Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] A MIDLIFE CRISIS? IP AND THE INTERNET AFTER 40 ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON COURTS, INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, AND THE INTERNET OF THE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ TUESDAY, JUNE 30, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-75 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via: http://judiciary.house.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 64-158 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY JIM JORDAN, Ohio, Chair DARRELL ISSA, California JAMIE RASKIN, Maryland, Ranking ANDY BIGGS, Arizona Member TOM McCLINTOCK, California JERROLD NADLER, New York THOMAS P. TIFFANY, Wisconsin ZOE LOFGREN, California THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky STEVE COHEN, Tennessee CHIP ROY, Texas HENRY C. ``HANK'' JOHNSON, Jr., SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin Georgia BEN CLINE, Virginia TED LIEU, California LANCE GOODEN, Texas PRAMILA JAYAPAL, Washington JEFFERSON VAN DREW, New Jersey J. LUIS CORREA, California TROY E. NEHLS, Texas MARY GAY SCANLON, Pennsylvania BARRY MOORE, Alabama JOE NEGUSE, Colorado HARRIET M. HAGEMAN, Wyoming LUCY McBATH, Georgia LAUREL M. LEE, Florida DEBORAH K. ROSS, North Carolina WESLEY HUNT, Texas BECCA BALINT, Vermont RUSSELL FRY, South Carolina JESUS G. ``CHUY'' GARCIA, Illinois KEVIN KILEY, California SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JARED MOSKOWITZ, Florida BRAD KNOTT, North Carolina DANIEL S. GOLDMAN, New York MARK HARRIS, North Carolina JASMINE CROCKETT, Texas ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri SUMMER LEE, Pennsylvania DEREK SCHMIDT, Kansas BRANDON GILL, Texas MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON COURTS, INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, AND THE INTERNET DARRELL ISSA, California, Chair THOMAS MASSIE, Kentucky HENRY C. ``HANK'' JOHNSON, Jr., SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin Georgia, Ranking Member BEN CLINE, Virginia ZOE LOFGREN, California LANCE GOODEN, Texas TED LIEU, California LAUREL LEE, Florida JOE NEGUSE, Colorado RUSSELL FRY, South Carolina DEBORAH ROSS, North Carolina KEVIN KILEY, California SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington Vacancy CHRISTOPHER HIXON, Majority Staff Director ARTHUR EWENCZYK, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Tuesday, June 30, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Page The Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California.......................... 1 The Honorable Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr., Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of Georgia....... 4 The Honorable Jim Jordan, Chair of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of Ohio......................................... 5 The Honorable Jamie Raskin, Ranking Member of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of Maryland....................... 5 WITNESSES Sean Astin, President, Screen Actors Guild--American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) Oral Testimony................................................. 9 Prepared Testimony............................................. 11 Chris Floyd, Counsel, Amblin Entertainment Oral Testimony................................................. 14 Prepared Testimony............................................. 16 Steve K. Francis, Executive Chair, IP House Oral Testimony................................................. 20 Prepared Testimony............................................. 22 Christopher A. Mohr, President, Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA) Oral Testimony................................................. 31 Prepared Testimony............................................. 33 Bhamati Viswanathan, Visiting Assistant Professor, Suffolk University Law School Oral Testimony................................................. 51 Prepared Testimony............................................. 53 LETTERS, STATEMENTS, ETC. SUBMITTED FOR THE HEARING All materials submitted for the record by the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet are listed below...................................... 79 Materials submitted by the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, for the record A letter to the Honorable Chuck Grassley and the Honorable Dick Durbin, from the Entertainment Software Association, Jun. 9, 2026 An Appeal Case, Vetter Communications Corporation v. Resnik Music Group, United States District Court, Middle District of Louisiana, United States Court of Appeals Fifth Circuit, Jan. 12, 2026 A statement from the Motion Picture Association, Inc., Jun. 30, 2026, submitted by the Honorable Sydney Kamlager-Dove, a Member of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, for the record A letter to the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, and submitted by the Honorable Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr., Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of Georgia, from Frank Cullen, Executive Director of Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP), Jun. 29, 2026, submitted by the Honorable Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr., Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of Georgia, for the record APPENDIX Materials submitted by the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, for the record A letter to the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, and submitted by the Honorable Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr., Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of Georgia, from Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP), June 29, 2026 An article entitled, ``In Graphic Detail: New data shows publishers face growing AI bot, third-party scraper activity,'' Apr. 13, 2026, Digiday A letter to the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, and submitted by the Honorable Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr., Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of Georgia, from Stanley Pierre-Louis, President & CEO, Entertainment Software Association, Jun. 29, 2026 A letter to the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, and the Honorable Jerrold Nadler, a Member of the Committee on the Judiciary from the State of New York, from several manufacturers, businesses, and other organizations A report entitled, ``Unboxing Fake Fashion Unleashing Real Dangers,'' Feb. 2026, American Apparel & Footwear Association QUESTIONS AND RESPONSES FOR THE RECORD Questions submitted by the Honorable Darrell Issa, Chair of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet from the State of California, for the record Questions for Sean Astin, President, Screen Actors Guild-- American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG- AFTRA) Response to question from Sean Astin, President, Screen Actors Guild--American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) Questions for Chris Floyd, Counsel, Amblin Entertainment Response to question from Chris Floyd, Counsel, Amblin Entertainment Questions for Steve K. Francis, Executive Chair, IP House Response to question from Steve K. Francis, Executive Chair, IP House Questions for Christopher A. Mohr, President, Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA) Response to question from Christopher A. Mohr, President, Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA) Questions for Bhamati Viswanathan, Visiting Assistant Professor, Suffolk University Law School Response to question from Bhamati Viswanathan, Visiting Assistant Professor, Suffolk University Law School A MIDLIFE CRISIS? IP AND THE INTERNET AFTER 40 ---------- Tuesday, June 30, 2026 House of Representatives Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, and Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet Committee on the Judiciary Washington, DC The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10 a.m., in Room 2141, Rayburn House Office Building, the Hon. Darrell Issa [Chair of the Subcommittee] presiding. Members present: Representatives Issa, Fitzgerald, Cline, Gooden, Kiley, Lee, Fry, Johnson, Lofgren, Ross, and Kamlager- Dove. Mr. Issa. The Committee will come to order. Today, the Subcommittee, without objection, will be authorized to declare a recess at any time. We welcome everyone here today for the Intellectual Property and Internet Subcommittee hearing which will cover a broad range of current, but important, issues. Candidly, we in Congress often wait until there is a crisis to move. We are known for the expression what we do is nothing at all or overreact. We cannot afford to do it either at this time. The growth of various types of theft of intellectual property through counterfeiting and piracy, in fact, has become an epidemic. Most of the rest of the world has at least made efforts to deal with these problems. This hearing will establish once and for all that the various pieces of legislation need to move and need to move quickly. That means that this Committee must come together, along with the Senate, to deal with economic crimes around the world, but particularly those who come to our shores and take advantage of a weaker enforcement. Additionally, the growth of AI means that in the near future, what we see as a growing epidemic will rise even further. I want to particularly to focus on something here today. It is not just the money that is stolen from people whose creative works are being taken. It is, in fact, the funding of criminal networks, whether it is Hamas and Hezbollah, ISIS, Al Qaeda, or others, almost all these groups in addition to the conventional drug cartels, are operating criminal syndicates that include various forms of intellectual property theft. That means that, in fact, not doing something in a timely fashion is causing people to die. It is causing countries to live in terror. It is costing countless amount of dollars that U.S. citizens pay in addition to the loss of revenue to those who create intellectual property. I want to make it clear. We all know that there are people who innocently think that watching on a bootleg channel something they would otherwise pay for, the cost is simply they are getting a deal of free. If that money is, in fact, going to syndicates that are involved in other illegal activities, you are funding criminals. You are funding people who hurt people. Four decades ago, the Advanced Research Project Agency, ARPANET, adopted a communications protocol. I was a young lieutenant in those days and we used it. We used it in a very limited fashion. One day, somebody came up with the idea of a way to communicate that became known as email. In those decades, half a century or so, we have gone from a connection of military bases and universities for purposes of furthering research to the internet as we know today. In addition, the advantage of Moore's Law, in fact, has made almost anything that you have seen in science fiction all the way back to Jules Verne and all the way through to the Terminator, a reality today or in the near future. Decades ago, we passed the Internet Freedom Act and the DMCA laws to protect fostering and nascent technology. They were good. They worked some. They have, in fact, been modified over time, and the notice and takedown orders have, in fact, made them more effective. The cooperation of all parties, including the internet providers for whom this is simply overhead, in fact, has been appreciated. It has come without a cost. Recently, the Supreme Court made decisions that provide certainty as to, in fact, whether there is liability for various actions or inactions. We are not here to talk about that today. We are, in fact, recognizing that we have to all work together if we are going to stop copyright piracy over the internet. Only a few days ago, I was honored to be at the White House to watch a UFC fight. It was amazing. The problem is all over the world people are watching those fights for free. The cost of that fight included $3 million of set up and take down there at the White House. Somebody has to recognize that this is not without a cost. In addition, those who took the blows deserved to be compensated. To do so requires that, in fact, the purveyors be able to put that out in a streaming format and have it, in fact, only go to those who pay the small amount to get it. Digital video piracy includes illegal downloads, streaming of films and television and has resulted in an estimate that of loss of over 230,000 jobs and conservatively $47.5 billion reduced to our GDP. That is the economic cost. I have already covered, in fact, the cost that I am not overreacting to say people have died as a result of the money that is gained from that piracy. While millions of listings for copyright-infringing content are removed every day under notice and takedown process set forth in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, right holders have raised concerns with the speed. Today, our witnesses come prepared to answer the major question, what is the reasonable speed? Can we do it at the speed of sound? Can we do it at the speed of light? More importantly, in a 45 minute or sometimes a fraction of that live sports broadcast, can we do it soon enough to make it no longer profitable for those who pop up and sell their clandestine wares. The internet is open to substantial news sales revenues for brands. That is enabling the trafficking of fake brands, and I want to make it very clear. I live on the Mexican border. My district covers 80 miles of the Mexican border. In my district, we have a holding facility that holds up to 40,000 square feet, racked three and four high of illicit drugs. Those drugs often look like the real drug. They are in similar packaging. The pill or other container always seems to look very legitimate. It even has the right letters on it. When it is fentanyl, it has led to people dying. Counterfeiting is not simply a matter of getting a purse that looks cool that you can take to a party and maybe no one will know or even you may even brag that it is a fake, it also includes the counterfeiting of pharmaceuticals that, in fact, once again lead to people dying. The patchwork of laws in many of these cases, State by State, asks the question, should we continue to have States make decisions that make honest, law-abiding purveyors of products life difficult, while in fact, not effectively stopping the clandestine work? We made this decision in 1972 through both legislation and court that we were not going to do it with copyright for music. It has been a long time since and there has needed to be some additional items done. We have profited as a Nation from having not just one standard, but having the Federal Government being able to aid States in the enforcement of copyright protection. The same needs to happen relative to AI. We all know it has to happen and more importantly, if we are going to protect the law-abiding citizen, we can't have it be simply an additional law on top of hodge-podge laws that, in fact, can create conflicts or greater regulatory requirements. There needs to be a congressional act targeted in a measured way, meaning don't overreact. Any Federal legislation must balance three goals to avoid hobbling American innovation in online services and AI technology which will, in fact, ensure the continued leadership around the globe of U.S. technology. Let us make sure, in closing, that there is one thing beyond all that I have mentioned that is at stake and that is global leadership. America leads the world in high tech. We do so because we welcome people from around the world to join us through immigration. Our universities are the envy of the world for both those who come and stay and those who come and go back. That leadership is challenged by many others, but particularly by a China that, in fact, does not respect intellectual property, but does appreciate the innovation. They appreciate it so much they steal it. It is Congress' responsibility thus to, in fact, make clear that we are in a war, we are in a battle, we are in a competition against China, and we are determined to win. Before I recognize the Ranking Member for his opening statement, I would like to set a tone quickly with a short video. If we could please run the video with audio. [Video shown.] Mr. Issa. I now recognize the Ranking Member of the Subcommittee for his opening statement. Mr. Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When the modern internet was born in January 1983, many considered it just another Department of Defense project for the military. Thanks to taxpayer funding, the United States was able to partner with research universities and eventually private companies to harness this innovation for use by the general public. Over its first 10 years, the internet evolved from an application to compete with the Soviets to a place where people could socially connect, conduct business, and communicate with others, and even through--it evolved into a medium for artistic expression. Today, it is hard for many of us to imagine a world without new recipes at our fingertips, instant news updates, or pictures of our friends and family on or social media news feeds. Good or bad, it is no longer the question. The internet is inescapable from modern society. This is quickly becoming the same with generative artificial intelligence which has been adopted by businesses and consumers alike in just a few short years. Even with widespread adoption of transformative technology, it is imperative that we continue to protect rights holders when technology is used to steal intellectual property, defraud consumers, and increase inequality. Products available online from a trusted website can seem identical to those at brick- and-mortar stores, but instead, are produced with harmful chemicals or contain dangerous malware. These nearly identical knockoffs can damage your favorite brand's reputation and harm their ability to stay in business. Websites that miraculously have Project Hail Mary streaming for free really are too good to be true. That product with Tom Hanks in the commercial may not have actually been endorsed by Tom Hanks, just a replica created with AI. Some of these may seem harmless at first glance, but they matter to me and my constituents. Film and TV spending in Georgia, the Hollywood of the South, hit $4.4 billion in 2022 with 412 productions, but increased costs have devastated our film and TV market. Spending was down $2.3 billion in the last Fiscal Year with just 245 productions. Our writers and actors need jobs to keep creating and market changes have made that all the more difficult to achieve. Across creative industries, innovators from writers and software developers to musicians and painters are watching their works used to train AI models for free, while the barrier to entry gets higher and higher. If Congress' role today is to play armchair psychologist to the internet's mid-life crisis, it is imperative we view harms to creators as the symptom of a more pernicious disease. The question we should be asking ourselves is: Are the innovations before us serving the American people or do they exclusively benefit a small handful of the wealthiest, most powerful corporations and individuals in the world? Georgia's 11 million plus residents have a median household income of just under $82,000. Mark Zuckerberg is worth $220 billion as of December 2025. Groceries in Georgia were found to be the 11th highest in the country earlier this month. Elon Musk just became the world's first trillionaire. Homes in 79 percent of Georgia's counties are considered unaffordable for the average worker. Jeff Bezos just spent an estimated nearly $50 million on his wedding. Americans are clearly facing an affordability crisis, but those at the very top are doing well and getting wealthier and wealthier every day. The price of everyday consumer devices such as your laptops and computers have continued to climb, now to an estimated 15- 25 percent. Data centers are driving up utility costs, straining the grid and degrading the quality of the everyday appliances families depend on, like our air conditioning and heating system. Senior citizens are having to choose between paying their utility bills and their prescriptions and the rich get richer. The middle class shrinks and the poor get poorer. The benefits from technological innovations, while impressive, are minimized if everyone can't enjoy their benefits. We can do this by meaningfully deploying technology in a way that uplifts us all. This means acknowledging creators as a key part of the ecosystem that is building AI and compensating them as such. This means enacting protections for American workers, building responsibility, and deploying equitably. I look forward to hearing from the witnesses how we can better protect America's artists, innovators, and the creative fields. I thank Chair Issa for holding this important hearing and I yield back the balance of my time. Mr. Issa. The gentleman yields back. Thank you. We now recognize the Chair of the Full Committee, Mr. Jordan, for his opening statement. Mr. Jordan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I will be brief. I just want to thank you for your work for now over two decades on trying to stop copyright piracy and harmful uses of AI while not harming choice, innovation, and maybe most importantly First Amendment liberties. We appreciate your tireless work, and I know this is your last session in Congress. We will probably have a few more hearings, but I did want to take the time to thank you for this issue and so many others that you have worked so hard on and I thank our witnesses for being here and look forwarding to hearing from today's panel. With that, I yield back. Mr. Issa. I thank the Chair. I profusely thank the Chair. We now recognize the Ranking Member of the Full Committee, Mr. Raskin, for his opening statement. Mr. Raskin. Thank you kindly, Mr. Chair. Welcome to our witnesses. A couple of months ago, I got a postcard in my mailbox which let me know that three books I have written over the course of my career had been used to train Anthropic's Claude AI large language models, and because of this I was entitled to be part of the settlement in the Bartz v. Anthropic case. Now, this surprised me because first it reminded me that I used to write books. Now, I just post 280 characters every day. It also surprised me because I didn't know anything about the litigation, much less did I know anything about the fact that Anthropic had essentially swallowed up the contents of three of my books, apparently rejecting the relevance and utility of several books I had written. Anthropic had never called to ask me to use my books, but a judge found that Anthropic's ingestion and digestion of my books without payment was fair use. Claude AI may not be allowed to simply reprint my book and regurgitate line for line and sell it, but it may profit off my word choice, my cadence, my style such as it is, my conceptualizations, and my research, among other attributes of my writing for free. Now, if I finally get around to filling out the form which means I have to finally get around to finding the postcard, I may get a de minimis check in the mail because the judge did find Anthropic had used pirated versions of the books that it used to train its large language model and the parties, including apparently me, settled shortly after this holding. Now, it would be cavalier to write these training episodes off as a random or minor incidence. AI companies intentionally select works with which to train their large language models, often with zero intention of paying the creators any royalties for use of their creative intellectual labor. Bartz v. Anthropic is just one ominous decision floating in a sea of developing case law in this brave new world to engage in a fair use vernacular borrowing of H.G. Wells famous work of science fiction, but it is illustrative of the proliferating tensions between existing law and social values that have materialized as we live through this time of astonishing technological transformation. The advent of the internet and the explosive emergence of AI have fundamentally changed the way that we interact with each other, the way we conduct business, the way we think about human thought and human feelings and human work, and the way we create and consume books, songs, and other creative works. Now, I tend much more to the heady enthusiast side of such changes over the brute and Luddite side when it comes to technological innovation, but that is only because I have a profound faith in democracy and our capacity to manage technological change when we put our minds to it. Now, is the time to pose and grapple with urgent and searching questions about the moment. How do we integrate titanic new technological changes in a way that supports, rather than undermines, the basic needs and values of our society? We know from experience that innovations mean little if they are left to create inequality and domination, joblessness, and poverty. How do we prevent the concentration of power and wealth, but instead work to fairly distribute the benefits of new technologies so they become part of our common life and inheritance? In this new era, we must ask ourselves what is fair, what is just, and what will secure the greatest good to the greatest number of people. That is what I hope we will be doing today. When the DMCA became governing copyright law nearly 30 years ago, dangerous products and merchandise that infringed on intellectual property rights overwhelmingly had to be bought in person. Movie and music pirates created physical copies of recordings and literally sold them on the street corners. Our laws did not contemplate the spread of streaming where content piracy occurs on a daily basis all over the world as far away as Vietnam, the Philippines, and the pirates can create a new infringing site the moment one gets taken down. Consumer products used to be bought almost exclusively in stores with the occasionally counterfeit handbag on the street. Today, harmful counterfeit products like exploding batteries, toxic baby cream, and asbestos-laden crayons can be bought often, usually unwittingly, by consumers online and they arrive at their doorsteps in a matter of hours. Even our music laws were designed for a world where listeners discovered music through their stereos, which is why we are left with laws that prevent performers from being paid when their music is being played on the radio. These issues affect not just the two million employees of the movie industry or the nearly $12 billion in revenue from the music industry, but also the consumers who end up paying the cost of counterfeit goods that break or cause harm or just drive up the price of the real product. The laws on the books may no longer be fair for these affected industries, and they are almost certainly unfair to consumers. I understand there are many proposals out there with ideas for improving the current situation. I am a proud cosponsor of one of them, the American Music Fairness Act, which would ensure that performers are paid when their music is actually played on the radio. In many ways, AI's supercharged problems have been percolating since the advent of internet. Generative AI models allow to use internet faster, more accurately, and beyond our individual technological capacities, but our laws have not kept pace with all the changes. Our intellectual property laws were created at a time when it was safe to presume that one must be human to have cognition and intellect. Some would argue that is no longer the case. It is long past time we considered how to protect the creative fields and address the ramifications of the proliferation of deep fakes, training AI models on copyrighted material, and other areas where AI may be unfair to both consumers and creators. I know some of my colleagues want to do away with the regulation of AI companies altogether, but we can protect content creators and help businesses thrive at the same time. We don't have to choose. Congress should help provide for the safe adoption of generative AI models that take into account the environmental labor and social consequences of such technology and we should do so while allowing the States to experiment with different approaches. I am dismayed by those who have caved to a small group of billionaires and now a trillionaire, who own these AI models and have proposed broad preemption of State common law causes of action and State legislative decisionmaking with no Federal regulation at all. There is no reason we should do away with common law tort claims that act as the basic national safety net for fairness. The National Institute of Science and Technology should absolutely be allowed to test frontier models and if AI models are being built on the hard work of artists, writers, and inventors, we should be thinking long term to ensure that there are more artists, writers, and inventors a generation from now creating material to sustainably train the next wave of generative innovation to come. The rational next step for this Committee is to ask ourselves how we can map a path forward for all Americans to use technology while ensuring laws that protect consumers and creators, workers, and families. Thank you, Mr. Chair, I yield back to you. Mr. Issa. The gentleman yields back. Without objection, all other opening statements will be included in the record. We now go to our distinguished panel of witnesses. Mr. Sean Astin. Mr. Astin is the President of the Screen Actors Guild. By the way, one of the few things I haven't done and I continue to say, I am available for a bit part. Am I allowed to do that? Anyhow, the American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, commonly known as SAG-AFTRA, he is himself an actor and a long-distinguished career in film and television. To name just a few, he has appeared in the ``Goonies,'' ``Rudy''--by the way, we are going to talk about ``Rudy.'' That is going to happen. How can we not? Even if you didn't go to the right college, the ``Lord of the Rings'' trilogy, ``Stranger Things,'' ``Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles,'' and many more. Thank you for being here as a well knowledgeable expert witness, in addition to your current role. Mr. Chris Floyd. Mr. Floyd is a legal and business strategy advisor to Amblin Entertainment, a film and television production company, basically, he is Steven Spielberg's most trusted advisor. He previously served as the Chief Operating Officer and General Counsel at his partnership for a decade and held various positions with Dreamworks Studios, Universal Pictures, Paramount, and Walt Disney Productions. Welcome. Mr. Steve Francis. Mr. Francis is the Executive Chair and President of IP House, a global intellectual property enforcement company. He previously served as the acting Executive Associate Director of Homeland Security Investigations as the Director of National Intellectual Property Rights Coordinator. Thank you very much and welcome. Mr. Christopher Mohr. Mr. Mohr is President and Chief Executive Officer of the Software and Information Industry Association, a collection of entertainment, consumer, and business software companies. He previously served as a Senior Vice President for Intellectual Property and General Counsel at the same organization where he led the association's intellectual property policy and antipiracy. Last, but not least by a long shot, Dr. Bhamati Viswanathan, or close to it. The doctor is a nonresident fellow at the Kemochan Center for Law, Media, and the Arts at Columbia University. She is also a Visiting Assistant Professor at Suffolk University Law School where she teaches courses in contract and transactional law. The doctor is, in fact, the author of a number of books including, ``How Creative Industries Can Harness Intellectual Property to Survive in a Digital Age.'' Welcome, and I apologize. As one left hander to another, I said I am not going to mess this up and between my hoarse throat and the other, I apologize. I want to thank all of you for being here. Pursuant to the Committee rules, I would ask you to please rise, raise your right hand, to take the oath. Do you solemnly swear or affirm under penalty of perjury that the testimony that you are about to give is true and correct to the best of your knowledge, information, and belief so help you God? Thank you. You may be seated. Let the record reflect that all witnesses answered in the affirmative. If you watch C-SPAN, you know I have to give this admonishment, that you will have five minutes in your opening statements, but 100 percent of all the material you brought with you and your opening statement plus additional material you may supplement with will be placed in the record, thus leaving you completely free not to just read what you brought, although some of you just might. With that, we begin, Mr. Astin. STATEMENT OF SEAN K. ASTIN Mr. Astin. Well, this is good stuff. You're going to want to hear it. Chair Issa, Ranking Member Johnson, the Members of the Committee, thank you very much for convening the hearing and for your continued work modernizing American intellectual property law. Thank you, Representative Lofgren, for your leadership on combating foreign digital piracy, and Chair Issa, for all your work and for your work on the American Music Fairness Act. The issues therein matter to the livelihoods of the 160,000 union performers and media professionals I represent as President of SAG-AFTRA. Today, I would like to speak about the abuse of nonconsensual digital replicas of our voices and likenesses. For all of human history, if someone saw your face and knew it was you, if they heard your voice and knew you had spoken, for thousands of years that simple connection was enough, your face, your voice, and your presence, reality itself was affirmed and simply put we knew who we were to each other. Artificial intelligence has begun to intervene and break that ancient connection. Today, someone can realistically make you appear to say something you never said, to endorse something you don't believe in, or even convincingly depict you confessing to something you had no knowledge of. For the first time in human history, the experiences we have always shared are no longer secure. Our relationship with the community is distorting thanks to a wave of technology made widely available without much concern for public safety. In my line of work, we deal with emotions, so on behalf of our performers I am here to tell you what this moment feels like. To begin, we make our livings by granting the use of our voices and likenesses to our employers. That is what they pay us for. Through every audition and with every career setback, we know, we rely on the fact that when the jobs finally come, we have something uniquely ours to offer. Now, imagine a performer waking up one morning to discover on their phone a version of themselves that never was, but they are watching it and so is the rest of the world. The voice and the face are a perfect match. For the performer, it is a moment of terror. Who is seeing it? Will anyone ever hire them again? Will their reputation that was built over a lifetime be destroyed in a moment? Every casting director, every producer, every executive, and every member of the public can see it. Even their family may hesitate for a moment. They can reach for something deeper. He would never say that. That is not who she is, but who are we? Think about anyone you love. Your understanding of them is built from memory. Imagine that memory being contaminated. The thing that brings us back to the real person is our faith in who they truly are. In the world of deep fakes, the damage is done instantly and without mercy. The public has no obligation to discover the truth about someone. They just keep scrolling. Our members have no ability to protect themselves from this kind of abuse, and neither does the teenager humiliated by a fabricated image, neither do parents trying to protect their children, neither does anyone whose reputation can be threatened by a digital replica they never authorized. Artificial intelligence is changing the way human beings experience life. We all know that this moment demands wisdom and action. Technology is not our enemy. Throughout our history, America has chosen both innovation and responsibility, usually sadly, only after ordinary people have suffered some calamity, but there is a right path. It is obvious that civilization is in the throes of a technological whirlwind the likes of which we have never seen and as of this moment, Americans are being forced to surrender their basic relationship to one another. We don't want to stop progress. We need to civilize it. Many Americans may never own a home or accumulate significant financial wealth, but every American does possess something of immeasurable value, their identity. That God-given gift really should belong to us and surely, we can all agree that no one else should be permitted to commercially exploit our identity without consent. In the world of entertainment, our image and likeness have been the substance of our transactions, but in the wild, we do not own them. We should, and you can make it so. Members of the Committee, what I am saying about this moment and about who we are is that every human being should remain the author of their own existence. Reality should remain verifiable. Consent is not a nuisance. Reputation matters, and truth is truth, and it is worth protecting. Thank you very much. [The prepared statement of Mr. Astin follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Issa. I thank the gentleman. Mr. Floyd. STATEMENT OF CHRIS FLOYD Mr. Floyd. Chair Issa, Ranking Member Johnson, and the distinguished Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for inviting me here today. I am of counsel at Amblin Entertainment, Steven Spielberg's film and television company. I have worked in the Amblin family for 20 years, including a decade as Chief Operating Officer and General Counsel. I have overseen many business and legal functions including content protection. Two weeks ago, Amblin and Universal released Steven's film ``Disclosure Day,'' adding to his legacy of films like ``War of the Worlds'' and ``Minority Report.'' ``Disclosure Day'' fully embodies Steven's beloved sci-fi genre, embracing modern technology that makes transporting audiences to another world even more thrilling. However, these technological advancements also present challenges. Steven's prior sci-fi movies were released in a drastically different marketplace, before the internet super charged digital piracy. When ``Minority Report'' was released in 2022, piracy was still limited largely to hard goods, DVD bootlegs from camcorders in a theater with muddle sound and shaky video, then sold on street corners. They were poor knockoffs and customers knew it. While the scale of piracy was reason for some concern then, today, digital piracy costs the U.S. economy a staggering amount at least $29 billion annually. We now expect each release will be made available immediately in perfect digital form from offshore pirate sites with global reach. This substantial increase in quality, coupled with wide and immediate availability on any device, makes this an urgent economic and consumer safety problem. Together with our studio distribution partners, we spend hours seeking removal of these infringing videos. Additionally, all the studios and streamers created the Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment to work with global law enforcement to combat piracy, but even with these extensive efforts, representing tens of millions of dollars and countless work hours, price still inflicts huge harm on the market for our films. When we find ``Disclosure Day'' online, we have limited recourse, primarily because most pirate sites are operated by overseas criminal enterprises. We have laws that enable us to go after pirate sites in the U.S., but Bulgaria, Vietnam, the Philippines, these jurisdictions sit outside the practical reach of U.S. law enforcement, but easily reach U.S. consumers online. The global revenues from U.S. films are shared with cast and crew in residuals and pension, health, and welfare payments. Profits are poured into new productions in every State of the union, including with local businesses. Shooting a one-hour television episode generates around $475,000 per day locally, while a feature film generates $670,000 per day. The billions siphoned from our economy by these overseas criminals should be available for these future productions and payments to industry workers, but they are not. Today, piracy detrimentally impacts millions of creators in the U.S. entertainment industry and the economy as a whole while funding a global network of crime. According to Digital Citizens Alliance, European authorities dismantled a piracy operation across 11 countries in 2024 that generated $3.5 billion yearly seizing drugs, weapons, and millions in crypto currency. In Spain, Operation Fake exposed another site that also dealt in drug trafficking and money laundering, resulting in 30 arrests and millions in frozen assets. What is to be done? Well, I ask you today for the tool proven effective in nearly 60 countries globally, but still lacking in the U.S, judicial site blocking. Under these laws, when a court determines there was full and transparent process that an off-shore site is dedicated to piracy, it can direct internet providers to block local access. Studies prove site blocking results in fewer visits to piracy sites and an increase to legitimate sites. Portugal witnessed a 70 percent drop in traffic. Australia saw a 25 percent decrease. The U.K. experienced a 10 percent surge to legal services. This would be a game changer for our industry's 2.3 million workers and America's creative economy. Historically, the U.S. led the world in IP enforcement, but we have lagged behind for the past decade. Other countries have shown us how to do this without impacting speech, due process, or the internet. It is time the U.S. reasserts its leadership role in antipiracy. Finally, allow me to turn briefly to artificial intelligence where the U.S. is the leader in innovation as it should be. As a tool, AI can further empower us to tell compelling stories and reach audiences, but as we consider how to maintain America's competitive advantage against China and other countries, we must also remain the global leader in both the innovation and creative industries. How these AI companies win the AI race and how they treat copyrighted work will affect the course of human creativity in the future. We will never maintain America's lead by lowering our IP standards to match those of the Chinese. That is why our industry supports the NO FAKES Act, which combats dissemination of unauthorized AI- generated deep fakes while safeguarding protected expression such as parody, news, and biopics. I would like to thank the Subcommittee for your dedication, as we look forward to working together rebuilding a vibrant U.S. entertainment industry. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Floyd follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Issa. I thank the gentleman. Mr. Francis. STATEMENT OF STEVE K. FRANCIS Mr. Francis. Chair Issa, Ranking Member Johnson, and the distinguished Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I spent over 25 years in Federal law enforcement, including as the Director of the National IPR Center, working alongside colleagues from Homeland Security investigations, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, the Department of Justice, and law enforcement partners across more than 30 countries. I have seen IP enforcement from multiple angles. I know where the government excels and where prioritization creates challenges for enforcement. I appear today on behalf of IP House, a global IP protection enforcement company I cofounded, after recognizing critical gaps in the enforcement landscape. IP House operates across every major jurisdiction because IP crime is truly global. We detect and disrupt infringement networks at scale, bringing global intelligence and operational visibility that complements the work of governments and rights holders worldwide. IP House confirms what I witnessed throughout my career. As commerce has moved online, IP crime has grown more sophisticated, more organized, and harder to disrupt. Criminal networks now exploit the speed, scale, and anonymity of the internet to steal IP and endanger consumers on a global scale. Today's hearing is incredibly timely. Counterfeiters operate through anonymous digital storefronts on the trust, online marketplace that American consumers use every day. They rapidly cycle through the seller's identities, domains, and payment processors to evade enforcement, often moving illicit proceeds long before traditional legal remedies can take effect. That is why IP House focuses on following the networks and the money, not just removing individual listings. It dismantles criminal organizations rather than chasing one product at a time. They are not harmless knockoffs. They include counterfeit pharmaceuticals, automotive parts, electronics, children's toys, and household products that threaten the health and safety of the American consumers. One of the most effective U.S. civil tools against counterfeiting is what practitioners call Schedule A litigation. It allows rights holders to bring a single action against multiple, anonymous foreign sellers engaged in the same infringing conduct. Just as importantly, it allows the courts to quickly freeze the seller accounts and related assets before these proceeds disappear beyond the reach of U.S. jurisdiction. That changes the economics of infringement. Without this tool, rights holders are forced to file dozens or even hundreds of nearly identical lawsuits against anonymous defendants who have moved assets and simply reappear under new identities faster than the courts can reach a judgment. Schedule A is one of the few law enforcement tools capable of matching the speed, scale, and anonymity of today's online infringers while preserving judicial efficiency and due process. Online piracy presents an equally sophisticated challenge. Our recent organized piracy crime report published with the Digital Citizens Alliance demonstrates that many of today's piracy operations have evolved in the criminal enterprises, built on a systematic theft of American intellectual property. A single network we examined reached more than 22 million subscribers and generated roughly $288 million a month. When law enforcement dismantled that operation, they uncovered drugs, weapons, and crypto currency, evidence that these organizations are engaged in far more copyright infringement. Large scale piracy networks view IP theft as low risk, high reward criminal enterprise and changing the calculation is what IP House is built to do. The enforcement gap is real and measurable. Rights holders are stuck with reactive platform tools that provide relief measured in just hours. More than 40 peer Nations now use court ordered site blocking to cutoff foreign, fully infringing content sites and services at the stores. The results have been significant. In the U.K., traffic to the targeted piracy fell nearly 89 percent after blocking orders took effect. The United States has not kept pace with its international partners, leaving creators, consumers, and businesses at a competitive disadvantage. Meanwhile, criminal organizations are now using generative AI to accelerate infringement to an unprecedented scale. These include mass produced counterfeit listings and brand presentation to synthetic media as well the name, image, and likeness violation. While the technology is new, the underlying challenge is not. Bad actors continue to exploit innovation faster than our enforcement tools can adapt. I hope my testimony today provides the Subcommittee with an operational perspective on how today's online infringement networks actually function, where the current enforcement tools are succeeding and where meaningful gaps remain. IP House is committed to working with Congress to ensure American innovators, creators, consumers, and businesses are protected in the digital age. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Francis follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Issa. Thank you. The gentleman yields back. Mr. Mohr. STATEMENT OF CHRIS A. MOHR Mr. Mohr. Chair Issa, Ranking Member Johnson, and the Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to appear here today. Before I get into the substance, I just want to take a moment to thank you, Mr. Chair, on behalf of our Members. You have been a genuine ally to us on patents and a straight shooter even when we have disagreed. That leadership shows up here, too, convening round tables on foreign piracy, advancing thoughtful, site-blocking discussions, and choosing an educational hearing over a rush to markup. It has been a privilege to work with you, and we are grateful for the way that you have sought to both protect and advance American innovation. SIIA represents more than 350 companies in the business of information, AI developers, publishers, financial data firms, and software creators. Unusually for a technology trade association, our members sit on both sides of many IP issues. We have platforms that distribute works and their rights holders. Some of our members have both functions. Over the course of our 40-year existence, we have seen a lot of technological changes that have affected member operations, some of which caused them to bring competing world views. When examining new IP and other policy proposals, we tend to ask the same questions every time. Does existing law already address the harm? What new risks does the technology create? What limits make a statute both effective and constitutional? I am going to briefly highlight two areas. Two years ago, SIIA testified in front of this Committee about unauthorized digital replicas. On digital replicas, the harm that these unauthorized uses cause is real. These AI-generated voices and likenesses are already defrauding consumers and exploiting performers. We support the creation of a Federal right here and we supported the TAKE IT DOWN Act last year as proof Congress can build precise, targeted tools for AI-enabled harms. In terms of vehicles that have recently moved, the NO FAKES Act has received a lot of attention. From our perspective there are four problems that remain and each one is fixable. First, the preemption clause grandfathers in existing State law and only displaces State regimes for expressive works. The bill doesn't really deliver on the promise of a national standard. Second, the counter notification safeguard against wrongful takedowns only exists inside the bill's safe harbor framework, statutory damages up to $750,000 per work and a life plus 70 terms, no company will risk staying outside that framework. In practice, this isn't a narrow opt-in category. It is close to the entire digital ecosystem operating under a takedown regime with no guarantee necessarily to put wrongly removed content back up. That raises concerns over speech at scale. Third, there is no general intent requirement risking liability for general-purpose AI tools and inadvertent look- alikes alongside the actual bad actors. Fourth, again, this goes to scope. The bill's frame is touching user-content platforms, but it reaches deep into the broader digital economy and shifts Section 230 treatment along the way. We don't have a problem with that resolution, but it emphasizes the importance of getting the details right. Now, we have supplied red-line language on these issues. These are fixes, not objections to the bill's premise, and we are ready to keep working on it until we handle these problems correctly. The second topic that I am going to address is foreign piracy and site blocking specifically. This is a different question, and our members are generally split onsite blocking as a remedy and my goal here is not to advocate a specific solution, but to present the equities that Congress has already begun to consider. First, the underlying problem is real. These pirate sites sit outside U.S. courts' reach, and they keep operating through mirror domains and offshore hosting, no matter how many times they are shut down. The concerns over how blocking gets implemented are just as real. Blocking is a level of DNS resolvers, doesn't respect borders. Targets increasingly share cloud infrastructure with thousands of unrelated lawful sites, so a narrow order can have overbroad effects. Foreign experience shows that legitimate services can get swept up by mistake. We are not here to endorse or oppose a specific proposal. We are here to say that if Congress moves forward, four guardrails should be nonnegotiable: Real judicial process with some adversarial testing, not rubber-stamp petitions; targeting precise enough to protect shared infrastructure and lawful content; strong, good-faith safe harbors for the providers required to comply; and no mandate for a single government-prescribed technical method. On both issues, our position is the same: Get the goal right, get the mechanism right, and we all win. Our members are going to have to operate under whatever regime Congress creates. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify, and I welcome your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Mohr follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Issa. Thank you. Dr. Viswanathan. STATEMENT OF BHAMATI VISWANATHAN Ms. Viswanathan. Chair Issa, Ranking Member Johnson, Ranking Member Raskin, thank you--pardon me, it is catching. Thank you so much for having me. My name is Bhamati Viswanathan. I teach at Suffolk Law School where I teach copyright law, constitutional law, contracts, and Artificial Intelligence and the Law. Happily, for all of us, I am here today to talk about contracts and copyright, both, and not constitutional law. I want to frame this with three thoughts quickly, and then I am going to move onto three potential solutions that I see. The frame is--I am going to take it from the title of this hearing, which struck me--the ``Mid-Life Crisis'' question. Those of us who sit around thinking about our mid-life sometimes, think of mid-life as both a crisis sometimes, but also an opportunity. It is an opportunity to rethink. It is a very strategic moment for us to think. Disruption, and since there was no internet 40 years ago, which is how we framed this hearing, begins with opportunity, and it begins with innovation. It also begins with disruption. We are at another moment and another inflection point. I want to frame this by saying we are not talking about one industry, we are talking about two, two critical industries. Mr. Issa, you said that America leads the world in high tech. Yes. We also lead the world in arts and entertainment, in culture. A $2 billion industry for tech. Many people are surprised to hear $3.3 trillion and more in 2024 was the estimate that was given. Two robust industries. We cannot kill the goose that lays the golden eggs. We need the goose to be alive, and we need the eggs to be gold; right? We need both sides. Second, we believe in our IP system. We have a strong and robust IP system. It's the pride and joy of our country, and it is in our Constitution. Sorry. I said I wasn't going to talk about con law, and I just did. We believe in the patent system. The patent system is strong and robust. We need to make sure that the copyright side is strong and robust, too. We can't just throw it off and scrap it at the behest of a few tech companies that say, ``oh, we are going to lose the arms race.'' There are multiple arms races going on here. Our arts and culture, no one compares to it. K-pop, Bollywood, and Eurovision? Sorry. Nothing is as great as our export of IT in both areas of technology and culture. For the new times we need new rights and, importantly, we need new enforcement mechanisms. Let me get to my three solutions that I think are strong on the table, and that we should really consecrate right now as urgent. First, as you have heard my, my fellow panelists speak about, judicial site blocking. For those of you who don't know what that is, it's a process through which you ask a court to stop an infringing website. You know already that it exists almost exclusively to disseminate infringing material. You are worried about a bad actor here. There are due process steps in place to say, OK, we need to make sure that is true. Once we've made sure that is true, what can we do? We can ask a court to say, through a no-fault process, without seeking damages, you need to shut this down because we can't. We can't go after these bad actors. They are often extraterritorial. We really have no other recourse. Over 50 countries have, have adopted it, as you have heard. The U.S. Copyright Office has written a letter of support to you in Congress about it. It is timely. It is a fair and reasonable, balanced solution. Second, I am going to talk very quickly about digital replicas because I know you have heard about them a lot. They are a problem. They affect people. Because we are people, we have personal property rights in our identity and in our autonomy. Let's not forget why this exists. It is rights in ourselves. As Mr. Astin said, ``we have human rights.'' Those rights deserve to be Federalized. They deserve to be made into a Federal property right. This needs to be made something that occurs across the country. We can carve out First Amendment concerns. We can carve out the scope of it, but it is something that needs to be addressed now. Third, perhaps nearest and dearest to my heart, is the question of the treatment of the ingestion of copyrighted materials by large language models (LLMs). What does that mean? We use this word a lot. We say LLMs train themselves on copyrighted material. Well, they can train, but just like the rest of us who train, they have to pay for the training. Licensing agreements need to flourish. They are beginning to happen. We need to make sure that creators, creators who create the stuff that we consume, are compensated--small creators, too, not just large intermediaries. We need to do that now. There's a lot of court cases pending, as Mr. Raskin said, various cases. We also need to make sure that there are licensing and market-based solutions that make it fair for all of us. Thank you so much for giving me the time to hear. [The prepared statement of Ms. Viswanathan follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Issa. Thank you, Doctor. We will now proceed under the five-minute rule for questions. By mutual agreement, we will go to the gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Cline, first. Mr. Cline. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for your leadership on this issue. You have given us a historical perspective that dates back many decades. I know many here and watching have been a large part of that history. As you said in your opening remarks, it is important to remember that history, but also to be cautious in any movement that we take moving forward. Recognizing that the DMCA, notice and takedown, all these things that were put in place 20 years ago, may need updating, but don't need wholesale replacement. We are not going to throw out the baby with the bath water, or the goose that laid the golden eggs, whatever metaphor we want to use. Mr. Mohr, in Cox v. Sony, this spring the Supreme Court held 9-0 that an internet service provider is not contributorily liable for its user's piracy unless it induced the infringement or tailored its service to it, which retired the older knowledge plus material contribution theory. With that route against intermediates now narrowed, does a no-fault judicial remedy to restrict access to foreign piracy sites become both the cleaner legal tool and the more realistic one, since it turns on blocking rather than on anyone's fault? Mr. Mohr. Certainly, from the rights' holder side of our constituency that this is exactly how they view the significance of the Cox decision. I will say that for the platforms that we represent, that there the problem, however, of these offshore sites existed well before the Cox decision was decided. The folks that are, the folks like Sci-Hub or that I mentioned in my testimony, and the other sites that are ripping off the other folks on this panel don't care about Cox. That is really the reason for the, from the copyright owner's side, the push for site blocking orders, because they need a way to get at websites that U.S. courts can't reach. Because if these websites existed in the United States, they would not last long. Mr. Cline. You are absolutely right. The Chair led a delegation of Members on a visit to the U.K. and other countries more than year ago and to see firsthand how their site blocking regimes are working. What we saw very clearly was that these remedies can work to reduce traffic on pirate sites and to increase traffic to legitimate sites, while safeguarding speech, due process, and legitimate internet activities, all without imposing undue burden and liability risks on the ISPs that are directed to implement the court orders. My understanding is that liability concerns on the part of domestic ISPs has been the most significant impediment to advancing legislation in the U.S. I am also told that the proposals offered to date in the House and Senate all include provisions to address that concern. My questions are these: First, do we now know enough from the experience with the many foreign jurisdictions that have implemented this remedy successfully over the last 15 years that we can confidently move forward with the U.S. legislation and avoid any unintended consequences? Second, in light of the Cox decision is the concern about ISP liability now a moot issue? Mr. Mohr. I am not sure I understand the second part of that question. With respect to the first part, as my testimony makes clear, I am not in a position where I can say a bill is good or a bill is bad. What I can say is that a bill that contains the guardrails is one that I believe Congress can advance. Those guardrails I mentioned in the opening by adversarial testing, the targeting is the biggest concern. Because of the internet architecture, again, from the kind of infrastructure/internet side of our membership, right, the architecture of the internet is designed to efficiently distribute, not necessarily it is not designed to throttle. The risk, then, of over-blocking because of that architecture and liability for over-blocking from the standpoint of those providers, is real. With respect to the guardrails, if the safe harbor isn't there, if there is no tech mandate, and if the targeting is precise and the process is fair, that is a roadmap for a successful site blocking bill. Again, the devil's in the details. I am not in a position where I can give you those. Mr. Cline. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Issa. The gentleman yields back. We now go to the Ranking Member of the Subcommittee, Mr. Johnson for his five minutes. Mr. Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Professor Viswanathan, AI systems require massive amounts of data for their training and development. The AI companies are continuing to train on copyrighted material to release better and better models. Should AI developers be required to disclose the dataset used to train their models? Ms. Viswanathan. Thank you so much for asking me that question, Mr. Johnson. I want to start by saying we use the word ``training,'' but I am not sure that this is always the right word. They do ingest enormous amounts of material to generate what they generate. When we train, when you and I train, when we learn, when we go use things, we pay for those materials. We license them or we buy them. I buy a book in the bookstore, I use it in the library which has already paid a licensing fee, I am training in respect, but that is not the same thing that the AI companies are doing. What they are doing is: They are gobbling up huge amounts of material. Do they need to disclose their datasets? That is one part of it.That in the various cases I have been talking about that Mr. Raskin was just referring to the one where his books were ingested. Right? What happens there? I don't think they ever paid you for those books. You will be paid, you will find that postcard in the settlement, because it is the point is, right, it is not just disclosing what they trained on. By the say, in Bartz, in the Bartz case we found they were, in fact, training on pirate sites as well; right? We are learning what they are training on, and it is not good. They should also be made to realize that you can't just take it. It is not a get-out-of-jail-free card to say, ``oh, it is expensive to license.'' They need to license the materials that they are using, as one does. It needs market-based solutions are the preferred solutions because parties come to them. We can't--we need to monitor what, in fact, they are doing. I think disclosure is a part of that but not the entire story. It is an important part of it. Most of all, I think we need to recognize that harm is being done to the markets, the actual and potential markets of copyright holders. That is not what fair use in the copyright fair use term was ever legally or in the spirit meant to have happen; right? It was not meant to be a, oh, it is beneficial and so you get to use it for free. It is beneficial, but it is also valuable. The value needs to be paid. Mr. Johnson. Thank you. Mr. Floyd, how has the proliferation of internet piracy changed the way that movies are made? Mr. Floyd. It has had a direct impact on the number of movies that we make and which movies we make. When we are making a decision as to go forward with a film, we do a profit and loss analysis. We look at the history of the movies in the last few years, and we look and see what kind of revenues have been generated. As piracy cuts down on the revenues, the legitimate revenues that we are getting, we determine that our next movie is going to make fewer dollars and that impacts maybe our ability to spend a certain amount of money on a movie or make that movie at all. What you end up with are fewer movies being made, fewer people being employed along the way, and more risk being taken by the studies on the movies that they do go forward on. Mr. Johnson. Thank you. Mr. Astin, you have made a career off your name, image, likeness, and voice, everything we talk about when we examine digital replica legislation. What about individuals whose names or likenesses are not a commercial business, do you think those individuals need to be protected as well? Mr. Astin. Absolutely. They need it as much, if not more. There, yes, if you are--I mentioned in my testimony that if you are a teenager somewhere, in your district for example, and for whatever reason, with very little difficulty someone is able to depict you, as you--not you, this imagined teenager-- saying they are doing something-- Mr. Johnson. I get it. Mr. Astin. You, too. We all, everyone in here. Mr. Johnson. Yes. Mr. Astin. We traffic in our identity and our reputations all the time. Well, so does a 14-year-old kid. Yet, these big platforms benefit financially from when some horrible depiction is done of them. They have no ability to do anything about it. Yes, they should have their identity protected as a right. Thanks. Mr. Issa. Thank you. I yield back. Mr. Issa. The gentleman yields back. We now go to the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Fitzgerald. Mr. Fitzgerald. Thank you, Chair. I just want to go back to February 2024 for a moment because that is when our Committee first began discussing the issue of AI and digital replicas. I see a lot of familiar faces on the witness stand as well, and in the audience where were also in Los Angeles for that field hearing. Mr. Mohr, in fact, you testified at that hearing, if I remember correctly. It was also the first time Mr. Astin was there as well, that first time we met. Mr. Mohr, let me start with you. When you testified in 2024 at that field hearing, you mentioned that there are already a number of State and Federal laws that address many of the concerns with digital replicas. If Congress were to act, and it should act in areas where AI poses a particular risk of harm left unaddressed by current Federal and State laws, so is that still kind of your testimony today, or has anything changed in the past two years since we last debated kind of the issue of AI? Mr. Mohr. What I would say is that it is true that a number of the harms that occur from the unauthorized use of digital replicas are covered by, in many instances, will be covered by existing State laws and remedies. There is no Federal remedy. That presents an opportunity for Congress to present a uniform rule and uniform protection which will benefit both the folks who are injured and the businesses that actually have to implement this by a uniform set of rules and a clear standard of what is allowed and what is not allowed. To do that, there are a number of equities that this body will have to balance. Our members view the current State of digital replica law as an opportunity to legislate constructively. Mr. Fitzgerald. Mr. Astin, let me come to you. I remember that we were able to visit in L.A. I know this is kind of general and wide open, but why is the Federal digital replica right, why is it important to you and those that are in the entertainment industry right now? What is prompting people to kind of move in one direction or another? Mr. Astin. Well, every day we have our images, our voices, our faces, and us created fictitiously in ways that people don't, can't tell the difference. It looks like I am saying or doing things. It is happening all the time. I had one friend, a colleague, I saw a video image of him. He is really upset in this image. He was talking in great detail about some problem that happened. I called him up and I said, ``Hey, man, are you OK?'' He goes, ``Yes. What are you talking about?'' I said, ``Well, I saw you were so upset about this thing.'' He said, ``No, I wasn't.'' I said, ``You were sitting in this room and there was a thing behind you.'' He said, ``No, I wasn't.'' His wife walks in and says, ``I can't believe you would fall for that fake.'' I am thinking. I went back and looked at it. I opened it up and I couldn't tell the difference between him and this creation. You know what? It is, ``could you please take this down, YouTube? Could you please pull this off your site?'' They need this law to have the instruction that it is OK to take it down. Mr. Fitzgerald. The process to do that is tedious. Mr. Astin. No. They just have to know it is OK. Let them work out the tech. These guys back here have it worked out pretty good. Right? They have got a system for how to take it down; right? Yes. Mr. Fitzgerald. Good. Mr. Astin. It is working. They have to know that it is OK, that we have got our First Amendment that we love and we have to protect. The First Amendment is implicated in this NO FAKES Act in both directions. You have to be able to do satire, tell the news. You have to be able to tell historical things. You have to be able to do all these things. You also can't rob someone else of their First Amendment right by having it misrepresented as them. It needs to be clarified for these companies where this country stands in Federal law on the nature of intellectual property, individual intellectual property. Mr. Fitzgerald. Very well said. Mr. Astin. Thank you for asking. Mr. Fitzgerald. Very well said. I will yield back. Mr. Issa. Would the gentleman yield? Mr. Fitzgerald. I do yield. Mr. Issa. I just want to cover one thing. Doctor, you said you are not going to do Constitution. Since you are here, I am going to pinch you a little bit. Is it true that States under the Constitution don't have international reach? In other words, they, by definition, might be able to pass a law, but to enforce against countries outside the U.S. is completely limited in the Constitution to the Federal Government? Ms. Viswanathan. I invite you to my Con Law class next year and we will talk. It is still to a certain extent an open question. Yes, what you are saying is essentially true. There is a case called Vetter right now that is pending that is asking about international reach of certain copyrights that we have. That case is in the Fifth Circuit. It is--and going up, hopefully. It is unclear. That one thing that Federalizing laws like the digital replicas law does is it gives us a level of security that we are playing at a national level and that we are not getting into the morass of States' rights versus international rights. Site blocking, too, this is something that is so agreed on so many countries in the developed world, it is relatively uncontroversial at this point. It is fair to say that. Digital replicas are going to be a problem worldwide. We can get not just bipartisan support, but international support behind this, which it is a rare opportunity. We should grab it. Mr. Issa. Thank you, Doctor. I would tease it up for our constitutional scholar here on the dais, the gentleman, the Ranking Member Mr. Raskin. Mr. Raskin. Well, thank you for that, Mr. Chair. I have to get you a copy of some of my books. Mr. Issa. I downloaded them already. What are you talking about? Ms. Viswanathan. Not piratable. Mr. Raskin. Professor Viswanathan, the Northern District Court in California held in Bartz v. Anthropic that the use of copyrighted works for AI training constitutes fair use. You just voiced your skepticism about thinking that it is training. According to the court, Anthropic is permitted to purchase a copy of a book and then use that work to train the model on language, writing, and story. Do you agree with the court's conclusion? Is that the right analysis? Ms. Viswanathan. That is not constitutional, that is a leading question. Mr. Raskin. Yes. Ms. Viswanathan. That the court is, that courts are struggling. They are struggling for the same reason we are. The court said, to be accurate, that it was transformative. It is still a question about fair use. Well, for those of you who are not copyright people, I am sorry for you but there is still time and I will help you through this. Right? I say to you, you infringed. You say, well, you are right, I did, but I did it for good reason. It is an affirmative defense. It has four prongs to it. The biggest ones are, did you do something really important, transformative? Did you change it in some meaningful way that makes it important that we preserve that? The fourth factor is, does it affect the market? I want to point this out: Actual or potential market, right, for the work, for the original work? The courts are confused and they are concerned, because they see the effect on potential markets. At least the Bartz court does; right? Mr. Raskin. Right. Ms. Viswanathan. What is the potential market? You could license that work otherwise. Right? Mr. Raskin. All right, are there licensing regimes in copyright law that can serve as a model? Ms. Viswanathan. Absolutely there are. There are licensing regimes that exist right now. You just asked someone a couple of months ago, how are movies made? They license and cross-license all the time. That is how movies get made. When you embed a piece of song into a movie, you license it. You cross-license it. There are regimes that exist. Fair use is not an open and shut case. There are over 100 cases that are pending right now. Mr. Raskin. All right. Let me just ask you, are we going to be able to get to the solution within the existing contours of copyright law, or do we need to legislate to address the brave new world we are in? Ms. Viswanathan. It is hard because we are at a moment right now where we want to go with a light hand because we don't want to hamper innovation. We would like to encourage licensing regimes. The thing I am concerned about, Mr. Raskin, is the small creator who can't go up against the big tech company and say, ``Help me here.'' There are also, by the way, schemes to help pay small creators. We have BMI and ASCAP standing as examples of collective rights, collective rights organizations that clear rights for people so that they can get their royalties. What exists right now? There is a lot that exist right now that we need to tap into. Mr. Raskin. OK. Thank you. Mr. Astin, I know that digital replicas are a big issue for SAG-AFTRA. You negotiated hundreds of pages of a four-year deal with the Motion Picture Association that would prevent studios from creating fake actors, as I understand it, absent some compelling reason for doing so, or replicating real ones. That seems to be more categorical; you can't do that. To get out of using living, breathing individuals on screen. Could you explain why collective bargaining agreements with provisions like those are necessary? Then, answer whether they are sufficient to protect creators from individuals using AI to replicate name, image, likeness, voice, intonation, and so on? Mr. Astin. Yes, absolutely. They are absolutely necessary because the relationship between workers and their bosses is often fraught with being taken advantage of. We are very grateful that the companies in the previous cycle when we had our big strike, but in this cycle were willing to work with us to try and figure out how to manage the fairness when it comes to digital replication and what you were talking about with synthetics. When it comes to digital replication, we are able in bargaining to achieve an understanding about how much we should be compensated. Mr. Raskin. Is that sufficient in your field? Does it cover all the people in the workforce? Mr. Astin. Well, our collective bargaining agreement is our labor. Mr. Raskin. Yes. Mr. Astin. So, no. Each different union, the writers, the directors, and the IATSE, everybody has to make their own deal. Mr. Raskin. Is everybody represented such that they could come up with a similar agreement? Mr. Astin. Everybody has to try to accomplish what we did first, which is to get meaningful artificial intelligence protections language in our bargaining. We are respected. SAG-AFTRA and our policy writers, our contract negotiating team have really been in the vanguard on this. To me, for this moment, the important thing is that it is only good for contracts that we are working with people who are signatory to our union. This NO FAKES Act and the digital replication we are talking about exists everywhere else. That is where nobody other than this body can offer the protections that we required, which is why we really appreciate you all working so hard on the piracy but on this NO FAKES Act. Mr. Raskin. Thank you. Mr. Chair, I yield back. Mr. Issa. I thank the gentleman. We now go to the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Gooden, for five minutes. Mr. Gooden. Thank you. I am impressed with the Ranking Member who can turn a Republican witness into a collective bargaining chat. Not surprised, but impressed. I actually have a question-- Mr. Issa. You do know that Ronald Reagan once sat in a similar position. It can happen. Mr. Gooden. It can happen, yes. No, we are not surprised. Professor, I was so fascinated with some of the things I have heard. These long, these LLMs, how do they ingest all this material, like these, the books we are talking about, the things you are talking about they should have paid in, so to speak, for? How do they, how do they consume all this information? Ms. Viswanathan. Think of them as the giant Hoover. They suck them up. Where do they get them? They get them, they troll the internet. They get them from various websites. As I said, it has come out in some discovery in some of the cases that they get them from pirate websites as well. In the Anthropic case, interestingly, they bought tons of books and ripped the covers off of them and copied them. It is essentially disambiguating and copying. Mr. Gooden. What are you saying--and I am not trying to be combative, I am genuinely into this--what do you say when someone, because you said you and I have to pay for these books before we read them, what would you say if I said, ``well, yes, but what if I pay for the book and give it to you?'' You are not going to then go write a check to the author, you are just going to read the book I gave you. How is that any different than me just giving a book to an LLM? Ms. Viswanathan. It is not. Who is giving it to them? I don't give them my book. I wrote a book called ``Cultivating Copyright,'' and it was uploaded to ResearchGate, a pirate website in about three minutes. I know I don't get a lot of royalties on my book, OK, but that is 200 buck-- Mr. Gooden. I am sure it was interesting, too. Ms. Viswanathan. Two hundred bucks. No, it wasn't, but it was 200 bucks. That could have been a couple Starbucks, you know. That it is a little false to say that they are--it is just like receiving a book. Sure, the first sale doctrine would say that you could receive a book. They are not receiving it. They are trawling the internet, they are finding it, and they are taking it. They are actually claiming fair use. Again I will just say, fair use means you are saying I infringed. You are not saying, I have the right to this. You are saying, I infringed but I did this for a good reason. There is an admission there that they are in fact taking stuff that is under copyright. The whole point of copyright law, y'all, is to make sure that creators get incentivized, but also that they get paid so that they keep doing what they do. Right? We all work because we love what we do, but we also need to put food on the table. Mr. Gooden. Do you think there is a solution that they would go for? Do you believe, is it your impression that they are just against any and all, no matter what? Ms. Viswanathan. No, that there have been some licensing agreements, especially in music lessons, things, for example, that have been emerging. I just think they think it is very expensive. They think that in terms of the arms race against China it might grind, put grind, put salt in the gears, and that it might slow things down. Again, I want to just emphasize that it is two industries here. We can't just talk about the cost to the tech industry; we should talk about the cost to the copyright industries. Mr. Gooden. Thank you. I enjoy hearing you. I would love to take one of your classes someday. I yield back. Mr. Issa. Would the gentleman yield? Ms. Viswanathan. Always welcome. Mr. Gooden. Take my time, sir, please. Mr. Issa. I thank you. I want to follow on the question of fair use and so on. As you see it, Doctor, clearly the right to input, in other words the right to read a book, isn't in controversy. The right to read or to learn from what is on the internet is not in controversy. The part that I want to ask all our panelists for a moment is, as we look at the absolute right to read, it would seem that we have two questions: Do you pay for which is copyrighted, similar to the way you would buy a book? That is a fairly straightforward. The cost of your books is on the cover of it, so to speak. The question, though, that I have for all of you is, once somebody has learned from, should this Committee look to the nature of the output? Because I want to go back to fair use that you cited very accurately--Shaquille O'Neal took my very words and put it in one of his rap songs, literally my voice, not my likeness but my voice. When I asked him about it one day, he looked down at me and said, ``fair use.'' I have never forgotten that I never followed up after he said it. The question, though, is should we be looking at output more than input? Meaning, some input is the result of education, meaning it doesn't look like the original input in any way, shape, or form. It is a result of learning. Some have a similarity, and some, as Rudy would say, if you will, is him, his likeness. Should that be a standard that is not in any of the current legislation, per se, relative to the injusters? I will let you quickly answer. Ms. Viswanathan. Quickly. It is tough. Mr. Issa. Each of you. Ms. Viswanathan. It is quickly, it is tough. It is complicated. Law professors' favorite answer: It is complicated. This is why I take exception to the word ``training''--when I, as the creator artist, train, I train so that I can learn things, so that I can make something new. Mr. Issa. Right. Ms. Viswanathan. Some people use AI, right, and these large language files to create new things. We should encourage that. I also think we should be restrained in saying you took something in my style. We don't want to start copyrighting style, because style is something that we want to see developed and grow. It is not something that is copyrightable, in fact. I don't think it should be. Your exact words? Boy. Maybe a short phrase was not copyrightable. If he took a paragraph from your book, that would be less likely to be fair use. Mr. Issa. It wasn't my book. Ms. Viswanathan. I know. It was you saying something. Mr. Issa. It was me saying, ``Protected by Viper. Stand back.'' Ms. Viswanathan. OK. Well, that is a tough one; right? It was a short phrase. The point stands, right, we should be able to use short phrases from each other, unless it is a trademark violation, which is another question altogether. The question about outputs is tough; right? When they are exact copies, we already have copyright to protect against that kind of infringement. It gets squishier and more difficult. The other question is, as those outputs get more and more created by prompts and less and less created by humans, do we want to copyright that stuff at all? Well, if there is some human authorship, the Copyright Office has drawn a hard line and said there needs to be an author behind that. That is the right line to draw. Mr. Issa. OK. On that note, one answer is going to have to be sufficient. We now go to the gentlelady, my friend, and indulgent to my question, Ms. Lofgren. Ms. Lofgren. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Mohr, in your testimony you note that copyright holders currently lack a targeted judicial remedy against foreign pirate sites operating beyond the reach of U.S. courts. The current law isn't effectively reaching many of the worst foreign piracy sites. That is exactly the gap that the Foreign Anti-Digital Piracy Act is intended to address. The bill is bipartisan and bicameral, and it was crafted really very carefully for more than two years, actually. I engaged with copyright holders, technology experts, service providers, and public interest advocates. After two years of sorting through various issues, it resulted in that bill, commonly known by the unlovely sounding FADPA. It is grounded in simple principle that Congress can fight online piracy without sacrificing due process, re-expression, privacy, or the open internet. Now, I have continued working with colleagues, both in the Senate and here, on discussion graphs. We are working and dialoging, trying to find a viable path forward. I would just like to mention, people have understandably raised the role that I played in SOPA so many years ago. As many of you know, I played a central role in stopping that adoption. That is not because I support piracy. I don't. It was because those proposals raised real risks to the open internet, free expression, and due process. I am hopeful that we will be able to make progress even in this Congress or, if necessary, in the next in getting something like FADPA adopted. Professor, your testimony describes judicial site blocking as kind of a no-fault process, no damages, no blame assigned, and no effort to hold providers liable for infringement. Given that, is it fair to say that Congress can provide strong liability protections for service providers that comply with the court order without also codifying broader, secondary liability rules from Cox? What do you think of that? Ms. Viswanathan. Yes, if you are asking me whether there are sufficient protections built into judicial site blocking, absolutely there are. We have been talking about it for a while now and we have seen it implemented in various countries. Yes, I think legitimate, noninfringing uses will still flourish. The question is really the bad actors, the pirate sites that we can't go after. It's whack-a-mole. Ms. Lofgren. Yes. Ms. Viswanathan. That is what we are trying to solve. Ms. Lofgren. I am interested as we noted, Congress is not usually quick to act. We have discussed the ruling in California, fair use, essentially finding that data for training models is transformative, nonexpressive and, therefore, protected. Reasonable argument can be made on the other side. Meanwhile, we are not doing much here. Now, I am wondering if anybody can address the technological protections that could be available to individuals? There can be digital watermarking. It is possible to make sites unavailable to, to AI scoping up. The question is, would Congress by rule or could the Executive by rule, or do we need to by rule enhance that opportunity for people to take technological steps to protect themselves from the Hoovering up of data? Anybody got an idea? Ms. Viswanathan. So far, it has been sort of leaky. There are watermarks and there is encryption and there are, there are ways. There are so many end runs, and that is part of the problem. One of the things Ms. Lofgren, that we could do is perhaps in- centivize companies that are creating technology, possibly by subsidizing them somewhat. The caution is fair and reasonable. We can't progress quickly. Again, we are concerned about stifling innovation. It is a very reasonable concern. The technological solutions have been--there is a will and, hopefully, where there is a will there is a way. So far, they haven't been perfect. Meanwhile, technology is moving so rapidly. Ms. Lofgren. The Copyright Office was working on what is copyrightable. Their ultimate conclusion was you have to have a human author-- Ms. Viswanathan. Right. Ms. Lofgren. --to have the protection. I agree with that. Here is the rub. If a human author is using AI to create, then they should have protection. Where do you draw the line between it is AI-generated and it is a human using AI as a tool? Unfortunately, before they reached the end of that process, the President illegally fired the Registrar and then fired the Librarian, and they have not been refilled. Do you think existing copyright law sufficiently addresses AI's role in creating? Do we need some more revision and guidance from experts in the Copyright Office, Professor? Mr. Issa. You can briefly answer that, though, but we are out of time. Ms. Viswanathan. Yes. At the moment, the Copyright Office is holding a fair line. It is basically saying to show us the human back here. If you can show us what you did, how your project--I tell my students this: Show me your prompts and I better be able to do it by doing those prompts as well. That is copyrightable. I think that is fair. It shows that the human, in fact, guided the AI. That is going to happen, like with any tool. Whether we can continue to do that or not remains to be seen. Mr. Issa. I thank the gentleladies. We go to the gentlelady from Florida, Ms. Lee. Ms. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As we hear today, the internet has created extraordinary opportunities for innovation. It has also made it easier to steal intellectual property and exploit identity through AI-generated content. As Congress considers whether our laws have kept pace, we have a responsibility to protect creators, innovators, and everyday Americans while preserving free expression and ensuring that the United States remains the global leader in AI innovation. All of you for being here today to share your insights and your expertise in helping us strike that balance. Mr. Floyd, I would like to start with you. You made the point that America should win the AI race, but not at the expense of lowering our intellectual property standards to match those of countries like China. That is exactly the right approach, that we shouldn't have to choose between innovation and protecting American creativity. As counsel to Amblin Entertainment, you have seen firsthand how much investment, planning, and talent go into bringing a project from script to screen. It is important that we recognize that uncertainty surrounding AI-generated digital replicas affects not just actors but studios, production companies, and the thousands of people whose jobs depend on the success of the creative industries. How would a clear Federal framework, like the NO FAKES Act, provide the certainty needed to continue investing in American storytelling while preserving our leadership in AI innovation? Mr. Floyd. Thank you for that question. It is a good balance. We, as other witnesses have talked about, do need to balance the interests of AI and the interests of our creative industry. The rules do that. Something like NO FAKES they carve out exceptions for bio pics, news, and documentaries, so we have a legal standard and balance so we know going in what can be used and what can't be used. We spend, a motion picture company will spend anywhere from $10-$200 million on a project. That is a huge investment. There are thousands of people who are working on it. On Disclosure they have 4,000 employees. To spend that kind of money and to hire that amount of people we need to have ground rules to know that our investment is going to be protected along the way. Balancing those with a Federal law would help that. Ms. Lee. Mr. Astin, you spoke about the impact that AI- generated digital replicas can have on performers, but also that these same technologies are increasingly being used to target everyday Americans as well. Whether it is an actor whose performance is replicated without consent, or a teacher, a veteran, a small business owner, a teenager whose voice and likeness is cloned to commit fraud or damage their reputation, the underlying harm is the same: Someone is exploiting another person's identity without permission. Would you speak to how protecting an individual's voice and likeness should be a right for all those people, but also, what you are hoping to see Congress do to make that a reality? Mr. Astin. Absolutely. Thank you so much for that. It is easy and obvious when you look at performers, if something happens with their reputation, their identity, their likeness, and their voice, the impact of their, to our business is immediate. Really what is at stake is you want to have some mechanism to stop someone from doing something harmful to you. The way you do that is Congress tells these companies you are not allowed to use a deep fake of some--to me, I don't know if it is because I have three daughters, I picture their--I guess they are getting older now. Sorry, guys. They are 29, 23, and 20. If somebody deep fakes them and there is nothing I can do about it feels so, it is so horrible. The idea that you guys could pass a law that says I can go to YouTube and say, please take this down. My daughters on their own behalf can say, please take this down. They have a law that says, well, yes, that has been established in the deep fake. That is not your identity. They can take it down. I just want to live in a world where they just can't abuse people like this. They just can't make you. It should be an outlier that someone steals your identity, your credit card identity, whatever it should be an outlier that somebody bad, there is a bad actor out there, bad behavior; right? This is so massively available to everybody to do without, just it is so simple. You just prompt a little bit. Make Sean look like he is doing this, or whatever, and it looks so realistic. Their creativity, their nefariousness can have me doing something, and we are just sitting here, that should not be allowed. It is just as plain as the nose on your face. It should not be allowed to make somebody do something or say something they didn't do or they didn't say. That goes for every American. It goes for everybody around the world. I would appreciate it if you guys would fix that for us. Ms. Lee. Mr. Astin, as a policymaker and as a parent, I agree wholeheartedly with that assessment. Thank you for your input. Mr. Chair, I yield back. Mr. Issa. I thank the gentlelady. I might have noted that a generation ago, somebody once said, ``Where do I go to get my reputation back?'' Perhaps that is a lot of what we are talking about with deep fakes. Mr. Astin. You want to hear a Shakespeare one, or it is sort of a paraphrase? Mr. Issa. If the gentlelady from North Carolina will indulge. Mr. Astin. I am sorry. Ms. Ross. I will indulge if I don't use my time. Mr. Issa. Exactly. Mr. Astin. All right. Mr. Issa. Please, sir. Mr. Astin. This is a good one. You take away my life, you take that which is beastial, you take away my reputation, and you take the immortal part of my soul. That is a paraphrase, but it sounds good. Mr. Issa. OK. You went back further than I could. With that, we go to the gentlelady from North Carolina. Ms. Ross. We have gone from the constitutional to the biblical. Mr. Francis, you haven't got much action. Many of my questions about AI have been taken. I am going to ask you the next question which, by the way, my secretary of State is very interested in because she ends up having to enforce counterfeit laws in North Carolina because there are not enough Federal resources to do it. By the way, she used to get grants to do that from the Federal Government. About 20 years ago that dried up. I want to ask you a few questions and then also ask you about who our partners should be in enforcing some of these trademark and copyright counterfeit laws. You testified that counterfeits in our supply chain pose significant risk to Americans' health and safety. They range from unsafe counterfeit auto parts, dangerous technology knockoffs, poisonous prescription drugs, and toxic personal care products. What happens when counterfeits steal the goodwill that legitimate companies have spent decades building, and use it to sell products that put customers' health and safety at risk? How would the SHOP Act help with that? Mr. Francis. Well, I will start with the partnerships. The secretary of State in North Carolina, there are so many task forces at the State and local levels that do tremendous amount of work. Yes, ma'am, you are right, the Bureau of Justice Assistance grants that were available for almost 25 years have essentially been stopped funding these task forces which have a significant impact on enforcing intellectual property. We would love to see the support of that, bringing these grants back, because we know the consequences without the Bureau of Justice Assistance grants. Yes, these counterfeit goods remain to be an extreme problem, especially with the health and safety risks to the American consumers. It is very difficult to assess the entirety of the issue. When we are looking at these marketplaces that have these anonymous foreign sellers that are just selling goods online, there's very few effective ways to take them down from State and local law enforcement. Something we have seen as a very useful tool, our Schedule A litigation. This allows a rights holder to file a lawsuit and join all these anonymous foreign sellers online in an effort to recover some of the losses to them. As it relates to the SHOP SAFE act, from a consumer's perspective I can answer it that way. I would, as a consumer, expect to understand where the origin of these products came from. Most consumers believe that there is a continuous monitoring of these sellers online. We would love to have and see continuous vetting of these sellers and where the products came from. Ms. Ross. Right. Basically, there has not been effective enforcement, either at the Federal level or now it is pretty much unfunded at the State level. We are leaving it up to State legislatures to decide whether or not they are going to give State law enforcement the tools they need. Is that correct? Mr. Francis. That is correct. Ms. Ross. That is unfortunate. That is something Congress could do; right? Mr. Francis. Yes. I will speak for the entire IP industry. The grants that are provided to State and locals are incredibly valuable. Today with the priorities of the Federal Government there is no one more important than State level law enforcement that are actually doing the work on the ground each and every day. Ms. Ross. Great. Thank you so much. I do want to pick up on something that the Chair asked about the output. Because we have been focusing a lot on the input, and we have had this Anthropic lawsuit. I took copyright law when I was in--and I had David Lange at Duke University who taught me copyright law. It was so much fun. We started with Ansel Adams. I want to talk about the output because I know that the Copyright Office is coming up with rules for what is produced and whether or not there is human content. Professor, could you tell us a little bit about how we could apply copyright law from derivative works to this? Because it seems to me that if you are actually using something that somebody else had, you should have gotten the license in the first place. It wasn't fair use. Then, it is considered a derivative work. A derivative work has to have the attribution and all those other things. I am going to ask for indulgence for the answer to that question. Ms. Viswanathan. Great question. Definitely a product of Professor Lange's excellent instruction. It is a good question. Derivative works are works that come from other works; right? As a copyright holder you have rights in your own derivative works. For example, the translation of your book, right, you have that right. If AI is being used to create a work that is clearly a derivative work, we have the copyright law now. We keep talking about how we want to amend the Copyright Act, now 50 years old. That is fair. There are new things that need to come into play. Let's use the tools we have now. The derivative rights--right is an important part of it. It is an important part of it. It is not the only part of it. The tough question becomes what if somebody creates something that is close but not the same? We want to encourage that, but we also want to say you can't come too close; right? You can't take where the authorship is. What did I put into that thing that made me the author? Author, by the way, can talk about a musician or anybody else creative. Copyright law exists and has been enforced for 50 years successfully. We can apply it to this space and the question of derivative works. Ms. Ross. Thank you very much. I yield back. Mr. Issa. I thank the gentlelady. I now ask for unanimous consent that a letter statement from the Entertainment Software Association be placed in the record. Additionally, we will be placing in the record the Fifth Circuit decision in Vetter v. Resnik, since it has been included so much as a part of this hearing. Without objection, so ordered. We now go to the gentleman from South Carolina for five minutes. Mr. Fry. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for having this hearing. Thank you, guys, for being here today. I appreciate your testimony. Mr. Astin, the actors that you represent are generally not the copyright owners in the films and television shows in which they appear. Can you explain how piracy, however, impacts you or the members that you represent? Is the adoption of site blocking in the U.S. important to those members, and why? Mr. Astin. We see our work exhibited in places like on YouTube and around the world where they have not made an agreement with the people who hold the copyrights. We are powerless in two directions. We are powerless to go to those big companies and get them to compensate us according to our contracts. The people we have the contracts with, don't seem to be doing anything about it. That is actually true. Yesterday, a lawsuit was filed and so we are very--we are looking forward to it. We are on the business end of a lot of this stuff, and we don't have a lot of control. We do the best we can to negotiate the best deals that we can. Then, we hope that the companies we are in business with advocate for the protection of their IP. We really want them to be good at that. Mr. Fry. Would site blocking be something that you and your members would like to see and appreciate? Would that have an impact for your members? Mr. Astin. Well, just as I said, the ability for our employers who we have our collective bargaining with to successfully impose the law or that copyright, to protect their copyright, if that mechanism, or that tool is going to help them, then we are all for it, absolutely. Mr. Fry. From a global perspective, It has been testified today that we were a leader, and maybe still are in some aspects, but were a leader in establishing standards for strong IP. We have got some catching up to do. That if we were to do something, create a more robust system to target these offshore criminal actors, could you explain what this would mean for the U.S. generally, and our ability to maintain the status as that global leader in creativity and innovation? Mr. Astin. My colleagues would probably speak to it better than I would. I was pretty moved by what I heard here today about the other 60 countries that are collaborators in other areas and are accomplishing in this space. I would rather hear their experts in that. Mr. Fry. Mr. Francis, IP House and Digital Citizens Alliance issued a report in April exploring the growing connection between global organized crime and online piracy. What are some of your top line observations of that, to the U.S. economy and also to our citizens? Mr. Francis. Yes, the joint publication, ``Organized Piracy and Crime'' just reiterated that. We are seeing a shift toward criminal organization syndicates. When the profits are very high and the risks are very low we are seeing a significant amount of bad actors organized in many ways. We showed that these are criminal organizations because they have a structure, they have operators, they have supply chains, they have ways to finance the funds, and they have IT technology significantly impacting the way that these networks need to be looked at. Right? The United Nations, INTERPOL, Europol all said that these types of behaviors are more toward indicators of organized crime syndicates. Mr. Fry. How does it affect our citizens, though? How does that translates to the average person in South Carolina, or New York, or California that are not directly involved with these criminal syndicates, or in the film industries, T.V., or whatever? How does it affect normal Americans and citizens? Mr. Francis. The effect is the malware that they are watching these unpaid or paid subscriptions that are illicit and piracy, that the malware that they are downloading impacts them because there is a significant amount of data that shows that they are also victims of identity theft. It could also show that there is probably not enough education and awareness around this issue. This report with the Digital Citizens Alliance really highlights the importance of education around this area of digital piracy which has a significant economic impact really across all sectors and around the world. Mr. Fry. Thank you for that. Mr. Floyd, really quick as we wrap up. What are the online effects or the effects of online piracy on the economics of film and television productions from the industry itself, to the workers, to the legitimate streaming sites, and even our citizens? What are the effects? Mr. Floyd. The impact will hit both the company in deciding what movies to make and how often to make them. It will impacts their workers and how many people get hired and paid. It also impacts people like Mr. Astin's group who have already made a movie. What happens is when someone streams it online and pays for it legitimately, we automatically share a portion of those revenues with the Screen Actors Guild, with the directors, and with all those people who worked on the movie. That gives them a buffer for when they are not working. It is sort of like a mini retirement plan. If we are not receiving that money, we don't have the money to share. They end up making less money along the way for the work they have already done. It impacts us and our ability to hire new people. It impacts them and their ability to make a living off the work they have already done. Mr. Fry. In effect, a lot of starving actors in L.A., but the stereotype is that they are baristas first or bartenders. You are saying that we might actually see a scenario where they are making less as an actor than a barista or a bartender? Mr. Floyd. Absolutely. When there are millions of dollars gone and then we are unable to share, they are losing a lot of money. Mr. Fry. Thank you for that. Mr. Chair, I see my time has expired. I yield back. Mr. Issa. I thank the gentleman. We now go to the gentlelady from California for five minutes. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to start by saying that I am glad that we are finally having a hearing on the issue of IP. From my district's perspective, today is the day when we are actually talking about issues that the American people care about. We have had 12 hearings in this Subcommittee, and this is the first one on this issue. The videos that were played at the beginning are a testament to the critical nature of this topic. I actually hope we have more hearings, because each of these topics deserve their own hearing. This is personal to me. My district includes Los Angeles and Culver City. It is home to actors, and musicians, writers, journalists, content creators, video game developers, and everyday Americans. For these and more of my constituents their voice, their image, their likeness, and their performance, that is their livelihood. AI we know can create opportunities, but it can also be used to profit off humans' identities, their voices, and their likeness. I am also reminded of a theme in ``Anaconda'' between these two, Paul Rudd's character and Jack Black's character. Paul Rudd's character says, ``Who cares about IP?'' Black's response is, ``Literally everyone. That is what big movies are about. That is why we are here.'' I am also going to make a plug for my Republican colleagues to join on as a cosponsor to the NO FAKES Act. The NO FAKES Act includes exclusions for documentaries, news, commentary, satire, parody, and fleeting uses as well as safe harbors for multipurpose creative tools, unless they are primarily designed to produce unauthorized digital replicas. The video game industry has raised some good faith concerns that because games rely on fictional characters, background characters, and user-created avatars, that the bill could unintentionally capture lawful content or expose developers to claims based on incidental resemblance. Mr. Floyd, how can Congress make sure that the bill doesn't sweep in fictional characters, incidental likenesses, or legitimate tools that are used in these interactive games? Mr. Floyd. Well, as long as there are guidelines in the legislation to help guide where everyone moves forward on it, it would be helpful. There are under the copyright laws now you could have incidental uses or uses that are similar. It is the substantiality of what goes on. The legislation talks about that, it will help give guidance to everybody as to know. If there is one background actor that looks similar, maybe that is not enough. If it is an exact, one exact replica wouldn't be too much, but many that are similar might be too much. You have that balancing act with those guidelines. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you for that. This has come up about counterfeiters. Mr. Francis, I know you don't know this about me, but I support the resale marketplace in a very real way. Trusted resale marketplaces are incredibly important. One problem is that bad actors use online spaces to traffic counterfeit goods. We talked about pharmaceuticals. It really harms consumers and legitimate businesses. We do need policies to crack down on counterfeiters while clearly distinguishing organized counterfeit trafficking from lawful resale. Mr. Francis, how do counterfeiters exploit the ambiguity between legitimate resale and sale of infringing goods online? Why is consumer confusion so important to mitigate in this context? Mr. Francis. Yes, thank you, Congresswoman, it is just deliberate deception. That confusion really is the goal of these counterfeiters. It is very challenging when you are a consumer and trying to distinguish between what is real, what is fake, the listings, the reviews. These are very extremely deliberate. Of course, extremely challenging for a consumer. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Uh-huh. Mr. Francis. Yes, we are very much in favor of the recommerce platforms. It is a growing market. It is one that really needs to pay particular attention what other marketplaces have been dealing with in the sense of they have also been deceived, these marketplaces by this resale market. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Uh-huh. Mr. Francis. Yes, it is very, especially with antiques and luxury brands and other products that I think are growing in this space. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Right. Right. Mr. Floyd, in the remaining time I have left, about piracy. How much traffic do pirated websites receive? Outside of copyrighted content being stolen, what are the harms that consumers face when they enter these sites and are asked to enter personal information to access the content? Mr. Floyd. I don't have the exact numbers on the traffic. If I could get it, I will get back to you. It is massive though. Because when you get on one of these sites you type in watch disclosure there, you think you are going to a regular site and then you end up on one of these pirate sites that has thousands of movies that are available. What happens, then, is the consumer thinks it is a legitimate site. It looks like Netflix. It has thumbnail photographs of everything. It has the list of people who worked on the movie. You think you are on a legitimate site, and you type in your credit card. When you type in your credit card that money is now used for all kinds of nefarious purposes. Also, there is malware that is on the ads. If you click on one of those you are now impacted that way. Then, they steal your credit card information. You, as a regular, innocent consumer have now been detrimentally harmed for trying to watch one movie online. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you for that. Mr. Chair, I would like to enter it. I ask unanimous consent to enter into the record a statement from the Motion Picture Association before this Subcommittee on this particular hearing topic. Mr. Issa. Without objection, so ordered. Ms. Kamlager-Dove. Thank you so much. Mr. Issa. I want to thank the gentlelady for her comments. The 12 hearings we have done, some have been clearly, many have been on IP, but the fact that this one focuses on piracy specifically, I take note that I, if I had it to do over again, would have done more and I would have done it sooner. With that, I will recognize myself for my five minutes. Five minutes isn't enough to deal with all the issues were are dealing with. I think that is clear. I am going to ask all of you to please revise, extend, give us your thoughts. Doctor, we will take it all, even though we couldn't have it all here. I want to focus on a couple of things. First, it is clear that we have some laws that the courts have found they are unable to use effectively. Mr. Mohr, I am going to ask you a tough one, one that you may not have actually come prepared for. In the ClearCorrect case, the Fed Circuit limited the ITC from enforcing essentially what we have been talking about here. They can't enforce that which comes in from outside the country which is intangible. I am going to ask you and then the others, as we look to do site blocking and the other enforcements, including and notwithstanding States that try to enforce Federal law or contracts, should we be looking to empower organizations like the ITC, and any other existing body to, in fact, have the ability to deal in this growing thing of intangible or nonphysical property in a way that would allow for a broader enforcement of our laws? I use that example because it is frustrating. Most of us didn't know until that case that the ITC can tell Customs to seize the fake DVD, but they can't seize the incoming, if you will, fake product. When we talk about site blocking, if the ITC had that authority perhaps they would have already done it. I will start with you, Mr. Mohr. Mr. Mohr. You weren't kidding about that being a tough question. What I would say is this: I think when you look at site, I think a couple of things. First, putting aside the merits of the decision itself, right, if you are looking, my mind would go to what the remedy is. In that sense what would the ITC have to do to stop this? They couldn't issue an order in the abstract. They would have to find someone, an entity, and tell it, OK, you might not be doing this conduct, but you must cease enabling it. That is, essentially, where site--that is site blocking. Right? The question then becomes for us, the questions would become what the guardrails are and whether they are appropriate. Mr. Issa. Absolutely. I am not going to claim that Ways and Means and we wouldn't have a lot to do. Mr. Francis, I am going to stay on this line because it is the one thing we didn't cover. The ports of entry into America are Baltimore, Los Angeles, Seattle, et cetera. The port of entry for products that are worth countless billions, literally trillions of dollars, in fact, today is the internet. Are we to a great extent looking at the customs process coming into the United States of product that has not been paid for, product that is, in fact, counterfeit, are we looking at customs in the broadest sense having to be expanded to include intangible? Should that be the work of this and the other Committees in the foreseeable future? Mr. Francis. Yes, Mr. Chair, I do think that nontangible items have been a concern. When I was even the Director of the IPR Center, we didn't really focus our efforts there. I do think that there could be some legislative and enforcement frameworks that could be built around that to ensure that we can do something beyond just the tangible items that we are seizing at the ports of entry. Mr. Issa. Quickly, Mr. Floyd, would you say that, in fact, the problem is bigger than today's hearing and bigger than this Committee's jurisdiction if we do that? Mr. Floyd. Yes. It is a massive problem. We are very happy that this Committee is working on it, but it will go much beyond this. Yes. Mr. Issa. Mr. Astin, you have been a superb witness. I am a fan of your work before you had this job. You mentioned support for deep fakes. Mr. Mohr and others have shown us some areas where there could be some unintended problems. Is it your position that if we can find the solutions that meet the goal of deep fakes that, in fact, you would be equally supportive as an organization to that, as long as we can get to it? Mr. Astin. Well, I will do you one better. I have been watching for three years our team and the other incredible coalitions work hard to meet every single one of these potential concerns with openness and creativity. I mentioned YouTube. YouTube is part of this coalition. OpenAI is part of this coalition. Is it complex? Yes, it is very, very complex. They know their--as far as I am concerned, the core, the essence of this NO FAKES Act is to protect people's identity. I have actually been reading, learning, and watching some podcasts about all your laws, all these kinds of enterprises. Phew, that is a different lifetime. This sausage is coming together nice, from my point of view. I feel like the group that is here and the group that you are working with will do it. Of course, SAG-AFTRA stands foursquare behind getting NO FAKES passed into law. Mr. Issa. Mr. Mohr, I would like you to be able to close on where you think we can get to the goal of deep fakes and other legislation, and where the challenges remain? Mr. Mohr. The challenge, when we talk about the challenges, I list four. I am going to focus on two. The first one is preemption. What we don't want is a situation where the rights are uneven. That leads to uncertainty both for individuals and for the developers of these tools, some of whom are now the subject of State statutes that would purport to create standards for them. That should be in the domain of digital replicas, a matter of Federal law. The second thing I would want to mention is that for us the counter-notification piece of this. Which is, I come back to something Mr. Astin said before in that there was a situation where a friend of his had a video and he simply couldn't tell who, whether it was real or not. There are instances where there will be things that are real and we can't yet tell the difference. In those circumstances, we should take care to ensure that those particular instances of expression remain available as best we can. Mr. Issa. Good, succinct. I understand that you have a unanimous consent. The gentleman is recognized. Mr. Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I ask unanimous consent to enter into the record a letter from the Council for Innovation Promotion supporting the NO FAKES Act, the SHOP SAFE Act, and judicial site blocking legislation. Mr. Issa. Without objection, so ordered. In closing, this is in fact not our last, and not this Committee's last hearing on this subject. Hopefully, though, it will be the last one before some of this legislation begins to move. I think that, in fact, people you have seen on both sides of this hearing are close. The issues that Mr. Mohr mentioned are of great concern but they do seem to be surmountable. I am going to make one closing statement. Rights of the Chair, if you will. This legislation is going to, if I have my way, move under my watch. It means that those who have said they are close, they are not opposed to it but they want to, we are going to test that. Which is that enough is known, language is being distributed on what we believe is final compromises to get to legislation. It is going to be my intention, with the help of my Chair and old friend, Mr. Jordan, that we will move it out of this Committee. I say so today because I think all of you have made the case that allowing this continued damage is simply no longer possible. I am going to further close by saying just one thing, which is I started in the era of protecting my trademarks. I certainly understood the standard for confusion as to source was all you really had to prove that you had it infringed. It shocked me many years later--Professor, you know the history of this--but, that we didn't use that standard in the courts. Having said that, if the courts aren't willing to use trademarks for likeness, then we will have to give them authority and the mandate to do so. That will be the goal of this Committee. The part I have to say at the close is simply that we will have five legislative days, which with our current schedule could give you a lot more than five days, to accept additional statements here, and questions for all of you, and then a reasonable time to respond. Will all of you agree to take those questions and answer them to the best of your ability. [Affirmative answers.] Mr. Issa. Thank you all. You have been very generous with your time. This Committee, the Subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:35 p.m., the Subcommittee was adjourned.] All materials submitted for the record by Members of the Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, and the Internet can be found at: https://docs.house.gov/Committee/Calendar/ByEvent .aspx?EventID=119417. [all]