DEFENDING FAITH AND FAMILIES AGAINST GOVERNMENT OVERREACH: MAHMOUD V. TAYLOR

Committee on Education and Workforce · Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education House February 10, 2026

Witnesses (4)

  • Baxter, Mr. Eric, Vice President and General Counsel, The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty
  • Daugherty, Mr. Donald, Jr., Senior Litigation Counsel, Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies
  • Rothschild, Dr. Zalman, Assistant Professor of Law, Yeshiva Univeristy, Cardozo School of Law
  • Parshall Perry, Ms. Sarah, Vice President and Legal Fellow, Defending Education

From the witness list in the published hearing record.

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

- DEFENDING FAITH AND FAMILIES AGAINST GOVERNMENT OVERREACH: MAHMOUD V. TAYLOR

[House Hearing, 119 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 DEFENDING FAITH AND FAMILIES
 AGAINST GOVERNMENT OVERREACH:
 MAHMOUD V. TAYLOR
=======================================================================

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON EARLY CHILDHOOD, 
 ELEMENTARY, AND SECONDARY EDUCATION

 OF THE

 COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE
 U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 __________

 HEARING HELD IN WASHINGTON, DC, FEBRUARY 10, 2026

 __________

 Serial No. 119-46

 __________
 
 
 Printed for the use of the Committee on Education and Workforce
 
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 Available via: edworkforce.house.gov or www.govinfo.gov
 
 __________
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
65-590 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026
======================================================================= 
 
 COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE

 TIM WALBERG, Michigan, Chairman

JOE WILSON, South Carolina ROBERT C. ``BOBBY'' SCOTT, 
VIRGINIA FOXX, North Carolina Virginia,
GLENN THOMPSON, Pennsylvania Ranking Member
GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JOE COURTNEY, Connecticut
ELISE M. STEFANIK, New York FREDERICA S. WILSON, Florida
RICK W. ALLEN, Georgia SUZANNE BONAMICI, Oregon
JAMES COMER, Kentucky MARK TAKANO, California
BURGESS OWENS, Utah ALMA S. ADAMS, North Carolina
LISA C. McCLAIN, Michigan MARK DeSAULNIER, California
MARY E. MILLER, Illinois DONALD NORCROSS, New Jersey
JULIA LETLOW, Louisiana LUCY McBATH, Georgia
KEVIN KILEY, California JAHANA HAYES, Connecticut
MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio ILHAN OMAR, Minnesota
JAMES C. MOYLAN, Guam HALEY M. STEVENS, Michigan
ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri GREG CASAR, Texas
RYAN MACKENZIE, Pennsylvania SUMMER L. LEE, Pennsylvania
MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington JOHN W. MANNION, New York
MARK HARRIS, North Carolina ADELITA S. GRIJALVA, Arizona
MARK B. MESSMER, Indiana
RANDY FINE, Florida

 R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director
 Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director
 
 ------ 

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON EARLY CHILDHOOD, ELEMENTARY, AND SECONDARY EDUCATION

 KEVIN KILEY, California, Chairman

MARY E. MILLER, Illinois SUZANNE BONAMICI, Oregon,
GLENN THOMPSON, Pennsylvania Ranking Member
BURGESS OWENS, Utah JAHANA HAYES, Connecticut
MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio SUMMER L. LEE, Pennsylvania
JAMES C. MOYLAN, Guam JOHN W. MANNION, New York
RYAN MACKENZIE, Pennsylvania FREDERICA S. WILSON, Florida
MARK HARRIS, North Carolina ALMA S. ADAMS, North Carolina
MARK B. MESSMER, Indiana ADELITA S. GRIJALVA, Arizona
 
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 
 Page

Hearing held on February 10, 2026................................ 1

 OPENING STATEMENTS

 Kiley, Hon. Kevin, Chairman, Subcommittee on Early Childhood, 
 Elementary, and Secondary Education........................ 1
 Prepared statement of.................................... 3
 Bonamici, Hon. Suzanne, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Early 
 Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education............. 5
 Prepared statement of.................................... 7

 WITNESSES

 Baxter, Mr. Eric, Vice President and General Counsel, The 
 Becket Fund for Religious Liberty.......................... 9
 Prepared statement of.................................... 11
 Daugherty, Mr. Donald, Jr., Senior Litigation Counsel, 
 Defense of Freedom Institute for Policy Studies............ 19
 Prepared statement of.................................... 21
 Rothschild, Dr. Zalman, Assistant Professor of Law, Yeshiva 
 Univeristy, Cardozo School of Law.......................... 26
 Prepared statement of.................................... 28
 Parshall Perry, Ms. Sarah, Vice President and Legal Fellow, 
 Defending Education........................................ 34
 Prepared statement of.................................... 36

 ADDITIONAL SUBMISSIONS

 Ranking Member Bonamici:
 Letter dated February 9, 2026, from Americans United for 
 Separation of Church and State......................... 53
 Article from The George Washington University Law School, 
 titled ``Mahmoud v. Taylor: Cause or Effect of 
 Disruptions in the Public Schools?''................... 66
 Letter signed by the National Women's Law Center and 14 
 civil rights organizations............................. 130
 Owens, Hon. Burgess, a Representative in Congress from the 
 State of Utah:
 Statement dated February 10, 2026, from the Sutherland 
 Institute.............................................. 133

 QUESTIONS FOR THE RECORD

 Responses to questions submitted for the record by:
 Dr. Zalman Rothschild.................................... 137

 
 DEFENDING FAITH AND FAMILIES
 AGAINST GOVERNMENT OVERREACH: MAHMOUD V. TAYLOR

 ---------- 

 Tuesday, February 10, 2026

 House of Representatives,
 Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and 
 Secondary Education,
 Committee on Education and Workforce,
 Washington, DC.
 The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:16 a.m., in 
Room 2175, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Kevin Kiley 
(Chairman of the Subcommittee) presiding.
 Present: Representatives Kiley, Miller, Owens, Rulli, 
Harris, Messmer, Walberg, Bonamici, Hayes, Lee, Mannion, Adams, 
Grijalva, and Scott.
 Staff present: Lauren Blunt, Intern; Vlad Cerga, Director 
of Information Technology; Hope Dennis, Intern; Halle 
Greenbaum, Staff Assistant; Charlie Hatcher, Legislative 
Assistant; Amy Raaf Jones, Director of Education and Human 
Services Policy; Libby Kearns, Press Assistant; Campbell Ladd, 
Clerk; R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director; Jack Leonard, Staff 
Assistant; Danny Marca, Director of Information Technology; 
R.J. Martin, Professional Staff Member; Audra McGeorge, 
Communications Director; Ethan Pann, Deputy Press Secretary and 
Digital Director; Sara Robertson, Press Secretary; Katherine 
Anne Russo, Director of Member Services and Coalitions; Brad 
Thomas, Deputy Director of Education and Human Services Policy; 
Thomas White, Deputy Clerk; James Whittaker, General Counsel; 
Shaunice Afriyieb, Minority CBCF Intern; Ilana Brunner, 
Minority General Counsel; Rashage Green, Minority Director of 
Education Policy & Counsel; Christian Haines, Minority General 
Counsel; A'Ishah Johnson, Minority Grad Intern; Raiyana Malone, 
Minority Press Secretary; Marie McGrew, Minority Press 
Assistant; Eleazar Padilla, Minority Staff Assistant; Veronique 
Pluviose, Minority Staff Director; Theresa Tilling-Thompson, 
Minority Professional Staff; Banyon Vassar, Minority Director 
of IT.
 Chairman Kiley. The Subcommittee on Early Childhood, 
Elementary and Secondary Education will come to order. I note 
that a quorum is present. Without objection, the Chair is 
authorized to call recess at any time.
 Parental rights are fundamental. That means parents have a 
right to direct their child's education and a right to the 
information necessary to do so. Across the country, a number of 
school districts are introducing controversial materials into 
classrooms while keeping parents in the dark. One of the worst 
examples is Maryland's Montgomery County Public Schools, which 
introduced curriculum promoting gender ideology for children as 
young as kindergarten during the 2022-2023 school year.
 If a student dared to even question the content of these 
lessons, the district coached teachers to chastise students and 
repeat the same line ``That comment is hurtful.'' These 
teachings conflict with the sincerely held beliefs of many 
parents, who are concerned about the rise of classroom content 
that is not age appropriate for young children.
 A group of parents from many faiths, including Muslim, 
Catholic and Ukrainian Orthodox families, asked the Montgomery 
District for advanced notice of days on which these concepts 
will be taught so they could opt their students out. The 
parents did not ask to dictate curriculum or forbid other 
families from participating in these lessons. They merely 
wanted the opportunity to keep their kids home for a day in 
accordance with their beliefs.
 The district said no. The case went to the Supreme Court. 
In Mahmoud v. Taylor, the Court granted a preliminary 
injunction on the grounds that the parents' right to opt out of 
the district's gender and sexuality teachings was protected 
under the free exercise clause of the U.S. Constitution. The 
Court held that ``A government burdens the religious exercise 
of parents when it requires them to submit their children to 
instruction that poses a very real threat of undermining the 
religious beliefs and practices that the parents wish to 
instill.''
 The Court concluded that ``For many people of faith, there 
are few religious acts more important than the religious 
education of their children,'' thereby receiving ``a generous 
measure of constitutional protection.'' These are common sense 
principles. Religious freedom is a cornerstone of American 
life, and parents do not surrender it for their children when 
they enroll them in public school.
 Unfortunately, we will hear testimony today that some 
districts are trying to circumvent or even defy the Court's 
holding in Mahmoud. The State of California is attempting to 
minimize the scope of Mahmoud by giving local districts vast 
discretion over how and when opt-outs are allowed.
 Seattle public schools have gone even further by banning 
parental optouts from certain classes. These reports are 
gravely concerning to this Committee. For the past century, the 
Supreme Court has repeatedly held that parents have a 
fundamental right to direct the upbringing, health and 
education of their children, including faith.
 As recently as 2000, the Court called it perhaps the oldest 
of the fundamental liberty interests recognized. Today's 
hearing will examine the Mahmoud case, the State of parental 
rights in America and whether districts are complying with the 
law. In a world where new and controversial types of content 
are finding their way into classrooms, it is essential that 
parents maintain control over their child's education. The 
Committee stands on the side of parents, students and the 
Constitution.
 With that, I yield to the Ranking Member for an opening 
statement.
 [The opening statement of Chairman Kiley follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Ms. Bonamici. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank 
you to the witnesses for being here today. Public K-12 schools 
across the country are right now facing a deluge of crises that 
affect the safety, security, and academic future of students. 
According to Sandy Hook Promise, nearly 400,000 children have 
experienced gun violence at school since the turn of the 
century, and that is far more than any other developed country.
 Some kids go to school with built-in bullet shields in 
their backpacks, and parents live in fear that their child 
might not come home. Children across the country are also 
experiencing trauma at the hands of their own government, as 
ICE rips families apart and preys on people near schools and 
hospitals. Right now, educators are asking me what to do when 
ICE agents appear on their school grounds. They are sharing 
stories of children distracted by fear, families afraid to ask 
for help, and staff struggling to support students who are 
carrying adult-size burdens into the classroom.
 One superintendent told me about a first-grade classroom 
where every student had a story about being afraid of ICE. 
These stories are heartbreaking, and they demand our attention 
and action. As our communities experiencing this overwhelming 
fear, Donald Trump and Secretary McMahon continue to illegally 
dismantle the Department of Education. Students who experience 
discrimination are left without recourse as Secretary McMahon 
has implemented a mass reduction in force that essentially 
emptied the Office of Civil Rights, and a new GAO report 
confirmed that the agency has dismissed 90 percent of the 
discrimination cases that have been filed.
 Add to that post-pandemic loneliness, device addiction, gun 
violence and social media addiction; it paints an alarming 
picture for both K-12 education and the overall well-being of 
our Nation's children. This Committee, and especially this 
Subcommittee, has a responsibility to help children thrive 
regardless of their neighborhood, their family income, or, 
according to the U.S. Supreme Court in 1982, immigration 
status.
 Instead of addressing these many real dangers to students, 
my colleagues on the other side of the aisle are once again 
turning classrooms into an epicenter of culture wars to the 
detriment of students and families. No one is arguing that 
parents should not be involved in their children's education. I 
know that firsthand because I was an active parent volunteer 
for years and know firsthand that family involvement is 
critical to a child's development and educational success.
 We all agree on that, but unfortunately, instead of 
focusing on community schools or other support that would help 
students succeed, today's hearing will further perpetuate a 
culture of fear and censorship. Instead of having a meaningful 
discussion about how to improve education or conducting 
oversight on what is left of the Trump Department of Educ--
Trump Administration's Department of Education, Republicans are 
using parental rights as another means to undermine public 
education.
 Students deserve to learn all of the nuance and intricacies 
of the world around them in an age-appropriate manner. 
Preventing students in public schools from learning certain 
material based on the religious objections of a vocal minority 
sets a dangerous precedent. Further, it increases the 
administrative burden on already resource-strapped schools and 
educators who fear retribution for teaching about topics that 
some might think is controversial: world religions, classic 
literature, African American history, evolution, climate 
science, and the history of the LGBTQ Community.
 Inclusion is not indoctrination. Differences exist in the 
world around us, and part of a good education includes teaching 
students about tolerance and understanding. Banning books or 
preventing students from learning about differences serves to 
perpetuate a culture of hatred and fear.
 I do want to note some hypocrisy here. Countless times in 
this Committee, my colleagues have said they want to give 
education back to the states. I have heard that numerous times 
over the years. For the most part, they are talking about 
curriculum. As we have repeated again and again in this 
Committee, the Federal Government is not in charge of 
curriculum or what books are in schools.
 If parents do not like books or curriculum, they can go to 
the school board and ask for a change. If they do not like the 
school board's decision, they can elect a new school board. 
That is the kind of local control I thought my colleagues 
wanted.
 My Democratic colleagues and I are committed to fighting 
against politicizing education. We will continue to work with 
students, parents, educators, and communities until every 
student receives an accurate and high-quality education in a 
safe, well-funded environment without fear of gun violence or 
masked Federal agents breaking down the classroom door.
 I look forward to the conversation, Mr. Chairman. I yield 
back the balance of my time.
 [The opening statement of Ranking Member Bonamici follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 Chairman Kiley. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8(c), all 
members who wish to insert written statements into the record 
may do so by submitting them to the Committee Clerk 
electronically in Microsoft Word format by 5 p.m., 14 days 
after this hearing. Without objection, the hearing record will 
remain open for 14 days to allow such statements and other 
extraneous material noted during the hearing to be submitted 
for the official hearing record.
 I will now introduce our witnesses. Our first witness is 
Mr. Eric Baxter, the Vice President and Senior Counsel at the 
Becket Fund for Religious Liberty from Washington, DC.
 Our second witness is Donald Daugherty, a senior litigation 
counsel for Defense of Freedom Institute from River Hills, 
Wisconsin.
 Our third witness is Mr. Zalman Rothschild, an assistant 
professor of law at Yeshiva University Cordoza School of Law 
from New York City.
 Our fourth witness is Ms. Sarah Parshall Perry, a Vice 
President and Legal Fellow at Defending Education from 
Arlington, Virginia.
 We thank our--we thank the witnesses for being here today 
and we look forward to your testimony. Pursuant to Committee 
rules, I would ask that each limit your oral presentation to a 
3-minute summary of your written statement. As Committee 
members have many questions for you, the clock will count down 
from 3 minutes. However, pursuant to Committee Rule 8(d) and 
Committee practice, we will not cutoff your testimony until you 
reach the 5-minute mark.
 I would also like to remind the witnesses to be aware of 
your responsibility to provide accurate information to the 
Subcommittee. I will first recognize Mr. Baxter for your 
testimony.

 STATEMENT OF ERIC BAXTER, VICE PRESIDENT AND GENERAL COUNSEL, 
 THE BECKET FUND FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY, WASHINGTON, D.C.

 Mr. Baxter. Good morning, Chair Kiley, Ranking Member 
Bonamici and distinguished Committee members. I am Eric Baxter 
from the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and the lead 
attorney for the plaintiffs in Mahmoud v. Taylor. Mahmoud is 
the Supreme Court's most significant parental rights case in 
half a century. It affirms parents' right to opt their children 
out of public school instruction that violates their religious 
belief, but it also signals a move to strengthen religious 
liberty more broadly.
 The case arose after the Montgomery County, Maryland School 
Board introduced LGBTQ storybooks with a stated goal of 
disrupting students thinking about gender and sexuality. The 
curriculum introduces children as young as three to pride 
parades, playground romance and gender transitions.
 Teachers are instructed to emphasize that doctors only 
guessed at student sex at their birth, and to frame contrary 
views as unfair and hurtful. The curriculum was immediately 
controversial. Even the elementary school principals union 
warned it was age inappropriate, factually dubious and 
dismissive of religious beliefs.
 Parents were first told they could opt their kids out, but 
the board soon reversed, saying they could not even be notified 
when the books were read. At a board meeting over a thousand 
parents, largely Muslim and Ethiopian Orthodox, expressed 
concern. The board responded by comparing them to xenophobes 
and white supremacists. The parents sued, seeking not to remove 
the curriculum but simply to restore the optouts. After two 
lower Courts rejected the parents' claims, the Supreme Court in 
a 6-3 ruling reversed. It said the curriculum was unmistakably 
designed to impose values hostile to many faiths, and that it 
exerted psychological pressure on young children to conform.
 The Court concluded that parents' right to a direct the 
religious upbringing of their children would be an empty 
promise if it did not extend into the classroom. This ruling 
has enormous significance. Schools nationwide must now adopt 
policies to accommodate students' religious beliefs or risk 
financial exposure for themselves and their employees. The 
ruling also calls into question the widespread school policies 
that support gender transitioning behind parents' backs.
 Any effort to undermine parents on such religiously 
sensitive matters cannot be squared with Mahmoud. Beyond this 
immediate impact, Mahmoud also bypassed Employment Division v. 
Smith, an earlier Supreme Court ruling that significantly 
limited free exercise protections. That move undermines Smith's 
continued viability.
 If the parents here get to bypass Smith, why should 
teachers challenging the same policy have to satisfy its higher 
standards? If not teachers, why anyone else defending their own 
religious liberty? In this sense, Mahmoud portends Smith's 
demise, which will strengthen religious liberty for all. Thank 
you for shining a light today on this remarkable Supreme Court 
opinion.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Baxter follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 Chairman Kiley. Thank you very much. I will recognize Mr. 
Daugherty for your testimony.

 STATEMENT OF DONALD DAUGHERTY, SENIOR LITIGATION COUNSEL, 
 DEFENSE OF FREEDOM INSTITUTE, RIVER HILLS, WISCONSIN

 Mr. Daugherty. Chairman Kiley and Ranking Member Bonamici, 
thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Don 
Daugherty, and I am Senior Litigation Counsel for the Defense 
of Freedom Institute. In my time, I am going to focus on the 
implications of Mahmoud v. Taylor. Going forward, parents of 
faith will be able to use Mahmoud to push back against 
overreach by public schools, and the case should lead to more 
curriculum transparency.
 For example, now in Montgomery County, each semester 
students receive refrigerator magnets detailing the upcoming 
curriculum, including books to be read so that their parents 
can decide whether they want to opt out or not. Also, in 
another case in late December in Massachusetts, a Federal Court 
there relied on Mahmoud to enjoin Lexington Public Schools when 
the schools refused to allow parents to opt their 5-year-old 
out of LGBTQ themed books that violated the family's Christian 
faith. That is just a very recent case.
 At the same time, Mahmoud is not a license for parents to 
micromanage the curriculum, and Courts will need to define more 
clearly what this free exercise parental right encompasses. 
Some parents in Mahmoud objected to the storybook series on 
purely secular grounds, and the Supreme Court has recognized 
that under the due process clause of the 14th amendment that is 
a part from the free exercise clause of the First Amendment, 
parents have a substantive right to direct the upbringing and 
education of their children generally, not just in matters of 
religion.
 Guidance from the Federal Courts will be needed on this 
issue as well going forward. Finally, a mystery surrounding 
Mahmoud is what critical principle was the Montgomery County 
Board of Education trying to vindicate by defending its no 
optout policy all the way to the Supreme Court. Many people 
wondered about this.
 In addition to Montgomery County families, many Montgomery 
County principals and teachers in public schools questioned the 
use of the storybook series. Before the case was decided, the 
Washington Post and the New York Times criticized the board's 
decision to force parents to go to Court and the board expended 
considerable taxpayer dollars fighting those parents when they 
could have easily reached, I believe, an out of Court 
settlement.
 During oral argument at the Supreme Court, Justice 
Kavanaugh, who pointed out that he is a lifelong resident of 
Montgomery County, he stated that he was a bit mystified how it 
came to this, noting that Maryland was founded on religious 
liberty in expressing surprise that the board had decided that 
this is the hill we are going to die on.
 Justice Alito similarly asked the board's attorney ``What's 
the big deal about allowing parents to opt their children 
out?'' Even Justice Alena Kagan, who ultimately dissented, said 
she suspected that there were a lot of nonreligious parents who 
were not all that thrilled about this. Although no one can read 
the board's minds as to what they hoped to achieve through this 
case, at the least, Mahmoud did reveal how disconnected some 
public schools have become from the families that they serve.
 The First Amendment and the Bill of Rights generally exists 
to protect individual rights from a tyranny of the majority. As 
public schools more and more encroach on aspects of a 
children's upbringing beyond the core curriculum, the 
importance of constitutional bulwarks only increases. In 
Mahmoud, the Supreme Court wisely reinforced the free exercise 
bulwark. At the same time, parents cannot allow themselves to 
be treated like a captive audience by their elected 
representatives. Mahmoud shows that parents can and must take 
back their children's public schools and that the First 
Amendment is one way that to assist them in doing so. Thank 
you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Daugherty follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 Chairman Kiley. Thanks very much. I will next recognize Dr. 
Rothschild for your testimony.

STATEMENT OF DR. ZALMAN ROTHSCHILD, ASSISTANT PROFESSOR OF LAW, 
 YESHIVA UNIVERSITY, CARDOZO SCHOOL OF LAW, NEW YORK, NEW YORK

 Mr. Rothschild. Chairman Kiley, Ranking Member Bonamici, 
members of the Committee, my name is Zalman Rothschild. I am an 
Assistant Professor of Law at Cardozo School of Law. I am also 
an ordained rabbi and have a Ph.D. in Jewish Studies. Thank you 
for the opportunity to testify today.
 This hearing concerns an issue that has generated intense 
public attention. In Mahmoud v. Taylor, the Supreme Court held 
that religious parents have a constitutional right to remove 
their children from public school instruction that conflicts 
with the religious values they seek to instill. The decision 
has been celebrated by many religious liberty advocates and by 
broader parental rights movements as it is being celebrated 
this very morning.
 That celebration is misplaced. To understand why, it is 
necessary to situate Mahmoud within a longer constitutional 
tradition, one that has governed for nearly a century. That 
tradition did not deny the importance of parental authority or 
religious liberty, but it recognized the need for limiting 
principles. Mahmoud departs from that tradition even as it 
presents itself as continuing it.
 I want to highlight just two decisions from that tradition: 
Barnett, decided in 1943, and Yoder, decided in 1972. Both are 
often invoked as victories for parental and religious rights in 
education. Both were far more limited.
 In Barnett, the Court held that public schools could not 
compel Jehovah's Witness children or any children to salute the 
flag and recite the pledge of allegiance. Barnett drew a line 
between compelled affirmation and mere instruction. Schools 
could teach contested ideas. They just could not require 
students to profess them.
 Second, the Court went out of its way to clarify that 
quote. ``The issue, as we see it, does not turn on one's 
possession of particular religious views or the sincerity with 
which they are held.'' Religion supplied the plaintiff's 
motive, but the constitutional violation was compelled speech, 
not religious burden.
 This distinction mattered immensely, because the injury was 
compelled speech, the remedy was to invalidate the policy 
across the board. Barnett did not create a system of 
individualized opt-outs.
 Yoder was also limited. It exempted Amish parents from 
compulsory high school attendance, but only because enforcement 
threatened a cohesive religious community's very survival.
 The Court stressed the collective nature of the risk. 
Compulsory schooling carried ``a very real threat of 
undermining the Amish community and religious practice as they 
exist today.'' The best reading of Yoder is that it reflected a 
pluralistic compromise. It protected a community's mechanism of 
cultural and religious transmission, while still expressing 
concern about children's later ability to exit that community. 
It was not a general endorsement of parental opt-outs from 
public school instruction.
 For 80 years, courts uniformly applied these distinctions. 
Parents could choose either public or private education. 
Students could not be compelled to affirm beliefs. Religious 
communities could--in rare circumstances involving threats to 
their survival--obtain narrow exemptions from high school 
compulsory education laws. Parents had no general right to opt 
out of public-school curriculum simply because it conflicted 
with their values.
 This consensus, it should be noted, was not invented by 
progressive courts. It emerged from decisions often associated 
with constitutional conservatism.
 Parental rights and religious liberty are part of America's 
constitutional history and for good reason. That tradition also 
embodies hard earned judgments about how those values must 
coexist with others, including child welfare, public education, 
and public health. Barnett and Yoder represent the best of our 
constitutional tradition, a careful balance among parental 
liberty, State authority, and children's welfare. They reflect 
wisdom about how to sustain religious pluralism without 
eviscerating public institutions.
 Mahmoud upends that settlement while pretending to preserve 
it. The celebration of Mahmoud by religious liberty and 
parental rights advocates may prove short lived once the 
decision's logic is deployed by parents across the ideological 
spectrum, and once states lose the ability to ensure that all 
children receive basic education, health care, and protection.
 There is a reason the constitutional consensus held for 
nearly a century. The Court seems to now be dismantling it 
without fully grappling with the wisdom it embodied or the 
problems its destruction may create. This deserves more careful 
consideration than it has received. Thank you. I look forward 
to your questions.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Rothschild follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Chairman Kiley. Thank you very much. I will last recognize 
Ms. Parshall Perry for your testimony.

 STATEMENT OF SARAH PARSHALL PERRY, VICE PRESIDENT AND LEGAL 
 FELLOW, DEFENDING EDUCATION, ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA

 Ms. Parshall Perry. Chairman Kiley, Ranking Member Bonamici 
and distinguished members of the Subcommittee, good morning. As 
a legal scholar, a policy analyst and a mother, the issue we 
are here today to discuss is near to my heart and I commend the 
Committee for holding this hearing.
 Mahmoud was not simply an extraordinary case because of its 
well-reasoned holding and sound jurisprudence. It was 
extraordinary insofar as the petitioner's challenges were 
necessary at all, that their yearslong efforts to opt their 
children out of questionable material pursuant to their free 
exercise rights even required the Supreme Court's deliberation 
is a grave condemnation on the State of American education writ 
large.
 Rather than orienting public classrooms toward the urgent 
task of reversing the Nation's flagging NAPE scores, indicating 
that only 22 percent of our high school seniors are numerate 
and only 35 percent are literate, most schools seem content 
instead to educate for activism, social Justice and queer 
propaganda.
 Consider a few of our unearthed examples. In Lexington, 
Massachusetts, kindergarten students are subjected to DEI 
curriculum that includes instruction on changing their bodies 
to fit their gender identity. In South Burlington, Vermont, the 
elementary school curriculum directs students to become active 
antiracists with resources from the groups reading is 
resistance and woke kindergarten. In Los Angeles, California, 
they offer a queer all year school calendar, providing teachers 
and students with new LGBTQ resources every month like Reading 
the Rainbow, a guide to literacy through a queer lens. 
Wauwatosa, Wisconsin Public Schools have instituted sex ed 
curriculum that teaches children as young as five about gender 
identity, and eliminates the word
 ``Men'' and ``women'' from the kindergarten lexicon.
 In Seattle, Washington, teachers are instructed to hide 
students' gender identity from their parents, making it more 
than 1,200 school districts now that we have identified with 
similar deceptive policies. Post Mahmoud, it also refuses to 
allow optouts from queer themed curriculum for religious 
parents and has solicited supplies for a community health 
locker project, including chest binders, nipple guards and tuck 
friendly underwear.
 Our organization has tracked thousands of incidents like 
these. They evidence the astonishing misconception under which 
many American schools operate that the child is the mere 
creature of the State. The Supreme Court, however, has held 
precisely the opposite more than 100 years ago in Pierce v. 
Society of Sisters, when it struck down Oregon's compulsory 
public education law.
 20 years later, it reinforced Pierce in Prince v. 
Massachusetts, holding that the custody, care and nurture of 
the child reside first in the parents, whose primary function 
and freedom include preparation for obligations the State 
cannot supply or hinder. Again in Wisconsin v. Yoder, the Court 
hued closely to precedent, determining that a parent's interest 
in the free exercise of religion outweighed the state's 
interest in compelling school attendance beyond eighth grade.
 Mahmoud was the capstone in the Court's parental rights and 
religious liberty canon, reinforcing the pre-political, natural 
and ancient right of a parent to direct their child's 
upbringing. The statist notion that children belong to all of 
us, that schools not to parents know better, is both 
intractable and persistent. Despite Mahmoud's unequivocal edict 
then, the battle for parental primacy is only just beginning. 
Thank you, and I welcome your questions.
 [The prepared statement of Ms. Parshall Perry follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 Chairman Kiley. Thank you very much to all of our 
witnesses. Under Committee Rule 9, we will now question, 
question the witnesses under the 5-minute rule and I will first 
recognize the Chairman of the full Committee, Mr. Walberg for 5 
minutes.
 Mr. Walberg. Thank you for your kindness on that, Mr. 
Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. As a 
parent who gave life to three children and as a grandparent who 
saw my kids give life to seven grandchildren, I appreciate the 
fact that we are talking about this issue because frankly it 
involves a very survival of the family itself and the primacy 
of parental responsibility, let alone rights.
 Not one school board member gave life to my three kids. In 
a time when we are about to see a rapid increase of lawsuits 
coming from transgendered young people, who have finally seen 
they were lied to, I'm hoping that Montgomery County Schools 
will receive significant lawsuits in the process. We need to 
remember as well that parents cannot opt out of paying local 
public school taxes. That is the difference Mr. Rothschild that 
we are talking about here. They cannot opt out of paying for 
something that they disagree with strongly.
 Though they can leave the schools, they still pay the 
taxes. Mr. Baxter, thank you for your work at the Supreme Court 
to defend parents. You were doing the Lord's work, truly the 
designer's work. It has been over 6 months since Mahmoud was 
decided. Have states been adjusting their policies to align 
with, the Court's decision in Mahmoud? Or are states looking 
for ways to work around the Court's decision?
 Mr. Baxter. I think it is important to remember that school 
boards across the country have long had optout policies, 
including Montgomery County itself. It was only when this 
particular curriculum was introduced that the board withdrew 
the optouts. When Mr. Rothschild asked where will this all go? 
Well really this was an extreme outlier situation where and 
there are other schools doing this, pushing an extreme ideology 
and then trying to block the parents.
 We are simply asking to maintain the status quo in Mahmoud, 
to allow parents to continue to make these decisions, 
especially on issues of gender and sexuality, where all 50 
states require some kind of parental consent. There are some 
states that are continuing to buck the rule from the Court.
 Mr. Walberg. We will have to be watching that carefully. 
Thank you. Mr. Daugherty, Christian parents have drawn a lot of 
attention in this case. It was not just Christians who objected 
to what the Montgomery County Public Schools did. Can you talk 
about why parents from other faiths found the school system's 
policy so concerning?
 Mr. Daughterty. As a practicing Catholic, I know that 
tradition best and I understand how it violates, you know, that 
tradition. Certainly as, as Mr. Baxter knows, his clients 
included Muslims, Eastern Orthodox. I think there were some 
Jewish parents involved. All the Abrahamic religions were 
represented, and I think, you know, just you look to, you know, 
scripture and things like that, that show that these types of 
lessons that were being taught by this storybook series violate 
that.
 Again, as we talked about, some parents who were completely 
secular, not religious, they too objected, thinking that, you 
know, my child and this started like with PreK and then 
kindergarten up K to 5, fifth grade I should say, that no 
children should be exposed to this kind of stuff at that young 
age. The notion that the school board was trying to do so 
offended a lot of people religious and even non-religious.
 Mr. Walberg. Yes. They could see it went against science 
and even common sense. Ms. Parshall Perry, you mentioned in 
your testimony and I quote, that ``Parental rights are pre-
political, ancient and fundamentalist.'' I agree fully. Can you 
explain more what that means and how these three pillars are 
essential to preventing government tyranny?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. Absolutely. These are connections that 
are rooted in biology, the very nature of the parent-child 
relationships, which predates not only government but the 
Constitution itself. In fact, some of the earliest writings 
that we see are from the 13th century in Thomas Aquinas's Summa 
Theological, in which he wrote about the nature of the parent-
child relationship and how it is fundamental.
 It is that basic building block of all civilized societies, 
and it is something on which the Supreme Court first weighed in 
in 1923 in Meyer v. Nebraska, recognizing that this was a right 
that simply had to be found somewhere in the Constitution, 
because we knew it had always existed from time immemorial.
 Mr. Walberg. We lose our country if these fundamental 
principles are broken down, starting with the family and the 
parents in controlling their children for the best interests of 
our country. Thank you so much. I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
 Chairman Kiley. I will now recognize the Ranking Member of 
the Full Committee, Mr. Scott.
 Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Rothschild, is 
there anything in the Mahmoud decision that would allow a 
parent or group of parents to veto information given to other 
children other than their own?
 Mr. Rothschild. Part of the problem with the decision in 
Mahmoud is how confusing it is. On the one hand, it presents 
itself as very narrow, an interpretation that was echoed by Mr. 
Baxter, and the Court goes on and on for about ten pages 
explaining how indoctrinating these picture books were, 
suggesting that that would be the limiting principle.
 Then, somewhat cryptically, Justice Alito adds a paragraph 
at the very end saying, in any event, it does not matter. 
Essentially everything that I just said does not matter, and 
the only question is: does this interfere with the parents' 
ability to instill within their child their religious values or 
their religious beliefs? There is no end point to that.
 Mr. Scott. Well, but they can opt their own children out. 
Can they veto the material being shown and presented to other 
children?
 Mr. Rothschild. Ostensibly not, because the decision is 
framed around opt-outs specifically.
 Mr. Scott. Okay. Now to opt out, do you have to have a 
legitimate claim of religious liberty, or can you opt out for 
values or opinions? Like ``I don't want climate change 
presented'' or not for religious purposes, but ``I just don't 
think LGBTQ material ought to be presented. It's just age 
inappropriate.'' Do you have to have a legitimate claim of 
religious liberty?
 Mr. Rothschild. Mahmoud is a religious liberty case, yes.
 Mr. Scott. You just cannot opt out on opinion?
 Mr. Rothschild. Right.
 Mr. Scott. Alito had some other information in there about 
a threat to religion. It can be contrary to your religion. Does 
it have to be a threat to your religion?
 Mr. Rothschild. Well, that language of a threat comes from 
Yoder, where the threat that the Court is articulating in Yoder 
is a threat to the survival of this distinctive religious 
community, the Amish community in Wisconsin. It somehow gets 
transported to opt-outs in public schools, even though Yoder is 
talking about opting out of compulsory education laws for 2 
years, the ages of 14 to 16, under very specific circumstances.
 The language of threat now is used in Mahmoud to suggest 
that so long as anything in the curriculum threatens the 
parents' ability to instill the parents' religious values in 
their children, that threat is constitutionally protected.
 Mr. Scott. Okay. Is there any consideration being given in 
this decision to the harm that may be inflicted on other 
children when they see some of their classmates opting out--all 
of a sudden, it puts a different view on the material they may 
be given. Has any consideration been given to the effect of all 
these opt-outs on the other children?
 Mr. Rothschild. The Court gives no consideration to that. 
It just dismisses it out of hand. One of the arguments that the 
board made was that there is inherent value to teaching 
inclusivity to children, and you can infer from that that it 
very much undermines the message of inclusivity when a group of 
students, you know, stand up and walk out.
 It is like a walkout essentially, from that particular 
teaching. The Supreme Court was just extremely dismissive about 
that particular interest that the State had articulated.
 Mr. Scott. Finally, if you have a complaint about this, 
what agency in the Federal Government would you seek guidance 
from? Would it be the Office of Civil Rights in the Department 
of Education?
 Mr. Rothschild. I would assume so.
 Mr. Scott. Are you aware of what is happening to that 
agency?
 Mr. Rothschild. Somewhat.
 Mr. Scott. Just being dismantled along with the rest of the 
Department?
 Mr. Rothschild. Yes.
 Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. I will recognize myself for 5 minutes. Dr. 
Rothschild, thank you for being here to testify today. I just 
want to get some clarity on your position. I mean you disagree 
with the Mahmoud decision clearly, right?
 Mr. Rothschild. Yes.
 Chairman Kiley. Nevertheless, it is the law of the land 
now. What is the what do you want the takeaway to be from your 
testimony today? What action would ideally you want to follow 
from it, given that Mahmoud is the law?
 Mr. Rothschild. Well, to the extent that Congress is 
contemplating any legislation in the aftermath of Mahmoud, 
which itself would, I mean somewhat be unconstitutional unless 
it is authorized by the Supreme Court, in other words, unless 
the Supreme Court has interpreted that into the Constitution 
itself, but to the extent that Congress is contemplating going 
further than that, my point is, is that Mahmoud should be 
celebrated less than it seems to be celebrated.
 Chairman Kiley. I see. You kind of paint this picture of 
how Mahmoud has unsettled this, you know, settled body of law 
on this particular issue. It is true that even prior to 
Mahmoud, schools across districts across the country do allow 
opt-outs, right?
 Mr. Rothschild. The key there is that it is the districts 
that allow the opt-outs.
 Chairman Kiley. Right. The existence of opt-outs is not 
inherently destabilizing in some sense, is it?
 Mr. Rothschild. Absolutely not. What is destabilizing is 
constitutionalizing opt-outs.
 Chairman Kiley. Do you think opt-outs are appropriate in 
some circumstances?
 Mr. Rothschild. Sure.
 Chairman Kiley. Okay. You think that there is no 
constitutional basis for that?
 Mr. Rothschild. There is no broad general constitutional 
basis for that. It should be a local decision made by the 
districts themselves.
 Chairman Kiley. I see. For the parents in Montgomery County 
who had very strong objections to this content, what was their 
recourse in your view of the law?
 Mr. Rothschild. They may not have had recourse; democracy 
would be their recourse.
 Chairman Kiley. Democracy would be the recourse, okay. You 
do not think there are circumstances in which there might be 
rights that individuals hold, irrespective of what, you know, 
the overriding policy of their jurisdiction is?
 Mr. Rothschild. Well, the question is not: are there 
rights? The question is: is this the right?
 Chairman Kiley. Yes. I mean I think that you just made an 
important concession, which is that you would leave parents 
without a recourse no matter how vile, no matter how, you know, 
discriminatory the curriculum that presented in their classroom 
is. I think that is a serious problem, and I think that you 
paint this decision as somehow some sort of rupture in 
jurisprudence or destabilizing. Actually, I think what is 
different now is the type of content that is coming into the 
classrooms, and the fact that districts are refusing to provide 
optouts for that content. Mr. Baxter, do you think that is an 
appropriate characterization?
 Mr. Baxter. Yes. It is important to remember that American 
democracy is tempered by the Bill of Rights, which protects the 
rights of individuals to live consistent with their religious 
beliefs, their own speech. Every, you know, I had spoke to a 
Washington Post reporter who had a similar view to Dr. 
Rothschild, but he wanted to object his children on issues that 
were concerning to him.
 Every parent has their own optouts, and it is important to 
realize that Mahmoud protects the rights of all parents.
 Chairman Kiley. Yes. It is interesting. I thought he might 
say that the recourse is to go to private school, which is in 
fact, what, you know, various briefs and the lawyers for the 
county argued. There is a problem with that as a legitimate 
recourse for folks as well, right?
 Mr. Baxter. Right. Most parents cannot realistically afford 
to send their children to private school or to homeschool them, 
as was the case of most of our clients.
 Chairman Kiley. Yes. It is ironic because, you know, there 
is this often opposition to school choice that exists among, 
you know, certain segments of the education establishment. When 
it comes to those who have the means to enroll their child and 
to exercise that choice, they are all for it. Do you agree, Mr. 
Daugherty?
 Mr. Daugherty. Yes, no. I mean the notion that you have to 
choose between either raising your children in your faith or 
going to a public school, to me that that is an 
unconstitutional kind of choice. The notion that just well, 
people can easily send their children to private schools, I 
should say or homeschool them, to some extent that to me is 
reminiscent of, you know, let them eat cake.
 I mean for example, just because, you know, you have these 
other ways of dealing with this, but those ways cost a lot of 
money, a lot of time, resources. To me, it is kind of almost 
let them eat cake kind of choice for parents who object to 
things like occurred in Montgomery County.
 Chairman Kiley. Yes. What do you think, Ms. Parshall Perry, 
about this idea that we should just be satisfied with the idea 
that parents have no recourse no matter how, you know, vile or 
how controversial or how threatening to their fundamental 
values content in classrooms is?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. Well, that invokes the arguments that 
we heard in the colloquy with Justice Jackson during oral 
arguments in Mahmoud, when she herself talked about sending 
kids simply to private school. Private school is about 10 
percent of American school kids. Nearly 90 percent of them go 
to public schools. It is a function of necessity for many 
parents. It was for my three children.
 I have two sons who have disabilities, who specifically 
benefit from the civil rights laws, that are enforced through 
public education and will continue to be, regardless of the 
future of the Department of Education. They will be offloaded 
to other agencies per interagency agreement or congressional 
action. It is, I think, a false choice to say you must 
participate in a mandatory tax scheme, but you also have to 
give up your religious liberty rights.
 Chairman Kiley. Thank you very much, and I actually 
appreciate your sort of honesty, Dr. Rothschild. I am just 
saying, there is no recourse rather than pretending that there 
is some recourse. I think that is an alarming thing for many 
parents who are concerned about what is going on in some of our 
schools.
 With that, I will now recognize the Ranking Member for 5 
minutes.
 Ms. Bonamici. Thank you, Chairman, and I want to followup 
on this conversation because I was here listening and Mr. 
Rothschild did not say there was no recourse. He said there was 
democracy. I remember years ago in Oregon, the school board had 
made the decision that the majority of the residents of the 
district did not support. They ran candidates and they changed 
the school board and they changed the decision. That is 
democracy. I do not want to put words in Mr. Rothschild's 
mouth, but I do not want there to be a perception that there is 
no remedy, because there is.
 Again Mr. Chairman, I wish we were here talking about the 
armed masked agents that are lurking outside of schools and the 
gun violence that students are experiencing. You know, we are 
here today because some people are claiming that their 
religious beliefs are threatened by some school lessons that 
may perhaps just acknowledge existence of gay people.
 To me, it is concerning. I want students to learn critical 
thinking and know that their parents are involved in that, and 
I think that is really critical. We do have an expert here on 
the intersection of religious belief. I just want to ask you, 
Mr. Rothschild, how did your Hasidic background and your 
rabbinical training shape your experiences and influence your 
understanding about the debate concerning Mahmoud?
 Mr. Rothschild. I grew up in a Hasidic community, which in 
many ways was a really beautiful upbringing, childhood, and 
education. It also is quite lacking, in particular with respect 
to basic secular education. It is no secret that the Hasidic 
community schools do not teach basics, including science, math, 
literacy.
 Attending law school, I was particularly interested in 
understanding how it could be that society would allow so many 
children, over 100,000 of them in New York alone, to be 
deprived of what is considered a basic right for every child.
 Ms. Bonamici. Thank you. I appreciate that very much, and 
your insight and what you bring to the conversation. I want to 
talk a little bit about the limiting principles that you were 
discussing. I know Pierce because I am from Oregon. That was 
more than a century ago.
 If you think about back in 1972 with the Wisconsin v. 
Yoder, where Yoder--where they addressed the free exercise of 
religion by the Amish and there was discussion about that 
today. Previous rulings had rejected the view that mere 
exposure to educational materials or ideas conflict with the 
students' or parents' religious beliefs and why that does not 
violate the free exercise clause.
 How did Mahmoud change that? What are the limiting 
principles that we are going to need to be aware of?
 Mr. Rothschild. On the one hand, Mahmoud seems to be 
suggesting there is a limiting principle, which is that it's 
fact dependent, case specific, that the courts would have to 
parse the curricula that is in dispute--in Mahmoud, it is 
picture books for three-to 5-year-olds, to determine whether 
that curricula is in any way indoctrinating. Like I said 
before, the Court also walks that back at the very end, just 
sort of sneaks that in there by saying that ``in any event,'' 
those are the exact words, ``none of this matters.''
 If none of this matters, the ostensible limiting principle, 
which itself is not all that much of a limiting principle, 
because indoctrination is not something that is objectively 
recognizable, one could argue that all of education is 
indoctrinating or none of it is indoctrinating. I do not know 
how anybody could really tell the difference.
 Then the Court seems to walk it back by saying so long as 
there is an interference with the ability of parents to raise 
their children according to their religious beliefs, that is 
constitutionally prohibited.
 Ms. Bonamici. If there has to be some sort of fact 
intensive analysis to determine if there is a threat and 
whether there is interference, how is that determined and by 
whom? Could a Christian Scientist say, ``I don't want my child 
to learn anything about health or science'' and opt out of 
that? I mean I just do not understand how this is going to 
work. Do you have any sense?
 Mr. Rothschild. I do not have a sense of how this will 
work, but I could imagine a whole host of very problematic 
scenarios including, for example, say a teacher tries to teach 
the value of nondiscrimination against religion and specifies 
and says it is wrong to discriminate against Jews or against 
Muslims, and some parents have a problem with that because of 
their sincerely held religious beliefs because, you know, 
Chapter 16 of Mark says that those who are not baptized are 
condemned. I have no idea how in any sense this can be bounded.
 Ms. Bonamici. I share your concern and before concluding, 
Mr. Chairman, I want to note that we have heard in this 
Committee again and again about returning education to states. 
Here we are using this hearing as an attempt to dictate what 
can and cannot be taught in schools. We have heard countless 
times in the Committee that is not the Federal Government's 
role to interfere in local curriculum decisions.
 We should not be using our time and resources to perpetuate 
a culture war that most American families do not want. I 
encourage my colleagues to select hearing topics that actually 
matter, like gun violence, trauma inflicted by ICE, and how 
dismantling the Department of Education affects schools and 
students. Mr. Chairman, I do ask unanimous consent to enter 
into the record a letter from Americans United for Separation 
of Church and State on Religion and Public Schools, as well 
as----
 Chairman Kiley. Without objection.
 Ms. Bonamici. As well as a scholarly article by Richard 
Katskee and Ira Lupu called ``Mahmoud v. Taylor: Cause or 
Effect of Disruptions in the Public Schools.''
 Chairman Kiley. Without objection.
 [The letter and article of Ranking Member Bonamici 
follows:]
[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 Chairman Kiley. I now recognize Mr. Owens of Utah for 5 
minutes.
 Mr. Owens. Thank you. Thank you so much. As a dad of six 
kids and 18 grands, this makes my blood boil. I am not--I 
cannot understand how we are sitting here talking how strangers 
should raise my kids. Now if you want to know how this opt-out 
is going to look, we have got it. It is called choice. You are 
going to see the mass opt-outing of programs like this, three 
and 4 year-old kids being taught this sexual smut, and we are 
sitting here as adults thinking it is okay.
 I will say this just to summarize before I get into my 
questions. We are seeing adults, grown people that have the 
power of having little children in their class that they cannot 
escape. They are captured, hiding from the parents the 
curriculum that they are going to teach no matter what the 
parents think or do not think.
 By the way, that is the way the Communism and Socialism 
work if you want to know how that looks. It is not 
hypothetical. Then hiding behind unions so they will not get 
fired. I say two things about these kind of people. They are 
bullies and they are cowards, and I do not want them anywhere 
close to my kids. I will be choosing opt-out, and my parents, 
my kids will be choosing and my grandkids will be choosing opt-
outs whenever we have a situation like this.
 I tell you what is going to happen. The free market is 
going to show itself in a big way. Schools and districts like 
this will go out of business. We will not fund this anymore and 
parents will not show up anymore. Schools out there that are 
doing the right thing, teaching our kids how to read, write, 
think, communicate, articulate, debate and succeed will 
prosper. We will not have to worry about going through this 
democracy mess that takes forever, as our kids being 
indoctrinated.
 Boy, I just cannot believe we are having this conversation 
with grown people. I just--I do not get it. I just do not get 
it anyway. No, I do get it. Anyway, Mr. Daugherty, you 
mentioned that some parents objected to inappropriate teachings 
that had no religious faith. Well, I am glad that the Court 
protected the rights of these religious parents, but I am 
concerned about the school boards that they still force non-
religious parents to have their kids indoctrinated.
 Your written testimony quoted that Justice Kagan mentioned 
there are probably a lot of nonreligious people who are not 
really thrilled about this either. How do you think courts will 
look at protecting rights of the nonreligious parents?
 Mr. Daugherty. Well, as I think Ms. Perry, noted, there is 
a case called Pierce that says that among other things--well, 
it says that parents have parental rights under the 14th 
Amendment, substantive due process clause, and it says 
critically ``Children are not mere creatures of the State.''
 That is very important. Children are they belong to their 
parents who have a duty to love them and raise them. That is 
really where first--the first line of child development begins. 
The notion that now that educational bureaucracies distrust 
parents and exclude them from decisions, that has gotten, I am 
afraid, too far out of hand in this country. A case like 
Mahmoud is a case when they push back.
 I do--I must disagree. I think there are limiting 
principles. I do not think this is going to be hard to deal 
with. As I mentioned in my testimony, in Montgomery County now, 
these issues are addressed by simple refrigerator magnets. Each 
semester, each student gets a refrigerator magnet that says 
what is going to be taught, the books they are going to be 
taught. If they are, if those are lessons violate sincerely 
held religious beliefs of parents, parents can opt out. I do 
not think this is any kind of difficult, you know, onerous 
problem for schools to deal with.
 If anything, I think schools, public schools, public 
teacher unions overreached. They got perhaps a little 
ideologically arrogant and this is a good way of pushing back 
on that.
 Mr. Owens. I think you said something, I just want to make 
a point. It is called arrogance. The district argument was that 
parents' free exercise was not a burden because they could 
remain free to enroll their children other private schools. 
That is pure arrogance. Well, guess what? It is coming. School 
choice can allow them to go to private, public, charter, 
homeschool, parochial. You are going to see a remarkable opt 
out, and I am sorry about that.
 Real quickly, Mr. Baxter, many opposed to the lawsuit 
against the district belief that these parents should have 
engaged in the democratic process to make their voices heard, 
rather than resorting to suing the school districts. Can you 
explain why the democratic process here is the wrong remedy?
 Mr. Baxter. Parents who do engage in the democratic process 
were called bigots, racist and xenophobes. This was a very 
diverse group of Americans of all religious and political 
stripes, who just simply wanted to protect their children's 
education. That is really what the first amendment is for, is 
to make sure that religious liberty of individual families is 
protected.
 Mr. Owens. My advice for these folks who think this way, 
keep it up. You are going to find yourself out of a business, 
out of a job, because we are opting out of this mess for sure. 
Thank you so much. Appreciate it, and I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Adams of North Carolina is 
recognized.
 Ms. Adams. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to our 
witnesses for being here. The Supreme Court's decision in 
Mahmoud v. Taylor was narrow, but the conversation surrounding 
it has not been. There is a real risk that this ruling is used 
to blur a longstanding constitutional line between protecting 
families from compelled belief and undermining the basic 
function of public education.
 Public schools do not exist to affirm any one world view. 
They exist to prepare students to live in a diverse, 
pluralistic society. That necessarily includes exposure to 
ideas that students and families may not agree with. My 
questions today are about limits, about guardrails, and about 
making sure that we do not turn a narrow ruling into a broad 
mandate that destabilizes classrooms across the country.
 Let me turn to our witnesses. Mr. Rothschild, the Supreme 
Court has consistently distinguished between compelled speech 
or forced affirmation of belief on the one hand, and the 
ordinary work of public education, including civics education 
that exposes students to differing ideas, differing ideas, 
excuse me, over time.
 In Mahmoud, did the Court meaningfully engage with that 
distinction? Going forward, how should courts understand the 
difference between unconstitutional coercion and the slow, 
noncoercive process of educating students in a democratic 
society?
 Mr. Rothschild. That last line of yours, I believe, is from 
Barnett, cited in 1943 by Justice Jackson, which was considered 
the quintessential statement on this very distinction that you 
are raising, between your right to send your children to 
private school and that if your child is to attend a public 
school, that within public schools there are some limits.
 To go back to a question that Mr. Kiley was asking me 
before, I think there are limits and Barnett, for example, 
represents some of them. Lower courts since 1943 unanimously 
held to that distinction as well. Mahmoud disrupts it.
 Ms. Adams. Okay. Do you see a risk that Mahmoud could be 
misinterpreted to treat mere exposure to ideas as 
constitutionally suspect, even when no student is required to 
affirm or adopt those ideas?
 Mr. Rothschild. I think it definitely will be interpreted 
that way, yes.
 Ms. Adams. While Mahmoud was framed as a narrow ruling, it 
raises broader questions about who gets to decide what is 
fundamentally necessary to teach children. What concerns you 
about courts or Congress stepping too far into curriculum 
decisions traditionally made by educators and local 
communities, and would a Federal opt-out law risk replacing 
professional education, educational judgment, with litigation-
driven oversight?
 Mr. Rothschild. Much better than I can ever articulate 
this, let me just quote to you Justice Jackson, the author of 
Barnett, in his concurrence in McCollum in 1948. He said ``If 
we are to eliminate everything that is objectionable to any of 
these warring sex or inconsistent with any of their doctrines, 
we will leave public education in shreds. Nothing but 
educational confusion and a discrediting of the public school 
system can result from subjecting it to constant lawsuits.'' 
Now, maybe that is the point.
 Ms. Adams. Maybe so. In your view, which institutions are 
best suited to set these boundaries in a way that protects 
religious liberty without eroding the mission of public 
education, local school boards, educators, states, or Federal 
lawmakers? Which one of those?
 Mr. Rothschild. I mean it has long been recognized that if 
there is any area where democracy is terrain, it is with 
respect to local government. There is nothing perhaps more 
local than boards of education in educational districts. Again, 
to quote from Brown v. Board of Education, ``education is 
perhaps the most important function of State and local 
governments.''
 Ms. Adams. Thank you, sir. I agree. Mr. Chairman, I yield 
back.
 Chairman Kiley. Pursuant to the previous order, the Chair 
declares the Committee in recess. Subject to the call of the 
Chair, we will plan to reconvene promptly in 5 minutes. Thank 
you. The Committee now stands in recess.
 [Recess.]
 Chairman Kiley. The Committee is back in order. 
Representative Miller of Illinois is recognized.
 Ms. Miller. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Parents have the God 
given right to raise their children, especially when it comes 
to educating them in accordance with their faith. This 
fundamental freedom includes the right to know what their 
children are being taught in school. These foundational rights 
are reinforced by Federal legislation through the Family 
Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), and the protection 
of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA).
 The bottom line, parental consent is integral to our 
educational framework. Schools cannot conceal student 
information from a parent. Schools must recognize this reality, 
but it comes as no surprise that Democrats want to take away 
parental rights and education. When parents voice concerns 
about what their children were being taught during the 
pandemic, Joe Biden's Department of Justice labeled them as 
domestic terrorists. Last year, parents in Montgomery County, 
Maryland, scored a monumental victory when the Supreme Court 
reaffirmed what we already knew to be true. Parents control 
their children's education.
 However, many school districts continue to circumvent the 
Supreme Court's ruling, including my home State of Illinois. 
For example, Chicago Public Schools featured sex education 
curriculum beginning in kindergarten. In the first grade, there 
were lessons on how to define gender identity. In second grade 
students were taught the concept of gender stereotypes and how 
to advocate for change.
 In fourth grade, the district curriculum utilized a gender 
snow person to help students explore the concepts of gender 
identity, sexual orientation, sex assigned at birth and gender 
expression. By fifth grade, there was an introduction to 
puberty blockers and students were forced to read gender 
unicorn, learning about sexual orientation and other concepts 
like gender role stereotypes and gender expression. Students 
were even expected to define terms like cisgender, nonbinary, 
and transgender.
 Last year's victory in the Mahmoud case means it is time 
for these schools to fall in line. My first question is to Mr. 
Baxter. In your written testimony, you mentioned the role of 
Congress in protecting parental rights in education, 
particularly through FERPA and PPRA. Do these laws, as written, 
sufficiently protect parental rights or are further protections 
needed?
 Mr. Baxter. They are often ignored by many school 
districts, and even the Supreme Court's ruling is being ignored 
by many school districts. I think Congress's attention to this 
issue and using its funding mechanisms can be an effective way 
to protect the rights of parents.
 Ms. Miller. Thank you. What about when schools manipulate 
FERPA and call it educational outreach, when they send student 
data to left wing voter registration organizations?
 Mr. Baxter. It is a little bit out of my expertise. I am 
here to testify on the religious liberty aspects, but hopefully 
under all of these laws, schools will ensure that all students 
are treated equally regardless of their religion or irreligion. 
All students deserve an equal opportunity to be educated.
 Ms. Miller. Yes, and to have their privacy respected, and 
we are on that. My next question is to Ms. Parshall Perry. In 
your written testimony, you mentioned Justice Kennedy's attempt 
to assuage concerns of religious freedom violations in light of 
the Supreme Court's Obergefell ruling. Could you please explain 
how this ruling was an affront to religious freedom and has set 
off a domino effect of violations, including the Mahmoud case.
 Ms. Parshall Perry. Yes. In fact, Justice Alito himself in 
his excoriating dissent to the Obergefell decision in 2015, 
actually responded to Justice Kennedy's majority opinion and 
said ``This is going to be utilized to stamp out every vestige 
of religious dissent.'' In fact, his words proved to be true. 
In fact, the Mahmoud decision was made necessary because of 
individual decisions like the Obergefell decision.
 Now we can talk about whether or not it is bad 
jurisprudence, which I think it is. It divined a constitutional 
right to same-sex marriage from the same shadowy ether of the 
14th Amendment that the Court did in Roe v. Wade, and that has 
been subsequently overturned. Then we can talk about it as a 
policy prescriptive matter.
 I think the fallout is something we cannot ignore. In fact, 
as we have seen sort of cultural institutions be overtaken by 
progressive orthodoxy, we find parents, good, noble, honest 
parents who simply want their children educated in the 
crosshairs of a culture war they did not start.
 Ms. Miller. That is what we want too. Thank you, and I 
yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Lee of Pennsylvania is 
recognized.
 Ms. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. It would seem that the issue 
is not that parents have a right to raise their children. I 
think the issue is that a certain parent doesn't have a right 
to raise somebody else's child. You do not get to determine for 
other children what religious beliefs they get to be exposed to 
in their schools.
 It just feels to me that Republicans and conservatives are 
always feigning outrage about the wrong things. For instance, 
right now as we are attempting to make it harder for children 
to receive a holistic education, American children are falling 
behind by every metric on the global scale. While kids are 
behind in reading, conservatives are busy trying to make sure 
they cannot read a story about a little girl who adores her 
uncle who is getting married. That is the most recent outrage.
 Reading is a crucial part of how children learn about 
themselves, and how much they have in common with others is how 
they learn about the world. Not only do kids deserve to see 
themselves reflected in books and the curriculum, they perform 
better when they do. The reality is, is that this is just 
another right-wing attempt couched in parents' rights to shield 
children from getting a real education.
 Everything this administration and the right-wing movement 
does is a blatant attempt to make us less educated, more 
narrow-minded, and easier to control. This has a massive impact 
on our ability to function as a society, let alone to compete 
internationally. Right now, we are not a country that people 
are taking seriously. Today, it is about exploiting religious 
exemptions to shield children from the reality of queer people 
existing. Other times it is been trying to shield children from 
the reality of black history lessons and how black history is 
American history or indigenous studies or various languages as 
we have seen through the outrage of Bad Bunny performing at the 
Olympics. It is always centered in bigotry and xenophobia. It 
is suffocating our country.
 Mr. Rothschild, First Amendment doctrine has shifted 
dramatically in the last few years due to President Trump's 
appointments to the Supreme Court. Do you expect we will 
continue seeing religious freedom weaponized to justify 
censorship in schools? How do you believe this will impact 
education, excuse me, public education in our country?
 Mr. Rothschild. Thank you for the question. Religious 
liberty jurisprudence has expanded drastically under Trump, 
under Trump's administration and his appointments to the 
Supreme Court. For example, during the pandemic, the Supreme 
Court interpreted the meaning of religious discrimination under 
the Free Exercise Clause in exceptionally expansive ways, such 
that basically any law that doesn't provide an exemption for 
religion is discrimination against religion.
 Most recently, it is Mahmoud, where the focus is not on 
religious discrimination, although there is vestiges of that in 
Justice Alito's opinion too, where he frames the lack of opt-
outs and the teaching or the reading rather of these picture 
books as hostility, as explicit hostility toward religion. 
Essentially anything can be framed as discrimination against 
religion. Technically speaking, Mahmoud is a religious liberty 
case, not a religious discrimination case.
 Ms. Lee. Conservatives are also hoping that cases like 
Mahmoud v. Taylor will cause already under-resourced public 
schools to preemptively censor curriculums to avoid costly 
lawsuits from a vocal minority. We are already seeing this 
happen, right? A Rand study found that teachers are 
preemptively whitewashing curricula following the manufactured 
moral panic against critical race theory.
 In Justice Alito's ruling in Mahmoud v. Taylor, he said, 
``Not allowing parents to opt out imposes a hostile 
environment,'' as you mentioned. Do you believe that this 
ruling could also create a hostile environment for LGBTQ+ 
children or other marginalized children in the same vein?
 Mr. Rothschild. Yes, I mean I could I just imagine, and 
this was argued in Mahmoud, that if you allow for opt-outs, it 
is not only about the administrability of the opt-outs. One of 
the concerns that the board had in Mahmoud was the influx of 
requests for opt-outs, once these children books were 
introduced into the curriculum.
 It is not just administrability, it's also the messaging 
that is sent when children are allowed to walk out of the 
classroom as soon as teachings about inclusivity of other 
children is implemented.
 Ms. Lee. Thank you. Conservatives are exploiting religious 
freedom to suppress other constitutional rights like the 
separation of church and State or equal protection. Our duty to 
religious freedom does not absolve us as a duty to protect 
marginalized groups from environments that condemn our 
existence. I want to end with the important point that despite 
this administration's best efforts, inclusive educational 
materials are still legal in this country. I welcome a hearing 
about the decision in American Federation of Teachers et al. v. 
U.S. Department of Education et al., that struck down the 
Department's guidance against diversity, equity, inclusion, and 
accessibility. I stand with all the educators, students, and 
families navigating the bigotry and the xenophobia of this 
administration.
 We are working to ensure that children feel included and 
accepted and safe and have the opportunity to become educated 
global citizens. I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Harris of North Carolina is 
recognized.
 Mr. Harris. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all 
of you that are serving on this panel today and for your 
testimoneys. I found myself, just overwhelmed at times in 
reading their testimoneys and to see how all of this played out 
there in Montgomery County.
 I want to just talk for a moment that one of the things 
that overwhelmed me was just kind of the attack or the 
villainization of parents that seemed to be working, from the 
board's perspective. Mr. Daugherty, your testimony mentioned 
that MCPS was incredibly hostile to parents who had legitimate 
religious concerns about the curriculum.
 In fact, you quoted one board member who suggested that if 
the parents were right, the board would have to ``Send out 
notices so white supremacists could opt out of civil rights 
contents.'' I find that absurd, and the board should be ashamed 
of themselves of comparing Muslims and Christians to white 
supremacists. Mr. Daugherty, I just want to ask you if you 
could take a moment just to give us your perspective about that 
comparison.
 Mr. Daugherty. Yes. I mean again, as I said earlier, I 
think one of the things Mahmoud revealed is how disconnected 
public schools are from the students and the families that they 
serve. The notion that Jewish families, Muslim families, 
Christian families, Ethiopian Orthodox are white supremacists 
or can be, even be equated to white supremacists, right?
 That is insulting as anything. I mean making that kind of 
extreme analysis or analogy just shows how out of touch they 
were. You know again, I think this is a problem in Montgomery 
County. Hopefully it has been resolved after they lost this 
lawsuit. You know, the notion that this storybook series was 
necessary to, I think they said disrupt heteronormative 
thinking and which, you know, it seems to be something that I 
do not know why kindergartners need to be able to have that 
sort of thinking disrupted in order to learn to read and write 
and do mathematics.
 Yes. It really was kind of scary how the school board chose 
this is the hill they were going to die on. Luckily, they lost. 
It revealed a lot about what their, what their priorities are, 
and it is certainly not serving the families that are in their 
county.
 Mr. Harris. Thank you, sir. Ms. Parshall Perry, there has 
been a lot of conversation today about inappropriate content in 
this hearing. I think many people really do not realize how 
deeply inappropriate it was. In fact, some of the left have 
characterized these teachings too often as lessons in mere 
tolerance or lessons in just mere understanding, and I think 
that is horrifically misleading. Would you take a moment just 
to share how inappropriate was this content?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. This centered on five LGBTQ themed 
storybooks for children as young as three and up. Again, we 
need to view this from the perspective of the diminished 
capacity of minors. This was very distinctly designed to change 
perspectives. In the colloquy with Alan Schoenfeld, who was the 
attorney for MCPS and Justice Alito, he said ``Why don't you 
just come out and say exactly what you want to say? You're 
trying to change minds. You have a distinct perspective on 
these things you were trying to institute in minor's minds.''
 Two of the storybooks, not only ``Uncle Bobby's Wedding,'' 
but ``Pride Puppy'' addressed nonbinary individuals, drag 
queens and pride parades. These are individuals who do not have 
a concept of their own identity as it relates to whether or not 
they want to be a fireperson or a fairy when they grow up. What 
we are dealing with is a designed attempt to change minds on 
perspectives.
 I would hearken back to what Congresswoman Lee said 
earlier, which is there are a number of very primary 
considerations in American education. Our biggest threat is the 
fact our children cannot read or do arithmetic, and there is a 
reason Harvard now offers a remedial math class. If we divest 
this kind of curriculum from public education, our children 
will succeed.
 Mr. Harris. Thank you, ma'am. Real quickly in the last 40 
seconds, Mr. Daugherty you mentioned in your written testimony 
about parents asking for optouts, and that was mentioned 
brought up earlier. It is fairly common across the country for 
schools to allow parents to opt out so the Maryland parents 
really were not asking for a radical new policy.
 Can you talk for the last 20 seconds about the kinds of 
teachings parents can often opt out from both at MCPS and in 
general?
 Mr. Daugherty. 47 of 50 states allow parents, by statutory 
right, to opt out of classes on human sexuality, family life, 
including Maryland. Now in Maryland, just showing you frankly 
the disingenuousness of the board here, they did not classify 
this storybook series as human sexuality, because that would 
have meant the parents had the statutory right to opt out. 
Instead, they said it was part of English and Language Arts, 
which to me seemed silly.
 I mean again, I think most of the people in this room were 
able to learn to read and write and do math without having 
their heteronormative normative things disrupted. I think it 
was slippery, evasive, and disingenuous not to say this is a 
human sexuality part of the curriculum, in which case there 
would have been a statutory right under Maryland law and most 
other states for the parents to opt out.
 Mr. Harris. Thank you, sir. Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Hayes of Connecticut is 
recognized.
 Ms. Hayes. Thank you, and thank you to our witnesses for 
being here. I am having a really hard time following along with 
this hearing, because terms like school board and district are 
being used in the abstract.
 Where I am from, the school board is composed of local 
members of the community who are elected to serve on these 
boards. In the State of Connecticut, we have our curriculum 
framework comes from the State, which says these are the topics 
that have to be taught. Then at the local level, curriculum 
committees, local curriculum committees, decide how will we 
teach those. In my district, a local curriculum committee--I 
should probably add that I am not talking about this in a 
hypothetical way; I taught in my school district, was the head 
of many curriculum committees, was the Connecticut Teacher of 
the Year, was the National Teacher of the Year.
 I looked back at my notes to see how the last eight 
curriculum committees I served on were composed, and they were 
subject matter teachers, technology coordinators, special 
education teachers, administrators, parent representatives 
always on these curriculum committees, students and community 
members who decided not only what the curriculum would entail, 
but how it would be taught.
 One step further, as a teacher, every week I had to turn in 
my actual lesson plans of what I was going to do Monday through 
Friday in my class. Those lesson plans were posted on Parents 
Square. Parents had the ability to view them, and we always, 
always, always had an opt-out policy. I actually believe that 
parents should have the ability to opt their children out of a 
lesson that they feel is offensive, or I am sorry, not 
offensive but goes against their religious beliefs.
 I also, however, am a mother who had all of my children 
formerly and currently went through a public school system. I 
think that I am a good, noble, honest parent, and I want my 
children to learn lessons about kindness and inclusivity, and 
do not object to queer subject matter. I think that the rights 
of those parents, parents like me, should also be respected to 
have their children learn about their neighbors and people in 
their community.
 While I agree that math and reading are very important, I 
also--and let me just say this, I want my children not only to 
learn about those things, but then come home and us have 
conversations about what this looks like in our community, 
because they will be living alongside people who they may not 
agree with, who have different lifestyles, who make different 
choices than them. I am as equally concerned about them 
learning reading and algebra as I am about producing 
conscientious good adults who are not racist or xenophobic or 
homophobic or bullies in their community. As a parent, I want 
my child exposed to all of the information so that they can 
make the most informed decision.
 I guess my question is Mr. Rothschild, I am going to come 
to you, is Congress the body that is best suited to make these 
curriculum decisions? Every Committee, every hearing, every 
conversation, every quote, every statement that comes out of 
the other side is about these things should be made locally. 
Now we are here today saying that a local board of education, 
made up of local representatives, local curriculum, that 
chooses their curriculum materials, that people can challenge 
if they do not like the decisions that come out of this board, 
they can elect new people to the board and change it.
 Now we are saying that those people still should not be 
able to make decisions on behalf of the children in their 
community? Mr. Rothschild, should that be something that 
Congress does?
 Mr. Rothschild. Again, I think the Supreme Court worded it 
a lot better than I could ever word it. In Milliken v. Bradley, 
this is what the Supreme Court had to say: ``No single 
tradition in public education is more deeply rooted than local 
control over the operation of schools . . . local control over 
the educational process affords citizens an opportunity to 
participate in decisionmaking, permits the structuring of 
school programs to fit local needs, and encourages 
'experimentation, innovation, and a healthy competition for 
educational excellence.' '' That is a quote from a previous 
Supreme Court decision, within the Supreme Court decision.
 Ms. Hayes. I just want to say, I mean I have members of my 
own family who identify as gay. I have people in the community 
who I look up to who identify as gay. I want my children to 
know that those individuals are not an abomination. Those 
individuals are not indoctrination to care about people being 
able to live their life in the way that they choose. Again, the 
fact that this Committee is doing this, you know----
 I am a teacher. I also represent Newtown Sandy Hook. We 
have yet to have one hearing on school shootings. If you want 
to protect children from the things that help them thrive in 
school, I would suggest that we start with that. I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Messmer of Indiana is 
recognized.
 Mr. Messmer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to our 
witnesses for joining us here today. Mr. Baxter, you mentioned 
in your testimony the congressional amicus brief that was 
submitted to the Supreme Court, in Mahmoud v. Taylor.
 I joined my colleagues in both chambers in signing under 
this brief, which challenged policies that compel students to 
participate in instruction that may conflict with their 
religious values and infringe on their First Amendment 
protections. Can you explain how this brief impacted the final 
decision made by the Court?
 Mr. Baxter. Thank you, Mr. Messmer and all who joined the 
brief. It was a critical brief cited by the Court, showing that 
there are--in the public schools today, there are children 
being opted in and out of the classroom all the time for 
learning English as a Second Language, for individualized 
education plans, and it is no additional burden to respect the 
few parents who have religious objections that want to opt 
their children out of, of 1 hour of curriculum.
 Mr. Messmer. Thank you. I was pleased that the Supreme 
Court decided to let parents make important decisions about 
what their children are exposed to in public schools, 
especially when involves ideology that violates their family's 
religious beliefs.
 Mr. Daugherty, for any school district watching this 
hearing, what advice would you give them on how to protect 
parental rights and religious liberty in the wake of Mahmoud?
 Mr. Daugherty. Well certainly, again already Montgomery 
County has figured out how to deal with it with the 
refrigerator magnets that they get every semester, telling 
parents what is going to be taught in the following semester.
 I think transparency and curriculum is going to be key 
going forward. The ability to opt your children out of certain 
lesson plans that you object to or that conflict with your 
religious beliefs, that means nothing unless you know when that 
is going to be coming. You have notice. I think through use of 
web-based tools and even refrigerator magnets, I think that 
schools can and will and must be more vigilant about letting 
parents know exactly what their kids are going to be taught, so 
that they can then exercise their opt out right.
 Obviously Montgomery County, having lost this lawsuit, I 
think that shows an incentive that you don't want to be on the 
wrong side of that decision going forward.
 Mr. Messmer. Thank you. Ms. Parshall Perry, many people 
think that children are merely creatures of the State. Many 
commentators are outraged by the Mahmoud decision and argue 
that school boards should have absolute control over what their 
children learn. Can you explain why that world view is so 
dangerous?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. It is not only dangerous, it is 
judicially inaccurate. In fact, the Supreme Court held 
precisely the opposite in Pierce v. Society of Sisters in 1925. 
We have year after year of Supreme Court jurisprudence 
reinforcing, underlining the importance and the fundamental 
nature of the parental right.
 What we have seen over and over again in school districts 
across the country is a sort of misapprehension, a 
miscomprehension of the fact that these children are in very 
temporary roles underneath the school leadership. The school 
operates in a tutelary custodial capacity for a very brief 
period of a few hours per day, only to instruct, not to 
indoctrinate and then those children go back home where they 
are under the care and primary authority of their parents.
 In fact, as recently as 2012, the Supreme Court has written 
about the diminished capacity of minors, indicating precisely 
that parents act in the best interest of their children because 
minors lack the appropriate intelligence, emotional maturity or 
understanding of the world around them to be able to make some 
of these important decisions.
 That is why the Mahmoud decision was necessary in the first 
place, because many of these children, three, four, five, were 
too young to know what the concepts were that they were 
actually being taught.
 Mr. Messmer. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I yield back the 
remainder of my time.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Mannion of New York is 
recognized.
 Mr. Mannion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Today we are not only 
discussing a flawed Supreme Court decision, but also a much 
larger agenda. My colleagues on the other side continue to 
mischaracterize what is happening in our classrooms, and I 
believe it is a major disservice to our students and teachers 
to put them at the center of these cruel culture wars.
 The statements made by my Republican colleagues in this 
Committee make it clear that they view Mahmoud case as just the 
beginning, opening the door for more sweeping opt-outs from 
school curricula. As a former teacher, I can tell you where I 
stand and what I have always fought for. Like my colleagues, I 
believe it is critical for parents to be involved in their 
children's education, and they are.
 Parents have more access to teachers, school boards, 
administrators than ever before with online curricula, emails, 
livestream school board meetings, and beyond. That was my 
experience. Parents should be involved. How public education 
has improved is to make sure that that access continues to 
increase, and I believe that it will.
 I have made that case before in this Committee, including 
to Secretary McMahon, that parents have more access and more 
visibility in their students' education than in the past, and 
that is a good thing. I do not believe we should go down the 
slippery slope of having parents opt their kids out of any 
topic they do not agree with or object to.
 Our public schools reflect our communities and the 
diversity of people and ideas within them. All curricula should 
be age appropriate, and parents have access to administrators 
and teachers. Whenever I, in the 30 years in my classroom, saw 
other teachers that may have put things into the lessons that 
were not appropriate, that was addressed immediately and often 
preemptively as teachers, as my colleague Representative Hayes 
said, have to hand in their lesson plans and syllabi ahead of 
time. We cannot hide our kids from the world around them or 
prevent them from engaging with different ideas or different 
people. I also believe that our teachers in schools, 
administrators, know their students well and should be trusted, 
and should continue to be accessible, that they do have our 
students' best interests at heart.
 Despite claiming to talk about local control and education 
and caring about that, this administration has made multiple 
attempts to target specific content and place new politically 
motivated demands on our schools. They have also weaponized 
funding, which is hurting all students. Just because a State 
may be represented by a Democrat or a Republican does not mean 
that all of those students or parents or teachers are Democrats 
or Republicans.
 Unfortunately, weaponizing and canceling grants is hurting 
our students, hurting our schools, increasing class sizes, and 
disrupting budgets. Our schools should always be inclusive 
places, and religious beliefs should always be respected. I 
worry about the political and legal attempts to broaden the 
scope of the Mahmoud ruling, and the implications of far-
reaching opt-out policies.
 Mr. Rothschild, my question is for you. Is mere exposure to 
educational content that parents might find religiously 
objectionable enough to trigger an opt-out under Mahmoud?
 Mr. Rothschild. Possibly, yes.
 Mr. Mannion. A followup question. From the ruling of 
Mahmoud, do you believe that parents have the ability to opt 
out of a high school unit on evolution?
 Mr. Rothschild. Possibly yes as well.
 Mr. Mannion. Do you agree that a parent should be able to 
opt their child out of evolution as a unit?
 Mr. Rothschild. Not as a constitutional right, no.
 Mr. Mannion. Ms. Parshall Perry, do you believe that 
parents have should be able to opt out of a unit on evolution?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. The Supreme Court's already addressed 
the issue and actually said there is no opt out right for 
particular scientific perspectives, and in fact in the wake of 
the Civil Rights Act enactment and desegregation efforts, both 
of those periods of time in American history, the Supreme Court 
routinely struck down so called religious objections to, for 
example, desegregation laws.
 They know when they can smell a rat. They have done so for 
many, many years and they will continue to do so now. These 
were very honest religious objections to inappropriate 
material. The Court will continue to apply that interpretation 
going forward.
 Mr. Mannion. Understood. It sounds as though your answer is 
that evolution would not be able to be opted out of because it 
is accepted science, and therefore a religious objection toward 
it would not be permissible.
 Ms. Parshall Perry. It is a scientific perspective, 
absolutely. It is generally included in scientific classes for 
which there is no constitutional or statutory opt out right. 
There may be religious objections. Those can be raised 
individually, but the Supreme Court has already addressed the 
question of evolution in public education.
 Mr. Mannion. Thank you. I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Rulli of Ohio is recognized.
 Mr. Rulli. Well, thank you Chairman. Nobody knows their 
child better than a parent. Not a teacher; it is the parent. 
Parents have a God given right to know what their children are 
being taught in schools.
 In Ohio, we protect that, right. Parents can review any 
material that includes in specifically sexual content, and 
excuse that child in Ohio from that being taught. Being a 
school board member for many years, when I heard about the 
violation of parents' rights in Maryland and that being 
stripped away by the parent, it just totally made me sick.
 These schools force children to view, and here is the key 
words here; here is the sweet spot, sexually explicit material 
of children under the age of 18 and threaten them with legal 
action against a parent who would fight back, who would even 
question it. In this particular subject, we have Muslims 
America, Christian, and Jewish America uniting for transparency 
in our school districts.
 None of us want sexual content for minors being taught in 
the school. That is unacceptable. The question would roll out 
to Mr. Daugherty. You said there were 47 states. Can you 
elaborate on the three states that chose to take away the 
optout option for the parents? Some of these school districts 
have been threatening, and here is another key word for you, 
truancy against the child and the parent for opting out on 
their kids being taught sexual content for being under the age 
of 18.
 I do not know what kind of upside down world we are living 
in, where it is okay to teach sexual orientated material to 
kids under 18. Mr. Daugherty, a two-part question. The first 
one going to those three states, and then another one for all 
of us on the board, including my honorable friends on the other 
side of the aisle. Is there some guardrails that Congress could 
actually do to make a better system so we could teach all 
material but not material that is illegal for minors?
 Mr. Daugherty. Sure. Unfortunately, I have not, I did my 
research many months ago, so I cannot recall the three states 
that do not. I think but even those states, I think informally 
it is recognized that if you really want to your children not 
to participate in certain things that are highly controversial, 
offend your religious beliefs, I think that is commonly 
recognized.
 Again, it was recognized in Maryland, but they said ``Well, 
this isn't about human sexuality. It's about learning to 
read.'' You have to read ``Pride Puppy'' in order to read, 
which seems to be a bit of a stretch here. With regard to what 
Congress can do, I mean Congress, there is obviously discussion 
right now about the Department of Education. What is going to 
be happening with regard to that?
 Department of Creation is a creature of Congress. Congress 
created it back in 1979, and what will happen with it going 
forward remains to be seen. Specific guardrails. I think, you 
know again, I think the United States Constitution, the Bill of 
Rights here is a tremendous guardrail, and you know, does not 
waiver.
 I think it was one that the parents were able to, to take 
advantage of. I would say also too that parents and voters do 
need to be careful about who is on their school board 
sometimes. It is my understanding, Mr. Baxter may know better, 
but some of the board members who stood up for this principle 
back when the case was started are no longer on the school 
board.
 You know, I have not really given any thought specifically 
to what the Federal Government can do about this.
 Mr. Rulli. Does anyone else have a comment on that?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. I can weigh in. We heard earlier about 
whether or not the Office of Civil Rights was the appropriate 
venue to be able to actually bring these challenges to. It is 
not. Having served as senior counsel in the U.S. Department of 
Education, in the Office for Civil Rights, I can say 
specifically they enforce and apply civil rights law, not 
constitutional law. These parents exhausted every 
administrative level of opportunity closest to where these 
actual decisions were being made.
 They were routinely struck down. The Montgomery County 
Public School system stonewalled them at every attempt. The 
Federal courts were their final recourse. The Department of 
Education does not have any authority whatsoever when it comes 
to the First Amendment.
 Mr. Rulli. Any suggestions to Congress?
 Ms. Parshall Perry. We have current existing spending 
clause laws like the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, 
that might provide a vehicle to be able to legislate in such a 
way that decisions like this do not come up again through the 
Federal court system. Obviously, the Constitution conceives of 
specific enumerated rights for this chamber, and one of those 
is spending clause legislation.
 There is quite a number of it that has actually been passed 
through these chambers, that might provide an opportunity to 
say ``We are going to enforce the parental right as we've done 
with FERPA, as we've done with PPRA.'' Those are suitable 
mechanisms, I think, going forward.
 Mr. Rulli. Well, thank you all for your time, and with 
that, I yield my time back to the Chair.
 Chairman Kiley. Representative Grijalva of Arizona is 
recognized.
 Ms. Grijalva. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Before coming to 
Congress, I served 20 years on a school governing board in 
southern Arizona, one of the largest, most diverse districts in 
the State. I worked directly with parents, teachers, and 
students every single day.
 I know firsthand how critical parent engagement is to 
student success, but I also learned something else just as 
important. Public schools exist to serve all students. They are 
not vehicles for political agendas, nor are they spaces where 
perspectives can be erased simply because they make some 
uncomfortable.
 The Supreme Court's decision Mahmoud v. Taylor was narrow. 
It does not give politicians permission to micromanage 
classrooms, override professional educators, or turn public 
schools into the latest front in a culture war. Framing this 
Federal overreach as consistent with returning education to the 
states is plainly contradictory to the majority's own stated 
agenda. Federal Government overreach is the opposite of local 
control.
 At the same time, we cannot ignore the broader context. 
Instead of investing in students and strengthening public 
education, some are pushing to dismantle the Department of 
Education and privatize our own public school system. These 
efforts do not empower families. They exacerbate existing 
inequalities, weaken accountability, and put our most 
vulnerable students in greater risk of being left behind.
 Our responsibility is clear. We must ensure students learn 
in safe, welcoming, well-funded schools, where curiosity is 
encouraged, facts are taught honestly, educators are respected, 
and every child has a real opportunity to succeed. This----
 My question will be to Mr. Rothschild. Is there a limiting 
principle in Mahmoud? Are we on a slippery slope, where schools 
will find themselves overwhelmed with opt-outs, that the 
curriculum will be erased to the lowest common denominator as 
to what is taught?
 Mr. Rothschild. I think that that concern that you have 
voiced is a legitimate one, and is one that was articulated by 
none other than Justice Alito in 2021, where in a concurrence 
in Mahanoy, which involves social media and free speech for 
children, for students, he said the following. He said: 
``Parents are not required to enroll their children in a public 
school. They can select a private school . . . and they may 
also be able to educate their children at home.'' By enrolling 
a child in a public school, he went on to say, the parents have 
impliedly consented to delegating some of their parental 
authority to the public school.
 Ms. Grijalva. Thank you. What are the failures of the 
Mahmoud decision, in your opinion? What did the majority 
opinion get wrong?
 Mr. Rothschild. Well, the majority opinion essentially 
rewrote previous precedents, claiming that it was just applying 
them. It restructured the way religious liberty works even in 
prior eras, which the Supreme Court has claimed it is simply 
resurrecting.
 Religious liberty has classically meant that if an 
individual has an opposition to doing or not doing something 
that is required of them by the government, they can invoke the 
Free Exercise Clause. Here, the right, as it is framed by 
Justice Alito in Mahmoud, is a right to unfettered control over 
the moral shaping of your child, even when you have opted to 
send your child to a public school.
 Ms. Grijalva. What I think is really interesting is that 
every school district has their own governing board that is 
duly elected. Those decisions should be made by those that are 
elected from that community. My concern, and one that I have, 
you know, pondered quite a few times while I have been in this 
room, is that the Republican Party, from what I understand, is 
the party that wants things to go back to the local level. Then 
when it is something that is an inconvenient truth, we tend to 
stick our nose in and try to rewrite Federal.
 I want us to continue to support our duly locally elected 
school districts to make decisions about school curriculum. 
Every single curriculum that is taught in our public schools is 
open in Arizona to anyone who wants to, and they have the 
option to opt out, and we should continue to push those kind of 
initiatives. Thank you, and I yield back.
 Chairman Kiley. Thank you very much. I will now recognize 
the Ranking Member for a closing statement.
 Ms. Bonamici. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank 
you to the witnesses for the testimony today. You know, this 
Subcommittee is responsible for and should be comprehensively 
addressing the real issues affecting K-12 schools and 
protecting our children's future.
 Instead of addressing the actual dangers to students, my 
colleagues on the other side of the aisle have chosen to turn 
classrooms into the epicenter of a culture war. I noted Mr. 
Daugherty just said that it is his understanding that the 
Montgomery County, Maryland, school board members are not there 
anymore. Well, you know what happened yesterday in Montgomery 
County? A 16 year-old student was shot in his school. You 
cannot solve that with a refrigerator magnet.
 The Supreme Court decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor has opened 
yet another avenue for Republicans to attack public education 
to the detriment of students and families. No one is arguing 
that parents should not be involved in their children's 
education. On the contrary, we recognize that family 
involvement is critical to a child's development and 
educational success.
 By turning what is taught in the classroom into a political 
issue and improperly a Federal issue, Republicans are using our 
children's future as a weapon to deepen partisan divides and 
threaten the foundations of our public education system. My 
Democratic colleagues and I will not support politicizing 
education.
 We will continue to work with students, with parents, with 
educators, and with communities until every student receives an 
accurate, high-quality, age-appropriate education in a safe, 
well-funded environment without fear of gun violence or masked 
Federal agents breaking down the classrooms, education that 
engages them and inspires them and leads them to be creative, 
tolerant, critical thinkers who are compassionate members of 
their community and our country. I yield back the balance of my 
time.
 Chairman Kiley. Thank you very much. Thank you to all of 
our witnesses. I think a major takeaway for me from this 
hearing is that the position of the opposition here is that 
there is no recourse for parents. That is an exact quote from 
their chosen witness, which I find to be very troubling. This 
idea that, you know, kids as young as kindergarten could be 
exposed to the most graphic content and the parents have no 
recourse.
 They are not allowed to pull their child out even for a 
day, that a school could inculcate values that are wholly 
incompatible with the religious upbringing that the parent has 
chosen for the child. There is no recourse. They cannot let 
them sit out even a day of class. I think that the opinion of 
the Supreme Court in Mahmoud simply affirms common sense 
foundational principles in this country.
 This is not about controlling curriculum at the Federal 
level. When a parent opts out, the curriculum stays the same. 
The other students who choose to participate and their families 
can be exposed to whatever curriculum is chosen at the local 
level. It certainly is not about undermining local control 
either. I believe very strongly in local control when it comes 
to education.
 At the same time, there are basic constitutional rules of 
the road that all institutions must abide by. What the Supreme 
Court has recognized is that religious liberty is one of them, 
and the right of parents to direct their upbringing of children 
is intricately bound up in that.
 I think this is a very important decision, and this 
Committee will be assuring that it is honored so that the 
rights of parents are respected throughout the country. Without 
objection, there being no further business, the Committee 
stands adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 12 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
 [Additional submissions from Ranking Member Bonamici 
follows:]
[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 [Additional submissions from Representative Owens follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 [Questions and responses submitted for the record by Mr. 
******* follows:]
[GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 [all]