Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] PARTNERING FOR INNOVATION: HOW BANK-FINTECH COLLABORATIONS ENHANCE FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE ======================================================================= HEARING before the SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY, AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE of the COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ MAY 20, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-75 Printed for the use of the Committee on Financial Services [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 64-470 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 HOUSE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES FRENCH HILL, Arkansas, Chairman BILL HUIZENGA, Michigan, Vice MAXINE WATERS, California, Ranking Chairman Member FRANK D. LUCAS, Oklahoma SYLVIA R. GARCIA, Texas, Vice PETE SESSIONS, Texas Ranking Member ANN WAGNER, Missouri NYDIA M. VELAZQUEZ, New York ANDY BARR, Kentucky BRAD SHERMAN, California ROGER WILLIAMS, Texas GREGORY W. MEEKS, New York TOM EMMER, Minnesota STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts BARRY LOUDERMILK, Georgia AL GREEN, Texas WARREN DAVIDSON, Ohio EMANUEL CLEAVER, Missouri JOHN W. ROSE, Tennessee JAMES A. HIMES, Connecticut BRYAN STEIL, Wisconsin BILL FOSTER, Illinois WILLIAM R. TIMMONS, IV, South JOYCE BEATTY, Ohio Carolina JUAN VARGAS, California MARLIN STUTZMAN, Indiana JOSH GOTTHEIMER, New Jersey RALPH NORMAN, South Carolina VICENTE GONZALEZ, Texas DANIEL MEUSER, Pennsylvania SEAN CASTEN, Illinois YOUNG KIM, California AYANNA PRESSLEY, Massachusetts BYRON DONALDS, Florida RASHIDA TLAIB, Michigan ANDREW R. GARBARINO, New York RITCHIE TORRES, New York SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin NIKEMA WILLIAMS, Georgia MIKE FLOOD, Nebraska BRITTANY PETTERSEN, Colorado MICHAEL LAWLER, New York CLEO FIELDS, Louisiana MONICA DE LA CRUZ, Texas JANELLE BYNUM, Oregon ANDREW OGLES, Tennessee SAM LICCARDO, California ZACHARY NUNN, Iowa LISA McCLAIN, Michigan MARIA SALAZAR, Florida TROY DOWNING, Montana MIKE HARIDOPOLOS, Florida TIM MOORE, North Carolina Ben Johnson, Staff Director ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY, AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE BRYAN STEIL, Wisconsin, Chairman TOM EMMER, Minnesota, Vice Chairman STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts, BILL HUIZENGA, Michigan Ranking Member WARREN DAVIDSON, Ohio BRAD SHERMAN, California JOHN W. ROSE, Tennessee BILL FOSTER, Illinois WILLIAM R. TIMMONS, IV, South JOSH GOTTHEIMER, New Jersey Carolina AYANNA PRESSLEY, Massachusetts MARLIN STUTZMAN, Indiana RITCHIE TORRES, New York BYRON DONALDS, Florida SYLVIA R. GARCIA, Texas ZACHARY NUNN, Iowa BRITTANY PETTERSEN, Colorado TROY DOWNING, Montana SAM LICCARDO, California MIKE HARIDOPOLOS, Florida TIM MOORE, North Carolina C O N T E N T S ---------- Wednesday, May 20, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Page Hon. Bryan Steil, Chairman of the Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology and Artificial Intelligence, a U.S. Representative from Wisconsin.................................. 1 Hon. Stephen Lynch, Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology and Artificial Intelligence, a U.S. Representative from Massachusetts......................... 2 WITNESSES Ms. Alexandra Steinberg Barrage, Partner, Morrison Foerster...... 4 Prepared Statement........................................... 6 Ms. Henrietta Thomas, Executive General Manager for Advocacy, Risk & Compliance, Xero........................................ 15 Prepared Statement........................................... 17 Ms. Sheetal Parikh, General Counsel & Chief Compliance Officer, Treasury Prime................................................. 25 Prepared Statement........................................... 27 Ms. Erica Khalili, Co-founder, Chief Legal & Risk Officer, Lead Bank........................................................... 36 Prepared Statement........................................... 38 Mrs. Mitria Spotser, Vice President, Federal Policy, and President, Julian Bond Institute for Financial Equity Research, Center for Responsible Lending Prepared Statement........................................... 62 APPENDIX RESPONSES TO QUESTIONS FOR THE RECORD Written responses to questions for the record from Representative John W. Rose Ms. Alexandra Steinberg Barrage.............................. 85 Ms. Sheetal Parikh........................................... 87 Ms. Erica Khalili............................................ 92 LEGISLATION H.R. 6552, the Bank-Fintech Partnership Enhancement Act.......... 94 PARTNERING FOR INNOVATION: HOW BANK-FINTECH COLLABORATIONS ENHANCE FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE ---------- Wednesday, May 20, 2026 U.S. House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial Intelligence, Committee on Financial Services, Washington, DC. The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:03 a.m., in room 2128, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Bryan Steil [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Steil, Hill, Huizenga, Davidson, Timmons, Stutzman, Downing, Haridopolos, Lynch, Foster, Garcia, and Liccardo. Chairman Steil. The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial Intelligence will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess of the committee at any time. Today's hearing is titled ``Partnering for Innovation: How Bank-Fintech Collaborations Enhance Financial Infrastructure.'' Without objection, all members will have 5 legislative days within which to submit extraneous materials to the chair for inclusion in the record. I now recognize myself for 4 minutes for an opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. BRYAN STEIL, CHAIRMAN OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM WISCONSIN When we think of innovators, sometimes we picture scientists or engineers working by themselves, toiling away in their labs, or entrepreneurs building companies from a garage or a dorm room by themselves and while we celebrate the achievements of individual innovators, some of the most important innovations in America are actually happening through really significant collaboration. The financial services sector is a prime example of that. In fact, across the country, we see how collaboration in this sector has supercharged innovation, increased consumer choice, and broadened access to the financial services space. In our current financial system, innovation is increasingly driven by partnerships between banks and financial technology companies (fintechs) working together to bring novel financial products and services to market and expanding choice for all Americans. By combining the speed and technology--and technological expertise of software developers with the consumer protections, compliance, and trust of regulated banks, these partnerships are helping cement the United States as the global leader in financial innovation. Bank-fintech partnerships are a win-win. Fintech firms gain a partner that can help them scale their business in a compliant way, while banks gain access to new technologies, consumer bases, and growth opportunities, and consumers can reap the benefits. It is no surprise that we see community and regional banks leading the way in partnering with fintechs. As fintechs innovate, they can give consumers and businesses of all sizes access to more efficient financial services. With adherence to prudent risk management and strong oversight, these relationships can better serve communities. This includes facilitating expanded opportunities and inclusion in the form of access to financial services to those who may be less likely to access financial services through traditional bank products. As we examine the benefits of these partnerships--as we examine the benefits these partnerships bring consumers, we must remain cognizant of managing risk and ensuring strong due diligence, consumer protections, and compliance safeguards. At the same time, Federal regulators and examiners should not stifle innovation simply because a product or technology is new or unfamiliar. I look forward to exploring recent developments in this space and hearing from our expert witnesses on what we can do to foster innovation through bank-fintech partnerships. Also, on a separate note, moments ago, I was informed of the passing of the former chairman of this committee, Barney Frank. He had a 32-year career in the U.S. House of Representatives and was one of the most impactful chairs of this committee, why his portrait sits to my right. Obviously, Dodd-Frank being one of the most transformative bills that he was engaged in, and affordable housing was a topic that he spent a lot of time working on. Maybe all the more appropriate that, today, the House will vote on a strong bipartisan housing package. With his loss, I think we all reflect on the service and commitment he had to improving not only the financial services and housing space in this committee, but to his commitment in work on behalf of all of us here in the U.S. House of Representatives. So, I request we all take a moment of silence in--following his passing. [Moment of silence.] Chairman Steil. I now recognize the ranking member of the subcommittee, Mr. Lynch, for 4 minutes for an opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. STEPHEN LYNCH, RANKING MEMBER OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM MASSACHUSETTS Mr. Lynch. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Let me just say, when I first came to this committee when I was a freshman, Barney Frank was the top Democrat and welcomed me--actually, persuaded me to come onto this committee because of what he thought we could do together, Democrats and Republicans, on issues like housing and consumer protections, investor protections. Many people remember Barney Frank and view his legacy of the work that he did as a champion on behalf of LGBTQ+ individuals in this country, and that is rightly so, but having sat next to him for many of those 32 years that Barney was here, he was equally a champion of working people. I remember when I was president of the ironworkers, he was our go-to person here--he and Joe Moakley--in terms of protecting worker rights and decent working conditions for Americans across this country. He also worked mightily on behalf of the fishermen in Massachusetts, from Gloucester to New Bedford and Fall River, and they were greatly appreciative of his work on their behalf. His work on housing--ironically, we will pick up that bill today in the House, and that was an area of keen interest on behalf of Barney Frank. He had so many--so many accomplishments here during his 32 years. I appreciate the moment of silence on his behalf. As, Mr. Chairman, you rightly note, the Dodd-Frank Act, which continues to be part of his legacy from a legislative standpoint here in Congress--that bill, when it passed, was meant to rescue our markets and rescue homeowners who were losing their homes after the collapse of markets in 2008, and every bit of it was meant to restabilize markets and stabilize our economy and it worked. It worked. There were contentious parts of it, but in his--to his credit, he was the person who drove most of the stabilizing influence within that bill, and we are grateful for his service here. He was an example to many of us here. A lot of people said Barney Frank was the smartest guy in the room. It was not from his natural ability. He worked at it. He was a voracious reader and consumed every bit of data and information he could get before he came to this podium. He was the best prepared person in the room, and that was to his credit and to his work ethic. My prayers go out to his partner, Jim, whose tender care surrounded Barney in his final days and throughout his sickness. My prayers and the prayers of the entire Congress go out to him and to Barney's family. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. Today, we welcome the testimony of Ms. Alexandra Steinberg Barrage, a partner at Morrison Foerster; Ms. Henrietta Thomas, the executive general manager for advocacy, risk, and compliance at Xero; Ms. Sheetal Parikh, the general counsel and chief compliance officer at Treasury Prime; and Ms. Erica Khalili, the cofounder and chief legal risk officer at Lead Bank. We thank each of you for taking the time to be here. Each of you will be recognized for 5 minutes to give an oral presentation of your testimony. Without objection, your written testimony will be made part of the record. Ms. Steinberg Barrage, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your oral remarks. STATEMENT OF ALEXANDRA STEINBERG BARRAGE, PARTNER, MORRISON FOERSTER Ms. Barrage. Thank you. Subcommittee Chairman Steil, Subcommittee Ranking Member Lynch, and members of the subcommittee, I am honored to be testifying before you today, and I appreciate---- Mr. Lynch. I am sorry. May I ask you to just speak a little bit more into the microphone? Ms. Barrage. Sure. Mr. Lynch. That would be great. Ms. Barrage. Is that better? Mr. Lynch. Thank you. Thank you. Ms. Barrage. You are welcome. I am honored to be testifying before you today, and I greatly appreciate your acknowledgment of the accomplishments of Barney Frank. I am a partner in the financial services group of Morrison Foerster, and I advise a wide range of banks and technology companies on bank-fintech partnerships. My clients are building products at the forefront of payments and AI, and I am also a former Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) executive, so I bring a form of regulatory perspective to this discussion. The Bank-Fintech Partnership Enhancement Act is an important way to ensure that we remain focused on U.S. competitiveness, innovation, and, of course, consumer protection. These partnerships are quite varied. They cover many different types of products, and as my written testimony notes, they are continually evolving. My testimony is going to focus on a few common frictions that I have seen in my practice across these very different types of partnerships, and I am going to suggest a few targeted ways I think reforms can help strengthen these arrangements as we move to the future. First, a brief history. Five years ago, there was a significant growth in banking-as-a-service partnerships. We saw tremendous scale both at banks--largely community banks under $10 billion--and an array of fintechs looking for bank partnerships to scale their products. Most of these products were lending, deposit-related products, and card products. The truth is that, at this time, many fintechs and many banks were not ready to risk manage these arrangements. They are operationally complex. They require a high degree of compliance and regulators took notice. We saw a spade of public consent orders, civil money penalties, and a number of banks getting caught up in public enforcement actions. One middleware in particular failed pretty colossally at the grave cost to many consumers. So 2023, 2024 was a real reckoning for this industry. Some basic lessons from this episode: Know your product; know your partner, whether you are a fintech or a bank; make sure you have the right subject matter expertise internally as a bank, including at the board level. Relentlessly focus on compliance and especially recordkeeping and, of course, do not lose the money, right. Those are very important lessons that I think many banks and many fintechs today take to heart. The vast majority of these arrangements actually really work well. They are risk managed. They are not the ones that you typically hear about, and they have not gone away. In fact, a lot of these products are just morphing. We are seeing more and more bank-fintech arrangements. Now we are looking at digital asset use cases, digital asset custody, and tokenized deposits. So, the flavor changes, but the underlying partnerships and the need for these different entities to come together really have not changed. I think there is real opportunity to improve the way these partnerships are entered into and to--and how they are conducted, and my testimony focuses on two areas. The first is making sure our examiners--the folks in the field looking at these partnerships, overseeing the banks--have the right tools they need to understand and identify what those risks are, how to prioritize those risks. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) report that is cited in my testimony notes that there is a real gap there. I think that there is an opportunity for thoughtful private sector collaboration with bank supervisory teams to help address these gaps. Some of that may involve more experimentation by staff with the actual technologies, but others may just be formal training sessions focused on anonymized case studies to level up and it is not just the bank examiners that I think need the upskilling. I think it is the industry too. They need to understand what supervisory teams are looking for. So, I do view this as a two-way street. The second is a rethinking of how we treat confidential supervisory information. There have been many examples in my practice and in the practice of my colleagues where banks do not feel they can share important information with their fintech partners because of existing rules. There are potential criminal penalties if information that is deemed confidential is shared without authorization and so this has, in many ways, hampered our ability to support safety and soundness at our banks. I think more focus on those areas would be very helpful. I am happy to answer any questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Barrage follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. Ms. Thomas, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your opening remarks. STATEMENT OF HENRIETTA THOMAS, EXECUTIVE GENERAL MANAGER FOR ADVOCACY, RISK & COMPLIANCE, XERO Ms. Thomas. Okay. Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and distinguished members of the subcommittee, good morning, and thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. I am Henrietta Thomas, the executive general manager of advocacy, risk, and compliance at Xero. I am a lawyer with 25 years' experience in financial services, including serving as a regulator and specializing in financial crime, retail banking, and payment systems. The subject of this hearing today is part of what I work on every day at Xero. What is Xero, you might ask. Well, Xero is a trusted financial operating system for small businesses, serving nearly 5 million customers in over 180 countries for the last 20 years. Our purpose is simple: To make life better for small business owners, their advisors, and communities around them. We serve a variety of businesses: restaurants, farmers, specialist manufacturers, technology companies, and many more. What small business owners have in common is that they often do every job in the business, and every hour spent on financial administration is an hour not spent working on what they actually set out to do. Xero's mission is to give those businesses the financial visibility and control they need to focus on growth. How we do that in partnership with banks and fintechs is what I am here to talk about today. Our Xero small business insights data, drawn from real transaction behavior of tens of thousands of U.S. businesses, not a self-reported survey, shows that, in the first quarter of this year, American small businesses waited an average of nearly 29 days to be paid on their invoices, with those invoices running 9 days past the agreed due date. For a business operating on thin margins, this is not just an inconvenience; it constrains hiring, investment, and growth and our research shows it affects the personal well-being of people running these businesses. Cash flow is the number one reason for small businesses' failure, and bank fintech collaboration is one of the most important, powerful tools we have to change that. As a global, small business platform and a trusted financial operating system in the AI era, Xero is building around the jobs that matter most to small businesses' financial health: accounting, payment, and payroll. I want to focus today on the first two because they are where that collaboration comes to life most directly. I would like to give you a tangible example. Imagine a restaurant owner in Wisconsin or Boston who uses Xero to connect their bank account and their--and the transaction data flows automatically into their ledger overnight. When a supply invoice arrives, they approve it inside Xero and pay it, funded from their bank account, delivered by Automated Clearing House (ACH), and reconciled automatically in their books. Their accountant sees the same real-time picture they do. That experience is made possible by a specific kind of collaboration. The bank holds the money. Financial data networks carry transaction data securely to the platform. Licensed payments infrastructure processes what moves in and out. The invoice is getting paid. The supply bill is going out. Our recent acquisition of Melio, a U.S.-based licensed payments business, means bill payments can now happen on the Xero platform for U.S. customers, automatically reconciles with customers saving up to 15 hours a month on accounts payable alone. Our data shows that customers who use our payments capability end more months cash-positive than those who do not. Each of the parties in the scenario I just described perform a function that others cannot, and Xero serves as the foundation where they all seamlessly connect--the workflow, the visibility, and the reconciliation--turning discrete financial services into a coherent experience for small business owners. We find that this matters particularly in the United States where nearly 10,000 banks and credit unions serve America's small business, including the community banks and credit unions that are essential to the local economies across the country. The partnership model we have described is how a small business in rural Wisconsin gets access to the same modern financial tools as one based in the major city. That reach across institutions of every size is what bank-fintech collaboration makes possible. In closing, when banks, fintechs, and platforms each do what they do best for small businesses--get the visibility and control they need to thrive. What we have seen across every market we operate in is that clear, proportionate frameworks which treat collaboration as the expected model produce better outcomes for small businesses. The United States has a very-- has every ingredient to build the best version of this, and we are here to support that work and welcome the discussion. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Thomas follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. You yield back. Ms. Parikh, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF SHEETAL PARIKH, GENERAL COUNSEL & CHIEF COMPLIANCE OFFICER, TREASURY PRIME Ms. Parikh. Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and distinguished members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. My name is Sheetal Parikh. I am the general counsel and chief compliance officer at Treasury Prime. Over the course of my legal career, I have practiced both inside a large financial institution and at the leading edge of fintech, advising both banks and technology companies alike. That dual lens-- understanding traditional financial services and the vantage point of those reimagining it--is precisely why I am here. Before I describe what Treasury Prime does, I want to offer a brief explanation of how bank-fintech partnerships work in practice, because the mechanics matter to the policy questions this subcommittee is examining. An API, an application programming interface, is essentially a standardized set of instructions that allow two different computer systems to communicate securely and in real time. The most intuitive analogy is an electrical outlet. The outlet in your home is a standardized interface. Any device with the right plug can connect to it and draw power without knowing anything about the underlying wiring. The utility company provides the electricity, and your device accesses it through that standardized connection. Treasury Prime's platform works the same way. We are the outlet. The bank is the utility, providing the regulated financial infrastructure: the deposit accounts, the payment rails, the FDIC insurance. The fintech is the appliance, the one with the innovative product and the customer experience. The API does not hold money or own data. It is a secure, real- time conduit, and the bank is integrated into every flow of funds at the transactional level. To understand why that architecture matters, it helps to understand the structural challenge that Treasury Prime was built to address. Community banks sit at the heart of American economic life, but the technology available to them has lagged far behind what customers now expect. That is the problem Treasury Prime was built to solve; to help community banks modernize in the world they are operating in today. Treasury Prime's bank operating system, the BankOS platform, bridges that connection, a modular software layer that links a bank's existing core systems to fintech and enterprise partners, synchronizing in real time. Bank-fintech partnerships built on this kind of infrastructure are not a convenience for the financial system. They are how millions of Americans, particularly those who have been historically excluded by traditional channels, access basic financial services today. Consider Atlas, a fintech company on our platform that offers a 0 percent APR credit card designed for consumers with no credit history. This is a population caught in a structural catch-22. You cannot build credit without access to credit, and you cannot access credit without credit history. Academy Bank, a Treasury Prime bank partner, provides the infrastructure and the compliance backbone. The fintech provides the underwriting innovation and the customer reach. Together, they have served over 100,000 active members, with users building credit scores by an average of 50 points in the first year. Well-structured bank-fintech partnerships do not dilute the bank's compliance obligations. They actually have the ability to strengthen the bank's ability to meet them. Our platform is built on the principle that the bank must own its data in real time, automated Know Your Customer (KYC)/anti-money laundering (AML) reporting and reconciliation, all through a single control center that gives the bank complete visibility. That is the standard model this subcommittee should come to expect of every partnership operating at scale. The regulatory response to these partnerships has too often been overbroad, causing many community banks with the intent to modernize responsibly to pause their strategies altogether and here is the reality of this dynamic. A regulatory posture that inadvertently discourages community banks from these partnerships does not inherently make banking safer. It makes community banks less competitive and ultimately drives customers outside the supervised perimeter entirely. Displacing activity to less regulated corners of the system is not consumer protection. It is risk transfer with no net gain. This subcommittee has an opportunity to provide the statutory clarity this ecosystem needs. Directing regulators to study the impact of bank-fintech partnerships on innovation is a great first step. Beyond that, we need a framework that creates uniform standards and calibrates supervisory resources to promote the investment that durable innovation requires. I have spent enough time at the intersection of regulation and innovation to know they are too often framed as opposing forces, as if safety requires slowness and innovation happens in spite of regulatory oversight rather than alongside it. Treasury Prime's experience and the experience of the community banks on our platform tell a different story. Banks that invest in strong governance infrastructure and genuine compliance capability are better positioned to innovate and move with confidence rather than uncertainty. The framework this subcommittee establishes should make both achievable at once, not as a compromise but rather as a design principle. I believe that is possible, and I am grateful for the opportunity to contribute to that effort. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Parikh follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much--thank you very much, Ms. Parikh. Ms. Khalili, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF ERICA KHALILI, CO-FOUNDER, CHIEF LEGAL & RISK OFFICER, LEAD BANK Ms. Khalili. Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Erica Khalili, and I am the co-founder and chief legal and risk officer of Lead Bank. Lead Bank is a community bank headquartered in Kansas City, Missouri and I have spent my career building compliance infrastructure for financial institutions operating at the intersection of technology and banking. I say that Lead is a community bank, but we are also a partner bank. We work with innovative fintech and digital assets companies to offer products and services that expand access in a compliant, technology-enabled manner. We have seen firsthand that strong compliance and sound technology enable fintech partners to innovate in ways that strengthen the banking system and open new lines of business for community banks. What distinguishes our model is a clear and deliberate allocation of responsibility. Lead owns every compliance stack, and Lead is accountable for the consumer experience of each and every product and service that we offer. Fintech partnerships extend the reach of our services but in no way do they displace our obligations. This is a key component of responsible bank- fintech partnership model. Lead's experience is consistent with broader data demonstrating that community banks that have built strong and sound partnerships have actually grown as a result. That being said, we have never lost sight of this business line--we have never lost sight with the inclusion of this business line of our Kansas City lineage and serving the local community and the agricultural sector. The risk management that is required to engage in a bank- fintech partnership is technically demanding. It requires fluency across bank regulation, best-in-class information security, software systems, data architecture, financial crimes compliance, and consumer protection. Before Lead enters into any partnership, we conduct robust technical and regulatory due diligence on every prospective partner but that is just one part of the process. Once engaged, the ongoing third-party relationship, our oversight framework includes governance, reporting obligations, contractual rights, and exit protocols sufficient to identify, escalate, and remediate compliance issues. Understanding each partner's business model is central to our compliance practices and to maintaining productive coordination with our regulators. The importance of bank-fintech partnerships to consumers is well-documented. For consumers, the financial products made possible by responsible bank-fintech partnerships represent a meaningful path to mainstream credit choice and access. These partnerships dramatically reduce the cost of reaching underserved sectors. Digital partnerships reduce customer acquisition costs from between $100 and $200 per customer down to $5 to $35, which is what makes it economically viable to serve populations that often larger institutions have concluded are not cost-effective to reach through traditional channels. Partnerships also support fintech underwriting tools that enable credit decisions based on a more complete picture of a borrower's financial condition. Individuals who depend on these responsible bank-fintech partnerships for access to products and services to meet their financial needs benefit from a well-calibrated regulatory framework that holds banks to rigorous standards while also enabling responsible innovation. With this in mind, Lead Bank appreciates the opportunity to offer the following policy recommendations. First, we support greater standardization of bank exam manuals across the prudential regulators, combined with investments in examiner training. The FDIC's Emerging Technology Team offers a useful model. By embedding specialized examiners alongside local exam teams, the FDIC has created a more iterative, dialog-driven process that clarifies regulatory expectations and sharpens the focus of exams on material risks. Second, Congress should affirm that the chartered bank is the true lender in a bona fide bank-fintech partnership with clear preemption. This concentrates accountability where it belongs: with the bank. Third, Congress should address the uncertainty created by the Tenth Circuit's decision in the National Association of Industrial Bankers v. Weiser, which held that out-of-State chartered banks must comply with Colorado's usury limits when lending to Colorado residents. If replicated elsewhere, State- chartered banks would face a fragmented, State-by-State compliance regime that constrains credit choice and availability and erodes competitive parity between State and national banks. This is exactly what Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act (DIDMCA) was designed to preserve. We support the American Lending Fairness Act, introduced by Representative Davidson and Senator Moreno, which aims to resolve this uncertainty. Bank-fintech partnerships, when approached responsibly, expand access to financial products and services for consumers underserved by traditional banking channels and strengthen our community banks, which are the lifeblood of America. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Khalili follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. We will now turn to member questions. I recognize myself for 5 minutes for questions. I will start with you, if I can, Ms. Barrage. I want you just to help me level-set, not only what the landscape looks like today, but what market trends are you seeing that are shaping these arrangements into the future. I think we all look and think about the familiar--our familiarity with banking-as- a-service. That is just one example. What market trends--and succinctly--are you seeing in the bank-fintech relationship? Ms. Barrage. I am seeing a tremendous amount---- Chairman Steil. Can I just check your microphone, if it is on? Ms. Barrage. Is this better? Thank you. Thank you for the question. The types of arrangements that we are seeing are very focused on digital assets and AI, consistent with the mandate of this subcommittee. We are seeing banks looking to third parties to help them do digital asset custody, so on-chain activities. We are seeing banks band together to figure out how they are going to do tokenized deposits with fintech parties. We are also seeing some banks publicly partner with exchanges to allow their customers to buy, sell, and hold crypto. There are a wide variety of these types of arrangements. I think they will continue. On the AI side, as my testimony describes, I feel like there are a lot of opportunities for upskilling in this area. Chairman Steil. Are you also seeing uptake by smaller banks, community banks in fintech? What is the trend line you are observing there? Ms. Barrage. I think over the past 5 years, we have seen--I personally have seen fewer community banks engaging in these partnerships. That may be a result of the 2023, 2024 events that I discussed earlier. That said, there are some that do these types of partnerships very effectively. They are well risk-managed. They have experts at the bank, and I think some of the testimony today bears that out. It is a mixed bag. Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. Let me jump to you, Ms. Thomas, if I can. We are looking at all these new financial products that are coming to market that are often raising questions about how easily they fit under our existing financial services regulatory framework and under what legal structures--such as bank charter, money laundering--money transmitting licenses--best aligns with fintech based on the product and on the size. Can you describe the factors that informed your firm's decision regarding which licenses and regulatory structures to pursue? Ms. Thomas. Absolutely. Thank you for the question, Chairman. Our licensing approach is generally driven--is generally driven by a desire that supports small businesses. That is at the core of what we--core of our purpose and we provide them-- so that we can provide them with the best tools to effectively run their business. Our accounting platform, for example, itself does not require Federal financial services--Federal financial licenses because we do not hold customer money or extend credit. That said, we have found that giving our customer--users and our customers the ability to process payments directly on the Xero platform provides valuable time-saving. As I have discussed in my testimony, that has led us to look at ways in which we can provide those sort of services, which led us to acquire payment services, a business recently, that holds money transmitting licenses that allows our customers better access to payments. In addition to that, we also operate, as every other corporation, under SOC 2/ISO certifications and the applicable customer and data protection frameworks that apply. Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. Let me come to you, Ms. Parikh, if I can. I want to come back to what I was--what we were speaking about at the beginning with Ms. Barrage. Can you describe the interest you are seeing in fintech partnerships from smaller institutions and what change you are seeing in this space most recently? Ms. Parikh. Sure. I think I cite to this research in the written testimony but, unequivocally, community banks are very interested in these partnerships, but if you look at the number of community banks that can actually convert, there has definitely been a chilling effect, particularly in the post- 2024 era where we saw a lot of consent orders disproportionately, some will say, against partner banks. I think by Q1 2024, we saw almost 35 percent of all consent orders were directed at partner banks in this space and so that has definitely had a trickle-down effect where community banks that need these partnerships to stay relevant are very hesitant for that reason to enter into them. Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. I appreciate all of your testimony here today. I yield back. I now recognize the ranking member of our Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Mr. Lynch of Massachusetts, for 5 minutes. Mr. Lynch. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I want to thank all the witnesses. This is a really important topic. While we have benefited greatly, I think, in this country from technological innovations in the area of finance--there is no question about that--but from where I sit, most of that technological change has been in support of the traditional banking system, with all the safeguards for depositors and people who take out loans, and there has been a reaffirming aspect of all those fundamental protections that are put out there for consumers. If you look at the culture of these two industries, banking in our country and banking regulations have been the result of--you can actually--if you read the banking regulations, it is almost like a chronology of this--the market failures in this country. You go back to the Great Depression. We ended up with bank failures, so we put in the FDIC, Ms. Barrage. We had stock market crash. We put in regulations around stock trading and the use of leverage. You go forward where we had the stock market crash of 1987. We put in provisions that might prevent that from happening again. We have got the savings and loan crisis. Major, major regulatory changes after that. We had the global financial crisis. If you read, all of that--all of that is in response to market failures and that was the culture because we learned from the disasters that we experienced. Now, we have fintech coming in and technology in general, and the culture there is to move fast and break things. This is the Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial Intelligence. So, this is the crossroads of where all this happens and it is the same for fintech as it is for crypto, as it is for AI. They come here and they fight regulation like hell. They do not want to be regulated, and they spend millions and millions of dollars trying to persuade Members of Congress to give light-touch regulation or no regulation or self-regulation to the industries. I see that continually. It is just a drumbeat. Some of these countries--some of these companies are so big now--trillion-dollar companies with market cap over a trillion dollars--that their power is only increasing and their influence is only increasing. How do we resolve that? Ms. Khalili, how do we--how do we protect--how do we maintain the protections that we have afforded to depositors and to businesses and fair lending and, yet, onboard some of this technology that we agree is very important and transformative in many ways and may, in fact, help to bank the unbanked? So there is some good here, but we are trying to get the good and then hold back on the things that we think will undermine the legitimacy and integrity of the financial system. Ms. Khalili. Thank you so much for the question, Congressman, and I think that is a great example of where the bank-fintech partnership model is actually massively accretive. In this model, you have the fintechs who are able to manage the distribution channel and the product innovation side, but the best partners that make it onto Lead's platform are those that view this as a partnership and not a vendor relationship. Mr. Lynch. Yes, yes. Ms. Khalili. Meaning that we have to understand the products and services that we are offering, and we remain responsible for ensuring that they maintain and adhere to all bank regulatory standards. We are sort of where the buck stops, so to speak. So, that is the internal check that you have for these technology companies as they are iterating, and it keeps it grounded in the most important regulations that protect our consumers and also protect the general safety and soundness of the financial system. I think this is a way where we ensure that the fair lending considerations are taken into account, we make sure that the complaints are being monitored, we make sure that all of these things remain regulatory-compliant, and then we discuss them with our regulatory bodies on a regular basis to ensure that there is never any surprises and that it is an iterative process versus a, quote/unquote, move fast and break things model. Mr. Lynch. Yes. Ms. Parikh, what do you think? Ms. Parikh. Yes. I do not see the two as binary, and I think what we see in our experience is there is not a need for not having regulation. It is ensuring that the regulation is tailored to the risks we are seeing. A lot of the fintech partners we are working with want to be compliant, they want engagement, and there is a very healthy partnership with their banks because they understand the space they are in. Mr. Lynch. I yield back. Thank you. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The chair recognizes the vice chairman of the full committee, Mr. Huizenga of Michigan, for 5 minutes. Mr. Huizenga. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am going to take a moment here of personal privilege, if that is okay, to acknowledge the passing of Barney Frank as well. I am, on this subcommittee at least, the only Republican who had the opportunity to serve with him. I was a freshman. He was in his last term. While I disagreed with him on many things, I did respect him. I actually had a unique opportunity. He and I became cosponsors of a bill that my predecessor had worked on with Mr. Frank regarding Federal Prison Industries and what was happening with that. Mr. Lynch is nodding his head. He remembers a number of those debates. Massachusetts had lost a lot of glove and textile industries. In Michigan, we lost a lot of office furniture opportunities to Federal Prison Industries, and I had the unique opportunity to work with Barney Frank. He also then provided me with the opportunity to really test myself on the House floor. At one point, I was--for some reason, as a freshman, I was given the opportunity to be the counter voice to him as the ranking member on a housing bill and it might be--my background in housing might have had something to do with it. I took a moment and I debated and I debated and I debated inside my head whether I should ask the gentleman to yield, and I did. I finally did and he looked at me much like a cheetah would look at a limping gazelle at the back of the herd and very gladly said, I would be happy to yield to the gentleman, knowing that he was ready to pounce at any moment. I got my point in so succinctly and, I think, to the point that he pounded the lectern and demanded, I regain my time. I take my time back and he started yelling into the microphone. I knew I had arrived, that I could actually do this job here in Congress, that I could go and battle back and forth with Barney Frank while working with him on another piece of legislation. I think that is just illustrative of what Barney Frank was. He was someone that would be an amazing ally but could also be a formidable foe all within a span of a very short period of time. So, blessings to his family and his memory. I appreciate that opportunity to share that moment. Moving on to our hearing here, Ms. Steinberg Barrage, I would like to ask you. We have seen supervisory attention to bank-fintech arrangements accelerate, particularly under the Biden Administration, in my opinion but several witnesses have noted material examiner expertise gaps. I think that is a polite way of saying we have got regulators that are not up to speed necessarily. In fact, GAO had a 2023 report which flagged the need for examiner upskilling--that was their term--in fintech, IT, digital assets, and it seemed your statements echoed this. I personally had a couple of weeks ago an opportunity to spend 4 days in Silicon Valley looking at tech, looking at sort of innovation that is happening. Frankly, I was struck by the speed of innovation, the speed of change in technology, and I was--I think it underscored my fear and the fear that many have, is that regulations and regulators are not keeping up with the speed of change in business. That is not unusual, but we are seeing it in hyperdrive now here with this fintech side of things. I am curious, how can--and I assume you believe that agencies should, but how should and how can these agencies close these knowledge gaps, and what impact is there if they do not do that? Ms. Barrage. Thank you for the question and for sharing those observations. I have those same observations in my practice. I feel like I am always on a learning curve and I am learning from our clients. I think technology moves in real time, and our regulatory agencies do not, and they do not have time to pivot. Closing that gap is perhaps the wrong goal. Addressing that gap robustly and thoughtfully, I would say, is the goal, because it is going to be impossible to always close that--or any time close that gap. What can we do? I think we need to find the examiners on the ground who need the expertise following the GAO report. I think Ms. Khalili had a great example of how the FDIC is embedding subject matter experts on their exam teams. To the extent the other agencies are doing that, I think---- Mr. Huizenga. Are they on loan, or are they from other areas, or are they from private sector coming in for a period of time, or are they actually adding them to their staffing? Ms. Barrage. My understanding is that they are from the FDIC, but they are just being redeployed for different types of exams, for different partnerships. Mr. Huizenga. Okay. Ms. Barrage. Obviously, I would support that. I also think that we need to be willing to invite private sector collaboration without fear of enforcement or something like that. We can do this in a way that is anonymized, that is addressing the gap, that is also giving staff the ability to engage directly with the technology, which probably is not happening as often as it should. So, those are just some ways. Mr. Huizenga. Apprec---Okay. Ms. Barrage. There are probably other ways too, but those are the ones that I---- Mr. Huizenga. Appreciate that. Ms. Khalili, you were referenced in that, if you want to just--and I do have a question for you as well, but if you want to quickly just shed some light on the FDIC situation. Ms. Khalili. Yes. We have experienced--as a bank that is prominent in the bank partnership sector as well as digital assets, we have seen our exam teams now comprised with subject matter expertise from the DC office that come specifically with respect to those novel activities that we engage in. We find that to be incredibly accretive during a bank examination because there is more of an open dialog and there is more depth in the understanding, which then leads to a better evaluation of the material risks associated with the activities. I think one other thing that I see as a big need is both industry and the banking community need to increase their transparency. At Lead, we meet with our regulators at least quarterly so that they know exactly what we are doing, and we answer questions in a collaborative manner, because we do recognize, especially for our region, specifically with respect to our banking-as-a-service and our digital assets partnerships, this is something that we are the only bank doing. Mr. Huizenga. Can you explain a little bit about the pre- launch, and what might be happening there? What is going to happen if consumers--how would they--how would they potentially lose out if policymakers made it harder for bank and fintechs to work together? Ms. Khalili. I think with the fintech innovation that we are seeing, we are seeing things like credit that is opening the aperture of those that responsible credit can be extended to, and that is something that is incredibly important. I think Ms. Parikh mentioned a credit card that was targeted to people with low credit at a 0 percent APR that assists them to build. That is something that, from the customer acquisition cost, a traditional bank would never be able to offer and needs the digital distribution and the innovation of their fintech partners to be able to do in a cost-effective and accretive manner. This is one example where you see customers being protected and actually great products and services that they desire being offered to them. Mr. Huizenga. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. Representative Garcia of Texas is recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Garcia. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all the witnesses today who are here with us. There is no debating that this industry, the financial system, should continue to innovate and leverage new technology. I chose to become a member of this subcommittee to make sure that as we discuss the adoption of financial technology, we keep underserved communities in mind. Too often they are left behind. I represent a district that has been historically excluded from the traditional banking system. Unfortunately, we are not able to hear from the Democratic witness, Mrs. Spotser, today. However, in her written testimony, she wrote about the wide spectrum of bank-fintech partnerships with the arrangements at one end generally expanding access and arrangements at the other end evading consumer protection rules. Ms. Barrage, given your experience of working in the bank- fintech space, what have you seen more of; arrangements that increase access or arrangements that put consumers further at risk? Ms. Barrage. I would say, across the board, the arrangements that I have worked on are not really falling into either one of those buckets necessarily. I think that the arrangements that I work on either from the technology side or the bank side are very well risk-managed arrangements. Some of them do touch consumers and others are business-to-business (B2B) products. For the ones that have addressed more of the consumer side, I think that there has been a real understanding through some of the models and some of the credit decisioning that fintechs often use that better approaches and expands access to more consumers on the credit side. Ms. Garcia. Well, you said in your testimony, however, that one of the challenges was managing risk. Yet, you do not think that alone would put it in one of the risk buckets? Ms. Barrage. I think managing risk is always an important thing for both the bank and the technology company to do. That does not change across any partnership, but I do think that there is an important lesson to be taken from the 2022, 2023 set of--sorry--the 2022, 2023 set of consent orders. If you look at those consent orders, some of them touched on fair credit. Some of them touched on Bank Secrecy Act (BSA)/ AML. In fact, many of them did. It really depends on the type of partnership. I think that we should learn from the lessons of that period and make sure we do not repeat those lessons, and part of that is going to involve a really important focus on understanding and describing the products to consumers so that they understand---- Ms. Garcia. My concern is simply, if we are expanding and embarking on new partnerships, we should do it for access and convenience for--not only for the customers that you have but to reach the unbanked and the underbanked. Mrs. Spotser also clarified in her written testimony that the partnership should expand access that are safe and affordable, and I completely agree. Access is great, but the quality of access is even more important. Ms. Thomas, you also mentioned the importance of safety a few times in your testimony. Can you discuss why simply increasing access is not enough and we need to make sure that it is safe and affordable, especially as we keep in mind the communities that are unbanked and underbanked? I think, Ms. Khalili, you put--in your testimony, you have the--you noted that 4.2 percent in 2023 were unbanked and an additional 14.2 percent were underbanked. Can we make sure that these communities are kept in mind? No, the question was for you, Ms. Thomas. Ms. Thomas. Oh, thank you. Ms. Garcia. No, I just referenced that she put the--she talked about it too, but she put the stats in her written testimony. Ms. Thomas. Absolutely. Thank you very much. Absolutely, those communities should be kept in mind. I think the balance is ensuring that there is safety in the way regulation is administered but also accessibility to those communities and I think, as Ms. Barrage mentioned, having-- looking at the commensurate risk of the way you--of the way those systems work is going to be quite important in ensuring that those communities are also taken into account. Ms. Garcia. Well, also in her testimony, she noted that a recent study showed that 67 percent of Black Gen Z respondents aspire to own businesses, 55 percent of Hispanic Gen Zs share that aspiration. We certainly have to make sure that there is safe and affordable access for them so that they can grow their wealth, and that is a deep concern of mine. Thank you. I hear the gavel, so I need to wrap it up. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentlewoman yields back. The gentleman from Arkansas, the chairman of the full committee, Chairman Hill, is recognized for 5 minutes. Chairman Hill. I appreciate the chairman. I thank our panel for being with us today. We are grateful to have your expertise. As somebody who has spent really the better part of their career in the intersection of finance and technology, I have seen firsthand throughout my experience that financial institutions' embrace of technology can really enhance consumer choice and improve Americans' financial lives in so many different ways, and also improve the operation of the institution from a compliance point of view and documentation point of view but we also have to recognize, and the purpose of this hearing today, is to think about the regulatory framework, if our bank supervisors and examiners got the training that they need. Are they properly accounting for these relationships? In the last year, we have seen some issues. We have seen, over the last 2 years--I would say the last 24 months--we have seen some fintech partnerships that did not work out so well where it was not clear in the due diligence responsibilities of the financial institution and of the fintech partner that they were in sync, which is a fundamental business obligation. It would not make any difference no matter what industry we are in. Ms. Barrage, let me start with you. What updates, if any, to that regulatory framework, such as the third-party risk management approach, do you think needs to be amended to better foster these partnerships and make sure there is more certainty that they are being conducted in the right way? Ms. Barrage. Thank you, Chairman Hill, for the question. First, I think we need to think about what should be regulated and what should not. Maybe there is a role for standards setting that helps fill some of those gaps. The reason I mention that is because these partnerships are so varied and they cover so many different products and so many different types of banks. We should give some thought to what we regulate and why. The guidance that has come out is purposely general. It does not apply to any one type of partnership. Where could we do better? I think across the board--to your earlier point--we would all here agree that examiner training is top of mind. It feels like low-hanging fruit. There has got to be a way we can collaborate with the private sector to get better and smarter, especially with these new types of technologies and new partnerships coming on. Chairman Hill. Thanks, and that is why Senator Rounds and I have approached the AI sandbox issue--and I do not want AI as a catch-all, but I believe strongly in the fintech sandbox issues too. I saw that in practice in Little Rock when Fidelity National Information Services (FIS) had their sandbox as a core processor for all the community banks to come participate, and all the examiners from the regional offices at the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the FDIC came and actively participated in that. I think that kind of give-and- take is important. I take for granted all safeguards in a sandbox should be met, so timeframe, exact features, full approval. I recognize that, but I am concerned that maybe we do not have people trained well enough to look at novel risks. As a bank CEO, I also believe that it is the board of directors and the due diligence of the board of directors and the management team in any partnership at the bank, any vendor of the bank but what is a little different here is the operational integration of the fintech and the bank. That is a deeper, quote, vendor-type relationship. It really is a partnership and things can go wrong, and when they go wrong, go wrong badly, as we saw summer before last. Ms. Parikh, could you describe how Treasury Prime solutions offer due diligence and risk management tools for both banks and fintechs to use? Ms. Parikh. Yes, absolutely. It is interesting you mentioned Fiserv or FIS, because we see ourselves very much akin to those core technology providers and so the way we see our technology is we are actually enabling risk management by building it in directly into the tech. For example, you look at fintech onboarding. Our banks have tools to actually be able to identify from whether that is a funding perspective or whether it is a business continuity, really being able to isolate specific risks, and then making sure that the fintechs they are partnering with have risk mitigation strategies in place. So, you could automate that through the tech itself, and it is no different than how bank core technology companies--like the FISs and the Fiservs--are doing it today. Chairman Hill. I think it is important, and I think just having this template in place will help examiner training, but it will also help those boards ask the right questions on something as fundamental as a really significant business relationship. I thank the chairman. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from California, Mr. Liccardo, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Liccardo. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I want to thank our other chair for his comments this morning. I recall there were some statements that Chairman Hill made about the importance of having hearings on the topic--which we look forward to--on payment processing and the imperative for or at least an interest in a nationwide payments licensing regime--which is certainly something I strongly support--rather than being reliant on State-by-State regulation. I wanted to ask a question of Ms. Thomas, because I know you have responsibility over regulatory compliance and risk mitigation for a prominent company, fintech. Partnership between fintechs and banks is certainly the subject of the hearing. They are helpful, certainly, but there is also competition in some submarkets. When it comes to protecting consumers and reducing fees, that competition can be pretty important. I think you are aware that Congresswoman Kim and I have introduced a bipartisan bill, the Payment Access and Consumer Efficiency (PACE) Act, to help reduce fees and accelerate payments processing for millions of Americans by offering fintechs an opportunity to get access to the Federal payment rails--ACH and others--with a Federal license. Now, I know that there is some disagreement within the financial services industry, so I hear, and I think the Federal Governor--Governor Waller expressed he was hearing quite a bit from all sides. What I am hearing certainly from the banking industry is concerns about whether or not these companies will be appropriately regulated with KYC and anti-money laundering regulations, and I am also hearing concerns about deposit flights, that diverting deposits away from insured banks will reduce capital available for lending. Congresswoman Kim and I attempted to address these concerns in the text of the PACE Act by ensuring that fintechs that participate, that get the Federal license would have Know Your Customer and anti-money laundering requirements--that would be Federal--and that there would be no ability for companies to engage in maturity transformation as taking deposits and engaging in lending and so funds with a one-to-one reserve requirement would still be sitting likely at a depository institution. Mr. Liccardo. I would like to think that we might get the benefit of competition--that is, removing a costly layer in this process that we know is imposing many, many millions of dollars in fees on Americans who need payments processing for everything from being able to make their downpayment on a home to being able to provide remittances to families who critically need them at home. Is it accurate to say that an approach like this could actually enhance the partnership between banks and fintechs to allow each entity, each institution do what it does best, which is allow banks to focus on lending and deposits and allow fintechs to accelerate our financial system, to the betterment of consumers, who would pay much less? Ms. Thomas. Thank you for question, Congressman. The short answer would be, yes. I think any type of collaboration in that way and clear definition of roles and some clear guidelines on how to ensure that the industry remains regulated and also, to your earlier point, ensuring that consumers--there is protection for consumers from a KYC, an AML perspective is important. I think the policy objective of ensuring that there is better access to payments for consumers and for small businesses is something that we would support, and happy to have a further conversation about that. Mr. Liccardo. Thank you. I appreciate that and I hope that we will, obviously, continue the conversation not just with our fintech partners but also folks in the banking industry because I think that a lot of work has been done to ensure that this license is one that does not intrude on or impose too much on their key competency around deposits and lending. I realize that I am just about out of time, so I will yield at this time. Thank you. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from Ohio, the chair of the Subcommittee on National Security, Mr. Davidson, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Davidson. Thank you, Chairman. To our witnesses, thank you for being here today. Your preparation, your written testimony, really appreciate it, and helping us clarify bank-fintech partnerships here. Mr.--or, sorry, Ms. Parikh, I wanted to talk with you about the Bank Secrecy Act. Just looking at it, as we apply it to bank-fintech partnerships, one of the most basic things is, who is bound by their obligations under the Bank Secrecy Act? Is there any shift of responsibility and what kind of compliance things should we give attention to in an era where bank-fintech partnerships are incredibly important, and maybe particularly with respect to payments? Ms. Parikh. That is a great question. Thanks for the question. I think what is interesting in our model is, these are still bank accounts, so the bank still has all of its regulatory obligations, particularly under the BSA/AML regime, and so that does not change. I think what we do see change and where tech is actually enhancing our ability to detect risk is, we see the changing anomalies in the risk patterns. For example, in your traditional deposit account, you see something like structuring, which is cash coming in and cash coming out. That is not necessarily a risk you see with digital payments or payments in general in the digital world. It is more money moving quickly between payment rails like ACH. We have actually been able to use--with regulatory technology (RegTech) and specified tools to actually identify risks that are endemic to electronic payments and so it is evolving how we calibrate risk and the types of risks and the patterns and the anomalies that we are looking at. Mr. Davidson. Is there anything that changes there? Because, traditionally, with account-based relationships, kind of, there is daily or over-the-weekend netting, versus going to blockchain-based, real-time payments, you have a clear chain of custody, but it is real-time and 24/7, in theory. Ms. Parikh. Sure. Mr. Davidson. So, compliance and oversight for that, how does that change? Ms. Parikh. Yes. I mean, the way we have dealt with it is, we adhere to the banks'--the banks already--for example, for ACH, we look at the windows that already exist and then look at the type of risk to see if you need any additional coverage, but it is no less than what already exists today. Then, honestly, with digital channels, that has to be 24/7 with--with risk. Mr. Davidson. Yes. Just to confirm, under the law, all the obligations that a bank would have to account-based customers, people who have accounts with financial institutions, whether they are using a payment card or other things--regardless of how the bank does the back-end fintech partnership, they are still obligated to provide, kind of, the risk mitigation that you do say, on a Visa/Mastercard kind of payment. Was there fraud? Was there payment? Can the account be done? Those are still the law, right? Ms. Parikh. Absolutely. Those are absolutely still true. I think what changes is, sometimes the banks can lean on the fintechs, who often are the face of the applications, to get additional context to determine but the bank still has that responsibility, and the fintechs respect that, in our opinion. Mr. Davidson. Yes. I am intrigued by Mr. Liccardo's reference to the PACE Act. I have not co-sponsored it yet, but when you look at the skinny master account, fintechs are not really included in that. Custodia Bank, for example, complied with the letter of the law under the Fed's statement, and if you do these things, then ``shall issue'' is the standard. Of course, they were not issued an account. Now, they are leaning on language that basically says, ``Well, you are not really one of us.'' How do you change the status quo there and facilitate what the consumer demand is in payments? Ms. Parikh. Yes. I think we have focused a lot of the accessibility question to consumer accessibility, but I think a really important part of that question is bank accessibility. So you look at payment rails like Real-Time Payments (RTP) and FedNow; those are rails that are not often available to smaller community banks. To your point, this issue of creating better access and having innovative technology fills that gap is, I think, going to make sure community banks have the same access as well. Mr. Davidson. Yes, you think about payments, for example, it is--and you mentioned smaller community banks. A lot of them are State-chartered banks and we are dealing with a fixed endemic, where Colorado and other States are trying to basically regulate banks as if an Ohio bank is based in Colorado. Well, they are regulated in Ohio and there are supposed to be Federal preemptions so you can bank customers, including people from Colorado, but they want to apply Colorado's laws to them. Do we need a fix here in Congress to clarify what I think the plain meaning of words are, but Colorado and other States have done? Would that help if we had a law that clarified that? Ms. Parikh. I think there is a need for a lot of clarity in general with the regulatory regime and how it applies to evolving technologies. Mr. Davidson. All right. Last thing, peer-to-peer payments, digital cash, things like that. If the custodian is the individual, how is that different than cash? Do the banks have any other obligation, in the sense that--same kind of thing that they would have in a cash payment if they moved it to a self-hosted wallet and they had custody of their own resources? You can respond in writing, or any of our witnesses, to that, kind of open-ended question. Mr. Davidson. Thanks, Chairman, for this hearing, and I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The Representative from Florida, Mr. Haridopolos, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Haridopolos. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate the opportunity. I appreciate the candor of the witnesses as well. Ms. Thomas, this first question is for you, if you do not mind. In general, one of the goals that I think we should always have is to try to take the mystery or fear out of handling new technology and, with that, especially the advancements we are trying to make to make it more accessible to everyone and they do not fear that something nefarious might happen. Getting into the regulatory environment, what gray areas are making it more difficult for fintech companies to serve not only businesses but, most importantly, the consumers? Ms. Thomas. Thank you for the question, Congressman. It is a good question. I think I would look at it more from the perspective of education rather than gray areas. I think what we find is that better alignment, clarity, and guidance will better serve the participants in the industry. I think having regulators that have that shared understanding and knowledge of the constraints that industry faces and, much like regulators understanding what constraints industry faces, for industry to also understand the challenges that regulators there are facing, too, and their drivers. I think coming together for an open dialog is what will help--will help that greater clarity, alignment, and also provide--provide an opportunity for regulation to be proportionate and perhaps dispense with some of those gray areas that might exist. Mr. Haridopolos. Okay. Thank you, Ms. Thomas. I am going to ask Ms. Khalili and also Parikh this question, if I could. First, Ms. Khalili, can you give us, kind of, some real- world examples of how fintech partnerships are helping some small businesses access credit and handle money-management tools more effectively? Ms. Khalili. Absolutely, and thank you so much for the question. I think one of the key principles is also the speed with which money moves, the velocity. As a small business, it is often using very slim margins. The need for cash in a very fast manner is very much paramount to them right now. So, the introduction of FedNow, RTP, and even stablecoins as a payment rail allows small businesses and consumers, who perhaps do not generally have access to these rails, to access them in a compliant manner when the bank is offering those services in partnership with one of their fintechs. I think we have also talked a lot about access to credit and also choice in credit. This is where we see the nontraditional underwriting metrics that are often utilized in these sort of fintech-bank-partnership relationships really accrete to a broader credit box that is still safe and sound by utilizing nontraditional metrics that really allow you to see the full health and wellness of a business rather than--in real-time versus as a trailing last month's bank statement sort of thing---- Mr. Haridopolos. Uh-huh. Ms. Khalili [continuing]. which I think then allows for more products and services to be offered to the people that are most in need of them. Mr. Haridopolos. Thank you. Ms. Parikh as well? Ms. Parikh. I referenced a fintech we work with, with a partner bank, that offers a zero-percent APR credit card, and this is really a segment of a population that has not traditionally had access to credit. We have seen that is one of our fastest-growing fintechs and with the bank, they are growing responsibly. We have also seen examples in, kind of, the B2B space where we have a bank partner working with a fintech trying to innovate on Treasury management services. Oftentimes, if you are a smaller bank, you do not necessarily have access to the same tools and so we have seen innovation in, kind of, the space of neo-banking and Treasury management. Then, also, we have a fintech that is offering-- revolutionize the venture capital experience, so allowing access for, kind of, everyday Americans to participate in venture capital (VC) funding through the way that the bank- fintech innovation has grown. Mr. Haridopolos. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I would just say, I appreciate you holding this hearing today. I think it is so vital that the access to markets is so important and taking away some of the mystery from this new, emerging industry. I am excited because, again, it provides the opportunity for everyone to access capital, when in years past it was just such a barrier they could never gain access to that capital. That is the beauty of technology, is, eventually, not only improving the speed as you just brought up, but also they are eventually lowering the cost because this will build a more competitive marketplace. The best way to take care of consumers and knowing--knowing that, whoever they are doing business with, if they do not provide the necessary services, a bunch of competitors who are willing to take up and meet the needs of the consumer. Thanks for holding this meeting, Mr. Chairman and this is very much necessary information as we tackle this new technology. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from South Carolina, Representative Timmons, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Timmons. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses for joining us today. As this subcommittee continues to examine how emerging technologies are becoming more integrated into everyday finance, innovative partnerships between banks and fintech firms are helping make financial services more efficient and more accessible for consumers and small businesses. These partnerships are modernizing payments, expanding access to financial tools, and helping community banks compete in a rapidly changing economy. They also give consumers faster and more convenient ways to manage their finances in an increasingly digital world. At the same time, banks must continue to uphold strong standards for consumer protection, data security, and financial integrity. This hearing provides an important opportunity to discuss how Congress and regulators can support responsible innovation while maintaining trust in our financial system. Ms. Barrage, you have served both at the FDIC and in the private sector advising institutions navigating the current supervisory environment. From your perspective, how has the regulatory approach to bank-fintech partnerships evolved across recent administrations and what impact has that had on innovation and on supervisory expectations for banks seeking to partner with fintech firms? Ms. Barrage. Thank you for the question. I would say, at a very high level, just over the past 5 years, we have seen tremendous growth in some of these partnerships, going back to 2021, 2022. We saw, in many ways, a reckoning, sort of that middle period, where there was a lot more regulatory scrutiny, and, frankly, there were banks and technology companies that were doing this irresponsibly. We have seen somewhat of a maturation in this process. I think that the supervisory issues are probably--are very much still there. They might not be as public, but we have more sophisticated banks and we have more sophisticated technology companies continuing to engage. In fact, we have some of these technology companies seeking to become banks themselves. That is how big they have scaled and how much they have learned from their sponsor-bank experiences. So, it has been a really interesting trajectory. In terms of where we are in the future, appreciate your comments. I think we need to double-down on engagement and education with private sector and we need to let banks, in a safe way, describe to their fintech partnerships--or to their fintech partners where there are issues and how we can remediate those to promote safety and soundness. So, that is where I hope our future is heading. Mr. Timmons. Thank you for that. During the Biden Administration, many institutions argued that regulators increasingly relied on informal pressure and enforcement actions rather than cleared guidance. How did that uncertainty affect banks' willingness to innovate or work with newer technology providers? Ms. Barrage. Well, I think part of the issue, just generally, with public consent orders is, as you are trying to read them and divine what the actual issues were, it can be very difficult. So, there definitely was a view that more specificity would be helpful. At the same time, we have confidential supervisory information to safeguard. It was difficult, I think, to really get at what those issues were and kind of reverse-engineer how we might do things better. I am hopeful that we have, as an industry, learned the lessons from the not-too-distant past. I think that additional guidance to banks and technology companies as well as upskilling on the examination side will hopefully support that. Mr. Timmons. Thank you for that. Ms. Khalili, you mentioned that digital partnerships can reduce customer acquisition costs from $100 to $200 down to as little as $5 to $35. Help me understand what that means in practice for consumers, especially individuals and small businesses in communities that large banks have often chosen not to serve. What kinds of products and services are firms like Lead providing today that were not widely available 5 years ago? Ms. Khalili. Thank you so much for the question. I think that, right now, what we are seeing is that these communities, or banking deserts, as I would call them, are being served because these products can now be sourced online in a digital manner. That reduces the acquisition costs materially, which then allows us to still open the account for a gig-economy worker or somebody who did not have a minimum that they could hold as a balance such that a larger institution may not be willing to take that on because it is not an economically viable solution. These fintech-bank partnerships have worked in tandem to create the products and services as a suite to not only increase the access to the product but also the choice that small businesses and consumers have. Some of the things that we have seen are access to faster payment rails, being able to get your money into your bank account sooner; being able access credit in a new way; being able to manage your Treasury function in a more technologically accretive manner and manage your money so that you are earning maximum yield on it. These are all things that these small businesses and consumers that were traditionally left out never had access to, and these partnerships now allow them to be reached. Mr. Timmons. Thank you for that. I am out of time. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Montana, Representative Downing, for 5 minutes. Mr. Downing. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses for being here. It has been a very interesting hearing, and I am happy we are having this hearing. Bank-fintech partnerships have the ability to make it easier for constituents in very rural areas to access banking services and Montana's 2nd District is very rural. We have more cows than people. It is incumbent upon Congress and our regulators to ensure our laws foster modernization and innovation. I am going to start with Ms. Khalili. I represent Montana's 2nd Congressional District, which is one of the most rural areas in the country and several of my counties have fewer than 500 people. I mean, rural-rural. How are you seeing these bank-fintech partnerships expand banking access to rural communities? Ms. Khalili. Thank you so much for the question. Again, these are areas where there is not a local community bank to serve them. Where there is a community bank, such as where we are in Kansas City, we service the local agricultural community's small businesses but with the digital partnerships, we now have an online solution, so we can serve customers not just in the Kansas City Metro area but throughout the country. These products and services can be accessed broadly and efficiently. I think that is a lot of where innovation drives from. I like to use the example of my father. Before the pandemic, I think remote deposit capture and peer-to-peer payments were things he would have never thought of using, despite the fact I have spent 20 years in the payments industry. These are things that now have become mainstream. Folks in your districts and your community can then access them online and have an equal playing field with those in New York City or somewhere else that have 12 banks on their street to serve them. Mr. Downing. Right. Thank you. I am going to turn to the role of States. As a former regulator, we dealt with a lot of regulatory sandboxes, a lot of fintech, insurtech issues. It was interesting as a regulator, because I would have a lot of people come into my office with great ideas that came from the innovation side but had never built anything in a regulated industry. These sandboxes, to some extent, gave them that ability to do that. Obviously, the role of the State regulators is important. I am going to move to Ms. Barrage. Can you discuss the roles that State regulators and State- chartered institutions play in fostering responsible innovation through bank-fintech partnerships? Ms. Barrage. Thank you for the question. I mean, I think both States and State-chartered banks play a very critical role. Going back to the DIDMCA discussion, I think there is a really important issue that is currently being litigated that would involve, potentially, a lot of these State-chartered banks wanting to be become nationally chartered banks, because some States are taking the view that loans made in their State are where their borrowers are located, and as we just heard, that is really not how loans are made, especially online. If we could get smarter on that, and we can avoid a situation where State-chartered banks no longer want to lend into certain States---- Mr. Downing. Uh-huh. Ms. Barrage [continuing]. I think that would be really important, again, in trying to serve the purposes of DIDMCA and to preserve our dual banking system. I am concerned that if we do not get that right, we will see a lot fewer State-chartered banks. Mr. Downing. Right. Thank you. I am going to move back to Ms. Khalili. One complaint that I hear frequently from community banks in Montana is how burdensome compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act and anti-money-laundering laws are. These laws play a role in combating illicit finance but have not been substantially updated since first passed in Congress in 1970. How can bank partnerships with fintech companies reduce the burden of complying with these laws? Ms. Khalili. Well, first and foremost, let me state that it is always the bank's obligation to comply with, and no matter how the bank-fintech partnership is structured, that should never be changing. That being said, I think that these partnerships also allow banks of all sizes to utilize a more technology-driven approach to compliance. Money is moving at a much faster velocity, and the way that the Bank Secrecy Act was initially drafted has not kept pace with the changes in technology but we, as banks that want to be good partners to law enforcement, must keep pace with the technology as it evolves. A lot of our fintech partners have real-time data being fed into Lead, where we can actually see anomalous patterns in real-time not only stop fraudulent actors but also immediately report to law enforcement to stop the bad actors. I think we are very much in favor of modernization, but, right now, I think where we are focused is how technology can unblock compliance and really turn compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act into a feature, not a bug. Mr. Downing. Right. In my last few seconds, in 2023, the OCC, FDIC, Federal Reserve issued joint guidance titled, ``Third-Party Relationships: Risk Management,'' which created the new challenges regarding BSA and AML compliance. Very briefly, in our last few seconds, can you discuss what those challenges are? Ms. Khalili. Again, I think that---- Chairman Steil. We may ask the witness to provide that answer for the record. Mr. Downing. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I yield. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. I would like to thank all of our witnesses for their testimony today. Without objection, all members will have 5 legislative days to submit additional written questions for the witnesses to the chair. The questions will be forwarded to the witnesses for their response. Witnesses will please respond no later than June 24. [The information referred can be found in the appendix.] Chairman Steil. We appreciate everyone's testimony today. A productive dialog. The hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:26 a.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- MATERIALS SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]