Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-125] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-125 HEARING TO IDENTIFY CHALLENGES TO MEETING INCREASED ELECTRICITY DEMAND ======================================================================== HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ JULY 23, 2025 __________ [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Printed for the use of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 61-245 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES MIKE LEE, Utah, Chairman JOHN BARRASSO, Wyoming MARTIN HEINRICH, New Mexico JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho RON WYDEN, Oregon STEVE DAINES, Montana MARIA CANTWELL, Washington TOM COTTON, Arkansas MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii DAVID McCORMICK, Pennsylvania ANGUS S. KING, Jr., Maine JAMES C. JUSTICE, West Virginia CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO, Nevada BILL CASSIDY, Louisiana JOHN W. HICKENLOOPER, Colorado CINDY HYDE-SMITH, Mississippi ALEX PADILLA, California LISA MURKOWSKI, Alaska RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona JOHN HOEVEN, North Dakota Wendy Baig, Majority Staff Director Patrick J. McCormick III, Majority Chief Counsel Jake McCurdy, Majority Policy Director for Energy Jasmine Hunt, Minority Staff Director Sam E. Fowler, Minority Chief Counsel Anais Borja, Minority Energy Policy Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Lee, Hon. Mike, Chairman and a U.S. Senator from Utah............ 1 Heinrich, Hon. Martin, Ranking Member and a U.S. Senator from New Mexico..................................................... 3 WITNESSES Huntsman, Peter, Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer, Huntsman Corporation.................................. 4 Tench, Jeff, Executive Vice President, North America and Asia Pacific, Vantage Data Centers.................................. 12 Gramlich, Rob, President, Grid Strategies, LLC................... 20 ALPHABETICAL LISTING AND APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED Gramlich, Rob: Opening Statement............................................ 20 Written Testimony............................................ 22 Responses to Questions for the Record........................ 68 Heinrich, Hon. Martin: Opening Statement............................................ 3 Hiatt, Shon R. and Angela Ryu: Article entitled ``Turning Old Into New: Meeting Immediate Data Center Demands by Converting Gas Peaker Plants to CCGT'' published on July 30, 2025 by the University of Southern California Marshall School of Business............ 83 Huntsman, Peter: Opening Statement............................................ 4 Written Testimony............................................ 7 King, Jr., Hon. Angus S.: Department of Energy press release entitled ``Department of Energy Terminates Taxpayer-Funded Financial Assistance for Grain Belt Express'' dated July 23, 2025................... 38 Photograph of a carbon fiber-based conductor next to a conventional high-tension conductor........................ 41 Lee, Hon. Mike: Opening Statement............................................ 1 McLaughlin, Thomas: Letter for the Record........................................ 102 Tench, Jeff: Opening Statement............................................ 12 Written Testimony............................................ 14 Responses to Questions for the Record........................ 63 HEARING TO IDENTIFY CHALLENGES TO MEETING INCREASED ELECTRICITY DEMAND ---------- WEDNESDAY, JULY 23, 2025 U.S. Senate, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:02 a.m. in Room SD-366, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Mike Lee, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MIKE LEE, U.S. SENATOR FROM UTAH The Chairman. The hearing will come to order. Good morning and welcome to all of you. Today's hearing focuses on the challenges that America faces in meeting the increased demand for electricity, something that has gotten a lot of attention, with good reason. Demand has been trending upward in recent years, and some expect it could grow by 25 percent just in the next five years alone. Data centers supporting artificial intelligence, advanced manufacturing, and the planned retirement of current production sources are just a few of the causes creating this increased demand, and as more people are drawn toward electric cars, that could put additional demand in play, as well. America needs to put more electrons on the grid, and we will be hearing from three witnesses to better understand these issues today, and we are very fortunate to have them. They are, first, Peter Huntsman, the Chairman and CEO of Huntsman Corporation; Jeff Tench, the Executive Vice President of Vantage Data Centers--welcome--and finally, Rob Gramlich, the President of Grid Strategies. Thanks to all of you for being here. Now, let's begin with a simple fact. America's electricity demand is surging. It's not creeping up, it's surging. For decades, power demand in this country remained relatively flat--utilities planned for it, markets priced for it, regulators counted on it, but that era is over. We are now entering a new era of electrification--data centers, AI computing, manufacturing returning home, electric vehicles, all of it. Even conservative estimates suggest that we could see two to three percent annual growth compounded over the next decade. Now, that number, two to three percent, annually compounded--that might not sound like much, but it's like a two-way highway that was built decades ago that is now expected to carry rush hour traffic to and from a major city every day of the year--more cars, bigger trucks, constant congestion. And if the road hasn't changed, but everything around it has changed, that is going to be an issue. Now, that is a fairly decent analogy, something to help understand our power grid and the challenges now facing it. Now, here is the real problem. We have spent much of the last 20 years shutting down the generation that can actually meet that demand--coal plants retired, nuclear blocked, natural gas tied up in endless litigation. And we replaced a lot of that capacity with wind, solar, and batteries--resources that by design don't work all the time, but work roughly a third of the time. One-third of the time--that's not enough. Not enough to support the dispatchable baseload power that we got from the other sources I mentioned. These resources, being non- dispatchable, means that they cannot be dispatched at the exact moment that they are needed with the predictability and the reliability that is required. They do not provide baseload power and they do not build themselves. They require massive transmission overhauls, grid upgrades, and most importantly, in many circumstances, subsidies. So this isn't a free market. In many ways, it's a rigged one. The Federal Government has been investing heavily in certain green energy technologies for decades, handing out tax credits like candy. So naturally, developers follow these credits, and why wouldn't they? But what is the result? Ninety- five percent of the projects waiting to connect to the grid happen to be wind, solar, and batteries, but only 10 percent of those ever make it online--onto the grid. Meanwhile, gas plants, nuclear reactors, geothermal, these things that can actually power a modern economy, providing predictable, reliable, affordable, clean baseload power, they get crowded out or delayed endlessly or blocked entirely. Why? Well, government red tape is responsible for a lot of it and activist-funded lawsuits also have a fair amount to do with it because a government that picks winners and losers--and consistently picks losers--creates a lot of this problem. Now, look at what FERC tells us. According to FERC, between now and 2028, we are set to retire 24 gigawatts of coal-fired generation, just in the next three years alone, and replace it with just five gigawatts of gas-fired power. That math doesn't work--not in theory, not in practice, not now, not then, not anywhere, or at any time. The system was built for slow, steady growth. What we are facing now is a tidal wave. And if we don't change course, if we don't wake up to this reality, the lights are going out. We need utilities, developers, states, and Congress to start telling the truth about this. The grid is not ready. The system is not built for this. And the path that we are on will culminate, quite predictably, in rolling blackouts, rising prices, national vulnerability, and our inability to remain competitive in what many are describing as the AI global arms race. In fact, on only July 7, the U.S. Energy Department warned that between the growth in demand and the retirement of some current sources, if we don't take steps to respond to the increased demand, the risk of blackouts in the United States will increase a hundredfold. I repeat, increasing 100 times what we currently face in terms of blackouts across the country. We currently experience annual outage hours in the single digits. And if we don't take effective steps, the estimate is more than 800 outage hours per year in the next five years. We cannot allow that to happen. We have too much riding on that. It's time that we face the facts, and that's what this hearing is about. The Chair now recognizes the Ranking Member, Senator Heinrich. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARTIN HEINRICH, U.S. SENATOR FROM NEW MEXICO Senator Heinrich. Thank you, Chairman Lee. Welcome to our witnesses, Mr. Gramlich, Mr. Huntsman, and Mr. Tench. As we will discuss today, the scale and drivers of today's rising electricity demand are relatively unprecedented. It's not just that electricity demand is reaching record highs, it's that we are entering a new era of sustained load growth. The structural forces underlying today's load growth are converging--the growth of AI data centers, the electrification of vehicles, buildings, industry, as well as a resurgence in domestic manufacturing. And meeting this load growth will require structural changes to how we permit and build our energy infrastructure. In his testimony, Mr. Tench states that Vantage would prefer to source power from the grid, but that the system is out of sync. From interconnection timelines that are too long, transmission lines that take too long to build, and permitting that is too fragmented, the challenges that Mr. Tench articulates are the same ones that this Committee has been trying to address for some time. As Mr. Tench notes in his testimony, no single business or technical workaround can substitute for a coordinated, modern, responsive grid. Fortunately, we sit on the Committee that can help make that happen. The urgency isn't just about maintaining our edge in AI innovation, it's about affordability. As Mr. Gramlich points out in his testimony today, electricity bills are becoming unaffordable for too many Americans, and recent actions by President Trump and by the ``Big Bad Bill'' will make this worse. The reconciliation bill alone is estimated to increase annual energy costs more than $16 billion in 2030, and more than $33 billion by 2035. This is because, at a time when we need every single electron we can get, the reconciliation bill is causing many clean energy projects to be canceled. And the President's tariffs are driving up equipment costs, raising the cost of all energy generation resources--all of them. This is leading directly to Americans spending more on their utility bills. And on top of this, an aging electrical grid is causing many energy projects to be stalled for years in interconnection queues. In June 2025, Grid Strategies released a study that found that investing in well-planned, high-capacity transmission could save U.S. households between $6.3 and $10.4 billion annually, and that is even after accounting for the cost of actually building those transmission lines. The amount of energy currently in U.S. interconnection queues substantially exceeds the existing electricity demands--if only the grid could integrate it. According to the Energy Information Administration (EIA), in 2024, the U.S. installed nearly 49 gigawatts of new grid capacity, 95 percent of which was for renewable resources. This year, the EIA estimates that developers will build 63 gigawatts of new capacity, including 32.5 gigawatts of new utility-scale solar, 7.7 gigawatts of wind power, 18.2 gigawatts of energy storage, and just 4.4 gigawatts of natural gas-fired generation. Clean energy is the most affordable, and it's the fastest type of energy generation to deploy, outpacing natural gas, which is facing years-long backlogs in turbine availability. If you order a combined-cycle natural gas turbine today, you will be lucky if it puts its first electron on the grid before 2032. Meanwhile, states like Texas and California are demonstrating that high levels of renewable energy do not compromise grid reliability. In fact, they improve it. After Texas added 9,600 megawatts of clean energy, including 5,400 megawatts of solar, 3,800 megawatts of energy storage, and 253 megawatts of wind, ERCOT CEO Pablo Vegas said that the risk of grid emergencies dropped to less than one percent. That is down from 16 percent the previous year. NERC's 2025 Summer Reliability Assessment confirmed this trend, showing that the risk of rolling blackouts in Texas fell from 15 percent to 3 percent as battery capacity came online. I will close by saying that I am deeply disturbed by the recent Department of Interior policy that requires Secretary Doug Burgum to personally review and sign off on wind and solar projects on federal lands. This nakedly political decision will risk delaying new generation additions to the grid when we need them the most. And consequently, it will drive up cost. According to the Department of Energy, federal lands in the contiguous United States could support more than 7,700 gigawatts of renewable energy capacity. And with that said, I look forward to discussing how we can meet the rise in electricity demand and lower energy costs for households by integrating the most affordable and rapidly deployable energy resources today while also investing in long-term modernization. Thank you, Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Heinrich. We will now hear from each of our witnesses, giving you five minutes to make your opening statements. We will hear first from Mr. Huntsman, then from Mr. Tench, and then from Mr. Gramlich. Mr. Huntsman, you may proceed. STATEMENT OF PETER HUNTSMAN, CHAIRMAN, PRESIDENT, AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, HUNTSMAN CORPORATION Mr. Huntsman. Thank you very much. Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, members of the Committee, my name is Peter Huntsman, and I am Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer of Huntsman Corporation. For the first time in a generation, America faces an increase in electricity demand that will have far-reaching consequences if not managed appropriately by elected officials in both parties at federal, state, and local levels. This may sound like hyperbole, but it is not. Look no further than Germany, the United Kingdom, and much of Europe and see how quickly great powers can implement policy to kill productive and thriving industries that form the backbone of modern economies. Just a decade ago, these nations were great industrial powerhouses. Today, they have the highest electricity prices in the industrialized world, shrinking economies, and factories are being shuttered almost daily. Sadly, I have experienced this firsthand, as our company has laid off thousands of employees in Europe. Facilities that were globally competitive just a few years ago are now closed and are no longer operating due to ruinous and unrealistic net-zero and decarbonization policies and the failed ideas that you can power a modern economy without developing oil and gas resources. In the chemical industry, we use large amounts of energy and electricity, take molecules mostly derived from oil and gas, break them apart, and then put them back together to make the physical building blocks of virtually everything you see, touch, and consume in modern life. Our entire supply chain employs millions of Americans and is mostly domestic-based-- from transportation, technology, food supplies, medical equipment, building materials, pharma, and textiles--none of this would be possible without the chemical industry. None of it. Technology companies perform similar functions, taking energy and electricity to create data that enables everyone of us to tap our mobile phones--by the way, another product that contains over 100 different chemicals to build--and access the world at our fingertips. Virtually every step in the tech world, from chip manufacturing to data generation, storage, transmission, computing, and consumer interface, uses petrochemicals and enormous amounts of electricity to not just maintain, but to grow this vital industry. The advent of artificial intelligence is fast changing the face of modern society and global competitiveness. AI will bring an enormous wave of societal benefit, similar to every past industrial and technological advancement. However, it is simply impossible for this to happen in a society that does not have the basic hydrocarbons to both construct the physical materials needed to build and the electricity required to power this great advancement. The challenge before us today is real, but the opportunities are even greater. The United States has both the raw material and the technological base to not just compete, but to continue to lead. Our greatest challenge will be to balance the enormous demand for more electricity while being able to keep prices affordable and supplies reliable for both consumers and industry, especially those who do not benefit from trillion-dollar balance sheets. If our growing demand for electricity being consumed by data centers and a growing tech industry are not met with additional reliable and affordable energy sources, we risk losing both our manufacturing and consumer affordability. It is simply impossible to build a modern industrial and technological economy on an energy base that is neither reliable nor affordable. We can talk all we want to about nuclear ambitions that are decades away or intermittent wind and solar dreams that are operable 25 to 40 percent of the time and require even greater investment and more reliable backup and unrealistic battery storage, but these dreams will never solve today's problems. The demand for power and raw materials is here today and growing tomorrow. If we continue to build out more tech industry consumption than production of electricity while at the same time prohibiting the reliable and affordable production of largely hydrocarbon-based energy sources, we will look more like Europe and less like the continued model of growth that has made the United States the envy of the world. Senators, now is the time for ambitious and bipartisan planning that will allow American industry, capital markets, and innovation to meet the needs of these exciting times and opportunities. Our company, our industry, and most importantly, the millions of people who rely on our operations, look forward to being a part of the needed solutions and innovations that will be required for our continued success. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Huntsman follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Huntsman. Mr. Tench. STATEMENT OF JEFF TENCH, EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT, NORTH AMERICA AND ASIA PACIFIC, VANTAGE DATA CENTERS Mr. Tench. Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, and members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Jeff Tench, and I serve as the Executive Vice President for North America and Asia Pacific at Vantage Data Centers, a Colorado-based developer, owner, and operator of hyperscale data centers for leading U.S. technology companies. I would like to briefly summarize my written remarks that have been submitted for the record. While I do not claim to be an expert on energy policy, I have spent my career building businesses and leading teams that construct and operate the most efficient, secure, and resilient large-scale digital infrastructure in the world, and I appear before you with one message, based on what I have seen from my position: the greatest barrier we collectively face to our country's leadership on artificial intelligence today is timely access to reliable electric power. Demand for the AI and cloud infrastructure that Vantage provides is accelerating. Over the past decade, I have seen the scale and speed of hyperscale data center development grow dramatically. Five years ago, a 30- megawatt facility was considered large. Today, 100 megawatts is the starting point, with campus developments commonly reaching 500 megawatts or more. And we have multiple customers seeking one gigawatt or more for AI infrastructure, which is the equivalent of all electrical power used here in Washington, DC. In market after market across the U.S., our development teams all report the same issue: we cannot get the amount of electricity we need in the time frame to build our data centers. Without electrical power, it is not possible to build digital infrastructure. The infrastructure that supports AI, data centers, transmission lines, and generation facilities must scale rapidly if the U.S. is to remain the global leader in AI innovation. We are asking for your leadership to drive a more modernized policy framework that reflects today's growth, aligns with investment timelines, and ensures that the power system is ready when and where it is needed. From Vantage's perspective, the challenge is clear: we cannot access power on a timeline that aligns with customer demand. First, interconnection timelines are too long, both for new load and new generation resources. Second, we must develop new transmission for a more scalable and reliable grid. Third, permitting is fragmented and sequential, resulting in both increased costs and delays in projects that are otherwise ready to proceed. If we do not act decisively, we risk ceding AI leadership to countries that are moving faster to modernize their energy infrastructure. The United States is at a pivotal moment. The United States is looking at an AI era that is not coming, but is here. We have the capital. We have the customers and the talent, but we will not lead if we cannot power it. By prioritizing infrastructure for high-growth sectors, strengthening federal leadership, enforcing interconnection reforms, and incentivizing high-impact transmission, these policies can unlock the power system needed to support America's digital future. Vantage is prepared to invest and deliver. We bring development and operational expertise, capital, and long-term commitments to the communities where we build. Let us work together to build an energy delivery system that is ready to meet the scale and the importance of this moment. Thank you for the opportunity to share our experience. I look forward to your questions and working together on solutions that can keep the United States at the forefront of digital infrastructure, innovation, and investment. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Tench follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Tench. Mr. Gramlich. STATEMENT OF ROB GRAMLICH, PRESIDENT, GRID STRATEGIES LLC Mr. Gramlich. Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify. My name is Rob Gramlich. I am founder and President of Grid Strategies. We are a power sector transmission and power markets consulting firm based here in the DC area. Thank you for doing this hearing. This is about one of the most important topics facing the country before one of the most--if not the most--important legislative committee. Power demand growth is sudden and significant, and it will be a challenge to meet, and affordability is equally important, as I am sure you are hearing from your constituents. I will focus now on how we can meet demand growth affordably. Basically, we need both transmission and generation. I am going to start with transmission because that is the one that is largely in federal jurisdiction and has a federal role, while generation is largely reserved for the states under the Federal Power Act. Transmission is also the main thing we need right now. It has the highest impact. It is the great integrator of all resources. It may seem like it's a renewable energy piece of infrastructure, but that is just because over the last five years, that is all anybody was trying to connect to the grid. Right now, we are seeing a lot of other things trying to connect to the grid, including Jeff's data centers and data centers around the country, other large loads, manufacturing, and other types of generation. And whether it is nuclear, CCS, or other types of generation, guess what--it is going to face that same constrained grid. So we should really focus on the grid. Transmission is also a great deal for consumers. The economies of scale are massive. There is a 75 percent discount if you do it at the higher voltage, like 765-kV lines, as opposed to 230, like four regions are doing. Transmission can also help in the 2020s. It's not just the 2030s or 2040s option. There are a lot of ways to expand transmission. Some lines are actually quick, and there are advanced transmission technologies and other ways to use existing corridors. Transmission supports reliability and resilience more than any other resource. The availability of transmission lines is 99.85 percent or above for all voltage classes, meaning it is much more available than any type of generation. With severe weather events in recent years, we have seen tens of gigawatts, like up to 10 percent of a region's power, served from large-scale movements of power across the regions of the country because of interregional transmission, which is why Congress directed the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) to study interregional transmission, which it did, and it found we have a need for 35 new gigawatts of interregional transmission. The U.S. is falling far behind its competitors. China is doing 80 times what we are doing here on high-voltage transmission. So I do think transmission really should be the bipartisan and the unifying force that commands Congress's attention. But in addition to transmission, we do certainly need to expand generation as well. There are three general types. There is, low-cost, plentiful energy. There is the fast, flexible balancing type of generation. And then there is firm power. So I am not saying all resources provide all of these things. We do need firm power to meet peak loads. Resources provide varying levels of contributions to meeting peak loads. Nuclear has the highest contribution at 95 percent, but we're not able to get much more very soon. Gas CTs, at least according to PJM, are around 60 percent in terms of their ability to serve peak loads. Combined cycle is a little higher--in the 70s. Offshore wind is actually 69 percent. And so, none of these resources are perfect, but the point is, when you put them all together on the integrated grid, that is how you get nearly 100 percent reliability of the power system--by way of flexible loads, flexible data centers, and other loads to help alleviate the need for that capacity. The good news is, we have two working processes in this country to get the generation we need. We have utility-owned planning--sort of regulatory planning under states, and we have some regions with markets. It's up to the state whether they want to be in a market or have planning. It turns out, both are working. Older plants are staying online longer than anybody thought, and new plants are coming in, both in the integrated resource planning context and in the market context. Look at the PJM prices that came out yesterday. Markets are screaming for generation to either stay on or be added, and that is working. The interconnection queues do need some improvement to get those there. So in my final 20 seconds, what can Congress do here? I really would focus on transmission. I have some specific ideas in my testimony--regional planning, like FERC Order 1920-A, interregional planning, like this Committee's EPRA. By the way, congratulations on a bipartisan and decisive vote on EPRA last year. It had a lot of great ideas, and I hope that is a starting point for further bipartisan cooperation on legislation. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Gramlich follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Gramlich. Okay, we will now begin five-minute rounds of questions, alternating between Republicans and Democrats. I will lead off, followed by Senator Heinrich and then we will alternate between Republicans and Democrats in order of seniority, subject to the early bird arrival rule. Mr. Tench, let's start with you. In comments filed in response to the AI action plan RFI issued by the White House, Vantage noted its development of an onsite utility-scale gas power plant in Virginia to power a data center in that region. Can you explain why Vantage decided to use gas for that onsite generation? Mr. Tench. Well, the shortest answer is that we were left no choice. The planning cycles for our data center developments can sometimes expand multiple years. And in this particular case, we were subject to a change in the demand algorithm from the local utility. It had been planning on having allocated to us 100 megawatts, or MVA worth, of power to power our data center project there in Loudoun County, when suddenly, after we were under construction, we were told that power was no longer available and would not be available for five to seven years, at which point we had already committed hundreds of millions of dollars into the development project. So in this particular case, we were fortunate in the fact that our property sat on top of a high-volume, high-pressure natural gas line. And we scrambled and we designed, built, and commissioned a power plant operating completely independent of the grid within 18 months, and that data center is up and running with a very important customer of ours today. The Chairman. Great. And I assume you didn't go with others for various reasons. Nuclear would have taken too long. Why not wind and solar? Mr. Tench. Well, in this particular case, our option was only to be able to develop a power solution for that site that was not grid dependent at all. The Chairman. Got you. Mr. Tench. And that was the choice we made, and people may refer to that as island mode, but it effectively has no connection to the public grid. The Chairman. Right. But wind and solar wouldn't provide the---- Mr. Tench. Not in that particular case. The parcel was only big enough to handle a turbine plant, and there would have been no way to bring in wind and solar in that particular case. The Chairman. Got you. Mr. Huntsman, in testimony that you provided, I believe last year to the Senate Finance Committee, you argued that affordable, abundant, reliable energy is foundational to American manufacturing dominance. America has abundant resources like coal, gas, geothermal, and in some cases hydroelectric. We also have expertise to build advanced nuclear, which I am optimistic about as far as it becoming commercially viable in the coming years, assuming we can overcome the regulatory hurdles, which we are anxiously trying to do. Now, there have been some anti-growth forces, including environmental NGOs, that have helped capture many of our Fortune 500 companies--in some cases, big energy companies, in other cases, big tech companies--to endorse a net-zero framework. Now, I believe corporate leaders know that such goals and commitments are impossible to achieve, not to mention that they are harmful to many of the varied industries they represent. Can you elaborate on how the sustainability commitments harm energy affordability and reliability? Mr. Huntsman. Well, so many of these commitments have a longer-term objective, like we are going to be carbon free by 2050 and so forth. You would be shocked at the number of CEOs I have spoken to that have said, ``I don't have to worry about that, I won't be around.'' I can make the commitment today, but I am not going to be around then. There is no viable path when you look at, on a global basis, when you look at just replacing hydrocarbons with renewables. Again, renewables have a very important role to play in certain areas, in certain fields. We make the raw materials to go into the wind blades and solar panels and so forth. I am not anti any of that. I want to be very clear on that. But as far as the reliable, the reason why you are building gas turbines is because you don't have the reliability. Nobody knows if a week from today wind turbines are going to be turning or not. Nobody knows exactly how much power you are going to be getting out of solar panels a week from today. They can tell you what you are going to be getting out of a gas turbine. So I am more concerned about the today and how we get to the issues of today and how we get to the issues over the next five or ten years because that will dictate where we are in 2040 and 2050. And coming up with unrealistic goals that we just hope that eventually we will come up with some means or some mechanism just isn't plausible and isn't realistic. That's what we are seeing in Europe. The Chairman. So they have got their place, certainly, and there are good things that can be accomplished with those, but some of those areas, including those areas that are growing fastest within our economy, things like AI data centers, you can't really rely on that because it doesn't provide baseload power. What would happen if you tried to do that, whether it's manufacturing or an AI data center that needs consistent baseload power? What would happen if you had to rely on something that is intermittent? Mr. Huntsman. Well, you are shutting down. In facilities like ours, if they go down unexpectedly, they can take as long as 30 days to restart, costing tens of millions of dollars. So unexpected shutdowns--that is why I mentioned, I think, four or five times in my oral testimony the word reliability. And that is very key here. The Chairman. Right. And some of the emerging nuclear technologies certainly hold a lot of promise in that area, offering zero-emissions alternatives. Those are coming--not yet here in a way that is commercially deployable. Okay, my time is expired. We will go to Senator Heinrich. Senator Heinrich. Mr. Tench, you may be aware the Department of the Interior recently released a memo that is going to require the Secretary to review all wind and solar projects on federal lands. It adds just one more layer of red tape. Do you have an opinion on what the potential business impacts are of energy projects being delayed in that regulatory process--how further delays impact the business prospect? Mr. Tench. Our observation and our requirement is for more electrons, as you called out in your opening remarks. Vantage is relatively agnostic as to the source of those electrons. So in the case of rulemaking or regulatory action that slows down the process of approving new generation or new transmission, that would definitely be a negative for our business. Senator Heinrich. In the sort of five-year window, like 2025 to 2030, shouldn't we be focused on putting as many electrons, agnostic of generation source, on the grid as possible to be able to meet the kind of demand that you represent? Mr. Tench. Yes. Our position is that efforts to move electrons around through enhanced transmission is important. Necessary, but insufficient---- Senator Heinrich. Sure. Mr. Tench [continuing]. Relative to the overall demand. We need more energy---- Senator Heinrich. More generation and---- Mr. Tench. More generation and we need more transmission, independent of source. That said, it does need to be a reliable, you know, grid-dispatchable source, which I believe can be accomplished with the right combination of energy source for generation and energy storage. Senator Heinrich. And storage. You know, one of my concerns is, we have an existing pipeline that is the result of decisions that have been made over the course of the last decade. That pipeline is 95 percent clean energy plus storage. It's about five percent gas. You know, a year or two ago, we had a couple of nuclear plants come online, which are great. I support that, but that's kind of a one-off. You know, in the next five years, if we start building new nuclear today, whether that's SMRs or traditional light- water reactors, that is going to take longer than the five-year window. If I order a combined-cycle natural gas turbine today, it's probably going to come on the grid in 2032 or 2033, if we are lucky. So if you don't allow the existing projects that are in the queue today that are renewables plus storage, what does that do to the price pressure on the grid? What's the impact of that? Mr. Tench. As it relates to price pressure, I will probably defer to Rob on that question as more of a grid expert, but in the broader context, you know, our goal is to encourage speed and change in the regulatory process to bring more electrons onto the grid. And again, you know, depending upon the site we are developing, our access to proximate energy sources varies, and we are being very pragmatic about how we approach that, making available to ourselves whatever we can in order to meet the demand. Senator Heinrich. Mr. Gramlich, do you want to address the price pressure issue? Mr. Gramlich. Sure, I mean, basically, it's supply and demand. There is scarcity of generation, so anything that is limiting new generation from coming on, whether it's interconnection queues, permitting holdups at Interior, or anything else, that is cutting off supply, and that is definitely raising prices and---- Senator Heinrich. We are actually seeing prices go up as a result. Mr. Gramlich. We are seeing prices go up. Wholesale power prices are going up. Those higher costs are required to be incorporated by state public utility commissions into retail bills. So retail consumers/voters are paying more. Senator Heinrich. Are there places where prices have actually come down in recent years that you can point to, and what was the reason why those prices came down? Mr. Gramlich. Sure, well, I mean, if you just look at, say, the supply stack for someplace like Texas. Texas, just over the last couple of days, has had a majority of their peak demands-- not just overnight, not just winter, but peak afternoon air conditioning-driven demand served by a majority renewables plus storage. Senator Heinrich. And were there rolling blackouts? Mr. Gramlich. There were not. Reliability---- Senator Heinrich. Has reliability gone up, or---- Mr. Gramlich. You probably heard about rolling blackouts in California like five years ago. Honestly, they got behind on resource adequacy, but what did they do? They built a lot of solar and batteries. So same dynamic there. I am sure we are seeing a majority renewable energy. Any hour now, it's going to kick in and then, you know, when the air conditioning load this afternoon is high, there is going to be solar, and then the sun will set. Air conditioning load will still be high, but the batteries will then kick in and serve through the evening. So again, they don't do everything---- Senator Heinrich. One last question, because I am running out of time here, Mr. Gramlich. What could we do, as the Congress, to improve the interconnection queue process? Because that is preventing a lot of resources, a lot of electrons from getting on the grid in a timely way to meet the kind of demand that Mr. Tench represents. Mr. Gramlich. Yes, so, FERC has been working on interconnection queues, and each RTO is kind of doing it in their own way. I think there are some great models, like the Southwest Power Pool, where it's more just a simple entry fee. You pay it, you get in, and you don't have to do a four-year- long study. Congress could encourage things like that, encourage FERC to undertake activities like that, and you have probably a couple of nominees coming before this Committee pretty soon. You could ask them about that. Senator Heinrich. I will. The Chairman. We will now turn to our colleague from Mississippi, Senator Hyde-Smith. Senator Hyde-Smith. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member. And thank you to all of our witnesses that have come to share your testimonies. It's great to have the resource that we have to you and I appreciate your willingness to do that. My question is going to be directed to Mr. Tench. You mentioned in your testimony that Vantage prefers to connect to the grid for power, obviously, but there may be a need to deploy outside generation at the start of the project, which makes sense. And as you point out, beyond company building schedules, adding to the grid can take a long time. It can take years, and usually taking around five years for the most traditional baseload power that you are looking at there. What short-term solutions has Vantage explored for initial builds, and do you think other companies would follow a similar pattern waiting to connect to the grid? Mr. Tench. In the case of Vantage, we have, coming out of the experience I described in Virginia, been far more planful in terms of the expectations of our delays as it relates to the interconnection that we applied for to receive load from the grid. And the form that it has taken, for the most part, has been in investing in a supply chain of turbines and reciprocating natural gas engines, which we increasingly plan to deploy at a mobile setting so that we can deploy them on trailers for, let's say, two years, three years, until we can get the interconnection from the grid, and that has proven to be an important part, but only one part, of our overall plan for how we make our way through the wait, if you will, as it relates to the electrons that we need. Senator Hyde-Smith. And you think other companies may follow a similar pattern to that? Mr. Tench. Well, I think that would be up to them, but certainly for us, we found it to be a way of reducing our risk and smoothing out the gaps in availability. Senator Hyde-Smith. And from a connectivity standpoint, what would Vantage's plan be once utilities meet electrical generation demand, once you get there? Mr. Tench. Well, our plan would be to connect to the grid and operate according to the regulations that exist in any of those states in terms of having a firm commitment from the utility through an electrical services agreement. And then, we would use that as our primary source of power to our data centers, coupled with emergency generation backup, which we deploy in most of our sites as well. Senator Hyde-Smith. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I will yield. The Chairman. Senator Wyden. Senator Wyden. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. This is an important panel. And let me begin by saying I don't believe we got in this predicament by osmosis. The fact is, the Republicans have been doing favors for their big oil buddies at the consumer's expense, and that is why--a major reason why-- energy bills are going through the roof. And I am just going to take a minute to look backward and then talk about where we ought to be going. We had 50 years' worth of gridlock on climate--no pricing, no regulatory reform, no nothing. In the Senate Finance Committee, we put together an alternative, and it was based on markets. It was based on technology neutrality. Underline those words--technology neutrality. Everybody is part of the market. You get choices. And the more you reduce carbon, the bigger your tax savings. And in a couple of years, we got hundreds of billions of dollars committed--committed--to making sure that we had those renewable choices. Now, along come the Senate Republicans, particularly in the last couple of weeks. And when the natural gas folks--these are not the environmentalists, these are the natural gas folks-- basically said, we will take electrons if they are from Mars. We have got to have electrons. We will take them from anywhere, not just because of AI, but because of growth, because of innovation. And regrettably, the Senate Republicans said, we're not for choices. We're not for options. We're not for alternatives. And of course, that doesn't let us meet the challenge of demand. So my view is, and what I am going to keep pushing for as the senior Democrat in the Finance Committee, is working with anybody across the political spectrum to get us more choices, and particularly, as my colleague from New Mexico said, the gas industry, not the League of Conservation Voters or the Sierra Club, will tell you that the cheapest alternatives now are solar and wind, and they need them today, not tomorrow. They need them today in order to drive markets. So apropos of your good work, Mr. Gramlich, I would be interested in what your ideas are to kind of resurrect a choice-based system, rather than one that just hands out the goodies to the big oil companies. And by the way, people tell me, and you all are welcome to add this, fossil fuels cannot meet our demand today. If we are going to meet demand, we need solar and wind. We need these alternatives. And after 50 years of gridlock on this issue, we broke up the inertia. We broke up the lack of progress. And we were making a lot of progress. And I want to see us get back to something that has as many of those choices, the technological neutrality principles that we wrote in the Finance Committee, because I think that is America's energy future. And by the way, nobody knows what the big alternatives are going to be 30 years from now. We need a science-driven kind of approach. And when we talked to Joe Manchin about putting this together, which he backed, he said we need more science, and we will get that with a technology-driven kind of system. So tell us about what you would be working on in terms of more choices for the days ahead. Mr. Gramlich. Well, Senator Wyden, thank you for your leadership on the technology-neutral tax credit. I think that is a perfect example of something that provides the support to any and all technologies that meet the performance standards that Congress can set out. And so, I thought that was a great idea. Glad to see it enacted. Sad to see the early phaseout. I think at this point it's important for Treasury to implement at least what Congress passed recently. Senator Wyden. So you want to make sure that there is no more stalling around because, as you know, we got a modest bit of the current system into the final bill, and now it looks like a bunch of people in the House are trying to roll that back. You tell the Administration, suck it up here and stand in there for choices and alternatives. Is that one of your messages? Mr. Gramlich. Certainty is critical for investment, and uncertain IRS regulations kill certainty. You can't invest if you don't know what the rules are. Senator Wyden. What else would you do? More choices. Mr. Gramlich. Well, I think, you know, generally, as I was saying before, the transmission grid really is in the purview of this Committee and Congress and FERC, and that is the great integrator of all resources that enables choice of whatever a state may choose, and generation---- Senator Wyden. Good. My time is up. That was the one thing that we weren't able to get in the 2022 election, and had we been able to negotiate a compromise with more choices, I would have put transmission number one as our challenge for the future. And we are going to try to get those choices back, and we are interested in working with you on transmission. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Wyden. We will go next to Senator Cortez Masto. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, all three of you, for being here. In many ways, Nevada has really led the way in developing new energy capacity over the last several years. And quite honestly, with the help of the tax credits in the Inflation Reduction Act, Nevada was able to attract new businesses hoping to use our natural resources, one of them being solar, geothermal, in the great state. I assume that's one of the reasons, Mr. Tench, you were there. And I am excited to hear that not only has Vantage pushed for new data centers to be sustainable by design, you are including an AI campus in Nevada, which was announced July 15th, that also seeks to use a closed-loop chiller system to minimize the need for large volumes of water, again, in the West, where there is a lot of drought. Can you talk a little bit about why renewables are important, depending on the region where your data center is, and are you using a renewable source for this data center and the AI in Nevada? Mr. Tench. Yes, we are, as you know, developing a substantial AI-focused campus in TRIC, just outside of Reno, and the selection of that location was driven by a number of factors, including its proximity to the West Coast, as an alternative to California, where things can get pretty expensive and pretty hard to do. At the same time, the mix of energy sources that were available to us through Nevada Power included, as you noted, there are prior investments in solar, in particular. And for Vantage, for our customers, again, we prefer to use grid, and the combination of total cost of ownership, the ease of doing business in Nevada, and the physical location conspired to make it a great location for this deployment. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Mr. Gramlich, you have outlined some of the challenges contributing to increased electricity bills across the country. In addition to severe weather and electric equipment constraints, you listed the uncertainty surrounding the current administration's tariff policy and the Republicans' termination of the tax credits. A recent Bloomberg Government article stated that when fewer renewables meet more expensive gas and explosive demand from data centers, an upward pressure on rates is the predictable result. Some estimates suggest that electricity bills in parts of the country could jump as much as 60 percent to 350 percent over the next decade. My question to you is, can you summarize current market considerations and why U.S. grid operators aren't in a position to turn away renewable electrons? Mr. Gramlich. Yes, grid operators need all the power they can get, and as I have said, not all resources do all of the functions, right? So we do need firm power, and by the way, the geothermal in your state is providing excellent clean firm power, and I really am hopeful about geothermal going in many more states to provide that clean firm power, but the grid operators do depend on it, and in terms of affordability, it's supply and demand. If we take any of these resources out of the mix, that just leads to higher wholesale prices, and those necessarily move down into retail customers' electric utility bills. Senator Cortez Masto. And shouldn't the states, working with the private sector, basically determine what that energy mix or that portfolio should be based on their geography, based on their opportunities there? I mean, we have geothermal. We have solar. We have wind. We have battery storage. We have natural gas. That's different than my colleague here sitting to my left, from Maine. So shouldn't it be driven by that need, based on the states where their region is, what the private sector is wanting to build there? Does that make sense? Mr. Gramlich. I think that's exactly right. Well, that's the structure of the Federal Power Act that you all oversee on this Committee and its implementation at FERC. Generation is largely in the purview of states. I mean, it's kind of a states' rights issue. And so, this micromanaging of individual power plant dispatch through things like Department of Energy emergency orders, or, you know, specific targeting of projects for not getting permitting at Interior--that is really micromanaging from the federal level something that really is the states' job to address. Senator Cortez Masto. And if we are going to compete with other countries like China and others, and grow out our grid and our transmission and really invest in it, that micromanagement shouldn't occur. It really should be driven from the states, the private sector on, correct? Mr. Gramlich. That's right. And I mean, the reality is, we have a very diverse electric industry structure. Your state has one structure. It's very different in Maine and other states. And so, each state uses markets or regulation or various combinations of investor-owned and other types of utilities to meet their power demand needs. And that is where the process should take place. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Senator King. Senator King. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The word transmission has come up numerous times today and how important it is, and what a great important part it is of this discussion. Unfortunately, this morning, the Department of Energy terminated a loan program for a major interregional transmission system in the Midwest. [Department of Energy press release follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator King. So here we are talking about how important transmission is, and here's the Department of Energy, and it wasn't a grant, it was a loan guarantee program. I just think the timing is somewhat ironic. We all know that solar and wind are intermittent. We understand that. Everybody knows that. I was in the hydro business. That's also intermittent. It doesn't always rain, as well as wind and biomass and large-scale conservation. But what's really happening is really dramatic in terms of energy storage. If you have adequate energy storage, solar and wind are baseload, because you have something to make up the difference. And I used AI in your honor, Mr. Tench, to check on where we are on batteries. As of five minutes ago, the U.S. added a record 10.4 gigawatts of utility-scale battery storage in 2024, marking a 66 percent increase from the prior year. In 2025, the EIA anticipates a record-setting year, with another 18 gigawatts of utility-scale battery storage on the grid. Looking ahead, the EIA forecasts that U.S. utility-scale battery storage will nearly double, reaching 65 gigawatts by the end of 2026. In other words, the battery industry is no longer a fantasy or a distant dream. It's happening right now on a very substantial scale. And as you point out, Mr. Gramlich, it saved the day in Texas and in California, and it's already working--the idea of the integration of batteries with solar and wind. Let me talk for a minute though about transportation. And Mr. Gramlich, this is what worries me. It used to be an electric bill in Maine was 25 percent transmission and distribution and 75 percent source of energy. It's now about 50/50, and transmission is getting more and more expensive. Everybody knows we have to rebuild the grid. My concern is, it's going to be done in an expensive way that's going to add dramatically to ratepayers' costs. Mr. Gramlich, you are nodding. I take it you agree. The record doesn't show nodding. Mr. Gramlich. Absolutely. We are doing transmission in sometimes the most expensive way possible now and we could change that. Senator King. Well, one way to change it is reconductoring. Here is a conventional electric line, a high-tension conductor. Here is a carbon fiber-based conductor. This little guy will carry twice the energy as this one. [Photograph of the two conductors follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator King. So if we put these on the grid, we don't need to change all the poles, the rights-of-way, all of that kind of thing, and we can get a significant amount of additional throughput in the grid at a fraction of the cost of rebuilding the whole system. The same with--you are familiar with the term GETs--the various technologies that enable the grid to be managed more efficiently in terms of temperature and load and all those kinds of things. The estimates I have seen is that reconductoring and GETs could increase throughput on the grid by something like 40 percent, at a fraction of the cost of rebuilding. My concern is that the rate-based model encourages utilities to build rather than to reconductor or use GETs. Mr. Gramlich, talk to me about how we solve that problem. How do we provide incentives for those who will be rebuilding the grid to do so in the most cost-effective way and to minimize the effect on the ratepayers? Mr. Gramlich. Yes, well, and I would note, that cable that you are holding is manufactured near Los Angeles, but unfortunately, 90 percent of that company's sales go to other countries, which are deploying advanced conductors and grid- enhancing technologies in far greater levels than we are here. Senator King. Is that partially because there is no incentive on our utilities to use this kind of technology? Mr. Gramlich. I think that is generally right. I think a lot of utilities are actually looking at them now, but we need to get beyond pilot stage to make it more systematic. Senator King. And another factor we haven't talked about is demand response. That is, the ability of customers to modify their demand load in terms of what's on the grid. Is that a promising technology? Mr. Gramlich. That is a very promising technology, and it's not just sort of the peak hour, but think about flexible data centers. Sometimes there is some grid contingency that might happen once every three years, and if they can just curtail just a little bit at that time, then we can integrate a lot more data centers without having to rely on the full network capacity, which takes so long to serve that data center. So that type of flexibility is critical. Senator King. And I should point out, I know I have run out of time, solar and wind today are (a) the cheapest and (b) the quickest to deploy. And I am worried that, as the Vice Chairman has said, there is a five- to seven-year lag in new grid-scale gas turbines. We can't give China a five- to seven-year head start in AI, and we have got to be timely as well as control costs. So thank you all for your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Senator Risch. Senator Risch. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for being here today. This is a fascinating subject, really, to dig into. I have to tell you, in recent years, as I have sat in this Committee, we have had the people come in here and predict to us what was going to happen as far as demand for electricity in America because of AI and the other things that are coming on board, particularly AI. And I have to tell you, I was a doubter at the beginning, but the further we go, the more obvious it has become that we are going to be inundated with demand for electricity here in the next recent years. It's a problem, but the good news is that this particular problem, we know how to deal with, and that is, we know how to generate electricity. We, in Idaho, in 1951, demonstrated for the first time that nuclear energy could be used to create electricity and we have been at it ever since. Of course, we had the setback as a result of Three-Mile Island, which really put us a generation behind, but now I think the world knows there is a real renaissance going on as far as nuclear energy is concerned, not only in the United States, but also particularly in Eastern Europe, where they are trying to cut the cord with Russia. So I guess I would like to get your thoughts on this. You know, we are going flip the switch, hopefully, in the next year or so on the first SMR, which is really going to change the delivery of electricity in the world. And this August, we are going to cut the ribbon on a microreactor that they are starting at the INL in Idaho. We are very proud of the work we do in Idaho on nuclear. We really think that we have the solution to all of this. I really think that nuclear is going to have to be--and I agree that we want to be all-of-the- above--but I think to deliver the load, I really think it's going to take nuclear to do that. And I would like to get each of your thoughts on that. Peter, good to see you again. And your thoughts first, please. Mr. Huntsman. I believe that nuclear eventually will be able to fill that baseload, but look, I just, I will be honest with you. I am the only one that sitting here at this table that pays a power bill of over a quarter of a billion dollars a year. That's my gas and electric bill in my company. We can talk all we want about all these renewables and so forth and solar and wind. The fact of the matter is, it's failing in Europe, where it has been implemented on a widespread basis, it is failing. And the prices are going up through the roof. We can't afford it. We are shutting down facilities. We are laying off people. And we talk about these--especially in the State of Texas, we have spent hundreds of millions of dollars a year manufacturing in the State of Texas. The State of Texas's entire baseload is natural gas and nuclear and petroleum-based projects. The incremental piece that is renewable is wonderful. Again, I am not opposed to that, but without the baseload, we couldn't afford to buy electricity in Texas. And the only way we are able to compete today is because of the hydrocarbon-based energy sources. That's just the reality of all of this. Eventually, somebody has got to pay for all this stuff. Senator Risch. Well, the fact that the utilities now are really kindling a lot of interest in nuclear, does that give you any solace going forward? Mr. Huntsman. Not a great deal. Personally, I am very concerned about where a lot of this stuff is going. When I see how much of this is renewable coming off--for every windmill that is built--again, this is our product--but for every windmill that is built, you have got to build a backup to it because 70 percent of the time it's not going to be turning. So you have got to have a backup that most of the time is going to be idle. So therefore, I am paying for two systems. If I have wind, solar, and backup, I am paying for three systems. Senator Risch. Not a problem with nuclear. Mr. Huntsman. Not a problem with nuclear, no, but again, I think we are probably ten-plus years away from having mass- scale nuclear power. Senator Risch. Mr. Tench. Mr. Tench. You know, as I think about our fleet across the United States, we are fortunate to be operating data centers in places where part of the grid power we take down is nuclear. We are big proponents of further investment and acceleration of nuclear power, both as a complement to the entire grid, as well as some of the emerging technologies around SMR. I hope you are right about in the next couple of years us seeing the first commercially viable solution for that, but I think nuclear is absolutely a big part of the solution here. Senator Risch. Mr. Gramlich. Mr. Gramlich. Yes, I have not seen a change in public perception about a technology ever as much as we have with nuclear, which, because so many people motivated by the climate crisis want clean power, and I think everybody who is looking at the grid also realizes, we do need firm power. So that is a clean firm source that could make a great contribution. Senator Risch. Well, take heart, Idaho is here to help you. We've got the SMR that we developed there and moving forward, and we are really excited about the micro that's coming. Those two things are just going to change the world, I think, as they develop them and as they prove them out in the marketplace and as they interest utilities in being able to get what will be a new wave, I think, of how they produce nuclear energy. My time is up. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Hickenlooper, you are up next. Senator Hickenlooper. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Tench, let me start with you. I think we all agree with you that we have got to win the AI race. And it's not just our economic future, it's our national security that's at stake there. In your testimony you highlighted the importance of high-voltage transmission, noting that, and I will quote, ``Enabling the transfer of electricity between regions can lower operational costs for data centers and other large users.'' Without action from this Administration and this Congress to accelerate high-voltage transmission development, will the U.S. stay globally competitive in the AI race? Mr. Tench. I don't think we can say definitively that without interregional transmission we will fail to be globally competitive. What I can say is that our ability to move electrons seamlessly across this country in between these regions will free up access to power where it's needed, and it allows us to build the data centers that contain the AI that we are all scrambling for here in terms of being able to stay competitive. So it is one part--and an important part, I think--of a change we can make in order to make better use of the grid that we have, but it is not, in and of itself, sufficient to avoid the outcome you are describing. Senator Hickenlooper. Well, let me rephrase it then. Would you agree that the probability of our losing ground in the race toward AI, the probability that we are going to lose ground increases if we don't address this issue within the grid? Mr. Tench. Yes. Senator Hickenlooper. Good. And would you believe that any bipartisan or administration-led permitting reforms aimed at supporting data centers should also include some of these ambitious reforms to building that high-voltage transmission? Mr. Tench. Yeah, I would agree with that, yes. Senator Hickenlooper. Great. Mr. Gramlich, studies show that high-voltage transmission improves reliability and affordability, yet in the U.S. we have only built 3,238 miles of high-voltage transmission from 2017 to 2024. Experts say we should be building 5,000 a year. So that means we should have built 35,000, and we built less than 3,500. Meanwhile, China is rapidly building a super-grid of ultra-high-voltage that allows it to support growth on a variety of facets that we will not be able to match. In 2023, Congress directed NERC to study U.S. transmission needs. The Commission found we may need 35 gigawatts of additional interregional capacity just to ensure reliability. So Mr. Gramlich, can you explain in layman's terms the value of interregional transmission in terms of affordability and reliability? Mr. Gramlich. Sure, thank you, Senator. It is absolutely true that interregional transmission is one of the best ways to improve reliability and resilience. We sometimes see 10 percent of a region's power served by the large-scale movement of power across the country over that interregional transmission network. Unfortunately, none of us inherited a power system that is very conducive to that, with thousands of little vertical silos of utilities that don't have those horizontal connections, and our regulatory structure is only trying to catch up to that. So your work through EPRA and other efforts, other bills that you have introduced on interregional transmission, is very welcome. Senator Hickenlooper. We always appreciate the preparations that our witnesses make that make us Senators look good. We appreciate that. Senator Cassidy. It takes a lot of preparation for you, but that's okay. [Laughter.] Senator Hickenlooper. Thank you, Senator, I appreciate that. Also, Mr. Gramlich, I was going to put out--within all of this discussion we have been making, there is a hard truth that we need 100 gigawatts of power or more, really, by 2030, yet only four gigawatts of natural gas projects are even in the pipeline, and certainly zero for coal. So the market isn't buying what's out there being sold. What kind of state-level intervention studies and subsidies should Congress and the Trump Administration--what would we have to back, which they would be backing, to actually build that 100 gigawatts of new natural gas or coal capacity by 2030? Mr. Gramlich. Yeah, it's not really feasible to do it all with gas or, you know, nuclear in this decade isn't going to happen. Nothing against it, it's just not going to happen. Gas turbines are constrained, as Senator Heinrich mentioned. You just can't get one to get in line. So we really have to, just as a physical matter, we have to rely on many sources, all of those sources that are being developed, and that certainly includes wind, solar, and battery storage. Senator Hickenlooper. Great, thank you. So what you are saying is that we need to take those things that are in the queue and are ready to be built, even though they're not going to be sufficient to provide a baseline, that I think there is a consensus that we need to raise the baseline, or the baseload capacity. We need to build everything we can right now. Mr. Gramlich. Yes. Senator Hickenlooper. Great, thank you. I yield back to the Chair. Senator Cassidy [presiding]. Mr. Huntsman, in your testimony--now first, as context, I have seen that the GDP of Europe over the last 20 years, which was roughly equal 20 years ago to the U.S.--collective GDP--has flattened out and ours has grown. Now, there is a relationship we all know between power usage and with economic growth. You speak about the deindustrialization of Germany and how no rational executive would now invest in Germany, which is incredible. Can you expound on that? Because that would have incredible impacts upon jobs for working Germans, just like having a similarly wrongheaded policy in the U.S. would have incredibly negative implications for working Americans. Mr. Huntsman. Yeah, as somebody who has done business in Germany for 40 years, we have never had power outages in Germany. It's just not a question of availability of electrons, it is a question about the value of electrons. And in Germany, I'm paying for coal, I'm paying for solar, I'm paying for wind, I'm paying for nuclear from France, and I'm paying for imports of gas coming in from the United States. I am paying for five sources. At best, two of those sources are actually operating and supplying our facilities. But I am paying for all five of them. I mean, that literally--and you add on to that the regulatory, the carbon taxes, and the costs above that, and I am paying roughly about six times more for electricity. For exactly the same facility in your State of Louisiana, we operate a very large facility in Geismar, Louisiana, and we operate virtually the same facility---- Senator Cassidy. So how many people did you employ at peak in Germany? Mr. Huntsman. In Europe, across Europe was about 6,500. Senator Cassidy. At peak? Mr. Huntsman. At peak. Senator Cassidy. And where are you now? Mr. Huntsman. Just over a thousand. Senator Cassidy. And so, the implications are that if you get your regulatory policy and if you get your electricity policy or your power policy wrong, then people disinvest, de- invest, and then you end up with working families losing their livelihood. Mr. Huntsman. Not just ours, but our customers, our suppliers, the entire supply chain. Senator Cassidy. I once heard you say, going to another portion of your testimony--intriguing conversation--you are suggesting that the chemical industry may be more carbon- intensive but the downstream effect is to decrease carbon intensity. You use the example of using carbon fiber instead of steel in a plane. I can imagine how much fuel that saves in a plane. But I can imagine that the carbon-intense carbon fiber, by definition, may be a little bit more carbon-intensive to produce, or at least roughly equal. But it saves you more in life cycle. Mr. Huntsman. That's right. Senator Cassidy. Can you elaborate on that? Because I think there are probably other examples. Mr. Huntsman. Earlier, the Senator, I believe it was King, that had the cabling--the wraparound of that cabling, of that carbon fiber, is going to be for the most part an epoxy material that obviously insulates a lot of that transmission. That's the same materials that are going in and lightening the load, lightening the transmission, making these things stronger. The Boeing 787 gets about 35 percent better mileage than the Boeing 767, the model it replaced, and all of that is virtually no aluminum, it's mostly carbon fiber and composite materials. We have, just our company alone, about somewhere between 17 and 18 tons of liquid material--glue, essentially-- that goes on each 787 or Airbus A350. That is lightening the plane. It is allowing it to fly further over the lifetime of that plane. You will be saving a hundredfold. Senator Cassidy. So even though, in the moment in time, in the snapshot, it may look like, oh, my gosh, emissions are increasing, or whatever is increasing at Huntsman, but if you take that product you are producing over the life cycle of its use, the global climate is better, if you are looking at it from the perspective of carbon. Mr. Huntsman. That's right. I would also tell you though that our carbon is actually coming down---- Senator Cassidy. I accept that too. Mr. Huntsman. From our manufacturing. We are getting the benefit of both, better and lighter usage on the customer side and also the manufacturing side. Senator Cassidy. Sounds good. Well, next is going to be Senator Padilla. Senator Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Cassidy. Excuse me, hang on. I have Padilla before Cantwell. That's the list given to me. It's up to you guys. You all work it out. [Laughter.] Senator Padilla. All right, well, if you don't mind because you were here earlier. Thank you all for your participation here today. I want to begin by talking about transmission. Obviously, the only way to meet our growing energy demand is by building out the necessary transmission infrastructure to get power from where it's generated to where it's needed. In the last Congress, I was proud to work with my colleagues on this Committee in a bipartisan manner, as we crafted the Energy Permitting Reform Act, which would have significantly advanced transmission efforts. Since last Congress, we have not only continued to see delays, but also consistent projections of load growth. And in addition to that, we have seen energy costs increase. So Mr. Gramlich, in your testimony, you talked about the need to improve our transmission infrastructure as a means to improve energy affordability. So I would love to see you expand on that and specifically discuss how building more transmission would directly increase energy affordability. Mr. Gramlich. That's right. Well, your State of California is now accessing resources in New Mexico, Wyoming, and other parts of the West, and what that does is, it's like a puzzle-- putting pieces together. At different times of day, different resources are operating, right? The wind from Senator Heinrich's state or the wind from Senator Barrasso's state or others are operating at different times than the solar in Southern California, right? So you put all these resources together and you get an overall much more steady supply that holds rates down and it improves reliability. So the transmission network is critical to making that happen. Your state has been leading in getting a lot of that transmission built. Senator Padilla. Do I hear you suggest that multi-state coordinating of the grid will improve affordability as well as reliability and even efficiency, with some emission reductions, as a result? I hear chatter among some western states around that concept. Mr. Gramlich. Yes, and that legislation in Sacramento is critical to get that regional network of an integrated grid, a seamless grid. Senator Padilla. As long as we get it right, I agree. Mr. Gramlich. That's right. Senator Padilla. So, to be continued. Let me also do a quick sidebar because I heard the Chairman in his opening remarks talk about some concerns in some quarters about solar and wind and other renewable energy and the concerns about intermittency, to which I just want to make sure we are adding storage to the conversation. If you look at California's capacity now, not just breaking records on the amount of our electricity that comes from renewable sources, but a huge reduction in the threat of blackouts, even brownouts, because of the stability brought when you add storage to the equation. In addition to storage, another technology that I am excited about is reconductoring. So I was proud to hear a couple of you talk about the benefits of grid-enhancing technologies and high-performance or advanced conductors in meeting our load needs. Rewiring our existing transmission lines with state-of-the-art carbon fiber or aluminum alloy materials has the potential to deliver as much as twice the current of the same size conventional steel and aluminum transmission cables. And what's especially exciting, it's by utilizing existing infrastructure and existing rights-of-way. So again, Mr. Gramlich, can you expand on how these new technologies, particularly reconductoring, can help us meet load growth in the future? Mr. Gramlich. That's right. Well, we all know how scarce rights-of-way are and how hard it is to get new rights-of-way, right? So we have these rights-of-way around the country that are a tremendous asset for this country. And so, if we can squeeze more power over those rights-of-way, which might be as simple as stringing up a new cable on the existing towers, or it might be a rebuild of the towers, but these advanced conductors and superconductors can really help to sometimes double the capacity right there. And then grid-enhancing technologies are more the operational technologies that Senator King also referenced. Those squeeze more, sometimes up to 40 percent for dynamic line ratings, for example. And these operational tools can create more headroom on the grid that allows more load to be developed reliably. Senator Padilla. So are you suggesting that with these upgrades, we can deliver more electricity more quickly than projects that are built from the ground up? Mr. Gramlich. Yes, and we are going to need both. We are certainly going to need new rights-of-way and lines as well, but creating that headroom quickly and much more affordably seems like a no-brainer. Senator Padilla. So the last question I have, and I will try to make it quick, I know my time is running out here. Obviously, I am proud to represent California. We are proud to be a policy leader on not just building capacity, but lowering our emissions footprint as a result. But California is not alone in investing and bringing online more solar, more wind. Can you name other states, maybe some not-blue states, that are similarly investing in improving their grid reliability and affordability as a result? Mr. Gramlich. Well, absolutely. I mean, the whole center of the country from Texas up through North Dakota has tremendous penetrations of both solar and wind. Texas, the last couple days, has had over 80 gigawatts demand. They are nearing record demand. And a majority is being met with solar, wind, and battery storage. They are using storage, just as you suggest, and just as you do in California when the sun is setting, that is when the batteries have charged up with all the solar power and then they discharge to keep the evening lights on. Senator Padilla. So renewables plus storage is not a Democratic agenda or a Republican agenda. It's just common sense. Thank you very much. Senator Murkowski [presiding]. Gentlemen, thank you for being here. These kinds of hearings before this Committee, I think, are so important because they remind us that an energy policy that really covers from Maine to Alaska and Hawaii and the parts in between requires a diversity, right? I come from a state where we are proud to be producing oil. We are proud to be producing natural gas. But our reality is that most of that is--most of the oil, of course, is sent outside. Our natural gas supplies in Cook Inlet are dwindling to the point where our utilities today are discussing how they are going to keep the lights on in the South Central region, where the vast majority of Alaskans call home. And they are looking to Canada for their source of supply. That is insult to injury to this Senator, who has been working so hard to get us to a place where our energy is affordable, reliable, secure, diverse, whatever you want to call it. It is a challenge for us right now. And one of the things that we have looked to, we have recognized that there is no one-size-fits-all that fits us. And so, I think we have--I don't know if it's fair to say that we have pioneered microgrids in Alaska, but we have darn well been leading in the country when it comes to how you take these isolated grids, because we have one grid in the state, and it's called our Railbelt grid. And it goes up about 350, 400 miles and it comes down. And it's not a grid, it's like a rope, and there is vulnerability in that rope. And so, this is something that, again, we are looking at ways that we can reduce our energy costs in the state that, unfortunately, experiences some of the highest energy costs in the entire country. And I think that is counterintuitive to so many people who think, well, wait a minute, you guys supply all of this stuff. Why are you not able to keep your own lights on? So we are a little bit of a conundrum. At the same time, we have got great opportunities. We would love to be a leader in data servers. It's cold up there. We have got cold water. It's all the right things for you all, but if we can't power it, we can talk about these advantages until the cows come home. We don't have very many cows in Alaska. But we need to recognize that there is more that must be done in recognizing the extraordinary diversity. Mr. Huntsman, I really appreciated your testimony. You talk about the risk of distorted markets. I absolutely agree. I think our challenge is that we don't have a distorted market, but we just need to have more on our Railbelt grid, just like we need on our microgrids. We were kind of pushed behind with this executive order that came out a couple weeks ago on wind and solar because we do have a couple projects that were going to be integrated into this broader grid that is LNG, it's hydro, it's a little bit of wind, it's a little bit of solar. Basically, we are piecing everything together as best we can, and now we see a pushback on that EO by taking away the opportunities for greater affordability and reliability. It reminded me that we have been down this road before. It was the late 70s where the government prohibited the use of natural gas for electric generation. Think about where we would be if we still had that policy in place. And so, we are back to this place where it's kind of dangerous to pick winners and losers. Just figure out how everybody participates in, again, advancing a portfolio, an energy portfolio that makes sense across the board. So I guess I would direct a question, well, to any of the three of you in terms of the importance of ensuring that our federal policies are not in a position where we are picking the winners and the losers. And I grant you, wind and solar have been the ``mature'' technologies for a long time--a long time. But we are now in a place where the Secretary of Energy and his Deputy are going to be spending a lot of their time over at DOI with a review of every individual wind and solar decision that comes before the Department. They have got a lot to do. I think that this is going to be distracting and taking away the time that they need to be working on some of the issues that all three of you have mentioned here this morning. Any comment on that? I have run my full five minutes. So that's not very fair to you, but go ahead. Mr. Tench. Well, real quick. Oh, sorry, go ahead. Mr. Huntsman. I would just say, to the extent that it adds cost to consumers, I hope they take a long time in reviewing those projects because there are a lot of companies out there and a lot of consumers that just can't afford these redundant systems and the higher cost to all of them. And I think we are losing focus here. When a Tier 4 data center comes online, they need 99.997. That means they are out of electricity--an Amazon center could be out of electricity for 27 minutes per year. They're not going to be relying on wind. They're not going to be relying on solar. That may be part of their system--a very small part of it--but for the most part it's why they are looking to buy nuclear facilities and so forth. And it's the consumers that are going to get caught up with this higher pricing and it's companies like ours that are going to get caught up with this higher pricing. So I am concerned about a lot of those. Senator Murkowski. No, I hear you. I just want to add one final point to this. I am dealing with communities, though, that if they can get 20 percent of their diesel-powered consumption offset by some incremental wind and solar, it's 20 percent that they're not spending. Mr. Huntsman. Totally right. Senator Murkowski. So we are operating in different worlds, I get that. I get your point. And I just need to make sure that you understand what it means in some of these really remote off-the-grid places. Mr. Gramlich. Mr. Gramlich. Well, I would just thank you for your leadership on the permitting issue, not just this review, which seems awfully inefficient and could take whole generation types off the table. But on the staffing, many of these permitting agencies for your state and others, have great staff, but they, you know, they need to be staffed up. They are trying to get permits issued, but they are trying to do it in a legally sustainable way. And if we lose staff at these permitting agencies, that is a real challenge for any of the infrastructure we are trying to build. Senator Murkowski. Very good. Mr. Tench. You made the comment a minute ago that it's not a job to pick winners and losers. You know, I agree. We are, in our business, we are simply trying to deliver for our customers the technology and the buildings and the infrastructure to drive the deployment of AI, the grid, and as we receive electrons off of it, it doesn't know what the source was. We have requirements in terms of availability. We have backup generation for those times when there is a problem with the grid. But anything we can do to encourage as many different sources of power to increase the total load that's available, along with the transmission of that load, you know, I think is a good idea. Senator Murkowski. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Chairman [presiding]. Thank you, Senator Murkowski. We will now begin a second round of questions under the same terms as the original one. Mr. Huntsman, I would like to start with you, if that is all right. One big tech company recently released its sustainability report sometime last week, and it shows that that company's carbon emissions rose by six percent last year in 2024, primarily due to the development of data centers and electricity consumption that goes along with that and other activities. Now, despite the rhetoric from some big tech companies and others about net-zero, the reality is that their business model, particularly the business model of those that are heavily reliant on big data centers, requires reliable power, affordable power, and oftentimes natural gas is the best option. In many cases, it is effectively the only realistic option. Can you discuss how Huntsman Corporation focuses more on innovation than sustainability as a means to achieve both economic growth and cleaner supply chains? Mr. Huntsman. Well, I think that in all of these supply chains, again, as we look at, particularly in the chemical industry, the innovation that we have is to make things lighter. If you look at just the science of something as basic as a water bottle. Think of the water bottles you pick up today. This is, unfortunately, pretty poor science right here, but most of the water bottles you pick up today, they feel like they are almost going to fall apart. That water bottle today contains about 15 percent of the material that the same application did 10 years ago. That's innovation. It's making the industry more efficient, it's lowering the cost, and it's better for the environment. And if you apply that same technology into the lightweighting of an EV, you are going to extend the mileage, and of a plane, you are going to extend the mileage and the fuel consumption. A long-range power cable, high-voltage power cables, again, being able to lighten that, being able to increase the capacity of that, depending on the insulative materials that are built into that cable. It's all about science and it's all about innovation. I would just note that when we talk about the battery and the materials that make all of this stuff, how much of that is actually being built and made and produced here in the United States? That's something that I think may be a topic for another day, but we import a lot of raw materials, especially on the mineral side and the copper side and all this from foreign powers and from foreign entities. And so, when we talk about the battery buildout and we talk about the long-term cable construction and so forth, a lot of this is going to require more construction and more permitting here in the United States. If we really want to domesticate and we really want to take advantage of this buildout, we ought to be building these raw materials in the U.S. as well. The Chairman. If I am understanding you correctly, you are saying for every widget that a Huntsman chemical produces, or every widget that someone else produces using Huntsman chemical products, something like this, for example (the Chairman holds up a water bottle), I will never look at these any more without thinking ``poor science.'' If you are able to innovate, you can produce the same number of widgets or even more widgets with fewer environmental impacts, including fewer emissions through technological innovation. Do I understand you correctly? Mr. Huntsman. I believe our industry does that as well as anybody, if not better. The Chairman. Mr. Tench, arguably, the primary issue that your industry contends with involves the availability of reliable power. According to some reports, there are some utilities that told data center developers that additional power to fuel data centers can take up to a decade to deliver. Obviously, that could be unsatisfying in that industry, which needs to be nimble and move quickly. What barriers exist within traditional utility business models to deploying large data centers at scale? Mr. Tench. You know, I am not an expert on the underlying business model for most of these utilities, but I can describe what I observe and the interactions that we have, and that is that when we begin our planning cycle, we will submit applications for engineering studies, which can take a year. They are then coupled with other developers that are looking to do similar things and, in some cases, we are all attempting to serve the same load requirement. So the utilities do have a difficult job in sifting through ten requests that may be for actually two projects that ultimately go live. Their response to that has been to require very significant financial commitments to even undertake the engineering studies. And again, those take a long time. The need that we have is speed and certainty as it relates to that power. And in our observation over the last five years, across the country, those two factors are moving in the opposite direction. The Chairman. So existing challenges coupled with the urgent need for permitting and regulatory reform sort of manifest to us a problem. We are kind of on the knife-edge of a problem, which, if we move in the right direction can help bring about needed reform quickly, and it can go the opposite direction quickly. And then, finally, I want to just make a point in response to some of the comments that we have had so far that puts some of the comments in context. As the Wall Street Journal pointed out earlier this week, ``the IRA,'' meaning the Inflation Reduction Act, ``turbo-charged subsidies for wind and solar in ways that distorted energy investment because the subsidies can offset more than 50 percent of the project's cost.'' It's a significant amount that ends up being borne by the U.S. Government and the U.S. taxpayer. Now, the claim that these tax credits reduce electric rates is, I think, contradicted, or certainly undermined, by experience. Wind and solar credits must be backed by peaker gas plants or batteries, which cost more than three times as much as baseload power. So the problem is not that there is anything inherently wrong with wind and solar being used to generate electricity. As I said earlier, they have their place. There are things that they can do. But baseload power is not something that they produce. And when you need baseload power, nothing else will do, and those don't provide that. Senator Heinrich. Senator Heinrich. I just want to make the point that in my own experience, because the thing I find most intuitive is to look at the power in my own grid and to ask the question, does what people are representing line up with actual reality? On my grid, we are only five percent coal now, and that's because coal is really freaking expensive. We are 23 percent gas and declining, but that's very useful generation. It's hard to add to because you can't get a turbine. We are seven percent nuclear, which is great. It's firm, it's baseload--if people like those terms. I prefer capacity factors, and it has got a really good capacity factor, but it's really expensive, really expensive. And then, we are 35 percent solar, 15 percent wind, and with just 15 percent battery storage and a little bit of geothermal, we are able to balance all of that with incredible reliability, and consumers will not compromise on reliability. But most importantly, they also like low cost. And in most of the country, the average--you are paying 17 and change cents per kilowatt-hour for electricity. In my grid, we are paying about 11--10.8, to be precise. So it is bringing the price pressure down and it is providing the cheapest new sources of generation to replace the older, more expensive sources of generation. One of the things we have to deal with here is these agencies and the role that they play in permitting new generation and transmission. So Mr. Gramlich, if our permitting agencies--for example, the Department of the Interior, which has added this new level of red tape, stall or slow-walk permits for generation projects, which we are currently seeing, and those permit projects, as a result, don't get on the grid or they get on the grid slower, what is the impact to people who pay retail electric prices? Mr. Gramlich. Sure, well obviously, that will raise prices. And what's happening is, you know, love it or hate it, many utilities with their state regulators have put in place plans for the next few years of how they are going to meet load. There might be retirements. There might be load growth. They routinely go through these plans, and just the reality is, it's largely wind, solar, and storage that are in those plans---- Senator Heinrich. About 95 percent in most cases. Mr. Gramlich. Right, to meet next load. So if---- Senator Heinrich. So if you take that 95 percent out, even some portion of it, say a third, what are you going to replace it with in year one, two, or three? Nothing. Mr. Gramlich. Curtailment, per load. Senator Heinrich. Curtailment, exactly. Why I said capacity factors is because I am an engineer and I don't remember a lot the terms and buzzwords that get thrown around a lot here now--firm, baseload, dispatchable. What I remember from my education is capacity factors, right? And if you look at generation today, you know, I have wind in my state that has a 40 percent capacity factor. It's not perfect, but it's pretty darn good. You know what else has a 40 percent capacity factor, Mr. Gramlich? Mr. Gramlich. The gas? Senator Heinrich. Coal, today, in the United States of America. Everybody says it's firm and baseload and it's not. It's not, because it's expensive and it's unreliable. And when you have a coal-fired generating station go down, the whole thing goes down. It doesn't go down three percent, it doesn't go down 10 percent--you lose that generation until that thermal plant is back up and running. So, in your testimony, you talked about the increase in demand over time. DOE also is predicting a similar amount, about two percent a year. But they are also claiming that there is somehow a hundredfold increased risk of outage, and this relates to the capacity factor issue if forecasted retirements occur between now and 2030, as predicted. What were the assumptions that went into that, that were baked into that claim? Mr. Gramlich. Yeah, I think the Department of Energy, I mean, they provided useful analysis with this report, but I think they vastly overstated the retirements of generation. And as I said earlier, we have processes, either through utility planning or markets. Senator Heinrich. And markets. Mr. Gramlich. Right, you know, to discourage or prevent retirements, and that's happening, but also on the supply addition side. There is a lot more generation out there that could come onto the grid, and I think the Department of Energy study understated that new supply. So if you understate supply, overstate retirements, suddenly you have a reliability crisis, but it might just be manufactured by those numbers. Senator Heinrich. Yeah, we certainly haven't seen that in New Mexico, and we haven't seen that next door in Texas. where they have a totally separate grid from ours, but they are bringing on lots of new sources of generation, lots of new solar and batteries, in particular. You know, transmission lines are such an important piece of all this because they do help us wheel power around the country. And it's hard to build transmission. It's why we need to actually do permitting reform, which this Committee did last Congress, but hasn't done this Congress yet. You know, I worked on one transmission line for 17 years of my life. And today, it has facilitated tens of billions of dollars of economic output. It has facilitated the largest renewable project in the continent's history, but it wasn't easy to get that done. If you create a system where the politics can change overnight, where, for example, a loan from the Loan Programs Office can be decided by politics rather than by metrics, what is the impact of that on reliability and on price pressure? Mr. Gramlich. Well, I mean, so many utilities have testified before this Committee over the years about the need for stability. They are making 60-year investments--6-0--and if the policies change 180 degrees every four years, they simply can't do that. So I think your point is well taken. We need some stability, I do think. FERC is a great place for a lot of these orders, as a bipartisan, non-partisan agency. For permitting, they could do more in that regard, but we need to get that regulatory stability for investment. Senator Heinrich. Thank you. The Chairman. Senator Justice. We will go to Senator Justice, then Senator Cantwell, then Senator Hirono. Senator Justice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Well, guys, you know, we have got some really smart folks up here. There is no question about that. And I am sure that you all are super-smart and I am very proud of your contributions to this great country in every way. And I really thank everybody out here in the audience and everything. I know you have family and everything, and we congratulate everybody for being here. Let me just ask you just simply just this--or make this statement: why do we continue to make this so much harder than it is? Really and truly. I am from West Virginia. And I am a new kid on the block and I have got a lot of white hair and everything. But I was the Governor of the great State of West Virginia for eight years and everything, and we did it with logic, and reason, and businessmen or businesswomen approaches and everything, and all of a sudden, we took a state that was flat dead on its back any way you can cut it, to prospering like you can't imagine in no time. We know in the energy sector today that a year from now or a year and a half from now, we are going to hit the wall like nobody's business. That is all there is to it. We know that. And we absolutely know the contribution of fossil fuels, and that if we had carried on and gone down the pathway of some that would say we want rid of all of it, coal is the nastiest, terrible, most terrible word in the dictionary, and so, with all that being said, we want rid of all of it, and what would have happened? Here is exactly what would have happened, you know, and there is no point in dancing around it. We would absolutely be deciding between homes and industry or homes and jobs because we couldn't do them both. There's no way. And you know it. We all know it. All of you all know it. So why don't get at trying to do something that is the right thing? We know what the problem is. My dad would have told me ten million times, son, you've got to first know how deep you are in the hole, but when you know the position you are in the hole, then we can try to get out of the hole. He would have also said, for God's sakes-a-livin', I don't care how hard you try, don't confuse effort with accomplishment. You know, we've got to achieve right now. That is all there is to it. So I would ask you just this, and this is the simplest thing I can possibly ask you. We all know we have got to have reliable. We know we have to have a regulatory climate that we can function. I mean, for God's sakes, we know all the answers. Why don't we just get at fixing the problem? But my question is just simply just this--from the standpoint of can you talk about the dangers of retiring all fossil fuels, whether it be gas or coal or whatever, can you talk about where we would be in this country today if we just decided, okay, that is what we are going to try to do, because I do know this--West Virginia-- 83 percent of the power in West Virginia comes from coal. I do know there are states out there that don't derive a lot of power from coal. I was the guy that said embrace all, but for God's sakes-a-livin', let's quit subsidizing one and making it unfair against the others. If it's not fair, let's quit doing it. You know, so talk to us about just what I just asked. Talk to us, please, and just go very quickly because I have only got a minute left. Mr. Huntsman. National suicide. Senator Justice. I love it. And I will tell you this, I was going to say this before we started. I love--and I don't know Peter Huntsman at all, but I love your bluntness, gosh almighty, because that's exactly what we need. We need to quit dancing around the ring around the rainbow. We need to absolutely do it. Now, go ahead, sir. Mr. Tench. Look, we are at the edge right now in terms of having the power we need. We are going to be running short. We need to preserve and add resources everywhere we can. Mr. Gramlich. All I will just say, I mean, your state is very different in its preferences than neighboring states and that is a good reason why states are largely in charge of generation choices and portfolios. So I don't think the Federal Government needs to be meddling right now in specific power plans. Let's leave that to the states. Senator Justice. Would we not all say, if we were all being really smart, we have a situation that could become a national security situation, and it's right at our doorstep. Would we not all say, for God sakes-a-livin', why in the world don't we just look at what countries of the world are trying to do right today? China is building a coal-fired power plant every day, you know? And I am exaggerating to make my point, but they're not doing it just for fun. I mean, they know how absolutely important power is. So nevertheless, I thank you for being here. Mr. Chairman, I defer. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Cantwell. Senator Cantwell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good to see you, gentlemen. I like the subject of affordable electricity. It has kind of built the State of Washington over and over again. And so, we have had a pretty robust conversation now with all of my colleagues from different parts of the United States about how to get there. I haven't heard the word fusion yet. I certainly believe that while we are talking about transmission capacity and various sources of energy, the United States continuing to be a leader in breakthrough technology is also a key component, very important to the equation. Maybe if somebody wants to address that. But I did, Mr. Huntsman, want to talk about the need for more electricity in the AI revolution, and particularly this issue you were talking about, the large amounts of composite material. I really did want to follow Senator Cassidy because it was a good lead up, being from the State of Washington and aerospace and the transformation that we want to see in aerospace with larger percentages of composite materials. But won't we be able to create some efficiencies by using AI and then making it more efficient in the development of these very lightweight materials, but also intensity in what it takes to actually produce them? Won't there be a feedback loop here that will help us? Mr. Huntsman. Absolutely, Senator. You are spot-on correct in that if you use the sciences of material scientists to lightweight anything, it's just a simple law of physics. You are going to require less energy to move that product, whether that end-item is an automobile or whether it's an airplane. And yes, AI is going to greatly facilitate the design, specifications, and the raw material usage to do these. What we also need to make sure of is that we have a permitting process in place. If AI can tell us that we can make this new product, and we have got the capability of altering our manufacturing footprint to make it tomorrow, I may have to wait three to five years for the EPA to approve a new chemistry. And that is simply not acceptable when you look at what we are doing with AI and what we are doing with material sciences. So you are spot-on. Senator Cantwell. Okay, so how do we accelerate that then? Mr. Huntsman. Well, it would be great if the EPA would follow the laws that all of you passed creating TSCA, which is, they have 90 days to approve a product or not. Right now, we have products that have been waiting for three to four years to get approval. I can build a facility in China in less time than that. If you are going to be building these composite materials, you are better off going someplace other than the United States because it takes so long. Senator Cantwell. No, no, we don't want that. We have a world demand for 40,000 airplanes right now. Mr. Huntsman. That's right. Senator Cantwell. We are about to go to a major transformation where instead of building 40 planes a month, you will be able to build 100 planes a month. But wait, only if you get this next phase of composite manufacturing or thermal plastics right. Mr. Huntsman. We are ready to go. Senator Cantwell. And so, and we want to see that. We want to see it particularly related to AI and large-scale parts of the airplane. Obviously, you articulated very well in your earlier testimony how much the current manufacturing prowess has given us some percentage--18 to 20, maybe even higher-- percentage of an airplane now with these lightweight materials, but the big move now is, you can build bigger pieces. And obviously, instead of taking hours to bake in an autoclave, you can do them in a large-scale press. And so, that's the thing in front of us. I was thinking a little more like, I mean, yes, TSCA, but a little more about what agencies or what other people do you think we need to get involved to get people to understand that AI, you know, we went to one of our national labs and were just seeing some testing that was done that might have been done in the past by individuals--a very repetitive, formulated process, very time consuming, probably would have taken, you know, maybe years, but certainly months, but it was AI and automated and they just ran 24/7. So they are going to get that chemical analysis done in a few months instead. That's what AI is helping us to deliver. So how can we communicate this in a broader way that we get more people understanding what the opportunity is? Mr. Huntsman. Well, I think if you make it applicable to the average person, for example, in cancer research, if you are able to apply AI, what if your cancer outcomes for cancer medications were to improve multiple fold? What if your prices of your groceries and so forth because of growing seasons and so forth and AI, what if that were to improve? I think you need to be able to--there is such a fear of AI taking my job. That needs to be supplanted with the idea that every technological advancement we have had in modern industry has benefited larger society. AI will do likewise. We need to do a better job selling that, both at a federal level and a state level, and at an industrial level. Senator Cantwell. We just, I know my time is up, but fusion, good idea to make sure we are keeping/making progress, right? Mr. Gramlich. I would say absolutely. That's an exciting opportunity. Senator Cantwell. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Hoeven. Senator Hoeven. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. So you all need a lot of power for your AI. How are we going to get more baseload on the grid? We keep adding variable-rate sources, and that is creating grid instability. You all want to use a lot of power off the grid. And when Chairman Lee turns his lights on and the lights don't come on, or he turns on his air conditioning on a hot day in Utah and it doesn't work because you are sucking all the power off the grid and we are having blackouts and brownouts, he is going to be really unhappy, and he has got a temper. So how are you going to get enough baseload out there to make sure that you not only can do all your great AI stuff which you have been talking about, but we keep the power on for everyone, all of our consumers that need it 24/7? And you can go in any order you want, but I would like to get your opinions on it. Mr. Tench. I would be happy to start. Look, I think what we have been talking about in the hearing is about ways in which we can ensure that we can gain access to the electrons that are already on the grid through greater levels of interconnection, enhancement to the intelligence of the grid itself, so that it can be more adaptive to load changes that are occurring. And again, use better the generation and transmission infrastructure that we already have. That said, it's not enough, and you know, our position is that we need to encourage as much new generation of whatever type as we can, including nuclear, including geothermal, et cetera. Senator Hoeven. Right, but if you don't balance it out, you are going to have instability, you are going to have blackouts. If you just keep adding wind power, or other variable sources, you are going to have problems. And it seems to me there are a lot of people who want to take coal off the grid and there are a lot of people that seem to have phobia about nuclear, and a lot of people don't want to allow any transmission or any of those kinds of things to be built. How are you going to break through that and get this done, because you all are bringing on a big-time demand for power at a high rate. And at some point, you know, everybody kind of wants to go on like everything is going to be just fine and they are going to have all their power and not kind of get the idea that we are going to have to do some of these things. How are you going to crack this mindset so people kind of put their shoulder to the wheel and say, yeah, we need all these things? Mr. Tench. Well, hopefully, hearings like this, where we are helping to inform folks like yourselves, who are in a position to influence regulation and the other agencies that are involved in this will help. But if we can agree that the ability for the United States to be dominant in AI technology is a matter of national security, which I think it is, hopefully that will rally folks around us applying our influence, our pressure, and in our case, our capital toward incremental sources of generation and transmission. Mr. Huntsman. Simple fact---- Senator Hoeven. Well, let me add one more thing before both of you, the others, you know, give me some thoughts, but look, nuclear is going to take some time. And we are going to have to change the way we build it to practically build it at some reasonable cost and a reasonable time frame, which, obviously, we are trying to do. Chris Wright and everybody is trying to do it. And we are going to need to keep baseload coal around, you know, for a lot longer. So we are going to have to start putting some of these things together. How do we do that? I mean, it's not just telling our Chairman about it. I mean, somehow, we have got to get folks to really understand and buy in to this program if you guys are going to get the power that you want for AI, because a lot of folks see the potential of AI, but a lot of folks aren't all that thrilled about it. Mr. Huntsman. I am not an AI producer. I am from the chemical industry. But if I have got a trillion-dollar balance sheet, I am always going to be able to afford the power. That's not a concern to me. If he's got a billion-dollar balance sheet, he comes behind me, and if he's got a thousand-dollar balance sheet, like the average household in America, guess who is going to pay the highest price, and guess who is going to get the incremental last bit of electricity? And that is the way it's going to work. It's a pyramid. And so, if you can afford it, and what we need to be doing is, you are absolutely right, we need to be building out the baseload power, which has got to come back to natural gas. That is going to be the cleanest. It's the fastest. It's the most economical means of having a reliable baseload across the board. And that's from our industry, because we don't have a trillion-dollar balance sheet. That's--we have been through Europe. We have been through all these continents that have tried seven different ways of making electrons and they are virtually bankrupt. It doesn't work. We know it. It's not a theory. It doesn't work. Senator Hoeven. That was a really well--that's exactly what I am getting at. I think folks have got to hear what you just said because that is going to be meaningful to them, you know? That was very good. And sir, any thoughts you would have? Mr. Gramlich. Well, I would just say we have heard a lot today about a balanced, diverse portfolio, and the power system is more like a basketball team. The point guard doesn't do what the center does and vice versa, and you need it all. And particularly in this moment of rapidly rising load growth, we can't be taking one of those players off the court. Senator Hoeven. Yeah, I mean, I just think folks need to understand what we have to do here. And I think how you all communicate that, how we all communicate it, really matters because we have got to get going. Thanks for being here. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Hoeven. Just to wrap up, I want to push back a little on some of my colleagues claims that renewable generation paired with batteries is somehow significantly cheaper and more reliable. It's just not borne out by the data. Renewables and storage have a significant scalability issue. Backup power is required and is needed whenever you have renewables and storage operating as a significant leg of the energy stool because it happens from time to time when they don't perform adequately up to the task when demand peaks. Now, this is especially true whereas is bound to happen with some frequency demand peaks for a period of time longer than four hours. Four hours matters because that is about the capacity of utility-scale batteries to hold power. So you are inevitably going to have times when the wind, the sun, some combination of the two, aren't doing what they need to do when demand peaks and then, at those moments, you have got to have something to back it up. Then, additionally, if we want to cherry-pick data, let's look at some of the electric power costs in different parts of the country. Louisiana's retail cost of electricity is lower than, say, New Mexico's. And its electricity mix is 76 percent gas and three percent renewables. Utah's retail cost of electricity currently stands at around nine cents per kilowatt-hour, and statewide, the grid runs on 77 percent coal and gas-fired generation. And more specifically, my local utility also has low retail rates, about ten cents per kilowatt-hour, and runs on roughly 60 percent gas and coal. So renewables and storage have a place. They are capable of helping do their part to make the grid more resilient and reliable, but scalability is an issue. We cannot forget the need for backup generating capacity. And if we are going to have two grids to accommodate all of that, it's going to get a lot more expensive, and that in turn drives a lot of the potential for our competitiveness, a lot of the demand for these things outside the United States, and we don't want to lose that race. This has been a great hearing, and I want to thank each of you for being here and for your testimony. All three of you have offered phenomenal insights, and I am grateful for the participation of my colleagues as well, who made some great points. This will wrap up today's hearing. The deadline for submitting questions for the record, any Senator who wants to do that must do so no later than 6:00 p.m. tomorrow, Thursday, the 24th of July. Senators will also have until 6:00 p.m. this coming Wednesday, July 30th, to add statements for the record to today's hearing. Thanks again to our witnesses and to all of you who participated. The Committee stands adjourned. Thank you. [Whereupon, at 12:05 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED ---------- [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]