THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1996: 30 YEARS LATER

Committee on Energy and Commerce · Subcommittee on Communications and Technology House March 26, 2026

Witnesses (4)

  • Chip Pickering, Chief Executive Officer, Incompas
  • Michael O'Rielly, President, MPORielly Consulting, LLC
  • Adam Thierer, Resident Senior Fellow, Technology and Innovation, R Street Institute
  • Prepared statement \1\ Matthew F. Wood, Vice President of Policy and General Counsel, Free Press Action

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1996: 30 YEARS LATER

[House Hearing, 119 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1996: 30 
 YEARS LATER
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND 
 TECHNOLOGY

 OF THE

 COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND COMMERCE
 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 MARCH 26, 2026

 __________

 Serial No. 119-68
 
 
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Published for the use of the Committee on Energy and Commerce 
 govinfo.gov/committee/house-energy
 energycommerce.house.gov
 
 __________
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
64-512 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
====================================================================== 
 
 COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND COMMERCE

 BRETT GUTHRIE, Kentucky
 Chairman
ROBERT E. LATTA, Ohio FRANK PALLONE, Jr., New Jersey
H. MORGAN GRIFFITH, Virginia Ranking Member
GUS M. BILIRAKIS, Florida DIANA DeGETTE, Colorado
RICHARD HUDSON, North Carolina JAN SCHAKOWSKY, Illinois
EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia DORIS O. MATSUI, California
GARY J. PALMER, Alabama KATHY CASTOR, Florida
NEAL P. DUNN, Florida, Vice PAUL TONKO, New York
 Chairman YVETTE D. CLARKE, New York
DAN CRENSHAW, Texas RAUL RUIZ, California
JOHN JOYCE, Pennsylvania SCOTT H. PETERS, California
RANDY K. WEBER, Sr., Texas DEBBIE DINGELL, Michigan
RICK W. ALLEN, Georgia MARC A. VEASEY, Texas
TROY BALDERSON, Ohio ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois
RUSS FULCHER, Idaho NANETTE DIAZ BARRAGAN, California
AUGUST PFLUGER, Texas DARREN SOTO, Florida
DIANA HARSHBARGER, Tennessee KIM SCHRIER, Washington
MARIANNETTE MILLER-MEEKS, Iowa LORI TRAHAN, Massachusetts
KAT CAMMACK, Florida LIZZIE FLETCHER, Texas
JAY OBERNOLTE, California ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ, New York
JOHN JAMES, Michigan JAKE AUCHINCLOSS, Massachusetts
CLIFF BENTZ, Oregon TROY A. CARTER, Louisiana
ERIN HOUCHIN, Indiana ROBERT MENENDEZ, New Jersey
RUSSELL FRY, South Carolina KEVIN MULLIN, California
LAUREL M. LEE, Florida GREG LANDSMAN, Ohio
NICHOLAS A. LANGWORTHY, New York JENNIFER L. McCLELLAN, Virginia
THOMAS H. KEAN, Jr., New Jersey
MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio
GABE EVANS, Colorado
CRAIG A. GOLDMAN, Texas
JULIE FEDORCHAK, North Dakota
 ------ 

 Professional Staff

 MEGAN JACKSON, Staff Director
 SOPHIE KHANAHMADI, Deputy Staff Director
 TIFFANY GUARASCIO, Minority Staff Director
 Subcommittee on Communications and Technology

 RICHARD HUDSON, North Carolina
 Chairman
RICK W. ALLEN, Georgia, Vice DORIS O. MATSUI, California
 Chairman Ranking Member
ROBERT E. LATTA, Ohio DARREN SOTO, Florida
H. MORGAN GRIFFITH, Virginia YVETTE D. CLARKE, New York
GUS M. BILIRAKIS, Florida RAUL RUIZ, California
EARL L. ``BUDDY'' CARTER, Georgia SCOTT H. PETERS, California
NEAL P. DUNN, Florida DEBBIE DINGELL, Michigan
RUSS FULCHER, Idaho ROBIN L. KELLY, Illinois
AUGUST PFLUGER, Texas NANETTE DIAZ BARRAGAN, California
KAT CAMMACK, Florida TROY A. CARTER, Louisiana
JAY OBERNOLTE, California ROBERT MENENDEZ, New Jersey
ERIN HOUCHIN, Indiana GREG LANDSMAN, Ohio
RUSSELL FRY, South Carolina JENNIFER L. McCLELLAN, Virginia
THOMAS H. KEAN, Jr., New Jersey KATHY CASTOR, Florida
CRAIG A. GOLDMAN, Texas FRANK PALLONE, Jr., New Jersey (ex 
JULIE FEDORCHAK, North Dakota officio)
BRETT GUTHRIE, Kentucky (ex 
 officio)
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 
 Page
Hon. Richard Hudson, a Representative in Congress from the State 
 of North Carolina, opening statement........................... 2
 Prepared statement........................................... 4
Hon. Doris O. Matsui, a Representative in Congress from the State 
 of California, opening statement............................... 9
 Prepared statement........................................... 11
Hon. Brett Guthrie, a Representative in Congress from the 
 Commonwealth of Kentucky, opening statement.................... 13
 Prepared statement........................................... 14
Hon. Frank Pallone, Jr., a Representative in Congress from the 
 State of New Jersey, opening statement......................... 17
 Prepared statement........................................... 19

 Witnesses

Chip Pickering, Chief Executive Officer, Incompas................ 21
 Prepared statement........................................... 24
Michael O'Rielly, President, MPORielly Consulting, LLC........... 26
 Prepared statement........................................... 28
Adam Thierer, Resident Senior Fellow, Technology and Innovation, 
 R Street Institute............................................. 37
 Prepared statement \1\
Matthew F. Wood, Vice President of Policy and General Counsel, 
 Free Press Action.............................................. 39
 Prepared statement \2\

 Submitted Material

Inclusion of the following was approved by unanimous consent.
List of documents submitted for the record....................... 84
Letter of March 26, 2026, from Kevin Donnelly, Executive Director 
 and Chief Advocacy Officer, Real Estate Technology & 
 Transformation Center, to Mr. Hudson and Ms. Matsui............ 85
Letter of March 25, 2026, from Grant B. Spellmeyer, President and 
 Chief Executive Officer, America's Communications Association, 
 to Guthrie, et al.............................................. 89
Letter from Jonathan Spalter, President and Chief Executive 
 Officer, USTelecom, to Mr. Hudson and Ms. Matsui............... 92
Letter of March 26, 2026, from Odette J. Wilkens, President and 
 General Counsel, The National Call for Safe Technology, to Mr. 
 Guthrie, et al.6093
Letter of March 26, 2026, from Michael R. Romano, Chief Executive 
 Officer, NTCA, to Mr. Guthrie, et al........................... 125
Tweet of February 20, 2020, from Brendan Carr, Commissioner, 
 Federal Communications Commission.............................. 127
Statement of Russ Fulcher, a Representative in Congress from the 
 State of Idaho, March 26, 2026................................. 128

----------

\1\ Mr. Thierer's statement has been retained in committee files and is 
available at https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF16/20260326/119115/
HHRG-119-IF16-Wstate-ThiererA-20260326.pdf.
\2\ Mr. Wood's statement has been retained in committee files and is 
available at https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF16/20260326/119115/
HHRG-119-IF16-Wstate-WoodsM-20260326.pdf.

 
 THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1996: 30 YEARS LATER

 ---------- 

 THURSDAY, MARCH 26, 2026

 House of Representatives,
 Subcommittee on Communications and Technology,
 Committee on Energy and Commerce,
 Washington, DC.
 The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:16 a.m., in 
the John D. Dingell Room 2123, Rayburn House Office Building, 
Hon. Richard Hudson (chairman of the subcommittee) presiding.
 Members present: Hudson, Allen, Latta, Griffith, Bilirakis, 
Carter of Georgia, Dunn, Fulcher, Pfluger, Cammack, Obernolte, 
Goldman, Fedorchak, Guthrie (ex officio), Matsui (subcommittee 
ranking member), Soto, Clarke, Ruiz, Peters, Dingell, Kelly, 
Barragan, Carter of Louisiana, Menendez, Landsman, McClellan, 
Castor, and Pallone (ex officio).
 Also present: Representative Joyce.
 Staff present: Jessica Donlon, General Counsel; Michael 
Essington, Chief Counsel, Communications and Technology; Sydney 
Greene, Director of Finance and Logistics; Megan Jackson, Staff 
Director; Noah Jackson, Clerk, Communications and Technology; 
John Lin, Senior Counsel, Communications and Technology; Joel 
Miller, Deputy Staff Director; Elaina Murphy, Professional 
Staff Member, Communications and Technology; Dylan Rogers, 
Professional Staff Member, Communications and Technology; Chris 
Sarley, Member Services/Stakeholder Director; Timothy Trimble, 
Staff Assistant; Matt VanHyfte, Communications Director; Hannah 
Anton, Minority Policy Analyst; Giancarlo Ceja, Minority Staff 
Assistant; Parul Desai, Minority Chief Counsel, Communications 
and Technology; Waverly Gordon, Minority Deputy Staff Director 
and General Counsel; Tiffany Guarascio, Minority Staff 
Director; Serena Klebba, Minority Intern; Jaime McCoy, Minority 
FCC Detailee; Elisabeth Mellen, Minority Intern; Dan Miller, 
Minority Professional Staff Member; Emma Roehrig, Minority 
Staff Assistant; Andrew Souvall, Minority Director of 
Communications, Outreach, and Member Services; and Johanna 
Thomas, Minority Counsel.
 Mr. Hudson. The committee will come to order.
 The Chair recognizes himself for an opening statement.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD HUDSON, A REPRESENTATIVE IN 
 CONGRESS FROM THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA

 Good morning. Welcome to today's hearing, examining the 
Telecommunications Act of 1996.
 It is hard to believe that 1996 was 30 years ago. That 
February, I was a student at UNC Charlotte. I won't ask any of 
my colleagues where they were at the time. I am certainly not 
going to ask the staff, because most of them probably weren't 
born yet. But here in Washington, right across the street at 
the Library of Congress, Members of Congress celebrated the 
passage of the Telecommunications Act.
 I have to admit, the event was not on my radar as a college 
senior. However, the Telecom Act was a huge milestone when it 
was enacted. It was the first major rewrite of communications 
policy since the Communications Act of 1934.
 The law was designed to deregulate the market, unleash 
competition, and open opportunities for new technologies and 
services. In many ways, it succeeded. By eliminating certain 
monopoly-era laws and preempting State and local barriers, the 
Telecom Act opened the communications ecosystem to new players, 
leading to competition and innovation that ultimately benefited 
consumers.
 Competitors could enter local phone markets. Telephone 
companies could now provide video. Cable companies could 
provide voice service, and they could do this while entering 
markets that previously were not allowed to serve. It also 
enshrined the principles of universal service that are so 
important to rural America. Finally, it included what we now 
know as Section 230--26 words that created the internet economy 
as we know it today.
 But the world has changed significantly since 1996. Back 
then, the internet was a new technology. We were just beginning 
to hear the familiar, but now extinct, dial-up tone and use web 
browsers like Netscape. None of us could have predicted the 
technological revolution that was coming.
 The Telecom Act, unfortunately, did not foresee how 
essential broadband would be to our lives, nor did it see the 
rise of new ways to communicate. Back then, everyone relied on 
their home landline to make phone calls. Cell phones were 
considered a luxury. But today, we all have a computer in our 
pocket that, among other things, is a very quality cell phone. 
I am not sure if any of us even still have a home phone. If we 
do, I wonder how many can even remember their phone number.
 And if we wanted to talk with someone on the other side of 
the world back in 1996, we had to rely on a long-distance 
carrier to place an expensive, charge-by-the-minute call, 
whereas today we can connect with anyone anywhere via cell 
phone call, a video call, a text message, or through social 
media.
 The world of 1996 looks nothing like the world today, and 
it is time we update our laws to reflect that. That is why we 
are holding this hearing. Today's hearing is an opportunity to 
look back at the Telecom Act as well as the law it amended, the 
Communications Act of 1934, and find out what continues to work 
and what does not.
 For example, does it still make sense to regulate 
communications technologies in different silos? Do we still 
need an entire section on pay phone service? Is it time to 
revisit Section 230? And how should we address media ownership 
as broadcasters must now compete for engagement and revenue 
against platforms that didn't even exist in 1996?
 Congress needs to consider how we should modernize our 
communications policy framework to reflect the technologies of 
today in a way that will also work for the technologies of 
tomorrow.
 We have an esteemed panel of witnesses here today, some of 
whom were intimately involved with the drafting of the Telecom 
Act. I look forward to hearing from them, and I look forward to 
this really important discussion.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Hudson follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 Mr. Hudson. I now recognize the ranking member, the 
gentlelady from California, for her opening statement.

OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. DORIS O. MATSUI, A REPRESENTATIVE IN 
 CONGRESS FROM THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

 Ms. Matsui. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank 
you to our witnesses for being here today.
 Thirty years ago, Congress passed the Telecommunications 
Act of 1996 with a clear and ambitious vision: to promote 
competition and deliver lower prices and better service for 
consumers.
 At its core, this law was about making sure that, as 
technology evolved, the benefits would reach everyone, and in 
many ways it succeeded. It opened the door to greater 
competition and telephone markets, it laid the groundwork for 
the internet revolution, and it established a universal service 
framework built on a simple idea: Where you live should not 
determine whether you can connect.
 That work included two programs vital to the success of the 
Universal Service Fund: E-Rate, which helps connect schools and 
libraries, and the Rural Health Care Program to improve 
broadband access for rural clinics and hospitals, laying the 
foundation for expanded patient care. These achievements were 
possible because Congress acted boldly, but 30 years later we 
haven't finished the job. Too many Americans still lack 
reliable, affordable broadband.
 The 2021 Bipartisan Infrastructure Law was our answer to 
that unfinished work. Through the BEAD Program, Congress made a 
once-in-a-lifetime generation investment to really fully close 
the digital divide. But under the Trump administration, NTIA 
has thrown BEAD into chaos, freezing funds, forcing States to 
scrap years of work, and stripping away affordability 
protections. Communities that are ready to build are still 
waiting because the administration decided it knows better than 
Congress, the States, and the communities that did the hard 
work.
 The same pattern of sabotage is showing up in the FCC under 
Chairman Carr. Just last week, the FCC rubberstamped the 
Nexstar-Tegna merger, flying in the face of the law.
 The Telecommunications Act set clear media ownership caps 
to protect local voices and competition. Congress said no 
single company can reach more than 39 percent of U.S. 
households, but Chairman Carr ignored that rule to clear a mega 
merger that would reach 80 percent of American households. Why? 
Because these companies are willing to bend to pressure and 
silence speech President Trump disagrees with. Just look at 
what they did to Jimmy Kimmel.
 And the damage is clear: weaker local news, fewer 
independent voices, and less competition. These are serious 
setbacks, but the goals of the Telecom Act--competition, 
connectivity, consumer protection--remain just as urgent today. 
That means modernizing the Universal Service Fund so it can 
continue supporting our schools, hospitals, and communities. It 
also means getting serious about affordability, because 
connectivity is not universal if it is unaffordable.
 Since Republicans let the Affordable Connectivity Program 
expire, millions of families have struggled to stay connected. 
Seniors have lost access to telehealth. Students have fallen 
behind in school. If universal service is our goal, 
affordability has to be front and center. We need policies that 
keep pace with the technology.
 Look at next-gen TV. Broadcasters are already using it to 
deliver better emergency alerts and on-demand local news. That 
is the kind of innovation the Telecom Act was meant to 
encourage. And it is a reminder that Congress has to keep 
revisiting these laws, building on what works to support both 
consumers and cutting-edge technology.
 One strength of the Telecom Act was that it didn't shut 
States out. States keep a meaningful role in regulating 
telecom, addressing issues on the ground, and protecting their 
residents. We need that same balanced approach as we navigate 
AI. Let me be clear: Sweeping State preemption without strong 
guardrails is ignoring the lessons our most successful modern 
industry was built on.
 The Telecom Act gave us a strong foundation. Our job now is 
to build on it, fix it where it has fallen short, and hold this 
administration accountable when it ignores the law. I look 
forward to hearing from our witnesses on how we get that done.
 And with that, Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
 [The prepared statement of Ms. Matsui follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 I now recognize the chairman of the full committee, the 
gentleman from Kentucky, for 5 minutes for his opening 
statement.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. BRETT GUTHRIE, A REPRESENTATIVE IN 
 CONGRESS FROM THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY

 Mr. Guthrie. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate you for 
bringing us all together in an important hearing, and thank you 
to our witnesses for being here, and to my friend from 
California, Ms. Matsui, for you holding--everybody holding this 
hearing.
 So it is incredible how things have changed over the last 
30 years. In 1996, I was actually in business school learning 
from case studies that had not yet anticipated the dramatic 
evolution of technology we have seen since then over the last 
three decades, which have fundamentally changed the world of 
business and daily lives of our constituents.
 One of the case studies in probably 1995 or--1996 or 1997 
was, will Apple survive? Will Apple survive? So it shows how 
much we knew of what was coming forward.
 So the Telecommunications Act of 1996 was a monumental law 
when it passed, and it is largely responsible for ushering in 
the years of growth and development. The 1996 Act deregulated 
the telecommunications industry, allowed for technological 
innovation and new competitors to enter the marketplace, which 
ultimately benefited consumers.
 The law was also essential to rural America by codifying 
the principle of universal service, which has played a critical 
role ensuring that every American has access to the 
communication services that have become essential to everyday 
life.
 But things have changed in the last 30 years. Landlines are 
no longer a primary mode of communication. Technologies that 
were in their infancy or unforeseen in 1996--broadband, AI, 
streaming--are now the foundations of how we communicate, 
interact, and carry out tasks in our day-to-day lives.
 One of my priorities as chairman of this committee is 
modernizing the laws in our jurisdiction that govern nearly 70 
percent of the economy. The 30th anniversary of the Telecom Act 
gives us an opportunity to reexamine our communications laws 
and consider how to update them for today's world and the next 
generations.
 In conducting this review, we must recognize this is a 
critical moment in history. The United States is the global 
leader in technological advances due in large part to policies 
that allow the private sector to innovate. Congress should 
continue the deregulatory framework of the Telecommunications 
Act and implement light-touch policies that allow the U.S. to 
maintain its status as the global leader in technological 
advancements. This is especially important as we compete for 
technological leadership against adversaries like China.
 I look forward to hearing from the witnesses on this 
important topic and hearing how Congress can modernize our 
communications laws.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for conducting this, our witnesses 
for being here, and I will yield back. 
[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 I now recognize the gentleman from New Jersey, the ranking 
member, for 5 minutes for his opening statement.

OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. FRANK PALLONE, Jr., A REPRESENTATIVE 
 IN CONGRESS FROM THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY

 Mr. Pallone. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 I have to digress a minute and say, when I see Congressman 
Pickering, I keep thinking of ``Home Town'' with Erin and Ben 
fixing up Laurel, Mississippi, his hometown--because my wife 
insists that I watch ``Home Town'' almost every night--fixing 
up Laurel to, like, make it more southern or whatever. It's 
very pretty, but I have never been there.
 In any case, 30 years ago Congress, on a bipartisan basis, 
passed the Telecommunications Act of 1996. This landmark 
legislation sought to catapult the communication industry to 
the digital age by promoting the principles of competition, 
innovation, and, importantly, universal connectivity, ensuring 
that all Americans have affordable access to advanced 
communication services, such as broadband.
 Congress also envisioned a media marketplace defined by 
competition, diversity of voices, and consumer choice, and in 
some respects, Congress got it right. The law helped fuel the 
internet age as we know it, but there are still too many goals 
of that law that have not been met. And I am deeply concerned 
that with Brendan Carr as Chair of the Federal Communications 
Commission, the agency is moving further away from the goals 
that Congress envisioned in 1996.
 Instead of delivering access to reliable and affordable 
broadband for all Americans, Chairman Carr has rolled back 
broadband price transparency requirements and taken steps to 
limit students' ability to access Wi-Fi on school buses for 
homework. Rather than preserving local and diverse voices, 
Chairman Carr is fighting First Amendment battles he can't win 
and squeezing competition from the media market, undermining 
the very principles Congress set out to achieve in 1996.
 And Chairman Carr seems to think his only role is to serve 
as President Trump's lackey and target news outlets and 
broadcasters for exercising their First Amendment rights and 
not bending to the President's will.
 And last week's decision by the FCC's Media Bureau to 
approve the Nexstar-Tegna deal simply adds insult to injury, in 
my opinion. This decision, which is a favorite to President 
Trump's allies, was released in the dead of night and without a 
full Commission vote. And it is simply illegal, because the 39 
percent statutory cap on broadcast station ownership can't be 
waived away without an act of Congress.
 So this decision also paves the way for unprecedented media 
consolidation at both the national and local levels, and 
undercuts the 1996 Act's goal for a media market built on 
competition, localism, and a diversity of voices. There is also 
a lot of evidence that this wave of consolidation will lead to 
higher bills for consumers that subscribe to pay-TV services, 
and yet again another opportunity for the Trump administration 
to drive up prices on hardworking American families.
 At the same time, the National Telecommunications and 
Information Administration has delayed and undermined our 
country's best shot to achieve universal connectivity and 
finally close the digital divide. The Broadband Equity, Access, 
and Deployment, or BEAD, Program represents the most well-
financed effort to date to bring affordable high-speed internet 
service to every community in the Nation. Yet under the Trump 
administration, NTIA has sought to redirect the BEAD Program in 
ways that were never intended by Congress. The administration 
is effectively turning the BEAD Program into the Republican 
FCC's failed Rural Digital Opportunity Fund program, an outcome 
Congress specifically wanted to avoid.
 So closing the digital divide also means ensuring Americans 
have the skills to use the internet. Yet NTIA, under the Trump 
administration, unilaterally and illegally stopped funding 
programs under the Digital Equity Act, which was a part of the 
Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. This act funds programs that 
would help seniors, veterans, the disabled, and others learn 
the skills needed to fully participate in today's and 
tomorrow's digital economy.
 My Democratic colleagues and I have repeatedly requested 
information and answers from NTIA about its management of the 
BEAD Program, but their response was late and woefully 
inadequate.
 And finally, while there is still more work to do to 
achieve the universal access Congress envisioned three decades 
ago, we are now experiencing another technological revolution 
driven by artificial intelligence. Unfortunately, Trump and 
congressional Republicans are undermining our ability to 
protect consumers and ensure that they are the real 
beneficiaries of this technology, not the victims.
 As AI seemingly becomes integrated into Americans' daily 
lives, Congress must implement guardrails and consumer 
protections before it is too late.
 And with that, Mr. Chairman, I yield back the balance of my 
time.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Pallone follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 We have now concluded with members' opening statements. The 
chair reminds members that pursuant to committee rules, all 
members' opening statements will be made part of the record.
 I would like to thank our witnesses for being here to 
testify before this subcommittee. Our witnesses will have 5 
minutes to provide an opening statement, which will be followed 
by a round of questions from members.
 The witnesses here before us today are the Honorable Chip 
Pickering, chief executive officer of Incompas, and no stranger 
to this room, a former member of this committee; the Honorable 
Michael O'Rielly, president of MPORielly Consulting, LLC; Mr. 
Adam Thierer, resident senior fellow, technology and 
innovation, R Street Institute; and Mr. Matt Wood, vice 
president of policy and general counsel at Free Press. Thank 
you all for being here.
 Mr. Pickering, you are recognized for 5 minutes for your 
opening statement.

 STATEMENTS OF CHIP PICKERING, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, 
 INCOMPAS; MICHAEL O'RIELLY, PRESIDENT, MPORIELLY CONSULTING, 
 LLC; ADAM THIERER, RESIDENT SENIOR FELLOW, TECHNOLOGY AND 
 INNOVATION, R STREET INSTITUTE; AND MATTHEW F. WOOD, VICE 
 PRESIDENT OF POLICY AND GENERAL COUNSEL, FREE PRESS ACTION

 STATEMENT OF CHIP PICKERING

 Mr. Pickering. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and to the entire 
committee, Ranking Member Matsui.
 As we gather today to celebrate and reflect on the 30th 
anniversary of the Telecommunications Act, I also want to 
recognize Congresswoman Dingell's spouse--John Dingell, 
Chairman Dingell, Ranking Member Dingell--for his tremendous 
leadership in the 1996 Act. And of this committee, Robert 
Matsui was a great leader at the time in the 1996 Act. So 
Congresswoman Matsui's husband. So I just want to recognize 
Michael Bilirakis, Gus Bilirakis' father was here during the 
1996 Act.
 Ranking Member Pallone, thank you for recognizing my 
hometown. It was discovered on Facebook, and so it is kind of 
interesting that social media, which emerged out of the 1996 
Act, found my hometown and the stars of the show that really 
has resurrected and revitalized my hometown. So there are many 
great stories and great relationships.
 And this committee has done a tremendous job of overseeing 
the implementation and the oversight of the 1996 Act over the 
last three decades.
 This milestone is especially meaningful to me personally. I 
had the privilege of working on the Act as a staffer for 
Senator Lott and then overseeing the implementation of it as a 
member of the Energy and Commerce Committee.
 Today, I see its lasting impacts on the private sector as 
CEO of Incompas. I get to represent the companies building the 
networks that power our digital economy. Incompas represents 
competitors building networks of the future, innovators 
creating and delivering internet content, and AI infrastructure 
companies that ensure we have the energy and infrastructure 
needed to win the global AI race.
 Our members are catalysts for economic growth and for 
improving the quality of life for all Americans through 
technological innovation, new services, greater choice for 
consumers and businesses. These services they offer today were 
made possible by the 1996 Telecommunications Act.
 Few pieces of legislation have had as profound and enduring 
impact on our economy and society. At its core, the Act was 
grounded in a simple but powerful principle: Competition drives 
innovation. And Congress made a deliberate choice to break down 
monopolies, open markets, and allow new entrants to compete. 
That decision helped unleash unprecedented private investment, 
expand consumer choice, and create the foundation for the 
modern internet.
 The light-touch, pro-innovation approach is a key reason 
the United States became a global leader in the internet. The 
Act helped create the policy framework that allowed the 
internet to grow as an open, dynamic platform, and by 
encouraging competition and removing unnecessary regulatory 
barriers, Congress set the stage for innovation at the edge, 
where entrepreneurs, startups, and new ideas could flourish.
 The Act reflected a broader national commitment to 
universal connectivity. Universal service is not just a policy; 
it is a promise that every American, regardless of where they 
live, can access our networks and participate in the digital 
economy. It is why the transition to next-generation networks 
must be done responsibly and with access to critical 
infrastructure, preserving and protecting public safety, and 
keeping those principles in mind. That promise remains just as 
important today as it was 30 years ago.
 Today, we are entering a new era defined by artificial 
intelligence, cloud computing, and next-generation networks. 
The infrastructure that Incompas members are building--fiber, 
data centers, energy transmission and generation, the global 
connectivity platforms--is a direct result of the policy 
decisions made in the 1996 Act.
 And just as before, success will depend on getting the 
fundamentals right: promoting competition, removing barriers to 
deployment, encouraging investment through predictable national 
framework policy, and ensuring that connectivity remains open, 
accessible, and secure.
 The lessons of the Telecommunications of 1996 is clear: 
When Congress sets the right framework, the private sector 
delivers, investment follows, innovation accelerates, and 
consumers benefit. The 1996 Act endures not because it 
anticipated every technology that followed but because it was 
anchored to principles that transcend any particular 
technology: competition, openness, and universal connectivity.
 We are now writing the first sentences of the next chapter, 
and I would ask that you write them with the same clarity of 
purpose. That means streamlining permitting so that data 
centers, fiber networks, and transmission and energy 
infrastructure can be deployed without years of regulatory 
delay and advancing competitive energy policies that ensure the 
power required to run an AI-enabled economy is available and 
accessible to all market participants.
 And just as the 1996 Act unlocked the internet era, this 
committee has a real opportunity, more importantly a duty, to 
lay the foundation for America's future in AI and digital 
infrastructure, and the country is counting on you to get it 
right, and I look forward to working with you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Pickering follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 Mr. O'Rielly, you are recognized for 5 minutes for an 
opening statement.

 STATEMENT OF MICHAEL O'RIELLY

 Mr. O'Rielly. Subcommittee Chairman Hudson, Ranking Member 
Matsui, full committee Chairman Guthrie, and Ranking Member 
Pallone, thank you for the opportunity to participate in 
today's hearing on such an important topic.
 I am Michael O'Rielly, an independent consultant in the 
telecom media technology space. I am likely here before you 
today because a little over 30 years ago I sat at a table like 
this, in this room, in this institution, to help pass 
legislation as part of this committee. I also stayed to see its 
implementation and eventually moved to the FCC as a 
Commissioner from 2013 to 2020.
 I am really sitting here because of the legislative skills 
of one of my former life mentors, former Chairman Tom Bliley, 
whose picture hangs on the wall before us, and only because of 
him did the Telecom Act become law. He was able to finesse the 
substance, the egos, and wishes of the members of the 
committee, and the uniqueness of the other body to reform the 
underlying law and cross the finish line, as no one did before 
and no one has since.
 Sectors of the industry flourish because of him and his 
vision, and we are all better because of his ability to pass 
legislation into law.
 The lessons of the Telecom Act--what went right, what went 
wrong, which aspects remain contested, and what fell out of 
scope--can be instructive for the subcommittee. Humbly, after a 
long review, I identified six lessons that shaped how I 
approach legislation throughout my professional career.
 First, comprehensive legislation is extremely difficult. 
The Telecom Act was enacted partly because the right conditions 
existed, driven by the desire of various companies to compete 
in the then-existing local and long-distance telephone markets. 
That single purpose helped propel the other provisions forward. 
It often takes a very strong engine to pull the rest of the 
cars forward.
 Second, key industries were intentionally excluded or only 
marginally affected. Although the Telecom Act included reforms 
across many areas, some sectors or segments of the industry, 
such as wireless and the internet, were not included or only 
marginally impacted.
 Third, timeliness and asymmetrical trade affected outcomes. 
Resolving the local and long-distance telephone disputes, which 
faced a fairly turbulent process, was driven by older legal and 
regulatory challenges. Congress likely overestimated how 
difficult it would be to open the local telephone voice market 
to competition, which still faces obstacles, but it is thriving 
in many instances.
 Fourth, Congress cannot rely on the implementing agency. 
Once enacted into law, much of the responsibility for 
implementing the law shifted to the FCC. While the agency 
addressed some issues effectively, there were numerous 
instances in which the law's provisions were either 
intentionally or unintentionally misapplied. Some of these 
outcomes aligned with my views. In other instances, the abuses 
were extremely difficult to accept. My advice to policymakers 
is to explain in great detail what they want an agency to do 
and, more importantly, what they do not want them to do. Do not 
rely on the faith that an agency will do the right thing.
 Fifth, compromise is proven painful. The legislative 
process often requires tradeoffs to simplify the process and 
garner support. In nearly every instance in the Telecom Act, a 
seemingly harmless provision, one that would have drawn 
opposition from the Republican majority if examined standalone 
or separately, was used differently than intended and given 
more significance than it deserved. That is not a failure of 
the law's authors but those who gave their word on what they 
really wanted from the provision.
 And sixth, we are still litigating vague language. Several 
key provisions are still being challenged 30 years later. That 
has proven to be highly problematic.
 As to whether Congress should undertake a major rewrite of 
our Nation's communication laws, focusing primarily on the 
Communications Act of 1934, and, if so, what should be 
included, I do not at this time see demand for comprehensive 
reform.
 This notwithstanding, there are several areas the 
subcommittee could consider taking action, including completely 
deregulating the video service marketplace or, alternatively, 
expanding FCC forbearance authority to apply to video providers 
and operators; reforming universal service, but only if it 
addresses all three elements of distribution, contributions, 
and administration; continuing to push satellite regulatory 
reform and simplification; and preempting State regulation over 
standalone VoIP.
 I welcome any questions the subcommittee may have.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. O'Rielly follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 Mr. Thierer, you are recognized for 5 minutes for an 
opening statement.

 STATEMENT OF ADAM THIERER

 Mr. Thierer. Chairman Hudson, Ranking Member Matsui, and 
members of the committee, thank you for the invitation to 
participate in this important hearing.
 My name is Adam Thierer, and I am a senior fellow at the R 
Street Institute, where I cover technology policy. I have spent 
34 years working on communications and media policy issues, and 
in the early 1990s I worked closely with members of this 
committee and others in Congress on what would eventually 
become the Telecommunications Act of 1996.
 It was an exhilarating time when many of us hoped for 
comprehensive modernization of communications law and bold 
reforms of the Federal Communications Commission. Ultimately, 
however, the Telecom Act has not lived up to those lofty 
expectations.
 America's information ecosystem remains overregulated and 
subject to far too much FCC meddling with both markets and 
speech. This happened because the Telecom Act failed to impose 
serious constraints on the FCC and even empowered the agency to 
regulate in new ways using many open-ended powers on top of the 
many older rules that remained untouched by the law.
 Twenty-six years ago, while testifying before the House 
Oversight Committee about the FCC, I noted that just 4 years 
after the supposedly deregulatory Telecom Act passed, the 
agency had only grown bigger and more powerful. Quote, ``There 
is simply no development within the communications marketplace 
today that is not scrutinized under the FCC's regulatory 
microscope,'' I noted in 2000.
 Unfortunately, that remains true today even though most 
experts agree, quote, ``Its original mission has faded and, 
worse yet, the FCC has become increasingly politicized,'' end 
quote. While the Telecom Act sought to promote competition and 
reduce regulation and encouraged the FCC to forbear from 
overregulating, it became clear quite quickly that the agency 
would never relinquish control.
 The FCC has taken advantage of the fact the Telecom Act 
was, in the words of the Supreme Court, quote, ``a model of 
ambiguity or indeed even self-contradiction.'' The agency used 
the law's many vague provisions and the countless existing 
rules to continue micromanaging markets and speech. As one 
leading analyst concludes, the agency's, quote, ``broad grant 
of authority, combined with its impenetrable complexity, means 
that it has nearly boundless ability to distribute favors and 
shape the trillion-dollar technology and media industries.''
 Today, the FCC ranks first among independent regulatory 
agencies in terms of rules promulgated, and an estimated 88 
percent of those rules affect small businesses. These continued 
mandates raise costs by undermining innovation and competition. 
The agency only seems to be willing to loosen restrictions once 
sectors or technologies have become completely obsolete, as 
when the FCC finally scrapped its Morse code regulations in 
2007 and eliminated rules governing telegraphs and phone booths 
just last year.
 The good news is, is that innovations in digital computing, 
e-commerce, smartphones, and video streaming were able to 
accelerate rapidly because they were not constrained by the FCC 
or older, quote, ``Mother, May I?'' regulations.
 But this has left us with a bizarre and unfair situation. 
The innovators least regulated by the Telecom Act and the FCC 
are freer to innovate and to speak, while the sectors still 
under their control remain burdened by excessive economic and 
speech controls.
 Congress needs to address this situation and should do so 
by undertaking a thorough regulatory spring cleaning, as I like 
to call it, to address the unfinished business of the Telecom 
Act.
 Technological change has made the traditional rationales 
for FCC regulation largely obsolete. Congress should establish 
clear timetables for the gradual phaseout of outdated media and 
telecom restrictions to free older sectors and ensuring that 
the FCC will not expand its mission to become a veritable 
Federal Computer Commission.
 Most old policies can be sunset after an orderly 2-to-3-
year winddown. Congress should pass a new communications 
freedom act that would, number one, scrap wireline 
communication--common carrier regulations and media industry 
mandates and let the Federal Trade Commission and Department of 
Justice handle competition policy and consumer harm matters.
 Number two, depoliticize the spectrum and treat it as a 
fully flexible and tradable property right, then transfer any 
remaining technical spectrum allocation and management tasks to 
the National Telecommunications and Information Administration 
or a technical coordination body.
 Number three, convert inefficient universal service 
programs into means-tested welfare programs administered by 
other agencies or State governments.
 Number four, sunset arbitrary, quote, ``public interest'' 
authority and FCC speech controls to protect the First 
Amendment rights of all speakers and listeners.
 Number five, preempt or simplify remaining State barriers 
to competition that undermine interstate competition 
investment.
 In closing, the key lesson of the Telecom Act experience is 
that it is essential for Congress to get the job done when 
looking to clean up past messes, and even more crucial to not 
create new problems in the process. No matter how well-
intentioned any of these rules may have been, the resulting 
regulatory regimes have had many unintended consequences and 
costs for innovators and the public.
 The danger of continued FCC meddling in existing and 
emerging information technology markets remains real, and 
Congress should address the unfinished business of the Telecom 
Act by cleaning up this mess for good.
 Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ AMr. Thierer's prepared statement has been retained in 
committee files and is available at https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/
IF16/20260326/119115/HHRG-119-IF16-Wstate-ThiererA-20260326.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 Mr. Wood, you are recognized for 5 minutes for an opening 
statement.

 STATEMENT OF MATTHEW F. WOOD

 Mr. Wood. Chairman Hudson, Ranking Member Matsui, thank you 
for inviting me to testify at this landmark hearing.
 Such discussions about three decades of change often look 
back to now quaint-sounding tech trends and touchstones. Yet 
there are timeless principles in the 1996 Act, places your 
predecessors and their staffers, like many of my fellow 
witnesses, got it exactly right--not always in the terms they 
wrote but in the values they espoused.
 Sadly, the Trump administration is trashing many of those 
values. I would like to explain how and then look forward to 
four ways this subcommittee and the agencies you authorize can 
meet the Act's goals. Those include establishing solid ground 
for Federal oversight of our Nation's networks; investing in 
affordable broadband for everyone; promoting diverse media, not 
cheerleading mergers or censorship; and staying out of online 
content regulation and AI preemption where agencies under your 
watch have no role.
 First, the FCC abdicated authority Congress gave it over 
the essential service we now call broadband, but we can 
disagree on which protections should apply to that service, 
including net neutrality rules often debated in this room. We 
must move beyond the word games about what qualifies as a 
telecom service.
 Free Press believes broadband clearly fits that definition, 
and the Sixth Circuit decision that held otherwise last year is 
plainly wrong. But we must fill this vacuum if we want 
deployment, to quote the Act, ``of advanced telecommunications 
capability to all Americans.''
 Funding universal broadband and protecting users from 
overlong outages and other abuses requires sound jurisdiction. 
Industries' assault has erased advanced telecommunications from 
the law Congress wrote. Not every Title II provision should 
port over, but the heart of that law, updated in 1996, is 
ensuring service on just, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory 
terms. That is a timeless promise: no expiration date, no 
tether to past technologies.
 We need a firm, flexible framework for public investment 
and safeguards. Corporate forces alone won't provide 
affordable, robust access to every corner of your districts.
 Lawmakers must do more too. The Lifeline program remains 
crucial, but $9.25 a month isn't adequate. Yet Chairman Carr 
wants to cut enrollment to score partisan points. And this NTIA 
has delayed BEAD money, which I think is a funny remedy for 
complaints about past delay.
 Instead of renewing the Affordable Connectivity Program, as 
Commissioner O'Rielly advised, Congress let it lapse. Will we 
really spend $1 billion a day for reckless wars but not $30 a 
month to keep a kid connected to her homework?
 The FCC should not set broadband prices, but it should know 
what they are. Carr has ignored statutory mandates and said he 
would stop even looking at price. He claimed in your last 
Oversight hearing that the prices he won't measure are falling, 
but as my written testimony explains, Carr is misleading you, 
and the story is more complicated.
 This FCC Chairman ignores facts, laws, and even the 
Constitution when he pleases, so long as it pleases this 
President. He attacks free speech and freedom of the press. He 
threatens broadcasters for coverage he doesn't like. Carr 
twists the public interest standard, then blames Democrats and 
says, ``They did it first.''
 No one can criticize past administrations but stay silent 
on Carr's abuses if they truly want to defend the First 
Amendment. Carr says this is all to empower local broadcasters, 
but he is just favoring the conglomerates he likes. Giants like 
Nexstar are local the same way CVS is a local pharmacy. Nexstar 
eagerly joined in Carr's Jimmy Kimmel debacle to win those 
favors, and Senator Cruz even called that dangerous.
 The prospect of local TV news monopolies complying with 
government demands is dire. It is frightening for any democracy 
that values debate and dissent. Yet just last week Carr 
unilaterally blessed Nexstar's merger, flouting the national 
cap we have heard about today that Congress set in 2004.
 It should alarm members on both sides when any FCC ignores 
statutes. Commissioner O'Rielly once called this specific trick 
a preposterous attempt at, quote, ``one of the biggest 
backdoors in the history of legislating.''
 Carr wrongly holds up some deals, though, until companies 
end their diversity and inclusion efforts, with no proof of 
wrongdoing or relevance to merger review. He imagined invidious 
harms to people who look like him. Yet looking at this panel, I 
would say White men still have a shot in this field.
 My written testimony addresses bad ideas like the FCC 
preempting State AI laws or using Section 230 to police 
platforms outside FCC jurisdiction. The latter reminds me of 
what I believe Mr. Thierer and O'Rielly called some 
conservatives' evolving views on regulating the internet.
 Free Press actions support Section 230, as I testified here 
in 2021, and I know that not all of you do, yet I hope we can 
agree these provisions are not the FCC's to enforce.
 So agencies and Congress must do more to honor the Act's 
goals but no more of the damage this administration has done in 
just over a year.
 Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ AMr. Wood's prepared statement has been retained in committee 
files and is available at https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF16/
20260326/119115/HHRG-119-IF16-Wstate-WoodsM-20260326.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you. We will now begin questioning, and I 
recognize myself for 5 minutes.
 Mr. Pickering, your opinion--I want to dive a little 
deeper. You talked kind of top level about some successes and 
failures of the Telecommunications Act. What do you see as kind 
of the top success, top failure? Do you think the Act works as 
Congress envisioned it at the time you wrote the Act?
 Mr. Pickering. As we look at the three buckets--successes, 
surprises, still to do--the great success is that we as a 
Nation really over two decades, starting with the divestiture 
in 1981 to 1984 of AT&T and the long-distance market, we 
rejected the natural monopoly theory and the heavyhanded 
regulation required to regulate rates and prices and investment 
and infrastructure and construction and all that is involved in 
monopoly-based regulation.
 The long-distance competition that emerged in the 1980s 
that ended up changing the networks from copper and analogue to 
fiber and digital, that became the internet backbone, then said 
to Congress and every policymaker, competition works. It is 
better than monopoly. Prices get lowered, consumers benefit, 
investment rises, innovation rises.
 And as you look at 1996, don't look at it just in the one 
act. Look at the 1992 Cable Act, which introduced satellite 
competition to cable. And satellite was digital, it could do a 
thousand channels, and cable was still analogue and they could 
do 30 channels. And that competition made cable upgrade their 
networks to digital so that you could begin to have the 
internet capacity in the last mile.
 Then the competitive wireless auctions in 1993 rejected 
duopoly wireless policy for full competition, seven licenses 
per market, and it went from analogue to digital, which gave 
the networks the capacity to have the iPhones that we enjoy 
today.
 And then the 1996 Act was really the culmination of 
competition policy for two decades, and it was a bipartisan 
commitment of all of the Energy and Commerce Committee on all 
of those actions that brought us to what I think the 1996 Act 
got right: Remove all barriers to competition--I mean, all 
barriers to entry so that all networks, whether it is cable, 
telco, wireless, satellite, fixed wireless, whatever imaginable 
advanced network emerges into technology, that they can compete 
against each other and that you interconnect, you interoperate, 
and all the devices interconnect and operate over that network 
of competition.
 We got that right, and because of it the market forces and 
the technology forces, even though there was regulatory 
friction with the FCC, you could say that maybe we were not as 
clear in our definitions and that we delegated too much to the 
FCC.
 The unleashing of competitive market forces have given us 
the world in which we now live and the success of the digital 
economy and infrastructure and now the emergence of AI. It all 
rests on removing those barriers.
 And we got permitting and deployment right too, that 
everyone could enter with access to rights-of-ways and poles 
and conduits and to build the new infrastructure of the digital 
age and economy. We got that right.
 So those were the successes.
 Mr. Hudson. That makes a lot of sense. If the Government 
had mandated building this infrastructure we have got out 
there, I shuddr to think how far back we would be, in the Stone 
Age.
 Mr. Pickering. And one last thing. This committee--I think 
when the Telecom Act passed the House, it was with about 90 
percent of the House voting in support of it. Same in the 
Senate, 95 to 5. Now, it took, you know, those two decades to 
reach agreement and consensus, and it took really two 
Congresses to get to the 1996 Act. There was a close Act, 1993, 
1994, but in the end, it was relationships, it was 
bipartisanship. And that bipartisanship of this committee has 
made 30 years of sustainable, predictable policy and the 
framework enduring and sustainable.
 So that is the other big success of that Act.
 Mr. Hudson. That is a good point.
 Well, I am running out of time, so I am going to submit a 
bunch of questions to the rest of you.
 I just want to say to the panel, your testimony, your 
written testimony, the testimony you are giving today, is 
really valuable, and I really appreciate the thought you put 
into it, because you were there and you've seen it, and so I 
think your perspectives are really important for this committee 
as we look forward. So thank you to all the witnesses.
 And in the interest of being able to keep everybody else on 
time, I will stop and recognize my ranking member, the 
gentlelady from California, Ms. Matsui, for her 5 minutes of 
questions.
 Ms. Matsui. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 And let me just say this--I am going to go right into it--I 
have been very clear that the Trump administration can't use 
communications law as a backdoor to wipe out State AI 
protections. That is why I coauthored guardians--the GUARDRAILS 
Act with Congressman Beyer, to repeal the Trump AI Executive 
order. The EO is a dangerous attempt to bully States out of 
enforcing their AI laws, threaten broadband funding, and direct 
the FCC and NTIA to act beyond their authority.
 Mr. Wood, does the Telecom Act of 1996, or any law, allow 
the FCC to preempt State AI laws? And that could be a yes or 
no.
 Mr. Wood. No. They would have to be preempting laws that 
inhibit the deployment of telecom services, and that is not 
what we see here.
 Ms. Matsui. OK. The Trump administration seems to claim 
that because some State AI rules might affect 
telecommunications providers, the FCC can step in. Why is that 
wrong?
 Mr. Wood. Well, I mean, sure, I can imagine some laws 
impacting them, but that is not what States are doing. States 
are passing consumer protection laws, civil rights laws to 
prevent discrimination, concerns about data centers being built 
in their backyards. And so those kinds of laws clearly have 
nothing to do with most telecom providers, and that would be 
far too broad of a tool.
 Ms. Matsui. Right. Right.
 OK. So I want to make one point clear. The 
Telecommunications Act was not written to erase the role of 
States. Congress recognized that States are often closest to 
the communities affected by these policies and that they have 
an important role to play alongside the Federal Government.
 Mr. Wood, what are some of the clearest examples in the Act 
where Congress expects the States to remain partners in shaping 
communications policy?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah, that is a great question. There are lots of 
examples of cooperative federalism, I think it was called, if I 
can say it, and there were places where, as Congressman 
Pickering talks about, States and the Federal Government worked 
together to open these long-distance and local markets. There 
are other places where jurisdiction is more divided and where 
wireless was given to the States to some degree but not 
completely. So it really was a partnership and not some sort of 
preemption or wipeout.
 Ms. Matsui. OK. So if Congress were to revisit the Telecom 
Act, what lessons from that Federal-State partnership should we 
be preserving rather than abandoning?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah. I mean, I think it has been a bipartisan 
ideal that the States can be laboratories of ideas. That 
doesn't mean every idea is good, but we should let States do 
what they need to do to assess situations and protect their 
residents against any kind of harm in order to unleash those 
benefits we have heard about today.
 Ms. Matsui. Right, right, right. OK. Thank you.
 Mr. Thierer, you have criticized Chairman Carr for 
threatening broadcasters reporting on the Iran war in ways that 
President Trump doesn't like. You wrote that Carr's use of the 
broadcast hoax and the news distortion standards is 
``particularly misleading, as the FCC's own rules define those 
terms far more narrowly than his rhetoric suggests.''
 Do you stand by this statement?
 Mr. Thierer. Yeah, absolutely. The FCC should have no 
business regulating news distortion, and all better reason to 
reform the public interest standard, if not eliminate it.
 Ms. Matsui. Sure. Good. You also wrote that ``Carr offered 
no criteria, no specific broadcast, no standard by which a 
regulator could distinguish impermissible reporting from 
legitimate journalism.''
 Do you stand by that statement?
 Mr. Thierer. Absolutely. We have seen the same sort of 
abuse of regulation we have seen for about 60 years on this 
front.
 Ms. Matsui. OK. So you went on to warn that the public 
interest standard is being reduced to a loyalty test 
administered by the FCC on the White House's behalf.
 So let me go on here. Mr. Wood, your testimony says that 
Chairman Carr is thumbing his nose at both Congress and the 
Constitution, including when he ignored both the evidence and 
the law to approve the Nexstar-Tegna merger.
 How did the Trump FCC break the law here, and how are they 
misrepresenting this merger's impact on local news and 
consumers?
 Mr. Wood. So we think that the point of these deals is to 
eliminate local news. Sometimes they will claim they are 
increasing it, but what they are often doing is just having 
nationalized content being pushed down to local stations and 
repeating stories that you can see on other stations.
 We think the Bureau order last week that Mr. Pallone talked 
about basically ignored all of that evidence, and so there are 
lots of procedural defects. But as Commissioner O'Rielly could 
attest, the biggest flaw, in our view, for this subcommittee is 
Congress wrote that 39 percent cap on national reach, and this 
FCC has purported to waive a statute, which is not within its 
power.
 Ms. Matsui. OK. Well, I don't have much time here either, 
so I will follow the chairman's edict here, and I will yield 
back.
 Mr. Hudson. Well, thank you so much.
 I now recognize the chairman of the full committee for 5 
minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Guthrie. Thank you.
 And I want to point out the AI framework that came from the 
White House does have the four C's. One is community, and it 
makes sure that each local community has the right--and their 
rights are protected in any kind of national framework. So that 
is good.
 But also, in States, our laboratories for democracy, they 
have good ideas and bad ideas. Sometimes the bad ideas affect 
people that live in other States too, particularly States that 
are so big that they can really force regulation. So it is 
interstate commerce, and so there is a role for the Federal 
Government in that as well in a preemptive way.
 So, Commissioner O'Rielly, as we look to ways to update our 
communications laws, one thing sticks out to me. The United 
States is one of the few countries--developed countries that 
has two communication agencies. Does this still make sense? 
Should we look at combining the FCC and NTIA?
 Mr. O'Rielly. So I think my view is changing based on the 
experiences of what is happening in this administration. If you 
are going to have less of an independent FCC, then the 
combination makes a lot more sense. Having duplicative reviews 
of mergers, in my mind, doesn't make sense no matter how many 
agencies you have.
 So I have advocated that we combine the merger review of 
DOJ and FCC. But the less independent the FCC is, then the less 
need. I think there is value in having an independent agency 
that I worked with many years and worked at for many years, but 
that is for you and others to decide.
 Mr. Guthrie. Thank you.
 So, Mr. Pickering, you discussed that the Telecom Act 
endures because it is anchored in principles that transcend any 
particular technology. I have long advocated for a technology-
neutral approach to regulations, but the Telecom Act still 
regulates the industry based on different technologies.
 How should Congress change the law so it becomes technology 
neutral?
 And, Mr. O'Rielly, while he is answering, if you will think 
of your response to that, that would be great.
 So how can we do it technology neutral?
 Mr. Pickering. So, today we are in an intense build period. 
We are building the AI infrastructure, but we are also building 
historic levels of private investment and broadband 
connectivity, and the BEAD historic levels of Federal funding. 
And what we are learning--and this is a good demonstration of 
technology neutral.
 In the BEAD Act, the Trump administration changed to a 
technology-neutral approach, and it recognized that fiber, in 
many ways, as our States looked at it, is foundational. You 
have backhaul to wireless. You extended fiber for fixed 
wireless. Satellite still has to connect to fiber. But we want 
it to be technology neutral.
 And Incompas members are all of the above. We have fiber 
companies, wireless companies, fixed wireless, and satellite. 
So we support that approach, but they are all building in a 
convergence of how the consumer broadband market is going to 
work.
 Mr. Guthrie. Well, how does the current law disadvantage 
certain technologies versus the other?
 Mr. Pickering. Well, I would say that today it doesn't 
disadvantage, that we need the expertise of the FCC and NTIA on 
spectrum policy. We need it in the cable broadband, telco, 
fiber, competitive fiber, and the wireless. New technologies in 
LEO----
 Mr. Guthrie. So the cable companies will say that they are 
regulating in a certain way, and they are competing with 
broadband. So if you have YouTube TV or Google or whatever, 
then they are competing. So the question is, do you bring those 
into the regulatory framework or do you relieve some of the 
regulatory framework for the other technologies?
 Mr. O'Rielly. You absolutely do the latter. Don't try and 
scoop in streamers into Title VI. I appreciate the work that 
you have done in this space and have recognized how video needs 
to be deregulated.
 Mr. Guthrie. So how would you do the technol--how would you 
address technology then different? I agree with you. I agree 
with what you are saying.
 Mr. O'Rielly. Most of the services that are regulated under 
the Communications Act can be deregulated substantially. 
Provisions can be stricken by this committee, and those--you 
know, if you give a forbearance authority that is targeted and 
has not been abused, then I think that can be helpful along the 
cases specifically in Title VI in the video service section.
 The BEAD Act, as Congressman points out, does have 
something that Congress put in, which is you must be technology 
neutral, and the previous administration tried not to do that. 
This administration has corrected that substantially and has 
actually been----
 Mr. Guthrie. Tried not to do that. Do you know how many 
inches of fiber were put out after the BEAD Act passed in the 
last administration? We can measure it in inches. Zero.
 Mr. O'Rielly. Zero.
 Mr. Guthrie. Zero because of all of the requirements on it.
 Yes, Mr. Thierer, do you have an answer?
 Mr. Thierer. Very briefly, Mr. Chairman. The easiest way to 
address this, if the FCC is going to continue to exist, is to 
collapse all the titles and silos into one simple title that 
basically treats everything as an information service. We 
should not have analogue-age distinctions be the basis of 
digital-age information technologies. We need parity, we need 
simplicity, and that is how we do it.
 Mr. Guthrie. Thank you. Well, that is perfect.
 My time has expired, and I will yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 The Chair now recognizes the ranking member of the full 
committee, Mr. Pallone, for 5 minutes.
 Mr. Pallone. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Local broadcasters are some of the most powerful voices 
shaping public opinion, and because of that, Congress imposed a 
national ownership cap for broadcasters to ensure the needs of 
local communities are met. Importantly, there is nothing in the 
statute to suggest that the FCC can adjust this cap.
 So this is what makes the FCC Media Bureau's recent 
approval of the Nexstar-Tegna deal so concerning to me. The 
agency just decided to waive the cap in violation of the law, 
and once again President Trump's buddies win while consumers 
lose.
 So I have got a bunch of questions, so I am going to ask 
all of you not to take too long to answer them, but let me go 
to Commissioner O'Rielly. You recently filed an amicus brief 
where you laid out why only Congress has the authority to 
change the national cap, not the FCC.
 Am I correct?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Yes.
 Mr. Pallone. All right. And we agree on that.
 Now, Mr. Wood, my Republican colleagues have suggested that 
the ownership caps are preventing broadcasters from competing 
with Big Tech. Is that a valid argument to allow for further 
broadcast consolidation?
 Mr. Wood. No, I don't think it is valid. We looked into 
antitrust metrics that suggest they are not, and broadcast 
executives themselves go to Wall Street and they say we have a 
competitive moat around our service because it is a different 
product. So, yes, they are competing for advertising dollars in 
some large sense, but they are not actually competing over the 
same services or the products they are delivering to people.
 Mr. Pallone. And how are consumers harmed by the Media 
Bureau's decision to ignore the cap and allow Nexstar to 
purchase Tegna?
 Mr. Wood. I mean, we think in several ways. For one thing, 
we will see reduced diversity in local news and reduced 
competition. We will see more journalists laid off because that 
is really what these deals are designed to do, to create what 
companies call synergies but that means job cuts.
 Another synergy they have promised their investors is they 
will make more money off of retransmission consent, which as 
members of the subcommittee will know, is when broadcasters are 
getting payment from cable companies for their signals. So 
retrans is a good thing for broadcasters, but having artificial 
power to inflate it and pass that cost off to customers is 
exactly what this deal is designed to do.
 Mr. Pallone. All right. Thank you.
 Let me go to the BEAD Program. I have always been 
supportive of NTIA's efforts under the BEAD Program to 
prioritize the most robust and future-proof technologies for 
deploying the next generation of broadband networks. And 
Americans lacking high-speed internet are eager to see these 
types of networks built in their communities because they are 
essential to participating in today's economy.
 And that is why it was so disappointing that the Trump 
administration has, I think, sabotaged the BEAD Program by 
prioritizing the cheapest technologies for short-term savings 
rather than investing for long-term productivity and economic 
growth.
 Mr. Pickering, you touched on this. You stated in your 
testimony that, and I quote, ``Universal service is not just a 
policy, it is a promise that every American, regardless of 
where they live, can access our networks.''
 So why is fiber foundational to achieving the 1996 Act or 
aim of universal connectivity? I know you briefly talked about 
fiber versus satellite, but I am trying to find out why fiber 
is still foundational.
 Mr. Pickering. The way that network architecture works, 
whether it is a fixed wireless, it comes back to fiber as 
quickly as possible. 5G networks backhaul to fiber and get to 
fiber as quickly as possible. LEO, the satellite networks, need 
to have a terrestrial fiber network to function and work.
 So fiber is still the founda-if you look at it like you are 
building a house, it is still the foundation of every network, 
and you want to get back into fiber because it is the highest-
capacity, most secure, fastest, and scalable network base.
 But all of these other technologies--wireless, fixed, LEO--
are also critically important into the builds, and each kind of 
represent a way to get to market as quickly as possible, at a 
cost-effectiveness, and in rural and remote and hard-to-serve 
areas. So an all-of-the-above approach we think is the right 
approach.
 But recognizing that fiber, the more that we can extend and 
densify fiber, in an age of AI and connectivity to data centers 
and then the applications and the uses of AI, we need all 
networks working, and we need a fiber foundation to make all of 
the others on top of it as fast and as reliable and as robust 
and as resilient as possible.
 Mr. Pallone. Well, thank you.
 And, Mr. Wood, there are only 30 seconds here. But in 
addition to fiber networks, what else do consumers need to have 
access to so they can truly benefit from technological 
advances? You have got 20 seconds.
 Mr. Wood. Well, they need robust networks, but they also 
must be able to afford them and know how to use them. And so 
that's why the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law was so important, 
to hit all three of those points.
 And I understand the calls for tech neutrality, but really 
the genius of that law was letting States make that choice for 
themselves, and I think that is where we have seen the current 
administration kind of interfere too much also.
 Mr. Pallone. Thank you.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the vice chair of the 
subcommittee, the gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Allen, for 5 
minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Allen. Thank you, Chairman Hudson, for holding this 
important hearing, and I thank the witnesses for your expertise 
and testimony here today.
 As we mark nearly 30 years since the passage of the 
Telecommunication Act of 1996, it is clear that the 
communication landscape has changed in ways few could have 
envisioned. At this particular time, with advancing technology, 
challenges still exist. It is a moving target, I mean, and it 
is fast. It is important that we evaluate what has worked, what 
hasn't, and how we can improve it.
 Commissioner O'Rielly, I represent a pretty rural district, 
and many providers in rural America have come to rely on the 
Universal Service Fund. Has the Universal Service Fund worked 
as intended when Congress wrote the Telecommunications Act of 
1996?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Well, I have given speeches to this effect. I 
think that the implementation of that language was far beyond 
what anything Congress envisioned. But accept that and set that 
aside for a second.
 I think that it has generally worked. There are problems 
because USF needs to be modernized on the distribution side. 
You have got a high-cost program with 12 or 13 programs that 
are fighting themselves. They are also fighting the E-Rate 
program. You have E-Rate and high cost subsidizing two 
different providers in the same community where no provider 
could actually survive by themselves. So it is a problem.
 You have a Lifeline program that has got problems, 
fundamental problems, and you can say, well, we support 
connectivity or affordability, but this program isn't working 
as intended and needs substantial rewrite.
 So I would say universal service distribution needs an 
entire overhaul. Though the concepts I have endorsed and 
supported and advocated, it only takes you one trip to go to 
Alaska and realize how beneficial USF is.
 Mr. Allen. Right, right. Well, I have conflicts between one 
county that the telephone operator can use universal services 
and in the next county they can't. And so one has internet, 
full internet coverage, and the adjacent county does not. So 
thank you for that.
 Mr. Pickering, what do you think? How can you add to that 
conversation?
 Mr. Pickering. You know, USF, as we see the build-out right 
now, both historic levels, as I mentioned, by the private 
sector, historic levels with BEAD funding from the public 
sector, and the--BEAD is just now hitting the shovel to the 
ground. And so, as we go through the next year, 2 years, we 
need to assess what the right size of the USF should be post-
BEAD and then look at the right reforms, as Commissioner 
O'Rielly mentioned: How do we right size it, keep what is 
critical and core? How do we reduce the size of the USF?
 And one thing that we need to make sure that we don't do: 
We don't need to tax the innovation economy, and we don't need 
to put fees on the innovation economy that could then be 
replicated by our international competitors that would 
disadvantage us. So those are measure, right size, reform.
 Mr. Allen. And Federal procurement policies are wrecking 
the whole thing. I mean, best implemented by the local folks 
who own the local transmission lines and poles and things like 
that. So it just seems like it is one conflict after the other.
 Commissioner O'Rielly, the Telecommunications Act did very 
little to regulate wireless networks, and yet wireless is 
probably the most common way we stay connected with others 
today. How did this happen, and what lessons do we take from 
this?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Well, it happened because Congress addressed 
it a couple years--3 years earlier over in 1993 and addressed 
kind of a lot of the structural issues and set up the auction 
process, and so it was done differently. And, similar to how 
this committee has acted on spectrum last year, setting the 
framework for spectrum for a number of years and as you debate 
whether to do something on some of the other pieces. So it is 
kind of a separate universe.
 The lesson is that, you know, there are pieces in OBRA-93 
that you--one that you obviously know very well because this 
committee--auctions are the only way to--only the best way and 
the only way to award licenses, and allocation must happen. We 
must have more spectrum, and we have to clear from inefficient 
users.
 And then you have the issue of, how do you deal with 
States? Mr. Wood referenced States have some involvement in the 
wireless, and they actually have very little role in wireless 
service, and it has actually worked very, very well.
 Mr. Allen. Yeah. And, Mr. Thierer, I wanted to get your 
input on it. I have 12 seconds.
 Mr. Thierer. In 2007, when Steve Jobs announced the iPhone, 
he didn't stand up and say, ``Is this in the public interest, 
and do I need to get a permit from the FCC to do it?'' He 
launched it, and the rest is history.
 Mr. Allen. Good. Thank you. I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Florida, Mr. 
Soto, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Soto. Thank you, Chairman. Orlando is now the 20th 
largest metro area. We relish the opportunity to have local 
stories, local voices about central Floridians, and there is a 
reason why we have laws preventing any one company from owning 
it all, protecting these local stories, ensuring competition, 
multiple viewpoints.
 Yet we saw the FCC just approve the Nexstar Media Group 
acquisition of Tegna on March 19th, a deal valued at $6.2 
billion, where one company would own 265 local broadcast 
stations in 44 States and DC. That goes well beyond the 39 
percent national cap to now a company that would reach 80 
percent of the market. There isn't any language that I know of 
in the FCC laws that allow for waiver of this cap, which is why 
eight attorney generals have filed suit on this issue.
 And President Trump, to his credit, has flip-flopped more 
than a Mar-a-Lago beachgoer on this issue. ``No expansion of 
the fake news networks,'' he said as recently as November 2025. 
Three months later, quote, ``We need more competition against 
the enemy, the fake news national TV networks.'' I am sure 
future Congresses are going to be fascinated to learn about his 
change of opinion.
 In the meantime, Mr. Wood, is FCC Chair Carr's magical 
mystery waiver lawful?
 Mr. Wood. No. I like the Beatles reference too. But, no, it 
is not lawful. Congress wrote that law, and whatever people 
think about broadcasters need to get bigger, we think they tell 
a different story to their investors than they tell you, but 
Congress has to be the one to change that law. The FCC can't 
simply ignore it.
 Mr. Soto. Now, you mentioned nationalizing content, reduce 
journalists, reduce diversity. Walk me through for my 
constituents, you know, they are getting their local stations 
now talking about these local stories.
 What changes when these things happen to a medium-sized 
market like Orlando for our local news?
 Mr. Wood. Right. And it is not in every market, but several 
markets, at least 35 around the country where these two 
conglomerates have overlapping stations, what they do is they 
put those news rooms together, and they often just wind up 
having the same story on two channels. So, when they talk about 
the benefits of increased coverage, really what they mean is 
now you get the same thing on two, or sometimes three or even 
four channels, and we simply don't think that is a good way to 
use that spectrum.
 Mr. Soto. You know, I love Jacksonville and Miami and 
Tampa. We have great Members on this committee, but would you 
see a consolidation where Orlandoans would see a lot of these 
other media markets in Orlando, rather than local stories, 
right?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah. I mean, that is what they talk about. They 
talk about synergies. They talk about cutting cost. They touted 
a local benefit as being now more stations will have access to 
Nexstar's Washington, DC, bureau. Washington, DC, is important, 
but it is not local in Orlando, and it is not local in every 
other place in the country.
 Mr. Soto. Sure. I did want to talk about the BEAD Program 
too. You know, we passed it in November of 2021, a $42 billion 
program, and in 2024 all the States had plans approved. We were 
ready to roll across the Nation. And then President Trump 
stopped it in its tracks in early 2025 to, quote, ``remove 
unnecessary rules and mandates to improve efficiency, to cut 
unnecessary red tape, and streamline deployment.''
 Streamline deployment. What a joke 15 months later. Florida 
still hasn't gotten our money for rural broadband. Mr. 
Pickering stated Mississippi hasn't gotten it either, among 
others.
 Mr. Wood, how does this delay affect rural families, farms 
and businesses?
 Mr. Wood. Well, I think every day delayed is a day not 
connected, quite obviously. I understand there is some 
frustration about the last administration, but as you said, 
they were getting to that finish line. And that was really part 
of the design of the law, was to let States take control and 
take the reins and not have the kind of top-down approach we 
have seen in previous FCC efforts.
 So, yes, there was some time taken to consider those plans, 
but really that was what Congress said, the States should have 
the power. And, as they were getting ready to exercise that 
power and start getting money out the door, everything was 
called to a halt, once again, at the start of the Trump 
administration.
 Mr. Soto. Mr. Pickering, how has it affected--the delay 
affected rural families and businesses in Mississippi?
 Mr. Pickering. You know, as we--in a place like 
Mississippi, where so many of our communities are not connected 
as they should, we want to get BEAD deployed as quickly as 
possible, broadband built to places in the Mississippi Delta, 
and all through the rural areas of the State.
 I do think that we are now poised to see the build part of 
BEAD, and I celebrate that all the States now just about have 
approved, and the funding is going out and that they are 
getting it right. And there is also a major next phase and the 
benefit of the bargain savings, so we really want to see the 
NTIA give the States the ability to promote permitting reform, 
permitting resources for local communities, and to enter into 
agreements at the Federal level with the permitting council, to 
the State level, and to the local level so that we can build as 
quickly as possible.
 Mr. Soto. Thanks. My time has expired.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you. The Chair now recognizes the 
gentleman from Mr. Ohio, Mr. Latta, for 5 minutes of questions.
 Mr. Latta. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to our 
witnesses for appearing here today. I really appreciate it. I 
have always enjoyed these discussions in the past and look 
forward to them in the future.
 If I could start with you, Commissioner O'Rielly, and also 
just to thank you very much for the couple of times you came to 
my district. It was always appreciated to have an FCC 
Commissioner really telling the people what the score was. 
Coming from Washington, they always appreciated that.
 But, if I could just start, you know, you only have six 
points, and I think lessons learned, I think it is interesting 
the way you put that, but under your fourth point is the one I 
think that caught my attention right off the bat. It says, 
``You cannot rely on the implementing agency.''
 And I think that is important because, again, when Congress 
writes a piece of legislation, we want to make sure that 
whoever is going to get that is going to implement it. But you 
said that in your testimony, ``While the agency manages some 
issues effectively, there have been numerous instances where 
the law's provisions were either intentionally or 
unintentionally misapplied.'' And some of those, you know, what 
those outcomes turned out to be then. And it goes on to say, 
``but the changes were never intended by the underlying law.''
 Could you talk about that, because, you know, you said that 
the abuses were also ``extremely difficult to accept.'' If you 
could just kind of delve into that a little bit, because that 
is one of the things we want to make sure is, when we write 
something, that it is going to get implemented.
 Mr. O'Rielly. The 1996 Act did, and I think Congressman 
Pickering would agree with this, there were a number of places 
where they couldn't exactly--Members couldn't exactly agree on 
something and trusted the agency to solve the issue: We are 
going to give you enough guardrails, and we are going to give 
you framework, or here is some language, and you are the 
technical agency, solve this, you know, rubric.
 And, you know, in some instances, they just did, and other 
instances, they didn't. And some of those matched up with my 
philosophical viewpoints. I liked what they did even though it 
violated what was happening.
 I will give you examples, you know. There is language--
prison payphones, there is very little on prison in the 
payphone section, and it had nothing to do--it was a totally 
different debate, and we spent, you know, over a dozen years 
fighting whether it could be used for prison payphones. 
Congress eventually passed a different statute that governed 
prison payphones, or, you know, incarcerated individuals, that 
is--but that was the authority issue, where Congress never 
asked them to do this, and the FCC tried to do it anyway and 
abused the provision.
 There are so many instances where we have gone on beyond 
the language. 706 is a great example. It never was intended--it 
was a study provision, and it turned into how to authorize net 
neutrality. I mean, it is beyond comprehension that it was 
abused like that.
 Mr. Latta. Well, is that Congress' fault that we are not 
doing that oversight to make sure that that doesn't occur?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Well, I did some oversight--I worked on 
oversight here, and it was very difficult to get answers from 
the agency. And it was very difficult, once it has been passed, 
it was very tough to get it back, to get the authority back and 
to get arms around the agency. You know, it requires you to 
have more hearings in the FCC. It requires them to be here 
defending their actions. Once every couple years is not going 
to do it from a perspective.
 I testified many times before the committee. You have to 
really be on top of it and be very aggressive once you pass 
something to know exactly--you know, some of it is also a 
factor, and I talked about this in my oral presentation, is 
that Members sold a bit of goods to people, said this is what 
they want the provision to do and then turned around and told 
the agency, ``This is what I really wanted to do.'' So I find 
it disheartening that a number of Members that my boss, you 
know, worked with and trusted, and then turn those language 
into things that was never intended.
 Mr. Latta. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman, Representative, 
thanks so much for being here. We appreciate it. Working with 
you through the years, you know, we all know this is the best 
committee in Congress. The great thing about this committee is 
that we look over the rising 5 to 10 years. And it is 
interesting because you also said something in your testimony 
about that light touch that we have to have on that regulatory 
side to make sure that we can always make sure that we are 
going to maintain our lead in the world.
 And, you know, when we look at the 1996 Act right now--and 
I am at about my last 45 seconds--you know, can we maintain 
this light-test regulation to make sure we maintain that lead 
across the world when we talk about telecommunications in the 
United States?
 Mr. Pickering. Yes, I do believe that we can take a light-
touch approach in the lessons from the 1996, and now it applies 
to both energy and telecommunications and broadband. That is 
the critical infrastructure of AI that meets at the data 
center. You are in a great position as chairman of the Energy 
Subcommittee, and with Chairman Hudson, how do you get the 
permitting reform packages through this session, because we are 
in a race against China, and the clock is ticking, and the 
advantages that they have could swing the race in their favor 
if we don't act in this Congress so that we can build both new 
energy networks and capacity as well as achieve the fiber 
connectivity that then distributes all of AI applications and 
uses to the country. So I look forward to working with you on a 
remove the barriers to build.
 Mr. Latta. Thank you very much. Mr. Chairman. My time has 
expired, and I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you. And I thank the witness for his 
answer. I often say a data center without broadband 
connectivity is a very large refrigerator. So you have got to 
have both. I agree with you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from California, Mr. 
Ruiz, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Ruiz. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 As we mark the 30th anniversary of the Telecommunications 
Act of 1996, we reflect on a law that sought to expand access, 
promote competition, and ensure that all Americans, regardless 
of geography,could benefit from modern communications. And, in 
communities like Coachella, San Jacinto, and Imperial Valleys 
in the southeast corner of California, where I represent and 
where I grew up, that promise has made a real difference. 
Because of the Act's commitment to universal service, rural 
communities in my district saw expanded access to basic 
communications infrastructure. Programs built on that framework 
helped connect homes that have long been left behind, and over 
time the policies established in 1996 laid the groundwork for 
broadband expansion, supporting telehealth in rural clinics, 
improving communication for agricultural businesses, and 
helping small businesses connect to broader markets.
 But, while these benefits are real, they can still be 
improved upon, because today I hear from families in the 
Coachella and Imperial Valleys who lack reliable and affordable 
internet access, students who struggle to compete and to 
complete their homework at home, communities where connectivity 
is inconsistent and competition is limited.
 Mr. Wood, how can we build on the success of universal 
service programs to finally close the digital divide in rural 
and underserved communities like those in my district?
 Mr. Wood. Well, I think two things. For one thing, 
affordability is important in rural areas too, so we need a 
sort of comprehensive approach to make sure that the networks 
are there and people can afford to use them. I think, as we 
have also talked about today, the BEAD Program and other 
programs that were enacted in the last 5 or 6 years are 
crucial. So we have to get those right and then be smart about 
what we still need to do after those are implemented. And, you 
know, there has been some squabbling over how they should be 
implemented, but we have to get them right. And I think that is 
why it is worth taking some time, but now getting money out the 
door and getting these networks built and improved.
 Mr. Ruiz. So the Trump administration's quote/unquote 
``benefit'' of the bargain reforms to the BEAD Program was 
supposedly meant to deploy broadband quickly. That, of course, 
has not happened, like many of his promises.
 Why is it important that these Federal broadband 
investments reach places like the Coachella and Imperial 
Valleys efficiently and with accountability for real outcomes?
 Mr. Wood. I mean, obviously both of those things are very 
important, and that is why you are rightly focused on them. 
Accountability and efficiency are crucial, and what we have 
seen in previous broadband investment programs at the FCC have 
been money flowing to places that don't need it. So we did a 
lot of work studying what was called the RDOF program, the 
Rural Digital Opportunities Fund, at the FCC, and we saw money 
being sent towards golf courses and highway medians and parking 
lots. So that is why, again, we don't want to go too slow, but 
we also don't want to go too fast and kind of miss things that 
are happening, and if not fraud, then certainly mistakes being 
made by sending money to places that don't need it.
 Mr. Ruiz. That is interesting because access must also mean 
affordability, as you mentioned, and reliability. The 
Telecommunications Act of 1996 helped bring connectivity to 
communities like mine. The House of Representatives--the House 
Republicans and the Trump administration have derailed 
Congress' efforts in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to 
ensure that working families can actually afford broadband and 
that the service they receive meets modern standards.
 What should Congress do to achieve these objectives?
 Mr. Wood. Well, that is a great question. I think it is 
hard to say, ``Please follow the law that we wrote,'' but I 
think there are ways that the current administration has 
deviated from that, as you noted, and so giving States that 
power to actually fulfill the promise of the bipartisan law is 
important. I think we are getting there, but it has certainly 
taken a while. And, as you said, you know, we have delayed it 
even more now for the past more than a year. So the fact that 
money is just barely starting to flow I guess we have to say is 
encouraging, but it has taken too far long to get to this 
point.
 Mr. Ruiz. Yeah. So, while we have come a long way and 
connected most schools and supported some rural infrastructure 
and created some opportunity, 30 years later we still have work 
to do to ensure that every family, no matter their ZIP Code, 
can fully participate in the digital world. It is unacceptable 
that classrooms in my district, teachers have to print out 
what--video scenes to describe what a video would be showing if 
they had sufficient broadband in their schools. That is just 
not acceptable in the United States of America, and so we need 
to make sure that no kid goes without all the equal 
opportunities that this great Nation offers. And I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you. The Chair now recognizes the 
gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Griffith, for 5 minutes for your 
questions.
 Mr. Griffith. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I 
appreciate that. I have heard some criticisms of the Trump 
administration that may very well be valid. That is something 
we will have to discuss. But I will just tell you we were very 
frustrated in Virginia when we had a program ready to go early 
on the BEAD proposal, and it was held up because the 
administration's agencies. And I don't know that the President 
himself was involved, but the agencies decided to take on 
authority that they didn't have and give new requirements to 
Virginia that weren't in the law and basically held us hostage 
until the new administration came in and released--or the new 
administration was coming in when the Biden administration 
finally recognized the law and let us go forward.
 All right. Got that off my chest. I appreciate you all's 
patience.
 Mr. O'Rielly, I am glad we have you here testifying today. 
You worked directly on the drafting of the Telecommunications 
Act of 1996. And I don't know what was going on behind the 
scenes, but I know that Mr. Bliley put in a phone call to get 
me on this committee. So I am very appreciative of that, and I 
know you worked with him.
 Now, that particular Telecommunications Act includes a 35 
percent ceiling on television viewers reached by one company, 
which Congress subsequently raised to 39 percent of viewers 
reached. How can this subcommittee revise the provisions to 
ensure video competition and encourage localism in news, 
amateur sports, and even minor league sports that the big 
companies, the conglomerations aren't going to cover?
 Mr. O'Rielly. So a couple parts. One is I--intellectually I 
don't have a problem with the cap, it being eliminated. I 
object to ignoring and violating statute and have talked about 
that, because I worked on the 2004 statute that raised it to 39 
percent. So I disagree with that.
 Intellectually I think the cap is being mushed in together 
with other provisions that I think are probably as important. 
And we talked about Orlando. It is the local market 
consolidation and test and standard is probably more concerning 
for the--you know, whether one person owns the top four 
stations, you know, that would probably be more concern and 
should be more concern to the committee than someone who is 
able to reach the entire breadth of the United States but has 
one in every market.
 And so, to your larger point, though, how do we deal with 
all of the complexities----
 Mr. Griffith. Right.
 Mr. O'Rielly. As those rights and all of the content is 
migrating to new platforms that are not regulated by the FCC. 
Right. You have got--they are moving to streaming, they are 
moving to a lot of different platforms that are outside the 
FCC. My argument is--and I made it to the full committee 
chairman--we have to deregulate the existing framework on video 
services. And then, on broadcast, we have to recognize that 
broadcasting is shrinking, and its legacy value is important--
and I love broadcasters, but it has--you know, we have to 
reflect the fact that nobody wants to invest in broadcasters 
generally. They are really in a very tough spot financially.
 And so I disagree with Mr. Wood in terms of whether there 
is justification for changing existing rules. I do think that 
they face competition for advertising, for everything else. So 
all of the rights that you spoke about at the end of your 
question are really important, and they are migrating away 
because we are still regulating some of the underlying services 
inappropriately. But that doesn't mean there aren't important 
concerns regarding a particular market and somebody owning 
three or four--especially four stations, the top four stations, 
those are the ones that we really care about. And it really 
matters if you own the first station. I don't have as much 
problem if someone owns three and four, or even two, three and 
four, but the number one is making the money, and one and two 
are probably where the concerns should be if we are going to 
have something.
 And I suggested in the paper, if you are going to do 
something, you probably want to limit the one and two merging 
versus the three and the four, or anything down below that is 
probably not network.
 Mr. Griffith. Let me see if I can get this next one out, 
and I am going to try to combine two questions into one. I know 
we are talking about the Telecommunications Act of 1996 today, 
but I think it is fruitful to compare the relative success of 
that Act to the perplexity of the 1992 Cable Act that imposed 
rate regulation on the cable industry. In your opinion, did the 
Cable Act's one-size-fits-all regulations lead to innovation 
and large capital investments in cable systems?
 Mr. O'Rielly. The 1992 Cable Act was a how to harm the 
cable industry because Members didn't like and appreciate what 
the cable industry was doing. The 1996 Act made many different 
reforms and deregulated a number of aspects from the 1992 Act. 
So it was incredibly important and gave you the capital to 
expand those networks.
 Mr. Griffith. And I am running out of time. One of the 
outcomes of a few commentators--that few commentators 
anticipated when the 1996 Act was passed was the cable 
companies would get into the broadband internet business.
 What lessons should the subcommittee learn from these two 
contrasting acts? And you have 2 seconds.
 Mr. O'Rielly. OK. Getting rid of the cap on rate regulation 
was incredibly important for having capital to invest and build 
those broadband networks for the cable operators.
 Mr. Griffith. I appreciate that greatly, and I will have 
more questions for the record. And I appreciate all of you all 
being here today on this important topic.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you. The Chair now recognizes the 
gentleman from California, Mr. Peters, for 5 minutes for your 
questions.
 Mr. Peters. Thank you, Chairman Hudson, for calling this 
important hearing.
 Over 60 years after Congress originally passed the 
Communications Act of 1934, which centralizedthe regulation of 
telephone, telegraph, and radio communication, President 
Clinton signed the Telecommunications Act of 1996 into law, the 
first major overhaul of our original communications 
legislation. That Act represented a major milestone in the 
evolution of modern communications policy because it focused on 
competition and private-sector innovation while aiming to 
ensure universal service for all Americans regardless of their 
income or location.
 Before coming to Congress, I served on the San Diego City 
Council. And because of the Telecommunications Act in 1996, 
local elected officials, like city council members, we were 
limited in our ability to restrict the placement of wireless 
service facilities, including cellphone towers. This limited 
zoning preemption was critical for the placement of wireless 
infrastructure, accelerating network expansion, and limiting 
excessive local barriers that might otherwise have been in 
place.
 Mr. O'Rielly, can you discuss how the FCC has used this 
authority to address State and local barriers to broadband 
infrastructure deployment?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Well, the wireless siting provisions you 
spoke of I think have been incredibly beneficial. They probably 
were expanded beyond what Congress envisioned, and that is one 
of the examples of what I would say that the agency read into 
the statute that probably wasn't there and was not the deal 
that was struck in this committee amongst Members that are no 
longer here.
 But, in terms of policy, I think it was the right policy. 
And one of the things they did do that the Commission has since 
undone is say that aesthetics could be part of the factor. We 
said that aesthetics couldn't be part of the factor and we 
should build them where they are needed so we could have 
infrastructure.
 Mr. Peters. Right.
 Mr. O'Rielly. The Commission has kind of undone that and 
said aesthetics can be a factor, and that has led to problems 
in siting. Siting--
 Mr. Peters. So what are the cell towers of today, like the 
equipment for which we should be reducing barriers right now.
 How should we address siting and permitting of new 
infrastructure in any revisions?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Sure. So many of the current rules already 
cover the new technology. You know, there are going to be, you 
know, some things in the AI space--you were speaking about 
that--that may need help. But we do need help in two areas: 
permitting and poles. Pole tested provisions have exemptions in 
them, and they shouldn't.
 Mr. Peters. OK. So I would just say I share Mr. Griffith's 
concern about the deployment of BEAD. I thought it was an 
embarrassment. We put aside $43 billion. And, as a proud 
Democrat, I was proud to vote for it, but I continue to be 
really angry that we didn't get more done. And I don't think we 
should do that again. And I think, as we deploy these things 
out, that executing these things on the ground is really 
important.
 And it is not just about writing a good idea down or 
putting money in the bank, it is about getting it in the 
ground. So I am going to be paying attention to that going 
forward.
 As we set out on our path to 6G deployment, there are still 
several major obstacles. Congress has to consider how to best 
support a smooth and competitive transition and how the 
Communications Act zoning preemption precedent may come into 
play. Ultimately, though, market forces alone do not--have not 
made internet affordable for all, which is why we rely on the 
Universal Service Fund and its associated programs.
 Mr. Wood, what changes would make USF affordability 
programs more effective in reaching underserved communities and 
ensuring that those communities will be able to benefit from 
the continued digitaltransition?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah. I mean, it is a simple answer: More 
affordable means more money and more public investment. Now, at 
Free Press, we are very concerned that that not be done in a 
way that consumers are bearing too much of that burden. But the 
$9.25 that Lifeline has been set at since I believe 2012 is 
pretty much adequate today for any kind of robust broadband 
service. And that is what we need to address, is making sure we 
spend money smartly but we are not doling it out in drips and 
drabs and people being forced to have a second-class service.
 Mr. Peters. Since you are here, can you elaborate a little 
bit more on what you mean by spending money smartly?
 Mr. Wood. Well, I mean, affordability is crucial to all of 
these deployment programs, right? If people can't afford to get 
on the network, then they can't make use of it, and so I think 
there is that.
 There has obviously been through the years a lot of 
complaints about how Lifeline is administered. We think that 
the misspending rate there has been wildly overstated. That has 
been the basis of some of Chairman Carr's recent Lifeline 
proposals.
 Obviously, we need program integrity, we need to make sure 
our funds are not wasted, but oftentimes what we see are 
attacks on that program based not on actual waste but based on 
other political concerns that people want to bring into that 
mix.
 Mr. Peters. So can you be more specific? So what are some 
of those attacks? What kind of things do you mean so that we 
can understand what you talking about?
 Mr. Wood. What kind of attacks am I talking about?
 Mr. Peters. Yeah.
 Mr. Wood. I mean, so the current proposal would say, 
``Well, there are a bunch of people getting money who are 
deceased and shouldn't be on the rolls anymore.'' Studies have 
been done to say that is about one one-thousandth of the 
spending. So obviously we don't want companies committing fraud 
to draw more money to themselves if they are enrolling people 
who have passed away. But I think there is actually some 
explanation for that, and it is a really tiny percentage. And 
so that is what we regret to see, are political attacks 
launched based on very tiny problems, or at least ones that we 
haven't fully studied.
 Mr. Peters. Well, I hope this committee will be doing a 
better job of perspective setting and reality checking. 
Obviously no one wants dead people on the rolls, and that kind 
of political attack really serves no purpose.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. The gentleman yields.
 I now call on Representatives Fedorchak for your line of 
questioning.
 Mrs. Fedorchak. I am usually last. So I am excited to have 
been moved up through the system today.
 One second here. All right.
 Well, thank you all for being here. I appreciate your 
lending your expertise. I appreciate all the work that many of 
you have done throughout your career. This is sort of the body 
of the work for many of you and have focused your entire 
professional lives on these issues, and that means a lot. And I 
appreciate you taking the time to share your experience so that 
we can ensure that the future changes that we make are smart 
and the best for our country.
 Mr. Pickering, a few questions for you. We spend a lot of 
time talking about the energy demands of data centers but not 
as much on the connectivity side. That is also a critical piece 
of it. As our chairman said, a data center that is not 
connected to the internet is a big, expensive refrigerator.
 Can you explain why fiber infrastructure is just as 
critical as power in enabling these projects?
 Mr. Pickering. So, as you look at the AI applications and 
the uses and the Agentic AI and the application--we don't talk 
enough about the AI applications and uses, and businesses and 
individuals and families and homes will not have access to the 
great transformational benefits of AI unless they have 
broadband connectivity in every part of the country. And so, 
getting broadband universally deployed and built is really a 
critical component of the principle of universal access to the 
next technology and the benefits of that next technology. So 
whatever we can do to speed the build, permitting reform, get 
the BEAD funding out and right resources of the nondeployment 
so that we can speed the permitting--all of those things are 
critically important in the next stage.
 Mrs. Fedorchak. To that point, what is the right balance 
between Federal action and State action to accomplish this 
goal?
 Mr. Pickering. So we recently encompassed filed comments to 
NTIA that tried to create the incentives and the resources to 
build relationships between the Permitting Council, the 
national Permitting Council, which has adopted really what I 
think is the best model I have seen in my public and private 
service. They have one project manager, and if you have 
multiple Federal agencies they do concurrent permitting versus 
sequential permitting. They make sure everybody is in the room, 
that everybody is coordinated and everybody has collaborated, 
and they have exponentially increased the speed of the Federal 
permitting process while maintaining the high standards. And 
they are asking every State to reach an MOU with the Federal 
permitting council so that, if there is any project that has 
both Federal and State permitting, that they work together.
 And we are asking NTIA to adopt that model, incentivize it, 
and then, when it goes to the city and the county, many of the 
localities don't have the resources to pay for the technology, 
the engineers, the compliance and the staff to permit as 
quickly as possible, and we are encouraging a use of some of 
the BEAD money to give resources to States and localities so 
that you have a true local, State, Federal, national purpose of 
building the infrastructure of the AI economy as quickly as 
possible to high standards and having the resources to do so.
 Mrs. Fedorchak. Excellent. If there is any role that my 
office or this committee can play in those MOUs, please let us 
know. It sounds like a great solution.
 Pivoting a little bit over to you, Mr. O'Rielly. There are 
a number of proposals right now to expand the USF contribution 
base to include broadband providers, or even edge companies. 
Tell me your thoughts on those pros and cons, and some of the 
concerns that might be out there.
 Mr. O'Rielly. First and foremost, I don't think you can 
address contributions until you deal with distribution and 
administration of the program. But, in terms of contribution 
reform, I have deep problems with the idea that we are going to 
tax broadband consumers. We have made it a point, and I think 
the previous chairman said, you know, broadband is essential, 
and that has been a debatable word that has been used against 
me, whether it is, you know, necessary. Broadband is important, 
and if we want people to have broadband, we should not tax it 
and increase its costs. So I have problems with the idea that 
we are going to bring more people by paying into the system 
without reforming the system, and then who we are taking that 
money from, whether it be the high-tech industry that 
Congressman Pickering talked about, that I would oppose as 
well, whether it be the broadband providers.
 So I think it would be incredibly problematic in taxing 
broadband. So I am really worried about where we are going to 
get--you know, what that reform looks like on the contribution 
side of the equation.
 I have favored appropriations as a mechanism. Others hate 
the idea and want to consider that for other reasons. AndI am 
loyal to the committee and respect the jurisdictional 
boundaries, but there has to be something that is done 
fundamentally on contributions, and part of that is dealing 
with the spending side of the equation. You don't need to raise 
as much if you don't spend as much.
 Mrs. Fedorchak. Sure. Thank you, sir. I appreciate that. I 
am over time, and I yield back.
 Mr. Allen [presiding]. The gentlelady yields, and now I 
will recognize Representative Dingell for her 5 minutes of 
questioning.
 Mrs. Dingell. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 And thank you, Mr. Pickering, for your comments. I am 
sitting here--I sat in the back of this room 30 years ago, and 
Doris did too, a lot of memories of those days. But, 30 years 
later, after the passage, the internet has fundamentally 
changed. What once connected people now often exposes them to 
harm, whether it is harassment, exploitation, misinformation, 
or increasingly AI-generated content that can be weaponized, 
and is being weaponized.
 Just this week, back-to-back jury verdicts on major social 
media companies liable for harming children, including for the 
way their platforms are designed and the harms those design 
choices caused. These rulings should be a wake-up call for all 
of us to take this issue seriously and to act. And, as 
companies now embed generative AI tools directly into these 
platforms, the need for accountability is only growing.
 I have been a champion of domestic survivors before I ever 
got to Congress or married John Dingell, and I have heard 
directly from women and families who have been targeted by 
nonconsensual intimate imagery, including the AI-generated 
deepfakes. And this is a form of sexual violence that follows 
victims into every aspect of their lives.
 I was proud to help lead the bipartisan TAKE IT DOWN Act, 
which will help combat the spread of nonconsensual intimate 
imagery, including AI-generated content, and ensure platforms 
remove this material quickly. However, it is just the 
beginning, because the reality is platforms have shown, time 
and time again, you can't police yourselves.
 Today we are confronting a new and rapidly evolving threat: 
generative AI tools embedded directly into the platforms. Tools 
like Grok or--on X can produce and amplify harmful content. 
They are doing that, including deepfakes and sexualized and 
nonconsensual images at scale with unprecedented speed and 
often without meaningful guardrails or any accountability.
 We should not accept the status quo where companies can 
deploy powerful AI tools, benefit from the engagements they 
drive, and avoid the responsibility they should take when those 
tools cause harm, particularly for women and our children.
 Courts have interpreted Section 230 to provide broad 
immunity to platforms for user-generated content, but that 
framework was built for a very different internet that didn't 
include AI systems generating content themselves or platform 
design choices that actively promote and amplify harm.
 We at Congress have a responsibility to ensure our laws 
reflect today's technologies. We must ensure that platforms are 
held accountable, not just for what they host but for what they 
build, design, and deploy.
 Mr. Wood--and I am going to ask you to be short because I 
have got three questions--when a platform like X deploys an AI 
tool like Grok that generates harmful content, should that 
still be treated as third-party speech under Section 230, or is 
the company responsible for its own product?
 Mr. Wood. The company is responsible. It should not be 
treated as third-party speech. There is a big difference 
between the social media platform and then Grok, or the other 
engine that is producing that content. In Section 230 it says 
that the person responsible is the person producing that 
information either in whole or in part. So the statute hasn't 
always been read that way and enforced that way, but that is 
actually something that the statute accounts for and the courts 
should take more heed to.
 Mrs. Dingell. Mr. Wood, do you think current law is failing 
victims of nonconsensual or sexualized AI-generated content?
 Mr. Wood. I certainly think people have been slow to 
respond. And so, yeah, your leadership on TAKE IT DOWN, other 
acts like that are certainly incredibly necessary and 
incredibly well-intentioned, but the law needs to catch up to 
the speed and scale of the abuses we are seeing.
 Mrs. Dingell. OK. So, knowing we need to do that--and you 
are absolutely right--what is the single most important reform 
Congress should make to ensure companies are accountable for 
the AI tools they build?
 Mr. Wood. I mean, I think it is hard to reduce it to a 
single most important one, but that conversation about Section 
230 is live today and in this hearing room. I think that that 
is important to get right and to make sure that companies are 
held accountable for the harm that they cause or they know that 
they are causing, and there are some legal tests along the way.
 We still favor Section 230. We think it is important for 
promoting free expression online, but it shouldn't be a sort of 
get-out-of-jail-free card for companies that are profiting to 
the tune of billions of dollars knowingly causing harm and 
perpetuating that over the course of, you now, years, sometimes 
even decades.
 Mrs. Dingell. Thank you, Mr. Wood.
 My time is almost up. But it is clear to me Section 230 has 
not kept pace with the technology shaping our online ecosystem. 
And I hope we will all work together in a bipartisan way--they 
did it 30 years ago--to fix this.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Hudson [presiding]. Hear, hear. Let's do it. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Idaho, Mr. 
Fulcher, for 5 minutes of your questions.
 Mr. Fulcher. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 The court case yesterday that came out in Los Angeles is 
kind of the thought process that triggers this first question, 
but I will start with Mr. Pickering. You were here at the staff 
level during the drafting of the 1996 Act, and this is in 
regard to Section 230, and I understand the rationale, I think, 
at that time because the internet was truly in its early 
stages, and we couldn't really tell--there was no way to know 
exactly what was going to happen with that.
 But given what has happened in the last 30 years and the 
landscape that you see it today, do you think it is time to 
revisit 230 Section and how that is structured?
 Mr. Pickering. I will give a little bit of context first 
and then speak to the question on 230 and kids and children's 
protection. You know, as a father and as a grandfather, I have 
two of my sons who are here who have grown up in this internet 
world and economy, and so getting this right about protecting 
children as we go to AI is critically important.
 When we did the 1996 Act, most people forget that it was 
the Children's Decency Act, which was intended to protect 
children from online pornography, that was paired with a House 
provision that is now 230, known as Internet Freedom, and the 
Children's Decency Act was struck down by the courts, and the 
Section 230 stood and stands today.
 I think the best way to--and this is where, from left/
right, 230 has been very important for the internet ecosystem 
and competition and free expression and all the innovation that 
has occurred over the last 30 years. But we need targeted, 
specific protections for children today. And I want to commend 
Chairman Hudson and Chairman Guthrie for their efforts in this 
committee to have kids online and children safety initiatives 
come out of this committee. I know the Senate is working on it.
 I think direct, targeted approaches to protecting 
children--not undermining the core objective of 230, but 
standalone, targeted, focused efforts on children's safety--is 
the best way to handle and address in a legally sustainable way 
the issues that are so important to protecting our children.
 The administration's AI framework makes children's safety a 
core component of the AI framework, and what I am hoping is 
that this committee and this Congress in a bipartisan way can 
find a way to unite around children's safety initiatives as we 
build out the AI framework and the infrastructure that comes 
with it.
 Mr. Fulcher. I have a couple more questions, so, please, if 
you could--still the question remains, do you think we should 
restructure 230?
 Mr. Pickering. No. I think that we should maintain 230, but 
then have----
 Mr. Fulcher. Mr. Pickering----
 Mr. Pickering [continuing]. As this committee did recently 
is markup----
 Mr. Fulcher. Mr. O'Rielly, your thoughts on that, please.
 Mr. Pickering. A number of Children's Protections Acts.
 Mr. O'Rielly. There are two parts. One is, does the FCC 
have any authority? I would argue no. The second is, should you 
change 230? And I would argue no.
 Twenty-six words have worked as intended by this committee. 
Most--that behavior that people, whether they like it or 
dislike it, that is governed by 230 is protected under the 
First Amendment.
 Mr. Fulcher. OK. Right. Thank you for that. I appreciate 
it. We have also heard in testimony that we should convert 
inefficient universal service programs into a means-tested 
welfare program administered by other agencies or State 
governments.
 Back to Mr. O'Rielly, what do you think about that? Should 
USP be a means-tested program?
 Mr. O'Rielly. So I advocated that we means test the high-
cost program and mechanisms to do so. I didn't get traction. I 
couldn't get buy-in from the industry, but I think it is 
important that we means test almost everything in the Federal 
Government. And I worked on a number of different statutes 
throughout the Government to means test them to make sure that 
we get the most efficient stretch of our dollar, and now we are 
not.
 Mr. Fulcher. Mr. Pickering, do you agree with that? You 
think it should be a means-tested program, the USP?
 Mr. Pickering. I think that we should measure and assess 
where we are post-BEAD, then right size the program and reform 
it on the distribution side and decide what kind of program we 
need for an E-Rate, for a Lifeline, and for any operational 
subsidy. We need to see what the market has done and BEAD has 
done before we do the reform.
 Mr. Fulcher. OK. Just about to wrap up, but very quickly, 
Mr. O'Rielly, how would a telecom carrier go about doing that?
 Mr. Hudson. I will let you go ahead and answer.
 Mr. Fulcher. Yep. Sorry.
 Mr. O'Rielly. Go about doing--which part? The means 
testing?
 Mr. Fulcher. The means test part.
 Mr. O'Rielly. I think there are a number of mechanisms the 
Commission could have done. When I was there, we tried to leave 
it on the provider side and say, ``You can actually, you know, 
have an annual survey of your customers: `Are you above a 
certain threshold?''' I was pushing for a $10 million 
threshold. If you make more than $10 million a year, you 
shouldn't be eligible for our----
 Mr. Fulcher. Thank you, Mr. O'Rielly.
 And, Mr. Chairman, I apologize. I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Great question. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Illinois, Ms. 
Kelly, for 5 minutes to ask your question.
 Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Chair Hudson and Ranking Member 
Matsui, for holding this morning's hearings, and thank you to 
our witnesses for participating.
 The Telecommunications Act of 1996 remains a foundation of 
our digital economy. The world it governs has evolved from 
dial-up connections to a landscape defined by broadband, 
artificial intelligence, and always-on connectivity. From the 
southside of Chicago, where I represent, to the rural 
communities of Kankakee and Danville, access to these tools is 
essential for work, education, healthcare, and, frankly, civic 
participation. We must protect and strengthen programs like 
Lifeline that ensure our most vulnerable communities can stay 
connected.
 At the same time, we are seeing growing concerns about the 
misuse of Federal authority, including efforts to expand the 
FCC's role into areas like online free speech and content 
moderation. That kind of overreach threatens the integrity of 
the agency and undermines public trust.
 Mr. Wood, I would like to start where I ended in my opening 
on the scope of the FCC's authority. In your testimony, you 
stated that the FCC and NTIA have no place enforcing or 
interpreting Section 230.
 Can you explain why the Telecommunications Act did not 
provide that authority to the FCC, and why it is important that 
Congress, rather than the FCC, take the lead on any reforms to 
Section 230?
 Mr. Wood. Yes. I think as the other witnesses have said, 
too, 230 was part of the 1996 Act, but it is not really the 
same kind of animal at all. And so there is no role for the FCC 
to interpret or enforce it.
 In the last administration of the Trump Presidency, the 
first Trump administration, they proposed doing that. And I 
think luckily that has quieted down a bit, but there is really 
nothing there to enforce.
 We don't want a government agency sitting in judgment of 
whether or not a content moderation choice was made in good 
faith. There are other accountability measures these platforms 
should be held to. But, you know, anybody, including this 
administration, deciding what content should be allowed online 
is a problem, and we have seen Chairman Carr wade into those 
waters far too many times.
 Ms. Kelly. Thank you.
 I want to shift gears to affordability and the Lifeline 
program. Mr. Wood, you noted that Lifeline remains crucial but 
that the current $9.25 benefit is inadequate in today's 
broadband marketplace. As of last year, there were nearly 
190,000 Lifeline subscribers in Illinois. Additionally, there 
were over 1.4 million households eligible for Lifeline but have 
not yet enrolled.
 To ensure everyone eligible for Lifeline is aware of the 
program, I introduced the Promoting Access to Broadband Act, 
which would make grants available to States to inform Medicaid 
enrollees, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, 
participants, and low-income residents of their potential 
eligibility for the Lifeline program.
 Mr. Wood, would providing funding for States to engage in 
additional community outreach for the Lifeline program be 
helpful in furthering the objectives of this program?
 Mr. Wood. In a word, yes. I mean, that is why we saw the 
success of the Affordable Connectivity Program, something that 
was advertised and companies had a larger stake in.
 I hate to be seen as critical at all of Lifeline, but it 
has basically become a Lifeline wireless program, and people 
can get access to data through wireless connections, of 
course--many of us do that all the time--it is just such a very 
low amount most of the time.
 And so ACP actually got to 23 million households by the 
time it ran out of money, unfortunately, and that is because we 
saw people with a more robust and more portable benefit that 
they could choose to use on wireless, but they could also apply 
that to wired connections and get faster speeds and have that 
be a meaningful discount as well.
 Ms. Kelly. And then, additionally, what changes to the 
Lifeline program do you envision to ensure the program is being 
utilized by the students and their families who need broadband 
connectivity to complete their homework, stay engaged in their 
schools, even to apply for jobs?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah. I mean, it is a hard question to summarize 
quickly, but I think we have heard it here today, there has to 
be some analysis of the contributions. But, as other witnesses 
have said, too--like. I do not favor either, and Free Press has 
not favored taxing broadband customers because oftentimes 
people say, ``Make Comcast pay for this,'' and we have to 
realize that those charges by phone companies, and if cable 
companies were included, those get passed onto customers.
 So we want to make sure that there is adequate funding to 
support affordability and adoption. We just don't want that to 
be borne by the people who are actually in need of those 
programs themselves.
 Ms. Kelly. Does anyone else have anything quickly to say 
about that question? Anything additionally?
 No?
 I yield back. Thank you so much.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Texas, Mr. 
Pfluger, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Pfluger. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank the witnesses 
for being here.
 Some of my colleagues, and many of you have pointed out 
today, technology has changed significantly over the past 30 
years. And, although the networks have advanced from copper 
lines and circuit-switched voice to broadband streaming and 
wireless, many of the regulations still remain outdated. I know 
we have been talking about this, and it underscores the gap 
between technological progress and regulatory adaptation.
 For example, the 1996 Act was most effective, I believe, 
when Congress limited government intervention, removed the 
outdated rules, and allowed private investment and innovation 
to flourish. And I commend Chairman Carr and the FCC for the 
new Delete, Delete, Delete Initiative, which reviews all FCC 
rules and guidance documents to identify and remove unnecessary 
burdens. And I think that Congress should follow the FCC's 
example and act promptly to systematically remove the obsolete 
and technology-specific mandates from our laws, and updating 
these statutes is essential to that.
 Mr. Thierer, I would like to ask you how Congress should 
update--or, how should Congress update the framework of the 
1996 Act to match the work that Chairman Carr is doing, such as 
deleting obsolete technology-specific rules and statute and 
moving us towards a more technology-neutral solution, and what 
examples can you give us specifically on that?
 Mr. Thierer. Yeah. Thank you, Congressman, for that 
question. I absolutely agree with it. And what we need to do is 
move towards date-certain timetables for how we might go about 
sunsetting certain things. The Delete, Delete, Delete 
proceeding is a really good example of how we could try to move 
in that direction.
 We should have been doing that a long time ago. Instead, 
Congress in the Telecom Act delegated broad forbearance 
authority and said, ``Well, we hope that the FCC will 
voluntarily just loosen the chains and do it.'' It hasn't 
worked out that way. Congress even required the agency to do 
reports on this. Never really much came out of that process.
 So I would encourage this committee to go back and actually 
provide some very clear timetables and a process like Michael 
O'Rielly identified here about very specific types of things 
that you expect them to do.
 Mr. Pfluger. So you are saying we are the problem?
 Mr. Thierer. When you are delegating vague authority, that 
is a serious problem. Yeah.
 Mr. Pfluger. I agree.
 Well, kind of moving in the same direction, I mean, what, 
Commissioner O'Rielly, what are the most important lessons from 
the successors and failures of the 1996 Act, and which ones of 
those should guide Congress as we update our laws to protect 
our national security or economic security, and continue to 
innovate? I mean, what can you point to in that Act that we 
should be looking at?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Well, I pointed--I outlined six in my 
testimony, but I will give you just the two I think--one is 
don't wait for a comprehensive reform. You can do, whether it 
be piecemeal or smaller, you know, bite off chunks and you can 
really be effective in reframing how the Commission looks at 
things.
 Two is don't--and this is not about this Commission--but 
you cannot rely on a Commission to do the work that you expect. 
It will deviate from whatever--you thought it was going to go 
here, everyone thought it was going to go here, and it went 
this way. And then provisions that are--years later they are 
still reinterpreting provisions far--you know, 30 years later, 
reinterpreting provisions under a new creative mindset.
 So what I tell people and tell policymakers is write in 
what you don't want the Commission to do: ``Do not do X, do not 
do Y, you don't have authority to do Z.'' Be very clear what 
you cannot do is really important.
 Mr. Pfluger. Take some lessons from the Chevron deference 
case as well.
 Lastly, I have introduced a bipartisan Keep It Moving Act 
to establish clear timelines for the FCC's merger review 
process, and this Act would require a full Commission vote to 
deny an application to ensure that critical decisions are made 
transparently and don't create unnecessary barriers.
 And so I will go to Congressman Pickering. In your view, 
how would legislation like Keep It Moving Act set the right 
framework and provide market certainty and predictability?
 Mr. Pickering. As I keep saying, we are in a build period. 
There is going to be a heightened time of mergers and 
acquisitions as the scope and scale to build the big 
infrastructure that is going on. So the faster that we can go 
through merger reviews, the more transparent is a welcomed 
legislative initiative on your part. And, whether it is denial 
and approval for a vote, or having a dissenting debate, the 
better we have an open, transparent process with a shot clock 
is the best way to go.
 Mr. Pfluger. Thank you. Chairman, I mean, this highlights, 
I think, the need for bipartisanship, and I hope we will be 
able to achieve that, you know, even in an environment that is 
politically tough. You brought together a hearing that really 
highlights our competition with China, our economic 
competition. The stakes are really high, and I hope that both 
sides can really come to the table on this.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. I appreciate that.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Louisiana, Mr. 
Carter, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Carter of Louisiana. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and 
Ranking Member.
 Thank you to all the witnesses. Your commentary has been 
quite insightful.
 The Telecommunications Act of 1996 is a landmark law that 
created many programs that our constituents benefit from today, 
including Universal Services Fund, which helps connect schools, 
libraries, healthcare providers, rural areas and low-income 
households to affordable and reliable broadband services.
 As Congress revisits this landmark 30 years later with the 
Supreme Court's decision to successfully uphold the Universal 
Service Fund just last year, it is critical that we look at 
making the upgrades to the law necessary in order to bring it 
up to speed with the latest technologies and ensure the long-
term sustainability of the Universal Service Fund. This program 
is critical in supporting telehealth, rural healthcare access, 
bridging the digital divide, and ensuring that everyone has 
access to broadband. My State is pivotal and very important in 
this discussion.
 Mr. Wood, communities in and around my district rely on 
Universal Service Fund's Rural Health Care Program for 
healthcare delivery, which enables telehealth, remote 
monitoring, and access to specialists. However, the 
contribution model still relies heavily on traditional telecom 
revenues, which are, in fact, shrinking.
 What reforms should Congress consider to modernize the USF 
program while preserving support for critical services like 
rural health, rural healthcare connectivity?
 Mr. Wood. Well, I was glad to hear Commissioner O'Rielly 
talk about this too. We think progressive funding for these 
kinds of distributions are important, and that is what BEAD got 
right in the infrastructure law as well. So we want to make 
sure that there is enough money to support those programs. The 
Rural Health Care Program is usually the smallest of the four 
USF programs. It is obviously crucial to get right. We just 
want to make sure that, as we bring more money into the system, 
we are not putting that on the backs of the people who need to 
benefit from it rather than paying more into it.
 Mr. Carter of Louisiana. Exactly.
 Let me pivot for a second, if you will indulge me, pivot to 
BEAD. As you know, Louisiana was the first State to receive 
Federal approval for its plan to deploy some $1.3 billion in 
BEAD funding, which included using $100 million in 
nondeployment funds to improve access to telehealth in rural 
areas. Unfortunately, the Trump administration overhauled the 
program and locked rural and underserved communities in 
districts like mine into second-tier technologies.
 Can you share with this committee how the community is 
harmed when high-speed, reliable internet broadband access 
isn't available and how this can lead to worse healthcare 
outcomes?
 Mr. Wood. Sure. I mean, I think, you know, as we have 
heard, there are a lot of different ways to reach rural areas. 
But, if you want to do anything to do with telehealth, you need 
the most robust connection possible, I would think, in almost 
every case. And so, again, I think that the genius of the 
bipartisan law was that States were the ones empowered to make 
those choices for themselves. We have seen that thrown off 
track too often by anybody in the Federal Government saying, 
``Oh, we think you have to do it this way or that way.''
 Mr. Carter of Louisiana. Is it fair to assume that the 
departure from the higher-grade performance that was done under 
the original BEAD Program to what Louisiana will now get is far 
inferior towhat we had before?
 Mr. Wood. I think that is unfortunate. I think States were 
supposed to make those choices for themselves, and so any 
pressure from this administration to say, ``You have to choose 
a cheaper option,'' might be something States say, ``We don't 
want to invest in the cheap kind. We want the better kind that 
will actually serve our residents better for years to come.''
 Mr. Carter of Louisiana. So it went backwards. Even though 
we hear our colleagues talk about the time it took, how long it 
was taking to move forward, Louisiana was ahead of the curve. 
Louisiana was ready. We had shovels in the ground ready to move 
when we were given an abrupt halt. And now we are moving 
forward again, but we are moving forward in a vein that is less 
than what we had before. So the citizens of Louisiana, daresay 
other parts of the country, will get a less superior product.
 Mr. Wood. I hope that we can recover from that, but, yes, 
any additional uncertainty introduced to the program--whatever 
people want to say about the previous administration, adding 
more uncertainty and more delay in this administration was not 
the right recipe to fix that.
 Mr. Carter of Louisiana. Well, you know, therein lies the 
problem. We get caught up in who did what, when, when our core 
mission, our responsibility is to do what is best for the 
American people, not to see who gets a greater level of credit, 
not to see which party gets to pound their chest the most but 
to make sure that the resources that will improve the lives of 
the people--in this case, in my State of Louisiana, they are 
getting less bang for their buck than what they had before 
since this administration changed.
 Mr. Wood. That reminds me of an old cliche that there is no 
limit to what you can accomplish in DC if you are willing to 
give somebody else the credit. And we have heard today about 
the bipartisan spirit that animated the 1996 Act, and hopefully 
we can get more of that as we really try to make sure that 
people are getting the benefit of the bargain, as it was 
called, you know. We haven't seen that thus far, but we need to 
make sure that that is what people----
 Mr. Carter of Louisiana. Well, the BEAD act transmission 
went from a Democratic Governor, John Bel Edwards, transitioned 
into a Republican Governor, Jeff Landry. Both agreed that the 
product they had was better and ready to move, and now we find 
ourselves in one that is subpar, and that is unfortunate.
 Mr. Chairman, my time has expired. I yield.
 Mr. Hudson. I appreciate that.
 And, you know, we had Mr. Soto quoting the Beatles and now 
we have Mr. Wood quoting Ronald Reagan. This is a great 
hearing. I think we have heard everything today.
 Mr. Wood. I have done it before in this room, sir, so I am 
used to it.
 Mr. Hudson. OK.
 So keeping the Carter theme going, I will recognize the 
gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Carter, for 5 minutes for your 
questions.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. I am going to follow up from my 
first cousin from Louisiana. So thank y'all for having--thank 
y'all for being here today. I appreciate it.
 This is very important, but 30 years--30 years is a long 
time. Think of what has changed in 30 years, particularly when 
you talk about telecommunications, and think about--and don't 
get me wrong, the Telecommunications Act of 1996, we all agree 
it was great. It unleashed competition and innovation, but it 
was different then, and we need to make sure that we are--we 
need to make sure that we are dealing with these times.
 I am going to jump to something that is very important to 
me. Mr. Pickering, I have got a bill. It is the Undersea Cable 
Protection Act of 2025, and your group just recently endorsed 
that. Thank you for doing that.
 Ninety-five percent of international internet transmissions 
are vital not only to the international e-commerce but also to 
our national security. Ninety-five percent of the internet 
transactions--financial, whatever--are carried through undersea 
cables, and that is what this bill addresses. So thank you for 
that.
 If this bill were signed into law, how would it impact our 
capacity for laying more cable for e-commerce and also bolster 
our national security?
 Mr. Pickering. Well, the faster that we can build the 
subsea cables, we build the redundancy, the reliability, the 
resilience of, really, the ocean arteries of communications in 
commerce that are critical. And with AI, the demand on our 
undersea pipes, so to speak, that deliver all of the now AI 
applications and data and uses are going to exponentially 
increase.
 So we need more subsea cables and landings. And wherever 
they land--it is like a new port city in the old world where 
all the commerce and all the energy and all the data centers 
and everything locates in a way to then build the new economy.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. Right.
 Mr. Pickering. So it is critical to the economy, critical 
to national security, and to be able to build as fast as 
possible is critical to beat China in the race toward AI.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. Well, good. Well, thank you, again, 
for your endorsement of that bill. I am very proud of it, and I 
want to see it--it has passed the House. I want to see it pass 
the Senate and signed into law. It needs to be.
 Mr. Pickering. It is essential, and we commend your 
leadership.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. Thank you. Thank you.
 I want to talk about permitting real quick. You know, I 
tell people all the time, I don't care what sector of our 
economy you are talking about--whether you are talking about 
telecommunications with health, energy--when people come into 
my offices, when companies comes into my offices, it is always 
the same thing: permitting, regulations crushing us, crushing 
us. We have got to do something about it.
 We are trying to address this, and I want to ask you, Mr. 
O'Rielly, how do we ensure that current permitting practices 
don't undermine U.S. competitiveness, especially in AI?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Well, look, I think you have been a leader on 
this issue and have the legislation in this committee to 
simplify the permitting process and to expedite the process, 
and I think it is absolutely essential. You know, when we talk 
about--a lot of conversation in permitting has been about 
energy and the energy sector, and that is great. I am not 
dismissing it, but there has rarely been a conversation of how 
do we take the telecom pieces and add them to that, because 
that should be part of the conversation.
 You have to move forward. If you want AI, if you want all 
the new technologies where communications technology is going, 
we have to deal with the permitting issue. It is the cost, it 
is the slowdown, it is the layers of approval, and no 
disrespect to local governments, it is just slowing down the 
process and has been for 30-plus years.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. Are there any steps that you think 
the FCC should be taking that perhaps they are not taking?
 Mr. O'Rielly. There are things that they could be helpful 
on. You want to give them authority. I think that is what your 
legislation and other legislation--this committee had a number 
of legislative efforts that would improve.
 There are things that I think that are vital that the 
committee didn't delve into. We have to do something more on 
poles. We have to expand the reach of the FCC rules on poles. 
It has got too many exemptions in the current statute, and they 
have got to be addressed.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. And what you are speaking of, my 
legislation, the American Broadband Deployment Act of 2025, 
this is very important because it is a combination of many of 
the Member priorities of this committee, and this subcommittee 
in particular, that will help to speed up deployment and reduce 
barriers and actually put shot clocks, as we like to refer to 
it as.
 And we are not trying to force municipalities. I was a 
mayor in another life, and I never liked the Federal Government 
or the State government telling me what I should be doing, but 
at the same time some of these local municipalities, 
especially, are slowing things down, and they are barriers. So 
this is what we are trying to address here.
 Is there anything in particular that you think we really 
need to concentrate on besides what we were doing in there?
 Mr. O'Rielly. I would pass your legislation. I would say 
many of those pieces are wonderful. They do codify current 
practices at the FCC in some instances, so you are already 
getting some of the benefit. But if I were to add one thing 
that is not included, you have to deal with poles.
 Mr. Carter of Georgia. OK. Good enough.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Thank y'all.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from New Jersey, Mr. 
Menendez, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Menendez. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the 
witnesses for being here.
 The Telecommunications Act of 1996 was a significant update 
to America's communications laws. Its goal was simple: boost 
competition, spark innovation, and make sure everyone has 
access to modern services. It aimed to expand broadband, open 
the door for new media companies, and give Americans access to 
a wider range of voices and viewpoints.
 Thirty years later, as technology continues to evolve, we 
need to determine where the FCC is still delivering on those 
promises and whether today's policies are truly meeting the 
needs of American families.
 To each witness, just yes or no: Was modernizing the media 
landscape to allow for new entrants and expand Americans' 
access to a broad range of viewpoints a key goal of the 1996 
Act?
 Mr. Pickering. Yes.
 Mr. Menendez. We will skip you.
 Mr. Thierer. Yes.
 Mr. Wood. Yes.
 Mr. O'Rielly. It wasn't a key----
 Mr. Menendez. Thank you.
 And to each witness, just yes or no: Would you agree that 
preserving a broad range of viewpoints in the media market is 
beneficial to all Americans, yes or no?
 Mr. Pickering. Yes.
 Mr. O'Rielly. Yes.
 Mr. Thierer. Yes.
 Mr. Wood. Yes.
 Mr. Menendez. Mr. Wood, should the FCC use its broadcast 
licensing authorities, including in merger reviews, to promote 
viewpoint diversity in the media market?
 Mr. Wood. Well, I mean, they should be promoting diversity, 
but they shouldn't be using their licensing authority to sort 
of control it or threaten people for any viewpoint they take, 
and I think that is a key distinction.
 Mr. Menendez. And I agree, and that is what we have seen 
since President Trump has taken office. Chairman Carr has used 
these powers in ways that undermine viewpoint diversity.
 Mr. Wood, does Chairman Carr's use of FCC's licensing 
authorities to pressure broadcasters into suppressing criticism 
of the Trump administration align with the 1996 Act's goal of 
promoting a broad range of viewpoints in the media?
 Mr. Wood. It does not. There is not only the First 
Amendment, which should be foremost here, but there is also a 
statute in the Act, Section 326, that I think is much older 
than 1996, that says the FCC has no power of censorship over 
radio, which, of course, means TV as well. And so it doesn't 
align with anything in the Act that I am aware of.
 Mr. Menendez. I agree.
 And, Mr. Wood, just yes or no: Has Chairman Carr's abuse of 
the FCC's broadcast licensing authorities impacted Americans' 
access to accurate, reliable information?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah, I think so. I mean, it is not only that we 
have seen this kind of pressure put on, but we have actually 
seen tangible results, which are unfortunate but is exactly 
what it seems like this administration has wanted when 
companies have either canceled shows or pulled back stories or 
changed their whole news operation.
 Mr. Menendez. I agree.
 And so while President Trump's FCC Chair uses the agency to 
censor broadcasters and limit viewpoints for political favor, 
Americans ultimately bear the cost. We have seen this happen 
again and again under this administration. The FCC has opened 
investigations into networks like CBS over how ``60 Minutes'' 
covered the 2024 election during a major media merger. Late-
night talk shows like ``Jimmy Kimmel Live'' were taken off the 
air while another merger was under review. There have been 
threats to take away licenses over straightforward news 
reporting about the war in Iran, which Americans continue to 
overwhelmingly oppose.
 Mr. Wood, do you recall an FCC Chair ever threatening 
broadcasters by saying, quote, ``We can do this the easy way or 
the hard way''?
 Mr. Wood. No. I recall Commissioner Carr saying those 
things shouldn't happen, and since he has been Chairman he has 
very much changed his tune. But there used to be, and I think 
there still is at this table, bipartisan agreement that this is 
wrong. It is just that this administration continues pressing 
that case.
 Mr. Menendez. I agree, and these actions send a troubling 
message. Instead of protecting a wide range of voices in the 
media, as the 1996 Act intended, the FCC under Chairman Carr is 
focused on Donald Trump's interests and not what is best for 
the American people.
 I want to read a quick statement and see if the panel 
agrees, and just a yes or no. ``
 ``Political satire is one of the oldest and most important 
forms of free speech.
 ``It challenges those in power while using humor to draw 
more people into the discussion.
 ``Equating this type of political speech with doctored 
deepfakes or illegal content is a serious mistake.
 ``From internet memes to late-night comedians, from 
cartoons to plays and poems as old as organized government 
itself, political satire circumvents traditional gatekeepers 
and helps hold those in power accountable.
 ``Not surprising that it has long been targeted for 
censorship.
 ``This isn't a close call or slippery slope.
 ``Shutting down this type of political speech, especially 
at the urging of those targeted or threatened by its message, 
would present a serious threat to our freedoms and ability to 
hold those in power accountable.''
 Do you agree with that statement, yes or no?
 Mr. Pickering. I believe in the competition of ideas.
 Mr. O'Rielly. Yes.
 Mr. Thierer. Yes.
 Mr. Wood. I do agree with that Brendan Carr statement, yes.
 Mr. Menendez. Oh, you stole the punch line.
 Mr. Wood. I am sorry, sir. I just know it so well. I have 
memorized it.
 Mr. Menendez. Brendan Carr in 2020, and 6 years later, here 
we are, him using his position to put his thumb on the scale of 
what we hear and how broadcasters are able to communicate what 
is happening in our country and across the globe, a deep 
departure from what he stated here, which you all agree with 
and I think my Republicans agree with.
 But I often hear more silence from them instead of them 
voicing their opposition to what this administration is doing. 
And we can't overlook this abuse of power when we are assessing 
how well we have achieved the goals of the 1996 Act. I urge my 
colleagues across the aisle to recognize this for what it is: 
political censorship, plain and simple.
 Thank you, and I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from California, Mr. 
Obernolte, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Obernolte. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you 
to our witnesses.
 You know, I am really struck by similarities in between 
when the Telecommunications Act was passed in 1996--you know, 
really at the dawn of the internet, and all the 
transformational changes that it was going to bring to our 
economy and our society--and where we are now with artificial 
intelligence, you know, at a very similar point where, you 
know, the landscape is just now becoming clear about just how 
transformative and, yes, disruptive it is going to be.
 And, you know, it seems to me like we have a similarity of 
purpose here, where back in 1996 the whole point was to 
increase competition and to put in place a light-touch 
regulatory structure that allowed Americans to succeed in this 
new digital age, and we are at exactly that same point now.
 So, Mr. Pickering, I will start with you. You know, 
obviously, we are seeing huge capital investment in AI, not 
just in model development and employment but in infrastructure 
like fiber networks and data centers.
 Does the Communications Act, as amended by the Telecom Act, 
still work for this new technology, or have we stretched it too 
far?
 Mr. Pickering. I would encourage this Congress to begin a 
new framework for the new age and for the new technology, 
taking lessons from the 1996 Act. And what do I mean by that? 
The 1996 Act did create a national framework that was critical 
for both the deployment of competitive networks and advanced 
networks, but it is also critical for the internet economy to 
emerge, that it was a national framework.
 So I really commend your work on a bipartisan basis to 
create an AI national preemptive framework on a light touch as 
it relates to preserving States' rights to regulate on the 
consumer protection and the existing applicable laws and 
applications. And what you have done, I think, is reflected in 
what the administration just put out in their AI framework.
 What this committee is doing on the permitting reforms, on 
fiber and the grid and electricity and energy and data centers, 
is the infrastructure pieces of the '80s and '90s that we did. 
So that if you can give a national framework of 
predictability--and I think children's safety is a core anchor 
into an effort that allows us to build the infrastructure, 
protect our children, and give a national predictable framework 
that allows us to win the race on AI.
 Mr. Obernolte. Thank you.
 Commissioner O'Rielly, I wanted to ask you about broadcast 
ownership rules because this is a topic that has come up 
recently again. You know, obviously, that was one of the key 
provisions of the Telecommunications Act, was to require the 
FCC to periodically review those rules, which they did. 
November of last year was their most recent time.
 But, you know, the question has arisen now, with the 
decline in local journalism, about whether or not those 
ownership rules are still well serving the purpose for which 
they were intended. And it has been opined by a number of 
different people that perhaps a reexamination of those rules is 
what is required to get the capital investment required to keep 
local journalism going.
 Would you think that that is true or false?
 Mr. O'Rielly. Generally true. I supported the biennial and 
then the quadrennial. It started as a biennial. But, you know, 
I think the ownership limitations no longer make any sense, and 
they should be modernized. I didn't think that we could do the 
cap through the FCC alone and have articulated a different 
position there, but overall, yes, the ownership limitations, 
certainly on the cap, make no sense.
 And then on even the local market, I think there was a deal 
to be had there that could have provided more comfort than we 
are probably going to get. In some regards it might already be 
addressed. The transaction will likely lead to more 
transactions and so, therefore, may be a moot question.
 Mr. Obernolte. Well, thank you.
 Mr. Thierer, I can tell you have an opinion on this. I 
would like to ask you as well.
 Mr. Thierer. On many of these things, but I want to join 
Chip Pickering in thanking you for your leadership on the 
important issues of the Federal AI framework and the bipartisan 
task force that you led with Representative Lieu.
 And I think that, you know, we have a framework not only in 
the Telecom Act, but a year after that the Clinton-Gore 
administration came out with a framework for global electronic 
commerce--again, global electronic commerce--saying, quote, 
``The internet should develop as a market-driven arena and not 
a regulated industry.'' It made it very clear that we needed a 
national framework and that it should be very light touch, and 
they moved forward in a bipartisan way with Congress to develop 
that and foster that environment that led to an explosion like 
the world had never seen of investment.
 I mean, AI last year, $400 billion invested in this 
country. We are running laps around the rest of the world on 
this. Why? Because we got our policy framework right for the 
internet and AI. We need to continue that and expand it with 
the kind of vision you provided.
 Mr. Obernolte. Right. Well, thank you, everyone, for your 
testimony.
 My time has expired. I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Virginia, Ms. 
McClellan, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Ms. McClellan. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 I am actually very excited about this hearing because I was 
a second-year law student when Congress passed the Telecom Act 
in 1996, which was written for a world that doesn't exist 
anymore.
 Voiceover landlines were still the primary form of 
communication provided over hundred-year-old copper 
infrastructure. As we heard, the internet was still in its 
early stages. There was no iPhone, no app economy, no Internet 
of Things, no modern broadband marketplace as we know it, no 
algorithms steering content to people. The industry 
predominantly looked like this panel of witnesses.
 A year later, I began a 25-year career implementing the 
Telecom Act at the State and Federal level. So I have a real 
appreciation for both the ambition of the Act and the profound 
ways that the marketplace has changed since then.
 As a young lawyer, I negotiated and arbitrated 
interconnection agreements across multiple States, including 
the first arbitration under the Act at the FCC, focusing on 
what was then called advanced services. I monitored evolving 
service quality standards to protect consumers at the Federal 
and the State level, helped shepherd through the transition of 
communications infrastructure from that copper network to 
state-of-the-art fiber facilities.
 I witnessed a rapidly evolving State and Federal regulatory 
framework and the challenge of recovering costs from a rapidly 
shrinking customer base without pricing services out of reach 
as technology brought intermodal competition faster than ever 
imagined.
 I saw firsthand how permitting and citing officials 
struggled to adapt regulations created for giant cell phone 
towers to small cell wireless antennas the size of a backpack. 
And my final assignment before coming to Congress was figuring 
out how to implement BEAD across the Mid-Atlantic States from 
Virginia to New York.
 And in light of some of the complaints that I have heard on 
this committee, I want to remind my colleagues, as I have done 
in the past, that some of that lag was due to the need required 
by the Act to develop a broadband map of underserved areas to 
ensure Federal funds weren't used to build duplicate 
facilities, the time to stand up broadband offices, plans and 
grant processes that allowed public participation and would 
meet open meeting and notice requirements.
 We saw new entrants come and go. Baby Bells consolidated 
and gobbled up their competitors and even gobbled up their 
former parent. We saw the rise of cable and wireless providers, 
the growth of intermodal competition, the shift from voice to 
data, the rapid acceleration of mobile broadband after the 
invention of the smartphone, the emergence of fiber and 
satellite.
 We saw network providers get into content, content 
providers get into networks, cable providers get into data and 
voice, so on and so on.
 We saw industry executives push to make their workforce 
reflect the diversity of their customer base because they 
understood it was good for competition and it was good for 
business, and they could do so without fear of punishment from 
the FCC before the term ``DEI'' was ever heard in the wider 
community.
 We saw customers change how they communicate, work, access 
entertainment, and participate in civic life.
 The Act has done a phenomenal job. It is woefully outdated 
and does not meet the moment of what we need for the modern 
communications infrastructure. We are still grappling with 
persistent questions of universal connectivity and 
affordability. We are still debating how best to protect 
consumers, who I haven't heard a lot about today, in a 
broadband-driven marketplace, including through transparency, 
privacy, and public safety protections. We are still asking 
whether our communications laws are doing enough to preserve 
competition, diversity of voices in an era of consolidation and 
concentrated market power, and whether every American can 
afford the communication tools they need to survive.
 So while today's hearing has not just been an exercise in 
nostalgia, it needs to help us think seriously about what 
modern communications policies should look like.
 When I came to Congress, I believe it was you, Mr. 
Pickering, who said, ``You need to work on modernizing the 
Telecom Act.'' At the time, having just spent 25 years 
implementing it, I wasn't very excited about that. But 
listening to this hearing and, frankly, since the first day 
getting on this committee, you were right, and I am excited to 
be a part of modernizing it, but it can't wait, and this 
Congress has moved very slowly.
 And whether it is implementing it in small batches, as 
suggested today, while focusing on a complete overhaul, we have 
got to get it right, because technology is changing much more 
rapidly today, and if we are not careful, the next Telecom Act 
could be obsolete in 4 or 5 years.
 Now, I do have questions that I will submit for the record, 
but I wanted to give you the experience of somebody who tried 
to figure out what Congress meant when it passed the Telecom 
Act and spent 25 years doing it.
 Thank you, and I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you. I appreciate your perspective on 
that.
 I now recognize the gentleman from Florida, Representative 
Dunn, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Dunn. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 You know, 30 years ago Congress passed the 
Telecommunications Act, and the first major overhaul--that was 
the first major overhaul since the Great Depression. The bill 
had the clear intention of promoting competition while reducing 
burdensome regulation. In many ways we were successful, but 
competition expanded, innovation accelerated, and consumers 
gained more choices than ever before. We can't ignore this.
 In 1996, very few of us would have ever imagined that 
broadband internet would become the foundation of a modern 
economy or a world where artificial intelligence and cloud 
computing have revolutionized how we live and work. Here we are 
30 years later, and the communications landscape has been 
transformed beyond recognition.
 The 1996 Act remains the last major update to 
communications law this country has enacted, and today's 
hearing is an opportunity to ask whether that framework is 
still serving the American people and what we need to do as 
Congress to take care of people.
 Commissioner O'Rielly, improving our satellite capabilities 
has always been a top priority for me, which is why I led the 
Launch Communications Act with Mr. Soto back in 2023. And 
satellite connectivity was not a major focus, obviously, of the 
Telecom Act back then.
 How would you propose we update the Act to properly address 
satellite connectivity?
 Mr. O'Rielly. This committee has been very active and 
actually led the effort to push for regulatory reform of how 
satellites are regulated by the FCC. In terms of the process 
and the timing, I would continue that process. I think it has 
been wonderful. The Commission has picked up on that and has 
really charged ahead to make sure that the old structure that 
we had for GEOs is modernized for the smaller LEO systems in 
how dynamic they are.
 We have to fix the processing rounds that were built for a 
GEO universe where you might have only two or three applicants 
for a particular spectrum band. Well, now we are having, you 
know, dozens that want to have--when I was at the FCC, you had 
a dozen different applicants for LEO spectrum. And we are going 
to have to deal with the fact that additional spectrums are 
needed, probably, likely in the satellite field. Where do you 
find that? How does it compete with everybody else?
 So there are things to do, but the story for satellite is 
incredibly promising because of the exciting technology and 
investment that has gone on in that space, but also the 
committee's work to push processing reform and licensing 
reform.
 Mr. Dunn. Well, so I think I agree with you, and I hope 
that you will work with my office on that because we spent a 
lot of time on satellite and communication.
 Mr. Pickering, your testimony argues that getting the 
policy fundamentals right is the key to our success.
 Given how quickly these technologies have evolved, is 
legislation the best way to accomplish this as opposed to 
perhaps regulation? And if not legislation, what is the best 
approach for emerging technology so that we don't get too 
bogged down in our legislative problems?
 Mr. Pickering. So if you follow the core principle of the 
1996 Act, which is to promote competition in every sector, 
every market, every network, and if you look at how does that 
apply today on the AI front--so if California, Colorado, New 
York are regulating AI models differently than all the other 
States, then they constitute barriers to entry primarily of the 
new entrants in this. And we represent from new AI companies 
entering the market to the larger, established American 
technology companies. And what we want is one national standard 
on the models so that everybody can deploy and then have 
maximum competition among the models. And the same is all of 
the above on our networks and our infrastructure.
 And the AI revolution--and I know Congresswoman Fedorchak 
is not here and Congressman Latta left, but the AI revolution 
has a chance to bring competition to energy like it did to 
digital infrastructure, and don't miss that opportunity to 
bring competition to all parts of the infrastructure and all 
models.
 Mr. Dunn. Thank you very much.
 I don't think I have time for another question here, Mr. 
Chairman, so I am going to yield back to you. Thank you so 
much.
 Mr. Hudson. I appreciate your discretion, sir.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Florida, 
Representative Castor, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Ms. Castor. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman, for holding this 
important hearing on the Telecommunications Act of 1996. Thanks 
to our witnesses who have been here.
 The Act definitely is responsible for the digital age that 
we live in now, mostly for good, but we have--I think there is 
bipartisan concern with how Section 230, that shield, has 
evolved now as the technology has evolved.
 And this committee has spent a good amount of time over the 
years learning about the harms to young people through online 
social media platforms, especially the way that the platforms 
are designed, not the content but the addictive features that 
keep kids online or expose them to predators or encourage them 
to participate in violence, social media challenges, or fall 
victim to financial exploitation.
 I think these lawsuits out of L.A. and New Mexico this week 
are very telling. I think the public understands the harm to 
children, and I don't--the bills that passed out of the House 
Energy and Commerce Committee don't do the job. They will 
actually leave children worse off with fewer protections.
 So there is a lot of work yet to be done here, but I don't 
want anyone peering into this hearing to think that this 
committee has been hard at work on those solutions this 
Congress--yes in last Congresses where we were bipartisan, but 
we have a lot of work to do. And until we are able to do that 
in a bipartisan way, the courts and citizens across the country 
will take the matter into their own hands.
 Mr. Wood, you said, yes, Section 230 has acted kind of as a 
get-of-out-of-jail-free card to some extent. How do you want us 
thinking about bringing clarity to Section 230 in a day and age 
where the technology has evolved? It is not just static 
anymore. We have automated content recommendations, AI-
generated digital material.
 How do you recommend that we proceed here?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah. The technology has changed. I don't know 
that that is the key part for any kind of amendment to the law. 
When I testified back in 2021 on this, we supported looking at 
what we called distributor liability, so think of the bookstore 
rather than the publisher.
 And so there was actually a bill at that time to overrule a 
case that I think made 230 too broad. I want to be clear again: 
We support 230. We think it has been vital. We think it is 
still vital today. But when a company knows that it is causing 
harm and we can show that, then that is when they should be 
held to account.
 And the kind of product design liability theory that you 
mentioned, I haven't had time to fully study this week's 
results in the court cases. These are all productive 
discussions to have. Obviously, we think that every lawsuit 
shouldn't land, but that too many times they have been turned 
away by an overly broad reading of 230 that goes back to some 
of those very first decisions about it.
 Ms. Castor. I agree.
 The committee has also spent considerable time examining 
how to build out infrastructure and boost connectivity. There 
are many folks back home, many of my neighbors, who still are 
barred because they simply can't afford the device, and that is 
why I thought it was terrific that Congress came together and 
passed the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to consider broadband 
as infrastructure. It is if you want to fully participate in 
today's economy.
 That is why we created a grant program at NTIA for digital 
equity, and the city of St. Petersburg in my district won a 
competitive $6.9 million grant. St. Pete was in the first round 
of the grants. It was the only city in Florida to win, because 
there are a lot of barriers. There is a big digital divide 
between the haves and the have-nots, so that was going to be an 
important way to address the digital divide and get devices and 
hot spots and home internet equipment out.
 Mr. Pickering, you said--you highlighted the--you thought 
this is beneficial, an infrastructure law that considers 
broadband expansion.
 Do you still think that is the truth?
 Mr. Pickering. Very much. We just need to get it in the 
ground and build it and deploy it as fast as possible and then 
use the very sizeable savings, about $21 billion, to help in 
the permitting across the country to speed----
 Ms. Castor. But for these kind of grants--I mean, for the 
administration to come in and rip those funds away after the 
Congress has passed a law, we have appropriated the money--that 
is our constitutional role, right--what is your view of an 
administration acting illegally to cancel those kind of grants?
 Mr. Pickering. Well, look, whether it is a Republican or a 
Democratic administration, unfortunately, government is not 
known for moving fast. The private sector is----
 Ms. Castor. I don't think this is an issue of them moving 
fast or for the NTIA grant. It was a matter of the 
administration illegally taking back appropriated dollars that 
have been granted to a community that needed them.
 You don't have to answer. My time is up.
 Mr. Pickering. Thank you.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 Ms. Castor. You hear where I am coming from.
 Thank you. I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. I thank the gentlelady.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Ohio, Mr. 
Landsman, for 5 minutes for your questions.
 Mr. Landsman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you all 
for being here and your testimony today.
 The 1996 telecoms bill, to me, is about corporate 
consolidation and what Congress did to take on corporate 
consolidation to create the kind of competition that would lead 
to better outcomes for consumers.
 And, you know, we find ourselves in a situation where we 
are dealing with extreme concentrations of wealth and power 
throughout just about every sector, and that leads to this kind 
of--concentration of wealth and power leads to fewer choices 
for consumers, higher costs, the quality of services typically 
goes down, workers get less.
 And, you know, in 1996, Congress took action. They had a 
lot of courage. They took on this situation with AT&T, which at 
the time had 90, 80, you know, percent of the market share--it 
was something significant like that--and broke up AT&T into, I 
think, seven companies and returned competition back to the 
marketplace.
 It is important to note that at the moment, three companies 
now have 90 percent of the market share again, AT&T and a few 
others. So there is the question as to whether or not this 
Congress has to find that courage again to say we are going to 
break up this concentration of wealth and power because it is 
terrible for consumers. It is terrible for the markets.
 And it is not just in telecom. I am going to just give you 
a couple of examples. There are four meatpackers in the United 
States that control 80 percent of the beef market. So farmers 
get paid less and consumers pay more. There are three 
pharmacies that own more than half of the market. There are 
three PBMs that control 80 percent of the market. There are two 
hardware stores--companies--that control more than half of the 
market.
 There is one healthcare company that is buying up 
hospitals. They currently only have 5 percent of the market, 
but that is significant. They have purchased 200 hospitals. 
Their goal is to get to 30 percent by the end of the decade, 
just in a few years. That is 2,500 more hospitals that they are 
going to buy.
 This is, I think, at the heart of why the economy is 
broken, is that you have this extreme concentration of wealth 
and power where only a few people are making these big 
decisions.
 And, you know, it is important to remember that Congress 
did have courage to act on this in 1996. They broke up AT&T. 
They took on corporate consolidation. So I guess the question 
is, is that courage still here? Do we still have it? Because it 
is clearly needed.
 So I would like us to take on, you know, a similar bill as 
it relates to food in this country, as it relates to healthcare 
in this country, as it relates to media across the board.
 Mr. Wood--and you all can talk about, you know, any other 
sector, but, you know, in telecoms, you know, clearly this 
competition question is still an issue.
 Does it need to be resolved? I mean, as we take up this 
legislation, isn't there the question, well, aren't we back at 
this place where three companies own 30 percent of the market?
 Mr. Wood. Yeah. I mean, I have certainly seen commentators 
talk about AT&T sort of putting itself back together almost 
Terminator-like and, you know, becoming as big as it once was. 
I think the important thing to note, we have heard a lot today 
about deregulation and how that boosts innovation and 
investment, and that can be true, but we have to be careful 
about that because I think we also have on both sides of the 
aisle concerns about the power of Big Tech.
 And so deregulation, I don't agree that every situation is 
the same. I don't really agree with suggestions we have heard 
that we should put every kind of tech company into the same 
bucket. I think the larger point you make, though, is exactly 
right, that there is tremendous concentration of wealth, and 
that can maybe lead to faster pace sometimes. We have to be 
worried about who is being tossed aside along the way.
 Mr. Landsman. Mr. Pickering, you were in Congress. You 
know--I have got 25 seconds--so I don't feel the courage, and I 
am curious what you think.
 Mr. Pickering. Courage, in part, sometimes can build a 
hole, and so take the steps where you can make a difference. I 
want to commend you for the RAIL Act. It is an example of 
allowing new entrants, new fiber companies, new deployments to 
cross the railroad track in time and at cost without delay, and 
it really is an important part of bridging the digital divide.
 So removing barriers helps on the competition side, and so 
I commend you and Congressman Joyce and Congressman Peters, a 
bipartisan initiative to do so.
 Look, Incompas started in 1981 as the first and founding 
voice for competition to break up AT&T. So, you know, today we 
celebrate so much more competition in the digital economy from 
what it was.
 Mr. Landsman. Fair enough.
 Mr. Pickering. And I tell all my friends, my family, and 
you, I have met progress. I haven't met perfection. And we have 
made a lot of progress.
 Mr. Landsman. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 The Chair now recognizes the gentleman from Pennsylvania, 
Mr. Joyce, for 5 minutes to ask your questions.
 Mr. Joyce. Thank you, Chairman Hudson and Ranking Member 
Matsui, for allowing me to join in this important hearing.
 As the development of advanced technology accelerates, it 
is important that we evaluate existing law to ensure that 
regulations are appropriate and that innovation is encouraged. 
This is increasingly necessary as we see tech development 
leading us into the age of AI.
 Pennsylvania is leading innovation in the artificial 
intelligence space. As I have previously mentioned before this 
subcommittee, the historic $92 billion investment announced by 
President Trump in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania last year 
is securing more jobs, attracting domestic companies, and 
increasing energy production.
 We must continue to invest in this industry that is 
promoting economic growth and leading to advancements across 
all sectors, including manufacturing and healthcare. With these 
crucial developments, the United States can win the global AI 
race. We must allow innovation and competitiveness to thrive. 
We must provide the proper guardrails for this to all be 
possible at the same time.
 Mr. Pickering, you mentioned the importance of the United 
States winning the global AI race in your written testimony. 
You also mentioned that we are entering into a new era defined 
in a completely different way by AI.
 Is this definition--as we enter into this, is it clear that 
we are living in that different world than when this Act was 
originally passed?
 Mr. Pickering. Yes, and that is why earlier, in one of the 
answers to a question, I said we need a new framework. We need 
an AI framework and an AI infrastructure and the policies to 
build, as quickly as possible, a national standard delegating 
to the States what they do best, reserving for our national 
interstate commerce a policy on AI, and bringing competition to 
the energy and electricity markets that we brought to the 
digital infrastructure networks for the last 40 years.
 Mr. Joyce. Is that framework capable of being developed 
with this Telecommunications Act of 1996?
 Mr. Pickering. I would recommend a new framework.
 Mr. Joyce. What updates, what specifically should occur 
that would allow AI development and competition to continue to 
develop?
 Mr. Pickering. It goes back--you know,having a national 
framework on model regulation is critical, because if you take 
the European approach, which is a permission base--before you 
develop a model, you must get regulatory approval--and that 
slows innovation, it slows adoption, and it slows and sometimes 
blocks competition.
 So have a national framework on model regulation, allow the 
States to continue consumer protection, civil rights, and all 
the core innovative things that they do but not to be able to 
say yes or no to a model being built and deployed at the front 
end.
 Mr. Joyce. You talk about the keenness of innovation. Does 
that have to be maintained at the forefront to be successful?
 Mr. Pickering. Yes.
 Mr. Joyce. I agree with you on that.
 You mentioned the RAIL Act. I am the grandson of 
railroaders from Pennsylvania. I saw the advancements of what 
railroad has done, but I see the lack of cooperation currently 
right now with the rail industry that allows the lines that 
need to be placed either alongside, underneath, or over rail.
 How important is that to allow telecommunications to 
continue to advance?
 Mr. Pickering. You know, it is critically important both to 
the fiber to the home across--a lot of times the railroad 
really is the dividing line in a community, between the 
advantaged and the disadvantaged. So to be able to connect 
fiber to the home is important.
 But we are also having long routes and middle-mile routes 
that connect key hubs, like in Pennsylvania, to the data 
centers and the energy and the large language model data 
centers. Those long routes connecting a global and a national 
system of AI infrastructure, of cloud computing and 
supercomputing and next quantum computing--to be able to have 
those long routes, you have to cross railroads.
 And a lot of times we are seeing 6 months, 12 months, 18 
months where the railroads sit on an application and never 
respond. And then when they do, they are charging exorbitant 
rates to cross the railroad. And we can do it at cost, with 
shot clocks, safely, more than current safety standards. We can 
cross underneath in a very, very safe way.
 And we need--your legislation fixes that, and it is 
bipartisan, both House and Senate, and I hope it can be part of 
the Broadband Deployment Act and whatever permitting reform, 
comprehensive approach this Congress tries to do this year.
 Mr. Joyce. I think you recognize, as we continue to 
modernize the Telecommunications Act of 1996 30 years after it 
was made into law, innovations and technologies, specifically 
in artificial intelligence, should be one of our collective 
focus points.
 I thank you for your discussion today. I thank all of you 
for this hearing.
 Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
 Mr. Hudson. Thank you.
 And I ask unanimous consent to insert in the record the 
documents included on the staff hearing documents list.
 [The information appears at the conclusion of the hearing.]
 Mr. Hudson. Without objection, so ordered.
 Seeing there are no further Members wishing to be 
recognized, I would like to thank our excellent panel of 
witnesses. This has been a fantastic conversation. I really 
appreciate all of your thoughts and testimony and answers to 
the questions here today.
 I remind Members they have 10 business days to submit 
questions for the record, and I ask our witnesses to please 
respond to those questions promptly. I believe I will have a 
few for you too. I am looking forward to continuing this 
conversation.
 Members should submit their questions by close of business 
on April 9, 2026.
 Without objection, this subcommittee is adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 1:00 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] 
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 [all]