Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-326] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-326 SANCTUARY CITIES: THE COST OF UNDERMINING LAW AND ORDER ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON THE BUDGET UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ March 10, 2026 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Budget [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 63-061 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON THE BUDGET LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina, Chairman CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa JEFFREY A. MERKLEY, Oregon MIKE CRAPO, Idaho PATTY MURRAY, Washington RON JOHNSON, Wisconsin RON WYDEN, Oregon ROGER MARSHALL, Kansas BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont JOHN CORNYN, Texas SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island MIKE LEE, Utah MARK R. WARNER, Virginia JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana TIM KAINE, Virginia PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska CHRIS VAN HOLLEN, Maryland BERNIE MORENO, Ohio BEN RAY LUJAN, New Mexico RICK SCOTT, Florida ALEX PADILLA, California Nick Myers, Majority Staff Director Ben Ward, Minority Staff Director Mallory B. Nersesian, Chief Clerk Alexander C. Scioscia, Assistant Clerk C O N T E N T S ---------- TUESDAY, MARCH 10, 2026 OPENING STATEMENTS BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS Page Senator Lindsey O. Graham, Chairman.............................. 1 Senator Jeffrey A. Merkley....................................... 4 Prepared Statement........................................... 47 STATEMENTS BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS Senator Grassley................................................. 20 Senator Van Hollen............................................... 22 Senator Johnson.................................................. 24 Senator Whitehouse............................................... 26 Senator Cornyn................................................... 27 Senator Lujan.................................................... 29 Senator Lee...................................................... 31 Senator Padilla.................................................. 33 Senator Kennedy.................................................. 34 Senator Kaine.................................................... 36 Senator Scott.................................................... 38 Senator Moreno................................................... 40 WITNESSES The Honorable Chad Wolf, Former Acting Secretary U.S. Department of Homeland Security (2019-2020), and Homeland Security and Immigration Chair, America First Policy Institute.............. 7 Prepared Statement........................................... 50 The Honorable Michael L. Chapman, Sheriff of Loudoun County, Virginia....................................................... 9 Prepared Statement........................................... 55 Ms. Jessica M. Vaughan, Director of Policy Studies, Center for Immigration Studies............................................ 11 Prepared Statement........................................... 57 Mr. David J. Bier, The Selz Foundation Chair in Immigration Policy, Cato Institute......................................... 12 Prepared Statement........................................... 67 Mr. Brendan Duke, Senior Director, Federal Budget Center on Budget and Policy Priorities................................... 14 Prepared Statement........................................... 84 APPENDIX Responses to post-hearing questions for the Record Mr. Bier..................................................... 95 Mr. Duke..................................................... 96 Charts submitted by Chairman Graham.............................. 97 Charts submitted by Senator Merkley.............................. 103 Statements submitted for the Record by Chairman Graham........... 107 Statements submitted for the Record by Senator Merkley........... 122 Document submitted for the Record by Senator Kaine............... 132 Documents submitted for the Record by Senator Padilla............ 136 Documents submitted for the Record by Mr. Bier................... 181 SANCTUARY CITIES: THE COST OF UNDERMINING LAW AND ORDER ---------- TUESDAY, MARCH 10, 2026 Committee on the Budget, U.S. Senate, Washington, DC. The hearing was convened, pursuant to notice, at 10:00 a.m., in Dirksen 608, Hon. Lindsey O. Graham, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. Present: Senators Graham, Grassley, Johnson, Marshall, Cornyn, Lee, Kennedy, Moreno, R. Scott, Merkley, Whitehouse, Kaine, Van Hollen, Lujan and Padilla. Also present: Republican Staff: Nick Myers, Majority Staff Director; Erich Hartman, Deputy Staff Director; Lillian Meadows, Senior Counsel; Meghan Green, General Counsel. Democratic Staff: Ben Ward, Minority Staff Director; Melissa Kaplan-Pistiner, General Counsel; Joshua Smith, Budget Policy Director. Witnesses: The Honorable Chad Wolf, Former Acting Secretary U.S. Department of Homeland Security (2019-2020) and Homeland Security and Immigration Chair, America First Policy The Honorable Michael L. Chapman, Sheriff of Loudoun County, Virginia Ms. Jessica M. Vaughan, Director of Policy Studies, Center for Immigration Studies Mr. David J. Bier, The Selz Foundation Chair in Immigration Policy, Cato Institute Mr. Brendan Duke, Senior Director, Federal Budget Center of Budget and Policy Priorities OPENING STATEMENT OF CHAIRMAN GRAHAM Chairman Graham. Good morning. Welcome to the Republican hearing on Sanctuary Cities. Are our Democratic friends on the way? Should we wait? Do we know if they're coming? Could somebody find that out? I will go ahead and make sure our Democratic colleagues can have their time and ask their questions. So we're the Budget Committee, the mighty, mighty Budget Committee that did reconciliation and thank you very much. Right on cue. I would hope this Committee would take round two and see if we can do something on reconciliation round 2. But that'd be up to a group of us and talk to the leadership about that. But this hearing today, I think it's timely. We're trying to look at the budget impact of a policy called Sanctuary Cities. Now there are 200, I think cities, 14 States--We got a chart here somewhere--that engage in the practice of Sanctuary Cities. And what is that practice? Local officials, state local officials, basically have adopted a policy of not turning over to the federal government illegal immigrants subject to being turned over, because they don't like the policy. They don't want to engage in deporting these people. Now, under President Obama, I think three million people were deported and I don't believe any Republican refused to work with the federal government to deport these people. And when President Obama deported three million people, it was called being strong and good government. When we try to deport people as a result of being invaded by illegal immigrants for four years under the Biden administration, we're not seizing bad guys. I don't buy that at all. I think most Americans would like to get control over our country and sovereignty over our nation. Immigration done right can be a tremendous benefit to the country. When you obliterate the borders for four years and people from all over the world flood in, you got a problem and it needs to be fixed and cleaned up. As to United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), if we can make ICE more professional, if we can do things at Department of Homeland Security (DHS) that make it more professional, count me in. I think Markwayne Mullen will be a great Secretary to do that. But to my Democratic colleagues, we'll never fix illegal immigration until you get to the source of the problem. And one of the problems we have is magnets to encourage future illegal immigration. I got 12 Sanctuary states, 200 cities. There are 25,000 people that ICE had a detainer on that were refused to be turned over. Next one. We believe it endangers public safety, 10,000 criminals released by Sanctuary policies who went on to be arrested for additional crimes. They should have been turned over. They weren't. They stayed in the country and they committed crimes, $9 billion in fraud that we know of and probably growing. 59 percent of illegal immigrant households are on government welfare programs costing taxpayers 42 billion a year. And that's some real, real money. Let me give you a real life example of what happens when you don't do this, right? Fairfax. I think we're going hear here in a minute from one of our sheriffs. Fairfax police warned prosecutors about a repeat offender months before deadly bus stop stabbing. And this gentleman here, Jalloh, what's his name? Jalloh, was in custody and had a pretty bad rap sheet. People in the prosecution business say, don't release this--I mean deport this guy, turn him over. Don't release him. That was good advice. It was not taken. This young lady here, Stephanie Minter, was murdered by this man. And we had this man in detention in Fairfax County and they refused to turn him over for deportation. He was allowed to stay in the county and the rest is history. A young mom is dead because of that decision. And who was this guy? He came to the country in 2012. He was arrested 30 times, rape, malicious wounding and assault. 2020, ICE submits a formal detainer to deport him. The request is blocked by Virginia's attorney for Fairfax County, a Soros- backed prosecutor and defender of Sanctuary Cities who ignored the detainer. On May, 2025, he was arrested once more for stabbing and the individual in the leg, but was--but again released. 30 arrests. May 2025 stabbed somebody in the leg. Let him go again. February 2026, just months later, he murders Ms. Minter. I'm not okay with that. I think that's offensive to who we are as a rule of law nation to the people in Fairfax County to this district attorney. I wish we could find a way for these people to sue you and make you pay a heavy price for ignoring your legal obligations under federal law and showing such poor judgment. How many arrests is necessary? How many people need to be stabbed before a guy like that is deported? And what's the upside of keeping them here? Is this the model citizen we want to keep in America? Now there's an ideology around Sanctuary City that needs to be broken and we're here to break it. I've got legislation designed to change this dynamic. Going forward if a local official or a governor, anybody refuses to cooperate with federal government in turning over people subject to deportation under federal law, they can be prosecuted because they should be prosecuted. You got to make it so that those who hang on to these illegal immigrants in defiance of federal law, that they feel the pain, not just the public. So my hope is that we can find a way forward to break the cycle of the damage being done from Sanctuary Cities, the cost incurred to the taxpayer and what happened to Stephanie, just like never happens again. We're not going to quit on this. If you want to defend it, you're welcome to do it. And this is not going away. You'll never have rational immigration as long as you have 12 states saying if you get here, you never leave. You're never going to fix this if you have 200 cities that practice Sanctuary policy, because the illegal immigrant believes I get there and never leave. I've tried to work with Democrats like many over here to find a rational solution to our illegal immigration problem. We're not going to ignore four years. So for Joe Biden obliterated our border. People came in from all over the world by tens of millions, flown into the interior of the country and only God knows where they're at. Look at the number of people on the terrorist watch list and how it's gone up 2,700 percent in '21, '22, '23. Where are these people? They don't know. I asked. Nobody knows where they're at. So in this invasion during the Biden administration, we had 11,000 murderers. Look at the number of people on the terrorist watch list. They're in our country and we don't know where they're at. So what we're going to do is be willing to reform ICE, try to fix problems that we've seen, but we're not going to give up on the idea that we need to right wrongs here and deport people that present danger and try to regain control over our immigration system. To my Democratic colleagues, what is the answer to Sanctuary Cities? Is it to continue the policy? Is it to eliminate the policy? All of us say eliminate it. I think the public is with us by like 80 percent. Until we eliminate the policy, you're going to see more and more stories like I just described and it is now time to call the question on Sanctuary Cities. Will it be the norm going forward in America or will it change? To my colleagues on this side of the aisle thank you for supporting this effort. We're fully committed to eliminating Sanctuary Cities for the good of the country. To my Democratic colleagues, we'd love to join with you in a rational way to do some things to make ICE more professional. But what you need to do in return is work with us to eliminate one of the biggest magnets to future illegal immigration, which is Sanctuary City policy. With that, Senator Merkley. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR MERKLEY \1\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Prepared statement of Senator Merkley appears in the appendix on page 47. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Senator Merkley. Thank you very much Mr. Chairman. It's been a year since we've had a meeting of this Budget Committee and a lot has happened in that last year. Of course, one of the big things that happened was a piece of legislation that Trump called his Big Beautiful Bill, but most of us consider it a big ugly betrayal of the American citizen. What did it proceed to do? Slash nutrition for hungry children, gutted health care for millions of families, enormously increased the wealth of the already wealthiest in our country. That's certainly not government by and for the people; that's government by and for the powerful. And it massively increased our national debt, estimated to be a $30 trillion increase over the next 30 years. And if interest rates are one percent higher than used in the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) model, call that a $50 trillion increase in national debt over the next 30 years and it also massively increased the budget for ICE. I don't think you'll see many changes in budgets that look like this. You won't see a leap like this for housing in America, a fundamental need for families. You won't see this for health care in America. In fact, health care was savaged by the Big Ugly Bill. You won't see this for education in America, but you certainly see it for ICE. Now these issues of the impact on nutrition budgets and health care budgets and housing budgets and deficit and debt and the budget for ISOs are all very good topics for this Committee to hold a hearing on, but we haven't held a hearing on that. Now Trump has turned ICE into secret police. I can't believe that we now have secret police in America, but we do. I well recall studying secret police back when I was in college and the basic mark of them was they'd show up in unmarked vans, unmarked uniforms, no judicial warrant, knock down doors without a judicial warrant, grab people, detain them and often prevent them from having access and communication with families or lawyers. All of that's happening right now in America. We now have a secret police called ICE and it's a tremendous black spot on our nation that this has happened under this administration. Freedom and privacy, laws, norms and our Constitution all shredded. Heartbreakingly, three American citizens have been killed by ICE. Renee Good, Alex Pretti in Minnesota and Reuben Ray Martinez in Texas. Now when ICE killed Reuben Ray Martinez, they hid the facts. So most Americans aren't aware that a third individual was killed. But recent reporting by CBS News obtained the body cam footage showing him being killed by an ICE officer in March of 2025. Now ICE's budget has been increased by a factor of seven. The way that it operates has been dramatically changed from the norms of law and justice in a democratic republic to the strategy of secret police in an authoritarian regime. That would be a very good topic for a hearing, given how much ICE's budget has increased and we should be holding one in an examining that question. Wars come with enormous costs. We know that the wars in the Middle East and Afghanistan and Iraq were staggering in terms of blood and treasure. More than 7,000 Americans killed, more than 50,000 Americans injured, often life-altering injuries, more than $6 trillion of national treasure expended. So here we are. America's at war. That'd be a good topic for a budget hearing. Seven U.S. service members already killed. The Pentagon estimating a billion dollars a day. And in fact, some of my colleagues have said it's $2 billion a day, a big change in expenditures and revenues. But none of those are the topics of today's hearing, the first we've had in a year. But we do have this topic that my colleague has pointed out, Sanctuary Cities. Well, Sanctuary is a bit of misnomer. Sanctuary states and cities are not places that are a safe haven where immigrants cannot be detained or deported. It refers to the decision that local police will serve as local police and not be commandeered to be assistant ICE agents. These policies are rooted in the 10th amendment of the Constitution and my colleagues across the aisle like to lean on state's rights. It's certainly a state's right to refuse to have its local police commandeered to be assistant ICE agents, assistance now to ICE operating as a secret police in the United States of America. So the idea that local police do local police work and ICE agents do ICE work is protected by our Constitution. But there's also a public safety rationale behind it. We know that when local police serve as local police, they build relationships with the community and decrease crime. Research shows that jurisdictions that choose for local police to be local police and not assistance to a secret police, refusing to be commandeered as a federal agent, they have a higher median household income, they have less poverty, they have less reliance on public assistance, they have lower unemployment. Those all sound like pretty good things to me and they have lower crime rates. A 2022 study found that allowing local police to be local police, not commandeered to be assistant ICE agents, results in a decrease in crime rates in those communities. And why? Well, because in places where they do get commandeered to be assistant ICE agents, they get less information, less trust, less ability to prosecute and crime goes up. So if my colleagues are all for crime, then persist in trying to violate the 10th amendment and the wise wisdom of those states that see the wisdom in separation with different roles. And there's nothing about local police being local police that hampers federal immigration enforcement. In fact, when people are arrested, fingerprints, data, crime are all put into a national database. So the federal government has all it needs and if it wants to make sure that a person is handed over at the time that a person is completing their sentence in a local or state institution, all they have to do is get a judicial warrant, a judicial warrant. That's all that's required. We've already seen the harm that happens when the executive branch tells the executive branch that it's okay to override Americans' civil rights. Reason: we have separation of powers in our Constitution, something being seriously eroded under this administration. So as a reminder, each of these issues, slashing nutrition assistance, gutting health care, increasing the wealth of billionaires, exploding deficits and debts, transforming ICE into a secret police, launching a war, are all appropriate issues this Budget Committee should be focused on. But the decision by cities and states to enhance public safety by having local police focus on local police issues is not a new change. And so it's puzzling to me why that's the decision for this first hearing in a year. What we know is that states and cities that let local police be local police do pretty damn well. With that in mind, I've invited two expert witnesses to join us today, Mr. David Bier from the Cato Institute, an expert on Sanctuary policies and the broader concerns about the Department of Homeland Security and its $170 billion for immigration enforcement, with little accountability or oversight. Joining him is Mr. Brendan Duke from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, which focuses on critical budgetary concerns, including how the big ugly betrayal law exploded our debt and raised the costs for working families. So I appreciate both of you joining us today. And while he is not able to join us for today's hearing, Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield has written a statement and it explains how the home states, my home state Oregon, how their policy is to let police be police, has assisted and helped him and the law enforcement officers keep Oregon communities safe. As he notes in his statement, Oregon's police policies have peacefully coexisted with seven presidential administrations. Mr. Chair, I ask unanimous consent to enter his statement into the record.\2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ Statement submitted by Senator Merkley appears in the appendix on page 122. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Chairman Graham. Without objection. Senator Merkley. And I also asked unanimous consent to submit a statement for the record from the Law Enforcement Action Partnership,\3\ which states ``When local departments are pressured to prioritize federal immigration objectives, officer time and resources are diverted from serious threats such as violent crime, domestic violence and community safety concerns. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ Statement submitted by Senator Merkley appears in the appendix on page 125. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ``The result is a policing environment that is less effective and less trusted. Creating a less effective and less trusted local public safety environment should not be the objective of the federal legislature.'' Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Graham. Thank you very much. So the novel approach, the 10th Amendment protects Sanctuary Cities, I hadn't heard that one, but we'll talk about that later. So our witnesses are Secretary, former secretary Chad Wolf, Acting Secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security from 2019 to 2020 and the current Homeland Security Immigration Chair of the America First Policy Institute. Sheriff Michael Chapman has been the sheriff of Loudoun County, Virginia since 2012. I think you're next door to Fairfax County. You can tell us about that. Ms. Jessica Vaughan is Director of Policy Studies at the Center for Immigration Studies, where she has worked since 1992. Welcome to y'all. If you'd rise and raise your right hand, please. Do you solemnly swear the testimony you're about to give this Committee is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help you God? Panel. I do. Chairman Graham. Thank you. Welcome to y'all. Mr. Wolf. STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE CHAD WOLF, FORMER ACTING SECRETARY, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY AND HOMELAND SECURITY AND IMMIGRATION CHAIR, AMERICA FIRST POLICY INSTITUTE \4\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ Prepared statement of Hon. Wolf appears in the appendix on page 50. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hon. Wolf. Well thank you, Chairman Graham and Ranking Member Merkley for the opportunity to testify before the Committee today. What we now commonly call ``Sanctuary Cities'' was born nearly 50 years ago in California and since then has exploded nationwide. According to the Department of Justice, 12 states, the District of Columbia, as well as 22 other jurisdictions for now are officially considered Sanctuary jurisdictions. But as the Chairman said, there are likely hundreds more. According to a 2024 report, nearly eight million illegal aliens resided in those jurisdictions and one in every three Americans or 120 million Americans live in Sanctuary jurisdictions. To be clear, this is not a localized phenomenon. Ultimately, Sanctuary policies affect every American. And so while not all Sanctuary jurisdictions have the exact same policies, they all share a core belief that it is acceptable and even justified to ignore illegal immigration and violations of our immigration law. But our law is clear. Title VIII, Section 1227 clearly states that aliens who entered the U.S. illegally or otherwise in the U.S. without lawful authorization are in fact removable. That is the mission of ICE. The law goes on to address those who harbor illegal aliens. Title VIII, Section 1324 states that any person who encourages or induces an alien to come enter or reside in the U.S. knowing or in reckless disregard of the fact of such coming to, entry or residence will be a violation of law. Now due to the supremacy clause and a long list of judicial opinions interpreting that, states do not have the authority to pick and choose which federal laws are recognized and enforced. And they do not have the authority to nullify federal laws by ignoring them or proactively creating obstacles to their effectiveness. Tragically, Sanctuary policies are unleashing devastating consequences for the American people, particularly those that live in those jurisdictions. In California, again the birthplace of the Sanctuary movement, local politicians released 4,641 criminal aliens from local jails in 2025, rather than handing them over to ICE for removal. Those criminals included aliens that had committed Homicide, assault, sexual predatory offenses and burglary. And just weeks ago, as the Chairman indicated in Fairfax County, just miles from where we are today, a criminal illegal alien with more than 30 arrests fatally stabbed a woman in the neck and that county, Fairfax County, has been a Sanctuary for almost a decade and this is the tragic result. Despite the dangerous nature of Sanctuary jurisdictions, there are some that will not stop until we've become a Sanctuary nation, largely free from all border enforcement and immigration enforcement. Calls for ICE-free zones, detention bans and even an outright abolishment of ICE are becoming increasingly common. The evidence is clear to restore the rule of law, common sense and public safety, the era of Sanctuary jurisdictions need to come to an end permanently. Thankfully, President Trump and numerous states are taking action, but legal challenges persist and Sanctuary jurisdictions are still largely able to exist under current law. Congress should take action. In my written testimony, I've outlined several recommendations to address this issue, including the need to hold local officials accountable for knowingly violating the law. Let us heed the lessons that we've learned from tragedies unfolding in cities like New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Seattle, San Francisco and others. The American people are safer when state and local governments cooperate with federal immigration agencies. State and local governments should give our agents access to their jails and prisons, so that federal agents can screen prisoners, determine their immigration status, process removable aliens and transfer custody to federal authorities once an alien is released. This requires little effort from local governments, yet under Sanctuary policies, state and local officials often slam the door shut on immigration officers. I'd like to close with a simple question. For those who continue to support Sanctuary policies, how many more Americans need to die at the hands of illegal aliens released by Sanctuary jurisdictions? Sanctuary cities must become an artifact of American history, rather than the ongoing safe haven for drug dealers, narco-terrorists, murderers and dangerous people who threaten the safety and the security of the American people. And let me just end on a comment made by the Ranking Member, talking about secret police. I think that's an outrageous comment. I think the men and women of ICE are sworn law enforcement officers, they do their job, they're trained to do their job. They have a very dangerous job in what they do and to continue to denigrate their job and how they go about it in such a dangerous environment I think is a disservice to them. Senator Merkley. Mr. Chairman, since the testimony involves the comment I made, I will just reply that if you don't want to be secret police, don't act like secret police. And I laid out the factual basis on exactly all the qualities that they are utilizing now that are the hallmark of secret police around the world. Thank you. Chairman Graham. Mr. Chapman. STATEMENT OF THE HONORABLE MICHAEL L. CHAPMAN, SHERIFF, LOUDOUN COUNTY, VIRGINIA \5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\ Prepared statement of Hon. Chapman appears in the appendix on page 55. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hon. Chapman. Chairman Graham, Ranking Member Senator Merkley and other Members of the Committee. I am Loudoun County Sheriff Mike Chapman and lead Virginia's most complex and largest full-service sheriff's office, employing over 900. Loudoun County sits just outside of Washington, D.C. and is the home to Leesburg, Middleburg and the Dulles International Airport. In Loudoun County, we celebrate a diverse community, have an extraordinarily diverse workforce. We welcome everyone here that's here legally and within our organization speak over 25 different languages. I have served 47 years in this profession as a local police officer, a career Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) special agent and for the past 14 years as an elected sheriff. I am honored to sit before you today to discuss our mutual concern of Sanctuary cities and counties. I am fortunate that Loudoun County is part of a traditional form of government that enables a sheriff to conduct all law enforcement, jail and court operations under one roof, essentially making me both a sheriff and a police chief. This differs significantly from our surrounding jurisdictions where appointed county, city and town police chiefs are the norm. Loudoun's form of government has enabled me to make decisions in the best interest of our citizens, free of mandated political agendas. It has also allowed me to be the only Republican law enforcement leader in all of Northern Virginia. That responsibility is a double-edged sword. While I don't answer to our 7-2 Democrat Board of Supervisors for policy decisions, I do receive my budget from them. This dichotomy causes significant friction, making this a very challenging area. Our system of government, however, provides our citizens with a check and balance. We endured a two year battle with our Board of Supervisors who pursued rather converting our sheriff's office into a police department several years ago, to exercise complete power and control over our agency. We defeated this aggressive action because our citizens ultimately decided that they prefer having a direct voice in who leads their public safety through the election process. This system and our common sense approach to problems putting citizens first is why the Sheriff's office has been awarded favor, government service for two years running in our local newspaper, and why I've been selected as favorite public servant for the past five years. Regarding immigration, it is important to distinguish criminal aliens who pose a threat to our community from immigrants here legally. Consequently, while our surrounding jurisdictions choose to be sanctuaries, not make this distinction and not honor ICE detainers, we do just the opposite. We have always cooperated with all of our state, local and federal counterparts including ICE, and have routinely notified ICE of those in our custody for criminal offenses who also had active detainers issued by ICE regardless of the presidential administration. We honor all detainers and warrants from other law enforcement jurisdictions, just as I would expect them to honor ours. These practices likely contribute to why our agency has the lowest crime rate in the entire Washington D.C.-Northern Virginia area, and is one of the safest counties in the entire United States. That doesn't mean we're exempt from problems related to illegal immigration. In 2024, we experienced five homicides, three of which were committed by people here illegally. Two of the three were committed by an Mara Salvatrucha 13 (MS-13) gang member and in a neighboring county, one that refuses to contact ICE regarding the criminals they arrest, two homicides were committed in just over the past two months. One occurred within 24 hours after the criminal who had an outstanding ICE detainer on him was released from jail without any notification to ICE. The other, police questioned why the subject had been released and warned the prosecutor of danger, stating not if, but when he would assault again, resulting in a grandmother being stabbed to death at a bus stop. This exemplifies what happens with Sanctuary counties. Law enforcement's hands are tied by politicians and political agendas. Last year, I signed a 287(g) warrant service officer program agreement, which enabled us to hold a person arrested for a criminal violation an additional 48 hours for ICE, in the event ICE couldn't pick them up immediately. This enabled us to safely turn over criminal illegal aliens to ICE who otherwise would have been released into our community and could pose an additional threat to our residents. This simple process has kept ICE from having to conduct street operations in our area. I have told my community that not turning over criminal aliens to ICE, who could endanger our residents, would be irresponsible and dangerous to the very people I've sworn an oath to protect. This process, which has worked well for us, is likely to become far more challenging considering the legislation currently in motion in Richmond. Our governor rescinded the previous administration's executive order, which enabled jurisdictions to cooperate with ICE. This was followed by legislation proposed by both houses of our general assembly, which if passed and signed by the governor, will likely require judicial warrants from ICE for local law enforcement to act on anything. Considering illegal immigration is a civil offense, this action will no doubt force us to release detainees incarcerated by us for criminal offenses unrelated to immigration back into our communities, where they could pose an additional threat to our citizens. If this Committee can exercise any leverage to influence a different outcome, I am confident that law enforcement officials throughout Virginia and other locations who are familiar with these challenges would be grateful. We take our jobs seriously and want to keep all of our citizens safe. Thank you for your attention and, I look forward to answering any questions. Chairman Graham. Ms. Vaughan. STATEMENT OF JESSICA VAUGHAN, DIRECTOR OF POLICY STUDIES, CENTER FOR IMMIGRATION STUDIES \6\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ Prepared statement of Ms. Vaughan appears in the appendix on page 57. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ms. Vaughan. Good morning and thank you. More than half of removable aliens live in those jurisdictions that have Sanctuary policies intended to hinder immigration enforcement and prohibit cooperation between state and local law enforcement and federal immigration enforcement, which is almost always a violation of federal law and imposes enormous costs on taxpayers. My organization has been tracking these policies since 2015, and we maintain a list and map of jurisdictions and policies on our website. Those who promote Sanctuary policies often claim that they're needed to build trust with immigrants, so that they'll report crimes or to avoid distracting local law enforcement agencies with immigration enforcement. These claims are disproven and disingenuous. In fact, Sanctuary policies are an irrational political response based on disagreement with federal immigration policy and opposition to enforcement of immigration laws. The motivations for Sanctuary policies are ideological and political, but the cost of Sanctuary policies is unfortunately very tangible. First, the public safety costs, and these are the most significant and problematic. Between October of 2022 and February of 2025, Sanctuary jurisdictions refused more than 26,000 detainers for criminal aliens. Half of these were in California and large numbers also were released in Illinois, Virginia, Massachusetts and Connecticut. The individual jails that released the most were Santa Clara County, California, Cook County, Illinois and Fairfax County, Virginia. In 2024 alone, the Fairfax County sheriff declined to honor 744 detainers for criminals that she had in custody. That's more than two a day. Some of these are gang members with long rap sheets who get arrested over and over, costing county taxpayers, untold sums in repeated crimes, prosecution and incarceration. Others are child predators and sex offenders. Oregon is another place that protects criminal aliens with strict Sanctuary policies. Last fall, ICE actually had to issue subpoenas just to try to get four Oregon sheriffs to share information on violent felons who had been released despite ICE detainers. They had convictions for rape, assault, child exploitation and kidnapping, among other crimes. What possible reason can there be for not cooperating with ICE for their removal? It's certainly not a public safety reason, and it seems as if they actually want to make immigration enforcement as costly and labor intensive as possible. Besides blocking law enforcement agencies from cooperating with ICE Sanctuary states typically have other policies that attract illegal settlement and thus burden taxpayers with support of illegal immigrants. Besides funding emergency health care and schooling for all, a number of Sanctuary states go farther and choose to provide Medicaid subsidized health insurance, nutrition assistance, housing and much more. Illegal immigrants use these welfare programs in large numbers. My organization has found that over 60 percent of illegal alien-headed households are using at least one form of welfare program and usually more than one, at a cost of tens of billions of dollars to taxpayers. This is why any resources spent on immigration enforcement actually save taxpayers money, taxpayer money in the long run. It is my repeated observation that the politicians who support Sanctuary policies are not moved by the costs or the pain their policies have caused American families. Victims like Stephanie Minter, Denny McCann, Drew Rosenberg, Matthew Denice, Dominic Durden, Laken Riley and Kate Steinle and so many others. These are priceless lives lost to Sanctuary policies, and it's wrong to trivialize their loss as a statistical blip. Some states like South Carolina, Florida and Texas, have banned Sanctuary policies. The Trump administration is making progress through outreach and litigation, but while the federal government likely cannot force Sanctuary jurisdictions to do the right thing, it can create consequences for sanctuaries. Congress needs to create additional consequences like disqualification from certain federal funding, so that taxpayers are not subsidizing sanctuaries. Congress should also clarify that state and local police have the authority to cooperate with immigration enforcement, so that they can't be blocked from doing it by state or local laws. In addition, those who are seriously harmed as a result of Sanctuary policies should have some resource in the courts. Thank you. STATEMENT OF DAVID J. BIER, THE SETZ FOUNDATION CHAIR IN IMMIGRATION POLICY, CATO INSTITUTE \7\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Prepared statement of Mr. Bier appears in the appendix on page 67. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Bier. Chairman Graham, Ranking Member Merkley and distinguished Members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify. For half a century, the Cato Institute's research has shown that people, whatever their ancestry, background or birthplace, can thrive in a free society. Immigrants come to work for us and with us to make our lives better. They work at higher rates and are nearly twice as likely to start businesses here. Immigrants have reduced government deficits by 14 and a half trillion dollars over the last 30 years, and yet Congress has not updated the legal immigration system during that entire time. So just three percent of all legal immigrant applicants were approved in 2024. Rather than fix this broken system, the new administration banned half of all the legal immigrants who had made it to the end of that process, including spouses and children of U.S. citizens. The fallout from this flawed system is left to our cities to manage. In many areas one in five residents lives with someone here illegally. Mass deportation is not an option for these places. It is an attack on them. It is taking Americans, Americans away from their spouses, parents, pastors, parishioners, employees, employers, customers and friends. It's not us Americans versus them immigrants. Cities know immigrants are part of us. They also know that immigrants are here to build, not destroy. A mountain, literally a mountain of research proves that immigrants and reasonable limits on participation with ICE do not increase crime rates. Immigrants, even illegal immigrants, are half as likely to be incarcerated for crimes in the United States. According to DHS, only about three percent of illegal immigrants have any criminal convictions. Immigrants reduce crime rates, which means your less likely to be a victim of a crime. Let me be clear. When a non-citizen does victimize someone, they should be convicted, imprisoned and deported. But it is DHS that has ignored this formula. Just 28 percent of the people detained by ICE right now were convicted of any crime at all. This is no surprise. DHS has abandoned its public safety mission. It has stripped millions of vetted immigrants of their legal status, just so that it could deport them. Instead of protecting us, DHS violates the Constitution. Its massed agents invade our homes without warrants. They detain without evidence, and they deport without due process. They intimidate, beat and even kill Americans who protest. They arrest legal immigrants for writing opinion articles. They lie to the courts and then they ignore them. With all this unconstitutional mayhem, Congress should not itself violate the Constitution by threatening local law enforcement, not for interfering with ICE, but rather for following their own local laws that they swore an oath to uphold. Under our system of federalism and the Constitution, Congress can't force cities to do its bidding, whether on immigration, guns or the environment. If Congress wants cities to help DHS, it'll need those cities to trust DHS. But to get trust you need to be trustworthy, and this DHS is not. Consider this. Before this administration, non-citizens were more likely to report serious crimes to the police than the U.S.-born population. Now, DHS is arresting immigrant crime victims. For example in Iowa, a shooting victim who helped bring to justice violent robbers was arrested by ICE before he had even healed. But since he had a pending charge for an unpaid traffic ticket, ICE considers him a criminal. This has caused filings for U visas for crime victims working with police to drop by 63 percent. This is not making Americans safer. Congress must require DHS to focus on real threats, and it must empower Americans to sue federal agents for violating the Constitution. We need accountability and constitutionality to restore trust. Thank you. STATEMENT OF BRENDAN DUKE, SENIOR DIRECTOR, FEDERAL BUDGET, CENTER ON BUDGET AND POLICY PRIORITIES \8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ Prepared statement of Mr. Duke appears in the appendix on page 84. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Duke. Thank you. Chair Graham, Ranking Member Merkley and Members of the of the Budget Committee. My name is Brendan Duke, and I'm Senior Director for Federal Budget Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. The Center on Budget is a non-partisan research and policy institute that advances federal and state policies to help build a country where everyone has the resources they need to thrive and share in the nation's prosperity. Let me first begin with an overview of our fiscal situation for the Budget Committee. Analyses typically focused on government spending and revenue as shares of the economy. In 2025, revenue was 17 percent, which is around the same level as in 1985. Programmatic spending on the other hand grew seven- tenths of a percentage point since 1985. But Social Security and Medicare are responsible for more than 100 percent of the increase in spending, because the country has gotten older. That is nobody's fault. I'm sure everyone on this Committee wishes they had the same knees or back they did 40 years ago. Similarly, we all wish we had the demographics and ratio of working age Americans to retirees that we had 40 years ago. The combination of population aging in basic arithmetic means we will face a choice between raising revenue past the 17 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) level set when the country's demographics were more favorable, or making drastic cuts to important programs. The retirement of the baby boom was a predictable and predicted development. But at the beginning of the 21st century, we had a fiscal system that would deliver adequate projected revenue to meet our needs. Rounds of unpaidfor tax cuts ruined that. Take a look at projections for 2025 that were made right before most of the Bush tax cuts were made permanent, and before anyone even thought of the Trump tax cuts and compare them to the actual 2025 numbers. The 2025 deficit is much higher than projected in 2012, despite programmatic spending being lower than projected. The reason the deficit roses revenues come in far lower than projected as a result of those unpaid-for tax cuts. Importantly, Social Security, Medicare and other health programs such as Medicaid and premium tax credits also came in below CBO's 2012 projections. What all of this ultimately shows is that it's entirely possible to meet our commitments to seniors, while ensuring millions of low and moderate income Americans have health care and food if we are willing to raise the revenue to do so. Instead, Congress made a different choice last summer. The giant reconciliation bill adds $3.4 trillion to the deficit, as it extends tax cuts tilted to the wealthy despite cutting Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Medicaid by about 20 percent by 2034. CBO more recently estimated this figure at $4.7 trillion over the new budget window and including interest. Notably, this $3.4 trillion cost is higher than the cost of extending all of the expiring tax cuts for all families, including for millionaires, but without the cuts to SNAP and Medicaid, and it would have cost far less than, to extend the tax. That's for the 98 percent of families making under $400,000 without those cuts to SNAP and Medicaid. In other words, the cuts to health care and food assistance in the reconciliation bill were entirely the result of Congress's choice to load the bill with tax cuts beyond the 2017 tax cuts, along with large increases for defense and immigration enforcement. The result is millions of low income families will lose the ability to afford the high cost of groceries or go to the doctor when they're sick, cuts that a vast majority of the public staunchly oppose. Moreover, the entire cost of the tax cut was essentially offset by the Trump administration's decision to raise taxes on imported goods. Cutting income taxes financed by taxes on imported goods is a poor trade. It is both economically inefficient and further pushes the burden of financing the government from high income to low and middle income families. In fact, the combo of the Trump administration's tariff regime and the spending cuts on the reconciliation bill will leave households in the bottom 70 percent worse off. The Supreme Court last month handed the Trump administration an opportunity to save face by ruling that many of these sweeping tariffs were illegal. Instead of using the Court decision to back down on a failed policy, Trump has instead replaced those struck down tariffs with a sweeping 10 to 15 percent across the board tariff. I think we can all agree that the steps required to significantly improve the outlook, whether through revenue increases, program cuts or both can be politically challenging. Immigration can reduce the need for those difficult measures. Immigrants contribute to our communities and the U.S. economy in many ways. In particular, they improve our fiscal outlook by boosting our national birth rate and they boost our workforce. Last month, CBO evaluated the economic and fiscal effects of the administration's anti-immigrant policies. CBO cut in half the projection of the annual growth rate of the U.S. population over the next few 10 years. CBO now estimates that the 2035 working age population will be 2.4 million people smaller than in its previous projection. This has important fiscal costs too. CBO projects that the administration's actions to reduce immigration will increase deficits by $500 billion over ten years, principally by reducing the number of taxpayers. Those higher deficits will make deficit reduction that much harder, adding to the damage from H.R. 1. Financing income tax tilted to the wealthy by cutting programs and raising import taxes while discouraging and disparaging immigrants is no way to fix our country's fiscal imbalances. Thank you. Chairman Graham. Thank you all for your testimony. We'll do five minute rounds. Mr. Bier, is it accurate that Barack Obama deported three million people when he was president? Mr. Bier. Those are total removals, not people deported from the interior. Chairman Graham. What does that mean? Mr. Bier. Well, there are people deported from the borders who never lived in the United States. Chairman Graham. Were there people deported inside the United States? Mr. Bier. Well, I mean I think it's a little bit unfair to compare people deported at the border---- Chairman Graham. Oh, hey, hey, hey. Mr. Bier [continuing]. Versus people in the interior. I think Jessica would agree to this. Chairman Graham. So hey. Hey listen, listen. You don't want to answer a question, that's fine, but don't tell me what's fair and unfair. Bottom line. Did he use judicial warrants to deport anybody? When he deported somebody interior, did he have a judicial warrant? Mr. Bier. No. Chairman Graham. No. Why? Because it's stupid. Mr. Wolf, tell me what would happen if we adopted his approach. You can't deport anybody unless you have a judicial warrant. Would that be effectively the end of deportation? Hon. Wolf. I think it would. I mean if you just look at---- Chairman Graham. Don't you think that's what they want to do? Hon. Wolf. In part, absolutely. Chairman Graham. These people over here want to stop deportation. Hon. Wolf. So if you just look at the 1.5 or 1.6 million individuals here with a final order of removal, right? They've been through the judicial process. They've been to an immigration judge, probably an Immigration Board of Appeals, and every time the judge says, you don't have a legal right to be here. If you had to get a judicial warrant for each one of those, you'd be here for the next 20 years trying to remove those 1.6---- Chairman Graham. But when a Democrat says you need a judicial warrant to deport somebody, they're turning--Obama didn't do it, did he? Hon. Wolf. Not that I'm aware of, no. Chairman Graham. No. No, he didn't because it's impossible. You just stop the whole system. You're not trying to reform ICE. You're trying to stop deportations. If it were up to you, we'd have more illegal immigrants. I hope people are paying attention to what the hell is going on in this country. Sheriff, tell me about what it's like to live next to a Sanctuary county. Hon. Chapman. Well, we're the only ones that actually work with ICE and are able to get people out based on our 287(g). We turn them over to ICE. We arrest them for criminal violations outside of their immigration status. They come and they pick them up and they're gone. And I'll tell you, it's made a big difference. We had---- Chairman Graham. Well, those laws that you're enforcing, were they on the books before Trump became president? Hon. Chapman. Yes. Chairman Graham. So all these laws were there before Trump became president and Obama used them. Now, when we use them, all of a sudden we're Nazis. I think people see through this. Do you believe Sanctuary City policy is bad for crime, Mr. Chapman? Hon. Chapman. I do. I think, you know, the ability--if you look at us and compare it to our next door neighbor there they, I think, maybe have notified ICE maybe about seven times last year, where it was 184 times for us. Those are people that could have been released back to our community, that could have committed other crimes, and we don't need that here. It's irresponsible of me to allow that to happen and let these people back in our community. Chairman Graham. Ms. Vaughan, how would you--what's your takeaway about Sanctuary City policy? What damage has it done to our country, if any? Ms. Vaughan. Well, there's the cost of the lives lost to illegal aliens who were released by Sanctuaries. That's priceless. There's the fiscal---- Chairman Graham. This case behind me, Jalani. Is that his name? He should have been deported. Do you agree Ms. Vaughan? Ms. Vaughan. Absolutely, yes. Chairman Graham. You know, you're talking about suing somebody who's been abused by the government. Why don't we sue local prosecutors who put this in motion? I'd love to do that. So I'm going to try to find a way to give victims a chance to go to court when a local prosecutor puts back on the streets somebody with 30 priors. That's some--do you support that idea, empowering people? Ms. Vaughan. I do. I think that that would be an effective deterrent to Sanctuary policies, because they're adopted---- Chairman Graham. Make these counties and cities pay. Ms. Vaughan. Right. They're adopted for political reasons, not public safety reasons. Chairman Graham. Yeah. What are--what's the upside of ignoring federal law and keeping people like this out of federal custody? It's a political choice. So let me ask you this question. There was a clerk of court, Mr. Wolf, in Kentucky that did not want to issue a marriage license to a gay couple, in spite of the fact Supreme Court said that gay marriage was legal, and she went to jail. Do you think that's a good outcome? Should she have gone to jail for refusing to obey the law? Hon. Wolf. I think it's important to obey the law. Chairman Graham. Yeah, I do too. Hon. Wolf. The law is the law. Chairman Graham. And when I suggested that the clerk of court who had a religious view, that she could not in good conscience issue a marriage license to a gay couple, even though the law required, she needed to get out of her job. I was--boy, what a great guy I was then. Now the shoe's on the other foot. All of a sudden, that's not--that's not a good idea. You can--what you want to do is just ignore the laws you don't like. Is that where we're headed, Mr. Wolf? Hon. Wolf. I believe it is. Chairman Graham. Well, let's stop it now. Let's end this madness. There is no upside to Sanctuary Cities. It's all downside. Senator Merkley. Senator Merkley. Well, no upside other than, higher median household income, less poverty, less reliance on public assistance, lower unemployment and safer communities, all of which seem pretty much on the upside from my point of view. Mr. Duke, what effect did the Big Beautiful Bill, as Trump called it, have on debt over the ten year budget window? Mr. Duke. CBO shows that it adds $4.7 trillion to the deficit. Senator Merkley. That's a pretty whopping sum. Mr. Duke. It's enormous. Senator Merkley. For one piece of legislation, and over 30 years? Mr. Duke. It comes to $30 trillion with a T. Senator Merkley. Wow. Mr. Duke. Yeah. Senator Merkley. What's our national debt right now? Mr. Duke. As a share of GDP, it's around 100 percent. Senator Merkley. And that's about $30 trillion? Mr. Duke. Yeah. Senator Merkley. So another $30 trillion. But if interest rates are one percent higher, how much more does that add to the debt? Mr. Duke. I can't believe I'm saying these numbers, because they sound like they're from Star Trek, but $50 trillion. Senator Merkley. Yeah, $50 trillion. Well, thanks a lot folks for passing a bill that's going to add $30 to $50 trillion to our national debt, suppressing our investments in health care, housing, education, public safety, transportation, all important things for the welfare of America. And Mr. Duke, how did that bill affect the size of the working age population? Mr. Duke. Yeah. So basically the combination of that--so first that bill funded ICE a lot, as you showed, and CBO says that it is going to shrink the number of people who are in the workforce, because they are going to leave the country or be in detention camps. That directly shrinks our tax base. Senator Merkley. Okay. So that has an overall effect on the GDP of our nation? Mr. Duke. Fewer working people means smaller GDP. Senator Merkley. Okay. Mr. Bier, in states or cities that have policies referred to as Sanctuary policies, but more accurately that dedicate local police to doing local police work, do those locations fully cooperate in detaining somebody when there's a judicial warrant for them? Mr. Bier. Yes, absolutely. They turn over anyone subject to a criminal matter upon notice by the federal government that they have a warrant. Senator Merkley. So those jurisdictions have entered into the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) federal database fingerprints, arrest record, what that person's being detained for, how long they're being held. Federal government has all that information. Mr. Bier. Exactly, yes. So they could go and get those individuals anytime they want. And in this case in Virginia, for example, the Laken Riley Act, which they all supported, directed the Department of Homeland Security to get those people. And instead of getting those people, they're out on the streets profiling random Hispanic workers going to their jobs. So it's a total misdirection to blame the county, when the Department of Homeland Security isn't even following the law that they passed. Senator Merkley. Why not, since they could get that warrant and pick up those individuals who have committed violent crimes? Mr. Bier. Because the White House has created an arrest quota that's the only metric for success for them. How many arrests can you make today? And the fastest way to make arrests is indiscriminate raids, indiscriminate profiling of people on the street. That's what's led to this huge jump in the number of people, and the frankly chaos that we're seeing in cities across the country. Senator Merkley. So there was a chart in your longer written testimony showing that only five percent of the individuals booked by ICE have ever had a violent criminal conviction. Mr. Bier. Yeah. And not only that, if you look at my written testimony as well, I talk about how the Department of Homeland Security has its own internal threat assessment that they assign to each individual who comes into their custody. And those people have to prioritize. They actually have a mandate. They can't be all political. They have to figure out who is actually a threat. And of those people, only ten percent received the highest threat level and 70 percent were deemed by the Department of Homeland--this Department of Homeland Security, to not be a threat at all. Senator Merkley. So how does that match the campaign rhetoric about we're going to go after the worst of the worst, which I think 100 percent of Americans supported the idea that anyone who had committed a violent crime should be--should be investigated, should be prosecuted, should be if convicted and incarcerated should be deported. But those numbers don't match that. Mr. Bier. Great campaign messaging, great messaging for, you know, a $200 million ad campaign by the DHS Secretary. Not based in reality at all. On day one of this administration, they rescinded all policies that forced ICE to focus on violent offenders and people with criminal convictions. Senator Merkley. They did the exact opposite of what they told the citizens they were going to do during the campaign. Mr. Bier. It was a lie, just like it was a lie about all the things they said about Renee Good and Alex Pretti and all the other people that they've killed over the last year. Senator Merkley. And you recommend--do I have time for the last question, or my time has expired? Chairman Graham. Sure. Go ahead. Senator Merkley. You recommend in your testimony that there be a private right of action when individuals' civil rights are violated. Now my understanding is that if local police or state police violate your civil rights, you have a cause of action against that; is that correct? Mr. Bier. Yeah. Under Title 42, Section 1983, there's a private right of action against state and local, but not against the feds. And this is a critically important issue, because right now they're recruiting all these state and local officers into essentially the ICE framework, which gives them immunity against all constitutional violations that they carry out while working in conjunction with the federal government. So we need to expand that to cover federal officers as well, to make sure we don't have this immunity creep into every police department in America, which is their goal, including through this bill that we're talking about today. Senator Merkley. So when the Vice President said ICE agents have absolute immunity in violating people's civil rights, he was right? Mr. Bier. Effectively, yes. Right now, as the law stands. Senator Merkley. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Graham. Thank you. Just one point of clarification. Is it your position that a non-violent illegal immigrant shouldn't be deported? Mr. Bier. My position is that we should give people who are peaceful people a path to citizenship. You endorsed that principle for many years, Senator. Chairman Graham. So no matter how many people come? Mr. Bier. No. It should be based on whether people have a demonstrable basis to remain in the United States, which is whether they contribute to this country or whether they're a threat to it. Chairman Graham. I guess---- Mr. Bier. We should have all laws---- Chairman Graham. I guess what you don't understand, and I don't want to, I'm familiar with the Gang of Eight bill, shut down illegal immigration. We did away with the magnets. We're going to give people a chance who've been here for a long time. Mr. Bier. Your bill had the exact opposite approach of what this Department of Homeland Security is carrying out. Chairman Graham. Listen, listen. For four years, Biden obliterated the border. 11 million people came in and the bill I was working on would have prevented that. He took everything we were trying to do to stop illegal immigration, be fair to the ones here and blew a hole in it, and now we got 11 million more and you want to give them amnesty. They'll never stop. Senator Grassley. STATEMENT OF SENATOR GRASSLEY Senator Grassley. Yeah. The United States is a country based on the rule of law, and it's against the law to enter our country without our permission. And I compliment the Chairman for having this hearing, and his strong statements and his strong questioning. We all know that our country benefits from legal immigration and entering our country. This is a Budget Committee, and my questions will basically be based upon budget impact and cost to our government. Mr. Wolf, there are some legal limitations that prevent states from completely excluding illegal immigrants from access to some of their government programs. What are those limitations and what immediate steps considering those limitations can the federal government take to minimize the fiscal burden of Sanctuary jurisdictions? Hon. Wolf. Yeah. I think when we talk about public benefits, whether they're federal or state benefits, I think and the Chairman I believe mentioned this earlier, these are strong magnets of why folks decide to come to the United States illegally. Now there's a variety of different reasons for them to do so. But if they're able to stay in a jurisdiction that shields them from law enforcement, that provides public benefits, particularly at the state level, but also at the federal level, both need to be looked at, that continues to incentivize those individuals to come and to stay. And so when you look at how to secure the country, it's it not only border security, it's a big part of it, but it's also getting at these pull factors, and those public benefits are a big part of that. I think the American people are generous. I think they want to help people that need true help. But to have folks that come here to the country illegally choose to stay illegally, have no protections under U.S. law and continue to get public benefits, I think that's where the American people draw the line. Senator Grassley. Ms. Vaughan, Sanctuary jurisdictions frame their policy as squarely a matter of local policy. But we know these policies have both broader public safety and fiscal effects on areas beyond their border. So what are some examples of the cost to both the federal government and the state government caused by Sanctuary policies that are often forgotten or overlooked, with emphasis upon forgotten or overlooked? Ms. Vaughan. Well, I think too many of the victims of these policies have been forgotten. I named a few of them, but these families are still suffering silently. Another forgotten cost is the cost of providing benefits, taxpayer-funded social services to illegal alien households. And federal law currently allows states to choose to do that if their legislature approves it, at enormous costs, and some of those dollars are federal dollars. So all of us as Americans share the cost burden of that arrangement, and Congress can do something about that. But there's also the cost of the erosion of the integrity of our immigration system, when individual states and jurisdiction and local jurisdictions can obstruct the enforcement of federal laws that are passed by Congress without consequence. Even though they are--many of these Sanctuary policies are clearly in violation of Section 1373 and 1644 of the Immigration Act. And so, you know, it's a slap in the face to legal immigrants to have--say allow these policies that shield individuals from immigration enforcement, most of whom are criminal aliens. Immigrants don't want to live with these policies either. Something like 70 percent of the American public is opposed to Sanctuary policies for all of these reasons. Senator Grassley. Mr. Wolf, if you can answer this question. It's in regard to the 11 million people that came here under Biden and Harris. Over that period of time, did illegal immigrants seek out Sanctuary jurisdictions for safe harbor? And is there any evidence to back up your statement? Hon. Wolf. Well, I think if you look historically at where illegal aliens reside now, they reside all across the United States. But if you were to do a heat map, you would see them in--the majority of them in places like New York City, Chicago, Los Angeles and others that have these Sanctuary jurisdictions. So, yes. I do believe over time that illegal aliens do tend to, go to these types of jurisdictions. Senator Grassley. I got six second left. Sheriff Chapman, what are some examples of state and local cost increases those jurisdictions incur? Hon. Chapman. Well, I look at the funding that goes to our state and local, the folks that surround us and folks that do not support, you know, the immigration policies here and the funding that they get. And I think if that was curtailed, maybe they might look at this a lot more seriously. But it is a cost to us. It's a cost of putting people out there. You're talking about more homicides, you're talking about--we've had our share locally here and certainly as a Chairman brought up, and we've had them in Loudoun County. And it's a human factor that is really important here. We want to keep our people safe and keep them alive. Chairman Graham. Senator Whitehouse. Senator Whitehouse. Thank you, Chairman. Chairman Graham. Van Hollen. I apologize. STATEMENT OF SENATOR VAN HOLLEN Senator Van Hollen. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Wolf, if I could start with you. You would agree that in America, people have the right to peacefully protest under the First Amendment, right? Hon. Wolf. Correct. Senator Van Hollen. You would agree that people have the Constitutional right to due process, right? Hon. Wolf. Correct. Senator Van Hollen. Would you agree with Kristi Noem, who characterized Renee Good as a domestic terrorist? Is Renee Good a domestic terrorist in your view? Hon. Wolf. I've been very clear on this point when that incident occurred, as well as, the Pretti incident as well, as to let that investigation play out before any comments are made about the motives of any of the individuals involved, including the law enforcement officers. Senator Van Hollen. So clearly it was wrong to label them domestic terrorists, right? Hon. Wolf. Again, I don't--I'm not at the department. I don't know what the information she had. If you're asking me my opinion, I would have wait till the investigation play out before I rendered any decision. Senator Van Hollen. So you think it's still an open question, as to whether or not they're domestic terrorists? Hon. Wolf. Again, I'm going to let the investigation play out. Senator Van Hollen. It sounds like you do, which I think, you know, the country has seen the videos, okay. So I find it outrageous that you would sit here today and hold open the idea that they were domestic terrorists. Their parents and their loved ones deserve an apology from the U.S. government. And I find it outrageous that you're taking the position that you are here today. Hon. Wolf. I'm not taking a position. Senator Van Hollen. Yes, you are. By taking no position and leaving on the table the notion that they're domestic terrorists, you are taking a position. Mr. Bier, thank you for emphasizing the big lie, that what the Trump administration is doing is going after the worst of the worst. As Senator Merkley pointed out and as you've shown, that's just not true. I mean nobody wants people who are here illegally committing violent crimes, but the overwhelming majority of people who are in detention right now, by ICE's own admission, pose no risk to public safety, is that right? Mr. Bier. That's right. Over 70 percent were given no threat level at all. They could be released right now without a threat to the public. Senator Van Hollen. Yeah. So this is just such a big lie. I mean that's what we're seeing playing out in this forum and out of the White House from people like Stephen Miller and the President of the United States. Could you talk about another big lie? We do know that the so-called Big Beautiful Bill, as Republicans called it, increased the debt massively, like over 4 trillion bucks, right? They gave tax cuts to billionaires permanently. They cut health programs, they cut food safety, food programs. They had a walloping increase for ICE, like seven times its regular budget. And at the same time, we hear people like Stephen Miller and others claiming that it's actually immigrants who are the cause of increasing our deficits and debt. In fact, they've said that immigration is the cause of the growing national debt, and immigrants take more from the country than they contribute. Now, Mr. Bier, you've looked at this question very closely. Could you just respond to what I think is the second big lie? Mr. Bier. Yeah. Over the last 30 years, we looked at all the government budgets, federal, state and local combined. Immigrants reduced deficits by 14 and a half trillion dollars, which is about a third of all of the total deficits during that period of time. And it's easy to understand why, because they work at 12 percentage points higher than the national average. They use less benefits because they're subject to constraints, unique barriers to applying for those benefits in particular Social Security and Medicare, where those are by far our largest programs and they're not eligible for those at all if they're here in the country illegally, or if they came legally and they don't have a sufficient work history to qualify. So you have clear reasons for believing that they are reducing the deficits and debt. They are a benefit to this country, and we need more people who are going to contribute in the future as our population ages. Senator Van Hollen. Could you amplify a little more on the issue of Medicare and Social Security, because those, you know, trust funds in just a couple years there won't, you know, be enough to pay out full on the dollar for Social Security and Medicare? Mr. Bier. That's right. Senator Van Hollen. But as you pointed out, there are many immigrants that are paying into that, but not paying out. So could you just elaborate on that? Mr. Bier. According to the Social Security Administration, we need about 35 million more workers in order to keep revenues equal to expenses by the middle of the 2030's. So we are at a position right now where immigration is not going to solve it. Obviously, it's not going to solve it. But it is moving us in the right direction. These are people who are showing up. They're ready to work. They're often prime age individuals who are ready to enter the labor force. So it's a huge benefit fiscally to the United States to have these people who want to contribute to our country. Senator Van Hollen. Thank you. And thank you for exposing two of the big lies coming out of the Trump administration. Mr. Bier. Thank you. Senator Van Hollen. Thank you. Chairman Graham. The information we have is that 64 percent of the people encountered by ICE are either convicted or pending criminal charges. So if somebody's wrong, we'll find out who's lying. STATEMENT OF SENATOR JOHNSON Senator Johnson. Mr. Chairman. Yeah. Let's talk about some realities here. The Ranking Member talked about the funding for ICE rose dramatically this first year of the Trump administration. Well, this is why, because for the previous four years, President Biden and the Democrats opened up the border. Now I like this chart. First of all, saved the President's life. But the other reason I like this chart is it shows cause and effect. And the catalyst for this explosion in illegal immigration really was deferred action on childhood arrival. That's what sparked this. That created the first incentive for people to come this country illegally. That started the first wave. Now back in 2014, these were massive numbers. I remember President Obama calling it 2,000 a day. It was, you know, a humanitarian crisis. I think under Biden we had over 14,000 a day average. So Mr. Wolf, you were Acting Secretary trying to clean up the Obama mess. You know, I remember leading a delegation down to McAllen, Texas during the Obama administration, where we looked at the facility they set up and everybody, Democrat, Republican, were singing the praises of DHS for kind of skirting the rules and establishing a facility that would keep the children safe, as they were being encountered and detained across the border, because of the incentive of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). A couple years later in the Trump administration, that exact same facility, all of a sudden now the Democrats are calling that kids in cages. I mean first of all, will you just confirm the fact that that was the exact same facility that we praised in 2014, and all of a sudden 2017, those are kids in cages? Hon. Wolf. That's correct. Those were Border Patrol facilities. Senator Johnson. I think out of your Department, last year we got a memo that said of the millions, and nobody knows exactly how many millions came in here, the wide open border. I mean this is--I mean it's so out of whack. 650,000 people that are at large in America have committed crimes. 15,000 murderers, 20,000 rapists. Mr. Bier, you're shaking your head. Mr. Bier. They're not at large. The murderers are in prison. They're in prison, where they should be. Senator Johnson. They're not detained. Mr. Bier. They're detained by the state. They're not detained by ICE. They're in prisons ready to be deported. Now I don't---- Senator Johnson. Ms. Vaughan, have you kept track of how many people have been murdered, raped, victims of vehicular homicide at the hands of somebody that the Biden administration let in this country? Ms. Vaughan. I wish there were a way to do that. But so many law enforcement agencies do not keep track of the immigration status of people in their custody. They don't want to know. Senator Johnson. Would you say it's in the hundreds? Ms. Vaughan. Yes. Senator Johnson. Thousands? Ms. Vaughan. Yes. Senator Johnson. Tens of thousands? Ms. Vaughan. One data point that I do know is that at a certain point a few years ago, ICE determined that there were 10,000 deportable criminal aliens who were released by Sanctuary policies, who subsequently re-offended within 18 months. Senator Johnson. So where is the outrage on the other side of the aisle to those victims and their families? You know, we had a hearing and in Homeland Security, and they were talking about the trained activists. The number was very large I mean, but I couldn't believe it. Trained activists that are trained to basically interfere and obstruct with the legal law enforcement actions. And I made the comment, I can't imagine encouraging my supporters, first of all, to get trained to obstruct justice much less than go ahead and do it. Put yourself in harm's way, knowing people are going to potentially get hurt. Well, people did get hurt. Three people lost their lives, and now the other side exploits those martyrs while they completely ignore the thousands. Let's face it, it's thousands of the Laken Rileys and those individuals, you know. Where's the outrage to the crimes committed by that massive wave? And of course, I didn't want to have to spend money on ICE. But what are you going to do and trying to clean up this mess? I mean it is difficult enough for you to clean up Obama's mess. Try and clean up Biden's mess, and rather than getting help from the other side, no. They trained activists to obstruct trying to clean up that mess. That's the reality of the situation. That's why I agree and I appreciate this hearing. We have to end Sanctuary Cities, because it's just another incentive, a massive incentive for more illegal immigration. And the next time Democrats get in power, they'll open it up again. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Graham. Senator Whitehouse. STATEMENT OF SENATOR WHITEHOUSE Senator Whitehouse. Thank you, Chairman. Let me first observe for my colleagues here that ``Sanctuary City'' is a political term. It's not a technical term as your own witness has acknowledged, and it's important to get things right. So I want to just describe what's happening in Rhode Island. In Rhode Island, our federal district court has decided that local and state police officers can be held liable if they hold a person under an ICE detainer without a proper warrant, that the warrant requirement actually applies. And particularly when you're dealing with someone's freedom, detention. And that decision is not a fluke. It has been upheld by the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. So in my state, the district of Rhode Island from a federal point of view, and in my circuit the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, it is binding law that state and local officials who hold somebody under an ICE detainer where ICE hasn't bothered to get a warrant, can be held civilly liable. So we need to face that fact, because that's actually binding federal law. The second comment I want to make is about the behavior of ICE agents when they operate in Rhode Island. Those of you on the Judiciary Committee will remember me describing the set of affairs to then Secretary Noem. So masked agents appear in the Rhode Island Superior Court courthouse. They're operating in violation of an agreement that they have with the Court not to operate in that courthouse. They are operating with cameras, in violation of a courthouse rule that forbids taking photographs. They're pursuing a 30 plus year-old individual who they have mixed up with a high school intern who is interning for one of our state court judges. The state court judge is going to take the intern back to high school, so they walk out to the judge's car. If the ICE agents hadn't bothered to figure out who the judges were in the courthouse, when they got to the car, parked in a judge's only spot, they had the information necessary to deduce that this might be a judge. But rather than accept the judge's representations that he was returning an intern to the high school, I'll take out the full F-bomb because they used the actual full word. They told the judge ``We are going to smash your effing windows and we're going to drag you out of your effing car if you don't turn over this intern to us.'' And then they grabbed the intern, and they took the him into another car for half an hour and figured out that the high school intern was not the 30 plus year-old person they purported to be looking for. Why would regular law enforcement, why would those sheriffs in the courthouse want to cooperate with an agency whose legal--whose law enforcement behavior is so wildly irresponsible and unprofessional? It's hard to imagine. And when I asked Secretary Noem about the problem of deconfliction, I think pretty much everybody in law enforcement understands what deconfliction is. Even if the state police aren't cooperating with the Bristol Police, when they run in to do a raid in Bristol, they will let the Bristol police know that they're going to do a raid so that when calls come in about cars in the street or people with guns or whatever, the local police department know what's going on. Deconfliction is elementary stuff that is taught to law enforcement, and yet ICE refuses to deconflict and the secretary didn't know the difference between deconfliction and cooperation. So clearly there's a massive hole in the way in which DHS thinks about this stuff, and it is in that environment that I think a lot of sensible decisions are being made by local police chiefs, about whether they want to cooperate with an organization that behaves in unreasonable and unprofessional ways, that threatens judges with violence and that refuses to even give them the courtesy of deconflicting when they're operating in their jurisdiction. Thank you, Chairman. Chairman Graham. Thank you. Senator Cornyn. STATEMENT OF SENATOR CORNYN Senator Cornyn. Well Mr. Chairman, I think President Trump has done it again, exercising almost magical powers, turning Democrats into budget hawks. It's an amazing thing to behold, And of course they reflexively oppose anything and everything that he proposes, whether it's standing to honor law enforcement and public safety and not illegal immigrants, whether it's eliminating the threat of nuclear weapons and the number one state sponsor of terrorism. They take the side of the state sponsor of terrorism. It's just amazing to me to behold. Sheriff, I was struck by the Ranking Member's introduction to his comments. He said let the police be the police, and I assume that would extend to other law enforcement officers like you and the sheriffs and other folks who maintain public safety. But is the collective role and job of law enforcement officers like yourself to protect public safety? Hon. Chapman. It is, and I think we all need to work together. One of the things that was just left out of the testimony just provided is the fact that communication is important to this, and we work very well with our counterparts. And a lot of times it's because of the chiefs are driven by the politicians above them, that don't allow them to actually work properly and cooperatively with our federal and other local counterparts. When you have that level of communication, you can work these issues out in advance before you have a problem like, you know, what the Senator was just saying. Senator Cornyn. Well, a lot of it boils down to information-sharing; correct? Hon. Chapman. That's correct. Senator Cornyn. And even where in the Senator Whitehouse's Circuit, the judges said that maybe local law enforcement can't keep people beyond their jail sentence without some other additional warrant. Let me ask you to go out on a limb here a little bit. If the two individuals who tragically died in Minneapolis, who interfered with law enforcement operation by ICE, if there had been the kind of cooperation that you demonstrate in Loudoun County and the sort of cooperation that you've advocated for here, do you think it's like more likely than not that those two individuals will still be alive? Hon. Chapman. Well, I can't really speak directly to that. What I can tell you is that the cooperation that we've had actually works well, and I do believe that that would have had an impact there. When you're talking about 287(g) and again, Senator Whitehouse's information, we have an agreement with ICE and our people are trained in order to hold onto people for a little bit up to 48 hours after they're incarcerated for a completely separate offense with us, okay. Senator Cornyn. That's a memorandum of understanding between the feds and the local law enforcement? Hon. Chapman. That's right. And that way they're already in custody. All we got to do is turn them over. They don't only have to come to the community to do--very often to do any enforcement operations. So it actually works out well. And to get on the front side of this and to have that level of communication prevents that kind of thing. But if you have politicians that are directing you to act in a particular way it really, you know, really messes up the system here, and I think that's largely the problem. We all want to work together. We work with everybody. All of our federal counterparts, all of our state and local counterparts, which I believe is one of the reasons we got one of the lowest crime rates in the entire country. Senator Cornyn. And you have--as a result of that cooperation, you haven't experienced any of the tragic consequences that we saw in Minneapolis? Hon. Chapman. We've actually had--before that, we actually had people that were--had not been arrested by us that committed crimes. But anybody that's been arrested by us and turned over to ICE is not a problem. They're out of our hands. Senator Cornyn. And Mr. Wolf, you were of course former Secretary of Homeland Security, and our Democratic colleagues say that they won't fund the Department of Homeland Security and alleviate these long waiting periods that citizens are experiencing at airports all around the country. They won't fund the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), until federal warrants are required. Now will you explain how a final order of deportation is a civil matter, and that requiring after that due process has already been exhausted why requiring a criminal warrant would be not only unnecessary, but also destructive of ICE's ability to actually enforce immigration law? Hon. Wolf. Absolutely. An alien will go before an immigration judge through--towards the end of their pendency of their hearing. They will go before an immigration judge and they will rule on their case. If they want to appeal that, they'll go to the Immigration Board of Appeals and they could perhaps even appeal that outside of that. And in every case a judge, through the due process, they'll have an attorney with them through the due process, says you don't have a legal right to remain in the United States and it's time for you to self deport. It's time for you to leave. And we know, as I indicated earlier, about 1.6 million of those individuals have said ``No. I'm going to defy that order. I'm going to stay here in the United States. I don't want to go back to my home country.'' And then ICE is coming in at the very end of this process, enforcement removal officers, to effectuate that judge's order, to understand and to remove that individual from the country. And in some cases, they are in their house, and so they have a final order of removal. They have reasonable suspicion that that individual is in that house. They have likely observed that individual go in and out of that house, and they are there to remove that individual. It's very different than a judicial warrant, where you're just going into arrest someone who's then going into the due process system, has to go before a judge, have their case heard, all the facts. That is not as what is occurring when you have a final order of removal. Senator Cornyn. Thank you. Chairman Graham. Senator Lujan. STATEMENT OF SENATOR LUJAN Senator Lujan. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Everyone, thank y'all for being here today. And I just want to begin by reminding everyone this is the first hearing of the Budget Committee in this Congress. This is the first one, 13 months into this Congress. Oh, you're saying second, sir? I appreciate that, Chairman. Second. Voice. What was the first one? Senator Lujan. Look. When we talk about what's happening to constituents across the country right now, you'd think there'd be some hearings about the high cost of everything. They're detainers, 287. I certainly hope we get to that place. But since we're here today and we're not talking about the high cost of groceries or how expensive it's to get a birthday cake for your kids, gas prices through the roof, housing unaffordable, my Republican colleagues want to have a conversation about the One Big Beautiful Bill that they passed, which by the way we've now learned from the Congressional Budget Office that the legislation increased the federal deficit by $3.4 trillion. Trillion. That's a lot of money, while failing to provide real relief to middle and low income families. So, look. The proposal's tied to the package and its broader agenda included cuts to programs like food, like SNAP, providing support to millions of working families just to put food on the table. So as we sit here in the Senate Budget Committee, yes or no, and my question is to Mr. Duke. Does focusing federal attention on punishing so-called Sanctuary Cities meaningfully address the affordability crisis Americans are facing? Mr. Duke. No. Senator Lujan. Does it lower health costs for a child with diabetes? Mr. Duke. No. Senator Lujan. Does it make the gas that people put at a gas station into their vehicles more affordable to get to work, or does it make it more expensive? Mr. Duke. It has nothing to do with gas. Senator Lujan. Does it help a single mom afford to put food on the table? Mr. Duke. No. Senator Lujan. Does it address the medical solvency issues to make sure seniors can count on their benefits? Mr. Duke. It addresses them by making them worse. Senator Lujan. Does it help a young couple who wants to buy a home and start a family maybe afford that house? Mr. Duke. It does not help. Senator Lujan. Well, what the hearing discusses does not include anything that I just asked about, and the constituents I've been talking to at home are saying when's Congress going to get off their rears and do something about the prices that we're hitting every day, as opposed to just protecting the Epstein class and not demanding that these documents and everything else get released? So Mr. Wolf, you had responsibilities in a few of these places, and I appreciate the responses you were providing to one of my colleagues now about the process that you believe is fair, that allows ICE agents to go into someone's house without a judicial warrant. I just--it's hard for me to continue to listen to justification on how American citizens can have their homes broken into without a judicial warrant. I don't understand this, that American citizens, it's okay for an American citizen to have their windows on their car bashed in. That's not okay, and with all these conversations about Artificial Intelligence (AI) and some of these companies now that are working with ICE for facial recognition, which I have concerns about, what I don't understand now is how the Department of Homeland Security has access to the best facial recognition, AI. DHS says they know who the violent criminals are. Their words. They say they know who they are. And if they only had access to facial recognition, they could go find all the violent criminals. Well, why aren't they doing it? It's one unanswered question after another. It's one American right after another that is being torn apart, and there's justification now to say we can pound in your door. We can go in your house if you're an American citizen, or we can bust out your windows and drag your butt out of a car as an American citizen. I just don't get it, Mr. Chairman, and I hope we have some hearings about getting answers to that, because I think there's agreement between Democrats and Republicans on this issue. We don't want American citizens being treated this way. None of us. We want to go after the violent criminals. We both agree with this. I certainly hope that we can have a thorough and thoughtful hearing and get some answers to that as well, and that everyone agrees, stop doing that. Mr. President, tell your folks to stop doing that. I hope now that Senator Mullin, who's going to be Secretary of Health or Homeland Security, maybe he'll get these people to stop all the bad shit and to go after the bad people. Then we'll be in a better place. Thank you for the time, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Graham. Thank you. Yeah. We'll have a hearing on affordability and Ms. Vaughan, what percentage of a legal immigrants in Sanctuary Cities or just in general receive federal benefits? Ms. Vaughan. I don't have numbers for specific Sanctuary jurisdictions. Chairman Graham. Yeah, just in general. Ms. Vaughan. but nationally, it's more than 60 percent---- Chairman Graham. So more than 60 percent of illegal immigrants receive federal benefits, and it has absolutely no budget impact. Well, that's interesting. Senator Lee. STATEMENT OF SENATOR LEE Senator Lee. Thank you Mr. Chairman for holding this hearing. Thanks to each of you for being here. I want to say at the outset a couple of things. First, I'm not familiar with many countries that are asked to simply ignore their own immigration laws, separate and apart from their criminal laws, just their own immigration laws. Those countries that do exist or may have existed over time don't remain countries very long, because things happen when you don't enforce your own immigration laws. We don't have to travel very far in our own continent or throughout Europe or Asia or Africa, to see what would happen if one of us entered one of those countries, took up residence there unlawfully. It likely wouldn't end well for us. I also want to observe that there's been several mentions here today about the difference between state authority and federal authority in reference to state's rights. I don't like using the term state rights, not only because it conjures George Wallace's image, also because it's inappropriate. States don't have rights. Individuals have rights. States have authority. It's the inverse polar opposite of a right. We have parallel authority with parallel sovereign jurisdictions in this country. The U.S. government, the one headquartered in this city where we sit today, has authority over our immigration laws, laws governing naturalization. Who may enter the country, who may stay, under what terms and conditions or for what period of time. We do need our federal government to be able to undertake those efforts, to perform those efforts well. We've adopted a number of techniques to procure and encourage the cooperation of state and local jurisdictions. Sometimes those have been ignored, and that is unfortunate. I'll get more to that in a moment. But look, we're exploring something today that is not without cost. The cost of an unsecured border, an unprecedented illegal immigration during the four years of the Biden administration, remain both stunning and debilitating. The Trump administration, for its part, quite fortunately has done a very effective job at securing the border and beginning the process of deportations on a very large scale. But there's a lot of work left to be done to deport the many millions who remain in this country, for us to be able to restore law and order, people who if they did immigrate to almost any other country on Earth, would be in a whole lot of trouble and would be facing those things. And yet we're made to feel as if we would be doing the wrong thing by enforcing our immigration laws as such. That important work that's being done carried out every day by brave men and women in federal law enforcement, continues to be obstructed across the country, as radical leftists, who are proudly, aggressively supporting Sanctuary Cities, are trying to try to undermine the enforcement of federal law. These Democrat-controlled state and local governments have, in many instances, been working actively, aggressively through these Sanctuary City policies to subvert not just federal law, but the enforcement of federal law by duly sworn and authorized federal law enforcement officials. And they are trying to do one thing by enforcing the law, which is to prioritize the well-being of American citizens and the safety of the American homeland. This terrible reality that we face is highly offensive to the citizens of the United States, especially those who have done the work to immigrate to this country legally and to do it the right way. Now believe it or not, not that long ago, Democrats supported and President Clinton himself signed into law the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act, commonly known as IIRIRA. That Act in expanded border enforcement capabilities and helped bring immigration under control at a time when illegal immigration to the United States was far less frequent, far less of a large problem than it has been in recent years. In 2016, President Trump ran for President and was elected on a promise to stop illegal immigration. Democrats intending to oppose the President at every turn decided to depart in that moment from their previous, more common sense position, and to go all in on the belief that our nation should effectively have no border at all, that borders are sort of aspirational suggestions that we can look the other way on. That brings us to the topic of today's hearing, the cost of Sanctuary Cities. So what is that cost? Well, the cost is clear. It is waste, fraud and abuse by illegal aliens who shouldn't be within our borders. We saw this in Minnesota and we've seen it elsewhere. The cost is clear more than anything else. It's the loss of human life, innocent human life. Innocent American lives at the hands of illegal aliens, who have perpetrated some of the most heinous attacks on innocent American lives in recent memory. And these are entirely preventable, entirely avoidable crimes, crimes that would not have happened but for our open border policies facilitated by Sanctuary Cities. The cost is clear. It's also the increased additional avoidable tax burden on state, local and federal taxpayers, who are expected to subsidize and in fact are forced to subsidize problematic social welfare programs that illegal aliens have obtained eligibility for through fraudulent means or various loopholes, to say nothing of the education system, which because of a Supreme Court ruling in Plyler v. Doe four and a half decades ago, states are also forced, by no choice of their own, to supply that additional benefit as well. So, look. The cost is clear. It's all over the place. We can't ignore it, and by continuing to ignore it, we create additional problems. Let's not dress this up as something that it is not and never can be. Thank you. Chairman Graham. Mr. Padilla. STATEMENT OF SENATOR PADILLA Mr. Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to echo the sentiment that several of my colleagues have mentioned earlier in this hearing, in more than just being surprised that this is well, I guess the second hearing for this Congress, but the first of this calendar year. It is not about the federal budget, not about an economic outlook. But I understand why the Republican majority wouldn't want to talk about that, not while gas prices are spiking because of an unauthorized war against Iran. Instead, we're here to discuss how off base this whole Sanctuary conversation really is. Now I know it's an area of passion for the Chairman. We've debated Sanctuary policies on the floor of the Senate. As I've objected to the legislation he has presented that would promote federal overreach, in my opinion. I think part of my frustration comes from the fact that there's a fundamental misunderstanding about what Sanctuary policies are and what Sanctuary policies are not. Sanctuary policies do not mean that there are no laws in Sanctuary cities or states. They do not keep ICE and other federal agencies from entering a city or a state to arrest violent criminals as they're released from prison. Sanctuary policy simply affirm that immigration enforcement is the job of the federal government, and that the federal government cannot unilaterally decide to co-opt state and local authorities or their resources, precious resources in carrying out these responsibilities. True, there's some states and local jurisdictions who may choose to coordinate, collaborate, but there's many who don't for their justifiable reasons. It means carrying out immigration enforcement activities is ICE's purview, while respecting state and local law enforcement agencies to make their own decisions about how to focus and direct their limited resources that they deem best protects and serves their constituents. It means prohibiting federal overreach through policies that have been upheld by the courts. And so I'm glad several of my Republican colleagues are here to listen me to me quote Justice Scalia in the case Prince v. United States. ``The federal government may neither issue directives, require the states to address particular problems, nor command the states'' officers or those of their political subdivisions to administer or enforce a federal regulatory program.'' Look, folks. We can have disagreements on policy, but the fundamental misunderstanding about what Sanctuary policies are has led to the promotion of enforcement actions across the country that have become damaging to our communities and to our local economies. So it seems to me that this debate has not really been about public safety, because if it were, we could also be talking about how the data shows that Sanctuary policies actually make communities safer, healthier and more prosperous. That's right. The evidence shows, the research shows Sanctuary jurisdictions have lower crime rates, higher meeting household income, less poverty, less reliance on public assistance, higher labor force participation and lower unemployment. That's right. Seems like Sanctuary cities are helping to make America great. I said it. So let's stop perpetuating the lies. Let's ensure that ICE and United States Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents are accountable and conduct their jobs in accordance with the law and the Constitution. Let's allow local law enforcement leaders to do what they deem is best for public safety. And Mr. Chairman, just so you know that I'm not exaggerating in my claims, I'd like to submit for the record articles and reports from researchers at the University of Texas-Austin, from the Center for American Progress, from the University of Arizona, University of North Carolina and the American Immigration Council.\9\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\ Documents submitted by Senator Padilla appears in the appendix on page 136. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Chairman Graham. I have no objection. Senator Padilla. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Graham. Senator Kennedy. STATEMENT OF SENATOR KENNEDY Senator Kennedy. Secretary Wolf, thank you for your service. Why in your opinion do so many, not all, but so many of my Democratic colleagues believe in open borders? Hon. Wolf. Well, that's a good question. I think it's a couple of different fronts. One, it would be they don't believe in immigration law. They don't like enforcement, they don't like removing of individuals. Senator Kennedy. What else? Hon. Wolf. And they believe that--there are some that believe that anyone and everyone should be able to come to the U.S., whether they apply for protections under what else U.S. law or not. Senator Kennedy. What else? Hon. Wolf. And then there are some probably that would like to see more voters in the U.S. as well. Senator Kennedy. Ms. Vaughan, some of my colleagues for whom I have great respect, believe that the 10th Amendments, the 10th Amendment allows local governments to ignore federal immigration law and implement Sanctuary policy. The Supreme Court has ruled that racial quotas represent a pernicious form of racial discrimination. Can local governments ignore that ruling under the 10th Amendment? Ms. Vaughan. Well, the 10th Amendment is about---- Senator Kennedy. And can they--answer my question, please. Ms. Vaughan. The 10th Amendment is about commandeering, and so it's not really appropriate to this because---- Senator Kennedy. Is the answer yes or no, ma'am? Ms. Vaughan. Could you ask me again because I don't understand the relevance to--I'm sorry, because ICE is not asking them---- Senator Kennedy. Secretary Wolf, you heard my question. Under the guise of the 10th Amendment, can local governments ignore Supreme Court ruling? Hon. Wolf. I don't believe they can. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Women have the right to vote in America by statute and by Constitutional interpretation. Under the guise of the 10th Amendment, can local governments just ignore that and prohibit women from voting? Hon. Wolf. No. Senator Kennedy. Mr. Duke, you worked for President Biden and Vice President Harris, didn't you? Mr. Duke. Yes. Senator Kennedy. And I listened carefully to your testimony today. You expressed--well, you offered the opinion that the One Big Beautiful Bill is terrible in part because it will cause deficits. Is that, is that right? Mr. Duke. Yes. Senator Kennedy. Isn't it a fact that the profligacy of President Biden caused nine percent inflation in America? Mr. Duke. No. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Isn't it a fact that if President Biden had discovered life on Mars when he was president, he would have immediately sent it money? Mr. Duke. I don't believe so. Senator Kennedy. Oh, you don't? Okay. Well, I appreciate your newly found fiscal conservatism. Mr. Bier, you seem to be a very smart guy and you seem to be a nice enough guy. Mr. Bier. Thank you, Senator. You seem smart as well. Chairman Graham. I object. [Laughter] Senator Kennedy. Don't, don't you---- Mr. Bier. That was the Chairman, not me. Senator Kennedy. Don't you think your hyperbolic statements undermine your credibility? Mr. Bier. What hyperbolic statement did I make? Senator Kennedy. On February the 11th, 2026, you posted on Bluesky, quote--my words or your words, not mine. ``The Democrats'' video telling service members to ignore illegal orders didn't go far enough. They should have also urged them to refuse unethical orders, whether illegal or not. There are many things deemed legal that are still obviously unethical and everyone should hold themselves to this higher law.'' Did I read that correctly? Mr. Bier. I believe you did. Do you disagree with it? Do you think people should do unethical things in their capacity as---- Senator Kennedy. On December the 31st of 2025, you posted to in front of---- Mr. Bier. But wait, wait. Do you disagree with---- Senator Kennedy. But wait, let me finish my question, sir. In front of God and country. You said ``They,'' referring to Republicans, ``think they can troll their way into us accepting ethnic cleansing.'' Your words, not mine. Did I read that correctly? Mr. Bier. That was in regard to a Department of Homeland Security---- Senator Kennedy. Did I read that correctly? Mr. Bier [continuing]. Post about advocating 100 million deportations. That is what DHS has tweeted from their own account.---- Senator Kennedy. Truth hurts, doesn't it? Mr. Bier [continuing]. 100 million deportations would be ethnic cleansing. You would be removing---- Senator Kennedy. Truth hurts, doesn't it? Mr. Bier [continuing]. One-third of the country. So yes, there are people within the Department of Homeland Security---- Senator Kennedy. Truth can just gut you like a fish. And you don't think this is hyperbolic? Give me 30 more seconds. Mr. Bier. I think advocating 100 million deportations is ethnic cleansing. Senator Kennedy. I'm having fun, Mr. Chairman. On February 5th, you said the following on Bluesky. Mr. Bier. Your time is up. Senator Kennedy. ``These are all good. But there's no enforcement mechanism.'' I'm sorry. Let me try a better one. On March 2nd, you said ``If you rule against Trump's population purge agenda,'' no hyperbole there, ``The nativists will name you, threaten you and come after you. These judges are much braver than the ICE agents who hide behind masks while violating the Constitution.'' Mr. Bier. They are much braver. They put their names on their rulings, and they stand behind their Constitutional rulings. When I talk about population purge, I'm talking about the fact that they're trying to deport U.S.-born citizens, people born here. They are trying to deport them as well. So it's not a mass deportation agenda. It is also an agenda intended to reduce the population of the United States, including U.S.-born people---- Chairman Graham. Thank, thank you. Mr. Bier [continuing]. So these are not hyperbolic statements. I appreciate you reading my account. I appreciate your concerns. Senator Kennedy. What planet did you just---- Chairman Graham. Wait, wait, wait. Senator Kennedy. Wait a minute, Mr. Chairman. What planet did you just parachute from? Chairman Graham. No, no, no. Hey guys. Senator Kennedy. You trigger my gag reflex, Mr. Bier. Chairman Graham. So we got a process here, and it's good to know you don't have an agenda. Senator Kaine. STATEMENT OF SENATOR KAINE Senator Kaine. Mr. Chair, thanks for doing this, and Sheriff, welcome. I've got a Virginian at the table and that's why I wanted to come. My sheriff in his testimony said ``It is important to distinguish criminal aliens who pose a threat to our community from immigrants here legally.'' All of us agree with that. We should try to find that balance. I don't think we're balanced right now. I've been here 13 years. I wish we'd have a hearing about the positive impact immigrants make on the United States. We've never had that hearing in this Committee or the Health, Education, Labor and Pension (HELP) Committee or any others. When we have hearings, it's about immigrants doing bad things rather than about---- Chairman Graham. When y'all were in charge, why didn't you have them? Senator Kaine. Well, can I take my time? Can I take my time? Because I think what happens, I think what happens---- Chairman Graham. You get a whole minute more. Senator Kaine [continuing]. When the only hearings about immigrants are about crime, and we have a President who calls people's countries shithole countries. I got a lot of immigrants in the United States and in Virginia who feel like they're being targeted. And let's talk about positives. I'm going to use Loudoun as an example. The sheriff is rightly proud of Loudoun County. 420,000 people in the last census. It's probably coming up to 450 now. It is not only one of the safest jurisdictions in the United States, it's also by recent count the wealthiest county in the United States. And guess what? 25 percent of the population and climbing is immigrant. 25 percent. Safe, economically successful immigrant. And I also applaud this Sheriff's Department. If you have something to do or if you don't have something to do on Halloween sometime, go to the Halloween parade in Leesburg and you'll see the Sheriff's deputies helping order and they all wear uniforms with their names on them. None of them wear masks. The county's been an innovator in body camera, in body camera use. Wow. What a novel concept. I like the professionalism that I see with your Sheriff's Department, and I think we could use it at the federal level. Here's an issue about Sanctuary Cities in the Trump administration. DHS--Mr. Chair, you might like this one. DHS in May put out a list of Sanctuary cities and they included 34 Virginia communities, cities and counties on that list. It provoked laughter in Virginia. There were cities that were not cities but counties. There were counties that were not counties, but cities. There were jurisdictions that have virtually no immigrants whatsoever listed as Sanctuary communities. Here was my favorite, the city of Duffield, Virginia. Now, if you don't know where Duffield is, you're not alone. Scott County, deep in Appalachia, 0.6 square miles, 76 people, not a single immigrant, not even a police department. Sanctuary City. Virginia laughed the DHS out of the office. And so in October, this was in August. I'm sorry, this was in May. In August, United States Department of Justice (DOJ) came back and did a new list, number of Sanctuary Cities in Virginia, zero. They redid the list in October. Number of Sanctuary Cities in Virginia, zero. Mr. Chair, I'd like to introduce DHS's bogus Sanctuary Cities list into the record.\10\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\ Document submitted by Senator Kaine appears in the appendix on page 132. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Chairman Graham. Without objection. Senator Kaine. And then Mr. Chair, my last question is, look. I'm not on Judiciary, and the bill that you have about imposing liability on local officials would suggest that the only fault in this area lies on local officials. Now if you have a markup, it'll be in Judiciary. And I'm not on it, but my question is sort of for you. Isn't what's good for the goose, good for the gander? What about all the times when I was governor of Virginia, 2006-2010, and my DOC, Department of Corrections or local law enforcement, told ICE and the federal immigration agencies, three years under President Bush, one year under President Obama that ``Hey, we've got somebody here who is not lawfully here. Please come pick them up, and ICE didn't show up.'' And ICE still is not showing up. So often the bad examples, including one of the ones in Fairfax recently, repeated instances of ICE having this person in their purview, in their grasp and then letting them go. So wouldn't it be--I mean if you're going to do a bill and and blame cities for this, and try to impose liability on their local taxpayers? What about letting people sue ICE, when hard-working local officials and sheriffs let folks know ``Hey, we got folks here that, you know, are here unlawfully. Come pick them up.'' And when they don't come pick them up, shouldn't they be liable for that? Chairman Graham. Maybe that's something we could do together. Sounds like a pretty good idea to me. Be glad to work with you. I think those days were probably over with this administration. But the idea that the federal government had notice and the local community is willing to turn them over and they turned a blind eye and somebody got hurt, I would be willing definitely to create liability there. Senator Kaine. And I'll just conclude Mr. Chair and say, you know, the mayor in me, the governor in me gets mad when things like this get blamed on mayors and governors, when often it's complete dysfunction at the federal level under multiple administrations. That's the real culprit. I yield back. Chairman Graham. Right. The lawyer in me wants to hold people accountable who create problems. Senator Scott. STATEMENT OF SENATOR SCOTT Senator Scott. Thank you, Chairman. Thanks for holding this important hearing. The United States is a nation of law and order. Those two things go hand in hand because when you have laws that are obeyed, you have order in your communities. But for too long, liberal states and cities have decided to simply ignore the federal laws they don't agree with. When I was the governor of Florida, I didn't have to worry about our sheriffs not enforcing law but President Trump and our federal law enforcement have to worry about that every day. The American people voted very clearly to secure the border. That's what the election was about, and stop illegal immigration we're a country of legal immigration, not illegal immigration. And without a single new law being enacted, President Trump has delivered and secured the border when President Biden said he couldn't do it. President Trump and the heroic men and women of our ICE and border patrol are enforcing our laws and they're securing our nation and the crime rate is down. But some Americans say no, we won't follow federal law. We want to be a Sanctuary for people who broke the law to enter our country illegally. It is a violation. It's against the law to come into our country illegally, like most countries. It's dangerous. It's costly to the American taxpayer and has horrific consequences. That's why I and my colleague on this Committee, Senator Moreno, have introduced two bills to curb this kind of dangerous disregard for the law. Our unifying American Security Interest Act and Sanctuary Jurisdiction Event Security Enhancement Act, which stopped DHS funding grants and financial assistance from going to cities and jurisdictions that refuse to support our ICE and DHS agents in their efforts to keep our streets safe. Americans clearly don't want their tax dollars used for handouts to illegal aliens for health care or food stamps while we have American citizens here at home who are going without. And that's exact kind of waste and financial mismanagement that these bills will stop. But that's just the financial cost. Let's talk about the human costs. Laken Riley, a nursing student, 22 years old in Georgia was beaten with a rock and strangled by a Venezuelan illegal alien, who had been caught at the border and released under Biden's Open Borders rules. Rachel Morin, 37 of Maryland, a mother of five who was raped and murdered while hiking by a Salvadorian criminal alien who crossed our border illegally, not once, not twice, but three times under Biden. Kate Steinle, 32, died in her father's arms on a San Francisco pier after being shot by a five-time Mexican deportee, who was allowed to roam freely because the city's Sanctuary policy led local officials to ignore an ICE detainer. These are just a few of the many lives cut short in the potential unrealized lives because of Biden's Open Borders, that allowed dangerous people to come into this country, and the Sanctuary Cities that chose to support and encourage these criminals. I'm from Florida. We are an immigration state, legal immigration. We don't support illegal immigration. Sheriff Chapman, my question. How can open borders and lax immigration policies like a Sanctuary Cities be considered humane by Democrats if they fail to protect the very citizens, Democrats and other elected officials are meant to serve, and they're under oath of office to serve. Hon. Chapman. Well, I agree with that. I mean the most important thing is for us to keep safety, keep our people safe and we've got to do everything in our power, and that includes working with everybody. I make that point all the time to my constituents, saying ``Look. We want to work with all of our federal counterparts. We all have different missions here, different cogs in the wheel. But we all have to work together to keep everybody safe.'' Senator Scott. Is it better for you if you turn somebody, a criminal over to ICE, rather than let them back into the community? Hon. Chapman. Absolutely, absolutely. Senator Scott. Mr. Wolf, in Sanctuary Cities, local authorities can decline ICE detainers, which means that criminals are released back in the community rather than transferred safely into ICE custody. This creates opportunities for illegal fugitives to relocate or re-offend, like in the tragic murder of Kate Steinle. It also forces DHS officers to go into neighborhoods to root out violent criminals. Not only does this cost the taxpayer more; it also increases the risk for everyone involved, including bystanders, DHS officers and potential future victims. How do these policies prioritize offenders over American victims by obstructing deportations? Hon. Wolf. Well, when ICE is required to go into a community, out on the streets, right, instead of going into that jail setting and picking up that criminal illegal alien; it'll take one or two officers to go into a jail setting. If they have to go into their neighborhood, it's going to take 15 to 20 officers to apprehend that same individual. You're putting not only the officers at risk, you're putting that alien at risk and you're putting others in that community at risk. So the idea here, and it's an ironic kind of play here, is that individuals and politicians that want less ICE in their jurisdictions, they will give them Sanctuary policies to say ``We want ICE out.'' But in fact, it just requires them to be more in their communities because they won't go into a jail setting. They have to go into their neighborhoods. They have to continue to enforce immigration law. So if your idea is I want to see less ICE in my community, I don't like immigration enforcement, let them into your jail. Let them pick up those criminal illegal aliens. Otherwise, they're going to be out on your streets because they have to continue to enforce immigration law. And of course, it's better with local law enforcement support and cooperation. But again, in many jurisdictions, Sanctuary jurisdictions, we don't see that either. Senator Scott. Thank you, Chairman. Chairman Graham. Senator Moreno. STATEMENT OF SENATOR MORENO Senator Moreno. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A quick question for all of you. You can just do a very simple if it's okay, yes or no. I'm going to try to ask it as a simple yes or no question. Are you familiar with U.S.C. 1325? Hon. Wolf. Yes. Hon. Chapman. No. Ms. Vaughan. Yes. Mr. Bier. Yes. Mr. Duke. No. Senator Moreno. You're not. Okay. So the law passed the 1952 is the Immigration and Naturalization Act (INA). It talked about how the country controls immigration. Mr. Wolf, we'll start with you. Do you think that we made a mistake passing that law, that prohibits people from entering this country illegally? Hon. Wolf. No, I don't think that's a mistake. Senator Moreno. Sheriff, do you believe we made a mistake passing that law? Hon. Chapman. No, I don't think so. Senator Moreno. Ms. Vaughan? Ms. Vaughan. No. Senator Moreno. Mr. Bier? Mr. Bier. It was a mistake to not let them come legally. That's what we need. Senator Moreno. But that's not what the law said. The law said you can't enter the country illegally. Was that a---- Mr. Bier. There were definitely mistakes in the INA, many mistakes. Senator Moreno. Was that part--don't be cute. Was that part of the law a mistake, yes or no? Mr. Bier. The part of the law that says you can't come legally? Yes, that was a mistake. Senator Moreno. That was a mistake, that you can't come illegally? Mr. Bier. No, legally. Legally is what I said. Senator Moreno. Okay. So you haven't answered to my question. But that's okay. You're a smug guy and that's part of your shtick. How about you? Mr. Duke. I don't know anything about this law. Senator Moreno. Do you think it should be a crime to enter the country illegally? Mr. Duke. I don't know anything about this. I'm here to talk about budgets. Senator Moreno. Well, no, no. You don't have to--look, I'm not a lawyer. You don't have to be a lawyer. It's a simple question. Should it be a crime? I'll say it slowly. Should it be a crime to enter the United States of America illegally without permission? Mr. Duke. I don't know anything about that. Senator Moreno. Do you have a home? Mr. Duke. I rent. Senator Moreno. Do you have a place that you sleep in? Mr. Duke. Yes, correct. Okay. Should it be a crime for people to enter your home without permission? Mr. Duke. Yes. Senator Moreno. You're pretty certain on that one? Mr. Duke. Yes. Senator Moreno. Okay. But you're not sure if it's okay to enter America without permission. Which is our home, by the way. You don't know about America? Okay. Gotcha. All right. So this is the best the Democrats can come up with Mr. Chairman. I hope the Ranking Member can listen for just a second, if you don't mind. This is the best witnesses you've got? A guy who can't distinguish whether it's okay to have people enter our country illegally. Of all the millions of people that you could have chosen to testify---- Senator Merkley. To my good colleague---- Senator Moreno. Oh, let me finish. The best you have is a guy who has no idea what our immigration law is and isn't sure if somebody should enter the country illegally. Another guy is a smug guy who obviously has an agenda. And in fact, let me just ask you a question, because I was---- Senator Merkley. Maybe you can maybe stick to the facts, instead of badgering the witnesses. Senator Moreno. I'm not badgering the witnesses. Senator Merkley. Well, you're attacking them. Senator Moreno. I'm asking simple questions. Senator Merkley. Yeah, why don't you ask some actual factual questions? Senator Moreno. But why don't you do this? Why don't you speak when it's your turn? Oh, because we actually take turns. Senator Merkley. You're addressing me, so I am addressing you back. (Simultaneous discussion.) Senator Merkley. You're looking right at me. You're addressing me. Senator Moreno. Because here's what I find out ironic, is that you follow rules here about speaking order. People can't speak out of turn, but it's okay with you that people enter our country and skip their turn. See---- Senator Merkley. Oh, now you're attributing views to me I haven't expressed. Isn't that interesting? Senator Moreno. What I would love to find interesting---- Senator Merkley. Not only are you attacking the witnesses, now you're attacking your colleagues here on the dais, which I think is very inappropriate. Chairman Graham. Gentlemen, gentlemen. Wait a minute. I'm in charge. Senator Moreno. Yes, sir. Chairman Graham. You ask him a question. Senator Moreno. Yes. Chairman Graham. He'll get a chance to answer that question. Finish your time. Senator Moreno. Thank you. All right, moving on to the next question, Mr. Sheriff. How important is it for local law enforcement to cooperate with federal officials? Hon. Chapman. I can tell you it's worked for us, and it's kept our crime rate down extraordinarily low. Senator Moreno. So if somebody is in your position in Hamilton County, which is the county where Cincinnati is with the Cincinnati Chief of Police, would you advise them that you think it's helpful to cooperate with law enforcement? Hon. Chapman. Absolutely. Senator Moreno. Okay. Do you find it interesting that politicians who have no idea, no background in law enforcement, will pass laws that prohibit law enforcement to cooperate with federal officials, local law enforcement? Do you think that's a good idea? Hon. Chapman. No, it's not a good idea. Senator Moreno. It's a terrible idea. Do you have death threats against your sheriff deputies on a regular basis? Hon. Chapman. We get threats. Not that often, but we do. Senator Moreno. Constant, constant death threats or do you get constant? Hon. Chapman. Not constant death threats, but we do get threats, yes. Senator Moreno. Do you have drug cartels that have bounties out for your deputies? Hon. Chapman. No. No, we don't. Senator Moreno. Do you get your agent's doxed, where they go to your agent's--your deputies' homes and threaten their children and their wives and their kids? Hon. Chapman. No, we have not. Senator Moreno. Do you get politicians that call your deputies Gestapo and Nazis? Hon. Chapman. We've had certainly politicians, not locally here, but certainly we've had a lot of people in the community that have said that. Senator Moreno. Do you find any of that helpful when talking about law enforcement agencies? Because see, here's the irony. What we're disparaging is the people whose job it is to enforce the laws. And I find it extraordinarily interesting that the people in charge of making these laws are disparaging the people who are enforcing those laws. And I wonder and I'll ask for the record if the minority witnesses could just sign an affidavit that they have not received any money, and the organization that they work for or participate in from any organizations tied to the Mexican drug cartels, which would have an absolute incentive to have illegal migration at the levels that we saw under Biden? Chairman Graham. If you have any reason---- Mr. Bier. We haven't accepted any drug cartel money. Senator Moreno. Again, if they could just put that in affidavit or an affiliated organization. Chairman Graham. You okay, Mr. Duke? Mr. Duke. I'd like to look at the affidavit. Chairman Graham. Okay, fair enough. But do you know if you've accepted any money? Mr. Duke. I do not know of anything like that. Chairman Graham. Right. Yeah, sure. Okay. Thank you. All right. So good hearing. Senator Merkley, I'll let you go first. I'll have a few words, then we'll go vote. Senator Merkley. Well, let's start with the Gang of Eight that my colleague referred to from 2013. Democrats and Republicans came together, four and four. They crafted a bill on immigration. It was all about the rule of law on the border. Democrats and Republicans together saying the rule of law matters, and it addressed many of the immigration challenges that we have in different sectors, be it employment, agriculture, a path to citizenship for people who'd been here a long time, a path to citizenship for Dreamers, Democrats and Republicans together. So one of the myths we've heard today from some of my colleagues is that Democrats don't support the rule of law. Absolutely wrong. What happened to that 2013 bill that went over to the House of Representatives controlled by Republicans, they would not even hold a hearing on it. They wanted to keep an open sore of immigration as a political issue. In 2024, Democrats and Republican Senate came together again, crafted a deal and it was President Trump as a candidate who said ``Don't do it. I want to keep immigration as an election issue.'' So I just think it would be more productive if we quit casting aspersions across the aisle, and go back to the philosophy of 2013 and work together to actually get a bill done, or the philosophy of 2024. And certainly all of us agree in going after violent criminals. That's the second myth that was presented today that people don't support going after violent criminals. Absolutely a myth, and it's just irritating to continuously hear that. Myth number three from one of my colleagues was that Democrats won't fund FEMA. In fact, last week in the Senate we asked unanimous consent to fund FEMA and the Coast Guard and Transportation Security Administration (TSA), and it was the Republicans that objected. So let's clear up that piece. The next myth, that is that undocumented individuals receive benefits. It is illegal under the law for undocumented individuals to receive Medicaid or Medicare or Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) or SNAP or Social Security benefits. Another myth, that states that have decided that local police are more effective being local police, somehow attract immigrants because they're not held accountable to the law. They are held accountable to the law. In fact, you have lower crime rates in those states. So that's kind of interesting. And in fact, we see that some states like Texas, they have 50 percent more undocumented immigrants as a ratio of population than Oregon does. So clearly it's not Oregon's policies that say we're more effective and safer and more prosperous when ICE does ICE and local police do local police work. And yet another myth. One of my colleagues across the aisle said ``States do not have powers.'' He says they do not have rights. But they do have powers, the 10th Amendment. The powers not delegated to the U.S. by the Constitution are reserved to the states and to the people. And that is why the federal government cannot commandeer individuals in the states to do federal responsibilities. It's called the Constitution of the United States of America. Another myth was that it's less safe in states where local police do local police work. There's many statistics that show the opposite of that. But let's just take for example, where is the highest murder rate in America? Is it in a state where local police are assigned to local police? No. It's Mississippi. Who's the second highest murder rate? Louisiana. How is the murder rate in Oregon? It is one-fourth of what is in those states. So let's be clear again. This myth that you have higher crime rates in places where the local police gain the trust of the people, work carefully between state and local and with federal officials, but they don't do the work of ICE. And if ICE knows that someone is in a jail, and they know because it's in the federal database and the FBI database and they want that person, it only takes a couple days to go get a judicial warrant and pick that person up. Every time there's a judicial warrant, that person is held. So if it's just being lazy or sloppy or whatever else, there's a whole lot of misinformation coming forward here that needed to be corrected. Chairman Graham. Well, thank you very much. I have a different view of things. I really appreciate the hearing. Obama deported three million people. I don't think all of them were criminals. They didn't use judicial warrants. What you're trying to do is make it impossible to deport people. If you have to go to a judge and get a judicial warrant to deport somebody, you effectively destroy the ability to deport. You're denying Trump the same system you are giving Obama. This hearing to me is stunning. I'm so glad we had it. You're all in on Sanctuary City policy. If you're looking to America, if you're looking for anybody to change this system, our Democratic friends have no interest. They think it's good for America. The more illegal immigrants, the better. I don't. I'd like to have a rational immigration system. Gang of Eight. I was involved in it. What we tried to do is stop future flow and the trade-off was to give people a pathway to citizenship, knowing you would stop future flow. You're right. The House blocked the bill during 20 to 2020--from 2020 to 2024, Joe Biden destroyed every concept of rational immigration. He made it impossible for a Republican to sit down and talk with a Democrat, because during his four years, he took every rule and ignored it. There are no taxpayer dollars associated with legal immigrants. They were flown into the country on airplanes. They were bussed in, they were fed, they were given housing. 11 million people are not living in the streets. They're in some apartment or a house somewhere, and if you don't think that affects housing, that's crazy. 11 million people came at least in a four-year period, and to hear you say it, no impact on this country, that's just absurd. So what are we going to do? We're going to try to start with the magnets. If you don't think Sanctuary City policy is a magnet for future illegal immigration, that's just insane. How can you fix it if you don't take the magnets off the table? The bottom line is I want a vote on my bill to hold local and state officials accountable for violating federal law, when they should enforce it like they did during Obama, and you won't let me have a vote. You won't let me have the debate. The reason you don't want to vote is because 70 to 80 percent of the American public think the policies you're pushing are harmful. There is a budget impact to being overrun in a country in a four-year period. To think this is not a problem is insulting to the American people. It is a problem, and you try to rationalize it and make it a good thing. It's not a good thing. It's a bad thing. At the end of the day, if you can't answer the question ``It should be a crime to come into the country illegally,'' that says all you really need to know about the people here. Of course it should be. It should be a crime as Senator Moreno said, to go in your house without being invited. We cannot have a sovereign nation when people just show up and come in and go anywhere they want to go. That's just not rational. We've got more people on the terrorist watch list than we've ever had, 2,700 percent. The people who have come here are all not well-meaning. I understand immigration pretty well. I understand the need to fix it. The American people want to be fair. But Senator Merkley, they're not going to buy into a system that constantly allows people to come in unchecked. Once you can prove to them you've stopped illegal immigration, then we could have a rational discussion about what to do with people who have been here a long time. But you've doubled or tripled the number of people. So all I'm going--all I will say, this is a debate worthy of a great nation. Our Democratic friends are accepting of a Sanctuary policy. They don't think it's a problem. I do. Let's have a debate. Let's have a vote. This will be good for the country going into 2026, as to who should be in charge of controlling our borders and enforcing law. This administration is enforcing the law.The prior administration obliterated the law. Thank you very much to all of you for coming. I appreciate your time and attention. Senator Merkley, thank you. The hearing's adjourned and oh, one second. I want to introduce a statement. Yeah, you didn't finish up. Donald Rosenberg was unable to be here. I'd like to put his statement in the record. He represents Victims of Illegal Alien Crime. Without objection I'd like to introduce this statement if that's okay. Is that okay? \11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\ Statement submitted by Chairman Graham appears in the appendix on page 107. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Senator Merkley. Yes. Chairman Graham. Thank you. I want to thank our witnesses for appearing before the Committee. You want to finish your thought? Go ahead. Senator Merkley. Mr. Bier, you have a pile of documents that you want to enter into the record. What are those documents? Chairman Graham. Without objection. Mr. Bier. These are all the studies that show that immigrants do not increase crime, and places that place restrictions on ICE cooperation are not resulting in an increase in crime.\12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\ Documents submitted by Mr. Bier appears in the appendix on page 181. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Chairman Graham. Without objection. Senator Merkley. Thank you. Chairman Graham. Okay. The hearing record will remain open until noon tomorrow for the submission of questions to the record to the Committee Clerk. The hearing is adjourned. Thank you all very, very much. (Whereupon, at 12:24 p.m., Tuesday, March 10, 2026, the hearing was adjourned.) [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]