Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- REEVALUATING THE RATING SCHEDULE: EXAMINING VA'S EFFORT TO MODERNIZE DISABILITY BENEFITS [House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] REEVALUATING THE RATING SCHEDULE: EXAMINING VA'S EFFORT TO MODERNIZE DISABILITY BENEFITS ======================================================================= HEARING before the SUBCOMMITTEE ON DISABILITY ASSISTANCE AND MEMORIAL AFFAIRS of the COMMITTEE ON VETERANS' AFFAIRS U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 14, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-43 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Veterans' Affairs [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via http://govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 63-301 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON VETERANS' AFFAIRS MIKE BOST, Illinois, Chairman AUMUA AMATA COLEMAN RADEWAGEN, MARK TAKANO, California, Ranking American Samoa, Vice-Chairwoman Member JACK BERGMAN, Michigan JULIA BROWNLEY, California NANCY MACE, South Carolina CHRIS PAPPAS, New Hampshire MARIANNETTE MILLER-MEEKS, Iowa SHEILA CHERFILUS-MCCORMICK, GREGORY F. MURPHY, North Carolina Florida DERRICK VAN ORDEN, Wisconsin MORGAN MCGARVEY, Kentucky MORGAN LUTTRELL, Texas DELIA RAMIREZ, Illinois JUAN CISCOMANI, Arizona NIKKI BUDZINSKI, Illinois KEITH SELF, Texas TIMOTHY M. KENNEDY, New York JEN KIGGANS, Virginia MAXINE DEXTER, Oregon ABE HAMADEH, Arizona HERB CONAWAY, New Jersey KIMBERLYN KING-HINDS, Northern KELLY MORRISON, Minnesota Mariana Islands TOM BARRETT, Michigan Jon Clark, Staff Director Matt Reel, Democratic Staff Director SUBCOMMITTEE ON DISABILITY ASSISTANCE AND MEMORIAL AFFAIRS MORGAN LUTTRELL, Texas, Chairman AUMUA AMATA COLEMAN RADEWAGEN, MORGAN MCGARVEY, Kentucky, Ranking American Samoa Member JACK BERGMAN, Michigan CHRIS PAPPAS, New Hampshire NANCY MACE, South Carolina MAXINE DEXTER, Oregon KEITH SELF, Texas KELLY MORRISON, Minnesota Pursuant to clause 2(e)(4) of Rule XI of the Rules of the House, public hearing records of the Committee on Veterans' Affairs are also published in electronic form. The printed hearing record remains the official version. Because electronic submissions are used to prepare both printed and electronic versions of the hearing record, the process of converting between various electronic formats may introduce unintentional errors or omissions. Such occurrences are inherent in the current publication process and should diminish as the process is further refined. C O N T E N T S ---------- WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 14, 2026 Page OPENING STATEMENTS The Honorable Morgan Luttrell, Chairman.......................... 1 The Honorable Morgan McGarvey, Ranking Member.................... 3 WITNESSES Panel I Ms. Nina Tann, Executive Director, Compensation Service, Veterans Benefits Administration, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs... 4 Accompanied by: Dr. Ulia Sokol, Medical Officer, Compensation Service, Veterans Benefits Administration, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Panel II Ms. Elizabeth Curda, Director, Education, Workforce, and Income Security, U.S. Government Accountability Office................ 14 Mr. Philip Armour, Senior Economist, Director of Ph.D. Program, Professor of Policy Analysis, RAND............................. 16 Dr. Kyleanne Hunter, Chief Executive Officer, Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America................................ 18 APPENDIX Prepared Statements Of Witnesses Ms. Nina Tann Prepared Statement................................. 37 Ms. Elizabeth Curda Prepared Statement........................... 39 Mr. Philip Armour Prepared Statement............................. 53 Dr. Kyleanne Hunter Prepared Statement........................... 63 Statements For The Record Disabled American Veterans Prepared Statement.................... 71 Berry Law Prepared Statement..................................... 75 Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States Prepared Statement. 95 REEVALUATING THE RATING SCHEDULE: EXAMINING VA'S EFFORT TO MODERNIZE DISABILITY BENEFITS ---------- WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 14, 2026 Subcommittee on Disability Assistance & Memorial Affairs, Committee on Veterans' Affairs, U.S. House of Representatives, Washington, DC. The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:16 p.m., in room 360, Cannon House Office Building, Hon. Morgan Luttrell (chairman of the subcommittee) presiding. Present: Representatives Luttrell, Radewagen, Bergman, Self, McGarvey, Dexter, and Morrison. OPENING STATEMENT OF MORGAN LUTTRELL, CHAIRMAN Mr. Luttrell. Right. Good afternoon. Thank you for coming today. Everyone in the audience thank you for attending the committee hearing today and Disability Assistance and Memorial Affairs. The chair may declare recess at any time. The subcommittee hearing will come to order. Good afternoon. Again, thank you to our witnesses for being here today. This afternoon the subcommittee is examining the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Schedule for Rating Disabilities, otherwise known as the VASRD, and the Department efforts modernizing this system. The VASRD is the scale that determines how the veteran's service-connected conditions are evaluated, which then determine a veteran's eligibility for benefits, overall disability ratings, and, ultimately, the amount of tax-free money they receive each month. While the VASRD is incredibly is incredibly overly over complicated, it is important to step back and know that the schedule affects real lives. It allows VA to deliver compensation to veterans for their service-connected disabilities and ensure all veterans are evaluated at the same standard. Congress created the VASRD with a clear purpose to compensate veterans for the average impairment caused by their service-connected disabilities to their earnings capacity. The rating schedule was created in 1945. While parts of it have been updated over time, the overall framework remains unchanged. In 2007, VA Advisory Committee on Disability Compensation concluded that the rating schedule was outdated and recommended a full review of all 15 body systems. VA formally began the effort in 2009, with a plan to complete this work by 2016. Ten years later, VA has only completed a review of 11 body systems out of the total 15. According to the testimony provided in a Senate hearing last year, VA has now extended its timeline to 2026. Again, this is more than 10 years beyond the original goal. VA has made progress, but it is inconsistent thus far. In my personal opinion, the veterans of today deserve a system that evaluates their disabilities based on the medical evidence of today's medical practices. The respiratory, endocrine, musculoskeletal, and digestive systems have been updated in the past 10 years, but several important systems remain unfinished. The neurological, cardiovascular, and hematologic systems are still in various stages of review despite many of these conditions being common and often complex. Mental health remains the most concerning. VA proposed updates to the mental health rating criteria in 2022, but those changes have not been finalized. As a result, one of the most heavily relied upon portions of the rating schedule continues to operate under criteria that many believe no longer reflects modern clinical understanding or the full scope of functional impairment that veterans experience. Just as important, VA has not undertaken a comprehensive review of the economic component of the rating schedule. That component is supposed to connect medical findings to loss of earning capacity. Without updating this, the system risks drifting further away from its statutory purpose of benefiting veterans. This uneven modernization has real consequences on the veterans community and their families. When rating criteria are outdated, inconsistent examiners and raters are left actually just to fill in the gaps. That increases the likelihood that similar claims are handled differently. Recent U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) reporting has highlighted inconsistent outcomes for similar conditions, outdated medical and occupational criteria, and quality review processes that are not strong enough to catch errors before they affect veterans. VA's current quality assurance approach relies on limited samplings that often fail to identify broader area of twins-- trends, excuse me, and too often problems are discovered only after decisions have already been issued, leading to rework appeals and additional delays. Systems matter, standards matter, and today oversight obviously matters. I will close with this. For veterans, the disability rating process is not an abstract policy exercise. It is often the moment when they sit across from the system and ask for help, sometimes years after they left the military. When the process feels outdated, inconsistent or confusing, veterans do not lose confidence in a form or regulation. They lose confidence when they ask for help. Where will it be? Modernizing the rating schedule is not just about updating language or revising criteria. It is about trust. It is about ensuring that when a veteran raises their right hand and serves, a system they return to is worthy of that commitment. With that, I will yield to the ranking member. OPENING STATEMENT OF MORGAN MCGARVEY, RANKING MEMBER Mr. McGarvey. Thank you, Chairman Luttrell, and good afternoon, everyone. Appreciate you all being here today. Mr. Chairman, I am grateful for you holding this hearing. The VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities, or VASRD, is a massive program. It is big in size, it is big in impact, and it is absolutely central to how we support our veterans. Everything we do on this committee starts with one simple idea, that when a service member raises her right hand and serves this country, we owe her a system that works. If she is injured or becomes ill because of her service, she has earned care, benefits, and services, full stop. The process to get those benefits should not be so confusing or slow that she feels lost before the process even begins. This hearing should not be about cutting those services. It should be about cutting red tape. Veterans should not need a law degree or a medical degree and a decade of patience just to get what they have earned by serving our country. We also should not be afraid of change. I, for one, think the VA's Schedule for Rating Disabilities is outdated. Medicine has changed. Diagnostics have changed. The nature of military service itself has changed. The injuries and illnesses our servicemembers face today look very different to what they did 80 years ago. Yes, the schedule needs to be updated, but the goal has to be clear, and that is to modernize the system without harming the veterans. That is the line we cannot cross. That is the mission that is central to this committee. I have a few questions that I think we can begin to answer today. If we are trying to figure out whether the current schedule actually works, we have got a real challenge. There is almost no up-to-date, publicly available research on how VA's compensation system is performing. How do we fill that gap? What additional data do we need? How do we get it? How do we use it? If today's hearing is about understanding the methodology VA is using to update this disability rating schedule, then I welcome that. Across multiple administrations, VA's work on VASRD has been a black box. Veterans deserve transparency. Congress deserves transparency so that we can help our veterans. Mr. Chairman, I also want to address something that we have been hearing in the media a little bit, that there is a growing narrative that disability compensation is somehow too generous or that it is arbitrary and there is encouragement for veterans to game the system. I want full transparency. I want to know everything that is going on. I resent that characterization of our veterans. Our veterans, it is not who they are, and it is not what this program is. These benefits are not handouts. They are not freebies. They are a recognition of service and sacrifice. For many veterans, they are the only support they have when service- connected conditions make work difficult or impossible. Mr. Chairman, you know better than I do about the risks that military service carries and that most civilians will never fully understand. Those risks do not end when someone takes off their uniform. They can follow a veteran for the rest of their life, and they cannot be reduced to a simple earnings loss formula. We also have to remember that health relates to the whole person. A diagnosis that sounds minor to you or to me might be a sign of something much bigger. A veteran who has cystic acne that is linked to Agent Orange exposure is not just dealing with acne. They are living with the consequence of toxic exposure, and that context matters. We also have to remember what these programs are. No matter how big they are or how big they get, the heart of these programs are our veterans, human beings. Our brothers, sisters, moms, dads, sons, and daughters who put on a uniform willing to serve us, people who deserve the dignity and care they have earned in exchange for that service. Which brings me to the last point I will raise, Mr. Chairman. My concern today that we only have one veteran service organization testifying. Veterans are not monoliths. They go into different branches of the service with different experiences at different times. Their voices should be central to this conversation. I hope that we can have more conversations with the Veterans Service Organizations (VSO) on this topic as we move forward. Their voices are important, the most important ones in this discussion. Mr. Chairman, I am looking forward to a productive and honest discussion today. I hope this is just the beginning of our oversight into this issue. There is a lot more work to do, and I yield back. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, Mr. McGarvey. I would like to introduce our witnesses. Our lead witness from VA is Ms. Nina Tann. Ms. Tann is the executive director of Compensation Service at the Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA). Good afternoon. She is joined with Dr. Sokol, correctly pronounced, is a medical officer in Compensation Services at the Veterans Benefits Administration. Thank you both for being here today. I ask that you please stand. Raise your right hand. [Witnesses sworn.] Mr. Luttrell. Let the record reflect that the witnesses have answered in the affirmative. You may be seated. Ms. Tann, at any moment if you need to--okay. Ms. Tann, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your opening statement. STATEMENT OF NINA TANN Ms. Tann. Good afternoon, Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, and members of the subcommittee. I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today. Mr. Luttrell. Ms. Tann, is your mic on? Ms. Tann. Yes, sir. Mr. Luttrell. Okay. Thank you. Ms. Tann. Good afternoon, Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, and members of the subcommittee. I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss VA's efforts to modernize disability benefits. I am accompanied today by Dr. Ulia Sokol, medical officer with the Veterans Benefits Administration. For disability compensation or pension purposes, a veteran's disabilities are evaluated using the guidance in the VA Schedule for Rating Disability, or VASRD, also known as the rating schedule. Under the authority established by 38 U.S.C. 1155, the VA Secretary shall adopt and apply a schedule of ratings of reductions in earning capacity from specific injuries or combination of injuries. This rating shall be based, as far as practicable, upon the average impairments of earning capacity resulting from such injuries in civil occupations. The Secretary shall, from time to time, readjust this schedule of ratings in accordance with experience. VA is committed to updating its disability rating criteria to accurately reflect medical science advancements and improved technology and current terminology. These updates allow VA to ensure its disability evaluations more accurately compensate veterans based on impairments and average earning ability. While VA has made numerous changes to the VASRD, it has not completed a holistic comprehensive update since 1945. In 2003, the Government Accountability Office, or GAO, deemed VA's disability program high-risk because VA had not systematically updated the VASRD. In response, VA developed a modernization plan in 2009, with the goal of comprehensively updating all 15 body systems of the VASRD. VA established work groups that included medical and VA policy Subject Matter Experts (SME) and used the analysis following its thorough review of established medical research to begin the rulemaking process, which involves drafting and publishing a proposed and final rule for each body system. To date, VA has completed updates on 11 of the 15 body systems. Any updates made to the VASRD are point forward in that they do not impact veterans currently service-connected for that particular condition or veterans who filed their claims prior to the implementation date of new rules. VA anticipates publishing the final rules for all four body systems in three rulemakings by the end of Fiscal Year 2026, which will complete the first holistic comprehensive update since 1945. In 2019, VA established the VASRD Program Management Office with a mission of revising the VASRD through rulemaking, body system by body system in staggered cycles of recurring reviews as well as in response to GAO's high-risk recommendations. VA has successfully met three of the five high-risk categories identified by GAO and have partially met the remaining two as we continue the iterative process of ensuring alignment of the VASRD evaluation criteria with medical, scientific, and technological advancements. The rulemaking process generally takes 2 to 5 years to complete, but can take longer due to the length and medical complexity of the VASRD proposed updates. Updates to the VASRD require coordination to implement required claims processing changes and to provide training and guidance to clinicians on the disability benefits questionnaires and to claims processors charged with correctly applying current disability evaluation criteria. Following the completion of the first holistic and comprehensive update to the VASRD since 1945, VA will actively pursue opportunities to update the VASRD. In our next phase VA plans to continue updating the VASRD with the evolution of medical science, technology, and treatment modalities. While VA aims to update the schedule to simplify the claims process for veterans and to promote a fair, objective, and efficient process, VA will also standardize rating terminology, incorporate the effects of court decisions, and address contemporary claims processing issues to assist claims processors charged with delivering fair, efficient, and timely benefit decisions to veterans. VA is focused on completing the first holistic change and anticipate starting the next phase of this iterative process at the end of this fiscal year. In closing, VA remains committed to modernizing disability benefits by making continuous updates to the VASRD. We thank the committee for your continued support of programs that serve the Nation's veterans and look forward to working together to further enhance delivery of benefits and service to veterans. Mr. Chairman, this concludes my statement. My colleague and I are prepared to respond to any questions that you or other members of the subcommittee may have. [The Prepared Statement Of Nina Tann Appears In The Appendix] Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, Ms. Tann. The written statement of Ms. Tann will be entered into the record. We will now move to questioning. I am going to ask some clarification questions. By the end of 2026, all body systems will be complete and this program will be completely buttoned up? Ms. Tann. This first holistic comprehensive review of the body systems. Mr. Luttrell. All 15 body systems? Ms. Tann. All 15 body systems. Mr. Luttrell. By the--in the Fiscal Year 2026? Ms. Tann. By the end of this fiscal year. Mr. Luttrell. Okay. That is great news. Good to hear that. Can you explain to me, and I can appreciate the complexities of this, why has this taken so long? I do not want to have to ask you this question at the end of 2026 of why we have not completed it. Can you explain to me? I understand when we are diving into the mental health issue, and I know that is almost impossible to figure out. Right? Can you explain to me why the last three have taken so long considering--and I will not put 1945 in there, just from the late 2019s to now. Ms. Tann. Sure. We have actually been updating all along. We have focused in, primarily, some of the most recent updates have been from 2017, but we have updates all the way back to 1994. Some of the---- Mr. Luttrell. What is an update? Ms. Tann. Update is through a final rule in which we are using updated medical evidence, science, technology to look at each of the body systems, as you mentioned, and we are looking at each of the diagnostic criteria that goes along with it. Mr. Luttrell. Where are we aggregating our data from? Ms. Tann. We have a series of processes through our work groups and the development where we look at all sorts of data from the medical community, and Dr. Sokol can speak more about---- Mr. Luttrell. Our medical community or outside the VA? Ms. Tann. We use a combination. We look at published literature. We use resources from things like all the American--also American Heart Association, for example. We look at peer-reviewed literature, all sorts of data and information. Mr. Luttrell. We are bringing that internal to the VA system? Aggregated data outside and internal to the VA is all aggregated internal to the VA, correct? Ms. Tann. When we establish a working group, we have a number of SMEs and clinical advisors, both in VA and outside of VA, and they look at current medical literature from those types of associations and things of that nature. They are bringing all of that data in. We do have clinicians, not only in VBA, in Compensation Service and our Medical Disability Examination Office (MDO) office, which you are familiar with, at Veterans Health Administration (VHA). Those are some of the sources who then look at the available data and evidence and they pull that into the process. Mr. Luttrell. Where do we currently sit with the advancements of Machine Learning (ML) and Artificial Intelligence (AI)? Ms. Tann. We are open to exploring how we can bring technology into this process. I think we have a unique opportunity now. Mr. Luttrell. We have not done that yet? Ms. Tann. Not in the process of VASRD modernization. Mr. Luttrell. Why not? The world around us is. Ms. Tann. Sure. Mr. Luttrell. You may not be able to answer that question, but I know somebody in your Department who I am going to call as soon as this hearing is over with to ask why implementation of AI and ML is not in this rating discussion, because it makes absolute sense for it to be. Ms. Tann. I think as our focus has been on this first holistic update as we move into our next iteration, that is something that we are absolutely welcome to explore. I think there is opportunity for that, sir, and I can take that back or as--if you---- Mr. Luttrell. Please do. I would actually like to have an answer to that. It makes more sense to me now and an understanding of how machine learning is effectively changing the dynamics of how we interpret medicine. I can assure you our veterans will be very pleased to know that we can do this in a matter of milliseconds, not a matter of months and years, and these platforms can do that for us. Implementation is where we seem to be hung up. Not to beat up on the VA too much, but the VA can be very siloed at times. I think that might be a missed opportunity if we just continue down the kind of the railway that we are on with--and by all means, I know that everyone that touches this information is brilliant, but when you can process information at petaflop speeds, that is a game-changer. Thank you. Ranking Member. Mr. McGarvey. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will build on that point for just a second. I do not want to speak for you at all, but, you know, we do not want to hear something is too complicated, especially if that means 5 and 10 years from now it is really a lot more complicated because we did not do something today that we should be doing. I just want to build on that a second. Ms. Tann, I will start with you. As I said at the beginning, veterans are at the heart of every single thing we do. That is what this committee is about. It is about serving our veterans. I would like to start by asking the Department's process for including veteran and VSO feedback into your methodology. Ms. Tann. So---- Mr. McGarvey. Waiting until the notice and comment period for proposed rules, to me that is too late. I want to know to what extent and through what process do you ask stakeholders for their input before you get into the rule drafting phase? Ms. Tann. We do follow the American Procedures Act (APA) and within that we do have limited opportunities with which we can have what is considered ex parte conversations so that we are not being unduly influenced or having more weight or access to more information for any group of stakeholders and others so that we maintain transparency. We do invite, through that required 60-day public comment period as--we invite anyone to provide input into that process. We do not actually currently have processes in which we are doing it because we are bound by those requirements of the APA. Mr. McGarvey. I appreciate you being clear and at the end there getting to the point: it does not happen. To take this out of government-speak, when you said there is limited opportunities for ex parte conversation, what that really means is we are not talking to veterans before you all come up with a rule. To me that needs to change. You said unduly influenced. I do not view this as undue influence. I think talking to the end user of this service is of paramount importance, particularly because this is all about helping our veterans and we know this. Sometimes something can look good on paper and then it gets into practice and it does not work the way you intended, even if you had the best intentions. Getting that feedback from our veterans is really important. I understand that Disability Compensation Advisory Committee exists, but their work is infrequent and it is increasingly sidelined by this administration. Can you commit to doubling down on efforts to get more veteran input into this process at an earlier stage? Ms. Tann. I will identify ways that we can do that, sir. Mr. McGarvey. Thank you. We would love that. As I understand it, VA is working on a new loss-earnings study given how old the previous one is. When do you expect to complete that study? Will you commit to making both the data supporting that study and its results public? Ms. Tann. We are evaluating the deliverables from that study. We actually had contractor support that ended at the end of Fiscal Year 2025. My team is actually in the process of evaluating that information from those studies, which was a test program and a proof of concept to kind of see where we go next from that. Mr. McGarvey. Can we see the data supporting the study and the results when it is all finished? Ms. Tann. I will take that back, sir. Mr. McGarvey. Yes. I am going to press you a little bit on that because I think we deserve better than that and I know our veterans deserve better than that. This is not a gotcha moment. This is asking for the data used in conducting a study and the results that impacts our veterans. We want to understand how we are coming up with these calculations that our veterans oftentimes depend on when they have been injured because of their military service and what that means for them. It is really important for anyone to have that and for it to be a transparent, inclusive process so we know what is going on. We are going to keep following up with you on that. It needs to be more than an answer, a throwaway answer in a committee of we will take that back to somebody. I know our veterans are entitled to that information and I want to make sure they get it. As I understand it, the VA has historically provided updates to GAO on your ongoing work around revising VASRD. When was the last time VA met with them? Have you shared your methodology with them recently? Ms. Tann. We do meet with GAO regularly. The last status update, I cannot give you the exact date when we did that. I do know in Fiscal Year 2025 that is when we had the increase and moved to partially met for the monitoring stage of the high- risk list criteria. We do have ongoing communications with GAO and others and provide status updates as required. Mr. McGarvey. Have you shared it with any outside researchers at all? Ms. Tann. Not to my knowledge, sir. Mr. McGarvey. I think it would, also--this is another thing. I just think it is helpful to have a second set of eyes on this type of thing to validate the methodology, to make sure we are coming up with the best system to help our veterans. Especially these are our veterans who have been injured in their service or are disabled because of their service. Appreciate that. Mr. Chairman, my time is expired. I yield back. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, sir. Mr. Bergman, General, you are recognized, sir. Mr. Bergman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I had a chance here the last 20 minutes or so just kind of reflect on what everybody was saying. Couple of thoughts. 1945, my dad was just mustering out of the Navy after World War II. Okay. I think about his last endeavor before he passed some 40-some years ago, was he was a volunteer driver for the county VSO to get the veterans to the VA hospital over by the Minneapolis airport. I, you know, I think about my parents, what they went through in the Depression and then World War II. We are using the date here, 1945, in current data. Scares the hell out of me in some ways because it means we did not change. Someone said a couple of different ways, it is complicated. Yes. Life is tough, but it is tougher when you are not exactly, you know, embracing it every day. It gets more complicated. It is like a ball of bureaucratic string that was built over time. Nobody knows where it starts, where it ends. All they know is it is this big ball of string, and it is a reason to say no. Having said that, let me just ask just--and a sense of urgency would be extremely helpful and desired within the Veterans Administration, as well as everybody involved in this, whether it is the VSOs, the veterans, but especially the bureaucracy of the Veterans Administration. If it is complicated, it is up to those of us in charge of what we are doing right now to uncomplicate it as best we can. When you heard about AI and ML, that is a way to begin the unraveling and the uncomplication of it. To what extent do outdated portions of the VASRD--you can use that in a pronunciation and an acronym, VASRD? Ms. Tann. ``VASR-D.'' Mr. Bergman. Yes, boy. ``Varsity,'' VASRD, huh? As opposed to the junior varsity? Okay, got it. Ms. Tann. You can say rating schedule, sir. Mr. Bergman. All right. To what extent does the outdated portions of it make it harder for the VA to consistently and accurately evaluate modern, complex conditions among younger veterans? We know, based on the nature of war, the injuries that were received in World War I, World War II, Korea, Vietnam, Desert Shield, Desert Storm, Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF), Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF) have changed because of the nature of the fight, the survivability, et cetera, et cetera. Are we getting rid of the outdated stuff? I mean, regardless of timelines, do you really think when all is said and done, this will really be reflective of the types of injuries that our veterans are receiving in conflicts today? Ms. Tann. Yes, sir, I do. As part of our updates, and again, to be clear, it is not that we have not updated since 1945. The systemic and holistic update has not been completed, but we have updated body systems, diagnostic codes, and we do remove outdated terminology. We remove outdated testing and things that are not accepted in the medical and clinical community. We remove instances where there may be subjective criteria. I will use for an example in the proposed rule for the neurological body system where some nerve paralysis could be rated by mild, moderate, or severe. Well, that is not really great objective criteria then for someone to use. We are adding testing and objective and measurable components that help reflect the current disability picture, like you mentioned, of what our veterans are experiencing today. We add new diagnostic codes. We--like for mental health, for example, we are proposing updates that adapt to the DSM-4. Mr. Bergman. I mean, I know you could--okay. Is there a sense of urgency? Ms. Tann. Absolutely. Mr. Bergman. I guess it would be helpful if you could, you know, not today, but give us something that shows a sense of urgency, that actually shows that. We hear it, but I can be honest with you, I do not see it. Okay? Ms. Tann. Yes, sir. Mr. Bergman. I will just leave it at that and I will yield back, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Luttrell. Mrs. Radewagen, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Radewagen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for holding this important hearing today. Thank you to the witnesses. Ms. Tann, what is VA's plan for future updates of the VASRD and what criteria is VA using to prioritize future updates? Ms. Tann. Thank you for that question. We are using the lessons learned from this first iteration and best practices. We are looking at ways to be more strategic in that. We do not just necessarily want to take a look body system by body system, but where we have evidence and data that supports that we need to take another look. Some of that may come from studies and things such as our earnings loss studies, if we are able to use that. We will use areas where we know in medical science that have changed and updated through technology and treatment modalities. We will look at the body systems. We will also look at individual diagnostic codes and, based off the available evidence, we will prioritize those remaining updates or the next phase of updates with all of that information in mind. Trying to take a much more strategic approach, project management focused approach to it, I think, because we do have this experience and lessons learned from this first holistic update that will be completed by the end of this fiscal year. Ms. Radewagen. Ms. Tann, does VA have a project management plan or other document that outlines goals, objectives, or a schedule for future updates? If not, is there a timeline for VA to develop such a plan? Ms. Tann. We do have a plan for the first iteration, which is coming to a close, as I mentioned before, and we are working on what that project management plan for the next iteration will look like so that we do have schedules, milestones, and things like that to measure our progress and to make sure that we are following good project management principles for our future updates. Ms. Radewagen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back the balance of my time. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, ma'am. Mr. Self, sir, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Self. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have just got some probably easy questions to answer. Why sleep apnea? Is that military related? Ms. Tann. It can be. For VA disability purposes, we look at disabilities that were incurred in or caused by or aggravated by military service. If something started during military service, then we have a responsibility according to the law to service-connect sleep apnea for any residual disability based upon that. Mr. Self. Really? Okay. How much of this, and I realize this is not Veterans Integrated Service Network (VISN) driven, but how much of this is customization that is allowed amongst the different contractors? How much of that? We see that, I see that often, we allow too much customization across the VA. Ms. Tann. So are you referring to our Disability Benefits Commission? Mr. Self. Yes, yes, the---- Ms. Tann. We have criteria which must be supported by clinical findings and medical evidence. That is one---- Mr. Self. How much of that is customizable? Ms. Tann. We do cut down on areas of free text, but we do need the doctor's observations. We do--but we use testing, we use clinical criteria, and we look at the entire disability record and we do not rest anything on just one single piece of evidence. Mr. Self. There is a statement in here that more veterans are relying on disability. Is that actually true or is that--do we see a growth in this? Ms. Tann. I do not have any evidence to support that. More evidence--excuse me, more veterans are relying on this benefit. We do have veterans that are employed. Most veterans that we serve are actually employed in some part and gainfully employed in many situations. Mr. Self. Would you just give me, and you may have already covered this and you probably have, and I apologize if you have, give me a short dissertation on impairment disability versus financial inability to earn? Why that distinction and how is that working in all of this review that you are doing? This seems to me to be part of the crux of what we are asking here. Ms. Tann. Part of our evaluations, we look at occupational impairment and functional loss. I think when, in VA terms, when we look at things like TDIU, which I am sure you are familiar with, when we find veterans who are unemployable because of service-connected disabilities, if they do not meet that criteria otherwise, then we have benefits in store for that. You could very easily have a 100 percent service-connected disabled veteran who is able to work, For us, a disability and 100 percent evaluation does not mean unable to work in many situations. Disability compensation does not mean that a veteran cannot earn wages, that they are unemployable. It means that based off the residual impairment, the VA finds them to be 100 percent disabled because of the severity of their disabilities. Mr. Self. Right. How are you going to apply either one of those really to mental health, which is a growth industry? As we know, mental health amongst veterans is rampant. How is that working with mental health? It is a little bit different than physical impairment. Ms. Tann. Certainly. I am going to ask---- Mr. Self. How are you going to apply that? Ms. Tann. I am going to ask Dr. Sokol to address that because she has done a lot of the work in that area. Dr. Sokol. Good afternoon. Currently, the portion of the rating schedule which addresses mental disorders is in the final stages of its publication as a final rule. We did publish the proposed rule several years ago, which received overwhelmingly positive feedback from the veterans community, from clinicians. That is because we adhered to the latest approach to assessing the functional impairment due to mental disorders, which is outlined in great detail in DSM-5, which is the governing document for all psychiatrists and clinical psychologists to assess the level of functional impairment due to mental disorders. In this new portion of the rating schedule, we will be able to adequately address the level of functional impairment and corresponding occupationally significant disability. We are looking forward to publishing it by the end of the Fiscal Year 2026. Mr. Self. Okay. Real quickly, what has the toxic exposure law done to this examination, this review of your disability criteria? Dr. Sokol. I will ask Ms. Tann to weigh in on this question, please. Mr. Self. Just quickly. I am out of time. Ms. Tann. Sorry, sir. We have a process by which we look at toxic exposures through our military. I am sorry, it is called the Military Environmental Exposures Sub-Council (MEESC) for-- it escapes me right now what that group looks at, but that is a separate group that looks for things based off our presumptive conditions---- Mr. Self. Right. Ms. Tann [continuing]. based off the codified requirement for that disease process. We look at those slightly differently based off exposures and what the science and evidence shows based off that exposure. Mr. Self. You have made my point, more complexity. I yield, Chairman. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, Mr. Self. If we are using DSM-5, what data--can you give me, Dr. Sokol, can you give me kind of a timeframe of the data that we are currently using to define mental health for the VASR system, VASRD system? Let me give you a little bit more depth to this because---- Dr. Sokol. Yes. Will you please---- Mr. Luttrell. Yes, absolutely. Dr. Sokol [continuing]. expand a little bit on the data portion? Mr. Luttrell. Before I showed up to this wonderful place, my focus was in neuroscience. One thing my professors told me when I was in grad school is that what you are going to learn today will not be correct in 5 years. How were they right. It is not more or less a concern because research is research, but are we about to do an implementation of information that is already outdated? Dr. Sokol. Well, let me revisit DSM-5. DSM-5 is updated on average every 16 to 18 years. Mr. Luttrell. Great. I mean, that is a home run. Dr. Sokol. There is a great big committee which gathers all the data between the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) publications. The current DSM, DSM-5, was published in 2013, and it had introduced a lot of changes to the way we look at the functional impairment due to mental disorders. Mr. Luttrell. In 2013, a severe traumatic brain--there were three levels of traumatic brain injury in 2013: mild, medium, and severe. Dr. Sokol. Well---- Mr. Luttrell. That is it. Dr. Sokol. Actually the biggest introduction was the multidimensional approach to the way we look at their mental health and mental disability. Those multidimensional approach means that all of us are built the same way and there are certain number of domains of function, such as ability to interact with others, cognition, self care, and so on and so forth. That multidimensional approach, which was introduced based on a great deal of data by DSM-5, is the basis of our review of the VASRD Rating Schedule for disability mental disorders portion. Mr. Luttrell. That will not be updated until the DSM-5 comes out with the DSM-6 version? Dr. Sokol. It will be updated by the end of Fiscal Year 2026. It is updated already. It will be published. This final rule---- Mr. Luttrell. Off of the DSM-5? Dr. Sokol. Yes. It is based on DSM-5 multidimensional approach. Mr. Luttrell. Fifteen years ago. Somebody do the math. Dr. Sokol. No, it was---- Mr. Luttrell. 2013? Dr. Sokol. 2013. Mr. Luttrell. 23 is 10 plus--that is concerning because how much more we know today will not be near as much as we know tomorrow when we are dealing with the beautiful mind that sits between our ears, which every single human being is different, which I am sure you absolutely know. Ms. Tann, the end of 2020, give me a--do you have a date? I am big on dates. The day after this thing goes out, I would like you and Dr. Sokol sitting in front of us and assuring us that we are--we got a green light and we are good to go. Do you have---- Ms. Tann. We anticipate our remaining final rules to be published around the summer of 2026. Mr. Luttrell. Summer of 2026. Ms. Tann. Then we will have time for implementation and an effective date, sir, beyond that. Mr. Luttrell. Summer of 2026. Interesting. Okay. Mr. McGarvey, you good? General? Mrs. Radewagen, do you have a question? You are good? Mr. Self? Good to go? Okay. Thank you very much for your testimony today. Thank you. Again, thank you for everything that you are doing for our veterans and the Department of Veterans Affairs. I like to say this every single time we have a hearing. The VA is one--is a big machine. Everybody plays their role. Every morning that we wake up, every morning that you wake up, we absolutely know that who we are serving is our veterans, and we are here because of them. Thank you and have a very blessed day. Ms. Tann. Yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you for this. Dr. Sokol. Thank you for this opportunity. Mr. Luttrell. Yes, ma'am. Once the first panel is up, panel number two may be seated. Our first witness on this panel will be Ms. Elizabeth Curda. Ms. Curda is the director of Education, Workforce, and Income Security at the Government Accountability Office. Second witness on the panel is Mr. Philip Armour. Mr. Armour is the director of the RAND School of Public Policy Ph.D. program and a senior economist at RAND. Our third witness is Dr. Kyleanne Hunter. Dr. Hunter is the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America (IAVA). What branch? Dr. Hunter. Marine Corps. Best one. Mr. Luttrell. I feel like as a Navy guy, I should say something. Okay. Thank you for your service. I would like to welcome the witnesses to our second panel. The witnesses, I please ask that you stand and raise your right hand. [Witnesses sworn.] Mr. Luttrell. Let the record reflect that the witnesses have answered in the affirmative. Ms. Curda, you are now recognized for 5 minutes to deliver your opening testimony. STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH CURDA Ms. Curda. Good afternoon, Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, and members of the subcommittee. I am pleased to discuss GAO's work on VA's efforts to update its disability rating schedule. When veterans file claims for disability compensation, VBA claims processors use the rating schedule to determine monthly compensation. VA's Disability Compensation Program provides billions of dollars in benefits to millions of veterans and their families. VA must be able to make accurate decisions about the amount of compensation a veteran receives as a matter of fairness to veterans and to ensure the program is achieving its intended results. VA has struggled to stay current with needed updates to the rating schedule. In 2003, we designated VA's Disability Compensation Program high-risk, in part because its rating schedule did not fully reflect advances in medicine and technology and changes in the labor market that have occurred since 1945. VA is required to base its compensation decisions on the average loss in civilian earnings resulting from a veteran's service-connected disability, but it has never updated this information based on data-driven analysis. My testimony today discusses VA's progress on updating the medical and earnings loss information in the rating schedule as well as remaining challenges. Medical information includes the types of disabling conditions that veterans may have organized into the 15 body systems. Earnings loss information is the average decrease in expected earnings caused by those disabilities. VA has taken positive steps to improve the process for updating medical information. In terms of progress, between 1945 and 2009, VA mainly focused on updating the rating schedule with new medical terms and criteria for determining a condition's severity. In 2009, VA embarked upon an ambitious effort to comprehensively update both medical and earnings loss information. These changes included establishing an office to plan and oversee these efforts. VA has also begun making plans for a 10-year cycle for updating the medical information to more systematically consider advances in the evaluation and treatment of medical conditions. Since 2009, VA has completed updates to the medical information for 11 of 15 body systems. After years of fits and starts, VA has also begun testing its own earnings loss studies. VA is testing how the Department could produce earnings loss data and update the rating schedule with this information. However, VA still faces challenges keeping its rating schedule up to date. It has yet to complete comprehensive revisions for four body systems. VA's attempts to revise some of these systems have been going on for years. In addition, information about how veterans' disabilities affect earnings loss remain a major gap. It is uncertain whether or when VA will complete these studies and use the information to update the rating schedule. Going back decades, VA and external studies have evaluated the average loss of earnings for veterans with service- connected disabilities and suggested that not all veterans were being equitably compensated. For example, certain external studies suggested that veterans with mental health conditions were being undercompensated. As of today, VA has not updated its rating schedule with earnings loss information. Consequently, ratings determinations for all earnings loss calculations remain based on information from over eight decades ago. We have been monitoring VA's efforts to fix these problems through the lens of our high-risk list. As of 2025, VA has met three of the five criteria for removal from the list. It has shown leadership, commitment, developed an action plan to address root causes of its problems, and has been monitoring its progress. To have this area removed from the high-risk list, VA must continue to meet these three criteria and fully meet two more: capacity and demonstrated progress. Capacity involves things like identifying and applying the resources needed to implement its plans, and demonstrated progress means VA is accomplishing its goals and objectives for updating the rating schedule. Ultimately, without a rating schedule that fully reflects present day medicine and changes in the labor market since 1945, VA may overcompensate some veterans while undercompensating others. This concludes my prepared statement and I am happy to address your questions. [The Prepared Statement Of Elizabeth Curda Appears In The Appendix] Mr. Luttrell. The written statement from Ms. Curda will be entered into the record. Mr. Armour, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF PHILIP ARMOUR Mr. Armour. Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, and members of the committee, thank you for your invitation to testify. As a labor economist, I research how health conditions impact individuals' ability to earn income and on the design of disability programs. Today I will focus on four points related to the economic effects of disability and describe implications for VA Disability Compensation (VADC). By statute, VADC benefits consider veterans' earning losses from service-connected disabilities, not just a medical rating of impairment severity. The most recently published VA commissioned earning loss study was in 2008. Although there have been more recent studies, none of these studies have incorporated modern disability research findings, specifically how different elements of disability programs can independently impact earnings. Evidence from other programs shows that cash and noncash disability benefits do directly affect earnings, but no research exists on how VA's programs impact today's veterans' earnings. Updated earnings loss studies that incorporate research on today's veterans would inform more accurate disability ratings. Alternatively, a move toward individualized disability determinations could also increase accuracy and eliminate the need for detailed earnings loss studies, but would require statutory changes. To zoom out, in disability studies, there is a distinction between impairment and disability. Physical or mental conditions can lead to impairment, a reduction in the functioning of a body system or structure which can be diagnosed by medical professionals. Disability, however, relates to how these conditions lead to limitations to societal participation. For many disability programs in the U.S., there is a focus on how impairments lead to work disability, specifically reduced earnings capacity. Unlike with impairments, evaluating work disability requires consideration of the economic consequences of health conditions and thus requires collaboration between medical and labor force experts. VA disability compensation is aptly named. By statute, a veteran with a service-connected health condition receives a rating that, quoting here, ``shall be based upon the average impairments of earning capacity resulting from such injuries in civil occupations.'' Given the statutory requirements, VA has commissioned studies to estimate how service-connected health conditions translate into average earnings losses. In general, these studies compare earnings of veterans with service- connected ratings with earnings of otherwise similar nonveterans or veterans without ratings. There are two issues facing the state of VA earnings loss studies. First, to be relevant, earnings loss studies need to reflect the current employment environment. However, the last published study relied on data from at least 20 years ago. Since then, there have been substantial changes in medical treatments, veteran disability evaluation, and the labor market, such as, for example, substantial increases in remote work. Furthermore, a rated health condition is rated because of its impact on earnings capacity, but the rating then facilitates access to VADC benefits and additional VA programs. How participation in VA programs affects the earnings of veterans is largely unknown. Yet, since the publication of the last earnings loss study, research on the causal impacts of other disability programs has proliferated. Specifically, there is now strong evidence on how the benefits in those programs have direct effects on earnings. For example, recent evidence indicates that low cost- sharing healthcare access and targeted vocational rehabilitation benefits similar to benefits offered by the VA can facilitate return to work and higher earnings. Not accounting for these program-induced earnings increases would make average earnings losses appear less severe, but only due to the success of the programs. Other programs are different than VAs and serve different populations, and the field of disability research also tells us the program details matter and that different populations respond differently. These other findings are suggestive of potential VA effects, but are not conclusive. Because we do not have a clear understanding of the relationship among VADC, other VA programs, and veterans' earnings, we have limited ability to evaluate these programs' effectiveness and thus limited ability to estimate earnings losses from service-connected work disability. Other disability programs also offer potential alternatives to the average earnings loss approach. The VADC statute reflects a concept known as disability-based average justice, or the notion that individuals with similar levels of disability should receive the same rating and the same compensation. Most other disability systems take an individual justice approach to at least disability determination, where an applicant's disability is rated based on the impacts of their health condition on their own earnings capacity, not on the average work disability. Regardless of the conceptual framework, recent research from Social Security and Workers' Compensation programs can provide insight into how the impact of VA programs on earnings could be incorporated into the current average justice framework or on how VADC could implement an individual justice framework. Yet these other programs serve distinct populations, so additional research with and insights from today's veterans are essential to ensure an accurately implemented VADC program. Thank you for your time and I look forward to your questions. [The Prepared Statement Of Philip Armour Appears In The Appendix] Mr. Luttrell. The written statement for Mr. Armour will be entered into the hearing record. Dr. Hunter, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF KYLEANNE HUNTER Dr. Hunter. Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America is dedicated to improving the lives of post 9-11 veterans and it is an honor to speak on their behalf today. It is also concerning that at today's hearing there is only one veteran organization represented. This despite the fact that veterans who engage with the VASRD are not a monolith and there are several voices not in this room, including those that have directly worked with veterans to navigate the benefit process, and I hope in future conversations we can include more veteran voices. Modernization should be done with us, not merely on our behalf. Veterans Affairs is currently undertaking a process of modernizing the VASRD, attempting to reflect both the realities of injuries experienced by servicemembers and advancement in medical science. The modern veteran population faces conditions and occupational realities that were not examined in many of the previous efforts. For example, traumatic brain injuries, toxic exposure, military sexual trauma, and complex mental health disorders are central to the post 9-11 veteran experience and have a significant impact on veteran quality of life and long-term employment outcomes. Current modernization efforts to be undertaken by the VA include earning-loss studies to incorporate data on how service-connected conditions affect veterans' earning capacity and to align compensation with functional impairment and labor market realities. However, there remains virtually no transparency into how these studies are being conducted and whether or not they truly reflect the complete reality of the veteran experience. Earnings loss studies may provide us useful data, but are in an incomplete lens to view the problem. For example, the Congressional Budget Office study on disability compensation focused only on male veterans, despite the fact that when this study was conducted, women made up the fastest growing group of veterans. We do have significant evidence to show that women veterans, even when fully employed, have different earnings than their male peers. As a representative of the generation that has seen the largest increase in women's service, this shows why it is critical that veteran voices are included at the table to ensure fulsome and essential studies. While the VASRD shares some similarities to other disability compensation programs, there are fundamental differences between veteran and civilian populations. Military service impacts the human body physically and mentally in ways that few civilian occupations ever will. From high physical risk occupations to repeated exposures to toxic substances, to increased risks for interpersonal harmful behaviors, and to having little control over where one lives, military service comes with inherent health risks. VASRD is one way that the country recognizes and compensates the individuals who volunteered and accepted these risks on behalf of the American people. This system also exists in a unique legal framework shaped by the Ferris Doctrine, which prevents servicemembers from suing the Federal Government for injuries incurred during military services. Because veterans cannot legally seek tort damages for pain and suffering or loss of quality of life, disability compensation often also serves as not just income replacement, but redress for harms incurred while choosing to serve one's country. Many service-connected conditions, such as chronic pain, migraines, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), sleep disorders, may not immediately remove a veteran from the workforce, but still impose real lifelong impairments that merit compensation. Veterans service organizations for decades have been advocating to include lagging quality of life indicators in disability compensation calculations and that total compensation should look not just at the ability of veterans to be employed, but the compound and long-term medical impacts of service-connected illnesses and injuries. New research is also showing that quality of life indicators may be uniquely impactful to veterans and may exacerbate existing employment challenges. VASRD as a program is also not just an investment in those that served, but an investment in our long-term national security. Veteran care after service is still a strong recruitment tool for military service, which requires the public trust. Veterans' participation in the modernization process will increase the confidence that these reforms are justified, fair, and aligned with modern veterans needs. It maintains the buy-in of one of the country's best recruiting assets: those of us who have already served. Like many other veterans organizations, IAVA stands ready to support the VA in these modernization efforts and our members are eager to engage. In our most recent polity priority survey, over 50 percent of IAVA members cited modernizing the process as their top area that they would like to be involved in. Additionally, of our members that have a disability raising over 65 percent report that their disability payments are essential to their overall financial well being. Thank you for your commitment to America's veterans and I look forward to your questions. [The Prepared Statement Of Kyleanne Hunter Appears In The Appendix] Mr. Luttrell. The written statement of Dr. Hunter will be entered into the hearing record. Well said, Dr. Hunter. All right. Mr. Armour, I was trying to pick your opening statement apart as best I could, but what I took from it is I think we are in trouble. Now I am going to ask you to talk to me. I consider myself a highly educated guy, but if you would not mind putting it in crayon for me. What you just said is do we have the capability to get there from here with compensation levels through this rating system? It did not sound like it. You were doing a comparative analysis to the civilian population and the veteran population, and Dr. Hunter most eloquently defined both, which, again, good job. Can we do this or is this an uphill battle that we will constantly have VA in front of us saying it will be next year? Mr. Armour. I can speak for the analytic question. Mr. Luttrell. I am going to beat on you. You got a Ph.D. That means you are way smarter than me. Mr. Armour. We can do the earnings loss. We can do modern earnings loss studies. That is right. I think transparency about the methods that are used in it, pretty much all the methods used so far from the work cited in my testimony and the other panelists, it is outdated or it is using estimation techniques that are just not actually getting action. Mr. Luttrell. It will always be outdated. Mr. Armour. Not always 20 years outdated. Mr. Luttrell. We have to land somewhere, this panel right here and subcommittee, the full committee, all the way to where it needs to go. It will always be outdated. Where is the landing zone for us? We are going to have this conversation with VA and the fact that the other veteran organizations--Dr. Hunter, as you stated, this is an--anyone is welcome to sit in front of this committee at any time. I welcome it. We welcome that. Mr. Armour. We have done these, this kind of research for other programs. They do differ in these ways, but modern techniques can do it and they can do it relatively quickly in terms of, you know, months and years instead of decades. Mr. Luttrell. Define ``relatively quickly'' for the Federal Government. Mr. Armour. Months and years instead of decades. Mr. Luttrell. Okay. Dr. Curda, is the VA in a position to get this thing completed and pushed across the finish line in summer of 2026, in your personal opinion? Ms. Curda. I cannot tell you that they will be done in 2026. We---- Mr. Luttrell. From the information that you have gathered and the research that you have done, what are we looking at? Ms. Curda. They are in the final stages. Mr. Luttrell. Final stage. Man, I tell you what, you would be surprised how many people are in final stages in the U.S. Government. I mean, we are like there. Ms. Curda. That is what I--that is all I know. Mr. Luttrell. I mean, the electronic healthcare record has been in the final stages for the past 10 years and we are about 50 billion into it and it is still not done. Matter of fact, we are shutting it down. Ms. Curda. Yes. Meaning they are just before the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) phase, I guess---- Mr. Luttrell. Right. Ms. Curda [continuing]. with the final rule. It is possible that they can be done this year and we are hopeful. We would love them to be done this year. I cannot be sure they will. We have not seen an update on their progress since June of last year, and we have not had a substantive update on their action plans since August 2024. Mr. Luttrell. I would be interested to know how, once the 15 body systems rescheduling is complete and we have the 15 body systems that we consider, okay, how do we continue to update that at a pace that stays relevant to science and medicine? Mr. Armour, you got something for that? You are a doctor, are you not? Mr. Armour. Ph.D. Again, I think we can do these analyses much faster. We have the capacity. Mr. Luttrell. Can I will tell you what? Mr. Armour. That access is the biggest issue, I think, right now. Mr. Luttrell. Analysis to application is the death of this place. You know how--looking around at the walls, everybody wants to write about something. We have to touch human bodies. I mean, I am so sick and tired of that. I am not beating up on you. I am talking out loud for the world to hear this. How do we stay relevant in your personal and professional opinion once this thing goes nuclear? Is that a possibility or, Ms. Curda, are we going to be having this conversation 5 years from now that we are still using the DSM-5 and the information that we have on traumatic brain injuries date from 2013? I am sure Dr. Dexter is going to clack off on this one in a hurry when it is her turn. Ms. Curda. Yes, I am not a medical doctor either. I think it is possible for VA to stay up to date and I think they need to stay up to date, but they will have to continue to have really rigorous and realistic planning. They need to address some of the root causes of the issues. For example, the internal review process. I took a look at all the stakeholders internally to VA and there is something like 18 different--8 parts of VA that have to look at the draft rule and 16, according to them, 16 levels of review. Then once you are done with that, there is external parties, there is something like 11 external parties that they review it. Mr. Luttrell. I mean, the complexities are mind-numbing, but it is so important for us to figure this out, us, we, the Department of Veterans Affairs, figure this out because it is the veterans that are feeling the pressures. Mr. McGarvey, you are recognized, sir. Mr. McGarvey. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. I am just going to pick up on what you were just saying, Dr. Armour. I used to work with a lawyer who would say, had an old expression, he said, you can get it fast, good, and cheap. Pick any two of three. Right. What is the best and fastest way we keep up to date? Mr. Armour. I think it is facilitating access to data for researchers. There is a paper that Dr. Hunter cited forthcoming by David Silver and Jonathan Zhang, looking at the impacts of ratings for mental conditions on quality of life outcomes and on healthcare utilization. That was--it is a phenomenal project. I think that represents the current state of what research can do in this field. It is entirely limited to outcomes that the Veterans Health Administration has access to. Mr. McGarvey. Where is the lag in data coming from? Mr. Armour. I cannot speak to specifically the internals of that study. I think, in general, getting linkages between VBA and VHA to occur is pretty much impossible to have happen, let alone the other aspect of this, which is the earnings loss studies. Those data generally need to come from the Social Security Administration, which has--they will not export individual data, but will allow for some Memorandum of Understandings (MOU) to understand it. Setting those up, facilitating that, that enables research to be done, the good research, and--yes. Ms. Curda. Can I comment on--just comment on that? Mr. McGarvey. Yes. Ms. Curda. VA actually has in place agreements now with the Social Security Administration and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and some other entities to do that kind of data exchange. They have made progress in that area. I just wanted to point that out. Mr. McGarvey. It sounds like we still need to have some progress in that area. One thing we need you all is help on and I can tell you on this committee, we are not going to accept the idea that we cannot do this because I think we can. Dr. Hunter, do you want to say something? Dr. Hunter. Yes. I will just add to the conversation and I will disclose Phil and I were colleagues until just a little while ago here. There is also a big issue in the transparency of these studies being done. We hear a lot that VA is making these--like having these MOUs, doing all of these data, but they are doing it in a black box, which does not allow for either organizations like RAND and other Federally Funded Research and Development Centers (FFRDC) to actually do reproduction surveys or you do the data or do the studies faster, often through tools, or for VSOs to validate and understand. Like are you actually representative of this hierarchy of the population? We end up with studies like the U.S. Congressional Budget Office (CBO) does that excludes the fastest growing part of our population. Data transparency coming out of the VA is one of the biggest blockers to being able to do these fast and accurately. Mr. McGarvey. That should be something we should be able to help fix a little bit, I would think, Mr. Chairman. Dr. Hunter, I am going to go over to you. Thank you for your service. Appreciate that. I want to get away from--we have been out of government-speak now for a solid 3 minutes. I hope we can stay in this zone. I am just going to ask you point blank, do you think the VA disability is overly generous right now? Dr. Hunter. No. Mr. McGarvey. Have you spoken with anybody who does? Dr. Hunter. No. Mr. McGarvey. Okay, good. What would you say to someone who thinks that veterans who receive VA disability are somehow taking advantage of taxpayers, they are scamming the system? Dr. Hunter. I would first say that when you raise your right hand to serve, you make a contract with the United States, and that is that we put our lives on the line 24/7, and as a result, we are to be taken care of for the time when we are done. Mr. McGarvey. I think that contract you make when you raise your right hand and give yourself to service is both a legal and a moral obligation that we have as a country. I want to ask you about the statutory mandate for the basis of disability ratings. The law says, quote, ``The rating shall be based upon the average impairments of earning capacity resulting from such injuries in civil occupations,'' which is wonderful statutory language to say you get injured in the service. We are going to look at your disability rating based off a civilian counterpart. It is that ``civil occupations'' part that concerns me because military occupations do not always line up with civilian occupations. You yourself, Dr. Hunter, you were an attack pilot on a helicopter. I am not sure there is a civilian equivalent for that type of job. Dr. Hunter. I have not found it. I was looking for it for a long time. I have not found it. Mr. McGarvey. I do not think it is there. You know, and whether it is a Navy SEAL, whether it is an artillery crewman, we are going to have trouble lining this up. Dr. Hunter, how do you compare injuries and illnesses that happen in military service with civilians? Dr. Hunter. They are not comparable. The military service, as I stated, there are physical risks that are unique. There are mental and psychological risks that are unique. There are environmental risks that are unique. One of the biggest areas of sort of divergence between the civilian and military occupations is that military servicemembers have very little to no control over where they spend their time, what environmental factors might be around them, what they are exposed to, the types of injuries they may receive. A lot of the research that is done on the civilian side also include some opt in, right, some buy in to whatever career path they choose to be in in terms of how those calculations are done. The military, that is also removed, which goes back to some of this contract, that there is a volunteer to do whatever the country asks of you to do. Both the type of injuries and the environment in which those injuries might take place are divergent in medical aspects as well as the moral contract that we have made with the country. Mr. McGarvey. Thank you very much. I do think that how, when, and where the injuries occur are often important in military service, just as the injury itself. Mr. Chairman, I am out of time. I yield back. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, sir. General Bergman, sir, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Bergman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is really fascinating to sit here and listen to the discussion back and forth because I sense everybody here is--no matter what role you are playing, even if you are sitting out there in a crowd, we are all here for the betterment for veterans outcomes, which is a good thing. Not necessarily in Washington, DC, can that be said in every hearing room. I will just leave that for a discussion of a different time. I would like--and this is a generic--it is not a generic question. It is a specific question for any of you to respond to. To what extent do silos currently exist that inhibit the breakthrough results and the speed at which we need--the change that we know needs to occur occurs? Would anyone like to address the--however you want to address silos? Ms. Curda. Yes, there are silos that exist that prevent the speed of things getting done. Mr. Bergman. Okay. In that case, so we agree that there are silos. I think that is not a surprise. Is the level of understanding that those silos exist, let us say within the Veterans Administration, to acknowledge they exist and then deal with the fact that do they need to exist? Do we need--is it additive in a positive way for the outcomes? Sometimes we have to work to get things done. If we work too long in a silo, we do not share the information. As the Veterans Administration looks at their reorganization of the business, which was just announced, you know, in the last month or so, do you believe that a part of being able to speed up the process here toward positive results, it would be a positive effect to, however it is done, break down, rewicker, whatever you want to call the silos? Dr. Hunter. Sir, I will answer that one and I will answer it both from now as a CEO of a veteran organization and someone who was a public policy researcher before coming into this role. Absolutely, and particularly breaking down the silo between the VA and veterans in this research. One of the things I learned very early on doing public policy research is that numbers are all great and fine in the spreadsheet, but the rubber meets the road when you engage the population that whatever you are researching is going to be impacting. Breaking down that silo, A, it will allow information to get to the VA faster about the reality of what is happening to veterans rather than waiting 10 years of the study. Talk to us, ask us. We can tell you that very quickly, as well as allow for a more, you know, robust and rapid updating of the system to meet the realities. We talk a lot and we hear in the news all the time that warfare and the type of, like, modern warfare is expanding at this exponential rate. We have--whether it is advancements in technologies or the change in the type of enemies that we have, and if the VA remains siloed and cutoff, doing their research and not interacting with those who most recently served, there is always going to be this lag. We are always going to be playing catch-up and saying, oh, yes, well, next time we will deal with this injury. Next time we will look into this body system. Next time we will figure this out. From where we sit, absolutely, we are here and ready and want to break down those silos and work to ensure that our veterans are taken care of. Mr. Bergman. Anybody else want to comment? Okay, that is all right. Silence is you do not want to comment. Okay. Along with the silos, what can we do, from your perspective, as a committee to advance the decrease--or, excuse me, the increase in transparency? Once you have got the silos broken down, how do you set the environment where now if you are working on this project--we are all working, you know, but there is that transparency of data exchange? Any thoughts? Ms. Curda. Well, I think certainly hearings like this are a great way to make situations at VA more transparent and having testimony. I think, encouraging the agency to be forthcoming and transparent with information with GAO, for example. We have had a good dialog with them in the past number of years as we have been monitoring their progress on the high-risk issue. Sometimes the information has to go through extensive levels of clearance and takes a lot of time to get to us. We just would prefer to have a more give-and-take kind of relationship on these things because we think that would help give us an opportunity to respond to them sooner and it may help things-- keep things from going off track. Mr. Bergman. Okay, thank you. Mr. Chairman, thank you. I see I am over my time. I yield back. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, General. Dr. Morrison, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Morrison. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank you and the ranking member for holding this hearing today. I want to thank our witnesses for being here to testify, too. I am also glad there is bipartisan agreement that the VA Schedule for Rating Disability should be modernized and it is essential that we get this right. We need to require transparency from VA and a process that incorporates feedback from medical experts, economists, and, of course, the veterans themselves. My late father-in-law was an Army Ranger and received disability compensation for the injuries he sustained in combat. We know that so much has changed since veterans like my father-in-law served, both in terms of the nature of military service as well as significant advances in medical research and treatment. We know more than ever we have the--we know more about the effects of military service on veterans' physical and mental health. It is critical that we put this data as well as veterans' experience to use as we tackle this important issue. Dr. Hunter, I want to begin with you. As you noted, women are the fastest growing group of veterans. According to VA, women made up about 4 percent of the veteran population in 2000. By 2040, VA expects that number to increase to 18 percent. What should VA be doing to incorporate data that accurately accounts for the increasing population of women veterans? Dr. Hunter. When we look at women veterans, and particularly for this topic in particular, there are two areas that need to be done. One is ensuring that when we are looking at the actual impacts of certain injuries, illnesses, and exposures, that women are part of the clinical studies to understand what the impairments actually are. There is a long history of medical research excluding women and so we are basing women's conditions off of what men have experienced. We know that women are not just little men in this regard. Actually doing the clinical studies to understand the impact on women is essential. When we are looking at earnings loss statements as well, women need to be considered in the workforce aspect of this. You know, we look at a lot of conditions that may, you know, triple or almost quadruple impact women if we look at things like reproductive healthcare issues that are connected to service-related conditions and what that does to workforce engagement. We also have a whole like a host of new issues since women have been involved in ground combat of the musculoskeletal systems that have not been studied. We cannot make accurate determinations without knowing that. Which is why, again, the veteran community stands here willing and wanting to be involved. Ms. Morrison. I appreciate that and thank you for bringing reproductive healthcare and its impacts into it. As an Obstetrics and Gynecologist (OB/GYN) myself, I think that is critically important. Dr. Hunter, in your testimony you mentioned that post 9-11 veterans are more likely than previous generations to endure exposure experiences that contribute to diagnosed mental health disorders, both from the psychological and physiological perspective. Traumatic brain injury, toxic exposure, and military sexual trauma are all factors that have to be considered to meet the needs of the modern day veteran population. As we continue to learn more about these various forms of trauma--how these various forms of trauma affect a veteran's quality of life and economic prospects, what role do veteran service organizations have to play in ensuring the needs of the veteran are reflected in any proposed changes to the rating schedule? Dr. Hunter. Thank you so much for bringing up the mental health side of this, too. I think VSOs have three or four big areas that we play. One is we are the frontline touch points with veterans. As IAVA, we conduct multiple surveys a year to understand the experiences in closer to real time than any of these VA studies can be done. If we want to know how this is impacting people, we can tell you. We actually have that data. When we talk about data sharing and transparency, we can get it to you in a much faster way. Additionally, one of the big parts of this is that VSOs engage with veterans who may not be in the VA system. When VA is doing their studies, they have a huge bias that we have not even talked about, the fact that when they are looking at outcomes, they are looking most often at people who are already part of the VHA system. Part of what we want to do is catch that wherever it is, between 20 and 50 percent, depending on what study you read, of veterans who are outside of the system. We are the conduit to those people. We are the conduit to the people that is actually the hardest to get the data on, which is important. Then third, we are a trusted agent. There has been historic--through all of the scandals and all of the reporting, the VA has been all over the place in how much the veteran community actually trusts them. VSOs are often more trusted organizations, and we can serve a role in helping the VA build that trust back in the veteran population through collaborative work. Ms. Morrison. Thank you so much. Many more questions, but I see my time has expired. One more? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Luttrell. Mrs. Radewagen. Ms. Radewagen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to thank the witnesses for appearing today. Ms. Curda, does GAO believe that VA is still treating this rating schedule updating, overhaul as a project instead of a program? Ms. Curda. I am not sure I understood your question. Ms. Radewagen. Does GAO believe that VA is still treating this rating schedule updating, overhaul as a project instead of a program? Ms. Curda. No, they have--they are treating it like a program. They have a program office which they have established. They have staffed it mostly. Those staff have been, you know, developing, promulgating the regulations to provide the medical updates. They have also been working on the earnings loss studies. Ms. Radewagen. How does the schedule influence the claims processing workload? Do you believe that the lack of updates is causing issues within VBA when it comes to claims processing? Ms. Curda. No, I do not think it really affects the claims processing. You know, down the road, if they change the regulations, it will have an impact. They will have to make updates to a lot of the training and all the inputs that go into the process so that it is up to date and in line with the regulations. I think the impact is more along the lines of the equity issues we have been discussing today, where outdated information might lead some veterans to be overcompensated and others to be undercompensated. I mean, if you are just strictly on an earnings loss basis. Ms. Radewagen. Yes. Mr. Armour, when researchers evaluate the impact of veterans' benefits, what challenges exist in isolating the effects of a single benefit when many veterans are accessing multiple programs at the same time? Mr. Armour. There is a lot of challenges with that. That is actually a fundamental concern here, is that we do not have a sense of why some veterans access certain programs at different times and thus the impacts that those program--participation in those programs has. It is very difficult to tease apart for these earnings losses. You know, was it vocational rehabilitation, the Veterans Readiness and Employment (VR&E) services that went into it? Was it kind of the access to VA healthcare being priority group 1 through 3 that had an impact or is it just fundamentally the health condition itself improved? These are all things that are from the data alone are quite challenging because we just do not have an evidence base on the impacts of these programs or also like how benefits themselves sort into using them. Yes, so I guess I would leave it at that. Ms. Radewagen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back the balance of my time. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, ma'am. Dr. Dexter, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Dexter. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you both, our ranking member as well as you, for your leadership in this. I think this is a really important topic and I am grateful for this today. I appreciate the committee being engaged and bipartisan as well. This is unique in Congress to have folks who are aligned, so thanks. To our witnesses, thank you, also, for your service as well as being here today. As a physician, I strongly believe that disability rating schedules must be data-driven, medically sound, comprehensive, and centered on veterans' lived experiences, so certainly need to include women in those studies as well as many other conditions. I will just share, as a medical student and then as a medical resident in the early 2000's, 30 years after the Vietnam War, I cared for patients in the VA system with complex and poorly understood symptoms. Over time, research made clear that many of these conditions were linked to Agent Orange exposure, something that many of the veterans expressed suspicion of, but felt very, we will say, gaslit these days. We were not saying that then, but not trusted. The frustration, the betrayal, the despair I saw so many veterans experience left an impression. It also showed how long it can take for science to catch up to exposure impacts and why ongoing monitoring and research are essential. As a pulmonologist, the lungs in particular are uniquely vulnerable. They are the only organ continuously exposed to the outside world without any protective barrier unless we put something on. Toxic exposures are constantly evolving, as we know on this committee, which means our understanding of their long-term health impacts must evolve as well. First for Mr. Armour, you noted--or Dr. Armour, sorry, you noted that the last VA Commission's RAND studies were conducted more than 20 years ago before much of our current understanding of toxic exposure, PTSD, and traumatic brain injury were available. From your perspective, what are the most important next steps to ensure veterans are benefiting from the most up- to-date science when disability rating schedules are reviewed and updated? Mr. Armour. I mean, just updating those earnings loss studies and in particular like bringing in the issues that we have observed from other disability programs to address, like those modern techniques. Ms. Dexter. Just to follow up on that, that is sufficient, you think, for the science to catch up as well? Mr. Armour. I will speak as an economist on what the economic angle would be. Ms. Dexter. Okay. Mr. Armour. I think that would check that box, but I am not a physician. Ms. Dexter. No, of course. Obviously, it is an unfair question for many of you. I will just state that we need to have ongoing evaluation and iterative evaluation of our medical information in the same way that I hear you arguing for economic information. The second question, I am proud that my bipartisan bill to strengthen the Veterans Readiness and Employment Program, the VR&E Act, with a lot of support from people here passed both the House and Senate, and I am continuing to work to better support VR&E counselors. Mr. Armour, can you speak to the role of rigorous research in evaluating and strengthening VR&E and what this program can tell us about earnings losses associated with service-connected disabilities? Mr. Armour. I can tell you I think there is tremendous potential to learn those things. I think the current state of research on it is such that it is very difficult to identify the causal impact of those services. There are--the VR&E longitudinal study is one sort of study that has been going on for a stretch of time. Again, it is sort of a study that does not use modern methods in comparing people who did get services versus those who did not and the subsequent outcomes. I think that there are ways in which we could--there is a lot of potential to find out for whom it is working and what those impacts are. We just do not have that evidence base right now. Ms. Dexter. Very good. Not good, but obviously you have expressed the need for implementing change to how we collect data. Dr. Hunter, disability rating decisions must be grounded in sound medical evidence. Proposals to lower disability ratings based on whether a condition is treated raise serious concerns for me. Take obstructive sleep apnea as an example. When untreated, it can worsen hypertension, heart failure, and significantly increase risk of heart attack and stroke. Trying to lower ratings to treatment could discourage veterans from seeking care, which puts their health at risk and may ultimately cost more for the VA as well as cost of productive life here for those veterans. Dr. Hunter, from a veteran's perspective, can you speak to the concerns around lowering disability ratings based on treatment status? Dr. Hunter. In addition to what you mentioned about it potentially discouraging veterans from getting care, there is also the very real thing that we need to look at about treatment for veterans who may not live close to VA symptoms. Like, I am out in the West, as are you, and for me, I get all of my care at the VA and I often have to travel 3-1/2 to 5 hours, depending on the weather conditions, to get some specialized care. If we say, well, you are getting care, you are not getting compensation, the other thing that we have to look at is how does that remove people from the workplace? What is the added stress and time and, you know, hardship that is put on it, on an individual? Which is something that needs to be looked at as the total overall compensation. We do not want to say we are correcting one issue and making a bigger problem, which is why these updated studies need to be done. Additionally, what it does not take into effect is the long-term impact in quality of life issues that arise. Even if a condition is considered treated, there still is often a lagging quality of defect of life indicator. I actually encourage the committee to encourage the VA to look at studies coming out of Australia and Canada and Israel where they actually include like verified quality of life measures into their veterans' disability compensation programs that have had results of actually improving workplace outcomes through addressing the fact that there were initial quality of life concerns. Just through the redress payments from those, you end up having much better long-term economic outcomes as well. Ms. Dexter. Thank you. I appreciate your patience. Mr. Luttrell. Yes, ma'am. Mr. Self, you are recognized for 5 minutes, sir. Mr. Self. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Curda, I was very curious that the management of disability compensation claims has been on your high-risk list since 2003. Yet you said that August of 2024, January, February, and June of 2025, you got a lot of input. Can you estimate how much of the advances they have made happened since August of 2024? Just a rough estimate. Ms. Curda. That I cannot tell you much. I would say it is not true that is the first time we have heard from them. We actually have been talking to them pretty frequently since about 2019, but we saw progress more in more recent years. It took a while. We went through a process of deciding, okay, what are the root causes of these issues? VA came up with root causes. They developed an action plan to address those root causes. The first version was more like a list of stuff we have done. It was not a plan. Then they had to go back to the drawing board and come up with a plan that had milestones and goals and, you know, ended up being something we were--we thought was an actionable plan and they had something they could monitor their progress against. It just--it is been a multiyear effort and it has not all been since 2024. Mr. Self. Well, I would ask you what can Congress do to help GAO? Not just in VA, but across the government, you have hundreds and hundreds of reports that have not been acted on by many of the departments. I think Congress ought to be looking at GAO, how we help you to get things implemented. Now, let us go back to your five criteria for removing them from the GAO high-risk list. They have met leadership commitment, action plan, and monitoring, less so in capacity, which is basically resources. It is not capacity, it is resources, and demonstrated progress. We have got a saying in Texas, when you look at the three that they have met, they are still fixing to do something. Ms. Curda. Yes. Mr. Self. They have not done--I mean, logistics is everything. If they have not provided the resources for the capacity to do it, then they are not going to demonstrate progress. I think this is very telling chart that you have given us, that they really need to do something now that they have made the commitment, apparently. Then, Dr. Armour, you talked about individual versus average justice. You spent a lot of time on that with the Social Security. Now, Social Security Administration supposedly has outdated computers, old coding, and yet you basically said that the Social Security Administration does a far better job individualizing plans. Can you kind of talk to that? Mr. Armour. I will say historically, Social Security has been very welcoming to the research community in allowing us to conduct research on how the disability determination process works and at sort of which stage. They do contract with--they contract with states to actually administer the first stage of it. For each kind of level of that. They have shared a lot of their earnings data, their benefit data, and we have provided over the years a lot of strong results on kind of the--every stage of their determination process, sort of how it works. That has allowed them to make various policy decisions to provide that feedback back to that determination process. They have also engaged in a lot of National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine panels to update their own listings. Mr. Self. Well, that is not really my question because you get a very individualized plan from Social Security Administration. These are your earnings, this is your disability. This is--I mean, it is pretty detailed and it is individualized. Yet you say that VA uses an average justice sort of model. Yet we spend a lot of time individually, and part of that is the problem. We have 66 percent of claims have errors and 44 percent of all--I have forgotten the data, but, I mean, we have a tremendous error rating. Why is that if we are using average justice as opposed to individualized? It looks to us as though we spend a lot of time with the individual. Can you explain that? Mr. Armour. I can speak to how Social Security does this-- -- Mr. Self. All right. Mr. Armour [continuing]. and how they separate the determination process into two steps. One is a listing of impairments. These are conditions that are sort of severe enough that through medical evidence alone can determine that there is a disability. There is that. They have an all or nothing determination as well, is another thing that makes that makes Social Security a little clearer. Then if there is not that listing of that level of severity, then it is an individualized assessment that they have, and it is a residual--it is trying to estimate functional capacity at that individual level. They have done a, you know, spelling things out for the things that can be easily spelled out and then having an individual assessment where they see people's earnings leading up to it. You know, they have physicians comment not just on the medical component, but on the functional capacity component, and then they have a lot of oversight of that particular process. They have split apart that decision instead of trying to schedule everything. Mr. Self. Thank you very much. I think that is something we might do a deeper dive on. Chairman, I yield back. Mr. Luttrell. Thank you, Mr. Self. Go ahead. Mr. McGarvey. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just want a couple of quick follow-up questions. Ms. Curda, earlier I asked VA if they would commit to sharing their methodology with you. Would you be receptive to that? Ms. Curda. Absolutely. Mr. McGarvey. Perfect. Beyond sharing methods and data, is there anything more that you would ask the VA to better provide oversight, accountability, and quality assurance in this rating schedule? Ms. Curda. Just quicker turnarounds on things. When we ask for information, just instead of having to wait a long time for clearances and stuff, you know, just get it to us. If it exists, they should be able to provide it. Mr. McGarvey. Thank you. One common theme between the first panel and between you all seem to be these silos of information. These silos are terrible things that I think are hurting our veterans. They are holding information and keeping it from people who need it when it should be shared, it should be transparent. Dr. Armour, you talked a little bit about this and we seem to be dealing with several information gaps, in part caused by some of these silos, which leads to nonexistent research, out- of-date data sets. What other sorts of basic research need to happen and does it make sense to have that before people start talking about radically changing the VA compensation system? Mr. Armour. I think given the state of knowledge on the economic consequences of VA benefits, yes, we just do not have a lot of publicly available research on, right, today's veterans and today's system. I think, yes, kind of more research. I particular, I think it is not wildly complicated. I think it is sharing the existing data that Social Security has that the VBA, the VHA has, together could provide if that were more widely available, if more research could be conducted on that in a way in which there is transparency and comment so that modern techniques could be used. I think that would answer a lot of questions very quickly, again, if things moved. Mr. McGarvey. Transparency and sharing of information, I like it. Mr. Chairman, I yield back to you. Mr. Luttrell. Mr. McGarvey, I have--since my time in academia to the time I am sitting next to you today, trying to convince--I do not care which institute of higher learning you are talking about and that famous catchphrase of silos, how do you sew the seams between the two? Who will have the willingness to open--like in my personal opinion, the VA should be the premier institute of research on the planet, amount of information that is inside of the VA system. They have always been, since I have had the opportunity to work alongside the VA or with the VA, very protective of us, the veteran community. That information is some of the most cherished data on the planet. Everyone is knocking on the door saying, please let us engage with you to share this information so we can move any side, any kind of information forward. VA has always been very reluctant of that because who is going to fall on the sword? Who is going to take responsibility if there is a breach and the information is gone or lost or taken or worst case scenario? Conversations on the committee and with secretaries, deputy secretary, who you are talking to, and this kind of goes to what you are talking about, Dr. Hunter and Mr. Armour, is, yes, if other institutions, whether that is VSO or any institute of higher learning, had the opportunity to do that, where would we be now? I have been having this conversation for 12, 15 years, so I can only imagine how long you guys have been having it. I speak to the broader research base. You guys look like you are in your 20's. How do we break that down? We do. It is a fair question. I can understand and I really appreciate where we are in the protection mechanism, especially in the branches of artificial intelligence, machine learning, and the bad actors that are pushing that out to take from us that we cannot defend against. As we incorporate machine learning language models into this data to find these answers, at what point, this is a fair question to ask, at what point do we find the answers to solve the issues of the brain? If we have the ability to get rid of sleep apnea or tinnitus or the varying degrees of heart disease and exposures from being in combat, where do we sit then? Do we ask the veterans, like, hey, we are going to give you this and everything is going to be okay? Or do we grandfather it in and we move forward into the next generation? These are discussions we are going to have to have. You would be pleasantly surprised how challenging those discussions are going to be. It lends itself to what Mr. Self was saying, is that what point do we say, hey, look, we can fix these things? How do we engage with the veterans so they will receive it? How does the VA implement it? Then how do we move forward to make sure that we do not talk about 1945 infrastructure, which I still find moderately entertaining? I will never say we are moving fast enough because of all the veterans in my district that walk up to me and say we are not. I am listening. As a veteran myself, I have that same response. I do understand how complicated the VA system is just from this side. I have never actually been inside the VA, but having offline afterschool conversations of how challenging it could be, it is. I just hope and pray every single day they keep moving forward. We will do everything that we can on this committee to make sure that they have what they need. As problem sets continue to increase and it seems like we always have to talk about dollar bills. Well, I am going to be quite honest. You know what? Dollar bills is something that is extremely hard to find even in the VA considering how far in debt we are as a country. We beg, borrow, and steal and kick a lot of butt to get the money for our veterans because we would not be sitting there having this conversation if it was not for you all. We are willing to do that, but we make sure we have to do it right. It has to be done right. I want to thank all of our witnesses for joining us today to discuss how the Department can address the longstanding delays in updating the rating schedule and, more importantly, how we ensure this does not remain a recurring problem for the future and for our veterans. When the rating schedule is outdated or applied inconsistently, it just creates confusion, frustration, and delay. That is something that we do not want. Updating the system is necessary. I am excited about the opportunity. This will be closed up and we will complete this at the summer of this year. This committee will be on standby to see if that actually happens. Ranking Member, do you have closing remarks? We good to go? Mr. McGarvey. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Luttrell. Yep. I ask unanimous consent that all members may have 5 legislative days to revise and extend their remarks and include extraneous material. Without objection, so ordered. We are adjourned. [Whereupon, at 4 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= A P P E N D I X ======================================================================= Prepared Statements of Witnesses ---------- Prepared Statement of Nina Tann Good afternoon, Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, and distinguished Members of the Subcommittee. I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss the Department of Veterans Affairs' (VA) efforts to modernize disability benefits. Joining me today is Dr. Ulia Sokol, a Medical Officer with the Veterans Benefits Administration. For disability compensation or pension purposes, a Veteran's disabilities are evaluated using the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities (VASRD), also known as the ``rating schedule.'' The statute giving VA authority to establish and maintain the rating schedule, 38 U.S.C. section 1155, states: ``The Secretary shall adopt and apply a schedule of ratings of reductions in earning capacity from specific injuries or combination of injuries. The ratings shall be based, as far as practicable, upon the average impairments of earning capacity resulting from such injuries in civil occupations...The Secretary shall from time to time readjust this schedule of ratings in accordance with experience.'' VA is committed to updating its disability compensation rating criteria to accurately reflect medical science, advancements and improvements in technology, and current terminology. These updates allow VA to ensure its disability evaluations accurately compensate Veterans based on average impairments in earning capacity. While VA has made numerous changes to the VASRD over time,\1\ it has not completed a holistic and comprehensive update since 1945, despite notable progress during that time period. In 2003, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) deemed VA's disability program high-risk because VA had not systematically updated the VASRD. In response, VA developed a Modernization Plan in 2009 with the goal of comprehensively updating all 15 body systems of the VASRD. VA established workgroups that included medical and VA policy subject matter experts. VA used the groups' analyses of established medical research to begin the rulemaking process, which involves drafting and publishing a proposed and final rule for each body system. To date, VA has completed updates on 11 of the 15 body systems. Specifically, VA completed: Dental and Oral Conditions in Fiscal Year (FY) 2017; Endocrine, Gynecological Conditions and Disorders of the Breast, Organs of Special Sense (Eyes), and Skin in Fiscal Year 2018; Hematologic and Lymphatic and Infectious Diseases, Immune Disorders, and Nutritional Deficiencies in Fiscal Year 2019; Musculoskeletal, Cardiovascular, and Genitourinary in Fiscal Year 2021; and Digestive in Fiscal Year 2024. Updates made to the VASRD are generally applied prospectively and therefore, do not impact current beneficiaries in receipt of disability compensation. In circumstances where a change to the rating schedule lowers the rating assigned to a particular disability, Veterans enjoy numerous protections. Most notable of these protections is that a readjustment in the rating schedule cannot cause a rating in effect at the time of the change to be reduced unless an improvement in the Veteran's disability is shown to have occurred. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Genitourinary, effective 02/17/1994. Dental/Oral, effective 02/ 17/1994. Gynecological Conditions/Breast Disorders, effective 05/22/ 1995. Hemic and Lymphatic, effective 10/23/1995. Endocrine, effective 06/06/1996. Infectious Diseases, effective 08/30/1996. Respiratory, effective 10/07/1996. Mental Disorders, effective 11/07/1996. Muscle Injuries, effective 07/03/1997. Cardiovascular System, effective 01/12/ 1998. Ear, effective 05/11/1999. Skin, effective 08/30/2002. Eye, effective 11/10/2008. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- VA published proposed rules for the remaining four body systems, Mental Disorders (AQ82), Respiratory, and Ear (AQ72) in Fiscal Year 2022 and Neurological Conditions and Convulsive Disorders (AQ73) in Fiscal Year 2025. VA anticipates publishing the final rules for all four body systems in three rulemakings by the end of Fiscal Year 2026, which will complete the first holistic and comprehensive update since 1945. In 2019, VA established the VASRD Program Management Office with a mission of revising the VASRD through rulemaking--body system by body system, in staggered cycles of recurring reviews, in response to GAO's high-risk recommendations. This iterative process ensures continuing alignment of the VASRD evaluation criteria with medical, scientific, and technological advancements. As with the initial iteration, VA will apply lessons learned from previous efforts and begin future iterations by establishing workgroups prior to developing proposed and final rules, which undergo a thorough medical, legal, and policy review prior to publication in the Federal Register. The rulemaking process generally takes 2 to 5 years to complete but can take longer due to the length and medical complexity of the VASRD updates. Updates to the VASRD require coordination to implement required claims processing system changes and to provide training and guidance to clinicians on disability benefits questionnaires and to claims processors charged with correctly applying current disability evaluation criteria. Following the completion of the first holistic and comprehensive update to the VASRD, VA plans to continue updating the VASRD with the evolution of medical science and treatment modalities. While VA aims to update the rating schedule to simplify the claims process for Veterans and promote a fair and efficient process, VA will also standardize rating terminology and address contemporary claims processing issues to assist claims processors charged with delivering fair, efficient, and timely benefits decisions to Veterans. In closing, VA remains committed to modernizing disability benefits by making continuous updates to the VASRD. We thank the Committee for your continued support of programs that serve the Nation's Veterans and look forward to working together to further enhance delivery of benefits and services to Veterans. Mr. Chairman, this concludes my statement. We look forward to answering any questions you may have. Prepared Statement of Elizabeth Curda [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Prepared Statement of Philip Armour [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Prepared Statement of Kyleanne Hunter [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Statements for the Record ---------- Prepared Statement of Disabled American Veterans Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey and members of the Subcommittee: On behalf of DAV (Disabled American Veterans) and our nearly 1 million members, I am pleased to offer this statement outlining our views of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) disability compensation schedule of rating disabilities (VASRD) and how well it fulfills the purposes for which it was created. As you know, DAV is a congressionally chartered, VA-accredited, nonprofit veterans service organization (VSO) with nearly a million members, all of whom are wartime service-disabled veterans. We are dedicated to a single purpose: empowering veterans to lead high-quality lives with respect and dignity. To fulfill DAV's service mission assisting veterans, their families, caregivers and survivors seeking benefits earned as a result of their military service, we have over 4,200 chapter, department, transition and national service officers (NSO) nationwide; including DAV accredited county veterans service officers. Today there are over 1.1 million veterans and their survivors who have chosen DAV to be their representative before the VA and last year we helped them file over 560,000 claims for benefits to the Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA), taking over 3.1 million actions to support them. This assistance, like all of DAV's charitable services, was provided at no charge to veterans and their families, and DAV receives no compensation of any kind from the government for providing these services. Our comments are informed by the collective experience and expertise of our benefits experts. The Subcommittee's hearing comes in the wake of a series of outrageously misleading and highly inaccurate stories that The Washington Post published last fall. Frankly, DAV was shocked and disgusted to read the Post stories and deeply disappointed with certain so-called veterans advocates who have been repeating and amplifying these falsehoods. To assess how well the VASRD has served and can continue to serve as an instrument to provide justice and compensation to veterans injured, disabled, and made ill from their service, it is necessary to first debunk several myths about VA disability compensation. For example, the Post alleged that disabled veterans are ``swamping'' the VA with ``false'', ``fraudulent'' and ``dubious'' disability claims for injuries and illnesses because the Post considers them illegitimate. Nothing could be farther from the truth. According to the VA Office of Inspector General, there have been fewer than 200 fraud convictions annually in recent years. With VBA processing almost 3 million claims in the most recent fiscal year, that equates to a fraud rate of less than 1/100th of 1 percent. To justify their conclusion that VA is ``swamped'' with illegitimate claims, the Post argued that common claims for conditions such as depression, PTSD, hypertension, diabetes, eczema, tinnitus, and pain were ``dubious'' and ``exaggeration''. With veteran suicide still slowly rising, it is outrageous to assert that depression and PTSD are not real disabilities, just as it is absurd to argue that hypertension and diabetes are exaggerations. Moreover, severe eczema, tinnitus and pain can be highly disruptive and disabling to a veterans life. The Post also advanced the myth that ``Congress and VA have made it easier to cheat and take advantage of the system,'' referring to the Sergeant First Class Heath Robinson Honoring our Promise to Address Comprehensive Toxics (PACT) Act of 2022 (P.L. 117-168) and the Veterans Appeals Improvement and Modernization Act (AMA) (P.L. 115-55). These landmark laws were expressly designed by Congress to make it easier for veterans to receive earned benefits because millions of them have faced unnecessary obstacles that delayed or too often denied their legitimate claims for benefits. It is a gross mischaracterization to imply that these laws made it easier for criminal veterans to steal taxpayer dollars, rather than recognize how the laws have fundamentally improved the ability of millions of veterans to receive long overdue justice and compensation. Another misunderstanding the Post and others continue to promote is that VA disability compensation should only go to veterans unable to work. According to the Post story, ``The current [VA] disability program was designed 80 years ago to provide a safety net for unemployable [emphasis added] veterans wounded or injured during World War II.'' That statement demonstrates ignorance about the history and purpose of VA's disability compensation system, how it has evolved over the years, and how it operates today. It is important to recognize that the VA disability compensation system is fundamentally different than Social Security Disability Insurance and workmen's compensation programs that are only concerned with a person's ability to work. This is because military service is a uniquely dangerous type of work for the men and women who wear the uniform. Further, unlike other hazardous occupations, service members are not able to quit their jobs whenever they choose, since they are under orders. They are also not able to sue the Federal Government if they are injured, regardless of the circumstances, due to the Feres Doctrine\1\. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Feres v. United States, 340 U.S. 135 (1950) --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The VA disability compensation was not created only to assist ``unemployable'', veterans, nor was it designed to compensate for veterans' lost earnings, a common misunderstanding. Instead, beginning after World War I, Congress created and over the course of many years evolved a system centered on providing compensation to disabled veterans based on ``...the average impairments in earnings capacity...'', a legal phrase that may sound like economic loss, but in reality, measures functional loss. Under this standard, a blind or paralyzed veteran who through perseverance is able to overcome their disabilities and work is still recognized as having suffered a loss of functional capacity and deserving of compensation. The fact that they have been able to overcome their disability does not alleviate our Nation's obligation to compensate them for the price they paid and will continue to pay for the rest of their lives. For these reasons, VA disability compensation uses an ``average person'' standard rather than an ``individual'' one that would require VA to evaluate the unique characteristics and circumstances of each of the millions of veterans who are wounded, injured, or made ill in service. Creating such a system based on each individual veteran's actual loss of earnings would not only be impractical - since most service members leaving the military have never had a full-time civilian job - but would also be dramatically more complicated, time- consuming, and expensive to implement. What this also means in practice is that disabled veterans are strongly incentivized to seek meaningful work since doing so will not result in a reduction in their disability compensation. In fact, this is one of the most important but often overlooked strengths of the current VA disability compensation system: disabled veterans are incentivized to continually improve their health and well- being in order to pursue meaningful employment and entrepreneurship. The Post apparently believes that even severely disabled veterans - those who have lost limbs, are blind or paralyzed - only merit disability compensation when they are unable to work. This view fails to recognize all the time and effort it may take for these men and women to overcome such disabilities, the impact on the families and the other parts of their lives, including how it often shortens their lives. Providing disability compensation is just one way that our government helps to keep the promise to the men and women who served. Another common myth is the false belief that VA's disability rating system, and specifically the VASRD, has not been updated or modernized since 1945. While there was a major overhaul of the rating schedule following World War II, particularly to add new psychological conditions, there have been literally hundreds of changes and updates to the VASRD since then, as can be seen in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Appendix A to Subpart B of Part 4. More recently, since September 2017, VA has comprehensively reviewed and updated the rating schedule for at least eight of the 15 body systems, and is actively working on the others. Mr. Chairman, almost two decades ago, after Congress created the Veterans Disability Benefits Commission to explore whether major changes were needed to VA's benefit programs, one of my DAV predecessors testified that the disability compensation system was: ``...fundamentally sound and the most practical approach to the complex task of fairly compensating a large number of veterans for whom the effect of disability is as diverse as the demographic and socioeconomic characteristics of the members of the military force and the citizens of our Nation from which those members come.'' \2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ Testimony of Rick Surratt, DAV Deputy National Legislative Director, before the Committee on Medical Evaluation of Veterans for Disability Compensation of the Institute of Medicine, July 7, 2006. This statement echoes a famous quote attributed to Winston Churchill, who observed that, ``democracy is the worst form of government except for all those other forms that have been tried...'' While the VA rating system and the VASRD is not perfect, DAV continues to believe that is the most effective and efficient way to fairly and equitably compensate veterans for the disabilities, injuries, and illnesses they have suffered in service to the Nation. We also believe that some of the questions being raised about whether the VA disability compensation system is properly structured are the result of persistent problems with the claims processing system. If veterans were able to receive fast, accurate, and transparent decisions on their claims for benefits, confidence in the system could be significantly improved. To help accomplish that, DAV offers the following recommendations to make the claims processing system work better for veterans. Allow veterans to file claims by phone VA allows a veteran to submit an Intent to File (ITF) form by phone, but not a formal claim, such as for an increased evaluation or secondary condition. We believe a veteran should be able to contact the VA by phone and file a claim for any condition at any time, just as they can for an ITF. Amend VA's policy on incorrect forms Currently, the VA treats claims filed on an incorrect form merely as a request for a claims application, which can result in a veteran receiving a delayed effective date and potential loss of tens of thousands of dollars in benefits. To remedy this situation, VA should accept any filing made by a veteran for benefits as a clear statement of the veteran's ``intent to file'' a claim and protect that effective date. Allow veterans to certify their symptom statements during examinations When veterans receive VA disability examinations, they are often required to describe symptoms of conditions they are claiming to be used in making a rating decision. However, when they receive their claims decisions, many times the symptoms they reported during the exam are different from what was recorded by the examiner. To alleviate this problem, VA should add a step in the exam process that allows veterans to review and certify that the symptoms they reported have been accurately recorded. Strengthen presumptive decision-making processes for toxic exposure claims Presumptive service connection is used to improve the process and outcomes for veterans filing benefit claims related primarily to military toxic exposures and environmental hazards. The historic PACT Act created new presumptives for burn pits and other airborne hazards, however, it did not cover all affected veterans and all toxic substances. The DAV and MOAA report, Ending the Wait for Toxic-Exposed Veterans, includes a number of recommendations to build on the PACT Act and create a more effective presumptive decision-making process to improve the accuracy and timeliness of toxic-exposed veterans claims for disability compensation. Optimize the use of technology, particularly AI In order to improve both productivity and accuracy, VBA must continue to maximize and optimize the use of advanced technology, including artificial intelligence (AI), which can significantly increase processing speed and reduce errors. However, its application must be carefully implemented and continuously monitored to ensure essential expertise and decision-making authority is retained by human employees. Ensure VA has the resources to improve accuracy and timeliness of claims Due to the enactment of the PACT Act in August 2022, along with expanded outreach efforts to veterans in crisis or at risk of suicide, VBA has seen a tremendous influx of new benefit claims and a larger claims backlog. Thanks to staffing increases in 2023 and 2024, the rising backlog was stemmed early in 2025 and has since declined. However, we urge the Committee to closely monitor staffing levels at VBA, and particularly VA's 30,000 FTE force reduction last year, to ensure there are adequate resources to process veterans claims quickly and accurately. Mr. Chairman, we appreciate the Committee's interest in reviewing the VA rating schedule and how well it serves disabled veterans. While it is not perfect, we believe it is a proven and reliable methodology to fairly compensate the men and women who have served, suffered, and sacrificed for the country. We look forward to working with the Committee and VA to continually review, and when appropriate, update the VASRD and other aspects of VA's disability compensation to keep the promise to the men and women who served. Prepared Statement of Berry Law [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Prepared Statement of Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, and members of the subcommittee, on behalf of the men and women of the Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States (VFW) and its Auxiliary, thank you for the opportunity to testify on the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) ongoing modernization of the Veterans Affairs Schedule for Rating Disabilities (VASRD), which is a critical component of VA's disability compensation system. The VFW considers this review as essential to ensuring the accuracy of disability compensation ratings while also providing equitable financial relief to veterans whose service-connected injuries or illnesses have caused, or may cause, undue economic hardship. As we begin this most important discussion publicly, we must note no witnesses appearing before the subcommittee for this hearing represent national VA-accredited organizations that routinely interact with VA and the rating schedule on behalf of claimants. Notably absent are organizations such as the VFW, Disabled American Veterans, the American Legion, the National Association of County Veterans Service Officers, any accredited agents or attorneys, or their representative trade associations that collectively hold power of attorney for millions of VA beneficiaries, and possess decades of direct, practical experience navigating the complexities and nuance of the VASRD in real-world adjudication. Moreover, anyone who is accredited through VA has a regulatory requirement under 38 CFR Part 14 to understand the intricacies of the VASRD. Without witnesses who routinely train on and apply the VASRD for claimants seeking benefits, this hearing risks trusting academic or theoretical assessments rather than current, veteran-centered perspectives grounded in daily practice. This may unintentionally shape the subcommittee's understanding of the VASRD in ways that do not fully reflect its operational realities. The VFW is particularly concerned that mischaracterizations or misunderstandings about the VASRD may go unchallenged, including assertions that it is inherently flawed due to its perceived age, that the combined ratings table philosophy is incoherent, or that disability compensation should be tied to employability. These arguments, while often presented as justification for radical reforms, carry serious implications for veterans and their families. Absent testimony from accredited advocates who can explain these principles in practical terms, the VFW believes the subcommittee may accept these positions without sufficient scrutiny or rebuttal from those most familiar with how these standards protect veterans from economic harm resulting from service-connected disabilities. If these issues are not fully and publicly examined in the hearing room, the conversation risks moving in directions that undermine long- standing principles of veteran disability compensation. This compensation is first and foremost recognition of diminished earning capacity caused by injuries or illnesses incurred in service. Likewise, the combined ratings table reflects deliberate calculations intended to balance equity, consistency, and sustainability. These are complex matters that demand input from experienced practitioners who represent veterans every day, not just abstract policy discussions. For these reasons, we believe the subcommittee has a responsibility to convene an additional future hearing that includes testimony from accredited Veterans Service Organizations, agents, and attorneys with experience applying the VASRD on behalf of claimants. Committee members deserve to hear directly from those who understand the downstream consequences of proposed changes. Similarly, we recognize that our perspective is not the only perspective on this matter, and we invite public dialog and scrutiny of our perspective from members of the subcommittee to reach the best possible outcome for our veterans. Veterans deserve nothing less than a complete, balanced, and fully informed record before the subcommittee contemplates any legislative reforms to this critical system. The current VA disability rating framework has been in existence since April 1, 1945. For more than 80 years, this framework has undergone continued modernization to ensure veterans receive fair and accurate compensation based on current medical science and labor market realities. The basis of the current system is centered on the ``whole person'' formula, establishing a mathematical calculation that assesses each disability as independent of one another. This structure works hand in hand with a veteran's ``average impairment'' and the claimant's current disability picture. Previous to this implementation, a veteran who was fortunate enough to be granted a disability rating received payments based on ``occupational variants'' that were grounded in the veteran's pre-war occupation. The current structure offers a more objective evaluation based on the ``average impairment of earnings capacity'' more reflective of the typical person in civil occupations. The justification for this structure is grounded in tort law, as the VFW has noted in its recent discussions over The Washington Post's misrepresentation of the current VA disability system. This fact was recently reinforced in a Military.com editorial by contributor and Marine Corps veteran Haley Fuller, reminding readers that service-connected disability payments ``were not designed as a safety net for those unable to function in civilian life. They were designed as a liability mechanism.'' Any deliberation on changes to the VASRD must respect this legal fact. Proposals like eliminating compensation for so-called minor disabilities or means testing the receipt of compensation must be stopped before ever coming before Congress. The VFW invites discussion with the subcommittee on these principles to ensure that there is consensus that ``average impairment'' and ``lost earning potential'' mean that veterans drawing service-connected compensation can both work and thrive financially, but that these factors do not absolve the U.S. Government of its responsibility to resolve the tort. Every American who volunteers for military service understands that service is dangerous. Every enlistment contract obligates the service member to upon order report to ``combat or other hazardous situations.'' Understanding this contractual obligation, veterans cannot sue the military for resolution of occupational illnesses or injuries under the well-established Feres doctrine. Eroding this paradigm would compromise the good order and discipline of the military and undermine the willingness of Americans to volunteer for this inherently dangerous profession. This is why the VFW has vocally opposed anyone who whispers the notion of eroding this benefit system, scaling back compensation systems, or radically manipulating the rating schedule. While some view providing benefits to veterans as a sacred obligation, it is in fact much simpler than that. It is fulfilling a contract. Honor the contract. At the time of its implementation, the schedule categorized approximately 1,600 medical conditions into broad body systems. The criteria were heavily designed to evaluate the physical trauma more common to World War II such as shrapnel and gunshot wounds, amputations, and infectious diseases. In the present day, there are more than 1,100 specific diagnostic codes, organized into 15 body systems that may qualify a veteran for disability compensation. This is clearly indicative of the changes in how medicine has advanced, but it also indicates that VA has been receptive to changing with the times. We know that on today's modern battlefield, troops are more likely to survive catastrophic injuries or diseases that may have been fatal in past conflicts. The current rating system is reflective of these advances that have been adjusted as medicine and other technologies continue to evolve. MODERNIZATION The VA's modernization plan is centered on a phased revision of all 15 body systems in the VASRD. This effort involves updating outdated diagnostic criteria, incorporating modern medical terminology, and aligning evaluation criteria with contemporary clinical and functional evidence. Part of this modernization includes Earnings Loss Studies (ELS) that use data from multiple Federal sources to better understand how disabilities impact veterans' earning capacity, which is a critical data source for setting compensation levels. Organizationally, the VFW has asked for updates to any available ELS data on multiple occasions but has yet to receive any useful information. This data is critical to ensure that veterans are fairly compensated for injuries during service that impact their financial well-being. Additionally, this critical information will help show more clearly the long-term effects of illness or injury incurred in service in a way that is often overlooked in the civilian sector, and especially in recent news articles that have painted veterans as undeserving and even criminal. Many veterans who have rightfully been awarded a disability payment end up unemployed or underemployed because of long-term or unseen effects of their service. This is particularly true in veterans who experience the consequences of mental health or traumatic brain injuries. Previous occupations may trigger symptoms or cause disruptions in their daily employment. Employers may not be aware of these injuries and do not understand why the veteran needs to be absent from work for treatment or the side effects of medications. This can result in veterans taking jobs that do not require exposure to loud noises, interactions with the public, or other stressors that may have a negative result. The rating system, whether in its current form or future state, is critical to acknowledge and be sympathetic to the symptoms they may suffer and provide the necessary compensation to make up for lost wages. To date, VA has made measurable but nominal progress. Several body systems, such as digestive, dental, endocrine, gynecological, and others, have recently been revised or updated with new criteria. Updates to the digestive system, which added or refined evaluation criteria for conditions like celiac disease and irritable bowel syndrome, became effective in 2024. Additional proposed updates for respiratory, auditory, and mental disorders are underway, with public commentary periods concluded and rulemaking in progress. Despite these efforts, implementation has been slower than expected and extended far beyond initial timelines. According to the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the comprehensive update has been delayed by lengthy internal reviews and lack of clear metrics. As a result, full completion is now projected for Fiscal Year 2026, far behind VA's original intent. The VFW provided comments to the Federal Register as far back as April 2022 for proposed changes to mental disorders among others. Through the last two Administrations, we have asked for progress reports as to the remaining proposed changes and final rules. We have been consistently told that the regulations are still under review. We are happy to note that over the past 3 years limited progress has taken place. However, it has been inconsistent and, at times, obscure. While VA has published updated criteria for some body systems, major areas still await final rulemaking and implementation. Several proposed changes have been delayed multiple times, leaving veterans and stakeholders uncertain about timing and the potential effects of the proposed changes. This prolonged uncertainty undermines confidence among veterans, family members, and survivors. There are considerable advantages to the modernization plan. Updated criteria reflect contemporary medical understanding, removing archaic language and measurement concepts, and enabling adjudicators to make clearer, more consistent decisions. By continuing to evaluate and incorporate earnings loss data, there will be a closer tie between disability evaluation and real-world economic impact. This can lead to fairer and more equitable compensation among veterans. It will also encourage those who may have shied away from seeking benefits and health care treatment to pursue the benefits their service has earned them. CHALLENGES However, this modernization effort also faces substantial challenges. The slow pace of rulemaking and implementation frustrates veterans who have waited years for meaningful updates. The lack of transparency, clearly defined metrics, and organizational leadership as noted in GAO reports, makes it difficult to assess where bottlenecks persist and how they will be resolved. As VA moves forward with modernizing the rating schedule, it must also continue to invest in its IT infrastructure. This has long been a concern of the VFW and our partner organizations. The constant changing of platforms and systems may be an operational necessity, but it also has unintended consequences. If VA were to complete its review today, it is more than likely that the underlying systems VA depends on to process claims still would not be up to date to manage these vast and complex changes. This will lead to continued delays in benefits and an excess workload. The VFW has long held that we support the use of AI and analytics to assist in the claims development and review process. It has the potential to increase the efficiency of evidence gathering, improve accuracy, and promote consistency in benefit decisions. We agree that changes to the rating schedule and its underlying support system are necessary to support objective review and decision-making. However, we remain steadfast in our position that VA must balance technology and human discernment. An overreliance on underdeveloped technology may lead to poor quality in decisions, especially when considering the unique human factors of each disability claim. While AI is a powerful tool to promote efficiency, the VFW maintains that claims must include human review prior to issuing any final decisions. VA should ensure that regulatory changes and the use of technological platforms enhance the process but do not replace the human element of supporting veterans. CONCLUSION In closing, the modernization of the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities represents a potential vital step toward a more just and contemporary disability compensation system for our Nation's veterans, if it is conducted with the needs of the veteran as its central obligation. While the current plan has yielded some updates and demonstrates a commitment to consistent, evidence-based revisions, its execution has been hampered by delays and management challenges. VA's advisory mechanisms, such as the Advisory Committee on Disability Compensation, provide important stakeholder input, but they too have consistently highlighted the complexity of this reform. These committees are designed to guide periodic review and revision of the VASRD, yet their outputs must be integrated into a larger regulatory process that has proven slow and administratively heavy. The VFW is ready to work with VA and this subcommittee to overcome these persistent obstacles. VA must continue to honor the selfless service of veterans, family members, and survivors. We look forward to working together to ensure equitable benefits for all entitled claimants. The VFW urges VA to accelerate progress, provide clear updates to stakeholders and this subcommittee, establish clear milestones, and maintain transparent communication with veterans and Congress. Chairman Luttrell, Ranking Member McGarvey, this concludes our testimony. We are happy to answer any questions you may have. Information Required by Rule XI2(g)(4) of the House of Representatives Pursuant to Rule XI2(g)(4) of the House of Representatives, the VFW has not received any Federal grants in Fiscal Year 2026, nor has it received any Federal grants in the two previous Fiscal Years. The VFW has not received payments or contracts from any foreign governments in the current year or preceding two calendar years. [all]