AMNESTY AND CHAOS: ABUSE OF U.S. IMMIGRATION POLICY

Committee on Oversight and Government Reform House June 9, 2026

Witnesses (4)

  • Mr. Mark Krikorian, Executive Director, Center for Immigration Studies
  • Mr. Matt O'Brien, Deputy Executive Director, Federation for American Immigration Reform
  • Mr. Chris Newman, General Counsel and Legal Director, National Day Laborer Organizing Network (NDLON)
  • Mr. David Bier (Minority Witness), Director of Immigration Studies, CATO Institute

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- AMNESTY AND CHAOS: ABUSE OF U.S. IMMIGRATION POLICY

[House Hearing, 119 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 AMNESTY AND CHAOS:
 ABUSE OF U.S. IMMIGRATION POLICY
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 TASK FORCE ON DEFENDING CONSTITUTIONAL 
 RIGHTS AND EXPOSING INSTITUTIONAL ABUSES

 OF THE

 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM

 U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 JUNE 9, 2026

 __________

 Serial No. 119-66

 __________

Printed for the use of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 Available on: govinfo.gov, oversight.house.gov or docs.house.gov
 
 __________
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
63-956 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
=======================================================================
 
 COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNMENT REFORM

 JAMES COMER, Kentucky, Chairman

Jim Jordan, Ohio Robert Garcia, California, Ranking 
Mike Turner, Ohio Minority Member
Paul Gosar, Arizona Eleanor Holmes Norton, District of 
Virginia Foxx, North Carolina Columbia
Glenn Grothman, Wisconsin Stephen F. Lynch, Massachusetts
Michael Cloud, Texas Raja Krishnamoorthi, Illinois
Gary Palmer, Alabama Ro Khanna, California
Clay Higgins, Louisiana Kweisi Mfume, Maryland
Pete Sessions, Texas Shontel Brown, Ohio
Andy Biggs, Arizona Melanie Stansbury, New Mexico
Nancy Mace, South Carolina Maxwell Frost, Florida
Pat Fallon, Texas Greg Casar, Texas
Byron Donalds, Florida Jasmine Crockett, Texas
Scott Perry, Pennsylvania Emily Randall, Washington
William Timmons, South Carolina Suhas Subramanyam, Virginia
Tim Burchett, Tennessee Yassamin Ansari, Arizona
Lauren Boebert, Colorado Wesley Bell, Missouri
Anna Paulina Luna, Florida Lateefah Simon, California
Nick Langworthy, New York Dave Min, California
Eric Burlison, Missouri James Walkinshaw, Virginia
Elijah Crane, Arizona Christian Menefee, Texas
Brian Jack, Georgia Ayanna Pressley, Massachusetts
John McGuire, Virginia Rashida Tlaib, Michigan
Brandon Gill, Texas
Richard McCormick, Georgia

 ------ 

 Mark Marin, Staff Director
 James Rust, Deputy Staff Director
 Ryan Giachetti, Chief Counsel
 Karl Keyzer-Andre, Professional Staff Member
 Rodney Rios, Counsel
 Mallory Cogar, Director of Operations and Chief Clerk

 Contact Number: 202-225-5074

 Robert Edmonson, Minority Staff Director
 Contact Number: 202-225-5051
 ------ 

 Task Force on Defending Constitutional Rights and Exposing 
 Institutional Abuses

 Brandon Gill, Texas, Chairman

Jim Jordan, Ohio Lateefah Simon, California, 
Michael Cloud, Texas Ranking Member
Andy Biggs, Arizona Dave Min, California
Byron Donalds, Florida James Walkinshaw, Virginia
Brian Jack, Georgia Ayanna Pressley, Massachusetts
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Page

Hon. Brandon Gill, U.S. Representative, Chairman................. 1

Hon. Lateefah Simon, U.S. Representative, Ranking Member......... 3

 WITNESSES

Mr. Mark Krikorian, Executive Director, Center for Immigration 
 Studies
Oral Statement................................................... 4

Mr. Matt O'Brien, Deputy Executive Director, Federation for 
 American Immigration Reform
Oral Statement................................................... 6

Mr. Chris Newman, General Counsel and Legal Director, National 
 Day Laborer Organizing Network (NDLON)
Oral Statement................................................... 8

Mr. David Bier (Minority Witness), Director of Immigration 
 Studies, CATO Institute
Oral Statement................................................... 9

Written opening statements and bios are available on the U.S. 
 House of Representatives Document Repository at: 
 docs.house.gov.

 INDEX OF DOCUMENTS

 * Article, NBC, `` `Abolish ICE' Creeps Back into Democratic 
 Messaging''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, PolitiFact, `` `Abolish ICE' Movement is Growing. Is 
 the Agency's Disbanding Likely?''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, The Hill, ``Democratic Rep. Shri Thanedar Proposes 
 Abolish ICE Act''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, The New Republic, ``Here Are All the Democrats Who 
 Voted to Keep Funding ICE''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, MEAWW, ``Mamdani Tells Democrats to Ignore Party 
 Leaders and Abolish ICE''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, Fox News, ``Mamdani Urges Democrats to Fully Embrace 
 the `Abolish ICE' Message''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, NJ, ``Unapologetic Sherrill Defends Sending State 
 Police to Delaney Hall, Blames Out-of-State Agitators for 
 Violent Clashes''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, NJ, ``Violent Clash Erupts at Delaney Hall. Chaos 
 Follows Sherrill's `Peaceful Protest Zone' Plan''; submitted by 
 Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, Yahoo News, ``Violent Delaney Hall Protests Again 
 Grow Chaotic''; submitted by Rep. Biggs.

 * Article, UN News, ``30,000 People Flee Fresh Violence in 
 Haiti''; submitted by Rep. Simon.

 * Article, Brennan Center for Justice, ``DHS Warrantless Home 
 Entry''; submitted by Rep. Simon.

 * Article, NPR, ``New Lawsuit Alleges DHS Illegally Tracked and 
 Intimidated Observers''; submitted by Rep. Simon.

 * Article, NPR, ``Police say ICE Tactics are Eroding Public 
 Trust''; submitted by Rep. Simon.

 * Article, AP News, ``Trump Says He Wants to Deport the `Worst 
 of the Worst.' Government Data Tells Another Story''; submitted 
 by Rep. Simon.

The documents listed above are available at: docs.house.gov.

 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS

 * Questions for the Record: Mr. Mark Krikorian; submitted by 
 Rep. Eli Crane.

 * Questions for the Record: Mr. Matt O'Brien; submitted by Rep. 
 Eli Crane.

These documents were submitted after the hearing, and may be 
 available upon request.

 
 AMNESTY AND CHAOS:
 ABUSE OF U.S. IMMIGRATION POLICY

 ---------- 

 TUESDAY, JUNE 9, 2026

 U.S. House of Representatives

 Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

 Task Force on Defending Constitutional Rights and Exposing 
 Institutional Abuses

 Washington, D.C.

 The Task Force met, pursuant to notice, at 9:37 a.m., in 
room 2154, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Brandon Gill, 
[Chairman of the Task Force] presiding.
 Present: Representatives Gill, Cloud, Biggs, Jack, Simon, 
Min, Walkinshaw, and Pressley.
 Also present: Representative Crane.
 Mr. Gill. This hearing on the Task Force on Defending 
Constitutional Rights and Exposing Institutional Abuses will 
come to order.
 So, welcome everybody. Thank you to the witnesses for 
taking the time to come out here. We certainly always really 
appreciate it.
 Without objection, the Chair may declare a recess at any 
time, and I now recognize myself for the purposes of making an 
opening statement.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF CHAIRMAN BRANDON GILL

 REPRESENTATIVE FROM TEXAS

 Good morning, and welcome to today's important hearing on 
abuses of the U.S. immigration system and their effects on our 
Nation. Prior administrations and the infinite amnesty lobby 
weaponized the U.S. immigration system, both for political gain 
and at the expense of the American people putting foreigners 
over our own citizens. The Biden Administration flooded our 
country with millions of illegal aliens unvetted from all over 
the globe, and the impact has been to reduce working-class 
wages, to strain our social system, our education system, our 
healthcare system, and to culturally transform the United 
States. At the same time, it has devalued the meaning of 
American citizenship to the detriment of the American people. 
The American people were left picking up the pieces, which is 
precisely why they elected President Donald Trump in the last 
election cycle to both secure the border and to deport illegal 
aliens, and he has done exactly that. He secured the border in 
record time whenever nobody in the American political class 
thought that it was possible, and he has begun the largest 
deportation campaign in American history.
 And yet, despite the political pressure that has caused him 
to do that, the left has pursued frivolous and coordinated 
litigation that seeks to subvert the will of the American 
people and negate our immigration laws and effectively reopen 
our border. The intent it seems of this litigation is to make 
immigration law ineffective and unenforceable. To this end, we 
have a vast network of radically left-wing Nongovernmental 
Organization (NGO)s providing legal services and other support 
to illegal aliens. We have seen coordinated campaigns against 
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) personnel and 
facilities across the country. And even now, Democrats are 
holding up funding for ICE and Border Patrol, causing a partial 
government shutdown, while at the same time, adamantly opposing 
the Save America Act, which would provide commonsense voter ID 
laws and citizenship requirements to vote in American 
elections.
 I think the key question that many Americans ask themselves 
is why is that? Why would Democrats oppose borders and oppose 
citizenship requirements to vote in our elections? And I think 
that the answer is, of course, because they believe that they 
gain politically from open borders, both from the impact of 
illegal aliens impacting congressional apportionment. Illegal 
aliens tend to congregate in sanctuary states and sanctuary 
cities which tend to be blue, which gives Democrats greater 
congressional representation at the expense of Republicans, 
while at the same time, Democrats are making the bet that 
illegal aliens who do vote in our elections will vote Democrat. 
That is something that Democrats have talked about for quite 
some time now, and I think that that is the motivation behind 
pushes for amnesty in many cases.
 At the same time, Democrats are doing everything they can 
to keep as many of these illegal aliens, people who came into 
our country illegally, here as possible, and we do not need to 
look any further than the Temporary Protected Status, or TPS, 
system. Temporary Protective Status, which was originally 
intended to be just that, it was intended to be a temporary 
reprieve from deportation due to specific circumstances, yet 
the Biden Administration abused it and has utilized TPS as a 
form of backdoor amnesty for over a million people who entered 
our country illegally.
 The numbers speak for themselves. At the start of the Biden 
Administration, there were just about 410,000 TPS beneficiaries 
from ten countries. In four years, that number increased by 
over a million to 1.4 million thanks to new TPS designations 
and redesignations for multiple countries. That includes Burma 
in 2021, Ukraine in 2022, Afghanistan in 2022, Cameroon in 
2022, Ethiopia in 2022, Venezuela in 2021 and 2023, Haiti in 
2024, and Lebanon in 2024. About half of all current TPS 
beneficiaries were not even residing in the United States until 
after Joe Biden took office. In other words, TPS was a vehicle 
for providing backdoor amnesty for the very people that the 
American people saw pouring into our border for four years and 
voted President Trump into office to deport.
 Moreover, the vast majority of the people covered under TPS 
did enter the United States illegally, and I think that is 
really important. That includes an estimated 95 percent of all 
Venezuelan TPS holders and 91 percent of all estimated Haitian 
TPS holders. This and many others are precisely the abuses of 
our immigration system that Republicans were elected to stop, 
and it is going to be the focus of our hearing today. So, I 
look forward to hearing from the witnesses today about how this 
institutional abuse occurred and continues to occur, and what 
needs to be done to restore an immigration system that works 
for the benefit of the American people.
 And with that, I yield to the Ranking Member Simon for her 
opening statement.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF RANKING MEMBER

 LATEEFAH SIMON

 REPRESENTATIVE FROM CALIFORNIA

 Ms. Simon. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the 
witnesses for traveling here, and thank you to members of the 
public for being a part of this hearing today.
 So, I find it rather ironic that we are holding a hearing 
today that ignores the systemic abuse of constitutional rights 
by our current Administration. Now, if we are serious about 
addressing our broken immigration system, then we cannot only 
scrutinize those navigating that system, we must also 
scrutinize the government's role in driving the chaos and the 
abuse.
 The Constitution is a promise, a promise that government 
power will be exercised fairly. It is a promise that no one 
will be denied due process under the law. Now, at the moment, 
when the Republicans are pushing through a second 
reconciliation or funding package to provide billions in 
additional funding for immigration enforcement, we do, in this 
room, have an obligation to ask whether those resources will 
uphold constitutional rights and human dignity. As taxpayers, 
we have to ask those questions. Now our taxpayers are being 
asked to finance more detention facilities while basic 
questions around accountability remain unanswered. Across this 
country, from Oakland, where I represent, to Minnesota, people 
are asking whether their government sees their humanity. There 
are families who are watching families separated, communities 
living in fear, and lives forever changed by Federal 
enforcement activities and actions carried out in their own 
neighborhoods.
 Now, before we give another dollar to this Administration's 
immigration enforcement machine, we must examine consequences 
of these policies firsthand. We should be examining facilities 
like Delaney Hall where reports of inadequate medical care have 
been met by this Administration with indifference. We should be 
talking about American citizens--American citizens--who have 
been killed and wrongfully detained, American citizens, or how 
immigrant detainees are dying in custody and children, babies, 
are left wondering if they will ever see their parents again. 
Now, allegations of excessive force and medical neglect and the 
mishandling of sexual assault cases--rape--deserve serious 
oversight, not billions of dollars in more funding for 
uncountable and unaccountable Agencies like ICE and Customs and 
Border Protection (CBP). Rather than making communities safer, 
I assert that this Administration is terrorizing them in our 
communities.
 As a representative of one of the most diverse districts in 
this Nation, I approach this issue today through the premise 
and the praxis of both humanity and the law. Immigrants are 
workers, they are scientists, they are physicians, they are 
caregivers and taxpayers, part of our communities and part of 
our economy, and they should not be scapegoated for the 
economic challenges facing working families across our Nation. 
The Bay Area Council Economic Institute found that the Bay Area 
alone stands to lose $67 billion in regional GDP and $8.4 
billion of annual tax revenue from this Administration's 
immigration enforcement activities.
 Now, the true measure of our values in this country is not 
how we treat and anoint the powerful, but how we treat the 
people with the least power in the room. When families are torn 
apart, when people are dying in custody without due process, 
and when constitutional rights are denied and ignored, our 
responsibility is not to look the other way. Our responsibility 
is to demand accountability to protect human dignity and to 
ensure that government power is never, ever exercised without 
scrutiny. That is the standard that I hope this hearing will 
uphold, and I look forward to hearing all of the testimony and 
the comments from our witnesses. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I yield 
back.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Ranking Member Simon, and without 
objection, Representative Eli Crane of Arizona is going to be 
waived on the Task Force for the purpose of asking questions at 
today's hearing.
 Pursuant to Committee Rule 9(g), the witnesses will please 
stand and raise their right hand.
 Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony that you 
are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing 
but the truth, so help you God?
 Mr. Krikorian. I do.
 Mr. O'Brien. I do.
 Mr. Newman. I do.
 Mr. Bier. I do.
 Mr. Gill. Let the record show that the witnesses answered 
in the affirmative, and thank you. You can take a seat. We 
appreciate you being here today and look forward to all of your 
testimonies.
 Let me remind the witnesses that we have read your written 
statement, and it will appear in full in the hearing record. 
Please limit your oral statement to 5 minutes. As a reminder, 
please press the button on the microphone in front of you so 
that it is on and the Members can hear you. When you begin to 
speak, the light in front of you will turn green. After 4 
minutes, the light will turn yellow. When the red light comes 
on, your 5 minutes have expired, and we would ask that you 
please wrap up.
 And now we can go ahead and begin opening testimonies, and 
I now recognize Mr. Krikorian for his opening statement.

 STATEMENT OF MR. MARK KRIKORIAN

 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, CENTER FOR IMMIGRATION STUDIES

 Mr. Krikorian. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Abuse of our 
immigration system is widespread. Criticism often focuses on 
fraud, and there is certainly plenty of that, but arguably, 
more alarming and certainly more amenable to congressional 
action is when the executive branch itself is engaging in abuse 
of the immigration system.
 I would like to discuss two immigration programs, duly 
enacted by Congress, but which have been abused so flagrantly 
and so consistently by Presidents of both parties, I am afraid, 
over a period of decades, that they have demonstrated that the 
executive branch simply cannot be trusted to exercise 
discretion responsibly in immigration matters. The two programs 
are immigration parole and Temporary Protected Status (TPS).
 Presidents have used parole to allow in foreigners who have 
no right to be here in any number, anyone they want, for any 
reason, for as long as they want, and Presidents have used TPS 
to let people who have already illegally entered the country 
stay indefinitely. And the key in both cases is that the point 
is to get work permits and Social Security numbers into the 
hands of illegal immigrants, so it is harder to deport them in 
the future. Those two programs are the pillars of a shadow 
immigration system operated across Administrations to 
circumvent immigration limits enacted by Congress.
 Immigration parole is the first, and it was invented in 
1952 to enable the executive branch to let in certain specific 
individuals for emergency or reasons of great importance to the 
Nation. It was understood to mean people with medical 
emergencies or people who had to appear in court. They did not 
specify in that granular detail because in that naive age in 
the 1950s, Congress assumed that the executive branch would 
exercise its discretion responsibly. They were disabused of 
that notion almost immediately. Presidents used parole to 
affect the mass importation of refugees. Congress was so 
frustrated they passed the 1980 Refugee Act so that Presidents 
would have a lawful system to use.
 Unfortunately, when that happened, the Executive then 
invented whole new parole programs that had nothing to do with 
refugees: family reunification parole, Central-American minors 
parole, international entrepreneur parole, and something called 
parole in place, which is a legal fiction where illegal aliens 
are retroactively paroled. So, parole for almost every purpose. 
But those abuses pale in the light of the misconduct of the 
Biden Administration and its DHS, led by Secretary Alejandro 
Mayorkas, who paroled in nearly three million inadmissible 
aliens, more than all previous grants of parole combined, which 
was one of the main reasons this House impeached Secretary 
Mayorkas.
 The other pillar of this shadow immigration system is 
Temporary Protected Status. And again, as with parole, the 
point was Congress trying to fence in Executive freelancing 
because before that, what Presidents had done who did not want 
to deport illegal aliens is they made up this fake status, 
which has no basis in law, called extended voluntary 
departure--EVD. And so, the point of TPS was to create kind of 
a system that was regularized and subject to oversight. The 
problem is when the first grant of TPS, which was granted to 
Salvadorans, who were pretty much all still here, when that 
expired, the first Bush Administration made up another three 
initial fake status called Deferred Enforced Departure--DED--to 
let them all stay. So, whether it is EVD or TPS or DED, it does 
not matter. It is all the same thing: get work permits into the 
hands of illegal immigrants. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration 
Services (USCIS) currently lists 12 countries whose illegal 
aliens have TPS, and the total number is estimated at more than 
1.3 million.
 So, what can Congress do about this? Trying to fence in 
parole and TPS by adding more adjectives and adverbs to the law 
is not going to work. It has not worked before. It is not going 
to work again. There are three changes I would suggest to limit 
these kind of abuses. One, repeal the TPS statute. There is no 
need for it. ICE can always withhold/suspend deportation for 60 
days or 90 days if there is some problem at, say, the airport 
in a country suffering from an earthquake. Number two, cap 
parole. Numerically limit grants of parole. You need some kind 
of parole because you need to have a little wiggle room in any 
big system, but Presidents have shown they cannot be trusted 
with discretion, so that a numerical cap, there has been a 
legislative suggestion of 3,000 a year, maybe 5,000 a year. I 
do not have a magic number, but the idea is the same. And most 
important, prohibit DHS from giving work permits to any alien 
whose statutory status does not expressly provide for it, like, 
say, an H-1B.
 None of those changes are going to end all abuses of the 
immigration system. Asylum, in particular, is one of the real 
problems that Congress eventually is going to have to deal 
with, but the changes I have outlined would go a long way to 
limiting freelancing by future Presidents and restoring 
Congress' authority over this area of immigration. Thanks for 
your indulgence, and I look forward to your questions.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Krikorian, and I now recognize 
Matt O'Brien for the purpose of making an opening statement.

 STATEMENT OF MR. MATT O'BRIEN

 DEPUTY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

 FEDERATION FOR AMERICAN IMMIGRATION REFORM

 Mr. O'Brien. Chairman Gill, Ranking Member Simon, and 
Members of the Task Force, my name is Matthew O'Brien. I am a 
former Assistant Chief Immigration Judge, and I previously 
served in senior positions with the Department of Homeland 
Security, and earlier in my career with the former Immigration 
and Naturalization Service. I appreciate the chance to share my 
perspective on the continuing breakdown in the enforcement and 
administration of our immigration laws.
 For many years, people across the political spectrum have 
said that our immigration system is broken. In my view, that is 
true, but not necessarily for the reasons most often cited. The 
core problem is straightforward. For decades, Administrations 
of both parties have selectively ignored portions of the 
Immigration and Nationality Act, or INA, when those provisions 
were viewed as politically inconvenient. As a result, the 
agencies charged with enforcing our immigration laws have too 
often relied on inconsistent regulations, shifting policy 
memoranda, and operational guidance that depart from the text 
and the intent of the laws enacted by Congress. To put it 
plainly, the executive branch has repeatedly substituted policy 
preferences for statutory requirements.
 Now, that should concern everyone regardless of party or 
position on immigration policy because our constitutional 
system depends on each branch of government respecting its 
proper role. Congress writes the laws, the Executive enforces 
them, and the courts interpret them in cases of genuine legal 
dispute. In the immigration context, however, that balance has 
frequently broken down. Congress has enacted immigration 
statutes that reflect policy choices made through the 
democratic process, but successive Administrations have often 
attempted to circumvent those choices through executive action. 
At the same time, some states have sought to exempt themselves 
from Federal immigration enforcement despite longstanding 
Supreme Court precedent recognizing immigration as primarily a 
Federal responsibility.
 The result has been a confusing and often contradictory 
system that undermines public confidence and creates incentives 
for further violations of the law. During my 30 years working 
in immigration law and policy, I often heard a phrase repeated 
by immigration officers and DHS attorneys, ``The case isn't 
over until the alien wins.'' That sentiment reflected a growing 
belief that the system increasingly prioritized delay and 
loopholes over consistent enforcement of the law.
 Now, historically, our immigration system operated on the 
principle that foreign nationals seeking admission to the 
United States or immigration benefits within the United States 
had the burden of establishing eligibility under the law. 
Legally, that framework still exists. In practice, however, 
many modern policies have treated virtually every humanitarian 
or discretionary program, including parole, TPS, and asylum, as 
opportunities to create broad exemptions to statutory limits 
established by Congress. Yet, the Supreme Court has 
consistently reaffirmed that unadmitted, non-resident aliens do 
not possess any constitutional right to enter the United 
States, and that has been true from Ekiu v. United States, 
decided in 1892 to Department of State v. Munoz, which was 
decided in 2024. The Court has repeatedly recognized Congress' 
broad authority over immigration and the Federal Government's 
power to regulate admission into the country.
 At the same time, efforts to restore enforcement and 
administrative order have often been met with claims that even 
individuals who knowingly violated the immigration laws of the 
United States are entitled to expansive procedural protections 
far beyond those contemplated by the INA and by the 
Constitution. President Ronald Reagan once said, ``We must 
reject the idea that every time a law is broken, society is 
guilty rather than the lawbreaker.'' I believe that principle 
remains relevant today. A functioning legal system requires 
accountability, consistency, and respect for the rule of law. 
The American people expect an immigration system that is 
lawful, orderly, and faithfully administered according to the 
statutes enacted by Congress.
 Regardless of where one stands politically, we should all 
agree that immigration policy must be made through the 
constitutional process, not through unilateral executive 
action, selective enforcement, or attempts by individual states 
to override the Federal law. Congress has both the authority 
and the responsibility to insist that the INA be enforced as 
written and that all levels of government respect the 
constitutional separation of powers upon which our system 
depends.
 Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. O'Brien, and I now recognize Chris 
Newman for his opening statement for 5 minutes.

 STATEMENT OF MR. CHRIS NEWMAN

 GENERAL COUNSEL AND LEGAL DIRECTOR

 NATIONAL DAY LABORER ORGANIZING NETWORK (NDLON)

 Mr. Newman. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member, and other 
distinguished Members of the Task Force, my name is Chris 
Newman. I am the Legal Director at the National Day Laborer 
Organizing Network where I have worked for more than 20 years 
defending the rights of workers and residents in this country, 
including many people that you may call illegal immigrants, 
including people that Stephen Miller has called invaders, and 
including names that the President has called them that I will 
not even repeat in this Committee. I call them my friends, my 
family, my clients, and I am grateful to testify on their 
behalf.
 Testifying before Congress for the first time should be 
considered an honor, but honesty demands that I tell you that 
it does not feel that way today. This institution's failure to 
do its job in general, and on immigration in particular, has 
caused real harm to the American public, and I think on that, 
we can all agree. For both parties, as has been said, the chaos 
caused by unjust, outdated immigration laws has become an issue 
to exploit politically. A way to change the subject from work 
that you, Members of Congress, should be doing to rebuild our 
infrastructure, lower costs, raise wages, reign in oligarchs, 
and just delivering for everyday working people. But for people 
in power, the chaos has been good for business. It has been 
good for your business. Well, I should tell you, I am here to 
tell you that it is not good for the country.
 Last week, I was talking to my son, who just finished 4th 
grade, about the issue of bullying. When I told him that I was 
coming to speak before Congress, he told me to be careful. He 
heard that there are people that were mean to immigrants here, 
and he knew that this is a place where dangerous things 
happened on January 6. Then he asked me why I was invited, and 
I told him I did not know. I suspect that my invitation was 
less about seeking my expertise and more about sending a 
message to me, to my colleagues, and to others that no one who 
defends immigrants is beyond reach of intimidation and 
retaliation. So, I want to tell this Committee the same thing I 
told my son: I was raised not to bow to bullies. I draw courage 
from those who have withstood far worse than anything that will 
come at me with these questions that you guys will have today, 
and now onto the substance.
 The title of this hearing, which I think is called 
``Amnesty and Chaos,'' is riddled with irony. The Majority's 
own witness, Mark Krikorian, to my right, has acknowledged that 
amnesty--his word, not mine--is inevitable. He says he wants 
enforcement first, but enforcement that we have seen has been 
the true cause of chaos, fomenting violence and delegitimizing 
the rule of law.
 [Photo]
 Mr. Newman. A year ago today, this was the scene in my 
hometown of Los Angeles, California. The violent assault on our 
community produced a bottom-up wave of unity and peaceful 
protests that has spread to Chicago, Minneapolis, and, most 
recently, New Jersey. Ordinary people standing in public 
squares defending each other and their shared values have shown 
more courage than this institution has shown in a generation.
 The people at the center of the debate today, the people 
who I have the privilege of working for, to borrow the words of 
one of the greatest bands in American history, Los Tigres del 
Norte, are more American than many of the detractors that hurl 
epithets at them. They are not abstractions. They are not 
chaos. They are, in many cases, victims of exploitation, civil 
rights abuse, and when they try to speak up, they are 
intimidated and unable to document their abuse because of the 
fear of retaliation. Look, the evidence in this congressional 
record for 20 years is clear. Immigrants strengthen the country 
economically, culturally, demographically, they do not cause 
crime, et cetera. Equally unambiguous is that the people who 
profit from this coarsening debate are you all, for-profit 
prisons, demagogues who would rather keep a problem than solve 
it, putting your own interests for political power in front of 
the interests of the American people.
 So, I come here today with a challenge and an offer. My 
challenge is this: please stop dehumanizing immigrants, stop 
weaponizing immigration for political gain, and start doing 
actual work. You know, there is obviously a consensus of people 
that support amnesty for Dreamers and for people with TPS who 
have been here for years. We can talk about that. Immigrants 
deserve political equality the same as all of our previous 
generations were afforded it coming into this country. It is 
time for you guys to act, and here is my offer.
 I am here in genuine good faith today. I did not have to be 
here. I came at the invitation of the Chair, and I am here to 
try to find common ground. I believe that there are people on 
this Committee who care about the rule of law, workers' wages, 
public safety, and the national interest. So do I. I have spent 
my career working to advance these things. I am not your enemy. 
I will not pretend otherwise, even if this hearing and my 
invitation to it was designed to treat me as an enemy. I look 
forward to your questions and a spirited discussion. Thank you 
very much.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Newman, and I now recognize David 
Bier for his opening statement.

 STATEMENT OF MR. DAVID BIER (MINORITY WITNESS) DIRECTOR OF 
 IMMIGRATION STUDIES, CATO INSTITUTE

 Mr. Bier. Thank you all for the opportunity to testify 
before this Task Force on Constitutional Rights and Exposing 
Institutional Abuses. The Cato Institute's half century of 
research has shown that when constitutional rights are secure, 
people, whatever their ancestry, background, or birthplace, can 
thrive. Unfortunately, our current immigration policy is indeed 
leading to constitutional abuses.
 Courts have found that DHS has likely violated at least the 
First, Fourth, Fifth, Tenth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the 
U.S. Constitution, as well as the spending power, the taxing 
power, the writ of habeas corpus. DHS agents invade homes 
without judicial warrants. They arrest and detain legal 
immigrants, U.S. citizens, and others without evidence of a 
violation of law. They detain Americans based on their 
perceived demographics and race. They deport legal immigrants 
for their speech, and they threaten Americans who record and 
protest the abuses.
 DHS agents pumped ten bullets into U.S. citizen, Alex 
Pretti, a nurse for veterans who was peacefully protesting, yet 
officials immediately labeled him a terrorist simply for 
lawfully possessing a firearm while protesting, a complete 
repudiation of the Second Amendment. DHS has arrested and 
falsely accused dozens, maybe hundreds of people of assaults, 
only for charges to be dismissed when their lies were exposed. 
In fact, most people that DHS has publicly accused of assault 
were never even charged, let alone convicted. Willful 
deprivations of constitutional rights under color of law are 
crimes under Section 242 of Title 18 of the U.S. Code, yet the 
violations continue. Why? Amnesty. Whatever this hearing's 
intent, the amnesty happening now is not for immigrants. It is 
for government agents who violate the Constitution with 
impunity.
 The amnesty has five main causes. First, DHS has gutted 
internal review mechanisms by, for example, firing 80 percent 
of the Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Office. Second, DHS 
regularly undermines state investigations by withholding 
evidence to protect its agents who hide behind their masks. 
Third, DHS has repeatedly ignored court orders, and last week, 
the new DHS Secretary refused to repudiate that behavior under 
oath. Fourth, DHS has imposed multiple unconstitutional 
policies in secret, thwarting judicial review. Fifth and 
perhaps most importantly, the Administration tells DHS agents 
they have absolute immunity and will not be held to account. 
The President's pardons for his allies further embolden rogue 
agents.
 So, what recourse do citizens have? Sadly, very little. 
First, you could request a court injunction. Americans believe, 
somewhat naively, that if a policy is illegal, you can just go 
to a court and ask them to stop it. In reality, your rights 
having been violated is insufficient. You need to show that you 
are likely to be targeted again and that blocking the policy is 
the only way to achieve that goal. Unless the government admits 
it will go after you, that is a huge barrier to stopping the 
policy, and even if you win, DHS is often free to continue the 
policy against other people in other places. That is because of 
the Supreme Court's decision last year that no statute permits 
universal injunctions by district courts.
 Your second option is to sue the agents for damages, but 
since Federal law only allows suits against state agents, not 
Federal ones, there is effectively no way to sue DHS agents for 
constitutional violations in Federal court at all, no matter 
how egregious the crime. That is the real amnesty. It is not 
amnesty when immigrants follow the laws and procedures set up 
by Congress for them to get vetted and get on the right side of 
the law. It is amnesty when government agents violate the law 
and our constitutional rights with impunity. The opposite of 
amnesty is accountability. Instead of targeting peaceful 
immigrants, Congress should end the amnesty for DHS agents by 
allowing Americans to vindicate our rights in court. Thank you.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Bier. We appreciate it, and we 
certainly appreciate all of the witnesses for taking the time 
to come here. And with that said, we are going to begin the 
question-and-answer portion of this hearing. I am going to 
begin with Mr. Biggs, so I now recognize Mr. Andy Biggs from 
Arizona for 5 minutes for the purpose of asking questions.
 Mr. Biggs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank the witnesses 
for all coming today.
 Mr. Newman, I was totally unfamiliar with the National Day 
Laborer Organizing Network until I saw that you or someone from 
the organization was going to be here, so I wanted to find out 
a little bit about it. So, I went to the 990, and I am 
wondering as the lawyer for the organization, did you review or 
participate in preparing the 990?
 Mr. Newman. We have several procedures to prepare and 
submit our 990, yes, sir.
 Mr. Biggs. Did you help--my question is, did you help 
personally because I do not know. Did you review this? I 
realize there are going to be procedures.
 Mr. Newman. I certainly did not----
 Mr. Biggs. You probably have a CPA on the board.
 Mr. Newman. I certainly did not----
 Mr. Biggs. Did you review it?
 Mr. Newman. I certainly did not look at it before this 
hearing, in preparation for this hearing, but I have been 
working for the organization since----
 Mr. Biggs. You said 20 years.
 Mr. Newman. For 20 years.
 Mr. Biggs. Yes, so I figure you are going to----
 Mr. Newman. And I prefer ``employee.''
 Mr. Biggs. I figure you are going to know quite a bit about 
this, so I am going to just ask a couple questions, and maybe 
you know, maybe you do not. Just I want to get a feel for it.
 In 2022, there was what I would call kind of a record, 
basically, over the history of the organization. You guys 
brought in $14 million in revenue that year, and normal looks 
to be about $6 to $7 million, although in 2023, it was about 
$3-and-a-half million. Let me just put it this way. Were there 
any government grants ever given to the National Day Laborer 
Organizing Network to your knowledge? If you know.
 Mr. Newman. Yes. Federal grants are a very small portion of 
our budget empirically, Congressman. What we have seen, 
particularly since 2016 when President Trump came down the 
escalator targeting our members, has been a ginormous 
outpouring of public support and donations----
 Mr. Biggs. So, you rely mostly on----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. To support civil rights and 
economic rights of our members.
 Mr. Biggs. Right, so you----
 Mr. Newman. And so, yes, we have received tons of 
donations.
 Mr. Biggs. Yes. So, you are getting donations from across 
the country and stuff like that.
 Mr. Newman. We get them at our website----
 Mr. Biggs. Okay, but you cannot tell----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. www.NDLON.org.
 Mr. Biggs. But you cannot tell me the amount, if any, of 
Federal grants you guys get on an annual basis?
 Mr. Newman. I cannot, no.
 Mr. Biggs. Okay. That is what I wanted to know because in 
2022, 64 percent of your revenue was public donations, and on 
your 990, nobody is listed on there. I assume that they are 
either all small or you did not list the major donors because 
there are no donors listed.
 I wanted to ask you another question with regard to grants. 
The organization gives out grants to a number of other, I do 
not know if they are affiliate organizations or other 
organizations. I mean, are you familiar with Houston's America 
for All?
 Mr. Newman. I am not.
 Mr. Biggs. How about SALVA?
 Mr. Newman. SALVA, oh yes.
 Mr. Biggs. Okay. SALVA, it says they received from you guys 
$11,000 bucks--they are based in Palmdale--it says for program 
support. What does ``program support'' mean?
 Mr. Newman. We provide a variety of services to day 
laborers when their employers do not pay them, which 50 percent 
of day laborers have reported.
 Mr. Biggs. So----
 Mr. Newman. We help them recover their wages.
 Mr. Biggs. Okay, but this is actually a cash grant. This is 
not you providing services. That is another listing. You gave a 
grant to SALVA for $11,000 bucks. It says program support. 
Transnational Villages Network (TVN), Red De Pueblos 
Transnacionales, they got money for support. Unidad Latina en 
Accion received $21,000 for program support, and you can go on 
down, and the Chinese Affirmative Action received $60,000 to 
support worker centers. I am just trying to know. These are 
cash grants, and are you familiar with these? Do you guys vet 
these organizations or anything?
 Mr. Newman. Well, you say, ``cash grants.'' I mean, yes, 
they are money that we provide.
 Mr. Biggs. Right.
 Mr. Newman. We have 71 member organizations in 17 states. 
The fact of the matter is, although the numbers you are citing, 
both big and small, are, you know, again, I am not, you know, 
familiar with all the details of each particular grant. The 
fact is that we have to ration scarce resources----
 Mr. Biggs. Right.
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. Because the level of assault----
 Mr. Biggs. Yes, I get that. I think we all can get that. 
Yes, but you also provided over $800,000 worth of travel 
expenses. Who is using the travel expenses? Are you funding 
travel? Are you guys funding any participation in any kind of 
protest or organized protest anywhere?
 Mr. Newman. Well, I was invited by this Committee on 
Friday, and the ticket prices are quite high because obviously 
gas prices are high.
 Mr. Biggs. Right.
 Mr. Newman. So, I spent money on that travel. I spent 
travel----
 Mr. Biggs. Yes, but that----
 Mr. Newman. I spent money----
 Mr. Biggs. That does not get to the question. I mean, it is 
a great dodge, it is a beautiful dodge, but it would sure be 
nice if you just answer whether you guys fund anybody traveling 
to protest, which is what the question was.
 Mr. Newman. People have a First Amendment right to protest, 
and we definitely pay for the gas.
 Mr. Biggs. And you help fund protests, right?
 Mr. Newman. Well, I mean, I am here, in essence, to protest 
immigration policy----
 Mr. Biggs. Sure, sure, but, I mean, you are protesting 
other----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. So, I have been funded to come 
here.
 [Cross-talking.]
 Mr. Biggs. Are you participating in the Delaney Hall 
protests? Are you funding people to get there?
 Mr. Gill. And the witness can answer the question, and then 
the 5 minutes is up.
 Mr. Biggs. Sorry.
 Mr. Newman. We are definitely trying to ensure that there 
is peaceful protest in solidarity with the brave hunger 
strikers who are trying to defend their human rights.
 Mr. Biggs. I take that as a ``yes'' then.
 [Laughter.]
 Mr. Newman. So, the answer, Congressman, is yes, and if I 
can just----
 Mr. Biggs. Okay. Mr. Chairman----
 Mr. Newman. If you will just indulge me----
 Ms. Simon. Regular order.
 Mr. Newman. If you will indulge me more in answer to his 
question.
 Mr. Biggs. It is his call. Yes, go ahead.
 Mr. Gill. You can answer the question. You got 5 seconds.
 Mr. Biggs. I thought he did answer the question, so.
 Mr. Newman. I look forward to answering any other questions 
you might have.
 Mr. Gill. Okay.
 Mr. Biggs. Well, my time has expired.
 Mr. Gill. Correct, the time has expired.
 Mr. Biggs. But I do have some UCs, if I can go forward.
 Mr. Gill. Yes.
 Mr. Biggs. This one is, ``Violent Clash Erupts at Delaney 
Hall. Chaos Follows Sherrill's `Peaceful Protest Zone' Plan.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. ``Unapologetic Sherrill Defends Sending State 
Police to Delaney Hall. Blames Out-of-State Agitators for 
Violent Clashes.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. ``Here Are All the Democrats Who Voted to Keep 
Funding ICE.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. `` `Abolish ICE' Creeps Back into Democratic 
Messaging.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. ``Democrat Rep. Shri Thanedar Proposes Abolish 
ICE Act.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. ``Mamdani Calls to Ignore Democratic Party 
Elders and Push for Abolishing ICE.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. ``Zohran Mamdani Calls to Abolish ICE, Ignore 
Dems Who are Against It.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. ``Violent Delaney Hall Protests Again Grow 
Chaotic. Crowds Ignored the Governor's Plea for Peace.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. And ``Abolish ICE Movement is Growing as the 
Agency's Disbanding Likely.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Mr. Biggs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Biggs, and I now yield 5 minutes 
to Ranking Member Simon.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you so much. My 
colleagues on the other side of the aisle have called this 
hearing today to talk about the chaos and abuse of the United 
States' immigration policy. You know, they have called this 
hearing to talk about the impact on Americans--on Americans--
and that is exactly what I want to talk about today.
 Over the past 17 months, we have seen chaos and violence 
and abuse on American streets. American citizens are being 
illegally arrested and detained by ICE. Orlin Hernandez Reyes, 
a three year old U.S. citizen and American, a toddler, a baby, 
murdered after ICE separated him from his mother, another 
family torn asunder by unspeakable cruelty by Donald Trump's 
America. We have seen immigration agents pepper spray and 
teargas American citizens. We have watched as they have 
terrorized and killed our neighbors, our friends, and our 
family members: Aliya Rahman harmed by Donald Trump and Stephen 
Miller's secret police force; Ruben Ray Martinez, Renee Nicole 
Good, and Alex Pretti all shot and killed by Donald Trump's and 
Stephen Miller's secret police force. American citizens. We are 
talking about Americans, American families that will never be 
the same.
 Mr. Bier, does this sound like an Administration that is 
putting the safety of Americans first?
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely not. In fact, they are explicitly 
saying they are deprioritizing serious public safety threats to 
focus on people going to work, and they are open about that. 
They think that is a good thing to deprioritize public safety.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you. Thank you so much. Last week, my 
colleagues on the other side of the aisle decided that they had 
not seen enough. Senate Republicans decided that they actually 
want ICE and CBP to do more, to go further. They want American 
taxpayers to send ICE and CBP another $70--seven-zero--billion, 
with a ``B,'' dollars, and that is on top of the $162 billion, 
with a ``B,'' dollars slush fund Republicans sent this past 
year. So, while our government is taking hard-earned taxpayer 
money away from American citizens to fund its campaign of fear 
and violence, do you know who is not? Immigrants. Yes, I said 
it. In fact, over the last three decades, immigrants in this 
country have added more than $14 trillion, with a ``T,'' 
dollars to our economy. The Trump Administration is throwing 
all of that out.
 Mr. Bier, while President Trump and the Administration 
claim that affordability and that poor people's struggle, poor 
Americans' struggle is a hoax, it is one of the most important 
issues facing the American people right now. Are President 
Trump's policies making life more or less affordable for 
everyday Americans, Mr. Bier?
 Mr. Bier. Well, there are two different ways in which the 
immigration policies are negatively affecting affordability for 
Americans. On the one hand, you mentioned the debt is going up 
as a direct consequence of the immigration policy of this 
President. If you look at what the Congressional Budget Office 
(CBO) has said, they had said that the recent cohort of 
immigrants that they are trying to deport will reduce the 
deficit by a trillion dollars if they do not deport them. 
Obviously, they are trying to deport them, so they are going to 
try to reverse those gains. The increase in the debt directly 
affects interest rates and makes costs more expensive for 
mortgages and car loans, and things of that nature. At the same 
time, we are losing all of the goods and services that they 
were previously producing----
 Ms. Simon. That is how----
 Mr. Bier [continuing]. Which is also of value to Americans.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, Mr. Bier. You know, once again, I am 
struck, extremely struck by the misguided focus of our 
colleagues. There is no shortage of attacks on our 
constitutional rights. Again, I am talking about Americans. 
These attacks are happening every single day in our 
communities, attacks that are harming families, our children, 
like this little boy, Liam Ramos.
 [Photo]
 Ms. Simon. Now, you want to talk about chaos, the Trump 
Administration is causing chaos all around us. All around us. 
Those names that I lifted up today, they represent real people 
with real families, Americans who have been violated by their 
own government, and we have seen that they have had, under this 
Administration, little to no recourse, and I yield back.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Ranking Member Simon, and I now 
recognize Mr. Cloud from Texas for 5 minutes.
 Mr. Cloud. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, witnesses, 
for being here.
 You know, I live in South Texas, and obviously have been to 
the border a number of times, and I remember day one under the 
Biden Administration where, literally, a wall was being built 
to protect our borders and was taken down, the border assets 
being a force multiplier for our Customs and Border Protection. 
There had been lights that were put up that, literally, they 
would not plug in under the Biden Administration. We sat here 
in this Committee, and Mayorkas came here and told us time 
after time after time that we had to have legislative action to 
stop the massive onslaught that was coming into our country, 
yet under President Trump, that was resolved pretty quickly.
 Now, we still have some work to do in Congress to close the 
loopholes that the Biden Administration took advantage of, but 
what happened under the Biden Administration, he turned what 
was supposed to be protection into processing and, you know, 
all this massive--I would call it immigrations, except it was 
not immigration; immigration is when you come here properly and 
legally--people coming across our border illegally. The open 
border policies are always under altruistic reasons, 
supposedly, you know, humanitarian efforts. Meanwhile, they 
turned a blind eye to the 300,000 children that were lost. I 
was down there, and, you know, the cartels were renting a kid 
out, basically, from families to send them with false claims of 
being a family unit and the like. It was atrocious.
 Mr. Newman, I believe you are from Los Angeles, is that 
correct, or your organization is anyway? You live in that area?
 Mr. Newman. Yes, sir.
 Mr. Cloud. Homelessness is a massive problem there. Is that 
correct?
 Mr. Newman. It is a heartbreaking problem in Los Angeles.
 Mr. Cloud. It is. How many homeless people have you invited 
into your home to live with you?
 Mr. Newman. You know, honestly, I have actually invited 
homeless people----
 Mr. Cloud. Yes.
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. While I was in law school. So, I 
mean, a couple----
 Mr. Cloud. No, with you and your family. You mentioned you 
have a son.
 Mr. Newman. I started out working and helped people.
 Mr. Cloud. Do you have any homeless people living with you?
 Mr. Newman. I helped open a day labor center in Denver, 
Colorado----
 Mr. Cloud. Do you have any homeless people living with you?
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. That serviced homeless people.
 Mr. Cloud. Do you have any homeless people living with you?
 Mr. Newman. Excuse me?
 Mr. Cloud. Do you have any homeless people living with you 
from Los Angeles right now? It is a major problem. Have you let 
them into your home?
 Mr. Newman. I do not have any homeless people currently 
living with me, Congressman.
 Mr. Cloud. Okay, and I imagine that is in part to protect 
your family. The reason we have these laws is to make sure that 
we are protecting our communities. You know, half the world's 
population live under $10 a day, and it is a misguided notion, 
and actually an arrogant notion, to say that we solve that 
problem by inviting everybody into the United States. We want 
people to prosper everywhere, and we should have partnerships 
with countries, you know, that hopefully allow them to 
flourish, but the idea that we are supposed to bring everybody 
here is a false notion.
 One of the things that was a real tragedy in this that kind 
of got overlooked is, it was a new industry of bringing people 
into this country. Now, the messaging we see often from the 
left is, like, this was some organic movement of people coming 
to be free. The asylum claims were, you know, way blown out of 
proportion. They were really coming here for, basically, 
economic benefit as opposed to what true asylum is supposed to 
be for, but in the meantime, we saw this massive NGO 
organization basically funneling taxpayer dollars into these 
organizations. Now we see it on the other hand where, not only 
the migration coming here is not organic, it is funded through 
NGOs, but we are seeing the protests are doing the same.
 Mr. Krikorian, could you speak to the NGO industrial 
complex that was stood up surrounding immigration?
 Mr. Krikorian. Yes, absolutely. I mean, it is huge, and it 
is partly, in fact, funded by the Federal Government and in a 
variety of ways. See, one thing that people obviously focus on 
is the NGOs in the United States that were flying people, under 
Biden, around the country, but there are U.S. taxpayer-funded 
groups outside the United States, sometimes through the U.N. or 
funded through the U.N. or funded directly, that were moving 
people, giving people, you know, debit cards in order to 
facilitate their movement toward the U.S. border. So, the 
taxpayer, under President Biden, was funding NGOs abroad to 
move people to the border, and then NGOs inside the country to 
move people around the country.
 Mr. Cloud. So, in a sense, we were forcing taxpayers to pay 
for the demise of their own country and the communities and----
 Mr. Krikorian. You could put it that way, yes.
 Mr. Cloud. Yes. Now, has this stopped completely or is this 
still ongoing?
 Mr. Krikorian. Well, it has not stopped completely as far 
as I know, but most of the flow obviously stopped----
 Mr. Cloud. Obviously the flow.
 Mr. Krikorian [continuing]. Because of the President's 
policies.
 Mr. Cloud. Are these organizations still at work, lying 
dormant, or?
 Mr. Krikorian. I do not know. That is a good question. I 
assume they are lying dormant, eagerly waiting, like many of 
the illegal immigrants have said to reporters, waiting for the 
next Administration and hoping that they will let them in.
 Mr. Cloud. Right, and as I mentioned at the beginning, we 
still have a lot of loopholes to close to make sure this does 
not happen. Thank you, Chairman. I yield back.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Cloud, and I now yield 5----
 Ms. Simon. Mr. Chair, I have a UC request, sir.
 Mr. Gill. Without objection, go for it.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, sir. I ask unanimous consent to enter 
into the record, February 23, 2026, an article from NPR 
entitled, ``A New Lawsuit Alleges DHS Illegally Tracked and 
Intimidated Observers,'' sir.
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you.
 Mr. Gill. Is that it? All right. I now recognize Mr. 
Walkinshaw from Virginia for 5 minutes.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We are back for 
another hearing of the Task Force on Defending Constitutional 
Rights and Exposing Institutional Abuses, and I am glad again 
to be here because there are many violations of constitutional 
rights and institutional abuses taking place in this country.
 The Fourth Amendment to our Constitution expressly protects 
individuals against warrantless searches and guarantees the 
right to safety in our homes. It requires a judicial warrant 
before law enforcement can smash down your door, search your 
home, except under a few specific circumstances. That Fourth 
Amendment was born from our Founding Fathers' struggle against 
tyranny, specifically against the general warrants--I guess 
today we would call them administrative warrants--that allowed 
British royal officials to conduct sweeping, warrantless 
searches of homes and businesses to target their political 
enemies or those deemed insufficiently loyal to the king.
 Over the last year, DHS, ICE, CBP, and others have carried 
out these exact violations of the Constitution across the 
country under the direction of President Trump. I want to play 
a brief video of one of those violations.
 [Video shown.]
 Mr. Walkinshaw. ``Show the warrant.'' ``There is nobody 
here but my babies.'' ``Chaos.'' This video of ICE invading the 
home of a U.S. citizen, a pediatric nurse, Teyana Gibson Brown, 
with military weapons and without a judicial warrant 
illustrates one of the many constitutional violations that ICE 
has perpetrated under this Administration, and it was not an 
accident. An internal 2025 ICE memo, signed by Acting Director 
Lyons, directed agents to use administrative warrants signed 
not by Article III judges, but immigration officers, to 
forcibly enter private homes. Courts, including in a case filed 
by Ms. Gibson, found the use of these warrants to be 
unconstitutional. Mr. Chairman, when will we have a hearing of 
this Task Force on those violations of the Constitution?
 This week, our Republican colleagues are refusing to reign 
in these violations of the Constitution. In fact, they are 
greenlighting them, refusing commonsense reforms and pumping 
another $70 billion into smashing down the doors of American 
citizens without a warrant, in violation of the Constitution.
 Mr. Bier, based on Cato's research, do you have a rough 
estimate of how many Fourth Amendment violations DHS has 
engaged in under this Trump Administration?
 Mr. Bier. Well, according to DHS, they burst into people's 
homes without warrants at least 28 times. I do not believe that 
number for even a minute. I have seen, personally, videos of at 
least 28 encounters, and they are not recording all of those 
incidents where peoples' homes are being invaded without 
warrants.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. I analogize these searches and seizures to 
the very searches and seizures that our Founding Fathers 
objected to that the Redcoats were engaged in. Do you think 
that is an appropriate analogy?
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely. John Adams called it the start of the 
American Revolution when James Otis exposed what the Crown was 
doing with these general warrants going into people's homes, 
and again, it was from judges that were not independent of the 
Crown. They served at the pleasure of the Crown, and if they 
turned down the request for a warrant, they could be fired, and 
that is the same thing with an Immigration and Customs 
Enforcement supervisor: if they do not do the will of President 
Trump, they will be fired, too, as they have been.
 Mr. Walkinshaw. Thank you, Mr. Bier. I yield back.
 Ms. Simon. I have a UC request, Mr. Chair.
 Mr. Gill. Yep.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, sir. I ask unanimous consent to enter 
into the record, February 4, 2026, an article from Brennan 
Center entitled, ``DHS Warrantless Home Entry Memo's Fourth 
Amendment Problem,'' which shows that the ICE acting Director--
--
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon [continuing]. Instructed agencies to violate the 
Fourth Amendment and to enter homes without a judicial warrant.
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, sir.
 Mr. Gill. Great, and I now recognize Mr. Crane from Arizona 
for 5 minutes.
 Mr. Crane. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for allowing me to 
waive on today.
 I would like to start with you, Mr. Bier. Did you state in 
the past that President Biden led the U.S. immigration system 
out of an unprecedented calamity? Just ``yes'' or ``no.''
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely. Absolutely.
 Mr. Crane. Thank you.
 Mr. Bier. The first Trump Administration destroyed our 
immigration system.
 Mr. Crane. I reclaim my time. Many would argue that 
President Biden did not lead us out of this unprecedented 
calamity, but he actually created it. I want to read a quote to 
you. I want to see if you know who the author of this quote 
was. ``What I would do as President is several more things 
because things have changed. I would, in fact, make sure that 
we immediately surge to the border all those people who are 
seeking asylum. They deserve to be heard. That is who we are. 
We are a Nation that says if you want to flee and you are 
fleeing oppression, you should come.'' Do you know who said 
that, Mr. Bier?
 Mr. Bier. Biden said that.
 Mr. Crane. Yes, while he was running for office, so we all 
knew what was going to happen.
 Mr. Bier. Who was the ``we'' in the sentence? The ``we'' is 
the government.
 Mr. Crane. Those of us with----
 Mr. Bier. The government was going to surge the border----
 Mr. Crane. Those of us with common sense, of course.
 Mr. Bier [continuing]. Not immigrants.
 Mr. Crane. Thank you. I reclaim my time. Mr. Bier, you also 
stated that Trump's policies endanger the rights of Americans 
by undermining due process in focusing on mass deportation 
rather than public safety. And I want to riff on public safety 
for a second because a couple weeks ago, Congressman Biggs and 
I met with several Angel families in Arizona. They were 
heartbroken families who felt like the Biden Administration 
and, quite frankly, policies promoted by yourself, that their 
family members were left vulnerable. They also said that there 
were a few Republicans that would not meet with them, but that 
no Democrats would meet with them. Why do you think that is, 
Mr. Bier? Why do you think that Democrats are unwilling to meet 
with Angel families?
 Mr. Bier. I would be happy to meet with them, and I have. 
That is exactly why I think ICE should focus on public safety 
to prevent tragedies like that.
 Mr. Crane. Yes. Well, they do not feel like you and the 
President prioritize American citizens and their family 
members. They feel like all you guys really do is prioritize 
the safety and welfare of illegal aliens, and that is coming 
from them and I agree with it. Why is it that you prioritize 
the safety and welfare of illegal aliens over those of American 
citizens, Mr. Bier?
 Mr. Bier. It is a ridiculous question. I think we should 
prioritize the safety of all people by focusing all law 
enforcement on people who victimize other people. I am the only 
libertarian here.
 Mr. Crane. Mr. Bier.
 Mr. Bier. I am the only one who thinks that the government 
should spend all of its time----
 Mr. Crane. If that is true----
 Mr. Bier [continuing]. Focused on public safety.
 Mr. Crane. If that is true, why did the American people 
largely reject the Biden Administration and many of your 
policies in reelecting President Donald Trump?
 Mr. Bier. Well, there are lots of reasons why people voted 
for Trump. I am not going to get into them here, but I think 
all Americans want our law enforcement to focus on public 
safety, and I agree with them.
 Mr. Crane. Do you think it had anything to do with 
witnessing and watching four years of your policies being put 
out into the atmosphere?
 Mr. Bier. They were not my policies, sir.
 Mr. Crane. Oh, they are not? You do not support----
 Mr. Bier. In fact, Title 42 was the main----
 Mr. Crane. You do not support the President's immigration 
policies? You do not support President Biden's immigration 
policies?
 Mr. Bier. President Biden's immigration policies were not 
even implemented until the end of his term. Title 42----
 Mr. Crane. You seem to be a big supporter of President 
Biden's immigration policies.
 Mr. Bier. Title 42 was the main immigration policy, sir, 
during the first part of the Biden Administration that the 
Republican states sued to keep it in place. That was the policy 
in effect in the border. It was not a Biden policy. It was a 
Trump policy up until 2023 when he got rid of that policy.
 Mr. Crane. Oh, so the 10 to 15 million illegal aliens that 
came in, that was not a Biden policy? That was not a Biden 
policy?
 Mr. Bier. What was not a Biden policy?
 Mr. Crane. The 10 to 15 or 20 million illegal aliens that 
came into the country?
 Mr. Bier. Well, those are made up----
 Mr. Crane. That was not President Biden's policies?
 Mr. Bier. Those are completely made-up numbers, sir, but of 
course it was not a policy.
 Mr. Crane. Oh, I am sure they are made up.
 Mr. Bier. They were trying to stop----
 Mr. Crane. I am sure they are made up, sir.
 Mr. Bier. They were doing everything they could.
 Mr. Crane. And all the numbers and data that you come in 
here and spout, they are absolutely factual. Is that right?
 Mr. Newman, moving on to you, you posted on X, ``No one who 
voted for the Laken Riley Act should have any role in the 
future leadership of the Democrat Party in this country. It is 
disqualifying.'' Did you post that, sir? Yes or no.
 Mr. Newman. Congressman, yes, I did.
 Mr. Crane. Why is it disqualifying in your opinion that the 
detention of illegal aliens who are accused of theft, burglary, 
assaulting a law enforcement officer, and any crime that causes 
death or serious bodily injury is disqualifying?
 Mr. Newman. I posted that tweet because I believed that it 
was a capitulation to Republican demagoguery to create two 
systems of justice where people are treated differently for 
similar crimes, and I stand by that. I think it was a grave 
mistake on the part, well, first, on the part of the Republican 
Party, but on the part of cowardly Democrats to stand up to 
that level of demagoguery. That is the reason why I posted that 
tweet.
 Mr. Crane. I yield back.
 Ms. Simon. Mr. Chair, I have a UC request, sir.
 Mr. Gill. Yep.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you. I ask unanimous consent to enter into 
the record, March 30, 2025, an article from NPR entitled, 
``Police Say ICE Tactics are Eroding Public Trust in Local Law 
Enforcement''----
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon [continuing]. Which shows that police chiefs 
agree to----
 Mr. Crane. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 Mr. Gill. I now yield 5 minutes to Ms. Pressley from 
Massachusetts.
 Ms. Pressley. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Trump 
Administration's chaotic campaign of lawlessness and cruelty is 
traumatizing our children. ICE is detaining people who have 
committed no crimes, people in our country with legal statuses 
and even American citizens. Teenagers, toddlers, babies have 
been abducted and taken to a detention center in Dilley, Texas, 
run by a multibillion-dollar private prison corporation that 
profits from their pain. That profits from the pain of child 
abuse, child neglect, and childhood trauma. As a mother, I am 
heartbroken, and as an American, I am ashamed.
 And this Administration over and over again keeps making 
history for all the wrong reasons, and on a daily basis, you 
have an emerging legacy, again, of the abuse, negligence, 
trauma, and even the death of our children. This is state-
inflicted trauma. And yes, I said ``our children'' because 
anyone on this land and certainly in our facilities, we are 
charged with their welfare and their well-being. And as Members 
of this Oversight Committee, hell, as people of conscience, 
every single person should be raising their voice and doing 
everything in their power to close the Dilley facility 
immediately.
 Now, Mr. Krikorian, how many children have been locked in 
detention facilities since Trump took office in 2025?
 Mr. Krikorian. I do not have that number, but they were put 
there by their parents, not by the Trump Administration.
 Ms. Pressley. Reclaiming my time. Did you just hear me just 
state for the record, and we have it well documented, that 
these are people overwhelmingly that have been unlawfully 
detained, some of them even American citizens that are here 
with legal statuses? So, do not try to deflect. This is not 
about the parents, and as I said, they are in our facilities 
that we fund, so you are charged with their welfare and their 
well-being. So, let me move on and just give you the 
information since you said you do not know. I will help you 
out.
 According to ICE data, roughly 4,000 children, 4,000 
children under the age of 18, including 20 infants, and I am 
not even naming the girls and the women that are pregnant and 
the lack of prenatal care for unborn children, but that is how 
many have been forced behind the wall by this cruel 
Administration. How many children have been held in detention 
for longer than the legal maximum amount of time?
 Mr. Krikorian. I do not know, but again, they are there 
because of----
 Ms. Pressley. Reclaiming my time.
 Mr. Krikorian [continuing]. They are there because of their 
parents.
 Ms. Pressley. Just for those watching at home, just so you 
know, the lawful maximum time is 20 days, and we have over 
1,300 children--children--who are locked in custody beyond that 
time, and anyway, 20 days is too long. Mr. Krikorkian, do you 
think that children should endure vomiting after eating or 
drink contaminated water and wait days for medical attention 
while they are detained at Dilley? Yes or no.
 Mr. Krikorian. It is ``Mr. Krikorian''--excuse me--but 
the----
 Ms. Pressley. Oh, my apologies. Names matter. Mr. 
Krikorian, yes, for the record.
 Mr. Krikorian. The conditions in detention facilities are 
probably better in ICE facilities----
 Mr. Krikorian. Mr. Krikorian, reclaiming my time.
 Mr. Krikorian [continuing]. Than in regular detention 
facilities.
 Ms. Pressley. Please just answer my question, ``yes'' or 
``no.'' I do not have time for you to filibuster. Just answer 
the question. This should be an easy answer. Do you think 
children should endure vomiting after eating, drinking 
contaminated water, and waiting days for medical attention 
while they are detained at Dilley? Yes or no.
 Mr. Krikorian. They are detained because their parents have 
put them there.
 Ms. Pressley. I will take that a yes, that you are okay 
with that.
 Mr. Krikorian. Their parents----
 Ms. Pressley. That you want to be complicit----
 Mr. Krikorian [continuing]. Put them in those facilities.
 Ms. Pressley [continuing]. In the abuse, negligence, and 
trauma of our children. Moving on, dozens of families and 
children, like Susej, a nine year old girl detained in Dilley, 
have reported the cruel and inhumane conditions of this 
facility. We have nine year olds having to advocate for 
themselves. She said she loved going to school, playing with 
her friends, until enduring the prison-like conditions of 
Dilley stole her sleep, stole her appetite, and stole her 
innocence. In that cage that they call a family residential 
center, she repeatedly woke up screaming from nightmares 
begging to go home. She left Dilley changed forever, fearful, 
withdrawn, burdened with trauma that was never hers to carry.
 That is the human cost of Republicans' harmful policy 
choices, and if you are not working actively to close Dilley 
and address the systemic harm taking place in all these 
facilities, you are complicit in child abuse, period. And the 
evidence is clear, this Administration is imprisoning thousands 
of children for weeks and months in unsafe conditions, denying 
them due process, and inflicting lasting trauma. This is a 
blatant violation of basic human rights and our constitutional 
values.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Ms. Pressley, and I now yield 5 
minutes to the gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Jack.
 Mr. Jack. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Krikorian, if I 
could start with you, could you walk us through the history of 
the TPS program? When was it created? What was the intention 
behind it? Thank you.
 Mr. Krikorian. It was created in 1990 as part of a broader 
immigration bill, and the point of it was to fence in executive 
freelancing where Presidents of both parties had used made-up 
status they called extended voluntary departure to let illegal 
immigrants that they just did not want to deport, stay in the 
country, and give them work permits and Social Security 
numbers. So, Congress said they were concerned that this was 
executive freelancing. This was not subject to the law, was not 
subject to oversight, and so they created TPS as a way of kind 
of putting a structure around that.
 The problem is that what happened is that Presidents, 
again, of both parties, gave TPS often on pretty flimsy 
grounds, but also the most important thing is there was nothing 
temporary about it. TPS was always just renewed over and over 
again, year after year, decade after decade, and it has become, 
as I suggested, one of the pillars of a shadow immigration 
system that the Executive runs to let in and to let stay and to 
let work pretty much any illegal immigrant they wanted to.
 Mr. Jack. So, I try to personalize things for my 
constituents watching at home during these hearings. So, could 
you help me estimate with the flagrant abuse you saw under the 
Biden Administration of this program, what the cost to the 
American taxpayer was, whether it be economic output, jobs 
lost, whatever the case may be? Hoping you can quantify for us 
what the cost to the American taxpayer is for this flagrant 
abuse of this system.
 Mr. Krikorian. Just to put it in context, all legal and 
illegal immigrant households use welfare at about a rate of a 
little more than 50 percent. In other words, more than half of 
immigrant households are using at least one Federal welfare 
program. They, in fact, pay taxes as the Democrats' witness 
will no doubt point out, but they also use services, and they 
use them in greater quantity than they pay in taxes, and that 
is not a moral fault. That is because they are low skilled. 
Especially in TPS, they are almost all illegal immigrants, so 
they have low levels of skill, which means they earn low 
incomes, which means they qualify for benefits at a much higher 
rate than others, and so they end up becoming a burden on the 
taxpayer whether we like it or not.
 Mr. Jack. Thank you very much, Mr. Krikorian. Mr. O'Brien, 
the Trump Administration has moved to end certain TPS 
designations and parole programs, but much of that effort has 
been tied up in litigation. Could you walk us through how 
various activist groups are actively slowing down and trying to 
thwart the Administration's efforts to solve this immigration 
crisis?
 Mr. O'Brien. Certainly. Well, in a number of cases, there 
are specific provisions within the legislation implementing 
these programs that strips the courts of jurisdiction to review 
the designations, so TPS contains one of those provisions. Many 
of those things were put in place because these are acts that 
affect the Presidential exercise of the foreign affairs power, 
the diplomatic power, the war powers. There seems to be a large 
number of suits that were filed based on forum shopping and 
then submitted on a wing and a prayer in hopes that even though 
the suit had no merit, it would be heard, so at the very least, 
there would be an injunction blocking large numbers of these 
particular moves.
 And if you look at this from a commonsense perspective, 
lots of these things are absurd. I mean, there are TPS 
designations that are based on volcanic eruptions that happened 
20 to 30 years ago that clearly have no effect whatsoever on 
the countries that we are talking about, and we are 
simultaneously removing many citizens from those countries to 
those places safely with no problem whatsoever when those 
people are subject to deportation for violating the immigration 
laws.
 Mr. Jack. Could you also explain for us the legal 
definition of ``asylum'' and elaborate on whether this 
classification is being abused to allow unauthorized 
individuals into our country?
 Mr. O'Brien. Well, it is most definitely being abused. So, 
asylum is available to individuals who are experiencing 
persecution by their own government or parties that the 
government is unable or unwilling to control, which a classic 
example of that is, say, the FARC in Colombia where a 
nongovernmental group has seized control of part of the 
country. And it can be given on the basis of persecution that 
occurs on account of race, religion, nationality, political 
opinion, or membership in a particular social group. Nobody 
knows what ``a particular social group'' is. It has never been 
clearly defined.
 So, what is happening is that, when I was an immigration 
judge, virtually every single asylum application that I saw was 
made by someone coming from Central America who was claiming 
that MS-13 had taken control of their country and that MS-13 
was seeking them out. The vast majority of these people had 
never attempted to access the criminal justice system, or file 
any kind of complaint, or seek any kind of protection in their 
own country. And so, what, in effect, has been happening is 
that asylum, rather than being used as humanitarian protection 
for people suffering persecution the way, perhaps, Soviet 
dissidents did in the past, it has become a protection that 
appears to be applicable to anyone who is living in a country 
where the conditions are not as nice as the United States. The 
fact is that crime----
 Mr. Gill. If the gentleman could wrap it up.
 Mr. O'Brien. Crime is a sovereign problem that should be 
dealt with under the criminal justice system in a country where 
it is occurring.
 Mr. Jack. Well, I appreciate both of you all's testimony as 
well as the other panelists, and I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
 Ms. Simon. Mr. Chair, I have a UC request.
 Mr. Gill. Go for it.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, sir. I would like to enter into the 
record, July 12, 2026, an article from the Associated Press 
entitled, ``Trump Says He Wants to Deport `the Worst of the 
Worst.' Government Data Tells Another Story.''
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, sir.
 Mr. Gill. I now recognize Mr. Min for 5 minutes.
 Mr. Min. Thank you. I want to thank Chair Gill and Ranking 
Member Simon for assembling this important oversight Task Force 
on Defending Constitutional Rights and Exposing Institutional 
Abuses. This is a very important topic, and especially in light 
of the repeated attacks on our constitutional rights that we 
have witnessed over the past 18 months, and the tremendous 
corruption and lawlessness of so many agencies and Trump 
Administration officials over the last year and a half. I hope 
we will be doing many more hearings on these topics, including 
around the alleged pay-to-play bribes being taken by Trump 
family members in relation to pardons and tariff relief, the 
illegal impoundments of funds appropriated under the last 
Congress by the Trump Administration, the illegal targeting of 
Trump critics and media companies with baseless investigations, 
and abuse of power by agencies, including the Department of 
Justice and FCC, as well as the illegal war in Iran.
 But today's topic is particularly salient, something I hear 
a lot about in my district in Orange County, California, 
``Amnesty and Chaos: Abuse in U.S. Immigration Policy.'' As my 
colleague, Mr. Walkinshaw, pointed out earlier, we have seen 
videos of literally hundreds, perhaps thousands of documented 
instances of DHS, CBP, and ICE agents, often masked and 
unidentified, violating the constitutional rights of Americans, 
including making unlawful arrests and committing violent 
assaults against Americans who have not committed any crimes or 
provided any probable cause to believe that they have committed 
any crimes.
 I have eagerly been looking forward to today's hearing. I 
was, therefore, very surprised and disappointed to see that we 
do not have a single witness from the Department of Homeland 
Security, Customs and Border Patrol, or Immigration and Customs 
Enforcement here because they have a lot of questions to 
answer. But since we do not have anyone there, I wanted to 
direct a few questions to some of our witnesses. Perhaps you 
can answer on behalf of CBP and ICE, and so I will start with 
you, Mr. Bier.
 Since this Task Force is predicated on the idea of 
defending constitutional rights, I just want to ask you a few 
questions about the different constitutional rights that DHS, 
ICE, and CBP have allegedly violated under the leadership of 
President Trump, Secretary Noem, and Border Czar Homan. Just 
answer ``yes'' or ``no,'' potentially elaborate shortly, if you 
will. First, is it a constitutional right to peacefully protest 
actions that you think are wrong or to assemble with other 
like-minded individuals?
 Mr. Bier. Of course. It is a First Amendment right.
 Mr. Min. Would it then be a violation of those 
constitutional rights if masked and anonymous agents decided to 
randomly spray pepper spray in the faces of those people 
protesting, or punch them in the face, or pull a gun on them?
 Mr. Bier. I believe so, yes.
 Mr. Min. I believe that would definitely be the case. Is it 
a constitutional right to be free from unreasonable seizures by 
the government?
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely. Fourth Amendment.
 Mr. Min. Would it then be a violation of those 
constitutional rights if government agents engaged in random, 
warrantless stops; questioning; detentions; and arrests of 
people just based on their appearance?
 Mr. Bier. My view, the view of many of the courts that have 
looked at the question as well. We will see what the Supreme 
Court says.
 Mr. Min. Is it a constitutional right to consult with legal 
counsel when facing government proceedings that might deprive 
you of your liberty?
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely.
 Mr. Min. Would it then be a violation of those 
constitutional rights if government officials prevented 
detainees from communicating with their attorneys, sometimes 
denied them access to counsel, attending legal meetings, or 
allowing them access to legal advice?
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely, and we have seen this. It is a Fifth 
Amendment violation. We have seen this repeatedly happen in Los 
Angeles, and courts have actually said, ``Look, you are not 
even following the court order to stop this behavior.''
 Mr. Min. Yes, it is outrageous and we are seeing a lot of 
this, and it continues to happen, I just want to point out, 
under the leadership of the new Secretary, Markwayne Mullin. 
Now, a few minutes ago--I want to switch to public safety--
Representative Crane, who I think is no longer with us, accused 
you of prioritizing violent criminals over the safety of law-
abiding Americans. I want to dig a little deeper into that.
 Now, when Trump campaigned in 2024 for this office, he 
emphasized that if he won the election, he would go after 
violent criminals and MS-13 gang members. Now, the Cato 
Institute has done some research on the activities of ICE and 
DHS, including the percentage of arrests of violent criminals 
or those with prior criminal convictions. Can you elaborate on 
that?
 Mr. Bier. Yes. So, according to DHS data, just five percent 
of the individuals that have been taken into ICE custody and 
detention facilities have any violent criminal convictions of 
any kind, even, you know, minor assaults included in that 
statistic. And even if you look at how DHS itself categorizes 
detainees, 70 percent are not deemed a public safety threat.
 Mr. Min. This is something Joe Rogan, the popular 
podcaster, has pointed out repeatedly. Trump is going after 
people at Home Depots, he is going after day laborers, he is 
going after children, not after violent criminals. Now, in your 
mind, does that policy of going after nonviolent offenders over 
violent criminals make us more or less safe?
 Mr. Bier. Makes us less safe. They are not going after the 
people that we are most concerned with.
 Mr. Min. And if they had been going after violent 
criminals, perhaps we might have prevented some of the crimes 
we have seen over the last year and a half, crimes that my 
Republican colleagues like to point out.
 Mr. Bier. Yes, absolutely. They even talk about some of the 
crimes that they have committed, and they look at the past 
criminal history of those individuals. They did not go and get 
them. They went after the gardener and the construction worker 
and the farmhand.
 Mr. Min. So, in short, ICE is basically going after 
nonviolent people, they are violating the constitutional rights 
of Americans, and they are making us less safe.
 Mr. Bier. Absolutely.
 Mr. Min. I yield back. Thank you.
 Mr. Gill. Thank you, Mr. Min. I now recognize myself for 5 
minutes for the purpose of asking a few questions.
 Mr. Krikorian, how many illegal aliens came into the 
country during the Biden Administration?
 Mr. Krikorian. Our estimate is at least eight million, 
maybe as many as ten.
 Mr. Gill. Maybe as many as ten.
 Mr. Krikorian. Yes.
 Mr. Gill. How many came into the country last year in 2025?
 Mr. Krikorian. We do not know yet, but it was not anything 
close to that.
 Mr. Gill. Not very many, so a substantial decrease.
 Mr. Krikorian. Dramatic, 90-plus percent decrease at the 
border.
 Mr. Krikorian. Got it. Mr. Newman, is it a good thing that 
Mr. Trump, President Trump, secured the border?
 Mr. Newman. I think that Stephen Miller has squandered what 
used to be a signature issue for the President.
 Mr. Gill. I am asking is it a good thing that our border is 
secure?
 Mr. Newman. I think our border has been secure for quite 
some time.
 Mr. Gill. Our border was secure during the Biden 
Administration?
 Mr. Newman. Yes, sir.
 Mr. Gill. That is your testimony?
 Mr. Newman. That is my belief, yes. It is my opinion.
 Mr. Gill. How many illegal aliens came into the country 
during the Biden Administration?
 Mr. Newman. Whatever it was, it was not the number that 
Mark Krikorian just cited. That came----
 Mr. Gill. You do not think it was ten million?
 Mr. Newman. That came out of whole cloth.
 Mr. Gill. It could have been quite a bit higher. So, would 
you agree that there are fewer illegal aliens entering the 
country now than there were entering during the Biden 
Administration?
 Mr. Newman. That is not an area of my expertise, so I would 
not agree or disagree with that.
 Mr. Gill. You spend a lot of time in the immigration space. 
You cannot tell me whether there are fewer illegal aliens 
coming into the country now than there were during the Biden 
Administration?
 Mr. Newman. That is not an area of my expertise. I have 
been spending too much of my time----
 Mr. Gill. I think most people who are awake----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. Defending civil rights of my 
neighbors in Los Angeles.
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. Can say that there are fewer illegal 
aliens coming into the country right now. It is astounding that 
you will not at least admit that. Should illegal aliens receive 
taxpayer-funded unemployment benefits?
 Mr. Newman. That is not an area of my expertise either. My 
concern primarily is----
 Mr. Gill. Your organization----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. The people I work with who do not 
get----
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. Promoted a petition telling Governor 
Newsom----
 Mr. Newman. Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. To sign AB 2847. This is your 
organization----
 Mr. Newman. Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. The National Day Laborers Organizing 
Network? AB 2847 will provide unemployment benefits to workers 
who are ineligible to receive unemployment insurance solely due 
to their immigration status?
 Mr. Newman. Mr. Chairman, if I could answer your first 
question?
 Mr. Min. Yes, I am asking you, do you think that illegal 
aliens should receive taxpayer-funded unemployment benefits?
 Mr. Newman. Well, first off, I do not know what you mean by 
``illegal aliens,'' but if you are talking about residents in 
the State of California----
 Mr. Gill. I am asking----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. Then the answer is yes.
 Mr. Gill. I am talking about people who entered our country 
illegally.
 Mr. Newman. People come here for all kinds of reasons and 
in all kinds of ways.
 Mr. Gill. Without documentation. Should illegal----
 Mr. Newman. Residents in California----
 Mr. Gill. This is a really simple question. Should illegal 
aliens receive taxpayer-funded unemployment benefits?
 Mr. Newman. I think people in the State of California 
should receive benefits under the law.
 Mr. Gill. So, illegal aliens should receive taxpayer-funded 
unemployment benefits?
 Mr. Newman. Again, that is your word----
 Mr. Gill. And that is----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. And what I am trying to get you to 
do, Congressman----
 Mr. Gill. And that is the view of your organization.
 Mr. Newman. Congressman, what I am trying to get you to do 
is to stop throwing around dehumanizing rhetoric like this.
 Mr. Gill. You are trying to get a thousand signatures. You 
only got 503, and I think it is worth pointing out because that 
is a crazy idea. Let me ask you another question. Your 
organization shut down the Manhattan Bridge during rush hour a 
couple years ago to demand that New York State set up a $500 
million fund to give unemployment benefits to illegal aliens. 
Do you think that was a good thing to do?
 Mr. Newman. I do not know that my organization shut down 
anything, Congressman. I know that there were people 
protesting.
 Mr. Gill. ``March in NYC shuts down Manhattan Bridge to 
call for $500 million unemployment fund.'' ``The march was led 
by members of the Few Coalition, including the National Day 
Laborers Organizing Network.''
 Mr. Newman. You are holding----
 Mr. Gill. That is your organization, is it not?
 Mr. Newman. Yes, that is. You are holding up a sheet of 
paper. I do not know where that is from.
 Mr. Gill. This is from your website.
 Mr. Newman. Peaceful protestors----
 Mr. Gill. This is from the National Day Laborers----
 Mr. Newman. Peaceful protestors----
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. Organizing Network website.
 Mr. Newman. Peaceful protestors do things when there are 
large crowds of people.
 Mr. Gill. Does that include shutting down----
 Mr. Newman. I think you would agree, Congressman.
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. Shutting down one of the busiest 
bridges in the Nation in order to push for a $500 million fund 
to give taxpayer-funded unemployment benefits to illegal 
aliens?
 Mr. Newman. I think we should give taxpayer----
 Mr. Gill. You think that is a good thing for the country?
 Mr. Newman. I think we should allocate resources 
accordingly to people who are going to become citizens of this 
country eventually, as Mark Krikorian acknowledges.
 Mr. Gill. What if there were emergency vehicles trying to 
cross the----
 Mr. Newman. As Mark Krikorian acknowledges is inevitable.
 Mr. Gill. You realize that there are people commuting to 
work, and the people commuting to work were the ones who are 
paying the taxes to fund these benefits that you want to give 
to illegal aliens, right?
 Mr. Newman. Congressman, what is your beef with immigrants?
 Mr. Gill. I do not have any beef with immigrants. I am 
asking you if you think it is appropriate to shut down one of 
the busiest bridges in America to give taxpayer-funded 
unemployment benefits to illegal aliens.
 Mr. Newman. Well, let me ask you this question. Do you 
think it is appropriate----
 Mr. Gill. No, you----
 Mr. Newman. Do you think it is appropriate for people to 
protest----
 Mr. Gill. You do not ask questions in these hearings.
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. For equal rights?
 Mr. Gill. Do you think that illegal aliens should receive--
--
 Mr. Newman. Were you against Congressman----
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. Cash payments from taxpayers?
 Mr. Newman. Were you against Congressman----
 Mr. Gill. Should illegal----
 Mr. Newman. Were you against Congressman Lewis' effort?
 Mr. Gill. No, you are not going to ask the questions here. 
That is not how this works.
 Mr. Newman. I am answering your question with a question.
 Mr. Gill. I have got another question for you. We are 
moving on. Should illegal aliens receive direct cash payments 
from taxpayers?
 Mr. Newman. I believe future citizens, Americans in 
waiting, should receive equal rights----
 Mr. Gill. So, they should receive----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. And they should receive benefits 
so we can integrate them into our society.
 Mr. Gill. It makes sense because your organization sent a 
letter to Governor Cuomo advocating for immediate cash relief, 
cash payments to illegal aliens. I think that is way out of 
line, out of step with----
 Mr. Newman. I think the alternative is to create a 
permanent underclass----
 Mr. Gill [continuing]. The rest of the country----
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. That allows people like you to 
exploit.
 Mr. Gill. And with that said, we are already 30 seconds 
over, so we are out of time here, and my time is up.
 Mr. Newman. But Congressman, you did not even give me a 
chance to answer.
 Mr. Gill. No, sir. Your time is up. Do we have a UC?
 Ms. Simon. Chair?
 Mr. Newman. Well, I am here to----
 Mr. Gill. Go for it.
 Mr. Newman. I will give you the rest of my data----
 Mr. Gill. No, we are done.
 Mr. Newman [continuing]. To answer your questions, sir.
 Mr. Gill. We are done with this. We have got a UC request 
here. Go for it.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I ask unanimous consent to 
enter into the record, May 20, 2026, an article from the U.N. 
entitled, ``30,000 People Flee Fresh Violence in Haiti as 
Hunger Crisis Deepens,'' which shows the extreme violence 
compromises----
 Mr. Gill. Without objection.
 Ms. Simon. Thank you, sir, Mr. Chair.
 Mr. Gill. All right. In closing, I would like to thank the 
witnesses once again for the testimony, and I would like to 
thank Ranking Member Simon and Members of the other side of the 
aisle.
 With that, and without objection, all Members have five 
legislative days within which to submit materials and 
additional written questions for the witnesses, which will be 
forwarded to the witnesses.
 If there is no further business without objection, the Task 
Force stands adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 11:03 a.m., the Task Force was adjourned.]

 [all]