Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-210] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-210 HOW THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT LAND USE PLANNING PROCESS UNDER THE FEDERAL LAND POLICY AND MANAGEMENT ACT AF- FECTS PERMITTING FOR ENERGY, MINING, GRAZING, AND INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS ON PUBLIC LANDS ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ NOVEMBER 19, 2025 __________ [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Printed for the use of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 61-932 WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES MIKE LEE, Utah, Chairman JOHN BARRASSO, Wyoming MARTIN HEINRICH, New Mexico JAMES E. RISCH, Idaho RON WYDEN, Oregon STEVE DAINES, Montana MARIA CANTWELL, Washington TOM COTTON, Arkansas MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii DAVID McCORMICK, Pennsylvania ANGUS S. KING, JR., Maine JAMES C. JUSTICE, West Virginia CATHERINE CORTEZ MASTO, Nevada BILL CASSIDY, Louisiana JOHN W. HICKENLOOPER, Colorado CINDY HYDE-SMITH, Mississippi ALEX PADILLA, California LISA MURKOWSKI, Alaska RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona JOHN HOEVEN, North Dakota Wendy Baig, Majority Staff Director Chris Prandoni, Majority Deputy Staff Director and Chief Counsel Sam Crofts, Majority Policy Director for Natural Resources Jasmine Hunt, Minority Staff Director Sam E. Fowler, Minority Chief Counsel Maya Hermann, Minority Natural Resources Policy Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Barrasso, Hon. John, a U.S. Senator from Wyoming................. 1 Lee, Hon. Mike, Chairman and a U.S. Senator from Utah............ 2 Heinrich, Hon. Martin, Ranking Member and a U.S. Senator from New Mexico..................................................... 3 WITNESSES Brown, Hon. Derek, Attorney General, State of Utah............... 5 Kenna, Jim, Retired State Director, Bureau of Land Management.... 14 Christensen, Micah, Natural Resource Counsel, Wyoming County Commissioners Association...................................... 24 Cramer, Adam, Chief Executive Officer, Outdoor Alliance.......... 37 Sheehan, Greg, President and CEO, Mule Deer Foundation........... 46 ALPHABETICAL LISTING AND APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED Barrasso, Hon. John: Opening Statement............................................ 1 Brown, Hon. Derek: Opening Statement............................................ 5 Written Testimony............................................ 7 Christensen, Micah: Opening Statement............................................ 24 Written Testimony............................................ 26 Cramer, Adam: Opening Statement............................................ 37 Written Testimony............................................ 39 Responses to Questions for the Record........................ 81 Digital Power Network: Statement for the Record..................................... 93 Grid Action: Statement for the Record..................................... 102 Response to DOI Request for Information, dated June 20, 2025. 106 Heinrich, Hon. Martin: Opening Statement............................................ 3 Kenna, Jim: Opening Statement............................................ 14 Written Testimony............................................ 16 Responses to Questions for the Record........................ 74 Lee, Hon. Mike: Opening Statement............................................ 2 Chart entitled ``Restrictive Land Designations''............. 51 Statement for the Record..................................... 87 Risch, Hon. James E.: Statement for the Record..................................... 92 Sheehan, Greg: Opening Statement............................................ 46 Written Testimony............................................ 48 Responses to Questions for the Record........................ 82 Western Governors' Association: Letter for the Record........................................ 113 Policy Resolution 2024-01.................................... 114 HOW THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT LAND USE PLANNING PROCESS UNDER THE FEDERAL LAND POLICY AND MANAGEMENT ACT AFFECTS PERMITTING FOR ENERGY, MINING, GRAZING, AND INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS ON PUBLIC LANDS ---------- WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2025 U.S. Senate, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:30 a.m. in Room SD-366, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Mike Lee, Chairman of the Committee, presiding. The Chairman. The Committee will come to order. Good morning and welcome to all of you. Today, we are holding a hearing on how, exactly, the Bureau of Land Management plans land use under the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, also known as FLPMA. More specifically, we will examine FLPMA's impact on how the Bureau--the BLM--issues public land permits for energy, mining, grazing, infrastructure projects, and other uses. We will be hearing from five witnesses today to consider how BLM's permitting process has become rigid, slow, and often detached from the intent Congress expressed in passing FLPMA of multiple use and sustained yield as those concepts are articulated in FLPMA itself. The witnesses include, first, the honorable Derek Brown, Attorney General of the State of Utah; second, Jim Kenna, retired California BLM State Director; third, Micah Christensen, who is Natural Resource Counsel for the Wyoming County Commissioners Association; fourth, Adam Cramer, CEO of the Outdoor Alliance; and finally, Greg Sheehan, former Utah BLM State Director, and current President and Chief Executive Officer of the Mule Deer Foundation. We are going to recognize Senator Barrasso for a moment to talk about one of these witnesses with whom he is familiar. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JOHN BARRASSO, U.S. SENATOR FROM WYOMING Senator Barrasso. Well, thanks so much, Mr. Chairman. And I do appreciate what you just said--rigid, slow, and often detached. And that has certainly been the experience that we have seen in Wyoming. And so, I am delighted that Micah Christensen is here today, and I am honored to introduce him to the Committee. He is Natural Resource Counsel for the Wyoming County Commissioners Association. He works closely with Wyoming's County Commissioners every day on federal natural resource issues. He is a seventh-generation member from Wyoming, grew up in the Bighorn Basin in Wyoming, and graduated from the University of Wyoming College of Law. Prior to joining the Wyoming County Commissioners Association, he served as Assistant Attorney General for the State of Wyoming. At that point, he represented the Wyoming Oil and Gas Conservation Commission. He now lives in Casper with his wife and his four children. Over the past few years, he has worked to defend and represent Wyoming's interests when it comes to federal land management. He has become a pivotal voice for Wyoming, and has seen firsthand the federal overreach from the previous administration. So, I am grateful that he has come here today to be with us to discuss the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, and I am thankful for all he does on behalf of Wyoming's County Commissioners and the people of our great state. Micah, thank you very much for joining us. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for allowing me this opportunity. The Chairman. Thank you. Thank you very much. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MIKE LEE, U.S. SENATOR FROM UTAH When Congress first enacted FLPMA back in 1976, the idea was pretty straightforward. Federal agencies would manage public lands with a clear eye toward multiple use and sustained yield. States and counties would, of course, be partners in this. The planning process would be predictable and would be responsive to conditions on the ground, as expressed by those involved in the process. It's not always how the system functions today. Congress intended the resource management plan (RMP) to be flexible and that these processes would involve flexible instruments that could adapt with changing circumstances and according to local needs. But instead, they have often become these very large and, in fact, enormous static documents that take many, many years to write and even longer to revise. By the time an RMP is finalized, local conditions have often shifted, new technology may have emerged, and project needs may have changed substantially. The rigidity that we see in this process can end up affecting everything, from energy development, to grazing renewals, to recreational access. A project can satisfy federal law and environmental requirements, but if the plan that governs the landscape is outdated, the project may be stalled anyway, in which case, applicants are left waiting for permits that should be routine. Project proponents face uncertainty. Counties are forced to operate under assumptions that no longer match reality. The expanded use of restricted designations, like areas of critical environmental concern (ACECs) and wilderness study areas (WSAs), demonstrates how far the process has deviated. Congress intended these tools to protect specific resources. Over time, however, the BLM has applied these concepts to enormous tracts of land, often layered with other restrictions, and these things are rarely reviewed. Even before the Biden administration's abuse of the ACEC designations, as of 2021, over 20 million acres of BLM land were designated as areas of critical environmental concern. This designation limits active management and access for uses that Congress specifically drafted FLPMA to support. The Rock Springs RMP in Wyoming provides a pretty clear case study of this phenomenon. The Biden administration tagged more than a million acres with restricted designations, which had sweeping implications for communities that rely on public land. Wyoming counties raised concerns. The state raised concerns. The proposed plan moved forward anyway. Now, thankfully, in response to public outcry from local officials, the Trump administration reopened the plan. But that sequence of events reveals a process in which coordination with state and local governments is a courtesy, not an obligation. FLPMA requires the Secretary to coordinate with state and local governments, yet the statute gives that requirement no legal teeth. As a result, federal planners can move forward without the most current information available. States and counties have up-to-date data on wildlife migration, water availability, infrastructure, and emergency needs. That information should strengthen federal planning. Instead, it's often incorporated late in the process or incorporated not at all. Coordination, when done correctly, results in locally supported plans that are durable, leading to more certainty for projects on federal lands. We have an opportunity to explore ways we can improve the planning process. A functional system should allow for adaptive management. It should allow for timely adjustments and stable expectations for project sponsors. It should respect the knowledge of state and local governments that live with the practical consequences of these federal decisions. FLPMA rests on the idea that decisions made in Washington, DC, gain legitimacy only when they reflect the judgment of the people who have to live with the outcome. That assumption is as true today as it was in 1976, and it remains embedded within FLPMA today, as it was in 1976. The question before us is whether the Federal Government is meeting that obligation if what we want is a planning process worthy of the land that the process governs. Accountability cannot be merely symbolic. It must be real, it must be early, and it must include the states and local governments that know these landscapes the very best. With that, we will turn the time over to our Ranking Member on the Committee, Senator Heinrich. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARTIN HEINRICH, U.S. SENATOR FROM NEW MEXICO Senator Heinrich. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I want to add my welcome to our witnesses here today to talk about how we decide what to do with our public lands. Talking about resource management plans might not be everyone's idea of a great way to spend their Wednesday morning, but personally, I am very glad that this Committee is looking at this important element of public land management. The Federal Land Policy and Management Act, or FLPMA, says something pretty simple: it says that the Bureau of Land Management should look at the lands it manages and decide how to manage those lands for multiple uses. The BLM has a complicated job--it has to figure out how to fit energy development and wilderness and grazing and wildlife habitat and mining and fishing and forestry and recreation and cultural resource preservation on the lands that it manages. One approach could be a free-for-all--whoever puts the land to use first gets to decide what happens there going forward. Our nation did that for a long time, giving away public land via homesteading and mining claims and granting lands to railroads to facilitate western expansion. But conservationists like Teddy Roosevelt began to recognize that if we kept going down that path, we would have no public lands left, which would mean most Americans would be locked out of the nation's open spaces. A few decades later, Congress passed FLPMA, and directed the BLM to keep public lands public and to manage public lands under the principles of multiple use and sustained yield. To do that, it requires the BLM to periodically produce land use plans to guide its management decisions. Now, recognizing that multiple use doesn't--and frankly can't--mean every use on every acre, these land use plans ensure that all uses have some of those acres. Land use planning is a robustly public process, integrating information and priorities from local residents, from businesses, from tribes and local governments, and public land users from across the nation. Finding ways to accommodate the broad range of everything from wilderness to mining is not easy, but the planning process makes sure that all uses are considered and everyone's voices are heard. Now, unfortunately, these plans are updated far too infrequently--that is something that I think we all agree on-- and are intended to be in place for about 20 years. The BLM has not been able to keep up with revisions to keep these plans aligned with today's priorities and technologies. Some plans in place now were written well before utility-scale solar was common, and few are ready to facilitate the increase in geothermal energy production that's on the horizon. Many current plans don't accommodate the explosion in outdoor recreation that our public lands now host. Recreation on public lands is now an economic powerhouse, generating $128 billion in economic activity every year and driving $6 billion in federal tax revenue. On BLM land alone, recreation supports 76,000 jobs and contributes to more than $12 billion in economic output. Those numbers are very different than they were 30 or 40 years ago, when many BLM land use plans were actually written, and in fact, we weren't even keeping track of recreation statistics when many of these plans were written. I look forward to hearing from our witnesses about how we can make the planning process more efficient and more responsive to changes in how we use our public lands while making sure that our public lands continue to serve the public for generations to come. Thank you, Chairman. The Chairman. Thanks, Senator Heinrich. We will now begin hearing from each of our witnesses, and we will start with Attorney General Brown and then move over from there. Each of you will have five minutes. As we do so, I want to briefly introduce Attorney General Brown. Derek and I have known each other for most of our lives now, going back 30-plus years, ever since college. We have worked together on four or five separate occasions, working at the same location. He has been a member of my team in the past. We practiced at the same law firm, and he and his wife Emilie are good friends of ours. So, I welcome our state's esteemed Attorney General, The honorable Derek Brown. Mr. Brown, you may proceed. STATEMENT OF HON. DEREK BROWN, ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF UTAH Mr. Brown. Thank you. I appreciate that. Good morning, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member, and members of the Committee. As the Chairman said, I am the Utah Attorney General, Derek Brown, and I appreciate the opportunity today to speak with you about an issue that is critical, not just to my home State of Utah, but to the entire American West, and that is effective public land management. Now, in Utah, the Federal Government controls the overwhelming majority of our state, roughly 68 percent of our landmass. So, because the Federal Government controls virtually two out of every three acres in our state, it's critical for our environmental, economic, and social well-being to have a functioning system of what we often call ``cooperative federalism,'' where we work together. And the nature is what are really the ``3 C's'' of public land management-- coordination, cooperation, and consistency in mandating the multiple use and sustained yield that is part of FLPMA. So, FLPMA, itself, mandates meaningful public involvement of state and local government officials in land use decisions. And so, for that reason, in 2015, our state did what I think was the first of its kind--the legislature asked all 29 counties to create a comprehensive county resource management plan, and that plan was then used to create a state resource management plan to manage our state's precious natural resources. But that plan is largely useless if the regulatory space doesn't have predictability or consistency. And so, while cooperation and collaboration are critical to the process, the language of FLPMA, as has already been mentioned, stops short of giving states any real meaningful say in the process itself. And so, often, the level of cooperation depends on the political context. So, in my state, for instance, we have unfortunately seen federal agencies simply ignore state-specific input and state- specific science. One example of this was in 2015, when the administration at that time just ignored the state-specific information and ended up adopting sage grouse plans that were inapplicable to Utah's unique environment. Another example involves not just wildlife, but infrastructure--what we refer to as the Northern Corridor. This is a highway project in Washington County, Utah. It is designed to alleviate traffic concerns and has been planned for over a decade now, and state, county, and local stakeholders have largely been shut out of the process entirely, and state-specific science involving the Mojave Desert Tortoise was mostly ignored. Another example is where state and county officials in Utah were largely denied any meaningful role in the development of the final RMP for the Bears Ears National Monument. So, other stakeholders, not necessarily the state and local officials, had the benefit of countless coordination meetings where they were provided meaningful opportunities to be involved in the planning process. And one of the most well-known, that you may be familiar with, is the TransWest Express transmission line. This was a renewable energy project that was a priority for multiple administrations, and it has taken over 18 years to go simply from the application to the construction phase. So, this creates a lack of predictability, which really hurts everyone. So, I guess the question is, what can be done? I believe there are bipartisan solutions that can be had to change FLPMA. As Utah's Attorney General, one of the things I do is, I look to work with other attorneys general in other states, both red and blue states, to identify long-term solutions to critical problems. And generally, I start by finding issues on which we can agree. One of the issues where I see there is a lot of agreement in this area is the fact that there is a regulatory whiplash every time an administration changes, throwing an RMP back into question. And that not only doesn't achieve FLPMA's goal of multiple use and sustained yield, but it's bad for the land, all of the land, regardless of where it's located. So, ultimately, as a state, we want to be a partner, and that was what was contemplated by FLPMA, and we want to create an environment where there is more collaboration, more cooperation, more consistency, and more predictability. And I believe that result will create less friction with those individuals who are closest to the land, and it will empower states to make better long-term decisions preserving the land for future generations. Thank you, and I look forward to any questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Brown follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. Kenna. STATEMENT OF JIM KENNA, RETIRED STATE DIRECTOR, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT Mr. Kenna. Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, members of the Committee, I really appreciate an opportunity to talk a little bit about what I think is a very important subject. I am a retired BLM State Director with 40-plus years of public service. My background includes experience in planning and permitting, in project proposals and policy, and it crosses all of the levels of the Bureau of Land Management, from the field office to the Washington office. Land use planning is one of the most fundamental processes to management because it really does three things that I think are really important and critical: one, it integrates land use decision-making across a broad landscape; two, it does that by including public participation; and three, it applies the best available information about the planning area itself. By congressional design, federal land use planning is a systematic, interdisciplinary approach. That means it is required to integrate all of the conservation values with all of the detailed expectations around coordination, with all of the various uses that apply in that planning area. And land management is the basis, basically, for all of BLM's work, and it affects all of the multiple uses. And I appreciate the Ranking Member's comment on that. It is just as much about oil and gas as it is about hunting and fishing. Those are inside the definition of multiple use. If there is one thing that Congress could do to really have an impact on land use planning, it would be to pay more attention to funding and staffing for that function because that is where the on-the-ground work happens. There is no substitute for the on-the-ground work. It is the meat and potatoes of the process. And every planning area is different, with different issues, and different alternatives to be considered. A solid resource management plan incorporates and addresses those differences. It doesn't start from some sort of perceived starting point. There is also no substitute for involving the people with the knowledge of the area. That is the local folks. And you need to get there early and often. I appreciate that there have been planning processes where things--and Chairman Lee, thank you for mentioning this--that sometimes you have a dual problem of outdated plans and then an attempt to come in and sort of fix the process late. Those don't work very well. It is really important when you initiate a process to pay close attention to not only the formal level, which is all the state and local and tribal officials, but also to all of the relevant community interests from the very beginning, so, how you launch becomes really important. The public participation that is out there right now is really very sophisticated and well-informed. They won't take anything but addressing the things that they raise forthrightly and honestly. And that is, frankly, the best approach. Public dialogue is your best anchor point for the balancing discussion that FLPMA requires. The most valuable lesson I learned in my 40 years is to invest in that on-the- ground work--the local knowledge, the expertise in the planning team, and the participation and the interfaces. If you look to some of the examples I cited in my written testimony--Arizona's Restoration Design Energy Project and California's Desert Renewable Energy and Conservation Plan-- those are very complex settings. One of them was statewide, the other in an area with a whole slew of very complicated issues. How you launch is really important. The California planning process launched with an agreement between the Secretary and the Governor. That was the beginning, and that framed how the dialogue went back and forth. If I were to talk about a well- managed process, what I would always look for is that very characteristic. How did you launch? How did you structure all the public participation? How did you make sure that the dialogue was about the best information? Thank you for the opportunity to give my perspective on this. I look forward to the conversation. [The prepared statement of Mr. Kenna follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Kenna. Mr. Christensen. STATEMENT OF MICAH CHRISTENSEN, NATURAL RESOURCE COUNSEL, WYOMING COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ASSOCIATION Mr. Christensen. Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, thank you for holding a hearing to discuss land management planning under FLPMA and Wyoming's experience with ACECs under the Rock Springs RMP. My name is Micah Christensen, and I serve as the Natural Resource Counsel for the Wyoming County Commissioners Association, a non-partisan, statewide association that represents all 23 counties and their 93 elected commissioners. Five counties are fortunate to call the lands of the Rock Springs Field Office home. The Rock Springs RMP generated substantial fervor, not only in Southwest Wyoming, but in many states. The record of decision (ROD) was signed on December 20th, 2024, not in Wyoming by our field office manager or state director, but by the Principal Deputy of the BLM. The ROD designated 935,000 acres of ACECs with substantial use restrictions. This represented a 226 percent increase over the previous RMP and an 85 percent increase of ACEC designations across the entire State of Wyoming. Admittedly, this data is not the easiest to come by. As the Rock Springs ``no action alternative'' was over 100,000 acres off from the BLM's ACEC database it maintains online. However, calling the simple Excel sheet a database is likely inappropriate. The BLM's system for conveying to the public, local governments, and itself the ``what, where, how, and why'' ACECs exist is largely inadequate for the purpose. This harms its proper utilization and enables a lack of compliance with FLPMA's directive. Numerous RMPs share similar deficiencies. Designations offer minimal information on relevant and important values that ACECs are designed to protect. They often include substantially more land than values exist, and the restrictions are often general, instead of being specific to prevent irreparable harm to identified values. For example, the South Bend River ACEC contains the historic Buckskin Crossing Cemetery. The public and the BLM may wish to establish an ACEC to protect this resource and could prescribe, for example, a ``no surface occupancy'' restriction for fluid mineral leasing as a reasonable buffer around the area. However, closing 439 square miles of all fluid mineral leasing is likely disproportionate, especially noting that most of Wyoming's current oil and gas development occurs on two-mile horizontal wells that are thousands of feet below the surface. Congress did not give the BLM unilateral authority to establish wilderness areas or national monuments. Instead, Congress created a specific and narrowly tailored conservation tool designed to protect important public land values within the multiple-use, sustained-yield framework in full coordination and cooperation with local governments. The Rock Springs RMP demonstrated how vulnerable ACEC designations are to being shaped by broad political objectives such as limiting fossil fuel development rather than the carefully targeted measures FLPMA envisioned. Wyoming's Counties support ACECs to protect unique and sensitive resources, but their effectiveness and legitimacy depend on agencies identifying values explicitly, demonstrating the necessity of special management to prevent irreparable harm, evaluating the tradeoffs, considering impacts to state and private lands, and working collaboratively with local governments, whose communities will live with the consequences. These lands are the cultural and socio-economic lifeblood of our rural communities, and our future is inextricably intertwined with their proper conservation. But, as President Theodore Roosevelt, the ``father of conservation,'' once said, ``Conservation means development as much as it means protection.'' Both sides of the aisle need to understand that top-down edicts that weaken local engagement undermine the planning process goals to balance conservation across all lands. As energy security, water, catastrophic wildfire, and habitat fragmentation continue to be important conservation considerations, treating federal lands as if they exist in a vacuum is not a winning strategy. These landscapes and resources cannot be managed on four- or eight-year terms from DC. They must transcend elections by being grounded in the cooperative federalism principles that Congress envisioned and FLPMA demands. There is a better way. We desperately need the Federal Government to empower local land managers on the ground-- federal leaders who don't chafe under the cooperative ethos of NEPA, but appreciate the inherent value of partnering with state, local, and tribal governments, so that collectively we can craft RMPs that address the great moral issue of conservation for the betterment of our nation today, and future generations of Americans tomorrow. In short, we need a cultural shift in the nucleus of power from DC back to the people we have entrusted to steward these lands. When local federal leadership can embrace local governments as partners in the planning process, we can achieve mutual benefits to federal agency missions and for our communities. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Christensen follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you. Mr. Cramer. STATEMENT OF ADAM CRAMER, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, OUTDOOR ALLIANCE Mr. Cramer. Good morning. Thank you, Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, and Committee members for the opportunity to speak with you all here today. My name is Adam Cramer, and I am the CEO at Outdoor Alliance. Outdoor Alliance is a national coalition that unites the voices of the human-powered outdoor recreation community to conserve public lands and waters and ensure sustainable management and recreation access for current and future generations. We represent paddlers, climbers, mountain bikers, backcountry skiers, surfers, and anyone who likes to get outside and enjoy our country's public lands and waters. Our nine member organizations include the Access Fund, American Canoe Association, American Whitewater, International Mountain Bicycling Association, Winter Wildlands Alliance, the Mountaineers, the American Alpine Club, Colorado Mountain Club, and Surfrider Foundation. Outdoor recreation is, these days, the most common way Americans come to know their public lands and waters and cultivate a stewardship ethic. It's also a ``principal or major'' use under FLPMA. So, the Bureau of Land Management is responsible for the care of some of our country's most spectacular outdoor recreation experiences, like mountain biking on Gooseberry Mesa outside of Hurricane, Utah, paddling at New Mexico's Upper Taos Box, or climbing at Red Rock Canyon outside of Las Vegas. And these things are really just a drop in the bucket. The 245 million acres of public land under BLM's management contain more than 10,000 miles of mountain bike trails, about 2,500 miles of whitewater paddling, and over 20,000 climbing routes and bouldering problems. Cumulatively, these resources are the literal infrastructure of the outdoor recreation economy, which, as you all know, supports nearly $1.2 trillion in gross economic output, about five million American jobs, and about 2.3 percent of our country's GDP, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. And outdoor recreation helps support vibrant, diversified local economies, particularly in public lands communities, and it helps attract workers and businesses across a range of industries because of the quality of life benefits it brings to local communities. Now, outdoor recreation may be, these days, the most economically significant and socially relevant use of our country's public lands, but it's not the only use. The BLM has a complicated job to implement its multiple-use, sustained- yield mandate. It is a complex and consequential balancing act, and planning is how BLM takes a ton of information from the public to help strike a balance to create the ``harmonious and coordinated management'' that FLPMA describes. Now, successful and durable planning requires community engagement, especially at the local level, with critical input from local communities, their elected officials, as well as consultation with tribal governments. The BLM also needs reliable and current information. And to that end, I commend Congress, and this Committee in particular, for the bipartisan work that led to the unanimous passage of the EXPLORE Act last year, which directs the BLM and other land management agencies to inventory for recreation resources and values to support better agency decision-making. Now, planning is essential for protecting and enhancing public land and outdoor recreation opportunities. Plans lay out what lands are open or closed for energy, mining, grazing, and recreation; conditions and stipulations for development activities; special designations; and of course, lands that are eligible for disposal. Now, plans that are outdated and vague are recipes for conflict, and planning is a huge and important investment in the success of the permitted projects that ultimately need to tier off of these plans. Clear plans, with public support that comes from a sound and participatory process, give communities and stakeholders the certainty that they need to make investments in recreation infrastructure, in businesses, as well as other public land uses. Importantly, and maybe most importantly, planning is part of the democratic management of our public lands, and part of what makes public lands truly public. Sound planning is responsive to local and national interests. It may not fully satisfy everyone, but at its best, it reduces conflict and leads to compromise where stakeholders feel heard and their communities' needs are meaningfully reflected in the final plan. In closing, I want to be clear that the outdoor recreation community strongly supports BLM's Public Lands Rule, which helps to develop better information on landscape health to support sound, sustainable management decisions. Thank you for the opportunity to be here. I am truly grateful, and I look forward to all of your questions and conversations. [The prepared statement of Mr. Cramer follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Cramer. Mr. Sheehan. STATEMENT OF GREG SHEEHAN, PRESIDENT AND CEO, MULE DEER FOUNDATION Mr. Sheehan. Chairman Lee, Ranking Member Heinrich, and members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Greg Sheehan. I serve as the President and CEO of the Mule Deer Foundation, a national organization whose mission is to ensure the conservation of mule deer, black-tailed deer, and their habitats. Further, our interests include sportsman access in order to ethically hunt these iconic species. Each year, we engage with more than 420,000 hunters, members, volunteers, and supporters. We speak for the millions of sportsmen and women who depend on healthy public lands, intact migration routes, and wild places. My testimony also reflects a lifetime in state, federal, and nonprofit conservation service. I spent 25 years with the Utah Department of Natural Resources, including five as the Director of the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources. I later served as Acting Director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and then as the Utah State Director for the Bureau of Land Management under both the Trump and Biden administrations, overseeing 22.8 million acres of federal land. That experience, from energy and mineral development, to wildlife, recreation, fires and fuels, grazing, and national monuments, gave me a practical understanding of how planning decisions shaped day- to-day management, and how essential strong partnerships with states, tribes, local governments, industry, permittees, and non-profit partners really are. The Federal Land Policy and Management Act provides the framework for this stewardship. FLPMA's multiple-use and sustained-yield principles recognize that conservation, recreation, grazing, energy, mining, habitat, public access, and the preservation of wild and undeveloped landscapes are all legitimate uses of the land. As President Theodore Roosevelt said, ``Conservation means development as much as it does protection.'' To be clear, multiple use does not mean every use everywhere, but it does require a planning system capable of balancing these needs while keeping landscapes healthy for future generations. Today, however, many of BLM's resource management plans, some written in the 1980s on typewriters, no longer reflect modern wildlife science, migration data, wildfire conditions, recreation growth, energy and mineral needs, or other current demands on the land. Updating these plans is essential for both conservation and responsible use, but revising an RMP today takes two to three years--sometimes even up to ten--and costs $2 to $6 million. BLM has stated that 134 of its 169 plans are outdated. Because funding does not meet all the planning needs, only the most prioritized plans are updated, while many landscapes continue to be managed under frameworks that no longer match on-the-ground realities. Part of that challenge is that FLPMA provides very limited direction on how BLM is actually supposed to develop plans that meet the expectations of Congress and the public. Let me give you an example. When I was kid, we liked to play Monopoly. We didn't have phones to play on back then. Imagine if the instructions simply said ``buy property, build houses and hotels, make more money than the other players, and if those instructions are not sufficient, then make up your own rules.'' You can imagine that result. Players invent their own rules and every game ends in an argument. FLPMA can feel a little like that. It's 71 pages long, yet only about two pages of Section 202 explain how to do land use planning for 245 million acres of public land. When the statute provides such little direction, the BLM has to fill in the gaps with regulations and policy, and states, tribes, counties, industry, conservation groups, and all the public end up unhappy with some part of the outcome. If Congress has clear expectations, updating those few planning pages would be very helpful, especially for the BLM. Another factor is the cumulative use of administrative designations. BLM has more than two dozen planning and management tools, from wilderness study areas and ACECs, to lands with wilderness characteristics and visual resource management classes. Each can serve a purpose, but when layered together, or left in place indefinitely, they can limit flexibility to manage habitat, address wildfire risk, support communities, and maintain access. At the same time, society increasingly depends on BLM lands for energy production, critical minerals, transmission lines, recreation, and solitude. Planning has to be thoughtful enough to allow for those needs while still protecting wildlife habitat and migration routes. I also want to share that my experience, working side-by- side with BLM staff, is that they are dedicated, hardworking, and committed to fulfilling all elements of FLPMA and other governing acts. Finally, I want to emphasize that land stewardship matters deeply to America's hunters and anglers. Protecting wild places, migration corridors, watersheds, and healthy habitat is fundamental to our mission at the Mule Deer Foundation. A planning system that is timely, collaborative, science-based, and flexible will better support wildlife, rural communities, and the other diverse uses Congress intended under FLPMA. Thank you for this opportunity to testify, and I would be pleased to answer any questions from the Committee. [The prepared statement of Mr. Sheehan follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. Thanks so much, Mr. Sheehan. We will now begin our five-minute rounds of questions. I will go first, followed by Ranking Member Heinrich. We will then alternate between Republicans and Democrats, each with five-minute rounds in order of seniority, subject to the early- bird rule. Attorney General Brown, I would like to start with you. I have a chart here that shows two maps of BLM-managed land within Utah. [The chart referred to follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] The Chairman. The map on the left shows all the BLM land in Utah that was open for multiple use in 1976 upon the enactment of FLPMA. And then the map on the right shows those same lands today, now plastered with a lot of restrictive designations pursuant to FLPMA. Now, comparing these two maps, what does the increase in restrictive designations over the last 49 years since FLPMA's enactment--what does that mean for the rural economies in the State of Utah, especially those that depend on access to these lands, and how does it affect the ability to permit projects like transmission lines, wildfire mitigation, grazing, basic rights-of-way, and so forth? Mr. Brown. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think, first of all, if you look at that map, the purple also represents what are effectively single uses. And the reality is, under FLPMA, the dual mandate, obviously, is multiple use and sustained yield. You mentioned these rural communities. One of them--I spend a lot of time in Garfield County, for instance. I have a father-in-law that lives there. We love it. I love the mountain biking there. It is roughly 93 percent owned and controlled by the Federal Government. So, you literally can't take any action without implicating the Federal Government. And by the way, you mentioned the economic impact. Imagine trying to run and fund a county on what is effectively three to four percent of the land being able to tax. And so, things like hospitals or schools, I mean, so when I talk to commissioners, for instance, in Garfield County, they are very passionate about this issue. And so, I think ultimately one of the things that we need to do is have what is mentioned, I think, by every testimony here today, which is meaningful involvement of the people who are local and who are most directly affected by these designations. And I think that will make a huge impact on how it is that we address these issues. The Chairman. Right. That makes things very difficult. You mentioned the 93 percent ownership--the fact that that's all owned by the Federal Government makes a lot of things more difficult, including building up their own tax base. Now, can we talk for a moment about the TransWest Express transmission line? You spoke about that and the fact that it took more than 18 years to move from application to construction of the project. That's a long time. It took that long in large part because the project had to navigate multiple outdated or ever-shifting federal planning documents. And it spanned the creation and revision of two separate sage grouse plans, each with different requirements. So the ground was shifting throughout the duration of that because of these multiple governing documents. What does that experience tell us about how rigid and sometimes outdated RMPs affect transmission permitting, and what would need to change in the planning process in order to ensure that projects like that aren't stuck perpetually in limbo? Mr. Brown. Well, FLPMA was passed over 50 years ago, and I think those who voted for it at the time wouldn't recognize what it looks like at this point in time. And I think one of the things we need to do is rethink the rigidity of the process, because it's not good for anyone and it's not good for permitting projects. I mean, you mentioned this TransWest Express, I mean, this transmission line was a renewable project that was a priority for multiple administrations. So everyone wanted it to happen. And so, you can imagine, if you have a project that everyone wants to happen and it still takes 18 years, I mean, clearly, the process itself is broken. Now, admittedly, this was a very complicated project, spanning multiple states, starting in Wyoming, delivering power to California, but that being said, we have got to be able to rethink the process if it takes that long. The Chairman. Indeed. And that's for, as you say, a relatively non-controversial project. Mr. Sheehan, you noted that BLM now uses more than 26 different administrative designations that can be layered, often one on top of the other, compounding the complexity of it. What happens on the ground when these designations are layered over the exact same landscape, and how does that affect BLM's ability to carry out habitat work, fuels treatments, or even maintain existing infrastructure on those lands? Mr. Sheehan. Thank you, Chairman Lee. Certainly, when we have this multitude of layers--some of those were identified on that map you showed a moment ago--it can restrict even our ability to help, in many cases, wildlife and those needs. Wildlife do need our help. We have changing and evolving landscapes. We have fire regimes. We have drought situations that occur. And it's really important that we can get in for the benefit of wildlife and do water structures and developments and projects, do habitat restoration to help reduce the impact of non-native invasive plants that come into our landscapes. We do need to get into these areas to address fire rehabilitation after they occur. And you know, at times, some of these designations will preclude us from being able to get in and adequately help wildlife and their needs. The Chairman. Thank you. My time is expired. We will turn to Senator Heinrich now. Senator Heinrich. Actually, Chairman, I know both of my down-the-dais members have a meeting to get to, so I am going to defer to them. The Chairman. Great. Who has the more pressing---- Senator King. She was here before. The Chairman. Roger that. We will go to Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you. Senator King. Early-bird rule. The Chairman. Early-bird rule, thank you, Senator King. Senator Cortez Masto. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and to the Ranking Member, and thank you to the panelists for being here. This is a great conversation. I am from Nevada, and similar to Utah, most of our land is owned by the Federal Government--over 84 percent. Just about 63 percent is managed by the BLM. So, I appreciate all of the conversation about how we have to find that balance and manage this public land for use, not only those individuals who live in the state, but those who want to come and engage in tourism and transportation and then be stewards of federal land as well. Let me ask you this, and let me start with Mr. Kenna. I appreciated your comment about Congress needing to pay more attention to funding and staffing at the BLM level, because I couldn't agree more. What we have right now, I am very concerned that the current administration is taking actions that will only exacerbate the BLM's backlog in resource planning. We have identified today that 134 out of the 164 RMPs are outdated. And if we don't have the staff and we don't have the resources to even look at how we need to update, I am very concerned. Can you talk a little bit about the importance of the staffing levels and what role they play? And let me just touch on this--every single one of us has worked with our local BLMs. We know who they are. They are in our states. They live there. They have worked with the local jurisdictions. They understand better than anybody in Washington. And I will call out folks in Washington under both administrations that are playing politics. And we need people driven from the ground up--I could not agree more, General Brown--that are focused on how we manage the land to the benefit of the people that live there and recreate there. But I am concerned about the staffing levels under this administration. How much more is that going to set us back in trying to address the issues we are talking about today? Mr. Kenna. Let me start by sort of taking the perspective of a field manager--so, the manager of an office at the ground level. And one of the things that it calls for in a plan or in a project is, you've got to have access to an interdisciplinary staff. You need to have a wildlife biologist. You need to have an archeologist. You need to have those specialists that have expertise that are unique. And that's a lot of the processes that are underneath that, like the SHPO process--State Historic Preservation process. They help manage that. They help bird-dog all of the details of what goes on. So I share your concern as I see that some of these field offices are losing key bits of expertise. We have had times in my career at the BLM when, for example, there was a shortage of wildlife biologists. If you have to do Section 7 consultations under the Endangered Species Act, you've got to have one. So, if you don't have one in the office, you've got to find one. It's not really a discretionary thing. You've got to have that expertise. So, I think if I were to try to put a fine point on it, imagine that happening in every single field office. As you lose people, and if you have a vacancy in a key position, what are you left to do? You are out there trying to cast around with your neighbor offices to see if you can find the right expertise in order to assemble what needs to be done. Senator Cortez Masto. Yes. Mr. Kenna. So, I think that's essentially the crux of it, you've got to have that interdisciplinary mix in there, or some very specific pieces of expertise that are essential. Senator Cortez Masto. Yes, I appreciate that. My time is running out, but let me touch on one other thing. Early this year, Congress took the unprecedented step in using the Congressional Review Act to reverse three separate resource management plans that were approved under the previous administration. That's the first time. And there is an argument--a legal argument to be made whether they are actually rulemaking or not. But the question I have is, I am concerned, if a land use plan is now considered to be a regulation that Congress can overturn, how does this bode for other existing or future land use plans? I mean, again, isn't this--the concern we are all talking about is top-down, right? Driven from Washington dictating what happens, and we are still doing it. How is that going to impact any resource planning that you plan in the future, and then all of a sudden, Congress can come along and use the CRA to overturn it? Wouldn't that frustrate the process moving forward? I am going to just open that up to anyone. Mr. Kenna. Senator, I don't see how it can't help but undermine it. I think it's going to create a mess. Senator Cortez Masto. Yes, I appreciate it. Thank you. I know my time is up. The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Cortez Masto. Senator Barrasso would otherwise be next. He has graciously deferred to Senator King, who has a time commitment elsewhere. Senator King, go ahead. Senator King. Thank you very much. One specific question, Attorney General Brown--timing. Are there any limits on this process? Are there any time limits? Is that something we should be discussing here? Because you talk about the 18-year transmission line. That's unacceptable, particularly in this day and age. Should we be talking about perhaps putting limits on times and steps so that there is a foreseeable end to the process? Mr. Brown. I think that's definitely something that we ought to look at. When you look at FLPMA Section 202, as was already mentioned, when it comes to things like land swaps, it is very prescriptive, but Section 202 is not. And there is not a whole lot of language and yet, it is a very impactful section of code. And so, those kinds of limits might make sense. I think it also might make sense to figure out how it is we can get meaningful involvement, as has already been said, with those on the ground. And maybe that's the answer to--if there is currently a lack of staffing, maybe we can look at those folks with the local interest. Senator King. Well, work tends to expand to fill the time available, and if the time available is unlimited, it is going to be a long process. So, I hope you would provide some suggestions to the Committee on where we might be able to look for some time limitations that would improve this--the uncertainty surrounding the process. Mr. Sheehan, you used an important term, and I think this is sort of an undercurrent of this hearing--``regulatory whiplash.'' And part of the problem is that the Congress is not being very specific about what it wants. And therefore, it leaves tremendous discretion to whatever administration it is, and you go from one to the other and the whole world turns upside down. Is one way that we can address this by being more specific in terms of FLPMA and what the criteria are so Congress isn't basically abdicating its entire responsibility in this area to the executive? Mr. Sheehan. Thank you, Senator King. Certainly, it's worth considering. I think that's why Chairman Lee asked for this hearing today--do we need to do more? Attorney General Brown mentioned a moment ago, but when we look at Section 202, I mentioned in my remarks that it's only about two pages of guidance for 245 million acres of land. There is a little bit more in there. It talks about a congressional process and how they could look at amending these actions, but essentially 202 says three things: it says coordinate with state, local, and tribal governments; try to use their planning efforts where you can; and prioritize areas of critical environmental concern. That's the guidance from Congress in a nutshell in Section 202 of a 71-page law. And everything beyond that has been crafted through rules, everything's been crafted through internal guidance policy handbooks by the BLM, and we get where we get. Senator King. And that leads to the problem of executive overreach because there are no boundaries. So, again, I would ask all of you for some homework to suggest to us how Section 202 could be amended to narrow what the criteria are and what the specifics are so that we could get policy on a more timely basis that is more predictable and more resilient. I think one of the problems you have all identified is uncertainty. And it takes so long and you don't know what the result is going to be. So I would ask you to provide us with some suggestion as to--that is the business we are in here is lawmaking--as to how this law could be more definitive in order to provide better guidance to the process, which will hopefully produce a better and more resilient result so that we don't have what you characterized, I think quite accurately, as regulatory whiplash. My final comment, Mr. Sheehan, is, I was concerned that our white-tailed deer don't seem to be among your constituents--of the deer species that you mentioned, and I---- Mr. Sheehan. Everyone in the East can have the white-tail, we will take our mule deer in the West. Senator King. All right, that's fine. [Laughter.] Mr. Sheehan. See how it all works out? But thank you for that comment. Senator King. And I come at this as someone who has no BLM land in their state. And so, I am looking at it just from the point of view of good policy going forward, and I hope that you can help us with that. Thank you all for your testimony. Thank you, Senator Barrasso. The Chairman. Senator Barrasso. Senator Barrasso. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Christensen, I want to just talk about what we have seen under the Federal Land Policy and Management Act, because there are many tools there that are designed to uphold multiple use, the mandate that we have. But one tool is a special land use designation known as areas of environmental concern--ACECs. Those designations have been used in the federal land management process since this law passed 50 years ago. The original intent was to provide flexibility and locally led protections, but what we have seen in Wyoming in the last decade has been a substantial use increase in these designations that seemed to me to limit use, to use these in ways to make non-use a use. And I am just wondering if you could explain the increase in what we have seen in Wyoming in the last few years of this designation being used in a way that we never anticipated it being used. Mr. Christensen. Chairman Lee, Senator Barrasso, we have seen a substantial increase in ACEC acreage since our most recent planning efforts, and that is the Rock Springs RMP. It's good to note that RMP took place after the BLM's Conservation and Landscape Health Rule. And so, we certainly didn't see that rule fix our problem, which is that the BLM is utilizing the ACEC as a tool for large swaths of land, not identifying unique resources for protection, but hundreds of thousands of acres, often, and really combining them with all sorts of things that we care about, like wildlife habitat and historic places, but doing so in a way that's really hard to untangle and understand what we are actually trying to protect. It's unclear because we have numerous uses. So, we have seen a huge increase of ACECs in Wyoming. I think in my testimony I said an 85 percent increase in a single RMP, and that RMP is only one of seven field offices that we have--so, a large increase. Senator Barrasso. So, are these designations really being driven by local folks, or does it seem like it's more the Federal Government getting involved? Mr. Christensen. Senator Barrasso, interesting question. It's hard to tell. Again, back to BLM's ability to track, we don't actually know often in our resource management plans who is nominating these parcels. There are two ways--the public can nominate, and also the BLM can internally nominate. But, for example, on the Rock Springs RMP, I don't believe, you know, anywhere is it stated. So we have seen certain nominations like the Sagebrush Sea nomination, with 19 NGOs supporting that--48 million acres. We at least know the NGOs that supported it, but for the Rock Springs RMP, it's really hard to tell where those nominations came from. Senator Barrasso. So the Biden administration's BLM finalized the Rock Springs Resource Management Plan in December 2024 as that administration was on the way out the door. And I have worked closely with the county commissioners to ensure that Wyoming stakeholders are included. I am grateful to President Trump and Secretary Burgum for announcing an amendment process for the Rock Springs RMP. Can you talk a little bit about the socio-economic impacts that communities in the West are seeing, especially Wyoming, or how they are impacted by some of these federal land management programs? Mr. Christensen. Yes, I think it's easy to think of public lands as sort of being isolated out in the middle of nowhere. However, as you know, Senator Barrasso, our lands are often intertwined and intermixed, so we have different surface ownership maybe than mineral ownership. We also have inholdings inside of some of these areas. So, anytime that the Federal Government, through an RMP or another rule, restricts some sort of use on federal land, there is often a restriction that also occurs on state and private land as well, further limiting our ability to develop resources, to access certain lands, and so, there is a big impact. The Rock Springs RMP estimated, you know, based on their preferred alternative, was roughly, you know, $14 million a year in losses to county government, county services, including the school districts. So we're not talking about inconsequential numbers--a fairly significant impact. Senator Barrasso. So, in terms of the land management and what I see as federal overreach, particularly in land management across Wyoming, it seems ultimately so many of the final decisions aren't made locally, but they are made in Washington, DC. How can we improve upon the land management process? Mr. Christensen. That's a great question, and I think one of the first things I would start with is that we have this idea of consistency, coordination, and cooperation, but we do things sort of out of order. So, the BLM could propose a land management plan with multiple alternatives, but maybe one or even none of those alternatives are consistent with state and local plans. How can we-- you know, we could really prioritize plans to have consistency done up front, allow for that building, so that you're not doing the check-the-box at the very end. Senator Barrasso. Thank you. Mr. Chairman. Thanks for coming back to testify, appreciate it. The Chairman. Senator Heinrich. Senator Heinrich. Mr. Kenna, how critical is it for the public to guide the direction of the land use plan for that plan to be effective and successful? Mr. Kenna. I think it's very important, and I would highlight the fact that planning processes, particularly if they are of any size or duration, create a record, and it's a public record, and that public record underpins all of the decision-making that happens in the plan. So it essentially is the balancing dialogue around the FLPMA questions. And so, you can't sidestep that, and you need to make sure that the local knowledge is integrated, and not just the social preferences. Those are very important, but also, where is the mule deer winter range? Where are the cultural resources and cultural properties? Where are the things that we care about? Where are the trails that get a lot of recreation? All of those things are very local. Senator Heinrich. Right. Mr. Kenna. And they are very specific. Senator Heinrich. And how does the Congressional Review Act incorporate the public input and the creation of that record? Mr. Kenna. Well, my concern is that it is the exact opposite. If you think about the perspective of the person who participated in a plan, they have just invested years to get to that kind of endpoint where everybody kind of got together, and whatever the deal was, the deal was the deal. Senator Heinrich. Yes. Mr. Kenna. And now, the Congressional Review Act is sort of taking a political process and putting it over the top of that and vacated that. Senator Heinrich. And with no public--there is no mechanism for public input in the Congressional Review Act. And I want to get at some of the unintended consequences that might create. Mr. Sheehan, you know, with Congress recently overturning a number of RMPs through the Congressional Review Act, one of the limitations under the CRA is that it means that the BLM, under the statute, can never issue a ``substantially similar'' plan for those areas. Is that correct? Mr. Sheehan. Yes, I believe that's accurate, Senator. Senator Heinrich. So, I am wondering if a plan, if an RMP plan allowed for development of oil and gas, development of mining and grazing, hunting in the planning area, and the plan is overturned by the CRA, could BLM ever issue a new plan that allowed those same uses in the same areas? Mr. Sheehan. Senator Heinrich, I believe that--and I am not a lawyer here, and there are lots of lawyers in the room. There is one right to your left. Senator Heinrich. I am not either, but let's take the verbiage at its---- Mr. Sheehan. If we work under that premise that a CRA pulls this plan back and then a new plan could not be substantially similar, then it would certainly lean into a set of facts around you can't go back and do the same thing again until Congress says you can do it again. But what it does do, as you pull it back, is it reverts back to---- Senator Heinrich. The previous plan. Mr. Sheehan [continuing]. The prior plan that's sitting there. And if that allowed for some of those uses, of course, those---- Senator Heinrich. It could be 40 years old and that plan may not actually address the uses that are most pressing today, correct? Mr. Sheehan. Yes, absolutely. When we talk about planning, and I wrote down a comment that Chairman Lee mentioned in his opening comments, which is, adapt to changing circumstances. And I thought for a moment, what happens over these 40 years, 45 years in some of these plans that have sat there, and, you know, with the new technologies that have come about, I look at what do we know different about wildlife management and movements and how we can restore habitats. We have got wild horses and burros, and in some of these areas that we have plans for, we don't necessarily want to manage for wild horses and burros in those areas anymore. Senator Heinrich. We also know where corridors are that, in 1986---- Mr. Sheehan. Exactly, we have that technology, absolutely. It has taught us that. Renewable energy. Senator Heinrich [continuing]. Nobody knew where the Mule deer corridors were, where the Pronghorn corridors were, and so, that doesn't get managed for, if we are dealing with a 40- year-old plan. Mr. Sheehan. Exactly. So, I guess my hope is, as a former land manager, if the CRAs are going to be a thing that gets used, let us try to avoid that to any extent possible. Senator Heinrich. Why not just redo the plan? Mr. Sheehan. A plan can be---- Senator Heinrich. And avoid all those unintended consequences? Mr. Sheehan. Yes, absolutely. And I think if the plans can be done initially and make sure we do that coordination and cooperation, do all of the efforts we need to so that we get a better, higher level of buy-in, and I would hope Congress does not need to step in on these because, to your earlier point, I don't know what kind of certainty there is for future planning in these areas, and I hope that that's not compounded. Senator Heinrich. I think one of the things that I am concerned about is the opening for litigation, because the statute is so vague about what a substantially similar plan would look like, is that you could literally see every permit-- whether that permit is for outdoor recreation, like Mr. Cramer represents, whether that permit is for oil and gas, whether that permit is for grazing--called into question because of some of these CRA activities. And I think that's something that everybody ought to be considering before using such a blunt tool. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Daines. Senator Daines. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Heinrich, thank you. Last month, Congress acted to right a wrong and repeal the violation of the multiple use and public engagement principles enshrined in FLPMA. The Biden BLM land use planning process was weaponized to push radical anti-energy policies in states like Montana, like Wyoming, like North Dakota and Alaska, despite significant opposition from the states. Thankfully, Congress acted and they passed my bill to repeal the anti-coal Miles City Resource Management Plan Amendment, and I look forward to President Trump signing it into law very soon. I want to focus my question on a specific violation of FLPMA in Montana that was prevalent under Biden, and that's the disregard of the views and the input of the local counties, elected officials, and specifically, the governor of the state. The Miles City RMPA was strongly opposed by those living, working, and representing the lands affected, and despite this opposition, Biden's BLM ignored local feedback and they pushed forward with this harmful effort. It is so frustrating to see the disconnect between federal bureaucrats here in Washington, who had a very strong agenda, and local elected officials on the ground in Montana. And during the official governor's consistency review, after multiple official protests, and an appeal from Governor Gianforte, the BLM decided to, ``reject the Governor's recommendations.'' This is shameful and we need to ensure the voice of those closest to the land are not ignored or just rejected. My question for Attorney General Brown and Mr. Christensen: what actions should Congress take to ensure that local, state, and local statewide elected officials and those most affected by BLM's actions do not have their voices literally shut out of the planning process? Mr. Brown. Thank you, Senator Daines, I appreciate that. And we have seen that as well in our state where you get to the place where you have the governor's consistency review and then it is effectively overruled. So, I think one of the things that I think this body could do is look at meaningful changes to FLPMA such that there is meaningful involvement that is more than just sort of a pat on the head to the states because, as we mentioned, we need consistency, coordination, and collaboration. But we also need the states to have some sort of meaningful input so that they can effectively be co-sovereigns over these lands where they have jurisdiction. And I think the consistency review is one specific example where, I think, if there were maybe a little more teeth to that, where they could be meaningful partners rather than just pro forma partners, that would solve, I think, a lot of the issues we have in the local areas in Utah and in places like Montana. Senator Daines. Thank you. Mr. Christensen. Mr. Christensen. Senator Daines, it's a great question. I agree with the idea of increasing the teeth, if you will, of consistency review, but really, I speak more of a cultural shift. I mean, we heard earlier about the impact of having not enough planning employees at the BLM. This is a real concern. But one way to fix that lack of employment at the BLM for planning is to utilize state and county resources, so, utilize state wildlife agencies to help you with developing your sage grouse plan instead of working against those plans. So incorporating state and local knowledge meaningfully in the planning process by authorizing those individuals who sit on ID teams, on planning teams, and really utilize the science and data that they provide. And as far as the rejection letter, I think our governor got a few of the same letters, so we've got some government efficiency there. But it is a problem. It is a problem that after the entire process, a 13-year planning process, the Rock Springs RMP ends with a whimper. Your recommendations are rejected. And it certainly isn't the way that you would like to see a planning process be working to unite forces, states, local governments, and the federal agencies to really manage these lands for all of America. Thanks. Senator Daines. Thank you. I want to shift gears to forestry and transmission. In order for electric utilities and our rural co-ops in Montana to be able to provide energy in an efficient way, we've got to get the transmission lines in place crossing a patchwork of private, state, and federal lands. To protect these power lines and communities from devastating wildfires, electric utilities develop and retain authorized vegetation management plans to cut and remove dangerous trees on public lands. However, they cannot protect and power communities if land management agencies are not responsive or cooperative when utilities are managing the rights-of-way. Recently, the Vigilante Electric Cooperative from Dillon, Montana, was slapped with a $5 million fine from the Forest Service because a tree outside of their right-of-way caught on fire. Any attempt from Vigilante to remove the tree would have been illegal, yet they were held liable for the fire. In 2018, FLPMA was amended to include a strict liability cap of $500,000 for electric utilities, which expires in 2028. The $5 million dollar Vigilante fire was far beyond the $500,000 limit, and one that's nearly impossible for a small, rural electric co-op to pay. It literally can put them out of business. It is common sense that no entity should be fined without proven negligence or non-compliance, and the status quo is not providing enough certainty on it. Last, quick question, Mr. Brown. The Utah and Montana state legislatures have both recently passed legislation to address these liability problems and the unique burden placed on electricity providers. What still needs to be changed at the federal level to replicate the success we are seeing in our states? Mr. Brown. Well, and I think this is something this body should look at in terms of caps and liabilities and frankly, I think a lot of what you are talking about in terms of, you mentioned sort of the catch-22--they really need to do something, but they are disempowered from doing it in the first place. And I think having more meaningful involvement with the folks on the ground who recognize the problems involved with the rights-of-way is something that should be addressed. And I think changing, as Mr. Christensen said, that cultural shift as well, I think, could be helpful, but I think this body ought to look at things such as those caps and then how that can be addressed. Senator Daines. Thank you. The Chairman. Senator Padilla. Senator Padilla. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good morning to all of you. I want to begin by noting Mr. Kenna's long and distinguished career in public service, which includes more than 40 years in his role as BLM Director for the State of California. So, I want to thank you for your service, for your dedication to protecting our cherished public lands, not just in California, but especially in California. There are a number of great examples from your time there of successful resource management plan development. We successfully brought thousands of stakeholders together to establish the Desert Renewable Energy Conservation Plan. I know you are more than intimately familiar with this, the DRECP, which focuses on 10.8 million acres of public lands across seven counties in California. The DRECP is a landscape-level plan that streamlines renewable energy development while conserving unique and valuable desert ecosystems. The DRECP is a success story on incorporating robust public and tribal participation into land use planning, and it's a great example of working collaboratively to ensure that all stakeholders benefit from BLM's multiple-use mandate. So, I share all that not just to thank you, and to point out a success story, but to ask you, Mr. Kenna, can you discuss how the energy permitting landscape looked in the California desert before successful implementation of the DRECP and how the plan actually helped provide the certainty, the transparency, and the efficiency for the energy industry after it was adopted? Mr. Kenna. Thank you, Senator, for your comments. I think this is a really important thing, to be clear. One of the characterizations we have heard so far is that land use planning is sort of a combative or adversarial relationship between the state and the Federal Government. That was certainly not my experience in California. It started with a Republican Governor and a Secretary of Interior and a Democratic administration setting up an agreement that was the umbrella to the entire process. In terms of what things were like when we started, nobody really anticipated the flood of applications that happened with renewable energy. We had 15 to 20 coming in the door at a time. There were 6 to 10 that were active. And they were all in different stages and frankly, with very different applicants. We had everything from Florida Power and Light, a very sophisticated operator that operates globally, to startups that had ideas about where they wanted to put a wind farm. So, that is a variable that is really important and has a lot of impact and control on the timeline-- is the applicant itself. But there are also the things we have talked about before, like capacity to do the work. And then, you have to go to the issues and let that steer the process because the content of what's going on. In the case of the DRECP that you mentioned, you are in a national conservation area that was congressionally designated in 1976. So, as a starting point, you've got to have a robust, reliable, conservation design. And the governor and the secretary agreed on that. But then you also have a very complex system that you are overlaying and working with. You have interstate transmission of power, how California fits to the grid, how things move across, and then how that all fits together with transmission and generation. So, it's a complex process and there are a lot of people who have unique information that you need to get from Point A to Point B at the end of the process. So, hopefully that's responsive to your question, Senator. Senator Padilla. Yes, I appreciate how you began your response by saying this process isn't meant to be a barrier, an obstacle, necessarily. To the contrary, I mean, I have used in this Committee and in other hearings the concerns of the carpenter's rule, right--measure twice, you cut once. If you do the appropriate engagement--including by the way, I want to put an emphasis on tribal consultation, genuine tribal consultation, not just box-checking--you get the information you need to be thoughtful on the front end, whether you are in the development of a plan or in the context of, you know, national monuments, for example, just the designation of the exact perimeters, you can better protect ecosystems that are worth protecting and establishing clear energy development opportunities, renewable or otherwise, because you are informed on the front end. And I think it does save you time on the back end, whether it's through litigation, whether it's revisiting plans or boundaries, et cetera, but it takes the thoughtfulness, open-mindedness, and due diligence on the front end. That's the point that we are trying to make. So thank you for your response. Thank you all for your testimony. Mr. Kenna. Absolutely, Senator. The Chairman. Senator Gallego. Senator Gallego. Mr. Kenna, welcome back, and thank you, Chairman Lee and Ranking Member Heinrich. I am glad to see that we have representation from Mr. Kenna, who used to be the Arizona State Director for BLM also. So, you have a very long and rich career. I am glad you started at the rookie State of California and then graduated to Arizona. So, your insight will be very key as we talk about something that is at heart about-- which is public land use and planning. Arizona has 12.1 million acres of BLM land and over 17 million subsurface acres. These lands are home to some of Arizona's most important resources, including sacred tribal sites, 45 miles of the Arizona Scenic Trail, and over 55,000 mining claims. And we will get to some of the questions about Arizona specifically, but first I want to point out an underlying challenge that impacts every potential use of public lands, which is staffing. We talked about that earlier. Regardless of what you would like to see on lands, to do or use, we need BLM staff to get it approved, and 15 to 20 percent of BLM staff have been fired or forced to retire since the beginning of this year, not including layoff plans that are currently on hold. That just doesn't make sense, and I just urge the administration to reverse course. Turning to Mr. Kenna, in your testimony you mentioned that when you were Arizona State Director, you worked on a plan called the Restoration Design Energy Project. That plan provided opportunities for renewable energy development while taking advantage of hardrock mine reclamation sites. Can you talk about how you approached development of the plan, and how did you balance the multiple-use requirement, including clean energy deployment? Mr. Kenna. Yes, as I mentioned earlier, none of the states or the land use plans that were in place at the time were prepared for renewable energy when it hit. And so, there was a lot of figuring it out on the fly that had to happen. That was also true in Arizona. And one of the goals is to get to something that is practical, and transmission aligned for the, basically, public interest reasons so that it makes sense with the grid. So, there are some technical issues that sort of overlay everything that you have to do, but doing a statewide plan requires sort of a unique mindset. And one is that you have to be willing to go where the people are and figure out what the issues are. So, the point I would emphasize, again, is one I made earlier, that there is no substitute for the on-the-ground knowledge and the on-the-ground information when you are doing land use planning. And each plan in each area is going to be different and unique. And that was true in the Restoration Design Energy Project. The reason I mentioned the mining situation is there is a fair amount of hardrock mining in Arizona, as you know, and when a mine is decommissioned, mines generally are big consumers of power. And so, the decommissioning, historically, had been, you know, reclaim the site and take out the power line. Well, if you have an already disturbed site that has been flattened and has power access into the grid, why not take advantage of that? So that was the concept behind it. Senator Gallego. And you kind of talked about this, which is also very important for Arizona because we have 22 federally recognized tribes, that there is no substitute for engaging with tribes and public and local leaders. Can you elaborate on your experience with tribal consultation and why a transparent local engagement process is important and how it improves project stability? Mr. Kenna. Yes, it's easy to talk about it in an oversimplified way, but the way I sometimes think about it is sort of as a nested process. There is a lot that has to happen in a very personal way and on a face-to-face kind of relationship, and so, getting with tribal councils and tribal preservation officers and that really individual conversation. And then there is a second sort of tier that has to happen. As you know, you would not expect the perspectives to be exactly the same for the Tohono O'odham as they are with the Hopi or the Navajo or someone up to the North. So, you have to have some way to assemble those points of view, and in Arizona, the magic of that was the Inter Tribal Council. Senator Gallego. Thank you. I yield back. The Chairman. Senator Hoeven. Senator Hoeven. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, although I should defer to my colleague, Senator Hickenlooper, because I was supposed to link up with him last night on some work, so I am going to offer him the chance to go first, as a--all right, thanks Governor, appreciate you. Thanks, Mr. Chair. Mr. Christensen, in North Dakota and Wyoming, we both have split estates where you have got federal, state, and privately owned minerals that are co-located. And in some instances, the federal minerals have no surface acreage. So, I have legislation in that I call the BLM Mineral Spacing Act, where the Federal Government has--BLM has no federal acreage so you avoid duplicate permitting when you are trying to drill for oil and gas. Does that make some sense to you, and protect private property rights while helping our country develop more energy? Mr. Christensen. Yeah, that's certainly a great idea. I think the split estate---- Senator Hoeven. Would you encourage the Chair and the Ranking Member of this Committee, strongly, to advance that legislation so that we can pass it on the floor? Mr. Christensen. If Senator Barrasso is for it, I think we are for it too. Senator Hoeven. Okay. He is for it. Mr. Christensen. Great. Senator Hoeven. He is probably on it. Thanks. Did you want to add anything? Mr. Christensen. Well, just on the split estate issue. It is unique that you have federal regulations that can control surface use, pipelines, rights-of-way, roads, when you are dealing with something that is owned underneath the ground. And so, there is sort of a complicated maze here. And again, I said it earlier--our states don't just have giant blocks of BLM land. We have checkerboarded. We have state lands all in between. And so, it's not a one size fits all. There are a lot of places that could see development that simply can't because federal lands might restrict right-of-way access. And so, they have no takeaway--things like that. So, it is a complex issue that should be looked into. Senator Hoeven. Yeah, thank you. And then, for Mr. Brown, Mr. Christensen, and Mr. Sheehan-- the BLM resource management plan put forward by the Biden administration for our state would have closed off 45 percent of our oil and gas to development and 99 percent of the federal coal acreage. I'm not sure why they left one percent available. I'm not sure what the point of that was, but they closed off 99 percent. Do each of you agree that an expanded federal regulatory approach like that is absolutely a problem if we are going to follow the law, which is multiple use on federal lands, meaning producing energy, you know, farming and ranching, tourism, and something that Senator Heinrich and I enjoy very much, which is hunting? So, fire away guys, starting with Mr. Brown. Mr. Brown. I would agree, and I think if you look at the map that Chairman Lee put up, it shows the transition from multiple-use lands to single-designation lands in my state, which are millions and millions of acres since FLPMA was passed. And so, I think it's all the more important that there's some sort of collaboration between the Federal Government and the state so you don't see those kinds of overreaches. Senator Hoeven. Yeah, it's hardly multiple use when you close off--I guess the one-percent was to maintain though. Mr. Brown. There is the multiple use, right? Senator Hoeven. Right, I mean, come on. Okay, who's next? Mr. Christensen. Mr. Christensen. Senator Hoeven---- Senator Hoeven. And by the way, don't take any more of our football coaches, all right? Mr. Christensen. We miss him already. Senator Hoeven. I know, he's a good one. Mr. Christensen. So, I think one thing that is interesting, when we talk about areas being closed, or just because an area is open for coal leasing does not necessarily mean it's going to be leased. It does not mean that we are going to have big mines there. It means that we have the opportunity to look into it or to invest in that if we need it. So reopening lands does not inherently change the landscape. There is still a permitting process. There is still infrastructure that needs to be built. So, closing lands seems so simple and so easy. Opening them should be the same way, but there is really a lot more to it than just opening and closing. There is an industry component. Senator Hoeven. Right on. Mr. Sheehan. Mr. Sheehan. Yeah, certainly I think what Mr. Christensen said is accurate. Having lands open for any of these extractive uses still requires mining plans, still requires reclamation planning, still requires evaluation of multiple resource uses, as well as Endangered Species Act, as well as National Historical Preservation Act, all that. So, I think when you have these open, there is still a lot of work ahead, but I don't know the exact, specific details in the North Dakota plan, but certainly, I am a proponent of multiple-use, sustained-yield. That's the tenet of---- Senator Hoeven. Well, I have got to get one hunting question in. Mr. Sheehan. Okay, get that in, yes. Senator Hoeven. I am sure the Ranking Member has worked you over on the hunting issues, but you know, any thoughts you have on what Congress can do to streamline the BLM planning and process and improve coordination within the state and the Federal Government as far as hunting issues? Any big recommendations? Mr. Sheehan. Well, you know, we obviously recognize that the states have that authority of wildlife management, but it's very important to a lot of these species. Senator Heinrich mentioned, you know, migratory corridors and things. We have learned a lot, even in the last ten years, about wildlife, and wildlife are struggling. Mule deer populations are down roughly 60 percent since the 1960s, and they continue to decline across the West. So, we care about that. And I think, you know, as we undergo planning or we work together with states and listen and coordinate with state fish and game agencies and do our planning work, that we take those factors into consideration and try to keep those species around---- Senator Hoeven. Yeah, it's actually the hunters that do a lot for livestock. Mr. Sheehan. Absolutely. Hunters help---- Senator Hoeven. And try to protect against disease and all those kinds of things. Mr. Sheehan. Yes, there are lots of challenges out there, but I appreciate your support and all of the hunters here on the Committee and in the room who support mule deer. Senator Hoeven. And yours. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Heinrich. Senator Hoeven, Senator King took issue with Mr. Sheehan because he doesn't represent white-tails, but as you know, the best states have both white-tails and mule deer, and the best state has white-tails, mule deer, and Coues deer, which is a very special white-tail. Mr. Sheehan. You might be the only state. I would have to look---- Senator Hoeven. Yeah, I was going to say. The Chairman. Which state could that be? [Laughter.] Senator Hoeven. Yeah, can't guess which state, but right on. Senator Hickenlooper. I think there might be two states with all three. Mr. Sheehan. Maybe Texas and maybe Arizona, probably Texas. The Chairman. Senator Hickenlooper. Senator Hickenlooper. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thanks to all of you for your work. Obviously, Coloradans cherish their public lands. When there were threats to sell public lands, there was an outrage, a giant pushback on that. And we have seen a lot of energy around how do we increase protections for public land, as well as seeking opportunities to enhance conservation through things like the Public Lands Rule, which we are still working on. Mr. Cramer, I will start with you. How does the health of our public lands, how does that really impact recreation? Mr. Cramer. Thanks for the question, Senator Hickenlooper. They are connected. I mean, you can't really have outdoor recreation without a setting. It does not mean anything. I mean, you need a place to paddle or to ride your bike or to go ski, so the setting--the place--is foundational for these pursuits to take place. And then, for the--these places are meaningful to individuals, to how they contribute to local economies, and the broader outdoor recreation industry. Place is essential. Senator Hickenlooper. Yeah, well, and we have seen that, you know, the value of outdoor recreation across the West is crazy. I mean, it's $17 billion just in Colorado and across the West. Just on BLM lands, we see somewhere like $6 to $7 billion. These are enormous sums. These are annualized numbers. Mr. Sheehan, I wanted to ask you also, just your take on FLPMA and how it helps provide a framework for conservation on our public lands. Are there some common-sense ways we can make that better? Mr. Sheehan. Yes, I think, you know, as we look at all the values--thank you, Senator Hickenlooper, for that question--you know, wildlife don't have much of a voice for themselves, so we have to look out for them, but I think what is critical is that--let's identify the areas that are most important and make sure we protect those, but let's, you know, we may not need to protect at a high level every inch of publicly managed land to help protect the wildlife that rely on those landscapes. So, I think through any of these planning processes or any of the work that happens within the planning processes, once they are implemented, we need to use the best current knowledge, best information, and make sure that we give this wildlife an opportunity to persist in the efforts that we undertake. Senator Hickenlooper. Yes. Mr. Sheehan. Thank you. Senator Hickenlooper. Give them at least a fair shot. I spent a--I guess I did seven hunts when I was Governor, up in Lander, Wyoming, for the one-shot antelope hunt, which is always--for those of us who aren't terribly good shots, was always a struggle because you only get one shot, but we did, my last year, Governor Matt Mead was sadly disappointed when our team won the whole shebang. Let me go back, Mr. Kenna, Congress amended FLPMA in 2018 to require BLM to issue regulations for transmission rights-of- way. The final rule directs BLM to enhance the reliability of the grid and reduce the threat of wildfire damage to transmission lines, which, all across the West, has become a huge issue. The cost of insurance right now, the rising cost of utilities having to rebuild that infrastructure after these fires is enormous, as wildfire risk is such a major priority, and we have a bill, the Fix Our Forests Act, which I think will help reduce fire risk in transmission corridors and in high- risk areas more broadly. How could we use the planning process to not just prevent the wildfires, but also enhance grid reliability? Mr. Kenna. Interesting question, Senator, thank you for that. One of the things that I have found in my career with planning is that there are two things to sort of pay attention to in any given planning area. And what you have when you talk about the grid in the West is a whole bunch of regional issues that are overlaid. It's different in the Bonneville Power region, for example, than it is in California, than it is in Arizona and so forth. So, the complexity is very, very real. But the things that I concentrate on are, what do you need to do in terms of the speed of trust? If you set the process up front, you have got to make sure that you don't try to go so fast that you don't keep everybody with you. And in each of those different regions, I think, what I--and this is probably not good wording--but what I have traditionally called the ``honesty habit.'' Some different areas have different capacity to tackle things like the wildlife trends that we heard discussed earlier where you see wildlife is declining. So, what is our issue here--or the fire with transmission issue, same thing. You have to be able to directly address the issue forthrightly and honestly with a whole range of constituencies. And when you are talking about a west-wide grid, that's a very complex undertaking. Senator Hickenlooper. Right, I appreciate that. Thank you all. I yield back to the Chair. The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Hickenlooper. All right, before we adjourn, I think Senator Henrich and I have just a couple of follow-up questions. Mr. Sheehan, let's go back to you for a moment. A lot of the BLM plans that are still in effect in Utah today were written in the early 1980s. So, we are talking, you know, 40 to 45 years ago. How realistic is it for BLM to manage fire, habitat, recreation, and energy projects and so forth under plans that were written before modern data, modern modeling techniques, or current demands even existed? And also, can you help us understand why it is that some of these plans, 40 to 45 years old, haven't been updated in that time period? Mr. Sheehan. Sure, thank you, Chairman Lee. First of all, it is vital, right? Changing circumstances-- your words, right? What do we know differently than we knew in 1983? A lot of the people in this room weren't born in 1983. And I was, unfortunately, or maybe fortunately, but you know, we have got to look at how has the world changed? What do we know now? What do we know about rare earth minerals that we didn't know then and maybe where they are? What do we know about some of these habitats that are shared by wildlife and wild horses and livestock communities? Do we need to revisit that? What do we know that's different now about uses that, you know, many have interest in putting renewable energy on public lands, you know, how has recreation changed? You look at the vehicle, in 1983 you didn't have side-by-sides and maybe not even Harley four-wheelers, right? And now they are quite prevalent. So, if we can't address the, you know, updating these plans on some regular basis, it's going to be very, very difficult to move forward. And it just makes sense, I think we all try to, you know, reevaluate our lives from time to time and you know, what has happened different than what we knew, as far as, you know, what's it going to take to get us there? You know, some of these plans I look at--Cedar City, Utah, you know, the southern Utah plan, you know, that started a dozen years ago. And it really still hasn't gone anywhere. When we initially-- you know, an early part of planning is scoping. We go out and say, what are the situations out here? What do we need to know? And we do an analysis of management situations and we say, how has the world changed? And maybe we just need to make sure that we continue to evaluate those top priorities. When I served in BLM, we had lists, and I am sure they would be happy to give you that. What are the top priority plans? Cedar City is one of the top on the list that, you know, as administrations change, priorities change, some of these plans continue, you know, to be redone, and it leaves a lot of these things on the sidelines. But if we are going to manage public lands, I think it's vital, as you point out, that we have to get this planning work done or we're not in a good place. The Chairman. It's a good point. As someone mentioned earlier today, typewriters were still in wide use. Some of these probably---- Mr. Sheehan. We have one. I have one. The Chairman. In many cases, the Commodore 64 was still an emerging technology. Great computer though, and some good gaming opportunities when I was in grade school. [Laughter.] The Chairman. All right, shifting gears for a moment. Under Section 603(c) of FLPMA, the Secretary of the Interior, for BLM, was given the task of designating wilderness study areas, and under Section 603(c), once the wilderness study area has been designated, only Congress can release the WSA, and the WSA, unless or until such time as Congress releases it, has to manage it as if were wilderness, designated as such by Congress. History has shown that these releases rarely occur, and so, this allows many millions of acres to be managed as de facto wilderness without ever specifically having been designated as such by Congress. So, how workable a system is that where one agency can unilaterally designate a WSA, and it can't be unlocked except by an act of Congress? I have been wracking my brain over the last couple of days trying to find any parallel to this. The U.S. code is replete with instances in which we delegated significant authority to an executive branch agency, but I am not aware of any other circumstance like this one where the authorization for an agency to exercise administrative authority becomes a complete one-way ratchet. It takes on some of the trappings of a statute and can't be revisited later in light of a subsequent finding that either the original decision was wrong or it has become outdated or otherwise. So, just tell us about how workable that sort of thing is, and how that may make things difficult for land managers. Mr. Sheehan. Yes, certainly, in these planning processes, as you point out, the BLM has authority to designate a wilderness study area. They can take an area of land and say, you know, in their opinion, in that planning opinion, that should be a wilderness study area. And further to your point, you acknowledge that only Congress can undo that. A future executive administration cannot undo what is done in that plan. And so, I can't say there are no other instances in Federal Government that allow, sort of, an agency or bureau to create an action that really elevates itself instantly to a congressional action that can't be undone, even in the future by the executive side. So, I, you know, whether it's a major problem or not, I am not certain how many of those WSAs are being designated now, but it's certainly curious that, you know, we have an ability to--in this case, the Bureau of Land Management--designate something. That has sort of a de facto effect of permanency behind it. The Chairman. Thank you. Senator Heinrich. Senator Heinrich. Mr. Cramer, there was recently a new report that came out that looked at outdoor recreation on public lands, and the scale of the economic impact of that was estimated at over $350 million per day. That's at a scale bigger than logging and mining taken together, and certainly has had a huge impact in my state on a lot of gateway communities to these public lands. But many of the plans that are on the books right now were written at a time when that scale was much smaller, and when it was sometimes not even considered. Do you think, in your experience, do land managers actually know all of the places and mechanisms that people use to recreate on the public lands that they manage, and for your typical BLM District Manager, do they know all the places that people hike, and climb, and hunt, or bike, or do they need a public process to understand where those things occur, and where conflicts might occur? Mr. Cramer. Great question, Senator Heinrich. I think they know a lot because they are there, and in some cases they might know almost all of them, but why not check? Why not double check? I mean, as you point out, there is so much desire to be outside, and the economic activity that tiers off of that desire is substantial. And if we don't inventory where these places are, where they could be, we are just leaving a ton on the table in terms of economic activity. In some cases, it's not--you might want to develop recreation infrastructure where there isn't recreation infrastructure to make sure there is equitable access for more people and it's closer to places where people live. So, data about this stuff is very liberating and it's available and accessible, you know, through my organization, Outdoor Alliance, and through a lot of companies that have a tremendous amount of data, and they are very generous about it. So, we get to a better place with this information, for sure. Senator Heinrich. As most folks in this room are aware, New Mexico produces a lot of oil and gas, but we have a lot of public lands. We value those public lands and we also rely on outdoor recreation, hunting and fishing, and other things to generate economic activity in our state. And so, the balance of those things is really important to us. You know, the budget bill this summer elevated oil and gas leasing above other uses on public lands by literally requiring the BLM to offer any parcel for leasing if it's open for oil and gas development in an RMP--a resource management plan. Now, before that change, the BLM would first look and consider oil and gas development and whether it was the best use for a parcel before offering the lease. And now, oil and gas gets preferential treatment over those other uses. So, Mr. Cramer, for people who like to recreate on public lands, what are the consequences of saying things are multiple use but then elevating certain uses above others? Mr. Cramer. Just setting things up for more conflict and slowing things down. You know, it's really, as a lot of the witnesses have shared, it's a composition of all these elements, and you need to allow that composition to be composed in a way that's in everybody's best interest. Senator Heinrich. Yes. Mr. Chairman, I think I am done. The Chairman. Thank you so much. Well, I want to thank each of you for being here today. You have all brought unique expertise to the table, and we have learned a lot from this. And so, this will conclude today's hearing. I want to thank my colleagues for participating, and especially our witnesses for being here. Any member of the Committee who wishes to submit questions for the record, any additional questions that haven't been asked today, may do so. The deadline for submitting those will be 6:00 p.m. tomorrow, Thursday, November 20th. Senators also have until 6:00 p.m. this coming Wednesday, November 26th, to add statements for the record of today's hearing. We received one of those from Senator Risch already today. He had to run to a Foreign Relations hearing that he was chairing, but that will be added without objection. So, thanks again for being here, for your testimony, and for answering our questions. The Committee stands adjourned. Thanks. [Whereupon, at 11:25 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] APPENDIX MATERIAL SUBMITTED ---------- [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]