Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- FINANCIAL SECURITY IN RETIREMENT: INNOVATIONS AND BEST PRACTICES TO PROMOTE SAVINGS [Senate Hearing 116-552] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 116-552 FINANCIAL SECURITY IN RETIREMENT: INNOVATIONS AND BEST PRACTICES TO PROMOTE SAVINGS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ FEBURARY 6, 2019 __________ Serial No. 116-02 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 47-615 PDF WASHINGTON : 2022 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine, Chairman TIM SCOTT, South Carolina ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania RICHARD BURR, North Carolina KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York MARTHA McSALLY, Arizona RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut MARCO RUBIO, Florida ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri DOUG JONES, Alabama MIKE BRAUN, Indiana KYRSTEN SINEMA, Arizona RICK SCOTT, Florida JACKY ROSEN, Nevada ---------- Sarah Khasawinah, Majority Acting Staff Director Kathryn Mevis, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins, Chairman.......... 1 Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Ranking Member 3 PANEL OF WITNESSES Hon. Gene L. Dodaro, Comptroller General of The United States, Washington, D.C................................................ 5 John Scott, Retirement Savings Project Director, The Pew Charitable Trusts, Washington, D.C............................. 6 Denis St. Peter, President and Chief Executive Officer, CES, Inc., Brewer, Maine............................................ 8 Linda K. Stone, Fellow Volunteer, Women's Institute for a Secure Retirement (WISER), Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania.................... 9 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Hon. Gene L. Dodaro, Comptroller General of The United States, Washington, D.C................................................ 35 John Scott, Retirement Savings Project Director, The Pew Charitable Trusts, Washington, D.C............................. 79 Denis St. Peter, President and Chief Executive Officer, CES, Inc., Brewer, Maine............................................ 89 Linda K. Stone, Fellow Volunteer, Women's Institute for a Secure Retirement (WISER), Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania.................... 96 Statements for the Record The Bipartisan Policy Center's Commission on Retirement Security and Personal Savings........................................... 105 FINANCIAL SECURITY IN RETIREMENT: INNOVATIONS AND BEST PRACTICES TO PROMOTE SAVINGS ---------- WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 6, 2019 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:30 a.m., in Room 562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Susan M. Collins, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Collins, McSally, Hawley, Braun, Rick Scott, Casey, Blumenthal, Jones, Sinema, and Rosen. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR SUSAN M. COLLINS, CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The Committee will come to order. Good morning. Ten thousand Americans are turning 65 every day. It used to be that this was the traditional age of retirement, but today, as this Committee has examined in previous hearings, many older Americans continue to work well past the age of 65. Some of those who are healthy enough want to continue working because of the personal satisfaction it brings. Others, however, continue to work because they simply have no choice. They cannot afford to retire. The Center for Retirement Research estimates that there is a $7.8 trillion gap between what Americans have saved for retirement and what they will actually need. As Americans live longer, the risk that they will outlive their savings only increases. Perhaps most startling are studies that show just how little Americans have in savings. According to the AARP, the typical working household in the State of Maine has just $3,000 saved for retirement. In fact, one out of two Americans has less than $1,000 in savings. For those living paycheck to paycheck, it can be difficult to cover the heating bill or afford much-needed medications, much less save for the future. For many, saving for retirement seems out of the question. I am also particularly concerned about the impact of those who take time out from the workforce to care for others on their retirement security. We know that time spent caring for loved ones can have implications for lifetime earnings and retirement savings. We are on the verge of a national crisis. We did not get here overnight. Over the past several decades, employment patterns in America have changed, creating new opportunities in some ways, and in other ways challenging the notion of retirement as our parents and our grandparents knew it. Three emerging retirement trends, in particular, warrant our attention. First, traditional pensions outside of the public sector are rare these days as employers have shifted away from employer-based ``defined benefit'' plans to ``defined contribution'' plans, such as 401(k)'s. This means that individuals are becoming increasingly responsible for their own retirement planning and are assuming more of the risk. Second, Americans who look to employer-sponsored plans are finding that many companies simply do not offer this option. In Maine, about 46 percent of all private sector employees work for an employer that does not offer a retirement plan. Third, it is increasingly clear that Social Security should not be the only source of retirement income that retirees count on to sustain their current standard of living. Nationwide, the Social Security Administration notes that among its beneficiaries, 48 percent of married couples and 69 percent of unmarried individuals receive half of their income for retirement, or more, from Social Security. Many seniors in my State rely almost solely on Social Security to cover their monthly expenses in retirement, despite the fact that the average annual benefit is just under $16,000 a year. Today we will examine the State of our Nation's retirement system. The Government Accountability Office has done extensive work studying this issue, including issuing this very comprehensive report, which has been updated for our hearing, and I very much appreciate the Comptroller General's personal interest in addressing the challenges that make it difficult for far too many Americans to have a comfortable retirement by adequately saving for the future. At the Federal level, we must continue to look for ways to help employers who wish to do so to start their own retirement plans for their employees. The Small Business Administration estimates that about 60 million Americans work for small businesses. To help make it easier and less expensive for these employers to establish retirement plans, as well as to encourage individuals to save more of their own hard-earned money, Senator Hassan and I have introduced the Retirement Security Act, and to provide greater flexibility and access to both employees and their employers seeking to use the popular SIMPLE plans as an option for saving for retirement, I have also introduced a second bill, the SIMPLE Plan Modernization Act, with my colleague Senator Mark Warner of Virginia. We know that when full-time employees have access to retirement plans, on average 85 percent will contribute. Clearly, increasing access to employer-sponsored plans is a vital part of ensuring retirement security. This is a significant public policy problem that requires bipartisan solutions. The longer that we ignore the looming retirement crisis, the worse that it will become. After spending decades in the workforce, seniors should be confident that they will have the money needed to pay their bills and enjoy their retirement, without the fear that they will fall into poverty during their golden years. I look forward to our discussion today with the excellent panel that we have assembled, and I am now delighted to turn to our Ranking Member, Senator Casey, for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., RANKING MEMBER Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins, for holding this hearing today on this critically important subject. Having financial security in retirement is a goal for each and every family in America. All of us hope that when we reach old age, we will be able to enjoy retirement on our own terms, but the reality is that millions of American families are approaching retirement with almost nothing saved, and despite working hard their whole lives, too many seniors are finding themselves barely able to make ends meet. According to the GAO, roughly one in four households ages 65 to 74 have zero--zero--retirement savings of any kind, and many others have managed to save only a fraction of what they will need. Some are living in fear of seeing significant cuts to a pension they have planned their lives around. The truth is that our retirement system does well for some, but it allows millions of Americans to fall through the cracks. As we will hear today, this is particularly true when it comes to women, who on average have lower retirement incomes and are more likely to live in poverty when in old age, and it is true for people who lack access to savings options at work and those who did earn retirement benefits at work but now live in danger of seeing them cut. Our Nation deserves better, more secure retirement options. We can start by strengthening the backbone of our Nation's retirement system, Social Security itself. We must ensure that Social Security is able to keep the promise--the promise--of financial security in retirement. We must not let Americans relying upon Social Security slide into poverty. That is why today I am introducing a bill to boost Social Security benefits for women who are the most likely to end up in poverty. Widows and widows with disabilities are significantly more likely to live in poverty in old age than are other Social Security recipients. The bill is the Surviving Widow Income Fair Treatment Act, which would eliminate arbitrary claiming rules and caps that substantially reduce a widow's benefits. I am pleased that a number of my colleagues have joined in introducing this bill, two members of this committee, in fact, Senators Blumenthal and Gillibrand. In addition to strengthening Social Security, we must ensure that promises to workers relying upon pensions are kept. Workers across the country, including tens of thousands in my home State of Pennsylvania, fear the pensions they have earned will be dramatically cut through no fault of their own. Congress must act immediately to keep multiemployer pensions solvent. Finally, we must work to ensure that our retirement savings system works for all Americans. We must work to expand access to workplace retirement plans, and we must make tax incentives for retirement savings, like the Saver's Credit, useful to the families who actually need it the most. We must approach these problems in a comprehensive fashion that ensures that all workers can participate and that all workers receive the benefits they have earned. I would also like to quickly note that for today's hearing, we are pleased to be represented at the witness table by so many with Pennsylvania roots. Linda Stone is from Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, and does a lot of her work obviously in Pennsylvania. The Comptroller General is here who has roots in Pennsylvania and who graduated from Lycoming College. John Scott has two degrees from Pennsylvania schools, and we are happy about that, both Penn State and, I have here--Penn State and Swarthmore. Yes, those are the two, and before the hearing is over, probably someone else will stand up and claim Pennsylvania roots. Chairman Collins, I will try not to dwell on that, but we are grateful for the time you set aside for this hearing on this critical issue. Thanks very much. The Chairman. Senator Casey, I will say that you did manage to one-up me on the number of witnesses with ties to your State, but I would point out that I was Chairman of the Committee with responsibility for confirming the Comptroller General, so but for me---- Senator Casey. I think you got me. The Chairman. I do want to welcome a new member of our Committee, Senator Scott from Florida. Obviously, Florida is the State with the oldest percentage of seniors. Maine is the oldest State by median age, and Pennsylvania is not far behind, so all three of us have a deep commitment to the issue of improving retirement security, which is one of the four major focuses of our Committee. Let me now turn to our witnesses, and, again, welcome, Senator Scott, for being a member of the Senate Aging Committee. First, I am very pleased to welcome the much sought and fought over this morning Comptroller General of the United States, Gene Dodaro. Mr. Dodaro's career at the GAO spans more than 40 years. His testimony today is based on extensive work the GAO has done to examine the State of the Nation's retirement system, but I also know that this is a personal passion for him and that he has been sounding the alarm for many years, so we welcome you and look forward to your testimony. Next we will hear from John Scott, the retirement savings project director at The Pew Charitable Trusts. Mr. Scott conducts original research to unlock barriers to retirement savings. He also develops policy initiatives that could lead to increased retirement savings and other strategies to encourage Americans to save more. We will then turn to our next witness who happens to be from the great State of Maine, Denis St. Peter. Mr. St. Peter is the president and CEO of CES, an engineering firm in Brewer, Maine. CES employs around 100 people and was recently the recipient of this year's Bangor Regional Chamber of Commerce Business of the Year Award. He will describe the challenges of establishing effective retirement plans for small businesses and the benefits of such plans to employees. I will now turn to our Ranking Member, Senator Casey, to introduce our final witness. Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I am pleased to introduce Linda Stone from Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, Montgomery County. Linda Stone is currently a volunteer fellow with the Women's Institute for Secure Retirement. She is an actuary, 26 years' experience advising companies on their retirement plans, a graduate of St. Joe's University. She travels across Pennsylvania to educate people on the challenges that women face in preparing for retirement. In fact, she spent her career working in retirement security. She will tell us about what can be done to help more Americans gain economic security in retirement. Linda, we are grateful you are here. Thanks for traveling to Washington, and we are looking forward to your testimony. The Chairman. Thank you very much. I also want to welcome another new member to our Committee, Senator Jacky Rosen from Nevada. We are delighted to have you joining our Committee as well. Thank you. Comptroller General, the floor is yours. STATEMENT OF HON. GENE L. DODARO, COMPTROLLER GENERAL OF THE UNITED STATES, WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. Dodaro. Thank you very much. Chairman Collins, it is a pleasure to be here, Ranking Member Senator Casey, Senator Rosen. I greatly appreciate the opportunity to talk about GAO's work on this important subject. The current retirement system is not well prepared to meet the 21st century needs of our country. All three pillars of the system--Government programs, employer-based solutions, individuals savings on their own--are under a lot of stress and face a number of challenges going forward. In the Government domain, the Social Security Old-Age and Survivors Trust Fund will have enough to pay 77 percent of scheduled benefits by 2034, and it faces serious and substantial long-term solvency problems. The multiemployer portion of the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation is expected at 90 percent certainty to be insolvent by 2025. The Medicare Hospital Trust Fund by 2026 will only have enough funds to pay 91 cents on the dollar of scheduled Medicare benefits. When you turn to the employer side, one-third of all working populations have no access to employer-based plans, so they are very limited, and you pointed this out in your opening comments very appropriately, and the shift, as Chairman Collins explained, to defined contribution plans from defined benefit plans has a number of implications. On the positive side, it more fits the mobility of the workforce today because the benefits are portable. A number of people are using it to meaningfully save for retirement, particularly high-income workers. On the other side, low-income workers tend to have much smaller balances in their accounts, and, importantly, as you point out, Chairman Collins, it shifted the responsibility to individuals to make many more complicated financial decisions on their own, in many cases without a lot of support in order to do so. It raises the risk for individuals. Now, the third pillar has always been individuals saving on their own in addition to these vehicles by the Government and the employers, but there we see many challenges. Some people are doing very well, but many are not, and they are facing head winds of relatively low real wage growth, high household debt payments, and rising costs for out-of-pocket health care costs, which continue to rise faster than the economy, so they are struggling as well. The bottom line in this case is that it has been over 40 years since the Congress commissioned a comprehensive commission to look holistically at the retirement system in the United States. Many actions have been taken incrementally over the years-- the establishment of the Social Security system in 1935, the ERISA law in 1974, and there have been a lot of incremental changes since then, but the demographics of the country have changed dramatically. We are aging as a population. We have low fertility rates, increased longevity--which is a good thing, but it is causing people to live a lot longer and, therefore, the financial models particularly for Social Security and some of the PBGC programs, are not well suited to meet these current needs and are really in imminent danger of not fulfilling the promise, Senator Casey, as you mentioned, that our country has made. I would urge the Congress to act on GAO's recommendation, which would be to establish a comprehensive commission to look at all these things interrelated and not just look at Social Security alone or employer-based systems or individuals' efforts, but to look comprehensively at this, given the changing dynamics of our country and the changing nature of work in the United States, and unless the Congress acts soon, I am afraid many Americans will not face a safe and secure retirement, and also the fiscal pressures will mount on the Federal Government at a time when the Federal Government is already on a long-term, unsustainable fiscal path. These are very weighty policy issues, both public policy and fiscal policy, and I really commend the Committee for focusing in on these issues and taking this very seriously. Whatever we could do at GAO to help, we will continue to do so. I would be happy to answer questions at the appropriate time. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Mr. Dodaro. Mr. Scott. STATEMENT OF JOHN SCOTT, RETIREMENT SAVINGS PROJECT DIRECTOR, THE PEW CHARITABLE TRUSTS, WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. John Scott. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman and Ranking Member Casey, for the opportunity to testify on the importance of financial security in retirement. The Pew Charitable Trusts is an independent, nonpartisan, nonprofit organization that applies a rigorous analytical approach to improve public policy. While workplace retirement plans are the primary vehicle for ensuring financial security in old age, as was noted, one- third of private sector workers still lack access to a retirement plan. Inadequate savings are not just bad for workers' retirement security, but also impose costs for Federal and State governments as well as on the larger economy. A 2016 study by the University of Maine, for example, found that Maine's retirement age population is projected to increase 30 percent by 2032. The associated costs of social services could grow to $362 million by 2032, with the State's share growing to $61 million, which would be double what the State covered in 2016. A similar Pennsylvania study determined that net costs to the Commonwealth due to insufficient retirement savings are projected to grow to $1.1 billion by 2030. To understand the barriers to savings, our research focused on small businesses and their employees. Certain categories of workers at small firms have inadequate retirement coverage. For example, part-timers are almost half as likely as full-time workers to have access to retirement benefits, and Hispanic, black, and Asian workers have much lower access rates than whites, but given the importance of plan sponsorship, I want to focus my remarks on small employers. Pew surveyed over 1,600 small business owners, both plan sponsors and those that did not sponsor a plan. We found that employers offered various reasons for providing retirement benefits. Nearly half cited a desire to help employees save for retirement as the main reason. Nearly a third said attracting and retaining workers was the reason they offered a retirement plan. We also found that firm financial stability is strongly associated with plan sponsorship. For example, employers with increasing earnings are much more likely to offer a plan than if earnings were flat. Businesses then tend to adopt plans during a middle phase in their development after initial startup and during a period of expansion and growth. We also asked about plan features that can improve workers' financial security, like employer contributions and automatic enrollment. Nearly all surveyed employers with retirement savings plans made employer contributions, but two-thirds of small business plan sponsors did not automatically enroll their workers. When asked why not, executives said either they were satisfied with their current set-up or they perceived employees would not like to be automatically enrolled. We also surveyed employers that did not sponsor retirement plans, and we first asked why they did not offer one. Thirty- seven percent of employers cited startup costs as too expensive; another 22 percent cited a lack of internal administrative capacity to run a retirement plan. Unfamiliarity with retirement plan options may also be a barrier. For example, only 11 percent of survey respondents were very familiar with a SIMPLE IRA plan, which is designed for small businesses. When businesses without a plan were asked what would motivate them to begin one, clear majorities cited increased business profits and increased tax credits for startup costs. There are many promising ideas to address these and other challenges. Let me note that Pew does not endorse or oppose any particular legislative initiative. However, legislation such as introduced by Senator Collins and your colleagues emphasized critical areas such as automatic enrollment, multiple employer plans, or MEPs, improving SIMPLE IRA plans, and increasing tax credits for startup costs. Initiatives that reduce plans' startup costs and improving awareness of SIMPLE plans and other plan options could be useful in encouraging new plan formation, and our research found that small businesses reacted very positively to the idea of MEPs, although it is not clear if they would actually join MEPs if they were made more widely available. Auto-enrollment also could boost participation. For example, in the State of Oregon, where they are using auto- enrollment to cover workers who do not have a plan at their jobs, 70 percent of workers are participating and saving at a rate of just over 5 percent of pay, but as you know, more work needs to be done, and in that regard I want to commend the GAO for their 2017 report and for their call for a comprehensive examination of the retirement system. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Mr. Scott, for all that great data. I appreciate it. Mr. St. Peter. STATEMENT OF DENIS ST. PETER, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, CES, INC., BREWER, MAINE Mr. St. Peter. Chair Collins, Ranking Member Casey, thank you very much for inviting me here today to discuss our company approach to promoting retirement savings for our employees. My name is Denis St. Peter, and I am licensed professional engineer in the great State of Maine. I am also the president and CEO of our company, but I am not a finance expert, so more an engineering degree. I have some additional information about our company in my written testimony, but for the sake of time, I am skipping through it. It includes our mission, vision, value statements, which I think are key to the approach that we took to improve our retirement plan. If you take the time to read through that, you will see that we do focus on and care about our employees, we care about our clients, and we care about the communities that we live and work in. About 10 years ago, we went through an ownership and leadership transition in our company. That gave us an opportunity to reevaluate our business approaches, one of which was our retirement plan. At the time we had a 401(k) plan with a profit-sharing component, but we did not have a match at the time, so there were really four key things that led us to change that. The first one, the lack of matching, was really perceived by our key employees as a missing component to our benefit plan, so for us to retain top talent and recruit good people, we felt we needed to add that, and again, it was consistent with our mission, vision, values. The second item was that, in general, we knew that our CES employees were underfunding their retirement. We had a participation rate at about 62 percent and an average employee contribution around 3.9 percent of base salary. The third item was really my history. As the first job I had out of college, I worked for the Federal Government, and I had 5-percent match opportunity, and I remembered how that really made me think about saving for retirement at that point. I am not sure I would have saved if I did not have the match. The fourth criteria really was the top-heavy testing that was required in our plan, and we were close to exceeding that 60-percent limit. We set a course on improving our plan. Our goal was to get to the 4-percent match. We increased it 1 percent a year to get to that 4 percent. That was in the 2011 to 2014 timeframe. We also implemented several other best practices. We started an investment committee, including an investment adviser to participate in that committee. We fully utilized our third- party administrator. We also established our benefits committee and lots and lots of education and communication with our employees. I have got four slides that show the results of our progress, the first one being participation rate. As I mentioned before, we were around 62 percent. We are up close to 90 percent. Our goal is 100 percent. We are getting there. The next slide is average contribution as a percentage of base salary. We were averaging just under 4 percent, and now we are up to close to 14 percent. The next slide is our 401(k) plan asset value. In 2010, we were at $2.45 million. We are now at $7.27 million. That includes a sizable distribution from one of our founding partners, so probably about closer to $8 million. Then the last slide is the top-heavy testing results. As I mentioned earlier, we were close to the 60-percent limit, at 59.8, and we have shown some pretty good results from our matching program and other best practices. We are down to 48.7 percent. I would be willing to answer any questions later. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Mr. St. Peter. Ms. Stone. STATEMENT OF LINDA K. STONE, FELLOW VOLUNTEER, WOMEN'S INSTITUTE FOR A SECURE RETIREMENT (WISER), BRYN MAWR, PENNSYLVANIA Ms. Stone. Good morning, Chairman Collins, Ranking Member Casey, and distinguished members of the Committee. I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss financial security in retirement, including the significant and unique retirement risks that many women face. I am here today in my capacity as a volunteer Fellow with the Women's Institute for a Secure Retirement (WISER). WISER is a nonprofit organization that works to help women, educators, and policymakers understand the important issues surrounding women's retirement income. Through my work with WISER and the National Resource Center on Women and Retirement Planning, in cooperation with the Administration on Aging, I have presented workshops to diverse groups of women across the country and have heard directly about their experiences. One reason that I am so passionate about this issue is the experience of my own mother. She was a ``Rosie the Riveter'' who worked in the shipyards in Chester, Pennsylvania, during World War II. After her divorce from my father, she was able to support our family while working as a machinist and later as a nursing home aide. She did not know to try to get a spousal benefit from my father's workplace retirement plan or to see if there were spousal Social Security benefits that would be larger than her own. There is more that can be done to help women like my mother have a secure retirement. First, I would like to address a question that WISER often receives: Why focus on women? Quite simply, there are 5.7 million more women than men at age 65, and 67 percent of the over-age-85 population are female. Many women over age 85 end up near-poor or in poverty even if they have never been poor before. Women face greater longevity risk than men due to their longer lives and the resulting need for more income. At age 65, women can expect to live an average of 21-plus years, 3 years Mr. St. Peter than men. One out of every two women in their mid-50's today will live until age 90. Having more income during retirement starts with your earnings during your working years and your access to employer- sponsored savings and pension plans. Generally, no matter how you slice and dice it, women earn less than men throughout their lifetimes. Caregiving responsibilities for children, parents, as well as spouses cause women to spend years out of the job market or to work part-time without access to benefits. Social Security reports that, on average, women have 9 years with zero earnings. The zero earnings are compounded in the calculation of their Social Security benefit. This all results in women having less in savings and employer-sponsored retirement benefits as most employer plans require full-time status to be able to participate and base benefits on pay, and many women who work have no access to employer-sponsored plans. A long life increases the risk that inflation will negatively impact the ability to live on a limited income and increases the chance that women will outlive their assets. Women are more likely to need long-term care in these later years as they are less likely to have a family caregiver. Among women more than 85 years old, 87 percent are not married. The bottom line is that women accumulate less money than men during their working years and have to make it last longer. Women often have a planning horizon that is much too short. As a result, they underestimate their need for savings to support the many years they will be in retirement and the need to start saving as early as possible. Women nearing retirement who do have savings have the burden of not only determining how to invest the money before retirement but also how to appropriately spend down their savings so that the assets last for their lifetime. As they change jobs, many do not appreciate how not cashing out balances, no matter how small, can make a big difference in the amount of money that is available at retirement. The reality of today's retirement landscape for many is do- it-yourself, and do it right, or live at or below the edge of poverty. The nature of today's system of individual responsibility demands financial capability. Women are in the difficult position of making big decisions while being unable to afford even a small mistake. Divorce, widowhood, and needing to leave the workplace earlier than expected can derail even the best planners. We need to strengthen existing programs wherever possible. That means focusing on Social Security and Medicare, expanding access to employer-sponsored retirement programs, and supporting and expanding individual savings initiatives. In conclusion, thank you for including a focus on women's retirement issues today. We know from the women who have contacted WISER and attended our workshops that they want to take better control of their retirement. We need to make sure every woman is getting support they need through education and access to carefully crafted programs that will make a difference in their ability to have a secure retirement. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Ms. Stone. Comptroller General, I want to start with you, and I want to start with a very basic question. First, however, let me acknowledge that we have been joined by three more of our colleagues: Senator McSally, Senator Braun, and Senator Jones. You will find that members will be coming in and out throughout the hearing, as Mr. Dodaro is well aware of, but it may come as a surprise to others as Senators are trying to balance complicated schedules. Comptroller General, I want to start with a very basic question, and that is, what are the biggest impediments that employees face in saving enough for retirement? Mr. Dodaro. There are a number of factors. I mentioned some earlier that I think are very important. One is that there is relatively low real wage growth, and many of the people in the country are earning about the same as they were in 1970 in real purchasing power, so that is number one. Number two is the accumulation of debt, but also I would say rising health care costs. Health care costs continue to rise faster than the economy, so the out-of-pocket costs are really important, and this is a factor in planning for retirement because you have more health care costs when you are in retirement and through the rest of your life. There are also features of the individual plans. In a defined contribution plan, those plans that do not have automatic enrollment reduce participation. We find that if there is automatic enrollment and even in some cases an auto-escalation clause as employees earn more, that helps save. You also have fees in those programs that are problematic in defined contribution plans, and in the defined benefit plans, there you have portability issues. If you change jobs frequently, there are the vesting requirements that are a problem in both kinds of plans, both defined contribution and defined benefit, and people do not understand that. Sometimes when they change jobs, they roll over or do not roll over their retirement accounts appropriately, so there are a lot of complicated factors. There is a set of basic economic factors that are important impediments, and then there are features of these plans that also can be impediments as well. The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. St. Peter, Ms. Stone mentioned people taking money out of their retirement plans when they change jobs and using it for non-retirement purposes, and I think when people are in their 20's and 30's, retirement seems so far away that oftentimes bad decisions are made, and I will confess to the worst financial decision that I ever made, which was when I left the Hill as a staffer with almost 12 years of retirement contributions, I withdrew all the money to buy a car instead of getting a car loan, and that was the worst financial decision I have ever made in my entire life, but I swear if just one person had said to me when I filed to withdraw the money, ``Do you really want to do this? You are already vested, and the implications are enormous, and there is nothing wrong with getting a car loan.'' I was just thinking, ``Oh, I cannot take on debt.'' And it was truly such a bad decision. I think a really important part of what your company does, Mr. St. Peter, is helping to improve people's understanding, your workers' understanding of financial decisions. Could you explain a little bit what you do? Mr. St. Peter. Sure. It is a double-edged sword, I think, the borrowing component of our 401(k) plans. I think it helps attract participation because they know it is not locked forever, but we do see the urge to borrow from the plan, and the benefit that we have as an employer is that we have an H.R. director who is kind of the first line that can counsel our employees that want to borrow from it, educate them that way. If she feels like she needs more expert advice, we have our investment adviser that willingly gives his time to communicate with an employee and help educate them of the negative consequences, and then the third line is our direct supervisors. We do have plenty of opportunities, and we just need to remind ourselves as a company to continue to take those opportunities to communicate with them. The Chairman. Your participation rate of nearly 90 percent is really impressive and shows the effort that you have made. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I will start with Linda Stone. Ms. Stone, I wanted to start with part of your written testimony where you talked about the complexity of Social Security claiming rules, and that might be among the biggest understatements that we can utter. Ms. Stone. Yes. Senator Casey. These issues get very, very little attention, and they warrant a spotlight, and I am grateful you are helping us with that today. The bill I talked about earlier would ensure that recently widowed individuals receive better information on the benefits available to them and how their claiming decisions, these complex rules and the decisions that flow from them, can permanently affect their retirement income. Based upon your experience talking with women in Pennsylvania saving for retirement, do you think there is a greater need for both more education and more guidance when it comes to these decisions? Ms. Stone. Yes, I think both, Senator Casey. Social Security claiming strategies can be very complicated, as you said, and a lot of women do not even quite understand that 65 is not their Social Security full retirement age anymore. For some of them it is 67, and what does that mean if they take their benefit at 62? Because it is available at 62. That is quite a big reduction that lasts for somebody's whole entire life, and there does not seem to be as much knowledge about that as there could be. We get a lot of questions from women who are divorced, and one of the biggest ``aha'' moments that happens in some of our workshops is when we mention that if you have been married for 10 years, you are eligible to collect on your ex-spouse's Social Security benefit, and so questions around surviving spouse benefits are also something that comes up quite often. You know, how are you eligible and how do you coordinate that if you also have a worker benefit? And you are likely aware that last year there was a report by the Social Security Office of the Inspector General that showed widows are not getting all of their options explained to them when they claim their benefit, and this has cost women hundreds of millions of dollars, because the rules are just incredibly complicated, and women need more education and, you know, factual advice on the implications of their decisions when they are in the process of making that decision that is going to impact their benefit for the rest of their life. Senator Casey. I guess part of this, of course, is what--in the case where it is a husband and a wife, and the wife survives, the husband passes away, sometimes the problem is what decision the husband made that then binds or limits what happens with the surviving spouse, the widow. Can you just walk through that circumstance? Ms. Stone. Yes. One of the things we talk about is that couples should figure out as a couple their claiming strategy, each of them, and then each of them as a couple, and obviously, they have different income levels, different life expectancies, and because the survivor benefit, you know, depends on the kind of highest benefit that the couple has, if the person making the most money--and for this we will say that is the husband-- you know, can delay receipt of their benefit, that will leave more of a survivor benefit for their widow, but maybe they just want to collect it early, and they do not think as a couple we will be better off in the long run if you postpone getting your benefit so it does not get the early reduction or even increases it 8 percent a year if you wait past your full retirement age. That is a pretty good return to push that benefit back, and that means, you know, I will have as your widow a bigger survivor benefit, so let us think about what make sense for the family as we think about this, not just, you know, each of us as individuals, and that is something that, again, needs to be more education around a family discussion on that. Senator Casey. I know I have limited time, and I will try to do some followup, but, Comptroller General Dodaro, I wanted to ask you about the circumstance that you outline urging us to take action. If Congress does not take action, do you think it is likely that many current and future retirees in these multiemployer pension plans will see their benefits cut? Mr. Dodaro. Definitely. I mentioned it is 90 percent certain that PGBC's multiemployer insurance program will be insolvent by 2025. It goes up to 99 percent by 2026. If that happens, the amount of benefits that plan participants would receive will be even lower than what they are now. The single employer insurance program has a higher benefit. If you work 30 years, you can get about $13,000, but if they go insolvent, they could get less than $2,000 a year, so that is not much of a retirement benefit, so they would definitely be hurt, so for the multiemployer portion, it is very urgent that Congress take action. I was pleased in the last Congress that a special committee was set up in order to address that, but they did not produce a final report, and I have been urging Congress on this for years. We have had the multiemployer program on our High- Risk List across the Government since 2009. We have had the single-employer program on it since 2003. That program is doing a little better now, but even the single-employer plan has reasonable expectations of losses of about $175 billion, according to recent PBGC estimates, so both components of PBGC's programs are facing financial uncertainty, but for right now, the most urgent program is the multiemployer program, and Congress needs to act, or these people are not going to have any meaningful benefit at all. Senator Casey. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator McSally? Senator McSally. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thanks for having this important hearing today and for all the testimony. When I was over in the House, I started a working group on Women in the Workforce in the 21st Century, trying to identify what are the real issues that women are facing in the workforce and how we can close the pay gap on education and just choices that are happening in people's lives, and especially for women. As you mentioned, Ms. Stone, women are more likely to be caregivers for their children and their parents, and we had some testimony related to exactly what you are talking about today, and this is hearing is highlighting that it is not just impacting them through their whole lives, but as they are living longer, they have less income, less retirement, more likely to be in poverty, so I really appreciate all the work that you are doing to address this issue. You know, it seems like we are in situation where those who are retiring now, those women, the Baby Boomers, they have less earnings throughout their whole life, less savings, less retirement, less Social Security. Yet my generation--which is, what, Gen X?--we are the ones that are more likely to be then caring for them, so we are coming behind them with the very same dynamics happening. Women are wanting more flexibility. Women are wanting to be able to move in and out of the workforce. We are seeing this with our generation, which then is going to perpetuate the challenges that you mentioned as our generation moves into retirement. You mentioned in your testimony as some solutions, study ways to offer retirement protections to women with significant time spent as caregivers, including possibility of a provision for Social Security credits and credits for out-of-pocket expenses that may be preventing women from saving. Can you talk a little bit more about what you are proposing there and what that would look like? Ms. Stone. Well, I am not making any specific recommendations. I think there are a number of recommendations or thoughts around how to reflect caregiving in Social Security, and I think that is good that the conversation is happening. I think one of the things that we try to do at WISER is have women understand, before they make the decision to leave the workplace to care for someone, the actual kind of opportunity cost of that, that they are not only giving up their pay, they are giving up, you know, maybe their employer- provided benefits, other benefits that they may have, and are they going to be able to get back in the workplace? Some of what we are trying to do is have people understand there may be other options that could be used to not give up your own financial security necessarily as your first reaction is, ``I have to quit my job to go take care of Mom.'' I think what we are trying to do is educate women, and I think to have kind of a policy decision about the facts, which is women do spend a lot of time out of the workplace, I think it is just good that that conversation is happening. Senator McSally. Great. Thanks. I want to followup with you maybe afterwards about any other specific ideas policy-wise, you know, related to what we are talking about. Also in Arizona, 54 percent of women are family caregivers right now, and we have a growing aging population in Arizona, so this is something that is very real, and trying to keep individuals in their homes and allow a better quality of life in their older years, these financial barriers are very real for so many of the people that I represent. I wanted to also ask about, you know, just the additional education we can have related to when someone becomes a widow or they are trying to make decisions with their own Social Security benefits. This is really complicated, as you said, and it is not--as is explained to you, I just went through this with someone close to me who lost her husband. It was like Mandarin Chinese; trying to understand what her options were and whether her own income and where the offset was and what month she might be able to get a benefit, it was really confusing. What can we do to make sure that it is simplified in the way, you know, individuals understand their options when they are looking at what their Social Security benefits are as a survivor or as someone who is continuing to work. Ms. Stone. Yes, I agree with you that is very complicated and more needs to be done, and I think it gets to how is the communication happening. You know, there used to be Social Security benefit statements mailed to people on an annual basis. That does not happen anymore, because then people could at least start getting used to like looking at their earnings: ``Oh, I see zeroes there. What does that mean?'' And, ``What is my benefit?'' And even to feel like when you call, you know, Social Security workers are doing their best, but it is very complicated, and to try to just get this explained to you over the phone, I do not know how anybody could really make decisions without really seeing something and, you know, can we have communications be done in a way that people can more easily read and understand them? Because some information is out there, and it is just making sure people know where to get that information and maybe having it, you know, kind of pushed to them versus having people out on the Internet trying to find some of this information themselves. Senator McSally. Great. Thank you. I am out of time. I appreciate it. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Jones? Senator Jones. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I appreciate it, and thank you all for coming today. Just to pick up a little bit on what Senator McSally said, with regard to women, obviously, you know, the President talked last night about the women in the workforce now. More and more women entering the workforce will hopefully narrow that savings gap a little bit down the road, but at the same time, 50 years or more after the passage of the Equal Pay Act, 10 years after the passage of the Lilly Ledbetter Fair--Equal Pay for Equal Work Act, we still have a disparity between the income of men and the income of women. Recently, a number of Senators and Members of Congress reintroduced the Paycheck Fairness Act, which has been introduced now 12 times since 1997, to try to help narrow that gap. I would assume that if we can also work as Members of Congress to narrow that pay gap, do what we can to make sure that women get the same pay as men, that is going to reap benefits down the road for women in retirement. Is that correct, Ms. Stone? Ms. Stone. Yes, because as I mentioned, many employer plans are based on somebody's earnings, and so higher earnings means a higher benefit, and also, if you are making more money, you certainly have more of an ability to put more money away in savings and get that employer match if they are offering that match. Senator Jones. It is not just for now. It is for the future when we are trying to do this, so thank you very much. I also want to--you know, I really appreciate the hearing, Madam Chairman, because I am witnessing an issue with my parents. My Dad worked at U.S. Steel and then had another job. He had a retirement U.S. Steel. He had Social Security, about as much as he could make for his generation. He is 87. My Mom worked sporadically, did not do a whole lot, but they planned. They thought they had a very good plan. They were putting money aside. They took some money from an investment and paid off their mortgage. What they did not anticipate, though, was Dad's Alzheimer's and having to go in extended care. They are both 87 years old now, and their savings is dwindling rapidly because of that. What can we do for people that are just the young people--I agree. Impulsively, I bought a similar car, but I bet mine is sharper than yours is, so I can relate. What can we do not just for the young folks of today, though, but for those folks that are 45, 50 years old that are also making these decisions, what can we do to educate so that they can understand that we are living longer and that we have got to make sure that we plan for that old age that may not be a healthy old age, that they are not just going to live to a point where they all of a sudden get sick and die and leave everything to their spouse or their families? What can we do to help those folks right now, educate them about the need for putting money back as much as they can, and looking at their monthly income, not just their bottom line: ``Oh, I have got half a million dollars.'' You know, that is awesome, but where is that going to be and how long might that take to--I will leave that to the panel. Any suggestions on that? Ms. Stone. Well, I will just start with one comment because you mentioned especially with everyone being in savings plans now, people do not know how much to save and how much is going to be enough, because in the world of Social Security, you get a fixed amount a month. If I am saving something, how do I know how much money it is really going to take at 65 to be able to support the rest of my life? And if I have that lump sum, how do I know how much to spend each year? And you are right that there is definitely not enough planning around long-term care. People somehow still think that that is taken care of by Medicare. I think truly what is happening is, generationally, people who had to deal with their parents get a real wake-up education fast, and you hope they change their own behaviors going forward, because they are learning through their parents and their friends' parents what the story is and how much money this really takes. I think more education and information to people who are in savings plans about how that lump sum actually translates into a monthly income can have people either feel good that they are saving enough or maybe realize, ``Oh, that is not very much. I better start putting some more money away,'' and try to incent some savings behaviors. Senator Jones. Right. Anybody? Mr. Dodaro. I think financial literacy is a real issue in this country, regardless of age. Recent surveys from the Federal Reserve shows on five basic questions about financial matters, people get three out of the five wrong, if not more, and so this is a real issue, and many people, four out of ten people, cannot even cover a $400 emergency now, and so I think on financial literacy, the Government has a role here to help empower people. The federal government tries to do that through Social Security agents, IRS agents, and others, but people do not have enough of a resource, and so I think education has to go a long way, but the other thing I would say, is that we have called for a commission to look comprehensively at retirement security in the United States. One of the fundamental precepts that I think needs to be done is Congress needs to simplify the system. It is way too complicated, and continuing to make incremental changes make it even more complicated, so unless you both educate and bring up financial literacy and better simplify the system, I do not think there is going to be enough headway made in time to help people. Senator Jones. Great. Well, thank you very much. Real quick. I am out of time. Mr. Scott, do you want to say something real quick? Mr. John Scott. Well, I would just say that, in line with the comment about a reexamination of the whole system, I think that would help elevate the issue and help understand that, you know, your private retirement savings can affect your Social Security benefits, so you could use part of your private retirement savings for a year, delay claiming of Social Security, and increase your benefits by 7 or 8 percent, so I think that sort of comprehensive conversation would be really useful to a lot of folks, and, just briefly, we have a lot of new technology coming online, robo-advisers and artificial intelligence, that could help simplify and get the message out there to help people through these complicated decisions. Senator Jones. Great. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Braun? Senator Braun. Thank you, Chairman. I am going to give you an idea what I think besets the whole system, and then I have got a couple questions at the tail end of it. To me, largely what pales the fact that people are not preparing for their future is the underlying ethic of savings. You know, I come from an area where it is kind of inherently frugal, a German, Catholic community and you were taught early on, even out of your wages you made mowing grass or something, stick some in the cookie jar or save it. I have had a business for 37 years and have been all about the idea of trying to make life better for my employees through all the tools we have, so I want to come back to a question later about the historic--the evidence on how that has changed in terms of how people view savings versus consumption. The tools we have got to address this would be Government, and I look at a statistic here that one-third of the budget was being spent on seniors through health care and Social Security in 2005. That is going to be 40 percent in 2029. We are running trillion-dollar deficits. We have got a balance sheet that looks terrible. You know, I come from a finance background. We are probably in the poorest position ever as a Federal Government to take on big issues like shoring up Medicare and Social Security, let alone things like infrastructure. I am thinking that one thing that occurred recently was tax reform, and for any of us that have had businesses--and I preached this on the campaign trail and have done it here--I think it is incumbent upon employers to make sure you not only expose savings opportunities to your employees, but you actually raise 401(k) benefits, invest--if you are a successful business and you are paying taxes, invest in your employees, because I think the reference was made that real wages have not been doing well. I think we are seeing some of that because we are unleashing part of the economy that I think can be unleashed, but we have got many years to go before that really sinks in. I am challenging folks that I think have businesses that are in the real economy out there to wake up, especially if you are successful, invest more in your employees. I do not feel confident in looking to Government in its current form of not living within its means as being a solution--not to say that we should not try to improve there. I want to circle back to the ethic of savings. I was looking through the notes. I was not here for most of the testimony. How much of what we suffer from now where people do not seem to be prepared for the future, knowing that Social Security has got a lot working against it actuarially and demographically, what can you tell me--and this is addressed to anyone that would have a special insight into it. What has happened since World War II in terms of savings and the fact that we obviously are a consumer society--I do not think there were credit cards around back then. How much of it is related to that versus the fact that, you know, we now see that it is not working through Government programs and businesses maybe need to do a little more? Anybody that would want to jump in, please. Mr. Dodaro. I have a chart in my prepared testimony that shows the national savings rate and how it has declined over a period of time, and it hit a low around the Great Recession most recently. It is back up to 6.8 percent, but is nowhere near historic levels, so there is a national savings issue that needs to be dealt with, but which has a lot of ramifications for capital formation and other things beyond retirement. Senator Braun. What was it historically, just out of curiosity? Mr. Dodaro. I think it was around 13 to 15 percent in the early 1970s, and now it is about half that. Senator Braun. Isn't that the plug-in variable? Mr. Dodaro. It is part of the issue. I do not think it is totally the issue, but I think it is part of the issue. I think another part of the other issue, though, that has to be part of the discussion is health care costs. Health care costs are eating up into a lot of people's ability to save at all levels. As long as health care costs continue to rise faster than the economy, which they have, that is going to impede any progress for people to try to make accumulate savings. Another part of the issue is that because of our economic model, a lot time has been spent encouraging people to spend. Consumer spending is one of the main drivers of our economy, so there is this tension between encouraging people to spend to promote economic growth and encourage them to save and deal with rising health care costs, so it is complicated, but the savings issue is part of the equation. Senator Braun. I am glad you mentioned health care costs. Another thing we did 9 to 10 years ago in our own business is the health care industry, specifically health insurance companies, totally dysfunctional. There is a really, I think, strong opportunity there to start growing costs out, because I think between health care costs and somehow figuring out how to get people to save more, look more to the future, would be the two things outside of Government that might make the most sense. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Sinema? Senator Sinema. Well, thank you, Chairman Collins and Ranking Member Casey, and thank you to all of our witnesses. You know, 10,000 Baby Boomers reach retirement age every single day, and many are unprepared for the financial challenges they face. An increasingly common challenge is how to balance retirement needs with caregiving obligations. Recently, a 2018 report from the Center for Retirement Research found that more than 10 percent of adults ages 60 and over provide some type of care to their own elderly parents, and that is what happened to Norma, who is an Arizona educator who took early retirement at age 61 to first care for her father and then later for her mother, and it also happened to Larry, who is an Arizonan with a successful career in marketing. He became his mother's caregiver and found his bills piling up. In his 70's, he had to take on part-time, low-wage work just to make ends meet. We know that preparing for retirement is challenging enough for many Americans, and those challenges are exacerbated when retirees also care for their aging family members. While this is often a choice that is made out of love, it can impact employment and even Social Security benefits if the caregiver must spend years working outside of the working. My question today is for Ms. Linda Stone with the Women's Institute for a Secure Retirement. Your testimony mentioned that retirement protections for caregivers within the Social Security system exist, and I previously supported legislation to provide tax credits to caregivers, but designing a caregiver retirement benefit would be more complicated, so how can we shift the conversation around caregiving from talking about it as a familial obligation to instead recognizing it as work, especially in the context of lost wages and the impact that it has on lifetime earnings? And how can we design an earned benefit to ensure that it reaches workers like Norma and Larry who have made these choices to care for their family members? Ms. Stone. I appreciate your questions and your raising situations that we hear about a lot at WISER and, you know, women having to make these choices, as you said, and the ramifications of that. You know, I think from a policy perspective, that is not WISER's expertise, so I will leave that to all the actuaries and other policy experts around Social Security. I will only say that, you know, knowing the facts that people do have to spend this many years working but not working within work for the Social Security system is something that, you know, I would agree needs attention and evaluation for how to address that because it definitely impacts the ability of large groups of people to be able to have a good Social Security benefit as well as to continue working to be able to save and get retirement benefits. Senator Sinema. My own aunt took early retirement in order to have more time to care for my grandmother, who suffers from Alzheimer's, and while she still works part-time outside of the home, she now is facing a smaller long-term Social Security benefit because of the choice she was forced to make in order to care for my own grandmother. The stories that I hear from Norma, Larry, and, indeed, in my own family continue to build and show the pressure that Arizonans are facing in the sandwich generation, caring for both younger family members and older family members. What kind of conversations are happening within the private nonprofit community as well as in Government structures to help realistically make adjustments for family members who are making these very difficult decisions to reduce their unemployment to care for family members? Ms. Stone. Really, I am sorry. I really cannot speak to that. Senator Sinema. Are there other members of the panel who might be able to address the issues of how to construct a benefit that would allow individuals who have taken time off of paid work to care for family members to retain the relevance of their work in Social Security? Mr. John Scott. I would just say that, you know, at Pew a different project other than mine is looking into caregiving issues, and we would be happy to followup with any information we can provide. Mr. Dodaro. At the request of Chairman Collins, we are doing work for this Committee now looking at this very issue of people providing caregiving and what the implications are for work. When we have completed our work, we plan to have some suggestions in that report associated with that. Also, I think more conversation needs to be had. We have called for a national commission to be chartered by the Congress to look holistically at retirement security in the United States. The current system is not well prepared to meet 21st century needs, and that would be part of that conversation, too, so that it could be looked at holistically. I think we need to address it more comprehensively, but that issue would definitely be part of the conversation. Senator Sinema. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Hawley? Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Madam Chair, and thanks to all of you for being here today to help us understand this very important issue. I also want to talk about the costs of caregiving, but I want to ask some questions about caregiving for children and how that affects families' abilities to save and plan for the future, but first, let me just pick up on Senator Sinema's questions, which I thought were very good and whose concerns I share. Ms. Stone, in your prepared testimony, you talk about the possibility of a provision for Social Security credits for those who take significant time, women in particular who spend significant time as caregivers. Would you like to say more about that? I think that is a very--I think Senator Sinema was asking about this. That is an important proposal. Ms. Stone. Yes. Well, as I mentioned, I am not getting detailed into the policy. WISER and myself was making this statement only in that the fact exists, here is what happens with women who are taking time out of the workplace to care for children or older parents and how can the system address that fact without going into any policy details. That is not my area of specialty. Senator Hawley. Just to pick up on that, it seems to me that when we think about care for children, this is a significant reason, we know from the data, that women in particular choose to, as you say in your prepared testimony, Ms. Stone, that women choose to opt for more flexible workforce options. They are often still the primary caregiver for children, and that, of course, has significant implications for savings, and the cost of raising children has significant implications for savings. I want to ask--I will start with you, Ms. Stone, but direct this to the panel. Are there steps that can be taken that we should be considering to bring down the costs of raising children that would allow for greater savings for families in prime earning years when they perhaps have one spouse who has reduced his or her workload or is staying home completely to care for children and, therefore, their income is down for that reason, and just the costs of raising children which continues to grow? Are there proposals that you think we ought to be looking at to bring down those costs that would allow families to save? Ms. Stone, we will start with you and just go down the line. Ms. Stone. Yes, I am really not aware of anything. Mr. St. Peter. I can just speak from an employer, and we try to provide as much flexibility to our employees to take care of children or elders. We have parameters that we have to--with our 401(k) we have parameters of eligibility, and if there is--and I do not know exactly what those are, but if those could stay within the 401(k) and still be eligible, that may be a minor step in the process, but I think just in general, trying to be a good employer and provide them as much flexibility as we can. Mr. John Scott. Well, as a father, I can certainly appreciate the question, and I would just repeat that I do not really have any specifics to offer today, but this is an issue of importance to Pew. It is something that we are studying, paid and unpaid care for both children and older parents and close ones, so it is something we would be happy to followup at a later time when we have some more data. Mr. Dodaro. Our current work for this Committee is focused on caregiving for parents and spouses, not on children at that point, so I would be happy to take a look at that in the future, but one of the big issues from a Government standpoint, most of the assistance has been provided in the form of tax credits, and also the whole issue about education. I think the student loan issue not only a parent but a grandparent of seven now, I am trying to help my grandchildren prepare for college, and that is a huge cost, so there are costs of raising children, and there are big costs, and those big costs come later on. Of course, you have the Medicaid program that allows children--you have the CHIP programs for health care costs, which are a big component of costs of raising your children if you confront a health issue. The Federal Government has a lot of issues, but I commissioned a special study on was all the programs to help children. I am very concerned, as I am with retirement security, with the number of children in poverty. The federal government does not have a coordinated, comprehensive, governmentwide focus on children generally. You are bringing up one aspect of that issue in terms of caregiving and the implications for the parents, but we have one in five children in poverty in this country. In fact, there are more children probably in poverty now than the elderly people, and so this issue needs a lot broad examination. Senator Hawley. Thank you for that. I would just say I am very concerned about the number of children in poverty, and as it bears on the subject of today's hearing, it seems to me that the costs of raising children both in child care and early years, the cost of lost income from a spouse or spouses who have to stay home or balance the workload that way, and also the costs of education is a very significant--I know from people in my State whom I have talked to, for families in my State, the rising costs of raising children and educating them and their health care and their child care is a significant barrier to savings that we then see manifest later in life when they find they have not been able from their private savings or from participation in the workforce to be able to do what they would like to do. At the same time, of course, we know that the reduced number of children, the reduced birth rate, has follow-on effects generations later in terms of the number of people we have in the workforce who are then able to support those who are retired and to support our important programs like Social Security and Medicare, so there is a bit of a Catch-22 here that I think we are coming to a reckoning with as our society ages, as the number of children born to us declines, and as the cost of raising children goes up, so these are issues that I would like to see us continue to address. Thank you all for the important work you are doing, and thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Blumenthal? Senator Blumenthal. Thanks. Thank you, Senator Collins. I want to come back to Social Security, one of the key pillars of any retirement financially, and roughly half of seniors rely on Social Security for 50 percent of their income. One in five rely on it for 90 percent. Women are even more dependent on it generally than men, and many are living in poverty, but the news is not great looking to the future. As you say in your report, by--and I am going to read it to get it right, ``current projections indicate that by 2034, the Old-Age and Survivors trust fund for Social Security's retirement program . . . will only be sufficient to pay 77 percent of scheduled benefits . . .'' That is a really startling statistic, and it is not sort of, well, if everything goes right or wrong. That is the reality, and for the first time, in 2005 Social Security is paying out more than it is taking in. We are talking about all kinds of issues here that involve education and awareness and savings, but one of those key pillars very much within our direct control is Social Security, so the question is: What do we do? I have introduced legislation--it is called ``Social Security 2100"--along with Chris Van Hollen, my colleague here; John Larson in the House. We have really developed a complex and I think sophisticated approach that, in effect, increases the benefits that are going to be received to keep pace with the cost of living, not to reduce it. Far from it, to increase the benefits, but at the same time make it financially solvent through a series of changes in the tax structure and raising taxes, in effect, for people who earn more than $400,000--I am not going to ask for a show of hands here, but my guess is a very small number in this room and generally in the American public make more than that amount--and really to update the Social Security system. I would like to hear from the panel--after that somewhat long-winded introduction but incomplete because there is a lot more to say about Social Security--what you think about the importance of this kind of reform. Mr. Dodaro. I think it is essential to reform the Social Security system. I mentioned that the Social Security Old Age and Survivors Trust Fund will have only enough to pay 77 percent by 2034, but just to give you an idea of the magnitude of the issue, the net present value, the difference between expected expenditures for Social Security and revenues coming in over the next 75 years is $16.1 trillion, expenses over revenues, so you would have to make up that amount of money. Another way of looking at it, you would have to increase payroll taxes by 2.84 percent to cover that gap. There are obvious policy decisions. There are benefits versus revenues, but you have a very significant issue here, and then if you think about in the Medicare program net present value of the projected deficity over the next 75 years is $38 trillion, so if you look at Social Security and Medicare combined, the program is facing a $54 trillion deficit in funding for those programs based on their current arrangements over the next 75 years. This is a huge cost, and there are alternative estimates for Medicare, if health care costs go higher, that number could go even higher over that period of time. This is one of the factors driving the overall deficit situation in the Federal Government. Right now, as of Monday, the national debt stood at $21.9 trillion, and the interest costs on that debt are rising and by 2028 it is projected to be over $900 billion a year just paying interest on the debt, so there is a very serious long-term fiscal problem, and Social Security and Medicare are a central part that need to be dealt with in order to deal with this situation. Senator Blumenthal. Well, I would just point out, because my time has expired, put aside the Federal deficit, I am deeply alarmed about it. A number of us have raised important objections to the so-called tax reform to deficit spending in the budget because of it, but Social Security is a trust fund, and we have an obligation to make it solvent, and the costs of living, apart from the cost of medicine alone--and maybe we can do more to bring down the cost of pharmaceutical drugs and other costs of health care, but the cost of living we know is going to rise, and right now a lot of seniors will not be able to rely on Social Security to stay out of poverty, and I think that is something very much within our control. We need to address it now. Mr. Dodaro. I agree. Senator Blumenthal. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. Dodaro, I want to followup on a Social Security question also. Increasing the minimum Social Security benefit may be one option that Congress should examine to protect low- income beneficiaries who have little else to live on. I was surprised, as I started looking into this concept, to learn that the Social Security Administration's distribution analysis showed that raising the minimum benefits could also raise the benefits of many who are not actually low-income because they may, for example, be married to a high-earning spouse. Do you have any thoughts preliminarily on what could be done to ensure that any increase in the minimum benefit, which I am inclined to think is a good idea, is targeted to just low- income beneficiaries and that it does not have this impact that we see in the analysis that SSA has done? Mr. Dodaro. I would be happy to take a more detailed look at that and give you some more detailed suggestions, but preliminarily, in our look at this issue, one of the key issues, I think, would be to try to understand from Social Security how many people actually receive the minimum benefit. It has been a number of years since we looked at that issue, but the last time I think it was 2013. There were very few people who were at the minimum benefit. Most people with a spousal benefit, assuming your spouse did the right thing and you had that option, have a much higher beneft than the minimum amount. I think the first thing to do is where should the minimum be if you want to adjust the minimum to make a meaningful difference. Then once you do that, the analysis that we have looked at quickly for Social Security shows that there are some high-income earners who would benefit from this, particularly those that have investment income, and so the difference would be to try to focus on earnings versus total income as a means of trying to keep it more targeted to the lower-income people, but we can study this a little bit further and give you some suggestions in that area, but those are two things I would suggest. The Chairman. Thank you. That is very helpful, and I appreciate your offer to do some additional work for us in that area. Mr. Scott, you discussed the challenges facing workers without employer-sponsored plans, and, understandably, it tends to be smaller businesses that are less likely to offer these plans. What does your research show would prompt smaller employers to offer retirement plans? Mr. John Scott. That is a really, really good question and an important question, because we do know that the coverage is very low among small employers. I think the focus we have seen from our research is on the high cost of starting a plan, the sort of lack of internal administrative capacity or bandwidth to operate a plan. These are business owners who are, you know, doing more than one thing with their companies, and I think also just the lack of awareness of plan options. As I said in my testimony, only 11 percent are very familiar with SIMPLE plans and other options that are specifically designed for small business. Many are not aware of the existing tax credit for startup costs. I think there are a number of things in terms of just raising awareness and helping them--you know, giving them the tools to start plans. You know, in our conversations in focus groups of small business owners, they want to do the right thing. They want to help their employees save for retirement. They told us that repeatedly, but I think they really just need--you know, so the motivation is there. I think they really just need the tools and awareness of what is available to them that works for their business. The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. St. Peter, you have illustrated how in just 10 years your company really transformed its retirement savings options for your workers, and it is a remarkable success story for a business that has only about 100 employees. That, by the way, in Maine is a pretty good-sized business, but from your perspective on the ground, how can we encourage other small employers to take the same kind of steps you did to offer matching contributions, which seems to have been the key in the transformation of your plan, and take other steps to offer retirement savings programs? Mr. St. Peter. Yes, I agree with you. I think our matching component of the best practices that we implemented was the reason we were so successful. Any incentives that you can provide to businesses, tax-wise or other, education---I think education and outreach is really important, so I am not sure what the best instrument is there, but utilizing local Chambers of Commerce or other organizations that are in place. I really like what I heard about the multiple-employer plans and removing the nexus requirement, I think that would go a long way. Within our engineering consulting industry, we have at least one association we could use for a multiple-employer plan, but if you remove that nexus requirement, you get someone like a Chamber of Commerce or other entities that are already in place to form some of these multiple-employer plans, I think that would go a long way. The Chairman. Thank you very much. And, Ms. Stone, your testimony was excellent. I deferred to Senator Casey to lead the questioning on you, but I do appreciate your testimony as well. Ms. Stone. Thank you. The Chairman. Senator Casey. Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins. I will actually ask a similar question or along a similar line about access to retirement plans that work. Ms. Stone, we know that is a problem, obviously, for part- time workers as one category; small employers, as Mr. St. Peter was talking about, and the ways he and his company have confronted this challenge. Workers in low-wage industries might be another example. Can you speak more to how difficult it can be for workers with no access or very limited access to workplace retirement plans to save and how we can bring more workers into workplace plans, how that could help? Ms. Stone. Well, I think, as you mentioned, it is very difficult for somebody who does not have access to a workplace plan to try to figure this out for themselves, even if they want to save. You know, what is an IRA? How do you do that? Can I trust that person? How do I pick the investments? There is something about the structure of a workplace plan that gives people more assurance as well as providing the means and, frankly, the discipline to do ongoing savings. We know from some of the work that WISER has done with child caregivers in Appalachia, so very, very low-income women, that if you give an incentive to save and put something in place, they want to save. You know, women want to save, and so I think it is getting to the access to a plan. There is, what, 30 percent--we heard some numbers today--of private sector employees who have no access to a workplace retirement plan, so if something could be put in place that they would have access and also perhaps to reflect the fact that many women are working part-time and that cuts them out of participating in a plan that has a thousand-hour requirement, can we do something to change those participation requirements so women who are working perhaps consistently on a part-time basis can have access to a workplace plan and be able to save? Senator Casey. The last question was about more of a demographic focus. I think it is still the case that the fastest-growing population is 85 and up overall, and in your testimony you talked about that there are 5.7 million more women than men at age 65, but you also said 67 percent of the over-85 population are women, so basically two-thirds of everybody over 85 is, in fact, a woman. I have introduced legislation the last Congress--actually, Senator Wyden and Senator Brown and I introduced a bill that would strengthen Social Security benefits for the oldest among us and for those receiving particularly low benefits. Walk through, if you can, both the risks and the challenges that face retirees, especially those who live to that advanced age. Ms. Stone. Well, as I had mentioned, when you are over 85, most of those--the majority of those folks are women. Many of them at that point are alone and living alone. They are not married at that point, and so they have spent time caregiving for their spouses, oftentimes using up the assets, the savings that they did have, and so when it comes time for their time, you know, it is less likely that there is a family person to take care of them, so they have to pay for assistance, and we also heard mention today, you know, of the cost of long-term care and what that can do to somebody's financial security when you have a shock like that that is unexpected, and so it is this group that is most likely to end up in poverty, and what was telling to me was they end up in poverty even though they have not been poor or near-poor in their life. It is just the circumstance of the longevity and no one expecting to live that long and not being able to plan to live that long, having very low Social Security benefits, and, frankly, at that point little or no assets to draw upon. Senator Casey. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Braun? Senator Braun. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Blumenthal mentioned Social Security. I think that is so important because it is a structural thing that most people end up depending on when it comes to retirement. I disagree with the fact that--you know, he was talking about raising revenues. As an employer and knowing what the percentage is currently that employees and employers pay into it, I think you are going to have a tough time having that sell. You know, he mentioned tax reform. That, according to CBO, was, I think, $150 billion per year, $1.5 trillion over 10 years, and in the Budget Committee the other day, I asked Director Hall, and he said, you know, he did not agree with the fact that it is revenue neutral so far, but he said you at least need to look at the fact when you are growing 3 percent, tax reform, you know, might be closer to neutral than negative on the deficit--my point being it goes back to employers, you know, having that extra capacity paying less to the Federal Government, so I think anybody out there that is an employer, look at enhancing your 401(k). Take on your health insurance issues. We did it. You could lower costs dramatically, but you have got to take risks and have the nerve to do it, lowering health care costs, which is such a big deal because the Medicare component was as lot larger than Social Security, so I think that those are the angles that are going to work better than what the Senator was referring to. Here is something in health care. Senator Paul has talked about it, I believe it is necessary: pooling and associating so you do not have individuals stranded out there with the poorest buying power possible to try to get, you know, good advice and any of the economy of scale that would come from having 300, 500, 1,000 employees. Is pooling and association, which has been kind of loath for health care to embrace, which they should? What about financial services? Maybe Mr. Scott or whoever would have some knowledge. Is that percolating out there to help individual folks planning for retirement? Mr. John Scott. Yes, I think there is a lot of interest in taking a pooled approach or an association approach to retirement savings, offering retirement benefits through sort of a pooled approach. I think, you know, in our polling, our survey work around the issue, we did raise the topic of multiple-employer plans, which is one pooled approach, and there is a lot of interest in that. A lot of the small business owners expressed or said that it would be very useful to them if they could sort of join in a multiple-employer plan. Of course, it is still voluntary. They still have to sort of make that decision individually if it makes sense from a business perspective to join in, so it is not clear if they will at the end of the day, but I think that is certainly an important option to be considered. Senator Braun. Do you see much of that happening out there? Is the impetus going to have to come from employers to push it? Or do you think the financial services industry will reach out to what to me looks like a big market to try to get an economy of scale there? Mr. John Scott. Yes, it is a really good question. I think Mr. St. Peter mentioned that, you know, there is some interest within the Government in terms of expanding the opportunity to join in multiple-employer plans, so you know, we are looking to see if there will be any guidance from the Department of Labor on this particular issue. Then, of course, it is a question of whether the financial services industry will put together the products. You know, retirement plans are sold to employers, so they will have to follow through on their end to construct pooled products that make sense for the individual business owner. Senator Braun. Thank you. Anybody else want to weigh in? Go ahead. Mr. St. Peter. Just a couple things. We have acquired some small firms in the last 5 years. Two of them had SIMPLE plans; one of them had a 401(k) profit plan, I think underachieving the success that we are having now, now that we are bigger,and then on health care, we did pool with our association, ACEC, and it was very successful for us for many years for our health care insurance. Senator Braun. When did you start that? Mr. St. Peter. It was probably 5 years ago. The funny thing is we did just opt out of it to another plan, but during those 5 years, it was very successful for us. Senator Braun. Measurable cost savings by doing it? Mr. St. Peter. Very, very much. Senator Braun. Good. Mr. St. Peter. We have also implemented--not the H.R. director. We share deductibles. I think it is HRA, so it is a bit of self-insuring ourselves. We have higher-deductible plans, HSAs with an HRA to help share the cost of that deductible and out-of-pocket expense, and that has been very successful for us, too. Senator Braun. Good. I am out of time. I yield back. The Chairman. Thank you so much. I would like to thank all of our witnesses for testifying today and sharing your analysis, recommendations, and insights on how Americans can better prepare for a secure retirement today and for generations to come. Your ideas, your expertise, your knowledge is extremely valuable to our Committee as we continue to work on how we can improve retirement security for all Americans. I believe that this is an issue that Congress must grapple with, and yet it really has not received much attention despite all the red flags and warning signs that we are seeing. This week, as I mentioned in my opening statement, I introduced two bipartisan bills that would better promote greater retirement security. Together, the Retirement Security Act and the SIMPLE Plan Modernization Act would encourage more employers to offer retirement plans and provide incentives for employees to save more for their own retirements. The frustration that I feel is we know this crisis is looming. We know that the three traditional pillars of our system--Social Security, pension plans, and personal savings-- are all three on very shaky ground, and yet it is an area that, because it is so difficult, Congress has tended to shy away from tackling what is a very important challenge, particularly given the changing demographics of our country with people living far longer and our population growing older. This will remain a major focus of our Committee. I appreciate the work that Senator Casey has done as well, and I want to thank our staff, which has done an excellent job in putting together this hearing. That is always key to a successful hearing. Committee members will have until Friday, February 15th, to submit any additional questions for the record, so some may be coming your way. I appreciate the fact that many of you have offered to keep in touch with the Committee and continue to assist us with our work on this important topic. Senator Casey? Senator Casey. Thank you, Chairman Collins, for the hearing on this critical issue. We have heard from our witnesses about our Nation's retirement system that works well for some but, as I said earlier, lets many others fall through the cracks. We do have to work together, as the Chairman said, to address the shortcomings of our retirement system. Part of that, of course, is strengthening Social Security and ensuring it keeps the promise of financial security in retirement. Part of that I think would be passing legislation like my bill to help both widows but also widowers because of the arcane and destructive claiming rules and other problems with the system. We have got to take action to ensure that workers depending on pensions that they have earned are not left struggling to make ends meet in their retirement years. We have got to work to improve access to retirement plans and to Government incentives to save so that our retirement system is serving every worker and not just some. So we look forward to continuing this work, and I want to thank our colleagues on the Committee, Chairman Collins, and also, of course, our witnesses for being here. Really a good education for all of us. Thanks very much. The Chairman. Thank you. This hearing is now adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:14 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Statements for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]