Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- THE U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE'S PROPOSED FISCAL YEAR 2025 BUDGET [Senate Hearing 118-721] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 118-721 THE U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE'S PROPOSED FISCAL YEAR 2025 BUDGET ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED EIGHTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ JUNE 12, 2024 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Environment and Public Works [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 61-834 WASHINGTON : 2025 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS ONE HUNDRED EIGHTEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION THOMAS R. CARPER, Delaware, Chairman SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia, Ranking Member BENJAMIN L. CARDIN, Maryland KEVIN CRAMER, North Dakota BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island MARKWAYNE MULLIN, Oklahoma JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas DEBBIE STABENOW, Michigan ROGER WICKER, Mississippi MARK KELLY, Arizona DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska ALEX PADILLA, California LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania Courtney Taylor, Democratic Staff Director Adam Tomlinson, Republican Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- Page JUNE 12, 2024 OPENING STATEMENTS Carper, Hon. Thomas R., U.S. Senator from the State of Delaware.. 1 Capito, Hon. Shelley Moore, U.S. Senator from the State Of West Virginia....................................................... 3 WITNESS Williams, Hon. Martha, Director, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.. 6 Prepared statement........................................... 8 ADDITIONAL MATERIAL Letter from Senator Dan Sullivan of Alaska to Hon. Deb Haaland, Secretary, U.S. Department of the Interior..................... 43 Fish and Wildlife Service 2025 Budget Request.................... 48 THE U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE'S PROPOSED FISCAL YEAR 2025 BUDGET ---------- WEDNESDAY, JUNE 12, 2024 U.S. Senate, Committee on Environment and Public Works, Washington, DC. The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:03 a.m. in room 406, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Thomas R. Carper (chairman of the committee) presiding. Present: Carper, Capito, Cardin, Whitehouse, Kelly, Lummis, Ricketts, Boozman. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. THOMAS R. CARPER, U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF DELAWARE Senator Carper. Good morning, everyone. The hearing will come to order. Today, as you all know, we are here to discuss President Biden's Fiscal Year 2025 budget request for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. We always appreciate the presence of Martha Williams, the Director of the Service, before our committee. Thank you for appearing today, and welcome back. We have heard time and time again in our committee that wildlife conservation works best for people and for species when it is collaborative, when it is inclusive, when it is proactive. Director Williams leads the Service with those thoughts in mind. The President's Fiscal Year 2025 budget request also embodies, I believe, we believe, this approach, and we look forward to hearing more about it from you today as our witness. The President's budget request includes $1.9 billion for the Fish and Wildlife Service. That is a 10 percent increase in funding over Fiscal Year 2024 enacted levels. One of the things we will get into in the course of our hearing is, 10 percent is not an insignificant increase, as you know, but I always like to ask, compared to what? I would like to look at the increases in the last couple of years, or the cuts in the last couple of years, that were proposed in this Administration and the previous Administration. The increase of 10 percent, coupled with the investments that we made, in no small part from this committee room, but through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and through the Inflation Reduction Act, would provide the Service with the support it needs to carry out its many important missions. Specifically, the President's proposed budget would support the Fish and Wildlife Service's work to conserve habitat, to combat climate change, to address biodiversity loss, and to maintain our national wildlife refuges, which we are all very proud of. All of these initiatives protect our planet while helping to drive our economy at the same time. A reasonable question is, how would the President's budget support these efforts? First, the budget request includes some $602 million for the National Wildlife Refuge System. That is, I believe, a 14 or 15 percent increase from Fiscal Year 2024's enacted levels. This funding would support habitat conservation as well as law enforcement and visitor services at over some 500 national wildlife refuges across the Country. We have two of them in Delaware. How many does West Virginia have? Senator Capito. Wildlife? Senator Carper. Wildlife refuges. Senator Capito. Just one, I think. Senator Carper. Okay. Two weeks ago, I was privileged to visit one of Delaware's two national wildlife refuges called the Bombay Hook National Wildlife Refuge in the central part of our State. Imperiled species such as red knot and piping plover birds call this refuge home. People come literally from all over the world to see these species in their natural habitat. They also come to hike, they come to bicycle, and they come to hunt in these special places. When they do, they support our local economies. I think the same is true in refuges in every one of our other 49 States. The Administration's budget request also includes funding increases for programs focused on stemming biodiversity loss, including notable increases for Endangered Species Act planning, consultation, and recovery efforts. Why are these investments in biodiversity important? Well, for a couple of reasons. One, our food system relies on biodiversity for pest control, for pollination, and for soil fertility. When our forests and oceans are healthy and biodiverse, they absorb more carbon dioxide, which is a good thing. We also rely on biodiverse ecosystems to provide us with clean water to drink. For all of these reasons and for more, biodiversity loss has significant economic impacts. According to a recent report by, I believe it was J.P. Morgan, biodiversity loss costs the global economy an estimated $20 trillion per year. When I saw that number, I had my staff double check. I said, is that trillion, with a ``t''? They said, that is $20 trillion, with a ``t.'' That is a ton of money. The Fiscal Year 2025 budget request also details how the Fish and Wildlife Service is implementing the Inflation Reduction Act by incorporating nature-based solutions into ecosystem restoration. For example, the Service is working with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, with Ducks Unlimited, and with the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission to enhance more than 5,000 acres of wetlands in Arkansas, and I see we have been joined by our colleague from Arkansas. Specifically, the Service will restore the wetlands' natural ability to capture, store, and release rainwater and mitigate the effects of severe weather events. We have seen firsthand in the first State, my State, and many other States that nature-based solutions actually do work. When Hurricane Sandy damaged the Prime Hook National Wildlife Refuge in our State, the Fish and Wildlife Service restored the refuge with climate resilience in mind. Not only did this restoration effort conserve habitat and benefit endangered species, it also addressed longstanding flooding issues in a nearby community. We call that, in our State, a win-win situation. That is what we are always looking for. Furthermore, the budget request of the President builds on our Inflation Reduction Act investments by including funding increases for programs like Partners for Fish and Wildlife and the Coastal Program. These programs are focused on improving ecosystems, as well as coastal resiliency through partnerships with States, partnerships with tribes, and partnerships with landowners. The President's budget request complements the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law by enabling the Service to continue implementing successful programs like the National Fish Passage Program. This program funds aquatic ecosystem restoration projects while supporting local economies. In addition to implementing the agency's own Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and Inflation Reduction Act funding, the Service is faced with an increasingly heavy workload as a result of Congress' investments in other agencies. The Fish and Wildlife Service's role in the Federal permitting process is especially important, given the historic passage of these laws. As part of its congressionally mandated responsibilities, the Service must consult with other agencies to ensure that we are deploying the investments from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, as well as from the Inflation Reduction Act, and issuing permits in a way that does not jeopardize species. However, neither the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law nor the Inflation Reduction Act included funding for the Service's responsibilities relating to permitting. In other words, Congress increased the number of environmental reviews that the Service must complete without providing the resources necessary to meet the increased workload. Fortunately, the President's 2025 budget would provide the Service with adequate resources to improve efficiencies in the environmental review process, while also protecting species. I would just add, I think we can do both, and I believe we must do both. As our colleagues on this committee oftentimes hear me say, we need to find out what works and do more of that. Having said that, we look forward to hearing from Director Williams today on what is working, and perhaps what is not working, and how the President's 2025 budget will support the Fish and Wildlife Service's important work. Before we do that, I want to turn to our Ranking Member, Senator Capito, for her opening statement. Let's have a great hearing today. Thank you. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA Senator Capito. Well, thank you, Chairman Carper, for holding today's hearing. Welcome, again, to Director Williams. It is always great to see you and your staff. I appreciate your coming before the committee today to discuss the Fish and Wildlife budget for 2025. In previous hearings, we have discussed my frustration that the consultation process under the Endangered Species Act has delayed critical projects in West Virginia and elsewhere. By the way, thank you for coming to West Virginia very early in your tenure. We are still very appreciative of that. Our State department of highways has faced delays on road and bridge projects, and our State DEP (State Departments of Environmental Protection) has dealt with delays on active mining permits and on projects to remediate abandoned mine sites through the AML (Abandoned Mine Land) program. If I sound like a broken record, I guess that is because I am. Those statements were taken from my opening statement at a hearing held around this time last year, and here we are again, seemingly in pretty close to the same position. My staff has been meeting with your staff regularly, and I appreciate that, for 2 years now. Effective communication and timeframes on consultations have only marginally improved. Currently, the field office has agreements with the West Virginia Department of Highways, the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection, the U.S. Forest Service, and the Gas and Oil Association of West Virginia to fund staff positions. Not all of those positions have been filled. The office's work force is being supplemented considerably by outside groups, and that was some of the substance of our conversation 2 years ago. State agencies in West Virginia continue to be bogged down by a back and forth with the field office on details which at times concern issues beyond the jurisdiction or expertise of your agency, in some cases, requiring project details on mines that date back to the 1950's. In May, the West Virginia Coal Association issued a notice of intent to sue the Service for violating the 2020 Biological Opinion for the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement's Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Projects. That is a mouthful, there. The 2020 Biological Opinion establishes a programmatic approach to consultation on OSMRE (Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement) projects and outlines coordination and elevation procedures to expedite reviews and effectively resolve disputes. According to West Virginia's notice of intent to sue, the field office has been blatantly disregarding this Biological Opinion. Specifically, the field office is not adhering to the 30-day coordination deadlines set by that 2020 document. Just a couple of months ago, the field office issued a permitting template, which was intended to expedite this application process. However, the information required by that template goes above and beyond the requirements of the 2020 Biological Opinion and is almost to the level of information needed to complete a full formal consultation or an environmental impact statement. Some of these projects covered by the 2020 document are as simple as ventilation holes, and yet, the field office seems unwilling to complete the consultation until they have studied the history of the mine dating back decades and analyzed even the types of construction equipment that will be used. West Virginia DEP is having to elevate some of these consultations as emergent just to keep the mines in the State operating. While my State is already facing problems with ESA consultations, the Service in D.C. here is rolling back commonsense reforms that were implemented in 2019 and will make ESA implementation even more complicated. Specifically, the Service reinstated the blanket 4(d) rule, which effectively treats all threatened species as endangered. The Service will no longer consider economic impacts when making species listing decisions. The Service removed language in its Section 7 interagency coordination process that limits reviews to ``activities that are reasonably certain to occur,'' which allows field offices to assess activities that are well beyond the scope of a proposed project, and the Service rescinded the definition of habitat in determining critical habitat designations. So, I am a cosponsor of congressional Review Act resolutions led my Senators Lummis, Ricketts, and Sullivan to overrule these three regulatory actions by the Service. I appreciate a lot the dialog that we have had between our staff and yours over the past couple of years, but we are at another crossroads again and I look forward to learning from you what solutions we can use together to address these endless paperwork exercises and delays. With that, I will yield back. Senator Carper. Great. We will have some time here today to address, I hope, all the points that you have just raised. As you know, we have a bunch of other committees that we all serve on. Members will be coming and going. They have already begun coming and going, and others, some of them will come back and be part of this conversation today. I am going to turn now to our witness. Martha Williams, as we all know, is currently serving our Nation as the Director of Fish and Wildlife Service. How many months now have you been in that role? How many months? Ms. Williams. Chairman, I have not been counting, but I at least realize it has been over 3 years now. Senator Carper. Does it seem longer? Ms. Williams. No, it has been remarkably amazing. It has been more wonderful than I would have expected. Senator Carper. Is not that great? I feel that way about what I do here. That is good. Prior to your leadership role at the Fish and Wildlife Service, you served as the Director of the Montana Department of Fish and Wildlife and Parks. I understand you are a lifelong outdoor enthusiast and enjoy hiking, hunting, and fishing. You are pretty well cut out for this job. Welcome back to our committee. Please proceed with your statement, and we will have some questions when you are finished. Thanks so much for joining us. STATEMENT OF HON. MARTHA WILLIAMS, DIRECTOR, U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE Ms. Williams. Good morning, Chairman Carper, Ranking Member Capito, and members of the committee. I really appreciate the opportunity to testify today on the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's 2025 budget request. The President's budget for the Fish and Wildlife Service totals $1.9 billion, an increase of $163.4 million above the 2024 enacted level. The budget promotes strategic investments to conserve fish and wildlife species that face many stressors. It connects Americans with the outdoors, facilitates economic development, and creates good-paying jobs. The Fish and Wildlife Service is a field-based organization that works collaboratively and creatively to meet our responsibilities. Our 9,000 dedicated employees carry out our work across eight regional offices and 800 field stations across the Country. These biologists, refuge managers, hatchery operators, law enforcement officers, maintenance professionals, and wildland firefighters and more depend on relationships to help implement our mission in ways that respect the needs of local communities and fit the places where we work. We partner with everyone. Although we are a relatively small agency, these many partnerships greatly increase our effectiveness and reach. Over the course of my career, and now as director, I have seen this firsthand. Just last week, I saw two examples of how the Fish and Wildlife Service is the glue to impactful partnerships built for the places where they are. I saw our leadership working to combat aquatic invasive species in Lake Tahoe and to address grizzly bear conflict in the Blackfoot Valley in Montana. Our collaborative work in the Blackfoot, as an example, is a remarkable story of ranchers and landowners, tribes, nonprofit organizations, State and Federal agencies, and local communities coming together to find solutions that keep ranchers on their land, keep their animals safe, and simultaneously allow grizzly bears to be on the landscape, too. I saw innovative solutions, including technology like electronic mats to keep livestock in or out, and virtual fencing to control livestock movement, and then livestock carcass management to prevent grizzlies from being attracted to the site. These actions keep ranchers ranching and conserve grizzly bears and a way of life, all in an effort to allow for thriving and connected landscapes. Through funding from USDA and the Fish and Wildlife Service, these efforts are being scaled up across Montana and on to other States. The work of the Blackfoot Valley stands as a national model for successful collaboration. Such efforts would not be possible without the years of relationship- building and leadership of the Fish and Wildlife Service staff on the ground. This is where we shine. Our staff bring parties together, bring them to the table, to work together to solve problems and ensure durable and lasting conservation for species, and supporting the communities in which they live. Building and sustaining partnerships like these takes people and resources. However, over the past 20 years, due to relentless budget constraints, the Fish and Wildlife Service has had to significantly reduce our work force, stretching our ability to do our work safely and proactively to the point of snapping. The Fish and Wildlife Service has consistently adapted and stretched our resources. For example, we seek reimbursable agreements to support our staffing needs because we do not have the capacity to staff each refuge as a standalone unit. We now administer units of the refuge system under what we call a complex structure to achieve management efficiencies. When Congress, though, invests in this work, as it did under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, the Fish and Wildlife Service, together with our partners, has demonstrated that we can do great things for wildlife, local communities, and the economy. It has given us a chance to show just what we can achieve together. If funded, our budget request would help restore capacity in key areas, and, as a result, provide positive impacts to people, communities, and habitat. We would maximize the budget's investments by leveraging capacity of our partners and tailoring implementation of our mission to meet the conditions and needs of local situations. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify before you today. I would be pleased to answer any questions that you may have. [The prepared statement of Ms. Williams follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Carper. Great. Well, thanks for joining us, again, today. I am going to go back to what I said in my opening statement. I think what I said is that the President's budget request includes $1.9 billion for the Fish and Wildlife Service. That is a 10 percent increase in funding over, I think, over what was funded for the current year, 2024. I oftentimes say, compared to what, when I am talking with folks, including in this room with our witnesses. Ten percent compared to what? Through the years before that, the decade before that? Give us some ideas, so we will have some sense of reference. Ms. Williams. Chairman Carper, thank you for that question. We have put, I have put a lot of thought into this question for numerous reasons. These are, it is compared to the 2024 enacted level, but when we look back over the last decade, the capacity within the Fish and Wildlife Service has continued to decrease by 20 percent. So as we think about rebuilding and being able to meet our statutory obligations plus being able to do the proactive work so that, for example, species do not have to be listed, so that we can be more efficient in our Section 7 consultation, we are thinking about, how do we build for the future in an efficient manner. So we are not just looking back to the last 10 years where we had larger capacity and saying we want it to be just like that. Instead, what we are thinking about is, how do we build from what we have now? How do we get through these lean years, first, and then how do we build going forward that meets the needs of today? Senator Carper. I am going to ask you in a separate question for the record, I want to make sure that I am comparing apples to apples. The 10 percent increase being requested, I want to be able to compare that apple to what has gone on in recent years. That will be a question for the record. My next questions deal with Endangered Species Act consultation and permitting. The Fiscal Year 2025 budget request includes about $147 million to increase environmental permitting capacity, which would be an increase of some $28 million. The Fish and Wildlife Service issues, as you know, a variety of permits under its wildlife protection statutes, but I want to focus today specifically on Endangered Species Act consultation. Consultation, as you know, is one of the Fish and Wildlife Service's most important responsibilities, but I find that a lot of people do not really know what consultation means or why it is essential to the Service's mission. My question is this: would you spend a minute or two explaining for us what consultation means when the Service does it, and how it protects species? Ms. Williams. Thank you for that question, Chairman Carper. I think back on the Endangered Species Act, and many people focus on Section 4 under the Endangered Species Act, and that is listing or the delisting process. The real heart of the Endangered Species Act is Section 7, that when Congress passed the Endangered Species Act, they set out Section 7 specifically to provide a means to conserve the ecosystems upon which endangered and threatened species depend. There are two parts to Section 7 under the Endangered Species Act: one that directs all Federal agencies to participate in conserving these species, so this is not just up to National Marine Fisheries Service and the Fish and Wildlife Service, it is up to all of government. The second part of Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act specifically says that when a Federal agency takes an action they must ensure that their activities are not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of threatened or endangered species. So that is what triggers what we call Section 7 consultation. It is that requirement that Federal agencies need to make sure any act they undertake or permit or fund do not jeopardize these species. That is what sends in motion the consultation process with the Fish and Wildlife Service. Senator Carper. Thank you for that response. I am going to yield to Senator Capito, and then I am going to come back and followup this line of questioning. Thank you. Senator Capito? Senator Capito. Great, thank you. I want to talk about the field office in West Virginia unexpectedly determined that a formal consultation was necessary for the Roaring Run Bridge project, which is part of the Corridor H project, but there is an issue here. I think you are aware of it. In order to ensure that Federal funding can still be spent on this project this year, this consultation needs to be completed by July. The field office and the regional staff, including Director Weber, have committed to making this a top priority. I have been told that the Department of Highways and the field office had a very productive meeting last week. Director Williams, I am just asking if you would commit to making this a priority, because if we do not get this done by July, it is going to be another year off. Ms. Williams. Ranking Member Capito, absolutely. I will make it a priority, and I understand that our West Virginia Field Office just received the Biological Assessment from the West Virginia Department of Transportation for Roaring Run, and that they indeed are in line to turn it around by the end of July. I would love to add just a deep appreciation for your engagement on this issue and your staff and meeting with Wendi Weber and all of us to really find a path forward where the Fish and Wildlife Service is not the bottleneck to these projects. We want to help them go forward. Senator Capito. Thank you. So, it has been 2 years since we came. We met with the DEP and DOH (Department of Health) and some other people, and then, I want to give you a chance to respond to my opening statement where I said that the Coal Association is intending to sue because the field office is in, they believe, violation of the 2020 Biological Opinion. We are restarting consultation on 880 mining permits with seemingly no plan to handle the workload. DEP is experiencing months of back-and-forth on the protection enhancement plans that ultimately required no substantive changes, and DOH has just decided to go to formal consultations, because the back and forth is taking too long. How do we resolve these challenges? We still need to, I think, work on improvement. What are we going to do about all these permits that are going to have to be re-looked at, as I mentioned in my opening statement, asking for information that goes well beyond what has been asked for in the past? Ms. Williams. Ranking Member Capito, I wish I had an easy one sentence answer to that, but I can speak to how we are trying to address this challenge and get beyond it. First off, as we recognize, we have had a 23 percent reduction in staff regarding consultations. We have had over, thank you to the Investment and Infrastructure, we have more and more projects coming our way than we have ever had before, let alone the OSMRE, these restarting these 880 permits. We have had a decrease in staff and increase in consultations. We have thought about it in a number of ways. We are, first off, we have developed this innovative online system to kick out those projects that do not even need further discussion or consultation. Senator Capito. Is that working now? Ms. Williams. That is working now, and is only improving. Fifty percent of the permits that are coming through that system are based in West Virginia, so it is working now. Senator Capito. Is that of the 880 permits? Ms. Williams. That is not of the OSMRE permits. Senator Capito. That is a separate thing. Ms. Williams. I can speak to, first, if I can pull back and talk about how we are trying to address Section 7 consultations, where we have had a decrease in capacity. We are requesting more capacity. Thank you for your leadership and others in the transfer authorities, so we can be bringing in, as we have in the West Virginia Field Office, more staff. We have to do it more quickly. We have to be thinking forward and be prepared for the permits as they come in. We are being more efficient now in weeding out those projects that do not need formal consultation. We have had over 11,000 informal consultations, 1,000 formal consultations. We are just trying to, one step at a time, be more efficient and pay attention and move our resources to where we have those formal consultations. With that said, for the 880 permits from the litigation with OSMRE and the Biological Opinion, we are working diligently with our sister bureau, OSMRE. Wendi Weber is in constant contact with them, and as you mentioned, we had first had this template. We are working on a better template. I am very interested in following up on where you think we have gone too far, and we can address those issues. I hope I am answering your question and the big picture. Senator Capito. You are answering the question, but as I stated in my opening statement, DOH, the Gas and Oil Association in West Virginia, DEP, recognizing that there is a capacity issue here, has funded into that office positions that have not been filled. If the argument is, we do not have the people to do this processing, and you are given the money to do the processing, but you are not hiring the people. Ms. Williams. I can understand that frustration, Senator Capito, but it does not all have, you know, had we been able to look ahead for the increase in projects coming through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, had we had the money and the capacity, we could have built up ahead of time. Senator Capito. Did you get any extra money? Ms. Williams. Instead, we are on our back foot, and yes, we are in the process of hiring those people, and we are very grateful for the opportunity to. Senator Capito. Did you get, in any of the FRAN, the IRA, or the IIJA, did Fish and Wildlife get any additional moneys in any of those? Ms. Williams. Not to cover this. Senator Capito. No, wait a minute. That is not my question. Did Fish and Wildlife get any additional dollars in these three bills, as a whole? Ms. Williams. Absolutely, we got that money, but we did not get that money to put toward the capacity and the consultation positions. That is a very good question, because it gets to the very heart of the challenge, is that the money that we got, which is terrific, was not, we were not always able to put it into the permanent staff to get these projects going. Senator Capito. Was some of that money for Section 7 consultation? Am I saying that right? Is it Section 7? It has a seven in it. Ms. Williams. Senator Capito, I do not believe that any of that money was specifically to Section 7, but I would like to get back to you on that, because this has been the challenge we shared in the past 3 years. Senator Capito. Thank you. Senator Carper. Thank you, Senator Capito. We have been joined by Senator Ricketts, faithful in attendance. It is great to see you. How are you today? Welcome. Senator Ricketts. I am doing great, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, Ranking Member Capito, for holding this hearing today. Thank you, Director Williams, for joining us. I want, again, to say thank you for the work that Fish and Wildlife has done on the Platte River recovery and implementation plan. We discussed this yesterday. This innovative and collaborative approach to the program has provided great benefits for the species along the Platte River while recognizing the value of public-private partnerships. Again, as we talked about yesterday, I think that was a great program to highlight for Fish and Wildlife. Also, though, as we discussed yesterday, I have serious concerns about the steps your agency has taken to backtrack on some of this commonsense regulatory reform that was taken by the former Administration. Specifically, I want to address the changes made surrounding critical habitat designation. The 2019 reforms updated the process to require areas where threatened or endangered species are present to be evaluated before unoccupied habitat can be considered critical. These reforms set a higher bar for agencies to designate unoccupied areas as critical habitat by requiring that unoccupied habitat contain one or more of the features required for a species' recovery. Your agency is reversing this commonsense regulation. Potentially, your agency's final rule restricts the sharing of economic impact data, which does not align with the principles of transparency and informed public participation in the rulemaking process, and of course, this Administration originally said it would be the most transparent in history. It has turned out not to be true. Critical habitat designation can carry major economic consequences for landowners and project developers. Landowners are not compensated for the lost value, and critical habitat designation causes significant job losses. My friends in the west vividly remember the 1990 listing of the northern spotted owl, and the nine million acres of critical habitat that caused the loss of 32,000 timber jobs. These were good paying jobs in small communities, which had to be supported by Federal dollars to keep their school systems open following this designation. As you are aware, I am leading a congressional Review Act along with my colleagues, Senator Lummis and Senator Sullivan, to overturn this rulemaking. I appreciate my Republican colleagues' support in overturning this overreach. Director Williams, following the reversal of the reform, what scientific criteria will Fish and Wildlife use to determine the necessity of designating unoccupied areas of critical habitat under this new proposal? Ms. Williams. Senator Ricketts, thank you again for meeting with me yesterday. Overall, regarding these Endangered Species Act regulations, after the last Administration promulgated them, they were litigated. As the President asked us at the beginning of this Administration to review the regulations, and in so doing, it was a policy determination to adhere to the law and the science to make these changes, including, as you asked about, unoccupied habitat. For example, with climate change and other stressors on species, there are times where recovery of a species could go faster and more appropriately in the habitat that is not currently occupied, but is the best habitat for them going forward. Especially when we have, as you have, a State with 93 percent private landowners, where we have landowners who want to restore these species. We would always do this in concert with the State and the landowners. Senator Ricketts. Specifically, getting back to the unoccupied areas, what criteria, what scientific criteria, are you going to use to determine whether or not this is a critical habitat under the new proposed rules? Ms. Williams. It will be necessarily specific to the specific species. Senator Ricketts. Okay, can you give us some examples? What are some examples then? Pick a specific species, or just give us examples. Give me an example of what this would look like. Ms. Williams. I am trying to think of any species that has a largely diminished area now that we are, I can think of actually most species that are dwindled to such small, think of a small endemic species, that are dwindled to such small areas that they only occupy now. If you want them to be healthy and to the future, that they might, one valley over, or one drainage over, be able to thrive and relieve the pressure of the area where they are now. I would think it can apply to myriad species, but the analysis should be specific to the species. Senator Ricketts. Okay, so what about, so you ca not come up with a specific scientific thing off the top of your head. What about economic impacts to communities? Are you going to be looking at what may happen to those communities as a result of mandatory designation of unoccupied habitat? Ms. Williams. Senator, we are always interested and care about the community health, but there are different interpretations of the law, the Endangered Species Act, and whether it allows us to take economic impacts into consideration in our Section 4 analysis. I would say we will follow the law and the science. Senator Ricketts. You are saying, there may be cases where you are not going to do the economic impact on communities to determine whether or not designating the critical habitat is going to impact them? Ms. Williams. I am saying we will follow the Endangered Species Act law, where there are places where we do that economic impact, and there are times where the statute does not allow for that. Senator Ricketts. Again, this is part of my concerns, is that if you are going to do the impact analysis, that is going to impact communities. Obviously, we need to know that, so those communities can be prepared. Will you share that data with those communities in the cases where you are doing the economic impact? Ms. Williams. Yes, Senator, we are always transparent in sharing our data through the public process, and the law requires that, as well. Senator Ricketts. Great. Well, I have run out of time, but thank you, Director Williams, I appreciate you being here today. Ms. Williams. Thank you. Senator Carper. I appreciate you being here today, Senator. Thank you. Senator Lummis, welcome. How are you today? It is good to see you. Senator Lummis. Very well, Mr. Chairman, thank you so much. Thank you, Director, for coming. Nice to see you. Ms. Williams. Nice to see you. Senator Lummis. I noted that when you were visiting with Senator Ricketts, you said that you will follow the law and the science. Let us talk about grizzly de-listing, because you are doing neither, so here we go. In January 2022, that is two and a half years ago, the State of Wyoming filed a petition with Fish and Wildlife Service to establish grizzly bears in the Greater Yellowstone ecosystem as a distinct population segment that is neither threatened nor endangered, and to remove it from the Endangered Species List. By law, your agency is required to make a determination within 12 months of receiving the application. We are now two and a half years out from when the petition was submitted, and your agency has stated you will not have a decision until July. Further, the science established by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service decades ago proves that the grizzly has recovered, and is way over population criteria. Will you, geez, will you commit to establish and delist the Greater Yellowstone grizzly bear population? Ms. Williams. Senator Lummis, I cannot answer that question point blank, as we are under litigation regarding this specific question. I, too, want to acknowledge your frustration and the challenge that this has taken so long, and that the Fish and Wildlife Service has not gotten this finding out in the time with which the statute says. I also recognize that the sheer numbers, the science shows that the numbers of grizzly bears have been a success story. When the Fish and Wildlife Service once petitioned, I will back up. When I started in this job, I met one-on-one with the three State directors, Montana, Idaho, and Wyoming, to say, how can we find a path forward regarding grizzly bears? How can we do this together where we get to a spot where we can delist and it will stand in court? Then, right after that meeting, we received petitions from the States of Idaho, Montana, and Wyoming making it very difficult for us to continue that collaborative conversation. We were pushed right into the potential litigation. Senator Lummis. Yes, but potential litigation, potential. Ms. Williams. Which we were then sued, then, Wyoming did sue us on the deadline, which we have a number of cases regarding grizzly bears before us right now. We have the Wyoming case; we have three petitions from the different States; we have an Idaho case. Senator Lummis. Are you using our litigation, Wyoming's litigation, against you as an excuse for not following the law, when we are suing you because you are not following the law? Ms. Williams. No, Senator I did not mean to say that in any way. Senator Lummis. Well, that is what it looks like. I am going to go on with gray wolves. Following years of delay, your agency committed to issue a new final delisting rule for wolves across the lower 48 by December 2024. This, after the agency has repeatedly missed the deadlines to issue defensible delisting rules that will hold up in court. Then, last fall, your agency issued a half million-dollar grant to an outside mediator to discuss how wolves and people can coexist. This looks like political favoritism thrown at some group to study how wolves and people can coexist, after two decades of regulatory process, socialization of the issue, and repeated discussions. This looks like a delay tactic and a waste of taxpayer dollars to me. I want to know, can you assure me this process will not delay a delisting rule and further, that no part of this ``can we coexist'' discussion will be part of the administrative record? Ms. Williams. Senator Lummis, first of all, wolves are now delisted in the northern Rockies. The Fish and Wildlife Service was challenged on that, and we received a petition, and in this Administration, we issued a decision that wolves remain delisted in the northern Rockies. Senator Lummis. Now you are doing this proposed National Recovery Plan? Ms. Williams. Absolutely, yes. Senator Lummis. You announced that? Wolves are under the jurisdiction of the State of Wyoming, and now you want to expand this to the whole Country? Ms. Williams. Yes. Senator Lummis. Oh my gosh. Will you maintain State jurisdiction in Wyoming? Ms. Williams. Yes, Senator Lummis. The wolf process has nothing to do with, and does not impinge on, the State's authorities where wolves are delisted. What we were seeing across the Country was various litigation that I wanted to be able to say, time out, let us focus on the real work of wolves on the landscape, just like in the Blackfoot challenge where I was, where we support landowners being on the land and supporting them addressing any livestock depredations. You are far more aware than I am of the various challenges in the States that have wolves, and the social tolerance and the culture wars around wolves. What I wanted this process to do was to cut through across the litigation and get to a place where wolves could have that quiet, where they remain delisted in the States where they are delisted, and we have some sort of coherent national strategy. Senator Lummis. I think it would be better to spend half a million dollars studying, getting a mediator to study, how people can get along and coexist with each other. Thank you. Ms. Williams. Thank you. Senator Carper. Thank you, Senator Lummis. We are back to Senator Capito. Senator Capito? Senator Capito. Thank you, and that was a good one. I forgot to mention at the outset, because I thought the Chairman would be interested in this. Very sad news this morning, but a West Virginia legend, Jerry West, died last night. Senator Carper. Really? Senator Capito. He was a basketball player, very well known. We are thinking about his family. Senator Carper. I am trying to remember what his number was. Do you recall? Senator Capito. Forty-four. Senator Carper. Forty-four, I was thinking 42. Senator Capito. Nope, 44. He is a true mountaineer. Senator Carper. What an icon. That is too bad. None of us can live forever, but he made every day count. Senator Capito. Anyway, he was good. I want to go back to the process on timelines. We have all been questioning, we are blowing through timelines here. What is happening between our field office and some of our State agencies, particularly highways, is that we are hitting pauses. The field office is pausing formal consultations. I am concerned that these pauses, if you pause something and then later on restart, you can still be within the timeline, but you still had this large pause. Who decides when to pause the clock? Who decides when the clock restarts, and how does the field office hold itself accountable to meeting the timelines for formal consultations? What constitutes a pause, and why pause, and who restarts? Ms. Williams. Senator Capito, I would like to further look into the pauses that have happened in the West Virginia Field Office. I do not know. I know that there are times where we are all challenged to get the information we need, and I know you mentioned that there are times where you feel that we are asking for more information than we need. I would like to sort through that. I can not answer your question on the fly. Senator Capito. Okay, we will followup on that. Thank you. You mentioned the template that you have put together as a tool for consistency, and that you are tweaking that. We would like to, and we mentioned that we have received complaints or concerns that a lot of the information is information that is extra information that is not really relevant to what we are doing, what they are trying to achieve here. Could we work with you on the template? Could we look at the template? I do not think our office has seen it, but I do not think we have asked to see it, either. I am making that request today. Ms. Williams. Yes, Senator Capito. I know we are still working with the bureau on that, and we would be happy to work with you on this, too. Senator Capito. Thank you, thank you. Then, it was interesting to hear Senator Lummis talk about lawsuits, and obviously, we have those issues in West Virginia and probably in every single State. Do you collect data on the number of lawsuits affecting projects in West Virginia as compared to, say, our sister States of Virginia and Kentucky that would see, is it, well, we have had instances, and I have had, personally, instances, where a project in coordination maybe with the Corps of Engineers or somebody else, well, the Ohio Fish and Wildlife, this is passing through quickly, same kind of information. It is held up in West Virginia. I am looking for more consistency State-to-State. I think this is an issue. I would be interested to know, if you see on this, how it is affecting lawsuits and the success of lawsuits in different States with the consistency in question. Have you looked at that? Ms. Williams. Senator Capito, that is an excellent question. I have not looked at or parsed out litigation and litigation success in our various field offices. What I have done and am interested in is finding more consistency across the Country, and how we implement the Endangered Species Act. It is one of the reasons behind our Section 10 regulation, where we have more consistency and it is meant to be easier to encourage habitat conservation plans and/or voluntary conservation agreements. I am very interested in following through on this and have been, as we are in lean times at the Fish and Wildlife Service, and we are having to think through how to get through these two difficult budget years, 2024 and 2025, hence our budget request. We are looking at having something like strike teams or pulling together teams with expertise on these matters to make sure we are covering what needs to be covered in places where the most work is coming up, but also where we have our best and most creative thinkers on these issues. Senator Capito. Well, I know, for instance, in some of the backlog that existed when we first started our conversation, that you sent some of your experts from different States like Kentucky or others to try to aid the West Virginia office as they were trying to clear through a backlog. I mentioned, and this will be my last question, I mentioned in my opening statement specifically things that had changed, and I think Senator Ricketts alluded to the one. You are no longer considering economic impacts when making species listing decisions. Is that a blanket statement there? Is that a correct statement, in your opinion, that you no longer are considering economic impacts because of some of the rules that you have put forward in making species listing decisions? Ms. Williams. Senator, what I mean to say is that the Endangered Species Act itself has language in it. I do not have it in front of me. It is funny, I normally bring it to hearings with me, I have a little packet with the Endangered Species Act. It is my understanding that the language of the statute itself talks about not adding in economic impacts for Section 4 listing and delisting determinations. I will followup on that with the exact language from the statute, but this is not just per regulation. It is how we interpret the Endangered Species Act itself. Senator Capito. Okay, and then you removed language in Section 7, interagency coordination process, that limits reviews to activities that are reasonably certain to occur. You took that out, which I think would allow for a wider berth of what you could predict could happen. Why did you do that? Ms. Williams. Senator Capito, that was really a policy decision also driven by our career staff on their expertise on Section 7 consultations. It was not to make them less flexible, but it was to follow the processes that we have had in place. It was bringing the proposed rules back into comport with what the Fish and Wildlife Service has done over the years, our standard practice. Senator Capito. My understanding is that this was in your coordination process. It must have been within the body of language that was guiding the Section 7 reviews, and you took it out because you were not doing that? Ms. Williams. Not at all, Senator Capito. Senator Capito. I know it is complicated. Ms. Williams. No, and I want to say this carefully, but I would say in the previous Administration, rules were in litigation. We looked at them with, actually, we made everybody mad with how we moved forward with the regulations, because we looked at them very carefully in concert with our solicitors to what we thought adhered to the Endangered Species Act and the science. Senator Capito. All right, thank you. I have to go to the Appropriations Committee, but thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you again for being here. Ms. Williams. Thank you. Senator Capito. Thanks again for the constant contact. We will be with you. We will be keeping that up, thank you. Ms. Williams. Thank you, Senator. I hope to go back to Charleston for the U.S.A. Cycling Nationals again. Senator Capito. Oh, it was awesome. We did that. Ms. Williams. My son raced. Senator Capito. Oh, did he? Were you there? Ms. Williams. Yes, I was there for the long weekend. Senator Capito. You should have told me you were there. Ms. Williams. I know. Senator Capito. I walked down off the hill, and then I got to ride with the car where they did the whole---- Ms. Williams. Oh, you did? Senator Capito. Oh, yes. Ms. Williams. It was incredible. Thank you for hosting us. Senator Capito. I will get you in the car for next time. Yes, you should have let me know. I just live like, an eighth of a mile from, actually, they went right by my house. They were serving beer by my house, but not me. Thank you. [Laughter.] Senator Carper. Senator Capito, thanks so much for being with us. We will look forward to seeing you on the floor. We have been joined by Senator Cardin. He has yielded, and has said he is happy to wait a few more minutes before jumping into this, but when he is ready, I will yield to him. Senator Cardin. I will benefit from your questioning and Senator Ricketts' questions. Senator Carper. I am not sure how much benefit will flow from my questioning, but hopefully, it will be of some value. We were talking earlier about the, the Ranking Member just mentioned that one of the all-time great basketball players in West Virginia history, Jerry West, has passed away. What a legendary figure. My sister and I were born in West Virginia. We go back in the summers to visit our cousins in the State with our grandparents. One of my grandfathers was a huge Cincinnati Reds fan. The others were Jerry West fans, so we note his life and his death today. Where I am going with this is, and the first question that I asked you today was, would you spend a few minutes explaining what consultation is, when the Service does it, and how it protects species. I will say that again. I will ask you to spend a few minutes explaining what consultation is, when the Service does it, and how it protects species. Every now and then, I ask witnesses a question, I ask, how would you explain this to your grandmother, or maybe my grandmother? I want to give you another shot at this. How would you explain this, seriously, so that lay people can understand it, and maybe even the rest of us and our staffs? Please, what is consultation, when does the Service provide it, and how does it protect species? You are on. Ms. Williams. Chairman Carper, that must mean I did not explain that in a way that my grandmother could understand. I will try to take another stab at that. I appreciate it. Senator Carper. I do not want to put words in your grandmother's mouth, but she might have been saying, ``say what?'' [Laughter.] Ms. Williams. No, that is a very fair question. I really appreciate the opportunity to pull back and think about what Section 7 means and how we implement it, especially because it is of such interest. Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act requires that when a Federal agency undertakes an action, much like under, oh, my grandmother would not like NEPA, when a Federal agency undertakes an action, Congress and the President, when they passed the Endangered Species Act, said, you must make sure that that action does not jeopardize or put a species that is of special concern, whether listed as endangered or threatened, in jeopardy, and that its habitat needs to be in place, too. What that has developed into, when a Federal agency takes an action or gives money to a company to do a project or permits that, that agency has to work with the Fish and Wildlife Service or with NMFS to say, does this project impact or affect that species and its habitat and if it does to a certain threshold where it might jeopardize it, what needs to happen to make sure that project takes into account the species' needs? What it was meant to do was to set up a conversation about making sure those projects that might affect a species be put together in a way where they no longer impact the species. It is meant to be a conversation. There are many, many projects that do not require that conversation back and forth, where they can go through a system and say, they do not need to have any more conversation or consultation with the Fish and Wildlife Service. There are those projects that do require that information gathering and the conversation to make sure that the project does not jeopardize a species. Senator Carper. think your grandmother is going to chew on that for a while. [Laughter.] Senator Carper. We have been joined by Senator Cardin, and I want to give him the opportunity to ask the next question, if you would like to. If you would like to, I am happy to recognize you for the next questions, to my Delmarva buddy. Senator Cardin. I thought Senator Ricketts was going to ask questions. Senator Carper. He has already asked one set of questions. Senator Cardin. He already asked? Senator Carper. He will comment after you, if we are not joined by others. Senator Cardin. First of all, thank you for your support. The Fish and Wildlife Service is critically important to us in Maryland. I know you have roots in Maryland, so we recognize your sensitivity. I want to talk first about the neotropical bird issue, which we just reauthorized earlier this year. We have seen a 30 percent reduction in the last 50 years in our bird population. I think, sometimes, your agency is somewhat misunderstood as a regulatory agency, yes, but a partner in trying to deal with the mission of protecting fish and wildlife. The neotropical bird issue is one that has been bipartisan here. We have reauthorized it, and we have an extra, I think, $100,000 in the appropriations, but it is a global issue that affects migratory birds that come through the United States. Can you just expand a little bit about the role of Fish and Wildlife in trying to accomplish a mission, a partnership, beyond just a regulatory mission, in an effort to accomplish the objectives that we all want to see, a healthier biodiversity species? Ms. Williams. Senator Cardin, I really appreciate that question, because I think it gets to the heart of just how the Fish and Wildlife Service can be misunderstood, that while we absolutely have a regulatory responsibility under the Endangered Species Act, we indeed do far, far more. The work that we do proactively, like under the neotropical work that you have so helpfully supported and led on, we build partnerships around the world to help prevent species being imperiled, such that they would ever have to be listed and getting to that regulatory component. Our 2025 budget request includes an increase of $5.1 million for the neotropical program because, if you think about how we, this is a really good example of how we stretch our money so far into other countries, and absolutely everywhere with partners, this is completely partner-driven work that you have helped to support that allows these incredible species to pass through our Country. I know, I think I understand that some of your staff were able to go on a bird walk. I would say it is one of the best ways to start a day for me, going into work, was to go on a bird walk on Roosevelt Island early in the morning with others, and got to see a Baltimore Oriole right up in the top of a tree, where you could see its color, and you could really hear it sing. I think that neotropical birds speak to people's sense of wonder, of how do these species migrate so many thousands of miles, and what they represent in our ecosystem, not only people's health, but the health of our Country and the habitat that we need to support them, and that they move these thousands of miles from other countries through and into the United States. It is an effort that we all have to address together. Senator Cardin. I just really want to underscore the number of projects in 40-some countries that we have been involved with, with the neotropical birds, the migratory birds. It is a real testament to U.S. leadership, and partnerships with other players, including governments, that have made a huge difference. The Baltimore Oriole is flying high. They are on a five-game winning streak, so it must be working well. [Laughter.] Ms. Williams. How about them Os? Senator, you are correct. We have had over 747 projects in 43 countries, and those countries absolutely rely on the U.S. Government's leadership. I have seen that firsthand as I have traveled to Panama and other countries, to know just how they rely on the funding that we have for these neotropical species. Senator Cardin. I just want to thank you. I know that you are working on the latest of our wildlife refuges in Maryland, which we are very proud about. The report is in on that. It is very popular in the southern part of our State. I think it is about 40,000 acres. This is cooperative; the governments and communities are all in support of what we are trying to do to preserve more land, so thank you for your leadership in that regard. Ms. Williams. Thank you for your support, Senator. Senator Carper. Senator Cardin, thank you for joining us. He mentioned the Birds. He is a huge fan of the Baltimore Orioles. As it turns out, I am a huge fan of the Detroit Tigers. Every now and then, over the years, we have been privileged to go to a game when the Orioles host the Tigers. Senator Cardin. We do not have too many tigers in our community. We have a lot of Orioles, a lot more Orioles, but anyway, maybe we can look at cosponsoring a bill to protect the endangered tigers in the world. Senator Carper. Just to give you an example of what a good friend he is, a couple of years ago, the Tigers and the Orioles were battling for a playoff position to see who was going to go to the World Series, and I could not go to the game. But he was nice enough to call me from the game when the Orioles were hosting the Tigers, had just won, and the cheering in Baltimore, you could almost hear it without a telephone. He held the phone out so I could listen the celebration. Where do they play? They used to play in Memorial Stadium. Where do they play now? Senator Cardin. Oh wow, you are going back a long way. It is called Camden Yards. We have to get you there more frequently if you do not know Camden Yards, the first of the modern stadiums. Senator Carper. There you go. I will always remember your thoughtfulness. Senator Cardin. Have you been following David Rubinstein's purchase of the Orioles? Senator Carper. A little bit. Senator Cardin. Good. Senator Carper. With that in mind, I think that leads right into Senator Ricketts for his second round of questioning. Go ahead, Senator Ricketts. Senator Ricketts. Great, thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Director Williams, I kind of want to just pick back up, because we were talking about the 2019, the Trump Administration published a rule that gave Fish and Wildlife the ability to use the economic analysis when it was looking at the Section 7 listings, correct? That is the one you are referring to, there was a lawsuit over. Is that accurate? Ms. Williams. There was a lawsuit over the suite of Trump Administration ESA regulations. Yes. Senator Ricketts. There was, right. Then, that is what, when the Biden Administration came in, they finalized the rule that basically reversed those. Is that accurate? Ms. Williams. When the Biden Administration came in, the President asked the Fish and Wildlife Service to review those regulations. We rescinded, and then promulgated new ones that were not the same as prior to the Trump Administration, were not just the same as the Trump Administration's regulations, but instead, were a very thoughtful and measured approach forward, I would argue. Senator Ricketts. Getting back then, to the economic analysis. You said that you would follow the law with regard to the economic analysis. It is not in the original act, there. You said, if you do the economic analysis, you share it. Do you have any examples where Fish and Wildlife, when you ever do an economic analysis, it had negative impact on species conservation? Ms. Williams. Senator, I am not sure I understand your question. Whether a listing or delisting? Senator Ricketts. Are there times when you did the economic analysis, did that ever impact your ability to be able to protect a species? Ms. Williams. I am not following how many, it depends. We do economic---- Senator Ricketts. If it has not harmed you in protecting a species, then doing the economic analysis would be beneficial to communities, so they are aware, right? We referenced the spotted owl costing 32,000 jobs. My point is, if you are not going to do the economic analysis, but if you do not have any cases where the economic analysis harmed you, why would not you do the economic analysis? Ms. Williams. Senator, we do an economic analysis in all of the cases and all of the instance where we think the Endangered Species Act allows us to, and where we should. It is just that there is, and I do not want to go too far, because I do not have my statute in front of me, it is only the one instance that was my understanding of Section 4 listing and delisting, where we feel that the statute does not allow for that economic analysis. We absolutely do an economic analysis in other considerations, and we do share that information. Senator Ricketts. Getting back to the unoccupied land and critical habitat, I believe the Trump Administration rule gave Fish and Wildlife the flexibility with regard to the, gave you leeway to designate only unoccupied areas as critical habitat only if it was necessary. I think, do the new rules say that you have to designate that unoccupied land as critical habitat? You are not required to do it? Ms. Williams. No, Senator, I would argue that the previous Administration did not give us flexibility, and our current regulation does give us flexibility. It does not require that unoccupied habitat be designated as critical habitat. Senator Ricketts. Let me switch up gears on you just a little bit here, with the remaining time I have. When you are thinking about success, and species conservation, would you, how do you define success when you are trying to conserve a species? Ms. Williams. Excellent question, Senator. I think there are different ways to think about success. I think the first step of success is stemming the loss of the species, of preventing extinction to begin with. Then, the next step is getting to full recovery of that species. Senator Ricketts. Then, full recovery meaning that you would delist that species. Would that be accurate? Ms. Williams. It is one method, yes. Senator Ricketts. Okay, so again, just the logic following that if a species, endangered or threatened, you are successful in recovering it, then getting it off the list would show that you have actually recovered the population, kind of what Senator Lummis was talking about with the grizzly bears in the Yellowstone ecosystem. Ms. Williams. Yes. Senator Ricketts. Since the last 51 years since Fish and Wildlife has been working on this, there have been, I think, about 1,300 species have been listed, but only about 100 have delisted. That is about a 7 percent hit rate. I would suggest that the Fish and Wildlife use that as one of the benchmarks to say, hey, we can actually show that this program is successful by getting more species to the point where they are being delisted. Quite frankly, 7 percent over 51 years is not a very impressive record. That means, if I was in school and I got a 7 percent on my grade, my parents would have been pulling my ear and telling me to pay more attention in the classroom. I think that one of the things that Fish and Wildlife, and I would encourage you to share this with everybody else, should be thinking about is, we ought to be thinking about not just how we can set aside this land and so forth, but how do we actually get to the end goal of, how do we get, be more proactive as far as delisting species, because that is really the definition of success, is that those species are not endangered anymore. Ms. Williams. Senator, I agree that is our end goal, but I do also feel that the Endangered Species Act has been incredibly successful in stemming the extinction of species that, when we lose them, we are poorer as a Nation. Senator Ricketts. Great. You know, actually, that will be one thing we will followup with, because I am out of time, is just how many species has Fish and Wildlife assessed that we have stopped from going extinct. Ms. Williams. Yes, I am happy to followup. Senator Ricketts. Great, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Carper. Thank you very much. I have a couple more questions. I do not know if we are going to be joined by other members of our committee or not. If we are, then I will yield to them as they arrive. I want to come back and focus a little bit on capacity building, on consultation, and also especially on partnerships. In your testimony and as you discussed a few minutes ago with Senator Capito, you stated, I think, over the last 20 years, the Service's capacity has eroded significantly. Meanwhile, costs and workloads have increased, and challenges to wildlife conservation have become not less complex, but more complex. I believe that we in the legislative body in Congress have an obligation to address this problem. Here is my question. Would you elaborate on how, specifically, this budget request prioritizes capacity building within the Service, particularly as it relates to consultation and relates to permitting? I will just say that again. Would you elaborate for us specifically how this budget request from the Administration prioritizes capacity building within the Service, particularly as it relates to consultation and permitting? Ms. Williams. Thank you, Chairman Carper. This budget request absolutely prioritizes capacity to provide those services that are necessary for Bipartisan Infrastructure Law projects to go forward to allow us to meet our mission. Specifically, the 2025 budget request includes a $146.6 million increase in our planning and consultation under Ecological Services, so that is specific to the consultation work. Where the budget request also prioritizes capacity that, as you mention, for the Fish and Wildlife Service to do its bulk of its work that is nonregulatory, it requires people to build those relationships and those partnerships. I think about our Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program. I think about our Coastal Program, as examples, where those are our people on the ground who are working day in and day out with our partners, with NGO's, and with landowners to piece together funding, technical assistance, and listening to what the community wants to build, and then working with our partners to build that. That is an example of asking our request for the Partners Program and for the Coastal Program. Our request also asks for money for our refuge system. An example is law enforcement officers, so we have a request for an increase for law enforcement officers because, as an example, there are seven States where we do not even have a refuge law enforcement in the State. In the State of Delaware, we share a law enforcement officer with the State of Maryland. We have nine States where we only have one law enforcement officer covering all of our refuge systems. That is an example of capacity that we have asked to build for the safety of our visitors, for the safety of our law enforcement officers. I get the question from our law enforcement officers; how much is the life worth? Are we willing to request and put the money forward to keep our law enforcement officers safe day in and day out? Those are examples, but our full budget request builds on those capacity needs for us to be able to do our jobs and meet our statutory obligations. Senator Carper. Okay, just repeat that for me, if you will, I want to make sure I heard it right. How many States have no law enforcement officers for the refuges? Ms. Williams. Seven States do not have a refuge law enforcement officer. Nine States, this is my understanding, nine States have only one. I also, Chairman Carper, I get serious incident reports, so I am aware of all of the serious incidents that happen on Fish and Wildlife Service-managed lands, whether it is refuge, hatcheries, and/or where our law enforcement officers are called to assist local law enforcement. It is pretty remarkable, the needs out there for our enforcement officers to step up and help visitors and communities, and that they are in harm's way. Senator Carper. Again, just for clarification, the Administration's budget request, how would it affect the population of law enforcement officers on refuges in the seven States or the nine States that you just referenced? Ms. Williams. Our Fiscal Year 2025 request is for $63.4 million specific to law enforcement. It would build the capacity, it would increase to 48 Federal wildlife officers. Senator Carper. As compared to? Ms. Williams. As opposed to right now, we have 205, but it would allow us, that increase of 48 Federal wildlife officers, would allow us to cover the seven States where we do not have law enforcement officers now. Senator Carper. It would be in terms of actual law enforcement officers, we are talking about a 25 percent increase, as I understand it. Okay, thanks. Let me move on, if I can. I want to come back. I think we are going to be joined by Senator Whitehouse here very shortly. Before he arrives I want to turn to, again, partnerships. Partnerships, which as you know, are so important, but when the Fish and Wildlife Service has more boots on the ground, how does that improve the agency's ability to partner with States, to partner with Tribes, to partner with local governments, and to partner with stakeholders? Ms. Williams. Chairman Carper, I was just in Montana last week working with the partners around the Blackfoot Challenge that are using grizzly bears and conflict as a way to build out support for conservation and keeping working lands working. They had, through the University of Montana, done a study on the necessary capacity to be able to build partnerships, but you have to have somebody in place to be able to build those relationships. We have traditionally focused just on implementing statutes without putting, investing in the people to get the work done and to build that support. Another example, Chairman Carper, is with the Fish Passage Program that had a once in a generation investment from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. What we have done in the Fish and Wildlife Service is used our capacity there to work with FEMA, to work with the Army Corps of Engineers, to work with Federal Highways, to work with the USDA, to work with the Department of Defense so that we sequence and coordinate all of our Federal projects. Without our Fish and Wildlife Service Capacity in that small program, there would not have been anybody to be that glue that pulls all the partners together. Senator Carper. Thank you for that. We have been joined by Senator Whitehouse. Senator Whitehouse, I know you have just sat down, but if you are ready, I am ready to recognize you. You are recognized. Go right ahead; thanks for joining us. Senator Whitehouse. Great. Thank you, Chairman. Welcome, Director Williams. Glad to have you here. Ms. Williams. Thank you. Senator Whitehouse. I am glad you enjoyed your visit to Sachuest Point, one of your most beautiful locations. Ms. Williams. I did. Senator Whitehouse. I wanted to flag just a few things for you. One is, I would encourage you to support as much as you can the Invasive Species Program. I have visited, for instance, Valley Falls Pond in Rhode Island and seen it completely overrun by invasive water chestnut. The homeowners nearby have a real problem on their hands, and the better we can be at helping them, the better off. A lot of these are historic and treasured features, and when an invasive species comes in and transmutes them, it is ordinarily not to anyone's advantage, so if you could help with that, I would be grateful. I know you have a lot of different places and a lot of different invasive species, but I wanted to flag that in particular. I also wanted to flag, as we discussed the other day, making sure we are paying a lot of attention to the Narragansett Tribe. We had a visit from the Secretary, and I sat down with her and the Tribe leaders. I mentioned that it had been a long time since the Secretary of the Interior has visited the Narragansett Tribe. I do not know exactly how long. John Brown, who is the Medicine Man for the Narragansetts, put his hand up and said, ``I do.'' He said, the last time, I am not going to get the year exactly right, but it is order of magnitude. He said, ``The last time was in 1862, and it was for purposes of removal of our Tribe.'' Secretary Haaland burst into tears at hearing that. I hope that the overlooked Narragansett Tribe is going to get a good deal more attention and support. The last thing I will mention is that I hope that the department, all the way to the top, tells the White House how important the RISE Bill is. The RISE Bill would take revenue from offshore wind development so that local revenue, the 37 percent from GOMESA (Gulf of Mexico Energy Security Act) that you get from oil and gas offshore, is matched by offshore wind. Because if you do not have a match, then when the developers are going into a State legislature or a Governor and they say, well, we can do more oil and gas, in which case, you get 37 percent of our revenues, or we can do offshore wind, in which case, you get the big zero, that puts offshore wind at a very serious regulatory and political disadvantage against further oil and gas development. We should eliminate that disadvantage. It is going to be very important, I believe, to offshore wind development in the Gulf. The RISE Bill has very solid support from Republicans along the Gulf Coast, and also the former Democratic Governor of Louisiana was a very, very enthusiastic supporter. We would very much like to get that done. If we get that done, then the revenues go to the Coastal Resilience Fund. As you know, I have had a long problem with the Land and Water Conservation Fund, that it should properly be called the Inland Upland and Freshwater Conservation Fund. When you get to the coast, there is essentially nothing there. We can have a big old fight with Delaware and Rhode Island quarreling with upland States about reallocating Land and Water Conservation Fund dollars more fairly to coasts and to saltwater. Better than fighting over that existing pie, better to add a little sibling that would take care better of coastal and saltwater concerns, and putting the Coastal Fund in as a, as I said, like a kid brother to the Land and Water Conservation Fund, so we are not trying to compete for resources, but we are adding to the conservation resource and doing so in a way that encourages offshore wind and is fairer and et cetera. Please take back that I am eager to see that become a priority recommendation to Congress from the Administration. I think we are there, but you are never entirely sure until it is game day. Then, if you find out you are wrong, it is too late. Let's try to get an enthusiastic--I do not know if you have a response to that already. Ms. Williams. Senator Whitehouse, what I do have a response to is an agreement about how much the Fish and Wildlife Service cares about coastal and marine resources. As an example, when I traveled to New Hampshire with the Secretary, I am so sorry it was not Rhode Island coastal area, to see the incredible projects in marsh restoration and her full support of that. I would add, in my travels with the Secretary, she has taught me, as she showed in meeting with the Narragansett Tribe, just how important our partnerships are with the tribes and the deep connection that tribes and indigenous peoples across the Country and even into the Pacific remote islands have with nature. There is much for us to learn from that, and to change our approach. I will be happy to carry forward your messages. I know it is something that the Secretary cares about deeply and expects all of us too, as well. We share that. I would love to see and continue to support coastal areas and marine resources that are very important, as well, not just Delaware and Rhode Island, but across our coastal areas. Senator Whitehouse. Well, thank you. I do not mean to suggest that the Land and Water Conservation Fund support for coastal and saltwater projects is zero, but it is way out of balance when you consider how much coastal land there is, how much ocean that is the sovereign property of the United States compared to upland freshwater. The best way to remedy that balance is to make the pie bigger with the RISE fund, rather than engage in a fight over where the Land and Water Conservation Fund should be dedicated. Let it keep doing what it is doing, but let's add in something for our coastal and saltwater areas. Thanks very much. Ms. Williams. Thank you, Senator. What I did forget, if I have a moment, I forgot aquatic invasive species, and that our 2025 budget does have a $7.7 million increase there. Just to share how important our efforts are to have a really early detection, rapid response. We appreciate your support there. Senator Whitehouse. Thank you, Chairman. Senator Carper. Thanks for bringing up the RISE Act. As a small State, when Senator Cardin was here, we talked about being neighbors, but we are not neighbors with Rhode Island, but we are a small State, and we are a coastal State, and we share a lot of the same interests, so thank you. Thanks so much for embracing them. I am not sure that we are going to have other members who are going to be joining us today, but I have another question or two, and then I am going to give you a chance to sort of raise a question, maybe something you wish you had been asked, but have not been asked. I will give you, at the end, a chance to do that. Before we do that, I mentioned in my opening statement that biodiversity loss costs the global economy an estimated $20 trillion per year, $20 trillion, with a ``t'' per year. We have heard from our colleagues concerns about the economic impacts of protecting species and their habitats. Would you just elaborate for us on how protecting species actually does have and provides economic benefits? Ms. Williams. Thank you for that question, Chairman Carper. I think this goes back to the very reason for which Congress enacted the Endangered Species Act. It was a recognition that biodiversity and conserving these species are key to our very survival ourselves, and that they are important for medicinal purposes. They are important for innovation across the board, for not just for medicine, but also we learn from these systems. I think science is showing us just how intertwined these ecosystem functions are, and the importance of keeping them with integrity. I think, also, it may not be an economic impact, but wildlife generally provides a sense of wonder and awe, and that most people, whatever their beliefs are, if they see a bear on the side of the road, or they see a peregrine falcon flying overhead, though they may not know it is a peregrine falcon, they see a deer or something, they stop and do not think about other things, but stop in the moment and get solace in seeing those species. There is also tremendous cultural significance for many people for these species. But I think, too, that the biodiversity needs keep our food secure. Pollinators, so many of our plants and food sources require pollinators, require the habitat to be healthy. It also brings in clean water, clean air, healthy soils. These are all things that habitats and the species that depend on them are also what support our economic wellbeing, and I think the wellbeing, more generally, of our communities. It is important to preventing flooding. It is important to preventing pollution of the wetlands. We think about the importance of wetlands as really pulling out these pollutants, but they also prevent flooding and are critically important to many of the species that we love and that we sustain ourselves with. I think about Alaska. I think about our hunters and anglers that depend on these species as well. Coming from Montana, I filled my freezer with an elk. I only killed it so that I would have food for my family, and I did not buy meat. I just think that there are so many myriad layers of reasons why biodiversity is so essential in this Country, and it is something we still have. Once you lose it, you can not bring it back. Senator Carper. That is probably worth repeating. Say that one more time, that last sentence. Ms. Williams. Once you lose a species, you can not bring it back. Senator Carper. Thank you. I do not know that we are going to be joined by any of our other colleagues. I have at least one more question, and it is a short one. Would you take a minute or two and talk more about how the Service is embracing nature-based solutions, please? Ms. Williams. Chairman Carper, this is something that I am incredibly proud of. Senator Carper. I thought you might be. Ms. Williams. I am proud of the way the Fish and Wildlife Service has really embraced nature-based solutions, and they have become part of the work we do. One of the first projects where I think we really saw the benefit of nature-based solutions was indeed, as you mentioned, after Hurricane Sandy. We used nature-based solutions for Prime Hook in a way that it supports the community. It restored the marshland habitat, and it brought back the species that depend on that place. That is just one example that we have learned from across the Country, and we are now working with our other sister Federal agencies and building out those nature-based solutions because they work, because they are cost-efficient, and because they poise us for the future and to try to buffer from climate impacts going forward. I just thank you and your support for nature-based solutions and how we have learned to build them into all of our work now. Senator Carper. All right. That is a pretty good example, I think. Ms. Williams. Have you ever been to Prime Hook? Senator Carper. Oh yes, once or twice. Even in the last couple of weeks, as you know. We are very grateful. I almost feel like I am part of their family now, so thank you. Ms. Williams. Good. Senator Carper. The last question, I have already telegraphed this question, but is there a question, just maybe one question, that you wish you might have been asked, but have not been asked? Go ahead and just briefly State that, and answer that question for us before we close. Ms. Williams. Thank you, Chairman. I have thought a lot about this, and in my serving for the past 3 years, as you know, I have traveled around the Country. I have really dived into---- Senator Carper. Let me just say, I am mindful of your travels around the Country and visiting States. Keep doing that; that is a good thing. Go ahead. Ms. Williams. Thank you. I hope to keep doing that, because I can see the impacts on the ground. I can visit with our staff and see the way in which we do our work. What I have observed is that the current budget for the Fish and Wildlife Service does not match the work that we do. It does not always reward where our work is best. So the 2025 President's budget request would help rebuild the capacity where we need to be proactive and to do that partnership-driven work. It would reward, say, for example, our fish passage work, where we are punching so far above our weight and bringing together many different organizations to really solve water quality, flooding, fish passage, aquatic connectivity issues. I think of our coastal work, where we absolutely do everything with partners and stitch together these efforts in support of a community, but also for the ecosystem health and its impact to species. I think of our Migratory Birds Program, where we have been proactive and innovative in trying to cut through challenges of the past and get these eagle rules through, to be thinking about, how does the Migratory Bird Treaty, how do we implement the treaty? I think about our Office of Law Enforcement, people across the world who are doing so much with so little to help allow for legal trade, but prevent illegal trade of wildlife. I think of all of our staff and their earnest faces, as I go across the Country, who are trying to solve problems and are trying to be creative and innovative with so little. That is the question that I would love to be asked, and how the Fish the Wildlife Service would make such good use of the investment in our work, were Congress to pass the 2025 budget request from the President. Thank you. Senator Carper. We thank you, as well. Tell us again how many national wildlife refuges there are in the Country? Ms. Williams. There are 571 now. Senator Carper. Five hundred seventy-one, Okay. Ms. Williams. That should be a, that is a trivia question, but the Secretary, I played trivia with her, and she got that right. Senator Carper. Okay, that is good. There are a couple in Delaware that we are really proud of what is called Prime Hook, and there is another one, too. What is it called? Ms. Williams. Oh, I think there is a special visitor center called the Thomas R. Carper Visitor Center. Senator Carper. What an honor, what an honor. We are just very proud of that. We are proud of both of our wildlife refuges, but as folks around the Country are looking for places to go visit that maybe they have not been to before, I hope they will consider that we have two great visitor centers, but one that is particularly close to my heart. Thank you. In closing, again, thank you for joining us today. Thank you for your service. Thank you for your testimony, and we especially appreciate your service to our Country at a time when we face great conservation challenges. I like to quote Albert Einstein. Albert Einstein used to say, in adversity lies opportunity. That is true in this instance as well, because those challenges also bring with them some opportunities. We are mindful of that. Before we adjourn today, some housekeeping. Let me say this to our staffs, both majority and minority side, our thanks to each of you for helping the members prepare for this important hearing. This is my favorite part of hearings, when I am the last one here, and I get to make a unanimous consent request, and there is nobody, none of my colleagues are here to object, but it is something that gives me great pleasure. I want to ask unanimous consent to submit for the record a variety of materials that relate to today's budget hearing. Hearing no objection, so ordered. [The referenced information follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Senator Carper. Senators will be allowed to submit written questions for the record through the close of business on Wednesday, June 26th of this year. We will compile those questions and send them on to you and your team. We will ask you to reply to us by Wednesday, July 10th of this year. With that, this hearing is adjourned. Thank you very much. [Whereupon, at 11:45 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [all]