Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-212] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-212 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS ======================================================================= HEARING before the COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ JUNE 4, 2025 __________ Serial No. J-119-47 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.judiciary.senate.gov www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 61-981 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Grassley, Hon. Charles E......................................... 1 Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 3 Hawley, Hon. Josh................................................ 8 Blackburn, Hon. Marsha........................................... 6 Schmitt, Hon. Eric............................................... 9 VISITING INTRODUCERS Hagerty, Hon. Bill, U.S. Senator from Tennessee.................. 6 NOMINEES Bluestone, Zachary M............................................. 39 Questionnaire................................................ 55 Responses to written questions............................... 93 Additional materials......................................... 159 Divine, Joshua M................................................. 40 Questionnaire................................................ 166 Responses to written questions............................... 224 Additional materials......................................... 302 Hermandorfer, Whitney D.......................................... 11 Questionnaire................................................ 313 Responses to written questions............................... 363 Additional materials......................................... 448 Lanahan, Maria A................................................. 41 Questionnaire................................................ 487 Responses to written questions............................... 523 Stevens, Cristian M.............................................. 42 Questionnaire................................................ 587 Responses to written questions............................... 639 APPENDIX Items submitted for the record................................... 705 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS ---------- WEDNESDAY, JUNE 4, 2025 United States Senate, Committee on the Judiciary, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice at 10:18 a.m., in Room 216, Hart Senate Office Building, Hon. Charles E. Grassley, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Grassley [presiding], Lee, Cruz, Hawley, Kennedy, Blackburn, Schmitt, Moody, Durbin, Whitehouse, Klobuchar, Coons, Padilla, Welch, and Schiff. Also present: Senator Hagerty. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF IOWA Chairman Grassley. Good morning, everybody. Today we'll consider five impressive judicial nominees. On our first panel, we'll hear from Whitney Hermandorfer, nominee for circuit judge for the Tennessee seat on the Sixth Circuit. On our second panel, we'll hear from four district court nominees; Joshua Divine, to the Eastern and Western District of Missouri, Zachary Bluestone, Maria Lanahan, and Christian Stevens to be Eastern District of Missouri. I'm grateful to my colleague, Senator Hawley and Schmitt for agreeing to co-chair this hearing when I leave in a few minutes. The exercise of our constitutional advice and consent role for judicial nominations is one of the most important functions of our Committee for the obvious reason that Article 3 judges serve for life, and the judges we confirm will impact the lives of Americans for decades to come. I'm pleased that the President has sent five strong choices to the Senate for our first hearing. Although the controversial moments in our Committee often draw the most attention, it's important to remember that we have a long tradition of cooperation across the aisle even in the face of heated political differences. Over the last 4 years, the Biden Administration put forward many controversial judicial nominees, most would not have been the choice of any Republican on the Committee, but elections, as we all know, have consequences. Despite our disagreements with their judicial philosophy, a substantial majority of the judicial nominees during the last administration received bipartisan support, and as my colleague on my left here now, then he was Chairman of the Committee, Senator Durbin, ``We are proud of the fact that these nominees have bipartisan support. More than 80 percent of them received bipartisan support.'' I'm proud of that as well, and I hope that we can have the same bipartisan support for highly qualified nominees before us. I worry that partisanship will hamper these efforts. Recently, the Ranking Member has raised the prospect of a blanket hold on U.S. attorney nominees. I hope that we can work together to avoid this. Confirming U.S. attorneys by roll call will consume more than 230 hours of Senate floor time and will keep us from working on other important matters for the American people. There is a longstanding precedent that U.S. attorneys are confirmed by voice vote, or unanimous consent with few exceptions. I understand and know where some Democrats are coming from, and that is because our former Republican colleagues held several U.S. attorneys at the end of the last administration. But make no mistake, that this isn't what you can legitimately call a precedent for blanket obstruction at the beginning of an administration before even a single one of these 93 U.S. attorneys have been filled. Holds should be used selectively, and this Senator has used holds as well. Blanket holds intended to wholly obstruct the confirmation process, or misguided and threaten to undermine the Senate's advice and consent. As the Ranking Member said in the last Congress, if the obstruction of U.S. attorneys is carried out, ``public safety will suffer across the United States.'' I agree with this sentiment and think that we should not place politics over keeping the Americans safe. The Ranking Member, and I agree that as he says, ``There cannot be one set of rules for Republicans and another set for Democrats,'' or as I would like to say, ``What's good for the goose is good for the gander,'' but we've also shouldn't take a single Senator's actions as setting precedent for Senate-wide precedent. This will result in inevitable and destructive race to the bottom. As Chairman and Ranking Member, I hope together we can agree to maintain the traditions, so the Senate will work. We both remain committed to the blue slip despite pressure from respective sides. I hope that we can also remain committed to moving qualified U.S. attorneys efficiently and using holds only on an individual basis or as last resort. Turning to our nominees now, today's business, we'll hear from five highly qualified lawyers. I'll leave it to the introducers to describe their qualifications in depth, but I'll briefly comment about the nominee to be Circuit Judge. Whitney Hermandorfer is uniquely impressive even by high standards of this Committee. She's clerked for three of the sitting Supreme Court justices. She was valedictorian of her law school, and she was co-captain of the women's basketball team at Princeton. After one hard fought loss, her college basketball coach said simply, ``She isn't afraid of anybody.'' Ms. Hermandorfer's grit is not limited to the basketball court. As a director of the U.S. Strategic Litigation Unit in Tennessee, she's led major cases on important issues of civil rights and the separation of powers. She is widely praised by practitioners across the political spectrum for her brilliant legal mind, hard work, kindness, and professionalism. Our district court nominees are also highly qualified, and I'll let Senator Hawley and Schmitt speak about them and their qualifications. We look forward to hearing from each of them today. Now, Senator Ranking Member Durbin, Senator Durbin. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS Senator Durbin. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. This is an historic meeting for the approval of Federal judges. We're doing things differently today than they've ever been done since I served in the U.S. Senate. What's happened? Well, a decision was made last week by Attorney General Bondi that the Justice Department would no longer cooperate with the American Bar Association rating process for judicial nominees. What's going on here? Why is this being changed so abruptly? Well, you look back and you can understand it, if you look at the history of it. During the first term of Donald Trump, the names were submitted to the American Bar Association of each of his judicial nominees. Nine of those nominees were found unqualified to serve on the Federal bench by the American Bar Association. Yet, President Trump in his first term, pursued anyway. Eight of them ended up being approved for the bench. What is that all about? The American Bar Association has a process of going to the peers and colleagues of the nominees and asking; what was your experience in the courtroom as a judge, as co-counsel, as opposing counsel, what did you think this individual was doing in their professional capacity? Were they prepared for the case? Did they comport themselves honorably? Just basic questions. And the nominees then are subject to rating by the American Bar Association; qualified, well-qualified, unqualified. Under Trump's first term, as I mentioned, 9 or 10 were found unqualified. Eight of them were approved for lifetime appointments to the Federal bench. All right, so Durbin, what about your nominees under President Biden? 235 were approved by this Committee? Were any of them found unqualified by the American Bar Association? Not one. So, the difference is the Attorney General has decided to protect against the vulnerability that some nominees, maybe even some today might have been find found unqualified. I think that's a mistake. I think that kind of professional valuation, which has been going on under, under Presidents of both political parties for decades should continue. But the Trump administration second term has decided the ABA is no longer welcome to review judicial nominees. That's a mistake. And then there's the Trump Administration's rejection of the Federalist Society. The Federalist Society. I asked this question for 20 years, literally 20 years. What's going on here? Why is this the secret handshake of all the Republican nominees that they belong to the Federalist Society created by Leonard Leo and others? What does it mean? A lot of the nominees would say, oh, it's just a free lunch. Go and listen to a lecture. It doesn't mean a thing, but it turns out to be a recurring pattern that if you're going to be considered as a serious nominee on the Republican side, you've got to be part of the Federalist Society. But guess what happened? Just recently last week, President Trump wrote on Truth Social, ``I am so disappointed in the Federalist Society because of the bad advice they gave me on numerous judicial nominees.'' From President Trump. He also called one of the organization's longtime leaders, Leonard Leo, ``a real sleazebag who probably hates America.'' From President Trump's own mouth. Yet, during his first Presidential campaign, then candidate Trump quote said, we're going to have great judges, conservative, all picked by the Federalist Society. President Trump's mindless inconsistencies are a classic example of situation ethics. But when they toss out the American Bar Association and they toss out the Federalist Society, they don't want anyone looking over the shoulders of the nominees to find out what they believe, what they've said, what they've done. I don't get it. I don't think that's in the best interest of picking the right people for the judiciary of either political party. And then there's this issue that the Chairman raised. And he and I are friends, so this is not a personal thing. We have been wrestling with this, at least between us, in conversation for weeks about how to resolve it. Here's what it boils down to. Trump's first term, 94 U.S. attorney appointees, Democrats in majority in the Senate. ``Boy, that must have been a battle royal.'' It was not. They were all approved by voice vote. In the Committee, voice vote on the floor, because that was a custom in practice. We decided that we'd do a background check through the FBI of these U.S. attorney nominees, and then basically agreed to them on a bipartisan basis. Things were going along pretty well. I think both political parties felt that it was a fair process and then something happened. One of the Senators from the State of Ohio, JD Vance, who went on to become Vice- President, decided to object to these voice votes on the floor of the U.S. Senate. So, he wanted to put 2 or 3 days of procedure into the choice of each of the U.S. attorneys. It stopped the process as the Chairman just noted, when you start taking 3 days or 4 days for 93 nominees, you start eating up the calendar of the Senate and they can't do anything else. I appealed to JD Vance, then-Senator at the time, saying you don't want to do this. To put an end to this process is just not appropriate, and it's not fair to these nominees. You're not objecting to any single person being unqualified. You're saying that every one of Biden's nominees has to go through a 3-or 4-day process on the floor. It it's just unmanageable, and it's unreasonable.'' And guess what? The tables turn. There comes a time when you want to move these by voice vote and we're going to have to say, as Democrats, we're going to follow the Vance precedent. So, it isn't just the fact that JD Vance started it, but I would go to the floor four different times asking for unanimous consent for him to reconsider this position. ``Don't do this. Stick with the original approach we used under President Trump at first term and President Biden as well.'' He would not budge an inch. And when he was off campaigning for a Vice-President, a group of Republican Senators, I'm not going to name names, but they're all a matter of record, joined on the floor to sustain this Vance precedent. I've been saying to Chairman Grassley, you expect me to just look the other way. Now, U.S. attorneys are coming before us and I'm supposed to say, ``Well, let's go back to voice votes again.'' One set of rules for Democrats, another set of rules for Republicans. That's the mess we're in. We can work this out and we should. I've got to hold on one nominee from Florida. I've spoken to both Florida Senators about it. It isn't personal. We've got to find a way out of this that is fair and bipartisan, and that we're going to stick with for both political parties. You just can't change the rules overnight. And that's what we're faced with. So, Mr. Chairman, this is more than just the ordinary meeting of the nominees to be considered by this Committee. This is the first time there's no ABA involvement. The Federalist Society is now a suspect sleazebag group when used to be the required approval before anyone's taken seriously. And we still have to resolve the mess left behind by Vice President Vance. Chairman Grassley. I don't expect you to know this, but I had at least one conversation with---- Senator Durbin. You want me to hear you? Chairman Grassley [continuing]. Yes, but I wanted to--I want to tell everybody. I want to, at least to my colleagues here, that I had at least one conversation with one of the Senators other than Vance that was holding up nominations because I thought this set a bad precedent. Maybe you and I can work it out. Can we? Senator Durbin. I hope so. Chairman Grassley. Okay. I do have a short rebuttal to what you said about the ABA. The ABA can still send letters to the Committee, just like any other organization. But Attorney General Bondi's decision to no longer provide them special access to nominees is hardly surprising. For decades, Republicans have criticized the progressive bias of the ABA. These complaints aren't new and are why the Bush administration stopped conferring with the ABA to select nominees. Examples of bias by the ABA rating abound. Just last Congress, the ABA told us that the Biden appointee, Charnelle Bjelkengren, was ``qualified'' to be a Federal judge. At the hearing, she didn't even know what the Article 2 of the Constitution was. The same ABA famously told us that Republican appointee, Judge Frank Easterbrook, a highly respected law professor who had argued 20 cases before the Supreme Court was in some members estimation, not qualified. The ABA has chosen to act as a partisan progressive organization. They advocate for transgender causes, racist DEI policies, and the outlandish assertion that the Equal Rights Amendment is now part of the Constitution. The ABA has recently sued the Trump administration for cutting USAID funding, and its current President has publicly attacked the administration. The ABAs political bias is obvious and has been for years. It's no surprise that the current administration doesn't trust the ABA to be a neutral arbiter of the nominees' appointments. Now, we'll go to Senator Blackburn to introduce the nominee from her State. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARSHA BLACKBURN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I am absolutely so pleased to introduce Whitney Hermandorfer. She is President Trump's nominee to fill the vacancy on the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. She is his very first judicial nominee for his second term, and I am thrilled that we have such an outstanding and qualified nominee to come before us. Whitney is a native Tennessean, and she grew up in the Nashville area. She attended the Harpeth Hall School where she was a standout, and today, we have a lot of those alums watching to see Whitney as she is here before our Committee. She received her BA magna cum laude from Princeton, where she was co-captain of the women's varsity basketball team. She received her JD from George Washington University, and as you mentioned Mr. Chairman, she graduated first in her class, and she served as editor-in-chief of the Law Review. So, she is smart, she is athletic, she is well-rounded, she is accomplished, and that is repeated in her career. After she finished law school, she was an associate at Williams & Connolly where her practice mainly involved appellate litigation, and regulatory and administrative law. In addition, she has clerked for four Federal judges, including three Supreme Court justices; Justice Alito, Justice Barrett, and then-Judge Kavanaugh when he was on the DC Circuit. After clerking, Whitney joined Williams & Connolly, again, from 2021 to 23. In 23, Whitney also served as an adjunct professor at her alma mater, George Washington University Law School. Since 2023, Whitney has served as director of the Strategic Litigation Unit in the Office of Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti. In that role, Whitney leads a team of talented attorneys in the AGs office fighting to protect the interest of Tennesseans and our State, and active policies. In his second term, President Trump is looking to fill our Federal judiciary with the best of the best. There is no doubt in my mind that Whitney fits this mold. She will be a tireless advocate for our Constitution, someone who will apply the law as it is written, not try to rewrite the law or the Constitution from the bench, and she's imminently qualified to serve on the Sixth Circuit. I could not be more honored than to support her nomination. And Mr. Chairman, I'm looking forward to working with you and Leader Thune to really get her confirmation completed very soon, and see her seated on the bench. Thank you. Chairman Grassley. Senator Hagerty. STATEMENT OF HON. BILL HAGERTY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Senator Hagerty. Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, thank you for allowing me to join today. It's my privilege to join Senator Blackburn in introducing Whitney Hermandorfer, a terrific Tennessean, and someone who is now President Trump's nominee to be Circuit Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Whitney's story begins at home in our home State of Tennessee. Let me begin with her academic background. She may well be the most credentialed lawyer to ever appear before this Committee. Whitney began at Princeton University earning her sociology degree magna cum laude. While she was excelling in the classroom, she was a leader on the court, a different sort of court, serving as co-captain of the women's varsity basketball team. Next, George Washington University Law School. She graduated first in her class. Not only that, Whitney served as editor-in-chief of the Law Review, making her scholastic success all the more impressive. Whitney then accumulated the most prestigious series of clerkships that I've ever seen. She clerked on the District of DC for my friend, Judge Dick Leon, for then Circuit Judge Brett Kavanaugh. And finally, on the U.S. Supreme Court for Justices Samuel Alito and Amy Coney Barrett. Frankly, that's remarkable. Most recently, she served as the director of the Strategic Litigation Unit in the office of the Tennessee's Attorney General. She served as the lead strategist and advocate for the State of Tennessee in its most complex and its most sensitive cases. We just distinguished herself in that role as an advocate. She brings profound insights regarding the structure, the genius of our Constitution. She weaves careful, nuanced reasoning throughout her briefs and oral arguments, earning the respect of the judges before whom she appears. She's proven that she has the experience and the demeanor that our very best judges possess. Though impressive, Whitney's professional achievements are only one side of this exceptional person. Her story is classic Tennessee. She hails from Franklin just south of Nashville, child of a songwriter, a musician, and a stay-at-home mother. She graduated from Harbert Hall High School, and was the co- captain of her school's basketball team that won the State championship during Whitney senior year. Now back at home in the rolling hills of middle Tennessee, Whitney fills what little spare time she has as a proud wife and mother of three daughters, and somehow still finds the time to fit in coaching her daughter's third grade basketball team and teaching Sunday school at her church. You can't spend 5 minutes with Whitney and not be impressed by humility and her genuine kindness. Her optimism is simply infectious. But perhaps most important is Whitney's genuine love for our Constitution. She understands the Constitution must be interpreted according to its original meaning, that its meaning doesn't shift due to changes in public opinion, nor the preferences of whoever it is that's sitting on the bench. Whitney is the very best and the very brightest that our Nation can offer. I'm confident that Whitney will, if confirmed, administer justice without fear or favor, and without preference to the poor, rich, the weak, or the powerful. Whitney Hermandorfer is an outstanding nominee to serve in the Sixth Circuit, and I urge all my colleagues in the Committee to quickly advance her nomination. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Senator Hagerty. And if you want to, you can stay here, go, whatever you want to do, Senator. Now, we're going to have Senator Hawley and Senator Schmitt. We'll start with Senator Hawley. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JOSH HAWLEY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. This is a great day for the State of Missouri. It is an honor today to introduce four outstanding Missourians who are being nominated by President Trump for the Federal bench. And we're very proud of the fact that these are President Trump's first judicial nominees from the State of Missouri. Let me start with Missouri's Josh Divine, who is our current solicitor general. Josh's experience as solicitor general is wide-ranging. He has litigated in trial courts and appellate courts in the State Supreme Court, in Federal trial courts, in Federal appellate courts, dozens and dozens. It may be hundreds of times by this point. And any way you look at his record, his success record, it's astounding. Just to quantify it in dollar terms, Josh, as Solicitor General of Missouri, has won in dollar terms, he has a $725 billion, that's with a B, billion dollar win record for the State of Missouri, including a judgment against China for the harms caused to Missourians during COVID-19 of $25 billion. Josh comes to us from Yale Law School. He's been a clerk at the U.S. Supreme Court for Justice Clarence Thomas. He worked in the Missouri Attorney General's office, first as a deputy solicitor general, where I had the privilege to hire him in 2017. Been here in the Senate as chief counsel to me, serving on this Committee, and then back to the Solicitor General's office now in the State of Missouri. And he's done all of this while serving his wife and family, which is probably the most important service he's rendered. They're here today, his beautiful and brilliant wife, Elizabeth, and their six children. And I think, I hope it's okay if I tell everybody that number seven is on the way. So, Elizabeth and the kids are all with us today, and we are so so glad to have them. I'll just add one other note, which is something about Josh's personal fortitude. Just a couple of years ago, while he was in the midst of these very high profile, high intensity, high stakes lawsuits. Josh suffered a catastrophic accident and was confined to a wheelchair. His early prognosis was he may not ever walk again, but Josh fought to regain his ability to walk just as he has fought for Missourians in court day in and day out. And you'll see here in a moment when he walks to the table that he has now fully regained his ability. We thank the Lord for that. But we also look at his tenacity and the character that it displays like Josh Divine. Maria Lanahan comes to us from the Missouri Attorney General's Office. She's a graduate of Gonzaga University, the University of Chicago Law School, and she has been a force as the principal deputy solicitor general in the State of Missouri. Here, again, Maria's experience is wide-ranging, litigating in courts at every level, trial courts, appellate courts, Federal courts, State courts. Before joining the attorney general's office, she had elite federal clerkships. She served in private practice, she did in- house counsel work. I'm really taken with what Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey, who's here today, by the way. We welcome you, General Bailey. It's great to see you. Andrew said that Maria was, in his view, one of the finest legal minds in America, and one of the finest legal minds he has ever served with. It's a delight to see Maria here today. Zach Bluestone, his legal career has taken him literally everywhere, and he has excelled everywhere he's been. He's had stints at Georgetown, the University of Oxford, Harvard Law. Zach is surely among the best educated lawyers that we'll see on this Committee. He clerked on the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. He has worked in all three branches of the Federal Government. He has significant trial and appellate experience in both Federal and State court. He worked ably by my side in the Missouri Attorney General's office as we worked to protect the Constitution and the law. And his record as a prosecutor is absolutely second to none. And finally, Hon. Chris Stevens. I know Senator Schmitt will want to say a lot more about Judge Stevens. So, let me just say briefly, we're so proud that he is a Missourian through and through. He's a sixth generation Missourian who did his undergraduate work at the University of Missouri, graduated from the University of Missouri School of Law, spent 15 years as a Federal prosecutor in our State. I'm told he is one of the best Federal prosecutors we've ever had in the State of Missouri, and is now serving ably on the bench in the State of Missouri. He was first assistant to Senator Schmitt, and he is going to make an absolutely terrific Federal judge. I will just say finally, Mr. Chairman, in closing, these are four tremendously, immensely superlatively qualified nominees, and I look forward to seeing them approved by this Committee and confirmed in due course on the floor of the Senate. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Senator Hawley. And Senator Schmitt. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ERIC SCHMITT, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI Senator Schmitt. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is a great day for Missouri, and it is an honor, special honor to have the four, the first four picks come from our State. I share that sentiment with Senator Hawley and also, I know it's a big day for them. It is also, I feel like I can share in a little of that pride with all four having worked with me in the Missouri Attorney General's office at different times in different tenure. These nominees also have something else in common. If you look at their legal experience, it's marked by exemplary public service to the people of Missouri, protecting their liberties, protecting their safety, and upholding the rule of law. I'm so proud of their careers that they've led that has led them to this day, and that President Trump has made such spectacular picks for these important positions. They're among the finest judges--they will be among the finest judges on the Federal bench. I'm confident of that. They each also have the highest moral and intellectual fiber. They each possess great experience, wisdom and judgment. But rather than lumping them all together, let me introduce them briefly, individually. Chris Stevens, who now serves as a judge, has dedicated his life to keeping Missourians safe and promoting law and Order. He's a judge currently at the Missouri Court of Appeals for the Eastern District. He was my first assistant attorney general, and before that was my criminal chief when I succeeded Josh Hawley, Senator Hawley. As Attorney General, you know, you have to build a team, and you have to really utilize that social capital that hopefully you've built up and you asking around who are going to fill some of these important positions when you're new to that spot in your core team. And his name just kept coming up over and over by respected lawyers that I knew. And I knew that we wanted to have a role to play in keeping Missouri safe. And so Chris doesn't live too far from where I live. And we met at PJ's Tavern and had a couple Busch Lights, and I immediately knew that Chris Stevens was the right guy. And he proved it over and over that he is somebody very capable. Outside of his tenure in the Missouri Attorney General's Office, he had a distinguished career graduating with academic honors from both the University of Missouri undergrad and at the University of Missouri School of Law, where he was editor- in-chief of the Missouri Law Review. Judge Stevens clerked for Chief Judge Bowman II on the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, and entered private practice at Bryan Cave, before serving as an Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Missouri for 15 years. And as Senator Hawley mentioned, one of the most accomplished Federal prosecutor we've seen in generations. He was then a partner at Armstrong Teasdale. After working at the Attorney General's Office with me, Judge Stevens joined the Missouri Court of Appeals, where he is been a judge for 4 years now. He is a great husband to his wife, Lee, and a great father to his children, a devout Catholic. I'm confident that Chris Stevens does the right thing every single time, and I'm very confident he'll be a great Federal judge. Maria Lanahan has dedicated her career to a life of public service as well. I had the pleasure of hiring Maria at the Missouri Attorney General's Office, first in the Solicitor General Unit which was then led by United States Solicitor General John Sauer which we're also proud to call a Missourian, as well as first deputy solicitor general in my office. Maria's determination, focus, and pursuit of the truth helped her excel in protecting Missourians rights, reigning in the excesses of big government and defending the State in court. Maria attended Gonzaga University where she was a member of the Gonzaga Women's Basketball Team, and graduated summa cum laude from there. She then attended the University of Chicago School of Law, where she was the article's editor at the University of Chicago Law Review. She clerked for Honorable Brian Zahra on the Michigan Supreme Court, before clerking for Honorable Raymond Gruender, who I also see here today on the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit in St. Louis. Maria worked for Thompson Coburn and Charter Communication as litigation counsel. She has been a rockstar in the Missouri Solicitor General's Office for the past 5 years. Maria has great legal experience in the private sector, in-house clerking, and in government. Maria is incredibly active in the St. Louis community coaching youth basketball as a big sister in the Big Brothers Big Sisters of Eastern Missouri, supporting her local parish, and in helping provide local educational opportunities for St. Louis Youth. Maria is a great wife to her husband, Michael, who's here today, a great mother to their children, and also, a devout Catholic. With her moral character, academic success, her professional experience and legal acumen, she's going to be a terrific and great addition to the Eastern District of Missouri. Welcome, Maria. Zach Bluestone. I just want to say a quick word also about Zach. I had the pleasure of having Zach in my office on the Solicitor General Unit for the first 2 years that I was Attorney General of Missouri. He went on to the U.S. Attorney's Office, has done great work there. He's intelligent, has all the credentials. Georgetown, Oxford, Harvard Law. He's had world class training. His time as a lawyer has been barked by nothing but success. He also clerked for Judge Gruender in the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, worked for Senator Jim Talent and Senator Orrin Hatch, a former Chairman of this Committee. He served with distinction in the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Missouri. For the last 5 years, he's worked in all three branches of government and in both State and Federal Government. He's dedicated his life to promoting law and order in our State, and has done with such distinction in his views toward the rights and privileges of the American citizens who stand accused of crimes. He's a man of the highest moral character, a faithful Christian. He's also going to make an excellent judge. Josh Divine. A lot has been said about Josh. He's done great work with Attorney General Bailey, did work great work with Senator Hawley, worked for me very briefly before coming to the Senate. He's brilliant, motivated somebody, widely respected for his thoughtful approach to law, to moral questions, and to keeping Missouri safe. He's going to be a great judge as well. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Grassley. Thank you, Senator Schmitt. Now, would Ms. Hermandorfer, please come to the table. And before you're seated, would you please let me swear you in. [Witness is sworn in.] Chairman Grassley. Please be seated. And our custom is that before you give your opening statement, if you want to introduce anybody please do that. Proceed. STATEMENT OF WHITNEY D. HERMANDORFER, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES CIRCUIT JUDGE FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT Ms. Hermandorfer. Thank you so much, Chairman Grassley. Good morning, Ranking Member Durbin, Members of the Committee, thank you so much for scheduling this hearing to consider my nomination. Thank you also to Senator Blackburn and Senator Hagerty for the very generous introduction and for your support. I'd also like to thank President Trump for the great honor of this nomination. I have here my family with me, my wonderful husband, Greg, our three daughters aged nine, five, and two. So, far so good girls. They make it through the introduction, that's a win from my perspective. My parents, Cliff and Leslie Downs, are also here. My father-in-law, Wayne Hermandorfer is with us as well. My mother-in-law, Carol is home helping watch our dog, which is an important member of our family because he keeps my husband company in a house full of girls otherwise. We have a dear friend, Jess Black, also with us, family watching at home in Nashville. We are blessed to be with many family members, my sister, Julianne, and her husband Luke, their two children. My brother-in-law and sister-in-law, Ajay and Jenny Hermandorfer, also in Nashville, with their two kiddos, one on the way. So, many family members have given me support throughout my life as have so many members of the legal community, coaches, teammates, teachers colleagues, mentors, of course, the judges for whom I've clerked. I can't express enough the gratitude I feel for their mentorship and support throughout my legal career. And I'm just so honored to be here. Thank you so much. Chairman Grassley. Are you done? You got an opening statement? Ms. Hermandorfer. I was told to keep it brief, so that's what I tried to do, Chairman. Chairman Grassley. Okay. Then we will go to questions. You've obtained clerkships. It's an impressive accomplishment for a young lawyer to be before Supreme Court clerkships. It's a mark of great academic distinction. It seems to me, without knowing all the history of clerks, that you're kind of in a category all by yourself. Having clerked for three sittings Supreme Court justices, one-third of the court, what lessons from your clerkship will you take to the bench if confirmed as a circuit judge? Ms. Hermandorfer. Clerking for the distinguished justices for whom I clerked was tremendous honor. Something I never anticipated I have the privilege of doing. I learned, Chairman, the importance of the judicial process. We have a deliberative judicial process and an adversarial system for a reason. We receive briefing, we hear argument from the parties. We discuss issues with colleagues. And through that process, the correct rule of law emerges. And that is what is to be followed, and that might sometimes diverge from how you originally thought a case might come out. So, the importance of the process is one thing I learned. Of course, I had exposure at all three levels at the Federal Judiciary to a tremendous volume and array of types of legal matters from sentencing, hearing revocations to the most meaningful constitutional questions at the Supreme Court of our generation. So, I learned that each case, no matter its importance to the Nation, is important to the parties and should be treated with respect and care. And finally, I learned that you can go through that process and issue the correct rule of law. And in our system, people might not always agree with the decisions that courts hand down. And it's important to understand that in our system decisions will not always be popular and that it takes grit and courage and determination to carry out your Article 3 obligation under the Constitution. And so those are things I witnessed in the jurists for whom I clerked, and I would try to take with me to the bench. Chairman Grassley. You've also practiced law at a highly regarded law firm, and you've led litigation for the State of Tennessee and some of our country's most important recent cases. Nevertheless, some progressive organizations have suggested that you lack the requisite experience to be a circuit judge. So, can you tell us how many cases you've served as counsel for a party or as an amicus? Ms. Hermandorfer. My best estimate is I've served as counsel in probably about 80 to 90 cases, distinct matters, ranging from State court, Federal Court. Primarily practiced in Federal Courts of Appeals and Federal District Court. And so, I think recently the cases have come fast and furiously, and I've been privileged to handle a number of nationally significant matters on behalf of my home State of Tennessee, as well as many other States. Chairman Grassley. Has your experience as a lawyer for the State of Tennessee on behalf of private clients prepared you to be a judge of the Sixth Circuit? Ms. Hermandorfer. I would hope they have, Chairman. Again, I've represented clients at the law firm of all types, from individual criminal defendants, to asylum seekers, to businesses, to Fortune 100 companies, to mom-and-pop stores. In my current role as director of the Strategic Litigation Unit, I've recruited seven to eight attorneys into our office to litigate some of the Nation's most significant and complex constitutional, statutory, and administrative procedure matters on behalf of Tennesseans. And through that experience, I have extensive knowledge of the Federal court system and of how to approach many of the legal issues that would come before me, if I were so fortunate as to be confirmed to the Sixth Circuit. Chairman Grassley. My last question is, please describe what judicial independence means to you? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, to me, judicial independence goes to the heart of the structure of our constitutional system. The Founders set up three branches of government, co-equal branches, and the Founders chose to vest accountability for two of those branches in the electoral process. So, lawmakers are elected and the President so, too, accountable to the people through the electoral process. By contrast, the Framers placed accountability for Article 3 judges in a different place. And that is judges are intentionally not accountable to electoral politics or to the majority in a political sense. Instead, they're accountable to the Constitution and to the rules that bind the exercise of the Article 3 judicial power, and that includes limiting judgments to cases or controversies. It means adhering to the jurisdictional limits that bind courts, and it means understanding that with the power to issue binding rulings that in some cases control the actions of private parties and coordinate branches of government, with that power comes great responsibility to ensure that rulings are proper in scope and legality. Chairman Grassley. Thank you for answering my question. Now, it's up to Senator Durbin. But before he takes over, Senator Hawley, you will take over for me now, please. Go ahead, Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Welcome. Thank you very much for coming before us today and bringing your great family. Terrific. Glad that they're here. So, let's get down to basics. Under Article 3, is your loyalty to the law and Constitution, or to the President who nominated you? Ms. Hermandorfer. Under both Article 3 and Article 6, the constitutional oath, the oath is to faithfully follow the laws that apply in a given case. Senator Durbin. And the Constitution? Ms. Hermandorfer. Absolutely Senator Durbin. Is the executive branch required to follow the orders of a Federal court? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, of course, this is an issue before the Supreme Court right now. And what I heard the Solicitor General say is how I understand the law as well, which is if there's a judgment issued by a court as to the parties that absolutely binds the parties and the way to parties go about your business, if you disagree with an order, is to seek maybe a stay, or emergency relief, or appellate review. Senator Durbin. And after you've exhausted all of those opportunities, are you--is the executive branch of our Government required to follow the orders of the Federal Court. Ms. Hermandorfer. If the Supreme Court issues an order at the end of the appellate review process, that order is to be followed as to the parties in the case. Senator Durbin. Ms. Hermandorfer, I'm a little bit interested in the decision that you and the State of Tennessee made to file an amicus brief in the Supreme Court in the case of Trump v. Casa. That case involved challenges to President Trump's unconstitutional executive order that purports to end birthright citizenship. President Trump's executive order has been blocked by a judge appointed by President Ronald Reagan, who said, and I quote, ``I've been on the bench for over four decades. I can't remember another case where the question presented was as clear as this one. This is a blatantly unconstitutional order,'' referring to the order to end birthright citizenship. The State of Tennessee was not a party to that case. You filed this amicus brief voluntarily, and you reached a conclusion which the court ruled the most blatantly unconstitutional order in decades. Why? Ms. Hermandorfer. Of course, we were amicus in the case, and the decision was made by the Attorney General reflecting the values of Tennesseans that we were not satisfied that all of the information regarding the contemporaneous meaning of the 14th Amendment was being presented to the various courts, given that the litigation was proceeding so quickly and at such a pace through the TRO and PI process. So, our role as amicus, as is any amicus role, was to bring additional information that could be helpful to the court's attention. And what we did there was draw the court's attention to contemporaneous 1800's-era sources regarding the meaning of the 14th Amendment. And I will note Ranking Member Durbin that even in courts that disagreed with the President's executive order, Tennessee's amicus brief was called out in particular as especially well written and mentioned by the judges in the hearing. So, I'm hopeful that we provided helpful information as the court decision considered the decision, which is all you can ask is to ensure the court has all the information before it as it deliberates. Senator Durbin. Did you agree with President Trump on this issue? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, the brief did not take an ultimate position with regard to the merits of the executive order. What it did was say the notion that this is an open and shut case, is hard to square with the contemporaneous evidence and executive branch practice in the latter 1800's interpreting the meeting of the citizenship clause. And so, I stand by completely those arguments and the historical sources that we advanced to the Court. Senator Durbin. You heard my opening remarks, perhaps when I relayed my experience with the so-called Federalist Society. I asked judicial nominee after nominee, why do you belong to this group? Well, it became pretty clear because this was the secret handshake, the calling card, if you wanted to be considered favorably to be a Republican nominee for a Federal judgeship. Well, they seem to have fallen on disfavor with President Trump. Leonard Leo has been characterized by the President as a sleazebag, and he went on to say some other negative things about the Federalist Society. So, now there's a new operation called the Teneo Network. Are you familiar with the Teneo Network? Ms. Hermandorfer. Yes, Ranking Member Durbin. Senator Durbin. Do you realize it was created by that same old sleazebag, Leonard Leo? Ms. Hermandorfer. I don't think I was aware of that. Senator Durbin. What is it? Ms. Hermandorfer. The Teneo Network. And I am a member as disclosed on my SJQ. I'm a new member, so I haven't had too much involvement, I will say. My understanding is that it's similar to the Federalist Society in that it's kind of a debating network and a networking group where individuals from across industries can get together and discuss the issues of the day and get insights into what challenges might be facing various industries. Senator Durbin. Well, listen, you must lead a pretty busy life. Your professional responsibilities, your family responsibilities. Why would you want to join this network so you can--well, describe for me why would you want to join this network? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, it was commended to me by colleagues, and I'm always interested as a Tennessean in connecting with other Tennesseans to discuss the issues of the day. I have not had any meaningful involvement given that, I believe, I was asked to join or invited to join a week or so before I was informed that I was receiving the nomination. And so, I haven't attended since then, any sort of events or been involved. Senator Durbin. Thank you. Senator Hawley [presiding]. I'm going to yield my time now to Senator Blackburn. Just before I do, I just want to just clarify one thing to make sure I understood your answer, Mr. Hermandorfer, to my friend, Senator Durbin's question. He's asking about the Casa case. He talked about your brief filed in the Casa case. The State of Tennessee was the party there filing, is that correct? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's right. And there's no filing that I would ever make or have made that would not reflect the interest of Tennessee. Senator Hawley. You're representing your client, this is the State of Tennessee. You work for the State of Tennessee? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's correct. I'm a State public servant who has a client and adheres to the direction of my appointed boss, the Attorney General. Senator Hawley. And I think your amicus brief also spent a good deal of time arguing that courts do not have Article 3 power to bind non-parties. In other words, it was about universal injunctions or nationwide injunctions. Wasn't that a core piece of your amicus brief? Ms. Hermandorfer. That was an important part of the brief? Senator Hawley. Yes, I thought so. Senator Blackburn. Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I have three letters I want to submit for the record before I begin my questions. One is from Tennessee Governor Bill Lee, and then a letter from 24 State Attorneys General, and a letter from Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti. Senator Hawley. Without objection. [The information appears as submissions for the record.] Senator Blackburn. Thank you. And to Chairman Durbin, I'll be happy to talk with him about the Teneo Network. My son and his wife, and so many outstanding young individuals really benefit from that. It's been beneficial in their lives. So, I'll be happy to enlighten you at a future time. I want to also mention, and for all of our nominees, my Democratic colleagues ask nearly every nominee this Congress, whether the executive branch must follow court orders and then they attack the nominees if they don't give a categorical yes or a no, because the question is nuanced in its academic. Now, yesterday we had a hearing on overreach of district court judges and the universal injunctions. Now, my colleague, Senator Kennedy---- Senator Kennedy. I deny---- Senator Blackburn [continuing]. Posed essentially---- [Laughter.] Senator Kennedy. I deny everything. Senator Blackburn. You can't deny this one, buddy. And so, he posed essentially the same question to the panel, asking whether they would advise a client to defy a court order. Professor Shaw was the witness for the Democrats, and here is how she answered. And I'm going to quote her, ``I would not rule out ever the possibility that a sufficiently egregious order there should be some consideration. If there's some way I think it's a qualified answer, yes. In an extremely narrow band of cases, I think it would be considered, yes.'' So, the Democrats' own witness at yesterday's hearing on the issue of judicial overreach disagrees with them. I suggest when nominees are asked this question that is intended to be a ``got ya'' question that they just refer back to Professor Shaw's answer. I think it's unfair to attempt to conjure up disputes with a hypothetical. And these nominees are clearly committed to the law and to the rule of law. Ms. Hermandorfer, I am so pleased that you are before us. I want you to just lay out for this body why you were qualified to serve on the Sixth Circuit. Ms. Hermandorfer. So, my substantive experience ranges across complex areas of law. I've litigated as counsel, dozens of cases in the Federal Courts across nine circuits. I've argued cases in Federal District Court, Circuit Courts, and counsel of record in Supreme Court cases, State Trial Court, State Appellate Courts. So, I think my litigation experience serves me well, as does my clerkship experience in which I was working within the judicial branch, getting a firsthand view of the deliberative process and the importance of treating every case and every party with care and respect. I think perhaps the most important qualification, my recent work is that I'm not a stranger to litigating cases that I know are going to be in the public spotlight and on which people have strongly held views in either direction. And when you're in a case like that, it is absolutely imperative that you treat every issue in every party and every opposing counsel with respect because you have to model civility the most when you're in a hot button-type situation. And I've also gotten a bit of a backbone by knowing that what I do will not always be well received by all members of the public. And I've learned how to take criticism, and attacks, and personal threats, and move forward with professionalism and integrity. Senator Blackburn. I know you're going to apply the law and you're going to protect people's individual rights. So, let's talk about how you will approach cases that come before you, and describe your method of statutory and constitutional interpretation. Ms. Hermandorfer. Sure. So, my method reflects the enacted text with the ratified text, reflects the will of the people as of the time of enactment or ratification. And so, the Supreme Court has instructed that if the meaning of the text at the time it was enacted or adopted is clear, then that is the meaning that fixes your interpretation and governs the legal issue that might be before the court. Of course, there are situations in which you use other tools of interpretation; statutory structure, history precedent, and you use all of those tools to get to the answer that binds the parties. And in no instance is your own view about what the policy should be govern or enter into the inquiry. Senator Blackburn. Thank you. I yield back. Senator Hawley: Senator Whitehouse. Senator Whitehouse. Thank you very much. Welcome. Ms. Hermandorfer. Thank you. Senator Whitehouse. We are here in the Senate Judiciary Committee in interesting times given the food fight that has erupted in the far right between what I would call the Leonard Leo, big polluter faction of the court capture effort, and the Trump MAGA election denial faction of the far right. And it's going to be interesting to watch as different candidates come forward, whether they look more like Leonard Leo, big polluter faction sorts, or whether they look more like MAGA election denial sorts. But clearly, when you've got the President blowing up Leonard Leo as somebody who hates America, something is going on. What we do know is that probably $600 million was spent in the dark money court capture scheme that has been operating now for well over a decade, well over two decades actually in this country. And the still funds front groups that come before the Supreme Court on a regular basis and a little orchestrated flotillas to give the justices the message as to what it is that the big donors behind that whole enterprise want. And it may be that what President Trump is beginning to notice is that the justices that he put on the Supreme Court are actually more responsive to the Leo polluter operation than they are to Trump and his MAGA allies. If you look at the record, the fossil fuel industry essentially wins every time something important to them gets before the Supreme Court and Trump is not winning every time. And it may have come to his notice that there's a bit of a difference between who's winning all the time and who isn't. And there's every reason to believe that during Trump-1, Leonard Leo and Don McGahn, who was his White House legal counsel, were actually operating for the benefit of the Koch brothers and the big polluters, that side of the operation, and that that's where the loyalty and the policy fell. There doesn't seem to be any doubt any longer that this in fact, was a political operation. Just recently, the Wall Street Journal, which has long been the mouthpiece of the Leo polluter side of this current squabble, published an interview claiming that those judges have achieved goals for the conservative movement that have been on the agenda since the 1970's. They're trying to make Trump happy with the decisions that he made and to reassure him that this is a really big Trump achievement. Whereas Trump and some of his allies are starting to recognize maybe this wasn't such a Trump achievement after all. Maybe he's the one who got played in this game. Maybe all those front groups that are appearing before the Supreme Court in those little flotillas and are getting those wins are actually reporting to somebody completely else than Trump and Trump world. So, this is indeed very interesting times. You are affiliated with the Teneo Group, which is a Leonard Leo group. Interestingly, in the recent hearing that my colleague just referred to about the newly discovered ``shock, shock'' that there are national injunctions going on here. The two Republican witnesses, one was sat in a chair paid for by Leonard Leo and his Marble Trust operation that he ran, runs billion-dollar slash fund for him from a billionaire, pretty sweet deal, and the other one wouldn't answer where his chair money came from. It got laundered through donors trust, the so-called ``ATM'' of the far right, and he wouldn't even answer whether he knew or not where the money for his chair was coming from. So, my default proposition is that if he won't say it probably is also Leonard Leo in the Marble Trust operation. So, even in our hearings right here, we have this very potent internal food fight between the Leo polluter faction and the MAGA election denial faction. And I just wanted to take my time and point this out because I think it's highly revelatory about what has been done to the judicial branch of government by the far right. Thank you, Chairman. Senator Hawley. Senator Schmitt. Senator Schmitt. Thank you. I want to first say a brief word on the judicial nomination success that just happened within the last week that we led right here on this Committee, kicking the woke, failed American Bar Association out of its privileged spot in the judicial selection process. In March, I sent a letter, a letter along with four other Members of this Committee informing the American Bar Association that we would no longer consider ABA recommendations on pending legislation or nominees crippling their role in the Senate's piece of the judicial confirmation process. Last Friday, attorney General Bondi joined our cause telling the ABA that it would be treated no differently than any other leftist activist group in the DOJ piece of the judicial confirmation process. I invite the rest of my colleagues to join this important cause. The ABA is an ideologically captured institution, and it has failed in its core mission while the ABA stayed silent during the weaponization of our justice system under Merrick Garland and Joe Biden, the ABA now has something to say on nearly every policy position by the Trump administration. Beyond that, the ABA has embraced cultural Marxism by forcing its DEI and woke initiatives on law schools across the country. When we look at these videos from law school graduations, we see activists, not lawyers, not future jurist, not people who can keep our streets safe. And this is downstream from the disastrous policies put in place by the American Bar Association. The American Bar Association was also biased in his judicial selection process against Republican President's nominees. It is high time for us to completely sever our link once and for all. This Committee should treat the ABA no differently than any other leftist activist group in our internal process for future legislative recommendations. And I applaud Attorney General Bondi for taking this pivotal step at DOJ. Ms. Hermandorfer, with that being said, I see that you're a member of the ABA while in law school. It's Okay, we all make youthful indiscretions. I'm not going to hold that against you. I've seen a lot of resumes in my previous job, and this one, it's very impressive. I think the breadth and the range of your experience, who you've had a chance to work with, who you've got a chance to sort of be mentored by, now in your role playing a similar role in mentoring lawyers and taking up important causes in Tennessee. That experience spans from, you know, administrative law and free speech cases that often would come before the Supreme Court. I think it's important to point out that that in many ways, that breadth of experience can compare very well to somebody with maybe a perhaps more narrow focus for a longer period of time. In that experience, how do you think you bring that to this position that you're being nominated for, a very important position, that experience you've had? Ms. Hermandorfer. Sure. So, I think familiarity with the subject matter, the bread and butter of Federal courts of appeals are, you know, statutory interpretation interpreting other legal texts, applying constitutional rules. And I've had the opportunity to immerse myself in that at the highest level for the past number of years now. And so, I think familiarity with the subject matter allows you to immediately come in with confidence and fulfill, carry out your Article 3 role in deciding what the case requires holding. And I think being able to jump in is especially important given that many of these cases do proceed on an expedited timeline. And I've litigated you know, emergency cases in the Sixth Circuit and you're often under the gun. And I think my practice has been very fast-paced; preliminary injunction motions, emergency appeals. And so that pace and complexity combined will, I would hope, suit me well to make an impact and help the court discharge its duties. Senator Schmitt. I think, you know, given the uniqueness of your background and the number of, I mean, justices on the Supreme Court that you've had a chance to work with, what would you say that you--what experience specifically would you say you've drawn from any one of them as far as decisionmaking or temperament? Ms. Hermandorfer. I think humility is one thing that really comes to mind. It is an extraordinary power, the Article 3 power to decide cases and controversies, and settles parties' rights and the most important cases, at least to the parties, and certainly to the country sometimes. And with that power, again, comes great responsibility and humility to understand the proper role of a judge is to interpret the law, and not to make the law or bend the law to whatever policy preferences the judge might have individually. And I think the justices and judges for whom I've clerked are models of that. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Senator Hawley. Senator Klobuchar. Senator Klobuchar. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. Hermandorfer, Donald Trump has said, ``I have an Article 2--'' this is an exact quote, ``where I have the right to do whatever I want as President.'' You filed a brief supporting his ability to fire Inspector General, and in another brief, you supported his attempt to undermine Congress's authority to create independent agencies to protect consumers, writing, ``Humphrey's branch-busting reasoning was wrong the day it was rendered.'' What is your view of Congress's constitutional authority to enact laws and create checks on executive power? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, I was, of course, an advocate representing a client in all of those briefs. My current understanding of the Supreme Court's precedent with regard to the President's removal power is that when it comes to principal officers. So, that would include heads of independent agencies. The President, if that officer is exercising in the language of Collins v. Yellen's significant executive authority, that that officer must be removed by the President no matter the size or role of the agency. And in those cases you mentioned, Senator Klobuchar, the Supreme Court recently handed down an order staying the district court, D.C. Circuit's decision, and indicating that with respect, at least to the NLRB and the MSPB, that the President likely had the constitutional authority to remove those principal officers. Senator Klobuchar. And inspector generals, you believe the same principle applies? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, there are lines of cases discussing inferior officers. There is a dispute in the Inspector General's case about how to characterize Inspectors General if they are indeed characterized as principal officers, then under the reasoning of the Supreme Court there would be reason potentially to think that the Supreme Court's role in the law might govern. There are separate lines of authority for certain inferior officers. I stand by the positions in the brief and wouldn't want to otherwise prejudge the merits of any controversy that could come before me as a judge. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. Let's go back to your work as Tennessee attorney in the Tennessee Attorney General's Office, where you defended the State's near total ban on abortion, which does not provide any exceptions for rape or incest. The law also contained a narrow medical necessity exception that chilled doctors from providing patients with the care they need. Isn't it true that as a three-judge panel in Tennessee noted, the record was, ``replete with examples of abortion care being denied in health and life-threatening situations despite the State conceding that the--'' now I'm talking, that the medical necessity exception would've entitled them to care under Tennessee's medical necessity exception? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, the decision of the three-judge panel at the preliminary phase was that the law should be interpreted to require and allow certain abortions provided in serious medical situations. Those included, the ones laid out in the order, things like premature, previable rupture of the membranes, insufficient cervix. What the State had argued was the statute that Tennessee adopted used the same language that was used and approved by the Supreme Court in the Casey v. Planned Parenthood decision. It was always the State's position that the language allowed abortion care in those serious scenarios. And that is what the court held. And that's what the court held as a temporary injunction matter. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. So, I actually met one of the plaintiffs, Rebecca Milner. She had suffered preterm, premature rupture of membranes. Her baby was unlikely to survive. And continuing the pregnancy put Rebecca at risk of potentially life-threatening infection. Yet, because of the law, her Tennessee doctor denied her the abortion care she needed. As a result, she traveled to Virginia, she developed an infection, the doctor said, resulted from the delay in care and required emergency treatment for sepsis. Given you argued the court should uphold that law, even if it didn't work to protect her health, what would you say to litigants who question that you can be even-handed in applying the law, including to women trying to vindicate their rights? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, what I would say is you can read the brief, and read the positions that Tennessee took in that case, and that I represented on behalf of my clients, and that was there were many serious medical scenarios in which abortion under the text of the law would and should be permitted. And I would say that we were carrying out the will of Tennesseans to have that type of life or health exception, but at the same time to vindicate a constitutional State amendment that makes clear that there is no otherwise non-medical right to an abortion under State law. Senator Klobuchar. One last question. We are--Steven Miller has said publicly that the White House is actively looking at suspending the writ of habeas corpus and, ``A lot of it depends on whether the courts do the right thing or not.'' Conservative law Professor Jonathan Adler said the White House can look at this question all at once, but it is ultimately up to Congress whether the writ should be suspended. Do you agree that only Congress can suspend the right to habeas corpus? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, I think as you mentioned, that is an issue that is under active consideration by the political branches and could very well come before me, if I were confirmed as a judge. So, I think in prudence, as a judicial nominee, it would not be appropriate for me to pass on the validity of any such arguments. Senator Klobuchar. Okay. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Senator Lee. Senator Lee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thank you, Ms. Hermandorfer, for being willing to be here today and to be considered for this position. I want get to questions in a moment. I do want to respond to a couple of assertions that have been made at this hearing already, some involving the American Bar Association, and some involving the Federalist Society, an organization that I belong to for the better part of the last 30 years. Look, the Federalist Society is not an advocacy group. It does not advocate. It's regarded by many as a conservative group, and that's fair because a lot of its members happen to be conservative. But its events, unlike most American law school classrooms, are open to people of all viewpoints. In fact, the panel discussions that it sponsors routinely, as a matter of course, do have multiple views represented, differentiating it from many other organizations, including ABA-accredited law schools, including ABA discussions themselves. The American Bar Association, I would add is about as independent, about as nonpartisan is about as ideologically even-handed as the Democratic National Committee. Now, the fact that the ABA first had an official role is itself stunning and alarming that it continued that long. The fact that it no longer plays an official role in this is appropriate. It's never appropriate in my view, particularly once the ABA decided to be a leftist organization, to be the lawyer's wing of the Democratic National Committee has made this inappropriate. But if you want to attack the Federalist Society, look no further than the fact that the ABA is itself an advocacy organization. The Federalist Society is not. So what? It provides is an open forum for discussion among lawyers and law students, open forum in which multiple viewpoints are in fact welcome. It's not an advocacy organization quite unlike the American Bar Association in that regard. Ms. Hermandorfer, you've accumulated a really impressive array of clerkships. It almost seems Grady to me that you've clerked for now three members of the current U.S. Supreme Court and very admirable that will serve you well. During that time. You've had the opportunity, well clerking for no fewer than four Federal judges slash justices to observe the role of the judiciary. How would you summarize your judicial philosophy? Ms. Hermandorfer. My judicial philosophy is that the law is to be interpreted by the judge and not made by the judge. And what I mean by that is, of course, there's new issue resolved and rulings made, but the judge is not supposed to, in the words of Alexander Hamilton in Federalist 78, ``substitute his or her passion, or policy preference for the will of the people, and it's the will of the people that gives all of our laws and the Constitution validity, because that's the consent of the governed.'' And so, the judge is intentionally unaccountable to the people because there are times when you, the judge, needs to issue counter majoritarian rulings and protect rights against the majority. But with that comes the responsibility to issue appropriate orders and abide the limits on judicial power. Senator Lee. In the same issue of the Federalist Papers, Hamilton also differentiated between will and judgment. What's your--in a sentence or two, just tell me what your understanding is of the difference between will and judgment, and how you tell them apart as a judge? Ms. Hermandorfer. Judgment as a judge is applying the laws and the rules of decision neutrally to reach an outcome supported by the law. Will, by contrast, is super imposing the judge's own policy preferences against what the law would require and ruling that way in a case Senator Lee. When interpreting the text of a federal statute which will often be your role as a judge on the Sixth Circuit, you'll have to decide what it means. How best would you describe how to go about that subjective intent on the part of Congress as a whole subjective intent on the part of the sponsor, or this or that Committee staffer who happened to write this or that report? Is it the original public? Meaning? How do you go about it? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, the Constitution prescribes the appropriate way to make Federal law, and that's bicameralism and presentment of the text. And yes, so this will of the internal decisionmaking process or intention is not what you look to. Senator Lee. I'm so happy to hear, hear you bring up Article 1, Section 7, one of the most overlooked parts of the Constitution, one of the most important and often overlooked. What happens when we neglect that the twin obligation, the twin prerequisites of Federal law-making, all Federal law-making bicameralism and presentment. What does that do? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, from a State's perspective, especially part of the grand compromise was having States with proportional representation in the Senate who could serve as a veto gate for any Federal legislation moving through. When you instead bypass that process and issue Federal rules that are not reflective of the democratic branches by capitalism and presentment, you have a situation where the people in the States are cut out of the political process and subjected to rules that they don't necessarily have accountability for. Senator Lee. I tend to believe--I'll wrap up now. If I could just finish this thought, Mr. Chairman. I tend to believe that most of the problems in the Federal Government, most of the contention around it, most of the discord that you see, most of our national debt, most of our sprawling regulatory system, all emanates from deviation from the Constitution's twin structural protections. The vertical protection we call federalism. The horizontal protection we call separation of powers. And within the legislative process are deviation from this concept of bicameralism and presentment being the indispensable condition, precedent that without which not of the legislative process. We now have 100,000 pages of new law made each year by unelected unaccountable bureaucrats accountable to no one imposing legal obligations that if you don't obey them, we'll fine you millions of dollars, we'll shut down your business, can even send you to prison. All without the ascent of either House of Congress, much less both, and without presentment to the President. This is wrong. And this is why you and others who have litigated some of these issues are right to point out the problem with so-called independent agencies. They lack under the Constitution any proper role in the lawmaking process that bypasses Article 1, Section 7. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Senator Coons. Senator Coons. Thank you very much. Ms. Hermandorfer, thank you for your service in the Tennessee Attorney General's office, and congratulations to you and your family for your nomination. As you may know, I am not a reflexive no vote on nominees of a President of the other party. I've supported President Trump's judicial nominees in his first term when they had the qualifications and experience for the job, and the character and the independence to carry out the role of a judge, particularly circuit judge with integrity. I am concerned about the striking brevity of your professional record. You graduated from law school just a decade ago and you spent 4 years with impressive clerkships, but often nominees for a position such as the Circuit have real experience in court. Have you ever served as the sole or chief counsel in any case, tried to a jury verdict? Ms. Hermandorfer. Not to a jury verdict, Senator. Senator Coons. Have you ever served as the sole of chief counsel in any case tried to a final judgment? Ms. Hermandorfer. I've served as chief counsel in many final judgment cases in trial court. If you mean a bench trial--I'm sorry, I don't understand. A bench trial would be no, but final judgment, yes. Senator Coons. How many direct examinations have you personally taken in Federal court? Ms. Hermandorfer. As an appellate lawyer, I don't usually take direct examinations of--the answer is zero. Senator Coons. How many cross-examinations have you taken in Federal court? Senator Lee. None. Senator Coons. How many depositions have you taken? Ms. Hermandorfer. Again, as an appellate lawyer, that's not really part of my practice. I tend to---- Senator Coons. How many depositions have you defended? Ms. Hermandorfer. I have not defended depositions. Senator Coons. How many Federal appellate oral arguments have you presented? Ms. Hermandorfer. Federal appellate oral arguments, that would be four. Senator Coons. And how many Supreme Court oral arguments have you presented? Ms. Hermandorfer. None. Though I've second-chaired and been counsel of record in Supreme Court matters. Senator Coons. I'll just point out that the jurist you've been nominated to replace, Judge Jane Stranch, had 31 years of legal experience under her belt when nominated to this position in the Sixth Circuit. And the ABA, although disregarded by some, has long had a standard that without more than a dozen years of federal service, they would deem someone unqualified for positions such as what you've been nominated for. Let me move to a different issue. The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Number 65, sets out the rules of the road for issuing TROs and PIs, including whether a party moving must post a security bond. What factors should an appellate judge consider when ruling on a challenge to a security bond set or not set by a district court under FRCP 65(c) before issuing a TRO or a PI? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, this comes up sometimes when the State is a litigant and oftentimes parties can move to waive the security bond. And what a court is looking to is the gravity of harm to the potential appellant should the case--the disposition in the district court be allowed to move forward. So, it's similar to kind of the equitable considerations of harm, and the gravity of that harm, and whether it would be reputable or compensable on the other end. Senator Coons. Thank you. And in what sorts of cases is it typical to set or require a security bond? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, I think cases in which there's going to be financial exposure, for example, on behalf of an appellant could be such a case where a, a bond might be posted. Senator Coons. Contract case or a case involving infringement of a patent or something like that. Does your analysis change if the matter is a constitutional case brought by a private plaintiff against allegedly unconstitutional actions of the Federal Government? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, it's--I would have to take each constitutional violation and ruling on its own terms and wouldn't want to prejudge, but the equitable factors, of course would be the ones that I would apply in such a situation. Senator Coons. How would you set a bond for something as foundational as a violation of the Constitution? Ms. Hermandorfer. I'm not sure I could answer that in the abstract, Senator. Senator Coons. And I'm not sure District Court judges could answer that either. What tools does the Sixth Circuit or any circuit have to enforce its judgments? If you were confirmed and a party disobeys, an order of the Sixth Circuit, perhaps even one you wrote, what would you do? Ms. Hermandorfer. Well, I know that there are mechanisms by which, of course, judgments are entered, and executed, and enforced through Federal district courts. Senator Coons. And what are those mechanisms? Ms. Hermandorfer. Well, the Federal District Court sometimes can issue contempt rulings, for example, that are appealable. And, you know, if you're talking about warrants or orders of those sort, I know the U.S. Marshals Office has some sort of involvement in that. But I confess this hasn't been part of something that I've litigated. Senator Coons. And when would you feel you'd met the standard to call in the Marshals to execute your judgment? Ms. Hermandorfer. I think it's very difficult, again, to answer that question in the abstract. And I can just tell you, as a party, I've followed the appellate practice process whenever I felt as though a judgment had gone the wrong way against me and I've secured appellate relief in those situations. Senator Coons. Last question. What would you do if the U.S. Marshals were to disobey and refuse to execute the judgment of the Circuit Court if they were instructed by the DOJ to stand down and to refuse to implement an order of the court? Ms. Hermandorfer. That would, as a probably junior appellate judge on my court, be something that I would look to my colleagues and whatever governing rules and precedents would govern that situation. But again, on the abstract as a hypothetical matter---- Senator Coons. Ms. Hermandorfer, I hope this is an abstract and hypothetical matter, but it's one that occupies quite a few of us and quite a bit of our discussion on this Committee as we come up against the question of whether or not we have a President willing to disobey orders of Federal courts. Thank you for your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Ms. Hermandorfer, we're going to go to Senator Moody, but let me just ask you beforehand just to make sure that I'm clear. My colleague was just asking about the number of cases that you've tried to a jury, and cross- examinations performed before a jury, and direct examinations performed before a jury. What court are you being nominated to? Ms. Hermandorfer. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. Senator Hawley. A court of appeals. Do you have any appellate experience at all? Ms. Hermandorfer. I have litigated probably over 100 appellate cases. Senator Hawley. Over 100 appellate cases. How many different courts of appeals, how many circuits, how many different circuits have you argued or litigated in front of? Ms. Hermandorfer. I've argued in front of nine circuits and the Supreme Court--not argued, litigated. Senator Hawley. Nine circuits and the Supreme Court, over 100 appellate cases. That sounds like quite a bit of experience to me. Senator Moody. Senator Moody. Thank you, Senator Hawley. And thank you for running such an efficient hearing today as our Chairperson. Appreciate your prior service to your State, ultimately, I believe to this country. Thank you for being here today and, and standing willing to answer some really tough questions. I will note there's been a lot of attention brought to the ABA and whether or not every Senator on the Judiciary Committee or every Senator for that matter who of an ultimate vote considers or should consider any recommendations. And, you know, if that were important to the ABA over the many years that people have been pointing out, they are becoming and perceived more and more and more as a partisan group. You would think they would stop doing things like awarding a progressive prosecutor who ultimately said that they would not prosecute laws that they didn't agree with politically and that a Governor had to remove from office after they were removed from office. Giving them an ABA award would seem to be inappropriate. And so, I think that organization should probably take to heart everything that has been said today, because that's the kind of things that they're still doing. And if they want to be taken credible by the United States Senate in determining who would make good judges, maybe when a judge is removed for saying they would not enforce or follow laws they don't agree-- or excuse me, a prosecutor was removed because they would not enforce laws they don't agree with, that might be something that would undercut the credibility of the ABA. You have gotten questions about your lack of experience in the trial court. Some of that may be related from the fact that you are serving over just over a decade as a lawyer, and now you're going on to a very important appellate position. I think you'll be a great appellate judge. I am overwhelmed and really impressed by your background. I wonder if your--the predecessor and your role had clerked for three Supreme Court justices at the time that they were nominated. I doubt it. I was a young judge when I became a judge. I served over a decade before I became the attorney general, and now a United States Senator. To some extent, I think that can bring a quality and a certain tenacity to move cases and a docket, and deliver expediency in the judicial system for the American people. That is much needed. In your opinion, how important is efficiency of a docket to being a good judge? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, as a party who's often seeking relief from courts, efficiency of the docket goes to the heart of the fairness and integrity of our judicial system because everyone's heard the saying, ``Justice delayed is justice denied.'' And I do think that is where my recent years of practice and the pace--again, I mean, there have been weeks when I've filed--there was a day I filed a supreme court brief and a district court brief on summary judgment the same day and the same case. That's how fast our cases move. And the volume of that and the pace of that is something that I think would suit me well to do my best to hit the ground running and contribute to my colleagues to the best of my abilities. Senator Moody. And right now, more than ever, at this moment in time we have a President in office that is desperately trying to clean up a lot of mess that was created. And I believe I was the attorney general fighting against a lot of unlawful policies from the last administration. And so, in doing so, is having to make really hard decisions at a fast pace as an executive to deliver safety and security for the American people. That is just a fact. And what we are seeing now every day are nationwide injunctions, another stay, another order that is in some way stymieing this executive from doing its job. And that is causing a lot of concern from the American public who wants to just feel safe and have some sort of order and stability in this country again. Whoever becomes a judge, an appellate judge, or even a district court judge, is going to have very critical matters and issues come before them dealing with separation of powers. And it is so important that we have judges that understand the importance of that and can rule on it quickly so that an executive's hands aren't tied for 4 years, and they can't do what they have promised to do for the American people when it is within the law to do so. In your experience, what have you done to fight for the separation of powers? You know, we're more and more evolving into what feels like a separation of parties, which is undermining the stability of this constitutional form of government instead of a separation of powers. And what are cases that you could highlight for this Committee, whereas an attorney you fought for the respect of separation of powers? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, I've litigated dozens of cases involving the attempt by the Federal Government to, through rulemaking, for example, impose a rule onto States and onto State citizens that did not ever go through Congress. That includes the Title IX case that includes cases like our challenge to the Section 1557 rule, which both of those involved gender, identity-based rules being applied to States through the executive branch and not through Congress. Other cases, many other such cases our office has litigated and all of those cases reflect the importance of our dual sovereign system and the importance of allowing States to govern themselves through their political processes absent proper lawmaking by the Federal branches. Senator Moody. Thank you so much. And Chairman Hawley, I owe you a minute. Senator Hawley. That's right. I was so generous with your time, Senator. I'd like to enter into the record here, a letter from 18 appellate attorneys, including the former Solicitor General of the United States, Paul Clement, all endorsing Ms. Hermandorfer, talking about her experience, talking about her expertise, talking about her outstanding record. Here's a representative, ``Ms. Hermandorfer has a brilliant legal mind, an outstanding work ethic, a strong sense of fairness and justice, a collegial manner, which we're seeing today, and an extraordinary record of academic and legal achievement. Based on our experience with Ms. Hermandorfer and her distinguished career in private practice and public service, we are confident that she possesses the character, temperament, and intellect to make her an asset to our Nation's judiciary.'' And without objection, I'll enter that into the record. [The information appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Hawley. Senator Welch. Senator Welch. Thank you. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. You know, you're hearing what is a real divide in the country and between the parties about what's happening in the justice system? I happen to think the ABA is an excellent organization. I'm disappointed the President is prohibiting the ABA from being involved. There's a different point of view on the so-called weaponization of what's happened in the Justice Department. But one of the elements that's emerging now is an incredible amount of criticism from the executive branch of judges who make decisions that the executive disagrees with. For instance, President Trump referring to some judges said who decided against him, ``U.S. hating judges who suffer from an ideology that is sick.'' There's a reference to by the President of judges who are ``monsters'' and want our country to go to hell. I don't think that's helpful. And just let me ask you. You've had judges rule in your favor, you've had judges rule against you. Is it your view that in your experience when judges have ruled against you, it's anything other than the exercise of their responsibility to decide the cases as they see it, or is it motivated by some political ideology? Ms. Hermandorfer. Well, I think your question, question touches on foundational aspects of our system, which is there's obviously--we're a country that values political dialog very much. At the same time, there no doubt are limits on violence limits, on criminal threats, things like that. So, you know, I don't want anything I say here as a nominee to be seen as---- Senator Welch. No, I'm asking---- Ms. Hermandorfer [continuing]. Passing judgment. Senator Welch. You've been a litigant, so you had cases decided, I'd take it, for you and against you, in both cases. In either case, do you accuse the judges of having some political motivation when the judge decides against you? Ms. Hermandorfer. When a judge decides against me, I file an appeal and litigate the appeal. And I will say--I mean, I've been a public official subject to criticism, and all I can say is it's part of the job and you do your duties. Senator Welch. Right. Do you think it's proper for litigants to be used in that kind of language when they disagree with the decision that a court has made? Ms. Hermandorfer. Well, again, as a nominee, I don't want to give a thumbs up or thumbs down to any particular category of statements. It's a---- Senator Welch. Alright. Well, let me ask you this. I know you signed a letter, I think, in your personal capacity, in support of--that was, I think, circulated and supported the Attorney General. And in that letter there was a reference to, ``a dark chapter of the United States Justice Department.'' What specifically do you--were you referring to when you signed the letter that had that phrase in it? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, that letter was on behalf of female members of the State Attorney General's offices. I could just tell you some---- Senator Welch. No, I'm asking--I know who it was on behalf of, but what the letter specifically said you're referring to a dark chapter of the United States Justice Department. So, explain what that dark chapter was and what specifically you had in mind. Ms. Hermandorfer. So, I spent the past 2 years litigating against rules, including Title IX and others, that we did not feel, as an office and as my client, reflected the proper meaning of the law, and indeed dismissed many well-meaning, deeply held concerns on the part of many women and others. And so, where I was coming from in signing that letter was, in my experience, litigating and often prevailing in those issues that we thought involved Federal overreach by the Department of Justice. Senator Welch. No, here's the issue for me that I think is getting so difficult in the courts. You can have different points. Citizens can have different points of view, and they don't have to attribute that difference to something radical anti-woman agenda or referring to the Justice Department as a dark chapter in the United States Justice Department. Because this is a big country, people have different points of view. Everyone's free to advocate what it is they want to advocate for. But now, it is custom that if the decision goes against you, you have a President who starts talking about monsters who want to take our country to go to hell. I guess I can't ask you to answer that, but you're going to be assuming, if you're confirmed, you're going to have the responsibility for really helping create a culture within the judicial system that hopefully restores respect, and that means respect for people with whom one disagrees. Thank you. I yield back Senator Hawley. Ms. Hermandorfer, let me just stay with this question about the Title IX litigation that Senator Welch was just asking you about. Tell us about the Title IX litigation that you carried on behalf of the State of Tennessee. Ms. Hermandorfer. Sure. In April 2024, the Department of Education issued a final rule interpreting Title IX, which of course, bars discrimination on the basis of sex and any federally funded educational program, interpreting that language to bar discrimination on the basis of gender identity and other ``sex-based characteristics.'' And as part of that rule, which again, was a rule did not go through Congress, the Department of Education informed all federally funded educational institutions from pre-K through college that sex separated spaces like locker rooms and bathrooms must instead be assigned by gender identity and not sex. And in similar ways sex-separated programs like intramural sports and others fell in the ambit of that rule. Senator Hawley. Let me just stop you right there. I want to make sure we understand the significance of this. What you're saying is that the Biden Administration used an administrative process to interpret a law, landmark law passed by Congress Title IX to interpret it, to require your State, and indeed every State to allow men, biological men, into women's locker rooms to allow men, biological men into women's sports, to allow men, biological men into any space that a biological woman might otherwise claim under the ambit of Title IX. Is that correct? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's correct. Senator Hawley. And so, you litigated on behalf of your State to preserve--would you say that Title IX is a landmark piece of legislation? Ms. Hermandorfer. Absolutely. Senator Hawley. Would you say that Title IX took years, indeed, decades to achieve? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's correct. Senator Hawley. Would you say that Title IX is a cornerstone of women's sports and the ability for women to have the same opportunities as men at the collegiate level, and indeed every level, to have sports opportunities, athletic opportunities, leadership opportunities? I mean, is this an important statute? Ms. Hermandorfer. It is. And for a former athlete, it hits especially close to home. Senator Hawley. Yes. You've lived it, have you not? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's right. Senator Hawley. So, when the Biden Administration issued a rule, not a law not passed by this Congress, a rule that would've completely changed the meaning of Title IX, would you say that that's a pro-woman agenda? Ms. Hermandorfer. We argued that the considerations of women were not adequately accounted for in the rulemaking process, and virtually every court to consider that rule. Almost a dozen agreed with the position Tennessee advanced on behalf of six States in our litigation. Senator Hawley. Every Court virtually to consider the litigation agreed with your position. Is that correct? Ms. Hermandorfer. Including the Supreme Court in the stay application. Senator Hawley. Including the Supreme Court of the United States. Would you say it is fair to call the effort to undermine a landmark piece of legislation for women that you yourself benefited from that fair and equal opportunity? Would you say it's fair to call that a dark chapter in the history of this country? Ms. Hermandorfer. Certainly on behalf of Tennesseans, we thought that that rule was unlawful and inappropriate, and we were, you know, happy to succeed in the litigation against it. Senator Hawley. Well, I just want to tell you, I'm happy you succeeded in the litigation. As the father of a 4-year-old daughter, I'm delighted that you succeeded in the litigation. I want to thank you on behalf of her, my whole family. I want to thank you for going to battle for our daughters, for going to battle for the women you played sports with, for standing up for this landmark legislation and for fighting it. And yes, I want to say it was indeed a dark chapter. The last 4 years have been a hellacious chapter in the Department of Justice. Those aren't your words, those are mine, to be clear. But I think it's absolutely a fact whether we're talking about the assault on women's rights under the Title IX context and others, whether we're talking about the assault on religious believers. Let's not forget, this is the Department of Justice that recruited informants into Catholic parishes in this country. If that's not a dark chapter in this country's history, I don't know what the heck is. This is a Justice Department that activated the Counter Terrorism Division, Counter Terrorism Division, against parents who went to school board meetings. If that's not a dark chapter, I don't know what is. This is a government, an administration, the last 4 years, that collaborated with the biggest corporations in the world to censor speech they don't like, and then lie about it. If that's not a dark chapter, I don't know what is. In fact, I'd go so far to say it is the worst chapter, the worst in the history of the Department of Justice, the last 4 years. Those are my views, not yours, Ms. Hermandorfer. But I'll just say, when it comes to the litigation that you carried out on behalf of the State of Tennessee, I think you did a great service, not just to Tennessee, but for the Nation. And I want to thank you for it. Senator Cruz. Senator Cruz. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Hermandorfer, congratulations. Welcome. I'm thrilled that you are seated here before the Committee. You are the very first appellate court nominee put forth by President Trump in this new administration. And it's symbolic that the seat you've been nominated to fill is the same one Democrats tried to hand the nomination to a woman named Karla Campbell, Karla with a K, in the Biden Administration. I'm glad that Republicans on this Committee stood firm and stopped Ms. Campbell's confirmation. She had a deeply troubling record. She affiliated with an explicitly Marxist organization that called for a working-class revolution and abolishing both the police and ICE. She financially supported a radical far left candidate that said that Republicans were ``siding with the devil,'' and she repeatedly misled this Committee about her past. That contrast tells a story. The Biden Administration tried to place a radical Marxist ideologue on the Sixth Circuit, a nomination that Republicans rightly stopped. And now under President Trump, we are restoring judges who respect the Constitution and the rule of law to the bench. Ms. Hermandorfer, your academic record is extremely impressive. You've clerked for not one, not two, but three Supreme Court justices; then-Judge Kavanaugh, Justice Alito, and Justice Barrett. Now, I would note the Chairman clerked for one Supreme Court Justice, Senator Lee clerked for one Supreme Court justice, and I clerked for one Supreme Court justice. For the record, I'm going to say I'm that you clerked for three, and I may have to filibuster your nomination because of it. But tell us what you learned clerking for those three jurists. Ms. Hermandorfer. So, I've taken so many lessons from those jurists. That the role of the judge is to carefully listen to all parties and carefully deliberate with respect to all cases that come before him or her, and to treat colleagues and litigants with respect, and to understand that you can disagree about the law without being disagreeable. I think the most important lesson, though, Senator Cruz, I learned, is that in our system, judges are intentionally insulated from political accountability precisely because they're going to issue rulings sometimes that some segments of the public or the majority may not agree with. And that's not always a pleasant task, but it's necessary to preserve our system. And so, too, it's necessary that judges have backbone, and grit, and courage in carrying out their obligations under Article 3. And so those are attributes that I witnessed, and that I would try to take with me to the best of my abilities, were I fortunate enough to be confirmed? Senator Cruz. So, you also were a star basketball player at my alma mater, at Princeton. Ms. Hermandorfer. Star might be a little strong, Senator. Senator Cruz. You were captain of the team. Tell us what you learned about playing competitive basketball at the collegiate level. Ms. Hermandorfer. My basketball journey started when I was very young, and my four parents who are here, you know, drove me around probably to every gym in Tennessee so I could pursue my dreams of playing college sports. And there's nothing like having to wake up early at 5 a.m. in the snow and go down to the weight room to instill self-discipline and grit. And I've carried those lessons and the work ethic with me. And I've been knocked down many times both on the court and off. And I learned that it's really about how you carry yourself, and your attitude, and your effort can get you through even when you're facing challenges. And I guess lastly, I would say playing basketball, I've had the pleasure of getting to know girls from all walks of life, from all over the State, all over the country. And so, getting along with folks from different backgrounds and who have different perspectives is something I have experience and would also try to take with me. Senator Cruz. Talk to us about the First Amendment and the importance of the First Amendment. Ms. Hermandorfer. Without sounding trite, you know, it's the First Amendment, for a reason, it protects both--I mean, the five main free freedoms. You know, the free exercise of religion, there's also the establishment clause, of course freedom of the press, freedom to petition the Government when you're want to change a law, freedom to assemble. And I can't remember if I said four or five, but the importance of that is that in our system, the people have the power to express their deeply held views and to try to make political change. And it's not up to the Government to stifle any views that it deems you know, heterodox or unorthodox. It is to protect the will of the people as they express it in their public accounts. Senator Kennedy [presiding.] Thank you, Professor. Senator Schiff. Senator Schiff. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Hermandorfer, welcome. I'm sure you're aware that it was recently said by President Trump, ``It was suggested that I use the Federalist Society as a recommending source on judges. I did so, but then realized that they were under the thumb of a real sleazebag named Leonard Leo. A bad person who in his own way probably hates America. I want to ask you about this. You're a member of the Federalist Society. Correct? [Poster is displayed.] Ms. Hermandorfer. That's correct. Senator Schiff. And for how long? For how many years? Ms. Hermandorfer. I believe I joined in law school Senator Senator Schiff. So, over a decade ago, then? Ms. Hermandorfer. About a decade. Senator Schiff. And were you recommended for a judgeship by the Federalist Society? Ms. Hermandorfer. I have no knowledge of why it was recommended or whether the Federalist Society had any role. Senator Schiff. The Federalist Society does though recommend judges to the administration? Do they not or did they not? Ms. Hermandorfer. I had no involvement in that. I'm not sure I've seen reporting to suggest they had some involvement, but I have no personal knowledge of that, Senator. Senator Schiff. Do you think having been a member of the Federalist Society for over a decade, that they're under the thumb of a real sleazebag named Leonard Leo? Is that your view? Ms. Hermandorfer. In my perspective, the Federalist Society has been a wonderful place to get together with the many, many lawyers who are members and learn about the law and discuss issues. Aside from my own experience, I, as a judicial nominee, I don't think it's appropriate for me to comment on any public policy debate about the Federalist Society or the particular quotation you're referencing. Senator Schiff. Do you know Leonard Leo? Ms. Hermandorfer. I've met him a few times at Federalist Society events, but I wouldn't say that I know him well or that he knows me. Senator Schiff. Do you concur with the President's assessment that he is a sleazebag? Ms. Hermandorfer. Again, Senator, that type of interpersonal or political dispute, I don't think is appropriate for me to comment on as a judicial nominee, given that either the President or Mr. Leo could come before me as party to a litigation. Senator Schiff. You clerked for Judge Richard Leon, did you not on district court? Ms. Hermandorfer. That is correct. Senator Schiff. How would you describe Judge Leon? Ms. Hermandorfer. When I worked for Judge Leon, I had a wonderful experience. I think he was a judge who treated everybody with fairness and impartiality, and was wonderful to his law clerks. And it was a very enjoyable year clerking for him. Senator Schiff. And he took his responsibility seriously? Ms. Hermandorfer. In my experience, yes. Senator Schiff. And upheld the law and the Constitution, in your view? Ms. Hermandorfer. We did our best to do so. Senator Schiff. You're aware that he ruled against the administration and against the President with respect to the President's executive order against Wilmer Hale? Ms. Hermandorfer. I'm aware. Senator Schiff. Do you agree with Judge Leon's decision that the executive order was unlawful? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's pending litigation and it would be very inappropriate for me to express a view on the merits of that litigation or any other act of litigation? Senator Schiff. Well, no, the President has attacked the Federalist Society because the judges it has recommended don't always do what the President wants. Is that the role of a judge? Is that the role of Judge Leon or any other judge? Would that be your role to do what the President wants? Ms. Hermandorfer. That would not be my role. My role would be to carry out my oath, which would be to the Constitution first and foremost, and any other laws that bind the rules of decision. Senator Schiff. So, you're willing to rule against the administration, against Donald Trump's executive orders if you believe them to be unlawful? Ms. Hermandorfer. If that's what the law requires, Senator. Senator Schiff. You were also an attorney at Williams & Connolly. Is that correct? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's correct. Senator Schiff. And they represent Perkins Coie and the executive order case against that law firm. Do they not? Ms. Hermandorfer. I'm aware of that fact. Senator Schiff. Is it important that law firms be able to represent individuals or causes that are unpopular and that are at times in disagreement with the administration? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, certainly, as a lawyer who represents a client that has views that people don't always agree with, I think it's an important role of an attorney to take on matters no matter the political popularity. Senator Schiff. So, you think it's appropriate for law firms to take on cases against the administration? Ms. Hermandorfer. I would not purport to limit any party in the representation that it would choose. And I don't want to be seen as commenting on any of the active litigation involving these issues. Senator Schiff. And would you agree that it would be inappropriate for a President or administration to try to punish a law firm for taking on a client whose interest was adverse to the administration? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, Senator, you're referencing, I believe, the pending litigation. And again, I've articulated why it's important for clients to have law firms. Senator Schiff. I'm not referencing any particular case. I'm asking you as a general principle, should the President of the United States be able to retaliate against a law firm that takes a case for a client whose interest is adverse to the administration? Ms. Hermandorfer. Again, embedded in the premise of that question is something that is referencing active litigation, and I, just as a matter of prudence, don't want to be seen as weighing in either way on whether that has occurred in any of these executive order cases. I stand by my answer that it is, of course, the role of a lawyer to represent clients consistent with the bounds of the law and ethics, and that's what I've tried to do in my role. Senator Schiff. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Senator Kennedy. Professor, tell me about the Loper Bright case. Ms. Hermandorfer. Sure. So, Loper Bright is the case that overruled the Chevron doctrine. And the Chevron doctrine or originally required that if there was an agency statute that governs an agency's conduct, the agency gets deference, meaning a thumb on the scale when it's interpreting what that statute might mean as it's carrying out its duties. Loper Bright determined that that framework was inconsistent with the Administrative Procedures Act, and instead, that moving forward, court should decide all of those statutory interpretation cases as a de novo matter, meaning the agency doesn't get any sort of special head start. Senator Kennedy. How much difference did a Federal court have to give to an administrative agency under the Chevron doctrine? Ms. Hermandorfer. Sure. So, the court would originally make a step one determination about whether the statute was ambiguous or not. That's in the eye of the beholder sometimes. But if the court determined that the statute was ambiguous and the relevant sense, meaning it didn't resolve the question the agency was facing it would defer to the agency's view of the meaning so long as the agency's interpretation was well explained and reasonable. Senator Kennedy. What's the relationship, if any, between Loper Bright and West Virginia v. VEPA? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, that's a fascinating question. I think, you know, West Virginia v. VEPA applied Chevron, but said, we're less likely to find ambiguity. And indeed, Congress needs to speak clearly if the agency is purporting to resolve a matter of in the court's terms political or social significance. And following Loper Bright, of course, there is no difference. And I think some have commented, including Justice Barrett, that the best way to think about West Virginia v. VEPA in interpreting statutes is that it informs the context of how we understand what the statutory terms mean in the context of an agency delegation. So, the fact that the agency is purporting to carry out its duties might resolve whether or not the particular question is sufficiently clearly delegated by Congress. Senator Kennedy. That just seems to me like a distinction without a difference. I mean, doesn't Loper Bright wipe out the need for West Virginia v. VEPA? Why do we still need a major question, Doctor? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, it's certainly true that West Virginia v. VEPA, I think was partially driven by non- delegation doctrine concerns and concerns about deferring to agencies. When doing so threatened our separation of powers after Chevron has been overruled. Of course, that might be relevant in a smaller number of cases. But I do think that the major questions doctrine still has vitality and understanding the best meaning of the statute as Loper Bright now requires. Senator Kennedy. What's the Public Rights doctrine? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, most recently, the Public Rights doctrine has been applied in the Seventh Amendment context. And the Supreme Court has a decision named Jarkesy where there's a line of precedent saying that if a matter involves public rights, so the conferral of a public benefit, for example that might be the type of matter that Congress can vest adjudication of in in Article 1 Tribunal or an administrative agency. Senator Kennedy. What's a public right? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's a very difficult question to answer in many cases. Senator Kennedy. That's why I'm asking you. Ms. Hermandorfer. Yes. So, I think the best way to think about it is to contrast it with private rights. And what the Supreme Court has instructed with respect to private rights is that they're what we would think of as common law-type claims. So, contracts, property torts, the stuff of Westminster in the court's terms. And so, if you have a matter like that, that's the type of matter that needs to go before a jury to ensure that the Seventh Amendment's jury protections are abided by contrast. If there's an internal administrative process, social security benefits things like that, that looks more like a public right, that wouldn't have existed, but for the Government granting it. Senator Kennedy. And what did the Supreme Court hold in-- was it Jarkesy? Ms. Hermandorfer. That's right. Senator Kennedy. What did the Supreme Court hold? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, the Supreme Court there held that certain matters of the Securities and Exchange Commission actually looked more like common law fraud claims and more like property-based claims that must be tried to a jury in court and cannot be vested in the in-house SEC proceedings to be tried before an administrative tribunal. Senator Kennedy. My time is done. Thank you, Professor. Senator Hawley [presiding]. Okay. Against my better judgment, I promised Senator Schiff because I skipped him in order, I promised him one more question. All right, Senator, this gavel will never come to me again, though, if you ask more than one question. So, I'm going to hold you to it. Senator Kennedy. Well, I've got the gavel. [Laughter.] Senator Hawley. Oh, there we go. Senator Schiff. This is just in honor of Mike Lee's birthday. His wish was that I got an extra question. I wanted to just followup on one of your answers to Senator Durbin. He asked about the necessity of following court orders, and you were very specific in your answer and said that if the Supreme Court rules that you have to, then you have to follow the order as it pertains to the parties to the case. I want to ask you about a lower court ruling, though. You would agree, would you not, that if a district court rules pending appeal, or pending any other stay or action by a higher court, that the parties covered by that order, including the administration, need to abide by that order? Ms. Hermandorfer. As I mentioned to Ranking Member Durbin, the normal course, if you disagree with the court order, is to seek appellate review in the way that you mentioned. Yes. I do note that my understanding is yesterday there was some testimony about, you know, particular cases and nuances of that debate that I think are active. And obviously, the interaction of Article 3 and Article 2 is an actively litigated matter. But absolutely, in the normal course, the proper way to vindicate your rights is through the appellate process. Senator Hawley. Thank you. All right. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Senator. No, really, John? Senator Kennedy. Yes. Senator Hawley. Oh, my gosh. Look at this. All order is dissolving. Okay, go ahead. But that's it, I'm serious. Senator Grassley's going to come in here and hit me with this gavel. Senator Kennedy. I want to be sure I understand, Professor. District court rules on the case. You got plaintiff and defendant. You are representing the plaintiff. Your plaintiff is very unhappy. Are there any circumstances under which you would advise the plaintiff to ignore the Federal court order? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, of course, as a judicial nominee, I would be trying to issue proper---- Senator Kennedy. I don't want to split hairs here. Ms. Hermandorfer. No, the normal process is to---- Senator Kennedy. I know what the normal process is. Can you think of any circumstances where you would tell the plaintiffs, ``No, you don't pay attention to this Federal judge.'' Ms. Hermandorfer. So, the problem with answering it that categorically is that there are potentially some very extraordinary situations you could imagine---- Senator Kennedy. Like what? Ms. Hermandorfer [continuing]. That could come before me as a judge---- Senator Kennedy. Like what? Ms. Hermandorfer. So, this is a subject of tremendous scholarship. Senator Kennedy. I'd be careful there. I'd be real careful. Senator Hawley. All right, Senator. All right, all right. I promised you one. That was four, I think. See what you started, Adam. Ms. Hermandorfer, thank you for your testimony. You are excused. And with that, I'll invite the four district court nominees to come forward to the witness table. And we'll take just a moment here, and we'll administer the oath and begin the second panel. [Pause.] Senator Hawley. All right. It's the custom of this Committee to administer the oath to all nominees who come before the Committee. And you're all standing and ready to do it. So, I'll stand with you. If you'd raise your right hand and repeat after me. [Witnesses are sworn in.] Senator Hawley. You may be seated. Well, we welcome all of you here today. It is our normal process, if you so desire, to allow you to introduce any folks who are with you, including your families, and then to give a brief opening statement. And we'll just go down the panel. We'll start with Mr. Bluestone, and then proceed all the way down to Judge Stevens. Mr. Bluestone, the floor is yours. STATEMENT OF ZACHARY M. BLUESTONE, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI Mr. Bluestone. Thank you, Senator Hawley. I'd like to start by thanking Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, and the Committee for holding this hearing. Also, incredibly grateful to the President for the honor of this nomination. To you, Senator Hawley, and Senator Schmitt, thank you for the kind words and your introductions. Thank you for your support throughout this process, and thank you so much for the trust that you both placed in me as a deputy solicitor all those years ago when you were both serving as Missouri Attorney General. Over the last few months, I've thought a lot about relationships and community. This process has reminded me of just how blessed I am with the people in my life. They're absolutely the reason I'm here today. Fittingly, the opportunity to serve my community is the reason I want to become a Federal judge. I can think of no better use of my talents to make a meaningful impact on the lives of those around me. I regret not having time to recognize everyone who's gotten me here. But I'd like to highlight just a few, starting with four key mentors; Senator Jim Talent, John Sauer, Jeff Jensen, and Judge Ray Gruender, who's here today with his wonderful wife, Kim. Judge Gruender is a rare combination of brilliance and humility, and he's a model I'll strive to emulate, if confirmed. I'm also lucky to be joined by three lifelong friends; John, Todd, and Broth, and I owe my clerk, Daniel, a huge debt of gratitude for his support. As for family, it means the world to me that my brother Alex, and mother-in-law, Shannon, have traveled so far to be here. And there's no distance that would've kept my mother from coming. In many ways, today is the culmination of all the work she put into ensuring that I had the educational opportunities that my parents never did. I also have her to thank for my faith and commitment to family. My mom's partner, John is here as well, and I'd like to recognize him for his service to our country both as a Marine in Vietnam and through his career with the FBI. My biggest supporters are behind me. My wife, Abby, and our little bud, Ezra, who's been instructed to cry if I get any tough questions. I'm looking in that direction, Senator Kennedy. I actually met Abby when we were clerking in the courthouse where I hope to serve, and she's been a pillar of my life ever since. She showed so much strength and devotion as a mother, and I'll never be able to repay her selflessness over the last few months, especially managing travel logistics with the baby despite having her own major oral argument in St. Louis yesterday. Finally, I'd like to recognize my dad, Randy, who we lost to a battle with leukemia almost 20 years ago. My dad's fearlessness and grit in starting a business are something that I'll always admire, particularly after having helped run that company after his passing. My dad often had some choice words for his lawyers after getting legal bills, but I know he's looking down today with a lot of pride. Thank you for giving me a few minutes to recognize those who got me here, and I look forward to your questions. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Bluestone. Mr. Divine. STATEMENT OF JOSHUA M. DIVINE, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE EASTERN AND WESTERN DISTRICTS OF MISSOURI Mr. Divine. Thank you, Senator Hawley. I want to thank Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin for holding this hearing today. I want to thank Senator Hawley and Senator Schmitt for all the support you've provided to me during this process. And of course, most of all, I want to thank President Trump for giving me the honor of this nomination. I'm joined today in spirit and in person by too many to name, but I'll mention a few. My wonderful parents, James and Susan are here, so too is my wife of 15 years. As Senator Hawley mentioned earlier, Elizabeth is pregnant with our seventh child. We have been truly blessed. The other six children are here as well. You haven't heard from them because the younger two, the boys, have been asleep the last 2 hours. Fifteen years as a husband, and 13 as a father has taught me much more than I ever learned in school. Alice, for example, our miracle child, had open heart surgery when she was just 2 months old. And grappling with the many challenges she has faced since then, has taught us the virtues of patience, prayer, and perspective. On a professional level, I'm especially grateful to the Attorney General of Missouri, who's here today, Andrew Bailey. When he hired me as Missouri Solicitor General, I knew I was being asked to fill big shoes. My predecessor, after all was John Sauer, who is now the U.S. Solicitor General. It has been a privilege to serve the people of Missouri these past years. And sitting here today, I'm reminded of what Justice Ginsburg told this Committee a few decades ago, ``What has become of me could happen only in America.'' My grandmother born into poverty overseas, never had a day of education in her life. My dad was luckier. He did miss several years of school, but grandma eventually pinched enough pennies to bring them over here to America. And once here she learned English by watching American soap operas, she made a living cleaning people's homes, and she did her best to navigate the anti- Italian discrimination that was all too common at the time. Today, barely a generation later, I sit here before this agust body having been given extraordinary opportunities, both professional and educational. But the most extraordinary thing about my family's story is just how ordinary it is. No other country provides so much opportunity to so many, and that is one reason I've dedicated my career to life of public service. My dedication to public service was reinforced a year ago when a life-threatening accident put me in the ICU. It left me unable to walk. For 6 months, I was confined to a wheelchair and then a cane. I'm still recovering to this day, but those are the kinds of experiences that humble you, and they're the kinds of experiences that broaden your empathy to those whose trials and tribulations last, not just a season, but a lifetime. Fortunately, although we come from different walks of life, the law promises equality. I had the privilege to clerk for a judge who, when he was Attorney General of Alabama, gave a speech condemning and rebuking the segregationists of that State's past. While lesser men like Governor George Wallace had promised to thwart the Constitution, Attorney General Bill Pryor, four decades later promised the opposite; ``Equal under law today, equal under law tomorrow, and equal under law forever.'' If confirmed, that is how I will judge. I look forward to answering the Committee's questions. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Divine. Ms. Lanahan. STATEMENT OF MARIA A. LANAHAN, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI Ms. Lanahan. Thank you, Senator Hawley, and Senator Schmitt, for your kind introductions and support. I'd like to start by humbly thanking President Trump for nominating me to this position. Thank you, to Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Durbin, and all the Members of this Committee for the opportunity to address the Committee today. I also have many other people to thank who are here supporting me. Thank you to my husband and best friend Michael Lanahan, who's here. Michael is responsible for introducing me to the great State of Missouri, which I have grown to love and have since devoted my career to. My oldest son is also here. He is 7 years old. And my other two children, 5-year-old and a 1- year-old are not here because I was not so sure that they would be able to abide by Senate decorum. So, they're at home with Michael's parents, and I'd like to thank Kevin and Kathy Lanahan for taking care of them. Thank you to my parents, Kevin and Anne Hassett, who are here. I would not be who I am today without their support and guidance. Thank you also to my siblings, and especially to my brother, Kevin, who made it out here and for bringing his family with him. That includes my sister, Adriana Hassett, who is a newly minted American citizen, their children and Audrey's mother-in-law, Susanna Iya Erda. Thank you to my friend Laurel Sagar, who is here and who is an adoptive aunt to my children in St. Louis. And I would also like to extend my thanks to the two judges who I clerked for. Judge Gruender, who is here today with his wonderful wife, Kim, and Justice Zahra, who is unable to make it today. These two judges have greatly impacted my understanding of what a judge's role should be. They are both committed to following the law as written, and fairly and impartially resolving legal disputes regardless of a party's background characteristics. I also want to extend my thanks to Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey, former Missouri Attorney General, and now Senator Schmitt. First Assistant Attorney General Jay Atkins, my boss, Josh Divine, who is next to me and the many other colleagues who I have worked with at the Missouri Attorney General's office to serve the people of the State of Missouri. And finally, thank you to everyone else who has helped me and supported me along the way, including my many family members, friends, teachers, mentors, and former colleagues at Thompson Coburn and Charter Communications. I am honored to be nominated for this position, and if confirmed by the Senate, I pledge to decide cases fairly and impartially according to the rule of law. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Thank you. Judge Stevens. STATEMENT OF HON. CRISTIAN M. STEVENS, NOMINEE TO SERVE AS UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI Judge Stevens. Thank you, Senator. Thanks to Chairman Grassley. Thanks to Ranking Member Durbin for holding this hearing. Thank you, Senator, for Chairing the hearing. Also, I want to thank all the Members of the Committee who are here today for their attention and their time. Also, of course, Senator Hawley, Senator Schmitt. I thank you for your support, as well as for your kind words earlier. Frankly, I'm humbled. I also want to thank my family who are here today. First and foremost, my wife, Lee. My wife is my rock. I want to thank her for her support over the years, for her sacrifice, for her grace throughout my career, and at this time, also my children. My, our oldest boy, Jack, is here, our son, Hank, and our daughter, Mary Rose. And all candor to the Committee, Mary Rose expressed this morning that she really didn't want to come because, ``This is boring'' but she is here, and so far so good. I also, of course, want to thank my parents; Ed and Melita Stevens are here today. And I can't begin to thank them for all they've done, for myself and my siblings, as children and all the way up through till today. They've been a great example of great Americans, great citizens who've raised their children, loved them, and supported them through thick and thin. I'd also like to thank my law clerks Clayton Watts and Tyler Dodd. My law clerk, Clayton, is here today. He's agreed to continue on for another year, serving with me regardless of which court I happen to be on at the time. So, I'm glad that he could make it here. I'd also, if I could, like to remember one other person that's not here today; my maternal grandfather, Edmund W. Albright. He was a self-made lawyer in St. Louis. He put himself through law school, hung out a shingle and took whatever case came in the door. As a young man, he taught me to love the law and our profession. I think of him all the time. Today, I'm wearing his watch, which has kept time for me throughout my career. I have his portrait in my chambers back in St. Louis, and I wish that he could be here today for this moment. I also would like to talk a little bit about my career to this point. I have the privilege of being a judge, a State judge in Missouri on the Missouri Court of Appeals Eastern District. I was appointed that position in 2021 pursuant to the non-partisan Missouri Court plan. Before that, I had the honor of serving as first assistant attorney general to then-Attorney General, Eric Schmitt of Missouri. That was a great privilege. A lot has gone on Senator, since our meeting at PJ's. I will say, if I could that I'm glad we met at PJ's and not at Cracker Barrel. I understand that some attorneys general met with staffers at Cracker Barrel, which is--I love Cracker Barrel, but PJ's is the place in Kirkwood. And before that, I was in private practice at several points in my career, early in my career and in later years. And so what that means basically, is that I've handled civil cases, I've had handled criminal cases, I've appeared in Federal Court and State Court, and particularly with the regard to the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. Senator, as you acknowledged earlier I was an assistant U.S. attorney there for 15 years. I would get up from my desk on the 20th floor of the Thomas F. Eagleton Courthouse, go down a few floors to see the Article 3 judges or the magistrate judges on at least a weekly basis. So, I can tell you that if this body deems fit, then my returning to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri would be like coming home. So, I appreciate the opportunity. I thank you for this hearing, and I look forward to answering your questions. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Judge. We will start now the questioning. I will lead us off. Mr. Bluestone, let me just start with you, and we'll just go down the panel. You are currently a violent crimes prosecutor in the United States Attorney's Office in the Eastern District. Tell us a little bit about the work that you do, the kinds of cases that you prosecute, and what you've learned from that experience. Mr. Bluestone. Thank you, Senator Hawley. Being an AUSA in the Eastern District of Missouri has been probably the most fulfilling job that I've had. It was commended to me by Judge Gruender, and frankly, before I clerked for him, it was not something that was really on my radar. But as both of my home State Senators are aware, there has been a violent crime epidemic in the city of St. Louis, in particular, in the area surrounding it. And it has been so gratifying to be able to do something about that. I prosecuted carjacking offenses, armed robberies and other gun crimes, drug crimes. Have been involved in white collar investigations as well. And the work is extremely rewarding. I will say I fully appreciate the importance of every single case that would come before my court, if I were so fortunate to be confirmed. Having seen probably north of 100 cases myself it's incredibly significant to the defendants who would be appearing before me, the victims, their families, law enforcement who were involved. And I take that responsibility very seriously. And I would also note that in addition to being a violent crimes prosecutor, I also serve as our district's appellate chief. So, and I handle my own cases certainly, but also am responsible for overseeing every appeal, both civil and criminal that comes through our office. Senator Hawley. Is it safe to say, Mr. Bluestone, given your experience as a Federal prosecutor, the volume of cases that you've seen and handled that you know your way around a courtroom? Mr. Bluestone. I would like to think so, Senator. Senator Hawley. We would like to think so, too. Mr. Bluestone. I've supervised more than 1,000 cases, and as I mentioned, handled more than 100 of my own. Senator Hawley. Fantastic. Mr. Divine, let's talk a little bit about your experience. You are the solicitor general of the State of Missouri. If you had to ballpark it, this may be tough, but if you had to ballpark it, how many cases would you say that you have litigated just in your role as a solicitor general? You were deputy solicitor general for several years, but let's just leave that to one side. Just as SG, how many cases? Mr. Divine. I mean, it would be impossible to know. It's in the hundreds of cases that I have supervised or personally litigated myself as solicitor general. I oversee the appeals for 200 attorneys in the office. We're getting a lot of appeals that are coming through, that we're supervising on a daily basis. I also have a second job, not just solicitor general, but also the director of Special Litigation. And so I'm in charge of the unit, the trial unit that is tasked with taking some of the most complicated matters that the State of Missouri is dealing with and taking those matters to court, to trial court especially. Senator Hawley. So, in these dual roles, you have represented the State of Missouri in trial courts? Mr. Divine. That's right. Senator Hawley. And in appellate courts? Mr. Divine. That's right. Senator Hawley. And in the State supreme court? Mr. Divine. That's right. Senator Hawley. And in the United States Supreme Court? Mr. Divine. That's right. Senator Hawley. You handled some of the office's most complex matters. Most complex litigation. Give us one example of a piece of complex litigation that you have handled and what you learned from it. Mr. Divine. Yes, I think the student loans cases that the office argued, we've now had three of those cases over the-- during the previous administration. Those were very, very quick cases. The administration at the time was trying to cancel hundreds of billions of dollars in student loans. We felt that that was unlawful. There wasn't any statutory basis for that. The courts ultimately agreed with us in all those cases, but it was a very, very quick-moving thing, and we needed to move quickly to ensure that there wasn't permanent irreparable harm. So, one thing we did in one of those cases, we actually sued before the rule had been published, which is a pretty novel thing to do. And we were able to come up with an interesting argument that ultimately prevailed in court for why we were able to do that. We showed that there is irreparable harm, $200 billion was about to go out the door, and we ultimately prevailed in that litigation. Senator Hawley. And your success record is hard to argue with. I mentioned it in my opening statement, what you have won in judgments for the State of Missouri through the litigation. You've handled totals in the hundreds of billions if you add it all up. I mean, is that correct? Mr. Divine. That's right. I think about $700 billion, Senator Hawley. $700 billion. That's pretty good. General Bailey, that's pretty good. Ms. Lanahan, in my expiring moments here, let me just ask you to say a word about your extensive and varied legal career. You're the principal deputy solicitor general now for the State of Missouri. If you had to ballpark, how many cases would you guess that you have handled in trial courts, appellate courts, you know, put them all together. I mean, what would it be? Ms. Lanahan. Certainly, upwards of 50. And I have also been in charge of many of the appeals in our office. I oversee directly at least one-fourth of the appeals, and I review them before they are sent in. And I've been doing that for the last 4 years or so. And we have numerous, numerous appeals out of many, many groups. So, that's employment law. And to remember that when you're doing an appeal, you're not only dealing with the trial court issues and whether the trial court got it right, but also the appellate issues, which is a whole another layer of separate issues on top. Senator Hawley. Very good. Well, Judge Stevens, I wanted to ask you a whole bunch of extremely difficult questions that that would've really been impossible to answer, but I'll leave that to Senator Schmitt. But first, Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Thank you very much, Senator Hawley. I feel like a kid from East St. Louis in the presence of a lot of St. Wilson's. I hope that I can stand up from my side of the river at least to some extent. Let me ask a few questions. Mr. Divine, you have referred to yourself as a zealot for the anti-choice movement. You previously wrote and I quote, ``Because we know a genetically unique human comes into existence at fertilization, abortion should not be ethically permitted.'' Let me ask you a couple questions. Do you believe an IVF embryo is a person? Mr. Divine. Thank you, Senator. My answer to that question in any policy question or political question that might be asked of me, is going to be the same exact answer that I know this Committee has heard from hundreds of nominees before me, that Justice Kagan gave, that Justice Barrett gave. I cannot talk about political disputes. That is obviously a hotly litigated issue and hotly disputed issue right now. So, I just cannot, under the canons of judicial ethics, talk about those kinds of political disputes. Senator Durbin. That's what I expected to hear. Do you believe in vitro fertilization should not be ``ethically permitted''? Mr. Divine. Can you tell me where the quote is coming from? Senator Durbin. I'll try to find that from the staff while you're thinking about the answer. Mr. Divine. So, I don't know the context of that, of what you're quoting to me right now. Senator Durbin. We're looking for the exact source on that. So, let's go to another question along that all the other members of this panel might address. I'm not going to get into the point made by Senator Blackburn about one of our witnesses yesterday saying she had some equivocation on following court orders, but as demonstrated by Senator Hawley, this panel has extensive court experience. So, the question I'd like to ask of each of you do you believe that the executive branch of our Government should be allowed to defy a court order? Mr. Bluestone? Mr. Bluestone. Thank you, Senator. I would have to take some caution in answering that question because this is a hotly litigated issue right now. But I would echo what we heard earlier in the hearing today, that generally speaking, that is of course, the rule. Senator Durbin. Mr. Devine? Mr. Divine. Thank you, Senator. My understanding of the doctrine is it is almost always required that you've to obey a court order. The only exceptions are for if there's a lack of jurisdiction, if there's impossibility. There is a well- recognized doctrine of exceptions to that. And so, you would have to check to see whether something fell within one of those very rare exceptions. Senator Durbin. But that would lead to an appeal, would it not? Mr. Divine. Certainly, you can appeal, and you would typically do that sort of thing in a jurisdictional setting. There have been cases before where a court has ordered somebody to do something that was literally impossible for them to comply with. And then in response to sanctions motion or whatever they've defended themselves on---- Senator Durbin. That's the only exception you can think of? Mr. Divine. There's a doctrine of well-recognized exceptions. There are some other situations, for example, in privilege issues. If a court has ordered somebody to disclose something and they're claiming privilege, sometimes in certain States especially, sometimes they actually have to defy that order to appeal it. That's the only way to appeal it. And that's a recognized exception in those circumstances. Senator Durbin. But there is a legal process that you follow if you're going to assert that sort of defense, correct? Mr. Divine. That is correct. Senator Durbin. And if you don't assert that, if you accept this as a final order, are you bound to follow that order? Mr. Divine. I stand by my previous answer. There's a doctrine of exceptions, but in almost all circumstances, the answer is yes. Senator Durbin. Ms. Lanahan? Ms. Lanahan. Thank you. I would agree basically that the typical rule is that parties before a court are bound by that court order. I think there have been a couple of exceptions that the panel has discussed. But I think as a general matter, that that is correct. I wouldn't want to go into specifics because this is a hotly litigated issue as Ms. Hermandorfer had talked about earlier. Senator Durbin. Mr. Stevens? Judge Stevens. Yes, Senator Durbin. As a judge, I do expect parties to follow my orders. Obviously, there's been references to other narrow exceptions to that rule. Frankly, with almost 4 years on the bench, I haven't encountered any of those exceptions. So, yes, I expect parties to. Senator Durbin. And each one, I want to make this clear. If you have a court order applying to you, you have to follow it or appeal it. That's my conclusion. Is that yours? Judge Stevens. Well, I expect that parties will follow my orders, yes. Senator Durbin. Well, I'm asking you whether or not you not only expect it, whether that is part of the rule of law in America, and I think it is, isn't it? Judge Stevens. Well, I think yes. There's a process, obviously before our court. If a litigant doesn't like a decision that they've gotten in our court, then they can ask for transfer from the Missouri Supreme Court. Senator Durbin. Mr. Divine, the quote comes from The Mirror, October 6, 2010. In The Mirror, you called yourself a zealot for the pro-life movement. So, I'll ask the question again. Do you believe in vitro fertilization should not be ethically permitted? Mr. Divine. Senator, I don't share the characterization of the article, which was written when I was a teenager. When I use the term zealot, I was referring to--I was using the same term you used in the March 26 hearing earlier this year, which is, if you're an advocate for a cause, you have a duty to advocate that cause energetically. I think Americans of all stripes, if they believe in an issue, they should advocate those issues energetically. Senator Durbin. So, where are you on in in vitro fertilization? Mr. Divine. Senator, I don't think any of my articles in college, and I've disclosed over 200, has ever taken a position on that. Senator Durbin. Well, talk--forget your college. I'm sure it was an exciting experience. Let's talk about now. You want a lifetime appointment to the Federal bench, and I'd like to know your position on in vitro fertilization. Mr. Divine. Senator, you said you weren't surprised by my previous answer, which has been given by hundreds of nominees before me. I can't talk about those politically contentious issues. Senator Durbin. After Alabama made that fateful ruling about saying that an IVF embryo was a person, there was an effort by most mainstream people in politics in both parties to clarify their position on in vitro fertilization, including current President of the United States. The fact that this panel is, at least, Mr. Divine is, struggling with that is unfortunately a tell as to what we can expect from you if you nomination is approved. I yield. Senator Hawley. It's going to be Senator Schmitt's time, but can I just ask, Mr. Divine, are you running for office? Mr. Divine. No, Senator. I've never been a political candidate. Senator Hawley. Are you seeking the nomination of a party or the approval of voters? Mr. Divine. No, Senator. Senator Hawley. You've been nominated to be a judge, is that correct? Mr. Divine. That's correct. Senator Hawley. Will you be able to faithfully follow the law as you understand it? Mr. Divine. Absolutely. And in fact, in my day to day when I'm advocating the interest of the State of Missouri, I set aside my own personal beliefs every single time I'm advocating the interest of my client. Senator Hawley. And what's the controlling Supreme Court case on the life issue now, as you understand it? Mr. Divine. The Dobbs decision. Senator Hawley. Will you follow it faithfully? Mr. Divine. Absolutely. Senator Hawley. Senator Schmitt. Senator Schmitt. Thank you. I mentioned this in the introduction, but I'm not sure we--somebody who can probably figure this out. I'm not sure it's ever happened in the history of our republic, that within the last seven or 8 years, you have two former attorneys general from the State of Missouri in the U.S. Senate in a confirmation hearing with four nominees for district court position that also served in that office in the last seven or 8 years. So, it's a pretty unique moment. And also, would be in a courthouse named after Tom Eagleton, who was an attorney general in Missouri and served in the U.S. Senate. So, it's a pretty it's a great day for all of you and your families. We're so glad that you could make it and share this really special experience. So, maybe the most important question for all of you, just to ask each, you know, to answer separately, how great was it to work for Eric Schmitt? [Laughter.] Senator Schmitt. I'm joking. By the way, you can add that to augment that to any question that's asked if you choose, but I'm not going to make you do that under oath, maybe. But I guess just to open it up for each one of you to answer, which may be a little bit of a different question that's often asked, each one of you have practiced before judges, you've clerked for judges in sort of different capacities. What is one thing that you would take from that experience, whether it's before a judge, or working from a judge that you saw a judge do that you would like to emulate now as you hopefully become a Federal judge? Mr. Bluestone. I'll take on with some risk. That first question before I dive into this one. And I will quote from now-Solicitor General John Sauer, that I love you both equally, and it was great working for you both. Senator Schmitt. He had a different answer once Senator Hawley left before the record. Mr. Bluestone. I have another mentor in the room, as I mentioned, Judge Gruender. And I will say, just thinking back to seeing him presiding over appeals, he was tremendously gracious with the parties that appeared before him. He gave everyone an opportunity to address what he would see as the weaknesses and their arguments, and was honest with them about that. And I think certainly the way that he approached the parties would be something I would hope to emulate. Mr. Divine. Senator Schmitt, you were my favorite Attorney General who I worked for in 2019. [Laughter.] Mr. Divine. You know, one, one of the things I really appreciated working for both Chief Judge William Pryor, and also Justice Thomas, is just the humility that both of them brought to the bench. I mean, you know, it wasn't unusual for a judge or some other judges in the building to kind of have an initial inclination of what the correct answer is going to be and then change their minds as they're going through the process. And I think being able to--being open to that sort of thing, being open to having your mind changed is a very valuable asset for a judge. Ms. Lanahan. Thank you, Senator Schmitt. And one of the things I loved the most while I was working for your office was the opportunity to be a part of the way that democracy works in this country. So, in the State of Missouri, the people of the State of Missouri elect their representatives. Then the General Assembly makes laws, and then our job as almost all those laws are challenged at one point or another, and it's our job in the Missouri Attorney General's office to give those laws defense. And so it is important as a role as, for instance, a public defender's role in the democratic process to protect and to defend those laws that are passed by the State, the people of the State of Missouri. As for things I learned from my judges, I think both of my judges, and I just want to talk about Judge Gruender, one thing that's coming to mind is that the way he went through very methodically, the opinions that he would write and make sure that he wasn't skipping any steps, was something that I thought was extremely valuable. Because I think the most often when you see judges go off track, it's because they've skipped a step. And it's very easy to when you skip a step in your analysis, it's easy to insert your own opinion here. And I think that that was one of the things I took from that clerkship, is to never skip steps and to always show your work to make sure that you're not going to be inserting your own opinion here. Judge Stevens. Thank you, Senator. I will say given the team that you put together at the Attorney General's Office, it was one of the seminal points in my career. Not just because of the great team working for you and the great working with the great team that we had, but also managing just some of the tremendous young lawyers that came up through that office. That's, of course, as I'm sure you and Senator Hawley both know the office where Justice Clarence Thomas began his career under then Attorney General John Danforth. It's an amazing place. It's an amazing training ground for great lawyers. I'm proud to say that one of my current clerks, Tyler Dodd, will be leaving me in the next few months to join the Attorney General's Office. And I expect that my other clerk Clayton Watts, who's here today, will be joining that office after we're finished next year. So, it's just a, a tremendous place to learn to practice law and to practice law long-term as well. As far as what I've learned, I had the privilege, the great privilege of clerking for Judge Pasco M. Bowman II. The first thing I can say that he exemplified was collegiality. That was a time on the Eighth Circuit where there were a lot of Reagan appointees, including Judge Bowman. But you also had senior members of that court from as long as long ago as the Lyndon Baines Johnson Administration, believe it or not. Senator Myron Bright was a giant of that court for many years, had been appointed by LBJ, and was one of Judge Bowman's greatest friends on the court. And they agreed on virtually nothing legally, but they exemplified what someone said earlier about being able to disagree without being disagreeable. And that left an impression. And I've had opportunities over the years to give presentations to young lawyers about how to approach trials or how to approach appeals. And that's one of the things I always mention is that you can't, in the rough and tumble particularly of trial, you can't expect to always get along with opposing counsel. You have to zealously represent your client. But if you can, you should at least try and--before the Eighth Circuit and the Courts of Appeals, they expect their bars to be collegial, and they respect that, and it's advantageous to your client to be that way as well. And the other thing was instinctual to him was a love for the rule of law and a respect for the rule of law. That was apparent to me from the beginning. I've had that experience in other capacities in my career as well. I talked about it, my investiture ceremony almost 4 years ago now, some of the mentors I had during my career, one of those was Judge Raymond Gruender, who changed my life when he hired me as an assistant U.S. attorney when he was the United States attorney in St. Louis. He also had the good judgment to hire my wife as his first law clerk, not coincidentally. And Judge Gruender also represents that, the rule of law. He as the U.S. attorney, and now for a judge for about 22 years, he's exemplified that. Another example would be Tom Meyer, who as Judge Schmitt-- I'm sorry, Senator Schmitt knows, is an institution in St. Louis. He was the United States Attorney appointed under President Reagan, and joined our team at the Attorney General's Office, worked for Attorney General Schmitt with the Cold Case Unit. And there's no one I know more that exemplifies the rule of law than Tom Meyer, even when it was--particularly when it was not politically advantageous for him as U.S. Attorney. He took some--made some risky decisions to ensure that the law was upheld. And those are the things that I've learned. Senator Schmitt. Thank you, and thank you-all. And you're all going to be great judges, so congratulations. Thanks. Judge Stevens. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Now, I gave Senator Kennedy an extra couple questions in the last round on condition that'd he'd be nice to all of these folks. So, with that, Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. I'm always nice. How many of you worked for Senator Schmitt? All four of you. Is it true that he was suspended 23 times in junior high school---- [Laughter.] Senator Kennedy [continuing]. In February alone? Senator Schmitt. They're under oath, John, be nice. Senator Kennedy. Look, I'm not trying to trick you. I just want to--I'm not going to ask you how you want to rule on cases, and I'm not going to ask you about your political beliefs. I just want to know how you think. Let's start with the counselor on the end. Suppose I'm a cop and I'm on duty, and it's 3 o'clock in the morning and I see somebody driving down the road. Not many other people around, it's on a Saturday night. Can I stop you? Mr. Bluestone. Just because you see him driving around? Senator Kennedy. Yes. Mr. Bluestone. There would need to be more of a basis than that. Senator Kennedy. So, the answer's no? Mr. Bluestone. Correct. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Let's suppose that I recognize him and on three previous occasions he's been caught for charged with DWI, but he's not driving erratically. I'm the cop, again. Can I stop him, constitutionally? Mr. Bluestone. Same answer. No. Senator Kennedy. No? Mr. Bluestone. You would need more than that to be able to conduct an investigation. Senator Kennedy. Why don't I have--why doesn't that give me reasonable suspicion? Mr. Bluestone. I think merely the fact that he was driving at 3 a.m. and had been pulled over previously for driving under the influence wouldn't be enough. Now, it certainly if he were swerving or driving improperly in some other way, if he committed a traffic violation or something along those lines certainly the officer would be well within his rights. Senator Kennedy. Okay. So, we can agree our privacy is precious to us, even if we're in a car, right? Mr. Bluestone. I would agree that the Fourth Amendment, very thankfully, protects us all from unreasonable searches and seizures. Senator Kennedy. So, how come the cops can set up a roadblock to and stop everybody when they don't have either reasonable suspicion or probable cause just to check and see if they have insurance? Mr. Bluestone. So, there are limitations on scenarios like that, roadblock cases. Senator Kennedy. Can I do it first, Counsel, I mean? Mr. Bluestone. Officers can set up roadblocks if they're applying it based on a neutral and articulable standard, and if that standard relates to something that is specific to automobiles. So, they could not stop every car to search you. Senator Kennedy. You're right about the law, but why? Why's not that they don't have reasonable suspicion, they're stopping everybody. They certainly don't have probable cause. It's intrusive. I mean, I can be--I can spend 10 minutes in line from to check my insurance. What's the basis for that being constitutional? Mr. Bluestone. I think the way I would frame it is that the courts have decided that scenarios like that--in scenarious like that officers would not be acting unreasonably, so they would not be violating somebody's Fourth Amendment rights. Senator Kennedy. Because the Fourth Amendment---- Mr. Bluestone. Guarantees against---- Senator Kennedy. Unreasonable searches and seizures. Mr. Bluestone. Correct. Senator Kennedy. And how do you determine whether something's unreasonable or not? Mr. Bluestone. Well, I think that would very much depend on the situation, the specific facts, and the context. Senator Kennedy. Don't you balance the costs and benefits? Mr. Bluestone. In a scenario like that, yes. Senator Kennedy. Okay, cool. Judge, what's the rule now that the Supreme Court follows on reapportionment cases, congressional redistricting? Judge Stevens. Congressional redistricting? My understanding, Senator, is that the Supreme Court has decided that that's a political issue. And under the political issue doctrine, that essentially the courts really don't have much of anything to say about political redistricting. Senator Kennedy. If Missouri's legislature gets together and it redraws districts, and they're going to say a majority of Democrats in the legislature. So, they say we're going to redraw these districts to benefit Democrats and we're not going to be reluctant to say so. They say in front of God and country. Is that okay? Judge Stevens. Well, it's pursuant to the Supreme Court precedent. It's legal---- Senator Kennedy. Yes. Okay. All right. I'm not going to get to all of you Counselor. This counselor, yes, ma'am. Do you think the meaning of the Constitution is immutable? Ms. Lanahan. So, I think that the Missouri--sorry, the U.S. Supreme Court has said that the---- Senator Kennedy. I want to know what you think. Ms. Lanahan. So, yes, my view in terms of like, what it is that--you know, my way of looking at the Constitution is to say what does the text say and what did it mean at the time that it was passed? And this is something that the U.S. Supreme Court also says. If that's not clear, I think there are other things you can look to, like history and tradition to decide what the---- Senator Kennedy. You look to the--what it meant at the time it was passed? Ms. Lanahan. Correct. Senator Kennedy. What it meant to whom? Ms. Lanahan. To the people who were passing it? Senator Kennedy. To the people who wrote it? Ms. Lanahan. So, I think there are various different ways of looking at this, and I think the U.S. Supreme Court has said that you look at the meaning that the words would have to the public at the time that the Constitution was ratified. Senator Kennedy. That's right. I'm done. Thank you. Congratulations. Senator Hawley. Senator Padilla. Senator Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and appreciate your patience and allowing me to come back to ask questions. This is the first of these for the calendar year and very important. So, I don't want to miss the opportunity to raise some questions, particularly for Mr. Divine. I'll start there. Mr. Divine, in 2011, you wrote a piece for your college newspaper arguing against marriage equality. While you acknowledged that, ``the gay community cannot be blamed,'' for the ``weakening'' of marriage, you were worried that marriage equality would, ``further this trend of traumatic digressions,'' against marriage. Now, it's hard to see how this could be interpreted as anything other than you suggesting that LGBT people enjoying the same rights as straight people is somehow harming your conception of the institution of marriage. But like I said, you don't just blame marriage equality. You also blame ``easy divorce, cohabitation, increased single parenting rates, and recreational sex.'' These are your words. So, Mr. Divine, noting for the record that June is Pride Month and that we are sitting here in Washington, DC, which is hosting World Pride this year, I have to ask, do you believe in marriage equality? Mr. Divine. Senator, thank you for that question. As you mentioned, this was a college writing 2011. At the time I expressed the same view that President Obama expressed, that Joe Biden expressed, that Hillary Clinton expressed under Canon 5 of the Judicial Ethics. As I'm sure you are aware, and as hundreds of nominees before me have expressed, I cannot tell you what my personal views are today or my political views are today. What I can tell you is that I'm no longer in college. That was, you know, almost 15 years ago. I can tell you that as a general matter, I've grown up, I've had a lot more experiences. A lot of my policy and political and even some of my religious views have changed in that time. But I can't tell you specifically any specific policy or political issue. Senator Padilla. So, then let's jump to today, and can you answer this question? Can you tell me the legal status of marriage equality according to the Supreme Court? Mr. Divine. Yes. Ten years ago, this month, the Obergefell decision was decided. I understand also maybe 3 years ago this Congress passed some legislation. And obviously, Obergefell is a binding decision of the Supreme Court. As a lower court judge, I would be bound by that decision, just like every other decision of the Supreme Court and also the Eighth Circuit. Senator Padilla. So, if you're fortunate enough to be confirmed, you would uphold that Supreme Court precedent? Mr. Divine. That's correct. Senator Padilla. Thank you for that. Now, being selected to serve as one of our Nation's Federal judges is one of the greatest honors that we can bestow on any person. It's also one of the greatest responsibilities. So, Mr. Divine, I'd like to ask, how many years of litigation experience do you have? Mr. Divine. Did you say how many years of litigation? Senator Padilla. Correct. Mr. Divine. About a decade. Senator Padilla. About a decade? Can you be a little bit more precise. I know you know your resume pretty good. Mr. Divine. So, it depends. If you consider--you know, I was chief counsel in the Senate, I was deputy counsel in the Senate. We also did some amicus briefs during that time, which would be considered litigation. I obviously wasn't doing litigation all the time during that period. But if you include that period of time, I think it's about 9 years. Senator Padilla. That include clerkship time? Mr. Divine. Yes. Senator Padilla. Okay. So, without clerkship time, it would be less? Mr. Divine. That's correct. It would be 7 years. Senator Padilla. Right. And I think it's important for this Committee to consider that because while President Trump has decided to throw out the American Bar Association's nonpartisan rating system I know that the American Bar Association does have a threshold for litigation experience for any nominee to receive a qualified rating. And you seem to fall short of that. So, again, something for this Committee to consider, I would hope. Last, we're about 5 months into President Trump's second term, and we've already seen numerous attempts by the President and even some of my colleagues in Congress to attack and undermine the judicial branch, all for the crime of issuing rulings, pausing, or striking down the President's illegal and unconstitutional actions. I was concerned to hear earlier in the first panel of this hearing, Ms. Hermandorfer's willingness to--unwillingness, I should say, to tell Senator Kennedy that the executive branch must follow court orders. So, again, Mr. Divine, I ask you, if you're lucky enough to be confirmed, and you author an opinion for the Sixth Circuit in which the executive branch or one of its officers is a party and you decide against the executive branch or one of its officers, would you believe they are bound by that decision? Mr. Divine. So, Senator, a point of clarification. I haven't been nominated to the Sixth Circuit, so. But taking your question with respect to the district courts in Missouri, I mentioned to Ranking Member Durbin earlier, that there is a well-established doctrine on this. The answer is almost always yes, with some exceptions for if there's lack of jurisdiction, if there's impossibility, things of that nature. Senator Padilla. So, my apology for the confusion, Ms. Hermandorfer is the one that was nominated for the Sixth Circuit, not you. But just expand for a moment, I know my time is up, on what those exceptions would be. I understand there's some exceptions, but some people in this day and age, the political climate that we're living in seem to be really broadening the categories of what qualifies for an exception. Very different than what we've seen historically. Mr. Divine. Yes, Senator. One of those exceptions, the first of the three that I just mentioned to you is if a court lacks jurisdiction. The Supreme Court has been very clear that an order issued without jurisdiction is void ab initio. It's as if it never happened. And so, for there to be a circumstance where, you know, a judge or a litigant was accusing somebody of violating an order and the district court was later determined to lack jurisdiction at the outset, then there would've been no order to violate in the first place. Senator Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will be---- Senator Hawley. Thank you, Senator. Senator Padilla [continuing]. Submitting additional questions for the record. Senator Hawley. Absolutely. And on that note, questions for the record may be submitted until June the 11 at 5 p.m. Senator Hawley. Thank you to the nominees. And with that, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 1:13 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [Additional material submitted for the record follows.] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] A P P E N D I X The following submissions are available at: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-119shrg61981/pdf/CHRG- 119shrg 61981-add1.pdf Submitted by Ranking Member Durbin: People for the American Way (PFAW), letter....................... 2 [all]