Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- OVERSIGHT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY: ICE, CBP, AND USCIS [House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] OVERSIGHT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY: ICE, CBP, AND USCIS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ FEBRUARY 10, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-38 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Homeland Security [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 63-777 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY Andrew R. Garbarino, New York, Chairman Michael T. McCaul, Texas, Vice Bennie G. Thompson, Mississippi, Chair Ranking Member Michael Guest, Mississippi Eric Swalwell, California Carlos A. Gimenez, Florida J. Luis Correa, California August Pfluger, Texas Shri Thanedar, Michigan Tony Gonzales, Texas Seth Magaziner, Rhode Island Morgan Luttrell, Texas Daniel S. Goldman, New York Dale W. Strong, Alabama Delia C. Ramirez, Illinois Josh Brecheen, Oklahoma Timothy M. Kennedy, New York Elijah Crane, Arizona LaMonica McIver, New Jersey Andrew Ogles, Tennessee Julie Johnson, Texas, Vice Ranking Sheri Biggs, South Carolina Member Gabe Evans, Colorado Pablo Jose Hernandez, Puerto Rico Ryan Mackenzie, Pennsylvania Nellie Pou, New Jersey Brad Knott, North Carolina James R. Walkinshaw, Virginia Vince Fong, California Troy A. Carter, Louisiana Matt Van Epps, Tennessee Al Green, Texas Vacant Keighle Joyce, Staff Director Hope Goins, Minority Staff Director Sean Corcoran, Chief Clerk C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Statements Honorable Andrew R. Garbarino, a Representative in Congress From the State of New York, and Chairman, Committee on Homeland Security: Oral Statement................................................. 1 Prepared Statement............................................. 3 Honorable Bennie G. Thompson, a Representative in Congress From the State of Mississippi, and Ranking Member, Committee on Homeland Security: Oral Statement................................................. 5 Prepared Statement............................................. 8 Witnesses Mr. Rodney S. Scott, Commissioner, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, U.S. Department of Homeland Security: Oral Statement................................................. 11 Prepared Statement............................................. 12 Mr. Joseph B. Edlow, Director, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, U.S. Department of Homeland Security: Oral Statement................................................. 15 Prepared Statement............................................. 17 Mr. Todd M. Lyons, Senior Official Performing the Duties of the Director, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, U.S. Department of Homeland Security: Oral Statement................................................. 21 Prepared Statement............................................. 23 For the Record Honorable August Pfluger, a Representative in Congress From the State of Texas: Article, Manhattan Institute, February 2026.................... 38 Honorable Matt Van Epps, a Representative in Congress From the State of Tennessee: Chart.......................................................... 77 Quote, Sheriff Tim Eads........................................ 78 Quote, Sheriff Frankie Gray.................................... 78 Quote, Sheriff Mike Van Dyke................................... 79 Press Release, March 25, 2025.................................. 79 Article, WSMV, January 6, 2026................................. 81 Article, Fox News, January 30, 2026............................ 83 Article, Tennessee Tribune, January 7, 2026.................... 98 Press Release, May 13, 2025.................................... 102 Honorable Bennie G. Thompson, a Representative in Congress From the State of Mississippi, and Ranking Member, Committee on Homeland Security: Statement of the Refugee Council USA........................... 107 Statement of the Baptist Joint Committee on Religious Liberty.. 110 Article, CBS News, February 9, 2026............................ 178 Article, NPR, January 25, 2026................................. 184 Article, The Marshall Project, December 17, 2025............... 188 Article, The Independent, January 29, 2026..................... 194 Report, Center for Election Innovation and Research, February 2026......................................................... 201 Article, AP.................................................... 212 Report, Brennan Center, November 21, 2025...................... 217 Report, The Guardian, March 18, 2025........................... 221 Honorable Delia C. Ramirez, a Representative in Congress From the State of Illinois: Article, Chicago Sun-Times, November 15, 2025.................. 116 Article, ABC7, October 8, 2025................................. 139 Article, ProPublica, January 13, 2026.......................... 147 Appendix I Honorable Bennie G. Thompson, a Representative in Congress From the State of Mississippi, and Ranking Member, Committee on Homeland Security: Article, NBC News, February 10, 2026........................... 227 Honorable Timothy Kennedy, a Representative in Congress From the State of New York: Letter, February 10, 2026...................................... 233 Appendix II Questions From Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino for Rodney S. Scott.. 235 Questions From Honorable Tony Gonzales for Rodney S. Scott....... 238 Question From Honorable Brad Knott for Rodney S. Scott........... 240 Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson for Rodney S. Scott.......................................................... 240 Questions From Honorable Delia C. Ramirez for Rodney S. Scott.... 244 Questions From Honorable Jose Hernandez for Rodney S. Scott...... 245 Questions From Honorable Nellie Pou for Rodney S. Scott.......... 246 Questions From Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino for Joseph B. Edlow.. 247 Questions From Honorable Tony Gonzales for Joseph B. Edlow....... 248 Questions From Honorable Gabe Evans for Joseph B. Edlow.......... 249 Question From Honorable Ryan Mackenzie for Joseph B. Edlow....... 250 Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson for Joseph B. Edlow.......................................................... 250 Questions From Honorable Delia C. Ramirez for Joseph B. Edlow.... 251 Question From Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino for Todd M. Lyons..... 253 Questions From Honorable Tony Gonzales for Todd M. Lyons......... 253 Questions From Honorable Gabe Evans for Todd M. Lyons............ 254 Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson for Todd M. Lyons.......................................................... 255 Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson on Behalf of Honorable Veronica Escobar for Todd M. Lyons................... 262 Questions From Honorable J. Luis Correa for Todd M. Lyons........ 264 Questions From Honorable Delia C. Ramirez for Todd M. Lyons...... 267 Questions From Honorable Jose Hernandez for Todd M. Lyons........ 269 Questions From Honorable Nellie Pou for Todd M. Lyons............ 270 OVERSIGHT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY: ICE, CBP, AND USCIS ---------- Tuesday, February 10, 2026 U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Homeland Security, Washington, DC. The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:09 a.m., in room 310, Cannon House Office Building, Hon. Andrew R. Garbarino [Chairman of the committee] presiding. Present: Representatives Garbarino, McCaul, Guest, Pfluger, Gonzales, Strong, Brecheen, Crane, Biggs, Evans, Mackenzie, Knott, Fong, Van Epps, Thompson, Swalwell, Correa, Thanedar, Magaziner, Goldman, Ramirez, Kennedy, McIver, Johnson, Pou, Carter, Green, and Walkinshaw. Chairman Garbarino. The Committee on Homeland Security will come to order. Without objection, the Chair may declare the committee in recess at any point. The purpose of today's hearing is to conduct oversight of the Department of Homeland Security and assess priorities for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services for the calendar year 2026. Before we get started, I would like to remind the Members and the public of the rules of decorum. These issues we are debating are important ones that Members feel deeply about. While vigorous disagreement is part of the legislative process, Members are reminded that we must adhere to established standards of decorum and debate. It is a violation of House rules and the rules of this committee to engage in personalities regarding other Members or to question the motives of a colleague. It is also a clear violation of the rules of the House to make statements that might personally be offensive to the President or the Vice President of the United States. Remarks of that type are not permitted by the rules and are not in keeping with the best traditions of our committee. The Chair will enforce these rules of decorum at all times and urges all Members to be mindful of their remarks. Further, under the rules of the House, the Chairman is responsible for maintaining order and preserving decorum in the committee room. I expect audience members to be respectful of the witnesses, Members, and the public. If members of the audience are persistently or overly disruptive, it is a violation of Federal law and you will be subject to removal and arrest. I now recognize myself for an opening statement. I want to start by thanking our witnesses for appearing before the committee today. Today's hearing provides the American people the ability to hear directly from the leaders that enforce our Nation's immigration laws. It is our imperative and as representatives of the people to be a voice for the people. Transparency, communication, and accountability are keys to good government. This is why oversight is important. Informing Congress and the public is not casting accusations, nor is it a punishment. Congress has a duty to hear directly from the Executive branch, a duty I take seriously. The Executive branch has a duty to keep us informed. While this hearing was long planned, we sit here today at an inflection point, an opportunity to assess and reinforce the integrity of immigration enforcement and to strengthen public trust, an opportunity to emphasize and underscore the Department of Homeland Security's no-fail mission as a whole. My top priority as Chairman is and will always be protecting America while ensuring the safety of law enforcement. This is further important in the context of another potential shutdown of the Department. Let me be clear. Shutting down DHS makes America less safe and negatively impacts thousands of Federal employees, like those at TSA and CISA. The Department of Homeland Security is the Nation's largest Federal law enforcement agency. It is this committee's duty, regardless of administration, to conduct oversight. We need to examine how DHS components are enforcing the law and ensure they have the resources in place to do work safely, effectively, and properly. Last year, we provided historic resources through reconciliation to strengthen public safety and support for the Trump administration's unprecedented efforts to secure the border. This was the single largest investment in the domestic homeland security mission. To succeed, we all need to work together seamlessly, and this committee is a partner in that effort. It is important to remember how we got here. For years, we witnessed a blanket refusal to enforce the law, wide-open borders, catch-and-release policies, and uncontrolled mass migration. These policies undermined the rule of law and endangered all Americans. Enforcing immigration law is not optional. The Trump administration's record on border security is irrefutable. Nationwide border encounters last December decreased 91 percent compared to 2023. Apprehensions between ports of entry last December decreased 86 percent compared to 2024. We ended last year with 8 consecutive months of zero parole releases by Border Patrol. Further, thousands of criminal illegal aliens have been detained and deported. These actions make America safer and more secure. But the credibility of these successes is on the line. We must take the temperature down and look at the record of enforcement actions through rational eyes. We have seen a significant increase in violent rhetoric and agitation. We have seen a significant increase in attacks on Federal law enforcement and in the number of threats facing them and their families. This committee highlighted the threat increases to law enforcement at an earlier hearing. We have seen State and local jurisdictions refuse to protect Federal law enforcement officers. Obviously, we have now seen the deaths of two American citizens in Minnesota. This is all unacceptable and preventable. The safety of law enforcement and the communities they serve and protect must always come first. When officials or elected leaders rush to conclusions about law enforcement or their fellow Americans, public trust suffers. There must be complete and impartial investigation. I expect each of our witnesses to keep this committee fully informed as the investigations run their course, and I will ensure this happens. While these investigations are on-going, officials and elected leaders cannot rush to judgment. I cannot put myself in the shoes of law enforcement, nor can I imagine what the families of Ms. Good and Mr. Pretti are enduring today. Public trust and public safety go hand-in-hand. We cannot have one without the other. I am encouraged to see that President Trump sent Border Czar Tom Homan and Commissioner Scott to Minnesota to work with Governor Walz, Mayor Frey, and other local leaders. I sincerely hope this dialog continues. This should stand as an example of cooperation to anyone who continues to incentivize reckless behavior in our streets, unlawfully impede law enforcement operations, or disparage their fellow citizens. State and local officials should be partners, not obstacles when it comes to public safety. Federal officials should keep in mind that this kind of partnership is a two-way street. Everyone should have the same goal of keeping America safe. Transparency and communication are needed now more than ever. The Department's no-fail mission hangs in the balance. A rule-based order is not one-sided. Enforcing immigration law and defending all Americans' Constitutional rights, including the rights to peacefully protest, bear arms, and privacy are not mutually exclusive. I want to thank Secretary Noem for making these witnesses rapidly available and again thank the three of you for being here today. As Border Czar Homan recently said, you can't fix problems if you don't have discussions. I hope we can have a positive, civil, and productive discussion today. Only together can we make our community stronger and the homeland safer for the future of all Americans. [The statement of Chairman Garbarino follows:] Statement of Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino I want to start by thanking our witnesses for appearing before the committee today. Today's hearing provides the American people the ability to hear directly from the leaders that enforce our Nation's immigration laws. It is our imperative, as representatives of the people, to be a voice for the people. Transparency, communication, and accountability are the keys to good government. This is why oversight is important. Informing Congress and the public is not casting accusations, nor is it a punishment. Congress has a duty to hear directly from the Executive branch--a duty I take seriously--and the Executive branch has a duty to keep us informed. While this hearing was long planned, we sit here today at an inflection point--an opportunity to assess and reinforce the integrity of immigration enforcement, and to strengthen public trust. An opportunity to emphasize and underscore the Department of Homeland Security's no-fail mission as a whole. My top priority as Chairman is, and will always be protecting America, while ensuring the safety of law enforcement. The Department of Homeland Security is the Nation's largest Federal law enforcement agency. It is this committee's duty, regardless of administration, to conduct oversight, examine how DHS components are enforcing the law, and ensure they have the resources in place to do this work safely, effectively, and properly. Last year, we provided historic resources through reconciliation to strengthen public safety and support the Trump administration's unprecedented efforts to secure the border. This was the single largest investment in the domestic homeland security mission. To succeed, we all need to work together seamlessly--and this committee is a partner in that effort. It is important to remember how we got here. For years, we witnessed a blanket refusal to enforce the law, wide- open borders, catch-and-release policies, and uncontrolled mass migration. These policies undermined the rule of law and endangered all Americans. Enforcing immigration law is not optional, regardless of the previous administration's failure to act, and the Trump administration's record on border security is irrefutable. Nationwide border encounters last December decreased 91 percent compared to 2023. Apprehensions between ports of entry last December decreased 86 percent compared to 2024. And we ended last year with 8 consecutive months of zero parole releases by Border Patrol. Further, thousands of criminal illegal aliens have been detained and deported. These actions make America safer and more secure. The credibility of these successes is on the line. We must take the temperature down and look at the record of enforcement actions through rational eyes. We have seen a significant increase in violent rhetoric and agitation. We have seen a significant increase in attacks on Federal law enforcement, and in the number of threats facing them and their families every day. This committee highlighted the threat increases to law enforcement at an earlier hearing. We have seen State and local jurisdictions refuse to protect Federal law enforcement officers. And, obviously, we have now seen the tragic deaths of two American citizens in Minnesota. This is all unacceptable and preventable. The safety of law enforcement and the communities they serve and protect must always come first. When officials or elected leaders rush to conclusions about law enforcement or their fellow Americans--public trust suffers. There must be a complete and impartial investigation. I expect each of our witnesses to keep this committee fully informed as the investigation runs its course. And I will ensure this happens. While this investigation is on-going, officials and elected leaders cannot rush to judgment. I cannot put myself in the shoes of law enforcement, nor can I imagine what the families of Ms. Good and Mr. Pretti are enduring today. Public trust and public safety go hand in hand--we cannot have one without the other. I am encouraged to see that President Trump sent Border Czar Tom Homan and Commissioner Scott to Minnesota to work with Governor Walz, Mayor Frey, and other local leaders. I sincerely hope this dialog continues. This should stand as an example of cooperation to anyone who continues to incentivize reckless behavior in our streets, unlawfully impede law enforcement operations, or disparage their fellow citizens. State and local officials should be partners, not obstacles, when it comes to public safety. And Federal officials should keep in mind that this kind of partnership is a two-way street. Everyone should have the same goal of keeping Americans safe. Transparency and communication are needed now more than ever--the Department's no-fail mission hangs in the balance. A rule-based order is not one-sided. Enforcing immigration law and defending all Americans' Constitutional rights--including the rights to peacefully protest, bear arms, and privacy--are not mutually exclusive. I want to thank Secretary Noem for making these witnesses rapidly available and again thank the three of you for appearing here today. As Border Czar Homan recently said, ``you can't fix problems, if you don't have discussions.'' I hope we can have a positive, civil, and productive discussion today. Only together can we make our communities stronger and the homeland safer for future generations of Americans. Chairman Garbarino. I now recognize the Ranking Member, the gentleman from Mississippi, Mr. Thompson, for his opening statement. Mr. Thompson. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Good morning to all of you who are here. I thank you for calling this hearing today. This important hearing has drawn a great deal of interest and attention and many of my colleagues who represent the border city of El Paso and who have been leader on border security, Veronica Escobar, has joined us today and would like to ask questions of our witnesses. So, Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent that the young woman from Texas, Ms. Escobar, be permitted to sit with the committee and question today's witnesses as we have afforded that to other individuals in past hearings. Chairman Garbarino. While I thank the gentlewoman for their interest in today's important hearing, as I previously informed both the Majority and Minority, committee will not be entertaining off-committee Member requests. Therefore, I object. Mr. Thompson. Well, your objection is noted, Mr. Chairman. But I would for the record want to say that it is highly unusual that a Member of Congress sitting with as much impact on immigration as her area is not afforded that courtesy. But you are the Chairman and that is your prerogative as if it would be anyone else's. Chairman Garbarino. As the Ranking Member knows, we had many requests. This is a very important hearing. It is my duty to keep the wheels on this hearing and get actual answers on the record. I thank the gentlelady's interest. We had a lot of Members who were interested in being here today, which is why we thought it would be best just to keep it for Members of the committee. These gentlemen have repeatedly testified before many committees at the Capitol, and I am sure other Members will get the opportunity to do the same questioning. This is the Committee on Homeland Security. We had previously said we would not waive on Members specifically for this hearing and we are going to stick by that rule today. Mr. Thompson. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. May I say to Ms. Escobar, if there are questions you would like to have asked of these witnesses, if you will provide those questions to me or any other Member of the committee, we will be more than happy to transmit them. Thank you so much. I hope my Republican colleagues will remember that our job is to conduct oversight, not cover for Donald Trump and his out-of-control administration, which is running roughshod over Americans' rights, killing U.S. citizens, and threatening our very democracy. The disease rotting the Trump administration from the inside out started at the top and has infected every part of the Executive branch. Nowhere is that more evident than at the Department of Homeland Security. This hearing is just the start of a reckoning for the Trump administration and its weaponization of DHS against American citizens and the principle our country stands for. DHS, led by Secretary Kristi Noem, must be held accountable for its lawless immigration operation. They are reckless, creating chaos in our communities, terrorizing adults and children alike, and undermining our moral authority as a Nation of liberty and rule of law. Last month, an ICE agent shot and killed Renee Good, a Minneapolis mom, in cold blood as she drove away from him. After killing her, the agent called her a disgusting name I won't repeat here. Other agents refused to allow a nearby physician to treat her. Democrats called for accountability. Instead, Secretary Noem blamed the victim, Ms. Good, and attempted to gaslight Americans with false claims that Ms. Good was a domestic terrorist. Renee Good was nothing of the sort. She was a mom, a wife, a neighbor, and an American citizen who did not deserve to die at the hands of her own government. She should be alive today. Ever since, the Trump administration has devoted the full resources of the Federal Government to blocking a legitimate investigation into Ms. Good's killing. If that isn't a sign of guilt, I don't know what is. Fellow prosecutors had a warrant to collect evidence from Ms. Good's vehicle for a civil rights investigation into ICE's use of force. But FBI Director Kash Patel and other Trump administration officials demanded they drop it. Career prosecutors, duly bound to the rule of law, not the political prerogatives of the White House, resigned in protest. Blocking an investigation into the Government's use of force against one of its own citizens is a self-dictatorship, not democracies. Every American should be outraged. Democrats tried to get answers in the aftermath of Ms. Good's shooting. We called on Acting Director Todd Lyons to testify at the committee's hearing 3 weeks ago. Unfortunately, he turned down the committee's invitation. This is part of a pattern of the Trump administration's refusal to comply with regular Congressional oversight. Committee Democrats have sent multiple letters to ICE and CBP on critical issues, but most of them, 10, have gone unanswered. Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent to include all 10 of these records into the record--letters into the record. Chairman Garbarino. Without objection.* --------------------------------------------------------------------------- * The documents were not available at the time of publication. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Thompson. ICE has blocked Members of Congress from visiting its detention facilities even after reports of horrific conditions, detainee abuse, and a detainee being murdered in a DHS facility. I was one of those individuals who partied to a lawsuit to try to get ICE to just follow the law that says Members of Congress can visit ICE facilities and present themselves at any time. So I understand that it is still being litigated, but I have been given authority to go and I plan to do it this week just to test ICE's adherence to the law. Mr. Lyons is here today, nearly a month after we invited him. I guess DHS needed time to get his story straight before he came to testify under oath. Fearing more violence from Federal law enforcement, Democrats have also called on DHS to rein in immigration agents and their brutal attacks on Americans immediately following Ms. Good's murder. But DHS ignored our pleas. Instead, Greg Bovino, who styled himself in Nazi attire and takes joy in deploying tear gas at Americans, continued to roam around Minneapolis with his masked gang, terrorizing people and violating their Constitutional rights. Tragically, our worst fears were realized. Just days after the hearing Mr. Lyons refused to participate in, CBP personnel shot Alex Pretti and he was face down on a Minneapolis sidewalk, killing him in broad daylight. In the video of the incident, a DHS agent can be seen cheering Mr. Pretti's death. Americans watched the video in horror. Yet once again, Secretary Noem gaslit the public, made up a demonstrably false story about Mr. Pretti, and blamed the victim for his own death. Mr. Pretti was a law-abiding U.S. citizen and a VA nurse who dedicated his career to caring for our veterans. Mr. Chairman, at our last month hearing, I asked for a moment of silence in the memory of Renee Good. Today, with great sadness about another American killed at the hands of DHS, I ask that the committee observe a moment of silence in honor of Alex Pretti. [Moment of silence.] Mr. Thompson. Thank you. The slaying of Ms. Good and Mr. Pretti by DHS are the most tragic examples of what is wrong with Trump's DHS, but far from the only ones. Last fall, a Border Patrol agent shot Marimar Martinez, a U.S. citizen and preschool teacher from Chicago, 5 times. The agent bragged in text messages about shooting her, saying, ``I fired 5 rounds and she had 7 holes. Put that in your book, boys.'' Again, the Trump administration tried to blame Ms. Martinez, the victim, but prosecutors dropped charges against her when it became apparent that the evidence contradicted the Border Patrol's phony account. Unlike Ms. Good's and Mr. Pretti's, who can no longer tell their stories, Ms. Martinez has shared her story about what Trump's DHS did to her. I want to play a bit of the video here because people need to see what ICE and CBP are doing to Americans. [Video shown.] Mr. Thompson. What happened to Ms. Martinez, Ms. Good, and Mr. Pretti is a scourge on this country and shameful chapter in our Nation's history. But tragically, there is more. DHS agents recently used a 5-year-old Ecuadorian boy, Liam Ramos, as bait to lure his family members outside their home to arrest them. The family had entered the country legally as asylum seekers and were living in Minnesota while awaiting their immigration proceedings. DHS sent the little boy and his father to detention in Texas for over a week. Thankfully, a judge ordered him release, slamming DHS for its, and I quote, ``incompetently implemented deportation campaign.'' Incompetently implemented deportation campaign is putting it nicely, especially as it relates to small children. More apt in the Bible quote from John 11, Chapter 35, referenced at the end of the judge's opinion, ``Jesus wept.'' DHS personnel are now forcing their way into private homes without a judicial warrant in violation of the Fourth Amendment. In one recent incident, ICE dragged a U.S. citizen from his home at gunpoint in underwear before realizing they had picked up the wrong person. The person ICE was actually looking for was sitting in jail in Minnesota. The Minnesota Department of Corrections says that ICE had this information all along. Bystander videos from Minneapolis and cities around the country show ICE and CBP personnel behaving like unprofessional goons, cursing at bystanders and mooning people from their hotel rooms. News reports have a Border Patrol agent was found passed out drunk and covered in vomit in a vehicle. ICE personnel apparently stole a child's phone and sold it for cash. It is an embarrassment and DHS's so-called leadership should be ashamed. If only they had any shame. Secretary Noem's Department of Homeland Security has the blood of American citizens on its hand, but she takes no responsibility for anything. To the contrary, Secretary Noem was last seen in this committee room hiding behind her family in a desperate attempt to distract from her Department's failures and abuses. Then she ran from our questions, leaving early under the guise of needing to attend a meeting that it turns out didn't even exist. Her inexcusable behavior should come as no surprise. She has always been more concerned with photo ops and wardrobe changes than following the law and fulfilling the mission of her Department. Since being sworn in, Secretary Noem has enriched herself, abused the power of her office, obstructed Congressional oversight, and violated her oath to the Constitution. Donald Trump and Kristi Noem are doing real damage to this country and to the Department that was stood up 25 years ago in the wake of 9/11 to protect American citizens from future attacks. Secretary Noem is a liar with no concern for the lives of Americans killed by the Department she runs. She must go. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. [The statement of Ranking Member Thompson follows:] Statement of Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson February 10, 2026 I hope my Republican colleagues will remember that our job is to conduct oversight, not cover for Donald Trump and his out-of-control administration, which is running roughshod over Americans' rights, killing U.S. citizens, and threatening our very democracy. The disease rotting the Trump administration from the inside out started at the top and has infected every part of the Executive branch. Nowhere is it that more evident than at the Department of Homeland Security. This hearing is just the start of a reckoning for the Trump administration and its weaponization of DHS against American citizens and the principles our country stands for. DHS, led by Secretary Kristi Noem, must be held accountable for its lawless immigration operations. They are reckless, creating chaos in our communities, terrorizing adults and children alike, and undermining our moral authority as a nation of liberty and rule of law. Last month, an ICE agent shot and killed Renee Good--a Minneapolis mom--in cold blood, as she drove away from him. After killing her, the agent called her a disgusting name I won't repeat here, and other agents refused to allow a nearby physician to treat her. Democrats called for accountability. Instead, Secretary Noem blamed the victim, Ms. Good, and attempted to gaslight Americans with false claims that Ms. Good was a ``domestic terrorist.'' Renee Good was nothing of the sort. She was a mom, a wife, a neighbor, and an American citizen who did not deserve to die at the hands of her own government. She should be alive today. Ever since, the Trump administration has devoted the full resources of the Federal Government to blocking a legitimate investigation into Ms. Good's killing. If that isn't a sign of guilt, I don't know what is. Federal prosecutors had a warrant to collect evidence from Ms. Good's vehicle for a civil rights investigation into ICE's use of force, but FBI Director Kash Patel and other Trump administration officials demanded they drop it. Career prosecutors--duty bound to the rule of law, not the political prerogatives of the White House-- resigned in protest. Blocking an investigation into the Government's use of force against one of its citizens is the stuff of dictatorships, not democracies. Every American should be outraged. Democrats tried to get answers in the aftermath of Ms. Good's shooting. We called on Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons to testify at the committee's hearing 3 weeks ago. Unfortunately, he turned down the committee's invitation. This is part of a pattern of the Trump administration's refusal to comply with regular Congressional oversight. Committee Democrats have sent multiple letters to ICE and CBP on critical issues, but most of them--10--have gone unanswered. Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent to include these unanswered letters for the record. ICE has also blocked Members of Congress from visiting its detention facilities, even after reports of horrific conditions, detainee abuse, and a detainee being murdered in a DHS facility. Mr. Lyons is here today, nearly a month after we invited him--I guess DHS needed time to get its story straight before he came to testify under oath. Fearing more violence from Federal law enforcement, Democrats have also called on DHS to rein in its immigration agents and their brutal attacks on Americans immediately following Ms. Good's murder. But DHS ignored our pleas. Instead Greg Bovino, who styles himself in Nazi attire and takes joy in deploying tear gas at Americans, continued to roam around Minneapolis with his masked gang terrorizing people and violating their Constitutional rights. And, tragically, our worst fears were realized. Just days after the hearing Mr. Lyons refused to participate in, CBP personnel shot Alex Pretti, as he was face-down on a Minneapolis sidewalk, killing him in broad daylight. In the video of the incident, a DHS agent can be seen cheering Mr. Pretti's death. Americans watched the video in horror. Yet, once again, Secretary Noem gaslit the public, made up a demonstrably false story about Mr. Pretti, and blamed the victim for his own death. Mr. Pretti was a law-abiding U.S. citizen and a VA nurse who dedicated his career to caring for our veterans. Mr. Chairman, at our hearing last month I asked for a moment of silence in memory of Renee Good. Today, with great sadness about another American killed at the hands of DHS, I ask that the committee observe a moment of silence in honor of Alex Pretti. The slayings of Ms. Good and Mr. Pretti by DHS are the most tragic examples of what is wrong with Trump's DHS, but far from the only ones. Last fall, a Border Patrol agent shot Miramar Martinez, a U.S. citizen and preschool teacher from Chicago, 5 times. The agent bragged in text messages about shooting her, saying ``I fired 5 rounds and she had 7 holes. Put that in your book boys.'' Again, the Trump administration tried to blame Ms. Martinez, the victim, but prosecutors dropped charges against her when it became apparent that the evidence contradicted the Border Patrol's phony account. Unlike Ms. Good and Mr. Pretti, who can no longer tell their stories, Ms. Martinez has shared her story about what Trump's DHS did to her. I want to play a bit of that video here, because people need to see what ICE and CBP are doing to Americans. What happened to Ms. Martinez, Ms. Good, and Mr. Pretti is a scourge on this country and shameful chapter in our Nation's history, but tragically there is more. DHS agents recently used a 5-year-old Ecuadorian boy, Liam Ramos, as bait to lure his family members outside their home to arrest them. The family had entered the country legally as asylum seekers and were living in Minnesota while awaiting their immigration proceedings. DHS sent the little boy and his father to detention in Texas for over a week. Thankfully a judge ordered him released, slamming DHS for its ``incompetently implemented'' deportation campaign. ``Incompetently implemented'' deportation campaign is putting it nicely, especially as it relates to small children. More apt is the Bible quote from John 11:35 referenced at the end of the judge's opinion: ``Jesus wept.'' DHS personnel are now forcing their way into private homes without a judicial warrant, in violation of the 4th Amendment. In one recent incident, ICE dragged a U.S. citizen from his home at gunpoint in his underwear before realizing they had picked up the wrong person. The person ICE was actually looking for was sitting in jail in Minnesota. The Minnesota Department of Corrections says that ICE had this information all along. Bystander videos from Minneapolis and cities around the country show ICE and CBP personnel behaving like unprofessional goons, cursing at bystanders and mooning people from their hotel windows. News reports show a Border Patrol agent was found passed out, drunk, and covered in vomit in a vehicle, and ICE personnel apparently stole a child's phone and sold it for cash. It's an embarrassment and DHS's so-called leadership should be ashamed . . . if only they had any shame. Secretary Noem's Department of Homeland Security has the blood of Americans on its hands, but she takes no responsibility for anything. To the contrary, Secretary Noem was last seen in this committee room hiding behind her family in a desperate attempt to distract from her Department's failures and abuses. Then she ran from our questions, leaving early under the guise of needing to attend a meeting that, it turns out, didn't even exist. Her inexcusable behavior should come as no surprise. She's always been more concerned with photo ops and wardrobe changes than following the law and fulfilling the mission of her Department. Since being sworn in, Secretary Noem has enriched herself, abused the power of her office, obstructed Congressional oversight, and violated her oath to the Constitution. Donald Trump and Kristi Noem are doing real damage to this country and to the Department that was stood up 25 years ago in the wake of 9/ 11 to protect Americans from future attacks. Secretary Noem is a liar with no concern for the lives of Americans killed by the Department she runs. She must go. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. Other Members of the committee are reminded that opening statements may be submitted for the record. I would now like to formally introduce our witnesses. First is Mr. Rodney Scott. Mr. Scott is commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection. After decades of service at CBP, including extent as Chief Border Patrol, he has served as the Senate-confirmed commissioner since June 2025. Second is Mr. Joseph Edlow. Mr. Edlow is director of Citizenship and Immigration Services. Director Edlow has served in numerous legal roles across the Executive branch in Congress, including chief counsel to USCIS. Mr. Edlow has served as the Senate-confirmed director since July 2025. Third is Mr. Todd Lyons. Mr. Lyons is the acting director of Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Acting Director Lyons began his Federal service in the U.S. Air Force in 1993 and joined ICE as an agent in 2007. Mr. Lyons moved up the ranks and has served as acting director since March 2025. I thank all the witnesses for being here today. Pursuant to committee rule VIII(C), I ask that the witnesses please rise and raise their right hand. [Witnesses sworn.] Chairman Garbarino. Let the record reflect that the witnesses have answered in the affirmative. Thank you and please be seated. I now recognize Commissioner Scott for 5 minutes to summarize his opening statement. STATEMENT OF RODNEY S. SCOTT, COMMISSIONER, U.S. CUSTOMS AND BORDER PROTECTION, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY Commissioner Scott. Chairman Garbarino, Ranking Member Thompson, Members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to appear here before you today. I'm honored to represent more than 67,000 dedicated men and women of U.S. Customs and Border Protection who are tirelessly protecting this great Nation every single day by simply trying to make sure we know who and what is entering our homeland. Border security is national security. Law enforcement personnel that selflessly provide this service to America increasingly perform under difficult conditions and intense public and political scrutiny. But these brave men and women deserve our gratitude and thanks. It's my privilege to be here today joining my colleagues from Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Citizenship and Immigration Services. Our agencies work in partnership to secure the homeland and uphold the integrity of our immigration system. CBP has spent the last year rebuilding what was an intentionally broken border. As I informed Congress in 2021 and again in 2023, the open border policies of the Biden administration all but eliminated any meaningful border along this--any meaningful border. It replaced it with a porous geographic line defined by record-high encounters with illegal aliens, overwhelmed facilities, and a work force that was stretched so far beyond their capabilities that hostile nations and the cartels exploited our border at will. That all changed on January 20, 2025, under the leadership of President Trump. We have now implemented effective policies, established unified priorities and objectives across all Federal departments, and empowered our work force to do their jobs by simply enforcing the laws that already exist. We have imposed consequences for those who break our laws, the laws that this body enacted. Today the United States, because of these efforts, enjoys the most secure border in our Nation's history. But this progress did not happen by accident. It's a result of a comprehensive approach to border security. We ended catch- and-release. We prioritized detention and removal authorities, and we sent a clear message that illegal entry into the United States will not be tolerated. The numbers speak for themselves. We have achieved record- low illegal crossings between ports of entry. Border Patrol apprehensions along the Southwest Border totaled over 90,000 for the entire year. That's a number that used to represent a single month under the Biden administration. Daily encounters have dropped by 95 percent, averaging about 250 per day, compared to 5,000 a day during the Biden administration. Our increased enforcement also resulted in the seizure of over 617,000 pounds of illicit narcotics. That's nationwide an 8 percent increase over the prior year. This included nearly 11,000 pounds of fentanyl and more than 186,000 pounds of methamphetamines. This is what having a secure border looks like. None of this would have been possible, though, without the vision and leadership of President Trump and the historic investments made in border security. The One Big Beautiful Bill, a $65 billion investment is enabling CBP to modernize border infrastructure, deploy additional advanced technology, and to grow our work force. Since January 2025, CBP is building SmartWall at record levels. We're installing high-tech attributes where the Biden administration had shut it off. We're installing water barriers along the Rio Grande River, which denies criminals access to these routes. But that is not all. We're investing in technology at our ports of entry, nonintrusive inspection equipment, biometrics, and advanced surveillance to improve our ability to know what's coming into this country, the land, air, and sea at and between the ports of entry. CBP's work force is without a doubt the greatest asset that we have. The One Big Beautiful Bill is investing historic amounts of money in recruitment, hiring, and retention and training to ensure that we have the most highly qualified and capable law enforcement professionals securing our border. Due to the collaboration across all Federal departments, the resultant record-low encounters, CBP has been able to surge resources to support ICE's targeted enforcement operations across the Nation. CBP has integrated with ICE and other partners to identify and remove dangerous criminals and others who remain in the country illegally. As recent events have demonstrated, though, our officers and agents are increasingly facing an unprecedented level of aggressive interference and intimidation when executing the laws that you have asked them to enforce. These attacks on Federal law enforcement personnel are coordinated and well- funded. This is not peaceful protest. No law enforcement officer should be put at personal risk simply for doing the job that we have asked them to do. I thank you for your continued support of CBP's mission and I look forward to answering your questions today. [The prepared statement of Mr. Scott follows:] Prepared Statement of Rodney S. Scott February 10, 2026 introduction Chairman Garbarino, Ranking Member Thompson, and distinguished Members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss U.S. Customs and Border Protection's (CBP) immigration enforcement and border security operations. I am honored to represent the more than 67,000 dedicated men and women of CBP--the largest law enforcement agency in the United States. We stand watch on the front lines of our country's borders to protect the American people from external threats while facilitating lawful trade and travel, often under difficult conditions and intense public scrutiny, but always in service to the Nation. It is a privilege to join my colleagues from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. Together, our agencies work in close partnership to secure our homeland and uphold the integrity of our border. The Human Cost of Failed Policy The past year has been one of the most consequential in the history of America's border security. Under the decisive leadership of President Donald J. Trump, Secretary Kristi Noem, and Border Czar Tom Homan, and thanks to the tireless efforts of the thousands of dedicated public servants who work at our agencies to ensure border security, CBP has fundamentally reversed years of open-border policies, achieving record-low illegal entries between ports of entry. These results reflect a clear commitment to restoring the rule of law, prioritizing the safety of the American people, and empowering our officers and agents to fulfill their critical mission. CBP spent the last year rebuilding a devastated border defined by record encounters, overwhelmed facilities, inadequate deterrence measures, and personnel stretched to the limit. We must be unflinchingly honest about the humanitarian catastrophe that defined the previous administration's open-border policies. The same critics attacking us today for enforcing the law were silent for 4 years as open borders empowered cartels to engage in industrial-scale human trafficking. Nowhere was this failure more tragic than in the treatment of Unaccompanied Alien Children (UACs). A bombshell report from the DHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) in August 2024 exposed the depth of this betrayal of UACs. Under the Biden-Harris administration, CBP encountered over 500,000 unaccompanied children at the Southwest Border. Investigators revealed that the Government on President Biden's watch had effectively lost track of hundreds of thousands of these children, in an utter failure to ensure their safety and well-being. The details are damning. The DHS OIG found that more than 291,000 children--out of nearly 450,000 transferred to the Department of Health and Human Services' custody--were never even issued Notices to Appear in court, and many who were served notices missed their court dates. By failing to initiate removal proceedings or determine the whereabouts of those UACs who did not appear, the previous administration made ghosts of these children, denying them any meaningful legal or physical protection. The prior administration released these children into the interior of our country with no supervision or controls, and no assurances that they were not being handed directly from a coyote at the border to a trafficker in the heartland, and left them vulnerable to exploitation and other criminal acts. Defeating the Cartel Business Model This administrative negligence did more than just fail these children; it financed their exploitation. The vast majority of illegal immigration at our Southern Border is facilitated by sophisticated, ruthless cartels that have built their business model on our own policy loopholes. Cartels knew that under the Biden administration, trafficked children would be processed and released into the interior with virtually no oversight. ``Catch and release'' policies that allowed illegal immigrants to remain in our country facilitated the presence of those who trafficked these children on their arrival. By failing to enforce our laws at the border, the Federal Government enabled human trafficking, not just of children but of those exploited for labor, by cartels, who profited from this trafficking and used the profits to finance their illegal activities. Breaking this cycle requires certainty of consequences and complete border security. When we secure the border and deny illegal entry, we are not just enforcing a statute--we are bankrupting a cartel operation and protecting innocent people. When illegal entry no longer guarantees release into the interior, and when UACs are protected and monitored, the cartels lose their product, their presence in the United States, and their ability to profit from our failures. A Year of Unprecedented Enforcement and Deterrence Today, by prioritizing law enforcement and leveraging the authorities granted to us by Congress, the United States has the most secure border in our Nation's history. We have realigned resources, applied consequences for those who break our laws, and empowered our workforce to do their jobs. Although we have experienced tremendous success ensuring unprecedented border security, every day is a new battle to prevent cartels and other criminals from operating within our country and threatening their victims and the American people. We must stay vigilant and continue to pursue effective policy and practice daily so that our success is sustained. National security cannot exist without effective border security. Over the past year, our enforcement efforts have been nothing short of historic across all our operational environments. As I alluded to earlier, we have achieved the lowest annual encounters in CBP's history. Total U.S. Border Patrol apprehensions along the Southwest Border during the last calendar year were approximately 90,000--a figure lower than the monthly average during the Biden administration.\1\ Daily encounters declined by 95 percent, averaging approximately 250 per day, compared to more than 5,000 per day previously. We have also seen historically low numbers of gotaways-- illegal aliens who evade apprehension by CBP. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The average number of monthly apprehensions during the Biden administration was 155,485, https://www.cbp.gov/about/history/cbps- historic-first-year-under-current-administration. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- This progress is the direct result of the administration's comprehensive enforcement approach. We ended the practice of ``catch- and-release,'' prioritized detention and removal authorities, and sent a clear message that illegal entry into the United States will not be accommodated or rewarded. Instead, consequences will be delivered consistent with law. For 9 consecutive months, U.S. Border Patrol has not released any alien who entered without authorization into the United States, a powerful reflection of restored control of our border. Policy changes and decreased encounters have allowed us to act more strategically and execute data-driven targeted operations. This has led to increased enforcement actions. For example, since January 20, 2025, CBP seized nearly 620,000 pounds of illicit drugs nationwide, an 8 percent increase over the prior year. This included nearly 11,000 pounds of fentanyl, 185,000 pounds of methamphetamine, and significant quantities of cocaine, heroin, and marijuana.\2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ https://www.cbp.gov/about/history/cbps-historic-first-year- under-current-administration, January 20, 2025-January 20, 2026. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- CBP is also a foundational partner in the President's Homeland Security Task Force (HSTF). Co-led by the FBI and ICE/HSI, these task forces now operate across all 50 States to dismantle transnational criminal organizations (TCOs) and foreign gangs. CBP's unique border intelligence and interdiction capabilities are force multipliers for the HSTF, ensuring that the border is no longer a gap for TCOs to exploit, but rather the starting point to dismantle their operations entirely. Front-line Investments in Infrastructure, Technology, and our Workforce None of these accomplishments would be possible without the historic investments in border security made by this administration. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, a $65 billion border security bill, represents the largest investment in border security in a generation, providing for modern infrastructure, advanced technology, and increased law enforcement personnel. CBP is actively executing Smart Wall construction consistent with U.S. Border Patrol requirements from the Pacific Ocean to the Gulf of America in support of the President's Executive Orders and CBP's statutory mission to secure the border. CBP has already placed $12 billion in Smart Wall funding on contract, with all remaining barrier contracts scheduled for award by June 30, 2026. We anticipate completing 250 miles of new barriers by September 30, 2026. Furthermore, in January 2026, we began installing waterborne barriers in the Rio Grande, denying smugglers a key avenue for trafficking people and narcotics, enhancing natural and land-based barriers, and providing a safer operating environment for our agents. The success of CBP's mission fundamentally relies on the expertise and dedication of our workforce. CBP is prioritizing recruiting, hiring, retention, and training to rebuild our workforce after years of attrition. Over the past year, we saw historic levels of recruitment and retention, with monthly averages showing an 84 percent increase in new U.S. Border Patrol hires compared to the previous year. The Act not only supports our hiring goals by funding 5,000 more CBP officers, 3,000 Border Patrol agents, and 200 Air and Marine agents, but also provides funding for recruitment and retention, ensuring that we attract, hire, and keep the best law enforcement professionals in America. In addition to personnel, CBP continues to invest in technology that enhances CBP's operational capabilities to detect and intercept individuals illegally crossing the border, dangerous goods and materials concealed in cargo and vehicles, and illegal activity in the air and maritime domains. With One Big Beautiful Bill funding, we are investing in non-intrusive inspection, biometrics, border surveillance equipment, aircraft, and communications systems. These investments rapidly modernize our border security posture and ensure that we remain ahead of current and emerging threats. supporting the larger federal enforcement mission With record-low encounters, CBP can enhance our support of nationwide targeted operations and immigration enforcement priorities. CBP's critical support of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement interior enforcement operations enables the removal of dangerous criminals, gang members, and aliens who remain in the country illegally. CBP personnel are deployed to support targeted operations in more than 20 cities, resulting in thousands of arrests. I must note that CBP officers and agents are increasingly encountering situations in which agitators interfere with lawful enforcement actions, including attempts to obstruct arrests or intimidate law enforcement personnel. These situations are unprecedented in scale and intensity. The current operational environment puts our officers, agents, and even their families, at tremendous personal risk of violence. Let me be clear. No law enforcement officer should be placed in a position where executing a lawful warrant or simply performing his or her lawful law enforcement duties becomes a flashpoint for confrontation with third parties. CBP officers and agents are trained to de-escalate, act professionally, and to use force only when necessary. Training cannot fully mitigate all risks created when law enforcement is undermined or publicly challenged in real time. conclusion In closing, I want to emphasize that the accomplishments of the past year are not just numbers on paper. They represent lives saved, communities strengthened, and a renewed sense of safety and security for the American people. Under the unwavering leadership of President Trump and Secretary Noem, CBP delivered on its promise to secure the border, enforce the law, and protect our Nation from those who would do us harm. Our work is not complete, but we are determined to maintain and consistently increase control over our borders. We are intercepting dangerous aliens and preventing their entry. We are keeping America safe. The men and women of CBP are proud to serve, proud to protect, and proud to be part of a mission that puts the American people first. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I look forward to your questions. Chairman Garbarino. Thank you, Commissioner. I now recognize Director Edlow for 5 minutes to summarize his opening statement. STATEMENT OF JOSEPH B. EDLOW, DIRECTOR, U.S. CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY Mr. Edlow. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Garbarino, Ranking Member Thompson, and Members of the committee, it is an honor to speak to you about the priorities and progress of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. I'm grateful for your partnership as we work together to uphold the rule of law, protect our citizens, and safeguard our homeland. Let me begin by expressing my appreciation to President Trump for his trust in me and to Secretary Noem for her leadership at the Department of Homeland Security. I'm proud to serve alongside a work force that's deeply committed to advancing the President's agenda, protecting our communities and restoring integrity to America's legal immigration system. As director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, my vision has been straightforward and clear: restore accountability to our immigration system and ensure that it serves the interests of the American people first and foremost. Today I want to highlight some of our most significant accomplishments: ending the exploitation of immigration programs, putting American workers first, protecting our communities from public safety threats, protecting national security, and combating immigration fraud. Fraud isn't just a paperwork issue. It's a national security and public safety concern. Often those who wish to do us harm exploit weaknesses in our system. Over the past year, USCIS has made nearly 33,000 fraud referrals to law enforcement, a 138 percent increase over previous years. We conducted thousands of site visits to homes and workplaces and thousands of social media checks to ensure aliens aren't espousing anti-American sentiment. Moreover, our fraud detection and national security team completed over 21,000 investigations identifying fraud in approximately 65 percent of those cases. In Operation Twin Shield in Minneapolis-St. Paul back in the fall, we uncovered marriage fraud, visa misuse, and student visa abuses leading to denials of immigration benefits, arrests, and removal proceedings. This work led to Operation PARRIS, where we continue reexamining thousands of refugee cases in Minnesota, conducting thorough background checks, and in-person reviews. We've also strengthened our vetting policies. If someone falsely claims U.S. citizenship to get a public benefit or try to vote, we hold them accountable through denial of citizenship or loss of immigration status. We've tightened screening to determine whether claimed marriages and family relationships are legitimate. We've changed regulations to employee authorization--excuse me, to employment authorization is no longer automatically extended. Now we require more frequent renewals so that we can vet aliens more frequently and ensure that they deserve to remain in the country. Additionally, we've taken action to end the exploitation of immigration programs. Mass humanitarian parole programs were being abused by the prior administration, so we've restored them to Congress' original intent, allowing those benefits on a case-by-case basis. Secretary Noem also ended decades of temporary protected status for several countries, returning the program to what Congress intended, temporary protection, not permanent status in the United States. Moreover, this administration is doing more to ensure the integrity of our elections. We enhanced the SAVE program so States can verify citizenship of those on their voter rolls more effectively. Since January 2025, we've processed over 58 million queries and 27 States are participating. Additionally, Federal agencies ran nearly 206 million SAVE queries last year to identify fraud and preserve public assistance benefits for lawful U.S. residents and citizens. We're also putting American taxpayers and communities and workers first. We affirmed that aliens should be self-reliant, not dependent on public assistance, and that their sponsors are liable for the cost of public benefits that they access. The Department of Homeland Security is also working to rescind the 2022 public charge rule, restoring our discretion to determine if an alien will rely on Government assistance. We've proposed protecting American jobs by prioritizing H1B visas for higher-skilled, higher-paid workers so that companies can't use those visas merely as a way to get cheaper noncitizen labor. We've also streamlined agricultural visa processing to better support American farmers. A major milestone was implementing the One Big Beautiful Bill, which added new fees for certain immigration processes. USCIS collects those fees, but only retains a small amount of the money while the rest goes to other agencies and deficit reduction. Finally, protecting the American people is at the heart of everything we do. After the attack on 2 brave service members of the National Guard last November, Secretary Noem directed us to review immigration benefits for aliens from high-risk countries. In closing, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services is restoring integrity, accountability, and security to America's legal immigration system. These accomplishments reflect the dedication of our work force and the transformative leadership of President Trump and Secretary Noem, both of whom have allowed USCIS to do the job it was created by Congress to do. We stand ready to continue working with Congress to protect the homeland and uphold the rule of law. Thank you and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Edlow follows:] Prepared Statement of Joseph B. Edlow February 10, 2026 Chairman Garbarino, Ranking Member Thompson, and distinguished Members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. I am here to discuss the progress, priorities, and challenges of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. It is an honor to testify before this esteemed committee, and I appreciate your continued commitment as we work together to protect American citizens, safeguard the homeland, and uphold the rule of law. I would like to begin by expressing my gratitude to President Trump for the trust he has placed in me to lead USCIS, and to Secretary Noem for her leadership at the Department of Homeland Security. I am proud to serve alongside a dedicated workforce committed to advancing the President's agenda, protecting our Nation and the safety of our communities, and restoring integrity to America's legal immigration system. As director of USCIS, my vision has been clear: to restore accountability and security to our legal immigration system, ensuring that it serves the interests of the American people above all else. Over the past year, USCIS has made historic strides in advancing this mission. Today, I will highlight our major accomplishments in 6 critical areas: combating fraud, ending the exploitation of immigration programs, upholding the integrity of the naturalization process, putting American communities and workers first, implementing the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and protecting our communities from threats to public safety and national security. combating fraud At the heart of our mission is the unwavering commitment to protect the integrity of the legal immigration system from those who seek to exploit, abuse, or undermine it. Fraud is a national security and public safety concern because its often through fraud that many of those who wish to do us harm have accessed the United States. Over the past year, USCIS has implemented rigorous measures to detect, deter, and disrupt fraud at every stage of the immigration process. Since January 20, 2025, USCIS officers have made nearly 33,000 fraud referrals to our Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate--a 138 percent increase compared to the average yearly referrals of the previous administration. Our Fraud Detection and National Security team completed investigations into more than 21,000 cases, identifying fraud in 65 percent of them. Our officers conducted over 7,000 site visits and more than 26,000 social media checks to identify national security, public safety, fraud, and anti-American concerns. This year, USCIS made history with Operation Twin Shield. Launched in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area, this targeted initiative uncovered a wide range of fraudulent schemes, including marriage fraud, misuse of H-1B work visas, and student visa abuses. Operation Twin Shield focused on more than 1,000 cases with fraud or ineligibility indicators, attempted over 2,000 site visits, and completed nearly 1,500 in-person interviews. The operation resulted in the denial of immigration benefits, the filing of numerous Notices to Appear before an immigration judge to initiate removal proceedings, and nearly a dozen arrests by our partners at U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). We also gained significant evidence that led to Operation PARRIS Customs Enforcement (ICE). We also gained significant evidence that led to Operation PARRIS. Operation PARRIS is a sweeping initiative reexamining thousands of refugee cases through new background checks and intensive verification of refugee claims. We have referred cases of fraud and other crimes to ICE. The initial focus is on Minnesota's 5,600 refugees who have not yet been granted lawful permanent resident status (Green Card holders). USCIS' newly-established vetting center is at the forefront of Operation PARRIS, with adjudicators conducting thorough background checks, reinterviews, and merit reviews of refugee claims. In the last year, USCIS also strengthened policy guidance to ensure that there is no legal defense if someone falsely claims U.S. citizenship to gain a government benefit, with officers considering only age or mental capacity to assess if a claim was made intentionally. Such false claims historically and routinely allow aliens unlawful access to benefits, services, and privileges reserved for American citizens, and we are committed to holding violators accountable. Lying about being a U.S. citizen, including attempting to fraudulently vote in elections, is a clear violation of the INA \1\ and will lead to the denial of a naturalization application and the alien's immigration status. We also enhanced screening measures to vet potentially fraudulent marriages and family relationships, ensuring they are genuine, verifiable, and compliant with all applicable laws. Aliens seeking legal immigration status through family relationships or marriage must prove their relationship is genuine and not a scheme to commit immigration fraud. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ A false claim to U.S. citizenship is a ground of inadmissibility under INA 212(a)(6)(C)(ii) and a ground of removability under INA 237(a)(3)(D), and generally, there is no waiver available. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Additionally, we changed regulations to ensure that aliens no longer receive automatic extensions of employment authorization when seeking to renew that authorization in some employment categories. This ensures that the U.S. Government doesn't allow aliens to work in the United States without regular, on-going screening and vetting. We also reduced the maximum period that certain employment authorization documents are valid--from 5 years to 18 months, ensuring more frequent vetting and screening. ending the exploitation of immigration programs USCIS has taken decisive action to end the abuse and exploitation of immigration programs, restoring them to their intended purpose as prescribed by Congress. This includes stopping the broad abuse of humanitarian parole authority and terminating the so-called ``family reunification'' and the Cuban, Haitian, Nicaraguan, and Venezuelan (CHNV) parole programs. Parole was never designed to be used as a blanket authority, and we are returning it to the case-by-case basis for only urgent humanitarian reasons or significant public benefit Congress intended. Temporary Protected Status (TPS) was always meant to be temporary. Secretary Noem has taken her statutory duties seriously and has ended TPS for many countries, restoring the long-ignored Congressional intent of this classification. We strongly encourage aliens whose parole or TPS was terminated to use the CBP Home app to self-report their departure from the United States. Doing so will enable them to receive a complimentary one-way ticket home and a $2,600 exit bonus to help them get resettled. Not only were CHNV and TPS never intended to be permanent pathways to citizenship, but they were easily exploited by bad actors. Individuals with criminal records, including those with links to terrorism and human trafficking, obtained status via CHNV and TPS through fraudulent applications and submission of fake documents, including through the filing of Form I-134A (Online Request to be a Supporter and Declaration of Financial Support) associated with CHNV sponsorship applications that identified over 600,000 supporter applications with suspected fraud and public safety concerns involving hundreds of fictitious addresses, fraudulent identities and social security number belonging to deceased individuals, exposing the American people to dangerous threats within our borders. Returning these programs to their statutory intent reduces this risk of exploitation and unacceptable risk to our citizens. These actions reinforce our commitment to upholding the rule of law and ensuring that immigration programs are not exploited for purposes beyond their statutory intent. upholding the integrity of the naturalization process Naturalization is a privilege, not a right, and USCIS has taken extensive steps to reinforce the integrity of the naturalization process. On September 17, 2025, we announced a revised version of the civics portion of the naturalization test, expanding the total bank of questions from 100 to 128 questions, increasing the number of questions on each test from 10 to 20, raising the passing score from 6 to 12 correct responses, and revising the questions to provide a more meaningful assessment of an alien's knowledge and understanding of U.S. history and government. We also restored the practice of conducting neighborhood investigations of those seeking citizenship. This is an authority provided for in statute, but long neglected in practice. These investigations verify aliens' eligibility for naturalization by reviewing actual residency, moral character, loyalty to the U.S. Constitution, ensuring they have not falsely claimed U.S. citizenship to obtain an unlawful benefit or registered to vote, and their commitment to the Nation's well-being. Neighborhood investigations are vital to maintaining the integrity of the naturalization process, assuring proper assimilation into American values and culture, and safeguarding the value and privilege of American citizenship. We have also ensured that voter registration services offered at administrative naturalization ceremonies remain strictly nonpartisan and are conducted only by State and local election officials. This practice safeguards the impartiality of voter registration for America's newest citizens. putting american communities and workers first USCIS is committed to putting American communities and workers first, ensuring that our immigration system serves the national interest and protects the rights and opportunities of American citizens first and foremost. We have launched enhancements to the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements service, better known as SAVE, allowing States to verify citizenship using the last four digits of Social Security numbers. States can run queries in bulk and use SAVE at no charge. By allowing States to review and verify their voter rolls, this administration is doing more to ensure the integrity of elections than any previous administration. Since January 20, 2025, SAVE has processed over 58 million voter verification queries, with 27 States signing memoranda of agreement for voter verification with USCIS. Moreover, we are cracking down on the abuse of public benefits. On September 4, 2025, USCIS reaffirmed long-standing policy that aliens in the United States should be self-reliant, and that government benefits should not incentivize immigration. On September 25, 2025, we reminded individuals who agree to financially sponsor an alien that they can be sued to recover the cost of any benefits accessed by an alien whom they sponsor. Additionally, DHS proposed a rule to rescind the ineffective 2022 Public Charge final rule and restore USCIS' discretion when making a determination whether an alien seeking legal status in the United States would become reliant upon government assistance. To further preserve public benefits for U.S. citizens who need them and to identify potential fraud in public benefits programs, Federal agencies responsible for providing oversight to benefit-granting agencies ran nearly 206 million SAVE queries during calendar year 2025. Another rule that DHS proposed prioritizes the allocation of the limited number of H-1B visas to higher-skilled and higher-paid aliens, better protecting wages, working conditions, and job opportunities for American workers while also ensuring American employers can access the best of the best foreign workers. We also published a critical final rule enabling USCIS to streamline the process for agricultural work visas, supporting America's vital agricultural industry. implementing the one big beautiful bill act On July 4, 2025, President Trump signed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act into law, adding new provisions and fees to the Immigration and Nationality Act. USCIS did not receive appropriations from the bill, but through the implementation of new immigration fees, $321 million has been collected--of which USCIS retains only a small portion. The revenue generated from immigration fees under the bill is allocated to USCIS; the Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR); the U.S. Treasury; U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP); and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). However, USCIS does not collect or track the revenue for CBP or ICE. USCIS moved quickly to implement the new fees that the agency is responsible for, publishing the July 22, 2025 Federal Register Notice approximately 2 weeks after the President signed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act into law. USCIS has since published several Federal Register Notices announcing the implementation of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act fees. The bill introduced fees between $100 to $1,000 for specific USCIS benefit requests with limited exceptions. Congress designated portions of each fee to specific Government entities, with USCIS retaining only 26 percent, and the remainder allocated to the United States Treasury. Fees mandated by the bill are non-waivable and non-reducible, regardless of eligibility for waivers under other USCIS regulations. The law requires DHS to make annual adjustments based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers to ensure fees reflect inflation and economic conditions. On January 1, 2026, USCIS implemented inflation-adjusted fees, in compliance with the law. We also updated our policies, guidance, and intake procedures to close loopholes, limit improper fee waivers, and ensure applications that do not comply with the law are rejected. These critical efforts have strengthened the integrity of our legal immigration system, reinforced accountability, and ensured that USCIS resources are directed toward lawful, properly-filed cases. Under this administration, USCIS is once again enforcing the law as written: firmly, consistently, and with integrity. I'm proud of the professionalism and discipline our workforce has shown in carrying out Congress's mandate. protecting american communities from threats to public safety and national security Protecting Americans is at the heart of everything we do at USCIS. We are committed to safeguarding public safety and national security by ensuring that every alien undergoes the most rigorous vetting and screening processes possible. Within hours of the November 26, 2025 attack where an Afghan national allegedly murdered a National Guard member and severely wounded another in Washington, DC, Secretary Noem directed USCIS to put asylum processing on hold for aliens from every country, implement a full-scale re-review of immigration benefits approved for aliens from Presidentially-designated high-risk countries for the last several years, and place a hold on the processing of immigration applications and petitions for Afghan nationals and aliens from those additional countries of concern. We implemented critical national security measures requiring USCIS officers to consider negative country-specific factors when vetting aliens from 39 high-risk countries, ensuring that USCIS can more meaningfully assess whether an alien is potentially a threat to public safety or national security. With the support of Secretary Noem, USCIS announced the creation of a new vetting center to enhance screening and vetting of immigration applications, with resources that allow us to better focus on identifying terrorists, criminal aliens, and other threats to public safety. The center leverages advanced technologies and works closely with law enforcement and intelligence partners to strengthen our ability to protect national security. USCIS has referred over 14,400 aliens to ICE since January 20, 2025, for public safety, national security, and fraud concerns, including 182 aliens who were confirmed or suspected to be national security risks. We have actively collaborated with other agencies on immigration enforcement and public safety efforts, resulting in over 2,400 arrests at USCIS field offices since January 20, 2025. USCIS has begun recruiting a new class of immigration officers called Homeland Defenders to better support the agency's mission and bolster efforts to combat fraud and other threats. Since launching the hiring campaign on September 30, USCIS has received more than 50,000 applications--the highest in agency history. The first Homeland Defenders began reporting for duty in early December 2025. USCIS is also exercising new law enforcement authorities delegated by Secretary Noem and is hiring a new team of special agents who will investigate and refer immigration law violators for prosecution. Additionally, under an updated policy confirming USCIS' role as an immigration enforcement agency, our immigration officers are once again empowered to enforce immigration law by issuing Notices to Appear before an immigration judge to initiate removal proceedings, and they have done so in historic numbers. Since January 20, 2025, USCIS officers have issued approximately 196,600 Notices to Appear. USCIS has aligned immigration policy with our deeply-held American values, issuing policy guidance emphasizing that there is no room in America for aliens who espouse anti-American ideologies or support terrorist organizations. We have also launched an on-line process for aliens to comply with a long-standing alien registration requirement that helps the Government track and manage their presence to more effectively enforce immigration law, supporting national security and public safety efforts. conclusion In closing, I want to reiterate my commitment--and the commitment of every USCIS employee--to restoring integrity, accountability, and security to America's legal immigration system. The accomplishments of the past year reflect the hard work and dedication of our workforce, the leadership of President Trump and Secretary Noem, and our shared commitment to putting the interests of the American people first. USCIS stands ready to continue working with Congress and our partners across Government to protect the homeland, uphold the rule of law, and ensure that our legal immigration system serves the Nation's interests. I thank the committee for its attention to our shared mission and for its on-going support of USCIS. I welcome your questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Garbarino. Thank you, Director Edlow. I now recognize Acting Director Lyons for 5 minutes to summarize his opening statement. STATEMENT OF TODD M. LYONS, SENIOR OFFICIAL PERFORMING THE DUTIES OF THE DIRECTOR, U.S. IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY Mr. Lyons. Good morning. Chairman Gabarino, Ranking Member Thompson, distinguished Members of the committee, thank you for the invitation to discuss the critical work U.S. Immigration and Customs is doing every day to carry out President Trump's agenda to keep America safe, restore order to our communities, and return law--return the rule of law to this country. Under the leadership of President Trump and DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, the men and women of ICE have been empowered to do exactly what they're trained to do: arrest and remove illegal aliens and criminals from our communities. We are enhancing public safety, securing our national security, and finally restoring integrity of the immigration system that had been allowed to collapse. We have supercharged our partnerships with State and local law enforcement, empowering offices around the country through the 287(g) program to help ICE identify and remove criminal aliens. Those partnerships have increased more than 900 percent since President Trump took office, and our communities are safer for it. I am also proud of our agency's unprecedented hiring campaign that led to hiring of more than 12,000 officers and special agents in less than a year, and more than 222,000 individuals submitted applications. This expansion of a well- trained and well-vetted work force will help further ICE's abilities to execute the President's and Secretary's bold agenda. Before discussing our broader operations, I must address the situation in Minnesota and the dangers that ICE agents and officers face nationwide. While the investigations remain on- going, I'm encouraged that some Minnesota officials are finally signaling the willingness to cooperate with ICE. But let me be clear, promises are not enough. We need action. In the wake of the unprecedented border crisis of the previous administration, ICE has stepped into the breach to enforce the law. This commitment has a cost. We are facing the deadliest operating environment in our agency's history. In fiscal year 2025, death threats against ICE personnel increased more than 8,000 percent. Assaults on officers have skyrocketed over 1,400 percent. One officer in Minnesota had his finger bitten off by a protester, egged on by elected officials characterizing our offices as Gestapo or secret police. The families of personnel--ICE personnel have been made to feel unsafe in their homes. I know this first-hand because my own family was targeted. But let me send a message to anyone who thinks they can intimidate us. You will fail. Despite these perils, our officers continue to execute their mission with unwavering resolve. We are only getting started. ICE remains committed to the fundamental principles that those who illegally enter our country must be held accountable. Since the beginning of the second Trump administration, we have achieved historic results. From January 20, 2025, through January 20, 2026, ICE has conducted nearly 379,000 arrests. Among those arrests were more than 7,000 suspected gang members and over 1,400 known or suspected terrorists. The President tasked us with mass deportation, and we are fulfilling that mandate. Thanks to the resources provided by this Congress, we are ramping up detention capacities and removal flights daily. In the last year alone, we conducted over 475,000 removals. It's a brutal reality that criminal immigration today is organized by sophisticated, ruthless transnational criminal organizations. These include cartels and transnational gangs President Trump has rightfully designated as foreign terrorist organizations. The only way to defeat them is to destroy their revenue. Within Homeland Security Investigations, our special agents are delivering critical outcomes in the fight against transnational crime. We are seizing fentanyl before it kills our children and dismantling the networks that poison our communities. In fiscal year 2025 alone, we seized more than 2.5 million pounds of narcotics, a 50 percent increase from the previous year and a critical blow to transnational organization groups everywhere. HSI criminal arrests are at the highest point in history. However, our approach is just not about enforcement. It is about restoring order and dignity to human beings sold alive by smugglers and exploited by these TCOs. In August 2024, the DHS Office of Inspector General released a report that concluded that more than 291,000 unaccompanied alien children, out of nearly 450,000 transferred from DHS to HHS custody, were simply lost by the system. We are talking about children exploited in factories, abused in sexual trades, and living as indentured servants on American soil. HSI is leading the charge to find them. We have conducted more than 71,000 field engagements to locate children, verify sponsor legitimacy, and uncover criminal activity related to exploitation. Since February 2025, ICE has arrested more than 500 criminal sponsors of these offenses, including sexual exploitation and forced labor, dismantled more than 2,400 human smuggling operations, and along with our Federal partners, located more than 145,000 children. To further ensure TCOs can never threaten our Nation again, President Trump dedicated the establishment of the Homeland Security Task Force. The Homeland Security Task Forces represent the most aggressive and coordinated attack on TCOs in history. Through Cross-Border Financial Crime Center, we have developed and implemented a strategy to combat rampant fraud, including Government programs in Minnesota and across the country. Using this strategy, HSI has opened numerous criminal investigations into the complex fraud systems that have resulted in the thefts of billions. Much of the fight ICE faces continue to be fueled by so- called sanctuary cities. These jurisdictions provided a shield for criminal aliens when a local jail refuses to honor ICE detainer and releases that predator back into the community. ICE exists to enforce America's longstanding immigration and custom laws. These laws are grounded in common sense, national sovereignty, and simple morality. Our officers and agents enforce these without hesitation, without apology. I ask that all the Members of the committee treat them with profound respect that they have earned. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Lyons follows:] Prepared Statement of Todd M. Lyons February 10, 2026 introduction Chairman Garbarino, Ranking Member Thompson, and distinguished Members of the committee: Thank you for the invitation to appear today to discuss the critical work U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is doing around the clock to carry out President Donald J. Trump's agenda to keep Americans safe, restore order to our communities, and return the rule of law to this country. I stand before you today with immense pride to represent the dedicated patriots who have answered the call to serve their Nation. These men and women do not just hold a job; they hold the line, saving American lives. They unapologetically enforce the laws of the United States, and they do so with a courage that humbles me every single day. Under the leadership of President Trump and Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Kristi Noem, the men and women of ICE have been empowered to do exactly what they were trained to do: arrest and remove illegal aliens and criminals from our communities. We are enhancing public safety, securing our national security, and finally restoring integrity to an immigration system that had been allowed to collapse. While all illegal aliens are eligible for removal, we have prioritized and removed tens of thousands of the ``worst of the worst''--known dangerous criminals, known or suspected terrorists, and gang members who threaten our neighborhoods. We have supercharged partnerships with State and local law enforcement, empowering officers around the country, under the authorities given to us by Congress through the 287(g) program, to help ICE identify and remove criminal aliens from the United States. Those partnerships have increased more than 900 percent since President Trump took office, and our communities are safer for it. We encourage more agencies and departments around the country to partner with us in this noble effort. I am also proud of the agency's unprecedented hiring campaign that led to ICE hiring more than 12,000 officers and agents in less than a year, after more than 220,000 individuals submitted applications. This expansion of our well-trained and well-vetted work force will further support ICE's ability to execute on the President and the Secretary's bold agenda to enforce our laws and remove illegal aliens. a deadly operating environment Before discussing our broader operations, I must address the situation in Minnesota and the dangers that ICE agents face nationwide. While investigations remain on-going, I am encouraged that some Minnesota officials are finally signaling a willingness to cooperate with ICE. But let me be clear: promises are not enough. We need action. The anti-ICE rhetoric from public officials not just in Minnesota but throughout the country has fomented violence against dedicated American patriots defending our homeland, and this must stop. In the wake of the unprecedented border chaos of the previous administration, ICE has stepped into the breach to enforce the law. This commitment has come at a cost. Our increased enforcement has been met with a surge in threats, assaults, and doxing incidents against our employees. We are facing the deadliest operating environment in our agency's history. ICE personnel, not to mention their families, are under assault like never before in this country. In fiscal year 2025, death threats against ICE personnel increased by more than 8,000 percent. Assaults on our officers have skyrocketed by over 1,400 percent. One officer in Minnesota had his finger bitten off by a left-wing protestor, egged on by elected officials characterizing our officers as the ``gestapo'' or ``secret police.'' The families of ICE personnel have been made to feel unsafe in their own homes simply because their loved ones have the courage to enforce the laws passed by this Congress. Notably, those criticizing ICE and encouraging this violence against our officers and their families were silent amid the horrors perpetrated by cartels and human traffickers due to a lack of immigration enforcement under the Biden administration. I know this reality first-hand. My own family has been targeted. But let me send a message to anyone who thinks they can intimidate us: You will fail. the results of ice's increased immigration enforcement operations Despite these perils, our officers continue to execute their mission with unwavering resolve. We are only getting started. ICE remains committed to the fundamental principle that those who illegally enter our country must be held accountable. Since the beginning of the second Trump administration, we have achieved historic results. From January 20, 2025, through January 20, 2026, ICE conducted nearly 379,000 arrests. Among these arrested were more than 7,300 suspected gang members and 1,400 known or suspected terrorists. We have taken these dangerous individuals off our streets, making our country dramatically safer. The President tasked us with mass deportations, and we are fulfilling that mandate. Thanks to the resources provided by Congress, we are ramping up detention capacity and removal flights daily. In the last year alone, we conducted over 475,000 removals. We are not just inflating statistics by counting border turnarounds; these are real removals of individuals with no lawful basis to remain in the United States. dismantling tco s and ending atrocities against children It is a brutal reality that illegal immigration today is entirely organized by sophisticated, ruthless Transnational Criminal Organizations (TCOs). This includes the cartels and transnational gangs that President Trump has rightfully designated as Foreign Terrorist Organizations (FTOs). For too long, these terrorist groups have effectively controlled our Southern Border, deciding who enters, what enters, and at what price. These organizations treat human beings as cargo and American laws as mere suggestions. The only way to defeat them is to destroy their revenue stream. Within Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), our special agents are delivering critical outcomes in the fight against transnational crime. We are seizing fentanyl before it kills our children and dismantling the networks that poison our communities. In fiscal year 2025 alone, we seized more than 2.5 million pounds of narcotics--a 53 percent increase from the previous year and a critical blow to TCO revenues. And, HSI criminal arrests are at their highest point in HSI history. However, our approach is not just about enforcement; it is about restoring order and dignity to many human beings who have been sold a lie by smugglers and exploited by these TCOs. Nowhere is the mission more urgent, or the history more horrifying, than in the protection of children. We must confront the atrocities that were allowed to fester under the previous administration. In August 2024, the DHS Office of Inspector General released a report that details a campaign of negligence against the most vulnerable among us. The report concluded that more than 291,000 Unaccompanied Alien Children (UACs)--out of nearly 450,000 transferred from DHS to the Department of Health and Human Services' custody--were simply ``lost'' by the system. These children were not just misplaced files; they were human beings abandoned to cartels and traffickers. By failing to issue Notices to Appear or locating minors who missed appearances, the Biden- Harris administration effectively surrendered them to traffickers and forced labor rings. We are talking about children exploited in factories, abused in illicit sex trades, and living in indentured servitude on American soil. This was a moral stain on our Nation and one of the greatest humanitarian tragedies in our history, fueled by a refusal to enforce the law. HSI is now leading the charge to find them. We have conducted more than 71,000 field engagements to locate children, verify sponsor legitimacy, and uncover criminal activity related to exploitation and trafficking. These operations have involved comprehensive criminal investigations, intelligence gathering, and close coordination with Federal, State, and local partners to identify fraudulent sponsors, dismantle trafficking networks, and pursue individuals who prey on vulnerable children. Since February 2025, HSI has: Arrested over 500 criminal sponsors for offenses including child sexual exploitation, forced labor, identity fraud, immigration violations, and aggravated assault; Dismantled more than 2,400 human smuggling operations, including nearly 730 criminal prosecutions related to human smuggling, human trafficking, immigration violations, and child exploitation; and Reached 45 million people nationwide through public awareness campaigns focused on preventing child trafficking and sponsor fraud. Incredibly, under President Trump's leadership, HSI special agents and others within DHS law enforcement and the Department of Health and Human Services have also located more than 145,000 UACs who the Biden administration lost--many of them exploited, trafficked, and abused. ICE deportations break the back of the TCO business model that relies on this trafficking and the abuse and neglect of our legal system. When illegal entry no longer serves as a meaningful method to plant operatives in the United States and to transport humans and product across our borders, these criminal networks lose their sources and methods of profit. By removing illegal aliens from the interior and rectifying the Biden administration's failures, ICE is not just enforcing the law; we are dismantling a machinery of human misery and protecting those who were victimized by criminals taking advantage of the prior administration's refusal to enforce the law. Further, through the President's ``Project Homecoming'' and our Incentivized Voluntary Departure pilot program, we are offering individuals the right to self-deport with dignity. This program allows aliens to return to their home countries on their own terms, without the stigma of a forced removal order. Crucially, by choosing this dignified path, they preserve the chance of coming back to the country the legal way in the future. We are sending a clear message: Do not trust the TCOs with your life. Respect our laws, return home with dignity, and keep the door open to a lawful future. homeland security task forces (hstf s) and illicit finance To further ensure these TCOs can never threaten our Nation again, President Trump directed the establishment of the Homeland Security Task Forces (HSTFs). The HSTFs represent the most aggressive, coordinated attack on TCOs in history. Our mandate is clear: dismantle the FTO-designated cartels and transnational gangs root and branch. A critical pillar of the HSTF mission is targeting the illicit financing that fuels this violence. Under the direct umbrella of the HSTFs, we have established the Cross-Border Financial Crime Center. This Center is the tip of the spear in our financial war against the TCOs. Through the Cross-Border Finance Crime Center, we have developed and implemented a targeted strategy to combat rampant fraud involving government programs in Minnesota and across the United States. Using this strategy, HSI has opened numerous criminal investigations into complex fraud schemes that have resulted in the theft of billions of taxpayer dollars. HSI is working side-by-side with Federal partners to identify those responsible and aggressively recover hard-earned taxpayer funds. We are cutting off the money, cutting off the supply, and cutting off the leadership. We will not rest until these criminal organizations are destroyed. sanctuary cities Much of the fight that ICE faces in keeping Americans safe is fueled by so-called ``Sanctuary Cities.'' The concept of a ``Sanctuary City'' is a dangerous lie. These jurisdictions do not provide sanctuary for immigrants; they provide a shield for criminals. When a local jail refuses to honor an ICE detainer and releases a predator back onto the street, they are not protecting their community--they are endangering it. They are complicit in every future crime that individual commits. We are seeing the impact of these reckless policies in real time, where innocent Americans are victimized by individuals who should have been deported. Worse yet, many of these sanctuary jurisdictions provide financial benefits and incentives to these illegal immigrants at the direct expense of the American taxpayer. In our last election, Americans voted unequivocally for support for immigration enforcement. There is no right to obstruct Federal law enforcement that the American people voted for by force or by policy, and we will use every tool available to hold these jurisdictions accountable and protect the American people. congressional access to ice facilities We have achieved these outcomes while maintaining transparency. Under President Trump's leadership, and consistent with Secretary Noem's guidance, ICE supported more than triple the annual number of Congressional facility visits compared to the past 10 years. As of January 8, 2026, due to the rise in political violence, we are enforcing strict security protocols for these visits to ensure the safety of our staff, the detainees, and Members of Congress themselves, consistent with all court orders. Even though these visits pull enforcement personnel away from arresting and removing illegal aliens, including dangerous criminals and those with final orders of removal, ICE supported more than 150 such visits between January 20 and September 30, 2025. We stand by our world-class detention operation as we expand it to remove historic numbers of illegal aliens. ice will continue to execute its long-standing, statutory mission My agency, ICE, exists to enforce America's long-standing immigration and customs laws. These laws are grounded in common sense, national sovereignty, and simple morality. Our officers and agents enforce them without hesitation and without apology. The men and women of ICE are dedicated, hardworking, and unmatched in their professionalism. They are the shield that protects our communities. I ask that all Members of this committee treat them with the profound respect they have earned. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. Chairman Garbarino. Thank you, Acting Director Lyons. Members will be recognized by order of seniority for their 5 minutes of questioning. As we have when Secretary Noem was here, we are going to limit it to the 5-minute rule. I am going to be strict on that for both sides, so do not be surprised if you go over I gavel you down. I now recognize myself for 5 minutes of questions. Acting Director Lyons, I understand that you cannot discuss the details of the two recent shootings in Minnesota because they are subject of several investigations, including by the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security, and the DOJ Civil Rights Division. Once concluded, will you commit to providing the reports and findings of each investigation to this committee? Mr. Lyons. Yes, Mr. Chairman, we're fully committed to give you the full and unabridged investigation and the outcome. Chairman Garbarino. Thank you. Commissioner Scott, can the committee have the same commitment from you? Commissioner Scott. Yes, sir. Chairman Garbarino. Thank you both. Commissioner Scott and Acting Director Lyons, following this hearing, in writing I would like to know what is the standard operating procedure for each of your agencies for an investigation when deadly force is used currently. Acting Director Lyons, are those procedures being followed for the two uses of deadly force in Minneapolis this past January? Mr. Lyons. Yes, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Garbarino. And Commissioner Scott? Commissioner Scott. Yes, sir, they are. Chairman Garbarino. Were the standard procedures followed from the beginning, Mr. Lyons? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, they were. Chairman Garbarino. Mr. Scott. Commissioner Scott. Yes, for CBP they were as well. Chairman Garbarino. Thank you very much. We are all obviously concerned about officer safety and have seen and heard about increasing threats and assaults against law enforcement. Director Lyons, are your officers trained regarding the difference between a protected protest and what is unlawfully impeding law enforcement? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Deportation officers and special agents are taught at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center. They are taught in defensive tactics, personal safety, but as well as, you know, laws to include 1st, 2nd, 4th, 5th, 10th, 14th Amendment. The officers are trained before they go out into the field, and then while they're in the field, they are specialized training with disturbance control and other special tactics. Chairman Garbarino. Commissioner Scott, are your officers similarly trained? Commissioner Scott. Yes, they are. At FLETC, on-going training in the field. Then anytime we're deploying them to the interior, they get updated law refresher training to include the First Amendment and Fourth Amendment. Chairman Garbarino. So I want to focus on the training here because with the historic investment in both ICE and CBP, there was a surge in hiring. I need to know, for these new hires, is the training different than what other agents and officers received before the hiring surge? Mr. Lyons, I will let you start there. Mr. Lyons. No, sir, it's not. The training was never--the meat of the training was never removed. The time line was. We took training from 5 days a week, 8 hours a day, to 6 days a week, 12 hours a day. In addition to that, training is different in the fact that before officers even go to the Federal Law Enforcement Training Academy, there's preemployment training, which we never had before. On top of that, we've adapted our on-the-job training program, which is much like a city or State field training officer program, that once they are removed from the Federal Law Enforcement Training Academy, have graduated, before they return to their field offices they are assigned a field training officer, and that's continued on after that. Chairman Garbarino. So let me get to this. For ICE officers, the curriculum has stayed the same, but it is now a quicker training? The time line has moved up? Mr. Lyons. That's correct, sir. Chairman Garbarino. OK. But the curriculum is the same? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Chairman Garbarino. All right. Commissioner Scott, can you talk about if there has been a change in training since the hiring surge? Commissioner Scott. There's been no change in the training within Customs and Border Protection. Border Patrol agents go through a 117-day academy. The CBP officers go through a 103- day academy. That's actually training days. There's been no changes to that. So the only change that has been made is in our quarterly training. We've added scenarios based on what we most likely think they will encounter in the field. So we've encountered some of--we've actually added some of the protest- type encounters as well. Chairman Garbarino. So there has been no change in the time line either? Same with ICE did that, you did not? Commissioner Scott. No, we did not. Chairman Garbarino. OK. While this is nothing while-- because I am--this is my last question I am sure. While understanding there are not suitable verifications every occasion, there has been a lot of talk about the use of deadly force. Are agents and officers equipped with and trained in the use of tasers or other less lethal alternatives to avoid the use of deadly force? Mr. Director Lyons, I will start with you and then Mr. Scott, you can finish. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Every deportation officer and special agent are trained in secretary--secondary weapons, which include the taser, OC spray, and baton. Chairman Garbarino. They are trained---- Mr. Lyons. Those are made available. Chairman Garbarino [continuing]. And they are equipped? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Chairman Garbarino. Mr. Scott. Commissioner Scott. It's a similar answer that all of our agents have to carry a secondary weapon. They train at the academy and then they go through quarterly refresher training every 3 months. Chairman Garbarino. OK. I appreciate it. I will have, I am sure, some follow-up questions today and I will submit those to you in writing. But with that, I yield back. I now recognize the Ranking Member for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Thompson. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Lyons, how many ICE agents have cameras as of today? Mr. Lyons. Sir, as of today, more than 3,000 ICE officers have cameras that are active in the field, with another 6,000 being deployed, sir. Mr. Thompson. So how many are in the field? How many ICE agents are in the field as of today? Mr. Lyons. Oh, I'm sorry sir. Agents in the field today? Mr. Thompson. You said agents in the field. I am just trying to get the number of ICE agents who have cameras on their body as of today. Mr. Lyons. Approximately 3,000, sir. Mr. Thompson. Three thousand out of how many? Mr. Lyons. Out of approximately 13,000, sir, that are in the field. Mr. Thompson. So you have 3,000 out of 13,000 who have cameras? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Thompson. Mr. Scott. Commissioner Scott. I don't have the actual number in front of me right now. It's about 10,000. We're building that program out as we speak. Mr. Thompson. Ten thousand out of how many? Commissioner Scott. Out of about 67,000. But there, the ports of entry, we have significant video. Mr. Thompson. No, no, no, I don't want to go to ports of entry. I just want to know how many cameras right now do you have on your agents? Commissioner Scott. When you say ``agents,'' Border Patrol agents, there's about 10,000. Mr. Thompson. Ten thousand out of how many? Commissioner Scott. Out of 20,000 Border Patrol agents. Mr. Thompson. So half of them? Commissioner Scott. Approximately, yes. Mr. Thompson. So I will give you a chance to look at that since you said approximately, and get back to the committee on what is the accurate number, not how many you are purchasing, how many as of this day. Commissioner Scott. Understood. I will get you that number. Mr. Thompson. Thank you. Mr. Lyons, what is the regular time table of training an ICE agent? Mr. Lyons. Right now, sir--sorry about that, sir. Right now the training is approximately 47 days at the Federal Law Enforcement Academy. Overall training is about 3 months, sir. Mr. Thompson. So you went from 3 months to 47 days? Mr. Lyons. No, no, sir, the whole total training to include the preemployment training and then the OJT program is 3 months and 47 days in the law enforcement--Federal Law Enforcement Training Academy. Mr. Thompson. So they go to FLETC for 47 days or for 3 months? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. You asked for the total training time. The total training time now is a combined 3 months, sir, with 47 days at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Academy. Mr. Thompson. So you didn't reduce the time line for any ICE agents to come on board? Mr. Lyons. We reduced the time line for the previous certified Federal law enforcement officers or special agents, where we went to the ones who are already trained in firearms and defensive tactics and criminal procedure. We adapted to a shorter program so they would just have the extensive Immigration Nationality Act training, immigration law, and ICE- specific training. Mr. Thompson. So if you hired somebody for ICE today, how much training would they receive before they become a full-time agent? Mr. Lyons. So for a person off the street who has never been a law enforcement officer, they're looking at approximately 3 months of training, sir. Mr. Thompson. The 47 days is for who? Mr. Lyons. That is for everyone that hasn't--who's never worked for ICE, sir. So you could have someone that's a Capitol Police officer, they would not have to go through extended training for when it comes to defensive tactics, firearms, et cetera. They would have to go through the rigorous immigration training, which, unfortunately, immigration law is just as confusing and long as tax code, which we have to ensure that we devote that extensive time to. Mr. Thompson. Thank you so much. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Thompson. But would you provide the committee with the time line? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, we will provide you the---- Mr. Thompson. Because some of us understand it is 47 days. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, we will provide you---- Mr. Thompson. But you are telling us it's 3 months. Mr. Lyons. From the beginning, sir, when they go ahead and come on preemployment training to the OJT program afterwards. But we will provide the committee with a full breakdown. Mr. Thompson. OK. For Mr. Lyons and Mr. Scott, over the past several weeks, the President has made a series of comments regarding the midterm election. The President has urged my Republican colleagues in Congress to nationalize elections. Now, are you involved in any planning on guarding precincts in this country as of today, Mr. Scott? Commissioner Scott. No, sir. Mr. Thompson. Mr. Lyons. Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Thompson. So there is no information? You have not been asked to start deploying people for areas anywhere? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Thompson. Well, thank you very much. Mr. Lyons--I will get it in writing, Mr. Chairman. I am going to follow your directions on that. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. Thank you, Ranking Member. I now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. McCaul, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. McCaul. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You know, a decade ago when I chaired this committee, Mr. Thompson and I passed a bill to authorize ICE into law. It was a bipartisan effort. It passed the House overwhelmingly, both Republican and Democrat. A decade later, here we are. The Dems have called to abolish ICE. Now they are trying to shut it down. So what has happened in that 10 years? Let's go back to the last 4 to 5 years what happened in this country and at the border. As someone who lives in a border State of Texas, we saw the most dangerous, wide-open border that I have seen in my 22 years in Congress, 10 to 12 million people, and that is what we know about, I think it is far greater, came into this country, many of them dangerous, violent criminals, some known or suspected terrorists, which I find extremely dangerous. That is why I served as an impeachment manager for Mayorkas because he violated Federal law. The Federal statute says, as a former Federal prosecutor, I know this, shall detain aggravated felons. What did Mayorkas do? He told his agents, that is discretionary, you can release them. As a result, we had tens of thousands of aggravated felons left on the streets of America to roam freely, not to mention the human and sex trafficking of children, Mr. Lyons, as you pointed out. So what is the administration trying to do? They are trying to remove a public safety threat from the United States of America. That is their job. Restoring public safety should be the No. 1 priority. One of the problems here, as I examine it, is that Minnesota, Minneapolis, in particular, is a sanctuary city. What does that mean? That means that it is a magnet for illegal. They are protected under the current situation because State and locals will not cooperate with Federal law enforcement. In fact, Mr. Lyons, is it not true that they were not honoring ICE detainers that were put on dangerous felons in prison so that you could remove them from the United States? Mr. Lyons. That is correct, sir. The detainees were not honored at the local level in Minneapolis. Mr. McCaul. This is the No. 1 violation. In addition, the rhetoric on the left led to over 1,000 percent increase in assaults on ICE officers, an increase of over 8,000 death threats to them. All this created a perfect storm for our officers being thrown into this situation. Then Agent Bovino came into the picture. I would argue, in fairness, that he escalated the situation by the way that was handled. Your officers are not trained to effectuate crowd control. They are trained to move in, surgically, go in and remove these dangerous, violent criminals from the United States of America. I have called for deescalation after the two deaths, the two shootings that took place. I believe that these roving patrols should be down at the border rather than in the major cities of the United States. So when the President decided to remove Agent Bovino and put in Tom Homan, who I have known for years, a consummate professional, law enforcement professional, I commended the President. What has been done since Mr. Homan came into the job? We now have targeted law enforcement operations. He is returning to the original mission of ICE. He is working with State and locals to do the crowd control. He is getting them to honor the ICE detainers. He is also getting the body cameras put on them and the roving patrols, in his words to me, should be done at the border, not in major cities. My question to you, Mr. Lyons, is Mr. Homan now, are his operations in Minneapolis now bringing the situation under control? Mr. Lyons. Sir, we have seen a deescalation in the fact that the protests, while they still go on, have subsided and ICE has been allowed to do their targeted, intelligence-driven enforcement operation. Just the other night, local authorities arrested 54 protesters at the local level where ICE officers did not have to be engaged in that. Mr. McCaul. My final question to you, do you believe the model that Mr. Homan is now setting in Minneapolis should be a model for the Nation? Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. McCaul. If he can be allowed---- Chairman Garbarino. I understand that, but I am holding---- Mr. McCaul. I would like on the record an answer, Mr. Chairman. Do you agree that Mr. Homan's model is one for the Nation? Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. McCaul. Yes or no? Chairman Garbarino. I now recognize the gentleman from California, Mr. Swalwell, for 5 minutes. Mr. Swalwell. A couple nights ago, I met with a woman who works as a cashier at a grocery store, and I told her I was coming to see you, Mr. Lyons. She said, will you ask him--and she didn't want to give her name. She was terrified to give her name. But she said, when I get off my shift around midnight and I walk through the parking lot to my car, she said, if somebody rolls up in an unidentified van and gets out wearing all black and their faces covered and they don't have any identification, and they ask me to get into the van, how do I know who they are? How does she know, Mr. Lyons? How does she know if they are an ICE agent or bad guys? Mr. Lyons. Sir, ICE agents have identifiable placards on their uniforms as well as their badges, Representative. But you won't see ICE agents rolling through the parking lots and just snatching someone up. ICE does intelligence-driven, targeted enforcement operations. Mr. Swalwell. Well, Mr. Homan and others have said that they target individuals based on the color of their skin and the accents that they speak, and that is why people are running through the fields and factories where they work. Director Lyons, last year you said in Phoenix at the Border Security Expo that you wanted to see a deportation process that was like ``Amazon Prime, but with human beings.'' Mr. Lyons, how many times has Amazon Prime shot a mom 3 times in the face? Mr. Lyons. None, sir. But you're also---- Mr. Swalwell. It is the square root of zero. That is right. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Yes. But if we're going to go down that route of my comment, I did say that comment. However, that comment was taken out. If you go back and watch the video, I did say that we need to be more efficient when it comes to removing individuals from the United States. Because ICE doesn't detain punitively, we detain to remove. I don't want to see people in custody. At the end of my statement was--and again, to your point, it was a industry day for AI inefficiencies. But I did say at the end of it, but we deal with human beings, so we can't be like them. Mr. Swalwell. Speaking of---- Mr. Lyons. That's the key part that you're leaving out. Mr. Swalwell. Well, speaking of human beings, how many times has Amazon Prime shot a nurse 10 times in the back? Mr. Lyons. None. Mr. Swalwell. How many times has Amazon Prime dragged a woman out of her car by her hair and then dragged her down the street? Mr. Lyons. None. Mr. Swalwell. How many ICE agents have been fired for their conduct under your leadership? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I can get you that data. I'll get that back to you. Mr. Swalwell. Is it more than one? Mr. Lyons. I'm not going to speak about personnel actions, but I'll get you that data. Mr. Swalwell. Can you tell us if at least--God, I hope at least one person has been fired for their conduct since these operations have begun. Are you telling us you can't even say one person has been fired? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I'm not going to talk about personnel actions, but we will get back to you. Mr. Swalwell. But two people have been killed so far. Is that right? A nurse named Pretti and a mom named Good. Two people have been killed so far? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Swalwell. Mr. Lyons, will you apologize to the family of Renee Good for being called a domestic terrorist by the President and his leadership? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Swalwell. Why not? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I welcome the opportunity to speak to the family in private, but I'm not going to comment on any active investigation. Mr. Swalwell. Is she a domestic terrorist? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I'm not going to comment on the investigation. The President and Secretary Noem are elected officials. That's their right to their comments. But as law-- career law enforcement, we won't speak to any. Mr. Swalwell. Do you agree with their comments? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I'm not going to go ahead and talk about any on-going investigation. Mr. Swalwell. Will you apologize to the family of Alex Pretti for also being called a domestic terrorist? Mr. Lyons. Sir, again, I'm not going to speak to any on- going investigation. Mr. Swalwell. Mr. Lyons, your staying to lead ICE is a decision. Mr. Lyons. Sir, I'm sorry? Mr. Swalwell. Your staying on to lead ICE is a decision. I have read your background. You have a decorated career, you have served in the military. You are what I would call otherwise employable. I think most people would agree this is not the only job that you can get. But since you have been on this job, women have been dragged by their hair through our streets. A 6-year-old child battling stage 4 cancer has been deported and it turns out he was a U.S. citizen. People are running through the fields where they work. People who have gone to the streets as allies have been shot and publicly executed. It is a decision to stay on at this point. Considering your honorable service in the past and the dishonorable acts that those who have worked for you have conducted, and the disgraceful statements that the leadership above you have said, you now have a decision. Will you stand with the kids who you are supposed to protect or will you side with the killers bringing terror to our streets? Mr. Lyons, will you resign from ICE? Mr. Lyons. No, sir, I won't. Mr. Swalwell. Why not? Mr. Lyons. Because, sir, that child that you're showing right there, the men and women of ICE took care of him when his father abandoned him and ran from law enforcement. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Swalwell. He never should have gone into custody. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. I recognize the gentleman from Mississippi, Mr. Guest, for 5 minutes. Mr. Guest. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, we stand on the verge of a second Democrat shutdown of the United States Department of Homeland Security just within the last 90 days. The Department of Homeland Security employs 260,000 men and women across 22 different agencies. Those agencies include 63,000 men and women who work for CBP, 60,000 who work for TSA, 22,000 for FEMA, 18,000 who works for USCIS, almost 50,000 civilian and military employees with the United States Coast Guard, 7,800 Secret Service employees, 2,500 CISA employees, and over 8,000 agents and analysts with the Department of Homeland Security Investigation who perform a crucial function, a crucial function to protect and serve this country. This second Government shutdown, led by my friends on the Democrat side of the aisle, will leave our country less safe. Don't just take my word for it. Let's look at the words of the Biden administration. President Biden and Kamala Harris' Department of Homeland Security, in September 2023, as the Nation faced a potential Government shutdown, they issued a fact sheet. That fact sheet is entitled, ``The Impact of Government Shutdown on the DHS Workforce.'' This fact sheet says this. It says, ``DHS work force is comprised of extraordinary public servants who safeguard this Nation.'' It goes on to say, ``Any lapse in Federal funding would disrupt this vital work, leaving Americans less safe as a result.'' Those working without pay include law enforcement conducting such acts as seizing illegal narcotics like fentanyl, combating child exploitation and child predators, identify and arresting human trafficking, responding to natural disasters, preventing cyber attacks, and protecting U.S. Government leaders. So I ask you, gentlemen, as we are once again on the verge of a shutdown of the Department of Homeland Security, if the Democrats take us to the edge, if they refuse to sign a CR, if, once again, the men and women who serve under your leadership, if they are once again not paid, I ask you, how will that impact our Nation? Will America be more safe or will America be less safe if we are once again led into a Government shutdown by the Democrat Party? Mr. Scott. Commissioner Scott. I believe consistency in seeing support from the leadership on both sides of this building and the President is very important to border security. I think the rhetoric and the back-and-forth, the politicizing of law enforcement in general detracts from the general morale of our personnel. Mr. Guest. Is it not important that we pay the men and women who serve under your command? Commissioner Scott. It's critically important. Mr. Guest. In a Government shutdown, the bills don't stop, do they not? The bills continue to accrue. Commissioner Scott. Correct. Mr. Guest. The deployment of technology ceases in many cases and America becomes less safe. Would you agree with that statement? Commissioner Scott. I would agree America becomes less safe. Mr. Guest. Mr. Edlow, what about you? Mr. Edlow. Well, Congressman, as I'm sure you're aware, USCIS is a little different in that we are fee-funded. So during a shutdown, the men and women working for USCIS will continue to be paid. However, in terms of our screening and vetting enterprises, as well as everything else we do, we form very--we have formed very, very strong working relationships with the other components and that's critical for us to be able to do our work. While we may be there, able to continue, without our partners being paid and with them being furloughed it's going to make America significantly less safe. Mr. Guest. Mr. Lyons. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. It will have a great impact, especially on the Homeland Security task forces and the men and women that are focused on the transnational crime and foreign terrorist organization. Mr. Guest. Mr. Lyons, very quickly, we have had many Members of this committee who have made allegations. The Democrats have, once again, taken the mantle of the party to defund the police and abolish ICE. Do you wish to take my last few seconds to speak about the consequences that has on the men and women that you serve? Mr. Lyons. The men and women of ICE are sworn law enforcement officers who are dedicated to do their mission to protect the United States. Mr. Guest. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from California, Mr. Correa, 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Correa. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to welcome our witnesses today. Gentlemen, I wanted to start out by talking a little bit about my district, Southern California, Disneyland. Southern California is the center of manufacturing for the United States. California, biggest ag State in the union. California, also big donor taxpayer dollars to the United States. President Trump got elected on the promise to deport the worst of the worst. Your numbers, Mr. Lyons, less than 14 percent of those arrested by ICE first year, 2025, had charges or convictions of violence; 70 percent of those deported had not even a traffic ticket. Mr. Lyons, I think we are all patriots, but I am trying to figure out how, this is a question to you, sir, how deporting a nanny makes our Nation safer, stronger. How trying to deport the father of three Marines make this country stronger. How deporting the parents of number of Marines at Camp Pendleton makes this Nation stronger. Mr. Lyons. Sir, thank you for your welcome first off. Just to address your--the numbers with the 14 percent, sir, that's 14 percent that are listed as violent criminal felonies. However, what's left out of that is the fact that what's left off that---- Mr. Correa. Those 70 percent that don't have a traffic ticket and deported, how has that made our Nation stronger? Mr. Lyons. Sir, if you look at what ICE has done, more than 60 percent of every individual that is in ICE custody has a pending or a conviction on a criminal charge. Not to count the---- Mr. Correa. Sir, let me move ahead. I only have 3 minutes and we will talk later. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Correa. Let's talk about American citizens. Again, back home, people, young people, asking me what do I have to carry with me so I won't be deported? Is, Mr. Lyons, carrying a passport, is that enough so they won't be detained or deported in my district? Mr. Lyons. Sir, an American citizen shouldn't carry--or shouldn't feel the need to carry a passport. Mr. Correa. Let me tell you what some of your ICE agents have done. They pulled over a gentleman in a pickup truck, showed his passport, they threw it to the side, detained him. What do we have to do to show that we are American citizens? Mr. Lyons. Sir, no American citizen falls under Title 8. No American citizen will be arrested for being American citizens. Mr. Correa. But you just said to my colleague that nobody has been fired because of violations of the law for disciplinary actions, yet this is happening in my district. Mr. Lyons, we are a very boring district. We work hard, mind our own business. ICE in our streets now. People are terrorized, American citizens. Number of cases of Americans being detained, being taken in, some being held for 5 days. Sir, what do we do with those people in that situation? What do we tell them? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I don't know of any particular case that you're speaking of an American citizen being---- Mr. Correa. I am more than happy to provide you a list, sir. Mr. Lyons. One hundred percent, sir. Mr. Correa. So let me ask you, sir, are you surveilling U.S. citizens today? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Correa. Those people protesting, practicing this First Amendment right, photos of them, data taken, they are not being placed in any kind of a database? Mr. Lyons. There is no database for protesters, sir. Mr. Correa. One of your officers in Maine said to one of the individuals protesting, we are going to put your face in a little database. What does that mean? Do you have a little database---- Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Correa [continuing]. Of Americans? Mr. Lyons. No, sir, we don't. Mr. Correa. Then what do you think your ICE agent was doing to this individual when he said those statements? Mr. Lyons. I can't speak for that individual, sir, but I can assure you there is no database that's tracking United States citizens. Mr. Correa. Sir, California, we are a sanctuary State. Does that cause you a problem picking up individuals? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Correa. I have with me today some data from Sheriff Barnes, Orange County sheriff. Very good friend, has been here to testify numerous times. For 2025, he referred about 300 individuals for your office to pick up, 250 were picked up, 50 were never picked up. We had a long conversation saying what is going on? If these are the worst of the worst, you have called ICE to pick them up and you didn't pick them up. Can you explain to us why you didn't pick up all these individuals that were referred to your office to pick up? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. That's the key part of that, is the referral. We make sure that those individuals are eligible to be placed in detention and for movability. So in that case---- Mr. Correa. You never even looked at those individuals. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Correa. I would like to talk to you about this issue later on, Mr. Lyons. Thank you very much. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Pfluger, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Pfluger. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Why are we here? I think it is pretty clear that until proven otherwise, at 5 years of experience, that it seems like one side of the aisle is in favor of open borders and wants to abolish ICE. I hope that that can be proven wrong. The other side of the aisle wants to enforce the laws that are on the books. Commissioner Scott, how many administrations have you worked for in your career? Commissioner Scott. Since the Clinton administration. Mr. Pfluger. So multiple Republicans, multiple Democrats. Commissioner Scott. Correct. Mr. Pfluger. Is it a crime to enter this country illegally and to skip a notice to appear, to skip a court-ordered appearance, and to not comply with the laws that that are on the books? Commissioner Scott. Yes, sir. Mr. Pfluger. Has that changed since you started working for President Clinton? Commissioner Scott. No. Mr. Pfluger. So I can't imagine, establishing the fact that it is a crime to skip a notice to appear, we had 10 to 12 million people who entered this country illegally in the Biden administration, as a conservative estimate. There are sanctuary cities all throughout the United States who have said we will not comply with Federal laws. That is why we are here today. I can't imagine being a DHS officer, an ICE officer, and being threatened with violence, having death threats, being doxed, having your family identified, putting that on the internet, and violently telling you that they are going to kill you because you are enforcing the laws that are on those books that were passed by both sides of the aisle in this body. Director Lyons, how many of your agents are being doxed, threatened, or harassed? Mr. Lyons. We've had over an 8,000 percent increase on death threats. Mr. Pfluger. You know, I am in the middle of working a bipartisan domestic terrorism working group with another Member on this committee. There is a group called Defend 612 that has come out with tactics, techniques, and procedures in Minneapolis to do things like encourage protesters to impede law enforcement, to push civilians toward legally and physically risky confrontations, to help mobilize a counterprotest, to help to coordinate strategies and trainings to aid illegal immigrants to avoid detention. Are you familiar with groups like this, Defend 612? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. We have multiple groups around that in all 50 States. Mr. Pfluger. There is an article written by Christina Buttons and I would like unanimous consent to enter this into the record, called ``Inside Minneapolis's ICE Watch Network.'' Chairman, I seek unanimous consent to enter this. Chairman Garbarino. Without objection. [The information follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Pfluger. This article talks about these tactics, techniques, and procedures that put your law enforcement agents and your agents at risk. What is different about Minneapolis? What kind of coordination have you received from the local police department that we don't see any of this in Texas? We have not seen--and there have been many ICE operations that have happened in Texas. But what is different from what you have seen in Minneapolis? Mr. Lyons. Unfortunately, sir, in the beginning of the Minneapolis operation, we didn't see any cooperation at the State or the local level, whether it be from the Minneapolis Police Department or the Minnesota State Police, which led to ICE officers and agents, as well as our other Federal partners, pretty much having to defend themselves from whatever impediment, riots, or protests. Mr. Pfluger. Were they told by local elected officials not to cooperate? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Pfluger. Is that because they are a sanctuary city? Mr. Lyons. I'm assuming that's what it is, sir. But I can't speak to the mind over those elected officials, but they were ordered not to stand up. Mr. Pfluger. How did it make you feel as somebody who carries out the laws that this body has passed, when you hear the mayor of Minneapolis say, F ICE? Mr. Lyons. Oh, sir, it's--I mean, from a morale standpoint, it hurts us to the fact that for decades, and I've worked since President Bush, ICE has always been in Minneapolis. We've always been in every major city and State, so it wasn't like it was a brand-new thing. We've always been doing immigration enforcement. So that's demoralizing. Mr. Pfluger. Commissioner Scott, are you separating families? Commissioner Scott. No. Mr. Pfluger. Tell me about when you served President Obama. Has anything changed in the policy of deportation? How many people did President Obama deport? Commissioner Scott. I don't have that number in front of me. Policies and how things are enforced do change. The laws have not changed. I believe what you're referring to is literally when someone is arrested, whether it's on immigration or whether it's a normal criminal offense and they have children, we don't necessarily prosecute the children. But when someone's deported, if they want to take their children with them, they have that right. We do not separate them. Mr. Pfluger. I hope that the other side of the aisle will read this article on Defend 612 and look at the tactics, techniques, and procedures. If this is domestic terrorism, where we have a group that is on Signal, that is calling out agents and doing things to interrupt, intercede, and prevent law enforcement from carrying out the laws that this body passed, that you will have the courage to call it domestic terror terrorism if it is that way. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlemen yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Michigan, Mr. Thanedar, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Thanedar. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good morning to our witnesses. Commissioner Scott, did the ICU nurse Alex Pretti deserve to die? Commissioner Scott. I cannot comment on an on-going investigation, sir. Mr. Thanedar. Do you believe that he deserved to die? Should he be killed by your agents? Commissioner Scott. I'm not going to comment on an on-going investigation, sir, before it's concluded and all the facts are available. Mr. Thanedar. Do you agree with CBP Commander Bovino's statement that Alex Pretti was planning to massacre law enforcement agents? Commissioner Scott. I'm not going to comment on an on-going investigation, sir. Mr. Thanedar. Director Lyons, did Renee Good deserve to die? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I can't comment on on-going investigations. Mr. Thanedar. Director Lyons, do you agree with Secretary Noem and Vice President Vance's characterization of Renee Good as a domestic terrorist? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I can't speak to their comments as that they are their own, but as an on-going investigation, I can't speak to that. Mr. Thanedar. Director Lyons, what did your agents mean when he said, ``You raise your voice, I erase your voice,'' in the video just that we have seen, all of us have seen. Mr. Lyons. Sir, I'm not aware of that video that you have, sir. I can't comment on what that officer has said. Mr. Thanedar. Does that statement, if that statement--if I show you the video of that, does that statement reflect the value of your agency? Does ICE respect and adhere to the First Amendment? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. ICE does respect and refer to the First Amendment, but that doesn't respect--that--your statement you said doesn't represent the values of the men and women of ICE. Mr. Thanedar. Commissioner Scott, does CBP respect and adhere to the First and Second Amendment? Commissioner Scott. Yes, we do. Mr. Thanedar. Don't you agree that Alex Pretti had every right to exercise his First and Second Amendment freedoms before being shot in the streets by one of your agents? Commissioner Scott. I believe every person in the United States has a right to their Constitutional rights. Mr. Thanedar. Look, I have heard and seen enough. I am just sick and tired of your agents running around in our cities, in our streets, causing illegal activities. ICE and CBP thugs are roaming our streets, attacking our communities, using our children as bait, referring to people as bodies and numbers, targeting people for their accents and the color of their skin, and killing American citizens, all while showing zero remorse for their actions. Director Lyons and Commissioner Scott, do you think President Trump will pardon you and your boss, Kristi Noem, before he leaves office, just like he has for insurrectionists and his political allies? Do you believe President Trump will pardon you? Because--go ahead. Commissioner Scott. I'm not going to speak on behalf of President Trump. But I'll tell you, I signed up for this job to protect America, and I'm very proud of the service that I provide. I don't need a pardon from anybody. Mr. Thanedar. Well, you better hope so. You better hope you get--been pardoned because you will be held accountable for the absolute disregard of the law your agencies have shown over the past year. Your agencies have lost the trust of the American people, with millions taking to the streets to protest the illegal actions of your agencies. That is why I introduced a bill in the U.S. Congress to abolish ICE. ICE must be abolished. I also cosponsored a bill to impeach Secretary Kristi Noem. I believe Kristi Noem must be impeached. This Congress must do everything in its power to carry out oversight actions against these rogue departments, including---- Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. A witness has requested a break. The committee will recess for 5 minutes. Members of the audience will remain seated. [Recess.] Chairman Garbarino. The committee will come to order. I now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Gonzales, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Gonzales. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, gentlemen, for your service to our great country. I was speaking to some agents that were deployed from Texas to Minnesota, just asking for the ground truth of what was happening. One of the things that stood out to me is one of the agents said, Tony, it reminds me a lot of Fallujah. Having someone that served in Fallujah, that caught my attention. So my question first is to you, Commissioner Scott, is on the safety of our agents. In particular, I see that these task forces work, these anti-gang, these anti-terrorism task forces. But thinking of Fallujah reminds me of we were fighting a war that was the Persian Gulf, when the world had changed. So my question is, is there a way we can protect our law enforcement--our Federal law enforcement agents in particular, through--I have got a bill, in particular through bulletproof glass or ballistic windshields? Is that something you think that could help protect the law enforcement officers that are on the front lines? Commissioner Scott. I think that can help protect the officers on the front lines, but it goes much farther than that because things have changed. So the tactical infrastructure at the border, the bulletproof vests, all of that, that helps tremendously. But we're fighting a different fight now. The reason you saw so many people surged into Los Angeles at one point and then now into Minneapolis was because we had to surge additional resources in to protect the ICE agents that were literally just going to try to make a lawful arrest. So we had to put in two teams, one to do the arrest and another one to deal with the protesters. Luckily, CBP--well, not luckily, unfortunately--CBP has had to build out this capability over the years because we had been dealing with increased protests at the border, mass incursions. So we trained our people how to do crowd control. But let's not miss the fact that we have coordinated, well- funded, and I think insurgencies or terrorist organizations, however you want to call it, literally trying to prevent legal laws from being enforced in the United States. That is a dramatic change. That's why we've had to shift. So we got to figure out how to protect our officers and agents more holistically. On social media, how do we keep them from being doxxed? When somebody goes to like did to Director Lyons, they follow his kid home and then have protests in his front yard and then put it out live on video, that needs to be a crime. I don't want to violate anybody's right to free speech, but going into your front yard and harassing your family just because you're a law enforcement officer, that should not be a protected action. Mr. Gonzales. The world has changed and we need to change with it to make sure our Federal law enforcement officers and their families are protected. My next question is for Director Lyons. Body cameras have been deployed in Minnesota. I think transparency helps regain public trust. Is there any plan to release any of the footage to the public? Mr. Lyons. One hundred percent, sir. That's one thing that I'm committed to, is full transparency. I fully welcome body cameras all across the spectrum in all of our law enforcement activities. Yes, sir, body cam footage will be released. Mr. Gonzales. I agree with you completely. Everyone assumes this body camera footage is bad footage. In so many cases, it is the exact opposite. We get a show from the officer's lens where what exactly they are dealing with on a daily basis, not just a 15-second clip we see on TikTok or whatever it may be. I am very pleased to hear the releasing of more public footage. My next question is for you, Commissioner Scott. As a Member of Congress, I have a very similar--all of us--the question is really for all of us. As a Member of Congress, what can I do to make sure what happened in Minnesota doesn't happen in my community? Commissioner Scott. Put laws in place that protect our officers and agents so they can go out and do their job confidently and know they really truly have the backing. Then I got to plug it, actually fund the programs. So when body cameras got rolled out to CBP, the technical capability, the camera got rolled out, but the funding for the personnel to support the programs and the data, that can drain basically all your other operations. So fund the entire program so that we can be transparent and, and that we can make sure America knows what we're doing because that trust is critically important. Mr. Gonzales. Thank you for that. My next question is to Director Edlow. Too many times we talk about the enforcement side, which I think is very important. We see the millions of criminal aliens that are loose in our country. We got to go out there and keep our community safe. But we need to be talking more about the legal aspect of it, the people that are doing it the right way. I was very encouraged to see 65,000 visas get released not too long ago. The question I have is what are the detail--what is the time line behind that? What is the purpose of those? Can you specifically speak to the legal visa process? Mr. Edlow. Well, you're referring to the 65,000 that were the supplemental H2Bs. Mr. Gonzales. Yes. Exactly right. Mr. Edlow. That's a--there's 60,000 or 65,000--66,000, excuse me, that go out every year at 2 times in the year. Then Congress has for many, many years given the Department the authority through the Secretary to increase that based on the needs of the country so that that--those visas were released. I don't remember exactly when the---- Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. I apologize. Again, any questions--I know I am being tight on the rules, we have to be. There are a lot of questions. We want to get through everything today. Any Members will be able to submit questions in writing and you can detail these. Thank you very much. I now recognize the gentleman from Rhode Island, Mr. Magaziner, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Magaziner. Mr. Lyons, has ICE hired anyone who is charged with a crime related to the January 6 riot here at the Capitol? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I don't have that information, but I would say no. Mr. Magaziner. Would you--could you find out and please report back? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, I'll get that. I will take that as---- Mr. Magaziner. Would you hire someone who attacked police officers here on January 6 even though they were, unfortunately, pardoned by the President? Mr. Lyons. Sir, we take assault on law enforcement very serious. We have a good strenuous vetting program, I'm sure. Mr. Magaziner. Thank you. Commissioner Scott, how many of your agents have been disciplined for excessive use of force over the past year? Commissioner Scott. I cannot comment on on-going or---- Mr. Magaziner. I am not asking you to comment on specific investigation. How many of your agents have been disciplined? I am just asking for the total of excessive force. Commissioner Scott. I'll get that number to you. I don't have it in front of me. Mr. Magaziner. All right. I sent you a letter asking that question and haven't received a response. Will you commit to sending a response to me, please? Commissioner Scott. Yes, sir. Mr. Magaziner. All right. I would like you to view this video. [Video shown.] Mr. Magaziner. Are you familiar with this incident? Commissioner Scott. Yes. Mr. Magaziner. OK. Now, this is a family of United States citizens who were out to get groceries at a Sam's Club in Chicago. When they arrived, they could see that there was a chaotic operation in the parking lot. They turned their vehicle to leave, at which point your agents sprayed pepper spray out of their vehicle and into the driver's side window of the Verazas' family vehicle. Is it proper procedure to aim pepper spray into the window of a moving vehicle? Commissioner Scott. I'm not familiar. I don't have all the details on this. It's an on-going investigation. Mr. Magaziner. I am not asking you about---- Commissioner Scott. But to answer your specific question-- -- Mr. Magaziner. Is it proper procedure? Commissioner Scott [continuing]. We try to avoid that. No is it not proper procedure. Mr. Magaziner. You try to avoid it. Because you understand it is dangerous, right? Not just for the driver, but for pedestrians, for other people who could be hit by a car if a driver is blinded, right? Commissioner Scott. I 100 percent understand that, but you're talking about intentional versus not intentional. Mr. Magaziner. Well, now, listen, I mean, in the video---- Commissioner Scott. If you've been in a vehicle in one of these situations---- Mr. Magaziner. Mr. Scott, reclaiming my time. From the video, this was clearly intentional. You know as well as I do that in any other law enforcement agency, if an officer did this, they would be put on leave, investigated, and likely disciplined. Were any of your agents ever investigated or disciplined for this incident? Commissioner Scott. I have to get back to you on this incident. Mr. Magaziner. So you don't know. Commissioner Scott. I believe it's still an on-going investigation, but we have at least 10 open cases. Mr. Magaziner. I would like to show you another video. This one is from Minneapolis. [Video shown.] Mr. Magaziner. So, as you can see, the agent sprayed pepper spray at close range directly into the face of an individual who had already been pinned to the ground by 3 other agents. There is a picture of this behind me to give you a better view. Is this proper procedure for the use of pepper spray? Commissioner Scott. I cannot comment on that because you're only showing one piece, and---- Mr. Magaziner. Has this agent been investigated? Commissioner Scott [continuing]. That subject's clearly not compliant. Mr. Magaziner. But this is not the intended use of this weapon, correct? Commissioner Scott. The intended use is to try to avoid escalating. It's to deescalate the situation and get the individual compliant. Mr. Magaziner. All right. Well, he was already pinned to the ground by 3 other agents. I think he had been deescalated. Is there any investigation into this agent for doing this? Commissioner Scott. I'll get back to you. There are several open investigations. Mr. Magaziner. All right. Listen, there has been no accountability in your agency under the Trump administration. None. Your agency has repeatedly been caught on tape using unnecessary violence against civilians. You can't even tell me if any of these agents have been investigated or disciplined. You are supposed to be making people safer and, instead, your agents are being unnecessarily violent. That is why the Trump administration has lost the trust of the American people on immigration. Understand, it is not just the actions of the agents in the field. It is the lack of accountability from the top that has caused public trust to erode. There need to be major reforms before we vote to give any of you any more funding. Your agencies need to act like other law enforcement agencies. Take off the masks, wear badge numbers, enforce discipline with real standards of conduct. But accountability starts at the top. Kristi Noem is completely unfit and should be removed from office. All of the operations that we just watched were overseen by Commander Gregory Bovino, who himself engaged in excessive use of force. He even admitted that he lied to a Federal judge when he claimed he had been hit by a rock prior to throwing tear gas--a tear gas canister at a crowd of civilians. But then after the footage came out and that turned out to be not true, he admitted that he had lied about it. Mr. Scott, what disciplinary action do you plan to take against Mr. Bovino? Commissioner Scott. I cannot comment on personnel actions on any---- Mr. Magaziner. Is there an investigation under way or being considered into Mr. Bovino? Commissioner Scott. Every allegation and every use of force is fully investigated within DHS. Mr. Magaziner. Well, please investigate him. Commissioner Scott. It goes through a review board and---- Mr. Magaziner. You need to start---- Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's---- Mr. Magaziner [continuing]. Enforcing discipline in your agency. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from Alabama, Mr. Strong, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Strong. Thank you, Chairman Garbarino, Ranking Member Thompson, and thank you to all our witnesses for being here today. Let me start with the simple facts. The border is now closed. Fentanyl poisonings are down by more than 35 percent. I thank each of you for your service to our country. I remember in April 2023 when then-Secretary Mayorkas testified before this very committee that the U.S. border was, and I quote, ``secure,'' and not open. At the same time, under his leadership, illegal alien population surged to over 11 million. They were coming from more than 160 different countries as migrants were released into our country by the millions. That is what the Biden administration, in concert with Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, did to America. They sold America out. The consequences of their failures were predictable. When the United States failed to enforce its border, the winners are not legal immigrants or American communities. It is the cartels, drug smugglers, human traffickers, and violent criminals. We didn't need new laws to stop this crisis. We needed a President willing to enforce the laws already on the books. President Trump did exactly that. Another promise made, another promise kept. Today, the number of illegal aliens being released into our country is zero. Zero. That is what it took, a President to make the hard decisions. America is better because of it. So my question is straightforward, Commissioner Scott. Was Secretary Mayorkas telling the truth when he testified before this committee that the border was secure? Commissioner Scott. Consistent with my prior testimony, no, he was not. Mr. Strong. As you stated earlier, the underlying immigration laws haven't fundamentally changed in decades. What has changed is how different administrations choose to enforce these laws, particularly during the previous administration. It was 100 percent orchestrated to allow illegal aliens to invade our country under the Biden administration. From an operational standpoint, how important is consistency and enforcement for deterrence and border control? Commissioner Scott. It's extremely important. We keep talking about immigration, but let me remind people, border security really is national security. The cartels use illegal immigration to literally overwhelm law enforcement at the border and bring in all kinds of other threats. It's the second wave that always is the most critical. The interior enforcement sent a message around the world that we're not going to just let you go. It took away the marketing ability of the cartels to get people to come to the border and overwhelm law enforcement. This all works together. It's critically important because it is national security. Mr. Strong. Thank you, Commissioner. The men and women of DHS deserve our respect and the ability to do their job effectively without mixed signals from Washington. I also want to be clear, I support the men and women who work every day to secure our borders and enforce Federal immigration laws. But lately we have seen growing strain on political rhetoric that goes beyond policy disagreement and targets the legitimacy of law enforcement itself, rhetoric that puts a target on the backs of agents doing their jobs. Acting Director Lyons, we keep hearing calls from left-wing politicians to abolish ICE. Some, including many who should know better, have denounced Federal law enforcement as secret police. How would you respond to these reckless attacks? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I can speak from personal experience, having served multiple administrations, that the men and women of ICE are out there every day doing the law as it's written. Mr. Strong. What are the consequences of not enforcing Federal immigration laws? Mr. Lyons. Sir, if you look at what ICE has done, if you look at the amount of, as I said earlier, the amount of known and suspected terrorists that we removed from the country, we arrested 1,477 this year and removed 1,480. Just that impact alone, along with the 7,800 gang members, makes a significant impact on public safety and national security. Mr. Strong. Thank you. Turning to you, Director Edlow, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service plays a role in administering legal immigration and protecting the integrity of the system. When immigration enforcement is undermined or treated as illegitimate, how does that affect USCIS's ability to manage lawful pathways, prevent fraud, and maintain public confidence in the legal immigration process? Mr. Edlow. It makes it absolutely impossible, Congressman. That's why we've done everything we can to administer that system now and to not cut corners that were previously cut during the last administration. Mr. Strong. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize a gentleman from New York, Mr. Goldman, 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Goldman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Lyons, what guidance have you given to your agents about asking people walking on the streets of America to show proof of citizenship? Mr. Lyons. Sir, as I stated earlier, the men and women of ICE Deportation Office, special agents, we conduct targeted, intelligence-driven operation. We don't walk around on the streets asking people about their American citizenship. Mr. Goldman. Really? So all of those individual American citizens who have been randomly asked are lying? Is that what you are saying? Mr. Lyons. Sir, if the men and women of ICE are conducting an investigation, whether it be for Title 8 immigration enforcement or Title 18 criminal enforcement, they'll ask someone their nationality. Mr. Goldman. Right, but that is not targeted because they are asking all sorts of American citizens, including off-duty law enforcement. Now, have you directed at any point your agents, under the Supreme Court's racial profiling ruling, to only stop nonwhite people and those who look like immigrants to ask for their citizenship papers? Mr. Lyons. No, sir, I haven't. Mr. Goldman. Now, you are aware, of course, and there is well-documented--numerous well-documented instances of people, American citizens being asked to show and prove their citizenship. Do you know what other regimes in the 20th Century required similar proof of citizenship? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Goldman. What? Mr. Lyons. Sir, there's very--various nefarious regimes that did that. Mr. Goldman. Is Nazi Germany one? Mr. Lyons. Yes, but I---- Mr. Goldman. Is the Soviet Union one? Mr. Lyons. I honestly---- Mr. Goldman. Sir, I am asking the questions. Is the Soviet Union one? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, but I totally--this is the wrong type of question you can ask me. Mr. Goldman. No, I will tell you what the wrong type of thing occurs. Mr. Lyons. But actually, sir, it's the Holocaust Museum has got---- Mr. Goldman. Reclaiming my time, sir. Reclaiming my time, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Lyons [continuing]. Not the men and women of ICE that are out there doing it every day. So to say it to men and women of ICE they're Gestapo---- Mr. Goldman. Mr. Chairman, I am reclaiming my time. I would like my time back, please. Mr. Lyons [continuing]. It's wrong. Mr. Goldman. Please give me another 15 seconds because he was unnecessarily speaking. You said in your opening statement that references to ICE as the Gestapo or the secret police encourages threats against ICE agents. Mr. Lyons. One hundred percent. Mr. Goldman. The problem is you have it backward, sir. People are simply making valid observations about your tactics, which are un-American and outright fascist. So I have a simple suggestion. If you don't want to be called a fascist regime or secret police, then stop acting like one. But people are simply just observing what they are seeing. That is why people are making those comments. Now, I was a prosecutor for 10 years. Prosecuted mob bosses, organized crime, violent criminals, the actual worst of the worst. Not a single criminal law enforcement agent that I worked with wore a mask to conceal their identity. But your Department, which is a civil law enforcement agency, is defending the use of masks by your agents because of a so- called rise in threats and assaults against your officer. Now, you said in your opening testimony that assaults against ICE officers are up by more than 1,400 percent, which is now even more than the 1,300 percent that your gaslighting spokesperson Tricia from Ohio has recently been citing. But here is the problem. There are 2 separate, very detailed, very thorough investigative reports based on your own data that both conclude that assaults against ICE officers are up about 25 percent, which is far less, of course, than you assert and far less than you would expect from an agency that has more than doubled its hiring and has an even greater increase in arrests. Now, why is that a problem, Mr. Lyons? It is a problem because the explanation that your agents are wearing masks because of fear of assaults or doxing is outright bogus. You and your untrained, unqualified, unvetted, unidentified agents are intentionally terrorizing our cities and communities all over this country to avoid accountability for their excessive force and their lawless actions. That is why you are wearing masks, so no one can hold you accountable. You know that the FBI is not going to because notwithstanding all of the investigations all of you say are going on, the Department of Justice and the FBI has stated they are not investigating those 2 murders. This is not the America that I know and love. This is not the America my immigrants came to. It is long past time that you rein in your out-of-control agency and start following the law and the Constitution. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from Arizona, Mr. Crane, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Crane. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is interesting being in this hearing today, you know, where my Democrat colleagues continue to demonize ICE and Homeland Security. I think history and context are very important here. It is not lost on most of the American public that my Democrat colleagues actually caused this entire crisis with their open-border policies that they all voted for, letting in close to 15 million illegal aliens. I also want to go through real quick some numbers of ICE deportations with other Presidents who I believe both you, Mr. Scott, and you, Mr. Lyons, have worked for. Under President Clinton, 12 million illegal aliens were deported and removed from this country, some voluntary, some departures; key, no riots. Under President Bush, 2 million, no riots. Obama, who was often referred to as the Deporter-in-Chief, 5 million, including returns, no riots. President Trump in his first term, 2 million deported, no riots. President Biden, 4 million, including expulsions varying by estimates, no riots. President Trump again this year, 625,000 with 2 million voluntary leaving through CBP Home app. Mr. Scott, can you explain why these other Presidents that you work for, both Democrat and Republican, have deported far more people than this President and we have seen no riots? Commissioner Scott. I would say it has a lot to do about rhetoric and misleading the American public about what's really going on and how important border security really is to this Nation. Mr. Crane. Let's talk also about my Democrat colleagues and something they also supported, and that is these sanctuary cities. I think that is very important. I don't think a lot of Americans really understand these sanctuary cities. Mr. Scott, Mr. Lyons, is it true that you would rather send your officers into a jail to get some of these illegal alien criminals? Is it safer for your agents and also the illegal alien criminal if your officers are able to go into a jail instead of having to go out and find them on the street? Mr. Lyons, I will start with you. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. It would be. You wouldn't see the amount of law enforcement officers involved in immigration operations. Mr. Crane. Right. How about you, Mr. Scott? Commissioner Scott. I 100 percent agree with the director. More--just as importantly, it would allow me to put more agents back on the border to prevent people from getting in here in the first place. Mr. Crane. Let's also talk about these riots. Mr. Scott, Mr. Lyons, do you guys remember any riots, you know, when--for some of these victims that were assaulted and victimized by illegal alien criminals, like Nate Baker, Laken Riley, Fletcher Harris, Skyler Provenza, Ivory Smith? I have got a whole list of them. Do you remember any riots from our Democrats or their constituents when any of these American citizens were victimized by illegal alien criminals? Commissioner Scott. No, sir. Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Crane. Why do you think that is? Because that is the question that I get asked all the time. Congressman, why do the Democrats care more about illegal alien criminals than they care about these American citizens? Many of them who are young, have their entire lives ahead of them, didn't show up to a protest, right, to obstruct Federal law enforcement. They are just going about their daily lives and they get victimized by people who aren't supposed to be here. Why do you think they don't care about American citizens? Commissioner Scott. I cannot speculate, but when I look at the chaos that it creates and the corrosive nature that it creates, I go beyond the politics of the United States and I look at our nation-state adversaries like Iran, Russia, and China, and their influence on social media to keep this negative discourse going. I think this is a much bigger issue than we're actually admitting that it is in here. Mr. Crane. I want to tie this together to something that is very pertinent that is going to happen this week here in Congress where the American people are going to see the bookend of what is going on. We are going to attempt to pass the Save America Act, OK, which requires documentary proof of U.S. citizenship to register to vote. It imposes photo ID requirements to vote and it penalizes officials who do not enforce these requirements. You won't see most of these folks over here on the other side that are demonizing you guys right now, you will not see them support it. So they let millions and millions of illegal aliens into the country. They set up these sanctuary cities so you can't go enforce these Federal laws that are on the books that Congress has passed. Now they won't vote to stop these illegals from voting in our elections. If the American people don't understand what this whole thing is about, it is about one word, and it always has been, and that is power. They want power. They need these illegals to vote in our elections. That is why they don't care about the fraud either because they need those votes as well. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentlelady from Illinois, Mrs. Ramirez, for 5 minutes of questions. Mrs. Ramirez. Thank you, Chairman. My mother, a Guatemalan immigrant and an American, taught me that I have the responsibility to look evil in the eye and to fight it back. Mr. Lyons, Mr. Scott, Mr. Edlow, you have used your power to perpetrate great evil. It is about time you answer this committee for the lawlessness that you have empowered and defended in your testimony. Mr. Lyons, I want to start with you and I want to talk about ICE. Because under your leadership, ICE has shot and killed Silverio Villegas Gonzalez and Renee Good, violated nearly 100 court orders in January alone. You have used banned choke holds in more than 40 cases, engaged in warrantless arrests despite of a consent decree, and you used children as bait to put 3,800 children in detention. You created traps for people at immigration court who are following the law and doing it the legal way. You broke the law by entering to people's homes without a judicial warrant in violation of the Fourth Amendment. Now, let's talk about you, Mr. Scott, and CBP next. Under your leadership, CBP has attempted to execute Marimar Martinez, shooting her 5 times and not releasing the footage that you should release so that we can see the evidence; murdered Alex Pretti; used chemical agents dozens of times in Chicago after a judge ordered you to stop; conducted warrantless surveillance and racial profiling; and acted with total disrespect and disregard for the law while engaging in roving patrols, plate switching, dangerous traffic maneuvers, and observer intimidation. Again, criminals act with that total disregard for the law and we continue to see it. You would both have us talk about respect for your mission and your agents, but your agencies are unaccountable paramilitary forces. I have just as much respect for you as I do for the last white man who put on masks to terrorize communities of color. I have no respect for the inheritors of the Klan hood and the slave patrol. Those activities were immoral then and criminal, and so are yours. That brings me to you, Mr. Edlow, and USCIS. Truly, USCIS is the most disappointing part of this whole panel for me. Mr. Edlow, let me ask you a question. Is USCIS's mission to uphold America's promise as a nation of welcome and possibility with fairness, integrity, and respect for all we serve? Yes or no. Is that the mission? Mr. Edlow. Congresswoman, the mission is to administer the lawful immigration---- Mrs. Ramirez. So let me move on. So it is not for the possibility of fairness, integrity, and respect. I get that. I want to tell you about Mr.--about Steven, my constituent, Mr. Edlow. Steven is a 14-year-old with autism who is seeking asylum. This child has spent 60 days in detention center after he was detained with his dad and at a check-in. Let me ask you this. What kind of agency would strip asylum protections from children, even those with pending asylum claims, and deport minors without due process? You don't have to answer that. It is your agency, Mr. Edlow. You are doing that to Steven, my constituent, an eighth grader. You have abandoned the mission and allowed USCIS to become a tool in DHS's abusive enforcement apparatus, Mr. Edlow. It is shameful to see what USCIS has become. As I have said before, DHS, ICE, and CBP, they are not really rogue. Congress designed DHS to violate our rights under the pretense of securing our safety. I am going to say it loud and clear, and I am proud to stand by what I say. DHS cannot be reformed. It must be dismantled and something new must take its place. Because if we let DHS persist, it will continue to be a weapon that can be pointed at anyone the Government considers the public enemy. Let me tell you, fascism always requires a public enemy. But the power of the people is stronger than the weapons they would wield against us. So, Mr. Lyons, Mr. Scott, Mr. Edlow, you have weaponized the Government. You have supported a fascist enterprise at the expense of our Constitutional rights. You have violated the law. But let me remind you, you will not always be in power. One day you will be held accountable for your role in this dark moment in America, in our Nation's history. I guarantee it. With that, Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady yields back. As I said, the issues we are debating here are important ones that Members feel deeply about. While vigorous disagreement is part of the legislative process, Members are reminded that we must adhere to established standards of decorum and debate. Witnesses are here today voluntarily. I will continue to remind Members that while oversight is important, aggressively attacking witnesses personally is inappropriate and not in keeping with the best traditions of our committee. I now recognize the gentleman from Oklahoma, Mr. Brecheen, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Brecheen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses. I want to start with a display over my shoulders. This is something that is not specific only to Oklahoma. This is something that every Member of this committee, if you will go to the DHS website, every constituent of every Member of Congress, if you're curious of really the dark days, I want you to go to the DHS website and I want you to look at those not far from where you live, Moms and Dads. The arrest of illegal aliens who are preying on minors. Just because of a really intentional act by Kate Bryan on my staff to go a couple of weeks ago and look just in eastern Oklahoma, on the right side of me here, just in eastern Oklahoma. I represent almost all the entirety of eastern Oklahoma. These are just the individuals, heinous acts to include those with children. Yet I am going to read you in the wider to my left over here, what is happening in the State of Oklahoma. This person was picked up. Angel Nick, sexual exploitation of a minor. Renton Andrew, molestation of a minor. Chan Truding, child fondling. Feliciano Garcia, enticement of a minor. Cayetano Lopez, statutory rape. Erasmo Avila, rape and lewd acts with a minor. So for everyone who is in short-term memory as the way things operate in the court of public opinion, everyone is looking and you are forgetting the conversations you were having 2 and 3 years ago. If you had teenage kiddos wanting to go outside of your home and you knew that they were going to go to Dallas, Texas, or some city and you knew that you had to have a conversation with them with what was happening, the 15 million you knew were in the country illegally, that you had no idea what they would be doing, who would they be preying upon. Moms and Dads, don't you feel just a little bit safer if we are going to be gut-level honest? That is the realization of what the generational opportunity this administration has afforded this country. It is the ability to feel safe over the madness of opening the border for that 4-year period that allowed 15 million people you don't know where they came from, you don't know their background, you don't know their history. This that is occurring right now is designed to make sure we have law and order in this country. If you do not have law and order, you don't have prosperity. So to all those who are second-guessing the reactionary moments, to the law enforcement who have to respond in real time, the quarterback whose questions Monday--is questioned Monday morning because he is facing the 300-pound defensive lineman, it is easy to do that. But law enforcement walks out of their home every day and is faced with life-or-death questions. We have to understand they are the ones who are affording us the opportunity for our children to feel safe against these that are in your back yard. It is not just in the north, it is not just in Minneapolis, it is not just in Minnesota. They are in every State in the country. Go to the Department of Homeland Security website and Google your area and look at who is being picked up in your backyard. That is how we recenter this conversation to truth. I want your children protected. I am grateful for this President who wants your children protected, and an administration. The same playbook is happening now to create chaos and take your eye off the real goal, which is to secure our communities to get back to a place of safety. Mr. Lyons, can you describe because of not allowing these people to stay in jails, these sanctuary cities are letting them go, thousands released from jail because they will not cooperate with ICE, and when ICE tries to execute a detainer, ask him to hold a criminal illegal alien for potential deportation, how is this compared with other nonsanctuary city regions in the country? Mr. Lyons. Sir, it's night and day. With the jurisdictions that we do have cooperation, we're able to take that individual in a safe, secure environment. Not only is it a safe, secure environment for the officers and agents, but it's also for the individual and the community because we only need 1 to 2 officers to make that arrest. Where now we're historically 5 or 6, we need up to 15. Mr. Brecheen. From what you have seen in terms of protests in Minnesota and elsewhere, do you get the sense these agitators are trying to provoke your agents into reactions? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Brecheen. Can you expound upon that? Mr. Lyons. We've seen multiple times and, unfortunately, we saw, like the shooting in Dallas, where agitated groups use apps to identify the location of ICE officers, sometimes prior to even the law enforcement action begins, and sometimes using those apps put the officers and as well as other Federal agencies and local agencies with them in danger because it exposes the fact of our law enforcement operation is happening. Mr. Brecheen. Mr. Scott, can you describe how the 300,000 children, the UACs, unaccompanied minors, that we are trying to find them, how these protests are stopping us from being able to recover those? Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman will respond in writing to that question. I now recognize the gentleman from New York, Mr. Kennedy, for 5 minutes. Mr. Kennedy. Thank you. Mr. Lyons, your written testimony today does not make one single mention of Renee Nicole Good or Alex Pretti. Not one. Two American citizens have been murdered at the hands of your agency, and you have deliberately chosen under oath before Congress to ignore these tragedies. So today, in my 5 minutes, I look forward to getting the American people some answers and some accountability that I believe they deserve. Mr. Lyons, I have some simple yes-or-no questions. Do you believe the U.S. Constitution provides due process for everyone in this country? Mr. Lyons. Yes. Mr. Kennedy. Do you believe American citizens have the right to protest freely without being assaulted or killed by our Government? Mr. Lyons. Yes. Mr. Kennedy. Do you believe there should be an independent investigation when an innocent person is killed by a law enforcement agency in this country? Mr. Lyons. Yes. Mr. Kennedy. Do you believe your agency has a legal obligation to follow court orders? Mr. Lyons. Yes. Mr. Kennedy. Well, Mr. Lyons, you have a very strange way of showing it with a Federal judge finding that your agency is in violation of 96 orders in 1 month alone, and that is just Minneapolis, Minnesota. This administration and the agencies represented before us have shown a complete and utter disregard for the law and the Constitution. Renee Nicole Good and Alex Pretti, both American citizens, both dead at the hands of Federal agents. Alex Pretti was a VA ICU nurse who dedicated his life to healing people, healing veterans. I worked as an occupational therapist for over a decade. In that video that we have all seen, it was Alex Pretti who was doing what health care workers do, what nurses do. They help people, help people who are hurting, help people who are in trouble, in this case helping a fellow peaceful protester who was shoved to the ground right before your agents shot him 10 times. We are now learning that FBI Director Kash Patel stopped the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota from investigating the death of Ms. Good because of fear that an investigation would contradict President Trump's falsehoods, that she violently, willfully, and viciously ran down an agent. Six Federal prosecutors resigned rather than participate in a cover-up. Kristi Noem, Stephen Miller, and you, Mr. Lyons, have appointed yourselves judge, jury, and executioner, allowing American citizens to be gunned down in our streets with impunity. We all know the President is a liar. He sold snake oil his entire life. But he can't tell us and the American people that we did not see with our own eyes what we saw in that video: two Americans shot dead in cold blood. The American people aren't stupid like he thinks we are. The fact that our Government murders American citizens, lies about it, and then refuses to investigate or seek justice is beyond abhorrent. It is un- American. Mr. Lyons, in America, we shouldn't have secret police. We shouldn't have masked Government agents executing citizens in the streets. The Constitution does not give your agency the right to hide their faces while they kill Americans. Will you commit, yes or no, to immediately unmasking every agent conducting immigration enforcement and requiring them to wear standard uniforms with identifiable badges? Mr. Lyons. No. Mr. Kennedy. Well, that is a sad response. Your answer is completely unacceptable. People who are proud of what they do aren't hiding their identity. We are a Nation of laws. You, your boss, Secretary Noem, and Donald Trump are not above the law. The American people are angry, and they are demanding accountability and justice from those giving the orders. Mr. Lyons, yes or no, do you believe that Secretary Noem should resign? Mr. Lyons. I'm not going to comment on that, sir. Mr. Kennedy. So you are going to look the families of Renee Nicole Good and Alex Pretti in the eye and tell them Secretary Noem should keep her job after their loved ones were killed? Mr. Lyons. Sir, the loss of any life is unacceptable. The heart--my heart, prayers, and thoughts go out to anyone who-- tragically losing his life, especially a child, since I've suffered personal loss in my life, but I'm not going to comment on on-going investigation. Mr. Kennedy. Well, Mr. Lyons, the American people are watching. Your unwillingness to demand accountability from your own leadership speaks volumes. Two American citizens are dead. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time is expired. Mr. Kennedy. The American people deserve accountability. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time is expired. It is a--Members are reminded that we must adhere to established standards of decorum and debate. It is a clear violation of the rules of the House to make statements that might be personally offensive to the President or the Vice President of the United States. I now recognize the gentlelady from South Carolina, Mrs. Biggs, for 5 minutes of questions. Mrs. Biggs. Thank you, Chairman Garbarino, and thank you to our witnesses. A big thank you for what you do each and every day to secure our border and to carry out the will of the American people. You know, this Trump administration and the CBP and ICE, they have done a stellar job of securing our border. We can just look at the numbers. They tell the facts. Crossings are down from a high of over 300,000 a month under President Biden to around 10,000 a month under President Trump. However, the lax border policies of the Democrats have flooded our country with tens of millions of illegal immigrants. This invasion was facilitated by sanctuary cities. Most cities will hand over criminal aliens with a deportation order to ICE. But sanctuary cities refuse to do so, often releasing them back into the public around our communities, our children, and making it unsafe. Cities like Minneapolis pick and choose which laws they want to enforce. By doing that, they place our Federal law enforcement in danger, forcing ICE agents to make arrests out in public, something that could be avoided if sanctuary cities simply cooperated with the Federal law. At the same time, radical leftists have stirred hysteria over routine immigration enforcement, calling immigration officers the secret police and even the Gestapo. Let me be very clear. This rhetoric has consequences. Between 2024 and 2025, we saw a more than 16,000 percent increase in threats of assault against immigration officers and over 8,000 percent spike in death threats targeting those who enforce our laws. In Minnesota alone, there have been over 60 threats and 20 assaults to ICE officers. Just think about that, if you were going to work every day and had to deal with that. Sanctuary cities, they choose criminals over citizens. My bill, the Mobilizing Against Sanctuary Cities Act, would cut off every single Federal dollar to any city that helps illegals instead of law enforcement. Mr. Lyons, my question is to you. Why should taxpayers fund far-left politicians who put your agents at risk? Mr. Lyons. Ma'am, unfortunately, what we've seen over and over is just the fact that there's so much rhetoric out there against the work the men and women of ICE have done. Again, going back on my career, this is my second decade, multiple administrations, and it's never been like this. The actual public safety impact that the men and women of ICE do every day is significant, and it should still be true for all 50 States. Mrs. Biggs. Thank you. So I want to take it a little closer to home. What is happening in my district, the Third District of South Carolina, it should alarm every single individual. These are real crimes committed by individuals illegally in our country, right here in our communities, confirmed by the Department of Homeland Security. We heard a little bit from my colleagues earlier. So let me just give you a few of the worst. Vehicular homicide, child cruelty and indecent exposure, armed robbery, assaulting a police officer with a weapon, and making terrorist threats, and I could go on and on. We are also seeing convictions for drug trafficking, burglary, forgery, repeated illegal reentry, and more and more. This is what I consider chaos. It is the direct result of open-border policies that put American lives at risk. But amid all of this, we are seeing true heroes step up. Our Federal immigration officers are on the front lines of securing safety and prosperity for us and for our children. They have been given a difficult task, but they are up to the job and certainly meeting the demands. We stand behind our immigration officers and their historic mission to restore the rule of law and to the United States. Right here at home, our local law enforcement is rising to meet the challenge, and I am very grateful to them. So just look at Anderson County Sheriff's Department, which you will see in the photo behind me, which recently seized 180 pounds of cocaine. That is 180 pounds of deadly drugs that will never reach our streets, thanks to the courage and commitment. So I just want to say thank you, and I am grateful for the job that you do. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady yields back. I now recognize the gentlelady from New Jersey, Mrs. McIver, for 5 minutes of questions. Mrs. McIver. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Ranking Member. Mr. Lyons, as the senior official lead in ICE enforcement, much of today's scrutiny falls on you, and it should. You have seen repeatedly--we have seen repeatedly that Republicans, Trump administration, its DHS, and your agency will do absolutely anything to avoid answering for your actions. When I showed up to inspect Delaney Hall, a private prison that you contract with, ICE tried not to give us an oversight tour. Then instead of taking accountability for ICE's attempts to keep us from seeing this facility's conditions, to know if people's basic rights were being upheld, this administration is doing all they can to try to put me in prison for 17 years. When ICE shot and killed Renee Good, Kristi Noem called her a domestic terrorist. When Alex Pretti, you all tried to tell us he was threatening officers with a gun, but all we saw was a phone. This administration's clear lies fell apart not because someone had a come-to-Jesus moment, but because we saw these murders from every angle. You are only here because public outrage has become so unavoidable. You are here, Mr. Lyons, because white people are getting shot in the face and chest when the cameras are rolling. Because now my Republican colleagues care about optics. But when Keith Porter, Jr., a Black American citizen, a son, a father, and a man loved by many, was killed by an off-duty ICE agent on New Year's Eve, there were no hearings. So this is for him today. In my district, Jean Wilson Brutus, a Haitian immigrant, a beloved family man, died within 24 hours of being in ICE custody. He is just one of more than 30 people who have died in ICE custody last year. This is for all of them, every human being your rogue, out-of-control agency has hurt, hunted down, imprisoned, killed, and continue to hold hostage even after they have agreed to be deported. We know this administration doesn't care about protecting people or sparing lives. We all see so plainly what you are doing, what you have been doing to Black and Brown folks, immigrants, people silenced in the shadows, now in broad daylight to people peacefully rejecting your cruel agenda in the streets, which is their right to do. This is the despicable but predictable result of an agency that laughs at oversight, receives billions to deploy lethal force on our neighborhoods, and seems to believe that they are above the law and should be without accountability. This administration believes it can act first, explain later, or hell, never, never explained at all, as we see here today. You all seem to think you are the highest power who decides which people deserve dignity, protection, and due process. But you are wrong. We are here for answers. We are here for accountability. We are here because people are dying. Let me repeat that. People are dying. You don't seem to care. So, Mr. Lyons, I have heard my colleagues ask many questions over and over again, and you cannot answer them. So let me ask you some questions that you may be able to answer. Mr. Lyons, do you consider yourself a religious man? Mr. Lyons. Yes, ma'am. Mrs. McIver. Oh, yes. OK. Well, how do you think Judgment Day will work for you with so much blood on your hands? Mr. Lyons. I'm not going to entertain that question. Mrs. McIver. Oh, OK. Of course not. Do you think you're going to hell, Mr. Lyons? Mr. Lyons. I'm not going to entertain---- Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady---- Mrs. McIver. Of course not. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady---- Mrs. McIver. How many Government---- Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady will suspend. The gentlelady will suspend. Mrs. McIver. Chairman---- Chairman Garbarino. As I--the gentlelady will suspend. As I said, the issues we are debating here are important to ones that Members feel deeply about. Mrs. McIver. Thank you, Chairman. Chairman Garbarino. While vigorous disagreement is part of the legislative process, Members are reminded that we must adhere to established standards of decorum and debate. The witnesses are here voluntarily. I will continue to remind Members that while oversight is important, aggressively attacking those witnesses personally is inappropriate and not in keeping with the traditions of our committee. Mrs. McIver. Mr. Chairman, I am just asking a question. You guys are always talking about religion here and the Bible. I mean, it is OK for me to ask a question, right? But let me continue on. I got your note. Chairman Garbarino. All right. The gentlelady may resume. Mrs. McIver. Thank you so much. Let me get back to my questioning, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, I appreciate you. How many Government agencies, Mr. Lyons, are you aware of that routinely kill American citizens and still get funding? Mr. Lyons. Ma'am, I'm not going to entertain that. Mrs. McIver. Of course you're not. Mr. Lyons. I much rather talk about the criminal---- Mrs. McIver. Exactly. Exactly. Mr. Lyons [continuing]. Aliens in your district than talk about that. Mrs. McIver. Once again, questions that you cannot answer. That is exactly why, Mr. Chairman, and to this committee, to my colleagues and to my colleagues across the aisle, this is exactly why we should not be funding this agency. The people are watching you. They are watching you. This is why we need to abolish ICE. With that, I yield back. Thank you kindly. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Colorado, Mr. Evans, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Evans. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member, for this important hearing. This past year has been historic for national security, thanks to the joint work between the agencies present today and our Republican colleagues. The Big Beautiful Bill unlocked billions of dollars to finally secure the border and deliver much-needed support for law enforcement officials who keep us safe every day, slashing things like the scourge of overdose deaths that claimed approximately 400,000 lives under the previous administration. This is despite increasing violence against Federal officers, which has been inspired by fear- mongering from the Democrats. As a soldier for 12 years, as a cop for 10 years, and as the only Latino in Colorado's delegation, it has been my long- standing position that with a secure border, we must use all available resources to target the worst of the worst, violent offenders like murderers and rapists, and so-called nonviolent, like drug dealers and thieves and child porn producers. Get the gangsters, not the grandmas. Director Lyons, is ICE's priority the apprehension and removal of criminal noncitizens rather than the broader population of illegally present individuals? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. ICE has continued focus is on the criminal aliens that are in our neighborhoods. Mr. Evans. Thank you. Unfortunately, Democrats in my State in Colorado champion soft-on-crime sanctuary policies at the State level and in cities like Denver, which borders my district. These policies not only impede Federal investigations that target cartels, gangbangers, entities like Tren de Aragua, MS-13, the Sinaloa Cartel, but they also endanger our communities by releasing dangerous criminals back into the streets who continue to traffic drugs, steal cars, intimidate families, and recruit children. In fact, fentanyl overdose rates in Denver are going up in 2025. It is common sense that when local or State police arrest an individual for a crime, those officers should be able to obtain basic information about the arrestee. Those State and local officers should then be allowed to share information with Federal law enforcement to communicate threats, honor detainer requests, and work together to ensure national security and public safety. So, Director Lyons, can you please explain how ICE works around sanctuary policies to go after the worst of the worst? Do these sanctuary policies that release criminals back into the community increase or decrease ICE's presence in the community and the temperature of the interactions that ICE has with the community? Mr. Lyons. Sir, when we deal with sanctuary jurisdictions, we do have to have more law enforcement officers on the street. Like I said earlier in my testimony, we'd much rather have the chance to take a aggravated felon, repeat DUI offender into custody at a prison, local jail, or some type of lock-up environment where it's safer for my officers and for not only the individual, but that community as well. Then given the opportunity to take that person into custody before that person can reoffend. Unfortunately, as a field office director, when I ran the Boston field office, we saw too many times that we placed a detainer on a sexual assault individual, who just went out later, after the detainer was dropped, to rape again. That is why we need cooperation at all levels, especially local and State. Mr. Evans. Thank you. Director Lyons, my district, 40 percent Hispanic. It is full of successful business owners and strong immigrant families. Unfortunately, my colleagues across the aisle are fanning the flames of fear for their own political gain in my Hispanic communities, scaring people over events that haven't happened in my district. So I would like for you, for just a brief moment, to speak directly to my constituents who are legally present in the United States, not criminals, but who are fearful of being searched or detained via immigration efforts. Should they fear ICE? What policies does ICE have to prevent the seizure of people with legal status? Mr. Lyons. Sir, ICE officers and special agents are trained in the Immigration Nationality Act. So anyone that is here legally or lawfully or a U.S. citizen should not be concerned about being deported or detained. Unfortunately, many times there are individuals that are with criminal illegal aliens. Sir, as you being a former law enforcement officer, you know, you arrive on a scene, you ID everyone in that case. If, you know, if we're looking for an individual and someone is here present in the country illegally, then we're going to take action. We're not going to turn a blind eye no more. But someone that's in the country lawfully should not feel scared to walk down the street, drive---- Mr. Evans. Thank you. Sorry, sorry, I got 23 seconds left. I have one thing that I want to ask. As a cop, if I had an arrest warrant, and there is a difference between arrest warrants and search warrants, if I had an arrest warrant for an individual and I thought they were in the house, or if I was assisting Social Services with a child removal, I still had to have an arrest warrant to go in the house. So I have many questions about the memo saying that you don't need a warrant to go into the house. Will you commit with me at a later date to discuss this? Mr. Lyons. One hundred percent, sir. I look forward to sitting down and discussing that. Mr. Evans. Yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentlelady from Texas, Ms. Johnson, for 5 minutes of questions. Ms. Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would like to, Mr. Lyons, I wanted to just follow up on a statement that you just made, which is that if you are here legally and lawfully, you should not worry. I think the problem is there are many, many immigrants that are here legally and lawfully that are very worried because they have been snatched off the streets, they have had their face beat in by ICE agents, they have been yanked out of their car, they have been driven around and harassed. So that is, I think at the end of the day, you know, the key of the crux here, which is that, unfortunately, there is not just this focus on criminals and that people who are here in legal status. For example, I have an example of this that I would like to highlight for you. Back in October, Maher Tarabishi, a North Texas resident, who was allowed to be in this country legally and was under a supervision order to check in on an annual basis since 2008, and did that because he had an adult disabled son. He was here working as an IT consultant and was here in the legal process to take care of his adult legal son. He went to check into his appointment and it so happened to be at the time that the Dallas ICE office was closed due to the shooting and so he was not able to check in. When he went back to check in, he was immediately snatched up and detained because he missed his appointment. That was unavoidable because the office was closed. He told everyone he was in legal status. He had been here since 2008, and he had an adult disabled son that would likely pass away if he was not released. He was not released. His son died. Then to complicate it, he was not allowed to go and attend the funeral and he is still in detention in the Bluebonnet facility in Texas. He is not a criminal. He has no criminal history. He was here legally. That is an unacceptable outcome. I would like to know if you are willing to review his case and help us get his release, because he should not be in the Bluebonnet detention facility under these facts. Mr. Lyons. Yes, ma'am. I'm committed to reviewing that case for you. Ms. Johnson. I appreciate that. The other issue that I am really very concerned about is these warrantless entries into people's homes. It is a problem that is of epic proportion. There was just recently, yesterday, circulation, a Latino family, ICE just broke into their home without a warrant. There was an example where they arrested a man in his pajamas, who had every right to be here as a U.S. citizen, but wrongfully snatched out in the freezing cold without a warrant to do so. The problem that we are having. Nobody wants to see attacks on ICE agents, sir. But this is something I have brought up in this committee time and time again, which is, unfortunately, under your leadership and under Secretary Noem's leadership, this rogue brutality that ICE agents are inflicting upon the people of this country is not being reined in. It is not being--the agents who are abusing their power are not being held accountable. I am sure that there are many, many fine agents who are doing everything they can to exercise their duty lawfully. But the problem is there are agents who are not. The power that they have has gone to their head. They use that power unconstitutionally, in violation of many people's direct Constitutional rights. What you are seeing in this country is the fact that your agency--you are not--it is not stopping. Rather than saying, yes, we are going to take steps to keep these people who are abusing their power and who are terrorizing citizens of this country wrongfully, that we are going to hold them account, rather than--that is what we want to see. You are doubling down on that we are only going after criminals, which is, in your own comments, you said that you had 397--I think that is right, 379,000 arrests, but only 8,700 of them were suspected gang members or known suspected terrorists. That is 2 percent. The problem is we can't terrorize 98 percent of the people in this country that have been wrongfully detained for 2 percent. That is not how the system works, and that is not OK. So we have to do a better job. So what procedures are you putting in place to hold agents accountable who clearly have a hot trigger and who clearly abuse their authority because someone has a phone and a whistle? Mr. Lyons. Ma'am, ICE does have the Office of Professional Responsibility. It's a robust internal investigation agency that does investigate allegations of special agent or deportation officer misconduct. We do take everyone seriously, and we do investigate those. Ms. Johnson. Well, those are not being publicly reported. So that is where there is a huge breach of the public trust because there does not appear to be any accountability, sir. Thank you. I will yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. Mackenzie, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Mackenzie. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate all of our testifiers being here today. Before I begin, I would like to thank all of our members of law enforcement across the country who work every day to keep our communities safe and also to their families that sacrifice. We know that it is a challenging job, and the environment is made particularly challenging by those who want to oppose our law enforcement from carrying out their lawful duties to keep everybody in our country and our community safe. As was discussed earlier, there are a couple areas, though, where I think it is appropriate to discuss potential reforms and the way that we can improve our Government operations. DHS guidance indicates that ICE does not arrest or detain U.S. citizens. On the other hand, social media is full of reports and accusations that this is occurring. As you know, any accusation that an American citizen's rights are violated is very serious. Can you clarify, Mr. Lyons, whether this is something that it occurs, and what are the circumstances where a U.S. citizen might be detained and what steps does ICE take to prevent mistakes? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, I appreciate the question. Well, unfortunately, there's a misnomer that ICE is just a civil enforcement agency, and that's completely wrong. ICE enforces over 400 criminal statutes as well. Special agents, especially with the Homeland Security Investigations, they're consistently out there doing human trafficking cases, drug cases, terrorism cases. We do encounter U.S. citizens, and those who do commit Federal crimes are arrested. But under Title 8, no U.S. citizen is subject to civil immigration enforcement, and that just doesn't happen. There are multiple safeguards in that way. If a U.S. citizen is detained in the course of an immigration investigation, they're quickly released. We don't take action on American citizens. Mr. Mackenzie. If it does occur where a U.S. citizen is detained during the course of another investigation, how is that documented and conveyed to the public about the fact that this did occur and what the circumstances around that were? Mr. Lyons. So, sir, if you say it is a separate investigation, if it comes to a criminal case, obviously a lot of those are under seal or on-going investigations. We won't expose that. But we're transparent in the case when it comes to any U.S. citizens that's detained in any law enforcement operations that's subsequently arrested. Mr. Mackenzie. I appreciate that. I think greater transparency could be beneficial for both the American public and everybody involved here if we clearly articulate what occurred in many of these instances. I have seen it myself when I am looking into local issues in our community. There are oftentimes two sides to the story. When it is actually conveyed what did occur and why it occurred, there is a greater understanding in our local community of the law enforcement activities that occurred. The second thing I would like to hit on is jurisdictions which are sometimes referred to sanctuary cities. Not a clear definition, as we all know, but local authorities in our community, we have Northampton County which does not honor ICE detainer requests for 48 hours and properly convey to ICE and law enforcement about the release of that individual, when that may occur, or even during that detainer period allow ICE to come onto their property to make an arrest in a secure facility. Obviously, that leaves our community in a vulnerable position. In our case, members of Tren de Aragua, domestic abusers have been released onto the street and ICE had to stake out that location, making the arrests in an unsecure way out in the local community. From your perspective, how does this dynamic affect public safety and day-to-day operations? Where or how can we change and improve the coordination between ICE and State and local partners? Mr. Lyons. Thank you, sir, again. What I would say is just very basic communication would go a long way for public safety. You know, ICE respects and abides by State and municipality laws well, where sometimes you can't hold for any reasons. But a simple phone call to let us know that that individual is going to be released or if that individual is released, sharing that biographical data with us will go a long way. Because the last thing we want is a criminal illegal alien to go back into the community. More often than not they prey upon other migrants who are coming here for a better life, yet that they can hide in plain sight because the sanctuary jurisdictions won't just pick up a phone, notify ICE that they're being released. Mr. Mackenzie. Well, I appreciate that. I think we want full cooperation between our local law enforcement and Federal agents when they are trying to do their job. If somebody is on a detainer, they should be allowed onto that property, given the ability within that detainer window to make a lawful arrest. I think it would go a long way to keeping our community safe. I would like to thank all of you again for being here. The fact that you are here and present for this kind of testimony, I think brings greater accountability and increases the ability for us to make reforms in Congress. Thank you again. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentlelady from New Jersey, Ms. Pou, for 5 minutes of questions. Ms. Pou. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and to our Ranking Member Thompson. Gentlemen, thank you so very much for being here. Let me just be clear. Secretary Noem must step down or be impeached by the House, period. The lawlessness, the cruelty, the outright viciousness that she has created has destroyed an agency whose very mission is to protect our country. Under Noem's leadership, Congressional oversight is ignored, detention visits are blocked, due process is ignored, and laws are broken without thought. This is the first time any of you have testified before our committee. It took two American citizens being murdered in cold blood to get you to show up. ICE raids schools, churches, and hospitals. Let's not forget 5-year-old Liam Ramos. You used him as a bait and then detained him despite his father's legally-- his father legally seeking asylum. Liam is the face of your cruelty. My district is one of the most ethnically diverse in America. Our diversity is our strength. But somehow you all seem to believe it is a weakness. Last fall, the Supreme Court greenlit ICE's ability to yank people off the street based on one thing such as ``the type of work one does, speaking Spanish, or speaking with an accent and their apparent race or ethnicity.'' Mr. Lyons, I speak Spanish. If I wasn't wearing any--if I wasn't wearing my Member pin, would me being a Latina or speaking Spanish be enough for ICE agents to harass me or shove me into one of your unmarked cars? Mr. Lyons. No, ma'am. Ms. Pou. I speak for all of us when I say that I think we know the real answer to this. These are the realities traumatizing my constituents. We know that ICE is transferring New Jersey detainees to other States, like Texas, ripping them from their families and leaving them unable to challenge their detention. Mr. Ice, yes or no--I am sorry, Mr. Lyons, yes or no? Will you provide us with a list of people ICE has transferred from New Jersey to other States so that I can inform their families where they are? Mr. Lyons. Yes, ma'am. Ms. Pou. These are people like my constituent, Leqaa Kordia, who ICE shipped to Texas and continues to detain, despite 2 judicial orders compelling her release. Over the weekend Leqaa was hospitalized for 72 hours while her family had no idea where she was at nor the status of her condition. Mr. Lyons, would you be willing to look into this to make sure to release my constituent? Why have we failed? Why have you failed to inform her family where she was sent and the status of her condition? When will she be freed? Mr. Lyons. Yes, ma'am. You have my commitment that I'll look into that. Ms. Pou. Thank you. Now, soon, Mr. Lyons, and all of you, my district will host the World Cup matches and hundreds of thousands of visitors will come. Visitors' confidence is plummeting and jeopardizing the World Cup. Mr. Lyons, will ICE commit, will you commit to ensure that pausing its operations and raids at FIFA matches and other FIFA sanctioned public events? Mr. Lyons. Ma'am, ICE, specifically Homeland Security Investigations, is a key part of the overall security apparatus for the World Cup. We're dedicated to securing that operation. We're dedicated to the security of all our participants as well as visitors. Ms. Pou. You realize that if they feel that they are going to be wrongfully incarcerated, wrongfully pulled out, that is going to hurt this entire process. I hope you realize that. Mr. Lyons. Yes, ma'am. ICE is dedicated to ensuring that everyone that visits their facilities will have a safe and secure event. Ms. Pou. Without these assurances, our local communities and national reputations will indeed be suffered. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentlelady yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Knott, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Knott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Using the trope diversity is our strength as an excuse for lawlessness is unbelievably naive and dangerous. Nobody in this room would say that diversity is a bad thing. Lawlessness is a bad thing. Law and order is much more of our strength than open border policies that welcomes anybody with no vetting. When you get down to the nuts and bolts of this issue, we would not be having this hearing if the Democrats attacked illegal immigration with the same vigor that they are attacking law enforcement and the men at this table. That is a fact. It is worth noting that the dishonesty in framing these issues has been unbelievably obvious. It has been consistent and just to--as an anecdote. Mr. Lyons, was Liam used as bait by your agency? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Actually, law enforcement officers took care of the child after the father abandoned him at a---- Mr. Knott. Walk us through what that means. Mr. Lyons. So, sir, the individual that was driving that vehicle with--Liam was in, fled from the scene, from the officers. He was obviously upset. We comforted him. The officers actually placed him in one of our vehicles, played his favorite song, favorite music. Then they took him to McDonald's. Mr. Knott. You all got him McDonald's. So you all did not abduct him. You did not use him as bait. Any characterization of that is a lie. It has been repeated over and over by the Democrats to frame your agency. You know, it is worth noting again that the Democrats fought to prevent any vetting of 20 million illegal immigrants into this country over the last 4 years. They attack agents rather than those who are assaulting agents today. They continually misframe what is happening on the ground. They continually malign the law enforcement officers who are providing legal structure to otherwise lawless landscapes in this country. It is worth noting that there have been roughly 2 million people in the country who have been removed in the last year, some voluntarily and then some by forced deportations. We have heard roughly about 25 cases of alleged abuse. Some of them, as I just pointed out, are dishonestly framed. But let's do a favor to the Democratic side. Let's increase that number by 1,000 times, 25,000 cases of alleged abuse or improper protocols. We are still operating at roughly 99 percent proficiency. Given the scale of the problem, the scale of the solution that you all are operating under, your agents are doing a remarkable job, and I thank you. But one issue that I want to talk about is this idea of sanctuary policies. Sanctuary policies is not just a passive relinquishing effort. It is an active obstruction. Isn't that true, Mr. Lyons? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Knott. What I mean by that is when I say it is an active, to be specific, there are sanctuary States and cities that will release violent criminals rather than handing them over to pursuing Federal law enforcement. Isn't that correct? Mr. Lyons. That is correct, sir. Mr. Knott. I left the hearing a few moments ago just to find a quick example. Here is one right behind me. Just 30 hours ago, an illegal alien arrested for stabbing an American in the back. He was charged with attempted murder. He pled to a lesser offense. The Feds wanted him, sought a detainer, and then rather than hold him for your agents' pickup, he was released back into the streets of Maryland. That is not an unusual action from local hostile law enforcement, is it, Mr. Lyons? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. That's what we face every day. Mr. Knott. So we have heard the Democrats complain that we are not getting the worst of the worst. But their sanctuary jurisdictions that control roughly 40 percent of this country's population will actively release sex predators, drug dealers, violent offenders, rather than hand them over to you for deportation. These are people who are already in custody. Am I correct, Mr. Lyons? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. The individuals are already deemed a public safety threat by local or State law enforcement. Mr. Knott. Then when they get a Federal detainer, they will release them on the street rather than turn them over for deportation? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Knott. It is disgusting. Mr. Scott, I want to talk to you briefly. I am running out of time. How many cities does your agency operate in? Commissioner Scott. We operate nationwide. Mr. Knott. Why is it that there is so much tension in Minneapolis-St. Paul right now? Commissioner Scott. Because paid agitators are actively trying to stop law enforcement action. Without that, you wouldn't even have any idea most of these arrests were taking place. Mr. Knott. In many parts of the country, local law enforcement assists your efforts to bring legal structure to these lawless areas, isn't that correct? Commissioner Scott. That's correct. Mr. Knott. When order is maintained, you can do your job peacefully, correct? Commissioner Scott. Correct. All we've ever asked is for law enforcement to do their job, not necessarily---- Mr. Knott. In Minneapolis-St. Paul, local law enforcement in some cases have been prohibited from maintaining order so you can do your job, isn't that correct? Commissioner Scott. Correct. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Knott. I yield back. Thank you. Chairman Garbarino. I now recognize the gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Walkinshaw, for 5 minutes. Mr. Walkinshaw. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Director Lyons, your opening statement referenced the importance of protecting children and I am glad to hear your commitment to that. I want to focus on one of President Trump's mass deportation policies that the experts say harms children: child detention. In this administration, under your watch, ICE has booked nearly 4,000 children and 1,000 of them have been held longer than the court-ordered 20-day limit. Recently, ProPublica obtained handwritten letters and drawings from children detained by ICE. These are letters from children describing what it feels like and what it does to them when the Government locks them up. This is Ariana. She is 14 years old, detained for 45 days. ``Since I got to this center, all I feel is sadness and mostly depression.'' This is Mia, 7 years old, ``I don't want to be in this place. I want to go to my school.'' This is Scarlet, 17 years old, ``I feel very bored and overwhelmed because I am locked up.'' This is Gabby, 14 years old, ``I feel so much sadness and depression of not being able to leave.'' This is Maria, 9 years old, ``Me and Dilly am not happy. Please get me out of here.'' This is a 12-year-old, ``Going to the doctor and the only thing they tell me is drink more water. The water here is what makes people sick.'' This one got me, Mr. Lyons, because this is a 5-year-old, Louise Annie, ``My son's five. He can't write many words, but he can communicate through drawings like this.'' This is a picture of Louise Annie's family. You might be able to see that none of the faces are smiling. Child detention is not required by law. You know that. It is not the only option available and it is not effective. We know that community-based alternatives can ensure compliance with proceedings without traumatizing these children. Yet you continue to detain and hold children for weeks or months, depriving them of school, stability, leaving them afraid, sick, and confused. One of the key reasons for your mass detention, including the detention of Liam and his father, is to pressure people to give up their legal opportunities and pathways to remaining in the United States. Liam's father was following the rules, following the legal process, with a valid claim. Let me be clear. No child, not Liam Ramos, not Gabby, or any of these children should be used as pawns in Stephen Miller's sick and twisted Great Replacement agenda. Mr. Lyons, in 2025, the British Journal of Psychiatry analyzed all of the data on the impact of immigration detention on children's health. Have you read that study and analysis? Mr. Lyons. No, sir, I haven't. Mr. Walkinshaw. You are the director of the--you are not familiar with that literature? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Walkinshaw. You could tell me, I am sure, chapter and verse on the tactics and the equipment that your agents use, military-style equipment across the country, in American cities. But you don't know anything about the literature of the impacts of your policies on children. You haven't read it? Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Walkinshaw. The Flores Agreement, I am sure you know that, sets a 20-day limit on detaining children. You and the Trump administration are trying to terminate that agreement. How long would you like to hold children, 20 days, 40 days, 60 days, 100 days? What is the right number, Mr. Lyons? Mr. Lyons. Sir, we wouldn't like to hold any children. We would like to remove that family unit together, safely and humanely and as quickly as possible. Mr. Walkinshaw. Thank you. Since you haven't read the literature, let me tell you what it says. ``Detention harms children.'' No period, no period, not 20, 40, 75 days that you are holding children, can be deemed safe. All detention of children has adverse impacts and is profoundly detrimental. Your policies are profoundly detrimental to children. I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from California, Mr. Fong, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Fong. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you all. For those who are here testifying. I want to thank you, to you and your teams and your personnel for what you do. Commissioner Scott, you mentioned and you in your testimony, National Security cannot exist without effective border security. Couldn't agree more. Everyone on your teams are doing tremendous work under difficult conditions. I want to thank you all. I do want to ask and dive in a little deeper as a Californian on the dangers and the consequences of these sanctuary policies. Director Lyons, I was in the State legislature in 2017 when sanctuary State policies were put in in California. I opposed S.B. 54 because at the time, and everything has proven to be true, it was outlined that the impact on ICE and Border Patrol agents was that there would be reduced information and access, agents would be conducting higher-risk enforcement operations, and that there will be operational constraints when it comes to limiting cooperation between State and local law enforcement. I wanted to get your perspective, Director Lyons, and I will go to you Commissioner Scott as well. What--can you give specifics on how these sanctuary State policies impact your operations in real time compared to nonsanctuary operations? Mr. Lyons. Well, sir, for ICE, what I kind-of--I will refer back to what we talked about earlier in my testimony. The fact that when State or local or county agencies don't cooperate with Immigration Customs Enforcement, it forces us to go back into the community, which we don't want to do. It also increases the number of assets we have to put toward that arrest. Like I said earlier, I would much rather send one or two agents or officers to make that arrest in a safe, secure location rather than being out in the street. It is safer for everyone involved. Mr. Fong. Before you--before I go to you, Commissioner Scott, and answer, I just want to let everyone know in California, and I think it was just reported a couple days ago, there are currently 33,179 illegal aliens in the custody of California jurisdictions with active detainers. The crimes of these aliens include 399 homicides, 3,313 assaults, 3,171 burglaries, 1,011 robberies, 8,380 dangerous drug offenses, 1,984 weapon offenses, and 1,293 sexual predatory offenses. These are the real-world consequences. Isn't that right, Commissioner Scott? When we don't have cooperation, they are released into the community. Commissioner Scott. Those are exactly the consequences. I would just add California-specific, they went above and beyond everybody else, I mean, in a negative way. They prohibited State and locals when they saw a crime taking place in front of them from sharing that information with us. San Diego, for example, right after that law was passed, a highway patrol pulled over a U-Haul van and it was a smuggling event, probably a human trafficking event. A Border Patrol agent just happened to roll up on it and found out, luckily, but that highway patrol was disciplined and actually investigated internally. That sent a chilling effect across the entire State of California that not only can you not actively take--like help us, you couldn't even pass information to us in a normal course of duties. Border security law enforcement is a team sport. We need to be working together, not against each other. Mr. Fong. Now, can you explain what would have happened, and I think you alluded to it, but what would have happened prior to that if there was local and State coordination with Federal law enforcement? Commissioner Scott. On a daily basis, especially along the Southwest Border, and let's not forget and the coast, because we have boats coming in, when a State or local agency would see illegal activity that they had--they could take action on, and then they saw a Federal crime, they would contact us. It happened all the time. That completely ceased to exist when S.B. 54 was passed. Mr. Fong. These crimes, of course, as you mentioned before, if you go into specifics, I mean, this is trafficking, both humans and drugs, this is rape, assaults, I mean anything. You are telling me that if any of those crimes occurred, if right now under--in California, if someone witnessed it, if a State law enforcement or local law enforcement witnessed these crimes being committed, they could not notify you. Commissioner Scott. They have some felony exceptions, but in most cases, you don't know until you start asking questions if it's just a smuggling event or a human trafficking event. Until you actually pop the trunk of the vehicle or the back of the car, you don't know what commodity is back there, if it's people or something else. It put a chilling effect beyond the actual written language on any kind of cooperation in the State. Mr. Fong. Well, I want to thank you for that. Yes, there were some exceptions when it comes to felonies, but as someone who lives in California and was there for the discussion and debate, everything we warned about when it came to sanctuary State policies and the consequences to our community and the consequences to public safety, they have come true. That is sad and unfortunate and we need to undo those policies. So I want to thank you all for your leadership and testimony and your work. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Louisiana, Mr. Carter, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Carter. Mr. Chairman, thank you very much. To our witnesses, thank you for being here. What we have heard today and seen play out in the streets of this Nation for the past year, straight out of the Trump administration's fascist playbook: cheat, murder, lie about it, practice the art of mass distraction. The American people are not happy about this. This administration's officials are sitting before us, two people are dead. I understand that there is an investigation and you cannot go into the details about that, but there certainly appears to be no shame on the part of these officials, who have undoubtedly watched some of your officers conduct themselves in ways that I know you don't condone, not as law-abiding people. Right? So I got to give you the benefit of doubt. I can't understand why you show no shame, no contrition, no remorse for the human lives that have been lost or for the trampling of the Constitution and the tearing apart of the moral fiber of our Nation. They think, apparently, you think, apparently, you have been coached, apparently, you have been called out of the room with a forced break to be told to be more aggressive, to push back against questions. The American people saw that happen. The American people watched as you all looked at each other, oh, I didn't ask for a break. Clearly you were called in the back to be coached, a halftime locker room pep talk. This isn't a game. These are people's lives. We should all be, you should be, your officers should be held accountable that no one is above the law. No one can evade the Constitution. No person can evade what is right, even though you think that Donald Trump will protect you, and maybe he will for now. But there will be a time that you have to answer these questions. While you have worked on many administrations and it has been asked, you worked on different administrations, what is different? I will tell you what is different. The approach. The approach of how you conduct your search and seizure. The reason there were so many others and they were not riots was because people were not being trampled. You had trained officers who knew the art of deescalation. They understood the rule of law. They understood the Constitution. Yet now we continue to hear lies. Last year, I took Members of Congress on an oversight visit to ICE facility. We were told certain things that turned out to be patent lies. They told us things that we witnessed within moments of being there to not be true. Yet we continue to hear you and some of my colleagues suggest, don't believe your eyes, don't believe your ears, just trust us. Well, the American people can see. This notion that Democrats don't want enforcement, those are talking points that are wrong. We want rapists and murderers off the street. We want the bad, the worst of the worst, to be arrested and to be deported if they aren't supposed to be here. What we don't want is citizens running down the street being chased by ICE agents, people being shot on the streets by rogue officers who are, in fact, American citizens. What we don't want is to see people like Ms. Good or Mr. Pretti simply doing what we often say if you see something, say something. We don't want to see people dying on the streets. So let me ask you a quick question. Mr. Lyons, has ICE ever detained American citizens such as they are not free to leave, whether it is on the sidewalk, street, or thrown into the back of an ICE vehicle because they looked or sound a certain way, even though they said they were American citizens? Yes or no, quickly. I only got 38 seconds. Mr. Lyons. No, sir. Mr. Carter. That has never happened before? Mr. Lyons. That we've arrested one? No, sir. We've detained individuals to verify identity, but we haven't arrested or deported. No, sir. Mr. Carter. Detained, arrest, check it out. Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Carter. It is the same thing, right. All right. What does an undocumented person look like or sound like? Does it look like Mr. Garbarino? Does it look like me? Mr. Lyons. Could look like anyone, sir. Mr. Carter. OK. Well, how are you training your people? Because you have said and others have said, if they sound a certain way, they look a certain way, we are going to stop them. That was quoted by your people. What do you say to that? Mr. Lyons. Sir, what I say is that ICE does criminal targeted enforcement based on intelligence, and we don't use the color of skin or accents for that. Mr. Carter. So the person who said that was wrong? Chairman Garbarino. We will---- Mr. Carter. Yes, the person was wrong? Chairman Garbarino. We will let the gentleman get that answer in writing. His time has expired. We will now recognize the gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Van Epps, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Van Epps. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for holding this hearing and to our witnesses for testifying today. I want to commend the job the Trump administration and you gentlemen are doing to secure the border, enforce Federal immigration laws, and keep dangerous criminals off our streets. Under President Biden, we saw unprecedented levels of illegal immigration, and many of those who came across the border were connected to transnational criminal organizations and have continued to commit crimes while in the United States. Despite doing everything they could to secure our borders, our brave CBP officers and Border Patrol agents were undermined at every turn by the Biden-Harris administration. Yet under President Trump, CBP, Border Patrol, and ICE have been empowered to do their job and fulfill their mission. As a representative from Tennessee, I can't help but compare operations in Minneapolis to those in Memphis. Federal law enforcement operations in Memphis have been successful by every standard and metric, with Memphis Safe Task Force arresting over 6,000 people. While immigration enforcement isn't a stated goal of this task force, there is no question that it is also taking place. The successful operations are due in large part to the outstanding leadership of Governor Lee, who has worked closely with Federal partners. Over the last year, the Trump administration has arrested numerous gang members, pedophiles, and drug traffickers in Memphis with little fanfare or interference from activists. As a result of this cooperation, murders in Memphis are down by 47 percent since President Trump took office and overall violent crime is down by 30 percent. In May of last year, ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations worked with Tennessee Highway Patrol and DHS components to successfully arrest 196 criminal illegal aliens across the greater Nashville area. I am grateful for the role the members of the Tennessee Highway Patrol played in that operation. Their cooperation has made my district significantly safer. Since then, over 56 partnering agencies are working together alongside ICE to keep Tennesseans safe. ICE has carefully highlighted the worst of the worst criminal aliens it has arrested. Today I will be entering into the record nearly 120 illegal aliens that have been arrested in Nashville with rap sheets ranging from identity theft to drug smuggling, larceny to arson, and robbery to rape. Federal agents are executing their mission to defend American citizens and protect our communities. The major challenges we have seen in Minneapolis and similar cities are directly caused by sanctuary city policies and the refusal of local leaders to enforce the law, preventing local law enforcement from working with ICE. This leaves ICE and others unsupported, having to manage protesters and domestic friction in addition to their actual mission of enforcing immigration law. Local law enforcement is crucial to facilitate the mission. Director Lyons, contrast ICE's experience in Minneapolis with other cities around the country, including Memphis and others, that have agreements to work with ICE. What can successful partnerships with local law enforcement and other partners look like? Mr. Lyons. Sir, thank you. I would say that Memphis is a prime example and I have to, you know, give credit to the U.S. Marshals Service that's leading that operation. Homeland Security Investigation agents are out there every day with the men and women of Tennessee Highway Patrol and Memphis Police Department, and the reduction in crime has been significant. But if you look across the country, almost at every State we do have cooperative jurisdictions. If you look at Texas, Texas we have outstanding cooperation. You don't see any riots or anything like that. You see side-by-side law enforcement working together as it would be. If you look at the State of Florida, State of Oklahoma, State of Louisiana, all across the Nation, we do have that. What it is, is public safety. Mr. Van Epps. Thank you. Next, I want to commend the Trump administration for locking down our Southern Border. A year ago, it was a highway for illegal aliens and illicit materials. Today, it is secure and closed. Commissioner Scott, as Congress and the Trump administration enabled DHS to secure the Southern Border, how are cartels and other criminal organizations adapting to effective border enforcement? Commissioner Scott. They're going to continue to push back. I think some of it is in these protests because if we can shut down interior enforcement, that allows them to basically market their goods, if you will, to smuggle people in. They need those people to be distractions because without it, they have to start digging million-dollar tunnels. Without it, they have to spend a bunch of money on drones, which we're countering. Without it, they have to go out into the ocean where they stick out like a sore thumb. We're increasing our radars on the West Coast and increasing our air coverage. Basically, it affects their bottom line and it makes it harder and harder for them to bring their poison and anybody that wants to threaten this country that's willing to pay them here. Mr. Van Epps. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I move to submit for the record a list of DHS worst of the worst in Tennessee, 3 quotes from Tennessee-7 sheriffs supporting ICE, and 5 news articles germane to the hearing in Tennessee. Sir, I yield back. Chairman Garbarino. Without objection. [The information follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Green, for 5 minutes of questions. Mr. Green. Thank you, Mr.--sorry, Mr. Chairman, can you hear me now? Is it---- Chairman Garbarino. Move the microphone right there. Mr. Green. Well, will you give me a moment to get a bit closer, please? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I say it sincerely, I believe this is a most valuable hearing, and I am honored that Ranking Member would be here with us to accommodate us, as is the case with you. Mr. Lyons, is it true that you have a criminal justice degree, a bachelor's degree in criminal justice? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir, it is. Mr. Green. Is it also true that you have a master's degree in criminal justice leadership? Mr. Lyons. Yes, I do. Mr. Green. Would you, as a professional with 2 degrees in criminal justice, indicate to us that if an officer commits murder, that that officer should be prosecuted? Mr. Lyons. Sir, any law enforcement misconduct needs to be investigated and prosecuted. Mr. Green. Investigated and prosecuted. Have you seen the widely-published video of the killing of Mr. Alex Pretti? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Green. Sir, my assumption is that if I ask you whether this was an injustice, you would say you cannot comment because of an on-going investigation. Is that a fair statement? Mr. Lyons. Yes, sir. Mr. Green. What is the rationale for not responding to an on-going investigation? Mr. Lyons. Sir, I don't want to impede---- Mr. Green. I don't want you to. Mr. Lyons [continuing]. Or jeopardize the investigation. Mr. Green. No, no, no. Not this one. Any. Any. As you--in your profession now. But any investigation, what is the rationale? Not this one. Any. Mr. Lyons. Same for any investigation, sir. I don't want to---- Mr. Green. You would not---- Mr. Lyons. I don't want to bias or put my finger on the scale of any investigation. Mr. Green. You are not. What is the rationale for your not testifying about it, is my question. Mr. Lyons. I don't understand your question, sir. Mr. Green. Why would--what does the law say? What is the rationale? What harm would it do if you testified? Mr. Lyons. Because I don't want--have the full facts in the case yet, sir. Mr. Green. Exactly. That is what I expected you to say. You don't have the full facts. Thank you. I assume you would agree with this, Mr. Scott, is this true? Commissioner Scott. Yes, sir. Mr. Green. Mr. Edlow, you would agree? Mr. Edlow. I assume so. I'm not a professional in law enforcement. Mr. Green. Well, but you are a professional person with a degree of intellect such as you can comment on whether or not it would cause harm. Mr. Edlow. Well, I certainly would not comment on anything. Mr. Green. Not a specific case. We are talking about now any case. Would you agree that it would cause harm for you to testify before there is an investigation? Mr. Edlow. Certainly, without having all the facts. Mr. Green. All right. Surely you would agree. Which brings us to Secretary Noem. Secretary Noem accused Mr. Pretti of brandishing a firearm while wishing to inflict harm on the officers. Secretary Noem. Same rules that apply to you apply to Secretary Noem. Accused these--this gentleman, Mr. Pretti, of brandishing a firearm. Secretary Noem doing this when she did without an investigation. We have to agree that there has not been an investigation. I don't think I have to ask you that. Not a complete investigation that we know of anyway. She did it right afterwards. Having done this, she is violating this very basic principle that you have called to our attention today. We have to ask ourselves, why would she go so far as to say brandishing when he did not? The video will clearly show it. She said wishing to inflict harm. Did not inflict any harm. But the Secretary, without an investigation, made these comments. I will tell you why. The Secretary was in a rush to cover up, to make sure that she was protecting the officers without regard for the life that was lost. In doing this, she was violating not only this basic moral concept, she was breaking the law. The Secretary should be investigated right along with those officers who were out there engaged in this ungodly conduct. She should be investigated. In my opinion, based upon my observation, the Secretary should not only be investigated. The Secretary should be prosecuted right along with those officers. This man did not brandish. This man was not armed. This man did not attempt to hurt those officers. They should all be prosecuted. You persons associated with the Trump---- Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time---- Mr. Green [continuing]. Administration said lock her up. I say lock her up. Chairman Garbarino. The gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize the Ranking Member for UCs. Mr. Thompson. That is correct, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent to insert 2 statements for the record, one submitted by the Refugee Council USA and the other from the Baptist Joint Committee on Religious Liberty. Chairman Garbarino. Without objection. [The information follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Thompson. Mr. Chairman, on behalf of Mrs. Ramirez, I ask unanimous consent to include in the record 3 articles. One, the Chicago Sun Times article describing how U.S. Border Patrol has separated a family. No. 2, an ABC-7 Chicago article that describes how ICE's warrantless arrests in Chicago has been ruled unlawful by a Federal judge. Third, a ProPublica article documenting how immigration agents are using banned chokeholds and other moves that can cut off breathing. Chairman Garbarino. Without objection. [The information follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Thompson. Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent to insert in the record the following articles. A CBS News article that states that contrary to the administration's claim, only 14 percent of those arrested by ICE had violent criminal records. An NPR story about a DHS memo that says ICE can enter people's home without a judicial warrant, which has alarmed Members on both sides of the aisle. An article from the Marshall Project that alleges that there are thousands of kids in detention, many for longer than the court-prescribed limit. An article from The Independent about a sick 5-year-old Liam Ramos asking for his mom in a detention center, which rebuts testimony we heard today that ICE was taking good care of him. A report from the Center for Election Innovation and Research updated this month that found that noncitizen voting is rare and allegations of the practice are a result of misunderstandings or fabrication. An article from the AP which highlights that Federal authorities are monitoring and tracking individuals who criticize immigration enforcement operation. A report from the Brennan Center titled ``ICE Wants to Go After Dissenters as Well as Immigrants.'' A report from The Guardian that describes the terrible condition in ICE facilities and that ICE deny urgent medical care to a 10-year-old. Chairman Garbarino. Without objection. [The information follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Garbarino. I want to thank--the gentleman yields back. I want to thank the Members--or the witnesses for being here today and all the Members for their questions. Members of the committee may have some additional questions for the witnesses and we ask that the witnesses to respond to these in writing. Pursuant to committee rule VII(E), the hearing record will be held open for 10 days. I want to let the audience know that please still be seated while the witnesses and their teams leave. Without objection, this committee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 1:26 p.m., the committee was adjourned.] A P P E N D I X I ---------- Article Submitted by Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Letter Submitted by Honorable Timothy Kennedy [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] A P P E N D I X I I ---------- Questions From Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino for Rodney S. Scott Question 1. Please provide the standard operating procedure for your agency for an investigation when deadly force is used. Answer. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) Special Agents (SAs) are responsible for investigating incidents involving the use of deadly force by CBP personnel. These investigations are conducted in close collaboration with local, State, Tribal, and Federal law enforcement agencies with concurrent jurisdiction over the incident. Upon notification of a use of deadly force incident involving CBP personnel, OPR SAs immediately initiate a comprehensive investigation and respond to the incident scene. The investigative process includes, but is not limited to, the following steps: Immediate Scene Management: Involved Officers/Agents: Involved officers and agents are separated to ensure the integrity and independence of their statements. Scene Security: The incident area and all potential evidence are secured to protect them from environmental factors and unauthorized access until involved agencies complete their investigation of the scene. Medical Aid: Immediate medical assistance is provided or ensured for any injured individuals. Identify Witnesses: All civilian and CBP personnel witnesses who saw, heard, or possess relevant information about the incident are identified and located. Evidence Collection & Preservation: Digital Evidence: Body-worn cameras, dash-cams, any other available surveillance footage, and available audio recordings, including radio transmissions, are secured. Physical Evidence: Weapons, shell casings, and other relevant items are collected and processed. Documentation: Comprehensive photographic and/or video documentation of the scene, injuries to any involved parties (suspects or officers), and any key evidence is completed. Medical Records: Records pertaining to the medical treatment of any injured individuals are obtained. Interviews & Statements: Subject/Suspect: Individuals involved in the incident are afforded the opportunity to provide video-recorded statements if they choose. Witnesses: Detailed video recorded interviews are conducted with all identified witnesses. CBP Personnel: Video-recorded statements are obtained from CBP officers and agents involved, in collaboration with other law enforcement agencies, giving careful consideration given to Garrity rights if a parallel criminal investigation is under way. Administrative & Criminal Review: Initial Assessment: OPR Field Office SAs, and OPR Headquarters conduct an initial review of the facts gathered. Chain of Command: The investigation proceeds through the established chain of command to determine whether the facts and circumstances surrounding the use of force have been thoroughly investigated. Parallel Investigations: Separate criminal investigations (to determine if laws were violated) and administrative investigations (to determine policy compliance) may be bifurcated and conducted concurrently by separate investigative teams. Reporting & Adjudication: Documentation: Thorough and detailed investigative reports are compiled. Congressional Notification: If the use of deadly force results in an in-custody death, CBP transmits a Congressional Notification to relevant oversight committee staff with 72 hours of when the incident occurs. U.S. Department of Justice Reporting: If the use of deadly force results in an in-custody death, CBP provides an annual report to the Federal Death in Custody Reporting Program in line with the requirements outlined in the Death in Custody Reporting Act of 2013. Final Determination: Criminal Investigation: The lead investigative agency conducts a review of investigation and if potential criminal conduct exists, the case is referred to the relevant prosecutorial agency (U.S. Attorney Office and/or local District Attorney) for a prosecutorial determination. Administrative Investigation: CBP OPR SAs present the facts of the investigation to CBP's National Use of Force Review Board (NUFRB). The NUFRB reviews each incident to determine if the use of force was consistent with CBP policy, if there are issues regarding potential administrative or policy violations (including potential misconduct) warranting referrals to CBP OPR (if not already previously identified by OPR), and to identify and assess any issues involving training, tactics, equipment, or policy. Question 2a. DHS has managed an unprecedented volume of tariff adjustments this year, requiring significant agility across CBP's trade processing systems. With a related Supreme Court decision nullifying IEEPA tariffs and requiring the administration to rapidly shift its tariff strategy, there remains a clear need for flexible responsiveness of the system.\1\ In addition, there are major economic events on the horizon--including the 2026 World Cup and the 2028 Olympics. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, No. 24-1287, (2026). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- What specific steps is the Department taking to ensure its trade and tariff collection infrastructure remains stable, outage-free, and continues to keep pace with the rapidly-developing environment? Answer. Implementing new tariffs is something that CBP is uniquely well-positioned to accomplish. The technical implementation of new tariffs is done in the Automated Commercial Environment (ACE), the technological backbone of the U.S. international trade system. Between January 20, 2025, and February 27, 2026, CBP implemented 49 Presidential tariff actions. Additionally, CBP deployed 4 enhancements to ACE to automate the creation of ACE Portal accounts supporting the mandated February 6, 2026, transition to electronic refund transactions, in accordance with Executive Order 14247. Also, in anticipation of the 2026 FIFA World Cup, CBP is deploying an ACE enhancement that will expedite the secure review and clearance of goods that are temporarily imported by truck, such as competitors' equipment. Question 2b. Are there capacity, technology, or workforce needs that Congress should be aware of, and what is DHS's plan to sustain the accurate and timely flow of goods into the country under these compounding pressures across these areas? Answer. Today's rapidly-evolving trade environment requires substantial and on-going upgrades and improvements for ACE to ensure it remains a robust, reliable, and efficient system. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and CBP continue to advocate for sufficient ACE funding, as it is critical to ensuring a safe, secure, and efficient U.S. economy. The fiscal year 2027 President's budget includes $136 million and 31 positions for ACE modernization to finalize modernization efforts essential to address growing trade volumes and evolving enforcement priorities. Question 2c. Are there any planned transitions or changes being made to the system or how it is continuously modernized, sustained, and operated to meet the administration's tariff objectives, including the industrial base supporting it? Answer. CBP's Office of Trade is executing a major technology modernization of ACE that will include the addition of new components and capabilities to enhance security, ensure scalability, and position the system to adapt to evolving processes and trade requirements. Key initiatives include completing cloud migration, strengthening revenue protection, reducing manual processes, and enhancing enforcement against violative parties. ACE modernization will help CBP enforce tariff requirements, protect U.S. interests, and maintain a resilient, compliant system. As CBP navigates the path for ACE modernization, it continues to optimize ACE through the regular deployment of system enhancements and swift implementation of Executive Orders and proclamations. Question 2d. If so, are any of these changes self-imposed by the department, and have they been fully reviewed by all relevant stakeholders, including technical authorities (e.g., OIT, CIO, and others) to ensure no lapses in the technology required while aligning the system to updated tariff strategies? Answer. ACE Modernization adheres to the Modernized Tailoring Approach as a post-Full Operational Capability IT modernization effort, as approved by DHS and other relevant stakeholders. Tailoring means modifying the traditional DHS Acquisition Lifecycle Framework to fit the program based on risk, complexity, delivery model, or mission urgency. Tailoring enables IT programs like ACE to execute delivery using agile methodology with a customized acquisition process that focuses on delivering value, not volume, and enables faster response without eliminating acquisition governance. Using this approach, we have the flexibility to support Executive Orders, Presidential proclamations, and legislative mandates, without compromising or eliminating critical technical reviews and checkpoints. Question 3. Commissioner Scott, my office has been tracking the Consolidated Tower and Surveillance Equipment program very closely and following the future of border surveillance towers and autonomous capabilities. Through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, Congress provided U.S. Customs and Border Protection with an unprecedented level of funding for border security and encourages the swift and effective execution of those funds. Please provide a comprehensive time line for acquisition and deployment of towers along our borders. In your response, please include award dates and a forecast of deployment dates, quantities, and locations of the towers. Answer. CBP anticipates awarding contracts under the Consolidated Tower and Surveillance Equipment program in late May/early June 2026. A solicitation was released on March 9, 2026. Below is the current time line and key milestones for the Consolidated Tower and Surveillance Equipment (CTSE) program: CTSE Contract Award.--CTSE multiple-award indefinite- delivery, indefinite-quantity contracts were awarded in September 2023. Deployment.--Delivery Order 01 was awarded in September 2023 for 15 autonomous towers, deployed across El Paso (Santa Teresa), San Diego (Campo), and Del Rio sectors. All towers meet the Working Families Tax Cut Act autonomy requirements. Next Steps.--CBP evaluated proposals for CTSE Delivery Order No. 2, with plans to obligate $345 million. Towers will be deployed to Del Rio, San Diego, El Paso, Big Bend, Tucson, Rio Grande Valley, Yuma, and El Centro Sectors. Locations will be finalized post-award. The acquisition and deployment time lines for border surveillance towers under various contracts: SBIR Anduril Contract: Anduril Delivery Order 21 includes 200 total tower recapitalizations, with 45 projected for deployment in fiscal year 2026. The full deployment under this order is expected to be completed within 14 months. CONTROP Recap Deployments (S&K Security Group): 16 tower recapitalizations are projected for deployment in fiscal year 2026. In partnership with SRC CONTROP, S&K Security Group will complete 49 tower recapitalizations in the Tucson Sector, between Douglas and Ajo, by the end of the third quarter of fiscal year 2027. This upgrade is based on the sustainment needs of Integrated Fixed Towers located in the Tucson sector between Douglas and Ajo, which are experiencing power issues, replacement part failures, and security vulnerabilities. Rather than making costly repairs, S&K Security Group, our sustainment vendor, is recapitalizing these towers to address these challenges and ensure continued operational reliability. Question 4a. Commissioner Scott, Congress has consistently recognized the risk that front-line CBP personnel face from secondary exposure to fentanyl and other potentially lethal narcotics while on duty, including through its passage of the Prevent Exposure to Narcotics and Toxics (PREVENT) Act of 2021 during the 117th Congress. Specifically, this bill (H.R. 5274) passed the House unanimously in 2022 and was later signed into law on December 23, 2022, as part of the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for fiscal year 2023 (Public Law 117-263, Sec. 7135), requiring the CBP Commissioner to ensure the availability of personal protective equipment, including containment devices, for ``all U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers, agents, other personnel, and canines at risk of accidental exposure to synthetic opioids.'' What is the status of CBP's efforts to satisfy this requirement? Answer. CBP manages risks associated with suspected fentanyl and other illicit narcotics through established occupational safety and health procedures, including the use of Job Hazard Analyses and nationally-recognized safety practices. CBP deployed protective measures for personnel who may encounter suspected narcotics. These measures include N95 respirators, enhanced 5-mil disposable gloves, Tyvek sleeves and suits, and eye protection. Naloxone is also available as a medical countermeasure in the event of suspected opioid exposure. Containment devices such as glove boxes are used by front- line personnel to contain suspected illicit narcotics during presumptive field testing and when leakage is observed. In addition, CBP locations are equipped with spill containment materials and maintain established protocols to respond to hazardous material incidents. Question 4b. How many CBP personnel currently have access to containment devices designed to prevent secondary exposure to fentanyl and other synthetic opioids? Answer. CBP officers and agents are provided personal protective equipment and are trained in handling unknown and potentially harmful substances, as well as in the use of naloxone. CBP deployed N95 respirators, disposable gloves, Tyvek sleeves and suits, and eye protection for handling suspected fentanyl and over 11,000 doses of naloxone as a medical countermeasure. CBP also employs approximately 350 self-contained glove boxes with replaceable gloves to contain suspected illicit narcotics when sampled for presumptive field testing and when leakage is observed. Additionally, CBP locations are equipped with spill containment devices and have response protocols for various hazardous spills. Laboratories and Scientific Services (LSS) functions as the scientific, technical, and forensic division within CBP. LSS oversees 7 field laboratories and 22 forward-operating laboratories and joint forensics centers, providing analysis by LSS forensic chemists and reducing risk of exposure to CBP officers. LSS forensic chemists and CBP officers each have access to protective equipment such as HEPA + Activated Carbon fume hoods, which ventilate a working area to lessen any chance of exposure. Air and Marine Operations crew members transporting fentanyl or fentanyl precursors are provided containment devices to limit to risk to crew members. All CBP Office of Field Operations (OFO) personnel have access to the personal protective equipment outlined in this response to protect against exposure to fentanyl and other synthetic opioids. U.S. Border Patrol (USBP) agents are provided Naloxone and are trained in the administration of Naloxone, in case of exposure. Furthermore, all USBP emergency medical technicians carry doses of Naloxone in their medical kits. Question 4c. If additional steps are required to ensure the availability of containment devices for all CBP personnel at risk of accidental exposure to synthetic opioids, please provide a list of those additional steps and estimated time lines for their completion. Answer. At this time, no additional deployment of containment devices is needed. CBP will continue to prioritize workforce protection through provision of personal protective equipment and medical countermeasures along with workforce training. Questions From Honorable Tony Gonzales for Rodney S. Scott Question 1a. Commissioner Scott, as you may be aware, in the previous administration the General Services Administration in cooperation with CBP, and the International Boundary Water Commission announced its Record of Decision for the proposed modernization of the Bridge of the Americas (BOTA) Land Point of Entry in El Paso, Texas, which include the elimination of all commercial cargo operations. BOTA is a critical gateway for cross-border trade and contributes to demonstrable employment on both sides of the border, and West Texas constituents have raised significant concerns with the potential negative impacts to economic growth across the El Paso region. What is the current status of the BOTA LPOE modernization project? Answer. The Bridge of the Americas Land Port of Entry (LPOE) Modernization Project is in the acquisition phase. General Services Administration (GSA) will award as a Design/Build contract, to include new non-commercial primary vehicle lanes, main building, outbound inspection facility, kennel building, and narcotics vault. The design will align to the 2023 CBP LPOE Design Standards. The current total project cost estimate range is $474 million-$579 million. GSA approved the Project Labor Agreement exception on November 17, 2025, to allow GSA to solicit without this requirement. There will be minor land acquisition (4.4 acres). The due diligence package, to include title examination services, environmental site assessment, and American Land Title Association/National Society of Professional Surveyors, was awarded February 19, 2026. Site acquisition is scheduled for completion in December 2026. Phase 2 of the design/build acquisition process, wherein short-listed firms submit concept designs with technical and price proposals (or best and final offers), will begin in June 2026. Contract award slated to follow in January 2027. Question 1b. Under your leadership, has CBP had the opportunity to engage in the review and re-evaluation of this modernization project? If not, can I get your commitment to review the merits of this project to ensure that stakeholder input is considered and that a final solution appropriately balances infrastructure modernization with maintaining if not bolstering economic opportunity? Answer. CBP is fully engaged in on-going reviews and refinement of this modernization project to ensure it aligns with current operational needs and the broader regional economic context, working closely with GSA, partner agencies, local stakeholders, and the trade and travel communities to validate assumptions and incorporate feedback. This modernization will allow significant specialization and enhanced national and border security. It will reduce the commercial footprint, thereby creating more specialized administrative space, while enabling higher Non-Intrusive Inspection scan rates for commercial vehicles at designated Multi-Energy Portal-equipped ports such as Ysleta, Santa Teresa, and Marcelino Serna/Tornillo. Concurrently, the expansion of passenger vehicle lanes from 14 to up to 35, coupled with substantial Low Energy Portal coverage, strengthens enforcement and national security for travelers. Economically, this project is expected to produce a positive impact on local, regional, and national economies, including job growth, by enhancing throughput and reducing wait times. This in turn will encourage increased visitor spending from Mexico, which currently contributes over $2 billion annually to El Paso's economy. Commercial traffic will be effectively redirected to other El Paso area LPOEs, including Ysleta, Tornillo (Marcelino Serna), and Santa Teresa, all of which have the capacity to absorb displaced volume. CBP is cooperative partner with GSA throughout the National Environmental Policy Act process, with stakeholder and community engagement commencing in November 2022 and continuing through 2025 to address concerns about traffic, environmental, and health impacts. CBP, in collaboration with GSA, also responded to community input during the development, review, and approval of the Environmental Impact Statement. CBP remains committed to the continued review and assessment of project merits, considering stakeholder input through formal coordination and outreach, with the ultimate goal of delivering a final solution that modernizes critical infrastructure, enhances security and processing efficiency, and strengthens economic opportunity for the region. Question 2a. Commissioner Scott, the Working Families Tax Cuts Act provided significant funding to secure our Nation's borders whether it's building additional physical barriers or modernizing our border infrastructure. It is critical we stay on track to ensure our Border Patrol Agents have the tools available and necessary to keep borders secure and communities safe. Of the funds appropriated for autonomous surveillance, what percentage remains unobligated, and what is the anticipated time line for full deployment? Answer. Of the $1.297 billion allocated for Integrated Surveillance Towers in the Working Families Tax Cut Act, 61 percent remains unobligated, with a current unobligated balance of $796.2 million. The CBP Integrated Surveillance Towers program anticipates full deployment of all 550 towers by the 4th quarter of fiscal year 2028. Question 2b. What metrics are being used to track the ``time-to- field'' for programs like the Consolidated Tower and Surveillance Equipment systems? Answer. The Consolidated Tower and Surveillance Equipment program is tracked using contract milestone completion dates, delivery schedules, and deployment readiness assessments. These metrics collectively ensure timely progress from contract award to operational deployment. The same metrics are used for all vendors. Question From Honorable Brad Knott for Rodney S. Scott Question. Customs fraud undermines American manufacturers and creates a significant revenue loss for the United States. I have heard from companies throughout North Carolina that have successfully challenged unfair trading practices of Chinese companies, only to then face a complex scheme of shell exporters and importers designed to evade the proper AD and CVD duties. Commissioner Scott, how successful has Customs been in collecting the duties owed after successful EAPA petitions? In particular, can you shed any light on the successes and challenges of cases involving cast iron soil pipe and fittings? Answer. Customs fraud, particularly through the evasion of Antidumping (AD) and Countervailing Duties (CVD), poses a significant threat to American manufacturers by undermining fair competition and causing substantial revenue loss for the United States. The Enforce and Protect Act (EAPA), enacted in February 2016, provides CBP with enhanced tools to investigate and combat these evasion schemes. Effectiveness of EAPA Investigations AD/CVD collection is notoriously difficult due to the U.S. Government's retrospective system where final duties are often calculated years after importation, resulting in massive, unexpected bills that insolvent or shell importers avoid paying. Evasion tactics like transshipment, misclassification, and fraud, combined with inadequate, low-value bonding, are some of the toughest problem sets for CBP. Despite these challenges, CBP's EAPA investigations is successful at not only disrupting illegal transshipment schemes immediately but also collecting duties owed to the U.S. Government. Since 2016, CBP initiated over 520 investigations and identified more than $2.2 billion in duties owed to the U.S. Government. CBP's investigative time line, which includes the imposition of interim measures on current and future entries subject to higher AD/CVD rates, enables the U.S. Government to take immediate measures to combat illegal transshipment schemes. CBP acknowledges the inherent difficulties in investigating individual importers, especially when faced with sophisticated evasion schemes involving shell companies. To combat this, EAPA investigates consignees and related companies, not just the named importer of record. Furthermore, personnel from CBP's Centers of Excellence and Expertise, such as Import Specialists who specialize in classification, valuation, compliance, and enforcement, play a crucial role by leveraging CBP's enforcement authorities outside of EAPA to act against additional importers identified during investigations that are involved in evasion schemes. Cases Involving Cast Iron Soil Pipe and Fittings The U.S. cast iron soil pipe and pipe fittings industry has been a particular target of unfair trade practices and subsequent evasion schemes. In 2017 and 2018, the Cast Iron Soil Pipe Institute successfully filed AD/CVD petitions against Chinese imports of cast iron soil pipe fittings and cast iron soil pipe, respectively. CBP actively investigated these evasion schemes through the EAPA and its other authorities. CBP took enforcement actions in such cases, requiring payment of AD/CVD duties and cash deposits, and evaluating continuous bonds. CBP remains committed to using all available enforcement tools to protect this vital U.S. industry from the harm caused by these evasion schemes. Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson for Rodney S. Scott Question 1. Commissioner Scott, will you commit to not deploying any CBP personnel inside or in the immediate vicinity of a polling place during voting in a general or special election? Answer. While there are currently no plans to place law enforcement personnel at polling places during elections, CBP will continue to conduct enforcement operations consistent with law and existing DHS and CBP policies. Question 2. Commissioner Scott, CBP, including U.S. Border Patrol, has been involved in some of the most aggressive and even deadly immigration enforcement actions in the interior of the United States. In fact, a CBP officer and Border Patrol agent were involved in the deadly shooting of Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. Following the killing of Mr. Pretti, what immediate changes, if any, did you make to interior enforcement protocols for CBP agents and officers? Answer. USBP enforces Federal law and agents are trained to operate within the CBP Use of Force Policy. CBP employees follow the policies and procedures related to a critical incident such as how to respond before, during, and after an officer-involved shooting. The number of USBP personnel assigned to interior enforcement in that region was eventually reduced, those decisions were not solely nor directly related to the shooting of Alex Pretti. Question 3a. Commissioner Scott, there have been reports of hundreds of United States citizens being arrested or detained during immigration enforcement efforts. What procedures does CBP take when someone claims to be a United States citizen? Answer. This answer varies depending on the environment. Minus articulable facts that lead to reasonable suspicion that an individual is committing a crime by making a false claim to U.S. Citizenship, supported claims of U.S. Citizenship are generally accepted. When arriving from outside of the United States, CBP officers follow procedures outlined in 8 CFR 235.1(b). CBP reviews travel documents provided at the time of the inspection, collects biometrics and biographical information, and utilizes U.S. Government databases to confirm a subject's identity and determine if an extraditable warrant exists. Question 3b. What training do officers get about how to ensure they are not arresting or detaining citizens? Answer. CBP officers and agents enforce Federal laws and receive training on the 4th Amendment. Under these laws, officers and agent retain the authority to arrest United States citizens for violation of Federal law in certain situations. The development of reasonable suspicion and probable cause is used to determine courses of action throughout the targeting, encountering, and detention process for a reasonable amount of time for investigative purposes. CBP agents and officers are trained to arrest individuals that are violating laws that CBP has the authority to enforce. This applies regardless of citizenship. OFO has the authority to inspect all individuals seeking entry into the United States, including U.S. citizens. Routine questioning and examination at a port of entry are part of the inspection process and do not, by themselves, constitute a detention or arrest. Question 3c. Where does CBP maintain data about citizen arrests and detentions? How many U.S. citizens has CBP arrested or detained? Answer. CBP maintains all arrest data within official systems of record. CBP publicly posts arrest data to include the arrest of U.S. citizens on CBP.gov monthly. Question 3d. Does CBP maintain data on investigative stops of U.S. citizens? If so, where is that data being maintained? How many U.S. citizens have been stopped? Answer. CBP does not maintain a separate, stand-alone database specifically dedicated to ``investigative stops of U.S. citizens.'' Question 4a. Commissioner Scott, according to media reports, DHS is using a new mobile facial recognition technology called Mobile Fortify to identify individuals encountered at the border or during enforcement operations.\2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ For example, see Public Broadcasting Service, Department of Homeland Security Intensifies Surveillance in Immigration Raids, Sweeping Citizens (Jan. 30, 2026), https://www.pbs.org/newshour/ politics/department-of-homeland-security-intensifies-surveillance-in- immigration-raids-sweeping-in-citizens. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- To what extent is CBP using the facial recognition app known as Mobile Fortify outside of ports of entries? Please describe those scenarios. Answer. Mobile Fortify is used exclusively outside of ports of entry (POE). It is not used when someone presents at a POE. The Mobile Fortify Application is used by CBP for interior enforcement on individuals present in the United States who are: (1) subject to an investigatory detention based on reasonable suspicion of being unlawfully present in the United States, (2) have been arrested based on probable cause of an immigration violation, or (3) who provide consent to perform facial recognition. Question 4b. If CBP is using Mobile Fortify outside of ports of entries to conduct biometric searches, are there Constitutional restraints in place on such searches of U.S. citizens and those exercising their first amendment rights? Answer. DHS does not profile, target, or discriminate against any individual for exercising his or her First Amendment rights. Under the Privacy Act of 1974, all DHS personnel are prohibited from maintaining records that describe how a U.S. citizen or alien lawfully admitted for permanent residence exercises his or her First Amendment rights, unless expressly authorized by statute or by the individual about whom the record is maintained; or unless pertinent to and within the scope of an authorized criminal, civil, or administrative law enforcement activity. i. What is the approval process CBP personnel must follow required before conducting a biometric search using the Mobile Fortify application outside of a port of entry? Answer. CBP personnel do not need approval to utilize this application in the lawful performance of their official duties and immigration inspections. Before gaining access to Mobile Fortify, CBP users are required to complete a facial recognition training named Facial Analysis and Comparison Essentials. The training covers current DHS and CBP policies governing the use of facial recognition technologies and reiterates privacy and civil rights and civil liberties concerns about using facial recognition technologies. DHS and CBP do not use facial recognition technologies to profile, target, or discriminate against any individual solely for exercising their Constitutional rights or to enable systemic, indiscriminate, or wide- scale monitoring, surveillance, or tracking. ii. What is the process CBP personnel must follow to review and verify potential matches after completing a biometric search using the Mobile Fortify application? Answer. After completing a biometric search using the Mobile Fortify application, CBP personnel treat any potential match as an investigative lead and follow a multi-step verification process: Review of the potential match.--The officer/agent reviews the Mobile Fortify hit, including the photograph and associated biographic information, and conducts a side-by-side visual comparison with the individual. Interview and document check.--The officer/agent interviews the individual to confirm identity and citizenship and requests any available identification. The officer/agent compares the individual's responses and any documents to the information contained in the record associated with the potential match. Use of facial recognition as supporting evidence.--If no identification is available but the individual closely resembles the target and the Mobile Fortify facial recognition result indicates a strong match, that result is treated as additional support for probable cause that the individual is the identified target. Fingerprinting for confirmation.--The individual is fingerprinted to definitively confirm or rule out the match. Release if not the target/U.S. citizen.--At any point, if available biometric and biographic information indicates that the individual is not the target and/or is a U.S. citizen, the individual is released. iii. If the Mobile Fortify application returns a match that conflicts with a person's government-issued identification or documentation, what procedures must CBP follow to determine the person's identity? Answer. When the Mobile Fortify application returns a potential match that conflicts with a person's Government-issued identification or documentation, officers treat the result as an investigative lead and follow a structured verification process: Initial review of discrepancy.--The officer compares the Mobile Fortify return (photo, biographic data, and any associated records) against the person's presented identification and stated biographical information to identify what specifically conflicts (e.g., name, date of birth, photograph). Interview and document examination.--The officer conducts a focused interview to clarify the discrepancy and examines all available documents for authenticity and consistency (e.g., physical security features, issuance date, expiration, and any indications of alteration). Database checks.--The officer runs additional queries in appropriate CBP and other Government systems of record to corroborate the identity associated with the presented identification and to verify whether the Mobile Fortify match corresponds to a different known individual. Use of biometrics as confirmation: If questions remain after interview and document checks, the officer uses biometric verification--primarily fingerprint collection and matching--to definitively confirm or rule out the Mobile Fortify match. Supervisory review and final determination.--The officer consults with a supervisor as needed and uses the combined results of document examination, system checks, and biometric verification to determine the person's true identity. If the evidence indicates that the individual is not the person associated with the Mobile Fortify hit and is a U.S. citizen or otherwise lawfully identified, the individual is released. Question 4c. Has CBP provided access to Mobile Fortify to any agencies in addition to ICE at the local, State, or Federal level? Answer. No. Question 5a. In a memo dated May 12, 2025, Mr. Lyons instructed ICE officers that they may enter residences without a judicial warrant to conduct civil immigration arrests. The Fourth Amendment has long been understood to require law enforcement to obtain a judicial warrant to enter a home, absent an emergency or consent. Are CBP personnel similarly being permitted to enter residences without a judicial warrant to conduct civil immigration arrests? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS does not comment on pending litigation. Question 5b. If so, what criteria, if any, must be met before CBP personnel may enter a home without a judicial warrant or permission to enter? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS does not comment on pending litigation. Question 5c. May force be used to enter homes without judicial warrants? If so, what are the limits on the type and amount of force that can be used? What are the consequences for CBP personnel who violate those limits? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS does not comment on pending litigation. Question 6a. Commissioner Scott, journalists report that U.S. citizens who criticize immigration raids have been receiving letters notifying them that their Global Entry and Transportation Security Administration travel privileges have been revoked. How many individuals who criticized immigration enforcement activities or participated in protests had their trusted traveler program status revoked? Answer. CBP does not deny or revoke Global Entry, or any other Trusted Traveler Program membership simply because an individual exercises their First Amendment rights. CBP is reviewing alleged cases of U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents whose Global Entry or Trusted Traveler Program benefits were revoked due to participation in First Amendment activities. Each case is being reviewed by the CBP Ombudsman to determine if the individual circumstances of each case warrant a sustained revocation or membership reinstatement, in accordance with program eligibility requirements detailed in 8 CFR 235.12(b). Question 6b. What is CBP's policy on this? Answer. CBP's policy regarding Global Entry program eligibility and revocations remains unchanged. Pursuant to 8 CFR 235.12(b)(2), Global Entry membership can be denied or revoked for reasons such as pending criminal charges and outstanding warrants; violation of customs, immigration, or agriculture regulations; or inability to satisfy CBP of low-risk status. If individuals feel their Global Entry membership was denied or revoked in error or based on inaccurate information, they may seek reconsideration through the CBP Ombudsman via their Trusted Traveler Program account. Question 7a. Commissioner Scott, it is my understanding that the ``commander-at-large'' role was created specifically for Gregory Bovino and does not appear in CBP's formal organizational structure. Who authorized the creation of this role? Answer. Operations may commonly require various employees to perform duties that correspond with cascading leadership roles that are required to meet emerging operational requirements, such as those which arose during a nationally-scoped Operation like At Large. Question 7b. While Gregory Bovino fulfilled this role, who did he report to? Answer. He reported to his chain of command, which includes the Department of Homeland Security and the subordinate component and sub- component chains of command. Question 7c. Gregory Bovino still operates an X account with the commander-at-large title. Does he still possess that title? What role does he currently fulfill within CBP? Answer. Gregory Bovino was the Chief Patrol Agent of the El Centro Sector until his retirement in March 2026. Question 8a. Commissioner Scott, the unnecessary separation of children from parents or legal guardians results in long-term trauma to children and renders them more vulnerable to trafficking and exploitation. Today, separations are being carried out by agents all around the country, leaving children at home without caretakers, or placed in the custody of the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) or State foster care systems. What procedures are in place to document any instances of family separation and the basis for those separations, including separations that occur in the interior of the United States? Answer. For separations that occur at the border, CBP complies with the Ms. L v. ICE settlement agreement. In the limited circumstances in which a family separation is warranted, the separation is documented in CBP systems of records. Unless a document contains national security information or other sensitive information prohibited from disclosure by law, all documents supporting the separation will also be included in the A-Files of both the parent or legal guardian and child. Question 8b. How can a parent challenge a separation if they believe it was unlawful? Answer. Parents and legal guardians are made aware of their child's location and the general reason for the separation. They are also provided information about the process for submitting additional information to the Government regarding their case. The intent is to eventually re-unify the family unit once the reason for the separation has ended. Question 8c. Since January 2025, how many children has CBP transferred to ORR custody? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Unaccompanied Alien Children Component January 20, 2025-February 10, 2026 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ OFO..................................................... 355 USBP.................................................... 4,734 --------------- Total............................................. 5,089 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Question 8d. Please describe the procedures in place to document any instances of family separations resulting from enforcement actions conducted in the interior of the United States. Answer. CBP follows the procedures outlined above. Question 8e. Please describe practices and procedures, including sharing and relevant written guidance, for parents in CBP custody to coordinate care for their children. Answer. CBP policy provides that, if a parent or legal guardian is separated from their child, they are advised orally of the separation. Additionally, they are provided with information about the reason for the separation, information about how to contact their child(ren) following the separation, and information about the separation process is explained to them in a language they understand. CBP policy provides that, when referring a child to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services' Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), CBP shares the following information with ORR, to the extent legally permissible: the fact that the child was separated from their parent or legal guardian; the parent's or legal guardian's location and contact information, if known; the reason for the separation, including facts specific to the individual parent or legal guardian at a level of detail that does not disclose national security or other sensitive information; any known or reported information regarding special needs of the child; and any information regarding the parent or legal guardian that might assist with reunification. CBP policy provides that, if a parent or legal guardian is transferred to the custody of the U.S. Marshals Service, CBP shares the fact that the child was separated from their parent or legal guardian; the reason for the separation; and location of the separated child's ORR placement (if known). CBP policy provides that, if a parent or legal guardian is transferred to the custody of a State or local agency, CBP informs the State or local entity that the parent or legal guardian was separated from their child and, if the child has been referred to ORR and the information is known at the time of referral, information on how the parent or legal guardian may contact their child. Questions From Honorable Delia C. Ramirez for Rodney S. Scott Question 1a. CBP is proposing to require social media information, in addition to other information, on ESTA applications. OIRA rejected a similar, though in certain ways less sweeping, DHS proposal a few years ago. It said that, ``[s]hould the agency desire to submit a similar proposal in the future, it must demonstrate the practical utility of collecting it and demonstrate that such utility outweighs the costs-- both monetary and social--of doing so.'' What new evidence, if any, has CBP submitted to demonstrate the practical utility of collecting social media information on ESTA applications? Answer. This proposal is being made to comply with an Executive Order (14161) that requires that any alien seeking a visa or other immigration benefit be held to a uniform standard for screening and vetting. The U.S. Department of State has required most visa applicants to provide social media information since May 2019; this change would bring Visa Waiver Program applicants up to the standards of screening and vetting that are already required of visa applicants. Question 1b. Given the significant monetary and social costs-- including but not limited to the collection's dramatic chilling effect on on-line speech and association, and its significant deterrent effect on travel to the United States--how will CBP demonstrate that the practical utility of this collection outweighs those costs? Answer. The purpose of the Electronic System for Travel Authorization is to add an additional layer of security allowing DHS to determine, in advance of travel, whether an individual is eligible to travel to the United States under the Visa Waiver Program, and whether such travel poses a law enforcement or security risk. To accomplish this purpose, Congress authorized DHS ``to collect such biographical and other information as the Secretary of Homeland Security determines necessary.'' 8 U.S.C. 1187(h)(3)(A) (emphasis added). Social media helps differentiate individuals of concern from legitimate travelers and can provide positive, confirmatory information to verify an applicant's identity and intentions. It can also be used to identify potential deception, fraud, or previously unidentified national security or law enforcement concerns. Question 2. A $2 million contract between the U.S. branch of the Israeli spyware vendor Paragon Solutions and the cyber division of U.S. Homeland Security Investigations was quietly reenabled in September 2025 after having been put on a stop work order pending review. Spyware like Paragon's Graphite poses a profound threat to free speech and privacy. It has already been used against journalists, human rights advocates, and political dissidents around the world. Publicly- available information indicates that the Paragon contract at issue is with ICE. Are there any other agreements, formal or informal, between Paragon and the CBP, or between the CBP and any other purveyors of commercial spyware? Answer. CBP is not leveraging any commercial spyware and CBP does not have an agreement, neither formally nor informally, to use Paragon software. Question 3. Please describe in detail the training that ICE and CBP officers receive on how to respond to protesters. Answer. Beginning in fiscal year 2026, all CBP Officer Basic Training graduates receive 24 hours of Mobile Field Force Level II training under the CBP Mobile Field Force Training Program. This training includes topics specific to crowd management such as legal authorities, tactics/techniques for managing crowds, and equipment such as shields and gas masks. The Border Patrol Academy Basic Course curriculum includes a lesson on Crowd Control. The terminal performance objective is as follows: ``Given an operational environment and limited resources, PERFORM crowd control duties, in accordance with the CBP Use of Force Policy Handbook and within the Constitutional limitations of government, specifically the First Amendment regarding freedom of assembly.'' In addition, ``Applied Authority'' (Office of Chief Counsel (OCC)) curriculum includes First Amendment, Prison Rape Elimination Act, and Crimes. Question 4. Please describe in detail the training ICE and CBP officers receive on the rights of members of the press who are reporting on ICE/CBP activities. Answer. All CBP Officer Basic Training graduates receive in-depth training on the 1st and 4th Amendments to the Constitution from OCC. To renew awareness/knowledge of 1st and 4th Amendments, Border Patrol Agents undergo mandatory annual refresher courses conducted by the OCC. Question 5. Please describe in detail the training ICE and CBP officers receive on the rights of observers, and people recording their activities. Answer. Please see previous answer. Question 6. Do you agree that the right to record law enforcement activity is a Constitutionally-protected first amendment right? Answer. CBP recognizes people in public places have the right to record public officials performing official duties in a public setting. Questions From Honorable Pablo Jose Hernandez for Rodney S. Scott Question 1. I share my colleagues' frustration and outrage that this is the first time we have had ICE and CBP in front of this committee. The Trump administration said they were going after criminals, but that is not the reality on the ground. We have seen ICE and CBP target U.S. citizens, legal permanent residents, and individuals with lawful immigration status. They operate with complete disregard for people's legal status and their safety. We also see ICE and CBP's constant illegal actions and abuses towards individuals with a severe lack of accountability for their harmful actions. Accountability is the foundation of justice. Without accountability, crime worsens and trust in the system breaks down, and the trust in ICE and CBP is at all-time lows. People do not trust these agencies to keep them safe or do the right thing. In my district, I've had constituents taken off the streets by CBP officers, forced onto planes, and carried thousands of miles away to detention facilities. CBP agents have violated their own policies by refusing to let my constituents in detention communicate with their lawyers. Commissioner Scott, on May 29, 2025, my constituent, a domestic violence survivor with an approved self-petition under the Violence Against Women Act was abducted off the street and taken to an ICE detention facility in Texas.\3\ She had a pending application for adjustment of status. In order to find her location, I sent a letter, along with 17 other Members of Congress, to Mr. Lyons and Ms. Anda- Ybarra, requesting information about her whereabouts.\4\ Her lawyer didn't know, so she clearly hadn't been given the opportunity to contact her. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ https://www.metro.pr/noticias/2025/06/30/fue-como-una- pesadilla-aracelys-terrero-regresa-a-puerto-rico-tras-30-dias-detenida- en-estados-unidos/. \4\ https://hernandez.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/ hernandez.house.gov/.les/evo-media-document/250611-letter-to-ice-re- aracelis-terrero-mota.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Why did your agents target someone with an approved Violence Against Women Act petition and a pending adjustment of status? Answer. USBP does not have sufficient information needed in this question, pertaining to this specific allegation, to provide a response. Question 2. What is your policy about allowing individuals to contact lawyers or family in detention? Answer. CBP follows Title 8, Code of Federal Regulations (8 CFR) Section 292.5(b), which states: ``Right to representation. Whenever an examination is provided for in this chapter, the person involved shall have the right to be represented by an attorney or representative who shall be permitted to examine or cross-examine such person and witnesses, to introduce evidence, to make objections which shall be stated succinctly and entered on the record, and to submit briefs. Provided that nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to provide any applicant for admission in either primary or secondary inspection the right to representation, unless the applicant for admission has been referred for become the focus of a criminal investigation, asylum screening, and/or judicial review/proceeding and has been taken into custody.'' Additionally, all juveniles are provided with the Form I-770, which advises juveniles of the right to make a phone call. Additionally, all aliens who are issued a Notice to Appear in immigration court are provided with a list of free legal service providers. All individuals may also contact the consulate of their home country if they desire. Additional phone access may be granted depending on operational feasibility. Questions From Honorable Nellie Pou for Rodney S. Scott Question 1a. Director Lyons and Commissioner Scott: Will ICE and CBP commit to pausing immigration enforcement operations at and around the World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events? Question 1b. If no, please provide all guidance and information pertaining to ICE's intended immigration enforcement actions, including but not limited information regarding: i. The number of ICE and CBP agents are expected to be present at the World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events; ii. The length of time ICE and CBP agents will be present at World Cup matches and FIFA-related fan events; iii. The locations ICE and CBP agents intend to patrol and conduct enforcement activities (including answers on whether agents will be performing enforcement on public transit such as New Jersey Transit and the Port Authority Trans-Hudson Line); iv. What training DHS is providing to ICE and CBP to conduct its enforcement activities; v. What guidance DHS has provided to ICE and CBP in how to conduct its enforcement actions; vi. Any and all coordination plans ICE and CBP are providing to State and local law enforcement as it relates to immigration enforcement activities; and vii. Any and all guidance between ICE, CBP, and State and local law enforcement when fans or players may be detained by ICE, including processes to allow detained players or fans to inform their legal counsel, team, or family members of their detention. Answer. While detailed security plans that may compromise our operations to keep people safe cannot be disclosed, both U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and CBP may have a presence at large-scale events and celebrations that are unrelated to immigration enforcement. During Special Event Assessment Rating events, such as the Super Bowl and/or FIFA World Cup, Federal law enforcement is typically involved to support overall security operations. These types of activities typically include: CBP.--Provides assets including aviation security, video surveillance capabilities, and non-intrusive inspection of vehicles and cargo support. CBP officers will scan vehicles and cargo entering the stadium for contraband such as narcotics, weapons, and explosives. CBP plays a critical role in the fight against human trafficking and the disruption of counterfeit merchandise smuggling operations. ICE.--Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) deploys task forces to identify and combat human trafficking, as well as intellectual property enforcement teams. CBP and HSI conduct operations targeting counterfeit vendors and merchants of game-related sportswear as part of a crackdown on intellectual property rights violations. These operations help ensure fans are receiving official, safe memorabilia. International visitors who legally come to the United States for the FIFA World Cup have nothing to worry about. What makes someone a target for immigration enforcement is whether they are illegally in the United States. Question 2. Director Lyons and Commissioner Scott, which law enforcement entities would have jurisdiction over individuals arrested or detained at World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events? Answer. Jurisdiction over individuals arrested or detained at FIFA World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events depends on the nature of the offense and the location of the incident. Federal, State, and local law enforcement agencies may all have jurisdiction, either independently or jointly, depending on the circumstances: Federal Law Enforcement.--If the offense involves Federal statutes (such as terrorism or crimes crossing State lines), Federal agencies such as DHS, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, or other relevant entities may assume jurisdiction. State Law Enforcement.--State police or other State-level agencies would have jurisdiction over violations of State laws occurring within their respective States. Local Law Enforcement.--Local police departments and sheriffs' offices have primary jurisdiction over offenses committed within their municipalities or counties. Additionally, coordination among these agencies is common during large-scale international events like the FIFA World Cup to ensure public safety and effective law enforcement response. Questions From Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino for Joseph B. Edlow Question 1a. As you know, various U.S. industries utilize the H-1B visa program to hire for specialty occupations, which helps to bolster domestic competitiveness and innovation in cutting-edge fields such as health care. This past year, a new $100,000 fee was implemented for H- 1B visa applications. What prompted the decision to implement this fee? Answer. On September 19, 2025, President Trump signed Presidential Proclamation 10973, Restriction on Entry of Certain Nonimmigrant Workers (90 FR 46027 Sep. 24, 2025), requiring new H-1B petitions filed at or after 12:01 a.m. Eastern Daylight Time on September 21, 2025, to be accompanied by an additional $100,000 payment as a condition of eligibility. Question 1b. Nearly 25 percent of practicing U.S. physicians are international medical graduates (IMGs).\5\ Health care employers especially rely on IMGs in medically underserved rural and urban areas, where 64 percent of these graduates provide care.\6\ Has USCIS studied the workforce impacts this fee change may have on these areas, and are you confident that patients will not see decreased access to care? --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\ U.S. Physician Workforce Data Dashboard, Ass'n Am. Med. Colleges, https://www.aamc.org/data-reports/report/us-physician- workforce-data-dashboard (last visited Feb. 12, 2026). \6\ Malayala, S. et al., Medically underserved areas and International Medical Graduates (IMGs) in the United States: challenges during the COVID-19 era, J. Cmty. Hosp. Internal Med. Persp. 11(4) 457- 463, doi: 10.1080/20009666.2021.1915548 (2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Answer. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) implemented the program requirements in accordance with Presidential Proclamation 10973. USCIS continues to monitor relevant data and will assess impacts as more information becomes available; however, one- quarter of economic data is insufficient to draw conclusions on workforce impacts. Question 1c. According to the Association of American Medical Colleges, the United States is currently facing a shortage of approximately 86,000 physicians within the next decade.\7\ Since this fee was implemented, various organizations in the health care field have sought exemptions to help address workforce shortages and resource strain across the country. Are there any plans to grant fee exemptions for applicants working in the health care sector to help address current workforce concerns? If not, why? --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Press release, Ass'n Am. Med. Colleges, New AAMC Report Shows Continuing Projected Physician Shortage (March 21, 2024), https:// www.aamc.org/news/press-releases/new-aamc-report-shows-continuing- projected-physician-shortage. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Answer. Section 1(c) of Proclamation 10973, Restriction on Entry of Certain Nonimmigrant Workers, grants the Secretary of Homeland Security the discretion to allow exceptions to the $100,000 payment in extraordinarily rare circumstances. Petitioning employers may seek an exception by sending their request and supporting evidence to [email protected]. The evidence must demonstrate that the alien worker's presence in the United States as an H-1B worker is in the national interest, that no American worker is available to fill the role, that the worker does not pose a threat to the security or welfare of the United States, and that requiring the petitioning employer to make the payment on the alien's behalf would significantly undermine the interests of the United States. Exceptions are reviewed on a case- by-case basis. Questions From Honorable Tony Gonzales For Joseph B. Edlow Question 1a. Director Edlow, the enforcement aspect of immigration law is critical but we cannot ignore or sideline the conversation around legal immigration and ensuring that processes to enter into the country legally are in place for the individuals that are doing it the right way. Can you provide a brief breakdown of the processing times for the H-2A and H-2B visas, as well as other employment-based visas? Answer. H-2A petitions are prioritized in their processing and adjudication. In fiscal year 2026 (through March 2), H-2A petitions for unnamed beneficiaries (generally requiring consular processing by workers outside the United States) had an average processing time of 0.3 months (effectively 9 days). This is without making any sort of exception for such petitions that can now be filed earlier under the U.S. Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) recent H-2A concurrent processing rule, according to which the petition may be filed but cannot be approved before the U.S. Department of Labor's approval of the underlying temporary labor certification. H-2A petitions for named beneficiaries (generally workers in the United States requesting an extension of stay or change of nonimmigrant status) have an average processing time of 1.2 months. H-2B petitions have an average processing time of 3.5 months. However, this calculation excludes those petitions requesting USCIS' premium processing service, which is widely utilized by H-2B petitioners at a rate of approximately 95 percent. For these H-2B petitioners requesting premium processing, USCIS generally takes adjudicative action within 15 business days of the petition being filed. USCIS has provided a breakdown of the fiscal year 2026 processing times for all employment-based classifications requested on the Form I-129, Petition for a Nonimmigrant Worker, in Attachment A. Question 1b. In your view, do you have the resources necessary to securely and efficiently process visa applications across all categories? What does your agency need to reduce backlogs and shorten wait times? Answer. USCIS makes every effort to maintain staffing levels, where appropriate, including with our I-129 workforce. Our agency also continuously looks for ways to efficiently process the respective categories, such as recent centralization of intake and technical enhancements, including electronic processing and on-line filing. Questions From Honorable Gabe Evans for Joseph B. Edlow Question 1a. Director Edlow, I represent a district that is roughly 40 percent Hispanic and is home to strong, successful immigrants, and I am proud of the work my office does with USCIS to process casework for constituents going through various visa processes. Thank you for your agency's work to support legal immigration. To ensure clear communication and open collaboration with USCIS on constituent cases moving forward, I have a few clarifying questions that I would be happy to meet with the appropriate staff to discuss: There have been a few casework inquiries from my office that result in USCIS closing the case or contacting the constituent directly to solve the case without any notification to our office first, or at all. i. What policies does USCIS have in place to ensure Congressional offices receive prompt updates on cases for which they have inquired? Answer. USCIS Congressional Liaisons are instructed to provide a meaningful response to Congressional inquiries within 30 days of receipt. In many cases, applicants and petitioners seek information and assistance through multiple routes, such as Congressional inquiries, Freedom of Information Act requests, and the USCIS Contact Center. While USCIS Congressional Liaisons do not contact applicants and petitioners directly, the Freedom of Information Act branch and Contact Center do, which may explain why your staff does not always receive notification from the USCIS Office of Legislative Affairs. ii. Can we work together to improve this line of communication so we can better serve our constituents? Answer. The USCIS Office of Legislative Affairs conducts briefings for Congressional staff to introduce them to the Congressional inquiry process and the USCIS Congressional Web Portal. These briefings are usually offered virtually and include opportunities for questions and answers. Your staff can also contact a Congressional Lead in the local USCIS office to set up office visits or virtual meetings to establish or improve communication. Question 1b. As you are well aware, processing times for certain visas can change a lot based on demand and capacity. Many constituents take note of the projected response time when they submit an application or form and only reach out to us for help with their case after the projected response time has passed. Unfortunately, by that point those time frames have typically grown even more. i. Does USCIS consider the processing time frame for an application to be the time frame given at the submission of the application, or is it always in flux? Answer. USCIS processing times shown on the website reflect the time it took to complete adjudication of 80 percent of a specific form type in a specific location over the past 6 months. These times are based on recent data and may change as cases are processed, so they are not fixed at the time of submission. Processing time is measured from the date USCIS receives an application to the date it is completed (approved or denied). For more details on processing times, visit: https://egov.uscis.gov/processing-times/more-info. ii. When time lines are significantly extended, does USCIS notify applicants? Answer. Applicants can visit the Case Processing Times webpage and use the on-line tool to determine if they are eligible to inquire about their case, especially if it has been pending longer than the typical processing time. iii. How can we ensure that the processing times for certain applications, like Form I-131, are updated in a timely manner on the USCIS website for public knowledge? Answer. The processing times website is generally updated on a monthly basis. Question 1c. Worker visas, through programs like H2A and H2B, are absolutely critical to the agricultural economy of Colorado's 8th District, which is home to one of the top agricultural production counties in the United States. As I often say, food security is national security, and we must ensure that our farmers have the utmost support to feed our communities. Folks from various sectors within this industry have expressed concerns with me over processing delays and unnecessary duplicate work between various Federal agencies, including USCIS. Will you commit to working with farmers to more expeditiously process forms like the I-129 that are necessary for critical industries to complete their workforce needs? Answer. USCIS makes every effort to expeditiously process H-2A petitions given the time-sensitive nature of agricultural work. As previously mentioned, USCIS will continue to explore avenues for efficiency to better address concerns with processing times, especially those impacted in the agricultural industries. USCIS has created an H- 2A mailbox for cases that have no receipt in 5 business days or cases that have been pending for 15 days or more. The mailbox address is [email protected]. Employers seeking H-2B non-agricultural workers may request expedited processing by submitting a premium processing request to USCIS. Question From Honorable Ryan Mackenzie for Joseph B. Edlow Question. E-Verify is widely supported as a common-sense, conflict- free way to strengthen enforcement at the workplace rather than at the point of arrest. What is USCIS doing right now to elevate E-Verify as a priority, expand participation, and ensure the system is accurate and workable for employers and workers alike? Answer. USCIS is committed to making E-Verify a top priority, ensuring it is accurate and effective. Recent initiatives reflect on- going investment in technology, policy, and user support to strengthen employment verification and compliance. Elevating E-Verify as a Priority: USCIS launched E-Verify+ in April 2024, integrating Form I-9 completion with E-Verify case creation in a fully electronic, streamlined process. This innovation reduces administrative burden, improves data accuracy, and empowers employees to enter their own information, minimizing errors and enhancing privacy. Early adopters report high satisfaction, with over 80 percent of those surveyed indicating intent to continue using E- Verify+. USCIS is analyzing existing employment eligibility verification rules and processes to determine if improvements can be made to reduce fraud and increase confidence in the process. Expanding Participation: E-Verify enrollment continues to rise, averaging 122,000 new employers annually, with 136,000 new employers enrolling and 44 million cases created in fiscal year 2025. E-Verify+ participation has grown rapidly, with more than 350,000 cases created to date. User numbers have expanded to nearly 139,000. USCIS is reaching out to employer agents and web service users, who account for the majority of E-Verify cases, broadening reach and usability. Ensuring Accuracy and Workability: E-Verify uses data integration with issuing source systems to verify documents such as SSNs, driver's licenses, and passports. This helps protect response integrity and reduce fraud. USCIS is enhancing fraud prevention through features like increased SSN locking, which allows both individuals and USCIS to ``lock'' and prevent the use of certain SSNs in E-Verify, reducing fraud. With E-Verify+, USCIS anticipates additional document and identity verification capabilities. E-Verify+ employers report experiencing fewer data entry errors and faster case resolution compared to E-Verify. As additional employer users are added, they will gain these benefits as they transition from E-Verify to E-Verify+. USCIS supports users with tailored guidance, expanded on- line resources, and on-going monitoring to address issues efficiently. Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson for Joseph B. Edlow Question 1. Mr. Edlow, will you commit to not deploying any USCIS personnel inside or in the immediate vicinity of a polling place during voting in a general or special election? Answer. USCIS does not administer elections and the agency's primary mission is the administration and safeguarding of the Nation's lawful immigration system. USCIS staff conduct their duties in accordance with applicable laws and regulations. Any operational activities undertaken by USCIS would be based on authorized mission requirements and applicable legal authorities. Question 2a. Mr. Edlow, under your leadership, USCIS has taken a series of actions to strip people of status that has already been granted to them. For example, you have instructed USCIS field offices to refer 100-200 denaturalization cases to DOJ each month. How did you arrive at the 100-200 target? Answer. USCIS, in coordination with the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), reviews cases where there is credible evidence that citizenship was obtained through fraud or misrepresentation. We will pursue denaturalization proceedings for any individuals who lied or misrepresented themselves during the naturalization process. We look forward to continuing to work with the DOJ to restore integrity to America's immigration system. Question 2b. Are you reviewing all naturalization applications? Are there specific factors you are looking for? Answer. As cases come to our attention, USCIS conducts a legal analysis de novo to. For pending naturalization cases, USCIS conducts a thorough review of the case to determine if all eligibility criteria are met. Question 2c. Mr. Edlow, in Minnesota and Maine, Federal authorities detained refugees--people already vetted, admitted, and living lawfully in the United States--transported them to Texas, re-interviewed them, and then released them when they were again found eligible. How many refugees were arrested in Minnesota? How many refugees were arrested in Maine? Question 2d. How many were ultimately found to be ineligible? Question 2e. How much did these operations cost taxpayers? Question 2f. Do you know how much the released refugees had to pay out of their own pockets to fly home from Texas? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS will not comment on pending litigation. Questions From Honorable Delia C. Ramirez for Joseph B. Edlow Question 1. Pursuant to the December and January memos outline a pause on pending benefit applications for countries listed in Presidential Proclamation (PP) 10949 and Presidential Proclamation (PP) 10998 respectively. Can you provide a list of what specific benefit categories are paused as a result of these memos? Answer. USCIS has determined it is operationally necessary to ensure that individuals from high-risk countries do not pose a threat to national security or public safety. Under DHS Delegation of Authority 0150.1, USCIS exercises its full authority to investigate immigration benefit requests from individuals who may present such risks. The Policy Memoranda, ``Hold and Review of all Pending Asylum Applications and all USCIS Benefit Applications Filed by Aliens from High-Risk Countries'' (December 2, 2025), and ``Hold and Review of USCIS Benefit Applications Filed by Aliens from Additional High-Risk Countries'' (January 1, 2026), require holds on all pending Form I-589, Application for Asylum and for Withholding of Removal, and other benefit applications for individuals from countries identified in Presidential Proclamations 10949 and 10998, pending comprehensive review, regardless of entry date. In addition, USCIS is conducting a comprehensive re-review of approved benefit requests affected by Presidential Proclamations 10949 and 10998 that were approved on or after January 20, 2021, including approved Forms N-400, Application for Naturalization, pending an oath ceremony or withdrawn from an oath ceremony when the holds were put in place. Exceptions to these adjudication holds are outlined in PM-602-0194 and include, with certain limitations: 1. Form I-90, Application to Replace Permanent Resident Card; 2. Form N-565, Application for Replacement Naturalization/ Citizenship Document; 3. Form N-600, Application for Certificate of Citizenship; 4. Form I-765, Application for Employment Authorization filed under (c)(8), limited (c)(11), and limited (c)(14) categories; 5. Form I-910, Application for Civil Surgeon Designation (only for U.S. citizen or national physicians); 6. Benefit requests filed by athletes, athletic team members, coaches, necessary support personnel, and their immediate relatives for participation in major sporting events (World Cup, Olympics, etc.) as determined by the Secretary of State; 7. Benefit requests prioritized for law enforcement where ICE has requested USCIS action to uphold public safety or national security; 8. Benefit requests filed by aliens whose entry serves a U.S. national interest; 9. Benefit requests and associated underlying benefits for programs terminated or discontinued by Executive Order, Proclamation, Federal Register notice, or Directive issued by the President, Secretary of Homeland Security, or USCIS Director; and 10. Automatic termination decisions for ancillary or related benefit requests when an alien is granted Lawful Permanent Resident status or becomes a naturalized citizen. For specific details and limitations on each exception, please refer to Attachment A. In addition, USCIS established an internal process for lifting holds on individual or group cases, requiring comprehensive review by multiple offices. Exceptions are determined exclusively by USCIS either during the standard review of the benefit request or in response to litigation. Exceptions are granted only in limited circumstances. The 10 exceptions listed in PM-602-0194 are automatically applied by USCIS officers during adjudication of a case. As stated in the March 30, 2026, update, holds have been lifted for aliens vetted through Operation PARRIS, certain petitions filed by U.S. citizens, intercountry adoption forms, certain rescheduled oath ceremonies, statutory and regulatory decision issuance, refugee registrations for South African citizens/nationals, certain special immigrant visa petitions, certain employment authorization documents, asylum applications from non-high-risk countries, and applications associated with medical physicians. We continue to review all application types and lift holds for both individual and group cases as appropriate and will communicate any changes or updates to the process through official channels. Question 2a. Reports indicate that at least 36 Salvadoran nationals were sent to the CECOT between March and April 2025. To date, only Kilmar Abrego Garcia has been returned to the United States; the rest are presumed to be in prison in El Salvador, if still alive. In several cases, family members were able to identify their loved ones through photos and flight logs and report they had no criminal history or outstanding arrest warrant in the United States or in El Salvador. In October and November 2024, the Inter-American Human Rights Commission issued precautionary measures for 4 individuals whom ICE reported as having been deported from the United States to El Salvador, but who could not be located in El Salvador. Media outlets in El Salvador later reported that the government of El Salvador told the Inter-American Human Rights Commission that they are in prison in El Salvador as a result of their initial detention by the United States Government. Can ICE and USCIS confirm that all Salvadoran nationals sent to the CECOT had final deportation orders to El Salvador and no pending appeals or hearings before being put on the planes? Answer. Throughout immigration proceedings, aliens maintain the right to pursue forms of relief as permitted by law. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) follows all legal requirements for aliens in their custody to ensure they are afforded appropriate process. USCIS completes screening interviews in accordance with statutory and regulatory requirements and applicable guidance upon receipt of a referral from ICE. DHS takes its responsibility to protect the homeland against violent transnational criminal organizations such as MS-13 seriously. DHS will not allow gang members, cartel affiliates, or other dangerous aliens to exploit U.S. immigration laws or threaten our national security and communities. Question 2b. Do any people remain incarcerated in El Salvador under the terms of any agreement made between the U.S. Government and the government of El Salvador? Question 2c. If so, who and what is the legal basis for their detention in El Salvador? Answer. DHS defers to the U.S. Department of State regarding agreements between the United States and El Salvador. When an alien with a final order of removal from the United States is removed, the alien is no longer in DHS custody. Attachment A [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Question From Chairman Andrew R. Garbarino for Todd M. Lyons Question. Please provide the standard operating procedure for your agency for an investigation when deadly force is used. Answer. It is U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) policy to respond promptly to a use of deadly force incident. Pursuant to ICE Directive No. 1044.2, Response to and Evaluation of Critical Incidents Involving ICE Employees, Non-Employee Status Individuals, and Officers Acting Pursuant to ICE Authority (Mar. 3, 2023), ICE employees and other individuals required to immediately report any uses of deadly force to their supervisor when it is safe and possible to do so. ICE generally conducts its thorough fact-finding review of all such incidents following the completion of the Primary Outside Investigative Agency's criminal investigation and adjudication. The policy defines the ``Primary Outside Investigative Agency'' as the Federal, State, local, or Tribal authority outside of ICE principally charged with first response and/or investigative responsibility involving the event(s) related to a critical incident. ICE policy further dictates that the Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) will have the right of first refusal in determining whether to conduct the fact- finding review. The ICE director, ICE deputy director, or the OPR associate director may direct an OPR-fact-finding review of any incident at their discretion. Further, the ICE Firearms and Use of Force Incident Review Committee will review all reported use of force incidents and enforcement-related officer safety issues, when needed, to determine if tactics, training, and policy were sufficient to address the incidents. See ICE Directive No. 19009.3, Firearms and Use of Force (May 26, 2023). Questions From Honorable Tony Gonzales for Todd M. Lyons Question 1a. Director Lyons, during the Biden administration I led a letter to DHS for information regarding ERO's docket and immigration detainers--in response to this letter, we learned some astounding numbers, including that there were more than 660,000 illegal aliens with criminal histories, and more than 430,000 convicted illegal criminals still on the docket. We also learned that during most of the Biden administration, sanctuary jurisdictions declining to honor immigration detainers accounted for approximately 95 percent of the detainers ICE lifted.* How many immigration detainers have been declined since Jan. 2025? Answer. Since January 20, 2025, and as of March 1, 2026, 19,715 detainers have been lifted with the reasons Detainer Declined by Law Enforcement Agency, Early Release, and Insufficient Notice to ICE. However, it is important to note that these numbers do not fully capture the scope of these jurisdictions being uncooperative. When uncooperative jurisdictions decline to honor an ICE detainer, they do not always inform ICE of their decision. Instead, in many cases the alien is simply released once other legal processes have concluded, with no notification to ICE. ICE often will not know a detainer has been declined until an alien is subsequently re-arrested, and/or the case undergoes substantial manual review to attempt to determine an alien's whereabouts. As a result, while ICE can provide the number of detainers in its system lifted by an officer in the field for reasons suggesting a detainer may have been declined, this is likely an undercount. Also, numbers alone do not tell the full story, as often release of a criminal alien into American communities has unquantifiable risk to public safety or national security. Question 1b. What is the level of cooperation we are currently seeing from State and local jurisdictions with regard to ICE detainers? What are the implications for ICE operations with a lack of cooperation in honoring these detainers? Answer. ICE recognizes the importance of its relationships with law enforcement partners to carry out its mission. However, due to many factors, some jurisdictions have decided to reduce their cooperation with ICE. Some jurisdictions have ceased to honor ICE detainer requests, even for aliens who have been convicted of serious crimes and who pose an on-going threat to public safety. This has had many negative impacts including requiring ICE officers to make arrests in less secure environments and increasing risks to the officer, as well as public safety or national security. This lack of cooperation also impacts ICE's limited resources, as the agency must increase its presence in the communities to apprehend aliens with serious criminal records who were released from local or State detention, instead of conducting a safe transfer of custody within the confines of a jail or correctional setting. This situation compromises the safety and welfare of the community, the alien, ICE officers, and State or local law enforcement personnel. Questions From Honorable Gabe Evans for Todd M. Lyons Question 1a. Director Lyons, I look forward to meeting soon to discuss the particular details about how ICE is planning and implementing warrantless searches of private residences to execute detainers. Along with my personal experience in local law enforcement, there are a few findings from previous Supreme Court cases that have led to me being unsatisfied with the internal ICE memo from May 12, 2025, that Federal personnel, civil or otherwise, can cross the threshold of a house without consent or a judicial search warrant to take enforcement action. With only an administrative warrant, or Form I-205, to arrest and/ or remove an illegal alien and in non-exigent situations: Can ICE agents enter the residence of a suspected illegal alien without consent to search for that individual? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) will not comment on pending litigation. Can ICE agents enter the home of a U.S. citizen or a legal resident without consent to search for a third-party illegal alien? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS will not comment on pending litigation. Question 1b. Does ICE track when administrative warrants alone are used to enter private residences without consent? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS will not comment on pending litigation. Question 1c. How many times have Federal law enforcement officers used administrative warrants alone to extract an illegally present individual from a private residence without consent to enter in non- emergency situations? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS will not comment on pending litigation. Question 2a. Director Lyons, in my testimony, I also referred to the dangers of sanctuary policies in the city of Denver and throughout the State of Colorado. How many illegal immigrants in Colorado has ICE had to go into the community to re-arrest that were in State or local detection and could have been transferred to ICE, but were released pursuant to some form of Colorado's sanctuary laws? Answer. ICE cannot provide the number of at-large re-arrests because of sanctuary policies. However, ICE can provide the number of at-large arrests. Between January 20, 2025 and June 4 2026, ICE arrested 4,670 aliens at-large in the State of Colorado. Question 2b. Of the people in ICE detention, what percentage have a criminal history in another country that ICE can see, but that would likely escape a traditional media inquiry that can only access U.S. criminal history? Answer. ICE can only provide the number of aliens in its custody with criminal history within the United States. Leveraging resources such as INTERPOL and the ICE Attache corps, ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) develops investigative leads and locates foreign nationals wanted for crimes committed abroad who are now at-large in the United States. While ICE has some access to foreign criminal history information that would not be available through databases limited to U.S. criminal history, foreign criminal history information is accessed on a case-by-case basis, and the percentage of individuals in ICE detention with such foreign criminal histories is not readily available in aggregate form. DHS continues to enhance its information- sharing capabilities to improve the completeness and accuracy of criminal history data for those in ICE custody. Question 3a. As a former police lieutenant, I know how important it is to have internal processes to ensure accountability and strengthen personal responsibility. I also know how dangerous it can be to work in law enforcement, especially when sensational media coverage inspires violent rhetoric. Director Lyons, if someone in the public feels it necessary to file a complaint against a specific ICE agent for misconduct during enforcement actions, what comprehensive processes does ICE have for such claims and to address any misconduct? Answer. As a law enforcement agency, ICE expects all employees to adhere to the highest standards of professional conduct and to demonstrate integrity and professionalism in all aspects of their work. ICE takes allegations regarding misconduct seriously, and ICE Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) investigates incidents and takes appropriate action in circumstances where it is warranted. Allegations of misconduct by ICE employees can be reported to the OPR. OPR promotes public trust and confidence by ensuring organizational integrity is maintained through a multi-layered approach using security, inspections, and investigations. Allegations of misconduct can be directed to OPR at 833-442-3677, [email protected], or on-line at https://www.ice.gov/webform/ opr-contact-form. Additionally, allegations of misconduct may also be reported to the DHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) at 800-323-8603 or by completing their on-line form at https//www.oig.dhs.gov/about/ contact. Question 3b. How can people identify the officer for a report in a way that doesn't put the personal details of officers at risk for doxxing--which we know is being perpetrated by ill-intentioned individuals, including cartel criminals? Answer. When reporting misconduct to OPR or OIG, the reporting party should avoid including unnecessary Personally Identifiable Information about the employee. OPR recommends providing the employee's name and badge number and/or information about the incident, such as date, time, exact address or intersection, city, State, name of those involved (if known), etc. Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson for Todd M. Lyons Question 1. Mr. Lyons, will you commit to not deploying any ICE personnel inside or in the immediate vicinity of a polling place during voting in a general or special election? Answer. Generally, there is no reason for ICE officers and agents to be deployed to polling places. Please note however, ICE does investigate aliens who violate U.S. law, including where unlawful voting activity intersects with immigration, identity, or document fraud. Question 2. Mr. Lyons, after the killing of Renee Good in Minneapolis by an ICE officer, what immediate changes did you make to interior enforcement protocols or guidance? Answer. ICE takes every use of force by an agent or officer seriously and supports an independent criminal investigation of any deadly use of force. Separate from that investigation, by agency policy, OPR routinely conducts its own administrative review of the incident upon conclusion of the criminal investigation. This includes a Critical Incident Review, which documents the facts and circumstances of the shooting and examines any possible training or policy violations. If deficiencies in training or policy are identified, ICE will make appropriate changes. Question 3a. Mr. Lyons, there have been reports that ICE agents are taking videos of bystanders, observers, and protesters, and potentially conducting real-time facial recognition on them. For instance, Jonathan Ross was recording Renee Good on his phone shortly before her death, and citizen videos have been released that show agents recording them and indicating that they will be identified and their names added to a database. Why are agents taking videos of bystanders and protesters? Answer. Within ICE, investigations and law enforcement actions are conducted based on violations, or the investigation into alleged or suspected violations, of specific statutes within ICE's investigative and enforcement authorities. ICE officers may document aspects of encounters to identify individuals reasonably believed to be involved in, or directly supporting potential violations of Federal law and to aid in potential investigations and prosecutions. If a bystander or protestor is not prosecuted after investigation, ICE follows established laws, regulations, and policies regarding the retention and destruction of records. Question 3b. What does ICE do with those videos, where are the videos being maintained, and under what circumstances are they shared with the FBI, JTTFs, or HSTFs? Answer. Videos recorded by ICE officers during law enforcement operations or around ICE facilities, including those involving protestors or bystanders, are maintained in accordance with Federal law enforcement records retention policies and ICE's internal guidelines. Videos may be reviewed for investigative, situational awareness, or officer safety purposes. Sharing such videos with other Federal agencies, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Joint Terrorism Task Forces, or Homeland Security Task Forces, occurs only when there is a valid law enforcement purpose, such as supporting on- going investigations, addressing threats to public safety, or complying with interagency protocols. All sharing is governed by applicable statutes, memoranda of understanding, and DHS/ICE privacy and information-sharing policies. ICE does not share or use videos for purposes outside its law enforcement, security, and investigative mission, and all actions are consistent with Federal law and DHS policy. Question 3c. What technological tools are used to analyze those videos or the identities of the people in them? If facial recognition tools are being run, what is the legal justification, and what databases and galleries of photos are they being run against? Answer. Facial recognition tools are not utilized in the review of body-worn camera footage. Question 3d. Are the technological tools being used to analyze the videos and identities commercially developed, and if so, by whom? Answer. The use of technology platforms to analyze video and other media in support of lawful investigative activities--including identifying individuals and developing evidence of potential violations within ICE's jurisdiction--is consistent with ICE's investigative mission and is conducted in accordance with applicable laws, regulations, and policies. Any technology used by ICE, including the Mobile Fortify application which includes a facial recognition component, must comply with the DHS and ICE policy and privacy requirements and oversight framework. For Mobile Fortify Use Case Summary, please visit the public-facing DHS.gov website page, United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement--AI Use Cases/Homeland Security. Like other law enforcement agencies, ICE employs various forms of technology to investigate criminal activity and support law enforcement efforts while respecting civil liberties and privacy interests. Question 4a. Mr. Lyons, a Federal court found that ICE officers shot exploding pellets of pepper spray at the Rev. David Black from the roof of an ICE facility, while he was wearing his clerical collar and extending his arms toward the officers with palms outstretched ``in a traditional Christian posture of prayer and blessing.'' Later, after he calmly spoke into a megaphone while standing on the street, officers pepper-sprayed him at close range, aiming at his head, and left him completely saturated with pepper spray. Does the conduct of these officers comport with ICE training? Answer. ICE declines to comment on these on-going investigations, but notes that agents and officers are trained to use force only when reasonable and necessary in light of the totality of facts and circumstances confronting an Authorized Officer at the time the force is applied. Any circumstance where force is used, which is not both necessary and reasonable, including the pneumatic firing of oleoresin capsicum (OC) projectiles or pepper spray, would not comport with ICE training or policy. OC is taught as a controlled tool that may only be used when there is a lawful, clearly articulable reason related to safety or a legitimate enforcement need. Question 4b. Were the officers subject to any discipline or consequence as a result of this conduct? Answer. If an investigation finds that an ICE employee engaged in misconduct, the completed investigative file is referred to ICE Office of Human Capital Employee Relations Unit for appropriate disciplinary action(s) in accordance with agency policy. Question 4c. How will you ensure that, going forward, ICE officers do not assault people engaged in peaceful prayer in accordance with their First Amendment rights? Answer. ICE is fully committed to upholding the Constitution and respecting the First Amendment rights of all individuals, including the right to peacefully assemble and express views through protest. Protecting these fundamental Constitutional rights is foundational to our Nation's democracy and rule of law. ICE policies and practices are designed to respect lawful protests and Constitutionally-protected activities. Question 5a. Mr. Lyons, U.S. citizens across the Nation have been caught up in Trump's immigration dragnet, have been forcibly arrested, detained for sometimes days, and even refused a phone call. What is your office doing to track these incidents? Answer. Please provide specific allegations of such actions and ICE will look into the matter. General, sensationalized questions such as the above do not assist in ICE adjudicating potential concerns. Between January 20, 2025, and April 6, 2026, ICE booked in a total of 2 U.S. citizens into ICE custody. Question 5b. What is the number of U.S. citizens who have been detained, including through investigative stops? Answer. As a matter of law, ICE may not detain or arrest U.S. citizens for civil immigration violations. However, ICE may arrest anyone--U.S. citizen or not--for violations of criminal law pursuant to ICE's authorities under Titles 8, 18, 19, and 31 of the United States Code. ICE law enforcement officers may also arrest anyone who willfully impedes, resists arrest, assaults, or even attempts to kill ICE officers or agents, or damages Government property during the course of lawful ICE enforcement operations. Between January 20, 2025, and April 6, 2026, ICE arrested 2,856 U.S. citizens. During this same time frame, ICE booked 2 U.S. citizens into custody.\8\ ICE arrests and book-ins differ. ICE defines an arrest as arresting a subject for civil immigration or criminal violations of U.S law. Conversely, a book-in represents the first time an alien enters ICE custody in a detention facility. Initial book-ins do not include book-ins due to transfers between facilities or book-ins after being booked out of custody for less than 72 hours (e.g., if an alien is booked out on Monday afternoon and booked in again on Wednesday morning, that book-in does not count as an initial book-in). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ ICE does not intentionally or knowingly arrest, book into custody, and/or remove U.S. citizens on administrative charges. While performing their civil immigration enforcement duties, ICE officers, agents, and attorneys may encounter individuals subject to immigration enforcement who are not certain of their citizenship status, who may have derived citizenship, who claim to be U.S. citizens, who may intentionally conceal citizenship to avoid criminal prosecution in the United States, and/or for whom there are indicia warranting further examination to determine if they are U.S. citizens. However, information may come to light after the arrest and subsequent book-in through which ICE discovers the individual may, in fact, be a U.S. citizen. U.S. citizens encountered during civil immigration enforcement actions may be captured in our system of records to solely document the status of a denaturalization process and other related criminal prosecution. There are instances where ICE conducts in depth criminal investigations of violations of U.S. criminal law, which may result in the issuance of a court ordered criminal arrest warrant and the subsequent criminal arrest of any person in the United States, to include U.S. citizens (e.g., 18 U.S.C. 111, 18 U.S.C. 1001, 8 U.S.C. 1324, 18 U.S.C. 1546, etc.). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Question 5c. Do your officers and agents document all interactions with U.S. citizens, to include investigative stops? If not, what information is documented about these interactions? Answer. ICE officers and agents document all arrests and detentions including those involving U.S. citizens for criminal law violations as part of routine law enforcement operations. This information is maintained in ICE's law enforcement databases. These systems are law enforcement sensitive and access is restricted to authorized personnel. ICE offers the number of arrests, book-ins, and removals of U.S. citizens on its public facing website, which may be accessed here: https://www.ice.gov/detain/detention-management. Question 5d. What is the number of U.S. citizens who have been arrested? Answer. As a matter of law, ICE may not detain or arrest U.S. citizens for civil immigration violations. However, ICE may arrest anyone--U.S. citizen or not--for violations of criminal law pursuant to ICE's authorities under Titles 8, 18, 19, and 31 of the United States Code. ICE law enforcement officers may also arrest anyone who willfully impedes, resists arrest, assaults, or even attempts to kill ICE officers or agents, or damages government property during the course of lawful ICE enforcement operations. Between January 20, 2025, and April 6, 2025, ICE arrested 2,856 U.S. citizens. Question 5e. Why are U.S. citizens remaining detained for hours or days without any charges? Answer. Please provide specific allegations of such actions and ICE will look into the matter. General, sensationalized questions such as the above do not assist in ICE adjudicating potential concerns. Question 5f. What procedures does ICE follow when someone claims to be a U.S. citizen? Answer. ICE has significant protections in place to ensure U.S. citizens are not arrested, detained, or removed mistakenly. ICE Directive No. 16001.2, Investigating the Potential U.S. Citizenship of Individuals Encountered by ICE (Nov. 10, 2015), establishes ICE policy and procedures for ensuring that the potential U.S. citizenship of individuals encountered by ICE officers, agents, and attorneys is immediately and carefully investigated and analyzed. A copy of the Directive is enclosed for reference. Question 5g. After a GAO investigation in 2021 (GAO-21-487), ICE said it would update its training materials to address detention of citizens. How has the training changed since 2021? What training do law enforcement personnel get now about how to ensure they are not arresting or detaining citizens? Answer. Since 2021, ICE ERO training on U.S. citizenship has been expanded to allocate more total classroom hours to the same core material, giving instructors and students more time for in-depth review. In the current (March 2025) lesson used in the ERO Basic Immigration Enforcement Training Program, the updated training devotes an entire 14-hour block to citizenship law and presents extensive scenarios (including complex historical and derivative citizenship cases) so officers can work through real-world fact patterns. Officers are trained to gather and corroborate facts through questioning, documents, and database checks, and they are formally assessed. Question 5h. ICE also said it would maintain data about those arrests and detentions of U.S. citizens. What steps is ICE taking to do this? Where is that information being maintained? Answer. As noted above, ICE officers and agents document all arrests and detentions including those involving U.S. citizens for criminal law violations as part of routine law enforcement operations. This information is maintained in ICE's law enforcement databases. These systems are law enforcement sensitive and access is restricted to authorized personnel. ICE offers the number of arrests, book-ins, and removals of U.S. citizens on its public facing website, which may be accessed here: https://www.ice.gov/detain/detention-management. ICE releases public statistics pursuant to fiscal year 2020 DHS appropriations bill. Once ICE is funded, these reports will be updated. Question 6a. Mr. Lyons, U.S. citizens wrongfully arrested in immigration enforcement have reported being DNA swabbed. Under what statutory authority does DHS justify these collections? Answer. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is required to collect DNA samples from both United States citizens as well as certain alien detainees in its custody pursuant to 34 U.S.C. 40702, and its implementing regulations at 28 C.F.R. Part 28. DHS is taking all appropriate actions to fulfill its statutory obligations, which also supports the Executive Order 14165, Securing Our Borders, issued by the President on January 20, 2025. Specifically, 34 U.S.C. 40702 (a)(1)(A) requires the collection of ``DNA samples from individuals who are arrested, facing charges, or convicted or from non-United States persons who are detained under the authority of the United States.'' Similarly, the implementing regulation at 28 C.F.R. 28.12 (b) states in relevant part, ``[a]ny agency of the United States that arrests or detains individuals or supervises individuals facing charges shall collect DNA samples from individuals who are arrested, facing charges, or convicted, and from non-United States persons who are detained under the authority of the United States,'' and defines ``non-United States persons'' to ``mean[ ] persons who are not United States citizens and who are not lawfully admitted for permanent residence . . . ''. In compliance with 34 U.S.C. 40702, ICE and U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents and officers are authorized to collect DNA from any individual for submission into FBI Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) DNA database who meets the above criteria, unless they fall into an exemption. ICE and CBP collect DNA samples for submission to FBI CODIS from persons in their custody who are arrested on Federal criminal charges, including United States citizens and legal permanent residents, and from non-U.S. persons detained under DHS authority who are subject to fingerprinting and not otherwise exempt from the collection requirement. Question 6b. What are the DNA swabs used for? Question 6c. What are the parameters for retaining this information? Answer. Neither ICE nor CBP uses DNA samples collected pursuant to 34 U.S.C. 40702 for any purpose other than submission to the FBI CODIS laboratory as per 34 U.S.C. 40702(b). Nor does either DHS component retain the samples. All completed and printed FD-936, Request for National DNA Database Entry Forms, and used buccal swabs are mailed directly to the Federal DNA Database Unit/FBI Laboratory. These records are not used, stored, or maintained by ICE or CBP, and there are no new, significant, or substantial changes to existing ICE or CBP records management requirements. Question 6d. Is the information destroyed after citizens are released? If not, why not? And how long is the information stored for? Question 6e. If the information is not destroyed, what system is this information stored in? Who has access to this information? Answer. DHS defers to the FBI CODIS laboratory for answers to questions (d) and (e) since ICE and CBP send all DNA samples collected pursuant to 34 U.S.C. 40702 to FBI CODIS as required by that statute. Question 7a. In a memo dated May 12, 2025, you instructed ICE officers that they may enter residences without a judicial warrant to conduct civil immigration arrests. The Fourth Amendment has long been understood to require law enforcement to obtain a judicial warrant to enter a home, absent an emergency or consent. How is this policy consistent with the Fourth Amendment? Question 7b. What was the basis for the change in policy? Question 7c. Under your new policy, may ICE officers and agents enter a mixed-status home that includes U.S. citizens with only an administrative warrant? Question 7d. Under your new policy, may ICE officers and agents detain and arrest other individuals present inside the home who were not the subject of the administrative warrant? Question 7e. The policy authorizes ICE personnel to use force to enter homes. What are the limits on the type and amount of force that can be used? What are the consequences for ICE personnel who violate those limits? Question 7f. What is the process of obtaining an administrative warrant to enter a home? Question 7g. What is the legal standard for obtaining an administrative warrant to enter a home? Is it probable cause, reasonable suspicion, or something else? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS does not comment on matters currently under litigation. Question 8a. Mr. Lyons, according to media reports, ICE is using a new mobile facial recognition technology called Mobile Fortify to identify individuals encountered at the border or during enforcement operations.\9\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\ For example, see Public Broadcasting Service, Department of Homeland Security Intensifies Surveillance in Immigration Raids, Sweeping Citizens (Jan. 30, 2026), https://www.pbs.org/newshour/ politics/department-of-homeland-security-intensifies-surveillance-in- immigration-raids-sweeping-in-citizens. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- What is the legal basis relied on by ICE for using mobile phone applications, including Mobile Fortify, to conduct biometric searches outside ports of entry? Are there Constitutional restraints in place on such searches of U.S. citizens and those exercising their first amendment rights? Question 8b. What is the approval process ICE personnel must follow required before conducting a biometric search using the Mobile Fortify application? Question 8c. What is the process ICE personnel must follow to review and verify potential matches after completing a biometric search using the Mobile Fortify application? Question 8d. If the Mobile Fortify application returns a match that conflicts with a person's government-issued identification or documentation, what procedures must ICE follow to determine the person's identity? Question 8e. Has ICE provided access to Mobile Fortify to any agencies at the local, State, or Federal level? Answer. In line with long-standing policy, DHS does not comment on matters currently under litigation. Question 9a. Mr. Lyons, there has been extensive reporting regarding multiple technological tools and capabilities that ICE is using to locate and arrest immigrants and to track and identify lawful observers and protesters, including facial recognition, license plate readers, cell phone location tracking, and more. However, there has not yet been a comprehensive accounting of the technology that ICE is deploying. What technological tools is ICE using to locate and arrest immigrants? Answer. To locate aliens, ERO utilizes databases and intelligence throughout DHS and other Government agencies. Additionally, ERO uses information obtained from State and local governments and other law enforcement agencies' information systems and intelligence through partnerships and information-sharing agreements, as well as public and commercial sources, and anonymous tips consistent with laws, regulations, policies, and user agreements. ERO also contracts with industry partners to set up continuous monitoring and alert system notifications for specified new information, arrests, and activities, as well as for using internet research and data analysis and access to person-centric commercial information to assist in the location of aliens. The Enhanced Leads Identification & Targeting for Enforcement system delivers improved capabilities for identifying and prioritizing high-value targets through advanced analytics. Question 9b. Please provide the legal justification for using these technological tools and capabilities to track and arrest individuals as part of your immigration enforcement actions. Answer. As part of its mission to protect the homeland through the arrest and removal of aliens who undermine the safety of our communities and the integrity of U.S. immigration laws, ICE must first identify aliens considered to be removable from the United States. Under its Title 8 authority, ICE officers are authorized to arrest individuals suspected of immigration violations and to remove aliens from the United States who are subject to final orders of removal issued by an immigration judge or other lawful orders. There is no legal prohibition against the use of technological tools that ICE uses in its law enforcement mission. As for information sharing with State/local governments and other law enforcement agencies' information systems, and intelligence through partnerships and information-sharing agreements, Congress enacted statutes to ensure that information sharing takes place for the effective implementation of the Nation's immigration laws. Congress enacted 8 U.S.C. 1373 to ensure that ``no person or agency may prohibit or in any way restrict, a Federal, State, or local government entity'' from sharing information regarding the immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual, with Federal immigration law enforcement agency. Question 10. Mr. Lyons, media reports have suggested that DHS and other Federal agencies have been hitting businesses who are critical of DHS activities with I-9 audits or subpoenas. Is it ICE's policy to audit or subpoena businesses in retaliation for first amendment activities? Answer. ICE takes its responsibility to enforce Federal immigration and employment laws in a fair and impartial manner seriously. ICE enforcement actions, including I-9 inspections and subpoenas related to worksite enforcement investigations, are initiated based on established procedures and objective criteria such as compliance concerns, tipline leads, tips received from the public or companies, information from audits, or referrals from other agencies. ICE is committed to protecting the rights of all individuals and businesses, including the right to free speech. If there are concerns about the fairness or motivation behind an enforcement action, ICE encourages businesses to use established channels to raise those concerns, and the agency will review any allegations thoroughly. ICE values open communication and strives to maintain public trust in its enforcement activities. Question 11a. Mr. Lyons, throughout the Trump administration, armed ICE agents have conducted so-called ``wellness checks'' of unaccompanied children that have terrified impacted children and families. ICE has even attempted to conduct a number of these wellness checks at elementary schools, sowing fear and panic among schoolchildren and their parents. Acting Director Lyons, how can you assure us that immigration enforcement will not harm children attending our schools? Answer. ICE manages several initiatives and operations aimed at enhancing public safety and protecting vulnerable populations, including unaccompanied alien children (UACs). ICE locates children released from the custody of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) who have not had contact with DHS since their release to a sponsor. ICE focuses on the safety and wellness of the children, ensuring that they have not been subject to any form of harm or exploitation, and emphasizing the administration's commitment to restoring trust in the immigration system and enhancing public safety. In August 2025, ICE began locating former UACs who are now adults and possess criminal history, gang affiliations, or final orders of removal. This initiative aligns with President Trump's Executive Orders that prioritize immigration enforcement, public safety, and the removal of individuals who pose threats to American communities. This program closes loopholes in the immigration system that allowed individuals to exploit protections afforded to minors, which allowed these individuals to evade accountability. In November 2025, ICE, along with State and local law enforcement agencies, including 287(g) enforcement agencies, began the UAC Safety Verification Initiative to search for a subset of UACs. This initiative underscores ICE's commitment to protecting vulnerable minors from abuse, trafficking, and exploitation through a whole-of-Government approach and partnerships. Question 11b. Will you pledge to halt ICE immigration enforcement activities of children at schools throughout the United States? Answer. ICE strives to avoid immigration enforcement activities involving children at schools; however, there may be exigent circumstances such as when a child is in danger or the subject of a criminal charge or investigations, for example, where it may be necessary and safest for the minor to be encountered in a custodial- like setting, such as at school. Question 12a. Mr. Lyons, the unnecessary separation of children from parents or legal guardians results in long-term trauma to children and renders them more vulnerable to trafficking and exploitation. Today, separations are being carried out by immigration agents all around the country, leaving children at home without caretakers, or placed in the custody of ORR or State foster care systems. What procedures are in place to document any instances of family separation and the basis for those separations, including separations that occur in the interior of the United States? Answer. Generally, ERO does not separate families. When operationally feasible, ERO accommodates parents' efforts to make alternative care arrangements for their minor child(ren) prior to detention. If a child is transferred to the HHS Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), ERO makes proper notifications and also follows specific procedures for certain populations that are outlined in the Ms. L. Settlement Agreement. Question 12b. How can a parent challenge a separation if they believe it was unlawful? Answer. ICE does not conduct ``unlawful'' separations. For affected populations the Ms. L. Settlement Agreement contains a formal process for individuals or their legal representatives to send information to ICE related to why they believe the separation was improper under terms of the settlement. Question 12c. Since January 2025, how many children has ICE transferred to ORR custody? Answer. From January 2025 to September 30, 2025, ICE transferred 422 UACs to ORR custody. From October 1, 2025, to March 3, 2026, ICE transferred 317 UACs to ORR custody. Question 12d. Please describe the procedures in place to document any instances of family separations resulting from enforcement actions conducted in the interior of the United States. Answer. ICE generally does not separate families as ICE has a family residential center. However, if a separation happens due to unforeseen events such as the hospitalization of parent, discovery of derogatory information (national security and/or public safety) about a family member, or a parent creating unsafe environment for children by being assaultive, the separation will be documented in ERO's system of record on both parent's and children's case. If a child was transferred to ORR due to a separation, ORR is notified of the separation. Transfers of aliens from the criminal justice system--such as individuals who enter ICE custody as single adults from local county jails or State prisons--or the arrest of individuals during interior enforcement actions are not considered family separations. Question 12e. Please describe practices and procedures, including sharing and relevant written guidance, for parents in ICE custody to coordinate care for their children. Answer. ICE follows Directive No. 11064.4, Detention and Removal of Alien Parents and Legal Guardians of Minor Children (July 2, 2025). This policy intends to protect parents or legal guardians who are arrested or detained for a civil immigration proceeding. Under this policy, the alien may coordinate care and maintain visitation with his or her child for whom they serve as guardian and participate in any related court or child welfare proceedings. Questions From Ranking Member Bennie G. Thompson on Behalf of Honorable Veronica Escobar for Todd M. Lyons Question 1a. Director Lyons, Camp East Montana in El Paso, Texas is currently the largest ICE detention facility in the country. The Department of Homeland Security awarded Acquisition Logistics, LLC $1.24 billion dollars for its construction and operation last year. During a briefing on December 16, you committed to producing the contract for Camp East Montana at the request of Congresswoman Veronica Escobar, who represents El Paso. Have you produced the contract as Congresswoman Escobar requested? Answer. The Camp East Montana (formerly known as Fort Bliss) contract was initially established as a Department of War (DOW) project and supported through DOW funding as part of an interagency effort to address immigration detention capacity requirements. Question 1b. Why have you not yet produced the contract? Question 1c. Will you commit to producing the contract before the end of the week? If not, why not? Answer. Effective October 1, 2025, ICE assumed responsibility for the contract. Prior to releasing the contract, ICE must first comply with 6 C.F.R. section 5.7 and issue a submitter notice to Acquisition Logistics, LLC, providing the company 10 business days' notice of requested disclosure and the opportunity to object. ICE has located the contract and is currently in the process of issuing a submitter notice to Acquisition Logistics, LLC, in order to comply with the disclosure requirements for confidential financial information under 6 C.F.R. section 5.7. Once this process is complete, ICE will provide the redacted copy of the contract to Representative Escobar. Question 2a. Director Lyons, in that same December 16 briefing, Rep. Escobar asked you about a series of oversight letters about concerns with conditions and operations at Camp East Montana that had been sent to the Department between September and December 2025. Has your office responded to these letters? Question 2b. What is preventing your office from responding to Rep. Escobar's letters? Question 2c. Will you commit to having your office respond to Rep. Escobar's letters by Friday March 6? If not, why not? Answer. DHS has responded to previous letters sent by Rep. Escobar, and is working diligently to provide a response to any letters from the Congresswoman still outstanding. Question 3a. Director Lyons, are you aware of the inhumane conditions that your agency and its civilian contractor partners are allowing to persist at Camp East Montana? Answer. ICE is committed to ensuring its facilities operate in accordance with their contractual requirements. ICE also employs a robust, multi-layered oversight and compliance program consisting of field office personnel, such as contracting officer representatives and headquarters-assigned compliance staff, who assess conditions of confinement and adherence to ICE standards and policies. Also, a variety of oversight bodies conduct inspections of ICE detention facilities and ICE is committed to resolving any identified performance concerns or other deficiencies quickly to ensure the safety and security of each facility housing ICE detainees. Question 3b. Are you aware of detainees being unable to access necessary medication--such as insulin--that is vital to their health? Answer. ICE is committed to providing the safe delivery of appropriate health care to aliens in agency custody. ICE's National Detention Standards (NDS) and other ICE policies require detention facilities to provide comprehensive medical and mental health care to aliens in ICE custody. Aliens have access to a continuum of health care services, including screening, prevention, health education, diagnosis, and treatment while in ICE custody. Generally, detention standards require facilities to conduct an initial medical intake screening (including medical, dental, and mental health) within 12 hours of arrival at a facility and a comprehensive health assessment within 14 days of arrival. Each facility is staffed by medical care professionals 24 hours a day, 7 days a week; or facilities have a plan in place to provide 24-hour emergency medical and mental health care when no medical personnel are on duty, for direct patient access. Without specific alien names or incident details, ICE Health Service Corps is unable to verify if instances related to medication inaccessibility are present. Question 3c. Are you aware of the inadequate food being served to detainees? Answer. In accordance with ICE NDS 2025, detainees at this facility are provided with 3 nutritious meals a day, specialized diet meals, including religious diets and more than a dozen types of therapeutic diets. Menus are reviewed and approved by a registered dietitian to ensure the nutritional program meets or exceeds minimum U.S. recommended daily allowances. Question 3d. Are you aware of the 3-day lockdown that occurred at Camp East Montana as a result of detainees protesting over having their rations cut in half? Answer. There was no lockdown at Camp East Montana related to detainees protesting over perceived food/snack ration reductions. Detainees expressed concerns regarding a change in the food/snack menu and snack distribution, which were immediately addressed and resolved. Detainees' required daily caloric intake per NDS 2025 was not cut in half. Question 3e. We are aware that ICE contracts out laundry services for detained individuals at Camp East Montana, paid for by the American taxpayer. Are you aware, however, that laundry services are being provided so irregularly, that detainees often wash their clothing in bathroom sinks, and that recently-arrived detainees have not been made aware of available laundry services at all? Answer. Per NDS 2025, Section 4.4, Personal Hygiene, Section II Standards and Procedures, Subsection A, Clothing, Bedding, Linen, Blanket and Towel Supply, ``The facility shall have a policy and procedure for the regular issuance and exchange of clothing, bedding, linens, and towels. The facility shall keep a supply of these items that exceeds the minimum amount required for the number of detainees to prevent delay in replacing the items.'' In accordance with NDS 2025, detainees receive clean clothing, linens, and towels on a regular basis to support personal hygiene. Socks and undergarments are exchanged daily and outer garments and sheets twice per week. The laundry services contractor maintains a log for tracking and accountability. In addition, laundry services are covered in the facility handbook provided to each detainee at intake, to include an electric copy (accessible via the Talton Tablets) that detainees must acknowledge receipt after receiving. Laundry schedules are also clearly posted in the pods. Question 3f. What have you, as head of ICE, done to ensure these issues are resolved? Answer. As part of its critical mission, ERO ensures each of its detention facilities adhere to the national detention standards that govern facility operations and protect the health, safety, and well- being of all aliens in its custody. Regardless of whether detention facilities are owned and operated by ICE, a State or local entity, or a contractor, each detention facility operates under one of several sets of ICE national detention standards. Question 4. What can you share about the on-going investigation into the death of Geraldo Lunas Campos, whose death was ruled a homicide by ``asphyxia due to neck and torso compression'' while in ICE custody at Camp East Montana? Answer. While ICE declines to comment on this on-going investigation, any allegation of inappropriate behavior is appropriately investigated. Question 5. What internal oversight mechanisms are currently in place to empower agents, civilian staff, and health care professionals on-site to report and correct hazardous conditions? Answer. As part of its critical mission, ERO ensures each of its detention facilities adhere to the national detention standards that govern facility operations and protect the health, safety, and well- being of all aliens in its custody. Regardless of whether detention facilities are owned and operated by ICE, a State or local entity, or a contractor, each detention facility operates under one of several sets of ICE national detention standards. To ensure compliance with each contract's terms and conditions and the applicable detention standards, DHS, ICE, and ERO employ a robust and multilevel oversight and compliance program. These multiple channels of oversight allow ICE to provide an appropriate standard of care for the detained population. At the ERO level, ERO Detention Service Managers and Detention Standards Compliance Officers monitor detention conditions through daily on-site compliance reviews to identify deficiencies, areas of concern, contract and facility issues, and to facilitate corrective actions. These reviews allow ICE another layer of oversight by providing senior leadership a unique tool to quickly identify and address issues that occur between or are not identified during annual inspections. At the ICE level, OPR's Office of Detention Oversight (ODO) conducts independent biannual inspections of ICE detention facilities with an average daily population (ADP) of 10 or more detained aliens for over 72 hours. Additionally, ODO conducts special reviews of under 72-hour ICE detention facilities with an ADP of 1 or more detained aliens and over 72-hour facilities with an ADP of 1 to 9. As part of their inspections, ODO partners with subject-matter experts in health care, food service, environmental health and safety, and security to comprehensively assess the performance of each detention facility. At the DHS level, the OIG, and the DHS Office for Civil Right and Civil Liberties, and the DHS Office of the Immigration Ombudsman provide additional levels of oversight, allowing for a layered, multi- level approach to compliance. Question 6a. Director Lyons, in recent weeks, Members of Congress have become aware of the Department's plans to establish warehouse-like ``mega centers'' for the purposes of detaining immigrants. Please elaborate on the Department's intention for these facilities. Question 6b. Who does the administration intend to detain in these facilities? Answer. ICE is reimagining its detention structure and acquisition strategy to address the rising operational tempo and increasing arrests. These efforts aim to meet the growing demand for bed space and streamline the detention and removal process in pursuit of mass deportations. Part of this strategy includes non-traditional facilities built specifically to support ICE's needs. Please note ICE is committed to safe, secure, and humane environments for all those in its custody, no matter what type of facility in which they are housed. As part of this new acquisition strategy, ICE is advancing an initiative with a goal of implementing a new detention model comprised of a mix of ICE-owned and privately-owned detention facilities. The new model is designed to strategically increase bed capacity, ensuring coverage across key field offices nationwide in support of ICE's immigration enforcement mission. ICE continues to evaluate bed space requirements and availability and is committed to strategically using existing detention beds in a fiscally-responsible manner as well as ensuring the safety and security of detainees in its custody. Questions From Honorable J. Luis Correa for Todd M. Lyons detention and arrest of u.s. citizens Question 1. Mr. Lyons, during your testimony you said you were unaware of ICE detaining and arresting American citizens. The U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigation issued a report in December 2025 citing 22 examples U.S. citizens being detained by ICE and CBP.\10\ ProPublica also recently reported more than 170 U.S. citizens have been detained by Federal immigration authorities.\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\ ``Unchecked Authority: Examining the Trump Administration's Extrajudicial Immigration Detentions of U.S. Citizens,'' U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations (December 9, 2025), https:// www.hsgac.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025.12.8_ICE-Report-revised- FINAL.pdf. \11\ Nicole Foy, ``We Found That More Than 170 U.S. Citizens Have Been Held by Immigration Agents. They've Been Kicked, Dragged and Detained for Days,'' ProPublica (October 16, 2025), https:// www.propublica.org/article/immigration-dhs-american-citizens-arrested- detained-against-will. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- How many U.S. citizens have been detained, which includes investigative stops, by ICE since January 20, 2025? Answer. As a matter of law, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) may not arrest or detain U.S. citizens for civil immigration violations. However, ICE may arrest anyone for violations of criminal law pursuant to ICE's authorities under Titles 8, 18, 19, and 31 of the United States Code. ICE law enforcement officers may also arrest anyone who willfully impedes, resists arrest, assaults, or attempts to kill ICE officers or agents, or damages government property during ICE enforcement operations. However, ICE's system of record only tracks book-ins to custody, not ``investigative stops'' that do not result in an arrest. Question 2. How many U.S. citizens have been arrested by ICE since January 20, 2025? Answer. Between January 20, 2025, and May 3, 2026, ICE arrested 2,638 U.S. citizens for violations of U.S. criminal law, specifically in the context of assaulting, obstructing, or impeding Federal law enforcement, resisting arrest, and similar actions. Question 3. What documentation does ICE consider sufficient to verify citizenship status? Answer. ICE has significant protections in place to ensure U.S. citizens are not arrested or detained for civil immigration offenses or mistakenly removed. ICE Directive No. 16001.2, Investigating the Potential U.S. Citizenship of Individuals Encountered by ICE (Nov. 10, 2015), establishes ICE policy and procedures for ensuring the potential U.S. citizenship or nationality of individuals encountered by ICE officers, agents, and attorneys is immediately and carefully investigated and analyzed. surveillance of u.s. citizens Question 4a. Mr. Lyons, during your testimony you said your agency was not surveilling U.S. citizens and you do not have a database of Americans. Last month, Tom Homan spoke about his push to create a database of individuals who ``impede'' ICE.\12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\ ``Homan pushes to create `database' to make those who impede ICE `famous,' '' Fox News (January 15, 2026), https://www.foxnews.com/ video/6387789141112. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Does ICE maintain any separate database(s) of biographic and biometric information of U.S. persons? If so: Question 4b. Does ICE share this data with other agencies? Question 4c. Does ICE retain data on individuals not suspected of being domestic terrorists? Answer. No. ICE does not have an independent database of biographic or biometric information on U.S. persons who ``impede'' ICE. ICE does not identify or designate individuals as ``domestic terrorists.'' Question 5a. Does ICE track information about people accused of interfering, impeding, or assaulting ICE officers or agents? If so: What database is this information kept in? Question 5b. Is this data shared with other agencies? Question 5c. Is this data shared with individuals' employers? Answer. ICE Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) has the authority to investigate and document allegations of interference and impeding with law enforcement. HSI has primary jurisdiction to investigate assaults on ICE employees. HSI uses the Investigative Case Management (ICM) system for documenting investigations and any evidence collected in support of all investigative work. The ICM system is governed by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS)/ICE External Investigations System of Records Notice, which can be reviewed on-line. This system is considered a Law Enforcement Sensitive system, which restricts who has access and excludes sharing of information to the public, including employers. HSI may share certain information about individuals accused of interfering with, impeding, or assaulting ICE law enforcement officers with other law enforcement agencies, as permitted by law and in accordance with established information-sharing agreements, policies, and regulations. Specifically, information about individuals charged or convicted of assaulting Federal law enforcement officers is entered into the National Crime Information Center (NCIC), which is accessible to authorized law enforcement agencies nationwide. The NCIC is a centralized criminal justice information system operated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) that facilitates information sharing among Federal, State, and local law enforcement agencies. Information maintained in the ICM system and shared via NCIC is considered Law Enforcement-Sensitive and is restricted to authorized personnel. It is not shared with the public, private parties, or individuals' employers. HSI does not share investigative information for non-law enforcement purposes. Question 6a. Recent reports have indicated that the Department of Homeland Security is requesting data from tech companies identifying individuals who track or criticize ICE operations.\13\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\ Sheera Frenkel and Mike Isaac, ``Homeland Security Wants Social Media Sites to Expose Anti-ICE Accounts'' The New York Times (February 13, 2026), https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/13/technology/dhs- anti-ice-social-media.html. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Has your agency sent administrative subpoenas to tech companies over the past 12 months? If so: Question 6b. Which companies have been issued these subpoenas? Question 6c. How many administrative subpoenas have been sent to each of those companies? Question 6d. How many people has ICE requested information on via these administrative subpoenas? Question 6e. What information is being requested? Question 6f. Are these requests for information on U.S. citizens? Answer. HSI does not investigate individuals based on disagreements with ICE priorities and operations. HSI issues administrative subpoenas to lawfully obtain relevant information pursuant to its criminal and administrative investigative authority. This authority includes investigating violations of hundreds of Federal crimes that use ``tech companies'' in the commission of crime, such as child sexual exploitation. It is the policy of ICE HSI to not discuss open investigations, but if the request is narrowed, HSI may be able to provide additional information. designation of domestic terrorist Question 7a. Has there been a change in the U.S. Government's nomination process for known and or suspected domestic terrorists to the terrorist watch list? Is ICE nominating individuals or entities as domestic terrorists for inclusion in the FBI's Terrorist Screening Dataset? If so: Question 7b. How many individuals have been added to the domestic terrorist watch list at your agency's request? Question 7c. What are your criteria for concluding an individual or entity is a domestic terrorist? Question 7d. Does your criteria include impeding immigration enforcement activities? Answer. The FBI administers the Threat Screening Center (TSC), which is a multi-agency body that maintains the Terrorist Screening Dataset (TSDS). Nominations to the TSDS are submitted through the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) and the TSC. ICE respectfully defers to the FBI for additional details on the TSC, TSDS, and other terrorism tracking or criteria-related questions. Question 8a. Over the past year, how many times have ICE agents and officers used the justification of suspected domestic terrorist to take law enforcement actions? Is ICE using the justification of alleged domestic terrorist activity to deploy surveillance tools and monitor U.S. citizens to include lawful protestors? Question 8b. Was Renee Good or Alex Pretti known to law enforcement or in any database maintained by DHS prior to their killings? Answer. ICE investigations and law enforcement actions are conducted based on allegations of suspected violations of specific statutes within ICE's investigative and enforcement authority. ICE does not comment on the specifics of an on-going investigation, including operational planning, decision making, personnel involvement, or other related matters. Once the investigation is concluded, information may be made available in accordance with applicable laws and regulations. agent and officer operations Question 9. How many ICE agents and officers are currently equipped with body-worn cameras? Answer. The fiscal year 2023 and fiscal year 2024 funding allowed ICE to procure and support approximately 6,200 body-worn cameras (BWCs) for Law Enforcement Officers (LEOs). Please see the table below for a breakout of current funding (assuming a full-year continuing resolution) versus the additional funding needed to deploy BWCs nationwide. BODY WORN CAMERA PROGRAM ($ in K) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Additional Additional Base One Big Full Year Budget for Beautiful CR Budget Full BWC Bill Act Deployment LEOs ------------------------------------------------------------------------ LEO's supported/BWC units............ 6,200 6,390 11,000 Equipment Non-Pay Costs: BWC Unit cost.................... $500 $4,700 $8,100 Licensing & Storage.............. $2,700 $2,600 $4,100 Ancillary Equipment.............. $100 $1,100 $1,800 IT Security & Maintenance........ $400 $1,200 $1,200 Administrative Operations $1,800 $1,200 $1,200 (Travel, Training).............. ---------------------------------- Subtotal Non Pay............... $5,500 $10,800 $16,400 ---------------------------------- Program Management Costs: Positions: 22 Positions..................... $3,684 .......... .......... Additional Two Base Positions.... ......... $700 .......... Additional Two Positions to ......... .......... $700 support OBBB expansion.......... ---------------------------------- Subtotal PMO................... $3,684 $700 $700 ---------------------------------- Total.......................... $9,184 $11,500 $17,100 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Question 10. How many additional body-worn cameras does ICE own that are not yet deployed to the field? Answer. ICE currently has approximately 250 unissued BWC devices. These devices are used to replace any broken or malfunctioning devices and to replenish inventory at BWC deployed offices. Question 11. What plans does ICE have to acquire additional body- worn cameras? Answer. ICE has a BWC strategic deployment plan that can only be executed if the program is fully resourced. Please see the above chart that provides a breakout of current funding (assuming a full-year continuing resolution) versus the additional funding needed to deploy BWCs nationwide. Question 12. Do ICE personnel have the authority to delete information, including videos, from members of the public's cell phones? If so, please cite the legal authority. Answer. No. use of administrative warrants Question 13. A memo you sent dated May 12, 2025 says that ``the DHS Office of General Counsel has recently determined that the U.S. Constitution, the Immigration and Nationality Act, and the immigration regulations do not prohibit relying on administrative warrants'' alone for arresting individuals subject to final orders of removal in their homes. Can you provide the specific citations justifying this determination? Answer. The General Counsel published an op ed on administrative arrest warrants in the Wall Street Journal from earlier this year. Jimmy Percival, Opinion, How the Deep State Thwarted ICE Administrative Warrants, WALL ST. J. (Jan. 22, 2026), https://www.wsj.com/opinion/how- the-deep-state-thwarted-ice-administrative-warrants- 1a847297?msockid=1c7a20af356066672520365a34eb6795. The op ed references a variety of authorities, which include Abel v. United States, 362 U.S. 217, 233 (1960), and United States v. Lucas, 499 F.3d 769, 778 (8th Cir. 2007) (en banc). Questions From Honorable Delia C. Ramirez for Todd M. Lyons Question 1. Please describe in detail the training that ICE and CBP officers receive on how to respond to protesters. Answer. With respect to ICE, students at the ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations' (ERO) Basic Immigration Enforcement Training Program (BIETP) receive comprehensive instruction on responding to protesters in a manner that fully respects Constitutional protections. Students are taught that the Constitution imposes clear limitations on their authority, specifically prohibiting law enforcement activity conducted solely to monitor the exercise of an individual's right to peaceably assemble, including public demonstrations. When Government actions may impact this fundamental right, officers must ensure any intervention is based on a valid law enforcement purpose. The curriculum emphasizes that officers are prohibited from initiating investigations solely because of a group's social or political agenda, from sabotaging or neutralizing such agendas, and from leading groups into criminal activity that would not otherwise occur. Students are taught free speech is a fundamental right and are instructed that officers are not to diminish an individual's ability to exercise this right. Any law enforcement interference must be related to an authorized purpose, carried out using the least intrusive method, and conducted so as not to infringe upon the speaker's ability to deliver their message. This instruction ensures ERO officers operate within legal boundaries and uphold the fundamental rights of all individuals during encounters. Question 2. Please describe in detail the training ICE and CBP officers receive on the rights of members of the press who are reporting on ICE/CBP activities. Answer. With respect to ICE, students at BIETP are instructed that the Constitution establishes clear boundaries on an officer's authority, and that ERO activities must not be conducted solely for the purpose of monitoring individuals exercising their right to free press. Students are instructed that newsgathering is protected under the First Amendment and warrants appropriate Constitutional safeguards. Accordingly, reporters should not be prevented from reporting, photographing, or video recording from locations where they have lawful access. The curriculum reinforces the importance of upholding Constitutional rights while maintaining operational integrity and compliance with legal standards. Question 3. Please describe in detail the training ICE and CBP officers receive on the rights of observers, and people recording their activities. Answer. Please refer to the above response regarding BIETP training in responding to protesters. Additionally, students at BIETP participate in Field Operations/ Tactics scenarios that incorporate recognition and practical application of First Amendment rights, particularly regarding observers and their right to record. Throughout these exercises, students receive real-time assessments and evaluations from ERO and ICE Office of the Principal Legal Advisor instructors to ensure proper understanding and implementation of Constitutional protections. Question 4. Do you agree that the right to record law enforcement activity is a Constitutionally-protected first amendment right? Answer. Please refer to the above response regarding BIETP training regarding newsgathering. Question 5. How is ICE relying on authority from NSPM-7 or information/databases compiled pursuant to NSPM-7 in its operations? Answer. ICE does not rely on any authorities granted by the National Security Presidential Memorandum-7 (NSPM-7), nor is it compiling or utilizing any information or databases pursuant to NSPM-7 in its operations. Question 6a. Reports indicate that at least 36 Salvadoran nationals were sent to the CECOT between March and April 2025. To date, only Kilmar Abrego Garcia has been returned to the United States; the rest are presumed to be in prison in El Salvador, if still alive. In several cases, family members were able to identify their loved ones through photos and flight logs and report they had no criminal history or outstanding arrest warrant in the United States or in El Salvador. In October and November 2024, the Inter-American Human Rights Commission issued precautionary measures for 4 individuals whom ICE reported as having been deported from the United States to El Salvador, but who could not be located in El Salvador. Media outlets in El Salvador later reported that the government of El Salvador told the Inter-American Human Rights Commission that they are in prison in El Salvador as a result of their initial detention by the United States Government. Can ICE and USCIS confirm that all Salvadoran nationals sent to the CECOT had final deportation orders to El Salvador and no pending appeals or hearings before being put on the planes? Answer. ICE follows all legal requirements under U.S. immigration law for aliens in their custody and who are removed from the United States. Throughout immigration proceedings, aliens maintain the right to pursue forms of relief as permitted by law and are afforded appropriate process. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services completes screening interviews in accordance with statutory and regulatory requirements and applicable guidance upon receipt of a referral from ICE. DHS takes its responsibility to protect the homeland against violent transnational criminal organizations such as MS-13 seriously. DHS will not allow gang members, cartel affiliates, or other dangerous aliens to exploit U.S. immigration laws or threaten our national security and communities. Question 6b. Do any people remain incarcerated in El Salvador under the terms of any agreement made between the U.S. Government and the government of El Salvador? Answer. DHS defers to the U.S. Department of State (DOS) regarding any and all agreements between the United States and El Salvador. When ICE removes an alien with a final order of removal from the United States, he or she is no longer in ICE custody. Question 6c. If so, who and what is the legal basis for their detention in El Salvador? Answer. DHS defers to the DOS regarding any and all agreements between the United States and El Salvador. Questions From Honorable Pablo Jose Hernandez for Todd M. Lyons Question 1. I share my colleagues' frustration and outrage that this is the first time we have had ICE and CBP in front of this committee. The Trump administration said they were going after criminals, but that is not the reality on the ground. We have seen ICE and CBP target U.S. citizens, legal permanent residents, and individuals with lawful immigration status. They operate with complete disregard for people's legal status and their safety. We also see ICE and CBP's constant illegal actions and abuses towards individuals with a severe lack of accountability for their harmful actions. Accountability is the foundation of justice. Without accountability, crime worsens and trust in the system breaks down, and the trust in ICE and CBP is at all-time lows. People do not trust these agencies to keep them safe or do the right thing. In my district, I've had constituents taken off the streets by CBP officers, forced onto planes, and carried thousands of miles away to detention facilities. CBP agents have violated their own policies by refusing to let my constituents in detention communicate with their lawyers. On June 4, 2025, it became publicly known that Puerto Rico's Department of Transportation and Public Works (DTOP) disclosed personal information to HSI regarding allegedly undocumented individuals.\14\ On June 6, 2025, the Governor of Puerto Rico stated that DTOP had complied with a subpoena and was obligated under Federal law to share this information to avoid jeopardizing Federal funding.\15\ However, on June 10, 2025, the head of ICE in Puerto Rico publicly contradicted that claim, stating that no subpoena had been issued and that no such threat to withhold funding had been made.\16\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \14\ https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/gobierno/notas/ice-y-dtop- confirman-intercambio-de-informacion-sobre-conductores-inmigrantes-en- puerto-rico/. \15\ https://radioisla.tv/gobernadora-reconoce-entregaron- informacion-sobre-inmigrantes-a-hsi-en-enero/. \16\ https://www.telemundopr.com/video/primera-pregunta/primera- pregunta-jefa-de-hsi-dice-que-dominicana-detenida-no-cuenta-con- estatus-migratorio/2724024/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Did ICE, HSI, or any other office under your leadership issue a subpoena to Puerto Rico's Department of Transportation and Public Works, yes or no? Answer. On January 26, 2025, a DHS Immigration Enforcement Administrative Subpoena was served on the Directoria de Servicios al Conductor (DISCO) in San Juan, Puerto Rico. DISCO is a division within the Puerto Rico Department of Transportation and Public Works (DTOP) responsible for managing driver services, including issuing driver's licenses and motor vehicle registrations. HSI routinely issues subpoenas as part of its standard investigative procedures to obtain records relevant to on-going investigations. The issuance of subpoenas is a lawful process conducted in accordance with Federal statutes and agency protocols. HSI has the statutory authority to issue administrative subpoenas under 8 U.S.C. 1225(d)(4) that allows immigration officers to require the production of records and evidence relevant to immigration enforcement. When HSI investigates individuals suspected of being unlawfully present in the United States, subpoenas may be issued to State and territorial agencies for data related to driver's license application or issuance. In these instances, records are sought to verify identity, residency, and eligibility. Information obtained may be utilized to support investigative efforts regarding potential violations of Federal immigration laws. Recipients of subpoenas are required to comply unless otherwise directed by a court. Question 2. Was any Federal funding directly, or indirectly, mentioned, implied, or suggested in communications with Puerto Rico officials in connection with this data transfer? Answer. No. Question 3. If no subpoena existed, under what statutory authority did ICE obtain personally identifiable information from DTOP? Answer. As noted above, a DHS Immigration Enforcement subpoena did exist. The HSI Special Agent in Charge for HSI San Juan stated in multiple media inquiries (links provided below) that a subpoena had been issued to DTOP. El ICE pone bajo la lupa a Puerto Rico: piden listado de extranjeros con licencia de conducir y otros datos--LA NACION Redadas y denuncias por venganza: Dentro de la operacion de deportacion del ICE en Puerto Rico: NPR (Adrian Florido) Federales obtienen informacion sobre inmigrantes/Federal/ elvocero.com Primera Pregunta: Jefa de HSI dice que dominicana detenida no cuenta con estatus migratorio Seguiran deportando inmigrantes en Puerto Rico! Entrevista a directora HSI San Juan--YouTube (Sonia Valentin) Directora del HSI asegura que no haran redadas en escuelas, iglesias y hospitales--TeleOnce TV/Vivelo. Question 4a. Has DMV or driver's license data from Puerto Rico been used in the last 2 years to identify, locate, or target individuals for enforcement action? Answer. Yes. HSI has the statutory authority to issue administrative subpoenas under 8 U.S.C. 1225(d)(4) that allows immigration officers to require the production of records and evidence relevant to immigration enforcement including Department of Motor Vehicles driver's license and identification data. Question 4b. If so, how was that data accessed? Answer. Driver's license data may be obtained through a DHS Immigration Enforcement Subpoena issued under the Immigration and Nationality Act or another appropriate legal mechanism such as a judicial or grand jury subpoena. Questions From Honorable Nellie Pou for Todd M. Lyons Question 1a. Director Lyons: There have been reports that individuals who have standard immigration check-in meetings at field offices, including the Newark ICE Field Office, have become detained at these meetings and have also been subjected to being transferred to detention facilities outside of the State. Does DHS or ICE inform individuals prior to these scheduled appointments regarding its plan to detain and transfer the individual at this appointment to a detention facility in or out of the State? Answer. For the safety of the community and staff, to ensure an alien's presence at their scheduled appointments, and due to the availability of detention space, an alien is not informed in advance of their scheduled check-in that they may be detained. Question 1b. Has ICE provided guidance to field office employees on detaining and transferring any and all individuals who arrive at field offices for regularly scheduled immigration appointments? Question 1c. If yes, please provide all materials related to the guidance and directives. Answer. No. Question 2. During the hearing, Director Lyons committed to providing me with a list of the names and locations of all individuals who were detained by ICE in New Jersey and who were sent to other States and/or countries. Director Lyons: Please provide a list with the following information: i. The full legal name of each individual; ii. The date each individual was initially detained; iii. The location where each individual was originally detained; iv. The date that each individual was transferred to another facility; v. The location of the facility each individual was initially transferred to; and vi. The current location of the individual (including any location where the individual was last deported). Answer. Please see Attachment A.\17\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \17\ Due to length and the Law-Enforcement Sensitivity of some responses, the document has been retained in committee files. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Question 3. Director Lyons: Please provide all information related to the reported Department of Homeland Security purchase of a warehouse Roxbury, New Jersey. This includes but is not limited to: a. The location of the facility; b. The intended detainee capacity of the facility; c. Information regarding who will operate the facility (e.g., privately-run, Government-run); d. Expected time line the DHS intends to open the facility to house detainees; e. The number of employees that will work at the facility during any given day; f. The number and type of medical staff DHS intends to have on sight at the facility; g. What, if any, medical capacity and care, the facility will provide to detainees; h. A list of, if any, partnerships or agreements between facility and local hospitals to provide care to detainees that the facility is unable to provide; i. The number of designated areas at the facility for in-person meetings with detained individuals and their lawyers or other legal service providers; j. The number of locations and technology at the facility made available for detainees to conduct confidential legal phone calls or virtual attorney visits. Answer. The facility in Roxbury, New Jersey, is the subject of on- going litigation and ICE is unable to comment about operational specifics at this time. Question 4a. Director Lyons and Commissioner Scott: Will ICE and CBP commit to pausing immigration enforcement operations at and around the World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events? Answer. No. Question 4b. If no, please provide all guidance and information pertaining to ICE's intended immigration enforcement actions, including but not limited information regarding: i. The number of ICE and CBP agents are expected to be present at the World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events; ii. The length of time ICE and CBP agents will be present at World Cup matches and FIFA-related fan events; iii. The locations ICE and CBP agents intend to patrol and conduct enforcement activities (including answers on whether agents will be performing enforcement on public transit such as New Jersey Transit and the Port Authority Trans-Hudson Line); Answer. Releasing the specific details ahead of ICE's presence at any event would place officer and agent's safety at risk. Incidents of interference with DHS immigration enforcement operations have increased dramatically. ICE law enforcement and their families continue to be targeted and doxed, and assaults on our law enforcement staff have significantly increased. In fiscal year 2025, death threats against ICE personnel increased more than 8,000 percent, while threats of assault rose 7,900 percent. Actual assaults on ICE personnel increased more than 1,305 percent between January 21 and December 1, 2025, compared to the corresponding period in 2024. Total threats increased roughly 1,000 percent year-over-year. iv. What training DHS is providing to ICE and CBP to conduct its enforcement activities; v. What guidance DHS has provided to ICE and CBP in how to conduct its enforcement actions; Answer. ICE officers attend the Basic Immigration Enforcement Training Program at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center. The curriculum is designed to expedite training while maintaining the rigorous standards expected of officers. Through classroom instruction and scenario-based exercises, officers are trained to consider a host of factors when conducting an enforcement action while ensuring that any stop, questioning, or arrest is supported by appropriate legal standards. ERO Officers are provided with 14 days of pre-academy training to prepare them for BIETP after completing 42 days of the BIETP training: For newly-hired officers with prior Federal, State, or local law enforcement experience who previously exercised arrest authority, ICE has developed the Virtual Deportation Officer Training Program (V-DOTP). V-DOTP is an agency- specific training program delivered via a FLETC on-line training platform. V-DOTP provides law enforcement instructional material that focuses on Title 8 enforcement, specialized training in immigration enforcement and removal operations, and various other training necessary to ensure that officers can perform their duties effectively and efficiently. Finally, all new Special Agents must meet the same training standards and requirements that have always been required. Special Agent Trainees are required to complete the Criminal Investigator Training Program (CITP), which is 62 training days and HSI Special Agent Training (HSISAT) which is 40 training days; both still have the same qualifications, competencies, and performance benchmarks. Starting in October 2025, the HSISAT course was reduced from 65 to 40 days to remove duplicative and redundant content already covered in CITP or repeated within HSISAT itself. Training does not end when recruits graduate from the academy. ICE officers go through rigorous on-the-job training and mentorship. This additional training is tracked on-line and monitored closely. The baseline courses at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center provide a solid foundation for the situations our agents and officers will encounter in the field. As with most other fields, our workforce never stops learning. Each office is staffed with senior officials who mentor, coach, and train agents and officers every step of the way, preserving ICE's reputation as one of the most elite Federal law enforcement agencies in the United States. vi. Any and all coordination plans ICE and CBP are providing to State and local law enforcement as it relates to immigration enforcement activities; and vii. Any and all guidance between ICE, CBP, and State and local law enforcement when fans or players may be detained by ICE, including processes to allow detained players or fans to inform their legal counsel, team, or family members of their detention. Answer. ICE will respond to law enforcement agencies (LEAs) working at World Cup events. ERO Dallas will designate officials who can be reached as points of contact for immigration-related questions or concerns. Similarly, ERO Newark will utilize a command center to coordinate operations and provide real-time support. Question 5a. Director Lyons: Does DHS have a standard deadline by which it must provide Congressional offices to receive information from ICE after submitting constituent privacy forms? Question 5b. If yes: i. What is the time frame and is it standardized across all ICE field offices? ii. What policies, internal performance standards, or accountability measures does DHS have in place to work to meet this time frame? Question 5c. If no: Will DHS commit to adopting a minimum time line to provide responses to Congressional offices? Answer. No. As each case differs in volume and complexity, there is no standard time line by which ICE responds to Congressional inquiries after receiving constituent privacy forms. ICE is processing an unprecedented volume of Congressional inquiries and thanks you for your patience. Support staff being furloughed or operating without pay for roughly 100 days in fiscal year 2026 only further contributed to an already historic backlog of inquiries, and the agency continues to work tirelessly to mitigate the consequences of Congressional Democrats' refusal to fully and timely fund ICE. While there is no realistic way to adopt the requested ``minimum time line,'' ICE works diligently to provide comprehensive, accurate responses to all Congressional inquiries while also processing briefing requests, facility visit requests, and other requests for information, as quickly as possible. Question 6a. Director Lyons: Does ICE's protocols and procedures for notifying family or legal counsel when a detainee has become hospitalized while under its care and supervision, including but not limited to, sharing information about the date and time of the medical incident, the current condition of the detainee, and where the detainee has been transferred to for medical care? Question 6b. If yes, please provide a copy of the procedures and guidance. Question 6c. If no, will DHS commit to swiftly adopting notification procedures that include immediate notification to family and/or legal counsel when a detainee has been injured or experiences a medical emergency? Answer. ICE's detention standards govern ICE's responsibility of notifying family and/or legal counsel in the case of hospitalization. ICE's detention standards are available on its public-facing website and may be accessed here: https://www.ice.gov/detain/detention- management. Question 7. Director Lyons: Does DHS have an incentive bonus (formally or informally provided) for ICE agents to make arrests and detentions? Answer. No. Question 8. Director Lyons: With respect to detainee transfers conducted by ICE, what procedures are in place to provide advance notice to a detainee's family members and legal counsel prior to transfer to another facility? Answer. Per ICE national detention standards and the ICE directive on detainee transfers, immediately prior to transfer, the sending facility will ensure the detainee is informed, in a language or manner he or she can understand that he or she is being transferred to another facility and is not being removed. For safety and security, ICE does not notify a detainee or their family before the transfer takes place. Detainees are afforded the opportunity to notify family members of their transfer upon admission to a new facility. To do so, detainees retain access to telephone and visitation while housed in ICE detention facilities. ICE notifies the legal representative-of-record of the transfer as soon as practicable, but no later than 24 hours after the detainee is transferred. Question 9. Director Lyons and Commissioner Scott: Which law enforcement entities would have jurisdiction over individuals arrested or detained at World Cup and other FIFA-related fan events? Answer. ICE conducts enforcement and removal operations within the interior of the United States. As a result, ICE agents and officers may arrest aliens who are in the United States unlawfully and are otherwise removable from the United States. [all]