WHISTLEBLOWER TESTIMONY ON THE COVID COVERUP

Senate Government Operations Committee Senate May 13, 2026

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[Senate Hearing 119-522]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-522

 WHISTLEBLOWER TESTIMONY
 ON THE COVID COVERUP
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 COMMITTEE ON
 HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS
 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 MAY 13, 2026

 __________

 Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov

 Printed for the use of the
 Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
 
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
64-606 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
=======================================================================

 COMMITTEE ON HOMELAND SECURITY AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS

 RAND PAUL, Kentucky, Chairman
RON JOHNSON, Wisconsin GARY C. PETERS, Michigan
JAMES LANKFORD, Oklahoma MAGGIE WOOD HASSAN, New Hampshire
RICK SCOTT, Florida RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut
JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania
BERNIE MORENO, Ohio ANDY KIM, New Jersey
JONI ERNST, Iowa RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ELISSA SLOTKIN, Michigan

 William E. Henderson III, Staff Director
 Christina N. Salazar, Deputy Staff Director and Chief Counsel
 Megan M. Krynen, Professional Staff Member
 J. Ryan Arient, Professional Staff Member
 David M. Weinberg, Minority Staff Director
 Christopher J. Mulkins, Minority Director of Homeland Security
 Alan S. Kahn, Minority General Counsel
 Laura W. Kilbride, Chief Clerk
 Ashley A. Gonzalez, Records Clerk

 C O N T E N T S

 ------ 
Opening statements:
 Page
 Senator Paul................................................. 1
 Senator Ernst................................................ 9
 Senator Moreno............................................... 12
 Senator Johnson.............................................. 14
 Senator Hawley............................................... 17
 Senator Moody................................................ 20
Prepared statements:
 Senator Peters............................................... 29

 WITNESS
 WEDNESDAY, MAY 13, 2026

James E. Erdman III, Senior Operations Officer, Central 
 Intelligence Agency
 Testimony.................................................... 4

 APPENDIX

Unclassified Summary of Assessment............................... 30
Potential Links Between WIV and Origin of COVID.................. 32
Declassified Assessment on COVID-19 Origins...................... 42
Senator Ernst picture............................................ 60
Senator Hawley's documents....................................... 61
Response to post-hearing questions for the Record:
 Mr. Erdman................................................... 63

 
 WHISTLEBLOWER TESTIMONY
 ON THE COVID COVERUP

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, MAY 13, 2026

 U.S. Senate, 
 Committee on Homeland Security 
 and Governmental Affairs,
 Washington, DC.
 The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10 a.m., in room 
SD-342, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Rand Paul, 
Chairman of the Committee, presiding.
 Present: Senators Paul [presiding], Johnson, Hawley, 
Moreno, Ernst, Moody, Hassan, and Blumenthal.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR PAUL

 Chairman Paul. The Committee will come to order. The 
Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic was one of the 
most consequential events of our lifetime, and to this day the 
American people have never received a full accounting of where 
it came from, what our government knew, and why they had to 
fight their own government to find out. Today, the Committee 
will hear from an intelligence community (IC) whistleblower 
about these questions. The witness will testify that the 
Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) scientific analyst repeatedly 
concluded that a laboratory leak was the most likely origin of 
COVID-19 and that those conclusions were buried, softened, or 
withheld from Congress while the public was told to trust a 
different story. For years, Americans were told to trust the 
experts, trust the agencies, trust the intelligence community, 
and trust the officials who assured us that they were following 
the science. But the evidence before the Committee tells a very 
different story.
 Today, we will expose a system in which a small circle of 
officials, scientists, grantees, and intelligence advisors move 
from agencys to agency, meeting to meeting, briefing to 
briefing, reviewing one another's work and shaping one 
another's conclusions and presenting those conclusions to 
Congress and the public as if they were independent 
conclusions. Only it was not independent; it was a circle. One 
part of that circle is a body most Americans have never heard 
of, the Biological Sciences Expert Group (BSEG) or the B Group. 
BSEG operates under the Office of the Director of National 
Intelligence (ODNI). Its stated purpose is to give the 
intelligence community access to outside scientific experts on 
biological threats. Sounds reasonable, but not if those experts 
are not independent.
 For example, Dr. Ralph Baric collaborated with Dr. Zhengli 
Shi in Wuhan to create gain-of-function (GOF) coronaviruses. 
But Dr. Baric was also part of BSEG and an active consultant to 
intelligence agencies on the origins of COVID-19 pandemic. 
Likewise, Peter Daszak received hundreds of millions of dollars 
from the U.S. Government and worked with Dr. Shi also on these 
gain of function experiments. Daszak was even sent to China 
with the World Health Organization (WHO) to investigate the 
origins of COVID. The very scientists that were commissioned to 
investigate COVID were, in some cases, the very scientists who 
were complicit in the origins of the gain-of-function 
experiments that may well have created COVID.
 In essence, the intelligence community pays researchers to 
review work and write papers. The National Institute of Health 
(NIH) funds their grants, the CIA then consults them and gives 
them access to classified information. The National Academies 
publish their work. Policymakers then cite the result as a 
consensus, but it is a circle.
 At the center of the government side of this circle was Dr. 
Anthony Fauci. For years, Dr. Fauci was not merely a public 
health official speaking from the NIH. He had a longstanding 
relationship with the national security and intelligence 
apparatus on biological threats, dangerous pathogens, 
classified life sciences researches, pandemic preparedness, and 
COVID origins. Again and again, documents show him being 
brought into national security discussions far beyond ordinary 
public health messaging. During COVID, intelligence officials 
arranged for Dr. Fauci to review highly classified intelligence 
assessments that could not even be sent outside the White House 
complex. But how can Anthony Fauci objectively comment on a 
discussion of COVID origins when he approved the very funding 
that may have caused the pandemic virus?
 From the outset of the pandemic, Dr. Fauci shaped the 
conclusions. Dozens of times, he referred to the idea that the 
pandemic originating in the lab was a conspiracy, that it was a 
conspiracy theory. Dr. Fauci convened the now infamous February 
1, 2020 call. Some scientists on that call privately raised 
serious concerns about a laboratory origin. Yet ironically, 
those same scientists later co-authored the Proximal Origin 
paper, which publicly dismissed the lab leak hypothesis. One 
author received a $9 million grant from Dr. Fauci's own agency 
after he changed his opinion from lab leak on the private phone 
call to natural origin in public. At the same time, Dr. Fauci 
coordinated with the National Academies on coronavirus origins 
and public-facing messaging. These were not independent experts 
reaching a consensus. They were part of the same machine 
designed to reach the same conclusion.
 The question is not whether the government may consult 
experts. The question is whether those experts were 
independent, whether conflicts were disclosed, whether 
dissenting views were preserved, whether the lab leak 
possibility was fairly evaluated, and whether Congress and the 
American people received the truth or a curated result.
 When Congress asked these questions, government officials 
lied to our face. They classified the documents. They 
suppressed the information. They changed the definitions. They 
invoked sources and methods. They told Congress only what they 
wanted Congress to know. In 2023, John Ratcliffe, the former 
Director of National Intelligence, testified before Congress 
with a stark warning. He said a lab leak was the only 
explanation credibly supported by intelligence, science, and 
common sense.
 He warned that partisan politics and analyst disagreement 
with Trump administration policy, Trump Derangement Syndrome, 
had created illegitimate roadblocks to the truth. I agree. He 
said that COVID-19 Origin Act, which Congress passed 
unanimously, should finally make intelligence on COVID's 
origins public. I couldn't agree more.
 Despite an unanimously passed law though requiring the 
declassification of all information related to COVID origins, 
the deep states still resist this congressional mandate. Our 
witness today will explain what happened inside the CIA. 
According to his testimony, CIA scientific analysts concluded 
multiple times between 2021 and 2023 that a lab leak was the 
most likely origin of COVID-19. Yet those conclusions never 
shaped the official narrative, never made the intelligence 
report. Congress was never told. It was not until after the 
2024 election that the outgoing Biden administration directed 
the CIA to issue an assessment, not because of new 
intelligence, but so officials could walk out of the door 
claiming there was nothing left to find.
 That is not analysis. That is a cleanup operation. This 
hearing is about more than one witness, one assessment, or one 
agency. It is about a Federal apparatus that told the American 
people to trust the science while hiding the machinery that 
shaped the science. It is about an intelligence community that 
relied on outside experts whose conflicts were never disclosed. 
It is about public health officials with access to intelligence 
that Congress has struggled to obtain. It is about researchers 
and advisors cycling through grants, contracts, classified 
briefings, Federal service and advisory committees and 
presenting the results as independent, even though they 
weren't.
 The coverup is not just about protecting one research 
grant. It is about protecting an entire network of labs, 
grants, intermediaries, and bureaucratic architecture quietly 
engineered to outlast any moratorium, any congressional 
inquiry, and any election. After millions died, children lost 
years of learning, small businesses were destroyed, civil 
liberties were restricted, and dissenting Americans were 
censored and smeared, the government owes its people the 
evidence.
 Our witness is testifying publicly today at great personal 
risk. He and other brave whistleblowers have come forward 
because the truth was being buried, because government secrecy 
cannot become government impunity. I want to acknowledge the 
Trump administration officials who made good on their 
commitment to transparency and cooperated with this 
investigation. Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), 
Robert F. Kennedy, Director of NIH, Jay Bhattacharya, Director 
of the National Intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, and former 
Secretary of Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Kristi 
Noem, they set a standard. I expect the rest of the 
Administration to meet it. We owe the American people a 
complete record. We owe every family harmed by this pandemic a 
government that does not hide behind secrecy, conflicts, and 
curated science when the stakes are life and death, in public, 
starting today.
 I want to note for the record that Mr. Erdman is appearing 
today pursuant to a subpoena issued by this Committee on May 5, 
2026. This is a public hearing. The witness is a current CIA 
employee and has previously provided testimony to the Committee 
in a classified setting. If a question calls for classified 
information or if the witness believes any answer may implicate 
classified information, the witness should advise the Committee 
before answering and the Committee will address the matter 
through the appropriate procedures.
 The transcript of the witness' prior classified deposition 
has not been finalized and has not completed classification 
review. Members and the witness should not quote from, 
characterize, or seek confirmation of deposition testimony that 
may contain classified information in this public setting.
 It is the practice of the Homeland Security and 
Governmental Affairs Committee (HSGAC) to swear in the witness. 
Will you please stand and raise your right hand.
 Do you swear that the testimony you will give before this 
Committee will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but 
the truth so help you, God?
 Mr. Erdman. I do.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you. You may be seated.
 James E. Erdman III is a CIA senior operations officer. He 
is a decorated officer with decades of intelligence and 
national security experience. Before joining the CIA in 2013, 
he served with the Second Battalion 75th Ranger Regiment and as 
a Foreign Services Officer at the Department of State. He 
recently completed a joint duty assignment with the Office of 
the Director of National Intelligence Director Initiatives 
Group (DIG). Mr. Erdman holds a Bachelor of Science (B.S.) in 
biology with a minor in chemistry from Western Oregon 
University and has received the Director of National 
Intelligence Award and the CIA Intelligence Medal of Merit.
 Mr. Erdman, you are recognized for your opening statement.

 TESTIMONY OF JAMES E. ERDMAN III, SENIOR OPERATIONS OFFICER, 
 CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY

 Mr. Erdman. Good morning, Chairman Paul, and other Members 
of the Oversight Committee. Thank you for the complimentary 
introduction and I appreciate the Committee's dedication to 
transparency and accountability. I am a career CIA Operations 
Officer and as you mentioned, I was on joint duty assignment at 
the Office of Director National Intelligence Directors 
Initiatives Group between March 2025 and April 2026. I was 
responsible for leading the DIG's investigation into COVID 
origins, anomalous health incidents, and unidentified anomalous 
phenomena.
 I am here today to discuss the COVID coverup, the national 
security implications associated with the DIG's investigative 
findings and CIA refusal to comply with lawful oversight as 
well as how we remedy these problems.
 Intelligence community leaders and senior analysts 
downplayed the possibility that the COVID pandemic originated 
as a result of a lab incident. Motives are difficult to define 
given the scope of the DIG's review. Intentional or not, the 
IC's actions resulted in a cover-up, wasted resources, and a 
failure to properly inform policymakers. Public health policy 
would have been very different had the American public been 
made aware that a virus from a lab in China was going to serve 
as the foundation for an emergency use authorization (EUA) 
messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) products being mandated by 
the former administration.
 Dr. Fauci's role in the coverup was intentional. Dr. Fauci 
influenced the analytical process and findings by leveraging 
his position to ensure the IC consulted with a conflicted list 
of curated subject matter experts, public health officials, and 
scientists. This included some of the authors of the paper, The 
Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2, and other public health experts 
who have been in his orbit for the last 20-plus years.
 Some of the scientists were part of the Biological Sciences 
Experts Group an office of Director National Intelligence 
advisory body whose members often receive considerable funding 
from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases 
(NIAID) and public health agencies. The BSEG scientists 
influenced National Laboratory Weapons of Mass Destruction 
(WMD) research, policy decisions, finished analysis, and other 
intelligence matters, creating misaligned incentives and 
conflicts of interest, as well as counterintelligence issues.
 Since 2006, the BSEG consulted part-time on biodefense 
issues for the IC while conducting government-funded research 
and holding academia positions, as well as maintaining roles in 
public health institutions and serving as members in the 
National Academy of Science (NAS). They received funding from 
NIAID and other agencies for vaccine research, United States 
Agency for International Development (USAID's) PREDICT project, 
the Cooperative Threat Reduction (CTR) Program, and even worked 
with Chinese scientists on coronavirus and other pathogen 
studies pursuing vaccines. There was no oversight monitoring 
how this web of relationships influenced research, policy, and 
public health in any holistic way for over 20 years. In fact, 
several of the BSEG scientists helped Dr. Fauci rewrite 
definitions of gain of function in 2015 to lift a funding pause 
on dangerous research. Still, others participated in Planning 
Event 201 in 2019. This was a coronavirus pandemic tabletop 
exercise curiously similar to the events that played out during 
the COVID-19 pandemic, and it was attended by Dr. Fauci and 
individuals with IC ties like former DNI Avril Haines.
 The CIA and DNI analytic managers responsible for examining 
the origin of COVID made decisions inconsistent with the 
conclusions of subject matter experts and analytical 
tradecraft, consistently favoring the theory of zoonosis or 
natural origin. Following the CIA's COVID relook that 
culminated in 2023, the CIA retaliated against analysts 
supporting the lab leak hypothesis.
 CIA analysts were not bribed. The analysts that supported 
the 2023 lab leak conclusion took every administrative measure 
available to them to address their deep concerns regarding the 
analytic integrity of their finished intelligence. CIA managers 
retaliated against them for their refusal to agree with 
management's middle-of-the-night anonymous rewrite of the 
analysis, which changed the assessment to a non-call judgment.
 Dr. Anthony Fauci's influence over the IC's COVID origin 
analysis and the witting and unwitting role some BSEG 
scientists and IC personnel played in the cover-up exposed why 
this issue is of deep concern. Failure to address the United 
States government's inability to differentiate between public 
health and biodefense and the oversight resistant ecosystem of 
life science actors has been fertile ground for increasingly 
dangerous continental United States gain of function research, 
as well as similar research conducted in U.S. government-
supported labs abroad.
 Post-9/11 changes in public health and biodefense roles and 
responsibilities have blurred the lines between scientists, the 
military, the intelligence community. It has resulted in a 
deliberately opaque and excessively redundant biodefense 
research policy and financial infrastructure seemingly intended 
to escalate bureaucratic bloat. This is a national security 
crisis caused by the inability to provide real oversight.
 The systematic failures associated with muddled boundaries 
between biodefense and public health and an overly complex 
infrastructure have been exacerbated by documented efforts to 
circumvent oversight. CIA did not comply with lawful oversight 
during the DIG's investigation. The behavior significantly 
impacted Director Gabbard's implementation of several Executive 
Orders (EOs) issued during this administration and tasked to 
the DIG.
 The CIA refused to provide information necessary to 
understand why analytical standards at the CIA were violated. 
The CIA illegally monitored the computer and phone usage of DIG 
personnel, their investigations, and contact with 
whistleblowers. These were Americans being spied upon illegally 
while executing duties directed by the President and under the 
authority of the Director of National Intelligence. One CIA 
contractor assisting with the DIG's investigation into the 
events that transpired between 2022 and 2023 was fired by the 
CIA one day after meeting with the DIG.
 When the DIG ceased operations, the CIA also took back 40 
boxes of John F. Kennedy (JFK) files and MKUltra files being 
processed for declassification by DNI Gabbard. The legislative 
and executive branches will continue to be misinformed if this 
type of behavior is not addressed.
 The partial solution to dangerous gain of function has 
already been laid out in Executive Order 14292, Improving the 
Safety and Security of Biological Research. We need a 
comprehensive review of government-funded life science research 
and a move back to pre-9/11 definitions of gain of function and 
WMD research, particularly in the IC and DHS.
 More broadly, we need effective oversight. We must hold 
agencies responsible for failure to comply with Executive Order 
14292 and oversight must have teeth. You must be willing to 
pull the purse strings, and if necessary, convene another 
Church Committee. The results of our investigation would have 
been impossible without whistleblowers willing to come forward. 
They are indispensable agents for reform.
 Despite statutory law, agency regulation, and training 
requirements, whistleblowers are almost never protected. 
Whistleblower protections always seem to protect the agency. 
Every time the CIA investigates itself, they coincidentally 
find no wrongdoing. When they do identify issues, they hold the 
system responsible. That last statement is a verbatim response 
from a European Eurasia Mission Center lawyer when the CIA 
Office of Inspector General (OIG) did identify shortcomings so 
serious oversight bodies were holding meetings about it three 
years after the events transpired. It was in response to the 
question, was anyone held accountable? Apparently the system is 
good enough.
 The only way we solve this issue is with real 
accountability for failure to comply with executive and 
legislative branch oversight and an escape valve where 
whistleblowers can continue to contribute to mission free from 
retaliation. All Inspector General (IG) elements need to be 
removed from the agencies and fall under a separate entity 
controlled by the IC inspector general. The personnel in IG 
elements should be 1811 certified with regular Department of 
Justice (DOJ) and legislative oversight reporting 
responsibilities.
 Thank you. My written statement provides far more details 
related to these issues. I look forward to your questions.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you, Mr. Erdman. Is it your testimony 
that there is still resistance from the CIA to comply with the 
law we passed to declassify all the COVID information?
 Mr. Erdman. Yes.
 Chairman Paul. One of the things that I think is new today 
that I am hearing from your testimony is that from an early 
period of time you believe, and the information you are aware 
of, is that CIA scientists from an early time after the 
pandemic began, 2020, 2021, were concluding that the lab leak 
was the most likely hypothesis.
 Mr. Erdman. Yes, Senator. I would like to offer some 
qualifications on that, as well. A lot of the issues occurred 
at the interagency space at the National Intelligence Council 
(NIC), the individuals responsible for conducting or writing 
WMD analysis. Many of those individuals are on Joint Duty 
Assignment (JDA) from the CIA. But yes, as early as 2020, there 
were agencies within the IC circulating papers that said, 
``Hey, there's--.'' For example, DOE circulated a paper in May 
2020 that said that all the conditions were present for a lab 
leak. I could go through the timeline, but yes, my short answer 
is, yes, periodically throughout 2020 all the way to 2024, yes.
 Chairman Paul. I think the arguments pro and con for what 
is the evidence on whether this came from a lab or it came from 
nature are still important. For years, we have been asking the 
CIA to produce the scientists, either in a classified setting 
or a public setting, to discuss the arguments. I do not see any 
reason why the argument should be classified. One of the 
arguments that is made publicly is that the source looks like 
it came from a single source of ribonucleic acid (RNA), not 
five different types of viruses or 20 different types like you 
had with SARS 2003, but it came from one source, and virtually 
everybody argues that indicates a lab and not a nature. Those 
arguments are important scientific arguments to have, but we 
have been prevented from having them. We have been prevented 
from getting all of the declassified information.
 But what I think is of importance that is new today is that 
your testimony is that the CIA scientists were concluding that 
it was lab, but then there was a 90-day study in 2021, and this 
study was done by NIC, led by NIC. Tell us what NIC is again.
 Mr. Erdman. It is the National Intelligence Council, and 
individuals responsible for writing various WMD and bio-related 
issues led to that.
 Chairman Paul. When they had this study, they had CIA 
scientists telling them, ``Look, the evidence, the scientific 
evidence looks like it came from the lab,'' but then they 
brought in Anthony Fauci. Is it your opinion that Anthony Fauci 
was able to overrule the scientist or get NIC to conclude 
somehow that there was not a conclusion to be added here? We 
are going to be neutral contradicting what the scientists were 
telling them?
 Mr. Erdman. There are two questions there and I want to 
break them up into two. One is where did Dr. Anthony Fauci and 
when did he inject himself into the IC? The other half of that 
question, and I do not want to extrapolate too much here is, 
OK, what happened with why was there a change in analysis? I 
will start with the--if it is OK, Dr. Paul----
 Chairman Paul. Sure.
 Mr. Erdman [continuing]. Senator, I will start with Dr. 
Anthony Fauci. There were two instances on February 3, 2020 and 
June 4, 2021, Anthony Fauci had contact with the interagency. 
How to broadly generalize this is that that contact was happily 
pursued within the IC. They wanted that contact, and he 
provided a curated list of subject matter experts, which 
coincidentally wrote the Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2. So it 
is not like he came in and said, ``You have to do X, Y, and 
Z.'' He provided recommendations. It is when you look at what 
has already been publicly released about Dr. Fauci and then 
what you are seeing under the curtain at the IC where you 
realize, OK, there is a narrative that was being generated by 
his contact not just with experts here in the United States, 
but experts in Australia and the United Kingdom (UK), and that 
is the public-facing piece. He had tried to sort of keep his 
hands clear of, hey, I didn't have anything to do with the 
proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2. But in the meantime, he is 
pushing those authors and individuals that have been in his 
orbit into the IC as experts.
 I will jump to June 2021. We, as the IC, at the NIC, 
happily pursued those recommendations. In one email, which I 
will describe to you, the person in charge of leading the 90-
day study, he introduced himself to the community on what they 
were supposed to be doing and then he said, ``Listen, we have 
these people we should be talking to.''
 Another very senior NIC officer sent a direct email to him 
saying, ``Hey, considering that Dr. Fauci is a public health 
expert, are you sure we should be relying on this? Shouldn't we 
have a separate set?'' In this instance, the individual 
responded, ``No. In this case, Dr. Anthony Fauci is a subject 
matter expert.'' However, that is directly contradicting his 
public testimony of being a subject matter expert.
 Chairman Paul. Part of the job in intelligence when you 
interview someone is assessing their truthfulness, their 
potential biases or conflicts of interest. Did anyone ever 
bring up that Anthony Fauci approved the research that went on 
in Wuhan and that it might not be in his interest for the 
conclusion to be that it came from a lab that he had funded? 
Did anybody ever bring up that he might not be an objective 
witness?
 Mr. Erdman. That was one example of an email. No one laid 
it out quite that clearly. We were piecing it together from 
multiple emails, from multiple agencies, multiple documents. It 
was more subtle than that. Nobody said, ``This is happening.'' 
Unfortunately, I think they probably should have. It was all 
out there.
 Chairman Paul. But your conclusion is that changing from 
the scientific consensus of it being from a lab to a neutral 
position by the CIA was significantly influenced by Anthony 
Fauci?
 Mr. Erdman. It was significantly influenced by Anthony 
Fauci's injecting himself into the IC.
 To go to the second part of your question about what 
happened, particularly during the 90-day study, we have 
documentation that shows that as of August 12th, the CIA was 
considering calling this a lab leak, August 12, 2021, then that 
changed on August 17, 2021. Unfortunately, because the CIA 
would not provide us documentation that we asked for, we have 
no idea why that changed.
 Chairman Paul. They weren't alone because we know the 
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) was coming to the same 
conclusion that it was lab leak. Senator Ernst.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR ERNST

 Senator Ernst. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I really appreciate 
you being here today. I know that this has been a topic for 
many of us for many years and we continue to get pushback from 
the Federal Government as we are trying to uncover the truth to 
this matter.
 For years, folks who discussed a possible COVID lab origin 
were dismissed as conspiracy theorists. They were censored. 
Some were even fired from their jobs. If there was or is a 
conspiracy, then U.S. Government officials and U.S.-funded 
scientists keeping secrets should be publicly questioned under 
oath about what they knew and when they knew it. But U.S.-
funded scientists somehow are still protected from being 
questioned publicly, even though they received millions of 
taxpayer dollars from NIH, DHS, Department of Energy (DOE), and 
Department of Defense (DOD). Look, folks, I have long warned 
about a potential government coverup of the truth, which our 
brave witness--again, thank you, Mr. Erdman--has confirmed to 
us today.
 I have called for answers from Dr. Ralph Baric, an expert 
virologist who showed the intelligence community in January 
2020 before the American people knew about the pandemic that, 
``We may be on the verge of a global pandemic,'' yet nothing 
was done to share this information with the American people. I 
exposed that the Wuhan lab received $1.4 million in Federal 
funds, fought to cutoff every single cent flowing to that lab, 
and I won on this for the taxpayers, and I have not backed down 
from fighting for more information on the true COVID origins.
 Yet, Congress is still here, six years later begging 
agencies to share answers and for committees to make relevant 
documents public. We are tired of Washington cover-ups. If they 
aren't our screw-ups here in the United States, why would the 
U.S. Government cover up for the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) 
and other countries?
 Mr. Erdman, Americans would have been angry to learn in 
early 2020 that their government may have played a role in 
COVID-19's creation. Would you say such thinking influenced the 
intelligence community to suppress a lab leak origin theory?
 Mr. Erdman. I would say that there is evidence in the 
emails that it was part of the calculus. It is very difficult. 
It is more subtle. There is a zeitgeist that runs underneath 
the analysis, and I will provide a conversation I had with one 
of our whistleblowers. This individual is an incredibly 
talented scientist, and I said, I asked that individual, ``Why 
don't you actually go forward, go public?'' There are a lot of 
reasons not to do that. There are a whole bunch. His comment 
was, ``Nobody wanted the lab leak conclusion, and I am 
concerned that there's too many people willing to make excuses 
for China in this organization for the wrong reasons.'' That 
was pervasive.
 The individuals we talked to, they never said one for one, 
it is because they disliked the sitting President or they were 
trying to cover up, like managers were trying to cover up for 
China, but it was a pervasive undercurrent is how they 
described it.
 I think to answer your question, there was certainly 
reluctance to provide information that would be geopolitically 
destabilizing or provide ammunition for actions that maybe they 
thought would be unwise.
 Did I answer your question, Senator?
 Senator Ernst. Yes, you did. It is troubling to hear that 
there is an undercurrent of making excuses for China as well. 
Deeply troubling.
 We spend millions of dollars to have an early warning 
intelligence system, and yet today I am hearing the system may 
have been alerted but no one was acting on the information. Do 
you think that is an accurate statement?
 Mr. Erdman. I can't speak to the health agencies. I can say 
that the IC was certainly aware early on that it looked like 
there might be an issue, and so the intelligence that had come 
in, I do not think they sat on it. I do not think they sat on 
the intelligence. Now, that speaks to maybe a broader issue 
with the interaction between IC elements and non-IC elements. 
Maybe there are some improvements that could be made there, but 
I did not see the IC sitting on information extraordinarily 
long.
 Senator Ernst. OK. It could have been agencies then 
extraneous to the IC.
 Mr. Erdman. Right. The bureaucracy is real. I mean, it is 
just every day sometimes feels like a fight just to get simple 
things done, and that is just part of working in a large 
organization. I am not making excuses. I am just saying from 
the intelligence perspective, I think they identified fairly 
quickly that this might be an issue.
 Senator Ernst. With this as an issue, typically we go back, 
we do after-action reviews. Do you think this is something that 
the U.S. Government has learned from? I see you grimace. Maybe 
share a little bit about that, because if this is a system-wide 
across the Federal Government, how do we stop this from 
happening again? What lessons have we learned from this, if 
any? You are still coming forward as a whistleblower. What have 
we taken away from this and how do we prevent this from 
happening in the future, whether it is the spread of a pandemic 
or what happened within the agency?
 Mr. Erdman. I really don't want to go beyond IC too much 
because I am not part of the health establishment. I am not in 
that organization. But part of the reason the DIG was pulled 
together as a task force, it was a temporary tool to perform 
something like an after-action review and get at the bottom of 
what happened. If you are asking me, did we learn anything, 
well, the problem is we did not receive support from the CIA in 
terms of--and I documented in my transcribed interview, and I 
don't want to go into the specifics of that, but there were 
very specific lists of information we needed so that we could 
put into context what happened. No, I do not think we have 
learned our lesson when it comes to transparency and reform. We 
didn't get the documents we needed.
 Senator, your Committee issued, what was it, 14 subpoenas 
in January 2025, requesting documents, and Director Gabbard did 
her absolute best to try and force the IC to start producing 
these documents. A bunch of them got sent over to ODNI, but we 
still did not get all of them. What I will say is we did not 
get the documents we needed from the CIA, State, Bureau of 
Intelligence and Research (INR).
 The lessons in terms of transparency and reform, I do not 
think those occurred. They can only occur if we actually do a 
full review of what happened during COVID. Again, there is a 
fair question, how long do you want to be backward leaning 
looking at COVID? That is a fair question. You only have 
limited resources, limited time, limited personnel, and we have 
limited experts that work within the CIA, and they have got 
forward-facing threats.
 The reason COVID is so important is because what we did 
find is that there is a much larger meta problem sitting on top 
of COVID. The fact that we have these scientists--and again, I 
am not vilifying any of these scientists we contracted in to 
come to the IC. We desperately need their expertise. When we 
invite them in, we are inviting them in because we want their 
help. We need them.
 But those same scientists, it is this ecosystem that has a 
lot of money involved. They are involved with the National 
Academy of Science, for example, some of them. National Academy 
of Science also helps with our WMD policy for the U.S. 
Government. Unfortunately, the National Academy of Science also 
has a great number of Chinese researchers that co-publish. If 
we are not careful, we are going to have Chinese researchers 
helping us draft U.S. WMD policy. That is not a good thing. You 
have the Counter Threat Reduction Program that involves some of 
these IC scientists.
 Once you start cross-pollinating like that, being able to 
tease out and really provide proper oversight becomes so 
difficult. You are talking about also multiple funding streams 
from multiple different places. It is a very complex problem. 
We would need the After Action Review (AAR) and it already 
pointed to the bigger problem, so maybe that's enough.
 Senator Ernst. Great.
 Mr. Erdman. But we need that.
 Senator Ernst. Thank you, Mr. Erdman. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Ernst, one thing I would interject, 
as far as lessons from my perspective is, the scientists 
overseeing gain-of-function research cannot be the scientists 
receiving the money.
 Senator Ernst. Right.
 Chairman Paul. We voted last year on the Risky Research 
Review Act. It will be a Presidential commission, but the 
scientists that oversee gain of function would not be receiving 
NIH grants. Part of it is that Fauci had a fiefdom, this normal 
fiefdom, and he was controlling the funds, but then there was a 
danger of that he doles it out to people who agree with him, 
and I think that was happening. Senator Moreno.
 Senator Ernst. Absolutely. Point well taken.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR MORENO

 Senator Moreno. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Erdman, first 
of all, thank you for your service to our Nation in the past, 
current, and future. Quick question for you, because I have 
obviously never been in the CIA. Is it easy to be a 
whistleblower? Is it easy to kind of think about, ``Hey, I'm 
going to go outside the normal chain of command,'' or does it 
come with personal risk, career risk, et cetera?
 Mr. Erdman. I do not believe whistleblower protections are 
sufficient to protect whistleblowers.
 Senator Moreno. So, it is not easy. It is not easy for you 
to be here.
 Mr. Erdman. It is not easy.
 Senator Moreno. Especially, you are serving now today. What 
is your reaction when you look at the dais and you see that 
there is not a single solitary Democrat member here to listen 
to your testimony? How does that make you feel?
 Mr. Erdman. My goal in being here is threefold. I want to 
talk about COVID.
 Senator Moreno. No, I get that, but I'm saying, but you----
 Mr. Erdman. I wish they were there.
 Senator Moreno. But you are taking personal risk. You are 
serving the country. You are not partisan. This is not about 
politics, but somehow it has become about politics because the 
Democrats do not even want to hear the conversation about what 
obviously was a grave error that this country made during 
COVID. Unlike previous situations, there has never been a 
situation, certainly not in my lifetime, where you had 
decisions made that affected generations of Americans, kids 
that were absolutely deprived of their childhood. Businesses 
that were destroyed. Families that were torn apart. Memories 
that you will never get back. Trillions of dollars of economic 
loss. We should at least have a conversation that is not 
partisan, and yet just for the record, there is not a single 
solitary Democrat Senator that is willing to sit in this 
chamber and listen to your testimony. I think that is an 
outrage and an insult to people like you.
 I am going to bring a little more levity to what I just 
said. Back in June 2021, you talked about that, which is 
interesting. June 2021, I remember June 2021 as something that 
came up during a comedy show. I'm not somebody who listens to 
Stephen Colbert, but he had Jon Stewart on and he said, and I 
am paraphrasing Jon Stewart, I will not deliver it with the 
same kind of comedic punch. But it said, ``Oh my God, there's 
been an outbreak of chocolatey goodness near Hershey, 
Pennsylvania. What do you think happened? Like, oh, I don't 
know. Maybe the steam shovel made it with a cocoa bean, or it's 
maybe the expletive deleted chocolate factory. Maybe that's 
it.'' A simple joke talking about it, or maybe the simplest 
solution is maybe the virus leak happened from the virus lab in 
the city of Wuhan. Or maybe this chain of events of animals 
mating to each other all over the world resulted in this virus.
 What ended up happening is that Jon Stewart was immediately 
tortured. The Washington Post called his joke a dangerous 
weapon of propaganda. They called him conspiratorial, and he 
got massive personal backlash. That was in June 2021. So does 
it turn out that the chocolatey goodness came from the 
chocolate factory in Hershey, Pennsylvania?
 Mr. Erdman. Yes. Just as Director Ratcliffe said in 2020, 
it sure looks like the chocolatey factory is actually where the 
chocolate came from.
 Senator Moreno. Yes. In fact, it is funny that we are all 
sitting here today because in that same torture of Jon Stewart, 
Steven Colbert said that maybe Jon Stewart was somehow a spy of 
Senator Johnson, because Senator Johnson was the one Senator 
that was saying this in the very beginning and has continued to 
hold that accountability. I applaud Senator Johnson for his 
absolutely relentless pursuit of the truth in all this.
 But let me just spend the last few minutes here talking to 
you about something that you mentioned, which is near and dear 
to my heart. I think all these hearings are important, what you 
said is super critical. Again, I applaud you for taking and 
having the courage to come here and your detailed and 
methodical review of all this;, but where is the 
accountability? This is what I hear from my constituents all 
over Ohio. It is like, great, you got a hearing, you said this 
and that happened, but they want to see the perp walks. Where 
are the people who made these decisions and how do we hold them 
accountable?
 Anthony Fauci is sitting probably sipping margaritas 
somewhere with his multimillion dollar financial success as a 
result of duping the American people into putting an 
experimental virus, vaccine into their bodies or risk losing 
their jobs. He is not accountable to anybody. He is having a 
great life. He was featured on Vogue magazine. He sat there for 
a cover shot for a day, trying to get beauty shots of him, 
which I imagine the photographer found difficult. Where do you 
think that we are on a path to accountability?
 Mr. Erdman. I don't work at DOJ, and so I can't speak to 
prosecutions or perp walks or any of that stuff. But what I 
will say is, and I want to go back to the first thing you 
mentioned here about the American public, I think, and this is 
my opinion--I am not expressing myself as a CIA officer or on 
loan to DNI, whatever it is--I think we really want both 
Democrats and Republicans to show up and communicate and 
cooperate on issues, because part of the most important, and 
you all know this, I am sorry, Legislative Branch, they have 
some power of oversight. You guys cannot make DOJ prosecute 
anybody. You can reach across the aisle and you can try and get 
these people to pull the purse strings when agencies are 
behaving poorly. From my perspective, and I do not mean to 
criticize anyone, we need the Legislative Branch to start 
pulling purse strings. It has to be with teeth if you want 
accountability. This is perfect, this forum here is perfect. It 
is about the transparency piece. Can't act unless people know.
 On the accountability side, I can tell you that Director 
Gabbard is doing her best to pursue accountability with all of 
the investigations that were undertaken by the DIG. We can 
serve everything up and it is up to DOJ to take action at that 
point. I can't speak to DOJ, but yes.
 Senator Moreno. No, I understand that. I think what the 
American people would even expect at a minimum is just an 
apology, an apology for putting the country through this, not 
giving the proper information, I think that would go a long 
way. But certainly, there was clearly bad actors.
 Mr. Chairman, you talked about the conflicts of interest. 
The way you described it was very nice, but ultimately, it's 
corruption. I mean, when somebody's getting paid to give an 
opinion that is not fact-based and it leads to personal gain, 
that is just flat-out corruption. What makes America unique is 
that we don't allow that kind of corruption in our government.
 I think ultimately where this all has to land is there has 
to be explicit accountability for individuals who profited off 
of the misinformation, the shaming of Americans, and the 
systematic destruction of lots and lots of things in this 
country.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Erdman. Thank you, Senator.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Johnson.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR JOHNSON

 Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and another 
excellent hearing. I feel your pain and frustration, in terms 
of trying to do oversight investigation and issuing subpoenas 
that are not responded to, certainly not in full, barely 
responded to, generally. What responses we get are generally 
non-responsive responses, just a bunch of bureaucratic 
gobbledygooks. Again, I appreciate your efforts though.
 Mr. Erdman, I appreciate you coming forward. One thing I 
know as former Chairman of the full Committee, now as Chairman 
of the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations (PSI) is, we do 
not protect whistleblowers. We have laws dating back over 100 
years, and the government is the worst offender in terms of 
retaliating against whistleblowers, even though there are all 
kinds of these legal protections. I appreciate you doing this.
 I will also note, because nothing shocks me anymore with 
our colleagues from the other side of the aisle, but I am 
shocked that not one of them showed up here. I think one showed 
up to register his attendance and then gone.
 I agree with you. It is well past time for us to have a 
Church Committee. We are not going to get bipartisan support 
for a Church Committee. There is no curiosity on the other side 
about what is happening inside the deep state. That is really 
my question. Who is running the deep state? I have example 
after example in agency after agency, very legitimate oversight 
requests. I subpoena documents. You don't get squat.
 Now I asked for your testimony last night, and I realized 
and I really appreciate the fact that the Committee staff and 
Chairman Paul is very concerned about retaliation against you. 
Apparently, they did not clear your testimony here at the CIA. 
Is that true?
 Mr. Erdman. No.
 Senator Johnson. So you are appearing as a true 
whistleblower publicly right off the bat. I will do, and I am 
sure Senator Paul and the staff, we will do everything we can 
to prevent retaliation. What is your game plan after this? You 
are done in DNI and the DIG organization. Do you plan on going 
back to CIA?
 Mr. Erdman. I returned to CIA on, what was it, April, I am 
back at CIA. I just took a couple of weeks' vacation it was a 
long year and I was tired, so I took some time off. Now I am 
back at the CIA.
 Senator Johnson. Were you welcomed back?
 Mr. Erdman. I just arrived and I have a desk and they are 
talking to me about what comes next.
 Senator Johnson. I mean, do you have any concerns about me 
keeping this? Because originally we said you can't keep this 
after the hearing, but it sounds like now I can keep it. Do you 
have a concern? Because again, I do not want to harm you in 
terms of what you have written here. I haven't had a chance to 
go through it yet.
 Mr. Erdman. You can keep it.
 Senator Johnson. OK. Should we distribute this publicly?
 Mr. Erdman. Please hold onto that.
 Senator Johnson. For the time being, I will. John Ratcliffe 
was very helpful when he was in that position at DNI. Now he is 
Director of the CIA. What is preventing the CIA from totally 
cooperating with the DNI?
 Mr. Erdman. I don't know.
 Senator Johnson. You have been in the CIA. Who is running 
this show?
 Mr. Erdman. Here is what I will say. We had requests. We 
have a formal process that we sent those requests over, and I 
detailed in the transcribed interview the dates and what those 
requests were for. It appeared to be bureaucratic slow rolling 
until the government shutdown happened.
 Senator Johnson. Well, that is the technique they use.
 Mr. Erdman. Yes.
 Senator Johnson. They look at every administration or every 
director of CIA and if they don't agree with them, this too 
shall pass. Right? They just wait them out. That is happening 
right now in both of our investigations. Again, I am calling 
for a Church-like commission. We will call it the Paul-Johnson 
Commission. OK? We need to figure out who runs the deep state, 
but in my final three minutes, because I held what I thought 
was a blockbuster hearing two weeks ago.
 Mr. Erdman. It was very good.
 Senator Johnson. This is on my investigation in terms of 
the harms done by the COVID injection. I am going to talk about 
it right now because it is not being covered by the legacy 
media. Alternate media, yes, Fox News, Fox Business has had me 
on. I was supposed to be on Cable News Network (CNN) last week, 
and I sent them my report and told them that is what I want to 
talk about. They canceled the appearance. ``Oh, that's not 
why.'' Sure it is.
 So this is what, and I can do this in two minutes and 20 
seconds. This is what we uncovered. This is what is being 
covered up by now the legacy media. On March 1, 2021, Dr. Peter 
Marks, head of Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research 
(CBER), the organization at the Food and Drug Administration 
(FDA) that approves vaccines and also supposed to surveil those 
vaccines post-market for safety, was given a multi-page 
briefing by the main data mining analysts within FDA working 
with the inventor of the algorithm they used to analyze the 
Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). That briefing 
told Dr. Marks that the current algorithm, because of the 
nature of the massive number of claims coming into VAERS--by 
the way, from 1990 until 2020, on average, about 280 deaths are 
reported in VAERS associated with a vaccine. In 2021, it is 
over 21,000. Nothing to see here.
 But anyway, so they are using an algorithm. They were 
warned that this algorithm, because the Moderna and Pfizer are 
so close together, the way they are analyzing is going to mask 
and hide safety signals. That is March 1, 2021.
 Twenty-six days later, a new state-of-the-art algorithm, 
developed by the inventor of the original algorithm, was 
presented to senior FDA officials, showing 49 cases of extreme 
masking, 25 safety signals, including sudden cardiac death, 
pulmonary infarction, Bell's palsy, different types of strokes. 
Month after month after month, they continue to do this data 
mining. They continue to show additional safety signals. Did 
Peter Marks, did Anthony Fauci, did President Biden go to the 
American public and say, ``Hang on here. We have some data. We 
have some concerns.'' No. They blamed the unvaccinated for 
continuing the pandemic. This is a pandemic of the 
unvaccinated, we need to mandate this.
 This is what government does. This is what the deep state 
does. I can't explain it all, my investigation now, because I 
finally got documents. This would never have happened if we did 
not have documents. By the way, just like we found that David 
Morens' email that now has resulted in prosecution, where he 
has a FOIA lady to show him how to make emails disappear if you 
send me something sensitive to my Gmail. We have the same types 
of evidence in our report.
 We need to get to the bottom of this, and right now I am 
just using this moment. I need the mainstream media, Columbia 
Broadcasting System (CBS), American Broadcasting Company (ABC), 
CNN, to step forward and start covering what is a major stand. 
How many thousands, tens, hundreds of thousands of people are 
permanently disabled or possibly lost their life because our 
FDA hid the fact that there was safety signals screaming at 
them with the COVID injection?
 Again, you can't answer all my questions in terms of who, 
but we need to figure out who is running this deep state. Thank 
you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Johnson, I completely concur with 
the call for a Church Committee, but I will tell you how 
difficult it is. Church Committee was like 1975, 50-some-odd 
years ago. I have been trying to get the classified version of 
the Church Committee for over two years, but I am being blocked 
by the Intel Committee, including someone from our own party is 
blocking having me--they have shown me a room with 400 boxes 
and I can go look in all the boxes to see if I can find it. My 
staff is not allowed to go in the room, but they will not 
reveal to me something that is 50 years old that should be 
declassified for the public, much less for me.
 Senator Johnson. Maybe we should go together. It would 
probably only takes us about four or five years to dig through 
all the boxes.
 Chairman Paul. That is right. Senator Hawley.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HAWLEY

 Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. 
Erdman, thank you for being here. In March 2023, the Senate 
unanimously passed legislation requiring the Office of the 
Director of National Intelligence to declassify all, I believe 
the exact language is, ``declassify any and all information 
related to potential links between the Wuhan Institute of 
Virology (WIV) and the origins of COVID-19.'' I have some 
familiarity with this legislation because I wrote it. It passed 
the House unanimously. President Biden signed it into law 
under, I think, popular duress. As you may remember--well, 
first of all, are you familiar with this law?
 Mr. Erdman. Oh, of course, yes.
 Senator Hawley. As you may recall, it set a statutory 
deadline of just a couple of months later, which the Biden 
administration promptly ignored and blew through. When they 
finally did release the report, I think we have a picture\1\ of 
it here that will appear over my shoulder, it was all of five 
pages. Here it is, wait for it. Five pages. Remember, the law 
says any and all information. Five pages, heavily redacted, 
even the five pages. I think one of those pages is a cover, a 
cover note or something. Yes, here it is. The executive 
summary, five pages, this is according to the Office of the 
Director of National Intelligence, this is any and all 
information related to COVID-19 and the Wuhan Virology Lab.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 \1\ The picture referenced by Senator Hawley appears in the 
Appendix on page 61.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Now, you have been on this task force that has reviewed 
these documents. Is this all the information the U.S. 
Government had?
 Mr. Erdman. That is not all of the information. I will tell 
you a little story about that, if you would like.
 Senator Hawley. Please.
 Mr. Erdman. A story about your five pages there. There was 
a classified report being written at the time all of this was 
going on, and I assumed as I am reading through the documents 
that they would just take that classified report, which did not 
look like that, and they would just redact it. Because I am 
reading through documents, but that is not what happened. They 
decided to write a different paper, instead of what was 
already----
 Senator Hawley. You say they. Who is they?
 Mr. Erdman. The National Intelligence Council.
 Senator Hawley. The National Intelligence Council was, at 
the time that the law passed, was doing a thorough review or 
doing a review. We do not know how thorough. How many pages? 
You have been on this task force. You have gotten a sense of if 
it is not five pages, how many pages worth of information would 
you guess the U.S. Government was in possession of related to 
Wuhan lab and COVID, possible links?
 Mr. Erdman. I can tell you that Director Gabbard is working 
through, I believe, 2,000 pages.
 Senator Hawley. 2,000?
 Mr. Erdman. That they are trying to get released in the 
first batch. The law states yes, any and all, but there is 
still the requirement to run it through the different agencies 
to ensure that there are not some sources and methods.
 Senator Hawley. 2,000 pages. I want to show you what Avril 
Haines, Director Haines said to me when I wrote to her. Senator 
Braun and I wrote to her following this outrageous, ridiculous 
report. She wrote back to me and said, ``We declassified only 
what we could without endangering sources and methods, only 
what we could.'' Five pages of summary that itself has 
redactions. The five pages have redactions. You are telling me 
there are literally thousands of documents. Why are they hiding 
all of this material?
 Mr. Erdman. I can tell you that the interagency process of 
declassification is highly bureaucratic, and that is being 
worked. I think you saw just a few days ago, Director Gabbard 
released some information about the labs.
 Senator Hawley. Was Director Haines, Avril Haines, was she 
involved in making the decision not to release the material?
 Mr. Erdman. I don't have any proof that she was involved in 
the direct decision. I have no emails saying that directly, 
but----
 Senator Hawley. It was her office and it is her signature 
on the letter to me. It is her office that sent the five pages. 
She is the one who said, ``This is what we have. This is all we 
have.'' You are telling me there were 2,000 plus documents and 
they sent us five.
 Mr. Erdman. No. I am telling you that the first swath of 
documents that we are looking to----
 Senator Hawley. Oh, I see. Many more.
 Mr. Erdman. There are many, many more than that.
 Senator Hawley. I gotcha. Many more. Let me tell you what 
this so called five-page report, what it said in its substance, 
to the extent there was any. They said, No. 1, that nothing 
that was researched at the Wuhan lab could plausibly be a 
progenitor of SARS-CoV-2. No. 2, they said there is no evidence 
of any research-related incident involving Wuhan employees that 
might have been related to the pandemic. Now, in your 
experience, given what you have seen, are those true 
statements?
 Mr. Erdman. Some of that would have to be covered in 
classified, but no, they are not true. If we wanted to get into 
details, I do not believe that is true.
 Senator Hawley. The U.S. Government first deliberately 
violated a law passed by Congress, signed by the President, 
that ordered them to release all information related to the 
Wuhan lab, No. 1. No. 2, they then violated the law again by 
withholding thousands and thousands of pages that they had at 
the time and knew were covered by the law. And No. 3, the 
conclusion, so called, they released to the public are false.
 If that is not a coverup, I don't know what is. If our 
elected officials and unelected officials in this case in the 
IC and ODNI, if they can get by with blatantly violating the 
statutes of this country and lying to the American people, I am 
sorry, but we do not have a democracy anymore. I do not know 
what it is, but it is not a democracy because we the people are 
not in charge. These people are in charge and they are lying to 
us every single day.
 You said in your opening statement that Dr. Fauci, speaking 
of someone who is not exactly a truth teller, that Dr. Fauci 
intervened to put his thumb on the scale of what information 
the intelligence community could review when they did their 
initial assessments of whether or not the Wuhan lab was linked 
to COVID. What exactly did he do?
 Mr. Erdman. Let me clarify that. He reached in and he 
provided this list of scientists and subject matter experts 
that we should talk to. It is not like he is saying, ``You will 
go talk to them.'' He does not have the power to do that, 
technically. It is just that the bureaucracy in place at the 
time was perfectly happy to pursue those recommendations, even 
when there was a number of individuals who expressed concern 
saying, at least one for sure that said, ``Are you sure we want 
to do this? He's a policymaker and we need to have our 
intelligence cycle.''
 Senator Hawley. He had a point of view, did he not?
 Mr. Erdman. He certainly did.
 Senator Hawley. What was that point of view? Just refresh 
our memories.
 Mr. Erdman. He believes it is natural origin. He still 
does.
 Senator Hawley. Of course. I mean, he said this over and 
over. Now he would have reason to, given that he supported 
gain-of-function research through the Wuhan Lab, lied about it 
to Congress, lied about it repeatedly to the Chairman, as I 
recall. His hands are dirty in this, and yet here he is 
intervening behind the scenes. It is bad enough that he is out 
there misleading the public. Behind the scenes, he is trying to 
intervene to stop our own intelligence community who are 
supposed to work for the public from actually accurately 
assessing the evidence. This is unbelievable. Then people 
wonder, gee, why are the American people not trusting of 
elected officials? I wonder, why are they? I will tell you why, 
because they are repeatedly, we are repeatedly lied to by these 
people, lied to and lied to and lied to.
 I want to thank you, Mr. Erdman, for your testimony. I just 
want to note, I think we have only scratched the surface here.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for calling this hearing. I just 
want to point out when you have a witness who is saying under 
oath that the report that the government issued lied to the 
American people, that it is false, we have a big problem in 
this country. We have a big problem and we have not begun to 
solve it yet.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Senator Moody.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR MOODY

 Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think this is one 
of the most important hearings we will hold during this 
Administration. I think when the world, when the country went 
mad, and I do not care if you consider yourself a blue State or 
a red State, the country went mad and people were craving 
leadership, and leadership that truly was based on science, not 
someone that alleged they were following science and seemed to 
care more about controlling the public. I think this is one of 
the most important hearings, and I think everyone that actually 
showed up today and you see who is here, involved, and taking 
part in this hearing, are the ones that want on behalf of the 
American people who are, by the way, are supposed to be in 
charge of the United States of America (USA), want to get to 
the bottom of what happened. Not just because that is right, so 
that the people that are in charge of this Nation understood 
what happened, but so that this never happens again.
 If we are trying to prevent a government that is trying to 
control a populace based on nothing, based on no justification 
and making sure that that never happens again, I just want it 
to be very clear to everyone in this room or anyone who has 
taken the time to watch that cares about their country and 
understands what it means to protect freedom. I just want them 
to see who showed up today and who is participating and who has 
thanked you for coming out bravely and disclosing these facts, 
what happened, and your opinion based on your years, decades of 
experience.
 I, for one, hailing from the great free State of Florida, 
you know, Florida used to be known for flamingos. We are now 
known for freedom. That is because what took place over the 
last administration and when churches were closed, when 
businesses were closed, when schools were closed, when people 
were shut up in their apartments, when families were prohibited 
from socializing and gathering, many were kept from their loved 
ones when they died, all under this guidance of government 
leading based on science. We really have to go back and 
question that because that cannot happen in this country. I 
think many of us that were in charge at the time questioned how 
we ever allowed that to happen.
 Certainly in Florida, I am so proud, along with Governor 
DeSantis, we led against that tide in many respects. When 
people were still being told to, ``Stay at home. Don't let your 
kids go to school. Don't go to church,'' all of these things 
that seem insane right now, we didn't. We stood up for the 
truth. We tried our best to discern what was true, what was 
not, what did not make sense.
 Let me tell you why things did not make sense. First of 
all, you had your Secretary of HHS, which was basically 
invisible, checked out. Those are words of the Biden 
administration at the time. Officials from the Biden 
administration said, ``Secretary Becerra was invisible. Checked 
out. An unfortunate choice for the role.'' Then, you had Dr. 
Fauci who came out and contradicted himself constantly. At one 
point, he even admitted later, he told people, people shouldn't 
be walking around with masks on. And later he said that was 
because we were trying to control the supply for healthcare 
professionals, it wasn't based on any science. But then later 
he told everyone to wear masks repeatedly. The six-foot rule 
seemed to have been just crafted out of thin air with no basis 
in science whatsoever. In fact, he said, ``That rule sort of 
just appeared,'' when he testified and that, ``Guidance on the 
shutdown of schools and small businesses was arbitrary and not 
based on any science.''
 I just want to make sure the American people hear that. You 
had a government who is supposed to be limited and stay out of 
people's lives coming in and offering guidance. Many times it 
was done under mandates to close businesses, people's 
livelihoods, to keep children from being educated, to keep 
people from expressing their faith and gathering to show 
freedom of religion and their faith and expression. I mean, 
unbelievable what happened during the COVID years.
 I was so proud of my State. Along with Governor DeSantis, 
we launched a grand jury investigation because the Federal 
Government sure was not doing it. We got to the bottom of some 
of what was being said publicly by those that we had trusted in 
these positions and how that was not actually the truth and the 
science. That was where the name the Free State of Florida has 
come from. I am so glad now to be here as one of the newest 
United States Senators bringing that experience, that grand 
jury investigation, everything that we did differently in 
Florida and stood up to the madness because that is how the 
people remain in charge of their government.
 In the grand jury investigation that we did, we followed 
the evidence. We found that many of those policies, including 
masking, lockdown mandates, they lacked sufficient scientific 
basis. They, in fact, caused significant harm to Floridians. 
The same grand jury found a pattern--I am quoting the grand 
jury here. This is a nonpartisan group, acquired from the 
community to judge facts. ``A pattern of deceptive and 
obfuscatory behavior from both Big Pharma and the Federal 
agencies charged with regulating them with respect to the COVID 
vaccines.''
 It appears from everything that we found from our own 
investigation, an unbiased, totally separate review of what was 
being said publicly by the Federal Government compared to what 
was actually based in science, it found that most of what was 
said in the events surrounding it was a public health 
establishment that was fixated on controlling the public and 
forcing narratives, rather than protecting public health or 
discovering the truth.
 I am grateful that you are willing to be here today. I know 
that this is under subpoena, but certainly it takes courage to 
be here and to be a whistleblower that can get accountability 
for the American people. Florida was years ahead of the Federal 
Government's supposed experts. We are proud of that, but this 
is so important.
 I want to know, and I have one question, we are getting to 
the what, what happened. We were glad that Florida led on that. 
Even while people remained locked down, we were trying to get 
to the answers. What happened? But in all of your reviews and 
what you have been able to compile and what you are saying 
today, what is the why? Why?
 Mr. Erdman. Why did the coverup happen? I think there are a 
lot of incentives, misaligned incentives that have been created 
because of this highly opaque and complex system of 
laboratories, life science research, and the IC is just one 
component of that. Why did it happen inside the CIA and inside 
DNI and inside the interagency space when they were doing the 
analysis over the course of four years? Part of it is iron rice 
bowls, your normal bureaucratic issues where one agency has 
this, another agency has that. There was groupthink. You could 
see it happening in real time as you read from beginning to 
end.
 I will give you a couple examples. Every time there was an 
open source publication that came out, they were very good at 
grabbing that and kicking it up for the contracted scientists, 
the BSEG, to take a look at and assess. The goal, it seemed, it 
always leaned one direction. They never took the publications 
from Sorenson and Dalgleish who came out very early, I think it 
was July 2020, that one of the best papers written was open 
source by Sorenson and Dalgleish. They never took those papers 
and said, ``Wow, we have a lot here. We need to make sure we 
get this added in.'' Or Dr. Steven Quay, for example, who had a 
lot to say about COVID origins.
 It was always one direction, and because the interagency 
space seemed intent on pushing it that way--and why the 
interagency space? I think the interagency space, I am talking 
about the National Intelligence Council and the people 
responsible for that, I mean, these are people who have 
relationships with the National Academy of Scientists and the 
National Academy of Sciences. They have relationships with the 
WMD community, and they are all part of the same, I don't know, 
ecosystem. The planets are all revolving around the same star. 
And so, you get groupthink.
 There are a multitude of reasons. I did not find any 
smoking gun where they said, ``We got to cover this up because 
for sure the U.S. Government paid for research in Wuhan, 
China.'' But they were certainly well-aware of PREDICT, they 
were well-aware of the DEFUSE proposal, that had circulated and 
they had those products available to them. I think you get 
enough people shouting something down, it gets shouted down, 
and that happened repeatedly.
 If I can take just a moment, particularly about the 
scientists that are brought forward. I really want to emphasize 
a couple of things and one of it is we can't vilify these 
scientists. I am going to give a very short anecdote and I hope 
I am not going over on time or anything like that, but when I 
got hired to the CIA, I cannot tell you how proud I was. I 
really could not believe that they hired me. I am sure there 
were some friends who are like, ``Yes, I can't believe it 
either.'' But they hired me because they saw potential to be 
able to be somebody who could recruit spies and steal secrets. 
That is my job.
 Imagine you are a scientist. Imagine the U.S. Government 
comes to you and says, ``Listen, sir, you are a specialist in a 
field no one else knows about.'' In fact, the whole point of a 
Ph.D. is to push beyond what is known further than anybody else 
in a very rarefied field. Imagine you are a scientist and the 
CIA comes up to you and says, or the NIC, the intelligence 
community, comes up to you and says, ``You're special, not 
because we see potential, but because we know you are special 
and we need your help.'' We cannot vilify these people who 
wanted to help.
 I might be contradicting myself here, but the system 
definitely needs a look because the system has been put in 
place now and you have got these same people that we have said, 
``You are important to the IC.'' We just have not done the 
proper work to ensure that those people who are important to 
the IC are not cross-pollinated all over in other places, so 
that they can incentivize the kind of research that we need 
done or the white papers we need written. We have to have a 
holistic overview, and I think it is really hard to have one 
agency do their review, another agency do their review, the 
Legislative Branch do their review. In this case, it is a team 
sport.
 Chairman Paul. So, one answer also, Senator Moody, to your 
question about the why people think, ``Well, gosh, was there a 
conspiracy where all these evil people had their hands together 
and they were conspiring to do something bad?'' I think George 
Carlin put it the best. He said, ``It isn't required that you 
come up with a conspiracy where interests converge.'' I think 
the interest is we funded a lot of dangerous research. 
Accidents have happened. This was an accident. In all 
likelihood, this was an accident. Even the Chinese probably 
didn't want this to happen in Wuhan. It was an accident. But 
the interest is that if you funded that research for 10 years, 
wouldn't I logically want to ask you why, why you did this 
funding?
 There are dozens of people throughout government who did 
cover this up, maybe hundreds, but they do not even know each 
other necessarily, but they had a hand in funding this research 
through the years. They have been in favor of it. It has been a 
big debate. For 20-some-odd years there has been a huge debate, 
maybe longer. People think this is the first virus that got 
out.
 It is not as much reported, but one of the most famous 
viruses that got out was the Russian flu of 1977. We are not 
sure it came from Russia or where it came from, but the 
interesting thing is nobody over 24 got the flu. Zero. Not one 
person. Why? Because the Russian flu of 1977 had the exact same 
RNA structure as a flu in 1953 that had been kept in a lab 
somewhere. How do you get an identical virus 30 years later? 
Viruses mutate every couple months, like COVID has. There is no 
way to have an identical virus unless you got it from a lab. 
Proof positive that the 1977 flu actually came out of a lab. An 
accident. Once again, an accident.
 There is a woman who has written about this. I think her 
last name is Young. She says that over a period of years, like 
1,500 major accidents that she has cataloged. It is not only 
about malfeasance, it is about safety of these labs. In fact, 
some people were finally convinced that this came from Wuhan 
because it was a Biosafety Level (BSL-2) instead of a BSL-4 for 
much of the time, that it didn't have enough safety 
precautions. But even the safest one, the four still has 
accidents. Maybe some of these experiments we ought to 
reconsider whether we do with them.
 Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It just goes to 
show why it is helpful to have a doctor as our Chairman. You 
could also be a witness.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you. We are going to conclude pretty 
quickly. I am going to give Senator Johnson another chance if 
you have another question.
 Senator Johnson. I have a quick question that I want to go 
someplace else. In September 2023, we apparently had a CIA 
whistleblower come forward and there are news articles written 
about this, that six of the seven analysts to described this 
were bribed to change their analysis. Is that true?
 Mr. Erdman. No. So, there is some clarifications on that. I 
thank you for bringing up this question, Senator Johnson, 
because this is one of the things I wanted to make sure the 
record was corrected. If I have just a few minutes here to talk 
through this, there was new information that came out in 2022, 
and it forced the community to try and conduct a relook. There 
were 10 CIA scientists, I am talking from the CIA side now, not 
on the NIC side, 10 CIA scientists that were said, ``Why don't 
you go ahead and do a COVID relook?'' On that team, there were 
seven subject matter experts (SMEs), technical experts with lab 
experience, medical experience. And so, they began their 
relook.
 By the time they wrote their paper, they wrote a paper and 
they said, ``We are assessing this as a lab leak,'' according 
to multiple whistleblowers, 8 of the 10 were definitely leaning 
in on lab leak. They sent that paper, that draft paper up to 
the Weapons and Counterproliferation Center front office and 
said, ``Take a look.'' Magically, a new report shows up that 
allegedly contradicted the information that had come in earlier 
that year. The multiple people we spoke to said, ``Yes, it 
didn't really contradict it,'' but they were told, ``Go back to 
the drawing board and do a reassessment.'' The interagency got 
involved, they were having discussions, they go back to the 
drawing board.
 By the time 2023 rolls around, they have their answer. They 
say six of the seven technical people on that team, so there's 
10 people on the team, six of the seven technical experts say, 
``Yep, we still think it's a lab leak''. They were sticking to 
their guns.
 Management changed the analytic line. They changed the 
conclusion to a non-consensus call. Actually, worse than that, 
they said that, the exact words were--I don't want to get this 
wrong. Excuse me. ``We may never precisely know the origin of 
SARS-CoV-2.'' Precisely. Precisely is not a term analysts use. 
They use like, low-confidence, medium-confidence, yes, no. 
Precisely is a word you use when you want to deliberately end 
discussion, because do you know how many resources we would 
need to precisely know the origin of SARS-CoV-2?
 Senator Johnson. I want the Chairman to indulge me a little 
bit more here. There were no bribes paid? This was just a 
management decision. They overruled what they----
 Mr. Erdman. Overruled.
 Senator Johnson. OK.
 Mr. Erdman. But the financial piece definitely needs to be 
looked into because they did receive an Exceptional Performance 
Award (EPA). They got it. It's $1,500.
 Senator Johnson. OK. So, it may be true then?
 Mr. Erdman. No, no, no, no, no. Let me be very clear, there 
were no bribes. They received an Exceptional Performance Award. 
They were upset with it and it was not a bribe. But what I will 
say, the people who were not----
 Senator Johnson. OK. They were rewarded for----
 Mr. Erdman. Their work. They did not know they were going 
to get it.
 Senator Johnson. I gotcha. OK. I got you and I understand 
this distinction.
 One point and one question. Just received this from Liz 
Lyons, the CIA Director of Public Affairs. ``The committee 
acted in bad faith by subpoenaing an agency officer for 
testimony today without notifying CIA. Despite having already 
obtained closed-door testimony from the individual previously, 
the witness testifying today is not appearing as a 
whistleblower in pursuant of the truth, but instead in response 
to the subpoena issued by Chairman Paul. This proceeding 
amounts to nothing more than a dishonest political theater 
masquerading as a congressional hearing as the CIA has already 
assessed COVID-19 most likely originated from the lab leak and 
efforts to undermine that conclusion are disingenuous.''
 I am calling on CIA Director Ratcliffe and this person to 
apologize to Chairman Paul and this Committee. This is not 
political theater. I have years and years and years of built-up 
frustration of agencies like the CIA, Department of Justice, 
the FBI, HHS, snubbing our oversight, giving us the big middle 
finger.
 That really leads me into my question. You talked about how 
proud you were, OK? I can imagine that. My belief is that I 
would say most people serving in government, all these agencies 
are doing good work. They are patriots. Why aren't there more 
people like you? I mean, you saw Senator Hawley's, the five-
page snub, the five-page middle finger saying, ``Any and all, 
this is it.'' People inside the agencies know that is not the 
truth. They know that is a big fat lie.
 What happens inside the agency that people, good Americans, 
patriotic Americans, people who believe in democracy witness 
that and realize the agency they are working for is lying bold 
face to legitimate congressional oversight, legitimate 
congressional investigations to the American people. What is 
causing this?
 Mr. Erdman. Two answers. One, we need more leaders like 
Director Gabbard who pulls together a taskforce of people to 
actually pursue this, despite the difficulty in wrangling 
agencies to do the right thing. I think the second thing I will 
say is it is a minority of officers. I mean, most of the people 
joining the CIA are barrel-chested freedom fighters. They are 
out there wanting to do the right thing. As you matriculate 
upwards into the bureaucracy, I just think that it gets easier 
and easier to find people who are more willing to get along.
 If we want to link this back to COVID, you had a bunch of 
Refuseniks out there that said no. They were trying to push 
these people out, and what you really need in these 
organizations, you cannot have the whole organization saying no 
to everything because nothing gets done, but you have to retain 
the people who are sometimes a little more difficult to deal 
with, more willing to say no over and over.
 I think we have created a milquetoast bureaucracy. When I 
first joined the agency, the chiefs of offices had a lot of 
power, and then modernization happened and they watered 
everything down and you didn't--the accountability piece has to 
be there, otherwise this is just going to keep happening.
 Senator Johnson. Again, I appreciate you coming forward. I 
am calling on Director Ratcliffe and that communications 
person. This Committee, this Chairman needs an apology. This is 
not political theater. This is serious oversight work. This is 
what the American people need to see, and I just wish our 
Democrat colleagues had any level of curiosity what is 
happening inside the deep state.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Paul. Thank you. I completely concur. I would also 
like to respond to the CIA spokesman. They say that we have 
already obtained closed-door testimony. Well, closed-door 
testimony does not provide oversight. Public testimony provides 
oversight. We have asked them for public testimony and for 
oversight. We would love to have the scientists, the six or 
seven scientists that were commissioned to look at this. We 
would love to see their report. Why would we not be allowed to 
see their report? I cannot even read that in private, but that 
should be public, the science. If there are sources and 
methods, mark them out, redact them. But we should be able to 
see that.
 But for them to have the gall to say, ``Oh, we allowed the 
witness to testify in private, and that should be enough.'' No, 
you were told by Congress unanimously to declassify this 
material and you send us five pages. You mentioned maybe 2,000 
pages. DOE has a report, that has got to be 40 or 50 pages, but 
the base documents for DOE's report probably run into the 
hundreds of pages just for that one report. They did a great 
analysis of this, but still most of that is not available to 
the public. Why does it need to be available? Because this is 
going to happen again and we need to be prepared and we need to 
talk about it.
 One of the other things we did not get to in this hearing, 
but we need to talk to, how do you prepare for the next 
pandemic? One of the things that actually worked was monoclonal 
antibodies. We need to be talking about how we can quickly 
produce them again, how we can quickly get started on things 
like that. What worked and what did not work. Masks did not 
work. Six feet of distancing, there was no science. They say, 
``Follow the science,'' and yet, it looks like everything that 
happened at the CIA was the politicians overruling the 
scientists. The scientists were concluding this came from the 
lab, from a lab leak in all probability. The politicians were 
overturning them, once at 2 in the morning. That is one of the 
takeaways from this is that yes, follow the science and the 
scientists and that the scientists need to not have a conflict 
of interest.
 Which leads me to the final point I will make before we 
conclude. I applaud the Trump administration for an Executive 
Order saying, ``No more gain-of-function.'' It is head and 
shoulders above anything. The Biden administration really did 
not do much of anything on this. The Trump administration is 
trying to live by that.
 The reason it will not work forever is that people who have 
a weaselly way with words, let's say Anthony Fauci, will come 
back into play, and half of his lieutenants probably still work 
over there. One of them will get in power again and all they 
will simply say is, ``Oh, creating that new virus that grows 10 
times faster and grows better in human cells, well, that's not 
gain-of-function,'' because that is what Anthony Fauci was 
doing. He was still doing the gain-of-function research. He was 
just saying, ``Oh, the way I look at the definition, that's not 
really.''
 We do need a commission. What I proposed is the Risky 
Research Review Act. It would be a Presidential commission. It 
will have scientists on it, they will be experts, but they will 
not be currently in the employ of government, competing for 
grants. I think that is a conflict of interest. They have to be 
people outside of it. There also will be some people who are 
national security experts as well. We have to look at the list 
of things.
 One scientist, Dr. Esfelt, ordered off the internet under 
Biden's policy, he ordered snippets of Deoxyribonucleic acid 
(DNA) from here and here, chopped them up, put them together, 
and he made the Spanish flu. He told the FBI he was doing it 
because he wanted to prove a point. He did not create the 
infectious portion of the Spanish flu, but he said, ``Look, I 
can do it by just ordering DNA.''
 There are a lot of things that have to be addressed, and 
unfortunately, it is somehow a partisan issue, and we are not 
getting anywhere.
 But I want to applaud you for your courage in coming 
forward. You did come forward at the response of a subpoena, 
that is a lawful subpoena, and I see no reason that anyone 
should try to punish you. If anybody does try to punish you, I 
can promise you that we will defend you. Thank you very much.
 Mr. Erdman. Thank you, Senator Paul.
 Chairman Paul. The meeting is adjourned.
 Mr. Erdman. Thank you.
 Chairman Paul. Yes. I would like to thank our witness for 
joining us here today to share his testimony and expertise with 
the Committee. The record for this hearing will remain open 
till 5 p.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026, for the submission of 
statements and questions for the record. The hearing is now 
adjourned. Thank you.
 [Whereupon, at 12:11 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.] ``

 A P P E N D I X

 ---------- 

[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 [all]