Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
[House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] RUNAWAY COLLEGE SPENDING MEETS THE WORKING FAMILIES TAX CUTS ======================================================================= HEARING Before The SUBCOMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT of the COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ HEARING HELD IN WASHINGTON, DC, FEBRUARY 4, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-45 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Education and Workforce [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via: edworkforce.house.gov or www.govinfo.gov ______ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 65-541 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE TIM WALBERG, Michigan, Chairman JOE WILSON, South Carolina ROBERT C. ``BOBBY'' SCOTT, VIRGINIA FOXX, North Carolina Virginia, GLENN THOMPSON, Pennsylvania Ranking Member GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JOE COURTNEY, Connecticut ELISE M. STEFANIK, New York FREDERICA S. WILSON, Florida RICK W. ALLEN, Georgia SUZANNE BONAMICI, Oregon JAMES COMER, Kentucky MARK TAKANO, California BURGESS OWENS, Utah ALMA S. ADAMS, North Carolina LISA C. McCLAIN, Michigan MARK DeSAULNIER, California MARY E. MILLER, Illinois DONALD NORCROSS, New Jersey JULIA LETLOW, Louisiana LUCY McBATH, Georgia KEVIN KILEY, California JAHANA HAYES, Connecticut MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio ILHAN OMAR, Minnesota JAMES C. MOYLAN, Guam HALEY M. STEVENS, Michigan ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri GREG CASAR, Texas RYAN MACKENZIE, Pennsylvania SUMMER L. LEE, Pennsylvania MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington JOHN W. MANNION, New York MARK HARRIS, North Carolina ADELITA S. GRIJALVA, Arizona MARK B. MESSMER, Indiana RANDY FINE, Florida R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT BURGESS, OWENS, Utah, Chairman MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington ALMA ADAMS, North Carolina, JOE WILSON, South Carolina Ranking Member GLENN THOMPSON, Pennsylvania FREDERICA WILSON, Florida GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin MARK TAKANO, California ELISE M. STEFANIK, New York LUCY McBATH, Georgia LISA C. McCLAIN, Michigan DONALD NORCROSS, New Jersey KEVIN KILEY, California JOE COURTNEY, Connecticut JAMES C. MOYLAN, Guam SUZANNE BONAMICI, Oregon ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri MARK DeSAULNIER, California MARK HARRIS, North Carolina ILHAN OMAR, Minnesota RANDY FINE, Florida ADELITA S. GRIJALVA, Arizona C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on February 4, 2026................................. 1 OPENING STATEMENTS Owens, Hon. Burgess, Chairman, Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development........................ 1 Prepared statement of.................................... 2 Adams, Hon. Alma, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development........................ 3 Prepared statement of.................................... 5 WITNESSES Akers, Dr. Beth, Senior Fellow, American Enterprise Institute (AEI)...................................................... 6 Prepared statement of.................................... 8 Landward, Mr. Geoffrey, Commissioner, Utah System of Higher Education.................................................. 12 Prepared statement of.................................... 14 Morgan, Dr. Julie Margetta, President, The Century Foundation 26 Prepared statement of.................................... 28 Rodrigues, Mr. Raymond, Chancellor, State University System of Florida................................................. 37 Prepared statement of.................................... 40 ADDITIONAL SUBMISSIONS Ranking Member Adams: Article from The College Investor, titled ``The Truth About Administrative Bloat at U.S. Colleges''.......... 51 Walberg, Hon. Tim, a Representative in Congress from the State of Michigan: Report dated December 6, 2023, titled ``A Framework for Reforming Federal Graduate Student Aid Policy''........ 60 Courtney, Hon. Joe, a Representative in Congress from the State of Connecticut: Letter dated February 4, 2026, from the American Association of Nurse Anesthesiology (AANA)............. 99 Grijalva, Hon. Adelita S., a Representative in Congress from the State of Arizona: Article dated August 2023, titled ``How Congress Can Strengthen the Pell Grant Program to Make College More Affordable for Millions of Americans''................. 106 Moylan, Hon. James C., a Representative in Congress from the State of Guam: Article dated August 23, 2023, from Forbes, titled ``1983: The Last Time College Costs Kept Pace With Median Income''........................................ 112 RUNAWAY COLLEGE SPENDING MEETS THE WORKING FAMILIES TAX CUTS ---------- Wednesday, February 4, 2026 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development, Committee on Education and The Workforce, Washington, DC. The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:15 a.m., in Room 2175, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Burgess Owens (Chairman of the Subcommittee) presiding. Present: Representatives Owens, Baumgartner, Grothman, Kiley, Moylan, Onder, Harris, Fine, Walberg, Adams, Takano, McBath, Norcross, Courtney, Bonamici, DeSaulnier, Omar, Grijalva, and Scott. Also present: Representative Mackenzie. Staff present: Lauren Blunt, Intern; Vlad Cerga, Director of Information Technology; Solomon Chen, Professional Staff Member; Hope Dennis, Intern; Maren Emmerson, Legislative Assistant; Halle Greenbaum, Staff Assistant; Lauren Hassett, Professional Staff Member; Amy Raaf Jones, Director of Education and Human Services Policy; Libby Kearns, Press Assistant; Isaiah Knox, Policy Advisor; Campbell Ladd, Clerk; R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director; Jack Leonard, Staff Assistant; Danny Marca, Director of Information Technology; Audra McGeorge, Communications Director; Ethan Pann, Deputy Press Secretary and Digital Director; Sara Robertson, Press Secretary; Katherine Anne Russo, Director of Member Services and Coalitions; Austin Small, Intern; Brad Thomas, Deputy Director of Education and Human Services Policy; Thomas White, Deputy Clerk; James Whittaker, General Counsel; Shaunice Afriyieb, Minority CBCF Intern; Amaris Benavidez, Minority Professional Staff; Ellie Berenson, Minority Press Assistant; Zenaida De La Cruz, Minority CHCI Fellow; Di Fang, Minority Robert Wood Johnson Health Fellow; Rashage Green, Minority Director of Education Policy & Counsel; Christian Haines, Minority General Counsel; Raiyana Malone, Minority Press Secretary; Eleazar Padilla, Minority Staff Assistant; Alexandra Pernie, Minority Intern; Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director; Banyon Vassar, Minority Director of IT. Chairman Owens. The Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development will come to order. I note a quorum is present and without objections, the Chair is authorized to call recess at any time. Today, we acknowledge a simple fact college has gotten too expensive. Since 1970, college tuition has increased fivefold, far outpacing the rates of inflation. Meanwhile, colleges have increased their administrative costs, spending more on non- instructional personnel, athletics and non-academic programs that are not at the core of the institution's educational mission. Recent college enrollment surveys and Federal data show that a long running trend is continuing. Colleges are on track to spend more per student on administrative costs than on teaching. It is no surprise, then, that Americans have began to question the value of post-secondary education. Congressional Republicans heard these concerns and responded by passing the Working Families Tax Cut, which included reforms to lower the cost of college. The Working Families Tax Cut simplifies student loan repayment plans from over 50 options down to just two. A fixed mortgage style plan and a repayment assistance plan that provides targeted relief for borrowers in need. The law will also hold schools accountable for student outcomes with do no harm measure of postgraduate earnings, ensuring that degree programs improve students' financial prospects if they are continued to receive taxpayer funding. It also placed a reasonable caps on Federal loans for graduate and professional students, ending the days of unlimited borrowing that allow college tuitions to skyrocket. Unfortunately, graduate student loan debt has become a significant driver in overall student debt. I am proud this Committee has taken meaningful action to address the college affordable crisis, but there is more to do. There is still an opportunity for accreditation reform, in line with the Department of Education's recent announcement to negotiate rulemaking on this topic. States also have a role to play. Today, we will hear about efforts in Utah and Florida to reduce administrative costs, implement performance-based funding, systems reform faculty tenure and workforce policies and refocus accreditation on student outcomes. I am confident that restoring market incentives to higher education will result in a better pricing for students. Every student should feel empowered to pursue an education that fits their goal and know that the degree they choose is going to be worth the cost. With that I yield to the Ranking Member. [The opening statement of Chairman Owens follows:] Statement of Hon. Burgess Owens, Chairman, Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development Today we will acknowledge a simple fact--college has gotten too expensive. Since 1970, college tuition has increased fivefold, far outpacing the rate of inflation. Meanwhile, colleges have increased their administrative costs, spending more on non-instructional personnel, athletics, and non-academic programs that are not core to an institution's educational mission. Recent college enrollment surveys and federal data show that a long-running trend is continuing: colleges are on track to spend more per student on administrative costs than on teaching. It is no surprise, then, that Americans have begun to question the value of postsecondary education. Congressional Republicans heard these concerns and responded by passing the Working Families Tax Cuts, which included reforms to lower the cost of college. The Working Families Tax Cuts simplified student loan repayment plans from over 50 options down to just two: a fixed ``mortgage'' style plan and a ``repayment assistance plan'' that provides targeted relief to borrowers in need. The law will also hold schools accountable for students' outcomes with a ``do no harm'' measure of postgraduate earnings, ensuring that degree programs improve students' financial prospects if they are to continue to receive taxpayer funding. It also placed reasonable caps on federal loans for graduate and professional students, ending the days of unlimited borrowing which allowed college tuition to skyrocket. Unfortunately, graduate student loan debt has become a significant driver of overall student debt. I am proud that this Committee took meaningful action to address the college affordability crisis, but there's more to do. There is still an opportunity for accreditation reform, in line with the Department of Education's recent announcement of negotiatedrulemaking on this topic. States also have a role to play. Today we will hear about efforts in Utah and Florida to reduce administrative costs, implement performance-based funding systems, reform faculty tenure and workload policies, and refocus accreditation on student outcomes. I am confident that restoring market incentives to higher education will result in better pricing for students. Every student should feel empowered to pursue an education that fits their goals and know that the degree they choose is worth the cost. ______ Ms. Adams. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. At this Committee's first Higher Education and Workforce hearing of the year, I am glad we are starting by focusing on what is top of mind for Americans across this country, rising costs. Let me start with the facts. A college degree remains the surest path to the American Dream. It is still the most reliable engine of economic mobility we have. College graduates earn more, experience lower unemployment rates and are better positioned to support their families and contribute to their communities. The basic truth has not changed. What has changed dramatically though, is the lack of State and Federal investment in higher education and that lack of investment has shifted the cost onto students and their families. From 1995 to 2025, the average published tuition and fees at colleges and universities have risen sharply, far outpacing wages, inflation and household income. This is not a perception problem. It is a real problem for Americans in search of a better life. Families are being asked to pay more each year for the same credential, even as they already stretched--already stretched thin trying to survive. We all agree there is a college affordability crisis in this country. Where we disagree is on the solution. We also need to be honest about what is and is not driving rising college costs. My Republican colleagues will say that this is about administrative bloat, but the facts do not support that claim. Federal data show that students still far outnumber staff at colleges and universities, including at highly selective institutions. Faculty make up a significant share of employees, and many schools appear staff heavy only because they operate hospitals, research centers and public service enterprises that serve communities far beyond their enrolled students. When those roles are, are properly accounted for, the idea that colleges are overrun by administrators simply does not hold up. Rising college costs are not driven by too many advisors, financial aid counselors or student support staff. They are driven by decades of public disinvestment that have shifted costs onto students, while basic expenses like housing and food and transportation continue to rise. Cutting staff does not make college more affordable. It makes it harder for students to stay enrolled and finish their degrees. My colleagues on the other side of the aisle increasingly argue that higher education is a luxury, that students, particularly low-income and first-generation students, simply should not pursue if they cannot afford it. Instead, they are told to go learn a trade or to attend lower quality institutions with poor student outcomes, including for-profit schools with troubling track records. Let me be clear. The solution to the college affordability crisis cannot be that quality higher education is reserved only for the wealthy. We cannot accept a system where opportunity depends on zip code, family income or whether your parents went to college. Telling students to lower their aspirations is not a serious policy response. It is a failure of leadership. The affordability crisis does not exist in a vacuum. Americans are struggling to afford basic necessities, including groceries and housing, childcare, utilities and health care. These pressures directly affect students' ability to enroll, persist and graduate. Even when students arrive on campus, a recent survey found three in five experienced food or housing insecurity. When we factor in access to transportation, childcare, technology and mental and physical health care, the number of students facing basic needs insecurity jumps to three in four. Instead of addressing these realities, recent policy choices have made them worse. Republicans continue to make cuts to food assistance/Medicaid, contribute to rising utility costs and freeze childcare funding, which all undermine economic security and by extension college access. We also need to be honest about what is driving rising college costs. Republicans today will argue that colleges should lower cost by simply not investing high quality faculty and administrators, like career counselors and academic advisors who help students reach the finish line. The spending is not the root cause of high tuition. In addition to stagnated State and Federal investments, unchecked privatization and for-profit colleges have targeted low income students, often leaving them with high debt and low value credentials. Students from the lowest income are twice as likely to enroll in for-profit colleges, and too often they pay the highest prices. Finally, we cannot ignore the elephant in the room. Republicans Big Ugly Law, which makes this crisis worse, changes to Pell Grants, new borrowing limits and a restructured repayment system narrowed the pathways to higher education, particularly for underserved communities. These reforms risk turning college into an expensive privilege rather than public good. This hearing is about one simple question. Do we believe college should be accessible to everyone willing to work for it, or only to those who can afford it? Mr. Chairman, I look forward to our discussion today. Thank you, and I yield back the balance of my time. [The opening statement of Representative Adams follows:] Statement of Hon. Alma Adams, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. As this committee's first Higher Education and Workforce hearing of the year, I am glad we are starting by focusing on what is top of mind for Americans across this country--rising costs. Let me start with the facts: a college degree remains the surest path to the American Dream. It is still the most reliable engine of economic mobility we have. College graduates earn more, experience lower unemployment rates, and are better positioned to support their families and contribute to their communities. That basic truth has not changed. What has changed dramatically, though, is the lack of state and federal investment in higher education. That lack of investment has shifted the cost onto students and their families. From 1995 to 2025, the average published tuition and fees at colleges and universities have risen sharply, far outpacing wages, inflation, and household income. This is not a perception problem. It is a real problem for Americans in search of a better life. Families are being asked to pay more each year for the same credential, even as they are already stretched thin trying to survive. We all agree there is a college affordability crisis in this country. Where we disagree is on the solution. We also need to be honest about what is and is not driving rising college costs. My Republican colleagues will say that this is about ``administrative bloat.'' The facts do not support that claim. Federal data shows that students still far outnumber staff at colleges and universities, including at highly selective institutions. Faculty make up a significant share of employees. Many schools appear staff-heavy only because they operate hospitals, research centers, and public service enterprises that serve communities far beyond their enrolled students. When those roles are properly accounted for, the idea that colleges are overrun by administrators simply does not hold up. Rising college costs are not driven by too many advisors, financial aid counselors, or student support staff. They are driven by decades of public disinvestment that have shifted costs onto students, while basic expenses like housing, food, and transportation continue to rise. Cutting staff does not make college more affordable. It makes it harder for students to stay enrolled and finish their degrees. My colleagues on the other side of the aisle increasingly argue that higher education is a luxury that students, particularly low- income and first-generation students, simply should not pursue if they cannot afford it. Instead, they are told to ``go learn a trade,'' or to attend lower-quality institutions with poor student outcomes, including for-profit schools with troubling track records.Let me be clear: the solution to the college affordability crisis cannot be that quality higher education is reserved only for the wealthy. We cannot accept a system where opportunity depends on zip code, family income, or whether your parents went to college. Telling students to lower their aspirations is not a serious policy response--it is a failure of leadership. The affordability crisis does not exist in a vacuum. Americans are struggling to afford basic necessities, including groceries, housing, child care, utilities, and health care. These pressures directly affect students' ability to enroll, persist, and graduate. Even when students arrive on campus, a recent survey found 3 in 5 experience food or housing insecurity. When we factor in access to transportation, child care, technology, and mental and physical health care, the number of students facing basic needs insecurity jumps to 3 in 4. Instead of addressing these realities, recent policy choices have made them worse. Republicans continue to make cuts to food assistance, slash Medicaid, contribute to rising utility costs, and freeze child care funding, which all undermine economic security and, by extension, college access. We also need to be honest about what is driving rising college costs. Republicans today will argue that colleges should lower costs by simply not investing [in] high-quality faculty and administrators, like career counselors and academic advisors, who help students reach the finish line. This spending is not the root cause of high tuition. In addition to stagnant state and federal investments, unchecked privatization and for-profit colleges have targeted low-income students, often leaving them with high debt and low-value credentials. Students from the lowest-income are twice as likely to enroll in for- profit colleges, and too often they pay the highest prices. Finally, we cannot ignore the elephant in the room, the Republicans' ``Big Ugly Law,'' which makes this crisis worse. Changes to Pell Grants, new borrowing limits, and a restructured repayment system narrow the pathways to higher education, particularly for underserved communities. These reforms risk turning college into an expensive privilege rather than a public good. This hearing is about one simple question: do we believe college should be accessible to everyone willing to work for it, or only to those who can afford it? Mr. Chairman, I look forward to our discussion today. Thank you, and I yield back the balance of my time. ______ Chairman Owens. Thank you. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8(c), all members who wish to insert written statements into the record may do so by submitting them to the Committee Clerk electronically in Microsoft Word format by 5 p.m., 14 days after this hearing. Without objections, the hearing record will remain open 14 days to allow such statements and other material noted during this hearing to be submitted for the official hearing record. I will now turn to introduce our four distinguished witnesses. Our first witness is Dr. Beth Akers, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute from Washington, DC. The second Witness is a fellow Utahan, Mr. Geoffrey Landward, Commissioner of the Utah System of Higher Education from Salt Lake City, Utah. My third witness is Dr. Julie Margetta Morgan, president of the Century Foundation from New York City. Thank you. The fourth witness is Mr. Raymond Rodrigues, the Chancellor of the State University System of Florida from Tallahassee, Florida. I thank the witnesses for being here today, and look forward to your testimony. Pursuant to Committee rules, I would ask that each of you limit your oral presentation to a 3-minute summary of your written statement. As Committee members have many questions for you, the clock will count down from 3 minutes. However, pursuant to Committee Rule 8(d) and Committee practice, we will not cutoff your testimony until you reach a 5-minute mark. I would also like to remind the witnesses to be aware of your responsibility to provide accurate information to the Subcommittee. I first want to recognize Dr. Akers for your testimony. STATEMENT OF BETH AKERS, SENIOR FELLOW, AMERICAN ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE, WASHINGTON, D.C. Dr. Akers. Thank you and good morning, Chairman Owens, Ranking Member Adams and members of the Subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. Higher education and workforce policy affect nearly every American family, and getting this policy right matters enormously for students and taxpayers alike. I am an economist, who studies how Federal higher education policy affects students and institutions. My remarks today will focus on two points, why reform has been necessary and what Congress should do next. Higher education still pays off on average, but outcomes vary enormously across programs. Many programs deliver strong economic mobility, while others leave students with debt and little improvement in earnings. For too long, Federal policy subsidized enrollment without paying enough attention to results. Students often enroll without clear information about costs and outcomes, and taxpayers carry growing risk when programs consistently fail to deliver value. The recent reconciliation legislation marked an important shift by tying access to Federal loans more closely to student outcomes. It is hard to overState how important this innovation was for those of us who have been following this field for a long time. It established a simple principle. Programs that routinely leave students financially worse off should not continue receiving Federal loan dollars. The legislation also introduced new limits on graduate student borrowing. These limits operate as a consumer protection, helping prevent students from taking on debt that exceeds the economic value of their degree, while also restoring some price discipline in graduate education. The work is not finished. I hope that Congress continues this work to strengthen accountability, by paying greater attention to price. Programs that deliver similar earnings at much lower costs provide better value to students and taxpayers, and should be recognized as such by policy. Congress should also continue improving transparency so students have clear, usable information before enrolling and before borrowing. That includes ensuring students receive standardized, easy-to- understand financial aid offers and have access to program level information on costs, completion rates, post-enrollment earnings, so they can make informed decisions before taking on debt. The question before Congress is whether Federal policy will continue rewarding enrollment alone or increasingly reward results that matter to students and taxpayers. The reconciliation legislations showed meaningful progress in that direction. Building on that progress can help ensure post- secondary education consistently delivers on its promise. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Dr. Akers follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Owens. Thank you. I will now recognize Mr. Landward for your testimony. STATEMENT OF GEOFFREY LANDWARD, COMMISSIONER, UTAH SYSTEM OF HIGHER EDUCATION, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH Mr. Landward. Thank you, Chairman Owens, Ranking Member Adams, members of the Committee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I am here before you on behalf of the Utah Board of Higher Education, to discuss one of our most urgent priorities in Utah, keeping higher education affordable and accessible, while ensuring it delivers real value to students, taxpayers and the workforce. Higher education remains essential to economic mobility, civic life and national competitiveness. For too many families, the rising cost of college has created the perception that higher education is out of reach. Over the past 50 years, tuition fees at public 4-year institutions have risen nearly three times faster than inflation. If left unaddressed, this trend threatens access, public trust and long-term workforce development. The causes of rising costs are complex. They include macroeconomic forces such as increased demand for credentials in a knowledge-based economy, rising costs of labor-intensive services. They also include institutional pressures, mission creep, regulatory burden, duplication of programs, expanded student services and intense competition for enrollment. No single factor explains the problem, and no single solution will fix it. In Utah, we believe affordability requires strong governance, disciplined decisionmaking and a relentless focus on student value. First, we are redesigning our system of higher education to fully capture the benefits of system-ness. A recent performance audit confirmed that institutions too often act independently, duplicate programs and compete rather than collaborate. Our response is a multi-year system redesign built around regional higher education centers with specialized institutional roles, shared services and coordinated academic pathways. This approach emphasizes collaboration over competition, reduces duplication and expands access without unnecessary cost growth. Second, Utah has implemented some of the most transparent and disciplined tuition and fee policies in the country. Institutions are required to justify every proposed increase through public hearings, clear cost disclosures and board level scrutiny. As a result, Utah's public institutions already have among the lowest tuition in the Nation, and real tuition levels have declined over the past 3 years. Third, we are aligning funding with value through strategic reinvestment. Under recent State law, institutions were required to reallocate $60 million statewide toward high value workforce line programs. Early results show significant reinvestment in health care, engineering, computer science and technical education while reducing administrative costs and strengthening instruction. Utah's outcomes reflect this approach. We have the lowest average student loan debt in the Nation, and one of the lowest rates of students graduating with debt. This is driven by low tuition, strong concurrent enrollment, high value technical pathways and a culture that emphasizes responsible investment. Finally, Federal policy matters. Financial aid reform, transparent value reporting, accountability for program outcomes and expanded Pell eligibility for short-term credentials all support affordability, and aligned with student return on investment. Affordability is not about lowering quality. It is about delivering education that is efficient, accountable and worth the investment. Utah's experience shows that strong governance and clear incentives can bend the cost curve while expanding opportunity. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Landward follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Owens. Thank you. Now I would like to recognize Dr. Morgan for your testimony. STATEMENT OF DR. JULIE MARGETTA MORGAN, PRESIDENT, THE CENTURY FOUNDATION, NEW YORK, NEW YORK Dr. Morgan. Thank you. Good morning, Chairman Owens, Ranking Member Adams and members of the Subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify at this hearing. The cost of college is simply too high for most families to afford. Tuition and fees for undergraduates this past year were almost $12,000 for an in-State public college student, 4,000 for a community college student and more than $43,000 for a private non-profit, and that is not even including room and board, books and other expenses For millions of students, the only option to afford an education is to take on mountains of debt. Total Federal student loan debt stands at nearly $1.7 trillion, with the average Federal student loan burden just under $40,000. Under the Trump administration's watch, an increasing number of borrowers have struggled to repay their loans, with an astounding one out of every four borrowers currently delinquent on their loan. Unfortunately, the prospect of higher education has become a Catch-22 for families across the country. Making a safe, secure living too often requires education after high school, but getting that degree requires taking on enormous debt and financial risk that could leave them worse off. The Century Foundation's own research found that people without a college credential are living in a different, harsher economy. They are twice as likely as their college educated counterparts to skip meals or medication due to cost, twice as likely to report being late on their bills and far more likely to turn to debt to cover their expenses. Higher education was expensive before Donald Trump came into office, but actions taken by his administration and by Congress have made the situation far worse. First and foremost, in the last year, the Trump administration has driven up daily costs from utilities to health care to school supplies, so much so that Americans are forced to make impossible tradeoffs between putting food on the table, keeping their lights on and getting the medical care that they need and deserve. I know the President has called the issue of affordability a hoax, but for countless families across the country, this pain is real. Congress's decision to gut Medicaid and SNAP to pay for massive tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans only deepened that pain, as did its decision to stand by and watch health insurance costs skyrocket. Now 3 in 10 Americans are delaying or skipping medical care due to cost. One in three people are skipping meals due to finances, and millions of Americans are behind on their utility bills. Nearly 40 percent of working-class people are relying on short-term debt like buy now/pay later to cover their bills. Second, H.R. 1 has created a huge vulnerability for public higher education that is already driving up tuition prices in many states. H.R. 1's cuts to Medicaid and SNAP are--put immense pressure on State budgets and a State scrambled to fill those gaps. We are already seeing them cut appropriations for public higher education, leading to tuition increases. Several states have slashed higher education funding or raised prices and unfortunately, I expect we will see more in the coming year. Third, Congress and the Trump administration have drastically increased the cost of student loans, both for current and future borrowers. H.R. 1 eliminated income-driven repayment plans including a SAVE plan, replacing them with a skimpier single plan that puts borrowers at higher risk of default. That change alone will cost many borrowers between 2,800 and 4,800 dollars per year. H.R. 1 also placed borrowing limits on certain Federal loans, creating new and lucrative opportunities for the student loan industry. Major private lenders like Sallie Mae, Navient and SoFi lobbied for these limits, and they are standing ready to extract profits from students. As SoFi told its investors, their company would be very happy to step in for the government and would absolutely capture that opportunity. Finally, the Trump administration has opened the door to predatory education programs and student loan servicers by taking the cops off the beat, sidelining the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and eliminating the units at Federal Student Aid in charge of enforcement. While there are many actions that Congress can take to undo this damage, I urge you to focus on using the big levers that the Federal Government has to make real change, not incremental tinkering on the edges or clever programs that make good headlines and trade publications, but no difference in family budgets. We need change that families can actually feel, change that makes life more affordable for all Americans. Thank you and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Dr. Morgan follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Owens. Thank you. Last, I would like to recognize Mr. Rodrigues for your testimony. STATEMENT OF RAYMOND RODRIGUES, CHANCELLOR, STATE UNIVERSITY SYSTEM OF FLORIDA, TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA Mr. Rodrigues. Good morning and thank you. Good morning and thank you, Chair Owens. I bring greetings from your hometown of Tallahassee. Also, good morning Ranking Member Adams and members of the Subcommittee. I would be remiss if I did not acknowledge my former colleague in the Florida House, Congressman Randy Fine, who during his time in Tallahassee was always willing to tackle tough issues in education. I am pleased to see you are serving on this Committee. In October 2025, the Pew Research Center conducted a survey, and in that survey, seven out of ten Americans responded that they thought higher education was on the wrong track. Eight out of ten expressed concerns around a college affordability. In Florida, our State university system serves 431,000 students at over 12 institutions, making it the second largest in the country. For the last 15 years, we have been on a path of reform and that path that is taught us three lessons I would like to share with the Subcommittee today. The first lesson is that change is possible. During the Great Recession from 2008 to 2013, Florida cut its higher education appropriations by 43 percent. That was nearly twice the national average during that time period of 23 percent. During that same 5-year period, we raised tuition 86 percent, which was the highest in the country and well above the national average of 39 percent. 2013, we came out of the Great Recession in Florida. In Florida we did something different. We embraced performance-based funding, which is funding based on successful student outcomes. We knew that that would bring in accountability and this was our second lesson, is that accountability works. Since we have implemented performance-based funding, we have seen significant student success. Our academic progress rate is up to 90 percent. Our 6-year graduation rate is up to 76 percent, No. 1 in the country. Our 4-year graduation rate is up to 60 percent, No. 2 in the country and our post-graduation employment rate is up to 74 percent. The third lesson we learned is that student success can drive affordability. Each year, we present the results of our ten performance-based funding metrics to our legislature and to our Governor, and our legislature and Governor have taken the progress that we have made and they have continued to invest in our system as a result of that. In-State resident undergraduate tuition in Florida has been frozen since 2013. We now have the lowest resident undergraduate tuition and fees at $6,359, nearly half the national average of 11,950. Important for us is that at the end of spring semester, a student can leave and if they are willing to work full-time during summer, even if it is a minimum wage job, they can earn enough over the summer that before the fall semester begins, they will have earned enough to pay both their fall and spring tuition and fees, making us one of the last systems that you can work your way through. The result of low tuition and fees is that fewer students need student loans. In our most recent data, 80 percent of our Florida resident undergraduates were enrolled with no student loans. Accountability, transparency and affordability have transformed our system and our pursuit of academic excellence. We continue to reform in other areas as well, such as containing administrative growth, post-tenure review, eliminating indoctrination and creating transparency tools for families like my Florida future. In closing, I commend Congress for passing the Working Families Tax Cut Act. For the first time the Federal Government has introduced accountability measures around student outcomes. Florida is proof positive that accountability and higher education works and I look forward to taking your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Rodrigues follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Owens. Thank you. Under Committee Rule 9, we will now ask questions to witnesses under the 5-minute rule. I will recognize myself for 5 minutes. First of all, I had a chance to go through all your testimoneys and I am very impressed. Thank you so much for taking the time to do that. It is going to add a lot to our conversation and how we move forward. Ms. Akers, in your testimony, you mentioned in the past we rewarded participation at whatever cost--I am going to paraphrase, when moving forward to the reward outcomes that matter to the student, worker and taxpayer. It is a remarkable way of approaching this. What are your thoughts on the Working Families Tax Cut capping Federal student loans for graduate and professional students? Dr. Akers. I think this is a tremendously important move for consumer protection. We have been talking for a decade now about, student borrowers being victims of this system that does not have any underwriting, that does not help them discern whether debt will be affordable for them to take on, the limits put in place, reasonable limits, to bring in line the amount that people are borrowing with what they can anticipate to see as a return from those degrees. Chairman Owens. Thank you. Mr. Landward, let me just say, coming from Utah and also growing up in Tallahassee and keeping up with that, there is a culture that we are seeing in both states, as one of collaboration and more importantly keeping the student first, not the institution. I want to applaud you both for making that happen. We know that the confusion about how much college education costs can cause students to make poor decisions about their, about their higher education options, and to be a major barrier for students considering postgraduate education. How does Utah require institutions of higher education to be transparent about the tuition policies? Mr. Landward. Thank you, Chair. In Utah, we feel an obligation because we are so highly supported by the State legislature, and because of the investment that the State makes. We have an obligation to ensure not only that we are putting downward pressure on tuition, but those who are reaping the benefits of this investment understand the nature of the investment. In Utah we require, first of all, all of the institutions to hold public hearings and advertise those hearings with the students on campus in multiple venues, to ensure they have an opportunity to come and hear what is the tuition paying for? If there is an increase, what is that increase going to pay for? How is it going to benefit the students? Then take that information and feedback and then make a recommendation to the Board of Higher Education. We take an opportunity to scrutinize all of those disclosures, and we also require them to provide us alternative scenarios. In other words, saying instead of raising tuition, what would it look like if we reduce the tuition that you are requesting to this level? Or what would it look like at zero? Please give us those scenarios, and then to push back on those to ensure that they are uncovering every opportunity to find different ways to pay for the needs for these increases. I mean that kind of public disclosure helps ensure that not only students understand what the tuition is paying for, but also that our institutions understand that they have to justify every increase to ensure that it is going to provide value to those students. Chairman Owens. Thank you. Mr. Rodrigues, Florida has the lowest resident undergraduate tuition and fees in in the Nation. What policies have been key to keeping college affordable without compromise and educational quality? Mr. Rodrigues. The performance-based funding measures have prioritized student success. The student success measures have given our legislature and our Governor the confidence to continue to invest. Each year, those metrics are reported and we can demonstrate to the legislature and to the Governor the connection between their investment in our higher education, and the success of our students and how that contributes to the overall economy. Our metrics are focused around student success, they understand the academic excellence that our students are receiving. That spurs further investment. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I just want to say again, thank you for prioritizing students first instead of institution and we are starting to see that is a great model for the rest of the country, and I am looking forward to them seeing that. That being said, I am going to now recognize the Ranking Member for her questions, question the witnesses. Ms. Adams. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you again to our witnesses. Let me turn to Dr. Morgan. Dr. Morgan, public college has remained the most affordable option for students, especially low-income, first generation and working students. That affordability has increasingly been preserved by shifting costs onto students rather than sustained public investment. Can you explain how State funding for public colleges has changed over the last few decades, and how those shifts translate directly into higher tuition and fees for students? From a policy perspective, why is sustained State and Federal investment in public colleges one of the most effective ways to control costs without sacrificing quality or access? Dr. Morgan. Absolutely. I will just start by saying, you know, public colleges and universities are really the backbone of our higher education system. This is where about 70 percent of individuals are going to school, and it is incredibly important to keep them accessible and affordable for all students. Traditionally, State appropriations have been the way that we have done that. The combined mix of appropriations from State government and grant aid from the Federal Government have allowed students to attend public colleges at a very affordable rate. However, we have seen over time that when State budgets are squeezed, one of the first things to go is investment in public higher education. As those State appropriations shrink, tuition goes up. That is partly why I am particularly concerned about what we have seen in H.R. 1, which is going to put that kind of pressure on State budgets and increase tuition costs for students. Ms. Adams. Thank you, ma'am. The millions of borrowers are struggling with delinquency and default, not because they were irresponsible, but because the cost of college and the cost of living outpaced the wages. What does the evidence show about how student loan default affects borrowers' financial stability, including credit access, housing and unemployment? Looking ahead, what policies are most effective at preventing default before it happens, and what should Congress be doing now to support borrowers who are already distressed? Dr. Morgan. Yes. Delinquency on student loans has incredible negative effects on people's lives. There is both the punitive effects of the way that we collect student loans through wage garnishment and other measures in the Federal student loan program, and there is also the effect of having a defaulted student loan on people's credit reports, which can of course, impact their ability to get credit. I think people do not always understand that it also impacts their ability to get a job, to get housing. This can be really crushing for students and for borrowers. I think, you know, when you think about what the Federal Government can do here, as a former employee at the Department of Education, what I saw was that that shift from delinquency to default is really the barrier where we want to focus our attention. If we can keep people in repayment on their student loans, we can keep them afloat and we can keep them out of the default, kind of bucket where it is incredibly difficult to pull them back out. I think this is where income-driven repayment plans really become important. Ms. Adams. Thank you. The Century Foundation has played a critical role in documenting and evaluating the chronic underfunding of historically black colleges and universities. I look forward to seeing that advocacy continue. I had the opportunity to work closely with Denise Smith during the HBCU Brain Trust last semester. I have taught 40 years on an HBCU campus. I went to a public university myself. Based on that work, why have public HBCUs continued to receive unequal treatment by their states, even after decades of legal settlements and Federal attention? How does that under-investment show up for students in concrete ways? Dr. Morgan. Yes. I really want to thank you for your advocacy on this issue. It is an issue that has been incredibly important to the Century Foundation, because it is important to people in this country and to creating equitable access not just to higher education, but to jobs. We know that HBCUs provide incredible support for black students around the country, and also have experienced unequal funding. It is incredibly important that we focus in on equalizing the funding for those schools so that students can experience the same outcomes as their peers. Ms. Adams. What should Congress expect from states and institutions, to ensure that HBCU funding gaps are actually closed, not just acknowledged? How can organizations like yours continue to play a role in holding systems accountable for delivering on that promise? Dr. Morgan. You know, I think we need to persistently put the data in front of our leaders, not only at the Federal level, but at the State level, to make sure that they cannot walk away from these gaps that they have created and that they have allowed to foster over decades. To me, that kind of advocacy is really important from an organization like Century, and I appreciate the advocacy that we had from you and others in terms of the impact that that has on students. Ms. Adams. Thank you very much. Mr. Chairman, I would like to put in the record the College Investor article ``Administrative Bloat is False.'' Chairman Owens. Without objection. [The articles of Ms. Adams follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Adams. Thank you. Thank you very much. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would now like to recognize the Chairman of the full Committee, my friend from Michigan, Chairman Walberg. Mr. Walberg. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for having a great panel here today, and panel, thank you for being here. It is great to have a panel that is an actual showcase of what happens when you focus on accountability with and responsibility for outcome, as opposed to just throwing money at it as we have done for the past number of years, with more government loans, which has exacerbated the cost of college education because there is no limit to what the government can give. Private sector will hold accountable. To see states that are focusing on accountability and responsibility for outcome, thank you for having them here. It is good to see your State represented well from Utah, as well as from Florida. Dr. Akers, what do you say to the people who often say a lot of whining going on out there, even before the one Big Beautiful Bill is in action fully for how we are dealing with student loan issues, but the people who are concerned that graduate student loan limits will impede college access. Dr. Akers. Graduate student loan limits are critically important to ensure that people are not continuing to take on amounts of debt that are unaffordable, based on what they are likely to earn in the future. There is a lot of concern about different programs, whether professional graduate degree programs have eligibility for different loan limits. It is really important to rewind and come back to the point that the limits on graduate and professional loans altogether, that is--the objective is to make sure that people are not able to borrow more than is going to be affordable for them to pay in the future. Yes, giving people piles of money with unlimited access to credit will create more access, but the question is access to what? I think it is critically important that we are ensuring access to high-quality programs, to programs that can deliver an economic return that is on par with the amount that people are able to borrow. Mr. Walberg. Yes. Thank you. I agree. Mr. Landward, good to see you here today. Missed seeing you in Utah in Salt Lake City at the great roundtable that our Chairman had out there. You were well-represented, and thank you for that. We have heard concerns that reforms in the Working Families Tax Cuts threaten college access, but do skyrocketing college costs not also make college unattainable for many students? Mr. Landward. Thank you for the question. The answer is yes. Ultimately, in the Utah system of higher education and as prioritized by the State legislature, affordability is one of the key priorities that we have. It is no secret. Any study about college going rates and even college retention, the cost of going to college and staying in college is one of the primary barriers to access and to completion. We simply have to recognize that as a system of higher education, we have an obligation to the students who enroll in our institutions to ensure that they are affordable. When we look at whatever reforms are coming, either from the Federal Government or at a State level, the intent here is that we want students to go, and we want them to stay and we want them to graduate. We would like them to graduate in a way where they actually have a return on that investment, meaning they are going to earn more than what they had to put in. The data shows that if they can get degrees that have that kind of return, it is so worth the investment that they are making. We have to make sure that we are removing all of those barriers to affordability Mr. Walberg. Yes, and it encourages them for continuing education in the future as they develop beyond the job that they are in as they start. Thank you. Mr. Rodrigues--boy, it is exciting to hear that a student in Florida, many students at least, can work during the summer and pay for their school bill. Kind of harkens back to my days of maybe working two, three jobs in the summer, but still paying for my education. How did Florida address administrative bloat while holding institutions of higher education to high standards of operational efficiency? Mr. Rodrigues. That is a great question. What we have seen over the last four decades is that the growth of administration has averaged around 3.9 percent annually. In Florida, we require each university when they submit their legislative budget request, which is what they give the legislatures asking for appropriations, to include on that request their number of administrators, FTE equivalent, and their 5-year trend. They know when they go to the legislature to ask for funding, that legislature has that top of mind when they are considering that appropriation request. What we have found is over the last 10 years, our appropriations have grown a total of 2 percent in administration. I am sorry. Our administration has grown a total of 2 percent over the last 10 years. Mr. Walberg. Wow. Mr. Chairman, could I, without objection, enter into the hearing record a report from the American Enterprise Institute, the Education Council and the Century Foundation, which recommends and I quote ``reasonable loan limits.'' That is exactly what we did in the Working Family Tax Cuts. Chairman Owens. Without objection. [The reports of Representative Walberg follow:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Owens. OK. I would like now to recognize my good friend from California, Mr. Takano. Mr. Takano. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. Chairman Walberg, you know, the premise of his line of questioning was that private markets will correct bloat and bring down college costs. With the passage of the Republican budget bill H.R. 1, Republicans laid out their vision for higher education. Clearly, they believe that college costs will be lowered through privatization, deregulation and competition in the free market. Dr. Morgan, what do we know about college pricing and student outcomes in the for-profit sector? Dr. Morgan. Thank you for the question. We know that college pricing in the for-profit sector is meant to maximize profits for shareholders, rather than providing affordable education for students. What we see in the for-profit sector is high prices, high levels of debt for students and very little spending on instruction. More often than not, we are seeing students who are getting a very high priced education that provides very poor outcomes in the labor market and in terms of their student debt repayment. Mr. Takano. In this case, does relying on a free market competition-based model effectively lower tuition? Dr. Morgan. These colleges are not competing on price for students, right? They are competing for access to Federal aid dollars. They are competing for access to profits. Mr. Takano. There does not seem to be any attention to this particular sector in H.R. 1 or among your counterparts at the table? Dr. Morgan. No. In fact, you know, H.R. 1 has very little attention to the issue of affordability overall, and in fact works in the opposite direction. It is increasing costs on families across the board, which is making it harder for them to afford higher education. Mr. Takano. Thank you. Republicans seem to be operating on the theory that an increase in Federal financial aid available to students leads to an increase in tuition for all. Dr. Morgan, in which sector of higher education has this theory been shown to be true, public higher education, private higher education or in the for-profit sector? Dr. Morgan. The studies that I have reviewed have showed that in the for-profit sector, when there is an increase in financial aid, we see a corresponding increase in tuition prices. That is, I believe, driven by this profit motive. They are looking to suck in as much Federal financial aid as they can. Mr. Takano. An increase in financial aid has not demonstrably been shown that for increases in public higher ed or in private higher education, but mainly in the for-profit sector? Dr. Morgan. No, certainly not to the same degree as the for-profit sector. I think the other thing to remember here is that even if Federal financial aid were driving up tuition prices, the idea that simply limiting Federal aid would somehow bring down tuition prices is a fallacy. What we are seeing is the creation of a gap between Federal student loans and tuition prices that families are having to fill by turning to the private market for private student loans. Mr. Takano. H.R. 1 capped how many--how much students could borrow in Federal loans, limited student eligibility for Pell Grants and fully replaced the student loan repayment system with one that is ultimately much more expensive for borrowers, changes which all increasingly pushed American students toward the private loan market. Dr. Morgan. Will the changes made in H.R. 1 safeguard students against defaulting on their loans or exacerbate the risk of default? Dr. Morgan. It is--they are certainly going to exacerbate the risk of default. I think in particular, the dialing back on the income-driven repayment plans available to people to give them a less generous option puts students at risk of default. Shifting them over to the private market for loans puts many, many students at risk of default and it puts them at risk of default on a loan that is more predatory than what they would have gotten in the Federal system. Mr. Takano. My Republican colleagues say that greater privatization of higher education will protect the American taxpayer from subsidizing student loans. Without corresponding protections for student borrowers and accountability measures, the private markets will have free rein to treat these students like piggy banks. Dr. Morgan, we are accelerating--we are accelerating American students toward the brink of a massive default crisis at a breakneck speed. What will a default crisis ultimately cost the American taxpayer? Dr. Morgan. I cannot put an exact figure on it, but I just really want to emphasize that this is--the crisis in defaults, and even just in delinquencies, is not just an impact on the individual borrower. It is an impact on the economy as a whole. It inhibits people's job mobility, it inhibits their ability to get housing and it inhibits their ability to consume, which is what powers our economy altogether. This is really a crisis that we all need to be paying attention to, and that is happening right under our nose even in the Federal Student Loan program. Mr. Takano. I am afraid to say that my Republican colleagues want to take a victory lap today, but I want to warn all Americans that these policies that they have embedded in H.R. 1 are going to create a default crisis that will leave every American, every American footing the bill. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like now to recognize my good friend from North Carolina, Mr. Harris. Mr. Harris. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to all of you on the panel for your testimoneys here and your written testimoneys that I enjoyed reading. Dr. Akers, every year, millions of high school seniors face one of the most significant and difficult decisions of their lives, what comes next after graduation. However, these young adults are all too often led astray when deciding on which college they should attend, what field of study to pursue or even whether college is necessary at all to achieve their career goals. I want to just ask you up front, in your view how is today's higher education system failing high school students as they prepare to make these significant life-altering decisions? Dr. Akers. I would say the primary way in which the system is failing students is that we are not delivering on the promise of opportunity. On average, higher education is delivering opportunity in spades, but there are plenty of programs out there that are allowed or have been allowed to continue to receive funding through Federal programs that are consistently delivering students not into good economic opportunity. I would say the variation that we have seen historically, hopefully which will now be stopped by the implementation of the reconciliation legislation, has been the significant failure for students. Mr. Harris. Well, as you noted in your testimony, while a college degree can and often does pay off for many Americans, those outcomes are highly program-specific. For some students, attending college actually leaves them worse off financially than if they had never enrolled. You also highlighted what you described as an information gap, I noticed, where students enroll without a clear understanding of the true cost of their degree. How does this information gap impact students' decisionmaking, and who would you say are disproportionately harmed by these misguided and irresponsible policies? Dr. Akers. In general, I would say it is the already economically or racially disadvantaged students who are struggling to make the best decisions about college. We have made it really hard for people to make good decisions. The information technically exists. There is a website out there, the collegescorecard.gov. I go there all the time. American students, especially young high school students or even returning adults, do not know that this is where the information is that they need to make decisions. Second, institutions have made it difficult for students to interpret or potential students to interpret the financial aid offers that they give to them in a self-serving manner. We need to make it more clear so that people can make decisions that are in their own best interest. Mr. Harris. Well, and I agree. Congress has a responsibility to hold colleges and universities accountable, which is why in H.R. 1 Republicans placed reasonable limits on how much students can borrow. I will ask you one more. In your expert opinion, how will these reforms not only help rein in rising college costs, but also increase accountability in higher education by ensuring institutions prioritize value over volume when offering degree programs? Dr. Akers. For the first time, this legislation puts in place standards that says to an institution if you are not delivering your graduates, your students into better economic circumstances than where you started, we do not want you in the Federal lending program. That is a tremendous win, both for individual students and for taxpayers. Layer on top of that, what I think is a really important protection for graduate students. We have--we have struggled to pin down exactly through research the relationship between the availability of credit in student lending programs and prices. Very recently, a set of economists were able to pin down very precisely that there has been a tremendous increase in cost of graduate professional programs because of the eligibility for credit that has been largely unconstrained. This is going to, for the first time, put downward pressure on prices of those programs, which really works to serve students better because they get a better deal. They get those returns at a lower cost, and also protects taxpayers from the downside of having to repay these loans. Mr. Harris. I have only got a minute left. Mr. Landward and Mr. Rodrigues, I will say I was greatly encouraged by the steps your respective states have taken to ensure institutions of higher education remain accountable to both students and taxpayers. Since I only have about 45 seconds left, Mr. Landward, Utah requires public institutions to submit 3-year plans to evaluate your programs and administrative costs. How has this planning requirement changed decisionmaking at the institutional level, and can you give us any specific examples of how costs have been reduced? Mr. Landward. Yes. Thank you for the question. I will be brief. We do require now institutions to provide a 3-year what we call a strategic reinvestment plan. These reinvestment plans were developed through a State law that essentially took $60 million out of the State higher education budget, held it and then had those institutions tell us in a 3-year plan where would that money come from and cuts-- and where would it go, based on criteria like enrollment, completion rates, discipline-related professional outcomes including placement, employment, licensure, wage outcomes, current and future industry demand, all of these things showing that this is the type of thing that ensures a high return on investment. Institutions now are making decisions based on those criteria, and can show that we have deinvested in programs that were poor performing or administrative costs that were not fundamental to the mission of the institution, and have reinvested that back into instruction, in programs that provide higher value to students. The investment in higher education did not go down. It is just smarter. Mr. Harris. Thank you. My time has expired. Mr. Chairman, I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. My friend from Connecticut, Mr. Courtney. Mr. Courtney. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the panel. Last November, the Department of Education issued its hit list in terms of occupations that no longer are defined as professions. Which I think anybody who even has casually followed this issue has triggered a backlash of just biblical proportions. You know, particularly in the health care space, where occupational therapists, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, nurse anesthetists were again basically removed as a professional occupation, aside from the insult that I think many people in that area felt, I mean it had real life consequences. It put a lower cap in terms of borrowing. You know, again the fantasy that we hear from some of these witnesses today, particularly from the American Enterprise Institute, that that is somehow going to introduce market discipline in terms of tuition. I mean the fact of the matter is, is banks know better, because they were lobbying for these caps because they understand that the limits are going to force student borrowers into the private market. Again Dr. Morgan, maybe you can talk about that. You mentioned it in your testimony. Dr. Morgan. Yes, thank you. I will start with that lobbying effort. I think it is important to understand that we saw private lenders place paid advertisements in places like Politico, you know, driving up this idea that student loans were this huge problem, and that the thing that we needed to do was to cap them, right? Publicly they are saying we need caps on student loans. Privately, what they were saying to their investors was we are waiting in the wings. There is a profit opportunity for us here. I think that those people who you are describing who are locked out of professional degrees, the limits on professional degrees, so particularly, you know, nurse practitioners and other people in these advanced health care fields who are not doctors, they are exactly that prime kind of target, right? For a SoFi or for a Sallie Mae, this is the person who they are going to go after. Those borrowers cannot expect their tuition to decrease to match the Federal loan limit. They are going to end up paying for high cost, private student loans to fill the gap. Mr. Courtney. With private loans, I mean there is always an underwriting component in terms of, you know, trying to qualify for a loan. Whether it is a collateral requirement or, you know, just again a financial position where the bank, you know, can certify that it is a low-risk loan. Banks again have sort of recognized that this is going to be an issue for a lot of students, because they are now basically talking about coming to Congress to ask for loan guarantees, which is really just a, you know, basically a trip back in time in terms of just the sort of the ripoff that was in, the student loan space, where banks were getting basically total government guarantees as well as higher interest rates. I mean that is really sort of where they are trying to push the system, is that not correct? Dr. Morgan. Yes, exactly. We have seen this play before, right, from the banks, where they get people hooked on the student loans and then they come in and they say, you know, if we cannot offer the loans, people will not have access to college. Why do you not help us out here, and it ends up costing the Federal Government an enormous amount of money and really for what, right? You know, I think the other thing to think about here is like for people who cannot get that loan from a Sallie Mae or a Navient or a SoFi, they're being turned to credit products that are much more predatory and much worse for them than even those private student loans. We are going to see people taking on credit card debt, we are going to see them increasing their buy now pay later debt and turning to shadier providers with much higher interest rates and much more onerous terms for default. Mr. Courtney. Yes. The title of this hearing really should be about working families getting run over by the One Big Beautiful Bill. Again, I know they are trying to rebrand the H.R. 1 to a different title, but the fact of the matter is, is most people in this country have sort of figured out what a scam it is. The American Nursing Association, when this announcement came out in November, they made it crystal clear we have a nursing shortage in this country. This whole enterprise is going to aggravate that nursing shortage. Mr. Chairman, I have a letter from the American Association of Nurse Anesthesiology, which again lays out the reason why-- the record of the fact that their members have almost a perfect record in terms of loan repayment. Again, the qualifications are highly stringent. They do incredibly important work. I just had a knee replacement in December. The anesthesiologist did a great job and I really appreciate that. Again, I would ask that it be entered into the record. Chairman Owens. No objection. [The letter of Mr. Courtney follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Courtney. I would also note that on January 29th, the comment period started for people on this new rule out of the Department of Education, Honestly, I think every Member of Congress should be standing up for the health care providers, the caring professions. The fact that we have a shortage of critical people in our health care system, which is only going to get worse, is being aggravated by H.R. 1's loan caps that again, are just going to, you know, really hit one of the most critical sectors of our economy. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. Now I would like to recognize my friend from Florida, Mr. Fine. Mr. Fine. Thank Mr. Chairman. I would like to use my time to basically brag on Florida, because Florida has led the way. I would be remiss if I did not acknowledge Chancellor Rodrigues, who is a third term member of the Florida House. Took a shy, unassuming, very quiet member when he showed up under his wing and helped show me the ropes. I was privileged during my time in the legislature to help spearhead a lot of the changes we have talked about here today. I chaired Education committees for four of my eight and a half years. While we have talked about loans, one of the things we have not spoken about in Florida is that in the State of Florida, every single student, everyone if they work hard has the ability to go to one of our State institutions for free. In the State of Florida, we offer free in-State tuition to every single student who gets an IB diploma, a Cambridge ACE diploma or frankly, thanks to the hard work of my son, who is now a high school senior, a College Board AP capstone diploma. You get one of those, you go for free. That is no tuition. That is no loans. We do that, I would note, with no State income tax either. That is why perhaps we are the No. 1 State university system in the country, with the lowest tuition. Florida shows how to do this. Now one other way in which Florida has distinguished itself, and I am dealing with this right now as the father of a high school senior, is the safest place in the country for Jewish students to attend school. Little known fact, more Jewish students attend the University of Florida as a raw number than any other institution in the United States, more than any other. Part of the reason for that is a bill that I worked on when I was in the Florida legislature and then House Member Rodrigues voted for House Bill 741, which was signed into law by Governor Ron DeSantis almost 7 years ago on May 29th, 2019, a bill that required that antisemitism be defined and it be treated the same way in our institutions as racism. I would like to take a minute to ask Chancellor Rodrigues to talk about if that bill has been effective in making Florida's institutions safe for Jewish students, and if that might be one of the reasons why more Jewish students go to the University of Florida than any other institution in the United States. Mr. Rodrigues. Thank you for the question. I want to begin by addressing the first part of what you led with, which is what we provide students in addition to those scholarships. Florida's No. 2 in the Nation in financial aid that is awarded to students, and we are No. 2 in merit-based aid as well through Bright Future Scholarships, as well as the ones you have mentioned. It has played a big role in allowing the best of our State to remain in our State and go to school for free. In terms of your legislation, it was very important. After the events of October 7th, we saw demonstrations occurring in campuses across this country. While other states were struggling with whether the demonstrations crossed into the action of antisemitism, in Florida we had a definition of antisemitism because of your bill. In Florida, there was no ambiguity. We took the step of ensuring that First Amendment rights were protected. If students wanted to demonstrate, they could. We regulated the time, place and manner. We had a working definition of antisemitism, we were able to ensure that our Jewish students were not harassed and we were able to ensure that none of the demonstrations impacted our classes or our common spaces like libraries that all students need access to. I would say that the definition, having the definition of antisemitism in statute played a key role in our success. As far as whether that has attracted more students, I do know if you look at applications coming from the northeast to our system, they have gone up since the events of October 7th. I suspect there is correlation, but I do not have any data to support that. Mr. Fine. As a father of a high school senior who applied, and I am happy to note successfully got into all three Florida universities he applied to, I can tell you it is stunning how competitive these institutions. I mean I was shocked. There is not a single Florida State University that does not have competitive applications. There was a time when some of the lower ranked ones, anyone who applied who was qualified could get in. That is no longer the case at any of the 12. Last question, very brief. When I ran that bill, people were concerned about courts finding unconstitutional. In the 7-years that it has been in effect, are you aware of any court cases that said that that bill has been unconstitutional? Mr. Rodrigues. There have been none in Florida. Mr. Fine. All right, thank you. Look, again Florida leads the way. I believe very strongly if every State just replicated what you are doing in Florida, we would not have any of these problems that so many people want to talk about today. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to recognize my friend from Oregon, Ms. Bonamici. Ms. Grijalva from Arizona. Thank you. Ms. Grijalva. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am the proud parent of a freshman at the University of Arizona, and affordability, that affordability gap is real. We have a real problem with working families feeling like they can access higher education for their children. I disagree with the statement that the Chairman mentioned at the beginning, saying well, you know, people are questioning the value of higher education. No, we are questioning whether we can send our kids to school, period. Regardless of how academically, you know, their prowess in classrooms, their support systems here, there and whatever, some of the programs that I believe Federal funds have really done right is programs like TRIO. TRIO are the programs like Upward Bound, Talent Search and Students Support Services, that really help students who are first generation students, who are from families where if these programs were not available, they would not even know how to access loans. I think that that is--those programs are important, and those programs are on the chopping block. Many State and local universities and community colleges have tried to figure out a way to continue to support these programs. I want to recognize Arizona's TRIO professionals and the Western Association of Educational Support Personnel, work I saw firsthand literally just last week, whose 2026 training ``Rooted in Purpose, Growing in Community,'' reflects the essential role of these federally funded programs and how they play in supporting these students that we are talking about, first generation, low income and underrepresented students in our community colleges and universities. While TRIO provides the advocacy and support these students need to navigate higher education, that support must be matched by secure financial foundation. The most effective way to lower costs for these students and their families is to invest in the Pell Grant. As the Federal Government's foundational investment in college affordability, Pell Grants help more than seven million students attend and complete college each year. The evidence is clear. Need-based grant aid increases college enrollment and completion for low and moderate income students. Pell Grants are especially well targeted to those with the greatest financial need. 74 percent of recipients come from families earning 40,000 or less annually, including 34 percent of families earning 15,000 or less. As a result, the Pell Grant program serves as a powerful engine of economic mobility in communities across the country. Notably, 81 percent of black students and nearly three quarters of Latino students receive Pell grants during their time in school. Mr. Chairman, I ask for unanimous consent to enter into the record an article that further details the impact of Pell Grant programs on college access and student success. Chairman Owens. No objection. [The article of Representative Grijalva follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Ms. Grijalva. Thank you. Students across America are struggling to afford college, not only because of tuition but because meeting basic needs like food, housing and childcare has become increasingly difficult. Recognizing these challenges, some institutions are responding with innovative supports for low-income students, including campus food pantries, emergency financial aid, childcare for student parents, flexible options for adult learners. Dr. Morgan, given that the maximum Pell Grant now covers less than a quarter of the cost of attending a 4-year public college, students are facing massive affordability gaps even after receiving aid. Can you provide us with an overview of how this gap contributes to the basic need challenges such as food and housing insecurity that students face today? Dr. Morgan. Yes. I think there are two important factors for us to think about with this basic needs gap. One is the one that you mentioned, which is that the Pell Grant and other aid that students get from their institution or from their State does not cover enough of the cost of college, putting a lot of burden on the individual who, as to your point, from lower income families, particularly students of color, those burdens are already pretty insurmountable in the-- on their own. I think the other thing to think about is that, you know, the burden of paying for college does not fall on a family in a vacuum. It falls in the context of all the other costs that they face, including health care, utilities, all of these costs that are rising under Donald Trump. I think about the cost of health care in particular, where Congress has allowed the subsidies for ACA to lapse, and now families are facing much higher health care costs. For some families, that's an additional $4,000 a year, right? That is the cost of attending a community college. It is a big chunk of attending a 4-year institution, and that is putting even more pressure on the individual. To your point, colleges have done a lot to try to meet these basic needs, but they cannot keep up when this is three in five students who are facing basic needs challenges. Ms. Grijalva. How can Federal, State and local governments work with colleges to support students' basic needs? Dr. Morgan. I think that states and the Federal Government have to step in here. We have to understand that the aid that and the appropriations that we provide to these institutions are going to be the major way of filling that gap. Ms. Grijalva. Yes. The H.R. 1 repayment assistant plan hurts low-income borrowers. Dr. Morgan, for millions of borrowers, student loan repayment is not just a financial issue. It shapes whether you can save for a home and start a family. I appreciate all of your feedback here. Thank you, and I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. Thank you so much. Now my friend from Guam, Mr. Moylan. Mr. Moylan. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and for the Subcommittee hearing today especially. We are finally addressing the runaway college spending that we are seeing today. Dr. Akers, right? You expressed that really well on your opening statement, so thank you so much. It is a runaway college spending situation that we are seeing here. We have a study here provided by the U.S. Consumer Goods and Services and Wages, and it looked at the price changes from the year January 2000 to December 2025. They talked about housing. That was up 111 percent. They talked about medical care, up 140 percent; childcare up 158 percent; and then college tuition up 200 percent. The only thing higher than that was hospital services, but 200 percent from the year 2000 to 2025. It is runaway, as we mentioned what this hearing is about is runaway college spending. The issues are now what are we going to do about it? That is why we are addressing our tax bill here for the Working Families Tax Cuts. We have some meaningful provisions to combat this rising cost of college. Mr. Landward, you mentioned that a study done back in the 80's where the last time a college cost kept up with the pace of median income was back in 1982. That is--Mr. Chairman, I would like to enter the record that we do have a Forbes article specifying that, stating such as it is that the cost of living and college costs are just not staying together. I would like to enter that into the record. Chairman Owens. No objections. [The article of Representative Moylan follows:] [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Moylan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Rodrigues, you reminded me in your opening statement of what I went through going through college myself. I did have those part-time jobs, and I did--actually I joined the Army to help pay for my school and it and it worked out quite well. Back then, it was 1986 when I graduated from college, and I still have friends that I believe are still paying for their student loans as well. That is over 40 years ago. That is why it is important we are having this, and the House Republicans are working for lowering the financial barriers for all students, all students in the states, but also in the territories, the territories Guam, which I am from. It costs us much more to get our professionals degree, to fly to the mainland, to house our students there. Then also the airfare of course, and then we are paying out-of-State tuition in addition to that. Compared to these price changes, it is enormous for the territories to try to get higher education, to travel to the states, and this is why this measure is important. I would like you, Dr. Akers, to please expand upon some of the things you were you were discussing, especially what the results of when we have unlimited Federal borrowing for graduate students. Dr. Akers. This is one of the critical problems that is been plaguing higher education for a decade now. The reconciliation legislation did really a fantastic job in taking a first step toward tackling it. We know that with graduate students able to borrow basically unlimited sums, pair that with a lack of high levels of financial literacy and you get students paying more for their education than it is really going to be worth, and it is really appropriate for both those individuals and for taxpayers. These new limits put in place limits that put downward pressure on institutions, so that they can charge less or they will charge less for these programs. It also ensures that people are not going to be left with that overhang of debt to pay for their graduate and professional degrees that last well into their career. It is a tremendous innovation, most critically as a consumer protection. Mr. Moylan. Thank you for that. Mr. Landward, you also mentioned a 3-year plan. Can you expand a little bit more on that? It sounded really interesting. Mr. Landward. Yes, thank you. Again, this was--this was a conversation with the Utah legislature. In Utah, when you look at the total appropriated funds, tuition and State support, Utah contributes 63 percent of the cost of higher education from taxpayer funds. The question was for taxpayers and for those who represent those taxpayers in the legislature, are they confident that that investment is providing a good return? In other words, is it providing value to the students and is it providing value to the state? They asked us to take a look at all of the programs, all of our administrative costs, basically anything that is included in that cost, that is passed on through tuition and taxpayer support and say ``Can you make cuts in any of these areas, and as a reward for finding those cuts, we'll allow you to keep that investment from the State tax dollars as long as it's going to an area where we're seeing a high return on investment for the State itself.'' When you look at where those reappropriations went to, every single one of the schools in our system got all that money back from the legislature. It went to areas like health care, engineering, computer science, general education, business, technical education. These are all programs that have high enrollment, high completion, high return on investment for the students, and they also help drive our economy. Mr. Moylan. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to now recognize my friend from Oregon, Ms. Bonamici. Ms. Bonamici. Thank you Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member, and thank you to the witnesses. The cost of college is rising. That is clear. I hope my Republican colleagues can recognize that. As Dr. Morgan said, one of the reasons is the persistent disinvestment in higher education at the State level. My colleague from Guam mentioned something about 1982. Well in 1980, which happened to be the year I graduated from college and started law school, 79 percent of the revenue for public colleges came from State and local funds. By 2021, it had dropped to 57 percent. I would not be here today if I did not have the grants, loans and work study that I got to work my way through 2 years of community college, 2 years of college and 3 years of law school, with a very manageable amount of debt. I will tell you, work study was a great program. We need to enhance that. I have been working on that for a while. We could also make a significant difference if we invested more at the Federal level. It is not a lack of resources. It is a policy choice. Now, I want to talk about the H.R. 1, which I call Big Ugly Bill, because I do not think it is beautiful. You know, I support Workforce Pell, but I want those Workforce Pell Grants to be available to people who affirmatively want to go into workforce jobs, not as a backup for somebody who thinks I really could do well in college, but I cannot afford it. First, we talked about this already in the Committee. The H.R. 1 cuts Medicaid and SNAP, which is making it harder for families to pay for health care and groceries. Now states, as I know as a former State legislator, are trying to fill those gaps with their limited budgets and students will pay the price. Yes, they say Working Families Tax Cuts is part of the title of this hearing. At the same time, all the other costs are going up because of chaotic tariff policies, not addressing things like affordable housing. We are already facing those high costs for food, rent, health care, utility bills. Here is a point I want to emphasize. That Big Ugly Bill gave ICE $75 billion, close to 75 billion, that is with a B dollars, and the Customs and Border Patrol almost 65 billion with a B dollars. That was a policy choice. It certainly was not mine. That does not sound so beautiful to me. In fact, it is been pretty catastrophic on many levels. I submit that if we had invested that $140 billion in education and economic development instead, we would be far better off as a Nation. I want to ask you, Dr. Morgan, how does a fully funded public university system contribute to the economy and the well-being of the country? Dr. Morgan. Having a strong, robust public education system contributes not only to the ability of individuals to get ahead, but it also contributes to our communities and to states' economies as a whole. You know, our college and university system can be a driver of innovation. It can be a driver of workforce development and a way to handle kind of planning for the technological changes that are coming our way. In fact, we are seeing the opposite in the country right now. You know, to your point, we are seeing investments in tax cuts for the wealthy. We're seeing investments in ICE, and we're ignoring these really critical parts of our infrastructure that help us prepare and build the kind of communities we---- Ms. Bonamici. I also serve on the Science, Space and Technology Committee, which I have been running back and forth to. I want to say that, you know, right now a lot of people in our institutes of higher education who are getting degrees in sciences, they are being recruited by other countries. That is a serious concern, and we have scientists and people who come to this--people who come to this country to study and learn. That is a benefit for us, and we are seeing them not wanting to come right now because of cuts to research, cuts to science and because of the terrible immigration policies that are making them feel afraid to come to this country. I also want to talk about eliminating the Graduate Plus Loan program, and establishing loan caps on professional degrees. Many prospective nurses, and we have heard a lot from nurses. I know as a bipartisan--co-chair of the Bipartisan Nursing Caucus, they are concerned, teachers, social workers, that they will not get the financial support they need to complete their degrees. I am not sure if Republicans thought that this would somehow force institutions to lower their tuition when they want to implement this. It seems implausible in light of the myriad financial pressures that they already face. Dr. Morgan, how does H.R. 1 affect the ability of low-income students to afford nursing medical school? How will this affect access to affordable health care in the long term, especially in rural and underserved areas? How should Congress reform graduate school funding to better serve and support students, rather than eliminating graduate loan program and establishing loan caps? What would be a better alternative? Dr. Morgan. This bill is going to make it much, much more expensive for people to pursue education in health care fields, and particularly for people who are left out of that professional degree categorization, which was a policy choice by the Trump administration to narrowly define professional degrees. It is going to cost people a lot more money. I think your question asks a larger question about what this means for our health care system. If you look at H.R. 1 as a whole, it is putting our entire health care system at risk, right? We are making it harder for people to be insured. We are making it harder for people to be able to work in hospitals, and I think we are reaching a point where people are seeing that every time they walk into a doctor office. Ms. Bonamici. I represent a lot of rural areas as well as urban areas, and the word I have heard over and over from health care providers and systems like the hospital association is catastrophic. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like now to recognize my friend from Wisconsin, Mr. Grothman. Mr. Grothman. First of all, a couple comments. Everybody loves Workforce Pell because it sounds so good. One of the degrees that they made the pitch on in my area was truck driving, where they can go to tech school and learn how to drive a truck. I called some of my local trucking firms, because I figured the law of supply and demand should be taking care of that. Sure enough, all of the ones that I talked to were already paying for the tuition, the trucking firm. All it was, all we are doing with Workforce Pell is we are spending government dollars on a problem that was already being solved by the private sector. I do not know anybody else called their trucking firms. By the way, the same thing is true of advanced welding degrees. The companies were paying for it by their own, and now we got the government coming in paying for something that the private sector is paying for anyway. It seems to me one of the big problems to education is frequently people get degrees that there is not value. We will come back to nursing in a second, which is a great value. You know, plumber, electrician today where we have such a huge shortage, those guys can be making far more than college graduates. Does anybody have any suggestions how we can prevent students not from getting a Nursing degree, but prevent students from getting a Psychology degree or Communication Arts degree, when they could do so much better going into the trades? That is where I think the real problem is. You want to take a crack at it, Beth? Dr. Akers. I can jump in there. You know, my feeling is that we have an insufficiently informed set of consumers when it comes to higher education. We have done too little to help people understand what it is that they are paying for, what they are likely to pay and what opportunity it is going to deliver to them in the future. Surveys show that people go to college for primarily one reason, and that is to make more money. If we give people and empower them with this information, they will make the choices that lead them down those paths. That is, I think, what the role of government is today. Mr. Grothman. OK. Just another factoid that I have been trying to point out here. You see those Walmart trucks driving around, you know, live better, whatever it is said in the back of the Walmart trucks. Those guys make 140 grand a year, just so you know. OK. I think one of the reasons I want some of you guys to comment on it, well first of all, I'll take a little bit of a shot at what we are doing here, because I had some people from the private colleges in my office the other day and with regard to nursing. They knew people who wanted to go through that program in like 3 years and wanted to go to summer school, as well as the regular time. They felt that because we could not--because of the annual cap in student loan debt, that those students could not get through, say in 3 years like they wanted. Do you think, Dr. Akers, there is any way to tinker with that program, to get a little more out to kids who are doing summer school? Dr. Akers. I cannot say I am an expert exactly on the mechanics of how we would make that possible, but that seems like a reasonable accommodation. Mr. Grothman. OK. It is reasonable. Well, we will let our Committee Chair--he is not here anymore. We will let him remember that it is reasonable. I think one of the reasons why the cost of college has gone through the roof is the number of non-teaching personnel and universities and colleges has gone through the roof in the last 40 years, right? Normally, you would think if I am going to set up a college, the vast majority of my employees are going to be professors or teachers of some sort. Instead, we have had a skyrocketing number of people in non-teaching positions. Does anyone care why that is true or comment on that? Mr. Rodrigues. I will take a stab at that. Mr. Grothman. OK. Mr. Rodrigues. I read a study that was released a year ago by an economist at AEI, Preston Cooper. He looked at all of the administration across higher ed education from IPEDS. He pulled the IPEDS data, and the big takeaway I took from his study is there has been tremendous growth in administration, but that tremendous growth is isolated to the top quintile. For example, the institutions in the top quintile have about 161 administrators per 1,000 students, whereas the median across the country is 70. In Florida, we have 62 per thousand students. I think what we are seeing is a significant increase. That increase is largely isolated to Ivy League, Ivy League plus and very prominent flagship institutions. The vast majority of the institutions have had a very slow growth over that time. Mr. Grothman. I am not sure that it is right. You mentioned administrators, and one of the areas that I think is going up is counselors and those sort of people. Thank you very much for giving me an extra 10 seconds. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to now recognize my friend from Georgia, Ms. McBath. Ms. McBath. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman, and thank you all for coming today. Thank you to each of our witnesses. I do not have any formal questions for you today, but I would like to say that the American people know that it has become far too expensive to simply get the skills necessary to provide a decent life for themselves and for their families. The solution to that problem is not to cut Federal dollars and to force students and families to make up the difference on their own with their savings, or by taking out high interest loans that they will never be able to pay those back. The Republican reconciliation bill does nothing to really lower the price of higher education on the back end, or help people keep more of their own money. All this does is shift more of the cost of school away from the taxpayer dollars that people have already paid toward money that they have saved on their own. People are going to pay more of their own money for school, while they pay the same amount in tax and get less in return from their government. Regardless of what you hear today, that truly is the truth. I believe it is the major reason why the American people are so frustrated with their government. Instead of using tax dollars for schools and scholarships, instead of using the people's money for programs that really help them afford basics like daycare, prescription drugs or any of the things that have gotten too expensive, this majority holds hearings and votes on bills to act like they are addressing these problems as they push policies that make these problems worse. Every Republican member of the House, except for two, voted to cut the Pell Grant and to take it away from part-time students who may be working or raising a family. Just two. The Pell Grant, a program for students with significant financial need for the students and families who have the least in our country. There are members of this majority who had millions of dollars in PPP loans forgiven during the pandemic, but refuse to help nurses and teachers go to school, so that they can do some of the most important jobs that are needed in our society. There are members of this body who had loans forgiven for amounts that many Americans only dream of making in their lifetimes, all while they cut funding for health, health care and education. Time and time again, Republicans ask the American people to listen to what they say, but please ignore what they do, to ignore the loans that they secure and forgive for themselves while they ask everyday people to buckle down and make sacrifices. Before coming to Congress, I was a flight attendant for 30 years, so I know what it is like to be a single mom and I know what it is like to struggle to make ends meet. Instead of doing anything to make life more affordable like capping interest rates on loans, Republicans are making Americans pay more for something that is as basic as getting a decent job. At a time when Americans are looking for some breathing room to keep their head above water, this majority continues to support policies that squeeze them as much as possible. I would like to remind everyone that these are choices that this majority actively makes every single day. They choose to make life more expensive and increase the national debt that they claim that they care so much about. They choose to cut programs for disabled students, to cut grants and scholarships for the lowest income students and families in this country. The American people are tired of these broken promises. They are tired of being asked to give more and more and more of themselves while it gets harder and more expensive to acquire the skills necessary to just get a decent job and keep it. I yield. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to now recognize my friend from Missouri, Dr. Onder. Mr. Onder. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to all the witnesses for appearing here today in front of this Subcommittee. Last year, House Republicans and the Trump administration put an end to a government policy that exploded college costs, unlimited student loan borrowing. Before the passage of the Working Families Tax Cut Act, colleges were incentivized to raise the cost of attendance far beyond the pace of inflation, because they knew they could count on the Federal Government to subsidize the increase. However, the job is not done. We can continue to make college more affordable by improving price transparency, something we need in many areas of the economy including my own area of health care. I am working with my friend from Kentucky, Chairman Brett Guthrie, on the Student Financial Clarity Act. Our bill creates a universal net price calculator and expands the College Scorecard, so students can compare costs, outcomes and financial aid across multiple institutions. This Committee has approved that bill, and I am hopeful that it will be brought to the house floor soon. After college, many students do not know how to navigate the loan repayment process. They are overwhelmed and do not feel they fully understand there will ever be an end in sight. They receive loan disclosures that are hard to understand. The disclosures should prioritize important personalized information such as origination fees, interest rates and early payment plans. Current law only requires lenders to give three disclosures, one at reimbursement, one before repayment--one at disbursement, one at or before repayment and one during repayment status. Ms. Akers, do you think students would benefit from regular monthly disclosures during the life of their loan? Dr. Akers. Absolutely. We know from research that students are not aware of how much they are borrowing, even just months after signing their initial promissory note, so the system is really broken. This is in the interest of the institutions, who do not necessarily want them to have a top of mind how much they are paying every semester. Mr. Onder. Yes. Dr. Akers. It is something that we need to fix, absolutely. Mr. Onder. Do you think that those disclosures should include projected monthly payments based on how much a student borrowed, with an option to pay any interest that accrues while the borrower is still in school? Dr. Akers. Absolutely. I ran an experiment probably 10 years ago trying to show that when we give people this information, they become better informed, make better choices. Turns out they had so little information, anything we gave them moved, you know, was a huge game changer. I think that we need to put this information into context for student borrowers. That big number of how much they are borrowing maybe $30,000 for STEM students, might be meaningless for somebody who has never managed a household budget. Mr. Onder. Exactly. Dr. Akers. Anything adding context to allow people to make better decisions, because if we empower them to do so, they will make the right decisions for themselves. I think this is a step in the right direction. Mr. Onder. I think a lot of policy error errors we make in Washington regarding economic and social policy assume that people are not rational economic actors. I think that is far from the case. I think in almost every context in life, human beings are rational economic actors, but they cannot be if there is not price transparency and transparency about terms of complex financial instruments like loans, so I appreciate that. You know, fortunately there is also a bill that accomplishes the above, the Student Loan Disclosure Transparency Act. This bill was introduced last Congress by then-Congresswoman Abigail Spanberger, and I look forward to reintroducing it with her successor Congressman Vindman as a co-lead. Let us see how much time do I have left? Finally, I want to examine a State level reform to make college more affordable again. As everyone in this room knows, the Federal Government plays a limited role in education policy and often states lead the way. By rewarding professors for strong student outcomes, tenure reform could increase institutional efficiency and refocus spending on student success. Mr. Landward, in your testimony you discussed Utah's success with post-tenure review system reform. How does Utah's post-tenure review system help institutions control college costs for students and taxpayers? Mr. Landward. Well, the intent here is accountability and value. Again, we are relentless on just asking the question. Anybody who is employed at any of our universities, no matter what role, we have to ask the question are you contributing to the core mission of the institution? Are you doing so efficiently and effectively? With post-tenure review, this is an opportunity to give us sightlines into the performance of every professor, no matter what their status is in the faculty ranks. This allows us to ensure that there is an annual review of their performance-based on factors, there is a comprehensive post-tenure review every 5 years. That we are only making decisions based on substantive issues with their teaching and research and not political issues or other items. It balances that along with due process, to ensure that we can protect academic freedom and still have transparency and accountability and performance. Mr. Onder. Thank you very much. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to now recognize my friend from California, Mr. DeSaulnier. Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to thank all the witnesses. It is an important discussion. I appreciate it being here. In the discussion in this Committee for the past year, we have had a lot of not very subtle sort of elites versus working people. I am reminded of my parents, who were the first people in their families to ever go to college and how proud they were of that. My dad's dad was a cab driver in Lowell, Massachusetts who ended up owning the company, but never went to college. My mom's dad was a firefighter, an Irish firefighter outside of Boston, who could imagine, who was very proud of the fact that he worked very hard so that his daughter could go to college. One of the things I wanted to ask you, Dr. Morgan, is sort of following in that, which we forget sometimes that the American higher education system is something to be tremendously proud of. Like all human institutions, it has its shortcomings and sometimes things that I disagree with. The importance of remembering that the people who go to college are like my grandparents aspiring for their kids to go to college. It is not all people who have had the good fortune to inherit a lot of money. Most people are aspired to it. In California, I am very proud of the University of California, California State University system and particularly the community college system, so that there is a track if people choose, if they want to do--if want to graduate from high school and do career tech that is great too, and we have a great program for that. Really discouraging the past year and all the politics, the optics of who are fighting for working people and elites and other class sort of challenges that this country has had. Dr. Morgan, what are the things that really stand out to you in what we refer to on our side as the Big Ugly Bill, that really make it harder for that tradition of Americans to be able to aspire if they choose to go to college? Dr. Morgan. I really appreciate your question. I also grew up in a working-class area of Massachusetts, where not a lot of people went to college. Mr. DeSaulnier. You do not have an accent. Way to go. Dr. Morgan. Over time, I just lost it. Mr. DeSaulnier. I was born in Lowell and grew up and went to college in Worcester. Dr. Morgan. Oh, great. I grew up in Fall River. Mr. DeSaulnier. Oh, Fall River. Wicked. Go Pats. Dr. Morgan. You saw exactly what you were describing, you know. People were really focused on getting their kids a better life, a more secure life than what they had. They are saving to send their kids to college, and you know, in many cases that is what we want for our country, right? What we have seen over time, from the time that I was going to college to now, that people have to take on incredible amounts of debt, both parents and students, to make that happen, right? They are ending up in a very risky situation, where if they do not get the job that they thought they were going to get, they do not have that income they thought, they are going to be struggling to repay those loans and regretting the decision. H.R. 1 makes that much more risky for people. You know, we are going to see the Medicaid and SNAP cuts squeeze State budgets, to push public tuition, public college tuition even higher, and the bill makes it more expensive for people to pay back their loans as well. If you are one of those people who takes on more debt than you can afford based on your income, this bill pushes you closer to default than you would have been otherwise. Mr. DeSaulnier. I listen to younger people all the time, my two sons in particular, who complain about Baby Boomers and Elizabeth Warren's great book, ``The Two Income Track,'' long before she got involved in politics, I think really summed up the challenges generationally, that the five wholesale costs that economists count are education, health care, transportation, I am spacing, taxes, and I am spacing on the last one. When you look at those generationally and education, a key part of that and what we just talked about, it really makes the affordability issue tougher. I heard a comment in a meeting today that wages are far underperforming GDP, so all that money is going to capital investors. The concentration of wealth is getting worse and worse, and education is part of that. The very thing that some of my colleagues rail about when they complain about elitism, their actions from my perspective, are fostering that. Working people and poor people cannot afford to go to higher education when they have to worry about their paycheck to paycheck. The rest of the GDP is growing because of private equity. Dr. Morgan. Absolutely. We are increasing that gap between working class families and the wealthiest families in this country. Increasingly, our economy is getting tied up only in the decisions made by that wealthy elite part of the country, and the rest of us are kind of left on our own. It is really concerning. The only other thing I would say is that those same things that Elizabeth Warren wrote about so many years ago, education, health care, housing, those are the same costs that we are still waiting for our leaders to fix for us, so that we can all live a more secure and stable life. Mr. DeSaulnier. Well, as Benjamin Franklin said at the founding of this country, any investment in education will always be the best investment for Americans. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to now have my friend from California, Mr. Kiley, recognized. Mr. Kiley. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A little over 2 years ago, we reached this crisis point in American higher education, with sort of the, you know, the horrifying antisemitism that we saw on our college campuses, bringing this crisis into sharp relief. I said at the time, this was a moment of reckoning for American higher education where, you know, we saw our universities, which are supposed to be the leading centers of open discourse and debate, had become some of the most repressive institutions in American life in terms of censorship and limiting free speech. We saw our universities, which are supposed to be places where humanist values flourish, becoming hotbeds of one of the world's most retrograde and ancient prejudices when it came to antisemitism. Then at the same time, it gave us an occasion to focus on other aspects of university life, where more and more our universities were becoming costlier and costlier for students, a greater and greater source of indebtedness for graduates and yet delivering less and less value, were not well adapted, in many cases, to the demands of our modern economy and our workforce. In response, this Committee has been trying to tackle reforming American higher education from all of these different angles. We of course have had a still ongoing investigation into antisemitism, with a number of leading university presidents resigning after testifying before this Committee. In conjunction with that, we have seen in many institutions renewed commitments to freedom of speech, efforts to take antisemitism, treat it with the seriousness that it deserves, faculty reforms, reforms designed to promote institutional neutrality, reforms to eliminate coerced, so-called diversity statements. There has been some pretty good progress in that respect, though there is certainly a long ways to go. Then on the other side of the issue with H.R. 1, we of course addressed the indebtedness and affordability aspects of the problem, with trying to make college more affordable, limit indebtedness and providing incentives to teach skills that are of economic value to graduates. We have made progress there as well, though again we still have a long way to go, and a lot of the reforms that need to happen, particularly when it comes to our public institutions, do exist at the State level. I am really glad that we have with us today two leaders of systems that have been very innovative in that respect. I would just like to give Commissioner Landward and Chancellor Rodrigues an opportunity to discuss some of the reforms you have highlighted today, but how your efforts sort of work toward addressing all of these aspects in a way that focuses the mission of the university on what universities are there for, and ultimately allows you to serve your students and limit the costs and expense that goes into getting an education. Mr. Landward. Thank you for the question. With the risk of sounding reductive, in operating a system of higher education, a public system of higher education, the first question that we have to ask is how is what we provide going to benefit the State of Utah and its citizens? Every dollar that comes in should provide value to the State. It should help drive economic prosperity. It should better the lives of the people that live within the State. It should provide students who receive or degrees or certificates high value in what they are offered. It is a fundamental question you have to continue to ask in everything that we do, whether it is how we design our system, how we approach tuition and fee-setting, how we approach what programs we offer and where they offer them, how we approach the mission of each institution. The question is will this benefit the students and will this benefit the state? If we look at anything that is beyond that mission of that system or beyond the mission of the institution, then we have to question why we are providing it and why we are funding it. If we just continue to ask those questions, is this best for the State, is this best for the student, we often get to the right decision no matter what is happening around us, no matter what the swirl is saying. Those fundamental principles that we go back to lead to those better decisions. That is we want higher education to be valuable and we want it to benefit the State and the student. Mr. Kiley. Great perspective. Does it benefit the state? Does it benefit the student? Chancellor Rodrigues. Mr. Rodrigues. Thank you for the question. I mentioned in my opening remarks. We embrace performance-based funding. We have metrics. In addition to retention and graduation and post- graduate employment, we have metrics that tie our degrees to the workforce needs of the State, programs of strategic emphasis in both our undergraduate and graduate degrees. The reason we have those metrics is to encourage universities to grow those majors, so that the students benefit with a well-paying job when they graduate. Mr. Kiley. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think that your efforts provide a great model, and the work of this Committee has been truly of paramount importance when it comes to reforming higher education for the benefit of our young people and for our country's future. I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you so much. I would like to recognize my colleague from Minnesota, Ms. Omar. Ms. Omar. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Over the past year, we have heard our Republican colleagues claim that their solution in the One Big Beautiful Bill will somehow make college cheaper for working families. This is the same bill that cut a trillion dollars out of Medicaid and over $180 billion, from SNAP. The logic is hard to follow. By leaving millions without health care and struggling to buy groceries, higher education will apparently just become more accessible. It is no wonder that when the American people finally had the chance to see what was in this hideous bill, it was so unpopular that my Republican counterparts had to rebrand the name. Just because you put working families in the title does not mean you are not screwing them over. The reality is there is no amount of sugarcoating that can undo the damage that will be done by this disastrous legislation. Ms. Morgan, I would like to ask you some basic questions. To correct the record, Ms. Morgan, does this law, this new law, require schools to immediately lower their costs? Dr. Morgan. It does not. Ms. Omar. Does this law drastically increase funding for Pell Grants and other grant programs, so that its students will not have to borrow loans to go to college? Dr. Morgan. It does not. Ms. Omar. OK. Without more grant assistance, without forcing colleges to lower their costs, does this bill provide more access to Federal loans? Dr. Morgan. It does not. Ms. Omar. All right, thank you. We are not making colleges lower their costs, we are not providing more grant aid. We are not taking--we are not taking away Federal loan options. Where do we expect families to come up with the money to make up the differences, Ms. Morgan? Dr. Morgan. I think there are two options. I think there are people who will not go to college because college has become more expensive under this bill, and I think there are people who are going to take on private student loan debts---- Ms. Omar. All right. Let us talk about the private market. When this bill was being considered by Congress, private lenders were celebrating because they knew that this was their opportunity to cash in on the backs of families desperate to find a way to pay for their kids to go to college, because these type of loans involve a lot more financial risk and fewer protections for consumers. Ms. Morgan, can you expand on why these private loans are so risky? Dr. Morgan. You know, there are a couple of different kinds of private loans. There are what we consider to be like the bread-and-butter private loans that are offered by maybe like a Sallie Mae or a Navient. These loans are going to have a higher interest rate, and they are going to have fewer options for people when they get in trouble on paying their loan. They do not have the forgiveness options, they do not have the income-based repayment options. There is another kind of like underbelly of the student loan program that is predatory credit products. They arere going to be available to lower income students who cannot get those bread and butter products, and those are going to be even worse. They are going to have higher interest rates, they are going to have more onerous repayment terms and they are going to land people in default. Ms. Omar. Uh-huh. How does the Trump administration's gutting of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau increase these risks? Dr. Morgan. There is no cop on the beat anymore. You know, there is no one keeping an eye on those private student lenders to make sure not even that they are treating students well, right? That they are just following the basics of our consumer financial laws. I think that is a huge concern. I think the other thing to bear in mind is that the CFPB over the past 4 years has still been trying to clean up the problems we saw private student lenders caused two decades ago. There are people who are still trying to deal with loans that they took out 20 years ago through predatory colleges and predatory lenders, and so there is no one--there is no one there to help those borrowers either. Ms. Omar. It is clear that the Republicans Big Ugly Bill does nothing to make college more affordable. What it does do very well is push working families into the jaws of the private market. Thank you so much for your testimony today, and I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like now to recognize my friend from Washington, Mr. Baumgartner. Mr. Baumgartner. Well, thank you Mr. Chair, and thank you for holding such an important hearing. Higher education is truly one of the gems of American society in the way it creates social mobility, innovation that fuels our economy and research that advances our family farms. It is a jewel that has become tarnished in recent years with runaway costs and a growing leftist political agenda that has replaced the skills needed for the American job market with a radical and sometimes Marxist political ideology on college campus. We certainly have a lot of work to do to polish this gem. I salute the Big Beautiful Bill and the work of this Committee for doing some of that important polishing earlier this year. I am the son of a university professor and grew up in a college town. After attending Washington State University, I went to Africa and spent a year as a volunteer teaching at Catholic University of Mozambique. Then went to Harvard for a master's degree, where I was also a teaching fellow and taught some Harvard undergrads. While a State senator, I spent a little bit of time teaching at Sciences Po University, a counterinsurgency course at Sciences Po University in Paris, which is sometimes referred to as the Harvard of France. I have had a wide variety of experiences in higher education. I would not consider myself an expert, but I have had a wide variety. What I have come to conclude is there's not a lot of difference in undergraduate education outside of the will of students to work, that they can great education at really any institution if they have high standards and a culture of education. That is why it is so distressing to me we have these mounting student debt loads across the country, because we are taking away students' freedoms and their families' freedoms with all of this debt that has been piled on to college education, that really does not serve an educational purpose. When I was in the Washington State Legislature, the Democrats-- unusual before Washington State Republicans actually had control of the Senate. When I got there, we won some elections and had good members and did smart things and not stupid things and we took the majority. What happened with the Democrats when they were running the Washington State Legislature is they had paid a lot of lip service to higher ed. It was always their fourth or fifth favorite priority. What they had really done is defunded higher education and used those funds to expand social welfare services and health care, give State employees across the board big pay increases and moved this money out of higher education and then look to students to backfill with increasing debt burdens. When Republicans took control, one things I said is we got to color in bright, big, beautiful lines, like Ronald Reagan said to do, and let us actually reduce the cost of college tuition. I helped Republicans, and one of my colleagues, John Braun, was State senator there working with me, actually ran the bill. We reduced the price of college in Washington State by 20 percent in our regional universities and 15 percent of our flagships, and then backfilled the universities. In part we could do that because we could do things in a higher ed for pennies on the dollar compared to K through 12. I always argued, you know, it is hard for Republicans to win to spending war with the Democrats and the teachers union on K through 12. When we did that, we dropped the price by mandate, and then we locked future costs of college to inflation plus population growth and said ``Universities, this is the structure you have to work within.'' I see no reason why higher education costs need to go up higher than inflation as population. Frankly they should be lower, because they already have a lot of infrastructure. That would be one idea. I also think that we should always articulate that the right price for college is the price that every student should get through with no debt. By that, I do not mean that it should be subsidized, or that we need to have the taxpayers to do this. The right price for college ought to be incentivizing work for a reasonable summer job and part-time work, so that people can work their way through college. I think that should be our north star in what the price of the college should be, that there is an expectation that students going to work. That does not mean every student gets to go to Mazatlan on spring break and have three Starbucks frappuccinos a day, and live this Kim Kardashian lifestyle that they see on social media. It means that you go to your local college or community college, you work and you get through college with zero debt. I really think that is something that Republicans and Democrats can unify on. I think part of the recipe has to be forcing the colleges to, like the administration is doing, to get back to the basics, and I salute that. Some of that needs to be not allowing so much predatory lending, which has gone on. The Federal Government has facilitated these debt loads. If we can just get back to the basics of a streamlined undergraduate model that focuses on core competencies that the government wants, and is not always about climbing walls and ice rinks and keeping up with the Kardashians social media nonsense and just get back, we can repolish this gem and I think in a way that Republicans and Democrats can work together. I salute the good work of this Committee hearing. I am out of time now after my little soliloquy here, but would enjoy discussing with each of you this idea, particularly the north star of what the price should be and whether we can keep college tuition growth underneath inflation plus population like Republicans did in the Washington State Legislature. Thank you very much Mr. Chair, and with that I yield back. Chairman Owens. Thank you so much. I would like to recognize my friend from Pennsylvania, Mr. Mackenzie. Mr. Mackenzie. Great. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and appreciate all the panelists being with us here today. I represent the Lehigh Valley and Pennsylvania region that has a tremendous amount of institutions of higher education. We are very proud of all of those organizations and entities that provide great educational opportunities for people not only in our region, but from around the country. Over the past several decades, though, we have seen that the cost of higher education has risen far faster than families are able to keep up with. This has led many students to take on increasingly large amounts of debt or be priced out of college education altogether. I would like to ask our panelists, we have two individuals from institutions of higher education. What are the most practical and effective steps that institutes of higher education can take right now to reduce the cost and make college more affordable to students and families? I will go to Mr. Landward first. Mr. Landward. Thank you. Well, there are several things that you can do. You know, one is to have good metrics into the performance of every single program at the program level, to know what are the cost of the degrees, what are the outcomes, what are the completion rates, what are the enrollments, and make hard decisions when the data does not support the programs. That is the first thing. The second thing is to stay within your mission and role. Do not duplicate, in a State system anyway, what you can accomplish through partnerships within the State system and provide access to good programming, good degrees, good certificates to students across the State through partnerships among institutions, rather than institutions competing against each other. Another thing that I think is not talked about enough is building a robust partnership with the K through 12 system in each State, to have concurrent enrollment offerings. In Utah, 26 percent of our high school students have concurrent enrollment courses. They are enrolled in college. We charge $5 per credit hour to those students. They have saved well over $100 million in tuition in 1 year alone in Utah by enrolling concurrent enrollment, and have earned over 400,000 credits at that significantly reduced price. Now they can enter college with a headstart in completing faster, and that means more savings. That kind of partnership is another area that you can do now that has a profound impact. Mr. Mackenzie. Fantastic, and appreciate those thoughts. We have a similar program with dual enrollment for our high school students and our local community college, which works very well. I will go next to Mr. Rodrigues for your thoughts. Mr. Rodrigues. Thank you for the question. As I mentioned earlier, we have accountability in our system through performance-based funding. One of our metrics from day one has been affordability. That is something we measure our institutions on, and then appropriate based upon their success. The most significant change we have made in Florida to impact the cost of students was about 5 years into our performance-based funding. We changed our metric on completion, left the universal 6-year graduation metric and adopted a 4- year graduation metric, encouraging our institutions to identify what are the barriers that are keeping their students from graduating in 4 years and giving them the incentives to eliminate those barriers. If you do that right off the bat, you are saving your students 50 percent of the costs, because they are getting out in 4 years instead of six. We all had barriers. What we found in Florida was we had institutions that were not offering the classes that were needed or were not offering enough sections that were needed for students to graduate. We had--in programs, we had a number of programs, 87 majors where institutions had added additional requirements that forced the student to stay there more than 4 years. Then we had institutions that did not have enough student advisors to guide the students through the process. We made changes in each of those areas. Now our 4-year graduation rate is 60 percent, which is just a tick below the national 6-year graduation rate of 65 percent for public universities. We are almost doing in 4 years what the typical public university does in six. That is why our students are leaving with little debt in addition to our lowest tuition in the Nation. Mr. Mackenzie. Great. Well, I appreciate that, and those types of reforms are critically important, and I think that kind of thinking, not just sticking with the status quo, saying we want to do better, is very much appreciated. With the time remaining, I will go to Dr. Akers. Is there anything that you recommend that we in Congress should be doing to limit or reduce the cost of higher education and limit the amount of student debt? Dr. Akers. Well, I am absolutely thrilled with the progress that was made through the reconciliation legislation. I would like to see that work continued, particularly in introducing the price metric into the accountability mechanism that was introduced through the ``do no economic harm'' standard for programs of study. Basically, when a program is offering a really low cost, I think that can be an additional way for them to pass the threshold of participating in the lending program. Mr. Mackenzie. Great. Well thank you, all of you. Again, our institutions of higher education are one of the real bright spots in this country. We want to continue those opportunities for students and families to succeed in life. We have got to make sure though it is an affordable opportunity for everybody. Thank you again for being here. With that, I yield back to the Chairman. Chairman Owens. Thank you. I would like to now recognize my friend from Virginia, Ranking Member Scott. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms. Akers, we have heard a lot about the value of the education. Just checking, is there inherent value in a 4-year on-campus liberal arts education that cannot be monetized? Dr. Akers. Absolutely, I believe that is true. There is monetary value in college degrees. There is also something that is intangible and difficult to measure. I emphasize the financial return on investment, because that feels like the first and most important step to making sure that Americans are able to be prosperous. Mr. Scott. The Federal Government does have an interest in funding that kind of education? Dr. Akers. Absolutely. Mr. Scott. OK. Mr. Landward, the same question? Mr. Landward. Yes, it does. In fact, when we have made reforms to how we are funding higher education, one of the priorities that we still maintained was that we need a strong thriving general education program in all of our degrees. Frankly, we are--we are doing a good job of giving our graduates occupational skills. What employers are telling us is they still lack durable skills, and those durable skills oftentimes come from liberal arts degrees in general education. Mr. Scott. Thank you. Dr. Morgan, we have heard about the difficulty that the Big Ugly Bill has caused, and the choice they have when they run out of money. They either do not go and lose the opportunity, or get into the private market, whatever they can get. What are the consumer protections in Federal financial loans that are not available in the private sector? Dr. Morgan. I think the main protections are when you get into trouble on your loan. If you get into trouble on a Federal student loan, presuming that there is proper oversight of our loan servicers, which we do not always have, you know, you have the availability of income-driven repayment plans. You also have the option to get your loan forgiven if you work hard, go into public service or after a certain amount of time of repayment. You do not have access to those protections on a private student loan. Mr. Scott. What about income-based payments? Dr. Morgan. You do not have access to income-based repayment on a private student loan. Mr. Scott. The increase in costs is the fact that you have--you are paying PhDs, higher-salaried people. Have those in the workforce with higher salaries, have those salaries gone up more or less than other salaries? Dr. Morgan. The salaries for people with Ph.D.s generally or at colleges? Mr. Scott. Well yes, both. If your workforce includes a lot of Ph.D.s and the higher income--higher educated workforce income is going up higher than inflation, would not that mean that college costs would be going up, have an upward pressure on costs? Dr. Morgan. I do not--I actually do not know the answer to the question. I know that having professors at our institutions who have a Ph.D., provides a much richer experience. I know we have heard a lot about tenure from the Committee today, the Subcommittee. I think there is a real concern with people who are forced into adjunct positions at schools. More and more students at our colleges are being taught by adjunct professors who do not have the same protections and do not have the same benefits as a full-time job. More and more they are being pushed into programs where the courseware is actually not even provided by the school itself, but by an online program manager. Mr. Scott. How much of the increase in costs is due to room and board and not instructional? Dr. Morgan. We have seen an increase in costs across the board. Tuition and fees are going up, but you are correct that room and board is going up as well. That is related, you know, both to some of the factors we have discussed today, including disinvestment. Do not forget, colleges are part of the economy as well that is being affected by the tariffs and other actions the Trump administration has taken to drive up costs across the board. Mr. Scott. You mentioned disinvestment. How much has State disinvestment affected college costs? Dr. Morgan. We have seen it over the last several decades. I believe Congresswoman Bonamici quoted the numbers some themselves. We have seen a drastic decrease in the investment of public state--of states in public higher education systems. I believe that we are poised to see more as a result of H.R. 1, where the cuts to SNAP and to Medicaid are putting immense pressure on State budgets, in addition to the requirement to put in place costly work requirement systems, and we are going to see that squeeze effect public higher education. Mr. Scott. What does that do to a student's cost? Dr. Morgan. It is going to drive up tuition across the board for students pursuing their degrees at public universities. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Owens. Thank you. We will now move to our closing remarks. I would like to recognize Ms. Adams for her closing remarks. Ms. Adams. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you once again to our witnesses for speaking with us today. As we close, I want to bring us back to first principles. College has never been just a personal investment. It is a public good. When we expand access to higher education, we strengthen our workforce, our economy and our democracy. When we restrict it, we entrench inequality and leave talent on the table. The affordability crisis that we have witnessed today is not inevitable. It is the result of policy choices. We can choose to reinvest in students, support institutions that deliver real outcomes and address the basic needs that determine whether students can succeed once they enroll. Or we can continue down a path that narrows opportunity and tells millions of capable students that higher education simply is not meant for them. Our responsibility is clear. We should be lowering costs, expanding access and ensuring that every student, regardless of income, background or zip code, has a fair shot at earning a degree and building a better future. That is the promise of the American Dream, and it is a promise worth keeping. Thank you all for being here for your testimony. Mr. Chair, I yield back the balance of my time. Chairman Owens. Thank you. Thank you so much. This has been extremely, extremely helpful, and I want to start off with just first of all agreeing, Ms. Morgan, with your comments about how bad things are. The explosion of tuition, enrollment in which kids come in, they enroll, they quit, they leave with debt they will never pay off, with job skills they will never have, and not be able to really build the American Dream. This is not from the last 6 months of the family working tax plan. It is from the last 16 years when in 2010, President Obama through Affordable Care Act, took everything from the private sector and put it into the government. Government has controlled this for the last 16 years. We cannot look at the last 6 months and say because of our reforms, all these things are happening. We are now about to, to take care of that. I think the biggest thing that I am concerned about is how little we know in our country about capitalism. We are the No. 1 destination in the world because of something called capitalism. Now just quickly, what does capitalism mean? What does it mean to this industry here? It is about return on investment. It is competition. It is merit, it is value and the product of all that is profit. Now if it is a good program, there is a lot of profit, which it should be. It should spread throughout the entire country. People should be wanting to take advantage of it. If it is a terrible product, it should go broke. What we are finding out is that the government does not--is insulated from this concept. They can have a terrible competition, no competition, no value, no merit and still make a lot of profit off the customer, the students who pay their life blood for the rest of their life trying to pay off loans. We need to get back to teaching that. I think that--when I think, when I listen to my friends here from Utah and in Florida, I will say this about Utah. We are the--we lead the country in terms of small business startups. There is an entrepreneurial concept. There is a culture in which we are trying to figure out how we can give the best return on investment to where we are dealing with. I think the same thing, the way I listen to how you guys are solving things, same thing with Florida. We need to realize that government solutions have never worked. I just came back from Latin America last week. They are realizing after the last couple years they want to get away from that stuff. No, it is not--it is not the government that is going to give us the--out of this. It is going to be entrepreneurs, innovators, those who truly are in the game for the right reasons. That is to make sure our kids are No. 1 and not the institutions, not the professors, not those around just kind of sucking in everything they can from government payouts. I am excited about the fact that we are having this conversation. We can all agree it is broken, it cost too much. We are getting too little of a return on investment with our kids coming out not being prepared to go to work, not being hopeful for their future, being angry about everything. That is not what our education should be about. The other thing is this. Let us just make sure we are transparent enough that everyone realizes they do not have to go into debt to go to a 4-year college. How about trades? If that could be their way out, if they could look at that as being their way to achieve their dreams, let them go for that. I think it is very helpful that we finally have competition for higher education. It is going to make higher education better. It is going to make sure that the best of the best prove themselves and outcomes, will allow parents to say ``OK, I will invest in this, or the kids will invest in this because it will give me a good return on investment.'' If it does not, then that institution should go broke, period. I am excited about the fact we are finally over the last 6 months putting in reforms, 6 months. Please, as you go back and think about how terrible things are, it is not because of the Republicans' One Big Beautiful Bill. We will see that in the coming year, and I think you are going to be very, very excited about how we are going to turn this out, when everybody can kind of see the product of return on investment and also be educated. That being said, again I want to thank every one of you. This is such a healthy conversation. I think that the bottom line, if our kids are the end result, if our kids are the focus, our priorities, we are going to come around and figure out how to make sure that works out and that their legacy will be something we can be very proud of. That being said, I would like to thank our witnesses again for taking the time to testify before the Subcommittee today. Without objections, there are no further business. The Subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 12:27 p.m., the Subcommittee hearing was adjourned.] [all]