Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] DELIVERING FOR AMERICAN CONSUMERS: A REVIEW OF FINTECH INNOVATIONS AND REGULATIONS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY, AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE OF THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ JANUARY 13, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-50 Printed for the use of the Committee on Financial Services [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLIISHING OFFICE 63-578 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= HOUSE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES FRENCH HILL, Arkansas, Chairman BILL HUIZENGA, Michigan, Vice MAXINE WATERS, California, Ranking Chairman Member FRANK D. LUCAS, Oklahoma SYLVIA R. GARCIA, Texas, Vice PETE SESSIONS, Texas Ranking Member ANN WAGNER, Missouri NYDIA M. VELAZQUEZ, New York ANDY BARR, Kentucky BRAD SHERMAN, California ROGER WILLIAMS, Texas GREGORY W. MEEKS, New York TOM EMMER, Minnesota DAVID SCOTT, Georgia BARRY LOUDERMILK, Georgia STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts WARREN DAVIDSON, Ohio AL GREEN, Texas JOHN W. ROSE, Tennessee EMANUEL CLEAVER, Missouri BRYAN STEIL, Wisconsin JAMES A. HIMES, Connecticut WILLIAM R. TIMMONS, IV, South BILL FOSTER, Illinois Carolina JOYCE BEATTY, Ohio MARLIN STUTZMAN, Indiana JUAN VARGAS, California RALPH NORMAN, South Carolina JOSH GOTTHEIMER, New Jersey DANIEL MEUSER, Pennsylvania VICENTE GONZALEZ, Texas YOUNG KIM, California SEAN CASTEN, Illinois BYRON DONALDS, Florida AYANNA PRESSLEY, Massachusetts ANDREW R. GARBARINO, New York RASHIDA TLAIB, Michigan SCOTT FITZGERALD, Wisconsin RITCHIE TORRES, New York MIKE FLOOD, Nebraska NIKEMA WILLIAMS, Georgia MICHAEL LAWLER, New York BRITTANY PETTERSEN, Colorado MONICA DE LA CRUZ, Texas CLEO FIELDS, Louisiana ANDREW OGLES, Tennessee JANELLE BYNUM, Oregon ZACHARY NUNN, Iowa SAM LICCARDO, California LISA McCLAIN, Michigan MARIA SALAZAR, Florida TROY DOWNING, Montana MIKE HARIDOPOLOS, Florida TIM MOORE, North Carolina Ben Johnson, Staff Director ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY, AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE BRYAN STEIL, Wisconsin, Chairman TOM EMMER, Minnesota, Vice Chairman STEPHEN F. LYNCH, Massachusetts, BILL HUIZENGA, Michigan Ranking Member WARREN DAVIDSON, Ohio BRAD SHERMAN, California JOHN W. ROSE, Tennessee BILL FOSTER, Illinois WILLIAM R. TIMMONS, IV, South JOSH GOTTHEIMER, New Jersey Carolina AYANNA PRESSLEY, Massachusetts MARLIN STUTZMAN, Indiana RITCHIE TORRES, New York BYRON DONALDS, Florida SYLVIA R. GARCIA, Texas ZACHARY NUNN, Iowa BRITTANY PETTERSEN, Colorado TROY DOWNING, Montana SAM LICCARDO, California MIKE HARIDOPOLOS, Florida TIM MOORE, North Carolina C O N T E N T S ---------- Tuesday, January 13, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS Page Hon. Bryan Steil, Chairman of the Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology and Inclusion, a U.S. Representative from Wisconsin...................................................... 1 Hon. Stephen Lynch, Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology and Inclusion, a U.S. Representative from Massachusetts.............................. 2 STATEMENTS Hon. French Hill, Chairman of the Committee on Financial Services, a U.S. Representative from Arkansas.................. 4 WITNESSES Ms. Jodie Kelley, Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Transactions Association (ETA)................................. 4 Prepared Statement........................................... 7 Mr. Kevin Lefton, Global General Counsel, Stream................. 24 Prepared Statement........................................... 26 Mr. Ram Palaniappan, Founder and Chief Executive Officer, EarnIn. 30 Prepared Statement........................................... 32 Mr. Todd Zywicki, Law Professor, George Mason University Antonin Scalia Law School.............................................. 40 Prepared Statement........................................... 42 Ms. Delicia Reynolds Hand, Senior Director, Digital Marketplace, Consumer Reports............................................... 73 Prepared Statement........................................... 75 APPENDIX MATERIALS SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD Hon. Bryan Steil: Chamber of Progress60112..................................... National Asian/Pacific Islander American Chamber of Commerce and Entrepreneurship (National ACE)........................ 114 Labor Council for Latin American Advancement (LCLAA)......... 117 UnidosUS Action Fund......................................... 119 Maxine Waters: America's Credit Unions...................................... 121 National Multifamily Housing Council (NMHC), the National Apartment Association (NAA), and the Real Estate Technology and Transformation Center (RETTC).......................... 123 Center for Responsible Lending (CRL)......................... 126 Hon. Bryan Steil and Hon. Maxine Waters: U.S. Black Chambers, Inc. (USBC)............................. 135 RESPONSES TO QUESTIONS FOR THE RECORD Written responses to questions for the record from Representative Bryan Steil Mr. Kevin Lefton............................................. 138 LEGISLATION H.R. ------, the Earned Wage Access Consumer Protection Act...... 141 H.R. ------, the Fostering the Use of Technology to Uphold Regulatory Effectiveness in Supervision (FUTURES) Act.......... 156 H.R. ------, the Financial Services Innovation Act of 2026....... 164 H.R. ------, the Model Risk Management Modernization Act......... 182 DELIVERING FOR AMERICAN CONSUMERS: A REVIEW OF FINTECH INNOVATIONS AND REGULATIONS ---------- Tuesday, January 13, 2026 U.S. House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial Intelligence, Committee on Financial Services, Washington, DC. The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:08 a.m., in room 2128, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Bryan Steil [chairman of the subcommittee] presiding. Present: Representatives Steil, Hill, Huizenga, Davidson, Rose, Timmons, Downing, Haridopolos, Moore, Lynch, Waters, Sherman, Foster, Pressley, Torres, Garcia, and Liccardo. Chairman Steil. The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology, and Artificial Intelligence will come to order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a recess of the committee at any time. Today's hearing is titled, ``Delivering for American Consumers: A Review of FinTech Innovations and Regulations.'' Without objection, all members will have 5 legislative days within which to submit additional material for the chair for inclusion in the record. Chairman Steil. I now recognize myself for 4 minutes for an opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. BRYAN STEIL, CHAIRMAN OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY AND INCLUSION, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM WISCONSIN Technology continues to revolutionize our financial system, from payments to newer applications, like earned wage access. Digitalization, cryptography, and artificial intelligence give consumers faster, cheaper payment, flexible access to earned income, and new ways to manage everyday purchases. These innovations have the potential to improve Americans' financial well-being by making their day-to-day finances more practical, predictable, and affordable. Historically, workers were paid when they earned wages, yet today, many workers in our economy go home without their earnings. Holding an employee's pay until the end of a payroll cycle is a relatively modern practice. Earned wage access helps restore this link between work and pay by allowing workers the flexibility to access their wages as they earn them. This flexibility can help families deal with unexpected expenses, from medical bills to car repairs, or simply pay recurring bills timelier. By providing timely access to earned income, Earned Wage Access (EWA) can help Americans achieve their financial goals and help businesses improve worker satisfaction, retention, and overall productivity. Importantly, innovations, like EWA and buy now, pay later options, often coexist and intertwine with traditional financial institutions. Banks and other lenders are vital partners with financial technology (fintech), providing liquidity and credit as well as access to infrastructure like payment rails. These partnerships provide more efficiency and options for consumers and create new products to enhance competition. Our financial institutions can also benefit from partnering with fintech companies by enhancing their offerings and allowing small and community institutions to deploy cutting-edge tools. As we explore the benefits of fintech innovation, we must make sure that our regulatory framework is fit for purpose. A well-functioning framework for fintech should focus on risks posed by specific activities, not the identity or business model of the provider. Fintech products that meet consumer demand and improve Americans financial lives should have clear, practical legal pathways for operation and strong consumer protections. By supporting thoughtful and balanced regulation, we can encourage innovation while ensuring consumer protection and promoting financial well-being for American households and businesses alike. Today's hearing will inform these efforts, and I thank our witnesses for their upcoming testimony. I will now recognize the ranking member of the subcommittee, Mr. Lynch, for 4 minutes for an opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. STEPHEN LYNCH, RANKING MEMBER OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON DIGITAL ASSETS, FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY AND INCLUSION, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM MASSACHUSETTS Mr. Lynch. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I also would like to thank our witnesses for your willingness to come forward and help the committee with its work. This hearing continues our committee's work to examine fintech innovation, including the use of fintech liquidity products, such as buy now, pay later services and earned wage access. This is an area of great promise and potential to overcome preexisting barriers and to expand economic opportunity if we include proper guardrails that assure necessary consumer protections. This hearing continues our work, and these products present an attractive source of capital liquidity to help people meet short term needs. However, some consumer advocates and other stakeholders have pointed to multiple consumer protection concerns associated with fintech business models that incorporate hidden fees, lack meaningful underwriting and are not subject to adequate oversight, and they may target vulnerable consumers with deceptive claims about credit building. With the use of these products surging since the beginning of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, our committee's work on this issue has become increasingly vital to ensure that the proper oversight and adequate consumer protections are in place. As ranking member of this subcommittee, I participated in multiple hearings to examine the proliferation of fintech-powered earned wage access services that enable employees to receive a cash advance on their paycheck prior to payday, often at an inflated fee or at the cost of a voluntary so-called tip. Whether offered through an employer or through a direct-to-consumer provider, this on- demand pay market has grown rapidly with employers and providers now advancing billions of dollars in wages to millions of employees annually. As reported by the Harvard Kennedy School in a recent study on the proliferation of earned wage access products, 40 percent of the people who have access to an earned wage access application through their employer use it at least once a week. Over 75 percent of respondents indicated that they were using their money to pay for regular bills rather than emergency expenses, with one typical user noting, ``It just turned into a cycle of always taking money out.'' Moreover, the rush fees, tipping options, and other hidden charges associated with certain business models--not all--collectively amounted to an estimated annual percentage rate of more than 300 percent in some cases. Similarly, a growing number of consumers are now relying on buy now, pay later services to make ends meet. With Federal Reserve data indicating that nearly a hundred million Americans used buy now, pay later at least in 2025. These services, which allow consumers to pay for purchases over multiple partial payments, are now widely available at checkout both online and in person, where a customer can opt into services and receive approval in minutes without a hard credit check. Despite purporting to offer free services, some buy now, pay later loans, especially longer-term loans, can ultimately be more costly than using a traditional credit card. The Federal Reserve reports that nearly one-fourth of buy now, pay later users did not make payments on time and faced later fees. Considering the proliferation of buy now, pay later, earned wage access, and other fintech liquidity products, the consumer protection and enforcement mission of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is more important than ever. Unfortunately, President Trump does not agree. The Trump Administration has undertaken unprecedented and unlawful efforts to dismantle the very agency that should be protecting consumers against fraud and exploitation in this very area, including the issuance of cease work orders that halted virtually all Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) enforcement supervision and enforcement functions, the abandonment of dozens of pending enforcement cases, and the attempted termination of about 90 percent of CFPB Agency staff. I urge my colleagues to defend the CFPB in the face of these attacks. It will help with the innovation that we all desire to see in this wage space. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I yield back the balance of my time. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. I now recognize the chairman of the full committee, Mr. Hill, for 1 minute for an opening statement. STATEMENT OF HON. FRENCH HILL, CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES, A U.S. REPRESENTATIVE FROM ARKANSAS Chairman Hill. Thank you, Chairman Steil, for your great leadership of our subcommittee. This hearing is really deeply personal for me. For the past 4 decades as a former community banker and investor, I have seen how technology has expanded across banking, sharpened competition, and broadened choices for consumers and financial products. Earlier, as a payment system innovator, I witnessed banks' strong demand for modern tools and how meeting that demand delivered real benefits for our customers across the board. This committee has long championed innovation and responsible partnership between traditional financial institutions and technology companies. That commitment is now more important than ever. We should encourage regulators to foster those partnerships, unlock innovation, and reduce unnecessary regulatory burdens. I look forward to the discussion today on how we can work together to promote innovation, strengthen competition, and expand consumer choice. Thank you Mr. Chairman, and I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. Today, we welcome the testimony of Jodie Kelley, chief financial officer of the Electronic Transactions Association; Mr. Kevin Lefton, global general counsel at Stream; Mr. Ram Palaniappan, founder and chief executive of EarnIt; Todd Zywicki, law professor at George Mason University at the Antonin Scalia School of Law; and Delicia Reynolds Hand, senior director of digital marketplace at Consumer Reports. We thank each of you for taking the time to be here. Each of you will be recognized for 5 minutes to give an oral presentation of your testimony. Without objection, your written statements will be made part of the record. Ms. Kelley, you are now recognized for 5 minutes for your oral remarks. STATEMENT OF JODIE KELLEY, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ELECTRONIC TRANSACTIONS ASSOCIATION Ms. Kelley. Thank you. Chairman Hill, Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Jodie Kelley, and I am the chief executive officer of the Electronic Transactions Association, or ETA, the leading trade association representing the global payments industry. Our members, from banks and networks to fintech innovators, process more than $57 trillion in transactions annually and power commerce for millions of American consumers and businesses. Today, I would like to make three points. First, digital payments are essential national infrastructure, delivering enormous value to consumers and small businesses. Second, this innovation already operates within a robust regulatory framework. Third, targeted Federal leadership, especially on fraud and artificial intelligence, can strengthen that framework without slowing innovation. Payments have evolved from cash and checks into a secure digital ecosystem that underpins daily economic life. Payments are how Americans get paid, pay bills, run businesses, and manage emergencies. Digital payments enhance affordability by expanding consumers' effective spending power. Credit cards, buy now, pay later options, and cash back rewards help families manage unexpected expenses and smooth cash-flow. In 2024 alone, consumers received more than $43 billion in cash back rewards. Those are real dollars returned to real household budgets. For small businesses, digital payments are now table stakes. Entrepreneurs can start businesses with a smartphone and accept payments instantly. Embedded payments integrated directly into business software allow small firms to manage sales, payroll taxes, and compliance all in one place. Businesses that accept digital payments see sales increase by 8 to 10 percent, and the efficiency gains are significant. In 2024, faster checkout and back office automation saved small businesses an estimated 806 million labor hours and generated $34 billion in incremental sales. At the national level, the payments ecosystem contributes more than $350 billion annually to gross domestic product (GDP) and directly supports approximately 2 million U.S. jobs: high-quality, good-paying jobs across every State. The industry continues to evolve through mobile wallets, peer-to-peer payments, embedded finance, and AI-driven fraud prevention. Artificial intelligence is now central to payment security. AI systems detect sophisticated fraud in real time, often before consumers are harmed, while reducing false declines and improving customer experience. Looking ahead, agentic commerce, where AI agents transact on behalf of consumers and business, offers real promise, but trust, authorization, and accountability must remain foundational. Now, this payments innovation does not occur in a regulatory vacuum. Payments providers operate under a comprehensive framework of Federal and State laws covering consumer protection, anti-money laundering sanctions, privacy, cybersecurity, operational resilience, and licensing. In addition, the industry has developed strong self-regulatory standards, including Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS), Europay, Mastercard, and Visa (EMV) specifications, and network-level rules. This activity-based approach has protected consumers while allowing innovation to flourish. While new legislation is largely unnecessary, two areas do stand out for Federal leadership. The first is fraud and scams. Fraudsters increasingly rely on social engineering and AI- driven deception. The payments industry invests billions of dollars annually to combat fraud, but payments are often the final step in scams that begin elsewhere on social media, through text messages, or over the phone. ETA supports enhanced cross-sector collaboration and legislation, like the bipartisan Taskforce for Recognizing and Averting Payment Scams (TRAPS) Act, to disrupt scams at their source. The second area is artificial intelligence. AI in payments is already governed by Federal consumer protection and safety and soundness rules. However, a growing patchwork of State AI laws threatens to fragment national payment systems. ETA urges Congress to establish a uniform, risk-based, technology-neutral AI framework that builds on existing laws. The digital payments industry delivers extraordinary benefits to American consumers, small businesses, and the broader economy. We look forward to working with Congress to help ensure payments innovation continues to deliver secure, affordable, and innovative financial services. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Kelley follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. The gentlewoman yields back. Mr. Lefton is recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF KEVIN LEFTON, GLOBAL GENERAL COUNSEL, STREAM Mr. Lefton. Thank you. Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and distinguished members of the committee, thank you for your time today and for the invitation to speak about earned wage access and its importance to consumers everywhere. My name is Kevin Lefton, and I am the global general counsel of Stream. In this capacity, I oversee the legal and regulatory functions for our organization. Stream is an employer- integrated, earned wage access provider operating across the United States, United Kingdom, EU, and Canada. In addition to EWA, we provide a comprehensive suite of financial well-being resources designed to enhance the financial health of our users. Stream, alongside many of our industry peers, remains a staunch advocate for thoughtful regulation that prioritizes consumer protection. We stand as an important non-credit alternative to the high-cost products that trap consumers in a cycle of debt. It is a fundamental premise of my testimony today that EWA services do not constitute credit, are not loans, and should not be regulated as such. EWA is a critical tool for frontline and hourly workers in all industries, including healthcare, hospitality, manufacturing, education, and many others. By allowing employees to access wages they have already earned but have not yet been paid due to traditional biweekly or monthly payroll cycles, EWA provides a low-to no-cost alternative to the high interest rates and high- cost fees of other financial products. We cannot talk about EWA without talking about the essential consumer-focused benefits and consumer protections of EWA's benefits and protections that are absent in credit and other high-cost products. EWA lacks all the hallmarks of traditional credit and loan products. Specifically with Stream, there is always a free option to use our service, and the nominal fee for instant access should a consumer choose to use that feature is typically lower than a standard automated teller machine (ATM) withdrawal fee. There is no interest. There is no underwriting. We do not pull credit reports or base access to EWA services on creditworthiness. There is no debt collection. We do not report to the credit bureaus or engage in collection activity of any kind. The service is truly nonrecourse, and no debt is ever incurred. If there is ever an issue, Stream does not go after the consumer. We do not sue them, and we do not report them to debt collections. The arguments that are often presented against earned wage access are flawed because they conflate a nonrecourse financial wellness tool with a high-cost lending product. Labeling EWA as credit ignores the basic reality that workers are simply accessing capital they have already earned. Applying a traditional credit framework, like an interest rate, to a non- credit product is misleading and, ultimately, harmful to the millions of hardworking Americans who simply want the option of having access to their own wages so that they can manage their own money when they see fit. Applying a traditional credit framework, like an annual percentage rate (APR), to a flat, nominal, transparent fee is also misleading and creates a false protection that would effectively ban a low-cost or free service. These arguments do not protect consumers. They limit consumer options and force them back toward the very high- interest and high-cost fees that EWA was designed to eliminate. A lot has been written about EWA, and there is a lot of misleading information out there, but here are the key takeaways I would like to leave you with about EWA. EWA is either free or has a nominal fee. There is no interest. There is no debt collection. There is no underwriting. EWA is a nonrecourse service, and, most importantly, there is nothing wrong with allowing American consumers to decide how and when they can access their money through a product and service they want and like. EWA represents a shift toward a more equitable financial system for hourly and frontline workers, allowing them to better plan for the future and manage life's emergencies with dignity. We urge this committee to support a framework that recognizes EWA as a critical non-debt solution for the American worker. Thank you for your time and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Lefton follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you. Mr. Palaniappan, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. [No response.] Chairman Steil. You may you want to check your microphone. Mr. Palaniappan. Better now? Okay. STATEMENT OF RAM PALANIAPPAN, FOUNDER AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, EARNIN Mr. Palaniappan. Thank you. Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Ram Palaniappan. I am the founder and CEO of EarnIn, and I am honored to return and contribute to the discussion on how financial innovation can improve the lives of American consumers. Paying bills and managing expenses is top of mind for people every day. Innovation helps with that by making pay more timely and efficient. Innovations last only if they actually make people's lives better and earned wage access is an example of such innovation. Its use is growing because of the real impact that it has on people's lives. EarnIn started as an earned wage access company and now also offers a modern payroll platform that is used by over 10,000 companies, along with consumer tools that make the way people experience their pay better. Today, about 1 percent of the people in the U.S. who get a paycheck use EarnIn to access all or part of their pay. The idea for EarnIn started when I was working at another company. I heard that some of my employees were struggling between paychecks. That surprised me because they were paid well. I spoke with one of them. She said she needed money the next day, and could not wait until the following Friday, which was payday. She had already worked the hours, she had earned the money, but payday was still days away. The issue was not how much she earned; it was when she got her pay. I could not get the payroll system to pay up for the hours that she had already worked, so I gave her the money that she had already earned, and we settled it when payroll ran, and I continued helping many other of my employees the same way, just as happens with many other small businesses. What began as a one- time solution has become a reliable way for people to pay their bills on time and avoid expensive fees. EarnIn started with the simple idea that people should have access to the money that they have already earned when they want it, not when payroll decides. Today, most employees are paid digitally, but these digital dollars move more slowly than any other digital product. You work every day, and then you are paid once in 2 weeks or maybe once a month. Just imagine if other digital products worked the same way. If your phone said type your text messages every day and it would send them out every 2 weeks, you would not use that, but that is how payroll still works today. The biweekly or monthly pay cycle is a relic of an outdated era that is holding back the benefits of efficiency and today's technology from the people who need it the most. By shortening the work- to-pay gap, EarnIn helps people manage everyday expenses, like groceries, rent, utility and transportation. We are proud to do this in a way that puts the worker first without mandatory fees, interest, or credit checks. Multiple independent research studies have confirmed that workers are better off when they have access to their pay when they need it. A study by researchers at the University of Oregon on over a million EarnIn customers found a sustained monthly increase of 11-and-a-half percent in incomes. That is about $335 on average. Users work more shifts, miss work less, and manage their finances better. Another study from University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) on a dataset from a different provider found similar results. Incomes went up over 10 percent. Liquidity acts as upward mobility with reduced overdrafts and no debt cycles. Behind the data are millions of real people. One customer, a government employee, has a side business making custom candles. He used to wait until payday once he received an order to buy his supplies. Now he uses EarnIn, and as soon as he receives an order, he buys his supplies. That has let him do more orders a month and increased his income. Another EarnIn customer, Rae, a Southern California mother and retail supervisor who is undergoing cancer treatment, shared that on some days she feels better than others. Payday does not always align with when she is feeling better, but EarnIn gives her the flexibility and peace of mind, allowing her to take her daughter out on good days without being restricted by paycheck timing. Earned wage access can be delivered in different ways, including through employer-integrated programs or directly to workers. The direct-to-consumer model means employees can access the benefits wherever they work. Today, EarnIn serves over 2 million customers, including many in public service, healthcare, education, and small businesses across the country. Notably, about 1 percent of House staffers use EarnIn. I appreciate Chair Steil and Representative Torres for their bipartisan leadership to establish a clear Federal framework for earned wage access, and I look forward to continued collaboration in expanding access to these innovations to workers anywhere. I am happy to answer questions. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Palaniappan follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. Mr. Zywicki, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF TODD ZYWICKI, LAW PROFESSOR, ANTONIN SCALIA LAW SCHOOL, GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY Mr. Zywicki. Thank you. Chairman Hill, Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and members of the subcommittee, I am Todd Zywicki. I am the George Mason University Foundation Professor of Law at Antonin Scalia Law School, the former chair of the CFPB Task Force on Federal Consumer Law, and co-founder and co-director of the Institute for Consumer Financial Choice at the Scalia Law School. The modern American consumer finance system is really a miracle if you think about it. You can walk into a car dealership today and walk out an hour later with a car. I mean, just think about how transformative that has been for the world. As Ms. Kelley mentioned, we can make payments anywhere in the world 24 hours a day--day, night, online, in person-- anywhere in the world. As Congressman Lynch mentioned in his opening statement, I think very notably, just think about the way in which access to innovation and financial services helped us to deal with the disruptions of the COVID pandemic and the ability of people to bank online, pay online, do all these sorts of things, as well as the alternative underwriting models that were developed for data when people were not getting paid and the like. Above all, it is really democratized access to financial services. Innovation, more than anything, has been a vehicle for including people who traditionally have been underincluded by the traditional finance system, and how did this happen? Choice, competition, innovation is, basically, what has happened: new entry, often obstructed, often blocked by old incumbents, but new innovative technologies. Thinking back to the development of the Fair Isaac Corporation (FICO) score and the introduction of computers, which reduced discrimination, which opened competition. Think about even the telephone and the way in which telephones allowed credit cards to be marketed across State law. Think about payments. Just think about the way in which technology enabled us to go from knuckle busters on credit card processing to always on instant verification at a checkout, and most recently, of course, the development of the internet. Some of these innovations were really just developments of a better way of delivering an older product, such as buy now, pay later (BNPL), which replaces old installment loans, or EWA as we have heard about, which helps consumers or employees get money from their employers. Sometimes they are totally new, such as alternative data and underwriting systems and some of the payment systems we see today. Regardless of what they are, one thing they have in common is they must have a regulatory regime that supports innovation and that does not block it. An obvious point is that the regulation must reflect the technology, as we said, whether it is the Supreme Court's decision, the Marquette decision, that allowed credit cards to be marketed across State lines more effectively, whether it was debt collection rules that dealt with the telephone and the fact that you could then make phone calls across State lines, but second, it always also requires the right jurisdiction to deal with things. We went from a period of local credit to a period of national credit driven by department stores and the like, to what we have today, which is nowhere and everywhere via the internet. We have to have the right jurisdictional bodies acting on a lot of these things. So, we saw in the 1960s and 1970s, as the consumer finance system became more national, we saw more national laws dealing with Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), dealing with debt collection and the like. The products that are the focus of today's hearing are a good example. These are products that are offered on the internet. They do not bear any relationship to local jurisdictional boundaries and the like, and so thinking about sophisticated and appropriate places for the Federal Government to regulate and to, even when necessary, preempt State laws, I think that are important. I am very pleased with a lot of the innovations and reforms in the regulatory framework of the past few years, whether it was the recent decision by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) to recognize national trust banks for fintech firms, whether it was the CFPB's actions with respect to some of the regulations that they did, the decision of the CFPB to keep the 1033 rule and reframe it in a way that is more useful. I think there is a lot more that could be done, and I think a lot of the legislation that is the subject of this hearing moves in the right direction in terms of opening up competition, national markets in a more resilient in more responsive, technologically based regulation. In conclusion, history teaches that consumers do best when we recognize their ability to plan their own finances and we give them choice, competition, and the ability to plan their own lives, and not substitute the judgment of bureaucrats for American families. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Zywicki follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. Ms. Reynolds Hand, you are now recognized for 5 minutes. STATEMENT OF DELICIA REYNOLDS HAND, SENIOR DIRECTOR, DIGITAL MARKETPLACE, CONSUMER REPORTS Ms. Reynolds Hand. Thank you. Chairman Hill, Chairman Steil, Ranking Member Lynch, and distinguished members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Delicia Reynolds Hand, and I am the senior director of the Digital Marketplace at Consumer Reports. There, I lead our work ensuring digital financial products work for consumers, not against them. Before Consumer Reports, I spent nearly a decade at the CFPB. This hearing asks an important question--is fintech delivering for American consumers--and I would like to make three points. First is affordability. Affordability is key for consumers. Americans are stretched thin. Groceries and rent cost more, and credit card rates are near historic highs. In this environment, consumers will turn to products like buy now, pay later and earned wage access to manage cash-flow. This in itself is not a problem. The problem is when they cannot easily see what they are paying, they cannot compare options, and debt stacks invisibly across providers. The CFPB's own recent data point on buy now, pay later shows that BNPL usage continues to grow. Consumers are now taking an average of six loans per year from a single provider, up 11 percent, and that is just one lender. Many consumers use multiple providers, creating obligations that do not appear on traditional credit reports. Simple guardrails, such as cost disclosure, lets people compare options, and other guardrails against debt stacking allow consumers to avoid invisible overextension. These are not anti- innovation. They are baseline requirements for a market that works. On earned wage access, we are glad to see the draft legislation before you contains real protections, like a no- cost option, disclosure rules, prohibition on late fees. However, we are concerned that the bill also categorically excludes EWA from credit law and preempts State authority. Under the Truth in Lending Act, credit is defined as ``the right to defer payment of debt or incur debt and defer its payment.'' If it works like credit, we should regulate it like credit, and by that measure, EWA is credit. Second, consumers need accountability, especially for new innovation like AI. AI is no longer emerging in financial services. It is embedded. It is approving loans, freezing accounts, flagging fraud, as mentioned, determining who gets access to products at what price. These systems operate at machine speed, and if something goes wrong, accountability moves slowly, if it moves at all. Consumer Reports recently surveyed over 4,000 Americans on AI in financial services. Three-quarters are concerned that AI could lead to unfair treatment. When consumers encounter AI, many also report negative experiences. Fifty-seven percent do not believe current laws adequately protect them. Consumers should have the ability to opt out independent audits, a simple way to appeal, and public reporting on accuracy and bias testing; in other words, transparency, accountability, and human review. The subcommittee is considering the Financial Services Innovation Act, which would create sandboxes allowing companies to seek waivers from existing consumer protection rules, not just for AI, but for any financial innovation, and that just gets the burden wrong. Consumer harm during a test period is still harm, and the consumer whose account is frozen or wrongfully denied credit does not care whether it happened in a sandbox. Last, enforcement. I spent nearly a decade at the CFPB. I have seen what happens when we have an Agency that is active and mandating and holding its mandate to hold institutions accountable, and we are seeing what is happening when that capacity is dismantled. The CFPB has lost the majority of its enforcement capacity. Staff have been let go. Examinations have stopped. The Agency Congress created to be the cop on the beat is being hollowed out, and at the same time, this subcommittee is considering important legislation that would expand fintech activity and waive existing protections. That is a practical problem, not a solution. Who will supervise compliance with the EWA bill's disclosure requirements if no one is there to do it? Who investigates when AI systems malfunction at scale? The bills before you assume a functioning regulator from a consumer protection standpoint, and assumption no longer holds. So, the question today is not whether fintech innovation should continue. It absolutely should, but the question is whether consumer protections scale alongside with it, or whether consumers remain the shock absorbers for risk. We are ready to work with the subcommittee. We have tested the products' surveyed consumers, and I appreciate the opportunity to be here and welcome your questions. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Ms. Reynolds Hand follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. The gentlewoman yields back. We will turn now to member questions. I will recognize myself for 5 minutes for questions. Mr. Palaniappan, we are at a transformational stage here. EWA gives individuals access to the wages they earned. If you and I, a hundred years ago, were hired to carry sacks of potatoes at Ms. Kelley's farm, we worked our tails off all day long, we would expect to have been paid at the end of our day's work. Large enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems came in and made it very difficult to pay people every day. Now many people get paid every 2 weeks, some people every month. It makes it hard to meet the bills and so, one of the questions becomes, how do we regulate this new space under earned wage access where individuals are receiving access to the wages that they have already earned? Attached to this hearing is my discussion draft, the Earned Wage Access Consumer Protections Act, where we start to dig into this, making sure that there is a no-cost option, full disclosures for individuals taking advantage of EWA products and so, one of the questions is, is this credit? Do we need a new regulatory framework? We just heard Ms. Reynolds Hand suggest that this is credit and should be regulated like credit, but if we were carrying sacks of potatoes at Ms. Kelley's farm, we would expect to get that money at the end of the day, and it sure does not sound like credit. It sounds like I am getting access to the money that I earned. So, I come to you, Mr. Palaniappan. Can you walk me through the distinctions that you see between EWA products and credit under the Truth in Lending act in Reg Z? Mr. Palaniappan. Sure. So, like you said, what earned wage access does is it changes the timing of when somebody receives their pay, which is different than a credit product where you are giving somebody money and I think calling it what it is not, calling it credit actually confuses the customer because with the credit product, they expect interest to accrue. They expect there to be a repayment date. They expect that there will be penalties if it does not get paid. They expect that there will be collections. They expect that it is going to affect their credit report. None of those happen with earned wage access, and so calling it credit actually will confuse the customer. In terms of the legal aspects of credit, I think Kevin, who is an attorney, might actually be better positioned to talk about how it is different to credit. Mr. Lefton. Sure. Thank you. I think that is an important question and probably one of the most important questions of today. The Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and Reg Z apply to consumer credit that is subject to a finance charge, and EWA is not consumer credit, and I will explain, and the flat fee is not a finance charge. The CFPB recently stated in its December 23 advisory opinion that EWA is not credit because no debt is incurred. You must have a debt to have credit, and a debt is an obligation to repay. Chairman Steil. Should we think of that as a distinction between employer-sponsored EWA and direct-to-consumer EWA? Mr. Lefton. No. Chairman Steil. That is part of the conversation that we are hearing. Mr. Lefton. No, I think that is a great question, but no debt is no debt. So, if there is no obligation to repay on the direct-to-consumer and there is no obligation to repay on the employer-integrated, I think it is the same. I think the fundamental question is, is there an obligation to repay, and the answer is no for EWA because it is a nonrecourse product. Chairman Steil. So, Mr. Zywicki, I am going to come to you and kind of continue to pull on this same string. One of the challenges that we face are these new and innovative products are not always fitting neatly into the regulatory framework that, really, has not been updated since the 1970s, and so this is new technology that was not around and available now over 50 years ago. What are some of the principles that you think we should be looking at to strike the right balance in this innovative space? Mr. Zywicki. Exactly right. I think that frames it correctly, which is, obviously, it needs to be, as I said in my remarks, responsive to the current technology. It needs to be responsive to the right jurisdictional boundaries. Our laws are really set up in a paper-based world back in the 1970s, and, finally, I think we really need to tailor it to who consumers are, where they are, and how they get information. Nowadays, people do things on the phone, not with great big stacks of paper, and so in terms of getting the right disclosures at the right times so that consumers can understand them on these products, I think those are the principles we should look like; take a consumer-focused approach to how they get information. Chairman Steil. Should it be risk focused, should it be activity focused, or should it be how the business purports the business model itself? What is the best way for us to be thinking that through? Mr. Zywicki. I think the best way to think about it is how do we empower consumers to find the products that they want as easily as possible. One of the things about EWA and BNPL is they are pretty simple products usually, and consumers can generally understand them, but I would say what we want to think about is how do consumers take in the information, how do they use the products, and focus on from the consumer perspective. Chairman Steil. Thank you very much. I think we have some really innovative space here and appreciate your testimony. I yield back. I will now recognize the ranking member, the gentleman from Massachusetts, Mr. Lynch, for 5 minutes. Mr. Lynch. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. First of all, I want to recognize a couple of my dear, dear colleagues and friends in the audience, Congressman Lacy Clay from Missouri and Congressman Ed Perlmutter from Colorado, two outstanding Members of Congress when they were here, and they are missed, and good to see that they are gainfully employed. [Laughter.] Mr. Lynch. Just turning to the issue of earned wage access, so before coming to Congress, I was an iron worker for about 20 years, worked in the construction industry, mostly building high-rise office towers, that type of thing. The way it worked in the construction industry is we would work Monday through Friday, and then the following Wednesday, we would get a paycheck. So, by the time payday rolled around at the end of the day on the following Wednesday, we had loaned the company 8 days of labor. So, we floated, basically, providing credit to our employer, and life does not work that way. It did not work that way back then, and it does not work that way today. Back then, you had to ask for what they called a drag. A drag was an advance on your money, so it is the similar model here, but it was much less fair and transparent back in the day, so there is definitely the need for this, right? We need innovation, as several of our witnesses have pointed out. Mr. Zywicki and others have said we can expand opportunity, we can expand bank access if we do this properly. I do want to just acknowledge what Ms. Reynolds Hand has pointed out, that if we do not do this properly we allow this innovation to come in a way that we actually encourage, or let me put it this way: We unfairly require companies that are doing the right thing to compete with bad actors if there is no regulation, you know. We just know human nature, and we may put people in a bad situation, especially because of the demographics. Ms. Reynolds the recent bipartisan working group that we had here on artificial intelligence that I co-chaired with Chairman Hill specifically examined the impact of AI algorithms that target certain customers based on certain characteristics, including protected characteristics. Given the importance of consumer data feeding AI, there is a concern that some of these companies may use algorithms in BNPL buy now, pay later, and earned wage access products that feed off consumer datasets that violate their privacy and may be impermissible for other reasons. Can you talk about do we have any transparency or any visibility on how these firms are using those datasets, how they were acquiring them? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Sure. Absolutely. Over the last several years, Consumer Reports has evaluated, we have reviewed policies, and actually dug into the fintech apps, various kinds--buy now, pay later, peer-to-peer (P2P) apps, digital wallets, crypto wallets, for example--to examine how consumers use them, what they do. To your point, all across the board, even basic banking apps, more data is collected than is needed. That data is then passed on and sold and used. Consumers are upmarketed. It also allows the companies to strategically understand what consumers are willing to pay and what they are not willing to pay, and prices can be set using this data that they gather from consumers. We do see multiple use. Consumers do not have control over their data. These apps are typically set to a default that is obscured, hard to find, and so it can have a disparate impact on communities of color, poor communities, and other consumers. Mr. Lynch. Okay. Thank you. My time is going to expire, but I would just ask you if you might be able to share with the committee in writing ways that we might mitigate the potential bias used against certain populations, especially the 40 percent of BNPL users who are Black or Hispanic organic, as identified by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The vice chair of the full committee, the gentleman from Michigan, Mr. Huizenga, is recognized. Mr. Huizenga. Mr. Chairman, I find myself in an odd position agreeing with Mr. Lynch on a couple of things: one, acknowledging our colleagues, Mr. Lacy Clay, Mr. Perlmutter. I am not sure I would have used ``outstanding''---- [Laughter.] Mr. Huizenga [continuing]. but they are very good friends and great colleagues to have worked with across the aisle, both of them, and I do appreciate that. It is interesting, Mr. Lynch's work as an iron worker. My family, the small company that I own, is in construction as well. It is seasonal, and I can tell you we go through that payroll process every week. We have chosen as employers to pay every week because I do not want to disadvantage my guys. I can tell you, I am speculating here a little bit, but I am pretty sure that Henry, Cole, Larry, and a couple of the other guys would be really excited about being able to have access to their cash daily after they put in a 10-or an 11-hour workday in a gravel pit, and, frankly, they deserve it. Now, the realities are, is by the time they finish up at 5:30-6 on a Friday, we got to go get the hours, figure that out, get that into our payroll processor, and by the time that the checks are cut--we still are old school--they can choose to whether they want to have direct deposit or not, but we are still sending checks in the mail to some of these guys, and sign the check and they finally get it on Thursday. Amen. Hallelujah. Let us actually pay for people's work in a timely manner as we possibly can. So, I am going to start with Ms. Kelley here, and I want to touch on the transmitter licensing which I know you mentioned in your testimony. Currently, there exists a patchwork of State licensing regimes, and so it is kind of a quick two-part question here. First, what difficulties do you--do startups face when trying to develop or scale a new payment system, and second, what is the cost and complexity of complying with varying jurisdictional frameworks? Ms. Kelley. Yes, Congressman, thank you for that question. It is an important one. When you think about fintech startups and what it takes for them to get in market and operate, uniformity is so important, and the example you provide is one where there is incredible disuniformity. You have a small startup trying to get into business in 49 different jurisdictions with 49 different licensing requirements. We know that is expensive, we know it costs literally millions of dollars, and we know it takes a long time, as much as 2 years, and that is a death knell for a small business trying to get up and running. Then, of course, if they do manage to get up and running, there are 49 different compliance regimes they have to apply with. Mr. Huizenga. Well, that is okay. We will just have the Huizenga Gravel Company compliance department take care of that. Oh, wait a minute, that is me. Ms. Kelley. Well, that is exactly right. Small businesses have to focus on their business. Mr. Huizenga. Yes. Ms. Kelley. They do not have an army of compliance professionals and others who can help us navigate that patchwork, so it is an excellent example of a real-world problem that startups and businesses have. Mr. Huizenga. It is better than Mr. Steil and me carrying your sack of potatoes on the metaphorical farm. Ms. Kelley. Exactly. [Laughter.] Mr. Huizenga. All right. Mr. Zywicki, good to see you again as well. What role do nonbank firms play in partnering with fintechs, and how do these relationships help drive innovation that might not otherwise occur within traditional banking system? We are seeing this all the time, right? I mean, you certainly did at CFPB. Mr. Zywicki. Yes, thank you for that. It is really remarkable. Banks do some things pretty well, but banks do not always do innovation that well, especially smaller banks. Mr. Huizenga. Their regulators tend not to like that. Mr. Zywicki. Yes, their regulators often are not friends of innovation, but especially small banks. I think one of the things we are seeing is that a lot of fintechs are partnering with small banks, which I think are strengthening the dual banking system. A lot of these are State banks, smaller banks and so, what I think we are seeing is, especially in a regulatory environment where, for various reasons, including regulation, we are getting more and more consolidation and concentration in the banking system. I think the way in which fintechs are strengthening the ability of small banks to compete with big banks, they are often more nimble, they are more responsive, and that sort of thing. That is really been an engineer. Big banks innovate as well, but I think the ability of fintechs to partner with small banks has been a huge part of this story. Mr. Huizenga. Okay. I have 30 seconds left, and, sorry, with a name like Huizenga, I am not trying to be disrespectful when I mispronounce Palaniappan, right? Close-ish? Let me move to you on the remaining time. What elements of your current financial institution regulatory framework may be inappropriate for startups? I may have to take that in written form, but maybe briefly. Chairman Steil. Why do we not ask the gentleman to provide that in written form, cognizant of the time? Mr. Huizenga. I yield back. Thank you. Chairman Steil. Thank you. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. I will now recognize the gentlewoman from California, the ranking member of the full committee, Ms. Waters, for 5 minutes. Ms. Waters. Thank you very much. President Trump promised to reduce the cost of living. Instead, unemployment and grocery prices are rising, and consumer protections are eroding. Under the Trump economy, people are being forced to use products like earned wage access to get early access to their paychecks, and buy now, pay later loans to buy groceries. Trump called this affordability crisis a hoax, but he knows it is real and now wants to cap credit card interest rates at 10 percent. Well, President Trump, I am pleased to know that you are listening. We do not agree on much of anything, but we do on this, so let us do it. Let us cap interest rates, but, Mr. President, you are going to need to convince your Republican colleagues because they will not consider this or any other bill that would help keep money in consumers' pockets. So, not only am I interested in what the President has proposed, this interest rate of 10 percent on credit cards. Mr. Steil, do you believe this cap requires authorization by Congress? Yes? I did not hear you. Chairman Steil. Would the gentlewoman---- Ms. Waters. I yield. Chairman Steil. The gentlewoman would like to yield? Ms. Waters. Do you believe the cap requires authorization by Congress to get the 10-percent cap that the President is advocating? Chairman Steil. I would be more than happy to have a broader dialog as to exactly how we navigate it anytime, Ranking Member. Ms. Waters. Well, I want to know whether or not the committee have plans to move forward with this policy. Maybe some of our witnesses here today know a little bit more about it. Ms. Reynolds, are you supportive of 10-percent credit card rate cap? Ms. Reynolds Hand. We are supportive of anything that lowers the cost of goods and services to consumers. As you mentioned, loads of things, including the cost of financial services, are high for consumers right now. I think an important consideration is how that happens, and if that happens through a transparent process where we are able to come to the table and land on a workable solution, that is great. I think one thing I would like to note is about how credit card rates are set. They are based on risk price, right, lending happens that way, and so we would be concerned that this 10-percent cap, if not done correctly, could reduce accessibility of credit cards for some of the more vulnerable consumers and so, we would support the basic principle and are looking forward to seeing more details and working in a bipartisan way. Ms. Waters. Well, I am sorry I said ``Ms. Reynolds.'' It is Ms. Reynolds Hand. Fintech products like buy now, pay later and earned wage access, do you believe that they can help families struggling to make ends meet, especially during this crisis that we are confronted with? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Yes, they can. We have no objection to those products. What we have seen is with the introduction of innovation, more consumers have access to liquidity. That is an important foundation of American commercial life, and we want healthy credit that is available to consumers, but there should be some basic standards that are introduced and guardrails that are introduced with these products. Specifically, we want to ensure that there is an affordability standard. We got into the last financial crisis, the mortgage crisis, because there was not a real test of consumers' ability to repay. That deserves consideration with these kinds of products, especially when you have a significant business model. You have employer-sponsored EWA. You also have direct-to-consumer EWA, which is sponsored differently and, in some instances, can be riskier to consumers. We also want to ensure that all products that look like credit and act like credit are treated in the same way. If a consumer incurs a debt and that debt needs to be repaid later in time for a specific fee or interest is attached, I do not know what else you would call that other than credit, and that is what is defined under the Truth in Lending Act. So, we want that consistency. Ms. Waters. Thank you very much. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentlewoman yields back. The gentleman from Ohio, Mr. Davidson, who is also the chair of the National Security, Illicit Finance, and International Financial Institutions Subcommittee, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Davidson. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you to all of our witnesses for joining us today and for your testimony. One of the great strengths of America's financial system is the capacity for innovation. Fintech companies, in particular, have created tools that help consumers stretch the paycheck, avoid overdraft fees, build savings, improve payments, and access financial services in a way that simply did not exist a decade ago. Earned wage access is one of the things that we are highlighting today, and I think all of our witnesses, or really 4 out of the 5 witnesses, have done a good job describing how this works, why consumers want it, and I think Chairman Steil, his question, clarified and the answer clarified why it is not debt, so. I guess that debt is in the eye of the beholder because Ms. Reynolds Hand thinks that it is debt, but it seems very clear that you are not obligated to repay something in the future. You are just paying a fee for a service. I mean, who is served by treating it as if it is debt? How is this protecting consumers? Why would they want to categorize it as debt? Maybe, Ms. Kelley, would you give us an answer about what you think? Ms. Kelley. Yes. We agree that this is not debt, that it is access to wages that are already earned and we think it is a really important choice or option, and that is the hallmark of the fintech industry right now: providing choice and option to consumers who are best positioned to decide how to utilize those products. I know we have earned wage companies here who can speak in detail about what they do, but as an overarching matter, we agree this is not that. Chairman Steil. Mr. Lefton, your take? Mr. Lefton. Sure. I think it is absolutely clear that earned wage access is not credit because it does not have debt, and I think as I alluded to earlier, a debt requires an obligation to repay. With earned wage access, as we have stated, it is a nonrecourse product. So if something happens, whether it is a technological glitch or the user somehow changes their functions and the company does not recoup their money, we do not go after the consumer. There is no risk to the consumer whatsoever. At most, maybe they will be paused until we figure out how that happened, but there is no risk to the consumer. There is no debt collection and they do not go to the credit bureaus, so there is no obligation. Mr. Davidson. Thank you, and I think it is also essentially the same whether it is a direct-to-consumer or something that the employer offers as a service to the employees. I would say, look, the idea that payroll is deferred into the future and people would like to get paid is not new. I mean, this is as old as the Bible. You see stories about people who are paid one denarii for a day's wages. There are people that show up late in the day and are giving them one denarii and they are, ``oh, not fair,'' right? So, we have had a debate about payroll as old as we have written documents, I think so, but it is nice that we have this service, and I appreciate the clarification on it. One of the other things that we have done for a long time is we have State-regulated banks, and bank fintech partnerships are incredibly important to being able to provide access to consumers. When you think about community banks, a lot of people, that is where they find accessibility, and a lot of the biggest banks do not decide to launch massive products. They do not want to test the market. They want to be fast followers at best. Maybe the cutting edge is somebody smaller, more nimble and willing to test a product that they do not have to necessarily spend as much capital just testing it or getting into the market. So, we have a regulatory framework that creates preemption around the country where banks are regulated. This is the Depository Institutions Deregulation Monetary Control Act, DIDMCA, if I am pronouncing that alphabet soup correctly. Essentially, if a bank is based in Ohio, they are regulated by the regulators in Ohio, but because of preemption, they can service customers wherever customers want to reach out to them and access. How is that being reinterpreted and reimagined and why? Ms. Kelley, you got an answer to that? Ms. Kelley. Yes, so, and thank you for that question. It is an important one. As we spoke earlier, uniformity is really critical: predictability, certainty, uniformity for fintechs and the ability of a bank to partner with a fintech to make a loan, for example, there needs to be certainty about which State's laws apply, and that has been thrown into question lately. There was a recent decision in the Tenth Circuit that suggested States could override the law that would otherwise apply. Again, anything that creates disuniformity like that does makes it more difficult for innovation to thrive. Mr. Davidson. Yes, thank you. I will be introducing legislation in the near future to rebut that ruling and make sure that we know the law is clear as it has been applied for a long time. I hope all my colleagues across the aisle will join in it, and I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from California, the ranking member on the Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Mr. Sherman, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Sherman. Mr. Chairman, off the topic of this hearing, this is the first meeting of a subcommittee of Financial Services since President Trump has begun this unprecedented use of the criminal justice system to contort it, to militarize it, and to attack the Federal Reserve, to try to take away its independence and, thereby, imperil our economy. If you are gullible enough to think that Donald Trump did not order this to happen, you are probably gullible enough to think that he has been faithful to all three of his wives. Now, as to this hearing, the basic problem is rent is too high, groceries are too high, wages are too low, and an awful lot of Americans do not have a thousand bucks in the bank, and so they have to turn to all these expensive and complicated systems to get their hands on a few hundred dollars. We are told that these are not payday loans. Many payday loan companies call themselves payday advance. They are functionally equivalent to a payday loan, but the companies involved do not want to live by the same laws as the payday lending folks. We are told instead that you are selling an asset you already own, so, Mr. Lefton, let us say my pay period begins on February 1. I am 15 minutes into the pay period. I have been paid for every bit of work I have done for my company, except for the last 15 minutes. How much can I borrow from your company? Mr. Lefton. So, at Stream, it is---- Mr. Sherman. Can I not borrow $500 from your company 15 minutes into the business pay period? Mr. Lefton. You can borrow up to 50 percent of your gross earned wages. We are integrating---- Mr. Sherman. Of what I have already earned in 15 minutes, or what I am going to earn during the pay period? Mr. Lefton. No, what you have earned up to that moment in time. Mr. Sherman. Only what I have earned up to that moment in time. Mr. Lefton. That moment in time. Mr. Sherman. So, you have a company that is there to help me, but you can only help me significantly on February 14. You cannot help me on February 1. Mr. Lefton. Well, we can help you access any wages you have already earned in that moment in time. We are integrated with your employer---- Mr. Sherman. Okay. Mr. Lefton [continuing]. so we know exact date, time, and attendance of---- Mr. Sherman. Okay. I will ask the gentleman sitting next to you. I got paid on January 31. It is now February 1. I need 500 bucks. Can I get 500 bucks from your company? Mr. Palaniappan. No. The only amount that you can take is how much you have earned up until that point in time. We do not let you go beyond what you have already earned. Mr. Sherman. So, neither one of you will lend me even a hundred bucks on February 1 if I have been paid on January 31. Mr. Palaniappan. We are trying to make payroll be more efficient. People should not have to wait after they have worked to get their pay. That is what we are focused on. Mr. Sherman. Okay. So---- Mr. Palaniappan. We are now trying to help them out if they need---- [Cross-talking.] Mr. Sherman. Are there firms in your industry, though, that will advance me 500 bucks as long as I am going to make 500 during this pay period or during the---- Mr. Palaniappan. Not in the earned wage access product. Mr. Sherman. Okay. Mr. Palaniappan. There are lending products that will do that. Mr. Sherman. That is an interesting model. Well, I will ask Ms. Hand. It seems like these companies are direct competition for payday lending. They are doing the same thing. Should they be exempt from even what many would call the insufficient regulations that we have on payday lenders? Ms. Reynolds Hand. We think there should be the same regulation in the marketplace for products that are functionally acting in the same way. If a consumer is able to receive funds, defer the payment, and if there are fees or fees that act like interest as they accrue over time, these should be treated the same way. Mr. Sherman. I will point out that people have calculated that the acceleration fee is 300 or 400 percent APR, which is why I have said APR is just a crazy way to evaluate the fairness of an advance or a loan that is just for a few days. I go to my local ATM machine. I could walk four blocks to my banks. I get my money, well 10 minutes sooner, and I pay 2 bucks extra. You figure out the APR, $2 to get my money 20 minutes sooner. The APR is in the tens of thousands, but we see that 90 percent of the folks that use this system are paying the acceleration fee. Should we regard, Ms. Hand, this as a free service, or is it a service that people are paying the acceleration fee on? Ms. Reynolds Hand. I mean, what we see in terms of consumer usage is that consumers do not typically use these as a one- and-done product. I am happy to follow up in writing. They tend to stack these loans---- Mr. Sherman. Ah. Ms. Reynolds Hand [continuing]. and then functionally, that is where you see the equivalent of 300 percent or other high APR. Mr. Sherman. Gotcha. I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from Montana, Mr. Downing, is recognized. Mr. Downing. Well, thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the witnesses for spending some time with us today. As a former securities regulator, I have dealt with a lot of issues in this space with digital assets. I had to deal with ambiguous regulations that, in some cases, have forced companies to look for offshore domiciles in innovating and I think it is incredibly important that we continue to have innovation here in the United States of America and do not have that ambiguity that we have in the past that have made people decide to run their businesses elsewhere without a reasonable framework. Another thing that was really difficult for me as a regulator is the ambiguity we got from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) at the time on how to treat these and a lot of the enforcement by action rather than having a framework, which is why I think it is really important, that we need clarity for digital assets and for artificial intelligence. So, I am going to start with Professor Zywicki. I represent one of the most rural districts in the United States. In Montana's 2nd Congressional District, we have multiple counties with less than 500 people in them. It is very, very rural. So, how does financial technology increase access to banking services in areas that have sparse financial institutions, like in rural areas of Montana? Mr. Zywicki. Thank you for that question because I think the focus on financial inclusion for rural communities has been really understudied, and I think it is an area that is really important. It is an area that has become more important, as I mentioned in my opening comments, because of regulations like Dodd-Frank and the like, which have accelerated the concentration of the industry, and the regulatory costs have led to the disappearance of a lot of rural banks, small banks, community banks, and the like. Obviously one solution would be to reform the regulatory system, but I think this is the vehicle for that if you are talking about your local bank closes and now you have to drive 90 minutes to get to a bank in the next town. Fintech as a means for payments, as a means for obtaining short-term credit, for all these sorts of things, it is really the obvious solution for these rural communities that have lost access to financial services. Mr. Downing. Thank you very much for your answer. I am going to move on in the interest of time here. I was an advocate for regulatory sandboxes in Montana when I was a regulator. We effectively pushed policy on insurance technology (insurtech), and fintech was another part of this conversation, giving an opportunity to try out things that may not exactly fit within a current regulatory framework. So, I am going to start with Mr. Palaniappan. What role can regulatory sandboxes play in allowing fintechs to test and scale innovative products while maintaining appropriate consumer protections? Mr. Palaniappan. I think when a company is at an early stage in trying to come up with a product that does not exist before, the existing frameworks and laws usually have not contemplated what they are trying to do. So, I think you do want to provide the freedom for companies to try out new things with the right set of guardrails. I think there is also another set of startups where I would put earned wage access where the products are actually at reasonable scale. There is lots of evidence that it is better off for consumers, and when it gets to that stage, then you do want to have clarity so that consumers know that the product will continue to be available for them and also keeping bad actors out from that space. Mr. Downing. Thank you. Mr. Lefton, any comments on that? Mr. Lefton. Yes, I think that is a great question. I think sandboxes are critical for providers to work with regulators and figure out how best to serve the consumer, and I think a great example of something like that is Stream was founded 8 years ago in the U.K. At the time, my founders, basically, came up with the idea, they knocked on the door of the Financial Conduct Authority, the FCA, and said we want to do this, how can we work with you to do this? Mr. Downing. Right. Mr. Lefton. They worked hand in hand with the FCA in order to do this and we brought that mentality over here and have tried whenever we were given the opportunity, whether it is with State regulators or the CFPB or being here today, to work to see how best we can come up with appropriate regulation for the product. Mr. Downing. Thank you. In the interest of time, Ms. Kelley, I am going to move on to you. I often hear from banks and credit unions in my district how costly it is to comply with so many regulations. So, how can we ensure that compliance costs for fintech startups remain proportionate so that innovation is not stifled and pricing does not prevent these products from reaching the consumers they are intended to serve? Ms. Kelley. Yes, thank you for that question. So, I think as we look to ensure that regulatory burdens do not stifle innovation, there are a few things we need to stay focused on. First, it is critical that we regulate activity and outcomes rather than technology. The core principle is same regulation. Second, uniformity and clarity are key. It is difficult to run a business and comply. We need to know exactly what it is we are complying with, and reducing the number of competing regulations is critical. We think sandboxes done correctly play a critical role---- Chairman Steil. The gentlewoman can conclude in written testimony. We appreciate her testimony. Thank you. Mr. Downing. Thank you. I yield. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from Illinois, Mr. Foster, the ranking member on the Financial Institutions Subcommittee, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Foster. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and to our witnesses. Mr. Palaniappan, I was struck by the data that you mentioned about how earned wage access produces a better motivated and more productive and reliable employee. The question I have is, why did not the free market competition among payroll providers simply make this a standard feature of all payroll processing equipment? Was it just the overhead that Rep. Huizenga mentioned of filling out your weekly timesheet and the whole rhythm there? Is someone collecting the interest on this effective loan? What is it that prevented this from just happening naturally? I understand you are trying to disrupt it, a full-stack payroll provider yourself. [Laughter.] Mr. Palaniappan. Yes. Mr. Foster. I presume has this as a feature. Mr. Palaniappan. So, EarnIn Payroll does do what you described as the payroll system, but, typically, a payroll company does get interest on the money. The money is pulled from the employer's account. It goes into a master trust account. From there, the money goes into the employee's account, sometimes sits in the master trust account for some time, and then we also have to make payments for tax. Tax is actually not due immediately. Tax is sometimes due quarterly. Sometimes, depending on jurisdiction, it holds for more time. So, there is some interest that is being made. Mr. Foster. Is that the big---- [Cross-talking.] Mr. Foster. I just wonder---- Mr. Palaniappan. I actually think---- Mr. Foster [continuing]. what is your impression of why this did not happen naturally? Mr. Palaniappan. I think it is different. I think the way we see payroll systems is we think there should be two consumers for a payroll system. There should be the employer and the employee, and employee first is how we actually have started the company. Most payroll systems think of the employer as their only customer. The employer is not the one who says I want the wages to be disbursed immediately. It is the employee who wants that, and so I think when you are focusing---- Mr. Foster. It should be a competitive advantage to an employer if this is something they are offering. Mr. Palaniappan. Exactly. Mr. Foster. Right, and so any time I see, like, a failure of the free market to generate the right answer, I try and understand what drove that. Mr. Palaniappan. EarnIn Payroll does let employees access their pay when they need it, so they are---- Mr. Foster. Oh, yes. No, I understand, and I understand why you are probably gaining market share. Why did someone not invent this 2 decades ago and have it happened automatically, I guess. Anyway, if you have any thoughts on this. I do not want to burn all my time here, but I think it is an interesting question when we see it. Now, the big thing that I spend a lot of my time worrying about is agentic AI because that is going to be disrupting everything. When Mr. Zywicki, you, the dealer, the car dealer when you can go into a car dealer and get a car and then so, what happens now is that you go and you strike a price for the car, and then the car dealer will try to steer you into some crappy, overpriced loan, which is a big part of their business model. In the agentic future that I think many of us dream about is that you are going to have the Consumer Reports app give you advice and say, okay, yep, all right. Here, you struck a deal for this car, and then your Consumer Reports agent will go out on the internet and look and see what is available for loans, get the low-price loans and say, thank you very much, Mr. Dealer, there is a better. Trying to preserve that kind of competition is, I think, what is going to be the challenge of the next decade in financial services. The key thing there, it seems to me, is how do you get unconflicted financial advice to the consumer? Who is it? This is the problem because when startups come up to me and come into my office and say, we have this great new personal advisor product. AI advisor, and then I say, okay, how are you going to monetize that? It always comes to some variation of, we are going to be just like Google. We will get everyone to trust us, and then we will abuse that trust by steering people into crappy, overpriced products. So, what are the best thoughts out there on getting unconflicted advice to consumers through their AI apps? Mr. Zywicki, you look like you have been thinking about this. Mr. Zywicki. I have been thinking about it, but I am not certain I have a great solution, except, I mean, obviously there has always been a market. I am sitting next to somebody for Consumer Reports, which has been around for almost a century, for unbiased information, for subscription-based information and the like, and I agree with you that agentic AI is really important. Another thing I would say is dealing with the emerging issues of consumer data privacy---- Mr. Foster. Mm-hmm. Mr. Zywicki [continuing]. and the idea of AI, and the idea of bad guys, fraudsters having AI and being able to, basically, attack the way in which we have done consumer data security for years with our passwords and all that sort of stuff. Mr. Foster. Oh, sure, yes. Yes, when I go through the list of what government can actually do to help, number one on the list is get government support for mobile ID, digital driver's license as a means of reliably authenticating who you are, proving you are who you say you are online. Second to that is have the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) or someone like that come up with the standards of AI communication. Mr. Zywicki. Yes. Mr. Foster. This is something that I will be following up, I think, with you because that is something that would move the ball forward and get U.S. standards to really be promulgated around the world. Mr. Zywicki. I would enjoy that dialog. That would be useful. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Rose, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Rose. Thank you Chairman Steil, and thank you, Ranking Member Lynch, for holding this important hearing, and thank you to our witnesses for taking time to be with us. Mr. Lefton, how do earned wage access products enable consumers to meet their financial obligations without incurring overdraft and late fees? Mr. Lefton. Sure. Thank you. I think that is a great question. I think it was alluded to before that over a hundred million Americans live paycheck to paycheck, and the same number have less than $400 in savings. EWA enables users to access their already-earned wages at either no cost or for a low nominal fee, and I think that is important because it gives them choice. There is competition now, and that is at a much lower price than the traditional predatory products out there, and every time they use a service like EWA over a traditional, high-cost product, they are putting more money in their pocket. Mr. Rose. So, it seems to me that one of the risks here is, of course, once you do this once, if it continues, then you have kind of accessed that resource and then you are not able to go back to it. Is the evidence that is what happens in fact, or is there evidence that consumers tap it, then pay it back, then tap it? How does that end up working in practice? Mr. Lefton. No, I think that is a great question. I think you are talking about cycle of debt, which EWA, to be clear, has nothing to do with debt. It is a frequency of pay issue, right? It is a timing issue, and charging interest, requiring minimum payments, rollovers, those are all significant features in a cycle of debt, none of which are present with EWA. Our data shows that EWA users actually spend less and save more when they are in control of their own finances. Mr. Rose. Once you collect your wages early, if you will, do you kind of stay in that cycle and you do that paycheck to paycheck? Is that the evidence, or does it kind of go and come? Mr. Lefton. So, I think it fluctuates. I mean, it really depends on every user's situation, right? It depends on their income--how much they make, where they live, all those kinds of outside factors that we do not have insight into, but I think it spans the entire spectrum. Mr. Rose. Thank you. Mr. Lefton. Sure. Mr. Rose. Mr. Palaniappan, how does earned wage access complement existing financial products to benefit consumers? Mr. Palaniappan. So, earned wage access is an additional tool for customers, and what it does, it helps them control the timing of when they get paid. So, instead of being stuck to this rigid biweekly or monthly pay cycle, they can choose when to get their pay, and they can use that along with other financial products. We have a number of financial products as well within our app. We have automated savings, credit monitoring, and so they all work well together. Sort of coming to the question on the repeated use, I think different people use it in different ways. It is used very often to pay bills and to pay rent. The most common pay cycle in the U.S. is you are paid every other week. Every bill is monthly. So, for every bill, 6 times a year, the bill is due before payday. So, what you can do with earned wage access is access the money when your bills are due instead of having delayed fees added onto your bill. We also see a lot of people who are using this as a way to increase their incomes. So, I did mention the government employee uses us with his side custom candle business, and he is making more money on his side business because of that. I spoke with another customer who works at retail. When you work at retail, there are different types of roles. With one role you are tied to a particular store location. With another role you are tied to a department, like a cosmetics department, and you cover about three different store locations. That role pays more, but when she was offered the higher-paying role, she did not take it because she could not afford to front the gas money and then wait to get reimbursed, and so now she uses EarnIn. So, when she got the offer again, she took it the next time because she knew that with EarnIn, she could actually afford to front the gas money. EarnIn has helped her stay employed at a higher-paying job, so it actually makes sense that she uses it because that is what is keeping her in that job. So, I think in many cases, you are seeing incomes go up, and incomes go up because of reasons like this. Mr. Rose. I think--Mr. Palaniappan, you may weigh in on this, and, Mr. Lefton, I think this is the point you were trying to make--there is a very big difference between earned wage access and payday lending as we know it. Mr. Lefton, weigh in on that. Really press down on the difference. Mr. Lefton. Sure. Absolutely. I think the key differences with any loan product and earned wage access is there are two components to a loan. There is debt and there is interest, and with EWA, there is neither. I think that is a fundamental difference, that when we talk about this, people need to understand and realize that with EWA there is no debt, with EWA there is no interest, and those two things together are what form a loan. Mr. Rose. Thank you. My time has expired. I yield back, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Rose. The gentleman yields back. The gentlewoman from Massachusetts, Ms. Pressley is now recognized for 5. Ms. Pressley. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I am certainly glad we are having today's hearing to discuss buy now, pay later. While, admittedly, I am old enough to remember the layaway line decades ago when you did not get the product until you paid for it. We are certainly living in a different era. Klarna, Affirm, Afterpay, and PayPal are the four biggest buy now, pay later companies, and they are everywhere. With a simple press of a button on your phone, you can access product immediately and pay for it over time. To me, that does sound like a loan. A person is borrowing lump sum funds that they will have to pay back over time in the form of an installment plan, and if they miss payments, it can go to debt collection, show up on their credit report, and lower their credit score for years. Ms. Hand, do you agree with my assessment that buy now, pay later is a loan? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Yes, absolutely. You have, basically, two models in the marketplace. You have to pay in four or sometimes six, right? You pay back those four or six payments. There is no fee. Typically, there is no interest. That might not be a loan under the definition, and then you have the installment product, right? These are longer term. Let us just say you are buying an appliance for $2,500. That would come with actual interest. Let us say the interest is 24 percent or 36 percent over a 24-month period. A consumer for that product is going to be paying not $2,500 for the product. The effect of that APR over 24 months is roughly $1,070. Ms. Pressley. All right then. Ms. Hand, before the Trump Administration rescinded guidance, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and I want to underscore Consumer Protection Financial Bureau, took important steps to ensure proper treatment of these loans, like the ability to dispute charges and to obtain refunds. What are some of the harms that borrowers face now that those rights and protections are gone and we have people working actively to gut and to degrade the work of the CFPB? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Yes, it is quite alarming to see a marketplace evolving, frankly, in a way it should have been for the last 20 years to provide more access to different products to consumers, at the same time that the consumer protection regulator has shut down enforcement, examinations of financial institutions are not happening. This is alarming, and this is not the way a healthy marketplace is supposed to operate. What this means is the only ability is perhaps States who are actively looking for patterns and trying to regulate these products State by State. Regulation should not be our default. We need strong Federal floors to protect consumers. Ms. Pressley. Just with a quick ``yes'' or ``no'' here as my time is leaving us, do you think buy now, pay later companies are being transparent enough to ensure consumers know what they are signing up for? Ms. Reynolds Hand. They could do better. Ms. Pressley. Okay. Thank you. Even when buy now, pay later lenders are operating with transparency and following Truth-in- Lending laws, we must acknowledge that these fintech innovations do not get at the root problems. It is wage stagnation that leaves the young parents unable to keep up with the rising cost of living for their family. It is corporate greed that prioritizes profits at the expense of workers that are pulling double shifts. It is Donald Trump's fiscally chaotic and irresponsible policies that have reduced hiring and increased unemployment and ignored the affordability crisis that is plaguing our country. While fintech may help stand in the gap, people do not want to just get by. They want to thrive and prosper and achieve their dreams. So, Congress must get serious and fight for the people, not the corporations. I yield back. Ms. Pressley. The gentlewoman yields back. The gentleman from South Carolina, Mr. Timmons, is recognized. Mr. Timmons. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to thank the witnesses for being here today. Fintechs are transforming the way Americans interact with financial services. Millions of people around the world have already seen their lives meaningfully improved by digital assets and the services provided by fintech companies. From expanded access to capital to faster and more secure money transfers across often authoritarian borders, these technologies are already reshaping the global financial landscape. I have met with countless innovators who are building products that meet real consumer demand and help families better manage their financial lives, particularly those who have been underserved by the traditional banking system. This progress, however, depends on getting the policy environment right. Outdated rules and inconsistent regulatory interpretations can slow the adoption of beneficial technologies, limit competition, and drive innovation offshore. True leadership in financial innovation means providing clear, predictable guardrails that promote responsible innovation here in the United States rather than pushing it overseas. Mr. Lefton, what regulatory barriers currently prevent new fintech companies from going to market in ways that satisfy clear consumer demand? Mr. Lefton. Sure. Thank you for the question. I think some of the regulatory barriers are the lack of clarity and ambiguity. We have seen at the State level, while numerous States have passed pro-EWA legislation, it can be difficult to comply with a patchwork of regulation, which I think, ultimately, flows down to the consumer, right? Clear regulation, unambiguous regulation, allows companies, while also protecting consumers, to thrive with innovation. I think one of the greatest examples is while we do provide EWA, we have also created a savings product for consumers that is free of charge and many of our consumers, this is their first savings account. We are paying 5 percent interest into their savings account, one that they have never had before, and all in the light of that, we were able to innovate, and I think innovation is deeply connected with clear regulation. Mr. Timmons. Thank you for that. I will talk about the CFPB briefly. What steps should the Bureau take to provide clear, more predictable guidance for fintech firms, particularly smaller or early stage companies, so that compliance expectations are known before products are launched rather than enforced after the fact? What do you think about the CFPB and its role in this? Mr. Lefton. Sure. I think the CFPB, and I will only talk about earned wage access, but I think December 23, just a few weeks ago, they released their advisory opinion around earned wage access, and it really resolved the regulatory uncertainty, right? It made it very clear, and it confirmed what Stream and the entire industry has been saying for years that EWA is not credit, and that the nominal fee is not a finance charge. I think that is critical to the providers in innovating and competing, which, ultimately, leads to greater products and lower prices for the consumer. Mr. Timmons. It is almost like the last 4 years we were out of balance, and we got back in balance, and things are moving in the right direction. Weird. Professor Zywicki, in 2024, the CFPB took several actions related to buy now, pay later products, including applying aspects of the payday lending rule and certain Regulation Z obligations. In your view, how would these measures have hindered the buy now, pay later market in the United States? Mr. Zywicki. Yes, I think that is a good example of trying to jam new technologies into an old bucket, into an old hole. I mean, Ms. Hand herself was just sort of talking about sort of how these products are not exactly like old-fashioned products like credit cards and that sort of thing. This is a totally different product. If you pay on time, you do not have interest accruing, but they are talking about like sort of applying a regulatory framework that now only fits in perfectly as it has grown up over time to a brand new technology. I think what they really need to do is start over and think about what exactly are the challenges of this product for consumers and create its own framework rather than that blunderbuss of regulation that would have, I think, killed the product. Mr. Timmons. Thank you, Professor. As you have outlined, there is real risk that misapplying legacy regulations to innovative products could reduce access and push consumers toward less transparent or less suitable alternatives, and that outcome would undermine, rather than advance, consumer protection. I think that we are moving in the right direction with the CFPB, and we have to keep up the good work. Thank you, and I will yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from New York, Mr. Torres, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Torres. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I am a Bronx boy, so I have no farming analogies. It has been a while since the Bronx was farmland. [Laughter.] Mr. Torres. Earned wage access is based on a simple proposition: if you are a worker, you should have the right to access the money you earn the moment you earn it and the moment you need it. The notion that you must wait 2 weeks or even a month before accessing your own earnings should be seen as a scandal. It should be seen as an anachronism in a world as technologically advanced as our own. I have constituents who have fallen behind on their bills despite working full time, who have fallen behind not because of a lack of earnings, but because of a lack of access to their earnings. A lack of access to one's earnings puts the most cash-strapped Americans at risk of falling victims to the abuses of payday lending and overdrafts. So, in Congress, we have a choice. Either we give working people safe and immediate access to their own earnings, or we set them up for financial traps like payday lending. To be clear, like any financial product, EWA is neither inherently safe nor inherently dangerous. It is only as good as its design. We in Congress must ensure that EWA is designed to be a solution to a problem rather than a problem of its own. Congress should adopt a regulatory framework that designs EWA to be a free and affordable alternative to payday loans or overdrafts. My first question to the CEO of EarnIn, do you believe, as I do, that EWA providers should be required by law to offer a free option to consumers? Mr. Palaniappan. Yes. Mr. Torres. Now, the EWA industry maintains that EWA is qualitatively different from credit and, therefore, should be regulated differently. If we accept that premise as true, it then logically follows that there should be no collections, correct? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. There should be no charging of interest, correct? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. There should be no late fees, correct? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. There should be no wage garnishment, correct? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. There should be no adverse credit reporting, correct? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. Right. No collections, no interest, no late fees, no wage garnishment, no adverse credit reporting. Simply put, EWA should function as a free or affordable alternative to payday loans and overdraft fees, correct? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. Now, there is a debate surrounding the appropriateness of applying APR to earned wage access. APR is deeply informative when it comes to long-term products, but when it comes to something as extremely short term as EWA, does APR inform or does it misinform? I want to make a point by way of illustration. Suppose I was to give you a 1-day hundred- dollar loan with a $1 fee. The average person would consider that $1 fee not to be excessive or exploitive. It is $1. What if I were to tell you that $1 fee translates into an APR of 365 percent, right? Three hundred and sixty-five percent sounds massive, and so, the trouble with applying APR to the most short-term product is that annualization can make even the smallest fees seem massive on paper. A one-dollar fee can be made to seem massive when presented as an annualized percentage. Is that a fair point? Mr. Palaniappan. That is correct. Mr. Torres. So, the question for Congress to consider is not whether there should be disclosure. Of course there should be disclosure of all fees, of all costs. What is needed is the right kind of disclosure: disclosure that informs rather than misinforms, that illuminates the truth rather than distorts it. So, consumer protection, proper disclosure, and innovation should be our policy objectives. I do not know if anyone has any thoughts. Ms. Reynolds Hand. I do. Mr. Torres. Yes. Ms. Reynolds Hand. I would agree with everything that you said. I think an additional standard that applies that is missing in this space, particularly fintech, is dynamic disclosure: disclosure at the right time. We have technologies that can deliver funds to consumers instantly. Those disclosures should be delivered instantly, plainly, simply in an accessible way. The other principle that applies is protective design or consumer-friendly design. So, one of the things that we have seen in this space, the products that we have looked at, is oftentimes those zero-cost options, particularly in the direct-to-consumer space, are hidden. The defaults are options where the consumers will pay a fee, even where there is a zero-cost option available. So, the technology should be designed in a way, to your point, where it functions so that there is no cost. Mr. Torres. What good is a free option if you are unaware of it? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Sorry? Mr. Torres. What good is a free option if you are unaware of it? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Exactly. Mr. Torres. Yes, so, and I feel like those are imminently solvable problems that I am proud to co-lead the legislation with Congressman Steil. He is more rural than I am, so I am happy to elicit your feedback. Ms. Reynolds Hand. Thank you. Mr. Torres. Yep. Mr. Zywicki. I will just add it warms my heart to hear you talking about reexamining APR as a way of disclosing products to consumers exactly as you said. We talked about this in---- Mr. Torres. I am not sure if I said that, but---- Mr. Zywicki. Right, but---- Mr. Torres. Only in the EWA context. Mr. Zywicki. Right, but to compare apples to apples, right, consumers compared to, say, an overdraft or the late fee on a bill, they look at dollars a lot of times rather than APR. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentleman from North Carolina, Mr. Moore, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Moore. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Financial technology is transforming how Americans earn, spend, and save their money. From peer-to-peer payment apps and digital wallets to earned wage access and installation products, fintech innovations are responding to real consumer needs for speed and affordability. These products exist because they fill gaps in the traditional financial system, especially for consumers who have historically faced limited options or high costs. With my questions, I will start with Mr. Zywicki. Are there any particular populations--hourly workers, gig workers, rural communities--who benefit most from fintech services, and how are these tools especially helpful to them? Mr. Zywicki. Yes. The evidence on this is abundant at this point that traditionally underserved communities are the ones who benefit the most from fintech and fintech innovations, whether it is rural, whether it is young people. BNPL, for example, is used heavily by Gen Z and Millennials. Earned wage access obviously is very popular and used a lot by hourly workers who often live paycheck to paycheck. Upper-income people are using these more, especially BNPL, but, really, the value proposal proposition is for those groups. Fintech and fintech underwriting, use of alternative data like cash-flow data as opposed to credit scores and the like, the evidence on that is very clear that increases competition and benefits people most who are traditionally underserved and where traditional competition among banks is not very robust, which includes rural communities, obviously. Mr. Moore. Mr. Palaniappan and Mr. Lefton, how have earned wage access services improved financial stability for workers, and how are these products helping make everyday expenses more manageable? Mr. Palaniappan. Thank you for the question. The first thing that earned wage access does, which is what most people expect, is it helps people pay their bills on time so there are fewer late fees on bills, there are fewer other expensive fees because they are paying their bills on time. There are also nonfinancial benefits where there is less stress. So, I hear from our customers how they are able to send their children on field trips because they have access to our product, which they would not have been able to do otherwise, celebrate birthdays on the right days, go to see a dentist when the tooth starts aching instead of putting that off to Friday. I spoke with a customer. She works in healthcare and her daughter likes to dance. She has to pay for dance classes at the beginning of every month, and she would not have been able to do that without EarnIn. So, her daughter goes for dance classes and, today, takes part in dance competitions and can follow her passion for dance because of EarnIn. The other benefit that I spoke about in the testimony as well is that incomes go up. Incomes go up by over 10 percent. From the EarnIn dataset, a study on over a million customers, incomes went up by 11-and-a-half percent. That is about $335 per month, and so we are seeing incomes go up as well when people start using earned wage access. From our data, we are actually seeing incomes go up faster than inflation, and so we are seeing wage growth in real terms as well. Mr. Moore. Over what time period have you seen those increases? Mr. Palaniappan. We have seen wage increases higher than inflation over the last 3 years. Mr. Moore. Mr. Lefton, did you care to respond as well? Mr. Lefton. Sure. Well, first, I agree with everything that was just said. I think one of the things we need to remember when we are talking about EWA is that EWA users are not financially illiterate. They are just experiencing a frequency- of-pay issue, and so I think it is important we do not conflate the two, right? Consumers use EWA because they need to be paid on their own timeline, not because they do not know how to manage their own money. I think that is a very important distinction. We need to trust that the user is in the best position to know how and when to access their wages and manage their money. Mr. Moore. One thing that seems to have worked to me at the State level and otherwise is really to try to bring about innovation. Like the regulatory sandbox legislation, our State adopted that a couple of years ago, and it allows financial institutions and technology firms to test new products under the supervision of regulators. So, I guess just a follow up question to Mr. Zywicki: how can regulatory sandboxes help regulators better understand new fintech products before imposing broad rules? Mr. Zywicki. Yes. Briefly, I will just amplify on the EWA question some of the points that my colleagues have made here, which is, I think the best study on this is the Davis study, who, in addition to finding income goes up, also finds that there are no financial problems--people do not overdraft more, do any of that sort of stuff--as opposed to the Connecticut study where they found losing access to EWA led to a lot more payday, having to sell products, and that sort of thing. With respect to sandboxes, I think sandboxes are revolutionary. I think they are super important. The ability to get real-time information, tweak products. Even the discrimination-type questions that were being raised, I think could be addressed very well with regulatory sandboxes to make sure those products operate the way they should. Mr. Moore. Thank you, and my time is up. I did have other questions for the other witnesses, but I appreciate you all being here today. With that, I yield back. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. The gentlewoman from Texas, Ms. Garcia, is recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Garcia. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all the witnesses, and I first want to associate my remarks with the remarks of Mr. Torres. I think they were right on point. To the chairman, I did not sack potatoes, but I sure as hell picked cotton. [Laughter.] Ms. Garcia. We did not get paid daily. We had to work our asses off in the hot Texas heat all week until we saw any money Friday afternoon but it just underscores the point that workers do deserve to get paid and get paid well, and not under the table, to avoid all these things, and to make sure that they can have access to their money when they are needed. Like Representative Pressley said, I am waiting for the layaway plan because one of the things my mother used to do at the beginning of the cotton season is take us into town, and we would pick what we thought we might need for school in September, and then she would pay weekly until we got to September. Now, if you gain a little weight, you are in trouble, but that is how it was done, and some people are still living paycheck to paycheck. According to the Urban Institute, 52 percent of Americans do not have the money to cover essential costs, such as housing, food, healthcare, childcare, transportation, and education. Fifty-two percent. That is a lot of people, but in my district it is even worse: 74 percent. Let that sink in. So, as many of my colleagues mentioned, there is an affordability crisis. To call it a hoax is just flat a hoax. The American people are struggling to support themselves and their families day by day, paycheck to paycheck. That is why many Americans turn to alternative income sources that we have been discussing today. However, as financial technology and these products become more common, I share my colleagues' concerns that without consumer protection, these products will only take more money out of consumers' pockets. Ms. Hand, as we discuss how to regulate these products, several people have said that especially the earned wage access is free. Is it really free? Ms. Reynolds Hand. There are a variety of different products in the marketplace. In fact, we have recently looked at 23 different companies out there, both employer-sponsored and direct-to-consumers. The employer-sponsored products are typically less risky and, basically, you see what you have heard here today. Ms. Garcia. But are they free? Ms. Reynolds Hand. Those products can be free. For more of the direct-to-consumer products, some of them have free options, but then they do have fees, so they are effectively not free. Some of those free options we have seen are hidden, and consumers are defaulted into fee structures which may be clear and hidden. The other thing that I would add is that many consumers are using these on a weekly basis, so they are effectively stacking fees on a weekly basis and then their ability to repay over time. So, I would say that, effectively, these are not free products. Ms. Garcia. Okay. Now, what about the buy now, pay later? Is that free? Ms. Reynolds Hand. There are simple products, pay in 4, where if a consumer is successful, that is effectively a free service. Then you go down the installment path where these are loans, they are structured as such, they have interest, and I think one of the challenges that we have seen is oftentimes-- the consumers and our research support this--they see an advertisement, they go to pay for something, and they get offered the pay in 4 product. Then they go through the application, and they end up in an installment loan product and, oftentimes, are not really aware of the long-term effects, so it is not free. Ms. Garcia. So, do some have the APR as high as was illustrated by his example? I mean $1 on a hundred dollars does not sound bad, but once you do the math, the percentage is really high. Ms. Reynolds Hand. Yes. If that one dollar then gets deferred, you add on late fees. If those apply or the consumer simply does not have the ability to repay in the time that they have originally agreed to, that will put a consumer into a fee structure. Ms. Garcia. Yep. Just curious, what would you consider a fair fee for the service? Let us not talk yet about penalties and installment payments later or anything. It seems to me that one of these products is no more than a high-tech payday loan service. Chairman Steil. We will allow the gentlewoman to submit answers in the record. Ms. Garcia. I was just beginning to have fun. [Laughter.] Ms. Garcia. Thank you. Thank you to all the witnesses. Chairman Steil. We thank the gentlewoman. The gentlewoman yields back. The gentleman from California, Mr. Liccardo, is recognized for 5 minutes. Mr. Liccardo. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank all the witnesses for their testimony and, particularly, Mr. Palaniappan--please forgive me if I just mispronounced your name--but it is good to have a local company here, and congratulations on the great success of your company. I appreciate very much what EarnIn has done to enable millions of American workers to have more freedom in their lives. That is very important. I also, by the way, appreciate Ms. Reynolds Hand's important observations. I think we have good players and we have bad players in this industry. Like all industries, we need transparency. We appreciate those who are transparent, and for those who are not, that is why we need simple, predictable regulations, so very much appreciate points being made all around. I would like to shift gears, though, from EWA to the broader topic of the hearing and the subcommittee, which is around fintech regulation and innovation. Ms. Kelley, I am going to turn to you because I know you represent a lot of folks in the industry. An awful lot of focus in recent weeks and months has been whether or not fintech companies can get access to the Federal payment rails--FedNow-- and other transmission means, like Fedwire. I think there has been a lot of discussion, certainly Treasury publicly as well at the Federal Reserve. There is now, I think, a request for information from the Fed. They are looking for feedback about what a skinny account might look like or a payment account as a, I guess, an option that would be distinct from a master account. I guess, regardless of whether the Fed or Congress creates this, clearly there needs to be some regulation on those fintech companies that would avail themselves of this opportunity and there are a lot of ideas from the Bank Policy Institute (BPI), from Fed, and others about what regulations those companies should be subject to, things like Bank Secrecy Act and Know Your Customer (KYC), and anti-money laundering, whether or not they should be prohibited from overdrafting, from charging interest, et cetera. Do you have some views about what regulations would be appropriate for us to be thinking about here? Ms. Kelley. Yes, and thank you for the question. It is a particularly dynamic and interesting time to be in this industry, and I think what you have just described reflects that. So, I would start by saying in the relationships that exist now between banks and fintechs where they partner to provide services, there is a holistic set of regulations. There were interagency guidelines that were released in 2023 that, effectively, require banks to ensure that their fintech partners are following the same regulatory requirements that the banks must follow. So we are operating against that backdrop. As we look forward and say should these nontraditional bank fintechs have access to the Federal Reserve, that is a conversation that has begun with the request for information (RFI) and the conversations around the skinny master accounts. We are in very early days of those conversations, and I know the industry as a whole is still trying to understand exactly what that would look like but what is clear is there needs to continue to be a balance between fostering innovation that we see from nontraditional banks, but ensuring safety and soundness as well. The skinny master accounts is one attempt to strike that balance and, again, still in the early days. Mr. Liccardo. Okay. So, no commitments yet about what concessions industry might make, about what regulations would be sensible for this---- Ms. Kelley. Yes, I think it is still an open question. Mr. Liccardo. Okay. Well, I look forward to continuing to engage with you and with your members to understand what that might look like. Ms. Kelley. Absolutely. Mr. Liccardo. I think this is coming at us pretty fast, and we probably need to understand best how to respond. Regardless, I appreciate the efforts of many fintech companies to innovate in a space where I think consumers do need more choices, and I appreciate the work that is being done by many of the companies here. Thank you. Chairman Steil. The gentleman yields back. I would like to thank all of our members for their questions today, all of our witnesses for your testimony today. Without objection, all members will have 5 legislative days to submit additional written questions for the witnesses to the chair. The questions will be forwarded to the witnesses for their response. Witnesses will please respond no later than February 17. [The information referred to can be found in the appendix.] Chairman Steil. The hearing stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:01 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.] APPENDIX ---------- MATERIALS SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]