APPROPRIATIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2027

House Appropriations Committee House July 22, 2026

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[House Hearing, 119 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 APPROPRIATIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2027
_______________________________________________________________________

 HEARING

 BEFORE THE

 COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS

 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 ______________
 
 
 WEDNESDAY, JULY 22, 2026

 _____________
 
 FUNDING LAPSES:
 ANALYZING SHUTDOWN REFORM

[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 _____________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on Appropriations

 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
64-459 WASHINGTON : 2026
_______________________________________________________________________

 HOUSE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS

 TOM COLE, Oklahoma, Chairman

HAROLD ROGERS, Kentucky, ROSA L. DeLAURO, Connecticut,
 Chairman Emeritus Ranking Member
ROBERT B. ADERHOLT, Alabama STENY H. HOYER, Maryland
MICHAEL K. SIMPSON, Idaho MARCY KAPTUR, Ohio
JOHN R. CARTER, Texas JAMES E. CLYBURN, South Carolina
KEN CALVERT, California SANFORD D. BISHOP, Jr., Georgia
MARIO DIAZ-BALART, Florida BETTY McCOLLUM, Minnesota
STEVE WOMACK, Arkansas DEBBIE WASSERMAN SCHULTZ, Florida
CHARLES J. ``CHUCK'' FLEISCHMANN, HENRY CUELLAR, Texas
 Tennessee CHELLIE PINGREE, Maine
DAVID P. JOYCE, Ohio MIKE QUIGLEY, Illinois
ANDY HARRIS, Maryland GRACE MENG, New York
MARK E. AMODEI, Nevada MARK POCAN, Wisconsin
DAVID G. VALADAO, California PETE AGUILAR, California
DAN NEWHOUSE, Washington LOIS FRANKEL, Florida
JOHN R. MOOLENAAR, Michigan BONNIE WATSON COLEMAN, New Jersey
JOHN H. RUTHERFORD, Florida NORMA J. TORRES, California
BEN CLINE, Virginia ED CASE, Hawaii
GUY RESCHENTHALER, Pennsylvania ADRIANO ESPAILLAT, New York
ASHLEY HINSON, Iowa JOSH HARDER, California
JULIA LETLOW, Louisiana LAUREN UNDERWOOD, Illinois
MICHAEL CLOUD, Texas SUSIE LEE, Nevada
MICHAEL GUEST, Mississippi JOSEPH D. MORELLE, New York
RYAN K. ZINKE, Montana MIKE LEVIN, California
ANDREW S. CLYDE, Georgia MADELEINE DEAN, Pennsylvania
STEPHANIE I. BICE, Oklahoma VERONICA ESCOBAR, Texas
SCOTT FRANKLIN, Florida FRANK J. MRVAN, Indiana
JAKE ELLZEY, Texas MARIE GLUESENKAMP PEREZ, 
JUAN CISCOMANI, Arizona Washington
CHUCK EDWARDS, North Carolina GLENN IVEY, Maryland
MARK ALFORD, Missouri
NICK LaLOTA, New York
DALE W. STRONG, Alabama
CELESTE MALOY, Utah
RILEY M. MOORE, West Virginia
JEFFERSON SHREVE, Indiana

 Susan Ross, Chief Clerk and Staff Director

 
 APPROPRIATIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2027

 ---------- 

 Wednesday, July 22, 2026.

 FUNDING LAPSES: ANALYZING SHUTDOWN REFORM

 WITNESSES

HON. JAMES LANKFORD, UNITED STATES SENATOR
HON. TOM McCLINTOCK, MEMBER OF CONGRESS
HON. SHALANDA YOUNG, RESIDENT SCHOLAR, NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF 
 LAW

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. TOM COLE, CHAIRMAN

 The Chairman. The committee will come to order. I would ask 
the Members to take their seats.
 Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare a 
recess at any time.
 Without objection, Members shall have 5 legislative days 
within which to revise and extend remarks and to insert 
extraneous material into the record.
 I want to welcome everybody to today's full committee 
hearing entitled ``Funding Lapses: Analyzing Shutdown Reform.''
 While having all Members in the room usually denotes a 
markup, I am pleased to remind everyone that we reported out 
all 12 fiscal year 2027 bills before the end of June.
 It does not mean our work is complete, but it does create 
space for some needed conversations.
 We all know the adage, ``The first step toward fixing a 
problem is admitting you have one.'' I would say the two 
longest government shutdowns in American history, being 
instigated by Senator Chuck Schumer and Senate Democrats within 
the last year, is a strong indication that the people of this 
great Nation, and this institution, deserve better.
 I, for one, refuse to allow funding lapses to become an 
accepted norm in the appropriations process.
 The reasons are simple. Article I is not simply a talking 
point or a slogan. It is a constitutional duty. Article I is 
not merely a Chamber tradition. It is an obligation the Framers 
entrusted specifically to Congress, and Article I is not a 
process we can exercise only when it is politically convenient. 
It is a charge we must uphold.
 The power of the purse carries with it the mandate to fund 
the government in a timely, orderly, and reliable manner. While 
it is the duty of both Republicans and Democrats to advocate 
and debate specific levels of funding priorities and oversight 
of Federal programs, the tactic of plunging the country into a 
needless manufactured shutdown for the sake of partisan 
leverage betrays the responsibility we owe to the American 
people.
 There are a number of legislative ideas and approaches 
designed to prevent or at least mitigate the consequences of 
future funding lapses today. Today we have an opportunity to 
discuss some of those proposals.
 Notably, we are also doing this before the full committee, 
giving all our appropriators on both sides of the aisle a forum 
to examine these concepts in an open setting.
 I sincerely thank our witnesses for taking the time to be 
here. This is unprecedented for us to meet in this fashion. As 
a matter of fact, we cannot find another meeting like this on 
record, other than the Zoom meeting we had for a Member 
meeting, I think, years ago.
 This is very unusual for us to assemble in this way. We are 
together a lot when we are marking up bills, but we do not 
normally do hearings. That is a subcommittee function, but we 
thought this one was enormously important and timely.
 I certainly appreciate my good friend and fellow Oklahoman 
and former House Member, so we have got somebody that 
understands how to do stuff over there, Senator James Lankford, 
for making the trip across the Capitol; along with 
Representative Tom McClintock, my long-time colleague. We 
worked together on the Budget Committee for many years, sat 
next to one another. We could never persuade either one of 
anything, but good to have you here, Tom.
 Also, former Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Director 
Shalanda Young, extraordinary figure in this committee's 
history and knowledge expertise. Not only former chief clerk of 
this committee, but obviously OMB Director and fixture on 
Capitol Hill, expert in these things. We really appreciate you 
making the time to be here, Shalanda. Thank you very much.
 We appreciate all of these excellent witnesses for their 
perspective.
 Before I give a quick reminder on decorum and proceedings 
for the hearing, I wanted to close with a reflection on this 
committee and the work we do.
 Nothing can replace the stability, certainty, and 
accountability that come from enacting full-year 
appropriations. That is because Article I is not just a 
procedural exercise. It is the mechanism that ensures every 
Member has a voice, every bill has the opportunity to be 
debated, and every taxpayer can see how their government is 
funded.
 When Congress abandons that system, decision-making becomes 
more centralized, rank-and-file Members have less influence, 
and closed-door negotiations tend to replace committee work.
 Those conditions make funding crises more likely and more 
difficult to resolve.
 While we may have differing views on the reforms discussed 
today, I hope we can all agree on one fundamental principle: 
Government shutdowns are reckless and they are nothing--and 
they do nothing, other than create chaos and uncertainty.
 There is never a circumstance where a shutdown is 
preferable to keeping the government open and working. 
Americans deserve a Congress that resolves its disagreements 
through deliberation, not disruption.
 Finally, as the committee rarely conducts full committee 
hearings, a brief note on our process for today.
 We will generally follow the same process we follow during 
our subcommittee hearings. Our witnesses will each make brief 
opening statements. Following opening statements, we will 
recognize Members of the committee for 5 minutes for questions, 
alternating back and forth between the majority and the 
minority until all Members who wish to ask questions have had 
the opportunity to do so.
 During our full committee markups, I am generous with the 
5-minute rule. Today, though, I must be somewhat less generous 
given both the large number of Members present for this hearing 
and given the fact that our witnesses are, themselves, very 
busy people. They have generously agreed to appear before us 
today.
 I would ask each of us to confine ourselves to 5 minutes of 
questions. I want to, again, thank you for your cooperation.
 With that, I would now yield to Ranking Member DeLauro for 
5 minutes for any comments she wishes to make.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ROSA L. DeLAURO

 Ms. DeLauro. Thank you very much, Chairman Cole. As always, 
I appreciate your friendship and our partnership on this 
committee.
 Let me just say a big ``thank you'' to our witnesses and 
what a delight to have the former Director of the Office of 
Management and Budget, Shalanda Young, with us today.
 Thank you, thank you for your years of service, thank you 
for your direction at OMB, and thank you for your direction of 
this committee and where we had the opportunity to work 
together.
 Senator Lankford, welcome to you this morning.
 Congressman McClintock, delighted that you are here 
testifying before us today.
 We are convened to hear from sponsors of legislation to 
change the government funding process to put in place 
permanent, automatic, continued funding as a default position 
if annual appropriations have not been enacted.
 It fundamentally changes how the Congress funds our 
government. It replaces the current annual appropriations 
deadline with a standing default.
 Continuing resolutions, often called CRs, are temporary 
extensions of funding that bring forward the prior year's 
funding agreement, typically with few changes.
 They are imperfect tools even under the best circumstances. 
They can be helpful when used sparingly and can be important to 
facilitate full-year funding agreements. They should not be our 
first choice. They should not be made automatic.
 All of us here, at least at one point in our careers, have 
been charged under the Constitution with protecting the primacy 
of Congress' power of the purse.
 Nearly every President has endeavored to undermine that 
primacy, but rarely have we seen one go so far as the current 
administration.
 President Trump and Budget Director Russ Vought have sought 
unprecedented control over Federal spending, ignoring the 
Constitution and breaking the law in their efforts to take the 
power of the purse for themselves. It is their goal, and I 
believe it is to abolish the appropriations process entirely.
 Those of you who know me know the depth of my faith in the 
appropriations process. I view it as the center of government. 
Nearly all the government does is touched by appropriations.
 This administration has wrought havoc upon our system 
through impoundments, rescissions, reconciliation, and reducing 
Federal grants to partisan weapons.
 Ceding authority to this administration and any future 
administration would all but complete their mission. It would 
cement nearly complete control over government funding within 
the White House.
 Why? Why would we voluntarily forfeit that authority? Why 
would we choose to diminish the role of this committee? This is 
our responsibility, laid out in the Constitution.
 The Constitution is unambiguous. Article I, section 9, 
clause 7 states, and I quote: ``No money shall be drawn from 
the Treasury but in consequence of appropriations made by 
law''.
 James Madison wrote, and I quote: ``The power over the 
purse may, in fact, be regarded as the most complete and 
effectual weapon with which any Constitution can arm the 
immediate representatives of the people for obtaining a redress 
of every grievance''.
 Giving the President power over the sword and the purse 
would make him, in effect, a king. The decision to separate 
these powers was not accidental. It was a deliberate choice 
that is foundational to our system of government.
 The Founders were wary of vesting too much power within any 
single branch of government, so they devised a system of checks 
and balances. The requirement that the President come to the 
Congress to ask for funding for their government was designed 
as a forceful check on their authority.
 Deferring to the executive through continuous automatic 
funding substantially weakens that check and empowers the 
President. It takes power away from those elected to represent 
the needs of the American people.
 Providing a permanent and unlimited grant of funding would 
surrender essentially all of Congress' authority over 
government spending to the President. One individual making the 
decisions.
 The President could veto any spending legislation they even 
mildly disapprove of, with little consequence. In fact, they 
would be rewarded with greater discretion over spending under 
the automatic funding measures proposed, creating a powerful 
incentive not to negotiate.
 Auto CRs are permission never to finish the process at all. 
There ought to be a reasonable push-and-pull between the 
branches of government. That is what the Founders intended.
 A permanent government-wide appropriation for the President 
would stack the deck in favor of the executive against the 
Congress, weakening the branch of government closest and most 
accountable to the American people.
 I also strongly believe that permanently funding the 
government would incentivize some in the Congress to harden 
their positions and refuse to earnestly engage in the difficult 
but important work of bipartisan compromise.
 The strength of the appropriations--and I emphasize, 
bipartisan compromise--appropriations is the only piece of 
legislation where you need to have Democrats and Republicans, 
House and Senate--agree before it goes to the President for his 
signature. Otherwise, the government shuts down.
 Bipartisan compromise is what we need to have. The strength 
of the appropriations process is that the House and the Senate 
Democrats and Republicans must work together. They need to 
forge that agreement.
 Foregoing that process would exclude the diversity of views 
represented in the Congress in favor of the fiat of one 
individual--the President.
 While the permanent continuing appropriation proposals 
before us would keep the government open on paper, in practice, 
they would sacrifice many government functions.
 From year to year, the funding needs of the Federal 
government can change substantially. Perhaps there is a 
submarine base in serious urgent need of repair; or maybe an 
economic downturn has pushed more families into poverty, 
forcing them to rely on nutrition assistance to feed their 
family. Automatic funding would fail to account for these 
changes.
 Additionally, the proposals do not account for community 
funding projects and congressionally directed spending that 
Members rely on to meet their constituents' needs.
 Instead of emphasizing the need for Members of Congress to 
engage with one another in that annual appropriations process, 
permanent funding would push Members to lobby the White House 
directly for aid to their communities, giving the executive 
branch still more power.
 I am sympathetic to the goal of reducing government 
shutdowns, but the permanent funding proposals we will discuss 
here today would, in my opinion, create far more problems than 
they would solve.
 I am eager to hear from our witnesses, and I thank you all 
again for taking the time to appear before us today. I look 
forward to your testimony. I thank you.
 I yield back.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentlelady for her remarks.
 I want to welcome our three witnesses for today, each of 
whom will provide invaluable insights into these thorny 
questions.
 First, we have Senator James Lankford from my home State of 
Oklahoma. Senator Lankford is the author of the Prevent 
Government Shutdowns Act, one of the proposed pieces of 
legislation to address the recurring problem of government 
shutdowns that we will be examining today.
 Second, we have our colleague Representative Tom McClintock 
of California. Representative McClintock is the author of H.R. 
8380, a bill to amend the Congressional Budget and Impoundment 
Control Act of 1974 to establish certain procedures for 
consideration of annual appropriations bills in the event of a 
funding lapse.
 Finally, also with us today is the Honorable Shalanda 
Young. Ms. Young served as the 43rd Director of the Office of 
Management and Budget from 2021 to 2025. More importantly, she 
is a long-time staffer with the House Appropriations Committee, 
including service as the staff director and chief clerk of the 
committee.
 I want to thank all of you for joining us today.
 I also just want to note we extended an invitation to Ron 
Johnson, Senator Ron Johnson, who very much wanted to be here 
to talk about his legislation. We all know the tragedy that has 
pushed him in a situation where he is probably not able to 
devote the time to this hearing, but we would love to have his 
input at another time as well. He just could not make it today.
 I want to again thank you for joining us today. Your 
written statements will be made part of the hearing record. You 
will each be recognized for 5 minutes to summarize your 
testimony.
 With that, Senator Lankford, you are recognized for 5 
minutes.

 STATEMENT OF HON. JAMES LANKFORD,
 UNITED STATES SENATOR

 Senator Lankford. Chairman Cole, thank you very much. 
Thanks for holding this hearing. This is an exceptionally 
important hearing, and there are a lot of Members that are here 
that want to get a chance to be able to talk about this. Thank 
you for holding this hearing.
 Ranking Member DeLauro, thank you for your comments. You 
would be shocked to know that I agree with almost everything 
you just said and want to be able to find a way to be able to 
resolve some of these differences.
 I really do appreciate the time to be able to have this 
dialogue as we try to figure out what we are going to do about 
government shutdowns. This has been an ongoing issue for a very 
long time.
 This particular bill I have worked on since 2019. We have 
had multiple different versions for this. We have got to be 
able to find some way to be able to end the perpetual cycle 
that we are in of government shutdowns.
 As we all know, when a shutdown occurs, Members of Congress 
still leave to go on Congressional delegations (CODELs) or we 
travel home to be with our families while Federal workers and 
their families face real financial strain.
 It is not hard to be able to find different stories on 
this. We just did a quick search. Sharee Quick is a TSA agent 
in Las Vegas. During the last shutdown, she showed up to work 
every day and had no pay.
 She had to make decisions every week, how to be able to put 
gas in her car, pay the electricity bill. She went more than 40 
days without a paycheck. She did not know how she was going to 
pay for her essential blood pressure medication.
 That happened because we did not resolve our differences on 
time. That is both parties. That has happened over and over 
again. We all know it to be true.
 Federal workers and their families should not suffer when 
Congress has not finished their appropriation work, but they 
do.
 Some of you in this room may even remember December 2018, 
that particular shutdown, when we all left for Christmas and 
Federal workers all got lumps of coal. It happens.
 The question is, how do we actually solve this? I say, 
solve this together. I am bringing you something unique today--
a nonpartisan proposal.
 Seven years ago I sat down with my Democratic colleague, 
Maggie Hassan from New Hampshire, to develop a plan to end 
government shutdowns in a nonpartisan way.
 As we worked alongside Representatives Arrington and 
Panetta to get more input and ideas, we came up with a very 
simple idea.
 This bill has had multiple changes and a lot of input from 
both sides of the Hill, from countless Members and from staff. 
It received technical assistance from the Office of Management 
and Budget under President Biden. Then it has also received 
technical assistance from the Office of Management and Budget 
under President Trump.
 The bill does not solve every fiscal and budgetary problem 
that we need to address. It just solves one thing--it prevents 
a government shutdown.
 Very simply, if we get to the end of the fiscal year and 
appropriations are not complete, an automatic continuing 
resolution kicks in for 2 weeks. It self-renews.
 However, here is the part that I think a lot of people 
miss, Members of Congress and the White House Office of 
Management and Budget have to remain in Washington, DC. We have 
no official travel budget, nor can we use our campaign travel 
budget to be able to leave. We are in session 7 days a week, 
and we have to remain here working on one thing--
appropriations. The bill actually prevents us from moving to 
other topics until we finish the appropriation work.
 The goal is not an automatic CR. The goal is to finish 
appropriations. If we have not finished our constitutional 
responsibility of appropriations, we have to remain in session 
7 days a week until we finish appropriations work.
 Nothing is more motivating in this town than jet fumes. 
This is an opportunity that we have to be able to say the 
pressure will not be on members of the Federal family that are 
working at TSA and other places. The pressure will be on us to 
be able to finish our work on time.
 As my mom, the Sunday school teacher and school teacher 
often said, if you do not finish your work during class, you 
have to stay after class until it is done. The proposal is just 
that simple.
 The bill has been endorsed by a growing list of think 
tanks, unions, and associations across the political spectrum. 
As we put this idea out over the past several years, we have 
been very pleased at the number of groups that have stepped in 
and said: That would work. That is actually an idea that could 
actually get accomplished.
 Let me just list a few of them to you. We have given you 
the full list of these. Mr. Chairman, I would like to ask 
unanimous consent that the full record of the letters we have 
received so far be put in the record.
 The Chairman. Without objection.
 [The information follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 
 
 Senator Lankford. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Let me list just a few of them that have so far endorsed 
this idea: The America First Policy Institute, the American 
Federation of Government Employees, Americans for Prosperity, 
Americans for Tax Reform, the Bipartisan Policy Center, the 
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, the Association of 
Fire Fighters, the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, the 
Iraq and Afghanistan Retired Veterans of America, National 
Active Retired Federal Employees Association, the United States 
Steelworkers, the United States Travel Association.
 I can give you on and on and on and on. It is a very 
diverse group. It is not a group that is all on one side or the 
other. It is a diverse body that says: Let us figure out a way 
to be able to solve this problem.
 A national poll was recently conducted on this simple idea 
and 80 percent of the people like this very simple idea.
 There are a lot of things we can talk about, and I really 
do look forward to the dialogue here, but we feel like this is 
just a commonsense, nonpartisan way to put us in a position to 
finish our work, to do appropriations, but to also protect the 
Federal workers that desperately want a solution to this.
 With that, I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
 [The information follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 The Chairman. I thank the gentleman for his testimony.
 We now move to Representative McClintock.

 STATEMENT OF HON. TOM McCLINTOCK,
 MEMBER OF CONGRESS

 Mr. McClintock, you are recognized for 5 minutes.
 Mr. McClintock. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank 
you for cosponsoring H.R. 8380. Thank you for affording me the 
time to discuss it with your committee today.
 I believe the Budget Act of 1974 establishes a methodical, 
logical, and powerful process to bring spending in line with 
revenues. It just does not work very well.
 I think the biggest problem is, of course, that it requires 
hard tradeoffs and decisions--and, sorry, there is nothing we 
can do about that. Whatever process we use, the decisions are 
not going to get any easier.
 Periodically we hear calls for a new bipartisan debt 
commission. Of course we already have a bipartisan debt 
commission. It is called ``Congress.''
 Congress does have a clear process. The Budget Act requires 
both houses to set limits on both discretionary and mandatory 
spending by April 15 each year. The discretionary limit, the 
302A allocations, go to this committee, which dutifully every 
year marks up 12 appropriation bills, and the House works 
overtime to craft those bills.
 Meanwhile, the mandatory limits are supposed to be sent as 
instructions to the committees of jurisdiction to adjust 
statutes to adhere to those levels with all of those changes 
dropped in the reconciliation bill.
 Here is the problem. The appropriation bills are subject to 
cloture in the Senate, which means the hard work of the House 
can simply be blocked by a minority of Senators.
 The clock runs out, and Congress is then faced with the 
Hobson's choice of a government shutdown or, in desperation, we 
simply throw away the appropriations bills and vote a 
continuing resolution, which is the path of least resistance.
 This also wreaks havoc on the reconciliation process. 
Because reconciliation gives expedited consideration in the 
Senate, it is often used, as it is right now, not to 
comprehensively address mandatory spending, but rather to 
address whatever shiny object or exigency that presents itself 
at the moment.
 That is how the House got wrapped around the axle on 
ObamaCare in 2017. It is how we passed the Big Beautiful Bill 
(BBB) last year.
 Now, I happen to think the BBB was a remarkable 
accomplishment, addressing a variety of majority objectives 
through the reconciliation act. Unfortunately, it did not 
address the one objective for which the process is designed--a 
balanced budget--or at least a less imbalanced one.
 Of course, most recently we used it to address the impasse 
over DHS funding and currently for defense funding and election 
reform.
 In my opinion, those are all worthy objectives, but, once 
again, they are not the objective of the Budget Act.
 This bill makes one simple change. It provides the same 
expedited consideration for appropriation bills in the Senate 
that we already give the reconciliation bill.
 Now, this is not a cure-all. The fiscal decisions attendant 
to the budget are not going to get any easier. Since the Senate 
and House are designed to disagree, it is still going to 
require intense negotiation between the two houses.
 It would at least remove the blockage that often prevents 
that discussion from taking place, and it reduces the 
temptation to misuse reconciliation in order to bypass cloture.
 That is it in a nutshell, Mr. Chairman. As the President 
would say, in all caps, thank you for your attention to this 
matter.
 [The information follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] 

 The Chairman. I thank the gentleman very much for his 
testimony.
 We now turn to Director Young.
 You are recognized for 5 minutes.

 STATEMENT OF HON. SHALANDA YOUNG,
 RESIDENT SCHOLAR, NEW YORK UNIVERSITY OF LAW

 Ms. Young. Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member DeLauro, thank you 
for having me--I think. I think you all are my friends, but I 
somehow, from private life, find myself back here. I am back 
here because I love this committee, and I love this process.
 The throughput you will hear in all three testimonies is: 
What we currently have is unacceptable, but we have different 
ways to get there.
 I hope this is the beginning of a conversation and that we 
continue to have conversations in various venues to try to find 
solutions to prevent shutdowns. I just have a different way, I 
believe, I would go about it than Senator Lankford's.
 Congressman McClintock, you probably did not hear much 
disagreement about telling the Senate what to do from the 
House. It tends to be a favorite pastime of the House Members 
and staff. Senator Lankford can take that back to Senator 
Thune.
 I was Director of the Office of Management and Budget. 
Before that, I was the staff director of this committee, 2 
years in the minority, 2 years in the majority.
 For the newer Members on the committee, it is nice to get 
to meet you in this position, but if you talk to your 
colleagues who have been here a while, they will tell you I am 
funny, so please be nice today.
 I opened my phone when I was writing my remarks, and the 
headline pops up, ``What is wrong with Congress?'' It claimed 9 
in 10 Americans say they are unhappy with Congress, and 
obviously shutdowns and the theater that come with them play a 
big part in that perception.
 I would, however, ask you to think of shutdowns as one of 
the many symptoms of what is broken. My child once had 
pneumonia. We took care of the fever. It made her comfortable. 
If we did not figure out what was causing the pneumonia, we 
would have continued in this do loop.
 That is how I think about shutdowns. For too long, 
congressional dysfunction has been shrugged off as the norm 
while congressional leadership uses work-arounds as substitutes 
for the difficult work of legislating.
 Notice I did not say a party.
 We have reached this point because it has devolved over 
time. For example, using the reconciliation process to bypass 
the Appropriations Committee. I consider that a work-around.
 These tactics allowed the institution to continue to limp 
along, deepening the dysfunction most Americans now expect. If 
the goal is institutional restoration, reclaiming Congress' 
spending authority is a logical starting point.
 Although this past year's shutdowns might suggest 
appropriations are especially difficult, I think the opposite 
might be true. Because Federal spending directly affects your 
constituents, it offers one of the clearest opportunities for 
legislators to find common ground and demonstrate 
responsiveness to the needs in their districts.
 As we think through potential solutions, we also must 
refrain from making matters worse. After all, more cameras in 
hearing rooms have resulted in a lot of theatrics. I am sure 
today will be different.
 A reflection of good intentions but leading to awful 
outcomes, I view legislation creating automatic CRs in that 
light. Automatic CR legislation is likely to empower bad actors 
looking to frustrate, compromise, or hijack appropriations for 
their own legislative priorities and will lead to worse, less 
responsive governing.
 Because of the need to reach compromise each year, annual 
appropriations are a key way that Congress ensures spending 
meets the evolving needs of the country.
 A minority in the Senate or a President wielding their veto 
can more easily obstruct enacting appropriations bills without 
risking blame.
 Even efforts by Congress to assert its power of the purse 
or rein in executive abuse through appropriations would require 
veto-proof majorities to overcome a resistant President.
 Ultimately, automatic CRs would risk making it easier for 
the President to hold annual appropriations legislation 
hostage, whether by insisting on inclusion of his or her 
priorities, demanding the passage of unrelated legislation, or 
resisting the inclusion of bipartisan oversight in those bills.
 Sitting here I think about 2023, when I was OMB Director. 
Went in on a Saturday, September 30, thought we were shutting 
down the government. Speaker McCarthy was the Speaker at the 
time.
 Got there at 9:00, thought we would do an orderly shutdown, 
and Speaker McCarthy said absolutely not and put a hard bill on 
the floor, and it passed.
 I am not sure with a fail-safe like automatic CRs that day 
would have happened, and I believe we would have shut down.
 That was a tough vote and a tough thing for the Speaker to 
do, and we did not get all our priorities in that bill, 
including Ukraine funding, which was incredibly important to 
our White House. I believe the Speaker did the right thing, 
even if I did not know it that day.
 The breakdown of the appropriations process reflects 
broader institutional atrophy, not unlike the decline of the 
authorization process before it. Let us be real, all we have is 
the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), and that is so 
far. We will see how the year goes.
 One potential reform is to expand the size and 
representation of Congress' spending committees. In addition to 
considering membership structure, congressional staff also 
require significant expansion.
 As executive cooperation has declined, Congress has lacked 
the staff capacity and resources to counterbalance that shift.
 There are also promising ideas on apportionment reform, 
changing the budget resolution schedule so it is not an 
impediment to appropriations--I know Mr. Womack has legislation 
on that front--and, frankly, providing more specificity in 
appropriations law and less reliance on reports that do not 
have the weight of law.
 Look, my recommendations, just like the others I have 
talked about today, are not a cure-all. No process or 
structural change trumps political will. It never has.
 When I was OMB Director, there were no shutdowns, and it 
was not because we got everything we wanted. We chose, and many 
of you chose in this room, to put the stability of the country 
over strongly held positions on both sides of the aisle.
 We have done it before. We can do it again.
 I look forward to your questions.
 [The information follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]

 The Chairman. I thank the gentlelady for her remarks.
 Let me begin the questioning. I want to start first with 
you, Senator Lankford.
 There is a lot in your bill that appeals to me, 
particularly the fact that it puts the onus on Congress and the 
punishment and the pain on us and not on the American people, 
because 7 days here with all of my colleagues, as much as I 
love each one, followed by another 7 and another 7, would 
probably drive me to a solution as quickly as I can.
 There are also other causes of delay in this deal, and I 
will give you an example. We are supposed to get a Presidential 
budget by February 15. We do not.
 Now, the first year of any Presidency, I understand that. 
They do not even have their own people in place by February 15. 
However, the second and third years, I do not find much excuse. 
We got it this year April 1, something like that, weeks late.
 We are also supposed to have a top-line number from the 
Budget Committee. I do not think we have gotten that in at 
least six Congresses on either side.
 We were so divided when Speaker Pelosi was Speaker that 
Democrats could not literally get a budget out of their own 
Budget Committee, let alone across the floor, and she had to 
deem a budget.
 We have got other players in this that set us behind and 
make life very difficult. Is there anything in your legislation 
that would force them to get their stuff to us here in a 
fashion that would actually give us the time to do our jobs.
 Senator Lankford. There is not on that particular area. We 
tried to stay very, very narrowly focused on just working on 
preventing government shutdowns.
 I would be eager for us to reopen the 1974 Budget Act and 
to be able to reexamine when the President's budget is 
delivered, what we actually operate with that.
 Quite frankly, this is a totally different subject, but I 
am a fan of having calendar year rather than fiscal year. We 
need to admit the obvious gravity that every year we are 
fighting this in October, November, and December.
 This is now our 30th year that we do not have 
appropriations done on time before September 30, but that is a 
different issue than what this is trying to address.
 The Chairman. No, it is an important issue, but I would 
point out, this committee actually proceeded this year.
 Senator Lankford. Yes.
 The Chairman. We did not wait on the President's budget. I 
wish we had it, but if they cannot get it here on time, then it 
is going to become less relevant in consideration.
 We did not wait on the Budget Committee. I wish they had 
their deal. I very specifically--look, we have a great 
relationship. I am not critical of the committee. Although, I 
told the chairman of the committee: If you cannot pass it 
across the floor, I am not writing 12 bills to a number that is 
out of committee. Because if you cannot pass it on the floor, I 
cannot write 12 bills that will pass the floor.
 We have been flying on our own a little bit here and sort 
of backing into a top line, doing what we can as we can and 
moving ahead, but that is not a good way to proceed.
 That is something, if any of you have additional thoughts 
on, how we get the people that are supposed to do their job, so 
that we can do our job, to do it in time. Because they always 
escape the blame. It falls on this committee.
 The gentlelady from--well----
 Ms. Young. As the writer of four late budgets, the excuse 
becomes chicken-or-egg. I remember having this exchange in the 
Budget Committee when I was presenting.
 A Congressman was like, ``You need to submit it on time,'' 
and I replied, ``Well, you need to give me appropriations bills 
on time. You need to stop pointing the finger and probably get 
on time with each other and come to some agreement.''
 I will tell you as an example, though, I came from this 
committee. I had a predisposition to want this process to work. 
That is not, I believe, the norm for OMB Directors.
 The fight internally to make sure you got what you needed 
fell squarely on these shoulders. I cared about timing. Not 
necessarily everyone else did.
 If you know this, about what happens at OMB and in White 
Houses and how crises trump the basic work of budgeting and 
appropriations, that is what leads me to some of my concern 
about giving people more time and more access to work-arounds, 
as someone who fought to get you what you needed and get it in 
a more timely manner. Everything else becomes a priority.
 The Chairman. Thank you very much.
 I do not have a lot of time left, but Representative 
McClintock, I do have a question for you, and it really 
applies, in a sense, to Senator Lankford's proposal as well.
 Article I, Section 5, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution 
grants each Chamber of Congress ``the sole and exclusive right 
to determine the rules of its proceedings.''
 Given that, how can we impose upon the Senate--or even 
ourselves, our other colleagues--through statute you will 
proceed in this way? A lot of us have problems with the 
filibuster on both sides. Just depends on who happens to be 
using it.
 Really a lot of us do have those problems, but again, how 
would we constitutionally force the United States Senate to do 
something your proposal envisions, which is you cannot have 
this artificial barrier here that does foul up the process, no 
question?
 Mr. McClintock. Yeah. Well, the answer is, you cannot. The 
Senate has this annoying tendency to not see things our way. 
However, this changes a statute that requires the consent of 
both houses and the President's approval.
 The Senate does get a say in this. They get to either pass 
it, modify it, or reject it.
 The Chairman. Thank you very much.
 I ran a little bit over. I am going to be mindful of the 
time of the committee and recognize my good friend, the Ranking 
Member of the full committee, Ms. DeLauro, for any questions 
she may have.
 Ms. DeLauro. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 Thank you all for your testimony.
 I just might add that we cannot get Cabinet Secretaries 
today to come up and testify before the Appropriations 
Committee unless we threaten their appropriations. They do not 
feel the need to or the necessity to come before us and talk 
about their proposals.
 Senator Lankford, in 1986 the Reagan Administration wrote a 
letter to the Government Accountability Office (GAO) voicing 
opposition to auto CR proposals.
 Specifically, Reagan's OMB expressed concern that 
``Adoption of an automatic continuing resolution option could 
actually reduce the pressure on Congress to make funding 
decisions in a timely manner.''
 In other words, President Reagan's White House felt that an 
auto CR would eliminate the pressing end-of-the-year deadline 
that forces bipartisan compromise and action.
 Can you explain how your proposal would facilitate 
bipartisan compromise when many of us think that it would 
likely facilitate more entrenched partisan disagreement?
 Director Young, I would like to have you respond to that as 
well.
 Senator Lankford.
 Senator Lankford. That is great. Yeah, thank you for the 
question. It is a great question actually.
 In fact, during the Reagan Administration shutdowns were a 
couple hours, a couple days. They were not 47 days. They were 
not extending out where they are now. They are continuing to 
accelerate on it.
 This particular proposal puts the pressure on us, not to 
Federal workers. Right now the leverage to get our work done is 
TSA agents not getting paid, air traffic controllers not 
getting paid, Federal law enforcement not getting paid.
 Those families are the leverage for us to do our work. 
Those families have nothing to do with our inability to be able 
to get things finished up.
 I want to put the leverage on us, not on Federal workers 
and their families, and the best way to do that is basically to 
force us to stay in the room until we are finishing 
negotiating.
 If I can say it this way. I go back to my mom again. All my 
best advice ever came from my mom on it. When my brother and I 
would have an argument in the living room, she would make both 
of us leave and go to one of our rooms and say, if you guys are 
going to fight, go over there and fight, do not disturb the 
rest of the family. When you are done, then you can come back 
in here.
 This basically puts all of us, House and Senate, 
Republicans and Democrats, to say you cannot do anything but 
appropriations and you are going to stay there until 
appropriation is done. When appropriations is done, then you 
can go home or move to other subjects, but until you do 
appropriations, you cannot leave or switch to other things.
 I think that puts the pressure where it needs to be on us 
to get appropriations done.
 Ms. DeLauro. Well, it took us 79 days in the last go-around 
and for my colleagues on the other side of the aisle to make a 
determination when there was a proposal on the floor to say let 
us fund the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), the 
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Coast Guard, the 
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), et 
cetera, but let us hold because of the difficulties with 
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Border Patrol. 
Seventy-nine days. They finally on the other side of the aisle 
said, okay, we can go there.
 Those months because of politics and political will, which 
the Director speaks about, caused those families to suffer 
while we played around here with their lives.
 Let me ask you, Director Young, to respond to that same 
question of how does this proposal of an auto CR facilitate 
bipartisan compromise? I would just love to get your views on 
this.
 Ms. Young. I think if you listen to Senator Lankford, I 
think the forcing mechanism is you have to stay due.
 The problem is I have kind of seen it all. I was OMB 
Director, I did not really travel. I viewed it as more of a 
central DC--the Cabinet Secretaries went out, cut ribbons, 
these things. I did a little of that.
 I was mostly in DC. If OMB operates the way I viewed the 
job, the restriction on travel would not really impact OMB. For 
Members and Senators obviously it has more of an impact.
 You know and I have known, if no bill is coming to the 
floor for 2 or 3 days, you stop seeing Members around. If you 
have a child's birthday party you are going to find a way to 
get home after you check in with leadership.
 Just trying to think through how we have seen these things 
work. During a shutdown there is an expectation that Members 
stay around. We start losing people, because life happens, and 
if nothing is going to be on the floor, why would you miss a 
kid's birthday or wedding or any other event?
 I think there are limitations to this. I do not think there 
is an additional mechanism here to promote bipartisanship.
 You heard me before talk about the scenario in 2023. I have 
my doubts whether that would have come along, which prevented a 
shutdown, if there was a fail-safe that would have allowed the 
government to continue to operate.
 Ms. DeLauro. I have very few seconds left and maybe we can 
pick this up offline as well.
 In your testimony, Director Young, you say, you mentioned 
promising ideas of apportionment reform. Are there areas you 
think require greater specificity or are you making a broader 
suggestion on how we can take a look at apportionment reform?
 Ms. Young. Mr. Chairman, I am going to be quick here. I 
know we are out of time.
 I think this is incredibly important. Apportionment is 
yours. You gave it to OMB. What you also told me as Director of 
OMB is you were sick of apportionments being hidden and you 
wanted us to put them online.
 Ms. DeLauro. Right.
 Ms. Young. We did it at your bipartisan direction. I think 
when you think about apportionment reform, I hope as things 
come through Congress you think of that as something that does 
not belong to any executive branch. It belongs to you, as you 
think through reform. You do not have to allow on-veto 
apportion at all.
 It used to be appropriations to agencies and that is it. 
That is hard because agencies have gotten so big and 
complicated. OMB served a role. If OMB is not doing the job you 
want it to do, whether it be mine or this one, it belongs to 
you, and you can take it back if they are not exercising that 
authority in the way that Congress wants it to. That is how I 
think.
 Also appropriations, this committee has always relied on 
funding reports. The statutes are not very long. You encourage, 
you direct, you urge. If that is not being listened to, more of 
those things need to go into statute rather than the suggestive 
report language. That is my suggestion.
 Ms. DeLauro. Thank you very much.
 I thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 The Chairman. Thank you very much, my friend.
 We next go to Chairman Aderholt, but before you are 
recognized, it is your birthday. The tradition--newly 
established tradition--the Boehner birthday song will be 
rendered.
 [Singing.] This is your birthday song, it does not last too 
long. Hey!
 The gentleman is now recognized.
 Mr. Aderholt. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would say that I 
am usually not in Appropriations Committee meetings on my 
birthday, but looking back, I usually am in Appropriation 
meetings on my birthday.
 However, I will say, this is the first time I have been in 
a full committee hearing on my birthday. This is a little bit 
different day.
 It is great to have Senator Lankford, Congressman 
McClintock, former Director of OMB Shalanda Young. Good to have 
all of you all here today for your testimony and your thoughts 
on this issue. I know this is an issue that every one of us 
have dealt with, whether you have been here in one term or 
whether you have been here many, many terms.
 Let me address the first issue, first question to 
Congressman McClintock.
 Of course you are an authorizer, and here we are on the 
appropriations side here in this committee. How do you see the 
relationship between authorizing and appropriations in the 
process. As far as--do you think there needs to be greater 
alignment between authorizers and appropriators? What do you 
feel like could be changed to make that more easy to try to 
maybe avoid a shutdown?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, of course I have always been very 
critical of the tendency of the House to continue to fund 
programs that are unauthorized. Our House rules allow a point 
of order, but those rules are always waived in the rule that 
brings the appropriation bills to the House.
 Unauthorized appropriations are a big problem, and it is 
not the fault of this committee. It is the fault of authorizing 
committees that simply fail to look at the programs within 
their jurisdictions to determine which ones are efficient, 
which ones have become inefficient, which ones have become 
superannuated and need to be abolished.
 Within the budget process itself there is a very sharp 
distinction. The Appropriations Committee controls the 
discretionary spending. The authorizing committees are supposed 
to control the mandatory spending. That is the reconciliation 
process and that is the process that has really gotten fouled 
up.
 One of the problems that we face on both sides, 
discretionary and mandatory, is, again, that impediment in the 
Senate that allows the minority, if it wishes, simply to block 
consideration of the appropriations bills that are sent over.
 That obviously thwarts the appropriations process, but 
again, it also puts pressure on the reconciliation process to 
be used not for comprehensive reform of our mandatory spending, 
but rather to chase whatever shiny object we cannot get through 
the Senate.
 I think that this reform--again, it is not a cure-all, it 
is not a substitute for political will--but it does remove one 
of the impediments that I think is keeping this process from 
working.
 Mr. Aderholt. Thank you.
 Senator Lankford, of course you have had the privilege to 
serve in both Chambers, in the House and the Senate. How do you 
see the dynamics Congressman McClintock just mentioned about 
the issue with a minority being able to keep an appropriation 
bill from coming to the floor? How do you see the shutdown 
dynamics play out differently from your perspective in the 
House and now being in the Senate?
 Senator Lankford. I think I was in the House 6 hours as a 
Member when I heard for the first time: The other party is the 
opposition, the Senate is the enemy.
 Mr. Aderholt. Yep.
 Senator Lankford. That has not changed over the years in 
the process back and forth. I get that dynamic. The two bodies 
do function very very differently.
 As Representative DeLauro had mentioned before, 
appropriations is always bipartisan--always--when you go 
through the process on that, and that is true in the Senate as 
well. The Senate requires both sides to have to sit down and 
talk like grown-ups and figure out our differences and to be 
able to solve those.
 To be able to remove the requirement to have 60 on 
appropriations, which is the gist of this proposal on this, 
would pull away that requirement that we have bipartisan 
conversation in the Senate.
 It also would add into it in this particular structure one 
of the things that Senators hate the most, and that is the 
vote-a-rama. The House has the convenience of when you do a 
reconciliation bill of voting it, sending it over to the 
Senate. The Senate rules require a vote-a-rama. That is an 
unlimited amendment exercise where we are often in continuous 
voting for sometimes as short as 8 hours, most often 20 to 25 
to 30 hours continuous, one amendment after another, on 
unlimited subjects.
 You will not find very many Senators that want to do 
another one of those because they are painful, long, political 
exercises that do not accomplish anything. This particular 
proposal would add yet another set of vote-a-ramas into the 
Senate rules, and that would be tough to get Senators to 
actually vote far. We are trying to get rid of that, not add 
another one.
 Mr. Aderholt. Thank you.
 I think my time is up, so I will yield back.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentleman.
 The gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Hoyer, is recognized for 
questions.
 Mr. Hoyer. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 First let me say I think we have two thoughtful Members of 
the Congress of the United States presenting these proposals. 
Senator Lankford has represented that in the House and now 
represents it in the Senate. As I have told Mr. McClintock, I 
always enjoy hearing him speak because I think he speaks truth 
and with good analysis.
 However, I disagree with both of you strongly. Congressman 
McClintock, you just said what I think is the real issue, and 
you said that no legislation or rule can replace political 
will.
 Mr. McClintock. Correct.
 Mr. Hoyer. Let me speak just a little bit about political 
will.
 Ronald Reagan, as Jim Lankford just pointed out, was 
President for 8 years, Bush was President for 4 thereafter. We 
had 12 years where we essentially had 8 days of shutdown--or 12 
days, 8 years of Reagan, one and a half day average shutdown. 
Why? Because the political will of the President and the 
political will of the Congress was to reach agreement.
 That does not now exist. The Director of OMB has made it 
clear, ``We want their funding to be shut down.'' That is a 
quote of Mr. Vought.
 Mr. Trump said we had two shutdowns--excuse me, this is Mr. 
Gingrich--two shutdowns in 1995 and became the first reelected 
GOP majority since 1928. Speaker Gingrich pointing out that 
that was a successful effort.
 Mr. McCarthy said, ``Nobody wins in a government 
shutdown.'' Nobody wins in a government shutdown. I have been 
here. He said that on September 14th, 2023. He believes 
partially he was removed for facilitating agreement between the 
two parties, rather than a partisan shutdown and confrontation.
 I believe these proposals do exactly the opposite of what 
we need to do in the sense I think they weaken greatly the 
Congress and strengthen even more than has happened to date the 
Presidency, making the executive extraordinarily powerful and 
the Congress much weaker.
 Essentially, it makes the Appropriations Committee 
irrelevant and powerless to carry out the Founders' intent to 
give paramount and exclusive authority to the Congress for the 
spending of taxpayer money.
 Furthermore, I think that shutting the government down has 
been a tool of political choice by many Republican leaders, 
including Newt Gingrich, Donald Trump, and many others, 
including Vought, and it is a tool which has been employed by 
Democrats as well. No one has clean hands, if you will, on this 
issue.
 Let me refer to the Director of OMB.
 Director Young, when Congress provides only broad, outdated 
funding through CRs, who makes the operational decisions about 
what is delayed, reduced, or prioritized?
 Ms. Young. That is typically some combination of agencies 
and the Office of Management and Budget, and probably some 
insight from the White House if it is consequential enough.
 Mr. Hoyer. In fact, what a shutdown does by the failure of 
the political will, which Congressman McClintock talked about, 
it enhances greatly the authority and ability of the President 
of the United States, and through OMB and through his agencies, 
to set policies for those agencies.
 Ms. Young. Yes. During a shutdown each agency has to tell 
the American people what is open, what is closed. As we all 
know, that is different even within the same administration. 
One year it could be this is, and it was politically tough, and 
they change their shutdown plans to something else. There is a 
lot of latitude for the President to make those decisions.
 Mr. Hoyer. Let me say to Senator Lankford, I represent 
approximately 77,000 Federal employees. I feel their pain. I 
know their pain. Obviously that pain visited on not only 
government employees, but on others as well is reflected in how 
many people are looking for a solution.
 I really say that, as we did under Ronald Reagan, I was 
here all 8 years he was President--and George Bush--we rarely 
shut down the government.
 Under Joe Biden with a Republican Congress we did not shut 
down the government at all, not once, because we reached 
agreement.
 Political will, I suggest again, Congressman, is, in fact, 
the answer, not weakening the Congress of the United States, 
not saying somebody else will get government going.
 The incentive for the administration to undermine agreement 
is heightened by, I think, these proposals. Although I would 
like to see the Senate--I am one of those that think the Senate 
needs to reform itself so that it can do its business.
 Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentleman.
 The gentleman from Idaho, Mr. Simpson, is recognized for 
questions.
 Mr. Simpson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Thank you all for being here.
 I actually like all of this discussion of what is going on.
 Mr. McClintock, I am not optimistic the Senate would listen 
to us, but I agree with what you are trying to do.
 The filibuster rule has been changing forever. It was 
originally two-thirds vote. They dropped it to 60 because two-
thirds was too hard, and then they decided, well, we should not 
do it for judges or confirmations, so we will drop it to 50 for 
those positions.
 The appropriations process and appropriations bills are 
something that the Federal government has a constitutional 
responsibility to do. I think we have a constitutional 
responsibility to do it. The Senate ought to do it with simple 
majority. If they want to change their vote-a-rama rules, I do 
not even know what those are, but they could change those too 
if that became a problem.
 I am not optimistic that they will listen to us. I talked 
to my two Senators. They do not like the idea.
 Mr. McClintock. It is a helpful suggestion.
 Mr. Simpson. It will be a helpful suggestion, I agree with 
that.
 Senator, I agree with your proposal. I like parts of it. I 
think it is a good idea that puts the responsibility back on us 
to do this.
 However, if you listen to everybody in this room, almost 
everybody in this room would say they are opposed to shutdowns. 
They do not want government shutdowns. We want to make sure 
that does not happen.
 Yet they continue to happen, and they are getting worse and 
worse and worse. When you get narrower and narrower majorities 
they are going to become more frequent because all of a sudden 
any individual could become a king. If I do not get something 
that has absolutely nothing to do with funding over in this 
bill, I am not going to vote for this.
 We have all seen that happen. Happens every day around 
here. That is a problem. We even had shutdowns when we had some 
of your largest majorities, and that is a problem.
 I noticed that Rosa mentioned the shutdown where they 
proposed funding everything except ICE, and we did not go along 
with that until the very last. It was because I do not think 
you can pick and choose. I do not think that is right.
 Ultimately, how did that work out for you? We got ICE 
funded for 2 years, which I disagree with, because all of a 
sudden we do not have the ability to change and have oversight 
hearings of what the funding is for the next couple of years.
 I think that was the wrong thing to do, but we were kind of 
at odds of not being able to do anything else, and that is a 
real problem.
 However, I do want to compliment Tom and Ranking Member 
DeLauro and actually Susan and Patty over in the Senate, 
Senators Collins and Murray. They have been working on trying 
to get us back to what is called regular order, what we all 
refer to as regular order.
 I think one of the biggest problems that is driving this is 
we have not followed the Budget Act of 1974. We need a budget 
resolution. We need to know what the 302A is. They are hard to 
do.
 I listened to a speaker from one of our institutes here 
saying most Members of Congress do not even know what a budget 
resolution is. They have never voted for a budget resolution.
 When I was a freshman I came back early from my dad's 
funeral to vote for a budget resolution. That is how important 
they were.
 Then, all of a sudden, they became too hard to pass, so we 
stopped trying, and we started deeming numbers. The House deems 
a different number than the Senate deems. Consequently, how do 
you conference a bill if you do not have the same numbers? You 
do not have the same numbers until the four corners, or 
leadership, gets together and decides what that is. If Senator 
Murkowski is marking up her Interior bill to $40 billion and I 
am marking it up to $38 billion, how do you conference that? 
You cannot.
 We need to get back to regular order. I will tell you, we 
have been moving in that direction. Chairman Cole has 
emphasized that. We have been trying to get back to having a 
budget resolution, but it includes other committees.
 You talk about the authorizing committees and things that 
go in our bill that are unauthorized, I do not put anything in 
my bill that has not been approved by the chairman of the 
authorizing committees. I have to get their approval to put it 
in or they could object to it on the floor.
 Now, is that right or wrong? I will tell you, one year, I 
brought a bill down that defunded all the Endangered Species 
Act and critical habitat, and people thought I was crazy. The 
reason I did it, I was trying to make a point: The Endangered 
Species Act had not been reauthorized for 23 years at that 
time. It still has not. The authorizing committees need to get 
busy and do their jobs with the reauthorizations of some of 
these things.
 That is a challenge we all have, but I will tell you, it 
is--too many people in Congress, frankly, have forgotten what 
the word ``compromise'' is.
 We work with compromise in this committee. Our 
subcommittee, Chellie Pingree and I sit--as do all the ranking 
members and chairmen--sit and work on a compromise trying to 
solve that. We have disagreements on what the 302(b) is. 
Sometimes they would like to spend more; sometimes we would 
like to spend less. We have disagreements on that, but within 
the bill, how we spend the money, we compromise.
 Too many people do not understand what compromise is. That 
is what this place operates on--or should.
 Anyway, I appreciate you all being here.
 It is good to see you again, Shalanda.
 I look forward to working with you. There is no one simple 
answer to this. It is going to take multiple things.
 Thank you.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentleman for his questions.
 The gentleman from Georgia, Mr. Bishop, is recognized for 
questions.
 Mr. Bishop. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Welcome to all of our witnesses.
 Ms. Young, thank you for coming before the committee today. 
Your many years of experience working as professional committee 
staff with appropriators on both sides of the aisle, as well as 
your commendable service at OMB, is invaluable to this 
discussion.
 In your view, what is the role of the President in 
legislating government funding? Do the legislative proposals 
that are before us today, put forward, do they discourage the 
President's participation? Put slightly differently, do these 
proposals promote a more functional political system that 
encourages accountability of Congress and of the President to 
the public?
 Also, to Mr. Lankford, related to my questions of Ms. 
Young, while your legislation goes into quite some detail on 
the restrictions on Members of Congress and congressional 
procedures during a lapse, it is completely silent on the 
President. Yet the President has an immense role in negotiation 
on appropriations legislation and has many tools to hinder the 
process.
 Why does your legislation provide no carrots or sticks to 
encourage the President's participation in the appropriations 
process?
 In fact, the 2018 shutdown happened because President Trump 
refused to work with the House and Senate of his own party.
 After Mr. Lankford's response, Ms. Young, I would like for 
you to let me know your thoughts on ceding Congress' role in 
appropriations without providing any mechanism of 
accountability for the executive branch.
 Ms. Young. I will go first.
 To combine, kind of, what you and Congressman Simpson 
talked about, there are lots of things that come through White 
Houses that are difficult. White Houses operate in 6-hour 
sprints a day. When you have something complicated like the 
appropriations process and a budget--I have seen it firsthand--
it is difficult. It requires intense engagement to get all 12 
bills done. Sometimes--it does not matter the party--it would 
be easier to find an off-ramp.
 I look at all these proposals. I do not want to provide any 
more off-ramps for people not to do the hard work. That is how 
I look at all of it. I do not want the same thing, this 
authorization process that Chairman Simpson talked about, to 
happen to this committee.
 We all know--we can say it--we all know, once you stop 
doing something and you give people an out, it does not stop. 
Once you say ``you do not have to vote on this amendment,'' and 
``forget open rules,'' and this and that, it does not go back.
 We have seen this tale. My fear is, Presidents, White 
Houses, OMBs, of the thousands of things they have going on, 
this becomes a distraction. If you give them an easy way to 
deal with it--and I will put congressional leadership in that 
box--that is the path they will take.
 That is how I look at the lens of all recommendations that 
come up, a worthy aim, to prevent shutdowns. I want people to 
do more work, more rooms together, more CODELs so we know each 
other and have relationships and can find compromise. I want 
more, not less, interaction.
 Mr. Bishop. Senator Lankford.
 Senator Lankford. Yes. Great question, by the way, on it. 
If I can just clarify just a couple things on this, I do not 
want this proposal to be misunderstood.
 This is not the government on autopilot. This is us sitting 
every day at our desk having to work. It takes the pressure off 
of Federal workers and their families and puts the pressure 
where it should be, on us. Right now, the pressure is on 
Federal workers and their families, and we leave and go home 
and go to birthday parties and go to other things.
 I think this is being misunderstood. This is not just 
autopilot. This is pushing us towards appropriation. The one 
change is, the pressure point is on us rather than on them. 
That is why the American Federation of Government Employees 
union strongly supports----
 Mr. Bishop. Well, what about the pressure on the President? 
What about the----
 Senator Lankford. The pressure on the President is--this is 
actually long discussed, and we have done it in a bipartisan 
way, and there have been several versions of this--is that 
Members of Congress, our staff, we cannot travel--official 
travel, whatever it may be. OMB, their staff does not travel. 
Now, OMB does not travel much on it, but we looked at, who are 
the budget negotiators that are there?
 We did not put a limitation on the President of the United 
States. That is a different role----
 Mr. Bishop. That means if he is not interested in pushing 
it or his budget director does not want to get it done, they 
can just sit on it and do nothing.
 Senator Lankford. Well, I would only disagree in the sense 
that, whoever the political party is of the President, if we 
are all sitting here looking at each other for a week, we will 
find a way to be able to press the President and to be able to 
say, ``The people that support you are stuck in this spot. We 
have to be able to find a way to be able to work together.''
 Mr. Bishop. Mr. Chairman, may I have 30 seconds for Ms. 
Young to respond to that?
 The Chairman. The gentleman is recognized for 30 seconds.
 Mr. Bishop. Thank you.
 Ms. Young. I have done lots of these negotiations. Members, 
when they are sitting around waiting to see if the smoke from 
the chimney comes--when I was at OMB, I was on the phone with 
Ken Calvert, I was on the phone with every one of you who sit 
in rooms. Most Members are not in those rooms. What happens is, 
they are waiting, just like the American people are waiting.
 I think, in practicality, most Members are not going to 
sit--we do not sit on the floor and have these negotiations. We 
have these conversations, negotiations in our subcommittees, 
congressional leadership. If the President is engaged, it is at 
the White House.
 I get the point, but the way they have tended to operate is 
the majority of the Members are not beholden to this process, 
like the Members of this committee are, in OMB. If you are 
sitting around for 5 days, you do not see the Pope smoke. Are 
you really going to miss a family event? Like, you are not 
engaged in any meaningful way and probably have other things 
that this is not going to stop you from participating in. That 
is my worry.
 Senator Lankford. For right now, it is TSA agents waiting 
for the Pope smoke rather than us, and I am trying to take that 
away from them.
 The Chairman. The gentleman yields back?
 Well, reclaiming the committee's time, we will now go to 
the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Carter, for any questions he may 
have.
 Mr. Carter. I think we can all agree that Congress has a 
basic duty to fund the government. That is why we are here.
 We have a problem that--it did not start anywhere but at 
the courthouse in your hometown. That is where it started. When 
I was a judge for 20 years before I got here, I had to call 
Immigration a dozen times and say, ``My jail is full. I do not 
have anyplace to put my prisoners, and I am not going to pay 
for it. Send your people over here, and get your people out of 
my jail.'' They came in there and they got them out. Well, that 
was Immigration. That is what they were called then.
 The idea that the counties should decide ``well, we are not 
going to allow anybody to take anybody out of here'' is totally 
contrary to the way it operated for 20 years when I was on the 
bench. We had: If they were lazy, get them out. Now, they do 
not get any help at all getting them out.
 There is where this problem starts. That is breaking the 
law. After that, everywhere we go, somebody is slightly 
breaking the law again.
 We are here now talking about funding this and coming up 
with it.
 I serve Fort Hood. I represent Fort Hood. I am proud to 
serve Fort Hood. Fort Hood has around 15,000 civilian 
employees. The Federal contractors who work for them are some 
of the hardest-working people we got anywhere in our county.
 Could you explain how your legislation would protect the 
government contracts in these government shutdowns? What is 
happening to those people? First, that is my first question.
 Senator Lankford. This proposal actually uniquely does 
that, because it provides the funding for the programming as 
well as the pay.
 As we know, we just had a time where we determined we were 
going to pay employees, but we were not going to pay 
contractors and we were not going to pay programming. We had a 
situation where, literally, in the Coast Guard, for instance, 
the Coast Guard Coasties, they were actually paid, but they 
could not take their ships out because they did not have gas, 
because that was a contractor that provided the gas for it. 
They were getting their utilities cut off at some of their 
stations because they were getting paid but they were not 
actually getting any of the contractor pay that was actually 
going to it for programming.
 What I have tried to do here is to say: The functioning of 
government continues. We all have to stay here. It is required 
in this that we have a quorum call every day; we cannot go into 
recess for more than 23 hours.
 It requires everybody to be here. I know folks want to be 
at birthday parties, but they literally have to tell their 
constituents, ``I left the work.'' That is not required now. 
Now, if you head home for a birthday party, that is not a 
violation of what we are doing. This actually changes it. It 
also takes away all official funding and campaign funding for 
travel and puts a quorum call here.
 It puts us here at work, where we should be, to resolve our 
differences until appropriations is done, but it holds the 
programs, the contractors, and the Federal family, the workers 
that are out there, holds them harmless, because they cannot do 
anything about us not resolving things; only we can. The 
pressure goes on us.
 Mr. Carter. Well, I am hopeful we can get it.
 Anybody else want to talk about what their proposal does to 
protect the contractors?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, to your point, the continuing 
resolution introduces a great deal of indecision in 
contractors' relationships with the Federal government.
 How do we get to these continuing resolutions? Because the 
good work of this committee goes over to the Senate and then it 
just sits there. Now, they are supposed to amend it to their 
liking and send it back to us, but if it can be blocked for 
lack of cloture, you cannot have that discussion. Then we, 
again, have the Hobson's choice: We either accept the shutdown, 
with all of this devastating impact on the government, or we go 
to a continuing resolution.
 The contractors go from continuing resolution to continuing 
resolution, not knowing what is next.
 Mr. Carter. Well, that is not good.
 Ma'am, have you got a suggestion?
 Ms. Young. Well, I do not have legislation, but commenting 
on it, I would say: Senator Lankford, as we have sat here, 
there is nothing to prevent us from thinking about ideas to 
require--if the idea is to keep Members and OMB and the 
administration engaged, let us start that September 15th of 
every year rather than a new process to take the pressure off.
 If the idea is to make sure people do not leave--I do not 
know why we leave September 10th through 15th for random--you 
see what I am saying? There are ways, without taking pressure 
off--if the idea is to insist that people show up every day, 
let us do that September 1st through September 30th.
 This idea that we are arguing between automatic CRs and 
CRs--this committee knows that CRs are bad regardless. I also 
do not want us to leave this room thinking that is the choice 
either. We want regular, full-year bills done. Because whether 
it is automatic or whether it is a CR, we have never found 
those the way to operate government.
 Fort Hood told us about their funding needs almost 2 years 
ago in order to be in the budget process. To keep that in place 
through CR to CR is also not showing up for Fort Hood.
 Mr. Carter. Amen.
 Thank you.
 The Chairman. The chair would ask that Members do their 
best--the conversation is good, but we have a lot of people 
here that have questions, and I would just ask that we try to 
stick within the 5 minutes.
 The gentlelady from Minnesota, Ms. McCollum, is recognized 
for questions.
 Ms. McCollum. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 I want to thank you and the Ranking Member for making this 
happen. It gives me great solace to be able to go home and tell 
my constituents that we care about the Constitution, we care 
about our duties here in Congress, and we know we need to get 
our job done on time.
 It is clear we all know continuing resolutions are not the 
way to fund government. I want to talk about some of the people 
that--we talk about our constituents a lot, but our 
constituents also live in local communities. Local governments, 
our communities at large--hospitals, schools, transportation 
dollars--they are all impacted.
 We make a mess, having served on local and State 
government--and even county government, which I did not serve 
in--we take their budgets and we put them in total chaos. 
Sometimes we fail to think of the partners that we have in 
making this democracy work.
 I want to just take a second to talk about Trump and OMB. 
They used, in my opinion--and I can back it up--the full-year 
CR as an opportunity literally to break appropriations law. The 
impoundment of funds was rampant, and agencies that were 
established by Congress, like the Department of Education and 
the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), they 
were just torn apart and shut down.
 This is--in my opinion, it was completely unconstitutional. 
We did not stand up for the Constitution. We did not do our 
Article I responsibilities. Because Article I does give 
Congress, not the administration, the power of the purse.
 Let me just take this down a little bit of a notch here and 
talk about my subcommittee that I am proud to serve on with 
Chairman Calvert and how this is bad for the Department of 
Defense.
 When we do a full-year CR appropriations bill as being, 
kind of--or even going into December--it throws away the work 
that we do bipartisanly to work carefully to respond to all the 
specific activities that the Department of Defense covers.
 Let us think about what that includes. It includes dual-use 
technologies for small businesses like advanced manufacturing, 
microelectronics, cybersecurity, life-saving medical treatments 
that impact the lives of our servicemembers and benefits the 
civilian healthcare sector.
 When a CR happens, none of this happens. Under a CR, we 
cannot stop spending in areas where no longer it is needed, 
like old legacy platforms that should be retired. We fail, at 
the same time, to invest in critical needs that we have to work 
on.
 Russia and China do not operate on continuing resolutions. 
I do not agree with the President's decision on what he did in 
Iran, but we are at war. Now we are talking about a CR. They 
are bad for the Department of Defense, and they are bad for the 
United States of America.
 President Trump did not have any problems endorsing a full-
year continuing resolution for 2025 for the entire Federal 
government. With the discussions that I am seeing taking place, 
or the lack of communication from the Department of Defense to 
this committee when we request important things in order to 
plan our budgets, I have to wonder how engaged the 
administration really is in helping us put pressure, as you 
talk about, Mr. Lankford, for all of us to get together, sit 
down, and do the job.
 Bottom line, it is a complete disaster for the taxpayer. 
Without this, I want to reiterate it again, money does not move 
on time to businesses; contracts are late, costing the taxpayer 
more money; we lose an entire fiscal year.
 I am going to ask you a question, Ms. Young, because the 
bottom line is, we are cycle after cycle after cycle of this. 
If we really went back and looked at the inefficiencies, the 
wasted money from all of these CRs, I think the taxpayers would 
be enraged. We do not do an accumulation; we do not run a clock 
on that.
 In your experience, Director Young, on continuing 
resolutions, could you give us your thoughts on some of the 
impacts that it not only has on the employees that are not 
getting paid, but the long-term impacts of the inefficiency and 
the waste of tax dollars that happens? I used the Department of 
Defense as an example, but you could use whatever you want.
 Ms. Young. Sure. You can look at any drafted CR that has 
been passed you care to, a provision that rightfully says, 
agencies cannot make big decisions until full-year bills are 
done. If that is 6 months later, the Army, Navy, cannot go into 
long-term procurements on new things, most of your State and 
locals will not get their Low Income Home Energy Assistance 
Program (LIHEAP) funding or any other large grant, because if 
agencies--if OMB allowed that, it basically pre-presumed where 
you would land in the final bill.
 I am not suggesting you take that out, because you do not 
want us dictating the final legislation, but if we cannot make 
big, long-term investments, including grant programs that most 
State and locals just depend on from year to year, it is 
incredibly impactful to local units of government, who cannot 
make those long-term decisions if they are waiting on an 
Environmenal Protection Agency (EPA) State Revolving Fund loan, 
or the Army or Navy who are looking to make a large-scale 
acquisition.
 We all know CRs, whether it be the new proposal or the 
current way of business, prevents the government from operating 
in an efficient way. A private business would never do that.
 Ms. McCollum. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 Thank you, Ms. Young.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentlelady.
 I would ask the Members, try not to pose questions the last 
10 seconds of your time. It puts the witness in a very 
difficult spot.
 With that, the gentleman from California, Mr. Calvert, is 
recognized for questions.
 Mr. Calvert. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 I thank our witnesses for being here today.
 I will carry on what Betty was talking about. Obviously, 
our House Defense Appropriations Committee is half the 
discretionary budget--it is always good to see you, Shalanda--
and we had many discussions in the past. The frustrations that 
we have in attempting to operate the largest enterprise in the 
world under a continuing resolution or in a shutdown scenario, 
it should not happen.
 We have been forced to do this because we, unfortunately, 
have given away our Article I authority more and more to the 
executive branch and a dysfunctional congressional process at 
this point.
 Our global competition, whether it is China or Russia or 
Iran or North Korea, they do not have continuing resolutions or 
shutdowns. I am sure they are amused to watch us go through 
this process, as we attempt to make sure that the men and women 
of the United States military are paid, that we can operate our 
procurement process in an orderly fashion, which, 
unfortunately, is not occurring at the present time.
 Then we have now fallen back on extraordinary new ways to 
fund the Federal government. We used to pass appropriations 
bills, and if we needed to have a supplemental in order to deal 
with a conflict, as the gentlelady was talking about, Ms. 
McCollum, we would do a supplemental and we would pay for it, 
whether it was in the War on Terror through the Overseas 
Contingency Operations (OCO) process or in previous wars.
 Also, reconciliation I do not think was ever an intention 
to give the authority to OMB to determine how those dollars are 
going to be spent. Because one thing that I think the American 
public does not understand is that the appropriators, we do not 
control the reconciliation process. The authorizers really do 
not control the appropriations process. I would submit that the 
Department of Defense does not control how the outlays work 
under a reconciliation process. OMB does. They, in effect, make 
the final determination of what money will be spent for what. 
We can make a list of suggestions; they may or may not follow 
it.
 That is what we have fallen into over a number of years. 
How the hell do we get out of this thing and get back to 
regular order, all of us? Because this is not good for the 
process. This reconciliation process we are going through right 
now I do not think is healthy for us.
 Here we are on potentially the verge of another shutdown in 
a time of conflict.
 All of this, I think, is a problem within the family, 
really--that we have to come to a determination that this 
cannot continue.
 I am going to go with what Mr. Simpson said to my friend 
Mr. Lankford, that maybe we ought to rethink the filibuster. 
That is your decision to make, I know that. It is not our 
decision. It was never the intent of the Founding Fathers or, I 
think, of previous Senates that we would be held hostage to a 
60-vote process in order to pass needed appropriations, 
especially at time in conflict that we are in today in Iran.
 What would you--how do we get--we do not have time to keep 
talking about this; we need to do something. How would you 
respond to that?
 Senator Lankford. I would respond to that that we have 
become allergic to having bipartisan conversations. Because the 
filibuster is not an issue if you are actually having 
bipartisan dialogue and you are allowing grown-ups to sit down 
and talk to other grown-ups and to be able to figure out how we 
are going to solve things where we disagree.
 The filibuster really came into position--of course, it was 
part of the Senate rules from the earliest days, and it used to 
be that four or five Members could actually hold the Senate 
hostage because they could just rotate around and be able to 
speak. In 1917 that was changed over to a two-thirds, and in 
1974 it was changed over to the three-fifths, the current rule 
that we have now.
 I would say that--we have had some conversation about this. 
My predecessor, Don Nichols, who was two Senators before me, 
served on the Appropriation Committee in the Senate for 20 
years. They never had a single cloture vote in Appropriations 
in his entire time that he was in the Senate. The rules were 
the same; the behavior was different on this.
 Now we have practiced bad behavior so many years in a row. 
That is why I am looking for, how do we actually help guide us 
back to this? Because I do not think it is just going to be a 
situation where we say, ``Let us just figure out how we are 
going to cooperate together.'' I think we have to be able to 
put some new boundaries around this.
 The suggestion that Maggie Hassan, my Democratic colleague, 
and I have--and it is a bipartisan suggestion from multiple of 
us in the Senate--is to say, ``Let us put the pressure on us to 
be able to stay here until our work is done.''
 We all know how important it is to get home and see our 
families. If we were to say, ``No one leaves this week until 
all the work is done,'' we would somehow find a way to be able 
to get the work done, but we do not. We leave. The work is 
undone, and the pressure goes on Federal employees. We are 
trying to solve that.
 Mr. Calvert. Thank you.
 I yield back.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentleman for his questions.
 The gentlelady from Florida, Ms. Frankel, is recognized for 
her questions.
 Ms. Frankel. Thank you.
 Thank you to our witnesses today for being here.
 First, I want to just say in regards to leverages on 
Members, I want to respectfully suggest that no leverage--no 
leverage--should occur that would affect Members unequally.
 For example, someone from Maryland can go home overnight to 
see their family. Someone from California, Alaska would not do 
so. A wealthy Member could afford to travel.
 Unequal leverage is not right, not fair. Our decisions 
should be based upon what is best for our constituents and for 
the country, not our own personal considerations.
 I want to add that I do think the people on this committee, 
as has been said before, we understand that under the dynamics 
and the circumstances of the present-day Congress we have to 
have a bipartisan agreement to get a spending plan done. It 
seems to me the approach should be to get to that position 
earlier. That seems to me the reasonable thing to do. We are 
allowing--and I am not going to point fingers, but we have 
people in the process, not on this committee, who just hold us 
up on everything.
 With that, I am going to ask a question.
 Welcome back, the Honorable Shalanda Young.
 One of the greatest strengths of annual appropriations is 
to allow Congress to respond to a changing world, as some of my 
colleagues have said. Every year brings new challenges.
 We have seen the attacks of September 11th, the Congress 
increased funding for--Congress--that we saw Benghazi and 
having to increase security for our embassies. We have seen 
disease, Ebola, COVID outbreaks, where we have had to invest 
more in global health and pandemic response. The war in 
Ukraine, we had to respond to that. Year after year, we respond 
to hurricanes, earthquakes, famines, and other humanitarian 
disasters that sometimes we could not have anticipated.
 That is why I think the people on this committee believe 
that annual appropriations matter.
 I am bringing this from the perspective of our National 
Security, Department of State, and Related Programs (NSRP) 
committee. You knew it as the State, Foreign Operations, and 
Related Programs (SFOPS). I would like to get your opinion in 
terms of how a continuing resolution would affect these kinds 
of decisions, especially in this foreign assistance budget.
 Ms. Young. I assume you mean if my prognostications about 
how the auto CR would play out, that a bad actor--a President 
or a minority in the Senate or a leadership who did not like 
what appropriations bills come up--could gum up the process and 
keep us on CRs.
 I think what happens is, eventually you get to a 
workaround, right? If you see a problem and your regular 
appropriations bills cannot deal with it, you probably start 
doing more supplementals or figure out rules to exempt this or 
exempt that or exempt this and that.
 Someone asked me about automatic apportionments. I go, it 
works until it does not--until Congress is out in August and an 
agency goes over its funding and there are automatic 
apportionments and you do not let OMB do these things and 
exceptions start happening. Does it happen in year one? Does it 
happen in year two?
 If you believe what I believe what happens with auto CRs--
that a President or a few people could keep you in it--if there 
is something big enough, I think supplementals and other 
workarounds start to become more prominent if you are just 
stuck in the appropriations do loop and you cannot move regular 
appropriations bills. I do not think that is a good thing 
either.
 Supplementals, without budget caps, one does not really 
need them. You can come do a regular appropriations bill. We 
have just gotten used to it, and they are not a bad thing if 
they are easier to get done than regular appropriations bills. 
I would hate if they start being used because we just cannot do 
regular appropriations bills.
 Ms. Frankel. I think what you are saying and I think what I 
have heard my colleagues say is, continuing resolutions keep us 
stuck, many times, in a wrong, dangerous place.
 I would just--I know this committee, that we can find 
bipartisan agreement. I would just say, we have to figure out 
how we get the rest of our colleagues----
 Ms. Young. You have pointed out----
 Ms. Frankel [continuing]. To do that.
 Ms. Young [continuing]. The problem. You have lots of 
places coming into this process that are not necessarily as big 
of fans of this process as Members of this committee are.
 Ms. Frankel. Thank you, all of you, for being here.
 I yield back.
 The Chairman. I thank the gentlelady.
 It is my understanding, Senator Lankford, that votes have 
been called in the Senate and you will need to go. Please, go 
at your discretion. Whenever you think is appropriate is 
perfectly appropriate.
 I am going to proceed the following way. Mr. Diaz-Balart is 
next up for questions. I am going to recognize him. I have to 
step out, myself, so when he is done with his questions, he 
will come and take the chair. We will continue as long as 
Members want to continue. He will be running the meeting, the 
vice chair.
 I would say again, all of you have been exceptionally 
generous with your time. I am not sure we have managed your 
time as well as we should have, but I want to thank you for 
your patience.
 We will continue to proceed. I think this is a really 
important topic. I think the bipartisan exchanges have been 
very helpful, and I am very grateful for that.
 With that, I am going to recognize Mr. Diaz-Balart for any 
questions he might have.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Actually, it is great to see Director Young.
 I have to admit that I also, too, am always reluctant to 
give off-ramps. Because off-ramps are taken, right? Because it 
is tough, this is tough. You mentioned this is not a new issue, 
and it is not going to get any easier, unfortunately.
 You also mentioned the issue of cameras, right? That is a 
factor, that there are some folks who are less interested in 
getting the job done, more interested in just being 
celebrities. That has always been what one of my concerns is on 
any of these proposals.
 Let me start with you, Mr. McClintock. You talk about the 
issues of our authorizing committees not being able to get the 
job done, how frustrating that is and how, frankly, negative 
that is. Yet your proposal deals with, in essence, 
appropriations, correct?
 For those that might not be clear, why is the 
appropriations process different than trying to force, for 
example, the authorizers who do not get their jobs done, with 
very few exceptions that do? Why the appropriations process? Is 
it the constitutional issue? If you would just very briefly 
explain that.
 Mr. McClintock. Well, because that is where the system is 
seizing up.
 To Mr. Bishop and Ms. McCollum's point, the President is 
not the central figure in the appropriations process, nor, for 
that matter, is the United States Senate. Appropriations begin 
in the House. The buck literally starts here.
 The process that we put into place in the 1974 Budget Act 
has the Appropriations Committee working through all of the 
discretionary spending once they are given a budget resolution 
with those limits by the Budget Committee--which very rarely 
gets done, too. That is a whole separate matter. The point is, 
your work you have always marked to the levels.
 You take these bills to the floor, we pass them after many, 
many hours of debate and amendment, and then they go over to 
the Senate. Now, what is supposed to happen in the Senate? The 
Senate is supposed to say--either send the bill back to us with 
their modifications or send it on to the President. If they 
send it back with their modifications, we either agree to those 
or we send it to a conference committee and we have a 
discussion with them.
 The problem is, the system seizes up when we send the bill 
over to the Senate. Without 60 votes, they cannot even take it 
up.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Yeah.
 Mr. McClintock. They do not send us their alternative. They 
do not send the bill to the President. It just sits there until 
the clock runs out. As I said, we are then given a Hobson's 
choice.
 That is the central problem that I see in the Budget Act. 
There are a lot of other issues----
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Yeah.
 Mr. McClintock [continuing]. As well, that get back to that 
question of political will. There is no way around that.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Let me now again--and, Senator, thank you 
for your leadership and for being here as well.
 Again, as I said to the Director, I am always fearful of 
off-ramps. That is not what you are doing, from what I see. You 
are actually trying to create a different pressure point.
 Senator Lankford. Right.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I get that.
 Let me then--the appropriations process cannot happen as a 
vacuum. The chairman talked about that, about the things that 
have to happen. The Budget Committee--et cetera. I am not going 
to restate that.
 How--and then, going back to some folks who really are more 
interested in being celebrities than legislators--right? 
Because I will tell you, there are some folks--I think 
Congresswoman Frankel brought up a very interesting point. 
Folks that maybe are close, they can go home regardless. Also, 
there are some folks that might relish being here, not to get 
things done--because if you actually look at, kind of, what the 
impediments are, it is usually a relatively small group of 
people, right? Some of those, frankly, are celebrities.
 How do you deal with that aspect, to not create a system 
that actually empowers celebrities even more to not get their 
job done but to just be on television more? Have you put some 
thought into that?
 Senator Lankford. I have, in the sense that--I remember 
saying to my constituents at home, ``I do not pick the people I 
work with. Other people pick the people I work with. I just 
have to figure out a way to be able to work with them.'' We 
have a wide variety of opinions in 535 Members, and some folks 
love their social-media feed more than they love anything else. 
I get that. That is just the reality of the society that we 
live in.
 My focus is, the pressure point should not be Federal 
workers and their families. That is what it is now. The 
argument is, we want to keep Federal workers and their families 
as the pressure point, and if we take that pressure point off 
and put the pressure on us, instead, to be stuck in a room with 
each other, ``We do not want that.'' My option is, if not this, 
what?
 I do understand the leverage issue. I have had this 
conversation. There are some Members that have more ability to 
be able to fly on their personal expense, to be able to come 
back and forth on it. I had somebody that serves on the West 
Coast that said, ``If you can move the Capitol to the West 
Coast, I am willing to support this proposal on it.'' I get 
that dynamic.
 My issue is, our constituents have to hold us to account to 
get the job done. If the law says, you have to be there and you 
have to stay until you get it done, we will push each other to 
try to figure out how to do that. We always have. The last CR 
got resolved when we all stayed over a weekend and we all said, 
that is not going to happen twice, and it got worked out.
 By the way, Mr. Chairman, if I can apologize, I am going to 
run, vote, and then come right back.
 The Chairman. We appreciate that very much. Again, thank 
you for your patience, thank you for your cooperation. The 
gentleman is excused.
 The gentlelady from New Jersey, Mrs. Watson Coleman, is 
recognized for any questions she may have.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. [Off-mike.]
 The Chairman. Oh. I apologize for that. He had to vote.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. I am going to ask--first of all, I am 
going to say that I agree with the Senators----
 The Chairman. Oh. The gentlelady, just so you know, he is 
going to come back. You will be allowed to----
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Okay. Thank you.
 The Chairman [continuing]. Pose your questions when he 
comes back.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Shall I wait?
 The Chairman. It is up to you. You are certainly free to 
use time now if you have other witnesses you want to--but you 
will be recognized again when he returns so you can have an 
opportunity to address your question.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. All right. I just have a quick 
question for Shalanda.
 The Chairman. Please.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. I want to thank you for being here.
 Congressman, thank you for being here.
 Thank you for the thoughts, and thank you for the fact that 
this is all about trying to get business done so that Federal 
workers and the people who depend upon the programs that would 
be supported would not be hurt. I love the premise of it. I 
just think we are not in normal times and we ought not be 
having this consideration right now.
 Shalanda, thank you for your thoughts.
 One thing has become clear to me during the discussion. 
Would not the logical conclusion of a permanent automatic CR 
leave discretionary funding, such as job training programs, 
food safety inspection, certain types of disease research, 
housing assistance, et cetera, and so much more, chronically 
underfunded already--leaving these vital programs anemic and 
ultimately inoperable in the long term?
 Can you speak to the impacts that multiple years of an 
automatic CR would have on the operation and the delivery of 
these very important programs?
 Ms. Young. You just have to look at a few programs. Pell 
grants comes to mind. Consistently shifting depending on how 
many Americans choose to go back to school. That typically 
happens when the economy starts to sour. Now we see billions of 
dollars in shortfall in Pell grant. Without this process, I do 
not know how we deal with a Pell shortfall other than an off-
ramp of going to the reconciliation route.
 Those are the kinds of things--housing vouchers. Again, not 
knowing--when the government does not know what the uptake will 
be. Often we are behind, and we see that the need outweighs the 
funding and we have to catch up.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Yeah.
 Ms. Young. Well, I would rather--we are always behind, but 
I would rather the catch-up be 6 months behind than 2 years 
behind if we remain in the same stale funding scenario.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. As not to use all of my time up, Mr. 
Chairman, I just want to say this one thing. One word I keep 
hearing over and over and over again is, we could do a better 
job if we had the ``will'' to do it. That will does not exist 
right now, and that is unfortunate.
 One of the things I loved about being in Appropriations is 
that we debated stuff. We did not always disagree--we did not 
always agree, but we did not always disagree.
 Now we disagree. The will to do our work on behalf of this 
country, our constituents, and even taking into consideration 
those who work for us, that will does not exist. We need to 
find a way to get it back.
 I temporarily, partially, whatever----
 Mr. Diaz-Balart [presiding]. Thank you. Thank you.
 Mr. Womack, you are recognized.
 Mr. Womack. All right. Thank you, Mr. Acting Chairman.
 Let me begin by saying, I have the utmost respect for the 
witnesses on this panel today. Senator Lankford and I served 
together on the Joint Select Committee on Budget Process Reform 
back in 2018, left at the altar because we had several 
Democrats that voted ``present'' instead of for the reforms 
that we--and, Ms. Young, you know that process very well 
because you were there.
 I have a tremendous amount of respect for my friend Tom 
McClintock out of California, who, in my opinion, based on what 
we have seen here today, has the only true, legitimate 
legislation that could actually fix the problem, or go a long 
way toward fixing the problem, by requiring expedited 
procedures in the Senate, where a lot of this is held up 
because of filibuster rules.
 Ms. Young, your credentials speak well for themselves. As a 
matter of fact, if this were a Fortune company and we were the 
board, we would probably just hire you to execute this budget 
process.
 Now here is, kind of, the funny thing about it all. If you 
were an alien and you landed across the street this morning and 
then stumbled into this hearing room to see what was going on 
with the legislative body of the greatest country in the 
history of the world and you found out that they were talking 
about fixing a budget process, you would have to come away 
scratching your head. That is exactly what is going on right 
now.
 It is a shame, it is embarrassing that this country--that 
the legislative body of this country that was written into 
Article I of the United States Constitution, in 2026, is having 
this conversation, 250 years after we were founded, but here we 
are.
 Mr. McClintock, as you heard me say, I think that your 
proposal, based on the way the 1974 Budget Act is written, is 
the only legitimate proposal that could actually get us off the 
dime because of the concept that elections have consequences. 
In the House, it is a simple majority.
 If this is our basic function--one of our truly basic 
functions is to draft a budget, which is a reflection of what 
the winners of the election would want to do with the budget of 
the United States of America--then yours, pretty much, is the 
only thing that actually forces the hand of Congress because it 
would give you a simple majority.
 Would you agree with that?
 Mr. McClintock. I think--of course I do. Thank you for 
those comments.
 It gets back to Mr. Hoyer's point. I think this makes the 
Congress more powerful, not less powerful, because it makes it 
more likely that the actual appropriations bills that express 
the will of the Congress will be presented to the President. 
Right now, it is a constant parade of continuing resolutions.
 The basic problem, though, is, these are hard decisions, 
and they are going to be imperfectly--in any body, they are 
going to be imperfectly addressed. Benjamin Franklin has that 
wonderful line from the Constitutional Convention where he 
pointed out that, when you draw a group of people together to 
benefit from their mutual wisdom, you also will inevitably get 
their mutual folly. You cannot expect a perfect response.
 Mr. Womack. While I----
 Mr. McClintock. The processes that we have are meant to 
guide us to the most perfect that we can make given our flaws 
as human beings.
 Mr. Womack. While I agree with the principal details of 
what your proposal is, I also happen to agree with others that 
have proposed that we do something to prevent the government, 
or the country, from going through the gymnastics of a 
potential government shutdown, a la what we did yesterday on 
the House floor by passing a CR that probably is not going to 
be lawful.
 I also believe this--and, Ms. Young, I am going to give you 
the last 30 seconds on this. As you know, I have a bill that 
kind of mirrors some of the work we did back in 2018 moving 
Congress to a biennial budget, because I think the calendar is 
also a problem in this situation. Would you agree?
 Ms. Young. You were in my opening remarks as one of the 
proposals--I have always thought that was just common sense. 
Because, at the time we worked on that joint select committee, 
that is how we were operating. We had 10-year budget caps from 
the days of the Obama Presidency and, we would come together 
every 2 years to actually enact real levels that the 
Appropriations Committees operate under, and we did those in 2-
year cycles. That is already how it was operating.
 I will say, to Chairman Cole's point, the budget resolution 
is not happening right now. Giving the budget resolution 2 
years, like--it is not like anything is coming out of the 
Budget Committee.
 Yours is common sense. It is more common sense if the 
budget resolution process was actually happening. I think that 
is a proposal that makes a lot of sense. You have recounted, 
kind of, how that discussion in the joint committee came about.
 I will say for the record, Mr. Acting Chairman, I need 
everyone to know, I am the co-chair of the Steve Womack Fan 
Club. There is almost no one who takes these issues as 
seriously as Steve Womack. We all want a solution.
 My problem is, the same political will that we think we are 
going to magically come up with in these 14 days of auto CR, 
where was that September 1st through 30th? Or where was that 
April 1st through 30th? I do not think it magically comes.
 My worry is--because I have seen the inner workings of 
White Houses, even though I love you all most because I grew up 
here--is, they will say--Presidents will say, ``Under this, can 
I do this, this, this, and this and this, OMB Director?'' ``Yes 
sir, you can.'' Then why would I do this that has these other 
three things I cannot stand? That is my worry.
 If we can create that political will in these 14-day 
cycles, let us figure out a way--if it is keeping people in 
town--to do that now and do the work.
 Mr. Womack. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your indulgence. I 
yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Well--and I am also on the Womack Fan 
Club, but that is not why he went over time.
 Ms. Underwood, you are recognized.
 Ms. Underwood. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 First, I would like to say welcome to my friend, Ms. 
Shalanda Young. As always, we are so lucky to have your 
expertise and your insight into the critical role of the 
appropriations process and exercising our Article I authority.
 Based on some of the comments that we have heard here 
today, it looks like my Republican colleagues have taken the 
exact wrong lesson from the unacceptable 43-day shutdown we 
experienced last year while they controlled the House, the 
Senate, and the White House.
 Instead of taking our constitutional responsibilities 
seriously by fixing the appropriations process that they have 
broken, they are considering legislation that would do even 
more damage to our system of checks and balances.
 For the last 18 months, President Trump has trampled on the 
separation of powers in the Constitution, illegally withholding 
and delaying funds that Congress appropriated. Instead of 
protecting our power of the purse, Republicans in Congress have 
sat on the sidelines cheering him on.
 I want to be very clear that the proposals here today do 
not solve the problems Republicans created. They do not protect 
Federal workers. They do not protect Federal resources our 
communities rely on. They do not protect the American people 
from the whims of an out-of-control President.
 Automatic continuing resolutions fail to address the 
changing needs of our districts. They fail to provide the 
Community Project Funding so sorely needed by our constituents. 
They fail to incorporate expert insights from Federal agencies. 
They fail to impose the oversight and guardrails needed when 
agencies like ICE and the U.S. Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) 
go rogue and murder people in our streets.
 Our constituents deserve a responsive and a deliberate 
Congress that can adapt to challenges in real-time and fund 
essential services and programs with specificity, with 
stability, and with accountability.
 I will not vote to hand Congress' power over to a President 
who thinks that he is a king.
 Now, since Ms. Young is the expert on this topic, I would 
like to offer my remaining time to her in case she had any 
additional comments.
 Ms. Young. Do not offer it up to any President.
 There is--I think we are in a singular moment. Things feel 
worse and different, but there is no President who gives power 
back to Congress.
 Ms. Underwood. Hmm.
 Ms. Young. If you do not take it, in a bipartisan way, 
back, no one is going to give it back to you.
 Everything I think about, I write about, I talk to students 
about, they go, ``I thought we got a former OMB Director. Why 
do you keep talking to us about Congress?'' I sat and listened 
to a constitutional law professor tell us all the things wrong 
with the judiciary and the Presidency, and my only question to 
him was: Well, what about Congress? We just accept that it is 
broken, and we find these workarounds, and a lot of times, it 
comes from the body itself.
 I do not wax poetic about the past a lot, because I think 
that is a waste of time. Times move on. We are in the political 
moment we are in. However, we have got to figure out--and I 
think this committee is central to it--figure out a way to hold 
hands and do the hard work.
 This committee has always done it. You have the numbers to 
do it. One of my reform ideas is, maybe this committee has to 
be bigger, since all the focus tends to be on the 
appropriations process because it gums up the works of the 
House. If more Members were involved--maybe. That probably will 
not work.
 It is the idea of thinking larger than when you get to 
shutdowns. Do you know how many things have failed----
 Ms. Underwood. That is right.
 Ms. Young [continuing]. Before we got there? Let us start 
further up the road, than try to deal with the symptom of lots 
of problems that lots of people are responsible for.
 Ms. Underwood. Well, thank you, Ms. Young.
 I do believe that we can get there in a positive resolution 
that continues to maintain the Congress' Article I 
responsibilities to continue to protect our power of the purse 
and to continue to assert the Congress' authority in directing 
Federal spending.
 I hope that, as a bipartisan Appropriations Committee here 
in the House, we can commit ourselves to finding that path 
forward.
 I thank you for being here as a witness today.
 Ms. Young. Thank you.
 Ms. Underwood. Mr. McClintock, it is nice to see you as 
well.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentlelady.
 Dr. Harris, you are recognized, sir.
 Dr. Harris. Thank you very much.
 I want to thank all of you for being here.
 I will tell you, we are just applying a tourniquet to a 
hemorrhaging wound that is hemorrhaging more every year. I have 
been here long enough. Now, look, 2 years ago, did we celebrate 
the 50th anniversary of the Budget Act? No, because it has 
failed. Let us just admit it. Why do we not just admit to 
ourselves we actually need to redo the Budget Act? It does not 
work. It has not worked for decades. It has not worked since I 
have been here, 16 years.
 No wonder, because the size of the Federal government, the 
discretionary budget, has more than doubled since that Budget 
Act was passed--more than doubled. $730 billion, in today's 
dollars, then; we are now at $1.6 trillion. The bottom line is, 
these budgets have become too complicated to get done given the 
limited bandwidth of both the executive branch and the 
legislative branch.
 I will tell you--and, Ms. Young, you are absolutely right, 
we are just doing workarounds. The idea of a 2-year budget 
cycle for the budget--why do we not do 2-year appropriations? 
There are some States that do 2-year appropriations. We meet 
every year; if we have to adjust something, we can adjust it. 
At least half the government does not close on October 1st 
and--except with the exception of defense.
 The idea that we somehow--that a 1-year NDAA works and that 
a 1-year budgetary cycle works is ridiculous. The Ukraine war 
has--if the Ukraine government had an NDAA that they passed a 
year ago that said what drone they have to buy and did not give 
authority to the Minister of Defense there for stop/starts, 
they would have lost the war in that year.
 When it comes to--and, Ms. Young, you have said it 
absolutely right. The only real authorization--the real 
authorization bill that affects the discretionary budget every 
year is NDAA. Everything else, we do not really change the law 
that often. Why are we changing the appropriation every year on 
schedule, when we could, in fact, change it every 2 years for 
everything but defense?
 I will argue that, in defense, we do have to give the 
executive branch more stop/start authority, because we will 
otherwise freeze ourselves and we will have a technology freeze 
that will serve us very poorly in defense and wars going 
forward.
 I do think that we should consider it. We should--again, we 
should--look, the 1974 act has failed. We should start talking 
about how to replace it given the current state of affairs and 
the size and scope of the Federal government and the advancing 
technology in defense.
 I will tell you that there is another option we have not 
talked about, the True Shutdown Fairness Act, which is kind of 
the compromise of--Senator Lankford is not here; I was going to 
ask him about it--where you pay the workers but you do not pay 
everything that is non-defense-related contractual.
 I know--and I am going to ask you, Mr. McClintock, to 
comment on this. Because, as we have grown the Federal 
government, we have a lot of grants, we have a lot of things 
that go out that are not contractual. If we just pay--because 
the workers should not get in the middle of this. We should 
figure out what actually has to be done to keep the government 
functioning safely and preserve those in a--if we go to a 
Shutdown Fairness or no-shutdown act, whatever you want to call 
it.
 That would leave some leverage over the government to 
actually do something. The workers would be paid, but grants 
would not be going out. There would be plenty of pressure on 
us.
 Mr. McClintock, if you can just mention, within the scope 
of government, why do we not subdivide some of that out?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, ``the fault, dear Brutus, lies not in 
our stars but in ourselves, that we are underlings.'' The 
Budget Act has not failed. We have failed to apply the Budget 
Act.
 There is a story that Newt Gingrich tells. At a time when a 
Republican Congress and a Democrat President balanced four 
budgets in a row, during a leadership meeting, John Kasich, the 
Budget chairman, slams his fist on the table and says, ``You 
show me where it is written in stone that we have to balance 
the budget.'' Well, the next meeting, Gingrich brings in a 
stone tablet inscribed, ``Thou shalt balance the budget,'' and 
they did.
 Again, that is our responsibility. Now, we may have a lot--
as Ms. Underwood says--a lot of concerns over how that money is 
being spent. We do not get to spend the money. We get to 
appropriate. The President gets to spend it. We need to get 
back to our job of appropriations.
 Dr. Harris. All right. Well, thank you very----
 Mr. McClintock. That means getting past that blockage in 
the Senate.
 Dr. Harris. Thank you very much.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman.
 Ms. Kaptur, you are recognized.
 Ms. Kaptur. Thank you. Thank you so much. I had to find the 
button for the mike.
 Let me thank the chair and Ranking Member DeLauro, Chairman 
Cole and Ranking Member DeLauro, for this hearing, and to each 
of our witnesses and guests today.
 Actually, continuing resolutions represent this legislative 
branch's major breach of its Article I constitutional 
responsibility.
 The executive branch aids, abets, and even coerces this 
broken process even more, pressuring lawmakers to acquiesce to 
its will. It is very dangerous, indeed, what is going on.
 I also have served on the Budget Committee throughout my 
career many, many times over my Federal service, and at this 
moment, there is no budget from the Budget Committee to guide 
the Appropriations Committee, and we are being sent home.
 In addition, for the record, I have counted the number of 
days the current House Speaker has sent House Members back home 
since the beginning of the year without Congress' budget and 
appropriations work being done under regular order. It is close 
to 50 days, and that does not count what we are going to be 
sent home for now.
 Meanwhile, Federal workers and contractors, from air 
controllers to employees at our Veterans Administration and 
veterans homes have faced uncertainty and literally chaos. They 
cannot hire. They have to furlough.
 The executive branch takes full note and executes its power 
grab of spending across accounts. At this moment, as a Nation 
at war, which has not been declared, can you imagine the 
musical chairs being employed by the executive branch shifting 
defense accounts from one spending category to another, to 
others?
 No one here can explain what the Department of Defense has 
been doing, including the Department of Defense.
 I am concerned that Congress is acquiescing the automatic 
congressional CRs that kick the ball to the sideline--the big 
balls--while further empowering the executive branch.
 Let me focus on our defense-planning preparedness and 
procurement.
 At this moment in history, our Nation's defense requires 
replenishment--replenishment. Failing to give stable, 
predictive guidance and funding to industry makes it remarkably 
difficult to build ships, complex systems, or catch up to 
technological advancement where our country has lost edge.
 The Trump Administration has come before this very 
committee in recent weeks asking for more long-term defense 
planning and procurement. I am pretty astounded that we might 
consider going in the opposite direction, making it less likely 
that the regular appropriations process can go forward.
 As a Member of the Defense Subcommittee, I wanted to direct 
a question to Ms. Young and thank her for her service to our 
country.
 Can you explain to us what kind of an impact continuing 
resolutions have on our ability to plan for our Nation's 
defense?
 Continuing resolutions also impede our ability to address 
new challenges that arise and require timely congressional 
input.
 When it comes to automatic CRs, are there any 
constitutional, implications given the clause that no 
appropriation of money to raise and support armies shall be 
longer than 2 years?
 I am very concerned about what is happening at the U.S. 
Department of Defense, and I wonder if you could comment on 
this.
 Ms. Young. Sure. I think I gave some examples about what 
happens under long-term CRs, including the inability to do 
long-term procurement and fix problems that arise throughout 
the year, so I will not repeat those.
 The Army Clause in the Constitution obviously says that 
Congress is not supposed to appropriate Army for more than 2 
years at a time. At the time the Constitution was written, we 
can probably think back as to why the Founders and the writers 
of the Constitution did not want an Army that could rise up 
without the express approval and funding of the United States 
Congress.
 I think it is an interesting constitutional question that I 
would hope, as this legislation is thought about, some 
constitutional scholars weigh in.
 The Solicitor General, I believe, in 1904, we all live 
under ``his'' opinion--and I am assuming it is a ``his'' 
because it was 1904--that the part of the Constitution--or the 
defense appropriations that deals with that part of the 
Constitution is only military personnel, not procurement, not 
research.
 Again, I think if this was enacted, all of it would raise 
new constitutional questions and probably find their way into a 
court, like every other budget and appropriations item that has 
found their way into a court.
 The things we thought were law now judges are deciding what 
is constitutional, and not in the budget and appropriations 
space in a way we just have not seen this level of litigation.
 It probably will end up in litigation like lots of other 
things we have seen in the past year, to see if it violates the 
Army Clause of the Constitution.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart [presiding]. Yield back?
 Ms. Kaptur. I yield back for the moment. I hope we have a 
second round. Thank you. I did not get a chance, Mr. Chairman, 
to thank Senator Lankford and Congressman McClintock for whom I 
have very deep respect.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Well, thank you for doing that.
 We thank, again, Senator, I know that you ran and came 
back, so we are very grateful for that.
 Mr. Fleischmann, you are recognized, sir.
 Mr. Fleischmann. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and to the 
distinguished witnesses.
 Senator, you were my classmate in 2010 in the House and my 
neighbor. Always a privilege to serve with you there and in 
this capacity as well, and I thank you for your efforts. Of 
course you know I am a cosponsor of this bill.
 I did want to recognize the other two distinguished guests.
 Mr. McClintock, great, great friend. Thank you for your 
efforts in this regard. The accolades that you received are 
well deserved for the way that you have conducted yourself in 
our body.
 As for Ms. Young, thank you, not only for your work at OMB, 
but for your work with this committee. I remember very well, 
ma'am, when you acceded to the position at OMB, the tremendous 
bipartisan feelings of joy for you to get that. Thank you, and 
thank you for continuing this process, all three of you all.
 Again, my question will be for Senator Lankford. Again, a 
proud cosponsor of the Prevent Government Shutdowns Act. In my 
view, this bill solves many problems without letting Congress 
get off the hook.
 I firmly believe that we should never shut the Federal 
government down. Rarely do I get animated, but I did on several 
national TV outlets, both progressive, conservative, and in the 
middle, when we went through that government shutdown.
 It is just wrong to the American people. It hurts the 
institution, and it hurt families, so hopefully we get there.
 My question for you, Senator, you first introduced this 
legislation back in 2011. Can you speak on how the shutdown 
landscape has changed since then and why you believe this 
moment represents the best opportunity for Congress to finally 
enact a permanent solution, sir.
 Senator Lankford. Representative Fleischmann, thank you so 
much for your work on this as well.
 I have come a long way since 2011. When I first came in 
2011 and sat in the House, I saw the government shutdowns 
happening, and I jumped in and said there has got to be some 
way to be able to fix this.
 They have gotten longer. They have gotten more frequent 
since that time period. I have had multiple different 
iterations. There was an iteration I had initially that was, if 
we have a shutdown, then the budget gets cut by 1 percent until 
we keep doing it.
 Well, guess what, I never had a single Democratic colleague 
ever get on that bill on it.
 We had multiple different iterations on this. Then it was 
about 7 years ago I sat down with a Democratic colleague, 
Maggie Hassan, and said we have got to figure out a way that is 
a nonpartisan way to be able to solve this.
 That is where it was born, to be able to figure out how do 
we actually put pressure not on Federal workers, which has been 
interesting to me in the dialogue even here today.
 It was, if we change the current status quo of not paying 
Federal workers while we go home, that is going to be bad. I am 
like, no, that is bad. What we are currently doing, the status 
quo, is what is bad. Is that we, for months, will get our pay. 
We will go home and see our families. We will work on other 
bills and things, while Federal workers and their families 
cannot pay their mortgage.
 We have got to fix this. If this proposal is not the right 
proposal, let us work on one that is. That is why I am so 
grateful this committee has got a full committee. This is the 
heart of the body to be able to solve this problem, is right 
here, and it has got to be solved in a bipartisan way. That is 
the way we have to be able to solve big, hard, complicated 
things like this, and it has to be an agreement from Congress.
 This proposal has shifted over the years to multiple 
different iterations. That is why I mentioned before, Shalanda 
Young had this at OMB. She actually did the technical 
assistance for this bill when she was with the Biden 
Administration. Now this OMB has done technical assistance for 
it as well.
 We have tried to work through several iterations because we 
are not trying to make a message. We are trying to solve a 
problem on this. The problem is, we stop paying Federal 
workers, we go home and pretend things will get better at some 
point. They do not for them, and it is bad for the country.
 As I agree completely with you on that, we look terrible on 
the world stage on this as everyone tries to figure out what is 
wrong with the Americans, while we have a government shutdown.
 Mr. Fleischmann. I want to thank you for your answer.
 Once again, my compliments to all three of you all for 
tackling this arduous issue.
 In my remaining seconds, very quickly, Senator, this goes 
beyond--this bill goes beyond simply avoiding a shutdown. It 
pairs the automatic continuing appropriation with real 
accountability measures, including restricted travel and a 23-
hour limit on recess.
 Can you speak to why these provisions were important to 
include and how they ensure this bill does not just paper over 
the problem, but actually pushes Congress to finish its 
appropriation work?
 By the way, I agree with this.
 Senator Lankford. Yeah, thank you.
 By the way, the focus of this is not to have long-term CRs. 
It has been interesting, some of the dialogue today has been, 
well, this is going to put us into a perpetual CR.
 If we are all here 7 days a week, as required by law--we 
cannot travel, we only can recess for 23 hours, we have got to 
get back together every single day, House and Senate--if we 
have to be here every day, we will get our work done, because 
we will find a way to be able to solve a problem.
 This sense of we will just never do appropriations again, 
also means we never do another bill, because this bill actually 
prevents us from moving to anything but appropriations.
 The real focus is, you can only do appropriations. You are 
here every single day until you solve the problem. When you 
solve the problem, you can go home.
 I cannot even imagine this body not trying to say we have 
got to get on focus, let us solve this problem, because I do 
need to get to a birthday party, I do need to get to my family, 
I do need to get to CODELs and responsibility.
 This is far from a perpetual CR that some are saying. This 
is a focus of we are here till we solve the problem, and we 
will get the problem solved.
 Mr. Fleischmann. Senator, thank you.
 Also, to the entire panel, my profound thanks.
 Yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Thank you.
 We are going to go back to Mrs. Watson Coleman because she 
was very efficient and kept 2 minutes of her time still.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Well, thank you.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. You are recognized for 2 minutes.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you, Senator. You were walking 
out the door, and I am saying, I have got a question for him.
 Senator Lankford. Oh, I apologize.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. First of all, let me just say that I 
appreciate the motivation behind this. I agree with you that we 
need to do better, we need to do our job, and we ought to be 
inconvenienced when we do not.
 Senator Lankford. Right.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. I think, however, this issue of will 
is important, particularly in what I consider to be these non-
normal moments of governance. I am not sure that people would 
not stare us down for 10 days, 12 days, or whatever, and still 
not come to any conclusion.
 Nonetheless, I do not want to give up any of our authority 
because I think that we have been giving up congressional 
authority to this President's second term in a way that is 
shameful.
 I wanted to just ask you, if we do take our jobs as 
appropriators seriously, I cannot imagine why we would consider 
making permanently a tool that renders our committee's work 
unnecessary.
 How exactly would this automatic continuing resolution 
proposal encourage the kind of debate and consideration and 
respect for one another and each other's differences? How would 
we accomplish those necessary negotiations?
 Senator Lankford. Thank you for the very honest question on 
that. I really appreciate that.
 What happens under this proposal, and what Senator Hassan 
and I have agreed to on this, is the way to put pressure on 
Members of Congress to actually get our work done is that we 
all have to be able to remain here to be able to get our work 
done.
 The focus of this, especially by saying we cannot move to 
bills other than appropriations, puts the pressure on doing 
appropriations work.
 Literally, the goal of this bill was not to have a CR. Now, 
we are about to have our 30th year in a row of having CRs. I do 
not like CRs either, but I hate shutdowns more.
 The goal of this is to have, if we have a shutdown at all, 
it is short, and everybody has to drop everything and finish 
appropriations.
 When appropriations is done, then we can go back to 
everything else--our families, other legislation, other 
committees.
 If we have not done our constitutional responsibility of 
appropriations, we have to stop everything until that is done, 
because that is the first priority in the Constitution, for us 
to be able to accomplish that.
 I am a former Appropriations Committee member. I want to 
make sure this committee is actually empowered to be able to do 
its task. I am trying to draw a box around everything else to 
say nothing else gets done until this gets done.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you, Senator.
 Senator Lankford. It is literally empowering this 
committee.
 Mrs. Watson Coleman. Thank you.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Thank you.
 Mrs. Hinson, you are recognized.
 Mrs. Hinson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for holding 
this hearing today to our Chairman Cole.
 Thank you to our witnesses. It is a great discussion, a 
really important one, and I think the American people are 
certainly frustrated watching how this place does its business.
 I am encouraged by the fact that you all are here at the 
table, joining with us to try to solve this very important 
problem.
 We did see last year the longest shutdown in government 
history. It was incredibly destructive. Not only did it 
threaten our food assistance programs, it disrupted a lot of 
travel--we all saw those TSA lines--and it put our national 
security at risk, which I think is unacceptable.
 We saw people in both Chambers really choosing political 
theater over American families through that process. I do not 
want to see that happen going forward. I, again, appreciate the 
possible solutions here to avoid government shutdowns and all 
these proposals.
 Senator, you mentioned, hey, maybe yours is not the right 
one. Maybe it is. Maybe we need just more conversation around 
these things, and Congressman McClintock as well. I am 
encouraged by this discussion across the board.
 I wanted to ask you a question, Director Young. Thank you 
for coming. It is nice to see you again.
 My question for you, because I know that we have talked 
about the cost of government shutdowns--they do cost a 
significant amount of money. They are fiscally irresponsible, 
and they are inefficient, as are even the threat of a shutdown 
happening. You talked about that day, September 30, a couple of 
years ago when you were headed into the office to go through 
the process.
 Can you tell us a little bit more about what even the 
threat of a process of shutting down looks like? What motions 
do you have to go through at OMB to make that happen?
 Ms. Young. I said we did not shut down, but I did not tell 
you we did not spend a lot of time preparing, right?
 Mrs. Hinson. Yeah.
 Ms. Young. Because all the deals came through on the last 
day and hours possible, on the phone. You sure you got a time 
agreement in the Senate? Like, we are putting ourselves out 
here not to do an orderly shutdown.
 It requires each and every agency not only to develop the 
plans, but they have to start communicating with the staff. How 
traumatic, like, you do not know if the next day you leave your 
tools at the--because you are not supposed to answer any 
government phone.
 You have to tell grantees, you have to tell Federal 
employees, you have to tell contractors, and they are all 
waiting for this do we have a new Pope smoke to see if a deal 
is not. It is not without consequences to get to the threshold.
 We have talked today about how bad shutdowns are. Secondary 
to that are CRs, because I do not want to leave this room 
either thinking CRs are the panacea either.
 The regular appropriations bills are the goal and always 
have been the goal of this committee and should be the gold 
standard of Congress, and preferably on time, which we have not 
gotten all of that done since long before my time.
 Mrs. Hinson. Well, at least I am proud of the committee's 
work because in the past two appropriation cycles we have 
gotten all 12 bills through committee, and we are working on 
getting them over the floor for the second year in a row. Of 
course with the fiscal year being only 2 months away from 
ending, it is certainly challenging with the timetable.
 When you think about--you talked a little bit about kind of 
the planning that has to happen. Do you feel like culture 
across the board in many of our departments--many of these 
people are really experts in their field, life-long employees 
who are valuable contributors to government service--do you 
feel like shutdown culture is pervasive, they know this is 
coming and they just kind of shrug? Or is the frustration 
palpable to you?
 Ms. Young. The hope is you can prevent it, right? During 
the 4 years I was at OMB, we did not shut down. They had some 
hope, like, we would come out on the other side and they would 
come to work the next day.
 It is not a surety that you end up in the worst case 
scenario, but it is quite destabilizing.
 Look, you have it in your own office to tell somebody they 
are essential or not essential. Especially at an agency level, 
it also presents a morale problem.
 I have managed it from the congressional side, and I have 
managed it from the agency side, my own agency, not just the 
Federal government and the orderly operations.
 It presents a morale problem even preparing for it, because 
I have to tell somebody, your job is important. Well, all jobs 
are important. We just try to take the narrowest view possible 
to try to stay on the right side of the law.
 It is a morale bust when you have to go through this 
process for many reasons.
 Mrs. Hinson. Well, and I visited many of my Federal Student 
Aid (FSA) offices in the district where they talk about the 
struggles they already have with hiring personnel and how long 
it takes to get that process done. All of that is hit paused 
and delayed further.
 Our farmers are not getting the services they need. TSA has 
trouble recruiting and retaining employees if they are not 
getting paid and they are having to show up to work every day.
 I thank our witnesses for coming today, and I look forward 
to engaging and working on this problem so we can find a 
solution that does not play politics with government shutdowns.
 Thank you. I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Great. Thank you for yielding.
 Ms. Meng, you are recognized.
 Ms. Meng. Thank you so much.
 Thank you to all of our witnesses for being here too and 
for your work and this dialogue.
 I wanted to ask--and any of you are welcome to answer--
under this current administration, how has OMB Director Vought 
approached the legal requirements of our budget process? How is 
it different from maybe previous administrations, even under 
the first Trump Administration?
 Ms. Young. I am not going there, so you all----
 Mr. McClintock. Obviously they have been late in submitting 
budgets to the Congress. Again, as I said earlier, they are not 
the central player in the appropriations process.
 The chief executive is there to tell us how much he thinks 
he is going to need to faithfully execute the laws, to run the 
government. It is up to us to tell him how much we are willing 
to appropriate to him.
 Now, the Congress appropriates but cannot spend. The 
President spends but cannot appropriate. That separation of 
powers is central to the concept of good governance going back 
to Magna Carta.
 We need to focus on our responsibility to appropriate, and 
that is where we have an impediment that I think we can remove.
 Ms. Meng. Anyone else?
 Senator Lankford. Yeah, I would just say, obviously Russ 
Vought was also in the first Trump Administration as well as 
the second. It is hard for me to be able to say day-to-day 
operations there because I am not in day-to-day operations.
 Clearly the first year, very late in getting the budget 
over, which is typical for a President when they actually come 
in the first year, I think President Biden was as well on that, 
just because you are just getting your staff hired and trying 
to be able to get going.
 Also, as already mentioned by Chairman Cole, it is 
important to be able to get those numbers. As Representative 
McClintock mentioned as well, those numbers are the request 
from the President and the President's budget.
 In the 1974 Budget Act, they are supposed to be in on time, 
but this body actually determines--House and Senate--determines 
what is going to actually come out legislatively.
 It has to originate in the House. Literally this committee 
is the one who actually kicks it off first.
 Ms. Meng. I do not know, Director Young, if you want to 
offer any input even of differences.
 Ms. Young. Is it proper to comment on your own operations?
 Look, I mentioned this earlier, and I think it is true, I 
am the OMB Director, you have had Members of Congress, like 
Leon Panetta, who is the Budget chair. It is all, from a Member 
perspective, very different.
 I think having a staff director of the Appropriations 
Committee, even from a Member who had been chair of Budget, go. 
I think what that gave me was a perspective of, I knew what you 
needed. I knew your districts. Every government program, I 
would go, whose district is that?
 I had 15 years of that baked in. There was no way, as OMB 
Director, I would not consider how that impacted your 
constituents.
 I am from south Louisiana. I do not do red and blue, and 
certainly not in a job like OMB. While I worked for a 
Democratic President, I worked for Democratic Members, I have, 
and I believe I approached that job, a responsibility to make 
sure we are answering the mail for our constituents.
 I think of disaster response. It does not matter who 
represents them in the Senate and who represents them in the 
House. If there is a need--and thankfully I worked for a 
President who spent a long time in the Senate and I did not 
have to convince him that was the right way to approach the 
job.
 You have got someone who is predisposed, I think, to not 
bypass the system.
 Ms. Meng. Yeah. Thank you so much, and sorry to rush you 
all.
 I just wanted to ask one more question. Speaking about 
local districts, there is always a concern that these automatic 
types of procedures or process would freeze out benefits to 
local districts.
 For example, under an automatic CR, no new Community 
Project Funding, including local infrastructure and public 
safety projects, would be able to be enacted into law. Is that 
correct?
 Senator Lankford. That is correct. If I can just make one 
comment on that. We are hopefully going to get a continuing 
resolution. That is not our best-case scenario, but that is 
better than the worst-case scenario of a shutdown coming up.
 That will start September the 1st. That kicks it all the 
way into November, let us say, before we actually get 
appropriations done.
 What I am recommending is, instead of having a 2-month CR, 
it would be 2-week, and we have to get all the work done at 
that point, and we all have to be here.
 At this point, we are punting all this, and we are saying 
we will deal with this in November. That is very different than 
you do not leave until it is done.
 I totally agree that is how a CR works, but the goal of 
this is to not have a shutdown. Second best to having 
appropriations is having at least the government still 
operating, but we are all still here while we have to get this 
resolved. Hopefully CRs would be much shorter in the days 
ahead.
 Ms. Meng. Yeah. I am just concerned that that 2 weeks could 
keep getting extended under the bill.
 Senator Lankford. It could if you want to stay here forever 
with Chairman Cole, and be able to be here week after week 
after week with all of our colleagues here.
 By the way, Chairman Cole is a great guy to hang out with.
 It is just, we all want to be able to get home and see our 
families and do other responsibilities. If we are in a position 
where we have to legally stay here, and you cannot move to any 
other bill but appropriations, that is the incentive built in 
to get appropriations worked on.
 Ms. Meng. Okay. Thank you. I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Great. Thank you.
 Mrs. Bice, you are recognized.
 Mrs. Bice. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Thank the witnesses for being here this morning, slash, now 
afternoon.
 Shutdowns are bad for the American people, and more 
frequently Members will take votes to close government from a 
political standpoint.
 I have thousands of dedicated civilian employees in my 
district, and glad that we at least passed a CR last night to 
hopefully avoid another government shutdown.
 During the last shutdown, I had a constituent stop me in 
the airport, and he said his son had taken a job a few months 
earlier with the TSA. He was wondering why his son would do a 
job where a paycheck is not guaranteed. This is a 20-something-
year-old young man, single, trying to get out on his own.
 Yes, those government employees are made whole, but on the 
back end, when you have rent and utilities and bills to pay, it 
can become incredibly difficult.
 I am incredibly thankful for the work that my Senator, 
Senator Lankford, has done to try to address this issue, and I 
am incredibly thankful for the work that Representative 
McClintock has done on the Budget Control Act.
 Let me start with you if I can. The Budget Control Act was 
passed in 1974. Things have changed just a little bit since 
those days. Are there other things that we should be 
considering as we look to try to make sure that the budget 
process and our appropriations work is done in a timely 
fashion?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, as I said earlier, whatever process 
we use is not going to make the decisions any easier, and every 
year that goes by and we go deeper in debt, those decisions 
become more and more difficult.
 I continue to believe that the budget process outlined in 
the 1974 Budget Act is methodical, it is logical. The problem 
is, we just do not follow it because it requires hard 
decisions. That is on us.
 We cannot--there is that one impediment, though, that we 
keep running into. Even without fulfilling the budget process 
as envisioned by the Budget Act, the Appropriations Committee, 
this committee, has still established--or received--302 budget 
instructions, marked to those instructions, sent those bills 
on.
 We have spent endless hours debating and amending them on 
the floor. We send them over to the Senate, and nothing happens 
because a minority is able to block that, for lack of cloture.
 Again, this is not a cure-all. The two houses are still 
going to disagree. There will still be other impediments. At 
least that one impediment is removed, and perhaps we can get 
back to the process as it was envisioned.
 We have evolved this legislative process over two and a 
half centuries, and it is very good at resolving differences 
between the two houses when we use it. We have to use it.
 Mrs. Bice. Thank you for that, and I am proud to be a 
cosponsor of your legislation as well.
 I want to pivot to you, Ms. Young. You briefly touched on 
this earlier. Excluding the chicken and the egg problem, during 
your time at OMB, what was the biggest pain point in getting 
the President's budget submitted in a timely fashion?
 Ms. Young. Look, besides the chicken and the egg, which I 
think I could do the same thing Congress could do. I could 
ignore Congress' numbers, I can go there late. We are just 
going to go ahead.
 What happens is, we are then told, that is incredibly 
unhelpful, because you get a President's budget that is not 
compared to what reality is.
 I have literally had budgets go out as you all are 
finishing approps. I am then required to send supplemental 
tables from every agency because the appropriators, you guys, 
need to see real comparisons, and I appreciate that.
 Putting that to the side, seeing OMB and the White House 
and agencies and the 50,000 million priorities that happen, 
oftentimes you have to remind them that it is the law and a 
priority to put this together.
 Just like the budget resolution process faded because it 
was tough, my fear in Presidents' budgets is we are headed that 
direction.
 I fought very hard to have full budgets, mandatory, 
revenue, discretionary. What have you gotten the last cycle? A 
discretionary budget? No one screamed, and I bet you, you are 
going to get just discretionary. Every time an easier path and 
no one really squeals, that is what the system is going to do.
 Shalanda, at OMB in the future, will I win an argument that 
says our responsibility is to put a full budget that shows all 
spending, all revenues? I am going to lose that argument, 
because they are going to say: The last President did not have 
to do that, why do we have to take those bullets and arrows?
 Mrs. Bice. It sort of speaks to, Representative McClintock, 
we are taking the easy path to be able to try to address this, 
and sometimes the easiest pass is either punting or not 
adhering to the Budget Control Act provisions.
 With that, thank you for being here today.
 Special shout-out to my Senator. I am thrilled that you are 
working on this important legislation and appreciate your time.
 With that, I yield.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Thank you so much.
 Mr. Espaillat.
 Mr. Espaillat. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
 Thank you, Senator, Member, and Shalanda, thank you. Good 
to see you again.
 Shutdowns are horrible, right? The general public, the rest 
of the world, see us as dysfunctional. People get hurt.
 Continuing resolutions are not necessarily either the best 
solution to this budget issue, right?
 I tell you what I feel is just as bad. The winner-take-all 
attitude and the extreme budget decisions that either side 
makes present a scenario where it is difficult to build 
consensus and get this done.
 Imagine how the world looks at us when we cut food stamps, 
for example. That could very well be that it is something 
around $7 and change per person, per day. Imagine when a mom is 
hurt because in 1 of our 12 separate appropriations processes 
we present a scenario where they will be hurt that way--or 
other meritorious programs for the American people.
 I think that the extreme positions that we take make it 
impossible for us to reach consensus. The winner-take-all 
attitude presents a major obstacle for us to get this done, and 
then we have to resort to either a shutdown or a continuing 
resolution which is--both are not the best scenario.
 I think that unless we decide to be more flexible and 
understand that there is a middle road somewhere where we can 
all live and protect our point of views, we are going to 
continue in this direction.
 My question is to Ms. Young. As the Ranking Member of the 
Legislative Branch Subcommittee, I have met and heard concerns 
from Capitol Police officers.
 It has been a growing concern that the U.S. Capitol Police 
continues to lose staff to other law enforcement agencies that 
can offer higher pay and benefits as violence, right, and the 
threat of violence continues to hover above us--Members, staff, 
and visitors in this campus.
 This is a real issue that could have a devastating impact 
on the campus.
 Having served as Director of the Office of Management and 
Budget, you understand how continuing resolutions affect 
agencies' abilities to plan and manage their operation.
 What risk would Congress create if the Department were 
required to operate under an automatic CR for an extended 
period of time while staffing shortages and security demands 
continue to evolve?
 This is something right here on campus, right? We have seen 
it play out on different scenarios and theaters. What do you 
see?
 Ms. Young. Well, long before I was OMB Director, I was the 
clerk to the Legislative Branch Subcommittee. It is near and 
dear, and the Capitol Police are near and dear.
 It was always hard to recruit, and it has gotten harder, 
and obviously there are morale problems.
 Look, you have heard what I believe happens in an automatic 
CR scenario where a few people who see the year-long bills as 
something they would rather not have happen for whatever 
reason, whether it be a President, a few Senators, or a few 
House Members, that we have no way out of that do loop. 
Fourteen days becomes 28.
 Think about before election season, if there is something 
hard to deal with--like immigration has always been difficult--
what happens? You take tough votes, you put the House and 
Senate in that position, or do you say, I have this thing that 
allows me not to do that? That is my fear.
 Senator Lankford is right, he has quorum call every day for 
the Senate. I do not see that for the House. My fear again is, 
I see a provision that says that it is an order to have a bed 
check basically for the House. It does not dictate for the 
House in the same way it dictates for the Senate in the bill.
 My worry is that, especially in election years, we end up 
just the automatic CR becomes something we have to live with 
for a very long time.
 Mr. Espaillat. Thank you.
 Again, Senator and Congress Member, unless we deal with the 
culture of this place and our inability to talk to each other 
and reach consensus, this is a difficult endeavor.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman.
 Mr. Ciscomani, you are recognized, sir.
 Mr. Ciscomani. Thank you, Chairman.
 I want to, first of all, thank all three of you for being 
here and for giving us so much of your time. I think it has 
been a fascinating discussion on the solutions and also 
reiterating the problem.
 I think we have gone down the line in terms of explaining 
what the issue is, the problem that we are all trying to fix, 
and I think everybody agrees on what the problem is. The 
difference, of course, is going to come into the solution that 
we are proposing here.
 I have been here for three and a half years. I came in, in 
January of 2023, and so I have lived through a few of these 
moments both from, it was explained, Speaker McCarthy coming to 
an agreement and that potentially costing him the Speakership, 
to actually the longest shutdown in U.S. history, followed by a 
partial shutdown.
 We see the problems. I can read stats of how it has 
impacted my district, $1.3 billion per month in lost gross 
State product, disruption in Supplemental Nutrition Assistance 
Program (SNAP) benefits, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program 
for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) benefits, not to mention 
TSA has been mentioned before, and so on. I think we get that.
 Now, what is one of the most frustrating parts for me after 
being here for the period of time that I have been is the 
blaming on both sides. It happened under other leadership when 
I was here--before I was here, now this.
 There is a problem. There is a problem that has not been 
fixed. We could argue on who is the main responsible person 
depending on the year.
 This is the reality that I think we are trying to get to, 
and that I strongly believe that this is the case: The pain of 
a shutdown should be felt primarily by this body----
 Senator Lankford. That is true.
 Mr. Ciscomani [continuing]. And not by the people at home, 
because they are not the ones that have failed. It is the 
people that work in this building--specifically the Members--
that have been elected. That is where the pain should be felt 
for any shutdown.
 I withheld my pay. As long as people in my district and my 
office were not getting paid, I was not getting paid either. 
That is just a small part of what needs to happen in terms of 
everyone in the building making decisions to get us into a 
shutdown, to participate in that pain and to actually be the 
ones feeling the pain, not the people at home.
 My question is two, and I hope I can get to them real quick 
here.
 Ms. Young, the way that we have explained this--and I 
really appreciate your perspective because you have been in the 
practical sense of this thing working on it, and I think you 
have given a very thoughtful response to all this.
 The guardrails that have kept the shutdowns from happening 
in the past, as it was described, they still exist today. As it 
was mentioned before, the culture in this place is not the same 
that it was back then when the shutdowns were not acceptable 
and neither side wanted them and the work was to go to a 
solution.
 What we have here today is a different culture, a different 
mood in this building, that it seems that for some, that is 
where they want to go.
 The current guardrails that we have today are not working. 
They are not enough to prevent it because those in power of 
them, making the decisions, are not constraining themselves to 
those guardrails anymore.
 If not the solution that is being proposed, what can we do 
to fix this and prevent this from happening?
 Ms. Young. I would not say it is guardrails. It is people, 
right? The people in leadership, the people who occupy the 
Office of the Presidency, but more congressional leadership, 
giving this committee the space in which to do its job and to 
promote this process and stand on equal footing with any 
Presidency.
 I will say, listening to Senator Lankford, like, I am a big 
fan of people staying and working. If there is a way to ensure 
that that happens and people are as engaged as this committee 
is all summer long--I remember my summers only being 
appropriations--do it earlier.
 I do not--like, that is an honorable goal. I would like to 
see that same will or forced participation happen much earlier 
in the process. Because even before we got to the longest 
shutdown, CRs, like we all know, you get to September, that is 
not the time, you are never going to finish in time.
 What can we do--and some Members have brought up this--to 
bring--if it is Senator Lankford's idea, do not have it start 
October 1, this idea to keep Members around, what can we do 
earlier in the process?
 Mr. Ciscomani. I like that, so I want to talk offline 
because I want us to acknowledge that what we have today is not 
enough to prevent shutdowns from happening.
 The only thing worse than a short-term CR is a long-term 
CR, and the only thing worse than the long-term CR is a 
shutdown.
 We do not want any of those. We want to do our job and pass 
it. I do--I am happy that we can acknowledge that.
 Senator, with the seconds I have left, on Ms. Young's 
perspective here, the practical experience of this, if 
something like this goes through, the decision really at the 
end of how to pass this or not to pass it comes down to just a 
few, handful of people.
 Many of us in this room are not in those conversations, so 
just the decisionmaking of two, three, four, maybe ten people 
have an impact on the other 435 that are not at the table in 
the room when all these decisions are being made.
 How will a legislation like this or a rule like this one 
address that?
 Senator Lankford. For the five or ten people that are in 
the room at that point, they are at least known by the other 
400 people that are around them.
 At this point, we are just saying we are not going to pay 
TSA workers that have no idea where to point. We at least know 
who they are. We can pick up and call them. We can interact 
with those folks.
 When the final negotiations are done, they will be done 
here in this building, not out somewhere else. Right now I have 
got TSA agents that tell me they feel like their paycheck is 
bipolar, and they do not know who to be able to call to be able 
to fix it.
 The responsibility and the consequences should be on this 
body, not on Federal workers, and the idea that the best-case 
scenario for us is to continue to not pay Federal workers, I 
just completely disagree with.
 Mr. Ciscomani. It is unacceptable. Absolutely unacceptable.
 Senator Lankford. Absolutely unacceptable, and we have got 
to be able to solve this. If somebody has a better solution to 
this, bring it, but currently no one else is, so we are 
bringing one.
 Mr. Ciscomani. I am with you. Thank you so much, sir.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman.
 Mrs. Torres, you are recognized.
 Mrs. Torres. Thank you, Chairman and Ranking Member.
 To our witnesses, thank you for being here today.
 A special shout-out, of course, to Director Young, who many 
of us have had the pleasure of working with you in this 
committee and beyond.
 The appropriations process requires the discipline to work 
across the aisle, find common ground, especially to cut off 
extremes on both sides of the aisle and the extremes of a 
President.
 I know that a few Republican colleagues were relieved when 
some of the cuts proposed by the President and House majority 
were not signed into law for fiscal year 2026.
 Some of us were disappointed to see cuts in critical areas 
that help support our communities and the next generation of 
leaders.
 I support a transparent process that includes compromise, 
checks, and balances.
 Senator Lankford, I really appreciate your approach. What I 
do not agree on is the triggering of an automatic continuing 
resolution because I agree with Director Young that we should 
start this process earlier, and we should be committed and 
disciplined. Simply put, it is our job to compromise.
 The American people need Congress to step up when our 
country is divided. They need the Appropriations Committee to 
uphold our common American values and help our communities, 
especially on disaster aid.
 The January 2025 L.A. wildfires were devastating to 
communities across southern California, and the White House has 
not taken a single step to submit a disaster aid supplemental 
request--not for California and not for the 39 States, Tribes, 
and territories that have had major disasters declared since 
2025.
 Where is the outrage in that? Instead of lending a helping 
hand to hardworking taxpayers, the Trump Administration and the 
Republican majority are prioritizing funding the Iran forever 
war.
 To add insult to injury, California is also the biggest 
donor State in America, with 40 million of our hardworking 
taxpayers paying $275 billion more in Federal taxes than we get 
back in funding.
 Disaster aid should not be a partisan issue. Doubling down 
on this short-sighted decision, President Trump announced this 
week he is freezing Federal Medicaid dollars for California.
 The Appropriations Committee should be spending time on 
standing up for appropriations law instead of letting President 
Trump decide that Americans in blue States should not get the 
funding Congress provided in law.
 Instead of considering legislation to avoid hard choices 
and let automatic process take over, we should be working 
together, compromising, and finding a path forward.
 The proposals before us would do the opposite, and weaken 
not just this committee, but Congress itself, except for my 
agreement with you, Senator, on the issue of ensuring that we 
come together.
 We are already witnessing what happens when a party refuses 
to check its worst impulses. We need not only to stand up for 
the appropriations law, but we need to stand up for laws in 
general.
 Federal immigration agents need to follow the same law they 
impose on American citizens. You cannot say that we are pro-law 
enforcement or a party of law and order when you do not care 
when ICE agents break the law.
 It is still against the law to murder an American citizen 
for no reason on American soil even if you wear a mask and a 
badge.
 When agencies do not follow the law, that is when Congress 
and this committee must step in and hold them accountable, not 
give them a free pass and unlimited funding.
 Instead of proposals like this to get out of tough choices, 
this committee must work together across the aisle to hold this 
administration accountable, support our constituents, and 
uphold the law. There is really no excuse not to do that.
 Senator, how would you suggest we move forward? I think 
there is so much more agreement than disagreement. How can we 
cancel the two super extremes on both sides and find the middle 
to move forward?
 Senator Lankford. I think the best thing we can do is keep 
the conversation going. What typically happens in a moment like 
this is someone will say, I like everything in this proposal 
but this one thing, so let us not do it, and then let us not do 
anything.
 It is a different issue when we actually look at it and 
say, okay, I agree with these issues, I do not agree with these 
issues, let us figure out how to be able to solve this.
 If we have agreement that we should end government 
shutdowns, then let us actually figure out a bipartisan option. 
That is what we have been working on in the Senate, to figure 
out a bipartisan, nonpartisan option to try to figure out how 
do we end government shutdowns. That is what Maggie and I 
continue to be able to work on.
 The worst-case scenario for us is to finish this hearing 
and go, we had a hearing on it, check, and then a couple years 
from now, we are in a long government shutdown again and say 
nothing has changed.
 Nothing changes until we actually keep the conversation 
going till we figure out what does work and then do that.
 Mrs. Torres. I am committed to doing that, with you or 
anyone else. I can tell you that I got myself to Congress, 
elected to Congress, campaigning in my district. The party did 
not get me here. My commitment, and when I took that oath, it 
was to my constituents, not the Democratic Party or any 
President.
 With that, I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Thank you.
 Our witnesses are being extremely generous, but the Senator 
has to get back to the Senate, and so----
 Senator Lankford. I have got to run back and vote. I can 
try to run right back again.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Well, you do not need to because we are 
pretty much getting through the folks that have questions.
 Let me first, again, thank you. Thank you for your 
commitment, thank you for your service, and thank you for your 
willingness to spend this, what I think was very productive, 
time with us, Senator.
 With that, you are excused with great gratitude.
 Senator Lankford. Thank you. I do appreciate the time to be 
able to be in part of the conversation.
 I do encourage folks to glance through these. This letter 
from the American Federation of Government Employees, they 
really want a solution to this.
 Senator--I almost called you Senator Hoyer there for just a 
second. Sorry, that is just a default on that.
 Congressman Hoyer knows this extremely well from having so 
many Federal employees that live in his district. This is a big 
issue that they are crying out, they support this piece of 
legislation, but they are crying out for us to actually solve 
this.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Thank you. Thank you.
 The Senator has to be excused, and then we will----
 Mr. Hoyer. May I just have----
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Of course, we will give you a few seconds.
 Mr. Hoyer. I thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
 Mr. Kelly is, A, a good friend of mine, B, lives in my 
district, and we have talked about this. Everybody on this 
committee has said shutdowns are terrible.
 I cited three people who did not believe that necessarily, 
and that was Mr. Gingrich, who said that, Mr. Vought has said 
that, and President Trump has said that a shutdown under 
certain circumstances is good.
 I want to thank you for this thoughtful proposal. I will 
tell you, I am very much supportive of your proposal. You 
cannot consider other legislation until must-pass legislation, 
and the only must-pass legislation is the appropriation bills.
 None of the authorizing bills are must-pass. Consequences 
will occur, but they will not shut down government if they do 
not pass.
 I want to thank you for a thoughtful presentation and the 
way that you always present yourself and your issues in a 
constructive, positive way. I look forward to working with you 
as we go forward because, as majority leader, I indicated to 
the Appropriations Committee, and Shalanda Young, I want the 
bills ready to go to the floor by June 1. I want all the bills 
considered in June.
 I want July, by then, June, go to the Senate. The Senate, I 
want them to consider it. I think Mr. McClintock's idea is an 
interesting idea. I do not think we can effect it.
 I am, frankly, not for the filibuster. I know we Democrats 
are for it now. We were not for it when we were trying to get 
gun legislation through.
 I thank the gentleman.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman.
 Mr. Hoyer. Look forward to working with him.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman again.
 Senator, you are excused, but, again, gratitude for your 
willingness to do the work that you do, for your service, and 
also for spending this, I think, very valuable time. Thank you, 
sir. You are excused.
 Mr. Edwards, you are recognized, sir.
 Mr. Edwards. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 Thank all of you for being here on our panel today.
 Ms. Young, I represent western North Carolina, NC-11. We 
were hit on September 27, 2024, by Hurricane Helene, the worst 
natural disaster in my district's history. I got to witness 
firsthand how difficult that it became for us to continue our 
recovery from such a storm under two significant government 
shutdowns.
 Can you tell me, from your experience, from the inside of 
the White House, what difficulties that you have seen? Because 
I am not sure that every Member of this committee--and I 
certainly know that not every Member of Congress--understands 
the difficulties of folks that have lost everything when we 
choose to play political games with the budget up here.
 Ms. Young. Mr. Edwards, as someone who has pulled out 
drywall from my parents' house and grew up with a storm tracker 
under my arms in south Louisiana, there is nothing almost that 
energizes me than meeting people after they have experienced 
some of the worst loss after a hurricane, tornado, or fire.
 It should be nonpartisan--not even bipartisan, it should be 
nonpartisan.
 We were proud to work together to get a supplemental up. We 
did not have a shutdown during my time at OMB, but I can tell 
you, I have seen shutdowns over my time, especially when I was 
staff director.
 People have to--we have to determine whether people can 
continue to service in the disaster area or if we have to pull 
them back. You have to take 2 weeks to decide who can even stay 
versus leave.
 It is extremely--even if they can stay, you have gone 
through this process which slows down their ability to do their 
day-to-day work.
 It is detrimental in a regular time for people, for people 
who are wondering if the Small Business Administration (SBA) is 
going to continue to staff the disaster recovery center. Can 
you imagine like going through the muck, literally, after 
Helene, the muck, showing up to not have full support be there 
to take your application?
 While we did not have the scenario of a shutdown, I know 
how hard it is to manage disaster response, and shutdowns in 
general just put a strain on the system as you are even 
determining--and by the way, can the people in the disaster 
recovery center get paid.
 You have them trying to help people. The FEMA people 
probably are getting paid because they have the Disaster Relief 
Fund. The SBA people, maybe not. You have two class of Federal 
citizens.
 It is not a way to operate.
 Mr. Edwards. Well, I can tell you that there are positions 
in FEMA that might continue to operate during a government 
shutdown, but from firsthand experience, for me and for my 
constituents, a large part of FEMA absolutely shuts down. They 
will not even answer our phone.
 What would a shutdown--for example, what would a government 
shutdown do to replenishing the Disaster Relief Fund?
 Ms. Young. Again, we did not have a shutdown, but we talked 
about this a little, where during shutdowns OMB and the White 
House have a lot of flexibility on what they determine to be 
essential or not.
 This idea, this general theme where we seem to have 
agreement is, Congress wants to keep more of that authority. 
Shutdowns, just by their very nature, hand that authority over 
to White Houses and OMB to decide who can still answer phones.
 Now, the longer these go on, even people who are told they 
have to work may have to go find other jobs, and you start 
seeing people call out and not being able to sustain their own 
families in long shutdowns.
 Mr. Edwards. Thank you.
 I am going to run out of time, but I need to reiterate to 
this committee, I have seen what happens in a government 
shutdown.
 The North Carolina Governor came to my office, as the only 
appropriator from North Carolina, asking for additional relief 
funds, and 2 days later, his very delegation chose to shut the 
government down--the North Carolina delegation chose to shut 
the government down. That brought things to a screeching halt.
 Money that was due to folks looking to recover was brought 
to a halt. Debris removal was brought to a halt. Help that 
people in western North Carolina needed was brought to a halt. 
All while there were folks up here saying, we need more money, 
we need more resources.
 I thought it was rich and hypocritical of folks to then 
turn right around and vote to shut the government down. Just my 
perspective for those folks that are making decisions to shut 
us down for political reasons.
 Thank you. I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman.
 Mr. Ivey, you are recognized, sir.
 Mr. Ivey. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate it.
 let me say I appreciate the structure of this hearing as 
well. I think while I have been on appropriations, we have done 
a lot of hearings where, frankly, they are kind of very quick 
opportunities to chat, to have some questions with the heads of 
some of the departments and agencies.
 do not always get a chance to have this level of 
information that is shared with people who are knowledgeable on 
this topic, especially Ms. Young here. I want to thank the 
committee for that.
 I appreciate the fact too that this is such a critical 
issue for us. We have had a couple of shutdowns while I have 
been here in the Congress, only for 3 years. I represent the 
other half of Prince George's County that Mr. Hoyer does not 
represent. I have thousands of Federal government employees in 
my district.
 I used to be a Federal government employee along these 
lines as well, before I was elected to Congress. My parents, my 
father in particular, was a Federal employee as well.
 I have a lot of concern and sympathy with respect to them 
and the impact that these shutdowns can have on them.
 I also want to make sure too, though--and, Ms. Young, I 
think your testimony addresses some of this from the standpoint 
of the institutional impact that this piece of legislation 
might have, from the standpoint of transferring authority and 
power to the White House from Congress.
 I was kind of curious if you would elaborate on that and 
give me some of your additional thoughts on it.
 Ms. Young. I will give you an answer I gave someone 
earlier. Like, having been at OMB and knowing how decisions 
typically get made, where there are lots of balls in the air, I 
certainly see a scenario where, if you come together in a 
bipartisan way and you have some oversight that an occupant of 
the White House is not a fan of, what happens if they have this 
fail-safe in an automatic?
 If they go to the OMB Director and said, ``Look, the 
government is still open; can I still do these five things?'' 
and the OMB Director said, ``Yes, you can, Mr.'' or ``Ms. 
President,'' then why should I sign these bills if the 
government stays open?
 That is my worry, that you have 10 people--they could be a 
combination of the Senate--there could be bad actors in any 
administration, even in the House itself, who do not want this 
process to work for whatever reason, and you give them a fail-
safe, and will take a very long time to get regular 
appropriations done. That is my concern.
 Mr. Ivey. Mr. McClintock, do you have thoughts on that? By 
the way, it is good to see you again----
 Mr. McClintock. Good to see you again. We miss----
 Mr. Ivey [continuing]. From my days on Judiciary.
 Mr. McClintock [continuing]. You on Judiciary.
 Mr. Ivey. Yeah. What is your thought on that?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, I think Mr. Lankford's main point--I 
cannot speak for him, but--I think what it comes down to is 
this: If we are not here talking to one another, we are not 
resolving the issue as a whole.
 The name ``Congress'' comes from a root or word that means 
``coming together.'' It is a process, it is a human process, 
and it is a very messy process. The Founders wanted it to be 
very difficult to make these decisions. They wanted every voice 
in the country to be heard. They wanted these questions to be 
held up to every conceivable light. Once that--and that is this 
process.
 I think Senator Lankford's principal point is, it cannot 
work if we are not actually in Congress.
 Mr. Ivey. I appreciate that.
 I appreciate the fact that I guess we have two versions of 
the legislation here that we are going to take a look at. I 
share Senator Lankford's view that we do need to try and find a 
solution here, because it is an ongoing challenge. I do think 
it is critical for this to be the right solution, though. I am 
not sure that we, sort of, figured that out. We have two 
competing bills here that I think are honest and fair-minded 
efforts to try and address the problems, but I think we have 
some more work cut out before we get there.
 I am running out of time, but the SNAP-benefits piece would 
be one that I would ask that popped up. In the last shutdown, I 
think there was an assertion by the administration that they 
could not continue to pay SNAP benefits, and there was a real--
--
 Ms. Young. It is just another example of how much leeway an 
OMB, a White House has in a shutdown.
 I think we have all agreed shutdowns are awful; CRs, 
slightly better than awful, whether they be automatic or our 
regular way of doing CRs. What can we do to get this process to 
produce 12 appropriations bills?
 There is just a lot more agreement in this room than there 
is opposition. The solutions, there is disagreement, but the 
overall aims and goals--to stop shutdowns, and CRs not being 
much better--I think provides a basis to not end the 
conversation here but keep it going.
 Mr. Ivey. I thank you for that.
 Mr. Chairman, I apologize for running over, and I yield 
back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Well, thank you very much, sir.
 Ms. Maloy, you are recognized.
 Ms. Maloy. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
 This has been a really interesting hearing, unlike any I 
have ever been in. Sitting here as a still fairly newish Member 
of Congress, listening to three insiders with knowledge of how 
things work here talking about how broken we are has been 
informative and a little bit heartbreaking.
 Thank you. I know you are not used to being on that side 
for these hearings, but thank you for sitting here and 
patiently answering questions for more than 3 hours now. I will 
be brief. I do not think I will even use my whole 5 minutes.
 Mr. McClintock, I think you and I are in agreement on part 
of what is broken here, based on other conversations we have 
had. I think the reason that the annual appropriations bills 
are so important is that, when we have to pass spending bills 
every year, it keeps Congress accountable to the taxpayers 
every year. When we are talking about spending government 
dollars, they are taxpayer dollars. We are taking money from 
American citizens. We are deciding how it needs to be spent. If 
we have to vote on that every single year, it keeps us 
accountable, it keeps that at the front of our minds.
 The process of how we do that is only supposed to be a 
means to an end. What I am hearing here--and I am doing the 
thing I hate, which is giving a speech instead of asking a 
question--but what I am hearing is that the means has become 
the end. We get so caught up in the means, we are not getting 
there. Any proposal that includes automatic funding for 
anything seems like it defeats that purpose of making us vote 
on it every year so that we go back to our taxpayers and say 
what we are doing.
 I really like your bill. I like the idea that we need to 
change the process to make it work, but we cannot make the 
Senate change. They are going to have to vote on that in the 
Senate.
 How optimistic are you that we can get Senators to actually 
vote for a bill that changes their procedure? I know there are 
changes on our side too, but I know how our side works better. 
Do you think we can actually get the Senate to agree to process 
changes to get us back on track?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, that ultimately will be a question 
for the Senate to decide. Again, we are amending statutes, so 
both houses have a say in this. Obviously, this directly 
affects the Senate's procedures.
 I have been in contact with one of the leading Members of 
the Senate, who is very interested in introducing a similar 
measure on their side. I do not think he has made a decision 
yet, so I will not mention his name, but----
 Ms. Maloy. Okay.
 Mr. McClintock [continuing]. I do think there is enormous 
frustration in the Senate over that same problem of the system 
seizing up and not being able to deliver.
 That is going to be true whoever is--whoever has a 
majority, the minority can block the system, can block the 
process of coming together to compromise and to make a 
decision. That is a serious problem, because then the system 
cannot operate as it was designed--it cannot operate at all.
 Ms. Maloy. Yeah.
 As an appropriator, I have seen that it is a lot of work 
for us to get 12 bills written, marked up, out of committee, 
ready to go to the floor. When we know it is not going to go 
anywhere, that is a lot of wasted effort.
 I have also seen that, when we do that work, sometimes we 
are our own worst enemies. The public thinks these are enormous 
bills that were written at midnight and presented the next 
morning and nobody has seen them.
 Do you see any solution to that, where we have some control 
on our side that we can make sure the public understands this 
process and why it is so important and how many people are 
involved and how many steps are involved?
 Mr. McClintock. I agree.
 Ms. Maloy. That is a ``yes?''
 Mr. McClintock. Yeah.
 Ms. Maloy. Okay.
 With that, I have some other questions, but I am almost out 
of time, and you have been here for a long time and it has been 
a long day. I appreciate both of you and the Senator answering 
these questions. Again, this has been one of the most 
interesting hearings I have ever sat through.
 I yield.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. Well, thank you.
 Mr. Aguilar, you are recognized, sir.
 Mr. Aguilar. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate it.
 I know our guests have been here for a long time, and I 
appreciate their patience.
 Shalanda, it is always good to see you and always good to 
see you back here in this space. We think that we are your home 
here, on the Appropriations team.
 I wanted to know--and I know you have answered a ton of 
questions from Members. Can you talk to me specifically--you 
know I am from southern California, the home State for Mr. 
McClintock and I, often ravaged by wildfires in our region. The 
current administration has neglected our recovery needs, in my 
opinion because we are a blue State. I am also working to 
ensure that our region is prepared for national security when 
it comes to the 2028 Olympics.
 Can you touch on how policies of automatic CRs would impact 
Congress' ability to respond to unforeseen needs like natural 
disasters and other unforeseen events?
 Ms. Young. Again, if you believe my scenario on how 
automatic CRs play out--obviously I believe it quite well--that 
if there is a ``fail-safe'' and there are hard decisions to be 
made, like immigration, like a whole host of things that we 
have fought hard in the appropriations process to do, then it 
may not be this committee but it could be a President, it could 
be a group of Senators, it could be some combination of 
leadership who just say, ``Why would we take this tough vote if 
we have an out not to shut down the government?''
 If you believe that and you believe that leads to a longer 
CR, then you cannot be responsive in a CR. This committee has 
always been against CRs, because all the work that Ms. Maloy 
has talked about over the summer, where you are responding to 
things you have heard about from home, where, frankly, you are 
marking up a President's budget that is probably out of date 
before it even gets to you because agencies have started this 
late, then--we have never believed a CR and putting the third 
of government that depends on appropriations--that 2 or 3 years 
operating at the same levels was a responsive way to govern.
 When I started on this committee as a staffer, I would sit 
through senior members just rail, like, ``All this stuff comes 
to us, yet we at least do our work every year. Go talk to the 
authorizers who have mandatory and they do not deal with that 
every year.'' I just will always be shaped by that and cannot 
imagine a world where we put this now 28 percent of 
discretionary--even the possibility that that turns into yet 
another chunk of Federal spending that Congress does not deal 
with in an annual way.
 The complaint I grew up with from Members was that all of 
it needed to be reviewed in a more--in a clip that was more 
regular.
 Mr. Aguilar. That was Members on both sides of the aisle.
 Ms. Young. That was Members on both sides of the aisle and 
a unique perspective from the Members who served on the annual 
process committee.
 Mr. Aguilar. Mr. McClintock, your thoughts on how automatic 
CRs would respond to unforeseen circumstances or natural 
disasters?
 Mr. McClintock. Well, again, that is Senator Lankford's 
bill, but I think his point is that we need a default safety 
net when we cannot come to an agreement. I cannot disagree with 
Ms. Young's analysis that that can then provide a perverse 
incentive not to come to an agreement.
 Mr. Aguilar. Yeah.
 The theory of your case is that we all need to, kind of, be 
in the same space to work that out. I think that is also the 
same ethos of the Members on this committee. We want to, even 
in difficult times, even in shutdowns----
 Mr. McClintock. That is the whole purpose of that building 
with the big dome on top; it is----
 Mr. Aguilar. Yeah.
 Mr. McClintock [continuing]. To talk these things through, 
and sometimes that takes a lot of talk.
 Mr. Aguilar. Yeah. Sometimes that takes a lot of talk.
 I have been here when we have had shutdowns in a number of 
ways and a number of circumstances. Ms. Young was working here 
previously when we had shutdowns over the border wall that was 
unnecessary. We have had shutdowns over the Affordable Care Act 
tax credits.
 I say that just--and I know we are here to talk about the 
proposals, but it is not lost on me to kind of step back, and 
think why we get into the situation we are in are also big and 
complex and sometimes, are out of the purview of just this 
committee.
 That does not minimize the importance of the debates that 
we are having. I think what we want out of these proposals is 
to just ensure that we have the ability to shape what is in 
front of us. That is why we are here, and that is the job that 
we have agreed to.
 I thank you both for your time, and I appreciate your 
patience with the committee.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentleman.
 Ms. Letlow, okay, I think you are going to wind this up--
wind this down, I should say.
 On the other side, over here.
 Ms. Letlow, you are recognized.
 Ms. Letlow. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for 
holding this important meeting.
 Ms. Young, it is good to see you, a fellow Louisianan, here 
today.
 Last fall, the Nation experienced the longest government 
shutdown in history, lasting 43 days. The shutdown disrupted 
businesses across the country and placed a significant burden 
on American workers and their families. For weeks, dedicated 
Federal government employees were required to report to work 
without pay, while Members of Congress still received a 
paycheck. This is simply unacceptable.
 During every government shutdown, I have asked the House to 
withhold my pay until the government reopened, because Members 
of Congress should share in the consequences of a funding 
lapse.
 Earlier this year, my fellow Louisianan, Senator John 
Kennedy, led a successful effort to withhold Senators' pay 
during government shutdowns. I think this is a commonsense 
measure ensuring that Members are held accountable and are not 
treated differently from the Federal employees and American 
families they serve.
 While I hope our Nation avoids another shutdown, I believe 
the House should seriously consider adopting a similar policy 
to hold all our feet to the fire.
 For our witnesses today, as Congress considers ways to 
restore public trust in the appropriations process, should 
additional accountability measures, including whether Members 
of Congress should continue receiving pay during a funding 
lapse, be part of that conversation?
 Ms. Young. One, I cannot let pass a fellow Louisianan 
without--she is the only person in here who knows where 
Clinton, Louisiana, is, and----
 Ms. Letlow. Amen.
 Ms. Young [continuing]. That is my hometown. I promise you, 
she is the only one.
 Look, I think that this conversation today, there has been 
more agreement that this is unacceptable.
 Ms. Letlow. Uh-huh.
 Ms. Young. In my remarks, I reminded, not as a pat on the 
back--because it is low-hanging to say, ``I did not preside 
over a shutdown.'' I do not take great pride in that. That, 
like, should be basic, but nothing trumps political will.
 Ms. Letlow. Right.
 Ms. Young. I have asked and think through these reforms 
that Congressman McClintock has, that Senator Lankford has. We 
like to start with the symptom, but there has been a lot to 
fail before we get to shutdowns.
 Ms. Letlow. Uh-huh.
 Ms. Young. That could be a combination of administrations 
who--and it does not matter the party. If Presidents see an 
opportunity, they are not going to really offer you your 
Article I power back.
 Ms. Letlow. Uh-huh.
 Ms. Young. I would like to see a lot of effort and thought 
put into, what does it take to get the room to really work on 
the appropriations process and have leadership give you all the 
room to do the hard work----
 Ms. Letlow. Uh-huh.
 Ms. Young [continuing]. To have an administration who is 
fearful if they get in the way of your hard work?
 The soft power of the Appropriations Committee was often 
more strong than the hard power, the bills. A pickup of the 
phone, like, ``Hey, that is not what we meant.'' That was 
always listened to.
 I think--I get it, after the longest shutdown and we saw 
the harm on Federal workers, the want to do these things on the 
tail end, like pay. I will leave that to you all to discuss. I 
know there have been some constitutionality questions, but you 
all will have to answer that for yourself.
 I would just hope that we leave this--and it has been a 
very good discussion--trying to figure out what we can do to 
give this process the space it needs and the hard work you all 
sit here and do all summer, right?
 Ms. Letlow. Uh-huh.
 Ms. Young. I finally took my first June vacation last year, 
because appropriations is all the summer. What can we do to 
focus the House and the Senate's full body on this work and not 
leave it till September, when we know we are set up for 
failure----
 Ms. Letlow. Sure.
 Ms. Young [continuing]. Because we cannot finish in 2 
weeks.
 Ms. Letlow. Yeah. Thank you for your comments.
 I know the American people expect us to do our job. When we 
shut this place down, I just believe that we should not receive 
a paycheck, just like they would not receive if they did not 
show up to work.
 Mr. McClintock. The ideal outcome, of course, is for the 
appropriations process to culminate with the appropriations 
sent to the President for signature.
 Ms. Letlow. Absolutely.
 Mr. McClintock. We have a blockage in that system, where a 
minority, Republican or Democrat, can stop that process in the 
Senate. That seizes up the legislative progression that will 
ultimately arrive at agreement between the two houses and 
produce an appropriations bill to the Senate.
 Ms. Letlow. Uh-huh.
 Mr. McClintock. That is my principal concern. Again, not a 
cure-all, but it will make it more likely that those bills can 
make their way to the President's desk. That is the ideal 
situation, is for the Congress to work its will through the 
appropriations that it adopts. That is what the Founders 
envisioned.
 Ms. Letlow. Amen to that.
 Thank you both so much for your time. I appreciate it.
 I yield back.
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. I thank the gentlelady.
 Let me thank our remarkable witnesses for being here today 
and for your time and for your insight.
 As a reminder, Members shall have 5 legislative days within 
which to revise and extend their remarks and to insert 
extraneous material into the record.
 [The information follows:]
 [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Mr. Diaz-Balart. With that, the committee stands adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 1:27 p.m., the committee was adjourned.]

 W I T N E S S E S

 ---------- 
 Page
Lankford, James.................................................. 6
McClintock, Tom.................................................. 36
Young, Shalanda.................................................. 39
 
 (i)

 [all]