Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- PRICED OUT OF THE AMERICAN DREAM: UNDERSTANDING THE POLICIES BEHIND RISING COSTS OF HOUSING AND BORROWING [House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] PRICED OUT OF THE AMERICAN DREAM: UNDERSTANDING THE POLICIES BEHIND RISING COSTS OF HOUSING AND BORROWING ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ FEBRUARY 10, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-56 Printed for the use of the Committee on Financial Services [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 63-863 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= HOUSE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES FRENCH HILL, Arkansas, Chairman BILL HUIZENGA, Michigan, Vice MAXINE WATERS, California, Ranking Chairman Member FRANK D. LUCAS, Oklahoma SYLVIA R. GARCIA, Texas, Vice PETE SESSIONS, Texas Ranking Member ANN WAGNER, Missouri NYDIA M. VELAZQUEZ, New York ANDY BARR, Kentucky BRAD SHERMAN, California ROGER WILLIAMS, Texas GREGORY W. MEEKS, New York TOM EMMER, Minnesota DAVID SCOTT, Georgia BARRY LOUDERMILK, Georgia STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts WARREN DAVIDSON, Ohio AL GREEN, Texas JOHN W. ROSE, Tennessee EMANUEL CLEAVER, Missouri BRYAN STEIL, Wisconsin JAMES A. HIMES, Connecticut WILLIAM R. TIMMONS, IV, South BILL FOSTER, Illinois Carolina JOYCE BEATTY, Ohio MARLIN STUTZMAN, Indiana JUAN VARGAS, California RALPH NORMAN, South Carolina JOSH GOTTHEIMER, New Jersey DANIEL MEUSER, Pennsylvania VICENTE GONZALEZ, Texas YOUNG KIM, California SEAN CASTEN, Illinois BYRON DONALDS, Florida AYANNA PRESSLEY, Massachusetts ANDREW R. GARBARINO, New York RASHIDA TLAIB, Michigan SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin RITCHIE TORRES, New York MIKE FLOOD, Nebraska NIKEMA WILLIAMS, Georgia MICHAEL LAWLER, New York BRITTANY PETTERSEN, Colorado MONICA DE LA CRUZ, Texas CLEO FIELDS, Louisiana ANDREW OGLES, Tennessee JANELLE BYNUM, Oregon ZACHARY NUNN, Iowa SAM LICCARDO, California LISA McCLAIN, Michigan MARIA SALAZAR, Florida TROY DOWNING, Montana MIKE HARIDOPOLOS, Florida TIM MOORE, North Carolina Ben Johnson, Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Tuesday, February 10, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Page Hon. French Hill, Chairman of the Committee on Financial Services, a U.S. Representative from Arkansas.................. 1 Hon. Maxine Waters, Ranking Member of the Committee on Financial Services, a U.S. Representative from California................ 3 WITNESSES Mr. Brian Brooks, Chairman and CEO, Meridian Capital Group....... 4 Prepared Statement........................................... 7 Mr. Kevin O'Leary, Chairman, O'Leary Ventures.................... 17 Prepared Statement........................................... 19 Mr. Stephen Moore, Co-Founder, Unleash Prosperity................ 23 Prepared Statement........................................... 25 Dr. Darrick Hamilton, University Professor, the New School, and Chief Economist, AFL-CIO....................................... 33 Prepared Statement........................................... 35 APPENDIX MATERIALS SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD Hon. Brad Sherman: CFPB union NTEU 335.......................................... 88 Hon. Joyce Beatty: ``Now Is Time to Build on King's Economic Legacy, Hamilton Says''..................................................... 90 Hon. French Hill: Jay Parsons: Rental Housing Economist........................ 94 Sean A. Dobson: Chairman, CEO, and CIO, Amherst.............. 97 Hon. Sylvia R. Garcia: ``Construction Workforce Shortages are Leading Cause of Project Delays As Immigration Enforcement Affects Nearly 1/ 3 of Firms''............................................... 106 ``Punishing Institutional Real Estate Investors Will Worsen The Housing Affordability Crisis''......................... 109 ``Trump cannot Achieve His Economic Goals Without More Immigrants''............................................... 114 RESPONSES TO QUESTIONS FOR THE RECORD Written responses to question for the record from Mr. Kevin O'Leary Representative Ann Wagner.................................... 117 Representative Sylvia R. Garcia.............................. 118 LEGISLATION H.R.----, the Save our Shrimpers Act............................. 120 H.R. 6962, the Families First Housing Act of 2026................ 122 H.R. ----, the UAE Financial Accountability Act of 2026.......... 128 H.R. ----, the Exchange Rate Accountability Act of 2026.......... 130 H.R. ----, the American Family Housing Act....................... 134 H.R. ----, a bill to set restrictions on the sale of single- family homes by the federal government......................... 137 PRICED OUT OF THE AMERICAN DREAM: UNDERSTANDING THE POLICIES BEHIND RISING COSTS OF HOUSING AND BORROWING ---------- Tuesday, February 10, 2026 U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Financial Services, Washington, DC. The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:10 a.m., in room 2128, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. J. French Hill [chairman of the committee] presiding. Present: Representatives Hill, Lucas, Sessions, Huizenga, Wagner, Barr, Williams of Texas, Loudermilk, Davidson, Rose, Steil, Meuser, Kim, Donalds, Fitzgerald, Lawler, McClain, Downing, Haridopolos, Waters, Sherman, Scott, Green, Cleaver, Himes, Foster, Beatty, Vargas, Gottheimer, Gonzalez, Casten, Pressley, Tlaib, Torres, Garcia, Fields, Bynum, and Liccardo. Chairman Hill. The committee on Financial Services will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess of the committee at any time. Today's hearing is entitled ``Priced out of the American Dream: Understanding the Policies Behind Rising Costs of Housing and Borrowing.'' Without objection, all members will have 5 legislative days within which to submit extraneous materials to the chair for inclusion in the record. I recognize myself for 5 minutes for an opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. FRENCH HILL, CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM ARKANSAS The American Dream has long been a symbol of opportunity, promising economic freedom, home ownership, and a better future through hard work. However, for many American families today, rising costs, housing supply shortages are making those milestones increasingly difficult to achieve, and hence the title of today's hearing, ``Priced out of the American Dream,'' reflecting that reality for many. Affordability has become a serious challenge after years of harmful Biden era policies marked by reckless spending and inflation reaching 40-year highs, leaving households to absorb the consequences of those higher prices and increased borrowing costs. In 2024, we hit an all-time high for the cost of building a single-family home, and it is only expected to grow. Short rates set to fight persistent inflation are driving up mortgage payments, and borrowing has become more expensive. These pressures are squeezing household budgets and limiting opportunity. As the 2025 Financial Stability Oversight Committee annual report makes clear, economic growth is essential to financial stability. In a growing economy, rising incomes make debt more manageable, standards of living improve, and the financial system remains stable and resilient. Since the start of President Trump's second term, we have seen renewed economic momentum driven by pro-growth policies in a clear, regulatory framework. Under the President's leadership, the economy is back on track, reversing the damage left by the previous administration and restoring confidence in our financial system. This stands in sharp contrast to the warnings predicted by many across the aisle just before the President's inauguration. In 2024, Moody analytics predicted that a Republican-controlled government would lead to 3.5 percent inflation, 5 percent unemployment, a recession, and a budget deficit in excess of 6 percent of gross domestic product (GDP). Those warnings were echoed repeatedly by Democrats, who claimed that Republicans would derail the economy. The data has conclusively disproven those assertions. Inflation came in nearly a full percentage point below forecast. Unemployment did not exceed 4.5 percent. No recession materialized. GDP growth is on track for three consecutive quarters above 3 percent, and the budget deficit is projected to fall to 5.4 percent of GDP. While the broader economy has improved, affordability challenges that I outlined remain for many households. That is why Republicans in this committee continue to introduce legislation that address this challenge head-on. We have direct solutions to improve the cost of living for all Americans. Throughout the 119th Congress, we have unveiled legislative proposals that work to reinvigorate our banking system, expand access to credit, and remove unnecessary regulatory burdens. Recently I introduced the Main Street Capital Access Act with Subcommittee for Financial Institutions Chairman Andy Barr to revitalize local bank formation and right-size regulation so that banks can do what they do best: Lending to local businesses and communities. Late last year, Subcommittee on Housing and Insurance Chair Mike Flood and I introduced and the committee advanced, with the support of Ranking Member Waters, Mr. Cleaver, the Housing for the 21st Century Act which reduces regulatory barriers in making building homes and apartments--that are making that difficult. Last night, the House advanced that bill by a vote of 390 votes. In December, the House also overwhelmingly passed Subcommittee Capital Market's Chair Ann Wagner's Incentivizing New Ventures and Economic Strength Through Capital Formation (INVEST) Act with strong bipartisan votes of over 300 votes. This legislation will strengthen our capital markets, promote capital formation, and ensure that America's markets remain a global leader. President Trump has been clear about the importance of addressing the cost of living for all American families, and these bills reflect our shared commitment. Through our work on housing, community banking, and capital formation, we are dedicated to restoring affordability, expanding opportunity, and making the American Dream fully attainable for all Americans. I look forward to our discussion today, our panel, and I yield back. I now recognize the gentlewoman from California, Ms. Waters, for an opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MAXINE WATERS, RANKING MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM CALIFORNIA Ms. Waters. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. $1.4 billion. That is how much the Trump family has pocketed since Trump returned to the White House. Whether it is through peddling crypto coins or through baseless lawsuits against news media or Federal agencies, one thing remains clear: The Trump family cashing in while everyday Americans are struggling. Because of Trump's failed economic agenda, families cannot keep up with the rising rents and shrinking housing options. Workers are seeing their paychecks stretched more and more as jobs grow less security and the dream of home ownership slips further away, and small business owners struggle to access capital and keep their doors open in an economy that is only working for those at the top. What is Donald Trump's response? He floats absurd ideas, like a 50-year mortgage that would trap families in debt while doing nothing to lower costs. He says he wants to cap credit card rates, but he repeals limits on credit card fees and shuts down the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Trump's actions speak louder than his tweets. At the same time, this administration is attacking Federal programs, like Community Development Financial Institution (CDFI) Fund, which helps small businesses access capital and probably the biggest drain on our economy is Trump's reckless and unlawful tariffs. They have raised the costs of everyday goods like groceries and driven up the costs of building affordable housing. You name it: lumber, steel, and other construction materials all cost more. Why, Trump? At the same time, the Trump Administration's cruel attacks on immigrant workers are shrinking the construction workforce. You do not have to be a stable genius to know that, when you make building materials more expensive and deport construction workers, fewer homes will be built. Exactly the opposite of what we should be doing. So let me ask a simple question that every American should ask: Are you better off now than you were a year ago? Your paycheck buys less. Rent is more expensive and job prospects are less certain. Committee Democrats see this crisis clearly, and we refuse to look the other way. Now, last night, we worked with Republicans to pass the Housing for the 21st Century Act. This is a good first step, recognizing that we have an affordable housing program. Can you imagine me and Mr. Hill worked together, and we got something done? Wow. It happened but one bill alone will not fix a crisis of this magnitude, nor can it overcome the headwinds of Trump's terrible agenda. What would really be helpful is if we could hear from the Trump Administration officials charged with overseeing $7.6 trillion of the mortgage market but that is not going to happen. Director Pulte is apparently too busy making false allegations against Trump's political enemies, unlawfully installing himself on the boards of Fannie and Freddie, and pitching terrible and just plain dumb ideas like forever mortgages. Where is the Acting Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Mr. Chairman? The agency that returned $21 billion to Americans who have been ripped off by Wall Street. The agency that used to fight on behalf of veterans and students against predatory lenders. Well, Acting Director Vought may be too scared to come before this committee, and I am pleased to see several members of the CFPB Union, National Treasury Employees Union (NTEU) 335, who took leave to be in the audience today. Mr. Chairman, America's families need a sustained Federal investment in housing. We need strong oversight of consumer financial products and services, so Wall Street follows the rules. We need real accountability so that access to capital is based on merit and opportunity and not wealth and connection. Trump promised Americans a, quote, golden age, end quote but everyone now sees that he really meant a golden age for the Trump family, his family, and billionaire friends. Committee Democrats instead are prioritizing hardworking Americans over billionaires. We are demanding policy that lowers costs, expands access to capital, and protects consumers. Put simply, we want everyone to have a real shot at the American Dream. I yield back. Chairman Hill. The gentlewoman yields back. Today we welcome the testimony of Mr. Brian Brooks, the chairman and CEO of Meridian Capital Group; Mr. Kevin O'Leary, chairman of O'Leary Ventures; Mr. Stephen Moore, co-founder of Unleash Prosperity; and Derrick Hamilton, a university professor at the New School and the chief economist at the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations) AFL-CIO. We thank each of you for taking time to be with us. Each of you will be recognized for 5 minutes to give an oral presentation. Without objection, your written statements will be made part of our record. Mr. Brooks, we will start with you. You are recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF BRIAN BROOKS, CHAIRMAN AND CEO, MERIDIAN CAPITAL GROUP Mr. Brooks. Well, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Waters, and members of the committee, thanks for having me today. It is great to see many of you again. Most Americans know, as you said, Mr. Chairman, that everything got more expensive over the past 5 years as the country experienced the highest inflation since the 1970s and house price inflation was dramatically worse than inflation as a whole. Between 1991 and 2025, U.S. home prices increased at literally twice the rate of background inflation and prices of houses are compounded by high prices for credit. Interest rates remain persistently high, and regulatory pressures have reduced credit supply to a point that is almost as significant as the problem of housing supply itself. So today I will focus on several specific dimensions of this problem. First, let me start by addressing the housing supply deficit. We are about 5 million units short of what would be required to support total housing demand in this country, and one reason is the magical thinking of rent control. I live in Los Angeles, where I recently saw a building on the side of a decrepit--or a billboard on the side of a decrepit building that literally says ``Rent control, an LA tradition since 1919.'' LA's housing cost has been one of the highest in the Nation almost that entire time. Is this in spite of rent control, or is it because of it? In some cities with rent control laws, such as New York, where my company is headquartered, regardless of a building's operating expenses and maintenance or repair needs, not only are annual rent increases capped for existing tenants, but the rent cannot even be increased when an old tenant moves out, and a new tenant moves in. As a result, building owners, including many of my firm's clients, can predict with incredible accuracy the day on which the expenses of the building will exceed the building's income. On that day, there is no further capital available to perform necessary maintenance, meaning that small, deferred repairs turn into major structural problems. As we learned in 1970s New York, the building then fails. It is taken over by either the bank or the city, and the disaster becomes a taxpayer problem without any tenants being any better off. Rent control deters investors from building new housing units because they cannot recoup their investment. So rents rise in those cities due to shortages while rents are stable or even falling in places without rent control laws, places like Austin, Dallas, Denver, Phoenix, which have experienced building booms. Then there are the local environmental, permitting, climate mandate, zoning rules. I mentioned, again, I live in Los Angeles, about 5 miles from the Eden Fire burn zone that destroyed almost 7,000 structures. More than a full year after that devastation, construction has begun on only about 7 percent of those burned-out properties, and even fewer in the Palisades Fire area. LA's complicated overlapping rules on an array of environmental, fair housing, energy efficiency, and similar issues, may not explain all of that slow-rolling tragedy, but it is undeniable it is a significant part of it. The Federal Government can actually address all of this. Some of what this committee passed in the Housing for the 21st Century Act is a great start, but there is more. The Housing and Urban Development Department distributed tens of billions of dollars in State and local grants. Those funds require a finding that local policies promote the construction and availability of housing. Housing and Urban Development (HUD) could declare that some of these rent control and permitting ordinances in fact reduce the construction and availability of housing and refuse to subsidize States that pursue these policies. HUD also has the power under Section 8 and various other statutory provisions to revoke approval or withhold funding to localities that pursue policies that reduce the supply of housing. HUD could further consider preempting State and local rent control, environmental review, climate change, and other anti-housing laws to the extent that they would apply to HUD-insured mortgages. The affordability situation, especially in our Blue coastal cities, is dire enough that all of these options have to be considered at this point. Now, let us talk for a moment about Federal banking policy, something that all of us know well. Since President Obama signed the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010, and accelerating during the last administration, Federal banking policy has sharply reduced banks' role in housing finance. Nonbanks currently originate the large majority of all mortgages, and those loans that are made by banks usually wind up on the government balance sheets of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Ginnie Mae, or the Veterans Affairs (VA). At this point, only about 10 percent of mortgage credit risk is actually born by the private sector. Dodd-Frank is partly to blame since it imposed a series of rules that disincentivize mortgage lending as a banking line of business but, separately, bank supervision, including by my old agency, the OCC, led banks to be very wary of lending to apartment owners and developers. Time and again, those of you who speak to community banks will hear the story of how, over the last 5 years, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and the Federal Reserve have gone into banks and have declared that performing loans that have never had a payment default should nonetheless be charged off in an effort to make sure that they are not embarrassed by another Silicon Valley Bank failure again. That overcorrection has drawn community banks out of the sector, forcing the Federal Government to deal with the situation. In my written testimony, I talk about a couple of other topics, which I encourage you to talk about today, including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and their future. I appreciate the committee's time. Thanks so much. [The prepared statement of Mr. Brooks follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Hill. Thank you, Mr. Brooks. Mr. O'Leary, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your oral presentation. STATEMENT OF KEVIN O'LEARY, CHAIRMAN, O'LEARY VENTURES Mr. O'Leary. Thank you. Chairman French Hill, Ranking Member Maxine Waters, and members of the House Committee on Financial Services, thank you for inviting me to participate in today's important hearing. I want to use my opening statement to shine a light on an issue that impacts millions of Americans. Small businesses are the heart of the American economy. Companies between 5 to 500 employees create 64 percent of all jobs in America every year. If you take into account their use of supply chains to distribute their goods and services, they may be responsible for over 70 percent of all jobs created. Yet, when we create policy, small businesses are often forgotten and instead, we dole out billions of dollars to the S&P 500 companies, who rarely have problems accessing capital. As an advocate for small business, I see this as a gross miscalculation of resources and undermines a growing and competitive economy, which we all want. Affordability is one of the biggest challenges facing small business today and the millions of people they employ. A large portion of increased input costs are the result of radical changes in tariff policy. For decades, tariff policy has been designed to be reciprocal. For example, if a European country imposes a 10 percent VAT, value added tax, on American goods and services, traditionally they would have a 10 percent tariff imposed on their goods sold in the U.S. Over the last 9 months, the administration has elected to use tariff policy as a political tool. I am not opposed to this. I am on the record suggesting a 400 percent tariff on China until they comply with the rules of the World Trade Organization (WTO) that they entered into in the year 2000 and to provide protection for Intellectual Property (IP) ownership, like mine, along with resolving a long list of other grievances held against the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). The U.S. is still the world's largest and most successful consumer economy. So the Chinese have no option but to deal with U.S. demands. However, implementing punitive tariffs on other friendly nations and leaving them in place indefinitely has had an impact on American families, their businesses, and their customers. When tariffs are used for political leverage, the tariff percentages could change dramatically from day to day during negotiations. For example, the U.S. initially had imposed a 39 percent tariff on Swiss imports, but the tariff rate eventually landed at 15. During a brief period of instability, which has only been months, most businesses simply absorb the cost increases and refrain from passing them onto their customers. However, some businesses cannot do this indefinitely and may need to adjust their selling prices up in order to stay in business. I suggest that the current tariff policy needs some, as I call it, fine-tuning. The main issue is this: Why levy tariffs on scarce goods and services? For example, farmers need potash to fertilize crops. Why put a 25 percent tariff on potash when there is not enough in the U.S. to begin with? The same could be said for low-supply commodities, such as bauxite, aluminum, and softwood lumber. The Trump Administration has already taken a step in this direction. Last November, the President signed an executive order reducing tariffs on crops that are difficult to produce in the U.S., such as coffee, tea, and tropical fruits such as bananas and mangos. Housing affordability is a pain point almost in every State. A major issue, as you just heard from Brian beside me here, is permitting. One glaring obvious problem is Los Angeles. If you believe the deficit--as Brian mentioned is 5. Goldman Sachs is out there with 3 million deficits of houses. There are tens of thousands of homes that were burnt down to the ground in LA recently, and virtually zero reconstruction has commenced. Why? This is due to antiquated regulations and bad policy. This is a self-inflicted wound, and it needs to be resolved immediately. Also, providing more Federal and State land to build housing on will also increase supply and enhance affordability. Another policy I want to address involves the digital asset ecosystem. In 2025, the Guaranteeing Essential National Infrastructure in US-Stablecoins (GENIUS) Act was enacted, modernizing U.S. payments and settlement systems by establishing a clear, regulatory framework for the operation and issuing of stablecoins. Many small businesses, notably the ones I have invested in as well, are interested in using stablecoins to reduce transactional costs. In fact, they could bypass credit cards costing 2.5 percent. However, for stablecoins to reach their full potential, comprehensive digital asset marketing structure legislation, like the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act (CLARITY Act), must also be enacted. Without clear rules of the road, digital assets, including stablecoins, cannot fully recognize their potential. The Senate is currently debating the CLARITY Act, with one of the key issues centering on paying interest on stablecoins. The hallmark of the American economy has never been more about regulation, and really it should be about innovation. Enacting the CLARITY Act will enhance sufficiency in the financial services sector and help reduce transactional costs and free friction up. [The prepared statement of Mr. O'Leary follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Hill. Thank you, Mr. O'Leary. Your time has expired. Mr. O'Leary. Thank you. Chairman Hill. Looking forward to the question period. Mr. Moore, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your oral remarks. STATEMENT OF STEPHEN MOORE, CO-FOUNDER, UNLEASH PROSPERITY Mr. Moore. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. It is an honor to be able to testify before you all today. I just wanted to make a few opening points for this hearing. First, ``affordability'' is really the buzzword today, and this housing issue is obviously intertwined in the issue of affordability. I have some good news to report to the members of this committee, which is that, if you look at what has happened in the last 12 months, we have started to turn a corner on affordability. So what we found--and I have been tracking the Census Bureau median income data. Median obviously is the people in the exact middle. If you look at what has happened with real median income over the last 12 months, that number is up $2,400. So that is very good news. What that is saying is that people's incomes are rising faster than inflation rate, finally. So we turn the corner there. That is good news. By the way, it is also true that, if you look at the people in the top 25 percent of income--I just gave the median and then the people in the bottom 25 percent of income, even people in the bottom 25 percent of income, the poorest Americans have seen about a 16 percent increase in real terms in the past year. So you made the point that I think is so critical, Mr. Chairman, about economic growth and economic growth really is the solution to so many of our problems, and it is certainly the solution to affordability. Point number two is that there is good news and bad news on this housing issue. It is almost a conundrum. A home is an asset. For most Americans, the primary asset that they own is their home. For people--for the 60 percent or so of Americans who are homeowners, rising home values is a good thing, not a bad thing. I have always said, if you think rising costs-- prices of homes is a bad thing, there is one thing that is a lot worse than that, and that is falling home prices. We do not want to see that. That is what happens during great depressions and during bad times. One of the reasons that we are seeing--this is good news, by the way, in terms of what is going on. In my testimony, there is a chart that I think is really fascinating, that we really have become a Nation of homeowners and that is the equity that Americans have in their homes has continued to rise over the last 5 or 6 years, which is good news. Today the average equity that Americans have in their homes is about 70 percent. That means they own 70 percent of the home, and the bank only owns 30 percent. That is way up from, say, 2010, when people had less than 50 percent of equity. So this is good news that people are being able to own their homes and for homeowners, it is great news. The problem is--so I own my home--when I see the value of that goes up, I cheer but then my kids--I have three kids that are in their late 20s and 30s--it is bad news because they cannot own a home and that is the kind of conundrum you are dealing with. Third point. This is really critical. Please, please, whatever you decide in terms of policy with respect to housing, please, I am begging you, do not forget the lessons of what happened in 2008, when we crashed the economy, one of the worst downturns in the economy since the Great Depression and this was a result of really bad, bad housing policy. I remember, Mr. Chairman, I was in this very room testifying, oh, about 20 years ago and one of the economists came in--honest to God truth. He said the chances that Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac would ever fail were one in a million. One in a million and, of course, 5 years later, Fannie Mae needed a $200 billion bailout. So Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are not the solution to our problem. They are the ones that created the crisis in the first place. The other thing that is really critical to remember about what happened in 2008 is the number one factor behind people defaulting on their loans was the down payment on their loan. So people with low down payments tended to be the ones who defaulted. People who had equity in their home with higher down payments did not and so I am very wary of policies that tell people lower, lower, lower down payment because those are the people most likely--and by the way, you do not do anyone a favor by putting them in a home that they cannot afford. You know, there is nothing worse than losing your home because you cannot afford it. So that is an important point. Finally, and maybe most importantly, is, if you look at what is happening with housing prices in the United States, housing in terms of where homes are affordable and where they are not, it is mostly the big Blue cities where prices are very high. So if you look at my testimony--and I am almost done here--but I will just show you that the cities that have the highest---- Chairman Hill. Mr. Moore, we will consult your testimony. We thank you and we---- Mr. Moore. Yes. New York, San Francisco---- Chairman Hill. Thank you. Your time has expired. Mr. Moore [continuing]. those States have---- [The prepared statement of Mr. Moore follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Hill. Your time has expired. We will get into that detail with the questions. Thank you very much for your presentation. Professor Hamilton, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your oral presentation. STATEMENT OF DARRICK HAMILTON, UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR, THE NEW SCHOOL, AND CHIEF ECONOMIST AFL-CIO Mr. Hamilton. Good morning, Chairman Hill, Ranking Member Waters, and other honorable members of the House Committee and Financial Services. My name is Derrick Hamilton. I serve as the Henry Cohen University Professor of Economics and Policy and the founding director of the Institute on Race, Power, and Political Economy at the New School, and the chief economist for the AFL-CIO. I am here today in my capacity as a scholar to discuss rising costs and access to financial services. Rooted in these issues are asymmetries in power and economic agency. What has come to be labeled as the affordability crisis is the result of public infrastructure that is over-indexed on profit and speculation and under-indexed on investment in the American people. Over the past four decades, the top 1 percent of households have experienced a tenfold increase in their wealth whereas the bottom have not received that, resulting in the bottom 50 percent of Americans holding about 2 percent of our Nation's vast wealth. These conditions are not happenstance. They are the result of policies that concentrated capital and power, policies that prioritize speculation and profit over productive investment, and policies that treat people as costs to be contained or managed. For instance, last summer, the budget reconciliation law cut Medicaid, food assistance, subsidies to healthcare, student loans, and other essential programs while diverting nearly $4 trillion of our public investment by way of our TAX CODE to the wealthy and corporate sectors. Our infrastructure should first and foremost serve and invest in the American people. People are more than labor inputs to a firm's production process or consumer agents to whom resources might be redistributed to address inequality in a charitable sense. When properly resourced, people are the innovative, productive agents that make dynamic contributions that benefit themselves, the economy overall, and they promote healthy, tranquil, safe, and inclusive environments. That should be the purpose of our economy. Authentic freedom is grounded in resources. These resources include housing, healthcare, banking, and financial services, reproductive autonomy and agency with regards to family formation, the right to unionize and collectively bargain, good jobs, capital foundations, access to quality education from grade school through college, and a free mobility throughout society without the threat and the tension of--a threat of detention and bodily harm from a state-sanctioned terror because your identity is linked to a stigmatized group. Public investment and the capabilities of the American people empower us against predation, address our affordability crisis, and generate positive externalities and productive macroeconomic multipliers that benefit our economy overall. This approach is not new to the American zeitgeist. Between 1948-1979, as a result of government policy, accompanied by strong unions, American productivity more than doubled while wages rose at 90 percent. That reflected an almost 1-to-1 relationship between growth and worker prosperity and clearly firms benefited too. In contrast, the period between 1979 and 2025, a period defined by supply side-economics that emphasized deregulation, government outsourcing, privatization, corporate tax cuts and subsidies, and an outright assault on unions and collective bargaining, productivity continued to rise, albeit at a slow rate, but wages only rose by 33 percent. At a time when trust in Congress is near historic lows, we have an opportunity to demonstrate a governance approach that centers people as the purpose of our economy and the primary mechanism to achieve that purpose. To address our affordability crisis, perhaps we should put our trust in the American people with the resources and public infrastructure to match. Invest in our human capacities, our democratic institutions, our shared prosperity. Choose a governing paradigm that recognizes people as the best infrastructure and live up to the creed of a multiracial democracy with inclusive prosperity. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Hamilton follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Hill. Thank you, Professor. We will now turn to member questions. I recognize myself for 5 minutes of questions. Steve Moore, let me start with you. Chairman Powell recently said that the reason why consumers are angry about inflation is because of the increase in prices that occurred in 2021, 2022, and 2023 or, in other words, consumers are still feeling the higher prices generated from that inflation shock that some of you mentioned in your testimony. He stated, though, that as real incomes rise, which is a point you made, people will feel better over time. So I agree with that and we do not want to rehash in here. Members of this committee, some on both sides of the aisle but mostly on the Republican side of the aisle, in the fall of 2020 said, ``Let us get back to business, take the foot off the gas of the monetary policy expansionism'' and we did not support applying 6--trillion dollars more in fiscal stimulus in the spring of 2021. We thought that was over the top, vis-a-vis the pandemic and the recovery that we had already witnessed due to what was a very V-shaped recovery but you make a good point about real wage increases, and I think the Big, Beautiful Bill signed into law last year speaks directly to for seniors, for overtime, for tips, for taking the standard deduction, for doubling the child tax credit, produce some of that real wage increase. Can you reflect on how you see that coming to pass this year as Americans open up their notice from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and they see a bigger refund this year? Can you reflect on what you think that could do for the macro economy this year? Mr. Moore. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Hill. Mic. Mr. Moore. Quick responses to that. Number one, yes. You are quite right that the inflation that--the American people are angry about inflation, no question about it. They are very angry. Every poll shows that. They are angry about the cost of healthcare. They are angry about the cost of housing. My wife is angry about the cost of groceries. So it is at a boiling point. One thing I would sort of remind people is, yes, 84 percent of that inflation that people are feeling today happened in 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024 under the previous President. Trump is right. Inflation has actually come down. Now, we are not where we need to be. Chairman Hill. Yes. Mr. Moore. We are at about 2.7, 2.8 percent. We want to get that down to 2 percent or below, but the trend is good. I think you heard from Secretary Bessent a week or two ago saying that the trend right now is headed to 2 percent. So that is the first most important point. The second thing I just want to quickly say is with respect to how can we bring housing prices--how can we make housing more affordable? Clearly I think we could all agree that the mortgage interest rate is a big factor on whether people can buy a house. By the way, when I graduated from college, the mortgage interest rate was 17 percent. Nobody could afford to buy a house during those high inflationary times. What we are seeing now is that inflation is coming down and that will make affordability better but the point I am making is the single most important factor in bringing down the 30-year mortgage rate is the inflation rate today and the expectation of inflation---- Chairman Hill. Thank you---- Mr. Moore [continuing]. in the future and that is something even President Trump, who I strongly support, he thinks that if the Federal Reserve (Fed) lowers short-term rates that is going to bring long-term rates down. That is not necessarily true. So let us concentrate on keeping prices stable and the dollar strong. Chairman Hill. I appreciate that perspective. Mr. Brooks, let me turn to you on the subject of--I agree with that macro issue so much, and real wages does a lot to help on the affordability issue. We have put in our package we passed last night with 390 votes--we also freed up banks access to a greater stream of deposits, lowered and tailored compliance costs for our community banks because they make 60 percent of our one to four family construction loans across the country, banks under 10 billion. Can you talk a little bit, with your executive branch experience, about the importance of tailored regulations? Mr. Brooks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is a great question. The idea of treating relatively small banks the same as J.P. Morgan is something that we have had to grapple with since 2010 in the Dodd-Frank Act and in Basel III. Freeing community banks to do what they do best, which is to make loans based on a relationship basis to credits that they truly understand with borrowers in the community, whether that is purchase money mortgages or construction loans or whatever, it is a really big deal. I think the legislative move that the committee made is terrific. I would go further and say there needs to be oversight of the banking agencies to make sure that the supervisors inside of those agencies are not penalizing banks for making the very loans that the committee wants them to make. Chairman Hill. Right. I do hope that, under the leadership, now that we have all the Trump Administration agency heads confirm that they do that, harmonize directed leadership management. Thank you, Mr. Brooks. I yield back. I recognize the ranking member, Ms. Waters of California, for 5 minutes of questions. Ms. Waters. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Professor Hamilton, during the pandemic, there was a lot of bipartisan support for small businesses. We had the Paycheck Protection Program that made sure that community financial institutions, like the CDFIs and Minority Depository Institutions (MDIs), received an allocation, and small businesses were able to benefit. Since then, we have seen Trump and Republicans attack a number of programs and safeguards that help small businesses. For example, for decades, CDFI Fund has received bipartisan support for all of the good ways it has supported CDFIs across the country, including in urban and rural communities. CDFIs played an important role in providing Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans to small businesses, especially after biggest banks turned them down but now Trump wants to close down the CDFI. We have to fight. We have to fight him on this. Professor Hamilton, will that not hurt small businesses trying to access capital and affordable loans to expand their businesses? Mr. Hamilton. Absolutely, Ranking Member. It will not offer precision by which we need to ensure that we have economic inclusion for especially minority businesses that traditionally have not been included in the full prosperity of the American economy. So these programs have relationships. They have capabilities of steering finance in a way to promote economic inclusion, which should be consistent with achieving that American Dream and a melting pot. Ms. Waters. Thank you very much. As a matter of fact, speaking about the PPP program, the big banks basically took care of their concierge clients, and used up all the money in the beginning. We had to come back, Nydia Velazquez and I, Nancy Pelosi, even Mnuchin, to come up with a huge allocation to get to minority-owned banks and also for small businesses. They come here, and they talk about small business and what they try to do is get us believing that they are here representing small business but in essence, what they are doing is bringing the same old Republican arguments about rent control and other kinds of things, getting away from what we are trying to do for small businesses. Professor Hamilton, going back to former President Nixon, the Minority Business Development Agency, that is the MBDA, accepts small businesses owned by people of color and were ignored by the traditional financial system. These entrepreneurs could go to the MBDA and get legal and technical advice on how to run their businesses or access loans and capital to operate. If Trump closes MBDA, will it not be harder for small businesses to access affordable credit? Mr. Hamilton. Yes. The program was designed with a purpose in mind, and we have not completely fulfilled that purpose. So now is not the time to turn away from it. Now is the time to amplify it. Also, if we go back to the point that you made with regards to the PPP program, imagine the counter factual if we did not have it in place. Imagine how many workers would have lost their job in the midst of a pandemic if this Federal Government did not ensure that if employers were to keep their workers employed, that they would receive forgivable loans. Then the points you raise. We want to make sure we have an inclusive economy so to pivot in the midst of that allocation to go to CDFIs to make sure that businesses that might not have been as traditionally banked with the larger banks would also be able to keep their workers employed was what was good for America. Ms. Waters. Thank you so very much. Just quickly, Trump and Republicans also want to stop the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau from collecting data on small business lending. Section 1071 of Dodd-Frank, which I and Small Business Committee Ranking Member Velazquez led in drafting, requires banks to collect the small business loan data. It was finally implemented by the CFPB under Former Director Chopra's leadership, but Trump CFPB is seeking to delay and narrow this rule. As an economist, how does the lack of transparency and data on who gets small business loans and what it rates allow discrimination to persist? Mr. Hamilton. Information is power and then also hidden information allows for discrimination, allows for things to be not transparent so that we can address it. Indeed, the CFPB, we should also consider that origins of that great agency that we have with our government, it came about as a result of recognitions of a financial collapse---- Chairman Hill. Thank you, Professor. The gentlewoman's time has expired. I appreciate your testimony. Ms. Waters. Thank you. Mr. Hamilton. Thank you. Chairman Hill. The gentleman from Oklahoma, Mr. Lucas, the chair of our Monetary Policy Task Force, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Lucas. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all of our witnesses for being here today. The landmark reconciliation bill that Congress passed last year included a number of provisions to update and strengthen the farm safety net. While farmers back home wait to see the benefits of these changes, the President announced the Farmer Bridge Assistance Program set to hit producers' pockets by the end of this month. Mr. Moore, I have waited a very long time to ask you a question. So, in a very concise way, what can the farm economy look forward to with the administration and Congress working in harmony on the economy? Mr. Moore. Well, if the question--sorry. If the question is what can you all do to--first of all, we have a healthy economy right now. I mean, it is an amazing economy, one of the best--I have been in this business for about 40 years. This is about as good as it gets when you have all-time highs in the stock market. You have got rising median incomes. You have got falling gas prices. You have got inflation headed to 2 percent. I mean, it is a good picture, and we should all feel very good about that. The one piece of advice I would give to you all in terms of how you can promote more housing availability so that young people can buy a home is to index the capital gains tax for inflation on residential housing. So, if you look at, over the last 40 years, we have had about a fivefold increase in the value of houses but about a 300 percent increase in inflation. So a lot of the people--what has happened, people are locked in their homes. People who are in their 60s and 70s, the baby boomers who may want to downsize, may have a million and a half dollars of equity in their home; they literally are locked into their house. They cannot sell it because, if they do, they are going to pay a massive capital gains tax, mostly due to inflation. It is an unfair tax, and we could free up millions of homes if we allowed people to index that for inflation. By the way, it is just not fair to tax people on an inflationary gain anyway. Mr. Lucas. Absolutely. I would note when I was in State legislature, we had a piece of legislation dealing with sales tax. The Oklahoma Tax Commission testified before the tax and revenue committee that I sat on that 40 percent of Oklahoma City's sales tax revenue was generated by non-Oklahoma City residents, which said to me that rural America drives an important part of urban America's economy and we have to look at that whole package, and clearly the administration is. Thank you. Mr. Brooks, you have testified that the excesses of the Dodd-Frank Act have significantly diminished lending by banks. What should the committee look at scaling back to ensure that banks are able to lend to grow the economy? Mr. Brooks. Well, Mr. Lucas, thank you for that question. The Dodd-Frank Act did a number of very specific things that made it hard for banks to be in this asset class, and some of them were directly in the statute and some of them were in Basel III as the U.S. later adopted it. Let me just begin with the treatment of mortgages and mortgage servicing rights on bank balance sheets. The quintessential thing that banks do, possibly the most fundamental thing that banks do is they take short-term deposits, and they turn them into long-term loans for home ownership. We all saw ``It is a Wonderful Life.'' That is what a bank does. In Dodd-Frank, capital stress tests and capital ratios were established that disincentivize long dated assets, like mortgage, and makes it very expensive for a bank to hold a mortgage on its balance sheet. As a result, the vast majority of mortgages a bank makes today go to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and thus are taxpayer liabilities. They are not bank liabilities. So looking at capital ratios and stress tests specifically as they apply to mortgages is a way of tailoring Dodd-Frank without giving up the capital gains. That part is really important. The only other thing I would tell you is mortgage servicing rights (MSRs), that intangible economic strip of a mortgage that the banks who make the mortgage retain, became highly uneconomic to hold because banks had to hold capital against those MSRs at a very high rate. So those things made it very tough for your local 1 billion dollar bank in Oklahoma City to be in the business. Mr. Lucas. Continuing my thought, Mr. O'Leary, in the time I have left, how would the INVEST Act scale back red tape and unlock capital for small and growing businesses? Mr. O'Leary. Getting access to capital is the whole deal, actually, because if you see how small businesses--let us take a typical 50 million dollar business that is selling goods and services. Their large customers--maybe a Walmart or Target, whatever. When they go to their local bank or regional bank and say, ``Look, I am holding $5 million of receivables on Walmart; can you give me a rotating loan,'' rarely do they get that. So they go to the hard factoring market, which today is between 17 and 23 percent. That is effectively all the profit they are going to make because on average they make 15 percent pretax. Sometimes it is punitive, but they have to go to those markets to afford the next order to the next Walmart and so they start with 200 stores. They get to 2,000. The system is very broken because they are the best credit risk---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. O'Leary.--and Walmart and Target, and, and, and, and and---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Thank you so much. Mr. Lucas. Thank you, chairman. Chairman Hill. Appreciate that. The gentleman from California, Mr. Sherman, who is the ranking member of our Capital Markets Subcommittee. Mr. Sherman, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Sherman. First, Mr. Chairman, I would ask unanimous consent to include in the record a letter we received from the CFPB union NTEU 335 urging Congress to, among other things, to restore CFPB's funding. Some of the members of that union took their own time to be here. We welcome them. Chairman Hill. Without objection. [The information referred to can be found in the appendix on page 88.] Mr. Sherman. Thank you. A number of Republicans in this room have said the economy is wonderful and Republicans deserve the credit. Please, please continue to say that. Mr. Trump promised us that, if we elected him, things would be affordable, and they are not. There are two things that we could do to make things more affordable, many things, but two of them are to restore the CFPB, which not only punishes those that rip off consumers but, more importantly, prevents others from doing so. Second, I will be introducing legislation soon to regulate the price of all pharmaceuticals because they are a monopoly, and they are a necessity. One of the focuses that I thought would be here on a building--bills discussed for this hearing or listed is the idea of having large companies own single-family homes. I know it sounds good to say that should be prohibited, and I look forward to studying this market, but I will point out that only 0.6 percent of the single-family homes are owned by these large landlords, and we do need at least some homes available for rent. I represent the UCLA area. We have visiting professors. We will not be able to get them to come from Harvard to UCLA for 1 or 2 years if they are going to have to be in an apartment. I would also point out that these firms in effect act as a backstop for builders. They build a lot of homes. They are not sure they can sell them to consumers, and they have got a backup opportunity with those in this industry. Finally, an awful lot in this industry actually build the homes themselves. Mr. O'Leary, thank you for pointing out the great travesty of these crazy tariffs. They are not for fairness. They are not for opening up other markets. We have imposed tariffs on coffee and bananas just to raise a lot of revenue. We do not produce coffee and bananas here. We should tax people based on their ability to pay, not their proclivity to have coffee and bananas. John Burns, an economic consultant, indicated that the tariffs on building materials are raising the price of construction in this country by 5 percent. I am the only Member of Congress that actually got to confront the President face to face. That was a year ago. I begged him to exempt building materials from this tariff insanity. He said he would consider it. I guess he is still considering it because he is not doing it. Mr. Moore, you are right that we should not have Fannie and Freddie the way we did back then. We do not. We have Fannie and Freddie as government agencies where they do not face the peculiar circumstance where they can take a lot of risks, make a lot of money for their shareholders, or socialize the downside. Okay. Section 8 housing vouchers are one of the most important ways we provide for housing but, in some cities, you just cannot find a place that will rent to you with a Section 8 housing voucher and in some cities, half of all the new voucher recipients return their vouchers unused. Dr. Hamilton, what do we do to make the Section 8 program work? Mr. Hamilton. We should require people not to be able to discriminate on the basis of whether they--someone has a Section 8 voucher or not. That is a huge problem. Why should we exclude people based on a government program intended for them to get access to housing? Mr. Sherman. Are there regulatory burdens imposed on those who participate in the program that would discourage them? Mr. Hamilton. Are there regulatory burdens imposed? Mr. Sherman. Yes. Mr. Hamilton. Decent homes. To some extent, we require that there are quality homes that the people have access to, which I think is a good thing. Mr. Sherman. Thank you. Studies indicate that 24 percent of the cost of a new family home, single family, and 40 percent of the cost of multifamily development is attributable to regulatory cost at the local, State, and Federal levels. Mr. Moore, what can we do to change the regulations and the zoning so that we can build a lot more units, especially apartment units? Mr. Moore. Well, Congressman, unfortunately, you all here in Congress do not have a lot of authority over what the cities are doing with zoning, but I am a big opponent of zoning. I think it does--there is no question it restricts--it is a ``not in my backyard'' kind of phenomenon, and it is something that is really restricting the availability of homes. Mr. Sherman. One way we can push them in the right direction is the Yes in My Backyard Act, which I believe is part of the package we passed yesterday. I yield back. Chairman Hill. The gentleman yields back. The chair recognizes the chair of our Capital Markets Subcommittee. Mrs. Wagner, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mrs. Wagner. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank our witnesses. The United States is a country of entrepreneurs and innovators, trailblazers who turn ideas into successful businesses, mom-and-pop shops that grow from literally a single store into thriving enterprises. These are the individuals who have made the United States the strongest economy in the world, and their hard work deserves our support. The truth is, however, that capital is not easy to access for many small businesses across the country, especially in the Midwest. I hail from the ``Show Me State'' of Missouri, so I know, and other regions away from the big cities on the coast. As chair of the Capital Market Subcommittee, one of my main goals has been to address this lack of access. As you said earlier, Mr. O'Leary, it is the whole deal, access to capital. That is why I led the INVEST Act, a package of 22 bipartisan bills that will strengthen our capital markets, expand investment opportunities for everyday Americans, and provide greater access to capital for Main Street businesses. Mr. O'Leary, as an angel investor on Shark Tank and the chairman of O'Leary Ventures, you have invested millions of dollars in dozens of companies located across the United States over the last 16 years. In working with early stage startups, investing both your time and money in up-and-coming companies, you have direct experience leading with the challenges that these businesses face. Mr. O'Leary, when you work with early stage companies, what are some of the main challenges you hear about gaining access to capital? Mr. O'Leary. Between 1-and 5 million in sales, it is virtually impossible today. It really is. The challenge is that, right after about a million, we stop selling your grandmother and your cousins the product, and people start buying it because they want it. It may even be successful on social media acquiring customers. That is the time when you want to support these nascent entities because they have proven their product. So one problem is, when they get to 5 million, that is what generally they need to expand both on the employee base, and they need more capital for inventory because that is just at the time when the large, big box retailers, which still represent 50 percent of sales, including Amazon, require inventory. They are not going to receive cash on that for 60 days. I talked with the factory market. There is another problem, and I brought this up when we were having China hearings. Exactly at 5 million run rate on Amazon for any American consumer good product, that is when the Chinese knockoffs hit. What you see, and it comes on Alibaba, that IP is stolen--and I have been talking about this for years---- Mrs. Wagner. Well, I do not have time to let you talk about it for years, sir, so---- Mr. O'Leary. Yes. It is stolen, and it shows up at 60 percent the cost of innovation. Mrs. Wagner. I hear you. I hear you and we have addressed some of these issues in the INVEST Act. You mention the INVEST Act in your written testimony. From your experience working with companies that rely on private market investors, how could the reforms included in this package help unlock capital, increase competition, and improve options without requiring additional government intervention or a subsidy? Mr. O'Leary. Probably 40 percent of the friction is the regulation and the challenges at the regional bank level. It really is. If you could get that red tape gone, if you could deregulate it, make it easier, most of these communities would support their entrepreneurs. Even in small towns, they would do it because they can see the effect of growth. I mean, they watch these--whether it is a car dealer or a dry cleaner or a bakery, whatever it is, it is working. Mrs. Wagner. In talking about growth, as other nations move aggressively to attract capital, U.S. risks falling behind, and we are, if our markets remain too costly or inaccessible for growing companies. Mr. O'Leary, how essential are capital formation reforms such as those in the INVEST Act to maintaining U.S. economic leadership and driving long-term growth, as you have talked about? Mr. O'Leary. Well, if you look at the data, 70 percent of jobs are created by the businesses you just detailed and yet they virtually get no support in the large acts that are created, whether it is the infrastructure act or whatever in the last 4 years. I have read those acts. They are telephone books. There is nothing in there for small business and the point is, why would you not want to support at least--I would argue--70 percent of capital should be made available and-- because 70 percent of the jobs come from there---- Mrs. Wagner. My time has expired. I yield back. We have done that in the INVEST Act, and I thank you, sir. Chairman Hill. I thank the gentlewoman. The chair recognizes the very distinguished gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Scott. You are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Scott. Thank you, very special chairman of our committee. Now, Professor Hamilton, I first want to thank you for joining us. Every day, the dream of owning a home in Atlanta slips further out of reach for thousands of families, and in our 2025 Atlanta Regional Commission Survey confirms what many already feel. Number one, housing affordability is not just a talking point anymore. It is the top concern for our constituents, affecting employment, education, and economic stability. Mr. Scott. In our Atlanta regional survey, the respondents pointed to investors who buy and rent homes as a main cause of this affordability issue. Another major factor cited in this report is rising construction costs from labor shortages, materials, and the availability of land. So, over the last 7 years, the construction workforce in Atlanta has lost 6 percent of workers age 25 to 52 years old, and, each year, we see a shortage of over 700,000 new construction workers. So, Professor Hamilton, help us out here. You have such knowledge. How are these market conditions affecting first-time home buyers, especially young families and communities of color, in cities like Atlanta? Mr. Hamilton. Thank you, Congressman. The number one ingredient to purchase a home is capital. If there is a shortage of workers, the number one ingredient to attract more workers is wages. So we have a problem of asymmetries in both power and capital. That is what we need at a high level. We need a redirection of public investments to redress that asymmetry. We need to be able to offer residents of Atlanta a capital foundation if they want to get--in order to get into a home, which, as you eloquently pointed out, provides a great deal of other amenities beyond the living in the home itself. It becomes a capital foundation for economic agency. Mr. Scott. Okay. I have a minute and a half. What steps can we take in this committee, in Congress, to address these labor shortages? Have you talked with our unions and the residential construction industry, which is expected to get worse with the aging workforce? Mr. Hamilton. As it relates to the labor market, there are a variety of things that one could do. The first thing I would say is, facilitate the economic right to collectively bargain. Facilitate the capabilities of workers to bargain in unity against some of the asymmetries, again, with regards to power. There are other mechanisms as well. We can instill a minimum wage. We see the evidence that--you know, the rhetoric is that a minimum wage will lead to job loss. Well, we have had countless studies that have shown that there is plenty of slack by which we can raise the floor on wages for Americans to ensure that they get decent pay. Mr. Scott. Well, let us deal with things like zoning reform. How important is that and local Federal coordination in expanding this supply of housing? Mr. Hamilton. Well, it is---- Mr. Scott. Atlanta is one of the fastest-growing, most dynamic areas we got but this is our number one issue right now. We are either going to survive and swim or we could drown. Mr. Hamilton. Yes. Yes. Really quick, smart zoning is important and useful, but---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Hamilton [continuing]. trying to make sure that those residents---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Hill. Thank you very much. The chair recognizes the vice chairman of the full committee, the gentleman from Michigan, Mr. Huizenga. You are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Huizenga. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Zoning is a big issue. Dr. Hamilton, we have not had a chance to meet, but, Mr. Brooks, Mr. O'Leary, Mr. Moore, good to see you all again. Location, location, location--watchword in real estate. Well, it is also supply, supply, supply and demand, demand, demand. All right? My own family has been experienced in housing for over three generations. We have been in the aggregate business. We have been in the--for three generations. Two generations have been in the ready-mix concrete and housing development business. Personally, I was a realtor after I graduated with my oh-so-employable political science degree. My brother is currently a realtor. We have seen barrier after barrier after barrier be put up by every level of government, including with zoning, at the local level, the State level, and, yes, the Federal level. Mr. Brooks, you hit the nail on the head with your discussion about why local banks and regional banks are no longer holding mortgages because of a disincentive under Dodd- Frank. It has radically changed how the banking business relates to the real estate and to the housing industry. In fact, I most recently just did a 24-unit condominium project that we started just before the coronavirus disease (COVID) and finished, mercifully, after COVID. I can tell you that, when we went to the bank that we have done business with as a family for three generations, they would not lend the money to do the real estate development. Why? Were we a bad credit risk? Did we not have enough cash in the bank as family businesses? Three or four family businesses all bank there. No, it was not--had anything to do with that. It was, the regulators thought they were overweighted in real estate. Therefore, we had to go find another bank. We did. We successfully found another local bank and oh, by the way, three acquisitions later, we were back with the original bank that had denied us the ability to get the loan to do the development. It is just--it is fascinating to me that people are not seeing it for all what it is about, which is really, truly supply and that demand, and we have supply not matching demand right now. Mr. Moore, yesterday, the House, we overwhelmingly--and congratulations, both sides of the aisle, for this--we passed the bipartisan Housing for the 21st Century Act. The Federal Reserve is set to have a new Chairman. Just talk to me briefly, very briefly, how you believe lowering rates in the future can make housing more affordable for low-income and middle-class families. Mr. Moore. I am sorry, which---- Mr. Huizenga. The lowering--your microphone, please. The lowering of interest rates, how is that going to benefit those lower-and middle-income families? Mr. Moore. Well, one of the things I wanted to say regarding this is that--you mentioned zoning. The city in the United States--there is one major city in the United States that virtually has no zoning, and that is Houston and if you look at my testimony, guess what? That has some of the lowest- cost housing. So there is no question that you are exactly right, that zoning has really dramatically restricted the supply--you are so right, Congressman. It is all about the law of supply and demand. When you have zoning restrictions that dramatically reduce the availability of multifamily homes, you are going to see the prices of homes rise, and it is going to be harder for people like my kids to buy a house. Mr. Huizenga. Yes. Mine, too, by the way. They are worried about that, and interest rates certainly are a part of that affordability. Mr. O'Leary, you have been very successful both off TV and on TV with your businesses. As a job creator, what happens when government reduces outdated government impediments, including overburdensome regulations. Likewise, what does it mean, as a job creator, when your taxes are lowered, and for the taxes of maybe the customers as well, like we did in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act and more recently in the Working Families Tax Cuts? How does that benefit you and the economy? Mr. O'Leary. Well, I liked your analogy on real estate when you opened your statement; it is location, location, location. Let me add something to that now that we face: power, power, power. We do not have any. The Chinese built 511 gigs last year, 110 of it solar, the rest coal-burning plants that make electricity, 250 megawatts at a time. They are killing us. They have no regulations. The big guy says, ``Put one there, or you disappear in 18 months.'' Mr. Huizenga. So we need customers--you need customers---- Mr. O'Leary. I was saying--I am trying to answer it, saying, you want--I want---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. O'Leary.--deregulation on power so I can create jobs. Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. O'Leary. If I can get power, I could create data centers. I cannot do it---- Chairman Hill. Mr. O'Leary, thank you. Let us continue-- that power comment is important. Let us put it in the record. Chairman Hill. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Green, who is the ranking member of our Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee. Mr. Green. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank the ranking member as well, and I appreciate greatly the testimony of the witnesses. Mr. Chairman, I concur with what you said about persons being priced out of the American Dream. I would add this: There are people who are not only priced out of the American Dream for all of the reasons that have been called to our attention here today, but they are also priced out for another reason, and that reason is invidious discrimination, very well known as ``racism.'' This occurs when some persons of color are in financial institutions seeking a loan and they find themselves being given a loan, if they receive it, that will have terms that are less favorable, that will cost more, and they will be less favorable and cost more than persons who are less qualified than they are but of a different hue. This invidious discrimination is something that I contend can be dealt with and I will deal with that in just a moment but for now, I would just like to call to your attention, Mr. Hamilton, that this appears to be the case. Do you concur with my premise? Mr. Hamilton. We need an honest reckoning with our history and recognize what you said as true and validated with lots of evidence. Mr. Green. Thank you. One of the ways that we can acquire the intelligence necessary to prove the allegations that I have made--the empirical evidence is needed, and to acquire this empirical evidence, there is a process called ``matched pair testing.'' This is where you take persons who have similar qualifications and you send them out into a lending institution--similar qualifications, but of different hues--and you then can acquire results that will give you the empirical evidence to substantiate what I have said. In fact, we have had this done, and we have acquired some of this empirical evidence, but it was a while ago. We need to do more of it. This is a problem that has a solution if we would but only embrace it. The way is here for us. The question is, do we have the will. Quite candidly, I live today to live to see the day that we will have a hearing comparable to this to talk about invidious discrimination in lending and also the invidious discrimination associated with purchasing a home if you are a person of color. These things can be dealt with if we choose to, but we have to have the will to do it. Now, to be more specific in terms of a possible solution to this problem that has been plaguing us since the arrival of persons of color here on August 20 of 1619, here is a possible solution that actually passed the House of Representatives: It is called the Fair Lending for All Act. Under the leadership of Hon. Maxine Waters, we were able to pass this legislation, Fair Lending for All. This bill would create the Office of Fair Lending Testing in the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau that is under assault currently. It would be charged with testing creditors' compliance with the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA). The bill would also create criminal penalties under Federal law for knowing and willful discrimination by lenders when a person is applying for credit. It does not matter what color you are; if you are discriminated against because of your color, you ought to pay a penalty. Currently, persons who defraud the bank will suffer a penalty if found guilty. That penalty can be a million dollars in fines, and you can be imprisoned for up to 30 years. Well, no such thing exists if the bank somehow defrauds you with invidious discrimination. This bill would have, if passed, afforded persons who are found to have been discriminated against a penalty against the lender in the amount of up to $50,000 and imprisonment for up to a year--hardly the same as what happens if you defraud the bank, but at least it would give us something that would act as a deterrent. I do believe that, if we had the will, we could eliminate much of what we call invidious discrimination, but we just do not have the will. We deal with all of the other problems, and people of color have to suffer them, but they also suffer from invidious discrimination in this, the great country that we all know and love. My hope is that one day, H.R. 166 was the number for it last time--it will pass the House, the Senate, and be signed by a President who understands that invidious---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's---- Mr. Green [continuing]. discrimination still exists. Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Green. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Hill. The gentleman from Kentucky is recognized, Mr. Barr, who chairs our Financial Institutions Subcommittee. You are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Barr. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Brooks, welcome back to the committee. I think the testimony that you offered about the nexus between Federal bank policy, over-regulation of the banking sector, and affordable housing is very timely. As you know, Chairman Hill and I introduced the Main Street Act to right-size regulation so that especially our community banks can focus on the housing market and help Americans achieve the goal of home ownership. Your point, that non-banks currently originate the large majority of all mortgages, while banks originate the remainder, and most of those loans wind up on government-related balance sheets with only about 10 percent of mortgage credit risk borne by the private sector, I think, is a very important point. You highlight two causes, first, Dodd-Frank's disincentivizing mortgage lending and then, second, bank supervision, leading banks to be wary of lending to apartment owners and developers and the negative signal that sends. How might the Main Street Act that we have proposed help solve these problems and enhance community banks, in particular--their ability to help Americans achieve the American Dream of home ownership? Mr. Brooks. Well, Mr. Barr, thank you for the question. It is great to see you again and thanks for your leadership on that bill in particular. It is a great idea--I would argue, the most important idea of the package that the committee is looking at. I say that because community banks are so much better credit managers of these kinds of loans than Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and why? Because they live in the local community, where they know the asset, they know the borrower, they know the history of the asset. I think about Mr. Huizenga's story about his small apartment building in Michigan, right, where the local bank that knew him well was not allowed to invest in that loan, and instead it got shipped off to some bank someplace else that would not know it as well. So, first of all, an enormous amount of deployable capital sits in banks below $10 billion, which is what you are focusing on---- Mr. Barr. Yes. Mr. Brooks [continuing]. in this Main Street Act---- Mr. Barr. And nothing wrong with non-bank mortgage originators, but more competition, the better. Competition in-- -- Mr. Brooks. Hundred percent. Mr. Barr [continuing]. credit markets lower costs---- Mr. Brooks. Hundred percent. Mr. Barr [continuing]. obviously and do not forget the fact that most of--up to 60 percent of all of the one-to four-family residential construction and land development loans are community-bank-held, and so another reason to promote regulatory tailoring for these community banks. Mr. O'Leary, I want to pick up where you left off, on affordable energy and China and the investment that they are making in reliable, affordable sources of energy, coal being primary. You know, because of the war on coal over the last 16 years under the Obama and Biden Administrations, the United States has prematurely retired 290 coal-fired power plants precisely at the time when AI data-center energy demand is skyrocketing. We have taken offline over 120 gigawatts of power over the last decade or so. Coal's share of total electricity generation in the United States has plummeted from 44 percent of total U.S. electricity in 2009 to only 15 percent in 2024. It is no surprise that there has been a dramatic spike in electricity rates. In Kentucky alone, utility rates have increased 59 percent over the past 16 years. So what is the answer? You said, in China they say, ``Build it in 18 months, or you will disappear.'' How do we bring more coal generation back online to win the race for AI, which-- Jensen Huang says we are only nanoseconds ahead of China. Mr. O'Leary. Path to permit. I am a real estate developer. I also develop data centers. We need a path to permit in less than 7 months. So--there is plenty of stranded nat gas all over the country. So my job now is to go from State to State to find 2,000 acres with water, with stranded nat gas at sub-6-cents-a- kilowatt-hour, and then I sit with leadership and say, ``Can you get me a permit to begin construction in 7 months?'' Because I have to go--just to start the power, the 1.4 gig, to make a 1-gig facility, of which the demand in the U.S. is 45 gigs--only five under construction right now. I am one of maybe 10 teams that can do this. If we do not have a permit in 7 months, we cannot go to the debt markets. We need $2 billion to start. Mr. Barr. Well, I have talked to Secretary Lutnick about how we can encourage more construction and---- Mr. O'Leary. Just give me permits. Mr. Barr [continuing]. pull power. I would love to talk to you about that. Final question to Mr. Moore. In his testimony, Professor Hamilton said, ``We need an economic paradigm that rejects private interests under the banner of modern supply side economics.'' Can you speak to how unleashing the supply side of the economy through lower taxes, less regulation, more energy production, more supply of capital, lowers prices? Chairman Hill. He can, but he will have to do that in writing. Mr. Barr. Supply, supply, supply. That is how you lower prices. It is not that hard. Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Barr. I yield back. Chairman Hill. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Missouri, Mr. Cleaver, who is the ranking member of our Housing and Insurance Subcommittee. Mr. Cleaver. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. O'Leary, you and Mr. Moore both suggested that State and local barriers to affordable housing was due to a lack of building code inspectors and a variety of zoning matters. Are you suggesting that we should not have zoning in major cities? Mr. O'Leary. No---- Mr. Moore. No--was that for me or you? Mr. Cleaver. Either one of you or both. Mr. Moore. You go ahead. Mr. O'Leary. No. It is a very simple equation, actually. If you are agnostic to politics, you go to the path of least resistance with capital. So, if you want to invest a billion dollars in housing, you find a place, as Mr. Moore suggested, like Houston, where the path of least resistance is obvious. That is why they are getting the houses, because I can go put capital to work there, I can do it quickly, path to permit is a lot sooner. I am not suggesting it is the Wild West, no permitting but if you go and compare that to Los Angeles, it is not investable. You cannot invest in Los Angeles, and I have said this countless times. I am not against the people of Los Angeles, but you cannot raise capital there because of this issue. So path to permit in housing will increase supply, reduce costs--and I talked about input costs on softwood lumber and things like that, but it is really a supply chain problem. Just give more land, reduce the friction on permits, and watch the magic happen. Watch the money flow there. Fifty-two cents of every dollar invested on Earth comes to the United States. It wants to invest here. Mr. Cleaver. All right. Mr. O'Leary. It is still 52 cents on every dollar--the number one economy on Earth. You cannot get a permit anywhere, basically. Mr. Cleaver. Yes. There is this subtle suggestion in here that due to a lack of building code inspectors things are not done. As a former mayor in Kansas City, that is fine and easy for somebody who is not in that mayor's office because that is an unfunded mandate, if the government said, ``You do this zoning, and you do that,'' and it disrupts the municipal budgets. I want to--just a quick question before I go to my next question, and that is: Are all of you in support of consumer protection? Mr. Moore. I am. Mr. Brooks. I mean, as a former regulator, I will just say, of course I am in favor of consumer protection. There is an issue of how many agencies should have the overlapping responsibility for consumer protection---- Mr. Cleaver. Uh-huh. Mr. Brooks [continuing]. and what do you mean by ``consumer protection.'' Mr. Cleaver. Well, I am kind of asking the questions, but the issue is how you look at it, because I do not understand all of the hostility toward a consumer protection agency. I mean, it is just mind-boggling that---- Mr. O'Leary. I do not think you are getting any friction there. The point is, how fast can you do that work? I think every consumer should be protected, but not if it takes 2 years to determine whether they are protected or not. That just becomes a huge friction point, and the market cannot--cannot work. We have put so much regulation at so many levels, whether it is---- Mr. Cleaver. Yes. Mr. O'Leary.--at the city level, the State level, or the Federal level, that the markets stop working. Mr. Cleaver. Yes, but those human beings' lives stop working when they are---- Mr. O'Leary. Well if you want lower housing, you have got to fix this. Mr. Cleaver. When they are taken advantage of it might take 2 years to get it straight. I mean, I do not--it is just hard to--for me to figure out. I want to go over to some serious problems we are having that I hope we--we cannot solve this morning but we can probably solve tomorrow if you stop by--and that is: If the United States of America is going to become what I think the Founders wanted and what many of us want, why do we keep--I mean, why do we have to--even in testimony, we put ``blue city'' and ``red city'' and ``green city'' and ``yellow cities'' and whatever. I mean, why is that going on? I mean, why would you have to do that? Chairman Hill. I would like to ask you to respond in writing to the gentleman's question. Time has expired. Chairman Hill. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Williams, who is the chairman of our House Small Business Committee. Mr. Williams, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Williams of Texas. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank all of you for being here today. It is good to see so many of our friends. The rising cost of housing is hurting American families--we have talked about that all day today--and Main Street businesses too. When housing becomes too expensive, fewer homes get built. That slowdown in construction limits community growth, which, in turn, puts pressure on local small businesses. Small businesses are the backbone of their communities. We have talked about that. Almost 99 percent of them are small but when neighborhoods stagnate and entrepreneurs lose opportunities to grow and expand, that is a problem. From small builders and carpenters to plumbers and welders, housing affordability and small businesses are closely connected, and when one struggles, the other often struggles as well. Mr. Brooks, first, can you expand on how the rise in housing costs affects small businesses, Main Street America? Mr. Brooks. Well, as several witnesses have already said, Congressman, the foundation of most households' wealth is their equity in their house. So the ability of a household to spend, the ability of a household to sell the house and move for a better labor opportunity, it is all really tied up in the robustness of the housing market. As I said, the robustness of the housing market has two aspects to it: there is the price of the house and your ability to sell it. So we saw in the financial crisis that labor mobility went to zero because no one had equity and they could not sell their houses. The second piece is the price of credit, which is how much does it costs me every month to pay my mortgage and stay in that house. Both of those things are inflated right now, which contravenes what you learned in economics class in high school. Usually, if the cost of money is high, then the cost of the underlying asset is low. Right now, we have a strange stagflation in the housing market. Something has to be done about it. This is the Committee on Financial Services, and so you have jurisdiction to oversee the credit allocation in this country. I would argue that the regulation of our banking sector, the reduction in competition in lending to Main Street, right, where people can use home equity to fund businesses or sell houses to move for better jobs--that system is broken. It used to work well. It stopped working after the crisis. Mr. Williams of Texas. You are exactly right. One thing--I mean, full disclosure, I am a car dealer and so, when we start talking about access to capital, you are talking to me. It is essential to building a successful small business, in addition to--one of the most common challenges they raise-- small businesses--are the one-size-fits-all regulatory burdens that limit how small businesses can use their capital, and they must decide between regulatory compliance or expanding their business. It is like the banks who are hiring compliance officers, not loan officers; that affects Main Street America also. So to give small business a real chance to succeed, we need to reduce unnecessary red tape--we have talked about that--and remove the barriers that prevent entrepreneurs from securing the capital they need and, frankly, competing so the consumer is the beneficiary. So, Mr. O'Leary, you invest in small businesses, and we certainly know you do a great job, from a wide variety of industries. What are you seeing as some of, not the biggest hurdles, but the biggest regulatory hurdles to the success of Main Street? Mr. O'Leary. Across all 11 sectors, it is finance and receivables for small businesses. It has become a huge problem. When interest rates were really, really low, the hard money, as it is called, was available at 15 to 17 percent. That is a lot, but it was used quite a bit. My companies used it. We are way over that now. I have seen 27 percent offers for financing receivables, because they cannot go to a regional bank and get any financing and these are good companies that are actually recurring invoices to Walmart, to Target--I mentioned those two companies--and many others. Amazon, as well, is 40 percent of volume now for consumer goods. This is a--if we just solved this, if we made credit available at sub-10 percent for these companies, just like the big guys have--they are right now paying 7, 7\1/2\--if we did that for small business, you would see an explosion of growth in America--millions of businesses, millions. We are talking about millions and millions of businesses that do not get 7 percent credit for their receivables. This is stuff they sold, and it sold through. It is proven. It is a good asset; cannot finance it. This is a big problem. This act helps a bit with the red tape on it, but they are still not getting anywhere near what the big guys get; they are not getting 7 percent. Mr. Williams of Texas. They would make more profit and pay more taxes if the interest rate was lower. Mr. O'Leary. And more jobs. Mr. Williams of Texas. There you go. Mr. O'Leary. Way more jobs. Mr. Williams of Texas. So, Mr. Brooks, let me shorten my question, as we end it down here. What are the consequences for borrowers in local economies when community banks, which bank people like me, are forced to pull back in lending due to regulatory capital--and we just talked about that--pressures? Mr. Brooks. Well, Congressman, one of the things that happens is foregone consumption, because most people do not have access to Goldman Sachs. So, if First National Bank of my hometown in Colorado is not going to make the loan, the loan is not going to get made, is the bottom line. Most capital formation happens locally, and if community banks are not unleashed to supply that demand, you are mostly out of luck. Mr. Williams of Texas. Well, we talked about inventory, and flooring inventory is getting harder and harder and when you have less inventory, you have less opportunity to sell. It trickles down. I want to thank all of you for being here today. I yield my time back. Chairman Hill. The gentleman yields back. The chair recognizes the gentleman from Illinois, Dr. Foster, who is the ranking member of our Subcommittee on Financial Institutions. Mr. Foster. So, Mr. O'Leary, here is the pitch: Imagine it is 1975. Two brothers, a 19-year-old and his 17-year-old little brother, and a couple of their friends have the bright idea to start a new business, all right? They want to use the newly invented microprocessor to control theater stage lighting. Never been done before but they have a problem. To build their prototype, they need $500 from their parents. So my question is, do you give them the $500? If so, what do you predict for the future of their business? Mr. O'Leary. You know, that is--I love that question because my son just pitched me for a lot more than that on his deal. Mr. Foster. Well, this was $500 in 1975, which was real money back then. Mr. O'Leary. Oh, that is a lot. Mr. Foster. Yes. Mr. O'Leary. You know, I think it is--I would have done that, I would have lent it, because the outcome is unknown but there is a wonderful thing that happens when a young person takes on the responsibility of another person's money. It creates a fantastic platform by which they understand they serve someone in perpetuity. Mr. Foster. Yes. Well, so I was that older brother, and---- Mr. O'Leary. What happened? Mr. Foster. What happened is, that company--it is 51 years ago now, and that company, it is about $450 million a year, 1,600 employees---- Mr. O'Leary. Well, I rest my case, Your Honor. Mr. Foster [continuing]. that manufactures in the Midwest, all right? And, as of the beginning of last year, it has just completed the Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) transition. So that company that we started with 500 bucks 51 years ago is now 100-percent owned by the 1,600 employees who built the company. Mr. O'Leary. Well, you deserve the American Dream Award for that. Mr. Foster. Yes. Well, it is--I am, I guess, proud of that. I had my partners buy me out when I entered Congress, because I did not want to be casting votes that affected my net worth, which may sound sort of quaint these days, but, anyway, that is what I did. Anyway, the--and both sides here have emphasized the role of local community banks in housing and in business growth. Now, during the government shutdown last October, the Federal Reserve had two really excellent conferences--one on community banking, the other one on the future of payments. Since we had decided to cancel hearings, I attended both full- day conferences and what we heard uniformly from all the community bankers who showed up mentioned that their number one concern was what they viewed as the mortal threat from interest-bearing stablecoins, either by directly paying interest or indirectly through various payments from the crypto exchanges that was allowed by the GENIUS Act. They had a fear that interest-bearing stablecoins would just drain the deposits from small community banks and take away one of the only sources of capital that small communities have, rural communities. So I was wondering, the whole panel here, where would you land on that? I mean, we have a decision to make. Should we side with the community banks on this, or should we side with the---- Mr. O'Leary. I would love to opine on that for a short period. Mr. Foster. Sure. Mr. O'Leary. The opportunity is for the community banks-- and all money center banks included--to allow small businesses to open a stablecoin account beside their fiat currency account. There is absolutely no reason they cannot do that. If I were a small community bank, I would try and keep competition at bay, but you cannot. We have passed the law. It is legal tender. A stablecoin, backed by 92 days less duration of a Treasury bill, is now a legal tender for anybody that wants it. The banks are holding back by not allowing accounts to show up and every one of my companies is using these now to settle payments or take in payments. It is a huge inconvenience. You are forcing them to open accounts at Robinhood and Coinbase, when they would just rather work with their regional bank if they could. I am not against Robinhood or Coinbase; they are innovators but a small business doing $5 million in sales that can avoid 2\1/2\ percent on a credit card payment by using a stablecoin, let them do it. Like---- Mr. Foster. Well, I think the competition there, frankly, it is India. If you are in India and you want to give a pauper three rupees, you both get out your cell phones, authenticate to your bank accounts, transfer three rupees, zero fees. It has nothing to do with blockchain or anything else. Now, I guess, we have also hit on this issue of financing receivables. There is a big--the current issue there is a lot of the First Brand fraud and similar things, with double pledging of a collateral, is a huge problem. Those of you who follow ``Money Stuff,'' this very amusing blog has written a lot about that. Now, the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC) is doing a very interesting prototype that uses blockchain and tokenization to prevent double pledging of receivables and other assets. I was wondering if you can--you know, would that actually be a significant positive use of blockchain here? Mr. O'Leary. Yes, I think people should stop thinking about blockchain as crypto. It is really just software. It is contract management. That is what it is, and I think it has been misnamed. In fact, if you take out the speculation of Bitcoin and all the other coins and forget about that for a second, blockchain technology---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. O'Leary, if you would finish that thought in writing to Dr. Foster. Chairman Hill. The gentleman from Georgia, the vice chairman of our Financial Institutions Subcommittee, Mr. Loudermilk, you are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Loudermilk. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank all of you for being here today. I go back to when I first ran for Congress in 2014. As a small-business owner, I wanted to engage with businesses of all sizes in my district, so I spent many, many hours meeting with various businesses. I asked them, ``What is the key? What is it that I can do in Congress to help you expand, help your business to be profitable?'' We all know, if a business is profitable, then the community is profitable. I cannot recall anyone saying anything differently--is that the common answer was, ``The greatest cost to our business is government regulation,'' to a T. I even asked a group of executives, I said, ``Which would be more important to you, for us to lower taxes or cut regulation?'' You know what they all said? ``Cut regulation. Taxes are important, but regulation is the greatest drain on our profitability.'' With housing in mind, I started doing some research, and I came across a study--and this was in 2014--that, in some markets, over 50 percent of the cost of a new home is related to government regulation and I started thinking about that. You could cut the cost of a new home significantly just by reducing the regulation. As we look further, there is a lot of regulation that is not even applicable to the business that is having to live by that regulation. If you want to look at the high cost, we need to look at the regulation side, and I think that is what we are really focused on this side of the dais here, is how can we do that. Mr. Brooks, you mentioned in your testimony that most Americans know that everything got more expensive over the past 5 years as the country experienced this incredible inflation, the highest since the 1970s, but a lot of people do not know that housing inflation was dramatically worse. Can you talk about why we saw that spike in housing inflation? Mr. Brooks. Yes. So, Mr. Loudermilk, one of the worst parts of that problem is the 5-million-unit housing deficit is not new. The 5-million-unit housing deficit goes back basically to the immediate post-financial-crisis era, and nobody has built a house since, is almost what it feels like. Okay, and that was the point where two things happened at the same time. So one is, we had bad credit management, which meant many people had negative equity in their houses and could not move for work and could not sell their houses. The other is, we overcorrected on the credit side. I would argue that a corrective was needed; we needed something like Dodd-Frank but with 15 years of experience of that kind of regulatory environment, banks cannot do business. We could talk about it in the housing context like we have already done, but Mr. O'Leary has mentioned factoring and inventory finance for a while. The Federal bank regulators have more or less prohibited factoring as a business line for banks. Venture debt does not exist in the United States after Silicon Valley Bank failed. These are all overcorrections where there is a strong demand for a product, and when you drive the regulated institutions out, what you are left with is the hard-money lenders and the scary guys nobody wants to talk about. That has to be fixed. Mr. Loudermilk. Well, we are addicted--this institution is sort of like, when somebody has a headache, they go to the doctor, they give them an aspirin, and they never look at the real root of the problem. Our aspirin is money. Just throw money at something and hope it goes away, but it inevitably gets worse. Would additional government spending, instead of meaningful regulation relief and market-driven reforms, make housing availability and affordability--would those problems get worse or better? Mr. Brooks. Let me just say, the more regulation that has come into the housing markets, the more--it is like you squeeze a balloon. So you think you are solving one problem, and it pops up someplace else. As government gets involved in credit allocation, what winds up happening is, market discipline goes away. So think about Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were doing in the 1990s: They were inflating markets in areas and creating loans for people who could not afford the loans, leading to a very predictable foreclosure crisis. That is what happens when government, rather than private- sector actors, start managing credit, is they allocate the credit to their friends. This side has their friends; that side has their friends but squeezing the balloon is never a good idea. The good idea is, let the shareholders bear the risk. Let the private sector get back involved here. You know, private- sector banks can manage credit just as well and fail; if they fail, just as well as a car dealership can, just as well as anything else can but when government is too involved, bad things happen. Mr. Loudermilk. Real quickly--I am running out of time. How--I have a bill called the Taking Account of Institutions with Low Operation Risk (TAILOR) Act, which would cause government agencies to tailor their regulations based on the risk of the business, the size of the business, the scope of the business, instead of just blanket regulations. How important is that? Mr. Brooks. Critical. Compliance for compliance's sake is a waste of time. You have compliance because there is a risk. So say what it is and control that risk. Mr. Loudermilk. With that, Mr. Chairman, I am out. Chairman Hill. The gentleman yields back. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman from Ohio, Mrs. Beatty, who is our ranking member on our National Security Subcommittee. Mrs. Beatty. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Waters and to all our witnesses today, thank you for being here. On the record and off the record, let me say, I am a big fan of ``Shark Tank,'' and ``Mr. Mean,'' I am trying to decide if you are that on TV or here but thank you for your remarks on tariffs that we are doing. To my good friend Dr. Darrick Hamilton, good to see you again. You have been here and testified before us and also at many academic forums on the economy and on housing, and some things have not changed. Let me start with this, because I have been a longtime advocate for community development financial institutions, or our CDFIs. Our ranking member opened up the dialog early, talking about the importance and value of CDIs and so, in this committee, I like the theme when we are talking about ``priced out of the American Dream.'' It reminds me of, the American Dream for most folks is owning a home. Do you remember your first home, to the witnesses, yes or no. Mr. Brooks. Absolutely. Mr. O'Leary. Yes. I do. I do. Mr. Moore. Yes. Mr. Hamilton. I am still in that first home. Mrs. Beatty. Okay, there you go. There you go. So, right now, when I think of that American Dream, I think about home ownership. I think about whatever your financial goal was to reach it but then I think about our economic challenges. I think about Trump's tariffs and what it is doing to those individuals and the economy and small and large businesses. When I think of ``dream''--and we are here in the middle of February, and it is Black History Month--Mr. Chairman, I would like to enter into the record this article from Darrick Hamilton in 2021, when he talked about the difference between haves and have-nots, and he said these words, quoting from the lessons of Dr. Martin Luther King: ``Now is always the time to build on the lessons of Dr. King and shift our prevailing paradigm toward a more inclusive and self-prosperous future, with the strategic direction of our public resources toward people and a sustainable environment in both an industrial and economic sense. In the end, the optimistic message is in the power that lies within us as we dream the American Dream in our economy.'' Well, here we are---- Chairman Hill. Without objection, that will be included in the record. [The information referred to can be found in the appendix on page 90.] Mrs. Beatty. Thank you. Here we are, some 5 years later. I could have also, Dr. Hamilton, gone back and quoted you 15 or 20 years ago. I could have quoted when you were at where I left, The Ohio State, to come here, and you ran our current institute, doing some of the most prolific research that I have ever read on economic development, our country, our people, and our economy. So, last week, I asked Secretary Bessent for an explanation to when the appropriations for Fiscal Year 2025 funds would be disbursed to the CDFIs. I could not get a straight answer--no, I did get an answer. He said he chose not to answer it, because he did not have the answer, in my opinion. Aside from him putting the blame on the Office of Management and Budget for failing to appropriate the funds, I know that, for CFDIs, predictability in funding cycles is essential to plan long-term community investments and maintain the momentum in our neighborhoods, the neighborhoods that they serve. Can you discuss the risk associated with these extended funding delays on what is going to happen in our communities with CDFIs with the Treasury dragging their feet? Mr. Hamilton. Markets are local; markets are relational. So not funding those entities is highly problematic and will be detrimental to our economy. If I may address a point that was raised previously---- Mrs. Beatty. Yes. Mr. Hamilton [continuing]. about whether I am anti-supply, I am not anti-supply. I believe in the American people. I believe that people go beyond just being labor inputs and beyond just being consumption agents; that they are the innovators; that when CDFIs are able to invest in people, when government is able to invest in people, not only is it beneficial for them but they produce, they come up with new---- Chairman Hill. The gentlewoman's time has expired. Mrs. Beatty. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Hill. Thank you. The chair recognizes another distinguished member from Ohio--Mr. Davidson, you are recognized. Mr. Davidson is the chair of our National Security Subcommittee. Mr. Davidson. Thank you, Chairman. Thanks to our witnesses. What a great panel. I really have enjoyed the discussion. When I go back--you know, frankly, Mr. Brooks, Mr. O'Leary, Mr. Moore, you guys in particular--as we were watching this inflation crisis unfold, we called it. This is not the result of some phantom cause; like, how could we possibly know what would cause inflation? We could see this train wreck coming, because we saw massive spending, cash pouring into our economy. As the fiscal spending was going, Congress just kept cutting bigger and bigger checks. Meanwhile, you had executive authority around the country--frankly, around the world-- artificially limiting supply. They were closing our entire economy. So how did you not have too many dollars chasing too few goods? Under the Biden Administration, they came up with creative names like the ``Inflation Reduction Act,'' you know, to spend this money. I mean, when Lee Zeldin took over at the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), he cited the Biden Administration's own words, that they were ``pushing gold bars off the Titanic,'' shoving this cash out into the economy, to do nothing productive. We look at auto-industry companies writing off tens of billions of dollars in losses because there was no consumer demand for this and this is what happens with central planning. In essence, the central planning that we have, sort of, all embraced is the Federal Reserve. They arbitrarily set interest rates, and when they arbitrarily set them too low, as was definitely happening during this period of time, they cover for it by growing their balance sheet. In fact, they grew their balance sheet to over $9 trillion. So should the Federal Reserve continue to do this? Mr. Moore, you have highlighted this. Are the results predictable, or is it just, ``How could we explain this?'' Mr. Brooks, as you have highlighted, a house is maybe the most common asset people have. So, once you have inflated something, of course housing prices are inflated, but so are other asset prices. Mr. Moore, could you talk about these implications? Mr. Moore. Well, you did a nice summary, Congressman, of what has happened over the last 5 years. We spent $4 trillion to $5 trillion after COVID. By the way, it was mostly the Build Back Better bill, the Inflation Control Act, the quote, ``Infrastructure'' bill and that is-- look, you said it very well. Inflation is too many dollars chasing too few goods. It is not complicated, right? It is too many dollars chasing too few goods. What did we do, where did the money come from to fund--and, by the way, Trump, on his way out in his first term, passed a trillion-dollar spending bill we did not need and so it was all printed. We printed the money. By the way, there were 30 economists in The New York Times, including Nobel Prize winners, who said, ``Do not worry. All this spending will not cause inflation.'' I mean, those economists probably should send their Ph.D.s back and say, ``We do not know what we are talking about.'' So we had the highest inflation in 30 years, and the point I was trying to make to the committee is, we are paying a high price for that even today. It is the reason, Mr. Chairman, people are angry, because prices have stayed--and ground beef and eggs and everything that they buy is more expensive. It takes a long time to drain that out of the system. Mr. Davidson. Thank you for that. Mr. Moore. Hopefully, we learned the lesson that there is no such thing as a free lunch, that these expenditures came at a cost of much--everybody paying higher prices and much lower growth. The good news is we are now at a 4-to 5-percent growth path within 1 year of this new administration. That is a pretty remarkable achievement. Mr. Davidson. It is sort of like Narcan for a fatal overdose of government that was administered. We were trying to revive it with the Big, Beautiful Bill, the Working Families Tax Cut Act, and many pro-growth policies. When I think about pro-growth policies, one of the big ones, Mr. O'Leary, you highlighted. As a--I grew manufacturing companies between the Army and coming to Congress. Capital is really the lifeblood. When you look at being able to get access to that, one of the challenges has been still the Federal Reserve. They are paying banks not to deploy capital. Interest on reserves is one thing; they are paying interest on excess reserves. So the banks are hiding their cash at the Fed, not putting it at risk in the market. We know the banks are not meeting the market demand because you have a massive growth in non-bank lenders. Again, Mr. Moore, could you highlight kind of the challenge on interest on excess reserves? I think you have cited that it is costing like $200 billion a year that could be in our economy. Mr. O'Leary. Yes. What I like to solve this problem is always innovation and competition. I mean, to me, if you just let the American economy do its thing, as it is done for 200 years, it remains number one on Earth through all kinds of change, but it is all about innovation and competition. So anything, in the banking system particularly, that stifles innovation and competition is bad. We have some of that happening---- Chairman Hill. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Davidson. Unfortunately, my time has expired, and I will send a few questions for the record. Mr. Davidson. I yield back. Chairman Hill. I thank the gentleman. I now recognize the gentleman from California, the ranking member of our Monetary Policy Task Force, Mr. Vargas. You are recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Vargas. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and I want to thank the ranking member and, of course, the witnesses here today. I think that the hearing today has been excellent, and I appreciate it very much. We did just get lectured on fiscal responsibility. I would just like to remind my good friends on the other side, they just passed their ``Big, Ugly Bill'' that added $5 trillion to the deficit, with no benefit to it. I think that, Mr. Brooks, you spoke the most truth today when you said, that side has their friends, and this side has our friends. I think that is--I think that is very true. I think you said the quiet part out loud, and that is, they love the wealthy and the big corporations, and we love the working class and the poor. That is the truth, so I am glad you mentioned that. By the way, Mr. O'Leary, I do not watch the show much because I do not like TV, but I always like watching you because I think you are very clever when you banter back and forth with your friends on the--and, today, when you were asked a question about, ``Coal, coal, coal. Is not coal so great? We need coal, right?'', you said, ``Yes, wherever there is gas that is where I want to build, wherever there is gas and land.'' Did not answer the coal question and I thought that was great, and he felt like he got his answer and walked away, but you did not answer the coal question. Mr. O'Leary. Yes, I will answer it if you want. I do not think I can get a permit for coal. So I am not stupid and I am not going to waste my time trying until you tell me I can. Mr. Vargas. Yes. Mr. O'Leary. So I am a very simple person. How fast can I get a permit? Because what I can do is raise capital from all around the world. If you go and try and raise $2 billion and you tell them you are going to use coal right now, the cost of capital will go up 300 basis points. Mr. Vargas. I was going to get to that, because I think that is one of the things that you said that is very, very true. It is, actually, how quickly you can get a permit. That is with housing, with anything else. You need certainty to be able to finance it. I was on the San Diego City Council for 8 years. I chaired the Land Use and Housing Committee for some time on that committee. Unless you could have a developer get certainty that they could develop, it was very hard to carry that property. So they needed certainty. People that pushed back the most, actually, were the people that lived in the community where the development was coming near to or in, because of the issue of they did not want crowding. They wanted to protect their investment. They wanted density somewhere else, development somewhere else, not in their neighborhood and that is a problem. I mean, that really is a problem, the zoning issue, how quickly can you get the opportunity to build. You need to have that opportunity so you can finance that project. Mr. O'Leary. I do not even break the ground until the community is behind me. I do not even bother trying. You cannot win that way. Mr. Vargas. Exactly. That is what I am saying. Unless you have the ability to do that with zoning, where you can do it by right, and you can get to it quickly, you cannot finance it. The bank will not finance it. You need that ability. You have to convince your community that development is necessary so your kids can live somewhere and that, in California, means density. It is hard to convince people of that. Mr. O'Leary. I know how to do that. Mr. Vargas. Yes, no, and I think some people do well. Most people do not and that is why I think you need to have it by right and not by the ability of someone to charm them, but instead by--zoning does this, so you can, in fact--and in California, thank God, they are trying to change this. Because there are a number of things--for example, smaller lot sizes. They do not need these gigantic lot sizes too. Interestingly, at the turn of the last century, in 1900, a single-family detached home was about 700 or 1,000 square feet. Today, it is 2,400 and bigger. You do not need these large homes. You can have smaller homes. You can do this and have a very nice community. Anyway, I was going to add those things. The other thing I would like to say is that the interest rate is a problem, but--I bought my house in 1979. I paid 7.2- percent interest on the mortgage. I still live in the home, by the way, and my parents bought their home in 1972. They paid 7 percent. Today, the interest rate for a single-family mortgaged home is about 6.3 percent, 6.4. It is actually lower than when I bought my home. The problem is this, though: I bought my house for $176,000. If you put it in an inflation calculator to try to figure out what is the cumulative interest on--interest as well as inflation, today, that should be about $390,000. It is not; it is $2 million. That is the problem. The actual cost of the home has risen so dramatically that you cannot finance it anymore because it is too damn expensive. That is why you have to have smaller lots. That is why you have to have smaller homes. That is why you have to have the ability to get those permits with some certainty so you can finance the project in the first place. That is why I think this was a very helpful meeting, because I think you guys did speak of those things. Again, I believe very much that there has been discrimination, no doubt about that. With that, my time is over, and I yield back. Thank you. Mr. Huizenga [presiding.] The gentleman's time has expired. The chair right now recognizes the gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Rose, who is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Rose. Thank you, Chairman Huizenga. I want to thank Chairman Hill and Ranking Member Waters for holding this important hearing and thank you to all of our witnesses for taking time from your schedules to be with us. Mr. O'Leary, I appreciate your testimony emphasizing the need of streamlining permitting and freeing up Federal land for housing. I agree wholeheartedly. However, in many communities, particularly our densest urban areas, there simply is not undeveloped land left to be built on. In these places, the solution must be building up, not out. Yet restrictive zoning laws stand in the way. For example, here in Washington, DC, perhaps the most glaring example, the Height of Buildings Act of 1910 caps building heights based on street width, with an absolute maximum of 130 feet. This arbitrary limit, created over a century ago, artificially constrains housing supply in one of America's most expensive housing markets, where the median rent exceeds $2,200 per month. Do you believe that relaxing or eliminating Washington, DC's maximum height restrictions would allow the private sector to increase housing supply and reduce costs for working families? Mr. O'Leary. There is only one answer. It is, yes. We would build up in 2 seconds if we could do that. I mean, you need a combination of all of this. The thing that I wanted to point out to everybody is, there is a competition between States, and there is a competition between nations. So, right now, if you are given $2 billion to deploy, you have to find a State where you can get that money to work and so you go for the path of least resistance. The places that are obviously getting that capital now are places like Tennessee, Texas, Florida, North/South Dakota, because permitting has been relaxed there by the leadership, at either the Governor's office or the mayor or the Senator or whatever. Imagine my challenge. I have to deploy capital. I have to find a place to do it. The harder it gets, the less I want to spend my time fighting that fight. I am just a guy trying to put money to work. If you told me--if I was the first to know that you would lift those height restrictions, how about $2 billion right now? Like, in 2 seconds. Because the demand for housing is crazy in DC. I mean, that is a good idea. Why do you not do that? That is a fantastic idea. I 100 percent endorse that. You would get a ton of capital. Mr. Rose. Thank you. I appreciate that. Mr. Moore, in your written testimony you warned that Federal policies reducing downpayment requirements to 2 to 3 percent range, in some cases effectively to zero, were a major driver of the 2008 housing and financial collapse, with default losses concentrated in those low downpayment loans. At a time when it is very tempting for policymakers to respond to the housing affordability crisis by expanding lower and no downpayment programs, can you elaborate on why you believe that approach is so dangerous, and how we should weigh the short- term appeal of expanding access against the long-term systemic risks that you describe? Mr. Moore. There is nobody that is more in favor of increasing home ownership, and so, I am--that is one of the reasons I wanted to testify here because I think it is a high national priority. It is the American Dream. The mistake we made for 2008 was that we kept subsidizing so much of the downpayments that, thanks to programs like the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) and Fannie Mae, you had people paying 3 percent or less downpayment. In some cases, by the way, the downpayments were zero. You could finance your closing costs--and so essentially, what that meant is the person who was moving in had no skin in the game, right? Unfortunately, the lesson we learn--we should have learned from 2008 is that if you looked at the portfolio of loans that were defaulted on, the single biggest determinant was how much equity the person had in the home. In other words, if somebody has equity in their house, they are not going to default on a loan because they have got skin in the game. So all I am saying, my advice to you as Members of Congress is there are always ideas--oh, let us keep lowering downpayments so people can afford to move in a home, but then they cannot afford to make the payments and then everybody is worse off. So please avoid that because the losses were excruciating. It took 5 years for the U.S. economy to recover from that mortgage meltdown that we had in 2008. Mr. Rose. Thank you. I agree very much. Mr. Brooks, we do not have many seconds left here, but what can we do, what do you think Congress, policymakers here can do to reverse the damage done by the Biden-era inflation? Is there something we can do from a policy perspective? Mr. Brooks. Well, you can start by fixing the regulatory overhang. So somebody said earlier today you have got two problems, inflation and taxes on one hand and regulation on the other hand. Growth requires deregulation. We have to grow our way out of this. Mr. Rose. My time is expired. I yield back. Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired. The chair now recognizes the gentleman from New Jersey, Mr. Gottheimer, for 5 minutes. Mr. Gottheimer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member. We know that professional single-family rentals and build to rent providers have built more than 100,000 new homes in the past decade, adding to the supply. We know that we are about 4.5 million units short in the country which, of course, leads to higher prices in most of our communities and less mobility, because of mortgage rates, are stuck in their home that they are currently in even if they want to move. So we keep adding-- I know the build to rents and single-family rentals (SFRs) are adding supply and building to rent and giving people options to actually go somewhere. My concern here--and I just want to see if I am getting this wrong. My concern is if this disappeared, if suddenly you said you cannot do build to rent, what would happen to our-- what do you think would happen to our housing supply and--you know, it seems to me this would be--it is a basic supply and- demand thing, but I could be missing something here. Mr. Wonderful, I do not know if you want to start. Mr. O'Leary. Well, you are asking what would happen to the housing supply if what? Mr. Gottheimer. If suddenly we told the single family rentals and the build to rent folks we prevented that from going forward, from building to rent. Seems like we would lose supply, right? Mr. O'Leary. Well, my whole--New Jersey is an interesting place because you have got a housing issue there too---- Mr. Gottheimer. Huge housing issue. Mr. O'Leary. Yes. I would love to put money to work there but you got a lot of permitting issues as well. You also have rent control issues there. You know, it is a very---- Mr. Gottheimer. And some of the urban areas---- Mr. O'Leary. Yes. I mean, think about it this way--and I think you raise a really good issue. I am just a guy with a lot of money to put to work and so my investors say, ``Where is the next project?'' I say, ``New Jersey,'' they go, ``I do not think so.'' What do you got in---- Mr. Gottheimer. Mostly because of permitting and the time to build? Mr. O'Leary. Yes, because the--remember, I am 50 percent debt, and debt needs uptick certainty. Mr. Gottheimer. Right. Mr. O'Leary. I also need at least, as Brian brought up earlier, if the CapEx on a building is 3 percent a year and you have got a cap on rent control, he is right. There comes a time when the building is worthless, because you cannot fix the plumbing anymore. This is a huge problem, and you have it in your State, and you have massive demand. So if you fix that, if you fix that, you will have capital like that because it is a very desired location for sovereign wealth, 100 percent New Jersey, if you could fix that problem. Mr. Gottheimer. Of course you do not want to be in socialist New York. You want to be in capitalist Jersey. Mr. O'Leary. No, no. I am happy to--listen, I am agnostic. I work with leadership that helps me get a permit. It is that easy. Mr. Gottheimer. So on the point of insuring, in my opinion, what I think is really important is that we have supply and we do everything we can to get supply up, we know that the cost-- renting a single-family home is 30 percent cheaper than buying one, right? So for a lot of people, a lot of my constituents, they tell me this is their only option. They can only rent. A lot of them, of course, want to be in a lot of these neighborhoods. You know, in Jersey, we have got the best schools, so people want to be in a lot of these neighborhoods. Single-family rentals give children and families access to those neighborhoods and at a lower price. We know that people get a great education, how important it is for long-term success. So it strikes me, should families not--and I will start with you, Mr. Moore. Should families not have the option to choose rentals to give their children access to better schools and better neighborhoods? This is especially true for veterans and nurses. It strikes me that makes sense, no? Mr. Moore? That is you. Mr. Moore. I am sorry. Does what make sense? Say that again. Mr. Gottheimer. To give people--give them the ability to get a rental so they can have access--I know a lot of families in my district would not be able to afford to buy a house because it is expensive, so their only option is to rent because they want their kids to go to these great schools. Am I getting that right? Mr. Moore. Well, look. We need to do everything we can to increase the supply of homes so people--so that you can have lower-price homes so people can afford to buy them. I mean, the great thing about home ownership is that people put roots in the community, right? So we want policies that make these homes affordable and for so many reasons, including what my fellow panelists have talked about, regulations and building codes that are outrageous, et cetera, we are making it--we are pricing people out of the American home and there are ways that we can increase the supply. One other quick thing to think about, by the way, this is partly demographic. You know, I was born in 1960. That was the peak year of births in the baby boom. It is interesting we are having this conversation about, well, an inadequate supply of homes right now. Well, 10 or 15 years from now, we might not have that supply. We might have an oversupply of housing. Just something to think about. Mr. Gottheimer. It is a great point. Thanks. I yield back. Thank you. Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired. With that, the chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Michigan, Mrs. McClain, who is also the chair of our Republican House Conference. Mrs. McClain. Thank you. Mr. Huizenga. She is recognized for 5 minutes. Mrs. McClain. Thank you and thank you all for being here. I appreciate it. Mr. Brooks, I would like to start with you if that is okay. Obviously, we have talked about it, ad nauseam, right? Regulation, access to capital, et cetera, et cetera, is very important but I want to talk about, if we could, some action items. Chairman Hill's Main Street Capital Access Act, right, I believe it will lower costs for local, community banks, and rural institutions by lowering compliance costs for banks certified as low risk and healthy, right? We have gone from roughly 14,000 banks in the 1900s to 4,200 banks today. I would like to hear your opinion on how much of that decline in the banking industry is due to overregulation, versus normal market conditions because sometimes we have a--we say we are capitalists, but I do not know if I really like the free market. So I would like your opinion on that. Mr. Brooks. Well, I appreciate the question, Congresswoman. Mergers and consolidation usually happen when you need to spread your costs across a larger asset base, right? And so, if compliance and other nonproductive activities--and when I say ``nonproductive,'' I mean nonrevenue producing activities-- become a major burden, you have to put them inside of a larger institution so that you have the revenue base to support the compliance. So there is no question that is one of the factors that has led to the shrinkage in banking. The other thing, as a side point, that has led to the shrinking in the number of banks, of course, is that at some point we stopped chartering new banks. We went about 15 years post-financial crisis where we chartered one bank or zero banks a year at the Federal level. Previously the number was in the double digits every single year. Compliance is a huge burden. It really is and the point of the Main Street Act, and one of the reasons I applaud it so much is because small banks do not have the kind of complex operations and they typically do not support the kind of systemic risks that J.P. Morgan does. Mrs. McClain. Sure. Mr. Brooks. So holding the same set of stress testing environments, which are obviously different for small banks, but those kinds of things for small banks really do not make sense. Mrs. McClain. Appreciate that. Second is you have said and I thought this very interesting, the Dodd-Frank made compliance so big and so expensive, excuse me, that it is too small for banks to succeed. I thought that was a really interesting quote. Can you elaborate on that? Mr. Brooks. Well, with Dodd-Frank---- Mrs. McClain. I am sorry. We have all heard, Oh, my gosh, it is too big to fail but too small to succeed, I think, is interesting---- Mr. Brooks. Yes. It is 100 percent true. So what Dodd-Frank did is--and I think some of this was unintentional, and some of it was just an overcorrection in a crisis, right? But now we have history, so we know what was good and what was bad about it. Dodd-Frank almost singled out housing finance for negative treatment compared to almost everything else. The reason we did that is because of this belief somehow that the financial crisis was exclusively a mortgage crisis and the idea was, well, we have these long-dated mortgages, and these short-dated deposits, and that mismatch creates inherit risk, so you have to hold enormous capital against your mortgage book. If you are a small bank, if you are a sub $1 billion, let us say, community bank on Main Street USA, like in my hometown, you cannot hold that kind of capital---- Mrs. McClain. It is just not feasible. Mr. Brooks. Right. So what happened? What happened is, all of those loans got sold to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and banks no longer held any credit risk. Mrs. McClain. I appreciate it. Mr. O'Leary, if I could switch to you for a moment. Mark Carney has twice called for reducing the dollar's role as the world's reserve currency; once in 2019, and then last month at Davos. What threat, in your opinion, does that pose to the dollar's global status? Can you comment on that? Mr. O'Leary. You are talking about Carney's speech at Davos? Mrs. McClain. Yes, sir. Mr. O'Leary. Yes. I actually believe, as an optimist--you know, I am a Canadian citizen, I am Irish, and my kids are Americans. I have a foot in both economies. There is a huge opportunity to work out a Canadian-U.S. situation to the benefit of both countries in a different way. The problem is, you saw recently Modi got a deal done finally, just days ago. That was done because Modi met with Trump privately. We need this now with Carney and Trump. We are in a bad place. I am saying that this makes no sense, and I think the only way to get it fixed, because we know the President is a very transactional individual, and I endorse his policies. I do not get involved in politics. I never made money doing that. I am a policy guy. What we need here is to deal with everything you just said is to have Carney or Trump find a place without anybody, no cameras, not a Zelensky-type meeting, just the two of them go work it out. There is so much opportunity because Canada has all the national resources, the largest economy on earth needs right here---- Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time--the gentlelady's time has expired. Mrs. McClain. Could be a win-win for both countries. Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady's time has expired---- Mr. O'Leary. Yes. Mr. Huizenga [continuing]. regrettably, because it is an important conversation, but I do need to keep this on time. With that, the chair recognizes the gentleman from Illinois, Mr. Casten, for 5 minutes. Mr. Casten. I just make the quick observation that we could actually cancel tariffs on Canada this week if the Republicans decided to pull the vote. Get some thought at the Rules vote later today. I want to talk about the--sort of the third rail that we all know but we do not like to talk about because we will get in trouble if we talk about it. I think, Mr. Moore, you had alluded to this in your opening remarks that housing is both an expense, and we get political credit for bringing expenses down, and it is also an asset, and we get political credit for making assets more valuable. The math that we all know but we do not like to talk about is that 66 percent of Americans own their homes. Even greater percentage of voters. For most of those Americans, that is the majority of their wealth. So, it would be politically suicidal for any of us to go out and aggressively lower the cost of prices unless we follow the advice of Mr. Barr, which I share: supply, supply, supply. Right? You know, that is the lever that is politically possible for us, whatever we think about that in some optimal space, but I think it also creates this challenge where--all of us agree that affordable housing is good policy. All of us understand the politics and you got to watch politicians' feet because their lips will say things differently than where their feet go sometimes. I guess I want to start with you, Mr. Moore, because President Trump has directed large-scale purchases of mortgage bonds, proposed allowing people to put their 401(k) as a downpayment in homes among other proposals. Redfin's chief economist said that if enacted, those proposals would increase demand. That is going to raise the price, right? Mr. Moore. I like that policy. Mr. Casten. Just in a vacuum, those measures, per Redfin, will raise demand, which means we are going to raise the price of people's homes, right? It is politically smart because--for a lot of homeowners. Mr. Moore. Well, look. This is a conundrum, no question about it, because if you increase the demand for housing then the price of housing will go up---- Mr. Casten. I am just making the point--that is a--that is good for homeowners. It is bad for home buyers. Mr. Moore. If you ask me, do I support Trump's idea of---- Mr. Casten. I am not--I am not asking you---- Mr. Moore. I do favor that. I think it would---- Mr. Casten. Okay. So then separately, we have got on the supply side--Kansas City Fed researchers said that immigrants who joined the workforce ease labor shortages and help stabilize the labor market. BOS data said that we have-- American men have a labor force participation rate of 66 percent in 2024. American immigrant men had a labor force participation rate of 77 percent. According to a Harvard analysis, immigrants make up one in three workers nationally in the construction sector. In major metro areas like Dallas, Houston, Miami, they are 60 percent of construction workers. Mr. O'Leary, I would shift to you. If that is the workforce in construction, do mass deportations of the workforce increase or decrease supply? Mr. O'Leary. You have the same issue in farming, actually, as you do in construction. The solution to this might be a compromise where---- Mr. Casten. I am not asking for opining on immigration policy. Mr. O'Leary. Right. Mr. Casten. I am simply saying when 60 percent of the workforce is being deported, does not that hurt supply? I have been in business. You have been in business--I do not know how to deliver---- Mr. O'Leary. I do not agree with you. I do not think it is 60 percent of the workforce. That sounds---- Mr. Casten. Well, 60 percent of the construction workers in metro areas, that is according to Harvard. You are not agreeing with me. You are agreeing with Harvard. It is also one in three workers in the construction sector. I think any analysis from the Fed--is the factors differentially affected. So we are in this situation where you have actual policies from the White House that are increasing demand, actual policies that are reducing--and I will give you another question, Mr. O'Leary. Raising the price of kitchen vanities, does that make homes cheaper or more expensive? Mr. O'Leary. You are speaking of tariffs now? Mr. Casten. Uh-huh. Mr. O'Leary. Well, the tariff policy has been, for decades, reciprocal---- Mr. Casten. I am not talking about normal tariff policy. I am talking about the bizarro tariffs. National Association of Home Builders said that the liberation day tariffs will raise the cost of a home by $10,000. You disagree? Mr. O'Leary. I invest in that space. That is not our challenge, but it is not something we are worried about as much as---- Mr. Casten. I am pushing back because you are smart people. Basics of supply and demand are not complicated. The only reason this is complicated is because we have gotten to a point--we are saying xenophobia is bad for the economy. Tariffs are bad for the economy. This is not controversial but to acknowledge that you have to admit that there are economically illiterate people in the White House--and the sooner we can do that, the sooner we can actually have a conversation about lowering the cost of housing instead of this nonsense that we are doing right now that is pissing off every single American which, by the way, is bad policy. Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired. Mr. Casten. I yield back. Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman yields back. With that, the chair recognizes the gentleman from Wisconsin, Mr. Steil, who is the chair of the Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and AI. He is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Steil. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Thanks for holding today's hearing. We just heard from our colleague from Illinois. One in four construction workers, I think was the stat, in his opinion, is here in the country illegally. That may be true. I do not have the stat in front of me, but it does not doubt--I have no doubt that Illinois has major problems considering its sanctuary city status and giving driver's licenses to illegals. So when we vote later this week on photo identification, I think it should not be lost on anybody why we need citizenship verification when you have States like Illinois giving illegal immigrants identification that would otherwise be able to be utilized to vote, although illegally. Let us dive into the topic at hand. How do we make life more affordable for American citizens? We have seen all sorts of policies being implemented across the country as it relates to housing, some good, some bad. Mr. O'Leary, you were on CNN recently talking about New York City's new mayor, housing policies. New York City's approach is putting in place price controls restriction on that side. Do not worry about supply because, of course, we are 6 million units under supply. So instead of focusing on supply, they want to restrict pricing. What are the real-world implications when you put in place price controls like that? Mr. O'Leary. Well, New York is a very desirable market, number one. I, for the first time, got to meet Mamdani recently, and I had a very brief conversation with him as just one investor. I think he has made a lot of promises about the outcome for the city, and now he actually has to deliver. So the market is going to do its own assessment day by day in terms of housing, because it is impossible to maintain rent controls on new builds. You will not get a new build. No one is going to invest in that and so, I think that was--I was interested in that question. I am just waiting for policy. Everybody is waiting for policy there. I would not have voted for him, but I want him to succeed now. So he is--the market is a nasty thing because it does not care. It is not emotional and they need a lot of capital. They need a lot of debt. They need a lot of equity, and they need policy. We have not heard any yet, so I am kind of saying, like everybody else, I am waiting. Mr. Steil. So you are in a little bit of a wait and see approach. Let me come over to you, Mr. Moore. In particular, you have done some analysis on more affordable metro areas, more expensive metro areas. What do you see between the--what policy differences do you see that we should be looking at here in this committee? Mr. Moore. Well, I mean it is simply a fact that the cost of living--this is one of the biggest stories in America. The cost of living is much, much higher in blue States than it is in red States. That is just a fact. So if you look, for example, at one of the charts in my testimony, you will see that the areas where housing is more affordable, the cities, are--I will give you the ones with the most affordable housing: San Antonio, Virginia Beach, Memphis, Houston, Birmingham, Jacksonville, Oklahoma City, Tucson, Atlanta, St. Louis. What do they have in common? Oh, yes. They are all in red States. What are the most expensive places to buy a house? San Francisco, San Jose, Los Angeles, San Diego, New York, Seattle, Boston, Sacramento. I mean, this is not complicated. All of these regulations and the high taxes, all of those things that are imposed in blue States add to the cost of buying a house and make housing less affordable. It is that simple. Mr. Steil. So let us build on that. Let us shift away just from housing. You have explored environmental, social, and governance (ESG) policies at some of the Nation's largest companies. I am of the view that proxy advisors ISS and Glass Lewis have a disproportionate say on boardrooms trying to drive forward a liberal agenda. We are seeing maybe a shift away from that, but what are the implications of driving forward in a---- Mr. Moore. That will make--as we move away from ESG--and the good news is that banks are moving away from those policies. That will reduce costs. Mr. Steil. Mr. O'Leary, do you have a view of some of the ESG policies that we have seen companies engaged in? Mr. O'Leary. They have to compete in a market that is changing all the time. These proxy services, for example, are not transparent enough for me. I do not understand why they make the decisions. I wish we would force them to be transparent. That would be very helpful because they make some pretty outcome decisions, and I cannot see for the life of me, why, and so they will not tell me. I think that is a problem and a lot of CEOs and boards are starting to look at this saying, wait a second, something wrong here. Mr. Steil. Well, they have a huge conflict of interest. We have legislation in this committee that I have authored that would address that conflict. There is a whole lot of work we need to do in that regard. I appreciate all of you being here today and your testimony. Mr. Chairman, I will yield back. Mr. Huizenga. The gentlewoman's time has expired. The chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Massachusetts, Ms. Pressley, who is recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Pressley. Since Black history is American history, I will say happy Black History Month. On the 100th anniversary of Black History Month, I refuse to allow our contributions to be relegated to a footnote, or to be whitewashed by an executive order. Dr. Hamilton, I am grateful for your leadership in shaping the national conversation on baby bonds, and I thank you for your partnership and counsel in the drafting of my baby bonds legislation in partnership with Senator Booker. Republicans and Trump will not give you credit, but we know that Trump accounts exist only because of your genius and the work on the ground that you laid as spearheading the issue of baby bonds. So I want to give you your flowers officially on the congressional Record. You have been a pioneer in confronting the racial wealth gap. I represent the Massachusetts Seventh Congressional District, and a report by the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston found--and this will shock many--but that the median net worth for white households in Boston is $247,500, while for Black households it is a mere $8. That has everything to do with housing. Dr. Hamilton, would you agree that home ownership plays an essential role in wealth building? Mr. Hamilton. Yes and thank you, Congresswoman. I honestly am very honored and proud to have that accolade that you offered me. Ms. Pressley. Thank you and we are grateful for you. So yes, homeownership is essential to wealth building. I believe that a majority of the public agrees with and acknowledges that. In fact, during the 1950s and 1960s, one of the foundational bricks that built America's middle class was homeownership. It was the advice given by the government to citizens and passed down from parents to their kids. Homeownership symbolized financial opportunity and freedom, but we know what was also taking place in the 1950s and 1960s: Jim Crow, Jim Crow discrimination. Black families who sought homeownership were held back by red tape, limited to redline neighborhoods, and faced blatant racism from banks. For those who managed to secure a mortgage and buy a home, the value of their homes were grossly diminished by an appraisal system rife with racial bias and that same appraisal system is around today. Just look at the data. Last year, a report estimated that Boston's Black homeowners lose up to $2.3 billion in wealth because homes owned by Black families are valued about 18 percent less--they can literally be right next door to each other--than comparable white-owned homes, or roughly $125,000 but this is not just in my district. It is happening all across the country. I ask unanimous consent to enter into the record a March 2024 article from the Bay State Banner titled, ``Boston Black Homeowners Lose Billions to Biased Property Valuations.'' I also ask to enter into the record a Brookings Institution study titled, ``How Racial Bias and Appraisals Affects the Devaluation of Homes in Majority Black Neighborhoods.'' Finally I ask to enter a Freddie Mac analysis titled, ``Freddie Mac Research Explores Causes For the Appraisal Evaluation Gap For Homeowners in Minority Neighborhoods.'' Mr. Huizenga. Without objection. [The information referred to was not submitted prior to printing.] Ms. Pressley. Dr. Hamilton, with my remaining time, for Black families of all income levels, there is no getting around a discriminatory appraisal system. Why does this matter for the affordability crisis and the racial wealth gap? Mr. Hamilton. You know, we should recognize when we cited that most Americans own their home, that is not true for Black people, and that is grounded in a history that you describe. It is not happenstance. Indeed, as we have this conversation, one of the problems is if we look at any analytical issue in an historic way, it is myopic. So if we are revisiting the Great Recession, if we are revisiting inflation in the pandemic, if we are not telling the complete story, we are inaccurate. Inflation was to deal with a pandemic--frankly, a plague that we were faced--and we had supply chain issues. It is almost miraculous that we are still not in a great recession today. The critiques of Dodd-Frank Act that we are hearing today, we are losing the context by which it emerged. It is almost as if we will repeat the same problems that we had in the past. Of course we need smart regulation, but complete deregulation was the root of the speculation that nearly brought down our economy in two scenarios. Ms. Pressley. Thank you, Dr. Hamilton. On the issue of the appraisal system in particular, I just want to share that I was proud to partner with Senator Warnock to introduce legislation that would modernize the appraisal process to strengthen transparency and accountability---- Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady's time has expired. Ms. Pressley [continuing]. consumer right to appeal if they disagree with the evaluation. Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady's time has expired. Ms. Pressley. Thank you. Mr. Huizenga. With that, the chair is going to recognize the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. Meuser, who is the chairman of our Oversight and Investigation Subcommittee and who is celebrating his 39th birthday today. Well, that is what you said, Dan. It was 39 but happy birthday, nonetheless. Mr. Meuser. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am glad you are not under oath, by the way. I am 40. Well, thank you. Thank you very much to our witnesses. Very important subject. This committee, I think as you know, and the Trump Administration are working on correcting course to our economy, removing barriers to growth, expanding housing supply through the Housing for the 21st Century Act, strengthening capital formation through the INVEST Act, revitalizing community lending through the Main Street Capital Access Act, all bills that have been passed. Taken together, these efforts reflect a broader policy shift away from government driven market distortion and toward supply side growth, capital formation, access to capital, housing affordability, pro-growth, what we used to call supply side, but we do not want to necessarily call it that but that is what it is. More domestic supply, the more we make in the United States. We exceed demand with supply, inflation comes into check, comes down, and even prices start getting less. We create competition at the same time. Mr. O'Leary, good seeing you. From your vantage point as a venture capitalist, in terms of job creation, business formation, long-term economic growth, what benefits do come from this regulatory and tax supply side initiatives and approach? Mr. O'Leary. I think when we were discussing regulation before, in all 11 sectors, if you gave an individual--an entrepreneur--and the way I look at it I go into these classes of students, 240 in the cohort, and I know with certainty, and I tell them this, that in 25 years two-thirds will work for the other third of the class. That is basically the ratio when students emerge. When you ask these individuals what would you rather have, reduction in tax or reduction in regulation, it is always reduction in regulation because they assume with taxes they are competing with everybody else at the same tax rate. So what they want is a path to be able to deploy capital with less friction. By the way, applies to all 11 sectors of the economy. We can talk a lot about real estate. That is the most recent sector of the S&P 500. That is the 11th sector, but every other sector also has issues around regulation. Something has happened over the last 20 years that somebody decided, through multiple administrations, that more regulation is better than innovation. I can assure you that is not the case and it is now time to really take a jackhammer to that stuff and get rid of it and let the economy flourish. The market believes that is going to happen, because you are seeing new highs every day in the DOW. So somebody is optimistic out there. It is not just domestic capital. Money is coming in from all over the world into this index because they believe you are going to do it; you are going to jackhammer regulations. Mr. Meuser. Thank you. Yes. I was just with some folks who do a lot of 7(a) loans and small businesses, and they say access to capital continues to be the number one concern of small businesses up to, as you mentioned before, Mr. O'Leary, $50 million and such. So, Mr. Brooks, the decline in community banks, how has it affected mortgage availability, housing development lending, and overall affordability? Mr. Brooks. Well, Congressman, as I said earlier, one of the biggest issues in mortgage finance is who bears the risk. Over the last 15 years since the financial crisis, it has mostly been the government. So bank formation has been at an all-time low. That has reversed in President Trump's second term, but we have very few new bank starts until the last 12 months and the banks that do exist, especially the community banks, have more or less been told that mortgages are a risky asset and you should stay away from them. So as a result, community banks tend to be local small business lenders and not very much else. That can change. We know what a community bank driven housing finance system looks like because we had it for 80 years between the Great Depression and the financial crisis. It worked pretty well. Now we have a government balance sheet for all of this which is terrible. My main point here is, it is desirable for community banks to drive the housing finance system because community banks are relationship bankers. They know the clients. They know the credits and they know the collateral better than any Washington, DC or Wall Street credit manager will ever know. So it is in all of our interests that community banks deliver what they used to deliver, which was the majority of housing finance. Mr. Meuser. Certainly one of our axioms here has been to make community banks great again under our chairman, French Hill. Dr. Moore, the affordability relief, inflation moderation, wages rising, mortgage rates easing, what extent does housing market depend on sustaining this pro-growth economy? Mr. Moore. So, I will summarize it in the 13 seconds I have left, which is what the chairman said at the outset. The best solution to all these problems, including housing affordability, is economic growth. The stronger economic growth, people's incomes rise, they can afford more, so keep it up. The most positive feature---- Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired---- Mr. Moore [continuing]. of your tax bill was the allowing the business on their capital purchases---- Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired---- Mr. Meuser. My time has expired. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Huizenga. Happy birthday. With that, the gentleman from New York, Mr. Torres, is now recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Torres. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Hamilton, your testimony spoke about the importance of public investment, public infrastructure. After World War II, the U.S. saw the emergence of the largest middle class the world had ever seen. Is it fair to say that one of the most important ingredients in the creation of post-war prosperity was public investment? Mr. Hamilton. Absolutely. Mr. Torres. Public investment and electrification and transportation, and mass homeownership, and mass education. So the lesson of history is that public investment and productivity are not mutually exclusive but mutually reinforcing. Mr. Hamilton. I think that is the point. The point is that public investment can come in many forms. We can build up public infrastructure, and we can invest directly into the American people. So when we start talking about this distinction between supply and investing in people, that is a question of values and how we want to do it. I think there is a risk, and we have over indexed on investing in firms to the point that they are able to turn around and exploit the American people because of the asymmetry of power. When we have people with low endowments, people with unstable jobs, people without a base level of resource by which to compete, not only do we stifle their abilities to produce and engage, but we leave them vulnerable to the whims of those that have power. Mr. Torres. For me, it is no accident that the post-war golden age of public investment coincided with the golden age of American productivity growth. During the golden age, American productivity grew by an average of 2.5 to 3 percent a year for 25 years. The economy itself grew by an average of 4 percent a year for 25 years. If the U.S. had sustained that same level of productivity growth over the last 50 years, the U.S. economy would be twice as large. Mr. Hamilton. What is more, Congressman, the real wage growth rate was commiserate, so it was an inclusive growth. With that high level of growth, workers benefited as well. Mr. Torres. So you can have equity in economic growth. You can have productivity in public investment. No need to create a false choice where none need exist. Mr. Moore, I know you are a great admirer of President Trump. President Trump has repeatedly said, quote, ``I have done more for the Black community than any other President with the possible exception of Abraham Lincoln.'' In his mind, Abraham Lincoln is a possible exception. Do you agree with that statement? Mr. Moore. I will say exactly what I said to the previous Congressman, which is that what this country needs most to solve so many of our ailments is economic growth. The numbers over the last---- Mr. Torres. I asked specifically do you agree that he is the best President for the Black community with the possible exception of Abraham Lincoln? Mr. Moore. I am sorry. You said---- Mr. Torres. Do you think Donald Trump is the best President for the Black community, with the possible exception of Abraham Lincoln? Do you agree with that sentiment? I mean, I think it is delusion of grandeur, but I am interested to---- Mr. Moore. I think the two Presidents in my lifetime who have done the most to increase the prosperity of America have been Ronald Reagan and Donald Trump. Mr. Torres. Do you think Donald Trump's legacy exceeds that of Abraham Lincoln when it comes to the Black community? Mr. Moore. I am sorry. Do I think---- Mr. Torres. Do you think he has done more for the Black community than Abraham Lincoln? Mr. Moore. I think that Trump is not a racist. I think Trump is---- Mr. Torres. I am not--I never said he was a racist. I said he has done---- Mr. Moore. I am saying he pursues policies that are good for everyone. I mean, I think---- Mr. Torres. Do you think the President---- Mr. Moore. The policy that Trump---- Mr. Torres. Mr. Moore, I think this is a simple question. Do you think President Trump has done more for the Black community than the President who abolished slavery? Mr. Moore. I think Trump's policies are working for Black Americans. Mr. Torres. More than Abraham Lincoln? How about Lyndon Johnson? Has he done more for the Black community than President Lyndon Johnson? Mr. Moore. I do not know--I am not going to rank all the Presidents and what they have done. I am saying what he has done so far in this term---- Mr. Torres. Mr. Hamilton, do you have an opinion on this? Mr. Hamilton. Obviously, the answer is no. Let me even add one other point about that period that you cited, Congressman. The problem with that period is that it was not inclusive. We-- -- Mr. Torres. Right. Mr. Hamilton [continuing]. also know--all right. Mr. Torres. Right. African Americans were systematically excluded from higher education and homeownership, and so instead of intergenerational wealth, you have a legacy of intergenerational poverty. Mr. Hamilton. Absolutely, there are lessons to learn from that. The lesson is, unlike excluding people and attacks on diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility (DEIA), what we need is affirmative inclusion. We can ensure that everybody benefits from the largesse of America. We need to design, manage, and implement policies in a way to make sure that your humanity alone makes you eligible, and you are not excluded. Mr. Torres. I see my time has expired. Thank you. Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired. With that, the chair will note that we do have a one o'clock hard stop, so we are trying to get our folks in as quickly as we can. The gentlewoman from California, Mrs. Kim, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mrs. Kim. Thank you, Chairman and Ranking Member, for holding this hearing and I want to thank all of our witnesses for joining us today. Last year, I was proud to work with President Trump on getting key provisions in the Working Families Tax Cuts Act that is already signed into law, and I am so excited. A lot of Americans will see the benefits of it as they file tax returns. Thanks to his leadership, Americans are going to be super charged when they file. So one of my favorite aspects of the bill is Trump accounts that will be seeded with $1,000 for children who are born between January 1 of 2025 and December 31 of 2028. Last week, when Secretary Bessent was before our committee, he shared that already, over 1 million families had signed up for that account. Mr. O'Leary, good to see you again. Can you talk about how you think these Trump accounts will lead to a more financially literate generation of Americans? Mr. O'Leary. Yes. I think it is a great innovation. I endorsed it at the time it was announced. I think getting the word out is very important as you are doing now. What is unique about this in a bipartisan way--and I spent so much of my career in education, educational software, and most of the policies for that came from New York, Florida, Texas, and California. We were very successful in reading and math and advanced scores there. We failed miserably in financial literacy. So with this account, by the time the child turns 5, as we continue to advance in technology, or 6, around that age, on whatever device they have, they are going to see their own personal net worth. If it grows to the index of the market, with no further investment than 1,000, it will get 8 to 12 percent a year is likely. That will trigger an interest at an early age to understand what this is, how it works, and a great opportunity for the parents to explain all aspects of financial literacy, including debt, and how, if you have too much debt, you will lose what is on your phone here. I mean, I wish I had this for my kids. It is a great idea. I cannot say enough good stuff about it. I think it is completely bipartisan and what I like about it for my employees, I can also invest in the employee by advancing their family. So imagine if you are trying to retain a real great engineer, a software engineer, and they just had a kid, and you say to them, ``Look, not only are you getting your bonuses here but I am giving to your family by that child. I want to donate to that too.'' So I think you have already seen J.P. Morgan get behind this. Michael Dell put in another $6.2 billion with his wife Susan. It is a great innovation. I cannot find anybody who does not like it on either side. It is a great idea. So you are right. Mrs. Kim. Especially those of us in California and New York, New Jersey, we are going to do everything we can to amplify the benefits of Trump accounts. You may know, I serve as co-chair of the Financial Literacy and Wealth Creation Caucus, and I know this could be one of the tools that we can utilize. It is so hard to get kids' attention to financial literacy. However, if they know that they already have $1,000 that would continue to grow with the power, or I say, the magic of compound interest, I think they are going to be pretty much very, very excited, and they are far more likely to invest and use this so they can utilize the funds to create the long-term wealth. Continuing with that, I know, Mr. O'Leary, throughout your career, you have been a long-standing advocate for diversification of investment. So talk about why that investment strategy is so important to avoid financial disaster. Mr. O'Leary. Well, what we have all learned, diversity is the only free lunch in investing, and I learned that from my mother. She had a rule: no more than 20 percent in any one sector, no more than 5 percent in any one stock or bond and that has really saved my hiney over the years with lots of volatility. Lately, there are new asset classes emerging, and I think it is really--obviously crypto is volatile, et cetera but I love the idea of financial literacy talking about diversification and when you index, most of these accounts are just going to own the S&P 500. That is 500 stocks across 11 sectors. Now, that is diversification. That is why this is a great learning tool. It is a fantastic educational process. It is amazing when you can find something where nobody dislikes it. That never happens in this town. Mrs. Kim. I agree with you 100 percent. You are right on that, that when you spread investments across sectors and companies, you are much more resilient to market shifts. That is why I am so proud that--we are working on the Supporting Early-Childhood Educators' Deductions (SEED) Act that will not only make Trump accounts permanent but also allow our American working class families to be able to also invest in crypto assets. Let us talk quickly. In the last 5 years, cryptocurrency adoption and value have dramatically increased by allowing asset diversification through Trump accounts and will allow American families to continue to benefit from the democratization of finance. Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady's time has expired---- Mrs. Kim. I have so many questions for you and conversations I would love to have---- Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady can---- Mrs. Kim [continuing]. time is up. I yield. Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady can submit those questions in writing, and we will pass those along. With that, the chair now recognizes the gentlelady from Michigan, Ms. Tlaib, for 5 minutes. Ms. Tlaib. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As a good colleague that I am, Congresswoman Sylvia Garcia had a question I am going to ask all of you yes or no since we have a cutoff. Mr. Brooks, do you believe affordability is a hoax? Yes or no? Mr. Brooks. Well, it---- Ms. Tlaib. Yes or no? Mr. Brooks. It exists. I have seen it happen. Ms. Tlaib. Okay. Mr. O'Leary? Mr. O'Leary. I did not---- Ms. Tlaib. Is affordability a hoax? Is it a hoax? Affordability. Is it a hoax? Mr. O'Leary. Hoax. Ms. Tlaib. Yes. We know somebody that keeps saying that. Mr. O'Leary. No. Ms. Tlaib. Okay. How about you, Mr. Moore? Mr. Moore. Affordability is higher now--affordability is higher now than at any time in the history of the United States. Ms. Tlaib. Dr. Hamilton. Mr. Hamilton. It is not a hoax. Ms. Tlaib. Okay. I also like to bring in my district. Detroit just passed the Rx program. It is an incredible program with cash assistance to new mothers in our community and combating poverty in our country has been really challenging. It has been kind of bizarre to understand but the more I am here, I understand that--you know, studies by Harvard, for instance, 65 percent of working age renters, household struggle to pay for basic necessities after paying their rent. It just keeps going up. It is not even going down. Study after study. So, Dr. Hamilton, do you see a role in direct assistance in providing financial stability, addressing affordability crisis, and promoting what you call authentic freedom? Mr. Hamilton. Yes. It is power. Those studies that--those interventions and the studies that accompany those interventions demonstrate that people were able to do a lot more from the simple intervention of cash. Ms. Tlaib. I sat down with homeless youth, and that is what they told us, We understand you want to give us housing and everything, but we also--we need to go to work, we need gas money, all these kinds of things. My Economic Dignity for All Agenda encompasses the baby bonus, the child allowance, a monthly payment to adults that builds on such research that Harvard was talking about in regard to cash assistant being more impactful. Zooming out, Dr. Hamilton, you noted that in your outcomes that you see today, including affordability crisis and massive inequality, a result of concentrated economic and political power and that is what I feel like my colleagues do not have the courage to take on. So, I recently introduced a resolution calling on Congress to end the political economic dominance of wealth of the wealthy few, halt the subsidiaries and the tax advantages that concentrate economic power, and reinvest in the needs of the American people. Dr. Hamilton, if we are really serious about adjusting concentrated economic power, the affordability crisis, how would you think differently about public policy? What policies, like taxing the rich, which are incredibly popular across the board--go ahead and poll all kinds of districts. They will tell you to tax the rich--rebuilding labor movement, breaking up monopolies and promoting democratic forms of ownership to displace corporate power. Should we prioritize and think about those kinds of policy? Mr. Hamilton. I mean, we obviously need to facilitate the collective, the ability--the collective right to bargain, the ability for labor to formulate and be able to negotiate the conditions of their workplace. That is a good place to start. The taxing the rich not only offers additional public resources but it also curtails some of that political power. Ms. Tlaib. Yes. It is fairness, too. Most of the people we want to tax, we are subsidizing their workers' health insurance and food assistance. I mean, it is kind of like this game of you are not going to pay your workers enough but the public is going to give you subsidiary--you are going to pay less in taxes, we are going to give you tax breaks and giveaways, and by the way, we will cover the health insurance and food assistance programs that your workers need to survive. Mr. Hamilton. If I may, I will say something, and I will try to be brief. I know this does not get said in this room a lot. We need inclusive economic rights. Ms. Tlaib. That is right. Mr. Hamilton. We talk about political rights, civil rights, social rights, cultural rights but at the end of the day, if you do not have a baseline level of resource, you are not able to engage in a transaction. You are either at the whim of somebody's charitable largesse, or the vulnerability of their exploitation. Ms. Tlaib. It is exhausting. It is like survivor mode. It is crumbs. Mr. Hamilton. So what we are talking about when we talk about guaranteed income, when we are talking about baby bonds, when we are talking about Medicare for all, it is simply a baseline level of resource so that people will have the ability to compete and engage. Ms. Tlaib. I mean, my colleagues easily pressed the button for tax breaks for the wealthy, the corporations, but they do not seem to want to do it for our families. I mean it. I am not saying this as some sort of gimmick. I really believe this is the only way we can combat affordability crisis, poverty. Dr. Hamilton, I would love your opinion on my Public Banking Act. Public banking is something that I think we need to really explore. North Dakota is a great example but keep writing about it. Keep trying to push, again, the fact that we need public banking in our country. Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady's time has expired---- Mr. Hamilton [continuing]. as long as people have a baseline---- Mr. Huizenga. The gentlelady's time has expired---- Ms. Tlaib. Absolutely. I agree---- Mr. Huizenga. Thank you, Doctor. The gentlelady's time has expired. The gentleman from Florida, Mr. Donalds, is recognized for our last 5 minutes of questioning. Mr. Donalds. Thank you, chairman. I think it is important for this hearing that last year, Members of Congress on the Republican side of the aisle actually did pass the largest middle class tax cut in the country's history. No tax on tips is not for billionaires and corporate leaders. Everybody that is on tip sharing in the United States is going to realize that when they file their income taxes. So I think it is important for people to understand that. Mr. O'Leary, really quick. National Association of Home Builders just came out with an article or a report maybe about a couple of weeks ago. They said that for the cost of a new home today in America, 30 percent of that cost is compliance with the government. In the facilities that you are building, what is the percentage of the construction budget that is tied up in compliance costs? Mr. O'Leary. Varies State by State. That 30 percent number would not be correct for California. I believe it to be 45 percent there. So if you want to reduce costs in California, you got to get a big axe out and start chopping the red tape. I do a lot of commercial real estate, and what I have learned is there are States--let me give you an example--Utah, that has a program called Military Installation Development Authority (MIDA), M-I-D-A. Other States should copy that because it is an accelerated permit if you are bringing the project of State importance, so that it guarantees certainty for capital. So large projects that cost billions of dollars require some form of certainty path to permit. I really applaud the leadership of Utah with that program. I learned about it recently. It is something I have not seen anywhere else so they have got something going there and other States should copy that. The permitting is generally in commercial real estate less but it is more about the time. The hidden cost is the cost of capital. The longer it takes us to get a permit, the more the capital costs. States like New York and New Jersey right now with the rent control threats, they got issues, and it is a real big problem. I am just agnostic because I have to find States that want the money and where you can build in. So three cheers for Utah. I am a newbie, but I am loving that place. Salt Lake City, here I come. Mr. Donalds. It is interesting you say that because I know there was a conversation around, ``Is affordability a hoax?'' Look, here is the true answer. What President Trump is talking about is that Democrats caring about affordability is a hoax because it is their economic policies. It is their public policies here on Capitol Hill that have driven the fact that compliance costs for new housing construction are exorbitantly higher than they used to be. If a single-family home--and I come off of commercial real estate. If a single-family home in the United States costs $300,000, and a third of the cost is government compliance and permitting, well, then that means that the government, whether it is Federal, State, or local, is driving up the costs on home acquisition for the American people artificially. To your point, Mr. O'Leary, we have to decide if we are going to be efficient with the people's time and efficient with their resources because contractors are not eating the costs to develop property. Developers are not eating the costs to develop property because they will go out of business. The truth is, if we are going to be smart about this, we examine all of the regulatory burdens, Federal, State, and local, around constructing new housing, constructing commercial development. To the point, I think you made it earlier, it does not mean you are going to have a Wild West of no permitting but there does have to be certainty in the environment, because time is money and that does not change regardless of your politics. Dr. Hamilton, I know we were talking about--you were having a conversation about public infrastructure earlier. Do you believe the United States is spending less on public infrastructure today than it did in the 1970s? Mr. Hamilton. The question is how we spend it on public infrastructure. When we---- Mr. Donalds. Dr. Hamilton, I do not want to cut you off. Is the United States spending less on public infrastructure today than we were in the 1970s? Mr. Hamilton. The answer is nuanced. I can explain it, but it is nuanced. Mr. Donalds. I did not realize dollars were nuanced. You are either spending them, or you are not. Are we spending more or less? We can get to the nuance in a second. Mr. Hamilton. The nuance is important---- Mr. Donalds. Are we spending more or less than we were in the 1970s or the 1980s or the 1990s? Mr. Hamilton. Inclusive of that $4 trillion tax cut for the wealthy, the answer is yes, we are spending more on public infrastructure. The question is for whom and to whom. Mr. Donalds. So we are spending more. Yes or no? Mr. Hamilton. Yes. Yes. Mr. Donalds. Okay. So now that has been established, how are you going to then make the argument that we are not actually investing in things like public schools or roads or healthcare infrastructure, et cetera, if the United States is spending more today than we were in the past? Mr. Hamilton. I just did. I said it is for whom and to whom. So if we are spending $4 trillion directed by a tax cut to the wealthy---- Mr. Donalds. Tax policy has nothing to do with spending policy, sir. Those are two different things. Mr. Huizenga. The gentleman's time has expired. The gentleman's time has expired. We have hit our--a little past our hard stop. I want to say thank you to all of our witnesses today. This was appreciated and insightful. I would like to also remind all of our members, without objection, that they will have 5 legislative days to submit additional written questions for the witnesses to the chair. Questions will be then forwarded to the witnesses for their response. Witnesses, we ask that you respond no later than March 17 of 2026. [The information referred to can be found in the appendix.] With that, thanks again. Happy birthday, Mr. Meuser and we are adjourned. [Whereupon, at 1:05 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- MATERIALS SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]