A REVIEW OF THE SBIR-STTR PROGRAM

Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship Senate September 22, 2021

Witnesses (2)

  • Glover, Mr. Jere W., Executive Director, Small Business Technology Council, Annapolis, MD
  • Kavetsky, Mr. Robert, Chief Executive Officer and President, Energetics Technology Center, Indian Head, MD

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- A REVIEW OF THE SBIR-STTR PROGRAM

[Senate Hearing 117-212]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 117-212

 A REVIEW OF THE SBIR STTR PROGRAM

=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS
 AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP

 of the

 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS

 FIRST SESSION

 __________

 SEPTEMBER 22, 2021

 __________

 Printed for the Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship
 
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov
 
 __________

 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 
47-001 PDF WASHINGTON : 2025 
 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 
 
 COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP

 ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS

 ---------- 
 BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, Maryland, Chairman
 RAND PAUL, Kentucky, Ranking Member
MARIA CANTWELL, Washington MARCO RUBIO, Florida
JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho
EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts TIM SCOTT, South Carolina
CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey JONI ERNST, Iowa
CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware JAMES M. INHOFE, Oklahoma
MAZIE HIRONO, Hawaii TODD YOUNG, Indiana
TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana
JACKY ROSEN, Nevada JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri
JOHN HICKENLOOPER, Colorado ROGER MARSHALL, Kansas
 Sean Moore, Democratic Staff Director
 William Henderson, Republican Staff Director
 
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 Opening Statements

 Page

Cardin, Hon. Benjamin L., Chairman, a U.S. Senator from Maryland. 1
Paul, Hon. Rand, Ranking Member, a U.S. Senator from Kentucky.... 3

 Witnesses

Glover, Mr. Jere W., Executive Director, Small Business 
 Technology Council, Annapolis, MD.............................. 5
Kavetsky, Mr. Robert, Chief Executive Officer and President, 
 Energetics Technology Center, Indian Head, MD.................. 32

 Alphabetical Listing and Appendix Material Submitted

Cardin, Hon. Benjamin L.
 Opening statement............................................ 1
Glover, Mr. Jere W.
 Testimony.................................................... 5
 Prepared statement........................................... 7
 Responses to questions submitted by Senators Coons, Rosen, 
 Risch, Inhofe, and Young................................... 60
Howell, Sabrina and Lerner, Josh, The SBIR Program at 44
 Statement dated September 27, 2021........................... 52
Kavetsky, Mr. Robert
 Testimony.................................................... 32
 Prepared statement........................................... 34
 Responses to questions submitted by Senators Coons, Rosen, 
 Risch, and Inhofe.......................................... 79
Paul, Hon. Rand
 Opening statement............................................ 3

 
 A REVIEW OF THE SBIR-STTR PROGRAM

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 22, 2021

 United States Senate,
 Committee on Small Business
 and Entrepreneurship,
 Washington, DC.
 The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:15 p.m. in Room 
301, Russell Senate Office Building, Hon. Ben Cardin, Chairman 
of the Committee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Cardin, Shaheen, Markey, Coons, Hirono, 
Rosen, Hickenlooper, Paul, Young, and Hawley.

OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, CHAIRMAN, A U.S. 
 SENATOR FROM MARYLAND

 Chairman Cardin. The Senate Small Business and 
Entrepreneurship Committee will come to order.
 Today we are holding a hearing on the review of the SBIR-
STTR program. I want to thank Senator Paul and our witnesses 
for agreeing to start this hearing 15 minutes earlier than the 
previously advertised starting time, because of the adjustment 
of a Senate schedule and voting. It gives us a little bit more 
leeway. So I just want to thank everyone for their cooperation. 
I know Senator Paul will be joining us, and he encouraged us to 
get started.
 So thank you all for joining us today for this important 
hearing, examining two of the Federal Government's most 
important innovation programs, the Small Business Innovation 
Research Program, also known as the SBIR, and the Small 
Business Technology Transfer Program, or the STTR for short.
 The SBIR and STTR represent the best of government and 
industry's partnerships. They harness the creativity and 
ingenuity of America's small businesses to solve the most 
pressing public health and national security challenges of our 
time. They also support the growth of small, high-tech 
companies that create high-paying, local jobs and keep the 
American economy on the cutting edge of the technology 
industry.
 Congress created the SBIR in 1982, to increase the 
participation of small businesses and federally funded research 
and development opportunities. Under the program, Federal 
agencies that budget at least $100 million annually for outside 
research must allocate a portion, 3.2 percent since fiscal year 
2017, to support research and development in small businesses.
 There are currently 11 Federal agencies and departments 
participating in the program, including the Departments of 
Defense, Energy, Education, and Health and Human Services.
 The program awards funds in three phases. Phase I, awards 
are up to $225,000 and may be used to conduct a feasibility 
study to determine if the idea's scientific and commercial 
promise. Phase II awards are worth up to $1.5 million, and may 
be used to conduct further research and development on the 
feasibility of turning an idea into a commercial product. And 
Phase III does not award funds but denotes that an idea is 
ready to move from the laboratory to enter the marketplace. 
During the commercialization phase, small businesses are 
expected to raise funds from private sector or non-SBIR Federal 
funding.
 Congress created the STTR program in 1992. While the 
program is similar to the SBIR in structure, utilizing a 
similar three-phase progression, STTR awards are made to small 
businesses engaging in collaborative research and development 
with Federal labs as well as nonprofit, educational, and 
scientific institutions.
 The program requires Federal agencies and departments that 
spend at least $1 billion on outside research to allocate at 
least 0.45 percent of those funds to STTR opportunities.
 The American people may not be familiar with SBIR and STTR, 
but they definitely recognize the products and companies that 
were created through the program. The Sonicare electric 
toothbrush, the iRobot, Lasik eye surgery, and Qualcomm, the 
company that makes the technology that powers our smartphones, 
were all made possible through SBIR and STTR grants.
 The programs also help prepare our Nation's public health 
infrastructure for the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2013, the National 
Institutes of Health, which is headquartered in my home State 
of Maryland, awarded $2.53 million SBIR grant to the Seattle-
based Adaptive Biotechnologies to support the company's 
development of adaptive immune system testing technology. On 
March 5th of this year, the Food and Drug Administration 
granted the company an emergency use for its T-Detect COVID 
test, which is able to detect a recent or prior COVID-19 
infection. The development of this test was a direct result of 
the research and development the company was able to conduct 
through an SBIR.
 While the test cannot be used to detect a current 
infection, the FDA is confident that the test will be 
especially useful for people who may have exhibited symptoms 
previously or believe they have been exposed but have not 
tested positive for COVID-19. The test will deepen our 
knowledge of the virus and help keep our communities safe.
 Simply put, SBIR and STTR have been invaluable to our 
national economy, and they continue to help us keep safe.
 I have had many discussions with State government officials 
and leading scientists in Maryland who have told me that one of 
the most sensible steps we could take to improve the SBIR and 
STTR programs would be to make them permanent. Right now, SBIR 
and STTR are only authorized through September 30 of next year. 
The high-risk research that grant awardees are engaged in 
requires more certainty.
 Instead of leading the researchers who will create the 
technology that will power the economy of tomorrow wondering 
about funding for SBIR or STTR, we in Congress have an 
opportunity and an obligation to make these programs permanent, 
which both the Pentagon and NASA have urged us to do.
 Acknowledging the importance of these programs is not meant 
to imply that they are perfect, by any means. Today we must 
also discuss how to best improve the speed of grant reviews, 
how to assist and target potential applicants in underserved 
communities, the disbursement of award funds, and whether to 
increase the percentage of funds that agencies and departments 
are required to set aside for these grants.
 I look forward to hearing more from our witnesses about how 
we can improve the SBIR and STTR programs to ensure that 
American technology and research industries remain the 
standard-bearer for the global economy.
 As I pointed out earlier, these programs have enjoyed 
strong bipartisan support in the United States Senate, and for 
good reason. They have really resulted in a very fine 
investment for America's economy and America's future.
 With that let me recognize the distinguished Ranking 
Member, Senator Paul.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RAND PAUL, A U.S. SENATOR FROM 
 KENTUCKY

 Senator Paul. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 When the Federal Government spends other people's money it 
has little incentive to spend it wisely. Unsurprisingly, when 
taxpayers are compelled to support research proposals without 
any expectation of a return on investment, the results often 
have been bad science and wasted dollars.
 The Small Business Innovation Research and Small Business 
Technology Transfer programs are no different. We should look 
at the history of SBIR and ask ourselves whether the taxpayers 
should be compelled to continue funding the folly of this 
program. For instance, the National Science Foundation spent 
nearly $1 million to genetically engineer an alternative hops-
flavored beer. Now why would the government, which is trillions 
of dollars in debt, offer this almost million-dollar donation 
when the $100 billion beer industry would likely finance such a 
project?
 The SBIR not only funds projects that would be taken on by 
private actors but it also is duplicative and funds projects 
that no one in their right mind would spend their money on. 
SBIR funded studies for a phone app that measures your 
gratitude. Yes, that is right, a phone app that measures your 
gratitude, whatever that means. The SBIR also funded an app to 
promote virtual clothing fittings. Really? I wonder what cretin 
thought that was a legitimate function of government.
 SBIR even provided seed funding to test a new show that 
teaches children to eat their fruits and vegetables first. 
Well, one would think the proposal would call to mind something 
we already do through Sesame Street, the pro-veggie kids' show 
that the Federal Government already spends millions of dollars 
annually on. Maybe we should not be surprised that the 
bureaucrats at the SBIR program offices have never heard of 
Sesame Street. If they had they might be able to count all the 
way up to $28 trillion, which is our national debt at the 
moment.
 A country approaching $30 trillion in debt cannot afford 
such frivolous spending. Now is the time to put a stop to such 
waste. A century of economic history proves, beyond a doubt, 
that the free enterprise system is best suited to provide 
capital to help small businesses grow and succeed. When private 
investors have skin in the game they will prudently invest 
their own dollars rather than roll the dice with taxpayer 
subsidies.
 Milton Friedman got this right. He explained succinctly 
when he said, ``Nobody spends somebody else's money as wisely 
as their own.'' When those investments pay off, everyone in the 
market wins. But only a select few win and have figured out how 
the SBIR program worked for them, and them alone.
 Some companies have been so successful in creating an 
entire business model and revenue stream that solely for these 
grants they are known as SBIR mills. An analysis by the State 
Science and Technology Institute showed that from 2009 to 2019, 
21 percent of the awards were made to the mills, which the 
institute defined as firms who received more than 40 Phase I 
awards. Forty grants to just one company may raise a few 
eyebrows as unnecessary and excessive and somebody abusing the 
system. According to SBA's public data, 196 businesses received 
more than 100 awards each. Some businesses received more than 
900 awards. It sounds like somebody has figured out the system 
here.
 Various studies show minimal or no program benefits for 
firms that receive multiple awards. They typically do not 
commercialize their products or move on from the program. 
Instead, they crowd out new small businesses from 
participating.
 The question is, why do these firms receive so many awards 
without any limitations from Congress? The SBIR program is 
typical of government programs that pick winners and losers. 
The SBIR mills, the winners, will always ask to continue the 
flow of free money. It is somebody else's money anyway. It is 
the small businesses that are crowded out of this program that 
are not heard from, and the taxpayers, the people who pay all 
the costs while others get the benefits. These people are the 
losers in this game.
 We need to question whether this program should continue to 
exist. We need to hold agencies accountable, and at the very 
least, we need to stop the abuse of the SBIR mills.
 Thank you.
 Chairman Cardin. We will now go to our witnesses. Our first 
witness will be Mr. Jere Glover, who is the Executive Director 
of the Small Business Technology Council, a group of small, 
high-tech companies, most of which are involved in the SBIR and 
STTR programs. Mr. Glover's experience with the SBIR is 
extensive, as he is one of the fathers of the program. As 
counsel to the House Small Business Committee, he directed an 
extensive set of hearings on small business innovation that 
laid the groundwork for the SBIR in 1978. He was also the lead 
witness before Congress in 1982, when the SBIR program was 
first proposed.
 Our second witness will be Mr. Robert Kavetsky, who is the 
Chief Executive Officer and President of Energetics Technology 
Center, a research and development organization headquartered 
in the great State of Maryland. ETC executes technology 
development and tech transfer programs for the Department of 
Defense and other agencies.
 We will start with Mr. Glover. And for the information of 
our witnesses, your entire statements will be made part of the 
record. You may proceed as you wish.

STATEMENT OF JERE W. GLOVER, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, SMALL BUSINESS 
 TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL, ANNAPOLIS, MD

 Mr. Glover. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chairman Cardin, 
members of the Committee. I am Jere Glover, Executive Director 
of the Small Business Technology Council of the National Small 
Business Association.
 We know America's small business, which employs 35 percent 
of our scientists and engineers, are the primary innovators and 
job creators led by entrepreneurs developing new products and 
services and focusing on building their businesses. Yet Federal 
R&D is still done primarily by large businesses, government 
labs, and universities. Congress realized this disconnect, and 
with President Reagan passed the SBIR in 1992, to make sure 
that at least a small portion of the Federal R&D dollars was 
done by small business.
 The resulting SBIR has become a primary driver for American 
innovation and jobs. Seventeen countries have copied the SBIR 
program around the world, and China is even going further, 
making investments in businesses, even American businesses. The 
European Union invests over 20 percent of its R&D dollars on 
small businesses, more than twice what the United States does.
 The genius of the SBIR program is it enlists our Nation's 
small businesses to competitively convert American science into 
scientific breakthroughs, useful technologies that meet the 
Federal needs while engaging entrepreneurs to build their 
businesses and create jobs.
 SBIR does not cost anything. It redirects a portion of the 
Federal R&D dollars to small business, the most innovative 
sector of the economy. These small firms must be based in and 
owned by Americans, and the work must be done in America.
 Why does SBIR work? One, it gets Federal R&D done by small 
business, the most innovative sector of the economy. Two, there 
is a merit selection based on technology. Three, it is highly 
competitive. Four, it focuses on agency needs and there is a 
commercialization focus.
 Attached to my testimony is a list of links to hundreds of 
SBIR success stories, but let me just mention two in particular 
that are on everybody's cellphones these days. One is the GPS 
and Bluetooth, and the second is CMOS, which is the camera 
technology used for almost all cellphones.
 Let me talk about the DoD. Two agencies, DoD and the 
National Cancer Institute, have both had detailed studies 
showing over 95 percent of all Phase II SBIR awards. Looked at 
it. Out of an investment of $16 billion by those agencies, it 
attracted additional $30 billion in additional assets and R&D, 
and returned $130 million in sales, $56 billion for acquisition 
of SBIR technologies by those two agencies.
 The market really loves SBIR. Fifteen of the leading 20 
biotech companies have SBIR awards, 15 of 2000. Two thousand 
SBIR firms have been acquired, DoD firms, have been acquired. 
Most major prime contractors recognize the importance of SBIR 
technology and actually acquire them. Most of them have 
acquired at least 10 SBIR firms.
 Over 4,000 SBIR firms have received $170 billion worth of 
venture capital. The SBIR rate of return at the DoD is 22-to-1, 
and 33-to-1 at National Cancer Institute. The SBIR returns in 
tax money, State and Federal tax income, over $3 for every 
dollar invested in the National Cancer Institute of Health and 
just slightly under $3 at DoD.
 The best program at DoD is the Navy. Its SBIR program will 
reach $1 billion per year in follow-on contracts. That is $2 
for every dollar invested.
 In conclusion, the SBIR program works.
 I am sorry. One other thing.
 In many sectors, SBIR funding is the primary source of R&D 
funding. SBIR and STTR invest in the innovation stage, well 
before venture capital and banks will provide risk capital. VCs 
focus on sectors such as software, internet, 
telecommunications, and health care. These get 83 percent of VC 
investment deals. SBIR, on the other hand, invests in a broad 
spectrum of technologies in all sectors and regions of the 
country.
 In conclusion, after 19 National Academy of Sciences 
studies, 4 economic impact studies that have found the SBIR 
program meets the congressional goals with over 50 percent 
commercialization. The SBIR program works and should be 
reauthorized as soon as possible and should be grown.
 Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Glover follows:]
 [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Chairman Cardin. Well thank you for your testimony, and 
more importantly, thank you for your service in regard to these 
programs. We really appreciate it.
 Mr. Kavetsky?

 STATEMENT OF ROBERT KAVETSKY, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER AND 
 PRESIDENT, ENERGETICS TECHNOLOGY CENTER, INDIAN HEAD, MD

 Mr. Kavetsky. Chairman Cardin, Ranking Member Paul, and 
members of the Small Business Committee, my name is Bob 
Kavetsky. I am the CEO of the Energetics Technology Center. ETC 
is a 501(c)(3) headquartered in Maryland. It has been my great 
pleasure to head ETC for past 15 years.
 I am an engineer by training, and prior to joining ETC I 
served 32 years at the Department of Defense, working on 
hypersonics and undersea warfare programs. I greatly appreciate 
you giving me the opportunity to share my thoughts on the role 
of small business, in general, and the role of the Small 
Business Innovative Research program specifically with you 
today, and I look forward to, after my testimony, answering 
your questions.
 You are all acutely aware of the important role small 
businesses play in our economy. My fellow panelist has 
addressed the critical role the SBIR program plays in not only 
getting new technologies into the hands of warfighters but also 
serving as an economic catalyst in many parts of the country.
 I would like to direct my comments today to the role small 
businesses play in what I like to call technology-based 
innovation ecosystems, and the importance of these ecosystems 
to our national defense.
 MIT economists, Gruber and Johnson, in their seminal work, 
``Jumpstarting America,'' do an excellent job of documenting 
the benefits realized from government investments in creating 
science-based innovations that came out of World War II. More 
importantly, they recommend that the Federal Government make 
additional investments to position the U.S. to continue its 
leadership role as a major economic and military power.
 Specifically, they identified 100 regions of the country 
that were ripe for the creation of technology-based innovation 
ecosystems. They suggest, and I agree, that such an investment 
will result not only in distributing our economic prosperity 
across the country more evenly but also contribute a strong 
national defense.
 Innovation ecosystems bring together industry, academia, 
and government to provide technology solutions to the 
government and private sector markets. Two prime examples of 
this are Silicon Valley's semiconductor and computer industries 
and Boston in life sciences.
 There is an opportunity now to create a whole nation of 
ecosystems using programs such as SBIR as a primary engine for 
this development. This is a critically important issue, not 
only for our national defense but in addressing what I see as a 
developing economic inequality between regions of the country 
that have these ecosystems and those that do not.
 My organization recently completed a study of energetics 
for the Department of Defense. Energetics are explosives and 
propellants that are used in our weapons systems. We brought 
together experts from industry, academia, and government, led 
by Dr. Theresa Mayer, Vice President of Research at Purdue 
University, to examine what has led to now well-documented 
shortfalls in U.S. military capabilities when compared to China 
and Russia.
 These shortcomings can be traced in part to two major 
issues: one, our inability to develop and then transition new 
material developments into our weapons systems, and two, the 
fragile condition of the existing supply chain, especially 
chemicals needed to produce energetic materials.
 Small businesses can play a role in addressing both of 
these challenges. For example, the SBIR program has a strong 
record of creating solutions to defense requirements in 
critical sectors. We envision such an investment in energetics 
would bring new and innovative companies into the energetics 
research arena.
 Second, we need to develop a network of specialty chemicals 
manufacturing and production facilities to ensure a robust 
supply chain for energetics. Currently we need approximately 
350 specialty chemicals to produce the energetic materials the 
Department of Defense needs. There is absolutely no reason 
these chemicals cannot be produced by small and medium-sized 
companies. This production does not need to be from industry 
giants. Most critically, we cannot continue to buy these 
chemicals from our adversaries, such as China.
 The second example I would like to highlight is the work 
the Navy's SBIR program currently has us conducting to reach 
out and involve underrepresented communities and companies in 
the program. The catalyst behind this effort is to ensure that 
the Navy is tapping into the full potential of all of America, 
not just a handful of communities.
 We have created a process called ``City TechFire'' which we 
are starting to pilot in Houston, San Diego, Phoenix, Detroit, 
San Antonio, El Paso, Jacksonville, Cleveland, Greensboro, and 
Harrisburg. It is already abundantly clear to me that there is 
a massive untapped potential in these communities.
 In closing, I would like to make a few recommendations for 
the Committee to consider. First, make the SBIR-STTR programs 
permanent. Second, increase SBIR allocation to 7 percent. 
Third, increase the STTR allocation to 1 percent. Fourth, 
expedite security clearances for SBIR and STTR firms. And 
fifth, require all agencies to set goals of at least 15 percent 
of all R&D goes to small businesses.
 Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Kavetsky follows:]
 [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Chairman Cardin. Thank you very much for your testimony, 
and particularly your specific recommendations, which we very 
much appreciate.
 We will start five-minute rounds. I want to take a little 
bit of my time to respond briefly to Senator Paul's opening 
comments. We disagree. I would like to see us devote more 
Federal resources to research and development. I think it has 
shown that this is in the best interest of our country. I was 
proud to be part of efforts to increase the amount of research 
dollars at NIH, and the amount of research dollars we do in 
defense, the amount of research dollars we have under NASA, 
because those partnerships that we have with the private sector 
has paid off big time for our national security interests and 
our public health interests.
 And the SBIR and STTR program are not really about the size 
of the programs. They are more about making sure that the part 
of the business partnerships are done with small companies, 
because we know small companies is where innovation takes place 
at a higher level and jobs are created. So we want to make sure 
that small businesses are part of our technology firms that we 
do partnership with.
 So I really do not quite follow the point that Senator Paul 
was raising, but I just want to put on the record that the SBIR 
and STTR program does not deal with the size of the programs. 
It does more in making sure the allocation of the private 
sector, that there is fair allocation for smaller companies.
 I also want to point out that as you look at the Federal 
agencies that support this, the Department of Defense supports 
these programs, because they know they are getting a better 
product as a result of the partnerships under the SBIR and STTR 
programs. So they are supporting it. NASA supports it, because 
they know it helps them in their mission, their science 
mission, which is very important to my State and very important 
to the agenda of climate change. They know that their 
partnerships with small tech companies helps them complete 
their mission in a more successful manner. And you gave us the 
ratios of benefits to cost, which is 22-to-1, 33-to-1. These 
are pretty large numbers.
 I want to ask one question to both of you, if I might, and 
that is, there have been several studies and reports that have 
been done on both the SBIR program and the STTR program. They 
are all very, very positive, about meeting the missions that 
Congress set to stimulate technology innovation, to use small 
business to meet Federal research and development needs, to 
increase private sector commercialization of innovation derived 
from Federal research and development. All very high grades.
 There is one part of the mission that has not gotten high 
grades, and that is to foster and encourage participation by 
minority and disadvantaged persons in technology innovation, 
and I add to that the women-owned small businesses.
 So my question to both of you is, how can we do a better 
job in making sure there is real diversity in the companies 
that we are working with so that there is opportunity among all 
of our communities?
 Mr. Glover. Well, the immediate answer is better outreach 
and things like FAST and the incubators innovation. That is 
interesting.
 Probably a more in-depth, there is a recent study--not a 
recent, I am sorry, several years old now, that I just 
discovered that the National Academy of Sciences has even 
pushed as one of their own, which looked at pitch days. And 
what they found was that pitch days discriminated against women 
in particular. When you see a venture capitalist, we all know 
tend to discriminate, directly or indirectly against women and 
minority-owned businesses. They simply do not fund as many 
proportionally as they do other things. So the system obviously 
favors, quite frankly, white male-owned businesses.
 One of the things the Navy is doing right now is their 
pitch days are gender neutral. There is no face-to-face contact 
and there is no way to know whether it is run by a man or a 
woman. And I think that is working. GSA, which you guys have 
allowed to happen a few years ago, now is doing $4.6 billion of 
Phase III contracts. Their process is gender neutral and does 
not really have people coming in and talking to them face-to-
face. Over 40 percent of their $4.6 billion is to women-owned 
businesses. It is an interesting phenomenon.
 If we speed up the process, make it happen very quickly, 
which it should, then I think you take some of the gender out 
of this and you will see that the awards are going to be more 
like the GSA, and we will overcome some of that inherent bias. 
But we have still got to do a lot more educational outreach. 
Women business owners need to be able to have places to go and 
people to work with. But I think there is some hope here that 
we can make this process work better.
 Chairman Cardin. Mr. Kavetsky?
 Mr. Kavetsky. So I have a couple of near-term pragmatic 
things that we are actually involved in, as we speak, to 
address the issue, Chairman Cardin, you raised. As a matter of 
fact, this morning I had a discussion Vic McCrary, who is at 
the University of the District of Columbia, in terms of how we 
can work with UDC to build an innovation ecosystem around his 
university, tying that actually into DARPA, one of the Defense 
Department's, as you know, cutting-edge agencies. Because in 
many cases DARPA program managers do not know about specific 
technical capabilities at some of the HBCUs, such as University 
of District of Columbia, North Carolina A&T--we are engaging in 
discussions with Dean Robin Coger at North Carolina A&T--Morgan 
State, in your own State, Senator.
 But the thing is you have to be present there and start 
making those connections, intimate connections in the case of 
the HBCUs, between faculty members and, in my arena, in the 
world of the Defense Department.
 Relative to the issue of females involved in SBIR, a number 
of states, such as yours, have programs such as ACTiVATE, which 
was created many, many years ago, encouraging female 
entrepreneurship. And I think, again, a pragmatic idea we have 
is to go where the females are. For instance, Purdue University 
graduates, I think, more female engineers than most 
universities in the country. We have a partnership arrangement 
with Purdue where we are seeing how we can tap into female 
engineers coming out of Purdue to both start companies and 
actually work in the defense sector. Thank you.
 Chairman Cardin. Thank you. Senator Shaheen.
 Senator Shaheen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to 
both of you for being here and for your testimony. Mr. Glover, 
I especially appreciate all of your support for the SBIR 
program. I have been a big fan, as I am sure you know. It was 
originally introduced by New Hampshire Senator Warren Rudman, 
and so our businesses in New Hampshire really like the SBIR 
program.
 And Mr. Kavetsky, I appreciated your comments about the 
Navy. I had the opportunity to do an embark on the U.S.S. New 
Hampshire submarine several years ago, and one of the things 
they told me was that the biggest concern on a submarine is the 
potential for fires, because the dryers, the way the dryers are 
vented. And I was able to tell them that I had just been to a 
company in New Hampshire that had an SBIR contract to try and 
address the problem of dryers on submarines. So obviously a 
very important program when it comes to innovation and what we 
need to do, both in the defense industry but also in terms of 
innovation throughout the economy.
 Mr. Glover, I understand that one of the things that you 
have been working on is the question of commercialization of 
SBIR technology, and, as you know, that is one of the issues 
that comes up again and again with respect to SBIR. Can you 
tell us what you have found in your investigation of this issue 
and what we can do to encourage commercialization of SBIR 
technologies?
 Mr. Glover. Well, in 2000, Congress added the requirement 
in the reauthorization for commercialization would be an 
evaluation factor. Obviously, the technology, the personnel, a 
lot of other things go in there, but one factor was added. And 
commercialization added then has changed the SBIR world. And 
what you see is every company knows that they have to have a 
commercialization component. There was some discussion of 
multiple award winners. Well, those award winners learned, and 
the companies now have all focused on commercialization.
 You know, 2,000 of these companies have been acquired. They 
did not get acquired because their technology was not 
commercializable. It was because somebody wanted that 
technology to put in their weapons system, to put in their 
business. There is real success there. Sonar and a lot of 
components of the submarine are SBIR-driven. We gave an award 
to Dick McNamara, who ran the submarine program at the Navy, 
many years ago, for reaching $1 billion of SBIR subcontracts on 
the submarine.
 So commercialization has changed. They all do it. They all 
do it very well. There are many success stories, and the idea 
that somebody is in this business to win a $1 million award, 
no. They are in this business to develop a technology that 
somebody will pay lots of money for, whether it is DoD or 
somebody else.
 Senator Shaheen. Thank you. Do you agree with Mr. Kavetsky 
that we should make the program permanent?
 Mr. Kavetsky. Oh definitely, yes. I believe the ROI on SBIR 
is pretty clear-cut, so I think the evidence speaks for itself.
 Senator Shaheen. And do you agree with that, Mr. Glover?
 Mr. Glover. Yes, indeed.
 Senator Shaheen. I thought you might.
 Mr. Chairman, I hope that this Committee can make the SBIR 
program permanent, because I think it would be good for 
innovation in the country. So thank you.
 Chairman Cardin. As I think Senator Shaheen is aware, we do 
have hopes of getting legislation that can accomplish that 
purpose during this Congress. Senator Coons.
 Senator Coons. Thank you, Chairman Cardin, and thank you to 
both our witnesses today. I am intimately familiar with the 
SBIR and STTR programs, and the Small Business Development 
Center in Delaware has done a great job over many years to help 
make sure that there are small businesses in Delaware, in our 
community, and our innovation ecosystem who are able to take 
advantage of the resources that this pries loose from otherwise 
very large research-oriented conglomerates. And it creates 
opportunity, opportunity for small businesses to innovate and 
opportunity for the agencies that this is essentially directed 
at to achieve their mission. So I see real value in making SBIR 
and STTR permanent programs.
 I was proud to contribute to the Support Strong Startup 
Businesses Act to the NDAA, and to introduce the RAMP for 
Innovators Act, which I hope we will consider again on the path 
toward reauthorization.
 Mr. Glover, if you would, what would be the outcome for 
businesses if we failed to reauthorize these programs? What 
would be the consequences, both for the agencies that rely on 
them and for the businesses that have participated?
 Mr. Glover. Well, there is very little that we have in 
American as an advantage over the rest of the world. SBIR is 
one of those things. Now it is being copied, but not doing it 
as well or as effectively as we have. You lose SBIR, you lose 
that innovation spur. Most of the companies that get SBIR 
funding would not have developed that technology otherwise, the 
studies have shown. So we would lose that.
 We would also lose a lot of job-creating potential. In my 
testimony I list all the success stories, and I list, in 
particular, a number of companies that have come out of the 
SBIR program and have grown and developed. Things not only like 
your cellphones, Qualcomm starting, but some Symantec and a 
whole bunch of other companies would not have gotten their 
start.
 Eleven of 15 top biotech companies would not have gotten 
their money. At critical stages in economic development the 
government needs to provide funds because the private sector 
will not. Half of venture capital now goes overseas. It is no 
longer just an American phenomenon. And SBIR, without that, you 
would lose thousands of companies, thousands of individuals who 
would never have a chance to see if their technology, their 
ideas could grow into new markets and new businesses.
 Senator Coons. Mr. Glover and Mr. Kavetsky, some criticize 
SBIRs and tend to try to characterize them as just sort of 
repeat funding by the Federal Government of businesses that 
never actually produce anything, that do not commercialize, 
that do not come to scale. What do you think are the biggest 
remaining barriers to helping those who are successful in 
winning SBIR-STTR contracts and then developing technology? 
What are the biggest barriers to actually getting integrated 
into larger systems, or getting acquired, or being able to 
scale, that we should be mindful of as we move toward 
reauthorization?
 Mr. Glover. As I understand the question--and there is a 
little echo here so I might not have gotten it exactly right--
--
 Senator Coons. What are the barriers to commercialization?
 Mr. Glover. The commercialization is in areas one never 
expects it to be. Innovation drives new industries, new 
technologies that did not exist before, and they make things a 
lot better, and the SBIR program, by and large, goes into those 
areas. But it does provide one thing that is very important. 
The government needs research done. And when a company gets a 
2nd or 3rd or 10th or 100th award, it is because the people 
reviewing it decided that was the very best proposal, the very 
best company to give them the research they need.
 Senator Coons. Mr. Kavetsky, did you want to contribute 
briefly, and then we will move on.
 Mr. Kavetsky. I have a very specific answer to that, that--
I do not know if it is DoD unique. I think perhaps it is--and 
that is we need to make sure that people in the defense 
contracting business understand the contracting flexibilities 
that have, under the SBIR program, to rapidly acquire products 
and further R&D work from these companies. Many of our defense 
contract shops are very wedded to what we call the FAR, the 
Federal Acquisition Regulation system----
 Senator Coons. I am quite familiar with it.
 Mr. Kavetsky [continuing]. That would choke an elephant if 
you tried to eat it. And frequently they do not take advantage 
of the flexibilities afforded them under SBIR to more rapidly 
transition technology, which, from our standpoint, is 
imperative that the Defense Department be able to move nimbly 
in acquiring new technology.
 Senator Coons. Thank you for that input. Thank you, Mr. 
Chairman, for this hearing. I hope that we will proceed with 
reauthorization.
 Chairman Cardin. Thank you, Senator Coons. Senator Hirono?
 Senator Hirono. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I always wonder 
why people who say that they support small businesses and yet 
criticize programs such as the SBIR and STTR programs, without 
which small businesses would not be able to compete for the 
billions of dollars in Federal money that the Federal 
Government lets out. And so I always wonder, you know, what the 
thinking is, but maybe there is not that much thinking going 
on.
 Okay. So when we meet with small businesses, particularly 
with women-owned small businesses, they always say that access 
to capital is one of the real barriers to them being able to 
get started. That is why I have been a very long-term supporter 
of both SBIR and STTR programs. You talked a little bit, both 
of you, about what would happen if these programs were not in 
place. And, in fact, there is a lot of innovation that comes 
out of the small business sector of our economy, not from the 
big corporations. Isn't that true, there is a lot of innovation 
that comes out of small, you know----
 Mr. Glover. Absolutely. Years ago there was a study that 
showed two-thirds of major innovations come from small 
business. More recently, there is a study that says 20 percent 
of key innovations come from the SBIR program itself.
 Senator Hirono. And that is why, for a lot of us, it is 
very clear the import and importance of these programs.
 I do want to ask you a question, for both of you, about the 
SBA's Growth Accelerator Fund Competition, which has been an 
effective program when it comes to promoting startups, but 
especially those by women and minorities and those in 
underserved areas.
 Senator Booker and I recently introduced legislation to 
expand the program, called the SOAR Act, which would provide 
increased support for organizations that work with these 
businesses, and I am happy to report that Accelerate Hawaii, 
which is a growth accelerator in Honolulu, recently received an 
award through this program, and that President Biden has 
requested increased funding for fiscal year 2022, from $10 
million compared to $2 million in fiscal year 2021.
 Can either or you, or both of you, discuss why growth 
accelerators are so important for businesses in the SBIR-STTR 
programs and the broader innovation ecosystems more generally?
 Mr. Kavetsky. Well, I think Mr. Glover mentioned earlier, 
these types of programs, these funding sources provide some 
critical capital in the development cycle, even before, 
sometimes, the venture firms get involved. We find that is 
absolutely critical. That actually also applies to even 
technology and research done in defense labs as well. We call 
it the ``valley of death,'' that we try to get these companies 
through, if you will.
 So I think programs such as you were mentioning, Senator, 
are absolutely critical for providing those kinds of resources.
 Mr. Glover. The growth accelerators, FAST, those 
operations--and I attached two of those to my testimony to sort 
of what local organizations can do to increase the SBIR program 
and make them do work better--is critical, absolutely. And 
there are many states. Hawaii has had some great SBIR firms 
through the years. But it needs some additional infrastructure 
to help it match and compete with companies coming from Silicon 
Valley; Austin, Texas; Boston. And those accelerators and FAST 
programs do provide that knowledge and training that helps them 
understand.
 If you are in Boston you walk down the street and ask 
somebody what to do. You cannot do that in most of the country.
 Senator Hirono. So, of course, you would support increasing 
the funding for these accelerator programs, and I am glad you 
mentioned that. It is not easy for the entrepreneurs and 
innovators in Hawaii. We are kind of removed from the venture 
capital community, and often they want to be right there. And 
so you need these programs to get these companies to the point 
where they could attract venture capital. Would you agree?
 Mr. Glover. Absolutely.
 Senator Hirono. I also wanted to ask you about the SBA's 
Federal and State Technology Partnership Program, the FAST 
program, which provides competitive grants that can be used to 
promote diversity in the SBIR-STTR programs. I am very 
committed to increasing the opportunities for women and for 
minority-owned enterprises to have access to these kinds of 
grants. And so the FAST program is a partnership with the 
states to really facilitate this kind of diversity.
 President Biden has requested a substantial increase for 
the FAST program next year--$10 million compared to $4 million 
for 2021. I take it you would support that kind of increase 
also.
 Mr. Glover. We strongly support FAST. It is a great 
program. There is a chance to succeed if you are just really 
good and do everything right, without any help. But boy, it 
sure helps to be able to meet with people, talk to people, have 
people who know what they are doing, to facilitate your 
learning curve. It makes it much quicker, much faster, and much 
better.
 Senator Hirono. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Cardin. We were joined by Senator Young via Webex. 
I just really wanted to acknowledge that he was present. He 
indicates he has no questions he wants to ask.
 I will recognize Senator Hawley.
 Senator Hawley. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good timing. Thank 
you for waiting for me. Thanks to the witnesses for being here.
 Mr. Glover, if I could just start with you. I have seen 
some reports depicting the distribution of the SBIR awards, and 
I noticed that some of these reports include heat maps that 
suggest that there is a relative concentration of awards that 
are allocated to the East and West Coasts and to larger metro 
areas that already have a lot of capital, I mean, just by the 
nature of what they are and who they are. By comparison, more 
rural states like mine, Missouri, have been granted relatively 
fewer awards, and that is true even when you adjust for the 
population differences.
 So my question is, what do you think accounts for this 
geographical discrepancy?
 Mr. Glover. As an individual from a small rural town of 
1,400 people in Tennessee, I have had that fight and debate and 
discussion for a long time. And I entered into a debate at NYU 
some years ago in which they were saying that the Boston folks 
were saying there was no venture capital shortage in America. 
And I explained, I said, ``To the women in the audience, and to 
anybody outside the coast, it is a problem,'' and it certainly 
is.
 What we see, though, is that the SBIR program does about as 
well on science indicators, or maybe actually better in 
different science indicators like R&D, scientists, engineers, 
money going to universities--it does a little bit better than 
average in most states. Indiana has a very good system, and it 
works pretty well.
 We need to do more, and I think the FAST, the growth 
accelerator programs and others, one, should be increased, and 
two, should focus on underserved areas and populations. I was 
surprised and disappointed when I saw some limited FAST money 
going to California and Boston. Now, I understand it was going 
to rural areas that might be a little underserved, but quite 
frankly there are a lot of other states that are much more 
underserved.
 So we can do more there. It is a merit-based program, which 
is the beauty of it. If you do put a geographical requirement 
or a quota or a percentage, you would lose the merit-based, and 
that would make it have ripple effects in terms of getting 
people to accept the technology. Right now, when you win an 
SBIR and you go through a competitive round, your technology is 
vetted and reviewed in most cases, and people say this 
technology has at least a government seal of approval, so let's 
look at it. You take that away and it is just like anything 
else. The hardest thing to do is to convince somebody your 
technology has merit.
 Senator Hawley. Let me ask you--thanks for that answer--let 
me ask you about something that you wrote in your testimony. 
You said the SBIR program needs to do a better job of 
attracting high-quality, rural technology companies. So on a 
similar theme here, what tangible steps do you think the 
program can take to try to attract and recruit companies that 
fit that profile?
 Mr. Glover. You know, the universities are really helpful, 
but they are, again, more geographically focused. Like in 
Indiana you have got major universities doing good things and 
it is easy to build a company around university-driven 
technology. When you get away from that in the area, so that is 
when you get into--and SBA is doing a much better job than it 
used to, of online education, online training, so that a good, 
smart inventor, entrepreneur anywhere in America can win. And 
while we focus on the general area, we always want the best 
science to win but we want to make sure that the best scientist 
has an opportunity to compete and a fair chance.
 Senator Hawley. Mr. Kavetsky, do you have any thought on 
that?
 Mr. Kavetsky. Yes, I do. Relative to rural activity, I had 
a couple of thoughts. First, there are large businesses in all 
these rural areas. Frequently they are farming or agricultural 
businesses. If you talk to a farmer, and actually I happen to 
be married to the farmer's daughter so I have some experience 
in this arena, you find they have a whole host of problems that 
technology and programs like SBIR could help them with.
 And so I think part of it is really engaging with the major 
industries in any region and really understanding their 
problems, and bringing them then to the program that can 
actually help them. I am mainly a defense guy, but, you know, 
there is SBIR in agriculture and other arenas, and certainly I 
think that would be part of a specific thing.
 I have seen, as well, some states actually offer an SBIR 
match. They have seen the SBIR program is so good for them 
economically, you know, from an economic development 
standpoint, that the State actually matches an award from the 
Federal program with State dollars, which I would encourage 
rural states to consider as well.
 Senator Hawley. Very good. Thank you both for your 
testimony, and thank you for being here. Thank you, Mr. 
Chairman.
 Chairman Cardin. Thank you. I know that we were joined by 
Senator Rosen, and I understand that she did not have 
questions. I know Senator Markey has been with us. I am not 
sure he is ready now for questioning. Senator Hickenlooper is 
on his way, I have been told.
 So what I am going to do, I have a couple of questions I 
would like to ask. Mr. Kavetsky, in your recommendations you 
are suggesting that we increase the percentages that are 
allocated to both programs. I have been in the Congress when we 
have increased those numbers, and I know at times we have had 
different views from different stakeholders in regard to the 
changing of the percentage. I am just interested as to your 
assessment as to if the various stakeholders are prepared for 
us to increase the percentages of these two programs.
 Mr. Kavetsky. Yes. Thank you, Chairman Cardin. I think the 
short answer to that question is yes. Again, I work mainly in 
the defense sector, mainly with the Army and the Navy, and I 
know both of those program offices are ready to scale their 
program dramatically. They suffer, if you will, from many more 
proposals, good proposals, that they would like to fund that 
they cannot fund because they just do not have the resources to 
do that. I think that would engender additional competition, 
which is important to delivering quality products to our 
military, and also it would be an increased economic 
development engine across the country, if you will.
 Chairman Cardin. And a related question is that there are 
different eligibilities for agencies that are part of the SBIR 
and STTR programs. Do we have that right on the agencies that 
are included in those programs, obviously more on SBIR program 
because of the lower threshold than in the STTR program. Do we 
have that right?
 Mr. Glover. I pretty much think so. I think an SBIR 
program--and it is permissible for any agency to do an SBIR. 
And there have been some discussions about some of the agencies 
below the threshold, you know, could take advantage of using 
the program. And that may have been tried once or twice. But 
SBA can facilitate that if it is desirable.
 Chairman Cardin. So we will be looking at--we are looking 
at permanency, and I appreciate both of you strongly support 
that. At the same time, we would look at whether there are 
provisions that need to be updated or changed. And it seems 
like you are saying that increase the percentages should be 
under consideration but the eligibility of agencies that have 
to participate, you think it is pretty well--working fairly 
well, at the current dollar amounts?
 Mr. Glover. The real concern that I hear most often is the 
uncertainty that the program's life, and when we went through 
that with 14 continuing resolutions over a period of three 
years or so, the agencies stop-start, everybody cannot plan, 
cannot budget. It becomes a real serious problem not to have it 
continued, and that is why we would urge SBIR be continued as 
quickly as possible.
 Chairman Cardin. And Mr. Kavetsky gave us some specific 
recommendations. Mr. Glover, do you have other specific changes 
that you would like to see in the statute, other than 
permanency and perhaps considering increasing the percentage 
amounts?
 Mr. Glover. We have a variety of those. I will be happy to 
send you those. But yes, they are very similar to Bob's list of 
recommendations.
 Chairman Cardin. Good. That would be helpful if you have 
that information.
 I believe Senator Hickenlooper may be on the Webex?
 Senator Hickenlooper. I am here.
 Chairman Cardin. You are up.
 Senator Hickenlooper. Sorry about that. I was out racing 
around trying to, you know, get through wind and peril and 
other aspects of it. Give me one second here.
 All right. And part of this we heard as I was listening in, 
in transit, or my staff was. Colorado is a center of tech 
innovation. I think our State is home to over 30 Federal labs. 
How much further can we support STTR in bridging that gap 
between these labs and the smaller innovators? The innovators 
would be entrepreneurs, you know, putting that research into 
action.
 That is for both witnesses.
 Mr. Kavetsky. Yes, I would like to comment on that, 
Senator. We are actually working on just such a program with 
the Army Research Lab, and the Army Research Lab is the Army's 
corporate research institution, about 1,500 Ph.D.'s there. They 
have actually asked us to focus on finding those small 
businesses that should be collaborators with the Army Research 
Lab scientists and engineers, and that is a national effort. 
That is not just in the State of Maryland, where ARL is 
headquartered.
 Some of you may be aware that the Army Research Lab 
instituted a program called ``Open Campus'' about six years ago 
under Dr. Tom Russell, where they opened up branch campuses. 
They are all across the country. And part of the motivation for 
that was to tie into these innovation ecosystems across the 
whole nation and not just those geographically proximate to ARL 
headquarters in Maryland.
 So I think that is one example I would offer as a specific 
example of the type of work that, in this case, the Army 
Research Lab has an organization like us helping them with in 
terms of being kind of a tech scouter, tech hunter, and 
connecting small businesses to their researchers. Thank you.
 Senator Hickenlooper. All right. And then the second 
question, and the famous ``valley of death'' that, you know, 
stage between research and successful innovation. In other 
words, that period where you get up and going but then you find 
all the glitches. Beyond making the SBIR-STTR permanent, how do 
we, or should we require agency goals around R&D to go 
specifically to small businesses? How do you look at that?
 Mr. Glover. Interestingly enough, the SBIR law never 
expected to be the only program driving small business to the 
Federal R&D. They expected there to be goals, and there is a 
very specific requirement in the law that there be goals for 
small business, in general. We always expected there would be 
follow-on programs, once SBIR was proven to be so good that 
there would be other programs.
 That is a requirement. I think it is absolutely important. 
It is essential. With the most effective sector of the 
innovation economy, why shouldn't the government be spending 
more than maybe 6, 7, 8 percent with small business? The 
government ought to be spending a lot more. There definitely 
should be goals. I know that the Air Force is considering 
putting goals in place for small businesses, and I think the 
other agencies should do so as well.
 Senator Hickenlooper. Good. Well, we agree on that, and I 
think there are a lot of avenues that we can do to work on 
that.
 Another one of our priorities is ensuring equitable--you 
know, a level playing field for entrepreneurs who may come from 
socially disadvantaged background. Can you expand on how SBIR 
and STTR support diverse entrepreneurs and innovators?
 Mr. Kavetsky. If I could offer a specific example, Senator, 
that I touched on briefly in my comments, the Navy SBIR program 
actually is funding my organization to do exactly that. We 
have, over the last year, created a methodology. We call it 
``City TechFire'' to give it a little bit of glitz. We have 
actually identified an initial set of 10 cities across the 
country, 10 regions, where our focus is really on reaching into 
underrepresented groups, if you will, of businesses, and even 
colleges, if you will. Because in many cases you find the 
entrepreneurs, you need to get to them when they are in college 
so that when they are coming out of college those that have an 
entrepreneurial bent have a forum and a pathway ahead for 
creating their own business.
 So again, the Navy program actually has us doing that as a 
focused effort, with the idea being we could expand that from 
our lessons learned from this initial set of 10 cities to 
cities all across the country, cities and regions all across 
the country.
 Senator Hickenlooper. Does that seem viable at this point?
 Mr. Kavetsky. Oh yes. I mean, what we are finding is there 
is a real appetite in each of these communities, not 
surprisingly. We are working with the P-TECH network which is, 
in some cases, an underutilized network. But we are really 
finding a real hunger for this. And as with any other program, 
you find some areas are hungrier than others, and those are the 
organizations we like to work with, where a local economic 
development group is really trying to do what we like to call 
technology-based economic development. And we focus in on 
working with those organizations. But we are having some 
initial success, especially in places like El Paso, as one 
specific example where we are getting some really good 
traction.
 Chairman Cardin. If we can I want to go to Senator Markey 
and allow him to ask the questions so I do not have to go into 
recess, because of a vote that is pending, with Senator 
Hickenlooper's cooperation, if you have completed your 
questioning.
 Senator Hickenlooper. Yes, absolutely.
 Chairman Cardin. Senator Markey.
 Senator Markey. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, very much, and 
thanks to our witnesses from Maryland who have joined us today. 
Maryland and Massachusetts are not that dissimilar in terms of 
the overall makeup of our economy. And there is no question 
that SBIR and STTR programs have played a crucial ingredient in 
the economic vibrancy of Massachusetts, like Maryland itself.
 So far, 24,000 SBIR and STTR grants have been given to 
Massachusetts companies, which is an astounding number, 24,000. 
And just in 2020, we had 718 Massachusetts companies receiving 
over $400 million worth of investment. And it works. It has 
created hundreds of thousands of jobs, ultimately, in 
Massachusetts. And they are smaller companies, innovative 
companies.
 And I know, Mr. Kavetsky, that you support making SBIR and 
STTR programs permanent. I do as well. Why don't I just give 
you a minute to make the case for why these programs should be 
permanent. How long, oh Lord, do we have to go while 
recognizing the absolutely indispensability that these programs 
play in the economic growth of our country.
 Mr. Kavetsky. Yes. Thank you for that question. I will give 
you a very specific example of why the permanency is absolutely 
critical, and that has to do with the time it takes for the 
Defense Department to implement what we call a program of 
record, whether it is a weapon or a ship or whatever platform 
we are developing. And those program executive offices, we call 
them, they need to know that the SBIR program is going to be 
there.
 And people like Dick McNamara, many years ago, as Mr. 
Glover noted, used SBIR to really disrupt the base for 
submarine technology companies, and used SBIR as the fulcrum to 
do that. If he did not know that SBIR was going to be around 
for five or six or eight years during the development cycle of 
that submarine, he would not have stuck his neck out as he did, 
as the PM, to make that happen.
 So I think there is a very pragmatic reason, at least in 
the world of defense, that we need this program to be 
permanent, so if a PEO does want to stick their neck out and 
look at adopting emerging technology they know SBIR is going to 
be there to provide that critical funding to mature the 
technology to the point where the program can adopt it.
 Senator Markey. Thank you, and I think you put your finger 
right on it. We need predictability. Companies, private sector 
companies, they need predictability.
 And over to you, Mr. Glover. Can you give us an example of 
an agency, a Federal agency, that takes the SBIR program and 
simplifies it, streamlines it in a way that you believe is 
absolutely a model for how the program should be operating 
across the whole country, because so many different Federal 
agencies participate. But can you give us a good example of one 
that does it, in your mind, at the top of the level of 
excellence?
 Mr. Glover. I really cannot give you a model agency that 
has simplified it. Congress passed a law a couple of years ago 
that said the agencies should standardize, simplify, and 
expedite the contracting process. There has been some 
improvement in that area, but we still do not have that 
compressed.
 The shocking GAO study said it was taking 300 days between 
Phase I and Phase II to get contracts. That ought to be 
automatic. You ought to have a simple contract, you go to Phase 
I. Some grant agencies send you the grant when they tell you 
you have their word. Why can't contracting the agencies do 
exactly the same thing? The same for Phase II and Phase III.
 What we do know about GSA, when they started writing Phase 
III contracts they cut that down to 90 days, that had been well 
over a year, and almost impossible in some cases, ever. They 
get it down to a year and they are doing a very good job of it.
 And I want to reiterate that over 40 percent of their 
awards are going to women-owned business. That process is not 
discriminating against women, because they are doing very well 
under the program.
 Senator Markey. And how about minorities?
 Mr. Glover. Minorities are doing okay, but the women is 
what was really shocking, how much better they were doing. But 
minorities are doing better than the regular.
 Senator Markey. Well, let's hope that a year from today we 
can say how shocking it is how well minorities are doing, as 
well as women. That should, in my opinion, be the objective 
which we seek to achieve.
 So thank you both for your great testimony today, and back 
to you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Cardin. Thank you, Senator Markey, and I want to 
thank both of our witnesses not only for their testimony but 
for what you have done in regard to these programs. This 
testimony will be very helpful to us as we look at legislation 
in regard to both programs.
 With that the Small Business and Entrepreneurship Committee 
will stand adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 3:23 p.m., the Committee was adjourned.]

 APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 

 [all]