Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-382] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-382 THE SECOND AMENDMENT ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ APRIL 15, 2026 __________ Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov Printed for the use of the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 63-505 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS RAND PAUL, Kentucky, Chairman RON JOHNSON, Wisconsin GARY C. PETERS, Michigan JAMES LANKFORD, Oklahoma MAGGIE WOOD HASSAN, New Hampshire RICK SCOTT, Florida RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania BERNIE MORENO, Ohio ANDY KIM, New Jersey JONI ERNST, Iowa RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ELISSA SLOTKIN, Michigan William E. Henderson III, Staff Director Christina N. Salazar, Deputy Staff Director and Chief Counsel J. Ryan Arient, Professional Staff Member David M. Weinberg, Minority Staff Director Christopher J. Mulkins, Minority Director of Homeland Security Alan S. Kahn, Minority General Counsel Laura W. Kilbride, Chief Clerk Ashley A. Gonzalez, Records Clerk C O N T E N T S ------ Opening statements: Page Senator Paul................................................. 1 Senator Peters............................................... 2 Senator Johnson.............................................. 17 Senator Hawley............................................... 24 Prepared statements: Senator Peters............................................... 29 WITNESSES WEDNESDAY, APRIL 15, 2026 Panel I Hon. Thomas Massie, Member U.S. House of Representatives......... 4 Panel II Hon. Ken Cuccinelli, Senior Fellow for Homeland Security and Immigration, Center for Renewing America....................... 7 Erich Pratt, Senior Vice President, Gun Owners of America........ 9 Dudley Brown, President, National Association for Gun Rights..... 10 Stephen I. Vladeck, Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts, Georgetown Law................................. 12 ALPHABETICAL LIST OF WITNESSES Brown, Dudley: Testimony.................................................... 10 Prepared statement........................................... 67 Cuccinelli, Hon. Ken: Testimony.................................................... 7 Prepared statement........................................... 31 Massie, Hon. Thomas: Testimony.................................................... 4 Pratt, Erich: Testimony.................................................... 9 Prepared statement........................................... 33 Vladeck, Stephen I.: Testimony.................................................... 12 Prepared statement........................................... 70 APPENDIX Senator Paul's Letter to ATF..................................... 80 THE SECOND AMENDMENT ---------- WEDNESDAY, APRIL 15, 2026 U.S. Senate, Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10 a.m., in room SD-342, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Rand Paul, Chair of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Paul [presiding], Johnson, Lankford, Scott, Hawley, Moreno, Moody, Peters, Hassan, and Blumenthal. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR PAUL Chairman Paul. The Committee will now come to order. As we reflect on the 250th anniversary of our Nation, some of our most cherished rights stand at the crossroads. Modern prosperity and technology provide us with the means to enjoy and exercise our God-given rights to a greater extent than ever before. Yet as the means and interest of Americans in exercising those rights have increased, so has the desire and tools for tyrants, both inside and outside of government, to tighten control over who, where, and how these rights are exercised. We have discussed, at great length, the grave attempts by our government to censor unfavored, unpopular, and inconvenient speech, no matter how true, during the pandemic and beyond. We have also examined the threats to privacy and collection of data about all aspects of our lives by a myriad of government agencies. Today we examine the growing threats by our government to restrict the right to keep and bear arms, guaranteed by the Second Amendment. In the wake of a Federal officer shooting and killing a protester who was legally carrying a holstered firearm, a succession of Federal officials rushed to declare that citizens cannot exercise their First and Second Amendment rights at the same time. Administration official stated, ``You cannot bring a firearm loaded with multiple magazines to any sort of protest that you want. It's that simple.'' Another administration official said, ``If you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you. Don't do it.'' These statements were alarming and are part of the reason we are here today. Government employees take an oath to support and defend the entire Constitution of the United States, not just the parts which are convenient, depending on the political news of the day. It is not their job to decide when and which of your rights count on any given day, just as our constitutional rights are nonpartisan and belong to all Americans across the political spectrum. These liberties are also non-negotiable. These freedoms are not independent of each other but are undeniably bolstered by one another. They ensure that not only Americans have rights but that they can defend and speak about those rights without fear of government overreach. Unlike free speech, free exercise, and privacy, the right to keep and bear arms has been strengthened recently by the courts, and restrictions on that right are being overturned. In 2008, the Supreme Court upheld the Heller case, an individual's right to possess firearms in the home. Two years later, the Court ruled in the McDonald case that the right to bear arms is applicable to laws enacted at the State and local levels. In 2022, the Court again ruled on the side of liberty in the Bruen case, stating that the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to carry a handgun for self-defense outside the home. Even though the Supreme Court has made these rulings, politicians have not given up. Their attempts to usurp our constitutional right to keep and bear arms continues. In recent months we have seen, in Virginia, the State where we won our independence from the tyrannical British crown, forced through the General Assembly countless pieces of misguided legislation intending to disarm lawful gun owners. In fact, just days ago, bills sent to the Governor from the State legislature aimed to prohibit the carrying of a loaded firearm in public across the commonwealth. Another bill, poised to become law, makes it a Class I misdemeanor for any person who imports, sells, manufactures, purchases, or transfers an assault firearm, all while creating an exemption for any government officer. As we saw during the pandemic, the government's mantra continues to be ``rules for thee but not for me.'' Unfortunately, the case in Virginia is not unique. Many other states, including Colorado, Rhode Island, and California passed similarly egregious legislation. While most of these laws will undoubtedly be challenged through the courts, this should be a wake-up call for every State across the Nation. It is important to look at these and other specific instances of infringements on the right to keep and bear arms. We must be watchful to any and all violations and act accordingly. But what we really should do is aspire to, in this 250th year of our Nation, is a government that stops asking how much restriction on our liberties it can get away with and instead asks how it can protect and promote all of our rights, including our right to keep and bear arms. The Ranking Member is recognized for his opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR PETERS\1\ Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and, Mr. Chair, I certainly appreciate you convening this Committee for the discussion here today. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The prepared statement of Senator Peters appears in the Appendix on page 29. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- But given President Trump's unconstitutional and unauthorized decision to go to war with Iran, his abuse of power to enrich himself and punish his political enemies, and his decision to usurp congressional powers, including the appropriations of funds, I am troubled by the topic that we have chosen. While I agree that the Constitution gives Americans the right to bear arms, the Second Amendment is one of many such liberties that are guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution. While there may be some discreet examples where the right has been tested, the Second Amendment is simply not under the same threat as so many of our other constitutional rights today. The Trump administration's violations of Americans' First, Fourth, and Fifth Amendment rights, and the Administration's flouting of Congress' constitutional authorities are basically creating a crisis for the rule of law in our country. Meanwhile, Republicans in control of Congress have become mere cheerleaders of the Executive while they allow the constitutional power that Congress has to be undermined. That is something that as the Senate's top oversight body I believe this Committee should examine on a larger scale, and I hope that you would consider that, Mr. Chair. Today I want to expand the discussion to address these other issues and what Congress must do to not only reclaim our own authorities, as the co-equal branch of government, but also how we can restore the checks and balances that our Constitution created to ensure that no single branch of government can infringe on the constitutional rights and protections that are the very core of our democracy. The Trump administration has pushed the bounds of executive authority further than any other President, and our Republican- led Congress has failed to push back, instead ceding its constitutionally delegated responsibilities almost entirely to the President. Those in control have laid down and allowed loyalty to party to override duty, and even self-interest, when preserving a meaningful check on the President. Now, there is no question that past administrations of both parties have tested these boundaries, so their authorities, and Congress, as led by both parties, has basically been responsible for delegating away these authorities over many years. But today, we have an Administration that has refused to follow the laws passed by Congress, abused emergency powers for political purposes, imposed chaotic tariffs that have raised prices on everyday goods for American families, bypassed Congress to wage unjustified military interventions, and is now trying to completely circumvent Congress' power of the purse by refusing to pass bipartisan appropriation laws to fund key functions of government. In return, we have a Republican majority that has almost entirely capitulated to the President's whims. On top of that, this Administration has repeatedly violated the First Amendment rights of Americans by retaliating against, and even going so far as to arrest individuals who exercised their rights to free speech, assembly, religion, petitioning the government, and the press. This Administration has violated Americans' Fourth Amendment rights by allowing immigration enforcement officers to enter and search people's homes without a judicial warrant. It has violated America's right to due process under the Fifth Amendment, detaining and removing individuals to countries they have no connection to and without any opportunity to petition for redress from the government in the courts. Last year, I released a report detailing these constitutional violations and the overreach from the Executive Branch. In that report I laid out how the checks and balances designed in our Constitution are absolutely vital to protecting Americans' freedoms. I warned how President Trump's unprecedented actions to usurp Congress' Article I powers disregard the limitations of the Executive in Article II, and defy the judiciary's Article III lawful court orders have undermined our democratic principles and left us with a President who now is completely unaccountable. The Constitution provides Congress with the means necessary to check an Administration that is eroding the very principles and the institutions that have always made this country great. But that is only possible if Congress, especially the party in power, currently the Republican majority, stands up and takes action. I know many of my colleagues on the other side of the aisle are eager to discuss their views of perceived attacks on the Second Amendment, but I urge all of you to join me in broadening this discussion and finding the courage to take action that will protect our laws and our most fundamental rights before it is too late. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Chairman Paul. Our first witness will be Representative Thomas Massie. Thomas Massie represents Kentucky's 4th congressional District. He serves as the Chairman of the House Second Amendment Caucus and sits on the Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government. Congressman Massie, you are recognized for your opening statement. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. THOMAS MASSIE, MEMBER, U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Mr. Massie. Thank you, Chairman Paul and Ranking Member Peters for allowing me to speak to the upper chamber here today. I am very passionate about this issue of the right to keep and bear arms. I got my first firearm when I was 12 years old from my father, and with that I learned the responsibility and the rights that come with owning a firearm. I formed the Second Amendment Caucus about a decade ago, and have been using that venue to bring in people like Alan Gura, the lawyer who was responsible for arguing the Heller case and also the McDonald case, and he won both of those cases in the Supreme Court. In fact, we have had Dick Heller in our caucus, and we have had some of those brave men who have stopped mass public shootings. It has been a great venue for teaching myself and others more about the Second Amendment. In keeping with the Committee's request, I prepared a speech, but I will only deliver part of that, and then with your indulgence, I would like to talk about some legislation that I think is important that is sitting in the House. The simple and direct language of our Constitution is clear--the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. There are no qualifiers on who may keep arms, what types of arms they may keep, or for what purposes, and it certainly doesn't say that the right to bear arms is about trivial matters like deer hunting or skeet shooting. The Second Amendment exists for one clear reason--defense, for the defense of one's home, one's family, and one's community, for the defense of liberty and safety, not only from a lone assailant but from the whole of tyrannical government. That is why we have the Second Amendment. Our Founders understood the greatest risks to liberty are not always found outside a nation's borders, even though we go looking for fights abroad, sometimes too frequently, but oftentimes from within, when a corrupt and dangerous few grow too ambitious and attempt to subjugate the masses. When such tyranny arises, snakes prefer the path of least resistance. They prefer a population that is vulnerable. As George Mason reminded us, in 1788, ``To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them.'' History is riddled with oppressive states that striped and abused their own people to keep riches for the assaulting cabal, and in every instance, before those snakes bit, they first took away the guns, whether it was Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Castro, or Chavez. Gun confiscations and restrictions came first. Then the infringement of all the other liberties, and in many cases, millions were killed by their own governments. It is not by the grace that America has averted similar atrocities. It is because of our Constitution's design. As Madison wrote, in Federalist 46, ``The advantage of being armed, which the Americans possess over the people of almost every other nation, forms a barrier against the enterprises of ambition, a barrier against tyranny, and oppression by a ruling class.'' To this point, I think it is incumbent upon us to advance legislation that will protect the Second Amendment here. We have sworn an oath to the Constitution to protect it from enemies from within and abroad. Four pieces of legislation that I have sponsored in the House that I want to talk about today, one is to repeal the Gun Free School Zone Act. Ninety-four percent of mass public shootings happen in gun-free zones, so we should not be advertising as the default that our children are sitting ducks, that are unprotected. In the states and school zones where they have allowed the carrying of firearms there have been no such catastrophes. The other bill that is easy to explain is a bill to allow 18-to 21-year-olds to buy handguns from a federally licensed dealer. I think it is somewhat ridiculous that you can be conscripted to serve your country in a war, you can be 18, 19, or 20, and forced into service to fight for your country, but you cannot defend your own family with a handgun that you bought at a licensed dealer. We should repeal this Federal restriction. A piece of legislation that is coming up in the House next month, which I think is very important, is to report some of the data that we collect in the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) database. When you go to buy a gun you fill out a Form 4473--it is that gold form--and they collect data on there that they never report. What we have discovered, through my friend, John Lott, who is an economist and a statistician and an author, is that there is inherent racism in the NICS background check system. Because it is sloppy and they check only phonetically similar names, when you go to purchase a gun you can be deprived of purchasing that gun, and the appeals process can get messy to prove you are not the same person that they think is the person who is prohibited. It turns out if you are a Black American or Hispanic, you are far more likely to share a name phonetically with somebody who is a prohibited person, who has been convicted of a crime, that has a punishment of a year or more. In fact, you are probably twice as likely, if you are Hispanic, to be falsely denied the purchase of a handgun and three times as likely if you are Black to be denied the purchase of a gun at a dealer. This bill that is coming up in the House would just--and by the way, it has passed unanimously in our Judiciary Committee. Democrats and Republicans have both voted for it--simply requires the Department of Justice (DOJ) to publish that data, not of individuals but in the aggregate, of the denials by sex and also by race or ethnicity. Finally, the bill that I am most excited about is the National Constitutional Carry Act, and Senator Lee has that here in the Senate now, and some of you are sponsors of that. I thank you. Several years ago there was legislation advanced to force reciprocity among the states for concealed carry permits. Now, that made sense at the time because in most of the states you needed a permit to carry a firearm. But 29 states now recognize that the right to keep and bear arms should not require permission from your government to bear those arms, and so they have permit-less carry. I have advanced a bill, the National Constitutional Carry Act, that would extend that to all 50 states and the territories. Now, you may ask, well, does that violate the Tenth Amendment? Are you infringing on State rights? Thanks to the McDonald case, in 2010, which came two years after the Heller case--see, Heller was decided in D.C. so it did not impinge on the states--but the McDonald case, versus Chicago, incorporated the Second Amendment to the states, so the states are constrained by the Second Amendment. So no, it does not violate the Tenth Amendment to tell the states that you must follow the right to keep and bear arms in the Second Amendment. I would love to see some action on that here in the Senate. With that I will return to my prepared remarks and close. When we look to our Constitution, remember it is a document by our people, for the purpose of constraining our government, not the other way around. The Second Amendment is the ultimate check on our government. Any attack on those core tenets, whether it is the Second Amendment, the First Amendment, or the Fourth Amendment, or any other provision of our Constitution, is dangerous and wrong, and one does not need to look too far back in history to find examples of why. I will close with these words from Patrick Henry. ``Guard with jealous attention the public liberty. Suspect everyone who approaches the jewel. The great object is that every man be armed.'' Thank you very much for allowing me to testify today. Chairman Paul. Congressman Massie, thank you for your statement today. We appreciate your time. Thanks for coming to be with us. The next panel will now come forward and take your places. [Pause.] It is the practice of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee (HSGAC) to swear in witnesses. Will each of you please stand and raise your right hand. Do you swear that the testimony you will give before this Committee will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you, God? Mr. Cuccinelli. I do. Mr. Pratt. I do. Mr. Brown. I do. Mr. Vladeck. I do. Chairman Paul. Thank you. Our first witness will be Ken Cuccinelli. He currently serves as the Senior Fellow for Homeland Security and Immigration for the Center for Renewing America. He previously served in the Virginia Senate and as Virginia's Attorney General from 2010 to 2014. Mr. Cuccinelli, welcome to the Committee. TESTIMONY OF HON. KEN CUCCINELLI,\1\ SENIOR FELLOW FOR HOMELAND SECURITY AND IMMIGRATION, CENTER FOR RENEWING AMERICA Mr. Cuccinelli. Chairman, Ranking Member, and Members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today on the evolving landscape of Second Amendment rights. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The prepared statement of Mr. Cuccinelli appears in the Appendix on page 31. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- I will focus on recent developments in the Commonwealth of Virginia, which provide a timely and instructive case study of how rapidly state-level policy can reshape the practical exercise of a constitutional right. In 2026, Virginia's General Assembly passed a sweeping package of firearm-related legislation. These measures, taken together, represent the most significant shift in firearm policy in Virginia's modern history. They illustrate not only the breadth of regulatory approaches being pursued nationwide, but also the constitutional tensions that are likely to define Second Amendment and state-level equivalents jurisprudence in the coming years. Most notably, Virginia lawmakers approved legislation that would prohibit the sale, manufacture, importation, and transfer of many commonly owned semi-automatic firearms classified as ``assault firearms,'' along with magazines capable of holding more than 15 rounds. While generally allowing current owners to retain previously acquired firearms, it would effectively halt the future legal acquisition of entire categories of arms that are widely possessed for lawful purposes and makes it impossible for current owners to transfer their firearms, with exceptions for government officials, which I will touch on later. This type of prospective ban raises serious constitutional questions under both the Federal and Virginia constitutions. In its individual rights jurisprudence, the U.S. Supreme Court has emphasized that the Second Amendment protects arms ``in common use'' for lawful purposes such as self-defense. Policies that prohibit future acquisition while allowing continued possession create a legal paradox. They implicitly acknowledge the widespread lawful ownership of these firearms, while simultaneously restricting future citizens from exercising the same right. In addition to firearm-specific bans, Virginia is expanding restrictions on where firearms may be carried beyond historically recognized ``sensitive places,'' to potentially encompass large portions of ordinary public life. This raises important questions under the Supreme Court's framework requiring firearm regulations to be consistent with the Nation's historical tradition of regulation. Virginia lawmakers have also pursued policies imposing affirmative legal duties on firearm owners. Secure storage legislation would require individuals to store firearms in a manner that prevents access by others. While the goal of preventing unauthorized access is widely shared, such mandates must be carefully evaluated to ensure they do not unduly burden the core right of self-defense within the home, long recognized as a central component of the Second Amendment, as noted, for example, in the Heller decision. Further, the commonwealth is expanding its use of ``red flag'' laws. These laws allow for the temporary removal of firearms from individuals deemed to pose a risk. Although courts have generally upheld the concept, expansions to these laws, particularly those affecting evidentiary standards, duration, or who may initiate proceedings, raise due process concerns that deserve careful scrutiny. I fully expect to see the 2026 expansions of these laws weaponized to punish gun owners for political purposes completely unrelated to gun safety. Finally, the commonwealth has moved toward allowing civil liability actions against firearm manufacturers and distributors. Their approach seeks to navigate around existing Federal protections in an effort to destroy this industry through litigation. Taken together, these measures demonstrate a broader trend to transform firearm policy from a framework focused primarily on prohibited persons and background checks into one that increasingly regulates categories of arms, locations of carry, methods of storage, and the broader ecosystem of lawful commerce, all in an effort to cut into the rights of law-abiding gun owners and potential gun owners, and in many respects, to attempt to turn such citizens into law breakers of bureaucratic restrictions, in order to take their guns away or deter them from buying guns in the first place. In addition to obvious litigation, this devolution also creates growing divergence among states, leading to patchwork of laws that may complicate compliance for ordinary citizens. I would respectfully suggest that that is part of the point. It is one way of attacking Second Amendment rights, as I noted, as a practical matter. One law carried over to next year in the Virginia General Assembly is a double-digit tax rate on gun and ammunition purchases. As we know from the beginning of the republic, the power to tax is the power to destroy, and that is what is intended for it to be used as, and I expect to see that next year in my beloved commonwealth. With that I appreciate your time and consideration, and look forward to answering your questions. Chairman Paul. Thank you. Next up we have Erich Pratt, who is the Senior Vice President for Gun Owners of America (GOA), where he has been employed since 1990. Mr. Pratt, you are recognized for your opening statement. TESTIMONY OF ERICH PRATT,\1\ SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, GUN OWNERS OF AMERICA Mr. Pratt. Thank you. Chairman Paul, Ranking Member, Members of the Committee, my name is Erich Pratt, and I serve as Senior Vice President of Gun Owners of America. I represent more than two million Americans who believe the Second Amendment is the amendment that protects all the others. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The prepared statement of Mr. Pratt appears in the Appendix on page 33. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- I appreciate the opportunity to discuss some of the threats to our Second Amendment rights, and I want to begin with the gun owner registry that the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) is compiling. In 2021, GOA exposed that the Biden administration had accumulated 54 million gun owner records in a single year. Now, Representative Michael Cloud and 51 colleagues demanded answers from the ATF, and what they received was shocking. The ATF admitted to amassing nearly 1 billion records of American gun owners, with 94 percent already in digital format. This is gun owner registration, pure and simple. It is a violation of Federal law, and it is the reason the Senate should pass Senator Risch's bill, S. 119. His bill would destroy this illegal, searchable gun registry, hopefully by dropping the ATF computers containing this database into the deepest part of the ocean. Basically, ATF needs to have their own boating accident. Because, look. A database like this invites abuse, and we have already seen it happen. Biden's ATF tried to ban up to 40 million pistols with stabilizing braces, and these were firearms that had been legal during the Obama administration. But by a stroke of the pen, Biden's ATF turned millions of Americans into felons overnight. Thankfully, GOA took this to court, and we won protection for our members. But had this rule remained in place, the ATF would have known where every single one of those firearms were, because of the 4473 forms on file. This is not a registry in name only. That is a confiscation list waiting to be used. History tells us where this leads. The governments of Australia and Venezuela have carried out large-scale gun confiscations in recent years. Canada is now threatening to use its registry to do door-to-door confiscations. But this is not just an other-world problem. It has already happened here. In the 1960s, New York City (NYC) began registering long guns with promises that they would never confiscate them. Yet by 1991, they banned many of those guns, and in 1992, a New York paper reported that, ``Police raided the home of a Staten Island man who refused to comply.'' They seized his firearms and noted that spot checks were planned for other homes. That is the problem with maintaining records of gun owners' names. We are always just one step away from gun confiscation. Now, turning to some other important Federal issues, let me say this. The Trump administration has achieved many pro-gun victories in several departments outside of the DOJ, and I champion those in my written testimony and talk about them. Sadly, the Department of Justice has continued to fight us in court at almost every turn, including on Biden's pistol brace ban, his engaged in the business rule, and the frame and receiver rule, which registers every gun sold after 2002. The fact that a Republican DOJ is still defending Biden-era gun rules, in whole or in part, should tell us everything. That is why Congress must repeal every Federal infringement and finish the job by defunding, dismantling, and abolishing the ATF. After all, the Second Amendment is not about hunting. It is not about sport. It ultimately about preserving freedom. But right now our rights are under attack, by databases, by bureaucrats, and by government attorneys who too often would rather defend unconstitutional laws than the Constitution itself. By the way, just a word for the wise for Republicans on the Committee and in the rest of the Congress. These problems need to be fixed immediately, if you hope to win the gun vote in the midterms, because gun owners, as you know, are very politically active, and every time the DOJ attempts to moot our cases or continues to enforce a Biden-era policy, gun owners become less excited to vote. Thank you, and I look forward to answering your questions. Chairman Paul. Thank you. Our next witness is Dudley Brown, who is the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the National Association for Gun Rights, where he has grown the group from a small grassroots organization to the Nation's second-largest gun rights group. Mr. Brown, you are recognized for your testimony. TESTIMONY OF DUDLEY BROWN,\1\ PRESIDENT, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR GUN RIGHTS Mr. Brown. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Ranking Member, and Members of the Committee. My name is Dudley Brown. I live in northern Colorado. I am the President of the National Association for Gun Rights, and it has been my privilege to represent gun owners for 33 years now. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The prepared statement of Mr. Brown appears in the Appendix on page 67. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- A few months ago a man was shot and killed at a protest in Minnesota. Now, I am not here to litigate Alex Pretti's actions, whether the shooting was legally justified, or to endorse the politics of the protest he attended. I suspect he and I would have agreed on very little. My concern is what the current Administration said afterward. In those 33 years representing gun owners in State legislatures and the Federal Government, what is the main tool I have relied on to preserve firearms freedoms? Easy. The First Amendment. Today, I find it prudent to speak on the intersection between the First and Second Amendments, and the reason is simple. We, as a Nation, have never seen these rights as wholly separate. The First Amendment is how free people speak to power. Americans have shown since the founding they will tolerate being governed, but not tolerate being ruled. That is the arrangement that makes this country different from every other on Earth, and it is precisely why an attack on the right to bear arms at a lawful public assembly is not a Second Amendment problem alone. It is an attack on the entire architecture of American liberty. Before I go further, let me disavow the notion that this is a partisan issue. Regardless of the drastic changes of party control over the White House and the two legislative chambers, the one constant is that all those in power must be reminded that a civil right is in place to protect all the people, regardless of their politics, their race, or their creed. Consider what was actually said by officials from the Administration in the wake of that shooting. The President of the United States said, ``You can't have guns. You can't walk in with guns.'' The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Director remarked, ``You simply cannot bring a firearm to a protest.'' The former Secretary of Homeland Security said, ``I don't know of any peaceful protester that shows up with a gun and ammunition rather than a sign.'' That last statement is the most revealing. Former Secretary Noem was not citing law. She was kind of declaring a worldview, that carrying a firearm is inherently incompatible with peaceful assembly. I think it is a worldview the Founders would not have recognized. Just before the Second Amendment was ratified, 6 of the 13 colonies did not merely permit citizens to carry firearms to public assemblies, they actually required it. The generation that wrote ``the right of the people peaceably to assemble'' looked at an armed citizen in a crowd and did not see a threat to the peace. They saw its guarantee. The argument being made implicitly is that you may have a Second Amendment right and a First Amendment right, but not both at once. Choose one. If you choose wrong, do not be surprised if Federal agents unceremoniously snatch one of those, or both of those rights from you. Several states today forbid the carry of firearms at public demonstrations. Those laws deserve scrutiny not only on constitutional but also on historical grounds. Their roots trace directly to the Jim Crow laws. A law conceived to control a people does not become legitimate simply because time has passed and the target has changed. The states that enacted these laws were not concerned with public peace, but with public control. Each party has the same capacity for authoritarianism as the other side when it serves their short-term interests. I will ask the members in this room directly: Is this the precedent we intend to set, that officials can decide, after the fact, that a citizen had no right to carry because the Administration disliked his politics? That is not a legal conclusion. That is a rationalization. There is no textual, historical, or traditional basis for the proposition that Americans must choose between their First and Second Amendment rights. You do not forfeit one by exercising the other. These rights are not in competition. They are the same right expressed twice. An armed people is a people whose assembly the government must take seriously. A disarmed people protest at the government's pleasure. The Second Amendment does not exist in isolation. It exists to ensure that all the others remain meaningful. The Founders understood that. The statements made by this Administration suggest they do not understand it. The Members of this Committee have the standing, the authority, and the obligation to say so. I hope they will find the courage to use it. On behalf of the millions of members of my organization, who take this matter very seriously, let me thank you for your time. Chairman Paul. Thank you. Senator Peters will introduce the next guest. Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Our next witness is Professor Stephen Vladeck, the Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts at the Georgetown University Law Center. Professor Vladeck is a nationally renowned expert on the Supreme Court, Federal courts, national security law, and military justice. He is also a highly recognized appellate advocate, having argued before the Supreme Court, Federal civilian courts, and military courts. Professor Vladeck is the recipient of numerous awards for his legal scholarship, including the 2024 University of Texas President's Research Impact Award and a selection by the Order of Cloth to serve as its Distinguished Visiting Professor for 2025. Professor, thank you for taking the time to be here today. TESTIMONY OF STEPHEN I. VLADECK,\1\ AGNES WILLIAMS SESQUICENTENNIAL PROFESSOR OF FEDERAL COURTS, GEORGETOWN LAW Mr. Vladeck. Thank you very much, Ranking Member Peters, Chairman Paul, distinguished Members of the Committee. Thank you for the invitation to testify today. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The prepared statement of Mr. Vladeck appears in the Appendix on page 70. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Of all of the conversations that we can and should be having about the U.S. Constitution, this Committee's focus on the Second Amendment strikes me as singularly misplaced. Every day we see headlines documenting other unconstitutional behaviors by this Administration, from arrogating Congress' appropriations power to claiming the authority, to entering private homes without judicial warrants, to suppressing and chilling the constitutionally protected speech of law firms, universities, and political critics, to blowing up suspected drug boats, invading Venezuela, and going to war against Iran without even a scintilla of congressional authorization, which led one commentator to post on social media that, ``It's a good thing Congress isn't alive to see this.'' Indeed, all of this unconstitutional behavior has come not in the face of a hostile Congress but without any attempt to even obtain statutory authorization, even though the President's party also controls both legislative chambers, including this Committee. Instead of making the case for why Congress should loosen or repeal the various mandates that the Executive Branch is regularly violating or should authorize the unilateral conduct in which the Executive Branch is regularly engaging, this Administration is effectively thumbing its nose at our elected representatives, that is, at you. In response, this Committee chose to hold this hearing. It seems to me, Mr. Chairman, that it would be far more useful for this Committee to discuss the structural problems that have been highlighted by this Administration's disdain for the Constitution, and two, in particular, stand out. First, there is a large swath of unconstitutional behavior by the Federal Government that has proven to be effectively insulated from meaningful judicial review. On the individual rights side, a combination of rulings by the Supreme Court and legislation from Congress has all but foreclosed damages suits by Americans whose constitutional rights have been violated. That lacuna comes at the particular expense of First and Fourth Amendment claims, since unlike the Second Amendment claims, about which we have heard so much already this morning, violations of those provisions are typically fleeting. On the separation of powers side, the Supreme Court has likewise made it effectively impossible for litigants to challenge the President's arrogation of Congress' two most important powers, its power of the purse and its control of the war power. Second, the political constraints that have historically served to rein in systemic, unconstitutional behavior by the Executive Branch have also completely broken down. Examples abound, but an especially revealing one is a statement by House Appropriations Committee Chairman Tom Cole, who suggested last year that it was perfectly fine for the President to ignore congressional appropriations because, in his words, not mine, an appropriation, ``is not a law.'' In fact, the Constitution requires that appropriations be, by law, entirely so that this branch, and not the President, will decide how the people's money will and will not be spent. Both of these problems could be fixed quickly and easily by a Congress that cared more about the separation of powers than the separation of parties. For instance, it would take a one- sentence statute to ensure that everyone whose constitutional rights are violated by the Federal Government can have their day in court, and beyond new legislation, Congress, including this Committee, has numerous means to impose such accountability directly, through its oversight function, its ability to exact concessions out of the Executive Branch in exchange for everything from appropriations to appointments, and, if necessary, its impeachment power. Finally, to whatever extent Members of this Committee may tell themselves that they can just reclaim these abandoned powers the next time a Democrat is President, history and common sense are both to the contrary. The more time passes, the harder these powers will be to claw back. In the interim, the Executive's lawlessness and Congress' abdication of responsibility have combined not just to produce an unprecedented breakdown in the separation of powers but a growing and seemingly unending array of deleterious impacts on both everyday people and, at the risk of bringing some of this back to this Committee's jurisdiction, the long-term security of our homeland. If we are going to talk about the Constitution, we should talk about why and how it is being so systemically violated by the current Administration, why and how Congress is sitting idly by while that happens, why and how that attitude is destructive of our Nation's most fundamental ideals, and why and how a Congress that actually took its constitutional responsibility seriously should and would respond. As for the nominal topic of today's hearing, it seems to me that at this moment in our history, devoting resources to the Second Amendment is burying all of our heads in the sand. Even if we cannot agree on much, I hope we can all at least agree that it should not be the case that the only way to hold the Federal Government accountable is to elect a new one. Thank you for inviting me to testify today, and I look forward to your questions. Chairman Paul. Thank you. We will now proceed to a round of questions, and I will start things off. I have been to, I don't know, thousands of rallies. I have probably been the speaker at thousands of rallies. I have attended hundreds and hundreds of rallies. At every rally I go to someone is armed, and the people that are with me are armed. My driver is armed, and we do it for self-defense. I was also at the ballfield when 160 shots were fired at me and others, so I know what violence is like, and I know how important it is to have people there. We had Capitol Hill Police there that day, and they and the Alexandria police saved many lives. Steve Scalise almost died, and another young man was shot under the arm. The bullet traveled around his rib cage and came out the front of his chest, and did not get inside his rib cage, and he survived. But, I think if we pass laws like we are talking about in Virginia, where maybe it is OK for me to get protection but not for you because you are a private citizen, I just cannot imagine the hypocrisy of something like that. We have very prominent people in our society, some of the richest people in our society, who all the time lobby for gun control, and they want less guns out there. Yet they will have a phalanx of eight to ten people with them, all armed, because they can afford that, and most of us cannot. I was wondering, Mr. Cuccinelli, if you would comment on the law and the distinctions that they are talking about between that the government could have security but a private CEO or a private person or even a bail bondsman, not a rich person but somebody who does a risky business of repossessing cars, that somehow it would be illegal for them to have a gun. I cannot imagine a government official, yes, and then the bail bondsman or the repossessor of cars, no? Mr. Cuccinelli. I will take the kind of highest profile. The law they are passing, the so-called Assault Weapons Ban, exempts government officials and employees, thereby acknowledging the utility of the guns in question, which gets to the Supreme Court's judge of historical utility of a particular weapon. The law itself acknowledges that, and yet denies it to ordinary citizens, but allows their own employees to carry. To examples closer along the lines of what you described, there have been several amendments. The way Virginia's process worked, the General Assembly is now out of session. The Governor can propose amendments back to the General Assembly, and Governor Spanberger has done that this week. The General Assembly will be back next week to either accept or reject those amendments and then vote on the original bill if they reject the amendments. Several of those bills restrict exactly the kind of carrying rights and location that you are describing. In Heller, Justice Scalia spoke about sensitive places, and allowed room for regulation, meaning the banning of guns, in, for instance, school buildings was an example that he used. But what the Virginia General Assembly is now proposing goes far beyond that. If you are a person whose business or whose safety involves being armed, or you would choose to protect yourself that way, you are now going, in Virginia, to be restricted, depending on how litigation ends up. I am sure all of this will be litigated. I hope to participate in that. But those restrictions are now very real. Again, to my opening comment about the practical ability to utilize and exercise your right to self-protection, as we all know here, this is not granted by government. James Madison did not give us this right. The Bill of Rights was put in place to preserve what were understood to be already existing rights, in the case of self-defense, both of self and society. Unfortunately, that is the direction that the current government in my home State is trying to go. I hope that we will be able to reintroduce them to the concepts of George Mason, Patrick Henry, and James Madison. I know they have driven by their houses while they have been driving around Virginia, since we have that history there. Nonetheless, it is being ignored and now abused, and it is going to, unfortunately, have to be fought out in the courts to protect it. Chairman Paul. Senator Peters. Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Constitution guarantees each of us certain liberties, including the freedom to speak our minds, practice our religion, receive due process, and the right to bear arms, as we have been talking about here today. Our framers knew that the freedoms protected under our Constitution, however, would be at risk if any one branch of government was allowed to go unchecked. They did not trust anybody in government, figured you had to make sure there were checks and balances. Ronald Reagan, I think, explained the importance of this system of checks and balances very well, and I will just quote Ronald Reagan. ``The genius of our constitutional system is its recognition that no one branch of government alone could be relied on to preserve our freedoms. The great safeguard of our liberty is the totality of the constitutional system, with no one part getting the upper hand.'' Professor Vladeck, as you noted in your testimony, President Trump has gone to war with Iran without congressional approval, as required in the Constitution, usurped Congress' appropriations powers under Article I, powers are being usurped, and turned Federal agencies against American citizens, all while, unfortunately, most of my Republican colleagues have either cheered him on or they just kind of look the other way. My question for you, sir, is, is Congress currently functioning as a co-equal branch of government, as outlined in the Constitution, and if not, what is the danger that we are facing right now? What should the American people be concerned about? Mr. Vladeck. The short answer, of course, is no, and I think the danger is both a short-term danger, Senator, and a long-term danger. Just briefly, the short-term danger is that without Congress, without the President having to look over his shoulder, there is nothing to stop him from engaging in ever- more aggressive usurpation of appropriations, spending money he does not have, not spending money he is supposed to, violating individual rights in a context in which there is no way to challenge that in court, and going on ever-more misguided, misbegotten military operations, all to the detriment of our national security, of our economy, of our rights. Senator, in the long term, this destabilizes the ability of Congress to ever exercise those powers again. We have a Supreme Court that has interpreted the separation of powers, by reference to what Justice Frankfurter called ``historical gloss.'' If the gloss of the 2020s is that the President can do whatever he wants as long as a majority of Congress is not going to stop him, that is a gloss that can be deployed by future Presidents, Senator, with whom you and I might agree more to do plenty of things that I think would be deeply problematic for our rule-of-law society. Senator Peters. You mentioned the courts as a possible check. Obviously, Congress is a major check, and I would argue that our Founders always thought Congress was the preeminent of the three branches. We are Article I. But the courts are important, and unfortunately we have seen this Administration, based on recent actions, believes that they are above the law, including court decisions. Time and time again, judges have found that the Administration has violated court orders. One Federal judge found that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) had, ``utterly disregarded the court's earlier order,'' and, ``made no attempt to offer any justification for their blatant lack of effort to comply, thumbing their nose at the court.'' Another found that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement's (ICE) refused to provide information ordered by the court. Another case found that DOJ, ``elected to simply ignore valid court orders.'' I want to be clear. These are not liberal activist judges, as President Trump and some of my colleagues would claim. All of these quotes come from judges that were appointed by Donald Trump. These are judges he appointed, who saw how outrageous it was for them to ignore these orders. What does it mean for Americans if there is not a consistent adherence to the rule of law and some laws just simply do not get followed? Mr. Vladeck. Yes, I mean, John Adams, at the founding, said, ``Ours is a government of laws, not of men.'' A world in which the Executive Branch does not abide by court orders and faces no repercussions in Congress for violating court orders is a world in which that is not true, and it is a world in which the President can do what he wants. Senator, too many people may not care about those cases because those are immigration detention cases. But if the government puts one of us in immigration detention and says, ``You are not a U.S. citizen,'' even if it is a mistake, the only way to get out is a government that is going to comply with an adverse court order. That is the problem. That is the slippery slope. It is very slippery, and it is one that we are falling down way too quickly. Senator Peters. Thank you. The Fourth Amendment protects us from unjustified invasions of privacy by the government. However, this Administration has basically disregarded decades- old privacy protections, to combine and share Americans' most sensitive tax, health, and Social Security data. It is tracking Americans' location using data brokers. It is monitoring their social media activity, and potentially even using spyware to break into the phones of Americans. I am very concerned about these activities. My question for you, sir, or Professor Vladeck, is at the time when so many people chose to share all kinds of details online, why should we be concerned about information the government is collecting right now, and how might they use these tools against us? Mr. Vladeck. I think the concern, Senator, has been driven home by what we have seen this Administration do, which is retaliating against people because of, for example, what is in their social media profiles, denying visas to non-citizens who have done nothing wrong other than perhaps express sympathy for Palestinians. That is not supposed to be how the government uses our data, and there is a rich tradition, Senator, as you well know, of this Congress actually stepping in to protect Americans' privacy rights, even before the courts have had a chance to do so. The Wiretap Act was a response to the Supreme Court's refusal to apply the Fourth Amendment to wiretaps. That is the kinds of conversations we should be having, about what is happening in our government right not, not the possibility that some State laws might be subject to challenge in court, where those challenges are deeply available. Senator Peters. Thank you. Chairman Paul. Senator Johnson. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR JOHNSON Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate you calling this hearing. It is, I think, a very interesting one. It is an important debate. I always like hearings that kind of stay focused on the actual title of the hearing, which is ``The Second Amendment.'' You want to go into other areas, that is fine. Mr. Pratt, you seem to not be particularly happy with this Administration's reaction to some of these things. The same with Mr. Brown. I am not disagreeing with you at all. Mr. Pratt, you said that Congress has to act. The problem is we have those of us who support the Second Amendment, the opposition party basically wants to disarm Americans. I mean, they say they won't but that is the direction, I think, is pretty obvious in terms of all these guns laws and stuff. I would just ask, for the record, I would like you to list the things that the Executive Branch can do to undo some of the harm, some of the violations, I would say, of our constitutional right to keep and bear arms, and particularly that confiscation list, which I think is pretty much what it is going to be. I mean, why can't they just deep-six that? Is that something this Administration could do, and should we be putting a lot of pressure on President Trump and members of his Administration to do just that? Mr. Pratt. Thank you for the question, Senator Johnson. Gun Owners of America has been working with the Administration to do just that with the registry. They are coming out with a new rule, because under Biden they made those records permanent. Senator Johnson. We will go through the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) and that will happen. Mr. Pratt. I am sorry? Senator Johnson. They will go through the Administrative Procedures Act, and you believe that will happen. Mr. Pratt. Yes. Senator Johnson. OK. Mr. Pratt. We are urging them, a ``shall not be infringed'' view would mean the ATF retains those 4473s for zero years, not 10, not 20, 30, or indefinitely, but zero. Senator Johnson. Limited time. Mr. Cuccinelli, I think you are a pretty observant follower of the Supreme Court. A lot of President Trump's actions have been challenging in court. Correct? Mr. Cuccinelli. Yes. Senator Johnson. The minority witness has pointed those out. But President Trump has actually got a pretty good record before the Supreme Court. Correct? Have you been keeping track of that? Mr. Cuccinelli. He does have a pretty good record before the Supreme Court. He has a better record before the Supreme Court than many of the lower courts. When you look at injunctions, for example, over 90 percent of them came in five districts. That is probably not a coincidence. Senator Johnson. There has been a little venue shopping. Mr. Cuccinelli. There has been significant venue shopping. Senator Johnson. OK. Professor Vladeck, I assume that you are not a Trump supporter. It does not sound like you are particularly enamored with this Administration. Mr. Vladeck. I am not enamored with any administration, Senator, that does not commit to following the Constitution. Senator Johnson. Right. You talked a lot about war powers. Has any President since the War Powers Act been passed, accepted that as a constitutional constrained on that President? Has any President not acknowledged, admitted that this is a constitutional act? Mr. Vladeck. I think we have seen Presidents follow it, including President Carter. Senator Johnson. Again, I am asking has any President acknowledge this is constitutional? Has any Supreme Court ruled on the constitutionality of the War Powers Act? Mr. Vladeck. No, because as I suggested in my testimony the Supreme Court has made it hard to challenge it. Senator Johnson. Did President Obama ever get a congressional authorization in his military action against Libya? Mr. Vladeck. No, he did not. Senator Johnson. OK. Did President Clinton ever get congressional authorization in his military action in Kosovo? Mr. Vladeck. I think that one is a tougher question because it depends upon how you interpret the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) treaty and some of the authorities under that. Senator Johnson. He did not get authorization. Congress did not declare war. Congress has not passed---- Mr. Vladeck. I agree. Senator, I have been critical of the War Powers---- Senator Johnson. So you have blinders---- Mr. Vladeck [continuing]. By Presidents of both parties. Senator Johnson. You have blinders on. Mr. Vladeck. No. I think Presidents of both---- Senator Johnson. You have blinders on. Let me ask another question. I thought it was very interesting in Representative Massie's testimony the regime after regime after regime that he ticked off, that the first action these totalitarians, these tyrants, enacted was gun control, OK. I thought it was interesting because he was leading right up to, but he did not mention, the ayatollahs. Professor Vladack, you are part of academia, who I just think--I am not sure about Georgetown Law, but, it was shocking how many protests in favor of Hamas occurred on college campuses. That is because we have leftist professors poisoning the minds of our young people. But I hope our young people are watching. I am assuming, you do not support the ayatollahs in Iran, do you? Do you think they are anything less than a brutal, tyrannical threat and menace to world peace? Mr. Vladeck. No, but I also do not think that is the standard for when Presidents have the constitutional authority to send Americans men and women into harm's way. Senator Johnson. Do you think it would be a good thing if the ayatollahs were on the dustbin of history, that they no longer represented a threat and a menace to world peace? Do you think that would be a good thing? Mr. Vladeck. What I think and what this government has---- Senator Johnson. You cannot even answer that question? Mr. Vladeck. Senator, I do not know why what I think is relevant. Yes, I do, but I also think that you should be more interested in what the Constitution provides for. Senator Johnson. The point I want to make is they were a menace. They are an existential threat. I mean, they get a nuclear weapon, they have got missile technology. Mr. Vladeck. So the law does not matter? Senator Johnson. Park a barge off the United States, lob a missile up, hit off, explode a nuclear weapon, wipe out our electrical grid. That is an existential threat. We had to act before we could not act. But the hope was in acting, the hope is still there, that if we weaken the regime the Iranian people can take control, regain their freedom. Why can't they? Because they have been disarmed. Getting right back to the purpose of this hearing, because the Iranian people have been disarmed by the brutal, tyrannical regime within Iran. When are we going to finally learn that lesson? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Paul. Thank you, and we will do another round if anybody has any other questions. I will start us off on that. I opened by talking about that I have been to a lot of rallies with guns. I have never seen anybody commit violence. That is not why I support the right to have a gun at a rally. The right is separate of whether the practicalities are supportive of it. It is something that precedes government. It is a natural right, the right of self-defense. But I would be interested, Mr. Brown, if you know of any statistics looking at legal gun owners and whether they commit crimes, how frequently, compared to the criminal population, et cetera. Mr. Brown. Yes, thank you, Senator. The estimates are right now that there are somewhere around 22 million concealed handgun permits issued to Americans. There are, however, now, as you mentioned, 29 states that allow permit-less carry. The estimates are roughly that 16 million people carry on a regular basis in America, and that they commit crimes at one-third the rate of other Americans, people who do not carry. Of course, those are broad, general estimates. But we know in states with permits that those people are arrested at a much lower rate, not just for gun crimes like, for instance, carrying in a, ``illegal'' place or a sitting duck zone, as Congressman Massie called them, but they are also, on a regular basis, not arrested for other means, like assault. I think we can surmise the reason. I know, for me, I carry virtually every waking money that I can. It is because there an added level of seriousness when you do carry a firearm, and a responsibility. And so, yes, I think you just avoid problems wherever you can. Chairman Paul. Same question, Mr. Pratt. Mr. Pratt. Yes, the statistics show that concealed carry permit holders, for example, commit crimes at a lower rate than the police do. Interestingly enough, you have more private citizens who stop--over 50 percent of mass shootings in non- gun-free zones are stopped by law-abiding citizens. That is actually a greater percentage than police. That is because if you are in danger and you are in a gun-free zone, the police are minutes away, but if you are able to protect yourself, you are able to immediately respond. Chairman Paul. Yes, and I think that is the thing about people who do not own guns and fear the sight of a gun, and the gun scares them, is that people who own and carry guns are some of the most responsible people, as far as safety, as far as everything else. They do not brandish their weapon. They are carrying a weapon for self-defense, and it does work. On the idea of separation of powers, some of the discussion is the implication that this is a one-sided thing, that somehow this is Republicans are terrible, Trump is terrible, but maybe Democrats were somehow good. I would say both parties have been abysmal at this, and frankly, the court has not be very good either. One of your colleagues, Randy Barnett, goes back to Lochner, and I am with him on that. I am a libertarian that thinks Lochner was correctly decided. But it has been opposed by most on the left, and many on the right, frankly, for the last 100 years. The problem is in Lochner the Court did decide that they were going to make assertive decisions based on constitutionality. They basically decided in Lochner that the right to contract is a right, and that states cannot infringe upon the right to contract. That was a great direction, which has been reversed by 100 years. But for a 100 years now or more, the Court really has shown deference. I will not mention the Justice, but I recently met one in a casual situation, and the discussion was concerning no longer giving deference to the administration overturning Chevron, which I am in favor of. But the question I had to the Justice was, ``Well, you seem pretty deferential. Why wasn't there a discussion of the First Amendment in the TikTok case, or why was it sloughed over for national security?'' The point that was made by the Justice was that, oh well, we still give deference to Congress. When we have had questions of separation of powers, for example, some pretty explicit things. Taxes have to originate in the House. The Tax Reform Act of 1986 (TRA) was a bill, back in 1986. Congressmen took it there, and the Court basically will do stuff, like, you do not have standing, and so they never really decided on it. Recently we had a really big case on tariffs. I agree with the Court's decision on the tariffs. But they also made the decision, I think based on Ashwander, that, oh, we are not really going to decide on the Constitution. Heaven forbid we make a constitutional decision. We are going to decide it on the statute. I think there is some blame over there, and there is certainly a lot of blame in Congress, but really the blame is absolutely bipartisan and people tend to switch their positions. People who were once are now very critical of the war power under President Trump, which I have been. Many of them were very quiet when President Obama was bombing Libya, and that was the point I think Senator Johnson was making, is that the consistency on this position has been very partisan. I will just finish with, let's start out with the Court, with Lochner. Decided correctly? Is that part of the problem? Not decided correctly? Then with Ashwander, should Ashwander be binding us and keeping the Court from making constitutional judgment on what they call political questions? Mr. Vladeck. Mr. Chairman, I agree with, I think, a lot more of what you said than you might expect. I have been a consistent critic of abuse of the war powers by Presidents of both parties, and would have loved the chance to actually explain that to Senator Johnson. I think the point, though, that you are making, Mr. Chairman, is that the deference the Court is showing assumes a Congress that is exercising its ordinary oversight and accountability powers. I am not here to blame one party or the other, Mr. Chairman. My point is just that at this particular moment in American history we are seeing, in technicolor, just how significant the cost of that abdication, whenever it started and whoever is to blame are for the rights of all Americans. Chairman Paul. Here is my question. I think you are right. Congress is abdicating their duty. What about the Court then? Congress is not doing their duty. Does the Court have a duty, and they skate political questions, and they try to decide things on non-constitutional, which gets back to Lochner. In Lochner they had a more certain idea that if a State is acting unconstitutionally, if they are bridging the right to contract, we will overturn the State law. Then they got away from that. Really it is the question of Lochner being correctly decided or not correctly decided, and if the Court, if you want them to act in separation of powers issues like this, then is Ashwander, should it be binding as far as trying to go to the least common denominator instead of deciding based on the Constitution? Mr. Vladeck. Mr. Chairman, I think the Ashwander question is a nuanced one and really depends on exactly what Congress has done and said. A statute, Mr. Chairman, that was ambiguous, you and I might both think better to avoid the question. But where I think Congress has clearly tried to rein in the President, and has clearly tried to push back, the Court should be deciding on the question. If I may, just very briefly, I think we are seeing some of the same problems in that direction that we are talking about with regard to the relationship between Congress and the Executive Branch, which is Congress also used to be much more active in regulating the courts, and the Supreme Court in particular. I think over the last generation we have seen that fall away, as well. Chairman Paul. Senator Peters. Senator Peters. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I agree. The Chairman and I agree. This has been an issue with both parties over time. In my opening comments I was very clear that we have seen Congress give powers to the Executive on a continuous basis. I think we could argue whether or not it is accelerating or not, which was part of your point, Professor. But to that point, with war powers, I know, Mr. Chairman, I would actually like to hear your answer to the question our colleague asked about war powers. We are actually interested in learning about that, not just giving a speech. Mr. Vladeck. Yes. I think that the point I was trying to make to Senator Johnson is that I think Presidents of both parties have abused the war powers, and I do not think it is a particularly Democratic or Republican or conservative or liberal phenomenon. Presidents are going to use the powers they have, Senator. I think part of the problem is that we have seen perhaps more aggressive pushback when the President was a Democrat, perhaps because those were periods when you had some cross- party control. We have seen more aggressive pushback when a different party has controlled one or both chambers of Congress than when it has been the same party, and that has been true in both directions. It seems to me the result should not be to say, so-and-so is a hypocrite, but rather to say, well then, let's fix the problem, period, as opposed to let's fix the problem when someone else is in charge. Senator Peters. Yes. I think that is right, and the checks and balances works. Sometimes when you do not have one control, one party in all control, based on the partisanship that we are seeing in the country right now, unfortunately. Professor, you also stated in your testimony that the Trump administration has taken sweeping actions to undermine the First Amendment. The Chairman of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) threated the American Broadcasting Company (ABC) for airing a comedian who criticized the Administration. This Administration has also revoked the press credentials of journalists whose coverage it basically did not like. It targeted law firms, universities, and former government officials because it did not like their protected speech. It is trying to use Federal grants now to force organizations to adopt the President's political ideology with Federal money. Could you talk about Congress' role in addressing the scale of the Trump administration's systemic violations, particularly of the First Amendment right now? Mr. Vladeck. Yes. It seems like there are a couple of different things that Congress could do and that prior Congresses have done. I think the first is more robust oversight, using, for example, nominations hearings, using oversight hearings, using budget hearings as opportunities to ask the Administration what exactly it is doing and why. I think there are ways in which Congress could condition funding for some of these agencies on not engaging in those behaviors. It is not unconstitutional for Congress to condition Federal funds on the Administration refusing to retaliate. But also, Senator, I think Congress could make it easier for those who are having their speech chilled in these contexts to sue directly, because I do not think it is possible, even for a well-meaning Congress, to actually enforce every single flash point between the government and its citizens. That is why I think the absence of a meaningful remedy, even for ephemeral constitutional violations, is something that has been exposed over and over again as a structural flaw of our current moment. Senator Peters. Professor, you also noted in your testimony the Constitution grants Congress, not the President, the power to decide how the government spends taxpayer money. This power of the purse allows us to basically serve as a check on abuses by the Executive Branch. After two American citizens were shot and killed by DHS officers as a result of the Administration's tactics, many of us tried to use the Congress' spending power to ensure reform as well as accountability. But when the President decides to ignore Congress and claims the spending power for himself, not Congress, it leaves Congress basically with no leverage and the American people with basically no accountability. My question for you, sir, is are you aware of other instances in history where the President has violated Congress' power to appropriate funds and Congress basically did absolutely nothing? What are the consequences when the Administration ignores Congress' appropriations power, as granted in Article I of the Constitution? Mr. Vladeck. Senator, I am not aware of another example where we saw this degree of appropriations misbehavior by the Executive Branch and no congressional reaction. I think, as you know, the Impoundment Control Act (ICA) itself was Congress' response to not comparable but at least loosely analogous behavior by the Nixon administration, and Congress responded by, I think quite powerfully, reclaiming its power, and indeed, authorizing, Senator, some of the behavior President Nixon had engaged in, while prohibiting the rest of it. It seems to me that is the point I would have liked to have made to Senator Johnson, which is you can think the President having this power is a good thing or not. The point is that Congress has to provide it. It seems like what is missing from this conversation is the idea that if we like what the President is doing we should not worry about the separation of powers. Just to quote the Supreme Court for a second, it would be ironic if in the name of national defense we would sanction the subversion of one of our civil liberties that makes defense of the Nation worthwhile. Senator Peters. Thank you. Chairman Paul. Senator Hawley. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HAWLEY Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman and thanks to all of the witnesses for being here. Mr. Pratt, if I could just start with you, I want to ask you about something that I think deserves some answers. In fact, I have waited years for a substantive response on this. Back in 2021, I sent a letter to then President Biden's ATF asking about Rule 2021R-05, which is the rule that requires gun dealers to keep records on buyers permanently. They never gave me an answer. Thankfully, we now have a new administration, but it is often the case that old rules live on in sort of zombie-like lifestyle through bureaucratic inertia. Do you know, Mr. Pratt, how many Biden-era ATF rules are still either on the books or continue to be enforced, that we ought to be concerned about? Mr. Pratt. Thank you for the question. Unfortunately, there are several. With the one you just mentioned, the DOJ, even as of last week, was saying they intend to enforce the Biden rule. The same with the engaged in business rule. Same with the pistol brace rule. We are fighting every single one of those. I am so glad you took an interest in the registry, because GOA actually the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA'd) the ATF manual, and you can search the make, model, and serial number of, let's say, every firearm made by Smith and Wesson. You could then use that as a confiscation list to know which ones were the pistols with stabilizing braces. When ATF Director Steven Dettelbach testified before the Congress he told the Senate Judiciary Committee that they actually pay extra money to remove the search function on the names, and that was supposed to be our big defense against a confiscation list, our big defense against tyranny. They are paying extra money. What if they stop paying the extra money, or what if they open up that Adobe document in some other type of document? They would still be able to search by name. The only answer that we really have is to delete the registry. Senator Hawley. Speaking of registries, my understanding is that sitting right now in a warehouse in West Virginia, and you described this in your testimony, is roughly 1 billion gun owner records, 94 percent of them that are already in digital format. Mr. Pratt. Yes. Senator Hawley. Now, Federal law is supposed to prohibit a national gun registry, but I am wondering, what would you call that? Mr. Pratt. We call that a registry. Senator Hawley. It looks like it to me too. I mean, let's just walk through this. If a future administration that is hostile to Second Amendment rights in this country were to get its hands on those records, 1 billion gun owners' names, other information contained there, what do you think it might be able to do with them? Mr. Pratt. That is absolutely the problem, is with any gun ban that is passed they are able to search the makes and models of those guns, and if they stop paying for the names attached to them they know exactly who is not in compliance with the law, which, again, is something that already happened in New York City when they registered guns in the 1960s, passed a ban in the 1990s, and then they did spot checks on people that they believed were not complying with the law. Senator Hawley. In 1967, correct, New York required registration of rifles, I think it was. Mr. Pratt. That is right. Senator Hawley. Shotguns, as well. Promised then that, oh, it would not be used for confiscation. But then, in fact, they were confiscated. I think they went door-to-door back in the late 1960s. Mr. Pratt. Mayor David Dinkens signed the ban, and that is exactly what they did. Senator Hawley. Then, in 1991, New York City also banned another class of weapons, and officials used, as I understand it, an existing database to do the same thing, to force confiscation. There is also, I suppose, the example of our Australian friends. In 1996, I think it was, Australia passed the National Firearms Agreement (NFA), they called it, which, as I understand it, restricted gun ownership and mandated the creation of a firearm registry. Then, lo and behold, they went and used that to enforce mandatory buybacks. I seem to recall more than one Democratic candidate for President talking about mandatory buybacks. I mean, this is not a far-fetched conspiracy theory. This is something that has happened in our country. It has happened in our ally nations. You have members of the opposition party who are saying it is a great model. I mean, we should be concerned about this, shouldn't we? Mr. Pratt. We should be concerned about it, and that is why that registry cannot continue to exist, Senator. Senator Hawley. What is the thing that we have to do? What is the most urgent action we need to take, Mr. Pratt, to make sure this registry (a) is not abused, and (b) is eliminated so that it cannot be used for nefarious purposes, namely the violation of the constitutional rights in the future? Mr. Pratt. The No Registry Rights Act by Cloud in the House and Risch in the Senate would delete that registry. If Congress would take that up and send it to the President, that would be fantastic. Senator Hawley. I hope we will do that post haste. Thank you very much for your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Paul. I think this is a good discussion, and furthering on this I would just like to add that we have been requesting information also from the ATF for quite a while. We sent a letter\1\ in April of last year, requesting some of the same information that you FOIA'd, and we have gotten no response and no documents, and we have followed up. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ The letter referenced by Senator Paul appears in the Appendix on page 80. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We are going to pursue, through the Committee, the process of subpoenaing that information. It will be in consultation with the minority. But if you have an interest in that, if you will work with our office, if there is specific information you want to add to that subpoena. It is a friendly administration, but the ATF still is not giving us anything in a year. That is just too long, and we should figure out more about it. In our letter we refer to some of the FOIA'd things, and apparently there is evidence now that ATF agents can have their own target that they can monitor for 30 to 180 days, and monitor, along with the FBI, through this. It sounds like no due process or courts or anybody involved with this. The fact that they will not tell Congress what they are doing, I think our patience should wear thin, and I think we should really find out what is going on over there. Because sometimes even when an administration changes, people at the top change, but somebody who is in charge of this program may be the exact same people that were doing it in the previous administration. But we are going to try to get to the bottom of that. I do not have any further questions. We have gone a couple of rounds. Do you have anything you would like to say? I think we are going to wrap it up. Mr. Cuccinelli. Mr. Chairman? Chairman Paul. Yes. Mr. Cuccinelli. Can I just comment on that briefly? Chairman Paul. Yes. Mr. Cuccinelli. Senator Peters earlier, he did not use the phrase ``third-party doctrine,'' but he described examples of what is the third-party doctrine. The third-party doctrine was established by the Supreme Court in the 1970s in a bank case and a phone case, back when we made a phone call and wires actually connected, that connected you to me. You could put a trap on it, and you could see everybody I dialed. The theory of the third-party doctrine is that if I dial my phone, I know that I am giving the phone company that information, and therefore, giving up all constitutional rights to privacy---- Chairman Paul. A terrible theory. Mr. Cuccinelli [continuing]. Regardless of whether I have a contract with that phone company to keep those records private, on the old, pre-privacy theory of Fourth Amendment rights, which was based on, oh, the Constitution, and trespass theory, et cetera. Contract would fit in there. Same with my bank records. When I use a bank, and we all do, they fall under the same rules. You just commented, Mr. Chairman, about no warrants, no judicial, no due process. That is exactly right. Because all of our government agencies can just go ask the bank for your records. Now, then it is up to the bank whether they turn them over, or even let you know about it. Chairman Paul. Right. This is a huge issue---- Mr. Cuccinelli. Until that is legislated---- Chairman Paul [continuing]. A huge issue, and then the Court helped a little bit to abbreviate the expanse of the third-party doctrine in the Carpenter decision. I actually think and several Senators were caught up in this recently, in Carpenter--it was either Carpenter or the other case before that--they make the decision that your geolocation is actually among. It is all the data that the Court does not care about, and they say you have no privacy interest and no personal interest in. You do have it in your location. Mr. Vladeck. That was Jones, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Paul. Excuse me? Mr. Vladeck. The Jones case, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Paul. Jones case. So there are two, but it was the Jones case. I really think, absolutely, and I do not know if any of the Senators--you were not on that list, were you? You were on the list? But I think it needs to be pursued based on that case, because they did look at geolocation. They are looking at where you were on January 6th. Of course, the phone companies did not defend anyone. One phone company defended one Senator, and the other one did not defend anybody. But I think you have a real case on this. The question is whether or not this is a violation of the government or whether the phone companies have an obligation to protect geolocation. You could sue the phone companies, but can you sue the government over it too? Mr. Cuccinelli. You are going to run into sovereign immunity, and with the third-party doctrine established by the Supreme Court you will not be able to successfully sue the government, absent trying to go all the way to the Supreme Court, to getting the third-party doctrine overturned. Chairman Paul. But even though they have allowed now that geolocation is not protected by the third-party doctrine. Mr. Vladeck. Mr. Chairman, there was the bill that Congress passed last year, that I believe--Senator Hawley can correct me, but I believe authorized at least some Members, perhaps Senators, to sue over at least some of the phone records questions. But I do think the larger point, Mr. Chairman, is that whether we are particularly concerned with the phone records of Senators or Americans who do not hold elected office, the problem is the same, which is that there are woefully insufficient remedies for any government violation of our Fourth Amendment rights. Chairman Paul. Oh, I agree completely. I think Smith and the other decisions were all incorrectly decided. It took 60 years to go from Olmstead and saying you could wiretap anybody's phone, all the way to Katz. You had a long period of time until the Court finally started getting it right, but they still are not completely getting it right, and Carpenter and Jones are a step in the right direction. But I actually think Jones is on point here, and I do think that you can win a case. My suggestion is that you get--oh, you are a lawyer. I do not know. I think there still is an opening, the third-party doctrine does not, because geolocation, they say, is something that is not just that anymore. You have a personal interest in geolocation. Mr. Cuccinelli. They ratcheted or created exceptions, is how I would characterize it, to the third-party doctrine with respect to that level of nuance, which, of course, they did not foresee in the 1970s. But the 1970s technology was not foreseen by the Founders. I would suggest that it would be better, and it does not strike me as particularly difficult, to get bipartisan support to introduce this kind of protection, particularly given what has happened around here recently. Chairman Paul. We have that legislation, and I will introduce it again. Thank you. Mr. Vladeck, did you have another comment on this? Mr. Vladeck. No. Mr. Chairman. Thanks, everybody. I think we actually covered more than just the Second Amendment. We did the Second Amendment, we got some of the Fourth Amendment, we talked about First Amendment, the separation of powers. I think it was a good hearing. Thanks, everybody. [Whereupon, at 11:24 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] A P P E N D I X ---------- [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]