Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-191] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-191 RULE BY DISTRICT JUDGES II: EXPLORING LEGISLATIVE SOLUTIONS TO THE BIPARTISAN PROBLEM OF UNIVERSAL INJUNCTIONS ======================================================================= HEARING before the COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ APRIL 2, 2025 __________ Serial No. J-119-12 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.judiciary.senate.gov www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 61-880 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Grassley, Hon. Charles E......................................... 1 Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 4 WITNESSES Bray, Samuel L................................................... 6 Prepared statement........................................... 42 Responses to written questions............................... 48 Panuccio, Jesse.................................................. 10 Prepared statement........................................... 54 Responses to written questions............................... 76 Vladeck, Stephen I............................................... 7 Prepared statement........................................... 82 Responses to written questions............................... 88 APPENDIX Items submitted for the record................................... 97 RULE BY DISTRICT JUDGES II: EXPLORING LEGISLATIVE SOLUTIONS TO THE BIPARTISAN PROBLEM OF UNIVERSAL INJUNCTIONS ---------- WEDNESDAY, APRIL 2, 2025 United States Senate, Committee on the Judiciary, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:15 a.m., in Room 226, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Charles E. Grassley, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Grassley [presiding], Cruz, Hawley, Kennedy, Blackburn, Schmitt, Britt, Moody, Durbin, Whitehouse, Klobuchar, Blumenthal, Hirono, Padilla, Welch, and Schiff. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF IOWA Chairman Grassley. Welcome, everybody. One of our witnesses--oh, they are all here now. Thank you. Thank you for the hard work you put into this, to bring this issue to the Senate's attention. I want to give a quote: ``It just can't be right that one district judge can stop a nationwide policy in its tracks and leave it stopped for the years that it takes to go through the normal process,'' end of quote. Those words are from Justice Kagan, said during a speech 3 years ago. I happen to agree with her. Our hearing today is--goes by the title of, quote, ``Rule by District Judges II: Exploring Legislative Solutions to the Bipartisan Problem of Universal Injunctions.'' I hope that we can continue the discussion from our hearing on the same topic in 2020, and focus on some legislative solutions. For a number of years, but particularly in the last few months, we have seen increasingly sweeping orders from individual district judges that dictate national policy. These orders, quote, unquote, called ``universal injunctions,'' direct the Government to take--or, not take action with respect to persons who are not even before the court. Although our Founders saw an important role for the judiciary, they did not design a system that made judges national policymakers. They adopted a Constitution that strictly limited courts to exercising power of the words that are in the Constitution, to ``cases or controversies.'' Sweeping universal injunctions defy nearly two centuries of historic precedent. For the first 175 years of our history, universal injunctions were unheard of. They have been extremely rare until the last decade. Now we can barely read the news without learning of another district judge issuing an order that covers all 93 judicial districts in the country. It is one thing for a district court to offer relief to the parties before it. That is what a judge can and what a judge should do. A judge has authority to resolve a case or controversy, and sometimes that will include holding that a statute or Executive action is unlawful. It is another thing, however, altogether for a single judge to order the Government to act with respect to people who are not even before the court. That reaches far beyond the legitimate authority of the court, and becomes policymaking. This is something none of us--Democratic or Republican--should want judges to do. Right now, there are more than 600 active district judges, more than 1,000 if you count senior judges. Any one of them can effectively veto national policy. In one sense, district judges wield more power than any Supreme Court Justice, who must vote with their colleagues before stopping or compelling national Government action. This creates, then, a strong incentive for forum shopping. According to a 2024 Harvard Law Review study, nearly all universal injunctions against the first Trump administration and the Biden administration were issued by judges appointed by the opposite political party. This places tremendous strain on the judicial system. Universal injunctions are also unconstitutional. Article III of the Constitution tasks the judicial branch with deciding, as you have heard me say, ``cases or controversies.'' The Supreme Court has long required judges to engage in detailed analysis to ensure that they're--they have authority over a case. They must determine that a party before them has been injured, that the injury is traceable to a defendant's conduct, and that the court can do something to remedy it. Now, judges routinely ignore these constitutional limits and issue orders directing Government action for the entire country. In February, a district judge issued an order requiring $2 billion in USAID funding to be paid out within 36 hours, the vast majority of people who never even sued. The Supreme Court had to instruct the district court to narrow its ruling, and narrow it significantly. On Monday, a district court in California issued an order in a case involving seven Venezuelan plaintiffs and an association that advocates for them. Instead of just deciding the case before him, the judge halted the policy for approximately 350,000 Venezuelans under the Temporary Protected Status program. The district judge had no authority over people who were not before the court, but single-handedly vetoed a policy that Americans specifically elected President Trump to enact. Some people may ask, if universal injunctions are eliminated how can plaintiffs get relief--especially in cases where it is hard to represent every person affected by a law or order? The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provide a solution-- the class action. This is a powerful legal tool to offer comprehensive relief, and it also contains protections to preserve the rights of parties that are represented in this unusual way. Universal injunctions shortcut all of that. Eliminating universal injunctions still preserves the important role of the judiciary in a system of checks and balances. Class actions remain intact. And judges retain their awesome power to protect litigants before them from unlawful action. But when a single judge can override the political branches to set national policy, the checks and balances of our country and Constitution are thrown off. We should in turn--we should instead return to the framework established under the Constitution. District courts decide the case before them, and the appellate courts set precedent for all the courts below them. That is the appropriate check on other co-equal branches of Government. Universal injunctions turn the whole thing on its head. Most of us in this room have, at various times, supported or opposed universal injunctions. My fellow Republicans and I sometimes like them--when there is a Democratic President. And my Democratic colleagues probably like them right now, even though they criticized them a few months ago under President Biden. Too often, we accept politics over principle. But the truth is that we all know this is not how Government and the judiciary should operate. It is past the time to address this issue. The Supreme Court can and should fix this problem. Unfortunately, they have sat on their hands. If they will not act, Congress must act. I proposed legislation to fix this problem. I think it is a good solution because, like all good compromises, it probably leaves everyone a little unhappy. We all have to agree to give up the universal injunctions as a weapon against policies we disagree with. The damage it causes to the judicial system and our democracy is really too great. I hope today we can have a productive discussion about the--how to solve this problem that has plagued and frustrated Democratic and Republican Presidents alike. I am going to introduce now our two Majority witnesses today, and Senator Durbin will introduce the Democrat. Professor Samuel Bray is the John N. Matthew Professor of Law at Notre Dame. He is a leading expert on the law of remedies and the law of equity, and he has been cited by many Supreme Court Justices, including Justices Thomas, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Jackson. He has also been cited by both the Trump and Biden administrations. Professor Bray has written extensively on the topics of universal injunctions, including his Harvard Law article that goes by the title, ``Multiple Chancellors: Reforming the National Injunction.'' Professor Bray is an elected member of the American Law Institute and is an adviser on the ``Restatement of Torts: Remedies.'' Jesse Panuccio is a partner at Boies Schiller Flexner and co-leader of the firm's appellate practice group. He previously served as the Acting Associate Attorney General at the Department of Justice. Before that, he served as then-Governor Rick Scott's General Counsel. He is also a member of the Administrative Conference of the United States. I am very interested in hearing both of your remarks today, and thank you very much for coming, and now Senator Durbin. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS Senator Durbin. Thanks, Chairman Grassley. I want to thank you particularly for comments you recently made where you said, quote, ``You can't impeach a judge just because you disagree with their opinion,'' end of quote. It should not have to be said, but I hope every Member of this Committee will make that equally clear today. Indeed, in our Nation's 250-year history, a judge has never--never been impeached because a President disagreed with that judge's ruling. But we do say--need to say so loudly and clearly, as you did, Mr. Chairman, as President Trump and Co-President Elon Musk have demanded the impeachment of Federal judges who have ruled against the administration, House Republicans have rushed to kiss the ring, so far filing articles of impeachment against six Federal judges--and counting. The dangerous, irresponsible conduct of the President and his allies has resulted in a disturbing--truly disturbing increase in threats against our Federal judges and represent an existential threat to judicial independence. During my time on this Committee I have met with several judges whose lives have been threatened simply because of their service on the bench. Some of these threats have turned into acts of violence that have taken the lives of judges' family members, including spouses, parents, and children. It affected my State, in the Northern District. I have said it many times before in this Committee, and I want to say it again here. Violence or threats of violence, from the right or the left, on the political spectrum are never--never acceptable. When I was Chair of this Committee I repeatedly condemned threats against Republican-appointed Justices and judges, and we passed bipartisan legislation to improve security for the bench. We must speak with one bipartisan voice on this issue. Last week, my staff spoke with several judges about judicial security. Every single judge said exactly the same thing: The threats have become more frequent and more disturbing. And while these judges were careful not to comment on political issues, they noted that recent rhetoric against judges has contributed to increased threats to judicial security. One judge likened it to adding fuel to a bonfire, and she noted her fear that, in time, it would become a wildfire out of control. We must avoid that outcome, but it will require the President and his fellow Republicans, including Members of this Committee, to work together with the Democrats to lower the temperature and end the attacks on judges and judiciary. This hearing is about nationwide injunctions. It is impossible to separate the hearing from President Trump's record in office. The reality is that we would not be holding this hearing if the President took a different approach to the rule of law. We have heard repeated complaints from Republicans about the number of injunctions issued against this President compared to other Presidents. Why so many? They ignore the fact that this President has issued more than 100 Executive orders, the most by any President at this point in his term in at least four decades. Many are clearly illegal. Take the President's Executive order to end birthright citizenship. Three Federal judges, in three different States, have blocked this order, including two judges appointed by Republican Presidents, and three separate appeals courts have refused to lift these injunctions. Judge John Coughenour, who was appointed by President Ronald Reagan, was the first judge to block the order, which he called, quote, ``blatantly unconstitutional.'' The reality is that the number of injunctions issued against the first and second Trump administrations are evidence of a President who is clearly violating the law. That being said, I am happy to discuss the legal and practical implications of nationwide injunctions. But as I have said many times before, we cannot have one set of rules for Republicans and another set of rules for Democrats. Any legislation on this topic must be based on the merits, not political expediency. Professor Bray, in your testimony before the Committee, recall a decision by a Texas court about 10 years ago on DACA, that is near and dear to my heart. That is based on the DREAM Act which I introduced a long time ago, and my pleadings with President Obama to create that program meant a lot to me personally. I recall when that issue came before the court in Texas and a judge issued a universal injunction to enforce it. I would add, as the Chairman has noted, there was cheering from the Republican Senators from Texas for that decision. Some of them today see the issue differently, in the context of a President of their own party. I cannot support legislation that does not take a reality into consideration. Only if we have an effective date that makes sense would I considering making any changes myself. In 1776, in a pamphlet appropriately titled ``Common Sense,'' Thomas Paine famously wrote, quote, ``In America, the law is King. For as in absolute governments the King is the law, so in free countries the law ought to be King; and there ought to be no other.'' Today we will discuss the use of nationwide injunctions, but there can be no debate that in America the law is king, as it has been since our founding. The President is not a king, not even this President, as much as he might wish otherwise. He is bound by the decisions of our courts, just like every other American. Now, the President and his political allies are welcome to disagree with judicial decisions that block his illegal actions, but we cannot allow anyone to threaten or intimidate our judges, and we cannot stand idly by amid a threat to our Constitution and separation of powers. The Chairman has asked me to introduce my witness, and I will be glad to do that. Professor Stephen Vladeck is the Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts at Georgetown University Law Center--I knew Mrs. Williams. He is a nationally recognized expert on the Federal courts, the Supreme Court, national security law, and military justice. Professor Vladeck is also highly regarded as an appellate advocate, having argued several cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, and over a dozen before various lower Federal, civilian, and military courts. He is a graduate of Yale Law School and Amherst College. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley. Yes, thank you. Would you please rise for the oath? Do you swear that the testimony you are about give before this Committee will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God? Professor Bray. I do. Professor Vladeck. I do. Mr. Panuccio. I do. Chairman Grassley. All of you have answered affirmatively. Please sit down, and we will start with you, Professor Bray, and then Mr. Vladeck, and we will go across. STATEMENT OF SAMUEL L. BRAY, JOHN N. MATTHEWS PROFESSOR OF LAW, NOTRE DAME LAW SCHOOL, NOTRE DAME, INDIANA Professor Bray. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member, and Members of the Committee, I am honored to speak with you today. What is wrong with the universal injunction has a policy dimension and a constitutional dimension. The ordinary way the Federal courts work is that someone challenges a law in one circuit, and whether the challenger wins or loses, the decision of the circuit court will be a precedent for that circuit. Justice Kagan called this ``the normal process.'' It allows multiple courts to consider a question before the Supreme Court is eventually asked to resolve a disagreement. It takes some time, but not thousands of suits. This is how questions are supposed to be settled in the Federal courts--deliberately, collectively, and with appellate precedent. But universal injunctions, with lighting appeals straight to the Supreme Court, have accelerated judicial decision- making, leading to rushed and suboptimal decisions. The universal injunction reduces the chance that multiple circuit courts will consider a legal question. It is an end run around class actions. It is an end run around issue preclusion. It is inconsistent with basic principles about the precedential authority of a district court. And it has an asymmetric effect. One hundred people challenge a Federal policy, and if the Federal Government wins 99 of the cases, it will not matter as long as one plaintiff wins and gets a universal injunction. The Government has to run the table. These policy consequences are partly about the universal injunction and partly about how it interacts with heightened judicial polarization and extreme forum shopping. That is a point on which I agree with my friend, Professor Vladeck. He is right to criticize extreme forum shopping. He is right that challenges to the Biden administration, in single-judge divisions, were an egregious problem. Where I think he is wrong is to suggest that it would somehow be rash for Congress, at long last, to address the severe policy problems caused by universal injunctions. If I may, this is the fourth time that I have testified about these problems over the last 7 years. There is also a constitutional dimension. A final judgment binds the parties, and a court order must be followed. No one is above the law. But judgments and orders have this kind of authority in our legal system because of the principle that courts act as courts, deciding a case for the parties and giving remedies to the parties. Once a Federal court decides a case and gives a remedy to the parties and the people they represent, there is nothing left for it to do as a court. There is no constitutional authority for the judge to go on and decide the cases of other people or to give remedies to other people not before the court. The universal injunction is emphatically not a partisan problem. Universal injunctions and vacatur are stopping almost every major initiative of the second Trump administration, just like all the Democratic and Republican administrations in the last 10 years. They are a bipartisan scourge. At any particular moment, of course, there is a partisan valence to solving the problem of the universal injunction. But that partisan valence will not last. There are no permanent Majorities. In the long term, the real loser from the universal injunction is our democracy. The Republican or Democratic bias oscillates over time. What does not change is the universal injunction's built-in bias against any effective Government action. A legislative solution should be laser-focused on non- parties. It should apply to temporary restraining orders and to vacatur under the Administrative Procedure Act. It should not just put guardrails on universal injunctions. Only one proposed bill fits these principles, and that is the Chairman's bill. This bill would take the universal injunction and bury it six feet under--no evasions, no circumventions, no substitutes, no outs for Republicans, no outs for Democrats. The Federal courts are, and should be, a bulwark against unconstitutional or illegal actions taken by other Government actors. They should hold the President accountable, regardless of whether the President is a Republican or a Democrat. But the Federal courts should perform that essential function as courts do, by deciding particular cases, brought by particular parties, with remedies that control the relationship between these parties. The last 10 years have seen a fundamental transformation of the relationship between the judicial branch and the executive and legislative branches. It is past time to reset that relationship. [The prepared testimony of Professor Bray appears as a submission for the record.] Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Professor Bray. Professor Vladeck. STATEMENT OF STEPHEN I. VLADECK, AGNES WILLIAMS SESQUICENTENNIAL PROFESSOR OF FEDERAL COURTS, GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY LAW CENTER, WASHINGTON, DC Professor Vladeck. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for the invitation to testify before the Committee. In my testimony I would like to make three points about how we got here, and then offer some thoughts on the way forward. First, as Ranking Member Durbin suggested, any discussion about nationwide injunctions has to be put into the broader context of the unprecedented moment in which we find ourselves. Substantively, we have a President running roughshod over existing legal constraints to a degree we have simply never seen before. And procedurally, we have a Justice Department engaged in highly partisan and ethically dubious behavior in lower courts that we have never seen from lawyers working for the Federal Government. Even this Committee seems to be of the view that the central problem in these cases is the relief Federal judges are imposing, not the lawlessness they are imposing it against. At the risk of bringing data to a mud fight, the reality is not that a small handful of hand-picked judges, appointed by Democratic Presidents, are using nationwide injunctions to thwart the executive branch. As of last Friday, the 46 cases in which district judges have blocked Trump policies have involved rulings by 39 different judges, appointed by 5 different Presidents of both parties, sitting in 11 different district courts across seven circuits. That includes nine cases before district judges appointed by Republican Presidents, too. Many of those rulings have included nationwide relief, but not all of them. Against that backdrop, it seems to me that this Committee should be especially careful not to react to under-informed calls from the President and his supporters and rather to be focused on preserving the relationship between judicial independence and judicial accountability, rather than taking steps that might undermine it. Second, it is worth underscoring that Federal courts have, in fact, long and routinely issued relief that benefits non- parties and/or has nationwide effect. My friend, Professor Bray, already referred to vertical stare decisis, alongside Justices Kavanaugh and Barrett. Even Justice Gorsuch, the most visible critic of nationwide injunctions on the Supreme Court has voted in favor of them at least 11 times since 2020. More than that, any time a court invalidates a State or Federal law on its face, rather than as applied to the specific plaintiffs, it is necessarily providing a relief to non- parties, since the law can no longer be enforced against anyone. That is not only well-settled, there is no serious argument that it is beyond the Federal court's powers. And even nationwide injunctions have virtues that other forms of relief do not. Consider the birthright citizenship cases. Do we really think that parents should have to challenge that policy one child at a time? Would it make any sense at all, even on a broader scale, for the scope of birthright citizenship to differ in Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas, simply because those three States fall into three different circuits? Of course, a nationwide class action could solve that problem, but it does not strike me as a coincidence that the rise in nationwide injunctions came shortly on the heels of the Supreme Court's evisceration of nationwide class certification. Chairman Grassley's bill alludes to class actions as a preferable vehicle. I could certainly endorse that idea. But tellingly, it does nothing to make them more broadly available, even though Congress unquestionably could do so. Third, it seems to me deeply myopic to talk about the rise of nationwide injunctions without talking about shifts in behavior that have dramatically increased the impact of such rulings, several of which were already referred to by Professor Bray. Don't take my word for it, though. In the last three Supreme Court terms we have seen five rulings from the Justices reversing nationwide injunctions issued by hand-picked judges in Texas and Louisiana, and affirmed by the fifth circuit, because the plaintiffs in all five cases lacked Article III standing. There is no question that nationwide injunctions have been abused, but the abuses in those cases were not about the scope of the relief the courts were issuing. It is only exacerbated by it. And critically, those abuses would not go away even if nationwide injunctions were narrowed or eliminated. Meanwhile, the cost of eliminating nationwide injunctions would be less of an ability to restrain executive branch lawlessness at a moment in American history in which that power has proven singularly vital. So what is to be done? First, if the Members' real concern is that the President should have the authorities that courts are denying to him, it seems to me that they could consider legislation to provide those authorities, rather than legislation that would prevent courts from fully and effectively enforcing existing legal constraints. Second, insofar as this Committee wants to focus on procedural reforms, it should focus on reducing the ability of individual parties to manipulate the judicial system, not on limiting the ability of courts to hold the executive branch accountable, especially in an age in which Congress has proven less able to do so itself. Finally, if the Committee's true goal is to improve the functioning of the judicial system writ large and not just to maximize short-term partisan political advantage now that a Republican is in the White House, the Committee could follow the model of other recent court reform legislation and have any reforms go into effect on or after January 20, 2029. Otherwise, the message this Committee would be sending is that its goal is to insulate an unprecedented degree of lawless behavior by the executive branch from meaningful judicial review, a message I cannot imagine this Committee wants to send, and one that the separation of powers, to say nothing of the rule of law itself, simply cannot afford. Thank you again for the invitation to testify. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared testimony of Professor Vladeck appears as a submission for the record.] Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Professor Vladeck. Mr. Panuccio. STATEMENT OF JESSE PANUCCIO, PARTNER, BOIS SCHILLER FLEXNER, WASHINGTON, DC Mr. Panuccio. Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, and Members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I note at the outset that the views expressed in my testimony are entirely my own and not those of my law firm, or any of its clients, or any entity with which I am affiliated. Today the Committee considers a recurrent problem in our Federal judiciary. The propriety of non-party relief is a question at the heart of our constitutional Republic. It is a question that asks whether our Federal courts exist to decide cases or to advance causes. It is a question about a practice that renders every judge a king and every court supreme. The statistics show the issue is not confined to one President, one party, or a particular substantive policy. Accordingly, the Department of Justice, across administrations, has consistently argued against granting relief beyond the parties to a case. Just a few months ago, President Biden's Solicitor General explained, that, quote, ``universal remedies are inconsistent with long-standing limits on equitable relief and the power of Article III courts, and impose a severe toll on the Federal court system,'' end quote. And jurists on both sides of the ideological divide have recognized the problem. As Justice Kagan stated in a 2022 speech, quote, ``It just can't be right that one district judge can stop a nationwide policy in its tracks and leave it stopped for the years that it takes to go through the normal process,'' end quote. Before I highlight the many problems with non-party relief let me offer one concrete example. In 2017, the Department of Justice imposed new conditions on law enforcement grants, requiring participating local jurisdictions to cooperate with Federal law enforcement to remove illegal aliens who had committed serious crimes. The city of Chicago sued, alleging the grant conditions were unlawful. The district court issued a preliminary injunction, but rather than stopping at providing this complete relief to the party before it, the court enjoined the grant conditions nationwide. Cases were pending in other districts, and Chicago could not make any claim that its own interests required nationwide relief. Yet, the district judge, with one line of dubious reasoning, exerted power over every other grantee in the country, including those who did not want it and supported the conditions, and exerted power and stopped--precluded any other judge from effectuating a contrary conclusion. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York would later find these conditions lawful, highlighting how incredible it was for a lone district judge in Chicago to dictate the result in New York, and everywhere else. With that example in mind, let's just highlight a few of the problems with non-party relief. The first problem with non- party injunctions is, as Justice Thomas has explained, they are legally and historically dubious. The Constitution grants to Federal courts the power to hear cases and controversies, which the Supreme Court has long interpreted as the power to render a judgment or decree upon the rights of litigant parties, not non-parties. Some argue that nationwide non-party relief is a necessary check on the ever-growing power of the executive branch. But the answer is not to fix one constitutional distortion by creating another. Rather, if the concern is with the power of the administrative state then the answer is for Congress to reassert its atrophied policymaking muscle, not to transform the judiciary into a third political branch. The second problem with non-party injunctions is they undermine the norms, rules, and structures that undergird our multi-court, multi-jurisdiction, multi-tiered legal system. One such legal norm is the concept of percolation. There are several legal provisions and practices that reflect this preference for percolation, but I will highlight just one, and it is the U.S. Constitution. It establishes one, and only one, Supreme Court, and such inferior courts as Congress may establish. In this hierarchical system, one district court does not bind another and one circuit court does not bind another. It is only Supreme Court judgments that are binding on all Federal courts. Yet nationwide non-party relief effectively has any of 1,000 district judges wielding the same supremacy as the Supreme Court, by stripping from other courts the efficacy of their judgments. The nationwide non-party injunction thus simultaneously makes every court supreme and every court a potential nullity. The third problem with non-party injunctions is they are undermining public confidence in Federal courts. History has shown the American people have a stubborn tendency to demand a say in the rules that govern their lives. Humility, then, is a necessary judicial virtue for life-tenured judges who have a share of the ruling power for life, and cannot face elections by the people like the other branches. But in recent years, the third branch has lost all sense of itself. It will either rediscover judicial humility or lose the support of the people and force a national constitutional crisis. Because the Supreme Court appears unwilling or unable to rein in its own branch, it is time for Congress to act. Three legislative fixes seem advisable. First, Congress should amend the necessary statutes to make clear that Federal courts do not have the power to grant relief to non-parties. Second, it appears the latest trend in relief is for district courts to enter temporary restraining orders. Those should be made appeared--made immediately appealable. And third, and finally, even if Congress enacts the above fixes, it is likely the judges who believe they have nationwide power will shift from granting non-party injunctions to certifying classes. Congress should consider imposing mandatory jurisdiction on the Supreme Court for any injunction, or similar order, that the Attorney General certifies as a national emergency. Thank you. I look forward to taking questions. [The prepared testimony of Mr. Panuccio appears as a submission for the record.] Chairman Grassley. Thank you very much. We will have 5- minute rounds for questions and I am going to start with Professor Bray. One criticism has been leveled against the legislative solution that I have proposed. It has been that it undermines the judicial branch's checks and balances on the executive branch. Do you think this is a fair criticism? And how would you respond? Professor Bray. Thank you, Chairman Grassley. I don't think it is a fair criticism. I understand where it is coming from because the place of the courts as a check and balance on the executive branch and the legislative branch is very important in our constitutional system. But the way courts do that is by deciding according to the law in particular cases, and then that ripples out to other cases through precedent. That is the way they serve as a check, without fear of favor, following the law in the case. But they serve as a check as courts do, by deciding cases, by giving remedies to the parties in the case. Chairman Grassley. Mr. Panuccio, you have direct experience in the Justice Department dealing with non-party relief ordered by district judges. From your perspective, how significant is the problem of universal injunctions to the relationship between the executive and judicial branch? Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Chairman. It is a great question. I think it is a very significant problem, and I think it is-- years of this practice are eroding the relationship between the Department of Justice and the executive branch and the courts, and I think that is happening across administrations. What effectively happens when a nationwide injunction is entered is that every single case, every single policy of the executive branch becomes an emergency that needs to move up the appellate ladder very quickly. And Supreme Court Justices, appointed by Presidents of both parties, have noted that the increase in the emergency docket is straining the court, it is straining its resources, and it is also reducing the quality of decision-making. So you are seeing increased friction. And even in these district courts that issue nationwide injunctions, I think you are seeing very unfortunate comments made by some of the judges. There is a real tension between the jurists and the lawyers, and it is undermining the typical relationship between the Department and the courts. Chairman Grassley. Professor Bray, you touched on this a little bit in your opening comments. As administrations come and go, the problem of universal injunctions often appear partisan. You have been calling attention to this problem since the Obama administration, that it maintained a consistent position across four administrations now. From your perspective, is the problem of universal injunctions a partisan one? And then, what is the solution? Professor Bray. Thank you, Chairman Grassley. I do not believe it is a partisan problem, because it is a problem that has been hamstringing every administration since 2015--the end of the Obama administration, the first Trump administration, the Biden administration, and now the second Trump administration. So if you look at it over time, it is not a partisan problem. At any particular moment, undeniably, it is a partisan problem and has a partisan valence. But legislation should not just be about the moment. Legislation should be about the long view. And I think the only fair way to do this is to knock out the weapon of the universal injunction for everyone. Take it away from Democrats. Take it away from Republicans. Because what it really strikes at is our ability to have democratic self-government and effective government action by the Federal Government. Chairman Grassley. Mr. Panuccio, in your written testimony you said that it is important to pass legislation to make temporary restraining orders against the Government appealable. The legislation I propose does that. Can you expand a bit more on your views here? What are temporary restraining orders? And why is it important that they are appealable? Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Chairman. It is an important question because the latest trend in non-party relief appears to be courts entering what is called a temporary restraining order instead of a preliminary injunction. Now in my experience as a litigator in my years as a lawyer, a TRO was supposed to be a very short-term order from the court when it is impossible for the court to hold a hearing with both parties, and it might enter, for example, a 24-hour TRO until it can get a hearing on a preliminary injunction, an actual hearing with adversaries arguing the facts and the law to the court. But what we are now seeing is the courts are entering these TROs, which can, under the rules, last for up to 2 weeks and then be extended for another 2 weeks, and the issue is that the courts have interpreted TROs to not be appealable. Now, that may be a dubious interpretation, but that is the law of the land right now. And so, it is effectively allowing district judges to insulate themselves from review. So, it's bad enough that we have district judges saying, ``I am a ruler for the entire nation.'' But now they are saying they are not elected, so the people cannot have a say. They are also saying that, ``the appellate judges who are supposed to oversee my decisions, I don't want them hearing it either. So let me enter a TRO instead of a preliminary injunction or some other immediately appealable order.'' So I do think it is virtue of your bill, Chairman, that TROs, or any other similar order, would be immediately appealable. Chairman Grassley. Senator Durbin, I have asked Senator Moody to take over for me while I go to another meeting. Senator Durbin. She is very strict. Yes. [Laughter.] Chairman Grassley. You proceed. Thank you, Senator Moody. Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So Professor Bray, I am going to ask you to stick with me for a second here and talk about possibilities. Along comes President Trump and decides that the following sentence does not make sense, Fourteenth Amendment, Section 1, ``All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States, and of the State wherein they reside.'' So the President decides one of his 103 Executive orders will eliminate that language, the language of the Constitution, and questioned whether or not birthright citizenship is legal in America. Cases were filed. One judge, a Ronald Reagan appointee, said that efforts by the administration are ``blatantly unconstitutional.'' If you accept the normal process, which you described to us, how should that case be handled if we have done away with the universal application of decisions? Professor Bray. Thank you, Ranking Member Durbin. I think that is an excellent example of how the courts are supposed to work. The courts are going to decide the cases. In every single one the courts will say there is birthright citizenship under the Constitution. There will not actually be a disagreement between the circuit courts, and there will not even need to be a decision from the Supreme Court. So what you will see is distributed decision-making across the Federal judiciary that will resolve the question. Senator Durbin. But assume the alternative, that there is a Federal judge in some State--I will pick one, Texas or Louisiana, who says, ``I think the President is right. I believe birthright citizenship is unconstitutional.'' So you have a case in controversy and it affects only the cases filed in that district? Professor Bray. Well, it would not affect just the cases filed in the district because a district court judge actually has no precedential authority, even within a district. There is no ability for a district to---- Senator Durbin. Well, let me amend my comment. Circuit. Professor Bray. Yes. If the--if a district judge took that position, and then it was affirmed by the court of appeals, then what you would have is a circuit split between different circuits, and the Supreme Court would resolve that circuit split. And then what the Supreme Court would have is a range of different judges, from different geographical places, with different ideologies, different generations, all speaking to the same question, and that puts the Supreme Court in a position to do its best work. I do not think that particular legal question needs to be in doubt. But just because the--but just because one branch goes beyond its constitutional bounds does not mean the judiciary should go beyond its. Senator Durbin. So I guess my question is, in light of individuals personally affected by this, pregnant women, as an example, we just have to let the process play out? Is that what you suggest? Professor Bray. There are ways to get a faster decision. As Professor Vladeck noted, you could have a national class action. But I think the basic commitment--I recognize there can be a human cost there, but the basic commitment of our legal system is you do not get an immediate right decision, right away. It takes time. It is like the old carpentry adage, measure twice, cut once. And that is the kind of legal system we have. Senator Durbin. Professor Vladeck? Professor Vladeck. I think it is worth underscoring the human consequences that my friend just kind of brushed right past, because if it takes 3 years for that circuit split to get to the Supreme Court, you are going to have 3 years where, in large parts of the country, children born to undocumented parents will not be citizens. Some of those children could be subject to removal by the United States on the ground that they are not citizens. It is not possible for the Federal courts to order those folks to be brought back. And so that relief that Professor Bray holds out as possible 3 years later is of no help to the children who were citizens under the Constitution but who were removed in the interim. So again, I mean, the broader policy question here is, what should the rule be in this interim window? Professor Bray and I agree that it is all about what is the status quo while the case gets to the Supreme Court. Should the status quo be the policy is either in effect or not in effect, on a nationwide basis? Or, should the status quo depend upon which jurisdiction you live in and what your particular status is? And that is why it seems to me if we want to talk about real reform, we should be talking about reforms to bolster the other vehicles, the nationwide class action, and not just taking off this stopgap that has emerged in its place. Senator Durbin. Thank you. Senator Moody [presiding]. Thank you, Ranking Member. Senator Blackburn. Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you all for being here. I have got to tell you, being in Tennessee over the weekend and then doing a telephone Town Hall with several thousand Tennesseans last night, the overreach of the judiciary is something that continued to come up. The way we have seen these activist judges troubles people, and they are wanting to see something done. So they were pleased that we were having this hearing, and they are concerned that you are seeing district judges come in and exercise this sweeping injunctive relief that does not apply to the case before them, does not apply to the district in which they are seated. So Professor Bray, I want to talk with you for just a moment. One of the things that Senator Grassley noted and that many of us have discussed is that there is no constitutional and no statutory authority for Federal district judges to issue these injunctions. And so talk for a minute about the effect of that lack of authority. Professor Bray. I am happy to, Senator. So I think that is correct. There is no statutory basis for granting universal injunctions and there is no constitutional basis for doing so either. So courts, to be courts, have to exercise the judicial power, and the judicial power is not defined by the Constitution, but the Constitution instead uses what is a known commodity, that is the reference to the judicial power. It is courts deciding cases for the parties. So universal injunction is fundamentally different from that. A class action is still a case. It is a large case, but it is still a case, and if the class wins, the class wins. If the class loses, the class loses. But it is a decision for a case. And what makes the universal injunction different is you have a very small case and a remedy that is for everyone. So my friend, Professor Vladeck, noted this question about like what is going to be the interim rule? Is the interim rule going to be you have a policy or you do not have a policy? And when we have courts disagreeing about what the interim rule should be, we should not default to, as long as there is one court that does not like it, it is stopped. That is what makes it a sclerotic effect on Government action. The Government cannot act if all it takes is one court not wanting the rule or the policy to go into effect for the entire country. Senator Blackburn. Let me ask you also about injunction bonds, because under Rule 65, then a party who is seeking an injunction is required. The bond is mandatory. But we have not seen that used in these nationwide injunctions against President Trump. So speak a little bit about the utilization of injunction bonds and when that is appropriate. Professor Bray. I am happy to, Senator. I have an above- median interest in injunction bonds, and I am happy to talk about them. There was an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal a couple of days ago that suggested it was a problem for injunctions that were being given against the Trump administration, that no injunction bonds were required. Now I do think the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure require injunction bonds. I think it would be a good practice for Federal courts to be requiring injunction bonds, follow the rule, require injunction bonds whenever you give an injunction against the Federal Government. And I think it is a way of taking into account the regulatory interests of the Federal Government and the costs injunctions impose. That being said, there is nothing invalid about an injunction just because it is not accompanied by an injunction bond. It still has to be followed. That does not mean the court lacks jurisdiction. It is still an order of a court and it must be followed for that reason. Senator Blackburn. Thank you. Professor Vladeck, I wanted to talk to you about something you said in your testimony, and I thought it was really very interesting. You said that, and I am quoting, ``We have a Justice Department engaged in highly partisan and ethically dubious behavior,'' end quote. And I could not disagree with you more in that statement, and I really find it just rich with irony, after we have sat here for 4 years and watched President Biden's DOJ weaponized against the American people. We had parents that went to school boards that were called domestic terrorists. And we have seen two tiers of justice. So you can submit for me in writing, since my time has expired, your explanation of why the Biden DOJ was not highly partisan, and you have assumed that the Trump DOJ is. Professor Vladeck. Can I briefly respond? Senator Moody. You can submit that in writing. Thank you, Senator Blackburn. And we will turn it over to Senator Padilla. Senator Padilla. Thank you, Madam Chair. Professor Vladeck, good to see you. I just wanted to take a moment to follow up on something that you discussed in your opening testimony. There are Members of the Committee from the other side of the aisle that are trying to claim that there are a few radical judicial activists standing in the way of President Trump's agenda. But just as in his first term, it seems that the President's disregard for the law is actually the biggest thing standing in the way of his agenda. So I want to walk through some of the statistics again with you. How many cases have you identified where plaintiffs are seeking an injunction or a temporary restraining order against the current administration where the judge has had to issue a decision? And in how many was the relief granted? Professor Vladeck. Sure. Senator, as of last Friday--and the data obviously has changed since last Friday, the total number of cases we found was 67, and there were 46 of those 67 in which the judge had issued either a temporary restraining order or a preliminary injunction, or both. Senator Padilla. Okay. That is a lot. Sounds like a pretty good success rate in terms of the challenges. How many judges have heard these cases? And if you are able to tell or even have a ballpark, these judges were appointed by a President of which party? Professor Vladeck. Sure. So it is 39 different judges appointed by 5 Presidents of both parties, including 2 Republican Presidents, President Reagan and President Bush. And the cases are not symmetrically distributed, but the success rate is pretty close. So, of those 46 rulings against the Trump administration's policies, 9 have come from Republican- appointed judges, and the success rate in those cases has been about 45, 50 percent, so just a little bit lower than what we are seeing in the cases with Democratic-appointed judges. Senator Padilla. Okay. That is encouraging to demonstrate that it is not a partisan lens through which these judges are acting now. When it comes to geography, can you speak to where these judges sit? Are they concentrated in one region or one appellate court jurisdiction, one district? Or, are they spread around the country? Professor Vladeck. I mean, it has been spread much further around the country than what we saw, for example, during the Biden administration. So we have seen 11 different district courts for the--in the 46 cases that have blocked Trump policies, 11 different district courts in 7 different circuits, which is a pretty big shift from as recently as a couple of years ago when most of the nationwide injunctions against Biden policies were coming from district courts in Texas, Louisiana, and Missouri. Senator Padilla. Thank you. I appreciate your verification of some of the data that I have in front of me. To me it confirms not just the numbers but that it is not the judges getting in the way of the Trump agenda. It is certainly not a few radical judicial activists either. Now, a question on a different topic for you. You are an expert on sensible ways to reform the judiciary to make it better work for the American people in a way that it was intended by the Framers of our Constitution. In your view, what are the most pressing reform needs when it comes to the Federal courts? Professor Vladeck. Yes. I think the most pressing needs, I think, are to avoid the more general ability of parties to manipulate the Federal courts in ways that we have seen. You know, to some degree, administrations of both parties, but for various structural reasons, I think even more so during the last two Democratic administrations. Just to take one example, my friend, Professor Bray, I think joins me in criticizing so-called single-judge divisions and judge shopping. You know, that was a phenomenon we saw over and over again during the Biden administration. The only really sort of obvious target for that kind of behavior during the Trump administration, the district court in Massachusetts, changed its rules, actually, to prevent that kind of behavior. And it seems like that can be a model, Senator, for a nationwide rule that this body could impose, to avoid the appearance that litigants are steering cases to a particular judge because of that judge's ideological commitments. Senator Padilla. That is critical for the functioning of the judiciary and people's confidence in the process. Last question in my time remaining is sadly, very timely, because the attacks on the judiciary is not limited to attacks on judges by the Trump administration. Now we are seeing attacks on the legal community and specific firms or lawyers that represent clients and causes at odds with the President's ambition. Can you speak to the chilling effect that these targeted Executive orders are having on the legal community and their ability and willingness to take on clients or employees that might dare to disagree with President Trump? Professor Vladeck. Yes. I mean, we are seeing a chilling effect, Senator, in some of the law firms that are, you know, making these agreements with the President to not represent particular clients, to devote hundreds of millions of dollars to pro bono litigation in support of the President's agenda. You know, that kind of distortion is a problem not because of Democrats versus Republicans. That kind of distortion is a problem because as the Supreme Court itself explained in 2001, meaningful access to lawyers is actually central to the ability of the courts to play their essential role in our constitutional system. Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Vladeck. I appreciate your testimony. Thank you, Senator Padilla. Senator Welch. Senator Welch. Thank you. Just following up on that, I mean, is there agreement among the three of you that dealing with forum shopping would be beneficial for the judiciary and for the strength of the rule of law? Do all of you agree on that? Professor Vladeck. Yes, but it would only solve part of the problem. Senator Welch. I understand that, but it would be worthwhile, Professor Vladeck, you said that. How about you? Mr. Panuccio. I think plaintiffs, if they have the ability to file a lawsuit in a district, should be able to do that. I think that the incentive for forum shopping is that you think you can get a judge who can be a ruler for the whole Nation. So fix the problem of judges overreaching their power---- Senator Welch. Right. Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. And you will---- Senator Welch. So you are okay with forum shopping, just so I understand. Mr. Panuccio. Well, it depends on what you mean by that, Senator. If you mean---- Senator Welch. I mean you pick where you file--what lawyer wouldn't do that, where you think you can win? Mr. Panuccio. Well, there are all kinds of reasons---- Senator Welch. All right. Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. Why lawyers choose to file in different districts. It can be---- Senator Welch. Okay. I got you. I think I got your answer. Two to reform that, and one thinks it is fine. The next thing, just this practical question of a class action lawsuit versus an individual suing. I mean, I will ask you, Professor Bray, because you are talking about class actions, and I support class actions. There has been a lot of debate within the Committee about whether they are useful or not, and a lot of pushback on the use of class actions. But there is an enormously increased burden on the plaintiffs in order to get class certification. Is there not? Professor Bray. Senator, with respect, this bill, the Chairman's bill, would leave class action---- Senator Welch. I am not asking about the Chairman's bill. I'm just talking--I'm a lawyer. Somebody comes in, birthright citizen is the claim. I'm just--I'm a small-town lawyer. That is what I was, White River Junction. I say, ``You know what? You are right. Let's take the case. I will do it.'' But if I have to go get a class certified, just tell me the steps I have to go through for getting that class certification as opposed to just taking my client, who came into my White River Junction office, and we go to the Federal district court in Burlington. Professor Bray. So class certification does require more steps, but it is entirely appropriate given that what you are seeking is remedy to representation---- Senator Welch. No, no. I am talking--I understand that it is appropriate. I am just talking about what is the practical burden in terms of cost, in terms of what kind of legal power you have to have as opposed to a single lawyer who has a single client, who comes in to see me and wants relief? What is it going to cost for me to do a certification for class as opposed to me just filing and paying the filing fee at the Federal district court? Professor Bray. So I do agree, Senator, that there are more requirements, and that means more attorney hours and more cost. Senator Welch. Right. Professor Bray. So I agree with that. But it is also matches the scope of the relief sought. Senator Welch. Right. Professor Bray. And so it really is---- Senator Welch. No, I get that. But there is an acknowledgement here that it is a much bigger deal. You know, one of the wonderful things about our justice system is an individual who is harmed can come into a lawyer, and that lawyer may take it pro bono. But if you have to have the resources of a major firm, it is a much bigger uphill challenge to get your day in court. Second thing, you know, we have got a situation here with the courts that is unprecedented, and we have got a real debate on both sides of the aisle about who is weaponizing the court. I understand that. But do you, Professor Vladeck, have a view about whether the executive--and by the way, let me just give a context. The context that we are in right now is the separation of powers and three co-equal branches of Government. And my view is that the legislature is essentially ceding authority to the executive, and that is very dangerous in the long run for the well-being of our democracy. That is my point of view. I am not asking you whether you agree or you don't. But I will ask you, Professor Bray, what do you see as the impact on the rule of law when the Executive orders the Justice Department to dismiss a corruption case against the Mayor of New York City in order to get his cooperation on an Executive policy on immigration? Professor Bray. The rule of law applies to all three branches, and each one needs to act consistently with the law. That includes the executive, and also for the subject of the hearing today, that includes the courts. I am with you in thinking that it is imperative for every branch. Senator Welch. I know that, but I am talking something real world. This happened. We have got a major corruption case against the Mayor of New York City. And it was dismissed for political reasons. Does that conform to your view of how the rule of law should operate? Professor Bray. No, it does not. Senator Welch. Thank you very much. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Welch. Senator Welch. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Moody. You know, I was struck by the questions on the law firms and the approach of President Trump to try and bring them back to the table of working with this administration. I was struck. I found some of that ironic, and the questioning, Mr. Panuccio--and welcome, great Floridian from the great free State of Florida. Considering the way the law firms approached any conservative lawyer that was coming out of the last administration and the treatment of such, I thought it was very ironic. Did you notice that many lawyers who had stood up for good policies were refused employment or shut out of some of these large law firms? Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Senator. You know, I will be circumspect in my answer here, just because I am here to testify on universal injunctions. However, you know, I think it is an open secret in Washington that if you work for a Republican administration you face a much harder job market coming out than if you work for a Democratic administration. I do not think anyone doubts that to be the case, generally, over the years, not just specific to the Trump administration but going back to the Bush administration and others. And you often now hear people say, ``Well, if you take that job you may never work again.'' I think that happens much more often with Republicans than Democrats, and it reflects that, you know, law firms, like many institutions in this country, are overwhelmingly weighted in one direction politically than the other. Senator Moody. Mr. Panuccio, you have long been an academic, so to speak, on many of these challenges we see with nationwide injunctions and I appreciated your testimony, specifically when you quoted Justice Kagan, appointed by a Democratic President, when she said, ``It just can't be right that one district judge can stop a nationwide policy in its tracks, and leave it stopped for the years that it takes to go through the normal process.'' And what I--what struck me by that is this term, normal process, by someone who would know how long it takes to go through the normal process. And that basically means it could mean the 4 years, an entire term that a President is in office. Isn't that right? Mr. Panuccio. A full appellate process to the Supreme Court could take several years, yes. But Senator, I would say, you know, to coin a phrase, this is what democracy looks like. The Founders, at the Philadelphia Convention, considered turning the judiciary into what was called a ``Council of Revision,'' which would mean the judiciary had a chance to review laws and policies of the legislative or executive branch before they went into effect. And the Founders decided against that, and they said the judicial power is cases and controversies among the parties. The whole point of democracy---- Senator Moody. Let me just stop you right there. I want to focus on the normal process, the years it would take to go through the normal process, meaning, let's take for a moment that we can rightfully change the law to make sure that decisions apply to the parties before the court only. For the administration of justice to have any effect, and the people to believe that chaos and controversy and conflict can get rightfully addressed, expeditiously, should it take years for these cases to go through the courts? Or, should Congress consider an expedited process for matters of great national concern? Mr. Panuccio. I think it would be appropriate, Senator, for--if the Attorney General were to certify a case as of great national importance for there to be a faster process or mandatory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. I will say this, though. For individual parties, if an individual party is agreed by executive action, or legislative action, the individual party can go to a district court and get an injunction that gives complete relief to that party, and that does not take years. That can take days. It can take hours in certain cases. That is why the district courts are there. They are there to grant relief. Now, if what you are seeking is a change in policy nationwide, that is governing. That is what the elected branches do. But for individual parties, I do not think it is years for relief, as we have seen. Senator Moody. And Professor Bray, thank you for joining us. As a former judge myself, as someone who has great reverence for an independent and fair judiciary, it--it concerns me that the public, in general, based on what we are seeing in the numbers--and I thought it was really interesting, when we say 46 injunctions are orders that have gone against this administration, 9 were by Republican judges. Do you believe that limiting the relief sought to parties in front of the court will help alleviate this idea that these are judges acting in a partisan nature? Professor Bray. Thank you, Senator. I do think it will reduce the appearance of partisanship, because you get decision-making by more judges across the country instead of one judge giving an injunction to decide the question for the whole country. Senator Moody. So you believe the proposed legislation from Chairman Grassley would address bipartisan concerns? Professor Bray. Absolutely. Senator Moody. Senator Hirono. Senator Hirono. Thank you, Madam Chair. This is a question for Professor Vladeck. Professor Bray noted in his testimony the concern about extreme forum shopping, especially in single-judge districts. So I think you are familiar with a bill that I had introduced, which I intend to introduce once again, the Stop Judge Shopping Act. It was not motivated by a concern about nationwide injunctions, but here we are. I think it has relevance. And I am wondering, Professor, do you think that parties would seek and receive fewer nationwide injunctions if they were not able to judge or forum shop for favorable outcomes? This happened in the Texas mifepristone case. Professor Bray. I think there is no question, Senator. I mean, I think the data, such as it is, shows that there is a higher success rate when parties sought nationwide relief during the Biden administration in single-judge divisions than when they filed in courts that had random assignment to more than three judges. So, you know, that is a small dataset, and I do not want to overstate it. But yes, I mean, there is almost no conceivable way in which it would not be smaller. Senator Hirono. So that would be, in my view, it would be a fair, I suppose, way of addressing the concern over nationwide injunctions. Professor Vladeck. So I would say, if I might, two things. The first is that, I think distributing assignments would at least mitigate the allure---- Senator Hirono. Mm-hmm. Professor Vladeck [continuing]. Of nationwide injunctions in cases in which the median judge might not issue it. I mean, Professor Bray referred before, in the birthright citizenship case, to his confidence that any judge would block this order. The issue is not those cases. The issue is cases where the identity of the judge might be dispositive. So that is piece one---- Senator Hirono. Especially in single-judge districts. This is, again for you, and, perhaps, Professor Bray. You know, I am trying to understand the practical effect of Chair Grassley's proposed legislation, wherein the--where you limit the relief that a court can grant to only the parties before the court. So I would like to know how, in a case like the mifepristone decision, how the relief granted would apply only to the parties before the court. Professor Vladeck. So I think it is even more powerfully illustration, Senator, in the birthright citizenship cases, because in a contest in which you had, say, individual non- citizen parents, or even, you know, a group of non-citizen plaintiffs, say in Northern California, seeking to block the birthright citizenship policy, an injunction that only ran to them would be of no benefit to non-citizen parents in Southern California, in Oregon, or anywhere else in the country. And so, you would need litigation, you know, on a retail, nationwide basis, to ensure that the actual--that these parents could have confidence that when their children are born in the United States, they are born citizens. Senator Hirono. So you are saying that multiple lawsuits must be filed to obtain the relief---- Professor Vladeck. Unless, Senator---- Senator Hirono [continuing]. If we are going to go with what is in Senator Grassley's bill, that the relief will only be granted to the parties before it. There are certain issues that--certainly cases, where it would not make sense. Professor Vladeck. Well, and so---- Senator Hirono. In that way---- Professor Vladeck [continuing]. Senator, unless--and this goes back to the Chairman's opening statement, unless you were in the same bill to reinvigorate nationwide class actions, unless you were to effectively trade nationwide injunctions for a reinvigorated nationwide class action, where you would be able to show that all non-citizen parents who are, you know, who are of a childbearing age, are affected by this order. Senator Hirono. Professor Bray, did you want---- Professor Bray. Yes-- Senator Hirono [continuing]. To weigh in? Professor Bray [continuing]. I would love to. Thank you, Senator. I think the mifepristone case is a great example. You could not really have an injunction to protect the plaintiffs' interest there because the plaintiffs did not have standing. But what the case shows is---- Senator Hirono. Well, let's say that the plaintiffs did have standing. Professor Bray [continuing]. What the case shows is the lack of fit in so many of these cases with universal injunctions between tenuous, narrow, standing claims--including DACA, the original 2015 one, the tenuous, narrow, standing claims and massive universal relief. And that is not---- Senator Hirono. Okay. I am saying then, let's say that the standing issue was overcome, and then you have a court that says what the FDA did, did not comport with the APA, and can that court limit that holding just to the plaintiffs before him or her? Professor Bray. Well, in that sort of case the court should adjust its remedy to whatever the injury is. So you would have to have a real specific injury to then tailor the injunction to it. And in a case where you do not have one, you cannot really have an injunction tailored to the remedy--tailored to the injury. So, we'd have to hypothesize an injury---- Senator Hirono. Well---- Professor Bray [continuing]. And then hypothesize an injunction that matches it. Senator Moody. Thank you, Professor Bray. Senator Hirono. I realize my time is up, but my point is that I think there are some concerns about the approach that the Chairman is taking in his bill. Thank you. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Hirono. Senator Hawley. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thanks to all of the witnesses for being here. Let's just start by talking about the need to be here today and the fact that what we are seeing happen in district courts is, historically speaking, really unprecedented until recent years. [Poster is displayed.] Senator Hawley. And completely out of sync with our constitutional system, you alluded to this, Mr. Panuccio, the way that our Founders designed our constitutional system. Mr. Bray--Professor Bray, let me just start with you. When in--according to your scholarship, when is the first time that a district court issued a universal, non-party injunction of the kind that we are talking about today? Professor Bray. I think the first one is 1963. There is historical debate about when they started in the 20th century, but I think that would be the first one. But they certainly are not traditional in equity before then, and they were a peripheral backwater until 2015. Senator Hawley. So 1963. So the Republic is 200 years old-- almost, by the time we get the first district court issuing a universal injunction, binding parties who are not before it. And even then, as you just alluded to, then there is this period of quiet, where they are really not issued, until the 21st century, until the 20-teens. Is that correct? Professor Bray. That is correct. Senator Hawley. And then we see this explosion, as you can see in the chart behind me: in the Bush years, Bush 43, we have 6 universal injunctions, binding non-parties. In the Obama years, we have 12--and you referenced one of those cases, Professor Bray, in your opening statement, your written statement; and then, under Trump, in his first administration, 64 universal injunctions binding non-parties--14 under Biden-- and now 15 under the second Trump administration, in 1 month alone. Mr. Panuccio, let me just come to you. Tell us why this pattern that we are seeing here--and there is a clear partisan valence to it. But there is even more of a recency valence. I mean, this is something that just did not happen until very, very recently. Why is this so distortive to our Federal system? Mr. Panuccio. Well, thank you, Senator. It is distortive because it has judges operating outside their constitutional role. They are exerting policymaking power over the whole country. And the issue is this. We are a Republic. Those who get to exercise policymaking power, like yourself, like this body, have to face the electorate, every 6 years, 4 years, 2 years, whatever it is. Judges do not. We gave them life tenure so that they could be insulated and make decisions without fear of favor. But we limited the judicial power to cases and controversies just the party before them. And in my written testimony I note that Hamilton said it is the least dangerous branch. But he had a caveat, only if they exercise their judicial power. If they range beyond it, then it can be the most dangerous branch, and the public's confidence will be undermined because they have no chance to get rid of these judges because they have life tenure. They do not want to be ruled by kings. They want to be ruled in a Republic where they have a vote. Senator Hawley. And here is my concern, is that this pattern of, I think, abuse, this pattern of out-of-control behavior that we are seeing, that is illustrated on the graph that is behind me, is not decelerating. It is accelerating. And now we are seeing it not just with injunctive relief, we are seeing it in other orders, other procedural forums that are deliberately designed to insulate the judges, the district courts, from appellate review. Temporary restraining orders, you mentioned this, Mr. Panuccio. All of a sudden we have seen a huge uptick, in just the last few weeks, in district courts issuing what looks a heck of a lot like a nationwide non-party injunction, but it is styled as a temporary restraining order. Now, Mr. Panuccio, if I were a judge who wanted to insulate myself from review, why might I choose the temporary restraining order vehicle to do it? Why--I mean, why is this happening? Mr. Panuccio. Because, Senator, under current precedent, TROs, temporary restraining orders, are not immediately reviewable, unlike a preliminary injunction. So if you are a judge who believes a policy is unlawful and you want to exert power nationwide, and you do not want anyone to review, the voters certainly won't, the only people who can do it are appellate judges. So you issue a TRO, and then you extend it for another 2 weeks, and for at least a month you cannot be touched by the appellate courts. Senator Hawley. And has this happened in the last few weeks? Mr. Panuccio. It has been happening. We have seen straying beyond the typical preliminary injunction to TROs and other, what are being called administrative stays, which also appear to be unreviewable. Senator Hawley. So here I think is the issue that his before us. In one sense it is entirely appropriate that we are here today, and it is entirely predictable, given the urgency of the situation. In another sense, it is sort of a wonder we need to have a hearing on this at all, because my Democrat colleagues, for the last few years, have been decrying the very behavior that we are talking about now. And I think as you pointed out, Mr. Panuccio, we have had multiple members of the last administration, for example, Joe Biden's Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar, she herself said, in court, by the way. This was not a stray comment to the press. This was her at the Supreme Court, ``A court of equity may grant relief only to the parties before it. District courts violate this principle by issuing universal injunctions.'' Elena Kagan--Justice Kagan, ``It can't be right that one district court judge stopping nationwide policy in its tracks and leave it stopped for years while it goes through what is otherwise the normal process.'' I would just say to my Democrat colleagues, it should not be, to quote the Chairman, that once they were--or to quote the Ranking Member, that it is one rule for Democrats, it is one rule for Republicans. Let's make it one rule across the board, that no matter who appoints you, a judge can only bind parties who are before her or him. There are no nationwide, non-party injunctions. Let's make that the standard, and let's return these courts to the proper functioning of our constitutional system. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Hawley. Senator Hawley. I almost---- Senator Moody. You stuck to that timer. I am so proud of you. Senator Hawley. For me that was really good. Senator Moody. Senator Schiff. Senator Schiff. Thank you. I want to take a moment to acknowledge what took place today in the Southern District of New York, when the Justice Department dismissed a corruption case against the Mayor of New York City, not because of a lack of evidence, not because of any misconduct by the prosecutors in the case, but because of the most serious misconduct of the Attorney General and the top leadership of the Justice Department. Because the Justice Department wanted to leverage that case against the Mayor by dismissing the case without prejudice so that they could use him as a political pawn to help effectuate their immigration policy. That just happened today. It is one of any number of serious abuses of the rule of law by this Justice Department. Instead of having a single hearing on what the Department is doing, or a single hearing on all the other plainly unlawful acts of this administration--so instead of having a hearing on any of those things, Republicans are having a hearing on the one tool that could be used to try to mitigate the harm of these illegal actions. Now, I completely concur that whether nationwide injunctions are a good thing or a bad thing has depended entirely on who they are being used against. I count no less than 26 of my Republican colleagues who were vigorously supportive of a nationwide injunction against the use of mifepristone. They had a no problem supporting a nationwide injunction in that case. And, of course, on the Democratic side of the aisle, we are applauding injunctions against the unlawful actions of this administration. Where I think I come down at this moment in time gets to your point, Professor Vladeck, and that is the use of nationwide injunctions against an administration that has proven so breathtaking in its lawlessness and who is engaged in such a surge of illegal actions, the effort to do away with a singularly vital tool, I think you called it, at this time, would be disastrous for the country. It does not mean that there is not going to come a time when we should agree, on a bipartisan basis, to place limits on this capability. I think we should, and in particular on the abuse of forum shopping, on picking judges solely on the basis of their political predilection or who appointed them, for the purpose of a nationwide injunction. But this is not the moment to do it. This is the moment, frankly, we should be focusing on the illegality, not on the tool to constrain it. That does not mean we are powerless to work on legislation on this, and I think many of us have concurred with the idea of legislation that takes effect after this term, when we do not know who the next President is. Senator Cruz, you and I went to the same law school. There was a wonderful professor, at the college, in John Rawls, who wrote a book. You probably read about the ``veil of ignorance,'' where you cast a veil of ignorance over society, and society would develop rules to govern that society, not knowing their attributes, their race, their religion, their gender, none of that. Well, far be it for me to advocate a further veil of ignorance over this body. We are ignorant enough. But perhaps the ignorance of not knowing who the next President is, is useful here. We should come up with a sensible reform of injunctions and forum shopping, but there is no way this is going to have bipartisan support unless we defer its application until after this administration, when we do not know which way it will cut. I think the same is probably true about filling judicial vacancies. We have just come to this broken place, where probably the only way to get things done of this significance is to postpone their application until we do not know who the President will be. My time is almost up, but Professor Vladeck, in the moments I have left I would yield to you for any kind of response. Professor Vladeck. Well, just that, Senator, I think it is revealing that, you know, I, as the Minority witness today, am not here defending, in all contexts, universal injunctions. I have written before that I think that there are too many of them. I have written before that they raise at least some of the prudential concerns that Professor Bray has raised. And I just want to endorse your suggestion that holistic reform, to make litigation against the Government less manipulable, is something we should all be able to support, but that that holistic reform has to be about more than just closing off this one avenue today when there have been other developments that have closed off the other avenues, historically, that have made Senator Hawley's examples become so much more relevant today. Senator Schiff. Thank you. Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Vladeck. Senator Schmitt. Senator Schmitt. Thank you, Madam Chair. It occurs to me that, and I do not want to retread some of the same tire tracks here, but broadly speaking, really what we are talking about is a separation of powers issue. I mean, this is ultimately, when you distill it, this is one way it plays out. And as one of the witnesses remarked, the Founders never envisioned this sort of scenario. They certainly never envisioned the scenario, and the abuse that we are seeing here recently sort of--sort of puts an exclamation point on it. But I want to use one example of, and it is not a nationwide injunction, but just take Judge Boasberg's ruling here, in our Nation's Capital. And when--I think the Supreme Court was very clear in Justice Jackson's famous concurrence in Youngstown Steel, at the high-water mark of Presidential power is when you have congressional authorization, when you are actually performing Article II duties as Commander-in-Chief. And the Alien Enemies Act clearly grants that. It's silent, the stat--he text of the statute is silent on judicial review, and, of course, this is pre-Marbury so they never--they certainly would have never intended that anyway. Yet, we have got a judge, and there are other issues at play, habeas, you have got due process at play. But you have a judge that feels compelled to make this sort of decision. And inherently it is Article II power and/or a political question that is not justiciable. I mean, you could go through a number of different questions. Could the court--a few of them here--a judge have stopped Andrew Jackson from firing on the British at the Battle of New Orleans because we had already signed the Treaty again? Of course, the answer to that is no. Could a judge have stopped FDR from responding to the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor because they had not formally declared war until 2 hours later? These are questions--these are core Article II powers. So when we talk about the separation of powers, I think we do not teach civics anymore. But if we did, you would learn that the Article III branch, its powers are not unlimited either. It is, in fact, limited. And the Congress gets to limit Article III power, which is sort of, I think, one of the reasons we are here today. And I think we have seen, Senator Hawley had the graph of when we have seen this acceleration. And I do think--I think the Chairman's bill, I am a Co-Sponsor of it, I think the time is now, and maybe there is this sort of mutually assured destruction that Senator Schiff is talking about. Maybe these are the conditions by which you actually can get something like this done. But I do want to raise one other question, and Mr. Panuccio, I offer this to you. I mean, it is an open secret, the appellate bar and the politically sensitive litigators know this, that this randomly assigning district court judge thing, something is wrong here. Something is happening. It is statistically impossible for Boasberg--Judge Boasberg to get the cases he's getting. It is statistically impossible. When I was attorney general in Missouri we saw this in the eighth circuit. The one Democrat-appointed judge ended up on the panels. It is statistically impossible for that to have happened in that period of time. So I wanted to ask you, what are some reforms that we might consider to ensure that this is truly random? Because if one of the remedies is that you actually have a randomly selected district court judge, then they ought to be a randomly selected district court judge. Do we have like a lottery? Do we have a big wheel? What are some ideas? Because I think there is enough suspicion right now that it is affecting the credibility of the court. Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Senator. I am not an expert on the wheels across the country. My general understanding as a litigator is that most courts employ a wheel. How that wheel is weighted can change from district to district, depending on the judges. So, for example, in one of my home courts, the Northern District of Florida, there is a public order that tells you exactly how the wheel will work--35 percent of the civil cases to this judge, you know, 60 percent to this judge, 5 percent to that judge. My own view is that the more transparency courts have, the better, so that at least the public can know this is how the wheel is working. Even if you do not see the wheel operate, you at least know this is the weighting of the wheel, and that can be based on how many active judges you have, how many senior judges you have, how many judges you have in the district, and the geography of the district. Senator Schmitt. Well, I would just suggest that I think that in addition to what we are talking about here today, there probably ought to be more reforms contemplated, because this, I think you do not need to be some soothsayer or the Oracle at Delphi to understand that there is something amiss here. Thank you. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Schmitt. Senator Whitehouse. Senator Whitehouse. Thanks very much. Thank you, all, for being here. The first thing I would like to do is put into the record a partial list that my office pulled together of nationwide injunctions against the Biden administration, that my Republican colleagues celebrated and rejoiced in. So this is a bit of a ``What side are you on, who is in power right now?'' type of debate we are having. The second thing that I would like to do is to point out that the discomfort to fury, that is kind of the general range, about decisions against the Trump administration may actually have a lot to do with the unprecedented lawlessness and lawbreaking of the Trump administration rather than a weird cabal of judges trying to intrude. And it rolls into something that is very important to the court right now, which is threats to judges, and to their families, which I think there is significant evidence to show is, has been orchestrated and is systematized. It obviously starts at the top, with people like Trump and Musk making threats about impeachment and whipping up. In the case of Musk, he has curated a whole armada of characters, to put it nicely, on X, who, when he targets an individual, barrage that individual with abuse and threats. The idea that Musk does not know that he has this curated armada of, let's just say, not entirely all-there individuals who are willing to go and harass and threaten when he has identified a target, seems unlikely. Seems like he knows. Seems like it is deliberate. And, in that regard, I would like to put into the record a letter that I wrote to Judge Bredar, who is the new head of the Judicial Security and Independence Task Force. For the first time the judiciary felt it had to put together a task force to deal with the campaign of threats that begins at the top with Trump and Musk, and then works its way down to where individual judges are not only critiqued, that is fair game, but they are threatened. They are threatened with impeachment to the point where the Chief Justice has had to stand up and say, ``No, no, no. If you disagree with a decision, that is an appealable issue, not an impeachable issue.'' So I ask that both be put into the record, both my letter regarding what they have to do. Senator Moody. Without objection. [The information appears as submissions for the record.] Senator Whitehouse. Here is my concern. I do not know that the Marshals Service is actually going to provide the protection that the judges need. We had a very good response to the Rhode Island judge who was subjected to these threats. The court was very impressed and pleased with what the Marshals Service did in that instance. But it gets a little bit different when you start going after, it seems always to be female family members--when you start going after spouses, wives, and daughters, and things like that. You know, if you go after a judge's daughter who lives in a different location, how does the Marshals Service respond to safety issues related to the daughter who lives in a different city, who is not even in the district for the marshals. What do you do about that? And do the marshals have any authority to do any investigative work to see what can be done to understand the threat posture that these judges are facing? And who is behind it? And when is it deliberate? Or, are they constrained only to provide protection but not look into what the threat is? I think those are really important questions, and I hope that this judicial group will take a good, hard look at that. And that is what my letter requests. The last thing I would suggest is, this ain't that easy. If you are a district judge and you decide that a rule is unconstitutional, or an action is unconstitutional, and that action plays out across multiple States, that, as the law of that case and as the law on that subject, ought to be applicable in other districts. And the idea that every time some action is deemed unconstitutional, you have got to file it 93 times to hit every single district before it can apply? I mean, I think we get into some very significant practicality issues as we mount this little crusade that runs exactly counter to where my Republican colleagues were when the shoe was on the other foot. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Whitehouse. Senator Cruz. Senator Cruz. It has long been said that hypocrisy is the tribute that vice pays to virtue. I have to admit, I am enjoying listening to my Democrat colleagues suddenly discover the virtues of the rule of law, after 4 years where they brazenly supported the most lawless Department of Justice and the most politically weaponized Department of Justice our Nation has ever seen. We just heard the Senator from Rhode Island talk about the imperative of protecting judges, and yet not a single Democrat Senator cared about the violent protesters that showed up outside Supreme Court Justices' homes, including, I might note, female Justices, like Justice Amy Coney Barrett, threatening their family, and Joe Biden's Attorney General did not do a damn thing, and refused to enforce the law to protect those judges. Why? Because he agreed with the violent protesters and he wanted to intimidate and threaten those judges. Professor Bray, under our Constitution, who should decide elections? The voters or unelected judges? Professor Bray. The voters are the ones who should vote in the election, according to the laws, and the laws sometimes have to be applied by the judges if they---- Senator Cruz. And under our Constitution, who is charged with making policy decisions? Elected representatives elected by the people or unelected Federal judges? Professor Bray. I think the question of policy, Senator, is a little broader than the particular case. So, the basic laws-- the laws should be enacted by Congress. That is where the foundation of---- Senator Cruz. Policy decisions of the elected branch. Professor Bray. Right. Senator Cruz. Law is the province of the court. Policy is the province of the elected branches. Is it--these are not complicated. Professor Bray, let me ask you this. Do the Federal courts have power to issue remedies for people who are not parties to a case? Professor Bray. That is a question I agree is not complicated. They do not have that power. Senator Cruz. Is the phrase ``nationwide injunction'' or ``universal injunction'' found anywhere in the Constitution? Professor Bray. It is not. Senator Cruz. First chart. In the first 150 years of our Republic, how many nationwide injunctions were issued? Professor Bray. My view is that there were not any until 1963. Senator Cruz. Zero. Now fast forward. How many nationwide injunctions were issued in the entire 20th century? Professor Bray. It is a small number. I would--I would think it would be a dozen, give or take. It is not large. Senator Cruz. Twenty-seven, actually. [Poster is displayed.] Senator Cruz. Excluding Trump's first term, how many nationwide injunctions were issued in the last 20 years? Professor Bray. Far more than that. Senator Cruz. Thirty-two. From 2001 to 2024, against Biden, Obama, and Bush, 32. And how many nationwide injunctions have been issued in the last 2 months alone? Professor Bray. There have been quite a few. Senator Cruz. Thirty-seven. Let that sink in. There have been more nationwide injunctions in the past 2 months against President Trump than in the entire 20th century. There have been more nationwide injunctions against President Trump in the last 2 months than both terms of George W. Bush, both terms of Barack Obama, and Joe Biden's term. We saw, during the Biden Presidency, lawfare, indicting President Trump four times, using the machinery of justice to attack him, and that was an attack on democracy, because Democrats today hate democracy. Democrats today are angry at the voters for reelecting Donald Trump and electing a Republican Senate and a Republican House, and they engaged in lawfare to stop democracy from operating. Understand, this is the second phase of lawfare. Second chart. This is the second phase of lawfare. [Poster is displayed.] Senator Cruz. Now that their efforts to indict President Trump and stop the voters from reelecting him have failed, they are going and seeking out individual radical judges to try to shut down policies, and they are forum shopping like crazy. Give me any loon judge put on the bench by Obama or Biden who disagrees with the policy. We just saw a judge flagrantly ignore U.S. immigration law concerning TPS being revoked. U.S. law explicitly said there is no judicial review for that. But hey, they found a judge who says, You know what? We, the Democrat Party, we are the party of illegal aliens. We are the party of murderers and rapists and gang members. And the Democrat Party exists here to fight to keep murderers and rapists and gang members in your communities. There is a reason that the Democrat Party is at 26 percent approval nationwide. Because they put radical policies ahead of rule of law. Nationwide injunctions are abuse of power. It is the judiciary acting as policy deciders, and it is incumbent on this Committee and this body to rein in the abuse of power from these unelected radical judges who are trying to overturn the election because they disagree with what the voters decided. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Cruz. Senator Klobuchar. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. That was a lot. Let me start with a few things. Number one, we love the democracy, and I believe what we should be having is a civil debate about how we can best--if Donald Trump wants to make changes to the Government, we should be doing it in a legal way, not how he's doing it. And the only reason there are all these injunctions, Senator Cruz, is because he's violating the Constitution. Why would Trump-appointed judges---- Senator Cruz. Why don't you file---- Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. Rule---- Senator Cruz [continuing]. Them in a red dis--in red districts? Senator Moody. Senator Cruz---- Senator Klobuchar. Why--what did you just say? Senator Cruz. Why don't you file---- Senator Moody [continuing]. Senator Cruz---- Senator Cruz [continuing]. Them in red districts? Senator Moody [continuing]. I ask for point of order---- Senator Cruz. Why are the Democrat Attorneys---- Senator Moody [continuing]. Senator Cruz---- Senator Cruz [continuing]. General seeking out---- Senator Moody [continuing]. Senator Cruz---- Senator Cruz [continuing]. Left wing---- Senator Moody. My esteemed colleague---- Senator Cruz [continuing]. Blue---- Senator Whitehouse. You're quite patient---- Senator Moody [continuing]. One second---- Senator Whitehouse [continuing]. With Senator Cruz's activity---- Senator Klobuchar. Yes. Senator Whitehouse [continuing]. In this building. Senator Moody. Senator Whitehouse---- Senator Whitehouse. He's entitled to---- Senator Moody [continuing]. I am just going to ask for a point of order. Madam Klobuchar--Senator Klobuchar---- Senator Cruz. Senator Moody, we have debates on this Committee. They--they--they occur regularly. Senator Moody. Let's let her have her time, and then we will get back to them. Senator Klobuchar. It is---- Senator Moody. If you want to wait, we will get back to you, Senator Cruz. Senator Cruz. You are welcome to answer the question or not. Senator Moody. Go ahead. Senator Cruz. It is your choice. Senator Klobuchar. So, I would be---- Senator Moody. Go ahead. And I would encourage you to answer. Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. Following Senator Cruz, once again---- Senator Moody. Excuse me? Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. I will say this---- Senator Moody. Excuse me? I did not hear you. What did you say? Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. To be following him. He and I have a long-standing---- Senator Moody. I was permitting you your time to continue-- oh, to be following him in order. Excuse me. Go ahead, Senator Klobuchar. Senator Klobuchar. I have been following him during hearings---- Senator Moody. Go ahead, Senator Klobuchar. Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. That is what I am referring to. Senator Moody. Go ahead. Senator Klobuchar. And I will take more than my time, since he has taken more than his time to yell at me. Senator Moody. Go ahead. I will mark the time. Senator Klobuchar. All I will say is that---- Senator Cruz. I am not yelling. I asked a question. Senator Moody. Senator Cruz, please. I will give you time. Senator Klobuchar, I have got the time, and you will be allotted your time. Senator Klobuchar. I am making a strong case that the reason all these cases have been filed, and the reason that these judges, who have been appointed by Ronald Reagan--yes, they still exist, and the Bushes, and Donald Trump--judges appointed by Donald Trump, have been making these decisions because this is not legal. Donald Trump himself has used his social media account, the White House account, to post an image of himself wearing a crown, saying ``Long Live the King.'' The issue is that we do not live in a kingdom, and Elon Musk is not his court jester. Ours is a Nation of laws in which no one is above the law. That is why 39 different judges, from vastly different backgrounds, appointed by 5 different Presidents, have made clear that these are illegal actions. And these judges have rightly blocked these actions. And it is important that we not lose sight of the underlying cause of these injunctions. It is not that these judges are crooked or lunatics or evil. Those are words used by the President and his allies. It is because the administration is violating the Constitution. What happens when they use these kinds of words? You see more and more threats against judges. And that is what we are seeing. That is why Federal judges and the U.S. Marshals who are responsible for protecting them, are sounding the alarm about a spike in threats against judges. This is serious. And unlike what Senator Cruz said, I am remembering when the threat was made, the horrific threats and the man was in Justice Kavanaugh's, in his neighborhood, on his street. On a bipartisan basis we came together and got more funding for the judges and changed things so that they had more protection. So what he said was completely untrue in terms of Democrats and Republicans decrying violence. We did not just decry the violence. We actually did something about it in response to a court that is run by Justice Roberts, who is a Republican appointee. So I think that kind of language actually makes the situation worse when it is not even true. But unfortunately, Senator Cruz left so he did not hear my response to what was a lie. President Trump's attacks on these judges have made for some major, major risks for these judges. I would ask you, Mr. Panuccio, and not in a partisan way, just normal, as a partner in a law firm, would you ever--have you ever taken to social media to personally attack a judge who ruled against you? Mr. Panuccio. Senator---- Senator Klobuchar. That is all my question is. Mr. Panuccio. Senator, thanks for the question. I think that attacking judges personally, and not their reasoning, well, let me just give you a quote, ``I want tell you, Gorsuch, I want to tell you, Kavanaugh, you have released a whirlwind and you will pay the price''---- Senator Klobuchar. No. I have asked---- Mr. Panuccio. ``You want to know--you won't know what hit you if you go forward with those awful---- Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. I asked---- Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. ``Decisions.'' That was---- Senator Klobuchar. Okay. I was actually---- Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. Something that Senator Schumer said---- Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. I was---- Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. And I thought it was awful, and it unleashed a wave of violent threats---- Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. I--I---- Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. Against Supreme Court Justices-- -- Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. I have---- Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. I do think that is problematic-- -- Senator Klobuchar. Of course it---- Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. That kind of language. Senator Klobuchar. I have--I have no doubt the language is a problem on the left or right. I was just asking you if you have ever personally attacked a judge after you disagreed with a ruling. I am asking if you did it. Mr. Panuccio. I have not. Senator Klobuchar. Thank you. And you believe that the proper recourse is to appeal when you disagree with a ruling. Mr. Panuccio. When I disagree with a ruling on behalf of a client I appeal. Senator Klobuchar. Thank you. That was all I wanted. I was not going to criticize you. I believe that you would not have done this. And so that is my point. When people do this, and right now we have not just a random person on social media doing it. We have the President of the United States doing it. And I would just ask you, Professor Vladeck, in your opinion, are the judges who ruled against the President radical and rogue judges? Professor Vladeck. No. And just, if I might, even though he has also left the room, Senator Schmitt suggested it was statistically impossible that Chief Judge Boasberg has been assigned to multiple cases in the D.C. District Court. I think that rhetoric is highly inflammatory in addition to being just mathematically incorrect. There are 31 different cases in the D.C. District Court alone in which D.C. District judges have ruled against the administration. There are 11 or 12 active district judges. The notion that one of those judges would have multiple of those cases is not statistically impossible. It is statistically certain. Senator Klobuchar. And if the President does not want to have a judge rule against him, isn't the answer that he just follows the law? Professor Vladeck. One would think. But, you know, I think we live in a bit of an upside-down world at the moment. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. So this hearing was titled in a very academic fashion, ``Universal Injunctions.'' And we can make it all academic if we want. Clearly we have not, with Senator Cruz's remarks. But I just want to make the point that this has a real consequence--that these cases that are coming before these judges. This is outside of their decision, which is based on the law and the facts. Sometimes they have ruled with the President. Sometimes they have ruled against the President. But just to get it so people understand this is not just some academic exercise about injunctions and if they are a good thing to have legally. Last month, a Federal judge blocked the administration's plan to slash NIH funding for medical research. Could you talk about the impact if the judge had not been able to issue a nationwide injunction? Professor Vladeck. Sure. So, Senator, briefly, because I know our time is limited, NIH hands out thousands and thousands and thousands of grants. If you require the recipients of each grant to litigate the rescission of each of those grants on a retail basis you would have gaps in cancer research, you would have gaps in all kinds of, you know, work by the National Institutes of Health. Because there's this--it is not possible that those thousands of grants, the mass action by the Government could be challenged on a retail basis in Federal Courts. Senator Moody. Thank you so much. Senator Klobuchar. Could I have a second round? Senator Moody. Senator Klobuchar, oh, I allowed you to go way over your time in order to make up---- Senator Klobuchar. Are we having a second round? Senator Moody. No, ma'am. I just wanted to let you know that I did give you extra time, and over what was taken up. Senator Klobuchar. The practice of---- Senator Moody. Thank you so much, I appreciate it. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. A lot of times when Senators are still here and there is no one else here, they let them have a second round. Senator Moody. Absolutely. I have just, like, one moment to ask about an issue---- Senator Klobuchar. Okay---- Senator Moody [continuing]. That came up---- Senator Klobuchar [continuing]. Well, you should. Yes. Senator Moody [continuing]. That is regarding TROs. And, I just want to make sure that the Committee, as a whole, has an understanding of TROs, how they are used, so that they can take this into account in the proposed legislation. TROs have been used historically by judges, and they have not been immediately appealable. And it is in the proposed legislation that we change that practice, through law, and make sure that TROs are appealable. Do you think that would remedy some of what is happening today and some of the distrust that certain judges are making partisan rulings? Mr. Panuccio. Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Senator Moody. I do think that when a TRO, well, let me step back. TROs now are starting to look a lot like preliminary injunctions, and preliminary injunctions are immediately appealable. And so it really should not matter what label the court puts on it, whether they call that an administrative stay, a TRO, or a preliminary injunction. If the court is enjoining, preliminarily, before a party has proven, before a jury or a judge, entitlement to relief, if they are getting that injunction it should be immediately appealable, no matter what the label is. Senator Moody. And that would make a significant change in court procedure, as it--in comparison to how it has been applied historically. Mr. Panuccio. It would. There is some very recent scholarship out about how exactly it came to be that TROs are not appealable. But given what is happening, yes, legislation to address it would probably be the most expeditious way. Senator Moody. So that seeks to expedite review of some of these cases where judges are issuing nationwide orders. And I want to go back to something that we heard pretty much on both sides of the aisle today, questions pertaining to Executive authority, Article II authority, and whether or not that should even be reviewable in some instances, especially as it relates to national security matters. Are there instances to alleviate partisan concerns? And I am sure, as a lawyer, it causes you great concern for the stability of this Nation and our separation of powers that there would be a suspicion of partisan agenda among our judges. That is concerning. Correct? Mr. Panuccio. We want our judges to be seen as nonpartisan in applying the rule of law only. Senator Moody. And would there be an instance where utilizing a three-judge panel might alleviate those concerns? Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Senator. We have instances of that. There are numerous different kinds of cases where a three-judge panel, the statutes require that a three-judge panel is convened, and sometimes it is because the cases are of significant national importance or have some kind of, I don't want to say partisan, but important valence to them in terms of the policy. So we see this in redistricting cases, for example, there are three-judge panels. So there are--there is a place for three-judge panels, I think. You know, I will say that I don't--I personally do not believe that we should say if someone seeks a nationwide injunction or non-party relief it goes to a three-judge panel, because that would give the imprimatur of validity to non-party injunctions, and I do not think they are valid if 1 district judge does it or 3 or 17. I do not think district courts have that power. Senator Moody. And certainly in some instances it might be indicative--the public may prefer a three-judge panel for assurance of impartiality, that might be preferable. Mr. Panuccio. Right. Or another way to put it is just to make sure that there is greater deliberation among intelligent judicial minds about major issues. So, for example, you could have--in substantive areas you could say, look, if it is a case about the President's wartime powers, it is not going to go to a single district judge. It is going to go to three judges, because we will get the benefit of, you know, three times the benefit of judicial reasoning. Senator Moody. And even if there were a three-judge panel, the need for expeditious review would still be important if it is a matter of great national concern or interest. Mr. Panuccio. I think expeditious appellate review of cases implicating policies of significant national concern is important. Senator Moody. Senator Britt. Senator Britt. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. I want to go ahead and jump in. I know that you have talked about a lot of the issues that I wanted to bring up. But Professor Bray and Mr. Panuccio, I would like to turn to talking about the Administrative Procedure Act and vacatur. And one of the provisions of the Judicial Relief Clarification Act, which I am proud to be a Co-Sponsor of, amends Sections 705 and 706 of the APA to limit relief to the persons before the court. My question to the two of you is, can you discuss the emergence of the APA vacatur, and in the broader conversation surrounding universal injunctions and the importance of addressing that issue in any legislation that addresses the universal injunction problem that we have before us today? Professor Bray. Gladly, Senator. So the Administrative Procedure Act allows challenges and judicial review of agency action. And there is a vigorous debate among scholars about whether the Administrative Procedure Act should be understood as allowing a separate remedy of vacatur. Senator Britt. Mm-hmm. Professor Bray. I do not think there is such a remedy of vacatur. There is no traditional remedy called by that name. You will not find it in remedies case books or treatises or anything else. But there is a vigorous debate about that. What I do not think you can really debate is the interaction between vacatur and universal injunctions. So one of the things that we have seen, especially in the Biden administration, is litigants and courts were shifting form universal injunctions to vacatur, especially as appellate courts and some of the concurring opinions from the Supreme Court started to express more skepticism of universal injunctions. And that kind of switch is really important for a legislative solution. It means a legislative solution has to tackle the vacatur problem, as well. Otherwise, you are just going to play whack-a-mole, and you are going to stop universal injunctions, and all the same things will be done by courts, against agencies, at least, under the APA. Senator Britt. Thank you. Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Senator. Professor Bray is the expert on the history of this. I will just say that, as he has said, the issue of nationwide injunctions or vacatur is, they are one in the same at the end of the day. It is the court granting relief to parties not before it. There is the issue of the set-aside language in 706. Senator Britt. Mm-hmm. Mr. Panuccio. And I think any legislation that is going to address the issue of non-party relief needs to take that on. To just take on injunctions would then, in most cases, allow courts just to say, ``Well, I am going to look over here to the APA''---- Senator Britt. Yes. Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. And do the same thing. Senator Britt. Okay. Thank you. Professor Bray, I want to get your response to some of the criticism we have heard for those that are opposed to curtailing universal injunctions. Let's start with the criticism that we should not eliminate universal injunction because it could lead to inconsistency and an inconsistent application of the law around the country, or in some form of, as you have called it, disuniformity. As you have written about, it seems to me that the question is not about whether we have uniformity. It is more a question about at what level our legal system and our court system is such nationwide uniformity actually achieved. And so the process to get there and how we achieve that, I think, is kind of what is at question. What is your view on the question, and what is your response to the disuniformity criticism of limiting universal injunctions, and relatedly, is disuniformity an inherently bad thing? Professor Bray. So I think there is a lot of value to uniformity in the law. The question is how and when and who gets you there. And in our legal system we get uniformity, but we get uniformity over time. And I think one of the striking things that you see for universal injunctions is they--they are proceeding on a premise that the first judge, selected with highly intense forum shopping and in a time of high judicial polarization, that the first judge who takes the question is going to be right. Senator Britt. Mm-hmm. Professor Bray. But often universal injunctions get reversed or narrowed on appeal. And so, there is--there is no--should be no presumption of the first judge to tackle the question is the one who should get to uniformity. Instead, the right way to get to uniformity is through appellate precedent, which, as Justice Kagan said, is the normal process. Senator Britt. Absolutely. Thank you so much for your time. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Britt. Senator Klobuchar. Senator Klobuchar. Yes. Just two more questions here of you, Professor Vladeck. Federal judges, we are going through NIH and what that would mean if you had to have an individual case in every single grant, in every single jurisdiction of the country, which is why we have this ability on the nationwide front. Let's look at something else. Federal judges blocked the administration's funding freeze that jeopardized everything from community health centers to childcare to infrastructure to support for law enforcement. Can you talk about the impact if those judges had not been able to issue a nationwide injunction, including on non- parties? Professor Vladeck. Sure. I mean, I think we would have seen, Senator, overnight tons of entities that depend upon those Federal funds to provide vital services to everyone, just having to close up shop and not being able to provide those services because they do not have the money. And so, you know, Professor Bray is right that the question is uniformity at what point. I think part of what has not been fully explicated in our conversation this morning is that one of the justifications for uniformity earlier rather than later is irreparable harm, and is the notion that but for this kind of relief at this early juncture. Mr. Panuccio has been attacking TROs for most of this hearing. TROs are based on the idea that the harm the party is facing is so urgent that there is not time for the ordinary process. And I think we really have not done a lot this morning to talk about how these policies are harming people in ways that create, to me, extraordinary justifications for these kinds of judicial interventions. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. Last one. Judges have blocked the administration's plans to empower Elon Musk to rummage through American Social Security information--my words, probably not the words in the law--and get access to their bank accounts, tax returns. This is all the DOGE-related looking at things. If judges had not been able to issue a nationwide injunction, what would be the impact on the American people? Professor Vladeck. I mean, again, you know, it is different stock, same problem, right, which is you would need retail litigation by, you know, every American whose Social Security information has been compromised. Or, you would need to somehow overcome the insuperable barriers that the Supreme Court has created for class certification. And so, you know, I do not mean to beat a dead horse, Senator, but it seems to me that those who are averse to nationwide injunctions but not to the notion that the Federal Government should be acting within the confines of the law, should actually be supportive of reforms that would strengthen the nationwide class action as a procedurally proper and historically precedented device for restraining the Executive when the lawlessness is on such a wide scale. Senator Klobuchar. Thank you. Professor Vladeck. Thank you. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Klobuchar. Ranking Member. Senator Durbin. I want to ask a question of Mr. Panuccio, and I think you addressed this earlier, and I want to make sure there is clarity, at least in my mind, on your response. President Trump's Executive orders attacking a number of law firms because they employed attorneys who were involved in litigation or represented clients that he did not approve of--I also understand that he is withdrawing security clearances for some members of those law firms, which, of course, would impact their client relationship and their ability to do work. What is the impact of those Executive orders on the targeted firms? Mr. Panuccio. Ranking Member Durbin, you would have to ask those law firms what the impact has been. Senator Durbin. What message do you think these Executive orders send to the legal community, more broadly? Mr. Panuccio. I think you would have to ask the legal community more broadly. Senator Durbin. I am asking you. You are with a law firm, and it is not unreasonable to ask you. Has it come up in conversation in the last 2 weeks among your colleagues? Mr. Panuccio. Well, it is not what I was invited here to testify about, Senator. Senator Durbin. Well, it---- Mr. Panuccio. I think all of these law firms have the ability, as with any party in this country, to seek individual relief in a court, as many of them are doing. Senator Durbin. Yes. So you kind of think this is routine legal work. Mr. Panuccio. Routine? Well, challenging an Executive order, whether it was in the Biden administration or this administration or the Bush administration is, has become routine in this country, and the courts are open for those individuals to seek redress. Senator Durbin. Professor Vladeck, do you have any thoughts on this? Professor Vladeck. I mean, just, you know, I do not mean to repeat myself from before, Senator. I just note that, you know, we should all be invested, and by ``we'' I mean lawyers, law professors, Members of Congress. The courts thrive when they are receiving the best possible arguments from the members of the bar. And, you know, I think everyone is going to have their own views on who has weaponized what, against whom. I think the notion that we should be getting to a place where the executive branch is openly threatening law firms, in concepts in which those threats are designed to prevent lawsuits against the Federal Government, jeopardizes the very accountability that separation of powers exists to protect. Senator Durbin. Professor Bray? Professor Bray. I think you need a strong and independent bar to represent the interests of all the people in the United States. Senator Durbin. Thank you. Senator Moody. Thank you, Ranking Member. And because we allowed them additional questioning, Senator Britt, would you like to have any additional questions? Senator Britt. Absolutely. Thank you so much. Mr. Panuccio, as someone who worked at DOJ, what is your response to the argument of the universal injunctions are a good thing to help prevent having to relitigate the same issue in multiple jurisdictions? Mr. Panuccio. Thank you, Senator. That is not how our multi-tiered, hierarchical court system works. The whole point--the--the first ground for the Supreme Court to take jurisdiction over a case, the reason it will grant cert, as they say, the number one reason they will say is if there is a circuit split. Well, how can we ever have a circuit split if we have a district court, which is lower than a circuit---- Senator Britt. Mm-hmm. Mr. Panuccio [continuing]. Issue a rule for the whole country? Senator Britt. Right. Mr. Panuccio. The whole point is we have percolation, we have over 1,000 district judges in this country, to apply their judicial reasoning. And Justice Ginsberg, it is in my written testimony, she had a very eloquent explanation of why percolation, why getting different decisions from different judicial minds is important. So it is not within our historical tradition to have one judge set a rule for the whole country and have that uniformity. That is not what our legal foundation is built upon. Senator Britt. Absolutely. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Britt. I want to thank the witnesses for your time this morning. I know this has been a long morning, but certainly a topic that is important to this entire country. All eyes and attention is on this right now, so we are so grateful. I think what we have learned today is there is a very keen interest to address making sure that our judiciary remains impartial and that it is making rulings only in terms of relief as to the parties before it, and that we are encouraging expeditious resolution of these extraordinarily important matters, especially as you have a President that is trying to deliver on promises made to the American people and restoring safety and justice to this Nation. So with that I thank you for your time. I thank you to everyone that has participated in the hearing today. Certainly this is the People's House, and it is important that we have members of the public here with us as we are debating and addressing these important issues. Written questions may be submitted for the record until April the 9th at 5 p.m. I know certain Senators asked for written responses, if you are willing to provide them. And with that the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:20 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [Additional material submitted for the record follows.] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] A P P E N D I X The following submissions are available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg61880/pdf/CHRG-119shrg 61880-add1.pdf Submitted by Ranking Member Durbin: Malveaux, Suzette M., Class Actions, Civil Rights, National Injunction, article, Vol. 131:56, 2017........................ 2 Submitted by Senator Cruz: ``Nationwide Injunctions in U.S. History,'' poster displayed during hearing................................................ 11 ``Nationwide Injunctions Issued Against U.S. Presidents 2000- 2024,'' poster displayed during hearing....................... 12 Submitted by Senator Hawley: ``Axios: Nationwide Injunctions Against Recent Presidents,'' poster displayed during hearing............................... 13 Submitted by Senator Whitehouse: ``Nationwide Injunctions Against Biden Administration,'' list.... 14 Whitehouse, Hon. Sheldon, letter to Hon. James K. Bredar, District Judge, March 31, 2025................................ 16 [all]