POLITICALLY VIOLENT ATTACKS: A THREAT TO OUR CONSTITUTIONAL ORDER

Senate Judiciary Committee Senate October 28, 2025

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[Senate Hearing 119-306]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-306

 POLITICALLY VIOLENT ATTACKS:
 A THREAT TO OUR CONSTITUTIONAL ORDER

=======================================================================

 HEARING

 before the

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CONSTITUTION

 OF THE

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 FIRST SESSION
 __________

 OCTOBER 28, 2025
 __________

 Serial No. J-119-46
 __________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary

 [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 
 
 
 www.judiciary.senate.gov
 www.govinfo.gov 
 ______
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE

62-928 WASHINGTON : 2026 
 

 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

 CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman
 
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member
MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island
TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware
THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey
ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California
KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California

 Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director
 Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director
 

 Subcommittee on the Constitution

 ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri, Chair
 
JOHN CORNYN, Texas PETER WELCH, Vermont, 
MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah Ranking Member
TED CRUZ, Texas SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey
MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee ALEX PADILLA, California
 ADAM B. SCHIFF, California

 Ethan Harper, Republican Chief Counsel
 Ryan Ferguson, Democratic Chief Counsel
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Page
Schmitt, Hon. Eric............................................... 1
Welch, Hon. Peter................................................ 4
Lee, Hon. Michael S.............................................. 5
Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 17

 WITNESSES

Braniff, William................................................. 10
 Prepared statement........................................... 37
Hodges, Daniel................................................... 14
 Prepared statement........................................... 62
Knowles, Michael................................................. 12
 Prepared statement........................................... 64
 Responses to written questions............................... 74
Shideler, Kyle................................................... 16
 Prepared statement........................................... 67
 Responses to written questions............................... 75
Wolf, Chad....................................................... 8
 Prepared statement........................................... 70
 Responses to written questions............................... 77

 APPENDIX

Items submitted for the record................................... 81

 
 POLITICALLY VIOLENT ATTACKS: 
 A THREAT TO OUR CONSTITUTIONAL ORDER

 ---------- 

 TUESDAY, OCTOBER 28, 2025

 United States Senate,
 Subcommittee on the Constitution,
 Committee on the Judiciary,
 Washington, DC.
 The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:32 p.m., in 
Room 226, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Eric Schmitt, 
Chair of the Subcommittee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Schmitt [presiding], Cornyn, Lee, Cruz, 
Hawley, Blackburn, Welch, Booker, and Padilla.
 Also present: Senator Durbin.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ERIC SCHMITT, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI

 Chair Schmitt. Okay. We will call this hearing of the 
Senate Judiciary Committee, Subcommittee on the Constitution, 
to order. The hearing for today is on politically violent 
attacks and the threat to our constitutional order. I will give 
my opening statement. Then we will go to the Ranking Member. 
And then after, we might do a second round of opening remarks, 
introduce the witnesses, swear you guys in, and then get 
rolling with questions.
 For the past 15 months, political violence has been a 
constant fact of American life. We have seen arsons and 
bombings, armed ambushes and assaults, sniper attacks and mass 
shootings, riots, and violent mobs on our city streets. We have 
seen assassinations, we have seen murder, we have seen death. 
None of this is random. It is organized, coordinated, political 
terror.
 The people behind this violence are not common street 
criminals. They are not driven by money or drugs or gangland 
turf disputes. They are determined, militant extremists who 
wield violence for political ends. They know that their vision 
would never win at the ballot box, so they have chosen 
terrorism instead. They know their ideas could not win in the 
marketplace of ideas, so they shoot up the marketplace.
 Last year, President Trump survived not one but two 
assassination attempts. In Butler, Pennsylvania, he escaped a 
sniper's bullet by a centimeter in a split second. Only weeks 
later, in West Palm Beach, another would-be assassin camped out 
for 12 hours in the brush outside of Trump International Golf 
Club, armed with a loaded rifle, burner phones, a GoPro, hoping 
to finish the job.
 Less than 2 months later, a healthcare CEO was gunned down 
in cold blood on a New York street by a left-wing extremist who 
called his victim a ``parasite'' who ``had it coming.'' Within 
days, left-wing activists had made the murderer a folk hero. In 
California, they pushed a ballot measure named in his honor. A 
poll taken 10 days after the murder found that nearly half of 
very liberal Americans had a favorable view of the killer, 
whereas just 8 percent of very conservative Americans felt the 
same.
 Then came an all-out war on immigration and customs 
enforcement. Across the country, Federal officers were hunted 
like prey. They were attacked, surrounded, ambushed, and shot 
at. Their facilities were firebombed. There were arrests for 
arson, for assault, for violent threats and doxing, but the 
violence continued to escalate.
 On July 4, 11 members of an Antifa terror cell carried out 
a coordinated ambush on an ICE facility in Texas. They arrived 
in two vehicles loaded with semiautomatic rifles, handguns, 
Molotov cocktails, body armor, and encrypted radios. Their gear 
was painted with a circle A for Antifa. They detonated 
fireworks to lure officers out into the open and then opened 
fire and kept shooting until their guns jammed. One cop was 
struck in the neck and critically wounded while racing to 
respond.
 Just 3 weeks later, a transgender shooter entered a 
Catholic elementary school in Minneapolis and opened fire on 
hundreds of children while they prayed. Dozens were wounded. 
Two little children, a 10-year-old girl and an 8-year-old boy, 
were killed. The shooter marked his guns with slogans like 
``Where is your God now?'' and posted videos using an image of 
Christ for target practice.
 Two weeks after that, Charlie Kirk was murdered while 
speaking to students in Utah. The killer told friends and 
family he did it because Charlie was ``full of hate.'' Social 
media exploded with gloating celebration. Thousands upon 
thousands of people, journalists, professors, and government 
employees, could not contain their glee that a father of two 
young children had been gunned down in broad daylight.
 When Americans gathered to mourn him, they were attacked 
there, too. In El Paso an arsonist set fire to a church holding 
a vigil in his memory. A week later, a man opened fire into an 
ABC news station in Sacramento just days after the network 
suspended Jimmy Kimmel's show. Police found anti-Trump writings 
in his car and a handwritten note that read, ``Patel, Bongino, 
and Pam Bondi, they are next.''
 And just last week, an anarchist radical was arrested for 
placing a $45,000 bounty on Pam Bondi, posting an image of the 
Attorney General with a sniper dot on her head. The caption 
read, wanted, ``dead or alive (preferably dead).''
 A week after the ABC shooting, a sniper opened fire on an 
ICE facility in Dallas, killing multiple people. Investigators 
recovered shell casings etched with the words, ``Anti-ICE.''
 And this month, a man who flew across the country to murder 
Justice Brett Kavanaugh received a sentence of just 8 years. He 
brought a gun, ammunition, a knife, duct tape, and zip ties to 
kill a sitting Supreme Court Justice in his own home while his 
wife and kids were present because he didn't like the way he 
might rule on gun control or abortion.
 This is the nature of political violence in America today. 
It is driven by a system far larger than the people who commit 
the act itself. We have seen this system in action. We have not 
forgotten what happened in 2020. Five years ago, violent mobs 
burned and looted their way through our cities. The press 
called the riots ``mostly peaceful,'' though. Ivy League 
academics celebrated them as righteous acts of resistance. The 
wealthy corporations in the world donated billions to keep them 
going. Vice Presidential candidates bailed rioters out of jail. 
Prosecutors declined charges. Judges released arsonists and 
anarchists just hours after their arrests. The same public 
health experts who banned funerals and shut down churches 
declared mass protests justified because ``Racism is a public 
health crisis.''
 Politicians reserve their outrage not for criminals 
torching police precincts but for the officers trying to defend 
them. The largest cities in the Nation slashed their police 
budgets by hundreds of millions of dollars, unleashing a deadly 
wave of violent crime on a scale not seen in decades, the 
largest single-year increase in murders in more than a century. 
The activists on the ground claimed to be revolutionaries 
fighting the powers that be, but the truth is they were backed 
by the full force of the ruling regime. The mobs that torch 
cities, the radicals who ambush ICE agents, the activists who 
terrorize judges at their homes, all of them are foot soldiers 
in the same regime, a regime whose foundational ideology is 
that we are born either as victims or oppressors, and it is the 
duty of revolutionaries to impose their vision of equity upon 
us all.
 This sustained campaign of violence is explicitly and 
specifically political. It is motivated by a distinct and 
fanatical ideology, rabidly anti-American, anti-Western, and 
anti-civilization itself. It is a worldview that indicts the 
United States as an illegitimate nation born in evil. By now, 
most Americans have heard this language. It has dominated our 
public life for years. These are not fringe ideas any longer.
 They have not just been tolerated but actively embraced, 
repeated, and amplified through the largest megaphones in our 
country. To my friends on the other side of the dais who may 
take offense with these categorizations, how often have we 
heard Democrats praise these radicals for their idealism? How 
many elected officials have called riots the ``language of the 
unheard?''
 The violence stalking our streets today is a feature not a 
bug. There is an evil but consistent logic to it. It is the 
natural and logical result of the ideology itself. If the 
violent element's ideals were so praiseworthy, then the system 
which obstructs their fulfillment is to blame. And why work 
within a blameworthy system for praiseworthy ends? To these 
people and this movement, the only acceptable goal is the 
destruction of the system and its leaders.
 The central idea of every revolutionary project is that 
utopia must be achieved through any means necessary. If you 
truly believe that Charlie Kirk is an existential threat to 
your safety, and you have bought into the nonsense that words 
are violence, then silencing him by any means could seem 
necessary. If you believe that mass migration is an inalienable 
right, then opening the floodgates to uncontrolled immigration, 
tearing down the border, and attacking those who defend it 
might look like justice to you. If you believe that America was 
conceived in murder and built on stolen land, then you feel no 
moral obligation to respect and obey its laws. If you truly 
believe the police are the armed enforcers of racist 
oppression, who indiscriminately murder innocent victims in the 
streets, then you might see violence against an officer as an 
act of brave resistance.
 When Charlie Kirk was murdered, one of his killer's bullets 
was engraved with the message, ``Hey fascist, catch.'' But who 
taught him that Charlie Kirk was a fascist? Who conserved him, 
who convinced him I should say, that Charlie's hate made his 
murder a righteous act? Who told him over and over again that 
people who believe what Charlie Kirk believe are threats to our 
democracy? He didn't invent that worldview, he learned it, as 
did each and every one of the arsonists, assassins, and 
militants who came before him. Perhaps the people in power who 
said these things didn't really believe them, but clearly some 
of the people who listened to them did. And now, they are 
taking those ideas to their final, logical conclusion.
 Enough. We are faced with only two paths. Either we 
confront this political violence and end it, or it will end us.
 And I can think of no better person to introduce this topic 
than the late Charlie Kirk himself. I am going to show a quick 
video before we go to the Ranking Member of him speaking on 
this precise subject, and I hope everyone would listen closely 
and heed his warning.
 [Video is shown.]
 Chair Schmitt. Ranking Member Welch.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. PETER WELCH, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF VERMONT

 Senator Welch. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and I 
want to thank the witnesses for being here today.
 I just want to make it clear, I am absolutely horrified by 
political violence in this country. And Senator Schmitt, today, 
just now, but at a hearing last month, you said, ``Political 
violence is always wrong,'' period, full stop. It doesn't 
matter which side, in the name of any ideology or cause, it is 
wrong.
 And Senator Schmitt, I agree with you, it is wrong, and all 
of us must condemn every act of violence that tears at the 
fabric of our society and is absolutely, totally corrosive to 
our democracy. And I think us as elected officials on both 
sides of the aisle, we have a significant duty to engage and 
disagree but with respect, unmotivated by hate. Our rhetoric 
matters, and we can reflect our commitment to representing our 
constituents aggressively, assertively, but without the kind of 
hatred that foments bad, bad, bad behavior. And political 
violence touches all Americans, regardless of their political 
affiliation.
 You know, I got involved in politics when I was involved in 
the Civil Rights Movement, and two of the people that I most 
admired in politics, Martin Luther King and Bobby Kennedy, were 
both assassinated. And I unequivocally condemn Mr. Kirk's 
assassination, unequivocally. I know Mr. Knowles, you were 
very, very close to him. I know Senator Schmitt was very, very 
close to him. And I know millions of Americans were inspired by 
him. I condemn that. Let me be clear, I condemn that killing.
 I just want to say this. The stakes are really too high for 
the American people and the health of our democracy to use this 
hearing as an opportunity to demonize one side or the other. If 
all violence, all political violence is wrong, is evil, is 
corrosive, the debate about where there is more on one side or 
the other, I don't see how that helps us get anywhere. 
Politicizing violence with inflammatory rhetoric has real 
consequences, so all of us have to turn that temperature down, 
those of us who are in public office, those of us who are in 
public life.
 You know, one of the things that happens when we have a 
reaction that is political and demonize it as being one side or 
the other is there can be governmental action that then starts 
suppressing the rights of all of our citizens, whether on the 
right or on the left. And we've got that history in our 
country. The Alien and Sedition Acts made it illegal to 
criticize the Government under the guise of national security.
 My predecessor, Matthew Lyon, Vermont Congressman, in 1797 
went to jail because he criticized President Adams. That was 
wrong. He ran for re-election, and Vermonters responded by re-
electing him from jail, standing up for his free speech rights.
 In the 1920's, we saw the Palmer Raids, and what happened 
there with illegal searches and seizures without arrest and 
without warrants and other constitutional attacks on the rights 
of organized labor and of everyday citizens under the name of 
going after ``the far left.'' And of course in the 1950's, 
McCarthyism fueled a campaign of fear and prosecution against 
left-wing groups--and I put that in quotes--until the Supreme 
Court stepped in to ensure civil rights and civil liberties 
were guaranteed.
 You know, I was listening to Mr. Kirk, and I do believe 
what he did, going on campuses to encourage dialog, was a good 
thing to do. That is what we should have, and there should be a 
civil reaction to that. But I am worried that if we are just 
going to use the violence that we all abhor to get into an 
argument about whether it is more left or more right, we kind 
of lose the point that it is all to be condemned.
 So I am willing to work with any and all of us to condemn 
political violence and renew our commitment to civility. And 
Mr. Chairman, he is not here, but I sent over to his office a 
resolution about civility that is just basic agreement to 
disagree but not to use invective or hate at all in our 
discourse.
 So my view, we can't stop the discussion by having it focus 
on whether it is left or right wing, not to leave that 
unexamined, but it has to be wholly and completely condemned. 
And I look forward to hearing from our witnesses about your 
suggestions and how we as a country can do better.
 And I yield to Senator Lee. Thank you.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MICHAEL S. LEE, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF UTAH

 Senator Lee. Thank you. I want to thank each of you for 
being here. I look forward to hearing your testimony.
 I am also very grateful to Senator Schmitt, Ranking Member 
Welch, and those who put together this hearing, working with 
them.
 Violence for the purpose of achieving political ends in the 
United States of America is itself un-American. It is something 
that is anathema to who we are as a people, and it must be 
universally condemned and should be regarded as an unthinkable 
relic of societies that manifestly lack the rule of law because 
it is.
 Our republic has regrettably become infected by a type of 
ideological cancer, one that tends to excuse even the most 
heinous acts so long as they can be said to achieve or somehow 
advance politically favored causes. Now, because of the way our 
news media tends to lean and a number of factors, those are 
often leftist causes that are embracing this. If they weren't, 
if it happened the other way, the media would serve as a check 
on that.
 The media doesn't always serve as a check on that when it 
comes from the left because very often a number of voices 
within the media tend to agree with those thoughts. I think 
that is part of how we get to the point where such a high 
percentage of those who identify themselves as part of the left 
are willing to say that murder of President Trump is morally 
justifiable. And other polls have come out since Charlie Kirk's 
assassination that show that trend getting worse, not better, 
just in the last few weeks.
 For examples of this alarming trend, one need look no 
further than the mostly peaceful burning of various American 
cities throughout the so-called Summer of Love in 2020, or the 
coddling of pro-Hamas and antisemitic mobs by university 
administrators just in the last year or two, and even the 
disgusting attempts to rationalize, excuse, and in many cases 
even praise the cold-blooded assassination of Charlie Kirk 
through grotesque distortions of his past public statements and 
otherwise. This must end.
 Today, this hearing gives us a real chance to reflect upon 
and confront this very disturbing and building trend within our 
society. It is not enough to state that political violence is 
wrong. We must expose it, call it out where it exists, and root 
out the forces that tend to enable it.
 Now, to those who would cite the First Amendment somehow in 
defense of actions that cannot be defended on their own merits, 
let us be very clear. Violence is not protected speech. Neither 
is incitement to violence or funding of violence or 
facilitation of violence, any more so than a conspiracy to 
commit violent acts would be protected by the First Amendment. 
These things are not. They are analytically distinct, legally 
constitutionally distinct from speech. They're not covered by 
the First Amendment. Indeed, the preservation of free speech 
itself depends on our ability to shield peaceful discourse from 
those who would silence dissent through any form of violence.
 Look, modern American society is the greatest civilization 
the world has ever known. Now, many on the other side of the 
aisle have decided that they ought to repeatedly engage in 
inflammatory, sometimes irresponsible rhetoric that creates 
permission, sort of establishes a permission structure, you 
might say, for violence directed at our civil institutions.
 As the Trump administration works tirelessly to safeguard 
Americans from this wave of criminal illegal aliens that have 
come through over the last four and a half years, many Democrat 
leaders have fought back tooth and nail, describing Federal law 
enforcement as a ``modern-day Gestapo,'' as ``slave patrols,'' 
as ``thugs,'' and as a ``collective terror force.''
 Despite multiple assassination attempts against Trump, it 
was and remains today fashionable in leftist circles to compare 
President Trump to Hitler and smear his supporters as fascists. 
What has been the result of this? Well, across the country, ICE 
agents have been under attack, personally, not just as a group. 
At an ICE facility in Texas, officers were attacked, with one 
even being shot in the neck. Investigators later found evidence 
of left-wing anarchist and anti-government ideology, anti-ICE 
slogans, Antifa imagery in online discussions specifically 
targeting Federal agencies. And yet again, much of the left 
either ignored the story altogether or blamed the Government 
for provoking the attack, and leftists in the media, meanwhile, 
did at best nothing to stop it, and in other cases, tended to 
foment it.
 This violence toward the executive branch is not itself 
isolated. In 2022, a California man boarded a plane to Maryland 
with a pistol, with ammunition, and with a fairly distinct 
plan. His goal. To assassinate Supreme Court Justice Brett 
Kavanaugh because he disagreed with the leaked ruling in the 
Dobbs case that would go on to overturn Roe v. Wade. He 
disagreed with that ruling. Therefore, he decided he had to 
kill this justice. He was consumed by far-left ideology and the 
belief that violence is justified somehow when our system does 
not result in the outcomes desired by the left. He later told 
investigators that he wanted to ``give his life'' by killing 
Brett Kavanaugh himself. That is not activism. That is 
radicalism. That is extremism. It is driven by the same 
ideology that calls violent protest resistance and dressing it 
up in as many euphemisms as people can find.
 Shockingly, some leftists suggest almost as a matter of 
routine that daring to question their misguided beliefs is akin 
to perpetuating violence against certain favored groups or 
disfavored groups. I hope we can find bipartisan consensus in 
condemning all political violence without reservation and 
without regard to the ideology of the person at whom the 
violence might be directed. To overcome the very worst 
instincts of human nature's somewhat natural tendency toward 
violence, although it is a tendency that can and must be 
suppressed in any free civilization, we must first remember 
that we are one nation and one people under God, united by 
bonds far stronger than any passing political moment or cause.
 Political violence, regardless of the alleged 
justification, regardless of the political beliefs of those 
embracing it or opposing it, will never and must never be 
tolerated by this body or by the United States of America.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Senator Welch. Thank you, Senator Lee.
 Would the witnesses please rise? I will now administer the 
oath.
 Would you raise your right hand, please, and answer this 
question?
 Do you swear that the testimony you are about to give this 
Committee will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the 
truth so help you God?
 [Witnesses are sworn in.]
 Senator Welch. Thank you. Thank you very much.
 And I want to introduce our first witness. It is Mr. Wolf. 
Thank you for being here, Mr. Wolf. And I understand that you 
have a very distinguished career. You serve as America First 
Policy Institute's executive vice president, chief strategy 
officer, and chair of AFPI's Homeland Security and Immigration 
Center.
 And I also understand, prior to that, you were acting 
secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. And 
during your time at DHS, you successfully navigated an 
incredible number of global and domestic challenges to the 
Nation's security, including COVID-19, civil unrest, numerous 
border and immigration crises, and historic natural disasters 
and threats to global aviation security. And I understand, too, 
that you serve now as president and founder of Wolf Global 
Advisors.
 Welcome. You may proceed.

 STATEMENT OF CHAD WOLF, EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT, CHIEF 
STRATEGY OFFICER AND CHAIR OF HOMELAND SECURITY AND IMMIGRATION 
 CENTER, AMERICA FIRST POLICY INSTITUTE, WASHINGTON, DC

 Mr. Wolf. Thank you, Chairman Schmitt, Ranking Member 
Welch, and Members of the Subcommittee, for the opportunity to 
testify today.
 Political speech and violence should never go hand in hand. 
I'm here today because I've seen this play out firsthand over 
the last several years and certainly during my time in 
government service. Let me be clear. I support those who 
lawfully exercise their constitutional rights, but when speech 
turns to violence, we must hold those committing violence 
accountable.
 The increase in politically motivated violence over the 
last several years has been driven largely by radical left-wing 
extremist groups and individuals that believe violence is a 
legitimate means to achieve political goals. A recent analysis 
by the Center for Strategic and International Studies shows 
that, ``left-wing violence has risen in the last 10 years, and 
left-wing incidents in 2025 are on track to reach 30-year 
highs.''
 A recent Rutgers University poll found that 55 percent, 
over half, of the respondents of left of center said it would 
be somewhat justified to murder President Trump and 48 percent 
said the same about Elon Musk. According to another recent 
poll, one in four people on the far left believe that violence 
can be justified. That is one in four. The data paints a 
disturbing picture that some on the left, especially younger 
adults, are increasingly supportive of violence as a form of 
protest.
 In 2020, as acting secretary of Homeland Security, I 
witnessed 100 consecutive nights of violence in Portland, 
Oregon. Every night, hundreds of violent anarchists surrounded 
the Hatfield Federal Courthouse. They hurled commercial-grade 
fireworks, sledgehammers, concrete, and even IEDs at our 
Federal officers. They set fire, they vandalized property, and 
assaulted law enforcement. Their goal was not peaceful protest. 
It was destruction, coercion, and intimidation.
 At the time, I pleaded with local officials, including the 
governor and the mayor there in Portland, to help protect our 
officers, and time and time again, they refused to act. They 
chose politics over public safety. The result was more than 280 
injuries to law enforcement officers and millions of dollars of 
damage to Federal property and to local businesses.
 Back then, we saw public figures attacking Federal law 
enforcement officers, calling them stormtroopers, Gestapo, and 
thugs. Comparing American law enforcement to Nazi Germany was 
irresponsible, reckless, and dangerous then, as it remains so 
today. Unfortunately, this disgusting rhetoric and behavior has 
only intensified. Once again, we're seeing violent attacks 
against law enforcement officers, and again, public figures are 
describing them as Nazis.
 The difference between 2020 and now, however, is that the 
Trump administration knows what to expect and is fighting 
aggressively to hold these violent offenders accountable. The 
administration has rightfully designated Antifa as domestic 
terrorists, has begun a whole-of-government investigation into 
the financing and resourcing of this group, and has charged 
Antifa members with providing material support for terrorism.
 And despite what the mainstream media insists, groups like 
Antifa are not disorganized. They are increasingly organized, 
funded, and networked. They plan online, they operate 
anonymously, and execute in ways that make detection difficult. 
Make no mistake, their lack of structure is not a feature--is a 
feature, sorry, not a bug, and it is designed to evade 
accountability and prosecution. Critics argue because they have 
no formal leadership, they shouldn't be treated as domestic 
terrorists. I believe this completely misses the point. This 
decentralized model mirrors what we have seen from jihadist 
networks, cybercriminals, and other criminal groups. Their lack 
of a hierarchy makes them more dangerous.
 This past summer, the American people witnessed multiple 
antifascist-inspired attacks and threats on law enforcement, 
journalists, and civilians. This includes threats against ICE 
officers, other government officials, and even Attorney General 
Bondi just yesterday. Tragically, this also includes the 
sickening assassination of Charlie Kirk.
 I want to state this as plainly as I can. Enforcing 
immigration law, laws passed by Congress almost 60 years ago, 
is in no way, shape, or form fascism. Every sovereign nation 
has a right to choose who is allowed to legally enter the 
country. Throwing around words like ``fascist'' and ``Nazi'' 
not only cheapens history, but it fuels increasing hostility 
toward law enforcement, journalists, and ordinary citizens.
 The rise in political violence presents a grave threat to 
our constitutional order and rule of law. The Federal 
Government has a duty and a responsibility to respond. We must 
continue to give law enforcement the tools and the resources 
they need, allow ICE to operate safely in courthouses and jails 
across the country, increase penalties for those that dox 
Federal officers, and expand joint task forces to dismantle. We 
owe it to the families who have lost loved ones, including 
Erika Kirk and others who continue to grieve, to ensure that 
their calls for accountability are answered and that our Nation 
restores respect for law and order.
 Thank you again for the opportunity to testify.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Wolf appears as a submission 
for the record.]
 Senator Welch. Thank you, Mr. Wolf.
 By the way, our Chairman has had to go vote, and I am going 
to have to go do that after I introduce Mr. Braniff.
 Mr. Braniff is the director of Polarization and Extremism 
Research and Innovation Lab at American University where he is 
working on research and programming to prevent violent 
extremism, targeted violence, and the drivers of polarization 
in American society. And I also want to note that he is a 
graduate of the United States Military Academy at West Point 
and has served as a company commander in the U.S. Army.
 Mr. Braniff.

 STATEMENT OF WILLIAM BRANIFF, DIRECTOR, POLARIZATION AND 
 EXTREMISM RESEARCH AND INNOVATION LAB, AMERICAN UNIVERSITY, 
 WASHINGTON, DC

 Mr. Braniff. Chairman Schmitt, Ranking Member Welch, 
distinguished Senators, thank you for your leadership on this 
critical issue and the opportunity to testify today.
 Twenty-six years ago, I took an oath to support and defend 
the Constitution. I've spent my career honoring that oath as an 
Army officer, a terrorism researcher, and leading prevention 
programs at the Department of Homeland Security. It's a 
lifelong commitment to protect kids and schools, families and 
faith communities, public spaces and workplaces, and the 
democratic institutions and freedoms our Founders gave us. This 
isn't about politics or party for me. It never has been.
 I'm here representing a community of like-minded 
practitioners--law enforcement, mental health, educators, 
veterans--who work every day to prevent violence before it 
destroys families and communities. We're united by a simple 
belief. Targeted violence is preventable, and American 
communities deserve better than waiting for the next attack.
 We should all condemn targeted violence. It's tragic, 
unethical, and illegal. I want to start by acknowledging the 
threats, the loss, and the fear that too many Americans and too 
many elected officials have experienced. But we should also not 
mistake the blame game for advancing solutions. Solutions must 
be based on data and evidence. Solutions must focus on 
preventing political violence in the first place instead of 
reacting after the damage has been done. And solutions must 
reinforce our constitutionally protected freedoms, not erode 
them.
 To inform policymaking, Congress legislated that the 
executive branch provide data on terrorism and targeted 
violence. DHS contracted with START at the University of 
Maryland to produce the T2V dataset, although the 
administration abruptly canceled funding in March. START data 
demonstrate clearly that violent events do not fit neatly into 
any one ideological category and that there has been an 
alarming increase in attacks and credible plots in the United 
States, including over a 2,000 percent increase in mass 
casualty plots since the early 1990's.
 We average more than 2\1/2\ attacks and credible plots per 
day in the U.S., and over 50 percent of them succeed. They 
occurred in over 1,200 U.S. towns and cities. This year, 
compared to last year, terrorism events are up 67 percent, and 
fatalities are up nearly 150 percent. Americans are dying from 
ISIS-inspired, white supremacist, antisemitic, anti-government, 
anti-vax, anti-law enforcement, and nihilistic attacks.
 These data highlight three challenges that we need to solve 
for. The volume problem. With 2.6 events per day, we are at 
risk of accepting targeted violence as inevitable. It is not. 
It is preventable.
 The structural gap problem. These plots succeed 55 percent 
of the time. The structural gap is due to appropriate 
limitations placed on criminal justice investigations to 
protect privacy, civil liberties, freedom of speech, and 
freedom of association, so we can't fill the structural gap 
with criminal justice-only solutions and maintain the freedoms 
enshrined in our Constitution.
 And third, the reality is that targeted violence manifests 
in many different forms of terrorism, hate crime, and school 
shootings. Any approach that only addresses one manifestation 
will be both operationally ineffective and fiscally 
inefficient.
 At DHS, I led prevention programs that partnered Federal 
resources with local teams, sheriffs who knew their counties, 
schools who knew their students, mental health professionals 
who knew their patients, pastors who knew their congregations, 
local Americans protecting local communities. This allowed us 
to engage in early interventions that addressed all of the 
challenges I mentioned.
 Volume, we supported nearly 1,200 interventions for people 
on the pathway to violence. Zero committed violence while in 
the program. We filled the structural gap and bridged to public 
safety. In 94 percent of the cases, the individuals received 
support from mental health professionals, social workers, or 
other helping professionals. Six percent were referred to law 
enforcement. Most of the individuals, 70 percent, were not yet 
self-medicating on any one specific ideology when they came to 
us, just angry, isolated, and struggling.
 And yet, without indexing our programs on any one ideology, 
the intervention succeeded across all ideologies, making this 
approach both effective and cost-effective. Nearly 1,200 people 
at risk of hurting themselves and others, but before families 
had to bury loved ones, we invested in prevention instead.
 Political violence threatens our constitutional order, but 
not just the violence, also how we respond to it. Whether we 
choose to do what works, quietly investing and scaling up 
prevention efforts, or we feed political polarization that 
makes Americans less safe and erodes our Constitution. 
Americans deserve, and the Constitution demands, the former. 
Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Braniff appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you.
 Next up is Michael Knowles. Michael Knowles is the 
celebrated host of ``The Michael Knowles Show'' on The Daily 
Wire, as well as the Book Club on PragerU. He has published two 
number one national best-selling books, including Speechless: A 
History and Analysis of the American Free Speech Tradition. 
Michael has received numerous awards, including the 
Conservative Mind Award from The American Conservative magazine 
and an honorary doctorate of humane letters from Ave Maria 
University. Michael is a graduate of Yale and has lectured at 
universities and research institutions around the world.
 The floor is yours.

 STATEMENT OF MICHAEL KNOWLES, HOST, ``THE MICHAEL KNOWLES 
 SHOW,'' DAILY WIRE, NASHVILLE, TN

 Mr. Knowles. Thank you, Chairman Schmitt, Ranking Member 
Welch, and all the Members of this Committee.
 The Ranking Member suggested that we condemn political 
violence, which surely we must all do, but then he suggested 
that we not try to pinpoint exactly which side the violence 
comes from. This seems to me confusing and misbegotten, as one 
cannot solve a problem if one does not know where the problem 
lies.
 In light of the murder of my friend Charlie Kirk by a 
leftist assassin, I am gratified to see that at least some 
members of our Federal legislature are now confronting the 
consistent and escalating pattern of left-wing terrorism in the 
country. Lest I be accused of partisan invective, on September 
23, no less an emblem of American liberalism than The Atlantic 
magazine published an article citing a recent study from the 
Center for Strategic and International Studies admitting that 
the left is more violent today than the right.
 Less honest liberals, including Members of Congress, 
continue to deny this fact. Democrat Congressman Seth Moulton, 
for example, reacted to Charlie's assassination by blaming the 
right. Congressman Moulton claimed that \3/4\ of political 
violence in the United States comes from the right, while only 
4 percent comes from the left. That claim struck me, as it 
probably does many of you, as suspect.
 So I looked into just a few recent examples that came to 
mind of prominent left-on-right violence. The Covenant School 
Massacre in Nashville in which a trans-identifying shooter 
murdered Christian schoolchildren after outlining her 
ideological motivations. According to authorities, there was no 
ideological motive there. Go figure.
 The Black Lives Matter riots, overtly leftist 
demonstrations that left dozens of people dead and over a 
billion dollars' worth of property damage. Likewise, those fail 
to show up on registers of left-wing political violence.
 Even an attack by Antifa that targeted me personally, as 
well as conservative college students for our political views, 
appeared in official records and datasets as nothing more than 
obstructing law enforcement. It turns out the left commits 
relatively little political violence when you don't count the 
political violence that the left commits.
 I am here today to speak about that single illustrative 
incident. On April 18, 2023, I was invited to participate in a 
debate at the University of Pittsburgh on the topic of 
transgenderism. Before the debate, several hundred left-wing 
protesters gathered outside the student center, many dressed 
uniformly in black with face coverings. They lit the street on 
fire while burning me in effigy with a little Hitler mustache 
painted on my face, all because I hold the view, as most 
Americans do, that men cannot become women.
 Buildings in the area were placed on a soft lockdown. As 
the Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire put out my burning effigy, an 
Antifa operative named Brian DiPippa, hiding behind his wife, 
Krystal, rolled two smoke bombs under police barricades. 
Attendees scattered while demonstrators chanted, ``Fascists, go 
home.'' DiPippa then threw a lit firework into a group of 
police officers protecting the building. The explosion injured 
several officers, including severe and life-altering injuries 
to a female officer. The debate was forced to end early after 
campus police determined that the protests outside were 
becoming even more destructive. The campus issued a safety 
emergency notification.
 Despite popular efforts to deny the existence of organized 
left-wing terrorism, Brian and Krystal DiPippa were not merely 
two citizens protesting a speaker with whom they disagreed. 
Things just got a little out of hand. No. They are members of 
an extremist cell, a cell that meets at an anarchist bookshop, 
the sort of venue that operates as training grounds for left-
wing terror attacks. Brian DiPippa repeatedly set off TSA 
screeners for explosive material on his body. The TORCH Antifa 
network has claimed the DiPippas as members and raised money 
for them through a tax-exempt nonprofit organization. Imagine.
 Thanks to a courageous FBI agent who happened to be on the 
scene, the Department of Justice was impelled to bring charges. 
Unfortunately, our justice system gave them only a slap on the 
wrist. I think we should all be able to agree that throwing an 
explosive at a group of people is no mere minor indiscretion. 
That is a very serious crime. That's attempted murder, the kind 
of crime that merits life in prison. Instead, our justice 
system sentenced Brian DiPippa to minimal jail time for 
obstructing law enforcement. His wife got off with probation.
 The Federal Government must act now to stop the consistent 
and accelerating trend of leftist terrorism. For a legislator 
to deny the threat and neglect the remedy might once have been 
chalked up to ignorance. Today, it is nothing less than 
complicity. Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Knowles appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you.
 Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, I would like to introduce the 
next witness.
 Daniel Hodges was born in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, 
studied at George Mason University, currently studying at the 
University of Virginia, joined the Virginia National Guard in 
2012, and was honorably discharged after a 6-year contract. He 
joined the Metropolitan Police Department in 2014 and has 
served the city of Washington, DC, as a police officer since 
earning awards, citations, and commendations.
 On January the 6th, 2021, Officer Hodges responded with his 
colleagues to the U.S. Capitol to help defend against the mob 
who was attempting to stop the transfer of power. Officer 
Hodges was injured during the attack but returned to full duty 
weeks later.
 In 2022, he testified before the House Select Committee to 
investigate the January 6 attack and has since been honored 
with the Presidential Citizens Medal by President Joe Biden for 
his heroic service to the Nation during the assault on the 
Capitol.
 Thank you, Mr. Hodges.

STATEMENT OF DANIEL HODGES, POLICE OFFICER, METROPOLITAN POLICE 
 DEPARTMENT, WASHINGTON, DC

 Mr. Hodges. Thank you. I'm speaking in my personal 
capacity. However, I draw upon my experiences as one of the few 
police officers in this country who has policed both the 
protests and riots of 2020, as well as the insurrection of 
January 6, 2021. I am intimately familiar with political 
violence. As when I fought to defend the United States Capitol 
and many of your very lives, I was beaten, bloodied, crushed, 
with my eye gouged and my skull smashed with my own baton.
 Political violence is a worthy topic for discussion. 
However, the press release I saw from the Subcommittee Chair 
made it clear that this was not going to be an honest 
consideration of various causes and effects, but rather a ham-
fisted attempt to propagate the unsupported notion that liberal 
ideology is the greatest origin of modern political violence. 
This is particularly galling to me since every single member of 
the majority on the Subcommittee has either contributed to one 
of the most infamous examples of conservative political 
violence of our age or the protection of its perpetrators. 
Every majority member who could do so voted to acquit Donald 
Trump during his second impeachment, and now we find ourselves 
in a new horrific age of political violence, one where it is 
carried out by the State itself.
 A permanent resident was arrested without a warrant and is 
being threatened with deportation simply for his politics. A 
Tennessee man was arrested and is being held on $2 million bail 
for sharing a Trump meme on social media. Members of Congress 
have been denied access to ICE facilities despite the law 
granting them unannounced oversight rights. These detentions 
and prohibitions are all grounded in the threat of deadly force 
and violence, are absurd or outright illegal, and politically 
motivated by right-wing ideology. The fact that these actions 
are carried out by agents of the State doesn't make them 
acceptable, it makes them far worse.
 The current administration is doing whatever it can to 
downplay the threat that right-wing violence presents to the 
United States, including literally erasing data. Between 
September 12 and the 13th of this year, the Department of 
Justice deleted their own study from their website, which came 
to the conclusion that right-wing extremism poses a much 
greater threat than left-wing extremism. I quote now the 
opening paragraph of this National Institute of Justice report 
published just last year. ``Militant, nationalistic, white 
supremacist, violent extremism has increased in the United 
States.'' In fact, the number of far-right attacks continues to 
outpace all other types of terrorism and domestic violence 
extremism. Since 1990, far-right extremists have committed far 
more ideologically motivated homicides than far-left or radical 
Islamist extremists, including 227 events that took more than 
520 lives. In this same period, far-left extremists committed 
42 ideologically motivated attacks that took 78 lives.
 A recent threat assessment by the U.S. Department of 
Homeland Security concluded that domestic violent extremists 
are an acute threat and highlighted the probability that COVID-
19 pandemic-related stressors, longstanding ideological 
grievances related to immigration, and narratives surrounding 
electoral fraud will continue to serve as a justification for 
violent actions.
 There will always be those who seek to further their own 
political agenda through extralegal violence, and that is what 
law enforcement is for. But to reduce the risk of the 
population at large from falling into radicalization, the 
solution is simple. It's unfettered democracy. One of 
democracy's greatest assets is how, when unsullied, it provides 
a mechanism for everyone to have their voice heard. And when 
people believe their government speaks for them in some manner, 
then they're less apt to seek violent means to accomplish their 
political agendas.
 So make voting easier, not harder. Stop gerrymandering 
people into oblivion. Stand on the strength of your ideals, not 
the depth of your donors' pockets. Stop shopping for judges and 
start seeking ideas that withstand scrutiny from any political 
ideology.
 When you tell the people that an election was stolen from 
them, they will take up arms against their neighbors without a 
shred of evidence, I know. But if you tell them brilliant 
political rhetoric is their birthright and civic engagement is 
their privilege, they'll instead take up the book and the pen, 
and we'll all be richer for it.
 And when you--just so you know, this is the helmet that 
U.S. Capitol Police Officer Brian Sicknick wore on January 6, 
2021, and he died the following day. The family member just got 
back that today. Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Hodges appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Thank you for your service.
 Next up is Kyle Shideler, the director and senior analyst 
for Homeland Security and Counterterrorism at the Center for 
Security Policy, where he conducts research and analysis on 
domestic threats to the U.S. homeland and an emphasis on the 
doctrines which fuel terrorism and shape the variety of kinetic 
and non-kinetic threats to America's security. He has briefed 
senior U.S. Government officials; Members of Congress; Federal, 
State, and local law enforcement officers; and testified before 
the U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution and 
the Canadian Senate Standing Committee on National Security and 
Defense. He is the author of ``Understanding Black Identity 
Extremism: Considerations for Law Enforcement,'' and editor of 
``Unmasking Antifa: Five Perspectives on a Growing Threat,'' 
and a contributing author to Saudi Arabia and the Global 
Islamic Terrorist Network.
 His writing has appeared at The Federalist, The Hill, 
FoxNews.com, and the Claremont Review of Books, amongst others. 
He is a graduate of Boston University and a Lincoln fellow with 
the Claremont Institute.
 The floor is yours.

 STATEMENT OF KYLE SHIDELER, DIRECTOR AND SENIOR ANALYST FOR 
 HOMELAND SECURITY AND COUNTERTERRORISM, CENTER FOR SECURITY 
 POLICY, WASHINGTON, DC

 Mr. Shideler. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member 
Welch, distinguished Senators. I would like to thank you for 
the invitation to testify today about the threat our country 
faces from growing political violence.
 In my capacity at the Center for Security Policy, one of 
the things I am most proud of is our program to provide 
educational briefings to law enforcement officers at the 
Federal, State, and local levels. And for the 5-years of this 
program's operation, the No. 1 most requested briefing topic 
that we have been asked to provide has been on the topic of 
Antifa and related left-wing extremist groups.
 The reason it has been the most requested topic is not 
because, contrary to media reports, Antifa does not exist. 
America's law enforcement knows it exists because they see the 
effects every day. The reason it is the most requested topic is 
because they cannot get accurate and quality information about 
the threat. Until recently, the Federal Government has failed 
to define the extensive nature of this threat and has 
demonstrated a history of dismissing or reducing charges 
against left-wing extremists.
 But despite this failing, we have seen convictions for acts 
of political violence by Antifa members who were identified 
by--as such. In 2021, officers and citizens were injured in a 
violent preplanned riot carried out by Antifa. The San Diego 
district attorney successfully secured convictions against 11 
Antifa members, including on charges of conspiracy to riot. In 
2023, the State of Florida successfully sued Antifa members 
under the FACE Act, securing civil fines and felony pleas for 
their attack on pregnancy crisis centers. This is just one 
case, but in the 5-months after the Dobbs decision was leaked, 
more than 100 churches, pregnancy resource centers, and pro-
life organizations across the country were attacked.
 Mr. Knowles has already mentioned the case against Brian 
DiPippa and the Federal Government's guilty plea, but I think 
it is worth adding that Mr. DiPippa was also the web creator 
for ``It's Going Down,'' an Antifa website which has for years 
published both ideological manifestos and tactical instructions 
for aspiring Antifa members, including a 2007 ``Forming an 
Antifa Group'' manual, which I first brought to the attention 
of this Committee when I testified before it in August of 2020.
 But what is Antifa? Well, as a recent Department of Justice 
indictment accurately describes, ``Antifa is a militant 
enterprise made up of networks of individuals and small groups 
ascribing to a revolutionary anarchist or autonomous Marxist 
ideology, which explicitly calls for the overthrow of the U.S. 
Government, law enforcement authorities, and system of law. 
Antifa adherents have espoused insurrection and advocated 
violence to affect the policy and conduct of the U.S. 
Government by intimidation and coercion.'' That's a good 
working definition, which would bring U.S. law enforcement into 
line with the definitions which are utilized by other Western 
governments, which also have an Antifa threat that would 
include Germany and Sweden.
 These networks of small direct-action groups are connected 
through ideologically aligned organizations, online platforms, 
and support networks, which provide significant amounts of 
material support, but much of this material support is in the 
form of services rather than financial transactions. One 
example, the website Abolition Media posts communiques from the 
PFLP, the ELN, the PKK, and the MPA, all of them designated 
communist terror groups. That alone is actionable material 
support for terrorism. But it also posts claims of 
responsibility for anarchist arson attacks and propaganda on 
behalf of Antifa members currently in prison for violent 
attacks in the United States, Germany, Chile, Greece, and 
Hungary. The site distributes calls for actions and organizes 
efforts for Antifa groups across international borders and even 
posted an anarchist manual discussing the value of ``complex 
coordinated terrorist attacks.''
 If this site were promoting and advocating violence for Al-
Qaeda, there would be absolutely no question in the minds of 
U.S. authorities that it serves as a media arm for a terrorist 
organization. According to a recent article by journalist 
Hudson Crozier, Abolition Media is just one of a hundred such 
websites hosted on NoBlogs, a blogging suite provided by the 
Italy based Autistici/Inventati collective, which provides 
websites, emails, digital encryption tools to Antifa and 
related left-wing extremist groups, all while hiding their 
personal data from law enforcement.
 Very similarly, the International Antifa Defense Fund has 
distributed over a quarter of a million dollars to 800 Antifa 
members across 26 countries, including not just for legal 
support, but up to 20 percent has gone to security improvements 
and emergency relocation costs for Antifa members. It would be 
a reasonable avenue of investigation to determine if funds have 
gone to help fugitive Antifa members avoid arrest.
 I look forward to working with the Committee on ways U.S. 
policy and legislation might address the threat posed by Antifa 
and related left-wing extremist groups.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Shideler appears as a 
submission for the record.]
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you.
 The Chair will recognize a Ranking Member of the Judiciary 
Committee, Senator Durbin, for his opening remarks.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, 
 A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS

 Senator Durbin. I thank Senator Schmitt for that courtesy.
 At the outset, I want to recognize law enforcement who are 
here today, including those who defended the U.S. Capitol on 
January 6, 2021, and the family members of those who are no 
longer with us. Ken Sicknick, brother of fallen officer Brian 
Sicknick, is here. He reminds us, ``The simple act of not 
letting the events of that day be whitewashed, revised, or 
forgotten is more important than anyone can ever know.'' That 
statement by Mr. Sicknick rings painfully true today.
 This hearing examines a critical issue, political violence 
in America. I have said before over and over from this podium 
and will repeat, violence is not acceptable whatever the source 
or origin. I do not believe that one party owns the right to 
say it is the other party's fault. It is the fault of both 
parties in differing degrees, and it is our fault if we try to 
whitewash that reality.
 To seriously address this problem, we must be honest. We 
must start with the facts, not with partisan conclusions. To 
claim, as the Chairman of the Subcommittee has, ``Political 
violence comes predominantly from one side of the aisle.'' And 
don't give me this both sides BS. It is not supported by the 
facts. In fact, those facts tell a different story.
 For more than a decade, for more than a decade, data from 
the FBI, DHS, and nonpartisan experts show that far-right 
extremists have been responsible for most domestic terrorism, 
including most deaths by far. On this chart, which you can see 
behind me, from the Center for Strategic and International 
Studies, also known as CSIS, terrorist attacks from the right 
are in red and attacks from the left are in blue. CSIS found 
that since 2016, 112 people have been killed as a result of 
right-wing attacks, while three have died as a result of left-
wing attacks. These are not partisan talking points. They are 
the facts established by Federal law enforcement and national 
security experts across numerous administrations, both 
Democratic and Republican.
 [Poster is displayed.]
 Indeed, one of today's majority witnesses, Mr. Chad Wolf, 
in his confirmation hearing before Congress as acting DHS 
Secretary during President Trump's first term, testified, 
``White supremacist extremists, from a lethality standpoint 
over the last 2 years, are certainly the most persistent and 
lethal threat when we talk about domestic violent extremists.'' 
Far right extremists were responsible for the January 6, 2021, 
attack on the Capitol. I lived through it. And they have been 
responsible for a string of hate-fueled massacres, targeting 
ethnic and religious minority communities, including the 2012 
Gurdwara shooting in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, targeting Sikh 
Americans, killing seven; the 2015 Mother Emanuel AME church 
shooting in Charleston, targeting Black Americans, killing 
nine; the 2018 Tree of Life synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh, 
targeting Jewish Americans, killing 11; the 2019 Walmart 
shooting in El Paso targeting Latino Americans, killing 22; and 
the 2022 Tops supermarket shooting in Buffalo, targeting Black 
Americans, killing 10.
 Political violence has continued to rock the Nation in 
recent months, from the assassination of Mr. Kirk to the 
assassinations of Minnesota House Speaker Emerita Melissa 
Hortman and her husband, and the attempted assassination of 
Minnesota State Senator John Hoffman and his wife. Just last 
week, a man was arrested after allegedly offering $45,000 for 
the killing of Attorney General Pam Bondi. And a January 6 
rioter, who was pardoned by President Trump, full and 
unconditional pardon, was arrested for allegedly threatening to 
kill the House Democratic leader, Hakeem Jeffries.
 I have said it before, and I will say it again. There is no 
room for political violence in America, ever. Ever. Not from 
the right or from the left. I am deeply concerned by the Trump 
administration's response to the political violence crisis. On 
the one hand, the administration's threatening a crackdown on 
constitutionally protected speech based on false claims that in 
the words of Stephen Miller, there is ``a vast domestic terror 
movement on the left.''
 At the same time, the administration is gutting programs 
that have proven effective in combating domestic terrorism. For 
example, the administration has slashed the budget of DHS' 
Center for Prevention Programs and Partnerships by more than 30 
percent, cut the center's staff by 80 employees to fewer than 
20, and appointed a 22-year-old Trump campaign official to run 
the center.
 We honor our Constitution and serve our country not by 
rewriting history or weaponizing tragedy but by telling the 
truth even when it is uncomfortable because democracy cannot 
survive selective outrage or deliberate amnesia. To the 
officers and families here today and watching at home, we will 
never forget January 6. Our duty is to protect the truth, to 
defend the rule of law, and to be an American that rejects 
violence in every form.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you, Senator.
 I want to point out that the CSIS study that has been 
mentioned here and repeated ad nauseum excluded violence at 
protests from their study, allowing them to systematically 
ignore Antifa and Black Lives Matter riots, but they did make 
an exception for Charlottesville, interestingly. Even using 
their flawed methodology, CSIS recently reported that left-wing 
violence in 2025 outpaces right-wing violence. Imagine how much 
bigger that disparity would be if they actually weren't cooking 
the books.
 So without objection, I move to enter into the record an 
article by Tim Carney explaining CSIS' biased methodology. 
Without objection, it will be entered into the record.
 [The information appears as a submission for the record.]
 We will start with questionings. Mr. Knowles, I want to 
start with you. You are not going to have any bigger proponent 
of free speech than me, given especially what I did in my last 
job and this one. I believe in it wholeheartedly. I think the 
First Amendment is the beating heart of our Constitution. But 
what we are really talking about here is conduct, of course, 
violent conduct. And you have talked about you can't really 
have this competition in the marketplace if the marketplace is 
being destroyed and shot up in many instances. How do we get at 
this? What is the road forward in your view?
 Mr. Knowles. We might be able to find a little bipartisan 
agreement if we acknowledge something that both parties at 
different times have acknowledged, which is that marketplaces 
of ideas or any other kind of marketplace only function when 
there are rules and when we abide by those rules. You can't 
have a marketplace if bandits keep shooting up the marketplace. 
And this is why it's so important to identify where the threats 
to the marketplace have really been coming from. Have we seen 
left-wing speakers shouted down on campuses? Have we seen left-
wing events interrupted by terrorists? Rarely so, if ever. I 
can't think of an occasion.
 I am amused that Senator Durbin began by warning against 
pointing to one side or the other, making this a partisan issue 
before beginning one of the most partisan invectives that I 
have ever heard. But I'm not even opposed to a partisan 
invective here because I think it is very important that we 
identify where the threats are. I think any honest Democrat 
even would have to acknowledge, as The Atlantic magazine did, 
as even CSIS has acknowledged, that the threats today to the 
free marketplace of ideas come from the left. And so in order 
to restore the open marketplace of ideas, the healthy exchange 
of ideas, essential to our self-government, we must regulate 
where the problem is. And today, the problem lies on the left.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you.
 Mr. Wolf, I want to ask you--and thank you for your 
service. A common refrain is that Antifa is an ideology, not an 
organization. Could you talk about, in your experience, how 
that is complete and utter nonsense, that this is actually a 
pretty well-coordinated organization with safehouses and money 
that is laundered internationally, quite frankly, not just 
domestically?
 Mr. Wolf. Yes, well, I think we've seen that across the 
country. I think the indictment by the Department of Justice in 
Texas talks about the Antifa cell there in north Texas, about 
how they do coordinate, how they do pool their resources. I saw 
it firsthand in Portland, although it was very difficult to 
prove at the time. Those types of anarchists and others there 
being well organized, being well funded, being resupplied 
daily, you know, not that they were doing that themselves, but 
that they had help.
 And so as you look across the spectrum here, you know, is 
Antifa like other organizations? Does it have a hierarchy and 
an org chart and everything else? No, it's very different. But 
that doesn't make it any less dangerous. That doesn't say--and 
that shouldn't mean from a law enforcement perspective, well, 
let's not actually investigate. Let's not actually start to 
look at who these individuals are, how they're organized, how 
they're funded, how they're financed. Just because they're 
decentralized doesn't make them any less threatening.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you.
 Mr. Shideler, I am going to go to you and pick up on that 
point because you alluded to it in your testimony. 
Understanding what Antifa is and its connections and 
organization, what are some suggestions you might have of how 
we could get at this problem of this radical organization hell-
bent on destroying America? I mean, this is their stated 
mission. How do we get about that?
 Mr. Shideler. Well, I'm a firm supporter of the President's 
recommendation to target Antifa as a foreign terrorist 
organization. There are a number of Antifa organizations that 
operate across Western Europe and Latin America, which would be 
justified--we would be justified in designating as a foreign 
terrorist organization. There are also a number of networks 
which provide material support, including the one that I 
mentioned in my testimony, and that is a very common method in 
which Antifa receives support.
 Much like, for example, Islamic State or Al-Qaeda where 
they host media outlets like Dabiq and Inspire, which will give 
you both ideological instructions as to how to become Antifa, 
what you need to believe and how you need to believe it. They 
also provide instructions on what you should do if you wish to 
be Antifa, including how you should organize, how you can avoid 
arrest, what encrypted apps to use, what websites to use. They 
also provide instructions on how to destroy critical 
infrastructure, including 5G wireless communications and how to 
derail trains as, for example, the website It's Going Down did 
in a case that was related to two anarchists in the Pacific 
Northwest that derailed a number of trains in which the Federal 
Government received--was able to achieve a conviction.
 So these networks can be targeted for engaging in material 
support for terrorism. We are not talking about speech. We are 
talking about manifestos describing how to overthrow the 
Government and how to do that with violence.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. President Trump has designated 
Antifa as a domestic terrorist organization, and I have written 
to Secretary Rubio for the International Foreign Terrorist 
Organization, and we will see what happens with that.
 Ranking Member Welch.
 Senator Welch. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 I want to ask Mr. Hodges. You were here on duty in uniform 
on January 6. Can you tell us just what you went through and 
what the size of the crowd was that was attacking the Capitol?
 Mr. Hodges. Certainly. I'll try to be brief. It was a very 
long day. It started at 7 in the morning on Constitution 
Avenue. I was--everyone filed into the Ellipse to hear Trump 
give his rally so to speak, and then they--afterwards, they 
started heading back toward the--up Constitution Avenue toward 
the Capitol. I heard on my radio that they discovered bombs. I 
heard on my radio that the Capitol was becoming under attack.
 The commander who was on scene at the Capitol was getting 
overwhelmed and called for my platoon to reinforce them, so we 
did. We got on our pads, made our way down to the Capitol.
 Senator Welch. So you went to where the trouble was?
 Mr. Hodges. Correct, yes. We got as far as the edge of the 
western property, but the crowd was so dense, you know, we 
couldn't get any closer than that in a vehicle, so we got out 
on foot, started making our way toward the West Terrace itself. 
While we were walking through the crowd, you know, all Trump 
supporters, Trump flags, Trump gear, they started yelling at 
us, calling us stormtroopers, telling us to remember our oaths, 
calling us traitors, and we hadn't done anything yet. So----
 Senator Welch. You were uniformed officers, right?
 Mr. Hodges. Yes.
 Senator Welch. No mask?
 Mr. Hodges. Correct.
 Senator Welch. And you were insulted----
 Mr. Hodges. Yes.
 Senator Welch [continuing]. With those terms?
 Mr. Hodges. Yes, stormtroopers, to remember our oaths, all 
that nonsense. And then, eventually, when we were making our 
way through the crowd, we were attacked. A cutoff from our 
leadership, I was hit over the head from behind, lurched 
forward, and someone tried to steal my baton. I was able to 
retain my weapon, and I tried to forge a path through the 
crowd.
 Unfortunately, I looked back and saw that the rest of my 
colleagues were under attack from more of the mob. I went back 
to try--and I succeeded in pulling some of the assailants off 
my colleagues until I was attacked again. Someone tried to 
steal my baton again. We wrestled for control, went to the 
ground with it. He kicked me in the chest. I went to my hands 
and knees, and the medical mask I was wearing at the time got 
pulled up over my eyes, so I was blind, surrounded by the mob. 
But thankfully, my colleagues were able to free themselves from 
their attackers and came to my defense.
 I got up, and we--I forged another path through the crowd. 
There were--it was chaotic, explosions going off, smoke 
grenades, bike rack barriers being broken down into poles to 
use as weapons.
 Then, eventually, we made our way to the West Terrace 
itself where a police line was being held. We joined the 
defense there, where we held the line as long as we could. 
Unfortunately, we were comically outnumbered, 150, 175 officers 
to I think it was like 10,000 insurrectionists. I remember 
looking out over the crowd, and I couldn't see the end of it. I 
couldn't see the end of their numbers.
 And they broke through. They--about three or four of them 
attacked me, pushed me into a waist-high barrier. One of them 
reached underneath my visor, gripped my face with his hand and 
tried to gouge out my eye with his thumb. I was able to shake 
him off before any permanent damage was done. But we lost the 
line. We had to fall back to the building itself, and that's 
what we did.
 Senator Welch. All right. Thank you very much. And I 
understand that the brother of Officer Sicknick is here. I just 
want to acknowledge him. He is the officer who died, one of 
your fellow Capitol Police officers.
 I want to ask a question of the panel. As you know, 
everybody who was involved and convicted was pardoned. Raise 
your hand if you believe that those pardons were appropriate.
 All right. So that includes pardons for folks who were 
involved in attacking Officer Hodges. It does.
 Senator Welch. You know, Mr. Chairman, I have to say, I 
am----
 Mr. Knowles. Are we being invited to speak or is----
 Senator Welch. Pardon me?
 Mr. Knowles. Was that an invitation to speak, or----
 Senator Welch. No.
 Mr. Knowles. Oh, understood?
 Senator Welch. It was not. I mean, you said and I said--and 
I agree with you--political violence is to be condemned, 
whether it is on the right or the left. I mean, we just heard a 
pretty frightening description of political violence on a 
sustained basis against this Capitol Police officer, and there 
is a view that he should be pardoned. I guess I will just say I 
disagree with that.
 I yield back.
 Chair Schmitt. Senator Cornyn.
 Senator Cornyn. Thank you for being here.
 I am glad that at least we can agree on one thing, that 
political violence is unacceptable, no matter where it comes 
from. But I want to talk about the leadership and what some 
leaders have said, which I believe has contributed to that 
political violence.
 In 2018, when Nancy Pelosi was asked about policies she 
disagreed with, instead of saying she would do her job and 
legislate or try to persuade people to the contrary, she 
replied, ``I just don't even know why there aren't uprisings 
all over the country, and maybe there will be.'' About that 
same time, Kamala Harris was asked about being stuck in an 
elevator with President Trump, Mike Pence, and Jeff Sessions, 
and she replied, while laughing, ``Does one of us have to come 
out alive?''
 And then there is this. In March 2020, the majority leader 
of the U.S. Senate, Chuck Schumer, said about Supreme Court 
Justices the following, ``I want to tell you, Gorsuch, I want 
to tell you, Kavanaugh, you have released the whirlwind, and 
you will pay the price. You won't know what hit you.''
 [Poster is displayed.]
 In August 2020, Representative Ayanna Pressley said, 
``There needs to be unrest in the street,'' encouraging 
rioters.
 Then Maxine Waters said in 2021 that democratic rioters 
should, ``get more confrontational,'' with police. She said, 
``If you see anybody from Trump's Cabinet at a restaurant, in a 
department store, at a gas station, you get out and create a 
crowd and you push back on them, and you tell them they are not 
welcome anymore anywhere.''
 And then in 2023, Delegate Stacey Plaskett said on MSNBC 
that President Trump ``needs to be shot.''
 In 2024, President Biden told democratic donors that it was 
time to put Trump--this is a President of the United States, 
told democratic donors it was time to put Trump in the 
bullseye.
 And recently, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez posted in an 
Instagram story that people should ``resist'' ICE.
 And then Jasmine Crockett, a Member of the House of 
Representatives from the State of Texas--Kayla Hamilton was a 
young woman who was sexually assaulted and strangled to death 
by an illegal alien, an MS-13 member. I lead a bill named in 
her honor here in the Senate. Representative Jasmine Crockett 
called Kayla Hamilton a ``random dead person.''
 We have talked about the person, the would-be assassin that 
was going to kill Justice Kavanaugh and of course the 
assassination attempts on President Trump. Does everybody on 
the panel believe that the individuals who actually commit acts 
of violence should be held accountable? Would you raise your 
hand?
 Senator Cornyn. So we agree. Acts of political violence are 
unacceptable, and the individual who commits those acts should 
be held accountable.
 But I want to talk about the political leadership that I 
think has a greater responsibility, people who serve as the 
elected representatives of the American people. Does anybody 
believe that they bear no responsibility for inciting or 
encouraging acts of violence? Well, we've always had in the 
course of our Nation's history people who are ideologically 
driven to violence. Anarchists, maybe the historical antecedent 
of Antifa, people motivated by ideological reasons. But I 
believe that leaders elected to Congress should not say or do 
things which suggest that political violence is acceptable. And 
the examples I read to you just now I think should be 
condemned.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Thank you, Senator. Senator 
Durbin.
 Senator Durbin. Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Braniff, you previously served as director of the 
Center for Prevention Programs and Partnerships, or CP3, at 
DHS, an initiative created under the Biden administration to 
take a comprehensive approach to combating domestic violent 
extremism. CP3 prioritized public and community health 
programming to identify people before they commit acts of 
violence in coordination with Federal, State, and local law 
enforcement. In your experience, how have these investments in 
public health led to identifying at-risk individuals and 
stopping violent acts before they occur?
 Mr. Braniff. Thank you, Senator. I'm actually perhaps the 
one person who has something to offer in terms of solutions 
today, and I'm really excited to talk about that. At CP3, we 
learned from the violence prevention community, the same people 
who for 30 to 40 years have been studying suicide prevention 
and violence against children prevention, intimate partner 
violence prevention, and we started to apply those methods and 
that evidence to targeted violence prevention to try to prevent 
terrorism, hate crime, school shootings.
 And the great thing about this approach is that it's 
upstream, right? Violence is a universal human phenomenon. It 
just manifests differently. When someone starts to struggle, 
they might go answer-seeking online, and they might fall down 
one rabbit hole, or they might fall down another rabbit hole. 
And after time, if whatever underlying crisis goes unaddressed, 
they might decide that violence is a solution to their 
problems.
 Senator Durbin. Sorry to interrupt you, but we have heard 
allegations from both sides of the table as to whether there is 
more violence on the right, more violence on the left. What I 
hear you saying is that certain persons are predisposed 
toward----
 Mr. Braniff. No, Senator. Actually, thank you for the 
question. All of us have vulnerabilities, and if those 
vulnerabilities go unaddressed, we could wind up being 
manipulated into engaging in violent extremism. We did 1,172 
interventions. Think about that, 1,172 interventions for 
individuals who were exhibiting risks of violence. They were 
making veiled threats of violence. They were socially isolated. 
And those interventions were across the ideological spectrum. 
Some people were flirting with white supremacy. Some people 
were flirting with anti-government extremism. Some people were 
just flirting with violence for violence sake.
 The point is we didn't wait until something terrible 
happened and then blame the ideology behind it. We actually did 
a therapeutic intervention, and in 94 percent of those 
interventions, the individual got help, and there was no 
violence. In 6 percent, they had made a threat to public safety 
that was imminent, or they had crossed a criminal threshold, 
and they were referred to law enforcement. So we supported 
those individuals, averted nearly 1,200 potential acts of 
violence, and never sacrificed public safety.
 We have a solution that's cost-effective, that does not 
violate civil rights, civil liberties, and protects our 
Constitution, and I would encourage us to look at that as a 
potential solution.
 Senator Durbin. As you know, the Trump administration 
significantly cut the staff at CP3, which you worked with, 
which led to your resignation. Is that true?
 Mr. Braniff. Senator, there is no more office at all. The 
entire thing was dismantled on--the final two people left on 
September 11 and 12.
 Senator Durbin. So the prevention effort you are describing 
to us is now no longer funded?
 Mr. Braniff. That is correct.
 Senator Durbin. Are you concerned about the potential rise 
in attacks that we may see with a similar level of inquiries 
taking place under this administration?
 Mr. Braniff. Senator, I've given my life to protecting 
American people. I'm incredibly worried about the rise of 
targeted violence and terrorism across the ideological spectrum 
at the same time that we've dismantled the very apparatus that 
can prevent it. And we've seen 150 percent increase in 
fatalities from terrorism last year to this year. We've seen 
about a 70 percent increase in terrorist incidents from last 
year to this year. We've seen an increase of violence across 
the board, and I would encourage us to think about investing in 
prevention going forward because I know that it works.
 Senator Durbin. An ounce of prevention, as they say.
 Mr. Braniff. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Durbin. Well, I think that is an important lesson 
for us to take.
 The Republican Members of this Committee believe they are 
right. The Democrats believe they are right. The American 
people want to see less violence. I hope we all want to see 
less violence. This is one agency with an agenda directed 
toward reaching that goal, and unfortunately, it has virtually 
been shut down. If we are sincere about this on a bipartisan 
basis, let's do something to revive that effort.
 I yield.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Senator Lee.
 Senator Lee. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Knowles, I would like to start with you if that is 
okay. I hardly need to expand upon the violence that has 
recently been committed on campuses across the country. Most 
notably and prominently of late, Charlie Kirk was assassinated 
not too far from where I live in Utah, at Utah Valley 
University. That assassination occurred amidst many of the 
developments that you have referred to in your opening 
testimony. And it arose in the context of a public debate he 
was holding in a public forum specifically about some political 
issues. Now, while that investigation remains ongoing, there is 
a lot of circumstantial evidence suggesting political 
motivation for this attack. Can you help this body understand 
the violent tendencies inherent in some of these ideologies 
that are prompting a lot of this violence?
 Mr. Knowles. I certainly can. Thank you, Senator. Charlie 
was probably the most prominent proponent of civil and gracious 
dialog in the entire country, and they killed him for it 
because there is a--in a certain type of left-wing ideology, 
the belief that ideas don't really matter and that we're really 
just warring groups that must clobber each other over the head, 
which is why you're seeing the increased violence there.
 I think you saw this not only in the horrific assassination 
of Charlie but in the reactions that came afterward. You know, 
as the scene was unfolding, a Democrat analyst, Matthew Dowd on 
MSNBC, the left-wing cable outlet, blamed Charlie Kirk. He 
said, ``Hateful thoughts lead to hateful words, which then lead 
to hateful actions.''
 The New York Times reacted by publishing the assassination-
related musings of Hasan Piker, a prominent left-wing streamer 
who has suggested the assassination of Senator Tom Cotton and 
who has said of conservatives, ``Kill those mother effers, 
murder those mother effers in the street, and let the streets 
soak in their effing red capitalist blood.'' I could go on and 
on with the reactions. We all saw it, and they are reflected in 
other public opinion surveys relating to approval of violence.
 So it would appear that this is not merely a matter of some 
fringe actors, some extremists who simply have an emotional 
problem, as has been suggested here today. This would seem to 
be clearly an ideological issue at every level of the American 
left, which needs to be addressed accordingly, or else we are 
just twiddling our thumbs. We are not doing anything to solve 
the problem.
 Senator Lee. Now, if those same things arose in the context 
of someone in the right-of-center universe, what would be the 
reaction? Would there be a self-correction set in motion as a 
result of the media response?
 Mr. Knowles. There is no question, Senator. When I think of 
right-wing political violence, the clearest example we can 
think of in recent memory goes back about 30 years. It was the 
Oklahoma City bombing. And it was a little confusing, but we 
could place it on the right. What would happen after an attack 
like that? It was universally, uniformly condemned on the 
right. That is true any time there is some fringe attack, a 
shooting. And yet, on the left, what happened after President 
Trump came within 1/20 of an inch of being assassinated? You 
saw jokes. You saw minimizations. You saw comments throughout 
social media saying, ``Maybe we will get him next time.''
 What happened after Charlie's assassination? We could be 
here all day reading the excuses and the celebrations from 
normal and even mainstream figures on the left. There is no 
equivalence whatsoever. If we're to solve the problem, we have 
to acknowledge that.
 Senator Lee. There are a few tells that go along with it, 
perhaps without some of these people realizing it. Every time 
someone refers to a conservative, it is always far right. I 
don't ever hear the same publications using the term far left 
to describe someone who believes deeply and fairly consistently 
in the political ideology of the Democratic Party. But far 
right is the consistent mantra going the other direction. It 
almost seems like an homage to ad Hitlerum and the frequent 
invocation of ad Hitlerum attacks tend to prompt other 
Operation Valkyrie moments. And perhaps that is some of what is 
behind the 55 percent figure that you referred to earlier.
 Now, you are someone who gets around a lot of college 
campuses. You do a lot of public speaking. How has this 
impacted you personally? And what measures have you had to 
take, if you are comfortable sharing some of that with us, to 
ensure your own personal safety when all this is happening?
 Mr. Knowles. We have dramatically had to increase security, 
of course. And, you know, there is appropriate concern, the 
kind of concern that one would never have on the left because 
they don't face any threats on college campuses. College 
campuses are key though here, Senator, because when some fringe 
right winger does something awful, he's castigated, thrown into 
prison, as he should be. When a fringe left winger commits 
terrorist attacks, sometimes he's given university positions, 
as happened with the Weather Underground, an organization which 
blew up part of this very building, and they were rewarded with 
sinecures at universities.
 Senator Lee. For you and for others in the movement, this 
means that it is more expensive----
 Mr. Knowles. Yes.
 Senator Lee [continuing]. And from a personal security 
standpoint, a preserving-your-own-life standpoint, far riskier 
than it would be for someone else. I can't help but wonder 
whether that is a feature and not a bug. Thank you.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. It is also worth noting that a 
member of the Weather Underground, Bill Ayers, actually hosted 
Barack Obama's first fundraiser when he ran for State Senate.
 Senator Booker.
 Senator Booker. I find hearings like this frustrating, and 
they deepen to me what is a problem in our country, which is a 
growing tribalism and our inability to come together and work 
on issues where we have so much common ground.
 There is not a Senator in the United States--and I know 
them well and have friends on both sides of the aisle--that 
does not condemn political violence. But when we hold hearings 
that come at this issue that reflects the partisanship of our 
time and the tribalism of our time, we don't get to a solution.
 We are in a crisis right now, and there is growing 
political violence and a growing justification for it. But I 
find it stunning that the way we talk about it seems more about 
grievance politics and trying to score points than actually 
getting to the root of what is an American problem. And it 
frustrates me when that is so transparent and clear, especially 
when we don't talk about people on our own side of the aisle.
 Chuck Schumer was very wrong in what he said, and my 
colleague held up the quote. I have actually seen that quote. I 
have lost count of how many times my colleagues have raised 
that quote. But you know what they never say? Is that he came 
out and apologized for it, that Chuck Schumer, using self-
interrogation, said, ``I was wrong.'' I have never seen the 
President of the United States, who has spoken about punching 
people in the face, who has said a lot of violent rhetoric, has 
never given that type of self-interrogation.
 I don't understand how we could be having a hearing right 
now at a time when threats on the Senator sitting up here have 
gone through the roof, where we can't have a constructive 
conversation but instead are pitting witnesses against 
witnesses, many of whom, like Mr. Hodges, have had to sit there 
and relive his trauma over and over again in hopes that 
something would be done about the problem.
 And God, we should just tell the truth. There is political 
violence, extremists who have left-wing ideologies and right-
wing ideologies. To say it is just one and not the other is to 
deepen the problem. But we have an administration right now who 
is eviscerating the people that should be keeping us safe and 
who is pulling down from the website, as they did earlier this 
year when the Department of Justice removed from its website a 
government-funded report published last year that found that 
the number of far-right attacks continues to outpace all other 
types of terrorism and domestic violence extremism. If we can't 
accurately describe a problem and do it without partisan 
rhetoric or seeking to score partisan points, we will not solve 
this problem.
 I have a lot of colleagues that are wiser and more full of 
grace. I am a big believer about faith, that before you tell me 
about your religion, first show it to me in how you treat other 
people. If you ascribe to the beliefs of my faith, of Jesus 
Christ, God, show grace.
 And I still remember bemoaning to Tim Kaine about the 
problems we have in our growing hostile, degrading, and 
demeaning political climate. And he said the only way this is 
ever going to be cured, he said to me, was by each of us 
showing every single day a relentless commitment to ideals of 
extending grace to one another. I haven't heard any of that 
rhetoric in the little bit of this hearing that I have listened 
to. I have heard finger pointing, condemnation, demeaning and 
degrading that reflects our partisan divide. This is the 
American problem.
 I am so frustrated to sit before members of our law 
enforcement, who have suffered in our house trying to protect 
us. Violence that I never imagined could happen. And yet we 
have an inability to name it and condemn it and commit 
ourselves to doing something about it. I will do my best to 
call it like it is, to hear quotes that I have even said that 
need to be tamped down because the only thing that is going to 
save our country now is not more political posturing and 
partisan finger pointing. The only thing that is going to get 
us out of this condition is for courageous leaders in both 
parties to start standing up and extending grace and self-
introspection.
 It is a lot easier when I call out Chuck Schumer's comments 
to make a difference. And God, I wish I would see more of my 
colleagues being willing to call out the President of the 
United States for his outrageous comments as well.
 Thank you.
 Chair Schmitt. Senator Blackburn.
 Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Thank you to each of you for being here today and to our 
law enforcement that is here. We thank you for your service.
 Mr. Knowles, I do want to come to you, and it is wonderful 
to have you here with us today. And we appreciate that you are 
a Nashville resident, have been there for several years now.
 And I want to return to the topic of the assassination of 
Charlie Kirk. And one of the things that was quite disturbing 
to me was quotes that came from activist professors. And we had 
in Tennessee three professors that made just horrendous 
statements. Two have been terminated. One is going through a 
termination hearing at this point. An assistant dean at MTSU 
posted on Facebook, ``Looks like Ol Charlie spoke his fate into 
existence. Hate begets hate. Zero sympathy.''
 There was an assistant professor at the University of 
Tennessee, and their post referenced Charlie Kirk. And it was, 
``The world is better off without him in it, even those who are 
claiming to be sad for his wife and kids. His kids are better 
off living in a world without a disgusting psychopath like him 
and his wife.''
 And then an English professor at Cumberland University 
posted on Facebook, ``Crying about a Nazi getting shot while 
staying silent about the school shooting in Colorado today is 
peak Republican.''
 Now, I believe that people that praise violence should not 
be anywhere near our children. I do not know of a parent that 
wants their child to be receiving instruction from an 
individual who glorifies and applauds brutal murder, and the 
murder of a husband, a father, the murder of someone who 
believes, like me, that our Nation has been kept free because 
we believe in robust, respectful, bipartisan debate.
 [Poster is displayed.]
 And I would like for you to talk for just a minute about 
what is happening in higher education and the role that seems 
to be playing in some of this violence and violent rhetoric.
 Mr. Knowles. I think you make a marvelous point, Senator. 
You cannot possibly expect a parent to send their children to a 
school where the professors might endeavor to kill half the 
students. It would be like, you know, going to a restaurant 
with the assumption that the waiters want to poison half the 
customers or something like that. You can't go to a hospital 
where the nurses want to kill half the patients. It's just--you 
cannot operate a society that way. That is obviously beyond the 
pale.
 And if you are to permit that kind of speech into the 
marketplace of ideas, it doesn't have the effect of expanding 
the marketplace of ideas. It actually shrinks the marketplace 
of ideas. This is why the First Amendment obviously prohibits 
things like direct threats or obscenity or fighting words 
because these are forms of speech that actually undermine 
rational discourse.
 You know, I think Senator Booker made a good point just a 
moment ago when he said we have to self-examine. We have to be 
introspective. And, you know, I can't help but think of a line 
today. ``Jay Jones has the vision, commitment, and integrity to 
keep families safe and make sure every Virginian gets a fair 
shake in the justice system. I'll be working every day to 
ensure Jay wins this race.'' That's the endorsement of Senator 
Booker for a man who would seek to be the attorney general of 
Virginia. This is a man who, if people have not been reading 
the news, has called for a Republican to be murdered, for his 
children to be murdered, for the children to die in their 
mother's arms in order to persuade the Republican to change his 
policy views, and a man who says that he would urinate on the 
graves of multiple Republicans.
 Senator Booker, in this spirit of introspection, is 
standing by this endorsement. So I suppose I would--perhaps I 
should have looked because Senator Booker has left the room, 
and I think I can guess why. Senator Booker, I think, should 
practice what he preaches because this is the kind of moment--
you cannot have a professor who wants to teach students and is 
going to desire to kill half of them. You certainly cannot have 
law enforcement officers who would engage in this kind of 
violent rhetoric against half of their constituents. So long as 
anyone stands by an endorsement such as that, their words are 
meaningless. They are shedding crocodile tears on the topic of 
political violence.
 Senator Blackburn. I find it just so astounding that we 
have professors that continue to be in classrooms and hold such 
views, as I put on the posters behind me, and that parents are 
then having to address those issues with their kids.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Senator Padilla.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 I just want to join all of my colleagues in the stance that 
political violence is never acceptable. It should be denounced 
at every turn, regardless of where it comes from. We have seen 
what happens when violence becomes a political tool. It is not 
protests. It becomes an attack on our very democracy itself, 
and it strikes at the principle that political change in this 
country should happen through healthy, rigorous debate, and at 
the ballot box, not through fear or intimidation. And while 
political violence is rare, its impact is profound.
 Now, I want to ask a question specifically in the context 
of threats and intimidation that becomes aimed at public 
officials. Those are more than just personal attacks. They are 
attempts to make people too afraid to serve. We have seen that 
danger spread not just from Members of Congress and State 
officials, local elected officials but to judges and election 
workers now too. Now, protecting those who uphold our 
democratic system should not be controversial.
 Mr. Braniff, what does current research show about the 
surge in threats to Members of Congress since 2017? And how can 
Congress strengthen threat assessment capacity without chilling 
legitimate speech?
 Mr. Braniff. Thank you, Senator. Individuals who wind up 
fixating on elected officials or the integrity of our election 
system are clearly espousing antidemocratic sentiment, right? 
And often, those are observable, right? These individuals leak 
their intent or express things that others can pick up on. So 
in other contexts, 80 percent of school shooters leak their 
intent. About 50 percent of mass casualty attackers leak their 
intent, right? So there's often these indications that someone 
is starting to self-medicate on the idea of violence, and 
that's an opportunity to do an intervention.
 And unfortunately, the U.S. Secret Service is, of course, 
an exceptional organization when it comes to behavioral threat 
assessment and management. There are other entities in the U.S. 
Government that still train behavioral threat assessment and 
management. These are--this is becoming a normal practice 
across the country. Some States have mandates for behavioral 
threat assessment and management, but we really need to invest 
in nationalizing these programs, not--I don't mean in having 
one national program. I mean having them scale nationally, 
ensuring that those individuals are trained, that those 
programs are resourced so they can operate with fidelity.
 But there's a really important opportunity to do 
nonpunitive interventions for individuals before they get to 
the point of criminality but have a handoff mechanism there in 
case they have crossed that criminal threshold so that we can 
maintain--ensure our democracy remains intact and these 
individuals receive accountability if that's what the situation 
calls for.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you. And this is a followup, two 
followups, if you don't mind. One, we have seen doxing of 
Federal judges and attacks on elected officials. Which 
protective measures have proven most effective at deterring or 
preventing these types of threats?
 Mr. Braniff. Senator, I don't know that I have a great 
answer on the prevention of doxing. We live in a very online 
world. There's a lot of information available for all of us. We 
can all do the best we can to protect our personal information. 
I think that at the end of the day, a lot of what we've been 
talking about is important and that are norms. What are the 
norms that we allow for that we think are acceptable in our 
Nation, in our community, in our households, among our friends? 
Norms actually really do matter, norms and culture-shaped 
behaviors. And we right now are really struggling with the 
power that the online world gives us without a lot of norms 
that are--that work against our worst impulses.
 Senator Padilla. Thank you. And one question for Mr. 
Hodges, and I appreciate your service and all you have been 
through and your willingness to be here today. Based on your 
experience, Mr. Hodges, what operational or resource gaps must 
be addressed to safeguard democratic processes and better 
protect public servants?
 Mr. Hodges. That's an excellent question. I'm just a 
regular old patrol officer. I'm not in the meetings of 
management. I don't have the bird's eye view. I don't know. I 
don't know what resources we can dedicate to stemming this 
problem. I believe the other witness here had a great point 
earlier about intervention. I'd never heard of that before from 
a scholarly point of view, and that sounded very promising. I 
think that we should look toward funding that if it gets the 
results that he spoke of.
 Senator Padilla. Okay. Thank you. And I know my time is up, 
Mr. Chairman. I just offer an invite in closing that we as 
Members of the Committee, Members of the Senate, as an entire 
body can do a whole lot of good by leading by example.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Senator Hawley.
 Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Thanks 
for calling this hearing on such an important topic. Sadly, it 
is very, very timely.
 Mr. Braniff, can I just start with you? I actually just 
want to followup on something you were just saying to Senator 
Padilla. So I wasn't quite clear from your answer to him. You 
are anti-doxing or pro-doxing?
 Mr. Braniff. Anti-doxing, Senator.
 Senator Hawley. And you were talking about norms, that we 
are struggling with norms now around the internet and what is 
public and whatnot. Did I hear that correctly?
 Mr. Braniff. Yes, Senator.
 Senator Hawley. So what would you say about elected 
officials who are actively doxing Federal law enforcement 
agents?
 Mr. Braniff. Senator, I'd say that's problematic behavior.
 Senator Hawley. Yes, I'm glad to hear you say that. Let's 
just be a little more specific. The doxing of ICE agents, the 
doxing of Border Patrol agents that elected Members of Congress 
have engaged in, do you think that is a norm that ought to be 
encouraged?
 Mr. Braniff. No, Senator.
 Senator Hawley. Would you condemn it here today?
 Mr. Braniff. I condemn antidemocratic behavior that puts 
individuals at risk when there are alternatives.
 Senator Hawley. Well, I am sorry. What does that mean? Does 
that mean no, not really or what? You are saying it is wrong to 
dox these people or not?
 Mr. Braniff. Yes, Senator. I'm saying it's wrong to dox 
individuals instead of using normal order, policy debates, 
civil discourse, voting to address differences in a democracy.
 Senator Hawley. Good. Okay. Good. Well, I am glad to hear 
you say that. I think that is important. And I think that your 
point about norms is well taken. But I have been shocked--just 
on the doxing question, I have been absolutely shocked to see 
elected Members of this body and of the House of 
Representatives actively advocating for the doxing of Federal 
law enforcement officers and then doing it, some of them 
posting information about ICE agents, trying to post their 
pictures online, trying to post where they live online. I mean, 
that is just unbelievable. And I don't want that to happen to 
anybody. Judges, sure, but let's start with our Federal law 
enforcement who are out there doing a terrific job and 
literally putting their lives on the line. I think of our brave 
police officers. There are some in this room here who currently 
are not getting paid by the way. The idea that these folks 
would be doxed is, I think, just unbelievable. I would plead 
with my colleagues on the other side of the aisle to stop this.
 Mr. Knowles, while I have got you here, welcome. Great to 
have you here. Can we just drill down a little bit on the 
political violence question and maybe just do, you know, a 
little more truth telling? Because I feel like we talk about 
political violence generally. We talk about violence against 
conservatives generally. But let's just be real specific. A lot 
of the violence that we are seeing is actually against people 
of faith. And more particularly, it is against Christians. 
Isn't that fair to say?
 Mr. Knowles. That's certainly fair to say, Senator.
 Senator Hawley. I mean, Charlie Kirk, what he said just a 
month before his death--and I heard it. He said it to me. I 
mean, Charlie was a friend. I knew him for almost a decade 
before his assassination. What he said was he wanted to--the 
legacy he wanted to leave was a legacy of faith. What he wanted 
to be known for was his faith in Jesus Christ. And I thought he 
was just incredibly bold about saying that publicly all the 
time, you know, when he could be talking about politics. And 
sure, he talked a lot of politics, of course, but what he 
really talked about was his faith. And you can't tell me that 
that did not play into the reason that he was killed.
 Let's look at some numbers, though. Here is the Center for 
Religious Liberty. These are some recent stats. The most recent 
stats that we have for the year 2024, 415 separately reported 
instances of acts of violence against churches in the United 
States. We are talking now about arson, bomb threats, firearm 
incidents, and shootings, as well as vandalism more broadly. 
The Biden administration prosecuted about zero of these 
particular threats in their time in office. What do you think 
it says that we are seeing this massive uptick in violence 
against people of faith, against Christians? I mean, what is 
the reason for this, do you think?
 Mr. Knowles. Cardinal Manning wisely observed that ``All 
human conflict ultimately is theological.'' A lot of our big 
policy debates in recent years have really been anthropological 
and religious in nature. What is a man, what is a woman, these 
kinds of questions. And there is no doubt, Senator, that the 
attacks, widespread and increasing, on churches has been 
underreported and ignored in some cases entirely. You know, 
there has been a lot of dispute over where the violence lies, 
on the left or on the right. And we've observed, now it seems, 
I think, indisputable that it's mostly on the left. But in 
earlier years, it has been observed that a lot of incidents 
just don't appear on the registers.
 And two of the most prominent that come to my mind 
recently, the Covenant school shooting in which a trans-
identifying killer massacred Christian children when they were 
at school, and of course the Annunciation school shooting, 
another coincidentally trans-identifying shooter killing 
schoolchildren. The fact that these were shootings related to 
churches, related to faith, is no coincidence at all. And the 
fact that Charlie Kirk said that what he most wanted to be 
remembered for was his faith is no coincidence either. He was 
absolutely right, and that's the heart of the matter.
 Senator Hawley. Let me--I am almost done, Mr. Chairman. I 
know my time is nearly at an end, but I just want to press on 
this point. What message do you think it sends, Mr. Knowles, 
when our own Government implicitly encourages this kind of 
anti-Christian animus? And I am thinking in particular of the 
infamous FBI memo in which the Biden DOJ and FBI attempted to 
recruit informants into Catholic parishes, in particular 
traditional Latin mass Catholic parishes. This is our 
Government now effectively telling the world, you know, we 
think these believers are kind of crazy. I mean, we think they 
need to be spied on. These people need to be watched. You know, 
we need informants in the choir. We need them in the pews. We 
need them at mass on every Sunday. What kind of a message do 
you think that that sends when our own Government is attempting 
to spy on people of faith and put spies into pews in churches?
 Mr. Knowles. In four words, Senator, the message is ``Don't 
go to church.'' And coincidentally, I'm here today to testify 
about this event at the University of Pittsburgh when Antifa 
threw an explosive during one of my events. The FBI reached out 
to me afterward. They asked if I would speak, and I said no 
because the story had just come out that the FBI had been 
infiltrating Catholic parishes under the Biden administration. 
We know that the DOJ had been prosecuting nuns, had been going 
after pro-lifers, had been going after Christians broadly, and 
I couldn't take that risk, a damning fact about how our 
Government has operated and the position of Christians in the 
United States.
 Senator Hawley. I just want to leave everybody in the room 
and watching this with one more picture of Mark Houck. Speaking 
of pro-lifers, Mark Houck is a devout Christian, believes in 
the right to life of every American. Here he is with his 
beautiful family. Our own Government sent an FBI SWAT team to 
this man's door at 5 in the morning to arrest him with guns 
drawn in front of his children. He was later acquitted, I might 
add. They charged him with ridiculous crimes. It would amount 
to essentially praying in front of an abortion clinic.
 [Poster is displayed.]
 I think we got a do--I think it is time for our Government 
to do some soul searching. You talk about soul searching that 
needs to go on. How about the fact that our own Government in 
the last 4 years used the FBI against pro-lifers, used the FBI 
against Christian parents, attempted to recruit spies into 
Catholic churches. When our Government is doing this, is it any 
surprise that we see deranged lunatics out there shooting 
people like Charlie Kirk?
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chair Schmitt. Senator Cruz.
 Senator Cruz. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Welcome to each of 
the witnesses.
 Mr. Knowles, welcome to the swamp. I will say I am very 
confused being in a room with you, and there are no cigars and 
no scotch. I cannot recall the last time that transpired.
 I appreciate the testimony of everyone here.
 The topic we are considering is, I think, of exceptional 
importance. There is an epidemic of politically motivated 
violence, and the politically motivated violence in this 
country is overwhelmingly emanating from the left. We saw that 
during the Black Lives Matter and Antifa riots across the 
country as cities across America burned. We saw that during the 
antisemitic protests on college campuses as Jewish students in 
particular were threatened and feared for their lives. We saw 
that with the pro-open border riots in Los Angeles and other 
cities. And we saw that tragically with the murder of Charlie 
Kirk, someone who was a good friend to many of us and an 
extraordinary leader.
 Mr. Knowles, you too were targeted on a college campus. 
What does it say about the State of our universities that 
holding a debate on a public campus now requires police 
barricades, bomb squads, and body armor?
 Mr. Knowles. My question is, what are the universities for? 
Aren't the universities for educating students? Aren't the 
universities for pursuing truth? If the universities are not 
advancing those goals, as manifestly they are not, then I think 
we need to strongly consider defunding those universities. I 
think we need to strongly consider not sending our children to 
those universities because they have been perverted against 
their very purpose. And this is so apparent in much of the 
left-wing discourse. To me, it seems, hearing even mainstream 
Democrats on this, that for them, their violence is speech and 
our speech is violence.
 There was no more gracious or generous or charitable 
debater on college campuses than Charlie Kirk. He always 
endeavored to hear out the other side, to steel man their 
arguments, to give them the benefit of the doubt. And he was 
killed for it. He was killed for ideological reasons. And that 
has to be an inflection point.
 And as far as I'm concerned, if the universities and the 
political order cannot shore up a healthy marketplace for 
debate, they're useless.
 Senator Cruz. Look, I think you are absolutely right. I 
think our universities are failing profoundly in that regard. 
At Columbia University, during the antisemitic protests, the 
Orthodox rabbi on campus sent an email to the Jewish students 
on campus and said, ``Do not come to campus because the 
university cannot and will not protect you.'' That is a 
fundamental abdication of their most essential responsibility, 
which is to protect their students. And Columbia refused to 
protect them because, ideologically, they sided with the 
violent protesters.
 And let me ask, the attack on your event, was that a 
spontaneous protest, or was it organized, planned, and well-
funded?
 Mr. Knowles. It was the latter, Senator. And we can point 
to the specific networks. We can point to the anarchist 
bookshops. We can point to the email addresses for the tax-
free, nonprofit organizations that were funneling the donations 
to these people. This is organized left-wing crime.
 Senator Cruz. I am not the only person who noticed in the 
antisemitic protests that the tents all matched. There is real 
money. There is real money, and it is many of the same 
networks, unfortunately, whether they are open border radicals, 
whether they are anti-capitalist communists, whether they are 
jihadists, the funding is steady and significant.
 Mr. Wolf, in 2020, under your leadership, DHS officers 
stood on the frontlines in Portland facing more than 100 
consecutive nights of siege against the Mark O. Hatfield 
Federal Courthouse. Officers were assaulted with commercial-
grade fireworks, lasers, and Molotov cocktails. Were those 
random outbursts, or were they coordinated, resourced 
operations with strategy, logistics, and financing behind them?
 Mr. Wolf. Oh, without a doubt, Senator, they were 
coordinated. I had the chance to visit Portland during the 
middle of that 100-day period. And from the Hatfield Courthouse 
where I was, you could see into the park below tents, a lot of 
them, a lot of tents. And I asked the--my Federal officers at 
the time, what's in the tents? They said, well, we don't know. 
We can't go over there. The Portland police won't help us 
understand what's going on over there.
 We eventually sent an undercover agent there. And his 
response was, it's weapons, it's munitions, it's a variety of 
different things that get resupplied almost on a daily basis.
 Senator Cruz. Wow.
 Mr. Wolf. So yes, organized.
 Senator Cruz. These same checkbooks are funding the chaos 
in Minneapolis, in Portland, in Los Angeles. It is why I have 
introduced the Stop FUNDERs Act. The Stop FUNDERs Act adds 
rioting as a predicate offense to RICO to enable the Department 
of Justice to use the full tools that have been directed at the 
mafia to go after the corrupt enterprise because, at the end of 
the day, the thug who is engaged in violence is committing 
criminal acts, but the billionaire who is trying to tear down 
this country by writing checks to fund it bears, in many ways, 
far greater responsibility.
 Mr. Wolf, in your judgment, would passing the Stop FUNDERs 
Act, adding rioting as a predicate act to RICO, assist DOJ in 
going after and stopping these coordinated, politically 
motivated acts of violence?
 [Poster is displayed.]
 Mr. Wolf. Yes, absolutely it would. And happy to say that 
America First Policy Institute has endorsed that piece of 
legislation as well because you have to understand where 
they're getting their finance, where they're getting their 
backing. And if you can't use the resources that the Department 
of Justice should be using, it's going to make it very 
difficult. In 2020, we simply ran out of time before we left 
office in 21. It's my understanding the Department of Justice 
and FBI are looking into this financing. So giving them 
additional quivers, you know, in their bag, I think, would be 
very good.
 Senator Cruz. Thank you.
 Chair Schmitt. Thank you, Senator Cruz.
 So I want to thank all the witnesses for being here today 
and for your testimony. Written questions for them may be 
submitted for the record until Tuesday, November 4, at 5 p.m.
 And with that, this hearing is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 4:31 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
 [Additional material submitted for the record follows.]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 

 A P P E N D I X

The following submissions are available at:

 https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg62928/pdf/CHRG-119shrg
 62928-add1.pdf

Submitted by Chair Schmitt:

 Carney, Timothy P., American Enterprise Institute (AEI), article. 2

 [all]