Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- STAKEHOLDER VIEWS ON THE BROWNFIELDS PROGRAM REAUTHORIZATION [Senate Hearing 117-656] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 117-656 STAKEHOLDER VIEWS ON THE BROWNFIELDS PROGRAM REAUTHORIZATION ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ SEPTEMBER 28, 2022 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Environment and Public Works [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 51-973PDF WASHINGTON : 2023 COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION THOMAS R. CARPER, Delaware, Chairman BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, Maryland SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont Virginia SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island Ranking Member JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon JAMES M. INHOFE, Oklahoma EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts KEVIN CRAMER, North Dakota TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming DEBBIE STABENOW, Michigan RICHARD SHELBY, Alabama MARK KELLY, Arizona JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas ALEX PADILLA, California ROGER WICKER, Mississippi DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska JONI ERNST, Iowa LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina Mary Frances Repko, Democratic Staff Director Adam Tomlinson, Republican Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page SEPTEMBER 28, 2022 OPENING STATEMENTS Carper, Hon. Thomas R., U.S. Senator from the State of Delaware.. 1 Capito, Hon. Shelly More, U.S. Senator from the State of West Virginia....................................................... 3 WITNESSES Goldstein, Michael, Managing Partner, Goldstein Environmental Law Firm........................................................... 6 Prepared statement........................................... 9 Buschur, Brad, Project Director, Groundwork Lawrence............. 14 Prepared statement........................................... 17 Responses to Additional Questions from Senators: Carper................................................... 21 Kelly.................................................... 21 Pouncey, Gerald, Chairman, Morris, Manning, And Martin, LLP...... 23 Prepared statement........................................... 26 Responses to Additional Questions from Senators: Carper................................................... 28 Kelly.................................................... 29 Carico, George, Director, West Virginia Brownfields Assistance Center, Marshall University.................................... 31 Prepared statement........................................... 33 Responses to Additional Questions from Senators: Carper................................................... 36 Kelly.................................................... 37 Sullivan................................................. 38 STAKEHOLDER VIEWS ON THE BROWNFIELDS PROGRAM REAUTHORIZATION ---------- WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 28, 2022 U.S. Senate, Committee on Environment and Public Works, Washington, DC. The committee, met, pursuant to notice, at 10:03 a.m. in room 406, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Thomas R. Carper (chairman of the committee) presiding. Present: Senators Carper, Capito, Cardin, Whitehouse, Padilla, Sullivan, Ernst. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. THOMAS R. CARPER, U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF DELAWARE Senator Carper. I call this hearing to order. Good morning one and all, Senator Capito, good to see you. To our staffs, thank you for helping us put this important hearing together. Today we are going to discuss the Environmental Protection Agency's Brownfields Program as we begin to work on the program's reauthorization. For nearly three decades now, the Brownfields program has proven to be an important source of help for communities forced to contend with the long-term impacts of hazardous waste and other types of contamination. The program provides Federal assistance for communities to clean up contaminated lands, to revitalize the areas and rededicate the land to productive centers of civic and economic activity. We most recently reauthorized appropriations for this program with strong bipartisan support about 5 years ago, I think it was 2018. So it is time now to review the State of the Brownfields Program, and to examine what works well, to identify potential ways to update the program so it can best meet the evolving challenges that communities face. I like to say, everything I do I know I can do better. That includes our oversight of this program and the way this program operates throughout the Country. Fortunately, we have four distinguished witnesses joining, actually three this morning, and a fourth remotely. We have three distinguished witnesses joining us in person, and another remotely. They each possess decades of hands-on experience working with communities, working with State and local governments, private developers on brownfield sites across our Country. Mr. Goldstein is joining us remotely. Mr. Carico, Mr. Buschur, and Mr. Pouncey are here. Thank you all for joining us today. Senator Capito will in a minute introduce George Carico, a fellow from West Virginia. We have already had a chance to chat. We look forward to hearing from each of you. Before we do, I will deliver the history of this important program. The EPA's Brownfields and Land Revitalization Program began in 1995 with the purpose of cleaning up thousands of lower-risk pollutionsites across our Country known as brownfields. The program provided seed money and technical assistance to State and local authorities working with private developers to revitalize these brownfields, transform them. In other words, the program took the adversity of pollution and turned it into an opportunity for economic development and growth. Since that time, the program has grown both in scope and in impact. In 2002, Congress codified the program into law, authorizing EPA to assist with assessments, remediation, with job training, and site planning. In our most recent reauthorization of the program in 2018, we also broadened the types of assistance that could be provided and expanded eligibility for the program. The benefits of this program have proven themselves time and time again. According to EPA, the Brownfields Program has assisted in the assessment of over 35,000 contaminated properties and cleanups of over 2,300 sites across our Nation, probably in every State. The agency also reports that every dollar of Federal assistance leverages over $20 of non-Federal money for revitalization. This has contributed to the creation of over 180,000 jobs since 1995. That is a lot of jobs for a little State like Delaware, and even for a big State like West Virginia. We have seen the positive impacts of the program first-hand in Delaware. Since the program began, the First State has received millions in grants, helping to revitalize areas such as our riverfront along the Christina River in Wilmington, Delaware. Once a shipbuilding site turned toxic site, it is a site right close to our train station. If we go back to World War II, about 60, 70 years ago, 10,000 people worked along the Christina River close to the train station, for about a mile either way. Ten thousand people, mostly women, building the ships that helped win the war in World War II. When the war was over, we ended up with a toxic site. The question was what to do about it. What we have done about it is replaced it with something called the Wilmington Riverfront. It is a thriving place to live and work and we have a lot to thank with respect to the Brownfields Program and this wonderful outcome. Many Americans may remember that also as a place that President-Elect Biden proclaimed a victory after the election 2 years ago. So as we consider brownfields reauthorization, this committee should examine whether specific opportunities exist to further strengthen this program. I believe this reexamination should include building upon the program's existing capacity and resources, however, to help local authorities with area-wide and regional planning of brownfields remediation. Increased support for planning will ensure that communities are better able to maximize the benefits of projects. As our Nation continues to grapple with the adverse impacts of climate change and extreme weather, I am reminded of that today in thinking of our neighbors and friends in Florida, who are getting a terrible punishing from the hurricane that is working its way up the coast. But the Brownfields program should also encourage sustainable revitalization projects. By doing so, we can support community efforts to become more resilient to climate change while reducing greenhouse gas emissions. In addition, the program should incorporate environmental justice principles and practices to ensure that the people and communities negatively affected by local land pollution can fully participate in the benefits of brownfield revitalization. Finally, as we consider ways to improve the Brownfields Program, we should ensure that the program not only assists communities with financial and technical burdens of revitalizing contaminated lands, but also encourages stakeholders to fully engage with residents during the planning and execution of projects. Let me close by reiterating that now is the right time to explore and revisit improvements to this vital program. Last year, we provided EPA with a threefold increase in funding for the Brownfields Program under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, which this committee, Senator Capito knows, we literally helped to write in this room. We need to ensure that the program can use these additional resources to the greatest effect in assisting our cities, our towns, our communities, and our tribes. I look forward to our discussion today and the work that lies ahead of all of us. Again, we welcome all of our witnesses in person and remotely. Let me turn now to Senator Capito for her remarks. Thank you. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA Senator Capito. Thank you, Chairman Carper. I want to thank you for holding the hearing to talk about EPA's Brownfields Program. I want to thank all the witnesses for being here with us today. It is a rare occasion when an EPA program enjoys strong bipartisan support along this committee's dais, as we know. Since first being authorized in 2002, the Brownfields Program has become a resounding success story for our economy and the environment. Since we are on the east coast and developed a lot earlier, we have a lot of these older sites in both of our States. Brownfields are pieces of property where redevelopment is complicated by the presence of hazardous contamination. A large variety of contaminated properties are potential brownfields sites. Common examples are abandoned factories, landfills, and former gas stations, dry cleaners. We had an issue with a dry cleaner actually in our State. These underdeveloped properties line the streets of what once were bustling industrial, commercial, and agricultural areas across our Nation, discouraging investment in job creation, reducing local tax revenues and harming property values. Rather than viewing these properties as a stain on our community, the Brownfields Program recognizes the vast untapped economic potential these contaminated sites can have, after they have been successfully remediated. Since the program's inception, $36 billion in brownfields grants funding has been allocated to local communities, creating about 192,000 jobs. In addition, EPA's Brownfields Program is one of the most effectively leveraged financing tool across the entire Federal Government, providing a return of more than $20 for every $1 contributed by the EPA. Brownfields grants serve as a valuable financing tool for local communities and private investors by providing reliable funding and facilitating long-term re-use planning. The grants help incentivize private sector participation by reducing financial risks, and shielding developers from potential liability under CERCLA. In order to be successful, the Brownfields Program relies upon the establishment of effective public-private partnerships where all parties have a vested interest in the long-term restoration of a contaminated site. These partnerships help our local communities enjoy the benefits of economic development for decades to come. While we all recognize the successes of brownfields, we must acknowledge, as the Chairman did, that improvements are needed. This is particularly important if we are to maximize that return on the $1.5 billion investment the program received from the IIJA. For example, Congress appropriately intended brownfields grants to be awarded on a competitive basis. However, rigorous and complex application requirements remain a continued source of confusion within the program. Applicants typically have only 60 days to compete and submit an application from the date EPA announces another year's round of grant solicitations. The short timeframes and complicated requirements often lead to situations where rural communities are unable to compete with their larger, urban counterparts due to a lack of resources. Unlike larger cities and urban centers, local municipalities typically are operating on a shoestring budget and lack the good fortunate of having multiple full-time grant writers on their staff. This makes it an uphill battle for our rural communities when they try to compete. As Mr. Carico told me earlier, you lose points quickly. He says he has had projects that have been 92s that have not made it. So you can see how competitive it is. Discrepancies in staff resources and experience impede rural communities from competing on a level playing field, ultimately leaving many promising rural brownfield development opportunities unrealized in disadvantaged areas that really need them most. Until you can clean that and remediate, you are not going to get any development around it. EPA deserves credit for recognizing that there is a problem. One way the agency has attempted to address the issue is through the establishment of the Technical Assistance to Brownfield communities program, otherwise known as TAB. There are six recipients of TAB funding, and I understand the Morgantown office in West Virginia is a TAB-funded place, referred to as TAB providers, with each being assigned to a specific region in the Country. TAB providers serve as an independent resource, assisting applicants with expert technical assistance and guidance to help them better navigate the brownfield application process. They serve an important role in facilitating more grant applications in small and rural communities that lack their own grant-writing capacity. So we are privileged to have with us today someone who has worked with the TAB program and also has worked in West Virginia for many, many years, and that is George Carico. George serves as the Director of the West Virginia Regional Brownfields Assistance Center at Marshall University. He has devoted his entire career to the brownfields arena, helping to bring much-needed funding to our State and the region. Mr. Carico, I want to recommend you for the high praise the West Virginia Brownfields Assistance Centers often receive from the broader brownfields stakeholder community. Thank you. Your forward-looking and innovative approach to maximizing rural participation in brownfields grant opportunities should be a model for other rural areas in the Country. I look forward a to hearing about the work you have undertaken in rural areas to facilitate economic redevelopment and community vibrancy. We are also joined by Gerald Pouncey, thank you, Chairman of the Morris, Manning and Martin Law Firm, with decades of experience in the acquisition and redevelopment of hundreds of brownfield properties. Mr. Pouncey will provide this committee with a much-needed perspective from the developer side. Mr. Pouncey's past work was praised by EPA as a best practice in brownfield redevelopment. He continues to receive numerous accolades, having been honored as the environmental lawyer of the year in 2017, and is one of Atlanta's 500 most influential leaders. Thank you for coming today. I look forward to hearing about how private sector participation in the Brownfield Program is so important to long-term success. I want to thank everybody for being here. It is an important hearing. Chairman Carper, I will yield back to you. Senator Carper. Thanks you very much, Senator Capito. I want to add, a lot of people, they watch what goes on in Washington and they think we never agree on anything. You are welcome to a committee today where we actually work across the aisle remarkably well. The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law that the President signed into law 10 months ago, the most far- reaching, transformative infrastructure legislation in the history of the Country, we reported it out, the roads, highways, bridges portion unanimously. We reported out the water and wastewater, flood part unanimously. We reported it out, and that really became the foundation on which the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law was built. More recently, we passed out unanimously WRDA, water resources development legislation for the Senate. We have done similar things with recycling legislation this year. More often than not, we find the middle and work toward getting stuff done. I am a practical politician, recovering Governor, and Senator Capito is very much a practical politician. We are both West Virginians at heart. So it is a pleasure to work with her, her team, and we are delighted that you are all with us today. In terms of introductions, Senator Capito has already that for a couple of our witnesses. I would add to that Mr. Goldstein, who is an environmental law attorney and leader in brownfield development joining us from Florida. He is the founding chairman of the Florida Brownfields Association. I know Mr. Goldstein wanted to join us in person, but Hurricane Ian has prevented his travel. We are glad he can join us over WebEx, which I understand he is literally doing from the middle of the hurricane. My parents lived the last 30 years of their lives in Clearwater. I think they are under the gun there today. So we are thinking of them and the neighbors up and down the Gulf Coast. Mr. Brad Buschur, Brad, nice of you to join us. He is the Project Director for the Groundwork Lawrence, in Lawrence, Massachusetts, where I understand you have led a number of brownfield redevelopment within that particular area. Mr. Pouncey, we have had comments already from Senator Capito. The chairman, I said to him before, we are both chairmen. You can never have too many of them. [Laughter.] Senator Carper. He is Chairman of the Morris, Manning and Martin Law Firm in Atlanta, Georgia, which along with Mr. Goldstein's firm is a member of the National Brownfields Coalition. I understand you are the principal author of Georgia's new brownfields legislation as well. So it will be interesting to hear the insights you will provide. Finally, our friend from West Virginia, Mr. Carico, who is the Director of West Virginia Brownfields Assistance Center at Marshall University, Thundering Herd, and We Are Marshall, which assists communities across West Virginia on brownfields redevelopment. I told him before we started, Senator Capito, that my sister is a proud graduate of Marshall and a bunch of my cousins as well. About every 10, 20 years, they just knock somebody off in college football. Michigan State about 15 years ago, and earlier this year, Notre Dame. My sister and cousins are hard to live with when that happens. But I will get through it, and so will they. Our thanks to each of you for joining us. Mr. Goldstein, we are going to lead off with you. Again, thank you for connecting with us in this very difficult and trying time in Florida. Please proceed. Thank you. STATEMENT OF MICHAEL R. GOLDSTEIN, ESQ., THE GOLDSTEIN ENVIRONMENTAL LAW FIRM Mr. Goldstein. Thank you. Good morning, Chairman Carper, Ranking Member Capito, and members of the committee. My name is Michael Goldstein. I am the Managing Partner of The Goldstein Environmental Law Firm, a principal of Goldstein Kite Environmental, the past president of the Florida Brownfields Foundation, and chair of the National Brownfields Coalition's Public Policy, Redevelopment Incentives, and Regulatory Partnerships Committee. The Coalition, jointly managed by Smart Growth America and the Center for Creative Land Recycling, is a non-partisan alliance advocating for equitable remediation and redevelopment of brownfields nationwide. It is an honor to participate, thank you for this opportunity. My remarks today are informed by three decades of experience assisting businesses, local governments and community stakeholders remediate, redevelopment and re-use contaminated sites. Other witnesses today will no doubt speak to the magnificent Brownfields Grant Program administered by EPA, which has transformed how environmentally challenged and marginalized communities think about pollution, where they live, work, pray, and play. EPA's Brownfields Program and the funding that Congress has increasingly made available beginning in the mid-1990's has given the voiceless a voice and the powerless agency. This program is constantly evolving, innovating and reinventing. In terms of a regulatory strategy, it is as close to perfect as one could possibly want. Of course, the program is animated by the people who implement it. So I also want to take a moment to acknowledge and celebrate EPA staff in the Brownfields Program and the Superfund Redevelopment Program. If there are harder-working, more committed professionals in the environmental arena that make a difference in the millions of Americans every single day, I haven't met them yet. Turning to our substantive recommendations, the Coalition encourages this committee to double down on the boldness of the Federal Brownfields Program by adding to the resources that are currently available, not just enhancing those on the books. We need to add more tools to the toolbox by one, innovating legislatively with respect to financial resources, and two, providing additional mandates to certain Federal agencies to increase the regulatory firepower that communities and stakeholders can tap into. On the financial side, we recommend three new discrete funding opportunities. First, as part of a reauthorization bill, renew the Federal Brownfield Tax Deduction. Before it expired in 2011, this incentive allowed a party who voluntarily cleaned up contaminated property to deduct its cleanup costs in the year incurred. A report prepared by the Coalition showed that Section 198 of the Tax Code reduced remediation costs by one-third to one-half. Before sunsetting, it was used more than 625 times in more than 40 States. Second, we strongly recommend the creation of a Brownfields Loan Guarantee Program. This program would combine the aspects of the DOE Loan Guarantee program with the New Markets Tax Credit Program to leverage many billions of private sector dollars for early stage bridge financing of redevelopment projects that are considered too risky for conventional lenders. In my professional experience, there are countless projects that fail in the concept stage because they are caught in an unwinnable position. They are not loan-worthy until the environmental risks are cleared, but the environmental risks can't be cleared until loan funding becomes available. Third, Brownfields Reauthorization is an elegant and timely vehicle to combat the affordable housing crisis in this Country. So we are recommending a significant expansion of the way in which affordable housing is funded at the Federal level. To that end, we would like to see an increase of a 4 percent and 9 percent low-income housing tax credit under Section 42 of the IRS Code to 6 percent and 12 percent for affordable housing built on brownfield sites, a stepped-up basis under Section 42 of the Tax Code of between 130 percent to 150 percent for affordable housing built on brownfield sites, and a huge game changer: a new, one-time LIHTC in the amount of 80 percent of the cost of land acquisition to develop affordable housing built on brownfields. On the agency resources side, Mr. Chairman, we believe there is a much more active role that at least three agencies under this committee's jurisdiction can play in support of brownfields revitalization: the Federal Highway Administration, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the Economic Development Administration. Each of these agencies is deeply resourced, experienced, and credentialed, but to date has been functionally absent in the Federal brownfields arena. First, through reauthorization, Congress should direct FHA to provide technical and financial assistance including grant funding for brownfield redevelopment projects that are transit- oriented, that invest in environmental justice neighborhoods, that provide multiple transit options, and that reduce the distance, the cost, and the impact on climate of connecting people from home to school or work and all points in between. Second, the Army Corps likely has the largest working storehouse of environmental data and information regarding the remediation technologies in the Country. Access to this information should be readily available to stakeholders everywhere. Relatedly, the Corps could and should publish guidance documents regarding lessons learned, involving cleanup of common contaminants at brownfield sites, as well as emerging contaminants like PFAS. The Corps' rich experience with coastal communities creates tremendous opportunities for disseminating climate change-focused brownfields strategies. Also relatedly, we would like to see a brownfields grant program administered through the Corps that emphasizes climate change, sea level rise, acute public health risks, and environmental justice. Finally, Mr. Chair, through reauthorization, Congress should expand on EDA's mandate to promote sustainable job growth and the building of durable regional economies in two ways. First by directing that EDA convene a national public- private summit on brownfields economic policy and priorities, and second, by directing the creation of a standalone brownfield grant program that pulls from EDA's existing funding appropriations and repackages them to be utilized for a combination of cleanup, public health, job creation and job training activities with an emphasis on climate stewardship, energy security, and creative, affordable, and transit-oriented housing. The National Brownfields Coalition thanks the committee for its consideration of these remarks and I look forward to responding to any questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Goldstein follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Carper. Thank you so much for that thoughtful testimony. I would say to the witnesses who are here, one of the things I look for in hearings, as Senator Capito knows, is where is there consensus among the witnesses. Mr. Goldstein has laid out quite a list there. I am interested in seeing what you agree with, and maybe a couple of areas where you don't. That would be helpful. OK, thanks, Mr. Goldstein. We wish everyone down there in Florida our very best. We are here to help. Mr. Buschur, you are up. We are delighted that you are able to be here in person. Please proceed. STATEMENT OF BRAD BUSCHUR, PROJECT DIRECTOR, GROUNDWORK LAWRENCE Mr. Buschur. Chairman Carper, Ranking Member Capito, and members of the committee, thank you for giving me the opportunity to testify today on the Environmental Protection Agency's Brownfields Program. I represent Groundwork Lawrence, where I am a project director responsible for leading the organization's environmental improvement programs. Groundwork Lawrence is a community-based organization working to create a high quality built and natural environment by renovating existing parks, creating new recreational opportunities, and stewarding Lawrence's three rivers. We transform vacant and contaminated properties into parks and green spaces to support healthy active lifestyles. We are part of a network of independent locally based Groundwork Trusts in 25 cities and 18 states. Trusts are established with support from the National Park Service, the Environmental Protection Agency, and local stakeholders. Groundwork Trusts deploy a collaborative, community-wide and people-centered approach in the development of greenspaces and the restoration of the environment in the city, ensuring all stakeholders are invested in the project. I am speaking to you today, on behalf of Groundwork Lawrence, about the organization's work in the city of Lawrence, Massachusetts. Located 30 miles north of Boston, Lawrence is a planned industrial city founded in the early 1840's. Central to the city's rise as a center of textile and paper production is the construction of the Great Stone Dam along the Merrimack River, which diverted water to the north and south canals to provide power to the mills along its banks. Lawrence quickly became known as the immigrant city. By 1910, 90 percent of the city's 80,000 residents were either first-or second-generation Americans, and the city had become the largest manufacturer of worsted woolen textiles in the world. However, by the end of World War II, deindustrialization was in full force as mill owners moved their capital and employment out of Lawrence to lower cost regions. The challenges associated with Lawrence's deindustrialization are significant. Abandoned mills are impacted by polyaromatic hydrocarbons, petroleum, chlorinated solvents, arsenic, lead, PCBs, and cadmium. A wave of arson and abandonment in the 1980's left vacant housing lots potentially contaminated by lead and asbestos. Multiple trash incinerators formerly located in Lawrence have all been shuttered, but they left behind soils contaminated with dioxins from burning plastics and medical waste. The city's densely populated neighborhoods frequently abut industrial and commercial areas, exposing residents to contaminants by direct contact or inhalation of vapors via migration from soil into indoor air. Many of Lawrence's contaminated properties are small and interspersed throughout residential areas and present potential risks to human health for the homes and businesses surrounding them. The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection lists 332 identified sites with environmental constraints spread across Lawrence's seven square miles. Today the city is an economic and cultural center of the Merrimack Valley with over 90,000 residents, 80 percent of whom are Latino. The city has benefited from hundreds of millions of dollars of private investment in the redevelopment of its historic mills that now provide market rate and affordable homes for residents. Unlike many older urban areas, the city has a young and growing population, fueled by the influx of Caribbean immigrants who bring new energy, businesses, and dreams. In a city notorious for ethnic tensions, there is growing momentum behind the city's broad-based community revitalization efforts, a hard-working and entrepreneurial community, a high- functioning nonprofit sector, and renewed community vitality with the election of Mayor Brian DePena who recently led a tour of the city's brownfield redevelopment targets. Since 1996, the city of Lawrence has received $3.65 million in EPA Brownfields Program funding. The city has successfully utilized these grants to bring forth substantial economic benefits including leveraging $12 million in State and Federal funds and $51 million in private funding to assess, cleanup, and redevelop complex industrial properties and the creation of more than 200 construction jobs as well as an additional 200 permanent jobs. This is related to the Union Crossing project. Lawrence currently has two active brownfield cleanup grants to support redevelopment of the largest remaining parcels in the city. The most challenging project is the Tombarello Site, a 14-acre former recycling facility abutting residential properties and a school with extensive PCB contamination. The other project is the Merrimac Paper Site, comprised of 27 interconnected dilapidated buildings encompassing over 1.3 million square feet. Built in 1866, the site has become a perennial fire hazard placing first responders and public health at risk. Both properties have benefited from actions taken by the EPA Brownfields Program prior to the city taking ownership. EPA's Region I Emergency Planning and Response Branch undertook significant remedial actions to address imminent public health risks created by private property owners. Groundwork Lawrence has been fortunate to support the city's efforts to reclaim brownfields to provide residents with access to recreational opportunities within neighborhoods where the poverty rate, income levels, and sensitive populations are drastically higher than the rest of the State. Central to this work is the creation of the Spicket River Greenway. Over 12 years, Groundwork and the city created six new riverfront parks and connected them with a 3.5 mile long shared-use path providing residents with close-to-home high-quality parks. EPA Brownfield Program funding supported remediation of four of the new parks by providing $600,000 of the over $10 million required to create these projects. Additionally, the Land and Water Conservation Fund and the Community Development Block Grant programs are vital to supporting the creation of these spaces. As this committee undertakes reauthorization of the Brownfields Program, Groundwork Lawrence recommends evaluating three areas of the program. The statutory limit placed on EPA's cleanup grants is $500,000 per parcel which is a significant amount of money, but offsite disposal and transportation costs have increased dramatically over the past 5 years. Another item future legislation should address is making building demolition an eligible cleanup expense. Uncontrolled demolition of buildings through fire or neglect is often the source of environmental contamination placing public health and the environment at risk. Most importantly, future legislation should require strong community engagement to ensure all impacted residents have a strong voice in the redevelopment process of brownfields. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Buschur follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Carper. Mr. Buschur, thank you very much. Now, we are going to turn to Mr. Pouncey. Please proceed. Welcome. STATEMENT OF GERALD POUNCEY, CHAIRMAN, MORRIS, MANNING, AND MARTIN, LLP Mr. Pouncey. Mr. Chairman, Senator Capito, members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to testify today. This is a very personal issue to me. I grew up in a textile mill village in central Alabama, where my family and I worked either in the mills or the surrounding manufacturing facilities around those mills. Both of those mills are now closed and abandoned. So I am very sensitive, Senator Capito, to some of the questions and issues you raised about how we redevelop in some of these rural or not-so-urban areas which suffer from the same concerns about brownfields that you suffer from in the metropolitan areas that Mr. Buschur mentioned. In discussing brownfields, it is important to understand the consequences of the failure to clean up these sites. In large measure, these properties have either been, as in the case with the mills that I mentioned, completely abandoned, or in some instances, they are severely underutilized, meaning they are operating on a skeletal crew, to avoid intentionally certain EPA permitting requires kicking in once they are closed. They become significant safety hazards, particularly to young children, as an attractive nuisance. They represent a threat to the communities in that condition. The serve as a magnet for crime in many instances. They also constitute an environmental risk to the surrounding communities simply because of deteriorating buildings very often containing a number of hazardous substances, asbestos is one that comes to mind immediately, and the contamination that exists in the soil or the stormwater. What I don't think we have focused on, and I am going to take a little bit of a departure from the first two witnesses' comments, is the challenges that we have to redevelop these sites, particularly from a private perspective. These brownfield sites require a significant upfront investment in capital and in cost. Very often, the testing that you do to determine if the site is even viable for redevelopment can cost five to ten times what you would do if you are developing a greenfield. Similarly, you are making that investment with no certainty that you are going to realize on the ultimate redevelopment. Very often, those test results may say that the redevelopment is not viable because of the level of impacts that exist at that site. So we need to recognize that challenge for a private developer coming in and making this investment, that he is putting a significant amount of his working capital at risk with no certainty, in fact with some real odds to realize on that risk. I will come back to that in a few minutes in terms of the financial incentives that we have created. The second difficulty, and I say this both as leading a lot of brownfields redevelopment efforts across the Country but also personally doing some redevelopment in these areas as well, is there is an inherent delay in cleaning these sites up before you start the redevelopment. And there is an inherent additional cost that must occur with respect to that cleanup after you purchase the property. So it is not just the investment you make before you buy it, it is the investment you make after you buy it for purposes of cleanup. I will come back to that in a minute as well. So the question becomes, how do we create the incentive that encourages the private sector, either on its own or jointly with the public sector, to redevelop these sites. I would offer that one of the most effective ways to do this is to move these sites to State brownfield programs that exist in all of your States and in many of the States of the committee members. I will give you one example of the effectiveness of those State brownfield programs. Mr. Chairman, you mentioned that I was the author of the Georgia Brownfield Law, which we actually began implementation of that law in 2004. Since that law was implemented just in the State of Georgia, over 1,300 properties have gone into that brownfield program. Almost 800 properties have achieved cleanup under that program. That is a private incentivized program for cleanup. It has been effective not just in the metropolitan areas of Georgia; it has been effective in the rural areas of Georgia. The reason, like most programs, it provides two things that are critical. No. 1, it provides a financial incentive to conduct that cleanup. You are able to recover your cleanup costs back from your property taxes. So if I spend a million dollars on cleanup, and my property, because of the redevelopment, has increased in value, I am able to recover from that increase in value my cleanup cost. We are also able to monetize that, which means that if I sell the property later, my buyer will also then benefit from that offset in taxes that I can recover that sum from my buyer. That is a major incentive which has, quite frankly, underwritten a lot of these deals that otherwise would not have occurred. The second protection it provides, which is common with a lot of the State programs that I have discussed, is a liability protection. Senator Capito, you mentioned that earlier. That is, if I am a buyer who had no responsibility for the contamination, I didn't even own the property when the contamination occurred, and I am agreeing to come in and conduct a State or federally approved cleanup, if I don't have certain liability protections that attach to me in doing that, I have no incentive to come in and perform that cleanup. Most of the States have recognized that and introduced these liability protection provisions, some broader than others, that give you protection, and quite candidly, and perhaps even more importantly, give your lenders protection, so that I am able to get the financing necessary to fund those projects. That also is important when we are dealing with rural redevelopment or small-town redevelopment, as well as urban redevelopment, is being able to get the financing resources. The other item that I would note, and I will pause for a moment because in anticipation of my testimony over the last 2 weeks, I have spoken with the heads of several brownfield programs across the south, individuals with whom I deal on a weekly basis. I have asked them what is the biggest issue for them in terms of their ability to even more successfully implement these brownfield programs. For them, honestly, it is funding for the grant programs. The States, we talk about where we can invest this money, in assessments, in cleanup, and I am about to come back to your cleanup issue as well. Senator Carper. I do mean to say, your time is expired. But I am not going to cut you off. But we have other witnesses, and we have to ask you to wrap up. Mr. Pouncey. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will tie this up really quickly. The predominant comment by all these brownfield programs has been, we need the funding to keep these programs active. Some of them are fee-based. But the fees don't cover all the costs of the program. That is the predominant concern that I hear among those brownfield programs. Finally, I would note an item that my co-witness mentioned earlier, that is, there has been a lot of money spent in these grant programs on assessment. But the real price, the real cost is on the cleanup side. So raising the limit on the funds associated with cleanup is absolutely imperative in terms of allowing these programs to move forward. If there is one thing I can point to, and I think that is a great comment, but that is a burden when you get to the front door but you can't get in the front door because you don't have the funds to do the cleanup. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [The prepared statement of Mr. Pouncey follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Carper. Thank you very, very much for that testimony, all of it. Mr. Carico, you are on. Welcome. STATEMENT OF GEORGE CARICO, DIRECTOR, WEST VIRGINIA BROWNFIELDS ASSISTANCE CENTER, MARSHALL UNIVERSITY Mr. Carico. Thank you, Senator Carper, and Senator Capito. I really appreciate the opportunity to be here. I am George Carico. I am Director of the West Virginia Brownfields Assistance Center at Marshall University. I am here today to offer our experience on the value and importance of redeveloping brownfield properties and show our support for continuation of the Brownfields Program and offer some input on how this valuable program can be strengthened. Our Brownfields Assistance Center works in conjunction with the Brownfields Center at West Virginia University. These centers were established in 2005 by State legislation to assist communities and organizations across West Virginia in redeveloping brownfield properties for new and productive use. We have seen first-hand the importance of EPA brownfields funding, how these investments have resulted in strengthening of local and regional economies while adding new community vibrancy and resiliency to our cities and towns. Reutilizing brownfield properties for new commercial and industrial businesses, residential use, government, and recreational use has been quite prosperous for several communities, and it is our goal to see more successes, especially in our smaller communities and rural areas. West Virginia is just like most States, we have thousands of brownfield properties, found in all sizes and conditions. These properties can be quite challenging to redevelop, primarily due to the environmental hazards they contain, or are perceived to contain. Properly assessing and, if needed, remediating environmental hazards is vital to transforming these properties into new, productive use while ensuring the future safety of human health and the environment. EPA brownfields funding is providing this vital component. Since 2005, our Centers have seen a wide variety of successful brownfield projects. EPA states they have invested approximately $41 million in brownfield funding in West Virginia, resulting in an estimated $1.6 billion in leveraged funds, and creating about 5,400 jobs in our State. While I can provide dozens of examples, I will quickly focus on three different but important projects to illustrate this success. The first one is the Shepherdstown Library. Shepherdstown is one of the oldest towns in West Virginia, and they were in dire need of a new library building, as the old building was way too small and they had inadequate parking, lots of issues there. The most suitable location that could provide enough space was identified at the edge of their town. Decades ago, that was the former town dump. The site was fully assessed, and corrective actions were conducted. In July of this year, the town celebrated its new library. Second example is the Huntington Fire Station. This brownfield site consisted of a former gas station and a dry cleaner facility. Brownfield funds were utilized to assess the property, identify the hazardous contaminants in the soil and groundwaters. The site was entered into the West Virginia voluntary remediation program. Just recently, a certificate of completion as issued. Now a new and strategically located fire station is under construction. The last example I will give you is the Beech Bottom Industrial Park. A steel mill operated here for decades along the Ohio River. After closing and sitting vacant for many, many years, brownfield funding was used to assess and remediate the site. In August of this year, it was announced that an electric pontoon boat manufacturing company will be the first tenant on part of the property, providing 100 new jobs and investing $5 million into the facility there. These are again just a few examples of projects where EPA's brownfields investments have played a critical role. If this funding were not available, most of these projects would not have happened. This funding gets environmentally impacted properties ready for new use, clearing the way for other funding streams to be utilized that will result in successful projects. While we have a lot of success stories, we have many, many more sites that still need attention, especially in our smaller communities and our rural areas, where the number of brownfield properties may be less but are equally as important. Due to limited capacity and resources, it is much more difficult for these smaller communities to compete against the larger cities and urban areas. Successfully applying for brownfield grant funding and meeting all the requirements can be a daunting challenge for these communities. They are often at a disadvantage to successfully compete. In closing, I will say this. The EPA has numerous programs that are of tremendous value and importance to the U.S. We, like many others, we consider the Brownfield Program to be their crown jewel. Some changes to the competitive process should be considered to make it easier for smaller communities to compete. But the Brownfields Program is definitely a true champion. I thank you, and look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Carico follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Carper. We have been looking forward to your testimony. Let me just say, you have met and exceeded, all of you, our hopes. I want to again commend our staffs for finding you and convincing you to come and join us. I already telegraphed my pitch and indicated one of the things I am looking for is finding consensus. We work well in this committee in finding consensus on major issues. I mentioned some of those earlier. I am going to start off by asking each of you to briefly respond to this. We will start with you, Mr. Buschur. I am interested in two areas, two ideas where you think there is consensus among the four of you that are important, that you think we should really pursue. Of all the things you have heard said, where are a couple of really great areas we should pursue? Because there is a lot of consensus. Mr. Buschur. I spend a lot of my time building parks. There is never enough money to do everything that the community wants. As illustrated by my testimony, EPA cleanup moneys provides a very small sliver of the overall amount of funding provided to construct these spaces. Communities are then obligated to maintain that engineered barrier to make sure the space is safe for residents. So the statutory limit increase is important. I would also go further to say that sites that remain fallow but have received funding from the EPA should also, previous funding for cleanup should also be eligible for additional cleanup funds. The statutory limit used to be $200,000. So I think there is consensus on increasing the statutory limit. The second area where I think, we didn't hear it from the individuals today, but I know listening sessions in Region 1 really highlighted the need for building demolition to be an eligible cleanup expense. It is pretty wild that a mill building has to burn and the contaminants have to end up in the soils to be eligible for cleanup. Senator Carper. Thanks. Mr. Pouncey, just quickly, two areas where there is good consensus that we ought to drill down on. Mr. Pouncey. Mr. Chairman, I agree, raising the limit on the remediation cost component is a big issue for purposes of these grants. As I mentioned earlier, very often you have the assessed money, so you get to the front door but you can't walk in because you can't afford the cleanup. I would consider that to be a significant item, along with, as part of that, including demolition costs. The second item with which I would agree, and I think Mr. Goldstein may have mentioned it, that is reintroducing, enacting or extending the Brownfield Tax Credit which allows you at the Federal level to expense your costs in the year they are incurred from a remediation standpoint. Senator Carper. OK, thank you. Same question, Mr. Carico. What great ideas do you think there is a lot of consensus around? Mr. Carico. First, I completely agree with the cleanup aspects. I will add, though, one good thing, this round of current funding that has come up, there are actually three layers to the cleanup grant process, or three levels of funding: $500,000, $1 million, and $2 million. The higher grant numbers, the funding numbers are a reduced number of grants. There probably need to be more in that higher level. But it is good to see that that is advancing, because it is costing a lot more to remediate sites. Second, I want to give a big amen to the demo side. Finding demolition money is always a very, very difficult one. The third one I would add is, the complexity of the application process for small communities with their limited capacity and their resources, it is very daunting and challenging for them. It is very hard to compete against the larger cities and urban areas. So putting in some items that could help them to where they can compete on a little bit more level playing field would be a great benefit for everybody, I think. Senator Carper. Thanks for those. Mr. Goldstein, are you still with us? Mr. Goldstein. Absolutely. Following along very, very closely, Mr. Chairman. Thank you so much. My first item where I see consensus starts with an observation that Ranking Member Capito made, and that is with respect to reforming the grant administrative process. It is overly burdensome and if we could streamline that, that would, I think, increase the competitiveness of not only rural communities but environmental justice communities who are also under-resourced, even though they are in urban areas. That is No. 1. And amen to the amen that we just heard on including demolition costs in the grant process. But the second main areas of consensus I see is with my brother, Gerald Pouncey, and that is finding a way to have EPA relinquish jurisdiction in sites with primary Federal enforcement, so we can get those sites into State brownfield programs where they can enjoy State-based liability protection incentives and economic incentives. In many States, including my State, Florida, the two are mutually exclusive. If a site is under Federal enforcement, it is ineligible to participate in a State brownfield program. So I think there is a lot of bang for the buck in looking at, exploring that relinquishing of Federal enforcement jurisdiction. Senator Carper. Thank you for those. Senator Ernst, Senator Capito has graciously offered to step aside and let you go ahead and ask your questions. Thank you for being a faithful attender of these hearings. Senator Ernst. Thank you. I appreciate that. I had a tough battle here with the chair when I got in, but I won. [Laughter.] Senator Carper. Let the record show Ernst 1, chair zero. Senator Ernst. I won this one. Thanks to all of our witnesses for being here today. We really do appreciate the discussion. The city of Des Moines has recently gained ownership of what is known as the former Dico site, which has been on the EPA's National Priority List since 1983. So Des Moines has actually taken a number of steps forward in collaboration with the EPA and the Iowa Department of Natural Resources in an attempt to redevelop this property. The goal is to house a professional soccer stadium and bring economic development opportunities to the community. However, there is always a however, sites on the National Priority List are not eligible for brownfields funds. Mr. Pouncey, in your experience, how many sites have you worked with that are no longer owned by that original pollution source, such as the Dico site in Des Moines? Mr. Pouncey. Many. Many. And I would offer to the entire committee, one of the things we have met with EPA regarding is the effort to get these sites off the National Priority List so that they can be eligible for State programs that allow for the items which I mentioned earlier, which is tax relief, potentially, which is liability protection for the buyer that is coming in to buy that site and redevelop that site. We have also introduced the concept of partial deletion, which means even though all the site may not be removed, at least the lion's share of the site can be removed from the NPL. So that portion would be eligible for the State program and can proceed to the State program. Senator Ernst. That is wonderful. I think you just answered my second question. I was going to ask if you believed it would be appropriate for sites who have transferred that ownership then to be eligible for those brownfields funds. So absolutely, I think we have work to do there. We are blocking a lot of really great economic development by not engaging with those properties. I really do appreciate that. Mr. Carico, given your experience, what steps do you think would be most impactful in streamlining both the brownfields grant application and the implementation process? Mr. Carico. Streamlining the process, that would be a wonderful step in the right direction. It is extremely cumbersome to put these applications together. We work with communities, as an example, we have been doing webinars with communities this past summer, telling them about the grant process and helping them understand this is not an easy task that you are about to encounter, trying to take them through step by step what is required in the overall application process. By being able to streamline that a little bit, there is so much information that is required, it gets down into things like health statistics, cancer rates, lung disease, all these different things. As EPA says, they want you to tell a good story with your application. You have to fit the contaminants that are in your community that you are looking to deal with against those health concerns. A lot of times, especially in our more rural communities, it is hard to get that data that can be presented. So we are already at a disadvantage. Then you lose points for that, because you can't score well in that particular category. We should make sure we keep more of the focus on assessing that property, figuring out what is there, what needs to be cleaned up, and then figuring out the strategy to do just that, then apply the cleanup grant funding to go do just that. Simplifying that a little bit is going to help all of us down the road, especially with our smaller communities. Senator Ernst. That is great to hear. Thank you so much. I do think that is important as well. Let's get on it. Thank you very much, Ranking Member Capito and Chairman Carper, thank you. Senator Carper. Thank you. Senator Cardin has joined us from Maryland, and we have been joined by the Senator from Alaska, Senator Sullivan, and by Sheldon Whitehouse. Welcome. Ben, you are recognized. Senator Cardin. First of all, let me thank the Chairman and Ranking Member for conducting this hearing. The brownfields legislation has been critically important. I represent the State of Maryland. So let me talk about Tradepoint Atlantic, which is one of the largest brownfield sites in the Country. For those who are not familiar, it was the Sparrows Point steel yards from the 1800's to 2012. At one time it was the largest steel producing facility in the United States. When it shuttered in 2012, there was close to $70 million of immediate work that had to be done to clean up the environment. Today, as a result of the brownfields legislation, this property has been reprogrammed. We now have Amazon, Home Depot, Under Armour, BMW, Volkswagen, we have the DOE Offshore Wind Initiative, as well as large railyards connecting two Class 1 railroads, CSX and Norfolk Southern. So it is a hub for economic growth for the future, transitioning from a steel yard production facility to its modern needs. So I am a strong advocate for brownfields and for the legislation that we are talking about today. I would like to focus on one aspect of it, as to how we could do perhaps even a stronger job. We know that most brownfields are located in challenging communities. These are older communities by definition, and have had older types of facilities. So how do we focus the legislation to be more effective in regard to environmental justice and helping the underserved communities? I welcome your thoughts as to how, as we look at reauthorization, how would we want to provide additional incentives so that we can reach those communities? Sometimes these brownfields sites might be kind of small, other times they may be large. They may be located in urban centers, they may be located in rural communities. But how do we deal with the unusual commitments to communities that don't have the same resources that other communities may have in their brownfields sites? Who is the first person willing to help here? Mr. Carico. Yes, sir, I am happy to try to answer that. I am in West Virginia. We have a little different setup there. We actually have two Brownfield Assistance Centers. Our State legislation put those into effect back in 2005. So it is actually our job to go out and work with local communities to help them to understand the daunting challenges of going after these grant funds. It is literally hand-holding 101, a step-by- step getting them to understand what the environmental contaminants are all about, how do you address them, all the different issues that are there. So we are doing that in our State, and we have had a lot of success with it. Senator Cardin. Are we helping you do that? Mr. Carico. No, sir. Senator Cardin. How can the Federal Government help you do this? Mr. Carico. You have the TAB providers, the Technical Assistance providers that EPA has throughout the Country. I think there are six of them. My counterpart at West Virginia University is one of those TAB providers. So they work in EPA Region 3, for example, to do that same thing, to start interacting there. There probably needs to be a lot more work done there if you are going to get out to those more rural, smaller communities. I have to tell you, it takes a whole lot of one- on-one meetings in order to really get them on board. Senator Cardin. I agree with you. So you are saying, we could help, the Federal Government, in providing the resources for technical assistance for communities that have challenges working through the application process for grants and eligibility. Can we make the grants a little bit simpler and more focused to make it easier for these communities? Mr. Carico. That would make us all happier, I can assure you. Again, for our smaller communities, they are really kind of a step behind just because it is very difficult to be able to pull all the needed requirements into those applications. If you don't score well in just one little subsection of an application, you probably won't get funded. As was mentioned earlier, we have had projects that scored 92 points out of 100. In school, that is an ``A'' paper, but these were not funded because they didn't score high enough. Senator Cardin. I know my time is just about out, but I think Mr. Goldstein might want to add something to this. Mr. Goldstein. I am out here in the brownfields, ether, but I am listening carefully and eagerly. Senator, thank you for your question. There are two specific strategies that the Federal Government can employ to address your important concern. One is to overly induce the private sector. Here in the State of Florida, the legislature has put its thumb on the scale for affordable housing on brownfields sites, and for access to health care on brownfields sites. In my earlier testimony, I suggested ways in which the Federal Government could provide heightened subsidies to affordable housing developers through the Low Income Housing Tax Credit Program for developers that invest in communities that need critical affordable housing. I also provided testimony regarding a brownfield loan guarantee which in my experience would likely move billions of dollars off the sidelines in private capital into rural and environmental justice communities, provided that you incentivize those loan guarantees in that fashion. So that is on the one end, using a broader basket of financial tools to overly induce the private sector, and just make it a bad business decision to ignore rural communities and environmental justice communities. The other leg of the approach, the second leg of that approach would be to super-empower those EJ communities and rural communities by providing them direct and unique access to other Federal agencies with massive resources that currently aren't in the Federal Brownfields arena, like the Army Corps of Engineers, like the Federal Highway Administration, like the Economic Development Administration and other agencies that this committee doesn't have jurisdiction over, like HUD. But those are two very discrete and meaningful and material approaches that could help you execute on that important issue of concern you identified: how do we help those communities where the current marketplace hasn't organically produced an incentive for private sector investment. Senator Cardin. Thank you very much. I appreciate it. Senator Capito. [Presiding.] Thank you. Chairman Carper had to go a Homeland Security meeting, so he handed me the gavel, which I love. I am going to do my questioning, and start with you, Mr. Carico. Thank you for coming from the beautiful State of West Virginia. I think we have pretty much made the case here by everybody that rural areas, whether they are EJ communities or not characterized as such, need more capacity, need more help, and need maybe a different lens through which to look. So I am going to ask you a little bit more specific question. I understand that you are allowed to have administrative costs of 5 percent, is that correct? Is that an accurate figure? Should there be more, less? Does that reflect well on meeting the needs administratively? Mr. Carico. First of all, some years ago not too many years ago, you could not have any administrative costs. So first, it was great to see when EPA added that 5 percent administrative cost fee. That was really good for everybody. From what I can tell, and this is just my opinion on the matter and the folks that I work with, for our larger cities and our larger urban areas, I think the 5 percent fee is actually fairly sufficient for them. They have staff, they have other resources, et cetera, that they can draw from. For our smaller communities, where they don't have that many resources or they don't have the capacity, et cetera, possibly a little bump-up to that 5 percent allowance would definitely be of help to them. I would also add this as a caution, if I could. The vast majority of the funding should always focus on assisting those sites, figuring out what the contaminants are, and all those things that are needed, followed by the cleanup. The primary funding should always be focused on that, with a secondary focus on your site redevelopment and planning gaps. Again, the 5 percent is great. Maybe bumping it up a little for our smaller communities would probably help them out a little bit more, but may not be too big an issue for some of the larger communities. Senator Capito. All right, thank you. Mr. Pouncey, your testimony really brings into focus the partnership aspect of this. You talked about the State of Georgia and what you are doing there. You have all talked about States that are active here. Then also the private developers aspect of this. So as you are looking at that, and I know you mentioned some tax issues that would be helpful, opening up to demolition. We need to do demolition not just on brownfield sites, but on urban areas and rural areas that just have these dilapidated, uncared-for properties that are havens for ill use, unsafe and unhealthy. If you are looking at how would you improve and strengthen those partnerships to make sure that we are maximizing all the benefits, and I am curious to know as well, because I did work on the Opportunity Zone legislation with Senator Scott, are you using that, can you use that in this whole universe of brownfield redevelopment? Has that been useful? Mr. Pouncey. Senator, I will address those in reverse order. Yes, the Opportunity Zones play a huge role in our redevelopment activities. I think a number of the changes that are proposed are worthwhile changes. We have seen census tracks in areas that have grown out of poverty and may no longer be appropriate for treatment as Opportunity Zones. But certainly, they provide a real incentive for patient capital to come in and restore and help redevelop some of these neighborhoods. On the public-private partnership, and perhaps let me speak to the grant issue first. Respectfully, we have seen many instances in which the grants funded testing but that testing really was for no specific purpose toward cleanup. As a result, at the end of the day, nor for redevelopment of the community or improvement of the community, so at the end of the day, it becomes a report that goes into someone's desk and sits there. I would propose, and we have championed in some instances, the local communities who are applying for or receiving these grants, partnering with the private sector as well. So there is a real opportunity, because so many times the cleanup occurs as part of the redevelopment itself. The dirt that is moved, the yellow line that is out there moving this dirt is going to be there whether it is construction or whether it is cleanup. It is just where the material is taken afterwards. So I do think there is real benefit in the local communities that are applying for or receiving these grants partnering with the private sector, with interested entities or developers that can come in and say to them, here's the testing we need to come in and do this development, which very often includes both a public and the private component to it. I would suggest that is one way to more effectively use or ensure the effective use of these funds, is having that public-private partnership at the outset before the assessment begins. Senator Carper. Thank you. Senator Whitehouse? Senator Whitehouse. Thank you very much, Chairman. Welcome to all the witnesses. I think we can probably all agree that Superfund sites burning or flooding is a very bad outcome. I see heads nodding. For that reason, wildfire and flood risk is important in dealing with our existing and emerging Superfund site population, if you will. GAO did a report entitled EPA Should Take Additional Actions to Manage Risks from Climate Change, in which GAO found that EPA had omitted, omitted, climate change from its agency strategy and further, that many Superfund sites would be at increased risk of flooding and wildfires, and that obviously, if you have omitted that from your risk calculation, you have kind of missed the pitch. My question to you, and I guess I will start with our voice from the ether, if I may, Mr. Goldstein, is what did we lose in the denial years when EPA wouldn't count climate change into the Superfund risk factor? And have we caught up for whatever went wrong in those years? How prepared are we now in terms of a proper scientifically based accurate assessment of which Superfund sites face new risks from flooding and from wildfire? Mr. Goldstein. I think that the industry and the agencies, both at the Federal level and at the State level, are catching up very quickly. There is and has been over the last I would say five or 6 years a very significant effort to understand the remedies that are appropriate to implement for contamination in coastal zone areas that are acutely subject to sea rise and whether those remedies should continue to include encapsulation of waste onsite or source removal. This is an ongoing discussion that has technical implications, regulatory implications, legal implications, economic implications and equity implications. Not all cleanups are created equal, and not all cleanups are financially sourced reliable in the same way. This goes back to some of the testimony that we have heard in this hearing, and some of the testimony I provided, regarding the ability of the Federal Government to achieve better outcomes and better results in the age of climate change by putting our thumb on the scale with respect to certain outcomes and approaches to clean up where here specifically, the legislature could, Congress could prioritize source removal in coastal communities, the removal of all impacted contaminated soil or sediments, so that when waters rise from below or fall from above, the caps that are in place, which may no longer be an effective remedy, are not an issue, because the source of contamination has been eliminated. Senator Whitehouse. Thank you. I have a minute left, so if I may, let me ask the other witnesses to offer whatever thoughts they may have in response to those questions as responses for the record, put them in writing. It wouldn't be right for a Rhode Island Senator not to say a kind word about the Rhode Island role in establishing brownfields led by a chairman, once, of the Environment and Public Works Committee, John Chaffee, whose picture is right in that room as one of the former chairmen of this committee. And then reauthorized by his son, Lincoln Chaffee, years later when he assumed his father's seat. So we take a certain amount of pride in the Brownfields Program around Rhode Island, because it has good Rhode Island fingerprints all over it. Another Rhode Island credential that relates to this is that the Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council at the University of Rhode Island has worked to improve the mapping of flood risk along the Rhode Island coast. We discovered that the FEMA mapping was absolutely horrible, it was terrible. If you followed the FEMA mapping, it led to internal inconsistencies within its own program. It produced results for worse storms that were lower than what was measured for actual less bad storms. How is it possible to even come up with a flood risk map that shows for X level of storms it is actually going to be better than we actually experienced for a lesser level of storm? It doesn't even make sense. The sloppiness of the FEMA process, the inconsistencies within the FEMA process, and the flinch that they had about looking at sea level rise because, oh, my God, you might have to touch on climate change, and oh, my God, we can't talk about that. It just created a disaster. The State really stepped up and has done absolutely first- quality mapping. I encourage anybody who is in that predicament now to take a look at what Rhode Island did. It is called the Storm Tools App and Resource, is really pretty remarkable. Unfortunately, it tends to be coastal, but I am sure that in West Virginia some of those rain burst storm floods have a similar outcome on folks. I just wanted to say those thank yous to Rhode Island. Much appreciated. Senator Capito. I will thank Rhode Island as well, and I can speak to the 2016 flood where the maps in Rainelle showed that there would be no flooding, and they were flooded six to eight feet in these houses. If you talked to people in the community, they would say, oh, sure, sure they flooded, they would get water in their yard every spring. So they knew. But the maps showed no. These folks hadn't bought any flood insurance. So it didn't have a very happy outcome for many of them. So here is a question I want to ask everybody. We have talked about successful brownfields applications and projects that you have worked on. Have you ever had a project where you looked at it for a brownfield and you deemed that it would be not worth the effort, or something that was premature? We will start with you, Mr. Carico, then we will go back to the whole group. Mr. Carico. Yes, ma'am. The short answer is yes. Many times we interact with the community. I will give you an example, in the little community of Mullens, had a little project there. All they needed, when all was said and done, was about $30,000 to do some asbestos abatement. The EPA Brownfields Program is not the route to go to try to get that funding. It is just way too much effort for that one single project. We do often sit down with, especially in our smaller, more rural communities, and after meeting with them and going through all the details, we tell them, you are not ready to try to get into this brownfields arena. Maybe then we try to help them with one particular site. They have a little site, it is their highest-ranking site they want to do something about. We try to work with them on that one site. That kind of gets their appetite wet and gets them to learn the process a little bit, and then prepares them to where they can move forward into the brownfields arena. I will let these other fellows comment as well. Senator Capito. Yes, Mr. Pouncey. Mr. Pouncey. Senator, there are two categories of sites that we have had to walk away from. One are sites that are on the National Priority List because it just takes so long to get those sites off the list. Senator Capito. That is the Superfund? Mr. Pouncey. It is. We had one where we spent close to 15 years to ultimately get it off the National Priority List and went through four series of purchasers, because of the lack of patience. They just couldn't wait that amount of time to get it off. So that is why I think it is so important to develop innovative ways to get these sites off the Superfund list. The second is less subject to how you correct it, but it is simply where we are approached by a developer for a particular type of use and it turns out the site just wasn't appropriate for that use. That may be, if you are looking at a single family or multi-family residential development, and the cleanup is such that it is really only going to support an industrial use, or a warehouse/last mile use or something like that. Senator Capito. Thank you. Mr. Buschur? Mr. Buschur. We have two types of sites in Lawrence. We have scatter sites, smaller properties, smaller industrial properties in residential areas, then we have large properties with great proximity to transit, to highways, riverfront properties as well. The ones that are along the waterfront close to transit, they are going to find a private partner to complete that redevelopment and to really show that leverage that the EPA Brownfields Program is so known for. But when you get to the scatter sites in residential areas, the smaller industrial sites less than an acre with triple deckers or high density housing right adjacent to them, the end use is not very visible, and the partners with the brownfields expertise required to reposition these and get them back on the tax rolls, they are not really out there. So you are really relying quite frequently on somebody like a Groundwork to come in and do a park, or a community-based organization, community development corporation, that is going to take down the site and hopefully create some housing. But at the end of the day, it all requires a private partner who is willing to take on the risk associated with this redevelopment. If the market is moving fast, you are likely to have more traction. When the real eState market is slow, things tend to slow down. Senator Capito. Right. Mr. Goldstein? Mr. Goldstein. On our end, we from time-to-time experience many of the factors that the previous witnesses mentioned. Florida has been blessed with a very active economy. So that hasn't been a significant driver in terms of having to walk away from brownfield sites. On our end, what we find most as being too significant a hurdle to overcome is where the public health risk is acute, where there has been actual injury to public health and claims may be asserted or may be assertable in the future with respect to public health that could be absorbed by a prospective purchaser. That makes redevelopment very difficult. Senator Capito. I think Mr. Pouncey addressed that in his opening statement on liability issues. So if you have a site that you have decided, or it has been decided that you are not going to go forward on, is it remediated or does it just sit there with the contaminants? What happens to those sites. Do they sit there until somebody comes along later and tries to redevelop? Mr. Buschur. Until the leadership, until the political leadership is there, I want my staff, who has limited staff time, to go out and tackle this site. Within Lawrence, these are sites that are off the tax rolls, the cities take them for taxes. Senator Capito. It could be an old gas station or something like that. Mr. Buschur. Yes, we have a dry-cleaning site that is now a park. But we have former manufacturing facilities nestled between a river, a school, and residential areas that just aren't right for redevelopment, and the city is trying to figure out what to do with them. As Mr. Pouncey noted, you really need a private partner to make this happen. You can't just make it parking. Senator Capito. Thanks. Mr. Goldstein. Senator, if I may? Senator Carper. [Presiding.] Go ahead, please. Mr. Goldstein. Your question is a great one, because that is where we originally came into the Brownfields Program in the first instance in the 1990's. There were dozens and dozens of obstacles to clean up and redevelopment that were too high to surmount. Steadily, over the decades, EPA and State partners have been lowering those obstacles. There are not many that remain, but those that remain can be significant. We have just addressed many of those. That is why I return again to the suggestion that I made a few times where obstacles remain too significant for the marketplace to respond under existing conditions, the Federal Government should come in and change the conversation by super- inducing the private sector to absorb risk through the use of loan guarantees or expand grants or expanded access to liability protection. Mr. Pouncey. Senator, if I may, one comment on that. I think it is a number that is very reflective of this issue. We have had a superfund program in Georgia since 1992. Over the life of that program, which now is 30 years, we have had about 700 properties put on our State superfund list. Of those I think we are approaching 250 or so that have been cleaned up, of the 700, over a 30-year period. You compare that to the Brownfield Program, which is a private incentivized program, where we have had 1,300 properties go into the program in just a little over half the time and 750 or so of those properties are now cleaned up. So you compare that enforcement component versus the private incentive component, and you see the dramatic effect is has on the opportunity for cleanup. Senator Capito. That is a good point. Mr. Chairman, I am going to have to say goodbye, I have another obligation. Thank you. Senator Capito. Thanks so much. Thanks for running the show. Senator Sullivan was here, but he had to leave. I don't' know if any of our other Republican colleagues will be able to join us this morning. But we have been joined by Senator Padilla. He is recognized for any questions or comments. Thank you, Senator Padilla. Senator Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank you for holding this hearing on the need to reauthorize the EPA's Brownfields Program. The Brownfields Program has a long history of supporting safe and responsible redevelopment. Since its inception, it has made nearly 10,000 properties ready for re- use, many of which are in my home State of California, many of which are in my hometown of Los Angeles, and many of which are literally in my backyard, in the neighborhood I grew up in, Pacoima, California. I have seen and worked in these issues as a State legislator, putting State government resources to leverage Federal resources in redevelopment. I am familiar with these efforts, once upon a time as a city council member, trying to navigate some of these cleanup efforts and effort to redevelop into productive use and economic benefit, often in underserved communities. Mr. Buschur, I appreciated your written testimony for touching on the challenges of de-industrialization. The example I want to focus on today is actually not in my back yard but in the city and county of San Francisco. The shipping industry was the lifeblood of San Francisco's Bayview-Hunter's Point neighborhood for decades. The concentration of industrial sites has resulted in more than 150 brownfields in Bayview-Hunter's Point, many of which are not further threatened by sea level rise. So you see a convergence of challenges here. The actual shipyard itself is now a Federal Superfund site and one of America's most polluted places. Just last week, San Francisco broke ground on a project that will connect disadvantaged communities and Bayview-Hunter's Point to the kind of outdoor recreation opportunities that other shoreline neighborhoods in San Francisco have long enjoyed. Working with the EPA and a diverse group of community partners, San Francisco is redeveloping a 13-mile corridor of green space with trails and parks along the waterfront. Redevelopment of this site would not have been possible without first cleaning up the contaminated soil and debris and structures on the property, efforts which were supported by EPA's Brownfields Program. Now in a few short years, thanks to this program, the community members in Bayview-Hunter's Point will be able to enjoy shoreline trails on what was once an abandoned and blighted former industrial site. This project was successful thanks to the engagement and support from various State and local entities. While the project received almost $350,000 from the EPA Brownfields Program, the city also leveraged separate EPA funds as well as other sources of funding. But not every environmental justice community has the same access to technical assistance to be able to complete projects. There are surely other Federal agencies that can and should be brought into the brownfields redevelopment projects. My question is for Mr. Goldstein. How should we think about a whole-of-government approach to funding brownfield redevelopment projects and improving interagency coordination? Mr. Goldstein. That is a great question, Senator. I am glad you asked it. You are absolutely right, there are other agencies that should be part of this conversation and should be providing resources. I identified three that are under this committee's jurisdiction in my testimony earlier this morning: the Federal Highway Administration, the Army Corps of Engineers, which has massive resources to bring to the table and can absolutely partner and collaborate with environmental justice communities in an immediate and very material way, and the Economic Development Administration. The EPA has put out a wonderful guidance document which they have been doing every several years called the Federal Brownfields Program, which identifies aspirational brownfield agendas within 24 different Federal agencies and departments. But if you look at what is actually happening in the brownfields universe, really EPA is the only agency that has any meaningful involvement. So what I would suggest is a corollary to a friendly amendment to the testimony I gave earlier. Have EDA convene a national brownfields summit. Bring representatives from each of those 24 agencies and departments to the table, along with private and public sector stakeholders, State, local, tribal, NGO's, environmental justice, et cetera, and collectively identify what resources, human resources and financial resources, each of these agencies that are already part of the Federal brownfields constellation can bring to the table. Specific to reauthorization, which is what this hearing is about, again, we recommend new funding of resources be allocated specifically to the Corps, specifically to EDA, and specifically to FHWA for these purposes. Let's put our thumb on the scale to prioritize funding for EJ communities and rural communities. Senator Padilla. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I know my time is up, but I would like to ask one quick followup question for Mr. Goldstein. Another reason this project was so successful is because San Francisco accounted for potential climate change and sea level rise impacts by using EPA's Brownfields Cleanup Alternatives checklist. For example, they chose soil excavation as the preferred cleanup method, as opposed to remediation, because it would reduce the risk of re-mobilizing soil contaminants as sea levels continued to rise. How can the EPA ensure that climate change and potential sea level rise are adequately considered during brownfield redevelopment efforts? If I could ask for a brief response and we will continue the conversation after the hearing. Mr. Goldstein. Absolutely, Senator Padilla, thank you. I am glad you asked that question because it gives me an opportunity to supplement my response to Senator Whitehouse on this very same issue. EPA is laser-focused on climate change and brownfields. They have released several guidance documents that are encyclopedic in the way in which they approach this particular challenge including focusing, as you pointed out, source removal in coastal areas as a remedy. Why is that important? It is important because if you leave contaminated soil in place and it is subject to flooding, the waters rise and soak through that contaminated material. Like a sponge that may contain hot chocolate that is wiped up from a kitchen counter, that material is going to leak out of the soil or the sponge and further exacerbate contamination in communities. So remedies at the regulatory level should be focused on source removal as the first component of a climate change strategy for brownfields. Senator Padilla. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I will submit questions for the record relative to the recommendations and suggestion of codifying some of our environmental justice and equity directives into the Brownfields Program. Thank you very much. Senator Carper. Thanks so much for joining us and for your participation and questions. I have a couple more questions I want to ask before we break for the day. I was out of the room for a while, we all serve on a bunch of different committees. One my committees, the Homeland Security was voting on a bunch of nominations and legislation. I had to go, they needed somebody to show up and I am always happy to do that. So I missed a little bit of what was going on, but not too much. I am told, Mr. Pouncey, that you mentioned addressing developer liability as a way to better incentivize redevelopment. Mr. Pouncey. Yes, sir. Senator Carper. And I think Mr. Goldstein, I am told by my staff, you may have started to touch on this, some approaches in this regard in your earlier comments. Let me ask each of you to describe for us ways that this might be accomplished while still incentivizing health protection. Again, Mr. Pouncey, you mentioned addressing developer liability as a way to better incentivize redevelopment. The question would be to ask each of you to describe ways that this might be accomplishing while still incentivizing health protection. Mr. Buschur, would you like to go first? Mr. Buschur. Liability associated with ownership of brownfield sites is a barrier for all actors, whether they are trying to create parks or trying to redevelop sites. Within Lawrence, the State administers the brownfield program except for contaminants covered by TSCA. Covenants not to sue have been used through the State AG's office to absolve future owners of brownfields, particularly in certain park projects. I think it has been a barrier for us to act on certain park projects as well, to take ownership of properties when they are presented with us and they fit within our long-term vision for the city. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Mr. Pouncey, you may have raised this. Go ahead with any further comments you have, please share them. Mr. Pouncey. Yes, Senator. I do think that as part of the reauthorization there may be want to be some consideration to looking at a number of the States that have enacted liability protection and see if that can be applied to the Federal side as well for those brownfield buyers. I would note that there is still the requirement that you perform the cleanup that is agreed upon. That is the way to ensure the health and safety of those who might be impacted by liability relief. But I would also remind us the Superfund took a very remarkable approach when it was first drafted, and it has done tremendous things for this Country. But it did impose the liability upon an owner of property, whether they had caused contamination, whether they had owned it when it occurred or not. So I do think that is a disincentive in many instances for buyers as they have an opportunity to acquire this property versus a greenfield very often that is used to invest the resources somewhere else, which prevents that property from actually being cleaned up. So I do think liability protection is a tool that should be considered as part of the reauthorization. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Mr. Carico, same question. Could you describe for us ways that this might be accomplished while still incentivizing health protection? Mr. Carico. I want to completely agree with these gentlemen here. One thing in West Virginia I would add, we have our State voluntary remediation program. That program does provide that liability protection. That is oftentimes the only way you can really get a site to be cleaned up, ready to go, and everybody on the private side agrees with you. They see it, they realize that all the effort has been made, and that to me is one of the best routes to always keep in mind. I will agree with these gentlemen that the liability aspects many, many times, the site ends up just sitting there because of that big challenge, trying to handle that. It is a big hurdle that is for sure. Senator Carper. Thank you. Mr. Goldstein, I think when I was out of the room attending my other hearing, you may have started to touch on some approaches in this regard. Mr. Goldstein, if you would like to jump in here and share with us what I may have missed, anything else you want to add on this front, go ahead. Mr. Goldstein. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will try and be brief. We had some discussion earlier in the testimony about the tension between the Superfund program at the Federal level and many State brownfield programs across the Country in that the liability protections offered under both programs were mutually exclusive. It was impossible in many States to take advantage of either liability protection incentive if you are not in that same program. So the specific incentive I would offer that I think would be very meaningful would be a very narrow and discrete amendment to the Superfund statute to CERCLA that provides that any party that enters into a State-based brownfield voluntary cleanup agreement automatically has contribution defense and other defenses against third party claims under Federal Superfund law. That way you get the best of both worlds and you wouldn't necessarily have to worry about EPA relinquishing its enforcement discretion. That is a very discrete and I think meaningful approach that could immediately be taken by Congress to expand the scope of liability protection available to developers who may be able to address their State-based legal exposure but not their Federal legal exposure to third parties. This butters two pieces of bread with one knife. Senator Carper. Did you say butters two pieces of bread with one knife? Mr. Goldstein. Yes. That is exactly right. Senator Carper. That is one of the highlights of this hearing. This has been a great hearing. That is one of my favorite aspects. Go right ahead. Mr. Goldstein. Then I would also reinforce the point that Mr. Pouncey made, and that is to ensure continued protection of human health and keep developers on task with respect to the cleanup. This is a quid pro quo environment we are operating in. All of the incentives, especially the liability protection incentives, remain viable insofar as a developer complies with their cleanup and public health obligations. If they fail to do so, the incentives are lost, including the liability protection incentive. Senator Carper. I have three or four other questions, and I am going to ask you to respond to them just very briefly, if you could. Then we will call it a morning. The first one deals with local engagement. Brownfield cleanups involve government at all levels, Federal and State and local. Feds provide the cleanup money, the seed money, through grant funding and State governments dictate the cleanup standards for the most part. Local governments made land use decisions and have ultimately control over what brownfield redevelopment is ultimately going to look like. This is critical, because remediated land has the potential to provide, as you know, huge benefits to impacted communities. We have seen it in our own communities, very close to where I live, and I am sure you have seen it in your own. A question for the panel, but especially for Mr. Buschur and Mr. Carico, and if other colleagues would like to comment, you are welcome to do that too. We will start off with Mr. Buschur and Mr. Carico. Why is local involvement so important for brownfield redevelopment, and how can we improve our outreach to local governments and individual communities impacted by brownfield redevelopment? Mr. Buschur? Mr. Buschur. Residents just want to be heard, and they want to know what is going on. They want to be kept in the loop. It is so important to keep them in the loop. I think we have all been to a public meeting that has kind of gone off the rails when residents have not been properly communicated with. I will just give a quick plug to Avenues for Engagement, and that is the Groundwork Trust Network. We reach over 6 million people living in environmental justice communities across the Country, over 75 percent of whom are people of color. We support the cities' efforts to prepare and draft the cleanup and the assessment proposals by providing the statistics that others have referenced is so hard to access. Expansion of the Groundwork Network, which was created with support from the National Park Service and EPA, as well as local stakeholders, will go a long way to achieving the engagement goals within urban areas, but I would also say rural areas as well. Let's not overlook the smaller and mid-size cities. We are in Mobile, Alabama, we are in Atlanta, we are in Erie, Pennsylvania. The network is strong and can bring a lot of expertise to local decisionmakers. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Mr. Carico? Mr. Carico. Yes, first, great comments there. The big thing we have found on the local community with that local engagement piece is they want to be told the real story. The rumor mill goes around and around and around, and a lot of times they are misinformed about a particular property as to what it can and can't be used for, and then what is going on with it. Providing that local engagement piece, that gives them the opportunity where they can be heard and they can provide their input on what is going on on that property, how the future of development of it is going to affect them. Then when you do run into issues at the local level, that platform can then be addressed. This Brownfield Program, the way it is set up with that local engagement and community engagement piece, it provides that framework where that can be conducted. It is a great way to get the story out, get everybody involved, and come together with some consensus on how everything is progressing forward. That would be my comment. Senator Carper. Thanks, Mr. Carico. Mr. Pouncey, if you want to add to that, feel free, and Mr. Goldstein, if you want to add to those comments, feel free, but you don't have to. Mr. Pouncey. I think the comments by both those individuals on my right and left are spot on. A fundamental part of all our redevelopment is engagement with those local communities. That is a fundamental part of the zoning process. I do not see very many developers that are successful if they don't understand that fundamentally. Senator Carper. Yes, people like to be asked. Mr. Goldstein, before I ask my other questions, do you want to add anything on this one? Mr. Goldstein. No, sir. Senator Carper. All right. One down, 14 to go. [Laughter.] Senator Carper. Maybe not that many. All right. We know this deals with brownfields remediation planning, and this would be for the entire panel, but we know that thoughtful planning is a vitally important part of land remediation and the program has been reformed to include more support for the planning portions of brownfields redevelopment. For the whole panel, what can we do in Congress to further strengthen Federal support for brownfields planning so that communities not only engage in site-by-site planning, but can dedicate time and resources to develop regional area-wide plans to land revitalization, so that authorities can develop more comprehensive land use goals and plans for their communities? That is a pretty long question. I would be happy to repeat that if anybody wants me to. Mr. Buschur, would you like to take a shot at that? Mr. Buschur. Sure. I have been fortunate to participate in an EPA area-wide planning project that looked at, it was probably around 10 acres, north and south of the city's main commercial corridors. That set the stage for the city to create a new urban renewal plan and hopefully in 2023 we will begin construction on the rail trail that bisects that planning area. These funds were really vital to starting to have the conversation not only with property owners about thinking what they could do for the entire district with their individual small parcels, but also starting the underlying zoning and making sure that the right overlay district is there, reflecting the community's interest and the overall goals of the city. Then just building support for the conversion of the corridor to an alternative transportation corridor. It was a really good project. Hopefully, the reauthorization will continue supporting it. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Again, just a brief comment if you have it, Mr. Pouncey. Long question. I am looking for a short answer. Mr. Pouncey. I am always careful to have EPA get involved in land use planning. I think that is obviously much more effective at the local and regional level where they are on the ground. But I do think that there are areas where grants can be incentivized in certain forms, transit being one, a great example of that. There are a number of other categories like that where there is an ability to incentivize investment through grants, receiving extra points or receiving some level of priority if they meet with those categories. Transit, once again, being the obvious example. Senator Carper. Thanks for that example. Mr. Carico? Mr. Carico. I will just add a quick comment to that. With the brownfield funding, you can use some of that funding for conducting planning activities. I have seen that work both, we have had communities that already had some things in place but there was some additional work done, maybe it was a feasibility study or market analysis or a structural analysis or whatever, and it turned out that their original plans were really not the best plans. So those things got changed a little bit. So I see very positive results that have come from that. But again, that has to be done at that local level. Having our brownfield funding to help with that is a big key. That is part of the whole cleanup plan, is that key right there as well. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Two more questions, if I could. It has been well documented that low-income communities and racial minorities are disproportionately exposed to environmental harm. We are seeing that in my own State, frankly, not far from where my wife and I live. There are concerns that development of brownfields can do unintended harm by displacing the people who live there. For example, with remediation, there can be an influx of zoning, planning, and privately funded new development that can in turn cause rents to rise above what community members can afford. Again for the entire panel, this question. How can we incentivize private entities that invest in brownfield development to be sure that remediated sites benefit the communities where they are located and create sustainable, long-term infrastructure improvement for community residents? If I could, I am going to ask Mr. Goldstein to lead off on that one, please. Mr. Goldstein. Sure, I would be happy to, Mr. Chairman. This is the unfortunate secret in our world, in the brownfields redevelopment world, the unintended consequences of environmental redevelopment and revitalization, gentrification. The opposite of gentrification is anchoring in place. So how do we help communities that have long been in the neighborhood remain in that neighborhood? We do that by qualifying the private sector incentives with responsibilities and obligations to partner with local residents and local organizations. We require them to take on local partners. We require them to provide mentoring programs, job creation programs, job training programs. We require them to establish micro-lending programs, to invest in cultural amenities and gathering places and the like. All of this could be included in what one might call generically an anti-gentrification plan which could be a condition to the award of any Federal brownfield grant. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Mr. Carico, same question. Mr. Carico. I really don't have any additional comments to make on that. Senator Carper. All right, thank you. Mr. Pouncey? Mr. Pouncey. It is an issue. We see it, we have seen it dealt with at the local level. I can point to a number of developments that I have been involved in in Charleston, South Carolina, where there has been a tremendous amount of public involvement and comment to ensure that the local communities are not just informed but also involved and participate. I don't know the Federal role in that. Where I have seen it most effectively considered has been at the local level. Senator Carper. Good, thank you. Mr. Buschur? Mr. Buschur. Green gentrification is a concern for Groundwork and the work we do within the city. Displacement is an issue within Lawrence. There is a significant housing crisis, there is a significant affordability crisis. I was intrigued by some of the concepts Mr. Goldstein put forward earlier that called for enhanced low-income housing tax credits associated with brownfield development to actually make it more appealing to private sector developers to come in, instead of doing full 100 percent market rate housing, that perhaps there are other incentives that can be provided from the Federal Government to make sure that a certain share of those units created fall to those who are most unable to afford housing within that city. Senator Carper. All right, thank you, sir. One last question. This would also be a question for the entire panel. The question goes something like this. Earlier, we discussed detailed policy issues. I want to ask each of you to share with us briefly your experiences on what the brownfields program has meant to communities you have worked with. Can you give us some idea of an experience or two, briefly, that you have gone through and how the program has transformed not just land but the lives of people living in affected communities? Something from your own experience. Mr. Carico, would you like to share with us a memory or two? Mr. Carico. I could actually talk for quite a while on that subject. I shared a couple examples in my comments earlier. One that is very interesting and close to me is a little project in Ceredo, West Virginia. Senator Carper. Tell people where Ceredo is. Mr. Carico. It is in Wayne County, near the tip with Kentucky and Ohio. You can see both from there. There is a group called the Golden Girls Group Home. Senator Carper. I yearn to live there someday. [Laughter.] Senator Carper. In the distant, distant future. Don't tell my wife. Mr. Carico. It is a great name, but it is a home that was built for young ladies that have come from horrific home conditions. It is a place for them to get a second chance, a new start. They get safe housing, they get counseling. They get help with educational assistance and work to find jobs. It is a wonderful program. They first approached me back some years ago about a particular piece of property and said, we hope to build our facility there. I did some research on it. I am an environmental geologist by trade, so I have a background in that. I did a little look and said, there are some issues with this project. Rather than getting into the brownfields side of it, I said, do you all have any other properties. They said, yes, we have a second location that just came up, and we think it could even be the better location. So really quick, I did a little look into that. I said, it is a vacant property that nobody seems to know anything about. I said, let's find out for sure. We had Wayne County EDA, they had a brownfields grant, and I was working with them. I said, let's do a phase 1 environmental site assessment on the property just to see what the history of this site is, to make sure there are no recognized environmental conditions. They did a phase 1. At that time, I suspect that cost was no more than about $4,000. There were no recognized environmental issues on that property. That jump-started it and cleared the way for, I have no idea how many private investors that came in, the local hospitals, the local businesses, they all said, OK, we see you have done your homework and we want to be involved with this. Now, the facility has been built, all these young ladies go there, they have a place to stay. Those stories like that really make your day, quite frankly. And it all got started because we did a little background work just to make sure they weren't getting ready, as we say in West Virginia, to buy a pig in a poke, getting ready to take on something that had environmental challenges that they would not be able to handle. Senator Carper. That is a great story. Mr. Carico. I could tell you more, but I will stop there. Senator Carper. That is great. Mr. Pouncey? Mr. Pouncey. Senator, there is one particular project that comes to mind. Back in the 1960's, when the interstates were being built, when what we call our downtown connector in Atlanta was built, it split the east side and the west side. Senator Carper. It sounds familiar. There are a lot of places like that around the Country. Mr. Pouncey. All of the growth occurred on the east side. The only thing on the west side was a little school called Georgia Tech, and an area, an old 100-acre steel mill called the Atlantic Steel Mill. It was operating on a skeletal crew, so it avoided some of the EPA closure requirements. It was still considered to be ``operating.'' Well, in the late 1990's, we put together a group that ultimately redeveloped that steel mill that had lain in its underutilized capacity for close to 20 years. What it did is it sparked so many things on the west side of Atlanta, ultimately resulting a bridge that now connects the east side and the west side of Atlanta up in that area that we call 17th Street. It created grocery stores in areas that had no grocery stores. It created affordable restaurants in areas where there was no place to eat. It resulted in additional schools being built. It resulted in significant infrastructure improvement. All of that was started, the seed was planted was the Atlantic Station redevelopment. Fortunately, we did receive EPA's Brownfield Redevelopment of the year back in 2000. Senator Carper. That is great. Wonderful story, thank you. Mr. Buschur. Similar to the rest of the individuals up here, I have several stories. One that comes to mind is the Manchester Street Park site, which is a former rail yard right on Stevens Pond in the Arlington and Malden Mills District of Lawrence. When we did the park, when the city and Groundwork did the park, all the mills were quite dilapidated. Now there are hundreds of units of housing around the pond and near the park. The rail trail is going to be built that abuts it, and that connects to 30 miles of additional trails. It is the beginning of the end of the Spicket River Greenway. This park serves as that hub for the hundreds of families that now call that mill section home. Senator Carper. OK, thank you. How about one more story, Mr. Goldstein, from you, please? Mr. Goldstein. There is a story that is being written right now, a project that is underway involving a 100-year-old site, which is pretty old for Miami. Miami is not that much older than 100 years. It is in the neighborhood called Overtown. It is in the southwest quadrant of Overtown, historic African American community that had been split in two by I-95 many years ago. This particular site is bordered by Booker T. Washington High School, which is the second oldest African American high school in south Florida, and adjacent to the Metrorail station that connects to the county's largest job engine. This particular site had sat idle for over 30 years as a result of a pretty horrific spill of chlorinated solvents from a janitorial supply company. Using the Federal Brownfields Program and the State brownfields program, one of our clients came in, acquired the site, cleaned it up, brought up a best- in-class affordable housing developer who was able to close because of the affordable housing incentives offered by the Federal Government. The fact that the site is in an Opportunity Zone, the fact that there is State brownfields liability protection, and they are now going to invest $250 million in this site to build 612 units of affordable housing and put in a fresh food grocer in what is currently a food desert. So you now have the connectivity between transit, schools, housing, and the county's largest job engine, which is the health district. This is more than just environmental science, this is poetry. Senator Carper. Thank you for that poetry. I wanted to ask Bill Clinton a question, he had come and spoken at our annual Democratic Senate retreat over at the Library of Congress. He spoke before lunch, and he killed it. He is just so good; he was delivering the stories that he told. I said to him, as we were going through chow line, I said, ``Mr. President, I have heard you speak many times, but I have never asked you why you are so effective as a speaker.'' He said, ``Tom, what I do is I tend to tell stories,'' he said, ``I tell a series of stories that put together can explain more complex concepts. People understand stories. You draw them in, they get it.'' He said, ``I like to use some self-deprecating humor.'' He said, ``When I do that, I am usually fairly effective.'' I find that when I do those things, I am fairly effective as well. I think maybe the most effective part of a terrific hearing has been just what you closed with. Those are wonderful stories that we can all get our heads and our hearts around. We want to thank you for those, and for being here with us. Mr. Goldstein, to you and your neighbors down there in Florida, we send prayers for all of you, hoping that you come through this OK. There will be a lot of interest in providing Federal assistance and from others around the Country who are not government, but want to do it just because they want to be a good neighbor. Before we adjourn, a little bit of housekeeping. We have heard from Senators some of them want to ask more questions for the record, some of them couldn't join us and want to ask some questions for the record. We will ask our colleagues to submit the written questions for the record through the close of business on Wednesday, October 12th, and we will compile those questions, we will send them out to each of you and ask you to reply by Wednesday, October 26th of this year. I want to again thank our staffs, on the majority side and the minority side, for helping us put together a really good hearing on this important issue. It has been an important issue for a long time. Every member of this panel, Democrat, Republican, could tell a story, a bunch of stories that really would mirror what we have heard from each of you in your close. We want to thank our staffs for making possible this great hearing, for those who were able to participate on our panel, and our members of the committee, thank them for joining us, especially Senator Capito. All right. This hearing is adjourned. Thank you all so much. God bless. [Whereupon, at 12:09 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [all]