I would ask you, Mr. Ferrara, in your view, do FACE Act prosecutions against prolifers create a chilling effect among those in the prolive movement? Mr. Roy. Mr. Ferrara, can you use your microphone? Mr. Harris. Your mic, please. Mr. Ferrara. They most certainly do. As I indicated during my testimony, Justice Scalia rightly observed that we have, through the application of the FACE Act, a separate and distinct abridged version of the First Amendment for prolife advocates. The injunctions issued under the authority of FACE have no precedent in American law. They are, as I said during my testimony, ridiculous. Bubble zones, floating bubble zones, speech-free areas to prevent even a discussion of alternatives to abortion, all enacted in the name of protecting what turned out to be the nonexistent right to abortion. Yes, I think that this is a case of unprecedented restrictions on activities, some of which do involve civil disobedience. Civil disobedience, like it or not, is part of the American tradition of social justice movements. I'll tell you this: What I don't see in the prolife movement, even at the height of the rescue movement in the 1990s, is cities burning; police officers being attacked; Molotov cocktails being thrown into businesses; police officers being pelted with bottles filled with ice, and not just death threats, but actual acts of violence on a massive scale not the isolated acts we saw in the prolife movement in the nineties, which were punished appropriately under criminal law. As I indicated, Paul Hill was put to death. You can't do better than capital punishment for punishing lawless activity. My testimony has made clear, that FACE has, for the first time in American history, singled out a single protest movement for treatment under the law that has never been meted out to any other social justice movement in our Nation's history. Mr. Harris. Let me ask you a followup to that. During President Trump's first year in office, he took action to correct the injustices that occurred during the Biden-Harris Administration's enforcement of the FACE Act by issuing pardons to several of the prolifers that were unjustly targeted. Would you say what response have you seen from the prolife movement and your clients regarding President Trump's actions? Mr. Ferrara. Gratitude, and thanks to God for justice done. The sentences handed out, some of which I mentioned in my testimony, are absolutely absurd years in Federal prison for nonviolent conduct, the worst of it being someone's hand was injured or there was a sprained ankle. Then, with the combination of Section 241, conspiracy against rights, multiyear prison sentences for nonviolent conduct. Again, these things could be handled, and had always been handled, as matters of local law. By the way, the system is capable of handling these matters. If you have repeat offenders who are trespassing, sooner or later, they'll end up in a jail cell, and that might be appropriate. Mr. Harris. Correct. Unfortunately, what we are hearing today is part of a larger pattern of an anti-Christian bias we witnessed under the Biden-Harris Administration. Thanks to this Committee's work in the past, we learned that the Biden-Harris FBI used its resources to spy on Catholics in Richmond. On top of that, in today's hearings, we are hearing stories of prolife activists being unjustly targeted by the Biden-Harris DOJ, while attacks on churches and prolife pregnancy centers went largely ignored. In the last 30 seconds, I just want to ask you, Mr. Ferrara, is it fair to say that the Biden-Harris Administration's DOJ displayed clear anti-Christian bias in its actions, including its enforcement of the FACE Act? Mr. Ferrara. Well, there's no question about it. Even FBI Director Wray admitted that the report had been issued out of the Richmond office, characterizing traditionalist Catholics and I'm one of them, and I attend that parish in Richmond as, basically, domestic terrorists. He professed to be embarrassed by the memo and said it was only a localized product. It turned out that this was false. This memo had been widely circulated in FBI channels. Yes, the answer is yes. Mr. Harris. Thank you, sir. Mr. Chair, I yield back. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentleman from North Carolina. I will recognize the Ranking Member first and the unanimous consent request. Ms. Scanlon. Thanks. First, I have an article from The Atlantic, dated April 20, 2026, ``The DOJ's First `Weaponization' Report Is a Bust. The document purports to show bias under Biden Administration--and fails spectacularly.'' Second, I have a DOJ press release on an Ohio woman who was prosecuted for attacking a pregnancy resource center, December 8, 2023. Another one, DOJ press release about dated April 10, 2024, concerning prosecution of someone who fire-bombed a Madison building because of anti-abortion. Next, I have a press release from the DOJ, December 20, 2024, ``Florida Woman Convicted of Civil Rights Conspiracy for Targeting Pregnancy Resource Centers.'' Another DOJ press release from January 19, 2023, titled, ``FBI Offering $25,000 Reward for information on attacks against reproductive health service facilities.'' Mr. Roy. Without objection. Ms. Scanlon. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Roy. I now recognize the Ranking Member of the Full Committee, Mr. Raskin. Mr. Raskin. Mr. Chair, thank you very much. I know our friends are desperate to change the subject from President Trump's aggressive insults to the Pope, saying that he is weak on nuclear weapons and weak on crime, and his online impersonation of Jesus Christ, who he later claimed he was actually he thought that was an image of him playing a doctor. Of course, he is not a doctor, either. He is neither a doctor nor Jesus Christ. In any event, that doesn't make the FACE Act anti- Christian, and if you think it is, then go ahead and bring another failed lawsuit against the FACE Act and claim that it violates the Free Exercise Clause. It does not. In 2022, the Supreme Court in the Dobbs case reversed itself in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, and Roe v. Wade. The right to abortion was not legalized in 1973. It was legal in most of the country. What the Supreme Court did was strike down abortion bans criminalizing abortion. In any event, since the Dobbs decision, 21 States now have a total or a substantial ban on abortion affecting the rights directly of 29 million American women. The 169,000 of them at least, they have had to cross State lines in interstate commerce to seek the medical attention that they need. It is not enough for our friends now to allow State legislatures to ban other people's medical decisions. They want to repeal the FACE Act, so they can directly blockade hospitals and medical clinics. That is the very clear implication of what Mr. Ferrara was just saying that you should have a constitutional right to do what has been made criminal by Congress in the FACE Act, after nine or ten doctors and other medical staff were killed in attacks on people working in abortion clinics. Now, Ms. Waters, I want to ask you, is there any reason to think that there is a constitutional right to blockade other people from obtaining medical attention? Ms. Waters. There is no reason to think there's a constitutional right to interfere with other people seeking medical attention. FACE is very clear on this point and very deliberate, and the legislative history is clear. This was very deliberate. What speech gets at, or what FACE gets at is conduct, right? It's violence. It's threats. It's intimidation. It's blockades. FACE expressly excludes pure speech that does not do those things. Right? What we're talking about here is I hear talk of these crimes were minor and these things were insignificant. When I look at the stats of what's actually happening on the ground, 11 abortion providers have been murdered. Right? There have been 26 other attempted murders. There have been thousands of blockades. There have been hundreds of arsons. We are not talking about peaceful protests. We are talking about violence, and we are talking about a nationwide campaign of violence. Mr. Raskin. Well, Mr. Ferrara makes one good point, it seems to me; that if they are killing doctors who work at reproductive health clinics and other staff and we know that there have been many cases of that--they are already chargeable and punishable under State laws. There's a discrete injury here when people get together and blockade a clinic. You might not have State legislatures that are willing to enact laws to keep them, keep them open. Obviously, there is a Federal interest here, which is why eight Federal Circuit Courts have unanimously around the country upheld the FACE Act against attack. What happens, as in the case where Ms. Edl, again, sincerely goes out to protest, but is part of a protest that blockades people from getting healthcare? What is the effect on the people who are trying to get in? Ms. Waters. There are a couple of points there. The legislative history is replete with references to why a Federal remedy was needed. FACE does not stop States from acting, and FACE does not stop States or command that States do anything. What it says is this is bigger than any individual State. This is a coordinated nationwide campaign that deserves a remedy. Mr. Raskin. You are proud of them that they travel around. Ms. Waters. Absolutely. Mr. Raskin. Yes. Ms. Waters. I think that is important. Let's talk about what is actually happening on the ground, right. If you are a doctor going into a clinic and trying to do your job, and what you are facing are death threats. What you are facing are blockades. What you are facing is fear that people are going to show up at your home or at your children's school and engage in campaigns and intimidation, no one should have to go to work that way, and no medical professional should have to go to work that way. That is not good care. That is not going to help your health. Mr. Raskin. No patient should have to try to scale-- Ms. Waters. No patient-- Mr. Raskin. All those obstacles just to get attention. Let me ask you finely, this is the third time we have had a hearing on this, but there is no vote. It is because our colleagues know that the vast majority of the American people reject this idea and want to make sure that there is safety there. They keep throwing a bone to the prolife movement. I wonder if you agree with me that they are not willing to put this to the floor. Ms. Waters. I cannot speak to their intentions. What I can say is, there is a difference of opinion in this room about access to abortion care. What there should not be a difference of opinion about, and what there cannot be a difference of opinion about, is whether we should use violence to advance those aims. We can't. Mr. Raskin. Thank you. I yield back, Mr. Chair. Mr. Roy. I thank the Ranking Member. I will now recognize the gentleman from Missouri, Mr. Onder, for five minutes. Mr. Onder. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for holding this important hearing on the FACE Act abuse uncovered in the DOJ's recent report. The report explains how the Biden-Harris DOJ unevenly enforced the FACE Act and coordinated with antilife advocacy groups to target prolife Americans. According to the report, just one month after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, then Attorney General Merrick Garland, created a National Task Force that worked hand in glove with Planned Parenthood, the Feminist Majority Foundation, and the National Abortion Federation. These groups compiled dossiers, headshots, and travel information on prolife individuals that ultimately resulted in search warrants, surveillance, and prosecutions. In one instant, the National Abortion Federation prepared a law enforcement guide for an upcoming Christian prolife conference, complete with attendees' personal information. Planned Parent provided a similar dossier labeled opposition identified. After receiving this intelligence, the Biden-Harris DOJ even assisted these groups in securing private grant funding when the Task Force Director volunteered as a reference for NAF's application. The Biden-Harris Administration's conduct during prosecutions was probably most concerning in U.S. v. Houck. In it, the Justice Department authorized an aggressive early morning arrest rather than permitting a voluntary surrender. In U.S. v. Gallagher, the prosecutors withheld evidence from the defense, while sharing similar information with the National Abortion Federation. In United States v. Zastrow, internal emails show DOJ attorneys strategizing about screening out religious jurors, referring to prolife Christian activists as culty, and expressing frustration that a Catholic magistrate was on duty. The pattern continued through sentencing. Under the Biden- Harris DOJ, prosecutors sought an average of 26.8 months for prolife defendants, which is more than double the 12.3-month average sought for violent antilife offenders. One senior official in the administration even wrote that they should ``make sure that extremists know we still have this tool, the FACE Act, and we will use it.'' Mr. Ferrara, all of this is clearly weaponization of the Federal Government. Do you believe any of the recently uncovered activities by the Biden-Harris DOJ are criminal? Mr. Ferrara. I would not go so far as to offer an opinion on whether criminal prosecution is warranted. I would have to be careful about that and evaluate the facts of the case. Mr. Onder. Yes. Mr. Ferrara. Let me take this opportunity to take exception to something my adversary in this issue said, Ms. Waters. Mr. Onder. Please do. Mr. Ferrara. Regarding the predicate in the Commerce Clause for the FACE Act. I don't believe there is an adequate predicate. The Lopez and Morrison cases really have eliminated any serious argument for a Commerce Clause predicate. In Lopez, the Supreme Court struck down the Gun Free School Zones Act, finding that only economic activity that has a substantial effect on interstate commerce can be regulated. Citizens don't have that effect. In the Morrison case, the Supreme Court said that there cannot be a regulation of economic activity based on its supposed aggregate effect on interstate commerce, and therefore, struck down a provision of the Violence Against Women Act. Sit-ins and even what they call blockades of clinics don't have a serious local effect. Mr. Onder. They are local effects, yes. Mr. Severino, how does the uneven application of the FACE Act on prolife versus pro-abortion groups undermine the Constitution and civil rights protections? Mr. Severino. It is an example of the weaponization. We believe in equal justice under the law, which means justice is blind, right? That is part of our American ethos. When you have this rampant uneven enforcement where 97 percent of cases under the FACE Act have been enforced against the prolife side, when in fact the FACE Act also covers pregnancy resource centers and houses of worship. I was in the Department of Justice Civil Rights Division as a career attorney under Obama for several years. There was not a single case of a FACE Act prosecution brought for the invasion of a church. Mr. Onder. Were there no attacks against churches or prolife pregnancy centers? Mr. Severino. There were. Yes, during the Prop. 8 debate, there was video of a storming of the Mormon Temple in Westwood. That was brought to the attention of DOJ civil rights. Mr. Onder. Prop. 8 in California. Mr. Severino. In California, yes. Mr. Onder. Yes, the marriage amendment. Mr. Severino. Correct. Mr. Onder. Yes. Again, the DOJ brought no prosecution in that case? Mr. Severino. They brought zero with respect to houses of worship, up until very recently, in fact. Under the Trump Administration, they finally did. Mr. Onder. Thank you very much. I yield back. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentleman from Missouri. I will now recognize the gentlelady from Washington for five minutes. Ms. Jayapal. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Trump Administration and Congressional Republicans have launched an all-out assault on women. They have advanced the SAVE Act to disenfranchise 69 million married women whose birth certificates don't match their current last name. They have covered up the full Epstein files and refused to meet with Epstein survivors. They have made significant cuts to Medicaid, SNAP, and health- care, making it harder for women to take care of their families. Nowhere is the assault on women more evident than in reproductive health. Donald Trump has cutoff abortion options in States that protect those rights. This Administration has withdrawn Federal guidance requiring hospitals to provide emergency abortion care when life or health is at risk. It has frozen tens of millions of dollars in Title X funding for family planning. These unprecedented actions are not only unlawful, but they also put women's lives in danger. Now, Republicans want to repeal the FACE Act, a public safety law that protects healthcare providers and patients from physical intimidation, harassment, and violence. Now, I am one of the one-in-four women in this country that has had an abortion. I had to speak out publicly about it, frankly, when I came to Congress after not speaking about it for decades. When I saw the attacks on reproductive care around the country, I felt it was my responsibility to talk about it publicly. I don't begrudge anyone, including you, Ms. Edl, from making decisions about your own moral values, about the conduct that you would choose for yourself. I do not appreciate it when someone tries to block me from making choices about my body, about my family, and about my life. I certainly don't appreciate it when people try to block other people from getting healthcare. Professor Waters, at the core of this issue, is the basic principle that no one should fear violence in the workplace when seeking healthcare. Given the misinformation on the issue, could you just give us some details on what type of violent situations that abortion providers, patients, and volunteers face? Ms. Waters. If I may, I would like to quickly respond to the Commerce Clause point that my colleague raised. Then, I would love to get to your question. On the point of Lopez and Morrison, it is true that the Lopez and Morrison cases define what is covered by the bounds of the Commerce Clause. It is also true that most of the cases that we have cited that have said that the FACE Act is upheld are post-Lopez and some of them are post-Morrison. My colleague's point really doesn't hold. On the question of the type of violence, we were seeing on the ground, and this is the point, right, this is why we have FACE. If we are looking, we are talking about things like murders. We are talking about things like arson. We are talking about things like asset attacks, right? We are talking about, as we heard, women who are trying to get into clinics, because their fetuses are incompatible with life. They are having the worst days of their life, and they are blockaded from getting into a clinic and can't get in there. We are talking about harm. We are talking about threats. We are talking about violence. My colleagues keep raising hypotheti-cals about lobsters and fish, right? What we are talking about are real women. What we are talking about are real doctors who are going into work every day in fear of their life. Ms. Jayapal. Instead of addressing the violence, one of the first things that Donald Trump did when he took office was to pardon 23 anti-abortion extremists criminally convicted under the FACE Act. His Department of Justice released a memo directing prosecutors to cease enforcement of the FACE Act absent ``extraordinary ccircumstances.'' Based on your research, how did these actions impact women's access to reproductive care? Ms. Waters. Yes, it is ironic to me that we are here talking about some alleged weaponization, or some sort of selective prosecution. in fact, the Biden Administration was the first to actually bring cases to protect crisis pregnancy centers. Right? Ms. Jayapal. That is right. Ms. Waters. That was the administration that actually was applying this in a more even-handed way. When we are talking about what President Trump's directives and pardons will do, it declares open season, right? Ms. Jayapal. Yes. Ms. Waters. It says to abortion providers and patients, we are not going to be there to protect you. Ms. Jayapal. There is some confusion about all the services that people get blocked from when this happens at reproductive health clinics. Just a quick yes or no, whether it is easier or harder for women to get these services as a result of repealing the FACE Act. Is it easier for women to get STD testing and treatment? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal. Cancer screenings? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal Pregnancy testing? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal. Birth control? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal. Infertility services? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal. Prenatal services? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal. Postpartum services? Ms. Waters. Harder. Ms. Jayapal. Harder. All these things are harder. By the way, don't make choices about my body. Let me make those decisions for myself. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentlelady from Washington. I will now recognize the Chair of the Full Committee, Mr. Jordan. Chair Jordan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Ferrara, how many churches and crisis pregnancy centers were attacked in the aftermath of the Dobbs leak in the Dobbs decision, do you remember? Mr. Roy. Mr. Ferraro, can you please use your microphone? Mr. Ferrara. I don't have the exact number, but there were many. I am involved in one particular case, the firebombing of a prolife pregnancy center in Amherst, New York, causing $500,000 in damage and injuring two of the firemen. Chair Jordan. Well, I will tell you, there were hundreds. I will just give you a little sampling, you talked about the firebombing of that place. There was another place firebombed in Madison, Wisconsin on May 8, 2022. The next day, May 9th, three Catholic churches in Texas were attacked. Two days later in Michigan, activists vandalized the Family Life Services Pregnancy Center. I have actually it is like ten pages. We did a list of this back during the leak in the Dobbs opinion. I have ten pages just listing churches, crisis pregnancy centers that were attacked. Do you remember some of the groups that were attacking these churches and crisis pregnancy centers, Mr. Ferrara? Mr. Ferrara. Jane was here. Chair Jordan. Yes, Jane's Revenge, Ruth Sent Us. Do you happen to know if any of those organizations made the Southern Poverty Law Centers hate list? Mr. Ferrara. Of course not. Chair Jordan. No, they didn't, did they? Mr. Ferrara. No. The Southern Poverty Law Center is not a credible organization. In fact, if you, as a conservative activist, are condemned by the Southern Poverty Law Center, consider that a resume builder. Chair Jordan. They condemned Moms for Liberty. They condemned the Family Research Council. They condemned Alliance Defending Freedom. My guess, they may have gone after your group. I don't know. Any prolife group, it seemed like they were going to attack. Is that fair to say? Mr. Ferrara. Yes, it is. I would like to make a point about what Congresswoman Jayapal said, regarding public safety law. ``There is no Federal police power over the States.'' The idea that you would like to have a public safety law that caters to your particular interest in receiving reproductive health services, is contrary to the whole principle of federalism. That is the problem with FACE. That FACE purports to exercise generalized Federal police power in one area and one area only, and that being the activity of prolife activists. Chair Jordan. Yes. Mr. Severino, let me come to you. We know that the Biden Justice Department, the Biden FBI was actually paying confidential human sources to do all kinds of things. Well, we are trying to get some answers to that. I am just curious, do you think maybe some of the same folks, so, the Biden Justice Department was working with the Southern Poverty Law Center to train prosecutors, as if they were going to get some great wisdom from the SPLC, they were doing that. We know they were paying the confidential human sources. Do you think it is a fair question to say, I wonder if any of these ``informants of the SPLC, were also being paid by the Federal Government.'' Do you think that is a fair question? Mr. Severino. Yes, absolutely. Chair Jordan. Why wouldn't they double dip? It is like if, oh, if the Southern Poverty Law Center is training the prosecutors, and I know the FBI is going to pay confidential human sources in the Southern Poverty Law Center, well, sugar, I can get money from both of them. Three million dollars from the SPLC and who knows what the Federal Government is going to pay out. They got a pretty big bank account too. That is a fair question that we would like to get the answer to. Mr. Severino. We should get to the bottom of it. What the DOJ report on the FACE Act showed was that in fact, DOJ was in cahoots with outside groups-- Chair Jordan. Exactly. Mr. Severino. Similar to SPLC. The Left-wing groups, they get together and they pretty much create their own little branch offices within the DOJ whenever we have liberals in power. The SPLC has been talking to DOJ under Biden and certainly Obama, Planned Parenthood Federation, National Abortion Federation, all those folks, they pretty much open up their branch offices in DOJ when the Left is in power. Chair Jordan. Yes. You anticipated my next question, because that is exactly where I wanted to go. Do you think any of these informants actually were involved in the attacks on the churches and crisis pregnancy centers? I think that is a fair question as well. Mr. Severino. It is a possibility. That would be terrible if in fact, our own government was funding-- Chair Jordan. Well, maybe what the SPLC calls informants, we might call instigators, based on what you saw in the indictment last week. Mr. Severino. Sure. Chair Jordan. I don't know that it is out of the realm of possibility if they are, we don't know, but I think it is a fair guess to say they might have been double dipping, getting paid by the government and the SPLC. Maybe they were instigating some of these over ten pages, 100 different attacks on crisis pregnancy centers and churches in the aftermath of the Dobbs decision. Mr. Severino. Well, we know that a DOJ official actually endorsed a grant application for one of these abortion activist groups. Which is a clear ethical violation that the DOJ report said, ``it is very likely to be investigated for an ethics breach.'' This sort of too cozy relationship, is something that is very common that we see in abortion and SPLC. Any of these hot button issues from the Left, you see this sort of collusion. Chair Jordan. Yes. Again, I want to thank our witnesses. Ms. Edl, I am sorry I didn't to you. I listened to your testimony, but I was in a meeting backstage. When you came on, I turned on the TV to hear what you had to say. God bless you. We appreciate your Christian witness and your words. With that, I yield back to the Chair. Mr. Roy. I thank the Chair of the Committee, Mr. Jordan. I now recognize the Ranking Member for some unanimous consent requests. Ms. Scanlon. Yes. I just seek unanimous consent for an April 14, 2026, article from Justice Security, ``Separating Fact From Fiction in FACE Act Enforcement.'' Mr. Roy. Without objection. All right. I too, have a unanimous count request, an article from the Lozier Institute, saying that Planned Parenthood performed more abortions than pap tests, miscarriage care, preventative and primary care tests, prenatal services, HPV examinations, diagnostic procedures for cancer, combined. Without objection. I now recognize the gentleman from Tennessee. Mr. Cohen. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We are having this hearing because it is a political issue of great importance to both sides. On the Republican side, it can have an effect on different races that will be going on. I think we should have been having hearings on Executive Orders. Executive Orders that have gone way beyond the power that Congress should give to the President, and which I discussed with the Chair some time ago when we had a bill together on it. It is not gone and we have let the President overstep his bounds and take over Article I powers of the Congress. We have just given them up and that is a shame. That is a more important hearing than this. This does demonstrate the differences in the parties. Democrats are fighting to ensure that every American can access high quality healthcare practice, their faith freely, practice their faith freely, and rely on the rule of law. The Majority, however, seeks to hand individual healthcare decisions to a handful of radical activists, impose their preferred religious views on everyone else, and give cover to law breakers, even violent ones, when it benefits them politically. It was discussed earlier in a question to maybe Mr. Ferrara, about pardons that were given out by the President sometime after he pardoned everybody that participated in the insurrection of January 2025, I guess it was. He said that there were pardons given to these folks and thank God. We all have our different theories about God, Mr. Ferrara. I don't think God has anything to do with President Biden's pardons, particularly the ones that were paid, and bought, and given out to fraudsters and criminals that then committed crimes again. That is another issue. We should be hearing pardon exemptions. We need to reform the pardon power and give less power to the President to give pardons. It should be restricted, as we should be looking at emoluments as well. Back to healthcare. Every American should have meaningful access to high quality care. Too many barriers already exist. High prices, healthcare deserts, biases, which is why I support Medicare for all and have since I came to Congress. The last thing we need is self-appointed monitors preventing people from obtaining basic services. In December, 17 people were arrested for blocking access to the Planned Parenthood Clinic in Memphis, only a few blocks from my home. It is the only remaining Planned Parenthood clinic in Memphis. The other was closed because of the administration's deep Medicaid cuts. The protestors weren't stopping abortions. Abortion in Tennessee is a felony at all stages of pregnancy with no exceptions for rape or incest. The people entering the clinic were seeking routine preventative services like blood pressure checks, breast cancer screenings, and STI treatment. It functions like any other doctor's office, accepting insurance and serving patients whose reasons for visiting vary and are private. This wasn't about protecting life; it was about intimidation and imposing one groups' beliefs on everyone else. No one should be prevented from going to their doctor because of what one assumes they are there for. Here is the kicker, some of those arrested were antichoice activists whom President Trump had recently pardoned for earlier FACE Act violations. They don't stop. These, just like the January 6th people didn't stop. I think 30 of them have been arrested for everything from sex with a child, to rape, and to other heinous offenses. These individuals in Memphis had already been convicted of obstructing access to reproductive healthcare. The FACE Act plays a critical role in protecting the rights of patients and providers. This Administration and the MAGA movement want to dismantle it. Repealing the FACE Act would give political and legal cover to people who believe they can decide who should and should not receive healthcare. This is not about religion; it certainly is not about religious freedom. The FACE Act explicitly protects religious institutions. Repealing it would make them more vulnerable, not less. Even on the question of abortion, religion's perspectives vary widely. Christian denominations do not speak with one voice. Across Judaism, the prevailing view prioritizes the life and health of the mother. Muslim, Buddhist, and Hindu teachings vary as well. Repealing the FACE Act will elevate one narrow set of beliefs at the expense of all others. That is the opposite of religious liberty. In the United States, everyone has a right to their religious beliefs, but not the right to impose those beliefs on others. That is why I am proud to work with Congressmen Scott, Raskin, and Scanlon on the Do Not Harm Act. Tomorrow, this Committee will hold a hearing on victim services. The Majority argues that advancing policy in that area would convey a strong message. Apply that language here. Advancing FACE Act repeal would send a clear message. Donald Trump and MAGA Republicans believe they should control who gets access to healthcare, and that those who physically block Americans from seeing a doctor will be encouraged, protected, and empowered. I yield back the balance of my time. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentleman from Tennessee. I will now recognize the gentle lady from Wyoming for five minutes. Ms. Hageman. I find it very rich that any Democrat would attempt to lecture us about violence in light of the fact that it was yet another one of theirs who just three days ago sought to assassinate our President and his cabinet. Don't get me started on the Democrat's favorite KKK supporter, the Southern Poverty Law Center. Spare me your faux outrage about violence. According to the DOJ's report on the Biden Administration's weaponization of the FACE Act, ``in total, during the four- years under President Biden, the DOJ charged more than 45 prolife defendants, in over 20 cases, with violating the FACE Act in connection with prolife demonstrations.'' This is in stark contrast to largely ignoring attacks on prolife pregnancy resource centers, as Chair Jordan just pointed out, in which the DOJ, despite hundreds of cases and hundreds of attacks against prolife medical centers for women, the DOJ only charged a handful of them. Again, spare me your faux outrage. The report further reveals that the Biden DOJ prosecutors requested an average sentence of 26.8 months for prolife defendants, compared to 12.3 months for prochoice defendants. Mr. Severino, how do these average sentencing amounts correlate to the applicable range in the sentencing guidelines? Mr. Severino. It varies depending on whether it is a first offense or not. It is a misdemeanor for a first offense, and some of these cases where you get felony levels, are second offenses. What we see in the DOJ report is that it was effectively double for the prolife charge parties, versus the very few on the other side. There were only five that were brought recently that attacked the pregnancy resource centers. The disparity was essentially double. Ms. Hageman. Well, then we also have the circumstance where they raided, I think it was Mr. Houck's home, in the middle of the night, drug him out the door in front of his family, simply because he was trying to protect his son from a violent pro- abortion demonstrator at a, I believe it was a Planned Parenthood facility. How do these, what they did under the Biden Administration, how does that compare to other Administrations in terms of the sentences that they sought as well as the number of prosecutions? Mr. Severino. Sure. In terms of the numbers, 97 percent of the cases were against prolifers. It was about 26.8 months for those convictions. About 12 months for the prochoice side. You see with the Houck case you mentioned, that is a gross abuse where you have armed FBA agents with long guns go into this man's house where they were in contact with their attorney. Normally, under normal circumstances, if they are willing to turn themselves in, which in this case they were, they turned themselves in. Instead, they made this entire spectacle and frightened their families out of their skin to make a statement. Ms. Hageman. I would argue a very violent spectacle of our Federal Government, carried out by our Federal Government. In fact, Mr. Houck just received, what was it, $1 million dollars? The settlement for the way that he was treated, I believe. Federal funds going to him because of the Biden's violation of his civil rights. Isn't that correct? Mr. Severino. I don't know the dollar amount. This was a clear violation, because he was completely vindicated at trial. It took the jury three hours to say not guilty. He was defending his son from a bully and that was-- Ms. Hageman. A violent bully. Mr. Severino. Right. Ms. Hageman. A violent prochoice bully. Mr. Severino. Yes. They got into, that is why my opening statement says, look, these sorts of things, you have a weaponized DOJ that says you have this dispute, and a father defends his child from a bully, and that becomes a Federal offense. Right? This is rampant abuse. Then, they have armed a year later, a year later, armed Federal agents raid his house in the morning. It is just absolute abuse. Ms. Hageman. Well, in the case of the United States v. Gallagher, when one of the defense counsels contacted the Assistant U.S. Attorney, requesting information on the number of FACE Act criminal prosecutions in the last 10 years, the Biden DOJ prosecutors refused to share it, despite the information being readily available. Sanjay Patel, the Director of the National Task Force on Violence Against Reproductive Healthcare Providers, and a very corrupt man, after receiving several requests stated, ``as the National Clinic Violence Coordinator, I do not keep the kind of records you requested, and as a result, I do not believe that we will provide them to you.'' He was lying through his teeth. They did have those records. Sanjay Patel, he referred to the defense counsel to DOJ press releases. Then, it is also important to note, as what was done by a predecessor, that he actually agreed to be a reference on a National Abortion Federation third-party grant application. The point of this being, the report has demonstrated that the Biden Administration violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution in the way that they have dealt with prolife and prochoice prosecutions under the FACE Act. The FACE Act either needs to be reformed or abolished, because it has been abused by Democrat Administrations. With that, I yield back. Mr. Severino. May I answer, Mr. Chair? Mr. Roy. Yes. Mr. Severino. Yes. When I was at DOJ, if you had a FACE Act case, you would actually enter it, there is a particular spot in your tracking of time. DOJ knew exactly how many FACE Act cases at all times they had opened. Mr. Roy. I thank the witness. Thank the gentlelady from Wyoming. I will now recognize the gentleman from Tennessee for a unanimous consent request. Mr. Cohen. Thank you, sir. A unanimous consent request is an article written by Ms. Burton and Ms. Sanchez, and published in Ms. Magazine, about the arrest in Memphis that the anti- abortion training camp sparked. I would like to enter that for the record. Mr. Roy. Without objection. Mr. Cohen. I would also like to correct an error in my discussion. I think I said J6 was not, I didn't say 2021, which is of course, was the first term, not the second term. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentleman for the correction. I will now recognize the gentlelady from Vermont for her five minutes. Ms. Balint. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As a former history teacher, one of the things I always try to make sure that my students understand is the importance of context. I want to come back to thinking about how we got here, and let's consider the history of the anti-abortion violence in the United States. Since 1977, there have been 11 murders, 26 attempted murders, 42 bombings, 200 acts of arson, 100 acid attacks, four kidnappings, and over 600 assaults against patients and workers at reproductive health facilities. It has been nearly a five-decade long terrorist campaign. We are talking about militant extremists willing to use deadly violence to prevent women from seeking reproductive care and from having control over their own bodies. Congress passed the FACE Act in 1994, to protect doctors and nurses and patients from violent threats, assaults, and blockades. That is the history, and the context is important. Professor Waters, thank you so much for being here today. Can you describe the levels of violence against abortion providers and patients at that time, and the reasons why Congress had to come together to pass the FACE Act? Ms. Waters. I think you just covered many of the reasons very well. I will say on a personal note, one of the ways that I came to do this work, is I have a vivid memory of the late 1990s, I was a college student, and I remember hearing that Dr. Slepian had been murdered. Ms. Balint. Yes. Ms. Waters. He was an abortion provider who had just come home from a memorial service for his father at his synagogue. He was in his kitchen making soup and he was shot through his window in front of his child and murdered. Ms. Balint. Right. Ms. Waters. That is what we are talking about. Ms. Balint. Right. Ms. Waters. That is the history. Ms. Balint. I am so glad you brought that up, because we are forgetting, as you said earlier, ``these are real people.'' Ms. Waters. These are humans. Ms. Balint. These are human beings. Actually, I want to bring into this conversation also, something that a clinic worker said about the kind of environment she has to work in. She said, When I worked in Louisiana, someone threw a Molotov cocktail at the clinic. After that, the clinic couldn't have any windows anymore. There were literally no windows in the building whatsoever. You never knew what time of day it was at work, but it had to be like that, because people would just throw Molotov cocktails at the building. None of this is peaceful, or prayerful, or in the interest of not just public safety, but again, we are talking about patients trying to seek healthcare. Last year, as some of my colleagues have already said, I just want to remind everybody, President Trump pardoned 20 FACE Act violators. He pardoned people who got due process, and were found guilty in our courts of law, beyond a reasonable doubt by juries of their peers. He pardoned people who blocked off clinics while women who urgently needed care, were stuck bleeding and crying outside in their cars. Along with the pardons, Trump's Justice Department sent a clear message with their charging document. I want to read from it. It reads, Future abortion related FACE Act prosecutions and civil actions will be permitted only in extraordinary circumstances until further notice. No new abortion-related FACE Act actions, criminal or civil, will be permitted without authorization. What this sounds like to me, is a complicated way of saying, ``we are not protecting anyone for criminal attacks anymore.'' That is what we are talking about here. What kind of message does that send, Professor Waters, to violent protestors who are part of this movement? Ms. Waters. I think it sends several messages. I think it sends a message to providers that we will not enforce the Federal law, and we will not protect you, and you are on your own. It sends a message to violent protestors. I want to be very clear here we are not talking here about peaceful pickets, right? Ms. Balint. That is right. Ms. Waters. Or praying, right? Peaceful protests, even protests that we may disagree vehemently with. What we are talking about is sending the message to people who blockade clinics, who use violence, that you can get away with it. Ms. Balint. I agree. The last thing, I want to take issue with something that the Chair of the Full Committee said. He seemed to imply that women were not actually seeking full reproductive care from these clinics. As one of those millions of women before the Affordable Care Act was passed, and when I didn't have insurance, I got my reproductive care, my full reproductive care from a Planned Parenthood facility. The 2.2 million visits for birth control, 5.5 million visits for STI testing and treatment, nearly 400,000 visits for cancer screening, and no patient should have to walk through this kind of gauntlet to get care. I yield back. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentlelady for her questions. I will now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Gill, for five minutes. Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for hosting this hearing. I certainly appreciate your leadership, especially on this topic. Ms. Waters, thanks for being here. I really appreciate it. Do you believe that abortion should be safe, legal, and rare? Ms. Waters. I believe the abortion decision should be left to a patient, their doctor, their family, and their God. Mr. Gill. Do you believe it should be safe, legal, and rare? Ms. Waters. I believe it should be safe, legal, and rare, yes. Mr. Gill. OK. Why should it be rare? Ms. Waters. Because if we are engaging in public health activities appropriately, we are able to prevent pregnancies when people want to prevent pregnancies. I think a conversation-- Mr. Gill. What is wrong with an abortion then? Ms. Waters. May I finish my sentence? Mr. Gill. Sure. Ms. Waters. If we are actually talking about reproductive health, and caring about maternal health, we should be talking about, do people have adequate access to preventative care? Right? Do they have adequate access to contraception? Are they able-- Mr. Gill. Do you support any limits on abortion? Ms. Waters I am sorry, I didn't hear your question. Mr. Gill. Do you support any limits on abortion? Ms. Waters. This is a place where I suspect you and I will fundamentally disagree. What I believe, is that the abortion decision should fundamentally, because it is medical care-- Mr. Gill. Do you support any limits at all? It is just yes or no. Ms. Waters. If you would let me finish my answer. Mr. Gill. It is just yes or no, do you think that there should be any limits on abortion? Ms. Waters. I came here with the goal of providing truthful and accurate testimony. To truthfully and accurately answer your question, what I would say is, I fundamentally believe that the question of abortion should be left to a patient and their doctor and their family. I don't want to interfere in medical decisions. Mr. Gill. OK. I will take that as a no. Is that a good summary of your testimony? Ms. Waters. I answered your question. Mr. Gill. OK. I think that this is a no then. You are an advocate for abortion, for abortion policy. What is your favorite type of abortion? Ms. Waters. I am an advocate for patients having access to the full realm of reproductive healthcare. Mr. Gill. Do you have a preferred method of abortion that you like? Ms. Waters. I do not. Mr. Gill. Let me read through a couple different methods, and I want to get your take on how much you like these. The first type is called a suction abortion. This is when the cervix is dilated, and a strong suction, 29 times the power of a household vacuum cleaner, tears the baby's body apart and sucks it through the hose into a container. Do you prefer that method? Ms. Waters. I stand by my former testimony. Mr. Gill. That sounds kind of gross, doesn't it? It sounds pretty gruesome. Do you agree? It does to me. Ms. Waters. I stand by how I answered your question fully and accurately. Mr. Gill. OK. What about this one, this one is called dilation and curettage. After dilation of the cervix, a sharp looped knife is inserted into the uterus. The baby's body is cut into pieces and extracted often by suction. Do you prefer that method? Ms. Waters. What I believe we are here to talk about today is the FACE Act. We are not here to talk about the-- Mr. Gill. No, I am asking you, you are a pro-abortion advocate, I am asking if you prefer the dilation and curettage method? Ms. Waters. I am an access to reproductive healthcare advocate. Mr. Gill. You don't want to talk about abortion itself. Why is that? Ms. Waters. I would prefer to talk about the reason that the Committee called the hearing. Mr. Gill. Is it because it is uncomfortable to talk about? Ms. Waters. I would prefer to-- Mr. Gill. It should be uncomfortable. Ms. Waters. I would prefer, if you would let me finish my statement, to talk about the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, which is what I was asked to come here to talk about. Mr. Gill. We are talking about what that access--yes, how about this one? It is called dilation and evacuation. Forceps are inserted into the uterus, grabbing and twisting the baby's body to dismember him or her. If the head is too large, it must be crushed to remove it. Do you prefer that method? Ms. Waters. I would prefer to talk about the reason the hearing was called and the basis of my expert testimony. Mr. Gill. It is uncomfortable to hear this, isn't it? It is. It is, because it is barbaric and evil. How about this one, it is called the saline injection. It is when a 20 percent salt solution is injected through the mother's abdomen into the baby's amniotic fluid. The baby's skin is burned off. The baby ingests the solution and dies of salt poisoning, dehydration, and hemorrhaging of the brain. Do you prefer that method? Ms. Waters. I would prefer to talk about the subject of hearing. Mr. Gill. This is the subject of the hearing. This is about protests outside of abortion clinics. I am asking you about abortion. Ms. Waters. I stand by my prior testimony. Mr. Gill. OK. I wouldn't want to talk about this either if I were you, because it is barbaric and evil. With that, I yield the remaining time to the Chair. Thank you. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentleman from Texas. I will only note in the remaining 10 seconds, is that a good deal of the efforts by my Democratic colleagues to talk about this issue, has moved to the core question of abortion and what is carried on, and the activities that are carried out at Planned Parenthood and other facilities. That question by the gentleman from Texas is in line. I will now recognize the gentlelady from California. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The reality is, this hearing is not really about the FACE Act, because that was a bipartisan bill passed over 30 years ago that still has standing. It is a bill that is about protecting worshipers when they go to pray, and patients when they are trying to access healthcare. This is about how laws are enforced and interpreted, and how this Administration is cherry-picking and using selective prosecution of cases to support their desired claims and agenda. The claims and the agenda are, to take away rights and to silence groups with whom they dislike or disagree. Last month, the DOJ released a highly flawed 900-page partisan report, purporting to examine prosecutorial decisionmaking under the FACE Act, and alleging bias and Federal law enforcement during the Biden Administration. However, many cases brought between 2020-2024, involved serious crimes such as firebombing, arson, bomb threats, and coordinated clinic blockades. All which resulted in indictments by Federal grand juries and guilty verdicts at trial. We are talking about violent and unlawful acts. Professor Waters, even though I have answered my own question, but I will ask you the question as well. Do those sound like peaceful protests to you? Ms. Waters. They do not sound like peaceful protests to me. When we are talking about the incidents of obstruction and violence at clinics, it is important to look at all the cases that were not prosecuted, right? For example, when I look at the National Abortion Federation statistics, and I look at like, for example, the number of pickets and protests outside of clinics, there were tens of thousands, right? What we are talking about under the Biden Administration, is 25 prosecutions, not for that activity. The prosecutions are for blockades. The prosecutions are for threats. The prosecutions are for violence, not protected speech. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you. I would say that this Administration came into power with a real agenda against women. They have weaponized the DOJ to carry their agenda out, because what they didn't include in this 900-page report were a number of stories, like the woman who tried for years and years and years to get pregnant, and I know what that feels like, and miscarried. Went to a clinic to help her medically manage the miscarriage. She was blocked from seeing her doctor. She was in her car sobbing and bleeding out. The technical term when you have a miscarriage, and I know about this personally, is the doctor will call it an abortion. It is violent for anyone, especially a man, to suggest that they know more about my body and how I am trying to protect myself, in the hopes that I can get pregnant again, based on their assumption of me and the kind of healthcare that I deserve. We should also remind folks and include the incident that happened last year in a clinic in California, where the clinic was set on fire. Last month a clinic in Ohio was set on fire. These are about patients, doctors, and workers going to get some healthcare. Let me tell you something, when you go to a clinic, you are not wearing a sign that says, hey, I am getting an abortion. You could go to a clinic to get a pap smear, to get IVF, and a vasectomy. In the few seconds that I have remaining, I would be remiss if I didn't draw the Subcommittee's attention to the murders on the streets of Minneapolis by ICE, and the use of the FACE Act to charge two journalists, two black journalists, Ms. Fort and Mr. Lemon. These folks were documenting protest activities that the church, was happening at a church because its pastor was a key official in the ICE response to Minneapolis. I know my time is running up, but I just want to say that this Chair himself has said in other contexts, that free Americans should never live in fear of their government targeting them. Yet, that is exactly what happened to these two journalists and others. They were inappropriately charged under the FACE Act. Meanwhile, a MAGA influencer, Ms. Gomez, who also interrupted an LGBTQ friendly worship service, was neither charged nor arrested. I have receipts when I am saying that we are cherry-picking and using selective prosecution to go after folks that we want to sideline. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentlelady from California. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentlelady from California. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. I do also have some-- Mr. Roy. Consent requests? Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Yes. A testimony of Renee Chelian, founder and CEO of Northland Family Planning. Her testimony before the House Judiciary Committee. I ask unanimous consent. An article in Politico, ``Trump pardons abortion clinic protestors ahead of March for Life.'' This was January 23, 2025. Thank you, Mr. Chair. FBI investigating fertility clinic bomb suspects, possible antinationalist manifesto. From May 18, 2025. CDC archive, ``More men using family planning services.'' This is June 16, 2016. Last, our letter to the Chair and the Ranking Member, Amnesty International USA submits this letter to the House Subcommittee on the Constitution for their upcoming hearing from tool to weapon, the FACE Act-- Mr. Roy. Without objection. I will now recognize the gentleman from Wisconsin for five minutes. Mr. Grothman. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for having this hearing. A very timely and always very interesting, kind of an appropriate hearing to have in Wisconsin today. I know in the last year, for the first time in many years, we opened a third abortion clinic in the city of Milwaukee. It is something that I hadn't seen before in Wisconsin. It is something you hear about in other parts of the country. The clinic was in a neighborhood clearly designed to deal almost exclusively with customers or patients of color. I thought that was kind of illuminating, because that gets to the underlying goal of so many people in the pro-abortion movement. In any event, we will start off with Mr. Severino. Thank you for being here today. In light of your experience as a trial attorney at Justice's Civil Rights division, how did the Biden-Harris Administration's approach to prosecuting alleged violators of the FACE Act comport with the standard practices in this division? Mr. Severino. It was all one-sided. I saw that directly in the Obama administration. Mr. Grothman. Oh, I am sorry, always what? Mr. Severino. One-sided. Mr. Grothman. Oh, OK. Mr. Severino. The prosecutions were against the prolife side. It was mentioned earlier by one of the Members on the other side that now it is being enforced for churches. Well, now it is the first time it is being enforced to protect churches, because neither the Biden Administration nor the Obama Administration lifted a finger when we had hundreds of violations, including burnings and vandalizing of churches, especially after the Dobbs decision. Mr. Grothman. OK. How does this uneven application of the FACE Act on prolife or pro-abortion groups undermine the Constitution, in your opinion, and the civil rights protections for all Americans? Mr. Severino. Sure. It is the notion of equal justice under the law, right? People should not get favor from the government. The political identity of a party should not matter. What we saw with, especially the DOJ report that just came out, was that you had Left-wing activists, pro-abortion groups, who were surveilling American citizens and doing things that the Federal Government could not do themselves. They were outsourcing, DOJ was essentially outsourcing their investigatory functions to activist groups. Those activist groups, they don't care about the Constitution, right? They are not Federal agents, so they could do whatever they want to track people, get their licenses, see where they live, and track their religious exercise. Then, they packaged that and handed it over to DOJ, right? They did the dirty work on the front end, then DOJ on the back end, picked it up. By the way, the abortion clinics themselves weren't the ones complaining. These were the activist umbrella groups that were combining dossiers on people and giving them to DOJ to prosecute. Mr. Grothman. OK. Can you speak of your experience in the civil rights division on how the Federal Government can play a more responsible role in preventing the overfederalization of criminal law? Mr. Severino. Yes. The overfederalization is a horrific problem, if we do not know what crimes we may be committing in our everyday lives. The examples I said earlier, why could it be a crime for taking a nest off your roof? Well, there is a Migratory Bird Treaty Act that covers 1,100 bird species, and if you mess with their nests, you are committing a Federal crime. The DOJ has to go through every statute, finely count everyone, tell the American people, these are our crimes that you could be liable for. Then, Congress needs to repeal every one that doesn't have a constitutional basis. The FACE Act is one of those that does not have a sufficient constitutional basis. It is emblematic of the overcriminalization that you are talking about. Mr. Grothman. OK. A recent Justice Department report issued by the Trump Administration stated that Biden-Harris prosecutors withheld evidence that defense counsel requested to prepare an affirmative defense. In U.S. v. Gallagher, prosecutors had information readily available that they did not share with the defendants, while sharing substantially identical information with the National Abortion Fund. Mr. Ferrara, were there times you requested information that the Biden-Harris DOJ prosecutors refused to provide? Mr. Ferrara. I have operated on the civil side, not the criminal side, so I can't really respond to that question. I would note one thing; there have been a lot of references to acts of violence. Let's talk about what happens in those cases. The killer of Dr. Gunn got life in prison. The killer of Dr. Britton and his escort, death. The killer of Dr. Slepian, life plus ten. The killer of Dr. Tiller, 25 years to life. The criminal justice system under State law addresses acts of violence. There was no need for FACE in any of those cases. Which is the problem with FACE is that it usurps the role that is properly assigned to local law under State and local judicial systems, including the severest possible penalties for people who commit violence. We don't need this statute and never had needed it. Mr. Grothman. Thank you. Mr. Roy. I thank the gentleman from Wisconsin for his questions. I now recognize the Ranking Member, Ms. Scanlon, for five minutes. Ms. Scanlon. Thank you. Given some of the prior questions that we have heard, that it is important to note the importance of Planned Parenthood and other reproductive healthcare providers across our country. Two of my colleagues have already mentioned that they have sought services from Planned Parenthood at various times, as did I. When my husband and I were starting our family, we lived three blocks from a Planned Parenthood clinic. Went there frequently to get information, to consult books, and to buy books on having a baby. The attacks on Planned Parenthood are really, really important to note, because as funding is attacked and everything else, that it is often the only source of reproductive healthcare in so many of our neighborhoods. At any rate, we have heard a lot of really gross misstatements of facts, et cetera. I would refer people back to Ms. Waters' testimony and the articles I have submitted with respect to the complete misrepresentations in the recent DOJ report. I wanted to focus on a couple things here, Ms. Waters. One is we have heard a lot about disparities in prosecution and sentencing. I will give you two questions, and you can address as you will, which are not supported by the evidence. Then, also, I don't think there has been enough discussion of the fact that this is a national campaign of violence by anti-abortion activists. I mentioned earlier that six people were arrested in my district in July 2025, for trespassing at a clinic and harassing patients and staff. These six people were not local protestors. They came from New Jersey, Wisconsin, Texas, Michigan, Minnesota, and Ohio. Two had been pardoned by Trump for prior offenses in other States, FACE Act violations. At least one was arrested in D.C. just days after submitting a plea bargain with respect to the incident in my district. She was in D.C. to join other anti-abortion activists to plan their next national activities. If you can comment on the fact, comment on both the alleged disparity in prosecution and sentencing, and why, again, a national FACE Act is important? Ms. Waters. I will start with the second. The need for the National FACE Act was well documented in the legislative record at the time, right? What we saw, was local and State law enforcement saying, we can't handle this, right? Hundreds of people show up, and if my force goes to that clinic, we are not doing anything else in the State, right? We saw it as State law enforcement saying, this is very needed. We also saw ample evidence that a lot of this violence was cross State, right? State's jurisdiction ends where its borders end, right? They were having a hard time being able to prosecute this multistate violence going across State lines. That hasn't changed today. As I said in my testimony, we are in a time that, thanks to Dobbs, the State laws differ dramatically, and people are traveling at increased rates across State lines to both provide and obtain reproductive healthcare. The interstate commerce and the multistate aspect here is even more severe than it was at the time that FACE was enacted. On the question of the disparities, I read the DOJ report with interest. I am an academic, right? I looked at it and I have a lot of questions. My first reaction was, this would not pass peer review, right? I have a lot of questions about, for example, if we look at sentencing disparities, like yes, they are different. Because people committed crimes more than once. FACE specifically provides that each time you commit a crime, the penalties go up, right? People committed different crimes. We would be remiss not to look at the fact that there are at least four District courts that have, in the past two years, looked at this question of was DOJ engaging in selective prosecution. They have squarely been asked that question, including in the Gallagher case, which we have discussed quite a bit. Each time the court has said no, right? Some of the courts have said, look, like, if there is not a disparity, if where we are seeing the violence is against clinics that provide reproductive healthcare, that is not a disparity. The courts have also said there is no malfeasance if law enforcement offices have priorities. People do that. The courts have said post Dobbs, it makes some sense, given that we saw the increase in violence of clinics, that we would see prosecutions against people engaging in that violence. Four District courts have looked at this, and a circuit court actually, and have said there is not biased prosecution here. Ms. Scanlon. It is fair to say that if you look apples to apples, instead of apples to oranges, any disparities can be explained. Ms. Waters. Yes. I think they--I have questions, like I said, right? Ms. Scanlon. Sure. Ms. Waters. When I look at the report, I am not in the particulars of every individual case. Ms. Scanlon. Right. Ms. Waters. Those are the types of questions I would ask. Ms. Scanlon. Thank you for your thoughtful testimony. I yield back. Mr. Roy. Ms. Edl, you are a survivor, and I remind you to turn your microphone on. You are a survivor of a communist concentration camp in former Yugoslavia post-World War II. Is that correct? Ms. Edl. Correct. Mr. Roy. You testified that you have, in significant part, dedicated your life to the cause of defending the innocent unborn since the Roe decision in the subsequent 50 years. Ms. Edl. Correct. Mr. Roy. When you were arrested and then convicted for your actions in Michigan, did you assault anyone? Ms. Edl. No. Mr. Roy. You were present in a protest at this clinic, and you were obstructing people's access? Ms. Edl. Well, I stood in front of the door, yes. Mr. Roy. Now, you were convicted and you faced a sentence of up to 13 years. Is that correct? Ms. Edl. That is correct. Mr. Roy. You are, at the current time, 91? Ms. Edl. I will be 91 on Sunday. Mr. Roy. Well, happy birthday in advance. Ms. Edl. Thank you. Mr. Roy. At the time you were arrested, you were 89? Ms. Edl. Yes. Mr. Roy. Do you think that the use of the FACE Act, and then conspiracy charge under the KKK statute, do you think that is an appropriate sentence for someone, or the potential sentence, because you were not sentenced yet, but up to 13 years, for being present and expressing your views that abortion is in fact murder? Along the lines of my friend from Texas' description of the horrific and barbaric practices of abortion, do you think that an individual should be charged federally with up to 13 years in prison at the age of 89, or at all, for carrying out that activity? Ms. Edl. At any age, murder is taking place in those. Nobody seems to mention that. Murder is taking place inside those clinics. I am sorry, I-- Mr. Roy. No, go ahead. Ms. Edl. It is no different than in Nazi Germany or Yugoslavia, where I was. People would have probably, at that time, protected the law to kill us. Now, those that would have tried to save us would be called heroes. Why? Because we finally recognized that even I, as a child, was a human being then. These babies are human beings from a moment of conception on. Either in the process of growth or in the process of decline. Like I said, we are headed toward killing the elderly. First, they will be identified, they will be vilified, they will be dehumanized and then destroyed. I am trying to do what God calls us to do, protect human life. Not with violence, just placing my body in between the victim and the perpetrator. Mr. Roy. Ms. Edl, you witnessed, with respect to World War II and post-World War II, in Yugoslavia and generally, individuals who were being carried off to be murdered and executed, correct? Ms. Edl. Yes. I heard about it through my father when they took the Jewish families from our town. He was livid. Mr. Roy. You experienced the concentration camp yourself? Ms. Edl. Yes, I did. Mr. Roy. You equate, appropriately in my view, you equate the murder of the innocent unborn, with the murder of those people murdered at the hands of government authority, every bit the same. Ms. Edl. Exactly. Yes. Mr. Roy. Because of that belief, without assaulting anyone, the Federal Government was using the full power of its force to prosecute you, and to put you in jail for up to 13 years, using the full power of the Federal Government to do so. Is that correct? Ms. Edl. That is correct. Mr. Roy. Well, I want to thank you for your life, your life story, your dedication to life, and for fearlessly standing against the power of government being used against your God- given ability to try to stand up in defense of the innocent. In the false name of healthcare, in the false name of healthcare, the murder of the unborn. God bless you for standing up for that. God bless you for your courage. God will bless you when he welcomes you home someday long in the future. I appreciate it very much. Ms. Edl. Thank you. Mr. Roy. I appreciate all the witnesses. I appreciate your testimony. I will recognize the gentlelady for a consent request. Ms. Scanlon. Thank you. I ask unanimous consent to enter into the record, a press release from the DOJ dated August 20, 2024, entitled, ``Seven defendants, including Ms. Edl, convicted of Federal civil rights conspiracy and freedom of access to clinical entrances.'' I also ask unanimous consent to enter into the record, the following statements all dated April 28, 2026, from Reproductive Freedom for All, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the National Abortion Federation, and the Center for Reproductive Rights. I also have a unanimous consent request to enter into the record, a statement from David Gunn Jr. and Wendy Gunn, whose father, Dr. David Gunn, was murdered by an anti-abortion extremist and whose murder helped propel passage of the FACE Act. I would also enter into the record, pages 557 and 558 of Project 2025, detailing the push to repeal the FACE Act. Mr. Roy. Without objection. I would like unanimous consent to enter into the record, I will only ask for the Executive Summary portion of the Department of Justice Report, given the length of the full report being 800 pages. The Executive Summary of the Department of Justice Report outlining the extent to which there was deep coordination between the Department of Justice and abortion activists, and the collusion between the two, as well as lack of reporting to Congress. Mr. Roy. I appreciate that. Anything else from the gentlelady? That concludes today's hearing. We thank the witnesses for appearing before the Subcommittee today. Without objection, all Members will have five legislative days to submit additional written questions for the witnesses or additional materials for the record. Without objection, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:15 p.m., the Subcommittee was adjourned.] All materials submitted for the record by Members of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government can be found at: https://docs.house.gov/Committee/Calendar/ByEvent .aspx?EventID=119234. [all]