Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- CLICK HERE: ACCESSIBLE FEDERAL TECHNOLOGY FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, OLDER AMERICANS, AND VETERANS [Senate Hearing 117-320] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 117-320 CLICK HERE: ACCESSIBLE FEDERAL TECHNOLOGY FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, OLDER AMERICANS, AND VETERANS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ JULY 28, 2022 __________ Serial No. 117-20 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 48-178 PDF*(Star Print) WASHINGTON : 2022 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania, Chairman KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York TIM SCOTT, South Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts RICHARD BURR, North Carolina JACKY ROSEN, Nevada MARCO RUBIO, Florida MARK KELLY, Arizona MIKE BRAUN, Indiana RAPHAEL WARNOCK, Georgia RICK SCOTT, Florida MIKE LEE, Utah ---------- Stacy Sanders, Majority Staff Director Neri Martinez, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman...... 1 Opening Statement of Senator Tim Scott, Ranking Member........... 3 PANEL OF WITNESSES Eve Hill, Attorney and Partner, Brown, Goldstein & Levy, LLP, Washington, D.C................................................ 5 Anil Lewis, Executive Director for Blindness Initiatives, National Federation of the Blind, Atlanta, Georgia............. 7 Jule Ann Lieberman, (accompanied by her husband John Lieberman) Assistive Technology Program Coordinator, TechOWL, Devon, Pennsylvania................................................... 9 Ronald Holmquest, Retired and U.S. Navy Veteran, Mount Pleasant, South Carolina................................................. 11 CLOSING STATEMENT Closing Statement of Senator Tim Scott, Ranking Member........... 27 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Eve Hill, Attorney and Partner, Brown, Goldstein & Levy, LLP, Washington, D.C................................................ 33 Anil Lewis, Executive Director for Blindness Initiatives, National Federation of the Blind, Atlanta, Georgia............. 44 Jule Ann Lieberman, Assistive Technology Program Coordinator, TechOWL, Devon, Pennsylvania................................... 49 Ronald Holmquest, Retired and U.S. Navy Veteran, Mount Pleasant, South Carolina................................................. 51 Questions for the Record Eve Hill, Attorney and Partner, Brown, Goldstein & Levy, LLP, Washington, D.C................................................ 55 Anil Lewis, Executive Director for Blindness Initiatives, National Federation of the Blind, Atlanta, Georgia............. 59 Jule Ann Lieberman, Assistive Technology Program Coordinator, TechOWL, Devon, Pennsylvania................................... 63 Ronald Holmquest, Retired and U.S. Navy Veteran, Mount Pleasant, South Carolina................................................. 66 Statements for the Record American Council of the Blind, written statement................. 71 American Foundation for the Blind, written statement............. 74 Blinded Veteran's Association, presented by James R. Vale, Esq., written statement.............................................. 82 Consortium for Constituents with Disabilities, written statement. 87 Deepa Goraya, Attorney, written statement........................ 93 Jonathan Lazar, Ph.D., LL.M., Professor, written statement....... 95 Ken Lebron, Director, Berks County Veterans' Affairs, written statement...................................................... 102 National Association of the Deaf, written statement.............. 106 National Disability Rights Network, written statement............ 108 Ronald Biglin, written statement................................. 112 CLICK HERE: ACCESSIBLE FEDERAL TECHNOLOGY FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, OLDER AMERICANS, AND VETERANS ---------- THURSDAY, JULY 28, 2022 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10 a.m., virtually via Webex, Room 562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Casey, Blumenthal, Rosen, Tim Scott, Braun, and Rick Scott. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The hearing will come to order. Thank you everyone for being here this morning. I will start with my opening, then I will turn to Ranking Member Scott. This week marks the 32nd anniversary of the signing of the Americans with Disabilities Act. As we commemorate that anniversary, our Committee will examine an important disability issue, how to improve the accessibility of Federal information technology for people with disabilities. The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated a long-term shift in delivering government services using virtual front doors instead of physical front doors. Unfortunately, over the years, the U.S. Government has not prioritized making these virtual front doors accessible to people with disabilities, especially most recently. Digital access significantly affects older Americans and veterans, who experience disabilities at higher rates than the general population and more frequently use these government services. Federal law requires that the Executive branch agencies make their technology accessible to people with disabilities. However, bipartisan oversight that I have led shows the U.S. Government is falling short on digital accessibility. I want to thank Ranking Member Scott and our Aging Committee colleague Senator Burr for joining me in these oversight efforts. In 2018, my office heard from veterans who have a disability or more than one disability, who reported problems accessing the Department of Veterans Affairs' websites and kiosks. In response, I worked alongside Senator Jerry Moran to pass the bipartisan VA Website Accountability Act in 2020. That law requires the VA to report on the accessibility of its websites and intake kiosks. The resulting report had stark findings. Fewer than 10 percent--let me say that again--fewer than 10 percent of its websites were fully accessible as of last Fall and the Department's plans to fix them were, in a word, inadequate. My understanding is that the VA will soon be responding to the letter I sent with Senator Scott and other colleagues regarding these longstanding accessibility shortfalls. I will be reviewing those plans and look forward to working with the Department to address these longstanding issues. While serious, the VA's accessibility shortfalls are not unique, unfortunately. A long list of Federal agencies, and even the White House, have settled lawsuits in recent years alleging their websites and technology are not accessible. That is why I am concerned that the Department of Justice has not evaluated Federal technology access for a decade. Federal law requires, as I said, these evaluations every two years. The Biden Administration has rightfully prioritized improving digital access, but years of inattention to accessibility means there still is a lot of work to do. Someone who just happens to live in the same county I live in--his name is Ron Biglin and I am holding up a letter, some of which I have highlighted--Ron Biglin, he lives in Clarks Summit, Pennsylvania, not too far from Scranton. He is one of the people who has suffered from this inattention. He submitted a statement for the record, and I will make that statement part of the record. Ron Biglin is an Air Force veteran, who is blind. He can fish, kayak, and even do online banking, but the VA's My HealtheVet site does not work with his screen reader, making him unable to use it. Ron wrote a pertinent part in his statement: ``When you are visually impaired you want to be as independent as possible and having problems getting on VA websites takes away this independency. If the VA could lead the way to make access easier, this would be a great plus and then also other government agencies could do the same.'' I could not have said it any better than Ron Biglin said it. We would not ask someone using a wheelchair to walk up the courthouse steps, but in a real sense we are doing something similar when we ask people with disabilities to use Federal websites. We are saying that all the time in government services, and thankfully it has worked for a lot of Americans, but when we are telling people to use these Federal websites, mobile apps, and other technologies that are inaccessible, that makes no sense. We have got to do better than that as a Federal Government and as a society. I thank our witnesses for being here today and I look forward to hearing how to address these issues for people with disabilities, for seniors, and for veterans across the country like Ron Biglin and so many others. I will now turn to Ranking Member Scott. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR TIM SCOTT, RANKING MEMBER Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses for being here today. Without any question we look forward to hearing your testimony. For many of our Nation's seniors and people with disabilities, accessing Federal resources and services has been too big of a problem that must be solved. This is especially true for our veterans, and that is why Senator Casey and I are working to solve problems with a variety of solutions. I thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your participation in so many of the efforts to include working with the VA and to improve the website accessibility for disabled veterans and disabled VA employees. We also requested the DOJ comply with reporting requirements regarding improved website accessibility for Americans with disabilities. In May, I hosted an event to honor our active duty, reserve, and national guard and military personnel, defense contractors, and those who fought in Afghanistan and Iraq. We had nearly 700 attendees at home in Charleston, South Carolina. It was a wonderful event. It was a wonderful way for us to acknowledge the incredible sacrifice, and those who serve our country should be honored on a consistent basis. I would like to acknowledge our South Carolina servicemembers, veterans, and those currently stationed at military bases throughout this Nation. One out of four of our veterans have a disability that is consistent with their military service, and the median age of our veterans is around the age of 65. Tony Green is a veteran from Charleston, South Carolina, who served in the Navy for eight years. Following his military career, he had problems assimilating into civilian life and started suffering severe bouts of depression. He went from living in the comfort of his own home to living in a homeless shelter. Determined to change his life, he reached out to the VA and received treatment for his bipolar disorder. The VA and its telehealth services, which he accesses from his phone and laptop to receive care and manage his medication, have made all the difference in the world for Tony. He took advantage of the VA's comprehensive work-therapy program that led him to a job with the Palmetto Goodwill's Ability One program. He went from a food service worker, to cook, to supervisor. Tony is now an assistant project manager in downtown Charleston. He is also the first homeowner in his family. Telehealth became a godsend for millions of Americans like Tony, especially our seniors during COVID-19. Patients connected with their doctors even when they were isolated. From March 2020 through February 2021, more than 28 million Medicare beneficiaries used telehealth services. Donna Avant, named the 2021 Pharmacist of the Year, has been providing telehealth education free of charge, to the residents of Bamberg County, South Carolina, since 2020, in this rural community, where the nearest doctor is 12 miles away, the nearest emergency room is half an hour away, and, more that 100 seniors received free tablets for health screenings in chronic disease education, such as diabetes and hypertension. Seniors use Zoom and the phone. It improved access to health care, to doctors, and specialists that they otherwise might not be able to see. South Carolina is a leader in telehealth innovation. The Medical University of South Carolina has one of just two federally recognized telehealth centers of excellence in the Nation. In 2021, I introduced the Telehealth Modernization Act with Senator Schatz and a bipartisan group including Senators Collins and Warnock, which makes telehealth flexibilities permanent even after this pandemic is completely done. Without congressional action, however, these emergency provisions will end, and they will end soon, like in mid-October of this year. For the tens of millions of Medicare beneficiaries and others who rely on telehealth services, that would be tragic. Federal regulations have not kept up with the technological advancements that we have seen in this country. We must keep telehealth available and accessible for all Americans, including our seniors, our military heroes, and disabled individuals, so that they can take care of themselves and meet the needs they have. I look forward to learning from today's witnesses. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I yield back. The Chairman. Ranking Member Scott, thank you for your statement. I will now move to witness introductions. Our first witness is Ms. Eve Hill, a disability rights lawyer at Brown, Goldstein & Levy. Ms. Hill previously as Deputy Assistant Attorney General at the U.S. Justice Department in the Civil Rights Division, where she was responsible for oversight of the division's disability rights, education, and Title VI enforcement and the American Indian Working Group. She founded Inclusivity Strategic Consulting, a unit of the law firm designed to help businesses, organizations, government agencies, and industry groups to achieve real inclusion of people with disabilities in their workforces and their communities. Our second witness is Mr. Anil Lewis, Executive Director for Blindness Initiatives at the National Federation of the Blind. Mr. Lewis oversees the development and implementation of projects that improve the education, employment, and quality of life of all blind people. Our third witness is Ms. Jule Ann Lieberman, the Assistive Technology Specialist at TechOWL's Institute on Disabilities at Temple University in Philadelphia. Ms. Lieberman conducts assistive technology demonstration training for TechOWL and is responsible for public awareness activities at that organization. She is also blind herself and she will tell us how she has been personally affected by accessibility problems with Federal websites. Ms. Lieberman is accompanied by her husband, John Lieberman. She is also accompanied by her guide dog, Bob. That is a good name, and for our fourth and final witness I will turn to Ranking Member Scott. Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ronald G. Holmquest retired to South Carolina after a successful career in the Navy and later as a computer programmer and small business owner. Raised in New Jersey, he joined the U.S. Navy after graduating from high school. He served overseas in Japan and was honorably discharged in 1966, having been promoted to petty officer second class. He then pursued a career as a computer programmer and IT specialist in the New York City area. More importantly, he married Bonnie and they started a family. Ronald and Bonnie just celebrated their 56th wedding anniversary. What a blessing. Seeking a different pace, they moved to Vermont, where Ronald continued his work as an IT specialist and a small business owner. In 2015, he moved to Charleston--good decision--area to be closer to his family and granddaughter, who is now 10 years old. He is proud to have moved to South Carolina. Currently Mr. Holmquest receives care for chronic medical conditions at the Ralph H. Johnson VA Health System. He relies on telehealth and remote home monitoring devices to stay connected to his care team. Mr. Holmquest, we look forward to your hearing testimony today, and once again, happy 56th wedding anniversary. The Chairman. I join in those sentiments. Thank you, Ranking Member Scott. Before we move to witness statements I just want to make it clear for our audience that various Senator will be in and out of the hearing today. Thursday mornings are busy here. Lots of hearings and commitments that people have, so we will be acknowledging Senators as they arrive and as they have been present. I know we are joined already by Senator Rick Scott, and so we will now move to our first witness statement. Ms. Hill, you may begin. STATEMENT OF EVE HILL, ATTORNEY AND PARTNER, BROWN, GOLDSTEIN & LEVY, LLP, WASHINGTON, D.C. Ms. Hill. Good morning, Mr. Chairman. Good morning, Mr. Ranking Member and members of the Committee. As has already been said, my name is Eve Hill. I am a partner at Brown, Goldstein & Levy, and I have dedicated most of my career to implementing the rights of people with disabilities. Imagine trying to do your job without access to the internet, when everyone else--your boss, your coworkers, your competitors--has access. Picture yourself having to call a customer service line every time you need information from an office while your competitors and colleagues get the information they need with a click, or waiting for a coworker to find time to read a data base to you or to interpret a video for you, while your colleagues click, scroll, and go. Imagine traveling an hour or more to get to a medical office and waiting for in-person assistance while everyone sees a doctor through telehealth from their home. Or imagine a telehealth appointment in which your child has to interpret your intimate details for your doctor. We all laughed at the scene in the movie Coda, when the daughter had to interpret the sex lives of her parents for their doctor, but it is not funny, and it is not fiction. In 2022, 97 percent of the top million home pages in the world had accessibility barriers, an average of 51 barriers per page, and there is no reason for this. Digital accessibility is not technologically complex. It has been solved since Mark Zuckerberg was in high school. Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act has required Federal agencies to make their technology accessible for 24 years, but 30 percent of the most popular Federal Government webpages are inaccessible, and these are ones we use all the time, like weather.gov, energystar.gov, and census.gov, and websites are the simplest form of technology to make accessible. The accessibility of other forms of Federal technology is dismal. Clients of my firm right now are dealing with trainings required by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services that do not work with blind people's screen readers, and within intake kiosks at the Social Security Administration that are not accessible to blind people, and Federal employees with disabilities are dealing with inaccessible software programs that make it nearly impossible to do their jobs as well as timekeeping software, office machines, and online trainings that make their jobs more difficult. One might think this inaccessible technology is a relic of the past, but it is not. One blind employee of a large Federal agency for years worked on an inaccessible program that was central to her job, and recently the agency replaced the program, with a new one that is also inaccessible, and that agency failed to act on the employee's formal Section 508 complaint for eight years, so far. In another recent case, an agency sat on a Section 508 complaint for nearly five years, and had to be sued under the Administrative Procedure Act in order to act. The Social Security Administration, as a policy matter, is refusing to adopt accessible technology, insisting on wet ink signatures for documents to apply for SSDI benefits in spite of the wide availability, security, and accessibility of electronic signatures. So what to do? Section 508, in my opinion, needs six improvements. First, transparency. As you mentioned, the Justice Department is required to report on compliance every couple of years but has not done so since 2012. At the same time, GSA is collecting information on compliance but does not share that information with the Justice Department, with Congress, or with the public. Second, up-to-date standards. Technology develops quickly and accessibility guidelines keep pace, but Federal regulation does not. The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1 were released in 2018, and have not been incorporated into the Section 508 standards. Congress needs to ensure that the Access Board has the resources it needs to keep its standards up-to- date. Third, testing. Agencies clearly cannot rely on the aspirational, misleading, or incorrect statements of their technology vendors. They must have the ability to test technology accessibility themselves before they roll it out. There needs to be a significant remediation effort of barriers that already exist in technology, and fifth, oversight. Self-oversight has not worked. A Federal agency should be tasked with enforcing compliance with Section 508. Finally, accountability. The Federal agencies that are violating Section 508 are violating civil rights. They are harming taxpayers by buying technology that is not worth what we paid for it and by making it harder for public servants with disabilities to do their jobs, and vendors of inaccessible technology need to be held accountable to their Federal customers. Thank you very much for inviting me today and I appreciate your interest in this topic. The Chairman. Thank you, Ms. Hill, for your testimony. Mr. Lewis, you may begin your statement. STATEMENT OF ANIL LEWIS, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR BLINDNESS INITIATIVES, NATIONAL FEDERATION OF THE BLIND, ATLANTA, GEORGIA Mr. Lewis. Thank you. I want to thank the honorable members of the Special Committee on Aging for this opportunity to present on this extremely important topic. I see ICT, information communications technology as very important because it creates opportunities for us to access the fundamental civil rights that should be extended to every American citizen. As stated, my name is Anil Lewis. I am the Executive Director of Blindness Initiative for the National Federation of the Blind, the most transformative organization of blind people in this country, and we believe that access to public services and public information is a fundamental civil right. We recognize that ICT holds the hope for us to access these Federal programs in a more dynamic fashion. In my written testimony I go through the process of explaining how when I went blind in 1989, the old service systems that were in place made it frustrating, if not impossible, for me to access these services. I loved the term that you used and I am going to use it. Now that we have moved to the place of the virtual front door, those old services are even worse, because we put more resources into creating the virtual front door and taken them away from the old services, which were mediocre at best. Again, the accessible ICT--and I mean accessible, not just information communications technology itself; if it is not accessible it does not work--it holds hope for us to finally really be able to access the information and the services like every other American citizen. Through screen readers that convert speech, the digital information on computers into speech for the blind person to hear, refreshable Braille displays like the one I am using today, which converts that digital information into a tactile form that I can read with my fingers, we can provide access and information to blind individuals and those with low vision, individuals that are deafblind, and because it is speaking the technology, those individuals who are illiterate and could not read, because it is in a digital and accessible format, it can convert to foreign languages, again, creating opportunities for every American citizen to access the programs and services that we should be allowed to. Rather than going through a litany of personal examples, in my testimony you will see references of how inaccessibility has adversely impacted a representative sample of over thousands of people with disabilities, and it is preventing them from accessing services from the IRS, the Social Security Administration, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid, Department of Education, Small Business Administration, the Veterans Administration, and also even Homeland Security, and the reason that it is impacting is not just because we cannot access the information and services but also we cannot become viable Federal employees if the systems that are used to support the employment are not accessible or non-vision accessible to blind individuals. I want to spend most of my time in these remaining few minutes not to talk about the problems that are created but just get people to paradigm shift and recognize that accessibility is not difficult. That is the big thing. Accessible coding is just good coding, so we are not adding an additional burden on the existing systems to make them accessible if we focus on accessibility during the design and development process. The only big problem is there is a flawed accessibility implementation strategy within the Federal Government. In my written testimony I do an analogy around typing, where individuals within the Federal Government are using Smith Corona typewriters to create documents, taking that document and giving it to someone who can use a word processor to create a digital accessible document, so of course, that person who runs that Smith Corona typewriter is going to think that it is difficult, and of course it is going to be more expensive because you have to add another layer. The strategy should be to teach that one who is working on that Smith Corona typewriter how to use the word processor to create that accessible document from the start, and then it is seamless. No additional cost, no additional difficulty. It just works. I just want to stress, well, really appreciate the fact that this is a very good, collaborative effort, a bipartisan effort to really meet this need. We know that is law. Let's just implement it, and the Federal Government can be an exemplar. One, the Federal Government can continue to strive to be a model employer, making sure that blind people and other people with disabilities have the opportunity to obtain employment, lateral movement, and upward mobility within the Federal Government. Two, the Federal Government can implement a procurement process that demands that vendors to the Federal Government make sure that they provide accessible technology and other services so that they can encourage those vendors to make sure that they are developing accessible information from the beginning. This will also affect not only the vendors' production of accessible materials but also the training of individuals in the IT profession, because a person who learned to program and develop, as long as they learn about accessibility it is just part of their everyday. I would just really give one quick example of what has been really refreshing for me lately. We know that they have been offering free COVID tests to every American citizen. The National Federation of the Blind reached out to the Administration and recognized that these tests were not accessible to blind individuals. We, long story short, have been working with the National Institutes of Health, the Administration of Community Living, and we are working to make sure that the whole process, from soup to nuts, is accessible, the website is accessible, the instructions for the kits, we are working with those manufacturers to make sure they are accessible, the kits themselves, we are working them to be accessible, and the beautiful part about this is twofold. One, people are recognizing that accessibility is not expensive and it is not difficult, and two, we are enculturating the thought of accessibility into this whole infrastructure so that every other product or service that NIH works with, especially when we are talking about telemedicine and all these other home health care pieces of devices that they are working with, are accessible, born accessible from the start, so the same insulin pump that a sighted person uses, a blind person can use because it is accessible. The same home chemotherapy that a person without a disability uses is the same one that a blind person can use who has to have chemo. It is just a win-win. I am just optimistic that not only will this help us access the fundamental rights that we deserve, but the multimodal resulting impact of all this technology also helps every American citizen, not only just in literacy and language translation, but someone who can see also gets comfort in the validation of an audible confirmation when something happens. Again, thank you for this time to present. I am looking forward to working collaborative with you moving forward to make the Federal Government the exemplar and introduction of accessibility that creates a better quality of life for every American citizen. Thank you. The Chairman. Mr. Lewis, thank you for your statement. As I mentioned we will be acknowledging Senators. Senator Blumenthal has joined us, and now I will introduce our third witness, Ms. Lieberman. STATEMENT OF JULE ANN LIEBERMAN, ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY PROGRAM COORDINATOR, TECHOWL, DEVON, PENNSYLVANIA Ms. Lieberman. Thank you very much for this opportunity to speak before you today. I come to you not only as a person, as evident with the gray hair, of the aging community but also as a person who is blind. I was diagnosed in 1970 with a progressive vision loss, so I have gone through all the various stages of low vision to the point where now I would be considered profound vision loss or blind, and again, this does impact your daily life, especially when you do not have equal access to information. I work with TechOWL, which stands for Technology Our Whole Lives. It is an Assistive Technology Act program that is located within the Institute on Disabilities at Temple University. Our office works very hard to promote the independence of persons with disabilities and also promotes self-esteem and other personal choice opportunities. With that said, again, my experience teaching, I have been teaching for 24 years persons with vision loss, how to operate a computer independently, and that would be the use of assistive technology, as described previously, like screen readers. I have to comment. When Ms. Hill made the comment about the scene in Coda, it flashed on a memory of my son accompanying me to my mammogram appointment. We were given a form to fill out, and he had to ask questions. My son, I am very proud of him, and he is probably one of the kindest persons in the world. He said at the end, ``Mom, I know more about you than I ever wanted to know.'' Again, equal access and equal opportunities to provide information is critical for anybody with any disability, of any age, so even though I am within the older population now--I guess you could say that--I plan to continue working for some time, and having access to this information, not only for myself but also for the customers that I serve, I provide information assistance at my office and so very often I have to direct people to finding locations on the internet, over the phone, and it really bothers me when I know, in fact, I cannot get that information completely. Sometimes there are roadblocks. As an example, these past few years we have all been in a crisis situation, dealing with health inequities and also the health situation as a result of COVID. I am a person that thinks information is power, and I rely on reliable information. I would hope that the Federal Government and its resources, like at the CDC, would be able to provide me with accurate information. You do not want us to merely be relying-- as their best efforts are--with news media and/or social media to provide us with information that may or may not be accurate, so we look for these resources that we would hope that would ensure accurate information. I tried to find the prevalence of COVID activity, and this was in the spring of 2020, again, in my region, my State, and my county, and it was presented in a graph with no description, so it was very frustrating. I could get to one point, to where I could actually identify where I lived, and everything was represented in a graph which provided me no information at all, and so, you know, for me, I had to rely on other sources. Now I am very, very fortunate that I have a very supportive family, incredibly supportive family, so as a routine, my son would come up--we were both teleworking. Obviously, our offices were shut down, and as a routine he would come up at least once or twice a week, at lunchtime, sit down with his computer, and say, ``Okay, Mom, here are the updates.'' He would read them aloud to me, and it provided assurance to both of us and helped us make decisions on our activities. Is it safe for me to go to the grocery store? Is it safe for me to go to church? The things that are important to us, we need to know that information so that I know that, okay, I am safe if I wear my mask or what other guidelines are there, but having that initial information of how often this is happening in my neighborhood is incredibly important. You know, going down then to the spring of 2021, it was wonderful that we had the availability of vaccines. Unfortunately, when I tried to research how I could get a vaccine and make a vaccine appointment the sites that were directed by the CDC, including some providers, in order for you to access the information on availability of vaccines you had to click on a map. Okay, pointing and clicking is not an option for me. If it is a graphical representation and the only access you have is clicking with a mouse, it is no access, and then if I did get any information I would not be able to make an appointment. So out of frustration, I posted on our office, the Institute on Disabilities, listserv, what am I going to do about this? I need to find a vaccine, and fortunately a very respected manager--Jamie, thank you--sent me a phone number at the Area Office on Aging and Disability and she said, ``I believe there are starting to have appointments in your area.'' It took me five minutes to schedule an appointment. I did not have that information otherwise. There was no information of calling, you know, that agency anywhere, so that I could make that appointment myself. With that said, it was a very positive experience that I had good relationships with my coworkers and a very supportive family, but that is not the case for everyone. I do work with individuals that may be vulnerable, for example, that they are blind and they are relying on someone that perhaps is less trustworthy or abusive. You do not want them to be providing that information to someone when they are seeking support services from the government. I really do not think that is something that should be expected, but again, it does put people in a very risky situation. Again, I am fortunate that I do have a great support network, but that is not the case of many of my colleagues. I am active in the Pennsylvania Council of the Blind. Many of my colleagues do not have that option. They live alone, and they do not have those resources, so again, I am fortunate that I do, to a point, or it stops, and that is where I am hoping that these actions that you are taking today in this conversation, you can carry it forth, and like my colleagues here on right said to me, that it follows through. If you start with one, make some corrections at the VA, and then other websites to see how it works. Then they can become accessible--likewise in the commercial market. It is going to happen. Again, it is something that is not hard to do. There are guidelines. Most people, when they create a website that is not accessible, it is not because they are intentionally trying to lock me out of information. They just do not understand that is a need, and so, therefore, they do not know. In my written testimony I have some reference of where you could find about the website accessibility guidelines that are available, so that they can review, and also that there is information about how to get support services in order to do that. I do caution our Federal websites---- The Chairman. Ms. Lieberman, I just want to make sure we can move on to our next witness, if you can wrap up. Ms. Lieberman. Very quickly, yes. I just wanted to caution you not to take advantage of the commercial ones that say, ``We can fix your accessibility.'' Those overlays that they provide use artificial intelligence that, unfortunately, as much as this has evolved, it is not the answer. They cannot guess what my needs are. We have to be able to use our software independently. Thank you for your attention. The Chairman. Thanks, Ms. Lieberman. We will now conclude our witness statements with Mr. Holmquest. You may begin. STATEMENT OF RONALD HOLMQUEST, RETIRED AND U.S. NAVY VETERAN, MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA Mr. Holmquest. Good morning Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and distinguished panel. Thank you for inviting me to speak to the Senate Aging Committee about my experience with telehealth and the VA. You can probably tell I am not a native of South Carolina. I spent most of my life up north before moving here seven years ago. There are a lot of good reasons to live in South Carolina. I moved here to be close to my son, daughter-in-law, and granddaughter, who is now 10 years old. I have the pleasure of helping to take care of her a few days a week. When I moved to South Carolina in 2015, South Carolina veterans welcomed me. I was invited to the Port of Charleston for the commissioning ceremony for the USS Ralph Johnson, a guided missile cruiser named after a Marine from South Carolina who posthumously received the Medal of Honor for his heroic actions during the Vietnam War. Ralph Johnson used his body to shield two fellow Marines from a grenade, absorbing the blast and dying instantly. I am wearing this baseball cap today in his honor. South Carolina veterans recommended that I check into the VA. I have been with the Charleston VA since 2016. What I did not expect before I moved here was the excellent health care I would get at the Ralph H. Johnson VA Health Center, which is also named after that same heroic Marine. A couple of years ago, the VA invited me to sign up for telehealth, and I was skeptical. I have lots of severe medical problems, but I never signed up for VA health care before 2016, because I thought it was for veterans who were hurt and maimed in Vietnam and other wars. I figured they needed it more than I did. I served in the U.S. Navy during the Vietnam War, but most of my active service was in Japan, where I served as a communications technician. A highlight was attending a performance by Bob Hope. After being honorably discharged from the Navy, I eventually ended up in Montpelier, Vermont, where I worked in information technology. I also served as a volunteer EMT for about a decade in Fire and Rescue. In those days, all we had was bottled oxygen to keep people going until the ambulance arrived. We did not have all the modern technology they have these days. Sometimes the ambulance got lost on the back roads of rural Vermont. I guess it was tough to navigate when the cows moved. With telehealth, the VA can manage my complex chronic conditions very well. The VA assigned me a telehealth case manager--what a pleasure. Mine is an RN with a Bachelor of Science in Nursing who knows her stuff. Her name is Frances Santana. I thought that they were all vets, but not all of them are, and they always say, ``Thank you for your service.'' The Ralph Johnson VA Health Center is a teaching hospital, so some of the docs are from the Medical University of South Carolina, so you get the best, smartest medical staff to be found. A function of telehealth is that they watch after you. I send my vitals to my RN daily and if there is a problem you get a call immediately. She has direct contact with docs, fellow RNs, and other providers, and will get answers to your problems or education for you on medicine and procedures. She gets problems resolved for you. A big plus at the VA is that one computer system is looked at by all, including docs, RNs, and medical staff. When you have an appointment, your provider has all the necessary information. I have many decades of experience as a computer programmer from the early days of the industry. It is so important to have computers fully and properly used to benefit patients. Another point is that telehealth and technology have made care more personal, not less. I have five different cardiologists who treat me. When I have questions about a medication or why I have been taken off of a medication, I would pick up the phone and call Frances. She checks with the doctor and tells me they prescribed it because other medications have adverse reactions to my existing medications. I also use MyHealtheVet to make appointments. It is very effective. Telehealth is critically important to veterans' care. All veterans should have this opportunity. Telehealth and the VA need to stay for the benefit of all vets. It would be a shame to lose these valuable assets. Thank you for letting me share my story. The Chairman. Mr. Holmquest, thanks so much for your testimony and thank you for your service. We are grateful, and we are grateful you are with us today. I will now turn for our first set of questions to Senator Blumenthal, and we are joined by Senator Braun. Senator Blumenthal. Thank you very, very much, Senator Casey, and thanks to you and Ranking Member Scott for having this hearing, which is so important. Thanks to all of the experts who have come to talk to us, and a special thanks to you, Mr. Holmquest, for your service. I gather you are now in South Carolina but you lived for a long time in Vermont, and as a fellow New Englander I am especially grateful for your personal insight into how telehealth and the VA, this technology, is making your life better, and I would agree with you that South Carolina is a good place to live and it is also a nice place to visit. Thanks to Senator Scott for inviting you to be part of this proceeding and sharing your story, which is really powerful because I think you have shown us how telehealth, and I am quoting you, ``Telehealth and technology have made care more personal, not less.'' I think that is a really important point. I am on the Veterans Affairs Committee and the Armed Services Committee. Telehealth really has broadened and deepened the kind of care that people have available, especially for people who have disabilities and may not be able to travel to the VA hospital in West Haven or in Newington, but can get care at home if they have access to the technology. In Connecticut, 21 percent of all adults live with a disability, and 27 percent of all veterans--27 percent of all veterans in our state--have a disability, so this kind of technology is very, very important to them, and I wonder if you could tell us a little bit, Mr. Holmquest, talking about maybe some of your buddies in South Carolina, how access to this technology is very important to them, and maybe some of the difficulties they have encountered in accessing telehealth. Mr. Holmquest. I think the access to telehealth, for myself, if I had a question I would not know who to call as far as a doctor was going to be concerned, but I could call Frances and get her to be contacting the appropriate doctors, the appropriate services that you might need, get those services to give me a call to set up an appointment to followup on what is needed for my care. That was the biggest assistance for me was to have that synergy where she could talk to other people. I would not know who to call, to be honest with you, but she could, and she handles that for me very well. It is just fantastic. If I have a problem of any kind my phone call is to her first, and she can solve the problem for me. Senator Blumenthal. You mentioned you have access to five different cardiologists, some of the best in the State, maybe the Nation. Mr. Holmquest. Yes, absolutely. I came down with some heart problems, and because this is a teaching hospital there are VA doctors, MUSC doctors that all get together. They have their meeting in the morning, when they talk to you when you are in the hospital. There is a whole bunch of them that come in there and discuss what is going on, and when they leave there they have a plan of attack on what is going on. In fact, one day they said, ``Oh, by the way, we have discussed this and we think you need a defibrillator implanted in you.'' I said, ``Wait a minute. Am I that bad?'' Their decision was it is better to have a defibrillator available than have to wait for one, so I was very pleased with that. I went along with what they said. I trust every single doctor and nurse at the VA. They are just fantastic. The people that are with the VA are dedicated. The people that help them out, the nurses and so on, everybody is so dedicated and qualified to do their job here. It is unbelievable. Senator Blumenthal. Well, we are trying to push the VA to do even more of that kind of telehealth, and the present Secretary of the VA, Dennis McDonough, is very much on board with that approach. I am going to pass along your insights and your story to him, and thank you very much for joining us today. Two of my sons have served, one as a Navy SEAL, the other as a Marine Corps combat infantry officer in Afghanistan. They have made use of VA services from time to time, and I hope it is available to even more people in South Carolina, throughout the country. Thanks to Chairman Casey and to our Ranking Member, Senator Scott, for this hearing today. Thank you. Mr. Holmquest. Thank you, sir. Thank them for their service. Senator Blumenthal. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Blumenthal. I will turn next to Ranking Member Scott who will share his time with Senator Braun, I am told. Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman Casey, and thank you, Senator Blumenthal, for your kind comments about the importance of living in South Carolina, and for visiting South Carolina, if you have to represent other states, and thank you also for your time and your service and your dedication on the Veterans Committee as well as the Senate Armed Services Committee. Certainly working in a bipartisan coalition or fashion is really important for our country to see and have here our witnesses watch that. Hopefully we will improve just a little bit and people's perception of how Congress or the Senate actually works together. Mr. Holmquest, thank you for your comments. I am certainly proud to have you in South Carolina and thank you for your comments about Mr. Johnson as well, Ralph H. Johnson, who gave his life for the salvation--saving the lives of two other Marines was such a powerful story. I was at his commissioning of the USS Ralph Johnson in 2018. A powerful story that we should all read about, and I thank you, Senator Blumenthal, for focusing many of your questions on the importance of telehealth and how telehealth is actually bridging a gap and bringing expert care to where the person who needs it the most. With your questions I am going to go ahead and defer to Senator Braun, since you and I both were going to focus on the telehealth environment. Senator Braun, I will give you the balance of my time. Senator Braun. Thank you, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, as well. My question is going to be for Ms. Lieberman. Before I got here in Senate I ran a logistics and distribution company for 37 years, and I remember vividly, early on, how crude our systems were when we were starting to automate. I think it might have been a Radio Shack system or something when we first started. I do know that to be competitive in any business now, and especially in one like ours, when it is sprawling--it was so little for so long--technology, and being on the leading edge was the differentiator, in many cases, whether you were going to be successful in business or not. Two of my four kids, my sons, started about 15 years ago right when we were getting some size, and we had to say either we are going to embrace technology or we are going to be left in the dust. Thank goodness my older son, he got schooled in it, is great at it, and we decided to do it, and he and my younger son now run the company with one of my two daughters. I was listening to the testimony, and it is so reminiscent of what, in the early days, where we were not quite doing things the way they should be, mostly due to budgetary issues, and since I have been here in the Senate our technology is pretty good here for Senators, and I am sure over in the other side for Representatives, but I get complaints often when we are interfacing with the IRS, with the VA, and then hearing your testimony, especially in trying to access, being impaired in the way that you have to deal with it, you know, it is really kind of almost shameful. Because when you have got all these agencies spending this much money, yet you are having simple issues of connectivity, you look at the stats here which the Information Technology Innovation Foundation, 30 percent of the most popular Federal websites did not pass an automated accessibility test for their home page. I mean, that is almost laughable if it would not be so sad. So please elaborate on, in your particular case, what you have experienced, and then maybe give me a few ideas, give us a few ideas on what minimally needs to be done to see a difference. Ms. Lieberman. Sure. I think, first off, understanding how someone that is blind is accessing a website is the way things are logically arranged. Screen readers technically will read from left to right, up and down, and they will read everything, so when things are designed, especially those that are low vision, that it is cluttered and things are low contrast, for example, that can be very difficult for them to navigate and also for the screen reader to interpret the information. So what most screen readers will do--that is the software that I use to access--it will then allow us to be able to navigate quickly to various section of information, so if a website is designed with good structure, with headings and with well-labeled links--when I say well-labeled link, when you talk about those automated accessibility checkers, I am kind of burning it underneath because sometimes they will say everything is fine or your links are labeled, but it is not helpful when they are labeled ``click here'' or ``see more,'' because it is taken out of context in that list that the screen reader will do. It is very, again, disconcerting because I do not know what it is referring to, so having things that are well-structured, well-labeled, well-described, so graphics that are important. I will have to commend NASA, the most recent ones with the images from space is a delightful visit for somebody who is blind, because it does give us a great appreciation of what these images, and very well-crafted descriptions, so there are some organizations that are getting it, that understand it. Again, I mentioned the AI, the artificial intelligence that is being applied. That is not a good way of going about it. If you want to think about having accessibility you start with the basics of accessible design, so there are, as I mentioned, there are guidelines that you can refer to, and the best thing that I have found at my office they like to do is they pass it by, if Jule Ann can read it then it is okay, so a lot of times I will be asked by other organizations. In fact, I recently provide technical assistance for the Southeast Pennsylvania Transportation Authority, or SPTA, on the accessibility of their website, and I provided them examples with my screen reader aloud, so they can hear it, and what the experience was. So yes, there is information out there on how you can create it. Good structure from the beginning, good design saves a lot of time and remediation. You do not want to wait until a complaint. Senator Braun. That all makes sense, and I think for as much money as we spend and for all the good things we try to do through our various agencies, and as important as high-speed anything is, when you have got that and you are not formulating the right home pages, the right techniques, I would welcome any of you to make sure to give us--on the side of getting ahold of us. My Senate office, if you are having trouble doing it through the agencies, call my Senate office. Tell my staff, and we will get in touch with those various agencies to see why they are not maybe putting the resources, putting the effort to it, when that is so highly recommended. It is so great when it does work, where you do not have to deal with the frustration of the basics, so keep that in mind. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Braun. I will also turn back to Ms. Lieberman for a question and I will include it in this question. I will direct it also to Mr. Lewis. Both of you have had personal experience living with a disability, as your testimony indicates so clearly. You have also both had decades of experience working with people with disabilities. You have seen both ends of it, hearing from those who have had their own experiences and having your own. The hearing we are having today is, as I said earlier, particularly relevant because we celebrate this week the 32- year anniversary of the Americans With Disabilities Act, and the goal of the law is then-President Bush said, to quote, ``Let the shameful wall of exclusion come tumbling down.'' That wall of exclusion is still, unfortunately, so evident in some of these issues we are talking about today. Thirty-two years later, people with disabilities still face these walls of exclusion because of how technology has advanced and how we have not kept up with making that technology accessible, and of course, we are focused today on Federal agencies. I would ask both Ms. Lieberman and Mr. Lewis, can each of you share an example of people that you have worked with who have experienced information technology barriers and the impact that it has had on them. Ms. Lieberman. Do you want to go first? Mr. Lewis. No, I am a Southern gentleman. Ms. Lieberman. Oh, a Southern gentleman. Well, thank you, Southern gentleman. I am from Pennsylvania so we talk a little fast. Actually, Senator Casey, I did forget to mention that my formative years were spent in St. Clair, which is a small town in Schuylkill County. The Chairman. Schuylkill County, right. Ms. Lieberman. Oh yes. I am a coal-cracker too, my background, but I lived 40 years outside of Philadelphia in Chester County. To answer your question as far as the people that I have worked with, access is critical, as I have mentioned several times, and some of the barriers that they have, if a website is designed, oh, that you just need to tab, if you open up most websites, especially Federal websites, I believe when I attempted to look at the IRS one I think the opening page had over 200 links, so if you use your Tab key it is going to tab through each one of those links, so there has to be a way so that you can structure it so that you can get to things very quickly to get your answer, because quite frankly, time is not only money but time is also patience, so how much patience do you have? I have had several individuals that will tell me, ``Oh, I just gave up because it was too tedious. It was too hard to get to the information that I needed,'' and that seems to be one of, I would say, the carryover in most cases with all disabilities, and the older population. Our aging population, they want an answer now. They do not want to have to go through 15 steps in order to get to that answer. They want to have that information as easily found as possible, so that is pretty much the experience I have had with others, as well, on websites, not just Federal websites but in general. Mr. Lewis. I would have to offer that with respect to websites, we have a host of different examples of individuals that have tried to access information from the Federal Government website, and it is not even just the factor that you go to that site and it is inaccessible. It is to the point where there is a little bit of accessibility, so you can go through the process of actually providing essential information to get to the place where you need to get the information that you are requesting, and after you go through the tedious process of trying to maneuver through, and you are finally getting to that place where you are able to click this link that gives you access to this document that you have been searching for, for about an hour, you click it and the resulting document is inaccessible. I mean, it like the virtual front door is open and you walk in, and there are other doors that are still closed. The one I really like to highlight, because we are talking about, again, information communication technology--and let me say for the record, I am a believer in the potential. My undergraduate is in computer information systems, and I have been, for years, talking to individuals that this is not very difficult, because in the world of digital information it all boils down eventually to 1's and 0's, and if we focus on doing internet development and design process, we can make it accessible. It is not a problem. We just have to make sure that it is intentional and not done after we have done this wonderful creation of something, and then we say, oh, now we should make it accessible. No. That is why it is difficult. That is why it is expensive. Social Security Administration, trying to reach efficiencies in dealing with the old-school service system, where people have to go into the office to get access to services, and the kiosk system, which I have credibility. It is much better than going and just pulling a number. You can provide information that allows them to streamline the type of service that you specifically need. You just simply go to the kiosk, you enter your information including your Social Security number, your reason for the visit, boom, and you get associated not only just with a number but with the number that goes to that person that is going to help you with that specific issue. The only problem is as a blind person when I go to that kiosk it is inaccessible, so either now I have to coordinate my visit to the Social Security office with a friend or family member that I trust, or because it is not staffed by the Social Security Administration staff, I have to ask a total stranger to enter my Social Security number into this kiosk in order for me to get the same services. So yes, there are a host of examples we can give, but again, I would still like to continue to focus on the fact that the knowledge for accessibility is there, the tools already exist. It is really just about the efficient and ethical implementation of these strategies, and then that way all the money we are spending on DOJ complaints and the four-year wait to get access to services, all that time, energy, and resources can be refunneled into training the people who are developing the information delivery systems, and then it is a win-win for everybody. The Chairman. Thanks very much, and I will turn next to Ms. Hill. As you know, the Department of Justice is required to issue a report on the Executive branch's compliance with accessibility requirements in Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act, which you were highlighting and you know so much about. This report has not been completed in the past ten years. As I mentioned, Ranking Member Scott, Senator Burr, and I recently joined together to call on the Justice Department to begin issuing these reports again. We were joined by Senator Durbin, Senator Grassley, Senator Murray, Chair of the Health Education Labor Pensions Committee, and Senator Duckworth. In your view, why are these reports important, number one, and how will Pennsylvanians who rely on government services like Medicare, Social Security, and the VA Health System benefit from these reports being made available again? Ms. Hill. Thank you. Yes, transparency is really important in this field because without it agencies are tempted to not comply and wait to see if they get caught by someone who encounters the barrier. This transparency encourages agencies to take accessibility seriously at the beginning of a technology purchase, when it is easy and inexpensive to do, rather than wait and have to do fixes that are expensive and time-consuming, and Pennsylvanians and others will benefit not only from that cost savings but from the improved level of customer service that all that technology will provide if it is accessible from the beginning, not only for people with disabilities who will be able to count on being able to use it but as Mr. Lewis has said, accessibility is good design, so everyone with and without a disability will benefit from that additional good design, and the Federal Government's purchase power will improve those vendors' ability to have accessible products as a matter of course, and that ripples out into the rest of the world. The Chairman. Well that all makes sense and it is all the more reason why we have got to keep pushing every agency, but in this case to push the Department of Justice to begin to issue those reports again after such a long period of time of not issuing those reports. I will turn back to Ms. Lieberman. In your role as Coordinator of the Assistive Technology Program in Pennsylvania you come in contact with many people with many different types of disabilities. We know that there are over 61 million Americans in our country with a disability, and almost two- million of those are in the State of Pennsylvania. As I mentioned earlier, the pandemic has accelerated the Federal Government's adoption of electronic information and technology communications to share information and provide services online. That is a good thing that those services are available online. Critical benefits from the Federal Government, such as Medicare enrollment, now primarily take place online. Can you tell the Committee why it is essential to ensure online services, especially Federal online services, are accessible? Ms. Lieberman. I think, well, besides the fact that it is my right, as a citizen of the United States, to expect that I can obtain services when it is need, something like Medicare, for example, it is vital that I would have that access to that information and be able to complete it independently. Things that would be of note would be when we are requested to complete a form online that all the form fields are labeled. They may show up on the screen but the screen reader does not have that information so it is not telling me, so I just get blank edit fields. So for me, to quickly, efficiently apply without having to ask somebody else to help me, that is the type of barriers that I see as well, with individuals that contact our office, that they seem to have issues. Is it because the technology is too complex, so they think, or is it the website is not accessible? Sometimes I have to do a little detective work to try it out myself, to see if, indeed, if it is, again, operator error or is it an error literally in the design of the website. I have encountered that a few times over the years--I have been there nine years--and I would say I can think of 25 cases where people have asked me to get that assistance for them in order for them to access information on the internet, whether it be Medicare or any other location on the internet. I do not know if I answered your question. Hopefully I did. The Chairman. You did, and thank you for that testimony. I appreciate it. We will now turn to Senator Rosen for her questions. Senator Rosen. Well, thank you so much, Chair Casey. I really appreciate you bringing forward this hearing, and thank you to everyone for being here, digitally, and we just appreciate what you have been doing and how we can help you. I want to talk a little bit about digital equity because the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law that Congress passed last year, it is the most significant Federal investment we have ever made to close the digital divide, something that is really important. I was proud to be one of the group of Senators that helped draft the key portions of the law, which included critically important digital equity provisions. The past three years have shown us how critical access to affordable, high-speed broadband is for everyone. The pandemic has shown us that, but speed and low cost are just part of ensuring digital equity for all individuals. Digital literacy, access to devices that meet users' needs, applications that enable and encourage self- sufficiency and participation--well, they are all components of ensuring digital equity and inclusion. So in drafting the equity provisions of the infrastructure law Congress did make it a priority to improve the digital equity as well, including for individuals with disabilities. So I would like to ask Mr. Lewis and then Ms. Lieberman, how are your organizations working with NTIA and the State broadband offices to ensure that these digital equity programs that we created here in Congress are promoting equity among our aging, disabled, and our veterans communities, and if you are not collaborating, this is something that we should consider doing. Do you need help? Can you just speak to that? Let's start with Ms. Lieberman. Ms. Lieberman. I am very fortunate where I work. TechOWL has participated very much so in health equity issues in two areas. Initially, we received some money from the Area Office on Aging funding, and with that we expanded our lending library so that we could introduce iPads to seniors so that they could have that same access to telehealth, to Zoom, as we had previously heard described, so they could have all that kind of access, and we put it into our lending library and made the decision for them to borrow it for rather extensive time periods so that they can explore whether that works for them first, because one of the things that we have noticed over the years, assistive technology can be abandoned. If people have not had an opportunity to try it first, then they have a tendency to purchase something or have something provided and it sits in the drawer. The last thing we wanted to do was to have this resource not used properly, so that is the intent that we had with addressing the need initially. We now subsequently have received funding so that we can expand the health equity to providing tablets for individuals that have no computer access in the home, and that, again, is not necessarily disability based but it could be anybody that does not have that access in the home, and that program is going like gangbusters with applications from across the State. I think the latest I heard was that we were up to like 1,200-- but do not quote me on the data--applications that we have provided for the Android tablets. Senator Rosen. We have just a minute left. Mr. Lewis, could you speak a little bit? Are you having cooperation with other offices to be sure that we are doing some of the same things that Ms. Lieberman spoke about? Mr. Lewis. Sure, I will be brief, and just State that I will be reaching out to you after the hearing to see how we can work with those entities, because as a nationwide organization of blind individuals we have been focusing mostly on working regarding broadband access with some of the commercial providers, Comcast, et cetera, some of the innovative programs, they have been doing to get in the rural areas, but I would like to explore other ways that we can work with some of the entities that you just mentioned. Senator Rosen. Well, thank you. I really appreciate that. We will get together. I know I only have 42 seconds left. The last thing I wanted to just ask, and I will take the response off the record, is driver-assisted technology for disabled veterans, because in Nevada we have 225,000 veterans, but we are getting all this new technology that you do not have to drive the car, and I think our veterans really deserve that, and so we are developing legislation to provide tax credit to all disabled veterans, no matter what level of disability, to cover the cost of driver-assisted technologies, whether they are just helping them to park or cruise control, the mirrors, any of the features that we have. It does not have to be a driverless vehicle. Mr. Holmquest, we are going to ask you this question. You can submit that answer to us off the record. I am not in the room so I am sure there is somebody after me. Otherwise, if Chair Casey says there is not we can have you answer. Otherwise, I will take it off the record. The Chairman. It is perfectly appropriate to answer it if he would want to. Senator Rosen. Oh thank you. Mr. Holmquest, how do driver- assisted technologies and all the related supports help level the playing field for disabled veterans and their quality of life after they return home? Mr. Holmquest. I am not clear on the driver-assisted cars. Senator Rosen. Well, maybe not where they drive you by themselves, but I know that there are new technologies that will help you park, right, assisted parking, or there are special mirrors so you can see the backup cameras, they can help you notice if someone is getting close and merging, so that is what I would like to ask you about. Can you hear me okay? [No response.] Senator Rosen. That is okay. We can take it off the record. Okay. The Chairman. Mr. Holmquest, yes, if you want to you can provide an answer in writing, or if you want to answer now. What is your preference? Mr. Holmquest. I would take it off record if we can because we just got interrupted by a loud-speaker here. The Chairman. Oh, okay. Mr. Holmquest. I did not hear what you were saying. I am sorry. Senator Rosen. Okay. Well, thank you. All right. Well, thank you. Thank you, Chair Casey. I appreciate it. The Chairman. Senator Rosen, thanks very much, and just for everyone to know, and Mr. Holmquest, we often have questions that get submitted for the record and they are answered in writing, that becomes part of the record after the hearing is over, so there is nothing unusual about that, and we appreciate his willingness to do that. I know we have to conclude a little bit early today, but before we do that I just wanted to pose maybe one more question to Ms. Hill about the law. Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act, as we cited before, establishes a floor from which experts at the Access Board set standards for accessible information technology for the Federal Government. Despite the good intentions of this law, Section 508, there are serious accessibility gaps across the Federal Government. Today's hearing has, if anything, reinforced that fact. Are there changes to Section 508 that would bring it in line with the time, so to speak, after a quarter century of this law being on the books? Ms. Hill. Thank you for that question. I think we have learned a great deal over the last 24 years about how implementation of accessibility in technology works, and one of the things that we have learned, both in the private sector and in the Federal Government, is that self-monitoring does not work, and so a Federal agency should be tasked with enforcing compliance with Section 508. The Federal Government experienced a similar issue with the Architectural Barriers Act back in the 1960's, and the Access Board was eventually given enforcement authority under that act, and the same thing could happen here. In addition, right now the vendors of inaccessible technology, who may be not giving their clients the full scope of the inaccessibility of their technologies, need to have methods of accountability, so Federal agencies need to be able to take action against those vendors and to rescind contracts and take other actions, and that is not available, or not clear right now in Section 508. The Chairman. Well that is helpful to have that because we, obviously, want to make changes to law where we can. Mr. Lewis said it pretty well in his opening, and I am quoting from his very simple, blunt statement. He said, ``Accessibility is not that difficult. It is the law. Let's just implement it.'' Sometimes the challenge is implementing the law appropriately, and we have got some shortfalls here, but in addition to implementation of existing law we want to consider ways that we can, in fact, change the law. I just have one more question that my staff has given me, and I want to make sure that we get this on the record. The Blind Veterans of America first brought Federal accessibility shortfalls to my attention way back in 2018. I did not realize it was that long ago. They remain concerned that the VA is still far behind. Ms. Hill, I am going to turn to you again because these are questions we should have answered on the record if we can. You have received the report required by the VA Website Accountability Act, the law that I passed with Senator Moran that I made reference to earlier. We know the VA is answering questions about how they will move the ball forward, but what should we be looking for as markers of success? If you could give us some free guidance on that. Ms. Hill. Certainly. If an entity is planning to achieve success in accessibility there are a few things they have to do. One is stop digging into inaccessibility. Stop bringing in new technologies that are not accessible, and that involves not taking your vendor's word for it but testing your own technology before you roll it out, and that involves both automated and user testing. The other things are a substantial remediation effort, and that involves planning, identifying what is wrong, which really requires an audit of what is wrong, and then prioritizing when you are going to fix things in order--what is most important to fix--scheduling deadlines, assigning staff with responsibility and authority to get the job done, and paying attention to whether the deadlines are met, and then consequences for when the deadlines are met, and in the things that I saw from the VA, none of those elements were present. The Chairman. Well that is very helpful for us as we discharge one of the obligations of the members of the Senate and committees in the Senate, and that is oversight, is one of the changes that you have suggested. I want to thank our witnesses for their testimony and for their willingness to bring their professional and personal experience to this hearing so that we can make changes and hold Federal agencies and hold our government accountable, and to make sure that there is accessibility for people with disabilities, in all kinds of settings but especially in settings like the Veterans Administration. Today's hearing shows that there is a long way to go before Federal technology is fully accessible for people with disabilities, for older Americans, and for veterans. It also shows that Congress needs to take a close look at Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act to see if changes are needed. In the meantime, there is a path to ensuring websites and other technologies are accessible with existing laws, as I mentioned earlier. I plan to work with the Biden Administration to make sure it continues prioritizing improved disability access to Federal technology and online services. A good first step would be for the Department of Justice to begin issuing, again, the biennial accessibility reports required by Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act. This will provide taxpayers with an important status update that is at least eight years past due. As we move forward, let's keep the disability community's long-held motto of ``Nothing about us, without us.'' We should keep that front of mind and make sure that they have a seat at the table when it comes to accessing important information that they need and that their families need. Ranking Member Scott has submitted a closing statement for the record, and with that I want to mention for the record as well that if Senators have additional questions for the witnesses or statements to be added, as I mentioned earlier, the hearing record will be kept open for seven days, until next Thursday, August 4th. Again I want to thank our witnesses for their testimony and for their work in preparing for this hearing and being with us today, and this concludes today's hearing. [Whereupon, at 11:25 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= CLOSING STATEMENTS ======================================================================= CLOSING STATEMENT OF SENATOR TIM SCOTT, RANKING MEMBER Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and the witnesses for your testimony. Today's hearing highlighted how we can continue to develop policies that enable our seniors, veterans, and those with disabilities to remain connected. I will continue to prioritize legislation that grants all Americans access to telehealth services. The Telehealth Modernization Act is an important step to ensure that the tens of millions of Medicare beneficiaries and others who have relied on telehealth during the COVID emergency can continue to receive these services. I also join Chairman Casey in looking forward to the responses from the VA and DOJ regarding our letters on improving website accessibility. Thanks to today's witnesses, Congress is better informed to take steps to improve access for our seniors, veterans and Americans with disabilities. Thank you all for your testimony today. ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Questions for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ======================================================================= Statements for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]