Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES: UNDERSTANDING LONG-TERM CARE OPTIONS FOR OLDER ADULTS [Senate Hearing 118-306] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 118-306 ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES: UNDERSTANDING LONG-TERM CARE OPTIONS FOR OLDER ADULTS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED EIGHTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION ---------- WASHINGTON, DC ---------- JANUARY 25, 2024 ---------- Serial No. 118-14 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES: UNDERSTANDING LONG-TERM CARE OPTIONS FOR OLDER ADULTS S. Hrg. 118-306 ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES: UNDERSTANDING LONG-TERM CARE OPTIONS FOR OLDER ADULTS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED EIGHTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ WASHINGTON, DC __________ JANUARY 25, 2024 __________ Serial No. 118-14 Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 55-769 WASHINGTON : 2024 SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania, Chairman KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York MIKE BRAUN, Indiana RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut TIM SCOTT, South Carolina ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts MARCO RUBIO, Florida MARK KELLY, Arizona RICK SCOTT, Florida RAPHAEL WARNOCK, Georgia J.D. VANCE, Ohio JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska ---------- Elizabeth Letter, Majority Staff Director Matthew Sommer, Minority Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman...... 1 Opening Statement of Senator Mike Braun, Ranking Member.......... 3 PANEL OF WITNESSES Patricia Vessenmeyer, Advocate, Gainesville, Virginia............ 5 Jennifer Craft Morgan, Ph.D, Director and Professor, the Gerontology Institute, Georgia State University, Waleska, Georgia........................................................ 7 Julie Simpkins, Co-President, Gardant Management Solutions, Indianapolis, Indiana.......................................... 9 Richard Mollot, Executive Director, Long Term Care Community Coalition, New York City, New York............................. 11 APPENDIX Prepared Witness Statements Patricia Vessenmeyer, Advocate, Gainesville, Virginia............ 37 Jennifer Craft Morgan, Ph.D, Director and Professor, the Gerontology Institute, Georgia State University, Waleska, Georgia........................................................ 39 Julie Simpkins, Co-President, Gardant Management Solutions, Indianapolis, Indiana.......................................... 45 Richard Mollot, Executive Director, Long Term Care Community Coalition, New York City, New York............................. 47 Questions for the Record Patricia Vessenmeyer, Advocate, Gainesville, Virginia............ 53 Jennifer Craft Morgan, Ph.D, Director and Professor, the Gerontology Institute, Georgia State University, Waleska, Georgia........................................................ 54 Julie Simpkins, Co-President, Gardant Management Solutions, Indianapolis, Indiana.......................................... 58 Richard Mollot, Executive Director, Long Term Care Community Coalition, New York City, New York............................. 78 Statements for the Record Alzheimer's Association and Alzheimer's Impact Movement Statement 85 Argentum Expanding Senior Living Statement....................... 93 Oregon Health Care Association Statement......................... 105 Health Care Association of Michigan Statement.................... 109 Leading Age Statement............................................ 110 Justice in Aging Special Report.................................. 119 AARP of Arizona: The Arizona Reuplic Article..................... 142 National Center for Assisted Living Statement.................... 167 Pennsylvania Health Care Association Statement................... 169 Country Meadows Retirement Communities Statement................. 173 Delaware Health Care Facilities Association...................... 175 Nebraska Health Care Association Statement....................... 177 Florida Health Care Association Statement........................ 179 American Seniors Housing Association Statement................... 180 Center for Excellence in Assisted Living Statement............... 186 Julie Simpkins additional Exhibits Submitted..................... 190 ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES: UNDERSTANDING LONG-TERM CARE OPTIONS FOR OLDER ADULTS ---------- Thursday, January 25, 2024 U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:03 a.m., Room 106, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senator Casey, Blumenthal, Warren, Kelly, Warnock, Fetterman, Braun, Rick Scott, Vance, and Ricketts. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., CHAIRMAN The Chairman. The Senate Special Committee on Aging will come to order. As Chairman of the Aging Committee, my top priority is keeping our promises to older Americans and to Americans with disabilities. We owe it to every older adult, every person with a disability, and their families to have the necessary information to decide when, where, and how to receive care as they age. That has motivated my advocacy, for example, for home and community-based services. Every American who wants to receive care at home should be able to do so, and the workers providing that care must be paid, in my judgment, a living wage. It has similarly motivated my work to ensure that nursing homes are providing safe, quality care for all of their residents. We need to address the chronic underfunding and understaffing for the state agencies that conduct nursing home oversight, so they can effectively protect the health and safety of residents. This core mission of the Aging Committee brings us to today's topic, the topic of assisted living and that landscape. It has been 20 years since this Committee held a hearing on assisted living. With the dramatic growth of the assisted living industry in recent decades, it is long past time for Congress to reexamine this model and ensure that it is meeting our Nation's needs. The best estimates reveal that nearly one million Americans live in more than 30,000 assisted living facilities across our Nation, and that is almost certainly an undercount of that number. Assisted living facilities are state regulated residences that support assisted living while offering help with the activities--with activities of daily living, like bathing and medication management. They also often provide meaningful engagement and activities for their residents. Assisted living was first envisioned as a social model for residents who needed lower levels of support, but today, people living in assisted living facilities are older, require more care, and have health care needs similar to that of those who reside in a nursing home, and the needs of the assisted living population change. As those needs change, we need to know that--if assisted living facilities are meeting the needs of those residents or the needs of their families. One major issue I hear a lot about is cost. Assisted living facilities are widely unaffordable to the average American and their family. A recent survey found that 80 percent of older adults would be unable to afford, unable to afford, four years in an assisted living facility. The average annual cost is $54,000 a year, but the costs can be substantially higher depending upon the location and the type of care that a resident requires. The more assistance and care a resident needs, the more they pay. In some cases, residents and their families don't know the total cost until they receive their monthly bill. These substantial costs and often hidden fees make it nearly impossible for older adults and their families to accurately budget for long-term care. Now, that is one of the reasons why I am starting today, I am asking Pennsylvanians and people across the country to share their stories and their bills with us. I want to hear from you about the true cost of assisted living and understand whether families have the information that they need to make difficult financial and health care decisions. I am just going to hold up the--website address for those who need it. You can go to aging.senate.gov/ assistedlivingbills, all one word, assistedlivingbills, to share your stories. I think it is very important that we hear from people, hear from people about their own experience as family members, as people who are paying the bill and also expecting the promises that are made when someone becomes a resident of an assisted living facility. It is only by hearing those stories, only by hearing those--hearing about those experiences, can we bring the needed change that I know we all agree has to come. The assisted living industry is also facing the same workforce crisis that we see across other long-term care settings, and even beyond long-term care. It is also true in the context of childcare and so many other parts of our healthcare and care landscape. Workers are often struggling to support their own families because direct care workers are paid an average of just $15 an hour nationwide. Workers provide a higher level of care to support residents' growing needs, especially residents with dementia, but training requirements and worker support look very different in each state. As we will hear from our witnesses, these challenges make it harder for families to find the information that they need about assisted living facilities, including how much it will cost, the quality of the services they receive, and how safe their family member will be. A recent Washington Post investigation found that since 2018, more than 2,000 people have left assisted living facilities unsupervised and have been left unattended outside. Tragically, 98, 98 of these 2,000 incidents have resulted in the death of the resident, and those are just the cases that have been reported. The findings of the post investigation demonstrate how urgent it is that Congress better understand this industry. There has also been significant reporting by the New York Times and in KFF in a series written before the end of last year. To help in our understanding, I have sent letters to three of the largest corporate owners of America's assisted living facilities. These letters request information about costs, workforce, safety, and availability of information about quality and services in assisted living facilities. I hope these letters, or I should say the response to the letters, will improve transparency in the assisted living industry and help to inform policy solutions to address some of these concerns. As families are making difficult decisions about where to age, they deserve to know that their loved ones are safe. I think we can all agree on that, and assisted living providers making promises they cannot keep is a violation of trust. As we continue to increase the quality of the continuum of long-term care for older adults, it is time we prioritize efforts to improve the assisted living care option. If we say we are, as a Nation, the United States, the greatest country in the world, then we have to have the best, not second, not third, the best long-term care in the world, and we are not there yet. Older adults and people with disabilities who call assisted living facilities home, we have to remember this is their home, their residence, where they live, where their families come to see them--if those older adults and people with disabilities are calling those facilities home, they should have quality, affordable care. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses today, and I will turn to Ranking Member Braun for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR MIKE BRAUN, RANKING MEMBER Senator Braun. Thank you, Chairman Casey. You know, in 2050, you think the problem is bad now, one in four Americans will be 65 years of age or older. With an aging population that we know is coming at us, thank goodness we have hearings like this to highlight what you are going to do about it. Sometimes the market doesn't do the job. I do want to say that ideally, these things are crafted through the market and probably with states leading the way, and I say that for one big reason. I am on the Budget Committee, and the biggest thing that challenges this place is how you would add something even further to the list of things you want to do when we are now borrowing $1 trillion every six months instead of annually, and that has just changed over the last five years, so we have to be careful, but it still has nothing to do with a problem or an issue that is out there, and this is about highlighting who can do it best and how you get there. Chronic workforce shortage. When I travel, visit all 92 counties in Indiana--pre-COVID, that was the number one issue, and it is about double now the number of jobs in my own State. I think it is close to 130,000. It was 65,000. Caregivers, large percentage of whom are--that assistance is given by independent contractors, you know, small business owners. We need to figure out how to enable that, make it easier how you actually have your curriculums in various states and school systems that show the full spectrum of what jobs are out there and where the needs are. Senator Kaine and I introduced the Jobs Act here, which allows students to use Federal Pell Grants for high quality, short term, job training programs. That is a good Federal program. Does not add much to it. It is increasing the flexibility of how you can use it. Senators Rosen, Collins and I also introduced the Train More Nurses Act, which reviews all nursing grant programs to find ways of increasing nursing pathways. Happy to hear some things do work well here. That passed, I think, by unanimous consent last night in the U.S. Senate, so now we got to get it over to the House to do the same thing. The Federal Government should make it easier for people to enter the health care workforce and for families to take care of their loved ones by making sure that it is energizing the people that may be interested in it and in the places they are going to probably be doing the heavy lifting. Right now, for instance, the Biden Administration is saying one thing and actually doing another, I come from the world of small business, independent contractors, retailers, individuals that make their living out of maybe running a small business. The independent contractor rule that is out there, which would make that more difficult, could eliminate many of the existing caregiver jobs for that reason, so you got to make sure you are not wanting to do something, and then you are working at a cross purpose through another agency that will make it even more difficult. Unlike nursing homes that are regulated by both Federal and State agencies, assisted living facilities are primarily regulated by states. To increase safety and transparency, Indiana requires staffing ratios, dementia training, and maintains a website that discloses, reports and enforcement actions. States and assisted living facilities are also working to find creative ways to use existing resources to assist seniors. Indiana is using a combination of State and Federal tools to provide more affordable assisted living to Hoosiers. As a result, Indiana has seen affordability and quality improve. However, there is always more work to be done. Some of my colleagues may be tempted to call for a shift toward increased Federal involvement and regulation. I would say be careful. Help us get best practices out there. Help us have an environment to get it done where it is normally done more effectively and more affordably, at lower levels of Government. I believe that states are best positioned to meet that growing need. I am glad we here at the Federal level, this is the big microphone that has to highlight the issues, that is what we are doing here today. Thank you to all the panelists for being here, and I am interested to see what we can come up with. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Braun. We will next turn to our witness introductions. I am grateful for the time and the work that goes into an appearance from our witnesses. Our first witness this morning is Ms. Patty Vessenmeyer from Gainesville, Virginia. Her first husband, John Whitney, had dementia and lived in an assisted living facility at the end of his life. She will share some of her and her husband's experiences, where she supported him in an assisted living setting. Patty, we are grateful you are here today. Thank you. Our second witness is as Dr. Jennifer Kraft Morgan. Dr. Morgan is from Waleska, Georgia. Dr. Morgan is a Professor and Director of the Gerontology Institute at Georgia State University. She studies issues related to long-term care dementia and the health care workforce. Thanks for being with us today, doctor. Our third witness is Julie Simpkins, and I will turn to ranking member Braun for that introduction. Senator Braun. Julie Simpkins is the Co-President of Gardant Management Systems. She has been in the long-term care arena for nearly 30 years. Ms. Simpkins focuses on affordable assisted living, and she advocates for both providers and older Americans in Gardant's 82 facilities across the country. She leads on several state and national associations, including the Indiana Health Care Association Board of Directors and the National Center for Assisted Living Board of directors. Thank you for testifying here today. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Braun. Our fourth and final witnesses is Richard Mollot. He is the Executive Director of the Long Term Care Community Coalition. This coalition works to provide families with unbiased information about nursing homes, assisted living facilities, and other long-term care settings. Thanks for being with us today, and we will turn to our first witness, Patty Vessenmeyer. STATEMENT OF PATRICIA VESSENMEYER, ADVOCATE, GAINESVILLE, VIRGINIA Ms. Vessenmeyer. Good morning, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and members of the Senate Special Committee on Aging. My name is Patty Vessenmeyer and thank you for allowing me to share this testimony of my experience with assisted living for my husband, John Whitney, during his journey through the middle stage of dementia. I will focus on my experiences and observations that I believe are most relevant to your national focus. In 2013, my husband was diagnosed with dementia with Lewy Body. Although this dementia is similar to Alzheimer's, it manifests itself a bit differently and it is important that caregivers be informed and trained to ensure the comfort, safety, and security of their patients. Some key systems are loss of sense of smell, REM sleep behavior disorder, which causes individuals to violently act out dreams, often falling out of bed, visual hallucinations, marked fluctuations in attention and alertness, and gastrointestinal issues, including severe constipation, all of which my husband experienced. Loss of memory often occurs much later in this disease process. I took several free courses on caregiving for individuals with dementia, including a virtual reality dementia experience, which helped me to understand the challenges that people with this disorder face, and most importantly, why they become fearful and combative. I mentioned this to provide a basis for my ability to recognize problems with care as I saw it. These same courses are offered for professionals at reasonable costs. In June 2017, when my husband's disease was progressing more rapidly, I moved to Virginia to be near family. I cared for him alone at home until January 26th, 2018, when he attempted to strangle me in my bed. The State determined that John should be placed in a long-term care facility. I found him a room in assisted living facility in Warrenton, Virginia that specialized in memory care. He moved in the first week of March in 2018. I provided the management team with John's history, his diagnosis, and disease progression. The following is a list of issues that I observed in the Memory Care Unit during my daily visits with John. Poor facility design. There were blocks of rooms built around a large central room for group activities and TV. The central room was extremely loud and high levels of noise can easily agitate dementia patients. Activity stations were set up for residents. One of these had various lengths of PVC pipe, not kidding, some longer than a baseball bat. These were weapons in waiting and you can guess what happened. There was no quiet area for the residents other than their rooms. The hallways in the room blocks were isolated, making it difficult for staff to monitor. There were many incidents that I witnessed when there were no staff around. I will share one that I feel was very important. A woman fell by tripping on a raised area on the floor where the rug abutted the hard flooring. Nobody saw her fall. I found her bloody and staggering down the hallway. A company knowledgeable about dementia care would not design a facility this way. They would certainly understand that people with dementia have problems with gait and balance, and do understand, there were video cameras in place, but they only used them for reviewing incidents after the fact. They were understaffed. Too many patients were assigned to each caregiver. In the morning, each caregiver needed to give their assigned residence--get them up and dressed and ready for breakfast. Everybody ate at the same time, putting additional pressure on the staff. They only gave residents a shower when necessary, as they were always pressed for time. Caregivers needed extra time to spend on residents in more advanced--sorry, stages of dementia, as they required help to move from their bed to a wheelchair and be hand fed. After lunch, the caregivers would place most of the resident in chairs in the main room while they worked getting the advanced stage patients back into their beds. Every day after lunch, my husband urgently needed to empty his bowels. Several times when I was there, I tried to help him, but it was difficult for me as I had had a broken arm at the time. I could not find anybody, so I did the best I could, and often when I was not there, he soiled himself while waiting for help. I once believe I saved a man's life. I was with my husband in a room off the main activity area. I heard someone crying for help. I ran into the hallway and found an old man on the floor, trying to protect himself from being beaten with his own cane by another resident. I called for help, quickly moving closer and redirecting the attacker's attention. I kept him busy while calmly calling for assistance, trying not to further agitate him. It took several minutes before a staff member finally heard me and came to help. Night was no better as staff levels were lower as allowed by state regulations. They placed residents who had trouble sleeping in front of a TV while they dealt with other residents. Inadequate staff training. Most of their caregivers staff were trained as nurse's aides, but nothing specific to memory care that I could see. I witnessed them providing new hires dementia training care in a conference room. This consisted of a member of the management team showing them parts of Glen Campbell Zombie movie and pointing out some behaviors that demonstrated his dementia problems. I saw that movie and it was not appropriate for training purposes. I observed several instances where caregivers and nurses displayed limited knowledge of working with dementia patients, particularly those in mid-stage of the disease, who became more fearful and combative. Some examples: Nurses running toward the patient, causing the resident to become combative. Quick, erratic hand movements frightening the individual, and another example, the TV was on at 9:30 p.m. with extremely high volume. Several residents were seated in chairs and wheelchairs in front of the TV. Anyone who understands dementia and sundowning would never do this. They were overstimulating these residents instead of allowing them to relax and quiet their minds for sleep, and finally, at one point, the director of this facility told me to spend less time there and let them do their jobs. Well, I could not abide because I felt they weren't doing their jobs. In closing, unless things change, I could never recommend using this type of facility for a loved one unless things improve. I am hoping that you found my testimony helpful, and the Committee will find a way to set some national standards for appropriate levels of staffing and training for that staff. This would be a huge step in improving assisted living. Thank you for your time. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Ms. Vessenmeyer. I appreciate your testimony. Dr. Morgan. STATEMENT OF JENNIFER CRAFT MORGAN, PH.D., DIRECTOR AND PROFESSOR, THE GERONTOLOGY INSTITUTE, GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY, WALESKA, GEORGIA Dr. Morgan. Good morning, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and the members of the Committee. I am honored and delighted to be here. Thank you, Patty, for sharing that story. Assisted living is a large and growing long-term care residential option for individuals who need or want additional supports for activities of daily living. There are approximately 30,600 AL communities in the U.S., with approximately 820,000 residents employing about 500,000 workers. AL, often seen by the public as interchangeable with skilled nursing homes, was built and is regulated as a social model of care. This community-based care is less restrictive and strives to be home like. AL residents vary greatly in the amount of care they need from person to person. Rising acuity levels do mean that as residents age in place, they likely require more health services. While these services could overlay AL services, much like they would if the person was needing--needing care was at home, these are not provided directly by the AL communities. The haphazard growth of this model and the tensions between social care and health care inherent have spurred calls by scholars for assisted living to be reimagined. Most AL residents need help with medications, and more than half need help with three or more activities of daily living. AL residents depend on their care networks. The constellation of kin and non-kin involved in residents' lives to arrange medical care, to provide social support, to coordinate care, to engage residents, and activities, and bring needed supplies. These care works also play an important role in advocating for residents and negotiating care with AL staff. About 42 percent of AL residents have a dementia diagnosis, but we can assume this is underreported as many older adults are not screened, tested, or diagnosed with dementia, despite showing symptoms and memory thinking or making decisions that impact everyday life. Like all people with chronic disease, people living with dementia have good days and bad days. Person centered dementia care is needed to tailor care and support to individuals in ways that account for preferences, life experiences, communication styles, and support needs that change over time. According to MCAL, the average monthly cost of AL is $4,500. As such, AL is inaccessible to most Americans. Yet on the spectrum of long-term care, it is often needed. Seen as a step between unpaid care by loved ones and nursing home care, AL provides an a very important long-term care option. When the care of NE care needs of a loved one exceeds the capacity of their care network, the person and their care network is forced to navigate with little support or education, a variety of options, none of which are usually covered by health insurance. If they have significant financial resources, AL is a useful and attractive option. If not, managing the care situation means they care partners reduce working hours, build precarious care or financial arrangements across families, hire piecemeal personal care support, or simply cross their fingers and hope that it all works out. Sixty-six percent of the AL workforce are aides or direct care workers. Direct care workers in AL and across long-term care are predominantly women, people of color, and disproportionately immigrants. The typical direct care worker, a Senator Casey said, makes about $15 an hour, works 36 hours a week in assisted living, and works for a for profit company. AL workers, like most direct care workers, tend to go into this line of work to give back, to make a difference because they value elders or because it is a calling for them. Unfortunately, the system we have set up works against them. Direct care workers in long-term care settings experience low wages, few benefits, heavy workloads, dangerous jobs, and little to no career mobility. In her book, Disrupting the Status Quo of Senior Living. A Mindshift, Jill Vitale-Aussem lays out what I think is the crux of the problems facing senior living. AL is marketed to those who can afford it with a hospitality mindset. They advertise and compete on the basis of beautiful campuses, luxury food and furnishings, and concierge services. This model encourages residents and families to think about this next step as though they are going to a hotel or a resort. This framing, where residents are guests and staff are encouraged to cater to their whims, increases what Dr. Bill Thomas of the Eden Alternative calls the three plagues of long- term care, helplessness, boredom, and loneliness. By encouraging passivity, we leave residents with few opportunities for giving back or creative pursuits. Instead, long-term care that is person centered, community minded, and empowering for residents, staff, and care partners has a much better chance of success. My recommendations include improve and standardize initial continuing education training--initial and continuing education training for direct care workers and all staff in assisted living. Professionalize the direct care workforce. Incentivize and reward good employers who deliver high quality care. Increase access to assisted living. Improve care coordination and resources for people living with dementia and their care partners, and support standardization of monitoring and resources to increase state-based oversight and transparency. Thank you. The Chairman. Thank you, doctor, very much for your testimony. Ms. Simpkins, you may begin. STATEMENT OF JULIE SIMPKINS, CO-PRESIDENT, GARDANT MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS, INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA Ms. Simpkins. Thank you. Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and members of the U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging, thank you for inviting me here today to be part of this important discussion on assisted living, a topic that is very near to my heart. My name is Julie Simpkins, and I am the Co-President of Gardant Management Solutions. We are a provider that develops and operates senior living, assisted living, and memory care communities. We are the fifth largest assisted living provider in the country and have communities in five states, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Maryland, and West Virginia. I have dedicated most of my life to senior living, with over 30 years to the assisted living sector. This is my calling, and I would like to speak with you today about Gardant's unique model, as we share thoughts and how we can work together on important issues facing those who need and work in assisted living. Gardant is uniquely focused on offering affordable assisted living to low-income seniors. Our company was founded in 1999 after the creation of the Illinois Supportive Living Program, which is a home and community-based waiver program. Now, as we expanded into four other states, our commitment to serving this population remains. Many residents living in Gardant communities rely on Medicaid for their assisted living care through these waiver programs. Gardant has been limited in where we can offer our services due to the variability with state Medicaid waiver programs. It depends on the availability of state programs, of state reimbursement levels, and the number of available waiver spots. Offering affordable assisted living exclusively or even for a majority of residents like Gardant requires an entirely different business model altogether. We have had to persistently seek out HUD loans and income tax credits to stay viable. Therefore, we support efforts to make long-term care, including assisted living, more affordable to low and middle income individuals. With a rapidly growing elderly population, we need a public and private partnership to incentivize more providers to develop these models. When we talk about assisted living, it is important to note that every state, every community, and every resident is different. Efforts to standardize all assisted living communities would be both unworkable and irresponsible for resident care. State regulations recognize the diversity within assisted living by holding our profession accountable, and they are consistently updated to reflect the evolving nature of our sector and our residents. Meanwhile, Gardant is committed to exceeding the state requirements when we believe it is in the best interest of our residents. We will take memory care as an example and something that is top of mind for this Committee, as well as our residents and family. Every staff member at Gardant's memory care communities receive education and training in dementia related diseases, as well as training as a certified dementia practitioner. While elopements are rare, we all report to the state immediately, even something as technical as a resident walking out the door instantly returning with a staff member. We know they didn't leave our community and our staff immediately addressed the situation, but we still reported. The recent reports of resident elopements that were ultimately fatal are heartbreaking, and my thoughts and prayers go out to the loved ones of those residents. I serve in leadership positions on numerous national organizations dedicated to long-term care, and I know these tragic incidents are extremely rare and not indicative of the assisted living experience. The overwhelming majority of families and residents have a life affirming, safe experience. Assisted living providers are committed to upholding our policies and procedures, as well as continuing to learn all that we can about dementia care to prevent these incidents. It is critical that policies and regulations help protect residents while still supporting their freedom of movement and independence. Assisted living is a critical aspect of the long-term care continuum and dedicated to delivering person centered care to our Nation's seniors. We need collaborative, comprehensive solutions that ensure our ability as assisted living communities to continue doing what we do best, providing safe, quality care to our residents. From expanding more affordable long-term care options, to workforce programs, to addressing the growing caregiver shortages, these efforts could make a real difference. We must all work together to ensure current and future assisting living resident is seen, safe, and served to enjoy the highest quality of life possible. Thank you for your time and I look forward to answering your questions today. The Chairman. Thank you, Ms. Simpkins, for your testimony, and we will turn to our fourth and final witness, Mr. Mollot. STATEMENT OF RICHARD MOLLOT, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, LONG TERM CARE COMMUNITY COALITION, NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK Mr. Mollot. Good morning, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and members of the Committee. Thank you for inviting me to testify today on this important issue. My name is Richard Mollot, and I am the Executive Director of the Long Term Care Community Coalition. LTCCC is a national, nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to improving care and quality of life for residents in nursing homes and assisted living. We conduct research on long-term care policies and the extent to which essential standards of care are realized in the lives of residents who are typically elderly and frail. In addition to conducting analysis and advocacy, we educate and engage residents, families, and those who work with them so that they are aware of their rights and are equipped to overcome the challenges that so many of our seniors face when they need residential care. Our interest in assisted living is long standing, and we appreciate your commitments to ensuring that the promise of assisted living is realized in the lives of our growing senior population. Assisted living emerged in the 1980's as an alternate to nursing homes for seniors who want or need to live in a congregate setting where they can get help with tasks like housekeeping, meal preparation, and access to activities and transportation. Over the last 40 years, three developments have drastically changed the nature and character of the assisted living sector, with both positive and negative implications. They are one, the needs and frailty of assisted living residents have dramatically increased. Two, assisted living operators have adopted increasingly sophisticated and large scale corporate models, including ownership by real estate investment trusts, private equity, and other sophisticated private investment structures, and three, public payment for and Government interest in assisted living has increased significantly. Assisted living facilities now care for people who in many ways have the same needs and vulnerabilities as nursing home residents. Assisted living residents are actually older on average and those in nursing homes. Approximately 40 to 70 percent of assisted living residents have Alzheimer's disease or some other cognitive impairment. Over half have hypertension. One third or more have heart disease or depression. About half need help with dressing and, or walking, and two thirds need help with bathing. Over 10 percent of residents with dementia receive antipsychotic drugs. Unfortunately, we as a country have failed to keep up with these trends. While some assisted living can be wonderful places to live and to work, too many take in or retain residents for whom they are unable to provide safe care and dignified living conditions. Too many residents and families are at risk for financial exploitation and even fraud. Too many seniors and families get taken in by promises of ``memory care'' and aging in place, when in fact these are more often marketing terms than accurate representations of specialized care. The absence of any Federal quality of safety standards, coupled with the virtual absence of reliable public information on the quality, safety, and cost of assisted living, have made assisted living a sector ripe for investment by sophisticated private enterprises who can shuffle around resources and take profits, with little regard for the promises made to seniors and their family. These problems occur at every economic level, from $50,000 a month or more paid to luxury assisted living, to the 20 percent of seniors who access assisted living through public funds like Medicaid waivers. It doesn't have to be this way. Forty years ago, when nursing homes were in crisis, Congress took action. From numerous GAO reports to the growing chorus of local and national news reports of neglect, disastrous ``elopement,'' and financial shenanigans, it is clear that we have reached that point now with assisted living. We recommend three things. One, establish and implement national standards to promote quality, safety, and integrity in assisted living. Two, establish a national assisted living data base with information and metrics that the public needs to evaluate both costs and quality, and three, promote resident and family engagement to ensure that assisted living is truly a home and community-based service. As I mentioned earlier, assisted living experiences can range from positive to alarming, posing potential risks and exploitation. I think that we can all agree that the lives of seniors should not be left to chance, ambiguity, and insecurity. Thank you again for inviting me to testify today. The Chairman. Thanks very much for your testimony, and I will begin the first-round of questions, but I want to note for the record, we have Senators that are in and out because Thursday is a pretty busy hearing morning, and so, we will have Senators come here. Some will be here and then ask questions, and folks will be appearing intermittently throughout the hearing, but so far, I know that Senator Rick Scott was here, and Senator Blumenthal was here, and we will be awaiting others after my questions and those of the ranking member. I wanted to start with you, Patty Vessenmeyer, about your own experience, and I want to start by saying how much I appreciate--I know the Committee appreciates your willingness to share a personal story. That happens in hearings like this on a pretty regular basis, where an individual comes forward and talks about their own experience or that of their family, and from a distance it might seem easy, but I can't imagine how difficult it is to recount difficult, painful moments and doing it in the interest, of course, of helping others, so we are grateful for your willingness to do that, and telling your story is a very important part of the work we are trying to do together. I know that your husband was in an assisted living facility, and you were, as you indicated, paying privately for those services to make sure that he would get the care that he needed for dementia. I know I have heard from my own constituents back home similar stories. For example, Angela, who is a constituent of mine from Johnstown, Pennsylvania, Cambria County, out in the Southwestern region of our State. She wrote to me and said that her father was in one facility that charged $7,200 a month. I know that is not the average. It is very high. That works out to about $90,000 bucks a year, and Angela shared, and I am quoting her here, ``there was always a sense that no one cared for the residents beyond their monthly payments.'' That is one experience and that is one person's personal experience. Ms. Vessenmeyer, I wanted to ask, based upon your experience with your husband, did the facilities he lived in deliver on the care that they promised to provide? Ms. Vessenmeyer. Thank you, Senator. Thank you for appreciating me coming and doing this, and I think the good news is it has been six years, and I am able to do it without getting overly emotional. No, they did not deliver. They definitely over promised, and understand that they were absolutely a memory care facility, specialized in it, and knew what they were doing. His basic needs were not often met. You could hear from some of the examples that I gave, and I observed other people the same way. They would actually recommend that you pay an additional private caregiver to come in to give them the care they really should have gotten, but their staff was just--there just wasn't enough staff for them to get it done, and do understand that their staff was friendly and caring and they were wonderful people who were not trained, and they were just overwhelmed, but they definitely did not deliver, and by the way, it did come out of my pocket because my husband had chosen not to do long care insurance, and that number that the woman gave you was low. That was my starting figure, was $7,900. It cost me closer to $13,000 a month. The Chairman. We are grateful for you sharing your own story, your own experience. I wanted to, next turn to Richard Mollot, you mentioned the need for more substantive and meaningful ways for residents who might choose a particular facility or their families to know which services they receive, how much those services cost, the outcomes for residents living in a specific assisted living facility. For a family searching for care--and we hear about this all the time. I am not sure there is--doubt there is anyone in this room who doesn't know someone who has had the experience of having to search for care and to try to navigate it. It is obviously difficult to find the information that folks need about assisted living facilities, and sometimes they only have the word of an assisted living provider, or maybe someone else who has had their own experience they can rely upon. Can you elaborate more on the challenges that families have in finding both accurate information and unbiased information about services, about costs, about care outcomes for residents in assisted living facilities? Mr. Mollot. Thank you. Essentially, there is no independent, validated information on assisted living for the consumers, for policymakers, or for the general public, so families, as you noted, have to rely on facilities and facility marketing materials. They also quite often rely on companies like A Place for Mom and the other so-called consumer resources, excuse me, that are not independent of the industry. Companies like caring.com, A Place for Mom, that actually get money for--from facilities to be listed, so that is not independent either. That is not something that people can rely on as being necessarily an accurate information of what has happened, what they are going to pay for, and what they are going to get, and the state websites really are the last resource, and they tend to be very flimsy. I haven't looked at every single one, but the ones---- The Chairman. They tend to be, you said? Mr. Mollot. Very flimsy, I am sorry. The Chairman. Flimsy. Okay. Mr. Mollot. Yes. Most often what we will see is they just list the facility. They may list the facility's administrator, their phone number, and the address. Sometimes there is a little bit of information, but you cannot, in my experience, ever get into finding out really what has--what the staffing is, what the costs are going to be, or what the quality has been and any issues. The Chairman. I know that in your--going back to your testimony, you mentioned the three recommendations. The first one was, establish and implement national standards to promote quality, safety, and integrity in assisted living. The second was establish a national assisted living data base. Is that what you are referring to? Mr. Mollot. Yes. Yes. Similar to care compare--you know, there is nursing home care compare, home health care compare, hospital care compare on the Medicaid website. There should be an assisted living compare. The Chairman. Well, I think--and look, I think it is pretty fundamental that people should have the opportunity to place reliance upon a source that is objective, and to use your word, independent. That is, I think that is true in any walk of life. Why would someone only--why should we settle for just relying upon assertions by those who are operating facilities? I think that is pretty elementary, but we haven't reached that point yet in terms of a change in policy. I know I am over time, but I will turn to our Ranking Member, Ranking Member Braun. Senator Braun. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to start, first I want to ask Ms. Simpkins a question, but that idea of transparency and information, to me, I don't know how you could say that wouldn't be good. I have been a proponent since I have been here that this place out of focus as much on that as anything, because we are a portal of information that if you collate it properly, that would seem to make sense. I think that goes across the spectrum of health care as well. I have been the most vocal Senator that our health care system is broken. We do not have transparency. We do not have competition. It is kind of almost like an unregulated utility, and you get your bill at the--after you had a significant health care scrape or a bad accident. You got to hold your breath to see how much it is going to cost, or you can afford it. I like that idea. Ms. Vessenmeyer, you mentioned that it was $7,200 a month and it could have been more, and that is in Virginia, correct? Is that where the---- Ms. Vessenmeyer. Yes, but that isn't the number that I gave you. That his room charge was $7,800 to--actually $7,900 to start, and it cost me close to $13,000 a month. Senator Braun. $13,000 a month, okay. Ms. Vessenmeyer. That is correct. Senator Braun. That sounds unaffordable, so. Ms. Vessenmeyer. If he hadn't passed away rather quickly by the time--the length of time he was in there, it would have used up all of my nest egg. Senator Braun. That is the kind of stuff I have been appalled by from the time I took on health care reform in my own business 15, 16 years ago. How lucky the industry would tell you it is only going up five to ten percent each year, you know, in your health care premiums. Sooner or later, people can't afford it and that has got--something has got to give. I was noticing in your background, Ms. Simpkins, you focus on low-income because some people are going to be able to afford it despite the quality of care and the level, but most people will not. In Indiana and the four other states where you operate, what would that range be per month as you would compare it to $7,000 to $13,000 bucks a month, and it seems like when it was all in, it was closer to that higher figure. Just curious. Ms. Simpkins. Yes. Thank you, Ranking Member Braun, and the range that a resident or resident family would pay under the home and community-based services is really nothing. In Illinois, there is a small personal portion. It is based on resident income and allowing them to do things and still have money in their pocket. In Indiana, there is no personal portion, so the State of Indiana will pay for those services through the State. Senator Braun. In your facilities, for low-income individuals, there is basically very little out of pocket? Ms. Simpkins. There is very little out of pocket. There might be some personal portion based on what they actually receive in income, but it doesn't go over what anything a Social Security amount is. Senator Braun. How much would you be able to generalize that across the rest of the country? Ms. Simpkins. To model that program? Oh, you can model the program. Senator Braun. Are other states doing that? Ms. Simpkins. There are other states that are doing it. Now, I will say that Illinois supportive living program and Indiana are probably--and Ohio are doing it really well, recognizing that there is a need within their State, there is an underserved population. There are people that cannot afford it, and so, that is what we were founded for. That is our business model is to say there is an unmet need and how are we going to do it, and we work with states that have the programs, Medicaid waiver programs in place along with rate reimbursement that makes sense. Senator Braun. Mrs. Vessenmeyer, you would not have qualified for any low-income opportunities then. Is that what kept you in that, what seems to be outrageous in terms of the cost per month? Ms. Vessenmeyer. That is correct, because even though we were both retired, they look at all of your savings, and if you have a decent IRA out there, that counts. Senator Braun. It begs the question then, is the low-income stratum across the country being served adequately? That almost would seem to be surprising to me if that were the case, but what we are seeing on the other side, and then it is a question, there just wouldn't be many families that could afford it, and you know, I don't know what the criteria or the cutoff is. Can you fill me in a little bit? It sounds like in Indiana, especially if there were other options to choose from other than just your organization, that the low to maybe middle income strata are being served well. Is that a fair statement or not? Ms. Simpkins. That is a fair statement, Ranking Member Braun. Senator Braun. Do you think that is the case across the country as well as you know, because you serve on some boards that--where I think you would have that information. Ms. Simpkins. It is not across the country. Nationally, there needs to be programs in each state to--to provide access to affordable assisted living, and they are not all there yet. Senator Braun. Generally--and that is at least a little bit surprising, and generally, it is a folks at the other end of the spectrum, the low and middle, especially low, that don't get adequate services. I think that is something that you need to get those practices spread out to where we at least can get that in most other states, and then you got to tackle something like this, that I don't know how wealthy you would have to be to be able to afford that easily and for a long time. Something has got to give there. I will rest with that right now, and I will have another round of questions if we do it. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking member Braun. We turn next to Senator Kelly. Senator Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to all our witnesses for being here today. Mr. Mollot, the Arizona Republic, the paper of record in my State, published a series of investigative reports last year about the State of long-term care facilities in Arizona, and these journalists spent more than a year on this investigation. They reviewed police reports. They reviewed footage in some facilities. They analyzed regulatory reports from the State, and they interviewed families and experts, and what they found was, I think it is fair to say, horrifying. They reported graphic stories of a resident dying after being attacked by a roommate who hadn't received her medication in time. Another report of an assisted living resident being sexually assaulted by another resident, and incidents of violence among residents that often aren't reported because they aren't required to be reported under state law, and they highlighted the failure of state agencies to investigate these cases in a coherent, transparent way that would allow families looking for a safe place for their loved one to know what really goes on in these facilities, and I think a lot of us knew there were issues in the system. We knew that. I don't think we knew how bad it was. Since these articles were published, Arizona's Governor has put together a strong legislative package to standardize inspections, promote transparency for residents and their families, and empower our adult protective services to investigate, and the State legislature is looking at proposals. Mr. Mollot, are these the type of steps that can help tackle these issues? Mr. Mollot. I believe so. I mean, of course it all--the details matter. This is a very nuanced issues about caring for people with dementia and ensuring that that things are reported appropriately and that there is good oversight. As much as possible, we would hope that the State would be looking to implement policies and practices that prevent bad things from happening, as well as, of course, ensuring that when they do happen that they are rectified and that they are reported appropriately. Senator Kelly. Arizona can't be the only State that is facing these challenges. Mr. Mollot. Not at all. Senator Kelly. Should the Federal Government maybe consider having a role here and providing oversight for assisted living facilities? Mr. Mollot. I think it is time for the Federal Government to step in. As I mentioned in my testimony, 40 years ago when nursing homes were in crisis, Congress stepped in. Congress took that, you know, initiated action, and we are here now with assisted living as well. The same population in terms of numbers of people are in assisted living as they are in nursing homes, but we don't know what is happening to them. We don't know the care they are receiving. A lot of it is private pay, not all of it, but there is unfortunately a lot of fraud. Senator Kelly. Apparently, more than 20 years ago, this Committee helped to facilitate the creation of an assisted living work group, which was made up of 50 organizations, and this work group was tasked with coming up with recommendations for best practices in assisted living facilities to ensure a more consistent quality landscape across states. The result was a 380 page report with a lot of recommendations, and these were hard to agree upon. Mr. Mollot, what has happened with these recommendations since this report was finished, if you are familiar with it? Mr. Mollot. I haven't read it in a long time, but I am familiar with it. Frankly, on the Federal level, nothing has happened. As Ms. Simpkins said, we do see some things going on in the states, but it is--generally speaking, the states are just not inclined, frankly, to take action on a lot of the work that they do. Hopefully they will be different in Arizona, but it really is time, I believe, for the Federal Government to step in to ensure that wherever someone accesses dementia care, that means something. It is not just a term of art, and wherever they go for safety, they know that they can live safely, and wherever they are going into, they know what the expenses are going to be, that they are cognizable. Senator Kelly. Well, thank you. I do want to note for my constituents a resource created by AARP Arizona and by the Arizona Republic following this investigative series that I mentioned. It is a backgrounder on long-term care, the definition--definitions of different terms, what family should look for, and what questions to ask, and folks can find this on the AARP Arizona website, and my office will be posting this on our social media accounts, and I am going to submit this for the record as well, Mr. Chairman, and I urge Arizonans or anybody else interested to check it out, and thank you. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Kelly. That will be submitted--accepted for the record, not just submitted. Thanks very much. We will turn next to Senator Vance. Senator Vance. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thanks to you and the ranking member for hosting the Committee hearing today, and welcome to our witnesses. Thank you for being here, and welcome to all of our guests. I want to direct my questions to you, Ms. Simpkins, and I appreciate you being here. I am particularly concerned by some of the estimates that I have seen about labor shortages at our long-term care facilities. Not just now. I know there is sort of an immediate problem of not enough people at some of our elderly care facilities, but I saw an estimate that by 2030, we will need given--you know, obviously, people will retire, will drop out of the workforce, but then we also have changing demographics in this country. We are becoming older as a country. I read that we will need an additional seven million long-term caregivers at these elder care facilities. That seems like a shocking estimate to me. It is hard to imagine how we could possibly hire effectively one million additional people per year at these facilities, given the already existing labor shortages. I am curious if you think that estimate is within the reasonable range, and if it is not, how many more workers do we need over the next five to ten years? Ms. Simpkins. Thank you for the question, Senator Vance. I have not heard seven million. I have heard five million, but I can certainly I would be interested in your information, and I will follow-up and send you the information I have. In my response to that, we got hit by the pandemic really hard. Health care workers left, and they are never coming back. They said this was hard and we are not going to do it, and we have had to recover, and assisted living has recovered pretty well. What we also need to do is we need to build for this aging--our workforce is aging out and our seniors are aging, and we are doubling and tripling numbers when we get to 2040 and 2050, and so, having a really intense effort and what that means to both recruit and retain, and if you don't mind, I would like to share just quickly what we are doing. Senator Vance. Sure. Ms. Simpkins. From a recruitment standpoint--so that is how we recovered. We were able to get really creative. We looked at people and said, what do you need? What is it going to help your household? We knew we needed to increase wages, so even in an HCBS environment, you can have rate methodology that allows you to pay a living wage and higher than what a minimum wage is, and then we looked at retaining because, you know, as people-- people come into the assisted living, and they stay because they are so passionate about it, and in honor of their passion, we need to create something for them. What we do is from the first interview, we asked them what they envision six months from today, one year from today, three years from today. We want them to envision a future with us and at least a future with the assisted living industry, and then we have to meet that need by career pathing, career net mapping, and what we have--so we have done a lot of that and what we have realized through those interviews and people saying, this is my career path, is we also need to skill path. We need to provide them with the resources, whether it is through a nursing grant, is through additional education that we are reimbursing them for, additional training that they need, so if you are going to commit to working within this space in a workforce, you also need to create and having a workforce that has continued to be passionate, make a living wage, and have the tools they need, and they will want to stay. Senator Vance. Got it. Appreciate that. You know, one just additional thought here is, you know, you hear about these cases of elopement at some of our eldercare facilities and they are mercifully rare. You know, we have close to a million Americans in elder care facilities right now. You know, maybe 2,000 or so elopements happen per year. That is a small number, but that is--I worry, with increasing labor shortages, whether that number goes up. I have heard some suggestions that you could fill the labor shortage gap by expanding certain immigration programs, certain visa programs, and the one worry that I have there, of course, is that, you know, if you take a person caring for an elderly citizen, you want to make sure there is not a language barrier there, especially with people who are going through dementia and might be, you know, losing some of their cognitive capacity. We really have to wrap our minds around this. I appreciate the work that you are doing on this, and I appreciate your answer to the question, but are you worried that we might see an increase in elopements over the next few years, or do you think not? Ms. Simpkins. We need to plan for how our seniors are aging and the additional care needs, and we do that through person centered planning. I believe Dr. Kraft Morgan mentioned that our person centered care plans revolve around what a resident needs, because and to Patricia's point too, somebody can have the same diagnosis and their needs are completely different, and if you are not having person centered plan for that individual, which is collaborative with their family, with the resident when--as much as they can participate in it, with their caregivers, you are not going to have the best plan to keep them as safe and secure as you possibly can. On the immigration side, I would--you know, there is an opportunity here with unused visas to at least start bringing in--if you think about the workforce, start bringing in some health care workers. Senator Vance, to your point, there are some markets within--that we are within, that have the residents who also have language barriers. Having staff who speak Spanish, we have staff that speaks Polish based on where the neighborhoods are. Senator Vance. Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Vance. Senator Ricketts. Senator Ricketts. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Again, thank you to all of our folks here that are testifying. Appreciate you taking the time to help us out here today. I represent the great State of Nebraska. In Nebraska, we have nursing--skilled nursing facilities and assisted living facilities that are scattered throughout our State, and it is incredibly important to take care of the 20,000 people who require care in the 500 different facilities that we have, and they can get that care for about $3,875 a month. Anybody who is providing assisted living services in the State of Nebraska that has four or more residents is designated as an assisted living facility that is regulated by the State and is licensed. While I was Governor, I signed into law an Assisted Living Facility Act to update the standards and the requirements that we have for our assisted living facilities. They are just absolutely critical, especially in rural parts of Nebraska, and to be able to help take care of people, and we want to make sure that we continue to have that service for our folks. Ms. Simpkins, as you know, assisted living facilities, as I mentioned, are a regulated at the state level, which allows states, you know, flexibility to be able to be responsive to local consumer demands. Are there any states in particular doing an exceptionally good job that we can draw lessons from? States you say, hey, they have got some good programs or things that we should be adopting across the country? Ms. Simpkins. Well, I can speak for the states in which we operate. Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio have exceptional programs, and with that, Senator Ricketts, one of the things we noted in reporting--all of those states will require reporting of any of the incidences that were talked about previously. Senator Ricketts. Are there other characteristics though that you think has led, or some of the approaches that you say that these states are doing a good job. What are they doing right? What are the things that--so you mentioned the reporting. That is obviously an important factor. Are there other things that they are doing that you say, hey, this is why they have such good systems. Ms. Simpkins. This is why there is a good system, because we have access within a state, in a state that is--where assisted living is regulated under the state. I am going to talk particularly about home and community- based service, access to the regulators, access to families, access to everybody who--you know, you have this local model that can create and innovate and come up with best practices. I am a big proponent, let's share our best practices because there is nothing proprietary when it comes to caring for a senior and caring for somebody, and that is what those states are doing well. My fear is, if you move those conversations further away, we will no longer have those things. The states in which we serve, and I will talk about Indiana specifically, the state program, Medicaid waiver program and regulations are really dynamic. They promote and encourage having a local model where there is collaboration and there is innovation, and that is where we come up with best practices, so that--I would say that that is also a model. Senator Ricketts. Great. Well, hey, thank you because that actually leads into another question I had then. Last May, this Committee held a hearing that highlighted the strained nursing home inspection system. As you know, nursing homes are regulated at the Federal level and--are heavily regulated by the Federal level. Anyway, so if assisted living facilities are subjected to the same sort of one size fits all Federal type regulation, what can we do as lawmakers to ensure that assisted living facilities don't have the same sort of problems we are seeing in skilled nursing facilities? How do we protect that, what you talked about, that local model and best practices? Ms. Simpkins. Well, from the state level, we encourage all of the states, so the things that we were talking about, if we even just talk about reporting in the--reporting of those critical events, reporting those up through the Federal Government. Under the HCBS services, each State has really an obligation to report up in order to continue to have their federal funding. They also are well aware of the transparency that comes from and the opportunity--once those things the states report up, we have a transparency and the opportunity to see what home and community-based services are doing across the Nation, and we will have a window and more models that we can see, because I am sure there is more states that are doing it well. I just can't speak to those today. Senator Ricketts. Getting back to the idea of like if you have the Federal Government that is regulating those things, how do we preserve that ability of local folks to be able to really tailor how they are doing the regulation to make sure that we are not pushing a one size fits all answer? Ms. Simpkins. You know, there has been--we need to--from our perspective, we need to tell our story much better. There are really good stories to tell from a state perspective on our home and community-based services, and we need to do a better job of talking about those stories and the things that are going on within the states. The innovation that has happened. The times providers have been asked to sit at a table before there is a rule change and not just ask for comment, but sit face to face with somebody and say, if this rule changes, how does it impact the resident that you are caring for and your workforce who is caring for that resident. Senator Ricketts. Right. That interaction with--direct with the people who are doing the job---- Ms. Simpkins. Yes. Senator Ricketts. Before rule changes are made with the regulators so that we don't have unintended consequences with regard to the rules that are made that will harm the care that is being delivered in assisted living facilities. Is that fair? Ms. Simpkins. That is fair, Senator. I like the way you put that. Thank you. Senator Ricketts. Great. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Senator Ricketts, thank you, and we will turn next to Senator Warnock. Senator Warnock. Thank you so very much, Chair Casey. I would be remiss in this moment if I didn't just take a moment to remember the legacy of the late first lady, Rosalynn Carter, whom I was privileged to know and whose mission was to center and uplift our caregivers. Her extraordinary work demonstrates how a health care system that leaves so many drowning in caregiving costs, costs most of us will one day face, is a health care system that falls short of its basic obligations. Dr. Morgan, in your experience as a gerontologist, how does the cost, the cost of assisted living burden seniors, their caregivers, and their families? Dr. Morgan. Well, the cost of assisted living is both financial and emotional and real for many, many Americans. We have a system where there is not access to assisted living. In some states, there are Medicaid waivers that cover a larger portion of those who need it at the lower income, but there are also states that have virtually no waiver programs so that the only people that can afford assisted living are those who have those significant financial resources. The middle tier of America tends to do things that I talked about in my testimony. They reduce their working hours. They set up these arrangements across families to pay for assisted living, if that is what they can do. They bring in people who may not be trained to support their person living at home. They make these precarious work and family arrangements to be able to make it through whatever long-term care they have for their loved one. If they are lucky enough to get into assisted living, then they are still coming after work and they are still bringing the incontinence supplies, and they are still bringing the snacks and engaging the residents. It is another job on top of the job that they are trying to do if they are still working, if they are still able to work, and that is really important in young onset dementia as well, because in young onset dementia, these people are still earning, right, and they have young onset dementia and then the families have, very few options for thinking about their forward retirement, right. Retirement isn't what we end up doing. We end up mortgaging everything to do the care and to, you know, clean out our savings in order to support this person living with dementia who may not be able to be at home. A lot of the young onset dementias have the sorts of things that Patty was talking about with Lewy Body dementia and front temporal dementia. We have a different course of the disease, and it is really difficult for people to care for those folks at home, and so, even if they are able to afford assisted living for a time, they run out of resources, and then what do they do? Sometimes they can get into nursing home placement, and sometimes there is good nursing homes to go to, but not always. It is awfully precarious for many folks. Senator Warnock. Well, thank you. Your experience with this underscores the ways in which this cost not only to families, but all of us. It has implications for our workforce and our economy, and so we have to have long range, comprehensive thinking about this. The chair has been a leader in this, and I am happy to join him, I was happy in joining him, to ask that the GAO look into how Federal health care affordability programs like Medicaid and Medicare, which you mentioned, interact with assisted living facilities, how we can do better there, and whether families choose an assisted living facility or in-home care, they need help meeting caregiving cost. The average cost of $4,500 a month, that is an average cost, but you rightly point out the ways in which, for example, with early onset dementia, people's retirement funds actually drain just taking care of the individual, and that is why I support efforts to lower caregiving costs for aging adults. It is a critical issue for our country, and I will continue to work with my colleagues on this Committee, informed by the expertise of people like all the folks on our panel, to improve access to long-term care for families across Georgia and across the country. Thank you so much for your work in this area. Dr. Morgan. Thank you. The Chairman. Senator Warnock, thanks very much for your questions, and we will now move--a little bit out of order, we will move to a second round as we are waiting for Senators to ask their first-round questions, some of whom are on their way. I will start. I know Ranking Member Braun had some questions as well. Dr. Morgan, I will turn back to you. Your testimony provided a helpful overview of the importance of well-trained staff in assisted living facilities. We heard that direct care staff can have as few as six or eight hours of training only before beginning their care duties. They might be responsible, in some cases, for 20 or more residents. My--the constituent of mine that I mentioned earlier, Angela, said in part when she wrote to us, ``when I mentioned my concerns about my father falling repeatedly, a facility her head nurse said, ``falls are just part of aging.''" I would ask you, Dr. Morgan, are falls and other accidents in assisted living just part of aging, or are there procedures, strategies, rules that can be put in place to address the risks that older adults face? Dr. Morgan. Falls is a really important topic in aging. There are a lot of great tools that people can use. The National Institutes of Health has a great flier on this topic, six tips to help prevent falls. Falls is about--it is about prevention. Educating AL staff on fall prevention is vital. There are plenty of environmental audits that can be made, and some of these--some ALs have this training in place, but certainly it is an important aspect of initial and ongoing training that the AL workforce should do. The other thing that is tricky about falls is that there is a fear of falling that has a real impact in whether you are going to fall, and a fear from families who are scared that their mom or dad are going to fall, and one of the things that my father would say to his patients is if you don't use it, you will lose it, and in aging, it is important to keep up with balance, and balance exercises, and keep with strength training and doing those sorts of activities, and certainly, assisted living in other places could do that to really help with improving balance, because we know that balance is really important in terms of predicting mortality, and so, if we think about it and we support false prevention, that is what we--can really make a difference, and that is also educating families, that, you know, if you use your assisted devices, if you get up slowly, if you manage your medications, it make sense to really think about falls prevention, because a fall can really have an impact on the trajectory of aging for sure, and it is really important that long-term care take that seriously. The Chairman. Doctor, thank you so much. I am going to cut myself short here. I have a little bit of a jump ball between Ranking Member Braun's second round question and Senator Warren's first-round question. I think I will start with someone who is arriving. Senator Warren. I will yield to the Ranking Member. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Warren. Senator Braun. That is very gracious. I will actually yield back to you since you haven't done it, so. I will be here at the tail end. Senator Warren. All right. Well, thank you both, and thank you for holding this hearing. I appreciate that we are having this hearing. I appreciate your leadership on ensuring quality care for seniors in assisted living facilities. This issue is not a new one for me. In July 2020, my office released the findings from the first national survey of COVID- 19 in assisted living facilities, revealing that about 7,000 residents had died from COVID in just the first half of 2020. In many ways, the threat of COVID in assisted living facilities was just as serious as it was in nursing homes, but these facilities received little help and little attention. Now, before that, in 2018, I released the first ever National Assessment of Quality Care Issues in Assisted Living Facilities, which was completed by the Government Accountability Office at my request. That report revealed that over 20,000 serious health and safety problems occurring at assisted living facilities in just 22 states, from physical assaults to medication errors, to unexplained deaths. In the years since my office did that work, new studies have revealed additional problems in assisted living facilities. Mr. Mollot, you lead the Long Term Care Community Coalition, which is dedicated to improving the quality and accountability of senior living facilities. Can you say a word about what kinds of threats seniors at assisted living facilities face, and how serious the risk is? Mr. Mollot. Thank you. I think there are two major risks and both of them are serious. First, due to the increasing needs and vulnerability of people who go to assisted living, the risk of harm has gone way up. People are vulnerable. People are depending upon assisted living for significant dementia care, etcetera, and we just don't know if they are getting it, and we often don't know when terrible things happen, as you noted from that GAO report, which was so important. Second, due to the increased sophistication of operators, we have private equity, we have real estate investment trusts that are circling around this industry. The risk of financial exploitation has gone up tremendously in recent years. Senator Warren. You know, and your keyword, we just don't know. These are serious problems that have been going on for years, but we hear so much less about what is going on in assisted living facilities than we do in other facilities like nursing homes. Mr. Mollot, why do you think assisted living facilities receive so much less attention than, say, nursing homes? Mr. Mollot. It is a really interesting question. If I may, I think that, you know, in the 70's and the 80's, we had some tremendous scandals in the nursing home world, and that led Congress to pay attention and finally to take action. I think that is where we are with the assisted living now, is that we are hearing more and more of these stories. The GAO reports of 1999 and the more recent report that you mentioned. Washington Post and Times reports that Senator Casey mentioned. Local news reporting from around the country. Over and over, we are seeing that these issues are coming up, and now is really the time to take action. Senator Warren. With nursing homes, we put in Federal standards on this, got more Federal oversight, but assisted living facilities are governed by a patchwork of state laws without any meaningful Federal oversight, and that means no national standards that assisted living facilities are expected to meet. That is particularly worrisome because private equity firms and real estate investment firms rates have gone on a buying spree of senior and assisted living facilities. We know how their model works. Private equity comes in, strips the assets, cuts the staff, and sends the quality of care down the tubes. Mr. Mollot, your organization has looked carefully at the data, and you have heard from the residents of these facilities. When private equity comes into an assisted living facility and slashes jobs, what impact does that have on the residents? Mr. Mollot. Well, workers are the most important component of care in any setting, especially in nursing homes and assisted living, so that could be devastating for residents, but we know, I mean, unfortunately, we don't have a lot of data directly on assisted living, we have some on senior care in general and of course on nursing homes and other care settings. We know that when private equity comes in to a sector, they often pillage it. Senator Warren. Yes. In other words, more people will suffer when private equity comes in. We need to do more here. At a minimum, the Biden Administration should require additional reporting on problems at living--assisted living facilities. In fact, that is a priority recommendation from the 2008 team GAO report. While CMS is making progress on implementing this recommendation, they should finalize it quickly. This has gone on long enough without oversight, and Congress must look at ways to improve accountability, transparency, and quality of care in assisted living facilities. Again, I want to say to the chair and to the ranking member, thank you for holding this hearing, and to the ranking member, thank you for graciously letting me do this. I am trying to cover two hearings simultaneously, and I appreciate you letting me ask these questions. Thank you all for being here. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Warren and Senator Braun is again seeing to a colleague, Senator Fetterman. Senator Fetterman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Again, a credit to--Senator Warren. That is--outstanding questioning as well too. All right, anyway, thank you. Ms. Simpkins, your website states that your company's operating margins are consistently among the top in the country. I understand that your company manages upwards $700 million from the low-income housing tax credit program, and a majority of your residents rely on Medicaid through Medicaid waiver. Ms. Simpkins, is it fair to say that, you know, your company is viable because of Government subsidies? Ms. Simpkins. Thank you for that question, Senator Fetterman. It is available for a few reasons, and what is-- because we do have investors, and we are grateful to those who want to invest in affordable assisted living across the country, otherwise we would not be providing to almost 6,000 seniors today who are in Medicaid waiver. We also need a viable business plan, and it needs to be a business plan. When you talk about on the website, when it talks about our margins, our margins as compared when you look at affordable housing across the continuum, and it is because of our investors that we are able to have margins that we continue to do, like certified dementia practitioner training and give education reimbursements and get--you know, look into different workforce opportunities, and the third thing that happens in a viable business is you have to have a service plan. You have to have a service plan that is going to--it is focused on quality outcomes, and it is focused on high resident satisfaction, and it is focused on high employee satisfaction, and what you will see in our website, and thank you for noticing that, because what we are we doing our website, and I will be glad to send you a link as soon as it is done, because we are going to start posting our quality outcomes and our residents and employee satisfaction results, and that should probably be in March, so I will send you a link. Senator Fetterman. No, yes, of course I would be grateful, and also, true, I am glad that there are investors, and they are a critical part of it, but I think we are able to--it is safe to say that the subsidies from the Government is also very part--it is important too, right? Ms. Simpkins. It is definitely important. We need both to have a viable business. Senator Fetterman. Yes, and that is not a criticism or an attack. I am just wanting to establish that, so but you know, given the Government's undeniable role in this, in your operations, why do you believe that a company should not be able to use Federal dollars to make a profit? I don't judge anyone, of course, you know, or earning a profit, but if you are making that kind of a profit, you know, but at--maintaining at the same time the Federal care standard. Ms. Simpkins. Thank you for the question, Senator. You know, the Federal funds go into the state, and the state then decides and what that program is going to look like and what it is going to be. The opportunity at the state level is that we can have conversations with our state regulators and improve upon practices, share best practices across the continuum. I know Senator Warren mentioned the 2020 report that she had on COVID, and we were part of that report, and our outcomes were really-- you don't want anything to happen, but outcomes are really good in comparison to others, and we relied heavily on the state regulators and the resources within the state to help coach and educate and resource and everything we needed to do. I don't believe it could have happened at the Federal level, the amount of attention we were able to get from the state. Senator Fetterman. Sure. I want to be very clear that if-- earlier, of course, that we count on other investors to allow you to operate. I don't have an issue with you, you know, generating a profit. I mean, that is one of the reason why people are in this, and of course, it is--in fact, that is why it works, and I am grateful that it is, and really this line of questioning wasn't an attack or isn't anything other than just to just establish that because we are partnering through the kind of subsidies that we really--I think we should maintain those kinds of Federal standards as well, too, and because all of them are--they combine together to allow this to work and to provide that kind of--very important kind of a service, and that is really--do you--would you agree with that? Ms. Simpkins. They are providing a very important service, and Senator, I actually appreciate your line of questioning, because if we didn't have these kinds of discussions and even differencing in opinion--opposing views and different views, that is where great ideas come from and that is where improvement and evolution comes from, so I do appreciate your questioning today. Senator Fetterman. Okay and thank you. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Fetterman. We will now turn to Ranking Member Braun. Senator Braun. What we have just been hearing here is just what I like about a committee like this. You are hearing a broad array of viewpoints. I have--health care has been something I wrestled with long ago, and the whole spectrum from early childhood through when you are needing to look at how you are going to spend your last years, it has been cloaked behind closed doors. Large insurance companies and hospitals where we spend most of our money on the way to maybe a nursing home, assisted living, or if you are lucky enough to live out in your own abode, it has got to be swamped with transparency and where we can see. Ms. Vessenmeyer's story, how can something like that happen, and that was in Virginia, when we are hearing $3,800 a month in Nebraska. Every state is going to have a different cost of living, a different cost structure, but that idea, Mr. Mollot, of a transparency portal and at least some things that are going to make it easier to shine the light on issues that are out there. To me, when you are against that, you are just trying to hide something. For instance, on the bigger picture, and this is an interesting combination of individuals, myself, Senator Sanders, Senator Grassley, Senator Smith, Senator Hickenlooper, it is two Republicans, three Democrats. I have been working on this since I have been in the Senate. Competition and transparency. If you want to be in the biggest part of our economy, health care, and especially at the tail end of our lives, be out there, be open. Ms. Simpkins, I was wondering, because you have done a good job, and like Senator Fetterman said, your payor is coming through either State or Federal Governments, and you are aimed at low-income. What is your cost, roughly, to do what you are doing, across those five states? Because we heard $3,800 here. I just asked my staff, so maybe closer to $4,500 in Indiana per month. What are you finding? You are servicing low-income residents, so what does that cost structure look like? Ms. Simpkins. Thank you for the question, Ranking Member Braun. I am trying to---- Senator Braun. That would just mean in terms of your--you have a business---- Ms. Simpkins. Yes. Senator Braun. Without giving any trade secrets away, what does it roughly cost in those states to provide a service? Your payor is mostly from Government. In the case over here, didn't have that advantage, and you saw what happened, and that was in a state like Virginia, which I would have thought would have been maybe moderate on costs. Ms. Simpkins. Yes. The thing I am struggling with is--and I certainly agree with the transparency. Those are things that we are going to be showing all the conversations here today of, you know, the cost of care and making sure there is no hidden fees. The expense side, what I am struggling with is the expense really depends on the state in which you are in. I would certainly be willing to---- Senator Braun. Let's just pick Indiana then. Keep it simple, and then, what do you charge the Governments that end up paying you mostly? I am going to get an idea of what the variation is in cost across this country, and then that whoever is in any component of health care should be always willing to make it easy for us to understand, and on health care that leads up to assisted living or nursing homes, it is terrible. In in my own business, I tried to create health care consumers so you can actually manage your own well-being, and even when I attempted it, it wasn't easy, but we did it. Ms. Simpkins. Okay. Thank you for the clarity. The cost of care, if we were looking at Indiana specifically, and I think the best gauge is probably, you know, our operating margin because the cost of care of insurance and workforce--and insurance cost have going up 15, 20 percent, and sometimes it is, you know--a little bit higher in a, you know---- Senator Braun. You can give me a range too. Ms. Simpkins. I can give you a range, yes, so the operating margins are going to be, you know, roughly between like 20 and 28 percent. When everything is considered, that is also a debt load---- Senator Braun. That is operating margins. Ms. Simpkins. Yes. Senator Braun. I am talking about what the Government ends up paying per month. Ms. Simpkins. I would be glad to send that to you, Senator Braun---- Senator Braun. Well, you can get that to me, and I don't want to---- Ms. Simpkins. Yes, I don't have that--I don't have the exact--yes---- Senator Braun. belabor the point, but just the difficulty of this, and you guys are doing a good job by all standards. We have got to have transparency across the spectrum of health care, and when you get to the tail end of life, I think as important as it is, along the way, and until the industry and everyone in health care embraces transparency and competition, don't be surprised if there is going to be more of an interest to show how to do it from the Federal level. I am a believer that that generally isn't necessarily a solution. It can end up even costing more. Unless you at least embrace what is done in all other industries, which is make it easy for people that want to buy your services know what it is going to cost, embrace competition, don't try to keep people out of the business, you are never going to find solutions in health care. It is now up to 20 percent of our GDP. You know, as recently as three or four decades ago, it was only five percent of our GDP. It is breaking the bank even through the programs we offer here that elderly depend on, Medicare and Social Security on their retirement. Something has got to give. Ms. Simpkins. Okay. I understand, Senator. I will send you that information. It is not that I am not willing to share it. I am willing to share it wherever you want to share it. I just don't want to misspeak on what those numbers are. Senator Braun. I respect that. Thank you, and thank the other panelists for enlightening us on this subject. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Braun. We could spend a lot more hours, obviously, on these issues, so we are grateful for all of you helping us. I will have a closing statement and I will turn to Ranking Member Braun, and then we will wrap up. I know a vote is--if it hasn't started, it is about to start, but as we heard today, assisted living facilities are at a--or right now are growing piece of the, excuse me, the long-term care continuum, but more work is needed to ensure these facilities are quality facilities, that they are safe, and that costs are transparent and clear to families. As Ms. Vessenmeyer stated in her testimony today, assisted living facilities must provide what older Americans need to be safe and to be healthy as they age. This hearing has demonstrated that assisted living facilities face similar challenges to other long-term care options, including maintaining a well-trained workforce, providing safety, high quality services, and being affordable. Throughout my career, I have been working to improve care, to improve transparency and quality throughout the long-term care sector. We have a responsibility to make sure every American can age with dignity in a safe place of their choosing. That is why I have worked with my colleagues to expand access to home and community-based services, improve nursing home oversight, and strengthen the long-term care workforce, and now, we are going to continue our work on assisted living. As this sector grows, we must work to provide similar protections and safeguards that are in place for residents and their families as we have all strive to in the nursing home context. We also want to ensure that any facilities and corporate owners that violate the trust of American families are held accountable. I look forward to working with my colleagues to ensure everyone who needs long-term care has safe and accessible options. One way we will do that is to determine what the costs of assisted living are to families and how Federal dollars are being used. To ensure these funds are being used responsibly to pay for quality care, along with all of my Democratic Aging Committee colleagues, we have sent a letter to the Government Accountability Office asking them to conduct a study of assisted living costs and how available and transparent that information is to families, and as I said in my opening statement, I want to know more about what people are paying for assisted living and to have people tell their stories, as we heard some of the stories today. Again, we will be asking people from across my home State, as well as the country, to share stories and to share your bills with us, if you would want to do that. We want to hear from you about the true cost of assisted living and understand whether families have the information, the information that they need to make this difficult financial and health care decision for a family member and for the family. I will turn to Ranking Member Braun now for his closing remarks. Senator Braun. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you again to all the witnesses. This Committee is unique in that you really can't craft legislation out of it. A lot of it, though, from this discussion happens through other committees, so always keep that in mind. We heard how critical it is that Federal policies support the caregiving workforce. Senator Vance pointing that out. Back in Indiana, I mentioned how workforce in general has a lot to do with our school systems, making sure that they emphasize career and technical education along with four-year pathways, because not like in--across the country, maybe a third of jobs need the four-year degree, and we need a better high school education for many of these issues so we can hit the ground running. It should be policies from here, I think should focus on boosting workforce. I think we all kind of agree on that. Many bills are out there to do that, and to make careers in health care easier to attain. Got to make sure you don't work at cross-purposes. Like, some of the policies that are going through the labor agencies and that side of it that are wanting to get--make it harder for independent contractors, for individuals where a lot of this assisted living help comes from, so, we want to make sure we don't work at cross-purposes. We also heard how states and the providers themselves are doing things. Sadly, though, not all states seem to be doing it well because you cannot have many instances of that and say that you got an industry that is working. That should be the rare exception, never the rule, and then, when we are talking about how this place actually helps. When you are promoting transparency, it can bring on partners together. I have seen that. Two ends of the spectrum because no one should ever be against being able to have more information to make a good decision. When it comes to standards, I think that is important, data bases. That is all something we can do, share it with all the states. I think those are good ideas. I am encouraged by the conversation we have had here today. That is how you get better ideas, really good practices. This should be something--whoever is doing it the best, you need to shout it out so that the rest of the country can participate in it. Thank you again. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Braun. I wanted to thank again our witnesses for contributing both their time and their expertise, and of course bringing your own personal stories, your own personal experience to this issue. If any Senators have additional questions for the witnesses or statements to be added to the hearing record, the record will be open--kept open for seven days until next Thursday, February the 1st. Thank you all for participating today. This concludes our hearing. [Whereupon, at 11:42 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] ======================================================================= APPENDIX ======================================================================= ======================================================================= Prepared Witness Statements ======================================================================= U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Prepared Witness Testimony Patricia Vessenmeyer Good morning, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and members of the Senate Special Committee on Aging. My name is Patricia (Patty) Vessenmeyer. Thank you for allowing me to share this testimony of my experience with assisted living for my husband, John Whitney, during his journey through middle-stage dementia. I will focus on my experiences and observations that I believe are most relevant to your national focus. In 2013, my husband was diagnosed with Dementia with Lewy Body. Although this dementia is like Alzheimer's, it manifests itself a bit differently and it is important that caregivers be informed and trained to ensure the comfort, safety, and security of their patients. Some key symptoms are loss of sense of smell; REM sleep behavior disorder (RBD) which causes individuals to violently act out dreams, often falling out of bed, visual hallucinations, marked fluctuations in attention and alertness; and gastrointestinal issues including severe constipation, all of which my husband experienced. Loss of memory occurs much later in the disease process. I took several free courses on caregiving for individuals with dementia, including a "virtual reality dementia experience" which helped me to understand the challenges that people with this disorder face, and most importantly, why they become so fearful and combative. I mention this to provide a basis for my ability to recognize problems with care. These same courses are offered for professionals at a reasonable cost. In June of 2017, when John's disease was progressing more rapidly, I moved to Virginia to be near family. I cared for him at home until January 26, 2018, when he attempted to strangle me in my bed. The State determined that John should be placed in a long-term care facility. I found him a room in an assisted living facility in Warrenton, VA that specialized in memory care. He moved in the first week of March 2018. I provided the management team with John's history, his diagnosis, and disease progression. The following is a list of issues I observed in the memory care unit during my daily visits with John. Poor facility design There were blocks of rooms built around a large central room for group activities and TV. The central room was extremely loud and high levels of noise can easily agitate dementia patients. Activity stations were set up for residents. One of these had various lengths of PVC pipe (not kidding), some longer than a baseball bat. These are weapons in waiting and you can guess what happened. There was no quiet area for the residents other than their rooms. The hallways in the room blocks were isolated, making it difficult for staff to monitor. There were many incidents that I witnessed when there was no staff around. I will share the one I feel is the most significant. A woman fell by tripping on a raised area where the rug abutted hard flooring and nobody saw her fall. I found her bloody and staggering down the hall. A company knowledgeable about dementia would not design a facility this way. They would certainly understand that people with dementia have problems with gait and balance. There were video cameras in place, but these were used to review incidents after-the- fact. Understaffed Too many patients were assigned to each caregiver. In the mornings, each caregiver needed to get their assigned residents up and dressed for breakfast. Everyone ate at the same time, putting more pressure on the staff. They only gave residents a shower when necessary, as they were always pressed for time. Caregivers needed extra time to spend on residents in more advanced stages of dementia, as they required help to move from their bed to a wheelchair, be hand fed, etc. After lunch, the caregivers would place most of the residents in chairs in the main room while they worked getting the advanced-stage patients back into their beds. Every day after lunch, my husband urgently needed to empty his bowels. Several times while I was there, I tried to find help as it was difficult for me to help him alone, since I had a fractured arm at the time. I could not find anyone, so I did the best I could. When I was not there, he often soiled himself while waiting for help. I once saved a man's life. I was with my husband in a room off the main activity area. I heard someone crying for help. I ran into the hallway and found the old man on the floor, trying to prevent himself from being beaten with his own cane by another resident. I called for help and quickly moved closer and redirected the attacker's attention. I kept him busy while calmly calling for assistance, trying not to further agitate him. It took several minutes before a staff member finally heard me and came to help. Night was no better, as staff levels were even lower, as allowed by state regulations. They placed residents who had trouble sleeping in front of the TV while they dealt with other residents. Inadequate staff training Most of their caregiver staff were trained as nurse aides, but nothing specific to memory care that I could see. I witnessed them providing some new hires dementia care training in a conference room. This consisted of a member of the management team showing them parts of Glenn Cambell's "I'll be Me" movie and pointing out behaviors that demonstrated his dementia problems. I saw the movie and it was not appropriate for training purposes. I observed several instances where caregivers and nurses displayed limited knowledge of working with dementia patients, particularly those in mid-stage of the disease who become more fearful and combative. Examples: * Nurse running toward resident, causing resident to become combative * Quick, erratic hand movements, frightening individual * TV on at 9:30 PM, with extremely high volume. Several residents were seated in chairs and wheelchairs in front of the TV. Anyone who understands dementia and "sundowning" would never do this. They were over-stimulating their residents instead of allowing them to relax and quiet their minds for sleep. At one point, the Director of the facility told me to spend less time there and let them do their jobs. I could not abide, because they weren't doing their jobs. In closing, unless things change, I would never recommend using this type of facility for a loved one. I am hopeful that you found my testimony helpful and that the Committee will find a way to set national standards for appropriate levels of staffing and training for that staff. This would be a huge step in improving assisted living. Thank you for your time. U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Prepared Witness Testimony Dr. Jennifer Craft Morgan Assisted Living in the U.S. Assisted living (AL) is a large and growing long-term care residential option for individuals who need or want additional supports for activities of daily living. There are approximately 30,600 AL communities in the U.S. with almost 1.2 million licensed beds and 818,800 residents. This industry employs a total of 478,500 workers, 66% of which are direct care workers (DCWs) (NCAL 2023). These DCWs are the first line of care. AL, though often seen by the public as interchangeable with skilled nursing homes, was built and is regulated as a social model of care. This community-based care is less restrictive and strives to be home-like. AL typically offers 1) 24/7 availability of supervision, 2) exercise, health, and wellness programming, 3) housekeeping and maintenance, 4) meals and dining services, 5) medication management or assistance, 6) personal care, and 7) arranging for transportation (NCAL 2023). This differs from nursing home care in that there is no promise of 24/7 access to medical services or constant supervision. AL residents vary greatly in the amount of care they need from person-to-person (Kistler et al. 2017). Some AL residents are spouses who live with their partners whose care needs have become too great but are themselves much more independent. Some move into AL communes to support medication management, housekeeping and cooking and need little other support. Rising acuity levels, meaning the average AL resident has increasingly more health conditions and functional limitations, do mean that as residents age in place, they likely require more health services. While these services could overlay AL services, much like they would if the person needing care was living at home, these are not provided by AL communities. These health care services include primary care, home health, physical and occupational therapies, and hospice and often are performed by contracted providers, sometimes associated with the AL and sometimes contracted or arranged by the resident's family. The haphazard growth of this model and the tensions inherent have spurred calls for Assisted Living to be reimagined (Zimmerman et al. 2022). Assisted Living Residents About half of AL residents are over the age of 85, most are women (70%), about three quarters are not married and about 90% are White. Most AL residents need help with medications, and more than half need help with three or more activities of daily living such as bathing, dressing, or toileting (NCAL 2023; Kemp, Ball & Perkins 2019). AL residents depend on their care networks, a constellation of kin and non-kin involved in resident lives such as friends, neighbors and church or other community members, to arrange medical care, provide social support, coordinate care, engage residents in activities and bring needed supplies such as medications, favorite snacks, health and beauty items, and incontinence pads. These care networks also play an important role in advocating for residents and negotiating care with AL staff (Kemp, Ball & Perkins 2013; Kemp et al. 2018; Kemp 2021). Many residents living in AL have dementia. While the average older person living with dementia lives between four and eight years, they can live 20 years or more (Alzheimer's Association 2023). About 42% of AL residents have a dementia diagnosis (NCAL 2023) but we can assume this is underreported as many older adults are not screened, tested, or diagnosed with dementia despite showing symptoms in memory, thinking, or making decisions that impact everyday activities. The variability in symptoms and experiences is part of what makes people living with dementia so difficult to care for. Like all people with chronic disease, people living with dementia have good days and bad days. Person centered dementia care is needed to tailor care and support to individuals in ways that account for preferences, life experiences, communication styles and support needs that change over time (Fazio 2018). People living with dementia experience stigma and often become isolated. Residential care is an important option for combatting social isolation and exclusion often experienced by people with dementia and their care partners (Nguyen & Li 2020). Assisted Living is an Important Long-Term Care Option AL, unlike nursing home care, is almost entirely private pay. Only 18% of residents rely on Medicaid to pay for daily services (NCAL 2023). Most of these residents are very low- income and qualify for state Medicaid waiver programs that exist in 41 states and that often have waiting lists. According to NCAL (2023) the average monthly cost of AL is $4500. As such, AL is inaccessible to most Americans. Yet, on the spectrum of long-term care, it is often needed. Seen as a step of care between unpaid care by loved ones and nursing home care, AL provides an important long-term care option. When the care needs of a loved one exceeds the capacity of their care network, the person needing care and their unpaid care partners are forced to manage. This is often after an event. This event could be a hospitalization, a fall, a report of self-neglect, an unsafe situation, loss of driving ability or maybe mismanaged finances or medications. Sometimes, after a hospitalization or after insurance-supported inpatient rehabilitation care, discharge planners help individuals with very high care needs and nursing home placement. If that doesn't happen, the care network is forced to navigate, with little support or education, a variety of options, none of which are usually covered by health insurance. If they have significant financial resources, AL is a useful and attractive option. If not, managing the care situation means that care partners reduce working hours, build precarious care or financial arrangements across families, hire piecemeal personal care support or simply cross their fingers and hope things turn out okay. Given the geographic dispersion of today's families, the lack of affordable residential care options often leaves American families in tough situations. Assisted Living and Persistent Workforce Challenges Sixty-six percent of the AL workforce are "aides" or direct care workers (DCWs) (NCAL 2023). DCWs in AL and across long- term care are predominately women, people of color and disproportionally immigrants (PHI 2022). The typical direct care worker in AL makes about $15 an hour, works 36 hours week in AL, and works for a non-profit company. About half have health insurance through their employer and about 22% get health insurance through Medicaid or another means tested program. About half live under 200% of the poverty line with household income at about $46,000 (Kelly et al. 2020). DCWs also face dangerous working conditions, persistent occupational segregation, have limited access to paid leave, and experience very little career advancement (Dill & Duffy 2022; Dill et al. 2022). As stated by Scales & Lepore (2020) "[direct care work] requires a mix of technical caregiving skills; health-related knowledge; infection prevention and control expertise; emotional intelligence and relational skills; and problem-solving and decision-making abilities, among other competencies (p. 173). " Despite highly meaningful jobs with high intrinsic rewards, the lack of extrinsic rewards including compensation, drive turnover (Dill, Morgan & Marshall 2013; Morgan, Dill & Kalleberg 2013). Turnover rates in long- term care have been persistently slow to recover since the start of the COVID 19 pandemic and the recovery has been most difficult for women and people of color (Frogner & Dill 2022). In this context, the use of agency staff, or those that are temporarily hired from staffing agencies to all staffng shortages, has remained persistently high. Use of agency staff makes relationship-based, person-centered care difficult. Many organizations have reduced the number of new residents because they do not have the staffng to accommodate them despite having available licensed beds. More than sixty percent of AL facilities have moderate to high staffng shortages (NCAL 2022). Assisted Living Context and Pressures While the scope of abuse and neglect in AL facilities is unknown, several media reports have called attention to severe cases of neglect and mistreatment and the significant and surprising out-of-pocket costs that face older adults as they age in AL (Teegardin 2019; Rowland et al. 2023; Rau 2023). Abuse and neglect of our Elders and people with disabilities is unacceptable and is far too prevalent. I will say, though, in our hundreds of interviews with DCWs and other staff across the sector, I have met no "bad actors." While there are "bad actors" in all industries who are actively seeking to harm others, it is my experience that DCWs and AL staff go to work wanting to do the best they can, engage in meaningful relationships with their residents and promote their health and wellbeing. AL workers, like most direct care workers, tend to go into this line of work to give back, to make a diffierence, because they value Elders or because it is a calling for them (Kemp et al. 2010). Unfortunately, the system we've set up works against them. DCWs working in all long- term care settings experience low wages, few benefits, heavy workloads, dangerous jobs, and little to no career mobility. These DCWs are managing heavy workloads with unrealistic expectations of what they can get done in one shift, put themselves and their families at risk of infectious disease, are called on to do heavy emotional labor, often managing multiple jobs to make ends meet and many are experiencing burnout after the multiple personal and collective traumas experienced during and after the pandemic. For a group that was already vulnerable, these workers faced grief, uncertainty, risk, high unpaid care demands and high work demands, and mental health needs that go largely unaddressed. For AL management and owners, there is pressure to take or keep residents with high levels of acuity. Filling beds is an imperative to cover staffng costs and now rising agency staffng costs. Well-resourced families would rather have mom in a home- like or hotel-like AL rather than an institutional nursing home if given the choice. We gerontologists advocate for aging in place so that older adults can create home and have familiar settings in which to age well. This supports autonomy, meaning-making, relationship- building and also supports people living with dementia to be in familiar settings to support their cognition. As a social model of care, the walls of the AL building are permeable. People go for walks, sign in and out, go visit families and go on outings. This engagement with the community is vital to the well-being of AL residents (Ciof, Kemp & Bender 2021). Overworked staff, lack of documentation, lack of meaningful oversight, higher acuity levels, lack of communication, and haphazard care coordination mean that residents are vulnerable without these wrap-around supports. The tiered fee structure for additional services many Assisted Living communities offer, corresponds to the needs of residents and the need for providing additional staff to support those residents. Transparency in how those fees are determined and what impact they have on support for the residents who pay those premiums is certainly lacking. We know that 24/7 nursing home care and home health care are both, on average, more expensive than AL. The vast majority of AL services are private pay making it very difficult for residents and their care networks to plan for and understand how charges change over time. Inconsistent Staffing and Training Requirements in AL The AL direct care workforce is comprised of DCWs who are certified or registered (e.g., certified nursing assistants (CNAs)) and those who are not (e.g., personal care aides). AL communities make a choice between hiring CNAs, whose training and competency has been assessed by the State, or personal care aides with little to no formal training (Kemp at al. 2010). The CNA training is monitored by the state agencies responsible for facility licensure. Each state agency reviews CNA training programs for quality and state registries allow employers to verify credentials of DCWs who have completed this training and provide employers data on whether there are any outstanding complaints on file for a particular worker (Kelly et al. 2020). While many AL communities choose to hire CNAs, they lack this minimal oversight for initial training provided staff. In terms of initial and continuing education, states have sizable variability in the topics required (e.g. role of the PCA, consumer rights, ethics, and confidentiality, health care support, infection control) (Kelly et al. 2020). Several states have recently added training requirements for DCWs in AL, particularly in terms of dementia education, but these are generally loosely written and enforced with minimal oversight by state regulatory bodies. Monitoring and Enforcement of Quality of AL Monitoring and enforcement of quality of AL by states is inconsistent and not transparent. Kaskie et al. 2022, from their survey responses of state administrative agents, show that in half the states, monitoring and enforcement oversight of AL was dispersed across three or more agencies, staffing levels and budgets varied greatly. Fewer than 10 of the states shared information about their monitoring and enforcement procedures in a way that would be publicly accessible. Forty- five states conduct inspections at the time of licensure, 39 conduct annual or biannual inspections and only seven require AL facilities to submit an annual report (Kaskie et al. 2022). A Mindset Shift is Needed In her book, Disrupting the Status Quo of Senior Living: A Mindshift, Jill Vitale-Aussem (2019) lays out what I think is the crux of the problem facing senior living. AL is marketed to those who can afford it with a hospitality mindset. They advertise and compete on the basis of amenities, beautiful campuses, luxury food and furnishings, and concierge services. This model encourages residents and families to think about living in AL buildings as though they are going to a hotel or resort. In reality, this framing, where residents are the guests and staff are encouraged to cater to their whims, increases what Dr. Bill Thomas of the Eden Alternative calls the three plagues of long-term care - helplessness, boredom and loneliness. By encouraging passivity, we leave residents with few opportunities for giving back, participating in the community or creative pursuits (Basting 2020). Instead, long-term care that is person-centered, community-minded and empowering has a much better chance of meeting the needs of residents, staff and care partners. Person-centered care means that the person receiving care is in the driver's seat, to the extent they are able and for as long as they can. Ideally, the resident sets the goals of care collaboratively with both unpaid and paid care partners. Person-centered care practices have been associated with improved quality of life and quality of care for residents (Fazio et al., 2018; Poey et al., 2017). Shifting from a hospitality to a community mindset means that residents and the entire care network are valued members of the AL community. This shift encourages relationship building, transparent communication, interdependence and the promotion of citizenship where all members of the community have a role in improving quality of life. An open community mindset would also improve the safety culture of an AL by promoting communication, relationships and empowering all members to look out for one another. Empowerment of residents and their care network is also vital to moving this sector forward. For residents, it's truly engaging them in their own care, using a strengths-based approach where individuals are supported to do as much for themselves for as long as possible no mater how slow the process (Yan et al. 2023). For workers, particularly DCWs, it is more complicated. Empowerment for workers means that we listen to, respect, pay, include, collaborate with, provide for the safety of, educate, and ultimately professionalize the workforce (Morgan and Ahmad 2023). The persons (e.g. resident, staff, care partner), not the task, is what we attend to first. This means that workers have the job quality they need to be whole and happy individuals who can then have the space in their work to be creative and engaged problem-solvers in the community. Empowerment for unpaid care partners includes education on dementia, support to continue to engage and support their loved one and an open invitation to be part of the communities in which their loved one resides (Kemp 2021). Recommendations Support standardization of monitoring and resources to increase state-based oversight and transparency. Standardizing state transparency and oversight supports public awareness of the industry and promotes the ability of potential residents and their care networks to make informed decisions. Improve and standardize initial and continuing education training for DCWs in AL. This should include realistic job preview, interactive and engaging onboarding with peer mentorship and check-ins over the first three months, a training registry that supports both initial and ongoing training and promotes portability, stackability, and career progression. Training requirements should emphasize person- centered dementia care, meaningful engagement, living well with dementia, strength-based approaches, trauma- informed and self- care, communication skills, and non-pharmacological approaches to dementia care. See https://aging.georgia.gov/sites/ aging.georgia.gov/files/GARD%20Competency%20Guide--PDF.pdf Professionalize the direct care workforce. This strategy needs to be engaged in collaboration across long-term care sectors. This is one workforce that moves between and across sector lines constantly. Professionalization includes: occupational credentialing that acknowledges competencies of incumbent workers, ties competency accrual to significant and meaningful career lattices that have transparent wage increases, credentialing that is stackable and leads to higher order credentials that support key areas of need including meaningful engagement of residents, person- centered dementia care, strength-based creative expression outlets (e.g. music, drama, arts, expression), health and wellbeing, trauma-informed approaches, and documentation and quality improvement practices. Incentivize and reward good employers who deliver high quality care. Employers can make incredible differences in the lives of their workers and residents and curb turnover and improve recruitment by enhancing hiring practices, increasing compensation, enhancing benefits, improving orientation and onboarding, increasing access to education and training and expanding career opportunities (See short micro-learning videos on these topics: https://www.youtube.com/ playlist?list=PLXNnxuyRl8NQHl5kx6ukHxVHac--VjOCyn) Increase access to AL. Efforts should be made to increase affordable long-term care residential care options for middle class and working-class American families. This should include education about long-term care options, investment of resources in creating tools for navigating and making informed decisions about long-term care options, and incentives to develop and test inclusive models for rebalancing long-term care in ways that provides high quality care and system savings. Improve care coordination and resources for people living with dementia and their care partners. People living with dementia occupy many long-term care spaces. Regardless of space, they deserve high quality and coordinated care. People are not simply a diagnosis and holistic and integrated care approaches are possible and needed to support the growing number of people with dementia and their care networks. Models such as the GUIDE model (https://www.cms.gov/priorities/ innovation/innovation-models/guide) have great potential to provide holistic care to people with dementia and their care partners in ways that reduce stigma, coordinate care, improve outcomes and provide needed supports for all involved. References Basting, A. (2020). Creative Care A Revolutionary Approach to Dementia and Elder Care[Book]. HarperOne. Cartwright, J., Roberts, K., Oliver, E., Bennet, M., & Whitworth, A. (2022). Montessori mealtimes for dementia: A pathway to person-centred care. Dementia, 21(4), 1098- 1119.Ciofi, J. M., Kemp, C. L., & Bender, A. A. (2022). Assisted living residents with dementia: Being out in the world and negotiating connections. The Gerontologist, 62(2), 200-211. Dill, J., & Duffy, M. (2022). Structural Racism And Black Women's Employment In The US Health Care Sector: Study examines structural racism and black women's employment in the US health care sector. Health Affairs, 41(2), 265-272. Dill, J. S., Morgan, J. C., & Marshall, V. W. (2013). Contingency, employment intentions, and retention of vulnerable low-wage workers: An examination of nursing assistants in nursing homes. The Gerontologist, 53(2), 222- 234. Dill, J., Morgan, J. C., Van Heuvelen, J., & Gingold, M. (2022). Professional certification and earnings of health care workers in low social closure occupations. Social Science & Medicine, 303, 115000. Fazio, S., Pace, D., Flinner, J., & Kallmyer, B. (2018). The fundamentals of person-centered care for individuals with dementia. The Gerontologist, 58(suppl--1), S10-S19. Frogner, B. K., & Dill, J. S. (2022, April). Tracking turnover among health care workers during the COVID-19 pandemic: a cross-sectional study. In JAMA Health Forum (Vol. 3, No. 4, pp. e220371-e220371). American Medical Association. Kaskie, B., Xu, L., Taylor, S., Smith, L., Cornell, P., Zhang, W., ... & Thomas, K. (2022). Promoting quality of life and safety in AL: A survey of state monitoring and enforcement agents. Medical Care Research and Review, 79(5), 731-737. Kelly, C., Morgan, J.C., Kemp, C. L., & Deichert, J. (2020). A profile of the assisted living direct care workforce in the United States. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 39(1), 16-27. Kemp, C. L. (2021). # MoreThanAVisitor: Families as "essential" care partners during COVID-19. The Gerontologist, 61(2), 145-151. Kemp, C. L., Ball, M. M., Hollingsworth, C., & Lepore, M. J. (2010). Connections with residents: "It's all about the residents for me." In Mary M. Ball, Molly M. Perkins, Carole Hollingsworth, & Candace L. Kemp (Eds.), Frontline Workers in Assisted Living (pp. 147-170). Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press. Kemp, C. L., Ball, M. M., Morgan, J. C., Doyle, P. J., Burgess, E. O., & Perkins, M. M. (2018). Maneuvering Together, Apart, and at Odds: Residents' Care Convoys in Assisted Living. The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 73(4), e13-e23. https:// doi.org/10.1093/geronb/gbx184 Kemp, C. L., Ball, M. M., & Perkins, M. M. (2013). Convoys of care: Theorizing intersections of formal and informal care. Journal of Aging Studies, 27: 15-29. doi: 10.1016/ j.jaging2012.10.002 Kemp, C. L., Ball, M. M., & Perkins, M. M. (2019). Individualization and the health care mosaic in AL. The Gerontologist, 59(4), 644-654. Kistler C. E., Zimmerman S., Ward K. T., Reed D., Golin C., Lewis C. L. (2017). Health of older adults in AL and implications for preventive care. The Gerontologist, 57, 949- 954. NCAL (2022) htps://www.ahcancal.org/News-and-Communications/ Fact-Sheets/FactSheets/AL-Survey- June2022.pdf Morgan J.C. & Ahmad W. (2022) Lifting them up: Building Person-Centered Organizations. CSA Journal, Vol 87 (4). Morgan, J.C., Dill, J., & Kalleberg, A. L. (2013). The quality of healthcare jobs: can intrinsic rewards compensate for low extrinsic rewards?. Work, employment and society, 27(5), 802- 822. National Center for Assisted Living (NCAL) (2023) Facts & Figures. (n.d.). https://www.ahcancal.org/Assisted- Living/ Facts-and-Figures/Pages/default.aspx Nguyen, T., & Li, X. (2020). Understanding public-stigma and self-stigma in the context of dementia: A systematic review of the global literature. Dementia, 19(2), 148-181. PHI (2023) Direct Care workers in the United States: Key Facts 2023 - PHI. (2023, September 11). PHI. https:// www.phinational.org/resource/direct-care-workers-in-the-united- states-key-facts-2023/ Poey, J. L., Hermer, L., Cornelison, L., Kaup, M. L., Drake, P., Stone, R. I., & Doll, G. (2017). Does person-centered care improve residents' satisfaction with nursing home quality?. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 18(11), 974-979. Rowland, C., Frankel, T.C., Torbati, Y., Weil, J.Z., Whoriskey, P. & Rich, S. (2023, December 17). An alarming number of assisted-living residents die after wandering away unnoticed. Washington Post. htps://www.washingtonpost.com/ business/interactive/2023/assisted-living-wander-patient- deaths/ Rau, J. (2023, December 1). What to know about Long-Term Care Insurance. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/ 22/health/long-term-care-insurance-explained.html Scales, K., & Lepore, M. J. (2020). Always essential: Valuing direct care workers in long-term care. Public Policy & Aging Report, 30(4), 173-177. Teegardin, B. S. C. (2019, September 29). Suffering behind the facade. AJC. https://www.ajc.com/news/state--regional/ suffering-behind-the-facade/gEMTySxJUMEQ6GhD1OQiFO/ Vitale-Aussem, (2019) J. Disrupting the Status Quo of Senior Living: A Mindshift. Health Professions Press, ISBN 978- 1938870828, 216 pages. Yan, Z., Traynor, V., Alananzeh, I., Drury, P., & Chang, H. C. (2023). The impact of montessori-based programmes on individuals with dementia living in residential aged care: A systematic review. Dementia, 14713012231173817. Zimmerman, S., Carder, P., Schwartz, L., Silbersack, J., Temkin-Greener, H., Thomas, K. S., ... & Williams, K. B. (2022). The imperative to reimagine assisted living. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 23(2), 225-234. U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Prepared Witness Testimony Julie Simpkins Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and members of the U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging, thank you for inviting me here today to be a part of this important discussion on assisted living, a topic that is near and dear to my heart. My name is Julie Simpkins, and I am the co-president and chief operating officer of Gardant Management Solutions, a provider that develops and operates senior living, assisted living, and memory care communities. We are the fifth largest assisted living provider in the country and have communities in five states - Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Maryland, and West Virginia. I have dedicated most of my life to senior living, spending 30 years working primarily in assisted living. This is my calling, and I'd like to speak with you today about Gardant's unique model and share thoughts on how we can work together on important issues facing those who need and work in assisted living. Gardant is uniquely focused on offering affordable assisted living to low-income seniors. Our company was founded in 1999 after the creation of the Illinois Supportive Living Program, a home- and community-based Medicaid waiver program. Now, as we have expanded into four other states, our commitment to serving this population remains. The majority of residents living in Gardant communities rely on Medicaid for their assisted living care through these waiver programs. Gardant has been limited in where we can offer our services due to the variability with state Medicaid waiver programs. It depends on the availability of state programs, state reimbursement levels, and the number of available waiver spots. Offering affordable assisted living exclusively - or even for a majority of residents like Gardant - requires an entirely different business model altogether. We have had to persistently seek out HUD loans and income tax credits to stay viable. Therefore, we fully support efforts to make long-term care, including assisted living, more affordable to low- and middle-income seniors. With a rapidly growing elderly population, we need a public and private partnership to incentivize more providers to develop these models. When we talk about assisted living, it's important to note that every state, every facility, and every resident is different. Efforts to standardize all assisted living communities would be both unworkable and irresponsible for resident care. State regulations recognize the diversity within assisted living while holding our profession accountable, and they are consistently updated to reflect the evolving nature of our sector and our residents. Meanwhile, Gardant is committed to exceeding state requirements when we believe it is in the best interest of our residents. Take memory care as an example, and something that is top of mind for this Committee as well as our residents and families. Every staff member at Gardant managed memory care communities receive education and training in dementia and related diseases as well as training as a Certified Dementia Practitioner training. While elopements are rare, we overreport any to the state immediately - even something as technical as a resident walking out the door and instantly returning after a staff member sees them. We know they didn't leave our facility and our staff immediately addressed the situation, but we still report it. The recent reports of resident elopements that were ultimately fatal are heartbreaking, and my thoughts and prayers go out to the loved ones of those residents. I serve in leadership positions on numerous national organizations dedicated to long- term care, and I know these tragic incidents are extremely rare and not indicative of the assisted living experience. The overwhelming majority of families and residents have a life- affirming, safe experience. Assisted living providers are committed to upholding our policies and procedures, as well as continuing to learn all that we can about dementia care to prevent these incidents. It is critical that policies and regulations help protect residents while still supporting freedom of movement and independence for residents living with dementia. Assisted living is a critical aspect of the long-term care continuum, dedicated to delivering person-centered care to our nation's seniors. We need collaborative, comprehensive solutions that help ensure our ability, as assisted living communities, to continue doing what we do best - providing safe, quality care to our residents. From expanding more affordable long-term care options, to workforce programs to address the growing caregiver shortage, these efforts could make a real difference. We must all work together to ensure every current and future assisted living resident is seen, safe, and served to enjoy the highest quality of life possible. Thank you for your time and I look forward to answering your questions today. U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Prepared Witness Testimony Richard Mollot Introduction Good morning, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Braun, and Members of the Committee. Thank you for inviting me to testify today on this important issue. My name is Richard Mollot. I am the executive director of the Long Term Care Community Coalition (LTCCC). LTCCC is a national non-profit, non-partisan organization dedicated to improving care and quality of life for residents in nursing homes and assisted living. We conduct substantive research on long-term care policies and the extent to which essential standards of care are realized in the lives of residents, who are typically elderly and frail. In addition to conducting systemic analysis and advocacy, we educate and engage residents, families, and those who work with them, so that they are aware of their rights and are equipped to overcome the challenges that so many of our seniors face when they need residential care. While timelines vary, essentially, assisted living emerged in the 1980s as an alternate to nursing homes for seniors who want or need to live in a congregate setting where they an get help with tasks like housekeeping, meal preparation, and access to activities and transportation.\1\ Over the last 40 years, three developments have drastically changes the nature and character of the assisted living sector, with both positive and negative implications. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Wilson, K.B., "Historical Evolution of Assisted Living in the United States, 1979 to the Present," The Gerontologist, Volume 47, Issue suppl--1, Pages 8-22 (December 2007). https://doi.org/10.1093/ geront/47.Supplement--1.8. 1. The needs and frailty of assisted living residents have --------------------------------------------------------------------------- dramatically increased; 2. Assisted living operators have adopted increasingly sophisticated and large-scale corporate models, including ownership by Real Estate Investment Trusts, Private Equity, and other sophisticated private investment structures;\2\ and --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ See, for example, Fenne, M., "Private equity's growing presence in senior living," The Private Equity Stakeholder Project (blog post). (December 2023). https://pestakeholder.org/news/private-equitys- growing-presence-in-senior-living/. 3. Public payment and support for assisted living services --------------------------------------------------------------------------- has increased dramatically. The subsequent discussion delves into some of the ramifications of these trends, followed by recommendations aimed at fostering a sustainable business model for assisted living that effectively meets the evolving needs of our expanding senior population. The Growing Needs and Expectations of Our Expanding Senior Population to Live Safety and with Dignity Assisted living facilities (ALFs) are increasingly viewed by seniors and their families as a desirable option for residential care, particularly for those who wish to avoid the institutional environment that typically defines life in a nursing home. In fact, assisted living is the fastest growing form of senior housing in the United States.\3\ While too often overlooked by policymakers and oversight agencies, assisted living facilities house a comparable number of individuals to nursing homes in the United States. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ Castillo, L., "Assisted Living Industry Statistics," GITNUX Marketdata Report 2024 (December 2023). https://gitnux.org/assisted-living-industry- statistics/#::text= Assisted%20care%experiences%20the%20highest%20growth%in%20 terms,fastest%20growing%20segment%20of%20the%20senior%20 housing%20market. Importantly, ALFs do much more than just providing accommodations and assistance with housekeeping and prepared meals, as they largely did in the past. They now provide a range of health and support services to residents with --------------------------------------------------------------------------- increasing needs (and vulnerabilities): 1. Approximately 40 - 70% of assisted living residents have Alzheimer's Disease or some other cognitive impairment.\4\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ Estimates vary, and the lack of firm data on this important point is a result of the lack of transparency in the assisted living industry (including the needs of those they serve and the capacity of those providing care and services). 2. More than half of ALF residents are 85 or older (compared to 42% in nursing homes).\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\ Zimmerman S, Sloane PD, Wretman CJ, et al., "Recommendations for Medical and Mental Health Care in Assisted Living Based on an Expert Delphi Consensus Panel: A Consensus Statement," JAMA Network Open (2022). https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/ fullarticle/2796840. 3. Over 50% have hypertension.\6\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ Zimmerman, S., Wenhan, G., et al., "Health Care Needs in Assisted Living: Survey Data May Underestimate Chronic Conditions," Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, Volume 22, Issue 2, 471 - 473 (December 2020). https://www.jamda.com/article/S1525- 8610(20)31022-7/fulltext. 4. One-third or more have heart disease or depression.\7\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Id. 5. About half need help with dressing and/or walking and 64% need help with bathing.\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ National Center for Assisted Living, Assisted Living Facts & Figures. https://www.ahcancal.org/Assisted-Living/Facts-and-Figures/Pages/ default.aspx. 6. Over 10% of ALF residents with dementia are administered antipsychotic drugs, which carry a FDA "black box" warning against use on elderly people, due to significant risks of heart attack, stroke, Parkinsonism, falls, and death.\9\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\ Zhang, T., Thomas, K., et al., "State Variation in Antipsychotic Use Among Assisted Living Residents With Dementia," JAMDA, Volume 24, Issue 4 (February 2023).https://www.jamda.com/ article/S1525-8610(23)00088-9/fulltext. In summary, the evolving care requirements of assisted living residents have grown increasingly intricate over the years. As seniors experience longer lifespans with chronic conditions, notably dementia, the susceptibility of this demographic has heightened. Despite the escalating needs and vulnerabilities, the federal government has consistently adopted a "hands-off" stance, and state regulations are generally characterized by weakness and lax enforcement. Consequently, the assisted living sector operates under a caveat emptor - let the buyer beware - principle. We can and must do better for American seniors and --------------------------------------------------------------------------- their families. We can and must do better for American seniors and their families. The Imperative to Improve Transparency About Quality and Safety While the notion of "buyer beware" is already disconcerting for seniors and their families, the situation is exacerbated by the pervasive lack of transparency that extends to virtually every facet of assisted living. In any typical consumer scenario, one would rightfully anticipate clear information about the services to be provided, costs, quality, and safety. However, in the realm of assisted living, obtaining crucial indicators is challenging, if not impossible. Who's providing care? How much will living and services cost? What happens when/if I need more care and services? What happens if I run out of money? What is the quality record of this facility? If a facility has had issues, how do I find out what they were and, most importantly, what was done to address them? In the world of assisted living, the answers to these vital questions are not only hard to find, they are often purposefully obfuscated by both operators and the state agencies that are supposed to be protecting residents. Unlike nursing homes, for which vigorous, professional assessments are required upon entrance and periodically, to a large extent ALFs are free to accept - and retain - whomever they want. Licensed nurses may or may not be on hand to supervise care for residents with higher needs, respond to a fall, or ensure that medications are given correctly. Care, monitoring, and dignity for individuals with dementia may be wonderful or slipshod, depending on the facility or, even, the operator's profit goals for the quarter. While approximately 75% of ALFs claim to have a "memory care unit,"\10\ this term is often more a marketing strategy than an accurate representation of specialized care. Seniors and their families may lean on this term when placing an individual with dementia, despite potentially disastrous disparities in actual care quality. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\ Bretschneider, A., "Understanding the Cost of Memory Care" (December 2023). https://www.seniorly.com/resource-center/senior- living-guides/how-much-does-memory-care-cost#. The Case for Federal Interest and Engagement in Safeguarding --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Quality and Integrity in the Assisted Living Industry Although assisted living is commonly seen as a private enterprise functioning with a non-governmental payment model, it is essential to recognize the growing importance of public funding and the escalating demand for federal involvement. The government's interests have expanded over the years, emphasizing the need to ensure robust consumer protections and foster a healthy assisted living industry. 1. Close to 20% of assisted living residents currently rely on Medicaid to pay for services.\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\ National Center for Assisted Living, Assisted Living: A Growing Aspect of Long Term Care.https://www.ahcancal.org/Advocacy/ IssueBriefs/NCAL--Factsheet--2023.pdf. 2. Forty-seven states plus the District of Columbia provide --------------------------------------------------------------------------- access to Medicaid assisted living. 3. The U.S. Supreme Court's landmark 1999 Olmstead decision established that the unjustified institutional isolation of people with disabilities is a form of discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The court declared that states are required to make reasonable modifications to publicly funded programs to accommodate qualified individuals who desire to live in the most integrated setting.\12\ To meet this requirement, states have been "rebalancing" access to publicly-funded long-term care services over the last 25 years, favoring home and community-based services, which can encompass assisted living, over nursing home placement. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\ Long Term Care Community Coalition, Single Point of Entry for Long Term Care and Olmstead: An Introduction and National Perspective for Policy Makers, Consumers and Advocacy Organizations (2005).https:// nursinghome411.org/single-point-of-entry-for-long-term-care-and- olmstead-an-introduction-and-national-perspective-for-policy-makers- consumers-and-advocacy-organizations/. 4. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) provides advantageous loans to finance the purchase, refinance, new construction, or substantial rehabilitation of assisted --------------------------------------------------------------------------- living. 5. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) has focused on the need to improve safety and accountability in assisted living numerous times over the last 25 plus years. Unfortunately, the persistent failure to take substantive action to implement most of the GAO's recommendations over the years has resulted in untold numbers of residents suffering harm, including financial exploitation, sexual assault, and even death, due to substandard care and lack of promised supervision. 6. The LTC Ombudsman Program, which monitors care and helps residents resolve complaints under the authority of the Older Americans Act, has been authorized to monitor assisted living and provide services to residents since 1981. 7. Numerous news reports, in both local and national media, have uncovered the painful and heart-breaking problems that can occur as a result of the lack of federal standards and weak state oversight. A recent report from The Atlanta Journal- Constitution is emblematic: "During a routine room check, an 88-year-old resident told workers that hours earlier she had been sexually assaulted by another resident." Three weeks later, an investigation by the Georgia Department of Community Health found that Savannah Court of Lake Oconee "failed to provide supervision consistent with the residents' needs." "While the incident would be distressing on its own, its timing adds a layer of alarm. The assault took place two months after the state sent Savannah Court of Lake Oconee a notice that it planned to revoke its license, and while such an action should imply serious safety concerns, the department's efforts to move the process along and ensure residents are free from harm have lacked urgency. ...Court documents and inspection reports reviewed by The Atlanta-Journal Constitution show that, since 2021, Savannah Court of Lake Oconee has accrued over 70 state violations, including two incidents where residents died."\13\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\ Gross, A., "Possible closure of Georgia senior home reveals flaws in state oversight," The Atlanta Journal-Constitution (January 2024).https://www.ajc.com/news/possible-closure-of-georgia-senior-home- reveals-flaws-in-state-oversight/RWJRB3GBABFUPJ7RFFBANW7FMI/#. A senior or their family would have trouble finding out this history. Savannah Court's website provides no inkling about any of these problems (no matter what steps, if any, were taken to address them). It paints an entirely rosy picture of "an ideal place for your loved ones to age in place while also providing you with the peace of mind that comes with knowing they are well cared for."\14\ The state's "Find a Facility" page only provides a single row of information with the facility's address, phone number, bed capacity, and administrator.\15\ One has to do a separate search in a separate database of inspection reports to find any record of what has transpired in the facility. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \14\ https://www.savannahcourtlakeoconee.com/. Accessed January 22, 2024. \15\ https://forms.dch.georgia.gov/HFRD/GaMap2Care.html. Beyond highlighting the imperative for substantive measures to enhance safety and quality, the substantial variances among assisted living facilities, encompassing staffing levels, services provided, and costs, underscore the need for decisive --------------------------------------------------------------------------- action to improve both quality assurance and transparency. Recommendations 1. Establish and Implement National Standards to Promote Quality, Safety, and Integrity in Assisted Living: For years, the states have functioned as an incubator for developing assisted living policies. While this has not resulted in a high-quality system, there are many lessons that can be learned, and existing state requirements provide a logical basis for promulgating federal rules.\16\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \16\ See, LTCCC, Assisted Living: Promising Policies and Practices (2018). https://nursinghome411.org/ltccc-report-assisted-living- promising-policies-and-practices/. A system of regular inspections and oversight at the facility and corporate levels should be developed to ensure --------------------------------------------------------------------------- compliance with these standards. 2. Establish a National Assisted Living Database: Create a centralized and standardized database that includes key metrics on assisted living facilities' performance, include: staffing (levels and competencies), ownership, charges for residential and care services, and citation history (including how those citations were corrected and any penalties that were imposed). This database should be easily accessible to the public, empowering families with the information needed to make informed decisions. 3. Promote Resident and Family Engagement: Develop rules for the rights of resident and family councils in assisted living. Strengthen the involvement of residents and their families in the internal policies and operation of their assisted living facility (such as by strengthening requirements under the Home and Community-Based Settings regulations promulgated in 2014). Conclusion Improving transparency, quality, and accountability in assisted living is not only a matter of public interest but a moral imperative. Now more than ever, federal action is needed to ensure that older Americans receive the care and support they deserve while fostering a system that promotes transparency and accountability within the industry. I appreciate the Committee's commitment to addressing these critical issues, and I am available to provide any additional information or answer questions that may arise during or after the hearing. Thank you for your consideration of my testimony and the issues raised herein. ? ======================================================================= Questions for the Record ======================================================================= ? U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Questions for the Record Patricia Vessenmeyer Chairman Robert P. Casey, Jr. Question: What recommendations do you have to ensure that assisted living workers can provide residents with the type and quality of care that they need? Response: Caregiving for dementia patients is extremely difficult. There appears to be ample training options available, of which many of these facilities are not taking advantage. I would recommend that caregivers be required to take additional training classes to become certified as dementia-patient caregivers. They should also receive compensation commensurate with this higher level of training. Perhaps a program where the facility operators also reimburse the caregivers for their training costs would encourage more to enter the field. Question: What regulations or policies would you like to see in place to ensure that assisted living facilities are delivering on the services they promise? Response: Decreasing the maximum number of patients per caregiver would be very helpful. Right now, that number is controlled at the state level, and I understand that this would be a challenge to change on a national basis. However, as I mentioned in my testimony, many of these caregivers want to do a good job, but simply have too many residents in their care. Also, perhaps there could be a way to oversee performance and hold these organizations accountable. U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Questions for the Record Dr. Jennifer Craft Morgan Chairman Robert P. Casey, Jr. Question: Please share with us the profile of the assisted living direct care workforce, workplace supports, and opportunities for job growth, or lack thereof. Can you share any policy recommendations on increasing retention and creating opportunities for job advancement, including federal policies, or state policies that could be replicated? Response: A full profile of workforce demographics and training can be found in the linked article below (Kelly, Morgan & Kemp 2020). Like direct care workers across long-term care, AL DCWs are predominately women, about half are people of color and about 20% are immigrants. The typical direct care worker in AL makes about $15 an hour, works 36 hours week in AL, and works for a for-profit company. About half have health insurance through their employer and about 22% get health insurance through Medicaid or another means tested program. About half live under 200% of the poverty line with household income at about $46,000 (Kelly et al. 2020). DCWs also face dangerous working conditions, persistent occupational segregation, have limited access to paid leave, and experience very little career advancement (Dill & Duffy 2022; Dill et al. 2022). As stated by Scales & Lepore (2020) "[direct care work] requires a mix of technical caregiving skills; health-related knowledge; infection prevention and control expertise; emotional intelligence and relational skills; and problem-solving and decision-making abilities, among other competencies (p. 173)." Despite highly meaningful jobs with high intrinsic rewards, the lack of extrinsic rewards including compensation, drive turnover (Dill, Morgan & Marshall 2013; Morgan, Dill & Kalleberg 2013). Turnover rates in long- term care have been persistently slow to recover since the start of the COVID 19 pandemic and the recovery has been most difficult for women and people of color (Frogner & Dill 2022). In this context, the use of agency staff, or those that are temporarily hired from staffing agencies to fill staffing shortages, has remained persistently high. Use of agency staff makes relationship-based, person-centered care difficult. Many organizations have reduced the number of new residents because they do not have the staffing to accommodate them despite having available licensed beds. More than sixty percent of AL facilities have moderate to high staffing shortages (NCAL 2022). Improve and standardize initial and continuing education training for DCWs in AL: Policies to implement include increased requirements for initial training and continuing education of workers and implementing a coordinated way to share best practices and offer technical assistance. These practices and topics should include realistic job preview, interactive and engaging onboarding with peer mentorship and check-ins over the first three months, a training registry that supports both initial and ongoing training and promotes portability, stackability, and career progression. Training requirements should emphasize person-centered care, meaningful engagement, living well with dementia, strength-based approaches, traumainformed and self- care, communication skills, and non-pharmacological approaches to dementia care. Several states including Florida (430.5025 F.A.C.) have increased the required content for initial and continuing education for DCWs in Assisted Living. Also, while AL workers do not have to be CNAs, many of them are, so legislation that increased the continuing education requirements for the CNA workforce would raise requirements for initial and continuing education across much of long-term care. Professionalize the direct care workforce: This strategy needs to be engaged in collaboration across long- term care sectors. States such as Wisconsin (https:// wiscaregivercna.com/) have created partnerships across provider associations and state government to establish education and career pathways for direct care workers. This is one workforce that moves between and across sector lines constantly. Professionalization includes: occupational credentialing that acknowledges competencies of incumbent workers, ties competency accrual to significant and meaningful career lattices that have transparent wage increases, credentialing that is stackable and leads to higher order credentials that support key areas of need including meaningful engagement of residents, person- centered care, strength-based creative expression outlets (e.g. music, drama, arts, expression), health and wellbeing, trauma- informed approaches, and documentation and quality improvement practices. The Journal of Applied Gerontology has made this article publicly available upon my request: https:// journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0733464818757000. Question: Please share with us how assisted living facilities work to ensure that residents are supported in their activities of daily living, as well as being emotionally and intellectually supported? Response: Person-centered care means that the person receiving care is in the driver's seat, to the extent they are able and for as long as they can. Ideally, the resident sets the goals of care collaboratively with both unpaid and paid care partners. Person-centered care practices have been associated with improved quality of life and quality of care for residents (Fazio et al., 2018; Poey et al., 2017). Empowerment of residents and their care network is also vital to moving this sector forward. For residents, it's truly engaging them in their own care, using a strengths-based approach where individuals are supported to do as much for themselves for as long as possible no matter how slow the process (Yan et al. 2023). Assisted Living organizations create dense activity calendars that offer things for Assisted Living residents to do, but to engage residents emotionally and intellectually, we have found that these approaches are the most successful (particularly for residents with dementia): 1) Knowing the person, 2) Connecting with and meeting them where they are, 3) Being in the moment and 4) Realizing that every interaction is an opportunity for engagement (Kemp et al. 2021). Question: Please share with us strategies that states use to hold assisted living facilities accountable and how they could do a better job? Response: Standardizing state transparency and oversight supports public awareness of the industry and promotes the ability of potential residents and their care networks to make informed decisions. This should include publishing of quality data similar to that of the nursing home sector (https://www.medicare.gov/care- compare/). This will need to include regulation and oversight where states have to report survey results and individual AL communities will have to regularly report on quality indicators, incidents and deficiencies. Coordination of technical assistance and supportive resources for providers to meet standards and implement best practices will likely be necessary (Kaskie et al. 2022). Question: Would you support a set of federal regulations for assisted living facilities? If so, what issues would be most critical to have federal regulations address? Response: I would support federal regulations for assisted living facilities that support information sharing, transparency, public access to quality data and oversight data. These aspects are key to supporting high quality. Several states have made significant improvements to regulation(https:// www.ahcancal.org/Assisted-Living/Policy/Documents/2023--reg-- review.pdf). Technical assistance and support states to improve their regulation, quality data and documentation quality would be useful. The most critical issues to address are: worker initial and continuing training, career advancement, resident abuse, quality improvement efforts, efforts to combat social isolation, infection control, and strategies to support resident safety. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand Question: Staffing shortages in assisted living facilities are reaching crisis levels and are exacerbated by insufficient pay and benefits, strenuous workloads, limited training and advancement opportunities, and stigma. MY National Domestic Workers Bill of Rights Act extends common workplace rights to assisted living facilities workers while at the same time creating new protections and stronger ways of enforcing them. Is the current assisted living facilities workforce prepared to care adequately for residents with cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's Disease? Are programs or certifications available so that our ALF workforce may improve the quality of their care delivery? Response: No. Training is inconsistent across Assisted Living organizations and is not universally required (https:// www.ahcancal.org/Assisted-Living/Policy/Pages/state- regulations.aspx). There are several training certifications that are useful but not widespread. These include but are not limited to the Eden Alternative's Certified Eden Associate Training and Dementia Beyond Drugs, Teepa Snow's Positive Approach to Care Training Certifications, and training offered by the National Council of Certified Dementia Practitioners. Question: How would direct care worker protections like adequate breaks during work hours and training programs also protect assisted living facility residents? Would addressing factors that contribute to assisted living facility direct care worker burnout also benefit organizations and residents? Response: These protections would help a great deal. Burnout is real and pervasive in these and most long-term care organizations. Resources and requirements that hold employers accountable and reward good employers are important. Employers can make incredible differences in the lives of their workers and residents and curb turnover and improve recruitment by enhancing hiring practices, increasing compensation, enhancing benefits, improving orientation and onboarding, increasing access to education and training and expanding career opportunities (See short micro-learning videos on these topics: (https://www.youtube.com/ playlist?list=PLXNnxuyRl8NQHl5kx6ukHxVHac--VjOCyn). Greater access to mental health resources is sorely needed. This could be done through Employment Assistance programs or other collaboratives among organizations. High quality, low-cost mental health services are needed for all members of the care network, including residents. Destigmatizing and normalizing mental health and well-being promotion is vital for this industry. It is important to realize how interconnected residents, paid and unpaid care partners are in the AL context. The support of each impacts the other. Better supports for staff means they will be better positioned to provide care (Kemp 2021, Kemp et al. 2018). Question: What issues does marketing an assisted living facility as a "memory unit" create for consumers with cognitive impairment? Response: There should be standards attached to the ability to market dementia care services to potential residents and families. In my opinion, this would include environmental supports (e.g. lighting, built environment, privacy, community, safety), social supports (e.g. community engagement, meaningful engagement, avenues for contributing), and training supports (e.g. person-centered dementia care training, strengths-based & Montessori-based training, communication training, quality improvement and team training). References Dill, J., & Duffy, M. (2022). Structural Racism And Black Women's Employment In The US Health Care Sector: Study examines structural racism and black women's employment in the US health care sector. Health Affairs, 41(2), 265-272. Dill, J. S., Morgan, J. C., & Marshall, V. W. (2013). Contingency, employment intentions, and retention of vulnerable low-wage workers: An examination of nursing assistants in nursing homes. The Gerontologist, 53(2), 222-234. Dill, J., Morgan, J. C., Van Heuvelen, J., & Gingold, M. (2022). Professional certification and earnings of health care workers in low social closure occupations. Social Science & Medicine, 303, 115000. Fazio, S., Pace, D., Flinner, J., & Kallmyer, B. (2018). The fundamentals of person-centered care for individuals with dementia. The Gerontologist, 58(suppl--1), S10-S19. Frogner, B. K., & Dill, J. S. (2022, April). Tracking turnover among health care workers during the COVID19 pandemic: a cross- sectional study. In JAMA Health Forum (Vol. 3, No. 4, pp. e220371e220371). American Medical Association. Kaskie, B., Xu, L., Taylor, S., Smith, L., Cornell, P., Zhang, W., ... & Thomas, K. (2022). Promoting quality of life and safety in AL: A survey of state monitoring and enforcement agents. Medical Care Research and Review, 79(5), 731-737. Kelly, C., Morgan, J.C., Kemp, C. L., & Deichert, J. (2020). A profile of the assisted living direct care workforce in the United States. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 39(1), 16-27. Kemp, C. L., Ball, M. M., Morgan, J. C., Doyle, P. J., Burgess, E. O., & Perkins, M. M. (2018). Maneuvering Together, Apart, and at Odds: Residents' Care Convoys in Assisted Living. The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 73(4), e13-e23. https:// doi.org/10.1093/geronb/gbx184. Kemp, C. L. (2021). # MoreThanAVisitor: Families as "essential" care partners during COVID-19. The Gerontologist, 61(2), 145-151. Kemp, C. L., Bender, A. A., Ciofi, J., Craft Morgan, J., Burgess, E. O., Duong, S., ... & Perkins, M. M. (2021). Meaningful engagement among assisted living residents with dementia: Successful approaches. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 40(12), 1751-1757. Morgan, J.C., Dill, J., & Kalleberg, A. L. (2013). The quality of healthcare jobs: can intrinsic rewards compensate for low extrinsic rewards?. Work, employment and society, 27(5), 802- 822. NCAL (2022) https://www.ahcancal.org/News-and-Communications/ Fact-Sheets/FactSheets/AL-SurveyJune2022.pdf. Poey, J. L., Hermer, L., Cornelison, L., Kaup, M. L., Drake, P., Stone, R. I., & Doll, G. (2017). Does personcentered care improve residents' satisfaction with nursing home quality?. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 18(11), 974-979. Scales, K., & Lepore, M. J. (2020). Always essential: Valuing direct care workers in long-term care. Public Policy & Aging Report, 30(4), 173-177. Yan, Z., Traynor, V., Alananzeh, I., Drury, P., & Chang, H. C. (2023). The impact of montessori-based programmes on individuals with dementia living in residential aged care: A systematic review. Dementia, 14713012231173817. U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults January 25, 2024 Questions for the Record Julie Simpkins Please see pages 59 through 77 for Questions, Responses, and Exhibits [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] For Exhibits 1 through 4, please see additional exhibits submitted by Julie Simpkins in the "Statements for the Record" section. [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging "Assisted Living Facilities: Understanding Long-Term Care Options for Older Adults" January 25, 2024 Questions for the Record Richard Mollot Chairman Robert P. Casey, Jr. Question: Can you tell us what standard information about assisted living facilities would be most useful to families and who should be collecting and disseminating that information? Response: Seniors and their families would strongly benefit from the following information about assisted living facilities: 1. Staffing, including: a. the licensure, certification, and training levels of all staff providing resident care or services; b. whether there is a RN, MD, or other professional (i.e., individual with licensure to provide professional supervision, such as assess residents and manage medications) on staff with a regular presence in the nursing home (full time or part time indicated); c. the numbers of each type of care staff present in the building by shift and weekday vs. weekend based upon payroll or other auditable records; and d. Whether there are staff in the building 24/7 (indicating whether or not staff are required to be awake during their shifts). 2. Services offered, including: a. Care: Whether or not the facility provides specialized dementia care, aging in place, hospice, palliative, and/or Medicaid assisted living (or other reduced cost options), the extent to which these services are available (such as entire facility or one wing), the licensure/certification of individuals providing any special services; b. Community: Including whether there are resident and/or family councils (with contact information), a recent calendar of activities that the facility provides to residents, and how the facility provides connections to the broader community (i.e., bus to local shopping, religious services, etc.) 3. Costs of residential, care, and other services in a clear and concise manner (including costs of residence, cost of meals, cost of assistance and other services; what is included in base rate vs what will cost extra now or in the future). 4. Resident rights in the facility under state and federal law, including ADA and other non-discrimination rights, rights to access to LTC Ombudsman services, contacts for the LTC Ombudsman, Adult Protective Services, state oversight agency, law enforcement, emergency services and state "No Wrong Door" access point (see https://nwd.acl.gov/index.html). 5. Quality & Safety of facility, including access to complete inspection and citation records that are unredacted (except for the name(s) of residents). 6. Facility policies, including transfer/discharge policies, whether the facility imposes a pre-dispute arbitration clause in its residency agreements, whether residents have rights to have pets, smoking and drinking policies, etc. 7. Ownership of facility, including any individual or entity with 5% or greater ownership interest and the administrator of the facility, in a searchable federal database that provides information on ownership within and across states, with access to inspection and citation records. To the greatest extent possible, this information should be collected and published by the federal government in an online tool similar to Home Health Compare, Hospice Compare, etc. In addition, facilities should be required to have this information available for inspection by residents, families, and visitors in the facility and on its website (if it has one). The information provided by the facility should be in English and any other language of the residents that it has accepted into its facility. Question: The written testimony of Ms. Julie Simpkins stated that federal regulations would be irresponsible. Based on your research, do you think industry standardizations would be irresponsible for resident care? Response: The growing body of news media reports, Government Accountability Office reports, and peer-reviewed studies all indicate that, in fact, it is irresponsible not to have baseline federal assisted living standards to protect residents from physical, emotional, and financial harm. It is important to provide some background here. In order to fight growing calls for baseline federal standards, the industry has fallen back on the argument that such standards would inhibit its ability to provide individualized care and services. This is a false argument. Federal regulations are needed to ensure baseline safety, quality, transparency, and accountability. They would actually foster improvements in resident-centered care, by helping individuals and families understand what they have a right to expect and the extent to which a facility will be able to fulfill their needs, expectations, and goals now and in the future. Question: Can you speak to ways in which the industry standards could be improved, while still recognizing the diversity within assisted living? Response: Some ways in which industry standards could be improved include: 1. Setting baseline requirements for the individuals providing care and services in assisted living (including the minimum numbers of care staff in a facility and the licensure/ certification of those staff; 2. Establishing clear definitions of "memory care" and "aging in place" and other terminology used by the industry (so that they are more than just hollow marketing terms); 3. Ensuring that facilities fulfill their promises to seniors and families by establishing standards for government oversight including annual inspections carried out by state inspection teams with relevant core competencies (i.e., nurse, dietician, social worker) and meaningful penalties for violations that impact resident safety and dignity.; 4. Fire, emergency planning, safety requirements; 5. Implement federal community characteristic standards - which were recently promulgated for Medicaid assisted living - for all assisted living. None of these categories of standards would in any way impede an operator's ability to meet the diverse needs of the community it is serving. For more specific information on these and other policies that would improve quality of life and quality of care in assisted living, please see our report, "Assisted Living: Promising Policies and Practices for Improving Resident Health, Quality of Life, and Safety." https://nursinghome411.org/ltccc-report-assisted-living- promising-policies-and-practices/ Question: Ms. Simpkins also states in her testimony that state regulations are "consistently updated." Is it your experience that state regulations are consistently updated? If not, what are your recommendations for how and when they should be updated? Response: To my knowledge, state laws and regulations are not consistently updated. In fact, in my experience, state legislators tend to be disinclined to promulgate new assisted living laws and when changes or updates are implemented, they tend to be in response to pressure from industry lobbyists, resulting in a significant weakening of state rules and their enforcement. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand Question: Assisted living facilities are not required to disclose inspection reports, financial reinvestment in patient care, or staffing requirements for services offered. Residents and families should be aware of safety violations found during inspections, but this information is not always made public. In New York, citations are available, but the full inspection report is not. How would resident care improve by making information from current assisted living facilities inspections public? Response: Better information would enable prospective residents to make informed choices about where they are going. It would enable current residents and families to be aware of what is going on in their assisted living - their home - and hold their facility accountable for addressing the problems. Question: Does a lack of information exacerbate the health and financial burdens for residents and their families to house loved ones in assisted living facilities? What information should be available to the aging population to help them prepare for long-term care? Response: In short, yes. People tend to think that their base monthly payment will cover most if not all of their costs. However, additional costs often arise unexpectedly, particularly as an individual's needs increase. A resident may not realize when they ask for a helping hand it will come with a price tag. Seniors and their families need accessible information on what services are available to them, where they can access those services (with meaningful information on the potential strengths and weaknesses of different options), who will be providing the services (nurse, certified nurse aide, or someone with less or no training), how much services will cost, and options for paying for those services. Furthermore, seniors and their families should be informed, in clear language, about the agencies or companies that are providing services and the quality record of those providers. Question: Would transparency in the assisted living facility industry help residents during the transition from assisted living to skilled nursing facilities? Response: Yes. Due to lax state rules and oversight, too many assisted living retain residents for whom they can no longer provide safe care. Transparency would empower residents and families to make choices appropriate for their needs. Question: Private equity firms have capitalized on assisted living facilities as a real estate opportunity to collect higher profit yields than other investments in offices and hotels. Assisted living facilities increasingly house older adults whose the health needs demand care and specialization, but private equity firms have minimal accountability for the services they provide. When residents suffer harm while living in assisted living facilities, are they able to choose a course of action, such as a jury trial or arbitration, to hold assisted living facilities accountable. Does the current process adequately protect residents and the public from unnecessary harm? Does it facilitate transparency? Response: Too often, the answer to this question is no. Many assisted living companies insert pre-dispute arbitration clauses into their residency agreements, which effectively prevents someone from suing, even when their loved one has been severely harmed or dies as a result of neglect or grossly substandard care. Question: What consequences do private equity firms face when negligent behavior or harm occurs to residents or workers under their supervision? Response: Unfortunately, due to the lack of accountability and transparency, we have no way of knowing specifics about consequences for assisted living operators. However, we do know in the senior care industry generally that the use of complex investment vehicles in which the facility itself is depleted of assets is a common technique for avoiding accountability for negligence or, even, avoidable death. Question: How well is private equity delivering on the concept of an assisted living facilities as a social model? Are private equity-operate assisted living facilities performing comparably with the rest of the industry? Response: Based on what we have seen in nursing homes (and other areas of health care) quality and safety tend to degrade significantly when private equity investment enters the sector. ======================================================================= Statements for the Record ======================================================================= [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]