Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-260] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-260 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION ---------- SEPTEMBER 17, 2025 ---------- Serial No. J-119-48 ---------- Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.judiciary.senate.gov www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 62-461 WASHINGTON : 2026 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Grassley, Hon. Charles E......................................... 1 Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 3 Tillis, Hon. Thom................................................ 6 VISITING INTRODUCERS Johnson, Hon. Ron, U.S. Senator from Wisconsin................... 4 Budd, Hon. Ted, U.S. Senator from North Carolina................. 5 NOMINEES Bailey, Sara Carter.............................................. 31 Questionnaire................................................ 47 Responses to written questions............................... 64 Additional materials......................................... 102 Bragdon, David A................................................. 28 Questionnaire................................................ 121 Responses to written questions............................... 155 Additional materials......................................... 221 Freeman, Lindsey Ann............................................. 29 Questionnaire................................................ 236 Responses to written questions............................... 264 Orso, Matthew E.................................................. 29 Questionnaire................................................ 316 Responses to written questions............................... 351 Rodriguez, Susan Courtwright..................................... 30 Questionnaire................................................ 401 Responses to written questions............................... 457 Taibleson, Rebecca L............................................. 9 Questionnaire................................................ 505 Responses to written questions............................... 537 Additional materials......................................... 593 APPENDIX Items submitted for the record................................... 605 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS ---------- WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 17, 2025 United States Senate, Committee on the Judiciary, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice at 10:17 a.m., in Room G50, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Charles E. Grassley, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Grassley [presiding], Cruz, Hawley, Tillis, Kennedy, Schmitt, Britt, Moody, Durbin, Whitehouse, Blumenthal, Hirono, and Booker. Also present: Senators Johnson and Budd. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF IOWA Chairman Grassley. Welcome everyone. Senator Kennedy. Mr. Chairman. May I be recognized? Chairman Grassley. It's very unsual but I wouldn't want to tell you no. Senator Kennedy. Mr. Chairman. The entire United States Senate would like to congratulate you on your birthday---- Chairman Grassley. Well thank you. [Applause.] Senator Kennedy [continuing.] Which is today. [Applause]. Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Forget about it. Forget about it. [Standing Ovation.] Senator Kennedy. And folks you haven't lived until you see Senator Grassely's birthday cake with all the candles lit. [Laughter.] Senator Kennedy. It looks like a praire fire. Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Senator Kennedy. So happy birthday Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley. Thank you Senator Kennedy. Now maybe we can get down to work. I'd like to welcome everybody to todays' hearing. Our first panel features Rebecca Taibleson, nominated to the U.S. Court of Appeals Seventh Circuit. On panel 2, we'll hear from four district court nominees, Matthew Orso and Judge Susan Courtright Rodriguez, the Western District of North Carolina, and David Bragdon and Lindsey Ann Freeman, Middle District of North Carolina. The second panel will also include Sarah Carter, nominated for the Director of Office of National Drug Control Policy. Senator Johnson will introduce Ms. Taibleson in a moment, but I'd like to say a few words to lead us off. Ms. Taibleson clerked for not one, but two sitting Supreme Court justices; Justice Scalia, and then-Judge Kavanaugh when he was on the D.C. Circuit. Ms. Taibleson is no stranger to this Committee. In 2018, she testified in defense of Justice Kavanaugh's nomination. Ms. Taibleson's firsthand experience working with Judge Kavanaugh was an important counterpoint to the embarrassing partisan spectacle that some people on this Committee orchestrated. I hope that my Democrat colleagues treat Ms. Taibleson with the fairness and decorum that they denied her mentor. Indeed, Ms. Taibleson is extremely well-qualified to serve as circut judge. Her 15-year experience has spanned private practice and public service. She's been a Federal prosecutor and the appellate chief in the East District of Wisconsin for nearly a decade. Ms. Taibleson has prosecuted some of the most violent criminals and serious drug trafficking cartels. She's also a member of the Attorney General's Review Committee on capital cases. During the first Trump Administration, she worked on detail as an assistant to the Solicitor General. In that capacity, Ms. Taibleson drafted numerous briefs before the Supreme Court. She participated in oral arguments before that court, not once, but twice. Our district judge nominees in North Carolina are also highly qualified. Their experiences represent a broad array of legal experience. Mr. Bragdon and Ms. Freeman are Federal prosecutors who have helped uphold the rule of law. Mr. Orso is an accomplished attorney in private practice, and the Judge Courtright Rodriguez is a well-respected magistrate judge on the same court in which she has been nominated. We'll hear more about their background from our colleagues from North Carolina, and I look forward to hearing from each of them today. Turning to Ms. Carter, she's been nominated to oversee the National Drug Control Policy. Addressing the scourge of drug abuse is an important issue for Members on both sides of this aisle, and we've taken steps to address it in this Congress. I co-lead the HALT Fentanyl Act, which was advanced through this Committee in a bipartisan vote earlier this year and signed into law by President Trump this summer. I appreciate our Committee's collaboration to get that bill across the finish line. Ms. Carter is well positioned to lead the fight to save American lives through common sense drug control policy. As an investigative journalist, Ms. Carter developed a deep understanding of drug crisis facing our country. She's absorbed, has observed firsthand the unlawful trafficking of controlled substances over the Canadian and Mexican borders, and her efforts highlighted the importance of border security to the end the flow of drugs and illicit substances into the country. I look forward to hearing from Ms. Carter today as well. Before I turn over to Senator Durbin for his statement, I'd like to mention that we have a very long hearing today. We have six nominees, two panels, and multiple introducers. I'll ask everyone to keep their questions limited to the 5-minutes allotted to keep the hearing on schedule. Senator Durbin. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, happy birthday. Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Senator Durbin. At the outset, I want to thank you and the Members on both sides of the aisle for defending this Committee's longstanding bipartisan tradition of requiring blue slips from Senators supporting district court nominees from their State. As Chair of this Committee, I honored the practice despite pressure to do away with blue slips from the Democratic side. As a result, many Senate Republicans were able to negotiate with the Biden White House to fill vacancies in their States. Other Republicans use the blue slips to hold open seats in their States as Democrats have done, too. I didn't particularly like that approach, but I respect their decision. As a result, several of the district court nominees before us today have been nominated to fill some of those vacancies in red States. Blue slips remain a critical part of this body's advice and consent responsibility, even when they frustrate the party in power. Let me say a word about the nominees today. Two panels. First panel, a circuit court nominee, of course, by herself, and then a second panel, which consists of judicial nominees and others. President Trump has sent his nominees to us. Today, we'll hear from Sarah Carter Bailey. She's been nominated to be director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy, also known as the ``drug czar''. I can't think of a single issue. I agree with the Chairman on this of more serious consequence than drug addiction in the United States and the heavy price we pay, not just individuals and families, but as a society. Doing something about drug drugs certainly is the highest priority that we face. The Office of National Drug Control Policy is supposed to lead that effort, particularly because of the liaison with law enforcement, to make sure that the $300 million in Federal grants that was available last year will be given for law enforcement effectively on a local State basis to reduce drug addiction. This is an important position that requires a professional who is an expert in combating, for example, the opioid epidemic. Sadly, Ms. Carter is not that serious nominee. She has been a MAGA loyalist and podcaster whom President Trump has chosen for this critical role in government. Until she joined ONDCP 3 months ago, she had never worked in government. She has never served in law enforcement. She has no expertise in public health nor any drug policy. She's been a loyal MAGA podcaster. Why is it important to bring this up at this point? Because of two things from the Trump Administration, which we ought to take to heart. The first was a statement made by the Trump White House earlier this year about the HIDTA program, HIDTA, H-I-D-T-A. A program that provides $300 million to law enforcement. Here's what the Trump White House said about it. ``Initially, for every dollar invested in the HIDTA program, the American people get $68 in benefits, making HIDTA an effective and efficient use of taxpayers money, and an important tool in the Nation's effort to stop drug traffickers and save American lives.'' That was the first statement by the White House. The second statement was their budget request. Guess what they did to the HIDTA grants? They cut them by 34 percent from $300 million to $196 million. So, I'd have to say to Ms. Bailey, whose side are you on at this point? Law enforcement comes to us and begs for more money to fight drug problems in their communities, and I want to give it to them, but the White House wants to cut it by 34 percent. What's your position going to be? We'll find out in the questioning. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley. At this point, I'd like to enter into the record 10 letters from law enforcement organizations across the Nation who are fighting each day to combat drug and human trafficking, and who enthusiastically support Ms. Carter's nomination. They stated, ``Ms. Carter's commitment to the truth and firsthand experiences embedded with our Nation's military and law enforcement is proof that she has the determination to get the job done, as well as an understanding for what the men and women in uniform experience daily. This is precisely the bold and innovative leadership we need.'' Without objection, those will be entered into the record. Chairman Grassley. Senator Johnson. STATEMENT OF HON. RON JOHNSON, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF WISCONSIN Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley, happy birthday. We all wish you many, many more. Ranking Member Durbin and Members of the Committee. I'm pleased to introduce Rebecca Taibleson as the President's nominee to become the next judge on the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. She's highly qualified for this judgeship having graduated magna laude from Yale College and then from Yale Law School in 2010. After graduation, she clerked for then-Judge Brett Kavanaugh on the U.S. Circuit Court of Repeals for the D.C. Circuit, and Justice Antonin Scalia on the U.S. Supreme Court. She then practiced civil litigation at Kirkland & Ellis until 2016. In 2016, she joined the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Wisconsin, where she continues to serve as an assistant U.S. attorney and appellate chief. During the first Trump Administration. Rebecca also served while on detail from the U.S. Attorney's Office as an assistant to the Solicitor General in the solicit in the Solicitor General's office. She argued two cases before the Supreme Court on criminal issues and briefed dozens more. She also defended the President's First Amendment right to control his social media accounts, specifically his Twitter account. As an assistant U.S. attorney and appellate chief, Rebecca briefed and argued criminal and civil appeals, and prosecuted broad range of crimes including murder, human and drug trafficking, sexual child, child sex abuse, bank fraud, and robbery and embezzlement of public funds. When organizations were exploiting the COVID-19 pandemic to release prisoners, Rebecca fought successfully to keep them in prison. Praise for Rebecca's legal mind and commitment to the Constitution is numerous and glowing. But just as noteworthy is Rebecca's qualifications and accomplishments are even more impressive that her top priority remains devotion to her family, her husband Benjamin, and her three children, and to her faith. I'm proud to have recommended the President nominate Rebecca Taibleson to the Seventh Circuit, and to be introducing her to the Committee as the nominee. I strongly encourage everyone to vote in favor of her confirmation. Thank you. Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Senator Johnson. Now, Senator Budd. STATEMENT OF HON. TED BUDD, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA Senator Budd. Thank you, Chairman Grassley, happy birthday. Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Senator Budd. Ranking Member Durbin, thank you as well, and thank you to Senator Tillis for his partnership on these judicial nominations before the Committee today. It's my honor to introduce David Bragdon and Lindsey Freeman, who've been nominated by President Trump to serve on the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina. And Matthew Orso and Susan Rodriguez have been nominated to serve on the U.S. District Court for the Western District of North Carolina. I'm grateful to President Trump for nominating these exceptionally qualified individuals to serve as U.S. district judges for the great State of North Carolina. I have full confidence in each of these nominees, and trust that they will faithfully apply the words of our Constitution in the letter of the law without resorting to the wrongful practice of judicial activism. I'm equally confident they will make the decisions in an impartial manner, exercising deep judicial humility and treating everyone in the courtroom equally with respect. I'd like to now take a moment to briefly introduce these nominees to the Committee and present their qualifications to assume the bench. David Bragdon currently serves as the chief of the Appellate Division of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of North Carolina, and previously served as the assistant U.S. attorney in this office. Mr. Bragdon also served as the resident legal advisor for the Philippines and the U.S. Department of Justice, where he helped to strengthen law enforcement tools. Notably, Mr. Bragdon was also a law clerk to Justice Clarence Thomas on the Supreme Court and to circuit judge, Stephen Williams, on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District for the Columbia Circuit. Mr. Bragdon graduated from the University of Virginia School of Law summa cum laude. Campbell University where he served as student body president. Lindsey Freeman currently serves as the assistant U.S. attorney in the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Middle District of North Carolina. She's previously served in senior roles at the Department of Justice, including as chief of staff in the Office of the Associate Attorney General and the Office of Legal Policy. Ms. Freeman was also of counsel at the law firm of O'Melveny & Myers, LLP in Los Angeles and in Washington, DC. She began her legal career as a law clerk to Judge John M. Rogers on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Ms. Freeman graduated magna cum laude. Order of the Coif from the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School magna cum laude from Harvard University. Matthew Orso currently serves as partner of the law firm Troutman Pepper Locke in Charlotte, and was previously a partner at McGuire Woods in Charlotte. Mr. Orso began his law career as the clerk for Judge Robert J. Conrad Jr. of the U.S. District Court of Western North Carolina. Mr. Orso graduated magna cum laude from St. Louis University School of Law, where he served as editor in chief of the Law Review, and from the University of Dayton where he was captain of the rugby team. Last, but certainly not least, Susan Rodriguez, serves as the U.S. magistrate judge in the Western District of North Carolina. Judge Rodriguez was also previously a law partner at McGuire Woods in Charlotte. She served in policy roles at the White House Counsel's office and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. She began her legal career as law clerk to District Judge Frank Whitney of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of North Carolina. Judge Rodriguez graduated from George Mason University, Antonin Scalia Law School, and graduated magna cum laude from Center College. Mr. Chairman, I have personally met with each of these nominees before the Senate Judiciary Committee today. I've heard directly from them about their passion for the rule of law and our Constitution. They're highly qualified to serve the people of North Carolina in our great Nation with distinction and with honor. After hearing their testimony and responses to questions today, I'm sure that the Committee will agree that they are well qualified and prepared for the responsibility of serving North Carolina. I hope my colleagues on both sides of the aisle will find the same level of confidence in these four nominees before the Federal bench that I have, especially on this Constitution Day, as we reaffirm our duty to uphold the principles of justice enshrined as the supreme law of the land. Thank you. Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Senator Budd. You folks are excused if you want to go. Senator Tillis. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. THOM TILLIS, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA Senator Tillis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and congratulations, on the 42nd anniversary of your 50th birthday [laughter]. I also want to thank my colleague Ted Budd for being here. He is a great partner in the State of North Carolina. He makes us all proud. Chair Grassley, also I'd like to take the opportunity to thank Senator Durbin, former Chair Durbin, who honored the blue slip policy in the last Congress, which is why two of the nominees are before us today. So, thank you, Senator Durbin. It's an institution that's over 100 years old, and it's every bit as relevant today as it was 100 years ago when a Senator from Georgia sent a note on a blue slip of paper to a Chairman of the Committee saying that he disagreed with somebody in who was going to be solely in his State. And that began the process of the blue slip that I hope lasts another 100 years. Now, I want to congratulate the nominees and their families. And lots of kids here in the audience. Senator Kennedy is a very kind man and brought stationary to some of you, but there's more kids than we had stationary, so we'll make sure we get you some more before you leave today. But I want to welcome Matt Orzo, Susan Rodriguez, David Bragdon, and Lindsey Freeman. All four of these nominees are imminently qualified, and will make the State and our country proud. I want to thank Senator Budd again today for his great introductions. I may duplicate, but will add some to what I think are the best credentials you could possibly imagine for a District Court judge. There are currently only 10 active Federal judges in North Carolina, not counting those on senior statutes. So, filling these four vacancies is very important for our State. Senator Budd and I set out to find the best possible judges to fill these spots, and I could not be more pleased with the nominees that we have before us today. I'd also like to thank President Trump and the White House Counsel's office for their work with us on these nominations. Turning now to our outstanding nominees. Matthew Orzo is a graduate of the University of Dayton and St. Louis School of Law. Following law school, he clerked for Judge Robert Conrad in the Western District of North Carolina. Mr. Orso is nominated to fill that seat today. I believe Judge Conrad is in attendance today, and I'd like to welcome him, and thank him for his service. Following his clerkship, Mr. Orso went to private practice and is currently a partner at Troutman Pepper Locke. He has earned a reputation as one of the best lawyers in North Carolina, and will make an excellent addition to the bench. In addition to Judge Conrad, Mr. Orso is joined by his wife and five children. That's why I think he had a problem with the tablets. And I'd like to welcome them all. Susan Rodriguez is a graduate from Center College and the Antonin Scalia School of Law at George Mason. Between law school and college, she served in the Bush administration at the White House Counsel's Office. Following law school, she clerked for Judge Frank Whitney, whose seat she is nominated to fill today. Judge Whitney is also here today as well, and I'd like to welcome him and recognize him for his distinguished service. Judge Rodriguez was in private practice until she was appointed as a magistrate judge in the Western District of North Carolina, where she currently serves with distinction. In addition to Judge Whitney, Judge Rodriguez is joined by her husband, and children, and parents today. Welcome, to all of you. David Bragden is a graduate of Campbell University and the University of the Virginia School of Law. Following law school, he clerked on the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, and then for Justice Clarence Thomas on the U.S. Supreme Court. He has been with the U.S. Attorney's Office since 2007, serving as appellate chief since 2021. From 2017 to 2020, Mr. Bragdon served as the Department of Justice residential legal advisor to the Philippines. He has also served as an adjunct faculty member at Campbell University School of Law. Mr. Bragdon is joined today by his wife, two sons, and his in-laws. I welcome them. Finally, Lindsey Freeman is a graduate of Harvard University and the University of Pennsylvania School of Law. Following law school, she clerked for the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals before joining private practice. During the first Trump Administration, Ms. Freeman served at the Department of Justice, including as chief of staff and senior counsel. She currently serves as an assistant U.S. attorney in the Middle District for North Carolina. Ms. Freeman is joined by her husband, and I'd like to welcome them. It's an honor to introduce these four nominees with impeccable credentials, and I look forward to their testimony and their appointment to the bench. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Chairman Grassley. Senator Cruz was going to introduce Sarah Carter, but he's tied up in another Committee meeting, so I'd like to read his statement introducing Sarah Carter. So, I'm reading from Senator--what Senator Cruz would've said. It is my privilege to introduce my dear friend Sarah Carter as President Trump's nominee to serve as director of Office of National Drug Control Policy. The position is the so-called ``drug czar'' of the United States, charged with assessing and countering an ongoing crisis in which murderous substances pedaled by murderous cartels have flooded our streets and our country. It is a responsibility she is eminently qualified to fulfill. After graduating from California State Politic University with a BA in journalism and communications, Sarah began her distinguished career as a journalist. She currently serves as Fox News contributor, as well as senior investigative reporter and president of Dark Wire Incorporated, positions that she has held since 2017. Her career spans more than two decades of journalism, including Circa.com, the Blaze, Washington Examiner, The Washington Times, and the Los Angeles News Group. Sarah is one of the most tenacious investigative journalists, tracking and reporting on issues at the core of the national security and law enforcement. She has traveled, monitored, and reported on everything from Afghanistan to the U.S. Southern Border. She exposed the deadly impact of fentanyl and opioids, uncovered terrorists and cartel operations, and shed light on the devastating reality of human trafficking. She has brought to the Nation's attention the overlapping crisis of illict drugs cartels and human trafficking. Her focus on the fentanyl crisis and border security revealed secret tunnel systems, narcotics, trafficking routes, and even the involvement of the Mexican Federal officials in the drug trade. I have been to the U.S. Mexico border with Sarah several times. She accompanied me and other Senators on multiple delegations. Sarah and her team were on the front lines conveying footage of the humanitarian and drug crisis. In 2019, Sarah received the HIDTA Award for her nonprofit documentary, Not in Vain, which examined the fentanyl crisis cartel activity and national security threats. In 2023 she was honored by CPAC for her reporting on human trafficking in the Western Hemisphere. As President Trump said when he nominated Ms. Carter, ``Sara will lead the charge to protect our Nation and save our children from the scourge of drugs.'' I strongly encourage my colleagues to support her nomination. Thank you. That's the end of Senator Cruz's statement in support of Sarah Carter. Now, I'd like to have Ms. Taibleson come to the table, and I'd like to have you stand before you start out, because I'd like to issue this oath. [Witness is sworn in.] Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Now, as you sit down, you can give your opening statement. You have the privilege of introducing anybody you want to introduce that's here or isn't here in support of your nomination. STATEMENT OF REBECCA L. TAIBLESON, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES CIRCUIT JUDGE FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT Ms. Taibleson. Thank you, Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, and to the Committee, for considering my nomination. And thank you to President Trump for the great honor of that nomination. I'm also grateful to Senator Johnson for his generous introduction. I'll introduce some family who are here, my wonderful husband and three children in from Wisconsin. I just have to say, go Brewers for my son. Even today, especially today, the most important job I ever expect to have is being their mom. My parents, Michael and Cynthia are here from Pickens County, South Carolina, a place very familiar to Senator Graham. I lack the time or the eloquence to properly thank them today, both are lawyers. My father, a law professor, the apple did not fall far from the tree. We moved here from Canada when I was 4. We were not fleeing persecution or poverty. My parents simply wanted to raise their children in the greatest country that has ever existed. This one, and I am profoundly grateful. My brother, Josh, a veteran, has come here all the way from Hawaii, a State he fell in love with when he was stationed there as a Marine. My 3-month-old nephew and his mom are watching from Maui. I also have my husband's wonderful family here, and great friends and colleagues. Thank you for coming. Today, is Constitution Day, the 238th anniversary of its signing. That is the longest surviving written Constitution of any country in the world. And in my opinion, the Federal judiciary is one of our Constitution's finest creations. I know that firsthand from the judges who have been my bosses and mentors, especially Antonin Scalia, Brett Kavanaugh, and Diane Sykes, and from the work of appearing in the Federal courts day in and day out, representing this country and fighting crime in the Eastern District of Wisconsin. I know the Seventh Circuit particularly well. It's a learned and collegial court, and if I have the honor of being confirmed, I will spend the rest of my life living up to those values, to the examples set by my judicial mentors, and to the faith put in me by the President and this body. Thank you, Senators. Chairman Grassley. Are you ready for questions now? Ms. Taibleson. Yes sir. Chairman Grassley. Okay. Thank you very much. And compliments to your family for working with you for your public service. You had the rare opportunity clerk for not one, but two justices of the U.S. Supreme Court, Scalia, and then-Judge Kavanaugh when he was on the D.C. Circuit. What did those mentors teach you about the proper role of a judge and how did they inform your judicial philosophy Ms. Taibleson. So much, Senator. From Justice Scalia, I learned, I think, what we all learned from Justice Scalia, which is how to interpret the text of our Constitution and laws. He was a profoundly influential justice, perhaps the most influential of the century in which he served. And his influence on me was very pronounced. I wanted to clerk for him from the first Scalia opinion I read as a 1L in law school because no one more persuasively made the case for judicial restraint for textualism and originalism. And clerking for him was the best possible training in those values. From Justice Kavanaugh, I also learned so much. I think the number one thing I learned, I'll describe it as energetic public service, which is to say we in public service are supposed to--we work just as hard as someone who is billing a private client and getting paid by the hour. We take our obligation to the public profoundly seriously. And that means employing a very careful process to decide each case, no matter how long it takes. Reading each brief, carefully, deeply researching the law, and then writing in a manner that is so careful because your opinions need to withstand the tests of time and future testing in litigation. Chairman Grassley. The judiciary interprets laws to ensure the preservation of liberty guaranteed under the document. One of the most sacred is the right to free exercise of religion. Justice Kavanaugh recently said that the Supreme Court has, ``made some good progress on recognizing the Constitutional protection of religious equality and religious liberty.'' What are your views on religious liberty and the role of judges in protecting it? Ms. Taibleson. Justice Kavanaugh is right, Senator. In about the last 12 or 13 years, the Supreme Court has issued opinion after opinion that has been strongly protective of religious liberty. And I would of course follow those faithfully as a lower court judge. I actually had the privilege of working on several of those matters while I was at the Solicitor General's office. I worked on and helped draft the brief in a case involving Thomas More Law Center against Becerra challenging a California law. And there, the Supreme Court agreed with our religious protective views. I worked on Espinoza against Montana involving the Blaine Amendments and funding for religious schools. I worked on Fulton v. City of Philadelphia involving Catholic social services work to place foster children. And in both of those cases as well, the Supreme Court holdings protected religious liberty, which was consistent with the arguments that we made. In addition, Senator, I am a proud and practicing Jew, raising three Jewish children. And I think as a Jewish American you would have to be completely historically illiterate to be anything but profoundly grateful for this country's tradition of religious liberty. And that tradition protects not just the religious among us, but also secular values. I mean, if you think back to the sort of canonical phrasing in West Virginia against Barnett, the case involving the Pledge of Allegiance saying something like, you know, if there's any fixed star in our Constitutional constellation, it's that no official can tell citizens what is Orthodox in the areas of religion, politics, or morals. And so, that's, I think, an example of how the Supreme Court's protection of our religious freedoms really inures to the benefit of all Americans. Chairman Grassley. You appeared before this Committee several years ago in defense that Judge Kavanaugh's nomination. His hearing was tainted with unfair political attacks on his character. But your testimony as a woman who worked closely with him, provided critical insight into Justice's competency and temperament. How did Justice Kavanaugh's commitment throughout the confirmation hearing and his jurisprudence influenced you? Ms. Taibleson. The experience of watching and supporting Justice Kavanaugh's confirmation was a formative one. I remember thinking to myself many times that his commitment to public service, energetic public service, must be very strong to go through all of that. I was very honored to appear before this Committee in 2018. I actually had with me the littlest one there. She was a newborn. And so, she came, and she sat right outside the door there with a babysitter while I testified. And Senator Kennedy, I'm sure you don't remember, but at the airport later that day, our flight was 7 hours delayed. And I was there with a very fussy baby, and Senator Kennedy ran into me and was extremely kind. So, I remember that very well. And I'm very honored to be here before you, again, ideally in less contentious times and circumstances. Chairman Grassley. Thank you. Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Ms. Taibleson, you were doing just great until you mentioned the Brewers. [Laughter.] Ms. Taibleson. I'm sorry, hard disagree. Senator Durbin. Well, I won't hold that against you. Let me tell you, I'm wrapping up my Senate career with one more year. It's been my great honor to serve on this Committee, virtually, the whole time I've been in the Senate. There have been some glorious great moments and some not so glorious. I can recall when we had the first Muslim American nominee for the Circuit Bench in the Third Circuit a few years ago under President Biden. And the questions that were asked of that nominee I thought were beneath the of Committee. He was asked as a Muslim, if his family celebrated 9/11 in their home. He is from the New York area, and protested that he thought it was an outrage that anyone would suggest that because he had lost personal friends in 9/11. I thought that was a low point in the Committee. But I'm sorry to say what's happened to you today may be a new low point. We've received letters from conservative conservative political organizations criticizing you, your husband, and your family. How do they criticize you on the basis of your religion and your religious practice? I've never seen anything like it. American Family Association sends us a letter, let me tell you some of the things they criticize you for. You and your husband are affiliated with what they consider to be a politically liberal congregation. I can't pronounce it, but it's Emanuel Jerusalem in the Milwaukee area. They go on to criticize. ``It appears that the rabbi whom the Taibleson chose to perform their wedding currently serves a pro LGBTQ congregation.'' They then say that you and your family have donated to the Milwaukee Jewish Federation. I'm familiar with the Jewish Federation. It's a big deal in Chicago, as I'm sure it is in Milwaukee. They do remarkable great work. They then talked about other things such as your husband and you donating to candidates of both political parties. It's is beyond me to believe that an organization with this membership would raise these issues. They're ignoring the very basics of our Constitution, as you noted, which says, of course, in the Bill of Rights, we have freedom of religious belief or no religious belief. That's up to us, and the Government is not going to choose a preferred religion. But there's a third provision which says no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States. So, whether it's the First Liberty Institute or the AFA action group, both of which sent letters opposing your candidacy, conservative groups making that position, they're ignoring the obvious letter and law of the Constitution. I'd like to give you an opportunity to comment or react. Ms. Taibleson. Senator, I'm very proud of my Jewish faith. I was raised that way, my parents who are right there, raising our children Jewish. And, of course, Article VI of the Constitution says that there's no religious test for public office. And that's one of our Constitution's many protections for people of faith. And regardless of those letters, I'm really honored by--you know, it was the President's choice to nominate me, and he did so, and I'm honored by that selection and grateful for it. Senator Durbin. And let me ask you so it's a matter of record. Your selection for this position involved the two U.S. Senators from Wisconsin, did it not? Ms. Taibleson. Well, Senator, I don't want to mislead you. I don't think I have Senator Baldwin's support. What it did involve was its tradition in Wisconsin for any judicial nominee to proceed through this sort of nominating commission to which each of our Senators appoints three people. And I did go through that nominating commission, and they did send my name forward. But and I'm very privileged to have Senator Johnson's support. But I don't want to be misleading, to my knowledge, I do not have Senator Baldwin's support. Senator Durbin. Could I ask you to comment in the short time that's remaining. The Kavanaugh nomination was controversial at many different levels. One of the questions was what he would do as a member of the Supreme Court on the case of Roe v. Wade. What was your understanding of his promise, and what actually occurred? Ms. Taibleson. I don't recall him making any specific promise about a future case, like the one Dobbs that did come up. My memory is that like every nominee, he recited the sort of judicial canon that he can't make prejudgments or promises of cases in the future. I recall that, I think, he described as has every nominee, Roe v. Wade as a precedent of the Supreme Court, which of course it was. And then, in the Dobbs decision, the Supreme Court applied the established stares decisis factors to determine what to do with that precedent of the Supreme Court. Senator Durbin. What was your reaction to his vote on the Dobbs decision Ms. Taibleson. Senator, as a judicial nominee sitting before you, I can't give you a thumbs up or a thumbs down on Supreme Court precedents. Dobbs held that Roe was egregiously wrong on the day that it was decided, and had caused numerous problems in the law and in American society. And Dobbs determined that it was appropriate to overrule it. Senator Durbin. Thank you. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Former DOJ employees, they describe Ms. Taibleson as, ``An extraordinary lawyer, public servant, and colleague.'' And they praise, ``her topnotch legal mind, her unwavering commitment to the rule of law and her deep and abiding love of this country during her nearly decade long service within the department.'' Without objection, that will be included. Chairman Grassley. Senator Kennedy's the next. Senator Kennedy, you're the next. Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Counselor, as you know, it's hard to pass a bill in the U.S. Senate. Our Founders intended that to be the case. And consequently, if a bill does pass, it's gone through a long, arduous process; a lot of reports issued a lot of debate, and all of it is written down. Why has it become common practice, and do you support it, of ignoring that rich legislative history when you interpret a statute? Ms. Taibleson. Well, Senator, I think the first rule of statutory interpretation is that the text is what's paramount. And that's because the text is what actually proceeded through bicameralism and presentment, which are really just the---- Senator Kennedy. Of course, it's paramount, but why can't the text be supplemented by looking at the history? Ms. Taibleson. I think the legislative history can sometimes provide a tool to help interpret the text, and it's often in parties' briefs, and I would of course consider it that way. But it's just important to keep in mind its subordinated role in that interpretation because the intention of any particular legislator does not have the force of law. Instead, the text does. So, the legislative history and the intentions of specific legislators should never take primacy over the text or refute the text. Senator Kennedy. But it doesn't have to, does it, Counsel? It just gives you context. Ms. Taibleson. I agree with that. Senator Kennedy. When you interpret a statute or write a brief and you think that the language is plain, aren't you tempted to go look at the history just to make sure that your interpretation is correct? Ms. Taibleson. It depends, I suppose, on the particular statute, and the nature of the history at issue, and the question. Senator Kennedy. But don't you want to just go take a peek? You look at the language and you say, ``Well, this is, this is as clear as thunder on a summer night, but maybe I'll just take a peek at the legislative history to make sure that I'm not out in left field.'' And the Supreme Court condemns that. Does it not? Ms. Taibleson. The Supreme Court does not uniformly condemn that. And there are certainly cases where, you know, legislative history or statutory history have provided a tool-- -- Senator Kennedy. But sure, they do. Sure, they do. I mean, originalism--and I'm not saying they're wrong. Please don't misunderstand me. I'm just trying to understand your perspective. Originalism and textualism is accepted even by the left of center justices, and I've read opinion after opinion, lower courts as well, where they say, ``Well legislative history, we can't rely on it.'' Ms. Taibleson. Legislative history cannot be relied upon to trump the language of a statute. And so, in the language of a statute, really, is that clear, Senator? There's not that much, and it bears directly on the question before the court. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Well, let me ask you something. Does the Supreme Court sanction looking to the Federalist Papers in interpreting the Constitution? Ms. Taibleson. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Why isn't that legislative history? Ms. Taibleson. The process for ratifying the Constitution is of course different than the bicameralism and presentment process that applies to statutory text. The Constitution was of course publicly ratified---- Senator Kennedy. No, it's not. No, it's not. Ms. Taibleson. Well. Senator Kennedy. You look at the plain language, don't you? Ms. Taibleson. Yes, yes. But in looking at the plain language, the question we ask is what was the original public meaning of that language? And in the case of the Constitution, the original public meaning is elucidated by the debates surrounding its ratification. And those debates are really captured in the Federalist Papers, the Anti-Federalists Papers, ratification debates, the notes from the Constitutional Convention, documents like that. So, those documents can bear directly on the Constitutional text in a way that is more legitimate necessarily than the statement of an individual legislature would be vis-a-vis statute. Senator Kennedy. Well, then when we interpret the United States Constitution--and I agree with you that's the case, I'm just asking you whether you think it ought to be the case--then when we interpret the United States Constitution, why do we let lawyers do it? Why don't we just hire history professors? Ms. Taibleson. The history that judges are looking to in interpreting the Constitution and other statutes, is primarily legal history. It's not something like you know a biography of George Washington. It's instead things like statutes or debates about statutes, the Federalist Papers. And certainly, I think law schools could do a better job and should do a better job, teaching students how to read that legal history. But it is fundamentally legal history. And then the task the judges have in reading that legal history is to draw analogies between that legal history and our modern times. And that analogical reasoning is, I think, a fundamentally lawyerly task the judges are particularly skilled at. Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Senator Moody. Senator Moody. Thank you. Feel like I'm [off mic] over my colleague here, but I'll gladly do it. There. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Senator Moody. Thank you. You run a tight ship, and we appreciate you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you so much---- Senator Kennedy. It's his birthday. Senator Moody. It's your birthday, and it's the Constitution's birthday. Senator Kennedy. He was there [Laughter.] Senator Cruz. You should just ask him about the Federalist Papers and the debate. [Laughter.] Senator Moody. Absolutely. Senator Kennedy. Just ask Grassley. Senator Moody. Thank you for being here, and congratulations on your nomination. Thank you to your family. These hearings, we know, can be difficult, sometimes the most difficult because of my colleague Kennedy here than anybody else. But certainly, I know that you appreciate their support and we recognize them for being here today. I was particularly touched by your comments about Constitution Day, and that the Federal judiciary is one of our country's greatest creations. Indeed, the structure of our Government and the rights of its citizens that are set forth in the Constitution. I believe right now, at this moment in time, every American should be reminded of the beauty of this country. And it's the documents that set forth how we will govern ourselves as a free people, and the true purpose of government to protect its people and their rights. And I always love to hear from nominees their value in that, and especially right now we have this convergence of disorder and crime around some of our States and cities in which politicians are undermining the rule of law based on encouraging people in office to just obliterate the separation of powers. Meaning, someone in the executive branch that is asked for the responsibility to enforce the law, saying, ``Well, I don't agree with those laws and therefore I will not do that.'' Or even judges in some respect. And I say this with great sadness because I believe an independent judiciary is a cornerstone of securing the rights of a people and ensuring that grievances and conflicts have a place that people can take them, an independent arbiter. But I watch as district court judges around this country, not only rule based on what they believe the law should be, but go on to write lengthy written opinions that personally attack a governor or someone in office. And I don't say that that makes me angry or sad just because it may be a Republican, but because of what it does to the integrity of the institution, of the Federal judiciary, the undermining of the public's perception of its trustworthiness and independence. And I believe when you shake that too much you shake the foundation of this Nation and so on Constitution Day, I think it's important that we come back together and get back to basics on the true role of a judge. And you know you're going to be asked to write written opinions, sometimes you may author them. I was hoping you could give us your opinion on how a judge might author opinions that would restore or reinforce the public's trust in the judiciary and its true role. And it's a judges understanding of it's limited scope and the enormous trust of responsibility that we give judges. Ms. Taibleson. Thank you, Senator. The Federal judiciary plays, as you suggested, a vital role in preserving our separation of powers and done right. The Constitution assigns a very specific job to the Federal judiciary, which is to interpret and apply the law and not to make or change the law. And judges who carry out that obligation in good faith, I think, increase the public's faith in the institutions of our Government. Now, a few more specific interpretive principles flow from that general rule. Things like textualism and originalism help judges ensure that they're applying the law as written and not importing their own moral or policy preferences into cases. The elected branches are the ones who are able to exercise, and should exercise their moral and policy preferences in representing the people, but judges are not elected to the contrary. Senator Moody. What about these swipes that they like to take at elected officials in really superfluous language that is not needed in a legal opinion. Ms. Taibleson. I'm very lucky to be nominated to an extremely collegial court whose opinions are very disciplined, and I cannot think of such a swipe in a recent Seventh Circuit opinion. I would commit to following that tradition of collegiality and civility. There's really no need or place in for a judge to be taking personal swipes at anybody, whether it's from the bench or in your written work product. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Senator Blumenthal. Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Congratulations on your nomination. Thank you for being here. I want to go back to the question that Senator Durbin asked you about your support for Justice Kavanaugh. You were not only supportive, you were energetically and vehemently so appearing before this Committee as a witness and on cable television. I'm just curious if you knew then what he did in reversing Roe v. Wade, would you have supported him? Ms. Taibleson. Yes, Senator. What I said then, and what I still think is true now, is that then-Judge Kavanaugh had amassed a considerable record of experience on the D.C. Circuit that demonstrated his qualifications to serve on the Supreme Court. And I think his service on the Supreme Court has borne that out. Senator Blumenthal. But he demonstrated in Dobbs a total disregard for precedent and the principle of stares decisis. Ms. Taibleson. In Dobbs, the Supreme Court applied the established stares decisis factors to evaluate the ongoing precedential relevance of Roe. Those factors include the nature of the error in the precedent, how bad the error was or the quality of the reasoning, the reliance interests, the effect that the prior precedent has had on other areas of law, and its workability. Senator Blumenthal. So, you think Dobbs was correctly decided? Ms. Taibleson. Senator, as a judicial nominee, the cannons of ethics preclude me from giving a thumbs up or thumbs down to Supreme Court precedent because it suggests that I would apply that precedent according to my own thumbs up or thumbs down. And I wouldn't. I would apply every precedent of the Supreme Court faithfully. Senator Blumenthal. Let me ask you as a matter of precedent. Do you think Brown v. Board of Education was correctly decided? Ms. Taibleson. Yes, I do. As many judicial nominees, wiser than I, have gone before me to explain, Brown is a monumental and foundational decision of this country. And its core holding that's separate but equal is a violation of the Equal Protection Clause is correct. Senator Blumenthal. And how about Loving v. Virginia? Ms. Taibleson. The same exception has been recognized for Loving. And so, yes, I agree that Loving v. Virginia is correct. Senator Blumenthal. And Obergefell v. Hodges. Ms. Taibleson. In Obergefell, the Supreme Court held that the 14th Amendment requires States to recognize same sex marriages on the same terms as they recognize opposite sex marriages. And I would faithfully apply that precedent as a lower court judge. Senator Blumenthal. Well, let me make sure I understand. Are you answering the question, yes or no? Ms. Taibleson. I'm answering the question, that I would faithfully apply Obergefell as a lower court judge. And you know along with my fellow former nominees, I can't give Obergefell a thumbs up or a thumbs down. Senator Blumenthal. You said Loving was correctly decided, Brown was correctly decided. Obergefell, you won't opine? Ms. Taibleson. That's correct, Senator. Like previous judicial nominees who have sat before you, I'm bound by the canons of judicial ethics and I'm simply following the recognized examples of acknowledging the sort of monumental---- Senator Blumenthal. The principle of Obergefell is less valid to you than the principles in those other cases? Ms. Taibleson. That's not what I'm saying, Senator. I'm saying that Brown and Loving are monumental and solid decisions in sort of this Nation's history. The prior nominees have---- Senator Blumenthal. Well, I think there are a lot of folks who would feel that Obergefell is a monumental decision, too. Ms. Taibleson. Like basically every prior nominee before me, Senator, I'm not able to give a thumbs up or thumbs down there. Senator Blumenthal. Well, I think we expect more of an appellate court judge in your position than just to say like every other nominee before me, I'm going to evade an answer to that question. Ms. Taibleson. I will faithfully follow Obergefell and every Supreme Court precedent. Senator Blumenthal. And Griswold v. Connecticut, correctly decided? Ms. Taibleson. I will faithfully follow Griswold, along with Obergefell, and every binding Supreme Court precedent. Senator Blumenthal. Well, I'm disappointed in your answers, and my time has expired. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Senator Britt. Senator Britt. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and happy birthday. Thank you for being here. I appreciate your willingness to answer the call to service. You have an incredibly impressive career. To your children that are sitting behind you guys, your mom is a boss. Pretty incredible. And so, thank you so much for your willingness to do this at a time where I think our Nation is grappling with what it means to be in the public eye and stepping up to serve. In addition to that thank you for, for your willingness to do that at the highest level. Looking at your background, obviously clerking for then- Judge Kavanaugh and Justice Scalia, immensely impressive. In addition to your courtroom experience, I'd like to know, through that courtroom experience that you've had, is there a particular case that you've worked on that you believe is the most formative in your career? And how is that going to help kind of inform your work on the bench? Ms. Taibleson. I think the most formative case for me in terms of, especially, my Seventh Circuit practice was an in bank case called United States against Paige. And Paige concerned the standards for convicting people of conspiracies to traffic drugs. So, these are the more serious drug traffickers who we prosecute in the U.S. attorney's office. And in Paige, what we urged the Seventh Circuit to do was actually to overturn decades of its own case law that had sort of bit-by-bit, case-by-case, gone awry and deviated from the Supreme Court's guidance about the meaning of conspiracy. And we achieved that result successfully by doing essentially very deep research into the Seventh Circuit's case law, and then presenting our arguments forcefully, but respectfully, when you're asking court to overturn many of its cases. And we succeeded, you know, I think beyond my wildest expectations, garnering in the vast majority of the court to, I think, you know adjust its case law in the manner that we asked it to do so. Senator Britt. When you're looking at the then-Judge Kavanaugh or Justice Scalia and that experience that you had, is there any particular case or moment that where you were in discussion dialog with them? Anything that you feel like will be formative to how you conduct yourself when you're on the bench? Ms. Taibleson. As a law clerk? Senator Britt. Yes. Ms. Taibleson. As a law clerk, I think the most formative case that I helped with was the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare case. Obviously, the rules of confidentiality and clerkships preclude me from saying too much about that work, but it was a huge case and I was privileged to get to work for Justice Scalia on that. Senator Britt. Excellent. Look, I know that you're a member of the Attorney General's Review Committee on Capital Cases, and you've litigated cases involving issues related to the death penalty. I know that the death penalty is far more common at the State level than the Federal level. But as President Trump has now issued the executive order allowing the use of the death penalty when in criminal cases in Federal, when authorized and appropriate under the law, can you explain how the use of capital punishment differs from Federal court as opposed to the State court system, and discuss your role on the Attorney General's Review Committee and what all that entails? Ms. Taibleson. Yes. So, each State, of course, has the authority to decide for its own self, the penalties that are attached to its most serious crimes. So, some of our States have the death penalty and some do not. And you know in practice, as a result, there are far more executions in some States than in others. The Federal Government, by contrast, of course, has a uniform rule across the United States, and there are a reasonably small number of Federal crimes that are eligible for the death penalty upon conviction. Within the Department of Justice the decision of whether to seek the death penalty in a particular case is an extraordinarily weighty one that goes all the way up to leadership. And in its path up to leadership, there's something called the Review Committee for Capital Cases, which is a set of DOJ attorneys who review the cases that are eligible for the death penalty and make a recommendation that goes to department leadership about whether to seek or not. And so, it's a careful process that's really case-specific and that you know always keeps in mind the extreme weightiness of that work. I have, as you mentioned, led the appellate litigation team for two Federal executions, and that is among the weightiest and most serious work I have ever done. And so, I take that extremely seriously. Senator Britt. Absolutely. Well, I just want to say thank you for your willingness. Are these your parents here as well? Ms. Taibleson. Yes. Senator Britt. You've got to be so proud. I mean, her command of the issues, her knowledge, and the way she conducts herself with class, integrity, is amazing. You know, when you see somebody go toe to toe with our colleagues up here, it's amazing. And I also wanted to say thank you for your commitment to Senator Moody of conducting yourself with collegiality and civility, and the way that you approach things on the bench. Ms. Taibleson. Thank you. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Senator Whitehouse Senator Whitehouse. Thanks very much, Chairman. Ms. Taibleson, welcome. Tell me where the boundary is between First Amendment protected speech and unlawful prosecutable misconduct? Ms. Taibleson. There are a few categories of you know speech that are exempted from First Amendment protection and they are criminal. So, examples are threats or fraudulent speech. Things like libel and defamation can be subject to civil litigation. Fighting words, incitement. Those are the sort of standard categories of speech that are exempted from First Amendment protection, and instead, subject to civil or criminal liability. Senator Whitehouse. And that is pretty established set of boundaries. Right? Ms. Taibleson. Yes, Senator. I should have been clear. I was answering with respect to Supreme Court precedent not--you know it's not written in the text of the Constitution itself. Senator Whitehouse. But those boundaries have been there for a long time and are quite clear to ordinary normal judges. Correct? Ms. Taibleson. The categories are reasonably well established. There are sometimes questions about whether something fits into a particular category, whether it's conduct or speech. So, not every case is easy, but I think the categories I listed are pretty well established in Supreme Court precedent. Senator Whitehouse. And does that boundary shift in any respect depending on which side of a public argument you are on? Ms. Taibleson. Under Supreme Court precedent, viewpoint discrimination under the First Amendment is strictly--is basically almost never. And so, to the extent you're talking about viewpoint-based discrimination, which say sort of treating different speech favorably or less favorably under the law based on its viewpoint, that is subject--is the strictest scrutiny under the Supreme Court's cases. Senator Whitehouse. The reason I ask is that I think we're seeing an administration that wants to attack and perhaps even try to criminalize, or at least burden with investigation and prosecution, protected speech that it just happens to disagree with because the protected speech is to disagree with and challenge the administration. And I think it's really important in that contest that courts hue to that well established line. Do you agree that courts really need to stick to their guns on this question of the line between First Amendment protected speech and unlawful conduct? Ms. Taibleson. Every case has to be taken case-by-case with respect to the very specific speech that's in front of you, and the facts, and the law. And of course, Senator, the ultimate obligation of every Federal judge is to follow the law. Senator Whitehouse. And there's no rule that gives the President a special privilege to move that boundary just because he's the, the senior executive official? Ms. Taibleson. The President has the authority to set our enforcement priorities you know, as every President has done, including in criminal prosecutions. And then, within the scope of each criminal prosecution, the you know law will be applied to the facts of that particular case. And in that process, yes, it's the law that governs. Senator Whitehouse. And the boundary remains the boundary? Ms. Taibleson. Yes, Senator. Senator Whitehouse. Yes. I wanted to just flag one additional thing. I mentioned this fairly often in these hearings because court credibility often comes up as an issue, I think, in which we are all concerned. And I just want to take this opportunity to point out with respect to court credibility, that if you look at the record of what is going on at the Supreme Court, and particularly, you look at amicus practice in front of the Supreme Court, what I see regularly is a flotilla of anonymously funded, dark money- funded right wing groups that file packets of amicus briefs, 10, 12 at a time in a really big case, as many as 50. And the Court does not oblige them yet to disclose whether or not those amicus briefs are coordinated, scripted, commonly funded, multiple ways for the same actual voice to penetrate the Supreme Court case with seemingly independent, but actually like different piano keys on the same piano. And I think that's a failure of the court. And I also think that it becomes telling at some point when whoever's behind those briefs always wins. They don't always show up. They only show up when it matters to the interests of who are behind those front groups. But my experience is--and we're trying to put some hard numbers to this--my experience is that when those right-wing dark money groups show up, they always win. And I think that does not help the credibility of the court. And I thank the Chairman for allowing me to go 8 seconds over. Chairman Grassley [off mic]. Senator Hawley. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Taibleson, welcome. It's great to have you here. Congratulations on your nomination. Let me just pick up on a question that Senator Blumenthal was asking a moment ago about abortion and life issues. What standards should courts apply when reviewing State abortion laws? Ms. Taibleson. What the court held in Dobbs was that the Constitution does not provide a right to abortion. And as a result, Dobbs returned the issue of abortion to the people and the representatives, State-by-State, and said essentially, this is not a question for Federal judges because it doesn't say it in the Constitution. It's a question for the people and the democratic process. And that is the effect of Dobbs. And as a result, you know the State democratic process is now the process that has control over that issue. Senator Hawley. What about Federal legislation affecting abortion? Ms. Taibleson. Federal legislation affecting abortion would be subject to the same you know scrutiny as other Federal other Federal legislation. It has to fall within Congress' enumerated powers first and foremost. Senator Hawley. What's the precedent or lines of precedent that would govern any review of Federal legislation related to abortion? Ms. Taibleson. Well, I mean, a few lines of precedent might potentially be relevant. You know, whether it's legitimate commerce clause or spending clause, legislation is probably the first question that comes to mind, depending on how the law is structured and if not, whether there is some other affirmative hook in the Constitution that provides Congress with the power to pass that law. Senator Hawley. So, you recognize Dobbs then as the controlling precedent when it comes to life questions? Is that what I'm hearing you to say? Ms. Taibleson. From the Supreme Court, yes, sir. Senator Hawley. Well, and the Seventh Circuit or anywhere else for that matter. Correct? Ms. Taibleson. Absolutely. Senator Hawley. I mean, if there's any contrary Seventh Circuit precedent, Dobbs would supersede that. Ms. Taibleson. Absolutely. I think--yes. Senator Hawley. And you--I'm sorry, go ahead. Ms. Taibleson. No, absolutely. And I would faithfully follow Dobbs, of course. Senator Hawley. Good. And you regard it as controlling precedent and as settled law? Ms. Taibleson. Yes. Senator Hawley. Let me ask you this. How should courts weigh the rights of medical providers who object on unconscious grounds to participating in abortions? Ms. Taibleson. The Supreme Court's decision in Hobby Lobby provided--you know, reflected the fact that employers have important religious rights to resist the Government's requirements that they provide certain forms of healthcare to which they object. Senator Hawley. What about doctors? Ms. Taibleson. I'm sorry, Senator, what about doctors? Senator Hawley. Medical providers, I mean doctors who object to participating in abortion-related procedures? Well, how should the court weigh those claims? Ms. Taibleson. I think I should be somewhat circumspect because there is litigation pending around the country. And so, the canons of ethics preclude me from prejudging these questions too much. But I think the basic method of analysis would follow the Supreme Court's approach in Hobby Lobby, but extending it to that context. Senator Hawley. What about pro-life sidewalk counseling outside of clinics? Is that core First Amendment speech? Ms. Taibleson. Sidewalks are recognized by the Supreme Court as core public forum where the rights to free speech are at their Zen or their strongest. Senator Hawley. And there's no difference. It doesn't matter if it's an abortion clinic or something else you're saying. I mean, it regardless, the fact that the sidewalk is a traditional public forum should control the analysis and whatever the facts of the case may be. Ms. Taibleson. Generally, Senator, under Supreme Court precedent, content, or viewpoint-based discrimination in the context of a traditional public forum is viewed with extreme skepticism. Senator Hawley. Very good. Let me ask you about free exercise questions. Should the free exercise clause be given the same strength and weight of other fundamental rights like free speech? Ms. Taibleson. Absolutely. The free exercise clause, I believe, the very first clause in our Bill of Rights, and for a reason. Senator Hawley. So it is. How should courts evaluate claims of religious liberty when they conflict with generally applicable laws? Ms. Taibleson. The Supreme Court has spoken to that recently in cases like 303 Creative and some other--you know, Espinoza, Fulton. And what the Supreme Court has established is that even generally applicable laws don't carry with them an exception to the First Amendment's free exercise clause. And so, if the application of what looks like a generally applicable law, like, let's say, a funding restriction has the effect of discriminating against people for their religious practice, then that can violate the First Amendment. Senator Hawley. Is this the Trinity Lutheran case of any bearing here, do you think? Ms. Taibleson. Yes. Thank you, Senator. The Trinity Lutheran case concerned, if memory serves, funding for those playground grounds--we've all seen them with kids that are made of recycled tires. Senator Hawley. Correct. Ms. Taibleson. And there was a State program to fund playground grounds of recycled tires and a church playground applied for funding. And it was denied on the grounds that we don't provide funding to church organizations. And so, what the Supreme Court held in Trinity Lutheran was, no, you can't do that. If you have a general funding program, you can't discriminate against some of your recipients simply because of their religious faith. Senator Hawley. And how does that interact with the Smith case? Ms. Taibleson. The Smith case held that general laws of, I think, neutral applicability don't necessarily violate the free exercise clause. And Smith case remains a precedent of the Supreme Court that I would follow. But in the last 12-ish years, the Supreme Court has explained that Smith case doesn't mean a State can effectively exempt a religious entity from a State benefit, which is what was happening in cases like Trinity Lutheran. Senator Hawley. Last question, Mr. Chairman. I think, think you're Mr. Chairman now, right? Very good. Just one further question on Smith. So, in the Trinity Lutheran case and the Hosanna-Tabor case, the Supreme Court said, well, Smith actually is about physical acts, it's not about other things. How do you understand that? I'm not asking you to grade the Court. I'm not asking you to go beyond what the Court said. I'm just trying to figure out how you--you're a student of the law. You've worked at that court. You've litigated at that court. I'm just trying to figure out how would you, as a judge, you're going to have to read these intersecting lines of cases. What does that mean to you? How do you interpret that distinguishing of Smith? What do you think that means? How does that cash out? Ms. Taibleson. That's a tough question, Senator. I think the Supreme Court is struggling with Smith in many of these religion cases. I think the other thing that it said in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia was that Smith didn't apply there because although there was a general policy was one that the city was granting exemptions to sort of left and right. And so, there are certainly exceptions to Smith that the Court has recognized. But happily, there are enough of these cases that I think as a lower court judge, you can generally find one that's roughly similar to the facts before you, and that's particularly true in the last 12 or 13 years, where these cases have been uniformly protective of religious liberty. So, my essential method would be one of an analogy and to see which of these Supreme Court cases is most on all fours with the case before me. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much. Thank you. I've enjoyed your answers, and I think, very, very cogent. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Cruz [presiding.] Ms. Taibleson, let me first of all say, nice job dancing with both Senator Hawley and Senator Kennedy. They can be challenging questioners and you acquitted yourself ably---- Ms. Taibleson. Thank you. Senator Cruz [continuing]. For both of them. Ms. Taibleson. Thank you. Senator Cruz. By the way, Kennedy did show some mercy not quizzing you on obscure Latin maxim. So, I'm disappointed, frankly, because that's one of the things I enjoy most about these hearings. Senator Kennesy. Res Ipsa. [Laughter.] Ms. Taibleson. The thing speaks for itself. [Laughter.] Senator Cruz. You began your career clerking for two Supreme Court justices, Brett Kavanaugh, when he was on the D.C. Circuit, and then-Justice Scalia. What did you learn about judging and approaching the law, from both justices? Ms. Taibleson. From Justice Scalia, I learned to be fearless in your intellectual commitments. You know, when you've thought about something deeply and have written about it, and you've made a sort of intellectual commitment to an area of law, you follow that commitment wherever it goes. But at the same time, to maintain deep civility and collegiality with your colleagues, even those with whom you disagree as Justice Scalia did. I also learned from Justice Scalia that it's possible to balance a full life in the law with a very full life at home. He just. I mean, he had that huge family and really great friends, and he really lived life fully. And I hope to emulate that. From Justice Kavanaugh, I learned that you can never be too careful. It's really always worth the time to go back and read one more case, to reread your opinion one more time, to make sure that you've picked every single one of your law clerk's brains, because the work is profoundly important. And we serve the public by writing opinions that have to last and that have to work in different factual scenarios. And from both justices I learned, you know, they are both still learned in the law, but managed to maintain a persistent sort of intellectual curiosity about the law. You know, if there was a new law review article, they would read it. And they were always sort of interested in intellectual debates about corners of the law that they hadn't yet explored. And I think that curiosity and open-mindedness really serves a Federal judge well, because it keeps you open and also excited about your work. Senator Cruz. So, you have a very impressive legal career. You managed to overcome the enormous impediment of graduating from Yale. Not once, but twice. I will say though, your nomination has attracted quite a bit of interest. I have had people reach out to me on this nomination more than any other judicial nomination in the second Trump term both from critics and from multiple conservatives who I respect deeply and who know you well and have vouched for you energetically. As Senator Durbin, noted 55 conservative groups signed a letter opposing your nomination, and they raised concerns that I think boiled down to a concern that you are secretly a closet liberal, and that you'd be an activist on the bench. I want to give you an opportunity to respond to those concerns however you would like. Ms. Taibleson. Absolutely. Thank you, Senator. Let me say, I guess two things. First, I was raised by a very conservative law professor sitting right there. And you know, it has stuck. We were actually--you know, I went to a Jewish day school, and we were--I think it felt like we were the only conservatives at our Jewish day school in the 1990's. Especially back then, if you were Jewish and conservative, you had to really mean it. And we did, and my parents raised us to be proud of those beliefs and to be proud of those differences. I think my service in the U.S. Government has been fully consistent with those values. I have obviously been a prosecutor fighting violent crime. I have prosecuted human traffickers, meth traffickers, international opioid dealers, corrupt city employees, armed robbers, carjackers. I think that work is consistent with my values. We also turned our lives upside down to move to DC with two 3-year-olds and an infant so I could serve in the Solicitor General's Office in 2019. And in that job, I did work that I'm very proud of. And that was consistent with my conservative values. The second thing, you know I guess, I'll address, Senator, is I know that a lot of the concerns are about my husband. And it is true that my husband and I don't agree about everything in politics or the law, but my husband and I do agree about what it turns out are more important things in day-to-day life. We are agree about devotion to our children, our religious faith, love of this country, devotion to public service, deep relationships in our local community. And that is the stuff of day-to-day life. And I was raised in actually in the best tradition of Charlie Kirk to relish debate, you know, prove me wrong. And so, we do have law and policy debates, but it works for us because we have so much else in common. And although I'm quite certain my husband is wrong, on many matters of policy and law, I love him very deeply, and we have a wonderful family life. Senator Cruz. If you're anything like my wife, you're quite certain your husband is wrong on every issue that he disagrees with you on. [Laughter.] Ms. Taibleson. Depends if you take the trash out. Senator Cruz. And you're probably right. That was a very impressive answer. And I will say one thing that I find particularly impressive is Justice Kavanaugh's nomination before this body was incredibly contentious, and I think you showed a lot of courage standing up and defending your former boss. And I think that speaks to character. And I don't know if you care to explain why you chose to come forward and put your own credibility on the line to defend Justice Kavanaugh. Ms. Taibleson. Absolutely, Senator. You know what? It wasn't hard because everything that was being said about Justice Kavanaugh was fundamentally inconsistent with a man who I knew very well. I've known him very well for 15 years now. We worked very closely together, and I know that he's a good man. And those allegations were so fantastical to me that it was not hard to raise my hand and tell the truth about the man that I knew, and I would do that again, 100 times out of 100. Senator Cruz. Thank you. Senator Tillis [presiding]. Senator Schmitt. Senator Schmitt. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for being here. Congratulations on the nomination, and you're here on Constitution Day. Ms. Taibleson. Yes. Senator Schmitt. I mean, quite an honor. I do want to ask you in that vein the preamble of the Constitution states that, you know, says, ``We the people.'' The Second Amendment grants the right to keep and bear arms to the people. The Tenth Amendment sets aside rights for the people. Section 2, Article I says, the people choose their Members of the House. Who are the people? Ms. Taibleson. Well, Senator, this is obviously a subject of much litigation right now, particularly under the Second Amendment. And so, I need to proceed with a bit of caution given the judicial canons. But you know there are arguments out there that the meaning of the people was not necessarily exactly the same amendment by amendment and provision by provision, and that you know there might be some contextual analysis that needs to be done to define the precise scope of each of those constitutional rights. Senator Schmitt. Yes. It's been interpreted differently for public education versus maybe the Second Amendment. How do you wrestle with that as relates to sort of the privilege and immunities clause that guarantees rights to citizens? How do you--and what I'm getting at is are illegal aliens part of the people? Ms. Taibleson. Well, you know the privileges and immunity clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, when you read it, it certainly sounds like it would do quite a lot. But since the Supreme Court's decision in the Slaughterhouse cases, it has not had a ton of weight to pull in constitutional litigation. And instead, the Supreme Court has viewed the due process clause as the lens through which many substantive rights are incorporated against the States and apply to the people. You know in terms of the protections that illegal aliens have under different provisions of the Constitution. Again, it's an issue under active consideration in the courts, so the cannons prevent me from getting into it too much. The general parameters of the analysis would be to look at the text of the constitutional provision in question, look at the history of its application. So, for example, the history of the application of the Second Amendment might differ from the history of the application of the Fourth Amendment, and then understand the constitutional text in light of that history. Senator Schmitt. Yes. My guess is you might have some of these cases coming before you as they'll be litigated. In the time that I have remaining, I want to ask you about a couple of other things that you've done a very good job of addressing all the legal questions. What role in your view does common sense play in in your jurisprudence? Ms. Taibleson. I'm from Wisconsin, and so I embrace common sense. For me, I think it's fair to say I am a textualist and an originalist, and but I do have some common-sense guardrails in me. By which I mean, when you get to the end of your work, it's important just to pick your head up and look around, and make sure that you haven't lost the forest for the trees, or been staring at the same five words of a statute for so long that you've, you know have forgotten what else is out there in the world, and talk it through with your colleagues and your law clerks in a sort of common-sense way. Now, I don't think that means any judge's personal common sense should trump the law that this body has enacted. It definitely should not. But I do think that it's important for judges not to totally lose the forest for the trees. Senator Schmitt. During my time in the job I had before this as Missouri attorney general, I learned through some pretty contested litigation, I think, some of the important character traits that that public officials should have, or through this kind of forging process that you go through that matter. As a Federal judge, you're going to be confronted with a lot of difficult cases that have a lot of implications and consequences, and the chattering classes will be talking a lot. And do you still have a life outside, I hope. Outside of your role on the bench? And I guess what I'm getting at, and I actually think this question is perhaps the most important question least that I can ask especially in the times in which we're living in of this really hyper politically charged environment threats of violence; what, aside from your very commendable support for now, Justice Kavanaugh and his confirmation hearings, can you give me an example of a time where you stood up for your beliefs and your convictions, and risked really professional and personal backlash in making the right decision, even though you knew there was going to be a lot of heat in the kitchen? Ms. Taibleson. Yes, Senator. I mentioned before that I led the appellate litigation team for two Federal executions during the first Trump Administration. And one of those executions was on January 14, 2021. So, it was 6 days before the transition. And at that point, the issue of continuing lawful Federal executions became quite controversial in the department, and large parts of the department bowed out. But I did not. And I raised my hand to handle that work. And I did the work of not only the SG's office in that, but also the other divisions that had declined to participate. I don't think I left the office for several days. And I did so because a jury decades earlier had lawfully returned a verdict of death, and the victims in that horrific case had been waiting for decades for justice, but it was not easy, personally or professionally. Senator Schmitt. Okay. Thank you. Thank you for your time. Senator Tillis. Ms. Taibleson, thank you for being here today. I did want to compliment you. I think some of us noticed you did your opening statement, including the introduction of all your family members in 2 minutes and 44 seconds. For those about to do introductions, you may want to keep that in mind. [Laughter.] Senator Tillis. I'm not going to ask questions. I'm quite satisfied with your background and the work you've done, and I remember you walking the halls when we were doing the Kavanaugh hearings. I also want to tell your son I'm a Braves fan, but I'm also a Brewers fan because I once coached when I lived in Northern Virginia, a team that was called the Brewers a bunch of eight-and 9-year-olds out on the baseball field. So, the Brewers have a place in my heart, even if they don't for Ranking Member Durbin. But thank you for being here today, and you now may step aside, and we'll have the staff transition for the next panel-- -- Ms. Taibleson. Thank you very much. Senator Tillis [continuing]. I'd like to administer the oath. If you all please stand and raise your right hand. [Witnesses are sworn in.] Thank you. You may be seated. We will allow introductions at this point. It's our normal process if you'd like to introduce any of your family members, I know we got a lot here, please feel free to do so. Mr. Bragdon, we'll start with you. STATEMENT OF DAVID A. BRAGDON, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA Mr. Bragdon [off mic]. Senator Tillis. Make sure your mic is on red means go. Mr. Bragdon Thank you Senator Tillis. Thank you for your kind words. Thank you, Chairman Grassley, and Ranking Member Durbin, for holding this hearing. Thank you to President Trump for the honor of nominating me, and for the Committee Members for your work. Thank you, again, Senator Tillis and Senator Budd for your kind remarks, and for your support of my nomination. I am very grateful to all the friends and family who have supported me and prayed for me through this process. In particular, I'd like to thank my wife, Ellen, for her steadfast faithfulness in 24 years of marriage, courage, and perseverance. Thank you to my sons Evan and Ben who are here today. And my son Seth who is studying abroad. I appreciate my family's willingness to serve God no matter what the circumstances. I have wonderful in-laws, Frank and Claudia Whitaker from Oak Ridge, North Carolina, who are here today, and have always supported me. My mother and brother, Diana and Dan Bragdon are watching online, and my father passed away in June, but I have always appreciated how he and my mom have raised me and my brother, for his role in developing my character. I'm grateful to Justice Thomas, for the chance to clerk with him and how influential that was in my life. I'm grateful to my friend, Andrew McIndoe, who is here today also in support of me. And thank you for all the friends and family who have just supported me, and are too many to be named. Finally, I thank God for his grace and strength each day, and I look forward to the Committee's questions. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Mr. Bragdon. Ms. Freeman. STATEMENT OF LINDSEY ANN FREEMAN, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA Ms. Freeman. Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, and distinguished Members of the Committee. It is an honor to appear before you. I would first like to thank President Trump for this nomination. I'm incredibly grateful and humbled by this opportunity. I'd also like to thank you, Senator Tillis, and Senator Budd, for your warm words and your support throughout this process. I first would like to thank God for as many blessings, most importantly, the people he has given me in my life. I have to, of course, recognize my husband, Jordan, who drove up from Greensboro last night after putting our two little ones to bed so that he could be here by my side. He is the most amazing man, and he is an incredible role model to our two sons, who at 3 and 2, are not here today. But in case they watch this later. I want to say mommy loves you very much. I would also like to thank my parents who have always shown me incredible support, and my sister, who is also my best friend. I'm fortunate to have several friends here today, and that means so much to me. And throughout my career, I've been fortunate to have many friends, mentors, and colleagues. Too many to name to any degree. But I will simply say that I'm humbled by their kindness, support, grace, and guidance that they have shown me throughout my career, and I simply know that I would not be here without them. I would like to say a word about the judge that I clerked for, Judge John Rogers. His humble and faithful application of the law, and the respect and kindness he showed everyone in the courtroom inside and out continues to inspire me to this day. Again, thank you to the Committee, and I look forward to your questions. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Ms. Freeman. Mr. Orso. STATEMENT OF MATTHEW E. ORSO, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA Mr. Orso. Thank you. Senator Tillis, Ranking Member Durbin, Members of the Committee, thank you for having me here today and for your dedication to fulfilling this important constitutional role of advice and consent. I'm grateful to be here and consider it a privilege. First, I thank God without whom none with this would be possible. To President Trump, thank you for your support in nominating me. To Senator Tillis and Senator Budd, thank you for your kind words today. Thank you for your support throughout this process, and for supporting my nomination. I have a few very important people here today. First, my wife, Jenny, of 20 years. She's my best friend. She supported me and my career endeavors at every step of the way. She's a model of loving service and holiness to me and to our six children, and there's no way that I'd be here without her. Our oldest son couldn't be here. He's in college and should be in class and studying, but he may be watching. And the remaining five are all sitting here behind me. My children are the joy of my life, and they're each an immense blessing to me. My mother, Ann, is watching online. She's my biggest fan. I love her dearly. My brother, Joe, and his family, and my brother, Jim, are also probably watching. I'm dedicating this all to my father, whom we lost just a couple of years ago. I think he's probably here watching too, though. My wife's parents, Brian and Patty Blais, they welcomed me into their family from the start and have shown me nothing but love and support all of these years. And here in the room today also is my good friend and longtime mentor, Judge Robert Conrad, who currently serves as the director of the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts. He took a chance on me many years ago hiring me as his law clerk, and he hasn't stopped rooting for me after 16 years. Judge Ken Bell is similar. He hired me in private practice and provided me every opportunity to succeed and to grow as a lawyer. And I look forward to joining Judge Bell on the bench, if I'm fortunate enough to be confirmed. Also, a good friend here, I think Jim Whitaker, today, and I value his friendship and support immensely. Thank you, Senators, and I look forward to your questions. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Mr. Orso. Ms. Rodriguez. STATEMENT OF HON. SUSAN COURTWRIGHT RODRIGUEZ, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA Judge Rodriguez. Yes. Let me begin by thanking President Trump for this nomination and opportunity to serve the Western District of North Carolina. I also want to thank the home State Senators; Senator Tillis, Senator Budd, and to your staff for all of your support during this process. I also want to thank Chairman Grassley, of course, I didn't get to wish him happy birthday in person, but I do wish him happy birthday. Ranking Member Durbin, thank you for scheduling this hearing, and thank you to the other Members of this Committee in the Senate for considering my nomination. I want to introduce just a few people that are here with me today. My husband, Bert. He is a United States Naval Academy graduate, a talented runner, and of course, he honorably served our Country. Next year will be 20 years of marriage, and we together have four incredible children. Since it is Constitution Day. I'm very pleased to report to you that at least some of them through school and discussions can recite the preamble. And I told their teachers as an excuse for missing school today that this will be a great lesson in learning a little bit about our Government. I'm honored to have my parents, Vicki and Barkley Courtwright, right here. They're from Kentucky. Some of you knew or may know that I grew up in rural Kentucky. Thanks to the encouragement of my parents, I was the first to go to college in my family, and what a tremendous example they've been for me. And that's where I learned a very strong work ethic. My brother Mark and his wife Carolee are here. They also made the 11-hour trek to DC by car, and I'm very grateful that they're here today. My brother David and his wife, I think are watching. They're enjoying their new grand baby. I also want to introduce my father-in-law, my mother-in- law, Bert and Lucy Rodriguez, my niece Avery, and her parents, Christina and Ryan, as well as our cousins who came from Miami Liztie and Manuel Del Canal. I also want to recognize a few of the judges that are here with us today. Judge Frank Whitney, who Senator Tillis you mentioned earlier. I clerked for him, and you know what an incredible person he is. He's a wonderful judge, and I've just learned a lot from him. Judge Robert Conrad, who's already been introduced by my colleague, Mr. Orso. He once gave me a book that changed my life, and I'm very grateful for him. Judge Ken Bell is not able to be here today, but he's the one that had the trust and confidence in me as a young attorney to give me very significant matters upon which I built my career. There are many other judges watching from the Western District, and I know they're cheering us on today, and I'm very appreciative of all of them. I'll also want to mention U.S. Magistrate Judge Bob Numbers from the Eastern District of North Carolina is also here with us. And he's a good friend to not only me, but others on this panel. I also want to recognize U.S. Deputy Marshall Tommy Weeks and his family. And Senator Tillis, I know you're aware of this, but Deputy Marshal Weeks gave his life in the line of duty, and that was about 18 months ago. He's part of the court family, and I definitely want to recognize him and his family. I also want to recognize my law clerks who are not here today, but I know they're watching; David Greg, Mary Grove, and my former clerk Nicole Giffen. They are just incredible people with grit, and show me perseverance each and every day. I thank them. I also want to thank the good Lord for being here and the talents he's given me. I hope to put them to good use. If confirmed, I will defend and support the Constitution of the United States, and work hard to exercise my duties fairly and impartially. Now, there are many others that I could go on and on about, too many to recount today. But I do want to thank them. I know they're watching. And I look forward to answering the Committee's questions. Thank you. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Ms. Rodriguez. Ms. Carter. STATEMENT OF SARA CARTER BAILEY, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL DRUG CONTROL POLICY Ms. Bailey. Thank you so much, Senator Tillis. First, I want to say thank you to you, to Ranking Member Durbin, and distinguished Members of the Committee. Thank you for this opportunity. I want to begin by remembering my dear friend, Charlie Kirk, whose life left a lasting mark on many. Charlie was deeply committed to inspiring younger generations to engage with the world around them. His tragic loss is a solemn reminder that we must work together to unite to save American lives. I also want to acknowledge my husband, Marty, who is here with me today. He is a wounded warrior who knows the cost of fighting our Nation's enemies firsthand. I also want to thank our six children; Sophia, Analiese, Justin, Erica, I have the whole group, Alexander, behind me, and our six grandchildren who I love so much. Benjamin, Matthew, Charlotte, Gracie, Sage, and Baby Gabe. I love them dearly. They came from all across the country to be with me here today. Their love and their sacrifice make it possible for me to answer this call to serve. I am also deeply grateful to the angel families here today. Despite enduring the greatest loss imaginable, you continue to fight. You are the moral conscience of this fight, and your courage is an inspiration. And to the law enforcement officials here, including HIDTA Director, Mike McDaniels, and Deputy Director Goss, and to the men and women in uniform you represent, you are the tip of the spear in this war. Finally, I thank President Donald J. Trump. His leadership has been a fundamental declaration of our national will. By designating the worst cartels as foreign terrorist organizations, he has made it clear the era of tolerating this assault is over. America will no longer permit the infiltration of fentanyl and other illegal drugs designed to kill our citizens. I come before you, not just as a nominee, but as a witness to the war that has been waged against our country for years. For two decades, my work on the front lines wasn't just about telling stories, it was about mapping the enemy. I traveled deep into cartel territory because you cannot defeat an enemy you do not understand. I tracked the supply lines from the opium fields of Afghanistan, where my husband was nearly killed by terrorists, funded by drug money, to the cocaine labs in Guatemala, and the cartel battlegrounds in Mexico. I have seen these predatory criminal empires operate with impunity in our hemisphere. That impunity ends now. Let's be perfectly clear about the nature of this fight. This is not just a public health crisis. It is a chemical war being waged against the American people. Our greatest resource, our citizens, are being targeted and killed. They are not statistics. They are our children, our neighbors, our loved ones. This fight is personal to me. My mother was an immigrant who fled communist Cuba for the promise of a free and safe America. My father was a proud Marine who fought in two wars to defend that promise. Their fight for freedom and safety is the same fight we face today, and I carry their spirit with me in this mission. As director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy, my mission will be one of relentless offense. We will protect American lives by taking the fight to the enemy. We will hunt them in their safe havens. We will dismantle their labs, seize their finances and assets, and sever their supply lines. We will use every instrument of American power to break the backs of these organizations. But a true victory requires us to fight this war on two equally important fronts; relentlessly attacking the supply of these poisons, while systematically reducing the demand from them here at home through robust prevention, treatment, and recovery support. That means mobilizing every asset, enlisting educators, faith leaders, community leaders, and law enforcement, in a national effort to prevent drug use before it starts. We will work to create a culture of resilience where staying drug free is the norm. We must teach our children that these substances are not recreation, they are poisoned, deployed by an enemy. We will defend the next generation from this chemical assault. This mission is urgent. We are losing over 300 Americans every single day. To put this into perspective, we have lost more Americans to elicit fentanyl in the past 5 years than all U.S. troops killed in combat since World War II. We, as a Nation, would never tolerate foreign actions that kill our people on this scale. We are under attack, and we will respond accordingly. My life's journey has prepared me to lead this fight. I am committed to working with this Committee, with law enforcement, with the families who know this pain firsthand. Let me end with this. The chemical poison being pushed into our country does not care if you are Republican or a Democrat. The terrorists profiting from this death do not care about our politics. This cannot be a partisan issue. It must be an American mission, one that requires all of us united to defend our children and the future of this Nation. Our objective is not mitigation, it is victory, Senators. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Ms. Carter. I had the opportunity to meet with a number of the nominees in my office beforehand, and I told them all to go and watch the game tape of Senator Kennedy. I also went to Senator Kennedy and told him he gets to open up in my place. I'll be speaking last. So, Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr.--I'm sorry, I can't see that far. Senator Tillis. Bragdon? Senator Kennedy. Who wants to volunteer? [Laughter.] Senator Kennedy. Let's just start in the middle and we'll work to the end. Mr. Orso? Mr. Orso. Orso. Senator Kennedy. Yes, thank you. I'm sorry. I really can't--I guess I need to get new glasses. Mr. Orso, let's suppose, imagine this situation; small printing company and manufacturer of envelopes, stationary like that, that sort of thing. Twenty employees, small operation. They take customer orders, go in the back, print the stuff. They wear uniforms because the owner wants to promote his company logo. Employee shows up one day in uniform, but she's wearing a burka. And the owner says, ``You can't wear a burka here.'' And the employee says, ``Yes, I can.'' And the owner says, ``You're fired.'' Tell me how you'd analyze that case. What questions you need to know. Who would win? Who would lose according to Supreme Court precedent? Mr. Orso. Sure. I would likely look first to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act in 1964, since---- Senator Kennedy. That's correct. Mr. Orso [continuing]. It's an employment case. Senator Kennedy. And what does Title VII say? Mr. Orso. It says that a person cannot be discriminated against in employment on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, right, gender. And then, I would apply the facts of that case pursuant to any---- Senator Kennedy. What facts would you have to know? Mr. Orso. I'd have to know if the wearing of that burka was indicative of any potential religious closely, sincerely held religious belief. And then, if so, would analyze it from there. Senator Kennedy. What if the employer said my customers won't like it. Is that a justification? Mr. Orso. I don't believe that would be sufficient justification to discriminate against someone based on religious belief. I think you'd have to take into account whether the employee's employer is providing any type of accommodation that that allows for that person to---- Senator Kennedy. What if this small business owner said it's dangerous. The employee might get the burka caught in the manufacturing apparatus. Mr. Orso. I think I would have to look at the case law if there's anything similar in that. But my instinct is that in terms of protecting the safety of employees, is a valid concern of an employer. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Fair enough. David--I'm really-- can't see. I need to do something. Mr. Bragdon. It's Mr. Bragdon. David Bragdon. Senator Kennedy. Thank you. Mr. Bragdon, tell me about supplemental jurisdiction. Mr. Bragdon. Supplemental jurisdiction, I am having trouble remembering that term because it, it does not come up in criminal practice very much, but I believe it---- Senator Kennedy. It'll come up in Federal district court-- -- Mr. Bragdon. Absolutely. Senator Kennedy [continuing]. Every other Thursday. Mr. Bragdon. And I'll certainly carefully research any issue that were to come before me, if I'm---- Senator Kennedy. It used to be called pendant jurisdiction, does that help? Mr. Bragdon. But I think it's jurisdiction that builds on jurisdiction. I'm thinking it builds on jurisdiction of another party who's already properly before the court. But I don't specifically remember, Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Do you know? Ms. Freeman. Senator, I would say that that is my understanding as well, and I don't have too much to add. In my years as an AUSA, I haven't been working on that recently. Senator Kennedy. Who knows the answer? Judge Rodriguez. This is Judge Rodriguez, and so I'm a sitting U.S. magistrate judge right now, so I think that I'll step in for the panel. There was a recent Supreme Court case on this. So, supplemental jurisdiction is when the court would have original jurisdiction over some sort of Federal question, but then there is a State question, and so that's where the court can exercise its discretion over supplemental jurisdiction. A lot of times where that comes up is if something gets kicked and there's only State law claims. Does the court exercise jurisdiction otherwise over those State law claims? And there was a recent Supreme Court decision on this that basically said that the court could get divested of its jurisdiction if a plaintiff dismissed everything, all of the Federal claims. And so, it goes back to a jurisdiction issue. And that's what you would be normally looking at. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Let me go back to Mr. Orso. So, how do you amend the Constitution? Mr. Orso. Senator, I think you'd look to Article V of the Constitution and follow the instructions for two-thirds of the legislature, or two thirds of the States. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Fair enough. Let me move to the gentleman to your right. What's the difference between a preliminary and a permanent injunction, and how you decide them, Counselor? Mr. Bragdon. A preliminary injunction--well, let me start with a permanent injunction. Would be a final judgment in the case that occurs after the completion of all the litigation. Senator Kennedy. What do you have to--let's start with the preliminary. What do you have to prove to a judge? Mr. Bragdon. For preliminary injunction, there's several standards the court looks at. You're looking at irreparable harm. You're looking at the likelihood of success in the merits and the ultimate case as it goes through court. You're looking at balancing the equities of the parties. So, those are some of the factors the court considers and whether to grant that. And it's essentially, the idea is can you keep things in place while that litigation is pending? Senator Kennedy. What factors do you look at for permanent injunction? Mr. Bragdon. Well, the permanent injunction would depend on the relevant law or action that's being considered. Senator Kennedy. But what factors do you look at for a permanent injunction? Mr. Bragdon. So you, for a permanent injunction---- Senator Kennedy. You look at the same factors, don't you? Mr. Bragdon. I think that in my mind, a permanent injunction depends on the underlying statute or relief that you're taking. And it can vary based on the kind of case. Senator Kennedy. Well, on a preliminary injunction, you're asking is the plaintiff or the move likely to succeed on the merits. And so, and a permanent injunction, you're asking has the party succeeded on the merits. Right? Mr. Bragdon. Correct. My only point is what the merits are is going to vary based on the kind of case. Senator Kennedy. Fair enough. Counsel, tell me about class actions. What are they, and what are the elements of you have to prove? Ms. Freeman. Senator, I believe you're referring to Rule 23. So, in order to have a class action, you're allowing one plaintiff or just a few plaintiffs to stand in for a class of a larger number of individuals to bring that class action. You have to meet the factors that are set out, the elements that are set out in Rule 23. So, we're looking at numerosity, typicality, representation, commonality, I believe. But those are some of the factors. Senator Kennedy. I didn't realize I'd gone this far over. I'm sorry. Senator Tillis. This concludes the entrance exam. [Laughter.] Senator Kennedy. I really apologize. I didn't mean to go this far. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Senator Kennedy. I appreciate you asking the questions. Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Carter, I hope we can agree that the HIDTA grants are valuable to fighting the drug crisis in America? Do we? Turn your mic on. Ms. Bailey. Absolutely, Senator Durbin. HIDTA is a very important part of fighting. Senator Durbin. So, last year, the 33 HIDTAs, which are high intensity drug trafficking areas, the 33 areas identified by that program seized 4.1 million pounds of fentanyl and other drugs, and denied drug traffickers $17.7 billion in illicit profits. Proof positive of what we both agree on. HIDTA grant's work, right? Ms. Bailey. Absolutely. Senator Durbin. So, let me ask you to please explain why the HIDTA program is subject to a 34 percent cut by the Trump budget from $300 million to $200 million. Have we won this war on narcotics and don't need this anymore? Ms. Bailey. First, let me begin by stating that I absolutely support the President's budget. Secondly, I do and absolutely support our high intensity drug trafficking. HIDTA aide groups. I was actually just recently in Alaska. I made a trip to the furthermost part of the United States in an effort to meet with the HIDTA director there and an effort to see the fight that we are continuing to fight against the drug cartels. I figured it's already--we've seen the supply pouring across the southern border. We've come across---- Senator Durbin. I'm going to have to slow you down a little bit. We have a limited amount of time if we follow the rules of the Committee, and I would like you to answer my question. How would you justify a 34 percent cut in HIDTA grants if we haven't won the war on drugs? Ms. Bailey. The Big Beautiful Bill also supplements that funding. We continue to access this administration continues to assess those grants, and HIDTA is absolutely supported by the Office of National Drug Control Policy, which it falls under. Senator Durbin. 34 percent cut is not support. Ms. Bailey. Right behind me, I have HIDTA Director Michael McDaniels and Deputy Director Rick Goss. Senator Durbin. That's good. I'm glad they're here. But that doesn't help to cut the program by 34 percent. Let me go into the Mexican drug cartels because you said you have some personal knowledge of those. Are you aware that these drug cartels are heavily armed? Ms. Bailey. Absolutely. Senator Durbin. Do you know their weapon of choice? Ms. Bailey. Yes. I mean, they use assault rifles, they use grenades. They use quite an array of weapons. Sometimes, they out resource even our own law enforcement. Senator Durbin. And the Mexican police and military forces as well, correct? Ms. Bailey. That is correct. Senator Durbin. And one of the most common weapons they use is a 50-caliber rifle? Ms. Bailey. That is correct. Senator Durbin. I'm not an expert on firearms by any means, but I understand that that is a military-style weapon that is so powerful that it can penetrate a vehicle. Ms. Bailey. These are lethal weapons. Yes, that is correct. Senator Durbin. You also know that the Mexican government has done an analysis of where these crime guns come from for the drug cartels and find that 70 percent come from the United States. Are you aware that? Ms. Bailey. Yes, of course, Senator. We are assessing both sides of this horrific situation that our country is facing. Senator Durbin. So, if you're dealing with a drug crisis that you'd characterize as a chemical war being waged against the American people, and 70 percent of the weapons are coming from the United States to these terrorist cartels, do you believe we have any obligation to try to stop that flow of weapons? Ms. Bailey. We're assessing both sides of this issue. Absolutely. We're working with our partners both in Mexico, and here in the United States, as well as law enforcement to assess this and mitigate those threats? Senator Durbin. What do you suggest we do? Ms. Bailey. We're continuing to work with both sides---- Senator Durbin. You've got to get beyond assessment. You got to do something to stop the flow of deadly weapons to the cartels. Ms. Bailey. Well Senator, I believe shutting down the border has effectively stopped the flow, both going south and coming north. Senator Durbin. We stopped the flow of weapons from the United States and Mexico. Is that what you're testifying? Ms. Bailey. I believe by shutting down the border and working with our partners in Mexico, who are as responsible for the crisis that we are facing, we have significantly reduced the flow going south as well as coming north. Senator Durbin. I want to see that in writing. Can you produce it? Ms. Bailey. I will absolutely work with you on this, Senator. Senator Durbin. Well, I think it's very important that you do that. Ms. Bailey. Absolutely. Senator Durbin. The drug crisis is serious. You want to take on drug crisis for America. You don't have a background in this other than an interest in the subject. And I would just say that they trust you with that responsibility when we're cutting the budget of this agency by 34 percent the HIDTA grants by 34 percent really gives a lot of us pause. I'm not sure why you were chosen, you're articulate, but that doesn't mean you're expert enough to manage this job. So, let's see what you produce for me. Ms. Bailey. Absolutely, Senator. Thank you so much. Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Senator Durbin. I'd like to enter into the record three letters from Families Against Fentanyl, Parent Collective, and Lost Voices of Fentanyl. These nonprofits represent thousands of families deeply impacted by the drug crisis in our Nation. These organizations strongly support Ms. Carter's nomination and believe that she is the, ``hands-on, data-driven leader who will work to end the fentanyl poisoning crisis.'' Without objection, I'd like to have these entered into the record. Senator Tillis. Senator Hirono. Senator Hirono. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I always ask these initial questions of all nominees before any of the Committees on which I sit to ascertain fitness to serve. So, I'll ask the questions, and we'll start with Ms. Freeman and go right down the line. Since you became a legal adult, have you ever made unwanted requests for sexual favors, or committed any verbal, or physical harassment, or assault of a sexual nature? Ms. Freeman, then we'll go down the line. Ms. Freeman. No, Senator. Mr. Brandon. No, Senator. Mr. Orso. No, Senator. Judge Rodriguez. No, Senator. Ms. Carter. No, Senator. Senator Hirono. Have you ever faced discipline or entered into a settlement related to this kind of conduct? Ms. Freeman. I have not. Mr. Brandon. I have not. Mr. Orso. No, Senator. Judge Rodriguez. No, Senator. Ms. Carter. No. Senator. Senator Hirono. Thank you. One of my concerns with many of President Trump's nominees is their lack of qualifications and relevant experience for the positions to which they have been nominated. And I want to note for the record that Ms. Carter Bailey, who has been nominated to be director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy up until 3 months ago had never worked in this environment or in this space. And so, before 3 months ago, she had never even worked in government. She has no background in drug policy, no experience in public health. So, I have concerns as to the lack of relevant qualifications, experience of this nominee. I have a question for Mr. Orso. Mr. Orso, what does the Supreme Court case Griswold v. Connecticut stand for? Mr. Orso. Senator, the Supreme Court in Griswold held that there was a constitutional right to contraception I believe. Senator Hirono. So, Mr. Orso as a district court judge, you'll follow that precedent and the cases that that relate to contraception, use of contraception? Mr. Orso. Yes, Senator Hirono, I would to follow all Supreme Court precedent, if fortunate enough to be confirmed as a district court judge. Senator Hirono. And basically, you would follow Supreme Court precedent in all cases---- Mr. Orso. Absolutely. Senator Hirono [continuing]. Until the Supreme Court decides otherwise? Which by the way, this Supreme Court, as you well know, has been overturning decades of precedent in many, many areas, and this is possibly one of them going forward. So, I did want to also note Judge Courtwright Rodriguez, that since becoming a magistrate judge, you've presided over at least two naturalization ceremoneys. Can you share with the Committee what those experiences meant to you? Judge Rodriguez. Yes. Those are very near and dear to my heart. You may have read my comments that I typically make at the naturalization ceremoneys. I have my father-in-law and my mother-in-law who both immigrated from Cuba. Castro, came to power and literally took everything from my mother-in-law's family. And she came here to the United States, and they're very grateful. So, because they naturalized, I am lucky enough to be married to my husband here. So, those are near and dear to my heart. Senator Hirono. Thank you. And I want to note for the record that you commented that the United States has been referred to as a great melting pot where everyone brings their culture and history, and we are all the more enriched because of that. I completely agree with you as a naturalized citizen myself, and as we have a regime that is very much against diversity, equity, and inclusion, which is really reflective of the diversity of our country. I am very glad to know that you considered the naturalization ceremoneys where we are welcoming people from all over the world to be part of our great basically the mix of culture and the history in our country that en enables our country to be strong and great. I commend you for that attitude, because it's one that I share. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Senator Hirono. Senator Kenny. Do you have any intention of asking any other questions? Senator Kennedy. No, sir. I'm happy a happy camper. [Laughter.] Senator Tillis. Ms. Carter, I think we have Senator Moody coming. I have a couple of questions for you. Ms. Carter. Yes. Senator Tillis. I've been down to the border multiple times, and I am thrilled with the results of this administration in shutting down the border. I think it's a great disservice to people who immigrate legally. And it also has made our country less safe. In the time that I've been down there, I've had numerous briefings with Customs and Border Patrol, and I don't know if the statistic is right anymore. You made a comment about effectively shutting down the border. I agree that we've done a good job with that, but these cartels do an amazing job of getting around. I've been on the Rio Grande at midnight or 1 o'clock, and I've heard the coyotes, the human traffickers, the drug traffickers, literally across the Rio Grande shouting to us, ``We are coming.'' And they always would set a pick. What they would do is take about 40 or 50 persons trying to come into the country illegally, attract the border patrol there so that they could send their poison or human trafficking to another area where the Border Patrol is just too involved. They can't get to them. I think a lot of that play has been pretty much shut down because the President's done an extraordinary job of enforcing policies that the Biden administration didn't. But the concern that I have is you still have what they call the Sinaloa Cartel. So, they're flying ultra lights over and dropping off drugs. They're very difficult to detect because we don't have the situational awareness that we should at the border. And we also see a lot of the poison. And in my last briefing about a year ago, according to Border Patrol, that still the majority of the illegal drugs that come through this country come through a legal entry point, hidden in trucks, hidden in bodies. I mean what are we going to do to really combat that, and get this Congress to understand that people, technology, and infrastructure at the legal ports of entry so that we can increase commerce and legal entry and exit? What's going to be the priority there? How do we get that done balance between maximizing the flow between two nations that have very important economic and other ties, but do it in a way that's really plusing-up the resources that Border Patrol needs to get the job done and keep our country safer. Ms. Bailey. Well, thank you so much for that question, Senator Tillis. I think that's a vitally important question because it's such a complex question. We have nearly 2,000 miles of border with Mexico. You're absolutely correct, our law enforcement assesses that the majority of the narcotics continue to pour through our border, and the cartels are very savvy. For decades, they have been working to figure out ways to work around us, to find those loopholes, to bring that poison into our Nation. Not only are we dealing with the cartels, but we are dealing with adversaries who are taking advantage of those loopholes as well. President Trump did a phenomenal job coming in and shutting down that border. The cartels were operating with impunity, and we saw that under the last administration, the flow of human trafficking, the horrors of human trafficking. I saw it with my own eyes. I was at the border almost 24/7, monitoring the situation. I, too, would see, and I can attest to what you saw, sir, across the Rio Grande. Even late at night, looking through my nods, which were my night vision camera, you could see the cartels moving across with 75, sometimes 100 people every hour on the hour. Senator Tillis. Yes. I want to be respectful of Senator Moody's time, but I think one thing I look forward to speaking with you after confirmation, to really listen to the voices of Border Patrol who say we do need walls in some places. But what we need is a law enforcement-driven strategy for securing the border, not only from human crossings, but all of this poison that's coming across the border. And that means that we have to get the mix right between people, technology, and infrastructure. I don't want to spend a dime more on a wall if it's not what's going to make this country safer. And, you know, the problem with a 30-foot wall is a 40-foot ladder. And if we do not have situational awareness, operational awareness on the ground, then all these good works are going to be for naught when a future administration comes. That, I think, de- emphasizes one of the most important things that we need to do for Homeland Security. So, I appreciate you being here today. I'm going to turn to Senator Moody. Ms. Bailey. Thank you, Senator. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Tillis. And thank you for all of our nominees for giving up so much of your time and your families for being here today. Thank you for supporting them. Life of public service is not easy, especially these days. And oftentimes, I find that it is harder on our families than it's sometimes on us. So, thank you to the families that are here with you. You know, as Florida's attorney general, I fought very hard against the opioid and then synthetic opioid epidemic. It is something our country has never seen. We are losing more Americans working and fighting age Americans to the drug epidemic than any other cause of death. It's frightening when you put into perspective how it compares to when we thought we were dealing with this crisis in the 1980's, when Nancy Reagan first said, ``Just say no.'' We were losing about 3,000 Americans a year. We now lose over 100,000 Americans a year to drug overdose. And so, from holding pharmaceutical companies, distributors, manufacturers accountable in court, or working with law enforcement to step up interdiction efforts, or making sure that we were getting that message to our children, or equipping our first responders with naloxone, I was very focused on this as attorney general. And one of the things I found was that the message wasn't getting to the kids. And we were losing unsuspecting kids that did have no reason to believe that they were about to ingest a fatal dose of fentanyl. They were dying. The fastest growing age category for overdose on fentanyl is under 14. And so, I have been very vocal commending this administration for thinking outside the box on how we tackle our greatest challenges. And that goes from where we're putting our current resources. Shifting not only monetary resources, but human resources to different agencies or responsibilities, and then the people he's appointing. As it pertains to the Nation's ``drug czar,'' that has looked very differently for many different administrations. I believe under Biden, he had a physician. Some people have former Governors, some people have law enforcement. I think it is very unique that we have a mom of six. Ms. Bailey. I've got six beautiful children. I think I left one of them out. Luke, I am so sorry. I was thinking about that the whole time. Senator Moody. Ah, I set you up for that. Ms. Bailey. I've got Luke, Sophia, Analiese, there's Parker, her husband, there's Benjamin, my grandson. So, we've got six children, six grandchildren, all together. And nothing is more formidable, you are right, Senator, than a mama bear. Senator Moody. So, we were together recently speaking on the efforts of this administration to not only interdict, shut down the border, which they've done with no new laws. They've shut down the border, interdict this flooding into our country killing Americans, but also how do we get through to parents in terms of warning kids and kids that anywhere from 5-to-7 out of 10 pills contain a lethal dose of fentanyl, the counterfeit pills. And I was with the nominee and the sheriff in Miami-Dade County who is also a mom and dealing with these every struggles, coming up with ideas of how as ``drug czar'' you can get that word out. I was just hoping, because, you know, and I want to make sure everybody knows. To fulfill the responsibilities of this job, it has looked different depending on the administration and what they're trying to accomplish. But certainly, I think you bring a very unique on-the-ground perspective. Not just personally--although man, you should be given a trophy for six kids and having such an accomplished career, but professionally. And what do you think is unique about your background and your current, and your current work that that sets you apart from prior nominees, and you bring a fresh perspective and zeal about the responsibilities of this position? Ms. Bailey. Well, I think you already mentioned one of them, Senator Moody, and it's my family. But you're right, I'm not a doctor. I'm not a general, I'm not a lawyer. What I am was a more than two-decade investigative journalist who was on the ground, in the field witnessing firsthand what these cartels and what these terrorist organizations have not only done to our Nation and to the rest of the world, but to our children. And you mentioned something very important. You talked about the 1980's when we were losing 3,000. I think the number I got was at one point, it was 6,300 when we thought it was really in 1980, when we really thought that was a terrible sign of where our Nation was heading, you know, for drug overdose. And now we're looking at over 100,000. I have angel families sitting behind me who will never, never see their children again, because poison came across our border, and their children unknowingly took either a pill--even I say now, as Mike Gland who is sitting behind me has said. You know, he lost his son, Preston, but he said, ``One try, you die.'' Not one pill can kill anymore. It's one try, you die. You think about this, one of my son-in-law's closest friends from high school lost his life in Miami at a party, you know doing drugs, not expecting that to contain fentanyl, and immediately, immediately lost his life. I don't want to see that happen ever again. I am committed with all of my heart and all of my soul to working for every single American, every single family. As I said in my own statement, these drugs, these cartels are adversaries. They don't care if we're Republican or Democrat. They don't care if we're a member of the Green Party, or if we're of no party at all. They are making hundreds of billions of dollars off of the death of Americans, and off of the deaths of people all over the world. I have someone here as well, Rosie, who works with the Kaleido Foundation. And I can't tell you how many times Rosie and I have been in Mexico together. Human trafficking victims that I have interviewed, that I have spoken with. These cartels are taking lives with impunity. They were operating with impunity, now they know that we mean business. Their designation by the President as foreign terrorist organizations; Sinaloa Cartel, Nueva Generacion, El Mencho, the ghost who tries to hide from all of us, will no longer be sleeping restfully anymore. All of these cartel leaders, all of these terrorist organizations, and even our adversaries are on call right now, and especially the cartel leaders. Senator Tillis. Senator Booker. Senator Moody. Thank you. Senator Booker. Chairman, Thank you very much. I had a great exchange with the Chairman earlier, and we talked about the State of North Carolina. I've done years in service with this man, and he made it very clear to me, lay off my judges, Booker. So, let me just say simply this to all those who are nominated for positions in North Carolina, I'm a Jersey boy through and through, but I'm the son of a North Carolinian. And my dad grew up in Hendersonville, up in the mountains. And North Carolina was his pathway to progress. He went to North Carolina Central University. I know my dad is now in heaven. He died 6 days before I was elected to this office. But he was a North Carolinian through and through. So, congratulations on your nomination. You're representing a great State, and I know especially seeing a lot of the faces of your family behind you, that you take this nomination seriously. And I wish you Godspeed. I really thank you, Ms. Carter, for the passion. And I just would love to explore an area in which there's been tremendous bipartisan work, not just here in the Congress but all over America right now. We're seeing such wisdom from red States and blue States learning from the mistakes in the 1990's with that led to an explosion of incarceration, but no reduction in drug use. And it's something that I've leaned on. Everybody from Right On Crime to the Manhattan Institute have been invaluable in my journey in helping me shape policy, especially in my days as a mayor. I am this strange guy. I used to get joked by with by Mitt Romney. I'm not Mormon, but I've never drank. I've never smoked. I am a pretty boring guy as my fiance tells me. But I do have some frustrations with marijuana policy based on science, and I'd like to focus there first. On your podcast in 2023, Ms. Carter, you talked about cannabis and you said, ``I don't have any problem if it's legalized and monitored.'' You supported the use of cannabis for medical purposes, and we had bipartisan hearings here with military personnel talking about the transformative impact it's had on their PTSD. I just believe that we have a moment now where 40 States have made cannabis legal for medical purposes. Unfortunately, Federal law is lagging behind State law and behind popular opinion on all across the political spectrum. In fact, under Federal law, cannabis is still a Schedule 1 drug, the category that's really reserved for some of the most dangerous drugs, some of which I think I came in on a conversation that you were talking about. They say that cannabis has no medical value. That's what Schedule 1 says. In essence, cannabis is considered just as dangerous as heroin in the Federal system. In 2022, President Biden directed the Secretary of Health and Human Services to just review how cannabis is scheduled on their Federal law. And after its scientific review, Health and Human Services recommended rescheduling cannabis at Schedule 3. I think that's a step in the right direction, and that would finally, at least, recognize that we would not only have medical benefits, but it would allow scientists to study the short-and long-term health impacts. It would open up the door to more scientific study. And so, I'm wondering if you were confirmed, how would you advise the American President about the ongoing rescheduling process? Ms. Bailey. First, thank you so much, Senator, for your comments. You're right, I am very passionate. I could see that you are very passionate as well. This is a bipartisan issue, and I look forward to working with you as well as all the Republicans here on the Committee and other Democrats. So, first, thank you very much, and I extend an invitation to speak with you at any time of your choosing. If confirmed, as director, I will comply with all Federal laws and fulfill all statutory responsibilities of the ONDCP. However, we will continue to work extensively with research and data. We will continue to do that and explore all options. I've already met with Secretary Collins with the Veterans Administration. All of us are discussing, you know, these continued research and data that we will be delivering, and based on that research and data we can continue to assess. I think that is vitally important. Senator Booker. So, I know the Federal law prohibits the Office of National Drug Control Policy from funding any study or contract relating to legalization, including for medical use. It's unfortunate, but that makes the study of Schedule 1 drugs, including cannabis, really difficult. And so, I'm hoping as we work together across the aisle on legislation that would simply allow the ONDCP to study the impacts that this might be something that you would support. Ms. Bailey. Absolutely. We'll continue to study the impacts of that. Senator Booker. Thank you. I'm going to give some other questions for the record, but I just want to--one quick last question. We're seeing this overdose crisis, and we're seeing communities I think we're talking about tragically affected by fentanyl. I believe we need to make sure that people who use drugs or are in recovery have access to naloxone, which is proven to reduce overdose deaths. I'm going to put some questions in the record on that. But I am very concerned, and I've seen such bipartisan work in this area. I have a bipartisan bill on this that the ONDCP issued its drug control strategy of 2026, the top priority to reduce the number of fatal overdose. This is scientists saying the top priority, and this is what it reads, I'm going to quote it here, ``We will encourage State and local jurisdictions to increase the availability of drug test strips and naloxone to mitigate the impact of deadly drugs on communities across the country.'' I have seen study after study that show that test strips can save lives, that even addicts when they have access to test strips will test the drugs they're using before they're taking them. And so, I just will hope, and I'll put these questions in the record, that if confirmed, you'll ensure that ONDCP increases the availability of fentanyl test strips and naloxone. That we can work together as we have bipartisan legislation here with you to get it passed and done right. And that the tragedy that we have right now for test strips causing people who are trying to save lives, put them in criminal jurisdiction, criminal jeopardy is really bad. So, I know we don't have any time left. I look forward to those questions on the record. I just want to say one more time, these are wrote hearings, and often they're the Senators on both sides of the aisle are so busy, we're running to different hearings. I just want the people who are up for nomination to know, and the families especially that we take this very seriously. That there's a nobility. Everybody sitting at that panel who wants to serve their country in the best way possible. Most of you are giving up more lucrative positions to do what you're doing, and you're not doing it alone. It's also a family sacrifice. There's a lot of talk about our divides here in Congress, but I can say this for every, every Senator, thank you for stepping forward to serve your Nation, and thank you to every family person that's represented here as well. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Tillis. Thank you, Senator Booker. And Senator Booker, your points on cannabis, I think are very well taken in many respects. I think Congress is not doing its job by recognizing that that bell has been rung. And unless we get serious about regulatory regimens and other--Matt, we've talked about the fentanyl crisis. Now, we all know that at some point in the race for potency, that these subproducts that are being purchased, technically illegally in 40 different States, either for medical purposes or several dozen for recreational purposes, Congress needs to step up and try to figure out how we can manage this, exploit its efficacy in areas that are helpful, particularly for the treatment of persons with PTSD, a number of other studies out there, pain. But we've got to step up. And I appreciate you making those comments. And in my remaining time here, hopefully we can get something done. Well, this is going to conclude our hearing today. I had the privilege of being able to vet the district nominee, so I didn't feel like I had to ask you other questions after we put you through hours of discussion between my office and Senator Budd's. And Ms. Carter. Also want to congratulate you-all on your nominations. This is a unique opportunity here with four judges and a couple of dozen kids. So, I'm going to ask the North Carolina delegation to maybe stay behind so we can get a quick picture, and I can figure out how I can get some of these other kids some tablets that they may not have otherwise gotten. And I do want to especially recognize Judge Conrad, Judge Whitney, and Judge Numbers in the audience. They are people that I know and I admire, and I appreciate you being here. I'm going to adjourn the meeting shortly, but written questions for the record may be submitted no later than September the 24 at 5 p.m. Senator Tillis. Thanks again to all the nominees, and congratulations to you and your families. This Committee hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:46 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [Additional material submitted for the record follows.] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] A P P E N D I X The following submissions are available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg62461/pdf/CHRG- 119shrg 62461-add1.pdf Submitted by Ranking Member Durbin: Bragdon, David A., Alliance for Justice (AFJ), Opposition letter. 2 Bragdon, David A., People For the American Way (PFAW), Opposition letter........................................................ 4 Rodriguez, Susan Courtwright, Alliance for Justice (AFJ), Opposition letter............................................. 7 Taibleson, Rebecca L., AFA Action, Opposition letter............. 9 Taibleson, Rebecca L., Alliance for Justice (AFJ), Opposition letter........................................................ 13 Taibleson, Rebecca L., Conservative Action Project (CAP), Opposition letter............................................. 15 [all]