Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- PENDING LEGISLATION [Senate Hearing 119-305] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-305 PENDING LEGISLATION ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON PUBLIC LANDS, FORESTS, AND MINING OF THE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION on S. 462 S. 2787 S. 3695 S. 1349 S. 2860 H.R. 204 S. 1464 S. 2968 H.R. 677 S. 1497 S. 3004 H.R. 952 S. 1981 S. 3082 H.R. 1829 S. 2417 S. 3493 H.R. 3872 S. 2554 S. 3526 H.R. 3937 S. 2754 S. 3527 __________ FEBRUARY 12, 2026 __________ [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Printed for the use of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 62-927 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES MIKE LEE, Utah, Chairman JOHN BARRASSO, Wyoming MARTIN HEINRICH, New Mexico JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho RON WYDEN, Oregon STEVE DAINES, Montana MARIA CANTWELL, Washington TOM COTTON, Arkansas MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii DAVID McCORMICK, Pennsylvania ANGUS S. KING, JR., Maine JAMES C. JUSTICE, West Virginia CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO, Nevada BILL CASSIDY, Louisiana JOHN W. HICKENLOOPER, Colorado CINDY HYDE-SMITH, Mississippi ALEX PADILLA, California LISA MURKOWSKI, Alaska RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona JOHN HOEVEN, North Dakota ------ Subcommittee on Public Lands, Forests, and Mining John Barrasso, Chairman JAMES E. RISCH CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO STEVE DAINES RON WYDEN TOM COTTON MAZIE K. HIRONO JAMES C. JUSTICE ANGUS S. KING, JR. CINDY HYDE-SMITH JOHN W. HICKENLOOPER LISA MURKOWSKI ALEX PADILLA Wendy Baig, Majority Staff Director Chris Prandoni, Majority Deputy Staff Director and Chief Counsel David Gardner, Majority Professional Staff Member Jasmine Hunt, Minority Staff Director Sam E. Fowler, Minority Chief Counsel Maya Hermann, Minority Natural Resources Policy Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Barrasso, Hon. John, Subcommittee Chairman and a U.S. Senator from Wyoming........................................................ 1 Cortez Masto, Hon. Catherine, Subcommittee Ranking Member and a U.S. Senator from Nevada....................................... 2 Daines, Hon. Steve, a U.S. Senator from Montana.................. 3 Heinrich, Hon. Martin, a U.S. Senator from New Mexico............ 16 WITNESSES Checketts, Ty, President, Association of National Grasslands..... 18 Raby, Jon, Nevada State Director, Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Department of the Interior..................................... 24 French, Christopher, Associate Chief, U.S. Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture...................................... 40 Regan, Julie, Executive Director, Tahoe Regional Planning Agency. 60 ALPHABETICAL LISTING AND APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED Alaska Rainforest Defenders: Statement for the Record..................................... 607 Archuleta, Floyd: Letter for the Record........................................ 151 Baker, Robert D. et al.: Article entitled ``A New Frontier: Managing the Forests in Alaska, 1970-1995'' published by Intaglio, Inc., 1995...... 336 Barnes, Beret: Letter for the Record........................................ 268 Barrasso, Hon. John: Opening Statement............................................ 1 Bernstein, Mary-Claire: Letter for the Record........................................ 269 BlueRibbon Coalition: Letter for the Record........................................ 5 Bogart, Steven: Letter for the Record........................................ 270 Buck, Julia: Letter for the Record........................................ 271 Butler, Paul: Letter for the Record........................................ 272 California Wilderness Coalition: Statement for the Record..................................... 192 Carbon County, Utah: Letter for the Record........................................ 123 Carbon Water Conservancy District: Letter for the Record........................................ 125 Carr, Kaitlyn M.: Letter for the Record........................................ 273 Center for Biological Diversity: Letter for the Record........................................ 263 Checketts, Ty: Opening Statement............................................ 18 Written Testimony............................................ 20 Chicagof Conservation Council: Letter for the Record........................................ 274 Conservation Lands Foundation: Statement for the Record..................................... 176 Cortez Masto, Hon. Catherine: Opening Statement............................................ 2 Crandall, Karen: Letter for the Record........................................ 276 Daghero, Mowgli: Letter for the Record........................................ 277 Daines, Hon. Steve: Opening Statement............................................ 3 Poster depicting grazing allotments in the Middle Fork Judith Wilderness Study Area...................................... 111 Daniello, Paul: Letter for the Record........................................ 279 Davidson, Kirk: Letter for the Record........................................ 280 de Cavi, Sabina: Letter for the Record........................................ 281 DellaSalla, Dominick A.: Statement for the Record..................................... 266 Editorial entitled ``My Turn: Why I Oppose Privatization of the Tongass Rainforest'' published in the Juneau Empire on October 29, 2024........................................... 604 Donovan, Brittany: Letter for the Record........................................ 319 Down, Richard: Letter for the Record........................................ 282 Eastern Sandoval Citizens Association and Las Placitas Association: Statement for the Record dated May 13, 2019.................. 82 Letter for the Record dated February 25, 2026................ 173 Echo-Hawk, Walter R.: Article entitled ``A Context for Setting Modern Congressional Indian Policy in Southeast Alaska''........................ 401 Flammer, Steve: Letter for the Record........................................ 283 Fox, Sage: Letter for the Record........................................ 318 Franzen, George: Letter for the Record........................................ 106 French, Christopher: Opening Statement............................................ 40 Written Testimony............................................ 42 Responses to Questions for the Record........................ 118 French, Jesse: Letter for the Record........................................ 284 Gorsuch, Lee: Letter addressed to Amy Miller of Alaska Public Radio, dated December 7, 1993........................................... 610 Great Falls Bicycle Club: Letter for the Record........................................ 8 Harold, Stephanie: Letter for the Record........................................ 285 Heinrich, Hon. Martin: Opening Statement............................................ 16 Support packet for the Buffalo Tract Protection Act.......... 79 Support packet for the Cerro de la Olla Wilderness Establishment Act.......................................... 139 Holt, Jr., Stacy: Letter for the Record........................................ 286 Incline Village General Improvement District: Letter for the Record........................................ 160 Institute of Social and Economic Research, University of Alaska Anchorage: Report entitled ``A Study of Five Southeast Alaska Communities'' published in February 1994................... 447 Judith Basin (MT) County Commissioners: Letter for the Record........................................ 9 Kautzer, Schyan: Letter for the Record........................................ 289 Keep Tahoe Blue: Letter for the Record........................................ 179 Kemp, Molly: Letter for the Record with attached summary and review by John Wisenbaugh of the Institute of Social and Economic Research report ``A Study of Five Southeast Alaska Communities''.............................................. 291 Kilby, Mitchell E.: Letter for the Record........................................ 300 Klingel, Jon: Letter for the Record........................................ 155 Knight, Rebecca: Commentary entitled ``What So-Called `Landless' Supporters and Media Don't Tell You''................................. 598 Additional commentary on S. 2554............................. 602 (The) Las Placitas Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 81 Lee, Hon. Mike: Statement for the Record..................................... 120 Map entitled ``Land Conveyance Near Price, Utah, May 8, 2025''..................................................... 121 Letters of support for S. 3004............................... 122 Maps related to S. 3004 (Figures 1-10)....................... 126 Minutes from August 13, 2025 Price City Council meeting, including proposed alternative to the Upper Price River Watershed Environmental Impact Statement................... 136 Lujan Grisham, Hon. Michelle: Letter for the Record........................................ 103 Mackrow, Paula: Letter for the Record........................................ 303 Mapes, Craig: Letter for the Record........................................ 304 Mapes, Lynda V.: Seattle Times article entitled ``Target on Tongass: The Wildest National Forest May Soon Lose Its Protections'' published on January 3, 2026............................... 305 Meade, Parker: Letter for the Record........................................ 314 Menchego, Timothy: Letter for the Record........................................ 91 Montana Farm Bureau Federation: Letter for the Record........................................ 12 Montana Outfitters and Guides Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 13 Montana Sportsmen for Fish and Wildlife: Letter for the Record........................................ 10 Montana Stockgrowers Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 14 National Parks Conservation Association: Statement for the Record..................................... 190 National Stone, Sand, and Gravel Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 162 (The) Nature Conservancy: Letter for the Record........................................ 71 Olson, Rebecca: Letter for the Record........................................ 315 Outdoor Alliance: Statement for the Record..................................... 180 Outer Continental Shelf Governors Coalition: Letter for the Record........................................ 157 Pentz, Wyatt: Letter for the Record........................................ 316 Placitas Chamber of Commerce: Letter of for the Record..................................... 100 Poirier, Jeanne: Letter for the Record........................................ 317 Powell County (MT) Board of Commissioners: Letter for the Record........................................ 15 Price City Municipal Corporation: Letter for the Record........................................ 122 Price River Water Users Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 124 Prouty, Carolyn: Letter for the Record........................................ 288 Pueblo of Santa Ana: Letter for the Record........................................ 90 Questa, NM (Village of): Letter for the Record........................................ 147 Raby, Jon: Opening Statement............................................ 24 Written Testimony............................................ 26 Questions for the Record..................................... 114 Red River, NM (Town of): Letter for the Record........................................ 148 Regan, Julie: Opening Statement............................................ 60 Written Testimony with supplemental material................. 63 Representatives of the Southeast Alaska Landless Native Communities: Statement for the Record dated February 26, 2026............. 440 Statement for the record dated December 2, 2020.............. 570 Rio Grande Del Norte Coalition: Letter for the Record........................................ 152 Romero, Eliu E.: Letter for the Record........................................ 150 Sagebrush Habitat Conservation Fund: Letter for the Record........................................ 164 San Antonio de Las Huertas Land Grant: Letter for the Record........................................ 94 Sandoval County (NM) Board of Commissioners: Resolution No. 8-6-15.7...................................... 95 Letter for the Record........................................ 97 Sandoval, Michael T.: Letter for the Record........................................ 93 Sealaska Corporation: Statement for the Record..................................... 332 Shoup, Jack: Letter for the Record........................................ 321 Specialty Equipment Market Association and Off-Road Business Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 187 Sportsmen for the Rubies: Letter for the Record........................................ 169 Stewart, Nathanial: Letter for the Record........................................ 322 Storey, Nate: Letter for the Record........................................ 323 Street, Allan: Letter for the Record........................................ 324 Suh, Ian: Letter for the Record........................................ 325 Surfrider Foundation: Letter for the Record........................................ 209 Sykes, Allison: Letter for the Record........................................ 326 Taos County (NM) Board of Commissioners: Resolution No. 2018-21....................................... 143 Taos Pueblo Warchief: Letter for the Record........................................ 142 Taos (NM) Town Council: Resolution 18-28............................................. 145 Tenakee Springs, AK (City of): Letter for the Record........................................ 301 Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership: Letter for the Record........................................ 171 Torres, Jack: Letter for the Record........................................ 105 Torres, Marty: Letter for the Record........................................ 149 Trout Unlimited: Statement for the Record on S. 3526.......................... 212 Statement for the Record on S. 3527.......................... 214 U.S. Department of the Interior: Statement for the Record..................................... 206 Uy, Junice: Letter for the Record........................................ 327 Washoe County (NV) Board of Commissioners: Statement for the Record..................................... 166 Watts, John: Letter for the Record........................................ 329 Western Watersheds Project: Letter for the Record........................................ 168 (The) Wilderness Society: Letter for the Record........................................ 73 Wilderness Watch: Statement for the Record..................................... 215 Policy paper entitled ``Keeping the Wild in Wilderness: Minimizing Non-Conforming Uses in the National Wilderness Preservation System'' published in June 2005............... 224 Appendix I--Policies and Guidelines for Fish and Wildlife Management in National Forest and Bureau of Land Management Wilderness................................................. 244 Copy of House Report 101-405 from February 21, 1990.......... 256 Factsheet entitled ``Science Doesn't Support Livestock for Fire Prevention''.......................................... 262 Wilson, Karen and Jeff: Letter for the Record........................................ 330 Wynn, Carter: Letter for the Record........................................ 331 ---------- The text for each of the bills addressed in this hearing can be found on the Committee's website at: https://www.energy.senate.gov/hearings/ 2026/2/public-lands-forests-and-mining-subcommittee-to-receive- testimony-on-pending-legislation PENDING LEGISLATION ---------- THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 12, 2026 U.S. Senate, Subcommittee on Public Lands, Forests, and Mining, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Washington, DC. The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:00 a.m. in Room SD-366, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. John Barrasso, Chairman of the Subcommittee, presiding. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JOHN BARRASSO, U.S. SENATOR FROM WYOMING Senator Barrasso. I call this hearing to order. Good morning and welcome, all of you, to the hearing today. I appreciate all of you making the trip to be with us. We have a number of bills on today's agenda, priorities across the West. This morning's hearing will look at many pieces of legislation that impact our federal lands. Families and communities in Wyoming and throughout the West depend on federal lands for energy and mineral development, for grazing, for forest management, and for recreation. Included in the agenda is a bill of my own that is important to those who graze on federal lands. I would like to take a moment to highlight the importance of this legislation, S. 2787, the Grasslands Grazing Act. Livestock grazing on federal lands has a strong tradition in Wyoming and across the West. Federal grazing is a necessary tool for wildfire prevention and for promoting rangeland health. It is widely used by both the U.S. Forest Service and the Bureau of Land Management. The U.S. Forest Service manages both national forests and national grasslands. Livestock grazing is done on both national forest land and grasslands. Obtaining a federal permit for grazing on national forest land is common practice. However, there is a lack of federal certainty and clarity for obtaining the same permits for grasslands. In Wyoming, cattle graze on the Thunder Basin National Grassland, located in northeastern Wyoming in the Powder River Basin between the Bighorn Mountains and Black Hills. It encompasses a little over a half a million acres. That's a lot of land. My bill helps bring regulatory clarity for grazing permits from the U.S. Forest Service. Ranchers across the West depend on access to grazing on our national grasslands. They deserve to have certainty that their grazing permits will be approved in a timely manner. The Grasslands Grazing Act will give Wyoming's ranching families the stability that they need to keep their operations running strong. I would like to welcome all four of our witnesses here this morning, especially Ty Checketts, who is always wonderful to have here. He is one of the wonderful Wyoming ranchers who have been back to DC to testify, speaking on behalf of the important work that they do each and every day on their operations. I look forward to hearing your testimony, and from all of you. But first, I would like to turn to Senator Cortez Masto for her opening remarks. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO, U.S. SENATOR FROM NEVADA Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you, Chairman Barrasso. I also want to thank Chairman Lee and Ranking Member Heinrich for this legislative hearing today. Today is the second legislative hearing held by the Subcommittee, and I look forward to working with my colleagues on planning several more this year. We have a full agenda. As you have heard, there are 23 bills. Several of today's bills were previously processed through the Committee last Congress, and I look forward to working with my colleagues to advance them further. I also want to welcome all the panelists today. It's great to see everybody, from Jon Raby to Christopher French. Mr. Checketts, welcome, again, and also to the wonderful Julie Regan. I appreciate that Julie has come all the way over from Tahoe. She is Executive Director of the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency. She will be providing testimony specifically in support of S. 3695, which is the Santini-Burton Modernization Act. Thank you so much. And I, too, want to talk about some of the bills that I have on the agenda today. I so appreciate that there are several of my bills. One of them is S. 1349, which is the Ruby Mountains Protection Act. This bill, which has already been favorably approved by this Committee in each of the previous three Congresses--let me say that again, three Congresses-- would prohibit oil and gas development within the Ruby Mountains area of the Humboldt-Toiyabe National Forest, which is located in Elko and White Pine Counties in Nevada. The bill was created after the Forest Service received a request by an out-of-state member of the public to develop 54,000 acres of land within the Ruby Mountains. In 2019, the Forest Service determined the area was not appropriate for leasing due to the low potential for oil and gas resources and due to the extensive involvement of the community in opposition to leasing efforts. This bill codifies the determination that was made by the Forest Service under the first Trump administration, ensuring this great public space is preserved for its recreational opportunities, outdoor economy, rare wildlife and plant life, and the local culture that these mountains support. The other bill is S. 1981, the Strategic Grazing to Reduce Risk of Wildfire Act. This bill would direct the Interior Department and the Forest Service to work with grazing permit holders to create a strategy to utilize livestock grazing on public lands to mitigate risk posed by wildfires. In states where most of the land is managed by the Federal Government, like my home State of Nevada, ranchers and cattlemen rely on public lands for grazing purposes. Now, more than ever, due to climate change and historic drought conditions, these lands and the populated areas near them are threatened by wildfires that grow in size and intensity almost yearly. And then, I would also like to talk about S. 3695, which is the Santini-Burton Modernization Act. This bill is bipartisan, bicameral, and bi-state. It has wide local support from the Washoe Tribe of Nevada and California, local government, and the business community from both sides of Lake Tahoe-- California and Nevada. It has the full support from our Tahoe delegation in the Senate, co-sponsored by my colleagues, Senators Rosen, Padilla, and Schiff, and my co-lead in the House, Congressman Kevin Kiley from California. This bill modernizes the original Santini-Burton Act of 1980 that utilized revenues from targeted land disposal in Clark County in Southern Nevada to preserve Lake Tahoe from growing threats of environmental degradation and from rapid development through land acquisition and land management on both the Nevada and California sides of the lake. Changes were made to the law in 1998 that limited the use of funds granted by the act, by the land sales. However, preserving the pristine quality of Lake Tahoe requires our everlasting vigilance and ability to adapt evolving practices. Modernizing the Santini-Burton Act would allow Tahoe partners with additional tools to manage public lands and address visitation impacts. The goal here, and I am hoping working with our colleagues, is that we can continue the original intent of the Santini-Burton Act. I just want to mention two other bills on today's agenda that I am also appreciative of, and they are very important to my home state, and they are sponsored by my colleague, Senator Rosen. That is S. 462, the Truckee Meadows Public Lands Management Act and S. 3493, the Carson City Public Land Correction Act. Both of these bills, like the Southern Nevada Lands bill, received a hearing in December, were favorably reported by the Committee with bipartisan support last Congress, and are community driven. They prioritize locally identified needs, including specific land disposals to facilitate local economic development and residential housing needs, conveyances to facilitate efficient municipal management or support for local tribal communities, and efforts to preserve certain public lands for conservation and outdoor recreation. I look forward to the hearing today. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Barrasso. Thanks so much, Senator Cortez Masto. Senator Daines. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. STEVE DAINES, U.S. SENATOR FROM MONTANA Senator Daines. Chairman Barrasso, Ranking Member Cortez Masto, thank you. Included in today's agenda is one of my bills, the Montana Sportsmen Conservation Act. Our family roots in Montana go back five generations. My wife and I spend as much time outdoors as we can throughout wilderness areas in Montana, as well as our national forests. Montanans are clear about the importance of their public lands, and count me in as one who believes strongly in that. Local input and the best available science guide land management plan revisions, but unfortunately, congressional inaction has left many areas in Montana in limbo. The original intent of wilderness study areas was for land management agencies to study and then make recommendations to Congress as to whether an area is suitable and should be made wilderness or should be released to general management and not suitable for wilderness. There is so much misinformation--and frankly, lying--going on on this issue, but I want to set the record very, very straight. Congress, then, must act on these recommendations. Montanans are tired of going through the process of studying, providing input on these areas, and then not seeing any action taken or resolution. The consequence of this inaction is unacceptable, and I am determined to fix it. Following a multi-year, collaborative process with strong public comment, spanning multiple administrations, the three areas in my bill, covering just over 100,000 acres, have been deemed unsuitable for permanent wilderness. Let me say that again--multiple collaborations, over multiple administrations-- have been deemed unsuitable for wilderness designation. These are the Hoodoo Mountain, Wales Creek, and the Middle Fork Judith Wilderness Study Areas. The bill is supported by both the Powell and Judith Basin County Commissions, as well as multiple outdoor recreation, timber, and ag groups. I ask unanimous consent to add the eight letters of support I have received into the record. Senator Barrasso. Without objection. [The letters referred to follow:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Daines. I would also like to note that if this bill would be enacted, the lands included in it, as well as the Forest System as a whole, will continue to enjoy statutory protection from NEPA, the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, CERCLA, FLPMA, and multiple other conservation and land management statutes and policies. I hope that sets the record straight, because there is a lot of misinformation about this issue. The Forest Service, with public input, also develops forest management plans and travel analysis reports. The Montana Sportsmen Conservation Act does not strip protections, but instead, improves the ability to restore wildlife habitats, enhance sportsmen opportunities, mitigate wildfire risk, and increase multiple-use opportunities for Montanans. Montanans have waited too long for Congress to act on these three WSAs. It's time to listen to the science, listen to those on the ground, respect the collaborative process with massive amounts of public input, and return these areas to general management with multiple conservation protections remaining in place, as I mentioned earlier. I want to thank our witnesses for their attendance at today's hearing. I look forward to your testimony. Senator Barrasso. Thank you, Senator Daines. Senator Heinrich. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARTIN HEINRICH, U.S. SENATOR FROM NEW MEXICO Senator Heinrich. Thank you, Chairman, and I want to thank both you and Ranking Member Cortez Masto for convening this Subcommittee hearing today. This hearing will add to the significant number of conservation bills ready for markup, and I look forward to working both with you and Chairman Lee to get them marked up, passed, and frankly, signed into law, most importantly. I would like to highlight two of the bills that I have on the agenda that are widely supported in New Mexico. The first bill would implement a mineral withdrawal for four small parcels in the Placitas area, just north of Albuquerque. The threat of a gravel mine in the area and the particulate pollution that comes with it brought the community together to seek permanent protection for these parcels. The largest area, commonly known as the Buffalo Tract, is valued for hiking and outdoor recreation, but also serves as an important wildlife corridor between the Sandia Mountains to the south and the Sangre de Cristo Mountains to the north. These parcels are adjacent to a neighborhood and a community. There are literally several gravel mines only a few miles from the Buffalo Tract that are not controversial in this community because they are in an appropriate location. Further, the lands in this withdrawal proposal are culturally and ecologically significant to two Pueblos, two Native American tribes in New Mexico, who support this effort. For these reasons, it is an inappropriate location for gravel mining. This has been, literally, a decade- long effort, and I appreciate the support that the community as a whole has provided for this bill in past Congresses, from the local municipality, to the county, to the local tribes, and the neighborhood association. It goes on and on because this is not a controversial bill in my state. My second bill would establish the Cerro de la Olla Wilderness within the Rio Grande del Norte National Monument, and this parcel encompasses Cerro de la Olla, which is a towering shield volcano over the Taos Plateau where the people of Taos have hunted, gathered herbs, and collected firewood for literally generations. The high elevation of Cerro de la Olla offers solitude and unparallelled views, while the surrounding landscape of the monument offers recreational opportunities, including whitewater rafting, fishing, hiking, and camping. Designating this wilderness will ensure that all the above values are preserved so that future generations can experience them. In addition, this bill would make some minor adjustments to the boundaries of the Rio Grande del Norte National Monument to include recent Land and Water Conservation Fund acquisitions adjacent to the monument. The acquisitions will allow new public access to the monument, and increase opportunities for both recreation and traditional uses, but most importantly, we are further protecting these acquisitions from commercial development in an area that is renowned in New Mexico for its viewshed. LWCF acquisitions such as these are great examples of a community coming together to build economic development opportunities, to unlock access for pristine hunting opportunities, hiking, recreation opportunities, and provide an opportunity for protecting fragile and valuable landscapes. This bill is a major priority for the Taos community, including both the county, the Pueblo of Taos, the city, and I am proud to be able to offer this bill for consideration today. Both of these bills have had literally years of support and been processed by this Committee in past Congresses with bipartisan support. Understanding that the Chairman of the overall Committee and I may differ in opinion about this type of conservation legislation, I hope that we will be able to have these bills considered and advanced on a markup short-list soon. And once again, I want to thank you, Chairman Barrasso, and the Ranking Member for having this hearing today. Senator Barrasso. Thank you, Senator Heinrich. We are going to turn to the panel now, and it's an honor to introduce Mr. Ty Checketts this morning. Welcome to the Committee. He is President of the Association of National Grasslands. He is a Wyoming native from Newcastle, Wyoming. His wonderful wife, Becky, is here. She has joined us as well. Thank you, Becky, for being here this morning. Good to have both of you here. Ty ranches on his family operation. They run a thousand head of Black Angus on about 65,000 acres of both public and private land. He is a member of the Wyoming Stock Growers Association. He also holds a seat on the board of the Public Lands Council, and is a member of the National Cattlemen's Beef Association. Ty, I am very grateful that you are here today. I want to thank you for representing the ranchers across the United States. I also want to take a moment to thank the other witnesses for joining us this morning, especially the Nevada State Director of the Bureau of Land Management, Mr. Jon Raby, and Associate Chief of the United States Forest Service within the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Mr. Chris French, who is a friend and regular witness to the Committee. Thank you both for coming here again. I would also like to welcome Ms. Julie Regan, who is the Executive Director of the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency, and I look forward to hearing everyone's testimony this morning. Mr. Checketts. OPENING STATEMENT OF TY CHECKETTS, PRESIDENT, ASSOCIATION OF NATIONAL GRASSLANDS Mr. Checketts. Good morning, Chairman Barrasso, Ranking Member Cortez Masto, and other members of the Committee. I am grateful for the opportunity to be here to testify on Senate bill 2787, the Grasslands Grazing Act of 2025. For background, my name is Ty Checketts. I am President of the Association of National Grasslands, and also serve as a board member on the Public Lands Council, a member of the Wyoming Stock Growers, and also NCBA, like the Senator said. Most importantly though, I am a husband and a father. Our operation is on the Thunder Basin National Grassland. My family and I own and operate the historic Fiddleback Ranch. We run on 65,000 acres. We run a thousand cows. Without our permits, it would be impossible for us to ranch on this scale. ANG represents 30 national grasslands, grazing associations, and districts. There are 1,275 members that utilize one million AUMs of permitted grazing on four million acres on the national grasslands across the West. We work directly with our Forest Service friends to manage and improve these lands for long-term sustainability. Grazing on federal lands is diverse, but the laws governing it shouldn't create winners and losers. National grassland permittees have fewer rights than our friends on the BLM and National Forest lands. This inequity stems from FLPMA's final language in 1976. It originally included the national grassland permittees, but was later removed in committee, leaving them without due process protections under 43 U.S.C. 1752. As a result, the U.S. Forest Service created two classes of permits. Under 36 CFR 222.3, Forest Service permittees have more rights. National grassland permittees have fewer rights. It requires a simple change in language to replace the words ``lands within national forests'' with ``National Forest System lands.'' What this means for us as producers is, it gives us 10-year permits, priority for renewal, the preference system, written notice and opportunity to correct these issues before suspension or cancellation, and two-year notice before cancellation except in emergency. These are basic new process protections that BLM or Forest Service permittees currently enjoy. This bill simply puts national grasslands on equal standing. Long-term permits equals long-term stewardship, and allows us, as ranchers, to develop water, maintain fences, soil and forage improvements, and gives us financial stability. A 10-year permit gives our lenders the confidence so we can borrow the money we need to operate. Producers can plan and invest and stay on the land. The average age of a rancher is nearly 60 years old. Over the next 20 years, 70 percent of ranch land will change hands. Young producers need predictability and sustainability to stay in the business. Since 2017, the U.S. has lost 17 percent of cattle ranches--more than 150,000 operations. The national herd is at a 75-year low. Meanwhile, beef demand is up over nine percent from the past decade. We can't afford to lose more ranchers, and ranchers can't afford to lose more AUMs. The USDA's own plan calls for no net loss of AUMs. Sixty percent of the western beef herd grazes on federal lands. Fifty percent of the nation's breeding ewes do as well. Department of Interior estimates $1.5 billion in direct economic impact and $8.5 billion annually in ecosystem services. National grasslands are some of the highest quality of forage available. When you can plan, you can manage better and the land benefits. Grasslands cover 25 percent of the Earth's surface and they store 34 percent of the global carbon. Grazing supports native grasses, which are so important to our ecosystem. It reduces invasive species, such as cheatgrass, lowers wildfire risk that destroys communities and costs millions, and supports biodiversity in our wildlife. The changes this legislation addresses only extend to U.S.C. 1752 due process rights, not all of FLPMA. The Conservation Practice program stays intact. Prior exemptions stay intact. Grazing associations keep their current structure. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member, members of the Subcommittee, Senate bill 2787 is a simple fix with enormous impact. It creates a uniform, equitable, and predictable framework for ranchers who rely on the national grasslands. It helps ensure the long-term viability of rural communities, rangelands, America's food supply, and ultimately, our national security. Thank you for your time. I am happy to answer any questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Checketts follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Barrasso. Thanks so much for being here. Mr. Raby. OPENING STATEMENT OF JON RABY, NEVADA STATE DIRECTOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Mr. Raby. Chairman Barrasso, Ranking Member Cortez Masto, and members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify on the bills on the hearing agenda related to the Bureau of Land Management. My name is Jon Raby, and I am the State Director for the Bureau of Land Management in Nevada, an agency I have had the pleasure to work for for over 30 years. The BLM manages approximately 245 million surface acres located primarily in 12 western states and approximately 700 million acres of subsurface mineral estate. The Federal Land Policy and Management Act, or FLPMA, sets forth the BLM's multiple-use mission, directing that public lands generally be managed for a broad range of uses, such as energy development, livestock grazing, timber production, hunting and fishing, and recreation. FLPMA also requires BLM to manage public land resources on a sustained-yield basis for the benefit of current and future generations. Under the Trump administration, the BLM is managing the nation's public lands as national assets capable of growing our economy, helping balance the budget, and generating revenue for American taxpayers. These assets benefit all Americans. The BLM is working to fulfill the President's vision while protecting our beautiful lands and ensuring that America's public lands serve the American people. Many of the bills on today's agenda further the Trump administration's goals and priorities, particularly those related to mineral development, fire management, recreation and access, and supporting local communities. The administration is committed to unleashing American energy as part of the broader agenda of strengthening the economy and lowering the cost of living, and the BLM is working to secure a reliable and resilient domestic supply of minerals. BLM supports H.R. 3872, as it would expand the federal lands available for hardrock mineral development. This aligns with President Trump's direction to take immediate action to facilitate domestic mineral production to the maximum practical extent. Wildfires threaten lives and livelihoods and cost our nation hundreds of billions of dollars annually. The current administration is focused on streamlining organizational structures and regulations, including those needed to address today's wildfire crisis. The BLM welcomes the Subcommittee's interest in hazardous fuels reduction and supports S. 1981 and H.R. 204. Secretary Burgum recently reaffirmed the Department's commitment to expanding public access to the land and waters it manages by issuing Secretary's Order 3447, expanding hunting and fishing access, removing unnecessary barriers, and ensuring consistency across the Department of Interior lands and waters, which among other things, directs agencies to expand access and opportunities where compatible with law, safety, and conservation needs. Under Secretary Burgum's leadership, the BLM is taking concrete steps to implement and expand access to individuals with disabilities. The BLM supports S. 2968's objective of preserving accessibility and expanding outdoor recreation opportunities for Americans with disabilities and recognizes the importance of ensuring access to public lands in a manner that is safe, predictable, and consistent with applicable law. We welcome the opportunity to work with the sponsor and the Subcommittee on the bill. S. 3527 furthers the administration's recreation, timber production, and energy dominance goals while providing greater flexibility to manage and balance multiple uses, and the BLM supports the bill. Several bills on the agenda propose management designations that would restrict motorized vehicle use, decrease public access, prohibit mineral development, and limit the ability of BLM to adequately manage and protect the lands in response to changing conditions, including the growing risk of wildfire and changing public needs. The BLM does not support the special designations, mineral withdrawals, and other restrictions imposed in S. 462, S. 1464, and S. 1497. The BLM recognizes the challenges presented by irregular land ownership patters and believes that land conveyances are an important tool to ensure management strategies are effective and in the public interest. As such, the BLM supports the land conveyances proposed in S. 2554, S. 3493, and H.R. 952. Finally, the BLM has no objection to H.R. 3937, and looks forward to working with the Subcommittee and the sponsor to ensure the review directed by the bill includes all relevant agencies and mineral materials. Thank you for the opportunity to testify on these important bills. I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Raby follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Barrasso. Thanks so very much. Mr. French. OPENING STATEMENT OF CHRISTOPHER FRENCH, ASSOCIATE CHIEF, U.S. FOREST SERVICE, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE Mr. French. Good morning. Thank you, Chairman Barrasso, Ranking Member Cortez Masto, and other members of the Subcommittee. It is my pleasure to be here today. Today, I will present the views of the U.S. Department of Agriculture on 16 bills that pertain to the U.S. Forest Service. I am Chris French. I am the Associate Chief of the U.S. Forest Service, and in the wide-ranging nature of the bills we are discussing today, I think that when you look at all of them, it really demonstrates the breadth of the work that we do at the USDA Forest Service. The American people use national forests and grasslands for essential activities that support economies, ways of life, and American prosperity. Ranchers, loggers, miners, and recreationists, among others, rely on accessing these lands for their families, businesses, livestock grazing, timber harvesting, hunting and fishing, recreation, and mineral and energy development, all of which we will be discussing today in these bills. While the work we do on behalf of the American taxpayer is largely focused on delivering services locally, we recognize that management of our lands has broader regional and national impacts. So, I hope that today's discussion showcases the many ways in which national forests and grasslands provide benefit and opportunity to the entire country. While our positions vary across the bills, our testimony expresses our willingness to sit down and work with bill sponsors and the Subcommittee on the ideas they put forward. As always, I defer to the Department of the Interior for its views on the elements of these bills that would impact lands under its jurisdiction. Many of the bills included in today's hearing align with the Forest Service's commitment to ensuring the National Forest System lands are accessible and productive to the American people. S. 2968 updates the Forest Service travel management and motor vehicle use plans in order to facilitate access to a variety of recreation opportunities for all Americans. H.R. 3872 expands opportunities for hardrock mineral leasing on federal lands. S. 2787 and S. 1981 promote grazing on national forests and grasslands, ensuring streamlined implementation of permitting and the use of grazing as a strategic wildfire risk reduction tool. We support the goal of all of these bills and we hope to work further with the bill sponsors on any technical adjustments. H.R. 204 supports the Agency's ongoing efforts to build trust with the American public around the work we do, and in this case, our efforts to reduce wildfire risk. We support this bill and would like to work with the sponsor to ensure the bill's reporting requirements fully capture wildland fire risk to communities, the scope and effectiveness of our treatment efforts, and the associated cost to the American people. The remaining 11 bills under discussion today direct land- based changes in specific geographies. Across these bills, the Forest Service is committed to working with communities, tribes, and other local entities to resolve issues related to land uses. The Agency is similarly committed to working with you, Congress, to ensure that the bills' text achieves your intent. Across these bills, we do not support actions that limit our management flexibility or conflict with executive orders and other administration policies. To this end, the administration does not support further mineral withdraws from the federal, state and/or additional wilderness or wild and scenic river designations that limit our management. While our written testimony details some local concerns, in general, we support land conveyances, transfers, and disposals that make sense for our communities. In my experience, the legislative language directing these actions can often directly affect the agency timelines to complete them. We want to make sure that we are responsive and we meet your expected time frames established in the bills. So, for that reason, we hope to work with you to ensure that the bill language directing these actions facilitates prompt execution through the use of consistent language that streamlines our process requirements, reduces burden on agency resources, and effectively achieves the congressional intent. That concludes my testimony. I look forward to your questions and the opportunity to testify here today. [The prepared statement of Mr. French follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Barrasso. Thanks so very much. Ms. Regan. Ms. Regan. Thank you. Good morning, Chairman Barrasso, Ranking Member Cortez Masto, and members of the Subcommittee. As I am Julie Regan, the Executive Director of the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency, I am prepared for S. 3695. So, I will cede my time to others until that is called for further in the program. Thank you. Senator Barrasso. Senator Hyde-Smith, would you like to talk about your bill before we go to the questions? Senator Hyde-Smith. I would, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to these witnesses for being willing to do what you are doing, and all the services that you provide, but definitely for your dedication. It is much appreciated. And I do appreciate the opportunity to speak on the American Shores Protection Act of 2025 that would codify the 2020 memorandum that placed a moratorium on oil and gas leasing in the eastern Gulf of America. The moratorium still remains in effect today, and the bill comes as the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) continues to advance the draft proposed program for the 11th National Outer Continental Shelf Oil and Gas Leasing Program. The proposal fulfills BOEM's statutory responsibilities and it aligns with President Trump's executive order ``Unleashing American Energy''--what I have been so anxious to do. The proposal considers all potential options in federal waters that could benefit the American people. Expanding opportunities in the Gulf could help meet growing energy demand, create jobs, and support refineries along the Gulf Coast. Additionally, sales will help fund the Land and Water Conservation Fund, benefiting states across the country, not just Mississippi. Congress should allow BOEM's process to proceed without restricting the administration's authority. Thank you again, Mr. Chairman. I hope Congress continues exploring policies that strengthen American energy production on behalf of all Americans, and again, thank you guys for being here. Senator Barrasso. Thank you, Senator Hyde-Smith. Senator Murkowski, would you like to make an opening statement, or would you prefer that we proceed to the questioning? It's up to you, your choice. Senator Murkowski. Let's go ahead and proceed with the questioning, please. Senator Barrasso. All right, thank you. Mr. Checketts, if we can talk about some of the things you mentioned in your testimony, you know, almost half the land in Wyoming is owned by the Federal Government. In most of our states the Federal Government is the number one landlord for all of us here--public places that people from Wyoming depend on, accessing their livelihoods. Congress directed grazing, timber harvesting, and recreation to occur on these federal lands. National grasslands fall under a different authority, and therefore, there is no certainty when it comes to grazing permittees and the certainty that you talked about in your testimony. So, can you please describe the importance of certainty for you and other permittees on the national grasslands? Mr. Checketts. Senator Barrasso, it's so important that this bill passes. Let me explain. Currently, our grazing agreements can be canceled within 30 days--30-day notice. Imagine running a business where all you have is a 30-day guarantee. Many ranchers, such as myself, have debts. Many ranchers have obligations. We all have families to feed and cows to take care of. Think about the local economies, the schools, the hardware stores, the dealerships. Our local economies require ranching. We have to have ranching to support our rural way of life. It's the backbone of America. Some of the finest people I know are those who work every day out there, taking care of our lands to make them better for generations to come. Senator Barrasso. In a second, I am going to ask you what you actually have to go through each time a permit comes up for renewal because national grasslands and national forests fall under the jurisdiction of the Forest Service. They are not required to renew permits or allow grazing on the national grasslands. So, tell me what you have to go through. Mr. Checketts. Thank you, Senator. I am going to tell you a personal story. In 2022, when with the Thunder Basin Grazing Association went to renew our permits, there was a disagreement between our friends with the Forest Service, and we were simply told that if we did not sign, that we would be trespassing. So, we signed under duress. And I tell you, it is a stressful time for us, it is a stressful time for the Forest Service. Passing this bill will help us so that we have long-term sustainability on the 10-year deal, but that is something else that we should work on too. Senator Barrasso. So, you talked about the benefits to the local communities of the ranching and the agriculture. Could you also talk about how cattle grazing helps the national grasslands? Mr. Checketts. I would love to do that. I will tell you what, ranchers are the original conservationists. Nobody loves the land more than we do. Every day we work to protect the land, to preserve it, to make it better, to make it sustainable for our cattle, for our families, for our livelihoods, for the sportsmen that enjoy it. It helps with invasive species. As we graze, it protects against cheatgrass. Grazing protects us against the wildfires that destroy our local economies and cost millions of dollars each year. Senator Barrasso. So now that I have Chief French here, I am asking you, following up on what we have just heard, federal grazing permits from the U.S. Forest Service can be obtained for both national forest land and national grassland. Currently there is a lack of certainty that we are hearing about for the communities and for the ranchers and a lack of clarity for the permittees who wish to renew or obtain permits. How does the Forest Service undergo permit renewals for national forest land compared to the grasslands? Mr. French. It's under two different statutes. Mr. Checketts is right. There shouldn't be two different standards. They should be treated the same, and we would like to administer them in the same ways. Senator Barrasso. Great. And then in terms of wildfire, the United States Forest Service manages, what, 193 million acres of land, 154 national forests, 20 national grasslands, including, of course, the Thunder Basin National Grassland in my home State of Wyoming. Wildfires across the United States burn millions of acres every year--land at risk, homeowners at risk, the ranchers. How does grazing on Forest Service land actually help mitigate fire risk? Mr. French. It reduces fine fuels that carry those fires. It reduces dead fuels that often are carrying those fires, and most of those grassland systems, they evolved over time with fire as a part of them, and with heavy grazing. And so, it's a natural part of the system. Senator Barrasso. Great. Mr. French. It helps. Senator Barrasso. Mr. Checketts, anything else you would like to add? Mr. Checketts. This is so important, Senator, to take care of the ranchers, the local economies. I am so passionate about ranching. I mean, it is the backbone of America. As you know, in our home State of Wyoming, there are 500,000 people and a million cows. And everything that people use each day has beef in it, whether it's the makeup, whether it's our shampoo. Everything that has glycerin--I mean, beef is important. Senator Barrasso. It's what for dinner--and breakfast and lunch in Wyoming. Mr. Checketts. Beef, beef, beef, beef. [Laughter.] Senator Barrasso. Thank you. Senator Cortez Masto. Thanks for being here. Mr. Checketts. Thank you. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Thank you to the panelists as well. Ms. Regan, let me ask you a couple questions. I appreciate that you are here to talk about the Santini-Burton Modernization Act. To start with, why is the Santini-Burton Modernization Act necessary? If you would address that, and then also how it differs from the original act from 1980? Ms. Regan. Thank you, Senator Cortez Masto. Again, good morning, Chairman Barrasso and Ranking Member, and members of the Subcommittee. Julie Regan here, Executive Director of the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency. I will give you some brief introductory remarks and then continue to fine tune point the question. OPENING STATEMENT OF JULIE REGAN, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, TAHOE REGIONAL PLANNING AGENCY Ms. Regan. Our agency was formed by an interstate compact between California and Nevada, and ratified by Congress in 1969. Our mission is to protect Lake Tahoe, a federally designated Outstanding National Resource Water, while supporting our local communities and economy. I do appreciate the opportunity to address your questions and the Committee today in support of the Santini-Burton Modernization Act, S. 3695, a bi-state, bipartisan bill that is of the utmost importance to Lake Tahoe. The Tahoe Basin is the ancestral and current home of the Washoe people--the Washoe Tribe of Nevada and California, as they are known today. Tahoe is also the second deepest lake in the United States and one of the clearest large lakes in the world. Tahoe's nearly 200-square- mile surface straddles the border of California and Nevada at more than 6,200 feet in elevation in the Sierra Nevada Mountain range. Tahoe welcomes millions of visitors every year to our public lands. Outdoor recreation and tourism drive our $5 billion annual economy. This, in turn, supports our very small year-round population of 55,000 people. Tahoe also boasts a sizable community of second-home owners, who hail from nearly every state in the nation. Today, nearly 80 percent of the Tahoe Basin is owned and managed by the United States Forest Service, but it has not always been like this. The first public lands in the Lake Tahoe Basin were established in 1899, as the Lake Tahoe Forest Reserve, and totaled 37,000 acres with no access to Lake Tahoe's beaches. By 1960, just 50 percent of the Tahoe Basin was publicly owned. The 1980 Santini-Burton Act was essential to Lake Tahoe's conservation and public lands success story. Under the law, funds from the authorized sales of federal lands in Clark County, Nevada were appropriated to the Forest Service to acquire more than 16,000 acres of land in the Tahoe Basin. Through conservation and ongoing management, these public lands protect Lake Tahoe's famed clarity, are critical in community forest health and wildfire prevention, and offer world-class recreation opportunities. However, changes to the law decades ago inadvertently limited the law's scope so funds could only be used to acquire lands, but not to manage them. The lack of management funding contributes to negative environmental, community, and economic impacts across the region. If enacted, modernization would free up existing funding for ongoing land management, allowing the Tahoe Basin to complete more lake-saving environmental improvement projects--projects that protect Tahoe's famed clarity, improve recreation access, manage forests, and reduce wildfire risk. The modernized bill enables the Washoe Tribe of Nevada and California to make a meaningful step toward advancing traditional knowledge for forest health management and restoring tribal stewardship on their lands. Finally, the bill maintains the 1980 federal land sale boundaries in Clark County, and adds no new cost to taxpayers. The Santini-Burton Modernization Act is the product of a multi- year collaboration by our agency, Tahoe's state and local governments, the public, the Washoe Tribe of Nevada and California, non-profits, and the private sector. The bill also requires ongoing local input through an annual spending plan and partnerships with state and local jurisdictions. In 1980, Congress had a bold vision--transforming Tahoe into the national treasure that it is today. Thanks to Santini- Burton, Tahoe's unique character continues to be of national significance. But the threats to the lake require new solutions, solutions that the Santini-Burton Modernization Act can help deliver. I appreciate the consideration of this Committee today. Hopefully, you all have the opportunity to visit Tahoe soon. Samuel Clemens, the American author better known as Mark Twain, is a local legend in Nevada and the Tahoe Basin. He described the power of spending time at Lake Tahoe when he wrote, ``three months of camp life on Lake Tahoe would restore an Egyptian mummy to his pristine vigor and give him an appetite like an alligator.'' Quite a description. [The prepared statement of Ms. Regan follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Regan. I appreciate the opportunity to now answer your direct question, and the main difference that I would like to point out, as a summary of my testimony, Senator Cortez Masto and members of the Committee, is that the challenges are very different today in 2026 than they were in 1980. I will use a prop to demonstrate the power of the iPhone, which did not exist in 1980, and now with Instagram and social media, people descend in certain places all at one time, too many places and too many impacts to our natural resources. We are actually having resources degraded on our public lands, and the funds that were used to acquire those lands cannot be used to maintain those lands and to take care of those natural resources. So, that is a main difference. Another issue is our wildfire protection and the ability to actively manage lands that were purchased under the sale of Santini-Burton funds for defensible space and fire safety. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Let me just ask you one final question here. Discuss the difference between the funding that the Lake Tahoe Restoration Act provides versus what the Santini-Burton Modernization Act provides. Ms. Regan. Thank you, Senator, for the question. Julie Regan, TRPA's Executive Director, Tahoe Regional Planning Agency. The Lake Tahoe Restoration Act, which you championed along with our colleagues across the delegations in California and Nevada, has been vital to the protection of lake clarity, our forest health, fighting aquatic invasive species, and these programs are very large capital investment programs and projects. The Santini-Burton Modernization Act would allow maintenance to support those investments, making good on those investments, and it is a different suite of impacts that we are seeing. The Restoration Act will not address the recreational impacts. The Santini-Burton Modernization Act funds would support maintenance and protection of our recreation assets to allow more public access in the future. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Barrasso. Thank you. Senator Murkowski. Senator Murkowski. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I appreciate you and the Ranking Member for holding the hearing, and including S. 2554, which is the Alaska Native Landless Equity Act, on the agenda. This is legislation that has been co-sponsored by the entire Alaska delegation. Congressman Begich has introduced a companion in the House. This is legislation that we dub our ``landless legislation,'' and we are seeking to resolve an injustice that has been around for about a half a century now in Southeast Alaska. For reasons that are perhaps unknown and still debated, there are five communities--the communities of Haines, Ketchikan, Petersburg, Tenakee, and Wrangell--that were omitted from ANCSA's authorizations to form village corporations back in 1971. And as a result, the Alaska Natives in these communities have not received the lands that they were entitled to under ANCSA that other Alaska Natives received a long time ago. And that has left a situation that has just been unfair-- wrong, in my view, and something that needs to be addressed. And it's our responsibility in this Committee to attempt to do that. That is what this bill does. It allows formation of five urban corporations. It specifies the exact parcels of land that they have selected to fulfill the land entitlement. And importantly, it does so while fully protecting public access, valid existing rights, including for fishing, hunting, recreation, subsistence. It's about 115,000 acres of land for the landless communities. Now, some of you may say that seems like a lot, but in Alaska, or the Southeast region, or even the federal holdings in Southeast, which total about 21.9 million acres, what we are talking about here for this landless group is about one half of one percent going to rightful native ownership while about 190 times more stays under federal control. We have worked really hard over the years to bring this legislation to a place where people who are looking at it can say this is fair and this is something that I can support. We refined it. We worked it over and over again. This Committee has seen this issue before us multiple times. We have held Committee hearings on it over and over--in 2015, 2023, today. So, this is a little bit of a rerun here. But the changes that we have incorporated have been based on what we have heard from many, identifying the challenges, turning them around and really turning opponents into supporters--among them, believe it or not, the Nature Conservancy. They wrote us a letter back in 2023, which we reported to the bill with its passage. And as part of that letter, they say, ``Too often, advocacy in the United States has intentionally sought to undermine the rights of indigenous peoples in the name of conservation. This has caused tremendous harm to Alaska Native peoples and their traditional homelands, and the legacy of this power dynamic continues to this day. With this history in mind, TNC publicly affirms our support for resolution for the landless communities in Southeast Alaska. In assessing this legislation, we hope the voices that are most important to this Committee are not those of conservation groups, but rather, those of the sovereign nations in Southeast Alaska for whom this has been a generation-long injustice.'' That is from the Nature Conservancy. The Wilderness Society also wrote us a letter apologizing to the landless people for the hurt caused by their past opposition and declaring their support for the bill. So, we have come a long way, colleagues. I am going to ask unanimous consent to add those letters from the Nature Conservancy and the Wilderness Society to the hearing record. Senator Barrasso. Without objection. [The letters referred to follow:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Murkowski. But I would ask colleagues, take a look at them. See the legislation through the eyes of some of these conservation groups that have really been following this issue for a long time. I think we have worked to strike the proper balance and we are doing right by a special place, by the Tongass. We know that every acre in the Tongass is important to somebody, and particularly to those who have lived there since time immemorial. I want to ask one quick question to you, Mr. French. You know this issue very, very well. You have been around it a long time. In your testimony, you acknowledge the special relationship. You acknowledge the role that the Tongass plays in the economic health and prosperity of the region's community, and you point out that you are looking forward to discussing with the Subcommittee and the sponsor the implications of the bill, particularly to the timber program on the Tongass. I guess the direct question is, does the U.S. Forest Service, does USDA support our landless legislation? Mr. French. Thank you, Senator, for the question. And you are right, we have spent years working through the details. Senator Murkowski. Yes. Mr. French. On the individual parcels, and we completely understand the need and the whole delegation's approach on this, and we are very appreciative. We don't oppose the bill. We want to make sure that everybody does understand there are parts of this that will impact some planned timber sales. And as long as everybody knows that, we look forward to working with you as it goes forward. Senator Murkowski. Well, again, I would just remind that the parcels that have been identified have gone through a very laborious, thorough, open process in terms of identification. So, I would like to think that we can work with the Forest Service to deconflict in these areas. So, you have committed to working with us, and I appreciate that. BLM has also committed to working with us on some technical modifications. We think that we are in pretty good shape because you have been working with us, again, whether it's technical modifications or with regard to actual selection. So, my goal is to finally bring this home, that after decades of a longstanding injustice, that the people in these communities are finally able to have the equity that they deserve. And I would like to think that our agencies are going to be partners with us in achieving just that, along with this Committee. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Cortez Masto [presiding]. Thank you. Senator Heinrich. Senator Heinrich. Thank you, Ranking Member. Mr. French, we have seen a pretty substantial cut in the workforce in New Mexico in the Forest Service. We have seen that on the Santa Fe. We have seen it on the Carson National Forest, the Cibola, the Lincoln, the Gila. It has been felt across the system, from issues like trail maintenance, to processing permits for outfitter guides, to wildfire preparedness. The bills that we are talking about today direct your agency to do a number of things--to take actions and undertake new endeavors and new policies, all of which require an adequate workforce. How many National Forest System staff would actually be needed to fulfill your mission, all of the things that the Congress has tasked the National Forest System to do and to properly manage the roughly 193 million acres of land that the U.S. Forest Service manages? Mr. French. That's a big question. Senator Heinrich. And I bet the Forest Service has looked at this. Mr. French. We have. Senator Heinrich. I bet there's an answer. Mr. French. So, I mean, the reality is, if you look at the requirements of statutes of what we are told and asked to accomplish, the needs for funding and staffing far exceed the requirements that are placed on us to manage those to standard, and we manage the largest trail system in the country, 165,000 miles of trails. And yet, the staffing that we have, and the budgets that we have, we struggle to maintain up to a third of it a year. Now, I mean, we are working to overcome the things you just talked about. Today, we are announcing 2,000 summer hires, recreation hires to assist us in overcoming that work. We have been in a place of getting our workforce to a more sustainable level to the budgets we have, but we have done that work. We can certainly share it with you. I am not prepared, today, to give you---- Senator Heinrich. I would appreciate it if you can share that work with us. Do we pay our firefighters enough? Mr. French. In my opinion? Senator Heinrich. Yes, in your opinion. Mr. French. No. I think that--I want to be thoughtful here, because I don't have with me a particular position from the administration, but as a past firefighter, myself---- Senator Heinrich. Yes. Mr. French. When I look at what we ask them to do, and watching over the last 20 years, our fire seasons becoming larger and larger, putting more and more demands on them and their families, and when I look at what is being compensated at state levels, I think there is work to do there. Senator Heinrich. Mr. Raby, same question. The BLM manages 246 million acres. How many folks would we need to adequately manage that? Mr. Raby. Senator, thank you for the question. And of course, in the Bureau of Land Management, we have an organization of about 9,000 employees to manage 245 million acres. We receive about $5.75 per acre to manage these lands, which, we have always been a lean organization. We have been very focused, again, on our mission delivery, and at the same time, ensuring that we have organizational efficiency and workforce optimization. So, we have these, you know, again, we have always had these sort of competing objectives at times, but they are complementary objectives as well. And so, while, again, we may not have always received what we may have desired, we can't look on ourselves and say we are going to be woeful about what we don't have. We are very focused on what we do have, and then we set our priorities accordingly, and of course, we are fully staffed in our wildland fire organization, as well as law enforcement, and energy and minerals. And then, we certainly rely on a lot of partners to help us, between state and local organizations as well. Senator Heinrich. The parcels that were identified for withdrawal in the Buffalo Tract Protection Act make up roughly a little over 4,000 acres. One of my concerns is that they are kind of scattered through residential neighborhoods. So, the impacts of a gravel mine amongst a residential community would be felt pretty acutely, and residents are rightly worried about health impacts, noise, particulate pollution, as well as disruption to wildlife in the area. I mean, that's kind of the reason why there is, to my knowledge, no real opposition to this legislation. There is literally a gravel mine just down the road that is very successful and people are okay with because it's not in the middle of a residential community. Do you think that a suburban neighborhood is the appropriate place for a gravel mine? Mr. Raby. Senator, thank you again for the question. And when we look at the proposal for mineral withdrawals, that can preclude opportunities and options for, again, what we believe is responsible development that can take into account local considerations. Senator Heinrich. I'm sorry, Mr. Raby. How is it responsible to put a very noisy, very particulate-heavy industrial activity in the middle of a suburban neighborhood? I don't understand the responsible part of that statement. Mr. Raby. We go through a lengthy process between the environmental reviews. Senator Heinrich. I know the process. Because I heard about it from all of the community members in that area. I don't know of anyone who supports this. Your position--the BLM position-- has literally no community support. Do you listen to the community before you make a decision like that? Mr. Raby. Well, Senator, of course we listen to the community. We have our local line officers, our district managers, field managers who absolutely are engaged with the community, and they have to also account for the national policy direction when we have a declared national energy emergency, which, by reference, includes a mineral emergency. We have to---- Senator Heinrich. How does producing gravel solve the national energy emergency? Mr. Raby. Yeah, it's a mineral resource that, again, provides---- Senator Heinrich. Right. Mr. Raby. Opportunity for development and---- Senator Heinrich. Which we produce five miles away in abundance. Mr. Raby. Your point is well taken. I understand. Senator Heinrich. My point is that your policy in this case is completely disconnected from the local community, and while we have very wide opinions on this Committee, where we get crosswise is when there is a federal policy dictated from Washington, DC that is completely disconnected. And this is where Senator Murkowski and I actually agree. It's where Senator Daines and I actually agree. When we get in trouble is when we don't listen to the local community, and in this case, it is my view that the administration and the BLM are completely ignoring the local community. And so, Ranking Member Cortez Masto, I want to enter into the record, if there is no objection, all of the community groups, from local tribes, to the county, to the local municipality, to the neighborhood association that this would impact, their views on the Buffalo Tract Protection Act. Senator Cortez Masto. Without objection. Senator Heinrich. Thank you. [Letters and statements of support for the Buffalo Tract Protection Act follow:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Barrasso [presiding]. Anything else? Any additional questions? Senator Cortez Masto. I do, Mr. Chairman. Senator Barrasso. Please. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you for the opportunity here. Mr. French, let me talk to you, something similar, on the same vein that you are hearing, I think, from some of my colleagues. I want to talk about S. 1349, which is the Ruby Mountains Protection Act. In December, Senator Heinrich had asked you at a hearing here about the agency's decision to rescind a land withdrawal for the Pecos Watershed in New Mexico. And at that time, you replied the administration's policy is to preserve the spaces we have right now for future development until such time that we understand what our current mineral development is across the agency. I respect that. The agency, however, Mr. French, also rescinded then an administrative withdrawal for the Ruby Mountains in northern Nevada. And I know you are familiar with this because we have talked about this. However, the agency already understands the current mineral development potential in the Rubies, because in 2019, under the first Trump administration, the Forest Service released a decision saying that ``with the overall unfavorable, non-conducive oil and gas geologic conditions and the `No to Very Low' and `Low' potential for oil and gas, these lands have low energy resource values. Offering low energy resource value lands . . . would not serve the best interest of the public from an industrial or environmental perspective.'' So, this bill that we are introducing is merely a codification of the Trump administration's findings in 2019. So, I guess my question to you is, why are we still here with the withdrawal? Why are we still fighting this? And why are you still opposed to moving forward? Mr. French. Senator, I understand exactly why you are asking the question. That was the decision in 2019. That decision remains, and will continue to protect in that local way the further development of oil and gas. You know, what we are talking about here is, where a national policy approach, which, again, from the administration, is about making sure that we maintain the flexibility for future mineral development, aligned with policies that doing something through an administrative or legislative withdrawal doesn't take into account the local needs. And I think that was part of the conversation that was just happening to understand that. In this case, you are seeing a position in a statement that, in general, does not support any sort of withdrawals, but it doesn't change the fact of that 2019 decision that we made that made that finding that essentially limits oil and gas development in the Ruby Mountains. Senator Cortez Masto. So, then let me jump to you, Mr. Raby. On January 14, 2025, the BLM initiated a two-year segregation to consider a 20-year administrative public land withdrawal for the Ash Meadows National Wildlife Refuge and surrounding BLM lands that have been threatened by mining proposals to drill into the sensitive groundwater system, which could dry up seeps and springs that are the core of this refuge. You as well know the Devils Hole unit of Death Valley National Park and the lifeblood of the surrounding area. Local community leaders are in unanimous consent in their desire to see this withdrawal. A meeting took place on February 27, 2025 to receive public comment, but it is unclear if anything has taken place. So, Director Raby, I am disappointed, obviously in the Ruby Mountains withdrawal decision. I don't quite understand it, still, but I am glad the segregation for Ash Meadows has remained in effect, under the same administration. I'm a little curious about why there is a difference between the two, just pointing that out, but can you give me the status of the withdrawal? Mr. Raby. Senator, thank you for the question, and the status is that the parcel segregation is still in place, as in about, you know, 14 months of the two-year parcel segregation, we continue to work on, you know, with our partners with the Fish and Wildlife Service, the evaluation of that area. We no longer have the same mining proposal out there currently. And so, that, you know, does not exist out there, that application. And so, we will take that under consideration as to whether a mineral withdrawal would even be appropriate to advise on in the future. Senator Cortez Masto. Do you think you are going to need more time for any analysis, and if so, would you let us know and seek an extension of it? Mr. Raby. We will certainly let you know. Senator Cortez Masto. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Barrasso. Well, I think Senator Daines is on the way down to ask a couple of questions related to his bill, but any other thoughts that any of you have based on the hearing and what you have heard from one another today about ways we can be helpful? Mr. Checketts. Everyone is looking at me, but I---- [Laughter.] Mr. Checketts. I better say something. Senator Barrasso. We are having this hearing--in my opinion, this is the key bill to the Committee, so. Mr. Checketts. Well, Senator Barrasso, I will tell you what, grazing is so important. And grazing really protects our nation, protects our food supply. We have seen a lot of things in the news lately about beef prices, and even with beef prices the way it is today, guys, it's still tough to make it as a rancher. The beef prices, similar to what it was in 1980, when you add in inflation, when you add in all the different costs of operating, so to tie it back to our bill, our bill is so important to protect our ranching, to protect our families, the people that work every day to feed this nation, to clothe this nation, to give us the different supplies. And I am grateful for our Forest Service and BLM partners, and I affectionately say that we own the grass, you guys own the land, and I am grateful for them. Without the Forest Service and BLM, we couldn't make it work. What a nice nation this is to have the opportunity to work together with our federal lands to make it possible to feed our nation, and to allow me, as a rancher, to do what I love, what I am passionate about--to ranch, provide for my family, provide for my cattle. And I promise you that we take care of the land. We love the land more than anyone, and we appreciate that opportunity and our partners here in this room to allow us to do it. It is the honor of our lives. And we will take care of it. Thank you. Senator Barrasso. Well, you mentioned earlier, the best stewards of the land are the people that live on the land, the people that are there locally that want to make sure we are protecting it. We talk about the environment, the respect for the environment of the people that are on that land. Mr. Checketts. Yeah, we love it. And you know, we talked--I heard these guys talking about fire. We are grateful, also, for our partnership when we fight fires with the Forest Service and BLM, but I just want to add something here, and the important thing is cooperation and collaboration. I serve on two different rural fire communities, and when they are anxious to go fight fires, we are there first, and our Forest Service and BLM partners come and it works so good when we work together. And my encouragement to save money would be to have more local leadership with our BLM and Forest Service partners when we fight these fires. They have these command centers, and it's important that they involve the local people there. Senator Barrasso. Great. Well, thanks so very much to all of you. We are going to turn to Senator Daines for questions, but maybe other members may have additional questions, and they will be sent to you. There is going to be a deadline for us to submit those questions, and that is close of business tomorrow, but we would ask that you get the answers back to us by a week from the end of this hearing today. Senator Daines. Senator Daines. Great. Chairman Barrasso, thank you. Mr. Raby, when FLPMA was enacted, the BLM was directed to identify lands with wilderness characteristics. Congress has the opportunity to consider adding these lands to the National Wilderness Preservation System. Today, the BLM manages 487 wilderness study areas, totaling about 11.1 million acres. Thirty-seven of those 487 are in Montana. Until Congress decides what to do with the WSAs, the BLM continues to manage the area with the status in limbo indefinitely--that study status. My question is, Mr. Raby, what are the long-term consequences for recreation, forest management, and even wildfire response of wilderness study areas not getting resolved? Mr. Raby. Senator Daines, thank you very much for the question, and certainly having that wilderness study designation complicates multiple-use management. And so, it inherently limits our ability to carry out hazardous fuels reduction treatments. It can affect forest management activities. It can create limitations on recreation and access. So, it creates a layer of complicating, you know, management direction on areas that, as you noted previously, especially these ones in Montana that are before us in your proposed legislation, those were never found to be of suitable wilderness characteristics, and that has been since 1986. And so, they do complicate multiple-use management out there, and certainly their release would help uncomplicate that. Senator Daines. This isn't meant to be a Trivial Pursuit question, but do you remember who the President was in 1986? Mr. Raby. Well, I believe that was Ronald Reagan. Senator Daines. It was Ronald Reagan. Mr. Raby. Yes. Senator Daines. So it goes back to the Reagan presidency in terms of how long this has been in limbo and needs to be resolved. And we are talking about, in this bill I have, 100,000 acres of 11 million acres that are currently in limbo under the wilderness study area designations. Do you agree that Congress does need to move forward to finally resolve these 11 million acres currently in limbo to either put them in permanent wilderness or back to general management? Mr. Raby. Senator, the short answer is yes. Senator Daines. Thank you. Deputy Chief French, the Forest Service determined the Middle Fork Judith Wilderness Study Area was identified as unsuitable for wilderness over 30 years ago, and that was reaffirmed again in the fall of 2021 after extensive public engagement. Could you briefly talk about what led to this determination and what public input there was in that process? Mr. French. Yeah, our forest planning process that looked at this a second time, the engagement occurred over the course of six years--many, many public meetings. I think there were over 100 organizations that commented. We had about 1,200 individual comment letters that came in. And again, for the second time, it was found that it didn't have the characteristics to remain as wilderness. And so, we did our part of what Congress asked us to do, but it sits there still kind of in this limbo after we did the assessment, and it mandates a management that isn't aligned with what the community told us it should be. Senator Daines. And I think that that's important testimony, and I thank you that there was a public process with a lot of public input. And again, with these WSAs, when they are deemed suitable for wilderness, we should be looking at taking the next step to make them wilderness, but when they are deemed not suitable for wilderness, we should return them back to the general management status, which, as I mentioned earlier in my opening remarks, still has multiple protections as it relates to the general management status. It's just that they won't be managed as de facto wilderness as they are today. The Forest Service also manages three active grazing allotments that cover the majority of the WSA. I've got a poster board here behind me. [The poster referred to follows:] [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Daines. In 2019, the Forest Service reported to the Montana legislature that there is no mining and the vegetative management is minimal, though the Forest Service has recommended, and I quote, ``nearly one million board-feet of harvest per year for fuels management and to help maintain early successional habitat for health.'' My question is, could you confirm for this Committee that this continues to be the recommendation and that releasing the Middle Fork Judith back to general management will benefit hazardous fuels reduction and wildlife habitat? Mr. French. From my conversations back with the Forest Supervisor when they were doing this plan, generally, I would say yes. I haven't heard anything that would change that. You know, we are seeing a need to get in and actively manage these areas that have had fire excluded for as long as they have and have had no active management. I have not seen any change from that, so, yes, generally, I would agree. Senator Daines. As we say out West in these dry semi-arid climates, that either we are going to get in and proactively manage the forest or the forest starts to manage us, certainly through these catastrophic wildfires that we see as fire season is lengthened and temperatures have increased. How does the current designation affect the grazing allotments, and what happens if the WSA is returned to general management? Mr. French. Well, I mean, I think the thing to remember here is that it is being managed as wilderness right now, and what that does for us is, it changes the way we can access things, the way that we can do improvements for our permittees that have range allotments in those places. It limits our ability for flexibility for increasing some of those allotments because wilderness requires you only to allow what was historically there when it was designated. And then, it just limits our ability for active management of those areas, even in some places, folks not wanting to see prescribed fire, although we can do it. So, all of that is limited by the designation, of which, again, at the request of Congress to see if it was even suitable for that designation, through a large public process, we determined no, twice. Senator Daines. Mr. French, thank you. Mr. French. You're welcome. Senator Barrasso. Well, thanks so very much to all of you. I appreciate all of your input and your testimony. It was very helpful for all of the members. We are looking forward to moving these bills forward. So, we appreciate your time. This hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:19 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED ---------- [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]