Full text of the official published hearing record. Extracted from the source document — verify against the official record for citation.
- BUILDING AN AI-READY AMERICA: ADOPTING AI AT WORK [House Hearing, 119 Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] BUILDING AN AI-READY AMERICA: ADOPTING AI AT WORK ======================================================================= HEARING BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON HEALTH, EMPLOYMENT, LABOR, AND PENSIONS OF THE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION __________ HEARING HELD IN WASHINGTON, DC, FEBRUARY 3, 2026 __________ Serial No. 119-44 __________ Printed for the use of the Committee on Education and Workforce [GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Available via: edworkforce.house.gov or www.govinfo.gov __________ U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE 65-540 PDF WASHINGTON : 2026 ======================================================================= COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE TIM WALBERG, Michigan, Chairman JOE WILSON, South Carolina ROBERT C. ``BOBBY'' SCOTT, VIRGINIA FOXX, North Carolina Virginia, GLENN THOMPSON, Pennsylvania Ranking Member GLENN GROTHMAN, Wisconsin JOE COURTNEY, Connecticut ELISE M. STEFANIK, New York FREDERICA S. WILSON, Florida RICK W. ALLEN, Georgia SUZANNE BONAMICI, Oregon JAMES COMER, Kentucky MARK TAKANO, California BURGESS OWENS, Utah ALMA S. ADAMS, North Carolina LISA C. McCLAIN, Michigan MARK DeSAULNIER, California MARY E. MILLER, Illinois DONALD NORCROSS, New Jersey JULIA LETLOW, Louisiana LUCY McBATH, Georgia KEVIN KILEY, California JAHANA HAYES, Connecticut MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio ILHAN OMAR, Minnesota JAMES C. MOYLAN, Guam HALEY M. STEVENS, Michigan ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri GREG CASAR, Texas RYAN MACKENZIE, Pennsylvania SUMMER L. LEE, Pennsylvania MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington JOHN W. MANNION, New York MARK HARRIS, North Carolina ADELITA S. GRIJALVA, Arizona MARK B. MESSMER, Indiana RANDY FINE, Florida R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director ------ SUBCOMMITTEE ON HEALTH, EMPLOYMENT, LABOR, AND PENSIONS RICK ALLEN, Georgia, Chairman ROBERT F. ONDER, Jr., Missouri MARK DeSAULNIER, California, JOE WILSON, South Carolina Ranking Member VIRGINIA FOXX, North Carolina JOE COURTNEY, Connecticut JAMES COMER, Kentucky DONALD NORCROSS, New Jersey BURGESS OWENS, Utah LUCY McBATH, Georgia LISA C. McCLAIN, Michigan JAHANA HAYES, Connecticut MICHAEL A. RULLI, Ohio GREG CASAR, Texas RYAN MACKENZIE, Pennsylvania SUMMER L. LEE, Pennsylvania MICHAEL BAUMGARTNER, Washington JOHN W. MANNION, New York RANDY FINE, Florida MARK TAKANO, California C O N T E N T S ---------- Page Hearing held on February 3, 2026................................. 1 OPENING STATEMENTS Allen, Hon. Rick, Chairman, Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions............................ 1 Prepared statement of.................................... 2 DeSaulnier, Hon. Mark, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions.................... 3 Prepared statement of.................................... 4 WITNESSES Kelley, Mr. Bradford, Shareholder, Littler Mendelson, P.C.... 6 Prepared statement of.................................... 8 Sharfuddin, Ms. Revana, Research Fellow, Mercatus Center at George Mason University.................................... 20 Prepared statement of.................................... 21 Goldman, Ms. Tanya, Director, Fellow, Workshop............... 25 Prepared statement of.................................... 28 Walton, Mr. David, Partner, Fisher Phillips.................. 37 Prepared statement of.................................... 40 ADDITIONAL SUBMISSIONS Chairman Allen: Statement dated February 3, 2025, from Workday........... 77 Letter dated February 2, 2026, from Anthropic............ 82 Statement dated February 20, 2026, from CHRO Association. 86 QUESTIONS FOR THE RECORD Responses to questions submitted for the record by: Ms. Tanya Goldman........................................ 92 BUILDING AN AI-READY AMERICA: ADOPTING AI AT WORK ---------- Tuesday, February 3, 2026 House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions, Committee on Education and Workforce, Washington, DC. The Subcommittee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:15 a.m., in Room 2175, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Rick Allen (Chairman of the Subcommittee) presiding. Present: Representatives Allen, Onder, Foxx, Owens, Rulli, Walberg, DeSaulnier, McBath, Hayes, Lee, Mannion, and Scott. Also present: Representative Bonamici. Staff present: Lauren Blunt, Intern; Vlad Cerga, Director of Information Technology; Hope Dennis, Intern; Halle Greenbaum, Staff Assistant; Libby Kearns, Press Assistant; Katerina Kerska, Legislative Assistant; Trey Kovacs, Director of Workforce Policy; Campbell Ladd, Clerk; R.J. Laukitis, Staff Director; Jack Leonard, Staff Assistant; Danny Marca, Director of Information Technology; Brad Mannion, Professional Staff Member; John Martin, Deputy Director of Workforce Policy/ Counsel; Audra McGeorge, Communications Director; Ethan Pann, Deputy Press Secretary and Digital Director; Sara Robertson, Press Secretary; Katherine Anne Russo, Director of Member Services and Coalitions; Heidi Schneider, Professional Staff Member; Austin Small, Intern; Thomas White, Deputy Clerk; James Whittaker, General Counsel; Ilana Brunner, Minority General Counsel; Micah Buchman, Minority Intern; A'Ishah Johnson, Minority Grad Intern; Dhrtvan Sherman, Minority Research Assistant; Raiyana Malone, Minority Press Secretary; Kevin McDermott, Minority Director of Labor Policy; Marie McGrew, Minority Press Assistant; Eleazer Padilla, Minority Staff Assistant; Mason Pasek, Minority Labor Policy Counsel; Veronique Pluviose, Minority Staff Director; Banyon Vassar, Minority Director of IT. Chairman Allen. The Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor and Pensions will come to order. I note that a quorum is present. Without objection, the Chair is authorized to call a recess at any time. Today's hearing will examine how artificial intelligence or AI, as we all know, is reshaping American workplaces and what that means for job creators and employees. AI is no longer science fiction. It is here and it is significantly transforming industries and workplaces. Optimistically, this technology may boost productivity, empower workers, and put the American dream within reach for more Americans. In my neighboring district, the Port of Savannah has invested more than 4.5 billion in infrastructure to support its supply chain operations, an investment that has made it the fastest growing port in the U.S., on the U.S. East and Gulf Coast. As AI becomes more common in the workplace and fuels American innovation, we must ensure that workers are protected as well. To build an AI ready America, we must first understand AI technologies themselves, how employers are using these tools and the potential risk that AI adoption poses to workers. We want to help American workers and job creators compete and succeed in an AI driven economy. Today's hearing is a strong step in that direction. Today, we will discuss how the National Labor Relations Act can continue to protect workers' rights and promote stable relationships between employees and management in the age of AI. As AI adoption grows, labor laws and their enforcement should strike the right balance between protecting workers and allowing innovation to spur job creation and business growth. This hearing will also discuss the critical role of data collection to gain understanding of AI's impact on workers. The Bureau of Labor Standards (BLS) plays an important role in tracking workforce trends, and it can help inform how AI is changing the modern workforce. Leveraging BLS insights will help us identify the challenges ahead and allow us to make evidence based policy decisions. While technology can make our workplaces better, trust and transparency is--always benefits the workplace. Employers protect rights, strengthen morale and build trust when they communicate openly about how AI is deployed in the workplace. That trust is essential for a competitive workforce and strengthens the ties between workers and job creators. The bottom line is that AI can create a lot of opportunities without compromising fairness or safety. We appreciate the insights our witnesses will offer about how we can ensure that innovation serves people and not the other way around. With that, I yield to the Ranking Member for an opening statement. [The opening statement of Chairman Allen follows:] Statement of Hon. Rick Allen, Chairman, Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor and Pensions Today's hearing will examine how artificial intelligence (AI) is reshaping American workplaces and what that means for employers and employees. AI is no longer science fiction. It is here and there are already signs that it will significantly transform industries and workplaces. Optimistically, this technology may boost productivity, empower workers, and put the American Dream within reach for more Americans. We must also ensure that innovation and worker protections go hand in hand. To build an AI-ready America, we must first understand the AI technologies themselves, how employers are using these tools, and the potential risks AI adoption poses to workers. We want to help American workers and job creators to compete and succeed in an AI-driven economy. Today's hearing is a step in that direction. We will discuss today how the National Labor Relations Act can continue to protect worker rights and promote stable relationships between employees and management in the age of AI. As AI adoption grows, labor laws and their enforcement should strike the right balance between protecting workers and allowing innovation to spur job creation and business growth. This hearing will also discuss the critical role of data collection to gain understanding of AI's impact and to prepare workers. The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) plays an important role in tracking workforce trends, and it can play an important role in collecting data on how AI is changing the modern workplace. Leveraging BLS insights will help us identify the challenges ahead and allow us to make evidence-based policy decisions. While technology can make our workplaces better, trust and transparency can benefit the workplace. When employers communicate openly about how AI is deployed, they protect rights, strengthen morale, and build trust. That trust is essential for a productive, competitive workforce, and for labor peace. The bottom line is that AI can create opportunity without compromising fairness or safety. We appreciate the insights our witnesses will offer about how we can ensure that innovation serves people--not the other way around. ______ Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I must say I could have written that opening statement by you myself. This is a good sign. I think it is important for this Subcommittee and this Committee in particular, because so much of the jurisdiction is here. I am reminded as a member from the Bay Area, the fifth wealthiest district in the United States with a lot of investors in it, a friend of mine who was an early equity investor in social media called me a year or so ago and said ``They're doing the same thing they did with social media,'' meaning private equity investors. They are getting investment, but it is not all going to--the primary drive is to get return on investment, which is nothing against investors. It is just we have to have it proportionate. Historically, the American workforce has not proportionally benefited from new technology. We have to make sure, and I am really encouraged by your comments, Mr. Chairman, that we approach it that way, and this Committee and Congress is really responsible for this. I will say, as a former Chair of the Senate Labor Committee in California, I worked closely with a California labor friend that is working with responsible investors and employers to make sure we get it right. Again, as a member from the San Francisco Bay area where a lot of this is happening, we want to make sure it gets it right. With three national laboratories and research facilities, both public and private, it is important that all of that is done the right way so we do not repeat the mistakes when it comes to technology that history has taught us that we should avoid with all the benefits from technology. I want to thank the witnesses for being here. Again, I want to thank the Chair. Artificial intelligence or AI has rapidly been introduced into Americans' lives. While some uses of this technology in the workplace show promise, it also poses significant dangers. Concerns about this new technology are not without merit. Some employers have used AI as a weapon in retaliation against workers who are trying to unionize or to suppress wages. The unrestricted use of AI can also infringe on workers' privacy. AI risks making it harder for workers to prove it when their gender, race, age or disability status are used to discriminate against them. As AI proliferates, we have begun to see employers, not all employers, but some use sophisticated automated technology to monitor and evaluate workers. This can lead to efficiencies, but we have got to value the balance here in workers' privacy rights. This includes tracking workers on the job, physical activities such as bathroom breaks, using facial recognition to assess their attention to computer screens and other tasks. That is pretty amazing. I think we would all be concerned about that. We do not want to be monitored in this way, or at least we want guardrails and have the best available knowledge to first do no harm. In some cases, AI has the potential to make workers', consumers' and investors' lives easier and better. Without worker input, artificial intelligence could exacerbate the ever-widening power gap between workers and employers. AI should be used in the workplace to help workers do their jobs with ease and efficiency, not encroach on their privacy and pad the company's bottom line at the workers' expense. To strike the right balance, it is imperative that workers and their representatives have a seat at the table in the development and implementation of AI in America's workplace. It is the role of local, State and Federal Government to implement safeguards to prevent employer abuses and create this healthy balance. Congress has a responsibility to rein in big tech companies who take advantage of this prosperity and potential benefits, so that AI can be used for everybody, workers instead of against them. We do not need another tool that will funnel profits to the ultrawealthy at the expense of working Americans. Congress must take an active role in shaping how AI is integrated into our lives and developing thoughtful regulations that balance protecting workers with fostering economic growth. I will leave you all with a quote from a wonderful book that I have recently reread, ``The AI Con'' by Alex Hanna and Emily Bender. The authors warn that AI companies are selling consumers an attractive bill of goods that, quote, ``A few major well-placed players are poised to accumulate significant wealth by extracting value from people's creative work, personal data, or labor and replacing quality services with artificial facsimiles,'' end quote. We have a responsibility. Again, I want to thank my colleague and Chair--and our Chair--for setting the tone of this hearing. It is a balance, and I think we want to come to the table with the AI community, with investors and make sure we strike this balance the right way so everyone can benefit from this and nobody gets take advantage from it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. [The opening statement of Ranking Member DeSaulnier follows:] Statement of Hon. Mark DeSaulnier, Ranking Member, Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor and Pensions Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I must say, I could have written that opening statement by you myself, so this is a good sign. I think it is important for this Subcommittee, and this Committee in particular, because so much of the jurisdiction is here. I am reminded, as a member of the Bay Area--the fifth-wealthiest district in the United States, with a lot of investors in it--[that] a friend of mine, who was an early equity investor in social media, called me a year or so ago and said: ``they're doing the same thing they did with social media.'' Meaning [that] private equity investors [are] getting investment, but the primary drive is to get return on investment. Which is nothing against investors. It is just that we have to have it proportionate. Historically, the American workforce has not proportionally benefited from new technology. We have to make sure--and I am really encouraged by your comments, Mr. Chairman--that we approach it that way. This Committee, and Congress, are responsible for this. I will say as a former chair of the Senate Labor Committee in California, I worked closely with the California Labor Fed, that is working closely with responsible investors to make sure we get it right. Again, as a member from the San Francisco Bay Area, where a lot of this is happening, we want to make sure we get it right. With three national laboratories and research facilities, both public and private, it is important that all of that is done the right way, so we do not repeat the mistakes when it comes to technology that history has taught us that we should avoid, with all the benefits from technology. I want to thank the witnesses for being here today, and I want to thank the Chair. Artificial intelligence, or AI, has rapidly been introduced into Americans' lives. While some uses of this technology in the workplace show promise, it also poses significant dangers. Concerns about this new technology are not without merit. Some employers have used AI as a weapon in retaliation against workers who are trying to unionize or to suppress wages. The unrestricted use of AI can also infringe on workers' privacy. AI risks making it harder for workers to prove it when their gender, race, age, or disability status are used to discriminate against them. As AI proliferates, we have begun to see employers--not all employers, but some--use sophisticated automated technology to monitor and evaluate workers. This can lead to efficiencies, but we have got to balance here with workers' privacy rights. This includes tracking workers' on-the-job physical activity, such as bathroom breaks, using facial recognition to assess their attention to computer screens, and other tasks. That is pretty amazing. I think we would all be concerned about that. We do not want to be monitored in this way, or at least we want guardrails, and have the best available knowledge to do no harm. In some cases, AI has the potential to make workers', consumers', and investors' lives easier and better. Without worker input, artificial intelligence could exacerbate the ever-widening power gap between workers and employers. AI should be used in the workplace to help workers do their jobs with ease and efficiency, not encroach on their privacy and pad the company's bottom line at the workers' expense. To strike the right balance, it is imperative that workers and their representatives have a seat at the table in the development and implementation of AI in America's workplaces. It is the role of local, state, and federal governments to implement safeguards to prevent employer abuses and create this healthy balance. Congress has a responsibility to rein in big tech companies who take advantage of this prosperity and potential benefits so that AI can be used for everybody--for workers instead of against them. We do not need another tool that will funnel profits to the ultra-wealthy at the expense of working Americans. Congress must take an active role in shaping how AI is integrated into our lives and in developing thoughtful regulations that balance protecting workers with fostering economic growth. I will leave you all with a quote from a wonderful book that I have recently reread: The AI Con by Alex Hanna and Emily Bender. The authors warn that AI companies are selling consumers an attractive bill of goods and that ``a few major well-placed players are poised to accumulate significant wealth by extracting value from other people's creative work, personal data, or labor, and replacing quality services with artificial facsimiles.'' We have a responsibility, and again, I want to thank my colleague and our Chair for setting the tone of this hearing. It is a balance. I think we want to come to the table with the AI community, with investors, and make sure we strike this balance the right way, so everyone can benefit from this and no one gets taken advantage of [by] it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I yield back. ______ Chairman Allen. I thank the Ranking Member. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8(c), all members who wish to insert written statements into the record may do so by submitting them to the Committee Clerk electronically in Microsoft Word format by 5 p.m., 14 days after this hearing. Without objection, the hearing record will remain open for 14 days to allow such statements and other extraneous material noted during the hearing to be submitted for the official hearing record. I note that some of our colleagues who are not permanent members of this subcommittee may be waiving on to the hearing today for the purpose of asking questions. I will now turn to the introduction of our four distinguished witnesses. Our first witness is Mr. Bradford Kelley, a shareholder at Littler Mendelson, P.C. from Washington, DC. Our second witness is Ms. Revana Sharfuddin, a research fellow at the Mercatus Center of George Mason University in Arlington, Virginia, and I hope I got most of that correct. Our third witness is Ms. Tanya Goldman, a fellow at The Workshop from Washington, DC. Our last witness is Mr. David Walton, a partner at Fisher Phillips from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. I thank our witnesses and for being here today, and we look forward to your testimony. Pursuant to Committee rules, I would ask that you each limit your oral presentations to a 3-minute summary of your written statement. As Committee members have many questions for you, the clock will count down from 3 minutes. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8(d) and Committee practice, however, we will not cutoff your testimony until you reach the 5-minute mark. I would also like to remind the witnesses to be aware of your responsibility to provide accurate information to this Subcommittee. I will first recognize Mr. Kelley for your testimony. STATEMENT OF BRADFORD KELLEY, SHAREHOLDER, LITTLER MENDELSON, P.C., WASHINGTON, D.C. Mr. Kelley. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today on how we can build an AI ready America. When I think about this topic, I think about my 3 year old daughter. Despite her frequent attempts to commandeer my phone, she does not yet know what AI is, but she will grow up in a world fundamentally shaped by it. As we consider the path forward, we must resist the urge to regulate in haste. Premature or poorly conceived laws can stifle innovation, create regulatory confusion and give our global competitors an opening to outpace us in an area where American leadership is vital. AI is transforming the workplace before our eyes. Used responsibly, it can boost efficiency, reduce subjectivity, help prevent harassment and enhance workplace safety. Critically, these benefits run both ways. AI empowers both employers and workers. Of course, like any technology, AI carries risk including discrimination, intrusive surveillance and job displacement. While some might say that replacing lawyers is not the worst possible outcome, these risks deserve thoughtful, measured attention. We must focus on genuine harms, not speculative fears. Many of the more extreme hypotheticals, like using AI to suppress union activity, remain almost entirely theoretical. As a former official at the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission in the Department of Labor, as well as in private practice, I have never seen employers use AI in a nefarious way. To the contrary, most are focused on using AI to improve efficiency and compliance. That is why a rapid rush to enact new laws is not the answer. As a former Army infantry and intelligence officer and Iraq War veteran, I was trained to master and fortify the defenses you already have before building new. The same principle applies here. The United States already has a well-established, technology-neutral legal framework fully capable of addressing most AI related misconduct. We have already seen what happens when legislation gets ahead of itself. A prime example is the Colorado AI Act. The Governor urged the legislature to fix its flaws on the same day it was signed. Meanwhile, New York City's AI law has been widely criticized for being ineffective and no complaints have been filed. Overreach by Federal agencies can also produce serious and unintended consequences. In 2022, for example, the general counsel of the National Labor Relations Board proposed an amorphous framework that presumptively deemed most AI tools used in the workplace to be unlawful. More broadly, some agencies have issued guidance without attempting to meaningfully understand how AI is actually being used in the workplace. It is also important to highlight what organizations are already doing to ensure that AI is used responsibly and complies with the law. Many leading companies have embraced self-restraint or self-regulation. Countless organizations have adopted and published principles on AI, developed internal accountability measures and implemented policies ensuring that a human is kept in the loop. Employers are not trying to hide the ball. They fully recognize that transparency and accountability are essential. Finally, the growing patchwork of State and local laws has produced an increasingly unworkable regulatory environment. Congress should consider establishing a clear national standard that streamlines compliance, provides certainty and preempts conflicting requirements. A coherent Federal approach will better protect workers, support responsible innovation and help ensure that America continues to lead from the front. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions. [The prepared statement of Mr. Kelley follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Owens [presiding]. Thank you. I would like to recognize Ms. Sharfuddin. Thank you. STATEMENT OF REVANA SHARFUDDIN, RESEARCH FELLOW, MERCATUS CENTER AT GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY, ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA Ms. Sharfuddin. Good morning, Subcommittee Ranking Member, members of the subcommittee. It is an honor to testify before you. My name is Revana Sharfuddin. I am a labor economist and research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. My research focus on artificial intelligence and labor markets. Today, my testimony focuses on the Federal Government's capacity to measure AI's effect on American workers. The three key themes are first, AI transforms work different differently than previous technologies and it is harder to track with current data infrastructure. Second, our Federal statistical agencies lack the tools to measure this transformation. Third, Congress should direct BLS and census to close these data gaps. Previous automation replaced entire job categories. ATMs reduced bank tellers, robots replaced assembly workers. These changes were visible in employment statistics. AI operates differently. It automates specific tasks while leaving others untouched. For example, as an empirical economist, I used to spend significant time writing computer codes for economic modeling. AI now handles much of that, freeing me to focus on research design, collaboration and communication. The occupation economist still exists, but the work has changed. This is precisely what we need to measure. For instance, while AI may outperform radiologists at reading mammograms, it cannot handle the other 26 tasks required for patient care. In fact, a study by Stanford economists found that across 950 occupations, although AI could perform certain tasks near in nearly all jobs, there was no occupation that AI could fully handle alone. Our labor statistics count jobs, not what people do within them. The current population survey includes no question about AI--AI use or task changes. The GAO flagged the data gap in 2019, recommending that the DOL develop better methods to track automation's workforce effects. BLS agreed and has taken incremental steps, but the pace of AI adoption has accelerated dramatically. There are three achievable steps that are targeted and low cost. Adding an AI supplement to the current population survey would capture how workers use AI and whether it has changed their tasks. Linking farm level adoption data to worker outcomes through existing census programs would let us track real effects. Coordinated annual reports across the Federal agencies would give this Committee the comprehensive evidence base it needs. The decisions this Committee makes about workforce policy will shape whether AI delivers broadly shared prosperity. Good policy requires good data, and we currently do not have it. Thank you. I welcome your questions. [The prepared statement of Ms. Sharfuddin follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Owens. Thank you. I would now like to recognize Ms. Goldman. STATEMENT OF TANYA GOLDMAN, FELLOW, WORKSHOP, WASHINGTON, D.C. Ms. Goldman. Good morning. I want to thank Chairman Allen, Ranking Member DeSaulnier and members of the Health, Employment and Labor and Pensions Subcommittee for the opportunity to testify on the impacts of artificial intelligence for workers and implications for their rights and safety. I have over a decade of experience in senior positions within the Federal Government's worker protection agencies, including at the U.S. Department of Labor and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. During my time in the Biden administration, I advised on the creation of the blueprint for an AI bill of rights, as well as rules and guidance to support employers and workers with the use of AI in the workplace. I am currently a fellow with Workshop, an organization that leverages policy expertise and partnerships to advance policies that protect and expand workers' rights. The speed of AI development and adoption necessitates policy responses that ensure workers have a voice and seat at the table and the power to shape the design and implementation of AI. Congress can ensure safe and responsible use of AI in the workplace, including by shoring up existing workplace protections and enforcement, enacting new guardrails and preserving states' abilities to protect their own residents. Substantial data and research show that concerns about AI are not hypothetical. Workers are already experiencing harms. Employers are using AI tools to collect data, determine wages and hire workers. This includes the use of algorithms to set compensation for millions of workers, which can suppress their wages. This includes, as the Roosevelt Institute's Report on Nurses noted, that on the same day, at the same hour in the same hospital, two different gig nurses can be paid different amounts by the same app. These tools often replicate and exacerbate systemic biases. These systems lack transparency, so workers often do not understand how decisions affecting their livelihoods are being made. This can leave them without meaningful recourse to challenge the decision or to correct inaccurate data that is being used. Employers also collect and rely on data to inform automated management systems. This technology allows employers to surveil workers in more exacting ways than a human boss ever could. 90 percent of U.S. employers in recent surveys reported using algorithmic management for their workers. These systems can control scheduling and task assignments, performance monitoring and evaluation, and disciplinary actions. Time on task measures can pressure workers to work constantly and make it difficult to take necessary breaks, which can penalize pregnant or disabled workers if they take a break just to use the restroom or to take some medicine. Workers also feel pressured to increase their pace to unsafe speeds, which can lead to injury. During the Biden administration, DOL cited Amazon for injuries employees experienced from unsafe processing speeds. Constant invasive surveillance can also discourage workers from engaging in legally protected activities. These harms are the product of choices, not an inevitability. Congress has a role to play here in addressing these harms and shaping our future. Many of our existing workplace laws already provide workers with baseline protections but they must be enforced and strengthened. America's workers also need broader Federal guardrails on the use of AI. Majorities of both parties favor more regulation to limit AI's potential negative impact on society. Guardrails should include transparency, which has come up several times already; disclosure, so workers know when AI systems are being used to make decisions about their employment and they can correct any inaccuracies. Humans should be involved in significant employment decisions. Developers and employers must test systems for bias. Workers and their unions should have a role in these processes. Many states have already enacted laws addressing AI related workplace harms. These represent important progress in establishing baseline protections for workers. Federal legislation should be a floor, not a ceiling. We must meet the dynamism required of our modern workplace, while also establishing robust protections for workers across the country. Congress has a role to play in protecting workers' opportunities, safety and economic security. It can make sure worker protection agencies are enforcing existing laws, strengthen those laws and enact new ones. I welcome the opportunity to work with this Committee on policies that will safeguard workers' rights and ensure the fair and equitable use of AI in the workplace. [The prepared statement of Ms. Goldman follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Mr. Owens. Thank you. I would like to last recognize Mr. Walton. STATEMENT OF DAVID WALTON, PARTNER, FISHER PHILLIPS, PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA Mr. Walton. Thank you. Good morning, Chairman Allen, Ranking Member DeSaulnier and distinguished members of the Subcommittee. Thank you so much for this opportunity to be here. I am honored to be here, especially joined by my wife and my daughter, who gets to see her old man at work. I am Dave Walton. I am a partner at Fisher Phillips and founder and co-chair of the firm's Artificial Intelligence Practice Group. I have been practicing labor and employment law now for over 30 years and have been advising employers nationwide on AI governance since early 2023. My testimony addresses three key questions. How are employers using AI in managing risks? Will AI destroy jobs or create them? What is AI's impact on workers' Section 7 rights under the NLRA. First, as everybody knows here, adoption in AI has exploded. Companies are deploying AI across every function, screening resumes in minutes, detecting safety violations in real time, flagging compliance risks, recommending training and upskilling for employees, identifying promotions and transfer opportunities that employees should pursue, and even anticipating employee burnout. This list grows daily in trying to keep on top of all the developments in AI as a fulltime job. On top of this, AI has incredible potential to improve workplaces, of eliminating mundane tasks, making work more enjoyable, making factories safer. With great power comes great risk. That is why many employers are building governance systems, and governance means being intentional about risk management. It is about building a process, following the process and documenting your attempts to follow that process. These frameworks include cross functional teams that involve many stakeholders and companies, including IT, Legal, H.R. and Compliance; bias audit testing for discrimination; human in the loop requirements for major decision like hiring and promotions; training employees on how AI works on where it fails; and very importantly how to report any problems that they see with AI. These governance frameworks work. Self-regulation through robust internal controls outperforms blanket restrictions, especially in an emerging technology like AI. Second, the jobs question. Will AI destroy employment? The history of economics suggests no. AI will likely increase total jobs, not decrease them. Through Jevons Paradox, when technology makes a resource more efficient, it lowers costs, expands demand so much that consumption increases. Every automation wave that we have had, especially since 1750, has followed this pattern. ATMs have reduced tellers per branch, yet total teller employment rose as banks opened more branches. Spreadsheets eliminated bookkeeping departments, yet office employment exploded. AI will likely follow suit. Some argue we need regulation to slow AI adoption, but AI is inevitable. Trying to stop AI is like standing in front of a tidal wave with a wiffleball bat. It is just not going to work. The marketplace will force companies to embrace it. Companies that resist will not survive. Countries of slow adoption will fall behind. Third, employee surveillance concerns. Section 7 of the NLRA already protects organizing rights, and AI monitoring must respect them. The critical distinction, surveillance targeting union supporters, violates the law. It already violates the law. Monitoring for legitimate purposes, safety, antidiscrimination, and productivity is lawful. When done with transparency, manager training on protected activity, technical safeguards, and worker involvement, worker buy in is critical. In sum, AI has become essential for American competitiveness. The employers I work with prove daily that robust self-governance protects workers while capturing AI's benefits. We can harness this technology responsibly through smart governance, not blanket prohibitions. I welcome your questions. Thank you. [The prepared statement of Mr. Walton follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Allen. Again, I thank the witnesses and appreciate your testimony. Let us see. Here we are. Under Committee Rule 9, we will now question witnesses under the 5-minute rule. I will first recognize myself for 5 minutes. You know, in preparing for this hearing, we were discussing how our country evolved and how the workplace evolved. Obviously went from horse and buggy to automobile. That was a huge transition, and of course prior to really World War II, most folks like me grew up on the farm and were employed on the farm, over 90 percent of the people in the country. Then we had the Industrial Revolution, and then of course the Tech Revolution, and of course, now we have AI. It has been amazing what the economy, how resilient the economy has been and how the workforce has adapted to every one of those stages in our country. Ms. Sharfuddin, you point out in your written testimony that Federal labor market statistics were largely designed to count jobs rather than to measure how work is done. Can you explain how this creates a blind spot for policymakers as we consider AI in the workplace? Ms. Sharfuddin. I appreciate that question. Currently we ask workers what kind of jobs they are in, their wages and so on. We know from literature, especially from theory, that AI is affecting jobs at a task level, and we do not have questions related to task level. For example, if there is for example an image designer or a marketing person at a farm, if you ask that person what jobs do you do and that person can answer that they are doing design job, that is there in BLS. What we need to ask is that do you use AI in your job first, and second question, what parts of your job is being used via AI? Then, perhaps third and fourth question of how much of it is being automated, how much of it is augmenting and how much are you learning, via those tools? Chairman Allen. Good, thank you. Mr. Walton, you say in your written testimony that it is critical for employers who adopt AI tools to be fully transparent with their employees and to get their buy in. Will you explain why it is important from an employer's perspective to get employee buy in? Mr. Walton. Yes, great question. If employees do not buy into what you are doing, they are going to try to avoid it and they are going to try to work around it. We have seen that. Like for example, there are some tools out there that were used by some employers that would measure if your mouse was moving and stuff like that. Well, there are now tools that you can buy that move your mouse automatically for you, you know, if you are monitored like that. Plus, if you do not have employee buy-in, they will not trust you and they will not respect it. It is critical to be transparent with what you are doing for employees. Plus the other thing, it is hard to get good employees these days. Good employers are going to treat their employees well and if not, then the market is going to speak, and they are going to lose employees. It is absolutely critical to get buy-in and to be transparent with your employees. Chairman Allen. What are some of the most successful approaches you have seen employers take to get employee buy-in? Mr. Walton. Well, I think you run pilot programs and you involve employees from the beginning, especially in the unionized work environment. You are upfront with the employees, and you explain to them why are we doing this? Why are we bringing AI in? What are we trying to accomplish? It is also very important to add feedback loops, where the people on the front lines, because it is the employees on the front lines who see all the problems. It is critical to add feedback loops where they can see the problems and report back to management what the problems are with the tool. Chairman Allen. Thank you. Mr. Kelley, I was struck by your written testimony that in your expertise and senior leadership roles at the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the Department of Labor, as well as in your private legal practice, you have never encountered employer attempting to use AI to interfere with union activity or suppress union organizing efforts. Why do you think this? Mr. Kelley [off mic]. What Mr. Walton just said initially, in terms of the fact that I believe most employers want to do the right thing. They realize that it is a symbiotic relationship, that it benefits both sides by doing the right thing. I feel as if, you know, if you look at the laws that, you know, these historical laws that we have, the National Labor Relations Act is from 1935. The Fair Labor Standards Act from 1938. Title VII is from 1964. These laws were passed well before technology in the workplace, especially artificial intelligence, passed well before the Internet as well. These laws have been able to survive, and the current framework is really important. I feel as if, you know, as far as employees specifically, why employers are not looking at that way, is because of that idea of trust, that idea that you want to ensure that there is a good working relationship. During COVID, for example, a lot of employers turned to AI as part of the remote workforce. A lot of times, because they were not able to do traditional in person interviews, they were using AI tools. It was increasingly important as part of that tradeoff, to make sure that they were being productive, which is why a lot of employers turned to AI tools at the time. Chairman Allen. Well thank you. Thank you very much. Now I recognize Ms. McBath from Georgia for the purpose of questioning the witnesses. Ms. McBath. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to our witnesses for being with us today. I have actually read all of your testimoneys. There are fewer issues that stand to be as impactful to our society as AI, and it will be always that way in the near future. The American people are living through another Industrial Revolution, and Congress must do more to help Americans understand how they can make AI work for them but not against them. Atlanta is home to so many amazing artists and stagehands who bring our favorite music, shows, movies and commercials to life. As you can tell, I am from Georgia. Whether they be writers, actors, painters, musicians, key grips or any of the other professions that go into making Atlanta the Hollywood of the South, these jobs are incredibly important and they must be protected for the people who rely on them as their main source of income. Not only do they provide a good living, but these also are not just any jobs. They are dream jobs for people who cannot imagine themselves doing anything else. Jobs in the arts provide fulfillment that others cannot. They are passions that people stick with, despite being tough industries to break into. There is pride in being able to say that they stuck with their dream, that you honed, you know, you honed your passion into a skill that you not only truly love but really has value that other people are willing to pay for. People who built their careers and put out the best products are at risk of having their main source of income actually stolen from them. When an actor or a singer has their God-given voice taken from them and used in content without their consent, that is theft. When an artist spends their life creating a specific style, only for it to be plugged into an algorithm to create more content that they will never be paid for, that is theft. It is no different than stealing any other product that someone made. If anything, it can feel even more violating because what was stolen was your voice, your likeness or your art, something truly that is only unique to you. Unions like IATSE, SAG-AFTRA and the Writer's Guild of America have already gotten major agreements and contracts to protect their workers. For example, IATSE and the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers agreed that generative AI is covered union work, must be performed by a human, and that no crew member can be forced to input a prompt that would replace another crew member. This ensures that workers are given the opportunity to use their tools, not just be replaced by those tools. The right to join a union and collectively bargain is a concrete way for workers to have a real voice in their workplace. At a time when Americans feel like they have less power over their daily lives, unions give people a real say over the decisions that are being made that directly impact them and their communities and their families. Through their unions, workers negotiate better working conditions, higher wages and fair policies on the job, like the use of or the implementation of AI. Mr. Goldman, can you briefly describe why unions are so uniquely positioned to help regulate--excuse me, Ms. Goldman, to help regulate the use of AI and protect workers from being negatively impacted and possibly even losing their jobs? Ms. Goldman. Yes. Thank you so much, Congresswoman. I really appreciate your comments, and I agree that unions play such an important role in ensuring that workers have a collective voice in the workplace and that it serves as a counterweight to, you know, the improper--the imbalance of power in the workplace right now between workers and employers. When workers have a voice and a seat at the table in the design and deployment of AI, as Mr. Walton said, their expertise can inform the technology and also that enables the most effective interventions, which are won and implemented by unions through collective bargaining in how technologies are implemented in their workplace, including AI. You know, in addition to the examples that you raised, News Guild journalists have won protections in the newsroom from the use of AI, and this benefits them and it also benefits their employers. We are not getting--and consumers, so false and bad reporting is not getting out, right. CWA has done a lot of negotiating around the monitoring of call center workers, and this really helps those workers make sure that AI is used for feedback and to support their performance but not used for excessive surveillance and discipline and evaluations. Ms. McBath. Well, thank you. It is clear that unions are already playing an important role in being workers in helping workers to utilize the AI tools instead of being replaced by them, and I yield. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentlelady for yielding. Now I call on our great Chairman Walberg for his line of questioning. Mr. Walberg. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to the panel for being here. I almost and I will hesitate, I will not do it. I wanted to ask if any of you have your prepared statements made by AI. I would love someone to say ``yes'' and it fit exactly what I wanted to say, but thank you for being here. This is a key topic all over the world and if we do not use it well, China will overtake us, and that is something we have to understand. Regardless of workplace individuals, performing rights and all of the rest, we have to be the leader. Mr. Kelley, your written testimony is critical of the way the Biden era National Labor Relations Board approached AI. Will you explain the Biden general counsel's approach and why you believe it was to be misguided? Mr. Kelley. Yes absolutely, and it is an excellent question. Obviously there has been a lot of concerns about the use of AI in the workplace, which generated the general counsel at the time, Jennifer Abruzzo, to issue a memo on Halloween of 2022. This memo introduced an amorphous framework, that created a presumption that employers using AI overall would be in violation of the NLRA. It was flawed from the get-go. The entire scheme was based on a law review article or a law journal article from 2018, three sentences that included a footnote that said `This proposal is laid out here only briefly to be elaborated on in future work,'' which was never released, and these three sentences in this 2018 law journal article established this framework. I think that is also an important thing to kind of stress here, is that a lot of the concerns that we hear about with artificial intelligence originate in academic literature. When we hear about all these problems about artificial intelligence, we are not seeing the cases. You know, as somebody who does a lot of litigation, the reality is, is that when there is a big legal problem, you see cases generating on it. You are not seeing the cases come up. All these problems that you hear about with artificial intelligence really are speculative in many ways and they can only be found in academic literature. Going back to the NLRB memo, it lacked clear definitions in standards, and it also failed to acknowledge how AI is actually being used in the workplace, the fact that employers are using it to prevent harassment, that they are using it to improve safety. It disregarded those and put them to the side. Consider that the memo was not subject to notice and comment. There was no stakeholder feedback, there was no voice of employers, there was no vendor feedback, and those are the ones who were actually developing and using the technology. Mr. Walberg. Just a Halloween scare? Mr. Kelley. Yes, exactly. Mr. Walberg. Boo. Yes, yes. Thank you. Ms. Sharfuddin, your written testimony says that much of the existing research suggests that AI is, more likely to reshape tasks within occupations, than to eliminate entire jobs. I certainly hope that that is true. Could you explain what in the research leads you to that conclusion? Ms. Sharfuddin. Thanks, Chairman Walberg. That is a very important question. Right now, we do not see in our in 2025 labor data, we see that we are not seeing as many jobs created. We are also not seeing that many jobs, you know, people that many people getting fired. The unemployment rate is slowly getting up there, but also we have to make sure that the jobs losses we are seeing, are they an AI exposed area? Are they an AI exposed occupation? Currently, we do not have nationally representative data by Federal agencies, where we could study it very rigorously. All we have are some private data, for example, from Anthropic Economic Index. That is privately done data from Anthropic, who is one of the largest AI tech company. We have some issues with the type of people use that tool. There is selection bias in that tool, because only certain types of software engineers and so on, they use the tool. This is not nationally representative. From those privately available information, we can see that the changes are happening at task level. Certain, for example, economist researchers, they are using it for editing and writing certain things, but collaboration, idea generation still staying within human worker. We see it from private data, but we do need more comprehensive Federal data from the whole country. Mr. Walberg. Thank you, thank you. Mr. Walton, I am sure your daughter's glad that your only dad joke that you used this morning was very fitting. I will use it again. Tidal wave whiffleball bat. Perfect. Talk to me about the imposed tax on employers that some are suggesting, and why you think the robot tax is a bad way to protect American workers and what Congress should do instead. In 4 seconds. Mr. Walton. Yes, in 4 seconds. I think it is a bad idea because AI is going to create more jobs than it displaces. I was reading something recently from McKinsey, that the Internet created 2.6 jobs for every job that it displaced. If you stop innovation in the American workplace, it is going to hurt the American worker and it is going to hurt the American economy vis-avis of countries like China. Mr. Walberg. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Allen. I thank our Chairman. Now I will call on Mr. Mannion from New York for your line of questioning. Mr. Mannion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today. It is important that we are talking about responsible use of AI in the workplace, because it is something that affects so many types of jobs and industries out there, and people understandably have different feelings toward it, depending on their own experience. As the use of AI tools continues to expand, we must make sure that they are being deployed in ways that actually benefit American workers and benefit the American economy. We know the risks of AI as well as its utility. I certainly share the concerns raised by my colleagues, especially over worker privacy and job displacement. AI should never give employers a license to automate important decisions without human input and oversight, nor should it be used for excessive control or surveillance over employees. We need common sense policies that deter it from being used in these ways, and workers should always have a voice when it comes to AI implementation. We also can do more to promote the most beneficial applications of AI. Last month, I introduced the Immersive Technology for the American Workforce Act. This bipartisan bill would expand the use of immersive learning tools such as virtual reality and augmented reality to strengthen our Nation's workforce development programs. These immersive technologies often integrate AI, and when combined they hold enormous potential to improve job training and productivity across a wide range of industries. Ms. Goldman, my questions are for you. Obviously, with the adoption of any new technology, there are uncertainties about how the technology will be integrated into the workplace over the long term. Nonetheless, many employers are already experimenting with AI. Can you share what are the most pronounced sectors that are attempting to experiment with AI at this time? Ms. Goldman. Yes, Congressman. You know, we can see that it is very widespread. You know, I mentioned in my testimony that 90 percent of surveyed U.S. employers are using algorithmic management tools in the workplace. A survey done by my colleague, former colleague, Alex Hertel-Fernandez of U.S. workers found that two-thirds of them reported that algorithmic management tools were being used in their workplace, and this was true across earnings in different jobs. In the recruitment and hiring space, we see kind of variable data. A third to the vast majority of employers are using AI tools in hiring and recruitment. This is a range of industries. I mean it is really pronounced in warehousing. We are all very familiar with what warehousing workers are experiencing, rideshare drivers, delivery drivers. We see this in lots of sectors. It is retail, it is healthcare, it is government, it is manufacturing, it is hospitality, it is call centers. This is why it is really important that we have guardrails around this technology to protect these workers. Mr. Mannion. Is there a certain sector where experimenting in AI has actually shown that it has been very effective and also assured that jobs are protected? Ms. Goldman. I mean I think this goes back to why we need workers to have a voice and seat at the table and be involved in the design and deployment of AI. Even in call centers, where we know there is extensive use of AI tools, having that worker feedback is critical. You know, there are workers who have reported to us that they are prompted by the AI to give inaccurate answers to their customers. That does not help the customer or the employer or the worker, and they have to do it or they will suffer through their performance evaluations. By being able to provide that feedback, they can work with the employer to make sure the AI is being used in a way that is productive for all involved, and not harming the worker in causing excessive surveillance and monitoring. Mr. Mannion. Can you speak to AI and its role in the job application process, and where there may be some shortcomings? Ms. Goldman. Yes. Automated hiring systems are essentially acting as digital gatekeepers to workers' economic security, and this can result in discrimination. It can replicate and deepen existing inequities in our society. These algorithms can be trained on inaccurate or biased data. It could be unrepresentative. They could work from proxies that do not actually tell you how much a worker is able to perform the functions of the job, and they can pull from thousands of data points from social media, from the Internet, from third party data brokers. It is not just, you know, the interview and application process that the worker is being evaluated on. Mr. Mannion. Great. Thank you so much for your testimony. Go ahead. Ms. Goldman. I have 12 seconds, but just to respond to something that Mr. Kelley said, you know I just want to note that it is not a hypothetical concern that surveillance is affecting organizing in the workplace. You know, data collected by employers can definitely have a chilling effect and impede worker organizing. Mr. Mannion. This former union president thanks you. I yield back. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentleman for yielding, and now I will call on Mr. Owens from Utah for your line of questioning. Mr. Owens. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, thank you for this conversation. It is very, very important. It is a game changer, obviously. I want to say that AI is an incredible tool. It has potential to strengthen our workers and national productivity if used correctly. I look forward to the hearing of witnesses that are talked about the promise of AI and where we can take it from here. I want to Mr. Kelley, I want to kind of followup on a question that the Chair had asked earlier. When it is talking about the report that came out in 2018 that has kind of tainted the way people use or are looking at AI today, what can we do to make sure we are mitigating that fear factor? It is prevalent. We have to make sure that we are embracing AI and only to do that is again through education and using the right way. I do not know if you want to add to that conversation you had earlier. Mr. Kelley. Yes. I think that it is really important that when you look at a lot of the examples out there of these worst-case scenarios with artificial intelligence, a lot of them are very outdated. They are from 2018. They are from 2019. Think about how much technology changes and how much it improves. Think about like the latest update to your cell phone. You get your new cell phone. It has got a much better battery life. It has got incredible new features. You are like, wow, this is incredible. We are not recognizing that with artificial intelligence. The problem is, is we hear a lot from the employee side or the, you know, union side about well, we need new guardrails. We need a seat at the table. What does that mean as far as what laws do we need in place? If you are using artificial intelligence to screen applicants on the basis of race or sex or disability, those violate existing laws. We need to put the focus on the existing laws, and I do think that even for these hypothetical type scenarios is that it is really important that so I came from the EOC. I was a senior official at the EOC before joining Littler, and we launched the AI initiative in 2021 to look at how AI may result in discrimination in the workplace. That initiative has been completely suspended. It has been because there has not been these cases. There has not been this employer activity that was reported on. I mean when you hear about these concerns and again, they are completely found in academic literature, they are found in these hypotheticals. That is why I do academic articles, because I try to understand what the other side is saying on this. The cases are not there, and I think that is really important because the problem is by making these speculative concerns and these hypotheticals, you are going to hamper innovation. You are going to have employers who are going to say ``Well, let's not go full throttle with artificial intelligence. Let's hold back.'' That allows our adversaries overseas to get ahead of us. I think that is a really important thing to keep in mind. We cannot allow us ourselves to get outpaced in a lot of ways. When I hear about all these concerns with AI, the existing framework addresses those. That is really important, because we cannot have laws that are passed that have no purpose. You know, as I mentioned before in my opening, Colorado AI Act went into effect, and on the very same day, the Colorado Governor said ``This is a flawed law. We need to revise it,'' on the same day it was signed. A couple days later, the Colorado Governor and the State Senate Majority Leader and the Attorney General sent a letter to the business community, pledging to revise the law. Why are we doing that, and it does not make sense. Mr. Owens. Thank you. I want to make sure I have a couple of questions here. Ms. Sharfuddin, you point out in your written testimony that small business are adopting AI a little bit slower. Why do you think that is happening? Ms. Sharfuddin. Thank you for your question. Small businesses generally face higher fixed costs when they are adopting any new tool or adopting new technology, or expand their business. That is one of the reasons, that they lack the capacity. We are seeing that as AI is diffusing through the economy, we see that they are adopting it more. I think I would run out of time, but I would like to refer to a policy brief I wrote a few months ago, about how we can empower small businesses to first adopt AI but also train their workers. We can do that via tax expensing provisions that would empower 30 million, which is 80 percent of our economy, to adopt small business with their workers. Mr. Owens. Thank you. Thank you. I would like to know more about that, because small business obviously drives our economy in so many different ways, and we need to make sure that innovation is there for sure. Real quickly, Mr. Walton. We are familiar with AI discussions around AI, in terms of being a job creator or destroyer. In your testimony, you provide insight on how it can retain employees and thereby reduce turnover. Can you kind of share a few thoughts on that, on how that---- Mr. Walton. Yes, sure. My testimony talks about, for example, an approach by the University of Nebraska that was used to spot burnout by nurses. That is one of the things that they did is, is they stopped or they put a deep reduction in their nursing turnover. That is just one example of how AI can be used to improve the workplace, to keep employees happy. AI is also being used to help identify for employees where the best transfer opportunities are in their companies, because it is better to have to have companies doing different jobs, especially in large companies. AI is also being used to help identify bad managers, you know, and so these are just the tip of the iceberg. There are a thousand of examples like this. I mean AI is much more of a net positive in the workplace than there is a net negative. Mr. Owens. Thank you. Thanks so much. We need to bring innovation and heart to this conversation, and no place better than doing it here. Thank you so much for your comments. We sure appreciate it. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentleman for yielding. Now I will call on Mr. Scott, the ranking member of the full committee, for his line of questioning. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Several of the witnesses have indicated that we might create more jobs than we lose with AI, but that still acknowledges we will lose jobs. What kind of job training should we be developing to account for the displacement, Ms. Goldman? Ms. Goldman. Sure. I mean I think, Congressman Scott, there are a lot of really important questions about, you know, workers' future with the implementation of AI in the workplace. I think it is really important that we do the things that we know we need to do right now. We need to improve job quality, so workers have access to fair pay and benefits. We need to make sure workers have access to unions, which involves updating our labor laws that are on the books. Then we need to, you know, make sure that workers, as we have been talking about, have a voice in the workplace. This includes shoring up our existing social safety nets, including our job training system, so that if workers do lose their job, they have a bridge to another high-quality position. Mr. Scott. Anyone else want to talk about what kinds of job training initiatives? Ms. Sharfuddin. Actually, that helps me tie to my previous comment. I think AI is moving so fast and it is really hard to think about Federal or a centralized way to see where the training is necessary, because the American economy is huge and it is dynamic in its drivers. You have to think through policy. How can we empower businesses that they can train their workers and they can respond to the local labor demands? The labor demands, for example, in Colorado, is going to look different from Washington, DC. In my tax policy proposal, I suggest that small businesses, businesses of all sizes, are allowed to expense the cost that they put in for training their workers, and it will equalize the level playing field we have with technology. Right now, businesses are allowed to expense, their costs for when they buy a building or through bonus depreciation, or when they buy a technology or research and development investment, they are able to expense it completely, but they cannot do the same when they train their workers. I would recommend that we kind of equalize the human capital investment with capital investment in terms of tax expensing. Thank you. Mr. Scott. You mean in addition? It is already deductible. You mean an additional expense? Like---- Ms. Sharfuddin. Congressman, there are mazes of regulation for businesses to go through, and I have a policy brief. Again, I am happy to send it to your office. Mr. Scott. Okay. Ms. Sharfuddin. Thank you. Mr. Scott. Anyone else have any ideas on job training, what we ought to be doing? Mr. Walton. I will just say in a general Congressman, that AI has tremendous potential for education, and that includes upskilling and reskilling employees. I think it is very important for us to be thinking of ways that we can use AI to help up upskill and retrain employees. Mr. Kelley. I think we should look at innovative programs, sir. One that sticks out in my mind, especially as an Army veteran, as a combat veteran, is the skill bridge internship program. That is where at the last 6 months of your time in the military, you are able to do an unpaid internship with a private company. It gives you the ability, the whole idea of building a bridge from the military to the civilian sector. I think that looking at different ways, creative ways of having training, because with artificial intelligence, you know, these tools are incredibly--developing at an incredibly rapid rate. I think that just focusing on education overall and looking at new innovative ways to approach it will be very important moving forward. Mr. Scott. Mr. Kelley, you acknowledge that discrimination could happen with AI. If the AI is used to screen applicants, you could have a discriminatory--you could have discrimination and that is illegal under present law. How would anybody find out, particularly in light of the fact that the EEOC is diminishing, is taking away your ability to see a disparate impact? Mr. Kelley. Well, I think that it is really important to say that as far as establishing that baseline, that in a lot of ways the use of artificial intelligence to screen out resumes or find the best applicant, it takes away that human element, which oftentimes is the most discriminatory part. It increases the ability to make objective decisions. You could take away the consideration of names, that are oftentimes associated with, let us say---- Mr. Scott. Well, you can. I mean if you have got discrimination going on, how do you deal with it? Mr. Kelley. The existing law. I do not think that there is any problem with the existing law. I do think that---- Mr. Scott. If you do not have disparate impact, how are you going to prove your case? Mr. Kelley. Well, there is also the ability for commissioners to bring commissioner charges from the EOC. That has been something that has been---- Mr. Scott. Well, the EEOC said they are not doing disparate impact. How would they even know what to target? Mr. Kelley. It does not have to be just disparate impact. I mean it could also be disparate treatment. They do not have to just focus on the disparate impact, because one of the interesting questions with AI is at what point does disparate impact become disparate treatment? There is kind of overlap, you know, with that area. Mr. Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentleman for yielding, and now I will call on Dr. Onder from Missouri for your line of questioning. Mr. Onder. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to all the witnesses for appearing at this Subcommittee today. I am very interested to learn more about what AI might have to offer to our economy. I believe AI does have enormous potential. I mentioned at a previous hearing on AI I am a physician, and I know some of my colleagues now use AI scribes to decrease administrative burden and clinical documentation. I remember back in the day when before EHR, when I would bring home paper charts and spend hours dictating patient notes. Now AI can listen in and sometimes complete hours of paperwork in merely minutes. I have an Amazon distribution center in my district, and I watched as AI was used for sorting, packing, routing packages. Extremely impressive. These are examples of just tremendous efficiencies of AI in the workplace. Despite the potential benefits, a recent survey showed only 6 percent of workers believe that AI will lead to more job opportunities for them in the long run. A recent survey found that most workers are worried about AI in the workplace. Mr. Walton, in your testimony today, you explained Jevons Paradox, which says that as technology increases the efficiency of how a resource is used, the total consumption of that resource will increase rather than decrease. If this holds true for AI adoption, the technology could actually create more jobs in the long run rather than take jobs away. Can you share examples of how AI efficiency might produce higher economic activity, and if possible, more jobs? Mr. Walton. Sure. I mean we are seeing that already in the coding world, and we are seeing coders being able to do ten times more of the work that they have been able to do in the past. They have been able to do a lot more output. If you go back to the Internet, for example, there was a lot of fears when the Internet was adopted that it was going to cost a lot of jobs. Just think of all the new jobs that the Internet created from cloud computing, from website design, from ecommerce. I mean I got my daughter here today, social media influencers. I mean there is whole new economies and whole new industries that were developed by the Internet. You know, plus I think Congressman, AI is going to develop almost more like cottage industries, because it is going to give power back to the people more. I mean I have my phone is like having a Palantir in my pocket now, you know, with these types of AI tools. I can sit at my kitchen table and run a ten- person law firm, just me. That is going to give power back more to the people, to create value for themselves. I think we are going to see a lot of that in the future. Mr. Onder. Well, you know in this discussion, I am reminded of a famous story where the economist, Milton Friedman, was touring a quarry in China, and he noted that they were using picks and shovels. He asked the foreman well, why do you not use--you know, the United States, this would be run with, you know, tractors and excavators and backhoes. They said ``Well, with picks and shovels, we employ more people.'' Milton Friedman looked at him and said ``Then why don't you give them spoons?'' Mr. Kelley, in your testimony, you mentioned the Colorado AI Act, which apparently was so poorly crafted that Colorado's Democrat Governor had to tell his legislature to rewrite it. Could you walk us through some of the poorly drafted provisions, and lessons that Congress might learn from that experience? Mr. Kelley. Yes. I think that it is a prime example of just the rush. I think that they were trying to outpace the EU AI Act, the European Union's AI Act, and as part of that rush, they tried to really kind of force it through because they wanted to be seen as a leader on--among the states. On the very day it was signed, the flaws were acknowledged and they pledged to the business community, along with the State Attorney General and the State Senate Majority Leader, pledging that they would revise the law. The problem is, is that it was supposed to go into effect earlier this year and it has been delayed till June. A lot of the fundamental problems are the same. There is a lot of ambiguity with what the obligations are on developers and deployers. There is a lot of--kind of as far as questions over how should this be interpreted? I think that overall, it is just very flawed and it will likely--it is quite possible that it is going to be delayed again. I think that the New York City law is just as bad in a lot of ways. You know, that law was rushed through. It received a lot of criticism from a wide variety of groups. As of July 2023 when it went into effect, it has not received one single complaint that we are aware of. Mr. Onder. Thank you. I yield back. Chairman Allen. I thank you gentlemen for yielding, and now we will call on Ms. Bonamici from Oregon. Ms. Bonamici. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses. Thank you for allowing me to join this Subcommittee. I serve on the Education, Early Childhood, but also Higher Ed, but also on the Subcommittee on Science, Space and Technology, and spent a long time on the bipartisan AI Task Force. I am really interested in the conversation today. Obviously, AI is reshaping the workforce faster than many employers and employees can respond. It is my understanding that about one in five workers is expecting to see a major job disruption, and almost all workers are expected to see some of their tasks affected. What is concerning to me is that if this happens without proper education, security, privacy and guardrails, it is really concerning. I am actually working on a comprehensive human-centered framework for AI that will strengthen teaching and learning, prepare workers, and address the security and privacy concerns, because responsible AI policy should prepare people for changing economy, not just blindly deploy new technologies. I will add anecdotally that I was recently talking to someone who was grading college papers who said there is an extraordinary amount of time trying to figure out if it was written with AI, in violation of that institution's rules. Students are really concerned, because their professor decided to just give them a blue book test and they do not know how to write. When we look at the 21st century job skills that have been identified as critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, communications, we have to get this right. Ms. Goldman, what specific actions can the Federal Government take to identify occupations most affected by AI deployment, following up on Representative Mannion's questions? What resources or policies would be best to mitigate AI-related workforce disruptions? Ms. Goldman. Yes. Thank you, Congresswoman, and thank you for your leadership on these issues. You know, I think first we need to shore up our existing legal frameworks and make sure that we are enforcing the laws we do have on the books, as Congressman Scott was getting at. You know, these are really black box systems that workers lack transparency. They do not know what tools are being used, and therefore they cannot challenge them. We need the EEOC conducting systemic and disparate impact investigations, and we need to shore up our labor laws, which have not been, you know, amended---- Ms. Bonamici. Enforce them. Yes. Yes. Ms. Goldman [continuing]. In over like half a century, right? We need new comprehensive laws. I am delighted about the work that you are doing, and these really need to ensure that automated employment and management systems are fair and are being regulated. These new laws can have things like transparency and disclosure, which almost everybody here agrees is extremely important for workers. Ms. Bonamici. Right. Ms. Goldman. They can have a right to human review, to make sure that, you know, we do not have robot bosses firing our workers. Ms. Bonamici. Right? Thank you for mentioning my No Robot Bosses Act, which is bipartisan, H.R. 6371. If anyone wants to sign on, we invite you. I am leading this with Representative Moylan and Deluzio, and we are also looking at reintroducing the Stop Spying Bosses Act, which is to protect workers from invasive surveillance. Ms. Goldman. Yes, and that is so important. Then just last thing I will say is we need impact assessments. I think Mr. Walton has talked about that as well, and make sure that, you know, these tools are being tested for validity, reliability and nondiscrimination and that workers and unions should be involved in that process because they know how they are being implemented in the workplace. Ms. Bonamici. Absolutely, absolutely. You know, I heard the example, of Colorado or the Governor of Colorado, a former member of this Committee. I also have to say that until there is Federal regulation, I mean we spent a lot of time on the AI Task Force, bipartisan AI Task Force, but we did not pass anything. We made recommendations. We issued a great report, but we did not enact anything to protect against bias, to protect, you know, privacy and security rights. Until we do that, we need to respect the states that are acting to protect their states. Ms. Goldman, what can Congress do to support employers who want to responsibly adopt AI in the workplace? Ms. Goldman. Yes, and if I can just note Congresswoman, like how important it is that we do allow states to protect their own residents, including consumers---- Ms. Bonamici. Right. Ms. Goldman [continuing]. Workers and children, and make sure that, you know, they are able to respond to this rapidly evolving technology. You know, if Congress does pass a Federal framework, which I hope it will do so, it can provide a baseline of those protections. Those protections need to be a floor and not a ceiling. Ms. Bonamici. Right. With regard to the existing laws yes, they need to be enforced. We had a lot of conversations about how do you enforce and where do you enforce. If it is a labor issue, does it go to labor? If it is an education issue, does it go to what is left of the Department of Education, assuming that there is a Department of Education? If it is a health issue, does it go to HHS? Is there some separate enforcement agency? It is not as simple as enforce the existing laws, because it is complicated. I just want to thank you so much for your testimony, all of you, and look forward to the ongoing conversation. I yield back. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentlelady for yielding. Mr. DeSaulnier, you want to go? Mr. DeSaulnier. Sure. Chairman Allen. Okay. Ms. Lee from Pennsylvania is recognized for 5 minutes. Ms. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My Democratic colleagues have shared some of the ways adopting AI in the workplace can come at a cost to our civil rights and that of privacy. One would hope that officials at the highest levels of government are weighing these costs when adopting AI in their workplaces. We have a White House posting AI edited photos of civil rights attorneys and a president who is posting racist deep fake videos of Democratic leaders, and AI generated videos of him himself dumping feces on Americans protesting his authoritarian policies. Before Elon Musk went back to X to profit from pornographic deep fakes, he led a government agency that relied heavily on AI, as an agency we now know stole Social Security data to try and overturn election results. Let us not forget the environmental toll of AI data centers. This administration is driving up electricity costs and straining our water supply to steal our data, spread disinformation and silence dissent. Republicans are talking about responsible AI use while refusing to hold their own leadership accountable, just like they continuously refuse to hold corporations accountable. We must ensure that AI is not weaponized to undermine workers' rights, especially their right to organize. Mr. Kelley, just a yes or a no. Does your law firm, Littler Mendelson, use or encourage its clients to use AI or other algorithmic tools for union avoidance strategies? Mr. Kelley. That issue has not come up. Ms. Lee. Yes or no. Would Littler Mendelson and its clients inform workers if AI were being used to persuade them against unionizing? Mr. Kelley. We advise employers on the use of artificial intelligence. We advise on specific---- Ms. Lee. That is a yes, yes or no? It is yes, you would advise them? Mr. Kelley. There is no yes or no answer to that. Ms. Lee. No, I think there is, but I will move on. You claim that corporations' use of AI to suppress union activity is largely theoretical. You said you have never seen employees or sorry employers use AI in a nefarious way. It is hard for me to believe that one of the most notorious anti-union law firms in the country is unaware of nefarious practices. Like when Whole Foods, which is owned by a client of Littler Mendelson, Amazon, used AI to track which of its Whole Foods stores were at risk for union activities or when the National Eating Disorders Association fired all of its helpline workers and replaced them with an AI chatbot 2 weeks after workers voted to form a union, a chatbot they later had to suspend for giving harmful advice. We know corporations are not legally allowed to union bust or steal wages or discriminate or create dangerous working conditions just because AI helps them do it more easily or gives them more deniability. Worker protection laws are only effective if somebody is enforcing them. Ms. Goldman, are worker protection agencies like the Department of Labor and EEOC fully equipped to enforce worker protection laws in the age of AI and under this administration? Ms. Goldman. No, Congresswoman. I think, as you know, they are chronically underfunded and understaffed. My colleagues at the National Partnership for Women and Families put out a report recently that the EEOC has 1,000 fewer investigators than it had in 1980. As you know, they have 60 million more workers that they are trying to protect. They receive thousands more charges and they have more laws that they are enforcing right now. The same holds true at the Wage and Hour Division. I think as of May 2025, they had about 600 investigators to protect the rights of 165 million workers in the workplace. In addition, you know, they need to be able to hire technologists and really understand the data so they can get into the black box and do the kind of systemic work that needs to happen. Ms. Lee. Thank you. We cannot replace Federal worker protection agencies with corporations and tech monopolies, weak or nonexistent accountability policies. The last administration change showed us just how flimsy tech companies' standards are. The minute big tech platforms could step back from any accountability, most did, because profits will always come before workers' rights and as long as Congress allows them to do so. This is exactly why we need legislation like the AI Civil Rights Act or my Eliminating Bias Act, so that there are real guardrails and investments in place that demand transparency, accountability and strong civil rights protections. Republicans are far too eager to dive head first into an authoritarian regime fueled by tech leaders. Workers, not corporations or union busting law firms are going to suffer if we do not implement real guardrails. I thank you all for your time, and I yield back. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentlelady for yielding. Now I call on the Ranking Member, Mr. DeSaulnier, for his questions. Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I want to go back to your opening comments and ours, that I am hopeful that we can work together on this. I feel like we are starting to fall back in a pattern, where we are jumping to conclusions based on our historical perspectives. Ms. Goldman, I want to ask you about ghost jobs. I have asked this a lot and spent a lot of time on it. Mr. Kelley talked about--sorry Mr. Kelley, I am going to put words in your mouth, but this is the purview of us up here--is the wonder of algorithms. Mr. Walton, you alluded to this too, and I am struck by the research on ghost jobs in particular and cognitive development on social media. There is pretty common knowledge at this point. Ghost jobs, research now tells us almost 50 percent of the jobs posting are not real. It is data collectors trying to get more information. On the other side, are young people in America being creative? Up to 60 percent of the applications are not real applications. This goes into privacy and algorithms. How do we get control of this and be transparent, so we make sure that people are not unwittingly giving up more data and more data so the algorithms can be more predictive and more targeted. In addition to that, all the cognitive development where CDC discovered that a third of adolescent girls in this country are being targeted specifically by YouTube's algorithms, who are predisposed to depression, to deliver them to YouTubes on how to commit suicide. All of this was part of the algorithms, according to research at CDC, to actually get young women in particular as they developed cognitively to be predisposed even further to depression. Those two things, how algorithms and AI are affecting the workforce, but also our young people? Ms. Goldman. Yes. Thank you, Congressman. Let me tackle kind of both the collection of data and privacy in the workplace. You know, we have a lot of data brokers buying and selling information, including about workers. When they sell that information to employers, employers can use it in ways that are potentially discriminatory, invade their privacy or could be used for anti-union purposes. Employers can also sell information about their workers back to data brokers, and that can be done without the workers' knowledge or consent. We have an opaque market here that needs regulating and raises a lot of concerns about workers' privacy and civil rights. We know workers do not have sufficient privacy rights in the workplace. Employers are collecting information every day from them, from electronic wearables, geo-tracking, facial recognition software, cameras in their cars, their trucks, their home computers, voice recognition software, keyboard logging, I could go on. There is a lot of surveillance used to collect information. Also, the data that they are collecting from social media, the Internet and data brokers. I think we really need to consider making sure that data is not being collected, if there is not a business purpose for that data, it is not being stored longer than needed, workers know what data is being collected about them, that data is safeguarded and will not be exposed to breaches and that it is not being sold. Mr. DeSaulnier. George Santana said that we are condemned-- those who forget history are condemned to repeat it. Having grown up in Lowell, Massachusetts and listened to my grandparents and their generation talking about the Industrial Revolution, there was certainly great benefits that you alluded to. Workers did not get protections because employers gave it to them. I am reminded of one of my heroes who was the first woman cabinet secretary, Secretary of Labor, Frances Perkins. I have an original photo of her and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire, where she is a young, upper-class woman went across Washington Square and watched those young people fall to their deaths because we did not have worker protection. Let us talk a little bit about how we got labor laws during the Industrial Revolution for all those benefits. History repeating itself. Employers just did not--not all employers-- just took care of their employees. We should be aware of not being modern day Luddites, but we should also learn from history that workers did not benefit this without them responding to it. The first labor union was the Amalgamated Textile Workers, which were young women who came from the farms and started losing their fingers because there was not workforce protection. Talk a little bit about how we responded and protected workers, so we do not do the same thing here. That we see all the benefits of AI, but we do not have an appropriate protection for workers and not just trust people? We have to have--to your comments Mr. Chairman, we have to work together to make sure we do not repeat the mistakes of history. Ms. Goldman. Yes. Thank you, Congressman, and you know, it is so important that workers and unions have that voice in their workplace and that collective action. As you know, the NLRA has not been updated in, you know, since the late fifties. You know, workers' interest in joining unions and being able to protect themselves in the workplace is surging. Private sector union density is at historic lows. Yes, as Mr. Kelley says, we have laws on the books, but we need to update those laws and enforce them, to make sure that all workers have access to them. Then of course it is urgent that Congress act, you know. It is long overdue that we have additional protections for workers that respond specifically to the challenges that they are facing from AI in the workplace. Mr. DeSaulnier. Thank you. Chairman Allen. I thank you gentlemen for yielding. Votes have been called, so we are going to try to wrap this up. I will now call and recognize the Ranking Member for his closing remarks, and I am going to make mine quick, and I would like you to, so we can get the votes. Mr. DeSaulnier. Mr. Chairman, subtlety is one of your real strengths, as is mine. I just want to thank you for having this hearing. I think we could do really good work here Mr. Chairman together, and it would benefit the employers and the employees and learn from history. With all due respect, history teaches us that workers do not benefit at the same rate of investors. Let us get ahead of that. Let us make sure that we are not just assuming the marketing, that this is going to benefit everyone. I would be thrilled to work with you and all the panelists to have an honest, and sometimes honest means sometimes we are not going to agree on this, to get to a conclusion. With all the institutions that are sort of set up on both sides to go to warfare on this, we reserve those. That is my expression. Let us work ahead of it and see if we can get it right. To the EU, I think we can learn from them too. They are doing some really good things and I think the states are responding to that. I know California is as well. If you are worried about us getting wrong, let us get at the table, roll our sleeves up and most importantly to me, learn from history. You know, we start screaming about Luddites. Well, Luddites are misrepresented in Western history and the Industrial Revolution to me, because they overreacted to save their jobs. On the other hand, they were trying to protect, in their own way, things that came about. Child labor laws happened because people organized and said ``We don't want 12-year-olds losing their fingers. We want to protect workers.'' Minimum wage, all those things happened because the workforce had a say. Why do we not get ahead of that, rather than have people suffer and the industry suffer and have people lose trust, as they are losing right now, on things like ghost jobs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. I look forward to working with you on this. Chairman Allen. I thank the gentlemen for yielding. Now I recognize myself for closing statement. I want to thank our witnesses for sharing your perspectives on AI adoption in the workplace. It has been very helpful. AI is changing workplaces across the country, and we are going to have to adapt to this new world. As discussed today, we need better data on how AI is changing the workplace so that we can respond based on the evidence. I look forward to working with the members of the Subcommittee and the administration to make sure American workers and job creators benefit from the increasing use of AI. Let us make this a win-win decision. With that, I thank you, Ranking Member DeSaulnier, and before I get further into my closing, without objection, I would like to enter into the hearing record a statement from Workday on AI and the workforce. Then I say, so ordered. [The Workday statement of Chairman Allen follows:] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] Chairman Allen. Okay. Again, thank you witnesses for taking the time to testify before our Subcommittee today. Without objection, there being no further business, the Subcommittee stands adjourned. [Whereupon, at 11:39 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.] [GRAPHICS NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT] [all]