Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-181] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-181 THE CENSORSHIP INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX ======================================================================= HEARING before the SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CONSTITUTION of the COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ MARCH 25, 2025 __________ Serial No. J-119-9 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.judiciary.senate.gov www.govinfo.gov _______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 61-838 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director Subcommittee on the Constitution ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri, Chair JOHN CORNYN, Texas PETER WELCH, Vermont, Ranking MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah Member TED CRUZ, Texas SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee ALEX PADILLA, California ADAM B. SCHIFF, California Ethan Harper, Republican Chief Counsel Ryan Ferguson, Democratic Chief Counsel C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Schmitt, Hon. Eric............................................... 1 Welch, Hon. Peter................................................ 4 Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 6 WITNESSES Franks, Mary Anne................................................ 11 Prepared statement........................................... 35 Hemingway, Mollie................................................ 9 Prepared statement........................................... 41 Rottman, Gabe.................................................... 15 Prepared statement........................................... 43 Turley, Jonathan................................................. 13 Prepared statement........................................... 53 Weingarten, Benjamin............................................. 17 Prepared statement........................................... 62 APPENDIX Items submitted for the record................................... 77 THE CENSORSHIP INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX ---------- TUESDAY, MARCH 25, 2025 United States Senate, Subcommittee on the Constitution, Committee on the Judiciary, Washington, DC. The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:03 p.m., in Room 226, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Eric Schmitt, Chair of the Subcommittee, presiding. Present: Senators Schmitt [presiding], Lee, Hawley, Kennedy, Blackburn, Booker, and Welch. Also present: Senator Durbin. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ERIC SCHMITT, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI Chair Schmitt. Okay. We'll call the first hearing of the Senate Judiciary Committee's Subcommittee on the Constitution to order. It's an honor and a privilege to serve as the Chairman of this Committee, with a rich history, for the 119th Congress. And it's also fortunate to have my friend and Ranking Member, my colleague, Senator Peter Welch, as the Ranking Member from the great State of Vermont. So, thank you to all the witnesses and all the folks who've made their way here. This Committee will have several important hearings regarding our fundamental rights, the separation of powers, and our constitutional order. So, before we get rolling, I've got some opening remarks, and I know Senator Welch does, as well. Before joining the Senate, as Attorney General of Missouri, I led the Missouri v. Biden case, lawsuit, exposing the vast censorship enterprise that the Biden administration had built. [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the record.] Chair Schmitt. In the years that have followed, we've uncovered an even larger and more formidable censorship industrial complex that spans from our Nation and across the Western World. The issue we're here to discuss extends far beyond the borders of the United States. It's a crisis that implicates all of Western civilization, a crisis that threatens to plunge much of what we once called ``the free world'' into darkness. Over the past decade, an alliance of activists, academics, journalists, Big Tech companies, and Federal bureaucrats designed a system to suppress and silence their critics. They did so in unprecedented ways, using new, novel tools and technologies of the 21st century. What they built was, in effect, a second state--a faceless system of power not bound by the limits and liberties of our Constitution. Of course, this alliance was all too happy to wield traditional state power, as well. Under the Biden administration, the Department of Justice became a vehicle for lawfare against the left's political enemies. The victims of this assault were countless innocent Americans, from concerned parents at school board meetings to traditional Catholics to pro-life activists to President Trump himself. But to fully understand the scale of the left's war on the First Amendment, we must look beyond the formal limits of Government. The faceless adversary in American politics today is the sprawling labyrinth of left-wing NGOs, nonprofits, foundations, and activist groups--a shadow state that operates with collective purpose, even as its power is dispersed across a vast constellation of groups. Mass migration, cultural Marxism, political riots, the criminal violence that consumes our inner cities. Pull back the curtain on each one of these, and you'll find the same names, the same groups, time and time again. These groups are home to a permanent left-wing activist class that believes itself to be beyond the reach of our constitutional checks and balances. It's the same class that dominates almost every major power center in our country today: the NGOs and major foundations, mass media, the education system, the arts and culture industry, Big Tech, and the administrative state itself. Fundamentally, they see our constitutional order as an obstacle to their political ambitions, so they can operate in the shadows outside of its line of sight. Journalists have taken their talking points on disinformation from censorship industry experts. And those experts protect the legacy media's power by discrediting and blacklisting their competitors. Activist groups, along with their friends in the press, enforce this system by launching pressure campaigns against anyone who steps out of line. The revolving door never stops turning. The Biden administration was chock full of alumni of these groups. Some had previously worked in the Obama administration. To take one of the many examples, Gene Kimmelman, a man who was described as Obama's, quote, ``secret weapon'' on antitrust at the DOJ, left the Obama administration to open up the DC office of Global Partners & Associates, a so-called human rights group dedicated to combating misinformation and hate speech online. From there, he went on to take over as president and CEO of Public Knowledge, yet another online censorship group, that played a key role in suppressing speech during COVID. Once Biden came into power, Kimmelman was appointed to his transition team at the DOJ, where he subsequently took a job as a senior advisor. It's all in the open now, and you can see how it works. So, it should come as no surprise that Jen Psaki boasted about flagging disinformation for Facebook or that the Biden White House was revealed to have been revealed to have been back- channeling with YouTube about suppressing disfavored speech. Nor should it surprise us that the Biden administration coordinated directly with NGOs and nonprofits to wage a whole- of-society censorship campaign. The administrative state and the NGOs are partners in crime with the Big Tech companies themselves. Big Tech elites may be seeking to rewrite history, now, especially that our side, the Republicans, are in power. But for the past decade they have been eager participants in advancing the left's agenda. Facebook was transformed, and it worked side by side with NGOs to censor conservatives. Google had used its enormous power to systematically censor, de-boost, and throttle conservative ideas and speech, integrating the NGO censorship agenda into every facet of their algorithm. I know this because I've been fighting these people and these organizations my entire career. The Missouri v. Biden case forced the Biden administration to release 20,000 pages of evidence: emails, Slack messages, meeting notes, and other internal communications between the White House, the tech companies, and the NGOs. These documents revealed a vast censorship enterprise far larger in scope and scale than we could have previously imagined--a coordinated, well-oiled machine, with the NGOs at the very center. This machine is waging war on our free speech across multiple fronts. The first is blacklists. Groups like NewsGuard and Global Disinformation Index--both of which refused our invitation to testify here today, we did ask--feed blacklists of disfavored media outlets to major advertising firms, depriving these outlets of access to critical ad dollars. What this does, in effect, is to box out conservative or dissident outlets from access to the public square. The top 10 outlets on GDI's blacklist were all on the political right. Another front involves the manipulation of the private--or, the public narrative. The nonprofits work with the press to justify mass censorship, manufacture hysteria about right-wing disinformation, and smear and defame their critics. Groups like the Atlantic Council actively train journalists in their talking points about disinformation, which--surprise, surprise, almost always means conservative speech. This provides the public pretext for those same groups to push for more censorship. We've seen that in practice in a series of aggressive pressure campaigns waged against platforms that are too friendly to free speech. In 2020, the, quote, ``Stop Hate for Profit'' campaign, led by a coalition of powerful censorship groups, allied with journalists and advertisers to push for far more aggressive censorship on Facebook, and Facebook swiftly complied. They tried to run the same play against Elon Musk during his acquisition of Twitter. But Elon Musk was the only leader of a major social media platform who was willing to take a stand and defend free speech. Finally, many of these organizations are directly involved with real-time censorship. Groups like the Stanford Internet Observatory and the University of Washington Center for an Informed Public monitor social media platforms and flag disfavored narratives for the tech platforms themselves. These platforms proceed to use that information to throttle, censor, or ban disfavored ideas. This is not just an attack on free speech but an attack on the principle of self-government itself. All of this--all of it is funded in no small part by taxpayer dollars. Under the Biden administration, seemingly every agency became a conduit for funneling taxpayer dollars to censorship groups. To describe these groups as private makes a mockery of the term. The NGOs are inextricably tied to the Federal Government. They are another arm of Permanent Washington, advancing its ideological goals in places where the Government cannot. Where the state's power is limited either by political pressure or the Constitution itself, these groups step in to man the gap. Let us close with this--or, let me close with this. We are a Nation conceived in liberty. But over the past decade a great darkness has arisen in America, a darkness that threatens to transform our country forever. We have watched this darkness pour out in crashing waves, throwing open our borders to the world, dispossessing our people, and unleashing a lawlessness that has swallowed our towns and cities whole. But the agents of this darkness cannot win without aggressive censorship and suppression, dismantling the tradition of free speech and thought that has been core to the way that we live our lives even before our founding. In the digital age, with all the peril and possibility that accompanies with it, the struggle for free speech is the struggle for civilization itself. Once again, we must commit that this Nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom and that the Government of the people, by the people, and for the people shall not perish from the face of this new tyranny. Senator Welch. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. PETER WELCH, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF VERMONT Senator Welch. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I'm delighted to be your Ranking Member on this Committee and delighted to be your colleague in the Senate, in the same class, and delighted to serve with you on the Judiciary Committee. And welcome, Senator Durbin. I'm totally with you on the First Amendment and the central role it plays in the well-being of this Nation. It was such a radical concept in 1791. I mean, it's hard to imagine that, at a time when kings were the law, we had a Republic that protected our fundamental freedoms to religion, to speech, to assembly, the right to petition the Government, and to have free press that could operate without any fear of Government censorship. So, we have agreement on that, and we're going to have a discussion about how that's playing out at this moment in our history. That First Amendment does reflect our Founding Fathers' view--and, I think, my view and, frankly, yours, Mr. Chairman-- that we can have a society where individuals freely voice their views. And that First Amendment protection is the bedrock that allows folks to do that. I have some--you have some questions about the deep, dark state. We're going to go through those. I have some factual disputes with you that'll come out. I have some concerns about some of the actions that the current administration is taking and how it impacts on First Amendment rights and constitutional protections. [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Welch. You know, should Associated Press reporters be removed from parts of the White House press pool because they won't adopt the name that the President prefers for the Gulf of Mexico slash America? Should a news organization that provides negative coverage of a political person, including a President, be called illegal? Should a newspaper be sued--especially these days, when the finances of newspapers are so precarious--because a candidate did not like the poll results that were published in that newspaper? These are extraordinarily significant events that create a real suppression, in my view, of free speech. Should law firms be brought to heel because they defended somebody with whom a President disagrees? These are examples that do raise questions about free expression in this country, and those are things that I'd like to discuss with our witnesses today. But on this question of the censorship industrial complex, the basic allegation here, as I understand it, is that there is Government-facilitated interference with free speech. And we're going to hear from the witnesses on that. But the underlying premise of this, as I understand it, is the taxpayers are essentially footing the bill for this. My view is that facts don't support that allegation. Take, for instance, NewsGuard. That provides transparency and reliability ratings so that advertisers can make informed decisions about where to spend their money. We can have a big debate about whether their judgments are right or they're wrong. But I understand that the organization only received a few very small Federal grants to do specific things, and the main work that they did--and those grants, by the way, came from the Trump administration, back in 2020, to track and warn of Russian, Chinese, and Iranian disinformation that is targeting Americans--which is, by the way, a really fundamentally important distinction. The speech of Americans is protected. Does that mean that we want to protect literally foreign-actor efforts to undermine the rights of Americans to make their own decisions about who will be their leaders? Another allegation that is part of this is that the Twitter files released by Elon Musk--some claims were that the Twitter files show that the Government censored 22 million tweets. I have a factual dispute with that. [Poster is displayed.] Senator Welch. They argue that, because the Government provided funding to institutions that studied election disinformation and because the institutions flagged social media posts with disinformation for companies, they--these institutions were part of a Government conspiracy to suppress speech. In my view, those arguments are simply not based on the facts. In reality, the Government funding was not to track and report social media activity. It was to help counter foreign disinformation. And only 2,980 tweets were actually reported to Twitter because they did appear to violate Twitter's terms of service, Twitter's own terms of service. So, the Twitter files report is overcounted by nearly 22 million tweets. And, of course, last year the Supreme Court rejected the allegation that Government had unconstitutionally censored conservatives by pressuring social media companies to take down posts. [Poster is displayed.] Senator Welch. And that was a 6-to-3 decision by Judge Amy Coney Barrett that found no merits to the claims--Justice Barrett wrote, ``It's therefore difficult to say that the White House was responsible, even in part.'' So, Mr. Chairman, although we agree that Government should not infringe on free speech--I am with you on that and with all of my colleagues here--I don't believe that's what has been happening here. And finally, just on a matter of privileges to the Ranking Member, I hope as our Committee does its work this year, we focus on other aspects of the Constitution, including the separation of powers. You know, as Members of Congress, it's up to us to decide whether we're ever going to cede our authority to the executive branch, and while this is not the focus of this hearing, I want to express to my colleagues that I am concerned about Executive overreach. During the first week in office, the new administration Office of Management and Budget imposed a freeze on all Federal grants and other financial assistance. [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Welch. That is reminiscent of the impoundment action that President Nixon took, which was found to be unconstitutional. Congress seems on the brink of ceding that authority to the President in the recent CR. Seventeen inspector generals were fired without notifying Congress. That's in direct contravention of the clear language of the law. Two Democratic commissioners to the Federal Trade Commission--that's an independent agency--were removed, and that is true for other agencies, as well. And can a President dismantle a department like the Department of Education? Whatever your views are about that department--when it was created by Congress--and can the President do that? Any President, unilaterally? My view is no. It's a ceding of congressional authority where what we do is give up our legislative prerogative and therefore take away one of the checks in the checks and balances system that we have as Government. So, my hope is that over the next 2 years we'll have a chance to look at your concerns on the First Amendment, which I share, but also other essential constitutional structures, like the checks and balances system that has benefited us all. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chair Schmitt. Yes. As is the tradition of the Committee, the Ranking Member of the Judiciary Committee, Senator Durbin. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS Senator Durbin. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. The First Amendment protects the freedoms of religion, speech, press, assembly, and the right to petition the Government. These five freedoms form the bedrock on which our Constitution is based. But the First Amendment is under attack by President Donald Trump and his MAGA allies. In his recent Joint Address to Congress, President Trump falsely claimed to have, quote, ``brought free speech back to America,'' end quote. His actions have utterly failed his words. Instead of bolstering free speech in America, President Trump has sought to use his Executive power to punish his perceived opponents and those whose speech he disagreed with. In 2 short months, his targets have included the press-- Associated Press member invited out of the White House for not saying ``Gulf of America''--universities, students, and law firms. These attacks on free speech and association have a chilling effect and signal to others that if they don't fall in line with the Trump administration's preferred views, they could be next. If you really care about the First Amendment, these actions should trouble you. We all need to take notice and stand up and protect our rights. After the end of World War II, someone asked Winston Churchill, how do you think history is going to treat you? He said, it's going to be just fine. I know that because I'm going to write the history. We saw that happen then, and we saw the Soviet Union go through a revision of history regularly if there was some event that they, perhaps, didn't want to have reported as factual. I fear that's what's going on today when it comes to the January 6th riot here in the United States Capitol, particularly by one or two of the witnesses at the table. You are meeting here today, safe, peaceful, because men and women in uniform are risking their lives at this very moment for you and for me. What happened on January 6th to 140 of these men and women in uniform, protecting this Capitol? They were beaten unmercifully by a mob. Several of them died afterwards. That's a fact. And the facts should also be realistic, too. Anyone who wants to characterize that event of January 6th as, quote, ``the riot used to launch the war on wrongthink''--what in the hell is wrongthink? I can't keep up with all these words that are coming at us as brand new terms, and I hope it doesn't hide the fact that 140 policemen and women were here defending this Capitol and faced the wrath of a crowd. But the same person who used the word wrongthink went on to say law enforcement resources were better allocated toward not treating grandmas--not treating grandmas wandering the Capitol grounds, like jihadists. Let me tell you about some of those grandmas that were released by the full and unconditional pardon of Donald Trump. Here's one you should remember: Andrew Taake, re-arrested since he was pardoned by President Trump, in Leon County, Texas, on an outstanding charge of online solicitation of a minor. Taake had been sentenced to more than 6 years in prison for assaulting officers using a dangerous weapon while at the Capitol, having deployed bear spray on Capitol Police Officers--and hit one officer with a metal whip. Grandmas? Here's another grandma: David Daniel, awaiting sentencing after pleading guilty to assaulting police officers on January 6th. His case was dismissed by the Department of Justice after President Trump's pardon. Daniel is facing pending charges in North Carolina for production of child pornography and possession of child pornography which allegedly involved a prepubescent minor and a child under age 12. Peter Schwartz, sentenced to 14 years in prison for assaulting police officers--another grandma--during the attack on the Capitol. Shantelle Holeton, a former girlfriend, has voiced concern for her safety after Schwartz was released without any of the typical restrictions for a violent offender. He was previously charged and convicted for threatening his girlfriend and has been described by prosecutors as, quote, ``one of the most violent and aggressive participants in the January 6, 2021, attack, who has a long history of assaulting police officers and women.'' So, we're going to rewrite history, now? This is grandmas on a tour of the Capitol, on January 6th? Like hell it was. I was there. And some of us were there, as well. The men and women who risked their lives for me I owe a debt of gratitude that I can't even express at this point. That is rewriting history. That is a corruption of speech. We shouldn't allow it to occur. I yield. Chair Schmitt. Thank you, Senator. And now we'll introduce the witnesses. Mollie Ziegler Hemingway is the editor-in-chief of The Federalist, senior journalism fellow at Hillsdale College, and a Fox News contributor. She's a co-author of the national bestseller, ``Justice on Trial: The Kavanaugh Confirmation and the Future of the Supreme Court,'' and author of the bestselling, ``Rigged: How the Media, Big Tech, and the Democrats Seized Our Elections.'' Hemingway is a 2021 recipient of the Bradley Prize, awarded for extraordinary contributions to American scholarship and debate. Welcome, Ms. Hemingway. Jonathan Turley--Professor Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University Law School. Professor Turley is a nationally recognized legal scholar who has written extensively in areas ranging from constitutional law to legal theory to tort law. He has written more than three dozen academic articles that have appeared in a variety of leading law journals such as Cornell, Duke, Georgetown, Harvard, and Northwestern Universities. He's a frequent witness before the House and Senate on constitutional and statutory issues. Mr. Turley is a nationally recognized legal commentator who is also the second-most-cited law professor in the country. He's the author of the book, ``The Indispensable Right: Free Speech in an Age of Rage.'' He received a bachelor's degree from the University of Chicago and a juris doctorate degree from Northwestern University law school. Welcome, Mr. Turley. And then Benjamin Weingarten, investigative journalist and columnist at RealClearInvestigations. He has written extensively on the censorship industrial complex, there, and for other publications, including The Federalist, where he is a senior contributor. Newsweek--he's also a senior contributor at Newsweek and the New York Post. In June 2024, Ben testified before the House Small Business Committee on the Federal Government's support of third-party entities targeting the business models of conservative and independent media. In May 2023, he testified before the House Homeland Security Committee Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations, and Accountability regarding DHS subagency CISA's pivotal role in fostering public-private censorship efforts. Ben frequently appears on national television and radio programs to discuss these and other matters. He is a 2019 recipient of the Fund for American Studies Robert Novak Journalism Fellowship and a 2015 fellow at the Claremont Institute. Ben is a 2010 graduate of Columbia University, where he received his B.A. in economics and political science. Welcome. Senator Welch. I'm just going to preface this that we're both lawyers, but you all make us feel pretty inadequate, I've got to tell you. [Laughter.] Senator Welch. It's impressive credentials. And Dr. Mary Anne Franks, thank you so much for joining us today. You're the Eugene and Barbara Bernard Professor in Intellectual Property, Technology, and Civil Rights at George Washington Law School. You're an expert on First Amendment law, law and technology, criminal law, and family law. J.D. from Harvard Law School, and a doctorate from Oxford University, where you were a Rhodes Scholar, and you're admitted to practice in the U.S., in the Supreme Court, and District of Columbia--many other matters. But I am going to abbreviate my introduction so we can hear your comments. Also--so, thank you so much for being here. Appreciate it. And Gabe Rottman, thank you so much--vice president of policy at Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, and that is a big job these days. You're a practicing attorney with a focus on novel issues at the intersection of press freedom, news gathering, and technology. And I know that in the past, you've served as the Washington director for PEN America, deputy director for the Center for Democracy & Technology's Freedom, Security, & Technology Project, and as a legislative counsel and policy advisor at the American Civil Liberties Union. Joint honors from a B.A. at McGill University in political science and history--my major--and a law degree magna cum laude from Georgetown Law Center, where you were Notes editor of the Georgetown Law Journal. Thank you so much, Mr. Rottman. Chair Schmitt. Okay. It is now the tradition of the Committee to swear in the witnesses. Would you please stand and raise your right hand? [Witnesses are sworn in.] Chair Schmitt. Thank you. And so at this point, then, we'll start over here, and, Ms. Hemingway, each one of you give your opening statements. And, by the way, if you see us moving in and out and coming back and forth, we have to vote, and that is hopefully no sign of disrespect. You know, I hope you don't take it that way. We've got to vote, and then we'll get back here. Thank you. Ms. Hemingway. STATEMENT OF MOLLIE HEMINGWAY, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF, THE FEDERALIST, WASHINGTON, DC Ms. Hemingway. For freedom of speech to mean anything beyond the theoretical, we must actively practice it. President John F. Kennedy said people should be entrusted to confront unpleasant facts, foreign ideas, alien philosophies, and competitive values. He said a Nation afraid to let its people judge truth and falsehood in an open market is a Nation afraid of its people. Unfortunately, the right to free speech has been under worse attack in the last decade than at any other point in our Nation's history. The tentacles of the censorship industrial complex are choking out freedom of expression, debate, and the right to criticize powerful institutions, such as corporate media and the Government. Federal and State governments fund and promote censorship and blacklisting technology. They direct Big Tech companies to censor Americans' speech and debate. Academic institutions, such as Stanford and the University of Texas, are given large grants not to defend free speech but to conduct research on so-called disinformation for use by the censorship regime. Nonprofit think tanks, such as the Aspen Institute, post so-called disinformation seminars to groom journalists to publish pro-censorship propaganda and to suppress important stories, such as the Hunter Biden laptop bombshell. Nonprofit censorship groups, such as the Global Disinformation Index, and for-profit censorship businesses, such as NewsGuard, produce widely used censorship tools and blacklists to favor left-wing media while working to silence media that fight false narratives. Attacking free speech and debate has become a massive industry--much of it Government funded and all of it threatening a free society. My publication, The Federalist, and I, have been targets of the censorship industrial complex. In June 2020, a foreign group with the Orwellian name of The Center for Countering Digital Hate engineered an operation to de-monetize us because we published a critique of corporate media coverage of Black Lives Matter riots. The massive BLM protests were the most expensive of any civil disorder in U.S. history. At $2 billion, or more, in insurance claims, many in the media falsely described the arson, looting, and killings as peaceful or--who can forget--mostly peaceful. In April 2023, a House Subcommittee released a report documenting how Stanford colluded with two governmental entities to pressure social media companies into censoring true information, jokes, satire, political reporting, and analysis, all of which they claimed was disinformation. One post flagged for deletion was Senator Thom Tillis thanking his supporters for propelling him to victory, which they said was inappropriately premature. My colleague, Sean Davis, and I were victims of this censorship scheme, as was The Federalist. One of the censored items was a story about a TV appearance in which I said of the media, they lie, they lie, they lie, and then they lie. Gallop reported in February that my view is held by 70 percent of Americans, who say they don't trust corporate media to report news accurately, fairly, or fully. Blacklists and censorship tools, such as those provided by NewsGuard and the Global Disinformation Index, routinely rate left-wing news outlets that are no threat to the permanent bureaucracy higher than those that challenge prevailing orthodoxies. Companies use their lists to boycott some publications and reward others with advertising. The Washington Post and New York Times routinely receive the highest marks. Those publications won Pulitzers for their role in the Russia collusion hoax. And we have some participants in that hoax here on this Subcommittee. My publication, The Federalist, exposed that hoax through dogged reporting and investigation, as we did with the media's vicious lies against Justice Brett Kavanaugh. We exposed much of the censorship industrial complex, too, even suing the State Department after discovering its role in promoting and marketing censorship tools that are being used against us even as we sit here today. Facing this censorship has been difficult. It would have been easy to fold. But that's exactly what censors want--to make it impossible to report the truth about their lies. They know our voice is so powerful and influential that they can't accomplish their goals unless they shut us down. They will not succeed. We will never stop. The more they try to shut us down, the harder we're going to work to stay open, because it's not about us. It's about whether we will have a civilization where people are allowed to say and think things tyrants don't want us to. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Hemingway appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Welch [presiding]. Thank you, Ms. Hemingway. Professor Franks. STATEMENT OF MARY ANNE FRANKS, EUGENE L. AND BARBARA A. BERNARD PROFESSOR IN INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, TECHNOLOGY, AND CIVIL RIGHTS LAW, THE GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL, WASHINGTON, DC Professor Franks. I'm a constitutional law scholar who has studied and researched on the First Amendment for nearly two decades. I also study the intersection between technology and civil rights, and I've advocated for legal and policy reform to deter online abuse, such as image-based sexual exploitation. And in this work, I've always endeavored to honor the principles of free speech, due process, and equality, and greatly respect and appreciate the Members of Congress, including some of the Members of this Committee, that I've had the opportunity to work with, who've been committed to the same. It's work that often deals with aspects of the First Amendment that are ambiguous or contested. But my testimony today focuses on the aspects that are absolutely clear and foundational. The first is the core principle of the First Amendment, so eloquently expressed by Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson in 1943: ``If there is any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it is that no official, high or petty, can prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, religion, or other matters of opinion or force citizens to confess by word or act their faith therein.'' And to repeat, no official can dictate what Americans can say, think, or believe. The First Amendment constrains the Government from interfering with freedom of speech. That includes the President, Members of Congress, State officials, U.S. attorneys, special Government employees. The First Amendment does not constrain non-governmental actors from making their own choices about what to say, what to hear, what to promote. Indeed, it does the opposite. It protects what Justice Kavanaugh has called the robust spear of individual liberty, the right of private actors, including private universities, NGOs, businesses, to ignore, to criticize, refuse to associate with speech they don't agree with, or think is wrong. The Government also has its own rights of free speech, including the right to prefer certain viewpoints. It's allowed to communicate those preferences through persuasion, encouragement, and even funding. The Government can encourage military enlistment without promoting criticism of the military. It can fund organizations that promote childbirth without also funding organizations that promote abortion. What the Government cannot do is compel private actors to think or to speak a certain way, using coercion or threats. When Government actors speak on their own behalf, that is not censorship. When Government actors promote their own viewpoints, including through persuasion and funding, this is not censorship. When non-government actors ignore, remove, criticize speech, or encourage others to do the same, not censorship. But when the Government purges books, words, concepts that it doesn't like, that is censorship. When the Government threatens people with the loss of employment, lawsuits, violence, jail, or deportation for their speech, that is censorship. When it seeks to force universities, law firms, or businesses to adopt the Government's viewpoint, or when it seeks to punish judges, lawmakers, journalists, religious leaders, teachers, or students--for dissent or for criticism of the Government--that is censorship. The myth of the censorship industrial complex, a conspiracy that is so ludicrous that even the current conservative- dominated Supreme Court has dismissed it out of hand last year, has been used to vilify and harass experts, students, researchers, and nonprofits working on online misinformation, with the express goal of discrediting, de-funding, and dismantling that work. And the disabling of safeguards against foreign and domestic misinformation and media manipulation is a threat to free speech, and to national security. And while there's no evidence to support collusion between the Biden administration and Big Tech, the relationship between the Trump administration and Big Tech is alarmingly intimate. Trump himself owns an influential social media platform and has literally surrounded himself with Big Tech oligarchs--the owners of Meta, Google, and, of course, X, owned by Elon Musk, who spent a quarter of a billion dollars to elect Trump, turned X into a pro-Trump propaganda channel, and was rewarded by being named Trump's special Government employee, where he now enjoys seemingly unlimited powers over the Federal Government-- and over the American people. This administration has, within the span of a few weeks, unleashed the greatest assault on the First Amendment since the Red Scare, while insisting that they are restoring freedom of speech. The censorship industrial complex is a thought-terminating, gaslighting cliche that attempts to portray the most powerful people in the United States as oppressed and silenced. The current President of the United States is ordering lawful residents to be surveilled, kidnapped, and expelled from the country because of their speech. He is attempting to dictate what words people are allowed to use, what educational institutions are allowed to teach, what values businesses are allowed to promote. He is calling for critics and dissenters to be imprisoned and assaulted. He is threatening journalists, students, judges, lawyers, religious leaders, governors--anyone he deems insufficiently loyal and insufficiently obedient. Trump's message could not be clearer: You either say what he wants you to say, or you will be punished. This is an attitude of a king and not a President--a man who has declared himself above the law, including the First Amendment. Senators take an oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic, to defend the Constitution even if, and especially if, the threat to them is coming from inside the White House. And for the sake of the American people and of democracy, I hope, Senators, that you will have the courage to uphold your oath. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Professor Franks appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Welch. Thank you, Professor Franks. Professor Turley. STATEMENT OF JONATHAN TURLEY, J.B. AND MAURICE C. SHAPIRO PROFESSOR OF PUBLIC INTEREST LAW, THE GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY LAW SCHOOL, WASHINGTON, DC Professor Turley. Thank you very much, Chairman Schmitt, Ranking Member Welch, Members of the Subcommittee. It's an honor to appear before you today to discuss free speech and Government censorship. We are at a crossroads, in my view, on free speech. The decisions we make today will resonate for generations. For many years, some of us in the free speech community raised alarm over a growing and unprecedented anti-free speech movement in the United States, including a growing infrastructure for censorship that stretched across agencies, universities, and corporations. A cottage industry of disinformation experts emerged, with millions of dollars funneled to universities and groups to help target or curtail certain viewpoints. This new industry effectively commoditized free speech and, more importantly, monetized censorship. Suddenly, the market was awash with money for those who could offer systems or staff to combat viewpoints deemed misleading or false. The contractors often strove to keep examples of their work out of the public eye. At University of Michigan, James Park marketed the school's program and noted that it could do what many were searching for, by, quote, ``externalizing the difficult responsibility of censorship.'' When some of us raised the system in prior testimony, we were met with dismissals from Members who insisted there was no proof of any coordination with the Government on these efforts. For years, many in Congress opposed every effort to disclose the extent of this cooperation. With the release of the Twitter files and then the Facebook files, that narrative collapsed. Emails showed that Government officials directly targeting individuals or groups for censorship and other forms of speech curtailment. We know a great deal now about that system. We also know that the Biden administration made censorship part of its official mission. If you look at CISA's statement alone, CISA Director Jen Easterly declared, quote, ``The most critical infrastructure is our cognitive infrastructure.'' So, suddenly the cognitive infrastructure became the mission of CISA, and they announced that they would focus on misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation. By the way, malinformation is, quote, ``based on fact but used out of context to mislead, harm, or manipulate.'' That was one of the three categories targeted by the Biden administration, facts that the Government believes is being used in a misleading way. Consider the implications of that and how many governments in history have sought to silence people because they misused facts. And so it's crushingly predictable to see this expansion of the censorship system and the slippery slope that they found themselves on. It was a slippery slope that Meta recently got off. Meta decided to follow X and to restore free speech protections. Many of us were critics of Meta, but they have made some substantial moves to restore free speech. In the meantime, some of these organizations cited earlier have decided that even true stories must be targeted. Stanford's project said, after all, true stories fuel hesitancy, when it came to COVID. The Biden and the Facebook files--they remarked that they were under pressure from the Biden administration to remove negative information and opinions, to take them down, including humorous and satirical content. To their credit, some Democratic Members of Congress have recently changed their position. Representative Ro Khanna read the Twitter files and said that it was a violation of First Amendment principles. As CEO, Jack Dorsey reversed his position and apologized for what Twitter did and said that it did go too far and they yielded to the pressure of the Government. Nick Clegg, from the Facebook company, said that we, quote, ``shouldn't have done it'' and that we felt the pressure of the Biden administration. Even James Baker, former FBI employee and Twitter executive, admitted that there was need to find restraints to keep the Government from exercising this type of pressure. The termination of funding for some of these efforts is an important start. But I want to end by talking about a new emerging threat. I just came back a couple days ago from speaking at The World Forum in Berlin, which is a collection of leaders from around the world. It was a distinctly anti-free speech gathering. The EU is now using the Digital Services Act to--outside its borders--to require censorship, including of American citizens. Congress needs to address that. To put it simply, the anti-free speech movement is going old school. They've lost social media, so they're looking to governments to shut it down. And I encourage you not to remain silent as Americans are pulled into this vortex of the DSA. This is an American crisis, but it can be our greatest American moment, where we speak, regardless of party, with one voice in support of this indispensable right. [The prepared statement of Professor Turley appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Booker. Mr. Chairman, just for the record, when I was here alone, I was getting drunk with power, so I'm glad you've returned---- [Laughter.] Chair Schmitt. Thank you for showing restraint. Senator Booker. I tried. It was hard, sir. It was hard. Chair Schmitt. Put the crown on your head. Senator Booker. I hope I get some credit for that. Chair Schmitt. You do. You do. Mr. Rottman. STATEMENT OF GABE ROTTMAN, VICE PRESIDENT, POLICY, REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR FREEDOM OF THE PRESS, WASHINGTON, DC Mr. Rottman. Thank you. Good afternoon. Thank you to Chairman Schmitt and Ranking Member Welch for inviting me to testify, and thank you to the Members of the Subcommittee and staff. Founded in 1970, the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, where I work, is a nonprofit organization that provides pro bono legal representation, amicus curiae support, and other legal resources to protect First Amendment freedoms and the news-gathering rights of journalists. My understanding is that the impetus for this hearing is concern over a phenomenon that is commonly known as ``jawboning,'' that is usually defined as the Government improperly coercing private speakers to censor themselves or to change the substance of their speech. The primary case recognizing this activity as a First Amendment violation is Bantam Books v. Sullivan, from 1963, which established a crucial protection for the press. There, a State commission with no independent enforcement authority asked booksellers to remove books the commission deemed objectionable from shelves and noted that it would be circulating a list of books to the police and recommending prosecution. The Supreme Court held that this was a prior restraint and warned that free speech is, quote, ``vulnerable to gravely damaging yet barely visible encroachments'' like the, quote, unquote, ``informal censorship'' in that case. The Supreme Court unanimously affirmed the holding of Bantam Books just last term in National Rifle Association v. Vullo, finding allegations that a New York State agency had threatened entities with enforcement action unless they disassociated from the NRA was enough to defeat a motion to dismiss by the State. That said, while the Bantam Books rule is easy to articulate, whether interactions between the Government and private speakers are, in fact, coercive can be complicated. In Murthy v. Missouri, the Reporters Committee filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of neither party. We noted that, while it is essential and possibly existential that news organizations be able to challenge legitimate coercion in court, there are instances where tough conversations between State officials and journalists are helpful. The prime example we offer is national security reporting. There, Government officials, up to and including the President, have told publishers that they will have blood on their hands if they disclose Government secrets. That is likely not jawboning, because the ultimate decision to publish remains with the publisher. However, as has happened, if the State actor threatens prosecution, that is a different story, and likely a Bantam Books violation. The issue of jawboning is helpful in unpacking what we respectfully submit should also be a focus of this hearing. The original sin in Bantam Books isn't just soft censorship through the threat of, take this book off the shelves or else. It is, that the State is attempting to impose its own viewpoint on the bookseller and downstream on public debate. Courts have called that viewpoint discrimination poison in a free society, because it allows the Government to put its thumb on the scale of public discourse to its own benefit. Accordingly, in our written testimony, we highlight three areas of concern regarding viewpoint discrimination beyond jawboning, that we submit should also be within the scope of this hearing. First are recent steps by the Federal Communications Commission that appear to be efforts to interfere in the private editorial choices of news organizations. Most notable is the decision to reopen investigation into the CBS October 24 interview with former Vice President Kamala Harris. That investigation is based on the rarely used news distortion policy, which, if misused, could be deployed as a direct tool of censorship. Because of that danger, the FCC requires a complainant to present substantial evidence, beyond just the broadcast itself, of deliberate distortion. There is zero evidence in that case of deliberate distortion, and it should be immediately dismissed. Second is the use of State consumer protection laws in efforts to police perceived bias by news organizations and other private speakers. President Trump has sued CBS in Texas Federal court, based on that theory. Similarly, in States like New York and California, officials have sought to police First Amendment protected speech, using similar legal tactics and theories. The danger here is that a news organization's editorial standards or a website's content policies are not like the ingredient list on a candy bar. They are inherently subjective. Consumer protection laws are, therefore, a bad and dangerous fit for policing perceived bias, because they allow the Government to impose its view of fairness on private speakers. Finally, we note the Associate Press access dispute at the White House. That is the rare case where a Government actor has been explicit about the viewpoint-based motivation behind retaliatory action. Thank you, again, and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Rottman appears as a submission for the record.] Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Mr. Weingarten. STATEMENT OF BENJAMIN WEINGARTEN, INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALIST AND COLUMNIST, ESSEX FELLS, NEW JERSEY Mr. Weingarten. Chairman Schmitt, Ranking Member Welch, and Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify. Free speech is the bedrock of a free society. Over the last decade, as litigation, congressional oversight, and reportage have exposed, the censorship industrial complex has eroded that bedrock. A President, Members of the Judiciary Committee, witnesses at this very table, and countless fellow Americans have had their core political speech secretly surveilled and targeted for suppression. Millions lost the ability to speak about or hear news and views on critical policy matters, from election integrity to COVID-19. Media and technology companies have come under withering attack. Why? Purportedly because a pandemic of mis-, dis-, and malinformation, MDM, threaten national security, public health, and democracy itself, requiring our betters to intervene, to save us from ourselves. A cynic might surmise that as Americans rebelled against a ruling class on the left and right that they saw as failing them, the rulers chose not to be responsive to their critics, to the people, but rather to silence them, purging unauthorized opinions and inconvenient facts, lest they lose their grip on power. It's no accident that the censorship industrial complex emerged after President Trump's first election, nor that its primary targets have been anti-establishment voices, sources, and the platforms circulating their speech. The most disturbing aspect of the censorship regime, is that the Federal Government was its primary funder and driver, with the Biden administration enacting 57 censorship initiatives across 90 Federal agencies at a cost of several hundred million dollars, according to reports. The second most disturbing aspect of the censorship regime is that the Feds fostered the growth of a network of non- governmental accomplices, using them as cutouts to launder censorship in a conspiracy to skirt the First Amendment. Overwhelming evidence indicates the Feds have deputized academic institutions, think tanks, NGOs, fact checkers, risk raters, and for-profits as plainclothes speech police. This vast censorship enterprise is vertically integrated. Its business is controlling content and the flow of information via exerting influence over traditional and social media. Government sits in the C-suite. Non-governmental operators do much of the dirty work. Disinfo labs, lavished with tens of millions of tax dollars, emerging at universities nationwide, produce the research and make the political and technological recommendations and develop the tools to censor at scale. Powerful think tanks helmed by former national security leaders, and likewise funded with major Federal dollars, augment the academics' efforts. NGOs launch pressure campaigns to crush wrongthinkers. Federally funded fact checkers work with social media companies to algorithmically suppress disfavored media. Risk raters, operating with the Government's imprimatur, create blacklists of such outlets, to starve them of ad revenue. For-profits, too, often fueled by our tax dollars, develop analytics to support industrial-scale censorship. These entities have worked in overlapping and mutually reinforcing ways to control the American mind. In recent years, consortia like the Election Integrity Partnership comprised of academic institutions, like Stanford, and think tanks, like the Atlantic Council, often with pervasive Government ties and Government coordination, pressured social media companies to suppress categories of disfavored content, surveilled hundreds of millions of social media posts for alleged violations of their content moderation terms, and flagged offending items to the platforms that they often suppressed at significant rates, disproportionately silencing conservatives and anti- establishment voices. Schools like the University of Michigan and nonprofits like Meedan have researched and developed AI censorship tools to suppress wrongthink at scale. The National Science Foundation fueled such programs with tens of millions of dollars. Risk raters like NewsGuard and GDI, recipients of Government largesse, have reportedly hobbled disfavored media companies, generally on the right, causing them to lose partners, traffic, and revenue. Federally funded NGOs are collaborating with foreign regulators, including under the European Union's Digital Services Act, to impose alien speech codes on American social media platforms and potentially their American users, under threat of devastating fines. The Trump administration has taken immediate steps to get the Government out of the censorship business. Some key structures have dissolved, restructured, or retrenched, which speaks volumes. But overall, the speech police have neither dropped their arms nor recanted. Their casualties have received no restitution. The motives and means to control the digital public square, to monopolize narrative, to monopolize power, remain. In May 2023, I came before a House Committee with a message. Taxpayer dollars should not be used to silence ourselves. Last June, I came before another House Committee with a corollary. Nor should taxpayer dollars fund those who would silence others by destroying their businesses. Today, I come before this Senate Committee with a final plea. Dismantle the censorship industrial complex now, or it will dismantle our Republic later. Expose the regime to drive merited legal and regulatory action; de-fund it; starve it of support, direct and indirect; deter those who would violate needed laws with crippling penalties; prohibit proxies from receiving any Government- granted privilege or benefit; and erect a strict firewall between the U.S. Government and our body politic. If we allow euphemistic whole-of-society schemes, like the censorship industrial complex, to persist, whereby State and civil society fuse to legitimize weaponization against wrongthinkers, we will be on the road to a social credit system with American characteristics. We owe our forebears and our children nothing less than to do everything in our power to prevent such a dismal and disastrous fate. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Weingarten appears as a submission for the record.] Chair Schmitt. Thank you. And thank you all for being here. Thank you for your time. I want to start with Ms. Hemingway. Your publication, The Federalist, is one of the most targeted, it appears, which I suppose is a bit of a badge of honor. [Poster is displayed and appears as a submission for the record.] Chair Schmitt. But could you just sort of describe how that happened? Like, what was the--when did you first become aware of it? And how did it play out for The Federalist? Ms. Hemingway. One of the things that's very difficult about dealing with the censorship industrial complex--which does exist, is that it's very hard sometimes. The people who are engaged in the censorship are not always very transparent about what they're doing. We did start to see some problems around 2020. Some of it was related, as I mentioned, to our critique of media coverage of the Black Lives Matter riots. That's when we first got an indication that there was an effort to de-monetize us. That was done through a foreign entity with the Orwellian name, the Center for Countering Digital Hate. They conspired with NBC News and Google in that operation. And we were able to push that back. Then, of course, 2020 was also the year where we saw just widespread Government-related censorship for people who criticized the response to the pandemic. It was widely held at that time by elite people that you were not allowed to disagree with certain entities within the Government about how to handle pandemic response. But it just kept getting worse and worse. What The Federalist does is we exist to counter the false narratives promulgated by major media. On the left side of your chart, you see some of those people. So, one of the things that we became most well known for was disputing the Russia collusion hoax. That was the conspiracy theory that Donald Trump had colluded with Russia to steal the 2016 election. That was a very prominent theory. We worked very hard to dispel that hoax, and for that we gained a lot of attention. You will notice that supposedly the least dangerous entities there include The New York Times and The Washington Post, which remain--which remain in that. And, again, the Kavanaugh confirmation. When we pushed back against some of the outlandish and ridiculous claims that did, by the way, arise in some part out of this Committee, that put us at odds with major media, who were pushing some of those outlandish conspiracy theories. It just keeps going. I mean, whatever you're doing, if you're speaking against the orthodoxies of the age, which are frequently false, you're going to be targeted by the censorship complex. Chair Schmitt. Professor Turley, I want to ask you, you mentioned this, and it's starting to get a little bit more attention. You mentioned what's happening in Europe, too. What is--so, there's nothing new about any of this in particular. Right? People who've aggregated power want to exercise it. One of the first things they do is try to take away the ability for people to dissent. What is fueling this, do you think, here in this country and other Western countries, this sort of renewed sense and desire to censor speech? Professor Turley. You know, in my book I talk about basically two anti-free speech movements that are coalescing. One came from Europe. That's now reaching our shores. And free speech is in a freefall in Europe, and many of the free-speech groups there--and I just met with them at the--in Berlin--are on the ropes. And then we have our own anti-free speech movement that really started in higher education and metastasized throughout our system. But Europe has taken, in my view, the most dangerous turn and represents the most dangerous threat now, and that is through the DSA. So, after--after Musk bought Twitter and said that he was going to take down the censorship system, various leaders, including American domestic leaders, called on the EU to use the DSA, which is widely criticized by the free-speech community because of its sweeping terms allowing for the criminalization of speech. But what they were arguing is that the EU could effectively pool U.S. companies to force them to censor, in the United States, citizens on social media. The EU did exactly that. They told Musk that he had to restore censorship systems or he could be hit with confiscatory crimes, even arrested. I have to tell you, just a few days ago in Berlin, that was much the talk of many of the EU people speaking, is that they're calling for what they call a new world order based on European values. Those European values are, in fact, the DSA, according to many of them. Chair Schmitt. Yes. Thank you. Dr. Franks, I did want to ask, you--you yourself, in your writings--I want to ask you about it, to respond, don't seem to be a very big fan of the First Amendment. You've written, and I quote, ``The conception of free speech enshrined in the First Amendment reflects white wealthy men's experiences and interests.'' You've described free-speech advocacy as a, quote, ``neo-Confederate agenda.'' And in 2021, you published an op-ed calling for completely writing the First Amendment. Are those your comments? Professor Franks. Those are not entirely accurate, no. The Boston Globe piece was a thought experiment that I was invited to contribute to, and so I was asked, if we were rethinking the Constitution, what are some of the ways we could rethink it? So, that is the context of that op-ed. Chair Schmitt. Okay. I just--I think it's interesting that of all the people that could've been selected to come testify about the dangers of limiting free speech and censorship, my colleagues on the other side chose someone who believes that the First Amendment is essentially a white male fetish. Thankfully, that is not in the mainstream, and that we believe that the ability to speak your mind, to express yourself, is protected by the First Amendment as a God-given right. The Government doesn't confer that upon anyone. It's our job to protect it. And I think the dangers that we've seen from the Government outsourcing what it can't do itself have been laid out bare, and it's a very dangerous road to go down. And the reason why we're having this hearing is that you have every right to express a point of view that I find abhorrent. I would hope that you would defend my right to do it--to have an opinion that you disagree with. But in the previous administration, if you dared to say that masks were somehow ineffective or that you couldn't, you know, the COVID vaccine didn't actually prevent transmission, all those things were true, but you were de-platformed. You were told, you cannot speak. You cannot engage in dissent. That is a very unAmerican thing, and so that's why we're gathered here today. Senator Welch. Professor Franks. May I respond to the question? Chair Schmitt. Sure. Senator Kennedy. Mr. Chairman---- Professor Franks. Okay---- Senator Kennedy [continuing]. I don't mean--this is your Committee, and I respect it. But a lot of us have other places we could be, and I would respectfully ask if we could stay all within our time--so we can finish up today at a reasonable hour. Chair Schmitt. Sure. That's a reasonable request. Senator Kennedy. Thank you. Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Professor Franks. May I respond to the question? Chair Schmitt. Sure---- Senator Kennedy. I'm going to object. I'd like us to stay within our time. Chair Schmitt. Okay. Thank you. I'm sure you're going to have other questions. Feel free to respond. Senator Welch. Senator Welch. I'll let you answer the question in your time. Professor Franks. Thank you. Senator Welch. My time. Professor Franks. The evidence of my dedication to the First Amendment is the fact that I am here, defending the First Amendment--that I am defending it against a Presidential administration that is, at this moment, threatening journalists, that is surveilling citizens, that is punishing people because of what they say--not some sort of vague allegations about NGOs or about some plainclothes speech police--actual Government forces that this President and his officials are enacting. They want to jail people for their speech. They want to deport people for their speech. They want to take away people's money, their funding, for their speech. That is a violation of the First Amendment. I have plenty of criticisms about the way that the First Amendment has been interpreted. The reason why I distinguish between some of my previous work and the work that I am here to say now is that there are some aspects of the First Amendment that are genuinely contestable and ambiguous. And there are some that are not. The one that is not is that the Government-- the Government and its powers and its forces, its police and its jails, and all of those powers that it actually uses to hurt people, to threaten people, to punish people for their speech, that is what actual censorship is. That is my dedication to the First Amendment. Senator Welch. So, you know, and something like COVID was really contested, in the science. What's the best thing to do? There was a lot of confusion. And my view on that is that we were all trying to figure out how to get it right. And Fauci became a focus, as though he was imposing his point of view. But is there anything contrary to the First Amendment about any of us giving our opinion about whether we should or shouldn't wear a mask, even if it doesn't have a scientific underpinning to it, Dr. Franks? Professor Franks. No. We should be allowed to have those kinds of debates. And again, in reference to the idea that we can vigorously disagree with each other, have positions that we dislike. All of these things are protected by the First Amendment. It is certainly the case that people have very strong feelings about some of these issues. The question is whether or not the Government is allowed to dictate what kinds of things you are allowed to say or not. Senator Welch. Right. Mr. Rottman, I mean, you've got an incredible job, because the press is on the front lines. And, Ms. Hemingway, you know that, as well. What do you see as problematic for the press right now, in the current administration, if anything? Mr. Rottman. Well, so, as I touched on, both in the written testimony and just a few minutes ago, one of the key concepts in First Amendment jurisprudence is this notion that the Government cannot use its vast authority to pick and choose sides in public debate. And the legal term for that is viewpoint discrimination. The various examples that I pointed out in my testimony involve viewpoint discrimination. The AP case at the White House. Right? The White House has said explicitly that it's taking these actions because of the AP's editorial choice to continue to use the term Gulf of Mexico, while acknowledging---- Senator Welch. Let me interrupt for just a second. Mr. Rottman. Please. Senator Welch. That's good. But the Government can have a viewpoint. Mr. Rottman. That's right. Senator Welch. So, obviously President Trump has a significantly different viewpoint than President Biden had. Is there any reservation on their ability to express what their viewpoint is? Mr. Rottman. No. Until it becomes coercive. Until the Government uses its power to try and enforce that viewpoint on others. Senator Welch. Ms. Hemingway, what I understand is you felt there was coercive power that was used to infringe on the work that you do. Is that correct? Ms. Hemingway. Yes, because the censorship industrial complex. It involves government funding at the Federal and State level, working with NGOs, whether they're for profit or not. Senator Welch. This would be helpful to me. The industrial censorship complex is an abstract term. It doesn't mean a lot to me. It conveys a lot of meaning, obviously, to many people here. But it has to get down to something very concrete as to what the Government did. If it's an NGO, your view--I think the Chairman's view, too--is that that NGO is hand in glove with the Government. Ms. Hemingway. So, the Government will work in partnership with NGOs on something like the Election Integrity Partnership, where they flag items for removal from social media companies. Senator Welch. No, I---- Ms. Hemingway. And so they are funding these NGOs. Sometimes they're actually flagging for the NGOs. The for- profit Big Tech companies will then remove the content. Senator Welch. Let me interrupt, because I want--I'm being monitored, here, by the timekeeper, Senator Kennedy. But this is just an observation. I'm part of the Democratic party. You give us way too much credit for being that organized, to be able to put this whole massive enterprise together. I don't know how it works in Chicago, but we have---- Ms. Hemingway. In part because you can rely on the censorship industrial complex to do the work for you. Senator Welch. All right. Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Senator Welch. I yield back. Chair Schmitt. Thank you. Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I apologize for having to miss the testimony of some of you. And I appreciate you coming today. Professor Franks, let me ask--I listened to your and Ms. Hemingway's testimony and Professor Turley's, so I got part of it. As I understand it, your position, Professor Franks, is that--I think you used the word myth--it is a myth that the Biden administration used Government to compel speech, private speech, but that the Trump administration is doing that. Is that a fair characterization? Professor Franks. Yes, that's correct. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Do you think perhaps you're allowing your personal political beliefs to affect your objectivity here? Professor Franks. No, I do not. What is guiding my answers here is that I'm looking to see what the Supreme Court has said. You notice that in the testimony about the censorship---- Senator Kennedy. Okay. Professor Franks [continuing]. Industrial complex---- Senator Kennedy. I got that part. Professor Franks. Yes, I'm just---- Senator Kennedy. I got that part. Professor Franks. But I just want to clarify. Senator Kennedy. No, but I've only got 5 minutes. Your answer's no. I appreciate it. Let me ask you a couple questions. You wrote a law review article in December of 2023 for the New York University Law Review, and you--it was about the two cases--Bruen, Supreme Court case, and Dobbs. Remember that article? Professor Franks. Yes, I do. Senator Kennedy. Okay. In this article, you said, I'm going to quote your words, ``Taken together, these two cases demonstrate that the Supreme Court has embraced the use of the Constitution as a tool of racial patriarchy,'' end quote. Did you say that? Professor Franks. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Okay. And then you went on to say, quote, ``When the Supreme Court declares that there is a constitutional right to armed self-defense in public, it openly embraces and promotes a culture that privileges white men's ability to terrorize and kill those that they perceive as threats,'' closed quote. Did I read that correctly? Professor Franks. I believe so. Thank you for reading it. Senator Kennedy. Okay. And did you also say in that article--I'm going to quote, again, quote, ``By simultaneously expanding white men's right to kill and constricting women's right not to die, this Supreme Court''--referring to the current United States Supreme Court--``has turned the Constitution into a homicide pact, as well,'' closed quote. Did you write that? Professor Franks. That sounds like me. Senator Kennedy. Okay. In November of 2024--you tweet, don't you? Professor Franks. I'm not sure what the current terminology is for it, but, yes, I am sometimes on the social platform that was formerly known as Twitter. Senator Kennedy. Yes. You're on a lot. Aren't you? Professor Franks. I'm not sure what the relevance of that is. Senator Kennedy. You try to be provocative on there. Don't you? Professor Franks. Again, I am not sure what the relevance of this---- Senator Kennedy. Well, let me---- Professor Franks [continuing]. Question is. Senator Kennedy. Let me show you the relevance. On November 7, 2024, from your tweet--here's one of your tweets, at 2:41 p.m., quote, ``The majority of Americans hate women. The majority of Americans hate women more than they love anything, including democracy,'' closed quote. Did I read that correctly? Professor Franks. I am not sure what this has to do with the subject matter of this hearing. Senator Kennedy. Did you say it? Professor Franks. I do not have those words in front of me. I probably said something along those lines, but what is---- Senator Kennedy. Yes, you said it. Professor Franks [continuing]. The relevance of that to this hearing? Senator Kennedy. Here it is, big as Dallas. Right there. Professor Franks. Yes. Senator Kennedy. But your political beliefs don't impact your feelings about President Biden or President Trump? Professor Franks. I don't have feelings about either of them. What I have is doctrine. Senator Kennedy. Sounds to me like you have--your favorite feeling is anger. Let me ask you this. You issued another tweet. This was in May of 2022. You've just been tweeting up a storm. You said, quote, ``There's a reason why the conservative-dominated Supreme Court thinks the Constitution did not cont--does not contain a right to an abortion but is convinced that it contains an individual right to possess firearms. And that reason is white male supremacy,'' closed quote. Did I read that correctly? Professor Franks. Is there a question in this---- Senator Kennedy. Did I read that correctly? That's my question. Professor Franks [continuing]. Is there a question that is relevant to this hearing---- Senator Kennedy. Did I read that correctly? Do you really think that the United States Supreme Court--you're an officer of the court--is guided by white male supremacy? Professor Franks. I believe that the First Amendment prohibits the President---- Senator Kennedy. Did you---- Professor Franks [continuing]. And other State---- Senator Kennedy. Did you say that? Professor Franks [continuing]. Officials from punishing people for their speech. Senator Kennedy. Did you honestly say that, Professor? Professor Franks. I believe---- Senator Kennedy. And you expect us---- Professor Franks [continuing]. That the First Amendment---- Senator Kennedy [continuing]. As a Democratic witness, to take you seriously? Are you kidding me? Professor Franks. I believe that you should take the---- Senator Kennedy. You heard of---- Professor Franks [continuing]. First Amendment seriously, sir. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. Curb your enthusiasm? Here's my saying, curb my nausea. Professor Franks. I believe---- Chair Schmitt. Thank you. The time---- Professor Franks [continuing]. That you should take the First Amendment---- Chair Schmitt. Time is expired. Thank you. Professor Franks [continuing]. Seriously. Chair Schmitt. Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Mr. Weingarten, do you think the January 6th riot at the Capitol was protected free speech? Mr. Weingarten. I think to the extent there was peaceful protest, that's free speech. And when it bleeds into violence, to action, that's when it certainly crosses a line. Senator Durbin. So, you believe that some of the individuals who received full and unconditional pardons by the President of the United States in fact crossed the line and were guilty of criminal conduct? Mr. Weingarten. This is beyond the scope of what I prepared to discuss today. But in my personal opinion as a non-lawyer, yes, I believe some people committed crimes. Senator Durbin. Well, they certainly did. A hundred and forty policemen were assaulted by these rioters. I'm on the policemen's side. I hope you are, too. Mr. Weingarten. I am. Senator Durbin. Well, a full and unconditional pardon to some of these folks is incredible. Jake Lang, charged with assaulting police during January 6th. Now he plans to run for Senate in Florida. He's pretty emboldened by that pardon. Isn't he? You don't have to answer that question. Let me ask you what the word ``wrongthink'' means. Did you make that up? Mr. Weingarten. If I did make it up, I'd be happy to take credit for it, and my definition of it would be speech that flouts the orthodoxy of our political establishment and cultural elites. Senator Durbin. Interesting. I'll put that in my research bag, to look at a little later. But you said whole-of-society war. I don't know what that means. Can you define that? Mr. Weingarten. Well, whole-of-society is actually a phrase that the Biden administration used in any number of documents that could be relevant to---- Senator Durbin. I missed it. What does it mean? Mr. Weingarten [continuing]. Whole-of-society means Government working hand in hand with civil society to achieve some sort of outcome, as I understand it. Senator Durbin. Do you think that's inherently wrong or insidious? Mr. Weingarten. I think on its face it's potentially chilling, when you have Government and civil society working hand in glove, because that blurring of the line between civil society and the state can cross into potentially draconian methods and outcomes. Senator Durbin. Do you think President George W. Bush was guilty of that, when he mobilized America against the events of 9/11? Mr. Weingarten. Senator, in the context of this hearing, my view of it is that when Government works hand in glove with civil society to purge disfavored speech, that certainly crosses the line, and it's significantly different, in my view, from mobilizing support for a war effort. Senator Durbin. Very subjective. Dr. Franks, I'm going to let you finish the answer to this question. I think this attack on law firms for representing unpopular clients--unpopular with this administration--is one of the most dangerous developments I've seen in the violation of basic free speech. I think--come to mind immediately, John Adams. What would've happened to poor John Adams representing those British soldiers, if the incumbent President decided to punish him for that? What do you think about the future of legal representation, as these law firms, at least one of them, has reached an agreement, settlement with the Trump administration? Professor Franks. I very much share your alarm about those actions, because as you mentioned, access to the courts is a very key principle of our freedoms. And to threaten law firms, to threaten law firms that are trying to do what all of us should rely on, which is to defend people's rights in courts, is extremely chilling. And it is one of those ways where we're seeing just really a comprehensive assault by this administration, not only directly to try to round up people, surveil them, deport them for their speech. But also to try to disable the levers that they can defend themselves with and to punish businesses for acting on their own principles. Senator Durbin. Mr. Rottman, not much subtlety in saying to the Associated Press, if you use the term Gulf of Mexico, you're not welcome in the White House. Is there? Mr. Rottman. It is explicit viewpoint discrimination that underpins retaliatory actions by the White House, and that makes it a First Amendment violation. Senator Durbin. And deportation of individuals for making statements, political statements? Where would you characterize that? Mr. Rottman. So, the authority that's been invoked, you know, so, I come at it from the freedom of the press perspective. But what's notable about some of those cases is they're relying on a statute that explicitly allows immigration enforcement actions based on the speech of the person the action's being taken against. And that's of great concern for the press. Senator Durbin. Thank you very much to all of you, and I hope that you'll say thank you to the men and women of the Capitol Police when you leave, for keeping you safe today, as they did in my situation of January 6th with the rioters. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chair Schmitt. Thank you, Senator. Senator Blackburn. Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to each of you for taking your time to be here today. Dr. Franks, we're here to talk about free speech. Correct? Professor Franks. Yes. Senator Blackburn. And we're here to talk about that being a fundamental right guaranteed by the Constitution. Correct? Professor Franks. Yes. Senator Blackburn. Okay. And the Supreme Court plays an essential role in guaranteeing those constitutional rights. Correct? Professor Franks. Yes. Senator Blackburn. Okay. Now, I want to talk to you about a tweet that you had in January 2024, ``The Supreme Court is a death panel.'' Is that your opinion? Professor Franks. In the context of this hearing, I think it is important to emphasize why I'm here, which is to talk about my views on the First Amendment. My understanding---- Senator Blackburn. No, no, no, no, no. Professor Franks [continuing]. Of the doctrine. Senator Blackburn. That's not what I asked you. Do you think the Supreme Court is a death panel---- Professor Franks. In the context of the cases that---- Senator Blackburn [continuing]. For free speech? Professor Franks. Not for free speech, no. That was not the context of that particular communication. Senator Blackburn. Oh, my goodness. Okay. Well, it appears that you see the Supreme Court as a death panel. And that is some of the same rhetoric that unfortunately we continue to hear from some on the left who are trying to villainize Justices who are doing their job. And I would like to just ask you, knowing that you have put this out, that the Supreme Court is a death panel, then let me ask you this. Do you look at Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, Jackson as members of the death panel? Or, is this just the Justices that you disagree with? Professor Franks. I do not believe that the comments that you are referring to have relevance for this particular hearing. But here's what I will say. This is an administration that is threatening judges, in addition to other people that he disagrees with. So---- Senator Blackburn. Okay. I'm---- Professor Franks [continuing]. Yes, if your question is, do I defend judges--do I---- Senator Blackburn. I'm ready to move on. Professor Franks. Am I worried about---- Senator Blackburn. Thank you. Professor Franks [continuing]. Judges' security? I am. Senator Blackburn. Ms. Hemingway, I would like---- Professor Franks. I am worried---- Senator Blackburn [continuing]. To come to you. Professor Franks [continuing]. About this administration essentially---- Senator Blackburn. I---- Professor Franks [continuing]. Threatening those judges. Senator Blackburn [continuing]. Want to talk with you, Ms. Hemingway, about the State Department's use of the Global Engagement Center to censor news outlets like The Daily Wire and The Federalist. I know that this is something that you have had to deal with. And Daily Wire is located in Tennessee. We're proud of them. We are delighted that they chose to move from California over to Tennessee. And it is my understanding that the Global Engagement Center was created to counter messaging from bad actors, including terrorist groups. But the Biden administration weaponized it to silence conservative groups. And what has the censorship--I call it the censorship industrial complex--what do you think they're trying to hide, when it targets outlets like The Federalist and The Daily Wire? Ms. Hemingway. Thank you, Senator Blackburn. Yes, our reporter Margot Cleveland, who's our senior legal writer, uncovered through her reporting facets of the censorship industrial complex and learned that the State Department was one of the Federal entities that was engaging with non- governmental organizations and other entities in Big Tech to market, promote censorship tools and blacklists which were then used against my publication, The Federalist, and also The Daily Wire. Publications that are a threat to the reigning orthodoxies are targeted by the censorship industrial complex. They want to exist without people pointing out their lies or the fact that they're really important debates. And so, we are suing the State Department for that. And it is ongoing, this support of the censorship industrial complex. It is the bureaucracy, really, which perpetuates this even more than a particular administration. Senator Blackburn. Yes. And I think it's so important to note that robust, respectful, bipartisan debate adds to our freedom, helps to keep us free, and allows that debate in the public square. And when you have an entity that becomes weaponized and shuts down one side of that speech and only allows speech with which it completely agrees, that that is when you have that censorship writ large. My time's expired. Professor Turley, I have a question I will submit to you for the record. Thank you all for joining us. Senator Lee [presiding]. Thank you for being with us today. I'd like to start with you, Ms. Hemingway. Is the suppression of dissenting viewpoints under the broad banner, the auspices of fighting disinformation, is that something that, in your view, is eroding public trust in the media and in Big Tech? Ms. Hemingway. It's interesting that so much of the censorship took place in the context of how to respond to the global pandemic, because the idea was they'll suppress different ideas about how to respond, and therefore everyone will agree with public health officials or the corporate media. Studies indicate that, in fact, the opposite happened. Trust in public health officials who were protected from any criticism or any pushback has plummeted, and of course trust in corporate media almost could not be lower. Senator Lee. Didn't end up quite the way they wanted it to. Did it? Have any Big Tech companies or Big Tech CEOs funded any anti-free speech NGOs, that you're aware of? Ms. Hemingway. Well, the industry is massive and works together, and so they fund each other constantly, including purchasing blacklisting tools from NGOs that may have, themselves, been started by Federal agencies, and that's what keeps them going. And it's this public-private partnership which is what makes it so disconcerting. It's not just private entities trying to destroy my publication. Senator Lee. Right. Ms. Hemingway. It's that they were funded by the Government and assisted with other government---- Senator Lee. The combination of them, the alliance that turns it into one gigantic self-licking ice cream cone of sorts. Are you familiar with a group called the Center for Tech and Civic Life? Ms. Hemingway. I am. Senator Lee. This is an entity that, of course, hosted election misinformation ceremonies--seminars, rather--as recently as last July. Do you know who funded that entity? Ms. Hemingway. Yes, it was interesting, because someone was talking about Big Tech support for the Trump administration. But the most impressive Big Tech support ever was under the Center for Tech and Civic Life and the Center for Election Innovation & Research--both entities funded by Mark Zuckerberg to the tune of $430 million in the 2020 election. And they were engaged in election interference activities. The private takeover of government election offices in the blue areas of swing States was really important and really influential, and then also they were part of the effort to suppress any discussion about elections. Elections are the most--or, one of, the most important things that people should have free and open debate about, because if we don't have trust in our elections, if we don't have good elections, we don't have self-government. And so it's very important that that not be censored, as well. Senator Lee. Right. Yes, it's interesting. So, you would say that the Big Tech giants were active participants in what we're referring to as the censorship industrial complex, that's suppressed the free speech of American citizens, in many cases. Ms. Hemingway. Most notably, I would also point out in the 2020 election when the Hunter Biden laptop was under discussion, it was published by The New York Post, there had been massive NGO participation in preparing journalists to say that if a story like that came out, that they would suppress it. And they did. You saw many media outlets like NPR say, we're not going to cover this story. You saw Big Tech giants say, we're not going to allow you to discuss this story even in your private messages. That happened on Facebook, and it happened on Twitter. You even had the Press Secretary of the United States not being allowed to post information about an inarguably important story--whether the Biden family business involved taking money from corrupt oligarchs in exchange for access to people in power. There's no debate about whether that was an important story, and yet it was violently suppressed from the landscape. Senator Lee. Right. And you don't have that sort of thing happen without malice aforethought or at least without a lot of advance preparation. You even had people coming to the Senate, asking to brief Members of the Senate in a secured--in a secured, classified information facility, telling us that something was about to come out about a family member of a Presidential candidate and that we should not discuss it because it would be untrue. And I asked them, how is it that we're supposed to know what it is that's not true, if we don't know what the thing is? They didn't have a good answer for that. Mr. Weingarten, you described Mark Zuckerberg as, quote, ``one of the individuals most responsible for the censorship industrial complex.'' And you said this, I believe, in January. Can you elaborate on what that means? Mr. Weingarten. Well, I think to the point of your exchange, Senator, he is someone and he represents an organization that served as, essentially, a witting tool of Government pressure to suppress wrongthink. They also funded and incorporated the fact checkers who allowed them to outsource what amounted to subjective censorship decisions. And I think we've seen a mea culpa now, and it would've been useful had Mr. Zuckerberg interceded in the Supreme Court case where this very conduct was at issue. Senator Lee. Right. So, in light of that, can Big Tech really be trusted to dismantle the censorship industrial complex, in light of the fact that they built it? Mr. Weingarten. Big Tech will do what it perceives to be in its interests. Senator Lee. As any organism might do. Professor Turley, to what extent should Government-funded institutions and Government-funded nonprofit organizations be involved in defining and combating misinformation and disinformation? Professor Turley. I would put that near, if not at, zero. The, you know, one of the things I mention in the book is that many of the terms we use today actually were used at the beginning of the Republic, when the First Amendment was designed. These are not new arguments. You know, free speech is something that's easier to behold at a distance. But when you ask people--you talk about the McCarthy period, and they're horrified. But then you say, well, how about the censoring, blacklisting, throttling today? And they go, oh, well, that's different. We have to fight disinformation. These are the same voices. They've been with us for ages. They're making the same arguments. Everyone uses as an excuse that this is why I should be able to silence my neighbors. And it costs, not just politically. When you talk about COVID, you know, I spoke at University of Chicago, and most of the people that signed the Great Barrington statement were there. And I asked many of these scientists, who've been vindicated in many of their views, how many of you've been restored to your positions? How many of you that were fired were invited back? Zero. And the point I'm only raising is, when we talk about the cost of free speech, we never had that debate during COVID--not a robust debate of the masks, the six-foot rule, natural immunities. That's the cost of free speech. It has a direct impact on American citizens. Senator Lee. Mr. Chairman, if I can do a quick follow-up question on this. That creates a good picture of the grave risks involved, concerning the long-term consequences of allowing and even encouraging increased collaboration between Government entities, Big Tech firms, and academic institutions, insofar as they can do what Ms. Hemingway described a moment ago, of creating kind of a collusive understanding, an agreement in advance--we're all going to agree that this is the truth. Right? What are the long-term consequences of that happening, that kind of collusion between things like academic institutions, Government entities and Government-funded entities, and Big Tech firms? Professor Turley. Yes. That's something that I think really has to be kept in mind. We've had anti-free speech movements in our history. We've never seen anything like this one. We've never seen a coalition of corporations, academia, the media, the Government join together in this way. And it succeeded to an extent that I find truly chilling. And they've had a setback. They've lost X. Apparently Meta is stepping back from some of its censorship. And so they're going old school. They're turning to the EU. They're turning to countries like Brazil to start to use government power. And this fight is just beginning. And that's the reason I talk about The World Forum in Berlin. That was one of the most anti- free speech gatherings I have ever been at. There were two of us, both American, from the free-speech community. And so this fight is just beginning. Senator Lee. Thank you so much. And it's especially heartening to hear you describe what I think a lot of Americans totally understand, which is, stuff goes back to the 1790s. It's not as though--it's not as though modern technology has presented us with purely unique sui generis questions. There are some challenges that come up. But the fundamental question of the Government's ability to censor, those legal issues haven't changed. There's nothing about the technology that obliterates or creates a carveout from the First Amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Schmitt [presiding]. Thank you. And I suppose in the irony of all ironies, I just voted ``yes'' to confirm Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, who was a plaintiff in the Missouri v. Biden lawsuit that I filed because he had been censored because of his views related to COVID. So, I guess you can't make this stuff up. Senator Lee. Who was the attorney general leading that? [Laughter.] Chair Schmitt. Yes. His name was Eric Schmitt. My glory days, I suppose. We're--Senator Hawley, I think, had some questions. So, I'm just going to fill in the gap here by, Mr. Weingarten, just ask you, the way you've sort of investigated this, you've seen how these pieces come together. And I'll be honest with you. Whenever we filed the lawsuit, it was before--it was in May of 2022. It was before Elon Musk had bought Twitter. It was before the Twitter files. Before Jim Jordan's investigative hearings. This was referred to as a conspiracy theory. But the 20,000 pages of evidence suggested otherwise. And the idea that, and I appreciate, Mr. Rottman, your testimony, but the truth is, they were threatening. This wasn't just, hey, we have a point of view about the story. They were threatening investigations. They were threatening to revoke Section 230 protections. They meant business, and they made it very clear that they did. So, as you see all these things come together, the one thing that--the reason why we're having this hearing is the NGO network that's sort of the newest element of all this--Stanford, University of Washington were involved in helping flag posts. What would be, prescribing something for Congress to do? What would be the thing to do to disrupt this-- this epicenter of the complex? Mr. Weingarten. Well, I think point one is, the Government should not be in the business of silencing us directly or by proxy, whether a court defines it as coercive or mere persuasion. And to your point, of course, when the Government comes to you, it comes to you with the Government gun, essentially. The Government is force. It is power, even though it can do many positive things, too. So, there's an implicit threat. And, of course, when you're talking about a regulated industry, like the tech industry. So, the starting point is, and one question that I could ask, and it's somewhat rhetorical, is, would this whole ecosystem on the outside have been birthed, had there not been Government fueling it? Would it have been birthed had Donald Trump not been elected in 2016? I think the thing speaks for itself. And so, in terms of a policy prescription, the first thing is, starve it of the Government funding, direction, and coordination. And while some of these entities, like the Election Integrity Partnership that you helped expose, may have gone by the wayside or retrenched, the archetype is there. Europe, under the DSA, I think, is putting that precise model on steroids. It's a backdoor way to potentially censor us. Also-- and the last point I'll make is, because Murthy v. Missouri and Missouri v. Biden has been referenced many times, there's been a narrative that the Supreme Court ruled there was no there, there. And that is not actually what---- Chair Schmitt. That is not true. Mr. Weingarten [continuing]. The Supreme Court---- Chair Schmitt. There was a standing issue---- Mr. Weingarten. The Supreme Court did not rule on the merits. In fact, they explicitly said they didn't rule on the merits, put it in a footnote in the majority opinion. And Justice Alito said that the Supreme Court shirked its duty and that a model was created that could potentially be abused, down the road, and it was a shame the Supreme Court didn't grapple with the merits of the case. Chair Schmitt. Senator Hawley. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. That's a nice title for you to have. Chair Schmitt. Yes. Senator Hawley. Yes. It's good to be on this Committee with you. Thanks for convening this hearing. Let's take a look here at something that Facebook, Meta, whatever--something that they've said, Mark Zuckerberg, in particular, said, it was reported. [Poster is displayed.] Senator Hawley. ``In 2021, senior officials from the Biden administration, including the White House, repeatedly pressured our''--this is Zuckerberg speaking--``pressured our teams for months to censor certain COVID-19 content, including humor and satire, and expressed a lot of frustration with our teams when we didn't agree. Ultimately, it was our decision whether or not to take the content down.'' Now, the point that I want to get at, and maybe I'll start with you, Ms. Hemingway, because you and your outlet were a target of a lot of this and were censored left, right, center. You personally were censored. Don't you think that Facebook needs to be held accountable for their role in all of this? I mean, so Facebook, Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg says, oh, you know, gosh, they were so mean to us, the Biden people. They threatened us. And they did--Biden did. Was that unconstitutional? I think it was. This is why that Supreme Court case that we've been talking about today, the Missouri case, is so, so significant. But isn't it also true that, as Zuckerberg himself says in this statement, it was their decision? They owned it. And, truthfully, Facebook and others have a pattern of censoring long before this. The Hunter Biden laptop story they gleefully, willfully censored on their own. They have been avid participants in this censorship campaign. Would you agree with that, Ms. Hemingway? Ms. Hemingway. Yes. Mark Zuckerberg, who spent nearly four hundred--$450 million in the 2020 election to control the outcome there, has recently done a few little things, like saying, oh, I was sort of pressured to do this censorship. Or, oh, I'll give a million dollars to the Inauguration Committee. As if this in any way makes up for the campaign of censorship that he was engaged in, which was probably valued even more than the money he gave to the election, to censor and silence voices, like mine and my publication, because we said things on all sorts of topics that were at odds with what he wanted, whether that's the radical trans agenda, how elections should be run, how to respond to the COVID pandemic--all sorts of topics where, in a free society, you should have free and open debate. And he worked very hard to keep that from happening. So, I find these statements kind of interesting. But they nowhere near deal with the agency that he had on this and how much power he has as the head of Facebook. Senator Hawley. Yes. I'm glad you just used the word power, because that's a big part of the story. Isn't it? Companies like Facebook, Meta have enormous structural power that Mark Zuckerberg has spent--to your point, he has spent billions of dollars amassing. He has worked to destroy competitors who might break that power up, challenge that power in any way. He has used that power to stifle competition. He's used it to stifle views he doesn't like. This is a textbook example of what happens when a monopoly that has a political agenda--in this case, a very hard-edged political agenda, for years--when they use that monopoly in order to try to control other competitors and also to try to control the information that flows to the American people. Do I have that right, you think? Ms. Hemingway. Yes, and the political system itself, which had--had--had previously been so supportive of him and the work that he did to silence. Again, not just in the election sphere but those journalistic voices that were countering his preferred policy objectives. Senator Hawley. That's just terrific, and you are perfectly placed to talk about that and to bring this to light. I think it's so vital that we don't lose sight of the role that these massive companies--and there's just a few of them. I mean, it's Google, it's Meta--the control that they have amassed and that they have used to try and dictate, frankly, what Americans can see. And we know in the case of Google. We've had testimony in this Committee and Subcommittees before--Google has rigged their search results to try and influence independent voters and try to sway elections, for years, and not just in this country. They've done it in other countries. They've done it in Australia. These are massive monopoly corporations that have political agendas that have been using their market power to try and influence--actually, that's not strong enough--to try and control outcomes in our political system. That is a problem. And I would just submit until we deal with their power, this problem is going to persist. Thank you all for being here. Mr. Chairman, thank you for having this great hearing. Chair Schmitt. Thank you. And that will conclude the hearing. I want to thank the witnesses for being here. Thanks for your testimony. Thank you, all. [Whereupon, at 3:45 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [Additional material submitted for the record follows.] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] A P P E N D I X The following submissions are available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg61838/pdf/CHRG- 119shrg 61838-add1.pdf Submitted by Chair Schmitt: ``The Censorship Industrial Complex,'' poster displayed during hearing....................................................... 2 ``Global Disinformation Index: country report, U.S. news outlets lowest and highest in disinformation, according to GDI,'' poster displayed during hearing............................... 3 Submitted by Ranking Member Welch: ``Most Transparent Administration in History,'' poster displayed during hearing................................................ 4 ``Trump's Illegal Actions,'' poster displayed during hearing..... 5 [all]