A LEGISLATIVE HEARING TO EXAMINE S. __, BUILD NUCLEAR WITH LOCAL MATERIALS ACT, DISCUSSION DRAFT S. __, RECHARGE ACT, AND DISCUSSION DRAFT S. __, ENRICHMENT LICENSING MODERNIZATION ACT

Senate Public Works Committee Senate May 20, 2026

Official record ↗ · Linked to the scheduled hearing

Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.

[Senate Hearing 119-477]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]

 S. Hrg. 119-477

 A LEGISLATIVE HEARING TO EXAMINE S. __,
 BUILD NUCLEAR WITH LOCAL MATERIALS ACT, 
 DISCUSSION DRAFT S. __, RECHARGE ACT,
 AND DISCUSSION DRAFT S. __, ENRICHMENT
 LICENSING MODERNIZATION ACT

=======================================================================

 HEARING

 before the

 SUBCOMMITTEE ON CLEAN AIR, 
 CLIMATE, AND NUCLEAR INNOVATION AND SAFETY

 of the

 COMMITTEE ON
 ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS

 UNITED STATES SENATE

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION
 __________

 MAY 20, 2026
 __________

 Printed for the use of the Committee on Environment and Public Works

 [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 
 
 Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov
 
 ______
 
 U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE

64-161 WASHINGTON : 2026 

 
 
 
 
 COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS

 ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS

 SECOND SESSION

 SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia, Chairman
 SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island, Ranking Member

KEVIN CRAMER, North Dakota BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont
CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon
JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina MARK KELLY, Arizona
DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska ALEX PADILLA, California
PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska ADAM B. SCHIFF, California
ROGER F. WICKER, Mississippi LISA BLUNT ROCHESTER, Delaware
JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas ANGELA D. ALSOBROOKS, Maryland
JON HUSTED, Ohio

 Adam Tomlinson, Republican Staff Director
 Dan Dudis, Democratic Staff Director
 
 ---------- 

 Subcommittee on Clean Air, Climate, and Nuclear Innovation and Safety

 CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming, Chairman
 MARK KELLY, Arizona, Ranking Member

KEVIN CRAMER, North Dakota BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont
JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts
PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska ALEX PADILLA, California
ROGER F. WICKER, Mississippi ADAM B. SCHIFF, California
JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas LISA BLUNT ROCHESTER, Delaware
JON HUSTED, Ohio SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island 
SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia (ex officio)
 (ex officio)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 C O N T E N T S

 ---------- 
 Page

 MAY 20, 2026
 OPENING STATEMENTS

Lummis, Hon. Cynthia M., U.S. Senator from the State of Wyoming.. 1
Kelly, Hon. Mark, U.S. Senator from the State of Arizona......... 3

 WITNESSES

Loris, Nick, President, C3 Solutions............................. 6
 Prepared statement........................................... 9
Stein, Adam, Ph.D., Director, Nuclear Energy Innovation, the 
 Breakthrough Institute......................................... 18
 Prepared statement........................................... 20
White, Patrick, Ph.D., Group Lead for Fusion, Safety, and 
 Regulation, Clean Air Task Force............................... 45
 Prepared statement........................................... 48

 LEGISLATION

Federal legislative measures introduced:
 To require the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to allow the use 
 of commercial-grade steel and concrete in non-safety-
 related structures at nuclear power plants, and for other 
 purposes................................................... 91
 To amend the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 to align the licensing 
 of uranium enrichment facilities with other fuel cycle 
 facilities under that Act, and for other purposes.......... 93
 To exempt the conversion of covered sites into certain types 
 of nuclear reactor plants from the requirements of the 
 National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, and for other 
 purposes................................................... 99

 
 A LEGISLATIVE HEARING TO EXAMINE S. __,
 BUILD NUCLEAR WITH LOCAL MATERIALS ACT, 
 DISCUSSION DRAFT S. __, RECHARGE ACT,
 AND DISCUSSION DRAFT S. __, ENRICHMENT
 LICENSING MODERNIZATION ACT

 ---------- 

 WEDNESDAY, MAY 20, 2026

 U.S. Senate,
 Committee on Environment and Public Works,
Subcommittee on Clean Air, Climate, and Nuclear innovation 
 and Safety,
 Washington, DC.
 The subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:48 a.m. in 
room 562, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Cynthia Lummis 
(chairman of the subcommittee) presiding.
 Present: Senators Lummis, Kelly, Capito.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. CYNTHIA LUMMIS, 
 U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF WYOMING

 Senator Lummis. Good morning. Welcome to the EPW Committee, 
and its Subcommittee on Clean Air, Climate and Nuclear 
Innovation and Safety.
 Now, this hearing is entitled, A Legislative Hearing to 
Examine the Build Nuclear with Local Materials Act, the 
Discussion Draft RECHARGE Act, and Discussion Draft Enrichment 
Licensing Modernization Act.
 Thank you to our witnesses and attendees. I am so grateful 
that Ranking Member Kelly, who is very conversant with these 
issues and very involved in this subject, is here today. Thank 
you, Senator Kelly.
 I am going to begin with my opening statement, and then I 
have to go to another committee to introduce a colleague. Then 
I will be back. Senator Kelly will take the gavel for that 
time.
 Dr. Stein, I presume?
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Lummis. I am so sorry that you got waylaid in line. 
We are delighted you are here.
 I want to thank, again, all our witnesses for your 
willingness to inform our discussion today. We look forward to 
hearing the download of your expertise.
 I will start with my opening statement. America must remain 
an economic superpower in the decades ahead, and that requires 
smart energy policy to ensure the United States, and States 
like Wyoming and Arizona, continue to lead the way.
 For my State of Wyoming, we have fueled American prosperity 
through coal, natural gas, oil, and uranium production for 
decades. We even have a miner on our State seal. We have No. 1 
status in uranium reserves, and had a robust uranium industry 
for years before the technology fell asleep.
 Like Rumpelstiltskin, isn't that who fell asleep for years? 
Rip Van Winkle, excuse me, it has awakened and is more robust 
than ever. Wyoming workers and producers strengthen our grid 
and support the reliable energy systems that make economic 
growth and national security possible.
 We all know that our new embrace of technology, including 
artificial intelligence, the data centers that support them, 
the advanced manufacturing that comes from it, bitcoin mining, 
all of these demand reliable baseload power, and that is the 
key, the baseload power we need to continue to grow.
 The United States needs more reliable generation, more 
infrastructure, and a diverse energy strategy that supports 
affordability, reliability, and long-term energy security. 
Advanced nuclear energy must be part of that future. We are so 
glad that Rip Van Winkle is awake, and alive and well, and 
experts representing it are here today to help us understand 
it.
 Senator Kelly and I have a bill that we are going to talk 
about today, the ADVANCE ACT, and it has bipartisan support, in 
addition to us. We need to discuss that bill today and work to 
build on the momentum that other bills before us help 
represent.
 The Build Nuclear with Local Materials Act addresses 
unnecessary cost escalation in nuclear reactor construction by 
modernizing of the NRC rules governing commercial-grade steel 
and concrete in non-safety-related structures while preserving 
oversight of safety-critical systems.
 That means more opportunities for local manufacturers, 
suppliers, and skilled workers to participate in nuclear 
projects, while reducing unnecessary costs.
 We will also examine the RECHARGE Act. It is a discussion 
draft, and will focus on deploying advanced reactors at retired 
fossil fuel facilities and brownfield sites. These communities 
already have energy infrastructure and experienced work forces. 
Repurposing these sites for advanced nuclear development can 
attract long-term investment, strengthen local tax bases, and 
create new opportunities in energy communities.
 Wyoming is already demonstrating how this model can work. 
TerraPower, which is a project going up in my State near 
Kemmerer, Wyoming, is being developed on a brownfield site. It 
is bringing new investment and development to an existing 
energy experienced community.
 Finally, we will examine the Modernizing Enrichment 
Facility Licensing Act. It also is a discussion draft. As the 
United States moves toward ending reliance on Russian uranium 
imports in 2028, which is a big deal, and we have to be ready 
for it, this is about strengthening domestic uranium conversion 
and enrichment capacity, which are very limited.
 We only have one conversion facility, and perhaps only two 
enrichment facilities in the whole Country. This is really 
important for both energy security and national security.
 My State of Wyoming is excited about this technology. We 
are positioned to lead. Wyoming has uranium resources and 
uranium mines. A lot of them are in-situ mines, rather than 
open pit mines. It is a transformative technology in producing 
uranium out of the ground.
 It is amazing. When you come upon it, it looks like you are 
looking at a bunch of beehives off in the distance. It is a 
uranium field, so the surface disturbance is almost nil. It is 
just incredible. I just admire these brilliant minds that work 
in this area so much.
 What America lacks, as we said, is the domestic enrichment 
capacity necessary to support a growing nuclear sector. This 
committee needs to explore and I am committed to fixing 
policies that limit the ability of Wyoming's and other States' 
resources to power the world.
 The discussion draft seeks to modernize portions of the 
licensing process while maintaining NRC oversight and operating 
license agreements. However, discussions on this proposal 
remain ongoing, and I trust today's hearing will inform 
negotiations with Senator Kelly moving forward.
 If America intends to lead the future of advanced 
manufacturing, artificial intelligence, digital infrastructure, 
and emerging technologies, then we must also lead in reliable 
energy production, especially baseload. That future will 
require more power, more investment, and especially smarter 
policies that enable Wyoming and other American energy 
communities to continue to power this Country.
 Again, I want to thank our witnesses and I look forward to 
your testimony. I am going to go introduce a friend in another 
committee who has been nominated for an ambassadorship.
 You are now in the capable hands of Senator Kelly. Here is 
the gavel, and I will see you in a little bit. Thank you.

 OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. MARK KELLY, 
 U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF ARIZONA

 Senator Kelly. [Presiding.] Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank 
you for all the work you have done on this issue. Thank you to 
our witnesses for appearing before the subcommittee today to 
discuss nuclear deployment and the future of American energy 
security.
 Energy demand is going up. We all see it. We know it. It is 
going to continue to grow in Wyoming and Arizona, across the 
Country. We are going to need more reliable, affordable and 
abundant power on the grid. That is clear.
 Nuclear energy needs to be part of this solution. It is a 
proven technology. We have been building and operating nuclear 
reactors since the 1960's. This is not an engineering problem. 
It is a regulatory problem. If we are serious about expanding 
nuclear power, we need a regulatory framework that helps us 
build the fleet faster and more efficiently.
 We can not afford to wait 10 or 15 years to bring a new 
nuclear facility online, not when families and businesses and 
the economy need clean and reliable power. Common sense 
regulatory reform should not mean cutting corners. We can 
streamline permitting and we can streamline deployment while 
maintaining the high standards that protect communities. That 
is what the NRC's job was set up to do.
 Now more than ever, the NRC needs to keep the authority and 
independence given to it by Congress to oversee this industry 
and protect public health and protect the environment, and make 
sure reactors are being operated responsibly. That is how we 
move forward faster, bring down costs, strengthen our energy 
security and keep people safe at the same time.
 One challenge we have to address here comes down to the 
very materials that we used to build these facilities from. 
Nuclear-grade construction standards and materials are 
important for safety, but NRC rules can still force their use 
in parts of a nuclear plant that do not perform a radiation 
safety function.
 This broad, one-size-fits-all approach increases costs and 
extends project timelines without making nuclear plants any 
safer. That is why I was very happy to work with Chairwoman 
Lummis on the Build Nuclear with Local Materials Act. Our bill 
allows commercial grade materials to be used in parts of a 
nuclear facility where there are no radiological hazards.
 It also makes clear that the NRC has to certify where those 
materials are appropriate and where they are not appropriate. 
That is just one way we can speed up nuclear deployment without 
cutting corners.
 Fuel supply is another critical part of this equation. As I 
discussed in this committee just last week, building more 
reactors will not mean anything if we did not have the fuel to 
operate them. Nuclear power plants depend on a steady, reliable 
supply of enriched uranium.
 Yet today, in the United States, we import 80 percent of 
our enriched uranium supply, about 20 percent of that comes 
from Russia, who is an adversary. Not ideal. We only have two 
operating enrichment facilities in the United States, and only 
one that can do this at commercial scale.
 That leaves us short of the fuel capacity we need to 
protect against energy and economic and national security 
risks. We need more of these facilities.
 The licensing process had made this a lot harder than it 
needs to be. Right now, NRC requirements include well-
intentioned but outdated procedural hurdles that create a lot 
of uncertainty. It also drives up costs, and it delays the 
projects that we need to get new production capacity online.
 The licensing rules for new uranium enrichment facilities 
have not been updated in 40 years. Technology has advanced, the 
world has changed. Should the rules. If we want to expand 
nuclear power and strengthen our domestic fuel supply, reduce 
our dependence on foreign sources, we need a licensing process 
that moves faster while keeping the right kind of oversight in 
place.
 My Enrichment Licensing Modernization Act would address 
this imbalance by creating a framework more consistent with the 
process already used for other nuclear fuel facilities. It 
would allow certain construction activities to begin before an 
operating license is issued, while making clear that developers 
move forward at their own risk, and that early construction 
does not guarantee final approval.
 The bill would also give the NRC authority to determine the 
appropriate level of environmental review, based on the 
specific facts and the risks of each application. This bill is 
included on the hearing agenda today as a discussion draft. I 
believe it is a more targeted, practical approach than the 
status quo, one that can reduce unnecessary delays while also 
preserving the safeguards we need and expect.
 I look forward to getting the feedback from our witnesses 
today as we work to finalize and introduce this bill.
 I also want to acknowledge the third bill on our agenda 
today, the discussion draft of the RECHARGE Act, introduced by 
Senator Lummis. This bill seeks to streamline the NEPA review 
requirements, renew advanced reactors build on brownfields, or 
other retired energy sites.
 I think the concept of making it easier to build nuclear 
facilities where an older, dirtier energy facility existed has 
some merit. I hope the testimony we receive today helps us 
understand how we can advanced the concept in a bipartisan way.
 Taken together, the bills before us today move us toward 
more reliable, clean, and affordable power on the grid, while 
maintaining the strong oversight and accountability that the 
public deserves and expects.
 I want to thank our witnesses for being here and taking the 
time to review this package of bills with us. Each of you 
brings real expertise and a range of perspectives that will 
help inform this discussion and improve the legislation before 
us. I am glad we have the chance to discuss these proposals 
today.
 I also want to thank Senator Lummis for all of her hard 
work and the hard work of her staff to put this hearing 
together. This is a bipartisan topic, and I hope we can 
showcase that this is a space where we can reach some common 
ground.
 As two western Senators, Senator Lummis and I have had the 
chance to work together a lot over the years, from truck 
parking to uranium cleanup, and so much more. Her commitment to 
finding areas of common ground is commendable. I want to thank 
her for that work. We will try to do that again when she gets 
back.
 I know we have a lot more ahead of us before the end of the 
year, including today's hearing, where we hope to find some 
areas of bipartisan agreement.
 With that, I want to introduce our three witnesses, from 
left to right. Mr. Loris is the President of C3 Solutions. His 
work focuses on how a free market can signal for innovation and 
emerging energy technologies, like nuclear energy, to serve our 
communities with baseload power and lead in U.S. exports of 
advanced nuclear reactor designs. Welcome, Mr. Loris.
 I am going to introduce all three witnesses, then we will 
start with Mr. Loris for opening remarks.
 Our next witness this morning is Dr. Adam Stein, the 
Director of Nuclear Energy Innovation at the Breakthrough 
Institute. With over 20 years of experience in the energy 
sector, his advanced education at the intersection of 
engineering and public policy has led him to work in nuclear 
facility offsite risk analysis, publish work with Idaho 
National Laboratory, and lead the Breakthrough Institute's 
nuclear initiatives and engagement with the NRC. Dr. Stein, 
welcome.
 Finally, we will hear from Dr. Patrick White, Group Lead 
for Fusion Safety and Regulation at Clean Air Task Force. Dr. 
White's Ph.D. in nuclear engineering and work has focused on 
developing new licensing methods and regulatory frameworks for 
commercial advanced nuclear technologies. He also leads the 
Clean Air Task Force International Working Group, aimed at 
creating a globally harmonized regulatory framework for 
commercial nuclear technology in U.S. exports. Dr. White, 
welcome.
 Let's start with Dr. Loris' 5 minutes of opening remarks.

 STATEMENT OF NICK LORIS, PRESIDENT, C3 SOLUTIONS

 Mr. Loris. Thank you, Chairman Lummis, Ranking Member Kelly 
and distinguished members of the subcommittee. Thank you for 
this opportunity to testify this morning.
 My name is Nick Loris, and I am the President of the 
Conservative Coalition for Climate Solutions, and an Energy 
Fellow at the Abundance Institute.
 After two decades of flat demand, power consumption is 
surging. Grid strategies forecast 5 percent annual growth over 
the next 5 years, and the peak demand could be equivalent to 15 
times New York City's peak energy consumption.
 Meanwhile, electricity prices are rising faster than 
inflation, and families and businesses across the Country are 
feeling the effects. It is clear we need more supply, and 
nuclear power can be part of the solution. It is safe, clean, 
dependable and scalable.
 The key question for policymakers and ratepayers alike is, 
is it cost-competitive? While that is ultimately a question for 
the market to answer, there are reasons to be hopeful. The 
private sector is making big bets, investing across companies 
and technologies, directly financing projects, and helping 
reduce the costs and risk premiums associated with advanced 
reactors.
 Encouragingly, there has been bipartisan support and 
recognition that Federal policy has not kept pace with private 
sector innovation and investment. Bills signed by both 
President Trump and President Biden in recent years helped 
address some of the government-imposed regulatory burdens that 
increase costs and slow deployment.
 This is a long-overdue shift, one toward a risk-informed 
performance based framework that preserves the Nuclear 
Regulatory Commission's core safety mission, while cutting 
unnecessary costs and delays elsewhere. It is already paying 
dividends. TerraPower's Natrium Reactor in Kemmerer, Wyoming, 
received its construction permit 9 months ahead of schedule, 
and 11 percent under budget.
 In the coming months, the NRC will finalize several rules 
to further improve the licensing process and modernize outdated 
regulations. However, now is not the time to be complacent, and 
the bill and discussion drafts under consideration today would 
build on that progress.
 First, the Build Nuclear with Local Materials Act addresses 
the cost premium for construction materials in non-safety 
related areas of a nuclear plant. The concrete, steel and rebar 
used in nuclear power plants must meet strict quality assurance 
standards to be considered nuclear-grade.
 These materials and components cost considerably more than 
alternatives, even when they are identical in performance and 
composition, because the approval requires extensive analysis, 
testing, and documentation. The cost of nuclear-grade concrete 
can be 50 percent higher than non-nuclear concrete, and in some 
cases, components can be 50 times more expensive.
 Another reason for the higher costs is the shortage of 
suppliers and less competition. When nuclear-grade materials 
and components are required, nuclear energy companies are, in 
many respects, captive customers, paying stadium and airport 
level prices when suitable suppliers can offer grocery store 
prices for the same product.
 Expanding the use of commercial grade materials will 
broaden the supplier base, increase competition, and enable 
local manufacturers and construction firms to participate in 
nuclear projects.
 Second, the RECHARGE Act would accelerate the deployment of 
advanced nuclear technologies at retired fossil facilities and 
brownfield sites by categorically excluding NEPA reviews, all 
while keeping the NRC licensing requirements intact.
 These sites already have the grid connections, transmission 
infrastructure, skilled work forces, and communities that 
understand energy development. The RECHARGE Act eliminates 
redundant reviews where the environmental tradeoffs are already 
well understood.
 In fact, we just saw a version of this this week, where the 
NRC issued a finding of no significant impact for the Dow and 
X-Energy's advanced nuclear project in Seadrift, Texas. The 
finding comes after an environmental assessment that took 
months rather than an environmental impact statement that would 
have taken years.
 More efficient reviews like this will spur private 
investment, strengthen local tax bases, and position rural and 
industrial communities as hubs for the next generation of 
American energy and technology leadership.
 The reality is that the Federal permitting system is overly 
complex, often redundant, and prone to litigation. While 
wholesale modernization is necessary, the RECHARGE Act 
represents a step in the right direction.
 Third, the Enrichment Licensing and Modernization Act 
addresses a vulnerability in our nuclear fuel supply chain. The 
U.S. imports roughly 80 percent of its enriched uranium, and 
despite efforts toward a complete ban by 2028, 20 percent still 
comes from Russia.
 Enrichment is safe and it is well understood. America has 
the technology, capital, and human ingenuity to expand domestic 
enrichment capacity. Federal policy should help clear the path.
 This draft would allow at-risk construction to begin while 
licensing continues entirely at the developer's own risk and 
with no taxpayer exposure. It would also allow tailored 
environmental assessments, rather than mandating full 
environmental impact statements, and eliminate hearings when no 
party has requested one.
 These are common sense reforms that improve timelines 
without touching the NRC's core mandate.
 In conclusion, if the U.S. wants to be a leader in nuclear 
energy to meet rising demand, revitalize industrial communities 
and deliver clean, reliable power, we must build. To build on 
time and on budget, we must fix the rules that make permitting 
and construction unnecessarily expensive and slow.
 The reforms under consideration today will empower the 
industry to invest with certainty and to build with efficiency, 
all while maintaining strong public safety and environmental 
safeguards.
 Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Loris follows:]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Senator Kelly. Thank you, Mr. Loris.
 Dr. Stein, you are recognized for 5 minutes.

 STATEMENT OF ADAM STEIN, PH.D., DIRECTOR, NUCLEAR ENERGY 
 INNOVATION, THE BREAKTHROUGH INSTITUTE

 Mr. Stein. Thank you. Chair Lummis, Ranking Member Kelly, 
and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity 
to participate in this hearing today.
 My name is Dr. Adam Stein, and I am the Director of Nuclear 
Energy Innovation at the Breakthrough Institute.
 We work on continued use and safe use of nuclear and clean 
energy. We act in the public interest and do not align or 
receive funding from the industry.
 Nuclear power continues to simultaneously contribute to 
reliability, energy security, national security, emissions and 
pollution reduction, and long-term electricity price stability. 
Reliable and affordable electricity underpins advanced 
manufacturing, defense readiness, artificial intelligence 
infrastructure, industrial production, and economic 
competitiveness.
 The United States needs a nuclear regulatory system that 
protects health and safety in a way that is credible, 
predictable, timely, and proportionate to actual risk. Such a 
system is necessary not only to maintain safety but to ensure 
that nuclear energy can benefit society.
 The central challenge facing nuclear regulation today is an 
implementation and decision architecture problem. Congress has 
already provided substantial direction to modernize the NRC 
through legislation, including NEIMA and the ADVANCE Act. The 
NRC has begun to make visible progress.
 Modernization will ultimately be judged by implementation. 
Nuclear deployment exists in an ecosystem. Nuclear projects are 
simultaneously satisfying financing requirements, customer 
demand, supply chain readiness, public acceptance, permitting 
systems, environmental review and regulatory approval. Any 
mono-causal explanation of nuclear costs or delay is 
incomplete.
 One challenge facing the NRC is a decision architecture 
problem to truly consider benefit to society, as defined and 
reinforced under the ADVANCE Act. This committee, the 
subcommittee and larger committee, endorsed the ADVANCE Act and 
reported it. Two, adjust the NRC's mission to align with the 
Atomic Energy Act to ensure that bipartisan support of the 
NRC's actions continues.
 Considering actual benefits to society in decision 
architecture is imperative to continue implementation that 
remains that remains in the best interests of society. There 
are currently approximately 70 ongoing rulemakings at the NRC, 
and although it is impossible to say exactly what is going on 
in those rulemakings, many of them relate to bills in front of 
the subcommittee today. There may be some overlap, but due to 
reduced transparency by the engagement with OIRA at this point, 
it is unclear whether these bills will be duplicative or 
exactly the direction the NRC needs in this moment.
 Implementation of both statute and rulemaking is critical 
and significantly dependent upon the predictability and 
governance of the NRC's commission decisions.
 Another challenge is radiation protection coherence. This 
committee has stressed that reducing safety would be 
counterproductive to the bills at hand. Safety must be 
maintained while streamlining the rulemaking process.
 Environmental review of fuel facility licenses faces a 
similar challenge. While it has already been mentioned that the 
U.S. imports about 80 percent of its enriched uranium, what has 
not been mentioned is that to increase demand, we would need to 
increase enrichment production domestically if we move away 
from Russian capacity by two to five times, about 70 million to 
150 million SWU, or separative work units. That is a 
significant increase compared to the status quo, and will 
require streamlining and logical expansion of environmental 
reviews.
 The committee is currently evaluating three specific bills 
that have been introduced to help address these implementation 
challenges. All of them work to enable smarter, risk-informed 
and performance-based regulations, reducing the costs 
associated with nuclear-grade concrete and steel to use 
commercial when available and appropriate, without compromising 
public health and safety.
 The NRC has said in its own rulemaking that increased 
quality assurance costs add about 35 percent to a nuclear power 
plant's costs.
 Enabling appropriate environmental review of brownfield 
sites can significantly reduce the time to deploy new nuclear 
energy, while still protecting the environment. Reforming 
regulatory barriers to enriching facility licensing can make 
them more aligned with other fuel facilities and other nuclear 
power production facilities.
 Ultimately, successful NRC modernization will be measured 
by whether the United States has created a regulatory system 
capable of enabling the safe deployment of nuclear technology 
at scale required for the Nation's future.
 Thank you.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. Stein follows:]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Senator Kelly. Thank you, Dr. Stein.
 Dr. White?

 STATEMENT OF PATRICK WHITE, PH.D., GROUP LEADER FOR FUSION, 
 SAFETY, AND REGULATION, CLEAN AIR TASK FORCE

 Mr. White. Great, thank you. Madam Chair Lummis, Ranking 
Member Kelly, and distinguished members of the subcommittee--
oh, Madam Chair Lummis. That is good timing.
 My name is Patrick White, and I am the Group Lead for 
Fusion, Safety and Regulation at the Clean Air Task Force and 
an advanced nuclear technology and regulation expert. I cover 
both fission and fusion technology, but really with a focus on 
regulation, safety, and licensing, how do we get these 
processes right.
 The Clean Air Task Force is a non-profit organization that 
is really focused on all clean air energy solutions and how we 
can deliver abundant, affordable, and clean energy at scale in 
the United States and around the world.
 In my work, I lead CATF's work on licensing and regulation, 
and I think anyone who knows me, my friends, and unfortunately 
my colleagues, will say nuclear regulation is one of my 
favorite topics to talk about. I am really excited to be here 
with the subcommittee today to provide testimony on these bills 
and discuss it with the committee.
 At a very high level, nuclear energy has this great 
potential to help us meet our growing energy and climate needs, 
how we provide the affordable, reliable and clean energy that 
we need to ultimately see the continued growth of society.
 Efficient, effective and predictable regulation for these 
technologies is going to be absolutely critical to ensuring 
investment, helping facilitate new projects, build out supply 
chains, build out order books, and maintain trust in nuclear 
technologies. I am really interested in the work that the 
committee has been doing over the last several years, and that 
we expect the committee and Congress to do over the next 
several years to ultimately create this predictable regulatory 
framework.
 The proposed legislation that is under discussion today 
during the hearing really helps to address some of the 
outstanding gaps and weaknesses that I think we see in the 
licensing, the environmental reviews and the construction 
requirements for both new nuclear reactors and for uranium 
enrichment facilities.
 While I agree with the intent of the bills under discussion 
today, I think there are some specific, targeted changes we can 
make to the draft legislation to ultimately provide greater 
clarity on kind of the technical and legal justification for 
some of these changes, help enable more robust public 
engagement with stakeholders during public comment processes, 
and really help ensure that these regulatory changes did not 
have any inadvertent effect on ultimately other licensing 
processes that we are going to need to complete to get nuclear 
energy deployed at scale in the United States.
 The first bill, the Build Nuclear with Local Materials Act, 
will direct the NRC to initiate a rulemaking on the use of 
commercial grade concrete for non-safety related structures.
 While NRC regulations already enable the use of commercial 
grade concrete for many non-safety related structures, both 
this legislation and recent experience by the Natrium Reactor 
in Wyoming highlight potential gaps and weaknesses in some of 
the existing regulation and guidance. I believe that an NRC 
rulemaking on this topic can provide an opportunity for the 
NRC, private companies and public stakeholders to provide input 
to update this regulation and guidance on the topic, and 
ultimately help accelerate and lower the costs of new nuclear 
reactor construction.
 The second piece of legislation under discussion today, the 
Revitalizing Energy Communities by Hosting Advanced Reactors 
and Generating Energy, or the RECHARGE Act, will really focus 
on licensing and deploying new nuclear reactors at brownfield 
sites and those retired fossil fuel sites that can ultimately 
become the hub for the next generation of energy technology.
 By streamlining the environmental reviews, I think there is 
a really unique opportunity to try to accelerate the deployment 
of new nuclear energy technology with a specific focus on, 
again, repowering those sites where we have had energy produced 
for decades.
 While I believe that the environmental reviews that are 
completed to meet the NEPA requirements can be streamlined for 
both nuclear energy and for all energy technologies, I did not 
believe that a legislative categorical exclusion for all 
advanced reactors is necessarily the most effective way to 
address licensing timelines. Instead, creation of a legislative 
categorical exclusion for these projects would risk limiting 
public engagement and input, and that potentially applying the 
categorical exclusion to all advanced reactors at any covered 
site could be overly broad.
 Instead, however, I again really support the intent of this 
bill and think that leveraging existing NEPA reforms that are 
underway at the NRC and other Federal agencies could be used to 
accelerate licensing reviews in the near-term, and that the 
proposed legislation potentially could be refocused to direct 
NRC rulemaking on the use of environmental assessments or to 
develop more specific or targeted categorical exclusions for 
certain advanced reactor projects, ultimately, meeting the 
intent of this bill, of figuring out how can we get more 
nuclear energy on the grid, and how can we really prioritize 
some of the existing communities and existing sites.
 Finally, the Enrichment Licensing Modernization Act would 
update the statutory licensing requirements to help accelerate 
and expand U.S. domestic uranium enrichment capacity. I think, 
like Senator Kelly said, a lot of these requirements were 
really created in 1990 when we updated the NRC regulations for 
commercial enrichment facilities. There is an opportunity to go 
back and figure out how can we modernize those statutory 
requirements that we made.
 While again I agree with the need to enable certain pre-
license construction activities and remediation plans can be 
really useful at kind of ensuring public trust in these, I do 
think that there are changes that we can potentially look at in 
regulation instead of legislation that provide for a more 
streamlined approach, and ultimately gives opportunity for the 
agency to incorporate best practices on nuclear licensing, and 
provide opportunities for stakeholder engagement.
 With that, again, I thank you all for the opportunity to 
testify on these bills under discussion. I look forward to the 
questions from the committee.
 [The prepared statement of Mr. White follows:]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 Senator Lummis. [Presiding.] Thank you for your testimony.
 I am going to begin with Senator Kelly's questions, so he 
can get them in and then he has to go to another committee. You 
are recognized, Senator Kelly.
 Senator Kelly. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, all three 
of you, for your opening remarks and for being here today.
 Dr. White, I want to start with you and get to a topic that 
you mentioned at the end of your opening remarks, and that is 
the Enrichment Licensing Modernization Act. As I mentioned in 
my opening remarks, we need to rebuild this Country's capacity 
to enrich uranium. That is critical for our existing nuclear 
fleet, and it is going to be even more important if we are 
serious about bringing more reactors online in the years ahead.
 The Enrichment Licensing Modernization Act makes 
significant reforms to streamline licensing. Here is the thing: 
each reform is balanced with a safeguard. For example, the bill 
eliminates the requirement for a hearing when nobody asked for 
one. Makes sense. I mean, why would we hold a hearing when 
nobody is asking for a hearing?
 When the public does request a hearing, the bill makes that 
hearing mandatory. We preserve the public's ability to weigh in 
on this kind of development without adding more bureaucracy for 
no reason.
 Similar to that, the bill changes when a developer is 
allowed to begin building an enrichment facility. Under current 
law, the NRC has to review the application and issue a 
construction license before any work begins. Then the NRC has 
to issue a second license for operation. This causes months of 
delay, it drives up costs, and it creates a kind of uncertainty 
that holds back investment in these facilities.
 My bill changes the law to simply require an operating 
license. That is a real change. At the same time, we should not 
allow a developer to start building something as sensitive as a 
uranium enrichment facility on the basis of an application 
alone. We can not break ground without any protections in place 
for the community.
 That is why the legislation includes a requirement that 
developers submit a remediation plan in case construction stops 
or is not completed or the operating license ultimately is not 
issued. The community is not just stuck with this facility. It 
also gives the NRC the authority to require implementation of 
that plan.
 Dr. White, do you believe this type of remediation 
requirement is appropriate to ensure the responsible 
development of enrichment facilities?
 Mr. White. Yes, I do, Senator. I think it is an opportunity 
to provide essentially an additional public check on the 
creation of any potential new uranium enrichment 
infrastructure.
 Senator Kelly. Is it within the NRC's purview to require 
this type of remediation?
 Mr. White. Yes, Senator, I do. I think there are some 
really interesting opportunities to look at other licensing 
activities that the NRC completes, and kind of see this 
precedent for trying to provide additional assurances to the 
public on the creation of new facilities.
 The best example that I will go to is the requirements that 
the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has for what we call limited 
work authorization, or LWAs, for essentially early construction 
of new nuclear reactors. It is a very similar process, where 
you look at trying to propose, what are your construction 
activities, and then you provide a redress plan as part of that 
application to demonstrate that if your facility is not 
ultimately completed, what activities will you take to help 
kind of return that site back to its original condition, or 
another suitable condition for development.
 Senator Kelly. There are similar requirements in place for 
other regulated facilities?
 Mr. White. There are similar regulations that are in place 
for other facilities like commercial nuclear reactors. They are 
not necessarily the same exact requirements for other uranium 
facilities, such as conversion plants or fuel fabrication 
facilities. They are subject to different regulatory 
requirements.
 The one difference that I would highlight, though, is that 
those regulatory requirements are implemented entirely through 
regulation and not through statute.
 Senator Kelly. Can you speak briefly to why maintaining NRC 
authority and independence over enrichment licensing is 
critical, especially if we allow pre-license construction of 
these facilities?
 Mr. White. Yes. I think as we start talking about the 
deployment of nuclear energy at scale, it is going to be 
something that requires really societal acceptance and societal 
demand. We do not necessarily want to create nuclear 
technologies that communities are scared of, that they are 
skeptical of or that they did not feel that they had a voice in 
actually the siting and licensing of.
 I think by maintaining NRC public trust, by maintaining NRC 
independence, and by providing opportunities for public 
engagement with the NRC, it helps build the societal trust and 
continues, essentially, the momentum that we have on nuclear 
energy as something that is broadly bipartisan supported, as 
opposed to potentially creating gaps in public support or 
public trust in nuclear technology, more broadly.
 Senator Kelly. Thank you, and thank you for working with my 
staff and this committee to draft legislation that is both 
practical and responsible.
 Senator Lummis. I am going to take the liberty to ask both 
of you a question. I have a question. I did not obey the rules 
of chairman and so, you will have to forgive me for being the 
way I am.
 Senator Kelly and Dr. White, if a nuclear facility of some 
sort or nuclear-related facility is built on a brownfield site, 
does that relieve the initial polluter of liability? Does the 
liability for cleanup shift entirely to the nuclear facility?
 Senator Kelly. I did not know.
 [Laughter.]
 Mr. White. First, I would have to say, Chairman Lummis, 
this is a place where I am but a humble nuclear engineer, not a 
lawyer. I will definitely defer to my colleagues who have a 
little bit more expertise on the specific legal nuances of 
liability associated with it.
 Senator Lummis. Do any of our witnesses know the answer?
 Mr. Stein. Chair Lummis, the liability could or could not 
be transferred, depending on how the remediation plan would be 
defined.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you. Thanks, Senator Kelly, for your 
involvement in this topic. I have always enjoyed working with 
you on this topic. It is a very productive working 
relationship. If you choose to come back when your next hearing 
is completed, we would love to see you again.
 While you are gone, I am going to take the liberty to take 
more than 5 minutes.
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Lummis. Again, thanks, witnesses, for being here.
 Mr. Loris, I am going to start with you. One of the goals 
of the RECHARGE Act discussion draft is to create a strong 
incentive for private industry to invest in retired fossil fuel 
sites and brownfields, instead of leaving those communities 
behind. In many cases, these communities are already dealing 
with declining tax bases, stranded infrastructure and costly 
cleanup needs.
 How can advanced nuclear development leverage private 
capital to accelerate site remediation, restore long-term 
economic activity, and bring new investment into communities 
that have powered this Country for generations?
 Mr. Loris. Thank you for the question. I think it is 
critical, and there is, just given the infrastructure in place, 
the understanding of what energy means to these communities, as 
well as environmental protection, if you look at places like 
Alaska, who very much understand the benefits of energy 
production as well as environmental protection, a lot of the 
States in the west, in Wyoming.
 This represents just really critical opportunities to be 
new hubs of technological growth. Given the data center demand 
that we are already seeing, I know there is a lot of skepticism 
and hesitancy, but the amount of additional revenue that can be 
generated for tax bases, not just from the energy investment 
itself, but all of the additional investment that comes with 
it.
 Loudon County, right outside of here in D.C., is a 
tremendous example of kind of what that has built. These data 
centers, while they did not employ a lot of people, they bring 
in a lot of revenue. That is almost a sweet spot for a lot of 
these communities, because that does not mean a huge influx of 
people for the schools, for the roads. It does mean a lot of 
investment in the roads and the schools and all of the 
businesses.
 Having affordable, reliable, clean energy infrastructure as 
the kind of driving force for that is really essential. That is 
why I think places like Kemmerer, Wyoming and Texas and other 
places are really starting to get off the ground for what we 
can hope to continue to see across the Country.
 Senator Lummis. It is my experience that the people of 
Kemmerer, a town that would have dried up but for TerraPower's 
involvement in that community, is very supportive of its 
presence there. It was very welcoming.
 Wyoming has a history of uranium mining, you do not have 
some of the same fears of the unknown, because it is a known in 
Wyoming. The reemergence of this new technology is something 
that we have a tendency to welcome, especially those of us who 
are native to Wyoming and have that legacy history with this 
industry.
 Mr. Loris, opponents of permitting reform sometimes argue 
that additional process automatically produces better 
environmental outcomes. Under the RECHARGE framework, we are 
specifically incentivizing private investment into already 
disturbed industrial sites and brownfields, instead of pushing 
development onto undeveloped land.
 One of the things I have seen with TerraPower, for example, 
is their initial permitting process was completed in 19 months, 
rather than the projected 27 months, which I saw as an 
indication that permitting is working. Others, I think, fear 
that because the time spent on that initial phase of the 
evaluation was shortened that maybe steps were missed.
 How can we assure people that permitting that is expedited 
can still produce a complete, thorough, safe permit process?
 Mr. Loris. Yes, well, it has to for these projects to have 
an opportunity to move forward. You see what companies do with 
pre-application processes and as Dr. White mentioned, it is 
incumbent upon not just industry but also the permitting 
process to assure the public to engage communities, for sure.
 We just can not get into a system of kind of analysis 
paralysis or subject these projects to endless litigation and 
these kinds of litigation doom loops that energy projects of 
all stripes face.
 I think that there is a kind of Goldilocks scenario here 
where, yes, you can have the public engagement, you can ensure 
that we are not duplicating efforts, if there is a reactor 
technology that has already been reviewed by the Department of 
Energy or the NRC or there is these brownfield sites, that 
there are opportunities to just make a more efficient process.
 Also, again, kind of rein in some of this excessive 
litigation that we have seen. Sometimes it is just a few bad 
apples that can upset the cart. We have seen this, again, not 
just with nuclear, but with energy projects across the board. 
Even more industrial projects, one example in New York with a 
semiconductor fab, this is in more upstate New York, had 
acceptance from the community, the public, a lot of investment 
in jobs were coming. There were six people in the community who 
did not want it, resulting in trying to litigate it out of 
existence.
 Yes, we can have more efficient processes and reduce 
duplication, but we also need processes that allow these 
projects to move forward once the community accepts them, once 
the investment is there.
 Senator Lummis. Are there currently overlapping Federal 
reviews in the case of brownfields remediation processes?
 Mr. Loris. Yes, and I think just with the process 
generally, I think that is one of the hopes of reforming the 
National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, is to reduce some 
of the redundancies, not just at the Federal level, but also at 
the Federal and State level, and not allow for some of the 
abuses of these laws for litigation.
 Looking at kind of what previous analyses have already 
done, what previous engagements with communities and tribes 
have already been accomplished, those are things that we can 
learn from and we should buildup, so we are not doing it over 
and over again.
 Senator Lummis. Well, as we all know, reforming the way 
NEPA is implemented transcends so many sectors.
 Mr. Loris. For sure.
 Senator Lummis. Hopefully that can benefit this sector as 
well.
 Again, Mr. Loris, does codifying a clear rulemaking 
standard provide more certainty for regional manufacturers and 
fabricators and construction firms than otherwise might cause 
them not to participate in nuclear projects because of that 
kind of regulatory ambiguity?
 Mr. Loris. It does. Dr. Stein talked about this in his 
remarks, that the NRC already has the ability for permitting 
commercial-grade concrete, steel, rebar. Based on the NRC's 
report to Congress after the ADVANCE Act, it does seem like 
this is complex. It is unclear for both the developers of the 
power plant, but also for these companies.
 Having the NRC provide just more simplicity and more 
clarity about what can be done and what can not be done opens 
up that opportunities for more local manufacturers, 
construction firms to participate and engage with nuclear 
companies, not be kind of frozen out, thinking that because 
they do not want to go through the quality assurance checks or 
there is a constrained supply. If there is more clarity on 
that, that is going to open up this for more opportunities. 
That ultimately means more competition, more choice, and lower 
prices.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you. You mentioned Dr. Stein, and Dr. 
Stein, I am sorry I missed your opening statement, but I 
understand that you have noted that the NRC is beginning to 
adopt right-sized environmental reviews in cases where impacts 
are limited. What would it signal to private capital markets if 
Congress codified that kind of streamlined review for 
redevelopment on previous energy sites?
 Mr. Stein. It would be a signal that one, the history of 
building nuclear power projects shows that the impacts are 
commensurate to other industrial sites, therefore disturbing 
the same land that has already been disturbed would not 
increase and may actually leave the site better than found.
 It would also signal that the process should be scaled 
relative to the size. An environmental impact statement, as Mr. 
Loris mentioned, does become disrupted by litigation at times. 
Having an environmental assessment when an environmental impact 
statement is not necessary because the site impacts would be 
minimal would also streamline the entire overall process, and 
reduce NRC resources that would be necessary to complete such a 
study.
 Senator Lummis. Are there capital markets that are 
reluctant to engage in nuclear projects in the U.S.? Is it a 
problem? Is it hard to get money?
 Mr. Stein. Absolutely.
 Senator Lummis. Is it because it is nuclear?
 Mr. Stein. It is in part because it is nuclear, yes. The 
capital markets understand that the cost for nuclear materials 
alone, because of regulation or because of siting costs, 
because of regulatory uncertainty, all increases the 
uncertainty of the project being completed. That puts their 
capital at risk. That would be more at risk, simply due to 
regulatory risk, than it would be to invest in other projects.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you.
 You emphasized that credible nuclear development depends on 
a credible fuel strategy and reduces exposure to foreign supply 
chains. The U.S. has longstanding uranium resources in places 
like Wyoming, yet domestic production is not consistently 
translated into fuel security.
 Again, Dr. Stein, from your perspective, what is the 
missing link between domestic uranium resources and a fully 
resilient nuclear fuel supply chain?
 Dr. Stein. That is an interesting question. I think there 
are a few missing links. The first would be a clear, 
streamlined process for licensing fuel facilities and 
enrichment facilities and conversion facilities.
 The standards that we currently have are more restrictive 
than even licensing for reactors that utilize those facilities, 
instead of commensurate to the risk of the fuel facility 
itself. This is in part because they were last modified many, 
many years ago. The deterministic standard is that they now 
need to be reconsidered.
 The second is the cost of uranium production in the U.S. is 
simply much higher than in some other countries where the 
uranium is easier to get to than in the United States. 
Therefore, the market itself exposes the developer to more 
risk.
 To have national security and energy security, we need to 
have prioritized further exploration of uranium production in 
the U.S., so we can move away from other countries that put the 
entire supply chain at risk.
 Senator Lummmis. Madam Chairman has arrived. I am going to 
ask one more question of Dr. Stein, and I have questions for 
Dr. White. I will postpone those so our chair has a chance to 
ask questions.
 I have had the wicked indulgence of having this entire 
witness panel to myself.
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Lummis. I have used more time than that to which I 
am entitled. I am going to take another question with Dr. Stein 
before you ask your questions, if that is OK.
 Senator Capito. OK, sure.
 Senator Lummis. OK. Dr. Stein, in your testimony, you 
outlined a number of reforms that are already underway with NRC 
processes and rulemaking. Where do you see the remaining 
friction points that are sitting outside the agency's control, 
the NRC's control? How does today's hearing fit into addressing 
those constraints?
 Mr. Stein. Thank you for that question.
 There are several constraints, particularly inside the 
Atomic Energy Act, that are outside the agency's control, and 
the agency's current responses, even to modernize their own 
regulations, are confined by what they can accomplish under the 
Act.
 One example would be, an enrichment facility is required to 
have an environmental impact statement in the Atomic Energy 
Act, which is unique and exceptional compared to other 
industrial or even other nuclear facilities. The Advisory 
Committee on Reactor Safeguards is required to review every 
license application where, instead, if we had, for instance, 
100 applications under review in a year, that would simply 
become a bottleneck.
 Senator Lummis. Yes.
 Mr. Stein. I believe the Advisory Committee on Reactor 
Safeguards is important, but should focus on new, novel 
constraints instead of reviewing the tenth or seventieth of the 
exact same license.
 I also believe, as Senator Kelly mentioned earlier while 
you were out, that we should not necessarily require a hearing 
for a license where nobody requests a hearing. That was a 
remnant of the transition from the Atomic Energy Commission, 
AEC, to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission in the 1970's. It 
should be reconsidered as well.
 There is a definition between a research and test reactor 
and commercial or industrial reactor between Section 103 and 
104. It is unclear why that, the basis used there, where that 
line is, is the line in the sand, and why research and test 
reactors under that are subject to only the regulations 
necessary to protect the health and safety of the public and 
the environment, while commercial and industrial facilities can 
be required to have regulations far beyond what is necessary to 
adequately protect the health and safety of the public and the 
environment.
 Senator Lummis. I want to thank the witnesses. Now, Madam 
Chairman, you are recognized for as long as you want to talk. 
Do not use as much time as I did.
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Capito. Thank you, Senator Lummis. Thanks for your 
leadership here. Thank you to all the panel for being here.
 Over recent years, Congress has actively focused on 
addressing outdated statutory requirements that has limited the 
safe deployment of nuclear power. The cornerstone of those was 
the enactment of the bipartisan ADVANCE Act, the bill that I 
sponsored with help from members of this committee, including 
Ranking Member Whitehouse, Senators Lummis and Kelly.
 While we focused on ensuring that the NRC implements the 
bill as we intended, there are discrete and targeted 
legislative changes that need to be addressed, as the subject 
of this discussion, obviously. Those issues include eliminating 
what is known as the mandatory hearing, I do not know if that 
is what you were just talking about? Yes. Modernizing the 
Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards, and building on 
previous efforts to provide sufficient compensation to NRC 
leadership to compete with the private sector.
 I appreciate you, Senator Lummis, for calling this hearing 
on this conversation.
 We had a hearing last week, I think it was, although the 
weeks are starting to move together, recently, I will just say 
that, with all the NRC commissioners. I was very encouraged in 
that hearing, because having sat in past hearings, oversight 
hearings with the NRC, there had been previously been a lot 
more tension, I felt like, and a lot more disagreement among 
commissioners, and therefore, a lot of stagnation.
 This particular commission that has been put together, 
while there are differences, they are gliding, it appeared, and 
I think it is, and I will ask you your opinion, as though they 
are kind of cleaning out the cobwebs here, and moving toward 
where they have like and possibility of reaching agreements to 
pick up speed and to implement the ADVANCE Act at the same 
time.
 That, to me, is encouraging. I would be interested to know, 
we will just kind of go through the panel here. Mr. Loris, 
would you agree with that, with the implementation of the 
ADVANCE Act and the EO 14-300, how has the NRC been moving 
forward, in your opinion, on that?
 Mr. Loris. I think very well. Kudos to you for the passage 
and ultimately signing ADVANCE into law, as well as NEIMA. I 
think it builds a foundation that so many proponents of nuclear 
energy have been talking about for so long, which is how do we 
reform and modernize the NRC, and how do we reform a lot of 
outdated rules and regulations.
 I think what the NRC is doing now is making progress on 
that. One thing I noted in my oral remarks is that there has 
been talk about transitioning to this risk-informed, 
performance-based standard for how we approach different 
technologies and licensing. We are finally on the path to 
actually getting there, and there has been a few kind of 
hiccups along the way.
 I think now is the time we are actually seeing the fruit 
borne of all of the work that has gone into what the NRC is now 
doing.
 Senator Capito. Dr. Stein?
 Mr. Stein. Yes, I agree with that. I think the Commission 
is working well together at this point, and they all are, and 
mentioned in the last hearing, to my recollection, that they 
are all focused on enabling nuclear technologies for the 
benefit of society. That difference has shifted how they are 
approaching what needs to be done, and the timeliness of how it 
needs to be done. There are around 70 rulemakings ongoing right 
now, which is a huge change from the past.
 As Mr. Loris mentioned, we are moving to a risk-informed, 
performance-based standard. They have been doing that since the 
1990's. They previously were taking one step at a time, and 
every rule that they changed, they were hesitant to change the 
next one in line.
 They wanted to have licensees to come in and test to see if 
that was the right change to move forward. That would require 
us to have dozens of licensees over the years, just to see if 
the regulations were appropriate, where it is the regulators' 
job to define what the regulations should be, not the 
applicants that test them.
 Senator Capito. Dr. White?
 Mr. White. I agree with both Mr. Loris and Dr. Stein, the 
pace of change at the NRC over the last few years really pushed 
by Congress, and by the administration, has been unprecedented. 
I think if we had discussions about how quickly the NRC is 
completing some of these new rules, people that have been in 
the industry for years would not have believed it.
 I think it is a really exciting time to see how the NRC is 
updating its processes, updating its internal culture, and 
really moving quickly on these things.
 The two items I would just note, though, is that I think 
with the excitement that we have around the pace of this 
regulatory change, let's make sure that we are not just rushing 
for the sake of rushing, and we are still ensuring that the 
regulations we are developing are effective and efficient.
 To the point that Dr. Stein made, with 70 rulemakings that 
are ongoing right now, there is a lot to review, both for NRC 
staff, for the Commission and for public stakeholders that 
really want to provide the input from their own perspective, 
whether it is members of the public, or companies. How do we 
make sure that the rules that are moving through ultimately 
meet the need of the industry and of the Nation?
 I think the other thing to just keep in mind is, let's not 
lose sight of the licensing reviews that are underway right now 
at the NRC. I think sometimes there can be a bit of a 
distraction on, OK, what is the new thing that we are working 
through, what are the rules. Let's not lose track of the 
companies that are actually making progress and make sure they 
are getting the resources.
 Senator Capito. Right. As I recall from the previous 
meeting that we had, I think as part of my remarks it was 
noting that one of the license reviews had moved through in a 
much more timely previous license, much more timely than it had 
been in the past.
 The other thing is obviously, the first thing, No. 1 is 
safety all the way through, no matter. If you could say, oh, we 
are rushing 70 regulations through, it could appear that you 
are forsaking safety. They made it all clear, all through the 
panel, that safety is No. 1 and remains No. 1. I was pleased 
with that.
 I just have one last question, well, actually I have 
another comment on work force, because they all expressed, a 
lot of people left, and then how to replace, and the 
competition in the private sector, because there is so much 
more interest and actually people are seeing a little bit of 
light at the end of the tunnel, and we are actually going to be 
building these things.
 This is a challenge that we are well aware of, so we may 
have to do something there to help incentivize that young 
talent to not just come to the NRC but to stay there for a 
period of time to help move through what I think is an exciting 
time.
 Last question I wanted to ask is, the Department of Energy 
launched an initiative to use a previously unused authority to 
allow for construction and operation of privately owned and 
privately funded nuclear reactors. This was undertaken in part 
because of the historic challenges we just talked about, about 
slow and expensive licensing.
 Dr. Stein, what is your view of these respective tools for 
the DOE? If you have already talked about this, I am sorry for 
being repetitive.
 The roles of each DOE and NRC in terms of licensing test 
reactors and commercial power plants, and do you think any 
limits should be placed on DOE's authority and how to make sure 
that the current initiatives do not sacrifice long-term 
durability?
 Mr. Stein. Thank you, Senator, for the question. I think 
that the NRC has jurisdiction over commercial and industrial 
applications of reactor and nuclear power technology under the 
Atomic Energy Act, pretty clearly. That was not removed from 
the NRC's purview when the Energy Reorganization Act split the 
Atomic Energy Commission into the NRC and what became DOE.
 DOE has authority to develop technologies and test and 
research technologies. Their authority is limited to what is 
under contract for the Department of Energy. It is not 
primarily supposed to be for commercial or industrial uses.
 The Atomic Energy Act, under Section 104, gives the NRC the 
authority for research and test reactors for a reason. Research 
and test reactors can be properly licensed for long-term use, 
and the NRC has used that authority for both research and 
university and other test reactors in the past.
 For durability, my view is that we need to fix the NRC, not 
bifurcate the licensing between DOE to NRC process. That is not 
to say that there is no pathway between the two. Technologies 
that are developed under DOE should have a path to 
commercialization, ultimately. There should not be a barrier 
there.
 I do not think that that should be the primary pathway.
 Senator Capito. Dr. White, do you have an opinion on that?
 Mr. White. Yes, I do. It always great when I have a 
colleague like Dr. Stein who can quote chapter and verse from 
the Atomic Energy Act, so I do not have to.
 [Laughter.]
 Mr. White. I appreciate that.
 Senator Capito. Well, we already knew it, anyway.
 [Laughter.]
 Mr. White. Yes, speaking to the choir here on that one.
 I would actually, I completely agree with Dr. Stein here in 
terms of how do we think about the Atomic Energy Act and how do 
we think about really the role and regulatory jurisdiction of 
the Department of Energy and the NRC when it comes to these 
facilities.
 I think it is really important to keep in mind when 
Congress in 1974 ended up splitting the Atomic Energy 
Commission, the focus really was to say, one organization 
should be primarily looking at commercial applications, 
licensing different activities, and that the Department of 
Energy should be supporting these research and development 
activities.
 I think as we are trying to think about how to accelerate, 
I completely agree with Dr. Stein that the focus should really 
be on continuing the progress that we have seen at the NRC and 
not trying to create alternative shortcuts or pathways around 
kind of the original intent of the Atomic Energy Act and the 
amendments in 1974.
 I think there are opportunities to think about how do we 
leverage lessons learned from projects that are licensed under 
the Department of Energy to subsequent commercial activities. 
We should not necessarily look for ways to get around that 
essentially separation of the Department of Energy and the NRC.
 Senator Capito. Would you say, are the lines blurred there, 
or are they pretty clear?
 Mr. White. My personal opinion is that kind of in statute 
the lines are very clear, with the way Congress has essentially 
separated out the Department of Energy's authority and the 
NRC's authority. I think as we start talking about projects 
that are trying to move quickly, how do we make sure that there 
is still that clear division of responsibilities and 
authorities?
 Senator Capito. Yes. Thank you all very much.
 Thank you, Madam Chair.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you.
 I will let you know that if, I am going to ask some 
questions of Dr. White. When I am done, if Senator Kelly has 
not returned to ask more questions, I will ask one final 
question of all of you. That question is, is there something 
that you want to say on the record that you were not asked, but 
were dying to talk about today?
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Lummis. Thank you, Madam Chairman.
 Dr. White, thanks for being here. We are in a moment where 
demand for electricity is rising quickly. It is almost 
insatiable at this point.
 Some day, we may find a way to utilize the facilities that 
are being built right now more efficiently, so they produce 
more energy. Until that day comes, what do you see as the 
biggest practical bottlenecks to deploying nuclear energy 
faster at scale in our Country?
 Mr. White. Thank you so much, Senator. I would say my 
biggest, my opinion on kind of the biggest bottleneck is really 
the economic questions that we are facing, and how do we create 
kind of the demand signal and order books for new nuclear 
technology.
 The history of nuclear energy in the United States shows 
that if you keep building first-of-a-kind projects and one-off 
nuclear reactors, they are going to have schedule and cost 
challenges. They are going to take too long, and they are going 
to cost too much.
 If we look both in the United States and internationally, 
if we could start to build out order books of standardized 
technologies and get companies to not just build one reactor, 
but 10, 20, 50 or 100, we can come down the cost curve and 
deliver nuclear energy affordably, reliably and on time.
 I think as we start talking about nuclear energy in the 
next 5, 10, 25 years, how do we create the conditions where 
companies are willing to make the investments in new nuclear 
energy and build out these standard designs?
 Some of the work the Clean Air Task Force does as party of 
the Nuclear Scaling Initiative is trying to identify what are 
the company conditions, what are the government policies, and 
how do we ultimately kind of get nuclear deployed at scale, so 
we are not just building one or two of these reactors, but we 
can build hundreds of these reactors to meet some of the 
demands of energy that we have seen, and hit the goals of 
quadrupling nuclear energy by 2050.
 Senator Lummis. Do you think that is an attainable goal?
 Mr. White. I think it is a really important and ambitious 
goal. As we start looking at how we are going to need to power 
the United States by mid-century, we are going to need more 
energy than we can even possibly imagine. I think we would want 
that energy to be clean and affordable.
 I think it is really important to set these ambitious 
goals, then to say, what are the policies and what are the 
processes and partnerships that we can really look at to hit 
that goal.
 Again, if you only set your sights of, oh, maybe we can 
build five reactors by 2050, are we really dreaming big enough? 
Or do we want to figure out, what does it mean for nuclear 
energy to continue to play a really meaningful role as part of 
our future energy mix?
 Senator Lummis. I appreciate that response very much.
 You have discussed the importance of expanding domestic 
enrichment, and HALEU, the low-enrichment uranium. What do you 
see as the most immediate step needed to reduce reliance on 
foreign supply chains?
 Mr. White. Great, thank you, Senator. Yes, the HALEU, the 
high assay, low enriched uranium, it is a heck of a term that 
the nuclear engineers came up with. I think I can blame them 
for that.
 Yes, I think as we start talking about building out 
domestic uranium enrichment capacity in the United States, 
there are kind of two big steps that we really look at.
 The first is, how do we create essentially the market 
conditions necessary for companies to come in and make major 
investments in uranium enrichment facilities. I think a lot of 
the work that Congress has done to put in the Russian uranium 
ban, for example, is a really good way to say, we want to 
prioritize uranium production from the United States and its 
allies, and not just rely on Russia in the future.
 I think that helps create a really strong demand signal in 
the future, because we know we are going to have to make up 
that 20 percent of Russian uranium enrichment capacity. As we 
look forward to things like HALEU, we need to actually set up 
the opportunity and the infrastructure in the United States to 
produce it domestically. I think that is a really important 
first step.
 I think the second step is overcoming a little bit of the 
chicken and the egg program that we have seen historically 
around this. Companies are unwilling to make investments in new 
nuclear energy, uranium enrichment infrastructure, until they 
know there is a demand signal. Companies can not make contracts 
for this fuel until they know the fuel is going to be there.
 I think there has been really important work by the 
Department of Energy to try to create, through things like the 
Advanced Reactor Fuels Program, to try to provide economic 
support and contracts to companies to help facilitate that 
first investment.
 I think it is going to be really interesting over the next 
couple of years, as we see some of these private enrichment 
companies try to stand up new infrastructure. Companies like 
Orano in Tennessee, we have had conversations about companies 
like Global Laser Enrichment, GLE, in Paducah, Kentucky, 
General Matters, Urenco, Centrus, there are a lot of companies 
that are doing really interesting work.
 I think resolving those economic barriers is going to be 
the real key to get this going.
 Senator Lummis. A question for anyone on the panel who 
wishes to answer: is the fact that we only have one facility to 
accomplish conversion in the U.S. now a bottleneck?
 Mr. Stein. Not for the current fleet. For expanding 
capacity, absolutely.
 Senator Lummis. Anyone else?
 Mr. Loris. Yes, I was just going to say, not just like, for 
marginal expanded capacity yes, and then if we are talking 
about Dr. White's wish and goal, which I share, of building 
hundreds of reactors or even dozens of reactors, then it really 
becomes a challenge.
 Senator Lummis. Dr. White?
 Mr. White. I would agree with that as well. I think right 
now, there probably is sufficient conversion capacity for the 
fleet we have today. If we want to actually build nuclear 
energy out at scale, we are going to have to talk about where 
those different steps of the supply chain are going to come 
into play.
 Coming up with a plan now of how we are going to have those 
facilities ready in 10 years of 15 years is really important.
 Senator Lummis. What is government's role in that? Is this 
something that the private sector is contemplating and can 
respond to? Or does the government need to be involved in those 
discussions?
 Mr. White. I think my personal perspective on that, 
Senator, is really that the government can help kind of serve 
as a catalyst for private investment. If companies have 
uncertainty around what the demand is going to be like in the 
future, they might want to hold off on a major capital 
investment in something like a uranium enrichment facility or a 
uranium conversion facility until they know there will be 
demand for the next 40 years on this. They might be hesitant to 
make those investments early.
 Where the U.S. Government and other policies can come into 
play is to help kind of kick start that process, because we 
know this is a goal for the Country, this is something we want 
to see for U.S. energy production.
 Let's get that infrastructure going today, so it is ready 
when we need it, as opposed to in 10 years, when we suddenly 
see a huge demand spike in nuclear technology going, wow, I 
really wish we had started that in 2026, because that facility 
would be ready today. I think that is where government policy 
can be most effective.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you so much.
 Dr. Stein?
 Mr. Stein. If I may add, I think that Congress has already 
sent this clear signal by providing up to $2.7 billion for 
enrichment and conversion facilities, and for what was at the 
time termed a HALEU bank to have an early off-take agreement 
for HALEU production.
 Early developers in projects, it is difficult for a utility 
to allocate capital to a project when they do not think they 
can get fuel for 40 years at a reasonable price. It is 
difficult for an enricher to build a whole facility for a one-
off reactor.
 They need a large-scale procurement to justify the 
investment, and you need to invest five or 10 years before 
building an enrichment facility. We need an order book more to 
have enrichment facilities than we even need for one-off 
reactors. This is more long-term thinking that the government 
would be the appropriate source from, instead of industry.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you.
 Mr. Loris. I would also just quickly add that we do not 
need to be self-sufficient. Imports in and of themselves are 
not necessarily a bad thing. They are bad if they are coming 
from Russia. If they are coming from Canada or our allied 
countries, we can rely on imports to some extent. Building up 
that domestic capacity is critically important, but we should 
still maintain that open and free trade.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you.
 Senator Kelly is in another committee. There are multiple 
hearings going on this morning, so we apologize for coming and 
going.
 I do want to ask the panel this final question. That is, 
what do you wish to put on the record, the written record of 
this hearing, that we did not ask? What do you want the U.S. 
Senate to know about the status of this industry, areas where 
congressional involvement could spark some progress? The floor 
is yours.
 Mr. Loris, would you share that with us, please?
 Mr. Loris. Sure. Thank you for this opportunity, again, to 
testify. To build off Dr. White's one comment, my hope is 
really that we do not have an industry where we are just 
building a handful of reactors that are dependent on tax 
credits and loan guarantees, but we are actually reforming and 
creating a framework that allows nuclear plants, advanced 
reactors, large light water reactors, to be cost-competitive 
with other sources of energy and technology.
 That is critically important, because affordability is what 
matters most. These reactors are not going to get built if they 
can not compete on cost with solar and storage or with natural 
gas.
 The framework that we are building off of from the ADVANCE 
Act and what the NRC is doing and what this bill and discussion 
drafts are going are great steps in the right direction. My 
hope is that we continue to build on that and expand and think 
creatively. I am more open to alternative licensing processes 
and maybe the NRC can devolve even more responsibilities down 
to the State through the Agreement State program when it makes 
sense to do so.
 If we are building hundreds of reactors, that could create 
a huge bottleneck at the NRC. We need to expand and build the 
resources at the NRC. I do not want that necessarily to be the 
choke point for all of these reactors trying to get built.
 I think this is great, positive momentum in the right 
direction. I think there is a lot more to do and explore, to 
how we can truly have that nuclear renaissance.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you, Mr. Loris.
 Dr. Stein?
 Mr. Stein. Thank you, Chair Lummis. I believe that the bill 
on categorical exclusions for existing or old industrial sites 
has an opportunity to significantly streamline licensing. The 
review of the TerraPower Natrium EIS found only small impacts, 
except for in two cases, for historical preservation and for 
socio-economics.
 Socio-economics was actually a positive impact, even 
thought it was moderate. Historical preservation, while it is 
important, is not as much of a factor for a previously 
disturbed old industrial site, which would have either been 
already damaged or remediated previously.
 In terms of actions that only Congress can take, there is 
a, what I will call a tangled web of radiation standards across 
multiple agencies in the U.S. Government with a 100,000 factor 
difference between the radiation standards and what is deemed 
acceptable.
 Senator Lummis. Wow.
 Mr. Stein. These agencies are implementing different 
statutes in different ways that were set up at different times. 
They are mostly in statute or derived from the language in the 
statute, only Congress can help untangle some of these 
challenges.
 The final thing I would like to say is that I completely 
share with Dr. White's vision that we need more nuclear energy 
for the future, and that to get there, it should be a national 
priority, for multiple reasons.
 The NRC is being more efficient, they are acting more 
appropriately, particularly since the ADVANCE Act. The 
TerraPower application that you mentioned in Wyoming, and that 
Senator Capito mentioned was more efficient, it was more 
efficient by 30 percent than originally estimated under the 
existing regulations.
 Even before all of the rulemakings that are going on right 
now. That meant there was always efficiency to be had. NRC just 
needed to take the stance that they wanted to be more 
efficient.
 That being said, with the ongoing rulemakings, their 
implementation and the Environment and Public Works Committee's 
oversight of the NRC's implementation will be important to make 
sure that the public benefits are protected in this significant 
but important change.
 Senator Lummis. Thank you, Dr. Stein.
 Dr. White?
 Mr. White. Thanks so much for the opportunity, Senator 
Lummis.
 I think kind of just four quick topics I would love to get 
on the record. The first is I think just a recognition of the 
NRC and the work that has been done there over the last several 
years. A lot of this has come through the direction of 
Congress, through the direction of this committee.
 There have been real changes that have been made at the 
NRC. I think we are already starting to see the benefits of 
those changes in terms of how quickly they are able to review 
and approve some of these advanced reactor licenses that we are 
seeing today.
 I think if you had gone back and had this conversation in 
the committee 10 years ago, how long will it take the NRC to 
license a first-of-a-kind sodium fast reactor or high-
temperature gas reactor, people would have said, 48 months 
minimum, at least 4 years. The NRC is doing it in less than 
two. I think that really reflects a lot of the changes that we 
have seen, both with direction from Congress, a better focus on 
licensing modernization, and then the great work that the NRC 
staff and Commission have done to really implement these 
changes.
 I think while we are always talking about how we can 
improve regulation, I think there is a good opportunity to 
celebrate what is already being done there and what is 
continuing to go on.
 The second is that I think as we talk about trying to meet 
some of these deployment goals for nuclear energy, really 
recognizing that a lot of the great work that this committee 
and Congress have done have made it so that nuclear regulation 
is not the bottleneck that we should be talking about. We have 
resolved a lot of the regulatory issues.
 There are still things we need to work on, and we need to 
make sure that regulation is implemented correctly. Ultimately, 
it is starting to address now the policy and economic 
challenges laid to deploy nuclear technology in scale. Let's 
not always think, oh, regulation is stopping us from deploying 
nuclear energy, let's talk about the bigger suite of policies 
and opportunities to get us to deploy nuclear at this hundreds 
of gigawatts that we think we need by mid-century.
 The third is just to touch on something Dr. Stein said 
around environmental reviews. I think with both nuclear energy 
technology and other energy technologies broadly, let's always 
keep kind of the original intent of NEPA in mind, that it was 
not to try to figure out if something is good or bad, but it is 
really to try to document what are the potential environmental 
impacts of a major Federal action, and that the process should 
ultimately resolve in a record of decision or other kind of 
reports, to allow people to understand, what is this project 
going to mean for the human environment.
 I think there is sometimes a little bit of a desire to 
figure out, OK, how can we shorten this process as quickly as 
possible, because we have seen it start to grow out of hand in 
some cases, with the EIS it has taken years to develop.
 I guess my thinking would be, let's just not throw the baby 
out with the bathwater. Let's go back and think about how we 
can really meet the original intent of NEPA and perform 
meaningful environmental reviews that produce that public 
record, that enable public engagement, but also do not inhibit 
the development of the clean energy technology that we need.
 The final point, if you will grant me the moment, is to 
really just kind of emphasize the importance of NRC 
independence and NRC transparency in a lot of these 
discussions. I think the NRC is a regulatory agency that has 
just an incredible history, especially since the Energy 
Reorganization Act of 1974, of really showing their thinking of 
how they reach the decision on regulatory topics.
 As someone who is a complete nerd for regulatory history, I 
love that I can go to the NRC's library and actually go out and 
see, what was the NRC and the staff thinking about in the 
1990's when they approved facilities, and how are some of those 
lessons and best practices still applicable today, or what 
things have changed?
 I think as we talk about the NRC moving forward, to try to 
kind of meet the needs of the moment, I want to make sure that 
we are maintaining that independence and maintaining that 
transparency.
 When I start to see some of the changes at the agency 
around, for example, not publishing all the Commission votes 
for certain activities, as someone who is outside and trying to 
understand what is going on at the agency, it makes it harder 
to understand, what is the Commission doing? While I would love 
to trust that the NRC is doing great work, and I do, it is 
always good to be able to verify that.
 I think more opportunities to provide that independence and 
that view into what the Commission is doing and what the 
Commission decides is a really effective way to both get good 
regulatory outcomes, but then also maintain the public trust 
that we have in the NRC as that kind of independent nuclear 
regulator.
 Senator Lummis. Well, I must say, it warms my heart to know 
that there are people that actually go and read the 1990 
minutes of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. That just tells 
me that there are Americans that albeit nerds----
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Lummis [continuing]. are really watching out for 
what these agencies do, how they can do it better, what our 
history has been in areas like this that are critical to our 
energy future, but that the American people want to know, go 
forward with confidence that they are being done safely, 
efficiently, and that our communities are going to enjoy, not 
only the benefits of having things like brownfield sites 
revitalized and communities revitalized with jobs and 
opportunities in 21st century nuclear energy, but that it is 
being done more safely than ever before.
 The transparency that you advocated for is something that 
government owes its people. I appreciate your bringing that up.
 I appreciate all three of you and your testimony. I 
appreciate your willingness to respond to an open-ended 
question like, what do you wish you could have said.
 I can assure you, Dr. Stein, you may be hearing from one of 
my staffers with regard to the tangled web of definitions 
regarding--whatever my notes say.
 Mr. Stein. Radiation protection.
 Senator Lummis. That was it. That was it, thank you.
 [Laughter.]
 Senator Lummis. I did not bring my reading glasses, but I 
have very good handwriting, so I will be able to replicate 
this.
 Witnesses, thank you so much. With no further questions, I 
thank you all, and I thank my colleagues for their 
participation in today's subcommittee hearing.
 Senators who wish to submit written questions for the 
record have until 5 p.m. on Wednesday, June 3d to do so. The 
witnesses' responses to those questions are due back to the 
subcommittee no later than 5 p.m. on Wednesday, June 17th, and 
will be submitted for the record.
 With that, with my thanks to our witnesses, this hearing is 
adjourned.
 [Whereupon, at 11:16 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
 
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
 
 [all]