ENDING THE SCOURGE: THE NEED FOR THE STOP CSAM ACT

Senate Judiciary Committee Senate March 11, 2025

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[Senate Hearing 119-180]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-180

 ENDING THE SCOURGE:
 THE NEED FOR THE STOP CSAM ACT

=======================================================================

 HEARING

 before the

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON CRIME AND 
 COUNTERTERRORISM

 of the

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 FIRST SESSION
 __________

 MARCH 11, 2025
 __________

 Serial No. J-119-8
 __________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary

 [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 
 

 www.judiciary.senate.gov
 www.govinfo.gov
 
 ______
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE

61-837 WASHINGTON : 2026 

 
 
 
 

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

 CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman
 
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member
MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island
TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey
ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California
KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California

 Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director
 Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director

 Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism

 JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri, Chair
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member
TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
 CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey

 John Ehrett, Republican Chief Counsel
 Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel

 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Page
Hawley, Hon. Josh,............................................... 1
Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 19
 Prepared statement........................................... 30

 WITNESSES

DeLaune, Michelle................................................ 4
 Prepared statement........................................... 32
 Responses to written questions............................... 48

Pizzuro, John.................................................... 13
 Prepared statement........................................... 51
 Responses to written questions............................... 56

Schiller, Gregory................................................ 8
 Prepared statement........................................... 58

Sines, Taylor.................................................... 11
 Prepared statement........................................... 63

Tanagho, John.................................................... 6
 Prepared statement........................................... 65

 APPENDIX

Items submitted for the record................................... 95

 
 ENDING THE SCOURGE:
 THE NEED FOR THE STOP CSAM ACT

 ---------- 

 TUESDAY, MARCH 11, 2025

 United States Senate,
 Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism,
 Committee on the Judiciary,
 Washington, DC.
 The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:45 p.m., in 
Room 226, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Josh Hawley, 
Chair of the Subcommittee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Hawley [presiding], Blackburn, Britt, 
Durbin, Klobuchar, and Blumenthal.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JOSH HAWLEY,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI

 Chair Hawley. I'm pleased to call this first hearing of the 
Senate Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee on Crime and 
Counterterrorism to order.
 It is a privilege to serve as the Chair of the Subcommittee 
during this Congress, and I'm equally delighted to have as the 
Ranking Member my colleague, Senator Dick Durbin, who is on his 
way over from lunch.
 His staff tells me I can blame Senator Schumer. I said, I 
blame Senator Schumer for so many things.
 [Laughter.]
 But he will be--he will be joining us shortly.
 It's really--it's a delight to have Senator Durbin as the 
Ranking Member on this Committee. And it's particularly a 
privilege to partner with him on this important topic that 
we're here to discuss today.
 Senator Durbin and I have worked together on a number of 
initiatives. I don't think any is more important than 
confronting the scourge of child sexual exploitation, or CSAM.
 You know, that's an anodyne-sounding abbreviation. But, as 
I hope everybody in the room appreciates and those who are 
listening online understand, that abbreviation stands in for a 
terrifying, horrifying reality. We're talking about, in a word, 
child pornography. We're talking about child sexual 
exploitation, child sexual abuse.
 The amount of this material online--available online, is 
truly astounding. And we're going to talk about that over the 
course of today's hearing. But, of course, these aren't just 
statistics.
 Every single instance of CSAM online represents a real 
child, a real person who has been tragically and, oftentimes, 
life-alteringly abused.
 [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the 
record.]
 Chair Hawley. And it's the conviction of myself and, I 
know, Senator Durbin and, I hope, every Member of--not just 
this Subcommittee but the entire Senate Judiciary Committee, 
that we have to do something about this.
 We've talked about it for years. The time to take 
definitive action is here. And that's why the legislative 
framework that we are discussing today I think is so incredibly 
important.
 But let me just give you a sense of the scope of the 
problem that we're talking about. Worldwide, 302 million 
children have been victims of child sexual abuse material and 
child sexual exploitation online. Let me say that again. 
Worldwide, 302 million children. Three hundred million 
children, globally, have been subjected to online solicitation, 
solicitation that is for some sort of sexual abuse or following 
some sort of sexual abuse.
 To give you another angle on the scope of this problem, 
when an online platform becomes aware of instances of child 
sexual exploitation, under our law they're required to report 
those instances to the National Center for Missing & Exploited 
Children, NCMEC--their CyberTipline. And we're delighted to 
have the CEO of NCMEC with us today. But just consider this 
data: In 2014, the number of reported instances of online child 
sexual exploitation--in 2014--was 1.1 million.
 Now, that's a staggering number, but consider where it is 
today. In 2023, the year for which we have the most recent full 
data, that number was 36.2 million--1.1 million in 2014, 36.2 
million reports of online child sexual exploitation in 2023.
 And the number of urgent reports--those are cases where the 
child is thought to be at present risk, you might say clear and 
present danger, that number has grown by 140 percent in just 
the last 3 years.
 If you think about the images themselves, the poster behind 
me gives you some sense of this. Back in 2004, there were 
450,000 images reported online of child sexual abuse material. 
Again, that number in itself is huge. Nothing like what we're 
seeing today. The number today tops 104 million known reported 
images of child sexual abuse online.
 This is truly a crisis. It is an epidemic. And it's not a 
theory. It affects far too many children in the United States 
of America, to say nothing of the--as we've seen--hundreds of 
millions of children worldwide. So, the question is: What are 
we going to do about it? And that's what we're here to talk 
about today.
 Senator Durbin and I, in the last Congress, introduced what 
I believe is truly landmark legislation, which, I might add, 
passed the Senate Judiciary Committee, in what is nothing short 
of a miracle, by a unanimous vote.
 This legislation would protect child victims and witnesses 
in courts with new rights, new safeguards, new procedures. It 
would expand the scope of restitution provisions in current 
law. It would enhance the CyberTipline. It would create a Child 
Online Protection Board, to allow parents and victims to go and 
argue their case to have material taken down and to receive 
restitution.
 And, for my money, maybe most importantly, it would allow 
victims finally to have their day in court. It would allow 
victims to get into court and to bring suit against online 
platforms that are hosting this material and making money on 
it--which brings me to the culpability of Big Tech.
 You know, Big Tech has said for years, oh, we're doing all 
we can, but we know--because we've heard the testimony from 
folks who have sat right where our distinguished witnesses are 
sitting today.
 We've heard the testimony of parents who have gone to the 
Big Tech companies, have reported instances of child sexual 
abuse material online, including victims who reported their own 
abuse material--that I was abused, these are my images online, 
please take them down. The Big Tech companies often will fob 
them off on some complicated procedure that never bears any 
fruit--or just flat-out refuse to do anything.
 And I'll never forget the testimony of one mother who sat 
right there at that table and said, when I told this tech 
company--it was Snapchat, in that instance--when I told them 
about the sexual abuse material that was online, they just 
laughed at me and said, there's nothing that you can do. You 
can't sue us.
 Well, ladies and gentlemen, it's time to change that. It is 
time to allow victims to have their day in court.
 One of the most important foundational rights that we have 
as Americans is the right to get into court, to get in front of 
a jury, and to vindicate the personal rights given to us by our 
Constitution, by our systems of law--by our system of laws, 
and, dare I say, by nature and nature's God. And that right is 
currently denied to parents and victims in this country. You 
can't sue these platforms. They're protected by congressional 
legislation.
 It's time to change that. This bill would finally allow 
victims to have their day in court. And guess what? The Big 
Tech companies absolutely hate it. They despise it. Which is 
how you know it's a good idea. In fact, it's how you know it's 
essential.
 Listen, I will never forget watching the FTC, some years 
ago, fine Facebook at the time. I think it was a billion 
dollars. Maybe it was even more than that. What happened to 
Facebook's stock price the next day? It went up. They didn't 
care. Did they change their behavior? No. Did they do anything 
different? No. They just plowed straight ahead.
 But you know what these tech companies fear? They fear 
accountability before a jury of their peers. They fear a 
courtroom. They don't want to be accountable in court. They 
don't want victims, they don't want parents to have the right 
to sue them in an open court. They don't want to be held liable 
civilly, fairly. They don't want to be subject to due process.
 It is time to make them subject. It is time to impose civil 
liability. It's time to give victims this right. And that is 
what this bill would do, among the other important procedural 
safeguards and reforms that I mentioned just a moment ago.
 I want to thank everybody who's here in attendance. We have 
so many folks here from child protection organizations, so many 
of you who work in this field who are literally in the trenches 
every day, protecting children. Thank you for your incredible 
work, and thank you to our incredible witnesses who have joined 
us today. It's truly an all-star panel.
 And now let me introduce the witnesses. When Senator Durbin 
gets here, when the witnesses are finished, we'll allow him to 
make a statement. But let me introduce our witnesses, and then 
we'll have the opportunity to hear from each of them.
 We have Michelle DeLaune, who is the president and chief 
executive officer of the National Center for Missing & 
Exploited Children. She previously served 8 years as NCMEC's 
chief operating officer. We're delighted to have you, Ms. 
DeLaune.
 We've got John Tanagho, who is the executive director of 
the International Justice Mission's Center to End Online Sexual 
Exploitation of Children. The Center protects children in the 
Philippines, where nearly half a million children are sexually 
abused in order to produce this online CSAM material. This 
happens especially through livestreaming, and I think Mr. 
Tanagho will testify to that effect today.
 We have Gregory Schiller, who is the CEO of the Child 
Rescue Coalition. This is a nonprofit organization that rescues 
children from sexual abuse by building technology for law 
enforcement to identify and arrest and prosecute child 
predators. Thank you, Mr. Schiller, for being here.
 Taylor Sines, who is a survivor advocate--we're so glad to 
have you, Taylor. Specifically, Taylor is a survivor of 
internet-facilitated online enticement, child sexual 
exploitation, and CSAM. Her case was one of the largest online 
enticement sextortion cases prosecuted at the time, with over 
300 victims--300 victims of the convicted perpetrator.
 And we have John Pizzuro, who is the CEO and co-founder of 
Raven, a firm that focuses on legislative and policy solutions 
for child trafficking and child exploitation. Previously, John 
spent 25 years in the New Jersey State Police conducting, 
managing, and leading investigations in terrorism and organized 
crime, narcotics trafficking, and child exploitation. He spent 
his last 6 years as the Internet Crimes Against Children 
commander.
 Now, it's the custom of this Committee and Subcommittee to 
swear in our witnesses when they appear, so if I could ask each 
of you to rise and to raise your right hand, and then we'll get 
started.
 [Witnesses are sworn in.]
 Chair Hawley. Fantastic. Let's give the witnesses a chance 
now to make opening statements. Ms. DeLaune, we'll start with 
you, and then we'll just go down the panel. Thank you for being 
here. The floor is yours.

 STATEMENT OF MICHELLE DELAUNE, CEO, NATIONAL

 CENTER FOR MISSING & EXPLOITED CHILDREN,

 ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA

 Ms. DeLaune. Thank you so much. And good afternoon, 
Chairman Hawley, Ranking Member Durbin, and the Members of the 
Subcommittee. My name is Michelle DeLaune, and I am the 
president and CEO at the National Center for Missing & 
Exploited Children.
 NCMEC is a nonprofit organization created in 1984 by child 
advocates to help find missing children, reduce child sexual 
exploitation, and prevent child victimization. And I'm honored 
to be here today to share NCMEC's perspective on the need for 
the STOP CSAM Act.
 When NCMEC testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee 
2 years ago, we advised that we had reached an inflection point 
in our Nation's efforts to combat online child sexual 
exploitation.
 We have now passed the inflection point. But we have not 
missed the opportunity to work together to pass legislation to 
require meaningful and enhanced reporting by online platforms, 
to create meaningful incentives for these companies to ensure 
their platforms protect children from predators, and to support 
survivors.
 As the congressionally designated clearinghouse on issues 
related to child sexual exploitation, NCMEC remains at the 
forefront of the emerging threats that impact child safety 
online.
 Today, we're witnessing evolving threats in child sexual 
exploitation with the emergence of generative artificial 
intelligence technologies; online enticement, including 
sextortion; and a recent spike of violent online groups that 
have resulted in some of the most egregious online enticement 
reports that we've seen to date.
 For more than 25 years, the CyberTipline has served as the 
online mechanism for members of the public and electronic 
service providers to report incidents of suspected child sexual 
exploitation.
 Last year, we saw an unprecedented drop in CyberTipline 
reports submitted to NCMEC--in 2023, we received 36.2 million 
reports. Last year, we received 20.5 million reports.
 Now, some of this decrease can be explained by a new 
feature that we introduced, allowing tech platforms to bundle 
related reports. We view this as a positive development, as it 
streamlines the reporting process and enables law enforcement 
and NCMEC to more quickly address high priority cases.
 So, when we adjust for the bundled reports, we see that 
29.2 million incidents of child sexual exploitation were 
submitted to the CyberTipline last year.
 But that still leaves us with the 7 million decrease in 
reports, and that's a remarkable decline in reporting, 
particularly in a year when Congress, supported by many Members 
of this Subcommittee, passed the REPORT Act that mandates that 
platforms report child sex trafficking and online enticement 
for the first time.
 While we continue to analyze the drop in incidents, we 
believe that there are three contributing factors.
 Number one, NCMEC worked with Meta to remove a handful of 
images from their hash bank and its reporting process that 
violated Meta's terms of service but did not constitute child 
sexual abuse material. We estimate that that may account for a 
decrease of up to 200,000 reports.
 Number two, for unknown reasons, several online platforms 
with a history of consistent reporting to the CyberTipline 
submitted far fewer reports in 2024. The platforms included 
Google, X, Discord, Microsoft, Synchronoss--all of which 
reported at least 20 percent fewer reports last year than the 
year prior.
 And, number three, we believe that Facebook Messenger's 
full implementation of the end-to-end encryption significantly 
contributed to the 7 million drop in the reports in 2024.
 So, while we're deeply concerned by the decline, 
particularly in a year with the REPORT Act, which should have 
increased the incident volume, we are equally concerned about 
the inconsistent and poor quality of reports being submitted by 
many platforms.
 So, moving forward, things must change.
 NCMEC supports the passage of legislative improvements in 
the STOP CSAM Act to require platforms to include specific 
information in their CyberTipline reports; to require that 
online platforms report imminent and planned child sexual 
exploitation crimes; to require online platforms to issue 
annual transparency reports related to their child protection 
efforts; to establish a report-and-remove program to make it 
easier for survivors to have their images removed; and, to 
improve the privacy protections and safeguarding when a child 
must participate in a Federal court proceeding.
 I want to thank you, again, for the opportunity to appear 
before the Subcommittee to discuss the need for the STOP CSAM 
Act. Each individual provision of this bill will significantly 
support survivors of online child sexual exploitation, and we 
encourage the Committee to ensure that the bill's provisions 
pass Congress this year.
 Like you, we believe that every child deserves a safe 
childhood. And I thank you and look forward to answering any 
questions you might have.
 [The prepared statement of Ms. DeLaune appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much, Ms. DeLaune, for being 
here. Mr. Tanagho.

 STATEMENT OF JOHN TANAGHO, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR,

 CENTER TO END ONLINE SEXUAL EXPLOITATION

 OF CHILDREN, INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE MISSION,

 WASHINGTON, DC

 Mr. Tanagho. Chairman Hawley, Ranking Member Durbin, and 
Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for inviting me to 
testify at this important hearing. I work for International 
Justice Mission, a nongovernment organization protecting people 
in poverty from violence in 19 countries.
 For 27 years, IJM has strengthened justice systems to hold 
traffickers and violent offenders accountable, support 
survivors on their journey to safety and healing, and reduce 
the prevalence of violent crimes by up to 86 percent.
 I spent 7 years overseas leading teams to combat what the 
Department of Justice calls ``virtual child sex trafficking.''
 This is the in-person sexual abuse of children to create 
new CSAM while offenders, often Americans, watch and direct the 
abuse online in real time through livestreaming.
 It's pay-per-view CSAM. According to our research, nearly 
half a million children are sex trafficked in this way in the 
Philippines alone.
 Make no mistake, though, this is an American problem.
 One IJM study found 34 percent of cases involved U.S. 
offenders. Another study found that in an 18-month period, 
individuals in the United States sent over $7.3 million to the 
Philippines in payments that were flagged by financial 
institutions as suspicious transactions for child exploitation.
 And a quick search online reveals that Americans in all 10 
States represented on this Subcommittee have been convicted for 
sexually abusing children online, including in the Philippines.
 Now, I think what's important to note is that even when the 
offenders are here and the livestreaming victims are overseas, 
American kids--the threat to American kids from these offenders 
is very real.
 And that's because offenders who consume CSAM are more 
likely to abuse children in person. Research shows that 
livestreaming offenders pose an even greater risk, because 
they've arguably crossed the psychological barrier to contact 
offend by directing live sexual abuse of a child.
 So, if we want to make America safer, we should invest in 
holding livestreaming offenders accountable. But to do that, we 
need companies to prioritize the safety and privacy of victims 
and survivors by expediting detection, reporting, and removal 
of CSAM.
 At the same time, the sheer scale of child sexual abuse 
online requires that companies make it harder for criminals to 
abuse kids in the first place by making their products and 
their services safe by design, and using tools and measures to 
disrupt these active crime scenes.
 Today, livestreaming is a major source of new CSAM. And 
that's why Congress should pass laws that incentivize companies 
to disrupt and deter both the production and the distribution 
of CSAM, including in live videos.
 Now, 2 weeks ago, Australia's online safety regulator had 
this to say on Australian national radio, quote, ``There are a 
range of markers or signals they can look at. They all have 
technologies that they can use to identify whether child sexual 
abuse is happening in real time. Most companies have said 
they're doing nothing, because it's too expensive. These are 
trillion-dollar companies that have a responsibility to make 
sure that their platforms are not misused for the most grievous 
kinds of harm. Willful blindness, as I would call it,'' end 
quote.
 Now, the previous version of the STOP CSAM Act proposed 
several important policies. IJM's work with thousands of 
survivors reveals that access to restitution is a critical 
piece to recovery and a vital form of justice. It is tangible 
recognition of the harm done to them.
 But oftentimes the parents of child victims are complicit 
in their abuse, and survivors may not have a bank account to 
receive and manage restitution. That's why court-appointed 
trustees are so important. They can ensure that survivors 
receive the compensation they deserve, regardless of their age 
or where they live.
 Moreover, enhanced CyberTipline report requirements will 
ensure that providers provide enough information so law 
enforcement can identify and locate victims and suspects. And 
the reporting requirements will finally help policymakers and 
the American public know what companies are or are not doing to 
address CSAM.
 Finally, survivors should have recourse to require 
companies to remove their CSAM online. I think that the notice 
and takedown framework should also require that once companies 
are on notice of this CSAM that they should take effective 
steps to prevent the republication or uploading of that same 
CSAM on their platforms.
 Now is the time for Congress to act. I look forward to your 
questions. Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Tanagho appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much. Mr. Schiller.
 [Voice heard off microphone.]
 Chair Hawley. Mr. Schiller, is your microphone on? It's the 
red--there you go.
 Mr. Schiller. I knew I was going to do----
 Chair Hawley. There it is. It's----
 Mr. Schiller [continuing]. I knew I was going to do that. 
Sorry.
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. Oh, it's good. You're good.
 Mr. Schiller. Let me start again.

 STATEMENT OF GREGORY SCHILLER, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, CHILD 
 RESCUE COALITION, BOCA RATON, FLORIDA

 Mr. Schiller. Good afternoon, Chairman Hawley, Ranking 
Member Durbin, distinguished Senators of this Committee. Thank 
you for the invitation and opportunity to speak here today.
 My name is Greg Schiller. I am the CEO of the Child Rescue 
Coalition. The Child Rescue Coalition is a nonprofit 
organization that rescues children from sexual abuse by 
building technology for law enforcement, free of charge, to 
identify, arrest, and prosecute child predators.
 Headquartered in Boca Raton, Florida, we developed powerful 
technology which has been a significant tool for law 
enforcement around the globe, now utilized in 106 countries. 
Our technology has improved the success rates of investigators 
and policing operations in the ongoing pursuit to identify, 
apprehend, and convict individuals and networks associated with 
child sexual exploitation.
 I have the great honor of leading an incredible team of 
technologists, programmers, and developers being supported by a 
dedicated board of directors, all of whom have the same goal 
and one mission: to end child exploitation around the world.
 Prior to my recent beginning as CEO of the Child Rescue 
Coalition, I was a career prosecutor for more than 21 years. In 
fact, it is the only other job I have had since law school--
first as a State attorney in Palm Beach County for 12 years and 
then as an assistant United States attorney in the Southern 
District of Florida for the past 9 years.
 I have specialized in prosecuting violations of online 
child exploitation and human trafficking, convicting more than 
350 online offenders during that time. But no matter how many 
predators I acquired lengthy prison sentences for, more and 
more children are being victimized online.
 In the safest of our homes across the United States, 
parents do everything to protect their families. They lock 
their doors, video surveillance, security systems. Our State 
and local police, fueled by the Internet Crimes Against 
Children Task Forces, Homeland Security, the FBI, U.S. 
Marshals, and other Federal agencies, do everything within 
their power and budgets to protect our children.
 But despite all of this, more and more children are falling 
victim to online predators every day.
 Two things must be done: one reactive and one proactive.
 First, as this body is well aware and aims to do, we must 
continue to pass legislation that will protect victims of 
online sexual abuse. Congress has provided us the tools, 
through violations primarily listed in Chapter 110 and 117 of 
the United States Criminal Code, related to enticement of 
minors; production, advertising, transmission, distribution, 
receipt, and possession of CSAM; and related offenses of 
sextortion and livestreaming.
 But all too often, the most--the most devious offenders 
find new ways to use the internet and technology to exploit our 
children. We are reacting to the ever-changing landscape, 
plugging new holes as they develop--gaps the STOP CSAM Act aims 
to fill.
 But secondarily, and just as importantly, we just 
proactively educate our children on the inherent dangers of the 
internet, social media, apps, and online gaming. As the Greek 
philosopher Socrates famously noted, you don't know what you 
don't know. And, frankly, our children have no idea how 
dangerous the world is.
 Never before in the history of mankind has a place existed 
where children and adults can engage in a space without any 
supervision or protection. The internet, apps, and online games 
provide that space.
 But it is not our children's fault, because they don't know 
what they don't know. And although parents try their best to 
protect their children, there is not one amongst us over the 
age of 30 that knows what it's like to be a child with a 
smartphone and communicating through apps. The social and 
emotional pressures are so immense that children are afraid to 
tell their parents when they're being harmed, for fear of 
losing that single device that was the gateway of their 
problems. We must do more.
 That is why, for years, I, and the Child Rescue Coalition, 
have partnered with the National Center to teach tens of 
thousands of children and parents about the dangers they face. 
Yet there are so many prosecutors and police who can take their 
experiences and are brave enough to face a room of eighth 
graders. It's no easy task.
 The internet was created without the thought of child 
protection. It has grown by exponential bounds. Our Government, 
law enforcement, and citizens of this country are trying to 
play catch-up. We have been playing catch-up for more than 40 
years, since the ARPANET, the precursor to the internet, was 
developed. And it seems like every day a new app or variety of 
child exploitation comes online.
 For example, I recently prosecuted a network of child 
pornographers--excuse me, child exploiters who were using the 
dark web. They created, ran, and brought together thousands of 
members to exchange sinister, painful, and evil CSAM--the worst 
I've ever seen in my career. Those individuals received decades 
upon decades in prison, and one received life in prison.
 But what safeguards are there for a child who finds their 
way onto the dark web? None.
 Or the case of Robert Solove, who, in 2021 I prosecuted--
and created CSAM of an 18-month-old child in his care, in Boca 
Raton, Florida, in his home, and shared the images through an 
app to other individuals, including an undercover HSI agent.
 The child was, thankfully, rescued by HSI and the Palm 
Beach County Sheriff's Office.
 Solove also developed an online relationship with a 13-
year-old girl in a different State. He directed her to produce 
CSAM images and videos herself and send them to him through a 
different app.
 If that wasn't enough, he collected CSAM of other children 
from several internet platforms and stored them on his cell 
phone.
 While prosecuting this case, although we obtained a 50-year 
prison sentence for Solove, we also petitioned the court to 
appoint a guardian ad litem for each of the child victims, 
something that this Act aims to help do; hired an expert to 
calculate restitution; and was able to obtain an order of 
restitution of $1.3 million for those children.
 But I would be remiss if I did not remind this body that 
for each of these monsters who prey on our children, there are 
police officers and Federal agents who put their lives on the 
line every single day to protect these vulnerable victims. They 
push the limits of their sanity as they converse with predators 
online in chat rooms. They put their safety in jeopardy every 
time they execute warrants to find evidence against such 
predators.
 Some, as we know far too well in south Florida, pay the 
ultimate sacrifice, when just 49 months ago, two FBI agents 
were murdered executing a CSAM search warrant. Three others 
were injured.
 Whether it is social media apps like Snapchat or Instagram 
or online games, our children are being lured by enticers, 
online CSAM producers, and sextortionists to encrypted 
applications to commit their crimes and turn children against 
their families, in some instances.
 As a prosecutor, I fought to take down predators one at a 
time, protecting victims one at a time. And now, as the CEO of 
the Child Rescue Coalition, we aim to help law enforcement 
around the globe proactively fight against online child 
exploitation, stop child sexual abuse, and aid in the rescuing 
of children.
 The STOP CSAM Act that this body is hearing about today and 
has put forward provides so many needed stopgaps that Federal 
prosecutors will be able to utilize in combating child 
exploitation and protecting victims. Just a few examples.
 The amendment to Title 18 United States Code Sec. 3509(m) 
has previously hindered our ability to work with victims of 
CSAM in their civil pursuits. As currently written, that law 
gives the victims the right to review their images in law 
enforcement custody during, quote, ``any criminal proceeding.'' 
This has been interpreted as when the criminal charges are 
filed until the judgment is entered at sentencing.
 But in most cases, victims are not notified of their images 
in a criminal prosecution until just before or even after 
sentencing, when restitution is being sought on their behalf. 
STOP CSAM extends the time to review, to give victims and their 
civil attorneys the time and opportunity to more appropriately 
pursue civil remedies against criminal defendants by a year.
 STOP CSAM creates a much needed appropriation to the 
judiciary for the guardian ad litem program under 3509(h). Many 
times, our victims are violated by their parents or caregivers, 
as we've already heard. And, similarly, the STOP CSAM provides 
structure and funding for the judiciary to appoint trustees to 
manage victim restitution for minors, incapacitated victims, 
and foreign-born victims.
 With livestreaming cases rising to a never-before-seen 
level, this will give us the tools to protect both American and 
foreign-born children.
 STOP CSAM will require tech platforms to provide more 
information to NCMEC within a specific period. Too often, by 
the time the information reaches law enforcement and 
prosecutors, the offender has obfuscated their account or even 
moved from the residence they committed the act from, impeding 
law enforcement's abilities to stop, to act on the violation.
 STOP CSAM mandates a commonsense reporting requirement to 
the tech platforms so that law enforcement can protect our 
children. STOP CSAM will hold them accountable, including 
criminal liability on tech platforms who intentionally host or 
store or knowingly promote or facilitate online exploitation of 
a child.
 This is parallel to the related criminal statutes that I've 
prosecuted under. From my experience and perspective as a 
former assistant U.S. attorney, I pray that this body has the 
courage to say, ``No more'' to child exploitation of children.
 Place the stopgaps where they are needed in law that exists 
to protect our children.
 Give law enforcement the tools they need to fight back, 
while at the same time encouraging schools, parents, and 
community organizations to please educate our children 
regarding the dangers of the internet.
 And on behalf of myself and the Child Rescue Coalition, I 
thank you for the opportunity and look forward to your 
questions today.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Schiller appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Schiller. Thank you. 
Ms. Sines.

 STATEMENT OF TAYLOR SINES,
 SURVIVOR ADVOCATE, MARYLAND

 Ms. Sines. Thank you, Chairman Hawley and Ranking Member 
Durbin, and all of the other Senators on this Subcommittee. I 
am in front of you today during a time that will go down as a 
pivotal moment in fighting to protect our youth online.
 I was a freshman in high school in 2014 when I was 
approached by an online predator. He used the platform Facebook 
to first contact me and hid behind the account name called, 
``Closed Turn.''
 I remember that night. I was at TGI Fridays having dinner 
with my family. On the car ride home is when I opened the 
messages. He had stated that I had to get in contact with him. 
He immediately said that it was very important.
 At first, I ignored the messages. But he would only send 
more. I replied to the message, asking who this was, and they 
responded back, saying, I have something against you. You don't 
want anyone to see this. He had stated that he could not tell 
me what it was or who he had gotten it from. He told me that I 
couldn't tell anyone.
 He tricked me, making me believe that he already had 
compromising photos of me. In my teenaged brain, I panicked, 
and I thought I had no other choice but to comply with his 
orders. So, I did what I was told, and this began the torment 
that I endured.
 Despite his warnings not to tell anyone, I immediately 
disclosed to my school resource officer as soon as I got to 
school. He told me that there was nothing that he could do for 
me and to just ignore it and it would go away. He said that he 
couldn't help me in any way, even making me feel ashamed. He 
had no resources. He said he knew no one.
 After that, I thought there was nothing that anyone could 
do, especially because my school resource officer was a deputy 
from my local sheriff's department. If he's telling me that 
there is no one there to help, then it has to be true.
 After suffering for 2 years, I finally decided to take my 
voice back and share that I was being abused. The offender made 
good on his promises and took to Facebook to exploit me. He 
rapidly posted the hundreds of images and videos of me, making 
public pages and user accounts for more leverage. They were 
posted for the world to see.
 At that point, my family and I knew that we had to get law 
enforcement involved. We called 911, we explained what was 
happening, as my offender continued to post online.
 When an officer got to my house, we explained the 
situation, and I remember him looking at me and saying, look, 
I'm just a road deputy. I don't know much about this stuff. At 
this point, I had lost any hope that there was help. I had lost 
all hope that anyone even believed me.
 After a moment, he looked at me and he said, but I do know 
someone who may be able to help. Not much long after the phone 
call, there was a knock at my door--a detective who worked 
cybersecurity for the same department my school resource 
officer was from.
 As the detective and I sat in my kitchen and I shared my 
experience with him, he was on the phone with personnel from 
Facebook, attempting to get the content removed. We were told 
that the profiles, public pages, and content would not be taken 
down, as it did not violate their guidelines--guidelines that 
most companies still do not have in place. That was April of 
2016.
 It took time, and as we built connections within these 
platforms, we were able to get the content down within a few 
hours of the original postings, versus it taking a day or maybe 
a little bit longer to be taken off the platform.
 You have to understand, every minute, every second is 
filled with fear and anxiety for these victims. I consider 
myself lucky. Lucky that, in the end, I found a law enforcement 
agent who listened to me and who believed me. Lucky that my 
local State attorney offered a helping hand and, together, they 
set me up immediately with a trauma therapist. Lucky that they 
didn't give up. And it's because of their hard work that I get 
to sit in front of you today.
 I have connected with other survivors throughout the years, 
and I can tell you that my experience is rare. Not every victim 
has the same positive outcomes that I did. It took time from 
when I disclosed in April of 2016 to get to sentencing for my 
offender. He was eventually tracked down, as he masked his IP 
address, and arrested August 3 of 2017.
 From 2017 to 2021 was a back-and-forth of whether or not 
there would be a trial, or maybe we would get lucky and he 
would plead guilty. Finally, he pled guilty March 12, 2021. 
Four years ago from tomorrow is the day that he was sentenced 
to 75 years in Federal prison with no chance of parole. At the 
time of his sentencing, he had 375 other victims.
 The unique, unconsidered aspect of this crime is that we 
are trafficked right from our homes, right from our schools, 
from our communities. Anywhere that our cell phone goes with 
us, we can be trafficked.
 For these children, it feels that there is no escape and no 
end. While I no longer have content circulating the public web 
or any public platforms, my images could continue to be traded 
on the dark web. And what happens if they're ever publicly 
posted again?
 The STOP CSAM Act that is currently being considered will 
help ensure the safety of our children online and hold Big Tech 
accountable in reporting and protecting them while they use 
their platforms. The victim protections outlined in this bill 
will help others have a more positive experience with the 
criminal justice system overall.
 This bill could help give victims and survivors the 
opportunity to take back their lives and protect them from 
further victimization.
 Throughout my experience, I learned that this happened to 
me, not because of me, and it does not define me. Please help 
us continue the fight to protect our children online. Thank you 
for this opportunity.
 [The prepared statement of Ms. Sines appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much. Thank you, Ms. Sines, 
for that powerful testimony. Thanks for your courage in sharing 
it. Mr. Pizzuro.

 STATEMENT OF JOHN PIZZURO, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, RAVEN, 
 IRVING, TEXAS

 Mr. Pizzuro. Chairman Hawley, Ranking Member Durbin, and 
distinguished Members of the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee, 
thank you for the opportunity to testify today for the STOP 
CSAM Act.
 For me, there's no more pressing issue than safeguarding 
our children and helping those on the front lines who protect 
our children--so much so that Raven was created with the 
singular mission of transforming the Nation's response to child 
exploitation.
 I spent 25 years in the New Jersey State Police, and I can 
confidently tell you that this legislation will positively 
impact our ability to arrest more offenders and protect more 
victims.
 Many child victims of sexual abuse and CSAM do not report 
their abuse until they're adults, and the changes provided in 
this bill will allow them to have the support they need and 
deserve. Walking into a courtroom to testify on any topic 
intimidates most people--even testifying here today.
 Now, imagine having to do that in front of your abuser, as 
someone who's suffered unimaginable crimes at their hands. They 
deserve our best protection.
 They also deserve privacy. Since co-founding Raven, I've 
talked to survivors whose personal information was exposed to 
discovery in criminal and civil cases. Their online abusers 
were then able to find this information and use it to 
traumatize their victims all over again.
 Simply redacting their names is oftentimes not enough to 
protect them. STOP CSAM provides language that will allow law 
enforcement and prosecutors to protect them from being further 
victimized for their entire life.
 This bill would require providers to report apparent, 
planned, and imminent violations. Platforms often detect 
grooming behavior or other signs of a child in distress. Still, 
they have total discretion to decide whether or not to report 
information about planned or imminent offenses. This revised 
language will undoubtedly result in saving children from abuse 
before it happens. As a former ICAC Commander, I can say our 
best day is when we rescue a child before they are abused.
 Tech platforms are only required to send a report when they 
are aware of a specified violation. However, only the 
information that must be contained is the provider's contact 
information. That's it.
 Providers can, in their sole discretion, include 
information about the facts and circumstances of the apparent 
violation. There is no required information or uniformity. 
You've heard the statement, ``Garbage in and garbage out'' ? In 
many instances, that's what we get.
 Some providers even submit blank reports, which is all they 
currently need to do to comply with their legal obligations. 
These platforms often possess much information on a particular 
offender or account and simply choose not to report it. This 
type of reporting frustrates law enforcement, as it is often 
impossible to act on and begin investigation. We can no longer 
trust them to submit what is needed, when so many do the bare 
minimum required.
 As online child exploitation is getting worse, law 
enforcement's ability to respond is hindered by inadequate 
reporting from the tech industry. STOP CSAM would require the 
provider to submit limited additional data in its reports.
 These added requirements would provide law enforcement with 
much more information than they currently receive. They would 
likely result in quicker prioritization of leads, actionable 
investigations, and more arrests and prosecutions--and, 
undoubtedly, the protection of more victims.
 Raven is here to provide expertise based upon their real-
life experience in the field. We are here to support 
legislative solutions that are desperately needed. Law 
enforcement simply cannot do more with less. They desperately 
need your help and that crucial legislation be passed.
 The STOP CSAM Act would make meaningful changes that will 
better protect victims, support law enforcement, and promote 
transparency and accountability, the most important thing in 
the tech industry.
 The STOP CSAM Act was first introduced 2 years ago. How 
many children have fallen victim to online child exploitation 
since--while the bill is being held by those who refuse to 
compromise and insist on politically divisive changes? I just 
cannot understand how anyone would be in favor of having no 
legislation at all, leaving our children at risk if they cannot 
get the exact legislation they want.
 I just want to simply--and Raven simply wants to protect 
our children and those who defend them. That's why I implore 
you to have STOP CSAM passed. Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Pizzuro appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Pizzuro. Thank you, 
again, to all of our witnesses.
 Let's start the questioning. And, Mr. Tanagho, I want to 
start with something that you said about these companies and 
your experience.
 You said that they often complain that it's just too 
expensive to take any sort of enforcement action or deterrence 
action. Could you just elaborate on that? I mean, what's been 
your experience when working with these major platforms that 
often are hosting the streaming that you were talking about, 
for example?
 Mr. Tanagho. Well, the quote that I referenced comes from 
Julie Inman Grant, Australia's eSafety Commissioner. And 
thankfully, Australia has had a robust Online Safety Act, and 
regulatory powers for several years now, and so eSafety has 
been engaging with tech companies to understand what are they 
doing to address CSAM, what are they not doing?
 I think one of the most powerful things was in 2022, when 
eSafety published summaries of transparency notice responses. 
And specific to the question of what were companies doing to 
address livestream child sexual abuse, almost all of them said, 
nothing. They weren't detecting it. They weren't disrupting it. 
They weren't reporting it.
 And I think that quote comes from her continual engagement 
with these companies to try to understand why. Why would you 
ever look the other way, when there's an active crime scene 
happening on your platform, through your services, and you have 
the technology to detect it in real time? And so apparently 
what she has been told is, it's too expensive--which tells me 
that their priorities are absolutely backward.
 Chair Hawley. What a great way to put it. They are 
absolutely backward. And I want to just highlight what you said 
there--that the companies complain frequently that, oh, it's 
just too expensive for us.
 They're not disrupting, they're not detecting, they're not 
deterring. And yet in 2023, Meta had a profit--now, profit--not 
revenues, profits of $23 billion. Google: $60 billion in 
profits in 1 year. Apple: $97 billion in profits. Amazon: $27 
billion in profits.
 So, don't tell me that they don't have the wherewithal 
financially to disrupt, detect, and report. They absolutely do. 
The truth is, they don't want to do it. And right now, they're 
really not compelled to do it.
 I want to show everybody a picture of a young girl. This is 
a profile of what is a young woman who's clearly underage. You 
can just hold it up, yes. Let's have a look at this.
 [Poster is displayed.]
 Chair Hawley. So, here is what appears to be the picture of 
a young girl whose birthday, by the way, indicated that she was 
a minor. Now, the thing about this girl is, it's fake.
 The New Mexico Attorney General created this profile as 
part of that office's investigation into the behavior of these 
online platforms. So, they create a profile with a date of 
birth that clearly indicates she is a minor, she is underage.
 And what does she get from this Facebook profile? What does 
she get?
 She was immediately barraged with ``friend requests'' from 
men between the ages of 18 to 40--request after request uses 
sexually aggressive languages. This account received numerous 
sexually explicit chat messages each week, often with images, 
sexually explicit images, from the men who were messaging 
``her.''
 The account received an offer to be a ``sugar baby'' for 
$5,000 a week. The account was added to a chat group focused on 
cultivating young girls between the ages of 12 and 16 for 
sexual exploitation.
 And, get this, this girl was also--this profile was also 
served up Instagram video content featuring other young girls 
between the ages of 13 and 16. Meaning what?
 Meaning that Facebook's own algorithm knew she was 
underage, knew that there was sexual exploitation, and sexually 
suggestive messages happening back and forth. The algorithm 
knew that and served up additional sexually exploitative 
content.
 The girl was also served an Instagram advertisement for a 
law firm representing trafficking survivors. The ultimate 
irony.
 Now, of course, if this girl had really existed, could she 
have brought suit against Facebook? Not a chance. The law 
currently prevents it.
 And yet Facebook's own algorithm--they own Instagram--
Facebook's own algorithm recognizes her as underage, recognizes 
the child sexual abuse content going on, recognizes that she 
may be a victim of child sexual abuse, and therefore sends her 
referrals for attorneys who work in this space.
 What should that tell us? Their algorithms are absolutely 
capable of identifying potentially sexually abusive material; 
totally capable of identifying when there is potential grooming 
going on; and yet they say--Mr. Tanagho, as you said, they say 
all the time, oh, we just don't have the resources to do it.
 In fact, what they want to do is monetize people like this. 
They benefit, currently, financially from sexual exploitation.
 And this is why it is so important--it is so important to 
allow victims, actual victims--thank goodness this girl--this 
girl doesn't exist. But there are literally millions like her, 
as you know from your own experience, Ms. Sines--millions like 
her, who do, who are being exploited, sadly, as we sit here 
today in this Committee room, who feel as if they have no 
recourse.
 And, sadly, under our current law, they have very little 
recourse. It's time to give victims like this the right to get 
into court.
 Ms. DeLaune, can I just ask you--you have so much 
experience in this area. In your view, what is the role that 
the technology platforms, the online platforms--what role do 
they have in deterring and disrupting and reporting this kind 
of abuse? And why is it important to require them to do more 
than they currently are?
 Ms. DeLaune. Thank you. It's interesting. I think, as you 
were talking also about what we learned from the Australian 
eSafety Commissioner, it goes to also a provision within the 
STOP CSAM Act about transparency reports.
 We're spending a lot of time trying to identify where 
there's a decrease in reports, what happened.
 So much we have learned from what they are telling us from 
Australia is something that we would be able to take out, the 
transparency. What are these companies doing that is allowing 
this to happen? Are they detecting? Are they reporting? Where 
are they getting their information? How long are they holding? 
What types of reports are they getting from victims, from the 
public?
 At this point, we don't know. It's actually remarkable how 
much we do know, when you consider this is entirely voluntary. 
Besides when there is a known violation of apparent child 
pornography, sex trafficking, or online enticement--at that 
point, it triggers a report. Other than that, this is all just 
based on relationships and meeting the right person and finding 
out what they're doing.
 It's not going to work any longer. We're seeing that. The 
voluntary structure of how the companies are making decisions 
without any sort of transparency so we understand what they're 
doing and what they're not doing--it won't last any longer.
 We're seeing the drops, and, at this point, more 
companies--we're talking about the drop in reports. More 
companies can simply make different business choices. The 
reports will go away. The incidents are not going away. We're 
just being blinded to them.
 Chair Hawley. And that's why it's so important that we 
strengthen these reporting requirements, as we----
 Ms. DeLaune. Absolutely. Absolutely.
 You know, one of the examples that I have in the testimony 
was regarding two offenders who were ganging up on a young 
girl, forcing her to produce awful, horrific child sexual abuse 
content. We sent that report to law enforcement.
 We called out this weekend to find out what happened. You 
had two law enforcement agencies in two States serving multiple 
subpoenas, exigent subpoenas, trying to find that victim. Can't 
find the victim and don't know what happened, because enough 
information was not provided at the moment they made that 
report. We need more details. If a report has been triggered, 
we need more details so law enforcement can actually protect 
children.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you so much. Senator Blackburn.
 Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to 
each of you for taking the time to be here, for submitting your 
testimony, and for continuing to work on these issues to 
protect children in the virtual space and to rid the virtual 
space of CSAM.
 And, Ms. DeLaune, as you know, my REPORT Act was signed 
into law by President Biden last year. And, of course, that 
increases the time that you all can hold information from 90 
days to a year.
 And it also requires the social media platforms to report 
to you when there are bad actors, and when CSAM is present.
 And I was listening to you talk just a few minutes ago. We 
have heard that there are increases in reports to you all. But 
pick it up from there for me and build out with the increases 
in reports to the CyberTipline. Look at--let's look at what has 
happened, how law enforcement is responding, how we're being 
able to get these cases prosecuted.
 Ms. DeLaune. Thank you. And thank you for your leadership, 
Senator, on the REPORT Act. We have seen in the last year--we 
have seen 192 percent increase in online enticement reports. 
That is a result of reports coming in from the tech companies, 
as well as members of the public who are making those reports 
to us.
 We do have concerns regarding the quality of those reports. 
There is the requirement that the company report it if they 
become aware of it. But the fact that many of these reports are 
coming from the public rather than the provider shows that 
they're not detecting that.
 In addition, you know, the companies still--going back to 
the requirements of what should be included in a report, 
companies are still, you know, choosing based upon their own 
decision, what they wish to include in the report and what they 
don't. More consistency across the companies would be good. We 
did issue in response----
 Senator Blackburn. Okay. Hang on just----
 Ms. DeLaune. Of course.
 Senator Blackburn [continuing]. Right there. So then they 
are reporting, but their metric is a subjective metric? Is that 
what you're saying?
 Ms. DeLaune. That is correct, Senator.
 Senator Blackburn. Okay.
 Ms. DeLaune. That is correct. And we did issue guidelines, 
based upon the REPORT Act, last fall. That does provide very 
clear guidance and helpful information on the recognizing child 
sex trafficking and online enticement on their platforms.
 Senator Blackburn. So, should we look at going back into 
the REPORT Act and being specific in some of that guidance that 
you all issued? Should we put that into statute so that there 
is a uniform approach?
 Ms. DeLaune. There's also--that is one idea. There's also, 
within the STOP CSAM Act, there are provisions there regarding 
building out what information would be helpful in a 
CyberTipline report. If the report is being made, then there is 
a belief that a crime has occurred. At that point, provide the 
information that's necessary to identify the child and identify 
a possible offender.
 Senator Blackburn. Okay. Well, what we want to do is make 
certain that, with the changes that were made through the 
REPORT Act, that you all are able to get that information to 
law enforcement, law enforcement is able to apprehend bad 
actors, and we are able to get them off of these platforms and 
prosecuted. So, we would--we would appreciate that.
 Mr. Tanagho, I appreciate the work that IJM has done in 
fighting human trafficking. And one of the things that we have 
discussed, some of us have discussed, is the need to have a 
national--uniform national human trafficking database.
 And as you know, Senator Klobuchar and I have introduced 
the legislation that would establish that, so that we have a 
way to pull this information together. And then we're able to 
actually see what is happening, what trends are happening, and 
get a full picture of what is taking place in the 50 States.
 So, I want you to talk for just a minute about why it is 
important to have that data from each of the States and 
collectively be able to review that.
 Mr. Tanagho. Well, thank you for that question, Senator 
Blackburn. I think it's essential. And, in fact, in all of 
IJM's programs, we always conduct a baseline study to measure 
the prevalence of the crimes that we are combating at the start 
of our program and then again at the end of our program.
 And nine out of nine times, we have been able to measure a 
reduction in the prevalence of violent crimes. And I think it's 
really important.
 When I talked about the scale of harm, nearly half a 
million--you know, the half a million children who are being 
sex trafficked in livestreaming in the Philippines alone--the 
reason that we spent all the time and effort to do that 
research study is because we believe that at some point down 
the future, at the end of our program, that we will be able to 
reduce the prevalence of that crime.
 But the only way we know if anti-trafficking programs are 
working is if you collect the data. Right?
 At the end of the day, I think what all of us care about is 
that children are being protected. Whether it's from 
trafficking, whether it's from CSAM, whether it's from 
livestreamed child sexual abuse.
 At the end of the day, our work should lead to fewer 
victims of these terrible crimes. And the only way we know if 
that's happening is if we gather the data.
 Senator Blackburn. And I appreciate that, and I think the 
livestreaming is such a heinous act. And being able to curtail 
that and to apprehend those individuals is going to be an 
important part of what we do. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you, Senator Blackburn. Thank you for 
your tremendous leadership on this issue.
 Let me now call on the Ranking Member, if he's ready--yes, 
for any statement he might want to make, and then for his 
questions.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN,
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS

 Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for 
your support on this measure, which goes back to the previous 
Congress. We switched places. It was Durbin-Hawley, now it's 
Hawley-Durbin. It's a bill we're working on together on a 
bipartisan basis, as we should.
 I'm sorry that I'm late. I had a press conference scheduled 
with a leader that I couldn't change. I just want to follow up 
with a question or two.
 The STOP CSAM Act is a comprehensive child protection bill, 
as we all know. We counted on survivors, law enforcement, 
prosecutors, and victims to help write it.
 A significant portion of the bill is dedicated to 
strengthening privacy protections for child victims. All CSAM 
victims have their dignity and privacy further ripped away from 
them when their abuse is captured in pictures or videos and put 
on display.
 That's why the STOP CSAM Act includes significant updates 
to Federal law such as creating a presumption in favor of 
keeping protected information under seal and providing the 
court with remedies against any attorney who does not comply 
with these privacy provisions.
 Mr. Schiller, can you explain why it's necessary to make 
these updates? In particular, I'd like your thoughts on why 
it's important to have an enforcement provision within this 
statute.
 Mr. Schiller. Thank you, Senator. I appreciate the 
question. I cannot begin to tell you how many times, in my 
years of prosecuting cases, that I have had to redact 
documents, to do what I needed to do to protect a victim's 
identity.
 For years, we didn't know how to handle it. We didn't know 
exactly what we were supposed to do. And this legislation gives 
us that direction.
 But more so, it makes sure that criminal defense 
attorneys--pro se defendants who might not care about their 
victims because, frankly, they're the ones who were violating 
them, want to continue to harm them--not the defense attorneys, 
of course, but the defendants themselves. This law would make 
sure that they can't do that anymore. And there would be 
sanctions in place if they did.
 Senator Durbin. Ms. Sines, your exploiter was recently 
prosecuted in Federal court. I understand you participated in 
that process. What, if anything, could've been done to make it 
easier or better for you?
 Ms. Sines. Thank you, Senator. In all transparency, it was 
the easiest thing I think I have ever done. My prosecutor, to 
the detective who worked my case, made it effortless for me. 
They handled the brunt of any accusations, any terrible 
questions. They were able to shield me from having to sit and 
look through images and identify myself.
 Truly, I consider myself very lucky that I don't think 
anything could have been done better for my case. But I know 
that that's not how it is for every victim.
 I know that law enforcement falls short. I know prosecution 
can fall short.
 In my case, my school resource officer fell short.
 I think it's making sure that everyone is well educated on 
CSAM and what sextortion and exploitation means and how 
prevalent it is in their own back yards.
 Senator Durbin. That is so good to hear, after all you've 
been through--that you had a day in court of that nature.
 Ms. Sines. Thank you, Senator.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Pizzuro, welcome back.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Thank you.
 Senator Durbin. Let me ask you about the enhanced privacy 
protections available to child victims continuing when they 
turn 18. Is that important?
 Mr. Pizzuro. It's really important, and I think that's the 
aspect--you know, I think--you know, and part of the reporting 
aspects, just from a law enforcement, as Mrs. DeLaune had 
indicated, we don't have the information when we're trying to 
do these investigations, so I think that's the challenge.
 And the reports that we do get--and this is where STOP CSAM 
really helps law enforcement actually get quality leads in 
order for us to go out and investigate and find victims and 
protect them better.
 Senator Durbin. I'm going to ask a question that I'm sure 
others would like to know the answer to, as well. Are there any 
good guys out there? Any social media spots and others that are 
responding properly, in timely fashion?
 Mr. Pizzuro. It's--how do I word this? It's, uh, I would 
say no. I would say some do it better than others--but what 
they're doing good isn't good at all.
 Senator Durbin. Any of the panelists have anything to say 
on that?
 Mr. Schiller. Thank you, Senator. I agree. I think some of 
them have been getting better. But I think that a lot of that 
has to do with the pressure that they've been receiving from 
law enforcement, from prosecutors, from the Department of 
Justice, to provide more information. But that's not the way 
it's supposed to happen.
 There's supposed to be a uniform standard to make sure that 
they're all providing the same and necessary information. It 
would help NCMEC to be able to process their reports faster, to 
get to law enforcement, so that the prosecutors can issue 
subpoenas and search warrants and we can move faster.
 Every day that we have to wait on information, every day 
that we're not getting enough information is a day a child is 
being harmed. And we can't have that. We need robust 
information if we're going to do our jobs properly.
 Senator Durbin. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you. And now I see my friend Senator 
Blumenthal, who I've worked with--together, he and I in this 
space, very productively. It's great to have you here, Senator. 
And the floor is yours.
 Senator Blumenthal. Thank you very much, Senator Hawley. We 
have worked together, and my hope is that we'll continue to 
work together, especially on the issues that are before us 
today and, most especially, the Kids Online Safety Act, which 
was approved by the United States Senate in a vote of 91-to-3, 
91-to-3.
 Doesn't happen very often these days in the Senate. It was 
last session, and unfortunately the House never gave it a vote, 
which in my view is a tragedy, because it helps protect kids 
against the toxic content, the algorithms, the black box 
methodology that social media use.
 And, of course, the tech companies who would be held 
accountable under this law say they are for it, and then they 
work behind the scenes against it. And they try to shift blame 
for the skyrocketing increase in online harms to others, 
avoiding the blame that they well deserve.
 But more important than the blame is reforms that they 
could well institute: providing tools and safeguards for 
parents and children and a duty of care, so that they are 
required to mitigate harm if they know it's happening or have 
reason to know it's happening; and, of course, disclosure of 
the algorithms, the black box drivers of that toxic content.
 Mr. Pizzuro, you say that we're not going to arrest our 
way--I think in your testimony--we cannot arrest our way out of 
this problem. Let me ask you, perhaps you and Ms. DeLaune, what 
you think about the duty of care as a means of providing some 
safeguards here.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Well, I think, from my standpoint, is that 
there is no safeguards. And I think that's the problem. Right? 
We--the AI algorithms push all this content to them, and it 
doesn't matter what the mechanism is.
 So, there needs to be a duty of care. Because ultimately, 
these children are on their platforms so there is a burden on 
them to make sure that the children are safe.
 Ms. DeLaune. Thank you, Senator. It's really incumbent upon 
the companies to know their customer. You know, at this point, 
you know, most of the sites--most things online, you just check 
a box: you're over 13, you're over 21--whatever it may be. 
They're working and looking at age assurance, knowing who the 
child is, what age they're at.
 Going back to the case that we just saw a moment ago--
knowing who they're engaging with, whether or not they're 
overage, underage--there's a shared responsibility, in our 
view, for the platforms, for the app stores, for the device, 
and knowing who the child is and building and designing safer 
experiences for them, recognizing their age.
 I will also talk briefly about the necessity--we can't 
prosecute our way out of the problem. The reports are coming 
in, law enforcement rightly is investigating. Really, we need 
to be looking upstream about preventing these crimes from 
happening in the first place.
 One feature that we're seeing an increase--we actually saw 
a 1,300 percent increase in 1 year in the use of generative AI 
to create child sexual abuse imagery. There are--there are 
blockers right now in trying to prevent that.
 The current legislation allows the National Center to 
provide specific elements to help in the prevention of these 
crimes only with electronic service providers.
 What the STOP CSAM Act also allows us to do is share this 
information with other entities who are furthering the 
protection of children, whether it be an NGO, whether it be a 
GenAI tech provider.
 Right now, you know, we're hearing requests, working with 
Meta, with OpenAI, with Google, who are looking to build 
classifiers to detect generative artificial CSAM--AI CSAM. But 
there's limited information, in some cases, of what we can 
share.
 So, another really important thing that we just keep going 
to back to is: We will continue responding, we need to be 
preventing. They need to know who their customers are, and we 
need to be able to share good data, helpful data, to help them 
build solutions to the problems.
 Senator Blumenthal. And I agree that, you know, they have 
the technology, they know the customers. The burden should be 
on them. That's the importance of the duty of care. It's a 
design feature. It's not a censorship mechanism. It doesn't 
block content, it gives the consumers choices so that they can 
block it, if they wish, or their parents can take action to 
protect their children with tools that they deserve to have.
 And the duty of care imposes a measure of responsibility on 
the tech companies themselves to address the kind of problems 
that they are seeing and we are seeing children facing. Thank 
you all for your testimony today. Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you very much, Senator Blumenthal.
 Ms. DeLaune, could I just come back to something you said 
just a moment ago in response to Senator Blumenthal? You 
mentioned generative AI----
 Ms. DeLaune. Mm-hmm.
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. Just give us a sense of the 
field. Is generative AI going to make the problem of CSAM 
online--is it going to make it better or worse? In other words, 
is it going to contribute to the proliferation of these images? 
Or, is it going to make them--is it going to reduce the overall 
number?
 Ms. DeLaune. It will not reduce the overall number. I have 
spent hours looking at some of the reports that have been 
submitted to us by tech companies that include images of child 
sexual abuse that have been generated with this technology.
 There are examples of text prompts, where somebody types in 
what they want the image to look like. That ultimately produces 
child sexual abuse material. We have cases of teachers who are 
taking known images of abuse and putting faces of children they 
know--it's been happening for many decades. But now it's very 
easy and has kind of democratized the use of this tech.
 So, we do anticipate--we are seeing, in 1 year, a 1,300 
percent increase, which really just, you know, we're doubling 
down in terms of trying, before this genie is completely out of 
the bottle--how do we get the information? How do we get the 
good companies in, to try to build these tools and these safety 
designs at the beginning?
 It's a little late, but it's still something that we're 
going to be working on. And we do need the statutory authority 
to be able to share more information so we can get these 
systems built the way they need to, recognizing the harm that 
they're going to cause.
 Chair Hawley. And that last part you said is so key, I 
think. You need the statutory authority. This legislation would 
help accomplish that.
 But I think as we look at this new age of AI, we hear a lot 
of rosy predictions about how wonderful AI is going to be for 
everybody. I hope that that's true.
 But what we're seeing so far in this space is AI is 
driving--as you just said, Ms. DeLaune, an absolute explosion 
of CSAM material--an absolute explosion of it, and it's making 
life horrific----
 Ms. DeLaune. Mm-hmm.
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. For more and more teenagers, 
more and more folks like you, Ms. Sines, who now have images 
ripped off of--public images ripped off the web, ripped off of 
their profiles, put through an AI generative process that's 
readily available and turned into something else entirely--and 
have their lives ruined.
 And we've got to take steps now to give victims--because 
they're just as much a victim if AI does it as if someone's 
holding a livestream camera--we've got to give them tools to 
combat this. And then we've got to give NCMEC, and other 
enforcers, the tools to do the same.
 Senator Klobuchar, would you like to ask some questions?
 Senator Klobuchar. I would.
 Chair Hawley. All right. The----
 Senator Klobuchar. Thank you very much.
 Chair Hawley [continuing]. Floor is yours. Thanks for being 
here.
 Senator Klobuchar. Thank you. Thank you all, and thank you 
very much, Ms. Sines, for your story and for being willing to 
come forward. Do you believe that we need to put in place 
mechanisms to require online platforms to immediately take down 
nonconsensual and intimate images?
 Ms. Sines. Thank you, Senator. I absolutely do agree.
 As I mentioned in my testimony earlier, what happens if my 
photos were to be publicly posted? Again, do I think that Big 
Tech would have my back and immediately take it down?
 No. Never. I don't--so, we absolutely need this in place, 
so companies--as soon as they see these images, they're 
immediately taken down. That saves the victim a lot of shame.
 Imagine you are back in middle school or you're back in 
high school--and now everybody has a cell phone--you can get on 
the web at any time. You can screenshot, screen record, share 
it. Those images aren't just circulating by the predators 
online. They're circulating through these children's schools.
 Senator Klobuchar. Yes, exactly. And I thank my colleagues 
for their work on this important bill.
 I actually wanted to ask about an additional bill, Mr. 
Tanagho, and that is--both Senator Cornyn and I have the SHIELD 
Act, and Senator Cruz and I have a TAKE IT DOWN Act, which was 
actually referred to, at the State of the Union, and the First 
Lady has done a press event supporting the bill.
 In your written testimony, you called for the codification 
of a notice and takedown regime in Federal law. As you know, 
these bills create a mechanism through which platforms are 
required to remove sexual abuse materials from their sites, and 
it is unanimously--the TAKE IT DOWN Act has unanimously passed. 
SHIELD Act passed.
 Why is it so important that Congress pass into law a 
requirement that platforms permanently remove sexual abuse 
imagery from the internet?
 Mr. Tanagho. Well, thank you so much for that question. I 
think we've heard from a very brave survivor today about the 
harm that is done to survivors when their abuse material 
continues to circulate online.
 And I think it shouldn't be the responsibility of survivors 
to have to scour the internet looking for images and videos of 
their abuse, and then repeatedly requesting companies to take 
it down.
 I think once they have asked a company to take down their 
CSAM, the company should absolutely do it, and there should be 
a law that requires them to do it, so that it's not voluntary.
 But after that, that company is on notice. They know that 
that image or that video is known CSAM, and they can use 
technology to prevent the recirculation and reuploading of that 
image ever again.
 Senator Klobuchar. Yes.
 Mr. Tanagho. And that's what should be required of them.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay, thank you.
 Mr. Schiller, the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota has 
prioritized combating child sexual exploitation online. In 
fact, just last month, after an investigation with Federal law 
enforcement, the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension in 
the Winona County Sheriff's Office, a man was sentenced to 27 
years in prison after targeting more than 60 young girls, 
primarily between ages 9 and 12, in an online extortion scheme.
 Based on your experience as a former AUSA, what are the 
most effective tools that prosecutors currently have to stop 
the sexual exploitation of kids online, and what are the 
biggest challenges?
 Mr. Schiller. Well, thank you very much, Senator. This 
Congress and past Congresses have given us wonderful tools when 
it comes to laws punishing online offenders. We have minimum 
mandatories, we have online exploitation communities that we 
can prosecute, and we've got great criminal statutes to do 
that.
 But that's only one side of it. We need other tools. And to 
be honest with you, the STOP CSAM Act gives us some of those 
other tools.
 Senator Klobuchar. Mm-hmm.
 For example, I've had cases where I've had children who 
were abused by their parents or by other people who are 
guarding them. They have no guard at all.
 So, we had to get them a guardian ad litem. It becomes a 
difficult process when the courts have no funding for it. The 
courts are already strapped as it is, financially, so this bill 
gives them that funding and guarantees those children that 
protection.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay.
 Mr. Schiller. And one other thing that we heard earlier 
from Mr. Tanagho is, having a fiduciary. If we have victims 
outside of our country or incapacitated victims, they need to 
be able to maintain that restitution when it is finally awarded 
to them. And this bill, again, does that for them.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay. Thank you. Mr. Pizzuro, last 
question here. And I did have some questions on reporting of 
you, Ms. DeLaune. But I think Senator Blackburn took care of 
those.
 So, Mr. Pizzuro, could you tell me why it's so important to 
open the courtroom doors and reform Section 230 for those who 
suffer harms like the two boys who you described in your 
testimony?
 Mr. Pizzuro. Well, the reality is that, again, we've talked 
about this a while. There's not any penalties. Right? So, until 
there are penalties and people have their time in court for 
that victimization, how are we going to protect them?
 And ultimately that's what companies understand. They 
understand, as long as it's not going to cost them, it's a 
business decision. Ultimately, that is what's going to happen. 
And ultimately, that's what needs to happen.
 Senator Klobuchar. Okay. Thank you. And I thank the two 
leaders up here with me, as well. Thank you. Thanks, all of 
you.
 Chair Hawley. I think we've got--Senator Britt is on the 
way, so let me just ask another question or two while we wait 
for her to arrive.
 Mr. Schiller, if I could just come back to you. My 
understanding is that the Child Rescue Coalition plays a major 
role in developing new technology that can be used against 
online CSAM. Can you speak to that?
 Mr. Schiller. I certainly can, Senator. Thank you. Yes, for 
the better part of 10 years now, the Child Rescue Coalition 
generates software for law enforcement for free, so that it can 
expedite their work in combating child exploitation, between 
peer-to-peer networks, livestreaming technology, and everything 
else that's out there where our children are at risk.
 The technology gives law enforcement the opportunity to 
proactively go after these individuals, incredibly streamlining 
their process, and minimizing the work they have to do. The 
beautiful thing about the technology is it works hand in hand 
with every other law enforcement technology to combat child 
exploitation.
 So, when law enforcement receives a CyberTip from NCMEC, 
they will also run that information against information from 
the Child Rescue Coalition, to see if offenders are in 
different places, and make a robust and really wholesome 
investigation against the offender.
 Chair Hawley. Very good. Thank you for your terrific work, 
and thank you for your center's work.
 Ms. Sines, can I just come back to you? I want to pick up 
something that you said in your opening statement about when 
your exploiter posted all of the--created all of those profiles 
in order to post all of that material. And you said that 
Facebook said to you initially that they would not take down so 
many of these different profiles.
 How long did it take before you were finally able to get 
this content, which--and these profiles which were generated, 
as I understand it, with the sole purpose of embarrassing you, 
shaming you--how long did it take to get Facebook to finally 
take those down?
 Ms. Sines. Thank you, Senator. First, it took a little over 
a day, until we were able to hone in on a personnel that we 
could directly contact at Facebook. And then any other time 
there were postings, we would contact that one specific 
personnel, and they would be taken down within a few hours. But 
at first, it was a day, maybe longer.
 Chair Hawley. Well, I think one of the important things 
that this bill does, additionally, is it creates a reporting 
mechanism for victims, an independent board--because what we've 
seen all too often with the companies, and this was your 
experience, is that people go to them, report it, and 
oftentimes the companies--they drag their feet or they do 
nothing. They do nothing at all, and they say, well, you know, 
it's too bad.
 This bill creates an independent board that is able to 
receive these complaints, review them, and then order that this 
kind of material is taken down within 48 hours--and also to 
subject companies that violate this order to fines, including 
some restitution for victims.
 So, your experience, again, is so instructive in this 
regard. Thank you for being willing to be here and to share it 
with us. And thank you for your courage. Senator Britt, we are 
ready for you if you are ready for us.
 Senator Britt. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. I 
appreciate it, and appreciate you holding a hearing on this 
important topic.
 Look, there is nothing more important than protecting our 
kids. When you talk about looking at what's happening to the 
next generation, I think it is imperative that we step up and 
do better--do more to make sure that we are safeguarding, 
putting up guardrails, calling things out where they are.
 And so I appreciate you all being here to discuss this 
important topic. I mean, the perils of the digital era are 
literally turning the American Dream into a nightmare for so 
many families--not only in my State but literally across the 
Nation.
 I wanted to start with you, Mr. Pizzuro. Is that how you 
say it?
 Mr. Pizzuro. Pizzuro.
 Senator Britt. Pizzuro. Okay, there you go. Look, you--yes, 
I had intended to be in front of you and ask some questions 
when you appeared before the Full Committee last month. I went 
back and looked at some of the written testimony you submitted 
to the Committee, and one anecdote in your testimony really 
struck me.
 You recounted that you were taking a half-a-mile walk on a 
beautiful day on the beach, and during that relatively brief 
period of time, you counted 67 children and teens on their 
phones.
 And you also said that then you came across a lost child 
who couldn't find their parent. You concluded with a statement 
that statistically, at least 25 percent of those children will 
be victimized.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Yes.
 Senator Britt. In addition to reforming Section 230 and 
passing bills such as STOP CSAM Act, I'm of the view that one 
of the things that Congress needs to do is ensure that social 
media platforms verify the ages of their users, rather than 
relying on, you know, kind of them to do that themselves.
 And we all know that typically what they say, you know, you 
can't be on there until you're 13. But they never verify that, 
so that's just meaningless.
 I co-led another bill during Congress, Protecting Kids on 
Social Media Act, that addressed this issue. Given your 
background and experience, do you have any views regarding how 
Congress may best approach the age verification issue?
 Mr. Pizzuro. Yes. Device based. Your phone knows how old 
you are. Right? So, we--if I'm 10 years old and I try to 
download Snap and I try to get on it, it knows that I'm not. 
So, even Raven's been working on techs.
 But the solution is really device based, because we know 
that. And even parents today can't even understand, like, if 
parental controls----
 Senator Britt. Mm-hmm.
 Mr. Pizzuro [continuing]. There's, like, 51--each one has a 
different one. What happens if we were able to create one where 
a parent can press a button to prevent their kids, and that 
information, from going on?
 And it's not even a privacy issue. It's because the phone 
knows how old they are, so we need to----
 Senator Britt. The phone knows----
 Mr. Pizzuro. Yes.
 Senator Britt [continuing]. How old you are because when 
we, as parents--if you were to go and get your child a phone, 
you're saying we have to give that information when the phone 
is purchased. Right?
 Mr. Pizzuro. Correct. So, right----
 Senator Britt. So, the information exists.
 Mr. Pizzuro. It's there. It's right there. Yes.
 Senator Britt. It is already there. So, then, enforcing 
this, making these companies actually be able to not download 
an app, let's say, if you know that the child that owns the 
phone is under the age of that of which it should be available, 
shouldn't actually be that hard. And that kind of sort of seems 
that it would go into an app store.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Yes. And the apps would actually talk to the 
actual store that in--whether it be a----
 Senator Britt. So, what you're telling me is, we have all 
of the information we already need to help protect our children 
when----
 Mr. Pizzuro. Correct.
 Senator Britt [continuing]. It comes to age verification. 
We just have companies that are unwilling to do the hard thing, 
that would be the best thing for our kids.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Well, because----
 Senator Britt. Really, it's actually relatively easy.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Yes. Well, I guess the companies, they want 
the kids on their platforms so they can sell them whatever. You 
know? I think that's the challenge.
 So, the technology exists. And not only that, something 
along that thing as a solution would actually help parents. 
Because parents don't understand every new app that comes in. 
So, you give parents the ability to protect their children at 
home. I mean, to me, what's better than that?
 Senator Britt. Yes. Absolutely. As a parent of a 14- and a 
15-year-old, say Amen. Right?
 I mean, this is the exact thing--we've got to make sure--
what we know now, versus what we knew when, you know, all of 
this began and then the rise in social media and the nexus to 
the lives of our children, we have a duty and an obligation to 
do something about that.
 And what I hear you saying to me today is, these companies 
already have this information. And so it is a choice that they 
are making with regards to allowing these things to be 
downloaded on these phones.
 Mr. Pizzuro. Yes. Absolutely.
 Senator Britt. Okay. I think that's a choice that we should 
take away from them and make sure that we're safeguarding our 
kids. I know I am almost out of time.
 Is there anyone else that has anything to add to that 
particular topic? Well, see, it sounds like we found a winner 
here. Right? We figured it out.
 Mr. Chairman, thank you. I won't go over my time but really 
appreciate you bringing light to this so that we can hold 
people accountable and we can safeguard for our kids, you know, 
their ability to learn and grow and explore but to do that in 
as safe an environment as possible. So, thank you.
 Chair Hawley. Thank you, Senator Britt. Thank you for your 
leadership on this.
 Mr. Pizzuro, I think maybe you have summed it up well. 
These companies--this is a business model. They want kids 
online. They want to sell them stuff. They want the--let's be 
honest, they want the child exploiters online, also, because 
they benefit from their business.
 This is really about profit, at the end of the day. And 
until it is not profitable for these companies to host this 
abusive material online, they're going to keep doing it.
 Until it is not profitable for them to evade the reporting 
requirements, they're going to keep evading them. They're not 
going to be good actors until we force them to do it.
 And that's why the legislation we've been talking about 
today, and the other issues that we've been considering--age 
verification, et cetera--is so vital.
 Because we do need to protect our kids. We do need to put 
power back into the hands of parents and victims.
 And I'll just end with this. To me, this is the age-old 
American story.
 Who's going to have the power? Is it going to be these 
megacorporations who are not accountable to anybody? Or, is it 
going to be the people? Is it going to be the victims? Is it 
going to be the parents? Who's going to have the power here?
 This technology can work beautifully if victims and parents 
actually have power. Right now, they don't. We need to give it 
to them.
 I want to thank again the Ranking Member for his tremendous 
work on this. I said, Senator, when you were out of the room, I 
really said a lot of nice things about you, Senator Durbin, so 
maybe we'll leave it there.
 Senator Durbin. I'll check the transcript.
 [Laughter.]
 Chair Hawley. Thank you all for being here. Thank you for 
the witnesses, for being here today, for your testimony, for 
your work. Thank you to the many advocates who are here in the 
room.
 And with that, this hearing is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 4:10 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
 [Additional material submitted for the record follows.]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 

 A P P E N D I X

The following submissions are available at:

 https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg61837/pdf/CHRG-119shrg
 61837-add1.pdf

Submitted by Chair Hawley:

 ``In 2023 alone, 104,370,572 images and videos of suspected child 
 sexual abuse were reported in the U.S.--up from 450,000 files 
 in 2004,'' poster displayed during hearing.................... 2

Submitted by Ranking Member Durbin:

 Center for AI and Digital Policy, letter, March 11, 2025......... 3

 [all]