Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-450] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-450 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS ======================================================================= HEARING before the COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION __________ DECEMBER 17, 2025 __________ Serial No. J-119-54 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] www.judiciary.senate.gov www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 64-063 WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa, Chairman LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RICHARD J. DURBIN, Illinois, JOHN CORNYN, Texas Ranking Member MICHAEL S. LEE, Utah SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island TED CRUZ, Texas AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota JOSH HAWLEY, Missouri CHRISTOPHER A. COONS, Delaware THOM TILLIS, North Carolina RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee CORY A. BOOKER, New Jersey ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri ALEX PADILLA, California KATIE BOYD BRITT, Alabama PETER WELCH, Vermont ASHLEY MOODY, Florida ADAM B. SCHIFF, California Kolan Davis, Chief Counsel and Staff Director Joe Zogby, Democratic Chief Counsel and Staff Director C O N T E N T S ---------- OPENING STATEMENTS Page Hawley, Hon. Josh................................................ 1 Durbin, Hon. Richard J........................................... 3 Blackburn, Hon. Marsha........................................... 5 Schmitt, Hon. Eric............................................... 9 Moody, Hon. Ashley............................................... 7 VISITING INTRODUCERS Young, Hon. Todd, a U.S. Senator from the State of Indiana....... 2 Hagerty, Hon. Bill, a U.S. Senator from the State of Tennessee... 6 Banks, Hon. Jim E., a U.S. Senator from the State of Indiana..... 8 NOMINEES Benton, Hon. Megan Blair Prepared statement........................................... 27 Questionnaire................................................ 28 Responses to written questions............................... 63 Burrows, Daniel E. Questionnaire................................................ 109 Responses to written questions............................... 132 Lea, Brian Charles Prepared statement........................................... 160 Questionnaire................................................ 162 Responses to written questions............................... 212 Olson, Justin R. Prepared statement........................................... 358 Questionnaire................................................ 360 Responses to written questions............................... 403 CONFIRMATION HEARING ON FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS ---------- WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 17, 2025 United States Senate, Committee on the Judiciary, Washington, DC. The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:16 a.m., in Room 216, Hart Senate Office Building, Hon. Josh Hawley presiding. Present: Senators Hawley [presiding], Lee, Cruz, Kennedy, Blackburn, Schmitt, Moody, Durbin, Whitehouse, and Schiff. Also present: Senators Young, Hagerty, and Banks. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. JOSH HAWLEY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI Senator Hawley. Let me call this morning's meeting of the Senate Judiciary Committee to order. I am presiding on behalf of Chairman Grassley today, and sadly for a tragic reason. Two Iowa National Guard members were recently killed in a terrorist attack in Syria, and Chairman Grassley is with the President in Dover now to honor them as they return home. I know I speak for the Committee, as well as the country, when I say we are very grateful for their service and sacrifice, and we remember them and their families in prayer today as we prepare to honor their long service to this Nation. On a happier note, today, we will welcome a highly decorated panel of four nominees: three judicial nominees, and an Assistant Attorney General in the Department of Justice. And we will hear more about them shortly. This is our final nominations hearing of 2025, and I just want to point out, as we start, that the Committee has advanced 84 excellent nominees to the Senate floor this year. Thanks to my colleagues for that, and thank you, of course, to President Trump for choosing thoughtful, hardworking, and dedicated public servants as judges, Federal prosecutors, and senior public officials. Here is going to be our run of show today. In the remainder of my opening remarks here, I am going to introduce one of the nominees, a proud Missourian, eighth-generation Missourian, Judge Megan Benton, who is with us. Then I am going to turn it over to Senator Durbin for his opening remarks. And then we have a number of Senators, and I am going to start with Senator Blackburn, who would like to introduce their nominees, and then we will proceed to the panel. So without further ado, let me introduce an eighth- generation Missourian and a leading attorney in our State's bar, Judge Megan Benton. Judge Benton is a Jefferson City native who grew up in mid-Missouri. She earned her undergraduate and master's degrees at Emory University before enrolling and graduating from Vanderbilt Law School. After Vandy, she began her career by clerking for a trial court judge, and then she settled into private practice in Kansas City. Before too long, however, she responded to the call for public service, and she has been serving and protecting the State of Missouri since 2014 when she became a prosecutor in Platte County, which is one of Missouri's fastest-growing counties, and for those of you who don't know the State, just a little bit north of Kansas City. While she was a prosecutor, Megan handled some of the most serious criminal offenses in our justice system--capital offenses, crimes against children, violent felonies, drug offenses, and domestic violence offenses. In an era of plea bargains, settlements, and very rare trials, she never shirked away from a jury. In fact, she has tried 50 cases to verdict--50, serving as sole counsel in approximately 35 of those cases. She was appointed to the bench in 2021 and now serves as our State's highest-level trial court judge. She presides over criminal and complex civil cases that have given her the experience and temperament to manage the Federal docket. Just on the criminal side of her docket, she has presided over approximately 250 sentencings. Her wisdom, her prudence, her discernment in the most challenging part of her job have won widespread admiration, and I can tell you, if you talk to plaintiffs and defendants, prosecutors in the State, they will all rave about Judge Benton's professionalism, her work ethic, her courtroom management, and docket management. And maybe most importantly to the people who know her, she is wholeheartedly committed to her community and her family. She and her husband, Paul, are raising two wonderful sons, Nolan, who is 8 years old, and Pearson, who is 5. It is a very busy household, I imagine. I am excited for Megan and her family to have the opportunity to continue to serve the people of our State in this new capacity, and I thank President Trump for choosing her and making this truly outstanding nomination. With that, I will turn it over to Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, I might ask if our visiting colleague be given the chance to speak, and I will follow him. Senator Hawley. Absolutely. Senator Young, and then Senator Blackburn. STATEMENT OF HON. TODD YOUNG, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF INDIANA Senator Young. Well, I thank the Chairman, I thank the Ranking Member, and all Members of the Committee for this opportunity. I am here today to introduce a fellow Hoosier, Justin Olson, as the President's nominee to serve as a district judge for the Southern District of Indiana. Justin is really a Hoosier through and through. He has a distinguished record of public service, legal excellence, and respect for the rule of law. Over the course of his career, he has demonstrated the integrity, judgment, and temperament that are essential for service on the Federal bench. Mr. Olson practices civil litigation at a law firm in Indianapolis, where he has handled complex legal matters and fought discrimination against women in college sports. He specializes in healthcare fraud litigation. His experience spans both public service and private practice, giving him a well-rounded perspective on the law and knowledge of the real- world consequences of judicial decisions. From my interactions with him, my review of his record, and my conversations with those who know him best, it is apparent to me that Mr. Olson is fit to serve in this position. I have received several letters of support for Mr. Olson. They describe him as a thoughtful, evenhanded, and committed to applying the law as written. These are precisely the qualities we should expect of a Federal judge. In particular, I am grateful to former U.S. Attorneys for the Southern District of Indiana Josh Minkler and Zach Myers. Now, it is notable, Mr. Chairman, that they served under Presidents of both parties. Their joint endorsement of Mr. Olson, who served as an assistant U.S. attorney under their leadership, is especially meaningful to me. And I think it should be for Members of the Committee as well. So I am confident that Mr. Olson will serve the Southern District of Indiana with great distinction and honor. I urge the Committee to give his nomination full and favorable consideration. And I would say he scores bonus points because he is here today with his lovely bride, Leah, and three of his very attentive and well-mannered children. Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Senator Young. Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. I might just say, Senator Young, that at this moment in Big Ten history, we are all deferring to the Hoosiers. [Laughter.] Senator Durbin. We wish you---- Senator Young. Indeed, as we should be. Senator Durbin. Thank you for being here. Senator Young. Thank you. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. RICHARD J. DURBIN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ILLINOIS Senator Durbin. Mr. Chairman, I want to congratulate the nominees and their families. The Senate, as part of the legislative branch, must provide advice and consent on Presidential nominees. It is a responsibility that goes back to our Nation's founding. As James Madison warned in the Federalist Papers, quote, ``The accumulation of all power, legislative, executive, and judiciary in the same hands, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny,'' end of quote. To ensure the President could not become a despot like King George III, our Founders designed a system of checks and balances separating the Federal Government's powers among its three branches. The Senate's role in providing advice and consent on Presidential nominees is one critical check on the executive branch. Today's hearing is a step in that process. It has never been more important that the Senate exercise this role because the President continues to challenge what I have just said. And he is determined to push the bounds of his power at every opportunity. He is not the first. Across the country, immigration agents are racially profiling and arresting American citizens, even veterans. At a spotlight forum last week, I spoke about one Chicagoan, a U.S. citizen on her way to work, who was physically assaulted, arrested, and detained for several hours after ICE agents crashed into her car and pointed their weapons at her--all captured on videotape. Her supposed crime? Well, she looked Hispanic. This is the kind of thing we expect from totalitarian regimes that have rightly been relegated to the trash heap of history. It is not conduct we can or should tolerate in the United States. But the Trump administration's unlawful and sometimes un- American actions are not limited to our shores or our fellow citizens. The President has ordered extrajudicial killings of at least 95 people off the coast of Venezuela. And yesterday, our self-styled Secretary of War told most of us Senators to go to hell when we asked to see the videos of the episode where two stranded victims may have been executed in violation of international legal standards. The Trump administration alleges that these individuals are narco-terrorists. Drug trafficking is a serious crime and should be prosecuted. But that is not what is happening here. Instead, President Trump is engaging in the summary execution of criminal suspects. That is a violation of law in peacetime and wartime. When the President exceeds the limits of his constitutional authority, the other branches of Government have an obligation to push back. Today's hearing is part of our effort to fulfill our obligation. But we must also conduct oversight and hold accountable a President who too often ignores the limits of power. When I chaired this Committee for 4 years during President Biden's administration, we brought before this Committee, each year, the heads of the three major agencies that we have oversight responsibility for, the Department of Justice, FBI, and Department of Homeland Security. We are now about to finish off this calendar year with the Department of Homeland Security spurning every effort we have made to bring her--to hold her accountable for what is happening. In closing, I want to note that multiple nominees on today's panel are here because of the Constitution's--pardon me, the Committee's longstanding bipartisan tradition of requiring what we call ``blue slips'' from Senators supporting district court nominees from their States. When I served as Chair of this Committee, I honored this practice despite pressure from many Democrats to do away with blue slips when we were in the Majority. As a result, many Senate Republicans were able to negotiate with the Biden White House on nominees to fill vacancies. Others--Republican Senators used blue slips to hold seats open in their States. I didn't like it, but both parties have used that strategy, and I respected it. Just this week, the President falsely claimed--and I quote him, ``If you have one Democrat in a State, it is not possible to appoint because of blue slips,'' end of quote. Simply untrue. In fact, this year, the Committee has reported and the Senate has confirmed numerous judicial and U.S. attorney nominees from blue States with the support of Democratic Senators. It simply requires the President to do what every other President has done before him--work with home State Senators to identify well-qualified nominees. Blue slips remain a critical part of this body's advice and consent, even when they frustrate the party in power. I want to thank Chairman Grassley for continuing to follow this practice. I yield. Senator Hawley. Senator Young, thank you. And you are welcome to stay and listen to us, but if you have other work to do, thank you very much. Senator Blackburn. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARSHA BLACKBURN, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I want to say welcome to all of our nominees today. And it is my honor to introduce our district judge nominee for the Western District of Tennessee, and that is Brian Lea. Brian is an experienced lawyer who will serve our Nation with excellence and integrity. He grew up in Memphis, graduated from Evangelical Christian School in 2002. He went on to receive his B.A. from Union University in Jackson, Tennessee, and then attended the University of Georgia School of Law, where he graduated first in his class and served as Articles Editor for the Georgia Law Review. After graduating from law school, he served as a law clerk to Judge Ed Carnes on the eleventh circuit and then went on to clerk for Justice Clarence Thomas during the 2011-2012 term. Justice Thomas gives him a glowing review. Following these clerkships, he joined the law firm of Jones Day, where he worked primarily as a generalist litigator handling product liability cases, business disputes, constitutional litigation, and intellectual property matters. During his time at Jones Day, he served as a visiting law professor at Georgia School of Law, where he taught civil procedure, criminal procedure, and other courses. Most recently, he has served as Deputy Associate Attorney General in President Trump's Justice Department. In that role, he advises AG Bondi and Deputy AG Blanche in implementing the Department's priorities, as well as assisting in the Department's litigation. He has the experience and the qualifications to serve as a judge in the Western District of Tennessee, and I know that he is going to make the people of Tennessee proud. And I congratulate him and his family on this nomination. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Senator Blackburn. Senator Hagerty, welcome to the Committee, and we would love for you to introduce your nominee. STATEMENT OF HON. BILL HAGERTY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Senator Hagerty. Thank you. And I want to thank the Chair and the Ranking Member for holding this meeting today. It is my privilege to introduce Brian Charles Lea. He is President Trump's nominee to be the district judge for the Western District of Tennessee. Brian is a fourth-generation Memphian. But I will note, he can't quite claim to have been born and raised in Memphis because Brian was actually born in Montreal while his father was there for spring training. That's right, Brian's father, the late Charlie Lea, was an ace pitcher for the Montreal Expos. Charlie got his start playing in Memphis for the minor leagues and ended his career calling games for the Memphis Redbirds. You can see Brian's father's statue in downtown Memphis right in front of the stadium today. But let's talk about Brian. Brian earned his undergraduate degree at Union University with a nearly perfect GPA. At the University of Georgia Law School, Brian somehow did even better. With A-pluses in 15 classes, he finished at the very top of his class with a 4.06 GPA. After a clerkship with Judge Ed Carnes on the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, Brian went on to clerk for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas. As Senator Blackburn mentioned, Clarence Thomas gives glowing reviews for Brian. He then excelled in academia and in private practice. I would like to focus on those experiences. As a law professor, Brian co-taught a class alongside his old boss, Justice Thomas. I think that tells you a bit about his legal acumen. Brian also distinguished himself as a partner at Jones Day, one of the Nation's finest firms, and incidentally, one firm that has represented me and my company for years when I was in the private sector. In a noteworthy case, Brian served as Lead Counsel for our colleague, Senator Graham, asserting our legislative privileges under the United States Constitution. And this year, Brian served the President as Deputy Associate Attorney General at the Department of Justice. Brian bears enormous responsibility coordinating the litigation strategy of the United States of America in a vast number of high stakes and complicated cases. Not only are Brian's credentials impressive, I have been impressed by Brian's temperament. He has the patience, courtesy, humility, and thoughtfulness of a good trial judge. I think you will also be impressed, as I have been, by Brian's intellect. Consider his insightful law review articles on standing and severability, one of which has been cited four times by the United States Supreme Court. And most impressive is Brian's appreciation for a constitutional system. He recognizes that the Constitution should be interpreted according to its original meaning, and it must be followed, regardless of the ebbs and flows of public opinion or the personal preferences of the one who dons the robe. I am confident that Brian will uphold the highest standards of our judiciary, and I urge this Committee to quickly advance his nomination. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Senator Hagerty. And you are welcome to be excused if you have other work to do---- Senator Hagerty. Thank you. Senator Hawley [continuing]. As I imagine you do. Thank you very much. Senator Moody is going to introduce Daniel Burrows. Senator Moody. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ASHLEY MOODY, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF FLORIDA Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And good to see you, Mr. Hagerty--Senator Hagerty. We are excited about all of our nominees here today, and I have the distinct pleasure of introducing President Trump's nominee to lead the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Policy, Mr. Daniel Burrows. Mr. Burrows is joined today by his wife, Rachel; his three sons, Zachariah, Micah, Elijah; his brother, Philip; and his sister, Jenny. He earned his B.A. from the University of Virginia and his law degree from the University of Iowa. After graduating, Mr. Burrows went into private practice, and like me, after starting in private practice, he found his way--found his calling into public service, first clerking at the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces and spending a decade prosecuting fraud cases at the Social Security Administration. He then continued on in his legal career, entering private practice again. But hearing that call to serve, went back to public service and eventually landing at the Kansas Attorney General's Office, serving as chief deputy attorney general, which is where I got to know him in the attorney general world. Mr. Burrows now serves as Deputy Assistant to the President and Deputy White House Staff Secretary. Now, if all of that wasn't enough, throughout all of this success, he has led a parallel career of military legal service with the Army Reserves as Defense Counsel and a JAG. To me, he is the portrait of what our 26th President, President Teddy Roosevelt, called, ``The Man in the Arena.'' Many of you know the quotes from that. He--in that, President Roosevelt reminded us that credit and honor belongs to those, like Mr. Burrows, who have been in that arena, taken pay cuts, entered public service, and fought on behalf of We the People. Today, I think even more so than when President Trump-- President Roosevelt said it, there are so many critics, both online and in person--I have so much admiration for people who are willing to join in service and jump into that arena to serve based on what they value and what they hold so dear about this country. There are so many people on the sidelines that wouldn't do that, and all they really care about is that other people hear their hot take. But President Trump, among so many great Americans, has found fighters, those that are willing to be in that arena, and put them in positions of public trust to fight on behalf of the American people every single day. It is my distinct honor to introduce Mr. Daniel Burrows to my colleagues as President Trump's nominee to serve as Assistant Attorney General for the DOJ's Office of Legal Policy. Welcome to you and your family. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Senator Moody. Senator Banks, it is a pleasure to have you before the Committee. I understand you are going to introduce Mr. Olson. The floor is yours. STATEMENT OF HON. JIM E. BANKS, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF INDIANA Senator Banks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is an honor to be before this Committee and introduce President Trump's nominee for the Southern District of Indiana. Justin Olson is well qualified for this vital position. He earned his undergraduate degree at Grove City College. He went on to earn his law degree at Indiana University's Maurer School of Law. For 5 years, Justin served his country as an assistant U.S. attorney in the Southern District of Indiana, and there he led efforts to combat healthcare fraud and address the opioid crisis. Justin has fought to protect core American liberties. He is currently representing Riley Gaines and other female athletes who have been forced to compete against men in sports. And as a dad of three daughters, I am very grateful for his leadership on that front. Justin is seeking justice for women who have been harmed by unsafe and discriminatory practices. Justin himself is a husband and father to five children. They are all sitting back behind me. And he is a recognized leader in our community in Indianapolis. He served as an elder at his church and as a board member of the Jewish Community Center in Indianapolis. This is the first time, Mr. Chairman, I have gone through this process, being able to weigh in to the President of the United States and interview prospective judges to serve on the Federal court--on the Federal bench. And one thing that strikes me about Justin is his courage, and that is what I am looking for when it comes to a judge who is serving at the Federal level from my home State. And frankly, I had never met or heard of Justin before I went through this process, didn't have a relationship with him, but I was blown away by his credentials, his background, what he brings to the table. There are lots of things that you can say in an interview, but you can't fake courage, you can't fake your record. And Justin Olson has a record of doing the right thing and stepping up to the plate. So I am so grateful to President Trump, who nominated Justin Olson to serve as a judge on the Southern District of Indiana. I look forward to voting for him. And I ask this Committee to give him your full support. I am confident that he will serve our State and country very well. It is my honor to support him. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much. Thank you, Senator Banks. We appreciate you appearing before the Committee. And if you have other work to do, you are welcome to go your way. Thank you. Senator Schmitt, you would like to say a word or two about Judge Benton, I think. The floor is yours. OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ERIC SCHMITT, A U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MISSOURI Senator Schmitt. I would. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is great to see you, it is great to see your family here, and it is an honor for me to be able to introduce Judge Megan Benton today as President Trump's nominee to serve as a U.S. district court judge for the Western District of Missouri. Judge Benton, welcome to Washington. Judge Benton was born and raised in Missouri. She went on to attend Emory University, where she earned both her bachelor's and master's degree, graduating summa cum laude. She then received her law degree from Vanderbilt University School of Law. After clerking, Judge Benton returned home to Kansas City, where she spent her entire legal career, first in private practice, then as a tough and experienced prosecutor in the Platte County Prosecutor's Office where she tried 50 cases to verdict, judgment, or final decision. For nearly 5 years now, she has served with distinction as a circuit judge in Missouri's sixth judicial circuit. Her career has been defined by dedication--by dedicated service to the people of Missouri and to the rule of law. President Trump put it perfectly when he said, ``The great State of Missouri deserves a fighter like Megan, who will always protect our Constitution and ensure liberty and justice for all.'' Judge Benton, you have been an outstanding prosecutor, an excellent judge. You are going to make a great Federal district court judge, and I am proud to support your nomination and strongly encourage my colleagues to do the same. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Thank you very much, Senator Schmitt. Now let me invite the nominees to come forward to the witness table, and we will swear you in as soon as you are ready. Great. If you just want to remain standing, it is the practice of this Committee to administer the oath to all of our nominees and other witnesses before they testify. So I will invite you to raise your right hand and answer the question that I am about to put to you. [Nominees are sworn in.] Senator Hawley. Very good. You may be seated. In the interest of time, we have your written statements, and if you have additional remarks you would like to make, we will make sure that those are entered into the record. But we are going to forego any further opening statements and move directly to questions. And I will begin. And since I have just taken away your opening statement time, let me, out of my time now, let me invite you, if any of you have family you would like to introduce, there are other folks with you today, go ahead and do that. And we will start with you, Mr. Burrows, and we will just go right down the dais. Mr. Burrows. Thank you, Senator. I believe Senator Moody introduced all my family that is here, but I should also point out to the Committee that Judge Margaret Ryan, who is a judge I clerk for, is here as well. Senator Hawley. Very good. Glad to have them. Judge Benton. Judge Benton. Thank you, Chairman. My family is here, and I think you introduced them all. My husband, Paul, my father-in- law Mike, his friend Sheila, and my father. [The prepared statement of Judge Benton appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Hawley. Very good. Glad to have all of you. Mr. Lea. Mr. Lea. Thank you, Chairman. So my wife, Puja, is here, who has made me pursuing public service possible, so thank you to her. My mother, Lou, my boys, who will be in and out of the room, and my father-in-law, Radesh, and my mother-in-law, Raksha. [Laughter.] [The prepared statement of Mr. Lea appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Hawley. Very good. Glad to have them. Mr. Olson. Mr. Olson. Thank you, Senator Hawley. I am joined today by my wife, Leah, and three of my five children: Evangeline, Camille, and Calvin. And I know the two younger ones are probably watching ``Bluey'' at home. [The prepared statement of Mr. Olson appears as a submission for the record.] Senator Hawley. Very good. Very good. Well, let me just ask a question or two of you, all as the time permits. Let me start with you, Judge Benton, if I could. According to the U.S. Sentencing Commission, I noticed that they recently released stats about the sentencing matters that most often come before the Western District of Missouri. I am sure these won't surprise you. Drug crimes account for about 43 percent of that docket; firearm offenses, 24 percent; and then fraud, theft, and embezzlement offenses, about 10 percent. So just tell the Committee, are these offenses that you have seen before? Are these the sort of sentences that you are familiar with giving before? Tell us a little bit about your experience. Judge Benton. Yes, I have seen nearly all of those cases in State courts, and I have handled sentencing hearings on nearly all of those, if not all of those. And the sentencing guidelines in Missouri, the factors that you look at when deciding whether--or what sentence is appropriate to give someone in Missouri are nearly identical to what you look at as a Federal judge. Senator Hawley. So you have quite a bit of experience in administering a guideline system that is very close to the Federal system and presiding over all of the relevant topics and cases that you would see as a Federal judge. Is that fair to say? Judge Benton. That is. Senator Hawley. I said earlier in my introduction that you have presided over approximately 250 sentencings as a State court trial judge. What experience have you gleaned from that? I mean, obviously, you can't talk about the substance of any of those cases, but what have you learned from that that will prepare you to do this job, if you are confirmed? Judge Benton. I have learned that you look at each case individually. You give each case the time that it deserves. You look at the crime itself, and you look at the factors behind that crime. You look at the severity of that crime, and then you take care to look at the defendant, and the characteristics of that defendant. You carefully read that presentence report, and you go into every sentencing hearing prepared. And you also hold a hearing, and you listen to all parties and all witnesses who wish to speak. Senator Hawley. You are very familiar with the inside of a courtroom from behind the judge's bench. I think it is fair to say you are also very familiar with the inside of a courtroom from behind counsel's table. You were a prosecutor for a number of years. I think I said in my introduction that you tried 50 cases to verdict. That is a lot. Tell us about your experience as a prosecutor, seeing it from the other side of the bench, as it were. How has that informed your judgment? How has that affected your practice, your service as a judge, having seen it from the other side? Judge Benton. As a prosecutor, I was fortunate to first chair jury trials, to first chair bench trials, to deal with victims, to carefully look at cases, to talk to opposing counsel. And when you see it from that perspective, when you are in the courtroom nearly daily working on cases, working in front of judges, on the other side as a judge, you understand the process a bit better, and you come to that process--you approach that process from a position of experience. Senator Hawley. Very good. Senator Durbin. Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Olson, I understand that early in your career, you took on a pro bono case involving DACA recipients. Mr. Olson. I did, Your Honor--Senator. Senator Durbin. And what was your impression of those clients? Mr. Olson. Those clients were good people, and I was happy to help them. Senator Durbin. Did you have any question as to whether they had an aspiration to be part of the future of the United States? Mr. Olson. Based on the legal work that I did for them, I assume that was the case. I didn't know them at a personal level. But I think that's a fair assumption to make. Senator Durbin. I have been involved in this for a while. Twenty-four years ago, I introduced the DREAM Act, which led to DACA under President Obama. And there is still some 800,000 out there protected by DACA who are in question as to their future disposition. If a case came before you considering the legality or constitutionality of DACA, what would you do? Mr. Olson. Well, Senator, I think as many nominees before this Committee have stated, I will not give hints or, you know, prejudge how a case might come before me. I will apply all applicable law to that question and uphold the rights of the individuals who come before me. Senator Durbin. You wouldn't recuse yourself? Mr. Olson. I would--any recusal question that would come before me, I would take on a case-by-case basis and apply the relevant considerations to that. Senator Durbin. Thank you. Mr. Lea, among your clients in private practice was a major tobacco company, R.J. Reynolds, in product liability and wrongful death cases. In those cases, you defended the company against claims brought by plaintiffs and sought the reduction or vacatur of judgments to plaintiffs. In one certain position that you drafted, you went so far as to challenge the connection between cigarettes a woman smoked and the larynx cancer she was diagnosed with at age 36. As you sit before us today, can you acknowledge that cigarettes and other products made by tobacco companies can and do cause cancer? Mr. Lea. Yes, Senator. Senator Durbin. I am sorry? Mr. Lea. Yes, Senator. Senator Durbin. Well, that's good. What about gun laws? You had an interesting case concerning open carry in classrooms and the right of a professor to bar students from carrying guns in the classroom. Do you remember that? Mr. Lea. Not quite in those terms. But I think I know the case you were talking about. Senator Durbin. Could you--if I didn't state it properly, would you do so now? Mr. Lea. It was a group of professors who had retained our firm to argue that a Georgia State law was interfering with their ability whether or not to be able to permit guns in their classroom. They thought that they would have that authority through the Board of Regents, and they felt like the State law infringed upon that. Senator Durbin. And what position did you argue? Mr. Lea. We represented the professors, and so it was a State constitutional law argument. This would have been 2017 or so, kind of a separation-of-powers argument. Senator Durbin. And did that color your judgment as to the Second Amendment rights individuals have? Mr. Lea. The case itself did not involve the Second Amendment. It was a State law right. There was just no connection. But obviously, I would faithfully apply any binding precedent involving the Constitution. Senator Durbin. Did that experience influence your reaction to the Brown University incident over the weekend? Mr. Lea. No. That was obviously a tragedy, but I did not-- you know, I kept my legal position and views separate from acknowledging the clear tragedy at Brown. Senator Durbin. Mr. Burrows, 2 months ago, texts were leaked from a group chat of a number of young Republican leaders across the country revealing racist, misogynistic, and antisemitic language, including, for example, a message stating, quote, ``I love Hitler,'' closed quote. Two of those individuals led the Kansas Young Republicans chapter: William Hendrix and Alex Dwyer. Both participated in using inexcusable language. Mr. Hendrix made racial slurs and used the N-word. Mr. Dwyer referred to white supremacist neo- Nazi code. Rightfully so, Mr. Hendrix and others lost their jobs. Yet some have defended them, most notably Vice President Vance, waved off these disgusting texts as nothing more than, quote, ``edgy, offensive jokes'' made by, quote, ``kids.'' Mr. Burrows, let me ask you, do you know or have you worked with Mr. Hendrix and Mr. Dwyer? Mr. Burrows. I believe Mr. Hendrix was hired when I worked at Kansas Attorney General's Office. So yes, I--I know him. Senator Durbin. What is your reaction to those quotes? Mr. Burrows. I mean, obviously, it's problematic. Senator, I believe I'm over my time. Can I finish my response? Senator Hawley. Yes, by all means. Go ahead. Mr. Burrows. And, I reject any, you know, racism, division of people by characteristics, immutable or religion, anything like that. I think they were right to fire him. Senator Durbin. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Senator Lee. Senator Lee. Thanks so much, Mr. Chairman. Thanks to all of you for being here. Mr. Lea, why don't we start with you? I--apparently, I have been spelling my name wrong all these years. I will have to tell my family, I have got one of seven children. It is going to be a lot of name changing, but--yes, yes, yes, exactly. Perhaps we can explore later whether we are related. It--it could happen. Let's talk about Chevron for a second. Tell me how you think Loper Bright changed the landscape on administrative law, specifically just on the level of deference that needs to be applied under the APA to an agency. Mr. Lea. Sure. So before Loper Bright, the Chevron regime reigned, which was supposed to mean, according to the precedent, that if an issue was not directly and conclusively resolved by statute, which is itself a question that's often by the beholder, the agency could then come in, and so long as whatever it did was reasonable, you would go with what the agency did. It would be effectively legally binding and could control the case. That had been criticized for a long time. Loper Bright stepped in and said, no, the APA textually commits interpretation of legal rules to the courts, and therefore, judges cannot pass that off to let the administration effectively make its own rules, unless the law does that very clearly, as some laws do. And so Loper Bright took away that deference. Senator Lee. Unless it is committed to agency action or---- Mr. Lea. Exactly. Senator Lee [continuing]. Or something like that where they---- Mr. Lea. That is right. Senator Lee. Yes. That is a good point, and--because otherwise, you end up in a circumstance in which the U.S. Government or a U.S. Government agency is there with a stacked deck. It has to defend things only to a less significant degree relative to other litigants. And where the lawmaking power is concerned, this is especially concerning. So post-Chevron--after Chevron's demise, is the major questions doctrine still good? And how, if at all, has major questions doctrine been changed by Loper Bright? Mr. Lea. So that is currently a subject of a great deal of debate. Some people look at Loper Bright and say, look, the major questions doctrine was adopted mostly to try to take the edge off Chevron because of the extreme way it empowered administrative agencies. Other folks say, well, that's a different issue. The question whether a question is major and can be entrusted to an administrative agency still has a role to play. So I mentioned the idea that some laws say an agency can make rulemaking type X, Y, or Z. Some people say, well, the major questions doctrine could still help you determine whether an issue falls within that delegation. Senator Lee. Right. Mr. Lea. And so that's working its way through the courts now and being worked out case by case. Senator Lee. At some level, some of this tends to focus back inevitably on the intelligible principle concept and what the intelligible principle consists of. Some have suggested that perhaps one way around that might ultimately lead the courts into saying that the intelligible principle must mean more than simply identifying an agency and narrowing the field in which it may operate and to actually confine it in a way that provides notice to the individual whose life, liberty, or property interests might be impaired by failure to comply with the Federal rule of law. Article I, Sections 1 and 7, make clear that we are the lawmaking organ of the U.S. Government, and one could conclude that one is not on adequate notice unless--or until one's affirmative legal obligations are made clear by the Article I organ. I assume you--you wouldn't dismiss that as outside the possibilities of where the Supreme Court might ultimately go with this. Mr. Lea. No one would add that there remain at least two binding precedents that did, in fact, strike down laws on grounds of delegating effectively too much unbounded lawmaking power. Senator Lee. Right, right. And the fact that we can't identify more than those has, in the eyes of some, including some currently sitting on the Supreme Court, that perhaps we ought to take another look at it. Mr. Olson, let's talk for a minute about universal injunctions. What is your understanding of a judge's equitable authority to enter a universal injunction after the Supreme Court's recent ruling in Trump v. CASA? Are universal injunctions still permitted after that? And if so, what restrictions fall under that? Mr. Olson. Senator, my understanding of universal injunctions is that they are generally not permitted after Trump v. CASA. The equitable relief that a court may provide is limited to the parties before the court. Senator Lee. That likely inheres in the nature of equitable authority itself. At equity, that is the whole point of equitable power, is that other forms of relief aren't sufficient. Money damages aren't sufficient. If somebody from the Government is about to bulldoze your home, you don't want damages after the fact. You want your house not to be bulldozed. It is specific. It is unique to that case, so it lends itself well to that. I see my time has expired. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Senator Whitehouse. Senator Whitehouse. Thank you, Senator Hawley. I just want to take my time this morning to address the events that took place in Providence, Rhode Island, at Brown University and some of the aftermath of that. And I just want to make clear that, first of all, this was a crime. This was a murder--two murders so far, and it is an ongoing active investigation. We don't know who did it. We don't know what motivated them. And speculation, particularly out on the internet, by people who have no idea what they are talking about, who have no clue about what is happening, is not helpful to the investigation. It gets people agitated and revved up, and it causes a lot of stupidity to cascade into tiplines that then law enforcement officials have to try to work through. There is simply no need, from an investigative point of view, for people who have no idea what they are talking about to offer their stupid and ill-informed views about what happened, all over the internet. So I would please, just from a law enforcement perspective, ask anyone who sees this to just shut up until we know who did it and why. We will find out. Give it some time. This wasn't just a crime. It was also a tragedy. Two families who were looking forward to their college student son and daughter coming home for the holidays are now having to prepare funerals. They probably had already bought presents for their children. This has to come as perhaps the most savage blow that a parent can face. And for the parents of the students who are still in the hospital, and may well be in the hospital for some time through the holidays, all of their holiday plans have changed as well. They are not going to be around the tree with their kids. They are going to be in a hotel, visiting a hospital room in a State far from home. So give those families a bit of grace, too. Ill-informed and unnecessary speculation about what went on does those families no good at all, particularly not as they are trying to get through this immediate grief with the holidays ahead of them and all of their family expectations for those holidays now dashed into grief. So whether it is to protect the law enforcement investigation from a lot of unnecessary and ill-informed noise cluttering up the ability of the many agencies working on this to do their jobs, or whether it is out of simple courtesy and sympathy to the families that are going through this awful moment, just please shut up with the speculation. Sympathy and concern, reaching out helpfully is always welcome. I am grateful for the Chairman calling attention to this in the way that he did--the Ranking Member, I should say. But all the rest of this stuff, all the conspiracy theories, all the creepy, weird plot ideas--please, just knock it off. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Senator Whitehouse. Senator Kennedy. Senator Kennedy. Mr. Olson, I believe I am looking at your resume. You are an elder in the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America. Is that correct? Mr. Olson. I am an ordained elder in the RPCNA. I am not actively serving. Senator Kennedy. In August of 2015, you gave a sermon at the Second Reformed Presbyterian Church. Do you remember that? Mr. Olson. 2015, I think that might have been a Sunday school lecture, but I spoke, yes. Senator Kennedy. During that sermon, you said that marriage was not intended for all people, including--and I am going to quote your words--``our handicapped friends or our persons with physical disabilities that might prevent the robust marriage that we're called to,'' closed quote. Did you say that? Mr. Olson. I think I did, Senator, yes. Senator Kennedy. You believe that folks with handicaps and physical disabilities should not be able to marry? Mr. Olson. No, Senator. The--I was explaining the meaning of Christ's words that some, to use Christ's terms, are eunuchs by birth and explaining that--the meaning of that verse in the context of those who are called to singleness and that there are various reasons why individuals don't get married and that---- Senator Kennedy. Yes, yes, but--but what about folks who are handicapped or who have developmental disabilities? Mr. Olson. I was using that example as an illustration of why some don't get married, not as a kind of reason why someone shouldn't. It was illustrative of the condition in which some find themselves, but certainly not in any stretch of the imagination suggesting that they couldn't or shouldn't, merely that in some cases they don't. Senator Kennedy. On July 24, 2022, you gave another sermon at the Columbia Reformed Presbyterian Church. Do you remember that? Mr. Olson. The Columbus Reformed Presbyterian Church, yes. Senator Kennedy. You were speaking about sexuality. Is that correct? Mr. Olson. I gave two sermons at that church, and the main topic of both of those was not human sexuality. I---- Senator Kennedy. In one of them you said, quote, ``Transgenderism, homosexuality, fornication, and all sorts of sexual perversions was a form of hypocrisy from,'' quote--your words, ``shame on the inside.'' Did you say that? Mr. Olson. That--uh--I don't recall the precise wording, but that sounds familiar. Senator Kennedy. What did you mean by that? Mr. Olson. Yes, Senator, thanks for the opportunity to clarify that. So I was preaching a sermon on a passage in the Old Testament about an Old Testament King Uzziah---- Senator Kennedy. Yes, but---- Mr. Olson [continuing]. Who was stricken with leprosy---- Senator Kennedy [continuing]. I don't have a lot of time, Counselor. Tell me what you meant by that. Mr. Olson. Sure. That many---- Senator Kennedy. Do you believe that fornication is a form of sexual perversion? Mr. Olson. Senator, my--my personal views, my religious views, what I was speaking at that time were for the edification of--of the people that I was preaching to. As a judge sitting here today, my--my obligation is to apply the rule of law---- Senator Kennedy. Yes, I understand that---- Mr. Olson [continuing]. And the Constitution---- Senator Kennedy [continuing]. But my obligation is to try to understand you. Because this is a lifetime appointment. Do you believe that--that fornication, which I assume you mean by that the sex act, is a form of sexual perversion? Mr. Olson. Senator, the doctrine of the church that I was at does state that fornication is a sin. Senator Kennedy. Well, what do you mean by fornication? Mr. Olson. Any--any sexual act outside of the bounds of marriage. Senator Kennedy. Okay. So you believe premarital sex is a sexual perversion? Mr. Olson. Senator, my--again, my personal views, as many have said before, I won't comment, but the doctrine of the church that I belong to---- Senator Kennedy. Is it your doctrine? Mr. Olson. I--I took, as an elder, I took a vow---- Senator Kennedy. Is it your doctrine? Mr. Olson. As an elder of the RPCNA---- Senator Kennedy. Is it your doctrine? Mr. Olson. Senator, my personal views as a judge are not the object of what I would rule upon. Senator Kennedy. All right. Give me one more minute, please, Mr. Chairman. On August the 23rd of 2015, you--you spoke in Sunday school, and you said, quote, ``I'm not saying women can't have careers. That's not what I am saying.'' No, strike that. I am reading the wrong quote. I apologize. In your talks at your Sunday school, you said that God, quote, ``has called wives to be subject to their husband,'' end quote, and to, quote, ``serve the good of your husband and support his calling,'' closed quote. Did you say that? Mr. Olson. Again, I gave a couple Sunday school lectures around that time. I don't recall the particular one, but I think I recall saying something along those lines, yes. Senator Kennedy. What did you mean by that? Mr. Olson. So in Christian marriage, as explained by the Apostles, the--I was describing our church's understanding of what Christian marriage ought to look like. Senator Kennedy. And you believe Christian marriage provides that women have to be subservient to--to their husbands? Mr. Olson. Senator, I think I was quoting either a passage in Ephesians or--those are not my words. Those are--those are words in the---- Senator Kennedy [continuing]. Well, you said them. Mr. Olson [continuing]. Scriptures that I was---- Senator Kennedy. Do you believe them? Mr. Olson. Senator, I believe every word of the Bible. Senator Kennedy. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Mr. Olson, can I just follow up on that? Since those--you raised interesting questions, but let me just ask you. You are an ordained elder in your church. Is that correct? Mr. Olson. In my former church. I've actually transitioned to a different denomination. But I'm in a bit of a transition period, I still maintain my ordination, will resolve that through the Presbyterian order at some point in the near future. Senator Hawley. Well, let me just ask you this. If you are confirmed to this position, what is the law, rule, and authority that you will be bound to follow as a member of the judiciary? Mr. Olson. That is the United States Constitution, applicable Federal and State statutes, and binding precedent. Senator Hawley. Can you, in good conscience, consistent with your religious beliefs, including the ones that Senator Kennedy was just asking you about--can you in good conscience submit to the United States Constitution all relevant laws, precedents, and so forth, and apply those faithfully, if confirmed? Mr. Olson. Absolutely, Senator. Senator Hawley. Can you do that without reservation? Mr. Olson. Without reservation. That is the oath that I will take. Senator Hawley. Would that be your highest legal authority as a member of the judiciary, should you be confirmed? Mr. Olson. My highest legal authority is to my Nation, and that our Nation is governed by the United States Constitution. Senator Hawley. And the supreme--and the supreme law of this Nation, which is positive law, which is the United States Constitution, statutes and precedents, and the relevant order. Mr. Olson. That's correct. Senator Hawley. Senator Schiff. Senator Schiff. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Burrows, thank you for taking the time to meet with my staff. I understand one of your responsibilities in the Office of Legal Policy would be to revise and oversee the Justice Department Manual. Let me ask you about the Manual, in particular, one section of the Manual, 9-27.220, which provides the threshold requirements for prosecution. It states that a prosecutor may commence or recommend Federal prosecution only if he or she believes that the person will, more likely than not, be found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by an unbiased trier of fact and that the conviction will be upheld on appeal. Do you agree with that policy in the Justice Manual? Mr. Burrows. Thank you for that question, Senator. I believe that policy is consistent with the prosecutorial ethics codes of most States. And certainly, if I go to the Department of Justice, all the prosecutors there are bound by the Justice Manual and other policies of the Department. My personal beliefs about whether it's correct are sort of irrelevant at that point. But nonetheless, I have followed that requirement throughout my career as a prosecutor, 6\1/2\ years in the U.S. Attorney's Office in Denver, as well as---- Senator Schiff. Mr. Burrows, I just want to make sure. You say your views are irrelevant. But they are not irrelevant if your task is going to be revisiting the Manual to determine whether the Manual should be changed. That section also provides, both as a matter of fundamental fairness and in the interest of efficient administration of justice, no prosecution should be initiated against any person unless the attorney for the Government believes that admissible evidence is sufficient to obtain and sustain a guilty verdict by an unbiased trier of fact. I ask about this section in light of a few things--in light of the fact that, for example, in the case of Letitia James, the U.S. attorney has now repeatedly gone before a grand jury, and grand juries have returned ``no true bill'' because they found that the standard for probable cause could not even be met, a much lower burden than beyond a reasonable doubt. Career prosecutors had recommended against those cases for exactly this reason--that they did not believe it met the Justice Department Manual standard. That is, they did not believe it could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. In Los Angeles, we have another U.S. attorney, like Halligan, unlawfully appointed, named Bill Essayli, who has apparently gone before the grand jury so many times and received a no bill from the grand jury that his nickname in the office is now, ``No Bill Essayli.'' As a result of--in fact, he was overheard, apparently, reportedly, by a grand jury screaming through the phone, ``F-- the Justice Manual.'' Now, what portion of the Justice Manual he wanted to ``F'' wasn't clear. But it is clear that grand juries continue to refuse indictments and that a lot of the career attorneys are leaving that office in droves. The office is down more than 80 attorneys. Dozens have left, many citing moral dilemmas being posed by the leadership of that office. So let me ask you this. What--what would the remedy be for prosecutors that are willfully ignoring important provisions of the Justice Manual? Mr. Burrows. Senator, I think your question brings up two things. First, I think it's important to note that the Office of Legal Policy is not involved in decisions in any particular investigation, any particular prosecution. Our job is to set forth broad parameters under which prosecutors would exercise their discretion that they have. Senator Schiff. No, I get that, but you establish a policy or you affirm a policy such as you don't seek an indictment where you don't believe you can prove the case at trial. What do you do, what do you recommend, what sanctions should be applied to prosecutors that repeatedly willfully ignore that basic principle of fairness? Mr. Burrows. So I have not been read--I don't understand the details of the actual internal process of the Department of Justice. I haven't had that come up in my career. Nonetheless, my understanding is that if people are violating departmental policies, there are various ways, whether it be through, you know, employment discipline channels or whether it be through the professional responsibility offices, that those are dealt with. But nonetheless, I have been---- Senator Schiff. So if I could just ask--and I know my time is running out--one last question. Would it be appropriate, then, for attorneys who are willfully violating important policy provisions in the Justice Manual, like you don't seek an indictment or you don't believe you can prove the case, to be referred to the Office of Professional Responsibility for potential sanctions? Would that be appropriate? Mr. Burrows. May I answer the question, Senator? Senator, those are questions for the people that are in supervision over those people, which is not the Office of Legal Policy. That would be the Deputy Attorney General and the Attorney General. Senator Schiff. But you will support that policy that I read to you? Mr. Burrows. I don't have any reason to think that that policy needs to be changed--no. Senator Schiff. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Senator Blackburn. Senator Blackburn. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And, again, welcome to each of you. I want to come to Mr. Lea. Let's talk about your clerkship with Justice Thomas. And for the Committee, I want you to outline how that influences the work you would do on the bench. Mr. Lea. Thank you very much, Senator. So clerking for Justice Thomas was an incredible honor. I have to say at the outset that he, you know, plucked me as an unpolished lawyer out of a law school, which he does regularly. He goes and casts a wide net for people he thinks to be talented clerks. One aspect on the bench is hiring. I always felt very good about that. That is something I would, in my own small way, like to emulate to the substance of the law. I have met and been around very many good judges. I have never seen somebody so thoroughly committed to applying the law by his best lights as it was originally understood without fear or favor. The biggest lesson I took from the clerkship was that that is the job of a judge, and you should not take on the robe unless you're willing to do that. And so if I had to sum up one thing, it is that. Then on a personal level, incredibly decent, kind human being. My family had a bit of a family tragedy kind of happen, and the idea that a boss in that position would be so incredibly supportive and knows the family members of, it seems like, every employee in the courtroom, which is--now that sort of decency is something that I can only hope to emulate. Senator Blackburn. We have the Memphis Safe Task Force going on right now, which has been very successful. They are in West Tennessee, cutting the crime rate in half over the last 3 months, and so the court is going to have a heavy docket. You are going to have a large criminal docket that you are going to have to manage. So I want you to speak a little bit about how you are going to move into the court and how you would manage that heavy docket that you know is going to be there. Mr. Lea. Certainly. So I think the biggest tip when I talk to people who have been judges is to have systems in place to make sure that the docket is moving along speedily, and that if you don't have those, you will wind up at sea. So I come in with eyes open about the need to have those sorts of docket management techniques abiding by timelines. There is, frankly, no substitute for sweat equity beyond that. You could have your systems, but you just have to be able to put in the long hours and manage a large caseload. That is something I did as a coordinating counsel, sort of, role in private practice. It is something I have done at the Department of Justice. I feel that those skills, writ broadly, will translate very well with solid systems to making sure that justice is not delayed. Because we all know that justice delayed is justice denied. Senator Blackburn. Well, the task force has been very successful. They have topped 4,200 arrests and recovered 123 missing children. So moving this docket forward is important. I was down in Memphis on Friday, and this is one of the topics of conversation is, getting you seated and having you move forward in an effective and efficient way, working with the other judges that are on that bench. Talk a little bit about your work over at the Department of Justice and how that informs what you will do on the bench. Mr. Lea. Certainly. So as a Deputy Associate Attorney General, I assist the Associate Attorney General and the Deputy Attorney General and then the AG primarily with the litigating units that are civil. And so through my time there, I have had, sort of, point- of-contact responsibility for the Civil Division, the Tax Division, Environmental and Natural Resources, and the Civil Rights Division at different points. I think the biggest way that translates beyond the--like even broadening my already, sort of, general exposure to the law in a lot of areas is, frankly, the docket management and efficiency-focused nature of the job. Because the Department of Justice just has so much going on and is so busy doing the Nation's legal work that you have to have those sort of systems in place. So I think it's a good starting place to transition into a heavy caseload. Senator Blackburn. Thank you very much. Ms. Benton, I am delighted to know that you spent your law school at Vanderbilt. We like seeing that, and we wish you well. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. Thank you, Senator Blackburn. Senator Cruz. Senator Cruz. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. To each of the nominees before us, Mr. Burrows, Judge Benton, Mr. Lea, Mr. Olson, congratulations on your nominations, and thank you for your willingness to serve. And yet, even as we begin with congratulations, we do so under the shadow of grief. This hearing is occurring at a moment of national sorrow and reflection. This past weekend, Americans were reminded once again of how suddenly violence can intrude into ordinary life. At Brown University, a classroom meant for learning and safety became a scene of gunfire, driving students preparing for final examinations into fear and flight, and tragically taking the lives of two students. Almost simultaneously, across the world in Sydney, Australia, an antisemitic terror attack at a Hanukkah gathering on Bondi Beach left families shattered and an entire Jewish community in mourning. And here at home, Americans woke up to the horrifying news out of Los Angeles--the deaths of Rob and Michele Reiner, a tragedy that underscores how close violence can come, even within the family. In moments like this, our country needs moral clarity, a reaffirmation that murder is evil, whether it wears the mask of terror, ideology, hatred, or despair. And our country needs institutions that can do the basic work of civilization: protecting the innocent, punishing the guilty, and applying the law fairly without fear or favor. That is why today's hearing matters. Mr. Burrows, you have an impressive legal background, having served in the upper echelons of both State and Federal Government. You have been nominated to lead the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Policy, a role that helps shape the Department's legal direction and plays a central role in vetting and preparing judicial nominees. Judge Benton, Mr. Lea, Mr. Olson, you all, together, bring the kind of experience that the Federal trial courts depend on. Frontline prosecution, trial and appellate practice, and years of Federal litigation, including service as assistant United States attorneys and in demanding private practice. Mr. Burrows, I would like to start with you. After weekends like this, marked by mass violence, terrorism, and profound loss, Americans are expecting our institutions to carry out what the Trump administration has pledged to do: confront evil directly; enforce the law without hesitation; and administer justice without allowing it to be twisted into becoming a political weapon. As the head of the Office of Legal Policy--the legal brain trust of the Department of Justice, how do you see DOJ's duty to respond to political violence decisively, whether it be outside a house of worship, at a university, or outside a pregnancy center, while remaining grounded in the law as written and within constitutional limits? Mr. Burrows. Thank you for the question, Senator. I think you've hit on a very important issue. Political violence strikes at the heart of our constitutional system of government and what it means to be an American in a way that ordinary crime, if you will, does not, in that it attacks people simply for being a part of a political coalition or exercising their rights or something like that. Obviously, I think the Department of Justice historically, since, you know, Reconstruction has focused on stamping out political violence in places in which it suppresses the vote, in places in which it keeps people from exercising their religion or practicing their religion, et cetera, et cetera. And I certainly hope and intend that the Department of Justice would maintain the leading role that we have had, you know, since the Reconstruction amendments in doing that based on legislation that Congress has passed. Senator Cruz. So to each of the judicial nominees, I want to ask you briefly to share with this Committee the importance of the First Amendment and what it means to the American people. And Judge Benton, we will start with you. Judge Benton. The First Amendment is the First Amendment for a reason. It is one of if not the foundations of our Constitution and of our rights. Mr. Lea. The First Amendment obviously contains the five freedoms--freedom of speech, freedom of press, free exercise, freedom of assembly, and freedom of petition, in addition to the Establishment Clause. And in many ways, that not only guarantees freedom to hold and to exercise some of the most fundamental beliefs, but also via the freedom of speech and press to participate in democracy in a way that makes democracy possible. So it's a real cornerstone of our system of government. Mr. Olson. Thank you, Senator. I concur with my colleagues' comments. The only thing I would add to what they've already said is that our Nation was founded by those with strongly held religious views who were dissenters from many of the nations that they came from. And the First Amendment reflects this rich heritage and tradition. Senator Cruz. Thank you. Senator Hawley. Senator Moody. Senator Moody. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, again, to not just those that are sitting at the table today taking tough questions so that they can serve the people but to all the family members that showed up and are standing behind them. I know what that means to stand behind someone offering themselves up to serve and a nominee that is right here at a table like this, and so thank you for being here with them. I think they would probably turn around and tell you it is easier knowing you are at their back, so thank you for being here. One--as a prior judge myself, coming from a family of judges, one of the things I think is most threatening to our Nation at this moment in time is the public beginning to believe that there are judges in this country--and I think the actions of some would demonstrate that that belief might be merited--are trading in their black robes for blue jerseys, and that is not what this very delicate balance of the separation of powers ensures. In fact, for this country to remain the greatest nation on the face of this earth that has come up with this way of we, the free people, governing ourselves, we have to have men and women of integrity serving on the bench that understand their jobs, not just what it entails but what it does not entail, and the concept of judicial restraint. And I would like to start with you, Ms. Benton. You are actually coming from the State court, a trial court level, a circuit court judge. I was a circuit court judge myself. And this is a big transition going from a State court judge to a district court judge. Tell me a little bit about why you think being a State court judge benefits you moving into a new jurisdiction, the Federal jurisdiction, and specifically your thoughts on the concept of judicial restraint. Judge Benton. So thank you. As a State court judge in Missouri, I preside over jury trials. I preside over bench trials. I preside over hearings. I'm in the courtroom daily. And the Missouri Rules of Federal Procedure are nearly identical to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Additionally, as a district court judge, if I'm so fortunate to be confirmed, over half of my civil cases will be cases sitting in diversity where I will apply Missouri State law, and I believe that that well prepares me for the office of a Federal district judge. And on the concept of judicial restraint, I believe that, you know, judges are independent and free of the political process for a reason. Under Article I and Article II, the executive and the legislative branches were held accountable and meant to hold--be held accountable to the people through the electoral process. Judges are insulated from that process because they have to make impartial decisions based on the law, and from time to time, those are counter-majoritarian. So it's very important that a judge realizes that her job is to interpret the law as it is written and apply the law. Senator Moody. Were there instances, Mr. Burrows, of judges exceeding their scope of power that you were faced with when you were working within the Attorney General's Office? Mr. Burrows. Thank you for the question, Senator. I--the short answer is yes, and there were political restrictions on that. It was the position of our office, certainly, that the Kansas Supreme Court had overstepped its proper bounds under the State constitution several times. Right now, the citizens of Kansas are considering a constitutional amendment to change how those judges are selected. So there are ways to counteract those things. But under our system of government, I think it is exceptionally important that Congress stay in its lane, that the executive stay in its lane, and that judges stay in their lane. That's the system of government that the Founders designed and that has endured since 1787, and part of the reason that it has endured is because it was finely tuned. But it only works when everybody's doing their job. Senator Moody. And I want to thank the President who is making nominations now, people who understand that the judges-- the role of a judge, there is a limit on power, and there is-- it is absolutely essential that we have people offering themselves up to service that understand the importance of that for the continuity and success of this incredible Nation of ours. So, again, thank you for being here. Thank you for serving We the People. We are very grateful, and I look forward to supporting your nominations. Senator Hawley. Senator Blumenthal. Senator Blumenthal. Thank you, Senator Hawley. I would like to ask the judicial nominees, maybe in order of you're sitting there, who won the popular vote in the 2020 election? Judge Benton. And I'll start, Senator. In 2020, Joseph Biden was declared the victor. Senator Blumenthal. Well, who won the popular vote? Judge Benton. And in 2020, Joseph Biden was declared the winner of the election. Senator Blumenthal. So President Biden won the popular vote. That is your testimony. Judge Benton. And he was declared the winner, Senator. Mr. Lea. Same answer, Senator. Mr. Olson. Same answer, Senator. Senator Blumenthal. Well, then let me ask you, who won the Electoral College in the 2020 election? Judge Benton. And the same answer, Senator. Mr. Lea. Joe Biden was certified as the winner and served for 4 years. Mr. Olson. Same answer. Senator Blumenthal. Did Donald Trump lose the 2020 election? Judge Benton. And, Senator, my answer is the same. Joseph Biden was certified as the winner. Senator Blumenthal. Well, wouldn't you--you would agree with me that you are not answering the question. Correct? Judge Benton. And I will just repeat that Joseph Biden was certified as the winner. Senator Blumenthal. I mean, you can choose not to answer the question, but please don't insult my intelligence by asking me to accept that answer. You can say you don't want to answer the question. That is fine. But to say that Biden was certified as the winner, I am asking you, did Donald Trump lose the 2020 election? Judge Benton. And my answer is the same. As a sitting judge under Rule 2 of the Missouri Rules of Judicial Ethics and both the ADA, Rule 2, I can't give any further commentary on any pending or impending litigation or any cases. Mr. Lea. Same answer, Senator. Senator Blumenthal. Same answer--yours? Also declined to answer. Mr. Lea. No, Joe Biden was certified as the winner and served 4 years as President. Mr. Olson. Same answer, Senator. Joe--Donald Trump was not certified as the winner of the 2020 election. Senator Blumenthal. You know, these are basic facts. They are not political. They are, like, is the sun shining today? They are a matter of historical record. I don't know how I can vote for someone who declines to answer a clear, factual question and who seems unwilling to recognize the truth. We are not talking here about the politics of the issue. It is a matter of fact. Let me ask you this, Judge Benton. Was the United States Capitol attacked on January 6, 2021? Judge Benton. And, again, Senator, as a sitting judge under Rule 2 of the Missouri Rules of Judicial Ethics, I believe that there are cases pending in front of courts. And so, due to pending or impending litigation, I cannot comment on anything of political controversy. Senator Blumenthal. I am not asking about a specific individual. Was the Capitol attacked? Judge Benton. And, again, I do believe that there are cases currently in front of courts. And so, as a sitting judge, under Rule 2, I cannot answer. Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Lea? Mr. Lea. Same answer. And I would add that as an employee of the Department of Justice, I would refer to the Department of Justice's positions in briefs. Senator Blumenthal. Mr. Olson? Mr. Olson. Senator, the January 6th events are a matter of public controversy and debate on how to characterize those. And I think to wade into that robust public---- Senator Blumenthal. Well, tell me what your characterization is of that--those events. Mr. Olson. Well, individuals entered the Capitol, and some of them were charged, and there were cases that arose as a result of those events. Senator Blumenthal. So you agree that the Capitol was attacked? Mr. Olson. Well, Senator, the qualitative characterization, I think, of what happened and how it's been referred to by various individuals is debated. And I think to weigh in on that would be improper. Senator Blumenthal. Well, I am incredulous. I am totally disbelieving that nominees for the Federal district court will not answer purely factual questions just because you are in fear--of what? If you are so much in fear of answering these questions, how will you have the courage to be a fair and impartial judge who follows the law without fear or favor? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hawley. All right, very good. I think that concludes our questions for today. So thank you to the nominees for your testimony. Written questions for the record may be submitted until December the 29th at 5 p.m. And with that, the hearing is adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:38 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.] [Additional material submitted for the record follows.] Prepared Statement of Hon. Megan Blair Benton [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]