Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[Senate Hearing 119-548] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] S. Hrg. 119-548 THE NEED FOR SPEED: HOW TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCES ARE DRIVING TRANSPORTATION INNOVATION ======================================================================= HEARING before the SUBCOMMITTEE ON SURFACE TRANSPORTATION, FREIGHT, PIPELINES, AND SAFETY of the COMMITTEE ON COMMERCE, SCIENCE, AND TRANSPORTATION UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ JUNE 9, 2026 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available online: http://www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 65-595 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 SENATE COMMITTEE ON COMMERCE, SCIENCE, AND TRANSPORTATION ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION TED CRUZ, Texas, Chairman JOHN THUNE, South Dakota MARIA CANTWELL, Washington, ROGER WICKER, Mississippi Ranking DEB FISCHER, Nebraska AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota JERRY MORAN, Kansas BRIAN SCHATZ, Hawaii DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska EDWARD MARKEY, Massachusetts MARSHA BLACKBURN, Tennessee GARY PETERS, Michigan TODD YOUNG, Indiana TAMMY BALDWIN, Wisconsin TED BUDD, North Carolina TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri JACKY ROSEN, Nevada JOHN CURTIS, Utah BEN RAY LUJAN, New Mexico BERNIE MORENO, Ohio JOHN HICKENLOOPER, Colorado TIM SHEEHY, Montana JOHN FETTERMAN, Pennsylvania SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia ANDY KIM, New Jersey CYNTHIA LUMMIS, Wyoming LISA BLUNT ROCHESTER, Delaware Brad Grantz, Republican Staff Director Nicole Christus, Republican Deputy Staff Director Lila Harper Helms, Staff Director Melissa Porter, Deputy Staff Director ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON SURFACE TRANSPORTATION, FREIGHT, PIPELINES, AND SAFETY TODD YOUNG, Indiana, Chairman GARY PETERS, Michigan, Ranking JOHN THUNE, South Dakota AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota ROGER WICKER, Mississippi BRIAN SCHATZ, Hawaii DEB FISCHER, Nebraska EDWARD MARKEY, Massachusetts DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska TAMMY DUCKWORTH, Illinois ERIC SCHMITT, Missouri BEN RAY LUJAN, New Mexico BERNIE MORENO, Ohio ANDY KIM, New Jersey SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on June 9, 2026..................................... 1 Statement of Senator Young....................................... 1 Letter dated June 8, 2026 to Chairman Todd Young and Ranking Member Gary Peters from Jeff Farrah, Chief Executive Officer, Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association........... 57 Letter dated June 8, 2026 to Hon. Ted Cruz, Hon. Maria Cantwell, Hon. Todd Young and Hon. Gary Peters from Anne Reinke, President and CEO, Intermodal Association of North America.................................................... 59 Statement of Senator Peters...................................... 3 Statement of Senator Cantwell.................................... 36 Prepared statement........................................... 36 Statement of Senator Moreno...................................... 40 Statement of Senator Kim......................................... 43 Statement of Senator Lummis...................................... 45 Statement of Senator Lujan....................................... 47 Statement of Senator Cruz........................................ 51 Witnesses Ian Jefferies, President and Chief Executive Officer, Association of American Railroads.......................................... 4 Prepared statement........................................... 5 Chris Spear, President and Chief Executive Officer, American Trucking Associations.......................................... 9 Prepared statement........................................... 10 Laura Chace, President and Chief Executive Officer, ITS America.. 20 Prepared statement........................................... 22 Cole Scandaglia, Deputy Director, International Brotherhood of Teamsters...................................................... 29 Prepared statement........................................... 31 Appendix Letter dated June 9, 2026 to Hon. Todd Young and Hon. Gary Peters from L. Ed Dowell, President, American Train Dispatchers Association.................................................... 61 Letter dated June 8, 2026 to Hon. Todd Young and Hon. Gary Peters from Catherine Chase, President, Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety......................................................... 62 Letter dated June 9, 2026 to Hon. Todd Young and Hon. Gary Peters from John Samuelsen, International President, Transport Workers Union of America (TWU)................... 76 Letter dated June 9, 2026 to Hon. Ted Cruz and Hon. Maria Cantwell from Matt Hollis, National President, Transportation Communications Union (TCU/IAM).............. 78 Research article entitled, ``Cost-benefit analysis of side underride guards for new semitrailers in the United States'' by Eric Hein, Institute for Safer Trucking, United States of America.......................................... 80 Letter dated June 9, 2026 to Chairman Todd Young and Committee Members from Michael S. Baldwin, President, Brotherhood of Railroad Signalment......................... 97 Response to written questions submitted to Ian Jefferies by: Hon. Ted Cruz................................................ 115 Hon. Bernie Moreno........................................... 115 Hon. Maria Cantwell.......................................... 117 Hon. John Hickenlooper....................................... 117 Response to written question submitted to Chris Spear by: Hon. Ted Cruz................................................ 118 Hon. Maria Cantwell.......................................... 119 Hon. John Hickenlooper....................................... 121 Response to written questions submitted to Laura Chace by: Hon. Maria Cantwell.......................................... 122 Hon. Gary Peters............................................. 124 Hon. Tammy Duckworth......................................... 125 Hon. John Hickenlooper....................................... 129 Response to written questions submitted to Cole Scandaglia by: Hon. Maria Cantwell.......................................... 130 Hon. Gary Peters............................................. 134 Hon. John Hickenlooper....................................... 135 THE NEED FOR SPEED: HOW TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCES ARE DRIVING TRANSPORTATION INNOVATION ---------- TUESDAY, JUNE 9, 2026 U.S. Senate, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Washington, DC. The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:04 a.m., in room SR-253, Russell Senate Office Building, Hon. Todd Young, Chairman of the Subcommittee, presiding. Present: Senators Young [presiding], Cruz, Fischer, Moreno, Peters, Cantwell, Lujan, and Kim. Also present: Senator Lummis. OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR TODD YOUNG, U.S. SENATOR FROM INDIANA Senator Young. Good morning everyone, and welcome to today's subcommittee hearing to examine how technology is used and could be used across different transportation ecosystems and how to ensure industry has the flexibility to deploy such technologies voluntarily and in adherence with common sense principles. Over the past decade, we've seen a rise in innovative technologies that require us to reimagine how our transportation networks operate. Technology like autonomous vehicles, or AVs, as we call them, a solution to mobility and safety challenges our roadways have faced for decades. AVs will provide mobility for seniors and those with disabilities while increasing the safety of our roads by drastically reducing the number of crashes that are often caused by human error. In our trucking ecosystem in addition to safety, AVs can better secure supply chains while taking strain away from workers who often drive countless hours to meet deadlines. We've also seen the development of train inspection portals, which can analyze images of trains as they move throughout the country to better understand defects or other maintenance needs that a person may not be able to detect as easily or quickly. By taking the strain away from maintenance workers scouring over every rail car and maintenance bay, cars can get back on the track and continue delivering essential goods. There's also Vehicle-to-everything or V2X technologies that can provide drivers with critical information as they travel, like where construction crews are stationed on highways or where dangerous conditions exist, potentially preventing tragic accidents. I won't go into every technology that exists, of course, I don't want to steal the thunder of our esteemed panelists, but these are only a few of the vast suite of technologies contributing to safer and more efficient roads and tracks that may be discussed today, many of which were only a pipe dream A short time ago. They were, of course, referenced years ago in the Jetsons or Star Trek. But now many of those things are upon us. The technology ecosystem, especially within transportation, is fast and expanding, and it requires flexibility. The Federal Government has done well in the past establishing pilot projects or exemptions to test the effectiveness of certain technologies. However, we're often slow at the Federal level when it comes to expanding proven technologies past the pilot program stage. So to fully realize the benefits of these innovations, we'll need to provide certainty to the private sector and develop pathways to commercialization, especially for proven technologies. Where we've seen success, we've also seen stagnation. Enacted legislation and promulgated rules have mandated technology too nascent in its life cycle or set rules with limited to no flexibility. For instance, over half a decade ago, regulations were effectuated that would require truck drivers to deploy warning triangles whenever they stopped their truck on the side of the road. And for a time, this rule made sense to ensure the safety of other road users and the drivers themselves. As technology advanced, however, alternative solutions were developed with the very same, if not greater, effectiveness. If there are avenues that could allow for industry to provide the same or greater level of efficacy while increasing safety, then I believe Congress should remove the red tape prohibiting this sort of innovation. I'm glad to hear of the recent waiver issued by the Department of Transportation to allow for cab mounted warning beacons in certain instances, eliminating the need for a driver to get out of the vehicle, especially in unsafe situations like low visibility. But this is just one rule that's limiting the ingenuity of our private sector. Our adversaries won't wait for us to tie our shoes. If the technologies that will transform our transportation ecosystem are locked behind outdated rules or tied up in red tape, other countries will develop these solutions first and the job revolution and manufacturing capacity will occur overseas rather than here in Michigan or Indiana. Indiana is the most manufacturing intensive state in the country and known as the Crossroads of America. My state is ready to deliver solutions to meet the manufacturing capacity needs. I'm sure many of my colleagues want the same opportunities for their state as well. So as Congress continues to contemplate legislation, it's imperative that we protect the innovative opportunities that will bolster our supply chains, increase safety, and deliver other workable transportation solutions to meet the needs of our economy. We have an experienced panel covering several different modes of the transportation economy today. I'm looking forward to your testimony to better learn how we can work to advance technological innovation in our transportation ecosystem, to secure American leadership in the industry, and to ensure our private sector has the flexibility it needs to develop and deploy these transformative technologies. Thank you again for being here today, all of you. And I now recognize Ranking Member Peters for his opening remarks. STATEMENT OF SENATOR GARY PETERS, U.S. SENATOR FROM MICHIGAN Senator Peters. Well, thank you, Chairman Young, and thank you to our esteemed witnesses for being here today. Today we're going to be hearing from witnesses across sectors about how technology is transforming our transportation system, from our vehicles to our roads to our railroads. And I have long advocated for harnessing technological innovation to combat the challenges we face in the transportation sector, from unsafe roads, harmful environmental impacts, to freight and infrastructure challenges that raise prices for everyday Americans. A prime example is autonomous vehicles. For years I have said that Congress cannot continue to stand on the sidelines when it comes to these AVs. I believe we must pass a Federal AV framework to harness the safety benefits of this technology, ensure that it is deployed responsibly, and cement U.S. leadership in the development, manufacturing, and deployment on our roads. But autonomous vehicles are only one piece of the technological puzzle. When I first came to the Senate, I helped push for positive train control technology that is now deployed across the rail system to prevent collisions and high-speed train derailments. Last Congress, after the East Palestine derailment, we saw firsthand the importance of wayside detection technology and this committee authored the Railway Safety Act in response. On our roadways, both cities and states have leveraged Federal funds to deploy AI and connected vehicle technology to prevent accidents before they happen and to get first responders to the scene a whole lot faster. We've also seen passenger and commercial vehicle deploy advanced driver assistance systems to help keep both drivers and the public safe. But there's so much more to do. As we talk today about the opportunities and challenges posed by transportation technology and the role Congress should play in driving that innovation, I want to hear--I want to hear from our witnesses in four basic questions. First, how can we harness technology for economic growth? Technology should not just increase efficiency, it should also increase the affordability for Americans. Second, how can this technology support and not replace our workforce? Technology has the potential to improve safety and productivity for American workers, including America's truck drivers, if we play our cards right. But technology should also create good paying American jobs which I believe we must develop and manufacture here at home--here in the United States. And third, how do we ensure emerging transportation technology doesn't compromise Americans privacy or U.S. national security? So for example, today's vehicle technologies have advanced sensor suites that collect and analyze a huge amount of data which would be extremely dangerous in the wrong hands. That's why I pushed to keep Chinese vehicles and vehicle technologies out of the United States, and I want to hear from our witnesses today about protecting data exploitation by our adversaries as well as here at home. And fourth, and most importantly, how can transportation technology be harnessed to save lives? Every year, 40,000 Americans die on our highways and nearly 1,000 die on our railroads. And these aren't just numbers, they're families that will never be whole again. We must take action and we know that technology is certainly part of that solution. I believe it will require government, industry, labor and advocates coming together to address safety crises and to ensure that technology is deployed on our transportation system in a way that benefits all Americans. I look forward to contributing to this effort through our discussion here today. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Senator Young. Well, thank you, Senator Peters. I'd now like to introduce our witnesses for today for this hearing. The Need for Speed, again the catchy title we have. Our first witness is Mr. Ian Jeffries. Mr. Jeffries is the President and Chief Executive Officer of the Association of American Railroads. He has led AAR since January 2019. He has over a decade of experience in transportation policy, including roles at Federal agencies and the Senate Commerce Committee. Mr. Jeffries. STATEMENT OF IAN JEFFERIES, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ASSOCIATION OF AMERICAN RAILROADS Mr. Jeffries. Good morning, Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, other members of the Subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. Today's hearing comes at an important moment for American transportation. Next year, believe it or not, freight railroads will mark their 200th anniversary. An industry grounded in history but being rapidly transformed by innovation. The modern rail network increasingly relies on AI assisted inspections, machine vision, predictive analytics, advanced sensors, and real time data. These tools help identify risks earlier and improve safety across the 140,000 mile network and enhance service reliability. And the results are clear. According to the Federal Railroad Administration, 2025 was the safest year on record across key measures including derailment rate, equipment and track caused accidents, and importantly, employee injuries. This progress reflects sustained investment, employee expertise, and continuous innovation. And that leads to my first point. Technology is driving record safety gains and will be essential to the next leap forward. The future of rail safety depends on detecting issues before they become failures and we are seeing this across the industry. For example, at BNSF, systems collect real time track data during regular service, while AI enabled tools identify defects earlier than traditional methods. And together with continuous rail temperature monitoring, they enable a fully data driven inspection model. CSX uses advanced detection technology that combines GPS, cameras, radar, and LIDAR to monitor work zones to automatically stop equipment movement when risks are identified. Norfolk Southern deploys AI powered imaging portals that scan rail cars at track speed and flag defects in near real time. Technology now identifies 75 percent of mechanical defects on that railroad. Union Pacific uses machine vision and AI to analyze large data sets, detect patterns, and predict maintenance needs months in advance, allowing more targeted preventive action. Other railroads are advancing similar innovations. CN uses automated inspection systems and ground penetrating radar, while CPKC applies optical technology to detect early stage defects. Across the industry, technology is expanding both the reach and precision of inspections and these tools support not replace railroad employees, giving them better information to improve safety and operations. Which leads to my second point. When policymakers consider technology, I ask that they take a mode neutral approach to transportation technology. Advanced tools are reshaping freight movement across not only rail, but trucking, maritime, and logistics writ large. And rail should not be treated differently simply because it's an established industry or because innovative changes challenge legacy assumptions. Federal policies should encourage innovation based on measurable outcomes, not restrict through outdated frameworks or preferences. Third, rail needs a regulatory system to keep pace with innovation. Much of today's regulatory structure was developed 5 decades ago and does not reflect modern technologies or operating practices. Railroads now have more advanced ways to meet safety goals, yet regulations often prevent those methods from being used to satisfy requirements. At the same time, we're seeing legislative proposals that could lock in legacy practices or double down on legacy practices, risking slowing down progress at a time when innovation is thriving. If we want continued safety improvements, affordability, and supply chain resilience, policy must enable investment and support development and deployment of new technologies, not discourage them. Let data guide decisions and safety outcomes, not rigid inputs. Freight rail operates one of the world's most interconnected systems and invests roughly $23 billion annually in infrastructure, equipment, and technology. And the question is whether policy will support that progress. And this is not just about transportation, it's about American competitiveness. Rail moves about 40 percent of long-haul freight and supports critical industries across the economy. These technologies being deployed today will determine how effectively we continue to do so in the future. And so if we want a rail system that is safer, stronger and ready for the next century, we must allow innovation to lead the way. The choices made here will determine whether progress accelerates or stalls. And let's make sure it accelerates. Thank you. And I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Jeffries follows:] Prepared Statement of Ian Jefferies, President and Chief Executive Officer, Association of American Railroads On behalf of the members of the Association of American Railroads (AAR), thank you for the opportunity to testify before the Committee. AAR freight railroad members account for the vast majority of railroad mileage, employees, and freight traffic in Canada, Mexico, and the United States. In addition, AAR maintains two wholly-owned subsidiaries on the cutting edge of rail technology. MxV Rail in Pueblo, Colorado, is the industry's research, testing, and training epicenter, developing science-based solutions to make North America's rail network safer, more efficient, and more reliable. Railinc in Cary, North Carolina, is the industry's digital backbone, providing essential data, tracking, maintenance, and messaging services to power safe and efficient rail service around the country. Safety is at the forefront of everything the railroads do, and I am proud to report that 2025 was the safest year on record for railroads. The industry set four all-time records: the lowest derailment rate, equipment-caused accident rate, track-caused accident rate, and employee injury rate. That record-breaking year was made possible thanks to billions of dollars in reinvestment by the railroads into cutting-edge technology that has transformed the systems that support, operate, and optimize freight railroads. As a result, railroads are safer, more reliable, and more cost-effective than ever before, and the industry is continuing to develop and deploy new technology to maintain that trajectory. Railroads have identified a path to take us into the future that combines the power of innovative technology with the grit and expertise of our workers. That path will only come to fruition in a regulatory environment that supports innovation. Technological Innovation is Changing the Game for Railroads When many Americans think of railroads, they might not think of cutting-edge technologies, but the Class I railroads are working to change that image. Each of the railroads is at the forefront of researching, developing, and deploying game-changing technology to bring inspections, track health, and employee safety into the future. CPKC: Broken Rail Detector CPKC identified a problem with detecting broken rails in non- signaled, or dark, territories where a broken rail could go unnoticed and cause accidents. To address this concern, the railroad developed the Broken Rail Detector (BRD), an in-house proprietary technology to identify broken rails and halt train movements on a compromised section of track. These solar-powered detectors create an electrical circuit all along the rails on a certain section of track. When all the rails are functioning properly, the circuit will be continuous. If a rail breaks, that circuit will be broken and all traffic will stop. The BRD sends an alert to CPKC, and a team is dispatched to inspect and fix the broken rail right away. The BRD provides a constant stream of information, with new data coming in every 10 minutes ensuring that rails are continuously monitored rather than waiting between visual inspections to identify problems. These near continuous updates also allow CPKC to update its algorithms, identify out of service detectors quickly, and create work orders for CPKC track inspection teams. Combined with machine learning models and intensive data analysis, the company is working to continuously improve the health of its tracks, prevent accidents, and keep its track work teams focused on repairs around the network. BNSF: Track Safety Technology Systems BNSF's track safety work has focused on an array of different tools that allow for more frequent, technology-enabled inspections and identify problems sooner than traditional periodic manual inspections. BNSF is now inspecting track weekly or more frequently, at track speed in revenue service, safely integrating improved inspections without operational interruptions. BNSF uses two in-house designed and built systems to improve inspections. First, the Onboard Defect Identification and Notification (ODIN) is a locomotive-mounted track geometry system that measures track conditions as the locomotive is pulling freight. Every foot, ODIN uses lasers to measure the gauge, cross-level, alignment, and track surface. That information is transmitted to BNSF and analyzed in real-time so any defect can be addressed as quickly as possible. By the end of 2026, the entire BNSF network will be inspected by ODIN systems. Second, the Track Health Optical Recognition (THOR) system compliments ODIN's track geometry measurements with a machine learning optical inspection system that finds safety defects such as broken rails or bars in real time. THOR's high-speed optical cameras capture thousands of detailed images of rails at various angles while mounted on BNSF's track geometry cars. These images are analyzed on board using AI and reports are sent to BNSF within minutes, allowing maintenance personnel to be dispatched and fix defects early. In 2025 THOR found 1900 defects on 160,000 miles of inspected track, most long-before they would have been found by a manual inspection. Finally, BNSF is using rail neutral temperature measurement projects across the network to measure actual neutral temperature and identify and mitigate buckle risk before buckles occur, building our understanding of heat-related risks to the entire network. Collectively, these efforts reflect continued progress toward a data- informed, risk-focused approach to track safety. Norfolk Southern: Train Inspection Portals Working with the Georgia Tech Research Institute, NS sought to harness the power of AI and optical cameras to take train inspections beyond what a manual inspection can see with the naked eye. To that end, Georgia Tech developed and NS deployed cutting-edge train inspection portals equipped with state-of-the-art, ultra high- resolution cameras and stadium lighting to capture nearly 1,000 high- resolution, 360-degree images of each rail car as it passes through the portal at track speed. These images are analyzed using AI algorithms developed by NS to identify defects that would be otherwise invisible to the naked eye during a stationary, manual inspection. NS's 24-hour Network Operations Center receives near-real-time alerts for these defects, where experts review and flag the defects to be addressed as quickly as possible. NS now deploys 11 of these portals around their network, and combined with its other wayside detection systems, NS estimates that technology now finds 75 percent of the mechanical defects on the railroads. Union Pacific: Machine Vision Union Pacific (UP) is also improving its inspections and operations across the network, combining AI with innovative new technology to expand the reach of inspections and speed up the supply chain. UP's Machine Vision technology mounts high-resolution cameras, lasers, and other sensors on hi-rail trucks to quickly scan track infrastructure. Using Machine Vision, UP inspected 644,000 miles of track in 2025, or the equivalent of inspecting the entire network 20 times, and generated more than 100 billion measurements of real-world track conditions. That data is then analyzed by AI software to detect subtle patterns where conditions are changing or defects may occur, allowing the railroad to predict where maintenance may be necessary before a defect or an incident happens. Track inspectors can then prioritize repairs using precise GPS coordinates to identify problem areas and monitor trends in track performance over time. This technology allows UP to predict months in advance when specific sections of track may require maintenance or additional attention, ensuring UP can better plan its work and improve safety outcomes. CSX: Mobile Collision Safety System CSX noticed an uptick in machine-to-machine collisions and recognized the inherent risks for rail employees in the work environment. To address these concerns, CSX developed new technology that takes inspiration from advanced automotive safety systems to keep workers safer around heavy machinery. The Mobile Collision Safety System combines GPS, cameras, radar, and lidar to monitor the areas around the equipment, where employees are at the most risk of getting injured and machine-to-machine collisions are most likely to happen. The system monitors this so-called ``red-zone'' around the equipment and, if an object, person, or other collision risk is detected, stops the equipment and prevents an accident. While workers are already trained to anticipate and prevent collisions, this new technology adds an extra layer of protection to prevent accidents. The Mobile Collision Safety System is just one of the many innovative ideas developed in- house by CSX's InnovationX program, which encourages employees to submit ideas for new technology, processes, and other innovations to make the railroad safer and more efficient. Canadian National: Critical Risk Management System Railroads work every day to ensure employees follow the highest safety standards and return home safely. To support this commitment, Canadian National (CN) has developed a new mobile safety observation app focused on Life Critical Rules--the essential safety practices that prevent serious injury or death. Leveraging AI and machine learning, the app will identify the work that should be observed, which rule to focus on, and when and where the observation should take place to maximize impact. These insights are driven by trends in historical data, including injuries, accidents, prior observations, weather conditions, and other key metrics. By integrating these factors, employees can be confident they are conducting the most meaningful observations to reduce risk and strengthen workplace safety. When combined with CN's Enablon app--which enables real-time reporting and tracking of near misses and hazards--employees are empowered with the tools and data needed to proactively improve safety across the railroad. Regulatory Environments Can Foster Innovation and Improve Safety The billions of dollars in technology investment described above are already having an impact on safety and efficiency across the network. To take the next great leap forward in safety, regulators and policymakers must move beyond the prescriptive regulatory framework that stifles innovation and gets sidetracked by political issues. Railroads seek a regulatory framework that supports the effective systems in place today and embraces investments for the future. Performance-Based Regulations Rather than setting rigid, outdated mandates, a modern regulatory framework that emphasizes performance-based, data-driven results will help freight railroads improve safety and meet the growing demand for freight service while maintaining sufficient government oversight. Regulators should set strong safety and operational standards for railroads and give railroads the ability to identify the best processes, operating systems, and technologies to meet those goals. To move into the future and develop a modern, effective regulatory framework, policymakers should focus on implementing performance-based regulations that allow the industry to invest in cost-effective, innovative solutions to enhance safety and efficiency. These regulations should be based on verifiable data, sound science, and demonstrated need and should encourage innovation without locking in existing technologies and processes. Regulators should also strive to improve transparency throughout the regulatory process, including meaningful discussions with all stakeholders, robust benefit cost analysis that considers the cumulative burden of regulations, and guidance documents that clarify ambiguous regulations rather than creating new obligations or coercing compliance. Finally, these regulatory updates must be implemented in an equitable manner across all modes of transportation. Currently, other modes of surface transportation have embraced performance-based regulations, but railroad regulations continue to be bogged down in the status quo of the 1980s and 1990s. This divergence in how the different modes are regulated only exacerbates underlying modal inequities, putting railroads at a distinct competitive disadvantage. Finally, regulators should ensure that any Federal money invested in developing and expanding new technology, like telematics, creates incentives for information sharing between all stakeholders, including the railroads themselves. FRA Waiver Reform Policymakers should consider long-overdue reforms to the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) waiver process, which is intended to give railroads the opportunity to utilize new technology to improve safety outcomes when compared with current regulatory requirements. FRA is supposed to use the waiver process to encourage railroads to develop new technology that improves safety outcomes. However, in recent years, this process has turned into a bottleneck; prior administrations have sidetracked technological innovation by focusing on achieving unrelated political goals instead of improving rail safety. Refocusing that process on safety, rather than satisfying the demands of one stakeholder group over another, is one way to build a more technology- focused regulatory environment. Specifically, FRA should act on waivers in a timely manner consistent with statute; make decisions only based on transparent criteria and clear science-based data demonstrating improved safety outcomes; consistently renew or expand waivers as additional data becomes available; and create clear expectations and pathways for adoption of new technology and processes by the broader industry when the safety record is established. In addition, when a waiver is eventually successful, FRA should update the prescriptive regulation to a modern, performance-based regulation that follows the data, embraces technology, and allows for future development and deployment. Finally, lawmakers should not adopt new legislation that effectively eliminates or undercuts the waiver process. Bills that bar any regulatory waivers or modernizations will actually make the railroads less safe by limiting the use of safety technology in the future. Conclusion By investing billions in infrastructure and innovation, railroads are constantly modernizing operations to improve safety while meeting rigorous global supply chain demands. Railroads look forward to working with members of this Committee and other policymakers to create a regulatory framework that supports innovation, harnesses the expertise and ingenuity of the industry, and keeps our workers, customers, and communities safe while serving as the engine of America's economy. Senator Young. Thank you, Mr. Jeffries. Our second witness is Mr. Chris Spear, President and CEO of American Trucking Association. He has extensive experience in transportation and public policy, having held senior positions at Hyundai Motor Company, Honeywell International, and served as the Assistant Secretary of Labor for Policy at the U.S. Department of Labor. Mr. Spear, you're recognized for five minutes. STATEMENT OF CHRIS SPEAR, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, AMERICAN TRUCKING ASSOCIATIONS Mr. Spear. Let me thank you for letting Ian go first. I really appreciate that. Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today about how Congress can keep America's trucking industry safe, competitive, and innovative. Trucking moves the vast majority of our Nation's freight, connects manufacturers to markets, keeps store shelves stocked, and delivers essential goods to communities in every state. Our industry is already investing billions in technology to create a safer, more modern freight network. Innovation-driven solutions not only improve outcomes, but also help lower prices paid by consumers and businesses alike. We need Congress's support to continue building a stronger supply chain. First, Congress should repeal the 12 percent Federal excise tax on heavy duty trucks, trailers, and tractors. The century old tax punishes the purchase of the very vehicles that come with the latest technologies. Adding tens of thousands of dollars to the cost of new equipment discourages fleet turnover, keeps older equipment on the road longer. Congress has a ready solution in Chairman Young's Modern, Clean, and Safe Trucks Act, which would remove this outdated barrier and accelerate deployment of safer, cleaner, and more efficient equipment nationwide. Second, Congress should solidify the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's role as the primary authority over motor vehicle safety standards. Trucking is a national industry and vehicle standards must remain national as well. When states or courts impose equipment standards beyond Federal law, it creates a fragmented regulatory landscape that drives uncertainty for manufacturers, motor carriers, and the supply chain. Congress should reaffirm that when NHTSA acts, Federal standards take precedence. That clarity is essential if companies are going to invest confidently in new technologies and deploy them at scale. Third, Congress should establish and implement a Federal framework for autonomous commercial vehicles. These systems hold real promise to enhance safety, improve productivity, and strengthen America's economic competitiveness, but only if deployment is governed by a clear national strategy. The Build America 250 Act would provide this guidance preventing a patchwork of State rules from stifling innovation. Fourth, Congress should support technology upgrades and operational improvements at Federal agencies to combat the rise of cargo theft and supply chain fraud. Criminal networks are exploiting outdated systems, weak identity controls, and fragmented reporting structures to steal freight, impersonate legitimate carriers, and undermine trust in the supply chain. Congress can help close those gaps by supporting agency modernization, stronger registration integrity, better data sharing, and advanced fraud detection tools. Chairman Young's SAFER Transport Act would provide important tools to help DOT detect and deter fraud, while the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act would enhance and coordinate the response to organized supply chain crime. Fifth, Congress should continue promoting proven technologies while refraining from mandating technologies that have not yet matured or demonstrated effectiveness in real world trucking operations. Congress and regulators should distinguish between rules that are ready for broad deployment and those that are still requiring development, testing, and refinement. Sixth, Congress should support a resilient national approach to positioning, navigation, and timing without disrupting the existing technologies and services that keep freight moving. Policymakers should reject proposals such as NextNav's petition that would repurpose the Lower 900 MHz band in ways that risk harmful interference to the millions of incumbent devices and systems already operating there, including technologies that support logistics, transportation, and critical infrastructure. Together, these six steps would send a clear signal: Congress is ready to embrace technologies today and tomorrow and help the trucking industry deliver even greater safety, resilience, and economic strength for the American people. I look forward to discussing these issues with the Subcommittee and answering your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Spear follows:] Prepared Statement of Chris Spear, President and CEO, American Trucking Associations Introduction Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, and members of the Subcommittee, I am grateful for the opportunity to testify today on the key issues facing the trucking industry. I am the President & CEO of the American Trucking Associations (ATA), a 93-year-old federation and the largest national trade organization representing the 8.4 million men and women working in the trucking industry, including more than 3.6 million professional truck drivers. As a 50-state federation that encompasses 37,000 motor carriers and suppliers, ATA proudly represents every sector of the industry. From less-than-truckload to truckload carriers, from agriculture and livestock transporters to auto haulers and household goods movers, and from large fleets to mom-and-pop one-truck operators, ATA serves as the single unified voice of the trucking industry. Trucking is the backbone of our economy, with more than 80 percent of U.S. communities relying exclusively on trucking to meet their freight needs. According to Federal data, heavy and tractor-trailer truck driver is a top-ten occupation in 18 states.\1\ These truck drivers are the unsung heroes of our supply chain who keep our economy moving. In 2023, they drove almost 330 billion miles--the equivalent of 13 million trips around the globe--to deliver roughly 11.4 billion tons of freight,\2\ 73 percent of the Nation's annual tonnage.\3\ Over the next decade, those drivers will be tasked with hauling an additional 2.7 billion tons of freight above current volumes.\4\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics. U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. May 2024. https://www.bls.gov/oes/ current/oessrcst.htm \2\ American Trucking Trends 2025. American Trucking Associations, 2025. \3\ Freight Transportation Forecast 2024 to 2035. American Trucking Associations, 2024. \4\ Ibid. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Five years ago, ATA was one of the first industry trade associations to endorse the bipartisan Senate bill that became the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA). The IIJA represented a historic increase in funding for roads and bridges--our industry's workplace--and highway safety programs. In anticipation of IIJA's expiration on September 30, 2026, we hope and trust that Congressional willingness to invest in vital surface transportation programs and priorities remains strong and will be demonstrated in a new surface transportation reauthorization. ATA strongly supports the BUILD America 250 Act as negotiated and approved by the House Transportation & Infrastructure (T&I) Committee, and we welcome the privilege of working with Congress to advance a bipartisan, bicameral reauthorization bill to the President's desk. I am grateful to the Chairman, Ranking Member, and members of this important Committee for their support of key trucking priorities and the advancement of common-sense bipartisan bills such as the Household Goods Shipping Consumer Protection Act and the Promoting Resilient Supply Chains Act. We look forward to continued support of renewed investment in the roads, bridges, and safety programs that are critically important to America's economic wellbeing and growth. New technologies are changing the way that we all do business, across all roles and industries. Despite a multi-year freight recession that created perilous economic conditions for trucking companies of all sizes, motor carriers have met the needs of their customers by investing in technologies that increase safety and efficiency. The industry is currently deploying proven safety technologies and partnering with innovators to test new ideas and technologies that can help improve both highway safety and supply chain efficiency while paving the way for future economic growth. Thank you for holding this hearing to discuss opportunities to leverage technological innovation to improve highway safety, promote efficient supply chains that reduce costs for consumers, and ensure America's global economic leadership. I am grateful for the invitation to participate, and for your dedication to these key priorities. Opportunities to Increase Highway Safety Ensuring that our roads are safe for both commercial vehicles and the motoring public is the north star of America's trucking industry. To that end, trucking companies make significant investments every day in proven safety technologies for their fleets. In 2022, ATA's Safety Spend Survey showed that the industry invested $14 billion annually in safety, an increase of over 40 percent above the preceding 2015 survey.\5\ Federal regulatory reforms supported by ATA have reduced both the number of truck-involved crashes and the crash rate over the past several decades. However, more must be done to improve highway safety for all motorists. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\ 2022 ATA Safety Spend Survey. American Trucking Associations, 2023. https://www.trucking.org/news-insights/new-study-underlines- trucking-industrys-commitment-safety. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The simplest and most straightforward Congressional action that will put safer, cleaner trucks on the road is the repeal of the onerous 12 percent Federal Excise Tax (FET) on heavy-duty trucks and trailers. This tax dates back to American entry into World War I and has grown to become a major disincentive--if not an outright financial barrier--to investments in new equipment. The FET adds around $24,000 to the cost of a new truck and over $6,500 to the cost of a new trailer, forcing companies to defer upgrading their fleets. ATA is grateful to Subcommittee Chairman Young and Sen. Alsobrooks for cosponsoring the bipartisan Modern, Clean, and Safe Trucks Act, which would eliminate this outdated tax and remove a significant impediment that deters the trucking industry from investing in new equipment. Additionally, ATA welcomes Congressional investment in Federal roadway safety programs and research on innovative approaches to safety, and we are grateful for our partnerships with agencies and technology innovators that are working to make our highways safer. Examples of this work include: Partnerships with DOT modal administrations such as the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) on crash causation research and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) on automated vehicle safety studies. Collaboration with the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) sharing data and insights that support investigations and safety recommendations impacting trucking and broader safety of roadways. Joint initiatives with state departments of transportation and state enforcement agencies, including through the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA). Engagement with technology innovators/developers, including developers of advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS), telematics, and emerging roadway safety analytics tools. Collaboration with academic research centers, including university transportation centers (UTCs) and other transportation research institutes that study crash reduction strategies, human factors, and heavy vehicle safety technologies. Through those collaborations, we continue supporting workable requirements to deploy proven safety technologies, improve drug testing to meaningfully curb the rise of impaired driving, and ensure compliance with Federal requirements for training and driver qualification to make highways safer for all road users. Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB) Congress and the trucking industry need to ensure that the safety technologies on commercial vehicles enhance drivers' attention and alertness while behind the wheel. One technology that requires immediate attention is Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB). AEB, and the suite of tools that support it, is a prime example of a proven safety technology that can reduce and mitigate crashes. Because AEB was already a mature and broadly adopted safety technology in the heavy- duty sector, in 2021, Congress directed the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) to mandate AEB on all new heavy-duty trucks and ensure the proliferation of this critical safety tool. ATA supported this action because AEB technology had been available for over a decade in the heavy-duty sector and had clearly demonstrated benefits. Since implementation began on a voluntary basis in the heavy-duty sector, AEB has matured significantly and improved its effectiveness, integration, and driver experience based on industry feedback. By contrast, in 2024, DOT proposed an AEB mandate for industry segments outside of heavy-duty trucking, for which the technology remains under development and has not been widely adopted. This action exceeded Congressional intent to focus on the heavy-duty trucking sector where the technology is mature. Because new developments for different vehicle configurations, brake technologies, and sensor placements are required, AEB is not widely available for deployment in medium-duty and (in particular) vocational vehicle segments. Proposed timelines for that proposed mandatory deployment are not practical. Industry is working on these issues, but the systems are not yet developed at the same level of effectiveness, integration, and driver experience as for heavy-duty trucks. The mandate also proposed overly aggressive braking standards that effectively treat AEB as a replacement for the driver, a standard for which AEB is not designed. AEB and the suite of tools around it have always been designed as driver assistance technologies. AEB is designed specifically to help the driver respond more effectively, buy time for the driver to avoid hazards, and potentially mitigate or avoid crashes whenever possible. Industry has spent immense time and effort building driver trust in this technology. Rolling the technology out appropriately is necessary to maintain that trust. ATA urges this Subcommittee to provide oversight of DOT on this matter to ensure that regulation focuses on heavy-duty AEB, that the DOT applies performance requirements that represent the design intent of the technology, and that DOT works with industry to overcome barriers to implementation. Industry is eager to work with the DOT on AEB beyond the heavy-duty sector, but these efforts should be separate and distinct so as not to delay a rule in heavy-duty which could save lives in the near term. Distracted Driving Addressing distracted driving among all roadway users--commercial drivers and passenger vehicle drivers--is vitally important. ATA recognizes distracted driving--whether manual, visual, cognitive, or emotional--as a form of impaired driving. Any activity that diverts a driver's attention threatens roadway and industry safety and endangers all road users. Far too often, distraction is the cause of tragedy on our Nation's roadways. According to NHTSA, in 2022, distraction was a causal factor in 8 percent of fatal crashes and 12 percent of injury crashes. Distressingly, the true figures are likely much higher as distracted driving goes largely underreported in official statistics due to reluctance of driver admissions of distraction, difficulty for law enforcement to detect distraction, and inconsistent crash reporting. ATA welcomes collaboration with this Subcommittee and relevant stakeholders, including law enforcement, Federal and state regulators and legislators, safety advocates, and drivers, to tackle this epidemic. Effective and robust enforcement of existing handsfree and distraction laws is vital, and ATA supports federal, state, and local laws prohibiting handheld wireless device use while driving. These laws and policies should apply to and be strictly enforced among all motorists, not just commercial drivers, to promote safer roads. Because commercial drivers rely on essential in-cab technologies, lawmakers must consider how best to integrate the safe use of these vital tools while minimizing visual-manual interaction and distraction and allow safe use of hands-free technologies while vehicles are underway. ATA is committed to prioritizing awareness, enforcement, and technology-driven solutions that reduce distracted driving and improve roadway safety for all. We believe safety campaigns that highlight the grave consequences of distracted driving can lead to greater awareness and behavioral changes that ultimately lead to cultural shifts in how we think about and accept risky driving behaviors. We recognize that these shifts take time and continuous exposure to safety messaging, much like the cultural shift towards universal seatbelt use in the 1990s. It is important for Congress to provide DOT necessary resources to sustain and amplify similar, ongoing distracted driving campaigns and awareness efforts in the upcoming reauthorization measure. We support Section 4002 of the BUILD America 250 Act, which proposes consolidating national priority safety programs and outlines six key areas, including impaired and distracted driving, that states must target in their safety plans. We encourage this Subcommittee to prioritize providing federal, state, and local resources to study the scope of distraction, develop and implement innovative technologies and practices for detecting distraction, and enhance enforcement to discourage this dangerous behavior. Underrides Crash Data Collection Making investments in new safety technologies takes time as fleets purchase, sell, and upgrade their inventory. Investments need to be justified by concrete data showing a benefit to fleet safety. ATA welcomes key provisions in the BUILD America 250 Act that will help gather necessary, reliable data to inform Federal regulatory decisions around underride guard requirements. This data will in turn help fleets understand potential benefits as they evaluate and communicate costs of new equipment with regulators during the rulemaking process. Section 4002 of the BUILD America 250 Act directs the Secretary to provide technical assistance to states and local governments to improve safety data in key areas, including better quantifying the dynamics of drug usage in crashes that result in serious injuries or fatalities, state reporting alignment with the Model Minimum Uniform Crash Criteria, the use of safety data in transportation planning, and the reporting of underride crashes. Section 4002 ensures states are addressing the national priority safety initiatives in their highway safety plans and provides public visibility into state progress towards safety targets. Section 4016 of the bill then directs the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to study the quality of highway safety data used in Federal transportation programs. Specifically, the study must examine state-submitted safety data quality, including data on underride crashes. Under this provision, the GAO will be required to consult with state departments of transportation, state highway safety offices, transportation safety organizations, law enforcement, non- profit organizations, and DOT before submitting a report to Congress detailing its findings and recommendations. ATA strongly supports this provision to ensure Congress and Federal regulators are working with reliable data when considering potential future regulations that will impact the trucking industry. ATA has actively participated for years in efforts to improve understanding of underride crashes and potential countermeasures. ATA was represented on the DOT's Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, established under the IIJA, to examine rear, side, and front underride issues and provide recommendations to the Secretary. Throughout the advisory process, ATA and other representatives on the Committee emphasized the foundational need for reliable crash data, rigorous cost-benefit analysis, and consideration of the operational impacts of any new equipment mandates. ATA's position has consistently been that decisions regarding additional underride guard requirements should be based on demonstrated safety benefits supported by comprehensive real-world data. Improved underride crash reporting and analysis, as proposed by the BUILD America 250 Act, will provide all parties with the necessary information to assess the effectiveness, feasibility, and costs of potential underride countermeasures before imposing new Federal requirements. Protect NHTSA's Role in Setting Industry Standards ATA continues to support Congressional action to clarify an existing prohibition of states laws superseding NHTSA standards for motor vehicle safety. The trucking industry is grateful to the House T&I Committee for amending the BUILD America 250 Act to include a provision that would preempt lawsuits that seek to impose liability for failing to equip motor vehicles beyond federal motor vehicle safety standards. Amending Section 30103 of title 49, a key Federal statute that outlines how Federal motor vehicle safety standards interact with state regulations, would impact a broader spectrum of the trucking industry and provide the necessary legal certainty for both carriers and manufacturers. Under existing law--going back to the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966, Pub. L. 89-563--when NHTSA promulgates a Federal motor vehicle safety standard, states are prohibited from issuing standards of their own on that same subject (see 49 U.S.C. Sec. 30103(b)(1)). Congress has charged NHTSA with promulgating ``practicable,'' ``objective'' standards that ``meet the need for motor vehicle safety,'' (see 49 U.S.C. Sec. 30111(a)). Allowing states to promulgate their own equipment standards when NHTSA has acted undermines that decision. However, current law contains an exception that threatens to swallow the rule: it expressly provides that compliance with a NHTSA standard does not preempt ``liability at common law'' (see 49 U.S.C. Sec. 30103(e)). This invites legal uncertainty, undermines Congressional intent to empower NHTSA to promulgate nationally uniform motor vehicle safety standards, and threatens supply chain integrity. Given that the trucking industry operates in all 50 states and that the market for motor vehicles is national in scope, we strongly support NHTSA's role as the primary authority over motor vehicle safety standards and urge Congress to reaffirm that role in Section 30103 of title 49. Support Deregulatory Efforts While Preserving Key Technology Requirements ATA has welcomed and supported the Trump Administration's efforts to reduce undue burdens and costs on motor carriers without compromising strong safety regulatory protections. Regulated entities, including motor carriers, rely on thoughtful, well-written, and safety- driven Federal regulations and guidance to ensure the utmost safety for commercial drivers and all who share the road. However, ATA recognizes that certain Federal rules and regulations that affect the trucking industry are redundant, outdated, or place undue burden on members of the trucking industry--in some cases, invoking compliance merely for compliance's sake rather than a material benefit to the industry or national interest. ATA applauds this Administration and DOT's efforts to swiftly review and take deregulatory action to remove unnecessary or outdated red tape and regulatory burdens all while promoting industry efficiency without undermining safety. Changes such as eliminating rear underride guard certification label mandates, which incur unnecessary costs without measurable safety benefits, updating roadside warning device requirements, and removing legacy trailer marking rules that apply to equipment no longer in service are examples of overdue deregulatory actions. While ATA supports regulatory reform, we strongly urge Congress and DOT to preserve proven, safety-enhancing regulations that would have negative material consequences on the safety of all road users if eliminated. Among these critical regulations is the Electronic Logging Device (ELD) mandate, which has delivered measurable reductions in hours of service (HOS) violations and crash rates since implementation. Repealing or weakening this mandate, which has been requested by some stakeholders, would be a step back for the industry as ELDs modernize compliance monitoring and enforcement without altering rest requirements. We also emphasize that any future changes to the underlying HOS rules, upon which ELD rules are predicated, must be grounded in data and scientific research. As previously mentioned, ATA supports continued advancement of life-saving technologies like AEB and opposes any slowing or reversal of progress on drug and alcohol testing reforms. Regulatory streamlining must not come at the expense of highway safety, and we commend DOT and FMCSA's approach to sound, practical deregulatory action. Finally, ATA strongly supports Congressional efforts to make permanent agency waivers that have repeatedly been shown through notice-and-comment rulemaking processes and agency determinations to have no adverse impact on highway safety. Accordingly, ATA is grateful to Senators Fischer and Peters for introducing legislation (S. 4669) to relieve stinger-steered automobile transporters of a requirement to add duplicative warning flags to overhanging vehicles. FMCSA twice waived the warning flag requirement for stinger-steered automobile transporters, citing that cars already feature reflective devices and that trailers are equipped with proper lighting and conspicuity treatments. A provision paralleling the bill led by Sens. Fischer and Peters was included in the manager's amendment of the BUILD America 250 Act. Autonomous Trucks America's truck drivers are the unsung heroes of our supply chain; they are the trucking industry's greatest asset. The groundbreaking developments in autonomous vehicle (AV) technologies offer opportunities to help improve the safety and productivity of those individuals, and to make trucking a safer and more appealing profession for the next generation of truck drivers. Approaching new autonomous technologies as an ``all-or-nothing'' binary where human drivers are either completely behind the wheel or entirely replaced by robots relies on a fundamental mischaracterization of the technology. Autonomous technologies exist on a wide spectrum. Gradual integration of automated systems into the driving profession will mean an evolution--not an elimination--of the job and will almost certainly boost both safety and operational productivity. The expertise and skill of America's truck drivers cannot be overstated. Each year, professional truck drivers safely navigate hundreds of billions of miles across America's diverse geography, side by side with the motoring public. Given the diversity of freight movement--including liquids, livestock, hazardous materials, large construction equipment, and oversize loads--and the variety of road, terrain, and weather conditions throughout the country, drivers will always play a crucial and necessary role in the logistics system that includes automated trucks. ATA believes autonomous trucks will improve supply chain efficiency while giving truck drivers greater flexibility in choosing their preferred routes. AVs are one of many tools for the trucking industry to meet the growing and changing demands of our economy without replacing the truck driving profession. As Congress explores opportunities to improve roadway safety for all drivers, groundbreaking developments in AV technologies, automated driving systems (ADS), and connected vehicle technologies offer immense opportunities. The Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association reported in their 2026 State of AV report that autonomous vehicles have driven more than 360 million miles on U.S public roads.\6\ This is roughly double the number of miles driven at the time I testified before this Subcommittee last year. At that time, I stressed the importance of a Federal framework that supports safe interstate testing and deployment of AVs, including commercial motor vehicles (CMVs), and that urgency is amplified today. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ 2026 State of AV. Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association, 2026. https://www.theav industry.org/state-of-av --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ATA celebrated the inclusion of a bipartisan, workable legislative proposal in the BUILD America 250 Act. Among other key provisions, the proposal would: 1. Create a performance-based safety standard for AV CMVs operating in interstate commerce; 2. Establish stakeholder engagement opportunities to make formal recommendations on DOT's AV rulemaking; 3. Establish liability responsibilities and HOS requirements when ADS is engaged; 4. Give DOT the ability to preempt state laws and regulations when deemed necessary; 5. Provide parity with safety technologies for vehicle width exemptions for ADS; 6. Permit cab-mounted warning beacons for CMVs, something both AV and traditional trucking companies can celebrate; and 7. Support the future CMV workforce through workforce development opportunities. ATA supports this proposal as negotiated in the House, which reflects bipartisan consensus, is supported by a broad range of stakeholders, and would create a Federal framework for autonomous trucks for the first time. This framework will contribute to greater roadway safety and U.S. economic competitiveness. ATA urges the Senate to move forward with similar legislation to keep our country at the forefront of this vital technology. We are grateful to Subcommittee Ranking Member Peters, Senator Lummis, and other members of Congress for pushing the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to approve the deployment of Cellular Vehicle to Everything (C-V2X) technology. ATA concurs that connected vehicle technology has the potential to save lives on America's highways and to increase efficiency. Developing improvements such as signal priority will impact not only safety but also reduce congestion and help to drive down the overall cost of transportation. Similarly, we encourage Congress and Federal agencies to continue developing proactive policies at every opportunity to foster innovation and ensure that American leadership in the development of this important technology. Today's hearing is a promising recognition by this Subcommittee that AV and other advanced technology deployments have the potential to significantly enhance the safety, efficiency, and productivity of the U.S. freight and logistics systems. We look forward to supporting Congressional efforts to ensure that the technologies and vehicles that generate those benefits are developed, improved, implemented, and sold around the world by American companies. Protect American Manufacturers and Trucking from Unsafe Connected Vehicles ATA also strongly supports protecting American manufacturers and the trucking industry from unsafe vehicles, components, and connected vehicle software from China. We are grateful to Senators Moreno and Slotkin for their leadership on this issue and introduction of the Connected Vehicle Security Act of 2026, which would ban the import, sale, and operations of vehicles manufactured in China and ban the use of Chinese-developed connected vehicle technologies, such as software, and data systems on American roads. ATA shares the Senators' concern over Chinese influence in the U.S. transportation network and automotive supply chain, including the potential risks associated with Chinese-manufactured vehicles, connected vehicle technologies, and access to sensitive transportation data. As commercial vehicles become increasingly reliant on telematics, fleet management systems, safety technologies, and over-the-air software updates, it is important to ensure that foreign adversaries cannot exploit these systems to gain access to operational data or critical vehicle functions. ATA has engaged extensively with the Department of Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) on this issue, helping policymakers understand the unique role that connected technologies play in the trucking industry and the differences between commercial vehicles and passenger cars. As a result of this engagement, BIS ultimately excluded commercial motor vehicles from its initial connected vehicle restrictions and began developing a separate rulemaking tailored to the commercial vehicle sector. While ATA supports efforts to address legitimate security threats posed by Chinese-connected vehicle technologies, any restrictions affecting commercial vehicles should be implemented through a deliberate, risk-based approach that recognizes the complexity of trucking supply chains, avoids unnecessary disruptions to fleets and manufacturers that create operational or safety compliance challenges, and provides sufficient time for industry stakeholders to transition away from identified security risks. We encourage this Subcommittee to consider these realities and ensure any proposals regarding foreign influence in the automotive space reflect the technical differences between heavy-duty commercial trucking and passenger vehicles. Strengthen Technology Safeguards at DOT ATA is grateful for this Subcommittee's ongoing attention to bad and unsafe actors that exploit gaps in FMCSA's systems and undermine the integrity of the legitimate supply chain. These entities compromise industry and roadway safety and security by defrauding and stealing from stakeholders at every level of our supply chain. We also applaud the DOT's ongoing efforts to utilize technologies, including modernized systems, enhanced vetting and fraud detection tools, and artificial intelligence to restore integrity to government systems that are regularly utilized by motor carriers and drivers. Motus and Registration Integrity The entire supply chain--not just motor carriers but also shippers, property brokers, and freight forwarders--continues to experience increasing levels of fraud, cargo theft, and identity theft carried out by sophisticated criminal organizations and individual bad actors. Many of these schemes exploit weaknesses and gaps in DOT registration and credentialing systems through theft, purchase, manipulation, or misuse of DOT numbers, operating authority credentials, and carrier identities. Fraudsters often create shell companies, hijack existing carrier profiles, falsify ownership information, or acquire credentials associated with carriers that have strong safety records to evade scrutiny from regulators, law enforcement, brokers, and shippers. Similar tactics have long been employed by ``chameleon carriers,'' entities that abandon one corporate identity after accumulating safety violations, enforcement actions, or out-of-service orders only to re- enter the industry under a new name and new credentials with no trace of their old identity. These schemes have been all too easy to carry out and have grown in frequency in recent years. Recognizing these challenges, FMCSA established a dedicated fraud prevention team in 2024 and has taken several steps to strengthen oversight of registration processes, improve business verification procedures, and reduce opportunities for credential theft and misuse. The agency has also suspended online PIN requests and implemented additional safeguards around account access and registration changes to help prevent unauthorized system activity. Most significantly, after years of development, FMCSA launched its modernized Motus Registration System in May 2026 to replace an outdated legacy registration platform. The predecessor system had security and technological gaps that made nefarious activity possible and lacked integration with other FMCSA applications and portals. Motus is designed to strengthen identity verification, improve ownership transparency, enhance data quality and cross-system validation, and provide greater visibility into relationships among carriers, owners, and affiliated entities. FMCSA has also begun transitioning toward a more streamlined registration framework centered on a single USDOT- based identifier, reducing reliance on multiple standalone credentials that have historically been vulnerable to manipulation and misuse. Collectively, these improvements have the potential to significantly enhance FMCSA's ability to identify fraudulent applicants, detect chameleon carriers, and prevent unsafe operators from obtaining or retaining operating authority. A modern, secure registration system is more than an administrative improvement--it is a critical safety and security tool. When unsafe carriers or fraudulent actors can conceal their identities and repeatedly obtain new credentials, regulators lose visibility into safety risk and what is happening on the ground. Trying to identify these elusive bad actors strains existing enforcement resources without consistently removing these fraudulent entities from our roadways, all while legitimate carriers face unfair competition by non-compliant entities and increased exposure to fraud. By strengthening registration integrity and improving fraud detection capabilities, Motus can help restore confidence in FMCSA's credentialing systems, support law enforcement investigations, protect carriers and shippers from fraud and cargo theft, and promote a safer and more accountable trucking industry. While ATA strongly supports FMCSA's modernization efforts, continued oversight and investment by Congress will be necessary to ensure Motus achieves its full potential. As the agency continues refining the platform and addressing implementation challenges, Congress should ensure FMCSA has the resources, staffing, and technological infrastructure necessary to maintain a secure, reliable, and user-friendly registration system that effectively deters bad actors while minimizing burdens on legitimate carriers and brokers. Cargo Theft and Freight Fraud This Subcommittee held a hearing on cargo theft in February 2025 and provided a platform for the trucking industry to discuss the increasing sophistication of these schemes, as well as opportunities for DOT and other Federal agencies to combat broader supply chain fraud. As a result of that hearing, Subcommittee Chairman Young introduced the Securing American Freight, Enforcement, and Reliability in (SAFER) Transport Act, which strengthens Federal efforts to detect and eradicate freight fraud and cargo theft across the transportation ecosystem. ATA strongly supports Chairman Young's bill. Passing this legislation would be the most meaningful action Congress can take to equip DOT with the proper tools, technology, and authorities required to effectively mitigate sophisticated fraud schemes. The necessary counterpart to the SAFER Transport Act is the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act, which would establish the Organized Retail and Supply Chain Crime Coordination Center within Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) at the Department of Homeland Security. This center would serve as a central reporting repository for supply chain stakeholders to document theft and fraud events involving interstate commerce. Enhanced data sharing, trend analysis, and the ability to ``connect the dots'' across jurisdictions are indispensable to modern cargo theft investigations. ATA will continue working with members of the Subcommittee to attract cosponsors to both the SAFER Transport Act and the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act because a coordinated Federal effort to combat cargo theft is not only appropriate but essential. Only the Federal government possesses the investigative capabilities, advanced technical infrastructure, and national reach necessary to disrupt and dismantle these interstate and international crime rings. End ELD Provider Self-Certification ATA strongly supports Section 5202 of the BUILD America 250 Act, which will crack down on fraudulent ELD providers. As this Subcommittee focuses on the importance of technology, ATA encourages active oversight of FMCSA's ongoing effort to ensure that the hours driven by safe, qualified drivers are properly tracked by federally mandated devices and according to HOS regulations. In recent years, the proliferation of fraudulent, manipulated, or noncompliant ELDs has emerged as a serious and rapidly evolving threat to both roadway safety and the security of the Nation's transportation network. ELDs are intended to provide an objective, tamper-resistant record of a driver's HOS compliance. When functioning properly, they help prevent fatigue-related crashes, support fair competition, and ensure that carriers and drivers operate within Federal safety limits and requirements. But the growing presence of devices that can be altered, remotely manipulated, or intentionally designed by foreign enterprises to evade Federal requirements has subverted the very purpose of the ELD mandate and undermines the providers and carriers committed to legitimacy and compliance. A core vulnerability stems from the current regulatory framework, which allows ELD companies to self-certify their devices through an online registry process. This system enables foreign-owned or overseas- based companies to register, market, and supply devices with weak cybersecurity protections, opaque ownership structures, and remote- access capabilities that blatantly disregard Federal ELD regulations and protections. In some reported cases, these foreign actors--entities that have self-certified through FMCSA processes and posed as legitimate ELD providers--have been able to make real-time edits to drivers' HOS logs at the request of drivers or motor carriers. This can occur within minutes of a driver being pulled over for an inspection and generated using artificial intelligence (AI), producing fraudulent HOS logs that, to the naked eye, appear entirely compliant and legitimate. These capabilities effectively mask HOS violations, compromise regulatory oversight, and allow unsafe operators to continue driving. The consequences of ELD fraud are certainly significant but also not yet fully understood. As such, Federal entities have taken these threats seriously. FMCSA has already announced changes that strengthen the ELD certification and review process for new registrants and revoked dozens of noncompliant devices in 2025. ATA emphasizes the need for stronger oversight of ELD manufacturers already listed in the registry, more rigorous vetting of devices before they are approved, swift removal of noncompliant devices, and mechanisms to hold carriers who use those devices accountable. ATA also supports the implementation of a third-party certification process for ELD providers and, in the more immediate term, measures that can be taken to identify and stop bad actors, such as real-time checks of drivers' HOS logs for common indicators of fraud, requiring all companies registering ELD devices to verify their footprint in the U.S., and enhancing FMCSA's response to potential incidents of fraud. ATA strongly supports FMCSA's recent enforcement actions and urges Congress to play a role in expanding Federal oversight and enforcement of ELD providers. A secure and trustworthy ELD registry is essential to maintaining the integrity of the HOS system, protecting compliant carriers, and reducing fatigue-related risks. As demonstrated by states' failures and lapses in oversight of CDL issuance, weaknesses in ELD oversight similarly create systemic vulnerabilities that can be exploited by those seeking to evade safety rules--or by foreign actors seeking to access or disrupt critical transportation data. Issues Surrounding Marijuana Decriminalization Ensuring that our roads are free from drivers under the influence of controlled substances is a top priority for the trucking industry. Since the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse launched in 2020, more than 345,000 positive drug tests among commercial motor vehicle drivers have been recorded, highlighting a persistent and alarming trend in substance use that threatens the safety of our Nation's highways.\7\ Of these positive drug tests, marijuana remains the leading drug violation among drivers, accounting for roughly 60 percent of positive tests annually, over 260,000 total--a troubling statistic that underscores its widespread use and potential impact on highway safety. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse: March 2025 Monthly Summary Report. U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, March 2025. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Despite the alarming increase of positive drug tests and prevalence of impaired driving on our Nation's roadways, there is no universally agreed-upon standard or scientific threshold for marijuana impairment. Nor is there a mature technology available for law enforcement to test for impairment, such as what exists for alcohol and drunk driving. One of the most impactful contributions that Congress can make to technology developments in transportation would be to encourage the development of these standards and deployment of workable technology that would allow roadside detection of marijuana impairment. The longer-term outlook of a full rescheduling of all marijuana products raises safety concerns by weakening employers' zero-tolerance policies, compromising the current Federal drug testing program for safety-sensitive professions, complicating enforcement, and potentially increasing marijuana use among all drivers. Given the absence of a validated tool for measuring marijuana impairment and the fact that it already accounts for most drug violations in the FMCSA Clearinghouse, rescheduling marijuana would jeopardize the safety of millions of road users. This Subcommittee must ensure that effective and robust drug testing protocols for safety-sensitive occupations remain intact, and that transportation safety is prioritized regardless of the legal status of marijuana at the Federal level. ATA will continue working closely with DOT to remediate downstream consequences to its testing program and urges Congress, HHS, and other Federal partners to understand the implications of DEA's pending reclassification, assess any potential unintended consequences, and ensure that any future policy changes preserve DOT's authority to test safety-sensitive workers. Given the lack of a reliable impairment standard, maintaining the ability to test for marijuana remains essential to protecting highway safety. While ATA encourages Congress to continue supporting and providing resources for research on and development of a marijuana impairment standard, such as those provisions in the IIJA, we believe that in the absence of such tools, employers must be equipped with the most effective, reliable tools for ensuring a drug-free driving workforce. Furthermore, oral fluids testing offers employers a direct window into recent use of impairing drugs as a convenient, rapid, nonintrusive, and directly observable method. It has been proven to reduce, if not eliminate, instances of tampering or ``cheating'' and is ideal for post-accident and reasonable suspicion scenarios given its detection of recent use. This is particularly relevant within the context of the impending marijuana rescheduling and lack of a standardized impairment tool. Although oral fluid testing was approved for regulated use in 2023 by DOT, no U.S. laboratory has been certified to perform it. Thus, regulated employers cannot utilize this testing method. Additionally, ATA strongly supports providing additional resources and flexibility on testing methods, such as allowing oral fluids testing, to improve the rate of post-accident testing to determine whether CMV drivers involved in an accident were under the influence of illicit substances. NextNav & Trucking Applications of the Lower 900 MHz Band A discussion on the impact of technology on our freight transportation networks would not be complete without a discussion of the ongoing efforts by NextNav to privatize an important part of the wireless spectrum for proprietary use. In April 2024, NextNav petitioned the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) for a rule change to assign a portion of the lower 900 MHz band of spectrum to the company for use in testing, developing, and deploying a Position, Navigation, Timing (PNT) alternative to satellite-based global positioning systems (GPS). ATA, partners throughout the trucking industry, and a broad coalition of stakeholders including retailers and aviation, all strongly oppose this petition because of the important use cases of the spectrum for existing supply chain services. While this issue is not directly under the jurisdiction of this Subcommittee, the full Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee has an important role to play in overseeing the FCC and pushing back against an ill-advised effort to gatekeep vital portions of the spectrum. Trucking companies,\8\ retailers,\9\ utilities, tolling operators, port authorities, and an ecosystem of supply chain partners\10\,\11\ that span all modes of freight transportation have made significant investments in RFID-based solutions that help improve supply chain efficiency and drive down costs for consumers. In particular, the Lower 900 MHz band is used in trackers for supply chain security to thwart cargo theft, track equipment and inventory, bypass tolls, and bypass weigh stations to streamline inspections. These solutions allow for greater supply chain visibility that is valued by both shippers and individual consumers, as well as for management of equipment and the efficient movement of freight and people on our highways. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ United Parcel Service. (2026, April 14). UPS's RFID Sensing Technology Transforms Logistics Industry, Giving Customers Unprecedented Package Visibility and Reliability [Press release]. https://about.ups.com/us/en/newsroom/press-releases/customer-first/ups- s-rfid-sensingtechno logytransformslogisticsindustry-givingcu.html \9\ Walmart. (2025, October 22). Walmart and Avery Dennison Collaborate to Enhance Freshness and Increase Operational Efficiency Using RFID [Press Release]. https://corporate.walmart .com/news/2025/10/22/walmart-and-avery-dennison-collaborate-to-enhance- freshness-and-increase-operational-efficiency-using-rfid \10\ Michelin. Connective Innovations at a Glance. Michelin Tires. Retrieved June 5, 2026 from https://business.michelinman.com/by- technology/connective-innovations#RFID \11\ Mile Marker 2026: The National Bypass Impact Index. PrePass Safety Alliance, 2026. https://prepass.com/impact-index/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ATA recognizes the importance of strengthening the Nation's PNT capabilities and reducing reliance on GPS alone, particularly given growing concerns regarding signal disruption, jamming, and broader national security vulnerabilities. However, any effort to develop a terrestrial GPS backup system must be carefully balanced against the needs of existing spectrum users. NextNav's proposal would introduce a high-powered, wide-area network into a spectrum band currently used by low-power RFID and short-range communication technologies that support critical supply chain, transportation, retail, aviation, security, and healthcare operations. These systems were designed to operate in a shared environment and depend on reliable access to the Lower 900 MHz band. ATA and a broad coalition of stakeholders remain concerned that NextNav has not demonstrated a viable path for coexistence or adequately addressed the potential for harmful interference that could disrupt billions of dollars of existing infrastructure and create new operational, economic, and safety risks across multiple sectors of the economy. DEF Flexibility As mentioned previously, modern trucks are safer than ever. Today's trucks are also much cleaner than previous generations. Sixty trucks manufactured today emit less than a single truck manufactured in 1985. These advances are the result of proactive efforts by trucking companies and manufacturers, guided by workable Federal emissions regulations. However, in recent years, the issue of safe, well- maintained trucks being put out of service due to faulty diesel exhaust fluid (DEF) quality sensors or unreliable components in the emissions system has been a frustrating and growing issue for many truckers. ATA is working with leaders in Congress and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to address this issue through legislative and regulatory reforms. ATA supports the flexibility EPA provided for truckers in guidance issued in August 2025 and March 2026 that allows drivers to move freight to its destination and equipment to an appropriate location for service in the event of an emissions system failure. EPA's revised guidance ensures that drivers will continue to use DEF and benefit from the resulting emissions reductions without severe speed limitations and unnecessary towing costs that create operational challenges for trucking companies and raise safety concerns for all road users. As we work with Congress, we are grateful to members such as Sen. Sullivan on this Subcommittee for his efforts to address this issue in the context of the unique concerns of Alaskans. Obviously, no one wants a truck to shut down or a driver to be stranded on the side of the road in subzero weather. We also encourage the members of this Subcommittee not to allow the erosion of air quality improvements the trucking industry has already achieved. The issues around DEF, engine de-rating, and induced losses of torque and speed are significant, but should not result in deleting system components, rendering emission systems inoperable, or making DEF use optional. ATA urges the Subcommittee to be mindful of, and to maintain Federal leadership in, setting and maintaining feasible emissions goals for key pollutants. Because of the willingness of states such as California to overreach and place unreasonable mandates on the trucking industry, clear Federal leadership is vital. In Conclusion Thank you for the opportunity to testify on behalf of the 8.4 million people in trucking-related jobs who power our Nation's supply chains and keep the wheels of the economy turning. Surface transportation reauthorization in the 119th Congress is a potentially transformational opportunity for our country. The ATA looks forward to supporting your efforts to improve the safe and efficient movement of freight across our Nation and to encourage economic growth. Thank you again for your leadership on these vital issues. Senator Young. Thank you, Mr. Spear. Our next witness is Ms. Laura Chace, President and CEO of the Intelligent Transportation Society of America, also known as ITS America. Ms. Chace has led ITS America since August 2021. She has two decades of experience developing and implementing policy, including in roles at U.S. Telecom, the American Trucking Association, Justice Department, and the White House. Ms. Chace, you're recognized for five minutes. STATEMENT OF LAURA CHACE, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ITS AMERICA Ms. Chace. Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today on how technological advances are strengthening our Nation's transportation system. This discussion comes at an important moment as Congress considers the next surface transportation reauthorization and the future direction of our transportation system. ITS America brings together the full innovation ecosystem, public agencies, private companies, and research institutions to advance a vision of a better future transformed by technology and innovation, one that is safe, smart, and connected. Our focus is not on supporting deployment of technology for technology's sake, but on ensuring that innovation translates into real world outcomes for the traveling public. Our transportation system has evolved. It is no longer just concrete, asphalt, and steel. Today, transportation is increasingly defined by a combination of physical infrastructure and digital capabilities. Sensors, software, communication networks and data systems are now embedded throughout the transportation network, creating a digital layer that allows agencies and operators to understand conditions in real time and respond more effectively. This evolution is already delivering measurable results. These developments point to a broader shift. Digital technologies must be treated as core transportation elements. They are fundamental to how the system operates, how it performs, and how it delivers outcomes for the American public. You can't manage what you don't understand and digital infrastructure fundamentally improves our ability to understand our transportation system. Treating technology as a core element means prioritizing it throughout entire project life cycles, from planning and building to operating and maintaining, and funding it at meaningful levels and in the same dedicated way that we do our traditional physical assets. Across the country, technology applications are improving safety. From smart signals and pedestrian detection systems in Bellevue, Washington, delivering a 40 percent reduction in near miss conflicts at intersections, to digital alerting systems in Illinois, increasing driver reaction distance and reducing harsh braking, to real time detection technology in Indiana, keeping workers safe in work zones. The impact on safety is real. Technologies are also improving lives and reducing costs. In Detroit, travel reliability was improved by 30 percent from advanced traffic management systems using real time data to optimize signal timing and reduce congestion. Tools that provide real time truck parking information, streamline way station operations and improve logistics planning also allow goods to get to your door more efficiently. Digital twins, sensors and AI-enabled inspection systems for roads and bridges provide engineers with predictive intelligence to better maintain our infrastructure, saving agencies hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. State and local transportation agencies are deploying these solutions today, but they are often doing so in fragmented ways that limit their full impact. To understand why that matters, it's helpful to consider a broader example. Think about the standalone computer. On its own, it delivers real value: processing information, storing data, improving productivity. But its full potential was realized when it became connected. The Internet transformed individual machines into a network that enables communication, coordination, and shared intelligence at scale. Our transportation system is now at a similar inflection point. Intelligent technologies are already delivering meaningful benefits at individual intersections, along individual corridors, and throughout individual states. But when those systems are connected through national interoperable digital infrastructure, they become something more powerful: a coordinated, responsive network that can operate as a system. Without that integration, we risk a future where deployment remains uneven and fragmented, limiting the safety, mobility, and economic benefits these technologies can deliver. Addressing that challenge is essential to unlocking the full value of innovation. Federal leadership plays a critical role. A clear national approach to transportation technology will provide direction, reduce fragmentation, and give public agencies and private partners alike greater confidence to invest. Establishing consistent national frameworks for areas such as automated vehicles, data privacy, and system interoperability can help ensure that innovation is deployed safely and at scale across the country. Just as providing funding flexibility and incurring outcomes-based approaches can help agencies deploy solutions that evolve over time and deliver measurable results. America has an opportunity to lead the world in transportation system modernization. Digital solutions, both in infrastructure and in vehicles, are poised to provide safety and operational benefits that can unlock the next chapter of America's transportation evolution. By aligning policy, funding and deployment strategies, this Congress can deliver to the American people the full safety, efficiency, and mobility benefits that these technologies offer. Thank you for the opportunity. I look forward to the questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Chace follows:] Prepared Statement of Laura Chace, President and CEO, On Behalf of The Intelligent Transportation Society of America (ITS America) Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, full committee Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to speak today and highlight how technology is transforming and improving our Nation's transportation system. This hearing is particularly relevant given the backdrop of the current surface transportation reauthorization process and expiring authorities in September, and on behalf of our members, I appreciate the opportunity to share our perspective. My name is Laura Chace, and I serve as the President and CEO of the Intelligent Transportation Society of America (ITS America). ITS America is the Nation's leading advocate for the technological modernization of our transportation system by focusing on advancing research and deployment of intelligent transportation technology. ITS America was initially founded in 1991 as an advisory council to U.S. DOT on technology innovation and emerging transportation technologies. ITS America, now a nonprofit organization, is the only one in the country that represents all sectors--public, private, research and academia--to advance transportation technology in support of societal goals. Our vision is one of a better future transformed by transportation technology and innovation. One that is Safe, Smart, and Connected. Our membership includes state and city departments of transportation, transit agencies, metropolitan planning organizations, automotive manufacturers, technology companies, engineering firms, automotive suppliers, telecommunications providers and research and academic universities. Our work balances policy with innovation, accelerating the deployment of technology that saves lives on the road, makes travel more efficient, connects people to mobility options, improves transportation network operations, and increases return on investment for our infrastructure projects. ITS America's work focuses on connected and automated vehicle technologies, smart and digital infrastructure, artificial intelligence, tools that improve system efficiency and resiliency, and other technologies that support vulnerable road users, freight, public transportation, on-demand services, and advanced air mobility. I. The Transformative Power of Technology in Transportation Our transportation system is evolving from one largely defined by concrete, asphalt, and steel to one that today includes sensors, software, data, and algorithms. Today's digital networks provide tools to link physical transportation assets with a digital intelligence layer, allowing us to gather, transmit, store, analyze, and communicate information in real time, and to use that information to increase safety, reduce congestion, and enhance mobility for every transportation user. Transportation digital infrastructure helps us gather information about our transportation system and infrastructure, providing agencies with crucial tools to make planning decisions, enact safety countermeasures, build and operate their system more effectively and at lower costs, and provide real time information to drivers and road users. This is no longer a theoretical, high-tech future. Technology solutions deployed today across our Nation's transportation system are delivering real outcomes. Tools like artificial intelligence (AI), vehicle connectivity, automated vehicles (AVs), digital twinning, advanced air mobility, and many other intelligent transportation systems (ITS) technologies are transforming the way people and goods move; how we plan, build, and operate transportation systems; and how we think about the future. Technology is now a core, essential element of our transportation system. These technologies are helping us solve some of our most pressing transportation challenges that cannot be solved by physical improvements alone. Solutions that allow agencies to proactively identify and address dangerous stretches of roadways, react in real- time to reduce congestion, provide advance warning of severe weather to mitigate impacts, and provide faster emergency response are just some of the tools that make up this essential digital layer. As the pace of technology innovation continues to accelerate, we can leverage these tools to address the many challenges facing the U.S. transportation system today. It is well known that far too many people are injured or die on our Nation's roads each year. In 2025, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) estimates that there were 36,640 deaths on American roads.\1\ While this is positive progress from a few years ago, we still have much more work to do. Technology, both in the vehicle and infrastructure, provides an added safety layer that can help us change course and save more American lives. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ National Highway Traffic Safety Administration --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Traffic congestion is a key driver of economic harm and commuter misery. According to the U.S. Department of Transportation, the average auto commuter lost 63 hours stuck in traffic in 2024, costing nearly $1,500 each. This represents $269 billion in lost productivity and fuel costs. Advanced traffic management systems and AI-enabled systems can keep traffic moving efficiently across rural highways and urban streets. Infrastructure projects over the years have become more costly to complete and often run the risk of not being completed on time. According to research from Texas A&M University, just one month of delay can lead to over $4 million dollars for large projects.\2\ This remains a challenge if we want to operate and build a world-class transportation system that serves everyone from the urban streets of New York or Dallas to rural highways in Wyoming or Wisconsin. Fortunately, we have digital tools available today that can streamline project delivery, increase accuracy, and reduce time to completion. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ State of Texas --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Providing timely and safe access to transportation options remains a challenge in many communities. Research shows that millions of medical appointments are missed annually due to inadequate transportation options.\3\ Additionally, many people in both rural and urban areas rely upon on-time and safe public or on-demand transportation to reach critical goods and services, or just simply to see loved ones. Technology plays a critical role in ensuring not just the safety of these modes of transport, but also up-to-date information on service delays, payment options, and booking rides. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ Ruderman Foundation --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Our member companies are developing the innovative technology solutions that we have today, but as a country, we are not moving quickly enough to broadly scale these solutions throughout our infrastructure, vehicles, and broader transportation networks. Solving these pervasive challenges requires that we prioritize investments in technology solutions that will improve safety and mobility outcomes and remove existing barriers to deployment. The cost of not moving fast enough is not a net zero--it is measured in lives, time, and money lost. Coordinated Federal leadership, through strategic direction and funding, is necessary to spur greater deployment of these tools and to incentivize greater private sector investment. i. Enhanced Safety Technology provides the opportunity to proactively address safety challenges in myriad ways, such as recognizing and predicting dangerous conditions that were previously unidentified, and helping road users and transportation agencies understand and address dangerous situations to prevent crashes before they happen. These tools also provide drivers with more information about the hazardous conditions around them on the roadway, allowing more time to react and make better decisions that improve safety. Technology can take us from a reactive system whose tools are largely focused on responding to fatalities to a proactive system that addresses issues before they result in a death or serious injury. Vehicle Technologies Motor vehicle manufacturers continue to develop and deploy advanced technologies in vehicles, including SAE Level 4 and 5 automated vehicles (AVs), Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS), and Vehicle- to-Everything (V2X) communications. These tools provide safety and convenience benefits to consumers today and will only continue to become more technologically advanced and interconnected with the broader transportation system. Automated vehicle technology is already transforming the way people and goods move in various parts of the country. Our members are deploying automated vehicle technologies in different ways and in different geographies- including robotaxis, transit shuttle services, and heavy-freight. In Iowa, researchers have even piloted ways to deploy AV transit services on rural gravel roads with unmarked lanes to support communities that need to get goods from farms to market reliably and efficiently. Options such as Zoox's or Waymo's robotaxis or Aurora's trucks (among many other operators), have the potential to transform mobility and improve safety on the road. AVs do not get distracted, drunk, or tired, offering the potential to prevent thousands of fatalities per year. It is not a question of whether the technology will work- but rather how we can enable safe scaling and integration with the existing transportation system through a much- needed Federal framework. ADAS technologies are already responding to driver action or inaction to correct vehicle positioning, brake for other vehicles, assist in lane-keeping, and more. Over the years, automakers have made significant investments in ADAS, and these tools are probably what people are most familiar with in their vehicle today. The safety benefits are apparent. In some rural areas, nearly half of all crash- related fatalities over the last seven years have involved lane departure, and ADAS can help mitigate these crashes. Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) technology can play a greater role by providing drivers and other road users with critical information and improved awareness about roadway, traffic, and weather conditions before a user encounters them through the deployment of connected vehicles and infrastructure. The information exchange enabled by V2X communications, including spectrum-based, cloud-based, and cellular network solutions, can warn drivers about sudden braking, wrong way drivers, traffic queues, and other dangerous roadway scenarios beyond their line of sight, allowing them to take action to avoid vehicle pileups and other associated crash risks. Cloud-based digital alerting tools, like those from HAAS Alert, can alert motorists inside their vehicle that an emergency vehicle is nearby or that they are entering a work zone where workers may be present. When activated, these platforms deliver real-time digital alerts over cellular networks to approaching motorists. These alerts are received through navigation apps and connected car systems already in use by hundreds of millions of drivers, including Waze and other integrated displays, and enable drivers to reduce their speed and prevent a collision. A study in Illinois showed that digital alerting technologies increased driver reaction distance 4x more than just emergency lights, and led to reduced harsh braking compared to when there was no digital alert.\4\ This translates into safer driver behavior near emergency vehicles, queuing traffic, and roadside workers--reducing the chance of a collision. In Washington, D.C., data revealed that digital alerting applications helped D.C. Fire and EMS Department apparatus operators prevent collisions with other first responders.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ Illinois Center for Transportation \5\ ITS America Use Case Library --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We are encouraged by the continuous innovation in the automotive market, and these are just a few examples of how vehicle technology can improve safety. Infrastructure Technologies Modernizing our transportation infrastructure and treating technology as a core element of the system will help unlock numerous safety, efficiency, and mobility benefits for the traveling public. Today, states are already deploying technology within their infrastructure to help reduce crashes, improve transportation system operation, support vulnerable road user safety, identify incident hotspots, reduce congestion, improve emergency response, and plan safer physical infrastructure systems. For instance, our infrastructure is smart enough to detect when a person is still in the crosswalk and requires more time to finish crossing a street, allowing the infrastructure to automatically extend the light so that a person can safely complete the crossing. Technology can hold lights on red if it detects a speeding vehicle entering an intersection, preventing deadly T-bone collisions. Not only can technology work in real-time to prevent crashes, but it provides agencies with critical insights on near-misses or crash hot spots so that agencies can enact the proper safety countermeasures. Using cameras, fixed lidar technology, adaptive signals, and AI algorithms, cities like Bellevue, Washington have demonstrated success when deploying pedestrian detection technology with the help of companies like Derq, AWS, and Ouster. Some cities in the U.S. have seen a 33 percent reduction in crashes year-over-year after deploying AI- powered technology to detect potential conflict between pedestrians and vehicles and proactively alert agencies to adjust traffic patterns to prevent crashes. Rural communities suffer a disproportionately higher burden of traffic fatalities and sometimes face unique challenges due to a lack of broadband infrastructure and network connectivity.\6\ However, many states are deploying technology and wireless infrastructure along their rural interstates to help improve traffic management and bolster safety. States like Georgia are investing in fiber infrastructure across rural areas to support ITS, while Texas and North Carolina are deploying connected freight corridors with in-cab alerts for work zones, weather, and incidents on rural interstates. Iowa is piloting a safety alert system for motorists when slow moving agricultural equipment is on the road--this includes sensors on the roadside and on the tractors with dynamic message signs to warn motorists. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ National Highway Traffic Safety Administration --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Roadway workers face daily risks from high-speed traffic and rapidly changing conditions, but technology is transforming how we protect them. Smart work zones use sensors, connected vehicle data, telematics, and AI-driven analytics to monitor safety hotspots, detect hazards, and deliver real-time alerts to both workers and approaching drivers. Intrusion detection systems can warn workers immediately when a vehicle enters a restricted area, providing critical seconds to take protective action. At the same time, digital alerting platforms can notify drivers in advance that they are approaching a work zone or roadside incident, improving reaction time and reducing sudden braking and secondary crashes. Rekor helped Texas identify near miss hotspots by showing the transportation agency data about wrong way driving and dangerous pedestrian crossings. This allowed the agency to make improvements to physical infrastructure to immediately enhance safety. Additionally, AI tools can detect crashes well in advance of the traditional method of receiving a 9-1-1 call, automatically alerting first responders. This has allowed EMS to respond to incidents by an average of 11 minutes faster, while reducing the chance of secondary crashes and maximizing public agency resources. Wrong-way driving crashes are among the most severe events on our roadways, often resulting in high-speed, head-on collisions with devastating consequences. Many states today are deploying infrastructure-based solutions that can detect vehicles traveling in the wrong direction using radar, thermal imaging, and cameras, triggering immediate warnings through flashing signage and connected alerts to the driver and nearby vehicles. These systems can also notify traffic management centers and law enforcement in real time, allowing for rapid intervention before a crash occurs. By combining real-time detection, dynamic signage, and in-vehicle alerts, technology can actively prevent wrong-way driving incidents and alert authorities to take action before a tragedy happens. These are just a small sample of the technologies available today to improve transportation safety, with many more applications available today and under development relating to weather-related issues, flooding, bridge heights, and natural disaster response. ii. Greater Efficiency Advanced traffic management technology, such as cloud-based platforms and AI-powered tools, can help monitor traffic using real- time data and optimize traffic flow. Connected, smart traffic signals can maintain safety while promoting the efficient flow of traffic for all road users--vehicles, buses, and even cyclists. In one example, Detroit, Michigan saw a 30 percent decrease in travel times at major intersections after deploying advanced traffic management solutions from Miovision, while also reducing maintenance costs by 20 percent.\7\ This solution was similarly used in eight intersections in Anne Arundel County, Maryland to eliminate 17,200 hours of road user delay annually. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Detroit's Mobility Evolution | Miovision --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Technology can simplify and optimize the process of retiming intersections to better manage existing traffic patterns and congestion, significantly reducing the burden this costly and time- consuming process places on public agencies across the country. There are over 350,000 traffic signals in the U.S., and data shows that it takes 70 manual hours to retime one intersection.\8\ There are tools today, such as those from Flow Labs, that can optimize traffic signal timing almost instantaneously, generating optimized timing plans with a click of a button and integrating directly with traffic signal controllers for updates. In an era of constrained fiscal budgets and growing infrastructure needs, these technologies are helping our cities make limited transportation dollars go further while improving travel for residents. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\ Flow Labs --------------------------------------------------------------------------- North Carolina recently announced it is installing 2,500 AI-based traffic signals--an investment that will help the state bypass costly hardware installations and improve signal timing based on real-world traffic patterns. Additionally, the Delaware Department of Transportation won a SMART grant award from USDOT in 2023 which led to successful demonstrations of infrastructure-based V2X systems that would improve safety and traffic management in the state, with Delaware now ready to deploy these tools more widely if funding becomes available.\9\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\ Future-Ready Delaware: SMART Technology Enhancements for Safe, Resilient Intersections --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Parking for truck drivers remains a persistent problem on our Nation's interstates and can cause significant safety and quality of life issues on the road. In addition to building new parking spaces for drivers, companies are deploying technology in partnership with public agencies to help maximize existing capacity and provide drivers with up-to-date real-time information on truck parking availability. New Mexico is doing exactly that--leveraging AI-enabled sensing technology to fuse data from radar with video to provide real-time availability to truck drivers and help the state manage its truck parking facilities.\10\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\ Omnisight--New Mexico --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Additionally, innovative freight weigh station bypass technologies by PrePass have led to $12 billion in operational cost savings and 136 million driver hours saved over the lifetime of the technology.\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\ PrePass --------------------------------------------------------------------------- These are all critical tools that warrant further investment to support freight networks across the country so that our economy continues to thrive and we keep goods moving on time and safely. iii. Smarter System Management Digital tools can help agencies identify and prevent issues in their system, manage assets smarter, and improve project delivery times. Technology can detect structural issues in bridges and roads early on and monitor for further wear-and-tear. Traditional methods involve manual inspection, which can be costly and time consuming for public agencies. New inventions use computer vision AI, virtual reality tools, sensors, and drones to proactively collect images and videos of defects in roads and bridges that humans may not be able to see. While cameras continually monitor the asset, software processes and analyzes the collected data, providing engineers with a safety assessment that includes information about structural changes and weaknesses, as well as immediate damage. New technologies can help public agencies monitor the health of bridges and detect issues before a disaster happens. Structural health monitoring using sensors provides real-time data to allow engineers to detect stress, movement, or structural damage on bridges and roads-- giving workers more tools to investigate and remedy infrastructure deficiencies. Through the U.S. DOT's SMART grant program, West Virginia is deploying this technology on the Gunner Gatski Bridge to help manage infrastructure in a smarter, safer way.\12\ Many other places, including the cities of Denver and Seattle are using digital twins and sensor technology to monitor bridge health. Texas DOT is using drones to monitor bridges and inspect aerial structures, gathering critical data for contractors and engineers. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\ West Virginia Daily News --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Innovative technologies can also significantly improve roadway management. State and local governments oversee hundreds or even thousands of miles of roadway, making asset management costly and cumbersome. Tools such as dashcam footage and machine learning models combine to analyze roads for striping visibility, guardrail detection, damage, debris, and pavement conditions--often identifying issues beyond what the human eye can detect. Hawaii has utilized these tools from Blyncsy to save over $900,000 in maintenance costs per year, reducing the need for cumbersome manual surveys by nearly 95 percent and reducing emissions from work vehicles that now have to travel less often.\13\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\ Blyncsy --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We know that project delivery challenges, whether for highways, transit, rail, or otherwise, can be a serious roadblock to improving transportation systems in the United States. Digital twinning technology now exists that aids and accelerates infrastructure planning, design, and construction, giving engineers digital 3D and 4D models that improve contractor workflows, simplify public communications, and identify issues before construction. This represents a generational shift from traditional paper-based planning to model-centric frameworks where digital models become the primary deliverable. Modern infrastructure development increasingly requires integrating previously disconnected data sources--such as lidar, imagery, inspection records, sensor data, and asset inventories--into a digital ecosystem. Real-time asset management requires the most up-to- date data, making digital twinning technology and digital construction tools vital to project delivery. These innovations are transforming the way public agencies plan, design, build, operate and maintain the transportation systems American rely on, bringing critical data and intelligence into every aspect of the project lifecycle. With such innovative tools at our fingertips, we should ensure that their use is incentivized and encouraged by state and local agencies nationwide. II. Scaling Faster: Technology is a Core Element of the Transportation System i. National Approach to National Challenges Transportation challenges in one area of the country impact all of us. Roads and bridges cross state lines, but so do people, vehicles, goods, and data. To help scale technologies in transportation, national leadership is required. In addition to setting common goals, national leadership helps de-risk technology investment for the public sector and encourages broader investment in core technology tools. A national vision for our transportation digital infrastructure would set a gold standard for U.S. transportation innovation and signal to not only public agencies but also the private market that these technologies should be accelerated. It would bring together a network of successful, but currently fragmented, projects across 50 states toward shared common goals. That fragmentation limits the impact of innovation, constrains market growth, and ultimately leaves safety and mobility gains on the table. The Office of Research and Technology at U.S. DOT is already undertaking some of these efforts, but Congress should work hand in hand with its agency partners to set a national approach and implementation plan to make this a reality. Much like digital infrastructure, automated vehicles are a key part of reducing traffic fatalities and improving access to mobility. In recent years, states have set the pace on AV policy, but it is important for the Federal government to establish a Federal framework that supports safe and responsible AV deployment across the entire country. This includes establishing Federal guidelines on safety cases and crash data reporting, and modifying existing vehicle safety standards to allow for the use of AVs with innovative designs (i.e., without manual driving controls or purpose-built transit vehicles). In the freight sector, this also means allowing for the use of innovative warning beacons and other safety technologies, instead of requiring manually placed warning triangles on the side of the road when a truck becomes disabled. As part of any Federal AV framework, it is important that all stakeholders--including private industry, states, cities, organized labor, safety advocates, and others--are at the table for these critical conversations. We know the technology is ready, but we must work together to implement it in a way that integrates safely with the existing transportation system. Finally, a national data privacy framework is essential for the continued deployment of transportation technologies in a way that fosters consumer trust, protects privacy, and applies nationally so that all may benefit. The transportation industry and its users flourish when there is certainty and reliability, and the same applies to data privacy protections for ITS and transportation technology. A patchwork of state and local data privacy laws hinders the ability to scale life-saving technology that relies on accurate data. Companies are innovating and eager to develop and deploy technology solutions in the United States. As budgets across all sectors of the economy, especially public agencies, become tighter, we need innovative, cost-effective solutions that will help current transportation spending go further while making meaningful improvements to safety and mobility outcomes. Coordinated Federal leadership that recognizes technology solutions as core elements of our transportation system can help bridge that gap. Whether it's through setting strategic priorities and frameworks, providing financial incentives, or breaking down certain institutional barriers, the Federal government has an important role to play. Strong Federal leadership can unlock a scaled domestic marketplace, support American innovation, and strengthen our competitive position globally-- particularly as countries like China move aggressively to integrate technology into their transportation systems as a matter of national strategy. That leadership can simultaneously provide important cybersecurity, privacy, and general policy safeguards that will help ensure that emerging technologies are deployed in a way that maximizes their public good. The private sector is ready, and the technology is ready. The question is whether Federal policy will treat it with the urgency and importance it deserves. ii. Incentivizing Scaled Adoption Technology deployments are often fragmented into pilots and demonstration projects that prove successful but are unable to scale beyond local areas or across state lines due to lack of interoperability, lack of dedicated long-term funding, and procurement challenges. At the Federal level, current technology funding comes primarily from discretionary grant programs, such as the SMART grant program and the Advanced Transportation Technology and Innovation (ATTAIN) grant program. Many public sector agencies, however, are looking to move beyond a pilot and demonstration approach, given that much of the technology now is maturing and has demonstrated success. Moving from pilots to true operational deployments and scaling nationwide is key to seeing even greater measurable benefits. ITS projects are eligible under most Federal formula programs administered through the Federal Highway Administration. However, many states experience a common friction point--how do we prioritize both our physical and digital infrastructure when there are limited Federal dollars to go around? Because of this, many states and cities often must rely on state and local funding sources to deploy technology and build their transportation system's digital infrastructure. Funding stability and certainty are critical to deploying technology at scale in our transportation system, and U.S. DOT and Congress can help ensure that funding is prioritized when crafting policies for Federal programs. Technology projects have distinct characteristics from physical transportation projects. Unlike building a bridge or highway, technology deployments are not a single, massive project, but often a series of smaller projects that come together to deliver outsized outcomes. Since transportation technology is not delivered all at once, it requires certainty to allow for multi-year deployment and continuous improvement as new capabilities are developed that can help agencies transform operations and improve safety. Many of today's transportation technologies were not even contemplated when much of our country's infrastructure was constructed, and the Nation's economy and the mobility needs of our country have changed considerably in recent decades and will continue to change rapidly in the coming years. Previous surface transportation legislation from Congress laid a strong foundation for ensuring that the United States remains the international leader in the research and development of transportation technologies--this commitment is evidenced through programs like ARPA- I, investment in our University Transportation Centers, and continued support for research into innovative transportation technology solutions. Research and development, especially for high-risk, high- reward projects, is vital for the transportation sector. Without dedicated, standalone support for ITS technology deployment, however, we risk a situation where the United States develops innovative transportation tools, only to see our global competitors out-produce and out-deploy those same tools. We must ensure that our country's policies keep pace with the rate of American technological innovation. Beyond incentives, procuring technology and software as infrastructure assets can be challenging to public agencies. Current procurement methods were developed to purchase hard infrastructure through one-time purchases. Data streams, software licenses, and even cloud storage services are key to the transportation system today but were unheard of in infrastructure procurement even thirty years ago. These solutions are distinctly unique from physical assets--they are not one-time purchases and may require annual fees or licenses, require ongoing maintenance to ensure cybersecurity and data integrity, and can improve performance and value over time, unlike a static physical asset. We can ease the barriers to procuring technology by adopting outcomes and performance-driven metrics, rather than rigid technical specifications. State and local transportation agencies would benefit from additional Federal guidance on standards, definitions, and best practices around technology procurement. Shifting towards an outcomes- based approach encourages wider innovation and more competition in the marketplace and unlocks greater flexibility in deploying technology solutions that fit a specific community's needs. III. Conclusion Technology is a core element of how Americans move. Digital systems guide us on our daily commutes, deliver goods to our doorstep, keep us safe as we move about our communities, and ensure that the systems we rely on every day are resilient and reliable. As we build for the future, we must include technology as an essential part of our transportation system to meet the needs of future mobility while delivering better safety and operational outcomes. American innovation and ingenuity continue to lead the world. We currently have the opportunity to harness this American advantage in the communities where we live, work, and play to realize better transportation systems and safer streets across the country. ITS America is grateful for this Subcommittee's desire to discuss technology applications in the surface transportation sector, and we look forward to working with you on these issues going forward. Senator Young. Thank you, Ms. Chace. Our final witness is Mr. Cole Scandaglia. Mr. Scandaglia is the Deputy Director of the Department of Political and Legislative Action at the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, a union that represents over a million workers across numerous industries in the United States and Canada. Welcome, Mr. Scandaglia. You are now recognized for five minutes. STATEMENT OF COLE SCANDAGLIA, DEPUTY DIRECTOR, INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF TEAMSTERS Mr. Scandaglia. Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today on this important topic. Teamsters represent 1.3 million hard working people in the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico, including hundreds of thousands of employees in the rail and trucking industries. For our entire history, we've evolved alongside new transportation technologies. Our namesake refers to the men who once drove horse drawn wagons across the country and the first ever transcontinental shipment of goods by truck was conducted by a team of Teamster drivers in 1912. At the core of our mission, we believe that the tool available to the American worker to best navigate the impacts of technological change is a collective bargain agreement. Every day we use these tools to negotiate the terms of new technological deployments in a manner that ultimately benefits both our members and our employers. We do not oppose innovation. We welcome the adoption of technologies like automatic emergency braking and electronic logging devices and trucking, and the deployment of positive train control in the railroad industry. We will continue to work with Congress, regulators, and our employers on technologies which improve working conditions and increase safety on the job. Today, autonomous vehicles present enormous challenges. To date, the Federal Government has failed to advance an autonomous vehicle's framework, and the sole unique requirement to operate an autonomous vehicle in this country is to inform the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration of crashes. Continuing to permit the unfettered and unregulated operation of autonomous vehicles is a no win situation for the country. We continue to call Congress to create a binding framework that prioritizes safety, the workforce, and goes beyond weak self certification regimes. We also urge members to consider the economic impacts of mass deployment of unregulated autonomous vehicles on both our members and your constituents. Driving a truck is the single most common occupation for men in the United States without a college degree and a top 10 occupation overall in most states. More generally, increasingly connected transportation technologies also invite risk by bad actors and foreign adversaries. Teamsters believe strongly that connected vehicles and components from China must not be imported into the United States, that Chinese companies who open shop here should never receive a penny of Federal transportation dollars, and Congress must prohibit any scenario in which a person outside this country can operate or manipulate a vehicle on our roads. In the railroad industry, we're proud to represent the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen and the Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees. As two of the country's oldest unions, our rail members have adapted to extraordinary technological change. However, it is essential that Congress and the Federal Railroad Administration appreciate that tools are supplemental to our work, not a replacement. Track Geometry Measurement Systems, also known as ATI Automated Track Inspection, use advanced sensors, lasers and machine vision to identify track defects that may not be visible to the human eye. However, these systems are only capable of identifying certain regulatory defects, not all which must be evaluated under current regulation. We don't oppose this technology, in fact, we've called for it to be mandatory. But combining this technology with human visual inspections conducted on a twice weekly basis as currently prescribed in the regulations, is the equation for optimal safety outcomes. Locomotive engineers have also seen massive changes within the last 15 years, including the use of PTC as well as energy management systems like Trip Optimizer. Again, these technologies have value if used properly. Increasingly, however, we are seeing usage which takes away a substantial amount of decisionmaking from crews for up to 95 percent of trip time. These extensive periods of time risk deskilling of engineers, who may in turn be unprepared when asked to reassert control in a scenario where the technology fails or an emergency presents itself. Minimum time spent in manual operations can combat these effects. Further, the BLET continues to sound the alarm on the use of remote control locomotives, which are generally operated by an engineer who's not physically present in the cab. These operations carry risk already when operating in a yard environment, but are increasingly being used on mainline track and rail sidings, which invites unacceptable dangers. Across all modes, including those subject to this subcommittee and the full committee, the Teamsters Union continues to support strong prescriptive regulations where warranted. Innovation, regulation and the workforce need not be in conflict with each other, and we commit to working with the Committee and the Subcommittee to that effect. Appreciate the opportunity to testify today and look forward to questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Scandaglia follows:] Prepared Statement of Cole Scandaglia, Deputy Director, Department of Political and Legislative Action, International Brotherhood of Teamsters Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, and members of the Subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today on ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances are Driving Transportation Innovation.'' The International Brotherhood of Teamsters represents 1.3 million hardworking people in the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico, including hundreds of thousands of members in the transportation industry including in commercial trucking. In the railroad industry, we are also proud to represent the Teamsters-affiliated Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (BLET) and the Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes (BMWED). Throughout our history, the Teamsters Union has been at the forefront of adapting to and evolving with technological changes that fundamentally impact our work and workplaces. Our namesake refers to the men who drove horse-drawn wagons across the country, serving as the lifeblood of our economy and the origins of our freight network. By 1912, appreciating the promises of internal combustion vehicles, a group of Teamsters participated in the first transcontinental delivery of goods by truck, hauling three tons of soap from Philadelphia to Petaluma, California. Since then, our union has expanded greatly, organizing members across the Nation in innumerable industries and crafts. Technological change and advancement have, and will continue, altering these occupations and what work may look like day to day. Fundamentally, we are supportive of technologies that improve working conditions and safety for our members, or that offer new opportunities which did not exist previously. The Teamsters will continue to rise to the occasion and ensure that the evolution or creation of jobs also entails the ability of workers to choose to join a union--and the protections, wages, and improved conditions that are inherent to doing so. We also fundamentally assert that the most powerful tool available to the American worker to best navigate the impacts of technological change is a collective bargaining agreement. It is the only method by which workers have an opportunity to directly engage with their employers over the deployments of new technologies and provide the most valuable data while doing so--the perspectives of individuals who will directly interact with such technologies and can address both positive and negative impacts of such deployments. The Teamsters have been the vanguard of these efforts, increasingly using the collective bargaining process to create formal structures, such as technology committees, in which our members have direct and binding channels to negotiate the terms of new technological deployments in a manner that ultimately benefits both our members and our employers. Teamsters and Technology In recent years, Teamsters have championed and welcomed the adoption of numerous technologies in our workplaces. In the trucking industry, we have long supported the adoption of Automatic Emergency Braking systems in Class 7 and 8 heavy duty trucks--which were largely already installed in many of our vehicles even prior to the Federal mandate. The replacement of paper hours of service logs with Electronic Logging Devices is an important step in ensuring compliance with critical safety mandates and keeping unscrupulous operators off the road. We've also bargained over the use of non-regulated technologies, ranging from in-vehicle telematics to package tracking equipment, to efficiency technologies in warehousing. BLET represented locomotive engineers spent years calling for installation of positive train control (PTC) systems long before their Congressionally mandated deployment. These systems provide an extra layer of safety to help prevent collisions, derailments, and conflicting train movements, and in coordination with qualified locomotive engineers demonstrably improve outcomes. Across their long history, BMWED members charged with inspecting and maintaining track and railroad infrastructure have engaged with innumerable fundamental changes to their workplaces from the deployment of hydraulic tools to the development of production tampers, to the use and standardization of continuous welded rail in the industry. In all of these cases, and in many more across our union we have welcomed the adoption of new technologies that improved the jobs of our members as they functioned alongside them. It is also the case that positive opportunities for new technology exist outside of the physical operation of modes of transportation. Chairman Young's SAFER Transport Act considers the use of A.I. tools to identify patterns in Federal Motor Carrier Administration (FMCSA) registrations and safety data that are suggestive of the presence of chameleon carriers, fraudulent registrations, or double brokering. These flags would then be reviewed by FMCSA staff, who could then launch investigation or enforcement action. Given the vast universe of regulated entities FMCSA is responsible for overseeing, and the dangers presented by carriers operating unlawfully, providing AI tools in concert with human review to make actual investigatory and enforcement decisions could prove beneficial in addressing pressing safety concerns. Autonomous Vehicles There is likely no technology with a disruptive impact as wide reaching as autonomous vehicles, including autonomous commercial motor vehicles. We are seeing commercialized deployments of these vehicles increase by the day, across the country. At the same time, the Federal government has thus far failed to create any kind of framework that would address manufacturing standards, operational requirements, or workforce impacts of this technology. As the Subcommittee is well aware, the singular unique requirement placed on autonomous vehicles today is that significant accidents must be reported via the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's (NHTSA) Standing General Order 2021-01. Continuing to permit the unfettered and unregulated operation of autonomous vehicles presents only harm to roadway safety and to the continued existence of the millions of jobs directly in, or connected to, commercial driving. Action on this front is increasingly overdue, and the Teamsters continue to call on Congress and regulators to take action to create a binding regulatory framework that prioritizes safety and addresses unique conditions and risks presented by autonomous vehicles. Specifically, this framework must extend beyond un-benchmarked and amorphous fully self-certificated regimes which substitute meaningful safety oversight for box-checking exercises. We further reject the blanket conclusion that pursuing thoughtful regulation on these novel technologies is anathema to innovation and note that this position is not borne out by history. As horse-drawn carriages gave way to trucks, individual states began passing laws on truck safety as early as 1913. By 1935, Congress saw fit to pass the Motor Carrier Act, which specifically created authority under the Interstate Commerce Commission to ``establish reasonable requirements with respect to . . . safety of operation and equipment.'' That legislation ultimately paved the way for the Federal safety regime we know today, including the development of Federal Motor Vehicle Safey Standards (FMVSS), with the first FMVSS adopted in 1967. Over nearly 100 years of further technological advancement, Congress and regulators have created, amended, and repealed safety requirements as necessary to meet the times. However, it is simply ahistorical to now claim that technological innovation simply cannot exist outside of a laissez-faire regulatory structure. Well-considered regulation is a predicate for, not an unjust impediment to, to the safe deployment of new technologies. To that end, we are committed to working with both this Subcommittee and the full Committee to develop a strong Federal framework on commercial autonomous vehicles. Lastly, we urge Members to consider the economic impacts of mass deployment of unregulated autonomous vehicles on your constituents. The single most common occupation for men in the United States without a college degree is truck drivers and driver/sales workers.\1\ It is not a credible claim to assume that if given the opportunity, employers will only seek to automate small segments of the industry when the primary motivating factor behind AV deployment is the elimination of labor costs. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/07/11/among-young- us-workers-without-a-college-degree-men-and-women-hold-very-different- types-of-jobs/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Neither are our members, or commercial drivers writ large, swayed by promises that the economy will naturally produce equivalent numbers of jobs if AV deployment begins to result in displacement, much less that any such jobs will be similarly available and/or offer comparable levels of compensation and benefits. Congress must not ignore these potential impacts as it considers the adoption of AVs. Technology and Security Threats As transportation technologies of all stripes become more advanced and more interconnected, security risks also become more abundant. This is particularly acute as it relates to trucking and rail where the ability of a bad actor or a foreign adversary to access or otherwise effect operations could easily prove to be catastrophic. The Teamsters thank Senators Moreno and Slotkin for their introduction of Connected Vehicle Security Act of 2026, and Subcommittee Members Senators Schmitt and Capito for their cosponsorship. The legislation would prohibit the import of certain vehicles and components manufactured in China, which could potentially give the Chinese government or manufacturers access to Americans' data or even operational control of their vehicles. Similarly, the Teamsters are concerned with ownership and/or control of U.S. based manufacturing of transportation equipment by foreign adversaries. We continue to strongly oppose efforts by Chinese- controlled BYD and its poorly camouflaged subsidiary RIDE to re-enter into the domestic heavy duty transit bus market. Congress took decisive action to prohibit their access to Federal dollars through the Transportation Infrastructure Vehicle Security Act, adopted in 2019 as part of the National Defense Authorization Act, and these restrictions must remain and be strengthened. Lastly, we were disturbed at revelations from Waymo during the full Committee's February 4, 2026 hearing entitled ``Hit the Road, Mac: The Future of Self-Driving Cars'', in which the company revealed that remote operators in the Philippines were providing guidance to Waymo vehicles operating on American streets. While their technology may make such arrangements possible, there should never be a scenario where an individual outside the United States is able to provide guidance or assert operational controls over vehicles operating within our borders. AI Applications In addition to autonomous vehicles, Teamster members are increasingly reporting deployments of AI technologies in our workplaces, including in driver/operator monitoring, safety & health monitoring, H.R. decision making, automated scheduling, task/route assignments and optimization, fleet/operations management, predictive maintenance, productivity/quota metrics and others. As with all technology, we appreciate that if deployed and regulated appropriately AI tools have the potential to improve safety and working conditions as well as the possibility of job creation. For the purposes of today's hearing, the Teamsters encourage the Subcommittee to consider three policy principles. 1. AI must not be weaponized against working people. The opportunities for the deployment of AI tools in the transportation industry in a manner that is harmful for employees is significant. Surveillance and monitoring tools can present substantial human factors concerns including the effects of micromanagement and constant surveillance on fatigue and stress levels of workers, increased pressure on employees to complete tasks within machine-generated timeframes and performance targets. AI applications that purport to eliminate transportation jobs in their entirety, particularly when no comparable occupation is created by the use of the technology, should be viewed with extreme skepticism. 2. AI applications in transportation are a supplement, not a replacement. AI applications that combine with the experience of highly skilled professional workers with deep experience in their industries will be the most successful. Many Teamster- represented trucking fleets have deployed AI-powered real time route optimization and guidance to drivers, such as UPS' On- Road Integrated Optimization and Navigation (ORION). When functioning as an additive tool, these products can assist workers in their decision making. However, when employers instead require blind adherence to AI directives under the threat of discipline, and potentially in contradiction to the decision making of professional transportation employees, the value proposition is greatly diminished. 3. The most effective applications of AI will be the ones conducted in concert with the impacted workforce. As mentioned above, the utility of AI tools in transportation can be substantially improved when the workforce who will be operating the tools, or be impacted by them, are provided an opportunity to negotiate over their adoption, and participate in dialogue with their employers about their ongoing use and usefulness. Rail Technology Technological advancements in the rail industry present both significant opportunities and challenges, which are directly felt by the members of the IBT-affiliated BLET and BMWED. Track Geometry Measurement Systems (TGMS) TGMS systems, also known as automated track inspection (ATI) trace their roots to the 1970s. Today, some of these systems use a suite of technologies including advanced sensors, lasers, and machine vision to identify track defects that may not be visible to the human eye. ATI detects track geometry defects such as elevation, surface, and gauge deviations--a major cause of derailments. These geometry defects can sometimes be detected more precisely by ATI than by manual methods. The usage of these systems is entirely permissible under Federal Railroad Administration's (FRA) existing regulations. As a foundational matter, we would like to be extraordinarily clear that we support the use of ATI as an essential additive tool to augment twice weekly track inspections which have long been required by the FRA's regulations. In fact, the BMWED has even previously advocated for mandatory deployment of these systems. At its most useful, ATI is a supplemental tool that complements visual track inspections carried out by humans. As they are currently deployed, these systems are only capable of identifying 6 of the 23 regulatory defects which must be evaluated under 49 CFR Part 213. TGMS are incapable at identifying issues with ballast, rail wear, rail joint gaps, tie plate conditions, switch components, vegetation, obstructions in the right-of-way, or any underlying factor causing the listed defects. Simply put, they are not a replacement for human-conducted visual inspections. Additionally, like all deployments, the safety case for ATI will continue to be made in its actual usage. ATI systems send data to a central location, where it is later reviewed. Once the data is analyzed and defects are prioritized, a human inspector must still verify the defect on-site--potentially delaying repair or remediation for up to 72 hours. This delay introduces avoidable safety risks. It is also the case that identification of defects alone is of little value if appropriate maintenance is not being performed expeditiously. The persistence of railroad derailments, averaging three reportable incidents each day, underscores the need for strong Federal regulations for our Nation's railroads to keep our communities safe. To have the safest rail system, it is critical that railroads utilize both twice a week visual track inspections and automated track inspection (ATI) technology to keep our railroad tracks free from defects that can cause derailments. As the FRA continues to evaluate the performance of ATI deployments, we encourage the FRA to determine if the method by which this technology is now being deployed is resulting in improved safety outcomes. Finally, where these operations are taking place under the terms of regulatory waivers, FRA must ensure full compliance with all waiver conditions, ensure the validity and accuracy of reported safety data, and dispense with waivers where data has not proven safety equivalency. Locomotive Operations Within the last 15 years, new technologies installed in the locomotive cab have substantially changed locomotive operations. This includes PTC, as well as energy management systems such as Trip Optimizer (TO), and increased use and engineer oversight of distributed power units (DPUs) in a train consist. Managing these systems has become an increasingly significant part of the locomotive engineer's job duties. In particular, the use of TO, a technology similar to cruise control in a passenger vehicle, has become widespread with railroads requiring its use as frequently as 95 percent of a trip. This software may direct the locomotive engineer or may completely control the throttle of all locomotives used by the train, including DPUs. In the event an engineer attempts to override the TO beyond a set threshold set by management, the worker may now be subject to discipline. While we do not oppose the use of TO, the extent of its use means that engineers are often spending substantial components of their trip making a reduced number of independent decisions on train operations. When these systems fail, or unique operational circumstances present themselves, an engineer is handed control of the train in difficult situations which test their skills with no little to no warning. We are concerned that the extensive period of time in which an engineer is operating with limited decision making, including but not limited to in TO operations, will ultimately result in deskilling of engineers. This could prove catastrophic in emergency situations. Mandating minimum times spent in manual operations can combat these effects. Further, the BLET continues to sound the alarm on the use of remote control trains and locomotives (RCLs), which are generally operated without an engineer in the cab. Instead, RCLs are operated remotely by a rail worker who could be a significant distance away from the train and who usually has limited to no visibility of what is in front of the locomotive. Even within the yard environment, this creates dangerous hazards for other rail workers. Disturbingly, some railroads are now running RCL operations through towns and communities on their main tracks and rail sidings which invites unacceptable dangers to the public and should be prohibited. Federal Role In Transportation Technology Across all modes, including those subject to the Subcommittee and full Committee's jurisdiction, the Teamsters Union continues to support strong, prescriptive regulations and statutory direction from the Department of Transportation and its modal offices. In trucking, the need for such standards has never been clearer, as the Department both addresses novel technologies like autonomous vehicles and increasingly seeks to address long-term scourges in the industry. In rail, both the tragedy in East Palestine and conditions in the industry leading up to it make a similar case. Equally as important is that now the wrong time to go backwards on rail safety regulations by embracing ``performance based'' regulations at the FRA. Performance- based regulations do away with prescriptive requirements in favor of outcome targets and allow regulated entities to determine how they will demonstrate compliance. Despite claims to the contrary, FRA's regulations on key safety requirements were not drafted flippantly. They were promulgated in response to real safety issues, including those which have had tragic consequences for our members and the general public Allowing railroads, by virtue of their own in-house metrics, data, and reporting to determine if they have accomplished safety outcomes will not inspire innovation--it will instead bring unacceptable and unchallengeable risks to rail workers and the general public. We acknowledge that there are specific applications of performance-based rulemaking regimes that work well in differing agency and industry structures, but mandates requiring performance-based regulations are wrong for the FRA. Performance based regulation only works when the results achieved reflect mandated outcomes--this will not be the case in this industry. And when they do not, it will be our members who suffer. Finally, regardless of the content of a regulation, or how compliance is accomplished, it is essential that the Department of Transportation has the resources to address both ongoing compliance with existing regulation and the need to promulgate and enforce new regulations. This is particularly salient as these efforts relate to the deployment of new transportation technologies as they impact our members, the American worker broadly, and the public. The International Brotherhood of Teamsters thanks the Subcommittee for the opportunity to testify today. We look forward to continuing to work together on a bipartisan basis including during the upcoming surface transportation reauthorization. Senator Young. Thank you, Mr. Scandaglia. Before we dive into member questions, I'd like to recognize the Ranking Member of this committee, my colleague, Senator Cantwell. Senator Cantwell. STATEMENT OF HON. MARIA CANTWELL, U.S. SENATOR FROM WASHINGTON Senator Cantwell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will be brief. I look forward to the questions that our colleagues are asking, and I'm going to submit a statement for the record, but I was just visited by the City of Bellevue, and they had some very interesting technology success using AI related to responding to emergencies and law enforcement. And so we'll share that with the Committee. And I do think it is something, if we can improve on our transportation infrastructure in that way, it's something to consider. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [The prepared statement of Senator Cantwell follows:] Prepared Statement of Hon. Maria Cantwell, U.S. Senator from Washington Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for holding this hearing, and thank you to our witnesses for your testimony today. Safety technology has the potential to help solve the most pressing issues across our transportation system--saving lives, time and money. Each year, nearly 40,000 people die on our roads. New innovations in vehicle technology can enhance driver safety and significantly reduce accidents. Just one example--automatic emergency braking in heavy-duty trucks could prevent over 19,000 crashes and save more than 155 lives every year. American families lose 63 hours and $269 billion dollars sitting in traffic each year. Smart trip-planning technology that integrates GPS, weather conditions, and traffic data can help drivers avoid traffic jams and spend less time and money on the road. And with hundreds of train accidents caused by mechanical failures each year, defect detectors are helping alert railroads to issues before they become catastrophic, like the Norfolk Southern derailment in East Palestine, Ohio. In my home state of Washington, communities are piloting smart solutions to transportation challenges. The City of Bellevue uses smart technology at intersections to give first responders priority in real time--ensuring that help reaches those in need as fast as possible. In Yakima, along one of Washington's deadliest highways, the State deployed smart traffic monitoring devices that collect data on the conditions that lead to crashes so that engineers can determine the most effective safety solutions. And at our Canadian border crossing, Washington is using smart technology to send real-time updates to travelers on wait times. Successful deployment of these kinds of technologies also requires protecting the safety, privacy, and confidence of the traveling public. Rushed deployment risks undermining public trust in ways that could set innovation back rather than move us forward. I raised these concerns with the Federal Railroad Administration in response to proposals to reduce human track inspections and rely on automated inspections. And I also raised these concerns earlier this year when this committee held a hearing on autonomous vehicle deployment. As we work on the next Surface Transportation bill, we must prioritize policies that drive the safe deployment of these kinds of innovative solutions. And if we want to scale these innovations and compete globally, we need to invest in innovation projects across the United States. That's why I am concerned that this Administration is gutting Federal investments that make safety innovations possible in the first place. President Trump's budget request for Fiscal Year 2027 cuts funding for the Department of Transportation by $33.8 billion. It eliminates funding for the SMART grant program, cuts freight funding by 36 percent, and rail funding by 85 percent. And it's not just new budget requests. In fact, significant cuts have already taken place, including at the agencies charged with keeping us safe when we travel. Driven by DOGE, the Department of Transportation's Highway Safety Office lost 25 percent of its employees. At one point last year, the Office of Automation, which is responsible for coordinating the Federal government's work on automated vehicles and technologies, had just four people. A robust Federal effort to modernize our transportation system requires a strong Federal workforce. It also requires consistent, predictable funding and clear standards to ensure safety and transparency in the deployment of these technologies. Mr. Chairman, I look forward to working with you and with Ranking Member Peters to ensure we don't let innovation get left behind as this committee considers the next infrastructure law. Thank you. Senator Young. Thank you. I'll begin with Ms. Chace. Thank you for your testimony, Ms. Chace. I appreciate you discussing how our transportation system has evolved over time and that we should be treating technology as core transportation infrastructure in the United States. It's not just the conventional stuff. It's data and all the rest of it. You mentioned in your written testimony, and I think you just alluded to it, that we have a need for Federal leadership to scale these technologies, technologies that will reduce travel times, lower crash rates, improve asset management on our infrastructure projects. What happens if the Federal Government doesn't develop national leadership? What signal might it send to the private sector? And what happens to our globally competitive position, especially as China looks to surge ahead in the deployment of some of these critical technologies? Ms. Chace. Thank you, Senator Young, for the question. It's a very important question at this moment in time. So what would happen if we don't have Federal leadership is we will continue to see fragmented, uneven deployments across the country that really struggle to deliver the systemwide benefits that we know they can to the American public. On the private sector side, right now you have a situation where the private sector is actually asking for that unified national marketplace. And if we don't create that Federal leadership and don't create that national approach, the private sector is not going to invest their significant capital into our own transportation system. If you think about it from a private sector company, it's a rational decision to go to a market where you have a unified approach and a larger market share. And so the exact outcome that we do not want to see happen is, is for our companies that are developing technologies right here in America to then go deploy those technologies overseas at our global competitors because they have a larger marketplace that can be addressed there. So it's really critical that we ensure that we have Federal leadership from Congress and from U.S. DOT that can create, as I call it, national approaches to national challenges and show those Federal frameworks and approaches and strategies so that the private sector sees it's worth it to invest here and that there is a long-term ROI and then the public sector similarly can have confidence in deploying those technologies. Senator Young. Well, thank you. You know, and my reference to say China is not just, you know--I'm not trying to get people excited, I'm not trying to provoke them, I'm not trying to leverage a geopolitical competition into this narrow subset of policy. This could impact our rate over time of growth, which in turn allows us to fund our way of life, including our military. So that is--that's the long game. We need to be using this moment in American history to optimize our system at every level, including ensuring that our laws and rules allow for the integration of the best in class technology so that we can outcompete anyone. And that is what I was alluding to. Ms. Chace, when we discuss the integration and adoption of these technologies, it is important that we contemplate ways to secure this infrastructure as well from all kinds of threats. And your testimony discusses the tangential benefits of Federal leadership in unlocking a scalable marketplace for advanced tech in transportation infrastructure sectors. But one of these benefits is increased cybersecurity. Can you elaborate a bit on how this leadership can build stronger cyber safeguards and separately how we can ensure our cybersecurity technologies like firewalls or IoT modules in the underlying connectivity that powers cloud software tools are actually met? In 10 words or less. [Laughter.] Ms. Chace. Few more than 10. So, Senator, if we're establishing leadership right here at home in these technologies, then we're actually also developing the most innovative cyber tools and security methods right here at home. So that Federal leadership is incredibly important in ensuring that we secure these technologies, which absolutely, it's a priority for our members as well. And very quickly right now, what agencies and companies are doing to do that and secure these technologies is following the existing NIST guidelines, CISA protocols, zero trust architecture, secure by design principles, and following all of those best in class practices when it comes to cybersecurity. But we agree with you, it is incredibly important that we create the marketplace for those cyber tools to also be developed right here at America. Senator Young. Well, by way of follow up after this hearing, if you don't have an opportunity to unpack the cybersecurity best practices that you just alluded to, and if you see a role for Congress in ensuring that we're doing what we need to do, please, after this hearing, let me know, let my staff know and we'll get to work on it. Mr. Peters. Senator Peters. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Spear, I know many of us share a commitment to moving the ball forward on a framework for autonomous vehicles, including autonomous commercial vehicles. So my question for you is, do you believe that a legislative AV framework should include commercial vehicles? And if so, could you expand on why this is important for your members and how the trucking industry would certainly benefit from guidance from Congress? Mr. Spear. Well, quickly, absolutely. We would welcome that. I think inclusion with passenger vehicles is essential, but I'd go so far--I'm not competitive, but I would go so far to say trucks are business to business, whereas cars are business to consumer. If you're buying a car, you're going to pick the things that you want on that car. If you don't want things that drive technology, you know you're going to come up short on that. Businesses to businesses will design systems around moving freight more efficiently, more safely, more environmentally friendly. These are all things that can be developed faster through our OEMs, which we only have a half dozen compared to a couple dozen auto manufacturers. So, you know, we have a lot more ability to put technology platforms in place, move freight more efficiently, more safely, move more environmentally friendly. So yes, I think having trucks equal with passenger vehicles, if not leading this platform, would be more appropriate, in my opinion. Senator Peters. Very good. Mr. Scandaglia, you represent a lot of truck drivers, and as you heard in my opening comments, the views of the men and women who are employed in these industries are incredibly important to get their viewpoint. So I'd like to get your perspective from your members. You mentioned in your opening testimony some ideas related to what you'd like to see. But for the Committee, I would love to have you expand on what you think needs to be done in a national AV framework that addresses the concerns that we have of the men and women who work in these industries? Mr. Scandaglia. Absolutely, appreciate the question. I think we're thinking about this in three planks. One is robust premarket standards at NHTSA figuring out what has to be on the vehicle to make it safe before it hits the road. The second piece is substantial oversight tools at Federal Motor Carrier Administration to make sure that once there are deployments of these vehicles in a meaningful sense, that Federal motor carrier has an idea of how they're functioning and how they're operating and also has the ability to severably take action and enforcement on unsafe autonomous vehicle deployments. And then in as much as we do see displacement of workers, that we develop an approach to address workforce concerns that may present themselves down the road, both as that relates to workers whose jobs may change. For example, a mechanic who works on diesel engine is not going to be prepared to work inherently on an autonomous vehicle, at least out of the gate. And similarly, if there are to be displacements of drivers, what does the future look like for them? I think it's important that Congress gets in front of this now and instead of waiting until it's too late. Senator Peters. Very good. Ms. Chace, I believe there are many vehicle technologies in addition to autonomous vehicles that certainly have the ability to save lives and as regulators, we must do what we can to harness that potential. That's why I introduced the Vehicle Safety Research Act with Chair Young to codify NHTSA's parts program to accelerate advanced driver assistance systems, their research and their development. It's also why last week I introduced the Vehicle Safety Equipment Testing Act with Senator Fischer to speed the testing of vehicle safety technology so that they can be perfected and deployed quickly. The sooner they're deployed, the more lives that are saved. And that's why I also fought to protect auto safety spectrum from the deployment of connected vehicle technology. And why I and Chair Young have pushed together the Department of Transportation to lead the way on the deployment of CV2X. So if you could give this committee some examples of current CV2X deployments and tell the Committee why you believe the--what are the biggest barriers to broader deployment of these technologies? Ms. Chace. Thank you Senator, for the question and for your ongoing support. So there are several CVX deployments in the country right now that are growing. Atlanta, Georgia has actually the largest current deployment in the country, all throughout the metro area and extending now to the port of Savannah and actually giving freight signal priority, which has been very successful. Maricopa County, Arizona has a large deployment. Salt Lake City in Utah is coordinating with Colorado and Wyoming and Houston, Texas. Those last three are all funded by U.S.DOT grants and there are several in your home state of Michigan, Ann Arbor and Detroit. I'm actually going to be seeing the Detroit deployment this week. So some of the examples of what this is providing are: transit signal priority, emergency vehicle preemption, freight priority and support, pedestrian and cyclist detection and alerting for safety, work zone alerting, weather warnings, and newer is V2X tolling. And so there's actually a huge range of applications that are being leveraged as a part of these deployments. We're also seeing some network-based solutions being included now in these deployments. The biggest barrier I would say is actually consistent across all technology areas and is consistent with sort of my core message in this testimony, which is that we need to start treating technology as a core element of our transportation system and infrastructure because that directly ties into making sure that Federal transportation funding levels remain stable. And that is clearly prioritized, that these technologies should be deployed and scaled throughout the system. So ensuring that we have consistent, dedicated funding for these projects, ensuring that we are incorporating technology and integrating it into the full lifecycle of projects, those are some of the key barriers to both CV2X deployments, but also broader technology deployments across the country. Senator Peters. Thank you for the answer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Young. Senator Moreno, you're now recognized. STATEMENT OF HON. BERNIE MORENO, U.S. SENATOR FROM OHIO Senator Moreno. Mr. Spear, let's dig into a little bit of what you talked about in your opening statement. How much exactly of the things that American consumers buy do they get through trucks? Mr. Spear. Just over 80 percent of the communities in the United States depend on trucks for their day to day needs. So, you know, food to fuel, you name it. Senator Moreno. So groceries, basic essentials, construction goods, you name it, right? It's the entire economy. Mr. Spear. It's a grocery store shelf issue. Senator Moreno. Exactly. And if costs for transportation companies rise dramatically, what is the impact on household goods? Mr. Spear. Well, it definitely translates down no different than theft. You know, the price of fuel, inflation, all those things get transformed in the prices we pay. And we're the link between that from the goods to the fact when they're delivered and bought, what you pay is reflected and all those factors. So yes, prices definitely go up. We see that. We pass on some of those costs, but not all of them and---- Senator Moreno. But our goal should be to try to make it less expensive for transportation to exist in America. Would you agree? Mr. Spear. Always. Senator Moreno. All right. So are you familiar with the advanced truck rule that we got rid of last year? Mr. Spear. Mm-hmm. Senator Moreno. So that would have mandated--on electric semis, how many electric semis were sold this year out of the total? I will give you the answer. It's 0.2 percent. Mr. Spear. Yes. Very small. Senator Moreno. But just so that we're clear, because its numbers can be confusing, not 2 percent, 0.2 percent. So of all the semis sold in the United States this year, 0.2 percent were electric. What would the advanced car truck rule have required us to have been selling in America had it not been repealed? Mr. Spear. Well, it would have transformed us come 2030, 10 percent a year. Senator Moreno. What would be the number? Like, so we were 0.2 percent. We got rid of the rule. What would the percentage required by law have been to have been sold as in terms of electric semis? Mr. Spear. Well, starting in 2030, 10 percent. It would have been about three and a half million trucks. Senator Moreno. So a 5,000 percent increase in electric vehicles. Mr. Spear. Right. Senator Moreno. Would that have cost consumers money? Mr. Spear. It was three and a half times more than a brand new diesel, which by the way, emits, you know, the same amount of emissions that, you know, 60 trucks in 1988 emitted. So we've come that far. So to push us toward an electric platform with infrastructure that doesn't exist would have been horrendous in terms of cost and capability. Senator Moreno. Is it hyperbolic to say it would have been catastrophic for our economy? Mr. Spear. It would have imploded our economy. Senator Moreno. It would have imploded our economy. There wasn't a single solitary Democrat that voted to get rid of that rule. I just want to point that out. It's extremely important that we remember where we've been so we know where we're going. I want to absolutely give props to our Chairman for the bill that he has to get rid of the Federal excise tax. Can you talk about again a little bit more detail what that means? What's the average age of the semi on the road today? Mr. Spear. About 2010. Senator Moreno. 2010. So 15, 16 year old truck is the average. Average. Mr. Spear. That's correct. Senator Moreno. Not the oldest one, the average. Mr. Spear. In California as well. Senator Moreno. Right. So if you really want to improve fuel economy and safety, you want people driving a newer fleet. Is that accurate? Mr. Spear. Absolutely. You want to incentivize the procurement of brand new equipment. This would do it. This is $24,000 per tractor, $6,400 per trailer. This is money that should go in the hands of drivers that are operating their own equipment to fleets that are replacing their equipment. Senator Moreno. But just beyond that it incentivizes people to buy newer semis. So if the average age went from 2010 to 2013 or 2014, you're talking about dramatically better fuel economy, dramatically better safety. And this law was one that was passed a few years ago. FET was it passed a few years ago? It was past 120 years ago? Mr. Spear. At the time of the Titanic sinking to fund French warfare. [Laughter.] Mr. Spear. And by the way---- Senator Moreno. It was temporary, right? Mr. Spear.--it's the highest Federal excise tax that we have in the government and it's the only one of that grouping that funded French warfare that still exists today. Senator Moreno. But it was supposed to be a temporary tax. Mr. Spear. It's not. Senator Moreno. Here we are 120 years later. Mr. Spear. It's incentive. Senator Moreno. So obviously we need to get Senator Young's bill across the finish line and get that done. I think again it goes back to the connected--the advanced truck rule. We need to lower the cost to transportation companies. Mr. Spear. Senator, I point out too beyond safety and environmental gains, this is a jobs gain. Those six manufacturers that we have far less than the autos or here in the United States a little bit in Mexico. This is a union job issue right here. This is going to help union jobs. Senator Moreno. You must be referring to the fantastic factory in Chillicothe, Ohio---- Mr. Spear. Absolutely. Senator Moreno.--brand new Kenworth. So the other one is, Ms. Chace, I don't want you to be ignored, Connected Vehicle Security Act. It's a bill that Senator Slotkin and I put together. I applaud the Ranking Member, Senator Peters who has been after this topic for a long time of making certain that we don't allow Chinese vehicles into this market. Talk about, from your perspective, what could go wrong by having a company that's a Chinese defense contractor, BYD, allowed to sell cars in the United States that transmit high definition photos, videos, and location data back to the Communist party? Ms. Chace. Thank you, Senator Moreno for the question. We fully agree with your concern and your approach to ensuring that Chinese connected vehicles do not come into America. We were heavily involved--actually ITS America was heavily involved in the Department of Commerce BIS ruling and in understanding that we are all aligned in the need for secure supply chains also protecting the privacy of Americans and ensuring that we have the domestic and allied supply chains to do so. I think the risk it goes to data privacy and national security. And so we have to make sure that we're protecting American consumers data, that we're protecting all of our National security assets, and that we are ensuring that it's American made technology that is in these vehicles that are driving on American roadways. Thank you. Senator Young. Thank you, Mr. Moreno, and thanks for your help on the Federal excise tax repeal. We're going to get that done. Thank you, Mr. Spear. Mr. Kim, you're now recognized. STATEMENT OF HON. ANDY KIM, U.S. SENATOR FROM NEW JERSEY Senator Kim. Thank you, Chairman. Mr. Jeffries, I wanted to start with you. I just want to make sure I kind of level set here on the numbers I'm seeing in terms of just annual concerns that we have about 1,000 to 1,200 derailments, 1,600 train accidents annually, about 900 to 1,000 fatalities. Does that kind of mesh with your understanding on the safety concerns? Mr. Jeffries. So when you talk about specific derailments, I think there are--I can't give you the exact numbers. I think it was in the mid-900s, 2 years ago. And about 70 percent of those occur within yards. So think about, you know, a wheel coming off the line. About 20 percent of those occur out on the main line, otherwise known kind of the interstate railroad. When you think about 1,000 deaths on the railroad, approximately 95 percent of those are due to two issues. One is trespassers and the other is grade crossing collisions. And that's why we work so hard to ensure our employees stay safe. And we're proud of the fact that 2025 was the lowest employee injury rate in the industry's 199 year history. Senator Kim. And I'm glad to see that progress as well. Mr. Jeffries. Absolutely. Senator Kim. I think we can all agree though, we have more work to be done. Mr. Jeffries. Of course, always. Until we're at zero. Senator Kim. And as you talked about automated track inspection, ATI, I think all of us in this room embrace technology, want to make sure that we're using everything to be able to push on it. I guess I want to get a sense from you, just as we're thinking and making decisions here, what are some of the limitations of this type of technology in terms of what it's not able to identify? Things that we would want to make sure we're using other tools, including human inspections. Mr. Jeffries. Of course. So let's think about the regulation that's on the books right now. It requires a periodic naked eye inspections of individuals walking on the tracks. After years of pilot and waiver programs by several individual railroads who deployed autonomous track inspection in lieu of certain manual inspections. So right now I think the manual inspections require twice a week the tracks be walked. The pilot programs that were in place over several years reduced that to once every two weeks because ATI can identify up to 200 percent higher defects than the naked eye. And during those pilot programs, the safety outcomes were dramatic, a significantly higher safety result that occurred. And so when you look at what the regulation that's being contemplated right now is, reducing visual inspections to once per week and letting ATI continuously inspect that track with a performance standard that must be met, that is significantly more rigorous than what's on the regulations in the book. So you're guaranteeing a higher safety outcome. If you don't hit that, you have to go back to the old ways of doing things. To your point about what---- Senator Kim. Sorry, I just want to pause you on that one because I wanted to get another perspective. Mr. Scandaglia, I wanted to turn to you because in your statement here, you're saying that some of these systems are only capable identifying some, but not all of the types of regulatory defects that we can get and pick up through visual inspection. Can you go into a little bit more just like what would be missing from just doing the tech only or just mostly relying on the tech? Mr. Scandaglia. Yes. Current regulations require inspections to look at 23 total defect categories. ATI is primarily looking at track geometry issues, which encompasses about six of those categories. I mean, to Mr. Jeffries' point, we're not surprised that ATI used well will increase safety again. As I said in my opening statement, we've called for it to be mandatory. We think it's a really good tool. With that said, given the state of its capabilities at this hour, what it can and cannot do, we still believe strongly that the best way to deploy this technology is in keeping with the currently mandated visual inspection standards. Senator Kim. Mr. Jeffries, I mean, what Mr. Scandaglia put into his testimony here, that this technology is incapable of identifying issues with ballasts, rail wear, rail joint gaps, tie plate conditions, switch components, vegetation obstructions in the right of way. Is that correct? Mr. Jeffries. So one track geometry is an indicator of overall track health. And I don't disagree that there are things that ATI doesn't detect and that's--you know, for example, vegetation growth, et cetera--and that's why we think the balance is right to still have once a week individuals walking the track looking for those very things. And I think we should focus on the outcome: 2025 with the lowest number of track related incidents in the industry's history. And that's largely due to a broader deployment of new technologies that can identify more defects before they become problems. Senator Kim. I don't disagree that progress is being made. But again, like I think all of us here, we want to make sure we can look our constituency in the eye and guarantee that safety that is there. We're not there yet with what we have, we're not there yet with the accommodation of visual inspection as well as the technology. And I'll be honest with you, I'm uncomfortable with the idea that without achieving what we actually want to get to, that we would be potentially taking tools off the table at this important way. I agree with you, let's let the data decide and guide our decisions. I just don't see that data right now just yet. And with that, I'll yield back. Senator Young. Ms. Lummis, you're now recognized. STATEMENT OF HON. CYNTHIA LUMMIS, U.S. SENATOR FROM WYOMING Senator Lummis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and welcome panel. I want to start with Chris Spear. Welcome, Chris. As you know, I'm a strong advocate for autonomous vehicles, including the Autonomous Vehicle Acceleration Act, because I think it's a tool that can help evolve the industry. And I look at it as a person who has had--I live in a state where an ambulance driver was killed by an illegal trucker who could not read signs. We had another incident, multiple casualties, multiple deaths in the I-80 tunnel by green River, Wyoming, again caused by an illegal who is driving an 18 wheeler. And that was an absolutely horrific, deadly fire in a tunnel that killed multiple people. So what outdated requirements are holding back safe autonomous trucking deployment? And what standards should Congress consider to ensure those deployments improve safety, strengthen supply chain efficiency, and benefit the trucking work force? Mr. Spear. I see two things in this. For autonomous vehicles, you currently have 26 states that have permissive environments for this type of technology. We don't stop at State lines. We go from Green river right into Salt Lake. We're doing multiple states, every truck, every day. So we need a national framework. If you're going to invest in this technology, grow it nationally, not by State, or we're conceding this to China, they will take this technology, they will run with it, and then we will be reacting to that platform. It's that simple. That's a performance-based approach. It's about innovation. It's about technology solving solutions. You want a prescriptive environment, you know, compared to phones. If we had that in place right now, we'd still be working on blackberries. OK? Everybody else around the world would have an iPhone or a Droid. So you've got to have a performance based metric, not a prescriptive. And that's going to allow the agencies to work with tech solutions that are going to constantly evolve year over year and make certain that this platform is sound. The second piece of it that you mention on the illegal driver, look at the SAFER Act that Chairman Young has. It is enabling the FMCSA at DOT to do the right things in going after these criminals who shouldn't be on the road in the first place. A lot of these companies are chameleon carriers. They're bad actors. They get busted, they drop off the registry and they reregister in another name. So they replaced this last month with a system called Motus. Motus has taken a little time to get up and running, but when it does, it is going to rid a lot of the bad actors that we're seeing. English language proficiency, testing. These are done in all states to have a baseline standard in every state to make sure that when you get a CDL, you have met the minimum, minimum criteria, which should be several weeks of training, not two days over the Internet. So I applaud what they're doing. I want to see it made permanent. So I love the bill that you have. I think that'll solve that problem in kind. Senator Lummis. Well, thank you for that, Mr. Young. And Ms. Chace, I want to ask you some questions about digital twins and permitting reform. It looks like digital twins already exist, am I correct? Ms. Chace. Yes. Senator Lummis. So what is preventing the broader adoption across Federal infrastructure reviews and permitting processes? And what should Congress do to ensure agencies are able to review digital twins to deliver projects faster, cheaper? Ms. Chace. Thank you, Senator, for the question. So you're really referencing this generational shift from paper plans and paper--the use of 2D plans to 3D digital twins and digital documents. So Congress could do a couple of things in this instance. Congress should encourage the use of digital technologies to support project delivery. This can be through explicit eligibility criteria on grants or formula funding programs through guidance from USDOT. The ADCMS grant program is a great initiative in this area that has really incentivized digital delivery. And to your point, we should encourage recipients of DOT funds to utilize digital platforms when carrying out environmental reviews. In other words, we have to be able to submit those review documents digitally and for the agencies to accept them digitally. Ultimately, what we would believe Congress can do is consistent with my testimony in a whole, which is treating technology as a core element of transportation across all of the various life cycles of technology: project delivery, construction, operations, maintenance, is critical to ensuring that we actually aid this digital transformation in a comprehensive way. Senator Lummis. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, permission to ask one more. Senator Young. Please proceed. Senator Lummis. Thank you. Mr. Jeffries, can you explain how mandates like the two-man crew requirement or more strict high hazard train definitions could affect the movement of, say, Wyoming coal or other American energy products by rail? Mr. Jeffries. Sure. So I think it leads to a bigger question about locking in current operating requirements without any evidence to prove that those requirements result in a higher safety outcome. Because that's what we should be focused on, safety outcomes, period. And when you lock in current ways of doing things or you add new requirements that cannot be justified, the result is you undermine the ability for the network to remain fluid, you reduce service, you increase congestion, all without a positive safety outcome. And so if we can't draw a direct line to a positive safety outcome, we shouldn't be doing things. And I think that's why so many different groups outside of railroads, such as the coal industry, such as the Ag industry, have expressed serious concerns about some of these proposals. Senator Lummis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Young. Well, thank you, Senator Lummis. Mr. Lujan, you're now recognized. STATEMENT OF HON. BEN RAY LUJAN, U.S. SENATOR FROM NEW MEXICO Senator Lujan. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Jeffries, would you find it acceptable if 10,000 lives were lost per year in America on trains with train crashes? Mr. Jeffries. Absolutely not. Senator Lujan. Mr. Spear? Mr. Spear. Absolutely not. Senator Lujan. Ms. Chace? Ms. Chace. No, Senator. Senator Lujan. Mr. Scandaglia? Mr. Scandaglia. No, Senator. Senator Lujan. Mr. Jeffries, would you find it acceptable if 10,000 lives were lost in America on airline crashes a year? Mr. Jeffries. Absolutely not. Senator Lujan. Mr. Spear? Mr. Spear. Definitely not. Senator Lujan. Ms. Chace? Ms. Chace. No. Senator Lujan. Mr. Scandaglia? Mr. Scandaglia. We would not. Senator Lujan. Mr. Jeffries, do you find it acceptable that in America we lose 10,000 lives a year with car crashes based on DWI? Mr. Jeffries. Absolutely not. Senator Lujan. Mr. Spear? Mr. Spear. No. Senator Lujan. Ms. Chace? Ms. Chace. No. Senator Lujan. Mr. Scandaglia? Mr. Scandaglia. No. Senator Lujan. Look, I know NHTSA's not here today. Department of Transportation is not here today. We're here to talk about technology and vehicles. You all support technological advances in modes of transportation. Mr. Jeffries? Mr. Jeffries. Yes, indeed. Senator Lujan. Mr. Spear? Mr. Spear. Absolutely. Senator Lujan. Ms. Chace. Ms. Chace. Yes, I do. Senator Lujan. Mr. Scandaglia? Mr. Scandaglia. Yes. Senator Lujan. One of my colleagues was just talking about autonomous vehicles. That takes technology. There are investments, there are companies that hold patents, there are tier one suppliers in the automotive space that hold patents in this area. The market's working because there are signals to the market to say make investments in this space. Now, I also agree with one of my colleagues who's here today, when there's sunk in costs and there's still technology out there that's not doing a damn thing. And there's one technology, when it comes to preventing drunk driving car crashes, that's gotten appropriations from Congress, has gotten millions and millions of dollars from the auto industry, and they're still operating out a little garage somewhere in Virginia, if I'm not mistaken. And they've not come up with a solution. Now, all my colleagues don't agree with me when I say we should stop drunk driving deaths and impart impaired crashes in America. We have autonomous vehicles. There are self-driving taxis. Now, there are all kinds of incredible tools that are out there. And these--I've been in cars that do this. In Europe, there are cars being sold to those consumers that already say, hey, if there are some impaired problems on here, we're going to warn you, we're going to slow you down. If you have a heart attack, you have a stroke, we're not going to let you kill someone else. You know, every one of us has a phone in our pockets, or most of us do, that also has GPS in it and whatnot. Tells you which way you're going, which way you shouldn't go. When I'm on my mountain bike, my phone tells me if I start going down a wrong trail that I shouldn't be going down. I don't understand why this is so hard for vehicles. My colleagues know in the early 1990s, I was hit head on by a drunk driver less than half a mile from my house and I walked away from the damn thing. Not all my constituents can say that. I've been to a lot of funerals and I think other colleagues have been as well. It might make things a little more expensive to purchase a vehicle, but what happens if there's technology in a car that saves your kid, saves your mom or dad, saves your brother or sister? We can do that in America today. And look, I get this hearing there's no one here on the panel with cars and car safety or from NHTSA or from the Department of Transportation. We've had witness after witness from the Department of Transportation, from NHTSA here saying, no, we're going to do something, we're going to do something. They just issued a report that said, oh, the technology is not ready. If there were 10,000 Americans dying on an airplane every year, you bet your life that they would come up with technology to save them. If it was happening on trains, you know, that they would move mountains to save lives. But if you or I get killed on a paved road because we're driving a car, I guess we really don't matter. And I'm just beside myself that one of my colleagues out of Texas in the House of Representatives just passed an amendment that said his constituents, he really doesn't give a shit about them if they get killed because someone's been drinking or they're impaired on the damn roads in Texas. Well, in New Mexico, we care about people and I certainly hope that we can find a way to get this done. If my colleagues have one objection or another, let's talk about it. This isn't about privacy, you know, a bunch of folks out there saying they're going to steal privacy from you. Well, what about the autonomous cars? What about the airplanes? What about the rails? That's not what this is about. Let's find a way in America where we can drive innovation and save people's lives. I don't know why this is so hard. I'm beside myself this morning as we come together and I just recently read that report. Democrat, Republican, no matter, man. My libertarian friends, to all the smart staff that are in this room, let's find a way to do something, man. Let's save some people. I worked on this with Rick Scott. Rick's not a liberal. You know, there's a way to work together, y'all. Let's find a way to do that so that if someone gets behind a wheel that shouldn't be, that there's a way to keep them alive for their loved ones and anyone that they might meet on the drive to wherever they're headed. And I certainly hope we can do that, Mr. Chairman. I'm open to ideas. I want to thank the Mothers Against Drunk Driving who have led this effort across America and every survivor of a drunk crash and an impaired crash that has been willing to come and lend their voices. Mrs. Dole as well, I want to thank her for the work that she's been doing with MADD and everyone else. So I hope to God that we can find a way past differences and whoever the next administration is, because this one's not going to do it. The Biden administration didn't get it across the finish line. Whoever the next administration is, let's find a way to bring everyone together and save more people lives. I appreciate the time today, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Senator Young. Thank you, Mr. Lujan. Mr. Spear, thank you for your words throughout this hearing in support of and for your collaboration on the repeal of the Federal excise tax by legislation, the Modern Clean and Safe Trucks Act. I think this legislation is notable in this hearing because the subtitle of this hearing is ``How Technological Advances are Driving Transportation Innovation.'' I'd like you to unpack for those who are watching this hearing, how passing this legislation could actually better incentivize investments in the most technologically advanced vehicles? Mr. Spear. I think the FET repeal is a no brainer. Fact is it's going to put the newest, latest, greatest technology on the roads. It's going to replace those 2010s that Senator Moreno talked about. And you know, the California rules that were going to electrify us if they just focused on getting the 2010 or older trucks off the roads in California, they would have exponentially reduced emissions. They could have done that right now without turning on electricity, which they don't have, and turning our industry into an electric freight mover. So this was something that we pointed out year over year. The FET repeal is good for safety, it's good for environments, good for union jobs. There's something in this for everybody. Candidly, I think putting money in our industry's pockets, $24,000 per truck, $6,400 per trailer. That's money that can be invested in other things. Driver pay, training. But beyond that, putting that newer equipment out there is good for everybody. Senator Young. For innovation, right? The newest equipment. Mr. Spear. 100 percent. Senator Young. Right. The newest equipment with the latest safety upgrades, with the latest performance upgrades, efficiency tools, on and on. So thank you for your help on that. I'm going to turn to Mr. Jeffries. Mr. Jeffries, you alluded earlier to challenges with deployment of latest technologies in the rail sector. How should performance-based regulations look across a multitude of different technologies? Mr. Jeffries. Well, thank you for the question. So, you know, I think all of this talk of innovation and automation is fantastic. Autonomous trucks, autonomous cars, we operate on a regulatory structure that was developed in the early 1970s and very prescriptive, very manual based. And like every other industry out there, we have advanced dramatically when it comes to technological deployment, innovative new tools, et cetera, that have excellent advanced safety outcomes, service outcomes, efficiency outcomes. And other agencies in the DOT have embraced performance- based regulations, whether it's FAA, whether it's FHWA, whether it's FTA. The FRA for some reason has not, you know, really come around to that concept. And when we're talking about automation, when we're talking about autonomous trucks, when we're reading articles about driverless trucks delivering Dr. Pepper and Pepsi to stores in Texas today and operating out on the interstates, which by the way, I do not begrudge at all. I think it's fantastic. I just think we should be operating on a mode neutral tech policy that drives outcomes versus inputs. So tell me where you want us to be. Tell me the outcome we need to achieve and let us find the best path there. Senator Young. Can I stop you there? Mr. Jeffries. Yes. Senator Young. I think all of our witnesses were listening to your last statement. Let's focus on outcomes, not on process. Mr. Spear, do you agree---- Mr. Spear. Absolutely. Senator Young.--with that approach? Mr. Spear. You need a performance-based system. This is a technology hearing. Senator Young. Yes. Mr. Spear. Let's breed it, let's let it unbridle and not prescribe everything. Senator Young. Ms. Chace, do you agree with that approach? Ms. Chace. Absolutely agree. Senator Young. OK. Mr. Scandaglia, do you agree with that approach? Mr. Scandaglia. Not inherently, no. Senator Young. And why is that? Mr. Scandaglia. When we're talking about performance-based standards, part of the consideration of that conversation is will the method of compliance result in the outcome that we have prescribed. And frankly, if you speak to our members who do you---- Senator Young. But if you judge based on outcomes, especially over time, wouldn't that address that concern? You might have some high profile and politically resonant, I would add, examples of suboptimal outcomes along the way, even those involving safety. But over time, if you're improving more lives, if you're saving more lives, isn't that how you would measure success of a regime or not? Is that utilitarian sort of approach not one that we should be adopting? Mr. Scandaglia. I think if we're talking broadly in the concept of saving lives, I think that's obviously something we all support. But when we're starting to talk more specifically about the outcome of a specific regulation, we talked about automated track inspection. Part of our concern inherently here too is when we move--if we move entirely to a performance based system, we're also then relying on the information and data that is provided by the regulated entity. And to speak candidly, my members don't trust it. Senator Young. Give me an example, a bad information that the regulated entity is operating under. Because I thought this is how we have to judge under the current regime regardless, in the absence of outcome-based performance measurement. Mr. Scandaglia. The concern is not--the concern actually is not specific to either performance based or existing regimes. I think when we are looking at the way that industry has provided data to regulators and the characterizations that can be made as the result of that data, frequently that does not align with our members experience on the job. I would offer to any member of this committee, if you would like to go out and meet, say the railroaders that I represent-- -- Senator Young. Yes. Mr. Scandaglia.--if ask them about do they agree that we are in an era of unprecedented safety, they will tell you no to the man or woman. And I make that offer to any Senator who'd like to do that, I would invite them to do so. Senator Young. I think that's data too. That should be-- that should of course be part of what we are balancing and perhaps we capture that data. But in the end then it becomes a debate over what outcomes you're looking at. If your sole outcome is your membership, which you know, our perspectives are shaped by where we sit, so maybe yours is. But I think societally most Americans would say we should look at a broader array of data rather than just member feedback. Mr. Scandaglia. I don't think we would disagree there either. Senator Young. Right, OK. Thank you for indulging me, everyone on that. Senator Cruz is recognized for questions. STATEMENT OF HON. TED CRUZ, U.S. SENATOR FROM TEXAS Senator Cruz. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for holding this hearing. Mr. Spear, let's start with you. Mr. Spear, you said that the integration of AV trucks will mean, ``an evolution, not an elimination of the job.'' I suspect that many people will find that statement surprising or even contradictory since they assume that an AV truck wouldn't have a driver sitting in it. Mr. Spear, can you please explain what you mean when you say AV trucks will bring an evolution, not an elimination of the trucker? Mr. Spear. Well, I don't think it's a generality. We look at things from a number of perspectives. First and foremost, from an economic viewpoint, we're moving 11.4 billion tons a year. That's 73 percent of everything that's moved in freight is moved by truck. So everything you drink, I drink, eat, wear, came off a truck. Mom, dad, husband, wife, they made that happen. Over the next 10 years, just to keep pace with current economic growth in this country, we've got to move another 2.7 billion tons of freight. I need more drivers, I need more trucks, and I need innovation. I need all of it. And running autonomous vehicles, levels 1 through 4, which still require a driver, make drivers smarter, make technicians smarter, they're all going to benefit from this. You'll probably see some Level 5, from Texas to Southern California. It may not be ready for prime time yet, but in addition to more drivers, more technicians, more inspectors, dispatchers, trainers, we're going to hire more people with this technology just to keep pace with current economic growth. So I look at this as a win-win all across the board. Senator Cruz. Mr. Scandaglia, what do the Teamsters think about AV trucks? Mr. Scandaglia. [Off mic.] Senator Cruz. It is. Mr. Scandaglia. I would like to kind of jump off where Mr. Spear left off, which is, I don't think we disagree with the notion that we are not going to see an influx of driverless trucks in every fleet across America tomorrow. We're not going to see hundreds of thousands of people lose their job next week. I think anyone who has been rational about that can agree. Where I think we disagree somewhat is if this technology does hit the prime time, whatever point that may be, we are concerned that we're not going to talk about, well, we're just going to automate for whatever the delta of the purported driver shortage might be, or we're just going to automate in this nice strip of road through your home state. I think it is ahistoric to suggest that employers at some point in time will have the ability to eliminate their labor cost in totality or in large part, and decide not to do it. That's what concerns my members. Senator Cruz. I very much hope this committee will move a surface transportation bill this year. We are hard at work on it, and one of the important elements of that bill, I hope, will be an AV title. I think AV is probably the most important automotive and trucking innovation that we are facing. We had initially discussed focusing that AV title on automobiles rather than trucks. I have since been told that the Teamsters have expressed a pretty strong desire that trucks be included in any AV title. Is that right? And if so, can you articulate your views? Mr. Scandaglia. Yes, that's absolutely correct. I think at one point in time, when this kind of all seemed like a magical fairy tale, we were uninterested in the conversation. I don't think that's a conversation we can rationally have today. There are numerous testing and deployments we have in revenue service on automated companies, automated trucks. So I think the time to continue to pretend like this isn't going to happen has passed us on. But with that said, continuing to exist in an environment, as I said earlier, where we have created no unique Federal requirements other than you tell NHTSA when you get in a certain kind of crash is inappropriate. So we are very much committed to including AV trucks in that conversation. We want that to be a predicate for this bill, and we're very committed to working with the Committee to get that done. Senator Cruz. Good. Well, we will look forward to working with you closely on that and to trying to reach a resolution that hopefully incorporates the views of stakeholders across the spectrum. Mr. Scandaglia. Thank you. Senator Cruz. Let's turn to a second topic, which is freight fraud and chameleon carriers. This committee's taken testimony on the scourge of freight fraud and is prepared to legislate to address it. I want to thank Senator Young for his leadership on the Safer Transport Act, which is going to help stop freight fraud if enacted. Chameleon characters, meaning carriers with poor safety records that go out of business and then reincarnate as new carriers with clean records, are particularly problematic for fraudulent activities and poor safety records. Mr. Spear and Mr. Scandaglia, can you elaborate on the chameleon carrier problem and what Congress should do to address it? Mr. Spear. Mr. Spear. I think Chairman Young of this subcommittee has a bill called the SAFER Act that would enable FMCSA at DOT the tools regardless of administration, they would be focused on cleaning up their registry, which is the breeding ground for chameleon carriers. They shouldn't get busted, go under, and then repost under a new number. We're enforcing the law on the same people over and over. We need to get them out of the industry. These are bad people. I think also beyond that, fraud detection in your bill is really outstanding. This is a DOT specific issue that I think would add a lot of certainty within our industry with the agency overseeing us. I'd like to make it permanent. I don't want it to just be another two, two and a half years. I want this--this is exactly what the agency should be doing. I'm glad to see it being done now and I'm glad to see you putting forth legislation that would make that permanent. And beyond that, I think the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act, I really want to share my appreciation for the heavy bipartisan support in the Senate, but in the House, this passed the House Judiciary Committee unanimously. Nothing goes through that committee unanimously. It went off the House floor with 145 Democrats. This is going to bring the Federal Government, DHS, DOJ, DOT to the table where states, localities, and our industry do not have the ability to go after transnational organizations from Eastern Europe, Russia, other parts of the world. This is $18 million a day, costing my industry $6.6 billion a year. I applaud you all for taking this bill up. It's sitting in the Senate right now and the President's waiting to sign it. This could be done very quickly and would bring the Federal Government to the table. We can combat this. Senator Cruz. Good. That's helpful. Mr. Scandaglia. Mr. Scandaglia. Yes. I largely associate myself with Mr. Spear's comments. We've had this problem for decades and decades and I think, unfortunately have just continued to throw our hands up in the air and say it's hard and it's complicated and not made progress. I also agree that we have a small number of fleets and operators who are contributing to a large percentage of this problem. And so we're encouraged by efforts to finally deal with this. Both efforts that the DOT is taking. We appreciate consideration in safer transport for using new technology tools at Federal Motor Carrier to assess their datasets to look for patterns that are not currently being found. So we're all in, in this regard. I think it's a very important initiative. Senator Cruz. Great. Thank you. Senator Young. Senator Moreno, you're recognized for your second tranche of questions. Senator Moreno. Thank you. Ms. Chace, you talked about the importance of making certain that we don't have Chinese automobiles in the market from a national security perspective. Mr. Spear, from your perspective, from the Trucking Association's perspective, how important is it to make certain that we get that clear before we start talking about autonomous vehicles, because obviously that would leave a gaping hole? I think most Americans would be probably--I think it's a conspiracy theory, to think that manufacturers can remote access vehicles and take control of them. And, of course, having Chinese Communist Party defense contractors allowed to sell cars in the U.S. Can you talk about, just expand from what Ms. Chace said about the importance of national security? Mr. Spear. Happy to. I'd also dial back to past experiences of working in a tech manufacturer, Global Tech Manufacturing. We had an 80:20 rule at that time where you invest in China, you'll put 80 percent, but you always hold 20 back, because in 6 to 12 months, they're a half mile down the road taking your technology and replicating it. They're that good, they're that fast. So, yes, our conceding on a lot of these things hands the baton to China to take control of it. So we look at our industry a little bit different than passenger vehicles. Having our roughly half dozen manufacturers in the U.S., Mexico, we have better controls, I believe, about what's in a vehicle. They're not selling trucks in the U.S. but we do have Chinese parts in trucks. I think in working with BIS at Commerce Department, we were able to separate it from passenger vehicles and look at our trucks. As to what was a safety security concern, I think it's a bit less than cars. But I'm 100 percent wedded to what you're trying to do. My team's been working with yours, and I think there are some steps forward where we can get that rulemaking done at BIS and accomplish exactly what your bill proposes. Senator Moreno. Yes, exactly. So, again, the point being that let's make certain we solve the Chinese threat before we start thinking about autonomous vehicles, because if we did one before the other, you could have a huge problem. So obviously, we understand the national security threat. We talked about that. Mr. Scandaglia, I think you and your president wake up every day thinking about working Americans, making certain that you can have a mom or a dad, have one job where they can provide for their family. And that's where I think there should be commonality between Republicans and Democrats, that that should be our goal. How do we build and strengthen our working class in this country? So two points for you. Expand kind of what we're talking about. So we understand the national security threat. What's the economic threat to having Chinese automobiles in the United States from your perspective? Mr. Scandaglia. So one of the substantial threats that we see is safety for the actual operating workforce. We were extremely disturbed when the Committee held a hearing on autonomous vehicles in February when the witness from Waymo suggested that they had individuals located in the Philippines capable of manipulating those vehicles on our roads. That's really horrifying. The idea that you could have a driver in say a level 4 automated truck and someone in China could press a button and make that truck take a turn or accelerate is really horrifying to our membership and puts our members at risk. The other thing I would mention too is not so much about Chinese vehicles themselves being imported, but about Chinese companies setting up shop in America and then receiving the benefit of Federal transportation dollars. We're very proud to represent the employees of Gillig who have manufactured heavy duty transit buses in Lancaster, California. They continue to be under an existential threat from BYD who came to this country, opened up manufacturing facilities while being entirely funded by the Chinese government and supported by the Chinese government. We can't compete that way. And it would be a really horrible solution or horrible answer if our members and the company we represent was driven out of business by a Chinese owned company that's uninterested, at least for the time being, in whether or not they make a profit but wants to dominate a domestic market. Senator Moreno. Yes. And obviously the auto industry, take that exact analysis that you just gave, multiply it by 100, right. Ford, General Motors can compete with any company on earth, but they can't compete with a country. And so when you come into a market in a predatory way, in a way that these cars are dramatically less expensive, not because they're more innovative, but they're willing to lose hundreds of billions of dollars to basically destroy the western auto world, that we would have to be decently dumb to allow that to happen, right? Mr. Scandaglia. I would agree. Senator Moreno. All right, so we shouldn't be decently dumb. So the last question I have for you, Mr. Scandaglia, is we talked about some of the framework that we're trying to do. Talk about what it means to your members to have to share the road with others who are here illegally, who don't speak the language, who don't have to go through the rigor that your members do. What does that do for them on a day to day basis, having to be vigilant, not knowing who's in these other trucks? Mr. Scandaglia. Yes, there's certainly vigilance on the road, regardless of why someone specifically is unqualified. But potentially in those circumstances, our members, their workplace are the roads. So having someone who's sharing that road with them, who should not be, is concerning on a day to day safety perspective. The other thing that is equally worth mentioning though is whether or not those jobs exist. We're competing against people, competing against companies who are operating through low road systems, through having drivers who are not trained, who are not here lawfully. It presents a safety concern and presents a competition concern that relates to whether our jobs even continue to exist. Senator Moreno. Right. And the main job of government should be to make certain that something like that doesn't happen. Would you agree? Mr. Scandaglia. Absolutely. Senator Moreno. And Mr. Chairman, given what Indiana did to Ohio State, do you mind if I ask one more question? [Laughter.] Senator Young. Given that, yes. Go ahead, please. Senator Moreno. Perfect. All of a sudden Indiana is a football town. Who knows? Senator Young. I'm concerned that this will be a precedent, right. This will continue, I think, but. Senator Moreno. Well, that probably won't the football yet. Senator Young. Yes, no. Senator Moreno. Mr. Spear, one of the things that we haven't talked about, which I think is critical. So we talked about how reversing the advanced truck rule saved the trucking industry an apocalyptic scenario from our economy. We talked about the importance of jobs, we talked the importance of banning Chinese vehicles. But there's another threat to your industry which is completely out of control litigation. I think it's important to just give you some time to talk about that and what that means to your members and the companies. Mr. Spear. Yes, I think indifferent to this hearing, which has got a really good bipartisan tone, a lot of bipartisan legislation. Very good thought put into these proposals. California Air Resources Board does not sit down with our industry. They don't care what our industry has to say. Their attitude is, you'll figure it out. So if you're going to electrify our industry in a matter of five years with no infrastructure, no power, and I don't care where it comes from, could be coal, nuclear, could be wind, solar, hydro, maybe a combination, all of them. But this is a state that already suffers from rolling blackouts. So to say you're going to have the power to go through it. If you had the infrastructure, which you don't, you don't have the minerals. They're coming from China and the Congo. We have them here, but it would take 10 years to get to them. Environmentalists won't let us do that either. The cost parity, 3.5 times more than a diesel truck, which emits 98.5 percent less than a diesel truck did in 1988. One truck today is so efficient compared to all the trucks. 60, you know, trucks today on the road, brand new diesels emit what one truck emitted in 1988. That's how far we've come. They didn't take that into account. Senator Young. Thank you, Cummins engines. Mr. Spear. They're fantastic. I've been to that plant, it's fantastic. And then you look at the operational parity. It takes 15 minutes to fill a diesel to go 1,200 miles. It takes six to eight hours to charge an electric truck to go 200 miles. So we're going to need more drivers, more trucks. It's just colossal. It was one of the dumbest ideas I have ever seen put forward by anyone, including California, which I refer to as the breeding ground of all bad public policy. I mean, they just don't think things through. They don't care. Senator Young. So, thank you. Thank you. On that note, because it has been, I think, a constructive and thoughtful exchange from all of our witnesses. Thank you so much. And our members, we've learned a lot this hearing. So before we wrap up, I want to ask unanimous consent to enter into the record a letter from the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association and the Intermodal Association of North America. Without objection, so ordered. [The information referred to follows:] Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association June 8, 2026 Chairman Todd Young Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety United States Senate Ranking Member Gary Peters Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety United States Senate Re: Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association Statement for the Record on Subcommittee Hearing on ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances are Driving Transportation Innovation.'' Dear Chairman Young and Ranking Member Peters, The Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association (``AVIA'') is pleased to submit this statement for the record regarding the Subcommittee's hearing, ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances are Driving Transportation Innovation.'' AVIA thanks the Subcommittee for holding this hearing and for its continued focus on how emerging technology can improve safety, expand mobility, and strengthen American economic competitiveness. These are precisely the questions that Federal autonomous vehicle (``AV'') policy must answer, and AVIA welcomes the opportunity to offer our perspective. AVIA is the unified voice of the diverse companies advancing safe and trusted autonomous vehicles.\1\ Our membership is comprised of the world's leading technology, automotive, ridesharing, trucking, and transportation companies. Vehicles operated by AVIA members have driven more than 360 million autonomous miles on U.S. public roads, providing passenger and freight transportation services in states as diverse as Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Texas.\2\ AVs play a critical role in addressing some of the most persistent challenges facing our nation: the unacceptable toll of traffic fatalities, the barriers to mobility faced by millions of Americans, supply chain inefficiencies, and the need to maintain U.S. technological and economic leadership in a competitive global environment. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ AVIA members include Amazon, Aurora, AVRS, Avride, Bot Auto, Discount Tire, DoorDash, Ford, Gatik, General Motors, Honda, International, Kodiak, Lockton, Lyft, Motional, MOIA, NGV, Nuro, Plus, Stack, Rivian, Tier IV, Torc Robotics, TaskUs, Terawatt, Uber, UPS, U.S. Venture, Valgo, Volvo Cars, Volvo Autonomous Solutions, Waabi, Waymo, and Zoox. See Our Mission and Members, Autonomous Vehicle Indus. Ass'n, https://theavindustry.org/ (2026). \2\ AVIA's State of AV Report (2026) https://cdn.prod.website- files.com/67ee365c25e6530594 bd40c2/ 6a0b6c4fd80e0f5353ac1d11_2026_StateOfAV_AnnualReport_vs6_Web.pdf?utm_sou rce= press_release&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=stateofav_2026&utm_conten t=annual_ report --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The forthcoming surface transportation reauthorization presents one of the most significant near-term opportunities for Congress to advance a Federal AV policy framework, and AVIA urges the Subcommittee to seize it. The Safety Imperative The United States faces an ongoing public health crisis on its roads. In 2024, more than 39,000 Americans died in motor vehicle crashes, following three consecutive years of traffic deaths exceeding 40,000. Pedestrian fatalities have reached their highest levels in decades. The National Safety Council estimates that the total cost of motor vehicle injuries in 2024 alone reached $559.3 billion.\3\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ National Safety Council (2026) https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/ motor-vehicle/overview/intro- duction/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Autonomous vehicles offer a meaningful opportunity to reduce these unnecessary deaths. Automated driving systems (``ADS'') operate without distraction, impairment, or fatigue--the human errors responsible for the vast majority of crashes. The data from real-world deployments is increasingly clear. For example, AVIA's Robotaxi Report found that in San Francisco alone AVs generated $71 million in safety-related economic savings for residents--costs avoided from medical bills, vehicle repairs, insurance claims, and lost productivity.\4\ In addition, Swiss Re's analysis of Waymo operations found a 76 percent reduction in property damage claims compared to human drivers.\5\ A Virginia Tech Transportation Institute study found that full-scale deployment of occupantless AVs for delivery services could reduce roadway deaths by 58.2 percent.\6\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ AVIA Robotaxi Report (2025) https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/ 67ee365c25e6530594bd4 0c2/6930ab29af2f0cc7461e061b_Robotaxi%20Report.pdf \5\ Waymo. New Swiss Re study: Waymo is safer than even the most advanced human-driven vehicles (2024) https://waymo.com/blog/2024/12/ new-swiss-re-study-waymo/ \6\ Virginia Tech Transportation Institute. Estimating Crash Consequences for Occupantless Automated Vehicles, (2021). https:// vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/a28aa 936-8f89-4302-8859-ee54d34358e2/ content. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Economic and Mobility Opportunity The benefits of autonomous vehicles extend well beyond safety. By 2050, the value of public and consumer benefits from widespread AV deployment--including reduced congestion, avoided crashes, and saved time--could reach $796 billion annually.\7\ Wider AV deployment could create more than three million new jobs by 2035 and raise annual earnings for all U.S. workers by between $203 and $267 per worker per year.\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\ Securing America's Future Energy, America's Workforce and the Self-Driving Future 9 (2018), https://avworkforce.secureenergy.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/ 06/SAFE_AV_Policy_ Brief.pdf \8\ Securing America's Future Energy, America's Workforce and the Self-Driving Future 9 (2018), https://avworkforce.secureenergy.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/ 06/SAFE_AV_Policy_ Brief.pdf --------------------------------------------------------------------------- For Americans currently underserved by the transportation system, AVs represent tremendous promise for their daily lives and opportunities. The U.S. Department of Transportation estimates that 25.5 million Americans face travel-limiting disabilities, and roughly 560,000 people with disabilities never leave their homes due to transportation barriers.\9\ A National Disability Institute study found that wider AV deployment could create 4.4 million jobs for people with disabilities and generate a 3.8 percent increase in U.S. GDP. For elderly Americans, rural communities, and residents of transit deserts, AVs can provide access to employment, healthcare, and opportunity that current transportation options do not.\10\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\ ADA at DOT: Accessibility Initiatives, U.S. Dep't of Transp. (Feb. 13, 2025), https://www.transportation.gov/accessibility; Bureau of Transp. Stat., Transportation Difficulties Keep Over Half a Million Disabled at Home (2012), https://www.bts.gov/archive/publications/ special_reports_and_issue_briefs/issue_briefs/number_03/entire \10\ Dominic Modicamore et al., Economic Impacts of Removing Transportation Barriers to Employment for Individuals with Disabilities Through Autonomous Vehicle Adoption (2022), https:// www.nationaldisabilityinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/ndi- economicimpacts ofremovingtransportationbarriers.pdf --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Case for Inclusion in Surface Reauthorization Autonomous vehicle deployment progress has occurred despite the absence of a comprehensive Federal policy framework--a gap that leaves American companies operating under a fragmented set of state requirements and at a disadvantage relative to competitors in China and other countries that have already established regulatory certainty for AV developers. Only the Federal government can set nationally applicable vehicle design and performance standards, and the surface transportation reauthorization is the appropriate vehicle for Congress to exercise that authority. These Federal requirements can--and should--respect state authority over certain elements of motor vehicle regulation, including autonomous vehicles. AVIA urges the Subcommittee to support inclusion of strong autonomous vehicle policy in the reauthorization. These policies should make progress on nationally applicable standards for ADS-equipped vehicles and support the wider deployment of AVs that will deliver safety and mobility benefits to communities across the country. In January 2025, AVIA published Securing American Leadership in Autonomous Vehicles, a comprehensive set of Federal policy recommendations to accelerate the safe and timely deployment of AV technology and solidify U.S. global leadership in this field. That document provides a roadmap for the Subcommittee in establishing Federal policy that encourages American excellence on autonomous vehicles. Many of AVIA's priorities have been incorporated into the SELF DRIVE Act, sponsored by Representative Bob Latta, and the AMERICA DRIVES Act, sponsored by Representative Vince Fong. Many of the concepts in Rep. Fong's AMERICA DRIVES Act are included in the BUILD America 250 Act from Chairman Graves and Ranking Member Larsen. This bill was voted out of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee by a vote of 62-2. AVIA strongly encourages the Subcommittee to consider these priorities as it develops its own approach. The United States currently leads the world in autonomous vehicle technology. The surface transportation reauthorization is an opportunity to support American leadership with a Federal framework that matches the ambition of the technology. AVIA looks forward to working with Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, and the full Subcommittee to ensure that outcome. Thank you for considering AVIA's perspective. Sincerely, Jeff Farrah, Chief Executive Officer, Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association. ______ Intermodal Association of North America June 8, 2026 Hon. Ted Cruz, Chairman, Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Washington, DC. Hon. Todd Young, Chairman, Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, Washington, DC. Hon. Maria Cantwell, Ranking Member, Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Washington, DC. Hon. Gary Peters, Ranking Member, Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, Washington, DC. Re: The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances are Driving Transportation Innovation Dear Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, Subcommittee Chairman Young, Subcommittee Ranking Member Peters, and Members of the Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety: As your Committee contemplates a regulatory framework that balances safety and innovation, I write on behalf of the Intermodal Association of North America (IANA) urging a mode-neutral approach to technology. As the only transportation trade association representing the combined interests of intermodal freight providers and customers, IANA represents more than 1,000 corporate members, including railroads, ocean carriers, ports, intermodal truckers and over-the-road highway carriers, intermodal marketing and logistic companies, and suppliers to the industry. IANA's associate (non-voting) members include shippers (defined as the beneficial owners of the freight to be shipped), academic institutions, government entities, and non-profit trade associations. IANA's membership spans the supply chain and operates across road, rail, and water. The intermodal freight system is highly efficient, combining the benefits and advantages of each mode to deliver containerized goods safely, reliably, and cost effectively. Our nation's supply chains depend upon these seamless connections between transportation modes. To ensure the continued success and competitiveness of the freight network, it is essential that policymakers allow industry to advance technology that has a proven record of delivering equivalent--or superior--safety outcomes, regardless of mode. A regulatory framework for technological innovation that favors one mode over another harms supply chain interoperability as well as competition. When developing policies to support innovation, we urge Congress to take a holistic approach to further data-driven technological advancements. We've recently observed inconsistency across modes in Federal policymaking. For example, a single legislative proposal is seeking to advance a framework that identifies pathways for addressing safety- related operational barriers to the deployment of autonomous commercial trucks, while simultaneously codifying a minimum crew-size requirement and limiting the independent utility of automated track inspections for freight railroads. This mismatch pits modes against each other, launching one into the future and keeping another in the past. Parity across all modes is a critical element in advancing a technological framework. I appreciate the Committee's dedication to working with industry practitioners as emerging technology presents new policy considerations. As an association that works across all modes, IANA stands ready to be a resource in this important discussion and I hope you'll call on us. Thank you, Sincerely, Anne Reinke, President and CEO, Intermodal Association of North America. Senator Young. So thank you to all our witnesses for their important testimony today. Senators will have until the close of business on June 16 to submit questions for the record. The witnesses will have until close of business on June 30 to respond to those questions. This concludes today's hearing. The Committee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:37 a.m., the Subcommittee was adjourned.] A P P E N D I X June 9th, 2026 Hon. Todd Young, Chair, Hon. Gary Peters, Ranking Member, Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, United States Senate, Washington, DC. RE: ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances Are Driving Transportation Innovation'' Dear Chairman Young, Ranking Member Peters, and Members of the Senate Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, Thank you for convening a hearing on ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances Are Driving Transportation Innovation''. Technology undoubtedly plays a vital role in transportation, and no one knows that better than Train Dispatchers. The U.S. rail network depends on Computer-Aided Train Dispatching (CAD) Systems--software that shows where trains are, how routes are lined, and which tracks are occupied. These systems are relied upon by Train Dispatchers (or Rail Traffic Controllers) to authorize safe train movements, issue and enforce speed restrictions, protect grade crossing malfunctions, and to provide safety protection for trains, on-track workers, and the communities they operate through. America's freight and passenger railroads use these computer-based dispatch systems to move and coordinate train traffic and to provide protection to employees working on main tracks. Software for these systems is developed and maintained by vendors contracted by the railroads. Yet, new dispatching systems and updates to existing programs are presently implemented without any oversight, testing, or regulation by the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA). Moreover, when software problems are identified, including problems critical to the safe movement of trains, the railroads and vendors are often slow to resolve such issues in a timely manner. This leaves the users, Train Dispatchers, being forced to identify problems and troubleshoot the technology under live conditions and use ``work arounds'' (in some cases for several months) until safety defects are corrected. Likewise, this means there are no cybersecurity requirements to ensure the protection of these vital train-control systems. Just recently, the FRA, in coordination with a larger government campaign on cybersecurity, issued a notice that the U.S. railroad network is likely at-risk from Iranian-state-sponsored cyber actors.\1\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ https://www.cisa.gov/news-events/cybersecurity-advisories/aa26- 097a --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Train dispatching systems must be subject to FRA oversight, review, and approval, like other technologies that prevent train collisions and incidents, such as Positive Train Control (PTC) systems. On numerous occasions, system defects, errors, and malfunctions have put both passenger and freight rail at-risk. These include near head-on collisions at a major commuter rail, near miss fatalities of roadway workers, and more. In the last nine months alone, the American Train Dispatchers Association has received over 80 train dispatcher software error reports. The reliability and security of these systems is of utmost concern to train dispatchers. In July 2025, Canadian National Railway experienced a CAD system outage that affected its entire 6,400-mile U.S. network, leaving dispatchers unable to track train movements across 16 states. In August 2025, a system error at Norfolk Southern removed critical safety protection from the dispatching system while maintenance crews were working on active track. In November 2025, BNSF Railway experienced a widespread dispatching system outage affecting approximately 94 percent of its network across 28 states, leaving dispatchers unable to reliably track train movements or control routing. In January 2026, ATDA became aware that Norfolk Southern dispatchers were required to remove all safety blocks, info tags, track authorities, speed restrictions, and crossing protection blocks to update the system. These incidents are not isolated events and illustrate the systemic risks posed by unregulated dispatching technology. Our members experience the day-to- day challenges of these technologies, and while technological advances are often positive developments, they must be done in a way that ensure that they are thoroughly test, properly vetted, and appropriately maintained to ensure the safety of the general public. The technology must also serve to support the workers utilizing the technology rather than creating additional safety risks. Certifying that these technologies are safe and effective is not only vital for public safety and for the protection of our communities, but is also economically logical, profitable for railroads, and provides for the protection of our supply chain. Accidents, derailments, and fatalities cause tragic distress to our communities in a multitude of ways and are avoidable. We must guarantee to the highest extent possible that technological innovation does what it is meant to do: supplement the tools available to professionals, not create additional safety hazards, increase workloads, or security concerns. Granting the FRA oversight over dispatching technology will make sure that vendors are held accountable for their product and verify that innovation in transportation technology is safe, reliable, and properly maintained. Congress must implement directives that prioritize oversight of these systems, as innovation without safety and security is no innovation at all. We thank the committee for their consideration of these issues and look forward to working together to improve rail safety in technology innovation. Respectfully, L. Ed Dowell, President, American Train Dispatchers Association. ______ Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety June 8, 2026 Hon. Todd Young, Chair Hon. Gary Peters, Ranking Member Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety United States Senate Washington, DC Dear Chair Young and Ranking Member Peters: Thank you for convening tomorrow's hearing, ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances Are Driving Transportation Innovation.'' Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety (Advocates) urges this Subcommittee to advance proven solutions to improve safety on our Nation's roads and establish sensible safeguards to ensure self-driving vehicles are developed and deployed safely. Advocates respectfully requests this letter be included in the hearing record. Motor Vehicle Deaths Remain Historically High Resulting in a Tremendous Personal and Economic Cost to all Americans America's roads are moving an ever-increasing number of people and goods.\1\ This activity comes with a significant yet preventable human toll as well as infrastructure challenges and a robust price tag. On average, 108 people were killed every day on roads in the U.S., totaling over 39,000 fatalities in 2024.\2\ This is a 20 percent increase in deaths in just a decade.\3\ An additional 2.742 million people were injured.\4\ Early projections for 2025 traffic fatalities remain at a high level; over 36,640 people are estimated to have been killed that year.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ 2025 Report Card for America's Infrastructure, American Society of Civil Engineers, https://infrastructurereportcard.org/cat-item/ roads-infrastructure/ \2\ Traffic Safety Facts Research Note: Overview of Motor Vehicle Traffic Crashes In 2024, NHTSA, Apr. 2026, DOT HS 813 791, (Overview 2024). \3\ Overview 2024; and Traffic Safety Facts 2023: A Compilation of Motor Vehicle Traffic Crash Data, NHTSA, Aug. 2025, DOT HS 813 738 (Annual Report 2023).; [comparing 2014 to 2024]. \4\ Overview 2024. \5\ Traffic Safety Facts: Crash Stats, Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2025, NHTSA, Apr. 2026, DOT HS 813 800 (Early Estimates 2025). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The annual economic cost of motor vehicle crashes is approximately $340 billion (2019 dollars).\6\ This figure equates to every person living in the U.S. essentially paying an annual ``crash tax'' of over $1,000. Moreover, the total value of societal harm from motor vehicle crashes in 2019, which includes loss of life, pain and decreased quality of life, was nearly $1.4 trillion.\7\ When adjusted solely for inflation, this figure amounts to $1.81 trillion.\8\ Research from the Network of Employers for Traffic Safety (NETS) finds motor vehicle crashes cost employers $72.2 billion in direct crash-related expenses in 2019.\9\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ The Economic and Societal Impact of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2019, NHTSA, Dec. 2022, DOT HS 813 403. (Economic and Societal Impact 2019). \7\ Economic and Societal Impact 2019. \8\ CPI Inflation Calculator, BLS, available at https:// www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator .htm, calculated from Jan. 2019-Jan. 2026. \9\ Cost of Motor Vehicle Crashes to Employers--2019, Network of Employers for Traffic Safety, March 2021. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In 2024, 5,340 people were killed and over 161,000 people were injured in crashes involving large trucks.\10\ Since 2009, the number of fatalities in large truck crashes has increased by 58 percent.\11\ In that same timespan, the number of people injured in crashes involving large trucks rose by 118 percent.\12\ In fatal two-vehicle crashes between a large truck and a passenger motor vehicle, 97 percent of the fatalities were occupants of the passenger vehicle.\13\ Truck driving is identified as one of the most dangerous occupations in the U.S. by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.\14\ In 2024, 920 occupants of large trucks were killed in crashes.\15\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\ Overview 2024 \11\ Annual Report 2024, Note, the 58 percent figure represents the overall change in the number of fatalities in large truck involved crashes from 2009 to 2024. However, between 2015 and 2016 there was a change in data collection at U.S. DOT that could affect this calculation. From 2009 to 2015 the number of fatalities in truck- involved crashes increased by 21 percent, and between 2016 to 2024, it increased by 14 percent, and between 2015 and 2016, it increased by 14 percent. \12\ Annual Report 2024, Note, the 117 percent figure represents the overall change in the number of people injured in large truck involved crashes from 2009 to 2024. However, between 2015 and 2016 there was a change in data collection at U.S. DOT that could affect this calculation. From 2009 to 2015 the number of people injured in truck-involved crashes increased by 59 percent, and between 2016 to 2024, it increased by 20 percent, and between 2015 and 2016, it increased by 14 percent. \13\ Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), Large Trucks. https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/large-trucks. \14\ National Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries in 2024, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Feb. 2026, USDL-26-0230, available at: https:// www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/cfoi.pdf. \15\ Overview 2024. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), traffic incidents, which include crashes, are one of the seven main causes of traffic congestion which erodes the reliability of travel time.\16\ The report notes that for truck operators, ``[t]he cost of unexpected delay can add another 20 percent to 250 percent'' to their hourly costs.\17\ The cost to society from crashes involving large trucks and buses was estimated to be $152 billion in 2022, the latest year for which data is available.\18\ When adjusted solely for inflation, this figure amounts to nearly $176 billion.\19\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \16\ Traffic Congestion and Reliability: Trends and Advanced Strategies for Congestion Mitigation, March 2020, FHWA. Available here: https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/congestion_report/chapter2.htm (2020 Traffic Congestion and Reliability Report.) \17\ 2020 Traffic Congestion and Reliability Report. \18\ 2024 Pocket Guide to Large Truck and Bus Statistics, FMCSA, Jul. 2025, RRA-24-002. \19\ CPI Inflation Calculator, BLS, available at https:// www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator .htm, calculated from Jan. 2022-Jan. 2026. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- These devastating crashes impact millions of Americans each year including the families of U.S. Department of Transportation (U.S. DOT) Secretary Duffy and Members of Congress. These tragedies result in long-lasting effects which often are not accounted for in statistics alone. For every single death and serious injury, there is a horrific ripple effect forever changing the lives of children, parents, friends and communities. Major Contributors of Crashes Must be Addressed We urge this Subcommittee to continue to address the leading contributing factors to motor vehicle crashes. In 2024, alcohol impaired driving resulted in 11,904 people killed;\20\ speeding resulted in 11,288 people killed;\21\ 9,758 vehicle occupants killed in crashes were unrestrained;\22\ and, crashes in which at least one driver was distracted resulted in 3,208 fatalities.\23\ In 2024, 7,080 pedestrians and 1,103 pedalcyclists were killed in traffic crashes.\24\ Motorcycles continue to be the most hazardous form of motor vehicle transportation;\25\ 6,228 riders were killed in 2024.\26\ From 2014- 2024, fatalities of pedestrians increased 44 percent, pedalcyclists increased 51 percent and motorcyclists increased 36 percent.\27\ Additionally, in 2021, the most recent year for which data is available according to the Non-Traffic Surveillance (NTS) system, an estimated 3,990 people were killed in non-traffic motor vehicle crashes, an increase of 26 percent from 2020.\28\ These issues are persistent, and the solutions are known and available, yet remain underused, underfunded or are not required as standard equipment in vehicles. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \20\ Overview 2024. \21\ Id. \22\ Id. \23\ Id. These crashes are known to be underreported and undercounted. \24\ Id. \25\ The Economic and Societal Impact of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2019 (Revised), NHTSA, Feb. 2023, DOT HS 813 403. \26\ Overview 2024. \27\ Annual Report 2023 and Overview 2024. \28\ Traffic Safety Facts Crash Stats: Non-Traffic Surveillance: Fatality and Injury Statistics in Non-Traffic Crashes in 2021, NHTSA, Apr. 2024, DOT HS 813 539. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Experimental Autonomous Driving Technology Remains Unproven Vehicles equipped with various levels of automated driving systems (ADS) have been involved in numerous serious and deadly crashes, many of which have been subject to investigation by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).\29\ As NHTSA noted in the 2025 Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) on the ADS-Equipped Vehicle Safety, Transparency, and Evaluation Program (AV STEP), vehicles equipped with ADS ``. . . often struggle with driving tasks that humans consider relatively simple.'' \30\ Furthermore, according to data collected by NHTSA's Standing General Order (SGO) 2021-1 requiring manufacturers to report certain crashes involving vehicles equipped with ADS or SAE Level 2 advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS), there have been approximately 2,357 crashes involving ADS and 3,682 with ADAS. These include 58 crashes resulting in a fatality.\31\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \29\ Ian Duncan and Aaron Gregg, Crashes involving Tesla's Full Self-Driving prompt new Federal probe, WaPo (Oct. 18, 2024). \30\ 90 FR 4132. \31\ Standing General Order on Crash Reporting: For Incidents Involving ADS and Level 2 ADAS, NHTSA, available at https:// www.nhtsa.gov/laws-regulations/standing-general-order-crash-reporting, last accessed June 2, 2026. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to media reports, numerous dangerous incidents involving autonomous vehicles (AVs) continue to occur including failing to stop for school buses,\32\ ceasing operating in the middle of city streets during a power outage,\33\ traveling on light rail tracks causing the robotaxi's passenger to flee,\34\ swarming a residential cul-de-sac\35\ and navigating flooded streets.\36\ NHTSA and the NTSB have opened investigations into the incidents involving school buses. Earlier this year, a child was reportedly hit by an autonomous vehicle during school drop off.\37\ Aptly put, an individual who has witnessed AV operations remarked that the vehicles ``are driving like teenagers.'' \38\ It should be noted that teenagers are the most dangerous age group of drivers.\39\ Not surprisingly, according to a recent public opinion poll commissioned by Advocates, 81 percent of respondents are concerned about sharing the road with driverless cars.\40\ Trepidation is even higher for driverless tractor-trailer and delivery trucks, with 85 percent expressing concern, including a majority (54 percent) who are ``very'' concerned.\41\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \32\ Mary Cunningham, Waymo recalls more than 3,000 vehicles over faulty software following school bus violations, CBS News (Dec. 11,2025). \33\ Grace Eliza Goodwin, Waymo robotaxis stop in the streets during San Francisco power outage, BBC News (Dec. 22, 2025). \34\ Mickaela Castillo, Waymo passenger flees after car drives on Phoenix light rail tracks, AZ Family News (Jan. 8, 2026). \35\ Angeline Jane Bernabe, Empty Waymo vehicles swarm Atlanta cul- de-sac, ABC News, May 15, 2026. \36\ Isaiah Richard, Waymo Has Not Fixed the Problem of Its Robotaxis Driving Through Flood, Tech Times (May 22, 2026). \37\ Washington Post, Waymo robotaxi hits child at school drop-off, triggering safety inquiry, Jan. 19, 2026. \38\ Blake Ellis, Melanie Hicken, Yahya Abou-Ghazala, `Driving like teenagers': Waymo robotaxis have run red lights and nearly hit pedestrians, CNN finds, CNN (Jun. 3, 2026). \39\ See: https://www.cdc.gov/teen-drivers/risk-factors/index.html \40\ See: https://saferoads.org/2026-av-tech-truck-poll/ \41\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- If incidents such as the aforementioned had involved autonomous commercial motor vehicles (ACMVs), which are significantly larger and heavier with more stopping distance needed, the results could have been catastrophic, and the death and injury toll could have been much worse. Some of the most pressing safety shortcomings associated with AV technology, which include the ADS properly detecting and reacting to all other road users, driver engagement and cybersecurity, are exponentially amplified by the greater crash force of an ACMV. ``We Must Not Promise What We Ought Not, Lest We Be Called on to Perform What We Cannot''\42\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \42\ The Complete Papers and Writings of Abraham Lincoln. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Many promises have been touted about AVs bringing reductions in motor vehicle crashes and resultant deaths and injuries, lowering traffic congestion and vehicle emissions, expanding mobility and accessibility, improving efficiency, and creating more equitable transportation options and opportunities.\43\ However, as auto industry leaders have acknowledged, these outcomes are far from certain.\44\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \43\ Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association, State of AV Report 2025. \44\ Kristopher Brooks, The main reason why self-driving cars are not ready for prime time, CBS News (May 1, 2024); Nilay Patel and Andrew J. Hawkins, Pete Buttigieg is Racing to Keep Up with Self Driving Cars. The Verge (Jan. 6, 2022); Rebecca Fannin, Where the billions spent on autonomous vehicles by U.S. and Chinese giants is heading, CNBC (May 23, 2022). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- AV manufacturers and proponents of the technology often claim that AVs are safer because they don't get tired, distracted or drive impaired. While some AVs may be readily able to avoid crashes caused by those human drivers who operate impaired, fatigued or distracted, they also may cause crashes that sober, alert and engaged drivers would routinely avoid. AVs, which are essentially billion-dollar pieces of equipment with years of research, should not drive better than only the worst drivers on the road. Additionally, supporters of AVs often assert that these vehicles will improve roadway safety by inaccurately stating that 94 percent of crashes are due to human error pointing to a report from NHTSA as support for this misleading claim. However, the agency stated in the same document with this statistic that ``[a]lthough the critical reason is an important part of the description of events leading up to the crash, it is not intended to be interpreted as the cause of the crash nor as the assignment of the fault to the driver, vehicle, or environment.'' \45\ [Emphasis added.] In addition, NTSB Chair Jennifer Homendy has declared that using the statistic in such a manner is ``dangerous'' and ``[a]t the same time it relieves everybody else of responsibility they have for improving safety, including DOT.'' \46\ Proponents of AVs also have made the claim that these vehicles will prevent 90 percent of crash fatalities.\47\ Yet, as NHTSA states in the AV STEP NPRM, ``[t]his proposal recognizes that the potential of ADS is still largely unproven.'' \48\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \45\ Singh, S. (2015, February). Critical reasons for crashes investigated in the National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey. (Traffic Safety Facts Crash Stats. Report No. DOT HS 812 115). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. \46\ Hope Yen and Tom Krisher, NTSB chief to fed agency: Stop using misleading statistics, Associated Press (Jan. 18. 2022). \47\ Iyad Rahwan and Azim Shariff, Self-Driving Cars Could Save Many Lives. But Mental Roadblocks Stand in the Way. Wall Street Journal (Apr. 6, 2021). \48\ 90 FR 4132. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Often, claims made about the safety of their operations do not provide a complete picture. For example, as of December 2025, ``Waymo has driven 170.7 million rider-only miles without a human driver.'' \49\ Human beings drove 3.29 trillion miles on U.S. roads in 2024 alone. Thus, in its entire history from approximately 2019 to December 2025, Waymo vehicles have operated without a human driver for less than 0.005 percent of the mileage driven on U.S. roads by human drivers in a single year.\50\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \49\ https://waymo.com/safety/impact/ \50\ Overview 2024. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Waymo claims reductions in ``serious injury or worse crashes,'' ``airbag deployment in any vehicle crashes,'' and ``injury-causing crashes.'' \51\ However, over 45 percent of the crashes reported by Waymo pursuant to the SGO had no human occupants in the vehicle. The absence of passengers in a Waymo vehicle in a crash by default lowers the injury rate and could be unrelated to the safety performance of the vehicle given that there was no occupant available to be injured. Moreover, if the goal of AV operations is to transport people, claiming a safety benefit from crashes where no occupant is present is incongruous. Additionally, the majority of the incidents reported by Waymo pursuant to the SGO involved the Waymo vehicle being struck in the rear on roads with speed limits of 25 mph or less, conditions not generally associated with airbag deployments. In sum, Waymo vehicles are operating on roads with lower speed limits and are over involved in rear end crashes, with a large number of incidents not involving passengers in the vehicle. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \51\ https://waymo.com/safety/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Additionally, a recent Reuters Special Report revealed that while Tesla plans its ``Full Self Driving'' (FSD) systems will soon make all Teslas fully autonomous, ``interviews with nine former labelers and a former Tesla self-driving engineer show that the technology continued to struggle in recent months to execute basic maneuvers--such as avoiding emergency vehicles or stopping for school buses loading or unloading students.'' It also reported that Tesla executives have increasingly touted FSD's safety as they pushed Tesla to stage public displays of the fully autonomous capability. The article continued: The displays include a robotaxi pilot in Austin, Texas launched last June with some human safety monitors in the cars and others working remotely. Inside Tesla, as these events approached, staffers worked long hours mapping routes and training the software on specific hazards to make the company's self-driving technology appear more capable than it really is, four of the former Tesla employees told Reuters. The staffers said these labor intensive safeguards are impossible to deploy on a broad scale.\52\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \52\ By Chris Kirkham and Rachael Levy, Why Tesla's AI trainers don't trust its self-driving tech--or its safety stats, Reuters (May, 28 2026). Lastly, the SGO does not provide the data needed to fully analyze the operational difficulties and incidents that are occurring. To properly assess the safety of these operations, additional performance data beyond crashes is needed considering events such as Waymo vehicles traveling on light rail tracks and passing school buses.\53\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \53\ Mickaela Castillo, Waymo passenger flees after car drives on Phoenix light rail tracks, AZ Family News (Jan. 8, 2026); Mary Cunningham, Waymo recalls more than 3,000 vehicles over faulty software following school bus violations, CBS News (Dec. 11, 2025). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The U.S. is Not Lagging Behind Other Countries in Deployment In sharp contrast to what is happening in the U.S., other countries are taking a more calculated, careful and cautious approach to the development of AVs.\54\ Often-repeated claims about the U.S. ``falling behind'' other countries in the ``race'' for AVs are simply not true nor supported by research. For example: --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \54\ Autonomous vehicles: cross jurisdictional regulatory perspectives update, Oct. 7, 2022. China continues to require permits or restricts operations of AVs on its roads to only those areas approved by the authorities.\55\ In fact, the Nation recently delayed plans for production of AVs after a deadly crash.\56\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \55\ China drafts rules on use of self-driving vehicles for public transport; Aug. 8, 2022, Reuters; and Baidue bags China's first fully driverless robotaxi licenses, Aug. 7, Reuters. Real driverless cars are now legal in Shenzhen, China's tech hub, Jul. 25, 2022, TechCrunch+. \56\ Keith Bradsher, China Delays Plans for Mass Production of Self-Driving Cars After Accident, NY Times (Dec. 23, 2025). Germany continues to require permits, approvals, and limits areas of operation for AVs.\57\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \57\ Germany completes legal framework for autonomous driving | Federal Cabinet approves new ordinance, Apr. 2022, Malterer, M. In Japan, the introduction of Level 4 vehicles will be controlled and limited to specific, lightly populated areas.\58\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \58\ Japan to open roads to autonomous vehicles in 2023, Nov. 28, 2022, Wessling, B., The RobotReport. The latest United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) regulations will limit operations to restrict risks and oversee approval through testing and other requirements.\59\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \59\ New rules to improve road safety and enable fully driverless vehicles in the EU, Jul. 6, 2022, UNECE. In sum, no country is selling fully automated vehicles for unfettered use to the public and by many accounts, none will be for a significant amount of time.\60\ According to the most recent KPMG analysis, the U.S. ranks fourth in the world for AV readiness, while China stands at number twenty.\61\ The U.S. is not lagging behind other countries in allowing AVs to go to market, but we are behind in establishing comprehensive regulations to ensure public safety will not be jeopardized or diminished. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \60\ Lawrence Ulrich, Driverless Still a Long Way From Humanless, N.Y. Times (Jun. 20, 2019); Level 5 possible but ``way in the future'', says VW-Ford AV boss, Motoring (Jun. 29, 2019). \61\ Autonomous Vehicle Readiness Index, KPMG, 2020. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Federal Safety Standards Prevent Motor Vehicle Crashes, Save Lives, Avert Injuries and Reduce Associated Costs Advocates always has enthusiastically championed proven vehicle safety technology and for good reason--it is one of the most effective strategies for preventing deaths and injuries. According to NHTSA, ``[t]he FMVSS [Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards] remain NHTSA's core way of ensuring that all motor vehicles provide the requisite level of safety performance and provide it within a technical timeframe.'' \62\ In fact, the agency has estimated that from 1968 through 2019, NHTSA's safety standards have prevented more than 865,000 deaths, 49 million nonfatal injuries and damage to 65 million vehicles.\63\ In addition, during that time frame the comprehensive societal benefits amounted to $17.3 trillion, using 2019 dollars.\64\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \62\ 89 FR 76923, Sep. 19, 2024. \63\ Kahane, C. J., & Simons, J. F. (2024, December). Fatalities, injuries, and crashes prevented by vehicle safety technologies and associated FMVSS, 1968 to 2019--Passenger cars and LTVs (Report No. DOT HS 813 611). National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. \64\ NHTSA: 50 Years of Vehicle Safety Standards Saved Hundreds of Thousands of Lives, Prevented Millions of Injuries. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In 1991, Advocates led the coalition that supported enactment of the bipartisan Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA) of 1991\65\ which included a mandate for front seat airbags as standard equipment. As a result, by 1997, every new car sold in the United States was equipped with this technology and the lives saved have been significant. Frontal airbags have saved an estimated 70,059 lives from 1968 to 2019, according to NHTSA.\66\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \65\ Pub. L. 102-240 (Dec. 18, 1991). \66\ Kahane, C. J., & Simons, J. F. (2024, December). Fatalities, injuries, and crashes prevented by vehicle safety technologies and associated FMVSS, 1968 to 2019--Passenger cars and LTVs (Report No. DOT HS 813 611). National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Advocates built on this success by supporting additional proven lifesaving technologies as standard equipment in all vehicles in other Federal legislation and regulatory proposals. These efforts include: tire pressure monitoring systems;\67\ rear outboard 3-point safety belts;\68\ electronic stability control;\69\ rear safety belt reminder systems;\70\ brake transmission interlocks;\71\ safety belts on motorcoaches;\72\ rear-view cameras;\73\ safer power window switches;\74\ ADAS;\75\ advanced impaired driving prevention technology;\76\ rear designated seating position alert (hot cars);\77\ enhanced vehicle hood and bumpers to better protect vulnerable road users;\78\ and, advanced head lamps.\79\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \67\ Transportation Recall Enhancement, Accountability, and Documentation (TREAD) Act, Pub. L. 106-414 (Nov. 1, 2000). \68\ Anton's Law, Pub. L. 107-318 (Dec. 4, 2002). \69\ Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users (SAFETEA-LU), Pub. L. 109-59 (Aug. 10, 2005). \70\ Id. \71\ Id. \72\ Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century (MAP-21) Act, Pub. L. 112-141 (Jan. 3, 2012). \73\ Cameron Gulbransen Kids Transportation Safety Act of 2007, Pub. L. 110-189 (Feb. 28, 2008). \74\ Id. \75\ Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, Pub. L. 117-58 (Nov. 15, 2021). \76\ Id. \77\ Id. \78\ Id. \79\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The regulatory action undertaken by NHTSA to require pedestrian automatic emergency braking (PAEB) on light passenger vehicles is an excellent recent example of the benefits of requiring effective safety systems as standard equipment. The agency predicts that PAEB will save 362 lives, mitigate over 24,000 injuries annually and result in a yearly cost benefit of between $5.8-$7.2 billion. The Final Rule for PAEB issued in 2024 also noted that the end user price for the safety technology for a popular make and model vehicle, a Toyota Camry, is $240.24.\80\ This cost is modest, particularly given the returns on the investment. Moreover, research performed by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has found that AEB can reduce front-to-rear crashes with injuries by 56 percent. Any delay in implementing the Final Rule is an unnecessary safety setback. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \80\ Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 127; Light Vehicle Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB); AEB Test Devices, NHTSA, Final Regulatory Impact Analysis, April 2024. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Research also demonstrates that lifesaving vehicle safety technologies are not the chief contributor to increased prices for new cars. IIHS/Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) President David Harkey has stated, ``Sacrificing safety is not the way to make cars affordable,'' ``. . . safety features aren't the main thing pushing up prices.\81\ Buyers are paying more for convenience features such as hands-free power liftgates, puddle lights and automatically retracting mirrors. Size is also a major factor: Americans continue to gravitate toward larger vehicles.'' \82\ Additionally, a 2023 study by Consumer Reports (CR) found that ``[c]ommonly reported changes in average transaction prices appear to be primarily driven by shifts toward larger, more expensive SUVs and away from smaller and cheaper cars, rather than from the cost of technology improvements in individual models.'' \83\ As a result, CR concluded that ``[t]hese findings prove that regulators can and should be aggressive in ensuring that automakers continue to deliver cost-effective technology improvements that save dollars and lives.'' \84\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \81\ David Harkey, Sacrificing safety is not the way to make cars affordable, IIHS Insight (Jan. 20, 2026). \82\ David Harkey, Sacrificing safety is not the way to make cars affordable, IIHS Insight (Jan. 20, 2026). \83\ Consumer Reports, Vehicle Price Trends Fuel Economy and Safety Improvements Come Standard. \84\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Crashes, including those that involve some of the leading contributors to fatalities, can be prevented or mitigated by AEB and other ADAS systems. Research by IIHS has demonstrated significant crash reductions associated with these safety systems:\85\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \85\ Real-world benefits of crash avoidance technologies, IIHS, July 2023. [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] We urge this Subcommittee to conduct oversight to ensure the U.S. DOT issues the Final Rule for AEB in heavy vehicles and lane departure warning (LDW) and lane keeping assist (LKA) in passenger vehicles, as Congressionally mandated.\86\ Additionally, we urge Congress to direct NHTSA to enhance the AEB rule by including bicycle and motorcycle rider detection and response in all lighting conditions.\87\ According to a recent poll commissioned by Advocates, 73 percent of respondents support requiring AEB to respond to bicyclists and motorcyclists in addition to pedestrians.\88\ Research conducted by IIHS found that clothing which makes pedestrians stand out to human drivers may make them invisible to automated crash prevention systems, so ensuring AEB operates properly in all lighting conditions is essential.\89\ The Final Rule for AEB in passenger vehicles must be swiftly complied with, absent added delay. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \86\ Pub. L. 117-58 (2021). \87\ Magnus White Cyclist Safety Act of 2025, H.R. 3649, 119 Cong. Sec. 1 (2025); Motor Vehicle Modernization Act of 2026, H.R. 7389, 119 Cong. Sec. 2 (2026). \88\ See: https://saferoads.org/2026-av-tech-truck-poll/ \89\ IIHS, High-visibility clothing may thwart pedestrian crash prevention sensors (Jan. 9, 2025). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- We also urge Congress to direct U.S. DOT to issue standards and requirements for other vehicle safety technologies shown by research to reduce crashes and impacts, including as noted by IIHS research, blind spot detection, rear AEB and rear cross traffic alert. Many of these systems are already mandated in Europe.\90\ (Please see attached chart.) Additionally, two bipartisan bills referred to the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, the She Develops Regulations in Vehicle Equality (She DRIVES Act, S. 161) and the Preventing Roadside and Work Zone Deaths Act (S. 3871), as well as the Stop Underrides Act 2.0 (S. 3775) should be advanced. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \90\ See: https://etsc.eu/comparative-overview-eu-us-vehicle- standards/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) also directed NHTSA to issue a FMVSS requiring passenger motor vehicles to be equipped with impaired driving prevention technology by 2024.\91\ IIHS research estimates that passive impaired driving prevention technology will save more than 10,000 lives each year, once widely deployed.\92\ The agency issued an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) in January 2024 but has taken no further regulatory action.\93\ Until NHTSA completes this overdue rulemaking, lives will continue to be needlessly lost, injuries suffered and associated costs expended. As such, we urge this Subcommittee to employ its oversight authority to ensure NHTSA swiftly issues a Final Rule. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \91\ Pub. L. 117-58, Sec. 24220 (2021). \92\ Alcohol and Drugs, IIHS. \93\ 89 FR 830 (Jan. 5, 2024). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Since 1990, over 1,100 unattended children have been killed in ``hot cars,'' and 7,500 more have been injured.\94\ Cost effective technology exists to prevent these tragedies now. The IIJA directed U.S. DOT to issue a Final Rule within two years requiring all new passenger motor vehicles weighing less than 10,000 pounds to be equipped with a system to alert the operator to check rear-designated seating positions after the vehicle engine or motor is deactivated by the operator. The U.S. DOT has not taken regulatory action and should issue a Final Rule which requires the system to detect occupants in the entire passenger compartment rather than rely on reminder systems which are less effective. Of note, Euro New Car Assessment Program (NCAP) added testing of child detection systems in 2023 (protocol), and from 2025 onwards will only be assigning points for direct sensing systems.\95\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \94\ Kids and Car Safety, Hot Cars, available at: https:// www.kidsandcars.org/hot-cars/media-resources \95\ See: https://www.euroncap.com/media/79888/euro-ncap-cpd-test- and-assessment-protocol-v12.pdf --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ADS-Equipped Vehicles and Commercial Motor Vehicles (CMVs) Must be Subject to Federal Regulations to Ensure Public Safety Autonomous driving technology has made advances yet remains unable to consistently operate safely with all road users, conditions and scenarios, as evidenced by fatal and serious crashes involving passenger motor vehicles equipped with ADS of varying levels.\96\ Transparency and robustness in crash and incident data reporting involving vehicles equipped with ADS are critical to the safety of public roads, the management of cities in which they are operating, and for researchers and related industries as well as the U.S. DOT as it considers regulatory proposals. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \96\ NHTSA, Standing General Order 2021-01 (Aug. 2021). ADS Incident Report Data available here: https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/ffdd/ sgo-2021-01/SGO-2021-01_Incident_Reports_ADS.csv --------------------------------------------------------------------------- To identify a people-and-safety-first path forward on AVs, Advocates and numerous stakeholders developed the ``AV Tenets.'' \97\ These sound and sensible policy positions should be a foundational part of any national AV policy. The AV Tenets are based on expert analysis, real-world experience, and public opinion. They have four main categories including: 1) prioritizing safety of all road users; 2) guaranteeing accessibility and equity; 3) preserving consumer and worker rights; and, 4) ensuring local control and sustainable transportation. They are supported by a coalition of more than 65 organizations representing consumers, public health and safety experts, pedestrians, bicyclists, disability rights activists, emergency responders, law enforcement, labor and others. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \97\ See: https://saferoads.org/autonomous-vehicle-tenets/. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- While the AV Tenets were first established in 2020, the approach remains relevant today as progress in advancing key safeguards to ensure safety and the purported societal benefits of AVs has not been met. For example, requiring that AVs meet minimum performance standards, including a ``vision test'' to ensure the vehicle can respond to all people, vehicles and objects in the roadway environment, is essential. According to the recent opinion poll commissioned by Advocates, the public strongly backs specific Federal safeguards. The poll found 61 percent believe their concerns about AVs and ACMVs would be addressed if companies had to meet minimum government safety requirements, and 76 percent support a ``vision test.'' \98\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \98\ See: https://saferoads.org/2026-av-tech-truck-poll/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In addition, AV operations must be subject to adequate oversight, including a comprehensive database accessible by vehicle identification number (VIN) with basic safety information. The AV Safety Data Act (S. 3742), which has been referred to the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, would improve incident reporting for vehicles equipped with an ADS and should be advanced. Advocates' recent poll found that nearly 80 percent want to require AV manufacturers to report details of crashes that cause injury or property damage to the U.S. DOT. The Stay in Your Lane Act (S.3536), currently pending before the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, requires each manufacturer of an ADS to submit a declaration to NHTSA that details the conditions or the operational design domain (ODD) under which the ADS is designed to function safely.\99\ According to Advocates' opinion poll. 74 percent of respondents support requiring AV manufacturers to disclose the conditions in which their driverless vehicles can safely operate and ensure the vehicles do not operate outside those limits.\100\ We urge that this vital legislation be advanced. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \99\ The Stay in Your Lane Act, S. 3536, 119 Cong. Sec. 1 (2025). \100\ Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Similarly, it is imperative that ACMVs be subject to comprehensive safety regulations, including having a driver with a commercial driver license (CDL) and any relevant current or new accreditations behind the wheel for the foreseeable future. The interest in expanding the use of this technology must not be used as a pretext to eviscerate essential safety regulations administered by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), and particularly in the absence of new standards to ensure the technology performs safely and as needed. The public safety protections provided by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs) have become no less important or applicable simply because a CMV has been equipped with an ADS. In fact, there are additional substantial public safety concerns presented by ACMVs. Lastly, remote drivers and remote assistants for AVs and ACMVs will undoubtedly face unique challenges in giving instruction or operating a vehicle compared to a driver located in the vehicle. For instance, a human driver behind the wheel may have access to a broader range of details regarding the driving environment than someone located in a sterile office far from the actual location of the AV or ACMV. In fact, during the Committee's February 4, 2026 hearing, Waymo revealed it had remote personnel in the Philippines.\101\ Individuals in these roles must be given specific training for remote operations or assistance. In addition, these individuals should have significant experience operating both a motor vehicle or CMV on public roads and remote operation of AVs or ACMVs in realistic training scenarios. Moreover, remote operators or assistants must never be in a situation where they would even potentially have to oversee the ``real time'' operation of more than one AV or ACMV. According to Advocates' recent opinion poll, 79 percent of respondents agree there should be safety standards for remote personnel who provide guidance to driverless vehicles.\102\ It is essential that Congress address these remote personnel issues and require minimum standards in any AV or ACMV legislation. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \101\ Hit the Road, Mac: The Future of Self-Driving Cars: Hearing before the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, 119 Cong. (Feb. 4, 2026). \102\ See: https://saferoads.org/2026-av-tech-truck-poll/ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Conclusion Our Nation can and must do more to address the deadly and dangerous public health crisis on our roadways. Numerous pieces of legislation and additional proven solutions to advance safety, which have been mentioned in this letter, should be included in the next surface transportation reauthorization bill. Additionally, it is essential that proper protections, minimum safety standards, comprehensive data collection and thorough oversight of AVs and ACMVs be advanced to ensure the myriad of promises offered by their proponents are realized. Thank you for your consideration of these issues. We look forward to working with you to decrease motor vehicle and CMV crashes, save lives, reduce injuries and lessen associated costs. Sincerely, Catherine Chase, President. cc: Members of the Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Transport Workers Union of America June 9, 2026 Hon. Todd Young, Chair, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation. Hon. Gary Peters, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Surface Transportation, Freight, Pipelines, and Safety, U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation. Statement for the Record: Hearing on ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances are driving Transportation Innovation'', June 9, 2026 Dear Chair Young and Ranking Member Peters, On behalf of more than 165,000 members of the Transport Workers Union of America (TWU), I offer the below state for the record as part of the above hearing. TWU members include transit operators and mechanics, railroad car and brake inspectors, onboard service workers, bikeshare workers, and others whose economic and physical well-being are dependent on the successful implementation of new, pro-safety, pro- worker technologies. Workers must be involved to successfully implement new technologies Frontline transportation workers are the people ultimately responsible for executing safety standards. They are the individuals with the clearest view of what works in every transportation system and have the expertise needed to successfully transition to new technologies. These skills apply to both developing standards at DOT, where workers' voices should be proactively included in all advisory committees, and at individual employers, where workers should have a direct say on which technologies are implemented locally. This philosophy applies to every section of our comments below. Enforceable Federal rules on autonomous vehicles are urgently needed Under our current regulatory structure, safety standards on autonomous vehicles (AVs) are in free fall. A patchwork of inadequate and dangerously lenient state laws is encouraging a race to the bottom, and a complacent Federal government has allowed far too many risks into the system. Several times a week, new videos become available of AVs driving through police cordons, freezing in the middle of fire fights, ignoring school bus stop signals, and engaging in other unsafe activities. As more AVs have been deployed, the situation has not gotten better, rather the dangers they pose have become more widespread. With no realistic minimum safety standard in place and with more AV developers entering the market as time goes on, it would be naive to expect any safety improvements across the system without Federal intervention. Establishing a Federal safety standard, enforced by each of the appropriate modal agencies at the Department of Transportation, will ensure that AVs meet our safety expectations before they are deployed onto our streets. It is long past time that the Federal government acknowledge its responsibility for these vehicles in the same manner it does for traditional cars, trucks, and buses. While much of the public conversation around AVs has centered around robotaxis, development of autonomous trucking and buses has continued at the same pace. New deployments of these vehicles in Texas, Florida, and elsewhere emphasize the urgent need to set minimum, Federal standards for large freight and passenger vehicles. Commercial vehicle operations are governed by a combination of FMCSA, FTA, and state level rules. While NHTSA's role overseeing the manufacture of these vehicles is also essential to establishing safety standards, any rule siloed within NHTSA's authority will have a limited effect on AV safety. Additionally, as we have seen in other industries, financial resources flow towards the least regulated market. Any Federal AV framework limited to personal vehicles will redirect investment towards commercial vehicles, increasing the dangers of these larger, more complex operations. Today's workers in public transportation, motorcoach, trucking, and other commercial vehicle operations are highly qualified professionals. These professions are licensed under Federal guidelines, subject to Federal drug & alcohol testing, and must continually meet the highest safety standards to maintain their jobs. The most essential component of transportation safety is well-trained, qualified workers professionally conducting their duties. AVs, just like every other piece of equipment, will malfunction. The hardware and the software of these vehicles will break down. When this happens, humans must have the ability to intervene to prevent disaster. These are not theoretical concerns in our transportation systems. In two crashes in 2019 and 2020, automated systems on the Boeing 737- MAX aircraft overrode human commands after failing to correctly respond to the environment, crashing at full speed and killing 346 people. In 2009, 9 people were killed, including the operator, on the Washington, DC Metro's Red Line when the positive train control system ignored the operator's command to brake and accelerated into a parked train just north of the U.S. Capitol. In both instances, had humans been allowed to intervene the crashes would have been avoided. In addition to the obvious safety benefits of allowing human oversight and intervention in automated systems, AV developers must face a practical matter that many commercial vehicles will continue to require humans onboard even if they are not expected to operate their vehicle. Public transportation systems are obligated to provide services for the disabled community. Tour bus operators and other service companies may continue to want humans present to provide the services they do today for paying customers. In these cases, disallowing workers from accessing the controls to these vehicles would effectively hold them hostage at their job sites. These workers would be trapped, entirely at the mercy of their employer and the competency of the automated system. It seems obvious that such situations should be prohibited. The TWU does not believe that all vehicles must forever utilize the same methods of control present on our current fleets. We believe that equipment will change as safety improvements are developed. Certified operators will be able to work with any system to safely navigate our roads, provided the technology enables them to oversee and intervene as the workers deem necessary. Rail technologies require the same scrutiny as other modes Class 1 railroads are required to have railcars and brakes inspected by a qualified person prior to departure. The FRA has recently allowed these inspections, under limited circumstances, to be conducted using an ``inspection portal''--a series of well-positioned cameras networked together and operated by an artificial intelligence program. The program analyzes the images to assess brake conditions, freight car alignment, spacing between cars, and over a hundred other factors that have historically been tested by humans. The TWU has endorsed the use of these portals provided that FRA certified car and brake inspectors 1) participate in the development of the technology and 2) review and approve the results of each inspection. The TWU supports pro-safety and pro-worker technology like these portals. In fact, technological solutions like this emphasize the need for human oversight. The brake inspection portal enables immediate review of rolling stock by qualified individuals while allowing compliant trains to move without interruption. This approach stands in stark contrast to a recent proposal from the FRA (known as the ``Brakes III'' rulemaking), which would simply extend the amount of miles traveled in between required inspections. The Brakes III approach is effectively the Federal government closing it's eyes and pretending problems it doesn't see don't exist. Especially given that technological options like the brake inspection portal exist, options that empower workers and increase safety, it is deeply concerning that the FRA would consider this kind of non-standard. Additionally, we are deeply concerned about the potential for autonomous train operations. In 2024 Georgia Central Railway and Heart of Georgia Railroad asked the FRA to exempt one line from several safety requirements so the railroad could demonstrate autonomous rail technology manufactured by Parallel Systems. The TWU opposed this petition because it eliminated human oversight across the entire line, including essential pre-trip railcar and break inspections. The TWU has a history of supporting technological transitions, provided these technologies demonstrate their ability to increase safety and create good jobs in the U.S. To date, Autonomous Rail developers are failing on both of these measures as they demand broad exemptions from FRA regulations while cutting the rail workforce. FRA does not currently have the necessary authorities and practices to successfully implement performance-based regulations Performance-based regulation, when implemented properly, is not just a buzz word. Allowing regulated entities to demonstrate compliance with safety goals, rather than solely safety processes can deliver positive results when the regulator has the necessary tools to oversee those goals. The FRA, today, does not have either the authority or the capacity to oversee such a system. Aviation is the example proponents usually reach for as the FAA pairs performance targets with layers of independent verification, mandatory incident reporting systems that are shielded from enforcement retaliation, and a safety culture that was built over decades of prescriptive regulation that remains in place underneath. Even in aviation, performance-based approaches supplement prescriptive rules-- they do not replace them. The freight rail industry has none of those conditions. It is dominated by a handful of Class I carriers that control the infrastructure, the equipment, the operations, and-- critically--the data. There is no independent third-party verification of carrier safety models. The FRA's inspection force is a fraction of what would be needed to audit the kind of self-compliance frameworks that performance-based regulation invites. And the consequences of failure are not confined to the regulated entity--a derailment involving hazardous materials threatens entire communities that have no voice in the carrier's internal risk model and no ability to evacuate on the timeline a chemical release demands. If Congress believes the FRA should transition towards more performance based rules, we believe the building blocks around these rules ought to be in place first. Empowering the FRA to independently collect and verify railroad safety data, removing railroads' ability to obfuscate or deny safety requests, and bolstering the powers of Federal rail inspectors are all immediate policy changes that would begin setting up the agency for a more goal-oriented approach. Digital infrastructure should expand job opportunities under existing Federal protections Federal investment in infrastructure comes with a number of essential protections to ensure funds are not undermining local labor or safety standards. These requirements have been an integral part of our Federal programs since their inception. Digital tools must be subject to the same requirements and expectations to ensure infrastructure dollars are creating and sustaining good jobs across the country. Digital infrastructure tools will also come with their own, unique set of concerns. New methods of planning, evaluating, and overseeing infrastructure ought to be tested in their own right prior to widespread deployment. In cases where these new tools present novel environments or may otherwise create unanticipated issues, there may be a need for additional, clarifying statutes to ensure existing standards on the ground persist. The TWU believes digital infrastructure can be an important aspect of our Federal infrastructure program as long as it is used to increase jobs and safety. Thank you for organizing this hearing and for the opportunity to comment. Sincerely, John Samuelsen, International President. CC: The Honorable Ted Cruz The Honorable Maria Cantwell ______ Transportation Communications Union (TCU/IAM) June 9, 2026 Hon. Ted Cruz, Chairman, Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, United States Senate, Washington, DC. Hon. Maria Cantwell, Ranking Member, Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, United States Senate, Washington, DC. Dear Chairman Cruz and Ranking Member Cantwell: As the National President of the Transportation Communications Union (TCU/IAM), I am submitting a statement for the record for the June 6, 2026 hearing, ``The Need for Speed: How Technological Advances are Driving Transportation Innovation'' held by the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation Subcommittee. I am submitting for the record the policy statement unanimously approved by the 39 affiliated unions of the Transportation Trades Department, AFL-CIO on June 7, 2026, opposing the Federal Railroad Administration's proposed rule in Docket No. FRA-2019-0072, commonly referred to as ``Brakes III''. Sincerely, Matt Hollis, National President, Transportation Communications Union (TCU/IAM). ______ Transportation Labor Opposes the Brakes III Rulemaking and Calls on the FRA to Withdraw Its Proposal to Weaken Railcar Inspection Standards Transportation labor strongly opposes the Federal Railroad Administration's (FRA) proposed rule in Docket No. FRA-2019-0072, commonly referred to as ``Brakes III,'' which would extend required freight car brake inspection intervals from every 1,500 miles to every 2,500 miles for railroads that adopt an electronic air brake slip (eABS) system.\1\ If finalized, this rule would undermine the safety of the Nation's freight rail system. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ https://www.regulations.gov/document/FRA-2019-0072-0005 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Railroad Carmen, represented by the Brotherhood of Railway Carmen Division (BRC-TCU) and the Transport Workers Union (TWU), are the federally Qualified Mechanical Inspectors (QMIs) who perform hands-on inspections of freight cars at terminals and yards. Carmen physically examine brake systems, wheels, bearings, safety appliances, and other mechanical components to ensure equipment is safe and compliant with Federal regulations. They are the last line of defense between a defective freight car and the communities through which it travels. The most critical fact about Brakes III is what it does NOT require. In exchange for extending inspection intervals by 1,000 miles, the rule requires no technology that actually inspects brakes or detects defects--no sensors, no monitors, no automated systems. The only requirement is that railroads switch from a paper air brake slip to an electronic one: a paperwork format change. The eABS does not change the science behind brake system degradation and cannot detect the emerging defects that only a trained QMI Carman can identify through physical inspection. The impact extends far beyond brakes. Federal regulations under 49 CFR Part 215, covering safety standards for wheels, bearings, and structural components, do not have their own mileage-based inspection requirement. The Part 232 brake inspection is the only regulatory trigger that puts the eyes of a qualified Carman on railcar. Extending that interval eliminates the only regular opportunity to inspect for the mechanical defects that cause approximately one third of all derailments--including defects like the wheel bearing that failed at East Palestine, Ohio. Real-world data confirms QMI Carmen are irreplaceable. BNSF's Brake Health Effectiveness (BHE) test waiver trains are one of only two active programs operating at extended intervals--but critically, the BHE waiver for BNSF requires the railroad to install and maintain wheel temperature detector networks along the route, with data forwarded to QMI Carmen to better-improve their inspections and repair efforts. Even under these conditions--with detector infrastructure and Carmen still in the loop--the data shows that QMI Carmen find nearly eight times more brake defects than the automated systems alone (5,027 findings versus 654), and that is just for brakes, which cover only 10 percent of items inspected under Sections 215, 231, and 232. Brakes III, by contrast, would require none of this. No detectors, no detector data forwarding to Carmen, no safety infrastructure of any kind--just a paperwork change. If the results are this concerning under a waiver that actually requires technology and Carmen involvement, extending these intervals to all freight trains with no requirements whatsoever is unconscionable and reckless. At 2,500 miles, trains could travel coast to coast without a single hands-on inspection, enabling railroads to eliminate Carmen positions across the heartland of the country and jeopardize the safety and security of countless communities. Rail labor stands in unison vehemently opposing the adoption of this rule because--unsurprisingly-- locomotive engineers and conductors have significant and justified safety concerns when asked to operate trains in Ohio that were last inspected in Los Angeles. We therefore call on the FRA to take no further action on the Brakes III rule. Technology should assist QMI Carmen to improve rail safety and prevent derailments. To do otherwise is a disservice to the communities that host railroad tracks and the workers who keep those railroads safe. Policy Statement No. S26-06 *ADOPTED 6.7.26* ______ Research Article Cost-benefit analysis of side underride guards for new semitrailers in the United States Eric Hein\1\,* --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Institute for Safer Trucking, United States of America \*\ Corresponding author: ewh161@gmail.com --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Abstract: In the United States, the severe consequences of side underride crashes are well documented, yet no Federal regulation requires side underride guards on semitrailers. Side underride guards can prevent vehicle underride and protect cyclists and pedestrians. This paper develops a decision support framework using a cost-benefit analysis to evaluate a potential Federal requirement for side underride guards on new semitrailers. Annually, side underride crashes result in an estimated 300 fatalities and 400 serious injuries, costing society $7.4 billion. To estimate how side guards could reduce these losses, the analysis models paired full-fleet reductions of 50/50, 100/100, and 150/150 (fatalities and serious injuries), then scales impacts to one annual production cohort of 221,000 new semitrailers. Present value is calculated over the 13.2-year service life at a 2 percent discount rate using costs of $1,500, $2,500, and $4,500 per semitrailer, and includes fuel economy adjustments from weight and, where applicable, integration with aerodynamic skirts. Present value net benefits range from $0.137 billion to $2.8 billion. Scenarios that included fuel-saving skirts yielded additional savings of approximately 500 gallons per semitrailer annually (5.2 metric tons of CO2), adding $4.9 billion in fuel and $3.3 billion in CO2 benefits. Monte Carlo simulations for the $2,500 guard plus skirt configuration estimated mean present value net benefits of $0.58 billion ($0.39 to $0.77 billion) for the 50/50 case, $1.71 billion ($1.35 to $2.11 billion) for the 100/100 case, and $2.84 billion ($2.30 to $3.45 billion) for the 150/150 case. Modeled net benefits were positive in all iterations. Results indicate that a Federal requirement for side underride guards on new semitrailers would produce positive economic and safety effects and meet conditions identified by NHTSA and industry for side underride guard rulemaking. The analysis can be applied in other jurisdictions using local crash, cost, and fleet data. One sentence summary: This cost-benefit analysis evaluates a potential Federal requirement for side underride guards on new U.S. semitrailers, estimates positive safety and economic benefits, and presents a framework that can be applied in other jurisdictions. Keywords: Aerodynamic side skirt, Cost-benefit analysis, Federal safety standard, Regulatory analysis, Semitrailer, Side underride guard Publishing history: Submitted: 21 November 2025; Revised: 13 February 2026, 5 March 2026; Accepted: 5 March 2026; Published: 15 May 2026 Cite as: Hein, E. (2026). Cost-benefit analysis of side underride guards for new semitrailers in the United States. Journal of Progress in Safety and Security, 2. https://doi.org/10.59490/pss.2.2026.8512 ______ 1 Introduction In 1967, actress Jayne Mansfield was killed in a rear underride crash when her car collided with, and slid beneath, the rear of a semitrailer. In response, the Federal Highway Administration proposed a regulation requiring rear underride guards on semitrailers to prevent passenger vehicles from underriding, and indicated that a similar requirement for side underride protection would soon follow (Federal Highway Administration, 1969). The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) was created in 1970 and assumed rulemaking responsibility for the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT). In 1971, under pressure from the trucking industry, NHTSA formally withdrew the proposed rule for rear underride guards (Morris, 1971; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1971; Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, 1969). A Federal safety standard requiring rear underride guards on semitrailers was not finalized until 1996, with a 1998 effective date, yet Federal regulators have never proposed side underride guards (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1996; Thompson et al., 2023a; Thompson et al., 2023b). Side underride crashes occur when a passenger vehicle collides with the side of a semitrailer and slides beneath it. Due to the height mismatch, the passenger vehicle's crumple zones and airbags often fail to engage, frequently resulting in death or severe injuries to the occupants (Government Accountability Office, 2019; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a; Mattos et al., 2021; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018a; Thompson, et al., 2023a; Thompson et al., 2023b). These crashes bypass the vehicle's primary safety features because the point of impact is often the windshield rather than the front bumper, causing the passenger compartment to be frequently crushed when it contacts the semitrailer (Government Accountability Office, 2019; Mattos et al., 2021; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018a). Approximately 200 passenger vehicle occupants die each year from side underride crashes with semitrailers (Braver et al., 1997; Brumbelow, 2012; Hein, 2025; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2017c, 2023a; National Transportation Safety Board, 2014; Padmanaban, 2013). In 1977, the Highway Safety Research Institute at the University of Michigan (Minahan & J. O'Day, 1977) estimated that 195 side underride fatalities occurred each year. Simply put, over the last 45 years the annual number of fatalities from passenger vehicle side underride crashes with semitrailers has remained essentially unchanged. Over the last 50 years, this public health burden has resulted in nearly 9,000 fatalities (Hein, 2025). Vulnerable road users (VRUs), including pedestrians, bicyclists, and motorcyclists, are also at risk of traveling under, and being crushed and killed or seriously injured by semitrailers that lack side guards (Epstein, 2022; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a). Between 2019 and 2021, an average of 99 pedestrian fatalities, 22 bicyclist fatalities, and 187 motorcyclist fatalities occurred each year in crashes where the initial point of impact was the side of a large commercial truck (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2025b). Of these, there are an estimated 100 VRU side underride crash fatalities annually (Epstein, 2022; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2025b; National Transportation Safety Board, 2013). While side underride guards are specifically intended to prevent passenger vehicles from sliding beneath a semitrailer, the addition of an aerodynamic side skirt could further mitigate fatalities and serious injuries among VRUs by reducing, and in some configurations blocking, the space beneath the semitrailer (Badgley et al., 2020; Epstein, 2022; Epstein et al., 2014; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a; Kiefer, 2023c; Kwan et al., 2019; Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Volpe, 2021). For example, in Mexico, semitrailers are required to install pedestrian guards, which can be a slightly modified aerodynamic side skirt (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024; Hightman, 2024, 38:48). Additionally, in 1996 Strick designed a similar side guard for pedestrians, cyclists, and motorcyclists for use on semitrailers that were exported to Europe (Strick Trailers, LLC, 2022). By integrating side underride guards with aerodynamic skirts (Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2024b; Wilson, 2017), the system can also reduce aerodynamic drag to save fuel, one of the largest operating costs in long-haul trucking (Galipeau-Belair, 2014; Galipeau-Belair et al., 2014; North American Council for Freight Efficiency, 2020). This study develops a decision support framework and applies it in a cost-benefit analysis of a potential Federal safety standard requiring side underride guards on new U.S. semitrailers. By substituting jurisdiction-specific crash, cost, and fleet data, the framework can be replicated and adapted to inform regulatory decision- making. 2 Background Side underride guards, usually constructed from steel frames or cable/nylon webbing, are affixed to the sides of semitrailers (Airflow Deflector, 2024; Collision Safety Consulting, 2021; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2024b; Wilson, 2017). Functionally, side guards can help engage passenger-vehicle safety features (Mattos et al., 2021) and can shield passenger vehicles and VRUs from traveling beneath a semitrailer (Badgley et al., 2020; Epstein, 2022; Epstein et al., 2014; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a; Kiefer, 2023c; Kwan et al., 2019; Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Volpe, 2021). Research, crash tests, and simulations consistently demonstrate that side underride guards can prevent or substantially limit passenger vehicles from underriding semitrailers, a critical factor in reducing fatalities and serious injuries (Brumbelow, 2012; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2017a, 2017b; Kiefer, 2023a, 2023b, 2023d; Kumar et al., 2009; Mattos et al., 2021; Moradi, 2012; Seven Hills Engineering LLC, 2018, 2020; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022b, 2023b, 2024b; Wilson, 2017). Most side underride crashes occur at impact speeds between 30 and 50 mph (Bloch & Schmutzler, 1998; Minahan & J. O'Day, 1977). Crash tests and simulations at impact angles between 90 and 15 degrees indicate that side underride guards can attenuate at 35 to 40 mph crashes, with some simulations demonstrating protection up to 50 mph (Bodapati, 2006; Brumbelow, 2012; Castaneda et al., 2012; Galipeau- Belair, 2014; Galipeau-Belair et al., 2014; Hernando, 2021; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2017a, 2017b; Kiefer, 2023a, 2023d; Kumar et al., 2009; Mattos et al., 2021; Moradi, 2012; Seven Hills Engineering LLC, 2018; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022b, 2023b; Wilson, 2017). Nearly 80 percent of fatalities (966 of 1,415) from side underride crashes recorded in NHTSA's Fatality Analysis Reporting System between 2007 and 2020 occurred on Interstates, U.S. Highways, or State Highways (Hein, 2024). On these roadways, passenger vehicles average 60.1 mph and combination trucks/semitrailers average 57.3 mph, a speed difference of 2.8 mph (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018b). NHTSA and the National Center for Statistics and Analysis (NCSA) estimated that side underride guards would be 97 percent effective in reducing fatalities and 85 percent effective in reducing serious injuries (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023). Together, the roadway context and these estimates provide a useful benchmark for the effectiveness assumptions used in the modeled scenarios. Most major U.S. semitrailer manufacturers hold side underride guard patents (Great Dane LLC, 2021; Jaworski & Montiel Rosales, 2024; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2023a; Vanguard National Trailer Corporation, 2019; Giromini et al., 2012; Ehrlich et al., 2020; Kunkel et al., 2021). The industry has also drafted guidance addressing design, testing, and performance considerations for side underride guards (Stoughton, 2022b; Strick Trailers, LLC, 2022; Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, 2021). Several manufacturers have conducted crash tests of side underride guard designs (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2017a, 2017b; Stoughton, 2020, 2022b; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022b, 2023b, 2024b; Wilson, 2017). One manufacturer has factory-installed side underride guards on nearly 70 semitrailers, with sufficient ground clearance to prevent high- centering (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024; Bennett, 2023, 01:36:25; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2023a, 2024b). Side underride guards are also available as aftermarket safety options (Airflow Deflector, 2024; Collision Safety Consulting, 2021; Fortier, 2025), including at least one designed to safeguard VRUs (Fortier, 2019, 2025). In addition, one commercially deployed design (Angelwing) has logged more than 1 million road miles without compromising semitrailer integrity or operational performance (Airflow Deflector, 2024). Prior research documents crash mechanics and side guard effectiveness, yet it does not provide a regulatory cost-benefit framework that integrates safety performance, injury valuation, fuel effects, and annual semitrailer production, nor does it report explicit injury-based break-even thresholds for side underride guard adoption. 2.1 Institutional resistance and regulatory failure The NHTSA Administrator has statutory authority under the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966, as amended, to issue and enforce motor vehicle safety standards that reduce crashes, fatalities, and injuries (49 U.S. Code Sec. 30101; 49 CFR 1.95). NHTSA's mission is to save lives, prevent injuries, and reduce economic costs due to road traffic crashes (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2025c). Nevertheless, NHTSA has not advanced any rulemaking on side underride protection (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024; Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Thompson et al., 2023a; Thompson et al., 2023b), which is inconsistent with its statutory authority and safety mission. In addition, NHTSA has not acted on a recent congressional report (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024), including crash test data (Galipeau-Belair, 2014; Hernando, 2021; Hyundai Translead, 2022; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2017a, 2017b; Kiefer, 2023a, 2023b, 2023c, 2023d; Mattos et al., 2021; Moradi, 2012; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018a; Seven Hills Engineering LLC, 2018; Stoughton, 2020, 2022b; Thompson et al., 2023a, 2023b; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022a, 2022b, 2023b, 2024b; Wilson, 2017), decades of research (Hein, 2023b; Mattos et al., 2021), and recommendations from the National Transportation Safety Board (National Transportation Safety Board, 1971, 2014, 2023), as well as denied or delayed administrative petitions (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1979, 2014, 2022a, 2025a). Even when Congress mandated that NHTSA assess the feasibility, benefits, and costs of side underride guards on newly-manufactured semitrailers (Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, Pub. L. No. 117- 58, 135 Stat. 429, 2021), the resulting published Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023) was widely criticized for methodological flaws, including the exclusion of safety benefits for VRUs (Braver 2023; Chicago Department of Transportation, 2023; City of Boston Transportation Cabinet, 2023; Consumer Reports, 2023; Hein, 2023a; Institute for Safer Trucking & Road Safe America, 2023; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a, 2023b, 2024; National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, 2023; National Transportation Safety Board, 2023; Seven Hills Engineering LLC, 2023; Truck Safety Coalition et al., 2023). Furthermore, an ANPRM is not a proposed rule or final rule under the Administrative Procedure Act, but a discretionary Federal Register notice used to solicit information for possible future rulemaking (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2022). NHTSA has not prioritized side underride guards, and its review of public comments on the ANPRM remains incomplete more than three years after publication (Office of Management and Budget, 2025). In the ANPRM, NHTSA did not address the Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association's draft Recommended Practice, submitted to the agency by semitrailer manufacturers (Stoughton, 2022b; Strick Trailers, LLC, 2022; Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, 2021). The cost-benefit analysis (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023) also omitted relevant data from Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, the only major semitrailer manufacturer publicly offering side underride guards (Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022a, 2022b, 2023b, 2024b). Furthermore, the NCSA analysis (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023) inflated annual semitrailer production by nearly 20 percent (Trailer Body Builders, 2021, 2023, 2025) and utilized the obsolete 2020 Value of a Statistical Life (VSL), rather than the contemporaneous 2023 VSL (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2025). Collectively, these choices in the NCSA cost-benefit analysis distorted the results and substantially underestimated the annual economic benefits of side underride protection. Perhaps most concerning, neither NHTSA's ANPRM (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023) nor the NCSA's cost-benefit analysis (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023) underwent peer review as required by the Office of Management and Budget (Office of Management and Budget, 2005, 2023). The analyses also failed to comply with a Presidential Memorandum directing agencies to use the best available science and data for policy decisions (Executive Office of the President, 2021), and disregarded the USDOT's recent scientific integrity policy (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2024a). Peer review serves as a critical check on agency assumptions and helps ensure policy decisions are evidence-based. Failure to follow these published procedures raises serious concerns about the objectivity of the regulatory and cost-benefit analyses. NHTSA's failure to follow established USDOT directives on scientific integrity (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2024a) is compounded by a persistent pattern of unsupported conclusions that side underride guards would be too costly. For example, in a regulatory analysis concerning rear underride guards, NHTSA stated, without providing evidence, that side underride guards were ``not cost effective'' (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1991). A 2021 Freedom of Information Act request confirmed that the agency held no data, analysis, or records to support this assertion (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2022b). Despite this, NCSA's cost-benefit analysis for the ANPRM claimed that ``a similar regulation (for side underride guards) had been considered in 1991 during the preliminary regulatory evaluation for rear underride guards; at that time side underride guards were found not to be cost-effective'' (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023). This claim is not supported by the agency's record. NHTSA has never proposed a regulation for side underride guards (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024), nor has it produced any records or documentation supporting the 1991 assertion that side guards were ``not cost effective'' (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1991, 2022b). In the absence of Federal regulations, the trucking industry has long demonstrated reluctance to adopt side underride guards for widespread deployment, typically citing costs and raising speculative claims of ``unintended consequences'' (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024; American Trucking Associations, 2019; Government Accountability Office, 2019; Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, 2025a, 2025b; Sievers, 2020; Thompson et al., 2023a, 2023b; Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, 1969; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022a). In fact, resistance can be traced back to a 1969 comment that was filed opposing possible side underride protection requirements (Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, 1969). In the decades since, organized industry opposition to side underride guards has continued, with lobbying groups reiterating these objections in regulatory comments and Congressional testimony (Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, 2025a, 2025b). Investigative reporting has shown that such lobbying directly shaped USDOT's regulatory decisions, including a rejection of side guard requirements after meetings with industry representatives (Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Thompson et al., 2023b). Without a Federal mandate, semitrailer manufacturers are uncertain about future regulatory standards and, as a result, are reluctant to move forward with these safety devices (Government Accountability Office, 2019). Information from industry sources on side guard effectiveness has not been consistent. For example, Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company characterized the results of the same crash test differently across venues. In 2022, Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company reported to NHTSA that in a crash test of its side impact guard in which only 30 percent of the passenger vehicle's width overlapped the end of the guard, the ``instrumented dummy survived the impact'' (Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022a). In correspondence with a safety advocate, Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company described the results from the same crash test as ``Utility Trailer's SIG (side impact guard) prevented passenger-compartment intrusion without significant injury to the instrumented crash dummy'' (Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022c). By contrast, Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company stated in the recent congressional report that the side impact guard from the same crash test ``dramatically failed to prevent passenger-compartment intrusion'' (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024). These outwardly contradictory descriptions of the same crash test illustrate how industry representatives can selectively frame performance depending on regulatory or political context, or by emphasizing different criteria (occupant survival versus compartment intrusion). NHTSA's own Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, a federally chartered body established by Congress under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, Pub. L. No. 117-58, 135 Stat. 429, 2021), concluded in its congressional report that ``very little has changed regarding side underride guard advancements in the last 50 years, and no substantial progress has been made by USDOT to prevent these horrific crash fatalities and injuries'' (Advisory Committee on Underride Protection, 2024). This finding underscores decades of Federal regulatory inaction despite clear evidence of preventable harm. Accordingly, this study presents a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis of a prospective Federal rulemaking to require side underride guards on newly manufactured enclosed freight semitrailers, including dry vans and refrigerated models, in the United States. 3 Data and methodology 3.1 Vehicle population, cohort scaling, and service life assumptions In 2021, NHTSA's Office of Defects Investigation surveyed eight major U.S. semitrailer manufacturers. NHTSA concluded that these manufacturers represent nearly 100 percent of semitrailers that could be equipped with side underride guards, and it reported an in-service population of 2.45 million van (box) type semitrailers (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2022a). This estimate is consistent with industry segment statistics indicating more than 2 million dry van trailers in operation (ACT Research, 2026). The analysis scales full-fleet annual safety benefits to one annual production cohort of new semitrailers using the average annual U.S. production estimate of 221,000 units (Trailer Body Builders, 2021, 2023, 2025). Safety effectiveness is defined as paired annual reductions of 50 (low), 100 (medium), or 150 (high) fatalities and serious injuries per year under full-fleet adoption. The annual new- trailer cohort share is calculated as annual new production divided by the estimated in-service van-type semitrailer population, 221,000/ 2,450,000 = 0.090204, or approximately 9.02 percent. Annual fatalities and serious injuries prevented for one year of new semitrailers are calculated as the cohort share multiplied by the assumed full-fleet annual safety benefits. This single cohort and scaling approach mirrors the method used in NHTSA's NCSA cost-benefit analysis of side impact guards (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023). That analysis estimates mitigated fatalities and serious injuries under full-fleet adoption and scales the results to one year of new semitrailers using the new- production share of the fleet. For lifetime impacts, the average semitrailer service life is estimated at 13.2 years (American Transportation Research Institute, 2025). Semitrailers are assumed to be used at a constant rate until retirement, and side underride guards are assumed to maintain safety benefits over the full service life. The analysis converts annual benefits and annual operating cost effects using a lifetime present value adjustment factor (PVAF), defined as the sum of the annual discount factors over the 13.2-year service life with 2 percent discounting (PVAF = 11.5) (Office of Management and Budget, 2023). This present value approach does not model fleet turnover as older equipment is retired and replaced. It aligns with methodology that applies discounted lifetime impacts to calculate safety benefits and costs, including installation and any fuel adjustment effects, across the service life of semitrailers (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023). The analysis systematically varies key parameters and reports results in a consistent format. This structured sensitivity framework evaluates defined combinations of assumptions, including paired impacts in fatalities and serious injuries prevented, alternative unit guard costs, and modeled fuel adjustment cases, and reports present value net benefits for each scenario. Parameter values are drawn from peer- reviewed literature, Federal regulatory documents, and industry information. The analysis supports replication and updates as new data become available. 3.2 Baseline fatalities and serious injuries In the United States, side underride crashes are estimated to cause approximately 300 fatalities per year, including both vehicle occupants and VRUs (Braver et al., 1997, 1998; Brumbelow, 2012; Hein, 2025; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a, 2023b, 2025; National Transportation Safety Board, 2013, 2014; Padmanaban, 2013). Serious injuries are estimated at approximately 400 per year (Braver et al., 1997; National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023; National Transportation Safety Board, 2013). The baseline for this analysis represents the current state of practice, in which there is no Federal regulatory standard requiring side underride guards on new semitrailers. Industry resistance to voluntary adoption of side underride guards (Government Accountability Office, 2019; Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Thompson et al., 2023a, 2023b) reinforces the assumption that crash rates are expected to remain largely unchanged in the absence of Federal regulation. The annual societal cost of these crashes is calculated using USDOT's $13.7 million VSL for fatalities (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2025) and FMCSA's $8.12 million valuation of Maximum Abbreviated Injury Scale Level 5 (MAIS5) for serious nonfatal injuries (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 2024). 3.3 Safety effectiveness of side underride guards Crash test evidence and published evaluations indicate that side underride guards are effective in preventing passenger vehicles and VRUs from traveling beneath semitrailers (Galipeau-Belair, 2014; Hernando, 2021; Hyundai Translead, 2022; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2017a, 2017b; Kiefer, 2023a, 2023b, 2023c, 2023d; Mattos et al., 2021; Moradi, 2012; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018a; Rechnitzer, 1993; Seven Hills Engineering LLC, 2018; Stoughton, 2020, 2022b; Mehrotra & Thompson, 2023; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022a, 2022b, 2023b, 2024b; Wilson, 2017). Side underride guards are expected to reduce fatalities and serious injuries, but the magnitude of these effects remains uncertain without widescale implementation. Safety effectiveness is defined as the annual number of fatalities and serious injuries prevented under full-fleet adoption, meaning the entire in-service van-type semitrailer fleet is equipped with side underride guards. To model a range of plausible outcomes, three safety- effectiveness scenarios were evaluated, reflecting paired annual reductions of 50 (low), 100 (moderate), or 150 (high) fatalities and serious injuries (Brumbelow, 2012; Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 2023a; National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023). These full-fleet annual benefits are scaled to one annual production cohort of new semitrailers using the cohort share method described in Section 3.1. 3.4 Unit cost The analysis uses three unit-cost estimates for side underride guards, reflecting variation in manufacturing origin and aerodynamic skirt integration. The aerodynamic side skirt is included only in the integrated cost cases and is modeled strictly as a fuel-savings effect, not as a change in the safety-effectiveness scenarios. Because aerodynamic skirts are already used on some new semitrailers, the integrated configurations are modeled to avoid an added fuel penalty rather than attribute incremental net fuel savings attributable to a side underride guard requirement. Each unit cost represents installation of a full side guard system on a trailer, including guards on both sides. The unit-cost cases are: a $1,500 installation representing mass-produced OEM side underride guards without aerodynamic skirts; a $2,500 installation representing OEM integrated side guards with aerodynamic skirts; and a $4,500 installation representing aftermarket integrated side guards with aerodynamic skirts (Airflow Deflector, 2024; Epstein, 2022; Government Accountability Office, 2019; National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; Seven Hills Engineering LLC, 2023; Strick Corporation, 2000). 3.5 Fuel economy Fuel consumption impacts associated with the additional weight of side underride guards were modeled using two configurations, a 500- pound guard-only and a 1,000-pound integrated guard with an aerodynamic skirt (Airflow Deflector, 2024; National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023). The added weight was represented as a reduction in fuel economy of 0.25 percent and 0.5 percent, respectively, applied as a proportional increase in gallons of diesel used relative to baseline (North American Council for Freight Efficiency, 2019, 2020). For configurations that included aerodynamic skirts, a conservative 5 percent improvement in fuel economy (North American Council for Freight Efficiency, 2020; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2024a) was applied as a proportional decrease in gallons of diesel used relative to baseline. In those integrated cases, the skirt effect is modeled to fully offset the weight-related increase in fuel consumption, resulting in no net fuel penalty. Because aerodynamic devices are already used on some new semitrailers, the skirt effect is treated as a configuration assumption in the integrated cases and is not intended to be attributed as incremental fuel savings caused by a Federal side underride guard requirement. The analysis used a baseline fuel economy of 7.4 mpg, an average combined truck and semitrailer weight of 63,000 pounds, an average annual mileage of 82,677 miles per semitrailer, and a diesel cost of $3.78 per gallon (American Transportation Research Institute, 2025; North American Council for Freight Efficiency, 2019, 2020; U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2025; Williams & D. Murray, 2020). Associated changes in CO2 emissions were calculated from the modeled change in annual diesel consumption, using 10.21 kg CO2 per gallon of diesel fuel (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2025) and reported as metric tons of CO2 per year. The estimated reductions in CO2 emissions were valued using $250 per metric ton (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2024b). Results are reported as annual per-semitrailer impacts, then scaled and discounted using the cohort share and present value methods described in Section 3.1. The model assumes the same baseline miles driven and no change in how semitrailers are used or purchased, and does not model changes in trailer demand, freight demand, pricing, or consumer or producer surplus. The modeled fuel economy effects reflect side guard weight and, where applicable, the aerodynamic skirt, and are reported as changes in annual fuel costs and associated CO2 emissions increases or reductions. 3.6 Analytical approach This analytical approach follows Federal regulatory impact guidance (Office of Management and Budget, 2023), aligns with methodological standards established by the USDOT (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2024b), and mirrors the cost-benefit approach used in NHTSA's side underride ANPRM and NCSA cost-benefit analysis (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023). Benefits are monetized using USDOT's current VSL (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2025) and FMCSA's MAIS5 valuation for serious nonfatal injuries (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 2024). Benefits and costs were estimated and reported in U.S. dollars (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; U.S. Department of Transportation, 2024b). Present value net benefits were calculated as monetized safety benefits minus installation and operating costs (Table 1). Table 1. Formulas for present value benefits and costs, fuel economy adjustments, and break-even thresholds for a potential side underride guard standard.* ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Equation Formula ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Annual Baseline Societal (Annual Number of Fatalities x VSL) + Cost (Annual Number (Current State, No of Serious Injuries x MAIS5) Standard) Cohort Share Annual Number of New Semitrailers Manufactured / In-Service Semitrailer Population Annual Cohort Fatalities Full-Fleet Fatalities Prevented x Cohort Prevented (Scaled) Share Annual Cohort Serious Full-Fleet Serious Injuries Prevented x Injuries Cohort Share Prevented (Scaled) Lifetime Present Value (1 - (1 + Discount Rate)-(-service life in Adjustment years)) Factor (PVAF) / Discount Rate Annual Cohort Safety (Annual Cohort Fatalities Prevented x VSL) Benefits + (Annual Cohort Serious Injuries Prevented + MAIS5) Present Value Safety Annual Cohort Safety Benefits x PVAF Benefits Cohort Installation Cost Annual Number of New Semitrailers Manufactured x Unit Cost of Side Underride Guard (per Semitrailer) Adjusted Fuel Economy Baseline mpg of a Loaded Combination Truck (mpg), and Semitrailer Guard Weight Only (500 lb x (1 - Fuel Penalty Rate) or 1,000 lb) Additional Gallons per (Baseline miles / Adjusted mpg) - (Baseline Semitrailer miles / per Year Baseline mpg) Annual Cohort Fuel Penalty Annual Number of New Semitrailers Cost Manufactured x Additional Gallons per Semitrailer per Year x Diesel Price Present Value Fuel Penalty Annual Cohort Fuel Penalty Cost x PVAF Cost Present Value Total Costs Cohort Installation Cost + Present Value (Installation + Fuel Fuel Penalty Cost Penalty Cost) Adjusted Fuel Economy (Baseline mpg x (1 - Fuel Penalty Rate)) / (mpg), (1 - Guard Weight Plus Aerodynamic Fuel Savings Rate) Aerodynamic Skirt Benefit (Integrated Case) Break-Even Analysis (Net Present Value of Total Costs / ((VSL + Benefits MAIS5) x Cohort = 0, Paired Fatalities and Share x PVAF) Serious Injuries) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ *A supplementary Excel workbook contains the calculations for Table 1. 3.7 Uncertainty analysis Uncertainty in present value net benefit estimates was quantified using Monte Carlo simulation, focusing on two sources: crash applicability and guard effectiveness. The probabilistic analysis is applied only to the $2,500 guard plus skirt configuration, which is treated as the implementation baseline, while the $1,500 and $4,500 configurations are evaluated as deterministic alternative scenarios. Effectiveness is represented as paired annual lives saved and serious injuries prevented under three full-fleet cases (50/50, 100/100, and 150/150). In this framework, overall safety effectiveness is represented as the product of crash applicability and guard effectiveness. Crash applicability represents uncertainty in the number of side underride crashes that a side guard could realistically affect, given the inclusion decisions for higher speed crashes, multi-vehicle collisions, and VRUs. For example, the impact speed data NHTSA used to determine which crashes to include in the side underride estimates are subject to substantial uncertainty (Government Accountability Office, 2019; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2013, 2026). Despite research by NHTSA and others showing side underride guard effectiveness up to 50 mph (Bodapati, 2006; Galipeau-Belair, 2014; Mattos et al., 2021; Moradi, 2012; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018a), the ANPRM excluded side underride crashes above 40 mph, those involving more than one passenger vehicle, and all VRU crashes (National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 2023; National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2023). Guard effectiveness represents uncertainty in guard performance. Both components are modeled using triangular distributions with a mode of 1.0 and bounds of 15 percent. The side underride guard market remains immature, with only one manufacturer currently offering an OEM-installed system and only a small number of aftermarket offerings. As a result, real-world deployment and performance data remain limited, and triangular distributions were selected to provide a bounded, transparent representation of that uncertainty. The 15 percent bounds were chosen because a 10 percent range would likely understate the plausible variation, while a 25 percent range would extend beyond what the current evidence base can support. The multipliers are used only to improve interpretability and are not intended to imply that crash applicability and guard effectiveness are separately estimated from data or that separating these components adds robustness relative to using a single overall effectiveness factor. In each simulation iteration, the same combined multiplier is applied to both lives saved and serious injuries prevented, so the two outcomes rise and fall together. Each iteration converts simulated full-fleet annual safety outcomes to cohort impacts using the cohort share method described in Section 3.1. Monetized annual safety benefits are calculated by applying USDOT's VSL to fatalities prevented and FMCSA's MAIS5 valuation to serious injuries prevented. Annual benefits are converted to lifetime present value using the same discount rate, service life, and PVAF applied in the base model. Present value net benefits in the Monte Carlo analysis are calculated as present value safety benefits minus the present value cost of the $2,500 guard plus skirt configuration. This configuration is used as the implementation baseline because it reflects an OEM guard and skirt package, avoids a fuel penalty, and provides a practical baseline for testing uncertainty. The analysis does not attribute incremental fuel savings to a Federal side underride guard requirement, because aerodynamic devices may already be present on new semitrailers or adopted independently of side guards. Simulation results are summarized using the simulated mean and the 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles (95 percent uncertainty interval). Retrofit and maintenance requirements are not modeled because the analysis focuses on OEM installation on new semitrailers, and empirical data on side guard maintenance and repair are sparse. 3.8 Break-even analysis A break-even benchmark was calculated to estimate the annual full- fleet equivalent safety benefit required for monetized safety benefits to equal total costs in the lifetime present value model. The primary benchmark assumes paired impacts, the same number of fatalities prevented and serious injuries prevented. Total costs include side underride guard installation and, where applicable, the fuel consumption adjustment attributable to the added guard weight. Annual safety impacts are scaled and discounted using the cohort share and present value methods described in Section 3.1. This benchmark identifies the annual full-fleet equivalent safety impact that marks the threshold where net benefits equal zero (break-even). In addition, a fatalities-only break-even threshold was calculated by solving for the number of fatalities required for benefits to equal costs excluding serious injury benefits. Different combinations of fatalities and serious injuries prevented can produce the same break-even outcome (net benefits equal to zero) because the Value of a Statistical Life is about 1.7 times the MAIS5 valuation (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 2024; U.S. Department of Transportation, 2025). All calculations and the Monte Carlo implementation, including cell level formulas, are provided in supplementary Excel workbooks to support replication. 4 Results and Discussion 4.1 Economic analysis Annually, side underride crashes of passenger vehicles and VRUs into semitrailers that lack side underride guards result in an estimated 300 fatalities and 400 serious injuries, imposing an estimated baseline societal cost of $7.4 billion. This baseline reflects the status quo in the absence of Federal regulation and underscores the economic burden of regulatory inaction. Without quantifying these ongoing losses, the public and policymakers may misinterpret the ``No Action'' alternative as cost-neutral, distorting an accurate comparison of regulatory options. In all modeled cases, the present value net safety benefits of equipping new semitrailers\1\ with side underride guards exceed the associated costs (Table 2). Under the scenario of preventing 50 fatalities and preventing 50 serious injuries annually, with a $1,500 unit cost and a 500-pound fuel adjustment, the estimated present value net economic benefit is $0.531 billion (Table 2). Even under conservative assumptions, net benefits remain positive. For example, under the same safety scenario with a $4,500 integrated guard plus skirts unit cost, the estimated present value net economic benefit is $0.137 billion (Table 2). In the higher-effectiveness scenario of preventing 150 fatalities and preventing 150 serious injuries annually, with a $2,500 integrated guard plus skirts unit cost, the analysis yields an estimated present value net economic benefit of $2.8 billion (Table 2). Overall, these results indicate that a Federal regulatory standard requiring side underride guards is cost-effective under a broad range of modeled assumptions. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ For context, using representative purchase prices (e.g., Commercial Truck Trader, 2025) for a 53-foot dry-van semitrailer ($45,000) and a 53-foot refrigerated semitrailer ($90,000), the modeled unit costs correspond to an incremental purchase cost of approximately 3.3 percent, 5.6 percent, and 10.0 percent for a dry van and 1.7 percent, 2.8 percent, and 5.0 percent for a refrigerated semitrailer. Table 2. Present value results for side underride guard scenarios by safety effectiveness and unit cost, including fuel and CO2 effects where applicable.\2\ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PV Fuel Cost PV Skirt Fuel Scenario PV Safety PV Installation Adjustment ($B) PV Net Economic Savings ($B) Benefits ($B) Costs ($B) (CO2, $B) Benefit ($B) (CO2, $B) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Prevent 50 Deaths $1.132 $0.332 $0.269 ($0.182) $0.531 N/A + 50 Serious Injuries, $1,500 SUG only + 500 lb Fuel Penalty Prevent 50 Deaths $1.132 $0.553 N/A $0.579 $4.855 ($3.278) + 50 Serious Injuries, $2,500 Integrated SUG + Skirts (No Net Fuel Penalty) Prevent 50 Deaths $1.132 $0.995 N/A $0.137 $4.855 ($3.278) + 50 Serious Injuries, $4,500 Integrated SUG + Skirts (No Net Fuel Penalty) Prevent 100 $2.264 $0.332 $0.269 ($0.182) $1.663 N/A Deaths + 100 Serious Injuries, $1,500 SUG only + 500 lb Fuel Penalty Prevent 100 $2.264 $0.553 N/A $1.711 $4.855 ($3.278) Deaths + 100 Serious Injuries, $2,500 Integrated SUG + Skirts (No Net Fuel Penalty) Prevent 100 $2.264 $0.995 N/A $1.269 $4.855 ($3.278) Deaths + 100 Serious Injuries, $4,500 Integrated SUG + Skirts (No Net Fuel Penalty) Prevent 150 $3.396 $0.332 $0.269 ($0.182) $2.795 N/A Deaths + 150 Serious Injuries, $1,500 SUG only + 500 lb Fuel Penalty Prevent 150 $3.396 $0.553 N/A $2.843 $4.855 ($3.278) Deaths + 150 Serious Injuries, $2,500 Integrated SUG + Skirts (No Net Fuel Penalty) Prevent 150 $3.396 $0.995 N/A $2.401 $4.855 ($3.278) Deaths + 150 Serious Injuries, $4,500 Integrated SUG + Skirts (No Net Fuel Penalty) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2 Note. PV = present value. Dollar values are reported in $ billions (B). Values in parentheses report the monetized CO2 change associated with the fuel change for transparency only and are not included in Present Value Net Economic Benefit. ``N/A'' indicates no fuel penalty is applied in the integrated guard plus skirts configurations. Fuel savings and CO2 values depend on skirt inclusion and are identical across safety- effectiveness scenarios. 4.2 Uncertainty analysis For the $2,500 guard plus skirts configuration, Monte Carlo simulations show that present value net benefits were positive in all iterations. Based on 10,000 simulations per case, mean present value net benefits were $0.58 billion (95 percent uncertainty interval, 2.5th to 97.5th percentiles: $0.39 billion to $0.77 billion), $1.71 billion ($1.35 billion to $2.11 billion), and $2.84 billion ($2.30 billion to $3.45 billion) for the 50/50, 100/100, and 150/150 effectiveness cases, respectively. 4.3 Break-even threshold Break-even thresholds were modest relative to the modeled effectiveness cases. Under the paired benchmark, with equal annual reductions in fatalities and serious injuries, the break-even annual fleetwide equivalent threshold is approximately 27 for the $1,500 guard-only case (including the 500 lb fuel adjustment), 24 for the $2,500 guard plus skirts case, and 44 for the $4,500 guard plus skirts case.\3\ Under the fatalities-only benchmark, which excludes serious injury benefits, the break-even annual fleetwide equivalent thresholds are approximately 42, 39, and 70 fatalities prevented for the $1,500, $2,500, and $4,500 cases, respectively. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ Calculations are available in the supplementary Excel workbook. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4.4 Fuel efficiency and operational cost Integrating aerodynamic skirts with side underride guards can yield substantial diesel fuel savings. Even with an added 1,000 lb configuration, a modest 5 percent improvement in fuel efficiency would raise average fuel economy to 7.75 miles per gallon and reduce diesel use by 505 gallons (5.2 metric tons of CO2) per semitrailer per year. Scaled to the average annual number of new semitrailers manufactured, this equals 111.7 million gallons (1.1 million metric tons of CO2) saved per year. At a diesel price of $3.78 per gallon, this corresponds to about $1,910 in annual fuel savings per semitrailer. Over the service life in the present value model, the associated fuel savings are about $4.9 billion, with about $3.3 billion in monetized CO2 benefits (Table 2). In contrast, the fuel adjustment associated with the added weight of side underride guards is comparatively minor. A 500 lb guard is estimated to increase fuel consumption by 28 gallons (0.29 metric tons of CO2) per semitrailer per year, or about $105 in added annual fuel cost, while a 1,000 lb configuration results in an additional 56 gallons (0.57 metric tons of CO2), or about $212 in added annual fuel cost. These penalties are far smaller than the potential aerodynamic benefits when side underride guards are combined with fuel-saving skirts. 4.5 Limitations Costs are borne primarily by fleet operators, since manufacturers would likely pass these expenses through to trailer pricing, while benefits accrue more broadly to society through reduced mortality and severe injury burden. Although the results support the economic feasibility of a Federal mandate for side underride guards on new semitrailers, regulatory rulemaking would still need to develop a performance standard, a compliance test method, an implementation timeline, and enforceable requirements that can be applied consistently across manufacturers and equipment configurations. Similar to the engineering improvements of rear underride guards (Stoughton, 2022a), a Federal regulatory standard requiring side underride guards would undoubtedly prompt the development of alternative designs and innovations in reducing the weight of side guards while maintaining or improving safety effectiveness. The weight of side underride guards was modeled using 500 lb and 1,000 lb; however, other braided cable, nylon webbing, or aluminum side guard designs are available (Fontaine Commercial Trailer Inc., 2021; Fortier, 2019; Kiefer, 2018; Vanguard National Trailer Corporation, 2019; Giromini et al., 2012). In fact, NHTSA estimated that an effective side underride guard constructed of aluminum would weigh approximately 215 pounds (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2018a). Annual economic benefits should be considered minimum estimates because they do not incorporate additional benefits to the trucking industry including reduced legal liability (Manins, 2024; Sievers, 2020), reductions in insurance premiums (Kwan et al., 2019), and less risk exposure for drivers including potential criminal consequences in severe crashes (Nespral, 2025; Walsh, 2021). These issues are all outside the scope of the present research. 5 Conclusion and recommendations This study applies the USDOT valuation framework and NCSA cohort- scaling methods under transparent, testable assumptions to monetize the safety benefits of side underride guards and compare those benefits with compliance costs, informing the regulatory assessment of a potential Federal standard for new semitrailers. This approach is transferable to other contexts and countries for regulatory appraisal of side underride guards. Analysts can estimate benefits, costs, and break-even thresholds by substituting jurisdiction-specific inputs, including injury valuations, fleet production volumes, unit costs, and safety effectiveness. The structure also supports sensitivity testing to compare alternative parameter sets and to document the robustness of results for policy review. In every modeled scenario, preventing 50 to 150 fatalities and comparable numbers of serious injuries produces positive present value net economic benefits. Estimated net benefits range from $0.137 billion to $2.8 billion and consistently exceed the combined costs of side underride guard installation and the fuel penalty attributable to added weight. Successful crash tests, research, evaluations, and initial deployments, including Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company's integration of nearly 70 semitrailers and AngelWing's demonstrated durability, show that the technology is viable in practice. These data, together with NHTSA's statement that ``If the evidence gathered by the agency indicates that side underride rulemaking could contribute significantly to safety, the agency will commence rulemaking'' (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1979) support moving forward with a Federal side underride guard standard. The Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association and Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company have stated that they would support side underride guards ``if they ever become economically justified and technologically feasible'' (Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, 2023; Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company, 2022a). Collectively, the conditions identified by NHTSA, the Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association, and Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company have been met in the modeled cases presented in this study. These findings can also inform current legislative proposals in the United States concerning side underride protection requirements for new semitrailers (S. 3775, 119th Cong., 2026; H.R. 7354, 119th Cong., 2026). CRediT authorship contribution statement Eric Hein: Conceptualization, methodology, investigation, data curation, formal analysis, validation, writing of the original draft, review, and editing. The author has read and approved the final version of the manuscript. Data availability The calculations supporting this article are provided in supplementary Excel workbooks available on the article landing page at the same DOI link as this paper. The workbooks include the calculations underlying Table 1, present value benefit and cost estimates, fuel economy adjustments, break-even thresholds, and the Monte Carlo simulation used to quantify uncertainty in present value net benefit estimates. Use of AI The entire manuscript was developed by the author through original thinking, research, and writing. After drafting the manuscript, the author used ChatGPT only to help refine wording and improve clarity, and to cross-check calculations. The author takes full responsibility for the content of the published article. Declaration of competing interests There are no conflicts of interest. References ACT Research (n.d.) Trailer market demand & economic drivers in the U.S. https://www .actresearch.net/resources/us-freight-sector/trailer-demand-and- economic-activity Advisory Committee on Underride Protection. (2024). Biennial report to congress and the secretary of the advisory committee on underride protection. https://gsa-geo.my.salesforce.com/sfc/ p/t0000000Gyj0/a/3d000003BoqP/ CheZ62qtuZkvoirBzMr8CRKuWPwUiGcsyEJj35ggdog Airflow Deflector. (2024). Side underride guards for semi-trailers. https://airflowdeflector .com/angelwing_underride-1/ American Transportation Research Institute. (2025). An Analysis of the operational costs of trucking: 2025 update. https:// truckingresearch.org/ wp-content/uploads/2025/07/ATRI-Opera tional-Costs-of-Trucking-07-2025.pdf American Trucking Associations. (2019). Testimony: Hearing on Under Pressure: The State of Trucking in America. https://www.trucking.org/ sites/default/files/2020-01/SpearWrittenTesti monyHighwaysTransit61219Hearing.pdf Badgley, J., A. Breck, M. Dawes, A.K. Epstein, K. Welty, A. McNally, & S. Peirce. (2020). A Literature review of lateral protection devices on trucks intended for reducing pedestrian and cyclist fatalities. Department of Transportation. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/49250 Bennett, J. (2023, May 25). NHTSA virtual meeting advisory committee on underride protection [Video]. Zoom https:// usdot.zoomgov.com/rec/play/BGqXUFeD4MpVacV6ZnClFiEN-kJd PIRKrgMh3- 0roqieS_L6QfsWJtzW7QsgEkWEo9VbV1J32o2C24OC.JHWAkwyyUmDyMIOE?auto play=true Bloch, B., and L. O. F. Schmutzler. (1998). Improved crashworthy designs for truck underride guards. 16th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles, 98-S4-O-07. https:// sites.fem.unicamp.br/impact/conference.html Bodapati, V. K. K. (2006). Evaluation of energy absorbing pliers underride guards for rear and side of large trucks (Master's thesis, Wichita State University). http://hdl.handle.net/10057/617 Braver, E.R., E.L Mitter, A.K. Lund, M.X. Cammisa, M.R. Powell, & N. Early. (1998). A photograph-based study of the incidence of fatal truck underride crashes in Indiana. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 30(2), 235-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0001-4575(97)00079-1 Braver, E.R., M.X. Cammisa, A.K. Lund, N. Early, E.L. Mitter, & M.R. Powell. (1997). Incidence of large truck-passenger vehicle underride crashes in fatal accident reporting system and national accident sampling system. Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 1595(1), 27-33. https://doi.org/10.3141/ 1595-05 Braver E.R. (2023, July 20). Comments: Side underride guards; advance notice of proposed rulemaking Regulations.gov. https:// www.regulations.gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2044 Brumbelow, M. L. (2012). Potential benefits of underride guards in large truck side crashes. Traffic Injury Prevention, 13(6), 592-599. https://doi.org/10.1080/15389588.2012.666595 Castaneda, R., Jones, W., Shattuck, M., Mills, D., et al., (2012). Trailer side underride crash testing: Relating collision damage to impact speed. SAE Technical Papers. https://doi.org/10.4271/2012-01- 0614 Chicago Department of Transportation. (2023). Comments on the advanced notice of proposed rulemaking side underride guards on trailers and semitrailers. Docket No. NHTSA-2023-0012. https:// downloads.regulations.gov/NHTSA-2023-0012-2041/attachment_1.pdf City of Boston Transportation Cabinet. (2023). Comments on Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking for Side Underride Guards NHTSA-2023- 0012-0003. https://downloads.regu lations.gov/NHTSA-2023-0012-2042/attachment_1.pdf Collision Safety Consulting. (2021). SafetySkirt. https:// www.trailerguards.com/safetyskirt Commercial Truck Trader. (2025). Commercial Truck Trader. https:// www.commercialtruck trader.com/ Consumer Reports. (2023). Comments of Consumer Reports to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on the Request for Comments: Side Underride Guards Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Docket No. NHTSA-2023-0012. https://downloads.regulations.gov/NHTSA- 2023-0012-2072/attachment_1.pdf Ehrlich et al., (2020). Side underride guard (Patent U.S. 10,549,797 B2). U.S. Patent https:// patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/5f/09/8a/90de159b7d4d6e/ US10946824.pdf Epstein, A. K. (2022). Lateral protective devices (side guards) and vulnerable road users safety [Slides]. https://www.volpe.dot.gov/sites/volpe.dot.gov/files/ 2023-01/Volpe_BCIRPU_ LPD_slides.pdf Epstein, A. K., Peirce, S., Breck, A., Cooper, C., & Segev, E. (2014). Truck sideguards for Vision Zero: review and technical recommendations for Safe Fleet Transition Plan pilot deployment. John A. Volpe National Transportation Systems Center (U.S.). https:// rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/12164 Executive Office of the President. (2021). Presidential Memorandum: Restoring Trust in Government Through Scientific Integrity and Evidence-Based Policymaking. Federal Register, 86(26), 8845-8851. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2021-02-10/pdf/2021-02839.pdf Federal Highway Administration. (1969). Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Rear Underride Protection; Trailers and Trucks with Gross Vehicle Weight Rating Over 10,000 Pounds. Federal Register, 34(53), 5383-5384. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1969-03-19/pdf/FR- 1969-03-19.pdf Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. (2024). Crash Cost Methodology. https://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/sites/fmcsa.dot.gov/files/2024- 12/FMC-PRE-240812-001-Federal%20Motor %20Carrier%20Safety%20Administraction%20Crash%20Cost%20Methdology%20Repo rt-2024 _0.pdf Fontaine Commercial Trailer Inc. (2021). Side underride guard assembly for a trailer (Patent U.S. 11,713,013 B2). https:// patents.justia.com/patent/20220009436 Fortier. P. H. (2019). Side protection device for a vehicle, related kit and vehicle provided with the same (Patent U.S. 10,343, 636 B2). https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/27/4b/50/ 9c2dbe1e1cc865/US10343636.pdf Fortier. (2025). Road safety and efficiency; Lateral Protection, FLEXIGUARD-FRT: Ultra flexible for maximum protection and savings. Flexiguard FRT. https://flexiguardfrt.com/en/lateral-protection/ Galipeau-Belair, P. (2014). Design and development of side underride protection devices (SUPD) for heavy vehicles. [Master's thesis, University of Ontario Institute of Technology]. https:// hdl.handle.net/10155/416 Galipeau-Belair, P., S. Ghantae, D. Critchley, S. Ramachandra, & M. El-Gindy. (2014). Optimized rigid side underride protection device designs for tractor-trailers and straight trucks. SAE Technical Papers, 1, 1-12. https://www.sae.org/publications/technical-papers/content/ 2014-01-0565/ Giromini et al., (2012). Side underride cable system for a trailer (Patent U.S. 8,162.384 B2). U.S. Patent https:// patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/e3/70/8a/9a822ae04da651/US81623 84.pdf Government Accountability Office. (2019). Truck Underride Guards: Improved Data Collection, Inspections, and Research Needed (GAO-19- 264). https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-19-264 Great Dane LLC. (2021). Underride guard assembly for trailers (Patent U.S. 2021/0309176 A1). U.S. Patent Office. https:// patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/83/ee/90/2e4d340effcd37/ US20210309176A1.pdf Hein, E. (2023a). ANPRM Comments to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on the Advance notice of proposed rulemaking; side underride guards. https://www.regulations .gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2055 Hein, E. (2023b). Comment to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on the Advance notice of proposed rulemaking; side underride guards; Underride Literature. https://www.regulations.gov/ comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2055 Hein, E. (2024). Analyzing Side Underride Crashes and Fatalities: An Examination Using Data from the Fatality Analysis Reporting System for the Years 2007 to 2020. https://www.regulations.gov/comment/NHTSA- 2023-0012-2087 Hein, E. (2025). The estimated number of side underride, rear underride, and front override crashes and fatalities over the last 50 years. https://www.regulations.gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2095 Hernando, D. V., Lacruz, D. F., Herrer, L. C., Littago, H. M., Luque, P., & Mantaras, D. A. (2021). Numerical simulation of a semitrailer's lateral protection system against car frontal crash. Transportation Research Procedia, 58: 238-245. https://doi.org/10.1016/ j.trpro.2021 .11.033 Hightman, J. (2024, April 30). NHTSA ACUP Meeting--Motions and Discussion, the Advisory Committee on Underride Protection (ACUP).[Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0jWRsGhTr4 H.R. 7354, 119th Cong. (2026). Stop Underrides Act 2.0. https:// www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/7354/text Hyundai Translead. (2022). Request for information about defect petition (DP21-004). https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2021/INRD- DP21004-11525P1.pdf Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, Pub. L. No. 117-58, 135 Stat. 429 (2021). Congress.gov. https://www.congress.gov/117/plaws/ publ58/PLAW-117publ58.pdf Institute for Safer Trucking, & Road Safe America. (2023). Comments on the Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) on Side Underride Guards on Trailers and Semitrailers, Docket No. NHTSA-2023-0012. https://downloads.regulations.gov/NHTSA-2023-0012-2074/attachment_1.pdf Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2017a). 2009 Chevrolet Malibu Front-into-Trailer Side Underride Guard; 64.3 km/h. https:// annaleahmary.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/IIHS-Underride- Research-Crash-Dummy-Data.pdf Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2017b). 2010 Chevrolet Malibu Front-into-Trailer Side Underride Guard; 56 km/h. https:// drive.google.com/file/d/1BuUKKfBOjogLbswOAD HwlNFJeKF8dppR/view?usp=sharing Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2017c, August 29). Side guard on semitrailer prevents underride in 40 mph test. https:// www.iihs.org/news/detail/side-guard-on-semitrailer-prevents-underride- in-40-mph-test Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2023a). Comments on Side Underride Guards; Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. (Docket No. NHTSA-2023-0012). https://www.regu lations.gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-0092 Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2023b, June 23). NHTSA study underestimates benefits of side underride guards for trucks. https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/nhtsa-study-underestimates-benefits- of-side-underride-guards-for-trucks Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2024). Request for Correction of Information under the Information Quality Act. https:// downloads.regulations.gov/DOT-OST-2025-0033-0001/attachment_1.pdf Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. (2025). Fatality Facts 2023; Large trucks. https://www.iihs.org/research-areas/fatality- statistics/detail/large-trucks Jaworski, L. S., & Montiel Rosales, O. E. (2024). Side impact guard for trailers (Patent US20240174192 A1). https://patents.google.com/ patent/US20240174192A1/en Kiefer, A. (2018). Underride guards (Patent U.S. 9,908,493 B1). U.S. Patent. https://patent images.storage.googleapis.com/3e/de/56/9e46d9969c2fac/US9908493.pdf Kiefer, A. (2023a). Side underride guard crash test results. https://www.regulations.gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2079 Kiefer, A. (2023b, June 20). Crash testing of SafetySkirt performance by 35 mph t-bone collision. https://www.regulations.gov/ comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2065 Kiefer, A. (2023c, August 3). LPD+ crash test of a bicycle with fully-guarded trailer [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=HBtL9wPJwg0 Kiefer, A. (2023d, August 11). SafetySkirt SIG.R (Side Impact Guard Retrofit) Crash Test 2023, 43 mph T-Bone [Video]. Vimeo. https:// vimeo.com/853825849 Kumar, S., Enz, B., Ponder, P. L., & Anderson, B. (2009). Biomechanical analysis of protective countermeasures in underride motor vehicle accidents. Biomedical Sciences Instrumentation, 45, 89-94. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19369745/ Kunkel et al., (2021). Side underride guard (Patent U.S. 10,946,824 B2). U.S. Patent https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/e2/3a/3c/ ec27043950b888/US10549797.pdf Kwan, Q., Badgley, J., Breck, A., Dawes, M., Epstein, A. K., Welty, K., McNally, A., & Peirce, S. (2019). Truck side guards and skirts to reduce vulnerable road user fatalities: Final report on net benefits and recommendations. https://annaleahmary.com/wordpress/wp-content/up loads/2024/05/Cover-Sheet-Exhibit-B-combined.pdf Manins, R. (2024, February 25). $32.5M settlement after fatal crash that killed Army veteran. Atlanta Journal Constitution. Atlanta Journal-Constitution. https://www.ajc.com/news/atlan ta-news/325m-settlement-after-fatal-crash-that-killed-army-veteran/ CUBZS2IDVBG5XI4J3KFG P2VWKE/ Mattos, G., Friedman, K., Kiefer, A., & Ponder, P. (2021). Protecting passenger Vehicles from Side Underride with Heavy Trucks. SAE Technical Papers, 2021, 1-12. https://doi.org/10.4271/2021-01-0288 Mehrotra, K., & Thompson, A. C. (2023). DOT researchers suggested a way to make big trucks safer. After meeting with lobbyists, agency officials rejected the idea. Frontline. PBS. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/ frontline/article/department-transportation-truck-side-guards-trucking- lobbyists-safety/ Minahan, D. J., & O'Day, J. (1977). Car-truck fatal accidents in michigan and texas. HSRI Res Rev, 8(3). https://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/ bitstream/handle/2027.42/662/38204.0001.001 .pdf;jsessionid=4571CCF545C83E3128EA98BEEF03FB54?sequence=2 Moradi, R. (2012). Impact dynamics of mechanical systems and structures, and applications in crash energy management, impulse mitigation, and impact injury biomechanics [Dissertation, Wichita State University]. http://hdl.handle.net/10057/5363 Morris, J. D. (1971, July 19). Agency drops safety plan opposed by trucking men. The New York Times, 49. https://www.nytimes.com/1971/07/ 19/archives/agency-drops-safety-plan-opposed-by-trucking-men.html National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies. (2023). Side underride guards; Docket No. NHTSA-2023-001, Document Number: 2023- 0845. https://downloads.regulations.gov/ NHTSA-2023-0012-0096/ attachment_1.pdf National Center for Statistics and Analysis. (2023). Side impact guards for combination truck-trailers: Cost-Benefit analysis. Department of Transportation. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ Publication/813404 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (1971). Rear underride protection; termination of notice of proposed rule making. Federal Register, 36(118), 11750. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/ FR-197106-18/pdf/FR-1971-06-18.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (1979). Denial of petition for rulemaking. Federal Register, 44(186), 55077-55078. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1979-09-24/pdf/FR-1979-09-24.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (1991). Preliminary Regulatory Evaluation, Combination Truck and Rear Underride Guards. https://www.regulations.gov/document/NHTSA-1996-1684-0003 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (1996). Federal motor vehicle safety standards rear impact guards; Rear impact protection. Federal Register, 61(16), 2004-2036. https:// www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1996-01-24/pdf/96-682.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2013). Heavy- Vehicle Crash Data Collection and Analysis to Characterize Rear and Side Underride and Front Override in Fatal Truck Crashes. https:// www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.gov/files/811725.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2014). Federal motor vehicle safety standards; Rear impact guards, rear impact protection; Grant of petition for rulemaking; Still evaluating the petitioners' request to improve side guards. Federal Register, 79(132), 39362-39363. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2014-07-10/pdf/ 2014-16018.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2018a). Computer Modeling and Evaluation of Side Underride Protective Device Designs. https://www.nhtsa.gov/ sites/nhtsa.gov/files/documents/ 13611_supd_report_041118_v4-tag.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2018b). National Traffic Speeds Survey III: 2015. https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/ 35961/dot_35961_DS1.pdf National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2022a). Denial of motor vehicle defect petition, DP21-004. Federal Register, 87(127), 39899-39901. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/07/05/2022- 14165/denial-of-motor-vehicle-defect-petition-dp21-004 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2022b). Freedom of Information Act Request, ES21-000489. https://drive.google.com/file/d/ 1MkPh2YWl3TXi13C3Mv-1rjSg6wHyv_U7/view? usp=drive_link National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2023). Advanced notice of proposed rulemaking; side underride guards. Federal Register, 88(77), 24535-24543. https://www.federal register.gov/documents/2023/04/21/2023-08451/side-underride-guards National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2025a). Denial of motor vehicle defect petition, DP24-004. Federal Register, 90(61), 14409-14410. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/04/01/2025- 05561/denial-of-motor-vehicle-defect-petition-dp24-004 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2025b). Fatality Analysis Reporting System. Crash data report from a query of pedestrian, bicyclist, and motorcyclist deaths with the right or left side of a large truck. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1tToSan_GmIa9- DYFI337Pz6UuvBa _bya/view?usp=sharing National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2025c). NHTSA's Core Values. https://www.nhtsa.gov/about-nhtsa/nhtsas-core-values National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2026). Fatality analysis reporting system analytical user's manual, 1975-2024. https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/ Api/Public/Publication/813794 National Transportation Safety Board. (1971). Recommendation for NHTSA to consider adding side underride protection; H-71-042. https:// data.ntsb.gov/carol-main-public/sr-details/H-71-042 National Transportation Safety Board. (2013). Crashes involving single-unit trucks that resulted in injuries and deaths. https:// www.ntsb.gov/safety/safety-studies/Pages/SS1301.aspx National Transportation Safety Board. (2014). Safety recommendations; H-14-001 through -007. https://www.ntsb.gov/safety/ safety-recs/RecLetters/H-14-001-007.pdf National Transportation Safety Board. (2023). Comment on NHTSA's ANPRM side underride guards docket number NHTSA-2023-0012. https:// www.regulations.gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-0100 Nespral, B. (2025, August 23). Bond denied for truck driver accused of killing 3 in U-turn crash on Turnpike. NBC 6 Miami. https:// www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/bond-denied-for-truck-driver-accused-of- killing-3-in-u-turn-crash-on-turnpike/3681876/ North American Council for Freight Efficiency. (2019). 2019 Annual fleet fuel study. https://nacfe.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/NACFE- 2019-Annual-Fleet-Fuel-Study-Report-122919-FINALA.pdf North American Council for Freight Efficiency. (2020). Confidence report: Trailer aerodynamic devices. https://nacfe.org/wp-content/ uploads/2020/09/FullAeroTrailorConfidenceReport2020 .pdf Office of Management and Budget. (2005). Final information quality bulletin for peer review. Federal Register, 70(10), 2664-2677. https:// www.federalregister.gov/documents/2005/01/14/05-769/final-information- quality-bulletin-for-peer-review Office of Management and Budget. (2023). Circular A-4, regulatory analysis. https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/ 11/CircularA-4.pdf Office of Management and Budget. (2025). Side underride guards on trailers and semitrailers. https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/ eAgendaViewRule?pubId=202504&RIN=2127-AM54 Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association. (2025a). Testimony of Lewie Pugh, executive vice president owner-operator independent drivers association before the united states house of representatives, committee on transportation & infrastructure, subcommittee on highways & transit ``America Builds: How Trucking Supports American Communities''. https://transportation.house.gov/UploadedFiles/03-26- 2025_HT_Hearing_-_Lewie_Pugh_-_Testimony .pdf Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association. (2025b). Docket # DOT-OST-2025-0026, ``ensuring lawful regulation; reducing regulation and controlling regulatory costs''. https://downloads.regulations.gov/ DOT-OST-2025-0026-0901/attachment_1.pdf Padmanaban, J. (2013). Estimating side underride fatalities using field data. Annals of Advances in Automotive Medicine, 57, 225-232. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3861 811/pdf/ffile002.pdf Rechnitzer, G. (1993). Truck involved crash study: fatal and injury crashes of cars and other road users with the front and sides of heavy vehicles. https://www.monash.edu/data/assets/pdf_file/0020/216650/ muarc035.pdf S. 3775, 119th Cong. (2026). https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th- congress/senate-bill/3775/text Seven Hills Engineering LLC. (2018). Side Underride Guard 47.2 MPH Test Speed [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=QEHX7omUpuw Seven Hills Engineering LLC. (2020). Comments on docket number NHTSA 2015-0118 and GAO-19-264 Recommendation. https:// annaleahmary.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/2020-7-Hills- Engineering-Comments-to-NHTSA-Docket-2015-0118.pdf Seven Hills Engineering LLC. (2023). Comment on NHTSA's ANPRM side underride guards Docket Number NHTSA-2023-0012. https:// www.regulations.gov/comment/NHTSA-2023-0012-2050 Sievers, M. (2020). Hein v. Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company: Jury sends a message to trailer manufacturers about side underride. Journal of Trucking Litigation, Winter/Spring (2020), 3-9. https:// drive.google.com/file/d/1r-AG9GVTNYqs351YZA-i1x1JRxvD5yJl/view?usp =sharing Stoughton. (2020). Side Impact Guard Test. https:// static.nhtsa.gov/ odi/inv/2021/INRL-DP21004-11531.pdf Stoughton. (2022a). New Rear Underride Guard: Now the standard for dry vans; no additional cost. No additional weight. https:// www.stoughtontrailers.com/Portals/0/ documents/NEW%20Underride%202022.pdf?ver=2022-01-18-085406-390 Stoughton. (2022b). Response to defect petition, DP21-004. https:// static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2021/INRL-DP21004-11529P1.pdf Strick Corporation. (2000). Side guard cost estimates. Strick Corporation's supplemental response to Plantiff's demand for production of documents. Case No. VC048745. https://annaleahmary.com/wordpress/wp- content/uploads/2021/05/2000-Strick-Underride-Indermo dal-Guard-Design.pdf Strick Trailers, LLC. (2022). Response to defect petition, DP21- 004. https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2021/INRL-DP21004-11533.pdf Thompson, A. C., Hajj, K., & Schonder, G. (2023a, June 13). America's dangerous trucks [Video]. FRONTLINE and ProPublica. https:// www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/documentary/americas-dangerous-trucks/ Thompson, A. C., Mehrotra, K., & Ingram, J. (2023b). Trapped under trucks; how regulators failed to act to prevent underride crashes. FRONTLINE. PBS. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/trucks- underride-crashes-nhtsa-dot-iihs-safety-cars/ Trailer Body Builders. (2021). Comprehensive list of historical truck and trailer production figures. https://www.trailer- bodybuilders.com/trailer-output/article/21743538/comprehensive-list-of- historical-truck-and-trailer-production-figures Trailer Body Builders. (2023). Trailer output report: 2022. https:/ /www.trailer-body builders.com/trailer-output/article/21262072/trailer-output-report-2022 Trailer Body Builders. (2025, March 4). Trailer manufacturer output report 2024. https://www.trailer-bodybuilders.com/trailer-output/ article/55267500/trailer-output-report-2025 Truck Safety Coalition, Citizens for Reliable and Safe Highways, & Parents Against Tired Truckers. (2023). Side Underride Guards; DOT/ NHTSA # NHTSA-2023-0012. https://downloads.regulations.gov/NHTSA-2023- 0012-2040/attachment_1.pdf Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association. (1969). Letter to Federal highway safety bureau, Federal highway administration; opposition to rear underride protection; Docket No. 1-11. https://www.courts.mo.gov/ fv/c/Exhibit%208.PDF?courtCode=22&di=12775660 Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association. (2021). Draft recommended practice: Side impact guard. [Included in Stoughton Trailers, LLC, Side Impact Guard Test]. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2021/INRL-DP21004-11531.pdf Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association. (2023, June 6). Advanced notice of proposed rulemaking; Side underride guards [Docket No. NHTSA- 2023-0012]. https://downloads.regula tions.gov/NHTSA-2023-0012-0099/attachment_1.pdf U.S. Department of Transportation. (2022). Rulemaking Handbook. https://www.transpor tation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2022-05/2022-DOT-Reg-Handbook.pdf U.S. Department of Transportation. (2024a). Scientific integrity policy of the United States department of transportation. https:// web.archive.org/web/20250124034234/ https:/www.trans portation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2024-02/ DOT%20Scientific%20Integrity%20Policy%20Final% 20508.pdf U.S. Department of Transportation. (2024b). Benefit-cost analysis guidance for discretionary grant programs. https:// www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2024-11/Benefit%20Cost% 20Analysis%20Guidance%202025%20Update%20%28Final%29.pdf U.S. Department of Transportation. (2025). Departmental guidance on valuation of a statistical life in economic Analysis. https:// www.transportation.gov/office-policy/transportation-policy/revised- departmental-guidance-on-valuation-of-a-statistical-life-in-economic- analysis U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2025, June 25). This week in petroleum. https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/weekly/archive/2025/250625/ includes/hometables_print.php U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2025, January 15). Emission factors for greenhouse gas inventories (GHG Emission Factors Hub). https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2025-01/ghg-emission- factors-hub-2025.pdf Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2022a). Response to defect petition, DP21-004. https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2021/INRL-DP21004- 11074P1.pdf Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2022b). Side impact guard [SIG]; Sales sheet. https://www.utilitytrailer.com/wp-content/uploads/ Sales-Sheet-SIG-Side-Impact-Guard.pdf Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2022c). Utility trailer side impact guard tests. https://drive.google.com/file/d/ 1ogySPLGiM5DgP_gcFOy9KTUWvBpdlfGb/view?usp=sharing Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2023a). Side underride guards (Patent U.S. 11,691,583 B1). U.S. Patent https:// www.freepatentsonline.com/11691583.pdf Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2023b, October 19). Side underride guard/side impact guard crash tests [Video]. YouTube. https:/ /www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWRUMaUb4T0 Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2024a). Aerodynamic savings; fuel more profitability; make a positive impact on your bottom line by equipping your trailers with the utility side skirt. https:// www.utilitytrailer.com/aerodynamic-savings/ Utility Trailer Manufacturing Company. (2024b). Side underride guard makes an impact on safety. https://www.utilitytrailer.com/impact- guard/ Vanguard National Trailer Corporation. (2019). Strap underride guard (Patent U.S. 2019/0184925 A1). U.S. Patent https:// patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/3b/98/ee/bba021a50785 1b/US20190184925A1.pdf Volpe. (2021). Truck lateral protective device technical overview. https://www.volpe.dot.gov/sites/volpe.dot.gov/files/2021-04/ Truck_Lateral_Protective_Device_Technical_Overview.pdf Walsh, J. (2021, April 20). Trucker charged with manslaughter for crash that killed three Livermore teens. Danville San Ramon. https:// www.danvillesanramon.com/news/2021/04/20/trucker-charged-with- manslaughter-for-crash-that-killed-three-livermore-teens/ Williams, N., & Murray, D. (2020). An analysis of the operational costs of trucking: 2020 up-date. https://truckingresearch.org/wp- content/uploads/2020/11/ATRI-Operational-Cost-of-Trucking-2020- FINAL.pdf Wilson, C. (2017, September 29). Wabash prototype: Side underride guard with aero skirt. Trailer Body Builders, 1-3. https://www.trailer- bodybuilders.com/print/content/21742324 ______ [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ______ [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] ______ Response to Written Question Submitted by Hon. Ted Cruz to Ian Jefferies Question 1. In his written testimony, Mr. Scandaglia says the Teamsters support the use of automated track inspection, or ATI, as an ``additive tool to augment twice weekly track inspections,'' but not to replace these visual inspections. Please describe any safety benefits from using ATI to reduce the frequency of visual track inspections rather than having ATI supplement the current visual inspection regime, if applicable. Answer. Sustained railroad infrastructure investment and advancements in track safety--through technologies like automated track inspections (ATI), improved track components, and enhanced maintenance practices--have led to significant safety gains. In 2025, the freight rail industry cited improving safety metrics, most notably, derailments, equipment, and track-caused accidents as the lowest on record. ATI, also known as track geometry measurement systems (TGMS), incorporates key elements such as distance between rails, track alignment, elevation, and curvature to quickly identify and remediate potential track deficiencies. Using lasers and cameras mounted to locomotives or rail cars, ATI inspects track at speed as trains move across the network. This enables railroads to identify defects invisible to the human eye, assess track structural performance under the load of a train, and gather data that can be analyzed for patterns or warning signs. ATI technology also improves safety by reducing railroad track inspectors' exposure to risk along railroad right-of-way. Visual inspections are done by walking on and around the track or by hi-rail vehicles. FRA data show that slip and fall incidents are the highest source of employee injury. Hi-rail vehicle operations, particularly near highway-rail grade crossings, also pose significant hazards. ATI enables railroads to meet inspection mandates while also lowering risk to inspectors. Technological solutions are imperative to achieving an accident- free future. While not mutually exclusive, ATI technologies that track geometry conditions outperform mandated manual inspections, and railroads have years of data from pilot programs to demonstrate those safety improvements. The data is clear: blending ATI with reduced visual inspections increases rail safety and improves track health. Under the pilot program to test ATI's effectiveness, railroads found clear reductions in the number of derailments when ATI was used and manual inspections were reduced. Derailments dropped from 11 before the pilot program to three, two of which occurred when manual inspections were still occurring twice weekly and one of which occurred when ATI was inactive. Railroads also found fewer track defects over time, reflecting better track health when ATI is used. Combined, railroads found just under six defects for every 100 track miles inspected before the pilot program. After the pilot, railroads found 0.24 defects per 100 track miles inspected. The combination of manual inspections and ATI is important because TGMS and ATI are not designed to identify every defect, and manual inspections are still necessary to find problems like vegetation overgrowth, broken rails, or misplaced ballast, which can be identified by a manual inspection. While ATI can identify changes in geometry related to those defects, it won't see the defects itself. Providing railroads the flexibility to adjust the number of manual inspections when ATI is used improves safety and efficiency. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Bernie Moreno to Ian Jefferies Question 1. Hot box detectors have become an increasingly important part of the industry's safety framework, but no safety technology is infallible. a. What objective performance measures, including derailment rates, detector reliability, inspection effectiveness, and employee-reported defects, should be used to evaluate whether the combination of detector technology, equipment inspections, and frontline observations is effectively preventing equipment-related derailments? Answer. Wayside detection systems like hot bearing detectors (HBD) have been voluntarily used across the rail network for decades. The essential performance measure for HBDs and other wayside detectors like acoustic bearing detectors (ABDs) is the rate of bearing-caused accidents. If HBDs, ABDs, and other detectors are working effectively, it will be reflected in reduced bearing-related accidents and derailments. Generally, bearing-related and many other internal mechanical-component defects are not even capable of being detected via required manual visual inspections, but rather only by use of technologies the railroads have voluntarily implemented. The rate of train accidents caused by overheated bearings has dropped 68 percent from 2005 to 2025, and overall in 2025, the rate of equipment-caused accidents reached an all-time low. These improvements have been achieved through the railroads' layered use of technology- based detection systems and advanced computer-based trending analysis to identify bearings that may become a problem before they cause an incident. But wayside detection systems have been used for several decades, and Class I railroads are using even more innovative technology to identify equipment defects before they cause accidents. For example, railroads have deployed inspection portals equipped with state-of-the- art, ultra high-resolution cameras and stadium lighting to capture nearly 1,000 high-resolution, 360-degree images of each rail car as it passes through the portal at track speed. These images are analyzed using AI to identify defects that would be otherwise invisible to the naked eye allowing crews to fix them before the train leaves the yard. The future of reducing equipment-caused accidents lies not in wayside detection systems but in more advanced technology to identify and repair bearings before they reach those temperature thresholds. Question 2. Railroads are investing heavily in advanced signaling, automation, and digital systems. a. What objective indicators, such as workforce qualifications, training completion, vacancy rates, response times to system failures, and employee proficiency, should be used to determine whether workforce expertise and staffing levels are keeping pace with the increasing technological complexity of these systems? Answer. The essential performance measure for signal systems is the rate of mainline train accidents. If workforce qualifications, training completion, staffing levels, and technical expertise are keeping pace with increasingly sophisticated technologies, that should be reflected in the safe and reliable operation of signal systems. Signal-caused mainline accidents have averaged 2 per year over the past decade. This translates into less than 1 accident every 267 million mainline train miles. These results are driven by significant investments in proven technology. Railroads have invested heavily into Positive Train Control (PTC) systems and microprocessor-based and self- diagnostic system technology to better manage train movements and improve railroad safety. PTC is a critical safety technology that automatically monitors and can stop trains to prevent certain types of collisions and derailments. PTC's geo-mapping, advanced communications, and upgraded locomotives can help support greater capacity, better service, and lower emissions. At the same time, microprocessor-based and self-diagnostic technologies provide continuous monitoring of signal-system health. Unlike traditional inspection approaches that rely primarily on periodic visual inspections, these technologies provide real-time status information and early warning of degrading conditions. This enables railroads to identify and address issues before they result in equipment failures, improving both safety and reliability. Question 3. The committee discussed detectors, grade-crossing technologies, advanced signaling systems, and automation. All these technologies ultimately depend on skilled workers to install them, maintain them, interpret the information they generate, and respond when they fail. a. What evidence can the industry provide that workforce capacity, training, and technical expertise are growing at a rate sufficient to support the increasing complexity of these technologies? Answer. The strongest evidence that workforce capacity, training, and technical expertise are keeping pace with the industry's increasing use of advanced technologies is the industry's overall safety performance. If railroads lacked the workforce capability necessary to install, maintain, interpret, and respond to increasingly complex technologies, that would be expected to manifest itself in higher accident rates, greater system failures, or degraded safety performance. The rail industry assesses whether their workforce is effectively supporting technology deployment through operational and safety outcomes. Those outcomes demonstrate strong performance. Industry-wide derailment rates, track-caused accident rates, and equipment-caused accident rates reached historic lows in 2025. Likewise, the employee- on-duty injury rate was the second-lowest industry-wide and the lowest ever recorded for Class I railroads. Another important metric is employee retention, tenure, and collective bargaining. The 2025 National Collective Bargaining Round was the fastest in modern history with all unions and railroads participating in national bargaining reaching a five-year ratified agreement within 18 months, compared with the average of over 30 months in past rounds. That is evidence that railroaders who are actually on the ground working on the network are satisfied with compensation, health care coverage, leave policies, and work rules Class I railroads are negotiating. Moreover, railroad workers have a median tenure of 14 years in the industry, three times longer than the national average and with the Federal government as a distant second. As more technology is incorporated into railroad, workers are seeing their quality of life, predictability, and work improve. We are committed to keeping that momentum going. ______ Response to Written Question Submitted by Hon. Maria Cantwell to Ian Jefferies Federal Funding for Infrastructure and Technology: According to the American Society of Civil Engineers, cutting transportation funding below the level passed under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law could cost the average American family an estimated $700 a year. Question 1. The President's Budget request for next year would cut funding for DOT's rail programs by 85 percent. Do you think we need to continue funding rail infrastructure at the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law level in the next surface reauthorization? Answer. Class I railroads do not receive direct Federal funding and own, operate, and maintain their own infrastructure, reinvesting an average of $23 billion a year back into the railroad. Those private investments have made rail one of the safest modes of transportation in the country. However, the communities in which we operate and our public partners rely on Federal grant programs to repair and improve infrastructure projects in their states, towns, and regions, including rail projects. That funding can be critical to improve supply chain fluidity, safety, and efficiency, and railroads support robust infrastructure funding. Railroads are particularly supportive of programs like the Railroad Crossing Elimination (RCE) Program you championed, which provides the first dedicated funding for projects to separate grade crossings around the network. Grade crossings are the most dangerous point of any rail network because they are the only point on the railroad where the public and trains cross paths. These projects are large, expensive, and complicated, and dedicated, consistent funding through RCE is critical for communities to complete them. The additional funding for the Consolidated Rail Infrastructure and Safety Improvements (CRISI) program made by the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law was also instrumental in supporting short line and other railroads' investments to improve safety and efficiency. These improvements bolster the entire rail network. Maintaining robust CRISI funding going forward will improve safety outcomes and improve supply chain fluidity. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. John Hickenlooper to Ian Jefferies Automated Track Inspection (ATI) Colorado's mountainous terrain, steep grades, and extreme weather present unique safety challenges for freight rail. In the hearing, you discussed how automated track inspection (ATI) and artificial intelligence (AI) tools are helping to identify defects earlier than traditional visual methods. At the Transportation Technology Center (TTC) in Pueblo, Colorado, we have a world-class facility dedicated to testing innovative technology to improve rail safety. Question 1. Mr. Jefferies, given the environmental demands on our mountain corridors like the Moffat Tunnel, how is the railroad industry ensuring that AI algorithms for ATI are actually trained for extreme high-altitude terrain? Answer. The automated systems railroads use for ATI rely on track charts and inspection systems that contain all the necessary terrain information, including elevation and curvature as well as specific location information on infrastructure such as bridges, tunnels, switches, and others for the track section they will inspect. Algorithms are generated using the FRA's geometry requirements or, in most cases, the railroads' stricter geometry requirements to measure changes in geometry. It is important to note, there is no practical difference between testing at sea level vs testing at high altitude as far as ATI is concerned, and this technology has been used across the network for many years at various elevations to ensure it functions properly. Question 2. Mr. Jefferies, how do we ensure that these automated tools appropriately supplement the experienced track inspectors who know the ins and outs of our mountain passes? Answer. ATI and other automated tools are not designed to completely replace our highly-trained, highly-skilled railroad workforce who know the territory and can spot defects and issues visible to the naked eye. For example, ATI is not designed to identify vegetation overgrowth. That is why combining ATI with manual inspections to identify and fix defects leads to the best safety outcomes. It is also important to note that ATI can capture changes in geometry caused by issues like broken ties and ballast. The automated system will flag those defects, and crews will be deployed to address them. Track geometry measurements provide an overall indicator of the health a track system and its components. Automated Track Inspection (ATI) on Multi-use Tracks Denver's Regional Transportation District (RTD) operates 10 distinct rail lines that actively share right-of-way corridors with Class I freight operators like BNSF and Union Pacific. The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) has begun to advance and expand waivers allowing freight railroads to transition toward an approach that pairs Automated Track Inspection (ATI) with reduced manual track walking. Question 3. Mr. Jefferies, considering these changes, how are these operational changes being coordinated on shared tracks where passenger safety is also at risk? Answer. The track owners are responsible for all track inspection activities on their tracks, and that information is shared with any other railroad using the track, freight or passenger. ATI tests at the specified track class and maximum speed value for all types of traffic on the line, meaning the technology is measuring track safety for freight, passenger, or commuter service if they are sharing the line. If there are issues or defects that make it necessary to reduce speed or make other adjustments to any traffic on the line, freight or passenger, those changes are communicated to the other operators through daily updated track bulletins, immediate online messaging, or verbal communications directly between trains. Industry experience has shown that blending ATI inspections with manual visual inspections improves railroad safety, and so I'd fully expect passenger safety is improved in a corridor where ATI inspections are also voluntarily being used by railroads to complement legacy manual visual inspection requirements. Question 4. Mr. Jefferies, how is the rail industry sharing automated inspection data with transit partners like RTD to ensure maximum safety for both heavy freight and everyday Colorado commuters? Answer. While I cannot speak directly to how the individual railroads operating that share right-of-way corridors with RTD specifically share these messages, as explained above, in general this information is shared via daily updates to track bulletins, immediate online messaging, or verbal communication directly to train operators. I will be happy to connect you with any of the track owners who share right-of-way within RTD to discuss specific operating standards. ______ Response to Written Question Submitted by Hon. Ted Cruz to Chris Spear Question 1. In 2024, a Missouri jury awarded $460 million against Wabash after a vehicle collided with the rear of one of the company's trailers. Although the crash occurred in 2019, the trailer involved was manufactured in 2004 and complied with the Federal safety standards applicable at the time. The verdict raises concerns about regulatory certainty for truckers and motor carriers. If purchasing federally compliant equipment does not shield manufacturers and operators from liability years later, what incentives remain for compliance, and how can carriers confidently make long-term equipment investments without fear of evolving legal standards? Answer. These verdicts raise fundamental concerns for the trucking industry that extend well beyond the facts of any single case. At issue is whether manufacturers and motor carriers can rely on the Federal motor vehicle safety standards established by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) when making long-term equipment investments. Congress intended NHTSA to serve as the Nation's expert regulator for motor vehicle safety. Under the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966, and today under 49 U.S.C. Sec. 30103(b)(1), when NHTSA promulgates a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS), states are prohibited from establishing different standards addressing the same aspect of motor vehicle safety. Those standards are developed through an open, transparent rulemaking process that considers engineering data, public input, costs, and safety outcomes. While Congress prohibited states from adopting conflicting equipment standards, 49 U.S.C. Sec. 30103(e) also provides that compliance with a Federal standard does not exempt a person from liability at common law. Increasingly, that provision has allowed juries applying state tort law to effectively impose equipment standards that differ from or exceed those adopted by NHTSA. The result is legal uncertainty that undermines Congress's intent to establish nationally uniform motor vehicle safety standards. Congressional action is needed to clarify Section 30103 of Title 49 to ensure that when NHTSA has established a Federal motor vehicle safety standard governing a particular aspect of vehicle design, those standards cannot be effectively superseded through state common-law claims. Clarifying the statute would provide the legal certainty that manufacturers, motor carriers, and equipment purchasers need while preserving NHTSA's role as the Nation's primary motor vehicle safety regulator. Such a clarification would benefit the broader trucking industry and manufacturers by allowing carriers to make long-term equipment investments with confidence that compliance with Federal law provides meaningful certainty. Manufacturers already have strong incentives to comply fully with Federal safety standards. Failure to comply can result in costly recalls, civil and criminal penalties, enforcement actions, significant reputational harm, and substantial financial consequences. Those incentives are more than sufficient to ensure compliance with Federal law. The trucking industry does not need the additional threat of unpredictable punitive damages or state-law design standards that can be imposed years or decades after equipment was manufactured to motivate compliance. NHTSA sets standards that appropriately balance safety, feasibility, and cost. The trucking industry follows these standards and takes a proactive approach to safety, investing $14 billion annually in equipment, technologies, and driver training. Manufacturers devote substantial resources to designing, testing, and producing trailers that satisfy NHTSA's engineering-based requirements. Yet they increasingly face the prospect that meeting every applicable Federal standard may still be deemed legally insufficient years later because a jury concludes a different design should have been adopted. In practice, this encourages manufacturers to substitute speculation about future litigation for reliance on the expert judgments of the Federal agency Congress charged with making these determinations. The current legal environment sends exactly the wrong message. If NHTSA, after evaluating the available evidence through its rulemaking process, determines that a particular standard strikes the appropriate balance to maximize motor vehicle safety, that expert determination should carry greater weight than the hindsight judgments advanced by profit-seeking trial attorneys in individual courtrooms. Congress created NHTSA precisely because motor vehicle safety policy should be established through expert, nationwide regulation rather than piecemeal litigation. Importantly, this does not leave the public without recourse if a Federal safety standard becomes outdated or inadequate. Existing law already provides mechanisms for interested parties to petition NHTSA to amend its regulations. Industry participants, safety advocates, manufacturers, carriers, and members of the public can all participate in the rulemaking process and present evidence supporting stronger or different standards. That transparent regulatory process--not after- the-fact litigation--should remain the primary means of evaluating and updating Federal motor vehicle safety standards. Ultimately, Congress should reaffirm its original intent by clarifying Section 30103 to preserve nationally uniform motor vehicle safety standards and provide certainty for manufacturers and motor carriers that invest in federally compliant equipment. America's supply chains depend on predictable national standards, and companies should be able to rely on NHTSA's expert determinations when making investments that remain in service for decades. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Maria Cantwell to Chris Spear Federal Funding for Infrastructure and Technology: According to the American Society of Civil Engineers, cutting transportation funding below the level passed under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law could cost the average American family an estimated $700 a year. Question 1. The President's Budget for next year would cut funding for DOT's freight programs by 36 percent. Do you think we need to continue funding freight infrastructure at the level provided in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law in the next surface reauthorization? Answer. More than 80 percent of U.S. communities rely exclusively on trucking to meet their freight needs, and trucks deliver around 11.4 billion tons of freight annually, which represents 73 percent of the Nation's tonnage. Over the next decade, truck drivers will be tasked with hauling an additional 2.7 billion tons of freight. Highway capacity, especially on the Interstate system, cannot adequately accommodate today's traffic, however, let alone the increase in future volumes. Traffic congestion on U.S. highways added $108.8 billion in costs to the trucking industry in 2022, including a nearly $1.7 billion cost to Washington State. These costs are ultimately passed on to American consumers. ATA agrees that Federal investment in freight infrastructure is critical to an efficient supply chain and economic growth. The best way Congress can help is to invest in the most pressing infrastructure needs facing the industry that moves the vast majority of freight across our country. ATA recommends including a dedicated highway freight bottleneck program in the next surface transportation bill, as well as a program designed to fix roads that connect the National Highway System to freight facilities, such as airports, seaports, and railyards, and providing those programs with robust funding. Technology to Lower Costs and Improve Freight Mobility: At a time when American families, farmers, and businesses are facing an affordability crisis, the President's latest budget request cuts funding for major freight and innovation investments. These grants fund projects like providing real-time information about parking availability and truck parking along the I-5 corridor in Washington. Question 2. How does real-time truck parking information improve safety and efficiency for drivers? Does reducing time spent searching for parking improve freight movement? Answer. A lack of truck parking is a nationwide challenge that has been identified by truck drivers as among their most pressing concerns for many years. Without sufficient capacity, drivers are sometimes forced to decide between parking in an unsafe location or continue driving, even when fatigued, and potentially in violation of Federal hours-of-service rules. Drivers pay a financial penalty when they must shut down early to ensure they have a place to sleep, or they lose time and burn fuel searching for a safe place to spend the night. This penalty is a disincentive to recruiting drivers that, compounded with frequent lack of access to safe parking, also disincentivizes women from entering fulfilling careers as truck drivers. While building more truck parking facilities is often the best solution to mitigate these challenges, in many cases capacity expansion may not be feasible due to financial constraints, local opposition, or simply a lack of available space. In the absence of more truck parking capacity, providing real-time information on the availability of existing truck parking could help to fully utilize existing truck parking capacity. However, investments in real-time parking information are an inadequate substitute for the construction of additional safe truck parking capacity to meet the needs of our Nation's drivers. Workforce Implications: There are over 34,000 truck drivers in the state of Washington. According to the American Trucking Associations, truck driving is one of the top five occupations in 30 states. While I do not anticipate autonomous vehicles will take over these roles overnight, I do think Congress needs to consider the significant implications this technology could have on those state economies. Question 3. What do you say to drivers who are concerned that automated trucks will eliminate their livelihoods? Answer. Drivers are the greatest resource for trucking fleets of all sizes across our country, and I do not foresee that changing for the industry. When considering the workforce implications of automated trucks, it is important to think about both the safety and economic requirements for deployments to be viable. Commercial vehicle drivers perform far more duties than simply driving the vehicle. They inspect and maintain their equipment. They keep the vehicles fueled throughout operations. They safely hook up trailers and secure the connections. They provide security for cargo while it is under the fleet's responsibility. Most importantly, they manage unexpected conditions like traffic, road closures, inclement weather, or other roadway unknowns. For automation to be both safe and economically viable, all of these non-driving functions must be accounted for, but today and for the foreseeable future, automation is only able to handle the immediate driving task in limited testing conditions. One of the major economic challenges for automation deployment will be addressing non-driving functions. Even where it is economically viable to deploy automation, there will need to be humans engaged in these non-driving functions to facilitate the deployment. For this reason, ATA believes that automated vehicle deployments will continue to be incremental and require new jobs for humans performing non- driving roles. ATA simply supports providing opportunities for testing new technology to demonstrate where and when it can be deployed safely and economically for commercial vehicles. As highlighted in my written statement, ATA strongly supports the AV language in the BUILD America 250 Act as approved by the House of Representatives' Transportation and Infrastructure Committee in May. The Build America 250 Act proposes over $140 million for workforce development and strengthening employment opportunities for drivers, mechanics, and other industry professionals. ATA believes Congress and the DOT can facilitate the growth of both jobs and automation rather than choosing one or the other. ATA believes automation is one of many tools that the trucking industry can use to meet the growing needs of the economy, and that integrating automation into the human-driven system rather than replacing it will produce the most efficient and resilient outcomes. ______ Response to Written Question Submitted by Hon. John Hickenlooper to Chris Spear Autonomous Commercial Vehicle Safety Milestones Anyone that has driven down Interstate 70 through the Rocky Mountains knows the high degree of caution it requires, especially during a winter storm. In the hearing you mentioned that Level 4 and 5 autonomous truck testing is currently concentrated in flatter regions like Texas. However, operating an autonomous commercial vehicle on a flat, dry highway fundamentally differs from navigating a 6 percent down-grade on a snowy mountain pass in Colorado. Question. Mr. Spear, for companies actively developing autonomous trucking technology, what specific testing frameworks and safety milestones must be met to prove these platforms can safely navigate complex, high-altitude, severe-weather environments before widespread commercial deployment of AV trucks alongside everyday motorists? Answer. A comprehensive Federal framework for commercial automation safety needs to address not just typical driving scenarios but potential future deployments exactly like the I-70 example you provided. Congress and the Department of Transportation (DOT) have two major approaches available for ensuring safety, and ATA supports both pathways. The first approach is to ensure companies testing and deploying autonomous vehicles (AVs) have safe processes in place for their operations. This has so far been done via safety cases, with AV providers voluntarily submitting their safety cases to the DOT for review. ATA supports Congress and the DOT setting minimum requirements for safety cases to ensure they disclose sufficient information about their safety processes, where they are conducting their testing, and crucially how they are ensuring safety in the specific environments they are testing. This is critical for challenging environments such as the I-70 example you provided. The second approach is to ensure companies testing and deploying AVs maintain safety performance. This can be achieved by setting performance requirements that must be met before deployments and maintained throughout deployments. Performance requirements can take many forms, such as safety metrics, driving competency tests, or failure mode tests. ATA supports Congress and DOT setting appropriate performance requirements based on DOT's expertise to ensure that any AV deployment meets the minimum requirements and does so within the specific environments where they will be deployed. Again, this is critical for challenging environments such as the I-70 example you provided. A combined process-and performance-based approach to safety gives regulators two separate windows into risks and means to address them. As highlighted in my written statement, ATA strongly supports the AV provisions in the BUILD America 250 Act as approved by the House of Representatives' Transportation and Infrastructure Committee in May. The BUILD America 250 Act sets specific requirements on safety cases and directs DOT to create performance-based safety standards for automated vehicles, supporting a comprehensive approach to safety. ATA encourages Congress to work with DOT to build a Federal framework that ensures commercial automation engaged in interstate commerce would be subject to a single comprehensive safety requirement. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Maria Cantwell to Laura Chace Federal Funding for Infrastructure and Technology: According to the American Society of Civil Engineers, cutting transportation funding below the level passed under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law could cost the average American family an estimated $700 a year. Question 1. The President's Budget for next year eliminates funding for the SMART grants program which was funded in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to support the development of innovative transportation technologies. Do you support continuing Bipartisan Infrastructure Law investments in deploying smart technologies? Answer. Yes, the Intelligent Transportation Society of America (ITS America) supports continuing investments in transportation technologies at levels established in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) or higher. Specifically, it is critical that the SMART grant program be reauthorized and re-appropriated at such levels. Consistent, dedicated funding for technology is critical for State and local transportation projects that rely on Federal funds to be able to utilize the most modern, safe, and innovative solutions. Federal investment is a critical signifier of a national transportation strategy that treats digital infrastructure as core infrastructure, and such a strategy remains necessary for the United States to fully compete in the development and deployment of innovative transportation tools. Uncertainty around funding for one of the two existing dedicated Federal funding sources for technology deployment fundamentally undermines state and local efforts to modernize our Nation's transportation infrastructure while sending the wrong message to industry about investing in innovative transportation solutions for American markets. SMART Grants and Local Innovation: As you noted in your statement for the record, the City of Bellevue, Washington, used a SMART grant to deploy adaptive traffic signals designed to better protect pedestrians, bicyclists, and wheelchair users. The pilot resulted in a significant reduction in near misses between vehicles and people. Question 1. How have partnerships with local communities helped your members pilot their technologies? Answer. Local communities, as the owners and operators of infrastructure and transportation services, play an important role in deploying transportation technologies. Local governments can be hubs of innovation and can be microcosms for smart city efforts before the technologies scale more widely. Local governments also look to one another to pilot new innovations and share successes and lessons learned. Other small or mid-sized cities can look to communities like Bellevue as examples of transportation innovation and jumpstart their own use of transformative technologies. Notable partnerships between the autonomous shuttle provider Beep and cities such as Jacksonville, Florida, or Atlanta, Georgia are leading the way for expanding access to transportation services to those who need it most and for piloting new innovations. The successes here in individual communities can spur broader deployment successes in communities across the Nation. Question 2. Do local governments provide an important testing ground for transportation innovation? Answer. Yes, local governments, as well as state governments, provide an important testing ground for transportation innovations. Pilot projects, such as those in Bellevue, play a significant role in demonstrating the value and viability of technologies. Local communities also differ in their needs, road and transit conditions, geographies and populations, allowing them to showcase a diversity of technology applications across jurisdictions. Importantly, many of these local testing efforts have demonstrated that technologies are proven tools and merit scaled deployments across multiple jurisdictions, rather than ending at the pilot stage at an individual intersection, corridor or other limited-scale pilot. These ITS solutions provide system-wide benefits if funded and prioritized. Technology to Lower Costs and Improve Freight Mobility: At a time when American families, farmers, and businesses are facing an affordability crisis, the President's latest budget request cuts funding for major freight and innovation investments. These grants fund projects like providing real-time information about parking availability and truck parking along the I-5 corridor in Washington. Question 1. How do transportation technology investments translate to making the lives of Americans more affordable and safer? How important is long-term funding certainty for communities seeking to deploy transportation technologies? Answer. Investments in transportation technology can reduce the likelihood of vehicle crashes, pedestrian injury or death, and make the overall roadway environment safer. With crashes costing our economy $800 billion per year, this directly translates to cost savings for consumers. Proactively preventing costly crashes or other incidents lowers costs for all Americans. Technology, such as vehicle connectivity, automated driving systems, and intelligent intersections, can save lives on the road--for both those in a vehicle and outside the vehicles. Additionally, traffic congestion costs the average commuter $1,500 per year. Investing in our digital infrastructure, such as smart signals, advanced traffic management systems (ATMS), artificial intelligence-powered tools, and other solutions, can improve throughput at intersections, on major highways, and on other arterial roads. These tools can help cities adapt to traffic conditions in real-time, provide alternative routes for motorists, and make data-informed decisions about their system. When there is less traffic, productivity improves and people can access goods, services, and employment more seamlessly. Moreover, with less congestion on the road, goods reach our homes quicker and freight costs are lower. We can significantly reduce costs for Americans writ large scaling ITS solutions to reduce crashes and congestion on our roadways. However, communities need certainty that funding for these technologies will be available year-after-year in order to have to confidence to deploy a new technology solution, and that their technology projects will be eligible for Federal funding, both formula and discretionary grants. A local agency would not build a road if it did not have confidence that the funding for such a project would be available in its entirety to see the project through completion. The same calculation applies for technology deployment. Certainty and prioritization for technology funding in surface transportation reauthorization is necessary for agencies to confidently invest in technology tools to improve safety, mobility, and overall transportation operations. Technology to Protect Roadside Workers: Every year, roadway workers, utility crews, and first responders are injured or killed while working near traffic. New connected vehicle technologies offer opportunities to alert drivers to workers ahead and reduce these risks. Question 1. What technologies are available today to help protect workers in roadway work zones? Answer. Digital alerting technologies are one of the key tools being used today to help protect workers in work zones. Digital alerting uses vehicle-to-everything (V2X) technology to send real-time notifications to drivers' navigation apps and in-dash systems when approaching active construction areas. This can prevent crashes from traffic queues, lower speeds, and make drivers more aware of their surroundings. A study in Illinois showed that digital alerting technologies increased driver reaction distance 4x more than just emergency lights and led to reduced harsh braking compared to when there was no digital alert. This translates into safer driver behavior near emergency vehicles, queuing traffic, and roadside workers--reducing the chance of a collision. Smart work zone systems can adjust speed limits dynamically around work zones and can help reroute traffic in the event that a work zone shifts locations, or an incident occurs within a work zone. The Work Zone Data Exchange (WZDx) shares real-time work zone data with navigation systems and connected vehicles to improve driver awareness. There are projects now, including one led by a University Transportation Center in Maryland, that are testing technology solutions such as smart vests for roadside workers that vibrate when a vehicle is approaching at high speeds or providing workers with audible alerts when there is a hazard.\1\ Maryland is also using SMART grant funding to demonstrate how drones can be utilized along sensors to improve safety outcomes for road workers and other road users, demonstrating further the importance of this critical technology program.\2\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ Morgan State University's SMARTER Center Utilizes LiDAR Technology to Study Dangerous Intersections and Monitor Highway Road Conditions \2\ https://roads.maryland.gov/mdotsha/pages/ pressreleasedetails.aspx?PageId=818&newsId =4975 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Gary Peters to Laura Chace Question 1. Following up on your response on the greatest barriers for advanced technology adoption, I also agree that none of these groundbreaking technologies would be accessible to state and local agencies without robust and predictable Federal funding. Continued funding for research, design, and implementation across the technology life cycle is critical in helping scale these impactful technologies across communities throughout the U.S. Can you elaborate on the importance of increasing topline funding for technology-enabling DOT programs, and the potential risks of scaling back these investments? Answer. As we confront multiple challenges in the U.S. transportation system, we should be elevating the use of technology adoption to solve some of our hardest transportation problems by establishing direct and dedicated Federal funding sources for technology deployment, including through formula programs. Other countries make transportation technology a matter of national strategy and prioritize funding it--and the U.S. should be no different. Without dedicated funding for our transportation digital infrastructure, the U.S. risks ceding transportation leadership to adversaries like China and further risks missing our safety, efficiency, and mobility goals. Scaling back investments now would send the wrong signal to the private companies who want to develop and invest in the U.S. but need strong Federal leadership and an established marketplace. Without this established marketplace, we risk American technology bring deployed overseas by adversaries and letting countries like China win the global transportation technology race. Funding for programs such as the ITS Joint Program Office, Office of Research and Technology, SMART grants, ATTAIN grants, and other technology-enabling programs at USDOT should remain stable from IIJA levels or increase given the importance of technology to our transportation system today. Additionally, given the recent funding reallocation from the SMART grant program, we urge Congress to ensure that SMART is provided more funding certainty in the next surface transportation reauthorization by either including it under the Highway Trust Fund or advance appropriating funding for the program. Question 2. In your testimony you call for a Federal privacy standard to address concerns on the use and collection of sensitive personal data--can you expand on that recommendation? Are there existing privacy protections being adopted by your members? Answer. ITS America published recommendations for a national data privacy law, particularly as it pertains to the transportation sector.\3\ We continue to advocate for a national data privacy law that protects consumer privacy and personal information, while ensuring that we can continue to innovate and use appropriate data sources in a way that improves safety, efficiency, and mobility outcomes in transportation. A patchwork of state and local data privacy laws hinders the ability for the effective widespread use of life saving technology that relies on accurate data. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ ITS-America-Privacy-Policy-Recommendations-1.pdf --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Any Federal standard for data privacy must preserve the ability of organizations to collect, use, process, and share transportation data that will provide broader societal benefit to consumers and communities, such as reducing vehicle crashes, reducing vulnerable road user injury and death; lowering traffic congestion and increasing efficiency; improving traffic management operations; transportation safety research; and more. In 2025, ITS America published privacy principles to guide the development, deployment, and regulation of advanced technologies in surface transportation. This includes core privacy tenets that our members and other organizations should follow, as well as recommended actions organizations should take to protect consumer privacy. For example, this includes developing policies that limit data collection to only what is necessary to achieve a product or service's goals; conducting regular privacy audits to ensure ongoing compliance with applicable laws and best practices; incorporating privacy considerations into the design of new products; implementing robust consent management systems; and more. Question 3. Similarly, for cybersecurity, what steps are being taken by your members currently that ensure a sufficient minimum level of cybersecurity protection? What steps can Congress and the administration take to support best cybersecurity practices? Answer. Our members adhere to applicable federal, state, and local guidelines and best practices with respect to cybersecurity. State and local agencies are taking steps to manage risks every day, while American industry continues to invest in cutting-edge technologies that better secure our infrastructure from threats. ITS America continues to develop resources to support our members in the realm of cybersecurity through our Cybersecurity Community of Practice. We continue to support secure-by-design principles for ITS and our infrastructure, zero-trust architecture, and robust cyber incident response planning. Congress could take steps to encourage further collaboration between Federal agencies such as USDOT and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) to promote cybersecurity best practices in transportation, share resources, and ensure that Federal transportation funds are being used to bolster State and local transportation cybersecurity activities. Congress should additionally invest in training and capacity building for cybersecurity in transportation, potentially including through supporting the creation an Infrastructure Information Sharing and Analysis Center (ISAC). Dedicated funding for cybersecurity modernization would also be an appropriate area of consideration to fully bolster the defenses of our critical infrastructure from hostile interference attempts. Finally, Congress can and should ensure that there is a pathway for state and local transportation agencies to procure modern cybersecurity solutions to protect the infrastructure they manage. Recent Build America Buy America (BABA) rules around domestic content for manufactured products are poised to significantly limit what solutions these agencies can provide, as critical components like chips are not produced in sufficient scale domestically to meet the security needs of our critical infrastructure solutions. While ITS America and our members are aligned with Congress and Federal regulators on the priorities of BABA, we must ensure that the approach we utilize does not undermine our equally important priorities of ensuring the safety and security of American infrastructure assets. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Tammy Duckworth to Laura Chace Prioritizing Accessibility in Surface Transportation Reauthorization Question 1. With the upcoming expiration of the bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, please explain ITS America's position on the importance of prioritizing accessibility in the next surface transportation reauthorization. Answer. ITS America supports legislative efforts to improve accessibility for transportation users and agrees with the importance of ensuring broad access to mobility options for all travelers. We particularly encourage Federal support for technologies that will improve accessibility and the safety of all road users. These technologies include, for example, smart intersection technology that can hold crosswalk times longer for pedestrians (particularly those with mobility challenges), technologies that help vehicles detect and respond to vulnerable road users, and many more tools. Congress should meaningfully prioritize investments in transportation technologies so that states and cities have a broad set of tools at their disposal to improve safety, lower congestion, and increase access to mobility. We also support public agencies using their procurement power to ensure that mobility options, whether transit or otherwise, serve all populations when contracting with private sector companies for services. Innovations for Safety and Accessibility Question 1. Innovation can decrease the high rates of pedestrian deaths and injuries, specifically for travelers with disabilities. A. Would ITS support the collection and sharing of data on pedestrian crashes, including on crashes involving people with a variety of disabilities and mobility aids, such as wheelchairs, walkers and service animals? Answer. ITS America does not have an official policy position on this subject at this time, but we would be happy to work with your office and discuss this issue more in-depth. B. What solutions are ITS America members pursuing that would increase the safety of pedestrians with disabilities? For example, are members committed to increasing accessibility of streets through safer crosswalks and public rights of way, or ensuring vehicles can detect and respond to pedestrians using mobility aids? Answer. One key example of our members using technology to improve pedestrian safety is smart intersection detection technology. These tools are used at intersections to detect pedestrians, with or without disabilities, who may need more time to cross the street. These tools can then hold traffic lights and extend crossing times so that the individual(s) may cross safely. These tools typically rely on a combination of artificial intelligence software, camera, LiDAR, and other sensing technologies. USDOT's SMART grant program has already funded work in this space, and one grant in Texas developed and tested a smartphone application for use by blind/low-vision (B/LV) individuals to use to navigate smart intersections. This grant also deployed technology that alerted pedestrians and bicyclists using crosswalks and bike lanes of turning buses through an audible message and an illuminated outline of a bus above the pedestrian sign--both helping pedestrians with audio/visual impairments. Several of our members are also investing in wayfinding solutions in transit and rail stations that leverage innovative technologies. These are particularly helpful for persons with mobility challenges but also all riders. We continue to support and strongly encourage further investments in technology solutions that can improve safety for all road users. C. What policy solutions does ITS America believe would be most valuable to ensure innovation in transportation infrastructure best serves all individuals? Answer. Innovation in transportation should serve all individuals regardless of ability, and there are many technology solutions available today that can improve safety, accessibility, and overall mobility. We strongly urge the recognition of technology as core transportation infrastructure (i.e., digital infrastructure) given its outsized benefits and impact on our transportation system in totality. Sometimes, technology solutions address mobility challenges for persons with disabilities in a way that a physical infrastructure modification cannot be solved. Treating technology as core infrastructure allows agencies to better determine what solution or set of solutions should be applied to meet the specific mobility challenges they are trying to solve, rather than being limited by the technology solutions that are or are not eligible and funded. Dedicated funding for transportation technology would be incredibly valuable to state and local transportation agencies that are looking to make improvements to their transportation system in innovative ways. Additionally, there should be strong Federal support for workforce development efforts in ITS, research, planning, and cybersecurity. The SMART grant program, which has invested in technology solutions that improve transportation access and safety, should be reauthorized and funded. Autonomous Vehicles (AV) Question 1. One of ITS America Standing Advisory Committees focuses on Automated Vehicles. AVs have the potential to increase mobility for older Americans and travelers with disabilities. Despite the potential, the initial deployment of AVs has too often left communities behind, particularly individuals with disabilities. Please detail how ITS America is using its position to advance the use of AVs for travelers with disabilities. A. How is ITS America working to proactively ensure AVs and other technological innovations meet the needs of all transportation users? Answer. ITS America works closely with our members across the transportation ecosystem to improve transportation services for all users--including those with mobility challenges. Our member committees and working groups discuss ways in which technological developments in ITS can meet the growing needs of communities across the country. We have previously partnered with organizations such as AARP and Autonomous Vehicle Alliance (now the Future Mobility Collaborative) on accessible and barrier free transportation research and continue to work with our members and partner organizations to advance innovations that benefit all transportation users. B. Please detail ITS America's position on incorporating accessibility as a key pillar to any Federal framework on AVs, particularly regarding ITS America's efforts to promote manufacturer initiatives that ensure AVs are accessible and readily available for riders with disabilities to use--independently--as a reliable mode of transportation. Answer. ITS America's AV Framework includes accessibility as a key pillar, and we know that AVs are an option that can improve access to mobility for those who cannot drive themselves or lack alternative transportation methods. Federal policies that support the safe scaling of AVs across the country should include accessibility as a key component and address a wide variety of mobility needs. In our AV Framework, we called for policies that would not prevent unlicensed individuals from using Level 4 or 5 automated vehicles and have supported AVs with innovative designs or purpose-built vehicles that are intended to support a wide variety of users. Question 2. To ensure people with disabilities benefit from AVs, the vehicles must accommodate passengers who remain in their wheelchairs, and the human machine interface (HMI) must be accessible for people with a wide range of disabilities, including para- or quadriplegic individuals and riders who are blind, deaf or who have intellectual disabilities. How is the AV industry ensuring wheelchair users and people with disabilities can request rides and/or ride in AVs safely and independently through accessible HMIs? Answer. AV technology can bring transformative benefits and create new mobility options for people with disabilities. The AV industry is seeking to create an inclusive transportation service by incorporating accessibility features designed to support those with low-vision, blind, deaf, or mobility challenges. Many of our members are also committed to further enhancing the applications, products, and services offered to align with the needs of communities with disabilities. It is important that accessibility is carefully engineered into AV operations to support a wide range of mobility needs. One of our member companies, Beep, is investing in the development of features to support accessible voice-activated systems, telephonic and live agent support, and on-board interactions. In the instance of Beep, along with many other AV providers, trained remote supervisors will monitor fleets in real-time and can intervene when a passenger with a disability needs assistance, providing verbal guidance or even coordinating with ground personnel in the case of AV transit or shuttle service. In the case of Beep, tactile or visual alert options are also a feature that provides all types of riders with options to contact an operations center without relying on voice. The NAVI program from ITS America member Jacksonville Transportation Authority is ADA-compliant, with automated vehicles equipped with boarding ramps and wheelchair securement systems providing riders with disabilities the same level of service as other passengers, with the same schedule, and same independence. We welcome further engagement with the Committee on this issue and are committed to working with our members on ensuring wheelchair users and people with disabilities can request rides and ride in an AV safely. Question 3. For wheelchair users to use AVs independently, there must be a universal autonomous wheelchair securement system. A. Please describe how ITS America is helping ensure industry is investing in research and development to create and bring to market universal wheelchair securement systems for AVs. Answer. ITS America is supporting the deployment of AVs to bring more access to transportation options for those with mobility challenges. Our member organizations, including AV companies and research universities, are actively working to strengthen accessibility for its vehicle riders, including through universal wheelchair securement systems and strategic partnerships with disability advocacy organizations. Efforts such as the Universal Docking Interface Geometry (UDIG) are breakthroughs for bringing wheelchair securement systems to market. B. The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute (UMTRI) is one of your members. Researchers at UMTRI have designed a universal securement system. To date, has ITS America supported this research and bringing this technology to market, through resources or funding? If not, will you commit to helping bring a universal securement system to market so that people in wheelchairs can independently use AVs? Answer. ITS America supports continued efforts from AV companies, service providers, and researchers to develop and deploy tools that help secure wheelchair users in autonomous vehicles. We continue to support all our members' research, including the research you are referencing being carried out by UMTRI, to improve transportation accessibility. C. Has ITS America partnered with the SecureRide Coalition, which brings industry, advocates and researchers together with the goal of universal wheelchair securement? If not, will you commit to partnering with the SecureRide Coalition? Answer. ITS America has not formally partnered with the SecureRide Coalition to date, but many of our members--including AV companies and research universities--are active supporters and partners of SecureRide. We look forward to exploring ways to work with SecureRide in the future as well as other coalitions supporting greater accessibility in transportation. Question 4. For travelers with disabilities to safely utilize, enter and exit an AV the surrounding infrastructure must be accessible. When data are collected through mapping or other means, AV service providers and government entities could collect and share infrastructure accessibility information, including areas where pick- ups and drop-offs may be unsafe, or where there are curb cutouts or ramps. This data could then be used to identify necessary improvements. Does ITS America support collecting and sharing this data, including using this data to guide the AVs to accessible pickup and drop-off locations? Answer. Data collection to identify accessibility information about infrastructure is crucial for public agencies to make informed planning decisions and enact safety measures that support greater access to transportation. ITS America supports strong partnerships between government entities and AV providers to promote safe and accessible transportation in an AV, including ways to improve pick-up and drop-off locations for passengers with disabilities, and identify other infrastructure elements that may be unsafe for AV riders with disabilities. Additionally, we see these components fitting under a ``complete trip'' framework to ensure that riders can utilize a continuous journey from an origin to a final destination across all transportation modes used--the data you are referencing is a key enabler of that framework. Question 5. Disability advocates have expressed privacy concerns around AV use. What solutions or policies does ITS America support to protect the privacy rights of AV riders by ensuring passengers' health, disability status and locations visited are not shared or used for commercial or tracking purposes? Answer. ITS America strongly agrees with the need to protect consumer privacy, including the privacy of AV riders. We believe this is a broader policy question around a Federal data privacy standard rather than a technology-specific issue related to AV use, however. We have called for a national data privacy law that protects individual privacy while continuing to support innovation in the transportation sector. Such a privacy framework should ensure that individuals know whether a company is collecting, using, or sharing their personal information, allow individuals to modify or withdraw consent for the collection of identifiable information, allow for individuals to opt- out of data collection and processing to the extent feasible for that transportation service, and provide information on what categories of data are collected and processed by a company or service provider. Technology to Support Paratransit Improvements Paratransit provides a travel option for many people with disabilities who cannot rely on public transit. However, several issues with paratransit undermine its utility as an effective and efficient mode of transit for riders with disabilities. For example, if a passenger needs to drop a child off at daycare, pick up a prescription or stop at a bank, they are forced to book two separate, independent trips. Paratransit scheduling also has strict windows; a ``quick'' errand can result in a rider waiting up to 90 minutes for their second ride. Additionally, paratransit services often use outdated methods for dispatch and routing, with riders unable to track the status of their rides and length pick-up windows. Most services also do not allow riders to book same-day services. Ms. Chace, your written testimony noted: ``Providing timely and safe access to transportation options remains a challenge in many communities. Research shows that millions of medical appointments are missed annually due to inadequate transportation options.'' Question 1. Please detail innovations that ITS America members are pursuing to improve paratransit, including addressing the problem of excessive wait times. Answer. Our members are working to address issues facing paratransit operations and deploying technology to help optimize services for riders. Many in the industry have found that automated dispatching, dynamic scheduling optimization, real-time vehicle tracking, and arrival notification systems can materially improve paratransit productivity and reduce rider waiting time. Technology can dynamically adjust for no-shows, traffic delays, or cancellations. Cities are also investing in autonomous shuttle services that can improve paratransit services by providing transit agencies with more capacity. Other members have explored partnerships with transportation network companies (TNCs) such as Uber and Lyft to supplement paratransit services.\4\ Moving to app-based booking platforms and cloud-based services can also improve rider experience. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\ Mobility on Demand (MOD) Sandbox Demonstration: Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority (PSTA) Public-Private-Partnership for Paratransit Evaluation (Report 0213) | FTA Question 2. Would ITS America support a ``one-stop'' pilot program to help paratransit riders avoid excessive wait times between multiple trips; streamline the process for submitting accessibility complaints; and assist local communities with identifying gaps in transportation accessibility? Answer. ITS America strongly supports the use of technology to help improve paratransit accessibility and the ease of trip planning and travel. Technology and data have the power to improve wait times, provide real-time information to riders, and streamline complaint processes. ITS America would be open to supporting this type of program and would welcome an opportunity to discuss details further with your office, particularly about how such a program could align with the ongoing work being done on this subject by FTA and USDOT's ITS Joint Program Office. Broadly speaking, providing more dedicated funding to states and cities for transportation technology will help give communities the resources they need to invest in innovative solutions, upgrade and operate their system, and strengthen outcomes for transit riders of all kinds. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. John Hickenlooper to Laura Chace Interoperable V2X Digital Infrastructure In the hearing, you highlighted an analogy in which you compared standalone computers to the power of the connected internet. In Colorado, our Department of Transportation has pioneered regional Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) and connected vehicle data sharing especially along our mountain corridors. You also noted that these deployments across the country can still be frustratingly fragmented. Question 1. What are the primary constraints stopping us from scaling successful regional mountain-corridor pilots into a truly interoperable, national digital infrastructure? Answer. V2X solutions hold the promise to significantly improve transportation safety and mobility outcomes for all road users by providing instantaneous alerts and information to drivers about imminent hazards and other road conditions. They represent an important component of the broader digital infrastructure ecosystem ITS America has been advocating for throughout this surface transportation reauthorization process. There are three main constraints that hinder scaling of these solutions: lack of a national strategy for transportation digital infrastructure, absence of clear interoperability standards, and lack of sufficient levels of dedicated Federal funding. All three of these barriers must be addressed to scale digital infrastructure solutions. A comprehensive, national strategy for digital infrastructure is a critical element of evolving from fragmented pilots of disparate technologies into an inoperable national network of meaningful technology deployments. ITS America commends the work being done to help build out this strategy by USDOT, particularly USDOT's Office of Research and Technology, the ITS Joint Program Office and contributors from numerous USDOT modes, but Congressional support is a necessary enabler of those efforts moving forward. Providing focus and funding support in the upcoming surface transportation reauthorization process will be a significant element of fully leveraging digital infrastructure solutions across the United States transportation system. Data does not recognize jurisdictional lines, making interoperability essential for scale. Congress and USDOT can accelerate interoperability by setting clear national standards for data exchange and system interfaces, while supporting open architectures that allow systems across states and modes to communicate seamlessly. Additionally, Federal support for the deployment of technology solutions like V2X (and digital infrastructure solutions more broadly) must be treated by Congress with the same seriousness that we provide to the rest of our transportation infrastructure assets. Previous surface transportation authorization bills made incremental progress to ensuring United States leadership in transportation and infrastructure innovation. However, direct spending on transportation technology was only one tenth of one percent (0.1 percent) of the total surface transportation funding authorized in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA). In contrast, technology modernization investments in the recent FAA reauthorization bill were close to 15 percent of the total funds authorized. Additionally, while the discretionary grant programs included within IIJA are helpful for demonstrations and early- stage technology development, they are often limited in both size and scope. Transportation agencies need certain and dedicated funding over a multi-year timeline so that they can properly plan for and deploy technology into their systems at scale. In this next surface reauthorization, the U.S. must adequately fund transportation innovation, and reap the safety, mobility, and economic benefits of investing holistically in technology. Finally, in regards to V2X specifically, ITS America strongly urges USDOT to republish its Saving Lives with Connectivity: A Plan to Accelerate V2X Deployment, an official national deployment plan for V2X which was taken down in early 2025. This will greatly help incentivize and accelerate V2X deployment. Question 2. On a similar note, how can the next Surface Transportation Reauthorization better incentivize states to treat digital technology as a core funding priority? Answer. The next Surface Transportation Reauthorization has the opportunity to define transportation digital infrastructure in law, which provides significant weight and sends a strong signal from Congress that technologies are core to the transportation system. H.R. 8870 (BUILD America 250 Act) already does this. Additionally, the next reauthorization should fund technology in a similar way that it does physical infrastructure--by dedicating certain funding toward it so that states and local governments can rely on yearly, predictable funding for technology that will make safety improvements, support traffic management, upgrade cybersecurity, and provide greater access to mobility. Congress can provide clear funding eligibility, stable funding pathways, and support for innovative procurement methods that will help States invest in technology. This includes strong technology eligibility in formula programs, reauthorizing key technology grant programs (i.e., SMART and ATTAIN) and expanding opportunities for states and cities to use Federal funding for these types of digital improvements. Congress should treat technology as core transportation infrastructure, which fundamentally changes how states plan, fund, and deploy it, moving technology from an add-on to a default part of how projects are delivered. Today, technology is often treated as a pilot or an optional enhancement after a project is designed. When it is considered core infrastructure, it is included during planning and project development from day one--similar to how pavement, concrete, and other safety features are considered. Second, it becomes a lifecycle investment, not a one-time purchase. Digital infrastructure requires ongoing operations, software updates, and data management--rather than simply installation. Treating it as core infrastructure allows states to plan for those full lifecycle costs, rather than trying to fit them into capital-only funding models that were designed for construction. Third, it reduces risk and normalizes adoption across states. When Federal policy clearly signals that technology is a standard, eligible, and supported investment, it removes the uncertainty that currently slows deployment. That makes agencies more comfortable moving from pilots to scaled deployment and from isolated projects to system-wide strategies. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Maria Cantwell to Cole Scandaglia Federal Funding for Infrastructure and Technology: According to the American Society of Civil Engineers, cutting transportation funding below the level passed under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law could cost the average American family an estimated $700 a year. Question 1. Do you support continuing the investments in our transportation infrastructure made under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law? Answer. Yes. The BIL made historic and deeply overdue investments in our Nation's infrastructure. We know that investment in infrastructure has a multiplier effect economically. We also know that the longer we defer critical infrastructure maintenance, the more costly those things will be down the road. We absolutely support IIJA or higher funding levels in the next surface bill--critically including substantial advanced appropriations. Training to Prevent Deskilling: In the aviation industry, we've seen how important it is for pilots to maintain their core skills as the cockpit becomes more technologically advanced. As assistive technologies enter other modes of transportation, it's important that we focus on training to prevent deskilling. Question 1. Are railroads and trucking companies providing the right training to their workers to maintain skill as they introduce technologies like Positive Train Control and route assistance to the cabs of locomotives and trucks? Answer. In the rail industry, continued reliance on technologies like trip optimizer or ``Zero to Zero'' which removes decision making authority from a locomotive engineer for substantial percentages of a trip creates serious deskilling risks. This risk is exacerbated by the fact that railroads penalize locomotive engineers through discipline and threat of firing who don't follow the prompts from these software systems 95 percent or more of the time, even when the software prompts are wrong or would lead to safety risks. In the event of unexpected circumstances or technology failure an engineer may be required to assert control of the locomotive with little to no warning. An engineer who performs reduced manual operations on a day-to-day basis may suffer from an atrophy of skills in that scenario, which could have disastrous results. The loss of familiarity with operations over components of certain territories also presents serious risks in an emergency. The Teamsters endorse requiring a set time of each trip be conducted in manual operation to avoid these scenarios. In trucking, we have similar concerns. While route assistance/ guidance systems can be a helpful additive technology to drivers, they cannot substitute for the experience and knowledge of a professional driver. It is critical that companies do not require strict and unquestioning adherence to these systems under threat of discipline or termination, particularly when the experience of a driver on his or her route or area may be superior. Wayside Detectors and Railway Safety: Following the Norfolk Southern derailment in East Palestine, investigators found that a wayside detector identified the overheated bearing, but the warning came too late to prevent the accident. My Railway Safety Act would require the use of defect detector technology. Question 1. How can the technologies in the Railway Safety Act protect communities and workers and prevent the next East Palestine? Answer. The Railway Safety Act's requirements for the regulation of wayside detectors is critical, and an example of the correct way to address railroad safety. Currently, and prior to East Palestine, railroads are permitted to make all decisions on regarding the use of wayside detectors--where they are installed, how they are maintained, and how information is provided to frontline workers. East Palestine showed us both how that technology can help avoid tragedy, but also how allowing total authority over the use of the technology by the regulated entity will only end in disaster. We commend Ranking Member Cantwell for leading the Railway Safety Act and continue to call for its adoption into law in the strongest possible terms. Workforce Implications: There are over 34,000 truck drivers in the state of Washington. According to the American Trucking Associations, truck driving is one of the top five occupations in 30 states. While I do not anticipate autonomous vehicles will take over these roles overnight, I do think Congress needs to consider the significant implications this technology could have on those state economies. Question 1. What steps do you think Congress should take to address the workforce implications associated with autonomous commercial vehicles? Answer. In the immediate term, we should reject the narrative that a qualified driver is unneeded behind the wheel of a truck simply because a manufacturer claims they can operate that way. No commercial driver should ever be removed from a vehicle whose performance and operations are subject to no specific regulations on the technology. We should also dispense with the notion that if displacement occurs it will be restricted to certain industry needs or subsectors, or that commercial autonomous vehicles will simply fill the void left by (falsely) purported ``driver shortages''. The idea that employers could have the ability to eliminate labor costs and will choose not to do so does not survive the barest scrutiny. In the event of displacement and given the scope of the industry it would be essential Congress acts in advance of impacts. This response should be developed, in conjunction with professional drivers before any meaningful displacement occurs. We express deep skepticism that a future with substantial commercial AV development is likely to create a similar number, or quality, of jobs as an inherent symptom of introduction of new technology. Safety Cases and Checklists: I am concerned that even if well- intentioned companies treat AV safety cases as living documents, regulators and bad actors will view them as simple checklists. Question 1. How can we ensure that autonomous truck companies continually work to improve safety? Answer. Placing faith in corporations to self-monitor and self- improve their product, particularly in the transportation sector, only invites risk. We continue to call on Congress to develop a comprehensive and prescriptive regulatory framework which addresses both premarket and operational authority issues relating to the deployment of commercial autonomous vehicles. Question 2. How can Congress ensure that AV safety is more than a checklist? Answer. In legislation concerning autonomous vehicles, Congress should require the creation of actual standards capable of measuring performance and operational safety by which the claims of manufacturers and operators can be compared to. In lieu of such requirements, the Federal government is fully reliant on an unacceptable self- certification regime, for which agencies would have no ability to evaluate. Need to Enforce Safety Rules to Create Credibility for Technology: The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) recently released its annual enforcement report showing that FRA inspectors recommended violations 19 percent less frequently than the previous year, despite only a 4 percent reduction in railroad-reported incidents. Last year, I wrote to U.S. DOT concerned about reports of a 98 percent decline in proposed pipeline enforcement penalties. And under the Trump Administration, fines against hazmat motor carriers have decreased by almost 50 percent, while violations are down just 3 percent. Question 1. Are you concerned that DOT could be directing its inspectors to give industry a pass by recommending fewer violations and enforcement actions? Answer. While we do not have evidence to suggest precisely why enforcement actions have decreased, their decrease is deeply concerning to our membership. It is certainly not the case that railroads have become 19 percent more safe in the last year. Question 2. Do you think this lack of enforcement at DOT could undermine efforts to integrate safety technology into the system? Answer. If DOT agencies are unable, or unwilling, to exert their maximum enforcement authorities upon existing operations, it would not inspire confidence in the regulation of deployment of new technologies. Need for access to data for transparency. During your testimony you mentioned that railroaders do not always have access to the same data railroads use for decision-making. I previously wrote to the Federal Railroad Administration expressing concern over a waiver request from the Association of American Railroads that requires railroads to submit data to the FRA as part of a waiver to reduce visual track inspections. Question 1. Why do railroad workers not always trust data that railroads report? Have you documented errors or inconsistencies? Answer. Railroad workers don't trust the data the railroads report because the railroads are fully in control of the data they collect and report and railroad workers do not have access to that underlying data. The Federal Railroad Administration for the vast majority of situations does not independently collect data and instead relies on what the railroads submit to the FRA. Additionally railroad workers experience pressure a regular basis to not to report safety issues, including derailments and accidents. Contrary to the railroads rhetoric on making safety a priority, railroad workers are under constant threat of retaliation, including discipline and potential termination, if they report safety issues. OSHA has documented hundreds of whistleblower complaints from railroad workers over retaliation from railroads for reporting safety issues.\1\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ See https://www.osha.gov/news/newsreleases/kansas-city/20260504 and https://www.fox61 .com/article/news/nation-world/rail-whistleblowers-fired-voicing- safety-concerns/507-37798495-63ce-4a2e-9995-4e52bd00764a Question 2. What has the Teamsters analysis of Class I railroad data submitted to the FRA pursuant to the conditions of the waiver to reduce human visual inspections by 50 percent found? Answer. Under the waiver granted by the FRA in December 2025, covered railroads are allowed to reduce visual track inspections by 50 percent if they submit monthly reports that are meant to ensure that they are meeting the conditions of the waivers. BMWED does an analysis of these reports when they come in. Since implementation of the Federal Railroad Administration's (FRA) Automated Track Inspection (ATI) waiver began in March 2026, the ATI waiver has expanded rapidly. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Railroad Implementation Date ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Union Pacific 3/29/2026 BNSF South 4/5/2026 BNSF North 7/5/2026 CSX 7/5/2026 NS 8/2/2026 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ With the addition of CSX and Norfolk Southern, the waiver now encompasses nearly 33 percent of all U.S. Class I track miles, including major freight corridors, passenger rail routes, commuter rail territory, routes carrying hazardous materials, and some of the Nation's largest metropolitan areas. CSX's waiver includes heavily populated corridors serving Washington, D.C., Baltimore, Philadelphia, New York City, Richmond, Boston, Chicago, Nashville, Cleveland, Buffalo, Albany, and numerous other major cities. Norfolk Southern's waiver territory includes the line through East Palestine, Ohio, placing the route affected by the 2023 derailment within the reduced visual inspection framework authorized under the waiver. A review of the railroads' submissions raises several significant concerns regarding whether the FRA waiver conditions are being satisfied. The most significant issue is that none of the railroads provided the underlying Track Geometry Measurement System (TGMS) measurement datasets required by Condition 1(h) in the waiver. Instead, both submissions rely largely on summarized outputs such as movement logs and exception reports. Without the full geometry measurement data, including gauge, alignment, cross-level, warp, and profile readings, it is not possible to verify system performance or determine whether defects were detectable at the time of inspection. In practical terms, the submissions ask FRA to accept the railroads' conclusions without giving reviewers the data needed to test those conclusions. Both BNSF and UP's submissions also raise major coverage and completeness concerns. The available records indicate that TGMS activity was often performed in short or fragmented segments rather than in clear, continuous subdivision-level runs. To date it doesn't appear that any railroad in a reporting month has tested their entire territory Key findings from the initial waiver reports for the first month of reporting include: BNSF South reported 2,560 human-found defects compared with 157 ATI defects during the first month of reduced inspections, a ratio of more than 16 human-found defects for every ATI defect identified. BNSF North's baseline data reflected 4,159 human-found defects compared with 355 ATI defects. Union Pacific reported approximately 610 human-found defects compared with 90 ATI defects during its first month of operation. Analysis of the Union Pacific and BNSF submissions identified numerous instances where qualified track inspectors discovered defects after ATI equipment had already traversed the same territory, raising questions regarding claims that ATI provides earlier detection of developing track conditions. Both railroads experienced ATI coverage gaps during implementation, requiring FRA monitoring to ensure that reduced visual inspections were not applied where required automated inspection frequencies were not achieved. In total, the first-month reports submitted under the waiver documented thousands of defects identified through traditional inspection methods while ATI systems identified only a fraction of that number. These findings are particularly significant because ATI performance metrics focus primarily on track geometry conditions and do not measure many categories of defects routinely identified through visual inspections, including defects involving ties, fasteners, joints, switches, crossings, ballast conditions, drainage issues, and other critical infrastructure components. In total, the first-month reports submitted under the waiver documented thousands of defects identified through traditional inspection methods while ATI systems identified only a fraction of that number. These findings are particularly significant because ATI performance metrics focus primarily on track geometry conditions and do not measure many categories of defects routinely identified through visual inspections, including defects involving ties, fasteners, joints, switches, crossings, ballast conditions, drainage issues, and other critical infrastructure components. The disparity between human and automated defect identification is reflected clearly in the railroads' own data: BMWED's analysis of BNSF data from the baseline month shows: Human inspectors identified 7,142 total defects, including 156 geometry defects and at least 42 geometry multiclass drop defects. ATI systems identified only 719 total defects, including just 10 multiclass drop defects. BMWED's analysis of Union Pacific data from the baseline months shows: Human inspectors identified 609 total defects, including 15 geometry defects. ATI systems identified only 35 total defects, including 14 multiclass drop defects. [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Performance Based Regulations. During your testimony, you were asked about performance based regulations. Question 1. What does performance based regulation mean in the railroad industry and how would that approach change the way that railroads are currently regulated? Answer. A performance based regulation approach would be the opposite of how the railroad industry has been regulated since it came into existence over 150 years ago. For decades, the railroads have had to meet specific prescriptive requirements on what they need to do from a safety perspective. Those requirements include taking specific prescriptive actions on every aspect of the railroads' operations like inspections, hours of service limits for train crews, safety protections to protect workers working in the railroad right of way so they don't get hit from a train etc. Performance based regulations means that the railroad industry effectively regulate itself. This approach would be devastating from a safety perspective and could lead to more East Palestine type derailments. Because the railroads collect and control the safety data that is submitted to the Federal Railroad Administration, they would get to determine the safety performance metrics that they would meet and what would define ``success'' in terms of safety. Even if the performance metrics the railroads set are forward looking, the railroads still would set the safety metrics (derailments/per mile, defects per mile etc) that they would consider to be acceptable from a safety perspective. Based on the railroads' rhetoric, they consider the current level of three train derailments a day acceptable even though it means that other communities are at risk of an East Palestine type derailment. The railroads refuse to implement the operational changes and workforce levels necessary to get to zero derailments a day and are willing to accept certain level of safety risk in their system even if the communities they serve are not. It is a classic case of private companies transferring risk to the public in pursuit of profit. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. Gary Peters to Cole Scandaglia Question 1. Mr. Scandaglia, you discussed the importance of Collective Bargaining Agreements when it comes to worker involvement in transportation technology adoption. How can Congress best ensure that C-B-As are upheld in this area? Are there legislative approaches that you believe could reflect the kind of worker input CBAs allow? Answer. Within the jurisdiction of this Committee and the drafting of a surface transportation reauthorization, the Committee can statutorily prefer or prioritize, for example within grant applications, scenarios where it can where it can be demonstrated that impacted workers support the activity or projector that the recipient has negotiated a process with its workforce by which new technology is negotiated. Additionally, the Committee should broadly require that labor organizations are eligible recipients for workforce development and training programs, and champion the ability of labor organizations to conduct training and development for current and future members. However, the most important action Congress can take in this area is to ensure that more transportation workers have the ability to join a union and secure a collective bargaining agreement in the first place. Congress can do so by enacting the Faster Labor Contracts Act. The bill would prevent employers from dragging out negotiations indefinitely on a first contract for the purposes of busting newly organized units. The Teamsters thank Subcommittee Ranking Member Peters for being an original cosponsor of the Senate version of the bill, S.844. Now that the legislation has passed the House, it is imperative that the Senate follow and pass the bill into law. ______ Response to Written Questions Submitted by Hon. John Hickenlooper to Cole Scandaglia Transitioning Workforce in the Automation age Mr. Scandaglia, you have reiterated for the committee that driving a truck is one of the most common and vital occupations for working- class Americans across our states. In Colorado, our truck drivers are the lifeblood of our mountain and rural economies. I'm a big believer that technological innovation should lift workers up, not push them out. In the hearing, you noted that extensive use of automated systems can risk 'de-skilling' workers in which tasks are automated so that they require less human action or judgement to be performed. This transition often leaves workers unprepared when asked to reassert control in a situation where technology fails or an emergency presents itself. Question 1. Mr. Scandaglia, what concrete steps should Congress and industry leaders take right now to invest in workforce training and transition programs, ensuring our drivers are fully equipped to assist the automated system and manage these advanced technologies rather than being displaced by them? Answer. As discussed above, Congress should reject the current status quo in which manufacturers are able to eliminate a driver from a commercial vehicle solely based on their assessment of their own technology. As deployments are conducted with a driver in the vehicle, it is essential that traditional requirements which govern the safety of the driver and protect the general public, like CDL requirements, hours of service limitations, and drug and alcohol testing continue to apply to any individual, in or outside the vehicle, with the capability to manipulate its operations. In as much as the introduction of new technology modifies existing jobs, for example, for a traditional diesel mechanic now asked to maintain an AV, Congress should consider financial support for workforce development. Currently, the DOT and the Federal Motor Carrier Administration oversee extremely limited and fiscally insignificant programs which target specifically workforce development for those in commercial motor vehicle industry. Such programs are ripe to be expanded and further developed in the surface transportation reauthorization. National Security Concerns in Connected Vehicles Mr. Scandaglia, your testimony highlighted important national security considerations regarding reports that some AV operators have utilized overseas personnel to support or manipulate vehicle functions on American roads. For a state like Colorado, which hosts critical and sensitive military facilities--including NORAD/NORTHCOM, the ADF-C, and the NSDC--protecting the security of our physical corridors and transportation data is a top priority. Question 2. Mr. Scandaglia, as Congress works to establish a Federal AV framework, how should it explicitly define the domestic chain of custody for vehicle control, and what specific safeguards are necessary to guarantee that the operation and data management of connected commercial vehicles remain secure and within trusted hands? Answer. As it relates specifically to the vehicle and its technology stack, we have endorsed the Connected Vehicle Security Act (S.4429), which restricts the importation of vehicles and vehicle components from countries of concern. It is critical that AVs are not able to transmit any kind of data to foreign adversaries, and that foreign adversaries are not able to conduct data gathering by virtue of placing vehicles on American roads. Operationally, Congress must require that any individual who has any ability to influence the operations of a vehicle, whether that be a remote operator or a remote assistant, is doing so from within the United States. The Teamsters were deeply disturbed by recent testimony in this Committee from Waymo, in which the company revealed that many of its remote overseers are doing so from the Philippines, and call for such arrangements to be prohibited. [all]