Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- A CHANGING WORKFORCE: SUPPORTING OLDER WORKERS AMID THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC AND BEYOND [Senate Hearing 117-52] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 117-52 A CHANGING WORKFORCE: SUPPORTING OLDER WORKERS AMID THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC AND BEYOND ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ APRIL 29, 2021 __________ Serial No. 117-02 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 45-308 PDF WASHINGTON : 2022 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania, Chairman KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York TIM SCOTT, South Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts RICHARD BURR, North Carolina JACKY ROSEN, Nevada MARCO RUBIO, Florida MARK KELLY, Arizona MIKE BRAUN, Indiana RAPHAEL WARNOCK, Georgia RICK SCOTT, Florida MIKE LEE, Utah ---------- Stacy Sanders, Majority Staff Director Neri Martinez, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman...... 1 Opening Statement of Senator Tim Scott, Ranking Member........... 2 PANEL OF WITNESSES Elizabeth White, Aging Solutions Advocate and Author, Washington, DC............................................................. 5 Elise Gould, Ph.D., Senior Economist, Economic Policy Institute, Takoma Park, Maryland.......................................... 6 Ramsey Alwin, President and Chief Executive Officer, National Council on Aging, Washington, DC............................... 8 David Poston, President, Palmetto Synthetics, Kingstree, South Carolina....................................................... 9 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Elizabeth White, Aging Solutions Advocate and Author, Washington, DC............................................................. 29 Elise Gould, Ph.D., Senior Economist, Economic Policy Institute, Takoma Park, Maryland.......................................... 32 Ramsey Alwin, President and Chief Executive Officer, National Council on Aging, Washington, DC............................... 39 David Poston, President, Palmetto Synthetics, Kingstree, South Carolina....................................................... 51 Questions for the Record David Poston, President, Palmetto Synthetics, Kingstree, South Carolina....................................................... 55 Additional Statements for the Record Bonnie Marcus Statement, introduced to the Record by Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman................................. 59 AARP Statement submitted by Cristina Martin Firvida, Vice President, Financial Security & Livable Communities, Government Affairs........................................................ 61 National Council on Aging........................................ 71 A CHANGING WORKFORCE: SUPPORTING OLDER WORKERS AMID THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC AND BEYOND ---------- THURSDAY, APRIL 29, 2021 U.S. Senate, Special Committee on Aging, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:30 a.m., via Webex, Hon. Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Casey, Gillibrand, Blumenthal, Rosen, Kelly, Warnock, Tim Scott, Collins, Braun, and Rick Scott. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The Senate Special Committee on Aging will come to order. Good morning, everyone. This hearing we are having today comes at a very critical time, as Congress discusses how to get American workers back on their feet and to pull our economy out of the ditch. Over the last year, workers in every occupation and in every corner of the country have felt the effects of the devastating economic recession created by COVID-19. The COVID-19 pandemic has been devastating to every corner of the country and especially to workers. While the harm has not been contained to any one age group, the impact on older workers have been severe. As we all know, the threat posed by the virus is magnified for older adults, as individuals ages 50 and over have accounted for 95 percent of all deaths. Ninety- five percent of all deaths. Millions of older workers have had to make the impossible choice between continuing to go to work to pay their bills or staying home to protect their health and to protect their families. Many others simply saw their jobs disappear. For example in Pennsylvania, the 12-month rolling average unemployment rate of workers ages 55 and older increased from 3.0 percent in February 2020 to 9.2 percent in February 2021. While the unemployment rate has declined since last summer, one million seven hundred thousand workers ages 55 and older are still unemployed nationwide. As we will hear from our witnesses today, unemployment numbers do not tell the whole story. Hundreds of thousands of older workers fell out of the workforce altogether, giving up on finding a job or being forced to retire early. Fortunately, we are beginning to see the light at the end of this very dark tunnel. The American Rescue Plan contained critical investments to defeat the virus and help families, including, just by way of example, an extension of expanded unemployment benefits and a $1,400 direct payment; funding to help ensure employers are keeping workers safe and healthy in the workplace; and, third, a historic investment in vaccine distribution. All of these are critical to helping older workers return to work safely. The American Rescue Plan was a huge step forward, because there is still much more we need to do to ``build back better,'' as President Biden has said. I believe we must pass the President's American Jobs Plan to make investments in our Nation's infrastructure that are long overdue. The investments in the American Jobs Plan will create millions of middle-class jobs, raise wages and help workers develop the skills that will power economic growth for years to come. Older workers will benefit enormously from this investment. As older workers are looking to return to work safely, it is also more important than ever that Congress dismantle barriers, the barriers that have long made it more difficult for them to succeed in the workplace. One of the most significant of these barriers is age discrimination. That is why I reintroduced my bipartisan Protecting Older Workers Against Discrimination Act, Senate Bill 880, along with Senators Grassley, Leahy, and Collins. This bipartisan bill will strengthen age discrimination protections and make it easier for older workers to seek justice in court. In addition to that, another bipartisan bill I was proud to introduce yesterday with the Ranking Member as well as Senator Portman and Senator Cortez Masto. It is our Senior Care Act, which would allow seniors with disabilities to work while keeping essential Medicaid benefits. Today Ranking Member Scott and I are also sending a letter to the Department of Labor calling on the Department to specifically address the needs of older workers as our Nation recovers from the pandemic. As we build a better economy, we must work together to ensure that older workers are included and prioritized every step of the way. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses about these policies and others that will help guarantee that older workers help us lead the way to a stronger future. Before we begin, I want to remind Committee members and witnesses to please keep remarks and questions to five minutes. The countdown timer can be viewed alongside the other participant windows on Webex, as you can see. Following opening remarks, Senators will ask questions based on seniority, and I ask that members have their cameras turned on a few minutes prior to their questions. Ranking Member Scott, I am pleased to turn it over to you for your opening remarks. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR TIM SCOTT, RANKING MEMBER Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman Casey, for holding this really important hearing, and thank you to all the witnesses for joining us today. It is certainly a very important topic and one that I am becoming more and more acquainted with personally as I talk to so many friends and family members as well as constituents who are really engaged in this new economy and are excited about that as our seniors re-engage at a high level of entrepreneurship. Twenty-two million jobs were lost in March. Many states are still recovering. According to BLS, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, our unemployment rate right now in South Carolina is about 5.2 percent. It is below the national average. For our seniors, nationwide more than 10 million Americans ages 65 and older were employed, but by 2020 in July, we saw 1.1 million had lost their jobs. That is a major part of this epidemic that we are trying to stress the importance of re-engagement here during this hearing, and I thank Chairman Casey for doing such good work on bringing the focus back to the economics that so many seniors face going forward and the important work that we can do here today. The pandemic, however, did open a door for teleworking, and that could be great news for our senior population. Companies have realized the value of older workers as well. Michelin, who has its national headquarters in South Carolina, has initiatives for older workers, including wellness, training, and intergenerational mentoring and phased retirement. According to the SBA, almost 51 percent of small business owners are over the age of 50. One of those entrepreneurs is Veera Gaul, the owner of Oil & Vinegar in Greenville, South Carolina. Veera had a long and successful career teaching at a culinary institute before opening her own business, a culinary store. Veera and her husband are now proud owners and business leaders making major contributions to their community. Every single Senator should stop and embrace Veera's passion to pursue the dream. That is why I am introducing the Golden Entrepreneurship Act. It is focusing on folks like Veera so that we can help encourage and motivate more successful entrepreneurs who are in their golden years. The legislation provides new training opportunities for senior entrepreneurs. It requires SBA to track the number and the amount of loans provided to senior-owned businesses. Seniors also have tremendous opportunities in the gig economy. Scores of seniors work as independent contractors, seasonal workers, and freelancers, and a 2019 report by ADP Institute found that 30 percent of all contractors were 55 years or older. They participate in the gig economy in a very strong and powerful way. They enjoy incredible high levels of job satisfaction. South Carolina's own Theodosia, who supplements her retirement income by driving Uber, says that her flexibility and her independence that comes from being an independent contractor is really important to her. As Americans continue to work longer, we need to ensure that the Federal Government supports this workforce. That is why Chairman Casey and I--and he just alluded to it--have sent a bipartisan letter to the Department of Labor on behalf of older workers. We need to advance policies that ensure that these amazing opportunities exist for our older Americans. Proposals like the PRO Act will dramatically hike the minimum wage. Those two specific areas can actually reduce the likelihood of success for our older Americans. The PRO Act would be devastating to drivers like Theodosia who would lose that sense of independence as her status is reclassified. We should focus our time and energy on issues where we can come together at the same table. I ask my colleagues to join me as we work together on behalf of our seniors who are still in the workforce. Thank you, and I yield back. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Scott. Before I introduce three of our four witnesses, I want to acknowledge that earlier Senator Rick Scott was in the hearing. I want to acknowledge that he was present, as well as Senator Blumenthal and Senator Rosen. What I will try to do, as I mentioned earlier, because Senators are in and out because of other commitments of time, especially other hearings, many Senators have not just one other hearing but sometimes three all within the 9:30 to 11:30 window. We will acknowledge folks, and some will be able to stay and ask questions; some will just be able to appear and listen for part of the hearing. Let us go to our witnesses, and just by way of introduction, before we get to their testimony. First I am pleased to introduce Elizabeth White. Elizabeth is an author and an advocate for solutions benefiting older adults facing uncertain work and financial insecurity. She worked in the nonprofit sector for many years and is also an entrepreneur. She is the author of ``55, Underemployed, and Faking Normal,'' in which she shares her own experience with job loss and provides guidance to older workers facing similar hurdles. I want to thank Ms. White for being with us today and for sharing her expertise with the Committee. Our second witness is Dr. Elise Gould from the Economic Policy Institute, so-called EPI. Dr. Gould is an economist whose work focuses on labor market trends, wages, and poverty in the United States. She has examined how the COVID-19 pandemic has affected the labor force and, in particular, older workers. I want to thank Dr. Gould for being with us today and for sharing her expertise with the Committee. Our third witness is Ramsey Alwin. Ramsey is from the National Council on Aging, known by the acronym NCOA. She is the president and CEO of NCOA and has previously held leadership positions at multiple organizations. Ms. Alwin, thank you for being with us today and for sharing your expertise. Finally, I will turn to Ranking Member Scott to introduce our fourth witness. Ranking Member Scott? Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman Casey. It is my pleasure to introduce today David Poston. David is the president and CEO of Palmetto Synthetics in Kingstree, South Carolina, and the vice chair of the National Textile Association. He is an entrepreneur, leader, and innovator, and I am proud of the work he is doing in my home state. David was a founding partner of Palmetto Synthetics, which has distinguished itself in the fiber industry by providing high- quality plastic products. Notably, for the purposes of this hearing, his company employs a workforce of over 250 South Carolinians with an average age of over 50 years old. Way to go, David. I like that. David's testimony today is based on his experience as an entrepreneur and job creator. We will hear about how his manufacturing business has worked to hire, train, retain, and support older South Carolinians, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Thank you, David, for being with us today, and thank you for being a living, breathing model of what it means to actually do what the goal of this hearing is. I appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Scott. We will now turn to our witnesses. We will begin with Elizabeth White. You may begin your testimony. STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH WHITE, AGING SOLUTIONS ADVOCATE AND AUTHOR, WASHINGTON, DC Ms. White. Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and honorable Committee members, thank you so much for inviting me today. I want to speak to what happened to me during the Great Recession as an older worker, as I think it will speak to what many older workers are experiencing today under the pandemic. I was someone who was doing very well until I was not. I punched all the tickets: Harvard MBA, Master's in International Studies from Hopkins, undergraduate degree from Oberlin College. Until the Great Recession of 2008-09, I had a career that I loved. I landed my dream job at the World Bank at 29. I was recruited from among 5,000 applicants. They took two Americans. I was one of them. In my 40's, I became a retail entrepreneur and won the National Retail Federation's Small Retailer of the Year. When the Great Recession hit, I was working two long-term consultancies that put me solidly in the six figures. Both organizations retrenched, and I lost both jobs over a 6-month period, taking my income to zero. I was not worried initially given my experience and credentials. I had the kind of network here, I would hear about jobs before they were even posted. Now in my mid-50's, I was not getting the traction I was used to. The few assignments I got were small editing jobs, teaching at UDC, paying a fraction of what I was used to learning. Weeks turned into months, then years, depleting my savings. I started noticing friends in the same boat, former high earners barely making ends meet. At a low point, I wrote an essay describing what it is like to land here, to feel like you are looking through a window at a world that you are no longer part of. The essay, published by Next Avenue, made its way to the PBS Facebook page and went viral. Thousands of people responded with, ``Me, too,'' ``This is my husband,'' ``my sister,'' ``my colleague,'' ``my friend.'' ``How come we are not talking about this? I have the background to look at the data, and I was astonished by what I saw. I learned that the median retirement income--sorry, the median retirement savings of near-retirees 55 to 64 is $60,000. I learned that more than half of workers in their 50's are getting pushed out of their long-term full- time jobs, and that only 10 percent ever again get a job at that level and pay of the one they left. It is hard to believe that all these people just suddenly became incompetent. After my essay appeared, dozens of people started to write me their personal stories. We were all kind of looking for a way forward. There are lots of books on the retirement income crisis, but they are typically focused on how to avert this crisis for people who are in their 20's and 30's today. There was nothing for people who are living this crisis now. I wrote ``55, Underemployed, and Faking Normal'' to fill this void. The second edition was picked up by Simon & Schuster, and I started getting invited to speak. My TEDx on my book now has nearly two million views. In my travels, I met displaced factory workers in Martin, Tennessee, and aged-out senior executives in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Their stories were surprisingly the same: lost jobs, depleted savings, homes in foreclosure, and marriage on the rocks, shame too, fear, anger, the American dream upside down. Today they have to worry about their health, too, and there is something Congress can do to make sure older workers are not left behind in the recovery. You can fight age bias in the workplace by passing POWADA. You can make sure that the Jobs Act specifically addresses the needs of older workers. You can extend basic worker protections to gig workers, and you can support older entrepreneurs. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. I look forward to your questions. The Chairman. Ms. White, thank you for your testimony. We are grateful you are with us today. Dr. Gould, you may begin your testimony. STATEMENT OF ELISE GOULD, Ph.D., SENIOR ECONOMIST, ECONOMIC POLICY INSTITUTE, TAKOMA PARK, MARYLAND Dr. Gould. Thank you, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and members of the Committee, for the invitation to participate in today's important hearing on supporting older workers amid the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond. My name is Elise Gould. I am a senior economist at the Economic Policy Institute, a nonprofit nonpartisan think tank that analyzes the effects of U.S. economic policy on working families. Today I would like to outline the economic impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on older workers, how it compares to the Great Recession, and how we can build a stronger, more equitable economy going forward. This morning, I have five points. One, the U.S. economy faced devastating job losses, a pandemic recession, and continues to face significant employment shortfalls. Two, older workers were not spared in this recession. Millions of older workers lost their jobs. Three, older workers lost employment in greater numbers in this recession than in the Great Recession. Four, older workers were hit further by the pandemic itself and were among the least likely to be able to work from the safety of their homes. Five, the economy requires continued assistance from policymakers to ensure that the economy continues, comes back strong, and the recovery provides greater economic security and opportunity for all workers, regardless of age, race, ethnicity, gender, educational attainment, and where they work. I will go back to my first point. While a solid 916,000 jobs were added in March, the strongest job growth we have seen since the initial bounce-back faded last summer, the labor market is still down 8.4 million jobs from its pre-pandemic level in February 2020. In addition, thousands of jobs would have been added each month over the last year without the pandemic recession. If we count how many jobs would have been created if the recession had not hit, we are now short 11 million jobs since February 2020. It could take more than a year to dig out of those total employment shortfalls. My second point: Older workers were far from spared in the COVID recession. Between March and April 2020, 5.7 million workers 55 and up lost their jobs. Older workers experienced a bit of a rebound last summer, but then lost ground through the fall. March 2021 was the first month since October 2020 that older workers saw positive gains in employment. Older workers are still down 2.1 million jobs since February 2020, and considering population growth over the last year, older workers are facing a job shortfall of over 2.7 million jobs. My third point: The labor market outcomes were far worse for older workers in this recession as compared to the Great Recession. In particular, if we look at women ages 55 to 64, they saw much larger employment drops in the most recent recession than in the prior one than what they saw in the Great Recession. This could be due in part to additional caregiving responsibilities. They may have left the labor force to care for elderly parents who left their nursing home or assisted living facility. They could have left the labor force to care for other ill family members or even to help take care of grandchildren when the schools shuttered. My fourth point is that over half a million or nearly 95 percent of the deaths from COVID-19 were among those 55 years and older. It will be no surprise then that many older workers not only lost their jobs but opted out of the workforce for fears over their own health and safety. This may be particularly true for older workers of color who have been hit harder from both the health and economic aspects of the pandemic. These trends were exacerbated by the fact that older workers were less likely than many other age groups to be able to telework before the pandemic hit. Now only about one-fifth of the current workforce is teleworking. What that means is that nearly 80 percent of workers are physically going to work. Not only does that include many older workers, but it is likely that millions of younger workers who cannot telework may be putting older family members at risk by going to work themselves. I will conclude by saying that policymakers have a role in reversing these devastating trends. In order for the economy to grow back quickly and stronger than before, policymakers should make sure the recovery hits all corners of the labor market. This means putting significant investment in policies that meet the pressing social needs the COVID-19 pandemic made so visible and that lead to greater economic security and opportunity for workers, including, but not limited to, physical infrastructure, caregiving needs for young and old, paid leave, and expanded unemployment insurance. Thank you for this opportunity, and I look forward to your questions. The Chairman. Thank you, Dr. Gould. Ms. Alwin, you may begin your testimony. Thank you. STATEMENT OF RAMSEY ALWIN, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, NATIONAL COUNCIL ON AGING, WASHINGTON, DC Ms. Alwin. Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and members of the Committee, thank you for this opportunity. At the National Council on Aging, we are guided by our equity promise that aging well should be a right, not a privilege. For millions of Americans, aging well means being able to work up to and beyond traditional retirement age. As longevity climbs and Americans struggle to save for retirement, work is essential to affording a longer life. This is especially true for older women and people of color who age into higher rates of poverty. Since 1968, NCOA has been a proud sponsor of the Department of Labor's Senior Community Service Employment Program, or SCSEP, which trains and places disadvantaged older adults into work. Today we provide SCSEP services in 11 states and Puerto Rico, including Georgia, New York, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania. This has given us clear insight into the tremendous value of older workers. Over the past year, these older workers have felt the devastating impact of the pandemic on their employment status. As of March, over 1.7 million older workers remained unemployed. Between August and January, 1.1 million workers left the workforce entirely. These are older adults that opted out due to the frustrations and the struggles. This drop in employment among older workers was even greater among older workers of color, twice that experienced by whites. Older women were among those most likely to lose their job or leave the labor market. Older workers have struggled with long-term unemployment of 27 weeks or more at greater rates than their younger counterparts. Over half of jobless older adults in March were long-term unemployed. If we are not intentional about targeting our policy solutions, the economic impact of these job losses will position too many older adults to age into poverty. Today I would like to share three potential solutions. First, we must strengthen federal age discrimination protections. Ageism is the last socially acceptable form of discrimination in our society, and it remains stubbornly ingrained in the workplace. It is time to treat it like every other unlawful bias. Senator Casey's Protecting Older Workers Against Discrimination Act is a great start, and we applaud him and Senator Collins for the bipartisan effort. We also support legislation such as the Protect Older Job Applicants Act championed by Representative Sylvia Garcia. On top of prohibiting birth dates on job applications, we recommend banning questions related to graduation dates and salary history. Second, we need to expand job placement and training services. Older workers have been left behind by public workforce programs, which view them as too challenging for job training and placement, fail to recognize part-time and flexible work and measurable success, and lack the targeted assistance and wrap-around services older adults need. The exception is SCSEP, and we should ensure it receives significant investments to restore the erosion in funding over the past decade and enable the program to respond to the challenges of today. We know the program works. Participants who secure work earn more in their first year than the annual training costs, and seven in ten remain on the job a year later. Yet current appropriations are $60 million less than the funding nearly three decades ago. As such, SCSEP is currently serving far less than one percent of those eligible. At a minimum, Fiscal Year 2022 appropriations should equal at least the $480 million approved in last year's reauthorization with bipartisan support. In proposals to expand and create new job training programs, older workers must be included. We applaud the President's call for a substantial investment in workforce development, and a recovery investment in SCSEP of at least $500 million should be included. Older workers should be explicitly listed as eligible and prioritized for expanded new workforce development programs. When addressing historic inequities certain populations face in accessing job training and placement opportunities, older adults cannot be left behind. Third, we must ensure equitable access to quality jobs. The Federal Work Opportunity Tax Credit rewards employers that hire individuals from specific groups who have faced significant barriers. NCOA endorsed prior legislation to expand WOTC to include low-income workers, and we believe it is needed again. We also endorse Senator Casey's Disability Employment Incentive Act, which would extend WOTC to individuals with disabilities. Quality job opportunities also means flexible work arrangements, so we look forward to working with Ranking Member Scott on his legislation to support older entrepreneurs. Of course, we are mindful of the many barriers individuals face in taking full advantage of entrepreneurship, gig, and flexible work, and for those arrangements to be available, we support wrap-around services, access to benefits, and income supports. In conclusion, we need increased federal leadership. We need an older workers bureau, housed at the Department of Labor, that could lead a focused effort across federal agencies to maximize older adults' workforce participation, and that would be good for older adults, employers, society, and our economy. As Mr. Hawkins, an Air Force veteran and successful SCSEP participant working again sums it up for us, ``I now live life to the fullest as compared to just existing.'' That is the power of work at every age. Thank you again, and I look forward to any questions you may have. The Chairman. Ms. Alwin, thanks very much. Finally, we conclude our witness testimony with Mr. Poston. STATEMENT OF DAVID POSTON, PRESIDENT, PALMETTO SYNTHETICS, KINGSTREE, SOUTH CAROLINA Mr. Poston. Thank you, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and members of the Committee. My name is David Poston, and I am president of Palmetto Synthetics in Kingstree, South Carolina. We are a textile manufacturing company that produces specialty synthetic fibers for a wide variety of applications like automotive carpet, military uniforms, performance apparel, and a wide variety of industrial uses, and we ship that fiber all over the world. We started Palmetto Synthetics in 1998 with five employees in one 50,000-square-foot building with the goal of producing the highest-quality specialty fiber in the world, and it was a green field startup, like literally in a soybean field. Today we have 250 employees working in 375,000 square feet, and we produce more specialty fiber for a wider variety of applications than any other company in the world. We operate 24 hours a day, seven days a week. I am blessed and thankful for our success, which is the result of our talented and dedicated employees. Today 50 percent of our production employees are over 50 years old, and 70 percent of our employees are over 40. Furthermore, 100 percent of our upper management is over the age of 50, as well as 90 percent of our middle management. We actually employ more managers in their 70's than in their 20's and 30's. We do this because we found, while tracking attendance statistics a few years ago, we noticed that employees over the age of 40 had much better attendance records than younger associates. Older employees were less often late; they did not leave before the end of their shift and were our most reliable workers. Since an employee who is late or absent has to be covered by a full-time person from a different shift, the teams with older employees translated to less overtime and higher-quality production. We also discovered how older workers were a valuable asset to mentor and set strong work examples for younger employees as we build a workforce for the future. Our production jobs are not strenuous. The majority of our employees are monitoring the control panels for our production lines. Without the jobs being physically taxing, we make an effort to recruit an older workforce to improve employee reliability and production. Over several years, as our workforce has aged, we continued to notice increased production and efficiency, so we actively recruit older production and management employees today. Like all other sectors of the economy, the American textile industry was especially hard hit by the pandemic. In the span of just a few weeks in March, we went from 100 percent capacity utilization to less than 15 percent. In the face of countless lost orders and idle production lines, though, we were able to retool our production line to help with the COVID response. We started producing fiber for COVID testing swabs and antimicrobial fibers for medical gowns. During this difficult period, we were able to keep 100 percent of our employees on the payroll because of the PPP loan we received. I literally do not know where my company would be today without the lifeline we received from the PPP loan. It saved most if not all of our jobs. I want to thank Senator Scott for his leadership on this program to ensure that small businesses in this Nation like mine had the resources they needed to weather the storm. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we implemented several social distancing practices on the production floor like mask requirements. We conducted temperature checks at the start of every shift to ensure our workers' health and safety. In 2020, we did have four seniors in management and 12 senior manufacturing employees choose to retire. As the economy reopens, we will recruit older associates to replace those recent retirees. Hiring, training, and retaining older workers is the key to our successful and efficient workforce at Palmetto Synthetics. Because of modern technology, manufacturing and production jobs are no longer out of reach of older Americans. Meanwhile, more and more employers are discovering the unique advantages of older workers in the workforce to mentor younger workers, retain institutional knowledge, and increase reliability. Again, thank you, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and the rest of the Committee, for allowing me to testify today, and I look forward to your questions. The Chairman. Mr. Poston, thanks very much for your testimony. We will move to questions. Before I do that, as I mentioned, some Senators will be in and out, and I just wanted to make sure that we acknowledge them when they have appeared. Senator Collins is with us. I see Senator Collins. Great to be with her. Senator Warnock as well. Let start with my round of questions, and I will try to follow my own guidance with regard to staying within my time. I wanted to start with Dr. Gould. Doctor, in your testimony, you described in detail how older workers have suffered as a result of the economic downturn, really a jobs crisis produced by the pandemic. Your testimony also made clear that while labor market conditions are improving, we still have a ways to go to erase the losses, the millions of jobs that were lost. I believe it is critical that we make the types of large- scale investments in our Nation's infrastructure and workforce that the President has called for, and I think all of us would agree that inaction, doing nothing, is not an option. The scale of our response I believe needs to reflect the scale of the challenge before us. Dr. Gould, can you speak about the direct investments and infrastructure in the workforce, the benefits that we can derive from those investments? In particular, can you talk about how those investments could benefit older workers? Dr. Gould. Yes, thank you for your question, Senator. Absolutely, those investments in public services are of utmost importance to older workers, like all workers would benefit from a stronger infrastructure. Particular components of that infrastructure investment, like broadband, would disproportionately keep older workers safer as it enables them to work from the safety of their home. Those caregiving investments, a very important component, again, of our infrastructure, will help older workers as caregivers as well as older workers needing care themselves. Increasing labor standards in that caregiving infrastructure that I have seen as part of that legislation will raise wages and improve working conditions. Making sure that we encourage employers having to a neutral stance toward unionization efforts will also reap the benefits of a unionized workforce in the improved delivery of those services. We need to address the health and safety concerns head-on, making sure older workers are protected in their workplaces from COVID, meeting best practices for infectious disease standards, PPE and the like. This will provide vital protections to older workers. Those are some examples, I think. The Chairman. Thanks very much for your testimony and for your answer to that question. I am going to move next, before my time is up, to Ms. Alwin regarding a letter that I received from Bonnie Marcus, who is a Pennsylvanian. I am holding in my hand the letter she sent me, and I will, for formal purposes, introduce this letter to the record and hereby do so by reference to it. Bonnie Marcus is from Kennett Square, Pennsylvania. That is in the southeastern corner of our state. She worked for her employer for years doing highly skilled work. She became a victim of age discrimination and was fired along with several colleagues. She had to fight through the court system for years just to get justice. Here is what she said, in pertinent part, in her letter: ``It was so painful to be thrown away like something that was used up and not needed. I really hurt from that, and I felt a profound loneliness because so many of my thoughts centered around work and how to have my whole group be successful. Now that was gone.'' Cases like this is why we introduced the legislation I referred to earlier, to fight back against age discrimination. Ms. Alwin, based upon the testimony you gave, can you speak about the different ways that age discrimination can both undermine older workers and, second, why it is critical that we strengthen these protections? Ms. Alwin. Well, thank you. Age discrimination can take many forms, and thank you for sharing that painful but all too universal story that older adults experience. Age discrimination can be less favorable treatment of older adults in the hiring processes and in employment, which can lead to involuntary retirement and inability to change jobs. It can lead to underemployment, the underutilization of workers, and longer periods of unemployment. Despite the 1967 Age Discrimination Employment Act, or ADEA, which forbids discrimination against those 40 and older, many individuals, nearly two-thirds of Americans age 45 and older, have either seen or experienced age discrimination in the workplace. According to the 2019 Ageism in the Workplace study, the number of age-related discrimination charges filed with employers to the EEOC by workers aged 65 and older have doubled from 1990 to 2017. It is imperative that we restore and reinforce age discrimination policies, and POWADA would be critical to that. POWADA would restore the age discrimination employment protections Congress initially intended. It has been over a decade since the Supreme Court decision undermined the ADEA and older workers. We should not have to wait any longer to see their rights restored. Thank you for your leadership in reintroducing--with the bipartisan support for POWADA and the President's call for stronger discrimination protections generally, we hope it is now finally time to restore age discrimination policies. The Chairman. Ms. Alwin, thanks for your testimony and the answers to questions. I will turn to Ranking Member Scott. Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I note that we have former Chairwoman Collins with us this morning. Senator Collins, if you would like to go next, I am happy to defer to you. I will go ahead and continue then. Mr. Poston, thank you for being with us this morning. You said some very interesting and, frankly, illuminating comments about the importance of having senior management that is a little more seasoned. I will say it that way. Can you speak to me about the vital role that experience in your management's team as well as some of the things that you mentioned was timeliness, attendance, overtime? All those things are benefits to the company, but it frankly benefits the end user, the person that you are marketing to, that they are in a better position to have a more competitive product at a more affordable price, more reasonable price, because your workforce is so synergistic. Is that an accurate depiction of why your focus on seniors in the workforce is so obvious? Mr. Poston. Yes, Senator, that is very accurate. Seniors are really our lifeblood. I think there is a shortage of manufacturing employees in all markets today, and if we relied on only younger people, I am not sure how any manufacturing company today could survive. We have to--this is maybe a different discussion, but we have to somehow educate the public that manufacturing jobs are not like manufacturing jobs in the 1930 in a steel mill. You are not carrying 50-pound bags of concrete. This is jobs where you are monitoring control panels, and you can do it very, very late in life. In fact, you would probably get better at it because you are wiser. Again, having a predominantly senior workforce has certainly helped our efficiency and quality and on-time delivery, and, again, I am just not sure what we would do without that. Senator Tim Scott. Well, two things you said earlier, I do want to continue that discussion on the transformation that has happened in manufacturing. I have visited dozens of plants by this point, and most places I go, the environment is very clean, the environments are easy workplaces. You have AC. You could literally--the areas that they are working in, you look at this old model that we think is manufacturing, and you look at the reality of manufacturing, and as simple as it is, people think of a sweaty, hot place without normal AC ventilation. The truth is that is just ridiculous. If you have been to a recent manufacturing location, they are pristine clean. You could scramble eggs on the floor and be fine eating them. I mean literally that clean, and I have been all over the country, and, frankly, I have been stunned by the amazing transformation of the workplace. Let me ask you a question. Are other folks in the industry following your lead on our senior workforce or not? Mr. Poston. I think they almost have to be, Senator. I think with the lack of people who are willing to do manufacturing jobs, I think almost all companies have to lean on a senior workforce. Again, I do not know how any other company would not notice what we noticed, that their attendance is better and their work is better. I would think other manufacturing companies especially would have to be following that lead. I am not suggesting that we led it, but it was something that we certainly noticed. Senator Tim Scott. Absolutely. I want to make sure that people understand that my recommendation was not necessarily to scramble the eggs on the floor and try that. It was just a suggestion that things have gotten a lot better, just in case someone missed that. Mr. Poston. You would greatly upset our VP of manufacturing if you tried that. Senator Tim Scott. Ms. White, ``55, Underemployed, and Faking Normal,'' I love the title, frankly, and love your passion and your energy. The platforms today, the gig economy provides our seniors with the type of flexibility that they want, the type of certainty that they decide on. The workforce of the future will have the gig economy as the reality. Can you explain the benefit of using the platform economy for retired workers who might, frankly, want to stay active or make a little supplement to their retirement income and/or make it a full-time go? Ms. White. Thank you, Senator Scott. I think the gig economy is actually a mixed bag. You know, on the one hand, it does offer some flexibility. They do talk about, you know, workers. It is their entrepreneurial spirit that drives them there. Actually, I think what is happening--and this goes back to some of the points that were made earlier. If you have half of the people who are in their 50's pushed out of the job market, pushed out of their jobs, and then only 10 percent ever again get a job that pays at a level commensurate with the job they left, this means that these are people who then become desperate, and they are looking for any kind of job. I think that the person that we see sometimes bagging groceries at Whole Foods is not there because they want to be. Some people do, I think, enjoy the flexibility of gig work, but then gig work, it is often low pay, it is no benefits, it is no worker protections. I think that if it is here to stay-- and it is. Right now it is already a third of workers are what they call ``employer independent.'' They think over the next decade it is going to be half of the workers are going to be in the sharing economy, then I think we should give them the same protections as we give other workers. Thank you. Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Ms. White. It certainly is important. I know that my time is out, so I will not prolong the discussion. I will note that the studies have reflected that about 90 percent of the gig workforce, those independent contractors, enjoy the flexibility, the certainty that they are setting for themselves as a part of the workforce. Obviously, there are folks who are doing the jobs because they have lost other income, other opportunities for employment. There is a mixed bag, and we will have to continue that discussion perhaps in the next round. Thanks so much. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Scott. As I acknowledged earlier, we have Senators that are in and out. Some are able to appear for a brief period of time. Others are able to stay for questions. We have got--many Senators have multiple hearings going on. I want to acknowledge that Senator Gillibrand was with us a little bit earlier, and so for the next two rounds of questions, we will go to Senator Kelly and then Senator Collins. Senator Kelly. Yes, so, Senator Casey, my understanding is that Ms. Alwin is on, too. I do not see everybody here. Ms. Alwin. Yes. Senator Kelly. Okay, great. Ms. Alwin. Hello, Senator. Senator Kelly. My first question is for Ms. Alwin. Good morning. Sorry I showed up a little bit later here. Ms. Alwin, overall the economy is beginning to recover. We had incredibly strong economic growth here this last quarter. The projection for the year is rather shockingly good. We are talking about older workers here. Nearly two million people age 55 and above are out of work across the country, and we know based on historical data that it is likely going to be harder for them to reenter the workforce than it will be for younger folks. Are there employer incentives or actions that we could take to encourage businesses to hire and retain older workers? Ms. Alwin. Well, thanks so much for asking, Senator. We have learned from the historical records on workforce trends and older adults, that they often face the longest spans of unemployment, and are getting rehired at half or a third of previous wages. We saw that in the Great Recession, and we have seen that over time. We are particularly concerned about what older Americans are facing now and do want to invest in strategies that would help best position them with the right job training and placement. Additionally, it is important to incentivize employers, and I talked about the WOTC as an opportunity that could be expanded to prioritize low-income older workers as a significant population that has been left behind, has experienced barriers. This could be a tax credit that employers would receive if they prioritize this population as well as other special populations. We think it is a win-win ultimately because, as you heard, older workers are incredible collaborators. Creativity and compassion and a range of uniquely human skills are brought to bear when you have an older worker in your workforce. Incentivizing with the Tax Code is a fabulous way to ensure older workers are not left behind. Senator Kelly. Well, thank you, Ms. Alwin. For Ms. White, Arizona has a State Plan on Aging, and this plan was informed by a series of focus groups of older individuals around the state. Computer literacy was brought up several times, and one respondent said that--and this is a quote--``Older citizens who must remain in the workforce require specific and often intensive training in computer usage, and computers are a huge stumbling block for many.'' I know we have probably all experienced that as we try to get our parents situated with technology. I have heard from Arizona seniors on my Seniors Advisory Group about the difficulties assessing online vaccine appointments. Nationwide, survey upon survey says that older workers do not feel they have the skills to keep up with the technology required in their jobs, and they are not being offered the training that they need. As technology advances, how do we make sure that these workers are not left behind? Ms. White. I think it is important to not lump all seniors into sort of one monolith, that we are talking about a 40-year age span and that we have seniors who are actually quite competent at technology or could rise to the occasion. We saw with remote work, for example, where in April of last year, like 75 percent of the workforce was working remotely, that seniors actually who were working were able to get onboard. I think it is really that what I saw in the Jobs Plan is where it is assumed that these programs will benefit seniors, whether it is in the area of the technology, whether it is training, whether it is investment, I think that in this early outline, older adults are not mentioned specifically. I saw one reference in there to--I think it was aging relatives was the only reference I saw in the Jobs Plan to older adults. I think that what is recommended in there will also serve older adults, but we have to--on the technology side, but we have to be very specifically targeted, and we have to be very specifically in the plan name. It is not enough to say that there is this technology program and assume in the jobs bill that older adults will be included. I think what is there is robust and muscular, and just to carve out so that we are also included. Thank you. Senator Kelly. Thank you, Ms. White, and thank you, Ms. Alwin. I appreciate your testimony. I yield back. The Chairman. Thanks, Senator Kelly. Before turning to Senator Collins, as the Ranking Member indicated, Senator Collins is the former Chair of the Committee, and I do want to thank her for her cosponsorship not just recently but over a number of years on the bill that several of us made reference to. Everything, as folks know in Washington, has some kind of acronym. This acronym is POWADA. If you do not know the acronym, it is the Protecting Older Workers Against Discrimination Act, Senate bill 880. Senator Collins, thanks very much, and we turn to you. Senator Collins. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I cannot pronounce the acronym, but I am wholeheartedly in favor of the bill and appreciate your leadership on it and am grateful to be the lead Republican with you as we try to get this bill enacted. I want to direct my question to Mr. Poston and Ms. Alwin this morning, but before I do so, Mr. Poston, I want to tell you that you gladdened my heart when you talked about the PPP loan and the difference that it made to you. I was one of the four chief architects of that bill. You are right that Senator Scott was a strong supporter as well as our Chairman, and I am just delighted to know that it was the lifeline that we intended for your employees. Let me turn to my question. I have two people who are very close to me, women who in their 50's--one was vice president of a bank, one was a vice president of a college--and both of them lost their jobs when a new president came in and essentially fired all of the senior management and brought in his own team, both at the college and at the bank. Each of these women had worked there for several years and had done very well, were in their mid-50's. What their experience in each case was that when they searched for new jobs, they could not find employers who were willing to hire them at anywhere close to the comparable salaries that they had previously received because they could hire younger people much more cheaply, even though they were getting a lesser skill level, a lesser judgment level. Mr. Poston, I am going to start with you. You clearly recognize that older workers bring reliability, judgment, and abilities that sometimes younger workers have not had the time to develop yet and that the tradeoff can clearly be worth it, even if you are paying them a little more. That is not the experience that a lot of people who lose their jobs in their 50's find. How can we encourage employers to recognize, as you have, the advantages of hiring older workers? Mr. Poston. That is a really good question, Senator. I wish I had the answer. I actually do not understand why you would not look for an older workforce today. You know, I think 20 or 30 years ago, when you started a job, you worked for that company for your whole career, so if you were 50 or 55 or older, a company might see you as too close to retirement age. Well, now we can hire a 55-year-old person; they may have 20 more years in the workplace. We see it as a way to capitalize on that person's experience, and not only for the jobs we hire them for, but also to mentor a younger workforce. I am not really sure what the answer would be there, and it is certainly not something that I understand or that we do. I am not sure why you would shun--to me, being the same age, a 55-year-old person is pretty young. I do not really quite understand it. Let me finish by saying again that I would not be sitting here today probably without that PPP loan. Senator Collins. That is great. Thank you. Mr. Poston. Again, I really, really appreciate that. It saved every one of my jobs. Thank you. Senator Collins. That is wonderful, and thank you for sharing your experience with older workers. I hope it inspires other employers. Ms. Alwin, do you have any thoughts on this issue? Ms. Alwin. Absolutely. Well, first and foremost, thank you for your leadership on POWADA. Enforcing age discrimination protections is critical, first and foremost. Also, I would say to employers step back and look at the overarching economy. The 50-plus market, what we call the ``longevity economy,'' has a direct spend of $7.6 trillion annually. This is a market that is buying your products and services. To be in touch with their consumer desires, their pain points, you need a workforce reflective of your consumer. Tapping into that experience, understanding that value of experience, bringing it to bear on your offerings as a leader in industry is critical to your success. Including older workers in your workforce is truly a competitive advantage. Senator Collins. Great. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Collins. I know we have some Senators that may be going back and forth, as I mentioned earlier, so what I will do now is I will start a second round of questions. I will begin. Ranking Member Scott may have questions as well. Then we will see where we are when other Senators are moving back and forth. I wanted to go back to Ms. White for a question, and I was particularly moved by your testimony as someone who had the experience you had and was able to take the time to write about it and to provide guidance to so many Americans who have experienced job loss and have been challenged in some of the ways that you outlined. I wanted to ask you about obviously the topic of age discrimination in the workplace that we have been talking about this morning, but also the need to make sure that all workplaces are welcoming of workers of all ages. In your written testimony, you talked about the need to tackle age bias in the workplace so older workers are not unfairly forced out of their jobs or, frankly, to ensure that they are not denied opportunities that they would deserve. This is critically important that we strengthen both legal protections for older workers, but also make clear to employers that no amount of age discrimination is acceptable. I would ask you, Ms. White, if you can tell us a little more about why you think it is important to both strengthen the protections for older workers but also the importance of employers not just refraining from discriminating, but fully embracing, as Mr. Poston and others have, fully embracing what older workers bring to the workplace, the value, the benefit of those workers in various workplaces. Ms. White. Thank you, Senator Casey. I think one thing to think about is today the worker who is 55 years and older is already a quarter of the workforce, and over the next decade, they are going to be a third of the workforce it is not an insignificant group. Ramsey has already talked about the $8.3 trillion that the over-50 market is spending, and we have a situation where if people who are pushed out of the workforce are not able to again get jobs, as somebody said to me, ``I do not have to trade my 4-year-old Chevy in every year. I do not have to shop at Starbucks to get a coffee. I can take it in my thermos.' At this point about how much we are spending as we are significant driver of the economy I think is one point. The other point is to start to look at the potential pressure on public finances. Teresa Ghilarducci, labor economist and retirement security expert, estimates that with the way we are going, half of people who are now 55, by the time they get to be 65, are going to be living in poverty or near poverty conditions. This is not a pesky little Boomer problem. We do not have even for Generation-X or for Millennials, they do not have pensions. They are facing uncertain work. You know, they are facing escalating costs in housing, health care, and all the rest of it. Boomers, we are just the first who are living longer, but this is going to be the future. We are the first generation to live as long as we are, then we are, you know, at this place where we do not have rules yet. We do not have supportive legislation yet. We do not have many role models. My fellow witness here from South Carolina, I am so excited about the company, because this is a role model. I would like to see the Federal Government use its purchasing power when you are contracting with companies to actually start to look at how are they doing in terms of retaining and recruiting and advancing older workers. What kind of investment, how are they leveraging mature talent? That as you are deciding--as a country as we are deciding who we are going to do business with, that will be one of the things that we also consider. I am less interested at this point in the laggard companies. I would rather get behind a company like this in South Carolina, have other companies understand what they are doing, convening companies that are on the forward edge like this of hiring older workers, understand the value, how do you include incentives, you know, so maybe there are wage offsets, et cetera, to help the companies that are already there to do more. Thank you. The Chairman. Thanks very much. With the Ranking Member's indulgence, I will lunge back into round one questions. Senator Braun is here. Senator Braun? Senator Braun. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. COVID has, I think, give us a big wakeup call about another looming issue that drives our trillion dollar deficits annually, and I think if there is a silver lining, it is forcing us to look at many things that we avoid here. I am interested--and try to keep your answers to maybe a minute or just a little more, because I would like to hear from each witness. The big elephant in the room is Medicare, its high cost, and Social Security. For anybody that is a Boomer, retired, nearing retirement, the program is in jeopardy. The Medicare Trust Fund I think gets completely depleted now in 5\1/2\ years. It is 2031 or 2032 for Social Security. I am going to ask each one of you, because the variables are fairly simple, it is just tough. To keep Social Security solvent, do you think we need to raise taxes, raise the retirement age, or means test? I would love to hear your opinions because if we do not get the political will soon to start doing something about it, it is going to be here before we know it, and actuarially we have known it for a long time. Raise taxes, raise the retirement age, or means test? Whoever wants to jump in on that doozy first, go ahead. Ms. White. It is such a doozy that I am going to sit it out because I would be--I would actually be--I would be speculating, and I do not want that on the record. I will come back to you. Thank you. Senator Braun. I respect that. Anyone else? Dr. Gould. Sure, I would be happy to answer your question. Thank you, Senator. As we know, Social Security and Medicare are essential lifelines for older workers. We have already heard statistics discussed about how many may be in poverty, and Social Security is one of the No. 1 poverty reducers we have in this country. Maybe as not a Social Security expert but, rather, a workforce expert, I would say that maybe one other option I would put on your list is to increase the income that provides the payroll taxes into that system. As we have had growing wage inequality, a smaller share of wages are actually provided in that payroll tax. We could go the other direction and increase the solvency in that way. Senator Braun. That would be in the category of raising taxes, and I think that is a valid subset of that variable as well. Thank you. Anyone else? Ms. Alwin. Senator, those are two very important social insurance programs for older adults, and we really believe in strengthening those programs. A piece of the puzzle is making sure people can work as long as they want and need to so that they can delay claiming that Social Security benefit. For each year they delay increases their benefit will increase by eight- percent, but it also means they continue to contribute those payroll taxes that can help us with the solvency. Addressing these challenges in terms of older workers that want and need to continue to work and get that employer-sponsored insurance when it comes to health care can also help in terms of delaying enrollment in Medicare. You know, there was an interesting analysis by the Commonwealth Fund last October. The cost of public programs and to older adults themselves when job losses are premature and retirement starts are significant. The analysis demonstrates if half of the pandemic-related job losses among older workers, roughly half a million, are among those with employer-sponsored insurance, and they have to transition over to Medicare, it could increase Medicare spending by more than $4 billion in a single year. It just reinforces the need for today's conversation and leadership at the federal level to help the older workers that want and need to continue to work to do so, for their own retirement security and for the solvency of our programs. Senator Braun. Thank you. Well said. I think there is one other potential opinion out there. Go ahead. Mr. Poston. I am not sure--that was pretty tough to follow there. I think I would agree. I am not sure I have the answer, and I certainly am not going to masquerade as an economist. Senator Braun. Well, and I think that would be an answer that many would have because it is so complicated. I am going to end with this: Medicare is the biggest driver, and I am probably the most vocal Senator on trying to reform health care in general. We need the help of retirement groups to help individuals like me that have made it work in the private sector by finding transparency, getting your employees engaged in their own well-being so when they get to retirement age, they can enjoy it and be healthy. I would love to continue the conversation with anybody that is interested. I did that 13 years ago, and when I resigned as CEO and CFO of my company, and still these two years have not had a premium increase. Transparency, competition, getting rid of the barriers to entry and getting health care consumers engaged in their own well-being helps Government pay for health care and the private sector. I would love to engage with anybody further if you are interested in that topic. Good talking to you today. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Braun, and I will turn back to Ranking Member Scott. I know that Senator Warnock has appeared in the hearing, was here earlier, and as I said, Senators are juggling. Unless Senator Warnock has a question, I will turn to Ranking Member Scott. Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I see Senator Warnock. I assume he does not have questions at this point. Ms. White, you wrote in your book that the shared economy offers us plus-50 workers opportunities to supplement our incomes by renting out our assets and not just our homes and cars but also our time skills, accumulated knowledge and experiences from your book that I enjoyed reading. Can you just expound upon the importance of having seniors re-engage in the economy and/or supplement income by figuring out their place in the marketplace, especially from a platform perspective? Ms. White. Thank you, Senator Scott. One of the things I wanted to do in my book was to offer older adults options, and I definitely think that the gig economy is one option. I sort of look at it as how do you create an interesting casserole of work. I have a number of friends, for example, who are empty- nesters and who are renting a room in their home, and this is a way that they are making money. What has happened now with the pandemic, they do not want all those strangers in their house, and so that as an income avenue disappeared. I see that the gig economy is here to stay. I think what we need to do is just make sure that it offers the same kind of worker protections as other work. It is not about like making it go away. It is not going away. If you--you know, right now some of them--Uber, I know, and I think it was Lyft as well, lobbied for their workers to not get the pandemic unemployment. Those kinds of things that I think are not actually worker friendly. I think the narrative about the gig work where they talk about, you know, it is for your entrepreneurial spirit, et cetera, is a little bit of a marketing game. Since it is going to be half the economy's jobs over the next decade, let us make it work for everybody. Thank you. Senator Tim Scott. Yes, ma'am. I will note that one of the beauties of the pandemic--there are not many beauties in a pandemic, but one of the beauties in the pandemic was forcing us to reevaluate and then recalibrate unemployment for those folks who are 1099 and independent contractors. Fortunately, because of the fact that the pandemic was not brought on by any company or any employee, we changed the way that we saw unemployment and did include those Uber drivers and all the 1099 independent contractors. Something else you say in your book that I think actually speaks to that point as it relates to funding and bridging toward retirement is you may be able to piece together enough income to put off filing for early Social Security and avoiding reducing your ultimate benefit. One of the points that I like in that comment is the importance perhaps, Chairman, for a future hearing is around income insecurity as well as the importance of focusing on the buildup in your 401(k). I know that in South Carolina and around the country, it is not uncommon for someone to have one year of income in their retirement accountable, and one year of income simply will not make 15 to 20 years in retirement comfortable, and one of the reasons why I really appreciate Ms. White's comments that I quoted from there is because of the importance of us focusing on the importance of financial literacy, especially in the golden years, and perhaps even the necessity of preplanning in the 40's and 50's to help us to prevent too many folks with too few dollars in their retirement accounts. I am sure we will have an opportunity to have a discussion about that, but I think Ms. White's quote reinforces the fact that there are too many folks getting closer to retirement who have to make a strong and tough decision about perhaps taking Social Security earlier because they need the income as opposed to being able to delay that and getting a full benefit. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for the extra round of questions, and I look forward to sticking around for another one. The Chairman. Ranking Member Scott, thanks very much. I was going to move--based upon our Senators now, I was going to move to close unless, Ranking Member Scott, you had additional questions. Senator Tim Scott. No, sir. You go right ahead. Thank you very much. The Chairman. Thank you, and I want to thank our witnesses for both your testimony and your insights today and for appearing at this hearing. We know that every corner of our country has been touched by this terrible pandemic and every family has been affected in some way. We cannot leave older workers behind as the economy recovers. Indeed, these workers must play a central role in driving it forward, and many of you provided insight and testimony about the value of older workers today in our economy. The American Rescue Plan made some great strides toward ensuring that all workers have access to a vaccine and that they can return to a safe workplace. Now I believe Congress should enact the American Jobs Plan to spur economic growth and create millions of good-paying jobs that benefit all Americans. We also have to remove the obstacles that have long stood in the way of workers, and one of those big obstacles, one of those big barriers, of course, is discrimination, age discrimination. That is why we need to pass the Protecting Older Workers Against Discrimination Act without delay. It is bipartisan, and I am grateful for the support that we have. There is much work to do, but I believe working together we can meet the moment and protect older workers. I look forward to the continued work of the Committee, and I will turn to Ranking Member Scott for his closing remarks. Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you to all the witnesses for investing your time and your expertise in this hearing. We as a Nation benefit when people stand up and take their place in leadership, and certainly we have seen four really strong individuals participate in this process today during the hearing. I would like to give a shout-out to Mr. Poston and, of course, he being a home-state guy, it is one of the reasons why I am so thankful that he is articulate and clear and consistent with the philosophy that our seniors are where some of the hidden gems, some of the hidden jewels are in the workforce. More importantly, as the employer sitting here amongst the panel, he is proving that it can be done successfully and effectively and, frankly, it actually helps the bottom line and helps his customers. Thank you for your participation in the hearing. To all of the other witnesses, I really enjoyed and learned during the earlier part of the hearing. While one of you was giving your opening comments, I thought to myself and I was telling my staff in the room, these folks are really smart, very engaging, and powerful. Being a part of this Committee is highlighted by the number of people who are passionate about aging gracefully and being included in the most important workforce in all of the world. I thank you for bringing your expertise to bear on the issues that we focused on. I will say that many of the legislative priorities from our good friends--I sincerely think of Chairman Casey as a friend-- are really focused on making the world and work better. I would disagree, perhaps even vehemently, on the outcome of those legislative priorities because I think it would actually harm our workforce more than help our workforce, but I do not question the intentions. I certainly am thankful that we live in a country where we can actually have a civil debate, have civil discourse around those priorities and issues that face our Nation and the future of this Nation, and I look forward to continuing to be a productive member of this Committee. I want to thank all the Committee members for participating in some form or fashion. I know that Senator Lee provided questions for the record. That is very helpful. I look forward to seeing the response from the witnesses. With that, Mr. Chairman, I am going to do what rarely happens and return my time. The Chairman. Ranking Member Scott, thanks very much. I want to thank again our witnesses, and the comments of the Ranking Member about our witnesses were entirely appropriate about how much they contribute not just to the hearing but to the larger debate about how we help older workers. For the record, I want to say that if any Senator has additional questions for the witnesses or statements to be added, the hearing record will be kept open for seven days, until next Thursday, May 6th. Thank you all for participating in today's hearing. This concludes our hearing. [Whereupon, at 10:53 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= Prepared Statement of Elizabeth White, Aging Solutions Advocate and Author, Washington, DC Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott and honorable Committee Members, thank you for inviting me to speak today. My name is Elizabeth White. I am 67 years old and live in Washington, DC. I am someone who was doing really well until I wasn't. I have a Harvard MBA, a master's in international studies from Johns Hopkins, and an undergraduate degree from Oberlin College. Until the Great Recession of 2008 to 2009, I'd had a good run in a career I loved. At 29, I landed my dream job at the World Bank. In my early forties, I became a retail entrepreneur and later a senior non-profit executive and consultant. When the Great Recession hit, I was working two long-term consultancies that put me solidly in the six figures. In the downturn, both organizations retrenched, and I lost both jobs within six months, taking my income to zero. I was not worried initially given my background and contacts. I was part of a robust network and accustomed to hearing about jobs before they were posted. Something was different this time. In my mid- fifties, I was not getting the traction I was used to; my phone was not ringing. My bout of unemployment/underemployment dragged on with weeks turning into months. The assignments I managed to get paid a fraction of what I was used to earning. I had used a chunk of my savings in my retail business and, now that I was jobless, I was running out of money and scared. I noticed friends my age, also former high earners, in the same boat. At a particularly low point, I wrote an essay describing what it felt like to land here--55, underemployed, and faking normal-- pretending to be okay when I wasn't. My essay made its way on to the PBS Facebook page where it went viral with thousands of people responding, ``me too.'' What was happening to me was happening to husbands, wives, brothers, sisters and friends. Many expressed gratitude that someone was finally shining a light on it. I was astonished to hear from so many people. I have the background to look at the data. I thought my case was an outlier situation but learned that I was not alone--by a long shot. Research showed millions of Americans in their fifties being pushed/aged out of the workforce. Most, 90 percent, never recovered financially. When looking for guidance and advice on a way forward, I found many books on the retirement income crisis, but mainly written for the trade. I couldn't find what I was looking for-- a survival guide written for people actually living the crisis now. My self-published book sought to fill that void and was later picked up by Simon and Schuster. As people learned about my work I was invited to speak at conferences and other events. A TEDx talk I gave now has nearly two million views. Having these opportunities to connect with other older workers going through similar struggles gave me perspective on the scale of the challenge. Over the past year, millions of older workers have gone through experiences during the economic crisis created by the COVID-19 virus that look exactly like what I went through. Many lost jobs, lost savings and are struggling to find work that pays even close to what they earned before. On top of that, they have also had to worry about their health and the health of their families. There are a number of policies that policymakers should consider to help these older workers and ensure that they are not left behind in our economic recovery. Actions Congress Can Take: Pass the Protecting Older Workers Against Discrimination Act (POWADA) Into Law Research tells us that over half of working adults in their fifties will lose their long-term, full-time positions involuntarily. Only 10 percent will ever find replacement jobs at the level and pay of the career jobs they left. All these people did not suddenly become incompetent. Workplace age discrimination is real and rampant. Too often to survive, displaced older workers end up taking low-wage, part-time, or gig economy type jobs to scrape by, wreaking havoc on their finances and prospects for a secure future. In an interview with MarketWatch, Teresa Ghilarducci, a labor economist and nationally recognized expert on retirement security, estimated that ``about 50 percent of workers over the age of 55 will be poor or near-poor adults when they reach 65.'' Passage of POWADA would send a powerful message that the Congress takes seriously the hard evidence and anecdotes that age discrimination is a major factor in the long-term unemployment of older workers and is prepared to do something about it. Ensure that the needs of older workers are specifically addressed in The American Jobs Plan The American Jobs Plan is a bold proposal that would invest in multiple sectors of the economy to stimulate economic growth and create jobs. Emphasized in the outline of the plan is the need to direct investment toward individuals and communities who would most benefit, and to ensure that nobody is left behind. As Congress works to fill in that outline, we must ensure that older Americans are included and that the unique challenges they face are directly addressed. In the initial high-level outline of the plan, older adults are mentioned as ``aging relatives'' in the section on the care economy, but we need to go beyond that. Lawmakers have an opportunity to create policy that will be inclusive of America's older adults, and they must take it. Here is what I would like to see: That Congress, when it crafts the legislation to implement the American Jobs Plan, undertakes the deep review and analysis required to ensure that the needs of older adults--both those who require care and support and those who can and still need/ want to work and contribute--are fully integrated into the policy. We know that everyday ageism renders older adults invisible and dispensable. This is why strong communication, oversight, and incentives will be needed to ensure that employers and employment support service providers prioritize the needs of older workers as much as younger ones. This is also why it's important that policies be both targeted and tailored to ensure that workers age fifty and older get access to the proposed training and good quality jobs. On the subject of jobs, please consider older job seekers and the role of gig work in the future legislation. Many older adults facing a ``don't want you job market'' are testing out these ``gig'' jobs. A 2015 study commissioned by Uber, found that it had more drivers over fifty than under thirty. Airbnb reports that one in four hosts in the United States are over the age of fifty and 13 percent of hosts are over the age of sixty. While these freelance type jobs may offer some flexibility, many provide grossly inadequate pay, no benefits and no labor protections like minimum wage, overtime, and workers compensation. ``Entrepreneurial spirit'' may call some older workers to the gig economy, but many take these jobs because they have no other options. If gig work is here to stay, it is time it provides the same protections under the law as other work. Let's also ensure that the legislation's proposed investments in research and development include assistive technologies to help older adults with age-related physical limitations succeed in the workplace. let's ensure that dollars going to help entrepreneurs, small business incubators and innovation hubs also benefit older entrepreneurs. According to Kaufman Foundation about a quarter (25.5 percent) of all new entrepreneurs are between 55 and 64. While many are ``necessity'' entrepreneurs, some are high potential growth businesses too--ideal for the small business incubators and innovations hubs proposed in the plan. In fact, a study by researchers at Northwestern, MIT, and the US Census Bureau looked at 2.7 million business owners who launched companies between 2007 and 2014 and found that a 50 year old is nearly twice as likely to start a top or very successful business as someone two decades younger. Finally, I would like to see the government leverage its purchasing power to fight age-based discrimination in the workplace. Workplace age discrimination, now compounded by the health risks of COVID-19, is forcing millions of older Americans out of their jobs into early involuntary retirement-- an involuntary retirement marked by poverty. Future legislation can be part of a broader effort to ensure that federal investments promote the creation of inclusive, age-friendly workplaces. The federal government has enormous purchasing power, and policymakers should examine how it can use that power to encourage employers to invest in and leverage talent across generations, especially measures to attract and retain older workers. Fully fund SCSEP and provide incentives for participating employers to provide higher quality, higher paying jobs At current funding levels, the Senior Community Service Program (SCSEP) can only service a small percentage of eligible individuals. Also, the profile of today's SCSEP job seeker is not the same as it was when the program was first enacted some 50-plus years ago, especially post the Great Recession and our most recent pandemic recession. In the SCSEP program where I consulted in 2017, some 40 percent of the participants had at least some college. SCSEP is limited to paying the minimum wage and few jobs offered advancement opportunities. Participants shared that they were grateful to be working, but struggled to make ends meet, let alone save. The economics of aging is forcing many older Americans to work beyond traditional retirement age. For SCSEP this means expanding its services to meet the needs of a broader cross- section of economically vulnerable older job seekers for higher skilled employment opportunities spanning more functions and sectors. What Congress can do is provide incentives to attract new private sector companies into the program and strengthen the participation of existing SCSEP partners in a way that allows them to offer higher skilled, better paying jobs. Incentives could include support for training and workplace modifications, wage offsets and other subsidies. As noted earlier, good quality jobs could also come from specifically targeting assistance to older job seekers in The American Jobs Act or other big federally funded jobs programs. Appointment of a Presidential Envoy on Aging, Longevity, and Retirement Security By 2034, it is estimated that there will be more Americans over age 65 than under age 18. Extended healthy life expectancy is a game changer. There is literally no sector of the economy it does not impact in profound ways--labor markets, financial markets, education, housing, and transportation. We are already seeing the consequences. What will it take for America to become age-ready? In the same way that John Kerry is leading the way on Climate Change, I would like to see a Presidential Envoy charged with anticipating the short and long-term challenges (and opportunities) of aging and longevity and coordinating an all-of-government response. Thank you for allowing me to share my story and ideas with you today. I know, firsthand, what it is like to be an older woman in financial jeopardy--the uncertainty and fear. It was stressful enough without having to contend with a pandemic. This is why it is so important, coming out of this COVID crisis, to meet the needs of older workers who are struggling and ensure tomorrow's economy works better for them than today's. Prepared Statement of Elise Gould, Ph.D., Senior Economist, Economic Policy Institute, Takoma Park, Maryland Thank you, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and members of the committee, for the invitation to participate in today's important hearing on supporting older workers amid the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond. My name is Elise Gould, I am a senior economist at the Economic Policy Institute, a leading non-profit non-partisan think tank that analyzes the effects of U.S. economic policy on working families. Today I would like to outline the economic impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on older workers, how it compares to the Great Recession, and how we can build a stronger, more equitable economy going forward. Older workers were devastated by the pandemic downturn and continue to face adverse employment outcomes In 2020, the U.S. economy took a hit like none other in recent history. The 2020 recession was driven by a highly unusual cause--the need to control the pandemic and keep people safe--its first-round impacts were far different than most previous recessions in terms of which sectors and workers were hit hardest and most durably. Workers across the economy, including older workers, experienced devastating job losses. Five point seven million workers 55 years old and older lost their jobs last spring--15 percent of total employment for this group--and remain over two million jobs short of their employment levels before the pandemic hit. Labor market outcomes were far worse for older workers in this recession as compared to their experience in the Great Recession. In particular, employment losses were greater for older workers 55 years and older in the pandemic recession compared to the Great Recession while the oldest of workers (65 years and older) experienced employment gains in the Great Recession and losses in the pandemic recession. In particular, women ages 55 and older were met with a harsher economic reality in this recession than the prior one. One of the reasons the economic reality was bleaker for older workers is that they were less likely to be able to telework coming into the pandemic. They were also significantly harder hit by the pandemic itself and therefore may have left employment in greater numbers because of concerns over their own health. The economy requires continued assistance from policymakers to ensure that the economy comes back strong, and the recovery provides greater economic security and opportunity for all workers, regardless of age, race/ethnicity, gender, and educational attainment. The U.S. economy faced devastating job losses in the pandemic recession and continues to face a significant employment shortfall At the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic, the U.S. economy experienced losses in March and April of 1.7 million and 20.7 million jobs, respectively, losses the likes of which we hadn't experienced in modern history. Figure A shows the monthly changes in payroll employment between January 2020 and March 2021. The labor market saw a significant bounce back in May and June with 2.8 million and 4.8 million jobs added, respectively. Unfortunately, over the remainder of 2020, job growth rapidly slowed as vital federal relief expired and the virus surged. Then, employment fell outright in December 2020, a loss of 306,000 jobs. A solid 916,000 jobs were added in March, the strongest job growth we've seen since the initial bounce back faded last summer. Even with these gains, the labor market is still down 8.4 million jobs from its pre-pandemic level in February 2020. In addition, thousands of jobs would have been added each month over the last year without the pandemic recession. If we count how many jobs may have been created if the recession hadn't hit--consider average job growth (202,000) over the 12 months before the recession--we are now short 11.0 million jobs since February. Even at this pace, it could take more than a year to dig out of the total jobs shortfall. The latest jobs number is certainly a promising sign for the recovery, especially as vaccinations increase and vital provisions in the American Rescue Plan (ARP) have continued to ramp up since the March reference period to today's data. While the benefits of the ARP will continue to be captured in coming months, more can be done to continue to keep the economic recovery on track, invest in the economic infrastructure, and surpass pre-pandemic benchmarks. Millions of older workers lost their jobs in the COVID recession Older workers were far from spared in the COVID recession. Figure B charts the monthly employment level for workers 55 years and older between January 2020 and March 2021. Between March and April 2020, 5.7 million workers ages 55 and up lost their jobs. This represents a loss of 15 percent of employment among older workers. As with workers overall, older workers experienced a bit of a rebound last summer, but unlike most other workers, older workers lost ground through the fall. March 2021 was the first month since October 2020 that older workers saw positive gains in employment. Even with that more promising gain of 308,000 jobs in March 2021, older workers are still down 2.1 million jobs since February 2020. This understates the shortfall in employment for older workers because it simply calculates what it would take to return to the February 2020 labor market. A better measure would take into account the fact that the older population has grown significantly since then. The 55+ population has increased by more than 1.5 million since February 2020. Considering what the employment level could be given the February 2020 employment rate and recent population growth, older workers are facing a job shortfall of over 2.7 million jobs. Older workers lost employment in greater numbers in the COVID downturn than in the Great Recession In the pandemic recession, older workers have faced a more challenging labor market than they experienced in the last labor market downturn, also referred to as the Great Recession. The official Great Recession followed the business cycle peak in 2007 and ended in 2009, though job losses continued into 2011. Therefore, the depth of the Great Recession is best measured by comparing 2007 with 2011. Figure C reports full year data on the share of the population with a job, also known as the employment-to-population ratio (EPOP), by age group, comparing changes in EPOPs in the Great Recession (2007-2011) with changes in the pandemic recession (2019-2020). Comparing full year data for 2019 with 2020 does not capture the full extent of the worst of the pandemic recession, but it provides a sense for how the year as a whole impacts employment across age groups. The depth and length of the recession on employment rates was worse for young workers (16-24 years old) and prime- working-age workers (25-54 years old) in the Great Recession than in the pandemic recession. EPOPs fell by 7.7 percentage points for young workers in the Great Recession and by 5.3 percentage points in the pandemic recession. Prime-working-age workers experienced less of a difference between the recessions, but they did see a slightly larger fall in EPOPs in the former recession than the latter (4.8 ppt decline versus 4.3 ppt decline). Older workers, on the other hand, experienced far worse labor market outcomes in the pandemic recession than the Great Recession. Workers 55-64 years old experienced more mild employment losses in the prior recession and workers ages 65 and older experienced outright gains in the prior recession.\1\ Job losses may have been lighter among older workers in the former recession because of where the job losses occurred as well as the fact that older workers' retirement income may have been more compromised during the financial crisis than during the COVID recession and therefore they may have remained in the labor force longer than they otherwise would have. In addition, in the current recession, older workers may have left employment for fear of the pandemic itself. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ While the aging population--namely baby boomers reaching age 65 during the Great Recession--may be a factor in the employment increases for workers age 65+ in the Great Recession, an examination of the same data using smaller age groupings confirms that the labor market led to fewer job losses among this group and the outright gains were experienced among those 65-69, 70-74, and 75 and older when measured separately. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Figure D compares the employment rates of men and women older workers, separately. Older men ages 55+ experienced greater employment losses than women in the COVID downturn, but older women experienced a bigger difference in employment between the Great Recession and the COVID recession. In particular, men ages 55-64 only saw a mild difference in their losses between the Great Recession and the COVID recession (3.0 percentage point changes versus 3.5 percentage point change in their EPOPs). Women ages 55-64 saw a much larger drop in employment in the most recent recession, 3.1 percentage points versus 0.7 percentage points. This could be due in part to additional caregiving responsibilities for this cohort of older women. They may have left the labor force to care for elderly parents who left their nursing home or assisted living facility, other ill family members, or even grandchildren when the schools shuttered. Both men and women ages 65 and older experienced a significant swing in employment between the Great Recession and the COVID downturn. In the earlier period, both men and women saw increases in employment, while in the latter period, both experienced significant losses. Older workers were harder hit by the pandemic itself and therefore may have employment in greater numbers because of concerns over their own health The data over the last year have been conclusive that older workers are at higher risk for severe illness from COVID-19. Figure E shows the disproportionate death toll borne by the population 55 years old and older. The vast majority--93 percent--of the deaths from COVID-19 were among those 55 years old and older. Over a half a million deaths were attributed to this older population. It would be no surprise then that many older workers may have not only lost their jobs but opted out of the workforce for fears of their own health and safety. This may be particularly true for older workers of color who have been hit harder from both the health and economic aspects of the pandemic. Unfortunately, older workers were less likely than many other age groups to be able to telework before the pandemic hit. Figure F shows the share of workers who were able to telework before the pandemic hit, by age group. Nearly three- fourths of workers ages 65 and older--or over five million older workers--are unable to telecommute. Over two-thirds of 55-to 64-year-olds cannot telework either; this represents another 15 million workers. That means that these workers, who are at higher risk for severe illness from COVID-19 because of their age, could be putting themselves at risk to earn a paycheck. The latest data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that only about one-fifth of the current workforce is teleworking. That means that nearly 80 percent of workers are physically going to work. Not only does that include many older workers, but it's likely that millions of younger workers who cannot telework may be putting older family members at risk by going to work themselves. Congress has taken important steps to protect the health and economic well-being of workers and their families during the pandemic. However, in order for the economy to grow back quickly and stronger than before, policymakers should make sure the recovery hits all corners of the labor market. This means putting significant investments in policies that meet the pressing social needs the COVID-19 pandemic made so visible and that lead to greater economic security and opportunity for workers, including but not limited to, physical infrastructure, caregiving needs for young and old, paid leave, and expanded unemployment insurance. Thank you and I look forward to your questions. [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Prepared Statement by David Poston, President and CEO of Palmetto Synthetics, Kingstree, South Carolina Good morning Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and members of the Committee. My name is David Poston, and I am President of Palmetto Synthetics in Kingstree, South Carolina. We are a textile manufacturing company that produces specialty synthetic fibers for a wide variety of applications like automotive carpet, military uniforms, performance apparel, and industrial uses. We ship our fiber all over the world. We started Palmetto Synthetics in 1998 with five employees in one 50,000 square foot building with the goal to be the highest quality specialty fiber producer in the world. It was a green field startup. Literally in a soybean field. Today we have 250 employees working in a 375,000 square foot facility and we produce more specialty fiber, with a wider variety of applications, than any other company in the world. We operate our facility 24 hours a day, seven days a week. I am blessed and thankful for our success, which is the result of our talented and dedicated employees. Today, 50 percent of our production employees are over 50 years old, and 70 percent are over 40. Furthermore, 100 percent of upper management is over the age of 50, as well as 90 percent of middle management. We employ more managers in their 70's than in their 20's and 30's. We do this because we found, while tracking attendance statistics a few years ago, we noticed that employees over the age of 40 had much better attendance records than our younger associates. Older workers were late less often, did not leave before the end of their shift, and were our most reliable workers. Since an employee who is late or absent has to be covered by a full-time person from a different shift, the teams with older employees translated to less overtime and higher quality production. We also discovered how older workers are a valuable asset to mentor and set strong work examples for younger workers as we build our workforce for the future. Our production and manufacturing jobs are not strenuous. The majority of our employees are monitoring the control panels of the production lines. Without the job requirements being physically taxing, we made the effort to recruit an older workforce to improve employee reliability and production. Over several years, as our workforce has aged, we continued to increase production and efficiency. We now actively recruit older production and management employees. Like other sectors of the economy, the American textile industry has been especially hard hit by the pandemic. In the span of just a few weeks last March, we went from 100 percent capacity utilization to less than 15 percent. In the face of countless lost orders and idle production lines, and the growing need for PPE, we retooled our equipment to help with the COVID response. We retooled to make fiber for COVID testing swabs as well as antimicrobial fiber for medical gowns. During this difficult period, we were able to keep 100 percent of our employees on the payroll because of a PPP loan we received. I do not know where our company would have been without the lifeline we received from our PPP loan. PPP saved most if not all of our jobs. I want to thank Senator Scott for his leadership on this program to ensure our nation's small businesses had the resources they needed to weather the storm. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we implemented several social distancing practices on the production floor, instituted a mask requirement, and conducted temperature checks at the start of each shift to ensure our worker's health and safety. In 2020 we did have four seniors in management and 12 manufacturing employees choose to retire. We intend, as the economy opens, to recruit older associates to replace these recent retirees. Hiring, training, and retaining older workers is the key to our successful and efficient workforce at Palmetto Synthetics. Because of modern technology, manufacturing and production jobs are no longer out of reach of older workers. Meanwhile, more and more employers are discovering the unique advantages of older workers in their workforce to mentor younger workers, retain institutional knowledge, and increase reliability. Thank you Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and the rest of the Committee for inviting me today to share this testimony. I look forward to answering your questions. Thank you. ======================================================================= Questions for the Record ======================================================================= Questions for the Record To David Poston From Senator Lee Question: According to a report published by the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), older workers are more likely to be independent contractors than any other age group, with the share of workers between the ages 55 to 64 rising from 18.8 percent in 2005 to 22.9 percent in 2017 and workers aged 65 and older, rising from 8.5 percent to 14.1 percent in the same timeframe. Allowing for elderly workers to have access to flexible work arrangements, such as independent contracting, allows for these workers to pursue employment opportunities that may better suit their needs than traditional employment. What can Congress do to ensure that the federal government does not stand in the way of businesses, like yours, from being able to provide flexible work opportunities for the elderly workforce? Response: Our manufacturing company operates 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Our manufacturing process does not allow for production to start and stop. Once running, our manufacturing lines need to operates continuously. For us, having full employment around the clock is extremely important. Our older workers tend to have be lowest absentee rates, especially on nights and weekends. We would welcome any change to offer more flexible schedules to our employees. Especially if the changes drove more seniors into the workforce. Question: The COVID-19 pandemic has shown that work flexibility has become an even more valued benefit than it already was in the past. However, under the Fair Labor Standards Act, the only option available to private-sector, hourly employees who work overtime is to receive monetary compensation at 1 1/2 times their normal pay. These private-sector employers are not legally able to offer their employees paid time off as an alternative option. I have legislation, the Working Families Flexibility Act, that would fix this problem, giving employees more flexibility on how they use their overtime benefits. As an employer, would you value being able to have more flexibility from the federal government regarding the types of overtime benefits you can offer your employees? Response: Absolutely. Being able to offer other options, such as paid time off, would be a tremendous help in the recruitment and retention of older workers. We as a company would like to offer more flexibility to our workers, especially the older ones, where money earned may not be their sole reason for being in the workforce. Offering more options other than overtime pay could help drive more seniors into parts of workforce, like manufacturing, that are currently desperately needing additional workers. ======================================================================= Additional Statements for the Record ======================================================================= Bonnie Marcus Statement for the Record I would like to start at the end of my story . . . I thought that after all of the time that has passed between the trials and now, I was over the hurt, pain and loneliness I experienced. I thought I had left behind the sadness over betrayal by ``friends'', the humiliation of my situation being known in the industry and the feelings of failure. Recently in talking to Senator Casey's representatives about my experience with age discrimination, I felt my ``stomach ache'' come back--that feeling of anger about an unfairness and the inability to do anything about it. I am reliving what happened, and I'm still damn mad, sad and upset. Now to the beginning. I started at the company in 1994 after being approached at an international conference by senior managers of the company. At the time, I was working at an oil company that was doing very little work in my area of expertise, and I was looking for other opportunities. I was 50 at the time and had been in the field since 1981; I went back to school when my son was in first grade for my longtime dream--a degree in chemistry--and I got my Masters while working for Union Carbide Corporation in New York. I was hired by the company as a Senior Chemist. I was promoted to Manager, Market Development Zeolites and Custom later that year and was added to the bonus plan. In 1999 I was promoted to Manager, Technical Market Development. In 2005, the privately held company had been sold and a restructuring was to occur. I was told by a VP privately that the restructuring was going to target older employees for layoff and that I would be one. That hit me like a ton of bricks. I was devastated that after rising so quickly and being on the path for advancement, I was going to be let go. I was really surprised since I had gotten the maximum bonus possible, excellent yearly reviews and was working on projects with other companies that were designated as our company's next generation products. After the layoff, I was hurt by the lack of feeling of the people running the new company. It was so painful to be thrown away like something that was used up and not needed. I really hurt from that, and I felt a profound loneliness because so many of my thoughts centered around work and how to have my whole group be successful and now that was gone. I felt betrayed by my bosses who I thought were friends and respected my work. It made me so sad and angry to realize that their attitude was ``take her, not me.'' My feeling of failure was very high when I was told that all of my projects were being discontinued--it meant that I had really failed badly. Then when I was told to stay for several weeks to transition the supposedly canceled projects to others, I was really angry at being lied to about the reason for the terminations. I also realized that all of the R&D people who were laid off were older--all over 55--and that our projects were being transitioned to younger people who were less skilled in the science. That's when I decided to fight them. I approached the others and suggested getting a lawyer which several of us did. I was terrified of the legal process. I was really scared about going ahead with it, but I wanted to be strong in order to help my co-workers. They were in my group and they depended on me to be the voice that supported them and kept them going. I felt like I had a really heavy weight on me. There were two trials; both of them lasted for more than a week and had about 20 witnesses. The trials were a nightmare; going into Philadelphia every day, hearing ``friends'' basically trash all of us and try to prove that age wasn't a factor. VPs and managers who changed their story several times as to why we were fired and not younger people even though it was apparent from the ages of the people let go and those retained what the reason was. The company kept introducing new non-age reasons for our being fired . . . it was like playing wack-a-mole--as their reasons were shot down by facts, they brought up new ones trying to prove that it wasn't about age. We constantly had to prove that the non-age reasons were not true, and yet I felt that they never had to justify why they had introduced the untrue reasons. All of it felt like the goal was to humiliate and demean us to justify their decisions to ``get rid of the old farts.'' The appeals the company made that prolonged the case added more and more stress. I felt like I was on trial not the company. I hated it. I'm not a publicly emotional person, and I surprised myself by bursting into tears at the end of the second trial and bawling my eyes out. I realized it was letting loose all of the stress I had. Before I could fully decompress, along came the company appeal to the next court and the threat of taking it to the U.S. Supreme Court. I just kept getting hammered and feeling that I was being punished for suing. We carried on and finally it was done and we won the appeal--it was the end of the nightmare. Thanks to the support of my family and my lawyer and my own strength, I made it through the nightmare to the end. Several times I wanted to quit the case because I was so worn out emotionally, but I knew I was doing the right thing for me and the others. I know that I can live with being angry about what happened, but I know that I couldn't live with not having tried to right an injustice. I hope you can help others to not have to go through what I did. [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] National Council on Aging May 4, 2021 The Honorable Robert P. Casey. Jr. Chairman U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging Dear Senator Casey, I am writing to express my appreciation for the opportunity to testify at last Thursday's hearing, ``A Changing Workforce: Supporting Older Workers Amid the COVID-19 Pandemic and Beyond'' on behalf of the National Council on Aging (NCOA). As mentioned in my testimony, the unfortunate events of the past year have created an unprecedented opportunity to transform how we think about the pandemic's toll on older workers and the workforce at large. Now, more than ever, we must make every effort to surface the right role for us to play in changing the landscape to address these challenges. This includes addressing age discrimination in the workplace, revitalizing training and re-skilling programs for older workers, and enhancing retirement and support for career transitions. We recognize that many of these issues are not new and have been put forth for many years. This demonstrates that during times of both economic crisis and economic growth, the employment barriers facing older workers remain unaddressed. We appreciate that one of the first outcomes of this hearing is the joint letter which you and Ranking Member Scott sent to Labor Secretary Walsh to request information on older workers and the Federal Government's response to the issues they face accessing and retaining employment. We hope this will be the first of many efforts to engage the Administration to focus on the unique challenges and opportunities of an aging workforce, both now and into the future. Thank you again for enlisting NCOA in this important dialog and the opportunity to raise these issues and solutions with the Committee, and we look forward to continued collaboration to support older workers during the pandemic and beyond. Sincerely, Ramsey Alwin President and CEO [all]