Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- GROWING CONSTRAINTS ON LANGUAGE AND ETHNIC IDENTITY IN TODAY'S CHINA [Joint House and Senate Hearing, 117 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] GROWING CONSTRAINTS ON LANGUAGE AND ETHNIC IDENTITY IN TODAY'S CHINA ======================================================================= HEARING before the CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ TUESDAY, APRIL 5, 2022 __________ Printed for the use of the Congressional-Executive Commission on China [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available at www.cecc.gov or www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 47-621 PDF WASHINGTON : 2022 CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA LEGISLATIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS Senate House JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon, Chair JAMES P. McGOVERN, Massachusetts, DIANNE FEINSTEIN, California Co-chair MARCO RUBIO, Florida CHRISTOPHER SMITH, New Jersey JAMES LANKFORD, Oklahoma THOMAS SUOZZI, New York TOM COTTON, Arkansas TOM MALINOWSKI, New Jersey STEVE DAINES, Montana BRIAN MAST, Florida ANGUS KING, Maine VICKY HARTZLER, Missouri JON OSSOFF, Georgia RASHIDA TLAIB, Michigan JENNIFER WEXTON, Virginia MICHELLE STEEL, California EXECUTIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS Not yet appointed Matt Squeri, Staff Director Todd Stein, Deputy Staff Director (ii) C O N T E N T S ---------- Statements Page Opening Statement of Hon. Jeff Merkley, a U.S. Senator from Oregon; Chair, Congressional-Executive Commission on China..... 1 Statement of Hon. James P. McGovern, a U.S. Representative from Massachusetts; Co-chair, Congressional-Executive Commission on China.......................................................... 2 Statement of Gerald Roche, Senior Research Fellow, Department of Politics, Media and Philosophy, La Trobe University............ 4 Statement of Enghebatu Togochog, Director, Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center................................ 6 Statement of Lhadon Tethong, Director, Tibet Action Institute.... 7 Statement of Ayup Abduweli, Uyghur writer and linguist........... 9 APPENDIX Prepared Statements Roche, Gerald.................................................... 30 Togochog, Enghebatu.............................................. 36 Tethong, Lhadon.................................................. 39 Abduweli, Ayup................................................... 42 Merkley, Hon. Jeff............................................... 43 McGovern, Hon. James P........................................... 45 Submissions for the Record List of Uyghur Intellectuals Imprisoned in China from 2016 to the Present, submitted by Ayup Abduweli............................ 46 Article by the Tibet Action Institute, entitled ``Separated from Their Families, Hidden from the World: China's Vast System of Colonial Boarding Schools Inside Tibet,'' submitted by Lhadon Tethong........................................................ 72 CECC Truth in Testimony Disclosure Form.......................... 133 Witness Biographies.............................................. 135 (iii) GROWING CONSTRAINTS ON LANGUAGE AND ETHNIC IDENTITY IN TODAY'S CHINA ---------- TUESDAY, APRIL 5, 2022 Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Washington, DC. The hearing was held from 10:00 a.m. to 11:48 a.m. via videoconference, Senator Jeff Merkley, Chair, Congressional- Executive Commission on China, presiding. Also present: Co-chair James P. McGovern, Senator Jon Ossoff, and Representative Michelle Steel. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JEFF MERKLEY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM OREGON; CHAIR, CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA Chair Merkley. Good morning. Today's hearing of the Congressional-Executive Commission on China entitled ``Growing Constraints on Language and Ethnic Identity in Today's China'' will come to order. Before we turn to the subject of this hearing, I want to acknowledge that this is our first hearing since the publication of the Commission's annual report on human rights conditions and rule of law developments in China. Every year, the rigorously researched and sourced work of the Commission's nonpartisan research staff makes a profound contribution to the understanding of these issues in Congress, the executive branch, the academic and advocacy communities, and elsewhere. And that is certainly true again this year. When the Chinese government seeks to mislead the world about the treatment of Chinese citizens and the government's critics, the fact-based reporting of the CECC Annual Report shines a light and helps document the truth. Increasingly, this work informs and catalyzes meaningful action. The Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act is the latest example in a string of significant laws that grew out of the CECC's reporting. As Congress now works to advance China- focused legislation, it's crucial that it include tangible steps advocated by this Commission on a bipartisan and bicameral basis, such as expanded humanitarian pathways for Hong Kong residents and Uyghurs fleeing Chinese government persecution, as well as the creation of a China Censorship Monitor and Action Group to protect U.S. businesses and individuals from censorship and intimidation. I'd like to thank the Commission's staff--incredible team-- for its tireless, professional, and expert work preparing such a high-quality report. While it's truly a team effort, with significant contributions from everyone on the team, I'd like to especially recognize Megan Fluker, who played an integral role in eight of these annual reports and managed production of the last several before leaving the Commission last fall. So, Megan, I know you're on your next chapter, but we really appreciate your many years of dedicated effort. Some of the most heartbreaking reporting details the genocide being perpetrated against Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, as well as elements of eugenics and population control policies directed at ethnic minorities. These are not the only ways in which the Chinese Communist Party seeks to destroy religious and ethnic minorities. Chinese authorities have engaged in a years-long campaign of sinicization, requiring greater conformity with officially sanctioned interpretations of Chinese culture. One of the most pernicious aspects of this campaign is the targeting of ethnic minorities' language and identity. Under a policy that promises bilingual education, authorities in fact largely replace instruction in ethnic minority languages with instruction in Mandarin Chinese. Meanwhile, only a fraction of the languages spoken or signed in China today receive official recognition and support, threatening the ability and rights of unrecognized language communities to use and develop their languages. These policies break promises made to ethnic minorities under China's constitution, under the Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law, and under international standards such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, and the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. In this hearing we will hear from expert witnesses about the sinicization campaign that runs afoul of these standards for protecting linguistic rights. We'll hear about the recent substantial reduction in the use of Mongolian language instruction and the harsh crackdown on Mongolian culture that followed protests over these policies. We'll hear about insidious and widespread efforts to separate Tibetan children from their parents, placing them in boarding schools to disrupt the intergenerational transmission of mother languages. We'll also hear about the detention and imprisonment that often befalls those who stand up for language, who stand up for cultural rights, including the personal experience of one of our witnesses after he opened a Uyghur language kindergarten. This coercive assimilation erodes language, culture, and identity for ethnic minorities in China. I look forward to today's witnesses helping the Commission better understand the cost to communities of these policies as we work with Uyghurs, Tibetans, Mongolians, and others to protect their cultures from destruction. I'd now like to recognize Congressman McGovern for his opening remarks. STATEMENT OF HON. JAMES P. McGOVERN, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM MASSACHUSETTS; CO-CHAIR, CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA Co-chair McGovern. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for holding this hearing on language and identity in the People's Republic of China. First, I want to join you in welcoming the release of the Commission's Annual Report for 2021 last week. It comprehensively documents the Chinese government's appalling human rights record. And the report took countless hours to research, write, fact-check and publish. I particularly want to praise the Commission's professional staff of researchers for their expertise and skill in producing each annual report. They do amazing work and are a valued resource for this Commission and the entire Congress. Again, these researchers do their work objectively. They check out every single fact. The reporting is impeccably accurate, which makes this report especially powerful. Again, I can't thank them enough. Those of both parties who care about human rights ought to recognize their incredible work. Let me quote from author James Baldwin, in a 1979 essay. He writes, ``Language is a political instrument, means, and proof of power. People evolve a language in order to describe, and thus control, their circumstances, or in order not to be submerged by a reality that they cannot articulate. And, if they cannot articulate it, they are submerged.'' Baldwin was writing in a different context, but his message is one that anthropologists and political scientists confirm, that language is the core of a people's identity. The People's Republic of China is a multilingual society. There are 56 official languages and hundreds more that are not formally recognized by the state. On paper, language is protected under Chinese law. China's constitution gives ethnic minorities the freedom to use and develop their own spoken and written languages and to preserve or reform their own ways and customs. In practice, however, we are witnessing the exact opposite. Government policies appear to promote standard Mandarin at the expense of other languages. This is happening as the Party under Xi Jinping imposes a coercive conformity across all facets of society. This trend provides the context and the central question for this hearing. Is the Chinese government and Party deliberately eroding the language rights of ethnic minorities in a quest for majoritarian political control? And in so doing, isn't the government violating rights guaranteed under China's constitution and law? This Commission has documented protests by Tibetans, Mongolians, and others against restrictions on their own languages. These protests are often suppressed. People are jailed for simply asking that their guaranteed rights be respected. So I look forward to hearing from our witnesses today about the threats to the Mongolian, Tibetan, and Uyghur languages under PRC policies, and what this means for the concept of ethnic autonomy. I also look forward to hearing about the vulnerability of the hundreds of unofficial languages that also deserve protection and preservation. So again, Mr. Chairman, thank you for holding this hearing. I will yield back. Chair Merkley. Thank you very much, Representative McGovern. And I'd now like to introduce our panel of witnesses. Dr. Gerald Roche is an anthropologist who is currently a senior research fellow at La Trobe University, a La Trobe Asia fellow, and a co-chair of the Global Coalition for Language Rights. His work focuses on issues of power, the state, colonialism, and race in Asia. He has researched and written on issues of language, oppression, racism, ethnicity, urbanization, popular music, and community ritual in the region. Mr. Enghebatu Togochog is the director of the Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center, a New York-based human rights organization he established in 2001 dedicated to protecting the rights of Mongolian people in inner Mongolia. He is the chief editor of Southern Mongolia Watch and has testified before the UN Human Rights Council, the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, the UN Forum on Minority Issues, the UN Committee against Torture, and the European Parliament. Ms. Lhadon Tethong is a co-founder and director of the Tibet Action Institute. She served previously as executive director of Students for a Free Tibet and led the campaign to condemn China's rule of Tibet in the lead-up to the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games. Her real-time accounts of her travels through Beijing on her blog, one of the first in the Tibetan world, led to her detention and deportation from China. Mr. Ayup Abduweli is a linguist, poet, and former political prisoner, a proponent of linguistic rights, and an active promoter of Uyghur language education. He opened language schools and kindergartens in Xinjiang, for which he was subjected to repeated interrogation, harassment, and eventually a 15-month detention. After fleeing China with his family in 2015, he founded Uyghur Hjelp to document the Uyghur plight and aid the Uyghur diaspora. We'll now turn to our witnesses for their testimony. Five minutes each, if you can possibly do that, starting with Dr. Roche. STATEMENT OF GERALD ROCHE, SENIOR RESEARCH FELLOW, DEPARTMENT OF POLITICS, MEDIA AND PHILOSOPHY, LA TROBE UNIVERSITY Mr. Roche. Thank you very much. Greetings, everyone, from the unceded lands of the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin nation. Thank you sincerely for this opportunity to testify today. I deeply appreciate the chance to share with you all some insights into the language rights situation for people in China. And I thank the Commission for bringing attention to this important topic. This topic is important because defending language rights ensures dignity, freedom, and equality for all people. And who among us would want to live without any of these? When people are denied language rights, it severs their connection to their family, community, and heritage. It excludes them from political participation. When people are denied language rights in vital services like healthcare, their lives are at risk, and when they are denied language rights in education, their futures are at risk. Millions of people in China today face these challenges due to the state's denial of language rights. This happens primarily in two ways, erasure and suppression. Erasure refers to the state's refusal to acknowledge the existence of most of China's languages by calling them dialects. To put this in perspective, imagine if German, English, and Norwegian were defined as dialects of a single language. Imagine if your government told you what language you speak. How would you feel? In China, erasure means that from the country's 300-or-so languages, only about 56 are recognized as languages--one for each of the country's nationalities. Most people in China speak unrecognized languages, whether they belong to the Han majority or to a minority group. Most people in China are therefore completely denied their language rights. Our research demonstrates the catastrophic impact of this denial in Tibet. Tibetan people in China use about 30 unrecognized languages, not including Tibetan. People who use these unrecognized languages face linguistic barriers everywhere--in school, media, government, healthcare, the legal system and so on. When the government refuses to remove these barriers, people are forced to adapt by changing their language to either Tibetan or Chinese. Meanwhile, recognized languages like Uyghur, Mongolian, and Tibetan are suppressed. Suppression happens through the gradual dilution of the Chinese constitution's language freedoms, and the pervasive underimplementation of protections for minority languages. Suppression also takes place through the encroachment of the national language, Mandarin, into spaces for minority languages--part of a broader plan to universalize Mandarin among the entire population. The cumulative impact of erasure and suppression means that at least half of China's languages are currently losing speakers or signers as they switch to dominant languages. In an open, democratic society, people would be lobbying and protesting to change this unjust system. But in China, particularly under Xi Jinping, civil society has become increasingly repressed domestically and isolated internationally. China's citizens will therefore be denied an unprecedented historic opportunity to defend language rights, namely the United Nations International Decade for Indigenous Languages, which starts this year. China will prevent its citizens from participating in this event because it denies that it has indigenous people, and it denies its colonial history. The goal of this decade is leaving no one behind and no one outside. We have a responsibility to extend this inclusion to people in China, to ensure they are not left out or behind. So here are some suggestions for how we can do this: One, the U.S. must pressure China to clarify whether its citizens are able to identify as indigenous and whether they can participate in the UN Decade. And an ideal time to do this is China's upcoming Universal Periodic Review in the UN Human Rights Council in November 2023. Secondly, China's efforts to isolate its citizens from international civil society need to be countered. We must raise awareness inside China of language rights, and of activities taking place globally during the UN Decade. Third, with specific regard to Tibet, earmarking funding for Tibet's unrecognized languages will make a huge difference. This can be done using funds allocated under the Tibetan Policy Act. Fourth, finally, the U.S. needs to lead by example. The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples should be formally endorsed, and its obligations respected. Failing to do so will enable China to deflect attention from their language rights violations and onto America's. Thank you for listening and I welcome your questions. Chair Merkley. Thank you very much for your testimony. Now we'll turn to Mr. Togochog. STATEMENT OF ENGHEBATU TOGOCHOG, DIRECTOR, SOUTHERN MONGOLIAN HUMAN RIGHTS INFORMATION CENTER Mr. Togochog. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Mr. Co-chair, and distinguished members of the Commission for holding this hearing. My name is Enghebatu Togochog. I'm a Mongolian from Southern Mongolia, also known as Inner Mongolia. What's happening in Southern Mongolia today is what the Mongolians regard as wholesale cultural genocide, aimed at total eradication of Mongolian language, culture, and identity. In 2020, responding to China's new language policy, the Mongolians carried out a massive resistance movement. Three hundred thousand Mongolian students went on a total school strike. The Chinese authorities responded with massive arrests. An estimated 8- to 10,000 protesters have been arrested, detained, imprisoned, and placed under house arrest. Eleven lost their lives in defense of their right to their mother tongue. What followed this heavyhanded crackdown was a full-scale cultural genocide campaign, the scope of which has extended far beyond the simple switch of languages in schools. ``Learn Chinese and become a civilized person,'' has been an official slogan publicly promoting Chinese supremacy. Mongolian language programs have been removed from radio, television, and newspapers, or replaced with a Chinese one. Students are subjected to military-style training and must sing red songs to extol the greatness of China. Teachers are brought to the Communist red base Yan'an to receive patriotic education. To justify the campaign, the Chinese National Congress announced last year that local laws on the right to education in minority languages are unconstitutional. The subjects of Mongolian culture and history have been removed from the curriculum for emphasizing Mongolian ethnic identity. All extracurricular activities for learning Mongolian have been banned. Mongolian traditional arts and performance have been altered to adopt a Chinese style to reflect the superiority of Chinese culture. Mongolian sacred sites have been taken over by Chinese traditional art performers, and Mongolian customs and ritual ceremonies are scorned and mocked. Sculptures, monuments, and buildings with Mongolian characteristics have been taken down. Signs in Mongolian have been removed from schools, buildings, streets, and parks. Mongolian publications are banned, books have been removed from shelves, printing and copy services have been ordered not to provide service or any materials written in Mongolian. Postal and courier services are instructed not to deliver any Mongolian books and publications. Starting in December 2020, a regionwide training program called Training for the Foreign Inculcation of the Chinese Nationality Common Identity was launched. All Mongolian students, teachers, government employees, Party members, and ordinary herders were targeted for the training. A 47-page pamphlet, marked as an internal document, was issued to detail the urgency and goal of the training, and to compel Mongolians to fully accept Chinese identity and Chinese culture. The document also warns Mongolians that the wrong path of narrow nationalism can lead to the return of national separatism. The trainees told us that during the training they had to denounce their narrow nationalism and nationalistic feeling. They had to surrender all of their social contacts and the details of their online activities to the authorities. They were forced to confess their supposed mistakes, including wearing Mongolian clothes and singing Mongolian songs. They had to answer multiple questionnaires designed to assess their ideological improvement. One of the questions, a trainee said, was: How many Chinese friends do you have? Those who answered ``none'' or ``few'' had to go through further training before they were allowed to graduate. Before their release, all trainees signed a paper promising that they would not engage in any activities highlighting Mongolian characteristics or expressing Mongolian nationalistic feeling. And this is what's happening in Southern Mongolia today. Considering these deteriorating conditions--China's determination to erase the Mongolian language, culture, and identity and the lack of support from the international community--I would like to make the following recommendations to the United States Congress: One, conduct further hearings and testimonies to investigate the serious human rights violations in Southern Mongolia, in particular the ongoing cultural genocide. Two, establish a Mongolian language broadcast on Voice of America and/or Radio Free Asia to help Southern Mongolians have access to the free and democratic world. Three, introduce and pass legislation similar to the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act and Tibetan Policy and Support Act to support the 6,000,000 Southern Mongolians in their effort to defend their basic human rights and fundamental freedoms. Thank you. Chair Merkley. Thank you very much for your testimony about the many, many ways that Mongolian language and culture are being impacted. We now turn to Ms. Tethong. STATEMENT OF LHADON TETHONG, DIRECTOR, TIBET ACTION INSTITUTE Ms. Tethong. Thank you, Chairman McGovern, Chairman Merkley, members of the Committee, and CECC staff for this opportunity. As a Tibetan who has been working on the Sino-Tibetan conflict for more than two decades, I can say safely it takes a lot to shock me. But last year, when my colleagues and I began research into reports that Tibetan children were being sent to state-run boarding schools at an alarmingly high rate, we were stunned by what we found. Under the cover of darkness of China's near-total information blackout of Tibet, the Chinese authorities have been constructing a massive colonial boarding school system that threatens the future survival of the Tibetan people and nation. These residential boarding schools are the cornerstone of a broader effort to wipe out Tibetan resistance by eliminating the three pillars of Tibetan identity--language, religion, and way of life. The schools streamline and fast- track this by ripping Tibetan children from their roots, by stealing the language from their tongues, and trying to replace their identity with Chinese identity. In our report we find that at least 800,000 to 900,000 Tibetan children--representing nearly 80 percent of all Tibetan children ages 6 to 18--are now separated from their families and living in colonial boarding schools. And this number does not include 4- and 5-years-olds being made to live in boarding preschools. These children are forbidden from practicing Tibetan Buddhism, they're cut off from authentic Tibetan culture, and they're not allowed to study in their own language. Instead, they're forced to study in Chinese, under mostly Chinese teachers, from textbooks that represent China's history and culture, while completely denying Tibet's own rich and ancient history and culture. On top of this, they're subjected to intense political indoctrination. Most Tibetan parents have no choice but to send their children away to these schools because China has shut down all the village schools and nearly all the alternatives. Parents who try to resist or refuse are threatened, harassed, fined, and face other serious punishment. One person from Tibet described the anguish of these separations for young children: ``I know of children aged four to five who don't want to be separated from their mothers. They are forced to go to boarding schools. In some cases, the children cry for days, sticking to their mother's laps, begging not to be sent away and even refusing to go back.'' My 5-year-old son started kindergarten this year. To think of sending him away at this age to live apart from me for the rest of his school-age life, to think I wouldn't be able to comfort him or protect him day to day is devastating. And to know China's doing this intentionally so that Tibetan children are isolated from the influence of their parents and families is enraging. In the U.S., Canada, and Australia, residential boarding schools for Native American, indigenous, and aboriginal children are finally recognized as horrific and shameful mistakes of the past. Now is seen as the time for inquiry, reparations, and apologies, not as a time when any government would be deliberately implementing this genocidal model, and on such a massive scale. But this is exactly what Beijing is doing. China's colonial boarding schools, together with policies that severely restrict the use of Tibetan language, that seek to hollow out Tibetan Buddhism and end the nomadic way of life, threaten Tibetan existence in every space in Tibet. What's happening in front of our eyes is the annihilation of Tibet as a civilization, as an identity, as a culture. It is cultural genocide. And Tibetans everywhere know it. Just last month, 25-year-old Tsewang Norbu, a famous Tibetan pop star, self-immolated in front of the Potala Palace in Lhasa. He had every reason to live. He was young, successful, college educated. He had a family and resources. His whole life was ahead of him and he gave it all up in the ultimate sacrifice at the most meaningful location and political moment for Tibetans, on the eve of the anniversary of the 1959 Tibetan national uprising. His life and lyrics suggest he did this because he wanted to send a message that no matter what personal success we may achieve, what matters most is our roots, our homeland, our culture, and our freedom to live on our own land and be who we are. Tsewang Norbu's final act illuminates a simple truth that's held strong in Tibet for 70 years under Chinese occupation-- that generation after generation, Tibetans have shown that their love and allegiance is to Tibet, to the mountains, to the grasslands, to our mother tongue, our great sages, and spiritual teachers and leaders, most especially to His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama, and not to China. Because Tibetans are not Chinese. Though Tibetans and Tibet continue to battle courageously against China's onslaught, they can't do it alone. They need people and governments in the free world to step up, and there is so much more that can be done. I think global opposition to Russia's invasion of Ukraine has shown us how much the international community can do. We need to use every tool available to fight these genocidal dictators, because a state that so blatantly flouts international rules and norms, and indeed actively seeks to undermine them, threatens us all. The fate of Tibetans, Uyghurs, Southern Mongolians, Hong Kongers, and Taiwanese affects us all. I'll end my remarks here and save my specific recommendations for the Q&A. Also I'd like to submit our report on China's colonial boarding school system in Tibet for the record. Thank you very much. Chair Merkley. Thank you. Without objection, it will be submitted for the record. Now we'll turn to Mr. Abduweli. STATEMENT OF AYUP ABDUWELI, UYGHUR WRITER AND LINGUIST Mr. Abduweli. Thank you all for giving me this opportunity. Let me start with the historical narrative. After Chinese Communist rule, the Uyghur language faced difficulty--first, the Uyghur alphabet was revised. That meant that after 1949, Uyghurs could not read what their ancestors had written. For example, I cannot read what my grandpa had written in Uyghur. And second, in 1956, the Chinese government changed the Uyghur alphabet to Cyrillic and then we had another period of illiteracy and people could not read after five years--after 1940. In 1962, the Uyghur alphabet changed a third time, to Chinese phonetic Pinyin, like the Latin alphabet. And it was used until 1979. And then in 1982 it changed again. Since 1949, Uyghurs have experienced the alphabet changing four times. That means that we had millions of people becoming illiterate because of this alphabet changing. Since 1982, our alphabet hasn't been changed, but our orthography, our spelling system, changed a lot--five times-- and it gave people a lot of trouble, and you could not communicate with the written language because of this. In 1997, the Uyghur language started to be restricted, and in 2002, the Uyghur language was removed from higher education--from university, community college, and technology college. Uyghur was removed and replaced by Han Chinese in the education system. Because of this, in 2006, Uyghur intellectuals in Urumqi started the campaign to restore the legal rights of Uyghurs. This peaceful campaign ended up with one Uyghur sentenced to 12 years, Memtimin Elyar, and more than 10 Uyghurs were sentenced to different terms. In 2011, I started my mother language campaign. I had my mother language kindergarten and because of this, I was arrested on August 19, 2013. I spent 428 days in a Chinese detention center. And I was questioned, interrogated more than six months, and forced to ``confess'' that my goal in this mother language campaign was to separate from China and build an independent Uyghur country. I was sexually abused and experienced six months of torture. I spent 428 days without sunshine and without an appropriate toilet and without any healthcare. Since 2017, the Chinese policy against Uyghurs has totally worsened. Uyghurs were totally banned from public life. Uyghur textbooks were collected and burned in front of the students, and Uyghur textbook editors were arrested. According to Uyghur Hjelp documentation, about 400 Uyghur writers who participated in editing these Uyghur textbooks got arrested. And 1,000 mother language teachers got arrested. Among them is my friend, Ehmetjan Jume, sentenced to 14 years. And three Uyghur intellectuals were sentenced to life imprisonment, and one was sentenced to death. His name is Sattar Sawut. Second, Han Chinese officials were assigned to every Uyghur family so Uyghurs speak Chinese at home and have their cultural practices monitored. And third, Uyghur kids were displaced from their homes and forced to study at boarding school. According to Adrian Zenz, there are more than 900,000 Uyghur kids in boarding school right now. As we know, up to 3,000,000 Uyghurs are in concentration camps and their kids are in special kids' camps. I met two of them, because they are Turkish citizens, and they were saved by the Turkish government. I met them in Istanbul in December 2011. When I asked, they had forgotten their language in two years. They were arrested in March 2017 and released in December 2019. In two years they totally forgot their mother language. At the time of their arrest, the younger one was four years old. The other one was six years old. In two years they forgot their language 100 percent. And we can imagine that up to 3,000,000 Uyghurs are in concentration camps and their kids are in kids' camp--so-called boarding school. And we can imagine what happened to those kids. Uyghur kids, displaced from their homeland. For example, my niece, Saeda, was displaced from her home and from her homeland. Now she is studying in a Chinese boarding school in a Chinese-majority city, not at home. And Uyghur kids are forced to separate from their family and study and live in boarding kindergarten. According to Adrian Zenz, since 2017, boarding kindergarten in the Uyghur region increased more than 100 times. It's increasing very, very, very quickly. Fifth, Uyghur kids are sent to kindergarten in inland China, not in Uyghur East Turkestan. It's really dangerous and it means that we cannot find where they are in the end because they are submerged in Chinese society. It's really dangerous, especially the kindergarten in Xi'an. We don't know whether they are orphans or not. Maybe their parents are in concentration camps. They're sent to Chinese orphanages. Uyghur kids in kindergarten are not allowed to speak Uyghur. A social media video I received said that the teacher asked the kid's name and the kid said, ``I am not allowed to tell my name in Uyghur. I have to tell my name in Chinese.'' Those kids cannot even tell their name in their mother tongue because of fear. I waited to give this testimony for more than five years. Thank you, everyone, for giving me this opportunity. And I think we need to take urgent action, especially for those innocent kids who are separated from their family, who are separated from their homeland, who are separated from their culture. Thank you. Chair Merkley. Thank you very much for your powerful testimony. The Senate is holding a vote on a required timeline, so I'm going to turn this over to Co-chair Representative McGovern. I hope to be back, but it's a little uncertain. It may be back- to-back votes. I just want to note especially the testimony about the combination of the assault on use of the language and ripping children out of their family's arms to separate them, change the language, change the culture. It's an abomination. And you all have made that very clear today, about the extensive use both in the Uyghur communities and Mongolian communities and Tibetan communities. Thank you. I hope to return, but if not I turn this over to Representative McGovern. Co-chair McGovern. Thank you very much. And I want to thank all the witnesses for your testimony. Let me begin with Mr. Togochog. In your testimony you advocate for the creation of a Mongolian language service through Voice of America and Radio Free Asia. As I understand it, Voice of America has currently, or in the past, broadcast in some 80 languages, but never Mongolian. Can you expand on what a Mongolian VOA service would mean for Southern Mongolians? Mr. Togochog. Yes. Thank you. Thank you for the question. Neither Voice of America nor Radio Free Asia has any Mongolian service at this moment. And I don't think in the past they have ever had it either. So having a Mongolian service would be very helpful for the Southern Mongolians because the Mongolians do not have any channel or any way to communicate with the free and democratic world. Their situation, their conditions, are largely underreported. And so if we have a program, a broadcast service, it will help them to understand what's going on in the free and democratic world, and at the same time also it will allow them to have their voice heard by the international community and expose the human rights violations that are happening in Southern Mongolia, in particular the ongoing cultural genocide that is aiming at the complete erasure of Mongolian language, culture, and identity. Co-chair McGovern. I appreciate that. And that's, I think, a helpful suggestion and it's something we should explore in the upcoming appropriations process. Ms. Tethong, your testimony references the troubling experience in the United States, Canada, and Australia with residential boarding schools for indigenous children. Can you speak to your perspective as a native of Canada on how the Canadian experience can help us view what you report about boarding schools in Tibet in terms of accountability, restitution, and social justice? Ms. Tethong. Thank you. I think it was one of the most disturbing parts of what we were doing when we were researching and writing this report, that a number of us on the team of Tibet actually were Canadian. The unmarked graves of First Nation children were being uncovered in Canada from the residential schools there as we were writing this report, and it was haunting for all of us. It also gave us a great sense of urgency to get this story out. Not that they're exactly the same situation, but that it's happening again in another place in a slightly different way, but the intent is the same. I think for us, you know, the key right now is that people don't know that this is happening, because the Chinese have so effectively blocked information from leaving Tibet. They've scared people from saying what's happening on the ground. And they are hiding what they're doing. But the Chinese government cares what the world thinks, and this is why they have all of these hidden policies in Tibet. It's so that they can avoid international scrutiny. The boarding preschools or kindergartens for 4- and 5-year-olds, they're actively hiding their existence. We know there are preschools and kindergartens that are day schools. And we see those on Chinese state propaganda. But the actual boarding preschools they're actively hiding. We know that the key right now is to expose and condemn directly and openly. We need the U.S. Government to do that. That is the beginning. That's where we start. We need the U.S. Government to work with like-minded governments around the world to put a spotlight on this issue and to say it's unacceptable and that these children need to be returned to their parents and they need to have access to high-quality mother tongue education in their local areas, just like any of us who grew up in free and open societies do, no matter how rural or whatever the challenges may be. I think it's important to note that in China itself the rate of students even in rural areas who are in boarding schools is drastically lower. Tibetans are boarding at five times the rate, in the case of one primary school comparison that we did in central Tibet alone, in what China calls the Tibet Autonomous Region. I think the other thing that we need is to see--you know, the world has collectively condemned residential school policy, the practice of separating children from their parents in order to influence, to change who they are, to erase their culture and identity. And we need to see that the UN speaks out on this, that Michelle Bachelet, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, breaks her silence on Tibet. She hasn't even said ``Tibet'' since 2018, when she took up this mandate. So we need member states, we need the U.S. Government to push for accountability also at the UN. Co-chair McGovern. Thank you. You know, I was on a delegation with Speaker Pelosi, I think it was back in 2015, when the Chinese government actually allowed us to go into Lhasa and tried to micromanage and control every single moment of that visit. But despite all of those efforts, we were amazed and, quite frankly, inspired by Tibetans who approached us to talk about, among other things, the importance of their language, the importance of their culture, the importance of giving their children a future in which the language and culture were a reality. This is their identity. This is who they are. And it was a trip that, on the one hand, was depressing and shocking because of the Chinese government's repressive behavior, but on the other hand, inspiring and motivating because people, at great risk, found ways to communicate with us directly. And, you know, I will never, ever, ever forget it. And thank you for your response. Dr. Roche, many of us assume there is a single Tibetan language, but you testify to the diversity of languages spoken by Tibetans. And I appreciate the map that you provided us. Would a person from Lhasa be able to communicate with a person from the Dalai Lama's hometown of Amdo? Mr. Roche. Yes, thank you very much for that question. Just to answer that part very quickly, it depends on who those people were. There's a great difference between the spoken languages between Lhasa and the far-northern Amdo. If two people met on the street, chances are that they would not be able to communicate. But if they were educated in the common written language, if they had the experience communicating with Tibetans from a wide variety of backgrounds, then they would probably be able to communicate. There's flexibility around that issue. But those are two examples of what linguists call Tibetic languages, which means that they are varieties of Tibetan. There are also about a quarter of a million Tibetans that use languages which are much more different than those--a group of Tibetic languages that are vastly different from each other. Regardless of whether they were literate, regardless of how cosmopolitan they were, regardless of the amount of exposure, and without concerted study, they would not be able to communicate with one another. To give an example that might help, it would be as different as Swedish and Italian, for example. Most of the Tibetans who speak those languages, their communities are quite small, several thousand people among a broader population of over 6,000,000 people. And given the situation that I've described, where the state completely denies language rights in any forum--in education, healthcare, media, governance, etc.--those languages are facing a very serious predicament. In terms of thinking through these issues that we're talking about today, about the impact of the denial of language rights, thinking about the state's goals and their thinking about the program of sinicization, and so on, we can think of these smaller languages spoken by Tibetans as the canary in the coal mine. They point in the direction of where the actions of the state are going for other languages. What we see across all of those languages is people switching away from them. They're no longer transmitting those languages to their children. So, in an expert survey that I did of linguists who work in this area, I asked their assessment of whether those languages would still be spoken in future generations. And the answer was, in almost every case, that they would no longer be, that the children would be switching either to some form of Chinese or some form of Tibetan language. Co-chair McGovern. Yes, and I'm technologically challenged, but for those who are watching this, I mean, this is the map that you provided us [holds up map]. All of these different colors show all the different distinct Tibetan languages and dialects, which I think is fascinating, something that we don't always appreciate, when we're talking about protecting a language. How would an understanding of this linguistic diversity help the U.S. protect the Tibetan language? And you made a recommendation earlier, but maybe you can expand on it--how funding of the Tibetan Policy and Support Act could be used. Mr. Roche. Yes, thank you for that question. These languages face a very intense predicament. The speakers of these languages--also the people who sign them, because we should include Tibetan Sign Language here, as well-- these communities have no support from anywhere. They want to maintain these languages. They--in instances where they can-- create projects to support these languages--educational initiatives, community chances to use the language, and so on. One of the most clear examples of the desire to use these languages was seen when the COVID pandemic broke in Tibet, and no public healthcare information was available to these communities in the languages that they understood best and which they trusted the most, as well. And so that was creating great anxiety and putting those people at risk, so they initiated these community public health information translation projects on their own, without any funding, without any support, and so on. So the recommendation that I make--given that the Tibetan Policy and Support Act in part focuses on the protection of Tibetan language and culture--is the idea that funds could be earmarked specifically for these languages. And that money could be used, for example, to transmit information to those communities about language rights--the fact that they have them; how those language rights are denied. If it were possible to get money to the communities on the ground, to work with them, there are all sorts of projects that could be done to help those communities use their languages, develop them--for example, develop writing systems, recording the languages, helping develop vocabulary to use in new situations. And there are ample examples all around the world of different projects, different methods, for helping to support the language that some of this funding could be used for, and that Tibetan communities inside China could learn from. Co-chair McGovern. Well, thank you. And you know--I know USAID has money for this, and I think maybe we need to work with USAID to find a grantee that could actually do what you're talking about. I have other questions here--I'm not sure if Congresswoman Steel is still on the line. Representative Steel. Yes. Co-chair McGovern. OK. I want to yield to you for your questions. And I'll come back to me. Representative Steel. Thank you, Co-chair McGovern. And thank you very much to all the witnesses. It is alarming and disheartening that the CCP is working to restrict religious freedom and trying to eradicate entire cultures. The CCP is separating children from their parents, home, and community--I can't even imagine it. This is one more outrageous example of racism and troubling human rights violations at the hands of the CCP. Having said that, Ms. Lhadon Tethong--if I pronounce it wrong, I'm sorry--but you mentioned that the private schools run by monasteries and Tibetan communities have been shut down by the CCP. We already heard Mr. Togochog's recommendations of what the United States Congress can do, but what can global leaders do to stop this violation? I tried to let the whole world know during the Olympics what China has been doing, but I didn't get any response from the Olympic corporate sponsors who've been spending billions of dollars. So could you tell us what global leaders have to do to stop this violation? Ms. Tethong. Yes, I think the key is--and we can see this happening more and more--for like-minded governments, global leaders, to work together and to coordinate strategies and approaches in a way that really targets--for example, the case of sanctions. I think this whole area, you know, unlike, say, targeting military or security people, officials, the area of education policy just seems--it's such a different target. But there are Chinese academics and education policy experts who are conceptualizing and they're operationalizing these programs--that are separating nearly a million Tibetan children from their parents, and that are essentially threatening that an entire generation of Tibetans, and those that come from now on, will not speak Tibetan. So they are designing these genocidal policies and overseeing them, and they should be targeted, I think, for sanctions and other things. And governments can coordinate, I believe, to do that in a way that--perhaps, you know, the security officials and the top, top officials aren't so concerned about their international reputation, or their travel, or whatever. But academics are. I mean, that's so much of what it's about--reputation, and your international credibility. And I think this group of people, who are playing key roles in all of this, the rollout and the separation of very young children from their families, they play a key role. And if we want to sort of change behavior and send a very clear message, I think they should absolutely be targeted with sanctions. Representative Steel. Very essential. Thank you very much. So parents, not the CCP, have the right to choose how their child will be educated. That's what we are practicing here; we try to. Why is the CCP so threatened by having a diverse community? Ms. Tethong. Ms. Tethong. I think the key is difference, that because Tibetans are not Chinese, because Uyghurs are not Chinese, Southern Mongolians--we have our distinct histories, our distinct national histories. This is about wiping out resistance to Chinese Communist Party rule. And all of the efforts of the Chinese Communist Party in Tibet over 70 years have failed. All of the violence--you think of their economic, their political, their military power and might, and somehow, Tibetans are still resisting, and a whole new generation of Tibetans that has no memory of a free Tibet, is still fighting. And that's because who we are at our core is not Chinese. When Tibetans are being taught only about Chinese history and culture in this intense nationalistic curriculum, they know that they're not reflected there. Maybe it takes a littler kid some time to figure that out, but in the end, Tibetans know they're not Chinese. And when they leave these schools, or when they go out into the world, they face such incredible racism and discrimination that their instinct, of course, is to turn inward and to ask questions about who they are and where Tibet is in all of this. And so I think this is about wiping out resistance to Chinese Communist Party rule in places where the Party rules with a colonial occupation, where the Chinese government has taken over by force and maintains control by force. And parents' influence needs to be--I guess, they believe--broken. You know, these children, if they're removed from their parents, their families, and their communities, if they can forget who they are, maybe that resistance will end. And I think they're sadly mistaken. Congresswoman Steel. Thank you very much. And for Mr. Abduweli, you know, both my parents fled from North Korean communism during the Korean War, so you know, I've been hearing so much about the Communists. And now I am a proud American immigrant who is living her American dream. I speak Korean and Japanese as my first and second language, and English is my third. It is important to embrace diversity and to respect other cultures. I speak common greetings to my constituents and friends on a daily basis. Why is the CCP creating new language restrictions and engaging in religious persecution? What are they afraid of? Mr. Abduweli. I think it's mainly because Uyghurs keep protecting their language. Especially after July 5th--we had a demonstration in 2009, on July 5th. And after the demonstration, thousands of people got arrested. And after that, the Chinese government changed the policy a little bit and gave some economic benefits to the people. But at that time, I witnessed what happened, and for example, Uyghur books flourished, and Uyghur films flourished, and Uyghur poetry sold very well. Despite this economic benefit, however, Uyghurs were not fooled. Instead, Uyghurs increased in power, because of the economic development and people decided to keep the language alive, keep that language. And they used their money to support it. And when I started my mother language kindergarten, investment was already enough. I had enough investment, and I had enough support. At that time, we had--when we started our campaign online, we had 500,000 followers online to support us. So I think the main reason is because of this power-- because of this power of identity, power of culture. They are afraid of this. Representative Steel. Thank you very much. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Co-chair McGovern. Thank you. I think Chairman Merkley is back. Chair Merkley. I'm back and thank you very much. And I'll apologize in advance if I ask questions that others have already asked, but maybe they're worth reemphasizing. And let me start with the depiction of a strategy by the Chinese government to universalize Mandarin among the entire population of China. Do you all agree--I'll just ask each of you to comment very briefly--do you all agree that getting everyone to speak Mandarin is the ultimate goal of the sinicization campaign that we've all talked about today? Dr. Roche, you want to kick that off? Mr. Roche. Sure. Yes, I think it is. This is the goal--the policy has been in place for a while now. The plan has been set. The targets have been announced and shifted year by year. They target different regions as it progresses, and the aim is to have everyone speaking Mandarin, regardless of the cost to other languages, people's identities, communities, families, etc. Chair Merkley. OK. Does everyone else agree? Maybe just speak very briefly to that, to basically wipe out every other language except Mandarin Chinese, over the course of the next couple of decades? Mr. Togochog. Mr. Togochog. Yes, thank you. Yes, their goal is very clear. The Chinese authorities are stating their goals very publicly. And they are saying all the so-called 55 ethnic minorities must adopt and embrace the Chinese Zhongguo nationality, or Chinese nationality--that's the stated goal. And eliminating language and forcing all those 55 ethnic minorities to speak Chinese is not the only goal. Actually, their ultimate goal is to turn these peoples' identities into the Chinese, or Zhongguo, nationality, identity. Chair Merkley. So, it's both about everyone speaking Mandarin, but the underlying goal is to wipe out the ethnic identity of people across China, basically genocide against dozens and dozens of the diverse cultures of the country. Ms. Tethong, when you look at the strategies being used, including this absolutely horrific separation of small children from their families to boarding schools--I think you said 80 percent of the children are separated, about 800,000 to 900,000 children, if I got those numbers right. So do you see a path in which China, the Chinese government, is seeking to essentially wipe out the Tibetan language within another generation? Ms. Tethong. Yes, absolutely. And I think the focus now on kindergartens or preschoolers, the focus on 4- and 5-year-olds, really shows us that. These children are learning entirely from such a young age, entirely in Chinese, or Mandarin. And they are so young. They're also being taught--their psychological foundation will be sort of trained to think about Chinese culture . . . because they don't live with their parents and their families for the majority of their lives. Even if they're just living five days a week in these schools, the idea is to really change them on the inside, who they are fundamentally, so as to wipe out resistance. Chair Merkley. It's so much more than simply language. Mr. Abduweli, do you also see the Chinese goal being to wipe out the Uyghur language within a generation? Mr. Abduweli. Yes, the Chinese goal is, I think, not only to wipe out the Uyghur language, but also to make Uyghurs become, not modern Chinese, but make them become ancient Chinese. From my documentation, those Uyghur kids in camps, they're forced to recite ancient Chinese texts, not the modern texts, and they force them to wear ancient Chinese clothes, not modern Chinese clothes, and make them recite things not relevant to this modern society. And I think the ultimate goal is, make them more Chinese than ordinary Chinese. Chair Merkley. So Mr. Togochog, you observed that in January of last year--about 15 months ago--Chinese authorities announced that the legal protections for recognized minority languages are unconstitutional. Of course, it's the constitution, Article 4 of the Chinese constitution, that provides for those protections. So, can we essentially say that the Chinese constitution has been invalidated by the Chinese government, and that the protection in Article 4 of the Chinese constitution no longer exists? Mr. Togochog. Well, that's correct. As we all know, China is not a country of the rule of law. So yes, the Chinese constitution is still there. But at the same time, because of the Mongolian--the large-scale protests, they came up with the idea that--actually, the Chinese National Congress announced that all the local laws, including the ethnic minority autonomy laws and some other regulations on the minority languages, in particular the Mongolian language, are unconstitutional. And then they said, these must be changed. So that's their statement. So, the goal is clear. They just use whatever method available to just completely wipe out the Mongolian language. And so in this effort, they even invalidate their own constitution. Chair Merkley. And Mr. Abduweli, my time is running short, so this will be my last question. You note in your testimony that in 2013, there was a movement among Uyghurs to adopt this slogan: If the Chinese constitution protects our language, then it is our turn to protect it. So it's like, OK, hey, the constitution is our protection; let's protect locally--and ensure that Article 4 is followed. But the Chinese reaction was to essentially say, no, the constitution doesn't really--we're throwing that out. So, your effort to seize upon those constitutional protections was, unfortunately, unsuccessful. Is that a fair way to put it? Mr. Abduweli. Yes, that's correct. That's our slogan, and that's my--I tried to follow the law, and I tried to practice my constitutional rights. But in the end, I didn't succeed. Chair Merkley. Well, thank you all very much. This big picture--China has abandoned its constitutional protections; it's wiping out languages. It's not just language; it's trying to wipe out the minority cultures across China, and that's the big picture I want to keep coming back to. Senator Ossoff. Senator Ossoff. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thank you, Congressman McGovern, as well. And to our panelists--I've got to briefly run into another meeting, so I'm going to cut right to the chase, and just ask each of our panelists the following question: Can you please share your analysis of how the CCP's increased repression of ethnic minorities within China fits into its broader long-term strategy for consolidation of political control? Go ahead, Mr. Abduweli. Mr. Abduweli. Could you rephrase your question? I'm sorry. Senator Ossoff. No problem. My question is, how does the continued and increased repression of ethnic minorities by the Chinese Communist Party fit into the CCP's broader long-term political and state strategy? Mr. Abduweli. Yes, in Xi Jinping's speech made in 2014 in Urumqi, he used one very specific term, ``break the root.'' It means break this culture, separate. Implementing this for boarding school, and boarding kindergarten and those things-- implementation of his order to break the root means that those kids have their homes, their homeland, and their culture replaced. Xi Jinping also stressed Zhongguo identity. That's the only identity allowed in China. And that's why the Chinese government had these concentration camps and forced millions of people to speak Chinese in those so-called vocational centers. And third, the Chinese government transferred the Uyghurs from their own homeland to Chinese cities. In 2020 alone, more than 50,000 Uyghurs were transferred to Xinjiang. The ultimate goal is not only to force them to speak Chinese but have them disappear into the Chinese majority of the Chinese mainland. Mr. Togochog. If I may--can I respond to Senator Ossoff's question? What's happening in China is a continuation of what China has been implementing in these three nations. Especially in the Mongolian case, the new policy, new cultural genocide policy, followed by the so-called second-generation bilingual education, is considered by the Mongolians to be the final step of China's overall cultural genocide policy that is intended to systematically destroy the language, tradition, and identity of the Mongolian people as a whole. If you look at the history of the past 73 years, the history of Southern Mongolia, as early as the late 1940s, even before the establishment of the People's Republic of China, the Chinese Communist Party took over Southern Mongolia and implemented the so-called land reform movement. And then they executed tens of thousands of Mongolians and confiscated their land. Then in the 1950s, the Mongolian elite intellectuals were persecuted. And then in 1960 and 1970, for example, there was a large-scale genocide campaign, actually. In this campaign, at least 100,000 Mongolians were tortured to death, and half a million persecuted. At that time, the Mongolian population was only 1.5 million. That means that one-third of the population was affected by this policy. Then in 2001, the Chinese government implemented another set of policies to wipe out the Mongolian traditional way of life. The policies are called ecological migration, with a total ban on our grazing lifestyle. Under this policy, the Mongolian traditional way of life is targeted. Mongolian herders who graze their animals on their own land are considered criminals. And now they are targeting Mongolian language. This is a continuing pattern. The recent policy is not just an isolated policy. It's a continuation of overall Chinese policy to destroy the entire nation of Southern Mongolia. Senator Ossoff. Thank you, Mr. Togochog. Ms. Tethong. If I may, Senator Ossoff---- Senator Ossoff. Please, go ahead. Ms. Tethong. I agree completely. I think this is the continuation of destructive policies, and an intention to-- really, Xi Jinping has just completely accelerated this genocidal project in Tibet and East Turkestan and Southern Mongolia. I think we can see that, with the Chinese Communist Party, Xi Jinping, there can be no challenge to their authority. And that's what Tibetans and Uyghurs and Southern Mongolians do by trying to maintain our distinct way of life, our language, our separate national identities. If you look at China's threatening of Taiwan, if you look at the crackdown in Hong Kong, if you look at the attack on India, I think we can see that it doesn't end with--it's not like it's just about Tibetans or Uyghurs, what China considers its internal issues. It goes well beyond. Xi Jinping and the Chinese Communist Party have imperial ambitions. I mean, there is a belief that they have the right to rule over us, on their borders, and that they should have a greater position of power in the world--should have more influence at whatever cost and to wipe out dissent and to attack people fundamentally, who people are, to try to destroy or erase us. We can see with Russia right now under Putin the threat that Russia poses to global peace and security. I believe it is the same with the Chinese government, and I think no matter what their propaganda says--trust us, they're very, very good at using benign-sounding, positive language to mask their intentions, but we know the truth of what they want to do, and they're doing it to us in a way the whole world can see. And I think that's why it's imperative on some level--it's also self- interest, I think, globally to help to try to push China back to stop these genocides that are happening before our eyes-- because it doesn't just stop here, I don't think. Mr. Roche. If I may just expand on some of those points there. With reference to particularly the groups that I've worked with--I call these unrecognized languages, unrecognized groups, in terms of state and political strategy. Originally when these policies were formed several decades ago, the aim of not recognizing those groups--and it was a deliberate process-- the aim of that was to accelerate their assimilation. The idea was that those unrecognized groups would assimilate into the recognized 56 nationalities and then all of those groups would assimilate into a single, basically Han Chinese socialist unity. So, it was a deliberate strategy to speed up social evolution toward the socialist future, which would also coincidentally be Han Chinese. And so when those structures were put in place--those structures of recognition, the legal structures, constitutional freedom for language, the policies of ethnic autonomy and so on--they were all done with an aim to deliberately drive assimilatory processes, and they have been working as planned for decades now. And we see that in the fate of these unrecognized languages, which people are no longer basically able to transmit to their children or can only do so with great difficulty. Under Xi Jinping, in particular, that goal of accelerating assimilation has taken on goals which are primarily related to China's place on the global stage. It's taken on a geopolitical significance. Those structures that accelerate assimilation are now driving toward producing greater unity, integration, and therefore power that will accelerate China's place in the world order, which--you know, the aim is an ascendant China with a much broader, more important, powerful role on the world stage, and that place on the world stage will be built on the deliberate destruction of these communities. Senator Ossoff. Thank you, all. Thank you for your testimony. And thank you to our co-chairs. I yield back. Chair Merkley. Thank you, Senator Ossoff. And Co-chair McGovern, did you want to ask a second set of questions? Co-chair McGovern. Yes, briefly. Dr. Roche, you speak of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples as a mechanism for indigenous peoples of China to defend their languages. You say that the U.S. should formally endorse the non-binding declaration, as the three other countries who initially voted against it--Canada, the U.K., and Australia--have done. Would endorsement give our government a stronger moral position to urge China to allow its citizens to participate in the UN process? Mr. Roche. Yes, it absolutely would give the U.S. a stronger moral foundation for making these claims against China. We see this repeatedly--that when these issues are raised against China, whether it's in diplomatic or governmental forums or whether it's in the media or social media, that whenever these accusations are brought against China--about what they're actually doing, the first strategy that they always go to is one of deflection--to deflect the query back on the accuser and to say, you have no right to accuse us of this when you yourself have done it in your past, you are doing it now, etc., etc. Then they often go to other strategies of outright denial, conditional denial, and so on and so on, but the first rhetorical strategy is always to deflect the comment back on the accuser, and anything that can be done in that regard will prove the effectiveness of any efforts to hold China accountable for what they are doing--these assimilatory, eliminatory programs. Hopefully, that clarifies it for you. Co-chair McGovern. It does. Thank you. And thank you for being with us this--I don't know what time it is--what time is it where you are? Mr. Roche. It's after midnight now. We started at midnight. Co-chair McGovern. Well, thank you. We appreciate you staying up for us here. Thank you. Ms. Tethong, regarding the residential boarding school system in Tibetan areas, can you expand a little bit on the elements of coercion? I mean, do authorities order families to send their kids away? Do they make it a fait accompli by closing local schools or is it something else? And how would we find out more information about the schools for 4- and 5-year- olds, which you say Chinese authorities are trying to hide? Ms. Tethong. Thank you for your question, Chairman McGovern. Yes, the Chinese government is making it impossible for Tibetan parents to do anything but comply both because of the consolidation of schools--closing all the local schools, all the alternatives, the monastery schools, the Tibetan-run private schools. So Tibetans on the one hand have no choice in most places. If they want their children to get an education, they have to send them away. At the same time, parents do, of course, resist and refuse, and when they do, they are threatened. They can be threatened with financial punishment. The number one thing is, if you don't send your child now, say, to boarding preschool, then they won't be able to go and join later--at grade one or in primary school. And so Tibetan parents are really left--and Tibetans know-- anyone under Chinese Communist Party rule knows you don't disagree, you don't push back--to do so in any meaningful way will be considered a threat to the state and you'll be charged or could be held accountable for some serious political charges, even though all you're trying to do is keep your child at home where you can protect them and watch over them. I know with the boarding preschools--we're really working to try to understand more about the picture on the ground, and we need governments and everyone to be asking China about the boarding preschools. We've been hearing reports recently that Tibetan parents don't want their kids to go to these schools. They don't want to send them away so young. When they have to-- like in nomadic communities, we've been hearing that one nomadic family will move to the township and live in their car to be near the kids that are in that boarding preschool, and the other families back home will take care of their work and their business. And families will take turns. It's having a very, very detrimental effect on the life of nomads and rural people to have such small children taken away, and then, of course, the things parents try to do just like in Canada in the residential school history there, just like in the U.S. You know, when these children are taken away, parents try to go and be near them or do what they can to protect them because they're being taken out of their hands. And we need to know more. China needs to answer and tell us what the numbers are. Just trying to piece together this picture from Chinese state media, from Chinese government sources at every level, from Chinese academics and other academic studies--it really is an incredible challenge, and that's absolutely intentional on the part of the Chinese government to hide this--because they know it's wrong. Co-chair McGovern. Thank you. I apologize, I have to go to another meeting, but before I yield back to Chairman Merkley, let me just thank this incredible panel. You know, this is an important issue. It goes to the issue of identity. It goes to the issue of China trying to wipe out an entire culture. I think, Ms. Tethong, you had mentioned that one of the reasons they do this is to try to quash resistance. On the other hand, I could make an argument that their repression and their trying to rob people of their identity, I think only increases resistance in the sense that people are just horrified that there is an entity that wants to rob them of their identity, of their history, of their culture, of their language. As some people have said on this panel, it's really important for us to be able to fund initiatives that will actually protect these languages and to find ways to allow people to have access to appropriate instruction to be able to pass this on to the next generations. But you have given us some important ideas on things that we need to do in the upcoming appropriations process that will be coming up in a matter of weeks and also some follow-up questions for the Chinese government. This has been an excellent panel, and I want to thank you all. I yield back to Chairman Merkley. Chair Merkley. Thank you very much, Co-chair McGovern. I have some additional questions I'll continue with. Let me start, Dr. Roche, with the question as to whether the Chinese government is also trying to wipe out or start the process of eliminating the Cantonese dialect in favor of the Mandarin dialect? Mr. Roche. Thank you for that question. I'll just give a very brief answer because this is not my specific area of research. I haven't done work in this area, so my understanding of it is from a very broad, general background. Basically, in terms of policy, the same policy of erasure applies, which is that there is limited-to-no formal support for the Cantonese language. A lot of the support is ad hoc and superficial, which then makes it very difficult for the community to sustain their language. We know that in the past there have been protests against the imposition of Mandarin in the Cantonese-speaking communities, and interestingly, the protests seem to have had a knock-on effect in Tibet--in part inspiring language protests there, emboldening people. I think that that's an important thing to note, that all of these language contexts are connected. When one group is able to stand up and defend their language, if that information is available to other people and they know that, that emboldens them, it encourages them, it reminds them of their rights and so on, which is important. But beyond that, I would not like to comment further on the situation of the Cantonese language because I feel I don't have the adequate expertise. Chair Merkley. Are all of the university admissions in Mandarin, all of the university exams? Mr. Roche. Across the entire country or just in the Cantonese context? Chair Merkley. Across the entire country. Mr. Roche. Again, I don't think that I have the up-to-date information on that. I'll pass that over to--perhaps one of the other panelists would know. I haven't been able to enter China, so my on-the-ground access to information is now limited, unfortunately. Chair Merkley. So for each of you, in regard to Mongolia, Tibet, the Uyghur autonomous region, are all the university examinations in Mandarin? Mr. Abduweli. Yes, they are, and we had Uyghur exams until 2017, and since then, all college entrance exams are in Chinese. Mr. Togochog. In Mongolian areas, yes, now all college exams are--they have to be in Chinese, and then, there was until recently--until this new policy, there was a very limited number of colleges that had some majors in Mongolian. For example, a Mongolian literature and linguistics major was--the students were allowed to take the exam in Mongolian, but now all this is changing. All students have to take the exam in Chinese. Chair Merkley. Ms. Tethong. Ms. Tethong. Yes, I believe that's true, and it's important to point out that the pressure on Tibetan society and on the language and culture is coming from both sides. The children-- the youngest children are having the language stolen from them, and those in higher academic study are suddenly not able to--so they amalgamated the different departments. There used to be Tibetan studies and Mongolian studies and Uyghur studies, and under the common language policy, they sort of put everyone together, and the only way to teach is in Mandarin because Tibetans will not speak Uyghur and Uyghurs will not speak Tibetan. There have been Tibetan academics and education specialists who have been working hard for decades to try to promote Tibetan language and Tibetan curriculum and cultural content and everything, and suddenly, all of them are faced with no options to continue with their work. And the Tibetan language itself--I mean, as one Tibetan education policy expert from Tibet who was raised during the Cultural Revolution told us recently, he sees this--between the policy for little kids, the policies for higher education and, of course, what's happening in the monasteries and on the grasslands--he sees this, in a way, as a threat that could be the end of our history, and that just really struck me, when you think of it all together. Chair Merkley. It was in that perspective of seeing these many, many different strategies from different angles in which I was inquiring, kind of, about the plan to wipe out the language and essentially the culture in a generation. You spoke about a pop singer, age 26, I believe, who self- immolated. Was he allowed to sing? Did he become a star within Tibet or was he outside Tibet? Was he allowed to sing in Tibetan inside Tibet and become popular culturally in that language? Ms. Tethong. Yes, he was. He, in particular, was famous in Chinese circles because--he was known because he participated in all these Chinese talent shows, like the music, sort of, idol-type shows, and so he became really well known. But he would do--you could see in his lyrics and in his story, he really tried to promote Tibetan language and identity and to have a message in there about the importance of the Tibetan homeland, sort of without saying it, the Tibetan nation and our cultural roots. And I think the key is, if you look from the outside--and this is what China will say--Tibetans have freedom of expression. Look, they sing in Tibetan; you know, you can see the kids dressed in their Tibetan clothing. In the end, they do allow a certain amount of cultural freedom and expression, but it is very, very, very constrained, very limited. There was a platform recently--a Chinese social media platform--that was streaming a conversation between two Tibetan pop stars, very well known, and one was saying to the other, we can't do this--we shouldn't speak in Tibetan on this platform, or they will shut us down. So, you can see---- Chair Merkley. Yes. Ms. Tethong. You know, I think, really, within a generation we may see the end--if these genocidal policies are allowed to go ahead--we may see the end of Tibetans who can even sing and express themselves in sort of secondary discourse in that language. Chair Merkley. Well, it's a very powerful story when someone who's so successful and so young takes their own life in protest. And can you give us his name once again? Ms. Tethong. Yes. Tsewang Norbu was his name, 25 years old. Chair Merkley. Twenty-five. Thank you. I want to turn to Mr. Abduweli. You note in your testimony that the written language was changed from a Uyghur alphabet to a Cyrillic alphabet to a sinicized Latin script. How much does changing the writing play into interrupting the generational cultural traditions and language abilities? Mr. Abduweli. My father, when he went to high school, was educated using the Cyrillic alphabet, and then my mother, younger than him, was educated using the Latin alphabet. At home they have books in the Cyrillic alphabet, and they have books in the Latin alphabet, but no one can read what they say because it's a different alphabet. Then when we children started primary school, the first year we studied the Latin alphabet and the next year we studied the Arabic alphabet. And my brothers cannot read my books and I cannot read their books. Because the Latin alphabet was implemented in the Uyghur homeland more than 20 years ago, a generation became illiterate, because the Latin alphabet was replaced by the Arabic alphabet and people became illiterate suddenly. Chair Merkley. Thank you. Mr. Abduweli. We had illiteracy three times--use Cyrillic, they don't take it; know Latin and then they don't know the second or the third one. So they have a third generation dealing with this alphabetic change, and thus people become illiterate. Chair Merkley. Thank you. Congresswoman Steel, I see you've rejoined us. Do you want to ask any additional questions? Representative Steel. I just want to say thank you, and that this is so necessary for everybody to hear what the CCP has been doing. So, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all the witnesses. And you know what? I'm going to speak against the CCP, and I've been doing this since I got elected in 2020. Let's work together and let's make sure the whole world knows what the CCP's been doing. Thank you. Chair Merkley. Thank you so much, Congresswoman Steel. It's a really valuable contribution, and it's so important to have these hearings so that more of us become educated and articulate about these forms of oppression. I wanted to ask one last question, Mr. Abduweli, and this ties into a previous hearing we had. When you advocated for Uyghur kindergartens and worked to establish them--basically under that vision from Article 4 of the constitution--your family members were oppressed, and I believe your brother and sister have been imprisoned. We understand your niece, I'm very sorry to hear, passed away in detention two years ago after returning to Shandong from Japan. Did they face imprisonment for their own activities, or was it retaliation, in part, to send a message to advocates abroad? Mr. Abduweli. I started my mother language campaign on September 15, 2011--my first mother language kindergarten and then my mother language schools. Because of that I got arrested on August 19, 2013, and in Turkey in 2017 because of the Uyghur students that were arrested in Egypt on July 4, 2017. I received their voice message and written message, and I spoke up. Because of this my older brother got arrested, and I learned that he was sentenced to 14 years. Because of my activism, my younger sister was forced to denounce me for more than a year, from 2016 to September 2017. For an entire year she criticized me and denounced me and claimed that I'm a separatist or something like that, and then in the end she also ended up in a concentration camp and sentenced to 12 years. And then in November 2019, I participated in leaking the Xinjiang file and the Karakax List. And because of that my wife's family members--because at that time we had some contact--got arrested. And so I think those are related. When I take some action, when I speak up, the next step is retaliation. So I think it's related to the retaliation--to get me to stop. My niece, when she was in Japan, told me really clearly that I became a hero, but her father and her aunt became victims because of me. I feel really sorry about what happened to her. She went back to Japan because she was under the control of the Chinese police through the Chinese social media app WeChat. The Chinese police were always trying to force her to stop me, but she couldn't stop me. Because of this, she went back to China, and she died in detention at the place where I was first arrested and sexually abused. I feel very sorry about it. I hope this retaliation will stop and I hope these atrocities will stop. Chair Merkley. It's absolutely horrific and I'm sure very effective in suppressing conversation about China's many assaults on human rights. This retaliation against family for freedom of speech abroad is just--I think about this, and I think, why do we allow any import, any recognition, any validation of the Chinese government given the many, many crimes against humanity that we've witnessed through this series of hearings? Thank you for sharing that story, and we all have great empathy with the horrific situation it puts you in and everyone who wants to speak up from their heart about human rights abuses inside China. I really appreciate all of you on the panel for sharing your knowledge and experience. We have to keep speaking out. We cannot let Chinese pressure in any form--against our companies, against advocates within our country, against Chinese citizens abroad--stop us from scrutinizing and publicizing these activities. Without scrutiny, without publicization, there is no chance to diminish this strategy of wiping out the languages and the cultures of the many groups within China. And with that--I know I have an official script here somewhere for closing--specifically, the record will remain open until the close of business on Friday, April 8th. And for any members who would like to put additional things into the record, you are welcome to do so, and I extend that invitation to our panel of experts as well. Thank you. And with that, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:48 a.m., the hearing was concluded.] ======================================================================= A P P E N D I X ======================================================================= Prepared Statements ------ Prepared Statement of Gerald Roche Thank you sincerely for this opportunity to testify today. I deeply appreciate the chance to share with all of you some insights into the language rights situation for people in China, and I thank the Commission for bringing attention to this important topic. We must defend language rights because doing so ensures dignity, freedom, and equality for all people. Who among us would want to live without any of these? When people are denied language rights, it severs their connections to their family, community, and heritage. It excludes them from political participation. When people are denied language rights in vital services like healthcare, their lives are at risk. And when they are denied language rights in education, their futures are at risk. Millions of people in China today face these challenges due to the state's denial of language rights. This happens primarily in two ways: erasure and suppression. Erasure refers to the state's refusal to acknowledge the existence of most of China's languages, by calling them dialects. To put this in perspective, imagine if German, English, and Norwegian were defined as ``dialects'' of a single language.\1\ Imagine if your government told you what language you speak. How would you feel? In China, erasure means that from the country's 300 or so languages, only about 56 are recognized as languages: one for each of the country's ``nationalities.'' \2\ Most people in China speak unrecognized languages, whether they belong to the Han majority or a minority group.\3\ Most people in China are therefore completely denied their language rights. Our research demonstrates the catastrophic impacts of this denial in Tibet.\4\ Tibetan people in China use about 30 unrecognized languages,\5\ not including Tibetan.\6\ People who use these unrecognized languages face linguistic barriers everywhere: in schools, media, government, healthcare, the legal system and so on. When the government refuses to remove these barriers, people are forced to adapt by changing their language to either Tibetan or Chinese.\7\ Meanwhile, recognized languages like Uyghur, Mongolian, and Tibetan, are suppressed. Suppression happens through the gradual dilution of the Chinese constitution's language freedoms,\8\ and the pervasive under- implementation of protections for minority languages.\9\ Suppression also takes place through the encroachment of the national language, Mandarin, into spaces for minority languages--part of a broader plan to universalize Mandarin among the entire population.\10\ The cumulative impact of erasure and suppression means that at least half of China's languages are currently losing speakers or signers as they switch to dominant languages.\11\ In an open, democratic society, people would be lobbying and protesting to change this unjust system. But in China, particularly under Xi Jinping, civil society has become increasingly repressed domestically, and isolated internationally.\12\ In Hong Kong, Xinjiang, Tibet, and Inner Mongolia, wherever protest happens, the state sees foreign interference rather than legitimate grievances. China's citizens will therefore be denied an unprecedented historic opportunity to defend language rights, namely, the United Nations International Decade for Indigenous Languages, which starts this year.\13\ China will prevent its citizens from participating in this event because it denies that it has Indigenous people,\14\ and it denies its colonial history.\15\ The goal of this Decade is ``leaving no one behind and no one outside.'' We have a responsibility to extend this inclusion to people in China, to ensure they are not left behind or outside. Here are some suggestions for how we can do this: 1. The U.S. must pressure China to clarify whether its citizens can identify as Indigenous and whether they can participate in the UN Decade. An ideal opportunity to do this is China's upcoming Universal Periodic Review in the UN Human Rights Council in November 2023.\16\ 2. China's efforts to isolate its citizens from international civil society need to be countered. We must raise awareness inside China of language rights, and of activities taking place globally during the UN Decade.\17\ 3. With specific regard to Tibet, earmarking funding for Tibet's unrecognized languages will make a huge difference. This can be done using funds allocated under the Tibetan Policy Act of 2020.\18\ 4. Finally, the U.S. needs to lead by example. The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples should be formally endorsed, and its obligations respected.\19\ Failing to do so will enable China to deflect attention from their language rights violations and onto America's. Thank you again for your time, and if anything I have said raises questions for you, I would be very happy to discuss further. [Endnotes appear after Appendix One.] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ______ Prepared Statement of Enghebatu Togochog introduction My name is Enghebatu Togochog. I am a Mongolian from Southern Mongolia, widely known as ``Inner Mongolia.'' Southern Mongolia is home to six million Mongolians, a population that is twice as large as that of the independent country of Mongolia. In 1949, Southern Mongolia was officially annexed to the People's Republic of China, becoming the first so-called ``Nationality Minority Autonomous Region.'' Over the past 73 years, praised as the ``model autonomy,'' Southern Mongolia has served as the de facto testing ground of China's ethnic policies. These include genocide, ethnic cleansing, political purge, economic exploitation, cultural eradication, linguistic assimilation, social marginalization, resource extraction, and environmental destruction, as detailed below. As early as the late 1940s, before the establishment of the People's Republic of China, Southern Mongolia was occupied by the Chinese Communist forces and was subjected to the so-called ``Land Reform Movement.'' Mongolian land was effectively confiscated and distributed to the Chinese, and tens of thousands of Southern Mongolians were executed as ``herd-lords.'' During the 1950s, at least 20,000 Southern Mongolian elite intellectuals were persecuted as ``national rightists'' for demanding the materialization of ``nationality autonomy'' that the Chinese Communist government promised to Southern Mongolia. From the late 1960s through the early 1970s, Southern Mongolia had experienced a large-scale genocide campaign carefully designed by the Chinese Central Government and carried out by the People's Liberation Army and Chinese settlers. At least 100,000 Southern Mongolians were tortured to death, and a half million were persecuted. One-third of the Southern Mongolian population was affected by this genocide of unprecedented scale. In the early 1980s, the Chinese Central Government accelerated the process of Chinese migration to Southern Mongolia. As a result, in 1981, a large-scale student movement broke out across Southern Mongolia. After a three-month-long, region-wide student protest, the Chinese Government cracked down on the students and arrested, detained, and imprisoned the student leaders and supporters. In the early 1990s, Southern Mongolian intellectuals established a number of underground organizations protesting Chinese occupation and demanding national freedom. All of them were harshly crushed by the Chinese authorities. In 1995, one such organization--the Southern Mongolian Democratic Alliance (SMDA), which aimed to achieve the total independence of Southern Mongolia and ultimately to merge with the independent country of Mongolia--was declared a ``national separatist organization.'' The president and the vice president of the organization, Mr. Hada and Mr. Tegexi, were arrested and sentenced to 15 years and 10 years in jail, respectively, on charges of ``separatism and espionage.'' Nearly 70 other members were arrested, detained, and sent to jail for periods ranging from 3 months to a year. Mr. Hada is still under house arrest today after serving 15 years of imprisonment and an additional 4-year extrajudicial detention. In 2001, China started a fresh crusade against the traditional Mongolian nomadic way of life. Two sets of policies, namely the ``Ecological Migration'' and the ``Livestock Grazing Ban,'' were introduced to forcibly displace the entire Mongolian herder population from their ancestral lands to overwhelmingly Chinese-populated urban and agricultural areas. These displaced herders became homeless, jobless and landless. The Mongolian pastoralist way of life and nomadic civilization were effectively wiped out. Southern Mongolians consider this a critical step in China's overall cultural genocide in Southern Mongolia. According to the Chinese Central Government State Council announcement published on its website in May 2012, by the end of 2015, China would resettle the remaining nomad population of 246,000 households, or 1.157 million nomads, within the borders of China. This means by the end of 2015, the millennium-old nomadic civilization was officially put to an end in China. In 2009, the Chinese Central Government announced that Southern Mongolia would become ``China's largest energy base.'' Chinese extractive industries, including major state-run mining corporations and thousands of ninja miners, rushed into Southern Mongolia. In May 2011, a regionwide protest broke out in Southern Mongolia, sparked by the brutal killing of a Mongolian herder who defended his land from coal miners. Tens of thousands of students took to the street supporting the widespread herders' protest across the region. The Chinese authorities responded with riot police and paramilitary forces to put down the uprising. Hundreds were arrested, detained, and jailed. Resource extraction and environmental destruction were not halted, but only exacerbated. ongoing cultural genocide As the last phase of the cultural genocide campaign, in June 2020, the Chinese Central Government announced that it would implement ``Second Generation Bilingual Education,'' a new euphemism for the renewed attack on Mongolian culture. The goal of the new policy is clear: wipe out Mongolian language, culture, and identity and turn Southern Mongolia into a homogenous, worry-free Chinese society. In response to this, starting in late August 2020, the Southern Mongolians carried out a regionwide nonviolent resistance movement. The entire Southern Mongolian populace stood up to the Chinese regime. From kindergarteners to college professors, from ordinary herders to prominent scholars, from party members to government employees, from artists to athletes, from lawyers to police officers, from taxi drivers to delivery men, all walks of life of Southern Mongolian society took part in the protest in one way or another. At least 300,000 Mongolian students went on a total school strike. The Chinese authorities harshly cracked down on the movement. An estimated 8,000-10,000 Southern Mongolians have been arrested, detained, jailed, and placed under house arrest. Eleven Southern Mongolians lost their lives in defense of the right to use their mother tongue. What followed this heavyhanded crackdown was a full-scale and full- speed cultural genocide campaign, the scope of which has extended far beyond the simple switch of medium of instruction from Mongolian to Chinese in schools. On January 1, 2021, all government mouthpieces, including the Inner Mongolia Radio and Television Mongolian language services, were ordered to start replacing Mongolian cultural programs with Chinese ones in order to promote ``the strong sense of Chinese Zhongguo nationality common identity.'' ``Learn Chinese and become a civilized person'' has been an official slogan publicly promoting Chinese supremacy over Mongolian language, culture, and identity. Slogans of ``mutual interaction, mutual exchange and mutual assimilation of all ethnic groups to firmly establish the Chinese nationality common identity'' have been aired repeatedly from television and radio stations across the region. In schools, Mongolian students are subjected to military-style training and propaganda activities. Mongolian college students are forced to wear Mao suits and sing Communist ``red'' songs to extol the greatness of China. Mongolian teachers and professors are brought to the Chinese Communist red base Yan'an to receive patriotic education. In a move to justify the total elimination of Mongolian languages from the entire educational system in Southern Mongolia, the Chinese National Congress announced recently that ``education in minority languages as local legislations stipulated is unconstitutional,'' according to the Chinese official press People's Daily. This overwrites Article 4 of the Constitution of the People's Republic of China, which states, ``All ethnicities have the freedoms and rights to use and develop their own spoken and written languages and to preserve or reform their own folkways and customs.'' Local authorities in the Autonomous Region reacted promptly to implement this directive. Classes on Mongolian culture and history taught in Mongolian in local schools are considered to be ``underemphasizing the Chinese nationality common identity and deliberately overemphasizing [an] individual ethnic group's `ethnic identity' and `ethnic sentiment,' '' and hence are removed from the curriculum across the region. In an effort to completely block all avenues of learning Mongolian, on January 9, 2021, the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region Department of Education issued a document banning ``any school from gathering students to offer extracurricular learning courses or teaching new courses.'' It strictly prohibited middle and elementary school teachers from organizing or participating in any training organizations outside the campus or any paid make-up courses organized by teachers, parents and parents' committees, or inducing students to participate in any paid make-up courses organized by themselves or others; introducing student sources and providing relevant information to any training organization outside the school campus is strictly prohibited, according to Xin Lang Wang, one of the Chinese official presses. Flagrant cultural annihilation is most visible in the series of arts and cultural performances put together by the Chinese authorities for the Mongolian Tsagaan Sar, the traditional Mongolian new year. Peking operas have replaced the traditional Mongolian art performance in TV programs. In some programs, traditional Mongolian dances have been converted to hybrid ones that exhibit full features of Chinese operas. The horse-head fiddle, a traditional Mongolian musical instrument, has been played in concert with the suona, a distinctively high-pitched instrument often played in Chinese traditional music ensembles. The most sacred Mongolian sites, like Oboo, a stone altar devoted to the worship of Eternal Sky and local gods, have also been targeted by this campaign. Chinese traditional performers like Yangge dancers have frequently shown up on Oboo sites to mock the Mongolian Oboo ritual ceremony. Sculptures of Mongolian historical figures have been taken down and smashed; signs in Mongolian have been removed from schools, buildings, streets, and parks. The latest footage we received shows a group of construction workers removing the Mongolian letters from the official sign of the Hohhot City People's Procuratorates in the regional capital. In another photo, a group of Mongolian students stand next to a sign in Mongolian at their school entrance; the sign was scheduled to be removed the next day. Mongolian publications are banned altogether, and Mongolian books are taken down from bookstore shelves. Printing and copy services on the street are ordered not to provide services of printing and copying any materials in Mongolian. Postal and courier services are instructed not to deliver any Mongolian books and publications. On the official front, a regionwide intensive training program was launched. According to the Inner Mongolia News official website, the first session of the Region-wide Educational System Special Training for the Firm Inculcation of the Chinese Nationality Common Identity started on December 8, 2020. Although the exact details of the training and the total number of trainees remain unknown, the report confirmed that a three-phase training program will be completed by the end of March 2021. Other regional and local news revealed that the synchronized training sessions were held in all schools, colleges, and universities throughout the Autonomous Region. A 47-page internal document entitled ``Propaganda Pamphlet for Inculcating the Chinese Nationality Common Identity to Push for the Usage of Nationally Compiled Textbook and National Common Language Education'' was issued by the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region Department of Education in January 2021. According to a trainee who asked not to be identified, all the lectures, discussions, reflections, and quizzes are centered on this document. Quoting Xi Jinping's remarks, the document ``urges the masses to communicate and train together to take up the work of interfusing the feelings, to strive hard to create a social condition of living together, learning together, working together and enjoying together, and urges all ethnic groups to accept the great mother country, Chinese nationality, Chinese culture, Chinese Communist Party and socialism with Chinese characteristics.'' The document also warns the Southern Mongolians that ``the wrong path of narrow nationalism can easily lead to the return of separatist tendency.'' Another trainee who managed to leave China and who has arrived in the United States recently told us that he and all of his Mongolian coworkers were forced to receive this training for two months. During the training, they had to denounce their ``narrow nationalism'' and ``nationalistic feeling'' and embrace the ``Chinese nationality common identity.'' They were required to provide all of their social contacts and the details of their social media activities to the authorities. Toward the end of the training, they were forced to confess their supposed ``mistakes,'' including their past gatherings where they wore Mongolian traditional clothes and sang Mongolian songs. They were warned that these mistakes went against the spirit of ``Chinese nationality common identity.'' They had to answer multiple questionnaires designed to assess their ``ideological improvement.'' One of the questions, the trainee said, was, ``How many Chinese friends do you have?'' Those who answered ``none'' or ``few'' participated in extended trainings before they were qualified to ``graduate.'' Before the release, all trainees signed a paper promising that they would not engage in any activities highlighting ``Mongolian characteristics'' or expressing ``nationalistic feeling.'' From what is happening to the Uyghurs and what is happening to the Mongolians and Tibetans, it is apparent that the Chinese authorities are engaging in different forms of genocide campaigns on multiple fronts. While in East Turkistan, millions of Uyghurs and other Muslim peoples are locked up in concentration camps, in Southern Mongolia, a full-scale cultural genocide campaign is taking place. In Tibet, a similar campaign has been launched to eradicate the unique Tibetan culture and religious beliefs. Whatever form the campaign takes, the ultimate goal of the Chinese authorities is the same: wipe out the language, culture, and identity of these three peoples and force them to adopt the so-called zhong hua, or, simply put, ``Chinese'' nationality. This goal is publicly stated and advertised by the Chinese Government across China. recommendations Considering the deteriorating human rights conditions in Southern Mongolia; China's determination to erase the Mongolian language, culture, and identity; and the lack of support from the international community, I would like to make the following recommendations to the United States Congress: 1. Conduct further hearings and testimonies to investigate the gross human rights violations in Southern Mongolia, particularly the ongoing cultural genocide; 2. Establish a Mongolian language broadcast in Voice of America and/or Radio Free Asia to help Southern Mongolians keep their language alive and establish a channel to the free and democratic world; 3. Introduce and pass legislation similar to the Uyghur Human Rights Policy Act and Tibetan Policy and Support Act to support the six million Southern Mongolians in their efforts to defend their basic human rights and fundamental freedoms. Thank you. ______ Prepared Statement of Lhadon Tethong Thank you Chairman McGovern, Chairman Merkley, members of the Commission and CECC staff for all of your work and commitment to support human rights and freedom in Tibet. And thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak here today. As a Tibetan, and someone who has been working full time on the Sino-Tibetan conflict for the past twenty-three years, I can safely say: it takes a lot to shock me. But last year, when my colleagues and I began research into reports that Tibetan children were being sent to state-run boarding schools at an alarmingly high rate, and against their parents wishes, we were stunned and alarmed by what we found. Over the past decade--under the cover of darkness of China's near total information blackout and lockdown of Tibet--the Chinese authorities have been constructing a massive colonial boarding school system. These schools threaten the very survival of the Tibetan people and nation because they so wholly and completely target the future of Tibet--our children. And not just some of them, but all of them, even the youngest ones. China's colonial boarding school system in Tibet is the cornerstone of a broader effort to wipe out the current and future resistance of the fiercely proud Tibetan people, by eliminating the three pillars of Tibetan identity--language, religion, and way of life. In essence, the schools streamline and fasttrack this policy by ripping Tibetan children from their roots, by stealing the language from their tongues, and by turning them into something that they are not. And together with ``common language'' and ``bilingual education'' policies, and other policies purposely named to sound benign when, in fact, they are not, they represent an entirely new level of attack on the Tibetan people that threatens to irreversibly alter Tibetan life in every space in Tibet--on the grasslands, in the monasteries, in the universities, in villages, in cities, and even in the privacy of one's own home. As one Tibetan education policy expert from Tibet who was raised during the cultural revolution told me recently: ``What is happening now is actually worse than the Cultural Revolution. At that time, they destroyed so much physically, but now they are trying to destroy the entire foundation of who we are as a people on the inside.'' In our report, released in December, we found that: At least 800,000 to 900,000 Tibetan children in all of historical Tibet--representing nearly eighty percent of all Tibetan school children ages 6 to 18--are now separated from their families and living in colonial boarding schools. This number does not include four- and five-year-olds being made to live in boarding preschools because China is actively trying to hide their existence. We believe this number is also very high. These children are forbidden from practicing religion and cut off from authentic Tibetan culture--beyond, of course, what the Chinese Communist Party approves of. They are being taught almost entirely in Chinese, by mostly Chinese teachers, from Chinese textbooks that reflect Chinese life and history, culture and values, while completely denying Tibet's own rich and ancient history and culture. On top of this, they are subjected to intense political indoctrination which says they must be loyal to the Chinese Communist Party and the Chinese nation first and above all else. Most Tibetan parents have no choice but to send their children away to live in these state-run schools because the authorities have closed the local village schools, along with most privately run Tibetan schools and monastery schools. Parents who try to resist or refuse are threatened with fines and other serious consequences. And, of course, the children also have no choice. One person from Tibet described the situation like this: ``I know of children aged four to five who don't want to be separated from their mothers. They are forced to go to boarding schools. In some cases, the children cry for days, sticking to their mother's laps, begging not to be sent away and even refusing to go back. Both the children and the parents are unwilling.'' This insidious policy--to isolate children from their families so as to erase their Tibetan identity and replace it with a Chinese identity--was developed at the highest levels of the Chinese Communist Party. And it is blatantly racist. Of course Tibetan parents want their children to receive the best possible education, but they don't want to have to send them away to get it. Nobody wants to send their children away. Chinese people don't want to send their children away. A backlash against school consolidation policies in China led the State Council to rule, in 2012, that all levels of school should be, in principle, non-residential, especially for young children in grades one to three. Three years later, after Xi Jinping came to power, the same State Council issued a decree for so-called ``minority areas'' to ``strengthen boarding school construction'' and ``achieve the goal that students of all ethnic minorities will study in a school, live in a school and grow up in a school.'' Unlike in the past, where middle and high school students in Tibet had to attend boarding schools where we have heard firsthand accounts of horrific abuse and political indoctrination, now it's primary and even preschool children who are also being targeted. Any of you with kids, grandkids, nieces, and nephews will know that children at the age of four, five, and six, and even those seven, eight, nine, and ten are not that far off from being babies. They are sweet and vulnerable and they need their parents and their families just to manage daily life. My five-year-old son started kindergarten this year and I was surprised to find both of us quite nervous and emotional over this rite of passage. But I walk him to school each day. And I pick him up each evening. Every day he gets to come home and be enveloped into the love, safety, and comfort of our family where I can protect him and look out for his best interests. And I can teach and share with him--together with his father, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins--Tibetan language, stories, songs and dances, prayers and customs, and all of the other important cultural and religious practices and traditions of our family, our people, and our ancestors. That this precious time of social and emotional growth--where the basic building blocks of identity are transmitted and cemented--is being denied to the vast majority of Tibetan children, and to their parents and families, is truly devastating. And that it is being done intentionally is enraging. In the U.S., Canada, Australia and other countries, policies that separated Native American, Indigenous, and Aboriginal children from their families and made them live in residential boarding schools designed to erase or change their identity is something we think of as a terrible and shameful mistake of the past. We think of now as the time for inquiries and apologies--like the historic apology just given by the Pope to First Nations, Inuit, and Metis people for the Catholic Church's role in Canada's residential school system. It is the time for trying to repair some of the tremendous harm that was done and that continues to reverberate. Not a time when any government would be knowingly and deliberately replicating this heinous model, and on such a massive scale. And the reason China is doing this? The reason Xi Jinping is taking this genocidal approach in Tibet? To eliminate dissent and difference once and for all, by transforming Tibetans into Chinese. But this is a genocidal project that is bound to fail because even after 70 years of a vicious and violent occupation, Tibetans continue to fight for their rights and freedom. Because generation after generation of Tibetans--even those with no memory of a Free Tibet--have shown their love and allegiance to Tibet-- to the mountains, the grasslands, to our mother tongue, the teachings of the Buddha, and our great sages, spiritual teachers, and leaders, most especially His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama--and not to China. Just last month, 25-year-old Tsewang Norbu, a famous Tibetan pop star who was just signed, in December, by Warner Brothers China, reminded us all of this undeniable fact when he self-immolated in front of the Potala Palace in Lhasa. He had every reason to live. He was young, successful, college educated. He had a family and resources. His whole life was ahead of him. But he gave it all up, in the ultimate sacrifice at the most meaningful and political location and moment, on the eve of the 63rd anniversary of the 1959 Tibetan Uprising in Lhasa, when security in Tibet is at its absolute tightest. He again demonstrated that no matter China's economic, military, or political might, everything Chinese leaders have done to try to convince, co-opt, coerce, and force Tibetans to submit to Chinese rule has failed. After looking at Tsewang Norbu's lyrics and life story, I think he took this action because he wanted to remind us all that no matter what personal success we may achieve as individuals, what matters the most is your roots. Your homeland. Your culture. Your language. The freedom to be who you are. To live as you see fit in your own land and on your own terms. But, of course, this is not possible in Tibet today under Chinese rule. Tibetans are being blocked from even speaking Tibetan on Chinese social media apps like Kuaishou and Douyin, the Chinese version of TikTok. And even young children trying to defend their right to study and speak in Tibetan are being severely punished. Recently, we learned that three students, 16-year-old Palsang, 15- year-old Sermo, and 11-year-old Yangkyi, were sent from a colonial boarding school in Markham County to a detention center for expressing their sadness over the removal of Tibetan language classes from the school. They are reported to have been arrested and taken away forcefully under the pretext of needing psychological counseling. It has been five months since they were taken away, and still we know little to nothing about their condition. I think it is hard for people to fully understand what is at stake here for Tibetans. What this all means for our nation. Our history. Our survival. Language rights. Assimilationist policies. These are words that not everyone can relate to. They can feel quite cold or technical, perhaps even alienating to the average person who lives in a free and open society. What I would like to do today is to explain the battle for Tibet's existence in a way that perhaps everyone can relate to better, and while this example and its parallels are not perfect, I believe it helps to illuminate what is at stake. Imagine that Russia not only invades, but occupies Ukraine, as China has done to Tibet for the past 70 years. Imagine the beautiful Ukrainian children we see on TV, trying to flee the war with their mothers or hiding from Russia's bombs in basements, are trapped by Russian forces. Their parents and grandparents are killed, imprisoned, or ultimately, and only by sheer force, made to submit to their foreign rulers. After some time, these children are taken away from their parents. Not just a few of them. Eighty percent of them. Nearly all of them. And they are made to live in boarding schools designed by Russians, taught mainly by Russians in Russian language, and with a curriculum that celebrates Russian culture and history and Moscow's military conquests in Crimea, in Georgia, Chechnya, Syria. They are taught that Russia's invasion was for their benefit--that Ukrainians were liberated from Nazi rule. Every day these children have to raise the Russian flag. Every day they have to sing the Russian national anthem. After some time, most do not even realize that Ukraine was ever an independent nation. They do not know Zelensky's name. Or, if they do, they are taught he is an evil terrorist. I know any good and moral person can see how wrong this would be. On every level. It's pretty much crystal clear at this moment while we all bear witness to the horror and injustice of Russia's war of aggression in Ukraine. We would never accept it. We would fight against it and use every tool in our toolbox to make Russia stop. To save Ukrainian children. To reunite them with their parents. We would know we must refuse to let Russia erase Ukraine from our world and from history. That would be the course of action we would take. That would be the right thing to do. That should be the course of action we take with China. There is so much we can do. The world's opposition to Russia's invasion of Ukraine has shown us how much power people and governments, both individually and collectively, have. Just as Putin's actions have shown us that a totalitarian state with imperial ambitions cannot be allowed to invade, occupy, and endlessly terrorize its neighbors--because a state that so blatantly flouts international rules and norms, and indeed actively seeks to undermine them, no matter what its propaganda says are its intentions, threatens us all. Chinese imperialism must be stopped. Xi Jinping must be stopped. The fate of Tibetans, Uyghurs, Southern Mongolians, Hongkongers, Taiwanese, affects us all. I will end my remarks here and save my specific recommendations for the Q&A. I would also like to submit our report on China's colonial boarding school system in Tibet for the record. Thank you. ______ Prepared Statement of Ayup Abduweli When a Language Stands Up against Atrocities Uyghur was recognized as an official language, together with Mandarin, after the arrival of Communist rule in October 1949. This did not change when the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region was set up in 1955--Uyghur was preserved as the main language of instruction in the region, as it was before 1949. However, Uyghur orthography was treated as the remains of pre-Communist backwardness. This meant that the Uyghur Arabic script, which had been used for almost one thousand years, stopped being used, and was replaced with a new spelling system. This caused hundreds of thousands of people to become illiterate, and it also made a thousand years of written legacy unreadable. Furthermore, beginning in 1956, the CCP treated the Arabic Uyghur script as representative of Islam, and a competitor and cultural threat to Mandarin. Officials set out to ``revolutionize'' the Uyghur writing system, and the Xinjiang language committee was ordered to change the Uyghur Arabic script into a Cyrillic one. Uyghur linguists who didn't agree with the language policy were imprisoned, such as Ibrahim Muti, Abdurehim Otkur, Mirsultan Osmanov, and Reveydulla Hemdulla. Ibrahim Muti and Abdurehim Otkur, Uyghur scholars educated during the Kuomintang period, were imprisoned for 20 years. Uyghur teachers, publishers, editors, and professors were also arrested for the same reasons. The alphabetic change in 1956 resulted in thousands of Uyghurs being imprisoned and thousands of books becoming unreadable, and millions of people becoming illiterate. Uyghurs were forced to learn a brand-new writing system. Then, in 1962, the Uyghur alphabet was changed to a sinicized Latin script, aimed at unifying all ethnic languages under a Han Chinese phonetic alphabet. This created illiteracy, miscommunication, and discouragement among the Uyghurs. It also led to book burning and mass arrests of Uyghur intellectuals. From 1966 to 1976, the Uyghur language experienced a Cultural Revolution which was imposed by the CCP. Most of the Uyghur elite escaped to the Soviet Union within ten years. There were more than 100,000 Uyghurs and Kazakhs who escaped to Turkic-speaking Soviet republics because they were afraid of imprisonment and other types of physical and mental torture. During the Cultural Revolution, every aspect of Uyghur life was ``revolutionized''. Uyghur was ``enriched'' with ``red'' Mandarin revolutionary words. Millions of copies of books were burned. The Cultural Revolution treated the Uyghur script as the remains of the ``feudalistic backward old society.'' At that time, books in the Uyghur Arabic script were treated as anti-revolutionary yellow books. The books were all collected from every Uyghur family and then burned in front of mosques. My father kept some yellow books in secret boxes, and when I was young he read some books to us from those boxes. The Uyghur language was treated as an object of the revolution, and it was revolutionized by the Chinese phonetic alphabet. Based on my study of Chinese loan words in the Uyghur-language Xinjiang Daily of October 1st, 1970, the level of loan words reached 62 percent. This made Uyghurs feel marginalized, threatened, and endangered. The Uyghur language enjoyed a short period of a golden age from 1982 to the early 2000s. However, the Uyghur language was treated as an obstacle to the modernization of Uyghurs. During this time, Chinese symbolized modernity and Uyghur symbolized being outdated, feudal, and backward. In order to reach the goal of modernization, the Uyghur language was forced to change its orthography in order to absorb Chinese loan words. After the September 11th, 2001 terrorist attacks, the international war against terrorism not only changed the fate of the world, but also the fate of the Uyghurs' language. China has employed the international outcry against terrorism to curb Uyghur cultural practices, especially the Uyghur language, and has erased it as a language of instruction in universities, colleges, and technology schools. The Uyghur language has also been restricted in health care and other bureaucracies. This creates disagreement among the Uyghur community. In 2005, Memtimin Elyar, a website administrator and IT engineer, started an online campaign to protect and recover the legal rights of the Uyghur language as stipulated by the Chinese constitution and the Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law. However, Elyar was arrested and sentenced to 12 years in prison. More than ten intellectuals were arrested at that time. In 2016, the intellectuals who signed the petition were also targeted by the government. All of the scholars who signed the petition have been arrested--Perhat Tursun, Kuresh Tahir, Kamil Rehim, and Qurban Mamut are among them. In September 2011, another campaign was started to protect the legal rights of Uyghurs and preserve the Uyghur language as a language of instruction in education. I established the first mother-tongue kindergarten in Kashgar on September 15, 2011. My mother-tongue movement became so popular online that 500,000 followers followed it. In September 2012, together with my friends Dilyar Obulqasim and Memetsidiq Abdureshit, I decided to establish a new mother-tongue kindergarten in Urumqi. Unfortunately, the application for this kindergarten was rejected by the authorities. On March 19, 2013, we decided to start a joint campaign with Mongol, Kazakh and Kyrgyz intellectuals, because those languages were also in danger. We decided to hold a conference about how to protect ethnic minority languages in Xinjiang within the framework of the Chinese constitution, and how to strengthen the mother-tongue protection movement, and to base it on a legal foundation. We declared our slogan to be ``If the Chinese constitution protects our language, then it is our turn to protect it.'' For the conference, we invited Uyghur, Kazakh, Kyrgyz and Mongol scholars who worked for the Chinese government to discuss how to protect ethnic minority languages in Xinjiang under the Chinese constitution. After the conference, our slogan was popular in every city of Xinjiang, possibly because people thought it was a safe slogan to use. I think it was our last opportunity to try using this kind of action. On August 19, 2013, Chinese security personnel arrested four of us--Memetsidiq Abdureshit, Dilyar Obulqasim, Abdusalam Abdurahman and me. Dilyar Obulqasim, Memetsidiq Abdureshit and I were held in a detention center for more than 15 months, 18 months, and 24 months, respectively. Since 2017, language policy towards Uyghur has changed dramatically. Uyghur was banned from education at the end of 2016, Uyghur textbooks were forbidden, and textbook editors were heavily sentenced. All Uyghur books were banned, and Uyghur books in homes, at libraries and at bookstores were collected and burned. Uyghur publishers have also been sentenced--30 percent of Uyghur publishers have been sentenced, private bookstores have been shut down, and the owners of the bookstores have also been sentenced. Uyghur is not allowed at schools, even in schoolyards. Uyghur language teachers have also been sentenced, and textbook editors have been sentenced, with three of them sentenced to life imprisonment. According to the documentation of Uyghur Hjelp, more than 400 Uyghur textbook editors have been sentenced. Three editors-in-chief of Uyghur textbooks have been sentenced to life imprisonment, and one editor-in- chief was sentenced to death. There are now 900,000 Uyghur kids in Chinese boarding schools. Uyghur children from the age of six are forced to live in boarding schools. Boarding kindergartens are mandatory for Uyghurs throughout the countryside. Millions of Uyghur kids have been separated from their families and their homeland, and they are victims of indoctrination under the name of education. Han Chinese officials have been appointed to Uyghurs' homes to force Uyghurs not to speak Uyghur at home. Unqualified Han Chinese teachers have been recruited from Chinese provinces, just to force Uyghur students not to speak Uyghur in the classroom. These extreme measures put the Uyghur language at the edge of extinction. ______ Prepared Statement of Hon. Jeff Merkley Before we turn to the subject of this hearing, I want to acknowledge that this is our first hearing since the publication of the Commission's annual report on human rights conditions and rule-of-law developments in China. Every year, the rigorously researched and sourced work of the Commission's nonpartisan research staff makes a profound contribution to the understanding of these issues in Congress, the executive branch, the academic and advocacy communities, and elsewhere, and that is certainly true again this year. When the Chinese government seeks to mislead the world about the treatment of Chinese citizens and the government's critics, the fact-based reporting of the CECC Annual Report shines a light and helps document the truth. Increasingly, this work informs and catalyzes meaningful action. The Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act is the latest example in a string of significant laws that grew out of the CECC's reporting. As Congress now works to advance China-focused legislation, it's crucial that it include tangible steps advocated by this Commission on a bipartisan and bicameral basis, such as expanded humanitarian pathways for Hong Kong residents and Uyghurs fleeing Chinese government persecution, as well as the creation of a China Censorship Monitor and Action Group to protect U.S. businesses and individuals from censorship and intimidation. I'd like to thank the Commission's staff--incredible team--for its tireless, professional, and expert work preparing such a high-quality report. While it is truly a team effort with significant contributions from everyone on the staff, I'd like to especially recognize Megan Fluker, who played an integral role in eight of these annual reports and managed production of the last several before leaving the Commission last fall. Megan, I know you're on your next chapter, but we really appreciate your many years of dedicated effort. Some of the most heartbreaking reporting details the genocide being perpetrated against Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, as well as elements of eugenics in population control policies directed at ethnic minorities. These are not the only ways in which the Chinese Communist Party seeks to destroy religious and ethnic minorities. Chinese authorities have engaged in a years-long campaign of ``sinicization,'' requiring greater conformity with officially sanctioned interpretations of Chinese culture. One of the most pernicious aspects of this campaign targets ethnic minorities' language and identity. Under a policy that promises ``bilingual education,'' authorities in fact largely replace instruction in ethnic minority languages with instruction in Mandarin Chinese. Meanwhile, only a fraction of the languages spoken or signed in China today receive official recognition and support, threatening the ability and rights of unrecognized language communities to use and develop their languages. These policies break promises made to ethnic minorities under China's constitution, under the Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law, and under international standards such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, and the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. In this hearing, we will hear from expert witnesses about the sinicization campaign that runs afoul of these standards for protecting linguistic rights. We'll hear about recent substantial reductions in the use of Mongolian language instruction and the harsh crackdown on Mongolian culture that followed protests over these policies. We'll hear about insidious and widespread efforts to separate Tibetan children from their parents, placing them in boarding schools to disrupt the intergenerational transmission of mother languages. And we'll hear about the detention and imprisonment that often befalls those who stand up for language, who stand up for cultural rights, including the personal experience of one of our witnesses after he opened a Uyghur language kindergarten. This coercive assimilation erodes language, culture, and identity for ethnic minorities in China. I look forward to today's witnesses helping the Commission better understand the costs to communities of these policies as we work with Uyghurs, Tibetans, Mongolians, and others to protect their cultures from destruction. Prepared Statement of Hon. James P. McGovern Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for holding this hearing on language and identity in the People's Republic of China. First, I join the Chair in welcoming the release of the Commission's Annual Report for 2021 last week. It comprehensively documents the Chinese government's appalling human rights record. The report takes countless hours to research, write, fact-check, and publish. I particularly want to praise the Commission's professional staff of researchers for their expertise and skill in producing each annual report. They do amazing work and are a valued resource for this Commission and the entire Congress. These researchers do their work objectively. They check out every single fact. The reporting is impeccably accurate, which makes this report especially powerful. I can't thank them enough. Those of both parties who care about human rights ought to recognize their incredible work. Let me quote from author James Baldwin in a 1979 essay. He writes, ``Language is a political instrument, means, and proof of power. People evolve a language in order to describe and thus control their circumstances, or in order not to be submerged by a reality that they cannot articulate. And, if they cannot articulate it, they are submerged.'' Baldwin was writing in a different context, but his message is one that anthropologists and political scientists confirm: that language is the core of a people's identity. The People's Republic of China is a multilingual society. There are 56 official languages, and hundreds more that are not formally recognized by the state. On paper, language is protected under Chinese law. The PRC constitution gives ethnic minorities ``the freedom to use and develop their own spoken and written languages, and to preserve or reform their own ways and customs.'' In practice, however, we are witnessing the exact opposite. Government policies appear to promote standard Mandarin at the expense of other languages. This is happening as the Party under Xi Jinping imposes a coercive conformity across all facets of society. This trend provides the context and the central question for this hearing: Is the Chinese government and Party deliberately eroding the language rights of ethnic minorities in a quest for majoritarian political control? And in so doing, isn't the government violating rights guaranteed under the Chinese constitution and law? This Commission has documented protests by Tibetans, Mongolians, and others against restrictions on their own languages. These protests are often suppressed. People are jailed for simply asking that their guaranteed rights be respected. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses today about the threats to the Mongolian, Tibetan, and Uyghur languages under PRC policies, and what this means for the concept of ethnic autonomy. I also look forward to hearing about the vulnerability of the hundreds of unofficial languages that also deserve protection and preservation. So again, Mr. Chairman, thank you for holding this hearing. Submissions for the Record ------ [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] INTENTIONALLY BLANK Witness Biographies Gerald Roche, anthropologist, Senior Research Fellow, Department of Politics, Media and Philosophy, La Trobe University Gerald Roche is an anthropologist who is currently a Senior Research Fellow in the Department of Politics, Media and Philosophy at La Trobe University, a La Trobe Asia Fellow, and a co-chair of the Global Coalition for Language Rights. His research contributions have been recognized in several awards, including a La Trobe University Mid- Career Research Award and an Australian Research Council Discovery Early Career Research Award. His work focuses on issues of power, the state, colonialism, and race in Asia, particularly in the transnational Himalayan region. Much of his research explores how these issues manifest in the language politics of this linguistically diverse area, through state-sponsored language oppression and the social movements and community practices which seek to resist it. He has also researched and written on issues of racism, ethnicity, urbanization, popular music, and community ritual in the region, and how these are shaped by both state power and transnational flows. Enghebatu Togochog, Director, Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center Enghebatu Togochog is the Director of the Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center. In 2001, he established the Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center (SMHRIC), a New York-based human rights organization dedicated to promoting and protecting the rights of the Mongolian people in Inner Mongolia. Currently he is the Director of the SMHRIC and the chief editor of the organizational newsletter ``Southern Mongolia Watch.'' He has testified before the United Nations Human Rights Council, United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, United Nations Forum on Minority Issues, United Nations Committee against Torture, and European Parliament. In 2002, he testified before the CECC. His work includes the translation of ``Way Out of Southern Mongolia'' and ``Genocide on the Mongolian Steppe.'' Lhadon Tethong, co-founder and Director, Tibet Action Institute Lhadon Tethong is the co-founder and Director of the Tibet Action Institute where she leads a team of technologists and rights advocates in developing open-source technologies, strategies, and training programs for Tibetans and others living under extreme repression. Formerly the Executive Director of Students for a Free Tibet International (2002-2009), Lhadon led the high-profile global campaign to condemn China's rule of Tibet in the lead-up to and during the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games. As China prepared for the Games in 2007, she made international headlines as she posted real-time accounts of her travels through Beijing on her blog--one of the first in the Tibetan world--BeijingWideOpen.org. Ayup Abduweli, Uyghur writer and linguist Ayup Abduweli is a writer and linguist specializing in Uyghur language education. Born in 1973 near Kashgar in the Uyghur region, he completed his bachelor's studies in Turkic literature at Minzu University in 1997 and earned a master's degree at Xinjiang University in 2001. He was a professor at Northwest Minzu University and Xinjiang Financial and Economic University for nine years. He obtained a master's degree in linguistics in 2011 from the University of Kansas in Lawrence. He was a proponent of linguistic rights and an active promoter of Uyghur language education, returning to Xinjiang in 2011 after graduation. Abduweli opened language schools and kindergartens in the cities of Urumchi and Kashgar. During this time, he was subjected to repeated interrogations and harassment by Chinese authorities. He was arrested in August 2013 and accused of promoting separatist activities. After 15 months in detention, he fled to Turkey from China with his family in August 2015. In Turkey, he collected camp detainees' stories and documented the plight of the Uyghur diaspora, especially of Uyghurs in Turkey. Since 2019, Abduweli has lived in Bergen, Norway, as a writer-in-residence through the ICORN program. In September 2016, Abduweli founded the organization Uyghur Hjelp, advocating and documenting the Uyghur plight with his team and providing aid to Uyghurs in Turkey. [all]