Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- THE MONITORING RACKET: THE GRIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING [House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] THE MONITORING RACKET: THE GRIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON CRIME AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SURVEILLANCE OF THE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 13, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-57 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via: http://judiciary.house.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 62-913 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY JIM JORDAN, Ohio, Chair DARRELL ISSA, California JAMIE RASKIN, Maryland, Ranking ANDY BIGGS, Arizona Member TOM McCLINTOCK, California JERROLD NADLER, New York THOMAS P. TIFFANY, Wisconsin ZOE LOFGREN, California THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky STEVE COHEN, Tennessee CHIP ROY, Texas HENRY C. ``HANK'' JOHNSON, Jr., SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin Georgia BEN CLINE, Virginia ERIC SWALWELL, California LANCE GOODEN, Texas TED LIEU, California JEFFERSON VAN DREW, New Jersey PRAMILA JAYAPAL, Washington TROY E. NEHLS, Texas J. LUIS CORREA, California BARRY MOORE, Alabama MARY GAY SCANLON, Pennsylvania KEVIN KILEY, California JOE NEGUSE, Colorado HARRIET M. HAGEMAN, Wyoming LUCY McBATH, Georgia LAUREL M. LEE, Florida DEBORAH K. ROSS, North Carolina WESLEY HUNT, Texas BECCA BALINT, Vermont RUSSELL FRY, South Carolina JESUS G. ``CHUY'' GARCIA, Illinois GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California BRAD KNOTT, North Carolina JARED MOSKOWITZ, Florida MARK HARRIS, North Carolina DANIEL S. GOLDMAN, New York ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri JASMINE CROCKETT, Texas DEREK SCHMIDT, Kansas BRANDON GILL, Texas MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON CRIME AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SURVEILLANCE ANDY BIGGS, Arizona, Chair TOM TIFFANY, Wisconsin LUCY McBATH, Georgia, Ranking TROY NEHLS, Texas Member BARRY MOORE, Alabama JARED MOSKOWITZ, Florida KEVIN KILEY, California DAN GOLDMAN, New York LAUREL LEE, Florida STEVE COHEN, Tennessee BRAD KNOTT, North Carolina ERIC SWALWELL, California CHRISTOPHER HIXON, Majority Staff Director ARTHUR EWENCZYK, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Friday, February 13, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Page The Honorable Andy Biggs, Chair of the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance from the State of Arizona...... 2 WITNESSES Felix Garcia, President, CEO, Zoe Foundation, Inc. Oral Testimony................................................. 5 Prepared Testimony............................................. 6 Jon Riches, Vice President, Litigation, Goldwater Institute, Scharf-Norton Center for Constitutional Litigation Oral Testimony................................................. 8 Prepared Testimony............................................. 10 The Hon. Debbie Lesko, Fourth District, Maricopa County Board of Supervisors Oral Testimony................................................. 12 LETTERS, STATEMENTS, ETC. SUBMITTED FOR THE HEARING All materials submitted by the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance, for the record........................ 31 Materials submitted by the Honorable Andy Biggs, Chair of the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance from the State of Arizona, for the record A lease agreement between Luhr's Investors, LLC and Maricopa County, Jan. 13, 2021 A bill from Warshaw & Associates, Inc., to the Director OMB, County of Maricopa, Aug. 1, 2023 A letter to the Honorable Andy Biggs, Chair of the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance from the State of Arizona, and the Honorable Jim Jordan, Chair of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of Ohio, from the Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC), Feb. 12, 2026 A statement from the National Association of Police Organizations, Inc. (NAPO), Feb. 11, 2026 An article entitled, ``DOJ supports call to end Maricopa County Sheriff's Office oversight case,'' Jan. 10, 2026, AZFamily An article entitled, ``Supervisors call for end to $353M oversight of sheriff's office,'' Jul. 23, 2025, Washington Examiner An article entitled, ``County attorney says monitor has `financial incentive' to continue MCSO oversight,'' Jul. 18, 2025, AZFamily An article entitled, ``Sheriff's office monitor is draining Maricop County | Opinion,'' Sept. 3, 2025, The Arizona Republic A statement entitled ``A Citizen's Plea for Relief, Balance, and Local Accountability in Maricopa County,'' Chris Clark, Private Citizen, Taxpayer, and U.S. Marine Corps Veteran President, Deputies Law Enforcement Association A letter to Hon. Pam Bondi, Attorney General of the United States, from the Honorable Andy Biggs, Chair of the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance from the State of Arizona, Oct. 7, 2025 APPENDIX Materials submitted by the Honorable Andy Biggs, Chair of the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance from the State of Arizona, for the record A testimony from the United Coalition of Public Safety (UCOPS), Feb. 13, 2026 A statement from Representative Paul Gosar from the State of Arizona, Feb. 27, 2026 A Memorandum for Heads of Civil Litigating Components United States Attorneys, Office of the Associate Attorney General, U.S. Department of Justice, Aug. 13, 2021 THE MONITORING RACKET: THE GRIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING ---------- Friday, February 13, 2026 House of Representatives Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance Committee on the Judiciary Washington, DC The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9 a.m., MST, at the Arizona State Senate, 1700 W. Washington Street, SHR109, Phoenix, Arizona, the Hon. Andy Biggs [Chair of the Subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Biggs and Nehls. Also present: Representative Fry. Mr. Biggs. The Subcommittee will come to order. I recognize the gentleman from South Carolina, Mr. Fry, to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. [Pledge of Allegiance.] Mr. Biggs. Without objection, the Chair is authorized to declare a recess at anytime. We welcome everyone to today's hearing on the monitoring of the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. Without objection, Mr. Fry will be permitted to participate in today's hearing and will receive five minutes or more to question the witnesses. I want everyone to understand this is an official Congressional hearing, even though it is being held in Phoenix at the Arizona State Legislature. We will abide by all the rules of the House of Representatives and the House Judiciary Committee. This is being televised live by C-SPAN, which is a norm for Federal Congressional hearings. Thus, we expect decorum to be enforced, just like we would if we were sitting in a hearing room in the House of Representatives in Washington, DC. I also want to offer a short explanation, because I served here for many years. There is a distinction between what happens in a State Legislative hearing and a Federal Congressional hearing. In a State Legislative hearing, it is common for the public to have access to microphones and be able to speak. This is not the norm. I have never actually seen it, frankly, in a Congressional hearing. I do not believe it is permissible. That is why we have witnesses that come and testify, and that is one of the big distinctions between a State hearing and a Congressional hearing. I wanted to clarify that. Now, without further ado, I recognize myself for an opening statement. I thank everyone who is participating in today's field hearing in the beautiful State capital of Phoenix, Arizona. I thank our witnesses for being here, I thank the staff and the media who are here, and I thank mostly citizens who are here or watching this live, for participating in that way. While today's hearing is focused on the special monitor here in Maricopa County, it has implications for residents across this Nation who also find their law enforcement agencies held hostage by a special monitor or a similar situation. Since December 2013, the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office has been under Federal judicial oversight following a Department of Justice investigation into a case that started in 2008, Ortega Melendres v. Arpaio. In 2007, Latino motorist and passengers aided by the ACLU filed a lawsuit against Maricopa County and then Sheriff Joe Arpaio. The lawsuit alleged that MCSO violated the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments by engaging in a systematic practice of unconstitutional racial profiling, including stopping, detaining, and arresting Latino individuals during traffic stops and patrol operations, based on race or perceived immigration status. Following a bench trial in December 2011, U.S. District Judge Murray Snow ruled, in 2013, that MCSO had violated constitutional protections and imposed permanent injunctions that required MCSO to implement sweeping reforms to policies, training, operations, and internal investigations. Unlike a consent decree, which is a negotiated settlement agreed to by the parties, the court imposed these injunctions after findings of liability. The DOJ consent decrees are typically entered into voluntarily by the State or local governments to resolve a civil rights investigation without a trial, even though they can result in similarly extensive Federal oversight and court-appointed monitoring. In January 2014, Judge Snow appointed a Federal court monitor, Robert Warshaw, to oversee MCSO's compliance with the court's permanent injunctions, including reforms intended to address racial discrimination during traffic stops and deficiencies in policy development and oversight. Following that, in July 2015, the court mandated additional remedial measures, including further policy revisions to further strengthen oversight mechanisms. The Federal court monitoring was intended to last only until MCSO achieved full and effective compliance with the court's injunctions. Yet, oversight has continued for more than a decade, without a fixed end State. As the federally appointed court monitor, some of Warshaw's tasks include assessing MCSO's adherence to judicial orders, issuing periodic reports, holding community meetings, and reviewing MCSO internal practices and policies. This extended judicial supervision has placed significant financial burdens on Maricopa County taxpayers, with costs reportedly reaching nearly $350 million since 2013. Most of these expenses include the administrative efforts needed to demonstrate compliance with court orders. For example, despite remote work and meetings in 2021, the County was responsible for funding a 3,200-square-foot office suite for the monitor, costing taxpayers more than $97,000 for a year. That is in spite of remote working. This persistent Federal judicial intervention has created operational challenges for MCSO, including difficulties in recruiting and retaining qualified deputies. The increased administrative workload and ongoing scrutiny have led to a decline in staff retention, have discouraged potential recruits from pursuing careers with the Department, which ultimately has impacted on the officers' ability to serve and protect the community. The Federal court monitor typically issues quarterly reports, which track the MCSO's compliance with the court- ordered reforms, and provided the court with independent assessments of policy implementation, operational practices, and overall progress. Over the course of more than 40 reports, MCSO's compliance rate increased from 30 percent in 2014 to more than 94 percent by 2025, meeting the standard that requires the agency to demonstrate adherence in more than 94 percent of instances under review. According to Warshaw, MCSO's compliance framework has become self-sustaining and institutionalized. While compliance measurements are based on documented adherence and subject to court review, they are not determined by the monitor. Warshaw also labeled MCSO's compliance with policies, training, and supervisory review as solid, noting that the compliance measures were fully built into the agency's daily work, showing full, independent accountability. Last month, the Trump Administration's Justice Department filed a brief supporting Maricopa County's request to end Federal oversight, noting that the litigation has been successful in reforming the agency. The Department argued that the extensive reforms imposed through the consent decree or the judgment have been successful in correcting the unconstitutional practices identified in the original case, and that MCSO has demonstrated sustained, systemic compliance. The Department cited multiple recent monitor reports documenting consistently high compliance rates, institutionalized policy adherence, effective training programs, and durable accountability mechanisms. The Department indicated that continued Federal supervision is no longer necessary to ensure constitutional policing, supporting termination of both the consent decree, the court-appointed monitoring regime, and the court's order. Maricopa County is not the only jurisdiction lining the pockets of Robert Warshaw and his associates. Warshaw has been accused of taking exorbitant payments without producing results and monitoring law enforcement agencies in New York, California, Michigan, and Louisiana. For example, Warshaw faced criticism for the duration, high cost, and evolving compliance benchmarks of Federal oversight in Oakland, California, one of the longest-running Federal police oversight regimes in U.S. history, since a 2003 settlement. In 2024, 1,508 complaints were filed against Oakland Police Department's 710 sworn officers and were nearly universally, nearly all were completely dismissed. Despite reportedly spending little time in Oakland, Warshaw was paid more than $1 million annually by the city, a structure that incentivizes prolonging monitorship. Warshaw's monitorship is criticized for its expansive scope and prolonged duration. Compared to monitors who operate under narrowly defined mandates and fixed timelines, Warshaw's role continuously blurs the line between oversight and management. Questions about judgment and incentives have also followed Warshaw's consulting contracts elsewhere. In Niagara Falls, New York, for example, Warshaw was retained at a rate of $200 an hour, ultimately costing taxpayers more than $200,000 over two years, despite the mayor's initial public estimate that the contract would total only $57,000. Together these episodes have been cited by critics as emblematic of a pattern in which Warshaw's work unfolds with limited transparency, minimal cost controls, and little external check on the expansion or duration of his authority. I look forward to hearing from today's panel, and I thank the Members and witnesses for taking part and for the public's interest in attending. I yield back. Without objection, all other opening statements will be included in the record. Now, I will introduce today's witnesses. Ms. Debbie Lesko. Ms. Lesko represents the Fourth District on the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, where she is also the Vice Chair. She has previously served as our colleague in the House of Representatives from 2018-2025, and she also served in the Arizona Legislature from 2009-2018. Thank you, Supervisor Lesko. Mr. Felix Garcia is a member of the Community Advisory Board for the Monitor of the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. He is also the President and CEO of the Zoe Foundation, a nonprofit organizations that provides materials and resources to families and businesses. Thank you, Mr. Garcia, for being with us today. Mr. Jon Riches is Vice President for Litigation at the Goldwater Institute's Scharf-Norton Center for Constitutional Litigation and also serves as the Goldwater Institute's General Counsel. He litigates in Federal and State courts across the country on issues including economic liberty, regulatory reform, free speech, taxpayer protection, government transparency, and other issues. We welcome our witnesses and thank them for appearing today. Now, we will ask you to stand and be sworn in. Please raise your right hand. Do each of you swear or affirm, under the penalty of perjury, that the testimony you are about to give is true and correct to the best of your knowledge, information, and belief, so help you God? Mr. Biggs. Let the record reflect the witnesses have answered in the affirmative. Please be seated. Please know that your written testimony will be entered into the record in its entirety, and without objection we will allow each of you considerable leeway on the normal five-minute time constraint. Hearing none. Ms. Lesko--oh no, we are not going to begin with you, Ms. Lesko. We are actually going to begin with Mr. Garcia, so we are going to go back this way. Mr. Garcia, we welcome you here today and recognize you for your opening statement. STATEMENT OF FELIX GARCIA Mr. Garcia. Thank you, Mr. Chair and the Members of the Committee. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Felix Garcia. I am a volunteer member of the Community Advisory Board connected with this case. I want to make clear, today I am speaking in my personal capacity. My opinions are my own, and they do not represent the other members of the board who may have different views. I decided to serve because I believe in building trust between law enforcement and the community, especially within my community, the Hispanic community. Although oversight is important, it helps protect your rights, ensure accountability, and build trust when it has been broken. At one time court supervision played an important role in Maricopa County. After more than 10 years and the Federal monitoring cost $100 million to taxpayers, it is fair to ask this important question: Is the current system still helping our community to move forward? Over the past year, I worked directly with the community through my nonprofit working groups, over 10 years. Over the last year I have worked very closely with the community and the sheriff to organize many events, and I speak to hundreds and hundreds of Latino leaderships, people of faith, and families across the county. What I hear again and again is the people want to feel safe, respected, and included in it. I have personally seen engagement between the Sheriff's Office and community that shows progress. My opinion right now with this is my perception is the people support the Sheriff's Office. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Garcia follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Biggs. Thank you, Mr. Garcia. We now to go to Mr. Riches and recognize you for your opening statement. STATEMENT OF JON RICHES Mr. Riches. Thank you. Mr. Chair and the Members of the Committee, I appreciate the opportunity to testify. My name is Jon Riches. I am the Vice President for Litigation at the Goldwater Institute. That is a public policy and public interest litigation organization. I want to make two points this morning, one rooted in longstanding constitutional principles of federalism and the other rooted in democratic accountability and government transparency. First, under traditional principles of federalism, law enforcement and local spending decisions are and must remain primarily State and local functions, not ones administered indefinitely by Federal officials. Second, when tax dollars are spent to operate local government, including, and perhaps especially, in the law enforcement context, State public records laws and public policy require transparency, not secrecy. Taxpayers have a right to know how their tax dollars are spent. As to the federalism point, our Constitution leaves law enforcement to the responsibility of local officials. Indeed, the Federal Government has no general police power. Federal courts absolutely have the authority to remedy constitutional violations, but remedies are supposed to be temporary, targeted, and respectful of the State's paramount role in law enforcement, not substitutions for that role. Here that structural balance has broken down. In Maricopa County, a federally appointed out-of-State monitor, selected by one Federal judge, has exercised sweeping authority over a local Sheriff's Office for more than a decade, at taxpayer expense, exceeding $30 million just for the monitor's expenses. There is no clear end date in sight. At some point, oversight stops being remedial and starts becoming structural, and that raises constitutional concerns. When Federal supervision is open-ended it supplants local voters, it supplants local officials, and it supplants State law. The concern is particularly acute here where core decisions not only involve law enforcement but spending, and ultimately taxation. These have been delegated to a Federal agent with no accountability to the public. In that circumstance, there is a transfer of powers that the Constitution assigns to other branches and other levels of government. Our constitutional structure exists precisely to prevent this. Federal authority, even when well intentioned, must be limited, reviewable, and constrained, or it violates principles of federalism that are an essential feature of our republic and a guardrail for the protection of individual liberty. That brings me to my second point, transparency. Under Arizona law and the law of virtually every State, records concerning the operation of government and the expenditure of public funds are presumptively public. The public has a right to know what their government is up to, and that right is essential to democratic accountability. The Arizona Supreme Court has made this clear time and again. Citizens cannot hold officials accountable if they are denied information about what those officials are doing and how they are spending their money. Yet, in this case, millions of dollars are being spent with virtually no meaningful public disclosure. My organization, the Goldwater Institute, submitted State public records requests to the County and to the monitor, seeking an itemized accounting of the monitor's invoices and basic salary information for the monitor's staff. Because of existing Federal orders in this case, the County does not possess, or cannot disclose, that information, and the monitor simply did not respond at all. Under State law, that outcome would not occur in any other context. For virtually every public expenditure, things from road construction, consulting contracts, law enforcement grants, itemized invoices and supporting documents are public records. Allowing taxpayer funds to be spent indefinitely, without disclosure, directly conflicts with Arizona's transparency laws. The only information that has been available to the public consists of heavily redacted or nondescriptive invoices. There are no detailed time entries, expense reports, or supporting documentation. None of that information has been disclosed to the very people on whose behalf, and at whose expense, the monitor is purportedly operating. That is now how government transparency is supposed to work, and that is not how it does work as a matter of State law. Secrecy may be justified temporarily to protect a legitimate government interest, but blanket secrecy for more than a decade, long after reforms have been implemented, cannot be squared with democratic norms. In sum, federalism exists to ensure that law enforcement and spending decisions remain locally and democratically accountable. Public records law exists to ensure that taxpayers can see how their government is operating and how their money is being spent. When Federal oversight overrides both democratic control and transparency, it creates a system that inverts these core principles of our constitutional republic. Thank you, and I will be happy to answer any questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Riches follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Biggs. Thank you, Mr. Riches. Now, I recognize Supervisor Lesko for her opening statement. STATEMENT OF THE HON. DEBBIE LESKO Ms. Lesko. Well, good morning, Mr. Chair and the Committee Members. It is great to be here with my former colleagues from Congress. The Chair and I served right here in these chambers as our old stomping ground, so it is great to be here. I really want to thank you for traveling here. This is a very important issue for Maricopa County and the taxpayers of Maricopa County and for public safety in Maricopa County. That is what this is all about, making sure we protect the public. As a Maricopa County Supervisor, I am here today to talk about the long-term damage caused by the Federal court orders in Melendres v. Arpaio, and more specifically, the under- checked and costly monitor regime that has grown out of this case. It has become a clear example of how Federal oversight, when left unchecked, can drift far beyond its original purpose, at great cost in local control and taxpayers. This all started with a complaint against then Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, alleging racial profiling of Latino drivers and passengers. Fourteen years, three sheriffs, and millions and millions of dollars per year later, the Sheriff's Office is still under this burdensome and costly Federal monitor regime. For more than a decade, this monitoring process appears to be operating with virtually no limiting principle. What began as targeted oversight has evolved into an open-ended system, where compliance seems to be constantly redefined, new requirements are layered on, and progress is never allowed to be final. The monitor's role has expanded far beyond verifying constitutional policies and instead has expanded into day-to- day operational micromanagement of the Sheriff's Department. The consequences have been severe. Every dollar spent feeding this monitoring bureaucracy is a dollar not spent on deputies, patrols, training, crime prevention, or victim services. Every hour spent satisfying reporting demands is an hour not spent protecting our neighborhoods. The cumulative effect has been a long-term erosion of public safety capacity in Maricopa County. The public is told, ``This is all necessary,'' by the Federal judge. Necessary for whom? The monitor is paid to find deficiencies, and the system seems structured so that their deficiencies are always found. Even when benchmarks are met, new interpretation seems to appear, new metrics emerge, and the finish line moves. For example, I want to give you one example. Just last month, the monitor reversed himself and declared that the Sheriff's Office is not in compliance with a paragraph that has been in compliance for years. That paragraph requires the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office to submit training materials within 90 days of the order, which was satisfied back in June 2016. Now, after a decade, the goalposts have yet again been moved. The monitor, in this case, is the same monitor who has been monitoring the Oakland, California, Police Department for the last 25 years. Do you know what the kicker is? Existing court orders, as has been said before, dating back to 2014, prevent taxpayers from fully knowing where their money is even going. Detailed monitor billing and time entries are provided only to the court. The County itself is restricted from seeing that information, much less sharing that information with the public. That is not transparency. That is not accountability. Twelve years later, it is not justified. I want to be very clear. This is not about rejecting constitutional policing or resisting oversight. Maricopa County has made significant reforms, many of them at great expense and in good faith. The Sheriff's Office is doing a fantastic job. In fact, today there is no evidence of ongoing civil rights violations, there are no new allegations of targeted immigration enforcement, and the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office has achieved 100 percent compliance with required policy changes. The 2023 Traffic Study Annual Report that the court requires found no statistically significant difference between White drivers and Hispanic drivers across any measured benchmark. Late last year, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, of which I am a member, filed a Rule 60 motion, seeking relief from this Federal oversight, and I am happy to say that the United States Department of Justice supports a Rule 60 motion to end this oversight. Let's be clear. The County says it is time. The data says it is time. The monitor's own findings say it is time. The United States Department of Justice says it is time to end this burdensome, bureaucratic, costly Federal oversight of the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. It is time to recognize that Federal monitoring is no longer needed. I say enough is enough. Thank you, and I yield back. Mr. Biggs. Thank you, Supervisor Lesko. I appreciate that, and I appreciate your testimony, all your testimoneys. Now, I will recognize, for his questioning, the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Nehls. Mr. Nehls. Thank you, Chair. I would like to thank all the witnesses for being here. I am an old former sheriff from the great State of Texas, Fort Bend County. A relatively large agency. We had about 800,000 people there, and about 826 deputies. I feel I have some basic understanding of how to manage a law enforcement agency. I believe I understand the complexities that law enforcement is facing today across the country. I do believe that public safety, above all else, is their No. 1 priority, public safety. I am concerned with the impact of the Federal judicial monitor on the ability of this Sheriff's Office to adequately investigate, solve, and deter crime. Mr. Chair, you brought it up in your opening remarks, but I believe it is worth repeating. How did we get here? How did this all begin? When you go back to that Ortega Melendres v. Arpaio, the 2007-2008 timeframe, allegations surfaced of racial profiling, I believe, in the Latino community. In 2011, I guess there was a bench trial, and then in 2013, the District Judge, G. Murray Snow, ruled that the Sheriff's Office violated constitutional protections and imposed permanent injunctions, implementing the sweeping reforms--apparently it had to get done--to the policies, to training, to operations, and to internal investigations. In 2014, the judge appoints Robert Warshaw as a Federal court monitor. In 2015, they come back a little bit and say, ``We have got to make some additional remedial measures.'' The question I have to ask of all of you, one at a time, is: Was there, at that time, a need for this judicial oversight? Ms. Lesko? Just a yes or no, really. Was there a need for it at the time? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Mr. Nehls. I was not involved at the time, but there were allegations and the Federal court upheld them. They had a court order and said things needed to be changed. What I can tell you, for sure, as a matter of fact, is the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office has now gone through four sheriffs under this, and they have worked tirelessly to make reforms, and make sure that they are in compliance. As I have said, they are in 100 percent compliance on their policies, and many of the paragraphs, they have done everything over and above to satisfy this court. It is never enough. It is never enough. Mr. Nehls. I do not disagreeing with anything you said, but my question is, at the time that the judge made the ruling, back in 2014, was there a need for this type of judicial oversight, Mr. Riches? Mr. Riches. Mr. Chair, Congressman, Federal courts do exist to remedy constitutional violations, and if the court finds a constitutional violation, they can put in place orders to remedy it. The question today, though, is very different than the question as to what happened then, and as Ms. Lesko indicated, we are now four sheriffs and beyond the remedial purpose of the initial allegations in the case. Mr. Nehls. How about you, Mr. Garcia? Do you believe back then, when this judge, appointed by Bush, by the way, appointed by President Bush, do you believe that there was a need to have this back then? I tell you, I was an old sheriff 2012-2020, and I heard about show me your papers. I heard about this sheriff tents and everything else. There was a lot of attention. They called him ``America's sheriff.'' Mr. Garcia. Right. Mr. Nehls. Do you feel, at the time when the decision was made--I am not talking about today, four different sheriffs now, three or four--but back at the time, was it necessary? Mr. Garcia. I think yes. It was necessary. Mr. Nehls. Thank you. OK. His job, then, this Mr. Warshaw, was to get the Sheriff's Office to comply with the permanent injunctions, the court ordered. His job was to issue periodic reports, hold community meetings, which I would like to get into a little bit, and then review the Sheriff's Office's internal policies and practices. I want to talk a little bit about the periodic reports. I guess there are 40-plus reports that have been issued. These reports have shown significant improvements. Ms. Lesko, you brought it up to 100 percent, you said. These reports have shown much improvement or compliance. The compliance rate back in 2014 was 30 percent. I am kind of believing maybe back then there was a need. It was an order. Then, you see we get to 2025, and we are at 94 percent. These 40-plus reports, the fourth report back in 2015, had a 40 percent compliance rate. The 26th report, issued in 2020, are up to 98 percent. Report numbers 33 and 34, back in 2022 and 2025, show compliance rates of 93 percent, 94 percent. It certainly appears to me that the Sheriff's Office has complied with all the aspects of this judicial ruling. If I may, Mr. Garcia, I would like to start with you. If you could, for me--I am new to this here. I do not know who you are. Would you be willing to share with us a little bit about your background, how long have you lived here, and why are you on this Committee? What is your community involvement then? What makes you, I do not want to say, so special, but what made you part of this process? Mr. Garcia. Basically, I have lived in Phoenix, Arizona, for the last 26 years. I live in North Central Phoenix. I am a Mexican American, born in Hermosillo, Mexico. I am working with the community for so many years with my nonprofit, and in my nonprofit, we have one immigration program specially for new citizenships. We are very active in the community with the last sheriff, working very close with Penzone and the Hispanic board. With a new sheriff, I am appointed with the sheriff to this board. Mr. Nehls. OK. Again, in recent years the Sheriff's Office has reached very successful compliance with this oversight of the judicial monitor. I believe you mentioned in your opening that you believe the relationship today with the sheriff and the community he is charged to protect and serve is better today than what it once was. Mr. Garcia. That is excellent. I am attending every single event with the sheriff. One especially in November--not November--we have one with the Friends of Arizona. The sheriff is coming, and this is 100 percent Latinos come, first and second generation. Everybody at the event is interested in taking a picture with the sheriff, not only the people participating but every person at the event. We organize a lot of events for the sheriff, and everybody is interested in interacting with the sheriff. Mr. Nehls. What you are saying is you have seen improved relationships, you are noticing it, between the community and the Sheriff's Office. When I started in my law enforcement career 30 years ago, community policing, it was the buzzword, it was the big deal, community policing. You do not have issues. The Sheriff's Offices, or I will just focus on large municipal police, when there is friction or the Sheriff's Office or the Police Department and the people, the residents, when there is distrust there things are going to get ugly. We have seen it across our Nation over the last several years when there is a distrust. You have been here this long. Have you noticed that we have community policing philosophy at the Sheriff's Office back in 2012 or 2008-2009? Was that philosophy to build relationships with the people? Mr. Garcia. Yes, working very closely with my nonprofit, I started working with the Sheriff, I think in 2014, 2016. The relationship with the community is very active. After Sheriff Arpaio left, the inside started to change. I see the difference right now. That is good. Mr. Nehls. Very good. You believe that, I guess point blank, what has changed? Give me an example of what has changed now that you see, all of a sudden, a strong relationship versus having a Federal court get involved with these injunctions? What changed in that period of time? Attitudes? Different leadership style? Mr. Garcia. The leadership. I do not see so many stops with the Latino community. As you know, 150-200 people move from California to Arizona, obviously, the numbers have changed, because 200 people daily--daily--move to Arizona. Mr. Nehls. Very good. How transparent and collaborative is communication between the Community Advisory Board, which you serve on, Mr. Warshaw, and the Sheriff's Office leadership team? Mr. Garcia. Normally basically we have one meeting every month with the board, and every three months, all together in person. Mr. Nehls. Does Mr. Warshaw show up? Mr. Garcia. I have seen Mr. Warshaw two times, one dinner before one event and the court a couple of months ago. Mr. Nehls. OK. I am talking over the past several years; how many times has he actually attended one of these meetings? Mr. Garcia. Well, I am on the board for only one year. Mr. Nehls. Oh, you have seen him twice in the year? Mr. Garcia. Yes. Mr. Nehls. If he is not there, does he have other staff, or does he delegate to others? Mr. Garcia. Yes. There is one person working with him. We have a meeting with this lady. Mr. Nehls. Someone is there. Mr. Garcia. Yes. Mr. Nehls. In your experience, has the Community Advisory Board influenced policy or practice changes? Are they listening to you, the board, the community, as it relates to changes in policy? Are you effective? Do you feel like we actually have the ability to make things better, because they, the Sheriff's Office, the monitor, they are listening to the people? Mr. Garcia. Well, I do not see the difference in reality, because three on the board attacking me all the time because I organize these events to the Sheriff. This is specifically this week, I received two attacks from two of the members, attacking by email, why am I here, why, if you represent the whole board. Is the reason because I say, yes, this is my voice. Another member of the board, the husband, is an activist outside, and is attacking me frequently. Yesterday in the newspaper I read a newspaper, it is attacking me, saying I am a racist person, this sort of stuff. It is public right now. If you read Prensa Arizona, read that this person attacked me, says I am a Charlie Kirk person. That is the reason because I supported Charlie. It is really bad because I meet with the Sheriff, with the Latino community. Every single Latino outside is interested in meeting with the Sheriff. Mr. Nehls. You may have touched on this, but I want to get a yes or no from you. Do you believe that with the cooperation of the Advisory Board and the Sheriff's Office that the judicial monitor is still necessary? Do you believe that he is still necessary today? Mr. Garcia. He is not necessary. Mr. Nehls. OK, very good. This is not something that--it could be better managed at the local level with community input. You have your board, you have a Sheriff's Office, and you have everybody coming together. Everybody seems to be working well together. We could just say we do not need any more judicial overreach, because it is just costing money, and it is unnecessary. Mr. Garcia. Yes. Mr. Nehls. I appreciate that. Mr. Riches, Goldwater Institute's amicus brief argues that federalism requires that a County Sheriff's Office be overseen by the people of the county, not the Federal Government. In your view, has the more than a decade-long Federal monitoring of the Sheriff's Office violated this principle of local self-governance? Mr. Riches. Mr. Chair and Congressman, yes, as I indicated in my opening statement, obviously the initial order is a different question than the continued oversight long after facts and circumstances have changed. In this particular situation when there is no end to Federal oversight it raises principles of federalism. Mr. Nehls. Chair Galvin brought it up that Warshaw keeps moving or shifting the goalposts, I believe he stated, and how does that shifting compliance, the benchmarks, or the indefinite monitoring of the Sheriff's Office's ability to implement policies based on local priorities? How do they do it, when you have this type of overreach? Mr. Riches. Well, it is hard to say, and I am not a particular expert on that issue specifically. I would say that if there is going to be direction from Federal oversight to any State or local agency it should be clear and consistent, and there should not be circumstances where it is consistently changing. Mr. Nehls. These invoices that they keep receiving, really the taxpayers, do you believe the taxpayers should have access to detailed information, showing how monitor-related funds are spent, even when those funds are subject to Federal court oversight? Mr. Riches. Not only should they but as a matter of State law they have a legal right to that information. Arizona's law is abundantly clear on this. Anytime the government engages in public business or spends taxpayer funds, taxpayers have a right to see what they are doing with that money. As a result of the Federal court orders in this place, that has hamstrung taxpayers from a receiving information they would otherwise have a legal right to receive. Mr. Nehls. Thank you, sir. Ms. Lesko, in your capacity as the Vice Chair of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, you interact with the Sheriff's Office. Chair Galvin of the Board of Supervisors has described the judicial monitor's oversight as, quote, ``decimating the agency with a 26 percent vacancy rate.'' I do not know how in the hell he can go out there and perform his job and keep his people safe in this county when you have got a 26 percent vacancy rate. Do you share this view of the situation, 26 percent? Ms. Lesko. Mr. Chair and Mr. Nehls, I do. It makes it very difficult for the Sheriff's Department to do their jobs of protecting citizens. Mr. Chair and Mr. Nehls, I would like to add a few things, if you do not mind. Not only did the Sheriff's Department achieve 100 percent compliance with required policy changes, but the most recently quarterly reports acknowledged that Latino drivers are not being cited, searched, or detained for longer periods of times, at rates different than other drivers in Maricopa County, and for two years annual traffic study analysis found no disparity between White and Hispanic drivers. In fact, the thing that they keep bringing up as why they cannot be in compliance is these backlogs of complaints against the Sheriff's Department or the detention officers. The backlogs have nothing to do with the original court case. They could be a complaint about a detention officer in a jail that has nothing to do with racial profiling of Hispanic or Latino drivers. It is very frustrating, and they have to have been doing this for years. We have had Republican sheriffs and Democrat sheriffs. In fact, one of the Democratic sheriffs, Sheriff Penzone resigned over this. He said that was the reason he resigned. He cannot do his job with this Federal monitorship. It has just become so burdensome and cost. Mr. Nehls. That is unfortunate. I have more questions for you, but I am going to yield back to the Chair. I guess we will have a second round, so I will get back to you in a few minutes. Thank you. Mr. Biggs. The gentleman yields. The Chair recognizes the gentleman from South Carolina, Mr. Fry, for his questions. Mr. Fry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for being here. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. It is a wonderful State. Debbie, it is good to see you again. It has been too long. You said it best--14 years, three or four sheriffs, and millions and millions of dollars, and you are still under this Federal oversight regime. The question for all of us, and maybe even the public, is why? To me, if I am looking at this objectively, you are either not in compliance with a court order from 14 years ago, or we are in an era where it is duplicative and unnecessary. Would you agree with that? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Mr. Fry. Yes, I agree with it. This is what has been so frustrating, and this is why the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors hired an attorney that deals with Federal issues like this, to file a Rule 60 motion, because it has been going on and on and on, and the goalposts keep moving. I have other examples in front of me if you care to hear them about how things have changed. Mr. Fry. We are going to go into that in a minute. I want to set this up for you. Ms. Lesko. They accomplish one thing, and then court and the monitor say, ``Oh, here's another thing. Here's another thing. Here's another thing.'' It seems like it never ends. Mr. Fry. It is a game of Whack-A-Mole. I think you mentioned Rule 60(b). That is important. Mr. Riches, what is Rule 60(b), for the public, for people who are paying attention, who are here in the room or back home. What is Rule 60(b)? Mr. Riches. Mr. Chair, Congressman, it is a rule in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure that allows a party to get relief from an existing order or judgment. Basically, it just asking the court to reconsider the court's orders. Mr. Fry. Yes, hey, judge, this is not--we are either in compliance with it, we have done our tax. We do not need to be under this prior court order. That is the thrust of it, right? It allows an affected party to seek relief from the court, maybe on an outdated judgment or court order. Is that correct? Mr. Riches. Yes, exactly. Mr. Fry. One of the things that I would imagine that a court reviews is the factual basis for the motion, right, what facts today are different than they were maybe, in this case, 14 years ago. Is that one way the courts evaluate the merits of a Rule 60(b) relief motion? Mr. Riches. Yes, certainly. Mr. Fry. OK. You mentioned federalism. federalism also is triggered under Rule 60(b), at least as far as Federal oversight over State and local issues. Is that also correct? Mr. Riches. Well, the party can raise the constitutional arguments, legal arguments, and factual developments that have occurred that would warrant relief from the judgment. To the extent this raises federalism concerns, and we certainly think it does, a party can certainly raise that in Rule 60 motion. Mr. Fry. Why are courts deferential to federalism concerns as they pertains to maybe Federal oversight over a State or local issue? Why is that important? Mr. Riches. Well, our whole constitutional system is predicated on retaining power for themselves and the States being the primary repository of the police power. The Federal Government is a system of limited powers. It only has that power, which is expressly delegated to it under the Constitution. When you have a situation that involves law enforcement, local spending, which ultimately inevitably involves taxation, as well, those are the matters that our Constitution entrusts to a different level of government than the one that is currently being exercised. Mr. Fry. I would say that looking at court opinions, courts have been hesitant to have this endless Federal intervention, if you will, in State and local issues beyond the term that is reasonably necessary. Is that fair to characterize? Mr. Riches. That is fair to characterize. In any situation like this, oversight should be temporary, it should be reviewable, and it should be transparent. Mr. Fry. Perfect. Let's go back, Ms. Lesko, let's go back to you for a moment. When you look at the original court order in 2014, there were, I don't know, 194 paragraphs of things that the judge wanted to pay attention to and addressed. Of the 194 paragraphs, how many have the County fully complied with to date? Do you know? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Mr. Fry. I do not know the exact amount, but I know it is very significant. Mr. Fry. It's 174--does that sound about right? Ms. Lesko. It sounds right to me, but I would have to check for details from actually the Sheriff's Department themselves. The thing is: You are exactly right. This is going on too long, and the number of paragraphs that it started with has grown exponentially. They keep adding onto these requirements to the Sheriff's Department. The reason that we filed, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, filed the Rule 60 motion is because the original purpose of the Melendres lawsuit, it has been achieved. It has been achieved. The Maricopa County Sheriff's Department is doing a good job, and even in many instances, the monitor agrees. The monitor agrees. They are doing the job that the original purpose of the lawsuit has been fulfilled. It is now time to move on and end this. It has been too long. Mr. Fry. Right. Ms. Lesko, one of the original things that the court took exception with, and the monitor as well, is that there was an illegal immigration hotline. Is there an illegal immigration hotline today? Ms. Lesko. Thank you. Mr. Chair and Mr. Fry, my understanding is there is not one. Mr. Fry. Correct. Correct. There is no III unit. There is no targeting, that has been attested to, of Latino drivers and passengers. There is no detention of Latinos pursuant to attempted enforcement of the AHSA [ph] and the ESEA compliance. I thought this was interesting when I was preparing for this hearing. Maybe some of the first reports, would it surprise you to show that the Sheriff's Office was not in compliance in the early years? That sounds normal. They are getting their feet under them, 30 percent, 40 percent compliance in early years. You attested to earlier, what is that compliance today? Ms. Lesko. I do not know. There are so many different paragraphs that I do not know the compliance of all them. What I can tell you is that we are 100 percent in compliance with required policy changes. The quarterly reports show that there are no significant differences between when you stop a Latino driver versus a White driver, and that has been going on for two years. There is no evidence of ongoing civil rights violations. There are no new allegations of targeted immigration enforcement. What seems to have come down to now is just this backlog of complaints against the Sheriff's Department, which is not even related. The backlog is not related to the original complaint. It could be anything. Like let's say somebody does not like a jail detention officer. That has nothing to do with this lawsuit. I do not work for the Sheriff's Department, I do not know all the specifics of which paragraphs have been in compliance, how many or what percentage. They have done a great job, and even the monitor himself, and the judge himself, has said that there has been huge improvement and that it really comes down to this backlog now, it appears. Mr. Fry. Correct. I am looking for specific stats. In 2014, it looked like 40 percent--2015--reflected 50 percent, 40 percent, or 40.3 percent compliance with Phases I and II. That was in 2015. This was right after the order, right. At the time, there was at least efforts being made, 40 percent compliance, but today it is 100 percent, right, and it has been sustained close to 100 percent for quite some time. Is that your understanding? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Mr. Fry. My understanding is that the Maricopa County Sheriff's Department is in compliance with many of the paragraphs, and there are lots of different paragraphs in this court order. To be in compliance I believe you have to do it for three years in a row. It is difficult to do, and especially when the goalposts keep moving. Mr. Fry. Correct. Ms. Lesko. You get in compliance, and then the goalpost moves. In the cases of several of these things, the one that I brought up in my opening statement, they were in compliance in 2016, and now all of a sudden they are out of compliance, even though nothing has changed. I have other examples of that, as well. It is very frustrating. Mr. Fry. It is. Over the course, it is frustrating for the people, too, because you are under Federal oversight on things in which you are compliant of. It goes back to the original point of what 60(b) is. It is a relief motion for an aggrieved party, in this case the County, the Sheriff's Office. It is a relief valve for further duplicative and unnecessary oversight. In your legal opinion, Mr. Riches, do you think that the County has complied with the original order of the court, enough to warrant a 60(b) relief motion? Mr. Riches. I am not fully familiar with the entire architecture of the litigation, but I would say that a circumstance like this is precisely the reason that Rule 60 exists. When it is very clear that facts have changed, that circumstances have changed, and that continuing Federal oversight raises constitutional and democratic accountability problems, this is precisely the sort of circumstance in which that rule allows a party to go and seek relief. Mr. Fry. Thank you for that. Mr. Chair, I yield back. I am going to have some second round of questions later, but I will yield to you, sir. Mr. Biggs. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize myself for some questioning and comments. Mr. Garcia, one of the things that you mentioned today is that other individuals on the Community Assessment Board, or whatever we call that, that oversight board, have been attacking you because you were willing to come to testify today. Is that accurate? Mr. Garcia. Yes. I received an invitation last week to come here, but I did not receive any details. Basically, one of the Members emailed me, to the whole group and the monitoring office, and two Members start to attack me. Why are you going, and a lot of really bad stuff, not only by email but the newspaper too. Mr. Biggs. Well, we appreciate you being here. Mr. Garcia. Thank you. Mr. Biggs. The point that I see is that I am hearing from you, is that the community and the Sheriff's Office now are simpatico. Mr. Garcia. Yes. Definitely. A hundred percent. Mr. Biggs. If the regime continues, it is not going to get any better because it is pretty good, which is my understanding. Mr. Garcia. Yes, money for a couple of people. Not for the community. Mr. Biggs. Right. Right. For the community. That is what I am talking about. Mr. Garcia. Yes. Mr. Biggs. OK. Thank you for that. Then Mr. Riches, I will not dwell too much on the 60(b) aspect, but I will just get to the point of what courts look at with 60(b), and you have highlighted it. They are looking at the facts and the law, right? In this instance the law, early on the judge made a determination, what he felt the constitutional interpretation and application of that was to the facts that were brought before him. In your participation in this, the lawsuit ultimately, we now see that there seems to be, even on the part of the monitor's admission, although he does like to move things around a little bit, at least what I have read from him, he indicates that there is not just substantial compliance, there is almost complete and full compliance. That would be something that normally a court would take into account, as the changed factual circumstances, when they apply the same law to those facts, right? Mr. Riches. Mr. Chair, yes. Yes, exactly. You have a circumstance now where a party is saying the facts have changed, the monitor has essentially conceded near total compliance, and the Federal Government has also weighed in and said that it is time for the oversight to end. That confluence of factors is certainly an appropriate way to support a Rule 60(b) motion. Mr. Biggs. Well, this is a question for any of you. Since the original court order, has there been any modification in the actual court's order over the last 12 years? Do any of you know that? Ms. Lesko. Well-- Mr. Biggs. I am not referring to the monitor moving all over the place. I am talking actually in the language of the original order. Any modifications? Ms. Lesko. Mr. Chair, all I know is there's lots of modifications. I do not know if that is a court. The monitor works under the Federal judge in the court, and so they have changed the goalposts repeatedly, yes. I will find out if I can get your exact answer. Mr. Biggs. OK. That sounds good. Because in my looking through this I do not know that I recall seeing actual modification--oh, here we go. Ms. Lesko. The answer is yes; they have modified it three times. Mr. Biggs. OK. Very good. Thank you. Where the crux of the issue becomes is the monitor's, the rather carte blanche way the monitor has in acting and has moved things around. That was one of my questions on that. I will just say, Ms. Lesko, you talked about the incentives, so I am just going to talk for just a second about incentives and tradeoffs. When you look at incentives and tradeoffs, everybody responds to incentives, or disincentives, and everybody is making a tradeoff on virtually everything that they decide. When you have a monitor that is making a lot of money, and is making money from multiple jurisdictions--which, by the way, is contrary to something I am going to talk about in a second--their incentive is not to actually encourage compliance completely and then walk away and let people be free to continue in their actions. Their incentive, instead, is to maintain control and the economic benefit that they are getting. That is what I see happening here with Mr. Warshaw. The tradeoff that he is making, some people would say it is a moral tradeoff, and I will leave that aside, but the other people would say he is just flat-out making a tradeoff between finding compliance in Maricopa County and walking away to some other gig and staying here to the gig that he already has, where he going to be continuing to make money. That is the tradeoff that he is effectively making. The impact is those people in this county, who otherwise need good service from the police and the sheriffs, and that is hindered, right. The other thing is people who have absolutely no say in this at all whatsoever anymore have lost any ability. Their tradeoff is to stay in Maricopa County, where you have a monitor that is imposing his will on the Sheriff's Department, causing mass morale problems, lack of retention, and also taxes that we do not even see any accountability for, or leave the county. That is effectively what this monitor is doing. That is the tradeoff. That is why it was so important to me. I wanted to hear Mr. Garcia's assessment of whether trust has been rebuilt in the community. Do you see a synergy and a cooperation, maybe even a collaboration with the Sheriff's Department and the Latino community, which was where the issue arose. That is why I say if we start looking at that, the trust, we look at the law, and then we look at the tradeoffs and incentives, it all points to one thing, that the monitor's oversight ends. Before I recognize Mr. Nehls for a second round of questioning, I have to make one more statement, because as I was listening to you today--and by the way, I have set aside my questions because these guys are asking all the questions, but that is OK. The one thing I get here is that this is a type of Federal overreach. When I say ``type'' I am talking about an example or--it is not kind, I mean this is a type. This is something you can look at and say this happens in multiple other areas. What that is, where the Federal Government comes into a State or local government, ostensibly with a good intention and they never leave. They never leave. Which is why federalism and the Tenth Amendment have taken a bad beating in the last 125 years, in my opinion. I look at this and I say it is time for the Rule 60(b) motion to be granted, and quite frankly, it is time for this monitor to go on. I am going to end there before I go into Merrick Garland's interpretation of what a monitor should do. Right now, I am going to yield and recognize the gentleman from Texas. Mr. Nehls. Thank you again, Mr. Chair. This specific case, this was not the consent decree. This was judicial, yes. You notice a lot, too, with this new administration, the Civil Rights Division under the Trump Administration, he is closing all the investigations, whether it was right here in Phoenix; Trenton, New Jersey; Memphis; Oklahoma City; Louisiana State Police; Mount Vernon, New York; Louisville; and Minneapolis. Think about that in Minneapolis, and what we saw up there. I do not know, it is a sad State of affairs, anybody that is in law enforcement, how has law enforcement become so partisan? How? When somebody would call the local Sheriff's Office and say they need help, you are not going to call and say, ``You Democrat or Republican,'' ``You prolifer,'' or ``You prochoice.'' When we book somebody into a county jail, I do not think we ask that question either--those lives over here, conservatives over here, prolife, and prochoice. How did it get to the point where we are at? I have some opinions as to why we got where we are today. If you look at ICE and border enforcement, we have a very, very divided country. Law enforcement is struggling today because, quite honestly, I do not know if I would want one of my daughters or a son to even join the ranks anymore. It is just the ridicule. The number of officers that have lost their lives since I have been in office, I have got a picture of them on the wall outside my office. That thing has got to be 30 yards long and 10 feet high. We are losing hundreds and hundreds of law enforcement over the years because it is so dangerous today because of the partisanship. Where did it all begin? You have got to go back and say why are we at where we are? You could go back to George Floyd. That had something to do with it. You could even go back a little further and go back to Trayvon Martin. It just seems like we have leaders that--you go to Tim Walz and others that want to create the division, they want to create the chaos, thinking that their side, their politics is going to win over. I do not know. I am a Second Amendment guy, and I know, Andy, you are too, and this and that, but I believe the guy has a right to carry a gun at a demonstration or whatever. You are going too far when you get into a physical altercation with law enforcement. What the hell are you doing? Carry a gun at the demonstration, but if you start getting into physical altercations with law enforcement, I am questioning--well, you ain't going to be able to talk about it, obviously. I just think that we have to do everything we possibly can to get back to where law enforcement is considered. Remember the old picture where you see the law enforcement officer and he holds out his hand to a young child? We need to get back to that. Because when we have that distrust it just creates chaos. When you have distrust in law enforcement today, you can see where we are at. It is quite clear. Every other day, in every other city, you see what is taking place, and we are better than that. You mentioned the 26 percent vacancy rate. I do not know how many of those are in patrol, detective, or CID. I do not know how many they have. I cannot imagine. It has got to be affecting clearance rates, response times. As the Sheriff said, Hey, by the way, Ms. Lesko, I need more people. My response times on 911, a priority one call is now 2\1/2\ minutes versus 1\1/2\ minutes, because who wants to work here? Quite honestly, I cannot blame him, if Deputy Joe Snuffy would say, I may want to go to the county next to me, that I do not have all those oversight. I do not have to worry about whether I say something or if it is even perceived as something silly, that all of a sudden now I am going to have an Internal Affairs question. You know what I mean? How has that affected morale, response times, if you know any of that, clearance rates on crime? Ms. Lesko. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. In my conversations with the Maricopa County Sheriff's Department, it has affected it a lot, because every aspect, every employee, whether they are even assigned to traffic stops or not, they have to be trained in this. There are whole Federal bureaucracy and monitorship, and they are spending--the County estimates this is between the cost of trying to achieve what the monitor wants us to do, and the monitor costs themselves, and the attorney costs, as Mr. Chair said, ``the County believes it is $350 million so far. That is a lot of money that could be used for hiring more Sheriff Officers.'' Even like somebody that is in administration, that is not out on the street, they have to be trained in this. Every officer--I cannot remember how many things, at every traffic stop, they have to ask and report. It is just so burdensome that you are correct. If they could go to another agency, a city or DPS, Department of Public Safety, which is the State Patrol here, why wouldn't they do it if it is so burdensome? We have to help the Sheriff's Office, because I totally believe that the government's No. 1 responsibility is protecting the public. It is hard to do that when the Sheriff's Office has their hands tied behind their back. Mr. Nehls. Did we have cameras back then, back in all the studies. There were body cameras required by-- Mr. Garcia. It is a new system we have, the cameras. Mr. Nehls. The cameras would catch it. Even when you make a traffic stop you have to put on there why you stopped them, and are they Hispanic, Black, or White. You have to list all that. Mr. Garcia. Something important with that is 35 percent of the people are Latino. Mr. Nehls. OK. You are going to make quite a few traffic stops on Latino if it is a majority. I just have got to go back to this, and I do not know why. Was Sheriff Arpaio using his office--maybe he was and maybe he was not. I don't know. Help me out--was he trying to use his office to enforce Federal immigration law? Mr. Garcia. Yes. Mr. Nehls. OK. I tell you, I had the same issue. I am four hours North of the border in Houston, Texas. A lot of people would call me up and say, ``Look at them. They are over there. Go get them. They are over at Larry's Mexican.'' In the State of Texas, I had, a sheriff, right or wrong, I had no authority to put somebody in jail that came across the border illegally. I had no authority to do it. It was like it was the Federal Government's job to do that, and I understood that. Now, as the county sheriff, what I had the ability to do is if somebody was doing something wrong and he was documented, and I put him in the county jail, well then obviously every person I ever arrested, we ever arrested, I do not care what color you were, what was your name, everybody's name would be entered and we would send it to the ICE in Houston. Within two hours they would send me back a report that says, ``I want to put a detainer on this guy, this guy, this guy, this guy.'' I was not enforcing immigration laws, Federal immigration. I was enforcing Texas law if the individual committed a State violation law. A sheriff in the State of Texas does not have the authority. There is nothing in the penal code in the State of Texas that says I can arrest somebody for being here illegally, even though they are illegal, because it just seemed the Federal Government's job. Now, maybe the sheriff, I am sure he understood all this, but it just appears to me you are right. This overreach has to stop. It has been a decade. Just from my understanding, maybe back then a little oversight was warranted, and now you are building the community outreach and you have got new sheriffs coming in, and you just have to continue to build. This monitor, this gentleman, he is just feathering his nest. The guy is not dumb. You have got to give it to him. I just hope the judge is watching this, Mr. Chair, and he understands that we do not need this here anymore, and you cannot tie the hands of this county sheriff by all this overreach, when we have shown numbers that add up, that says we are in compliance. You have, in the budget, authority over this county sheriff. You have got to have the ability to be a good steward for the funds, be a good steward to the taxpayers and help the sheriff and end this overreach, this bureaucracy. I wish you all the best in that, and hopefully we can continue to be vocal. This hearing--great job with this, Mr. Chair-- hopefully this hearing will help this great State and this great county here in Arizona. Thank you. Mr. Biggs. The gentleman yields. I now recognize myself for some questions. Merrick Garland, former Attorney General under President Biden, in September 2021, issued a memo regarding monitorships of State and local government entities. I do not know, have any of you seen that before? OK, so this is good. You guys are a tabula rasa. I am going to just tell you what he says and then ask if you think that this has been done in this particular case. One of the things he said is you should cap the fees that a monitor receives. Has that been the case, Mr. Garcia? Are the monitor's fees capped in this case? Mr. Garcia. What is the question again? Mr. Biggs. Are the monitor's fees capped by the court in the Melendres case? Mr. Garcia. Yes. Yes, because I request to review the expense, and I do not have access to 100 percent for every detail. Mr. Biggs. Is it capped? Mr. Garcia. Yes. Mr. Biggs. Is it so they say you cannot spend more than, what, $5 million a year? Mr. Garcia. Oh, no. Mr. Biggs. There is no cap. Mr. Garcia. No. Mr. Biggs. They are just reporting to you, is that what you are saying? Do you know if it is capped, Mr. Riches? Mr. Riches. Not to my knowledge, Mr. Chair. Mr. Biggs. Supervisor? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I do not know for sure if it is capped, but how would we know? We are not even allowed-- Mr. Biggs. I will get to that. Ms. Lesko. It is my understanding there is no court order that caps it, that is my understanding. Mr. Biggs. OK. Ms. Lesko. If I am wrong, I will get back to you on it. We do not even know what he is spending it on. Mr. Biggs. Yes. In looking through I did not see a cap, but I could be wrong. He also says, Mr. Garland says, ``the second thing is monitoring is a public service. You should not be feathering your nest.'' He says, ``they should be structured to encourage the use of pro bono time or reduced rates.'' Now, you have seen some of their expenses. Does it look like they are reducing their rates or giving some stuff for free? Mr. Garcia. No. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Riches, have you seen any of this stuff? Mr. Riches. Mr. Chair, if they are providing pro bono time it would have to be an awful lot, because the expense invoices we have seen show considerable expenditures, $30 million over the course of the order. I would think that is unlikely. Mr. Biggs. Ms. Lesko? Ms. Lesko. No. As Mr. Riches said, it ``spent over $30 million.'' It is millions of dollars a year that we are spending just on this monitor. At one of the court hearings they made a point of flying in all these people that work for the monitors and giving their bios of how--anyway, it is a lot of expense. Thank you. Mr. Biggs. Nobody said, I am here and I am going to work at least half the time, or at least two percent of the time pro bono? They did not say that? Ms. Lesko. No, they did not. Mr. Biggs. It makes me wonder if they are lawyers, actually. That is the way lawyers--sorry. He also says the lead monitor participation should be restricted from participating in multiple monitorships. In other words, it is one and done. The lead monitor should serve on no more than one monitoring team at a time. Is this monitor working on multiple ones, Mr. Garcia. Mr. Garcia. I see only one person. I am working very closely with one person. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Warshaw himself, you have seen him twice, right? Mr. Garcia. Yes, twice. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Riches, is Mr. Warshaw involved in more than one monitorship? Mr. Riches. Yes. It is my understanding he is a monitor in other jurisdictions, as well. Mr. Biggs. At the same time? Mr. Riches. At the same time. Mr. Biggs. Ms. Lesko? Ms. Lesko. Mr. Chair, it is my understanding he does this in more than one location, more than in Arizona, and in fact, he has been doing it for 25 years in California in one case. Mr. Biggs. Yes. Here we go. This is another one that I think is interesting. Term limits for monitors should be included in a decree. I will go back this way. We are going to start this time with you, Ms. Lesko. To your knowledge, is there a term limit on Mr. Warshaw's service as monitor in the Melendres case? Ms. Lesko. Mr. Chair, I am not aware of any term limit for him. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Riches? Mr. Riches. Nor am I, Mr. Chair. This gets to one of the important points, that not only should the Federal oversight be temporary but anyone specific monitor should likely also be temporary, so there is not a circumstance where a monitor might be incen- tivized to continue the oversight. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Garcia, do you know if there is a term limit? Mr. Warshaw? Mr. Garcia. No. Not term limit. Mr. Biggs. OK. We will go with Ms. Lesko again. The next one is monitors' work should be publicly accessible. What do you think? Is that happening here? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair. No, as we have testified, the County cannot even see what he is spending his money on. It goes to the court, and only the court. I have been at one of the public community meetings and asked, the public asked actually, some of the people that are here today asked, ``What are you spending this money on?'' They did not answer. We have asked; they do not answer. It only goes to the court, so the public does not know. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Riches, have you seen anything different than that? Mr. Riches. No, Mr. Chair, that is one of our very primary concerns in this case. Under State law it is abundantly clear, taxpayers have a right to this information. The Federal FOIA would allow access to this information. The Judiciary is not subject to the FOIA. It is a central component of democratic government that citizens must know what their government is up to, and in this case, Maricopa County taxpayers simply have no idea because the monitor has not disclosed it and the orders in this case have prevented its disclosure. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Garcia, have you seen, are documents easily publicly available for this monitorship of Mr. Warshaw? Mr. Garcia. No. Mr. Biggs. OK. I will keep going. All right. The monitors-- and I have skipped some of it because we could just go on all day about this stuff, but let's get to this one. Community engagement begins with the selection of the monitoring team. Do any of you know if the community was consulted on the appointment of Mr. Warshaw? Ms. Lesko. I do not know. Mr. Biggs. Going on from there, the priority, according to Merrick Garland, was that a monitor should put a premium on stakeholder involvement. Mr. Garcia, you sit on the Community Oversight. Do you feel like this monitor, Mr. Warshaw, has put a premium on community input? Mr. Garcia. No. Mr. Biggs. Let's get to these here, because this one is actually very interesting. You should require a hearing to assess termination after no more than five years. [Laughter.] Mr. Biggs. These should not last longer than five years because, according to Mr. Garland, you want to incentivize both the parties that are being monitored and the monitor to get this thing done, make the changes and corrections, and move on. Well, I do not know, Ms. Lesko. Are you aware of any termination hearing after five years? Ms. Lesko. Thank you, Mr. Chair. No. In fact, it has been going on for a lot longer than that, and there is no end in sight. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Riches? Mr. Riches. No, Mr. Chair, I am not aware of that. Again, this gets to the temporary and reviewable components of this. This oversight should be temporary, and the decisions should be reviewable, both of the monitor and the court. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Garcia, are you aware of any additional hearing that has taken place from the time of the original order to assess termination of the monitorship? Mr. Garcia. No. It is time to finish this, you know. It is too much money. It is too much time. We need to put the money in the right place. Mr. Biggs. Well, thank you. In the alternative, he says you could use a partial termination. You could come in and say, well, they have complied here, but we are not finding compliance here. Ms. Lesko, do you know if there was a hearing which proposed a partial termination of some of the monitor's review targets? Ms. Lesko. I am not aware. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Riches? Mr. Riches. No, Mr. Chair. I am not aware. I know in Rule 60 motion there was a request that some of the oversight components be stopped. Mr. Biggs. Mr. Garcia, are you aware of any? Mr. Garcia. No. Mr. Biggs. OK. Well, thank you for answering questions. It is painfully obvious that Merrick Garland's suggestions and guidance on monitorships, of consent decrees, and in this case a judgment, a judicial judgment, have gone largely unheeded, and that is a problem. For the record I am going to put in some UCs here. First, the Amendment 2 to Lease Agreement Between Luhr's Investors and Maricopa County. This is on behalf of Mr. Warshaw, that amendment to that contract. Second, one out of paying for Warshaw and Associates. This is for professional services, $212,551 payment, net 15, by the way, on August 1, 2023. Third, a letter from the PORAC on behalf of the Peace Officers Research Association of California, encouraging that the monitorship come to a close. Fourth, a letter from the National Association of Police Organizations, encouraging that the monitorship come to an end. Fifth, a piece entitled, ``DOJ Supports Call to End Maricopa County Sheriff's Office Oversight Case.'' Sixth, an article ``Supervisors Call for $353 Million Oversight of Sheriff's Office.'' Seventh, the ``County Attorney Says Monitor has Financial Incentive to Continue MCSO Oversight.'' That goes back to my thing about incentives. Eighth, an article, ``A Monitor Keeps Moving Goalposts for MCSO Officers, Putting Our Safety at Risk.'' Ninth, an article, ``Citizens Plea for Relief, Balance, and Local Accountability in Maricopa County.'' Tenth, a letter to Hon. Pam Bondi, Attorney General of the United States, written by me. Admitted without objection. With that I am prepared to yield and recognize the gentleman from South Carolina for his second round of questions. Mr. Fry. Thank you for that, Mr. Chair, and I had to step out for a minute, but I think you covered--did you cover the Merrick Garland pretty thoroughly? Mr. Biggs. I did, yes. Mr. Fry. That was going to be my second round. Mr. Biggs. Yes. That was covered. Mr. Fry. I will yield back here in a minute, but I think in every which way, when I look at the merits of this case and what the County has filed with their 60(b) relief, supported by any number of groups, including the DOJ, the elements are satisfied, meaning that the County and the Sheriff's Office have complied substantially for quite some time, with what was intended in the court order in 2014. They have complied not just on the surface but deep structural changes within the Department. They have been validated by the monitor's own reporting. They have been validated by other reports that exist out there, that are independent of the monitor and the County. When I look at the federalism concerns, those speak to themselves. The Federal Government is not here to micromanage every aspect of State and local government. That is not their function. The Constitution limits the authority given to the Federal Government, and the Tenth Amendment is very clear-- those that are not enumerated in this Constitution are left to the States. While Federal oversight is maybe wanted, a judge orders that, these are routine sometimes in our country, in this you have a 14-year-old, well, over 10-year-old case where you had substantial compliance by the County for a long time. They have spent over $300 million on compliance costs. Shouldn't that money be better left appropriated by the people who are elected by the citizens of this area to be spent on, I don't know, further policing, more police, other initiatives within the county? Doesn't that make more sense than this continuing check-the-box. Look, if you go back to 2015, and some of the data that I highlighted, 50 percent compliance at that point, OK, that is a substantial start, but we are not quite there yet. The County is not quite there yet. Now you have 100 percent, high marks on everybody that seems to be reviewing this. Why must the County continue to endure this, both from an operational standpoint on what they are doing, and also a federalism component, which is critical to who we are in our republic. The Chair raised up some comments on maybe some oversight of monitors, that is not the case. Merrick Garland, who I do not agree with much--I did not think he was that effective at all as an Attorney General--he may have gotten this right, where there is some disclosure that is required by the monitor. There is some public input that is required on the selection of the monitor. There are term limits to the monitor. This is not an unfettered cash grab of continuing to say, ``Yep, they are doing their work. Here is a bill for $250,000,'' or whatever the case is. The monitor is not a taxpayer of this county. The monitor is not a voter of this country. The monitor has done his job, and it is time to end. I hope that the 60(b) motion is successful. I think it is beyond and past time to end, because again, the Federal Government does not need to micromanage every aspect of this. The Sheriff's Office should be commended for their hard work. I know it probably was not easy to have this oversight constantly on you. In many cases, in things that I have read, it sounds like they have done a dang good job at it. It is time for this to end, and I hope that it does. I appreciate you being here and your involvement in the community. I think that is huge. That nexus between the community and police is massive. It is underrated at times, but it works very successfully. You being a part of that, part of that discussion is critically important. With that, Mr. Chair, I yield back. Mr. Biggs. The gentleman yields. The Chair recognizes Mr. Nehls for two minutes. Mr. Nehls. Thank you, sir. I agree with what you just stated, Mr. Fry. Mr. Garcia, you are a key here, in my humble opinion, in its success. The Sheriff's Office--and it is an office. I always say department. It is an office. He is dually elected, so it is the Sheriff's Office. The Sheriff's Office is complying with the judicial orders. It has been doing that for years, the documentation that is there. You stated, and I am paraphrasing, the citizens are satisfied. Great, right? Everybody seems to be pretty pleased. I believe your working group--and if it is just coming from elected officials, I do not think that is going to work. If it is coming from the working group, if it is coming from the people that reside in this county, that are pleased now to see the significant improvement, change, at the Sheriff's Office, that should hold significant--significant--weight in the elimination of this Federal program. I just think having you more involved with this, letters to the judge, and everything else, that is the key to your success. I wish you all the best of luck. Thank you, sir. I yield back. Mr. Biggs. The gentleman yields. That concludes today's hearing. We thank our witnesses for appearing before the Subcommittee today. I must point out that we invited our colleagues on the Democrat side of the aisle to appear and to invite witnesses today, and they opted to not participate in this Subcommittee hearing today. Without objection, all Members will have five legislative days to submit additional written questions for the witnesses or additional materials for the record. Without objection, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 10:32 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] All materials submitted for the record by Members of the Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance can be found at: https://docs.house.gov/Committee/Calendar/ ByEvent.aspx?EventID=118963. [all]