Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- BARRIERS TO ENTRY IN THE TECH INDUSTRY FOR DIVERSE ENTREPRENEURS [Senate Hearing 116-279] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 116-279 BARRIERS TO ENTRY IN THE TECH INDUSTRY FOR DIVERSE ENTREPRENEURS ======================================================================= FIELD HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ OCTOBER 3, 2019 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 39-847 PDF WASHINGTON : 2020 COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS ---------- MARCO RUBIO, Florida, Chairman BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, Maryland, Ranking Member JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho MARIA CANTWELL, Washington RAND PAUL, Kentucky JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire TIM SCOTT, South Carolina EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts JONI ERNST, Iowa CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey JAMES M. INHOFE, Oklahoma CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware TODD YOUNG, Indiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois MITT ROMNEY, Utah JACKY ROSEN, Nevada JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri Michael A. Needham, Republican Staff Director Sean Moore, Democratic Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Opening Statements Page Duckworth, Hon. Tammy, a U.S. Senator from Illinois.............. 1 Witnesses Panel 1 DiMenco, Ms. Emilia, President and CEO, Women's Business Development Center, Chicago, IL................................ 3 Kaufman, Ms. Melissa, Founding Executive Director, The Garage at Northwestern University, Evanston, IL.......................... 12 Aglipay, Ms. Geri, Midwest Outreach Manager and National Women's Entrepreneur Manager, Small Business Majority, Chicago, IL..... 18 Panel 2 Meek, Ms. Kimberly, Founder and CEO, Hacha Products, Geneva, IL.. 30 Kollhoff, Ms. Katie, CEO, NUMiX Materials, Inc., Chicago, IL..... 36 Darby, Ms. Patrice, Founder and CEO, GoNanny, Chicago, IL........ 45 Alphabetical Listing Aglipay, Ms. Geri Testimony.................................................... 18 Prepared statement........................................... 20 Responses to questions submitted by Senator Duckworth........ 61 Darby, Ms. Patrice Testimony.................................................... 45 Prepared statement........................................... 47 DiMenco, Ms. Emilia Testimony.................................................... 3 Prepared statement........................................... 7 Responses to questions submitted by Senator Duckworth........ 54 Duckworth, Hon. Tammy Opening statement............................................ 1 Kaufman, Ms. Melissa Testimony.................................................... 12 Prepared statement........................................... 14 Responses to questions submitted by Senator Duckworth........ 58 Kollhoff, Ms. Katie Testimony.................................................... 36 Prepared statement........................................... 38 Responses to questions submitted by Senator Duckworth........ 65 Meek, Ms. Kimberly Testimony.................................................... 30 Prepared statement........................................... 32 Responses to questions submitted by Senator Duckworth........ 64 BARRIERS TO ENTRY IN THE TECH INDUSTRY FOR DIVERSE ENTREPRENEURS ---------- THURSDAY, OCTOBER 3, 2019 United States Senate, Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, Chicago, IL. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:43 p.m., in Harold Washington Public Library, Hon. Tammy Duckworth, presiding. Present: Senator Duckworth. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. TAMMY DUCKWORTH, A U.S. SENATOR FROM ILLINOIS Senator Duckworth. The hearing will come to order. Well, welcome everyone. I want to thank all the witnesses as well as those who are in attendance today. This is an official hearing of the Senate's Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship. With us today are Maggie Moore who is with the the Senate Chairman staff, Senator Rubio's staff. And then also Kevin Wheeler from Senator Cardin, Minority member's staff. I am just going to make some quick remarks as well as introduce everyone and then we will turn it over to our witnesses to each give your prepared statements. Today's hearing is titled ``Barriers to Entry in the Tech Industry for Diverse Entrepreneurs,'' and it will address the challenges that diverse tech entrepreneurs face when starting their businesses. It will come as no surprise to many in this room that there remains a lack of diversity in the lending space, some of which can be traced to a lack of diversity in venture capital investment firms themselves. For instance, a study by The Information found that in 2018, only 1 percent of private venture capital investment firms have black decision makers and only 1.5 percent of those same firms have Hispanic decision makers. That amounts to a total of 7 in 11 individuals, respectively, out of over 700 firms surveyed. Think of that. That is absolutely unacceptable. It is no wonder then that according to a recent report examining nearly 10,000 startups, black founders represent only 1 percent of the venture capital black firm and Latin-x founders only 1.8 percent. Women of all races, too, continue to be underrepresented in this space. While women now represent 15 percent of all partners, and accelerators, and corporate venture firms, up from only 8 percent in 2017, that representation is not keeping pace with women-owned businesses, which grew by 58 percent between 2007 and 2018, and women of color-owned businesses, which grew by an outstanding 163 percent during that same time period. We must better invest in women and minority entrepreneurs, especially here in Illinois. That is why I have joined Senator Cardin in introducing legislation to establish an Office of Emerging Markets within the SBA's Office of Capital Access. This office would be responsible for ensuring SBA's access to capital initiatives and programs--from the Micro-loan program and the Small Business Investment Company program--and it would address the needs of diverse entrepreneurs in new and emerging markets. We also need to make sure there is a strong pipeline for women and minorities to enter the tech industry before beginning their companies, starting at colleges and universities. Last week, I joined my colleague, Senator Hirono, in introducing two bills addressing this very issue. First, the Women and Minorities in STEM Booster Act 2019 would require the National Science Foundation to award competitive grants that support the recruitment and retention of women and minorities in STEM. The second is the STEM Opportunities Act of 2019, which would require Federal agencies to collect more comprehensive demographic data and develop guidance on identifying barriers to the participation advancement of women and minorities in STEM. Investing in these pipelines will ensure a better representation in all tech fields, thereby increasing the likelihood of women starting their own tech companies. But I am here to listen to and learn from you. So I would like to now introduce the first panel of witnesses. Our first witness joining us today is Emilia DiMenco, President and Chief Executive Officer of the Women Business Development Center. Under her direction, the WBDC has expanded its Women's Business Enterprise Certification program to a nine-state Midwest region, opening offices in its five major markets and three additional offices in the Chicago metro region. Since Ms. DiMenco's arrival, the WBDC has dramatically expanded its direct lending program to a pool of nearly $1.7 million. It has also expanded the Latina Business programs, offering bilingual business services, developed an e-learning library, and launched an entrepreneurship program to serve military veterans. Prior to her leadership at the WBDC, Ms. DiMenco spent 30 years at BMO Harris, being elevated to Executive Vice President in the corporate and commercial bank. She also led BMO Harris' Women in Business initiative which under her leadership made BMO Harris the bank of choice for many women business owners. Emilia holds a B.S. and an M.B.A. degree in Finance from DePaul University. Welcome. Our next witness is Melissa Kaufman. Ms. Kaufman is a Founding Executive Director of The Garage at Northwestern. The Garage is a community and physical space for Northwestern students interested in entrepreneurship to learn, iterate, and grow. She is a former Googler, startup executive, and entrepreneur with a decade of experience at consumer technology companies in Silicon Valley. Currently, she is a committee member of Chicago Next, a member of P33, and a venture partner at Chicago Ventures. She was named Chicago's Fierce 50 in 2016 and Crain Tech's 50 in 2018. She received her B.A. in Computer Science from Dartmouth College--a school I did not have the GPA to get into. [Laughter.] Finally, Geri Aglipay--I hope I said that correctly. Ms. Aglipay is the National Manager of Women's Entrepreneurship and Midwest Outreach Manager, overseeing small business majorities outreach education, policy, and advocacy efforts in greater Chicago. These efforts enhance financial capacity and economic security for small business owners, their employees, and their families. She lectures on access to capital and financing small businesses with partners in Government, nonprofits, banks, community organizations, and more, to increase awareness of growth, responsible financing, and how to get funding to grow in certain small business ownership. She is a member of the steering committee for the Illinois Asset Building Coalition and was selected to the Cultivate Women of Color Leadership program. Thank you all so much for taking the time to be here today. And Ms. DiMenco, please get us started. STATEMENT OF EMILIA DiMENCO, PRESIDENT AND CEO, WOMEN'S BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT CENTER Ms. DiMenco. Thank you, Senator Duckworth, for inviting me here today to represent the Women Business Development Center. Founded in 1986, the WBDC launched one of the first Women Business Centers in the country and, as you know, there are over 100 today. In Fiscal Year 2019 to set the stage, the WBDC provided counseling services to over 2,400 business owners and certified over 2,000 women's business enterprises. The certified businesses alone generated more than $21 billion in revenues and employed over 87,000 individuals. And with our assistance, I am proud to share with you that these women were awarded over $400 million in public- and private-sector contracts. For emerging businesses, we also helped our clients source and we directly lent over $3 million in capital. I would like to thank you for taking the time today to learn more about the barriers to entry in the technology industry for diverse entrepreneurs. As you know, it takes immense courage and passion to be an entrepreneur, no matter what demographic boxes you might check, but for women and minority entrepreneurs, it is even more difficult. I am going to share a well-known success story with you and that is a tech business called LuminAid. It was started by Andrea Sreshta and Anna Stork. They were students when they invented the first solar light product to address the disaster relief efforts in Haiti post-earthquake in 2010. So they had $10,000 and in 2011 they launched LuminAid. Today, this Chicago-based company has about 125 employees and it has expanded its product line from disaster relief to everyday living. We have all heard stories of entrepreneurs selling a house or cashing in their 401k to fund their business idea and we have heard of people losing everything in pursuit of their dreams. Entrepreneurs should not have to jeopardize critical, irreplaceable assets to explore innovative ideas that improve the quality of all of our lives and create jobs for people in our communities as the founders of LuminAid did. For certain businesses with high growth potential and sought-after industries, angel investors and venture capitalists are abundant. For most companies, however, innovation and growth, in addition to their personal resources if they had any, are fueled by alternative providers of capital, such as community development and financial institutions, CDFIs, micro lenders, and SBA-supported products offered through traditional avenues. Access to capital is particularly hard for women and minority- owned businesses, both debt and equity capital. And it is essential for them also to start growing and expand their businesses. And as you have already pointed out, with the statistics that you cited in your opening comments, only 2.2 percent of all venture capital funding went to female-founded teams. Black and Latino entrepreneurs received even less, just 1 percent of all startup financing. The only thing that makes these numbers worse is that this is where the innovation is coming. It is coming from women, and particularly women of color, higher than the general market overall. However, it is not just about having access to capital. It is about the right mix of capital. And in the finance world, it is referred to as capitalization. I mentioned the founders of LuminAid. Their company grew capital from a variety of sources, from crowdfunding to their first outside equity investor in 2015. And while LuminAid is a success story, there are many more entrepreneurs struggling to find the right capital. We see this routinely at the WBDC with thousands of hours of the advisory services we provide. To truly address the barriers to entry, we must ensure that the right type and mix of capital is available throughout our communities and, just as important, the right mix of technical assistance to support the entrepreneurs to pursue the funding that they need to grow and sustain their dreams so that their dream doesn't become a nightmare. Business acceleration assistance is needed, and it is more than office space and investors looking for hockey stick opportunities. It is about providing owners with the support they need to grow their business in their best interests so that they earn living wages, create wealth, and they create new jobs for others. There are ample examples for our Government agencies to support innovation and entrepreneurship to accelerate economic growth, and I would like to talk very briefly about two programs. First, the ScaleUp program, which started in 2015. The WBDC was one of eight organizations across the country selected to run a ScaleUp pilot, and we did it in Aurora, Illinois. It was to help companies get to the million dollar mark. And the reason we were looking to accelerate them to the million dollar mark is because that is where the most jobs are created and that is where there is sustainability of the business. This program was so successful that we brought it to low- to moderate-income communities within the city of Chicago. The owners that we served through the ScaleUp program to date have created and retained over 700 jobs and have access equity and debt capital close to $1 million. They identify as 87 percent female, 13 percent male, 47 percent black, and 27 percent Hispanic. The public funding for the ScaleUp program was discontinued in 2017. We have been lucky, and we have been able, with the data we collected in the success of the pilot, we were able to obtain private funding. Expanding programs for ScaleUp-like programs is one way to address the issues of barrier. The second example is for earlier stage companies, the Federal and State technology grants provided by the SBA which provide commercialization support to access Federal grants for entrepreneurs. Through this program, grantees like the WBDC increase access to early stage funding for entrepreneurs and researchers who are traditionally underrepresented in the $2.5 billion annual U.S. Small Business Innovation Research program. In 2017, the WBDC was awarded a FAST grant to reach out and enable diverse communities to pursue similar grants. During the course of the WBDC's two-year program, we helped 60 companies receive technical assistance; 37 of them were women, 9 were African American, 3 were Hispanics, and 3 were veteran-owned businesses, but the most impressive thing is that they realized $4.5 million in capital raised for contracts awarded. This is non-dilutive equity which builds wealth for the business owner and keeps the wealth within the community. Unfortunately, FAST grants, as you know, are not awarded in every State to support equitable opportunity to pursue similar grants. In fact, less than half the States have this program. When we received this grant two years ago, it was the first time in 3 years that it was awarded to the State of Illinois. And since it expired, our State once again is at a disadvantage. Expanding funding for the SBA's FAST program so that every State has access to this program to support its entrepreneurs in pursuing similar grants is another way to address the issues with barriers for innovative tech entrepreneurs. I can give you more examples, but I am not going to do that because I know I am running out of time. I will be finished shortly. We can address barriers to entry by supporting such programs that work but also we can make the programs that we support more effective, and we can do that by cost-effectively expanding geographic reach using a hub and spoke model so that infrastructure, administration, and fundraising for those programs can be done centrally while people that are serving their clients are locally rooted. We can increase operational effectiveness by removing the redundancy in the systems that are the programs that are offered out, and we can make sure that between programs they can communicate with each other. We can address success for programs--we can address that the success of these programs, that the measurement is more impact based versus effort based. And we can embrace and leverage technology to offer virtual services and support. We understand that balancing a budget requires choices, but it is alarming that proving programs designed to help underserved communities have been eliminated or underfunded or operated inefficiently. While the WBDC and many other organizations, some of which are represented here, scramble to continue to support proven programs impacted by budget cuts, we simply cannot do it alone. And that is why forums such as this are so important. By coming out to the community and hearing firsthand what is working and what is not, we can work together to find solutions that are not just wise investments but also effective investments. Despite considerable progress over the years, there is still work to be done to achieve economic parity. Without access to capital, it can be difficult for entrepreneurs to get their business off the ground, let alone grow their business enough to start creating jobs and benefiting their community. At the WBDC, we know that with the right tools and assistance our clients are more successful in securing funding for their businesses, and we also know that there are proven Federal programs that also support diverse entrepreneurs. Today, we ask that you continue to invest in expanding and improving these programs. And again, I thank you for this opportunity, and I am happy to answer any questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. DiMenco follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Duckworth. Thank you. I look forward to your participation in the discussion. Ms. Kaufman, welcome. STATEMENT OF MELISSA KAUFMAN, FOUNDING EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, THE GARAGE AT NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY Ms. Kaufman. Thank you for the opportunity to share The Garage at Northwestern's perspective on barriers to entry in the tech industry for diverse entrepreneurs. I joined Northwestern in 2015 to build, develop, and grow the University's first student center hub for entrepreneurship and innovation called The Garage. The Garage is one of the most unique and modern spaces on our Evanston campus. It is carved out of the second level of a parking structure, and the space is a technology playground with a nod to Silicon Valley and is open to all Northwestern students from any school and any level of study. Most of the early adopters of the space were male students, many of whom were studying engineering. As a former Googler and startup executive in San Francisco, I am no stranger to being the only woman in the room. While I would have hoped I was setting an example as a leader of innovation at Northwestern, I realize that breaking down the barriers to entry to entrepreneurship takes more than opening a new space. From programming to networking opportunities, we have developed ways for empowering female student entrepreneurs to do more than stay on the sidelines in the tech industry, and many of the lessons we have learned from our own operations are applicable to other underrepresented groups. Last year, The Garage launched the Propel program. The program's goals are to promote diversity and inclusion and entrepreneurship by providing networking, mentorship, and financial resources to women. We are aware of how Northwestern's population continues to change. Today, Northwestern student population is 20 percent Pell Grant recipients, 61 percent are funded through financial aid, and over 10 percent are first-generation students, and we hope to expand the Propel program to include other underrepresented groups at Northwestern in the future. First, we believe that it is important for students to see entrepreneurs and leaders that look like them. Whether that is women, people of color, or first-generation students, we have witnessed the impact that a one-on-one in-person conversation can have. We discovered this last year when we took a group of students from the program called Propellers to New York City-- they are on their second trip today. The most transformative moments came from a roundtable at Northwestern's New York office. The result was an open and enlightening dialogue and one student shared the comfort she felt being in a room with other supporting women. This transparent access to more senior women gives students the extra nudge they need to become the future leaders and founders we need. Second, we have learned the impact that individualized encouragement has had for female students. We have found that offering thoughtful communication and paths to funding gives women student founders explicit permission to pursue their entrepreneurial projects. As an example of this, I would like to share the story of Samantha Letscher one of our students. Sam applied to The Garage's full-time summer program for promising student startups with her idea for BOSSY. She shared that a mentor to her, an adjunct male faculty member at Northwestern, told her to apply to the summer program. She was accepted and worked on her idea and went on to win prize money at the end of the summer. She graduated from Northwestern in 2018, and now, BOSSY, her Chicago-based startup, features an online directory listing hundreds of women-owned businesses that consumers can shop from. Sam tells us that she never would have applied to The Garage's program without that push from her professor. She may have never seen the impact that her idea could have had. Sam is still working on BOSSY and currently serves as a mentor for the Propel program, allowing her work to come back full circle. An entrepreneurial mindset is a critical skill set for the future. It teaches students to be adaptable and resilient problem solvers. At The Garage, we are aiming to ensure that all students, regardless of their background, gender, or race are offered the same opportunities to develop this skill set. We are committed to doing this through meaningful networking, equal and fair access to funding opportunities, and individualized encouragement from mentors. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Kaufman follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Duckworth. Ms. Aglipay. STATEMENT OF GERI AGLIPAY, MIDWEST OUTREACH MANAGER AND NATIONAL WOMEN'S ENTREPRENEUR MANAGER, SMALL BUSINESS MAJORITY Ms. Aglipay. Congresswoman Duckworth, thank you again for inviting me to speak with you today about barriers facing diverse entrepreneurs and solutions to address inequities in accessing capital. As a Midwest Outreach Manager and National Women's Entrepreneurship Manager for Small Business Majority, I have seen firsthand how entrepreneurship can create lasting impact for both an individual and their community. At Small Business Majority, our mission is to empower America's entrepreneurs to build up driving and inclusive economy. As part of our work, small business majority promotes a policy agenda that can stimulate our economy and increase prosperity for all, but today I want to focus on two key areas of our agenda to support diverse entrepreneurs. One, expanding access to traditional responsible lending, and two tackling predatory lending practices, understanding that these issues disproportionately impact women and people of color. Despite the importance of small businesses to our economy, small business owners face hurdles accessing capital which you have heard from my previous colleagues as well and in your opening statements but what is more significant is for entrepreneurs of color and borrowers in the community, and women and veterans have trouble more especially accessing that capital. For example, women- and minority-owned businesses receive approximately 45 percent of conventional small business loans. And according to the U.S. minority business development agencies, businesses owned by people of color were three times more likely to be denied a loan than non-minority firms, and when they do access alone, their average loan amount is actually less than half the amount of white-owned businesses. And while women-owned businesses are the fastest growing segment of our economy in the United States, research shows women in general start off with fewer assets and receive inequitable access to both loans and venture capital, and women receive nearly 50 percent less funding than their male counterparts. It is this credit gap that hurts the profitability of these small business owners and inhibits their ability to grow. The small business credit gap will not be overcome without increasing traditional, flexible, and safe financing options. I will cover a few of our key recommendations, but more of them can be found on our website. But first we must expand the SBA loan programs like the 7A loan guarantee program, the 504 loan guarantee program, and the Microloan program. For example, Congress should pass legislation such as the Microloan Expansion Act of 2019, which will increase capital for entrepreneurs. Second, we should make permanent the SBA 7A Community Advantage program, which is a pilot actually set to expire in 2022. This program is a vital resource for mission-based lenders and provides both loans and assistance to underserved markets. We also need to ensure that women and entrepreneurs of color get equitable access to capital by increasing funding for the counseling capital and contracting services provided by Women Business Centers like the WBDC, small business development agencies and centers, and the Minority Business Development Agency. This includes for instance increasing the cap on matching grants for Women Business Centers. Additionally, we must address predatory lending practices in small business lending. There is innovation in small business financing, and it is making it faster and easier for people to borrow, but this innovation must be built on transparency and fairness. This is needed because alternative financing and brokers operate in an almost unregulated space, which leaves small business institutes vulnerable to predatory practices. While there are some funding institutions that are fair disclosing their terms and rates, many lenders are exploiting and offering desperate entrepreneurs predatory loan products. Loan terms are often unclear and not disclosed and borrowers later discover they are locked into hidden fees, higher interest rates than anticipated, and other unfavorable loan terms, which leaves them on the hook for much more than they expected, and the result is many lose their personal assets and business as well. While the Federal Truth in Lending Act does offer some protection to consumers from this exploitation, the law itself actually does not apply to small business owners. This is why we would like to see Congress enact legislation extending the Federal Truth in Lending Act disclosure requirements to small business loans and credit products as was done in the State of California last year. Our research shows small businesses strongly support this type of regulation. Second, any policy should promote small business lending practices that are responsible by lenders and brokers as outlined in the small business borrowers bill of rights, specifically by requiring transparency around rates and terms, including annual percentage rate, and curbing the practices of rates such as double-dipping among other issues. We would like to see Congress pass the Small Business Lending Fairness Act, a bipartisan legislation that was introduced but this legislation would prohibit confessions of judgment. Confessions of judgments are clauses where borrowers agree in advance to waive their right to contest any dispute with the lender, which often costs them their entire savings. In closing, we know that small businesses inject economic vitality into their communities. However, they need the proper resources and public policies to support them, with attention to entrepreneurs who struggle to access resources and economic security most, namely women and entrepreneurs of color. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on these important issues for small businesses here in Illinois and across the country, and I am happy to answer any questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Aglipay follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Thank you all for being here. Let us begin with my first question on--this is for all the witnesses. Each of you has spoken about the work you do supporting entrepreneurs at all levels, from enhancing access to capital for diverse business owners to helping students and entrepreneurs develop their tech startups and make their businesses successful. Based on your experiences, could each of you starting with. Ms. DiMenco speak about what you believe to be the most critical investment the Federal Government can make to help women and minorities enter the tech industry and gain better access to capital and support. If you just choose one or two things, what would be like the most immediate thing that you think we should be able to do at the Federal Government, and then what do you think would be the most impactful? Ms. DiMenco. There are two things that inhibit all entrepreneurs including tech entrepreneurs because you do not have collateral to secure the loan. Fifty percent of the problem is there isn't sufficient quality technical assistance. So an innovator as creative as they are might not have the business and financial acumen to understand capitalization and understand how you talk to a senior lender, how you talk to a venture capitalist, how you talk to a mezzanine player of some type. So that is half the battle has to do with technical assistance. We work long hours with the financial institutions in Chicago as they send us entrepreneurs that are not prepared to talk to them. Sometimes it is nothing more than helping them pull the package together that the bank requires. So half the problem is technical assistance. The other half of the problem is there aren't sufficient alternative providers of capital that address the issues that startup entrepreneurs who do not have connections and who do not have resources need. So, for example, in the Chicagoland area, there are a lot of community development financial institutions, but there are few that I can count on one hand that are CDFIs that serve small business. So helping to fuel more CDFIs and provide alternative types of products to address the issues and it is not high-interest loans is the other half of the problem. So problem one has to do with the entrepreneurs not provided. Problem two is there aren't enough products to fuel the innovation that we need to revitalize communities. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Ms. Kaufman. Ms. Kaufman. So I think the top two things, the first is really around how you can support diverse entrepreneurs. Both of my co-witnesses have talked a lot about some of the funding opportunities, but for me, it breaks down to two things. You need funding and you also need connections to other people through a network. Both of my co-witnesses speak to the funding piece and/or any opportunities around grants, but I think that there may be opportunities to elevate some of these diverse entrepreneurs. I truly do believe that more younger founders need to see people who look like them in leadership roles so anything that the Government can do to invite them to DC or elevate them or give them a platform so that they can be seen by others would be very important. The second thing is that there are a number of great things going on in the private sector that I think the Government can put some backing behind. For example, Melinda Gates has pledged $1 billion to gender equality and I think that that is a wonderful initiative that could use more support. Senator Duckworth. So when you talk about networks, are you--Ms. DiMenco certainly when you think about, where do the other tech startups that are run by men, where are they getting their access capital? Some of it is, and you sort of touched on this, personal relationships, networks, and the kind of things that you are talking about. Beyond just seeing a role model, but you know, if you don't know somebody who doesn't know somebody, then you don't have someone to invest in your startup the ways of other more traditional, you know males get that investment. Am I touching on that correctly? Ms. Kaufman. So, yes, you don't know what you don't know, right, and in certain communities and in certain networks that you might grow up in or live in you have access to people that can help you. But there is another issue and it addresses, for people like you. If we admit it or not, we have an affinity for people that look like us. There is a comfort level. There is a trust. There is a belief, and we need to ensure that those that are making decisions look more like our communities. In corporate America, it starts at the board level. You don't advance women and minorities when the board doesn't reflect that. The same is true of venture capitalists, right? They all look a certain way and there are not bad people. They just--we all have that affinity. So it is really, really important that we encourage diversity as we monitor, guide more of these venture capitalists that are coming together. We just need to encourage more of that, and I think it will naturally happen. Senator Duckworth. Ms. Aglipay. Ms. Aglipay. You know to add to that I think that the other challenge is why you see more men accessing the capital, venture capital is that simply women start off with less assets. You know, they start off with less assets, so it is difficult for them to find the capital to begin with when men have a little bit more in their wealth to start a business. And Emilia is right. You don't know what you don't know. Hence for us one of the points that we are advocating for is for increased appropriations for women business centers and Small Business Development Centers. If you go to many of the SBDCs and WBCs, you begin to see and you get the training and technical assistance by people who look like them because I believe these centers actually aim to have a diverse and inclusive staffing so that they can provide the assistance people need to navigate how to start the business, how to talk to different sorts of capitalization regarding loans, venture capital, or even a broker, how to navigate what type of funding you need, when do you need to use a line of credit versus when you need to take a term loan out. So that definitely is one of it. It is the value in it, funding the technical assistance centers and the resources through the SBA is incredibly important and significant. And so we advocate for more of that funding to go towards Women Business Centers and Small Business Development Centers. Not only that, I think one thing that people tend to forget is they are quality assistance with certified trained staff, and it is free for people. I could jump on a flight to San Francisco, Silicon Valley, go to the SBDC there and it would be fine, and people don't know enough about those assistance that they can get through the technical assistance through the SBA. Second part, the capital startup. As I said, women do start off with less than men. You know, they are not connected to the technical assistance that they need. Part of it is because we do need to fund WBCs and SBDCs more. But also they are turning to these alternative ways that--we need more flexible capital like for the CDFIs but unfortunately we are competing in a space in the financial world where there is a ton and a plethora of online funders. And some of them may be great but some are not, and because it is not regulated right now by the Federal Government, many times entrepreneurs, especially women and owners of color are turning to the quick online sources for funding for capital and that sets them a step back into developing their businesses. Many of them are turning to merchant cash advances or they see a company that is on the New York Stock Exchange and assume that because the company is on the New York Stock Exchange, it must be regulated. It is not. Or they will see a celebrity person from a show who is a businessman promoting a small business lending product, which in fact is not regulated. One of the things here in Chicago when we work with our partners like WBDC and others is we often hear business owners of color and women are falling prey to these quick cash capital products as well which are unregulated. Fees can go as high as 400 percent and they oftentimes want access to your bank accounts and cash statements for immediate payment even if you have no sales for that day. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Ms. DiMenco. I would like to respectfully clarify something Geri said who I admire very much. We do not provide free services. They are paid for by our tax dollars. We just do not charge for them. [Laughter.] Senator Duckworth. Well, this gets to my next question, Ms. DiMenco. You mentioned that the WBDC has had to raise private dollars to continue programs such as ScaleUp, which is now discontinued, and FAST grants, for example. And then those are not always awarded in every State. How successful have you been raising these private dollars to continue these programs even after they were discontinued or did you not receive those dollars for--having received them for 2020, for example. Ms. DiMenco. So as it relates to SCALA, the pilot that was funded by the Small Business Administration gave us the data and gave us the--because it was targeted to businesses that were already established, but it was for growth, we were able to attract corporate dollars for that. But if not for the pilot and not for the data, the group, the success, and the growth from that program, we would not have been able to raise that money. Corps were delighted to have funding for 2020. Corporate funding is not always sustainable with changes in CEO levels. The average life of a CEO used to be 7 to 10 years now it is 3 to 5 years and that results in priorities changing. So what is great about public funding is it helps us at an earlier level, and it is more sustainable. Regarding the FAST funding, it ended on the 30th of September and we are in pursuit of private funding, but we have not achieved--we have not gotten private funding for 2020 yet. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Ms. Kaufman, giving your experiences as a successful entrepreneur business woman working in Silicon Valley and on Chicago, what key differences do you see between here and the Bay Area, and are there things that can be done differently or better either here or there to promote greater diversity in tech? Ms. Kaufman. So my observations of over the past four years of being here is that culturally we are much more risk-averse in Chicago than in the Bay Area. And I mean that at a societal level meaning if an individual wants to pursue an entrepreneurial path, that may mean me raising an eyebrow and not ending frowned upon in some circles. Similarly with my students at Northwestern who have been I would say kind of programmed up to achieve, they think that there are certain jobs with titles that lead to success and they are kind of looking for the next stepping stone. So kind of breaking that down for some of our top-achieving students and helping them understand that there are other paths in life. And I also see it when it comes to the funding standpoint, which is that startups in Chicago tend to have to prove themselves in their revenue model much more so to receive venture capital funding versus in the Bay Area you can get an idea in a napkin funded. Senator Duckworth. So do you think there is a difference though? I mean, we are talking about between minority- and women-owned businesses. I mean the statistics also said that the growth in Black owned entrepreneur firms rose 168 percent over the last several years. So I think that there is a desire, the ability, and the passion to take a shot at it among the minority community and I think sometimes it might even be--this is just me speaking--I always feel like there is a sense of no one else is going to give you a job, I might as well try and start something myself. Is that not carrying over into tech? Is that what is happening where you see entrepreneurs---- Ms. Kaufman. I think so. I think those stats most likely apply to--when you look at all new businesses, probably the vast majority of them are small businesses. We are not thinking of the big technology companies that you hear of. I think we have seen more women taking companies and taking them public over the last maybe five years. I cannot think of a woman of color who has taken a company public in the same period of time. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Ms. Aglipay, do you want to say anything about entrepreneurship among women of color in terms of whether tech or general entrepreneurs with the small businesses? Ms. Aglipay. Yes. I mean, I think for women of color what it is, is it speaks to what Melissa was saying regarding the lack of networks as well for providing the assistance that you need not only from mentors but also peer mentors, too. When I speak with a lot of women of color who are entrepreneurs, I find that they can't find it in the mainstream so they are informally creating their own networks, you know, with one another so that they could feel more supported simply because the added fact that they happen to be a person of color and are facing barriers that most other--if you are not a person, you are not sympathetic to the challenges that you have wondering if you didn't get that loan or you didn't get that funding from your pitch because you are also a woman and on top of that woman of color. So it is also dealing with the gender, cultural norms there within accessing capital and getting that network that you need. I believe there needs to be more funding to support women of color mentorship networks which would be fantastic if we accorded that to Women Business Centers to help foster more formal networks across the country for women in the tech field to bring that there and to find ways to leverage their assets and navigate capital, too. So there is a, trying to say, you know, a colorism factor for women entrepreneurs who are of color that impacts the way that they view how they start their businesses and the fact also many of them, women and women of color, start with less assets, too. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Well, I want to thank each of the witnesses from the first panel. We have a limited amount of time. I could keep on going, but this is not the last time we are going to discuss these issues. And so I want to thank the first panel for being here and for your participation, and we are going to take a couple minutes and switch to panel number two. Thank you. We will move on to our next panel. As you are settling in, I will start introductions in the interest of time. We have Ms. Kimberly Meek, Ms. Katie Kollhoff, and Ms. Patrice Darby. Ms. Meek is Founder and CEO of Hacha Products Corporation, and its subsidiary, SolvePFAS Group. Hacha Products is an industrial product distributer specializing in products and services used in facilities maintenance, repair by operations, and is a certified woman- owned business enterprise--minority business enterprise, an economically disadvantaged, woman-owned small business. SolvePFAS is a vertically integrated laboratory and data company dedicated to testing and tracking PFAS in the Nation's water supply. Ms. Meek has 30 years of experience as a business owner and has been able to use a portion of her business profits to fund local before and after school meal programs. Next we have Ms. Katie Kollhoff. Ms. Kolhoff is a Co-Founder and CEO of NUMiX Materials, an ion exchange materials company specializing in the removal of heavy metals from complex liquid streams complemented by the recycling of valuable metals within the domestic supply chain. She leads a team at NUMiX, manages customer and stakeholder engagement, as well as develops and executes business strategy. She is a chemical engineer with 15 years of experience in chemical process performance analysis, risk management, and hazardous chemical operations. Finally, Ms. Patrice Darby. Ms. Darby is the Founder and CEO of GoNanny, a child care management and logistics platform that provides child care solutions for families, child center programs, and institutions. Through her digital platform, she has paired families with over 200 childcare professionals who are vetted through the proprietary system she and her team created. Ms. Darby has over a decade of childcare experience and is committed to helping families develop more balanced lives by merging childcare with technology. Welcome to each of you and we will begin with Ms. Meek. STATEMENT OF KIMBERLY MEEK, FOUNDER AND CEO, HACHA PRODUCTS Ms. Meek. Thank you. Well, good afternoon, Senator Duckworth. I am honored to share my testimony with you today. Technology startup success rate data are commonly accepted but they never tell the whole story. Minority and women participation rates are far lower to begin with and failure rates are far higher. Thus for diverse technology entrepreneurs, a large percentage of an already small sample size fail. Mere survival is considered a success but to truly succeed, to thrive and grow, access to tech talent and financial capital are critical. For any startup to survive requires sound business planning, access to market, and a well-developed solution. With a toehold in the market, the entrepreneur's own efforts can sustain the business indefinitely with cash flow. Diverse entrepreneurs in Illinois are fortunate to have several resources available, including the Women Business Development Center and the Chicago Minority Supplier Development Council. These organizations have proven invaluable to diverse entrepreneurs and established businesses including mine. But for a tech startup to grow and thrive beyond the first years requires multi-discipline strategic and tactical planning, a unique or superior solution, access to broader markets, and especially talent and financial capital. Again, diverse entrepreneurs benefit from resources like the WBDC and the CMSDC for planning and market access, but the war for talent in a robust economy and private capital in a bidding war for retiring Baby Boomers businesses leave diverse tech entrepreneurs with few options. Allow me to illustrate with my own company, Hacha Products Corporation, founded in 2015 with my own personal funds and with help from the WBDC and the CMSDC. In early 2019, we launched a subsidiary, SolvePFAS, funded with internal retained earnings. We had an extraordinary opportunity and a business model to capture it. SolvePFAS is a vertically integrated laboratory and data company dedicated to testing and tracking per- and polyfluorinated alkyl substances in the Nation's water supply. PFAS are a large group of manmade chemicals that are fire resistant, and repel oil, stains, grease, and water. Introduced in 1945, they were used for decades in fire-fighting foams, fabric and carpet stain repellants, nonstick cookware, waterproof clothing and shoes, fast food wrappers, personal care products, and many other consumer goods. And though they have been gradually, voluntarily phased out of U.S. manufacturing processes, imported products are likely to still contain them. These chemicals are very persistent, meaning they do not break down easily and they are found at low levels throughout the environment in air, water, and soil. The Federal and State Departments of Human Health Services have found them in a significant number of drinking water supplies across the United States and fully expect to find more. PFAS exposure poses a significant harm to human health. Unfortunately, they bioaccumulate in human tissue over many years and remain forever. The CDC reports that PFOA, the toxic chemical compound used to make Teflon, is now in the blood of 99 percent of Americans. The SolvePFAS market is quantifiable and growing rapidly. Our solution is unique and compelling, developed in collaboration with five world class research institutions, the University of Chicago's Pritzker School of Molecular Engineering, The Center for Data and Computing, and Searle Chemistry Laboratory, as well as Argonne National Laboratory, and The University of Illinois at Chicago Mass Spectrometry Laboratory, and with best in class industry leader Agilent Technologies. We have built a dedicated product laboratory in Chicago as a means to an end to generate PFAS data. This issue is fast becoming a reoccurring topic in C-suite and boardroom discussions. Ultimately, we enable risk management through data for every manufacturer that uses water-based operations. With a promising market and a unique solution, SolvePFAS is primed for stellar growth. And yet, two systemic risk factors threaten access to talent and affordable financial capital. Historically, minority and women entrepreneurs have struggled for even proportional access. Without it, chances for profitable, sustainable growth are greatly reduced at the onset. My recommendation, an endowed, proven boots on the ground organization with discretionary funds and the authority to deploy it to finance growth. No one is closer to diverse entrepreneurs than the WBDC and the CMSDC. No one understands the strategies and hacks better than they do. Senator Duckworth, I sincerely appreciate your interest in tech entrepreneurs like me. Thank you for inviting me here today, and for your time and consideration. [The prepared statement of Ms. Meek follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Ms. Kollhoff. STATEMENT OF KATIE KOLLHOFF, CEO, NUMIX MATERIALS, INC. Ms. Kollhoff. Good afternoon and thank you for the opportunity to testify today. Thank you, Senator Duckworth, for your time and your interest in entrepreneurship, and hard work on behalf of the people of Illinois and the United States alike. We really appreciate that, and we appreciate your representation. My name is Katie Kollhoff. I am a Co-Founder and the CEO of an early stage, deep technology company, NUMiX Materials. My co-founders and I are developing more efficient ways to remove dissolved heavy metal contamination from water to enable better water treatment complemented by concentration and recycling of valuable metals within the domestic supply chain of those same metals. Using the power of chemistry, we extract those offending metals using less time, less material, and creating less waste than conventional processes. The problem we are tackling affects every industry and every individual and solving it in the face of a changing climate becomes increasingly important as we necessarily move toward climate resilience. In our company, we approach our technical issues scale-up and testing with optimism, though we have faced a number of challenges in our short life--we are about a year and a half old at this point. While our path is unique, many entrepreneurs face similar struggles. Starting a new business in the United States is difficult by any measure. Starting a technology-based business increases the complexity, and since technology is commonly understood as software, the uphill battle for physical science companies like ours is yet again steeper. We recognize three major barriers as we work toward meeting our business and technical goals, and the first of those we have heard a lot about so far today, access to capital. The second representation, mentorship, and education. And the third is affordable healthcare. First, access to capital is widely recognized as a challenge. I have a lot of the same statistics that have already been mentioned here today so I am glad to see that that work checks out. Most adventure-backed firms are software firms. In the private investment space, outsized returns are expected within the life of the fund, which is typically 10 years. Compared to software companies, which can scale exponentially given the virtual nature of their delivered product, private investment is scarcer to come by for transformational deep science-based businesses. Of that private investment, we see only patient capital from philanthropic funds and wealthy individuals willing to invest in step changes that will promote resilience in the face of climate change and allow humans to sustain life on earth. By way of an example, as China will no longer take our recycling, what do we do with our waste at the end of its life when we can no longer land apply the biosolids from our water treatment processes because of PFAS contamination or lead content? What do we do with it? Where do the physical materials to manufacture the next generation of mobile phones and computers, internet of things, sensors, batteries, electrical systems, solar panels, where do those materials come from? How do we make food last longer? The goal of waste reduction and resource preservation is frequently squarely at odds with the revenue generation model for VC-backed high-growth companies, as the sustainability field is seeking to decrease the overall materials consumed, not increase it by attractive multipliers year-over-year as VC requires. These step changes must come from paradigm shifts in the way we source, create, use, and dispose of physical materials, with chemistry at the very heart of our problems and our solutions. Second, I would like to address representation. As an example of barrier to entry in venture capital for diverse investors is also quite high. Around 8 percent of partners at the largest VC firms are women, and African- American and Latino individuals comprise less than 1 percent. So then it is not really surprising that the entrepreneur pool mirrors the VC pool as we heard from--heard earlier that investors tend to fund founders who look like them. Meanwhile women comprise 47 percent of the workforce in the United States, yet they hold less than 25 percent of the jobs in the STEM industries, with the gap widening at the top where women make up just 2 percent of tech CEOs, and again generally in software technology. We need inclusive communities tackling the biggest problems and I believe this starts with early education focusing on real-world problem-solving. Finally, access to affordable healthcare is perhaps the most immediate barrier facing entrepreneurs as they decide to take the leap into entrepreneurship. There is even a name for it--entrepreneurship block. For an early stage company, a medical emergency for an uninsured or underinsured co-founder would spell the end of the enterprise. Without private investment, without independent wealth, the healthcare system in the United States exists as a significant barrier to technical entrepreneurship. I thank you again for the opportunity to share our story. I urge you to continue inviting experts to testify. I urge you to continue hosting focus groups with entrepreneurs to hear the issues that we face, and to continue listening to the people who are stubbornly focused on making dreams into reality and helping those around them along the way. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Kollhoff follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Ms. Darby. STATEMENT OF PATRICE DARBY, FOUNDER AND CEO, GONANNY Ms. Darby. Thank you so much, Ms. Duckworth, for giving me the opportunity to speak here today. I really appreciate it. As a second-generation childcare expert and entrepreneur, I was equipped early on with the capacity and willingness to develop, organize, and manage a business within the childcare industry. This grew as a lifestyle of solving massive problems and creating timeless impact. I remember studying the historical development of childcare and I was intrigued. However, I was also faced with the realization, in order for childcare businesses to be sustainable over the next two to three decades, these businesses must merge with technology. This led me to building a high-growth tech startup. GoNanny is a childcare management and logistics platform providing childcare solutions for families, child-centered businesses, and institutions. We have built a proprietary vetting system that has validated the dependability, safety, and trustworthiness of over 200 childcare professionals. We have utilized technology to develop a safe infrastructure with a proven and tested methodology for executing short incremental child care and safe pick-ups and drop-offs seamlessly. Now, we are equipping childcare institutions with this technology infrastructure as a tool for creating sustainability and economic growth for all small businesses within the child care sector. I share this background because there is no coincidence to the structure of our business model. When I started this journey in tech, I realized the largest barrier to my success was access to the capital necessary for a high-growth tech startup--that is a different kind of capital. In 2016, I took my business plan to Chase Bank, the Small Business Administration, Accion Chicago, and the Women Business Development Center in search of getting capital to launch my business. I was turned down by all four. Why? Because I did not have collateral. I just came out of college. I also did not have credit. I never started building my credit and so I was rejected. That was very challenging, despite the fact that these institutions publicized funding for small businesses who could not get approved by traditional lenders. I needed customers to validate my model but how do you get customers without the funding to build the platform? The only solution I had was to sell everything I owned, move out of my condo, and move into my sister's apartment. I slept on the floor for eight months. And I used that funding to start my company GoNanny. That was my startup capital. Through humility, grit, and determination I eventually created a demo. I took my product to downtown Chicago and I stood on the corner of Wells and North Avenue. Parents who walked by tried my demo and some signed up for the service. I gained valuable customer discovery and validation. Quickly after, I had my first paying customers. GoNanny experienced year after year growth by 240 percent via word of mouth, and the influx was greater than our infrastructure could support. Once again, I found myself in need of capital in order to create the infrastructure necessary to scale my business. I reached out to various funds, and institutions in order to nourish my robust growth. This time with renewed confidence as my business concept had been proven with significant revenue induction and returning customers. This is our second year of business and we have--over 80 percent of our customers have returned for the second year and 45 percent have increased their usage by 20 percent or more. Unfortunately, despite all that I had accomplished and regardless of projected growth, I still have yet to receive the necessary funding that a high-growth tech start-up requires. Funds like Accion Chicago and even the Entrepreneurs of Color Fund are designed to create access to capital for minority companies but still adhere to a traditional lending structure, or the process is extremely challenging, creating an additional barrier to entry, thereby eliminating the majority that it was designed to help. My hope is that the information gathered here today creates a system that removes these barriers to entry based upon feedback from entrepreneurs like myself and others represented here today. [The prepared statement of Ms. Darby follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Duckworth. Thank you. Maybe some of the folks on the first panel can help you. [Laughter.] Well, thank you all for your opening statements. To begin this panel, I would like to hear from everyone. Each of you discussed your own unique challenges to beginning and growing your business, but one persistent hurdle that all of you have is finding access to capital. Can each of you, starting with Ms. Meek, discuss how you overcame or are working through that hurdle, and you just touched on some of this, and what steps the Federal Government can take to make sure that tech business owners in the future have an easier time finding the sources of funding that you need. Ms. Meek. Thank you, Senator Duckworth. I would say my first barrier is that it is not only capital, it is not only financial capital, it is human capital as well. I have been fortunate with the WBDC to introduce me in a network and actually always seem to open doors with me. I have been very fortunate that through the WBDC, I met the University of Chicago, then went to Argonne Labs, and I went to UIC, and that whole process is just to me as important as financial capital, and it exposed and really changed the direction of my company based on finding this problem and then seeking a solution. So I would say the WBDC helped overcome the networking barrier that you speak of. As it relates to financial capital, the WBDC has given me opportunities to the various grants and various loans at times. But as a startup, it is difficult. I have been able, you know, to fund this myself. Do I see an opportunity? I think I am in a market where it is so important and I am so committed, and I know that it is water. If I don't get someone's attention about water, then I am doing something really wrong and that is how I look at it. And PFAS, I feel like I am now the spokesperson for Teflon pans that, you know, tell them probably they do not want me working for them. But I know that what I am doing is relevant, so if it is relevant, all those barriers--I mean I am speaking to a person who can overcome the obstacles. What am I going to say? That is part of life and they can never stop us. So it is just, to me, it is a step that I just have to keep going and that if the financial is not there, I am going to figure out how to make it there. Either that you know, we are picking up some business through opportunity. And it seems like everybody wants to give me money when I start making money. When you don't need it, I always can get money from a bank. [Laughter.] Senator Duckworth. Ms. Kollhoff, how did you find access to capital? How did you get that access? Ms. Kollhoff. Philanthropic grants and Government-supported grants have been key for us so far. We have been fortunate to earn support from the Department of Energy's competitions such as the now inactive Clean Tech University prize and the Argonne National Lab-embedded entrepreneurship program called Chain Reaction Innovations, which provides both funding and access to laboratory space and resources for companies developing physical technologies to take from the bench scale to market ready. We have participated in the Hallmark National Science Foundation Innovation Corps program, which trained scientists on developing commercial opportunities for deep technologies. We have also received very early stage support from philanthropic-backed organizations such as VentureWell. None of these granting organizations has taken equity in our company unlike many accelerator and incubator models, allowing us to maintain control of our own company at its earliest stage and preserve valuable equity for future fundraising and partnership events. These funding opportunities have ranged from $2,000 to $220,00, providing the seed capital to de-risk the physical technology and further develop their commercial opportunity. And though we have not yet--we have not received funding through the Small Business Innovation Research program yet--I hope. It also comprises a key part of the funding landscape for deep tech companies and note that the amount available through each of those varies by the agency, and when budgets are cut for certain agencies, the impact on associated entrepreneurship efforts is also deeply affected. For instance, BPA's program is the smallest of all the agencies and that is where I think our solutions are the best so that is pretty disheartening but also an amazing set of programs that are vital to deep technology companies. Senator Duckworth. Thank you. So, Ms. Darby, what are you looking at now that you sold all your stuff the first year and have nothing else to sell? [Laughter.] Ms. Darby. Yes, so we are, you know, speaking with investors. The challenge with that is for my background, I don't have any investors that are connected to me, you know, in my family's sector. So it is really, you know, about networking and getting more introductions. If people don't know you and you are not connected to their network, they don't trust you and you never get that meeting. It doesn't matter how much revenue you brought in that year. And so that is a big challenge. I was also looking, you know, at funds that the State and the City of Chicago offer and one of them was the fact that Chase Bank partnered with Accion Chicago and introduced the Color Fund, the Color for Entrepreneur Fund. And so I actually reached out to that fund and was told that it is just that you go through the regular system, and that regular system already denied me. So that doesn't create access for people of color, even though they are using it, you know, as a tool that should. And so I think for us we are looking at, you know, is there any funding out there for our company, our tech startup that is supposed to be bringing in $3 million next year because we closed a YWCA, Metropolitan Chicago contract and it is for the next four years. And so I think, you know, I am trying to be strategic about how do we, how do I find a mix of funding? Is there access to funding from the State that could subsidize, offset, you know, giving up some equity to investors. Ms. Kollhoff. And can I add to that quickly? And so I think that there are investment vehicles with State funds, but they are often managed by typical VC firms who don't invest in people like us, generally speaking. And so that is pretty frustrating to note also that you know, even if there appears to be a mandate, it doesn't necessarily feel like that is actually getting through. Senator Duckworth. Ms. Darby, I am going to follow up with you after the hearing. We are running short on time. We could go on, I could go on for quite a while, but I have time I think just for one more question. And this will be for Ms. Kollhoff. We know that the Small Business Innovation program is one of the most valuable Federal programs for developing science-based companies. Its goal is to stimulate tech innovation to increase private sector commercialization and encourage participation and innovation by small businesses across the country. In your testimony you put forth ideas on how to improve the SBIR program that go further than simply expanding it, which we can all agree would be beneficial to keeping the United States competitive in the global economy. Could you describe some of these improvements and how they would help companies like yours access that critical funding? What some of the improvements could be? Ms. Kollhoff. Yes, I would be happy to. So some of those thoughts, I think deep matching funds here in the State of Illinois would be incredibly useful to keeping businesses here in Illinois. I know a number of other States have those and they are incredibly valuable since the SBIR program is already selecting the most competitive companies. It is a good filtering mechanism as well. I think that it would be interesting to provide healthcare coverage for clusters of entrepreneurs including SBIR recipients, other Federal funding recipients, or companies younger than five years old. And then, I think it would be valuable to allow a portion of the SBIR total to be used for a commercialization or business person, if that person is a part of that inclusive community that we are hoping to build more of. So right now there can be no allowance of a salary for non- research personnel but allowing a diverse entrepreneur to take a commercialization role as part of that SBIR funding would be incredibly useful. Senator Duckworth. Okay. Thank you. Do either, Ms. Darby, Ms. Meek, want to add anything to some of those recommendations? Ms. Meek. No. I agree. Senator Duckworth. We are out of time. I do apologize for the short nature of this, but this will not be the last one of these hearings. And I do want to thank both panels of witnesses for coming forward and sharing your stories with us. We will be following up with this when I go back, week after next. I will get back to the Small Business committee and share my experiences with my colleagues, and hopefully we can get back to trying to fix some of the Federal programs and try to find ways to address access for women- and minority-owned business. Thank you again. And with that this hearing stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 3:57 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]