Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-350] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-350 FROM FRAUD TO RECOVERY: RESTORING INTEGRITY IN SMALL BUSINESS PROGRAMS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP OF THE UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ FEBRUARY 25, 2026 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISIHING OFFICE 63-360 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS ---------- JONI ERNST, Iowa, Chair EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts, Ranking Member JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho MARIA CANTWELL, Washington RAND PAUL, Kentucky JEANNE SHAHEEN, New Hampshire TIM SCOTT, South Carolina CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey TODD YOUNG, Indiana CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii TED BUDD, North Carolina JACKY ROSEN, Nevada JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah JOHN W. HICKENLOOPER, Colorado JAMES C. JUSTICE, West Virginia ADAM B. SCHIFF, California JON HUSTED, Ohio Meredith West, Republican Staff Director Sean Moore, Democratic Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- FEBRUARY 25, 2026 Opening Statements Page Joni Ernst, U.S. Senator from Iowa, Chair........................ 1 Edward J. Markey, U.S. Senator from Massachusetts, Ranking Member 3 Witnesses The Honorable William W. Kirk, Inspector General, U.S. Small Business Administration........................................ 5 Prepared Statement........................................... 7 Mr. Kenneth Dieffenbach, Executive Director, Pandemic Response Accountability Committee (PRAC)................................ 19 Prepared Statement........................................... 21 Additional Letters/Statements for the Record U.S. Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship Letter to the Administrator of the U.S. Small Business Administration Dated January 8, 2026........................... 48 Questions for the Record William W. Kirk Responses to Questions Submitted by Chair Ernst and Senator Scott.............................................. 52 Kenneth Dieffenbach Responses to Questions Submitted by Chair Ernst and Senator Scott........................................ 56 FROM FRAUD TO RECOVERY: RESTORING INTEGRITY IN SMALL BUSINESS PROGRAMS ---------- WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 25, 2026 United States Senate, Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, Washington, DC. The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 2:32 p.m., in Room 428A, Russell Senate Office Building, Hon. Joni Ernst, chairwoman of the committee, presiding. Present: Senators Ernst [presiding], Young, Hawley, Markey, Shaheen, Hirono, and Rosen. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ERNST Chair. I call the Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship to order. Nearly 6 years ago, the Small Business Administration's pandemic relief programs provided a much-needed lifeline for small businesses in Iowa and across America. Millions of small business owners and their employees were saved from closure and mass layoffs thanks to Paycheck Protection Program and Economic Injury Disaster Loan funds awarded by the SBA. But as we've seen time and again, when government funds seemed free for the taking, bad actors are ready to steal and scam. Government programs should never be able to be exploited at the American taxpayers' expense in the first place. However, the lack of oversight mechanisms in SBA's COVID relief programs coupled with the quick disbursement of funds to save shuttered businesses allowed swindlers to rob taxpayers of $200 billion in pandemic relief loans. The Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, or PRAC, sounded the alarm years ago on how allowing applicants to self- certify their eligibility increases fraud. Self-certification allows the government to rely on an applicant's promise that they meet program requirements. The SBA Office of Inspector General repeatedly echoed their concerns about this system. Unfortunately, for taxpayers, the Biden administration ignored repeated watchdog warnings, allowing blanket forgiveness without additional verification on PPP loans under $150,000, and potentially allowing a large swath of fraud to escape meaningful scrutiny. Self-certification was known to be a major problem as more pandemic relief programs were created. Consider the Restaurant Revitalization Fund, or RRF, and Shuttered Venue Operators Grant, the SVOG programs. These opened a menu of fraud for the taking. In 2024, music artist Chris Brown exploited these awards to the tune of $10 million. Half of these funds were paid directly to the singer himself. Additional funds were spent on an $80,000 birthday party. The SBA never should have been running a drive-through for fraudsters. However, even though the RRF program had a 20-location limit for franchisees restaurant chain, CoreLife eatery with 29 locations still got served $7.8 million from our taxpayers that it never should have been allowed to receive. But talk about fast fraud made to order, one Oregon dentist known for illegally distributing pharmaceuticals, used his personal address and fictitious restaurant names in Florida to generate nearly $8 million in RRF payments. To date, the PRAC has diligently helped law enforcement partners expose more than $2.4 million--or excuse me, billion, with a B, $2.4 billion in estimated fraud loss. IG Kirk's recent appointment as PRAC chair highlights how critical it remains to claw back these funds, especially across SBA programs. Last July, the SBA OIG flagged an astonishing $544 million of potential improper payments in the SVOG program. Yet, the Biden administration continued ignoring the program. Ultimately, officials from the previous administration did not refer a single case to the Treasury. Fraudsters can't be left off the hook just because time has passed. Congress must pass my SBA Fraud Enforcement Extension Act to extend the statutes of limitations for SVOG and RRF programs, and give investigators the time they need to continue going after crooks. Without my legislation, as soon as April, fraudsters who stole funds will escape justice. You heard me right folks, in just a little over a month, many of the swindlers who took advantage of some SBA COVID relief programs can no longer be prosecuted. The good news is my statute of limitations bill has already passed the House and this committee; it is now pending before the full Senate. I call on Democrats to stop blocking this legislation so there can be real accountability. I am grateful the current administration knows that the job is not finished. The SBA is conducting manual reviews of more than 10,000 RRF awards, totaling over $3 billion. Just over 1,000 of these awardees did not submit the required post-award report documenting how the money was spent. SBA also sent demand letters to an additional 8,000 awardees who were not a part of the manual review and never submitted a post-award report totaling over $1.2 billion in RRF disbursements. Additionally, last year, the SBA issued hundreds of demand letters to SVOG grant recipients. The total grant value of recipients who have not responded totals over $150 million. The SBA has been dealt an incredibly difficult hand reviewing the entirety of both programs before the statutes of limitations and referring all fraud to investigators. This critical work must continue. A few weeks ago, Administrator Loeffler suspended more than 110,000 California borrowers who took home over $8.5 billion in potentially fraudulent COVID relief funds. The recent fraud investigations in Minnesota have uncovered at least $9 billion from State and Federal programs, including $400 million in PPP loans, and Administrator Loeffler acted quickly to remedy this issue. Republican members of this committee sent a letter to Administrator Loeffler earlier this year, applauding her work to shut down these schemes. I ask unanimous consent to enter into the record our January 8th letter requesting information from the SBA on its efforts to uncover fraud in the SBA programs. Without objection so ordered. I look forward to hearing from our Federal watchdog partners today on how they are tackling fraud and recovering taxpayers' hard earned dollars. Thank you for your service, and I look forward to hearing your testimony. I now recognize Ranking Member Markey for his opening statement. STATEMENT OF SENATOR MARKEY Senator Markey. Yeah. Thank you, Madam Chair. Last night, President Trump declared a war on fraud. While fraud must be taken seriously, the Trump administration has shown it is only interested in weaponizing fraud for political gain, and last night was a clear example of that. Trump said the Somali community in Minnesota is plundering America and has pillaged $19 billion from the American taxpayer. You know, Trump lied and cynically weaponized fraud to demonize immigrants. Trump is falsely pointing the finger at immigrants while facing no accountability for his own behavior that enriches himself and his family. Trump said last night, if we're able to find enough of that fraud, we'll actually have a balanced budget overnight. That level of fraud does not exist, and it should trouble every American because what it really means is that Trump will use isolated incidents of fraud to punish his perceived enemies, and the attacks have already begun. Last month, the Trump administration used fraud as a pretext for freezing funding for childcare and low-income assistance programs, threatened to withhold Federal Medicaid funds, and ordered a review of Federal funding for Democratic-controlled states. These are not actions of a President fighting fraud. This is a President determined to make life miserable for anyone who doesn't support him. All the while, DOGE has been accessing American's sensitive data. We recently learned DOGE employees illegally funneled voter data to an organization pushing disproven conspiracy theories of widespread election fraud. We still don't know if sensitive data at SBA was compromised by DOGE because our committee has never been briefed on DOGE's activities at the SBA, and that is unacceptable. If the President cared about fraud, would he be doling out billion-dollar contracts to his cronies. Would he solicit donations for his gold-plated ballroom from companies that do billions of dollars of business with the Federal Government? Would he grant pardons to criminals convicted of money laundering, bank fraud, and wire fraud who have connections to him and to his administration? And we are just 1 year removed from the night President Trump illegally fired 17 independent watchdogs, including Mike Ware at the SBA. Are these the actions of a President serious about fraud? Or are those the actions of an administration where corruption is self-dealing are the norm? There's an old saying that hypocrisy is the tribute that vice pays to virtue. And so, yeah, we now have Donald Trump paying vice, paying tribute to the rooting out of fraud while at the same time. That is a good way of describing the entirety of his administration. And that's the hypocrisy I think that really bothers people even as they see the President up there trying to demonize a small number of people and promising that eradicating that level of fraud will balance the budget when he knows that is not true. Today's hearing is about fraud at the SBA, and we know that bad actors took advantage of some of these COVID programs. We don't deny that, and we must hold them accountable. Absolutely. But let's be very clear about when that fraud occurred. Take the Economic Injury Disaster program or the EIDL program, for example. Of the approximately 4 million loans issued during the pandemic, more than 3.7 million of those loans, or more than 90 percent of the loans, were approved in 2020 by the Trump administration itself, 90 percent of the loans that we're going to be looking at. So, when we hear about fraud today, let's keep in mind who was on watch when it happened, and Democrats and Republicans should stand up and acknowledge actual fraud wherever and whenever it occurs, and not just when it is politically convenient to do so. So, if we're serious about protecting taxpayer dollars, policing fraud should not become a farce where those in power give themselves a pass and use investigations to exact revenge on their political counterparts. The Trump administration abuses of Minnesota and other Democratic-led states like my home state of Massachusetts, which he mentioned last night, demonstrate exactly why we need real independent oversight at all levels of government. So, I thank you Madam Chair. I thank you for holding this hearing, and I look forward to hearing from our witnesses. Chair. Thank you, Ranking Member Markey. I do want to extend a warm welcome to our witnesses, and I'm thankful that you took time out of your busy schedules to share your expertise and insight with this committee. And, first, Mr. William Kirk serves as the inspector general for the Small Business Administration. Mr. Kirk was sworn in as SBA inspector general in early January, and has extensive experience in strengthening internal controls and combating fraud, waste, and abuse in his three decades of leadership across higher education, also private enterprise, and the Federal Government. So, yeah, thank you for your service. He earned his bachelor of business administration in accountancy and juris doctorate degrees from the University of Notre Dame. Mr. Kirk, I would also like to congratulate you on your recent appointment as chair of the Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, effective March 1. I am confident that you will continue to shine a spotlight on the pandemic-era relief programs, and work across the investigative community to recover funds and bring fraudsters to justice. Next, Mr. Ken Dieffenbach. Mr. Dieffenbach serves as the third executive director of the Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, or PRAC, and brings over 28 years of experience in the oversight community. As executive director, Mr. Dieffenbach leads the PRAC's efforts to support and coordinate oversight of the pandemic response, enhance transparency, and use data to detect fraud, waste, and abuse. Mr. Dieffenbach earned his bachelor's degree in business from the Citadel and a graduate degree in criminal justice from the University of Alabama at Birmingham. Thank you again. Briefly, I'd like to take a moment to explain our lighting system to our witnesses. There are three lights in front of you. Green means go, yellow means you need to wrap it up pretty quick, and red means to conclude your remarks. I ask unanimous consent that the witness's full statements be included in the record, and without objection, so ordered. As your written testimony has been made part of the record, the committee asks that you limit your oral remarks to 5 minutes. And with that, Mr. Kirk, you are recognized for 5 minutes for your testimony. STATEMENT OF MR. WILLIAM ``BILL'' KIRK, INSPECTOR GENERAL, U.S. SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Chair Ernst, Ranking Member Markey, and distinguished members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. It is a great honor to represent the Office of Inspector General at the U.S. Small Business Administration and the dedicated auditors, sworn law enforcement investigators, analysts, and support professionals who work every day to protect taxpayer dollars and promote integrity across SBAs programs. The SBA OIG operates independently under the Inspector General Act of 1978. Our mandate is straightforward, but consequential; we conduct objective oversight, grounded in evidence to detect and deter fraud, waste, and abuse, and to strengthen SBA program integrity through actionable recommendations and transparent reporting. While the acute economic phase of the COVID-19 pandemic has passed, oversight has not oversight, the scale and speed of SBAs pandemic response was unprecedented. To avert an economic crisis caused by lockdowns, business closures, and other impediments, SBA dispersed approximately $1.2 trillion in pandemic economic assistance. The response delivered critical relief to millions of legitimate small businesses, but it also created opportunities for fraudsters to exploit internal control vulnerabilities. Fraudsters stole identity information, created synthetic identities, duplicated information to exploit programs, all this to exploit to--they exploited programs meant to help those in need. Today I'm going to focus on three areas central to the committee's oversight responsibilities. First, the systemic risks within the 8(a) Business Development Program and the importance of eligibility oversight. Secondly, the underperformance in post-award monitoring within the Restaurant Revitalization Fund, also known as RRF, and the Shuttered Venue Operators Grant, known as SVOG, or SVOG awards, and the recovery of funds that were improperly or fraudulently dispersed. Third, the necessity of extending the statute of limitations to 10 years for RRF and SVOG fraud, which would match the statute enacted for the Paycheck Protection Program, PPP, and COVID-19 Economic Injury Disaster Loan, or idle fraud. These issues are interconnected. They all reflect the same underlying principle; when program eligibility is not rigorously verified, when red flags are not fully resolved, or when enforcement timelines are misaligned with investigative realities, the American taxpayer bears the risk. Our office has continued to identify indicators of potential ineligibility, unresolved fraud flags, and delayed recovery actions in certain pandemic programs. At the same time, we have seen the benefits of strength and controls, improved inter-agency data-sharing, and enhanced investigative coordination through partnerships such as with the Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, known as the PRAC. Oversight is not about revisiting the urgency of 2020. Rather, it is about ensuring that the structural lessons from that period translate into stronger controls today and in the future. Under my leadership, SBA OIG will continue to exercise independent judgment, pursue complex fraud investigations, wherever the evidence leads us, we'll issue recommendations to strengthen internal controls, and we pledge to keep this committee fully informed of risks, corrective actions, and measurable outcomes. The work before us requires persistence, sufficient time to investigate potential fraud, and a sustained commitment to integrity. I appreciate the committee's engagement on these matters, and I look forward to discussing them in greater detail. Thank you very much. [The prepared statement of Mr. Kirk follows.] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chair. Thank you very much. Mr. Dieffenbach, you're recognized for 5 minutes for your testimony. STATEMENT OF MR. KENNETH DIEFFENBACH, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, PANDEMIC RESPONSE ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE (PRAC) WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. Dieffenbach. Thank you. Chair Ernst, Ranking Member Markey, members of the committee, it is an honor to be here today to discuss the Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, or PRAC, and our work to investigate fraud and improve fraud prevention across Federal programs, including funds intended to help small businesses. PRAC's success would not be possible without strong partnerships like the one we have with the Small Business Administration, OIG. Thanks to Congress, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act extended the PRAC and its data analytics capability until 2034, provided $88 million in funding and expanded our jurisdiction to programs funded in the law. Operating an annual budget of approximately 18.5 and a half million dollars, to date, the PRAC has helped recover well over $500 million for the taxpayer. As executive director of the PRAC, an entity Congress created to oversee over $5 trillion in relief funding, I work with a phenomenal team that is leveraging artificial intelligence to collect, organize, and analyze data to rapidly provide insights into fraud risks. This proactive approach is clearly needed so that fraud is prevented before funds are dispersed. This past summer, the PRAC issued two fraud alerts that identified over $79 billion in potential fraud that could have been prevented with pre-award vetting and cross-agency coordination. To address these issues, the PRAC is developing an artificial intelligence enabled fraud prevention engine, trained on 5 million pandemic applications and other data, the tool can quickly identify anomalies, trends, patterns, and hidden connections in applications before payment. Our access to law enforcement sensitive and other unique data, over 119 million applications for pandemic aid and over 127,000 known or suspected pandemic fraud cases can reveal powerful new insights and serve as an early warning system of organized, often transnational, criminal conspiracies and other emerging threats. Had our fraud prevention engine been in existence in March of 2020, pre-award vetting would've flagged at least tens of billions of dollars in fraudulent claims for further scrutiny, allowing agencies again to prevent fraud. One of the many lessons of the pandemic is that fraudsters rarely target just one government program, they exploit vulnerabilities wherever they exist. This is why the PRAC uniquely focuses on cross program and cross agency risks. For example, in one project we found over 40,000 instances where the same person appears to have reported a low income to obtain housing benefits and also a high income to obtain small business administration benefits. These anomalies indicate potential fraud in more than $860 million in PPP loans, and they were likely caused by identity theft or other types of fraud schemes in one or both of the programs. Now, most importantly, it also means that legitimate beneficiaries likely lost out on benefits that they needed and deserved to have. The PRAC also works across--works with OIGs to develop analytics tools that provide new insights and prove effectiveness of oversight. For example, we recently developed a risk dashboard for the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation OIG, that to date has contributed to them recovering over $260 million. And we just launched a similar dashboard for the Federal Communications Commission OIG, which aggregates data related to $11 billion in disbursements to 14,000 entities that will allow them to provide more effective oversight. The PRAC also provides investigative support to more than 50 law enforcement partners related to 1200 investigations with 24,000 subjects and well over the $2.4 billion, Chair, that you referenced in your opening statement. In one of the tens of thousands of pandemic fraud cases, we identified one PPP scheme involving more than 450 applications from over 100 individuals across 24 states. This is but one example where the proactive use of data and technology could have prevented or aided in the early detection of a scheme, mitigated the need for a resource intensive investigation and prosecution, and helped ensure taxpayer dollars went to the intended recipients and not the fraudsters. Every dollar that goes to a fraudster does not go to the recipients that Congress intended the programs to help including small businesses, the unemployed, and veterans. With the support of Congress, we'll continue our work on behalf of the taxpayers to investigate fraud and demonstrate the value and effectiveness of fraud prevention. Thank you again for the opportunity to be here today and for your continued support of the PRAC, the IG community, and independent oversight. This concludes my prepared remarks. I look forward to answering your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Dieffenbach follows.] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chair. Thank you very much to our witnesses. And now, we will move into the question, answer session and I will recognize myself for 5 minutes. So, Mr. Kirk, we'll start with you. Reports from your office state SBA identified $544 million in potential improper payments in the SVOG or SVOG program and $522 million in the RRF program. Yet not one recipient had been referred to Treasury for recovery. Not one. This is actually pretty appalling. Your testimony also identifies more than $9.5 billion of RRF awards in need of review. Given the scope of potential fraud across the two programs, will you be able to investigate all credible leads before the statutes of limitations expire in April for the SVOG program and May for the RRF program? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator, for the question. There is no possible way that our office would be able to investigate all of the outstanding referrals and cases that we have received in the SVOG and the RRF program. I will acknowledge that the work of the SBA OIG to this point in the RRF and SVOIG investigations has been underwhelming, quite honestly. There's lots more work we can do. I can only say that that was probably as a result of resource allocation on other programs. The investigators and auditors have done tremendous work, but the scope of the work is such that we would need much more time, which is why I'm strongly supportive of the idea of extending the statute of limitations to allow for more time to investigate and resolve and return money to the Federal Fed. Chair. No, I really appreciate that. And does that mean that the ongoing investigations as well would time out? Mr. Kirk. I believe so. I believe that the handful of investigations, quite honestly, it's an embarrassing number of investigations that we currently have underway, those would probably time out as well if we could not bring them to prosecution. Chair. Yeah. So, even though you've invested time and resources through the department they could not continue if the statute of limitations runs out for the programs. Mr. Kirk. Indeed, it's my understanding that that work would be for nought. Chair. Okay. Which is exactly why we do need to extend the statute of limitations. So, thank you. Mr. Dieffenbach, the PRAC has produced over $57 billion in monetary findings and over 1200 indictments resulting in over 450 convictions. Is it safe to say you are aware of the time and energy it takes to investigate pandemic fraud? Mr. Dieffenbach. Yes. Very safe to say. I spent the bulk of my 29-year career doing fraud and public corruption investigations in the OIG world, and it takes time to identify the bad actors, track them down, and to do the necessary work to, to serve the purpose of justice. Yes. Chair. So, if Congress extends the statutes of limitations by an additional 5 years, how much additional SVOG and RRF fraud do you realistically believe could still be uncovered and prosecuted? Mr. Dieffenbach. So, Chair, I can't provide you a numerical estimate for that, again, because there's so many factors involved, but I can assure you that with additional time, we'll identify more bad actors and more losses and, and lead to more convictions and more arrests. Yes. Chair. Okay. Thank you. And maybe for both of you in, in the remaining time that I have, the Biden administration chose automatic forgiveness for paycheck protection program loans under $150,000, effectively waiving through potential fraud. What front-end control should have been mandatory before forgiveness was granted? And, and if we could start with you General Kirk. Mr. Kirk. Sure. Thank you, Senator. First off, the, the front-end control that would've certainly avoided many problems would be the avoidance of the use of self-certification of eligibility. That's a real problem. There are ways to crosscheck that self-certification, but certainly self- certification is problematic. I would defer to my colleague if there are others that he's aware of. Chair. Great. Thank you. Yes. Mr. Dieffenbach. Sure. So, the PRAC has done a tremendous body of work in lessons learned, and we've produced a program-- a blueprint for program integrity, it includes program certification. The biggest point I'd make to you is that agencies own this risk and they have to do risk assessments, and they have to identify how are we verifying eligibility, what are the terms and conditions of the award, what is the law as laid out by Congress, and how are we ensuring that we're mitigating a broad range of risk? And every program has different risk, overlapping risk, but first and foremost, agencies have to pay attention and devote resources to those activities. Chair. Okay. Thank you. Now I recognize Ranking Member Markey. Senator Markey. Thank you, Madam Chair, very much. The questions that I'm going to begin with refer to the Paycheck-- the Paycheck Protection Program, or PPP, and the Economic Injury Disaster Loan Program or EIDL, which helped save millions of businesses during the pandemic. The SBA and Congress should be learning from our experiences to improve programs, keep fraudsters out, and target help to deserving small businesses. However, Republicans seem more intent on blaming the Biden administration than anything else. 2023 SBA report found that 86 percent of the fraudulent loans came under Trump during the first 9 months of the first pandemic relief programs. So, Mr. Kirk, your office's own 2023 report on pandemic fraud states that many of the SBA's improvements to stem fraud, ``Were made after much of the damage had already been done,'' and that fraudsters, egregiously exploited SBAs weakened controls during the first year of the program, meaning during the Trump administration. So, Mr. Kirk, when were most PPP and EIDL loans made? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, ranking member, for the question. I appreciate it. As you described, the vast majority of the loans were made in the year 2020 and 2021. So, they were in that timeframe, that's when the pandemic occurred. So, the relief that the country needed was at that time in those--that's when the loans---- Senator Markey. So, 93 percent---- Mr. Kirk. Yes. Senator Markey [continuing]. Of the EIDL grants were made in 2020 when President Trump was in office. Mr. Kirk, do you agree with your predecessor's finding that the vast majority of fraudulent PPP and EIDL loans were made during the first Trump administration? It seems that you do. Mr. Kirk and Mr. Dieffenbach--excuse me? Mr. Kirk. No, I was going to say that that was the time place--time when the pandemic occurred, it was in 2020, and the economic relief that the country needed was at that time. So, that's when the loans were disbursed. Senator Markey. And I think I heard you say, Mr. Dieffenbach, that if pre-award vetting had been in place in 2020, we would've saved tens of billions of dollars. Is that what you said? Correct. Mr. Dieffenbach. Correct, Ranking Member Markey. Had we had the data systems, the authorities' jurisdiction in place, we certainly could have identified significant amounts of potential fraud for which the proper due diligence could have been accomplished before the money went out the door. Senator Markey. Right. So, back in 2020, if we had put those programs in place, we wouldn't be chasing fraud. We would've prevented the fraud in the first place? Mr. Dieffenbach. Correct. Senator Markey. Right. Thank you. So, do you agree with that, Mr. Kirk? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. Yeah, I agree that had different measures been taken, I think you learn an awful lot in hindsight. But because the pandemic was raging at that time and there was a strong desire, a bipartisan desire to try to save the economy, that's when those loans were made. Senator Markey. And what programs should the Trump administration have put in place? Because as you're saying, you live life forwards, but you understand it backwards. So, what programs should have been in place in order to prevent against faulty implementation of those laws? Mr. Kirk. I'm sorry. I'm not--what, the program, the pandemic, the people---- Senator Markey. You agree with Mr. Dieffenbach that we should have had those checks in right from the get go. You do agree with that? Mr. Dieffenbach. The protocols in place to prevent. Mr. Kirk. It would--again, hindsight is wonderful. I think there were significant controls put in place, but the frauds were very capable, and they were able to get by some of them. As I said, I think there was bipartisan interest in rescuing the economy from the ravages of the pandemic. And so, the loans and grants that were made were intended to save the economy. Obviously, in hindsight, we can---- Senator Markey. I'm just trying to get the timeline down-- -- Mr. Kirk. Sure. Senator Markey [continuing]. In terms of when that fraud, you know, began. Mr. Kirk. The fraud has continued in the past 5 years as well---- Senator Markey. I appreciate that. But as we just heard earlier, if the safeguards were in place initially, we would've saved tens of billions of dollars. And that's just the testimony that we received. And just a few weeks ago, the New York Times reported about a huckster who had been convicted of peddling bogus energy drinks in 2019, but was then pardoned with the help of one of President Trump's former lawyers as he concluded his first term in 2021. And just last year, that same huckster was convicted again of another fraud scheme that cost victims millions of dollars. So, what did the President do? He granted another pardon to that same huckster. So, Mr. Dieffenbach, as someone who has devoted nearly three decades of your life to fighting fraud, how does it feel to see convicted fraudsters let off the hook not once, but twice, because they happen to have a line into the President? Mr. Dieffenbach. So, Ranking Member Markey, I'm not familiar with that matter at all. But I can look into it if the law is followed throughout then it's followed throughout. I don't--I don't know the facts. Senator Markey. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Chair. This might be an instance where both Ranking Member Markey and I agree that if we had had the proper protocols in place for that very bipartisan bill the Paycheck Protection Program and EIDL, that we probably would've saved a lot of--a lot of taxpayer money, and we wouldn't be in this situation today. But I would remind everybody, probably everybody on this committee voted in favor of those programs because we did want to save our small businesses back home. But, you know, if we had instituted DOGE, Department of Government Efficiency at that time, we probably would've had the proper protocols in place. So, next, we have Senator Hawley. You are recognized for 5 minutes. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thanks to the witnesses for being here. Mr. Kirk, if I could just start with you, help me understand the scope of what you're looking at with the Restaurant Revitalization Fund and the Shuttered Venue Operators Act. These are the programs you've identified that are currently under shorter statutory limitations that you think that we need to adjust. And partly that's because as you outline in your written testimony, there is a good deal of potential fraud here that it sounds like to me your office and others are currently running down. Is that fair to say? Mr. Kirk. That is correct, Senator. Thank you for the question. Yes, we're running it down. I will acknowledge that I've only been in place 7 weeks or so. I have learned that really there's been an inadequate attention paid to investigating RRF and SVOG fraud. We can do much better. I commit to you we will do much better. We have only a handful of investigations underway. To me it's an absolute priority, but it will be critically important for us to have an extension of the statute of limitations to be able to continue those investigations. Senator Hawley. And you say only a handful of investigations have been performed or are currently underway, but it sounds like on the basis of your written remarks, that the potential fraud in the Restaurant Revitalization Program's quite large. Is that fair to say? Mr. Kirk. Yes, Senator. There's potential fraud in the billions of dollars. Senator Hawley. Billions with a B? Mr. Kirk. Yeah. Senator Hawley. That's incredible. I'm reading from your written testimony, you say, OIG in one review identified 33,168 restaurant revitalization recipients, who had also received PPP loans that have been marked as potentially fraudulent or ineligible. These recipients received nearly not quite $11 billion in RRF funds. And you go on to outline that a bare minimum of these, a tiny percentage have had any kind of substantive review. It sounds like there's a lot to be done here. Mr. Kirk. We have our work cut out for us, and we will make good use of the additional time in the statute of limitations. Indeed, there is a tremendous amount of fraud that has been uncovered, identified potential fraud. Not all of it has been proven. Obviously, we have work to do to ensure that fraudsters are brought to justice, but it is billions of dollars, Senator. Senator Hawley. You say that your recommendation called for review of more than 61,000 RRF awards totaling almost $10 billion. Mr. Kirk. That's correct. Senator Hawley. That's quite substantial. Why is it that there's been so little investigation done before now? Do you have a sense of that? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. The magnitude of work available to us to do is significant. I have come to know that the investigators and auditors that are in the SBA OIG right now are really dedicated professionals. I believe that they were performing their duties in other areas. The pandemic and EIDL fraud is significant. We have so much work to do. Having said that, we can't ignore one area of fraud just because we've got fraud in others. We are going to attack this fraud. We're going to do it diligently. I'm really honored to be named to the Pandemic Recovery Accountability Committee because I selfishly will look forward to using the PRAC to be able to identify more of the fraud. For example, it would be impossible for our staff to review manually 61,000 loans. But with the data analytical capability of the PRAC, we'll be able to do a much better job of that and return far more money to the--to the taxpayer. We need that time, though. We need the extension of the statute of limitations to undertake that work. Senator Hawley. And remind us when it runs out one more time, Mr. Kirk. When does the statute---- Mr. Kirk. Current, some of them as early as March or April. Senator Hawley. Very, very soon. Mr. Kirk. It's very soon. Senator Hawley. We need to act immediately. Mr. Kirk. Yes, sir. Senator Hawley. I'm glad that you're making this a top priority. Obviously, we've seen in recent weeks, I think just the scope of the pandemic era of fraud that has continued into the present. I had testimony at another committee, one expert suggested that we could be looking at as much as a trillion dollars in fraud every year. Not all of that pandemic fraud, of course, but that's an astounding, astounding number. I think the American people are astounded and also sickened by the fact that their tax dollars are being used to fund fraudsters buy private planes, luxury yachts. In one case there were 12,000 pounds of $100 bills smuggled out of suitcases in the city of Minneapolis. I mean, this is outrageous stuff. Any dollar of fraud is outrageous. But the scale that you're talking about here is truly alarming. What's the first order business for you? We get this statute extended, which is what we've got to do, what's the next order of business for you in terms of tackling this? Mr. Kirk. Oh, thank you, Senator. As I mentioned to our staff, our focus is fraud, fraud, fraud. I mean, there's three things we're concentrating on. We need to dedicate our investigative capabilities to identify the fraud, to return the dollars to the--to the taxpayer. The first priority really is to leverage data analytics, because when you're talking about billions, even trillions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of loans, it's simply not possible to do manual reviews in these cases. We have to use data analytics. We have--the fraudsters are taking advantage of the technology. We need to be able to do so as well. Senator Hawley. Very good. Well, I hope that we can get the statute of limitations extended so you'll be able to do your work. Thank you for the terrific work you're doing, both of you. Mr. Kirk. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Madam Chair. Chair. Thank you, Senator Hawley. Next, Senator Shaheen. 5 minutes. Senator Shaheen. Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you both for being here and for the work that you're doing. I appreciate what the chairwoman said about the importance of the programs and what you said Mr. Kirk, about the fact that when those programs were designed, and as somebody on this committee who helped design the PPP program, there was real urgency about getting that done, about trying to save the small businesses that were going under and the economy, and a recognition that fraud needed to be addressed. But it was secondary to ensuring that businesses were able to continue to operate. So, Mr. Dieffenbach, can you talk about how long it is taking to develop those pre fraud measures that you mentioned? Mr. Dieffenbach. I'm sorry, the pre fraud measures? Senator Shaheen. Yeah. What you're talking about. Mr. Dieffenbach. The pre award vetting? Senator Shaheen. Yeah. Mr. Dieffenbach. Yes, ma'am. So, thank you for the--for the question, Senator. We have developed, again, a artificial intelligence enabled system that can very rapidly identify---- Senator Shaheen. And how long? Mr. Dieffenbach [continuing]. Patterns, trends, anomalies. We can--we can review once the system is set up---- Senator Shaheen. How long did it take you to develop? Mr. Dieffenbach. To develop it? We've developed it over the last 6 to 7 months. Senator Shaheen. Okay. So, having that kind of a system in place before the program was done was probably unlikely given the urgency about getting---- Mr. Dieffenbach. From March of 2020, correct. Senator Shaheen. Correct. Okay. I just wanted to be clear as we're looking at timeframe here. And one of the things that you said was that we can't ignore--maybe it was you, Mr. Kirk-- we can't ignore one area of fraud because of fraud in other areas. And Senator Ernst mentioned the DOGE work. Last year we saw reports that DOGE had accessed SBA systems that had sensitive information about people and businesses. We requested a review of what they accessed and whether there was any misuse of personal information. Mr. Kirk, have you looked into what DOGE accessed and whether there was any tampering with the information at SBA? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator for the question. I've just been in place about 7 weeks. And in that time, I have not conducted any review of DOGE. If I may say though, I was--at the time I was a career employee in the Federal government over at the Department of Education. And when I worked with DOGE employees, we understood them to be government employees. Certainly, they were from the Department of Government Efficiency, I guess the name was, but they were government employees that were vetted and reviewed by the HR processes and procedures. Senator Shaheen. But in fact, they weren't. Mr. Kirk. I can't speak to that. I don't know. But the folks that I worked with were as I understood them to be, members of the Federal service. Senator Shaheen. Is this something you're concerned about looking at SBA? Mr. Kirk. Not currently. No, ma'am. Senator Shaheen. I would hope that you would do that. And in fact, when this was happening, we requested on the committee a briefing that I think both Senators Ernst and Markey said they would try and make sure we received. And yet, we haven't gotten a briefing yet, so. Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. I would be happy to work with your staff to see if there is additional work that we can assist you in trying to understand that. Senator Shaheen. That'd be great. I appreciate that. One of my next question is also about SBA and how it operates, because one of SBAs programs is the State Trade Expansion Program. It helps small businesses that are exporting, it helps them to grow their business. I think that's something that this administration is also very interested in. And Congress provided $20 million for STEP in fiscal year 2025 funding last March. But despite SBA putting out a notice of funding opportunities last May, they have yet to announce any awards from STEP. So, I would hope Mr. Kirk is your looking into the integrity of SBA and how it operates, that you would also look into why SBA is not getting out the funding that Congress has provided to ensure that those programs that are so critical to our small businesses are actually being funded. Will you commit to looking into what's going on and why the STEP program is not funded? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. It appears to me that you might be making a referral to an impoundment issue. And if so, that's a matter that falls under the Impoundment Control Act. That's a matter for the GAO to do that. Senator Shaheen. Well, I don't know that. Mr. Kirk. Perhaps not, but I'd be happy to try to research that more and understand if that's what you're referring to. Senator Shaheen. Because there are also several other programs, the Women's Business Centers and SCORE, where Congress has funded them, but the money hasn't actually gone out from SBA. So, I assume in your position, you can check on that and see if SBA is actually funding the programs that Congress determined it should fund. Mr. Kirk. I'll certainly be happy to work with my staff to try to get answers to those questions for you. Senator Shaheen. Thank you. Madam Chair, I hope that we can follow up and make sure that we have those answers. Chair. Yes, absolutely. Happy to work with you on that. Senator Shaheen. Thank you. Chair. Yes. And Senator Hirono, you're recognized for 5 minutes. Senator Hirono. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Kirk, in your testimony, you discussed the need to investigate fraud in the 8(a) Program, and I agree in fact, we should go after fraud by anyone and in all programs. So, there you go. We agree on that. And we should investigate fraud again in all programs, including the 8(a), but to allege widespread fraud in this program, which involves--how many people are--how many companies, entities are in the 8(a) Program? Mr. Kirk. Gosh, I apologize, Senator. I don't have that. Senator Hirono. Thousands, thousands. Mr. Kirk. It is thousands. Indeed, I can assure you. Senator Hirono. And these are small businesses, and we have decided in this committee that we should be supportive of small businesses---- Mr. Kirk. Absolutely. Senator Hirono [continuing]. And to work with them. But to come into the questions relating to this 8(a) Program as with the idea that there's massive fraud that is--that is inappropriate. So, I just want to get your commitment that in your review of the 8(a) Program that you maintain your independence from those within the administration, including the SBA leadership that considers the 8(a) Program to be a fraud magnet. But you would be independent in your assessment of whether or not there is fraud in the 8(a) Program. Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator, for the question. I can absolutely assure you. I swore an oath to uphold the law, to act impartially, to act without regard to political partisanship independently and objectively. That's an oath I take very seriously. Senator Hirono. I'm glad that you're reiterating once again, that the IG is really critical that you be independent. And I have the questions that I asked you during your confirmation hearing. Mr. Kirk. Yes, ma'am. Senator Hirono. Now, one question I did ask you was whether the rule of law applied to the President of the United States, and you didn't answer that directly. I'm going to give you another chance to answer that question. Mr. Kirk. Sure, Senator. I'm happy to acknowledge that the rule of law applies to all citizens, all people in the United States, including the President of the United States. Senator Hirono. Do you know that the President said that the rule of law doesn't--he doesn't think the rule of law applies to him? Mr. Kirk. I'm not aware of that statement. Senator Hirono. What if I were to tell you that that is his view of the rule of law as applying to him? He doesn't think the rule of law applies to him. He thinks that the Supreme Court has given him pretty much immunity from--although that that decision was based on any criminal doings, I think he certainly applies it to the civil situation. So, I have some concerns about your independence. I'm glad that you continue to affirm that you're going to be independent. Now, on the question of Planned Parenthood receipt of PPP funds, once again I believe that you're bringing up whether or not, or the SBA is bringing up whether or not the Planned Parenthood should have gotten this money. And your predecessor IG has said that it was done appropriately. Do you have any reason to suspect or disagree with your predecessor's assessment of whether Planned Parenthood had committed fraud? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. My understanding is that the SBA is conducting a review of the eligibility of many institutions and entities, including that one. Senator Hirono. No, but your predecessor had already said that Planned Parenthood had complied with the requirements. Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. I'm actually quite pleased that the agency is continuing to conduct reviews in all areas because the job of tackling fraud is shared between the agency and the IG. Senator Hirono. Well, the thing is---- Mr. Kirk. This administration has made--the agency has made really very significant efforts, since the beginning of last year to---- Senator Hirono. Hold on. I'm reclaiming my time. So, that's great that, you know, the agency is being very objective and all of that. But this regime is not objective when it comes to the funding of Planned Parenthood. And in fact, it continues to beat the drum that somehow Planned Parenthood committed fraud, or that it was inappropriate. Now, your predecessor IG has already reviewed--I mean, you must have enough other things to look at regarding fraud, but you're going to once again, pursue fraud with regard to PPP. So, my question to you is, do you not accept your predecessor IGs report, the assessment---- Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. Senator Hirono [continuing]. That Planned Parenthood had not committed fraud? Mr. Kirk. I understand the question. Senator Hirono. Yes or no? Mr. Kirk. The SBA is conducting a new review, reviewing the eligibility of the affiliates, as I understand it. I am not involved in that review. Our office is not involved in that review. If they make referrals to the Inspector General's office, it is our responsibility under the law, and we abide by the law in all cases to investigate those matters. Senator Hirono. Well, I have to tell you that this is very politically motivated, as you can imagine. And you must be aware that this regime--I call it a regime because of its authoritarianism--that this is a regime that has been calling to question funding for Planned Parenthood in many different ways, and certainly in this instance, you must be aware of that. So, I'm just saying this is yet another instance of politically motivated investigations. Thank you, Madam Chair. Chair. Thank you, Senator Hirono. And I, for one, have called for additional information regarding those programs and the allocations that went out to Planned Parenthood, because I did not believe that they fit with the original congressional intent of the package that we passed out of this Small Business Committee. So, I would applaud the Inspector General's efforts on reviewing that matter. Senator Young. Senator Young. Well, thank you, Madam Chair. And I want to thank our witnesses for being here today. Mr. Dieffenbach, I'd like to start by discussing the AI enabled fraud prevention engine that was developed by the Pandemic Response Accountability Committee that you highlighted in your written testimony. You noted that the tool can review approximately 20,000 applications per second before the funds are dispersed, and this would dramatically increase the government's ability to detect anomalies and potential fraud in real time. Given those capabilities, what specific action should Congress consider to ensure agencies are fully leveraging AI driven fraud prevention tools at the front-end, rather than relying on a costly pay-and-chase model after funds go out the door? Mr. Dieffenbach. Thank you, Senator Young. Indeed, we have built a very powerful tool. To what Congress can do to help enhance fraud prevention, I think first and foremost, it's ensuring the right incentives are in place, and that agency officials are taking their primary responsibility of preventing detecting fraud as they should. Inspector General Kirk and the rest of the inspectors general are here as kind of a secondary backup and an oversight mechanism. But the first and primary role of agency officials is to properly design programs, assess risk, and allocate proper resources to it. So, in my estimation, the more Congress pays attention to their ownership of that risk, the more they will pay attention to it, and the more they will seek assistance from the PRAC and from inspectors general and follow recommendations so they can have impactful prevention activities. Senator Young. Okay. Well, Congress will be--at least this member of Congress will be attentive to those issues. I know fraud throughout government programs is especially concerning to my constituents. Are there any statutory data sharing or other barriers that to your mind today prevent wider adoption of the AI tools you referenced across Federal programs? Mr. Dieffenbach. Sure. The biggest one that comes to mind is our jurisdiction of the PRAC is currently limited to pandemic programs and to programs funded in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which is an expansion we received last summer we're grateful for. But the greater jurisdiction that we have at the PRAC, the greater we can identify trends, anomalies, patterns, and hidden connections across all government programs. As I said in my opening statement, most fraudsters don't just defraud one government program. They go to the ones that are the weakest. We have an ongoing case now that involves frauds in 24 different states. The Department of Labor IG has identified one social security number that was used in 40 different states to obtain unemployment insurance benefits. So, expanding our jurisdiction, giving us the ability to responsibly look at a wider set of data, will give better visibility into these emerging trends and these organized groups to be more---- Senator Young. So, you would need statutory direction, is that accurate? Or would some other sort of direction suffice in order to broaden the scope of your current authorities or responsibilities to encompass non pandemic response programs that may be rife with or certainly you know, characterized by fraud? Mr. Dieffenbach. So, as I outlined in my written statement, our jurisdiction is currently limited, so we would need statutory authorization to look at a broader array of programs, which would allow us to collect more data to be more effective. Senator Young. Short of that, would it be allowable for members of your staff, perhaps you individually, to visit with me, any members of the Small Business Committee that would like to join and talk more generally about how lessons you've learned might be applied to other areas or tools you've developed? Mr. Dieffenbach. Yes, Senator. I would welcome that opportunity. I spent almost my entire 28-year Federal career as a Federal law enforcement investigating corruption and fraud. I can talk fraud risks with you all day long, which is the first step in the process. But happy to talk anytime. Senator Young. Here, today, I resolve to work with you and members of your team and have my office do so, and we will ask if other colleagues on the committee would like to also be supportive of cracking down on indefensible fraud. Mr. Dieffenbach. Anytime, sir. Senator Young. All right. And I see for the record, Senator Rosen, her face lit up. So, perhaps we can work together on this. Mr. Kirk. Mr. Kirk. Yes, sir. Senator Young. You've highlighted in your written testimony the recent steps the Small Business Administration has taken to strengthen program integrity. I regret that we're sort of running towards the end of our time, but I'll just ask you one threshold sort of question here. How's the SBA integrating AI machine learning or advanced data analytics into its fraud detection and application review processes today? Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator. I know it is a priority of theirs. I have had several meetings already with the chief technology officer there, and I look forward to continuing those. It's really imperative. What we have to do is, as we integrate AI and data analytics, we have to make sure it's done safely, in a way that protects data, in a way that doesn't create new problems, as such as we're created with pandemic program, when steps were put into place that had a tail to them. So, I am, I know they are committed. I am very committed to using technology because as Senator Ernst referred to, as Senator Markey referred to, we're talking about hundreds of thousands of loans, and there's no way to manually review these, that we have to use the data analytic tools that are available. Senator Young. Well, thank you for your focus on this important matter. Chair. Chair. Great. Thank you, Senator Young. Next, we'll go to Senator Rosen. Thank you. Senator Rosen. Thank you, Madam Chair, Ranking Member Markey, appreciate this. Data and analytics, you're talking my language here. So, I want to thank Senator Young bringing this up. I was going to ask this very same question. I agree that early fraud protection through better technology, AI, dashboards, and the like, it is really preferable to--we don't want to pay them ahead of time and chase them down later. We want to prevent them. And so, I do agree with your quote that the proactive use of data and technology could have prevented or aided in early detection schemes. So, I want to work with you to continue to use technology in smart ways to prevent fraud and join us on that. What we need to do to learn with you on ways that we can enhance your work. So, thank you for that. And I want to say since I entered Congress, I've worked really hard to fight wasteful spending, look after Nevadans' hard-earned tax dollars, ensuring that waste is responsibly minimized. Responsibly minimized, right? As fraud is prevented, should always be a top priority. Tax dollars are precious. And so, I do believe this effort, and again, I agree with my colleagues that we must take the preventative approach. It's always better prevention--what do they say? An ounce of prevention versus a pound of cure, right? And so, our goal should be to improve access to the support and SBA programs that are intended to provide. There's a lot of programs out there, not to create more barriers but to really enable people to navigate the complex environment that exists for I will say the people who aren't perpetrating fraud. The rest--the majority of folks really want to do the right thing, and they look forward and really dream about owning a small business. And so, we should be focused on implementing evidence-based reforms, identifying opportunities to improve compliance, and ensuring that critical resources do remain available for, look--99.2 percent of business owner of businesses in Nevada are small business. These are people's dreams, large and small. And we want them to use these resources. So, one opportunity to improve compliance exists in better leveraging small business resource partners. You have an extensive network of resource partners, like Small Business Development Centers, Veterans Business Outreach Center--I was glad to bring the first VBOCs, two of them to Nevada--Women's Business Centers, they're all utilized extensively I know in Nevada by our small businesses. And I believe that the reach of these resources can be expanded to better help people who really want to do the right thing and own their own business and stay compliant with program requirements. So, Mr. Kirk, how can the small business resource partners, like the ones I've named and others aid in the goal of educating business on compliance requirements? And what efforts are you taking to have the reach of our resource partners really get out there to the multitudes? Like I said, almost 300,000 small businesses in Nevada, so they know they're there. They want to do the right thing, and they just need to be able to get the resources to do it. Mr. Kirk. Thank you, Senator for the question. I really appreciate it because it allows me to talk about the other arm of what we do in the Inspector General's office. We are statutorily required to investigate and prevent and detect waste, fraud, and abuse. But our other critically important function is audit. And when we audit these programs, we can identify ways where their reach can be expanded. These are program responsibilities you're talking about, right? So, that those questions are--some of them are best directed to the administrator, but we are critically involved in auditing the programs to ensure that their reach is what Congress intended. There are so many programs available. I'm only now becoming familiar with many of them. But our audit work is geared in many cases to identify how those programs might be improved, how the reach of the programs can be expanded. Senator Rosen. Improved, for sure, because you can see the roadblocks for people who are trying to get things done and what are their obstacles to being compliant. Mr. Kirk. Indeed. Senator Rosen. Sometimes they're just not educated on what they need. Mr. Kirk. Indeed. And, you know, the problem, you know, the pandemic relief was pushed out so quickly. Senator Rosen. Yes. Mr. Kirk. It would be nice if we could push out SBA assistance program assistance as quickly, but we would do so at the risk of greater fraud. So, I really am grateful for your question because it allows me to talk to our audit folks about really having them bear down on the issue of how can we ensure that the program funding, the program availability, the knowledge of how to use the programs is made available to the 36 million small businesses. Senator Rosen. Right. Because some people are trying to perpetrate fraud and others may just not understand---- Mr. Kirk. Absolutely. Senator Rosen [continuing]. How to be stay in compliance if they don't have--it's not a very large business. Mr. Kirk. Indeed. Senator Rosen. It could be just a mom and pop, a smaller business that just doesn't have the resources. So, thank you for that. And Madam Chair, I yield back. Chair. Yes, thank you, Senator Rosen. And an excellent point, because we do have a lot of small businesses that just lack the ability to sort through some of the legalities. Senator Rosen. They are trying to do the right thing but they just don't have the resources. Maybe they're not sure how to fill out paperwork. Chair. Right. Exactly, exactly. Thank you for that line of questioning. And now I'll recognize Ranking Member Markey. Senator Markey. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Dieffenbach, you have been fighting government fraud for 28 years. You know that fraud is not a problem that is unique to only red and only blue states. Yet we've seen the SBA administrator take selective actions against borrowers in Minnesota and California. In fact, Administrator Loeffler went so far as to pause annual grant funding to the state of Minnesota after launching a probe into COVID-19 programs. I think the administrator is actually using isolated incidents of fraud from 6 years ago to deny law abiding small businesses in Minnesota access to SBA programs today. So, Mr. Dieffenbach, as head of the Pandemic Recovery Accountability Committee, you have a comprehensive understanding of the fraud landscape. Has the data given you any indication that there was a correlation between whether someone lives in a state that voted against Donald Trump or for Donald Trump in terms of the likelihood that they committed fraud? Mr. Dieffenbach. Ranking Member Markey, fraud exists in any program that gives away money. I have no data, no information about the geographic disbursement or the voting piece that you just discussed. Senator Markey. Yeah. So, it's not red states and blue states, it's all states? Mr. Dieffenbach. I don't know. It is--it is distributed across all states. Yes. Senator Markey. Thank you. So, do you think that targeting specific states for political reasons as the SBA has done is an effective way to pursue recovery for the American taxpayers or does the PRAC rely on more nuanced analytics yourself to identify concentrations of fraud? Mr. Dieffenbach. I don't have a comment on that except to say that I have 3 billion data points, and every day I've got a team that is looking for the patterns, trends, and anomalies of the fraud where it may occur so we can pursue it and refer it to the right inspectors general. Senator Markey. Yeah. And I like that about you. You know, you're like, Sergeant Joe Friday in Dragnet, it's nothing but the facts, you know, and just follow the facts. It's not let's just target the blue states, because obviously, you'll be letting off most likely half of the culprits at that point, because that's just the way fraud works. So, Madam Chair, as you know, this committee passed the SBA Fraud Enforcement Extension Vote Act by a voice vote this past July, and I am committed to passing this legislation as part of a comprehensive set of reforms and look forward to working with the chair to advance it along with other bipartisan priorities. And that said, our efforts to fight against fraud should not be limited to going after small restaurants and theaters, especially when President Trump is letting off fraudsters left and right. If we're going to combat fraud, let's look and see what DOGE is doing with the social security numbers they illegally harvested and take steps to make sure they're not doing the same thing with small business data. So, I just want to be consistent. Let's call out the fraud across the board, including when it's committed by the President's allies, as well as the President's opponents. So, let's not allow the search for fraud to be used as a weapon to hurt people in blue states. So, I'm committed to fighting fraud but we just have to be consistent so that we call it out like you Mr. Dieffenbach regardless of where we find it in the country. So, with that, Madam Chair, I yield back. Chair. Thank you. Thank you, Ranking Member Markey, and I love that Sergeant Joe Friday, just the facts. And yes, I do believe that if there is fraud out there, we need to call it out. I don't care whether it is a blue state or a red state. Unfortunately, we have seen a lot of fraud in Minnesota. So, that's the state that does garner the most attention. So, I'll just ask a brief question. So, the SBA had announced that there was nearly 7,000 Minnesota borrowers linked to an estimated $400 million in COVID relief loans. They are being suspended after massive fraud rings were exposed throughout Minnesota. So, right now, what we do know is that Governor Walz is now proposing new forgivable loans, claiming businesses are being harmed by law enforcement. So, Mr. Kirk, maybe what warning, as we're wrapping this up--what warning would you give to officials advocating for broad new grant forgivable loan programs? Mr. Kirk. Gosh, thank you, Senator, for the question. I would suggest they consult with my colleague here and with me and with others, inspectors general to try to put in place methods in advance that would prevent fraud from occurring. There's many steps that can be taken. They don't require all that much effort. As I said, hindsight's 20/20. I hope that folks that would do that would look to experts who can provide information in that regard. For example, self-certification, a real problem in these matters. There's opportunities that exist to check the self- certification that's being made. There's data tools out there that are available, and the data tools are better now than they were 6 years ago when the pandemic began, so. Chair. Well, thank you. This has been a very good hearing, and I appreciate it. And, ranking member, I absolutely agree, let's go after the fraudsters. It doesn't matter, R, D, blue, red, does not matter. Fraud is fraud. So, again, I want to thank our witnesses for being here with us today. I ask unanimous consent that the record of today's hearing remain open for 2 weeks for members to submit questions, revise and extend their remarks, and submit additional information into the record. And without objection, so ordered. And with that, the Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship stands adjourned. Thank you, Gentlemen. [Whereupon, at 3:41 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]